Opposition — Bosco v. Beck
Supreme Court brief1980
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United | Shaker oon. ie. cure
Octoser Term, 1979
No. 79-1643
MARGARET E. BOSCO,
Petitioner,
US.
ECKARDT C. BECK, Region II Administrator, U. S. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY; DOUGLAS COSTLE, as Administrator,
U. S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; JERRY F.
ENGLISH, as Commissioner, N. J. DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRON-
MENTAL PROTECTION; PEQUEST RIVER MUNICIPAL UTIL-
iTIES AUTHORITY (WARREN COUNTY) and TOWN OF
BELVIDERE,
Respondents.
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
BRIEF OF RESPONDENT JERRY F. ENGLISH,
COMMISSIONER, NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
IN OPPOSITION
JOHN J. DEGNAN,
Attorney General of New Jersey,
Attorney for Jerry F. English, Commissioner,
New Jersey Department of Environmental
Protection,
State House Annex,
Trenton, New Jersey 08625.
ERMINIE L. CONLEY,
Assistant Attorney General,
Counsel.
DENNIS J. KRUMHOLZ,
Deputy Attorney General,
On the Brief.
Adams Press Corp., 5 Commerce Street, Newark, N. J. 07102—(201) 623-8611
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CoUNTER-STATEMENT OF ISSUES PRESENTED .......-..-.--------
CoOUNTER-STATEMENT OF THE CASE .
ArGUMENT—The Supreme Court should deny the
petition for writ of certiorari because the Dis-
trict Court’s decision that the determination of
the Environmental Protection Agency to issue a
Negative Declaration and Environmental Impact
Appraisal was neither arbitrary and capricious nor
unreasonable presents no undecided legal issues
nor factual disputes not correctly decided below
and because the particular facts contained in this
record have no larger significance beyond this case
a nda adeangaenabanaane
Cases Cited
Minnesota Public Interest Research Group v. Butz,
498 F. 2d 1314 (Sth Cir. 1974) 0...
Sierra Club v. Froehlke, 534 F. 2d 1289 (9th Cir.
IE icis.sesesciniiniadenicechsseeecoacacamectigesaisniiteaieanasspharadeeelincees
Statutes Cited
New Jersey Clean Waters Bond Act of 1976 -.............
33 U.S.C. See. 1251 et seg. (Federal Water Pollution
SI BS sieeiiccceniancineeetiiineninintdaainsn
| | Rea ATER SNES ERE a Ee ee
a, SOUR a Beek
li YABLE OF CONTENTS
42 U.S.C. See. 4821 et seq. (National Environmental
Policy Act of 1969) ........
See. 4332(2)(c¢) .....
Regulation Cited
40 C.F.R.:
See. 6.102(e) an
See. 6.204
See. 6.212(b)(2) ..
See. 6.500 et seq.
Sec. 6.512(a) .........
PAGE
bo
1@ 2)
CO —- FH WwW Ww
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OctoserR Term, 1979
No. 79-1643
>.
a
MARGARET E. BOSCO,
Petitioner,
Vv.
ECKARDT C. BECK, Region IT Administrator, U. S.
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY ; DOUG-
LAS COSTLE, as Administrator, U. S. ENVIRON-
MENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; JERRY F.
ENGLISH, as Commissioner, N. J. DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIORNMENTAL PROTECTION; PEQUEST
RIVER MUNICIPAL UTILITIES AUTHORITY
(WARREN COUNTY) and TOWN OF BELVIDERE,
Respondents.
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
i.
———
BRIEF OF RESPONDENT JERRY F. ENGLISH,
COMMISSIONER, NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
IN OPPOSITION
Counter-Statement of Issues Presented
Should the Petition for Writ of Certiorari be granted
where the District Court and the Court of Appeals both
upheld the determination of the Environmental Proteec-
tion Agency that no Environmental Impact Statement
was necessary for the approval of a grant for sewerage
collection and treatment facilities where the decisions
below comport with existing federal law and raise no
significant issues of law or fact?
Counter-Statement of the Case
This is an action brought by petitioner Margaret E.
Boseo pursuant to the National Environmental Policy
Act of 1969 (hereinafter “NEPA”), 42 U.S.C. $4821 et
seq., seeking injunctive relief restraining respondents from
building sewerage collection and treatment facilities in
and around Belvidere, New Jersey, without the prepara-
tion of a complete Ervironmental Impact Statement (here-
inafter “EIS”). Petitioner contends that NEPA requires
the filing of an EIS, 42 U.S.C. §4832(2)(e), because the
construction of the sewerage facilities is a major federal
action significantly affecting the quality of the human
environment.
The Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 33 U.S.C.
§1251 et seq., establishes the EPA grant program for the
construction of publicly owned sewerage treatment works
and forms the statutory basis for construction of the
sewerage treatment plant and collection system at issue
in this litigation. 33 U.S.C. §1291(1) and (2). This statute
authorizes EPA to make grants to any state, municipality
or intermunicipal or interstate agency for the planning,
design and construction of wastewater treatment facilities
and collection systems and to provide up to 75% of the
eligible costs of construction. The State of New Jer-
sey, through the New Jersey Clean Waters Bond Act of
1976, has agreed to provide 8% of the funding for the
present projects.
Current EPA regulations require an applicant for a
wastewater treatment works construetion grant to sub-
mit an environmental assessment with the facilities plan
developed under a Step 1 grant. 40 C.F.R. §6.512(a). This
environmental assessment must include a description of
the environmental impacts of the project, a deseription
of the steps taken to minimize any adverse environmental
effects, an evaluation of feasible alternatives, a descrip-
tion of the existing and future environment without the
project and documentation of these findings. 40 C.F.R.
$6.512(a). The EPA then reviews this environmental as-
ssessment and determines whether significant environ-
mental impacts are expected from the proposed action,
whether feasible alternatives can be adopted or changes
made in project design to eliminate adverse impacts and
whether an EIS or a Negative Declaration is to be filed.
40 C.F.R. $6.204.
If EPA determines, as it did in the present action, that
the proposed sewerage collection and treatment facilities
will not have a significant impact upon the environment,
it issues a Negative Declaration together with an Envir-
onmental Impact Appraisal. The Negative Declaration
is a written announcement prepared after EPA’s environ-
mental review stating that the EPA has determined that
an KIS is not required for the proposed project. 40 C.F.R.
§6.102(e). The Environmental Impact Appraisal (here-
inafter “EIA”) is prepared concurrently with the Nega-
tive Declaration and briefly describes the proposed action
and feasible alternatives, environmental impacts of the
4
project, unavoidable adverse impacts of the action, the
relationship between the short-term uses of man’s envir-
onment and the maintenance and enhancement of long-
term productivity, steps to minimize harm to the environ-
ment, irreversible and irretrievable commitments of re-
sources necessary to implement the action, comments and
consultation to the project and reasons for concluding
that the proposed action will not have a significant en-
vironmental impact. 40 C.F.R. §6.212(b) (2).
The Warren County-Pequest River Sewerage Authority
submitted to the DEP in 1975 its proposed plan of study
of the region’s wastewater management options. The
DEP approved and certified this planning application in
April, 1975 and the EPA approved the Authority’s ap-
plication for a Step I grant for the preparation of the
Facilities Plan in July, 1975.
The full Wastewater Facilities Plan for the Pequest
River Drainage Basin was issued preliminarily to EPA,
DEP, the Authority and to the general public for com-
ment in May, 1976. This Plan provides a comprehensive
discussion and analysis of engineering and environmental
concerns relating to wastewater treatment in the Pequest
River drainage basin area and it develops and evaluates
possible alternatives to its proposals. The Facilities Plan
concludes that two regional facilities—one in Oxford
Township and the other in White Township and serving
the Town of Belvidere directly adjacent to this facility
—would provide the most environmentally sound and cost
effective method of sewerage treatment.
A public hearing was held concerning the Facilities Plan
in May, 1976 pursuant to EPA regulations for compliance
with NEPA in the Title Il Wastewater Treatment Works
Construction Grants Program, 40 C.F.R. §6.500 et seq.,
and a subsequent hearing concerning only the Belvidere
collection system was held in August, 1976. The only
questions raised at the initial hearing concerned the claim
that some of the public did not have adequate time in
which to read the Facilities Plan; the Authority fully
responded to written questions posed by interested per-
sons subsequent to the second hearing.
The EPA issued its Negative Declaration and Environ-
mental Impact Appraisal for the Belvidere treatment plant
and collection system on September 8, 1978. it is this deci-
sion by the EPA which petitioner challenges; the Oxford
project is not at issue in the present lawsuit.
No comments or objections were submitted to the HPA
for the consideration within fifteen (15) day comment
period provided upon the issuance of the Negative Decla-
ration and therefore no further hearing was required.
An additional public meeting, not required by law, was
held by the EPA in February, 1979, subsequent to which
the EPA upheld its determination of a Negative Declara-
tion in a nineteen (19) page letter sent to all interested
parties.
On June 12, 1979 petitioner filed a complaint in the
United States District Court for the District of New
Jersey challenging HPA’s issuance of a Negative Declara-
tion and on June 22, 1979 she filed a motion for prelim-
inary injunction. On the return date of August 21, 1979
the Honorable Clarkson S. Fisher, U.S.D.J., with the
consent of all parties, ordered the trial of this action
on the merits to be advanced and consolidated with peti-
tioner’s injunction application. Judge Fisher’s Order and
Judgment in this matter was filed August 30, 1979 deny-
ing petitioner’s application for injunctive relief and dis-
missing her complaint. In his opinion, filed simultane-
ously, Judge Fisher determined that petitioner had failed
to demonstrate that EPA’s decision to file a Negative
6
Declaration and an Environmental Impact Appraisal was
either arbitrary and capricious or unreasonable (Pet. App.
35-72). The Third Circuit affirmed the decision of the
District Court without opinion on January 18, 1980 (Pet.
App. 34).
The Town of Belvidere commenced construction of the
collection system portion of this project on October 15,
1979.
ARGUMENT
The Supreme Court should deny the petition for writ
of certiorari because the District Court’s decision that
the determination of the Environmental Protection
Agency to issue a Negative Declaration and Environ-
mental Impact Appraisal was neither arbitrary and
capricious nor unreasonable presents no undecided
legal issues nor factual disputes not correctly decided
below and because the particular facts contained in this
record have no larger significance beyond this case.
This case presents no undecided legal issues nor any
factual disputes which were not correctly and conclu-
sively decided by the District Court and affirmed without
opinion by the Third Circuit. Petitioner’s assertions of
error in the lower courts are plainly incorrect but, even
assuming them to be true, the decision in this case turns
solely upon the particular facts contained in this record
and has virtually no greater importance beyond this ease.
The initial Question Presented by the petitioner, whether
the decision of the District Court is in error because it
applies the “arbitrary and capricious” standard of re-
view instead of a “reasonableness” test to its review of
the EPA’s decision to issue a Negative Declaration, is
not raised by the decision below. The District Court
reviewed the determination of the HPA not to issue an
EIS under the “arbitrary and capricious” standard (Pet.
53) but it also explicitly examined EPA’s decision under
the more rigorous “reasonableness” test as well (Pet.
App. 67). While petitioner correctly asserts that there
may be some difference among the United States Cireuit
Courts as to which of the foregoing standards of review is
to be applied under NEPA in reviewing the activities of
federal agencies, compare, e. g. Minnesota Public Interest
Research Group v. Butz, 498 F. 2d 1814 (8th Cir. 1974) (en
bane) and Sierra Club v. Froehlke, 534 F. 2d 1289 (9th
Cir. 1976), the District Court’s finding that the Inviron-
mental Impact Assessment issued by the KPA passes
muster under both standards of review eliminates all
ambiguity and potential question of law and necessarily
removes this issue as a basis for granting the petition
for certiorari.
The third and fourth Questions Presented by the peti-
tion for certiorari concern allegations of conflict of inter-
est, undue pressure and political intervention associated
with the sewerage treatment works. The record is totally
devoid of any evidence beyond petitioner’s unsubstan-
tiated assertions at oral argument before the District
Court that there is any conflict of interest whatsoever on
the part of any individual which in any way affects the
decision of the EPA to proceed with the funding and
construction of this project. The District Court correctly
found that petitioner’s allegations were unsubstantiated
by facts and, moreover, that they are irrelevant to the
question presented to the Court (Pet. App. 67).
Petitioner’s assertion as stated in her second Question
Presented, that the District Court’s determination to uphold
8
the EPA decision to issue an Environmental Impact Assess-
ment is not supported by the evidence, finds no support
in the record and is plainly insufficient to warrant the
granting of this petition. The record in this case clearly
reveals that EPA has closely examined the proposed
sewerage collection and treatment facilities and has found
that they will not result in significant environmental im-
pacts. The EIA prepared by EPA and submitted with
the Negative Declaration specifically determined that the
installation of the sewerage system will not contravene
either state or federal air quality standards, that noise
levels due to actual operation of the system will not be
significant and will be contained within the isolated area
of the pumping station, that the construction of the
pumping station will have minimum impacts upon the
natural resources of the area and that the project will
not impact upon any critical areas. The EIA discusses
five alternatives to the present project before conelud
ing that the present plans are most acceptable, it inci-
cates that eleven separate steps to minimize the impact
upon the environment will be taken during construction
and its states that all affected areas will be restored to
a condition at least comparable to what existed prior to
construction. The record demonstrates that each of the
five (5) environmental impacts alleged by petitioner in
the District Court to be “significant” and thus to necessi-
tate the filing of a full EIS, see 42 U.S.C. $4332(2)(e),
including reduction in groundwater recharge, alignment
of the collection system, disruption of the Pophandusing
Brook and increased river turbulence at the treatment
plant outfall, was found by the EPA and upheld by the
District Court to be insignificant and in fact contradicted
by the express findings of the Environmental Impact As-
sessment.
The one specific error of the District Court alleged in
the petition for certiorari, that the District Court’s con-
clusion that a single internal contradiction in the environ-
mental impact assessment concerning the impact of odors
produced by the proposed treatment plant is attributable
to “sloppy draftsmanship” and not an error of fact (Pet.
21-22), is maifestly unsupported in the record. The
District Court found on this issue that EPA had given
“serious consideration” to the odor problem and that the
use of certain devices would render this impact “insig-
nificant” (Pet. App. 63). |
Because the factual issues presented by the record were
all decided correctly below and, in any event, have no
importance beyond the present case, and because this case
presents no undecided legal issues, there is no basis for
the granting of the petition for writ of certiorari.
CONCLUSION
For ‘hese reasons, the petition for writ of certiorari
should be denied.
Respectfully submitted,
JoHN J. DEGNAN,
Attorney General of New Jersey
Attorney for Respondent Jerry
F. English, Commissioner, New
Jersey Department of Envi-
ronmental Protection.
By Erminiz L. Contey,
Assistant Attorney General
Dennis J. KruMHoLz,
Deputy Attorney General,
On the Brief.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.