Appendix — Arizona Public Service Co. v. Snead

Supreme Court brief1979

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

IN THE MICWAEL R@DAK. JR., CLERK

Supreme Court of the United States

Ocroser Term, 1978

No. 77-1810

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, Ext Paso ELecrric

Company, Sari River Prosyect AcricutturaL IMPROVEMENT

anp Power District, Sournern Catirornia Epison Com-

pany, and Tucson Gas & Exectric Company,

Appellants,

Artruur B. Sweap, Director of the Revenue Division of the

Taxation and Revenue Department, Revenve Drvision or

THe Taxation and Revenve Department, and State or

New Mexico,

Appellees.

On Appeal From The Supreme Court of New Mezico

JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT FILED JUNE 21, 1978

PROBABLE JURISDICTION NOTED OCTOBER 10. 1978

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Docket Entries (New Mexico Supreme Court) ....... 1

Docket Entries (Santa Fe District Court) ........... 4

GED ons ccccdedcesecccscectacceoconncssccocces 9

Answers to Defendant Bureau of Revenue’s Interroga-

BED cacccecncancacenestecssedesendeteeuseesss 18

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment .......... 30

Affidavit of Henry B. Sargent, Jr. (Affidavit No. 1 to

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) .... 32

Affidavit of Martin P. Kuric (Affidavit No. 2 to Plain-

tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) ......... 40

Affidavit of C. M. Perkins ( Affidavit No. 3 to Plaintiffs’

Motion for Summary Judgment) ............... 52

Affidavit of A. L. Maxwell (Affidavit No. 4 to Plain-

tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) ...... rice aD

Affidavit of Kenneth L. Saul (Affidavit No. 5 to Plain-

tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) .......... 65

Affidavit of Phoebe Fornaciari ( Affidavit No. 6 to Plain-

tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) (Without

PEED codoccusveccadstoneddseiecéanerec 71

Affidavit of Carl M. Turner (Affidavit No. 7 to Plain-

tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment) (Without

EE 600 60b6udendeddheudé sesseacceadconss 75

ee gre Answers to Supplemental Interrogatory No. -

Office Memorandum to Bruce Norton ............... 85

Correspondence to Senator Fannin ................. 87

COIR, GES FO GD oc ccccceccsescccccceccceccce 90

First Amended Complaint ................-eeeeeees 91

Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Motion for Summary Judg-

GEE icccecccceceseoces aadeosedaesasesnnesese 102

Affidavit of Bruce Norton (with Attachments A, B

il Table of Contents Continued

Page

Answer to the First Amended Complaint ............ 110

Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment ........ 115

Affidavit of Martin L. Baughman .................. 116

Affidavit of Graciela Olivarez ...........0cseeeeeees 119

Affidavit of Cubia L. Clayton ..............00eeeeees 122

Affidavit of Dan Croy, M.D. ...........ccsceeeceeess 127

Affidavit of Bruce R. Nicholson ............00ese0005 131

Affidavit of Stephen R. Flance ..............0.e0055 139

Memorandum Opinion .............0eseeeeeeeeeeees 142

PE cncoceconceenésencesuscocedsenecessneuesc 143

Notice of Appeal (To the Supreme Court of New

BD acacaceceoccosocddscondcsodsonensonse 145

Opinion of Supreme Court of New Mexico .......... 147

BED GE BI o ccccccccccccccecccecccossccseses 148

Docket Entries (New Mexico Supreme Court)

SUPREME COURT OF NEW MEXICO

Docket No. 11369

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, Ex Paso Exvecrric Com-

pany, Sait River Proyect AGricuLTuRAL IMPROVEMENT AND

Power District, SourHerN CauiFrornia Epison Company

anp Tucson Gas & Execrric Company,

Plaintiff s-A ppellants,

vs.

Frep O’CuHesky, Commissioner of Revenue, Bureau oF

Revenve anp State or New Mexico,

Defendants-A ppellees.

ATTORNEYS

Daniel J. McAuliffe

3100 Valley Center, Phoenix, AZ 85013

Montgomery; Frank Andrews III

Bx 2307 Santa Fe 87501

Rodey; William C. Schaab

Bx 1888 Albu 87103

White, Koch, Kelly & McCarthy

Benjamin Phillips Bx 787 Santa Fe

Bigbee; Richard N. Carpenter Bx 669

Snell & Wilmer, Mark Wilmer

3100 Valley Center, Phoenix Az 85073

Toney Anaya, Atty Gen; Jan Unna Sp Asst

Bx 630 87503; Daniel H. Friedman

Charles T. DuMars, 1121 Kent NW 87102 (Amicus Curiae)

2

CIVIL APPEAL FROM DISTRICT COURT SANTA FE (50245)

COUNTY

Judgment 2/18/77

Notice of Appeal 3/18/77

Edwin L. Felter, Judge

CASH ACCOUNT FOR COSTS

DATE RECEIVED FROM OF PAID TO RECEIVED DISBURSED

1977

April 11 Bigbee Stephenson

Carpenter & Crout $20.00

State Treasurer $16.00

Sept. 12 Record Bound

cITaATIONS—Amicus Curiae

N. MEX. 576 pac. 2np 291

DATE PROCEEDINGS

1977

April 11 Skeleton Transcript

June 30 3 Transcript of Record (5 volumes)

Request for Oral Argument

July 29 Brief in Chief

August 24 Motion to extend Answer Brief to

September 26—app’d

September 26 Answer Brief

October 5 Motion to extend Reply Brief to October

17—app’d

AD ME AAR Ae Be

17

November 9

1978

March 23

April 4

10

12

June 13

15

3

Reply Brief

Certificate of Service

Argued and Submitted

Opinion (Peyne/Sosa-Easley)

Order affirming

Mandate

Receipt for Mandate

Notice of Appeal to United States

Supreme Court

Affidavit of Service

Request for Certification and

Transmission

Affidavit of Mailing (attached tu request)

Certification and Transmission of Record

4

Docket Entries (Santa Fe District Court)

No. 50245

Anizona Pvusiic Service Company, et AL,

Plaintiffs

vs.

Frepv O’Cueskey, Defendants.

Type or case—Declaratory Judgment ree $20.00

DATE DIV. U PROCEEDINGS MISCELLANEOUS ACCOUNTS

REMARKS

1975

Sept. 18—Docket Fee

18—Conaplaint, filed

18—Summons, issued

19—Summons, returned & filed

Oct. 10—Motion for extension of time to move or plead,

filed

10—Entry of Appearance, filed

20—Order, filed & entered

Nov. 10—Memorandum of Points and Authorities In Sup-

port of Motion To Intervene, filed

10—Motion For Leave To Intervene, filed

10—Answer In Intervention, filed

16—Motion To Dismiss, filed

13—Supplemental Memorandum In Support of Motion

to Intervene, filed

a

21—Plaintiff’s Brief in Opposition to Motion for

Intervention, filed

25—Stipulation, filed

25—Order, filed and entered

Dec. 18—Defendants’ Memorandum Opposing Intervention,

filed

22—Plaintiffs Brief in Opposition to Defendants’ Mo-

tion to Dismiss, filed

1976

Jan. 12—Petition for Leave For Defendants To File A Re-

ply to Plaintiff's Brief In Opposition, filed

12—Order, filed and entered

12—Defendants’ Reply to Plaintiff's Brief In Opposi-

tion To the Motion to Dismiss, filed

19—Notice of Hearing, filed

1976 50245 Arizona vs Fred O’Cheskey

Feb. 13—Entry of Appearance, filed

23—Supplementa! Brief In Support of Defendants

12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss, filed

May 26—Order, filed and entered

June 4—Supplemental Order, filed & entered

4—Application for Order Allowing Interlocutory

Appeal, filed

July 21—Joint Answer, filed

Aug. 16—Notice of Hearing, filed

25—Interrogatories, filed

Sept. 3—Objection to Interrogatories & Notice of Hearing,

filed

14—Answers to Defendant Bureau of Revenue’s

Interrogatories, filed

6

15—Brief In Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion For

Summary Judgment, filed

15—Plaintiff’s Motion For Summary Judgment, filed

20—Notice of Hearing, filed

21- Notice of Hearing, filed

23—Order, filed & entered

Oct. 6—Supplemental Interrogatories, filed

1976 50245 Arizona vs O’Cheskey et al

Oct. 12—Notice of hearing, filed

21—Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Answers to Interroga-

tories, filed

22—Answer to Defendants Supplemental! Interroga-

tories, filed

22—Order, filed and entered

22—First Amended Complaint, filed

25—Motion to Compel Answers to Interrogatories,

filed

27—Restated Interrogatory 8, filed

29-—Withdrawal as Counsel & Consent to Substitution

of Counsel, filed

Nov. 2—Order filed & entered

4—Notice of hearing, filed

5—Plaintiffs Supplemental Motion for Summary

Judgment, filed

5—Brief in Support of Plaintiffs Supplemental

Motion for Summary Judgment, filed

S—Answer to the first amended complaint, filed

9—Plaintiffs Answer to Restated Interrogatory 8, filed

1976 No. 50245—Arizona Public Service vs O’Cheskey

Dec. 2—Objection to Plaintiff's Affidavits No. 6 & No. 7,

filed

7

2—Memorandum in Support of Defendants’ Objection

to Affidavits 6 & 7, filed

2—Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment, filed

7—Notice of Hearing, filed

16—Memo in Opposition to Defendant Objections to

Plaintiff's Affidavits 6 & 7 to Plaintiff's Motion for

Summary Judgment, filed

20-—Certificate of Service, filed

21—Brief In Support of Defendants’ Motion for

Summary Judgment, filed

1977

Jan. 1—Notice of Hearing, filed

20—Plaintiffs Response To Defendants Brief In Sup-

port of Defendants’ Motion For Summary Judgment,

filed

Jan. 31—Memorandum Opinion filed & entered

Bf. 313P. 404-414

Feb. 18—Judgment, filed & entered Bf. 315P. 250-251

Mar. 18—Notice of Appeal, filed (vnm)

23—Clerk’s Certificate, issued & filed

23—Request For Transcript of Record Proper, filed

30—Appellees’ Designation of Additional Parts of

the Record, filed

May 27—Certificate of Satisfactory Arrangements For

Transcript, filed (vnm)

27—Motion For Extension of Time To File Transcript

On Appeal, filed (vmm)

27—Order, filed and entered (vmm)

June 28—Transcript of Record, filed

Oct. 7—Affidavit of Daniel H. Friedman, filed

7—Exhibit to Affidavit of Daniel H. Friedman, filed

7—Motion to correct the record on appeal, filed

Oct. 14—Plaintiff’s Response to Motion to Correct Record

on Appeal and Conditional Motion, filed

1978

April 7—Mandate (affirmed), filed & entered

ee et

9

(1) Complaint

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN TEE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pustic Service Company, Ext Paso Exvecrric

Company, Savt River Prosect AcricutturaL IMPROVEMENT

anv Power Distaict, Sourmern Catirornia Epison

Company, anp Tucson Gas & Execraic Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or Revenve, ano State or New Mexico, Defendants.

CoMPLAINT

Plaintiffs bring this action for declaratory judgment pur-

suant to the New Mexico Declaratory Judgment Act, Chap-

ter 340, Laws 1975, with respect to the constitutionality and

validity of the Electrical Energy Tax Act, Chapter 263,

Laws 1975, and for their complaint herein, state:

1. Arizona Public Service Company, an Arizona cor-

poration, generates, transmits, distributes and sells elec-

trical energy within the State of Arizona, and is regulated

as a public service corporation by the Arizona Corporation

Commission.

2. El Paso Electric Company, a Texas corporation, gen-

erates, transmits, distributes and sells electrical energy

within the States of New Mexico and Texas, and is regu-

lated as a public utility in New Mexico by the New Mexico

Public Service Commission and in Texas by the cities of

El Paso, Van Horn, Anthony and Clint.

3. Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (hereinafter “Salt River Project”), a politi-

cal subdivision of the State of Arizona, operating a federal

10

reclamation project pursuant to contracts with the Secre-

tary of the Interior, generates, transmits, distributes and

sells electrical energy within the State of Arizona.

4. Southern California Edison Company, a California

corporation, generates, transmits, distributes and sells elec-

trical energy within the State of California, and is regu-

lated as a public utility by the California Public Utilities

Commission.

5. Tueson Gas & Electric Company, an Arizona corpora-

tion, generates, transmits, distributes and sells electrical

energy within the Stete of Arizona, and is regulated as a

public service corporation by the Arizona Corporation

Commission.

6. Fred O’Cheskey is Commissioner of the Bureau of

Revenue of the State of New Mexico. The Bureau of Rev-

enue is the agency of state government charged with the

administration and enforcement of the Electrical Energy

Tax Act.

7. The Four Corners Power Plant is an electrical gen-

erating station composed of five generating units and re-

lated facilities located on Indian lands leased from the

Navajo Nation under Leases dated December 1, 1960 and

July 1, 1966, duly approved by the Navajo Tribal Council

and the Acting Secretary of the Interior.

8. Arizona Public Service Company owns and operates

generating units Nos. 1, 2 and 3 at the Four Corners Power

Plant. Arizona Public Service Company, El Paso Electric

Company, Public Service Company of New Mexico, South-

ern California Edison Company and Tucson Gas & Electric

Company each owns an undivided interest in generating

units Nos. 4 and 5 at the Four Corners Power Plant.

9. The San Juan Generating Station is an electrical

generating station composed of two generating units (one

operational and one under construction) and related facili-

11

ties located in San Juan County, near Waterflow, New

Mexico.

10. Public Service Company of New Mexico and Tucson

Gas & Electric Company each owns an undivided one-half

(1%) interest in the San Juan Generating Station.

11. Certain of the plaintiffs (Arizona Public Service

Company and El Paso Electric Company) sell electrical

energy generated from the Four Corners Power Plant to a

foreign country, Mexico.

12. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission

Lines annexed hereto as Exhibit “A”, the electrical system

of each plaintiff is directly interconnected with the system

of each other plaintiff and with the electrical systems of

Public Service Company of New Mexico, the U.S. Bureau

of Reclamation, and Utah Power and Light Company.

Southern California Edison Company’s system is also di-

rectly connected with San Diego Gas & Electric Company,

the Department of Water and Power, City of Los Angeles,

the Pasadena Department of Water and Power, and Pacific

Gas & Electric Company; its system is indirectly but sub-

stantially interconnected with the several Pacific Northwest

systems and through them to other utility systems in the

western United States. The interconnected transmission

lines thus constitute an interstate grid encompassing the

West.

13. As a consequence of the system interconnections

described in the preceding paragraph, the demand for elec-

tricity in the major urban centers served by the plaintiffs

in Arizona, southern California, and the El Paso area of

West Texas determines in substantial degree the amount of

electrical energy generated at generating stations located

in New Mexico (as well as those in other states). The elec-

trical energy generated in New Mexico in response to such

demand to which each plaintiff is entitled from its genera-

tion facilities is instantaneously transmitted over existing

transmission lines to that plaintiff’s service area.

12

14. All of the plaintiffs’ above-described transactions in

the generation and transmission of electrical energy at the

Four Corners Power Plant and the San Juan Generating

Station, and the distribution and sales of such electrical

energy, are in the course of commerce among the States

and the Navajo Tribe of Indians, except for the aforesaid

sales of electrical energy to Mexico, certain relatively in-

significant sales made by Arizona Public Service Company

within New Mexico to Utah International Inc., for cpera-

tion of the Navajo Mine which provides the fuel for the

Four Corners Power Plant, and for certain sales by El

Paso Electric Company within its service area in the State

of New Mexico. All other sales or exchanges of electrical

energy in New Mexico by any plaintiff are wholesale sales

to other electric utility companies on the interconnected

systems in interstate commerce under the exclusive juris-

diction of the Federal Power Commission. Such interstate

sales give rise to no New Mexico gross receipts tax liability

under the New Mexico Gross Receipts and Compensating

Tax Act.

15. Each plaintiff pays income, ad valorem, franchise

and other taxes imposed by the State of New Mexico or its

political subdivisions on it and other taxpayers similarly

situated, and income, ad valorem, sales and use (or their

equivalent), franchise, excise and other taxes imposed by

the state of its incorporation on it and other taxpayers sim-

ilarly situated.

16. Section 3 of the Electrical Energy Tax Act, Chap-

ter 263, Laws 1975 (hereinafter the “Act”), purports to

impose on persons generating electricity a privilege tax of

four-tenths of one mill “on each net kilowatt hour of elec-

tricity generated in New Mexico” for the purpose of sale.

17. Subsection 9B of the Act provides that the electricial

energy tax paid on electricity generated and consumed in

New Mexico may be credited against the gross receipts tax

due New Mexico. No credits of any type are provided with

eS

tM roe)

en. a

13

respect to the electrical energy tax imposed upon electricity

generated in New Mexico but transmitted and consumed

outside New Mexico.

18. Subsection 9C of the Act directs that the credit for

electrical energy tax paid on electricity generated and con-

sumed in New Mexico shali be assigned to the person sell-

ing the electricity for consumption in New Mexico on which

New Mexico gross receipts tax is due, and further requires

the assignee of such credit to reimburse the assignor for

the amount of the credit so assigned.

19. The practical operation and effect of Sections 3

and 9 of the Act is to tax the generation of electricity in

New Mexico but shift the incidence of such tax to those

who sell or consume that electricity outside New Mexico

since the person generating and selling electricity for con-

sumption in New Mexico receives either a credit (under

Subsection 9B) against his gross receipts tax due New

Mexico or a reimbursement (under Subsection 9C) in an

amount equal to the electrical energy tax payable on such

electricity.

20. Plaintiffs’ retail sales of electrical energy transmitted

from generating facilities in New Mexico to plaintiffs’ re-

spective service areas in Texas, Arizona and California are

subject to certain taxes imposed by those states, or the

political subdivisions thereof, or both. Such taxes are vari-

ously denominated as sales or other types of excise taxes,

but are uniformly imposed upon, or passed on to consumers

of electricity in those states.

21. There is no provision of law in Texas, Arizona or

California whereby any of the plaintiffs are entitled to any

credit, offset or rebate for the electrical energy tax im-

posed on them by New Mexico.

22. Public Service Company of New Mexico, an electric

public utility regulated by the New Mexico Public Service

Commission, with respect to its share of electrical energy

14

generated at the Four Corners Power Plant and the San

Juan Generating Station, will in practical effect sustain no

additional tax burden under the Electrical Energy Tax Act

due to the provisions of Subsections 9B and 9C of the

Act permitting the amount of electrical energy tax paid to

be assigned or credited against its gross reecipts tax lia-

bility due the State of New Mexico.

23. El Paso Electric Company will in practical effect

sustain no additional tax burden under the Electrical En-

ergy Tax Act with respect to the electrical energy gener-

ated in New Mexico and sold by it to consumers in New

Mexico due to the provisions of Subsections 9B and 9C of

the Act allowing the electrical energy tax to be credited

against its New Mexico gross receipts tax liability.

24. Plains Electric Generation and Transmission Coop-

erative, a New Mexico corporation, generates electrical

energy at its generating plant near Algodones, New Mex-

ico, and transmits and sells electrical energy solely to New

Mexico electric utilities which are its members; however,

by reason of Subsections 9B and 9C of the Act, it will incur

no additional tax burden due to the Electrical Energy Tax

Act.

25. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that no additional tax liability under the Electrical

Energy Tax Act is incurred by any other person (as de-

fined in the Electrical Energy Tax Act) engageu in the

same business as plaintiffs upon electrical energy generated

and consumed in New Mexico, due to the availability of the

crediting provisions provided for under Subsections 9B

and 9C of the Act.

26. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that all, or virtually all, of the additional taxes

claimed to be due under the Electrical Energy Tax Act,

after application of Subsections 9B and 9C of the Act, will

be borne by those persons, including plaintiffs, engaged in

ee

15

the generation of electricity in New Mexico which is trans-

mitted across and consumed outside the boundaries of the

State of New Mexico.

27. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that the Act was enacted for the purpose of and the

view to placing the exclusive burden of paying additional

tax revenues to the State of New Mexico upon transactions

in commerce among the several states and with the Indian

Tribes.

28. The language of the Act, coupled with the practical

application o1 the tax, constitutes a tax on the privilege of

engaging in commerce among the several states.

29. Plaintiffs contend that the Act is unconstitutional

and void for each and every one of the following reasons:

A. The Electrical Energy Tax Act violates the Com-

merce Clause of Article I, Section 8 of the United

States Constitution by deliberately and invidiously dis-

criminating against and imposing direct and multiple

burdens upon each plaintiff’s interstate commerce in the

transmission and sale of electricity.

B. Application of the Electrical Energy Tax to these

plaintiffs, measured by electricity generated in New

Mexico for transmission and sale in interstate com-

merce, is arbitrary, capricious and unreasonable and

denies to each plaintiff the equal protection of the law,

and the rights, privileges and immunities enjoyed

by other members of the class defined as persons gen-

erating electrical energy in New Mexico, in violation

of Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the

United States Constitution, and of Article IT, Section

18, and Article IV, Section 26 of the New Mexico Con-

stitution.

C. The Act deprives plaintiffs of property without

due process of law in violation of Section 1 of the

16

Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitu-

tion and Article II, Section 18 of the New Mexico

Constitution.

D. The Act violates Article I, Section 8, Clause 3,

and Article I, Section 10, Clause 2 of the United States

Constitution.

30. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that defendants contend the Act is constitutional with

respect to the matters set forth in paragraph No. 29 of

this Complaint.

31. The plaintiffs, being persons whose rights, status or

other legal relations are affected by the Act, request that

the Court determine the questions of validity arising under

the Act.

32. A genuine controversy exists between the plaintiffs

and defendants with respect to the matters hereinbefore al-

leged; however, there is no controversy respecting the

amount of the tax which would be payable by any plaintiff,

if the Act is valid, nor with respect to the form or accuracy

of any assessment of tax thereunder.

33. Due to the necessity to construe and apply pro-

visions of the United States Constitution and the New Mex-

ico Constitution in order to resolve the controversy between

plaintiffs and defendants, piaintiffs have no other plain,

speedy and adequate remedy.

34. All conditions precedent to the commencement and

maintenance of this action have occurred or been met.

Wuenerore, plaintiffs pray:

A. That this Court adjudge and declare the Elec-

trical Energy Tax Act, Chapter 263, Laws 1975, to be

unconstitutional and void.

B. That upon final hearing and determination the

defendants be enjoined from enforcing the Electrical

17

Energy Tax Act and plaintiffs have such other and

further relief as may be proper in the premises.

Bicsez, Byrp, Carpenter & Crovut

Richard N. Carpenter

Bokum Building, Suite 200

142 West Palace Avenue

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Ropney, Dickason, Stoan,

Axin & Ross

William C. Schaab

221 Central Avenue, N.W.

Albuquerque, New Mexico 87103

Snett & WiMEr

Bruce Norton

3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073

Montcomery, Feperici, ANDREWS,

Hannaus & Buei

Fred C. Hannahs

350 East Palace Avenue

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

/8/ By Frep C. Hannans

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

White, Kocn, Kerry & McCarruy

Ben J. Phillips

Post Office Box 787

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Co-counsel for plaintiff,

El Paso Electric Company

18

Answers to Defendant Bureau of Revenue's

Interrogatories

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FB

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusuc Service Company, Ev Paso Execrric

Company, Sact River Prosect AcricutturaL IMPROVEMENT

anp Power Disraict, Sovrmern Catirornia Epison

Company, ano Tucson Gas & Exvectric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or Revenve, anv State or New Mexico, Defendants.

Interrogatory No. 1. Please give the citation for and pop-

ular name of the state tax statutes, other than New Mex-

ico’s, to which you are subject.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 1. See affidavits 1 through

5 attached to plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment.

Interrogatory No. 2. Please identify all agreements, other

than those referred to in the Stipulation of Facts proposed

by your attorneys, currently in force between you and any

other plaintiff or any other utility generating or selling

electricity in New Mexico. If you will do so without a mo-

tion to produce, please attach a copy of each agreement to

your answers.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 2.

Objected to.

Interrogatory No. 3. Please give the amounts of elec-

tricity generated outside New Mexico in 1975 which you

sold to New Mexico utilities and identify the utilities.

19

Answer to Interrogatory No. 3.

Arizona Pustuic Service

Generated Outside Generated T

Sold To New Mexico in New Mexico ae

PSNM 1,585 Mwh 200 Mwh 1,785 Mwh

EPE Co. 3,075 Mwh 370 Mwh 3,445 Mwh

Ex Paso Execrric

Normally, all Kwh sold to other utilities in New Mexico

are generated in New Mexico. However, available records

for the last six months of 1975 indicate 180,000 Kwh gen-

erated in Texas were sold to PSNM. This should be re-

garded as an extraordinary transaction.

Sart River Prosecr

None.

Sovrnern Cauirornia Epison

None.

Tvcson Gas & Execrric

TG&E sold 30,000 Kwh to PSNM in 1975 from electricity

generated outside New Mexico.

Interrogatory No. 4. Please list the amount of electricity

generated in New Mexico i

teen 1888. purchased by you in each year

Answer to Interrogatory No. 4.

Objected to. However, plaintiffs, without waiving their

objections, will give the answer for the years 1970 through

1975 as the requested iaformation is available.

20

Arizona Pvusuic Service

Information is not available to make a direct answer to

this question exactly as it is stated. Therefore, individual

purchases by APS along with brief explanations are listed

as follows:

A: Energy generated at San Juan, purchased from TGE

1973— 50.836 Mwh all generated in N.M.

1974—190,195 Mwh all generated in N.M.

B: Energy generated at Four Corners, purchased from

SCE

1974— 8,186 Mwh all generated in N.M.

: Economy Interchange purchased from PSNM

Tota! amounts purchased by APS are listed below. Most

of this, but not all, was generated in New Mexico. A

portion was bought from USBR by PSNM and re-sold

to APS.

Year 1970-1971 1972 1973-1974 1975

17,120 31,507 19,600 1,480 109,334 108,400

D: Economy Interchange purchased from EPE

Total amounts purchased by APS are listed below. Part

of this was generated in New Mexico and part was

generated in Texas.

Year 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975

Mwh v0 0 2,423 1,395 6,083 7,259

E: Economy Interchange purchased from SRP and TGE

Total amounts purchased by APS are listed below. Most

of this was generated in Arizona, but small portions

were generated in New Mexico.

°

21

Year 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975

SRP (Mwh) 55,560 59,652 33,893 1,515 815 7,444

TGE (Mwh) 2,201 10,798 14,808 8461 4,908 11,716

Ex Paso Execrric

Exvectric:rry Purcnasen From Orner Utiuities By EPEC*

1970 «61971-1972, 1978S 974195

KWH KWH KWH KWH KWH KWH

PNM —0— 480,000 11,570,000 735,000 30,840,000 20,858,000

—O— 140000 —0—- -0- 20,000 —o~

—O— —0— -0~ 640,000 145,000 200,000

APS —0— —0— 5,152,000 4,615,000 4,130,000 2,710,000

oO -0— -0— 9200 -0—~ —o-

cPesS —-0—- -—-0- -0—- -0— — 0 19,626,000

—0— _ 620,000 16,722,000 6,020,000 35,135,000 43,394,000

22

Saut River Prosgect

1970—Four Corners #5 net test energy

(accounted for as a purchase from

the constructor, Bechtel Power Cor-

poration)—-SRP Portion 70,025,680 kwh

1971—Interchange from EF! Paso Electric 16.910,000 kwh

1972—Purchase from Plains ElectriceG &T 40,367,000 kwh

Economy Interchange from:

El Paso Electric 72,797,000 kwh

Public Service of New Mexico 140,000 kwh

Southern California Edison 486,000 kwh

1972 Total 113,790,000 kwh

1973—Purchase from Plains Electric G & T 163,005,000 kwh

Interchange from El Paso Electric 840,000 kwh

Economy Energy from:

El Paso Electric 30,518,000 kwh

Public Service of New Mexico 5,825,000 kwh

Tucson Gas & Electric 50,212,000 kwh

1973 Total 250,400,000 kwh

1974—Purchase from:

El Paso Electric 14,483,000 kwh

Plains Electric G & T 228,156,000 kwh

Public Service of New Mexico 98,631,000 kwh

Tucson Gas & Electric 179,604,000 kwh

Interchange from E] Paso Electric 289,000 kwh

1974 Total 521,163,000 kwh

1975—Purchase from:

El Paso Electric 18,766,000 kwh

Plains Electric G & T 32,689,000 kwh

Public Service of New Mexico 94,735,000 kwh

Tucson Gas & Electric 5,465,000 kwh

1975 Total 151,650,000 kwh

23

Sournern Cauirornia Epison

Energy generated in New Mexico and purchased by SCE:

Year MWH

1959 through

1968 0

1969 6,652

1970 21,165

1971 104,721

1972 2,650

1973 40,567

1974 46,422

1975 181,467

Energy purchases listed above include the total purchased

by SCE frem Four Corners Project participants. Our ree-

ords do not include the necessary data to determine what

portion of the energy was generated in New Mexico.

Tucson Gas & Execrric

No purchases by TGE 1970 and 1971

1972 80,000 KWH

1973 40,000 KWH

1974 1,892,000 KWH

1975 73,619,000 KWH

Interrogatory No. 5. Please list the amount of electricity

you generated in New Mexico and sold outside New Mexico

in each year since 1959.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 5.

Objected to. However, plaintiffs, without waiving their

objections, answer the question for the years 1970 through

1975 as the information is available.

24

Arizona Pustic Service

In year 1975 the amount generated in New Mexico and

sold outside by APS was 3,984,947 Mwh.

However, information is not available to make a direct

answer for years preceding 1975, for the following reasons:

A. There were sales of economy interchange energy by

APS to PSNM and EPE during these years.

B. These interchange sales are made hour-by-hour from

whatever generators may be available.

C. Hourly billing calculations are made automatically by

computer which provides the total amount sold and the

cost of generation. This is a composite mixture of power

from several different generators.

D. Due to prohibitive volumes of records, details of these

calculations were not recorded. Only the composite

totals were retained.

E. A portion of the electricity generated by APS in New

Mexico is included in these interchange sales to PSNM

and EPE. It is not known what the quantity of this por-

tion is.

F. The following tabulation shows the known quantities

and indicates where information is not available.

Year 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975

APS Generation Bey’ r

in N.M. Mwh 4,782,740 4,921,675 4,215,885 4,889,150 4,592,828 4,277,980

Less Portions

Sold in N.M.: Pe

NTUA Firm 98,552 142,016 199,961 211,596 244,476 253,622

Utah Mining 23,109 27,508 28661 29,891 34,603 38,841

PSNM Interchange ° . . . . 200

EPE Interchange ° ° ° ° ° 370

Remainder Sold ;

Outside N.M. ° © ° ° ° 3,984,947

® Indicates information not available.

‘4

re

25

Ext Paso Execrric

Generated by EPEC in New Mexico at

1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975

Four Corners 475,054 597,062 688,613 669,261 591,231 457,593

Rio Grande 596,199 561,139 968.465 1,045,608 1,024,211 1,102,932

Total Gen. in

N.M. by EPEC 1,071,253 1,158,201 1,657,078 1,714,869 1,615,442 1,560,525

- in New Mexico

ail 452,238 470,315 492,026 517,217 514,108 524,808

CPS (Almogordo) 78,553 81,246 © 93,813 101.953 106.532 105.317

Total Retail &

CPS in N.M. 530,791 551,561 585,839 619,170 620,640 630,125

Sold in New Mexico

Wholesale PNM —_O— 24,597 50,030 153,859 29,168 60

CPS (Lordsburg) -—O—~ -—0-— —o~ 1059 -—0O—- —o9-—

Total Wholesale

in N.M. —O-— 24,597 50,030 154,918 29,168 60

Total Generated

ts Outside

Mexico ® 540,461

61 582,044 1,021,210 940,782 965,634 930,340

* Includes ly electricity for Company’s customers in Texas, and for

International Export to Republic of Mexico; also included are amounts sold to

other utilities, delivered at Four Nw Mexico for ulti i

prone ogra ~ Corners, or ultimate consumption

—— a

| 27

96 :

SovuTHern Cauirornia Epison

Energy generated by SCE in New Mexico and sold outside

Sat River Prosect

1970—SRP Portion—Four Corners #4 and

#5 Generation 614,628,320 kwh | New Mexico:

Four Corners Unit Tripping Interchange Year MWH

to Arizona Public Service (‘‘APS’’) 3,755,000 | 1959 through

Four Corners Unit Tripping Interchange, | 1968 0

Over-schedule payback from APS = - 711,000 | 1969 474,144

- 3,044,000 kwh | 1970 3,249,643

1970 Net 611.584.320 kwh | 1971 4,098,885

1971—SPR—Four Corners #4 and #5 856,714,000 kwh | 1972 4,720,66~

Four Corners Unit Tripping Interchange | 1973 4,576,297

to APS — 50,000 kwh | 1974 4,054,820

1971 Net 856.664,000 kwh | 1975 3,134,110

——$———————————) :

1972—SRP—Four Corners #4 and #5 983,937,000 kwh |

Economy Energy to El Paso Electric — 400,000 kwh Tucson Gas & Execrric

1972 Net 983,537,000 kwh | Year 1970-1971 :1972,:1973 «1974 1975

1973—SRP—Four Corners #4 and #5 956,236,000 kwh Generated in N. M. 473,518 597,538 688,860 941,616 1,765,999 1,673,588

Interchange to: Sold to Utilities —o— 2,639 2,368 201,088 713,450 66,925

El Paso Electric 730,000 Sold to TGE

Public ervies ~ New Mexico 20,000 Customers 473,518 594,899 686,492 707,150 956,952 1,605,138

y= Flectric. : 640,000 Total Sales 473,518 597,538 688,860 908,238 1,670,402 1,672,063

Tucson Gas & Electric __ 40,000 oe are in MWH.

~ 1,430,000 kwh wee

1973 Net 954,806,000 kwh Interrogatory No. 6. Please list each power plant you

owned during the period from 1960 to the present, and for

= 4 and #5 845,355,000 kwh Log | - age

ee eS Elec A. 253,000 each plant please state where it is located, its capacity in

Sale to El Paso Electric 345,000 megawatts, when its was placed in service, whether it is

———~___ 598.000 kwh still in service, its actual output each year, the type of

lant (e.g., steam, or internal combustion, or hydroelectri

h p n, or hydroelectric,

1974 Net 944,757 000 kw etc.) and the kind of fuel it used.

1975—SRP—Four Corners #4 and #5 653,048,000 kwh

Sale to: —— 200,000 Answer to Interrogatory No. 6.

ectric ’ ;

Public Service of New Mexico 320,000 Objected to. However, as each of the plaintiffs in this

Tucson Gas & Electric 2,216,000 action are, or were at one time, participants in the Palo

— 2,736,000 kwh

1975 Net 650,312,000 kwh

28

Verde Nuclear Generating Station the information re-

quested in this interrogatory was gathered in a slightly

different form and supplied to answers to interrogatories

in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission proceedings regard-

ing PVNGS. That information is attached to these

answers for defendant’s use. However, plaintiffs do not

waive their objections to this interrogatory by volunteering

this information.

Interrogatory No. 7. Please identify each agreement un-

der which coal has been or is being purchased for burning

in the Four Corners Plant or the San Juan Plant. If you

wil! do so without a motion to produce, please attach a copy

of the agreement to your answers.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 7.

Objected to.

Interrogatory No. 8. Please identify any planning studies

or any other similar reports or documents prepared by you

or a consultant that deal in any way with the feasibility or

desirability of constructing the Four Corners Plant or the

San Juan Plant in New Mexico. If you will do so without a

motion to produce, please attach a copy of the document to

your answers.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 8.

Objected to.

Interrogatory No. 9. Please identify each person whom

you expect to call as a witness at the trial of this case and

state the subject matter upon which he or she is expected

to testify.

Answer to Interrogatory No. 9.

Fred O’Chesky

Einer Greve

Henry Sergeant

Ce en a ee Se

Martin Kuric

C. M. Perkins

Phoebe Fornaciari

Carl Turner

A. C. Maxwell

Stan Bizant

State or New Mexico i)

) 8s.

County or Santa Fe )

Bruce Norton, being first duly sworn, upon oath states

that he is one of the attorneys for plaintiffs in the above

entitled cause; that all of said plaintiffs maintain their of-

fices outside the State of New Mexico wherein this cause is

pending, and Affiant makes this verification on behalf of

each of said plaintiffs; that he has read and knows and

understands the matters and things stated in the foregoing

Answers to Defendant Bureau of Revenue’s Interrogatories

= . the same are true according to his information and

ief.

/s/ Bruce Norton

Bruce Norton

SusscriBep and sworn to before me this 14th day of Sep-

tember, 1976.

/s/ Dororny B. Lorz

Notary Public

My commission expires: 6-1-80.

I certify that I mailed a copy of the foregoing pleading

to opposing counsel of record on 9-14-76.

/s/ Ricuarp L. CarPenter

30

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW MEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ext Paso Evectric

Company, Sat River Prosect AcricuLTuRAL IMPROVEMENT

AND Power District, SovuTHEeRN CaLirornia Epison

Company, anp Tucson Gas & Evectric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’CHeskxzy, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureav or Revenve, anv State or New Mexico, Defendants.

Filed September 15, 1978

PiatntirFs’ Motion ror SuMMARY JUDGMENT

Comes now the plaintiffs, by and through their attorneys,

and, pursuant to Rule 56, N.M.R.C.P., move for summary

judgment in their favor on all issues raised by the Com-

plaint herein.

In support thereof, movants state that annexed hereto

and incorporated herein by reference are supporting affi-

davits, being Affidavit Nos. 1-7, inclusive, and that the

pleadings and answers to interrogatories on file, together

with the affidavits, show that there is no genuine issue as

to any material fact and that the movants are entitled to

judgment as a matter of law.

Wuereror:e, plaintiffs pray that the Court enter its order

rendering them summary judgment on the issues raised

by their Complaint.

Respectfully submitted,

Frank Anprews, III, Esa.

Montoomery, Feperici1, ANDREWs &

HanNaus

P. O. Box 2307

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

31

WituiaM C. Scuaas, Eso.

Ropyey, Dicxason, Stoan, Akin & Ross

P. O. Box 1888

Albuquerque, New Mexico 87103

BenJAMIN PHILLIPs, Esq.

Wurre, Kocu, Ketity & McCarry

P.O. Box 787

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Syett & WitMErR

3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073

/8/ By Bruce Norton, Eso.

Bruce Norton, Esq.

Bicsez, STEPHENSON, CARPENTER &

Crout

/s/ By Ricwarp N. Carpenter

Richard N. Carpenter, Esq.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

I certify That I mailed a copy of the foregoing pleading

to opposing counsel of record on 9/18/76

/s/ Ricuarp N. CarpenrTer

32

Affidavit of Henry B. Sargent, Jr.

(Affidavit No. 1 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ev Paso Execrric

Company, Sart River Prosect AGRICULTURAL IMPROVEMENT

anp Power District, SovurHERN CALIFORNIA Eptson .

Company, aNp Tucson Gas & Execraic Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frev O’Cueskey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or Revenve, aNp State or New Mexico, Defendants.

STATE OF ARIZONA )

) ss.

County of )

Henry B. Sarcent, Jr., being first duly sworn, upon his

oath, deposes and says:

1. That he is the Vice President and Treasurer of Ari-

zona Pusiic Service Company and as such he is authorized

to make this Affidavit, and that statements herein are made

upon his personal knowledge and belief.

2. The plaintiffs in this proceeding are Arizona Public

Service Company (APS), Tucson Gas & Electric Company

(TGE), Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (SRP), Southern California Edison Com-

pany (Edison), and El Paso Electric Company (EPE).

3. APS is an Arizona corporation with its principal of-

fice in Phoenix, Arizona, and as a public service corpora-

tion APS is regulated by the Arizona Corporation Com-

mission.

33

4. APS distributes electricity at retail in Arizona over

an area which encompasses approximately 50,335 square

miles and an estimated population of 1,065,000.

5. As of December 31, 1974, the aggregate generating

capability of APS’s facilities was 2,143.4 megawatts of rated

capacity, of which 812 megawatts of rated capacity or

37.9% is generated in New Mexico.

6. The Four Corners Power Plant is situated on lands

leased from the Navajo Tribe of Indians, wholly within

the Navajo Indian Reservation. Units 1, 2 and 3 of the Four

Corners Power Plant are owned entirely by APS. Units

4 and 5 of the Four Corners Power Plant are owned by the

following utilities as co-tenants with their undivided in-

terests set opposite their respective names:

Southern California Edison Company 48%

Arizona Public Service Company 15%

Public Service Company of New Mexico 13%

Salt River Project Agricultural

Improvement and Power District 10%

Tucson Gas and Electric Company 7%

El Paso Electric Company 7%

APS operates Units 4 and 5 as agent for the other co-

tenants. As defined in an Operating Agreement and a Co-

Tenancy Agreement among the co-owners, each co-tenant

is entitled to its respective percentage of the generating

capacity entitlement. Whenever any co-tenant directs the

generation of energy from either Unit, the other co-tenants

are required to operate same at minimum load. The co-

tenants share costs and expenses according to their re-

spective percentages as provided in these agreements.

34

7. For 1975, APS paid or became liable for the follow-

ing New Mexico taxes:

Apportioned

Corporate Ad Valorem Taxes

Income San Juan y Kinley

$54,506 $791,583 $ 1,373

Corporate Gross ;

Franchise Receipts Compensating Unemployment Excise

$25,720 $25,459" $225,539 $25,713" $87,814

(1) Applicable to energy supplied to Utah International, Inc.

for production of coal for Four Corners Power Plant. The

tax paid constitutes an operating expense chargeable to

co-owners in accordance with agreements.

(2) Applicable to purchase of property for Four Corners

Power Plant and chargeable to co-owners in accordance

with agreements.

(3) Applicable to payrolls at Four Corners Plant Station and

chargeable to co-owners in accordance with agreements.

Similar New Mexico tax liabilities apply for 1976 and are

reasonably expected for later years.

8. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission

Lines annexed to the Complaint and attached hereto as

Exhibit A, the APS electrical system is directly or indi-

rectly interconnected with the electrical system of each

other plaintiff in this cause, and either directly or indi-

rectly interconnected with the electrical systems of Public

Service Company of New Mexico (PNM), United States

Bureau of Reclamation (USBR), and Utah Power & Light

Company (Utah P&L). The interconnecting transmission

lines constitute an interstate grid encompassing the entire

western United States and portions of Canada and the

Republie of Mexico.

35

9. Deliveries of energy at the Four Corners and San

Juan Generating Stations are made through switchyard

facilities schematically represented on Exhibit B annexed

hereto. Transmission paths to the load centers of each

plaintiff are represented on Exhibit C. APS’ entitlement at

Four Corners (or energy purchased from others at Four

Corners) is transmitted to its load centers over transmis-

sion facilities owned by APS and USRR.

10. As a consequence of the system :nterconnections de-

scribed in Paragraph Eight, the demand for electricity in

the major urban centers served by plaintiffs in Arizona,

southern California, and the El Paso area of West Texas

determines in substantial degree the amount of electrical

energy generated at the plaintiffs’ generating stations lo-

cated in New Mexico (as well as those in other states). The

electrical energy generated in New Mexico in response to

such demand, to which each plaintiff is entitled according to

its respective ownership of the generation facilities, is

transformed and instantaneously transmitted at the speed

of light, along existing transmission lines to that plaintiff’s

service area.

11. Before it can be transmitted to market areas within

or without New Mexico, electrical energy generated in New

Mexico must be transformed as shown on Exhibit B and

allocated by switchyard facilities to the transmission lines

shown on Exhibit C, which serve particular markets. Be-

fore such transformation and allocation, the market in

which energy will be distributed cannot be identified.

Exhibit B. Exhibit B shows schematically the relation

between generation, transformation, and transmission at

the Four Corners and San Juan Generating Stations. At

Four Corners, energy is generated on Units 1, 2 and 3

(wholly-owned by APS) at 20 kilovolts and at 22 kv on

Units 4 and 5. After generation, the voltage of the energy

must be increased by transformers (shown as wavy lines

on Exhibit B) to the voltages required by the various trans-

36

mission lines. Transformers change voltage by electro-

magnetic induction, producing an induced current at

higher or lower voltage, which is then allocated to particu-

lar transmission lines through the switchyard facilities. At

Four Corners, energy generated on Unit 5 at 22 kv is trans-

formed to 500 kv for delivery at the bus tie to APS’ 500 kv

transmission line and thence to Edison’s service areas in

California; energy generated on Unit 4 at 22 kv is trans-

formed to 345 kv for delivery at the bus ties to APS’,

UPL’s, and PNM’s transmission lines; and energy gener-

ated on Units 1, 2 and 3 at 20 kv is transformed to 230 kv

for delivery at the bus tie to PNM’s and USBR’s trans-

mission lines and is again transformed to 345 kv for de-

livery through the 345 kv bus. The transformers between

bus bars shown on Exhibit B both “step up” and “step

down” the voltages of the energy, which “flows” in either

direction between buses at different times. No one generator

on the interconnected system serves a particular transmis-

sion line.

Exhibit C. Exhibit C shows schematically the transmis-

sion paths from New Mexico generating stations to rele-

vant markets. All energy delivered to APS at the 500 kv

Four Corners bus is transmitted to Edison’s service areas

in California; energy delivered to APS’ transmission lines

at the 345 kv Four Corners bus is transmitted to the APS

and TGE service areas in Arizona; and all energy deliv-

ered to TG&’s transmission line at the 345 kv San Juan

bus is transmitted to its service areas. Energy delivered to

PNM at the Four Corners 345 kv and 230 kv buses, or at

the San Juan 345 kv bus, is available both for transmission

to EPE’s kv line interconnected at PNM’s West Mesa

substation near Albuquerque, and for wholesale sale or re-

tail distribution to PNM’s New Mexico customers. En-

ergy delivered at the Four Corners 230 kv bus to the

USBR is available both for transmission of SRP’s entitle-

ment at Four Corners to its service areas in Arizona and

37

for delivery to rural cooperatives which transmit and dis-

tribute electricity in New Mexico.

12. In 1975, APS sold 254,087,410 kwh to the Navajo

Tribal Utility Authority (NTUA). Of this energy sold,

5,309,185 kwh or 2% was delivered at Indian Wells and

White Cane in Arizona and 248,778,227 kwh or 98% was

delivered in New Mexico.

13. Electrical energy required for operation of the Nav-

ajo mine which provides fuel for the Four Corners Power

Plant is sold to Utah International, Inc. by APS. The New

Mexico Electrical Energy Tax, as measured by energy sold

at retail to Utah International, Inc. is entirely offset by

the credit under § 9B. That is, APS’ 1975 electrical energy

tax liability of $15,536.40 upon sales of 30,841,000 kwh at

retail to Utah International, Inc. would be recouped by the

§$9B credit against APS’ 1975 New Mexico gross receipts

tax liability of $25,459.00.

14. The plaintiffs, as co-tenants of the Four Corners

Power Plant, have made agreements for economy and

emergency sales of energy. A “Six Party Economy Energy

Agreement” provides for voluntary sales of energy when

available energy of the interconnected systems can be pur-

chased more economically than employing additional gen-

erators on the buyer’s system, and “Principles of Inter-

connected Operation,” and a “Unit Tripping Agreement”

provide for emergency services as required by a co-tenant.

Also, APS has individual contracts with PNM providing

for purchases and sales of economy and emergency energy

and with TGE for purchase of contingent power and

energy from San Juan. The point of delivery for energy

supplied under those agreements is ordinarily agreed upon

between the parties. Where the switchyards at the Four

Corners Power Plant are the only points of interconnection

between the parties’ systems, deliveries are necessarily

made in New Mexico. All such sales of energy are whole-

sale sales in interstate commerce over which the Federal

38

Power Commission has exclusive jurisdiction (except in the

case of SRP which is not subject to such jurisdiction). The

agreements referred to above have been filed as tariffs with

the FPC on behalf of each of the plaintiffs, except SRP.

15. 1975 wholesale sales and transfers made by APS in

accordance with the agreements described in the preceding

paragraph, are set forth in the following table:

TGE SRP Edison PNM EPE

Delivered 795,000 —O— 59,385,000 1,785,000 3,445,000

Received 5,898,000 —O— 1,361,000 108,400,000 7,466,000

In 1975 APS delivered 253,621,603 kwh to the Navajo Tribal

Authority (NUTA), an enterprise of the Navajo Nation,

for distribution and resale on the Navajo Indian Reserva-

tion. During 1975 APS also delivered 6,670,000 kwh to, and

received 456,217,000 kwh from, Utah Power & Light Com-

pany.

The Electrical Energy Tax measured by the energy sold

at wholesale after July 1, 1975, is passed on by each plain-

tiff in whole or in part to the wholesale purchaser. Where

the eventual wholesale purchaser is a “person selling the

electricity for consumption in New Mexico”, §9C of the

Electrical Energy Tax Act requires the purchaser to re-

imburse the wholesaler for the amount of the credit ac-

corded the ultimate retailer by §9B, and §9C also

requires that such credit be assigned by the wholesaler to

its purchaser. Regulations issued under those provisions

require each generating wholesaler to assign a “potential

credit” equal to the Electrical Energy Tax to his wholesale

purchaser, who is entitled to an actual credit against the

gross receipts tax if the electrical energy is sold “for con-

sumption in New Mexico.”

16. On September 25, 1975, APS timely filed with de-

fendant a return (Form EE-1) showing that for July, 1975,

energy generated by APS in New Mexico was 417,874,000

kwh, and the amount due under the Electrical Energy Tax

39

for such period was $167,149.60. The amount of tax shown

on the returns was duly protested without payment in ac-

cordance with § 72-13-38 N.M.S.A., 1953. The tax for sub-

sequen’ months has been similarly returned and the unpaid

portion has been timely protested by APS.

17. APS is subject to the following Arizona taxes and

in 1975 paid or became liable for the amounts shown:

Corporate

Income Unemployment State Sales City Sales State Use

$1,515,687 $87,317 $12,315,992 $1,193,116 $769,502

City Use Ad Valorem City Franchise Excise and Other

$63,355 $35,762,052 $3,629,957 $779,760

TOTAL: $56,116,738

Similar liabilities apply for 1976 and are reasonably ex-

pected for later years.

Electrical energy generated in New Mexico. in respect of

which the Electrical Energy Tax is payable, is sold by

APS at retail to consumers in Arizona subject to the state

and city taxes shown above. There is no provision of Ari-

zona law under which APS is entitled to any credit, offset,

rebate or other form of recoupment for the Electrical

Energy Tax paid in respect of such energy.

/s/ Henry B. Sarcent, Jr.

Henry B. Sargent, Jr.

Susscrisep and Sworn to before me this 10th day of Sep-

tember, 1976.

/s/ Mary F. Trenspertu

Notary Public

My commission expires: Nov. 9, 1978.

40

Affidavit of Martin P. Kuric

(Affidavit No. 2 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ex Paso ELecrric

Company, Sact River Prosect AcRicuLTURAL IMPROVEMENT

anp Power District, SouTHERN CALIFORNIA Epison

Company, anp Tucson Gas & Exvectric Company, Plaintiff 3,

41

4. EPE distributes electricity at retail in south central

New Mexico and metropolitan E] Paso, over 10,000 square

miles and to an estimated population of 495,000.

5. The aggregate generating capability of EPE facili-

ties is 999 megawatts of rated capacity, of which 489 mega-

watts of rated capacity or 48.9% is generated in New

Mexico.

6. EPE owns and operates the Rio Grande Generating

Station near Anapra, New Mexico. The Four Corners

Power Plant Units 4 and 5 are owned by the plaintiffs as

co-tenants with EPE having a 7% undivided interest (112

megawatts).

7. For 1975, EPA paid or became liable for the following

New Mexico taxes:

vs.

Frep O’Cueskey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or Revenve, anv State or New Mexico, Defendants.

Ad Valorem Taxes

ones eo aes ss Otero Sierra Bernalillo Luna Valencia

County of El Paso ) ) $ 18,525.47 $12,711.23 $11,986.00 $1,936.18 $ 5,706.26

Martin P. Kuric, being first duly sworn, upon his oath, —_— Bishan

deposes and says: Income San Juan Socorro gation Dist. Dona Ana

1. That he is the Vice President of Ex Paso ELectric 9192.985.77 § 1097420 418,798.10 . aa ehemen

Company, and as such is authorized to make this oe ‘ ’ ms ’ , ,

on his persona orporate ross nem-

ae eo bape pel herein are made upon pe na A

Oo ; panne Rece

2. The plaintiffs in this proceeding are Arizona Public $ 12,441.55 $404,582.86 $35,796.40 $11,144.57

Service Company (APS), Tucson Gas & Electric Company (1) Applicable to energy supplied to Utah International, Ine. for produc-

(TGE), Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and tion of coal for Four Corners Power Plant. The tax paid constitutes an

Power District (SRP), Southern California Edison Com- —— expense chargeable to co-owners in accordance with agree-

pany (Edsion), and El Paso Electrie Company (EPE).

(2) Applicable to purchase of property for Four Corners Power Plant and

chargeable to co-owners in accordance with agreements.

(3) Applicable to payrolls at Four Corners Plant Section and chargeable

to co-owners in accordance with agreements,

3. EPE is a Texas corporation and is regulated as a pub-

lie utility in New Mexico by the Public Service Commission

and in Texas by the cities of El Paso, Van Horn, .Anthony

and Clint.

Similar New Mexico tax liabilities apply for 1976 and are

reasonably expected for later years.

42

8. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission Lines

annexed to the Complaint and attached hereto as Exhibit

A, the EPE electrical system is directly interconnec.ed with

the electrical system of each other plaintiff in this cause,

and either directly or indirectly interconnected with the

electrical systems of Public Service Company of New Mex-

ico (PNM), United States Bureau of Reclamation (USBR),

and Utah Power & Light Company (Utah P&L). The in-

terconnecting transmission lines constitute an interstate

grid encompassing the entire Western United States and

portions of Canada and the Republic of Mexico.

9. Deliveries of energy at the Four Corners and San

Juan Generating Stations are made through switchyard fa-

cilities schematically represented on Exhibit B annexed

hereto. Transmission paths to the load centers of each

plaintiff are represented on Exhibit C. EPE’s entitlement

at Four Corners is transmitted over PNM’s 345 kv lines

to its West Mesa Substation near Albuquerque, thence over

EPE’s 345 kv transmission lines to its service areas in

southern New Mexico and the El Paso Metropolitan area.

10. Before it can be transmitted to market areas within

or without New Mexico, electrical energy generated in New

Mexico must be transformed as shown on Exhibit B and

allocated by switchyard facilities to the transmission lines

shown on Exhibit C, which serve particular markets. Be-

fore such transformation and allocation, the market in which

energy will be distributed cannot be identified.

Exhibit B. Exhibit B shows schematically the relation

between generation, transformation, and transmission at

the Four Corners and San Juan Generating Stations. At

Four Corners, energy is generated at 22 kv on Units 4 and

5. At EPE’s Rio Grande Station, energy is generated at

14 kv. After generation, at these stations, the voltage of the

energy must be increased by transformers (shown as wavy

lines on Exhibit B) to the voltages required by the various

transmission lines. Transformers change voltage by electro-

43

magnetic induction, producing an induced current at higher

or lower voltage, which is then allocated to particular trans-

mission lines through the switchyard facilities. At Four

Corners, energy generated on Unit 4 at 22 kv is trans-

formed to 345 kv for delivery at the bus ties to APS’s and

PNM’s transmission lines; and energy generated on Units

1, 2 and 3 at 20 kv is transformed to 230 kv for delivery

at bes bus tie to een and USBR’s transmission lines

and is again transformed to 345 kv for delive

the 345 kv bus. The transformers between bus ies thee

on Exhibit B both “step up” and “step down” the voltages

of the energy, which “flows” in either direction between

buses at different times. No one generator on the intercon-

nected system serves a particular transmission line.

Exhibit C. Exhibit C shows schematically the transmis-

sion paths from New Mexico generating stations to rele-

vant markets. Energy delivered to PNM at the Four Cor-

ners 345 kv and 230 kv buses, or at the San Juan 345 kv

bus, is available both for transmission to EPE’s 345 kv

line interconnected at PNM’s West Mesa substation at

Albuquerque, and for wholesale sale or retail distribution

to PNM’s New Mexico customers.

11. EPE distributes electricity as a public utility at

retail in New Mexico, serving an area in south central New

Mexico. The Electrical Energy Tax measured by electricity

sold by EPE at retail in New Mexico will be fully offset by

gross receipts tax credits under §9B of the Electrical

Energy Tax Act (the Act), while the tax measured by

electricity transmitted to EPE’s service area in Texas and

to the U.S.-Mexican border for export will not be offset by

and credit.

12. The plaintiffs, as co-tenants of the Four Corners

Power Plant, have made agreements for economy and emer-

gency sales of energy. A “Six Party Economy Energy

Agreement”’ provides for voluntary sales of energy when

available energy of the interconnected systems can be pur-

44

chased more economically than employing additional gen-

erators on the buyer’s system, and “Principles of Inter-

connected Operation”, and a “Unit Tripping Agreement”

provide for emergency services as required by a co-tenant.

The point of delivery for energy supplies under those agree-

ments is ordinarily agreed upon between the parties.

Where the switchyards at the Four Corners Power Plant

are the only points of interconnection between the parties’

systems, deliveries are necessarily made in New Mexico.

All such sales of energy are wholesale sales in interstate

commerce over which the Federal Power Commission has

exclusive jurisdiction (except in the case of SRP which is

not subject to such jurisdiction). The agreements referred

to above have been filed as tariffs with the FPC on behalf

of each of the plaintiffs, except SRP.

13. 1975 wholesale sales and transfers made by EPE

in 1974 to plaintiffs in accordance with the agreements de-

scribed in the preceding paragraph, are set forth in the

following table:

APS TGE SRP Edison PNM

Delivered 6,524,000 2,207,000 18,766,000 —0O— 60,000

Received 2,710,000 —0— 200,000 —O— 20,858,000

The Electrical Energy Tax measured by the energy sold

at wholesale after July 1, 1975, is passed on by each plain-

tiff in whole or in part to the wholesaler purchaser. Where

the eventual wholesale purchaser is a “person selling the

electricity for consumption in New Mexico”, § 9C of the Act

requires the purchaser to reimburse the wholesaler for the

amount of the credit accorded the ultimate retailer by

§9B, and §9C also requires that such credit be assigned

by the wholesaler to its purchaser. Regulations issued un-

der those provisions required each generating wholesaler to

assign a “potential credit” equal 40 the Electrical Energy

T'ax to his wholesale purchaser, who is entitled to an actual

45

credit against the gross receipts tax if the electrical energy

is sold “for consumption in New Mexico.”

14. On September 25, 1975, EPE timely filed with de-

fendant a return (Form EE-1) showing that for July,

1975, energy generated by EPE in New Mexico was

155,314,000 kwh, and the amount due under the Electrical

Energy Tax for such period was $62,126.00. Because EPE

is entitled to recover the Electrical Energy Tax on energy

sold by it to New Mexico consumers by credit under § 9B

of the Act, since 60,593,248 kwh of EPE’s energy generated

in New Mexico was consumed in New Mexico, EPE paid

$24,237.30 of the total tax, leaving an unpaid balance of

$37,806.70. That balance was duly protested by EPE with-

out payment in accordance with § 72-13-38 N.M.S.A., 1953.

The tax for subsequent months has been similarly returned

and the unpaid portion has been timely protested by EPE.

15. EPE is subject to the following Texas and municipal

taxes and in 1975 became liable for the amounts shown

below:

State Ad Valorem $ 750,191.53

City Ad Valorem 1,138,272.23

City Occupation 893,888.44

Gross Receipts 1,139,942.88

Compensating 24,464.66

Corporate Franchise 135,694.00

Unemployment 2,208.37

Similar liabilities apply for 1976 and are reasonably ex-

pected for later years.

Electrical energy generated in New Mexico in respect of

which the Electrical Energy Tax is payable, is sold by EPE

at retail to consumers in Texas, subject to the gross re-

ceipts taxes shown above. There is no provision of Texas

46

law under which EPE is entitled to any credit, offset, re-

bate or other form of recoupment for the Electrical Energy

Tax paid in respect of such energy.

16. The practical application of the Electrical Energy is

illustrated by the following information showing its impact

upon EPE. The figures shown are based upon the actual

experiences of EPE for July 1, 1975 (the effective date of

the Electrical Energy Tax) through March, 1976.

47

Ex Paso Exvecrric Company

New Mexico Execrricat Enercy Tax

ANaLysis or System Input

Juty, 1975 Turu Marcu, 1976

SOURCE OF INPUT MWH

GENERATION IN NEW MEXICO

By El Paso Electric Company

At Four Corners 437,701.000

At Rio Grande 762,053.000

Total Generation in New Mexico

By El Paso Electric Company

GENERATION IN NEW MEXICO

By Other Utilities and Purchased

By El Paso Electric Company

PNM 11,552.000

CPS 9,645.000

Total Generation in New Mexico

By Others

Total Generation in New Mexico

GENERATION ELSEWHERE

By El Paso Electric Company

in Texas 1,397,477.000

By Other Utilities and Purchased

by El Paso Electric Company

PNM 5,043.000

UPL 11,790.009

APS 315.000

SRP 200.000

Total Generation Elsewhere

TOTAL SYSTEM INPUT

Schedule 1

1,199,754.000

21,197.000

1,220,951.000

1,414,825.000

2,635,776.000

48

Et Paso Etectric CoMPANY

New Mexico Evecrrica, Enercy Tax

Awnatysis or System SALes

Juxy, 1975 Turu Marcu, 1976

Schedule 2

MWH

GENERATED AND SOLD IN NEW MEXICO

To El Paso Electrie Co. Retail Customers 394,743.728

TO WHOLESALE CUSTOMERS

PNM 4,339.000

APS 6,037.000

CPS 80,540.000

RG CO-OP (DELL CITY,N.M.) 3,196.439

TGE 270.000

SRP 550.000

TOTAL GENERATED BUT SOLD IN NEW

MEXICO TO WHOLESALE CUSTOMERS 92,932.439

NOT GENERATED BUT SOLD IN

NEW MEXICO TO EL PASO ELECTRIC

CO. RETAIL CUSTOMERS 4,755.074

TO WHOLESALE CUSTOMERS

PNM 200.000

SRP 250.000

APS 857.000

TOTAL NOT GENERATED BUT

SOLD IN NEW MEXICO TO

WHOLESALE CUSTOMERS 1,307.000

TOTAL SALES IN NEW MEXICO 495,738.241

SOLD IN TEXAS

TO EL PASO ELECTRIC CoO.

RETAIL CUSTOMERS 1,709,272.075

TO WHOLESALE CUSTOMERS

RG CO-OP—Dell City, Texas 20,371.561

RG CO-OP—Van Horn 6,304.800

TOTAL WHOLESALE SOLD IN TEXAS 26,676.361

TOTAL SALES IN TEXAS 1,735,948.436

SOLD AT INTERNATIONAL BORDER

(MEXICO) 240,840.000

TOTAL MWH SALES

2,472,526.677

———_—_—_—_—_—_—_—

LINE

NO.

Ww bo

49

Ex Paso Extectrric Company

New Mexico Exectrica, Enerecy Tax

ELectricaL Enercy Taxes Borne

By Ex Paso Exectrric Company

MWH

Schedule 3

Generation

Tax

TAX BASED ON EL PASO ELECTRIC

COMPANY GENERATION

Total Generation by El] Paso

Electric Company in New

Mexico 1,199,754.000

TAX BASED ON GENERA-

TION BY OTHER UTILITIES;

CREDIT ASSIGNED TO EL

PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY;

EL PASO ELECTRIC COM-

PANY TO REIMBURSE

ASSIGNOR

Assignor

PNM *11,552.000

CPS 9,645.000

Total Electrical Taxes Borne

By El Paso Electric Company 1,220,951.000

Gen. Tax

MWH at .4 Mills

$2,184.40

630.000 252.00

11,552.000 $2,436.40

$479,901.60

2,436.40

3,858.00

$486,196.00

Elsewhere

(Tex.,

Recovered

Credit

Assigned

To

RECOVERY

Credit To

El Paso

Electric

Energy

Tax at

0.4 Mills

Generation

SaLes GENERATED AND So_p IN New

Sales

LINE

No.

50

Schedule 4 51

Ex. Vaso Evectric Company

New Mexico Execrricat Eneroy Tax (: For the period from July, 1975 through March, 1976,

Recovery or Taxes Borne By Ext Paso Evecrric COMPANY the Electrical Energy Tax applicable to EPE is meas-

Juuy, 1975 Turu Marca, 1976 ured by the energy generated by EPE in New Mexico,

1,199,754.000 MWH (Schedule 1, Line 3), plus the energy

| purchased at wholesale from other plaintiffs, 21,197.00

MWH (Schedule 1, Line 6). The total generation in New

Mexico totals 1,220,951.000 MWH (Schedule 1, Line 7). The

tax is $.40 per MWH which amounts to $486,196.00 (Sched-

dule 3, Line 4). Of that amount, $204,411.80 (Schedule 4,

Line 16, Columns D and B), is offset by credits under § 9B

or by reimbursements under §9C, and the balance of

$281,784.20 (Schedule 4, Line 16, Column E) is payable by

EPE.

17. Ex Paso Exvectric Company is in direct competition

with intrastate New Mexico utilities. This competitive sit-

uation arises in three areas:

1,187.60

4

Ete.)

Cot. F

$280,432.60

$486,196.00 $166,597.32 $37,814.48 $281,784.20

ee

1,512.20

1,227.20

33,504.64

Other

Cou. E

223.40

=

Cot. D

394,743.728 421,395.799 $166,373.92 $166,373.92 $

(1) in the serving of other utilities at wholesale rates;

1,735.60

2,414.80

108.00

220.00

33,504.64

1,406.44

a

(2) in the serving of large industrial loads where

the industry has the option of locating in either an El Paso

area of service or that of another utility; and

$280,432.60

Cot. C

(3) in the serving of large governmental and indus-

trial loads which are to be located in uncertified areas for

which any New Mexico utility can compete.

| /s/ Martin P. Kuric

Martin P. Kuric

270.000

550.000

5,043.000 — O—

200.000 0

250.000 -- 0—

857.000

4,339.000

6,037.000

Cou. B

3,516.085

270.000

550.000

200.000

250.000

857.000

Torau Sates IN New MExico

Cou. A

By Ext Paso E.tectric CoMPANY

4,339.000

6,037.000

80,540.000 83,761.600

3,196.439

4,755.074

| Susscrisep anp Sworn to before me this 10th day of Sep-

| tember, 1976.

495,738.241 526,219.484 $205,763.40 $166,597.32 $37,81448 $ 1,351.60

Sates OrHer THAN New MExIco

13 Texas (Retail &

1,735,948.436

14 Republic of Mexico 240,840.000

1,976,788.436

16 GRAND TOTAL = 2,472,526.677

/s/ CHartes Mais

Notary Public

My commission expires:

Mexico sy Ex Paso Etectric Co.

Mexico sy Ex Paso Extectric Co.

8 Retail Sales

Cuar.es Mats, Notary Public

In and for the County of El Paso, Texas.

SaLes Not Generatep But Sop IN

Wholesale Sales

9 PNM

TOTAL SALES

OTHER THAN

15 NEW MEXICO

10 SRP

11 APS

Wholesale Sales

2 PNM

3 APS

4 CPS

City, N.M.)

6 TGE

7 SRP

Wholesale)

1 Retail Sales

5 RG CO-OP (Dell

52

Affidavit of C. M. Perkins

(Affidavit No. 3 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ext Paso Exectric

Company, Sat River Prosect AGRICULTURAL IMPROVEMENT

AND Power District, SourHERN CaLirornia Epison

Company, anD Tucson Gas & Evectric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or REVENUE, AND State or New Mexico, Defendants.

STaTE OF ARIZONA )

) ss

County of )

C. M. Perks, being first duly sworn, upon his oath, de-

poses and says:

1. That he is the Director of Project Planning of Sait

River Prosect AGRICULTURAL IMPROVEMENT AND Power Dis-

rrict, and as such he is authorized to make this Affidavit,

and that statements herein are made upon his personal

knowledge and belief.

2. The plaintiffs in this proceeding are Arizona Public

Service Company (APS), Tucson Gas & Electric Company

(TGE), Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (SRP), Southern California Edison Com-

pany (Edison), and El Paso Electric Company (EPE).

3. Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District is a political subdivision of the State of

Arizona operating a federal reclamation project pursuant

to contracts with the Secretary of the Interior. SRP

53

distributes electricity at retail in Central Arizona, includ-

ing metropolitan Phoenix, an area which encompasses ap-

proximately 2,900 square miles and an estimated population

of 675,000. SRP also distributes electricity at wholesale to

Pinal and Gila Counties, an area of approximately 2,400

square miles.

4. The 1975 aggregate generating capability of SRP’s

facilities is 2,197 megawatts of rated capacity, of which

160 megawatts of rated capacity or 7.3% is generated in

New Mexico.

5. The Four Corners Power Plant Units 4 and 5 are

owned by the plaintiffs as co-tenants with SRP having a

10% undivided interest.

6. For 1975, SRP paid or became liable for the follow-

ing New Mexico taxes for San Juan County: $111,158.00.

Similar New Mexico tax liabilities apply for 1976 and are

reasonably expected for later years.

7. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission

Lines annexed to the Complaint and attached hereto as Ex-

hibit A, the SRP electrical system is directly interconnected

with the electrical system of each other plaintiff in this

cause, and either directly or indirectly interconnected with

the electrical systems of Public Service Company of New

Mexico (PNM), United States Bureau of Reclamation

(USBR), and Utah Power & Light Company (Utah P&L).

The interconnecting transmission lines constitute an inter-

state grid encompassing the entire Western United States

and portions of Canada and the Republic of Mexico.

8. Deliveries of energy at Four Corners and San Juan

Generating Stations are made through switchyard facili-

ties represented on Exhibit B annexed hereto. A por-

tion of SRP’s entitlement at Four Corners is delivered to

its load centers via U.S. Bureau of Reclamation (USBR)

transmission lines through Shiprock and Flagstaff ; the bal-

54

ance is exchanged with USBR for other energy delivered

in Arizona.

9. Before it can be transmitted to market areas within

or without New Mexico, electrical energy generated in New

Mexico must be transformed as shown on Exhibit B and

allocated by switchyard facilities to the transmission lines

shown on Exhibit C, which serve particular markets. Be-

fore such transformation and allocation, the market in

which energy will be distributed cannot be identified.

Exhibit B. Exhibit B shows schematically the relation

between generation, transformation, and transmission at

the Four Corners and San Juan Generating Stations. At

Four Corners energy is generated at 22 kv on Units 4 and

5. After generation, the voltage of the energy must be in-

creased by transformers (shown as wavy lines on Exhibit

B) to the voltages required by the various transmission

lines. Trmmsfesmers change voltage by electromagnetic in-

duction, preducing an induced current at higher or lower

voltage, which is then allocated to particular transmission

lines through the switchyard facilities. At Four Corners,

energy generated on Unit 4 at 22 kv is transformed to 345

kv for delivery at the bus ties to APS’ and PNM’s transmis-

sion lines; and energy generated on Units 1, 2 and 3 at 20

kv is transformed to 230 kv for delivery at the bus tie to

PNM’s and USBR’s transmission lines and is again trans-

formed to 345 kv for delivery through the 345 kv bus. The

55

Arizona and for delivery to rural cooperatives which trans-

mit and distribute electricity in New Mexico.

10. The plaintiffs, as co-tenants of the Four Corners

Power Plant, have made agreements for economy and emer-

gency sales of energy. A “Six Party Economy Energy

Agreement” provides for voluntary sales of energy when

available energy of the interconnected systems can be pur-

chased more economically than employing additional gen-

erators on the buyer’s system, and “Principles of Intercon-

nected Operation”, and a “Unit Tripping Agreement” pro-

vide for emergency services as required by a co-tenant. The

point of delivery for energy supplies under those agree-

ments is ordinarily agreed upon between the parties. Where

the switchyards at the Four Corners Power Plant are the

only points of interconnection between the parties’ sys-

tems, deliveries are necessarily made in New Mexico. All

such sales of energy are wholesale sales in interstate com-

merce over which the Federal Power Commission has ex-

clusive jurisdiction (except in the case of SRP which is not

subject to such jurisdiction). The agreements referred to

above have been filed as tariffs with the FPC on behalf of

each of the plaintiffs, except SRP.

11. 1975 wholesale sales and transfers made by SRP in

accordance with the agreements described in the preceding

paragraph, are set forth in the following tables:

nap Other New

transformers between bus bars shown on Exhibit B both + acho

“step up” and “step down” the voltages of the energy, APS TGE Edison PNM EPE Utilities

which “flows” in either direction between buses at different

times. No one generator on the interconnected system

serves a particular transmission line.

Delivered —O— 2,216,000 —O— 320,000 200,000 —0—

Received —O— 1,145,000 -—O— 94,735,000 18,766,000 32,689,000

Exhibit C. Exhibit C shows schematically the transmis-

sion paths from New Mexico generating stations to rele-

vant markets. Energy delivered at the Four Corners 230

kv bus to the USBR is available both for transmission of

SRP’s entitlement at Four Corners to its service areas in

The Electrical Energy Tax measured by the energy sold

at wholesale after July 1, 1975, is passed on by each plain-

tiff in whole or in part to the wholesale purchaser. Where

the eventual wholesale purchaser is a “person selling the

electricity for consumption in New Mexico”, §9C of the

Electrical Energy Tax Act requires the purchaser to reim-

56

burse the wholesaler for the amount of the credit accorded

the ultimate retailer by § 9B, and §9C also requires that

such credit be assigned by the wholesaler to its purchaser.

Regulations issued under those provisions required each

generating wholesaler to assign a “potential credit” equal

to the Electrical Energy Tax to his wholesale purchaser,

who is entitled to an actual credit against the gross receipts

tax if the electrical energy is sold “for consumption in New

Mexico.”

12. On September 25, 1975, SRP timely filed with de-

fendant a return (Form EE-1) showing that for July, 1975,

energy generated by SRP in New Mexico was 48,145,000

kwh, and the amount due under the Electrical Energy Tax

for such period was $19,258.00. The amount of tax shown

on the returns was duly protested without payment in ac-

cordance with § 72-13-38 N.M.S.A., 1953. The tax for subse-

quent months has been similarly returned and the unpaid

portion has been timely protested by SRP.

13. SRP is subject to the following Arizona taxes and in

1975 became liable for the amounts shown:

Corporate

Income Unemployment StateSales City Sales State Use

[Exempt] $3,135 $6,943,943 $2,357,498 $1,446,091

City Use AdValorem City Franchise Excise and Other

$9,610 $16,621,310° None $104,536

TOTAL: $27,486,123

* Voluntary payments

Similar liabilities apply for 1976 and are reasonably ex-

pected for later years.

Electrical energy generated in New Mexico, in respect to

which the Electrical Energy Tax is payable, is sold by SRP

at retail to consumers in Arizona subject to the state and

city taxes shown above. There is no provision of Arizona

57

law under which SRP is entitled to any credit, offset, rebate

or other form of recoupment for the Electrical Energy Tax

paid in respect to such energy.

/s/ ILLEGIBLE

SUBSCRIBED AND Sworn to before me this 13th day of Sep-

tember, 1976.

/s/ ILLEGIBLE

My commission expires: May 3, 1979

58

Affidavit of A. L. Maxwell

(Affidavit No. 4 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ext Paso Execrric

Company, SaLt River Prosect AcricuLTURAL IMPROVEMENT

AND Power District, SouTHERN CaLirorN1a Epson

Company, aND Tucson Gas & Exectric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cueskey, Commissioner of Revenue,

s

Bureau oF RevenvE, anp State or New Mexico, Defendants.

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )

) ss.

County of Los Angeles )

A. L. Maxwe.., being first duly sworn, upon his oath, de-

poses and says:

1. That he is a Vice President of SourHerRN CaLiFoRNIA

Epison Company, and as such he is authorized to make this

Affidavit, and that statements herein are made upon his per-

sonal knowledge and belief.

2. The plaintiffs in this proceeding are Arizona Public

Service Company (APS), Tucson Gas & Electric Company

(TGE), Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (SRP), Southern California Edison Com-

pany (Edison), and El] Paso Electric Company (EPE).

3. Edison is a California corporation with its principal

office in Rosemead, California, and it is regulated as a public

utility by the California Public Utility Commission.

4. Edison distributes electricity at retail in Central

and Southern California outside Los Angeles and certain

59

other cities, an area which encompasses approximately

50,000 square miles and an estimated population of

7,560,000.

5. The aggregate generating capability of Edison’s facil-

ities is 13,699 megawatts of rated capacity, of which 768

megawatts of rated capacity or 5.6% is generated in New

Mexico.

6. The Four Corners Power Plant Units 4 and 5 are

owned by the plaintiffs as co-tenants with Edison having a

48% undivided interest.

7. For 1975, Edison paid or became liable for the follow-

ing New Mexico taxes:

Apportioned

Corporate Corporate

Income L. San Juan Franchise

$8,976 $538,763 $10

Similar New Mexico tax liabilities apply for 1976 and are

reasonably expected for later years.

8. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission Lines

annexed to the Complaint and attached hereto as Exhibit

A, the Edison electrical system is directly interconnected

with the electrical system of each other plaintiff in this

cause, and either directly or indirectly interconnected with

the electrical systems of Public Service Company of New

Mexico (PSM), United States Bureau of Reclamation

(USBR), and Utah Power & Light Company (Utah P&L).

Edison’s system is also directly connected with San Diego

Gas & Electric Company, the Department of Water and

Power, City of Los Angeles, the Pasadena Department of

Water and Power, and Pacific Gas & Electric Company;

its system is indirectly but substantially interconnected with

the several Pacific Northwest systems and through them to

other utility systems in the western United States. The in-

terconnecting transmission lines constitute an interstate

60

grid encompassing the entire western United States and

portions of Canada and the Republic of Mexico.

9. Deliveries of energy at the Four Corners and San

Juan Generating Stations are made through switchyard

facilities represented on Exhibit B annexed hereto. Edison’s

entitlement at Four Corners is transmitted to its Eldorado

Substation in Nevada over APS’ 500 kv transmission line

to the Arizona line and Edison’s 500 kv line thence to such

Substation.

10. Before it can be transmitted to market areas within

or without New Mexico, electrical energy generated in New

Mexico must be transformed as shown on Exhibit B and

allocated by switchyard facilities to the transmission lines

shown on Exhibit C, which serve particular markets. Be-

fore such transformation and aliocation, the markets in

which energy will be distributed cannot be identified.

Exhibit B. Exhibit B shows schematically the relation be-

tween generation, transformation, and transmission at the

Four Corners and San Juan Generating Stations. At Four

Corners energy is generated at 22 kv on Units 4 and 5.

After generation the voltage of the energy must be in-

creased by transformers (shown as wavy lines on Exhibit

B) to the voltages required by the various transmission

lines. Transformers change voltage by electromagnetic in-

duction, producing an induced current at higher or lower

voltage, which is then allocated to particular transmission

lines through the switchyard facilities. At Four Corners,

energy generated on Unit 5 at 22 kv is transformed

to 500 kv for delivery at the bus tie to APS’ 500 kv trans-

mission line and thence to Edison’s service areas in Cali-

fornia. The transformers between bus bars shown on Ex-

hibit B both “step up” and “step down” the voltages of the

energy, which “flows” in either direction between buses at

different times. No one generator on the interconnected

system serves a particular transmission line.

61

Exhibit C. Exhibit C shows schematically the transmis-

sion paths from New Mexico generating stations to rele-

vant markets. All energy delivered to APS at the 500 kv

Four Corners bus is transmitted to Edison’s service areas in

California.

11. The plaintiffs, as co-tenants of the Four Corners

Power Plant, have made agreements for economy and

emergency sales of energy. A “Six Party Economy Energy

Agreement” provides for voluntary sales of energy when

available energy of the interconnected systems can be pur-

chased more economically than employing additional gen-

erators on the buyer’s system, and “Principles of Intercon-

nected Operation”, and a “Unit Tripping Agreement” pro-

vide for emergency services as required by a co-tenant. The

point of delivery for energy supplies under those agree-

ments is ordinarily agreed upon between the parties.

Where the switchyards at the Four Corners Power Plant

are the only points of interconnection between the parties’

systems, deliveries are necessarily made in New Mexico.

All such sales of energy are wholesale sales in interstate

commerce over which the Federal Power Commission has

exclusive jurisdiction (except in the case of SRP which is

not subject to such jurisdiction). The agreements referred

to above have been filed as tariffs with the FPC on behalf

of each of the plaintiffs, except SRP.

12. 1975 wholesale sales and transfers made by Edison

to plaintiffs in accordance with the agreements described in

the preceding paragraph, are set forth in the following

table:

APS TGE SRP PNM EPE

Delivered 11,513,000 800,000 —0O—- —0— 3,050,000

Received 36,272,000 1,238,000 -—-O— 12,449,000 2,012,000

The Electrical Energy Tax measured by the energy sold

at wholesale after July 1, 1975, is passed on by each plain-

tiff in whole or in part to the wholesale purchaser. Where

62

the eventual wholesale purchaser is a “person selling the

electricity for consumption in New Mexico”, §9C of the

Electrical Energy Tax Act requires the purchaser to re-

imburse the wholesaler for the amount of the credit ac-

corded the ultimate retailer by § 9B, and § 9C also requires

that such credit be assigned by the wholesaler to its pur-

chaser. Regulations issued under those provisions require

each generating wholesaler to assign a “potential credit”

equal to the Electrical Energy Tax to his wholesale pur-

chaser, who is entitled to an actual credit against the gross

receipts tax if the electrical energy is sold “for consump-

tion in New Mexico.”

13. On September 25, 1975, Edison timely filed with

defendant a return (Form EE-1) showing that for July,

1975, energy generated by Edison in New Mexico was

231,003,000 kwh, and the amount due under the Electrical

Energy Tax for such period was $92,401.20. The amount of

tax shown on the returns was duly protested without pay-

ment in accordance with § 72-13-38 N.M.S.A., 1953. The Tax

for subsequent months has been similarly returned and the

unpaid portion has been timely protested by Edison.

14. Edison is subject to the following Arizona taxes and

in 1975 became liable for the amounts shown below:

Corporate

Income Unemployment StateSales CitySales State Use

$9,173 $78 —0— —0— $55

City Use AdValorem City Franchise Excise and Other

—o0— $329,481 —0— —_0—

TOTAL: $338,787

Similar liabilities were incurred during 1976 and are rea-

sonably expected for later years.

There is no provision of Arizona law under which Edi-

son is entitled to any credit, offset, rebate or other form of

63

recoupment for the Electrical Energy Tax paid in respect

of such energy.

15. Edison is subject to the following California taxes

and in 1975 paid the amounts shown:

Franchise Requirements $ 11,850,291

Corporate Income 12,461,716

Unemployment 1,113,281

Use 3,712,821

Ad Valorem 84,602,841

Excise (gasoline, etc.) 420,000

Utility Users—Cities 16,100,000

TOTAL $130,260,950

(1) 22 chartered cities in Edison’s service territory impose

taxes on consumers of electricity ranging from 3% to 8%

of Edison’s bills for electric service. Edison collects the

tax without charge for the benefit of the cities. The Cali-

fornia Sales and Use Tax Law, Revenue and Taxation

Code § 6353, exempts Edison from the state sales tax,

sales of gas, electricity, and water.

Similar tax liabilities are reasonably expected for later

years. In addition, Edison has begun collection of a state

tax on consumers of electricity at the rate of 1/10 of one

mill per kilowatt hour. That tax will total approximately

$4 million in 1975.

Electrical energy generated in New Mexico, in respect of

which the Electrical Energy Tax is payable, is sold by

Edison at retail to consumers in California subject to state

and municipal taxes as shown above. There is no provision

of California law under which Edison is entitled to any

credit, offset, rebate, or other form or recoupment for the

Electrical Energy Tax paid in respect of such energy.

/s/ A. L. Maxweuui

64

SuBscriBED AND Sworn to before me this 9th day of Septem-

ber, 1976.

/s/ Dona Mary Witcoms

Notary Public

My commission expires June 18, 1977.

65

Affidavit of Kenneth L. Saul

(Affidavit No. 5 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ex Paso Evecrric

Company, SaLt River Prosyect AGRicuLTURAL IMPROVEMENT

AND Power District, SourHERN CaLirornia Epison

Company, anD Tucson Gas & Exectric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’CueEskey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or REVENUE, AND State oF New Mexico, Defendants.

State or Arizona )

) ss.

County or Pima _)

Kennetu L. Saut, being first duly sworn, upon his oath,

deposes and says:

1. That he is the Vice President and Controller of Tuc-

son Gas & Evecrric Company, and as such he is authorized

to make this Affidavit, and that statements herein are made

upon his personal knowledge and belief.

2. The plaintiffs in this proceeding are Arizona Public

Service Company (APS), Tucson Gas & Electric Company

(TGE), Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (SRP), Southern California Edison Com-

pany (Edison), and El Paso Electric Company (EPE).

3. TGE is an Arizona corporation with its principal of-

fice in Tucson, Arizona, and as a public service corporation

TGE is regulated by the Arizona Corporation Commission.

4. TGE distributes electricity at retail in the greater

metropolitan Tucson and Fort Huachuca areas, a certifi-

66

cated service area which encompasses approximately 1,155

square miles and an estimated population of 440,000.

5. The aggregate generating capability of TGE’s facili-

ties is 1,192 megawatts of rated capacity, of which 277

megawatts of rated capacity or 23.2% is generated in New

Mexico.

6. TGE and Public Service Company of New Mexico

(PNM) are equal co-owners of the San Juan Generating

Station, of which generating Unit 2 is presently in opera-

tion. The Four Corners Power Plant Units 4 and 5 are

owned by the plaintiffs as co-tenants with TGE having a

7% undivided interest.

7. For 1975, TGE paid or became liable for the following

New Mexico taxes:

Apportioned Ad Valorem

Corporate Taxes

Income San Juan McKinley Valencia Catron

$39,000 (Est) $475,182 $181,889 $35,288 $104,084

Corporate Compen-

Franchise sating Excise

$10 $48,427 $31

TOTAL: $883,911

Similar New Mexico tax liabilities apply for 1976 and are

reasonably expected for later years.

8. As shown on the Map of Principal Transmission Lines

annexed to the Complaint and attached hereto as Exhibit

A, the TGE electrical system is directly interconnected with

the electrical system of each other plaintiff in this cause,

and either directly or indirectly interconnected with the

electrical systems of Public Service Company of New Mex-

ico (PNM), United States Bureau of Reclamation (USBR),

and Utah Power & Light Company (Utah P&L). The inter-

67

connecting transmission lines constitute an interstate grid

encompassing the entire Western United States and por-

tions of Canada and the Republic of Mexico.

9. Deliveries of energy at the Four Corners and San

Juan Generating Stations are made through switchyard

facilities represented on Exhibit B annexed hereto. Trans-

mission paths to the load centers of each plaintiff are

represented on Exhibit C. APS’ and TGE’s entitlements

at Four Corners (or energy purchased from others at Four

Corners) and TGE’s share of power and energy generated

at San Juan are transmitted to their respective load cen-

ters over transmission facilities owned by APS and TGE.

10. Before it can be transmitted to market areas within

or without New Mexico, electrical energy generated in New

Mexico must be transformed as shown on Exhibit B and

allocated by switchyard facilities to the transmission lines

shown on Exhibit C, which serve particular markets. Before

such transformation and allocation, the me ket in which

energy will be distributed cannot be identitied.

Exhibit B. Exhibit B shows schematically the relation

between generation, transformation, and transmission at

the Four Corners and San Juan Generating Stations. At

San Juan, energy is generated at 24 kv, and after genera-

tion the voltage of the energy must be increased by trans-

formers (shown as wavy lines on Exhibit B) to the voltages

required by the various transmission lines. Transformers

change voltage by electromagnetic induction, producing an

induced current at higher or lower voltage, which is then

allocated to particular transmission lines through the

switchyard facilities. The transformers between bus bars

shown on Exhibit B both ‘‘step up’’ and ‘‘step down’’ the

voltages of the energy, which ‘‘flows’’ in either direction

between buses at different times. No one generator on the

interconnected system serves a particular transmission line.

Exhibit C. Exhibit C shows schematically the transmis-

sion paths from New Mexico generating stations to rele-

vant markets. Energy delivered to APS’ transmission lines

68

at the 345 kv Four Corners bus is transmitted to the APS

and TGE service areas in Arizona; and all energy delivered

to TGE’s transmission line at the 345 kv San Juan bus is

transmitted to its service areas.

11. The plaintiffs, as co-tenants of the Four Corners

Power Plant, have made agreements for economy and

emergency sales of energy. A ‘‘Six Party Economy Energy

Agreement” provides for voluntary sales of energy

when available energy of the interconnected systems can

be purchased more economically than employing additional

generators on the buyer’s system, and ‘‘ Principles of Inter-

connected Operation’’, and a ‘‘Unit Tripping Agreement”’

provide for emergency services as required by a co-tenant.

The point of delivery for energy supplies under those

agreements is ordinarily agreed upon between the parties.

Where the switchyards at the Four Corners Power Plant

are the only points of interconnection between the parties’

systems, deliveries are necessarily made in New Mexico.

All such sales of energy are wholesales sales in interstate

commerce over which the Federal Power Commission has

exclusive jurisdiction (except in the case of SRP which is

not subject to such jurisdiction). The agreements referred

to above have been filed as tariffs with the FPC on behalf

of each of the plaintiffs, except SRP.

12. 1975 wholesale sales and transfers made by TGE in

accordance with the agreements described in the preceding

paragraph, are set forth in the following table:

APS SRP Edison PNM EPE

Delivered 5,898,000 5,285,000 16,780,000 1,555,000 —O—

Received 795,000 2,216,000 —0— 77,894,000 2,207,000

In 1975, TGE also delivered 45,491,000 kwh to, and received

38,546,000 kwh from the United States Bureau of Recla-

mation.

The Ele +trical Energy Tax measured by the energy sold

at wholesale after July 1, 1975, is passed on by each plain-

69

tiff in whole or in part to the wholesale purchaser. Where

the eventual wholesale purchaser is a ‘‘person selling the

electricity for consumption in New Mexico,” §9C of the

Electrical Energy Tax Act requires the purchaser to re-

imburse the wholesaler for the amount of the credit ac-

corded the ultimate retailer by § 9B, and § 9C also requires

that such credit be assigned by the wholesaler to its pur-

chaser. Regulations issued under those provisions require

each generating wholesaler to assign a ‘‘potential credit’’

equal to the Electrical Energy Tax to his wholesale pur-

chaser, who is entitled to an actual credit against the

gross receipts tax if the electrical energy is sold ‘‘for con-

sumption in New Mexico.’”’

13. On September 25, 1975, TGE timely filed with defend-

ant a return (Form EE-1) showing that for July, 1975,

energy generated by TGE in New Mexico was 145,206,000

kwh, and the amount due under the Electrical Energy Tax

for such period was $58,082.40. The amount of tax shown

on the returns was duly protested without payment in ac-

cordance with § 72-13-38 N.M.S.A., 1953. The Tax for subse-

quent months has been similarly returned and the unpaid

portion has been timely protested by TGE.

14. TGE is subject to the following Arizona taxes and in

1975 became liable for the amounts shown.

Corporate

Income Unemployment State Sales City Sales State Use

$308,000 ( Est) $48,626 $6,087,885 $1,533,706 $132,982

City Use AdValorem City Franchise Excise and Other

--0-- $17,401,907 $1,675,724 $356,229

TOTAL: $27,545,059

Similary liabilities apply for 1976 and are reasonably ex-

pected for later years.

Electrical energy generated in New Mexico, in respect

of which the Electrical Energy Tax is payable, is sold by

70

TGE at retail to consumers in Arizona subject to the state

and city taxes shown above. There is no provision of Ari-

zona law under which TGE is entitled to any credit, offset,

rebate or other form of recoupment for the Electrical

Energy Tax paid in respect of such energy.

/3/ Kenneth L. Saunt

Susscripep anD Sworn to before me this 14th day of Sep-

tember, 1976.

/s/ Jean E. Ketrtewe_u

Notary Public

My commission expires:

February 1, 1978.

71

Affidavit of Phoebe Fornaciari

(Affidavit No. 6 to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

(Without Attachments) :

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW MEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, ET AL., Plaintiffs,

Vv.

Frep O’CueEskey, ET AL., Defendants.

Arripavit No. 6

To Puiarntirrs’ Motion ror SumMarRY JUDGMENT

State or New Mexico )

) SS:

County or Santa Fe )

PuHoesBe Fornaciari, being first duly sworn upon her oath,

deposes and says:

1. That affiant is employed by the law firm of Montcom-

ERY, Feperici, ANDREWs & Hannaus as a paralegal assistant

and was so employed during the time that the Ist Session

of the 32nd Legislature of New Mexico considered the bill

and substitute bills which, upon enactment and approval of

the Governor, became Laws 1975, Chapter 263; to-wit: Jan-

uary through March, 1975.

2. That during the aforesaid period, either the affiiant or

a member of the law firm attended all Senate and House

Committee and floor sessions at which such bills were for-

mally considered and a member of the law firm tape re-

corded these discussions and debate concerning said bills;

that all Senate and House Committee and floor sessions

were attended by the affiant, with the exception of the ses-

72

sion on the Senate floor on March 11, 1975, which was

attended by another member of the law firm.

3. That attached hereto are transcripts of the aforesaid

tape recordings, which affiant has reviewed and compared

with the tape recordings made by affiant or another member

of the law firm and the attached transcripts are true

and correct transcriptions of the tape recordings of such

discussions and debates.

4. That attached hereto as Exhibits 1, 2 and 3 are true

and correct copies of the bills and substitute bills consid-

ered during the 1st Session of the 32nd Legislature and

which resulted, upon enactment and approved, in Laws

1975, Chapter 263, to-wit:

Exhibit 1 to Affidavit No. 6: Senate Bill 258;

Exhibit 2 to Affidavit No. 6: Senate Corporations Com-

mittee Substitute for Senate Bill 258; and

Exhibit 3 to Affidavit No. 6: Senate Finance Committee

Substitute for Senate Corporations Committee Substitute

for Senate Bill 258.

5. That as more fully appears from the Exhibits and

transcripts attached hereto:

In the first hearing on the bill (S.B. 258) before the Sen-

ate Corporations Committee on February 27, 1975, Senator

Aubrey Dunn, the sponsor of the bill, introduced the Com-

missioner of Revenue to explain the operation and effect

of the bill. The Commissioner described the way in which

the energy tax would be credited against the gross receipts

tax applicable to a New Mexico sale of the energy and con-

cluded, ‘‘The taxpayer in California or the consumer in

California would bear the brunt of the tax.’’ Before the

Senate Finance Committee on March 5, 1975, Senator Dunn

stated that ‘‘there will be very little possibiliy of any of

this being passed on to the New Mexico consumer,’’ and the

Commissioner of Revenue stated that the tax was ‘‘really

73

on exported power.” On the Senate floor on Marcel: 11, 1975,

Senator Dunn explained the bill as follows:

[Ajnd the idea behind it, Mr. President, is that we

levy this generating tax and we allow the generating

companies to take credit for the gross receipts tax

which they collect on this power as they sell it, against

this particular amount of generation tax. When this is

done, Mr. President, it forms a washout which allows

that most of the tax could be passed on in almost 99.9

per cent of the time to the residents of Arizona and

California.’’

In the House, Senator Dunn described the intent of the

Senate-passed bill to the Taxation and Revenue Committee

on March 19, 1975, as follows:

‘*Mr. Chairman, the main idea behind this is that the

generator who is responsible for this tax may apply

against that tax the gross receipts which he collects.

Mr. Chairman, I think this is a very important part of

it. And in almost one hundred per cent, but not in

every case, I’d hasten to say that there would be hardly

any taxation on the individual consumer in the State of

New Mexico, in this particular area.’’

Senator Dunn later stated at the same hearing that “a

very, very large percentage of it—almost a hundred per

cent, in my estimation—will be passed on and can be passed

on to Arizona and California’’ and that ‘‘this particular

tax was for the consumer, Mr. Chairman, for the consumer

in Arizona and for the consumer in California.” On the

House floor, the bill was sponsored by Representative

Edward J. Lopez, Chairman of the Taxation and Revenue

Committee. Representative Lopez explained his sponsor-

ship of the bill as follows:

‘*T find myself in the unique position this year, Mr.

Speaker, of having to support a measure of this nature.

74

As you all know, for the last four years, I’ve stood up

in opposition to the imposition of this sort of tax. But

my opposition was based on the fact that there was no

way to impose the tax without placing a burden on the

New Mexico taxpayer or utility user. However, this

year a device has been worked out whereby there is a

credit in it and the tax will be paid by out-of-state

residents with no additional burden on our New Mexico

residents. So, for that reason I stand before you today

supporting this bill and carrying it.’’

The House thereupon passed the bill.

Further affiant sayeth not.

/s/ Pueose Fornacieri

Pheobe Fornacieri

SusscrrBep anp Sworn to before me this 8th day of Sep-

tember, 1976.

/s/ Vincinta C. THompson

Notary Public

My Commission Expires:

September 11, 1979

(SEAL)

75

Affidavit of Carl M. Turner

(Affidavit No. 7 to Plaintifis’ Motion for Summary Judgement)

(Without Exhibits)

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW MEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, et AL., Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cueskey, et aL., Defendants.

Arripavit oF Cart M. Turner

Strate or New Mexico )

) ss

County or Santa Fe )

Cart M. Turner, being first duly sworn upon his oath,

deposes and says:

1. Affiant is employed by the New Mexico Rural Electri-

fication Cooperation Association as executive manager and

was so employed during the time that the 1st Session of

the 32nd Legislature of New Mexico considered the bill and

substitute bills which, upon enactment and approval of the

Governor, became Laws 1975, Chapter 263, to-wit: January

through March, 1975. During the aforesaid period, affiant

attended ai! Senate and House Committee and floor sessions

at which such bills were formally considered.

2. Attached hereto as Exhibits 1, 2, 3 and 4 are true and

correct copies of the following documents distributed by the

Commissioner of Revenue to members of the Legislture in

connection with said bills, to-wit:

_ Exhibit 1: Bill Review Report dated February 24, 1975

concerning Senate Bill 258 ;

Exhibit 2: Bill Review Report dated February 26, 1975

concerning Senate Corporations Committee Substitute for

Senate Bill 258 ;

76

Exhibit 3: Bill Review Report dated March 10, 1975

concerning Senate Finance Committee Substitute for Sen-

ate Corporations Committee Substitute for Senate Bill 258;

and

Exhibit 4: Memorandum to Senator Aubrey Dunn dated

March 10, 1975 concerning Senate Finance Committee Sub-

stitute for Senate Corporations Committee Substitute for

Senate Bill 258.

3. Before Senate Finance Committee Substitute for Sen-

ate Corporations Committee Substitute for Senate Bill 258

was brought to the Senate floor, the Commissioner of Reve-

nue recommended that the tax rate be reduced from five

tenths of a mill to four tenths of a mill per kilowatt hour to

avoid imposition of any part of the tax on energy consumed

in New Mexico. In a memorandum dated March 10, 1975,

to Senator Dunn, the Commissioner stated:

‘*Tf the generating utility sells to other utilities in the

state, the generation tax can be assigned along the

route with the buyer reimbursing the utility generating

the electricity for the generation tax. The ultimate

retailer of the electricity can credit the generation tax

against the gross receipts tax.

‘*Under the generation tax rate of 144 mill per/KWH,

of all the utilities in New Mexico, it appeared that only

Southwestern Public Service Company might have to

pass some generation tax on to New Mexico consumers.

It appears that the amendment to 4/10 of a mill brings

down the generation tax so that even in Southwestern’s

case the gross receipts tax more than offsets the gen-

eration tax.’’

The tax rate was thus reduced before the bill was passed by

the Senate.

/s8/ Cant M. Turner

Carl M. Turner

77

Supscrisep anp Sworn to before me this 10th day of

September, 1976.

/8/ Rosemarie McCurry

Notary Public

My commission expires: 2-8-77

78

Plaintiffs’ Answers to Supplemental Interrogatory No. 9

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COUBT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ex Paso Execraic

Company, Sait River Prosgect AcricuLtuRAL IMPROVEMENT

AND Power District, SourHERN CaLirornia Epison

Company, aND Tucson Gas & Exxctric Company, Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Bureau or Revenve, anp State or New Mexico, Defendants.

Piaintirrs’ ANSWERS TO SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES

Defendants, Artzona Pusiic Service Company, Ex Paso

Exvecrric Company, Satt River Progect AcricuttuRau Im-

PROVEMENT AND Power District, SourTHERN CaLiFornia Ep-

ison Company and Tucson Gas & Exectric Company, pur-

suant to Rule 33 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, hereby

answer Defendants’ Supplemental Interrogatories, dated

October 6, 1976.

9. With respect to the taxes paid to states other than

New Mexico, as set forth in the affidavits in support of

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment, please state

what of each tax is attributable to electricity generated in

New Mexico, and please explain how it relates to such

electricity.

79

(A) Arizona Pusiic Service Company (APS)

Arizona Tax

Attributable to

New Mexico Generation

Type of Arizona Tax Total Amount Percentage

State Sales $12,315,992 $4,077,617 33.11%

City Sales 1,193,116 391,289 32.80%

City Franchise 3,629,957 1,180,596 32.52%

Corporation Commission

Regulatory Assessment 497,773 162,262 32.60%

Income 1,515,687 516,089 34.05%

The above taxes are revenue related and are directly related to

electricity generated in New Mexico. A portion of Arizona ad

valorem, payroll, ete., taxes which relate to the transmission and/or

distribution of electricity is also attributable to New Mexico gene-

ration, but have not been apportioned at this time.

(B) Ex Paso Extectrric Company (Ex Paso)

The nature of an interconnected transmission and gener-

ation system makes it impossible to specify the origin of

electric energy consumed throughout the system. For this

reason, the Company compared its New Mexico generation

to its New Mexico consumption and arrived at a net excess

generation of 902,843 MWH. It was assumed that this ex-

cess generation was absorbed by the Company’s Texas

load, and the appropriate percentage of gross receipts taxes

paid in Texas was attributed to the excess generation in

New Mexico.

Theoretically, a portion of the Texas ad valorem taxes is

attributable to New Mexico generation, but the data nec-

essary to make such a determination is not available.

80

Total Generated in New Mexico

and Sold Outside New Mexico in 1975* 930,340 MWH

Less: Sales to Other Utilities: (1)

APS 6,524

TG&E 2,207

SRP 18,766

Total Generated in New Mexico;

Sold in Texas & Mexico in 1975 902,843 (MWH)

Total Sales in Texas for 1975

(Includes Sales to R.G. Co-op. &

Republic of Mexico (2) 2,582,075 (MWH)

902,843 + 2,582,075 = 34.97% (% of Texas Sales that are

generated in New Mexico)

1975 Gross Receipts Tax Paid to Texas $1,139,942.88

x 34.97%

Texas Gross Receipts Tax Attributable

To Generation in New Mexico $ 398,638.03

*Is comprised principally of electricity for Company’s customers

in Texas, and for International Export to Republic of Mexico;

also included are amount sold to other utilities, delivered at Four

Corners, New Mexico for ultimate consumption outside of New

Mexico. (TAKEN FROM INTERROGATORY NO. 5, DOCKET

NO. 50245)

(1) Taken from El Paso’s 1975 Annual Report to the Federal

Power Commission, Page 424.

(2) Taken from El] Paso’s 1975 Annual Report to the Federal

Power Commission, Pages 410 and 411 for total Texas sales

and Pages 412 and 413 for Sales for Resale (excluding CPS).

(C) Sat River Prosecr (SRP)

The Arizona taxes paid by Salt River Project in Arizona

which are attributable to electricity generated in New Mex-

ico consist of 12.4% of the State and City Sales Taxes as

81

set forth in SRP’s affidavit in support of plaintiff’s Motion

for Summary Judgment.

(D) Sournern Cauirornia Epison Company (SCE)

The percentages of 1975 taxes paid by SCE in states

other than New Mexico, attributable to electricity gener-

ated in New Mexico, are estimated as indicated below:

1. California (Southern California Edison Company, Affi-

davit Item 15)

A. Franchise Requirements

1. Based on Revenues—.0569%*

2. Based on Other than Revenues (Miles of line, etc.)

—None

B. Corporate Income—.0569% *

C. Unemployment—None

D. Use—None

E. Ad Valorem—None

F. Excise (Gasoline, etc.)—None

G. Utility User’s—.0569%*

2. Arizona (Southern California Edison Company, Affi-

davit Item 14)

A. Corporate Income—.0569%*

B. Unemployment—None

C. State Use—None

D. Ad Valorem—None

3,134,110,000

_ © Equals ratio of = .0569

55, 123,835,000

82

(E) Tucson Gas & Exectric Company (TG&E)

Ratio of New Mexico Net Generation

to Total System Net Generation—1975

New Mexico Net Generation (in kwh):

Four Corners 456,998,000°

San Juan 1,216,590,000°

Total New Mexico 1,673,588,000

——___ __—__—__—__—__

New Mexico Net Generation 1,673,588,000

= 42.87%

System Net Generation 3,903,923,186**

* FPC Form 1 (12-31-75), Page 432a, Line 12

*¢ PPC Form 1 (12-31-75), Page 431, Line 9

83

1975 Arizona Taxes

Allocated to New Mexico Generation

Electric Gas Total

State Sales Taz $5,003,346 $1,084,539 $6,087,885

New Mexico Generation Ratio 4287

$2,144,934

,144,9

- - = 35.23% of State Sales Tax

$6,087,885

City Sales Taz $1,215,070 $ 318,636 $1,533,706

New Mexico Generation Ratio 4287

$ 520,901

20,901 :

$ = 33.96% of City Sales Tax

$1,533,706

City Franchise Tax $1,327,497 $ 348,227 $1,675,724

New Mexico Generation Ratio 4287

$ 569,098

_ - 33.96% of City Franchise Tax

$1,675,723 =

Arizona Corporation

Commission Assessment $ 214541 $ 43,031 $ 257,672

New Mexico Generation Ratio 4287

$ 92,017

=. = 35.71% of ACC Assessment

$257,672

State Income Taz (est.) $ 254,685 $ 53,315 $ 308,000

New Mexico Generation Ratio 4287

$ 109,183

$109,183 _ 35.45% of State Income Tax

$308,000 =

84

Darep this 22nd day of October, 1976.

Bicsez, STEPHENSON, CARPENTER &

CrouT

Richard N. Carpenter, Esq.

P. O. Box 669

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Ropey, Dickason, Sioan, Akin &

Ross

William C. Schaab, Esq.

P. O. Box 1888

Albuquerque, New Mexico 87103

Synett & WILMER

Bruce Norton, Esq.

3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073

Montcomery, Feperici, ANDREWws &

HanNAHS

Frank Andrews, III, Esq.

P. O. Box 2307

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Wuite, Kocu, Ketty & McCartruy

Benjamin J. Phillips, Esq.

P. O. Box 787

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

/s/ By Bruce Norton

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

(Certificate of Mailing Omitted in Printing)

(Verification Omitted in Printing)

(Verification Omitted in Printing)

(Verification Omitted in Printing)

85

Otfice Memorandum

SNELL & WILMER

Office Memorandum

To: Bruce Norton

From: Bud Jacobson

DaTE: June 4, 1976

Sussect: New Mexico Generation Tax

Senator Paul Fannin believes he has the support now

to get a bill through the Senate correcting the New Mexico

tax situation. He very much wants the language of the

Amendment to be reviewed by an expert to make sure that

in fact it does the job. I gather the language was drafted

by a man in Senator Fannin’s office named Bob Cable.

I talked with Senator Fannin Friday afternoon and told

him you would be in Washington Monday and Tuesday,

arriving mid-afternoon Monday at the Watergate. He asked

that I get you a copy of the proposed language [copy

attached] so you could study it before you get to Washing-

ton, making what changes you believe are in order.

NEXT HE ASKED THAT I BE SURE AND HAVE

YOU CALL HIM AS SOON AS YOU ARRIVE MON-

DAY AFTERNOON AND ASK FOR HIM OR GORDON

GILMAN. Mr. Cable, in his office, will not be back till

Tuesday, BUT SENATOR FANNIN WANTS YOU TO

ASK FOR HIM FIRST.

My own impression is that the language is a disaster!

Subsection (a) appears to prohibit a tax on interstate com-

merce, while New Mexico claims they are only taxing the

local activity of generating energy in New Mexico, and,

therefore, interstate commerce, claimed they, is not in-

volved. Should the Court hold they are right, that this is

a local activity, it would be untouched by this legislation.

86

Next, the Act talks of a higher rate, while my memory

is that the retail rate in New Mexico for the local sale of

energy is the same as the rate imposed on that shipped

to Arizona.

You are the expert on this, and I am going only from

memory.

Success and thank you.

87

Correspondence to Senator Fannin

LAW OFFICES

SNELL & WILMER

June 10, i976

The Honorable Paul J. Fannin

United States Senator

3121 Dirkson Senate Building

Washington, D.C. 20510

Dear Senator Fannin:

On the way back from Washington and while here, I

have reviewed in much greater detail the proposed Amend-

ment to Section 1322. I am enclosing what we consider to

be far better language.

The first sentence should read as follows:

Sec. 201

(a) No state, or political subdivision thereof, may

impose or assess a tax on or with respect to the gene-

ration or transmission of electricity which discrimi-

nates against out of state manufacturers, producers,

wholesalers, retailers or consumers of that electricity.

Upon reflection, this change is critical. Without it, the State

of New Mexico will simply make the argument that Section

201(a) does nothing but prohibit taxes on interstate com-

merce, the very argument they are making in Court today

on the challenge to the generation tax. The old language

is susceptible to the interpretation that the New Mexico

generation tax is imposed upon the local event of gene-

ration and not upon the ‘‘generation of electricity for

transmission in interstate commerce’’. If there is any way

in which the language can be changed to the above, it

should be done.

Senator West Viewiale old language case reading

ginie Blecivie end Power Company ©. Haden, 200 8.E. 2d

848 (W. Va., en teens eee a

ax Wan ae ena ao x ee ee :

feel that that argument will be available to them.

tax in New Mexico. None of them woul theenhoued

legislative history, however. We think the legislative his-

BN :ed

Order

SANTA FE COUNTY

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW MEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

Anizowa Pusuic Seavice Company, et al., Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, et al., Defendants.

Ornper

This matter having come on upon the oral stipulati

1b Gea uaathea to cle omat ab hate Gy to anata

plaintiffs to file their First Amended Complaint and the

Court having granted such leave in open court;

with;

Ir Is Funruer Onverep that defendants have, and hereby

es Se ee eS ae

/s/ Eowt L. Fetes

Edwin L. Felter

District Judge

91

First Amended Complaint

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

wy, Satt River Proyecr Acricuttura, Improvement

asp Power Disraict, Sovrmery Cairo!

Company, and Tucson Gas & Execrnic Company,

Plaintiffs,

Revewen, 0nd Gauteap Slew Blames, Defendants.

Fienst Amenpep CompLaint

and validity of the Electric Snergy Tax Act,

263, Laws 1975, and for their First Amende Chapter

herein, state:

_1. Arizona Public Service

within the States of New Mexico and Texas, and is rege.

eee OO 6 See ey 2S ee SEES Se

3. Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and

Power District (hereinafter “Salt River Project”), a politi-

cal subdivision of the State of Arizona, operating s federal

tary of the Interior, generates, transmits, distributes and

ste cicsieal enorgy within te Stat of Asioonn

4. Southern California Edison Company, a California

corporation, generates, transmi distributes and sells elec-

trical energy within the State of California, and is regu-

ea

energy within the State of Arizona, and is regulated as a

= service corporation by the Arizona Corporation

6. Fred O’Cheskey is Com

Revenue of the State of New Mexico Tho Busses of

gy Tax Act.

7. The Four Corners Power Plant is an electrical gene-

rating station composed of five generati a hall am,

lated facilities located on Indian lands leased from the

Navajo Nation under Leases dated December 1, 1960 and

July 1, 1966, duly approved by the Navajo Tribal Council

8. Arizona Public Service Company owns and operates

pees eae ee eee ee

Entre Company ach na ah undivided intern i ee

9. The San Juan Generating Station is an electrical gene-

mposed of two generating units (one

operational and one under construction) and related facili

Men in San Juan County, near Waterflow, New

exico.

(4%) interest in Juan Generating Station.

11. The Rio Grande Generating Station is an electrical

generating station composed of cight generating units and

related facilities located in Dona Ana County, near Anapra,

New Mexico and is wholly owned by El Paso Electric

Company.

12. Certain of the plaintiffs (Arizona Public Service

Company and El! Paso Electric Company) sell electrical

energy generated in New Mexico to a foreign country,

Mexico.

of ext shana to Gacine tateaes :

of each other plaintiff and with the electrical systems of

ile Sesvico Company of How Masten, tho US, Desens

of Reclamation, and Utah Power and Light Compas

electricity in the major urban centers served by the plain-

tiffs in Arizona, southern California, and the El Paso area

of west Texas determines in substantial degree the amoun'

of electrical energy generated at generating stations located

in New Mexico (as wel as those in other states). The

electrical energy generated in New Mexico in response to

such demand to which each pelts is entitled from its

generation facilities is instantaneously transmitted over

existing transmission lines to that plaintiff's service area.

15. All of the plaintiffs’ above-described transactions in

the generation and transmission of electrical energy at the

Four Corners Power Plant, San Juan Generating Station,

and the Rio Grande Generating Station, and the distribu-

tion and sales of such electrical energy, are in the course

of commerce among the States and the Navajo Tribe of

Indians, except for the aforesaid sales of electrical energy

to Mexico, certain velatively i insignificant wales made by

Arizona Public Service Company within New Mexico to

Utah International, Inc., for operation of the Navajo Mine

which provides the fuel for the Four Corners Power Plant,

and for certain sales by El Paso Electric Company within

its service area in the State of New Mexico. All other

sales or exchanges of electrical energy in New Mexico by

any plaintiff are wholesale sales to other electric utility

companies on the interconnected systems in interstate com-

merce under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal Power

Commission. Such interstate sales give rise to no New

Mexico gross pee 5 tax ability under the New Mexico

16, Roch sisfettl gape inceme, of Glen See

and other taxes imposed by the State of New Mexico or

its political subdivisions on it and other taxpayers simi-

larly situated, and income, ad valorem, sales and use (or

their equivalent), franchise, excise end other taxes imposed

by the state of its incorporation on it and other taxpayers

similarly situated.

17. Section 3 of the Electrical Energy ax Act, Chapter

263, Laws 1975 (hereinafter the ‘‘Act’’), purports to im-

pose on persons generating electricity a privilege tax of

four-tenths of one mill ‘‘on each net kilowatt hour of elec-

tricity Gunseates in New Mexico”’ for the purpose of sale.

Subsection 9B of the Act provides that the electrical

energy , tex paid on electricity generated and consumed in

New Mexico may be credited against the gross receipts

tax due New Mexico. No credits of any type are provided

with respect to the electrical energy tax imposed upon

o—, generated in New Mexico, but transmitted and

onsumed outside New Mexico.

Subsection 9C of the Act directs that the credit for

electrical | energy tax paid on electricity generated and con-

sumed in New Mexico shall be assigned to the person selling

the electricity for consumption in New Mexico on which

New Mexico gross receipts tax is due, and further requires

the assignee of such credit to reimburse the assignor

for the amount of the credit so assigned.

20. The practical operation and effect of Sections 3 and

9 of the Act is to tax the generation of electricity in New

Mexico, but shifts the entire incidence of such tax to those

who sell or consume that electricity outside New Mexico

since the person generating and selling electricity for con-

umption in New Mexico receives either a credit (under

Subsection 9B) against his gross receipts tax due New

ates or a reimbursement (under Subsection 9C) in an

mount equal to the electrical energy tax payable on such

"laintiffs’ retail sales of electrical energy transmit-

ted from generating facilities in New Mexico to plaintiffs’

respective service areas in Texas, Arizona and California

are subject to certain taxes imposed by those states, or the

ubdivisions thereof, or both. Such taxes are vari-

ited as sales or other types of excise taxes,

but are uniformly imposed upon, or passed on to consumers

of electricity in those states.

22. There is no provision of law in Texas, Arizona or

California whereby any of the plaintiffs are entitled to any

credit, offset or rebate for the electrical energy tax imposed

on them by New Mexico.

23. Public Service Company of New Mexico, an electric

public utility regulated by the New Mexico Public Service

Commission, with respect to its share of electrical energy

generated at the Four Corners Power Plant and the San

Juan Generating Station, will in practical effect sustain

no additional tax burden under the Electrical Energy Tax

Act due to the provisions of Subsections 9B and 9C of the

Act permitting the amount of electric*! energy tax paid

to be assigned or credited against its gross receipts tax

liability due the State of New Mexico.

24. El Paso Electric Company will in practical effect

sustain no additional tax burden under the Electrical Ener-

gy Tax Act with respect to the electrical energy generated

in New Mexico and sold by it to consumers in New Mexico

due to the provisions of Subsections 9B and 9C of the

Act allowing the electrical energy tax to be credited against

its New Mexico gross receipts tax liability. It will sustain

additional tax liability, however, on that electrical energy

generated by it in New Mexico and sold by it to consumers

outside New Mexico. This additional tax liability places

El Paso at a competitive disadvantage with New Mexico

utilities with whom it competes.

25. Plains Electric Generation and Transmission Coop-

erative, a New Mexico corporation, generates electrical

energy at its generating plant near Algodones, New Mexico,

and transmits and sells electrical energy solely to New

Mexico electric utilities which are its members; however,

by reason of Subsections 9B and 9C of the Act, it will

incur no additional tax burden due to the Electrical Energy

Tax Act.

97

26. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that no additional tax liability under the Electrical

Energy Tax Act is incurred by any other person (as de-

fined in the Electrical Energy Tax Act) engaged in the

same business as plaintiffs upon electrical energy generated

and consumed in New Mexico, due to the availability of the

crediting provisions provided for under Subsections 9B

and 9C of the Act.

27. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that all, or virtually all, of the additional taxes

claimed to be due under the Electrical Energy Tax Act,

after application of Subsections 9B and 9C of the Act, will

be borne by those persons, including plaintiffs, engaged

in the generation of electricity in New Mexico which is

transmitted across and consumed outside the boundaries

of the State of New Mexico.

28. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that the Act was enacted for the purpose of and

the view to placing the exclusive burden of paying addi-

tional tax revenues tc the State of New Mexice upon trans-

actions in commerce among the several states and with the

Indian Tribes.

29. The language of the Act, coupled with the practical

application of the tax, constitutes a tax on the privilege

of engaging in commerce among the several states.

30. Plaintiffs contend that the Act is unconstitutional

an’ void for each and every one of the following reasons:

A. The Electrical Energy Tax Act violates the Com-

merce Clause of Article I, Section 8 of the United

States Constitution by deliberately and invidiously dis-

criminating against and imposing direct and multiple

burdens upon each plaintiff’s interstate commerce in

the transmission and sale of electricity.

B. Application of the Electrical Energy Tax to these

plaintiffs, measured by electricity generated in New

Mexico for transmission and sale in interstate com-

merce, is arbitrary, capricious and unreasonable and

denies to each plaintiff the equal protection of the

law, and the rights, privileges and immunities enjoyed

by other members of the class defined as persons gene-

rating electrical energy in New Mexico, in violation of

Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United

States Constitution, and of Article II, Section 18, and

Article IV, Section 26 of the New Mexico Constitution.

C. The Act deprives plaintiffs of property without

due process of law in violation of Section 1 of the

Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Consti-

tution and Article II, Section 18 of the New Mexico

Constitution.

D. The Act violates Article I, Section 8, Clause 3,

and Article I, Section 10, Clause 2 of the United States

Constitution.

31. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that defendants contend the Act is constitutional

with respect to the matters set forth in paragraph No. 29

of this Complaint.

32. The Tax Reform Act of 1976, duly passed by the

United States Congress and approved and enacted by

President Gerald R. Ford on October 4, 1976, prohibits

the imposition or assessment of certain taxes upon the

generation or transmission of electricity:

Trrte 1J—Discrmuination Taxes

See. 201. No State, or political subdivision thereof,

may impose or assess a tax on or with respect to the

generation or transmission of electricity which dis-

criminates against out-of-State manufacturers, pro-

ducers, wholesalers, retailers, or consumers of that

electricity. For purposes of this section a tax is dis-

criminatory if it results, either directly or indirectly,

99

in a greater tax burden on electricity which is gene-

rated and transmitted in interstate commerce than on

electricity which is generated and transmitted in intra-

state commerce.

(b) Effective Date-—The amendment made by sub-

section (a) shall take effect beginning June 30, 1974.

33. Plaintiffs contend that the Act is rendered illegal,

invalid, inoperative, and void from June 30, 1974, forward,

by the terms and provisions of Tax Reform Act of 1976,

Section 201.

34. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and therefore

allege, that defendants contend that the Act is not illegal,

invalid, inoperative, or void from June 30, 1974, forward,

as set forth in Paragraph 32 of this Complaint.

35. The plaintiffs, being persons whose rights, status or

other legal relations are affected by the Act, request that

the Court determine the questions of validity arising under

the Act.

36. A genuine controversy exists between the plaintiffs

and defendants with respect to the matters hereinbefore

alleged; however, there is no controversy respecting the

amount of the tax which would be payable by any plaintiff,

if the Act is valid, nor with respect to the form or accuracy

of any assessment of the tax thereunder.

37. Due to the necessity to construe and apply pro-

visions of the United States Constitution, the New Mexico

Constitution, and the Tax Reform Act of 1976, in order to

resolve the controversy between plaintiffs and defendants,

plaintiffs have no other plain, speedy and adequate remedy.

38. All conditions precedent to the commencement and

maintenance of this action have occurred or been met.

100

Wuenrerore, plaintiffs pray :

A. That this Court adjudge and declare the Electrica!

Energy Tax Act, Chapter 263, Laws 1975, to be unconstitu-

tional and void.

B. That the Court adjudge and declare the Electrical

Energy Tax Act, Chapter 263. Laws 1975, to be illegal,

invalid, inoperative and void from June 30, 1974, forward,

by the terms and provisions of Tax Reform Act of 1976,

Section 201.

C. That upon final hearing and determination the de-

fendants be enjoined from enforcing the Electrical Energy

Tax Act and plaintiffs have such other and further relief

as may be proper in the premises.

BicBee, STEPHENSON, CARPENTER

& Crout

Richard N. Carpenter

P. O. Box 669

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Ropey, Dickason, Stoan, Akin &

Ross

William C. Schaab

P. O. Box 1888

Albuquerque, New Mexico 87103

Swett & WILMER

Bruce Norton

3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073

Montcomery, F'eperici, ANDREws &

HaNNAHS

Frank Andrews, III

P. 0. Box 2307

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

101

Waite, Kocu, Kerry & McCartuy

Ben J. Phillips

P. O. Box 787

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

/s/ By: Bruce Norton

Bruce Norton

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

I, Richard N. Carpenter, being one of the counsel for

plaintiffs herein, do hereby certify that I served a copy of

the First Amended Complaint upon defendants herein by

personally delivering a copy thereof to one of the attorneys

~s er for the defendants on this 22nd day of October,

/8/ Ricuarp NN. Carpenter

Richard N. Carpenter

102

Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Motion for Summary Judgment

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW MEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

Anizona Pvsitc Service Company, Ex. Paso Execraic Com-

pany, Sar Rrver Prosecr AcaicutturaL Improvement

anp Power Distaict, Sovurmean Catironnta Eptsow

Compaxy, and Tucsow Gas & Exrecraic Compary,

Plaintiff s

vs.

Faev O'’Cursxey, Commissioner of Revenue, Bureau or

Revewrve, and Stare or New Mexico, Defendants

PLaintirrs’ SuprLemMenta.

Motion ror Summary JupomMENT

Come now the plaintiffs, by and through their attorneys

undersigned, and, pursuant to Rule 56, N.M.R.C.P., move

for summary judgment in their favor on all issues raised

by the First Amended Complaint herein.

In support thereof, movants state that incorporated here-

in by reference are those supporting affidavits, being Affi-

davit Nos. 1-7, inclusive, attached to plaintiffs’ original

Motion for Summary Judgment and Affidavit No. 8 at-

tached hereto, and that the pleadings and answers to inter-

rogatories on file, together with the affidavits, show that

ceo 1 Se guumine Seene ao te any materiel Shet and Gat

Wuererore, plaintiffs pray that the Court enter its order

rendering them summary judgment on the issues raised by

their First Amended Complaint.

Benjomia Palltign, Hien

Warre, Kocu, Ketry & McCarruy

P. O. Box 787

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

Swett & Wumer

3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073

/s/ By Bauce Nortox

Bruce Norton, Esq.

Biosez, Sternenson, CARPENTER

& Crovut

P. O. Box 669

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501

/s8/ By Ricuarp N. Canpryrer

Richard Carpenter, Esq.

I hereby certify that I delivered in hand a copy of the

foregoing pleading to opposing counsel of record this 5th

day of November, 1976.

/s/ Ricuagp N. Canrenrer

Richard N. Carpenter

104

Affidavit of Bruce Norton

(with Attachments A. B and C)

IN THE DISTRICT COlRT OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

STATE OF NEW AfEXICO, COUNTY OF SANTA FE

No. 50245

Arizona Pusiic Service Company, Ex Paso Erectaic Com-

pany, Sat River Prosecr Acaicuttusa, Improvement

axp Power Dustaict, Sovurmern Catironnwiua Episow

Company, and Tucson Gas & Exectazic Compary,

Plaintiffs

vs.

Frepv O’Cuesxey, Commisioner of Revenue, Bureau or

Revewve, ist Ganpar ten mn Defendants

Strate or Agizona

County or Maricopa, ss.

Bavce Norton, being first duly sworn, upon his oath,

deposes and says:

1. That he is one of the attorneys for the plaintiffs in

this action and that statements herein are made upon his

eee ingstecinmtagye

sath atmueatiattion af Gadiian HOB of Gee toon adam at

of 1976, as duly passed by the United States Congress and

approved and enacted by President Gerald BR. Ford on

of certain taxes upon the generation or transmissio

electricity.

3. That nm! B to this affidavit is a true and

Section 1322 of the Tax Reform Act of 1976.

4. That attachment C to this affidavit is a true and

correct reproduction of the Senate Finance Committee

Report on Section 1322 of the Tax Reform Act of 1976.

105

5. sua neces © @ OM eee he nn aad ea

1322 of the Tax Reform Act of 1976 is set forth.

/s/ Bauce Nortow

Bruce Norton

Svusscersep anp Sworn to before me this 3rd day of No-

vember, 1976.

/s/ Susayw J. Muses

Susan J. Miller

Notary Public

106

Coxreresce Report Leorstative Lanouace

H.R. 10612

Senate Report No. 94-1236

Title 11—Discriminatory Tazes

Sec. 201. No State, or political subdivision thereof, red

pry eet certo ger te thd ag ti

; » of that electricity Dus sanneaes of Oi

is discriminatory if it results, either directly

or indirectly, in a greater tax burden on eluctricity which

is generated and transmitted in interstate commerce than

15 Sraggaaaaaasaeiaaa aimee

(b) Effective Date-—The amendment made by subsectior

(a) shall take effect beginning June 30, 1974.

Conrerence Report Statement or Manacers

H.R. 10612

Senate Report No. 94-1236

1322. Prohibition of Discriminatory State or Local Taxes

on Generation or Transmission of Electricity

House bill.—No provision.

Senate amendment.—Under present law, any restrictions

on the power of States or their political subdivisions to

tax goods or services »roduced in the taxing State for non-

domiciliary use outside the taxing State are derived from

court interpretations of the interstate commerce clause of

the Constitution.

107

mendment prohibits any State or political

subdivision ofa State from directly or indireetly i imposing

sion i ution for taxable years beginning wn June

1974

lowe the Genate mendmeut.

fol-

Senate Fisayce Comm. Report No. 94-938

H.R. 10612

23. Prohibition of Discriminatory State Taxes on Genera-

Present law

Federal statutes provide few limitations on the power of

States to tax nondomi iliaries or to impose special taxes on

goods or services produced in the taxing State for nondomi

ciliary use outside the taxing State.

However, Public Law 86-272 ' does establish certain mini-

mum standards upon the power of a State to tax nondomi

That Act did not affect the powers of States to tax goods

or services produced within its boundaries for consumption

outside its boundaries. Title II of the Act, however, also

provided for farther ‘‘studies of all matters pertaining to

Reasons for change

The committee has learned that one State places a dis-

* 86th Cong., Ist Sess., 73 Stat. 555 (1959).

108

its boundaries for consumpti D i

While the rate of the tax itself is identical for electricity

which is anuumnl inside the State, discrimination results

because the State allows the amount of the tax to be cred-

ited against its gross receipts tax if the electricity is con-

sumed within its boundaries. This credit normally bene-

fits only domiciliaries of the taxing State since no credit

is allowed for electricity produced within the State and

consumed outside the State.’ As a result, the cost of the elec-

tricity to nondomiciliaries is normally increased by the

cost the producer of the electricity must bear in paying the

tax. However, the cost to domiciliaries of the taxing State

does not include the amount of the tax.

The committee believes that this is an example of dis-

criminatory State taxation which is properly within the

ability of Congress to prohibit through its power to regu-

late interstate commerce.

Explanation of provision

The committee amendment prohibits any State, or politi-

eal subdivision of a State, from imposing a tax on or with

respect to the generation of electricity for transmission in

interstate commerce if the tax is discriminatory against

out-of-state manufacturers, producers, wholesalers, retail-

ers, or consumers of that electricity. A tax is considered

discriminatory if it directly or indirectly results in the pay-

ment of a higher gross or net tax on electricity generated

and transmitted in interstate commerce than on electricity

which is generated and transmitted in intrastate commerce.

This provision is not intended to prohibit, restrain, or

burden any other State which currently imposes a nondis-

eriminatory tax on the generation of electricity.

| However, o credit for the amount of o tax on the production of

electricity imposed by a second State is allowed against the first

State's gross receipts tax if the electricity is consumed in the first

State.

109

This provision replaces the current Title II of Pub-

lie Law 86-272, which is the title calling for further con-

gressional studies. A number of studies of the problem of

multi-state taxation of interstate commerce have already

been made by congressional committees, and the present

Title II is not needed to authorize any additional studies

that may be needed.

The House bill contains no similar provision.

Effective date

The prohibition of discriminatory taxes made by this

mendment applies with respect to taxable years beginning

after June 30, 1974.

Revenue effect

This provision will have no impact upon Federal reve-

110

Answer to the First Amended Complaint

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, et al., Plaintiff's,

vs.

Frep O’Cuesxey, et al., Defendants.

Answer To THe First Amenpep ComMPLaINT

Defendants Fred O’Cheskey, the Bureau of Revenue and

the State of New Mexico, for their answer to the first

amended complaint, state as follows:

FIRST DEFENSE

The first amended complaint fails to state a claim upon

which relief can be granted.

SECOND DEFENSE

The court lacks subject matter judisdiction over this

action because of § 72-13-36, N.M.S.A. 1953.

THIRD DEFENSE

The court’s discretion to render a declaratory judgment

should not be exercised as to this action.

FOURTH DEFENSE

Section 201 of the Tax Reform Act of 1976, referred to in

paragraph 32 of the first amended complaint, violates the

Constitution of the United States.

lll

FIFTH DEFENSE

1. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 1 of the

first amended complaint for lack of knowledge or informa-

tion sufficient to form a belief as to the truth thereof.

2. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 2, ex-

cept that, for lack of knowledge or information sufficient

to form a belief as to the truth thereof, Defendants deny

that El Paso Electric Company is regulated as a public

utility by the cities of El] Paso, Van Horn, Anthony and

Clint, Texas.

3. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 3 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a be-

lief as to the truth thereof.

4. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 4 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

5. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 5 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

6. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 6.

7. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 7 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof, except that Defendants admit that

the Four Corners Power Plant is an electrical generating

station composed of 5 generating units and related facil-

ities.

8. For lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form

a belief as to the truth thereof, Defendants deny the alle-

gations of paragraph 8.

9. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 9.

10. For lack of knowledge or information sufficient

to form a belief as to the truth thereof, Defendants deny the

allegations of paragraph 10.

112

11. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 11.

12. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 12.

13. For lack of knowledge or information sufficient to

form a belief as to the truth thereof, Defendants deny the

allegations of paragraph 13.

14. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 14.

15. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 15, in

part for lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form

a belief as to the truth thereof.

16. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 16 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

17. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 17.

18. In response to the allegations of paragraph 18, De-

fendants admit that the legislature of New Mexico enacted

subsection 9B of the Act, to which reference is made for the

correct text. Since paragraph 18 paraphrases subsection

9B, Defendants deny the allegations thereof.

19. In response to the allegations of paragraph 19, De-

fendants admit that the legislature of New Mexico enacted

subsection 9C of the Act, to which reference is made for the

correct text. Since paragraph 19 paraphrases subsection 9C,

Defendants deny the allegations thereof.

20. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 20,

except that they admit that a person generating and selling

electricity for consumption in New Mexico is entitled

to receive either a credit (under subsection 9B) against

the gross receipts tax due New Mexico or a reimbursement

(under subsection 9C) in an amount equal to the electrical

energy tax payable on such electricity.

21. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 21 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

113

22. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 22 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

23. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 23 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

24. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 24 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

25. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 25 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

26. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 26 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

27. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 27 for

lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief

as to the truth thereof.

28. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 28.

29. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 29.

30. In response to the allegations of paragraph 30,

Defendants admit that Plaintiffs make the legal contentions

set forth therein, but deny that any of the contentions is

correct.

31. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 31.

32. In response to the allegations of paragraph 32, De-

fendants admit that Section 201 of the Tax Reform Act of

1976 was enacted into law, and deny the remaining allega-

tions for lack of knowledge or information sufficient to form

a belief as to the truth thereof.

33. In response to the allegations of paragraph 33, De-

fendants admit that Plaintiffs make the legal contentions

114

set forth therein, but deny that any of the contentions is

correct.

34. Defendants admit the allegations of paragraph 34.

35. Paragraph 35 sets forth no fectual allegations and

therefore requires no response.

36. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 36.

37. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 37.

38. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 38.

Wuererore, Defendants pray that they have judgment

dismissing the first amended complaint, that they recover

their costs herein expended and that they have such further

relief as the court deems proper.

/s/ Jan Unna

Jan Unna

Bureau of Revenue

Assistant Attorney General

/s/ Danie. FrimepMan

Daniel Friedman

Bureau of Revenue

Assistant Attorney General

(Certificate of Service omitted in printing)

115

Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgement

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50245

Arizona Pustic Service Company, et al., Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frep O’Cueskey, et al., Defendants.

Derenpants’ Motion For Summary JupGMaNntT

Pursuant to Rule 56 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, De-

fendants move this Court to enter a summary judgment

in Defendants’ favor on all issues raised by the First

Amended Complaint on the grounds that there is no genu-

ine issue as to any material fact and that Defendants are

entitled to such judgment as a matter of law. In support

of this motion there are attached hereto the following afii-

davits :

. Martin Boughman

Graciela Olivarez

Cubia Clayton

Dan Croy

Bruce Nicholson

Stephen R. Flance

Lee Wilson

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Jan Unna

Jan Unna

/8/ Dante. F'rRrepMan

Daniel Friedman

Attorneys for Defendants

Post Office Box 630

Santa Fe, New Mexico 87503

(505) 827-3221

(Certificate of Service omitted in printing)

QIAO w>

116

Affidavit of Martin L. Baughman

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COUBT

No. 50425

Arizona Pusuic Service Company, et al., Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frev O’Cuesxer, et al., Defendant.

Arripavit or Marstix L. Bavonman

Martin L. Baughman, being duly sworn, deposes and

says:

1. I am an assistant professor of electrical engineering at

the University of Texas in Austin, Texas. My curriculum

vitae is attached hereto as Exhibit A. I have extensive

training and resserch experience relating to the mochenine

san metal ta tose tindien tn ao Gatien Miaten, Lama

fied and regarded as an expert in regard to these subjects.

2. The statements in this affidavit and in the exhibit which

is attached hereto as Exhibit B are based upon my personal

experience, research, and belief and are true to the best of

my knowledge. Included in this research are insp ctions of

the Four Corners and San Juan generating plants con-

ducted by me in October, 1976.

tensively in Exhibit B, are as follows:

a. The generation of electricity is an event which is local

to the place in which i cosuse and which is copesuiie

mendaenaarcuiacbeniaaeds

117

mission and distribution of electricity have not changed

since the early 1900's.

ec. The generation of electricity in New Mexico for export

to out of state consumers is a growing phenomenon. In 1975

over 60% of the electricity generated in New Mexico was

exported. The percentage of exported electricity is con-

siderably higher from the Four Corners and San Juan gen-

erating plants in which the Plaintiffs in this action own

significant interests. Some 80% of the electricity generated

in these plants is exported by the Plaintiffs.

d. In generating electricity in New Mexico for export, the

out of state utilities take advantage of the availability of

tow cost coal resources existing in New Mexico and the eco-

nomics of high voltage Msmission to obtain low cost elec-

electricity exported from New Mexico, the Plaintiffs would

have to increase their reliance on generating plants incur-

ring significantly higher fuel costs. If New Mexico elec-

tricity were unavailable to the Plaintiffs, and they had to

generate the equivalent amount of electricity at their plants

outside New Mexico, their costs would increase by a mini-

mum of one hundred and twenty four million dollars a year.

e. The process of generation in New Mexico accounts for

25% of the Plaintiffs’ delivered costs relative to elec-

tricity exported from New Mexico. Taxes paid to all col-

lecting jurisdictions in New Mexico account for 7% of the

cost of generation, excluding the Electrical Energy Tax Act.

ee ee eee ee a

sly with the rate of taxes paid by Plaintiff to all taxing

electricity, which averages 15% af the total cost expe

of the services performed in the state, New Mexico has re-

118

ceived lees in taxes than other govern 2

correct the dieparity.

f. Expressed as a percentage of the average retail price

f the electricity generated by Plaintiffs in New Mexico, the

Electrical Energy Tax is imposed at a rate of less than two

percent.

/s/ Maatix L. ae

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of De-

eember, 1976.

/s/ Hewtzn Mrrome.

Notary Public

119

Affidavit of Graciela Olivarez

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

Arizona Pustic Service Company, Ev Paso Execrnic

Compasy, Sact River Prosect Acricuttura, Improvement

axp Power Distaicr, Sovrmers Catirornia Epison

Company, anv Tucson Gas & Exectaic Company, Plaintiffs,

va.

Frep O’Cuesxey, Commissioner of Revenue,

Beums 69 Snsen, aap Sesser ties Mexico, Defendants.

State or New Mexico, County or Santa Fe, ss.

Gractecas Otvanez, being first duly sworn, upon her oath,

deposes and says:

1. That she is the State Planning Officer, State of New

Mexico, and as such she is authorized to make this Affidavit,

and that statements herein are made upon her personal

knowledge and belief.

& Sho ectendents in this proceeding ave Fred O'Chediey,

Jommissioner of Revenue, Bureau of Revenue, and State

of Rew Mexico.

3. The State Planning Office is an Executive Office of the

State of New Mexico.

Mexico i ineurs signi .% the ,

impacts onthe aren. The Durden of alviating these in

pacts result in significant costs. These costs are

population growth. Fhe copestty of Go pubile sector to poo

vide adequate facilities and services is being severely

120

strained. Potential exists that ‘‘boom’’ conditions may

quickly become evident.

6. Negative results of this rapid growth are evident | in

the deterioration of environmental quality, social p: m:

and general lowering of the quality of life.

7. At the same time, energy consumers in Arizona, Cahi-

fornia, and Texas enjoy the benefits of clean and relatively

cheap electricity transmitted from generating facilities in

San Juan County, New Mexico.

8. Particulate and other emissions from powerplants are

degrading New Mexico's clean air and costing us several

million dollars per year.

9. Loss of visibility is impairing the aesthetic quality of

major landmarks: in the area. Coal stripmining is carried

on while reclamation techniques remain uncertain. There is

no assurance that the thousands of acres mined can ever

be revegetated due to limited precipitation in the mining

area. This potential inability to reclaim the land will fur-

ther contribute to the negative visual impact and to partic-

ulate pollution of the air.

10. The State also sustains a loss of water quality. Utili-

zation of increasing amounts of water from the San Juan

River could increase the salinity of the river. Return water

trial activity contribute to

in the San Juan River.

11. Industrialization of northwest New Mexico is creating

jet, many && CE SES Be Ses Oy panneee Stnueee oe

growth creates a demanc Ser services and facilities which

quickly outstrips a communi

example, water and sewer ules in the Communit

or near capacity. octal tacts anh tunams canoe tied

serving San Juan County, require major expansion and up-

121

— Housing shortages have reached a critical level.

ert racer fac acter Sri ened =

1975. As noted in the State Plan for Mental Health Services,

19766-77, a rise in social and mental health problems can be

anticipated in the area.

12. To mitigate the negative impacts of rapid growth, the

public sector must have adequate tax revenues to insure

environmental quality and provide community infrastruc-

ture and services. However, the State of New Mexico is not

in a position to shoulder the total burden of these costs; nor

should Re Sie SES Gage Spee.

ploitation in the Four Corners area must also be prepared

to help offset the negative costs of growth impacts.

/e/ Gracteta OLtvanez

Graciela Oli

Susscaisep axp Sworn to before me this 23rd day of

November, 1976.

/s/ Paruici D. Sancuzz

Patricia D. Sanchez

122

Affidavit of Cubia L. Clayton

STATE OF NEW MEXICO COUNTY OF SANTA FE

IN THE DISTRICT COURT

No. 50425

Arizona Pustuic Service Company, et al., Plaintiffs,

vs.

Frev O’Cuesxey, Defendant.

Arriwavit or Cust L. CLaytox

L Cubia L. Clayton being duly sworn state:

(1) I am Deputy Director of the New Mexico Environ-

mental Improvement Agency. I have been employed by the

New Mexico Environmental Improvement Agency since

April of 1971 in various capacities including Environmental

Scientist III, Program Manager for Regulation and Stand-

ards Development and Division Chief of the Air Quality

Control Division. Prior to 1971, I was employed by the City

of Albuquerque, Environmental Health Department, for

eight years and the University of Minnesota, University

Health Services, for a year and a half. I have a Bachelor

of Science degree with a major in Biology from the New

Mexico State University and a Masters of Public Health

with a major in Environmental Sciences from the Univer-

sity of Minnesota.°

(2) The air pollution caused by electric power generation

at the Four Corners and San Juan plants has had a signifi-

eantly adverse impact on visibility in the Four Corners

area of New Mexico. New Mexico vistas historically

® The statements made here are based on my experience, knowl-

edge and belief and are supported by and referenced in an affidavit

submitted separately by Lee Wilson.

123

have been known for their depth, clarity and color quality,

particularly in the northern part of the state. These ex-

ceptional vistas have been important in the quality of life

enjoyed by New Mexicans and in the promotion of tourism

and movie production for the state. Emissions of particu-

lates, sulfur dioxide, and oxides of nitrogen from the San

Juan County power plants, primarily the Four Corners

generating station at present amount to approximately one

quarter billion pounds per year, and have been greater in

the past. These emissions have resulted in reduced visual

range, less atmospheric clarity, increased frequency of hazy

conditions. Studies conducted at New Mexico State Univer-

sity have shown that the reduced visibility represents a cost

borne by citizens and visitors in the impacted area. This

cost is conservatively estimated to exceed five million dol-

lars per year from the Four Corners generating station

alone.

(3) There is the possibility that significant long-term

health hazards could occur as the result of air pollution

from coal-fired power plants, even though air quality near

the plants may meet existing air quality standards. This is

so because of the fact that present standards do not address

the effect of many pollutants, including toxic or cancer-

causing substances such as heavy metals and radioactive

materials. Neither do the standards reflect possible inter-

active (synergistic) effects of different contaminants, nor

that the uncontrolled emissions from a power plant are

dominantly fine particles which may be relatively en-

riched in hazardous substances. Health problems result-

ing from long-term, low-level exposure to such substances

may not appear for many years.

An additional factor is the comparatively large number

of New Mexico residents who are sensitive to air pollution.

Further, the high altitude of the state may exaggerate

health impacts because of decreased oxygen supplies. Under

such conditions, prolonged exposure of sensitive individuals

124

to pollutants in concentrations lower than the standards

could be deleterious to public health. A significant portion

of the burden of investigating such potential health effects,

and of remedying them should they occur, falls upon state

government.

(4) Strip-mines and transmission corridors significantly

impact the aesthetic quality of northwestern New Mexico.

These impacts could involve an environmental cost valued

at more than seven million dollars per year. The mining

impact is total on a local, short-term basis; because of cli-

mate, soils and other factors complete recovery of the land-

scape may require decades or centuries. The impact of

transmission lines is most noticeable in areas where no

previous human intrusions were found.

(5) The development of coal-fired power plants in San

Juan County has led or may lead to environmental stresses

and problems additional to those already discussed, and

thus to added direct and indirect environmental costs. Many

examples can be noted.

Energy-related growth in the Four Corners area results

in increased demands f

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.