Appendix — Ford Motor Co. (Chicago Stamping Plant) v. NLRB
Supreme Court brief1979
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Od
Supreme Court, U. $.
se." =
APPENDIX ofc 4 1978
MICHAEL RODAK, JR.CLERK |
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1977
No. 77-1806
ForD Motor COMPANY
(CHICAGO STAMPING PLANT),
Petitioner,
Vv.
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
and
LOCAL 588, UNITED AUTOMOBILE, AEROSPACE
AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA, UAW,
Respondents.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED JUNE 21, 1978
CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 10, 1978
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
COMPLAINT AND NOTICE OF HEARING ............. 1
CE ov sctllpeeltcsdeisenciincdinieisatinannncanreeinaninameenciiinanansaianien, 8
REPORT OF PROCEEDINGS ....WW00.2.......eeeeeeeeeeseeeeeeeee 12
IIE OO tinrecccthlidahiiniicenisnninenevantaceavensetaiienstaniecsens 67
/ gf, gs, pidsidalalipniicisacbanisdleliaiedsoitiin 69
CIEE TP vidiciniinnesiiccsinniensnnienineceenniahinieneindinapunsinitin 71
I IE is oiisicicvindiianstinoenenmndieasnnneciabibinieninitininettiin 74
I ia aad earceelarracctanliianspciliaith 75
I, TIED nicciossnishisiniinidainesemsiietiteiabadceeibliéiitaiaininntenien 77
I I a leterlia iadannitanliasansiniiiiiaileih 78
I ici ciataetlicebicianndinaieesiinioemane 80
JOINT EXHIBIT 21 ................... siindbibisaeiadbiisnntia tannins 81
ORDER GRANTING CERTIORARI ....0 100
te a
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
THIRTEENTH REGION
Case No. 13-CA-15340
ForD Motor COMPANY
(CHICAGO STAMPING PLANT)
and
LOcAL 588, UNITED AUTOMOBILE, AEROSPACE
AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA
COMPLAINT AND NOTICE OF HEARING
It having been charged by Local 588, United Auto-
mobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Work-
ers of America (herein called Local 588) that Ford
Motor Company (Chicago Stamping Plant) (herein
called Respondent), has engaged in, and is engaging
in, certain unfair labor practices affecting commerce
as set forth and defined in the National Labor Rela-
tions Act, as amended, 29 U.S.C., Sec. 151, et seq.
(herein called the Act), the General Counsel of the
National Labor Relations Board, on behalf of the
National Labor Relations Board (herein called the
Board), by the undersigned Regional Director for the
Thirteenth Region, pursuant to Section 10(b) of the
Act and Section 102.15 of the Board’s Rules and Reg-
ulations, Series 8, as amended, hereby issues this
Complaint and Notice of Hearing and alleges as
follows:
2
I
The charge herein was filed by Local 588 on April
12, 1976, and was served on Respondent, by regis-
tered mail, on April 14, 1976.
II
(a) Respondent is, and has beef at all times mate-
rial herein, a Delaware corporation.
(b) Respondent, at all times material herein, has
maintained an office and place of business at 1000
East Lincoln Highway, Chicago Heights, Illinois
(herein also called Respondent’s facility) where it is
engaged in the manufacture and distribution of auto-
mobiles and automobile parts.
(c) During the past calendar year, a representa-
tive period, Respondent, in the course and conduct of
its business operations described above in subpara-
graph (b) of this paragraph, manufactured and dis-
tributed at its facility products valued in excess of
$500,000, of which products valued in excess of $50,-
000 were shipped from said facility to points located
outside the State of Illinois.
(d) During the past calendar year, a representa-
tive period, Respondent, in the course and conduct of
its business operations described above in subpara-
graph (b) of this paragraph, purchased and caused
to be transported and delivered to its facility, goods
and materials, valued in excess of $50,000, directly
from points outside the State of Illinois.
(e) Respondent is, and has been at all times mate-
rial herein, an employer engaged in commerce within
the meaning of Sections 2(6) and 2(7) of the Act.
3
Ill
Local 588 is, and at all times material herein has
been, a labor organization within the meaning of Sec-
tion 2(5) of the Act.
IV
At all times material herein, the following named
persons have occupied the positions set opposite their
respective names, and have been, and are now, agents
of Respondent, acting on its behalf, within the mean-
ing of Section 2(13) of the Act, and supervisors with-
in the meaning of Section 2(11) of the Act:
Thomas Brown—Industrial Relations Manager
Richard L. Smith—Supervisor of Hourly Person-
nel and Labor Relations
Harry Androsko—Employee Services Manager
Robert Jaranowski—Senior Labor Relations Rep-
resentative
Lou Cecchini—Labor Relations Representative
Barrett Whitcomb—Labor Relations Representa-
tive
Shelly Bates—Labor Relations Representative
V
All production and maintenance employees in the
Respondent’s facility described above in paragraph
II(b), but excluding general office employees and
clerical employees other than shipping and receiving
clerks, employees in the Industrial Relations and
methods and work standards department, employees
engaged in designing, drafting, laboratory, photo-
4
graphic and other technical, experimental and/or re-
search work, cafeteria and dining room employees,
plant protection and fire department employees,
guards, professional employees, foremen, trainee fore-
men and all other supervisors as defined in the Act,
constitute a unit appropriate for the purpose of col-
lective bargaining within the meaning of Section 9
(b) of the Act.
VI
On or about August 17, 1956, a majority of the
employees in the unit described above in paragraph
V, by secret ballot election in Case No. 13-RC-5122,
designated and selected International Union, United
Automobile, Aircraft and Agricultural Implement
Workers of America (hereinafter referred to as the
International UAW) as their exclusive representa-
tive for the purpose of collective bargaining with
Respondent, and on August 27, 1956, the Regional
Director for the Thirteenth Region certified the In-
ternational UAW as the exclusive bargaining rep-
resentative of the employees in the unit described
above in paragraph V.
Vil
At all times since August 17, 1956, and by virtue
of the Certification of Representative issued in Case
No. 18-RC-5122, the International UAW has been
the designated and selected representative for the
purpose of collective bargaining of all the employees
in the unit described above in paragraph V, and, by
virtue of Section 9(a) of the Act, has been, and is
now, the exclusive representative of all the employees
in said unit for the purpose of collective bargaining
with respect to rates of pay, wages, hours of employ-
ment, and other terms and conditions of employment.
beet —
Pas es ad er
5
Vill
Since in or about 1956, Local 588 has negotiated
successive local contracts with respect to topics spe-
cifically delegated to the local unions by agreement
of the International UAW and Respondent, or items
specified in the collective bargaining agreement be-
tween International UAW and Respondent which
give local negotiators a choice of options, or items
which through the parties collective bargaining his-
tory have been subject to local negotiations.
IX
(a) On or about October 31, 1973, Respondent
and the International UAW entered into a collective
bargaining agreement with an effective date of No-
vember 19, 1973 and a termination date of September
14, 1976.
(b) On or about June 19, 1974, Respondent en-
tered into a local agreement with Local 588 regard.
ing local conditions relating to the employees in the
unit described above in paragraph V, and said agree-
ment has an effective date of June 20, 1974 and a
termination date of September 14, 1976.
(c) At all times material herein, Local 588 has
requested and is requesting Respondent to bargain
collectively with respect to local terms and conditions
of employment as the exclusive representative of all
employees in the unit described above in paragraph
V.
(d) Commencing on or about February 18, 1976,
and continuing to date, Respondent did refuse, and
continues to refuse, to bargain collectively with Local
6
588 as the exclusive bargaining representative of the
employees in the unit described above in paragraph
V, in that on or about February 18, 1976, and con-
tinuing to date, Respondent refused to negotiate with
Local 588 representatives with regard to prices and
services of food provided for sale to employees in the
unit described above in paragraph V through cafe-
teria and vending operations at Respondent’s facility.
(e) Commencing on or about April 9, 1976, and
continuing to date, Respondent did refuse, and cor-
tinues to refuse, to bargain collectively with Local
588 as the exclusive bargaining representative of the
employees in the unit described above in paragraph
V, in that on or about April 9, 1976, and continuing
to date, Respondent has failed and/or refused to pro-
vide Local 588 with information necessary for con-
tractual administration and negotiations with re-
gard to prices and services of food provided for sale
to employees in the unit described above in paragraph
V through cafeteria and vending operations at Re-
spondent’s facility.
xX
By the acts and conduct described above in para-
graphs IX(d) and IX(e), and by each of said acts,
Respondent has engaged in, and is engaging in, un-
fair labor practices affecting commerce within the
meaning of Sections 8(a)(5) and 8(a)(1) and Sec-
tions 2(6) and 2(7) of the Act.
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on the 16th day
of August 1976, at 11:00 a.m. in Room 881, Everett
McKinley Dirksen Building, 219 South Dearborn
Street, Chicago, Illinois 60604, a hearing will be con-
ducted before a duly designated Administrative Law
eee
7
Judge of the National Labor Relations Board on the
allegations set forth in the above Complaint, at which
time and place you will have the right to appear in
person, or otherwise, and give testimony.
YOU ARE FURTHER NOTIFIED that, pursuant
to Sections 102.20 and 102.21 of the Board’s Rules
and Regulations, Series 8, as amended, the Respond-
ent shall file with the undersigned Regional Director,
acting in this matter as an agent of the National
Labor Relations Board, an original and four (4)
copies of an Answer to said Complaint within ten
(10) days from the service thereof, and that unless
it does so, all of the allegations in the Complaint
shall be deemed to be admitted to be true and may be
so found by the Board. Immediately upon the filing
of its Answer, Respondent shall serve a copy there-
of on each of the other pe ies.
Form NLRB-4668, Statement of Standard Proce-
dures in Formal Hearings Held Before the National
Labor Relations Board in Unfair Labor Practice
Cases, is attached.
DATED at Chicago, Illinois, this 26th day of
May, 1976.
/s/ Alex V. Barbour
ALEX V. BARBOUR
Regional Director
National Labor Relations Board
Thirteenth Region
Room 881
Everett McKinley Dirksen Bldg.
219 South Dearborn Street
Chicago, Illinois 60604
8
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
THIRTEENTH REGION
Case No. 13-CA-15340
ForD Motor COMPANY
(CHICAGO STAMPING PLANT)
and
LOCAL 588, UNITED AUTOMOBILE, AEROSPACE AND
AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT WORKERS OF AMERICA
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
Now comes Ford Motor Company (hereinafter re-
ferred to as “Respondent’”) and in answer to the
Complaint states as follows:
Paragraphs I-III
Respondent admits the allegations in Paragraphs
I-III.
Paragraph IV
Respondent admits the allegations in Paragraph
IV of the Complaint except that Mr. L. Cecchini was
Industrial Relations Manager at the Respondent’s
Chicago Heights, Illinois Stamping Plant until Oc-
tober 1975 and Mr. T. Brown has been Industrial
Relations Manager at the Respondent’s Chicago
Heights Stamping Plant since that date. Mr. Harry
Andrasco is Employee Services Supervisor. Mr.
Shelly Bates is Salaried Personnel Supervisor and
te, eee APM eh ee 8
aaa
9
Mr. B. Whitcomb terminated his employment with
the Respondent in April 1975.
Paragraphs V-VII
Respondent admits the allegations in Paragraphs
V-VIL.
Paragraph VIII
Respondent admits the allegations in Paragraph
VIII concerning local agreements with respect to
certain items specified in the agreement between the
International Union and Respondent, but further an-
swering avers that Local 588 had and has no status
in connection with such agreements other than as a
subordinate administrative component of the Inter-
national Union which continues to be the exclusive
statutory representative of the hourly rated employees
at Respondent’s Chicago Heights, Illinois Plant, de-
scribed in Paragraph V of the Complaint.
Paragraph IX
(a) Respondent admits the allegations of Subpara-
graph (a).
(b) With respect to Subparagraph (b), Respond-
ent admits the existence of the local agreement, pur-
suant to the 1973 collective bargaining agreement,
regarding certain local conditions at the Chicago
Heights Stamping Plant relating to the employees
in the unit described in Paragraph V of the Govern-
ment’s Complaint. Respondent further admits that
the local agreement has an effective date of June
20, 1974 and a termination date of September 14,
1976. However, Respondent further avers that Local
10
588 had and has no status in connection with such
agreements other than as a subordinate administra-
tive component of the International Union which
continues to be the exclusive statutory representative
of the employees at Respondent’s Chicago Heights
Plant, described in Paragraph V of the Complaint.
(c) With respect to Subparagraph (c), Respond-
ent admits the request from the Local Union to bar-
gain collectively with respect to local terms and con-
ditions of employment at the Chicago Heights Stamp-
ing Plant but reiterates that Local 588 had and has
no status with respect to such bargaining other than
as a subordinate administrative component of the
International Union, which continues to be the ex-
clusive statutory representative of the hourly rated
employees at Respondent’s Chicago Heights Plant.
(d) With respect to Subparagraph (d), Respond-
ent admits that it did refuse and continues to refuse
to bargain collectively with the International Union
or with Local 588, as a subordinate administrative
component of the International Union, with regard
to prices and services of food provided for sale to
hourly rated employees, in the unit described in
Paragraph V of the Complaint, through cafeteria
and vending operations at Respondent’s facility, and,
further answering avers that it had no duty under
the Act to bargain with respect to such matters; and
further answering avers that the Company and the
International Union have agreed in Article X, Sec-
tion 10, of the 1973 collective bargaining agreement
that neither shall be obligated to bargain collectively
with respect to any subject or matter referred to or
covered in the agreement or to any subject or matter
11
not specifically referred to or covered in the 1973
collective bargaining agreement.
(e) With respect to Subparagraph (e) of the
Complaint, Respondent admits that it has refused
to provide the International Union with information
with regard to prices of food provided for sale to em-
ployees in the unit described in Paragraph V of the
Complaint to cafeteria and vending operations at
Respondent’s Chicago Heights facility, but for the
reasons stated in Subparagraph (d) immediately
above avers that it had no duty to provide such in-
formation or to bargain collectively with respect
thereto.
Paragraph X
Respondent denies that the actions complained of
were improper or constituted unfair labor practices
within the meaning of the cited Sections of the Act.
Joseph A. O?Reilly
William J. Rooney
Attorneys for Ford Motor Company
By /s/ William J. Rooney
WILLIAM J. ROONEY
The American Road—Room 1021
Dearborn, Michigan 48121
(313) 322-1363
Dated: June 4, 1976
12
OFFICIAL REPORT OF PROCEEDINGS
* * * *
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
THIRTEENTH REGION
Case No. 13-CA-15340
IN THE MATTER OF:
ForD MoToR COMPANY
(CHICAGO STAMPING PLANT)
and
LOCAL 588, UNITED AUTOMOBILE, AEROSPACE
AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA
* * * *
Monday, August 16, 1976
Pursuant to notice, the above-entitled matter came
on for hearing at 11:00 o’clock a.m.
* * * *
[3] PROCEEDINGS
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE WINKLER:
The hearing will come to order.
This is a hearing before the National Labor Rela-
tions Board in the matter of Ford Motor Company,
Case No. 13-CA-15430.
My name is Ralph Winkler.
Will Counsel and other representatives of the
parties please state their appearances for the record?
aitew —s adi
13
MR. DUBE: For the General Counsel, Lawrence
E. Dube.
MR. ZIEGLER: And Frank J. Ziegler.
JUDGE WINKLER: For Respondent?
MR. SCHUR: For the Charging Party, Jerome
Schur of the law firm of Katz & Friedman, Seven
South Dearborn Street, Chicago, Illinois.
JUDGE WINKLER: For Respondent?
MR. ROONEY: For the Respondent, Ford Motor
Company, William J. Rooney, Office of the General
Counsel, Ford Motor Company, the American Road,
Dearborn, Michigan.
JUDGE WINKLER: General Counsel, please pro-
ceed.
MR. DUBE: Your Honor, at this point I offer the
formal papers, General Counsel’s Exhibit 1(a)
through 1(f), 1(f) being an index and description of
the formal papers. The exhibit has been shown to
both the Charging Party and Respondent.
[4] JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The documents heretofore marked General
Counsel’s Exhibit No. 1(a) through 1(f) for
identification, were received in evidence. )
JUDGE WINKLER: I take it that—I am fami-
liar with the Pleadings in the case—that the princi-
pal issue we have here is whether bargaining about
the food, et cetera, was a mandatory subject of bar-
gaining. Is that the issue we have?
MR. ROONEY: That is the main issue. There is
also an issue—
JUDGE WINKLER: We have a subsidiary zip-
per clause issue?
MR. ROONEY: Yes.
14
MR. DUBE: Based on some off-the-record dis-
cussions this morning, the parties are willing to
stipulate to a substantial amount of factual data re-
lating to the issues in this case, and what I would
propose is that we begin reading those stipulations
that have been achieved so far into the record and
start putting exhibits in as Joint Exhibits.
JUDGE WINKLER: You are at bat.
MR. DUBE: Pardon me?
JUDGE WINKLER: You are at bat.
MR. DUBE: Okay. The first stipulation: Em-
ployees at the facility of Respondent involved in this
proceeding, Chicago Stamping Plant, are engaged
in stamping automotive parts for shipment to Re-
spondent’s assembly plants located [5] throughout
the United States. There are currently approximately
3600 employees in the bargaining unit, which is de-
scribed in Paragraph 5 of the Complaint.
Mark this as Joint Exhibit 1.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 1 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: Joint Exhibit 1 is a list of the num-
ber of bargaining unit employees shown in six sepa-
rate years with the figures being a yearly average of
employees in the unit.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record.)
JUDGE WINKLER: Let’s go on the record.
Thus far we are—all parties are stipulating tliat
Joint Exhibit 1 come in, is that correct?
MR. ROONEY: Yes, sir.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right. Received.
Cel eminent ly
ole
15
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 1 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: Further we proposed to stipulate the
Chicago Stamping plant is located in Chicago Heights,
Illinois, approximately ten miles south of Chicago.
The population of Chicago Heights is approximately
40,900. The population of East Chicago Heights is ap-
proximately 6,400. There are more than a dozen in-
dustrial plants to the north and west of the [6] Chi-
cago Stamping Plant, located within several miles of
the Chicago Stamping Plant, employing a total of
several thousand persons.
Mark this as Joint Exhibit 2.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 2 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that the docu-
ment which has been marked as Joint Exhibit 2 is a
true and accurate copy of the map of the area in
which the Chicago Stamping Plant is located. The
scale of miles affixed to the exhibit accurately portrays
the scale of the map. The depiction of the Chicago
Stamping Plant on the map is a depiction of the
plant only and is not a scale depiction of the plant.
The point marked as X on Joint Exhibit 2 accurately
locates the location of the junction between Cottage
Grove Avenue and the sole driveway authorized for
use during lunch or meal periods by bargaining unit
employees leaving, leaving or entering, the plant
premises by vehicle or foot.
Based on the stipulation, I would offer Exhibit 2.
MR. ROONEY: No objections.
MR. SCHUR: No objection.
16
JUDGE WINKLER: All right. Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 2 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I further propose to stipulate Re-
spondent [7] operates three shifts at the Chicago
Stamping Plant. The day shift begins at 7 a.m. and
ends at 3:30 p.m.; the afternoon, also referred to as
evening, shift begins work at 4 p.m. and ends at 12:30
a.m.; the night, also referred to as midnight, shift
begins work at 12 midnight and ends at 8:30 a.m.
The day and evening shifts are operating production
shifts. Each production shift employes approximately
1500 to 1600 bargaining unit employees. The night
shift is engaged in set-up and maintenance work and
employes approximately 500 bargaining unit employ-
ees. A small number of skilled employees included in
the bargaining unit begin work shortly before or after
the shift starting times just described.
Mark this as Joint Exhibit 3.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 3 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose a stipulation that the docu-
ment marked Joint Exhibit 3, purporting to be a bus
schedule for the South Suburban Safeway Lines, is a
true and accurate representation of bus service as
listed on the schedule. I would offer Joint Exhibit 3.
MR. ROONEY: Without objection.
MR.SCHUR: Agreed.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
[8] (The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 3 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
he ae
17
MR. DUBE: I further proposed a stipulation that
bargaining unit employees are permitted a 30-minute
lunch or meal period once during each shift worked.
On each shift unit employees are scheduled for meals
during one of the following period: First the day
shift: 11 a.m. to 11:30 a.m., 11:45 a.m. to 12:15
p.m., 12:30 p.m. to 1 p.m.; the evening shift: 7:30
p.m. to 8 p.m., 8:15 p.m. to 8:45 p.m., 9 p.m. to 9:30
p.m.; the night shift: 3:15 a.m. to 3:45 a.m., 4 a.m.
to 4:30 a.m.
Mark these as Joint Exhibit 4.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 4 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I further propose to stipulate that
in addition to the 30-minute lunch period, unit em-
ployees who work directly on production lines on the
day and evening shifts are entitled to a five-minute
washup period prior to commencement of the meal
period. Approximately 50 percent of the employees
on those shifts are so situated. The direct produc-
tion line employees described just previously are also
permitted two 22-minute rest periods on each shift
worked.
Joint Exhibit 4 is a true and accurate copy of the
collective bargaining agreement dated October 31,
1973, effect- [9] ive November 19, 1973, between
Ford Motor Company and the United Auto Workers,
and I would offer Joint Exhibit 4.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 4 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
18
MR. DUBE: Joint Exhibit 4 contains on Page
198, in Article 4, Section 4(a) limitations on the
scheduling of rest periods.
JUDGE WINKLER: That is the only reason for
which this document is being offered?
MR. ROONEY: No.
MR. DUBE: No.
JUDGE WINKLER: What else is it being offered
for?
MR. ROONEY: For the zipper clause.
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay. Let me just say
this: With respect to, you know, large documents
that might contain matters extraneous to what we
have here, it will be incumbent upon each of the
parties to indicate precisely what you are relying on.
You needn’t do it now, but before the hearing closes
you can do it, you will do it. And I will be under-
standing of the respective problems of respective
parties.
MR. DUBE: Mark this as Joint Exhibit 5.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 5 for identification. )
[10] MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate the docu-
ment which has been marked for identification as
Joint Exhibit 5 is a true and accurate representation
of the location and arrangement of the Chicago
Stamping Plant. Distances in proportion on the ex-
hibit are shown to approximate but not exact scale.
The total area depicted by the exhibit is approxi-
mately one-half mile in length and one-half mile in
width. Plant buildings depicted occupy an area ap-
proximately one-quarter mile in length and one-
quarter mile in width. I would also note for the
19
record that there are some—there is a legend at the
lower left-hand corner of the exhibit which is not
being offered as part of the exhibit. It is color-
coded.
JUDGE WINKLER: What about these numbers
and letters on the exhibit?
MR. DUBE: We will get into those.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )|
JUDGE WINKLER: Joint Exhibit 5 is received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 5 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I propose a further stipulation that
bargaining unit employees on all shifts work in vari-
ous locations throughout the plant. The only air-
conditioned plant areas [11] either working or non-
working which unit employees regularly enter are the
cafeterias and coke cribs. Each bargaining unit em-
ployee is provided a locker. With the exception of
approximately two dozen employees who have addi-
tional lockers located elsewhere in the plant, all lock-
ers are located along the mezzanine. The mezzanine
is reached from ground level by means of five inside
stairways indicated on Joint Exhibit 5 by notation
of the letters A, B, C, D and E.
(Discussion off the record.)
MR. DUBE: I would propose to further stipulate
that the mezzanine referred to is a second-floor area
in the plant which runs on Joint Exhibit 5 approxi-
20
mately from the letter A to a notation marked on
Joint Exhibit 5 as F.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record.)
MR. DUBE: The Chicago Stamping Plant main-
tains three in-plant dining rooms, the Executive din-
ing room, salaried cafeteria, and hourly cafeteria.
Bargaining unit employees are permitted to use only
the hourly cafeteria. The hourly cafeteria is located
on the second floor of the plant mezzanine and is open
only from 5 a.m. to 8 a.m. for breakfast and during
the regularly scheduled lunch or meal periods. The
hourly cafeteria is equipped with seats and tables, and
has a seating capacity of 400 to 500. Three serving
lines are operated in the hourly cafeteria. Two lines
pass by [12] steam tables and offer hot meals and
beverages. The third line offers a limited menue of
hotdogs, sandwiches and beverages.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record.)
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
MR. DUBE: I would further propose to stipu-
late that the hourly cafeteria is open during shift
change periods but that no food is served or avail-
able in the hourly cafeteria except from vending
machines located therein.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
MR. ROONEY: Agreed.
MR. DUBE: The unit employees bringing food
or beverages into the stamping plant are required
to store such items in their personal lockers. Em-
ployees are not permitted to eat or drink except in
EAE St! ll ica
PAD Re AO ay CPO eGR
4 ete <n hie otic wll,
21
the plant cafeterias and coke cribs. Employees are
not permitted to carry food or beverages or per-
sonal clothing not required for work into working
areas of the plant. There is no refrigeration equip-
ment in the locker area or anywhere else in the plant
available for unit employees to refrigerate food or
beverage items.
Would you mark these as Joint Exhibit 6?
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 6 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate a document
which has [13] been marked for identification as
Joint Exhibit 6 is a true and accurate copy of the
collective bargaining agreement between Ford Motor
Company and the United Auto Workers, dated De-
cember 7, 1970, and I would offer Joint Exhibit 6.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Ex-
hibit No. 6 for identification, was received in
evidence. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Let’s continue.
MR. DUBE: Would you mark these as Joint
Exhibits 7 and 8?
(The documents referred to were marked Joint
Exhibits Nos. 7 and 8 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that Joint
Exhibit 7, a document that has been marked for
identification, is a true and accurate copy of the
22
collective bargaining agreement between Local Union
No. 588, United Auto Workers, and Ford Stamping
Plant, effective June 20, 1974. I would—
VOICE: I wouldn’t stipulate to that.
JUDGE WINKLER: Would you stipulate the
document is what it purports to be?
VOICE: It’s a local agreement, printed by the
Local.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
[14] (Discussion off the record.)
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
Let the record show that we are receiving Joint
Exhibit 7 as a document, the parties further agree,
is what it purports to be, and with the understand-
ing that should any of the parties discover some in-
accurgcies that might be relevant and material to
this pom they will call it to opposing Counsel’s at-
tention and a proper stipulation will then be entered
into and made a part of the record in this case. All
right?
MR. ROONEY: Agreed.
MR.SCHUR: Agreed.
MR. DUBE: All right.
JUDGE WINKLER: 7 is received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 7 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that a docu-
ment marked Joint Exhibit 8 is a collective bargain-
ing agreement between Local 588, United Auto
Workers, and the Ford Stamping Plant, Chicago
Heights, Illinois, effective December 11, 1970.
MR. ROONEY: Same stipulation.
eee a eee ee A
.
23
JUDGE WINKLER: All right. 8 is received
with the same reservation indicated with respect to
Joint Exhibit 7.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 8 for identi- [15] fication, was received in
evidence. )
MR DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that in
Joint Exhibits 7 and 8 where particular agreements
contained therein have a date earlier than the effec-
tive date of the contract that the dates set forth in
the particular agreement reflect the date of initial
agreement thereto.
JUDGE WINKLER: I don’t understand that.
MR. DUBE: Some of the—in those books, which
have effective dates on the cover, some of the in-
dividual agreements have dates three, six, nine years
earlier typed in, and this is just to clarify the record
to show that where those dates are shown, that date
shown on the individual page represents the date of
initial agreement on that issue.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
MR. DUBE: Mark this as Joint Exhibit 9.
(The documents referred to were marked Joint
Exhibits 9 and 10 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that on June
19, 1974, Respondent by its Plant Industrial Rela-
tions Manager, L. P. Cecchini, C-e-c-c-h-i-n-i, sent two
letters to Local 588 President Richard Marco, and
that the letters marked as Joint Exhibits 9 and 10
are true and accurate copies of the letters sent by
Mr. Cecchini and received by Mr. Marco.
[16] JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
24
(The documents heretofore marked Joint Ex-
hibits Nos. 9 and 10 for identification, were re-
ceived in evidence. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose a stipulation that on
July 2nd, 1976, the International Union, United Auto
Workers, by its Vice President Ken Bannon, B-a-n-
n-o-n, mailed a letter to Mr. L. Denise, D-e-n-i-s-e,
then Respondent’s Vice President of Labor Relations.
Joint Exhibit 11 is a true and accurate of the letter
sent by Mr. Bannon and received by Mr. Denise.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 11 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
MR. DUBE: I should correct that stipulation and
propose an amendment to that stipulation, Your
Honor. Joint Exhibit 11 was not sent to Mr. Denise
but was sent to—
JUDGE WINKLER: Ford Motor Company, At-
tention: Mr. McKenna?
MR. DUBE: Right.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good.
MR. DUBE: Would you mark that Joint Exhibit
12?
[17] (The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 12 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate and
offer, based on the stipulation, the document marked
. ARG ae > a Ton te
ere eee
25
as Joint Exhibit 12, which is a letter dated July
2nd, 1973, from Mr. Bannon to Mr. Denise.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 12 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that
Local 588 does not admit to membership or represent
for purposes of collective bargaining employees other
than employees of Respondent employed at the Chi-
cago Stamping Plant. Other than Local 588, no other
labor organization represents any employees of Re-
spondent at the Chicago Stamping Plant.
MR. ROONEY: Just a minute. I would like to
go off the record.
(Discussion off the record.
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
Thus far the parties have stipulated to everything
that has been proposed. There is some stipulation
that Respondent desires in connection with the last
mentioned stipulation to the effect that—mentioning
Local 588—Respondent desires to point out, which
in fact the General Counsel [18] alleges in his Com-
plaint, that the International and not Local 588 is the
certified bargaining representative. Is that correct,
sir?
MR. ROONEY: Yes.
JUDGE WINKLER: Continue, please.
MR. DUBE: Mark that as Joint Exhibit 13.
(The documents referred to were marked Jvint
Exhibits Nos. 13, 14 and 15 for identification. )
26
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that
the document marked for identification as Joint Ex-
hibit 13 is a true and correct copy of a letter sent
to Mr. Tom Brown by Mr. Richard Marco, sent by
Mr. Marco on or about February 13, 1976, and re-
ceived by Mr. Brown.
JUDGE WINKLER: Can we identify Mr.
Brown?
MR. DUBE: Industrial Relations Manager of the
Ford Motor Company.
JUDGE WINKLER: I think that is identified
through the Pleadings, as I recall. That is very good.
Joint Exhibit 13 is received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 13 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I would also propose to stipulate
that the document marked as Joint Exhibit 14 is a
true and accurate copy of a letter dated March
23rd, 1976, sent to the same [19] Mr. Brown by the
same Mr. Marco and received by Mr. Brown.
JUDGE WINKLER: Joint Exhibit 14 is received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 14 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: And I would propose to stipulate
that the document marked as Joint Exhibit 15 is a
true and accurate copy of a letter dated February
18, 1976, sent to Mr. Marco by Mr. Brown on or
about February 18, 1976, and received by Mr. Marco.
JUDGE WINKLER: Joint Exhibit 15 is received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
i)
)
3
;
27
No. 15 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that
on April 9, 1976, at a meeting between representa-
tives of Local 588 and the Ford Motor Company,
Chicago Stamping Plant, Industrial Relations Man-
ager Brown verbally informed Local 588’s repre-
sentatives that Respondent refused to provide to Lo-
eal 588 the information requested in Joint Exhibit
14, and that Respondent refused to bargain about
cafeteria and vending machine prices.
I further propose to stipulate that on various dates
since April 9, 1976, Local 588 has requested that
Respondent bargain with Local 588 about cafeteria
and vending machine prices. On each occasion Re-
spondent has refused to bargain [20] about those
subjects.
With regard to the last stipulation concerning
various dates since April 9th, 1976, I would propose
that stipulation be amended to include the word
prices, so it would read “cafeteria and vending ma-
chine prices and services.”
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that ARA
Enterprises, Incorporated, maintains a staff of ARA
employees on duty at the Chicago Stamping Plant.
ARA employees are engaged in preparing and serv-
ing food in cafeterias and in servicing and repairing
vending machines in the plant under the supervision
of an ARA Manager working in the Chicago Stamp-
ing Plant.
In July, 1973, Respondent and Local 588 com-
menced negotiations for a new Local agreement.
Negotiations continued until June, 1974, when Joint
Exhibit 7 was agreed upon. At various times during
the negotiations Local 588 requested that Respondent
bargain concerning cafeteria and vending machine
prices and services. Respondent’s representatives
replied to those requests by stating that those issues
were not proper subjects for bargaining. No written
or verbal agreement was concluded on cafeteria and
vending machine prices.
MR. ROONEY: With respect to that, of course
the same reservation on Exhibit 7 still applies.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
[21] (Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that cafeteria
and vending machine services in the Chicago Stamp-
ing Plant have been provided since 1970 by ARA
Enterprises, Incorporated. Prior to the commence-
ment of such services by ARA Enterprises, cafeteria
and vending machine services were provided by Al
Green Enterprises, Incorporated.
Mark this as Joint Exhibit 16.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. i6 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate and offer,
based on the stipulation, Joint Exhibit 16 as a true
and accurate copy of General Plant Rules and Regu-
lations distributed to bargaining unit employees at
the Chicago Stamping Plant.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 16 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. DUBE: Mark this as Joint Exhibit 17.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 17 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate and offer,
based on the stipulation, Joint Exhibit 17 as a true
and accurate copy of prices for the items shown ef-
fective February 9th, [22] 1976. These prices are
the retail sales price or cost to the consumer buying
them in the Chicago Stamping Plant.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 17 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
MR. ROONEY: Hold it.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
( Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: 17 is received.
MR. DUBE: Mark that Joint 18.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 18 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose a stipulation that
Joint Exhibit 18 shows selling prices of the items
listed on November 11th, 1975.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 18 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: We will be back at 1:30.
(Whereupon, at 12:40 p.m., the hearing in the
above-entitled matter was recessed until 1:30
p.m. this same day.)
30
[23] AFTERNOON SESSION
MR. DUBE: I propose to stipulate that in ad-
dition to the hourly cafeteria the following food
service facilities are maintained in the Chicago
Stamping Plant and are open to bargaining unit em-
ployees. First, Satellite Cafeteria. The Satellite
Cafeteria consists of an enclosed, air-conditioned
room equipped with chairs and tables and having a
seating capacity of 50 to 100 persons. No steam table
or cafteria service is provided in the Satellite Cafe-
teria. The room is equipped only with approximately
12 coin-operated vending machines. Sold in the vend-
ing machines are hot and cold sandwiches, stews,
soups, spaghetti, potato chips, pastry, ice cream,
candy, soft drinks, and milk. In additior. to the above,
the Satellite Cafeteria houses two coin-operated cof-
fee machines. The location of the Satellite Cafeteria
is shown on Joint Exhibit 5 by notation of the num-
ber One.
The Stamping Plant also houses five coke cribs or
vending machine areas. Each coke crib is an en-
closed, air-conditioned room equipped with approxi-
mately 12 coin-operated vending machines dispens-
ing cigarettes and all of the items dispensed in the
Satellite Cafeteria. Of the five coke cribs in the plant,
four are equipped with two coffee vending machines
each. The remaining coke crib houses three coffee
machines. The coke cribs are equipped with [24]
chairs but no tables. Each of the coke cribs has a
capacity of 40 to 50 persons with an exception of one
coke crib at the southern part of the plant with a
capacity of 75 to 100 persons.
<
31
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Interruption at door. )
JUDGE WINKLER: All right. Let’s continue.
MR. DUBE: The locations of the five coke cribs
are indicated on Joint Exhibit 5 by notation of the
letters G, H, I, J, and K. The largest, southern coke
crib referred to is identified by the letter notation
I. The coke crib labeled K on Joint Exhibit 5, ap-
pearing near the designation for the Satellite Cafe-
teria, is at ground level below the Satellite Cafeteria.
On or about February 6th, 1976, at a meeting of
representatives of Respondent and Local 588, con-
vened for the purpose of discussing unrelated issues,
Respondent by its Plant Industrial Relations Man-
ager, Thomas Brown, informed Local 588 effective
February 9th, 1976, cafeteria and vending machine
prices would be increased. No specific information or
—no specific information or information about the
amount of the increases was furnished. Local 588
had received no notice of said increases prior to the
meeting on February 6th.
At the same meeting after Respondent’s announce-
ment of [25] increases, Local 588’s President Marco
requested that the increases be postponed until after
discussions between Respondent and Local 588. Mr.
Brown responded verbally at the meeting that such
a postponement was not possible.
MR. ROONEY: In that respect, I would like to
say that—we are still stipulating—they were in-
creased by ARA, not by us.
JUDGE WINKLER: Is that accepted?
MR. DUBE: Yes.
32
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay. That stipulation is
noted with the modification proposed by Respondent’s
Counsel.
MR. DUBE: Mark this Joint Exhibit 19.
(The documents referred to were marked Joint
Exhibits Nos. 19 and 20 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that
Joint Exhibit 19 is a list of information about restau-
rants in the vicinity of the Chicago Stamping Plant;
Joint Exhibit 19 was prepared on behalf of the
Charging Party; that Joint Exhibit 20 is also a list
of information about restaurants in the area of the
Stamping Plant; Joint Exhibit 20 was prepared on
behalf of the Respondent. We would propose to
stipulate that Joint Exhibits 19 and 20 are admis-
sible for the truth of the matter asserted on each
exhibit, but that by so stipulating to their admis-
sibility, neither party—no party is stipulating to the
truth of the matter [26] asserted on this.
JUDGE WINKLER: I don’t quite understand
this. I thought you said you were stipulating to the
truth. Then you say you are not stipulating to the
truth.
MR. DUBE: Stipulating to the admissibility in
order to determine the truth.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
Let the record show that the parties are stipulat-
ing that the information contained on both 19 and
20 is accurate, with the further stipulation respect-
ing Joint Exhibit 20 that the column listed “Time”,
the parties are stipulating that the test period used
in driving the mileage indicated was done at approxi-
mately 12 to 12:30 noon, is that correct?
VOICE: In that vicinity, yes.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good. Received.
(The documents heretofore marked Joint Ex-
hibits Nos. 19 and 20 for identification, were
received in evidence. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Continue, please.
MR. DUBE: We would propose to stipulate that
beginning on February 16th, 1976, and ending on or
about June 7th, 1976, there was a boycott by Local
588 members of the cafeteria and vending opera-
tions. The cafeteria boycott [27] continued until
May 19th and the vending machine boycott continued
until June 7th. Substantially in excess of half of
the members of Local 588 observed the boycott dur-
ing these periods and refrained from using the cafe-
teria and vending machines.
JUDGE WINKLER: That stipulation is noted.
MR.SCHUR: Could we go off the record?
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
MR. DUBE:. I would propose a further stipula-
tion regarding Joint Exhibits 19 and 20, which have
already been received. Regarding Joint Exhibit 19,
I propose to stipulate that that exhibit be received
with the exception of the price information shown
thereon. And I propose to stipulate that Joint Ex-
hibit 20 be received with the exception of the time
information shown thereon.
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay. The stipulation modi-
fying the earlier stipulation is noted.
Okay.
34
MR. DUBE: Mark this as Joint Exhibit 21.
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 21 for identification. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record. )
[28] MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate and
offer, based on the stipulation, a set of documents
marked as Joint Exhibit 21, consisting of a letter
dated March 7th, 1972; a letter dated February 11,
1972; a catering vending agreement executed Febru-
ary llth, 1972, signed by Sidney Kelly, K-e-l-l-y,
Secretary of Ford Motor Company; and some blank
forms appended to the agreement. I will offer Joint
Exhibit 21.
JUDGE WINKLER: Received.
(The document heretofore marked Joint Exhibit
No. 21 for identification, was received in evi-
dence. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Anything else?
MR. ROONEY: Yes.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Short recess taken.)
MR. ROONEY: The parties are stipulating the—
to the following additional stipulation: In some
months revenues exceed costs and in some months
the opposite has occurred. When revenues exceed
costs, the Employer realizes income, and when costs
exceed revenues a loss occurs. For all recent years,
the operation has been on a loss basis and the Em-
ployer has made up the loss to ARA.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good. The stipulation
is received.
MR. ROONEY: Could we go off the record?
[29] (Discussion off the record.)
JUDGE WINKLER: Do we have any more stip-
ulations?
MR. ROONEY: Yes.
The following representative data is submitted by
the parties as an additional stipulation: In the period
January 10th through January 16th, 1976, the total
customer count at the—
(Conference off the record. )
MR. ROONEY: —at the cafeterias was 3,947; a
total hourly cafeteria count 3,873—hourly population
was 3,750.
(Conference off the record.)
MR. ROONEY: This is for the main cafeteria in
the facility. There were 3,873 hourly employees dur-
ing this period. During the period February 28th
through March 5th, 1976, the total customer count
was 875 total—820 hourly cafeteria and a total plant
population of 3,950.
With respect to the period 1-10 through 1-16-76,
the plant population is approximately 3,750. During
the period November 15th through November 21st,
1975, there was a total customer count of 3,938,
hourly—3,865; plant population, 3,755. As used here
“hourly” means hourly people using the cafeteria.
11-15 through 11-21-75 showed 3,938 total customer
count; 3,865 in the hourly cafeteria; 3,755, plant pop-
ulation. October 12th through October 18th, 1974,
36
showed 6,745 total customer count; 5,600 in the hour-
ly [30] cafeteria; 4,445, total plant population.
In the period 1-10 through 1-16-76 in the vending
sales, customer count showed 70,560 units sold; in
the period 2-28 through 3-5-76, the number was
16,741 units sold. And between November 15th and
November 21st, 1975, units sold were 61,568; and in
the period October 12th through October 18th, 1974,
units sold were 96,279.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good.
MR. ROONEY: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record.)
MR. ROONEY: With respect to the figures given
for plant population, it includes the total plant popula-
tion and not just the hourly employees represented by
Local 588.
MR. DUBE: Would you mark this Joint Exhibit
22?
(The document referred to was marked Joint
Exhibit No. 22 for identification. )
MR. DUBE: I would propose to stipulate that
Joint Exhibit 22 is an accurate collection of lists
showing the number and type of vending machines
in the hourly cafeteria, Satellite Cafeteria, and coke
cribs previously described in the record, and to stipu-
late that the Satellite Cafeteria is denominated on
Joint Exhibit 22 as Plant Location Z-20 Upper.
JUDGE WINKLER: 22 is received.
[31] (The document heretofore marked Joint Ex-
hibit No. 22 for identification, was received in
evidence. )
37
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
(Discussion off the record.)
MR. DUBE: Your Honor, I think we have reach-
ed the end of the stipulations that we have negoti-
ated.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good.
You have some witnesses or a witness to call?
MR. DUBE: Ido. I would like to take about five
minutes to check over my notes on questions so I
don’t spend time needlessly.
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay. Let’s come back at
3 o'clock.
(Short recess taken.)
JUDGE WINKLER: Will General Counsel please
call his witness?
MR. DUBE: General Counsel calls Richard Mar-
co.
RICHARD W. MARCO,
called as a witness for and on behalf of Counsel for
the General Counsel herein, and after having been
first duly sworn, was examined and testified as fol-
lows:
JUDGE WINKLER: Please be seated, sir, and
state your name and address.
THE WITNESS: My name is Richard W. Marco,
M-a-r-c-o. My business address is 21540 South Cot-
- Grove Avenue. [32] That is in Chicago Heights,
inois.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
Q (By Mr. Dube) You are President of Local
588, Mr. Marco?
A Yes, that is correct.
38
Q Do you hold any other title or position with
Local 588? a .
A Iam Chairman of the Bargaining Committee
by virtue of my election to President.
Q How long have you held those offices?
A Since June of 1972.
Q Had you held any Union offices before 1972?
A Five out of the six years prior to that I was a
District Committeeman.
Q Have you ever worked in the Chicago Stamp-
ing Plant yourself?
A Yes. I have been employed by Ford at the
Chicago Heights Stamping Plant since July 23rd,
1956.
What kind of work do you do for Ford?
I am a die maker.
Are you a full-time Union officer now?
Yes.
Do you ever work in the Stamping Plant?
On occasion, to work overtime, I work in the
plant with my tools, but other than that I am on full-
time Union duties, which do take me in the plant.
[33] Q How often do you go into the plant?
A Almost daily.
Q I think the record will show that there are nor-
mally three shifts of employees at the Chicago Stamp-
ing Plant. Do bargaining unit employees normally
work on Saturdays and Sundays?
A The history over the 20 years I have been
there is that a good deal of the employees do work
on Saturdays and sometimes on Sunday. More re-
cently, since ’74, there hasn’t been as much overtime.
>O PO PO
Q Is the hourly cafeteria open on Saturdays and
Sundays?
A Only when there is a significant number of
hourly employees that are working those shifts. It’s
a very slight number. Their cafeteria is not open for
hot meals.
Q How often on Saturday and Sunday is the
hourly cafeteria open?
A In the 20 year history I would say that approxi-
mately 75 percent of the time it’s been open.
Q Is the Satellite Cafeteria open on Saturdays
and Sundays?
A I would say rarely on Sundays. It’s open—I
don’t believe they lock it as such. A person could
go in there but officially it’s not open on Sundays;
only when there’s shipping activity.
Q What about—there is an exhibit showing—
there is [34] a stipulation on scheduled lunch periods
at the Chicago Stamping Plant. Is the Satellite Cafe-
teria open for all of those?
A Officially the Satellite Cafeteria is only open
for the latter two lunch periods of the three on the
two production shifts; or maybe, put another way, it
is not open for the lunch periods on days and after-
noons officially.
Q How do most bargaining unit employees get to
and from the Chicago Stamping Plant?
A Almost all of them drive or ride in a car pool.
Q There is a stipulation there is some bus service
in the area of the Stamping Plant. Is there a bus
stop outside the plant itself?
A No, there is no marked busstop. The people, I
would presume, would have to stop the bus at the
traffic light.
40
Q In the course of a normal day or a normal
week, how many employees have you observed using
the bus to get to or from work?
A I don’t recall observing anyone use the bus
coming to or going from work, although it wouldn’t
surprise me if someone did, but it’s very slight, if
any.
" Now, there is some stipulations that cover rest
periods or break time for direct production employees.
Are there bargaining unit employees, other than those
direct production employees?
[35] A Yes. There is indirect, Production Control
Department employees and skilled tradesmen.
Q Do those people get breaks in an eight-hour
shift in addition to their lunch period?
A Yes, they do, but not with any specified amount
of time or with tag relief as the production employees
do.
JUDGE WINKLER: May I ask where we are go-
ing with this? What are we trying to accomplish
with this? I am not trying to be critical. I am just
asking. Maybe we can short circuit.
MR. DUBE: Toestablish there are break periods.
JUDGE WINKLER: And that employees use the
eating facilities, right? Is that it?
MR. DUBE: The length of break period and
the fact that the witness would testify that employees
are not allowed to leave the plant during those break
periods.
JUDGE WINKLER: Is there any question about
that?
MR. ROONEY: I don’t think it is feasible for
them to leave in a break period.
JUDGE WINKLER: Let the record show the
parties are stipulating—apart from their luncheon
41
period, the parties are stipulating in view of the
time limitation it is not feasib.e for the employees
to leave during the break period. Is that a fair state-
ment?
MR. SCHUR: It goes further than the time limi-
tation.
[36] JUDGE WINKLER: Would the parties stip-
ulate thus far—
VOICE: It’s nota rule. He can get a pass and go.
JUDGE WINKLER: The parties are not stipu-
lating to that?
MR. ROONEY: It’s not feasible to me, but the
party can get a pass and go.
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay. Proceed.
MR. ROONEY: We admit it is not eafeasible.
JUDGE WINKLER: The Respondent concedes it
is not feasible for the employees to leave the plant
during these break periods. Okay.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Are employees permitted to
leave the plant during break periods?
JUDGE WINKLER: Isn’t it enough that Re-
spondent concedes it is not feasible for them to leave?
MR. SCHUR: We would like to show, Your Hon-
or, that it is not permitted in addition to not being
feasible.
JUDGE WINKLER: The Respondent concedes
the practicality so you don’t even have to reach the
other issue.
MR. DUBE: Weii, all right. There is another
question beyond this that goes to the captive audi-
ence issue basically, that employees are not permitted
to leave the building during break periods. And I
will explain the relevance of that.
JUDGE WINKLER: Well, I can understand the
relevance, [37] but it seems to me that is sort of
subsumed in the other thing.
MR. DUBE: I am trying to work around the
unfinished edges of those stipulations.
I am not sure if you answered the last question
or not.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Do you recall the last ques-
tion?
A The last question you asked, as I recall, are
people permitted to leave the premises for their break
time, and the answer is no, not to my knowledge, they
are not allowed to leave.
JUDGE WINKLER: Even if they were allowed
to leave, would it be feasible for them to leave?
THE WITNESS: No, sir, it would not.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Are employees allowed to go
outside the plant although staying on the plant
grounds during break period?
A No. They would be charged with loitering.
They are supposed to stay in the building.
Q Okay. Are bargaining unit employees permitted
to go into the hourly cafeteria with a brown-bag
lunch and just buy a beverage?
A During the lunch period, yes.
Q What about during break periods?
A They are not allowed in there during break
periods.
Q In a normal day or a normal week, have you
seen any [38] food trucks, food vendors, mobil food
vendors, outside the plant property?
A No.
Q Have you ever seen such vehicles on plant prop-
erty?
A No, never.
Q Have you ever seen employees pick up deliver-
ies of food immediately outside the plant?
JUDGE WINKLER: I think the witness just
answered that question.
THE WITNESS: No, I have not.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Is there any specific proce
dure that a bargaining unit employee has to follow
when leaving the plant during a shift?
A Yes, there is.
Q Could you explain that procedure?
A The employee must get a pass from his super-
visor, which is permission to leave the plant, and
then most often they are required to punch out their
time card, and when they leave the building they
get into their automobile, and as they leave the plant
premises they leave the pass that they got from their
supervisor with the plant security guard at the exit
open to Cottage Grove Avenue. On their return they
must get checked back in by the guard. And I be-
lieve the guard gives them the pass back, which they
in turn give back to their foreman when they return
to work and punch [39] their time card back in.
Q That security location you mentioned, that is
outside the plant building?
A It is outside the building and on the exit from
the parking lot to Cottage Grove Avenue.
Q Are there any locations inside the building
where an employee would have to stop while either
going out or coming back from such a trip?
A Occasionally a person leaving the plant at lunch
time would be stopped at the Security Office, which is
on the mezzanine, and asked to identify himself and
produce a pass as to where he was going and make
sure it was authorized.
44
Q Could you describe this exit or gate near Cot-
tage Grove Avenue?
A Location of it?
Q The physical appearance of the gate itself.
A Well, there is a guard shack that is right in
the middle, and there is one lane of traffic coming
in and one going out on each side. There is a rail-
road crossing type gate that is activated by the guard.
It must be raised before a car can go out, or on the
other side it must be raised to allow a car to enter.
Q Are employees the only vehicle drivers who
would use that gate?
[40] A No. All materials that are shipped out of
the plant by truck, or any deliveries made, come
through that same entrance.
JUDGE WINKLER: We are talking again about
the possibility of an employee wanting to leave in a
break period or are we talking about luncheon?
MR. ROONEY: Any time.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
Q (By Mr. Dube) All right. Mr. Marco, you
testified there is one traffic lane or one vehicle lane
in each direction, inbound and outbound. Have you
ever seen cars or vehicles lined up at that gate,
either inbound or outbound, around the time of the
meal break period?
A Yes, I have.
Q In your term of service as District Committee-
man or Local President, are you aware of any cases
where employees have been disciplined from return-
ing after leaving the plant during a shift?
A Yes, lam aware. I am aware of many of them.
I represented as many as five employees on one oc-
casion, as I can recall as a District Committeeman,
45
and I have bargained on grievances involving dis-
cipline in regard to numerous other cases over the
years.
Q Are there any restrictions or rules on where
a bargaining unit employee can eat food and drink
beverages in the [41] Stamping Plant?
A Yes. They are limited to eating or drinking
in the cafeteria or in the employee break areas or
coke cribs. They are not allowed anywhere else.
Q What about the locker areas on the mezzanine?
A They are not to eat in there. Only in the cafe-
teria or coke cribs.
Q Are you aware of any instances where em-
ployees have been disciplined for eating in the areas
other than you have described?
A I know of employees who have been told to
leave and admonished for being in there. Formally
I don’t know that they were disciplined.
Q Now, it appears from the stipulation that the
locker areas on the mezzanine are not air-conditioned.
What kind of ventilation, if any, is provided in the
locker areas on the mezzanine?
A There are some ventilating ducts coming into
that vicinity, but they don’t seem to do much good.
It is very hot and sticky and smelly in there. If there
is any air moving it doesn’t seem noticeable.
Q When you say “hot” do you know what heat the
inside of the plant reaches during the summer?
MR. RONNEY: Objection.
JUDGE WINKLER: What basis?
[42] MR. ROONEY: I don’t see what this has to
do with this case at all, the heat in the plant in the
summer.
46
MR. DUBE: Well, the argument is that there are
—in a plant where there is heat or where there are
fumes or odors that that is the disincentive to carry
and use a brown-bag lunch, in addition to the fact
the record already shows that the vending machines
and cafeteria areas are air-conditioned, which may
be an incentive to use those if the rest of the plant
is unpleasantly hot.
JUDGE WINKLER: Are they, or not, permitted
to bring their brown bags into the cafeteria?
MR. DUBE: Yes, they are allowed to bring them
in. I think the question goes to where it is kept in
the meantime.
JUDGE WINKLER: Where what is kept?
MR. SCHUR: One, if I may state so, one of the
thrusts of the question is to determine that the
locker room is very hot, which would lead to food
spoilage in the event an employee would bring his
lunch and store it in the locker room, which is the
only place he could store it.
JUDGE WINKLER: Objection overruled, if that
is the basis for it.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Do you recall what the last
question was?
[43] JUDGE WINKLER: You asked about the—
THE WITNESS: If I recall, temperatures in the
plant. The answer is yes, because routinely in the
summertime we take temperature readings through-
out the plant, and we have taken a large number of
those surveys year after year. I do recall tempera-
tures in excess of 100 degrees in the plant during the
summertime.
JUDGE WINKLER: Would it be rare to go
above 90, for example?
47
THE WITNESS: No, not at all.
JUDGE WINKLER: Would it be unusual to go
above 80?
In other words, does it frequently go above 80
in the summertime?
THE WITNESS: It frequently goes above a
hundred.
JUDGE WINKLER: Okay.
MR. DUBE: Would you mark these as General
Counsel’s Exhibit 2?
(The documents referred to were marked Gen-
eral Counsel’s Exhibit No. 2 for identification.)
Q (By Mr. Dube) Mr. Marco, I am going to
ask you to look at what has been marked for iden-
tification as General Counsel’s Exhibit 2, and ask if
you can identify that.
A Yes. I recognize this as a copy of a survey
similar to those that I told you we frequently take
in the summertime. This particular one was taken
at my direction in [44] August of 1973.
JUDGE WINKLER: Was this an unusually hot
day, do you recall?
THE WITNESS: On the first page, Your Honor,
it lists the temperature outdoors on that particular
day.
JUDGE WINKLER: Was this particularly hot
in the sense—was it hot as compared with other
days? That is what I am after. For example, on
that day outdoors it was 96 at 2 p.m. What about
August 26th or August 28th? Do you have any idea?
The point of the question is how accurate a sampline
is this one example; that is what I am asking.
48
THE WITNESS: I think in relationship to the
temperature outside, if it was 90 degrees on the
next day, Your Honor, it would be cooler inside as
well.
JUDGE WINKLER: I suppose I am not able to
communicate.
MR. DUBE: Your Honor, are you asking what
would be the average summer temperature in the
Chicago Heights area?
JUDGE WINKLER: That is what I am asking,
if you know.
THE WITNESS: I don’t know, Your Honor.
MR. DUBE: Your Honor, I would offer General
Counsel’s Exhibit 2.
JUDGE WINKLER: We will take General Coun-
sel’s 2 as indicating the temperature as of that date,
August 27th, ’73.
(The document heretofore marked General Coun-
sel’s Exhibit No. 2 for identification, was re-
ceived [45] in evidence. )
Q (By Mr. Dube) Mr. Marco, do you make your
home in the Chicago Heights area?
A Yes. I live about three and three-quarter
miles from the plant in the Village of South Chicago
Heights, which is adjacent to the City of Chicago
Heights.
Q How long have you lived in the area of Chicago
Heights?
A At the present location, 16 years; and prior
to that I lived three years, three or four years, in
Glenwood, which is adjacent on the north to Chicago
Heights.
49
Q From your experience in living in the Chicago
Heights area, do you recall the temperature reaching
95 each summer?
A Frequently. It’s not uncommon or unusual at
all.
Q Concerning the possibility of spoilage of food,
Mr. Marco, have you as Union Officer received com-
plaints, any complaints, of actual food spoilage from
unit employees?
A Yes, I have.
MR. ROONEY: Objection, Your Honor. That is
all hearsay.
MR. SCHUR: It’s not offered, Your Honor, neces-
sarily to prove—
JUDGE WINKLER: It really is. On the other
hand, I will take it, even though technically I see
the point of your objection.
THE WITNESS: Yes, I have received complaints
of spoilage, people bringing their lunch.
[46] JUDGE WINKLER: When was the last
time you got such a complaint, if you remember?
THE WITNESS: It was in May of 1976.
JUDGE WINKLER: All right.
THE WITNESS: Those were numerous com-
plaints, too, not just an isolated one in May.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Mr. Marco, you testified that
as a Union officer you still go into the plant on a
regular basis. When you go into the plant, have you
had occasion to go into the hourly or Satellite Cafe-
terias or the Coke Cribs during 1976?
A’ Very frequently, yes.
Q For what purpose?
A Well, it is the most convenient place to talk
to people because it is quieter in there as well as
cooler. And otherwise it is very difficult. You have
to shout and scream to get over the noise. So I go in
there frequently.
Q Let me show you what has been received in
the record as Joint Exhibit 17, the food price list
marked effective February 9th, 1976. Are you fa-
miliar with what the prices were for any of the items
on Joint Exhibit 17 prior to February 9th, 1976?
A Most of them were five cents lower; some,
perhaps, ten cents lower prior to February 9th.
Q The record also contains some evidence about
a boycott [47] organized by Local 588 which com-
menced on February 16th. Were any of the items,
any of the food or beverage prices, charged to em-
ployees reduced after February 16th?
A No, they were not.
Q Was there any change in cafeteria prices?
A Not actually. There was a change in method
of dispensing milk from cartons to bulk, but for the
same item in the same form, there was no reduction
in price. With the possible exception of some specials
that were offered.
Q Would you explain what you mean by a
“special”?
A Well, it is not unlike a restaurant.
JUDGE WINKLER: They have loss leaders some-
times, is that it? That is what is known in the retail
trade—
THE WITNESS: I’m not sure it is a loss item,
but frequently—well, maybe not so frequently—in
the past the cafeteria used to offer a special now and
then. I can remember them having spaghetti for 99
cents, and something like that.
51
JUDGE WINKLER: I think—maybe I am tak-
ing too much for granted, but I would presume that
all parties will stipulate that the boycott did not lead
to a diminution in prices, is that correct?
MR. ROONEY: Right.
JUDGE WINKLER: Sostipulated?
MR. DUBE: Sostipulated.
[48] JUDGE WINKLER: I presume that is the
point you were trying to get at?
MR. DUBE: Right.
Q (By Mr. Dube) How was the decision to end
the boycott reached? Was that an individual de-
cision?
JUDGE WINKLER: What difference does tit
make?
MR. DUBE: Well, the basis for the discussion,
~ # discussions, about why the boycott should be
ended.
MR. ROONEY: Your Honor, I don’t see what
this has to do with the union bargaining duty to
bargain cafeteria prices. I imagine he could testify
about ten minutes here about arguments that were
held in the committee that argue to end it or to con-
tinue it.
JUDGE WINKLER: I am afraid we would be
getting into an awful lot of hearsay, if you want to
get into that question. I am guessing as to what you
have in mind.
Let’s see. Did the boycott end as a result of com-
mittee action or as a result of general employee
action, if you know?
THE WITNESS: As a result of committee action.
JUDGE WINKLER: Committee action. And I
guess Counsel would like to ask you why they voted
to end the boycott. Do you know the answer to that?
52
THE WITNESS: The answer to that, the food
they were carrying into the plant was spoiling as the
temperature [49] increased.
JUDGE WINKLER: When was this?
THE WITNESS: In June we finally ended it.
It was becoming too great a sacrifice to ask people
to do in the hot summer.
JUDGE WINKLER: During this period did any-
one go out to lunch, sir?
THE WITNESS: I am sure some people did,
Your Honor, but a very, very, very few, I would
think.
JUDGE WINKLER: It is proportionately very
few, is that it?
THE WITNESS: Yes. I would think possibly
not more than a dozen people during a given lunch
period would go out.
Q (By Mr. Dube); Was that during the boycott
period?
JUDGE WINKLER: We weren’t talking about
boycott period; we were talking generally.
MR. DUBE: Okay.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Just a couple more questions,
Mr. Marco. If you would look at Joint Exhibit 19,
and then I am going to ask you to look at Joint Ex-
hibit 2. Joint Exhibit 19 makes reference to three
groups of restaurants, Group A, Group B, and Group
C. Would you be able to tell us approximately where
the locations are of Groups A, B, and C? If you
could, mark those on Joint Exhibit 2 with a cor-
responding letter A, B, and C.
[50] JUDGE WINKLER: The witness has com-
plied with your request.
53
Q (By Mr. Dube) Mr. Marco, these locations
are all—appear to be west of the Chicago Stamping
Plant. Would you be able to look at 14th Street, also
referred to on the map as Lincoln Highway, and
tell us approximately how many stop lights there
would be between Cottage Grove Avenue and Halsted
Street?
A Well, there is one right at Cottage Grove and
14th Street; there is one in front of the plant that
operates at shift time; there is one at State Street;
there is one at Wentworth; one at East End Ave-
nue; and there is one at Halsted.
Q What about on Halsted north of 14th Street?
A Well, there is on at, I believe it’s 13th, but it
might be 12th; and there is another one at, I believe
it’s 10th Street; there is another one at the Five
Corners; and then one at Joe Orr Road.
Q What about on Vincennes, V-i-n-c-e-n-n-e-s,
Road south of 14th Street? If you don’t recall the
exact location, if you can recall a number, any num-
ber, of the stop lights between 14th Street and Sauk
Trail Road?
A There is one at 15th Street; there is another
one at 16th Street; there is a flashing traffic light at
Main Street; there is a traffic light at 26th Street.
I believe [51] that is all between there and Sauk
Trail. There is one more at—no, I think that is
eliminated now at Illinois Street.
Q During 1976 on any occasions when you spoke
to Mr. Brown or any other representatives of Ford,
did any representative of Ford ever say anything
about Local 588 discussing food service or food prices
with ARA, directly with ARA?
A I don’t think I understand your question.
54
Q All right. During 1976 did Mr. Brown or any
other representative of Ford ever say anything con-
cerning the possibility of Local 588 representatives
discussing food service or food prices directly with
representatives of ARA?
A Yes. We were informed that we could not dis-
cuss them with ARA.
Q Do you recall who told you that?
A Mr. Brown, among others.
JUDGE WINKLER: What would happen if you
would?
THE WITNESS: Well, as a matter of fact, I
attempted to and was told they couldn’t talk to me.
JUDGE WINKLER: ARA said they couldn’t
talk to you?
THE WITNESS: Yes. We requested that a meet-
ing be set up for us with ARA, and the Company
refused.
JUDGE WINKLER: Just off-hand, I don’t know.
I am sure they could tell you—Ford could tell you
not to talk [52] to ARA but it’s a free country, I
guess.
THE WITNESS: In fact, Your Honor, I did go
to the cafeteria manager of ARA. He told me he
couldn’t discuss those matters with me and to see the
company manager.
JUDGE WINKLER: That is something else.
They might refuse to talk to you. I don’t know that
anybody can tell you you can’t. However, I’m al-
ways subject to being educated.
Q (By Mr. Dube) Have you received com-
plaints from bargaining unit employees about the
locker room other than the things you have men-
tioned, heat and humidity?
55
A We have gotten numerous complaints about
cockroaches in the lockers.
Q Have you ever seen cockroaches in the lockers
yourself?
A Yes, I have.
Q Do you know in those cases if any food was
damaged or destroyed by cockroaches?
A Well, I recall a particular day when I went
into the hourly cafeteria and sat down with four
people in the lunch room, and of the four people,
two of them told me they had to just throw their
lunch away because when they opened their dinner
bucket they found a cockroach in there.
MR. ROONEY: I object, Your Honor, to that.
It’s really hearsay and proves nothing.
JUDGE WINKLER: Sustained.
Is that it?
[53] MR. DUBE: Let me check for one moment.
(Conference off the record. )
MR. DUBE: I have nothing further.
JUDGE WINKLER: Cross?
CROSS EXAMINATION
Q (By Mr. Rooney) Mr. Marco, have you ever
complained to the Company about the sanitary con-
ditions in the locker rooms?
A Yes, sir, on numerous occasions.
Q Have they ever done anything?
A They notified us or informed us they would
have the exterminator come in again and again.
Q Have you ever seen the exterminator there?
A Yes.
56
Q You indicated that the traffic light in front
of the plant does not operate at noontime, is that
right?
° I believe it to be steadily on green except at
the shift change times. Then it changes from green
to red and back and forth.
Q You indicated something about gates. Are
those gates operating during lunch periods?
A Yes, they are. :
Q How many times have you seen a tie-up at the
gates?
A Frequently.
Q As frequently as you have seen the temperature
over 95 in Chicago?
[54] MR. SCHUR: I’m going to object to the
question, Your Honor.
JUDGE WINKLER: Sustained.
Q (By Mr. Rooney) Have you a count of the
number of people using the cafeteria during any day?
A No.
Q Now, I show you a document dated April 21,
1976. Do you ever remember seeing this document?
A No, sir, I don’t recall. I believe I was on
vacation at that time?
JUDGE WINKLER: Was that issued by the
Union, sir?
THE WITNESS: I really couldn’t say, Your
Honor. I don’t recall ever seeing it before. It is not
our standard format in any event. It doesn’t look
like what we usually put out. I would be inclined to
say no.
Q (By Mr. Rooney) Now, it says in this docu-
ment that most complaints were that enough con-
cessions were not made in the break area. Did you
ever hear that complaint made by union members?
57
A The members complained that the prices were
not rolled back.
Q Yes.
A That is no concession really, as opposed to not
enough.
Q Who made the decision to suspend the boycott?
A I did at the direction of the Shop Committee,
composed of [55] District Committeemen and Bar-
gaining Committeemen.
Q Did you agather some statistics from the em-
ployees as to their preferences?
A Several weeks prior to actually calling off the
boycott, some time in April, as I recall, there was a
survey taken but once again I wasn’t in town; I was
on vacation. I was informed on my return they had
taken a survey of all the members.
Q And the survey indicated what?
A The survey results, I was told by those who
tabulated them on the Bargaining Committee that
the membership voted, I believe it was 56 percent to
44 percent to continue the boycott. And it did con-
tinue.
JUDGE WINKLER: Was another vote taken
after that to discontinue the boycott?
THE WITNESS: No, Your Honor.
Q (By Mr. Rooney) Did you talk about ex-
tending the boycott to other locals of the UAW out-
side of the plant?
MR.SCHUR: Objection.
MR. DUBE: Objection. First, I don’t see the
relevancy and, second, even if the question was rele-
vant, it is still too vague.
JUDGE WINKLER: I will sustain that objec-
tion.
58
MR. ROONEY: I will withdraw that.
Q (By Mr. Rooney) What were the people do-
ing who were [56] observing the boycott for lunches?
A During the time of the boycott?
Q Yes.
A They were either not eating at all or carrying
food to work.
Q Well, do you think most people were not eat-
ing?
A No. I would think most people were carrying
their lunch as opposed to not eating, but some were
fasting.
Q Now, in your discussions in the Union of the
reasons to end this boycott, the only thing you dis-
cussed was food spoilage?
A No, I don’t think that was the only thing;
that was the factor that made our decision.
Q What else was there that was discussed?
A The lack of progress and anything happening.
JUDGE WINKLER: By “anything happening”,
bringing down the cost of the food?
THE WITNESS: Yes. It appeared that we were
at a hopeless deadlock.
Q (By Mr. Rooney) Did you talk about trying
to get the information—did you talk about attempt-
ing to get the information and compelling the Com-
pany to bargain by other means, and therefore the
boycott was no longer necessary?
A Yes. In April after the Complaint was is-
sued, the National Labor Relations Board Complaint
was issued, we pre- [57] sumed we could work things
out either through that or through the negotiations.
Q So that there were other factors besides spoil-
age of some people’s lunch?
A Yes. But once again, the factor that caused
us to make that decision was the warmer weather
and the spoilage. That was the key factor.
Q How many people can sit in the cafeteria at
one time?
A Just an estimate, I would say between 4- and
500; probably closer to 400. I have never counted
the chairs. Just guessing.
Q How many people are there on the two major
shifts?
A Between 1500 and 1600, I would say.
Q How many lights are there on Joe Orr Road?
A On Joe Orr Road? The only traffic light I
know of—and I presume you are talking about from
the plant in the direction of the restaurants in that
Group A?
Q Yes.
A The only traffic light there would be at the
intersection of 14th Street and Cottage Grove, and at
Halsted Street and Joe Orr. However, there are at
least three stop signs in there—no, two—as opposed
to traffic lights. I think Counsel asked earlier going
in a different direction.
MR. ROONEY: No further questions.
JUDGE WINKLER: Redirect?
[58] MR. SCHUR: I have some questions, Your
Honor.
JUDGE WINKLER: You have some?
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
Q (By Mr. Schur) Mr. Marco, since 1956 when
you entered the plant, has Local 588 had stewards
and committeemen?
A Yes, they have since 1956. I don’t remember
exactly the month, but—
60
Q And have these stewards and committeemen
filed grievances and generally administered the con-
tract with Ford?
A Yes, they have.
Q You testified about the number of people who
go out to eat lunch. During the boycott did the
number of people leaving the premises to eat lunch
outside the plant increase?
A No, not that I can recall.
JUDGE WINKLER: Would you know the an-
swer to that, sir?
THE WITNESS: Not from my observation, there
was no increase.
JUDGE WINKLER: You don’t know whether
there was or not? Do you know that?
THE WITNESS: I didn’t notice any increase.
JUDGE WINKLER: Did you notice any de-
crease?
THE WITNESS: No.
JUDGE WINKLER: The witness doesn’t know
the answer to that. Next question.
Q (By Mr. Schur) Well, is it your opinion that
it stayed [59] the same based on your observations?
MR. ROONEY: Objection.
JUDGE WINKLER: Sustained.
Q (By Mr. Schur) All right. You mentioned in-
sects in the plant. Are there rats or mice in the
plant?
A We have observed them in the break area.
Q Are you now engaged in negotiating with the
Ford Motor Company looking toward the signing of
a Local agreement at this particular plant?
A Yes, lam.
61
Q And approximately when did those negotia-
tions begin?
A July 30th of this year.
Q And in those negotiations have you reached the
stage where the Union makes demands upon the
Company?
Q Has the Union made any demand with refer-
ence to cafeteria and vending machine prices and
services?
MR. ROONEY: I am going to object.
JUDGE WINKLER: There is no question about
this. The Company concedes in its Answer it refuses
to give this data.
Q (By Mr. Schur) Has the Union made any de-
mand in its bargaining with reference to extermina-
tion services in the plant?
A Yes, we have. We have demanded pest and
rodent control [60] on a weekly basis.
I believe I said July 30th. We began negotia-
tions, I believe it may have been the 31st.
JUDGE WINKLER: Nothing further?
MR.SCHUR: Nothing further.
JUDGE WINKLER: Anything further, sir?
MR. DUBE: Just a moment.
JUDGE WINKLER: Don’t feel impelled because
you have an opportunity.
MR. DUBE: No further questions.
JUDGE WINKLER: Witness excused. Thank
you very much, sir.
( Witness excused. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Anything further?
I see no other witnesses. That must be the an-
swer.
62
MR. SCHUR: Could we have a minute, Your
Honor?
JUDGE WINKLER: Yes, sir. Take five minutes
while I check my other proceeding.
(Short recess taken.)
JUDGE WINKLER: I understand that General
Counsel has rested.
MR. DUBE: That is correct.
JUDGE WINLKER: Respondent?
MR. ROONEY: Rests.
JUDGE WINKLER: Let me just ask the parties
one or two [61] matters.
Is there any legal impact at all—and now I am
referring to Joint 7, Page 5, where it indicates that
there was some bargaining respecting cafeteria serv-
ice and vending service and variety at Page 5 of
this exhibit, and Joint Exhibit 8—now, there is no
date on that first item. Is there any way the parties
can tell me what the date of that—oh, I see. “It’s
mutually agreed on June 19, 1974. . .”. Do you have
that before you, sir?
MR. ROONEY: No.
JUDGE WINKLER: It’s the yellow document.
Now, I would like to have the views of both the
General Counsel and Respondent on the impact again,
if any, of the fact that Respondent did indeed bar-
gain to some extent about cafeteria service, and in
considering that, I haven’t had too much time to go
through these various exhibits. On Joint Exhibit 8
there is apparently—as of October 29, 1967, at
Pages 5 and 6 there is some kind of agreement be-
tween the Company——by Company, Ford Motor Com-
pany, and the Union with respect to vending and
63
cafeteria service. Now, my question really comes
down to this: Assuming arguendo that there is no
obligation generally to bargain about the vending
machine stuff and the cafeteria stuff, et cetera, does
it make any difference that the parties in fact have
bargained to some extent about that subject? In
[62] other words, does a generally non-mandatory
subject of bargaining change its character as such
because there has been bargaining?
Now, I don’t know the answer to that, I must say,
but it is a question that sort of piques my curiosity.
MR. ROONEY: I think, if I understand correctly,
the reason why the Company felt it had a duty to
bargain regarding sanitary conditions and regard-
ing having the cafeteria in the operation, where the
line was drawn by Westinghouse. We don’t feel we
have to bargain about cafeteria prices. Westing-
house doesn’t answer the question. You have read
this obviously. That is a question that has to be
researched and briefed, but the reason for putting
them in there, from the Company’s standpoint we
felt we had a duty to bargain about certain aspects
of the cafeteria, specifically sanitary conditions, but
not prices.
JUDGE WINKLER: In any event, I think may-
be all parties are caught a little by surprise by my
question in this connection. Maybe not. But if you
were, I think I would like some answers from the
respective parties, and I could guess, you know, what
the answers will be forthcoming from the respective
parties.
On the other hand, we are dealing with very com-
petent Counsel. I want to weigh the respective ar-
64
guments with appropriate citations of cases, et cetera,
et cetera.
[63] Let me ask the General Counsel a question,
if I may, please. And I am not going to ask you
under Board law what the result of this case, but
assuming the Court law to be the controlling law in
this area, how would this present case shape up? In
other words, is the instant case substantially differ-
ent and therefore distinguishable from the fact situa-
tions existing in the Westinghouse case, the Mc-
Cann case or McCall case, or is it the McCall case
and the Laddish (phonetic) case? On the other hand,
don’t feel impelled to answer that unless you want to
because, again, we are bound—I am going to be
bound by what the Board has said. But anyway, it’s
an interesting question.
MR. DUBE: Well, it is an interesting question,
and I suspect the Board in considering this case may
feel compelled to consider it in the light of the cur-
rent Circuit Court authority. I think this case does
present a strong fact pattern of a captive audience.
JUDGE WINKLER: Like the other cases?
MR. DUBE: No. At least as strong as the other
cases.
JUDGE WINKLER: That is not my question.
My question was, is this different from the other
cases?
MR. DUBE: Well, it’s also a one-union plant.
JUDGE WINKLER: What difference does that
make? You are referring to that case where the
Court said, “Well, since we have got five or six
unions that might make problems”? [64] With all
respect for the Court—I am not disagreeing or agree-
ing with the Court—I think that was just a make-
weight argument.
MR. DUBE: I think if the decision is one of
a policy, then probably this case is indistinguish-
able.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good.
MR. SCHUR: Your Honor, the Charging Party
feels this case is distinguishable from the others. I
think I would like to reserve the right to argue that
in my brief.
JUDGE WINKLER: Very good.
Well, I suppose we are down to the time for briefs.
The most I can allow is five weeks. You can usually
have five weeks.
MR. ROONEY: Five weeks from the record?
JUDGE WINKLER: Today.
MR. ROONEY: Can we go off the record for a
minute?
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Monday, September 20th.
Does any party desire to make any oral argument
at this point?
MR. ROONEY: I would like to say that Monday,
September 20th is just about four days after the
collective bargaining agreement expires, and it is
a to be very difficult for me to complete a
rief.
JUDGE WINKLER: Off the record.
[65] (Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: Let’s go on the record.
Gentlemen, although the Rules provide that the
limit of my authority for briefs is five weeks, I think
it would be really stupid in view of the fact that
Respondent’s Counsel will be in national negotiations
66
with the UAW, and for that reason he will be in a
position impossible to get a brief in by September
20th. We will take it upon ourselves to give him
two weeks longer.
Briefs will be due—
MR. DUBE: Monday, October 4th.
JUDGE WINKLER: October 4th.
All right. Is there anything further anyone de-
sires to say?
MR. ROONEY: No.
MR. DUBE: No.
JUDGE WINKLER: The record is closed.
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: On the record.
MR. ROONEY: At the beginning of this hear-
ing you indicated we had to tell you if the agree-
ment—
JUDGE ROONEY [sic]: Let’s go off the record a
second.
(Discussion off the record. )
JUDGE WINKLER: The hearing is closed.
(Whereupon, at 4:24 p.m., the hearing in the
above-entitled matter was closed. )
67
ae es
>
‘
wee
Se ee ee a te me de
~~
aie,
(
certo py goed ~ Serpprrg
Ss
3 a)
' Sane s N
; Ne ie a _
; eke <a | buyyany ? hompvoy
: ~¢ | ~ > . i
eopenear aint ~ SVU +, | Sowouyyg +, Duywozzew CL)
Shomurnys . ”
Svad\ly YONG OF
?
i ; git.
: DAVID |
| 19 | aaa
‘ sad if == 4 7 .
; ;*% i —- a q 4
t i a t. :
: - @ Hy ‘a4 ! lit q
Lai th r inti oe
; : ry | i. 4 +
| i"
| rs E | “a ls JL = { roo) .
=. | — —— E be TH § #
oo) FE. rents ces | ie
. . i ” un _ _ a 1 iat i.
bo | =f ee pean, hy l f RET) ad
at | ot] OS siptepepeme' ogy -|| ft f ett |
ae <P a0yR. = mt: St ~| Re wae SS. ; ly. | 3 . "
ete pepe: jel __Eeaeatd mle ie
| : ‘r {" ~*~ Pe ed Eh dsidi dials! *. - agra -. 2S Ss a a aet ' j .
; , | i | > a nel rEAAADA: a8 + te Sa. at veh | : | | ; : ¥a
= ; ™ 2 : vi Fy. j EY ~_- * i" : i ?
Ce tC patente ER RAN aged monet | ne te ey 1 ilfa lg I
= UE dot eect Lt Smaart mal
w = 1 ti, ibe cee, “kt = re ie. a ~~ 4 |
ee j. ah. st site SSS. Fl fect i *
- $3 ‘mn . ' “ -——-y = oa’
. Faas |S he ee ee ee
; + lpg p Meee “hd | 5 jae ae ii 1 |
Fide" y igi ba & et. err, sit i ar dt) ' _ . = | 7 i
— 4 ee oo. 7 ‘ a — eae “e~ a " ' it Wy ‘
Pee a oe Dbedbe é een I - t:
STS) ig] se wlio ae i =: t Ra a 4 |
| | eee ees a He Lae 1 | i
‘ms B, ot hoe "> ad te OR ite «less me or} a | } .
Ke | i* Skee ars serwematy |, aT ed © oR! mo - i: = ir
Fe a 7 < _ ~ : — a e : : “-.
| sae a Repay | Se ener aude
‘ -* o a) aay «. - "=. =e Smee 6 | t Fy
| Ln. AAA Se Sena EE Tg Renae ee | hall 4
8 a Te eee a Pe SEE HER S cpediltteoms i i
“| pn NT] pean ee at .. Fag 7 Wi oad
i . . m 4 .? ' yr + .
ieee ° , _~ —— : ii ‘ F iF .
— ! ; ey Beh he | | ; { ‘
, 5 Mt a a ; i i ie tt
‘ : '
By | te - i ! } a 4 .
' 2 i daa ane i- .. = s i ° iLea tt 4
q da? tas "ate Prewedbns 4 apreee noel "7 eal ;
one = ies ees * arma roe Nae aes (" a
a -t—- eeus _— a i fea i !
= shaaig a f foes ff] eeceeesl i_nedans | || -
Lye! ey —- . q | !
| e
|
a yee
; 7c isa decmnergs -
oe ree ae
ANE D : Vv oo **"= « .» ~ OF ai
69
JOINT EXHIBIT 7
LOCAL UNION NO. 588
Chicago Heights, Illinois
[UAW SEAL]
International Union, United Automobile
Aircraft and Agricultural Implement
Workers of America
AGREEMENTS
with
FORD STAMPING PLANT
Chicago Heights, Illinois
Effective June 20, 1974
* * » .
VENDING AND CAFETERIA SERVICE
It is mutually agreed between Ford Motor Com-
pany, Chicago Stamping Plant, and the International
Union, UAW Local +588, Chicago Stamping Plant
Unit, on 6-19-74, that provisions covering Vending
and Cafeteria Service for this plant are as follows:
1. CAFETERIA SERVICE
The Company assures the Union that steam table
items will be available at all times during the reg-
ular lunch period and that a comparable selection
of entries, salads and desserts will be available
during all regular lunch periods. In addition, the
Company will make arrangements for a delicates-
sen type sandwich service in the cafeteria. Cafe-
2.
70
teria supervision will be available during all lunch
periods to ensurs: that employes will be served in a
reasonable length of time through the main serv-
ing lines as well as to provide for the adequacy of
food service, condiments and utensils.
VENDING SERVICE AND VARIETY
To assure that vending machines will receive
prompt servicing in the event of a mechanical
breakdown, a sticker will be affixed to each ma-
chine indicating the number to call for repair.
Further, the Company assures the Union that a
greater variety of selections will be maintained in
the existing vending machines and that the qual-
ity of such items will continue to meet Company
standards.
The Company recognizes its continuing respon-
sibility for the satisfactory performance of the
caterer and for the expeditious handling of com-
plaints concerned with such performance.
ForD Motor COMPANY INTERNATIONAL UNION,
Chicago Stamping Plant UAW
L. P. Cecchini Local #588
R. L. Smith R. W. Marco
James Trusty
Donald Deel
W. B. Parks
R. Dahlke
* * * *
71
JOINT EXHIBIT 8
AGREEMENT
between
International Union,
United Automobile Aerospace and
Agricultural Implement Workers
LOCAL UNION NO. 588
Chicago Heights, Illinois
and
FORD STAMPING PLANT
Chicago Heights, Illinois
[UAW SEAL]
(Effective December 11, 1970)
* * * o
FORD MOTOR COMPANY
Chicago Stamping Plant
October 29, 1967
Mr. John M. Conway, President
Local 588, UAW-AFL-CIO
21540 Cottage Grove Avenue
Chicago Heights, Illinois 60411
Improved Vending and Cafeteria Service
This is to advise that in accordance with our dis-
cussion during 1967 local negotiations, a meeting was
held between representatives of the Company and Al
Green Enterprises, Inc. for the purpose of improving
cafeteria and vending services.
72
I was agreed there will be a reassignment of serv-
ing and kitchen duties to ensure additional personnel
for the serving of steam table items at all times dur-
ing regular lunch periods.
Additionally, assurance was given that the Cafe-
teria Manager or an Assistant Manager, during all
lunch periods, will be stationed in the cafeteria to
ensure the adequacy of food, service, condiments,
silverware and utensils.
Silverware will be subjected to continuing addi-
tional inspection after washing, and in the event of
a temporary shortage of personnel due to absenteeism,
ete., a standby supply of clean silverware will be
available to ensure an adequate supply during all
feeding periods.
To provide condiments for sandwiches dispensed in
the “Coke Cribs”, dispensers of mustard and catsup
will be installed.
It was further agreed that Al Green Enterprises,
Ine. will without undue delay fullowing the strike
provide a qualified expert from its home office to
study local conditions for the purpose of providing
attractive “weekly specials’, more varied menus and
to devise means for improving cashier service.
Additionally, a vending service specialist will study
the plant’s vending requirements and facilities, includ-
ing the added milk, pastry and ice cream machines
for the purpose of recommending an improved servic-
ing schedule and any additional manpower necessary
to implement such schedules. Each vending crib will
be serviced at least once a shift.
73
To ensure that vending machines will be given
prompt servicing in the event of mechanical break-
down, an instant means of communication with the
mechanic will be provided.
The Company recognizes its continuing responsi-
bility for the satisfactory performance of the caterer
and for providing the Union with a means for regis-
tering and expeditious handling of complaints con-
cerned with such performance.
/s/ J. E. Conen, Manager
Industrial Relations Dept.
* * * &
T4
JOINT EXHIBIT 13
February 13, 1976
Mr. Tom Brown
Industrial Relations Manager
Ford Motor Company
1000 E. Lincoln Hwy.
Chicago Heights, Ill. 60401
Dear Mr. Brown:
As the certified Bargaining Agent for your Produc-
tion and Maintenance employes, Local 588 is con-
cerned about prices and services in cafeteria and
vending operations. We would like to bargain with
you regarding these prices and services.
As you know this is a subject of great concern.
Good food at reasonable prices is considered to be a
condition of employment by our members. If we dis-
cuss this promptly, we may be able to reach full
agreement prior to opening of negotiations for a new
contract.
Sincerely,
RICHARD W. MARCO
Chairman
Bargaining Committee
Local 588 UAW
RWM:eb
opeiu#28
Please advise me of the time and place that such a
bargaining session might take place at your very
earliest convenience because of our grave concern
about these matters.
75
JOINT EXHIBIT 14
March 23, 1976
Mr. Tom Brown
Industrial Relations Manager
Ford Motor Company
1000 E. Lincoln Highway
Chicago Heights, Illinois 60411
Dear Mr. Brown:
As you know, since my letter to you of February
13, 1976, the employees have in very large numbers
refused to patronize the vending and cafeteria opera-
tions in the plant. I hope this has served to emphasize
to you the importance which the employees place upon
food services. As the certified bargaining agent of
the employees, Local 588, is faced with several prob-
lems. First, we would like to see that the present
local collective bargaining agreement is enforced.
Also, we must prepare for forthcoming negotiations
when this and the national collective bargaining agree-
ment expire.
In order to satisfactorily perform these functions
which must be performed pursuant to law and our
responsibility to our membership, we need some addi-
tional information from you. As examples of the
kinds of information we require, we would like to
know what Ford provides for the vending machines
and cafeteria, such as electricity, water, etc. We
would like to know whether Ford assumes any main-
tenance responsibilities with reference to any of the
cafeteria or vending machine equipment. We would
like to know exactly what kind of commission or profit
Ford realizes from the food operations. We would
76
like to know what control Ford has over prices, and
what ability Ford has to terminate the “lease,” con-
tract or other rights of any food supplier. Indeed, we
would like to receive copies of all written agreements
between Ford and any food supplier or vending ma-
chine operator. We would also like to know if there
are any oral agreements regarding food prices, qual-
ity, and services.
The effect of cafeteria and vending operations upon
employe morale, productivity, and recruitment should
be obvious. Will you please send us the requested in-
formation as soon as possible, and phone me to make
an appointment to discuss this subject with a view to
ironing out our problems under the present contract,
and also with a view to our forthcoming negotiations.
Sincerely,
RICHARD W. MARCO
President and Chairman of
Bargaining Committee
RWM:eb
717
JOINT EXHIBIT 15
[Ford Emblem]
February 18, 1976
Metal Stamping Division
Ford Motor Company
Chicago Stamping Plant
1000 East Lincoln Highway
P.O. Box 6
Chicago Heights, Illinois 60411
Mr. R. W. Marco
President-UAW, Local #588
21540 Cottage Grove Avenue
Chicago Heights, Illinois 60411
Dear Mr. Marco:
This letter is in response to your letter dated Febru-
ary 13, 1976 requesting to meet with the Company
for the purpose of negotiating prices and services
provided by A.R.A. Food Services.
Similar requests have been made by the Union in the
past, and the Company’s response has been the same,
that food prices and services are not a proper subject
for negotiations. Appropriately, your request is de-
nied.
/s/ T. M. Brown
T. M. BRowN
Industrial Relations Manager
Chicago Stamping Plant
78
JOINT EXHIBIT 19
GROUP C
The following restaurants are 3.75 miles from the
hourly parking lot to the intersection of Dixie Hwy.
(Ill. 1) and Sauk Trail. One severe traffic problem is
the C & FI railroad crossing at Jackson Ave. on Sauk
Trail.
This crossing is blocked by trains more often
than not and there are no restaurants in this direc-
tion until after these tracks.
1.
2.
3.
Pizza Hut—seats 40—parks 12—typ. $3.00
(pizza, beer, spaghetti)
John’s Rest.—seats 80—parks 12—typ. $3.00
(buffet & cocktails)
Valentino’s—seats 60—parks 20—typ. $4.00
(luncheon )
Dog & Suds—seats 20—parks 40—typ. $2.00
(drive inn)
Brown Onion—seats 120—parks 60—typ.
$4.00 (Lucheon & Cocktails)
McDonalds—seats 50—parks 50—typ. $2.00
(hamburgers)
Red Lion—seats 180—Parks 90—typ. $4.00
(luncheon & cocktails)
Burger King—seats 50—parks 80—typ.
$2.00 (hamburgers)
GROUP B
Restaurants
Ford City (1.6 miles)—seats 37—TYP. 2.00
Dairy Queen (2.8 miles)—seats 6—-parks 20—
(Plate Lunch) Parks 15
TYP. 1.50 Sandwich—Ice Cream
79
Helen’s Donut Shop (2.5 miles)—seats 40—
parks 15 closes at noon
Taverns
Marion’s (1.9 miles)—parks on the street—seats
30—TYP. $1.50 Sandwich
Silver Tap (2.7 miles)—parks 13—seats 24
GROUP A
Brown’s Chicken (4 mi)—seats 32—parks 12—
TYP. 2.00 Chicken Carryout
Taco Bell (4.5)—seats 40—parks 10—TYP.
2.00 Mexican Sandwiches
McDonalds (4.5)—seats 110—parks 85—TYP.
2.00 Hamburgers
Ponderosa (4.5)—seats 200—parks 200—TYP.
$2.25 Plate
Pizza Hut (4.5)—seats 100—parks 30—TYP.
$1.50 Sandwich—Pizza
Tivoli (5)—seats 300—parks 200—TYP. $4.00
(Lunch—Cocktails)
Bonanza (4.5)—seats 150—parks 140—TYP.
2.25 Plate Lunch
Village Inn (4.5)—-seats 75—parks 50—TYP.
$2.25 (Plate Lunch)
80
JOINT EXHIBIT 20
DISTANCES AND TIMES TO SHORT ORDER PLACES
Location Mileage Time(min.)
Sugar Shack, Bradfords BBQ on 30 west of
State 1.7 5
Hickory Nut BBQ on 30 just east of East End 2.2 6
Dairy Queen on 30 and Halstead 2.4 7
J D Drive In on 30 west of Chgo Road 3.1 9
Prince Castle on 30 3.4 10
Rib Cage, Tastee Freeze, Ky Fried Chicken
on 30 3.7 101%
Long Johns Pub on 30 4.0 11
Arbees Roast Beef on 30 east of Western 4.4 12
MacDonalds on Western just south of 30 4.6 13
Bozos on Halstead north of 30 2.7 11
Mornell on Halstead and Chicago north of 30 3.1
Pizza Hut on Sauk Trail east of Chgo Rd. 3.5
MacDonalds on Sauk Trail west of Chgo Rd. 3.6 8
Burger King on Chgo Rd south of Sauk Trail 3.6 8
Dog and Suds on Sauk Trail west of Chgo Rd 3.8 9
Bozos on Sauk Trail east of Route 394 2.5 5
Dog and Suds on Sauk Trail and Torrence in
Sauk Village 3.4 7
Dairy Queen and MacDonalds on Sauk Trail
and Torrence 3.5 8
All distances and times were calculated from the middle of the
hourly parking lot traveling at the maximum speed limit. Time
walking from the plant floor to the parking lot was not figured.
81
JOINT EXHIBIT 21
[Ford Emblem]
Ford Motor Company The American Road
Dearborn, Michigan 48121
March 7, 1972
Mr. Joseph P. Simon, Vice President
ARA Services, Inc.
Independence Square, West
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19106
Dear Mr. Simon:
Enclosed please find your copy of the recently negoti-
ated catering-vending agreement for our Chicago
Stamping Plant. Please note that my letter of Feb-
ruary 11, 1972, modifying this agreement, is to be
filed with and made a part of this contract.
This new agreement is effective January 1, 1972 and
a the catering-vending agreement of January
, 1970.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Richard W. Mather
RICHARD W. MATHER, Manager
Food Services Department
RWM_2:og
ee Secretary’s Office
R. W. Scott
J. M. Osborne
L. P. Ceechini (2)
82
[Ford Emblem]
Ford Motor Company The American Road
Dearborn, Michigan 48121
February 11, 1972
Mr. Joseph P. Simon
Senior Vice President
ARA Services, Inc.
Independence Square, West
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Dear Mr. Simon:
ARA Services, Inc. has been operating the food and
vending service at Ford’s Chicago Stamping Plant
under the terms of an agreement dated January 5,
1970.
On December 9, 1971, we agreed in a meeting held
in my office to replace the above mentioned agree-
ment and other similar subsidy agreements with a
new standard Ford Motor Company agreement modi-
fied as necessary for each location.
The purpose of this letter is to state the following
financial changes at this location:
* Paragraph 3a is amended to limit Ford’s subsidy
obligation to $52,000 per year except that it is
understood that if Ford’s plant population is re-
duced to less than 3,850 employes, or in the
event that Ford requires Contractor to operate
manual food service facilities in addition to those
in existence on January 5, 1970, then in either
event there shall be no limitation on the amount
of the subsidy that Ford is required to pay to
83
Contractor as a result of Ford’s guarantee to pay
Contractor’s costs and service fee.
It is further agreed that in the event of a strike
at Ford’s premises, which lasts more than 45
days, and in the event that Ford requires Con-
tractor to provide manual food and vending serv-
ice during such strike, the fiscal provisions set
forth in Paragraph 3a and Paragraph 3b of the
agreement shall be suspended for the duration
of the strike and, in lieu thereof, Contractor shall
be entitled to receive for its services reimburse-
ment for all direct costs (exclusive of the allow-
ance for general administrative expenses) of the
manual food service operation and the vending
operation plus 9% of said direct costs to cover
Contractor’s general administrative expenses and
service fee.
All commissary-prepared food items such as sand-
wiches, salads, desserts, will be charged to the
Ford location at 67% of the suggested retail sales
price as listed in the latest published menu of
Contractor’s Chicago Commissary. This menu
price list shall be updated on market conditions
quarterly, and will be furnished as published to
Ford. The 67% figure shall include raw food
cost, labor to produce, package and ship, packag-
ing material costs, labeling and delivery costs
along with all other costs incurred in the normal
business conducted by Contractor’s Commissary.
Thus, if the suggested price of hamburger is 35¢,
the cost to be charged to the operating statements
would be 23.45¢—cooked, packaged and labeled,
ready for sale.
84
If the foregoing correctly covers the exceptions for
this location, please sign a copy of this letter and re-
turn it to me. This letter becomes a part of the new
agreement effective January 1, 1972, and is to be
filed with it.
The signed agreement will be forwarded to you upon
receipt of a copy of this letter.
Sincerely yours,
/s/ Richard W. Mather
RICHARD W. MATHER, Manager
Food Service Department
RWM:og
Concur:
ARA Services, Inc.
By /s/ Joseph P. Sims
Its Vice President
35
CATERING-VENDING AGREEMENT
FORD MOTOR COMPANY, a Delaware corpora-
tion with offices at The American Road, Dearborn,
Michigan (hereinafter called “Ford”), hereby au-
thorizes the undersigned Contractor, and Contractor
hereby agrees to operate a manual food service and
to supply and operate vending machines at the Ford
location, Chicago Stamping Plant, 1000 East Lincoln
Highway, Chicago Heights, Illinois upon the terms
and conditions hereinafter set forth.
1. Ford shall:
a. furnish at its expense and as it deems suit-
able, space, office equipment (one file cabi-
net, desks, chairs and local telephone serv-
ice), cafeteria equipment (including kitchen
equipment, cooking utensils, chairs, tables,
counter steam tables, coffee urns, refrigera-
tion, ice machines, china, silverware and
glassware), utility outlets, and all heat,
electric light, power, gas, steam, and hot
and cold water required for the proper oper-
ation of said manual food service and vend-
ing machines;
b. keep said mechanical cafeteria equipment
in good mechanical condition and furnish
at its expense all replacements and repair
parts therefor, except as provided in Sec-
tion 2i;
ce. furnish pre-employment and periodic physi-
cal examinations at those locations where
Ford has a full-time medical doctor on its
86
rolls, and furnish courtesy first-aid treat-
ment, where such services are available, to
employes of Contractor while engaged in the
operation of said manual food service and
vending machines; and
. furnish all necessary sweeping and mopping
of the dining space furnished hereunder.
2. Contractor shall:
a. manage and operate said manual food serv-
ice and install (including connecting to
utility outlets), maintain and service said
vending machines in the space allotted, it
being understood that title to and ownership
of the vending machines shall remain with
the Contractor;
. obtain all necessary permits and licenses
for the conduct of the manual food service
and vending machine business in its name
and at its expense;
. furnish all foods, beverages, and materials
of every kind, and all management and labor
necessary for the proper operation of said
manual food service and vending machines;
. furnish products of quality in accordance
with purchasing specifications that shall
have been submitted to and approved by
Ford, and in accordance with a price and
portion list for said manual food service
and vending machines that shall have been
submitted to Ford and that shall be subject
to review at the request of Ford or Con-
tractor;
87
. furnish Ford a list showing the number,
classification, pay rates and work schedules
of personnel who operate said manual food
service and vending machines;
furnish Ford a list showing the number,
make and type of vending machines and
coffee and carbonated beverage formulas;
. Operate and maintain the manual food serv-
ize (including, unless excused from so doing
in writing by local Ford management,
Sweeping and mopping of the kitchen and
storeroom, cleaning of exhaust hood filters,
and washing manual food service tables and
chairs) and said vending machines in ac-
cordance with all laws, ordinances, regula-
tions and rules of federal, state, and local
authority and the standards of cleanliness,
safety and health established by Ford; pro-
vided, however, that any structural or
equipment changes necessary in order to
comply with such manual food service re-
quirements and standards shall be made by
Ford at its expense;
. Operate and care for vending machines and
all equipment required in the operation of
said manual food service so as to keep the
same in first-class condition, reasonable wear
and tear excepted, and permit inspection of
all such machines and equipment by persons
designated by Ford at any time to permit
a determination that established standards
of quality and cleanliness are being met by
Contractor ;
88
make (and furnish to Ford) a complete in-
ventory of all utensils, china, silverware,
glassware, and equipment every six (6)
months, and, at Contractor’s expense, im-
mediately replace all utensils, china, silver-
ware, glassware, and equipment missing due
to breakage, loss or theft, (replacements of
chinaware, silverware, stainless steel flat-
ware, and executive dining room glassware
shall be ordered from sources designated by
Ford) except that replacements or repairs
of mechanical cafeteria equipment due to
causes beyond the Contractor’s control shall
be made by Ford at its expense;
remove daily at its expense all garbage and
refuse from the operation of cafeteria and
dining room, and, upon its failure to so do,
Contractor agrees to pay Ford all reason-
able costs, charges, and expenses for re-
moval of the same;
. provide waste containers at each vending
machine location, if desired by Ford;
have its employes examined by Ford medi-
cal doctor, or other competent medical doc-
tor at locations where Ford does not have
a full-time medical doctor on its rolls, and
employ only persons who have been ex-
amined and approved by such doctor, and
require all employes to submit to a medical
examination each six (6) months during the
course of their employment, or at shorter
intervals if required by law;
89
m. keep said manual food service open, and
maintain adequate services at such times
and for such periods as shall be approved
by Ford;
. pay and discharge all taxes and/or license
fees which may be levied or imposed on the
business of operating said manual food
service, the sale of food and beverages, and
po! operation of said vending machines;
an
0. comply with all rules and regulations at the
aforementioned Ford location and not inter-
fere with the ordinary operation thereof.
3. Fiscal Arrangements
a. It is hereby agreed that Contractor receive
for its services reimbursement for all di-
rect costs of the food and vending opera-
tions at Ford’s premises including an allow-
ance for its general administrative costs
equivalent to four percent (4%) of net
receipts from its operation at Ford’s prem-
ises together with a service fee of five per-
cent (5%) of such receipts. Net receipts
are defined as gross receipts collected, less
applicable state and local sales taxes.
. Costs for vending will include (1) cost of
sales (including all product, cup, condiment
and serviceware costs); (2) labor cost (in-
cluding fringes and taxes) of all resident
personnel; (3) equipment depreciation based
on net cost of equipment on a write-off of
five (5) years (net costs of equipment will
90
be defined as Contractor’s cost of vending
machines with all applicable discounts plus
sales tax, freight and installation expenses) ;
and (4) all other applicable expenses di-
rectly related to this location. All vending
receipts in excess of the amount required
to reimburse Contractor for its above de-
fined cost of vending operations at Ford’s
premises including Contractor’s allowance
for general administrative costs and serv-
ice fee, will be credited to the combined
profit and loss statement as a reduction of
any deficit from the manual food service
operations on Ford’s premises.
ec. DISCOUNTS (VENDING AND
MANUAL)
(1) Contractor shall credit to the operating
statements, as a reduction of costs, all
trade discounts received (either at the
local level or at the corporate office)
with the exception of cash discounts
received for prompt payment.
4. Accounting
Within twenty (20) days following the close
of each accounting period, Contractor shall sub-
mit to Ford three (3) copies of profit and loss
statements for such period covering manual
food service (Exhibit A), vending machine op-
erations (Exhibit B), and a consolidation of
food and vending service (Exhibit C). Should
gross receipts be less than the sum of the cost
of operation plus the service fee, Ford shall
91
reimburse Contractor for the deficit within
twenty (20) days of invoice date. Within sixty
(60) days following the close of Contractor’s
fiscal year (October accounting period through
September accounting period), Contractor will
submit to Ford the final year-end statements
certified by an independent auditor acceptable
to Ford, along with the check for the amount,
if any, by which gross receipts for the prior
year exceed Contractor’s cost of operations in-
cluding its service fee. One copy of each state-
ment shall be sent to Manager, Food Services
Department, Central Office Building, The
American Road, Dearborn, Michigan 48121;
one copy to Industrial Relations Manager
Metal Stamping Division, Rouge Office Build-
ing, 3001 Miller Road, Dearborn, Michigan
48121; and one copy to Manager, Industrial
Relations Department, at the location covered
by this agreement.
. Contractor shall indemnify, defend and hold
Ford harmless against any and all loss, damage
and expense, or claims therefor, for injury to
or illness — any person, or damage, loss
or expense to property (excepting propert
Ford damaged by fire or pare, Bs ee
perils) arising out of the operation of said
manual food service and vending machines and
the sale of products therefrom, and for any loss
injury or illness resulting from the courtesy
first-aid treatment furnished employes of Con-
tractor, and for any loss or penalty resulting
from the Contractor’s violation of any law or
ordinance, except that Contractor shall not be
92
liable for any loss, damage or expense caused
by the sole act or omission of Ford.
. Contractor shall maintain at its cost and ex-
pense, with respect to all its activities under
this agreement, workmen’s compensation (or
employer’s liability) insurance, and public li-
ability insurance, including property damage,
products liability and contractual liability, with
companies acceptable to Ford and in the follow-
ing minimum amounts:
Public Liability $200,000.00 each person
$500,000.00 each accident
Property Damage $100,000.00 each accident
Contractor shall furnish Ford with certificates
of insurance as evidence of such coverage.
. Ford shall at all times have access to all space
furnished hereunder for the purpose of making
repairs and for sanitary, safety and fire in-
spections; and any recommendations or require-
ments of Ford relative to sanitation, safety and
fire protection shall be promptly complied with
by Contractor.
. No alcoholic beverages of any kind will be
stored or offered for sale by Contractor on the
aforementioned Ford location.
. Ford shall not be liable to Contractor for any
loss, delay or damage caused by Ford’s failure
to keep said premises or cafeteria equipment
in good repair, or from its failure to furnish
electric light, power, gas, steam, water or other
services.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
93
Ford shall not be liable for any damage to
food, materials, or equipment of Contractor.
It is understood and agreed that Contractor
is an independent contractor and not an em-
ploye of Ford, and that the employes of Con-
tractor are not employes of Ford, and Contrac-
tor agrees to pay all taxes and contributions
required by law for social security, old age
pensions, unemployment, or any other law or
act relating to its employes.
Contractor shall not, without prior written con-
sent of Ford, sublet or assign to third persons
any interest under this contract, or in the
operation of said manual food services and
vending machines.
This Agreement hereby supersedes any and all
prior Agreements heretofore made between the
parties for operation of a manual food service
and vending machines at the aforementioned
Ford location.
The term of this contract shall commence as of
January 1, 1972 and shall continue for a period
of ninety (90) days and thereafter until termi-
nated at any time at will by either party upon
sixty (60) days’ notice in writing to the other
party. Any notice of termination shall be
signed by an officer of the company originating
the notice and shall be sent by registered mail,
return receipt requested, to the address pro-
vided in Section 15.
Except as otherwise specifically provided here-
in, the submission or giving of all written lists,
reports, inventories, statements and notices re-
4
: 95
ferred to herein shall be, if to Ford, to the . :
Manager, Food Services Department, Central & BS
Office Building, The American Road, Dearborn, e |
Michigan 48121; and if to the Contractor, to 8
President, ARA Services, Inc., Independence 8
Square West, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19106. FI
aa
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have here-
unto set their hands and seals as of the 11th day p |
of February, 1972. a3 4
ForD Motor COMPANY 2 s
E 2 ¥ SS x
o «(6S
, s° €
By /s/ [Illegible] EB an §
Its Secretary a2 8 &
HA &
‘ S & a é
ARA SERVICES, INC. & 2 S
By /s/ [Illegible] = &
Its Vice President Ce 5 * “ ”
7 :
a Zora ea a
° PERE EEG aan
> EEE EES | |
; PLETE] is
Serece i th |
f itis. - 1a
Poiiidd ie
Biiiiiig , /d83
fee is pee
S a , = > g
Tene
Teer eS gs
Ssgeisgis 2 SHEE: 3
° ° set Ss
3 gaagcsas a yanks ”
qruseesnscuvsniansiannumineannncnetsnasinsieiedcusenenesen 897}01831-)
948 (]-0}-189 X
poliag yuerng jJO"ON
(ONIGNAA) SSOT GNV LIdOUd 40 LNAWALVLS
aguagA00 doludd
NOILVOOT
@ LIAIHXd
+ (49) 880] 40 qyorg IN
$¢$ %&
4 % 4 asuedxg Supzesedy [01
$ % $ esuedxg 19430 [®70]
cocsvsccsesesscoosccsccesenassestoce esusdxy snosueijsos1
cocerereencsenneeesencnesersnensesseseres ees souvansuy [B18Uer)
seseeeeeeenensseeecesees sayjddng ZujuvaQ y Arpuney]
comnatas quoulase|day Jali PY WVMSSBID “BUTYyD
qussecencenesesessensnesssncnnseesens suseuseneneee satjddng Jadtg
sasusdxy 3 e1edgQ 19410
948-074-189 X
potieg JueLINg
penuyyu0j)—(TVANVW) SSOT GNV LI4O0OUd AO LNAWALVLS
rr eee eee eee eee ee ee ee eee
80 JUsWIEZeUEW!
(49) 880] 10 WYorg ON
eeteeets seseneesenneesnnseseneeerseerers 3809 Burjzeredg pejoy,
eee ee ee ee ee rr sosusdxy 12410
Covcvecccequossosoccoocossoesocesooocscococasecesese IOqe’] jo 4805)
cevccenseeocoesoscooccsooencessccecocooooscoscoosesece sere JO 4809
% $ % -$ Coccvecccccescocooencocesoconcoeeesooeocsscososeseee sereg ON [eI0],
978 -0}-189 X polite JUeLIND
ONIGNGA GNV TVOANVW—LNAWALVLS CANIAWOO
aaduaAoo dorddad
NOILVOOT ANVdWOO YOLOW Guo
(a1 }] OUIeN 10}98.1}U00 MoYs)
oO LIGIHxd
‘yonpoid Aq sayes sso13 uO b pen. sisi
Alput 3daoxe sees you [e}0} UO peseq oq 0} o1e SesBjUBOIEd [jY * WL
% Sr someone =. pe a 2 | (AD) 880°] 40 qYO1d WN
% $ % s qs0Q BurzessdO [BOL
% $ % —$ esusdxg 10410 [FOL
sesonssnnsnecesoogssessnssnnenssse esuadxy eAryerystulMIpy
eeseeeceneetteeceeeeenneseeeeenees asuedxy Snooue[[sos!
netececeeecneceencenteretenteeeaneeceeeneens aoUBANSUT [B18Ud4)
sssstenseseeteansnnenscansnssnenesesnasectensnsnsanesanns satjddng
cenccennnsnereseeeeeeasstsnsnanenaceatesesenaenenses uolye1de1deq
seoseeeseecenenensnsecsesesenseseses souBUszUIVW P suredoy
gesuedxg Zur}eiedQ 19430
% $ 3809 JOquy [BIO],
% HI: OER AAT IS Miggrcdtisceed tts IP sesusdxy [Jo1ABg 19430
—_— [enisoy AeprOH F UoIywowA “souBINSUT
sesetecsescecesssrssessesneenesenennsnsenssansnsnes® SAxB], [Jose g
rere ee SoZ M PUB SOLIB[eS
toqe’T JO 480
SafBS JO WOH [BIOL
er, pooy 129430
Perr rrrer rrr iret irr Aryseg
RE eee EEE EERE EERE EEE EEE REE EE EEE EEO HEE Ee wieatD ao]
wo
% $ %
978 (J-0}-189 X polseg Juang
penunu0g—(ONIGNAA) SSOT GNV LI4O0Ud AO LNAWALVLS
100
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 77-1806
ForD Motor CoMPANY, ETC.,
Petitioner
Vv.
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, ET AL.
ORDER ALLOWING CERTIORARI
Filed October 10, 1978
The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cir-
cuit is granted.
eee
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.