Appendix — United States v. Swank
Supreme Court brief1981
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
_ iva
; rib b
F
APPENDIX = ges 85° 1989 |
°° - e . bd
FICMAEL RODAK, JR. CLE
— _—— —~-—- —---
nthe Saye Court of the Thuted States
OCTOBER TERM, 1979
No. 79-1515
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
v.
ELWooD SWANK AND RITA SWANK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
vz.
BLACK HAWK CORPORATION, INC.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
Vv.
BULL RUN MINING Co., INC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED MARCH 27, 1980
CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 12, 1980
ee
ee MG
In the Suprene Court of the Huited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1979
No. 79-1515
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
VU.
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
Vv.
BLACK HAWK COAL CORPORATION, INC.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER
Vv.
BULL RUN MINING Co., INC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
INDEX
Page
Elwood Swank and Rita Swank
Relevant Docket Entries ....................0085 la
I Wide hb aiblls Uk sis ono wala caldera Pare kae bere 8a
I ee ee Sg. a toe G kes wate at 13a
il
Page
pn PETC PETC TE EET TC COT ESET EET Tee l6a
Partial Stipulation of Facts ..........secccesecces 17a
Exhibit A (Lease of October 24, 1964)........ 22a
Exhibit B (Lease of October 26, 1966)........ 3la
Exhibit C (Lease of July 25, 1966) ........... 4la
Exhibit D (Equipment purchases)............ 48a
Supplemental Stipulation ..................00e eee 50a
Trial Judge’s Findings of fact (filed November 6,
PETE Uas Searchin suswnnde cape han ode ee 5la
Black Hawk Coal Corporation
Relevant Docket Entries ..................00 eee 58a
EEK AIRE Lucas eeah nds enahe tag eceed ceed 60a
ES aE hia isin bbkexiar bee bad enka ee nies 65a
ME br ce sacianwese ibeabecssces 68a
Exhibit 4 (Lease of February 20, 1964)....... 73a
Bull Run Mining Co., Inc.
Relevant Docket Entries ..................-0 00s 87a
Exhibit A (Lease of June 21, 1967)........... 90a
Mas AGA cok behead eetene4<¥20nnees 94a
Exhibit D (Lease of April 1, 1960) ........... 10la
Order Granting Certiorari................... 117a
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
GENERAL
No. 403-75
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK
Vv.
THE UNITED STATES
Income tax
November 18 1975
5 COPIES OF PETITION TO DEFENDANT.
$34,926.59
R.D. #1, Box 85 D
Paxinos, PA
Nov 18 1975
Dec 10 1975
Jan 19 1976
Nov 26 1976
Dec 27 1976
Dec 27 1976
Jan 6 1977
Filing fee of $10 paid by plaintiffs.
Notice of reference to Trial Judge C. Murray
Bernhardt filed. Copy to parties.
Defendant’s answer to the petition filed.
Copies (5) to atty.
Defendant’s motion for an order directing a
response to request for admissions filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
Plaintiffs’ motion for order directing a re-
sponse to plaintiffs’ request for admissions
filed. Copies (2) to deft. DENIED JAN 24
1978 without prejudice.
Plaintiffs’ objections to defendant’s motion
for an order directing a response to request
for admissions and request for admissions
filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Defendant’s reply to plaintiffs’ objections to
defendant’s request for admissions filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
la
Jan 26 1977
Feb 25 1977
Mar 14 1977
Mar 14 1977
Mar 28 1977
Apr 11 1977
Apr 14 1977
Apr 14 1977
Apr 14 1977
May 17 1977
May 31 1977
2a
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
February 25, 1977) to file objections to re-
quest for admissions filed. Copies (2) to atty.
ALLOWED FEB 2 1977.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
March 12, 1977) to respond to request for
admissions filed. Copies (2) to atty. AL-
LOWED MAR 15 1977.
Defendant’s supplemental motion for an
order directing plaintiffs to respond to de-
fendant’s request for admissions, ete. filed.
Copies (2) to atty. DENIED NOV 15 1977.
Defendant’s objections to plaintiffs’ request
for admissions filed. Copies (2) to atty.
Plaintiffs’ reply to objections to request for
admissions filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Plaintiffs’ motion to strike defendant’s sup-
plemental motion for an order directing
plaintiffs to respond to defendant’s request
for admissions, etc. filed. Copies (2) to deft.
SEE ACTION ON MOTION OF MARCH
14, 1977.
Defendant’s responses to request for admis-
sions filed. Copies (2) to atty.
Defendant’s motion for summary judgment
together with appendix in support thereof
filed. Copies (5 of motion and 1 of appendix)
to atty.
Defendant’s motion for leave to file a re-
duced number of copies (of appendix B) filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED MAY 6 1977,
see endorsement on motion*
Plaintiffs’ brief in opposition to defendant’s
motion for summary judgment filed. Copies
(7) to deft.
Defendants motion for extension of time (to
July 15, 1977) to file its reply brief filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED JUN 17 1977.
Jul 15 1977
Jul 20 1977
Aug 29 1977
Sep 2 1977
Sep 6 1977
Nov 11 1977
Dec 7 1977
Dee 21 1977
Jan 3 1978
Jan 3 1978
3a
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
August 29, 1977) to file its reply brief filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED AUG 2 1977
with no further extension of time to be
granted except for extraordinary circum-
stances.
Plaintiffs objections to motion for enlarge-
ment of time filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
September 2, 1977) to file its reply brief
filed. Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED SEP 2
1977.
Defendant’s reply brief in support of its mo-
tion for summary judgment filed. Copies (5)
to atty.
Submitted to the court on defendant’s mo-
tion for summary judgment.
Court entered order denying defendant’s
motion for summary judgment and returning
the case to the Trial Division as set forth in
the order. Copy to parties.
Defendant’s motion for leave to take depos-
itions and to serve subpeonas duces tecum
filed. Copies (2) to atty. DENIED JAN 5
1978 SEE TRIAL JUDGE’S ORDER THIS
DATE.
Plaintiffs’ objections and response to motion
for leave to take depositions, etc. filed.
Copies (2) to deft.
Defendant’s reply to plaintiffs’ objections to
defendant’s motion for leave to take depos-
itions and to serve subpoena duces tecum
filed. Copies (2) to atty.
Defendant’s motion for leave to take depos-
itions and to serve subpoenas duces tecum
filed. Copies (2) to atty. SEE TRIAL
JUDGE’S ORDER JAN 24 1978 denying,
without prejudice.
Jan 5 1978
Jan 9 1978
Jan 13 1978
Jan 19 1978
Jan 24 1978
Feb 22 1978
Mar 15 1978
Apr 14 1978
Apr 20 1978
Apr 24 1978
May 22 1978
Jun 7 1978
Jun 12 1978
4a
Trial judge’s order on defendant’s motion
Re: depositions, etc., filed. Copy to parties.
Plaintiffs’ motion for leave to amend petition
filed. Copies (2) to deft. ALLOWED JAN 23
1978.
Plaintiffs’ objections and response to de-
fendant’s motion for leave to take depos-
itions and to serve subpoenas duces tecum
filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Partial stipulation of facts filed by defend-
ant. Copy to atty,
Trial judge’s order on defendant’s motion re:
depositions* filed. Copy to parties. (*DE-
NIED, without prejudice).
Trial judge’s memorandum re pretrial con-
ference filed. Copy to parties.
Plaintiffs’ amendment to petition filed.
Copies (5) to deft.
Defendant’s amended answer filed. Copies
(5) to atty.
Transcript of testimony (one volume), taken
at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania on March 14,
1978, together with plaintiff's exhibits 1
through 3, and defendant’s exhibits 1
through 5 filed. Notice to parties.
Trial judge’s order closing proof, etc. filed.
Copy to parties.
Plaintiffs’ motion for extension of time (to
June 13, 1978) to file requested findings of
fact and brief filed. Copies (2) to deft. AL-
LOWED MAY 22 1978.
Supplemental stipulation of facts filed by
defendant. Copies (2) to atty.
Plaintiff's motion for extension of time (to
June 23, 1978) to file requested findings of
fact and brief filed. Copies (2) to deft. AL-
LOWED JUN 13 1978.
pom,
Jun 16 1978
Jul 17 1978
Aug 31 1978
Aug 31 1978
Aug 31 1978
Sep 13 1978
Sep 14 1978
Oct 3 1978
Oct 3 1978
Oct 10 1978
Nov 6 1978
Dec 11 1978
5a
Plaintiffs’ requested findings of fact and
brief filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
August 31, 1978) to file its requested find-
ings, ete. filed. Copies (2) to atty. AL-
LOWED JUL 18 1978.
Defendant’s objections to plaintiffs’ re-
quested findings of fact filed. Copies (2) to
atty.
Defendant’s requested findings of fact filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
Defendant’s brief to the Trial Judge filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
Plaintiffs’ motion for extension of time (to
Oct. 10, 1978) to file objections to defend-
ant’s requested findings of fact, ete. filed.
Copies (2) to deft. ALLOWED SEP 13 1978.
Plaintiffs’ amendment to requested finding
of fact No. 31 filed. Copies (2) to deft.
(BLOT J).
Defendant’s motion for leave to file objection
to plaintiffs’ supplemental requested find-
ings of facts filed. Copies (2) to atty. AL-
LOWED OCT 8 1978 & filed.
Defendant’s objection to supplemental in-
formation sought to be added to plaintiff's
requested finding 31 filed. Copies (2) to atty.
Plaintiffs’ objections to defendant’s findings
of fact and reply brief filed. Copies (2) to
deft.
Trial judge’s opinion and findings of fact
filed. Copies (5) to parties.
Defendant’s motion for leave to file out of
time notice of intent to except to trial
judge’s findings of fact and conclusions of
‘law filed. Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED
DEC 11 1978.
Dec 11 1978
Dee 21 1978
Jan 22 1979
Feb 15 1979
Mar 5 1979
Mar 28 1979
Mar 30 1979
Apr 13 1979
May 15 1979
Jun 4 1979
Jul 18 1979
Nov 21 1979
6a
Defendant’s notice of intent to except to trial
judge’s findings of fact, opinion, etc. filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
Defendant’s motion for enlargement of time
(to January 20 1979) to file its brief and ex-
ceptions to the Trial Judge’s findings of fact
filed. Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED JAN 8
1978.
Defendant’s exceptions and brief filed.
Copies (5) to atty.
Plaintiffs’ motion for enlargement of time (to
March 8 1979) to file its opposing brief filed.
Copies (2) to deft. ALLOWED FEB 16 1979.
Plaintiffs’ opposing brief filed. Copies (5) to
deft.
Defendant’s motion for leave to file out of
time a motion for enlargement of time to file
reply brief filed. Copies (2) to atty. AL-
LOWED MAR 30 1979.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
April 14, 1979) to fill its reply brief filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED MAR 30
1979.
Defendant’s reply brief filed. Copies (5) to
atty.
See 400-77 for defendant’s motion for order
directing consolidation.
See 400-77 for argument and submission.
The court concludes that plaintiffs in each
case [in this, 49-77, and 400-77], are entitled
to recover taxes and interest assessed, plus
interest as provided by law with the
amounts of recovery to determined pursuant
to Rule 131(c). Opinion Per Curiam.
Stipulation for entry of judgment filed by
defendant. Copies (2) atty.
Nov 26 1979
Nov 30 1979
Nov 30 1979
Ta
Trial Judge’s memorandum report for judg-
ment filed. Copy to parties.
Court filed order entering judgment for
plaintiffs’ in the sum of $35,806.07, plus
statutory interest. Copy to parties.
Certified transcript of judgment mailed to
attorney of record.
8a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK
Plaintiffs
>
Docket No.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Defendant
PETITION
1. This is an action for the recovery of Internal Rev-
enue taxes and interest thereon which were erroneously,
illegally and improperly assessed and collected from plain-
tiffs by defendant. Jurisdiction is based upon the provi-
sions of 28 U.S.C. Sections 1346(a)(1) and 1491.
2. Plaintiffs’ names are ELWOOD SWANK and RITA
SWANK, husband and wife, residing at R.D. #1, Box 85
D, Paxinos, Pennsylvania. The returns for the periods
here involved were filed timely with the District Director
of Internal Revenue, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
3. Defendant is United States of America which, at all
times material to this case, was acting by or through its
District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Mid-Atlantic
Region, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
4. Plaintiffs timely filed their joint 1966 and 1967
United States Individual Income Tax Returns with the
District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Mid-Atlantic
Region, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and paid the tax
shown to be due thereon in the amount of $9,957.28.
5. In their joint 1966 United States Individual Income
Tax Return, Plaintiffs claimed a deduction from ordinary
income in the amount of $41,371.24 as a deduction for de-
pletion of coal resources in which Plaintiff Elwood Swank
had an economic interest in 1966.
6. In their joint 1967 United States Individual Income
Tax Return, Plaintiffs claimed a deduction from ordinary
income in the amount of $16,274.00 as a deduction for de-
9a
pletion of coal resources in which plaintiff Elwood Swank
had an economic interest in 1967.
7. A deficiency for the year 1966 in the amount of
$21,720.11 was assessed by Defendant against Plaintiffs
and was paid by Plaintiffs during 1972, together with
interest in the amount of $6,055.15 and a penalty in the
amount of $763.22 for a total payment of $28,538.48.
8. A deficiency for the year 1967 in the amount of
$8,867.74 was assessed by Defendant against Plaintiffs
and was paid by Plaintiffs during 1972, together with
interest in the amount of $2,899.78, for a total payment of
$11,767.52.
9. $19,662.80 of the assessment referred to in paragraph
7 of this Petition and $7,351.79 of the assessment referred
to in paragraph 8 of this Petition were based respectively
upon Defendant’s erroneous disallowance of the $41,371.24
referred to in paragraph 5 of this Petition and the
$15,204.32 referred to in paragraph 6 of this Petition as
deductions for depletion claimed from gross income re-
ported on Schedule C of their joint 1966 and 1967 United
States Individual Tax Returns respectively.
10. Pursuant to a Deep Mining Lease, dated October 24,
1964, by and between the County of Northumberland,
Lessor, and Plaintiff Elwood Swank, a sole proprietor,
t/d/b/a Split Vein Coal Company, Plaintiff Elwood Swank,
as an independent coal mining operator, engaged in the
extraction of coal by the process of deep mining, during
1966 and 1967 on 112 acres of land at or near Trevorton,
Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of this
lease is attached hereto as Exhibit “A” and made a part
hereof.
11. Pursuant to a Deep Mining Lease, dated October 26,
1966, by and between the County of Northumberland, as
Lessor, and Plaintiff Elwood Swank, a sole proprietor,
t/d/b/a Split Vein Coal Company, Plaintiff Elwood Swank
as an independent coal mining operator, engaged in the
extraction of coal by the process of deep mining, during
1966 and 1967, on 1,371.5 acres of land in the Township of
Coal, Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of
10a
this lease is attached hereto as Exhibit “B” and made a
part hereof.
12. Pursuant to a Stripping Lease, dated July 25, 1966,
by and between the County of Northumberland, as Les-
sor, and Plaintiff Elwood Swank, a sole proprietor, t/d/b/a
Split Vein Coal Company Plaintiff Elwood Swank, as an
independent coal mining operator, engaged in the extrac-
tion of coal by the process of strip mining, during 1966 and
1967, on 133 acres of land in the Township of Coal, Nor-
thumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of this lease is
attached hereto as Exhibit “C” and made a part hereof.
18. Under the laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsyl-
vania, the three leases referred to in paragraphs 10, 11
and 12 of this Petition (hereinafter the “leases’”’) vested in
Plaintiff Elwood Swank a fee simple interest in the coal in
place by sale and purchase, subject only to the condition
that the coal be removed within the period specified in the
lease. The transaction left no interest in the Lessor other
than the royalties with such attendant rights as were
necessary to protect such royalty interest.
14. As an independent miner, Plaintiff Elwood Swank
was under no obligation to sell the coal to the Lessor or to
any other party. He could sell the coal to whom he pleased
and at whatever price he could obtain. The mining opera-
tions of Plaintiff Elwood Swank were not supervised or
controlled in any manner, except that the Lessor could in-
spect the premises to determine that the maximum
amount of coal was being withdrawn by Plaintiff Elwood
Swank without damage to the surrounding interest. Under
the leases, Plaintiff Elwood Swank had the right to mine
the coal to exhaustion.
15. The coal mined from the operations under the leases
was delivered by Plaintiff Elwood Swank to his breaker
for cleaning and sizing, and, thereafter, was sold by Plain-
tiff Elwood Swank on the open market to the general pub-
lic.
16. The Lessor under the leases derives no income from
the mining operations under the leases, except the royalty
lla
of 35 cents per gross ton of raw coal removed from the
land.
17. The Lessor under the leases retained no right to
terminate the leases except for noncompliance with the
convenants in the leases relating to royalties and the con-
ditions of operation or upon failure to continue work on the
leased premises for a period of 30 days. The latter provi-
sions are normal provisions in all mineral leases in the an-
thracite region and are inserted only for the protection of
the royalty interest of the Lessor.
18. The interest of Plaintiff Elwood Swank under the
leases constitutes an economic interest in the coal in place,
as that term is used in U.S. Treasury Regulations Section
1.611-1(b).
19. On or about February 25, 1974, Plaintiffs filed
timely Claims for Refund for the years 1966 and 1967 with
the District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Mid-
Atlantic Region, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Copies of
these Claims for Refund are attached hereto as Exhibit
=>”
20. Plaintiffs received a notice from Defendant dated
January 14, 1975, which stated that Defendant proposed to
disallow Plaintiffs’ Claims for Refund.
21. During March, 1975, Plaintiffs received notices from
Defendant, dated March 13, 1975, which advised Plaintiffs
that Defendant formally had disallowed Plaintiffs’ Claims
for Refund.
22. The actions of Defendant in assessing and collecting
the deficiencies referred to in paragraphs 7 and 8 of this
Petition and in disallowing Plaintiffs’ Claims for Refund
were improper, illegal and erroneous.
23. Plaintiffs have overpaid their United States Indi-
vidual Income Tax for the years 1966 and 1967 in the
amount of $27,014.59 with interest in the amount of
$7,912.00, which amounts together with interest as pro-
vided by law are due and owing to Plaintiffs from the De-
fendant.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray that judgment be entered
12a
in their favor in the amount of $34,926.59, together with
interest as provided by law, and that the Court grant such
other relief as it may deem proper and that Plaintiffs be
awarded their costs.
Respectfully submitted,
LLOYD R. PERSUN
HOWELL C. METTE
SHEARER, METTE & WOODSIDE
P.O Box 729
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108
717-232-6701
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
{Exhibits omitted. |
18a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 403-75
ELWOOD AND RITA SWANK,
Plaintiffs
v.
THE UNITED STATES,
Defendant
ANSWER
JAN 19 1976
Defendant, for its answer to the petition filed in the
above-entitled case, denies each and every allegation con-
tained therein, except as specifically admitted herein.
Defendant further:
1. Admits jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section
1491, but denies the remainder of the allegations contained
in paragraph 1.
2-4. Admits the allegations contained in paragraphs 2
through 4.
5-6. Denies the allegations contained in paragraphs 5
and 6.
7. Admits that in 1972 plaintiffs were assessed and paid
$21,720.11 in additional tax and $6,055.15 in interest for
1966, but denies the remainder of the allegations contained
in paragraph 7.
8. Admits that in 1972 plaintiffs were assessed and paid
$8,867.74 in additional tax for 1967, but denies the re-
mainder of the allegations contained in paragraph 8.
9. Denies the allegations contained in paragraph 9.
10-12. Admits the allegations contained in paragraphs
10 through 12.
13. Denies the allegations contained in paragraph 13.
l4a
14-16. Avers that its attorney is presently unable to ob-
tain knowledge or information sufficient for him to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in para-
graphs 14 through 16.
17-18. Denies the allegations contained in paragraphs
17 and 18.
19. Admits the allegations contained in paragraph 19,
except denies each and every allegation in the claims for
refund not specifically admitted herein.
20-21. Admits the allegations contained in paragraphs
20 and 21.
22-23. Denies the allegations contained in paragraphs
22 and 23.
WHEREFORE, defendant prays that plaintiffs’ petition be
dismissed with costs assessed against the plaintiffs.
Respectfully submitted.
MyYRON C. BAUM Acting Assistant Attorney General
CHARLES E. AUSLANDER, JR.
January 16, 1976
15a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
Docket No. 403-75
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK,
Plaintiffs
Vv.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Defendant
AMENDMENT TO PETITION
AND NOW, this 13th day of March, 1978, in accordance
with leave granted by the Learned Trial Judge on January
23, 1978, Plaintiffs hereby amend the Wherefore clause of
their Petition as follows:
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray that judgment be entered
in their favor in the amount of $34,926.59, together with
interest as provided by law and reasonable attorneys’ fees
and costs of counsel in preparation and presentation of
their case, and that the Court grant such other relief as it
may deem proper and that Plaintiffs be awarded their
costs.
Respectfully submitted,
LLOYD R. PERSUN
HOWELL C. METTE
SHEARER, METTE & WOODSIDE
P.O. Box 729
1801 North Front Street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108
717-232-6701
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
16a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 403-75
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK,
Plaintiffs
v.
THE UNITED STATES,
Defendant
AMENDED ANSWER
Defendant repeats the responses set forth in its answer
to plaintiffs’ petition filed November 18, 1975, and states
further:
Plaintiffs, having filed an amendment to petition on
March 15, 1978, in which they pray for relief including
“reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs of counsel in prep-
aration and presentation of their case,” defendant here
states that this Court is without jurisdiction to grant such
relief.
WHEREFORE, having responded to the matters raised in
plaintiffs’ amendment to petition, defendant respectfully
requests that plaintiffs’ petition, as amended, be dismissed
with costs assessed against plaintiffs.
Respectfully submitted,
M. CARR FERGUSON
Assistant Attorney General
JAMES L. MALONE III
Attorney
April 14, 1978
17a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 403-75
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK,
HIS WIFE, PLAINTIFFS
v.
THE UNITED STATES,
DEFENDANT
PARTIAL STIPULATION OF FACTS
AND NOW, this 14th day of December, 1977, it is hereby
stipulated and agreed by and between the parties hereto
by their respective counsel, for the purposes of this case
only, that the following facts may be accepted as true and
that the copies of the documents hereto annexed and iden-
tified as exhibits are genuine and are true and exact copies
of the original thereof, each party, however, reserving the
right to object to the relevance and materiality of said
facts and documents:
‘1. Plaintiffs are Elwood and Rita Swank, husband and
wife, residing at R.D. #1, Box 85 D, Paxinos, Pennsyl-
vania (hereinafter collectively referred to as ‘“‘Tax-
payers”). Reference hereinafter to “Taxpayer” means
husband only, the wife being joined only because of the
filing of joint tax returns by Taxpayers during 1966 and
1967.
2. Defendant is the United States of America (here-
inafter the “Government”).
3. Taxpayer owned and operated a sole proprietorship
trading and doing business as Split Vein Coal Company
during the entire calendar year 1966 and during the period
from January 1, 1967 through April 30, 1967. On May 1,
1967, Taxpayer transferred the assets of his sole proprie-
torship, Split Vein Coal Company, to Split Vein Coal Com-
pany, Inc., in a tax-free incorporation, pursuant to Section
351 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, as amended.
18a
4. Taxpayers timely filed their joint 1966 and 1967
United States Individual Income Tax Returns with the
District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Mid-Atlantic
Region, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and paid the tax
shown to be due thereon.
5. In their joint 1966 and 1967 Unaited States Indi-
vidual Incoem Tax Return, Taxpayers claimed as a deduc-
tion from ordinary income a deduction for depletion of coal
resources in which Taxpayer claimed an economic interest
in 1966 and in 1967.
6. After audit, the Government disallowed the deduc-
tions referred to in paragraph 5, above, and, as a result
thereof, assessed deficiencies against Taxpayers for the
years 1966 and 1967 in the aggregate amount of $30,587.84
which Taxpayers paid under protest to the Government
together with assessed interest in the aggregate amount of
$3,663.00.
7. At all times material hereto, Split Vein was a sole
proprietorship engaged in mining and strip mining anthra-
cite coal as lessee of various mining tracts in the North-
umberland County Pennsylvania area. Taxpayer mined
only from coal lands which it leased, as Lessee. Taxpayer's
mining operations included the deep mining and strip
mining methods of mining coal. Taxpayer purchased and
owned the machinery and equipment used in its mining
operations, and took depreciation deductions on such
machinery and equipment.
8. Taxpayer strip mined by using his power shovel to
remove the overburdening soil and terrain covering the
underlying coal (hereinafter the “overburden”). The power
shovel then “stripped” the exposed coal from the earth’s
surface and placed it in large piles next to loaders. The
piled coal then was conveyed by the loaders into trucks
which hauled the coal from the leased lands to a breaker
where the coal was cleaned and sorted. From the breaker,
the coal was sold to the general public on the open market.
9. Taxpayer deep mined by sinking shafts, or inclined
slopes, through the overburden into coal veins. When the
coal veins were exposed, Taxpayer transported his min-
19a
ers, his employees, in his “buggies”, or cars, on rails into
the shafts to the coal veins. The miners manually ex-
tracted coal from the veins with explosives and pick and
shovel and then deposited the extracted coal in the bug-
gies which then transported the extracted coal through the
shafts to the earth’s surface. At the earth’s surface, the
coal was trucked to a breaker where, as in the case of strip
mined coal, the deep mined coal was cleaned and sorted.
From the breaker, the deep mined coal was sold to the
general public on the open market.
10. Taxpayer was under no obligation to sell the coal to
the Lessor or to any other party. He could sell the coal to
whom he pleased at whatever price he could obtain.
11. When the coal was removed from the earth, either
by strip mining or deep mining, it was ungraded as to size
and contained slate and rock, thereby requiring sorting
and cleaning. This cleaning and sorting process was ac-
complished by using a breaker (which sometimes is called
a tipple). A breaker is a plant for processing coal. The
breaker removed the slate and rock, and sorted the coal
into seven sizes for sale to the general public on the open
market. The price per ton of coal varied based on the
quality of the coal and the market conditions at the time
when the coal was sold to the public.
12. The County of Northumberland is a political sub-
division of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and is a
county of the fifth class.
13. From time to time, Northumberland County has ac-
quired legal title to substantial acreage of land containing
substantial deposits of anthracite by purchase at County
Treasurer’s sales for delinquent taxes levied by the
County and by various Townships and school districts in
Northumberland County wherein the land is located. Fee
simple title was acquired by the County by virtue of the
right of County Commissioners to purchase said land
under Section 10 of the Act of May 29, 1931, P.L. 280, as
amended, 72 P.S. §5971(j). Said land is held by the County
as trustee for the County and the school districts and
Townships in which the land is located. During the years
20a
in issue, Northumberland County owned over 17,500 acres
of land in Zerbe Township, Coal Township, Mount Carmel
Township, East Cameron Township and West Cameron
Township, all having been acquired by purchase at County
Treasurer’s sales for unpaid taxes.
14. The Northumberland County Commissioners, in
whom the authority for the operation of county govern-
ment is vested, entered into leases with individuals,
partnerships and corporations for the extraction and re-
moval of coal from the county-owned land in consideration
for the payment of royalties to the county. During the tax-
able years involved, Northumberland County Commis-
sioners collected from Taxpayer the following royalties
from coal lands owned by Northumberland County and
leased to Taxpayer:
1966 — $7,545.10
1967 — 6,854.05
15. Pursuant to a deep mining lease dated October 24,
1964, by and between the County of Northumberland, as
Lessor, and Taxpayer, as miner, Taxpayer engaged in the
extraction of coal by the process of deep mining, during
1966 and 1967, on 112 acres of land out or near Trevorton,
Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of this
lease is attached hereto as Exhibit “A” and made a part
hereof. This lease was terminated in May, 1968 because a
mountain slide caused by heavy rains closed the deep
mine, thereby preventing further mining of the mine by
anyone. In May 1968, rain fell in the Northumberland
County, Pennsylvania area on 29 of the 31 days in that
month.
16. Pursuant to a deep mining lease dated October 26,
1966, by and between the County of Northumberland, as
Lessor, and Taxpayer, as Miner, Taxpayer engaged in the
extraction of coal by the process of deep mining, during
1966 and 1967, on 1,371.5 acres of land in the Township of
Coal, Northumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of
this lease is attached hereto as Exhibit “B” and made a
part hereof. This lease is still in effect, and Taxpayer’s
2la
corporation, Split Vein Coal Company, Inc., is still mining
the leasehold pursuant thereto.
17. Pursuant to a stripping lease dated July 25, 1966, by
and between the County of Northumberland, as Lessor,
and Taxpayer, as Miner, Taxpayer engaged in the extrac-
tion of coal by its process of strip mining, during 1966 and
1967 on 133 acres of land in the Township of Coal, North-
umberland County, pennsylvania. A copy of this lease is
attached hereto as Exhibit “C” and made a part hereof.
This lease is still in effect, and Taxpayer’s corporation,
Split Vein Coal Company, Inc., is still mining the
leasehold pursuant thereto.
18. Taxpayer purchased the equipment itemized on
Exhibit “D” attached hereto and made a part hereof for
use in the mining operations described in this Partial
Stipulation of Facts. The said equipment was so used at all
times material hereto.
19. The Lessor under the leases described in para-
graphs 16, 17 and 18, above (hereinafter the “leases”) de-
rived no income from the mining operations under the
leases, except the royalty of 35 cents per gross ton of raw
coal removed by Taxpayer from the land.
20. The number of employees of Taxpayer during the
tax years involved was as follows:
1966 — 14
1967 — 14
21. On or about February 25, 1974, Taxpayers filed
timely claims for refund for the years 1966 and 1967 with
the District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Mid-
Atlantic Region, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The claims
for refund were disallowed. Taxpayers timely filed this
appeal.
22. The only legal issue before the Court is whether
Taxpayer had such an economic interest in the anthracite
coal in place under the leases to support a deduction from
gross income for depletion under Section 613 of the Inter-
nal Revenue Code of 1954, as amended, for the years 1966
and 1967. If the Court so decides, Taxpayers are entitled
22a
to arefund of Federal Income Tax with interest thereon as
provided by law, which refund shall later be computed.
Respectfully Submitted,
JAMES L. MALONE, III, ESQUIRE
Department of Justice
Tax Division
Washington, D.C. 20580
LLOYD R. PERSUN
HOWELL C. METTE
SHEARER, METTE & WOODSIDE
P.O. Box 729
1801 North Front Street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108
M. CARR FERGUSON
Assistant Attorney General
EXHIBIT A
DEEP MINING LEASE
THIS AGREEMENT, made and concluded the 24th day
of October, A.D., 1964 by and between the COUNTY OF
NORTHUMBERLAND, acting by ana through W. Fred
Kohler, Fred E. Hoffman and Oscar Kehler its duly
elected and qualified County Commissioners, who are
hereby acting and contracting for and on behalf of the said
County and also as Trustee for the various municipal sub-
divisions interested in the hereinafter described property,
(hereinafter called LESSOR), Party of the First Part, and
Split Vein Coal Company—R.D. #1, Paxinos, Penna.
Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, (hereinafter
called MINER), Party of the Second Part:
WITNESSETH
IN CONSIDERATION of the covenants and agree-
ments hereinafter contained, and in consideration of the
sum of ONE ($1.00) DOLLAR, each to the other in hand
paid, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, it is
23a
agreed by and between LESSOR AND MINER, the par-
ties of this agreement, as follows:
1. LESSOR, insofar as it has the power and authority
so to do, hereby leases and lets unto MINER the coal un-
derlying the following described tract of land, together
with the right and privilege of mining and removing the
same, but not including any other mineral, gas or sub-
stance and not including the right to cut or remove timber,
which premises are described as follows, to wit:
Being Independent Mining Operation No. W-111
In the No 1 Vein, North dip,
at or near Southwest of Trevorton, Pa.
Located on Jeremiah Jackson Tract 112 acres.
Situate in the Township of West Cameron
More particularly described as follows:
More particularly described as follows:
The western limit of this lease is the western line of
the Jeremiah Jackson Tract in West Cameron
Township. The eastern line is 750 feet east of the
above mentioned western line.
A reservation pillar of 100 feet shall be maintained
at the eastern limit of this lease with 50 feet to be
held by the present lessee and 50 feet to be held by
any adjoining lessee.
The mining limit of this lease is for a distance of 700
feet in the Number 1 vein, north dip of the Jeremiah
Jackson Tract in West Cameron Township, southwest
of Trevorton, Pa.
The lessee shall have a survey made within six
months from the date of this lease and periodically or
at any time the county Engineers should find it neces-
sary and furnish the County Engineers with a print
showing the location of the surface opening and
workings on this lease.
2. The LESSOR hereby grants, demises and lets unto
the MINER the right and privilege of digging, mining and
carrying away anthracite coal wholly at his own expense
and cost in and from the described premises, in accordance
with the terms and conditions of this agreement.
24a
3. MINER hereby agrees, from and after the exectuion
and delivery of this agreement, and until the MINER shall
have finally ceased, whether voluntarily or involuntarily,
mining upon any or all of said premises, that MINER shall
pay as rent and royalty to LESSOR weekly the sum of
THIRTY FIVE ($.35) CENTS per gross ton of two
thousand two hundred forty (2,240) pounds of raw coal
removed from said land. It is understood that the term
“raw coal” as used herein shall mean the material taken
from the ground, prior to any preliminary cleaning and
prior to the time when it shall be prepared in any manner
whatsoever.
The MINER agrees to pay the LESSOR the royalty for
the said coal or have the same deducted and paid for him
by the purchaser of said coal within one week from the
time that the coal is mined and removed.
4. The MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and
removed from said tract delivered to any breaker desig-
nated by the LESSOR except that the MINER may, with
prior consent in writing of the LESSOR, change breakers
from time to time, and the LESSOR agrees not to unrea-
sonably withhold its consent to change, provided, however
that no coal shall be taken to a breaker outside of North-
umberland County. The MINER further agrees that the
part breaker operator to whom the coal is delivered shall
deduct the herein specified royalty on the gross weight as
herein specified upon the delivery of each load of raw coal
removed from the said tract described herein.
5. All royalty or rent collected by the breaker operator
on raw coal delivered from the tract herein described,
shall be paid to the LESSOR together with a complete and
adequate record of the royalty collected.
6. MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and re-
moved from said tract weighted at scales by a duly
licensed weighmaster of the Commonwealth of Pennsyl-
vania. The scales to be used shall be selected by the
MINER from the list of scales approved by the LESSOR
and the MINER shall not take any coal to scales not ap-
proved by LESSOR.
25a
7. MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and re-
moved from said tract weighed at the following approved
seales, to wit:
(Name of Approved Scales)
8. MINER further agrees that in the event the MINER
desires to weigh raw coal at scales other than the scales
specified herein, the LESSOR shall be notified in writing
of the desire of the MINER and the MINER shall not
change scales until such change is approved by the LES-
SOR and then shall not change except to approved scales
on the list of scales approved by the LESSOR.
9. The MINER agrees to keep complete and accurate
records of all raw coal removed from the premises and
agrees that the agents of the LESSOR shall have the right
and privilege of inspecting said books and records at any
time. This record shall include the daily gross tonnage of
raw coal mined or removed from the said tract. The
MINER also agrees to preserve and keep for two (2) years
after termination of this lease, a duplicate weight slip for
each and every ton of raw coal mined and removed from
the said premises. The MINER also agrees to keep and
maintain such records as shall be furnished by the LES-
SOR under this agreement.
10. MINER hereby agrees that the methods and man-
ner of keeping records, making statements, reports and
the time and place of payment of the royalties upon the
coal mined and removed from the herein described lands
may be changed at any time by the LESSOR.
11. MINER hereby agrees that it will work the land
herein mentioned continuously and in a skillful and work-
manlike manner under the direction and subject to the ap-
proval of the LESSOR, its agents or engineers, to its full-
est capacity, and to leave no merchantable coal abandoned
or neglected which in the opinion of said agent or en-
gineers can be taken out without injury to the mines or
lands.
26a
12. MINER hereby agrees to comply with all the laws
of the United States of America and the Commonwealth of
Pennsyvlania and to secure any permits and licenses which
may be required by the United States of America or
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and particularly from the
Pennslyvania Department of Forests and Waters before
engaging in any mining under this lease.
13. MINER hereby agrees to protect and save harmless
the LESSOR from all liability of whatsoever kind or na-
ture which may be caused by, or which may flow from, the
operations of said MINER upon said land.
14. This agreement shall in no way nullify, invalidate or
impair in any way the title of the LESSOR and payment of
the royalties or rents hereunder shall in no way work or be
construed as a redemption either in whole or in part, or as
a sale of said land either in whole or in part; nor shall it be
construed as an abandonment by the LESSOR of this land,
but said tract of land shall remain in the hands of the
County Commissioners as LESSOR and the payments
made hereunder shall be payments in the nature of rent or
royalty. The LESSOR and its said Commissioners,
W. Fred Kohler, Fred E. Hoffman and Oscar Kehler,
neither individually nor in any capacity assume any liabil-
ity hereunder except to receive and turn over the Treas-
urer of Northumberland County such moneys as are re-
ceived hereunder, so that the County Treasurer may
properly distribute them among the various municipal
subdivisions interested in the said lands in such propor-
tions as each may be entitled to under the law. It is fur-
ther understood between the parties hereto that in the
event of a sale of said lands by the County or a redemption
in full of the said lands by those persons legally entitled to
redeem the same, that this lease shall then immediately
terminate as well as all rights of the MINER hereunder.
15. It is expressly understood between the parties
hereto that the MINER shall operate the lands herein
leased as an independent contractor and not as the agent,
servant, or employee of LESSOR, and any provision in
this agreement pertaining to supervision, inspection or in-
27a
structions by LESSOR, its representatives, engineers,
employees or agents, is not intended to, nor shall it be
construed in any way, to create a master and servant re-
lationship between the parties hereto.
16. MINER hereby agrees not to transfer, assign,
mortgage, or encumber with liens of any kind whatsoever
the estate hereby granted, either in whole or in part, nor
interest or associate any other person, corporations or as-
sociations in the estate hereby granted without prior writ-
ten consent of the LESSOR first had and obtained.
17. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto that the MINER is granted the right and
privilege (as hereinabove limited) to remove coal from the
hereinabove mentioned land by deep mining methods only
and that the MINER shall not remove or cause to be re-
moved coal.from the hereinabove described land by the
open pit or strip mining method. This agreement shall au-
tomatically terminate and cease to have any binding effect
and force in the event that the MINER for any cause or
reason whatsoever, not due to abnormal conditions, shall
cease to mine and remove coal from the aforedescribed
premises for a period of at least thirty consecutive days,
and in the event of his failure to so mine, the LESSOR at
its option may, without taking any legal procedure, de-
clare this lease void and retake possession of the demised
premises together with any and all improvements situated
thereon.
18. The MINER agreed to permit ingress, egress and
regress over the leased premises for all persons who have
other agreements with the LESSOR for the mining of
coal.
19. Any violation of any of the terms of this agreement
by the MINER shall immediately cancel the same.
20. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto that LESSOR may terminate this agreement
completely and fully and without liability upon it or any
further recourse against it, upon thirty days written
notice given to MINER or by posting the same upon the
lands hereinabove mentioned.
je
28a
21. Should the presently located operation of the
MINER on the above described tract interfere with other
operations, LESSOR reserves the right to relocate such
presently located operations of the MINER to a new loca-
tion on the above described trace of land as may be avail-
able to and agreed upon by the MINER and in the event of
such relocation the MINER will be given the first prefer-
ence for a new location.
22. In the event of any dispute pertaining to mining
matters between MINERS who have agreements from the
LESSOR, the said matters shall be submitted to the
county engineers whose decisions shall be final. A failure
of any MINER to obey the decision of such engineers shall
operate as a cancellation of this lease.
23. MINER agrees at all reasonable time to permit the
LESSOR or its agents or engineers to go upon and inspect
the demised premises and every part thereof.
24. MINER agrees to peacefully deliver up and surren-
der possession of the demised premises to the LESSOR at
the expiration or sooner termination of this agreement or
any renewal or extension thereof.
25. The MINER shall furnish to the LESSOR at least
twice a year a correct map and survey of all his or its un-
derground workings brought up to date. The first map
shall be submitted on or before May 1, 1956, and each six
months thereafter during the continuance of this agree-
ment.
26. All rights and liabilities herein given to or imposed
upon the respective parties hereto shall extend to and bind
the several and respective heirs, executors, adminis-
trators, successors and assigns of the parties, except as
other wise herein set forth; and if there shall be more than
one MINER they shall all be bound jointly and severally
by the terms, convenants and agreements herein and the
word MINER shall be taken and deemed to mean each and
every person or party mentioned herein, be the same one
or more, and if there shall be more than one MINER any
notice required or permitted by the terms of this agree-
ment may be given by or to any one thereof and it shall
29a
have the same force and effect as if given by or to all
thereof. No rights, however, shall enure to the benefit of
any assignee of MINER unless the assignment to such
MINER has been first approved by LESSOR in writing as
aforesaid.
27. All notices required to be given by the LESSOR to
the MINER shall be sufficiently given if either mailed to
the MINER at his last known address or if the same be
posted on the demised premises. It is agreed that the
LESSOR has let the demised premises in their present
condition and without any representations on the part of
the LESSOR, its employees, engineers or agents. It is
understood by the MINER that in granting this lease
LESSOR makes no representation of any kind as to
whether there is any anthracite coal located on the leased
premises. |
28. This agreement, subject to all of its terms and con-
ditions, shall be in effect until termination of lease subject,
however, to the length of time during which the County of
Northumberland remains the owner of said premises and
subject, also, to the right on the part of the LESSOR to
increase the royalties hereunder by a thirty day written
notice to the MINER, provided that such increase shall
not be more than five cents a gross ton during the term of
this agreement. MINER further agrees, upon receipt of
such notice increasing the royalty, to be bound by the
same with the same force and and effect as through such
increased amount were stated in this lease, and the failure
to pay such increased royalty shall be considered a default
under this agreement, subjecting the MINER to the
penalties herein provided.
20. If the rent or royalty herein agreed to be paid shall
remain unpaid when the same ought to be paid, MINER
hereby empowers any Prothonotary or attorney of any
court of record to appear for MINER in any and all actions
which may be brought for rent and/or royalty as herein
agreed to be paid by MINER, and to sign for MINER an
agreement for entering in any competent court an amica-
ble action or actions for the recovery of such rent or roy-
. 80a
alty, and in said suits or said amicable action, to confess
judgment against MINER for all or any part of the rent or
royalty specified in this agreement and then unpaid, to-
gether with costs and with an attorney’s commission of
10%. Such authority shall not be exhausted by one exer-
cise thereof but judgment may be confessed as aforesaid,
from time to time, as often as any of said rent or royalty
shall fall due or be in arrears and such powers may be
exercised as well after the expiration either of the original
term and/or during any extension or renewal of this term,
and may be exercised successively and as often as pay-
ments herein reserved may fall due. It is further agreed
by MINER that a copy of this agreement shall be suffi-
cient evidence of the same and may be filed in said amica-
ble action.
30. Upon the breach of any of the covenants, obligations
or agreements of this agreement, and when this agree-
ment shall be determined by condition broken, either
during the original term of the agreement or any renewal
or extension thereof, and also when and as soon as the
term hereby created or any extension thereof, shall have
expired, the LESSOR may declare this agreement null
and void and of no effect, and upon default, expiration or
termination in any way herein provided, it shall be lawful
for any attorney as attorney for the LESSOR to file an
agreement for entering in any competent court an amica-
ble action in ejection against MINER and all persons
claiming under the MINER for the recovery by the LES-
SOR of possession of the herein demised premises for
which this agreement or a copy thereof shall be his suffi-
cient warrant. Whereupon, the Prothonolary or any other
attorney of any court of record is hereby authorized and
empowered by the MINER to appear for him and confess
judgment or judgments in an amicable action or actions of
ejectment against the said MINER and in favor of the
LESSOR for the said premises or any other premises of
the LESSOR then occupied by the MINER, and to direct
the immediate issuance of a writ or writs of habere facias
possessionen with clause of fieri facias for costs, waiving
all irregularities, without notice and without asking leave
3la
of court, and if after such action shall have been com-
menced, the same shall be determined and the possession
of the premises hereby demised shall remain in or be re-
stored to the MINER, LESSOR shall have the right upon
any subsequent default or defaults or upon subsequent
termination of this agreement as hereinbefore set forth, to
bring one or more amicable action or actions from time to
time as hereinbefore set forth, to recover possession of
said premises and the said powers herein granted may be
exercised as often as default shall occur and such authority
shall not be exhausted by one exercise thereof.
31. All the remedies hereinbefore given to LESSOR
and all rights and remedies given to it by law and equity
shall be cumulative and concurrent. No determination of
this agreement or the taking or recovering of the premises
shall deprive LESSOR of any of its remedies or actions
against the MINER for rent due at the time, or which
under the terms hereof would in the future become due as
if there has been no determination, or for sums due at the
time or which under the terms hereof would in the fu-
ture become due, nor shall the bringing of any action for
rent or breach of covenant or resort to any other remedy
herein provided for the recovery of rent be construed as a
waiver of the right to obtain possession of the premises.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have
hereunto set their respective hands and seals th: day and
year first above written.
ATTEST: COUNTY OF NORTHUMBERLAND
EXHIBIT B
DEEP MINING LEASE
THIS AGREEMENT, made and concluded the 26th day
of October A.D. 1966 by and between the COUNTY OF
NORTHUMBERLAND, acting by and through W. Fred
Kehler, Fred E. Hoffman and Oscar Kehler its duly
elected and qualified County Commissioners, who are
hereby acting and contracting for and on behalf of the said
County and also as Trustee for the various municipal sub-
32a
divisions interested in the hereinafter described property,
(hereinafter called LESSOR), Party of the First Part, and
Split Vein Coal Company—R.D. #1, Paxinos, Pennsyl-
vania Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, (hereinafter
called MINER), Party of Second part:
WITNESSETH
IN CONSIDERATION of the convenants and agree-
ments hereinafter contained, and in consideration of the
sum of ONE ($1.00) DOLLAR each to the other in hand
paid, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, it is
agreed by and between LESSOR AND MINER, the par-
ties of this agreement, as follows:
1. LESSOR, insofar as it has the power and authority
so to do, hereby leases and lets unto MINER the coal un-
derlying the following described tract of land, together
with the right and privilege of mining and removing the
same, but not including any other mineral, gas or sub-
stance and not including the right to cut or remove timber,
which premises are described as follows, to wit:
Being Independent Mining Operation No. C-692
In the No 8 & 9 Veins North and South dips
at or near East of Bridy’s Bank
Located on Fulton Lands (James Jenkins) Tract
1371.5 acres.
Situate in the Township of Coal
More particularly described as follows:
More particularly described as follows:
The eastern limit of this lease is the boundry line
between the Fulton Coal Company Tract and the
McIntyre Tract. The western limit of this lease is
1200 feet west of the above boundry line.
The mining limit of this lease is for a distance of
1200 feet in the number 8 and 9 veins, north and south
dips on the Fulton Lands (James Jenkins Tract), in
Coal Township.
The iessee shall have a survey made within six
months from the date of this lease and periodically or
at any time the County Engineer should find it neces-
sary and furnish the County Engineer with a print
33a
showing the location of the surface openings and
workings on this lease.
2. The LESSOR hereby grants, demises and lets unto
the MINER the right and privilege of digging, mining and
carrying away anthracite coal wholly at his own expense
and cost in and from the described premises, in accordance
with the terms and conditions of this agreement.
3. MINER hereby agrees, from and after the execution
and delivery of this agreement, and until the MINER shall
have finally ceased, whether voluntarily or involuntarily,
mining upon any or all of the said premises, that MINER
shall pay as rent and royalty to LESSOR weekly the sum
of THIRTY FIVE ($.35) CENTS per gross ton of two
thousand two hundred forty (2,240) pounds of raw coal
removed froni said land. It is understood that the term
“raw coal” as used herein shall mean the material taken
from the ground, prior to any preliminary cleaning and
prior to the time when it shall be prepared in any manner
whatsoever.
The MINER agrees to pay the LESSOR the royalty for
the said coal or have the same deducted and paid for him
by the purchaser of said coal within one week from the
time that the coal is mined and removed.
4. The MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and
removed from said tract delivered to any breaker desig-
nated by the LESSOR except that the MINER may, with
prior consent in Writing of the LESSOR, change breakers
from time to time, and the LESSOR agrees not to unrea-
sonably withhold its consent to change, provided, however
that no coal shall be taken to a breaker outside of North-
umberland County. The MINER furhter agrees that the
part breaker operator to whom the coal is delivered shall
deduct the herein specified royalty on the gross weight as
herein specified upon the delivery of each load of raw coal
removed from the said tract described herein.
5. All royalty or rent collected by the breaker operator
on raw coal delivered from the tract herein described,
shall be paid to the LESSOR together with a complete and
adequate record of the royalty collected.
34a
6. MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and re-
moved from the said tract weighed at scales by a duly
licensed weighmaster of the Commonwealth of Pennsyl-
vania. The scales to be used shall be selected by the
MINER from the list of scales approved by the LESSOR
and the MINER shall not take any coal to scales not ap-
proved by LESSOR.
7. MINER agrees to have all raw coal mined and re-
moved from said tract weighed at the following approved
scales, to wit:
(Name of Approved Scales)
3. MINER further agrees that in the event the MINER
desires to weigh raw coal at scales other than the scales
specified herein, the LESSOR shall be notified in writing
of the desire of the MINER and the MINER shall not
change scales until such change is approved by the LES-
SOR and then shall not change except to approved scales
on the list of scales approved by the LESSOR.
9. The MINER agrees to keep complete and accurate
records of all raw coal removed from the premises and
agrees that the agents of the LESSOR shall have the right
and privilege of inspecting said books and records at any
time. This record shall include the daily gross tonnage of
raw coal mined or removed from the said tract. The
MINER also agrees to preserve and keep for two (2) years
after termination of this lease, a duplicate weight slip for
each and every ton of raw coal mined and removed from
the said premises. The MINER also agrees to keep and
maintain such records as shall be furnished by the LES-
SOR under this agreement.
10. MINER hereby agrees that the methods and man-
ner of keeping records, making statements, reports and
the time and place of payment of the royalties upon the
coal mined and removed from the herein described hands
may be changed at any time by the LESSOR.
11. MINER hereby agrees that it will work the land
herein mentioned continuously and in a skillful and work-
35a
manlike manner under the direction and subject to the ap-
proval of the LESSOR, its agents or engineers, to its full-
est capacity, and to leave no merchantable coal abandoned
or neglected which in the opinion of said agent or en-
gineers can be taken out without injury to the mines or
lands.
12. MINER hereby agrees to comply with all the laws
of the United States of America and the Commonwealth or
Pennsylvania and to secure any permits and licenses which
may be required by the United States of America or
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and particularly from the
Pennsylvania Department of Forests and Waters, before
engaging in any mining under this lease.
13. MINER hereby agrees to protect and save harmless
the LESSOR from all liability of whatsoever kind or na-
ture which may be caused by, or which may flow from, the
operations of said MINER upon said land.
14. This agreement shall in no way nullify, invalidate or
impair in any way the title of the LESSOR, and payment
of the royalties or rents hereunder shall in no way work or
be construed as a redemption either in whole or in part, or
as a sale of said land either in whole or in part; nor shall it
be construed as an abandonment by the LESSOR of this
land; but said tract of land shall remain in the hands of the
County Commissioners as LESSOR and the payments
made hereunder shall be payments in the nature of rent or
royalty. The LESSOR and its said Commissioners,
W. Fred Kohler, Fred E. Hoffman and George F. Perles,
neither individually nor in any capacity assume any liabil-
ity hereunder except to receive and turn over to the
Treasurer of Northumberland County such moneys as are
received hereunder, so that the County Treasurer may
properly distribute them among the various municipal
subdivisions interested in the said lands in such propor-
tions as each may be entitled to under the law. It is fur-
ther understood between the parties hereto that in the
event of a sale of said lands by the County or a redemption
in full of the said lands by those persons legally entitled to
36a
redeem the same, that this lease shall then immediately
terminate as well as all rights of the MINER hereunder.
15. It is expressly understood between the parties
hereto that the MINER shall operate the lands herein
leased as an independent contractor and not as the agent,
servant or employee of LESSOR, and any provision in this
agreement pertaining to supervision, inspection or in-
structions by LESSOR, its representatives, engineers,
employees or agents, is not intended to, nor shall it be
construed in any way, to create a master and servant re-
lationship between the parties hereto.
16. MINER hereby agrees not to transfer, assign,
mortgage, or encumber with liens of any kind whatsoever
the estate hereby granted, either in whole or in part, nor
interest or associate any other person, corporations or as-
sociations in the estate hereby granted without prior writ-
ten consent of the LESSOR first had and obtained.
17. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto that the MINER is granted the right and
privilege (as hereinabove limited) to remove coal from the
hereinabove mentioned land by deep mining methods only
and that the MINER shall not remove or cause to be re-
moved coal from the hereinabove described land by the
open pit or strip mining method. This agreement shall au-
tomatically terminate and cease to have any binding effect
and force in the event that the MINER for any cause or
reason whatsoever, not due to abnormal conditions, shall
cease to mine and remove coal from the aforedescribed
premises for a period of at least thirty consecutive days,
and in the event of his failure to so mine, the LESSOR at
its option may, without taking any legal procedure, de-
clare this lease void and retake possession of the demised
premises together with any and all improvements situated
thereon.
18. The MINER agrees to permit ingress, egress and
regress over the leased premises for all persons who have
other agreements with the LESSOR for the mining of
coal.
37a
19. Any violation of any of the terms of this agreement
by the MINER shall immediately cancel the same.
20. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto that LESSOR may terminate this agreement
completely and fully and without liability upon it or any
further recourse against it, upon thirty days written
notice given to MINER or by posting the same upon the
lands hereinabove mentioned.
21. Should the presently located operation of the
MINER on the above described tract interfere with other
operations, LESSOR reserves the right to relocate such
presently located operations of the MINER to a new loca-
tion on the above described tract of land as may be avail-
able to and agreed upon by the MINER and in the event of
such relocation the MINER will be given the first prefer-
ence for a new location.
22. In the event of any dispute pertaining to mining
matters between MINERS who have agreements from the
LESSOR, the said matters shall be submitted to the
county engineers whose decision shall be final. A failure of
any MINER to obey the decision of such engineers shall
operate as a cancellation of this lease.
23. MINER agrees at all reasonable time to permit the
LESSOR or its agents or engineers to go upon and inspect
the demised premises and every part thereof.
24. MINER agrees to peacefully deliver up and surren-
der possession of the demised premises to the LESSOR at
the expiration or sooner termination of this agreement or
any renewal or extension thereof.
25. The MINER shall furnish to the LESSOR at least
twice a year a correct map and survey of all his or its un-
derground workings brought up to date. The first map
shall be submitted on or before May 1, 1956, and each six
months thereafter during the continuance of this agree-
ment.
26. All rights and liabilities herein given to or imposed
upon the respective parties hereto shall extend to and bind
the several and respective heirs, executors, adminis-
38a
trators, successors and assigns of the parties, except as
other wise herein set forth; and if there shall be more than
one MINER they shall all be bound jointly and severally
by the terms, convenants and agreements herein and the
word MINER shall be taken and deemed to mean each and
every person or party mentioned herein, be the same one
or more, and if there shall be more than one MINER any
notice required or permitted by the terms of this agree-
ment may be given by or to anyone thereof and it shall
have the same force and effect as if given by or to all
thereof. No rights, however, shall enure to the benefit of
any assignee of MINER unless the assignment to such
MINER has been first approved by LESSOR in writing as
aforesaid.
27. All notices required to be given by the LESSOR to
the MINER shall be sufficiently given if either mailed to
the MINER at his last known address or if the same be
posted on the demised premises. It is agreed that the
LESSOR has let the demised premises in their present
condition and without any representations on the part of
the LESSOR, its employees, engineers or agents. It is
understood by the MINER that in granting this lease
LESSOR makes no representation of any kind as to
whether there is any anthracite coal located on the leased
premises.
28. This agreement, subject to all of its terms and con-
ditions, shall be in effect until termination of lease subject,
however, to the length of time during which the County of
Northumberland remains the owner of said premises and
subject, also, to the right on the part of the LESSOR to
increase the royalties hereunder by a thirty day written
notice to the MINER, provided that such increase shall
not be more than five cents a gross ton during the term of
this agreement. MINER further agrees, upon receipt of
such notice increasing the royalty, to be bound by the
same with the same force and and effect as though such
increased amount were stated in this lease, and the failure
to pay such increased royalty shall be considered a default
under this agreement, subjecting the MINER to the
penalties herein provided.
39a
29. If the rent or royalty herein agreed to be paid shall
remain unpaid when the same ought to be paid, MINER
hereby empowers any Prothonotary or attorney of any
court of record to appear for MINER in any and all actions
which may be brought for rent and/or royalty as herein
agreed to be paid by MINER, and to sign for MINER an
agreement for entering in any competent court an amica-
ble action or actions for the recovery of such rent or roy-
alty, and in said suits or said amicable action, to confess
judgment against MINER for all or any part of the rent or
royalty specified in this agreement and then unpaid, to-
gether with costs and with an attorney’s commission of
10%. Such authority shall not be exhausted by one exer-
cise thereof but judgment may be confessed as aforesaid,
from time to time, as often as any of said rent or royalty
shall fall due or be in arrears and such powers may be
exercised as well after the expiration either of the original
term and/or during any extension or renewal of this term,
and may be exercised successively and as often as pay-
ments herein reserved may fall due. It is further agreed
by MINER that a copy of this agreement shall be suffi-
cient evidence of the same and may be filed in said amica-
ble action.
30. Upon the breach of any of the covenants, obligations
or agreements of this agreement, and when this agree-
ment shall be determined by condition broker, either dur-
ing the original term of the agreement or any renewal or
extension thereof, and also when and as soon as the term
hereby created or any extension thereof, shall have ex-
pired, the LESSOR may declare this agreement null and
void and of no effect, and upon default, expiration or ter-
mination in any way herein provided, it shall be lawful for
any attorney as attorney for the LESSOR to file an
agreement for entering in any competent court an amica-
ble action in ejectment against MINER and all persons
claiming under the MINER for the recovery by the LES-
SOR of possession of the herein demised premises, for
which this agreement or a copy thereof shall be his suffi-
cient warrant. Whereupon, the Prothonotary or any other
attorney of any court of record is hereby authorized and
40a
empowered by the MINER to appear for him and confess
judgment or judgments in an amicable action or actions of
ejectment against the said MINER and in favor of the
LESSOR for the said premises or any other premises of
the LESSOR then occupied by the MINER, and to direct
the immediate issuance of a writ or writs of habere facias
possessionen with clause of fieri facias for costs, waiving
all irregularities, without notice and without asking leave
of court, and if after such action shall have been com-
menced, the same shall be determined and the possession
of the premises hereby demised shall remain in or be re-
stored to the MINER, LESSOR shall have the right upon
any subsequent default or defaults or upon subsequent
termination of this agreement as hereinbefore set forth, to
bring one or more amicable action or actions from time to
time as hereinbefore set forth, to recover possession of
said premises and the said powers herein granted may be
exercised as often as default shall occur and such authority
shall not be exhausted by one exercise thereof.
31. All the remedies hereinbefore given to LESSOR
and all rights and remedies given to it by law and equity
shall be cumulative and concurrent. No determination of
this agreement or the taking or recovering of the premises
shall deprive LESSOR of any of its remedies or actions
against the MINER for rent due at the time, or which
under the terms hereof would in the future become due as
if there has been no determination, or for sums due at the
time or which under the terms hereof would in the future
become due, nor shall the bringing of any action for rent or
breach of covenant or resort to any other remedy herein
provided for the recovery of rent by construed as a waiver
of the right to obtain possession of the premises.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have
hereunto set their respective hands and seals the day and
year first above written.
4la
STRIPPING PERMIT
TO
EXPLORE FOR ANTHRACITE COAL
June 27, 1966
PERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTED TO Split Vein Coal
Company, R.D. #1, Paxinos, Penna. to explore for an-
thracite coal in accordance with existing mining laws on
the Gray & Cleaver Tract (133 acre) in Coal Township,
Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, for a period of 90
days from the date of this permit. This permission is
granted at the sole cost, expense and liability of the per-
son to whom the permit is granted and the County Com-
missioners assume no liability of any kind, whatsoever by
granting this permit.
The location for which the right to exploration is
granted on the said tract is several vein South dip.
In the event that anthracite coal is discovered during
such 90 day period, and the person or persons to whom
this permit is granted shall have the first opportunity to
secure a mining lease on the premises.
This permit is issued on the assumption that the land on
which the exploration is to be conducted is county owned
land. No permission is granted to interfere with the other
persons now mining on such county owned land.
NORTHUMBERLAND COURT COMMISSIONERS
EXHIBIT C
STRIPPING LEASE
THIS INDENTURE, made and concluded this 6th day of
June, A.D., 1967, between COUNTY OF NORTHUM-
BERLAND, a municipal subdivision of the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania, by and through W. Fred Kohler, Fred E.
Hoffman and Oscar Kehler, its duly elected and acting
Board of County Commissioners hereby acting and con-
tracting for said County and also as Trustee for the vari-
42a
ous taxing districts interested in the hereinafter described
land, hereinafter called lessor, First Party;
AND
Split Vein Coal Company
R.D. #1,
Paxinos, Penna.
hereinafter called Lessee, Second party.
WITNESSETH
Lessor does hereby grant unto Lessee, the right to strip
mine and remove coal from the hereinafter described
premises, for a term beginning on the 25th day of July,
1966 and ending on the Completion of lease, upon the con-
ditions hereinafter set forth.
1. The land from which the coal is to be removed is de-
scribed as follows, excepting and reserving therefrom,
however, such rights as may have been acquired by any
person, firm or corporation prior to the date of this lease:
This lease is for the right to strip the several veins on
the Gray & Cleaver Tract (133 Acres) in Coal Township,
Northumberland County, Pennsylvania.
Interference or encroachment on any other stripping
lease or Independent Mining lease within the limits of this
lease will not be permitted unless consented to by the
stripping or mining lessee.
2. The payments hereinafter set forth and charged are
and shall be construed to be a fixed, determined and es-
tablished rental charge to be paid for the rights hereby
granted, for the time and term designated in this lease
agreement or sooner termination of the same, excepting
the coal as and when removed from the ground shall be-
come the property of LESSEE at and for the price and
consideration hereinafter set forth.
3. LESSEE is granted the right to haul, convey and
transport the raw coal stripped from the said premises
over, through and across the above described premises
and the highways appurtenent thereto and cover which
43a
LESSOR has the right of ingress and egress for the pur-
pose of marketing the coal so removed.
4. LESSEE shall not assign or transfer this lease con-
tract or any part or portion thereof without the written
consent and approval in writing of LESSOR having first
been obtained.
5. LESSEE shall furnish, at his own expense and cost,
all labor, material, plant tools and supplies, including
gasoline and oil, shovels, grading equipment, trucks and
any other necessary equipment and material necessary for
the efficient operation and conduct of the strip mining of
coal from the property herein described.
6. In consideration where of the said LESSEE coven-
ants end agrees with the LESSOR to and as follows, to
wit:
a. LESSEE shall and will pay the sum of thirty-five
cents per gross ton of twenty two hundred forty (2240)
pounds for each: and every ton of raw coal stripped and
removed from the demised premises. All such payments
shall be paid to the LESSOR in weekly installments and
each payment shall cover the preceding week. The pay-
ments shall be made to the LESSOR, County of Northum-
berland, at the office of the County commissioners at the
Court House at Sunbury, Pennsylvania. It is understood
that the term “raw coal’, as used herein, shall mean the
material taken from the ground prior to any preliminary
cleaning and prior to the time when it shall be prepared in
any manner whatsoever.
b. LESSOR reserves the right to increase the royalty
hereunder by a 30 day written notice to the LESSEE,
provided that such increase shall not be more than 5¢ a
gross ton during the term of this agreement.
ce. LESSEE on or before the tenth day of each month
during the term and life of this Agreement, shall furnish
LESSOR or its duly authorized agent, or representative, a
statement of the daily gross tonnage of raw coal, stripped
and/or removed from said tract of land during each and
every day of the preceding calendar month; and such
- 44a
statement shall be based upon records of all coal stripped
and removed as aforesaid, kept by LESSEE and furnished
to LESSOR. LESSEE hereby agrees to preserve and
keep a duplicate wieght slip for each and every load of raw
coal stripped and removed from the herein described land
by himself or by his lessees and LESSOR through its duly
authorized agents or representatives shall at all reason-
able times have the right to examine and inspect such re-
ports, records and weight slips.
d. LESSEE agrees to have all raw coal stripped and
removed from the herein described lands, weighed at a
scales by a duly licensed weightmaster of the Common-
wealth of Pennsylvania, as shall be designated in writing
by LESSOR.
e. LESSEE agrees that all coal stripped and removed
from the herein described lands shall be delivered to such
breakers, or preparation plants as may from time to time
be designated in writing by LESSOR. Prior to any deliv-
ery of raw coal stripped or removed from the herein de-
scribed land to a designated breaker or preparation plant,
LESSEE shall obtain from the operator of the same and
deliver to the LESSOR a written authority for the LES-
SOR, its representatives, engineers, agents or employees,
from time to time to make a full and complete inspection of
all books and records of said breaker or preparation plant
pertaining to the delivery and preparation of coal at said
plant during regular business hours.
f. It is expressly understood between the parties
hereto, that LESSEE shall conduct his operations here-
under as an Independent Contractor and not as servant,
agent or employee of the LESSOR, and any provisions in
this lease agreement pertaining to supervision, inspection
or instruction by LESSOR, its representatives, engineers,
employees, or agents is not intended nor shall be con-
strued to create a master and servant relationship be-
tween the parties hereto.
m. It is understood and agreed that, in cases where, in
this agreement, the approval or direction of the said au-
thorized agent is required, that such requirements are of
eT
45a
approval only and not of direction or management and that
the said First Party shall not incur any responsibility by
reason of acting as such authorized agent.
n. This lease is issued with the understanding that any
persons now conducting deep mining operations or owning
or operating utility lines on the premises shall be pro-
tected by LESSEE and his stripping operators. If the
stripping operator desires to strip an area occupied by a
deep mining operation or by utility lines, arrangements
must first be made with the owner or operator of the deep
mining operation or the utility line. These arrangements
must be made by the stripping operator or else he must
by-pass the deep mining operation or utility line so as not
to disturb them.
o. It is understood that this Agreement shall in no way
nullify or invalidate or impair the title of LESSOR, ac-
quired at a Treasurer’s Sale as aforesaid, and the payment
of royalties hereunder shall in no wise work a redemption,
either in whole or in part, of the said tract of land, nor
shall it be construed as an abandonment to LESSOR in its
land, but said tracts of land shall remain in the hands of
the County Commissioners and on records in their office as
unredeemed land.
p. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto, the neither LESSOR nor W. Fred Kohler,
Fred E. Hoffman and Oscar Kehler, individually nor in
any capacity assume any liability hereunder except to ac-
cept and turn over and properly distribute among the
various municipal subdivisions the proportionate share of
said royalties as shall be due to the same under the terms
of this agreement. And it is further understood between
the parties hereto, that LESSOR and said W. Fred
Kehler, Fred E. Hoffman and Oscar Kehler in entering
into this agreement are acting only to the extent of their
power and authority under the Laws of the Common-
wealth of Pennsylvania, as the same is now declared or
may be determined at any future time and are granting to
LESSEE only such rights and privileges as they are able
to do thereunder.
*
46a
7. Regulating contract breaches and forfeitures, it is
provided and agreed as follows:
a. That should the payments aforesaid be at any time in
arrears and unpaid, the said LESSOR may enforce pay-
ment thereof, by distress upon the goods and chattels of
the said LESSEE, as fully as is by law given to landlords
to distrain and sell in ordinary cases of rent in arrears;
and, the said LESSEE hereby waives the benefits of any
law or laws exempting such goods and chattels, or any
part thereof, from sale under such distress, or exemption
laws.
b. That if LESSEE shall fail to make the payments
herein provided upon the day and time when the same are
due and payable, it may be lawful for the LESSOR to
reenter upon the described premises and take possession
and hold the same until all arrears of rent are paid and
discharged by the LESSEE.
ce. That for any breach of non-performance of any of the
covenants, conditions or requirements contained herein,
which on the part of said LESSEE, his successors and as-
signs, are to be performed, fulfilled and kept, this lease
shall be and become absolutely void and of no effect, and it
shall and may be lawful for the said LESSOR, his succes-
sors and assigns, to at once re-enter and take possession of
the said described premises and appurtenances; and in
such case the said LESSEE, for himself, his successors
and assigns, hereby authorized any attorney of any court
to record in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to appear
for him and confess judgment in ejectment against him in
favor of LESSOR, with a full release of all claims and
damages against said attorney by reason of his so doing;
and thereupon a writ of habere facies possessionen, with
clause of fieri facias for costs, damages and rentals and
payments in arrears, may be issued (without asking leave
of Court) to put the said LESSOR in possession of the said
promises, with the appurtenances, without stay of execu-
tion, certiorari, or appeal or other relief, in law or equity,
PROVIDED HOWEVER, said judgment shall not prevent
/
47a
said LESSOR from preceeding to recover any rent due by
distress or otherwise and that said judgment shall not bar
LESSOR from any action for damages for any loss sus-
tained by any breach of this lease, but that the LESSOR
may have and use any or all such remedies as herein pro-
vided if he may deem proper. The remedies herein pro-
vided may be enforced either separately or concurrently.
d. LESSEE hereby authorized and empowers any at-
torney of any court of record in Pennsylvania or elsewhere
to appear for and to enter judgment against him for any
and all rentals, and other sums agreed hereunder to be
paid, which may be due and payable, whenever and as
often as the same have not been paid, without stay of
execution, until the same have been paid and with 10%
added for collection fees and he also waives the right of
inquisition on any real estate that may be levied upon to
collect the said judgment or judgments and he does volun-
tarily condemn the same and authorized the Prothonotary
to enter upon the fieri facies whenever same may be is-
sued, his said voluntary condemnation, and he further ag-
rees that said premises may be sold on a fieri facias and he
hereby waives and releases all relief from any and all ap-
praisement, stay or execution laws of any state now in
force or hereafter to be passed; that these exemption con-
ditions and provisions shall apply also to any other judg-
ments in ejectment and habere facias possessionem
thereon or any other judgments or actions undertaken by
LESSOR to enforce the provisions, covenants, and
agreements under this lease.
e. LESSEE shall deliver up peaceable possession of the
said premises to LESSOR, upon the expiration or sooner
termination of this lease.
9. It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties the LESSOR may terminate this agreement com-
pletely and fully and without any liability upon it or any
further recourse against it, upon thirty days written
notice given to LESSEE or by posting the same upon the
lands herein-above mentioned.
48a
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have hereunto set
their hands and seals this 9th day of June, 1967.
COUNTY OF NORTHUMBERLAND
Chief Clerk
Commissioners
WITNESSES:
EXHIBIT “D”
EQUIPMENT PURCHASE PRICE
66 Mack Tractor $ 19,057.50
1964 Cadillac (Used) 75% Business 3,294.07
1960 Dump Truck (Used) 4,950.00
26 A St. Dump T/A 4408 4,745.68
Radios & Installation 987.11
Motors & Coal Scoop 1,844.75
Rolls 2,450.00
Space Heater & Speed Reducer 536.10
Trailer 800.00
Trailer 6,009.48
Trailer (Used) 500.00
Trailer 6,810.62
Truck (Used) 7,129.67
Truck Diesel 13,344.69
Mack Truck—Trailer Rig 18,000.00
Pick-Up Truck 3,524.30
Tractor 16,700.00
Truck—Studebaker 1,700.00
Truck—White 2,000.00
Truck—Fuel (Used) 450.00
Breaker 22,000.00
Coal Hole 1,000.00
Loader 10,943.00
Loader (Used) 8,790.00
Loader 11,162.00
Coal Hole Equipment $ 3,435.00
Crusher 2,500.00
49a
EQUIPMENT PURCHASE PRICE
Hoist, Generators, Pumps, ete. 4,000.00
Compressor 2,000.00
Compressor 2,225.30
Generator 3,338.16
Generator 9,275.34
Conveyor Chains 5,000.00
Conveyor Chains 4,665.00
Pipe & Pumps 1,218.00
Coal Washing Table 312.15
Power Saws & Motor 207.50
Fan 200.00
Overhaul Allis-Chalmer 3,092.26
Overhaul Loader 3,504.17
Conveyor Chain 1,053.60
Conveyor 2,500.00
Pump Motor Pipes 1,385.20
Steel Tracks & Carts 1,789.15
Payloader 13,000.00
Rolls 2,200.00
Breaker Stoker 2,115.35
Garage—Cinder Block 8,577.23
Drilling Water Well 1,042.00
Water Pump & Installation 1,810.00
Welder $ 2,250.00
Batteries 3,620.64
Cat. 950 Traxcavator 24,078.76
Shovel #8105 18,500.00
Gould Pump 2,500.00
Cat. D.9 Tractor (Used) 30,012.50
Air Compressor 2,500.00
Power Shovel 11,000.00
Bulldozer 12,000.00
Conveyor Chain 1,701.00
Wench (Used) 600.00
Screening Plant 11,519.80
Electric Sets 2,832.50
Conveyor Chain (Used) 450.00
Quaker State Pump 424.25
TOTAL
$373, 163,83
50a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 403-75
ELWOOD SWANK AND RITA SWANK, PLAINTIFFS
v.
THE UNITED STATES, DEFENDANT
SUPPLEMENTAL STIPULATION OF FACTS
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the
parties hereto, through their respective counsel, that the
following facts may be accepted as true for the purpose of
this case. The parties reserve the right to argue the rele
vance of or materiality of any matter contained herein.
1. On October 26, 1962, John Stanley Perles, a sole pro-
prietor, entered into a Deep Mining Lease for the extrac-
tion of anthracite coal with the Commissioners of the
County of Northumberland, Pennsylvania. Taxpayer did
not enter into this lease. A true and correct copy of the
said lease is attached hereto as Exhibit “E” and made a
part hereof. On July 16, 1963, the said John Stanley Perles
entered into a partnership agreement with Taxpayer for
the mining, marketing and sale of anthracite coal. A true
and correct copy of the said partnership agreement is at-
tached hereto as Exhibit “F’”’.
2. The property described in the Deep Mining Leases
(October 24, 1964, and October 26, 1966) and the Stripping
Lease (June 6, 1967) here in suite, was not redeemed
under Pennsylvania redemption laws by payment of over-
due taxes by a party in interest.
LLoyYD R. PERSUN
Attorney for Plaintiff
M. CARR FERGUSON
Assistant Attorney General
JAMES L. MALONE III
Attorneys for Defendant
5la
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. Plaintiffs are Elwood and Rita Swank, husband and
wife, residing at R.D. No. 1, Box 85 D, Paxinos, Pennsy]l-
vania. They owned and operated a sole proprietorship t/a
Split Vein Coal Company throughout 1966 and during the
first 4 months of 1967. On May 1, 1967, the assets of the
sole proprietorship were transferred to Split Vein Coal
Company, Inc., in a tax-free incorporation pursuant to
Section 351 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, as
amended. Hereafter the term plaintiff shall mean both
husband and wife, or their sole proprietorship.
2. Plaintiff timely filed joint 1966 and 1967 Federal in-
dividual income tax returns with the District Director,
Internal Revenue Service, Mid-Atlantic Region, in
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and paid the tax shown to be
due thereon.
3. In his joint 1966 and 1967 Federal individual income
tax returns, plaintiff claimed as a deduction from ordinary
income a deduction for depletion of coal resources in which
he claimed an economic interest in 1966 and in the first
third of 1967.
4. After audit, the government disallowed the deduc-
tions referred to in paragraph 3 above and, as a result
thereof, assessed deficiencies against plaintiff for the
years 1966 and 1967 in the aggregate amount of $30,587.84
which was paid to the government under protest, together
with assessed interest in the aggregate amount of $3,663.
5. On or about February 25, 1974, plaintiff filed timely
claims for refund for the years 1966 and 1967. The claims
for refund were disallowed. Plaintiff timely filed this ap-
peal.
6. At all times material hereto plaintiff was engaged in
mining and strip mining anthracite coal as lessee of vari-
ous mining tracts in the Northumberland County,
Pennsylvania area. Plaintiff strip mined and deep mined
only from leased coal lands. He purchased and owned the
machinery and equipment used in his mining operations,
52a
and took depreciation deductions on such machinery and
equipment. See finding 21, infra. .
7. In deep mining the plaintiff excavated shafts through
the overburden into veins of coal. He then conveyed his
employed miners in buggies on rails through the shaft, to
the coal face, where, using explosives, picks and shovels
they extracted coal which was carried to the surface on the
railed buggies. Thence it was trucked into plaintiff's
breaker where, as in the case of strip mined coal, it was
cleaned, sorted, sold to the general public, and carried by
plaintiffs trucks to plaintiffs siding (see finding 21) where
it was loaded onto railroad cars. A breaker (sometimes
“tipple”) removes the slate and rock and then sorts the
coal into seven sizes for public sale at prices varying with
its quality and prevailing market conditions.
8. During the tax years in dispute Northumberland
County, Pennsylvania, owned over 17,500 acres of coal
property in the county which it had acquired at sales for
delinquent taxes. Two of the properties had been leased,
separately, to Edward Gusick, and to the Kozar Coal
Company, as deep mine operations. These two leases were
cancelled on October 24, 1964 and October 26, 1966, re-
spectively, and immediately re-leased to plaintiff because
plaintiff had bought out the interests of Gusick (for
$12,085, including the assumption of remaining payments
of $5,085.50 on generating equipment, and the balance for
Gusick’s existing excavation on the property) and of Kozar
(for $7,000, including equipment and existing excavation).
Neither of the two properties had been redeemed by their
former owners from the county by payment of tax arrears
under Pennsylvania laws.
9. During 1966 and 1967 the plaintiff deep mined coal
under the lease of October 24, 1964, referred to in finding
8. The lease was terminated in May 1968 when heavy
rainfall caused a mountain slide which closed the mine.
Plaintiff never extracted coal under the lease of October
26, 1966, and it was terminated for cause in November
1969 due to plaintiffs failure to mine.
10. During 1966 and 1967 the plaintiff strip mined coal
53a
from land he leased on July 25, 1966, from Northumber-
tand County. The property had not been previously mined.
He strip mined by using his power shovel to remove the
overburdening soil and terrain covering the underlying
coal (hereinafter the “overburden”). The power shovel
then “stripped” the exposed coal from the earth’s surface
and placed it in large piles next to loaders. The piled coal
then was conveyed by the loaders into trucks which hauled
the coal from the leased lands to a breaker, where the coal
was cleaned and sorted. From the breaker, the coal was
sold to the general public on the open market.
11. Plaintiff paid Northumberland County royalties of
$7,545.10 in 1966 and $6,854.05 in 1967 on coal which was
mined under the leases referred to in findings 8 and 10.
The royalties were fixed in the leases at 35 cents per gross
ton of coal removed. The county would receive weigh slips
from the breaker verifying the tonnage sold, and plaintiff
would remit to the county the royalties from each sale.
12. Each of the three leases between plaintiff and
Northumberland County referred to in findings 8 and 10
herein, which was good until terminated, contained sev-
eral provisions for its automatic termination in the event
of sale of the lands by the county! or redemption of the
lands by tax delinquent former owners, or the lessee’s
failure to mine and remove coal for 30 consecutive days
unless due to abnormal conditions. Other clauses provided
for automatic cancellation of the leases for violation of any
of their terms. Finally, a clause‘in each lease provided the
following or its substantial equivalent:
It is hereby expressly understood between the par-
ties hereto that LESSOR may terminate this agree-
ment completely and fully without liability upon it or
any further recourse against it, upon thirty days
written notice given to MINER or by posting the
same upon the lands hereinabove mentioned.
Northumberland County has never sold a fee interest in lands ac-
quired for unpaid-taxes, for fear of criticism over selling such land if
valuable minerals were later discovered.
54a
A similar or identical provision for 30-day termination
notice was included in all coal mining leases granted by
Northumberland County From January 1, 1956 to May 31,
1969. It is reasonable to construe the clause as authority
by Northumberland County to terminate the lease without
cause on 30 days notice. However, the leases were “ad-
ministered” !eases, that is, they were standard forms with
“boiler-plate” clauses prepared by the lessor which were
not subject to negotiation.
13. The language of the deep mining leases referred to
in finding 8 is identical to the language of the lease in-
volved in Whitmer v. Comm’r., 28 T.C.M. 1480 (1969),
aff'd. 443 F.2d 170 (C.A. 3 Cir. 1971), except for the name
of the lessee, description of the property, and the termina-
tion date.
14. Taxpayer was under no obligation to sell the coal to
the lessor or to any other party. He could sell the coal to
whomever he pleased and at whatever price he could ob-
tain.
15. (a) Since 1956 it has been the publicly announced
policy that the Northumberland County Commissioners
would never terminate a mining lease except for the les-
see’s failure to mine for an unreasonably long period of
time, or for the lessee’s failure to pay royalties, or for the
lessee’s cheating on the royalty. Every lessee received the
same form lease from the county, and in each case it was
with the stipulation that the county would not cancel ex-
cept for cause, The reason for this was that the county
commissioners recognized that they could not expect an
independent miner to invest time and considerable capital
in the development of county coal lands without some as-
surance that, if he conformed to the terms of the lease, he
would be allowed to recover his investment and make a
profit on his mine.
(b) This policy was based on various charges made
during the primary election for Northumberland county
commissioners held in the early 1950’s'to the effect that
coal leases were being granted on a basis of political
favoritism. As a result of these charges the incumbent
55a
county commissioners were defeated in their bids for
reelection. For this reason the county commissioners
would not enter into leases without a 30-day termination
clause so that there might be no question of political
favoritism or criticism by the public of the actions of the
county commissioners in leasing coal lands.
(c) Statements to the effect that Northumberland
County would not terminate a lease except for cause were
made to various individual mine operators (including tax-
payer), in public meetings of the commissioners, and re-
ported in the press. However no assurance was given that
the county commissioners could not cancel a lease without
cause.
16. Interests in county mining leases and mining opera-
tions were frequently bought and sold by independent
miners. The county’s policy in such cases was to either
transfer the lease, or to prepare a new lease for the future
lessee. The county received no consideration for the
transfer of an old lease to a new lease. Nor was it con-
cerned if the present lessee received consideration for the
transfer from the future lessee.
17. Plaintiff is known as an independent coal miner. He
is so classified because the coal mining operations of inde-
pendent coal miners are generally small operations as
compared to the large corporate operations which at one
time flourished in the anthracite coal areas of Northum-
berland County. Independent coal miners produce coal
from public coal lands, and the operations are under the
active direction of the owners of the mine. As such, plain-
tiff belongs to the Independent Miners, Breakermen and
Truckers Association of Shamokin, Pennsylvania, an as-
sociation of similarly situated miners and other busi-
nessmen engaged in the mining, processing, trucking and
sale of anthracite coal.
18. Plaintiff had 14 employees in both 1966 and 1967.
19. Plaintiff spent $6,500 to build access roads to his
strip mine from the public highways. This expense was
depreciated on piaintiff's Federal income tax returns.
56a
20. Plaintiffs breaker referred to in finding 7, supra,
was located 5 or 6 miles away from the mines involved in
this proceeding. It was purchased by plaintiff about 1959
for $22,000, and was improved by plaintiff by 1966 at a
cost of $96,477.27, according to his testimony.?
21. In either 1962 or 1963 plaintiff, at a cost of $10,000,
purchased a railroad siding located approximately 1,000
feet from his breaker. This railroad siding was connected
to the Penn Central Transportation Company railroad line
and, during the years in suit, was used in plaintiff's mining
operations. During the years in suit plaintiff leased the
land where the siding was located for a rental of $600 per
year.
22. The parties stipulated that plaintiff purchased
equipment for $373,163.83 for use at relevant times in the
mining operations under the leases referred to in these
findings. However, the evidence indicates that this
equipment was not used exclusively for plaintiffs mining
operations at the mines which are the subject of this suit.
To an unascertainable extent the equipment listed was
also used in connection with the processing of coal pur-
chased by plaintiff from other mines, as well as in plain-
tiffs separate trucking businesses. Thus, plaintiffs 1967
income tax return, which states his occupation as “mining”
and “trucking”, claims depreciation of $5,705 for the min-
ing business, an.. $11,860.88 for the trucking business, the
one being for 4 months of 1967 and the other 8 months.
The depreciation schedule claiming the depreciation of
equipment used in the trucking business shows that the
acquisition cost of the depreciated equipment was
$139,827.71, which would infer that at that time plaintiffs
depreciable equipment used in the mining business had a
cost basis of $233,336.12 ($373,163.83—$139,827.71). Ac-
cording to the depreciation schedules all of the equipment
2The acquisition cost of the breaker of $22,000 in January 1959 is
listed in the depreciation schedule attached to plaintiffs 1967 tax re-
turn, but not the improvements of $96,477.27. It is assumed that nor-
mally such improvements, if made, would have been capitalized and
depreciated, but if so it does not appear in the 1967 schedule.
57a
depreciated had been acquired at various times from
January 1959 through April 1967. In other words, it would
be misleading to interpret the parties’ stipulation to mean
that plaintiff purchased and used $373,163.83 worth of
equipment exclusively for use in connection with the min-
ing and sale of coal under the leases involved in this suit.
CONCLUSION OF LAW
Upon the trial judge’s findings and opinion, which are
adopted by the court, the court concludes as a matter of
law that plaintiff is entitled to recover taxes and interest
assessed, plus interest as provided by law. The amount of
plaintiff's recovery should be determined pursuant to Rule
131(¢)(2).
58a
GENERAL
BLACK HAWK COAL CORPORATION, INC.
DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE NAME OF
BLACK HAWK COAL COMPANY, INC.
v.
THE UNITED STATES
Income taxes
January 24 1977
5 COPIES OF PETITION TO DEFENDANT.
$164,237.43
Feds Creek, KY and
Grundy, VA
GENERAL
Jan 241977 Filing fee of $10 paid by plaintiff.
Feb 9 1977 Notice of reference to Trial Judge C. Murray
Bernhardt filed. Copy to parties.
Mar 25 1977 Defendant’s answer filed. Copies (5) to atty.
Oct 311978 Stipulation of facts filed by defendant. Copy
to atty. (2)
Nov 11978 Trial Judge’s memorandum report returning
case to court on stipulation facts filed.
Copies to parties.
Nov 30 1978 Plaintiff's motion for extension of time (to
February 14, 1979) to fill its brief filed.
Copies (2) to deft. ALLOWED DEC 1 1978.
Feb 23 1979 Plaintiff's brief filed. Copies (5) to deft.
(BLOC).
Mar 26 1979 Defendant’s brief filed. Copies (5) to atty.
Apr 161979 Plaintiff's reply brief filed. Copies (5) to
deft.
May 151979 See 400-77 for defendant’s motion or order
directing consolidation.
Jun 4 1979 See 400-77 for argument and submission.
Jul 18 1979
Dec 3 1979
Dez 4 1979
Dec 7 1979
Dec 7 1979
59a
See 403-75 for Court Opinion.
Stipulation for entry of judgment filed.
Copies (2) to atty.
Trial Judge’s memorandum report for judg-
ment filed. Copy to parties.
Court filed order entering judgment for
plaintiff in the sum of $164,141.03 plus
statutory interest. Copy to parties.
Certified transcript of jud;ment mailed to
attorney of record.
ee
60a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 49-77
BLACK HAWK COAL CORPORATION, INC.
DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE NAME OF
BLACK HAWK COAL COMPANY, INC., PLAINTIFF
v.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DEFENDANT
PETITION
TO THE HONORABLE THE CHIEF JUDGE AND THE
ASSOCIATE JUDGES OF THE COURT OF CLAIMS:
1. Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc., is a
corporation chartered under the laws of the Common-
wealth of Kentucky on April 7, 1964, with its registered
office at Feds Creek, Kentucky and its business office in
Gru..cy, Virginia. Following its incorporation the company
transacted its business under the name of Black Hawk
Coal Company, Inc. Said corporation was authorized to
issue 250 shares of common stock with a par value of
$100.00 per share. One hundred shares were issued and
outstanding during the calendar years ending December
31, 1970, December 31, 1971 and December 31, 1972. The
following is a list of the shareholders and the number of
shares owned by each:
E. M. Bane, Sr. 18 shares
E. R. Bane 1 share
Eugene M. Bane, Sr. 40 shares
Betty M. Worley 40 shares
William D. Bane 1 share
Total 100 shares
2. Said corporation under the name of Black Hawk Coal
Company, Inc., filed its income tax returns for the calen-
dar years ending December 31, 1970 and December 31,
1971, with the Internal Revenue Service, Cincinnati, Ohio
and its December 31, 1972 return with the Internal Rev-
enue Service Center, Memphis, Tennessee, and paid the
6la
tax shown thereon to be owing in the respective amounts
of $57,236.65, $61,296.84, and $42,461.31.
3. This action is brought\pursuant to Sections 1346 and
1491 of the Judicial Code (28 _U.S.C.A. Sections 1346 and
1491) against the United States of America, as Defendant.
4. During the calendar years ending December 31, 1970,
1971, and 1972, Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation,
Inc., was engaged in the business of mining and producing
coal. Said company operated under a Lease dated the 20th
day of February, 1964, between Kentland Coal & Coke
Company Division of the Berwind-White Coal Mining
Company, a Pennsylvania corporation, Lessor, and
Eugene M. Bane of Grundy, Virginia, Lessee. Said Lease
was assigned by E. M. Bane to the said Black Hawk Coal
Corporation, Inc., pursuant to the “Initial Plans for the
Organization of Black Hawk Coal Corporation” as shown
in the Minute Book of said corporation, dated February
21, 1964.
5. Said Lease granted to the Lessee the exclusive right
to mine to exhausion, subject to the terms of said Lease,
certain specific seams of coal under seven parcels of land
in Pike County, Kentucky.
6. In consideration thereof the Lessee agreed to pay to
the Lessor as rent the sum of Five Thousand and No/100
Dollars ($5,000.00) per year in monthly installments and a
tonnage royalty of twenty-five cents ($.25) per ton for all
coal mined from the leased premises, to be credited
against the said rental.
7. As a result of the Lease Agreement and assignment
hereinabove referred to, the said Black Hawk Coal Corpo-
ration, Ine., acquired an economic interest in the coal
which it produced under said Lease Agreement and was
entitled to percentage depletion under Sections 611 and
613 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954.
8. No claim for percentage depletion on the coal ex-
tracted has been claimed by the Lessor or by any other
person, firm or corporation. The sole claimant to said per-
centage depletion deduction was Black Hawk Coal Corpo-
ration, Inc.
62a
9. Upon examination, the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue erroneously disallowed the depletion deduction
claimed by the Plaintiff.
10. On or about the 28th day of March, 1975, Plaintiff,
Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc. paid by three checks in
the name of Black Hawk Coal Co., Inc. the deficiency re-
sulting from the disallowance of depletion for the calendar
years ending December 31, 1970, December 31, 1971, and
December 31, 1972, in the amounts of $67,128.52,
$60,329.38, and $37,199.53 respectively, which included
assessed interest as provided by law.
11. On or about June 2, 1975, Plaintiff, Black Hawk
Coal Corporation, Inc., filed separate claims for refunds in
the name of Black Hawk Coal Company, Inc. for the
calendar years ending December 31, 1970, December 31,
1971, and December 31, 1972, and mailed same to the
Internal Revenue Service Center, 3131 Democrat Road,
Memphis, Tennessee, in the respective amounts of
$54,026.98, $51,018.50, and $32,719.89*, plus assessed
interest in the amounts of $13,101.54, $9,310.88, and
$4,059.64 respectively. These claims were based on the
fact that Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc. had the eco-
nomic interest in the coal in place and was entitled to the
depletion claimed for the calendar years ending December
31, 1970, December 31, 1971, and December 31, 1972.
12. The District Director of Internal Revenue on
January 7, 1976, by three separate letters addressed to
Black Hawk Coal Company, Inc., Grundy, Virginia, and
sent by certified mail, officially disallowed the claims for
- refund for the tax period ending December 31, 1970, in the
amount of $54,026.98, for the tax period ended December
31, 1971, in the amount of $51,018.50; and for the tax
period ending December 31, 1972, in the amount of
$32,719.89 and the interest paid thereon.
* The taxpayer concedes the adjustment to interest in-
come which increased taxpayer’s taxable income in the
amount of $875.00.
63a
13. By reason of the Commissioner’s failure to allow
claims for refund of Plaintiff for the years hereinafter set
out, the following amounts are now wrongfully withheld
from the Plaintiff without its consent and against its will.
Year Ended Amount Interest Total
December 31,
1970 $54,026.98 $138,101.54 $67,128.52
December 31,
1971 $51,018.50 $9,310.88 $60,329.38
December 31, 7
1972 $32,719.09 $4,059.64 $36,779.53
14. The amounts claimed represent the additional in-
come taxes and interest paid by the Plaintiff to the Dis-
trict Director of Internal Revenue as a result of the disal-
lowance of the claimed percentage depletion to Black
Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc., for the said calendar years
ending December 31, 1970, December 31, 1971, and De-
cember 31, 1972.
15. No action has been had on said claims in the United
States Congress, or any of the Departments of the gov-
ernment, nor in any other Judicial Proceeding, including
the Tax Court of the United States; no other person, firm
or corporation other than Plaintiff is the owner thereof or
interested therein; no assignment or transfer of these
claims or any part thereof or interests therein has been
made. Plaintiff is justly entitled to the amounts herein
claimed from the United States after allowing all just
credits and off-sets. The Plaintiff has at all time borne true
faith and allegiance to the Government of the United
States and has not in any way voluntarily aided, abetted,
or given encouragement against said Government.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation,
Ine., doing business under the name of Black Hawk Coal
Company, Inc., asks judgment against the United States
of America in the sum of $67,128.52 for the tax period
ended December 31, 1970; $60,329.38 for the tax period
ended December 31, 1971; and $36,779.53 for the tax
period ended December 31, 1972, making a total sum due
and payable for said three years of $164,237.43, together
64a
with costs and interest to the extent allowed by law, and
for such other and further relief as may to this Honorable
Court seem just and pyoper.
LERoyY KATz
KATZ, KANTOR, KATZ, PERKINS &
CAMERON
P. O. Box 727
Bluefield, WV 24701
Attorney for Plaintiff
65a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
No. 49-77
BLACK HAWK COAL CORPORATION, INC., DOING
BUSINESS UNDER THE NAME OF BLACK HAWK
COAL COMPANY,
Plaintiff
Uv.
THE UNITED STATES,
Defendant
ANSWER
The defendant, the United States, answers the plain-
tiffs petition by denying each and every allegation con-
tained therein which has not been admitted, qualified, or
expressly referred to below.
The defendant further:
1. Admits that the plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corpora-
tion, Inc., is a corporation chartered under the laws of the
Commonwealth of Kentucky, but states that its trial at-
torney is presently without sufficient knowledge or infor-
mation to either admit or deny the remaining allegations
contained in paragraph 1.
2. Admits the allegations contained in paragraph 2.
3. States that jurisdiction is conferred upon this Court
by virtue of 28 U.S.C. §1491.
4. Admits the allegations contained in the first two sen-
tences of paragraph 4, but states that its attorney is pres-
ently without sufficient knowledge or information to either
admit or deny the allegations contained in the last sen-
tence of paragraph 4.
5. Denies the allegations contained in paragraph 5.
66a
6. States that the agreement, dated February 20, 1964,
betwen Kentland Coal and Coke Company Division of the
Berwind-White Coal Mining Company, lessor, and Eugene
M. Bane, lessee, speaks for itself.
7. Denies the allegations contained in paragraph 7.
8. States that its attorney is presently without suffi-
cient knowledge or information to either admit or deny the
allegations contained in paragraph 8.
9. Admits that the Commissioner of Internal Revenue
disallowed the depletion deduction claimed by the plaintiff,
but denies that such disallowance was erroneous.
10. States that the plaintiff was timely and properly as-
sessed on April 15, 1975, additional tax and interest for its
1970, 1971, and 1972 tax years as follows:
Year Tax Interest Total
1970 $54,026.98 $138,117.45 $67,144.43
1971 $51,018.50 $9,325.90 $60,344.40
1972 $33,139.89 $4,059.64 $37,199.53
In respect to 1970, payments of $67,128.52 (received April
2, 1975) and $15.91 (received May 7, 1975) were made in
satisfaction of the plaintiffs 1970 tax liabilities. In respect
to 1971, payments of $60,329.38 (received April 2, 1975)
and $15.02 (received May 7, 1975) were made in satisfac-
tion of the plaintiffs 1971 tax liabilities. In respect to
1972, a payment of $37,199.53 (received April 2, 1975) was
made in satisfaction of the plaintiff's 1972 tax liability.
11. States that the plaintiff filed three claims for refund
(Forms 843) dated June 2, 1975, one for each of the three
years in question, as follows:
Date Amount
Year Received (Tax)
1970 June 9, 1975 $54,026.98
1971 June 5, 1975 $51,018.50
1972 June 11, 1975 $32,719.89
Defendant denies the grounds upon which those claims for
refund rest.
12. Admits the allegations contained in paragraph 12.
67a
13. Denies the allegations contained in paragraph 13.
14. Admits the allegations contained in paragraph 14.
15. States that its attorney is presently without suffi-
cient knowledge or information to either admit or deny the
allegations contained in paragraph 15, except denies that
the plaintiff is justly entitled to the amounts herein
claimed from the United States after allowing all just
credits and offsets.
WHEREFORE, defendant prays that the petition be
dismissed with costs assessed against the plaintiff.
Respectfully submitted,
Myron C. BAUM
Acting Assistant Attorney General
C. PATRICK DERDENGER
Attorney
MARCH 25, 1977
68a
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS
i No. 49-77
BLACK HAWK COAL CORPORATION, INC.
DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE NAME OF
BLACK HAWK COAL COMPANY, INC.,
Plaintiff
v.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Defendant
STIPULATION OF FACTS
It is hereby agreed and stipulated between the parties
hereto that, for the purpose of this case only, the following
may be accepted and adopted as facts and all exhibits re-
ferred to herein and attached hereto are incorporated in
this stipulation and made a part hereof:
1. Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc., is a
corporation chartered under the laws of the Common-
wealth of Kentucky on April 7, 1964, with its registered
office at Feds Creek, Kentucky, and its business office in
Grundy, Virginia. Said corporation was authorized to issue
250 shares of common stock with a par value of $100.00 per
share. One hundred shares were issued and outstanding
during the calendar years ending December 31, 1970, De-
cember 31, 1971 and December 31, 1972. The following is a
list of the shareholders and the number of shares owned
by each:
E.M. Bane, Sr. \ 18
E.R. Bane \ 1
Eugene M. Bane, Jr. — 40
Betty M. Worley 40
William D. Bane l
TOTAL 100
69a
2. Said corporation under the name of Black Hawk Coal
Company, Inc., filed its income tax returns for the calen-
dar years ending December 31, 1970, and December 31,
1971, with the Internal Revenue Service, Cincinnati, Ohio,
and its December 31, 1972, return with the Internal Rev-
enue Service Center, Memphis, Tennessee, and paid the
tax shown thereon to be owing in the respective amounts
of $57,236.65, $61,296.84 and $42,461.31. True copies of
the returns are attached hereto as Exhibits No. 1, 2 and 3,
respectively.
3. The plaintiff corporation during the years involved,
was engaged in the drift mining of coal under an agree-
ment entitled “Agreement of Lease” dated February 20,
1964. Said agreement was between Kentland Coal & Coke
Company Division of the Berwind-White Coal Mining
Company, a Pennsylvania corporation, Lessor and Eugene
M. Bane of Grundy, Virginia, Lessee. A true copy of said
Lease is attached hereto as Exhibit No. 4. Said Lease was.
assigned by E.M. Bane to the said Black Hawk Coal Cor-
poration, Inc., pursuant to the “Initial Plans for the Or-
ganization of Black Hawk Coal Corporation,” as shown in
the Minute Book of said corporation, dated February 21,
1974. A copy of said “Initial Plans for the Organization of
Black Hawk Coal Corporation” is attached hereto as
Exhibit No. 5.
4. The plaintiff corporation has mined coal continuously
from said property from 1964 through the taxable years
herein involved. |
5. The Lease Agreement hereinabove referred to is at-
tached hereto as Exhibit No. 4. The copy of Exhibit No. 4
has thereon certain lines which have been underlined, on
pages 3, 5, 6 and 8. Also appearing on page 3 is a star on
the left-hand side and an arrow on page 8 of said Lease.
None of the underlining, the star nor the arrow have any
bearing upon the Agreement and are not to be considered
in the examination of this Lease, and the interpretation
thereof by the Court.
6. The plaintiff corporation was engaged, during the
years in issue, in the drift mining of said coal, pursuant to
70a
the Agreement of Lease, hereinabove referred to. The ac-
tual mining of the coal was done by independent contrac-
tors employed by the plaintiff corporation for this purpose.
Drift mining of coal is an underground mining operation in
which a horizontal coal seam is reached by clearing away
part of the mountainside with a bulldozer, by a process
called “facing-up” the coal seam. Two parallel tunnels are
made into the coal seam, one for ventilation and the other
for working space in removal of coal. The coal is removed
as the drift mine is driven into the mountain following the
seam of coal. The roof of the mine is supported by leaving
pillars of coal in place and erecting wood supports. Under
the oral agremeent, the mining contractor provided the
labor and supervision necessary to mine the coal and to
transport the mined coal to the tipple site for a fixed dollar
amount per ton. The price per ton paid to the contractor
was not dependent upon the sales price of the coal. The
trucks used to haul the coal from the mine site to the tip-
ple were furnished by the mining contractors. Plaintiff
corporation furnished the majority of the mining equip-
ment needed by the mining contractors to extract the coal,
constructed and maintained the access roads and built the
power lines to the mining operations.
7. When the coal has been removed from the mine, it is
loaded into trucks and hauled approximately five miles to a
tipple located on land owned by The Flannary Coal & Land
Company, a partnership, consisting of E.M. Bane, J.W.
Garside, E.B. Woodruff and John W. Garside. The tipple,
located on said land, is known as the Apache Tipple and is
owned by the same partners as The Flannary Coal & Land
Company. The tipple consists of a preparation plant which
cleans the coal prior to its sale to customers. When the
coal is delivered to the tipple, by the trucks, it is weighed
on a truck scale and Apache pays Black Hawk Coal Com-
pany for the coal on a per ton basis. After the coal is
cleaned, it is dumped into railroad cars and then sold on
the open market through a commission sales agent, the
Woodruff Coal Company of Kalamazoo, Michigan.
8. The plaintiff corporation was free to sell its coal to
Tla
anyone and was not obligated to sell it to Apache Coal
Company (or Flannary Coal Company) or to Kentland Cval
& Coke Company, the Lessor, or its sales agency. In fact,
none of said coal was sold to the Lessor or its sales agency.
All of plaintiff's coal was sold to Appache (or Flannary),
and the said Woodruff Coal Company of Kalamazoo,
Michigan, then sold the coal on the open market to its cus-
tomers. All coal feasible to mine has been extracted with
mining operations ceasing in 1976.
9. All operating expenses of Black Hawk Coal Com-
pany, Inc., other than capital expenditures recoverable by
depreciation, including the fees paid to the independent
mining contractors, the rent or royalties paid under the
agreements entitled “Agreement of Lease” and the com-
missions paid to sales agents were taken as deductions
from gross income on the tax returns described herein as
Exhibits 1, 2 and 8.
10. No claim for percentage depletion has been made by
Kentland Coal & Coke Company, division of the
Berwind-White Coal Mining Company, under the agree-
ment entitled “Agreement of Lease” with Black Hawk
Coal Company, Inc. No claim for percentage depletion on
the coal extracted has been made by the independent
mining contractors. The sole claimant to the percentage
depletion deduction is the Black Hawk Coal Company, Inc.
11. Upon examination, the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue disallowed the percentage depletion deduction
claimed by Black Hawk Coal Company, Inc., resulting in
the assessment of deficiencies in income tax against Black
Hawk Coal Company, Inc.
12. Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc., timely
paid in the name of Black Hawk Coal Company, Inc., the
deficiency resulting from the disallowance of depletion for
the calendar years ending December 31, 1970, December
31, 1971, and December 31, 1972, in the amounts of
$67,144.43, $60,344.49 and $37,199.53, respectively, which
included interest as provided by law.
13. Plaintiff, Black Hawk Coal Corporation, Inc., timely
72a
filed separate claims for refunds in the name of Black
Hawk Coal Company, Inc., as follows:
Year Ended Amount Interest Total
December 31, 1970 $54,026.98 $13,101.54 $67,128.52
December 31, 1971 $51,018.50 $ 9,310.88 $60,329.38
December 31, 1972 $32,719.89* $ 4,059.64 $36,199.53
163,657.43
14. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue has disal-
lowed all claims for refund by statutory notices sent to the
plaintiff dated January 7, 1976.
15. All requirements for jurisdiction of the Court have
been satisfied. In the event the plaintiff is entitled to re-
cover, the amount of recovery will be computed by the
Internal Revenue Service subject to verification by the
plaintiff.
16. The issue to be determined by this Court is whether
the inclusion of the 30-day termination clause in the
“Agreement of Lease,” described in Stipulation Paragraph
3, supra, prevents the plaintiff from claiming the percent-
age depletion deduction permitted by the Internal Rev-
enue Code.
17. This Court decided the identical issue in Bakertown
Coal Company, Inc. v. The United States, No. 53-69, de-
cided January 13, 1972, holding that the Lessees in that
case were entitled to the percentage depletion deduction.
18. Lessor in Bakertown, supra, is the same Lessor as
in the instant case. True copies of the Leases in question
in Bakertown are attached hereto as Exhibits 6, 7 and 8.
* The taxpayer conceded the adjustment to interest in-
come which increased taxpayer’s taxable income in the
amount of $875.00.
7a
Respectfully submitted,
LEROY KATZ
Attorney for Plaintiff
Assistant Attorney General
Attorney for Defendant
EXHIBIT 4
THIS AGREEMENT OF LEASE, made this the 20th
day of February, 1964, by and between KENTLAND
COAL AND COKE COMPANY DIVISION of THE
BERWIND-WHITE COAL MINING COMPANY, A
Pennsylvania corporation, hereinafter called LESSOR,
party of the first part, and EUGENE M. BANE of
Grundy, Virginia, hereinafter called LESSEE, party of
the second part.
WITNESSETH:
That for and in consideration of the rents, royalties and
other moneys to be paid by LESSEE unto LESSOR, as
well as for and in consideration of the covenants and
agreements hereinafter contained on the part of the LES-
SEE to be kept, performed and observed, LESSOR does
hereby give and grant unto LESSEE, under and subject
to all the exceptions, reservations, terms and conditions
hereinafter contained and for the period of time here-
inafter mentioned, the exclusive right and privilege to
mine and take away the Feds Creek (Clintwood) Seam of
coal upon and underlying certain tracts or boundaries of
land situate as follows, to-wit:
Part of Kentland Tract 464 Matilda J. Fuller Mineral 11.94A
Part of Kentland Tract 467 Elijah Fuller Mineral 13.31”
Part of Kentland Tract 468 Matilda J. Estep Mineral 9.18”
Part of Kentland Tract 472 Thornsbury & Jones Mineral 27.78”
Part of Kentland Tract 501 George W. Dotson Mineral 41.55”
74a
Part of Kentland Tract 529 David Griffey, Sr. Mineral 37.88”
Part of Kentland Tract 530 James Griffey Mineral 37.65”
being those parts of tracts lying on the point ridge be-
tween Road Fork and Dicks Fork of Feds Creek and Hen
Roost Fork of said Dicks Fork, said Feds Creek being a
tributary of Levisa Fork of Big Sandy River, in Pike
County, Kentucky, said leased area being colored red as to
mineral and outlined in green on whiteprint map attached
hereto and made a part hereof, bearing the following title
and legend:
KENTLAND COAL AND COKE COMPANY
DIVISION OF THE BERWIND-WHITE COAL
MINING COMPANY
PIKE COUNTY, KENTUCKY
February 10, 1964 Seale 1” = 1000’
LEGEND
Mineral—Area of Feds Creek (Clintwood) Seam of Coal
Proposed To Be Leased To Eugene M. Bane
LESSEE agrees to have the outcrop of said Feds Creek
(or Clintwood) seam, also all property lines above the out-
crop of said seam, accurately, surveyed within six months
from date hereof, and shall furnish to LESSOR prints, on
a scale of one inch equals one hundred feet, showing the
results of said surveying, by accurate bearings and dis-
tances. LESSEE’S engineers shall consult with LES-
SOR’S engineers as to proper location of the outcropping
of said Feds Creek (or Clintwood) seam, property lines
and permanent points to be established.
TOGETHER WITH THE RIGHT to mine and remove
the said coal in accordance with the mining rights vested
in the LESSOR, it being distinctly understood and agreed
that the LESSOR grants only such mining rights and
privileges as it possesses or has acquired in conjunction
with the ownership of the coal covered by this agreement;
and that in mining, removing and carrying away said coal
the LESSEE shall be limited to the exercise of the
aforesaid rights and privileges, and shall protect and save
harmless the LESSOR from any liability or any claims for
damages to roads, railroads, wire or pipe lines, person, or
75a
persons and/or property, except property owned by the
LESSOR within the leased premises, caused by its opera-
tions hereunder. LESSOR agrees to so operate the seam
hereby leased that overlying seams will not be injured or
destroyed.
NOTHING HEREIN CONTAINED shall be deemed or
construed to be a covenant on the part of the LESSOR,
either expressed or implied, for title or for quiet enjoy-
ment; but the LESSEE must respect and observe all lim-
itations or defects in the title of the LESSOR in and to
said land and the coal rights. It is likewise understood by
the LESSEE that the LESSOR gives no warranty as the
the quality or quantity of the coal contained in the leased
premises and assumes no liability due to any deficiency
which may exist or develop therein.
IN THE EVENT ANY PART of the said leased prem-
ises is lost to the holder of an outstanding superior title, if
the LESSEE has mined and removed a part or all of the
coal therefrom and paid the LESSOR therefor on the roy-
alty basis, the LESSOR agrees to repay to the LESSEE
the amount of royalty so paid, without interest, but the
LESSOR shall not be otherwise liable for any damage on
account of the mining and removing of said coal by the
LESSEE, and the LESSEE shall protect and save harm-
less the LESSOR from all suits, actions damages or claims
whatsoever, resulting or arising therefrom.
THE RIGHTS GRANTED THE LESSEE herein shall
in all respects be inferior and subject to the rights granted
by the LESSOR herein unto United Fuel Gas Company,
by lease to Howe Oil and Gas Company, and passing by
assignment to it, dated July 24, 1930, recorded in Deed
Book 163, at page 84, Pike County Court Clerk’s Office,
which lease is referred to for more particular description
of the rights therein granted and to which this lease is
subject, but all rights and privileges respecting the mining
of coal reserved in said lease to United Fuel Gas Company
shall inure to the benefit of LESSEE, and, without limit-
ing the generality of the foregoing, LESSEE shall
76a
promptly transmit to LESSEE all information it has, or
may receive, of prospective oil and gas drilling.
THE RIGHTS GRANTED THE LESSEE herein are
also expressly made subject to the rights granted unto
Steleo Coal Company by LESSOR by Agreement of Lease
dated May 1, 1962, not recorded, granting the right to
mine the Freeburn, or Lower Elkhorn, seam of coal over-
lying the area hereby leased, copy of said lease is fur-
nished the LESSEE herein.
There is excepted and reserved from the area described
herein the following tract:
Virginia Iron Coal and Coke Company Tract No. 468-A
are as shown on above-mentioned whiteprint map on Or-
chard Hollow of Feds Creek, containing 0.32 ac., more or
less.
IT IS UNDERSTOOD that the LESSEE shall not be
required to mine coal where the thickness of the seam is
under thirty-six (36) inches, including normal partings, but
may do so; however, LESSEE must thoroughly prospect
thin areas and if coal thirty-six (86) inches and over in
thickness is found, LESSEE shall drive through or around
thin areas and recover the thicker coal. If LESSEE mines
coal from areas under thirty-six (36) inches, he must also
remove coal pillars where he has mined the coal in the
rooms.
THE LESSOR, ITS SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS,
shall have the right at all times to mine, bore, search for,
develop and market all other seams of coal in said land,
and the oil, gas, minerals and other substances therein and
thereon, and the right to use such of the leased premises
as may be reasonably required for the purposes aforesaid,
or any of them; also the right to lay in, on or under said
land any and all pipe lines for conveying oil, gas, water or
other substances from other tracts of land, as well as the
right to construct telegraph, telephone and power lines,
but such right shall be exercised in such a way as to
interfere as little as possible with the mining operations of
the LESSEE hereunder, all of which rights mentioned in
77a
this paragrap are hereby expressly reserved to the LES-
SOR, its successors and assigns.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the hereinbefore described
rights and privileges, excepting and reserving as
aforesaid, unto the said LESSEE, during the term com-
mencing on the first day of March, 1964, and terminating
when LESSEE shall have exhausted all of The Feds
Creek (or Clintwood) Seam of coal, subject to the excep-
tions herein set out, or until said tenancy shall be earlier
terminated as thereinafter provided.
IN CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, THE LESSEE,
FOR HIMSELF, HIS SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS,
DOES HEREBY COVENANT, PROMISE AND AGREE
TO AND WITH THE LESSOR, ITS SUCCESSORS AND
ASSIGNS, AS FOLLOWS:
RENTAL
lst. The LESSEE shall pay to LESSOR, as rental, the
Minimum sum of FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000)
per year, payable monthly in advance, without regard to
the quantity of coal mined, which sum shall be payable,
without demand therefor, on or before the first (1st) day of
each and every calendar month.
ROYALTIES
2nd. LESSEE shall pay unto LESSOR as tonnage roy-
alty the sum of twenty-five cents (25¢) for each and every
net ton of two thousand (2,000) pounds of coal mined from
the leased premises, or lost or left in mining, in the man-
ner following:
The royalty on all coal mined during each calendar
month of the term hereof shall be paid on or before the
20th day of the succeeding month, and the LESSEE shall
receive credit on every royalty payment due by the
amount of the monthly installment of the annual rental
paid for the month in which said tonnage was mined. If the
amount of royalty which becomes due in any month of the
term hereof does not exceed the rental paid for the month,
78a
then the payment of said rental shall be a full and complete
satisfaction of the said royalty. If the royalty aforesaid ex-
ceeds the rental paid for such month, then only such ex-
cess shall be paid in addition to the rental for that month;
provided, however, that the LESSEE shall not be re-
quired to make any payments on account of any excess
until all deficit, which might accrue under the provisions of
ARTICLE 38rd hereof shall have been worked out.
CREDIT
3rd. The accounts of the LESSEE shall be so adjusted
that if the quantity of coal which the LESSEE mines from
the leased premises in any month of the term hereof is less
than the quantity of coal required, calculated at the roy-
alty rate provided herein, to produce a sum equal to the
rental paid for such month, the LESSEE shall have the
right to mine and remove in any future month or months of
the term hereof, and without further royalty payment
therefor, an amount of coal equal to such deficit in quan-
tity, but only after sufficient tonnage, to pay the rental for
the current month, shall have been mined.
It is always understood that whenever the total pay-
ments from all sources of either tonnage royalties or rent-
als, or for coal lost, shall amount to a sum of money which
equals said tonnage royalty of twenty-five cents (25¢) on
all of the coal now in the Feds Creek (or Clintwood) Seam
in the leased premises which LESSEE is required to mine
hereunder including all coal lost in mining and all coal re-
maining in pillars and supports, which may result from the
LESSEE’s mining operations, and also including coal in
said seam under thirty-six inches in thickness which the
LESSEE has actually mined and paid for, the LESSEE
shall not thereafter be required to pay any further tonnage
royalty or rental, but may continue to hold the leased
premises without further payment of tonnage royalty or
rental until the expiration of the term of this lease or
sooner determination thereof. Howver, the burden shall
be upon the LESSEE to develop and prove the total ton-
nage contained in said seam and the LESSEE shall never
79a
have the right to recover from the LESSOR any payment
of tonnage royalties or rentals on the ground that the total
thereof is in excess of said tonnage royalty on all of the
coal in said seam.
WEIGHTS
4th. The quantity of coal on which LESSEE pays roy-
alty shall be determined by railroad weights of the rail-
road over which said coal is shipped, except such coal as
may be otherwise disposed of, which shall be estimated by
measurement of the bed of trucks on which same is deliv-
ered. A complete record and’account of all coal mined by
the LESSEE hereunder shall be kept at all times and shall
be open to the inspection of LESSOR or its representa-
tives. Coal delivered to the railroad and coal sold other-
wise shall be reported separately.
TAXES
5th. LESSEE shall pay all taxes levied upon the entire
estate of the LESSOR in the real estate covered hereby
and upon all coal mined and produced therefrom, and also
upon LESSEE’s plant, equipment and improvements lo-
cated upon the leased premises. If any payment of either
of said taxes shall be made by LESSOR, the same shall be
repaid by LESSEE upon statement and demand.
PLACE OF PAYMENT
6th. All rents, royalties or other moneys becoming due
and payable by the LESSEE to the LESSOR under the
terms hereof shall be paid promptly by the LESSEE unto
the Treasurer of the LESSOR at its office, 600 two Penn
Center Plaza, Philadelphia 2, Pennsylvania, at the times
herein specified, without previous demand for the same,
which manner and place of payment are hereby designated
as the manner and place of all payments to be made by the
LESSEE unto the LESSOR until such times as the LES-
SOR may, by written notice to the LESSEE, otherwise
appoint or direct, and all payments shall be treated as
rents reserved for the use of said premises.
80a
NON-PAYMENT OF RENT—FORFEITURE
7th. In the event of the failure on the part of the LES-
SEE to make payment of rent, royalty and other moneys,
or taxes, within the period of sixty (60) days next after the
times herein fixed for such payments, the LESSOR may,
at its option, terminate this agreement and declare the
rights and privileges herein granted to be forfeited
whereupon the said rights and privileges shall cease and
determine, and this agreement shall become null and void
and of no further effect, and the LESSOR may thereupon
repossess itself of the premises, either by action of eject-
ment or by act of re-entry, using whatever force may be
necessary, without any liability for damages for so doing.
RECORDS AND REPORTS
8th. LESSEE shall furnish unto LESSOR on or before
the fifteenth (15th) day of each month a complete, correct
and itemized settlement, in triplicate, on a form or forms
furnished by LESSOR, showing for the preceding calen-
dar month the number of tons of coal mined from the
leased premises and any other information required by
LESSOR. LESSEE shall keep and preserve full and com-
plete records of all coal mined from the leased premises,
which shall be open to the inspection of LESSOR at all
times.
OPERATION
9th. LESSEE shall start operations within thirty (30)
days from the date hereof, and shall conduct his operations
in a careful and skillful manner and in accordance with any
and all laws of the State of Kentucky, and of the United
States of America, he shall not dump overburden, slate or
mine refuse upon the mine property or adjoining land ex-
cept at point or points to be designated in writing by the
LESSOR.
LESSEE shall conduct his operations in a proper and
skillful manner under the direction of a competent mining
engineer and in compliance in every respect with the laws
of the State of Kentucky and of the United States which
8la
are now in force or which maybe hereafter enacted, and
shall employ only the best and most improved methods of
mining the coal to the end that the greatest possible
amount of coal may be recovered. The mine shall be kept
in good working order and condition, and no coal shall be
left that might have been mined. The workings shall be
left free from accumulation of water, and in such condition
that the remaining coat may be recovered.
The operation of the Feds Creek (Clintwood) Seam of
coal leased herein shall be conducted in such a manner as
not to interfere with, injure or destroy the overlying
Lower Elkhorn Seam of coal, now under lease to Steleo
Coal Company. LESSEE agrees to locate and establish by
proper engineering procedures, the outcrop of the said
lower Elkhorn Seam of coal underlying the premises
leased herein and to show the results of said location in
relation to his workings in the Feds Creek Seam of coal
leased herein, on his maps as hereinafter required.
LESSEE shall develop the Feds Creek Seam of coal
leased herein underlying the aforementioned Lower Elk-
horn Seam of coal now under lease to Steleo Coal Company
in accordance with plans of mining and descriptions
thereof which shall be prepared by LESSEE and sub-
mitted to LESSOR for his approval, and put in operation
only upon approval in writing by said LESSOR. No
change in any plan so approved shall be made in the de-
velopment or operation of the said Feds Creek Seam of
coal leased herein except as requested in writing by LES-
SEE and approved in writing by LESSOR, or as required
in writing by LESSOR, such request or requirement to be
accompanied by plans illustrating such change.
LESSEE shall give LESSOR prompt notice in writing
of any coal which may be lost in mining under this lease,
and should any coal be lost through negligent, careless or
improper mining by LESSEE, LESSEE shall pay for the
same as if mined and removed and at the times herein
fixed for the payment of royalty on coal mined and re-
moved; provided, however, that barrier pillars required
by law and pillars left standing for the support of surface
82a
improvements or for the support and protection of the
overlying Lower Elkhorn Seam of coal, upon the require-
ment of LESSOR as above set forth, shall not be deemed
lost coal.
SURVEYS AND MAPS
10th. LESSEE shall have a survey of the mine workings
made by a competent mining engineer promptly as the
work progresses, said survey to be based upon LESSOR’s
meridian and coordinate values on its base line from the
mouth of Dicks Fork of Feds Creek, up said Fork of Feds
Creek and up to Hylton Triangulation Station, said me-
ridian and coordinate values to be furnished to LESSEE
by LESSOR prior to the beginning of said survey, and
LESSEE shall keep an accurate and complete map of the
leased premises and mine workings, (on a scale of one
hundred feet (100’) to the inch, which map shall conform in
all respect with the requirements of the bituminous mining
laws of the State of Kentucky and the United States, as
now in force or which may be hereafter enacted, and shall
show all property lines, surface improvements and such
natural topography as may require protection against lia-
bility for damages to persons or property, or by flooding in
the operation hereunder. Such map shall at all times be
accessible to the LESSOR, its agents or representatives,
for inspection and a true, complete and correct copy of the
same, posted to January 1, April 1, July 1, and October 1,
of each year, shall be furnished in triplicate to the LES-
SOR, without demand, within ten days after the above-
mentioned dates. All rooms and entries, except those fol-
lowing a water drainage course, shall be driven on transit
survey sights, and no ribs or pillars shall be drawn until a
survey of the place driven to its destination has been
made. Accurate measurements at divers places of the
thickness and elevation of the seam of coal, as the same is
mined, the location of faults, clay veins, rolls and areas of
bad roof shall be shown on the mine maps.
LESSEE shall furnish to LESSOR on or before the
twentieth (20th) day of January of each year of the term
83a
hereof, and as such other times as may be fixed by law or
required for tax assessments, a statement showing the
acreage of the herein leased seam of coal mined, aban-
doned, lost and remaining, separated as to tracts.
INSPECTION
11th. LESSOR, its agents, engineers or other persons
in its behalf, with their assistants, shall have the right to
enter at all times the said mines or works of LESSEE, in
order to inspect, examine, select samples of coal, survey
or measure the same or any part thereof, for the purpose
of ascertaining the condition of the mine, the methods
practiced, as well as the amount of coal removed, or for
any other lawful purpose, and LESSOR shall have the
right to place and keep an inspector or other representa-
tive upon the tipple and in the mine of LESSEE, for the
purpose of checking the weights, measures, accounts and
methods of LESSEE, and for these purposes to use freely
the means of access to the said mines and works without
let, hindrance, or molestation. LESSOR alone shall be re-
sponsible for any injury to any agents, engineers or other
persons in its behalf who may enter said mines or works of
LESSEE, unless such injury is caused by the negligence
of LESSEE or his employees.
DAMAGES
12th. LESSEE shall so conduct his mining operations as
not to violate any rights of lateral and subjacent support
belonging to the owners of other estates, and shall assist
the LESSOR in the defense of any action instituted for the
recovery of any damages, resulting from his operations
hereunder or prior to execution of this agreement, to the
overlying strata or to the surface overlying the Feds
Creek or Clintwood Seam of coal leased hereby, or to any
buildings or other structures thereon erected, or to any
springs, waterways or watercourses thereon or thereun-
der, or to any other estate so situated as to be in any man-
ner affected. LESSEE shall notify LESSOR at once of any
action instituted against LESSEE for the recovery of
84a
damages aforesaid, so that a proper defense against such
suit may be arranged for and agreed upon. LESSEE alone
shall be responsible for any injury to any person or prop-
erty, caused by the mining, handling or preparation of coal
produced hereunder, and for any mining outside the leased
premises, and shall save LESSOR harmless from all suits,
actions, loss and/or damages resulting therefrom.
ASSIGNMENTS
13th. LESSEE shall not assign, or subject in whole or in
part, this agreement or the estate created hereby or any
interest therein, or part with the possession of said prem-
ises or any part thereof without first obtaining the consent
in writing of LESSOR thereto, but nothing herein shall be
construed to prevent LESSEE from subletting any part of
the leased premises for tenements, minders’ houses,
stores, schools, churches or other facilities incidental to
the mining of the leased coal or necessary to the providing
of adequate mining community for the purposes hereof.
INSOLVENCY, BANKRUPTCY, ETC.
14th. LESSEE shall not permit this agreement or the
estate hereby created or any interest therein to be levied
upon or sold under any execution or other legal proceeding
or process whatsoever. The assignment or transfer of this
agreement or the estate and rights created or any of them
under judicial process or under judgment or decree or ad-
judication of LESSEE as a bankrupt, or the discharge of
LESSEE by any court as an insolvent debtor, or the as-
signment or subletting by him of any interest in this
agreement, or the parting with the possession of the
premises or any part thereof, without the written consent
of LESSOR as above provided for, may, at the option of
LESSOR, be considered and held as an absolute forfeiture
of this agreement, and thereupon, all the rights of LES-
SEE hereunder shall at once cease and determine, and
LESSOR, in addition to all of its other legal rights and
remedies, may, at its option, at once resume possession of
the premises and all the improvements hereinbefore men-
85a
tioned, either by legal process or by summary proceedings
without legal process.
CANCELLATION
15th. This agreement of lease may be cancelled by either
party hereto at any time by either party giving to the
other thirty (80) days written notice of its or his intention
to cancel same. Said notices shall be sufficient if given by
registered letter postmarked in the United States mails,
and thirty (30) days after receipt of such letter said
agreement of lease shall stand cancelled and terminated,
and shall be of no further force and effect.
REMEDIES
All of the foregoing powers of reentry, and all other
provisions for enforcement of the rights of LESSOR are
remedies cumulative to one another and to all other rem-
edies, suits, actions and proceedings at law or in equity,
that LESSOR may choose to exercise and for the purpose
of enforcing the payment of any rent or royalty the said
LESSOR shall not only have all rights and remedies pro-
vided at any time by the laws of the State of Kentucky for
landlords, but a lien is hereby created and imposed upon
this lease and the leasehold estate hereby created with all
the rights and privilegs conferred upon LESSEE here-
under, together with all the improvements placed by
LESSEE upon the leased premises, to secure the payment
of all rent, royalty or other moneys of every kind and
character accruing or becoming due at any time under this
lease.
MODIFICATION AND ALTERATION
17th. NO MODIFICATION, ALTERATION,
WAIVER, OR ADDITION to this agreement or any part
thereof shall be valid or binding or be set up or relied upon
by either party unless the same be in writing and signed
by LESSOR and LESSEE. No evidence of any such mod-
ification, alteration, waiver or addition shall be received in
86a
any controversy arising out of this agreement, except it be
in writing and signed as aforesaid.
WAIVER
18th. NEGLECT OR REFUSAL OF LESSOR at any
time to avail itself of any of its rights or remedies here-
under shall not be construed as a waiver of its right and
privilege to avail itself of each and every of such rights
and remedies whenever and as often as any new ground
therefor may arise.
CONDITIONS
19th. THE TERMS, PROVISIONS, COVENANTS
AND STIPULATIONS herein contained shall be taken
and deemed as conditions for the breach of which the term
hereof may be forfeited.
IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, LESSOR has caused its
name to be signed and its seal to be affixed hereunto by its
proper officers, thereunto duly authorized, and LESSEE
has subscribed his name hereunto, this the day and date
first hereinbefore written.
EXECUTED IN DUPLICATE KENTLAND COAL AND COKE COMPANY
DIVISION OF THE BERWIND-WHITE COAL
MINING COMPANY a
"ia
ATTEST: al
Secretary President
-——- Bugene H. Bane
WITNESSES:
Jul 27 1977
Aug 16 1977
Sep 26 1977
Sep 28 1977
Nov 8.1977
Dec 7 1977
Feb 3 1978
Apr 6 1978
Jun 15 1978
Sep 15 1978
Sep 15 1978
87a
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
BULL RUN MINING Co., INC.,
A WEST VIRGINIA CORPORATION
Vv.
THE UNITED STATES
Filing fee of $10 paid by plaintiff.
Notice of reference to Trial Judge Roald A.
Hogenson filed. Copy to parties. vacated
11/8/77
Defendant’s answer filed. Copies (5) to atty.
Trial judge’s standard pretrial order on lia-
bility filed. Copy to parties.
Notice of reassignment of case to Trial
Judge Judith Ann Yannello filed. Copy to
parties.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
February 5, 1978) to comply with pretrial
order filed. Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED
DEC 8 1977.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
April 6, 1978) to comply with pretrial order
filed. Copies (2) to atty.
ALLOWED FEB 6 1978.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
June 5, 1978) to comply with pretrial order
filed. Copies (2) to atty.
ALLOWED APR 7 1978 with no further ex-
tension to be granted except for extraordi-
nary circumstances.
Trial judge’s order pursuant to Rule 114
filed. Copy to parties.
Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment
filed. Copies (5) to deft.
Plaintiff's motion for waiver of attaching
copy of depositions to dipositive motion for
Oct 16 1978
Nov 14 1978
Nov 22 1978
Dee 11 1978
Jan 15 1979
Feb 5 1979
May 15 1979
May 21 1979
88a
summary judgment filed. Copies (2) to deft.
ALLOWED SEP 29 1978.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
Nov. 14, 1978) to file its response to plain-
tiffs motion for summary judgment filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED November 1,
1978.
Defendant’s motion for extension of time (to
Dec. 14, 1978) to file its response to plain-
tiffs motion for summary judgment filed.
Copies (2) to atty. ALLOWED: DEC 7 1978,
to the extent that defendant is granted an
extension of time to Monday, December 11,
1978.
Plaintiff's objections to defendant’s motion
for enlargement of time to file response to
plaintiff's motion for summary judgment
filed. Copies (2) to deft.
Defendant’s cross-motion for summary
judgment and brief, etc., filed. Copies (5) to
atty.
Plaintiffs reply to defendant’s cross-motion
for summary judgment, etc., filed. Copies
(5) to deft.
Defendant’s reply brief in support of its
cross-motion for summary judgment and. in
opposition to plaintiff's motion for summary
judgment filed. Copies (5) to atty.
Defendant’s motion for order directing con-
solidation [in this, 49-77 and 403-75], and
establishing schedule for oral argument
filed. Copy to attys. ALLOWED MAY 24
1979 SEE ENTRY THIS DATE.
Plaintiffs motion in opposition to defend-
ant’s motion for establishing schedule for
oral argument filed. [in this, 49-77, and
403-75]. Copies (2) to deft., and to atty in
49-77 and 403-75.
May 24 1979
Jun 4 1979
Jul i8 1979
Aug 8 1979
Nov 21 1979
Nov 28 1979
Dec 7 1979
Dec 7 1979
89a
Re: defendant’s motion, filed May 15, 1979.
ALLOWED as to consolidation with the
three plaintiffs’ attorneys to argue first and
granted 45 minutes to be divided as they
may agree on or 15 minutes each, with de-
fendant to argue thereafter for 45 minutes
and with the court to determine at the time
of oral argument how much, if any time, is to
be allowed to plaintiff for rebuttal.
In this, 403-75 and 49-77. Case No. 400-77
argued and submitted on plaintiffs motion
for summary judgment and defendant’s
cross-motion for summary judgment, Case
Nos. 408-75 and 49-77 argued and sub-
mitted on the merits [before, Davis, Ka-
shiwa and Bennett].
See 403-75 for Court Opinion.
Trial Judge’s Order pursuant to Rule 111
filed. Copy to parties.
Stipulation and entry of judgment filed by
defendant. Copies (2) to atty.
Trial Judge’s memorandum report for judg-
ment filed. Copy to parties.
Court filed order entering judgment for
plaintiff in the sum of $20,960.43., plus
statutory interest.
Certified transcript of judgment mailed to
attorney of record.
90a
In the United States Court of Claims
No. 400-77
BULL RUN MINING Co., INC.,
A WEST VIRGINIA CORPORATION,
Vv.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DEFENDANT
PETITION
TO THE HONORABLE THE CHIEF JUDGE AND THE
ASSOCIATE JUDGES OF THE COURT OF CLAIMS:
1. Plaintiff, Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., is a corporation
chartered under the laws of the State of West Virginia, on
or about the 7th day of September, 1965, with its principal
office located at Masontown, West Virginia. Said corpora-
tion was authorized to issue 100 shares of common stock
with the par value of $100.00. Ten (10) shares were issued
and outstanding during the fiscal year ending September
30, 1974. The following is a list of the shareholders and the
number of shares owned by each at that time:
Carlton L. McKenney, Sr. 8
Mary McKinney 1
Carlton L. McKinney, Jr. a
Total 10
Said corporation filed its income tax return for the fiscal
year ending September 30, 1974, with the Internal Rev-
enue Service Center, 3131 Democrat Road, Memphis,
Tennessee, 38110, and paid the tax shown thereon to be
owing in the amount of $8,216.49.
2. This action is brought pursuant to Section 1346 and
1491 of the Judicial Code (28 U.S.C.A. Sections 1346 and
1491) against the United States of America, as Defendant.
3. During the fiscal year ending September 30, 1974,
Plaintiff, Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., was engaged in the
business of mining and producing coal. Said company op-
9la
erated under written agreement of lease dated the 21st
day of June, 1967, between Preston County Coal and Coke
Corporation, a corporation, Lessor, and Bull Run Mining
Co., Inc., a corporation, Lessee. A copy of said lease,
identified as Exhibit A is attached hereto and by reference
is made a part hereof.
4. Said written lease granted to Bull Run Mining Co.,
Inc., Lessee, the exclusive right to mine and remove
maximum amount of coal consistent with modern mining
methods and in accordance with all existing rules, regula-
tions and laws affecting deep mining of coal now in effect
or which may hereinafter be placed in effect by the State
of West Virginia or the United States subject to the terms
of said lease, under certain tracts of land situate in Valley
District, Preston County, West Virginia, known as Tracts
125 D and 126 D, as originally designated upon maps of the
Bethlehem Mines Corporation, as more specifically set
forth in said lease.
5. In consideration thereof, the Lessee agreed to pay to
the Lessor the sum of 25¢ per ton for all coal mined and
removed from the premises and which payment would be
made on or before the 25th day of each calendar month for
all coal mined and removed during the preceding calendar
month. The lease does not require that the mined coal be
sold or delivered to the Lessor, but the Lessee is au-
thorized to extract and dispose of the coal underlying the
leased premises to whomever and at what prices it
chooses, without any restrictions.
6. Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., from the date of the above
mentioned lease, to September 30, 1974, had made a sub-
stantial investment in the opening of the mine, construc-
tion of buildings, acquisition of mining equipment, vehicles
and supplies in the amount of $167,285.54.
7. Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., must look to the proceeds
from its sale of the coal as the sole source of the revenue
from which it could recover the rents and royalties it paid
for the privilege of mining and its investment in the lease,
including the machinery, equipment and supplies, pur-
chased to mine the coal.
92a
8. As a result of the lease agreement with Preston
County Coal & Coke Corporation, a corporation, here-
inabove referred to, and its substantial investment in the
opening and operating of said mine, the said Bull Run
Mining Co., Ine., a corporation, acquired an economic
interest in the coal which it produced under said lease
agreement and was entitled to percentage depletion under
Sections 611 and 613 of the Internal Revenue Code of
1954.
9. No claim for percentage depletion on the coal ex-
tracted has been claimed or deducted by the Lessor. The
sole claimant to said percentage depletion deduction was
the Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., a corporation.
10. Upon examination, the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue, erroneously disallowed the depletion deduction
claimed by the Plaintiff, Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., re-
sulting in the assessment of deficiencies in income tax
against the said Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., a corporation.
11. On or about the 5th day of May, 1976, Plaintiff, Bull
Run Mining Co., Inc., paid the deficiency resulting from
the disallowance of the depletion for a fiscal year ending
September 30, 1974, as provided by law, in the amount of
$34,031.99. The interest and penalty notice in the amount
of $3,137.62 was paid on or about the 22nd day of April,
1976.
12. On or about June 25, 1976, Plaintiff, Bull Run Min-
ing Co., Inc., filed a 1120X, Claim for Refund, for the fis-
eal year ending September 30, 1974, with the Internal
Revenue Service Center, 3131 Democrat Road, Memphis
Tennessee, for the amount of $21,591.08, plus interest. A
copy of said 1120X identified as Exhibit B is attached
hereto and made a part hereof. This claim was based on
the fact that Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., was entitled to
$5,000.00 deduction for the rental of equipment that the
agent erroneously disallowed in his report, and was enti-
tled to the depletion claim in the amount of $39,981.41
which it was entitled to for the fiscal year ending Sep-
tember 30, 1974.
93a
13. The Commissioner, on re-examination of the records
of Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., and by his report dated Feb-
ruary 16, 1977, allowed the $5,000.00 deduction for rent
expense but refused to allow the deduction for depletion as
claimed by the Bull Run Mining Co., Inc., in the amount of
$39,981.41. A copy of said Commissioner’s Report iden-
tified as Exhibit C is hereby attached and made a part
hereof.
14. By reason of the Commissioner’s failure to allow the
claim for refund of the Plaintiff for the deduction for de-
pletion as set forth above for the year ending September
30, 1974, plus interest, are now wrongfully withheld f
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.