Petition — Germain v. United States

Supreme Court brief1977

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Seprewe Court, U. &.

FILED

IN THE JUL 11 1977

Supreme Court of the United S : Dpgpanes noose on cuene

October Term, 1976

No. ..Z'Z.m 5] nd

CONRAD L. GERMAIN, ROBERT W. KANE, OUTPOST

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba LYDIA FELDMAN

METHODs, dba BRENDA HARDY RESEARCH,

Petitioners,

vs.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Respondent.

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

STANLEY FLEISHMAN,

FLEISHMAN, BROWN, WESTON & ROHDE,

A Professional Corporation,

433 North Camden Drive, Suite 900,

P.O. Box 4055,

Beverly Hills, Calif. 90213,

(213) 550-7460 or 272-4221,

Attorneys for Petitioners.

SAM ROSENWEIN,

Of Counsel.

Parker & Son, Inc., Law Printers, Los Angeles. Phone 724-6622

SUBJECT INDEX

Page

BD scninctiecsccsintidtedpernainanindia nealesisicesstaiaieite tail 1

IIIT | cctiiecinicniscinsnictiinencitninesiitintiniiaiescegtieiiisialiaiianaine 2

IID 1:5 ccicrisshinscinsnraicnmignensmniienietiitenlatnans 2

Constitutional and Statutory Provisions Involved .. 3

ID | iisieicceitlssteeipaiadleeclaltiendacelbcinibiiaiiclineaienbalaaa 3

DUORS GOR GUI THIN, cccccecrescsctescsemnenstonences 8

1. The Decision Is Contrary to Decisions of

This Court in Stromberg v. California, 283

U.S. 359, Thompson v. Louisville, 362 U.S.

199, and In Re Winship, 397 U.S. 358 .... 8

2. The Communications Contained in Peti-

tioners’ Advertisement for Their Diet Book-

let Are Protected by the Free Speech and

Press Provisions of the First Amendment,

Despite the Claim That the Advertisement

Repeats Allegedly False Representations

Contained in the Booklet ...............0000000.... 12

3. The Prosecutor’s Highly Prejudicial and

Unsubstantiated Argument to the Jury De-

nied Petitioners Due Process of Law and a

Fair Trial Guaranteed by the Fifth Amend-

EE | ciineetuticainchtnnnidsendicnnsinindenaidiiunitiiens 16

4. The Judgment Should Be Reversed Be-

cause of the Concededly Erroneous In-

structions to the Jury Particularly Since the

Case Against Petitioners Is Weak and There

Were Cumulative Errors Committed .......... 20

ERASE rene a ee Seana teen SNE SO nei LF a 20

ii.

INDEX TO APPENDICES

Page

Appendix A. Opinion and Judgment of the Court

of Appeals, Ninth Circuit ....................+. App. p.

Appendix B. Order Denying Petition for Rehear-

ing and Rejecting Suggestion for Rehearing En

BED © cccincicbnuthiseiiapeiidianddenincidgnindinietedsbennencveninansnaniiie

Appendix C. Constitutional and Statutory Provi-

ED FGI cvcsicccccesccessscnccorsccnnencncsonenasensecsancsens

Appendix D. Count One of the Indictment ......

Appendix E. The Advertisement. Want to Lose

SD dtininsiditastinrnctsitsbinibiniinibienasiininninaiabmneete

Appendix F. The Booklet MY SECRET by Lydia

Feldman. The Lydia Feldman Method for Weight

I stiicrepssttisssinocicianenhnbinibehidicinmmenmniinantidanpnettelmensins

iii.

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED

Cases Page

American School of Magnetic Healing v. McAn-

nulty, 187 U.S. 94 ....... sethitaiiicatochcbaaiapiaiitaitsttiieigei

Berger v. United States, 295 U.S. 78 .................. 17,

Cramer v. United States, 325 U.S. 1... 10,

Dunn v. United States, 307 F.2d 883 (Sth Cir.

DGIED. csveeutsecsscuiisincarinsendimapapionibctuiniasiplniimienienin

Garner v. Louisiana, 368 U.S. 157 ............00..........

Hull v. United States, 324 F.2d 817 (Sth Cir.

DED sexsscsissnnicannptioniyistepuniisciiiecioniliiabiatiamaiialidetinns

Linmark Associates, Inc. v. Township of Willings-

boro, .... U.S. ...., #76-357 (May 2, 1977) ......

McMillan v. United States, 363 F.2d 165 (Sth Cir.

TENTUP. <ccucesessecsssesteneinnseninaiaiuiplaemaiabianieiale

Rodale Press, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission,

407 F.2d 1252 (D.C. Cir. 1968) .......000000000.

Shuttlesworth v. Birmingham, 382 U.S. 87 ........

Splawn v. California, .... U.S. ..... #76-143 (June

eee nese ee ee

Steele v. United States, 222 F.2d 628 (Sth Cir.

PUPTEDD ~ <nswecsnisscniseiinsttanipiunglicnalajiteatyiniieaiaiageteiliessdilibeibitestl

Stromberg v. California, 283 U.S. 359 ....2, 8,

Thompson v. Louisville, 362 U.S. 199 ....2, 8,

18

10

iv.

Page

United States v. Achtenberg, 459 F.2d 91 (8th Cir.

a eeouiiion 18

United States v. Bledsoe, 531 F.2d 888 (8th Cir.

NE 17

United States v. Dailey, 524 F.2d 911 (8th Cir.

ES ee 18

United States v. Gonzalez, 488 F.2d 833 (6th Cir.

EEE 18

United States v. Grunberger, 431 F.2d 1062 (2d

SE ET SE a 18

United States v. Latimer, 511 F.2d 498 (10th Cir.

i enbsibuooonannee 18

United States v. Ludwig, 508 F.2d 140 (10th Cir

SES EE ee 19

United States v. Perez, 493 F.2d 1339 (10th Cir

EE ES Ss ST a 18

United States v. Phillips, 527 F.2d 1021 (7th Cir

EE TE 18

United States v. Serrano, 496 F.2d 81 (5th Cir

LS SELL ESI a 19

United States v. Stanley, 455 F.2d 644 (4th Cir

EE 18

United States v. White, 324 F.2d 814 (2d Cir

SD - csstialite TE ee 19

Virginia State Board of Pharmacy v. Virginia Citi-

zens Consumer Council, Inc., 425 U.S. 748 .... 15

Williams v. North Carolina, 317 U.S. 287 .......... 10

Winship, In re, 397 U.S. 358 ....2, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14

Yates v. United States, 354 U.S. 298 0000000000... 10, 11

v.

Statutes Page

United States Code, Title 18, Sec. 1341 ~.....0.0000...... 3

United States Code, Title 18, Sec. 4208(b) ... 7

United States Code, Title -..... , Sec. 4206(6) .......... 7

United States Code, Title 28, Sec. 1254(1) ........ 2

United States Constitution, First Amendment ......

sedi ditlintindionsiea ietenicicgeiinaiiiniaddddeidiadiaasabamianiniial 2,3, 12, 14, 15

United States Constitution, Fifth Amendment ......

sciatica cdadeietei ki elieataina caddie i Re aac 2, 3, 16

United States Constitution, Sixth Amendment ...... 3

AIRS RE o eew wre

~ = meme

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1976

SIN cncbiitieidcicnie

CONRAD L. GERMAIN, ROBERT W. KANE, OUTPOST

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba LypDIA FELDMAN

METHops, dba BRENDA HARDY RESEARCH,

Petitioners,

VS.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Respondent.

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

The petitioners, Conrad L. Germain, Robert W.

Kane, Outpost Development Company, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods, dba Brenda Hardy Research respectfully

pray that a Writ of Certiorari issue to review the

opinion and judgment of the United States Court of

Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, entered in the above

entitled case on March 24, 1977.

Opinion Below.

The opinion of the Court of Appeals, reported at

552 F.2d 868 (9th Cir. 1977), appears as Appendix

“A” hereto.

— =

Jurisdiction.

The judgment of the Court of Appeals for the Ninth

Circuit was entered on March 24, 1977. A due and

timely petition for rehearing and suggestion for rehear-

ing en banc was filed on or about April 5, 1977.

The petition was denied on May 16, 1977. A copy

of the Order denying the petition appears as Appendix

“B”. The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth

Circuit made an order staying issuance of the mandate

pending the filing, consideration and disposition by

this Court of the Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.

This Court’s jurisdiction is invoked under 28 U.S.C.

§ 1254(1). On June 7, 1977, Mr. Justice Rehnquist

extended the time for filing this Petition to July 14,

1977.

Questions Presented.

1. Whether contrary to the decisions of this Court

in Stromberg v. California, 283 U.S. 359, Thompson

v. Louisville, 362 U.S. 199, and In re Winship, 397

U.S. 358, petitioners were denied due process of law

in violation of the Fifth Amendment because the jury

was instructed that it was free to base its general

verdict on any of the multiple specific acts alleged

in the indictment, for some of which there was no

evidence to support the verdict, and it is impossible

to determine whether the jury convicted on a ground

for which there was no evidence.

2. Whether the communications contained in peti-

tioners’ advertisement for their diet booklet are protect-

ed by the Free Speech and Press provisions of the

First Amendment, despite the claim that the advertise-

ment repeats allegedly false representations contained

in the booklet.

=

3. Where the indictment charged fraud by promis-

ing and refusing to make refunds and the record dis-

closes that over 28,000 booklets were mailed and only

three persons testified that they did not receive their

requested refunds, were petitioners denied due process

of law and a fair trial guaranteed by the First Amend-

ment by the prosecutor’s highly prejudicial and unsub-

stantiated argument, among others, to the jury that

10,000 people requested and did not receive refunds.

4. Whether the instructions which the court below

found to be erroneous, but not plain error, require

a reversal in light of the weak evidence against peti-

tioners and cumulative errors of law.

Constitutional and Statutory Provisions Involved.

The pertinent provisions of the First, Fifth and Sixth

Amendments; and Title 18 United States Code, Section

1341 appear in Appendix “C”.

Statement.

1. The indictment herein, in 27 counts, was re-

turned in the United States District Court for the

Central District of California on November 5, 1974.

The indictment is confusing, each count alleging mul-

tiple separate allegedly fraudulent acts. Count One

of the indictment is set forth as Appendix “D”. The

allegations of Count One are realleged in each of

the other counts, except for the allegation contained

in the last paragraph thereof.

The case arose out of the mailing of an advertisement

entitled “WANT TO LOSE WEIGHT?”, a copy of

which is attached as Appendix “E”. Persons who re-

sponded to the advertisement by sending the requested

—_

sum of $5.95 received a booklet on how to lose weight,

entitled “MY SECRET”, a copy of which is set forth

as Appendix “F”.*

Essentially the indictment charged that the advertise-

ment was fraudulent because:

i. It allegedly falsely represented that by following

petitioners’ diet plan “the fats in the foods you eat

are changed into energy instead of fat”;

ii. “In many instances” petitioners did not mail

the booklet to persons sending $5.95;

iii. “In many instances” petitioners did not, as

promised, make refunds to persons requesting the same;

and

iv. It allegedly falsely represented that “LYDIA

FELDMAN” and “BRENDA HARDY” are real per-

sons.

A. The charge in the indictment that by following

petitioners’ diet plan, “the fats in the foods you eat

are changed into energy instead of fat” was interpreted

by the trial court, the parties and the witnesses as

meaning that if a person followed the diet plan con-

tained in petitioners’ booklet, the person would lose

weight.

The Government called two medical experts, both

of whom testified that a person following the diet

plan would not lose weight but would, in fact gain

weight. On cross-examination however one of the gov-

ernment’s experts qualified his answer and testified

that if a person followed the diet plan strictly, it

1Petitioners mailed the brochure and booklet either under

the name “LYDIA FELDMAN” or “BRENDA HARDY”,

enti:

is certainly possible that one could lose weight on

this reduction diet. (R.T. 363.)?

Petitioners called three expert medical doctors, each

of whom testified that the diet plan would work, if

strictly followed.

B. In support of the allegation that petitioners were

guilty of fraud because they “would and did accept

money and orders for [the booklet] ‘MY SECRET’,

which orders in many instances they did noi fill”,

the government called five witnesses who testified that

they sent their money but did not receive the booklet.

The undisputed evidence reveals that within the 22-

month period covered by the indictment appellants

mailed approximately 28,600 booklets.

The government called a former employee of peti-

tioners who testified that she was supplied with com-

puterized process labels that were addressed, and in-

structed to mail booklets as addressed; that she per-

sonally put the booklets in the envelopes and mailed

approximately 300 each week. (R.T. 640, 686-689.)

A government postal inspector who engaged in test

mailings testified that he ordered and received booklets

in a reasonable period of time. (R.T. 842-844, 850.)

C. In support of the allegation that petitioners were

guilty of fraud because they “would and did in many

instances fail to make refunds to those persons who

srecifically requested them” the government called three

w. «2s who testified that they requested, and did

nm ceive. refunds. As heretofore noted petitioners

mailed approxi ately 28,600 booklets during the period

covered by the indictment.

2R.T. refers to Reporter’s Transcript.

a

The government called a former employee of peti-

tioners who testified that she was instructed by peti-

tioners that the booklets were refundable if returned

by the customers with the name and address clearly

indicated on the envelope or the inside of the book

so a refund could be made. (R.T. 632.) She typed

out the refund checks and, after checks were signed,

mailed them. She personally prepared and mailed ap-

proximately 75 refund checks per month.

D. To support the charge in the indictment that

petitioners were guilty of fraud because they used the

business names “LYDIA FELDMAN” and “BRENDA

HARDY” the government called a former employee

of petitioners who testified that she never met “LYDIA

FELDMAN” or “BRENDA HARDY” and that she

did not know anyone who ever met either of them.

The only other evicence on this issue consisted of

two certificates of fictitious business names filed with

the Los Angeles County Clerk reflecting that petitioner

corporation was doing business under the fictitious

names of “LYDIA FELDMAN METHODS” and

“BRENDA HARDY RESEARCH.”

2. At the close of the government’s case the govern-

ment moved to dismiss counts 6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 16,

17 and 23. (R.T. 887.) Petitioners then moved for

a judgment of acquittal of the remaining counts be-

cause of insufficiency of the evidence. The motion

was denied. (R.T. 889-891.) Petitioners again moved

for a judgment of acquittal at the close of all the

evidence (R.T. 1199), which motion was denied with-

out prejudice to its being raised again when the jury

acted or failed to act.

=

3. The jury was instructed that although the indict-

ment alleged several false and fraudulent representations

it was not essential that the government prove each

and every one. All that is required, the court told

the jury is that the proof show beyond a reasonable

doubt any one fraudulent representation. The jury re-

turned a general verdict of guilty on all counts submit-

ted to it.

4. Following the return of the verdict petitioners

duly filed a motion in arrest of judgment, a motion

for a new trial, and a motion for judgment of acquit-

tal (C.T. 225-228, 230),* which motions were denied.

The court sentenced each of the individual defendants

to 90-year prison terms pursuant to U.S.C. § 4208(b)

and fines of $18,000 each. The corporate defendant

was also fined $18,000. In all the fines totalled

$54,000 and the prison terms totalled 180 years. (R.T.

342.)

5. The court below affirmed, holding that there

was sufficient evidence for the jury to find that the

representation that a person following the petitioners’

diet plan would lose weight was fraudulent. The court

expressly declined to decide whether the evidence was

sufficient with respect to each and all of the other

acts alleged in the indictment. As petitioners show

hereinafter there was no evidence to support some

of the acts alleged in the indictment, and insufficient

evidence to support other such allegations.

8C.T. refers to Clerk’s Transcript.

—

REASONS FOR GRANTING WRIT.

1, The Decision Is Contrary to Decisions of This

Court in Stromberg v. California, 283 U.S. 359,

Thompson v. Louisville, 362 U.S. 199, and In Re

Winship, 397 U.S. 358.

As heretofore noted each count of the indictment

charged multiple specific acts as constituting fraud.

Thus each count of the indictment alleged that petition-

ers’ advertisement fraudulently represented that persons

following the diet plan contained in petitioners’ book-

let would lose weight; that “in many instances” petition-

ers did not mail the booklet to persons sending $5.95,

as promised; that “in many instances” petitioners did

not, as promised, make refunds to persons requesting

the same; and that the use of the business names

“LYDIA FELDMAN” and “BRENDA HARDY” was

fraudulent because they were not real persons.

The jury was instructed that although the indict-

ment alleged several false and fraudulent representations

it was not essential that the government prove each

and every one. All that is required, the court told

the jury, is that the proof show beyond a reasonable

doubt any one fraudulent representation. The jury re-

turned a general verdict and it is impossible to determine

the ground on which the jury based its finding of

fraud.

In affirming the jury verdict the court below found

solely that there was sufficient evidence for the jury

to find that petitioners’ representation that a person

following their diet plan would lose weight was fraudu-

lent. The court declined to decide whether the evidence

with respect to the other acts alleged in the indictment,

and submitted to the jury, was sufficient. The court

_—

stated that the testimony that some persons sent their

money but did not receive the booklet was merely

“some evidence of fraud.” Similarly the court stated

that the testimony that some persons requested, but

did not receive a refund was “some evidence of fraud.”

Presumably the court found this evidence insufficient

to meet the “beyond a reasonable doubt” test. Jn

re Winship, 397 U.S. 358.

The court did not comment on the allegation in

the indictment that fraud was committed by using

the names “LYDIA FELDMAN” and “BRENDA HAR-

DY”, although the jury was instructed that it could

convict on this allegation in the indictment. The prosecu-

tor, in his closing argument urged conviction on this

ground stating: “There was no Brenda Hardy; there

was no Lydia Feldman .... I am sure. . . that

if Lydia Feldman existed, you would have seen her

in the courtroom. . . . There is no Brenda Hardy.

You would have seen Brenda Hardy if she existed.”

(R.T. 1207, 1253.) Petitioners submit that the use

of the names “LYDIA FELDMAN” and “BRENDA

HARDY” is no evidence of fraud. The court below

did not dispute this contention made by petitioners.

If the general verdict rested on the charge that

fraud was committed by using fictitious names, petition-

ers were denied due process of law since the use

of such fictitious names constituted no evidence of

fraud. Thompson v. Louisville, 362 U.S. 199; Garner

v. Louisiana, 368 U.S. 157, 163; Shuttlesworth v.

Birmingham, 382 U.S. 87, 94.

If the jury verdict rested on the testimony that

some persons sent their money but did not receive

the booklet and that others requested, but did not

=

receive a refund, that evidence failed to mect the

“beyond a reasonable doubt” test. Jn re Winship, 397

U.S. 354. See, Freeman v. Zaharadnick, .... U.S. ....,

97 S.Ct. 1150 (Stewart, J. dissenting). To say, as

the court below did, that the testimony concerning

these allegations constituted “some evidence of fraud”

is to say that the evidence is insufficient to meet

the Winship test.

Commencing with Stromberg v. California, 283 U.S.

359, this Court has repeatedly held that where a verdict

of the jury is general so that it cannot be determined

whether it rested on a valid or invalid ground, the

conviction cannot be sustained. Williams v. North Caro-

lina, 317 U.S. 287, 292; Cramer v. United States,

325 U.S. 1, 36, n. 45; Yates v. United States, 354

U.S. 298, 312; New York Times Co. v. Sullivan,

376 U.S. 254, 284.

Since it is possible that petitioners were convicted

on a finding for which there was “no evidence” or

insufficient evidence (as defined by Winship) a reversal

is mandated.

The court below sought to distinguish Stromberg,

Williams and Yates, saying:

“In all three cases . . . the convictions were

reversed because they could have been based on

an erroneous legal ground. Such convictions are

defective. These cases, however, are distinguishable

from the instant case, in which appellants claim

that the jury could have based its finding of fraud

on facts for which the evidence was insufficient.”

(Emphasis in original. )

The Stromberg rule however is not so limited. In

Cramer v. United States, 325 U.S. 1, the accused

—

was convicted of treason. The indictment set forth

a variety of overt acts, three of which were submitted

to the jury. In reversing, the Court stated:

“The verdict in this case was a general one

of guilty, without special finding as to the acts

© which it rests. Since fis not possible to identify

the grounds on yee was convicted, the

verdict must be set aside if any of the separable

acts submitted are insufficient.” (325 U.S. at 36,

n. 45.)

Even on the lower court’s own terms a reversal

is required here because the jury verdict may have

rested on “an erroneous legal ground.” As noted above

the conviction might have been based on “no evidence.”

Such a conviction is a denial of due process of law

and is “based on an erroneous legal ground.” Similarly

the jury verdict may have been based on evidence

that failed to meet the Winship “beyond a reasonable

doubt” test. Since Winship held that the Due Process

Clause requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt of

every element of a criminal offense, a conviction that

fails to meet that test cannot stand.

In Yates v. United States, 354 U.S. at 312, the

Court states:

“(We think the proper rule to be applied is

that which requires a verdict to be set aside in

cases where the verdict is supportable on one

ground, but not on another, and it is impossible

to tell which ground the jury selected.”

Applying the “proper rule” as set forth in Yates,

the verdict herein should be set aside,

The booklet entitled “MY SECRET” contains general

information on dieting and represents that by drinking

a fruit juice mixture of one-half cup of grape juice,

one-half cup of apple juice and one large mashed

banana just before regular meals, and eating nothing

between meals other than this juice mixture, a person

will lose weight. The booklet is concededly protected

by the First Amendment.

The advertisement makes essentially the same claim.

It states that by following petitioners’ diet plan “the

fats in the foods you eat are changed into energy—

instead of fat.” As already noted this statement in

the advertisement was interpreted at trial as meaning

that a person following petitioners’ diet plan would

lose weight. Thus, the government argued to the jury

“we prove[d] [fraud] by proving that the diet did

not work... .” (R.T. 1251.)

The court below held that there was sufficient evi-

dence for the jury to find that a person following

the diet plan would gain, not lose, weight, saying:

“[E]ach count alleged that the defendants false-

ly and fraudulently represented that by using the

diet tonic, ‘the fats in the foods you eat are

changed into energy instead of fat’. . . Two

government experts testified that a dieter following

the ‘with meals’ plan would not lose weight but

would, in fact, gain weight. The testimony of

—

these experts . . . provided a basis for the jury’s

verdict.”

Finding the evidence sufficient with respect to the

above quoted aspects of the case the court stated:

“We need not decide whether the evidence is

also sufficient with respect to each and all of

the other acts alleged in the indictment.”

It is true that the two government medical experts

testified that a person following petitioners’ diet plan

would not lose weight but would in fact gain weight.

But their testimony did not stand uncontradicted. One

of the government’s experts testified on cross-examina-

tion that if a person followed the diet plan strictly

he might very well lose weight using petitioners’ diet

plan. Additionally petitioners called three medical ex-

perts who testified in favor of the diet plan.

Dr. Gross testified that if the diet plan was strictly

followed according to the rules laid out in the booklet,

“it is quite likely that a person would lose weight

because of the routine, the ritual, the mixture of

the fruit juices will make an important change in

the eating behavior of the individual. Whenever a person

who wishes to lose weight engages in such activities

they tend to eat less.” Additionally, it was his opinion

that the fruit juice mixture will tend to suppress the

appetite and hence a person would eat less. (R.T.

1025.) Dr. Bernstein testified that the diet plan satisfied

the psychological and physiological factors essential

to any successful weight reduction program. (R.T.

1067.) He himself successfully went on the plan (R.T.

1068), and successfully used the plan on some of

his patients. (R.T. 1129, 1132.) He also lectured to

young doctors on the value of the plan. (R.T. 1070,

iabiiies

1072-1076.) Dr. Schlosberg testified that in his opinion

the plan is as good as plans used by doctors including

plans where doctors use drugs. (R.T. 1178.)

It may be that the conflicting expert opinions pro-

vided a basis for the jury’s finding that a dieter following

the diet plan would gain weight instead of losing weight.

That is a far cry however from saying that the evidence

provides a basis for a jury verdict that petitioners

knew that the diet plan would not work and that

the statements contained in the advertisement were

made with intent to defraud. See, American School

of Magnetic Healing v. McAnnulty, 187 U.S. 94; In

re Winship, 397 U.S. 358. It should be noted that

aside from the expert testimony there is not a shred

of evidence to support a finding that petitioners knew

that persons following the diet plan would not lose

weight.

Moreover as Judge Robinson stated in his concurring

opinion in Rodale Press, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commis-

sion, 407 F.2d 1252, 1258 (D.C. Cir. 1968), the

First Amendment may protect unconditionally an ad-

vertisement for a book that repeats “false, misleading

and deceptive” ideas in the book. See, fn. 2 of Justice

Stevens’ dissenting opinion in Splawn v. California,

innate U.S. ......... #76-143 (June 6, 1977). (“[T]o

ban advertising of a book . . . is to suppress the

book . . . itself.”)

Authoritative interpretations of First Amendment

guarantees “have constantly refused to recognize an

exception for any test of truth—whether administered

by judges, juries or administrative officials. . . . The

constitutional protection does not turn upon ‘the truth,

popularity, or social utility of the ideas and beliefs

~~ =

which are offered.’” New York Times Co. v. Sullivan,

376 U.S. 254, 271. A false statement may also have

value since it brings about the clearer perception of

truth by its collision with error. (376 U.S. at 279,

n. 19.)

In medical matters as in other areas of life, the

“false and dangerous ideas” of yesterday are now stand-

ard practice, and vice versa. The medical experts would

have regarded it as homicidal, if the suggestion had

been made in the not too distant past that a cardiac

patient should take up bicycle riding, or if it had

been suggested that a patient should get out of bed

the same day he has undergone surgery. Society’s pres-

ent changing attitude towards the drug laetrile illustrates

the point that it is arrogant to presume that in any

field of knowledge, whether dealing with health or

otherwise all answers are now in.

Even if the communications contained in the adver-

tisement for the booklet are not unconditionally pro-

tected, they are plainly entitled to some First Amend-

ment protection. Linmark Associates, Inc. v. Township

of Willingsboro, ........ == , #76-357 (May 2,

1977); Virginia State Board of Pharmacy v. Virginia

Citizens Consumer Council, Inc., 425 U.S. 748. Adver-

tisements may no longer be placed outside the protection

of the First Amendment by merely invoking the talis-

manic label “fraud.” Now allegedly fraudulent advertise-

ments must be scrutinized to see whether they are

of a character which the principles of the First Amend-

ment protect. The Court has a duty to carefully review

the advertisement and booklet to determine whether

the communications contained therein are within the

protected area. New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376

—a

U.S., at 285. Petitioners respectfully submit that their

communications do contain information and ideas which

bring them within the protected area.

3. The Prosecutors Highly Prejudicial and Unsub-

stantiated Argument to the Jury Denied Petitioners

Due Process of Law and a Fair Trial Guaranteed

by the Fifth Amendment.

As already noted petitioners mailed approximately

28,600 booklets and failed to make refunds in three

instances. At the time petitioners moved for a judgment

of acquittal, at the close of the government’s case,

the trial court recognized the thinness of the govern-

ment’s case based on the failure to make refunds.

After observing that there were only two government

witnesses who requested and did not receive refunds,

the court stated: “Of all the other thousands, the govern-

ment has only been able to show two that did not

get their refunds. . . . It seems to me if I were

defending . . . that I would argue .. . that out

of thousands of solicitations, the government comes

up with two or three . . . cases where the people

did not get their refunds when the defendant really

knew that they wanted the refunds or when this Mrs.

Urasaki knew it. Now in those cases why didn’t they

get their refunds? Well, maybe Mrs. Urasaki sent it

through the mail and it just got lost. That is a possibil-

ity. The mail gets lost every day. . . . [T]hat is

a good argument, and I think it is sustained by the

evidence in this case.” (R.T. 899, 900-902.) Taking

his cue from the trial judge, petitioners’ counsel made

that precise point to the jury in his closing argument.

Thereafter the prosecutor, in rebuttal, argued:

—_— =

“Mr. Fisher would have us bring in 10,000

people who did not get refunds. We are not going

to bring in 10,000 people, ladies and gentlemen;

we are just not going to do it. We brought in

some people. They tried to get refunds, and they

did not get them.” (R.T. 1259.)

This unsubstantiated-argument invited the jury to

believe that the prosecutor had personal knowledge

that 10,000 people requested and did not receive re-

funds. Petitioners were, in effect, subjected to a trial

on the unsworn statements of the prosecutor, which

were without evidentiary support in the record.

In Berger v. United States, 295 U.S. 78, this Court

reversed a criminal conviction because the prosecuting

attorney’s argument to the jury was undignified and

intemperate, containing improper insinuations and asser-

tions calculated to mislead the jury. The Court stated

that because it is the obligation of the United States

Attorney to see that justice is done, he is not at

liberty to strike foul blows although he may, of course

strike hard blows. The Court condemned the prosecut-

ing attorney for inviting the jury to conclude that

he had personal knowledge, harmful to the accused,

which was not in evidence. The Court noted that

the average jury has confidence that the United States

Attorney will be fair to the defendant. “Consequently

improper suggestions, insinuations, and especially asser-

tions of personal knowledge are apt to carry much

weight against the accused when they should properly

carry none.” (295 U.S. at 88.) A large number of

circuit courts have reversed convictions because of im-

proper argument by the United States Attorney. United

States v. Bledsoe, 531 F.2d 888, 892 (8th Cir. 1976);

— =

United States v. Dailey, 524 F.2d 911, 916-917 (8th

Cir. 1975); United States v. Latimer, 511 F.2d 498,

503 (10th Cir. 1975); United States v. Phillips, 527

F.2d 1021, 1023 (7th Cir. 1975); United States v.

Perez, 493 F.2d 1339, 1343 (10th Cir. 1974); United

States v. Gonzalez, 488 F.2d 833, 836 (6th Cir. 1973);

United States v. Achtenberg, 459 F.2d 91, 99 (8th

Cir. 1972); United States v. Stanley, 455 F.2d 644

(4th Cir. 1972); United States v. Grunberger, 431

F.2d 1062, 1068 (2d Cir. 1970); McMillan v. United

States, 363 F.2d 165, 169 (Sth Cir. 1966); Hull v.

United States, 324 F.2d 817, 826 (Sth Cir. 1963);

Dunn v. United States, 307 F.2d 883 (Sth Cir. 1962);

Steele v. United States, 222 F.2d 628, 631 (5th Cir.

1955).

The prosecutor’s improper closing argument was not

limited to his statement concerning 10,000 persons

who allegedly did not receive refunds. Although the

indictment did not charge that petitioners’ diet was

“dangerous” or that any person’s health was endangered,

the prosecutor repeatedly spoke of those “who may

have had bad health problems.” (R.T. 1212.) The

prosecutor argued that petitioners’ booklet was “danger-

ous”, that losing weight without a doctor’s care is

dangerous. (R.T. 1212, 1216-1217.) These inflamma-

tory statements went beyond all fair bounds of legitimate

argument. The prosecutor knew that his statement that

“those diets are harmful” was a misrepresentation of

the record.

The prosecutor also improperly vouched for the relia-

bility of the government’s witnesses and improperly

condemned petitioners’ witnesses. After speaking highly

— =

of the government’s experts and disparagingly of peti-

tioners’ experts the prosecutor argued that petitioners

could not get men such as those obtained by the

government “because these men told the truth.” (R.T.

1216-1217.) In United States v. White, 324 F.2d 814,

816-817 (2d Cir. 1963), the court condemned this

type of argument by the prosecutor, saying:

“Although the prosecutor did not use the person-

al pronoun ‘I’, nevertheless he was in effect vouch-

ing for the reliability of the government’s witness

and for this purpose personified the ‘government’

.... This negative approach [by the prosecuting

attorney concerning the accused’s witnesses] he

quickly contrasted with the affirmative by saying, in

substance, that the government called reliable wit-

nesses who would not testify falsely or change

their stories. These comments were quite unwar-

ranted... .”

See also, United States v. Serrano, 496 F.2d 81

(5th Cir. 1974); United States v. Ludwig, 508 F.2d

140, 143 (10th Cir. 1974).

Finally, although the prosecutor knew that petition-

ers had no obligation to prove anything, he argued

that he did not believe that petitioners had proved

that the diet plan worked. (R.T. 1215.)

In all the prosecutor was guilty of striking “foul

blows” in a pronounced, persistent and prejudicial man-

ner. The cumulative effect upon the jury, “cannot

be disregarded as inconsequential.” Berger v. United

States, 295 U.S. at 89.

ain

4. The Judgment Should Be Reversed Because of the

Concededly Erroneous Instructions to the Jury

Particularly Since the Case Against Petitioners Is

Weak and There Were Cumulative Errors Com-

mitted.

Although the indictment did not charge conspiracy,

the trial judge gave conspiracy instructions. The court

below noted that petitioners did not object to these

instructions. Accordingly the court stated that it would

not reverse “unless there was plain error.” Finding

no “plain error” the court affirmed. Petitioners sub-

mit that the conspiracy instructions were erroneous,

and require a reversal, particularly in light of other

legal errors herein and the weakness of the evidence

against petitioners.

Conclusion.

For the foregoing reasons, a Writ of Certiorari should

issue to review the judgment and opinion of the Court

of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

Respectfully submitted,

STANLEY FLEISHMAN,

FLEISHMAN, BROWN, WESTON & ROHDE,

A Professional Corporation,

Attorneys for Petitioners.

SAM ROSENWEIN,

Of Counsel.

APPENDIX “A”.

Opinion and Judgment of the Court of Appeais,

Ninth Circuit.

United States of America, Appellee, v. Outpost De-

velopment Company, Appellant. United States of Amer-

ica, Appellee, v. Conrad L. Germain, Appellant. United

States of America, Appellee, v. Robert W. Kane, Appel-

lant.

Nos. 75-3160, 75-3060, 75-3161.

United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit.

March 24, 1977.

Defendant individuals and corporation were convicted

in the United States District Court for the Central

District of California, A. Andrew Hauk, J., of mail

fraud, and they appealed. The Court of Appeals, Good-

win, Circuit Judge, held that where multiple specific

acts were alleged in each count of indictment, convic-

tions could be sustained where evidence was sufficient

with respect to one quoted fraudulent statement in

each count, regardless of whether it was also sufficient

with respect to each and all of the other acts alleged

in the indictment; and that no plain error resulted

from “common plan” instructions, though incorrect in

two respects.

Affirmed.

Appeal from the United States District Court for

the Central District of California.

Before TRASK, GOODWIN and KENNEDY, Cir-

cuit Judges.

endjum

OPINION

GOODWIN, Circuit Judge:

Conrad L. Germain, Robert W. Kane, and Outpost

Development Company, a corporation, were tried before

a jury and convicted of eighteen counts of mail fraud

(18 U.S.C. § 1341). They appeal.

In 1972, Germain and Kane established Outpost

Development Company to conduct a mail order business

under the names of Lydia Feldman Methods and Brenda

Hardy Research. The defendants operated the business

with the help of one employee. They mailed interstate

solicitations entitled “Want to Lose Weight?” The solic-

itations, written under the fictitious name Lydia Feld-

man, explained how Lydia had discovered in an occult

writing a recipe for a diet tonic that converted “un-

burned calories into energy.”

The diet tonic was a mixture of ordinary fruit juices

and was to be taken before meals or after meals,

depending upon whether the dieter was following the

“with meals” plan or the “mealless” plan. Lydia invited

the reader to send her $5.95 for the recipe and promised

a refund if the customer was not satisfied.

Testimony established that some persons sent the

$5.95 but did not receive the diet tonic recipe, and

that others requested, but did not receive, a refund.

This was, of course, some evidence of fraud.

Multiple specific acts were alleged in each count

of the indictment. The defendants argue that if the

evidence is insufficient with respect to any one of the

fraudulent acts alleged, the guilty verdict on that count

should be reversed. They rely principally on Stromberg

v. California, 283 U.S. 359, 51 S.Ct. 532, 75 L.Ed.

=——

1117 (1931), Williams v. North Carolina, 317 U.S.

287, 63 S.Ct. 207, 87 L.Ed. 279 (1942), and Yates

v. United States, 354 U.S. 298, 77 S.Ct. 1064, 1

L.Ed.2d 1356 (1957). None of these cases supports

their position.

In Stromberg, the statute contained three alternative

clauses, one of which the Court held unconstitutional.

Because it was impossible to determine whether the

jury had based its verdict of guilty on the unconstitu-

tional clause alone, the Court reversed the conviction.

In Williams, the instructions permitted the jury to

find the defendant guilty on either of two grounds,

one of which was unconstitutional. The Court followed

Stromberg and reversed.

In Yates, the defendant was tried on two different

grounds. In submitting the case to the jury the judge

misstated the law on one of the grounds. Because

the jury could have based its verdict upon an impermis-

sible finding, reversal was necessary.

In all three cases cited above, the convictions were

reversed because they could have been based on an

erroneous legal ground. Such convictions are defective.

These cases, however, are distinguishable from the in-

stant case, in which appellants claim that the jury

could have based its finding of fraud on facts for

which the evidence was insufficient. It is well established

that a count in an indictment is not improper if it

simply charges the commission of a single offense by

different means. United States v. Markee, 425 F.2d

1043 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 400 U.S. 847, 91 S.Ct.

93, 27 L.Ed.2d 84 (1970); United States v. Tanner,

471 F.2d 128 (7th Cir.), cert. denied 409 U.S. 949,

aw we

93 S.Ct. 269, 34 L.Ed.2d 220 (1972). See also Fed.R.

Crim.P. 7(c)(1). Thus, it has been stated:

“* * * The general rule is that when a jury

returns a guilty verdict on an indictment charging

several acts in the conjunctive * * * the verdict

stands if the evidence is sufficient with respect

to any one of the acts charged * * *.” Turner

v. United States, 396 U.S. 398, 420, 90 S.Ct.

642, 654, 24 L.Ed.2d 610 (1970); quoted with

approval in United States v. Hobson, 519 F.2d

765, 774 (9th Cir. 1975).

In the case before the court, each count alleged

that the defendants falsely and fraudulently represented

that by using the diet tonic, “the fats in the foods

you eat are changed into energy instead of fat.” With

respect to this allegation the evidence is more than

sufficient to sustain the verdict.

Two government experts testified that a dieter follow-

ing the “with meals” plan would not lose weight, but

would, in fact, gain weight. The testimony of these

experts also provided a basis for the jury’s verdict.

Because the evidence is sufficient with respect to

the quoted fraudulent statement, we need not decide

whether the evidence is also sufficient with respect

to each and all of the other acts alleged in the indict-

ment.

The defendants next complain about the instructions.

The defendants assert that they may have been con-

victed for conspiracy rather than for the crime charged.

The judge instructed the jury thet if it found that

the defendants had associated themselves in a common

plan with the intent to accomplish some unlawful pur-

pose or to accomplish some lawful purpose by unlawful

_

means, then the acts and statements of one defendant

in furtherance of the plan would be admissible against

the other defendant even though the acts and statements

occurred in the absence and without the knowledge

of the other defendant.

The defendants did not object to these instructions

at trial as required by Fed.R.Crim.P. 30. Because the

defendants failed to object, this court will not reverse

unless there was plain error under Fed.R.Crim.P. 52

(b). Rule 52(b) states that “[p]lain errors or defects

affecting substantial rights may be noticed although

they were not brought to the attention of the court.”

We have examined the instructions here as a whole

and in light of the entire record, and we find no

plain error. First, the instructions do not permit the

jury to base guilt upon mere association in a common

plan. The instructions only permit the jury to weigh

the acts and statements of one defendant in furtherance

of a common plan as evidence against the other defend-

ant. Although such use of evidence is not favored

where conspiracy is not charged, Hernandez v. United

States, 300 F.2d 114 (9th Cir. 1962), it has been

permitted in cases like this, involving a scheme to

defraud. United States v. —-rlin, 538 F.2d 737 (7th

Cir. 1976); United States v. Cohen, 516 F.2d 1358

(8th Cir. 1975); United States v. Grow, 394 F.2d

182, 203 (4th Cir. 1968); Robinson v. United States,

33 F.2d 238, 240 (9th Cir. 1929).

Second, the only essential elements of mail fraud

under 18 U.S.C. § 1341 are that the defendant devised

a scheme to defraud and that for the purpose of

executing this scheme he used the mails or caused

the mails to be used. 18 U.S.C. § 1341. A person

ontiiaen

may cause the mails to be used even though he

did not know that the mails were to be used or intend

that the mails be used, provided that the use of the

mails was reasonably foreseeable. United States v. Weis-

man, 83 F.2d 470, 473 (2d Cir. 1936) (A. Hand,

J.).

In the “common plan” instructions, the trial judge

told the jurors that if they first found a common

plan to commit an unlawful act, then they could hold

one defendant responsible for the acts of another de-

fendant. These instructions are incorrect in two respects:

first, a common plan to commit an unlawful act is

not necessarily a scheme to defraud; second, the “com-

mon plan” instructions did not make it clear that

the acts must be foreseeable.

Neither of these variations constitutes plain error.

Besides the “common plan” instructions, the judge also

defined “a scheme to defraud” for the jury. He explained

that a scheme to defraud “include[s] any plan or

course of action intended to deceive others, and to

obtain, by false pretenses, representations, or promises,

money or property from persons so deceived.” Further-

more, the only evidence of a common plan introduced

at the trial was evidence of the fraudulent scheme.

Because the only evidence of a common plan was

evidence of the fraudulent scheme, the instruction, even

if not wholly correct as a matter of law, could not

have prejudiced the defendants.

Although the judge did not tell the jury in the

“common plan” instructions that the acts had to be

foreseeable, the judge later went to some length to

explain that a defendant need not do the actual mailing

or specifically intend that the mails be used so long

as the use of the mails was reasonably foreseeable.

ouffies

Evidence at the trial established that the defendants

had jointly rented post office boxes for the purpose

of receiving mail addressed to Lydia Feldman Methods

and Brenda Hardy Research and that both defendants

picked up the mail delivered to these post office boxes.

Again, the only essential elements of mail fraud

are that a person devised a scheme to defraud and

that, for the purpose of executing this scheme, the

person used the mails or caused the mails to be used.

The jury knew they must find that the defendants

devised a scheme to defraud and that they intended

to cause the mails to be used to carry out the scheme,

or that the use of the mails in the scheme was fore-

seeable. As to the essential elements of mail fraud,

the instructions were clear. There was no plain error.

Affirmed.

—8—

APPENDIX “B”.

Order Denying Petition for Rehearing and Rejecting

Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc.

Received May 27, 1977.

Filed: May 16, 1977.

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

United States of America, Appellee, v. Outpost De-

velopment Company, Appellant. No. 75-3160.

United States of America, Appellee, v. Conrad L.

Germain, Appellant. No. 75-3060.

United States of America, Appellee, v. Robert W.

Kane, Appellant. No. 75-3161.

ORDER

Appeals from the United States District Court for

the Central District of California.

Before: TRASK, GOODWIN, and KENNEDY, Cir-

cuit Judges.

The panel in the above-entitled cases has voted unani-

mously to deny appellants’ petition for rehearing and

to reject the suggestion for rehearing en banc.

The full court has been advised of the suggestion

for en banc rehearing, and no judge has requested

a vote thereon. Fed. R. App. P. 35(b).

The petition for rehearing is denied and the sugges-

tion for rehearing en banc is rejected.

auliitin

APPENDIX “C”.

Constitutional and Statutory Provisions Involved.

The pertinent provisions of the First Amendment

are: “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging

the freedom of speech, or of the press . . .”

The pertinent provisions of the Fifth Amendment

are: “No person shall be . . . deprived of life,

liberty, or property, without due process of

law...”

The pertinent provisions of the Sixth Amendment

are: “In all criminal prosecutions, the accused

shall . . . be informed of the nature and cause

of the accusation .. .”

Title 18 U.S.C. §1341 (Frauds and Swindles)

provides that:

“Whoever, having devised or intending to devise

any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining

money or property by means of false or fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations, or promises, or to

sell, dispose of, loan, exchange, alter, give away,

distribute, supply, or furnish or procure for unlaw-

ful use any counterfeit or spurious coin, obligation,

security, or other article, or anything represented

to be or intimated or held out to be such counter-

feit or spurious article, for the purpose of executing

such scheme or artifice or attempting so to do,

places in any post office or authorized depository

for mail matter, any matter or thing whatever

to be sent or delivered by the Postal Service,

or takes or receives therefrom, any such matter

or thing, or knowingly causes to be delivered

by mail according to the direction thereon, or

onfiiue

at the place at which it is directed to be delivered

by the person to whom it is addressed, any such

matter or thing, shall be fined not more than

$1,000 or imprisoned not more than five years,

or both.”

ANDAR athens teria snes Mel

——

APPENDIX “D”.

Count One of the Indictment.

The Grand Jury charges:

COUNT ONE

[18 U.S.C. §1341]

From on or about June 19, 1972, and continuing

to on or about April 1, 1974, defendants OUTPOST

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, doing business as Ly-

dia Feldman Methods and Brenda Hardy Research,

CONRAD L. GERMAIN, and ROBERT W. KANE,

devised and intended to devise a scheme and artifice

to defraud and for obtaining money from numerous

persons throughout the United States, by means of

false and fraudulent pretenses, representations and

promises about “My Secret”, a diet plan purportedly

devised by Lydia Feldman and Brenda Hardy, well

knowing said pretenses, representations and promises

were false and fraudulent when made.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises, that be-

tween June 19, 1972 and November 19, 1973, OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods, CONRAD L. GERMAIN and ROBERT

W. KANE, would and did cause “My Secret” direct

mail solicitations to be mailed to numerous persons

throughout the United States, with a return address

of L. Feldman, 8228 Sunset Boulevard, Hollywood,

California 90046.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises that be-

tween November 1, 1973 and April 1, 1974, OUTPOST

— =

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Brenda Hardy Re-

search, CONRAD L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W.

KANE, would and did cause “My Secret” direct mail

solicitations to be mailed to numerous persons through-

out the United States, with a return address of Brenda

Hardy Research, 11848 Vose Street, North Hollywood,

California 91605.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises, that OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods and Brenda Hardy Research, CONRAD

L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, would and

did make the following false and fraudulent representa-

tions in the “My Secret” direct mail solicitations:

a. That Lydia Feldman is a real person.

b. That Brenda Hardy is a real person.

c. That Lydia Feldman, quite by accident, in some

occult book, came across a tonic to be taken before

each meal to preserve the body.

d. That Brenda Hardy, quite by accident, in some

occult book, came across a tonic to be taken before

each meal to preserve the body.

e. That Lydia Feldman, being curious, tried the

tonic.

f. That Brenda Hardy, being curious, tried the tonic.

g. That Lydia Feldman lost 12 pounds within a

week of first trying the tonic.

h. That Brenda Hardy lost 12 pounds within a

week of first trying the tonic.

i. That Lydia Feldman’s friends tried the tonic

and reported similar results.

=

j. That Brenda Hardy’s friends tried the tonic and

reported similar results.

k. That the fats in the foods you eat are changed

into energy instead of fat.

1. That pounds and inches will vanish from sight.

m. That the simple directions for making and using

“My Secret” can be in your mail box in just a few

days.

n. That results are guaranteed.

o. That a person who buys “My Secret” must lose

weight faster, safer and easier than he ever imagined

possible, or he will get his money back.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and obtain money by means of false and fraudulent

pretenses, representations and promises, that OUTPOST

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feldman

Methods and Brenda Hardy Research, CONRAD L.

GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, would and did

accept money and orders for “My Secret”, which orders

in many instances they did not fill.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises, that OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods and Brenda Hardy Research, CONRAD

L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, would and

did use the addresses of 8228 Sunset Boulevard, Los

Angeles, California 90046 and 11848 Vose Street, North

Hollywood, California 91605, to receive money and

orders for “My Secret” diet plan.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

—

lent pretenses, representations and promises that OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods and Brenda Hardy Research, CONRAD

L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, would and

did use a checking account at the Crocker National

Bank, 6424 Sunset Boulevard, Hollywood, California,

to deposit money from those persons intended to be

defrauded.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises, that OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods, CONRAD L. GERMAIN and ROBERT

W. KANE, would and did use P. O. Box 46100,

Los Angeles, California, in which to receive money

and orders for “My Secret” diet plan.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false and fraudu-

lent pretenses that OUTPOST DEVELOPMENT COM-

PANY, dba Lydia Feldman Methods and Brenda Hardy

Research would and did in many instances furnish

“My Secret” diet plan to persons who ordered and

paid for it, said defendants well knowing that “My

Secret” had no medical basis for losing weight.

It was a part of said scheme and artifice to defraud

and for obtaining money by means of false ard fraudu-

lent pretenses, representations and promises, that OUT-

POST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, dba Lydia Feld-

man Methods .and Brenda Hardy Research, CONRAD

L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, would and

did in many instances fail to make refunds to those

persons who specifically requested them.

ae te Be + .

ee ee

eniiiieens,

On or about June 22, 1972, in Los Angeles County,

within the Central District of California, defendants

OUTPOST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, CON-

RAD L. GERMAIN and ROBERT W. KANE, for

the purpose of executing the aforesaid scheme and

artifice, and attempting to do so, caused to be sent

or delivered by the United States Postal Service a

letter containing check number 456 for $5.95, dated

June 19, 1972, addressed to Lydia Feldman, 8228

Sunset Boulevard, Los Angeles, California 90046, hav-

ing been placed in the mail by Natalie Monat, at

Arlington, Virginia.

—

APPENDIX “E”.

The Advertisement.

Want to Lose Weight?

If you’re like me, you’ve probably tried diets and

pills and gadgets and exercises and health spas and

who knows what else—without lasting success. The

moment you stop dieting or exercising, those horrible

pounds come rushing back.

And isn’t it the most maddening thing the way

some people can eat anything and everything and never

put on weight?

Now there has to be a reason why we can’t keep

the weight off and why others never gain weight—and

here it is: No matter what you have been told in

the past, the only reason an adult gains weight is

because his body is not able to convert all of the

calories he eats into energy. Those unconverted calories

collect on the body in the form of useless fat.

But the person whose body is able to convert all

the calories into energy stays ‘slim as a rail’—no mat-

ter how much he eats.

Simple, isn’t it. But what can you do about it?

How can you get your body to start burning up those

calories instead of storing them?

Quite by accident, in some occult writings that I

was studying, I came across a tonic to be taken before

each meal to ‘preserve the body’. Being curious, I

tried it—and was shocked. Within the first week, I

had lost 12 pounds without experiencing a moment

of food-craving hunger. My astonished friends tried

it and reported similar results.

a a a A

==

Don’t ask me how it works—but it does! Taken

before each meal, this tonic seems to have a magic

effect on the body. You feel an instant lift as your

body goes to work doing whatever it does to convert

all those unburned calories into energy. And best of

all, the ingredients for this tonic are not expensive

and are available in any health food store.

Think of it! No more tortuous diets. No more strain

on your nerves. No more inhuman demand on your

willpower to starve yourself while others around you

feast.

Just think what this means to you! Now the starches,

the carbohydrates, the fats in the foods you eat are

changed into energy—instead of fat. Meal time, snack

time, party time are no longer moments of regret—no

longer the cause of more fat—because now your body

is protected!

Never again do you have to punish yourself with

harsh and tiring exercises or follow diets that turn

you into a ragged bundle of nerves. There’s no strain

on you—no drain on your health—no expensive change

in your living (except, of course, for the new clothes

you will have to buy as the pounds drop off and

stay off).

So if you are seriously determined to lose weight—

and keep it off—if you’ve finally made up your mind

that never again will you suffer the shame and em-

barrassment of being overweight—if you want to see

pounds and inches vanish from sight—and vanish for-

ever—take advantage of this offer today.

The simple directions for making and using this

amazing tonic—which I call "MY SECRET”—can be

—

in your mailbox in just a few days. Results are

guaranteed. You be the judge. You must lose weight—

and lose it faster, safer, and easier than you ever

imagined possible—or your money back. Use the handy

no-risk coupon below.

LYDIA FELDMAN.

RESEARCH DIRECTOR

8228 Sunset Blvd—Los Angeles, CA 90046

YES, I want to lose weight and keep it off. Send to me

the directions for making and using “MY SECRET”—

the safest, fastest, most effective fat-destroyer in the

world. I understand that the inexpensive ingredients

for this tonic are available in any health food store.

I must start losing weight within the first 24 hours—

and continue to lose it and keep it off as long as

I continue to use “MY SECRET” or my money will

be refunded in full.

Enclosed is full payment of $5.95

[] cash [] check [] money order

[] Mr. [] Mrs. [] Miss

Nee ea ssrtrrrsenceniinnsnsneonnseres

Please note: You must not only lose pounds but inches

as well. And you must look and feel better than you

ever have in your entire life—without feeling a moment

of hunger—or YOUR MONEY BACK.

Lydia Feldman Methods

8228 Sunset Blvd.—Los Angeles, CA 90046

F-523

— =

APPENDIX “F”.

The Booklet

M Y

SECRET

by Lydia Feldman

The

Lydia Feldman

Method

for

Weight Control

Copyright ©1972 by Lydia Feldman Methods. All rights

reserved. Nothing may be reprinted without written

permission from the publisher.

Published by Lydia Feldman Methods, 8228 Sunset

Boulevard, Los Angeles, California.

First Printing: February 1972

THANK YOU for ordering this booklet describing

‘my secret’ for losing weight and keeping it off.

In the weeks ahead—as you follow this program—all

of your friends and relatives who watch your progress

will marvel at your new trim figure as it appears.

How proud and pleased you'll be!

And to retain that new slimness for years to come,

all you need to is to continue to follow the simple

rules in this booklet.

Best wishes,

Lydia Feldman

—20—

CONTENTS

Page

I sincccstictenanssitstiinsiipiaigpaninivnninepenaniananatinateieie 5

A Word About Your Health .............2.2.0...........22----- 5

ee I saibsesdiitsnsinieniidiieditanabbineiaidcintcaennsmmnnicncetsnmnensenens 6

Here’s The Catch .......................... tbiiibitainaianilds 6

How To Squeeze Juice .....................-2..---.c.c0.-seceeees 7

Watels Tike TUMRBOTRORTO q..........22-00000-0.ceccs0e-sence-cccescese 8

Ue 9

Be I ID vison ia teccsinteressitnincetendiumeonenienncenecionbnetitin 10

RIT sath he nincciarinelnattiinieatinnmnniecenenehiemamnnnneidieniits 10

IEE THEE \sxshindigischainbbicteniitancinitinndensdimimneiiienntiveniiistias 11

a ll cellhieteliipialidaibanennailileile 12

IMPORTANT

Whether this is your first time—or another attempt

at losing weight, you must start this program with

the idea firmly planted in your mind that you'll stay

with it until you have reached your goal. And make

sure the goal you set is a realistic one.

If you don’t sincerely want to lose weight—if you're

not prepared to follow my program conscientiously—

then go no further in this booklet. Instead, return

it for an immediate refund.

A WORD ABOUT YOUR HEALTH

Your health is your most precious asset and should

not be taken for granted. Care should be taken with

any program of weight loss. Remember that you should

lose weight for the sake of your health and not for

your appearance alone. If you are in doubt, consult

your doctor.

As with any major change in your daily way of life,

don’t abuse your body. The program outlined in this

a ae ee ———— ee

olin

booklet will provide a most adequate reduction in your

weight. Don’t deprive yourself of all food just for

a quicker weight loss.

Also, bear in mind that losing weight is a personal

matter. Each person is his own special case. Don’t

judge your progress by others. Body metabolism is

different with each individual. My program is designed

to be successful—if you follow it!

MY SECRET

Here’s how you can drink your way to a slim figure

—and keep it.

Mix one-half cup of grape juice, one-half cup of apple -

juice, and one large mashed banana. Blend together

and drink just before your regular meals.

Eat nothing between meals. If you must have something

to carry you to the next meal, mix up another batch

of this tonic. You can drink all you want of this

tonic. Unlike regular foods, you cannot ‘over-consume’

this tonic.

That’s all there is to it.

Sound too simple to be tiue?

HERE’S THE CATCH

You cannot use the ordinary canned, frozen, or

bottled versions of the juice that sxe available in the

ordinary supermarket. They will not work!

I cannot emphasize this too strongly. The ordinary

juices that you buy in the supermarket are saturated

with additives, preservatives, white sugars, and sweet-

eners. The white sugars in particu. upset your body

metabolism, your body chemistry, and the delicate cal-

cium phosphorous balance of your body.

_

Furthermore, most commercially-prepared supermarket

juices have undergone a pre-heating process to pasteur-

ize and preserve them for a long life on your grocer’s

shelves. This is great for your grocer but the pre-

heating destroys many valuable and perishable nutrients

and enzymes your body must have to make this program

work.

You must purchase fresh fruits and squeeze your own

juice. If this is impossible, go to a health food store

and have them squeeze juice for you. As a last resort,

certain bottled juices can be used—but will not work

nearly as well as freshly-squeezed juice. The label on

these bottled juices must read: ‘No Sugar Added and

No Preservatives.’

HOW TO SQUEEZE JUICE

An electric juice extractor, such as those sold in almost

all health food stores and houseware outlets is the

best. An electric model is able to separate the juice

from the pulp in a matter of minutes. The juice comes

down a funnel right into your glass. Visit any health

food store and make your selection.

Second choice would be a manual juicer. You will

have to press a lever to get the juice. Nevertheless,

it does the job and will save you some money.

If you are without a juicer (traveling, for example),

make your own juice in this simple manner. Cut

the fruit into small pieces. Wrap in some clean cheese-

cloth.

Twist and squeeze the juice into a glass. Mash the

banana with a fork and add it to the juice.

Always select fresh fruit. Select organically grown fruits

if possible, such as those sold in health food stores.

ene) ae eeenere

Ce ATE A 6 OD ew 0 OF eee

_—

Store in a refrigerator (except the bananas) to prevent

loss of vitamin and mineral supply.

Cut out all discolored spots. These should not be

used since they may cause ‘juice fermentation’ and

loss of nutrients.

Wash the apples and grapes beneath free-flowing faucet

water. Use a stiff vegetable brush to scrub away any

residue.

Slice the apples into small pieces that can be inserted

easily into the feeder of the juicer. Close the lid or

whatever is used. Press the switch. The juice will

come down the funnel right into your glass. Do the

same with the grapes. Add the banana. Blend and

drink on the spot.

Never store freshly-squeezed juice. But if you must,

use a glass bottle. Screw on a tight cap. Store in

the section of the refrigerator where you keep the

milk.

Keep your juicer sparkling clean. Use warm water

and a brush immediately after you have finished squeez-

ing the juice. You will be rewarded with many years

of excellent service. At the time you acquire your

juicer, ask for instructions on how to operate and

maintain it.

WATCH THE TEMPERATURE

To be properly effective, the tonic you drink must

be neither too coid or too hot. If you store your

juice in bottles in the refrigerator, remember to bring

it out of the refrigerator ahead of time.

--

—24—

Ice cold juices decrease or halt the flow of digestive

enzymes and cause the famous ‘summer diarrhea’. Very

warm juices create a sudden flow of digestive enzymes

which lead to stomach upset.

If you are preparing fresh juice, squeeze the juice

immediately after you remove the fruit from the re-

frigerator. This will give you the best possible juice

at exactly the right temperature for your body.

WHY THIS TONIC WORKS

Many of the precious ‘body building materials’ and

vitamins are found in the juices of fresh fruit. These

are locked within the cellulose fibers of the plant.

In order to take out these nutrients, the digestive

system must labor to break down the fibrous cells.

For many persons this poses a difficult problem for

their digestive system. But raw juices contain ‘instant

digestion’ of such nutrients that might otherwise remain

locked within the cellulose fibers and imprisoned until

passed off as body waste.

The body can assimilate over 90% of the nutrients

in fresh juices within 10 to 20 minutes. It can take

up to four hours to assimilate bulk food. It is this

power of the juices that make this tonic work. What

you eat is vital but what you assimilate is inviolate.

Fresh juice provides the speedy assimilation without

bulk that your body needs to remain healthy and

slim.

No less an authority than the British Ministry of Health

and Public Health Service Laboratory says this about

freshly-squeezed juice: “The sources of the essential

amino acids, the cell building factors, are destroyed

by heat and processing and are not obtainable in foods

— nh ae a ORR Rane PPR on ee

-_

Pte

—, 1

thus prepared. Juices, therefore, are the only means

practical to get these re-building factors.

Most persons are overweight because they eat too much.

The key to appetite control is to stabilize your blood

sugar level. The natural sugars in the grapes and apples

combine with the fruit sugar of the bananas in this

tonic.

When this tonic is absorbed into your body’s system

(which is almost immediately) the blood sugar concen-

tration rises and is maintained for a period of time

along with a slowly-released carbohydrate action which

controls your appetite and reduces the urge to eat.

NEED I SAY MORE

Get busy right now. Search out and obtain a supply

of the ingredients for this tonic and start using it

today.

But remember—you won’t get anywhere by taking the

easy route of buying ordinary canned or frozen juice

from your supermarket. It won’t work.

You’ve got to do the work of squeezing it yourself

or finding a place that will squeeze it fresh for you.

But if you can gain—and keep—a slim, trim figure,

won't it be worth it?

REMEMBER

Buy fresh fruit.

Squeeze it yourself.

Make only as much as you need for one use. You'll

soon learn how much fruit to use.

—=— =

SPECIAL TIPS

1 — Never skip a meal.

2— Drink one glass of this tonic just before your

regular meals.

3 — Eat nothing between meals except this tonic. You

can drink all you want of this tonic as your

body will not permit you to ‘over-consume’ it.

4—Chew your food thoroughly. Take small bites.

Eat slowly. Make the most of each meal.

5 — Don’t weigh yourself every day. Weigh yourself

just once a week—at the same time—on the same

scale.

6 — If you fall off this program, don’t hate yourself.

Start again—right away.

7 — Don’t get discouraged. Those extra pounds won't

vanish overnight. Remember you did not gain

your excess weight in just a few days—so it

is not fair to expect to lose it in a few days.

8 — Most persons will lose a large amount of weight

the first week, less the second week, and probably

none the third week. Don’t let that discourage

you. Don’t be a quitter the third week. Your

weight loss will start in again during the fourth

week.

9 — If you’re a woman, remember that you'll probably

gain a few pounds of water the week before

your menstrual period, but you will lose this extra

poundage in a few days. Don’t let that make

you a quitter.

STICK WITH IT.

YOU'LL BE GLAD YOU DID.

= =

FOOTNOTE

I had thought this method for weight control to be

my own, having found it in an old occult book where

it was described as a tonic to ‘preserve the body’.

Imagine my surprise to discover this same tonic while

reading a book by Carlson Wade, editor of Popular

Medicine magazine. His book, entitled “Health Tonics,

Elixirs, and Potions for the Look and Feel of Youth”,

was published in 1971 by Parker Publishing Company.

On pages 189 and 190 you will find he speaks most

highly of this method for weight control.

I am deeply indebted to Mr. Wade for his explanation

of how this tonic works and I highly recommend his

book to those of you who would like more information

on what nature’s ‘pure foods’ can do for you.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Petition — Germain v. United States · 434 U.S. 965 | Frix