Appendix — Kentucky v. Whorton

Supreme Court brief1979

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court, U. &

FILED ‘|

it FER 17 1979

t

‘DAK, JR., CLERK

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1978

No. 78-749

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY - Petitioner

versus

HAROLD WHORTON - . . . Respondent

On Writ of Certiorari to the Supreme Court

of the Commonwealth of Kentucky

APPENDIX

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED

NOVEMBER 6, 1978

CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 8, 1979

WESTERFIELO-BONTE CO., 619 W. KENTUCKY~P.O, BOX 3251, LOUISVILLE, KY.

INDEX TO APPENDIX

PAGE

Relevant Docket Entries as Indexed by the Jefferson

Circuit Court Clerk’s Office in Indictment Number

SUS LER POEL CEES TOT ERT CT CT EeT 1- 2

Relevant Docket Entries as Indexed by the Jefferson

Cireuit Court Clerk’s Office in Indictment Number

BE eae cath cca elk ec aee Cire ed ak be a 3

Relevant Docket Entries as Indexed by the Jefferson

Cireuit Court Clerk’s Office in Indictment Number

PES Oe ey err en rere eee et pager ee 4-5

Mandate Issued by the Supreme Court of Kentucky .. 6

Instructions Tendered at Trial by Harold Whorton .. 8-16

Instructions Given to the Jury ...........eeceecees 18-31

pg | ey ee reer Aiea 33-40

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES AS INDEXED BY THE

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT CLERK’S OFFICE

IN INDICTMENT NUMBER 157391—TFiled March 10,

1978

INDEX

Supyner Paar

EES an SeRa ce ehsae a reek ECR ER een 1

NN a xan haan ee eeeee toes hed baci Seenean 2- 5

Order to reduce bail, dated June 6, 1976............ 6

Motion and Order on the withdrawal of James Bryant

as attorney, dated August 3, 1976...........005. 7

Motion for a Bill of Particulars with copy of order,

GOGAT Ta) Bis 6 us nace ansns base daweas 8-11

Motion to Produee with copy of order, September 7,

i Pe. RETO Te ee Ee fe Pe rere he 12-15

Response to Motion for Bill of Particulars, dated

UNE Dy Fees 6 veh vknec endear cennnent aces 16-17

Response to Motion to Produce, dated September 9,

Pe as 4. 0.65040 5 Kanone das veda naeeueameas 18-19

Supplementary Response to Motion for Bill of Par-

ticulars and Motion to Produce, filed February 18,

BEE 515 RTCRUR ENG RA ReORS AEE EDE ENTER EROS ETERS 20-21

Defendant’s motion for Leave to Withdraw Counsel,

POOCURTG BG, WOTEs cise sccdccceseseseavusessene 22-23

Motion to withdraw as counsel of record with copy of

order and Affidavit, dated February 28, 1977..... 24-27

Motion to Determine the Attorney of Record with

copy of order, filed in Open Court May 3, 1977. ..28-80

Motion to Grant Separate trial, filed May 16, 1977

with Copy Of OTOP. .....crecccvercccerveccvvcis 31-32

Judgment entered September 29, 1977..........0065 33-34

Motion to Elect, filed in Open Court September 16,

i SRP NerEN Oe WEMtn ES Mewes AL are pe eS Petrie tA 35

Motion to Separate Determination of Guilt Phase

from Punishment Phase, Filed in Open Court

2

Supyect Pace

September 20, 1977 with Memorandum of Author-

SPREE 6 06s Sa kdcn.b00bs vedpeceianss neues 36-89

Motion for Hearing Outside Presence Of Jury Regard-

ing Admissibility of Identification Testimony, filed

in Open Court September 20, 1977... 0.0.60 .00 ees 40-41

Motion to Suppress, filed in Open Court September 20,

SG. bas she caval pence eeesb cheese kee nhenes 42

Motion for Arrest of Judgement to Set Aside Verdict,

and for new Trial, dated September 20, 1977... ..48-44

Order on Memorandum Regarding Motion for Arrest

of Judgment to Set Aside Verdict, and for New

Trial, dated September 26, 1977........5++++. 45-46

Motion and Order on Substitution of Photograph for

Money Held as Evidenee, filed in Open Court

September 29, 1977........cceeeeeeeeevveeeenes 47-48

Notice of Appeal dated October 7, 1977.........0055 49

Motion to Proceed with Appeal in Forma Pauperis,

dated October 7, 1977... ..vcerccenenevevrevenves 50

Motion for Extension of Time, dated Deeember 6,

sn argh baad) ba AER REO S COTE ER AN 6 CmEOE

cc ccc eibavbasevevetereeneuses Last Paar

3

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES AS INDEXED BY THE

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT CLERK’S OFFICE

IN INDICTMENT NUMBER 157406—Filed March 10

1978

INDEX .

Sussgcor PacE

Ns ci din Cohnassak ea Wlce vk vecsacenecee 1

EE 5 Nin ov cic cin tacncdcacndeccessOeerer 2

Response to Motion for Bill of Particulars, dated

SE Uk Ma 9 4.55 60k ven en ewaspaccbelty o- 4

Response to Motion to Produce, dated September 13,

cf EE CETTE TTT CR TT CCCP EN rl 5- 6

Motion to Determine the Attorney of Record, filed in

Open Court May 3, 1977, with copy of order...... 7- 8

Motion to Separate Determination of Guilt Phase from

Punishment Phase, and Memorandum of Author-

ities, filed in Open Court September 20, 1977— .

SEE £5 kc eu een acassheksacnmeeenel saeueaci 9-12

Motion to Suppress Evidence seized from defendant’s

ear, filed in open Court September 20, 1977...... 13

Motion for Hearing Outside Presence of Jury Regard-

ing Admissibility of Identification Testimony, filed

in Open Court September 20, 1977.............. 14-15

Motion for Arrest of Judgment to Set Aside Verdict,

and for New Trial, dated September 26, 1977... .16-17

Order on Memorandum Regarding Motion for Arrest

of Judgment to Set Aside Verdict, and for New

ee CO Tk PUES os Ska kaeceesseesnnes 18-19

Judgment entered September 29, 1977............. 20

Notice of Appeal, dated October 7, 1977........... 21

Motion to Proceed with Appeal in Forma Pauperis,

AD: ere rete Sete 22

Motion for Extension of Time, dated December 6,

MUEEs os utccvctepukt casepeuasdhensd een ceeee 23-24

eo eceek beth behuen ka Last Pace

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES AS INDEXED BY THE

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT CLERK’S OFFICE

IN INDICTMENT NUMBER 157667—Filed March 10,

1978

INDEX

SuBJECT Pace

Ee sce Stak eh Fekie hanes hen ee eeues com 1

0 AEP CEEE Pe OPEL EEN EE TEC ee ear eee 2- 3

Motion for a Bill of Particulars with a copy of Order

ee IN BRIO, ors 5's ov cede he ter semen ews 4-7

Motion to Produce, with copy of Order, filed October

I ee ed Viet is whe eb an ok Reb a 8-12

Response to Motion for Bill of Particulars, dated

de ae Ceathaws 13-14

Response to Motion to Produce, dated December 9,

NE a ee ea ee Ere Cer eT ee Ree eae 15

Defendant’s Motion Pro se to Suppress Evidence. ...16-17

Motion to Determine the Attorney of Record, Filed in

Open Court May 3, 1977 with copy of Order....... 18-20

Motion for Competency Hearing, dated September 15,

eet en ee eaves Com saeien baa enw ys 21-22

Affidavit on defendant’s military service record, and

attached letter, dated September 14, 1977........ 23-25

Motion to Separate Determination of Guilt Phase

From Punishment Phase, Filed in open Court,

September 20, 1977 Memorandum of Authorities—

RES Siete etree Apne Parr rs ee ee ee 26-29

Motion to Dismiss, Filed in Open Court............ 30

Motion to Suppress Evidence, Filed in Open Court

September 20, 1977... ..cccccssceccesevvvvveces 31

Motion In Limine, Filed in Open-Court, September 20,

RPG Ere Saag tate bk ke naan eRe 32

Motion for Hearing Outside Presence of Jury Regard-

ing Admissibility of Identification Testimony,

Filed in Open Court September 20, 1977.......... 33-34

cq

SuBJECT

Instructions of the Court................ 35-62

cB ac Me Ee PO No te Ne tet 63-64

Order on Memorandum Regarding Motion for Arrest

of Judgment to Set Aside Verdict, and for New

Trial, dated September 26, 1977................ 65-66

Judgment entered September 29, 1977.............. 67

Motion to Proceed with Appeal in Forma Pauperis

Filed in Open Court October 7, 1977............. 68

Notice of Appeal, Filed in Open Court October 7,1977. 69

Motion for Extension of Time, dated December 6,

gO er tare pin pee) eet Ramee 1 ae beg ON cad 70-71

sp Eo: EET PEE Te te an Last Pace

ae sng eo, RE ETO EER OER. Ce Last Pace

6

SUPREME COURT OF KENTUCKY

OPINION RENDERED JULY 25, 1978

HaroLtp WHoRTON

v. File No. 78-SC-92-MR

CoMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

Appeal from Jefferson Circuit Court

Action No. 157406, 157667, 157391

MANDATE—Issued October 10, 1978

The Court being sufficiently advised, it seems the judg-

ment herein is erroneous.

It is therefore considered that said judgment be re-

versed for proceedings consistent with the opinion herein;

which is ordered to be certified to said court.

October 10, 1978 Appellee’s Petition for Rehearing Denied.

(s) Martha Layne Collins

Clerk

INSTRUCTIONS TENDERED AT TRIAL BY

HAROLD WHORTON

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT

CRIMINAL BRANCH, FOURTEENTH DIVISION

No. 157391

157406

157667

CoMMONWEALTH oF KENTUCKY - . - Plaintiff

v.

Harotp Worton . . . . . Defendant

DEFENDANT'S REQUESTED INSTRUCTION No. 1

The jury is advised that:

1. Only matters properly before the jury as a whole

may be considered. A member should not, for instance, be

influenced by any knowledge of the acts, character, or

service of the accused not based on the evidence or other

proper matter before the jury; by any opinions not prop-

erly in evidence; or by motives of partiality, favor, or

affection. In weighing the evidence a member is expected

to utilize his common sense and his knowledge of human

nature and of the ways of the world. In the light of all

the circumstances of the case, he should consider the in-

herent probability or improbability of the evidence.

2. As members of the jury you are required to deter-

mine the credibility of the witnesses, that is, their worthi-

ness of belief. In judging the credibility of the witnesses

in this proceeding, you should carefully weigh the testi-

mony given, and in so doing, consider all the circumstances

under which any witness has testified; his demeanor and

9

manner while on the stand; the acuteness of his powers of

observation; his interest, if any, in the outcome of the case;

his friendships and prejudices; the extent to which he is

contradicted or corroborated by other credible evidence, if

at all; and any circumstances that tend to shed light upon

his credibility, taking into acedunt your own experience in

dealing with people.

3. A member may properly believe one witness and

disbelieve several witnesses whose testimony is in conflict

with that of the one. You should reconcile the evidence in

this case in accordance with the weight and credibility

which you, in your best judgment determine should be

given to the testimony of each witness (and to each other

item of evidence), You should not disregard the testimony

of any witness without due consideration. f

4. The law presumes an accused to be innocent of

crime, He begins the trial with a clean slate, with no evi-

dence against him, And the law permits nothing but legal

evidence presented before the jury to be considered in

support of any charge against the accused. So the pre-

sumption of innocence alone is sufficient to acquit an ac-

cused unless the jury members are satisfied beyond a

reasonable doubt of the accused’s guilt from all the evi-

dence in the case,

5. A reasonable doubt is a fair doubt based upon

reason and common sense and arising from the state of the

evidence. It is rarely possible to prove anything to an

absolute certainty. The meaning of the rule is that the

proof must be such as to exclude, not every hypothesis or

possibility of innocence, but any fair and rational hypothe-

sis except that of guilt; what is required is not an absolute

or mathematical certainty but a moral certainty. An

accused is not to be convicted on mere suspicion or con-

jecture. A reasonable doubt may arise, not only from the

evidence produced, but also from a lack of evidence. Since

10

the burden is upon the prosecution to prove the accused

guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of every essential element

of the crime charged, an accused has the right to rely upon

failure of the prosecution to establish such proof. (An

accused may also rely upon evidence brought out on cross-

examination of witnesses for the prosecution.) The law

does not impose upon an accused the duty of producing any

evidence. A reasonable doubt exists in any case when,

after careful and impartial consideration of all the evidence,

the jury members do not feel convinced to a moral cer-

tainty that an accused is guilty of the offense(s) charged.

The final determination as to the weight of the evi-

dence in this case rests solely upon you members of the

jury. You must disregard any comment or statement made

by me during the course of the trial which may seem to

indicate an opinion as to the guilt or innocence of the

accused, for you alone have the independent responsibility

of deciding that issue. Kach of you must impartially re-

solve the ultimate issue as to the guilt or innocence of the

accused in accordance with the law, the evidence admitted

in court, and your own conscience.

I must caution you also against interpreting any com-

ment, statement, ruling or instruction which I have given

during this trial as indicating that the accused has the

burden of proving his innocence. On the contrary, the

burden is always on the Government to prove the accused

guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and this burden of proof

never shifts throughout the trial.

Reference: Air Force Manual 111-2, 15 October 1971;

United States v. Trotter, 15 USCMA 218, 35 CMR 190

(1965) ; United States v. Boswell, 8 USCMA 145, 23 CMR

369 (1957). See also United States v. Rinehart, 8 USCMA

402, 24 CMR 212 (1957). United States v. Offley, et al., 3

USCMA 276, 12 CMR 32 (1953); United States v. Moore,

4 USCMA 482, 16 CMR 56 (1954).

11

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

Assistant District Defender

Office of the Jefferson District

Public Defender

1000 Republic Building

Louisville, Kentucky 40202

CERTIFICATE

I do hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing was

delivered to the Commonwealth’s Attorney, or his agent, on

this 21st day of September, 1977.

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

12

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT

CRIMINAL BRANCH, FOURTEENTH DIVISION

No. 157391

157406

157667

CoMMONWEALTH oF KENTUCKY - . - Plaintiff

Vv.

HaroLp WuHorton - - - - - Defendant

INSTRUCTION No. 2

The jury is advised that:

“he defense has introduced evidence which may tend to

show that the accused could not have committed the offenses

charged in indictments 157406 and 157667 charging in-

cidents at the Krispy Creme Doughnut Shop, on May 15,

1976, and the Burger Chef Restaurant on May 25, 1976, be-

cause he was at another place at the time the offense was

allegedly committed. This is known as an alibi. An alibi

is one of the most perfect and conclusive means of estab-

lishing innocence, since an accused who was not present at

the time of an alleged offense could not have committed it.

The burden is on the prosecution to establish beyond a

reasonable doubt that the accused was present at the scene

of the offense at the time it was committed. Consequently,

unless you are satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the

accused was present, you must acquit him.

Reference: Air Foree Manual 111-2, 15 October 1971;

United States v. Moore, 15 USCMA 345, 35 CMR 317

13

(1965); United States v. Bigger, 2 USCMA 297, 8 CMR

97 (1953).

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

Assistant District Defender

Office of the Jefferson District

Publie Defender

1000 Republic Building

Louisville, Kentucky 40202

CERTIFICATE

I do hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing was

delivered to the Commonwealth’s Attorney, or his agent, on

this 21st day of September, 1977.

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

14

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT

CRIMINAL BRANCH, SIXTEENTH DIVISION

No. 157391

157406

157667

CoMMONWEALTH or KENTUCKY : . . Plaintiff

v.

Harotp Waorton . - : - . Defendant

INSTRUCTION No. 3

One of the most important issues in this case is the

identification of the defendant as the perpetrator of the

crime. The Commonwealth has the burden of proving

identity beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not essential that

the witness himself be free from doubt as to the correct-

ness of his statement. However, you, the jury must be

satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt of the accuracy of the

identification of the defendant before you may convict him.

If you are not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the

defendant is the person who committed the crime, you must

find the defendant not guilty.

Identification testimony is an expression of belief or

impression by the witness. Its value depends on the op-

portunity the witness had to observe the offender at the

time of the offense and to make a reliable identification

later.

In appraising the identification testimony of a witness,

you should consider the following:

15

(a) Are you convineed that the witness had the

capacity and an adequate opportunity to observe the

offender?

Whether the witness had an adequate opportunity to

observe the offender at the time of the offense will be

affected by such matters as how long or short a time was

available, how far or close the witness was, how good

were lighting conditions, whether the witness had had

occasion to see or know the person in the past.

(b) Are you satisfied that the identification made by

the witness subsequent to the offense was the product of

his own recollection? You may take into account both the

strength of the identification, and the circumstances under

which the identification was made.

If the identification by the witness may have been in-

fluenced by the circumstances under which the defendant

was presented to him for identification, you should seruti-

nize the identification with great care. You may also con-

sider the length of time that lapsed between the oeeur-

rence of the crime and the next opportunity of the witness

to see defendant, as a factor bearing on the reliability of the

identification.

You may also take into account that an identification

made by picking the defendant out of a group of similar

individuals is generally more reliable than one which re-

sults from the presentation of the defendant alone to the

witness,

(c) Finally, you must consider the eredibility of each

identification witness in the same way as any other witness,

consider whether he is truthful, and consider whether he

had the capacity and opportunity to make a reliable

observation on the matter covered in his testimony.

T again emphasize that the burden of proof on the

prosecutor extends to every element of the crime charged,

and this specifically includes the burden of proving beyond

a reasonable doubt the ‘identity of the defendant as the

16

perpetrator of the crime with which he stands charged. If

after examining the testimony, you have reasonable doubt

as to the accuracy of the identification, you must find the

defendant not guilty.

Respectfully submitted,

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

Assistant Distriet Defender

Office of the Jefferson District

Publie Defender

1000 Republic Building

Louisville, Kentucky 40202

CERTIFICATE

I do hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing was

delivered to the Commonwealth’s Attorney, or his agent, on

this 21st day of September, 1977.

(s) John B. Southard, Jr.

17

INSTRUCTIONS GIVEN TO THE JURY

1s

[T.R. 35]

JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT

FOURTEENTH DIVISION

Nos. 157667

157406

157391

CoMMONWEALTH OF Kentucky - - - Plaintiff

Vv.

Harotp Wuorton . - - - . Defendant

INSTRUCTIONS

Instruction No. I—-You will find the defenJant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 23rd of May 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Burger Chef Restaurant at 4975 Shelbyville Road;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical foree upon Jack Cole, an

employee, by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17

19

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 36]

Instruction No. I1—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 15th of May 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole property and a

sum of money from the Krispy Kreme Doughnut Shop

at 3920 South Seventh Street Road;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft of the Krispy Kreme Doughnut

Shop, the defendant threatened the immediate use of

physical foree upon Charles Sanders and other em-

ployees by pointing a pistol at them;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 37]

Instruction No, ITI—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

9{)

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 15th of May 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Charles Sanders;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical force upon Charles Sanders

by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17

If you find the defendant guilly under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your diseretion.

[T.R. 38]

Instruction No. IV—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, ane only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 15th of May 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from James Toohey;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical force upon James Toohey

by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17

21

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 39]

Instruction No. V—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 15th of May 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Harold Lovell; e

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical force upon Harold Lovell

by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruetion No,

17

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your dfseretion.

[T.R. 40]

Instruction No, VI—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruetion if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the

we

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Jerry’s Restaurant at 2106 Brownsboro Road;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical foree upon David Schaublin

and other employees by pointing a pistol at them;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instrugtion No.

17

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your diseretion.

[T.R. 41]

Instruction No. VI[—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the Ist of June 1976, and before the finding of the

indictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from John Sellinger;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent

to accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical force upon John Sellinger by

pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

, . . " . ’

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17

23

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruetion,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peni-

tentiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than

twenty (20) years, in your discretion,

[T.R. 42]

Instruction No. VIII—You will find the defendant,

Harold Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only

if, you believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt

all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Michael Golder;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical foree upon Michael Golder

by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon or was a

“dangerous instrument” as defined in Instruction No.

17.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than twenty

(20) years, in your diseretion.

[T.R. 43]

Instruction No, IX—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following: sl

”

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the Ist of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

24

dictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Lillian Cheek;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the im-

mediate use of physical force upon Lillian Cheek by

pointing a pistol at her;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than twenty

(20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 44]

Instruction No. X—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all

of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from David Voling;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the im-

mediate use of physical force upon David Voling by

pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than twenty

(20) years, in your discretion.

25

[T.R. 45]

Instruction No. XI—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant stole a sum of money

from Charles Cheek;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the im-

mediate use of physical force upon Charles Cheek by

pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than twenty

(20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 46]

Instruction No. XIA—You will find the defendant

Harold Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only

if, you believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt

all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant intended to accomplish

a theft of property from Charles Cheek;

(b) That in the course of so doing, and with the intent

to accomplish a theft, the defendant threatened the

26

immediate use of physical force upon Charles Cheek

by pointing a pistol at him;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than five (5) years nor more than ten (10)

years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 47]

Instruction No. XII—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant stole property from

Heidi Watley;

(b) That in the course of so doing and with intent to

accomplish the theft, the defendant threatened the im-

mediate use of physical foree upon Heidi Watley by

pointing a pistol at her;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than ten (10) years nor more than twenty

(20) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 48]

Instruction No. XITA—You will find the defendant

Harold Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only

27

if, you believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt

all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky. on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant intended to accomplish

a theft of property from Heidi Watley;

(b) That in the course of so doing, and with the intent

to accomplish a theft, the defendant threatened the

immediate use of physical force upon Heidi Watley by

pointing a pistol at her;

AND

(c) That said pistol was a deadly weapon.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than five (5) years nor more than ten

(10) years, in your discretion.

[T.R. 49]

Instruction No. XIII—You will find the defendant

Harold Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only

if, you believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt

all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 176, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant threatened the use of,

pointed and shot a pistol within close proximity of

several persons at the Jerry’s Restaurant at 2106

Brownsboro Road, and that he thereby wantonly cre-

ated a substantial danger of death or serious physical

injury to them;

(b) That under the circumstances such conduct mani-

fested extreme indifference to the value of human life.

28

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than one (1) year nor more than five (5)

years, in your discretion.

Instruction No. XIV—If you do not find the defendant

guilty under Instruction No, XIII, you will find him guilty

under this instruction if, and only if, you believe from the

evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and within twelve months before

the issuance of the finding of the indictment herein, he

wantonly threatened the use of, pointed and shot a

pistol within close proximity of several persons at the

Jerry’s Restaurant at 2106 Brownboro Road,

AND

(b) That he thereby wantonly created a substantial

danger of physical injury to them.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the county jai!

for a period not to exceed twelve months, at a fine not to

exceed $500.00, or at both confinement and fine, in your

discretion,

[T.R. 50]

Instruction No. XV—You will find the defendant Harold

Whorton guilty under this instruction if, and only if, you

believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt all of

the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and before the finding of the in-

dictment herein, the defendant threatened the use of

and pointed a pistol at Officer Tom Jenkins of the

~ Louisville Police Department, and that he thereby wan-

tonly created a substantial danger of death or serious

physical injury to him;

AND

(b) That under the circumstances such conduct mani-

fested extreme indifference to the value of human life.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the peniten-

tiary for not less than one (1) year nor more than five (5)

years, in your discretion.

Instruction No. XVI—If you do not find the defendant

guilty under Instruction No. XV, you will find him guilty

under this instruction if, and only, you believe the evidence

beyond a reasonable doubt all of the following:

(a) That in Jefferson County, Kentucky, on or about

the 1st of June 1976, and within twelve months before

the issuance of the finding of the indictment herein, he

wantonly threatened the use of and pointed a pistol at

Officer Tom Jenkins of the Louisville Police Depart-

ment ;

AND

(b) That he thereby wantonly created a substantial

danger of physical injury to him.

If you find the defendant guilty under this instruction,

you will fix his punishment at confinement in the county jail

for a period not to exceed twelve months, at a fine not to

exceed $500.00, or at both confinement and fine, in your

discretion,

[T.R. 51)

Instruction No. XVII—Definitions

(a) “Dangerous instrument”—means any instrument

which under the circumstances in which it is used, at-

30

tempted to be used, or threatened to be used, is readily

capable of causing death or serious physical injury.

(b) “Wantonly”’—a defendant acts wantonly with re-

spect to another’s death or physical injury when he is aware

of and consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable

risk that death or physical injury will occur. In order to

be “substantial and unjustifiable” the risk must be of such

nature and degree that disregard thereof constitutes a gross

deviation from the standard of conduct that a reasonable

person would observe in the situation.

(c) “Serious physical injury’—means physical injury

which creates a substantial risk of death or which causes

serious and prolonged disfigurement, prolonged impairment

of health, or prolonged loss or impairment of the function

of any bodily organ. |

(d) “Physical injury”—means substantial physical pain

or any impairment of physical condition.

Instruction No. XVIII—If upon the whole case you have

a reasonable doubt as to the defendant’s guilt, you shall find

him not guilty. The term reasonable doubt as used in these

instructions means a substantial doubt, a real doubt, in that

you must ask yourself not whether a better case might have

been proven but whether, after hearing all the evidence,

you actually doubt that the defendant is guilty.

Concerning Instruction Nos. XII and XIV—If you find

the defendant guilty but have a reasonable doubt as to the

degree of the offense of which he is guilty you shall find

him guilty of the lower degree. Instruction No. XIII is

the higher degree and Instruction No. XIV is the lower

degree.

Concerning Instruction Nos. XV and XVI—If you find

the defendant guilty but have a reasonable doubt as to the

degree of the offense of which he is guilty you shall find him

guilty of the lower degree. Instruction No. XV is the

higher degree and Instruction No. XVI is the lower degree.

31

[T.R. 52]

Instruction No. XIX—Under the evidence presented to

you in this ease, you may find the defendant not guilty of

all or some of the charges; or you may find the defendant

guilty of all or some of the charges.

Instruction No. XX—The verdict of the jury must be

unanimous and be signed by one of you as foreman. You

may use one of the form provided at the end of these in-

structions in writing your verdict.

(s) S. Rush Nicholson

Judge S. Rush Nicholson

THE JURY’S VERDICTS

33

[T.R. 53]

VERDICT No. 1

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. I.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 2

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. I and fix his punishment at confine-

ment in the penitentiary for 20 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E. Kidwell

Foreman

VERDICT No. 3

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. I

Foreman

VERDICT No. 4

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, II and fix his punishment at confine-

ment in the penitentiary for 20 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E. Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 54]

VERDICT No. 5

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. III.

Foreman

bd

VERDICT No. 6

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. III and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E. Kidwell

Foreman

VERDICT No. 7

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. IV.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 8

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction IV and fix his punishment at confine-

ment in the penitentiary for 20 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E. Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 55)

VERDICT No. 9

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. V.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 10

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. V and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James B. Kidwell

Foreman

35

VERDICT No. 11

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, VI.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 12

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, VI and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James KE, Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 56]

VERDICT No, 13

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, VII.

Foreman

VERDICT No, 14

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, VII and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James BE, Kidwell

Foreman

VERDICT No, 15

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, VIII.

Foreman

36

VERDICT No, 16

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, VIII and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James EK, Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 57]

VERDICT No. 17

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. IX.

Foreman

VERDICT No, 18

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, IX and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James EB, Kidwell

Foreman

VERDICT No, 19

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. X.

ee —— —_ —-<

Foreman

VERDICT No. 20

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. X and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 20 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E, Kidwell

Foreman

37

[T.R. 58]

VERDICT No. 21

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, XI.

(s) James EB, Kidwell

Foreman

VERDICT No, 22

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. XI and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for years,

(indicating the punishment)

Foreman

VERDICT No, 23

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, XILA.

Foreman

VERDICT No, 24

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No, XTA and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 10 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James EB, Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 59]

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, XII.

(s) James E, Kidwell

Foreman

38

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. XII and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for years.

(indicating the punishment)

Foreman

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, XITA.

Foreman

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Wherton guilty

under Instruction No. XILA and fixe his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 10 years.

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James KE. Kidwell

Foreman

[T.R. 60]

VERDICT No. 25

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. XIII.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 26

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. XIII and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 5 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James EK. Kidwell

Foreman

39

VERDICT No, 27

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. XIV.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 28

(a) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No. XIV and fix his punishment

at confinement inthe County Jail for ___-___ months and

a fine of $

Foreman

(b) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No, XIV and fix his punishment

at confinement in the County Jail for ______ months.

Foreman

[T.R. 61]

(c) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No, XIV and fix his punishment

at a fine of $

Foreman

VERDICT No. 29

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No. XV.

Foreman

VERDICT No. 30

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton guilty

under Instruction No. XV and fix his punishment at con-

finement in the penitentiary for 5 years,

(indicating the punishment)

(s) James E. Kidwell

Foreman

40

VERDICT No. 31

We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton not

guilty under Instruction No, XVI.

Foreman

[T.R. 62]

VERDICT No. 32

(a) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No. XVI and fix his punishment

at confinement in the County Jail for ____—_ months and

a fine of $

Foreman

(b) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No. XVI and fix his punishment

at confinement in the County Jail for ___—— months.

Foreman

(c) We, the Jury, find the defendant Harold Whorton

guilty under Instruction No. XVI and fix his punishment

at a fine of $

Foreman

Judge S. Rush Nicholson

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.