Petition — Stich v. United States
Supreme Court brief1977
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
——— 7. - - — . 3 ae «
Supreme Court, U. S,
: | ILED ;
JUL 5 1977
in ‘the ' | MICHAEL RODAK, JR., CLERK
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED'STATES
October Term 77
97-30
RODNEY F, STICH,
Petitioner,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Rodney F. Stich,
Petitioner, pro se
Rodney F. Stich
1416 Carleton Drive
Concord, California 94518
Phone: (415) 933-1233
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Opinions below...+s-+seerereereers 2
JUTiSdiCtiON, .,4-eeeeeeeerereeeres 2
Questions presented for Review.... 3
Constitutional and statutory
Provisions Inyolved......++-+s+++ 94
Statement of the Case,...-+-+ereee 7
ATQUMENE,.ceeeeeeeeererecevceses 1B
Reasons for Granting the Writ..... 36
ee cccevesceses > &
Appendix:
A--Opinion of the U.S. Court
re) Appeals... ,eeseseereree la
B--Petitioner's Petition for
Rehearing wo U.S. Court
of Appea eeerevveeenreer ere 3a
C--Dismissal Order of U.5.
Court of Appcals........- 25a
D--Due Process Clause of
Fifth Amendment to Con-
stitution of the United
StaleS...cceecereeereres 26a
E--Applicable Statutes...... 278
i
F--Dismissal Order of U.S. District
COMET. ccccccccccccccovccns eos 8
CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY PROVISIONS
The federal constitutional provision involved is
the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment
of the Constitution of the United States, which. is
set forth in Appendix D.
The following statutes, which are sect forth in
Appendix E are involved:
| 28 U.S.C, 2401
28 U.S.C. 2201
28 U.S.C, 1331
28 U.S.C. 1361
5 U.S.C. 701, 702,703, 704,706
28 U.S.C, 1406 (Cc)
Federal Aviation Act, Pub. L 85-726
(72 Stat. 797), Section 1007 (a)
42 U.S.C. 1985
In the
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1977
No.
Rodney F. Stich,
Petitioner,
Ve
United States of America
Federal Aviation Administration,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Petitioner, Rodney F. Stich, petition for a
writ of ccrtiorari to review thc judgment of
the United States Court of Appeals, rendered
herein on April 7, 1977.
OPINICNS BELOW
The opinion of the United States Court of
Appeals is shown as Appendix A to this peti-
tion.
JURISDICTION
The Judgment of the U.S. Court of Appeals
for which review is sought was entercd on
April 7, 1977. The jurisdiction of this Court
is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 8 1254(a) and
28 U.S.C. § 2101 (c). A petition for rehear-
ing was filed on April 20, 1977. This petit-
ion was denied by order dated May 9, 1977.
The mandate of the Court of Appeals was dated
May 18, 1977, affirming the judgment of the
U.S. District Court.
A petition to the U.S. Supreme Court for
P . an extcnsion of time was dated junc 22, 1977.
QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW
The following qucstions are presented by
this appeal.
1. Did the court err in rclusiny to accept
mandatory jurisdiction of the first cause of
action, sccking mandatory and prohibitory
relicf as to alleged gross abuse of discret- .
ion, culpable misconduct, actions outside the
law, as to the Federal Aviation Administra-
tion's air safety activitics.
2. Did the court crr in dismissing the pe-
titioner's first cause of action, by fabricating
and falscly stating petitioner was asking the
court to make an investigation of the PAA;
implying that petitioncr was not willing to
proceed with this action; and then citing this
false, fabricated cxcuse as taking this action
out of the class of "justiciable controversy. m
and thus claiming this was not a "justiciable
controversy."
3. Is the federai court powerless to inter-
vene when an executive agency is engaged in
gross abuse of discretion, actions outside of
the law, culpable misconduct, especially when
such acts can be associated with the deaths of
specific air travelers in specific air carrier
crashes.
4. Did the court err when it dismissed pe-
titioner's action for job reinstatement for fed -
eral employment, claiming the action should
have been filed in the U.S. Court of Claims in-
stead of the U.S. District court.
5. Did the court err wher it dismissed the
petitioner's action for back pey as a federal
employee, claiming the action should have
been filed in the U.S. Court of Claims instead
c* ree U.S. District Court.
u. Did t.. U.S. Court of Appeals and the
U.S. District court engage in a cover up of
the serious misconduct that forms the basis
‘ - of these three causes of action.
CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY
PROVISIONS INVOLVED
The Federal constitutional provision invol-
ved is the Due Process Clause of the Fifth
Amendment of the Constitution of the United
States, which is set forth in Appendix C .
The following statutes, which are set forth
in Appendix E, are also involved:
5 U.S.C. 8 701 (Administrative Procedure
Act, pertaining to government
and government employees).
5 U.S.C. 8 702 (right to judicial review to
federal employees).
5 U.S.C. 8 703 (Mandamus action involving
government and government
employces is function of dis-
trict court).
- 28 U.S.C, 8 1331 (mandatory jurisdiction
conferred upon U-S. District
courts, by law, to accept act -
ions pleading federal queation.
28 U.S.C. § 1361 (Action to compel an
officer of the United States to
perform his duty).
28 U.S.C. 8 1406(c) Court's duty to trans-
fer actions from U.S. District
Court to U.S. Court of Claims
if filed in the wrong court.
28 U.S.C. 8 2201 (concerns elements of
justiciable controversy).
42 U.S.C. 8 1985. Ancillary jurisdiction.
The United States District courts
have ancillary jurisdiction to
hear all matters when part of
the claims are within its juris-
diction.
Pub. L. 85-726; Stat. 797. Section 1007. Fed-
eral Aviation Act. Pertains to
mandamus actions in district
courts seeking mandatory and
prohibitory writ if any statute,
rule, regulation of the Act is
being violated.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
This case involves the attempts by the pe-
titioner to obtain a mandatory and prohibitory
writ Jirccted to the Federal Aviation Adminis -
tration, ordering the FAA Ww ccase illegal
coverup actions of major air safety irregular -
itles and directing the FAA to comply with the
gtatutes, rules and regulations of the nation’s
air safety laws that it is required to cnforce;
and to cease obstructing the lawful cfforts of
FAA safcty inspectors who scck to comply with
the nation's air safcty requiremcnts.
The petitioner is a former airline pilot and
Navy Patrol Plane Commander of many years;
holds numerous FAA pilot ratings including
jet and other types of air carrier aircraft; is
highly qualified in the field of air safety; and
had becn an FAA jet operations inspector and
investigator for approximately five ycars.
The basis for this action is the widespread
and long standing FAA misconduct discovered
by petitioner while in the emply of the FAA
as an inspector/investigator.
Petitioner discovered the cover up of
major air safety irregularities that were con-
trary to law and contrary to accepted indus-
try practices, at certain favored air carriers,
massive and illégal interference by key FAA
management personne! with the lawfully re-
quired corrective actions, the destruction of
official investigative reports citing major
safety irregularities. These were and are
deeply engrained into the FAA agency.
Petitioner's attempts to correct these irreg-
ularities, or at least attempt to comply with
his own legal and moral job responsibilities,
were met with harassment, intimidation, threats,
and other acts, contrary to law.
Appeals to higher FAA officials, to other
government agencies including the Civil Ser-
vice Commission and the Department of Jus-
tice, produced no corrective actions.
The CAB Bureau of Safety was requested to
conduct an investigation as required by the
Federal Aviation Act when a complaint is
made, and it too refused.
While unsucceesful in obtaining corrective
actions, petitioner developed a massive file
showing the existance of extensive internal
FAA misconduct in cover up of major air safety
irregularities and the association of such re-
fusal to act with several specific air diasters
that the National Transportation Safety Board
has refused to identify in its accident reports.
By means of government transcripts devel-
oped by petitioner's activities, the felonious
cover up activities of the FAA are shown in
detail, along with the deaths of the persons
perishing from the air safety irregularities
illegally covered up.
Meeting with a mass of executive agency
blocks, apathy from the legislative branch,
petitioner sought to obtain judicial relief in
what developed into a major government and
10
‘ air safety scandal, closely related to specific
deaths in certain air carrier crashes.
Petitioner sought judicial adjudication of this
controversy by using the mandamus functions
of the federal court system. He initiated this
use of the federal court system by first stating
in a written memorandum that he would refuse
to work in the illegal environment and that
after the FAA took removal action, a complaint
would be filed in court. The purpose of this
was to get the allegations and evidence of F AA
misconduct before the court, and obtaining a
mandatory and prohibitory writ.
Petitioner then filed, within the statute of
limitation period, three causes of action.
The first and primary cause of action seeks
a mandatory and prohibitory writ directed to
the FAA, forcing it to comply with the stat-
utes, rules and regulations pertaining to air
carrier safety.
Petitioner showed his readiness to proceed
with this litigation by his ability to circumvent
11
the leval blocks put into his path. Excercise of
petitioner's discovery rights were denied by |
the district court judge. Upon receipt of petit-
ioner's revealing documents in request for
admissions, and revealing interrogatories, the
Department of Justice requested, and the judge
accomodated, with an order stopping discovery.
Defendants filed a motion for summary judg-
ment, or in the alternative, dismissal.
The district court judge stated in open court
that this was a matter for Congress to investi -
gate, and not a matter for the courts; and stated
that the district courts cannot intervene in the
discretionary activities of a government agency.
The failure of Congress to respond to its du-
ties docs not void the numerous statutory and
case laws that give to the district courts the
mandatory jurisdiction, and the responsibility
to hear actions involving federal questions of
this nature.
Petitioner's pleadings alleged to gross abusc
of discretion, and the court has jurisdiction.
12
The mandatory jurisdiction of the United
States District Courts to hear mandamus act-
ions directed to gross abuse of discretion by
government agencies includes title 28 U.S.C.
2401; 28 U.S.C, 1361; the Federal Aviation
Act, and others:
. Title 28 U,S,C, 1331 states that allegations
of federal questions confers mandatory juris-
diction upon the U.S. District courts to hear
mandamus actions. Pctitioner's allegations
in the pleadings raised the type of questions
that confer mandatory jurisdiction upon the
district courts.
Section 1007 of the Federal Aviation Act
confers jurisdiction upon the district courts
in mandamus actions when the allegations in
the pleadings cite violations of any of the sta-
tutes, rules or regulations of the Act. That
ofcourse, is the gist of petitioner's plead-
ings.
None of these statutes conferring man-
datory jurisdiction upon the federal courts
13
qualify such jurisdiction with the point that
Congress should have first crack at it.
Despite the comments by the district judge
in pre-trial conferences about the seriousness
of the discovery documents, despite his re-
cognition of the-tragic side effects of such
cover ups, the action was dismissed.
Finding of facts and conclusions of law werk
requested by the petitioner, but the trial judge
refused to elaborate on his dismissal action,
and denied the request.
An appeal was filed with the U.S. Court of
Appeals, and this appeal route was again util-
ized to submit still more revealing evidence
into this action.
A stack of documents nearly a foot high were
introduced in the form of affidavits, including
parts of a manuscript that described in detail
the FAA misconduct. At this point the courts
had prima facie evidence supporting petitioner's
allegations, and surely recognized the gravity
of the matter.
14
From the evidence submitted into this action
to date, the court can determine the seriousness
of the subject matter, and the deaths that have
been associated with it, along with the deaths
that will continue to occur until this matter is
properly exposed.
The U.S. Court of Appeals, therefore, had a
recognizable problem of major national impact
before it, in this action, plus supporting evi-
dence.
Though by law a plaintiff does not have to
prove his case in the pleadings to have the
court decide to ry it, in this action the court
had supporting evidence, increasing its moral
and legal responsibilities to assist in the prompt
adjudication of the issues.
In open court, the position of the appeals
court was that this was a matter for Congress
to investigate. Thisis ofcourse a responsibil-
ity of Congress, but when brought before the
court in the form petitioner has done in this
action, the district courts have the mandatory
15
jurisdiction to adjudicate the matter. In open
court, no other point was raised by the appeals
court or the Department of Justice attorney.
The decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals
was issued on April 7, 1977, and as to the first
cauge of action, the court stated:
"To the extent Stich's action seeks a
judicially-supervised investigation of
the conduct of the FAA, he has failed
to present a "justiciable controversy, "
i.e., an issue in a form "capable of
resolution through the judicial process. "
Flast vy. Cohen, 392 U.S. 83, 95 (1968).
The federal courts are neither equipped
nor empowered to undertake congressional -
style investigations into »\legations of agen-
cy misconduct. "
The U.S. Court of Appeals has interjected a
false premise to circumvent the mandatory jur-
isdiction of the courts to hear this action.
Solely on the false basis that petitioner was
asking the court to conduct an investigation
16
of the FAA, the court of appeals dismissed this
serious action. The petitioner, in his petition
for rehearing, strongly stated he had not, and
was not, requesting the court to conduct an in-
vestigation.
The court ignored this statement, stuck to its
statement for dismissing this action, obviously
a fraudulent excuse, and refused to change its
dismissal order.
A "justiciable controversy", as described by
law in 28 U.S.C.A. 2201, and its footnotes,
states that a justiciable controversy requires
that a dispute must exist, and it can be safe to
assume that there exists a dispute between the
FAA and the petitioner; that the dispute must be
more than mere disagreement or debate; and that
it can be resolved by actions of the court.
All these elements exists in this action.
_———
It appears to be an act of desperation by the
appeals court to reach so far to fabricate an
excuse for dismissing this key government
scandal that is so easily proven false.
17
Also arising out of the underlying FAA mis-
conduct was the petitioner's action for job re-
ingtatement and back pay. The U.S. Court of
Appeals stated: "The claim should have been
made in the Court of Claims, not the district
court. "
The statutes contradicting this include title
28 U.S.C. 2401; title 28 U.S.C. 1361; title
5 U.S.C. 701, 702, 703; title 42 U.S.C. 1985;
By law, the district court should have trans-
ferred the actions for job reinstatement and
back pay to the U.S. Court of Claims as pro-
vided by 28 U.S.C. 1406 (c), but this was not
done.
Petitioner sought to correct the court's out-
rageous disregard of multiple statutory and
case laws, and filed a petition for rehearing on
April 20, 1977. By order dated May 9, 1977,
the U.S. Court of Appeals stated: ‘The petition
for rehearing ts denied. "
18
ARGUMENT
The U.S. District court refused to accept
jurisdiction of this first cause of action involv -
ing agency misconduct, falsely claiming it had
no power to intervene in the discretionary acti-~-
vaties of a federal agency.
Petitioner plainly stated in his pleadings that
it was a gross abuse of discretion, actions
outside the law, culpable misconduct, closely
associated with several major air carrier crash-
ea. By specific statutory and case law, cited
by petitioner and surely known to the federal
judges, these were federal issues that con-
ferred mandatory jurisdiction upon the court
to hear the matter.
The broad constitutional powers of the dis-
trict courts also conferred jurisdiction upon
the court. In light of the gravity of the matter,
the legal responsibility was augmented by the
moral responsibilities to intervene and hear
this action.
LY
It was not necessary to seek these broad con-
stitutional powers to hear the action petitioner
brings before the court. The jurisdiction of the
district Courts to accept this first cause of act-
lon is given by 18 U,S,C, 1331, which provides
that a district court must accept an action if
the pleadings cite a controversy involving fed-
eral questions within the court's jurisdiction.
Abuse of discretion by a government agency
fallg within the court's jurisdiction.
Title 28 U.S,C.A. 1361 provides for action
to “compel an officer of the United States to per-
form his duty.’ This section makes it clear that
the federal district courts have the mandatory
jurisdiction to order agencies of the federal gov-
ernment to perform their legal dutics. It states:
"District courts are open to prevent an
administrative body, exercising police
powcr, from excceding its jurisdiction
and from taking arbitrary and unreasonable
‘ action, and no special provision of law is
necessary to confer upon the courts author -
ity already possessed by them under the
Constitution. Rights of judicial revicw cxists
by statutes and under gencral powers of
the court conferred upon them by the Con-
stitution."
This authority and jurisdiction is clearly stated
in the statutes, is continually being used by the
district courts, and the statement that the Court
does NOT have authority is another example of
the judicial coverup that is so obvious in this
action.
Still further and specific authority specifically
directed to air safety matters is seen by the Fcd-
eral Aviation Act (Pub law 85-726; 72 Stat. 797;)
Section 1007, which states: "If any person vio-
lates any provision of this Act,....any party in
interest, may apply to the district court of the
United States for the enforcement of such pro-
vision of this Act or of such rule, regulation,
of
eee
21
Title 28 U.S.C. 2401 confers jurisdiction
of the district court to hear mandamus actions
directed to government agencies for mandatory
and prohibitory writs in the event of agency abuse
of discretion, job reinstatement of federalem- ‘*°
ployees.
The United States Court of Appeals is not so
ignorant of such basic legal rights as these. It
surely recognized that pa itioner's pleadings
conferred mandatory jurisdiction upon the
court.
The appeals court also, was not so naive or
ignorant that it didn't recognize petitioner's
action had very serious national implications,
had serious overtones of fraud and felonious mis-
conduct associated with the deaths cited by the
petitioner. The court surely recognized that
this was a government scandal that has gotten
out of hand, and that any actions that held the
risk of public discovery of these misdeeds
were a threat to the three branches of govern-
ment.
22
Incredibly, the federal court that has as
its primary function the forcing of compliance
with federal laws, acted to circumvent the fed-
eral laws, and fabricated a falschood to circum-
vent the federal laws of mandatory jurisdiction. -
It falsely stated ‘in its dismissal action that
petitioner was asking the court staff to make an
investigation of the FAA, and that this request
removed the action from being a "justiciable
controversy. "
In petitioner's petition for rehearing dated
April 20, 1977, he wrote:
“Appellant Stich is NOT asking the federal
courts to conduct a judicial investigation. The
judge, the clerk, and his secretary, would
hardly be qualified to conduct such an in-
vestigation, and Stich, after many blocks
put into his exposure attempts, would not
trust the politically sensitive fedcral courts
with such an investigation. "’
This denial did not affect the appeals court.
It refused to change its position that petitioner
23
was asking the court to conduct the investiga -
tion of the FAA. In its May 9, 1977 order, it
stated: "The petition for rehearing is denied. "
Petitioner didn't show any inability to proceed
with this action. The pleadings, the discovery,
the affidavits, the-methods of circumventing the
mass of blocks put in his path by the Department
~ of Justice and the judicial branch of government,
and before that by the executive branch, his
holding of hearings in the FAA, didn't indicate
any signs of lack of ability. His pleadings and
his grasp of federal law as shown in these plead-
ings, indicates his ability to procced with this
action.
We now have, if we didn't already have it
with the district court, the naked judicial action
in blocking this action, which many persons
would identify as judicial fraud.
If only a governmental scandal was involved,
this would be serious enough, Bi" as the courts
recognized, there were lives involved.
24
If only one branch of government had acted
within the law, had not engaged in a cover up of
the FAA, it is doubtful that such tragedies as the
Paris DC-10 holocaust could have happened. It
required the continuation of the FAA coverup for
that greatest of all diasters to occur. And it re-
quired the cover ups by the three branches of
government, the refusal to comply with moral
and legal responsibilities, for the three branches
of government to cover up for the FAA miscon-
duct that has caused such a heavy loss of life in
the air diasters cited in petitioner's pleadings.
The FAA misconduct is so deeply engrained,
aided and abetted by the actions of the National
Transportation Safety Board, that more crashes
arising from the dispicable misconduct will con-
tinue to occur.
The judicial system, now, will have a part in
such consequences, though it actually played a
part long before this action was filed in the fed-
eral courts.
A Congressional investigation was certainly
a concurrent need in this action, as to the govern-
mental misconduct. It appears there is a need
for a Congressional investigation as to the act-
ions of the federal courts in blocking this act-
ion and in the apparent cover up of the major
scandals involved.
If this type of cover up or acts done by the
federal courts, were done by a private citi-
zen, even though the citizen did not have the
moral and legal responsibilities and public trust,
the wrath of the Department of Justice and the
Federal courts would be heaped upon him, with
imprisonment a probability.
If done by an administration not popular with
the liberal press or judicial system, the news
media would have decimated the perpetrators.
Thesc judicial actions are nothing but raw and
naked misuse of government facilitics, in de-
fiance of law. Fortunately for the perpetrators,
the public hasn't yet learned of this outrage.
26
The appeals court dismissed petitioner's action
for job reinstatement and back pay, stating: "As
to Stich's contention that the district court erred
in dismissing his claim to job reinstatement and
back pay from the FAA which discharged him
after he refused tp work until alleged irregular-
itles in FAA air carrier safety check procedures
were rectified: The claim should have been made
in the Court of Claims, not the district court. "
Title 5 of the United States Code pertains to
government and government cmployees. Section
702 directs itself to the Right of review by govern-
ment employees, and states: "A person suffering
legal wrong because of agency action, or adverse-
ly affected or aggrieved by agency action within
the meaning of a relevant statute, is entitled to
judicial review thercof, "
The same title, section 703, states: "Mandamus
action is a function of district courts."
Obviously the action for job reinstatement is a
function of mandamus actions and filed in the
U.5. District courts.
27
Title 28 U.S.C, 1361 pertains to mandamus
actions within the district courts to compel an
officer of the United States to perform a duty
owed to the plaintiff. (Title 28 USC 1361; added
Pub. L. 87-748, 1 (a), Oct. 5, 1962, 76 Stat.
744).
Again showing the jurisdiction of the district
court to hear actions concerning job reinstate-
ment of federal employees:
Title 28 USCA 1361, note 34:
Note 34: EMPLOYMENT, MATTER RELAT-
ING TO:
A procedural avenue to reinstatement for an
ex-employee of the federal government claim-
ing to be the victim of improper discharge
is petition for mandatory injunction or writ
of mandamus directed to head of agency
concerned commanding the reemployment
of the petitioner. Beale v. Bount,C. A, Fla.
1972, 461 F.2d 1133.
2%
Note |7 states:
"Federal court could grant mandatory re-
lief under this section in action brought by
discharged civilian employee of the National
Guard who alleged that his dismissal was
an abuse of discretion. Chaudoin v. Atkin-
gon C.A. Del. 1974, 494 F. 2d 1323."
Obviously, petitioner's action for job reinstate-
ment was brought in the correct court. Disre-
garding, for the sake of argument, that the act-
ion for job reinstatement is vested in the U.S.
District court, the doctrine and statutes per-
taining to “ancillary jurisdiction" would have
conferred upon the U.S. District court juris-
diction to hear the matter of job reinstatement
and hack pay.
1c mandamus action in the district Court
directed w FAA air safcty misconduct is the
first and primary cause of action. ‘The actions
for job reinstatement and back pay would be
ancillary to that first and primary cause of
action.
29
As to ancillary jurisdiction, title 42 U.S.C.
1985 states:
“Ancillary jurisdiction. The United States
District courts have ancillary jurisdiction
to hear all matters when part of the claims
are within its-jurisdiction. "
Section 7366, chapter 86 of Jurisdiction and
Venue, states: "
“Under the concepts of pendent or ancillary
jurisdiction a federal court in a proper case
will assume jurisdiction over and dispose
of matters which could not be brought be-
fore it if standing alone. The doctrine ex-
pands the juriadiction of federal courts
over subject matter and is anologous to
thelogical relationship" doctrine applied
to compulsory counterclaims and to the
"clean-up" policy followed by courts of
equity. "
Moore's manual of Federal Practice and
Procedures states of ancillary actions:
3O
“When a federal court has jurisdiction over
the main cause of action, it also has juris-
diction over any proceedings ancillary to that
action, regardless of the amount of money in-
volved, ...
The action for job reinstatement stood on its
own merits in the district court. If, however,
it did not have statutory jurisdiction to be heard
in the district court on its own, the ancillary
jurisdiction would have conferred it upon the
district courts.
This is no secret; case laws arc in abun-
dance showing the U.S, District courts de-
ciding these actions.
Ancillary jurisdiction confcrs upon the dis-
trict Courts the action for back pay, as an-
c illary to cither the first, or the second
cause of action.
To further show the determination of the
U.S. Court of Appeals that petitioner's
actions Come to a grinding halt, regardless
31
of the law, look at this: Statutory and case laws
cited show the district court's jurisdiction to
hear the matter of job reinstatement on its own
in the district court. Ignoring these statutes, the
statute and case law dealing with ancillary juris-
diction confers thjs matter to the district court.
Still another set of statutory and case laws
would have saved petitioner's action for job re-
ingtatement and back pay, which the U.S. Court
of Appeals disregarded, and then when petitioner
pointed to them in his petition for rchcaring, the
appeals court still ignored the lawful require-
ment.
If the action for job reinstatement and back pay
had by crror been filed in the wrong court, and
that it should have becn filed in the U.S, Court
of Claims as the appeals court stated, title
28 U.S.C. 1406 (c) provides for the court to trans-
fer the action to the U.S. Court of Claims. It
reads:
"If a case within the exclusive jurisdiction
of the Court of Claims is filed in a district
court, the district court shall, if it be in
the interest of justice, transfer such casc to
to the Court of Claims, wherc the case shall
procecd as if it had been filed in the Court
of Claims on the date it was filed in the dis-
trict court. ".
To avoid a possible abuse of this discretion
as to transfer, and as stated in Moore's Manual
Federal Practices and Procedures, the Supreme
Court had protected the innocent party when the
action is actually filed in the wrong court:
", the Supreme Court has madc it quite
clear that transfer, where feasible, is
the proper choice except for extraordinary
circumstances. And this is the usual dispo-
sition. Also in contravention of the plain
mcaning of the language, courts of appeals
have ulgo assumed the authority of transfcr.
‘the underlying rationale of the judicial
decisions under this scction is that dis-
missal for improper venue is a severe
penalty; transfer to a proper venue
33
permits the action to go forward in the
right place; it is in line with the practice
of most state Courts; courts should strive
to decide and dispose of cases on the merits
rather than on pleas in bar and pleas in
abatement. Transfer also saves the plain-
tiff from the bar of the statute of limitations,
if the period ran out after the filing but be-
fore the attack on venue. Barnett v. New York
Central R.R, (1965) 380 US 424, 85S Ct
1050, 13 L ed2d 941: Goldawr v. Heiman
(1962) 369 US 463, 82S Ct 913, 8 L ed2d
39; Internation-Rotterdam, Inc. vy. Thom-
sen (CA4th, 1955) 218 F2d 941. Dismissal,
therefore, should be reserved for that action
where its institution in the wrong venue
smacks of harassment or some other element
of bad faith on the plaintiff's part. For exam-
ple, in Parham v. Edwards, (SD GA, 1972)
346 F Supp 968. ) the plaintiff instituted suit
in a district in which neither venue nor per-
sonal jurisdiction of the defendant could be
34
obtained. The only proper district was one
in which the applicable statute of limitations
had already expired. Holding that the plain -
tiff had no right to benefit by the more liber-
al statute of limitations of the district in
which suit was instituted, the court denied
transfer and dismissed the action. "
Obviously petitioner's action for job reinstate-
ment and back pay do not fall within the areas
that would justify or permit refusal to transfer
to the U.S. Court of Claims.
This is further shown on page 1689, under
Transfers 1406 (c):
"To alleviate this situation, Congress passed
the Act of 1960. First, the Act amended sec -
tion 1406 by adding subscction (c) as set out
above. This provides that if the district
court dctcrmines that a claim filed before
it actually is in the exclusive province
of the Court of Claims, it may order the case
transferred to the Court of Claims, if this
be "in the interest of justice. " Thus the
same option, to transfer or dismiss, in the
interest of justice, is given the district
judge in transfer to the Court of Claims, as
was provided in the 1949 amendment to sec- ,
tion 1406 (a).in regard to transfers between
district courts. And presumably for the same
reason--to prevent abuse by a plaintiff who
deliberately brings suit in the wrong forum.
To make clear that the statute of limitations
will not be affected by bringing the action in
the wrong forum, the Act provides that upon
transfer to the Court of Claims, “the case
shall proceed as if it had been filed in the
Court of Claims on the date it was filed in
the district courts. "
Petitioner's request, in his pctition for re-
hearing, that if the court does not allow this
action to continue in the district court, as
would be appropriate, that the second and
third cause of action be transferred, to the
court of claims, was refused.
36
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
The reasons why the United States Supreme
Court should issue a writ of certiorari would in-
clude the following:
1, Special and important reasons exist that
have a broad national impact, especially in the
area of air carrier safety. If the court's dis-
missal is allowed to stand, the serious govern-
ment misconduct, especially within the Federal
Aviation Administimtion and the National Trans-
portation Safety Board, will continuc to cause
or allow such tragedies as the Paris DC-10
crash, the UAL Salt Lake City crash, and others,
as described in petitioner's pleadings. As things
now stand, the federal courts--incredibly, will
have a role in the sacrificing of pawns in these
air carricr ‘crashes Closely related to the FAA
misconduct that is so deeply embedded into the
philosophy and conduct of that agency.
Petitioner recognizes the problems that
would face the Supreme Court. Any assistance
petitioner receives increases the risk the pub-
37
lic may discover the contents of this scandal.
If the public understands what it sees, then the
_ judicial branch, along with the executive branch
of government, are seen in a conspiracy against
such persons as the cremated Bennett family in
the Salt Lake City crash, and this hardly im-
proves the image of the branch of government
that is sworn to uphold the laws of the United
States.
But the price for refusing to bring this mat-
ter to the open is a continuation of what has ex-
isted for many years, and the price has been
horrendous sufferings by persons who didn't
have a chance to protect themsclvcs against
this government conspiracy,
2. Disregard by the U.S. Court of Appeals
of federal statutes and case law, affecting all
three causes of action. This disregard could
not have been judicial ignorance or mistake.
It was deliberate, and the reasons are obvious.
3. Disregard by the U.S, District courtof
the same statutory and case law, as well as
—_—
38
previous decisions of the United States Supreme
Court.
4, Implications in lower court's ruling that
federal courts cannot intervene in the activities
of federal agencies, no matter how onerous, how ,
illegal, how much an abuse of discretion. Ofcourse,
the court's method of deciding these issues were
in such a way that they will never be cited. But
the fact remains, they did make such decisions
and they did deprive petitioner of due process,
of his day in court.
5. Disregarding the rights of those who
serve as pawns in the conspiracy of silence to
keep this scandal from the public. These pawns
would include the 346 persons who perished in
the Paris DC-10 crash, the UAL Salt Lake City
crash, and many others.
6. Outright and fraudulent fabrication by
the U.S. Court of Appeals of the excuse that
petitioner is asking the court to conduct an
investigation of the FAA, thus this is not a
"justiciable controversy, ". This fabrication
39
was for one purpose and one purpose alone; to
circumvent the mandatory jurisdiction of the
district court to hear this action.
7, Apparent cover up by the U.S. District
court and the U.S, Court of Appeals of a major .
government and air safety scandal,
The United States Supreme Court obviously is
needed to supervise the actions of these two
lower courts, and hopefully, the Supreme Court
will not condone these actions.
Whatever restraint may be used to describe the
actions of the U.S. District court and th U.S.
Court of Appeals, one thing appears sure: the
courts are engaging in a reckless disregard of
the law with total indifference to the consequences
being paid by the pawns in this rcckless abuse
of government facilities.
The courts, especially with the amount of affida-
vits introduccd into this action, and from their
observations on the federal bench, certainly
recognize the conscquences of cevcn the smallest
Infraction of air safety laws.
40
The court has evidence of the relationship
between the misconduct by the FAA and the sub-
' sequent deaths in tragic and unnecessary air
carrier crashes.
The court has now openly entered into this
relationship, and shown their colors. There
will be more consequences arising from this
refusal to respond for the national welfare,
and now one can look to the courts also, incred-
ible, to determine what part they played in the
deaths that occurred.
If the courts that are looked to for enforcement
of the laws can so openly act contrary to law,
especially when the consequences are so great
and horrendous, the problem takes on a fright-
cning magnitude.
This petition is asking for a writ of certiorari.
It is obvious, under these conditions, that it is
extremcly unlikely such a writ would be issued.
41
CONCLUSIONS
If it is gross abusc of the judicial proccss
within the federal court system, matters of
broad national interests affecting large segments
of the population, disregard by the district court °
and the Court of Appeals of Supreme Court de-
cigions, decisions by other federal courts, dis-
regard of statutory and case law, this is a
most appropriate matter for the United States
Supreme Court to review.
The Supreme Court has managed to involve
itself in matters that some consider trivia. The
magnitude and implications of the matters within
this action certainly warrant some consideration
by the United States Suprepre) Court.
A writ of certiorayiyis
/ Rodnéy F. Stich
Pgtitioner
June 30, 1977
Rodney F. Stich
1416 Carleton Drive
Concord, California 94518
Phone: (415) 933-1233
APPENDICES
Appendix A la
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Roowsy F. Sricu, |
Plaintif-Appellant,
ve.
Unrrep Starzs oy AMERICA,
FPepepa. Aviation ADMINISTRATION,
Defendants- Appellees.
No. 75-2800
MEMORANDUM
[April 7, 1977)
On Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Northern District of California
Before: CHOY and KENNEDY, Circuit Judges,
and FERGUSON,® District Judge.
We are inclined to agree with Stich that he has exhausted his
administrative remedies, that he has standing to seek mandamus
and that the action is not barred by the applicable statute of
limitations. But we need not decide those points because we hold
that the district court properly diamiased Stich’s petition for a
writ of mandamus. |
To the extent Stich’s action seeks a judicially-supervised inves-
tigation of the conduct of the FAA, he has failed to present a
“justiciable controversy,” i.e, an issue in a form “capable of
resolution through the judicial proceas.” Flast v. Cohen, 392 U.S.
83, 95 (1968). The federal courts are neither equipped nor em-
powered to undertake congreasional-style investigations into alle-
gation of agency misconduct.
*Honorable Warren Ferguson, United States District Judge for the
Central District of California, sitting by designation.
2a
Rodney F. Stich vs. Umied States of America
As to Stich’s contention that the district court erred in dis
ccaiietiies tc Wak Uc teeis te cain hate amt on
Tucker Act limit of $10,000. 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a) (2). Therefore,
Stich should have filed his action in the Court of Claims
Nor did the district court have jurisdiction, as Stich argues,
under 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) and 28 U.S.C. § 1343(1). The easan-
tial elements of a cause of action under the Civil Rights Con-
spiracy statute include that “there must be some racial, or per-
haps otherwise class-based, invidiously discriminatory animus
behind the conspirators’ action.” Grifin v. Breckenridge, 403 U.S.
88, 102 (1971). Stich has alleged a conspiracy to deny him of
rights under the First Amendment, presumably the right to
speak out about FAA derelictions of duty, but he has not alleged
the type of class-based deprivation against which § 1985(3) pro-
tecta.
Because the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction
over Stich’s action, it did not err in dismissing.
AFFIRMED.
eeenene teen ee ae
PERN AU-WALSH PRINTING CO, BAN FRANCINCO 4-13-77—410
3a
Petition for Rehearing by Appellant
APPENDIX B
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Rodney F. Stich,
Plaintiff and Appellant
Vv.
United States of America,
Federal Aviation Administration,
Defendants and Appellees
This is a petition for rehearing from the mem-
orandum decision of the United States Court of
Appeals. The decision of the appeals court was
to uphold the dismissal by the United States Dis-
trict court as to appellant Stich's three causes of
action.
_ The underlying issues, the crux of this action
before the federal court, are the allegations that
a small but controlling group within the Federal
Aviation Administration has engaged in a con;
4a
tinuing fraud in covering up for major air safcty
irregularities at certain favored air Carriers
and companies, and that identifiable acts of
misconduct, including criminal acts that
should have been prosecuted by the Department °
of Justice, were directly involved in some of
the worst air carrier crashes,
Appellant Stich discovered these serious
irregularities as part of his official duties as
a investigator/inspector for the Federal Avia-
tion Administration, and accumulated numerous
official government documents to prove their
existance and also their relationship to subse-
quential serious air carrier crashes. Several
of these crashes are described in detail within
these pleadings, as examples of how they were
not cexuctly "accidents."
Appellant Stich has alleged that the wrongful
actions were covered up, by other government
agencies, apparently seeking to keep the long
standing misconduct and the associated deaths,
5a
from the public, The fear of the consequences
of an enraged public may cxplain why so many
government agencies and different branches of
government will not at this late stage step in to
meet their moral and legal responsibilities,
Those who aided in the conspiracy to keep
this matter from the public includes, among
others, the National Transportation Safety Board
and the Department of Justice,
In one alr carrier tragedy, the link between
cause and consequences is yery well documented
in the affidavits appearing as part of the record
in this action, Helping to worsen an already ser-
lous government fraud, the National Transpor-
tation Safcty Board is shown as investigating a
crash which, by its own fraud and misconduct,
it helped bring about, That crash was the UAL
Salt Lake City tragedy, u classic in air carrier
crashes that should never have happened,
Fourty three persons were cremated in that
Crash, including Mrs. Bennett and her two daugh-
6a
ters, no match for government fraud and arro-
gance that helped to guarantee their fate,
To show the long atanding nature of this
misconduct, the arrogance of the government
participants in this fraud, appellant Stich des -
Ccribes in detail the consequences over a per-
lod of years, using as the start the worst air
diaster of the sixties, the DC-8 that crashed
into New York City, with brief reference to
the great holocaust, the Paris DC-10 tragedy,
As part of the appeal process before the
United States Court of Appeals, and to support
these allegations~-and also to thwart what
appellant Stich anticipated would be a judicial
block, Stich submitted into this action a stack
of affidavits, documents and other writings,
supporting the allegations,
These writings are virtually prima facie
evidence supporting the strong allegations of
government misconduct and the associated air
diasters. The Court of Appeals is astute enough
to recognize the validity of these documents
7a
and what they indicate, In no way could the fed-
eral courts have failed to grasp the gravity of
the matter shown within this action; the conse-
quences that have occurred in crashes and deaths;
and the continuation of these tragedies unless an +
open exposure occurs,
Appellant Stich seeks, in his first and pri-
mary cause of action, a writ of prohibitory or
mandatory injunction from the federal court, di-
recting the Federal Aviation Administration to
comply with the federal laws and their own safety
directives, Similar writs would also be required
for the National Transportation Safcty Board and
other government agencies that conspired to
keep this fraud from being exposed,
The jurisdiction and the responsibility of the
federal courts to hear and adjudicate this action
is without question, Appellant Stich's pleadings
recite numerous statutory and case law point and
authorities, leaving no doubt that the federal courts
have the jurisdiction--and the responsibility - -to
allow this action to be heard,
8a
Appellant Stich has the right to be heard,
and this is not a discretionary court decision.
The statutory and case law citations listed by
appellant Stich makes it clear that the federal
courts can not decline jurisdiction where man- °
damus is sought and there are allegations such
as gross abuse of discretion, actions outside of
the law, culpable misconduct,
The court has a responsibility to a plaintiff,
especially if the plaintiff has no suitable alter-
native. Statutory and case law makes the court's
responsibility to the plaintiff very plain, that
the court's jurisdiction is broad, and that in
the sense of justice, the court must be respon-
sive to see that justice does prevail.
It is interesting to noté that from the time
of the oral argument in open court before the
United States District Court, not a word has
been written or spoken that questioned the validi-
ty of Stich's allegations, Actually, the implications
were that the allegations were essentially true,
9a’
The United States Court of Appeals stated
in its hcaring decision that appellant Stich has
gtanding to seek mandamus, 4s it stated: "...
{Stich/ has standing to seek mandamus and that
the action is not barred by the applicable statute °
of limitations, " -
But then, the appeals court dismissed the
three causes of action, citing simple excuses that
are thoroughly without merit, and which, by a
simple examination of the statutory and case law,
are contrary to law,
As to the first and primary cause of action
which involves specific fraud and criminal acts
in covering up for very serious air safety vio-
lations, and the subsequent crashes associated
with these wrongful acts, the appeals court de-
voted only eight lines of discussion, and these
were a sham, It wrote:
' "To the extent Stich's action secks a judi-
cally-supervised investigation of the con-
duct of the FAA, he has failed to present
a "justiciable controversy," i.e., an issye
lO a
in a form “capable of resolution through
the judicial process." Flast y, Cohen, 392
U.S. 83, 95 (1968). The federal courts are
neither equipped nor empowered to under-
take congressional-style investigations inlo °
allegations of agency misconduct, "
Appellant Stich is NOT asking the federal
courts to conduct a judicial investigation. The
judge, the clerk, and his secretary, would
hardly be qualified to conduct such an investi-
gation, and Stich, after many blocks put into
hig exposure attempts, would not trust the poli-
tically sensitive federal courts with such an
investigation.
Appellant has made it clear by word and deed
deed that he is ready, willing and able to proceed
with presenting this matter for adjudication.
| The sole excuse given by the United States
Court of Appeals to dismiss this very serious first
and primary cause of action is groundless. Stich
has not asked the court to make an investigation,
dla
and the court has the capability to hear and
understand this action, and it has the authority
and responsibility to issue the relief requested,
Appellant Stich expected a judicial block,
preventing the public from hearing of this mat- °
ter. This simple and groundless excuse now
shows how this blockage is being handled, Appel-
Jant Stich disagrees with the appeals court
and raises the following points:
1, Appellant Stich has not asked the court
to conduct a judicial investigation of this
matter, this "request" being the core of
the appeals court "justification" for
dismissal,
2. The United States District court has the
legal responsibility to take jurisdiction
of this matter; it does not involve any
discretion upon the part of the court,
This responsibility is clearly cited, and
is of long standing. «° shown by title 28
USCA 1331. When allegatione are made
in the pleadings of involvement of federal
k2a
statutes, the district court must accept
jurisdiction, ‘The court surely knows this.
3. As w the "justiciable controversy" ex-
cuse, implying the court can not resolve
this matter through judicial process, this °
argument has no validity. The court, first
of all, hag the jurisdiction to accept this
action, Appellant Stich has shown his cap-~
ability of pursuing this matter with vigor,
having surmounted the blocks of the exe-
cutive branch of government and the judic-
ial blockages to this date, By legal in-
genuity he forced into this record re-
vealing documents, using discovery, even
though the court, as expected, ordered
discovery halted, He has introduced a
stack of affidavits and revealing docu~
ments, over ten inches high, prima facie
evidence in the records supporting the
allegations.
The appeal record contents to date shows
his aggressiveness and capability to pursue
L3 a
this first cause of action, What he has
to introduce into the trial would include
many official government documents ac~
cumulated as part of his official duties
as an investigator for the federal govern °
ment,
4. The federal courte--namely the United
States District court, has the power lo
issue orders directing federal agencies
to comply with their lawful responsibili-
tics. This authority is so well stated in a
mags of statutory and case laws, 4 fun-
damental rights of the federal courts,
included in numerous citations within these
pleadings, that any question about the court's
ubility In this area would be ludicrous.
Title 28 USCA 2201, note 95, says of jus-
ticiable issues: "The test of a "justiciable
controversy" within this section is whe-
ther the facts alleged under all the cir-
cumstances show that there is a sub-
gtantial controversy between the partigs
A4 a
having adverse legal interest of suffic-
ient immediacy and reality... Henry L.
Crowley & Q@. v. Phillips Laboratories,
D.C.N.Y. 1952, 104 F. Supp. 840,
The gist of the various citations is that
there must be a ‘real controversy, the parties
have adverse legal interests, of sufficient \m-
mediacy,
From a legal point of view, the court's po-
sition is without any foundation, From a moral
point of view, the court's position is outrageous.
The court's jurisdiction to hear this case
is positive and cannot be tampered with by fabri-
cating such excuses as appellant is asking for a
judicial investigation,
While appellant Stich is angered at this
blatant misrepresentation by the court, the con-
tempt shown by the court for the rights of the
prior victims, or of their next of kin, the con-
tempt for those that will continue to die as the
perpetrators, and those guilty of criminal cov-
erup, are free to adversely affect the lives of
lSa
still more unsuspecting and helpless members
of our nation.
The United States Court of Appeals and the
United States District/court/are making a sham-
bles and mockery of our justice system, and are *
a key element in the continued consequences
that will be suffered. Slow and anticipated cre-
mation and mutilation is a terrible way to die;
the court is insuring, by its blatant and arro-
gant conduct that certain unknown members of
the community will meet this fate,
The federal courts are sophisticated from
long experience with accident litigation to re-
cognize the cause and effect relationship of
even the most minute violation or improper con-
duct in the highly sensitive area of air safety.
The court certainly recognizes the effects fol-
lowi »g }: dicial coverup of these acts of gov-
em »tTaud,
The court's dismissal of the first cause of
action, in light of the court's knowledge of the
supporting documents entered into this act ion
loa
Cannot be considered "judicial crror." If a
member of the public responded in the same
manner, cven though not holding the public
trust that is vested in the judiciary, they would
be guilty of aiding and abetting, of conspiracy-- °
crimes per se. How then, could the conduct
of the judicial branch be described? Judicia]
error?
The United States Court of Appeals uses
the excuse that Congress should inves-
tigate this matter. But appellant Stich made it
clear to the appeals court during oral arguments
that Congress already knows about the scan-
dal, key members of Congress were involved
in the coverup at a time when, had they acted
as they were legally and morally required to
do, suc persons as Mrs, Bennett and her two
daughters would have been spurcd the fate of
cremation in the Salt Lake Ctty tragedy,
This is a poor excuse. Congress isn't
about to expose it's involvement in such tra-
gic crashes as described in these pleadings.
l7 a
For all practical purposes the United
States Court of Appeals is the court of last re-
sort. by refusing to act as Clearly required
by a multitude of statutory and case laws, by
refusing to accept its moral responsibilities,
knowing that Congress will not investigate,
the court is sealing the fate on many innocent
persons,
Such tragedies as the recent DC-10 diaster
with its 346 persons dcad, probably could not
have occurred without the prior coverup of
the long-standing FAA fraud, The same Wes-
tern Region Federal Aviation Administration
shenigans that were responsible for so many
of the horrendous tragedies described in ap-
pellant's pleadings were behind the coverup
involving the Paris DC-lU crash. The federal
courts played a part in the earlier coverup
that permitted the FAA scenario to remain
unchanged. Good show!
Turning now to the second and third
cause of actions which pertains to job rein-
l8a
statement within the PAA and back pay, we
have the same type of iudicial ploy. These
- two causes of action arose out of the misconduct
by the FAA, Unable to obtain the legal response
out of various agencies within the executive
branch, unable to get any response from the
legislative branch, and seeking to circumvent
the many blocks put in Stich’s exposure at-
tempts, he put his job on the line to force the
issues into federal court.
Over ten years of hard work, costs and
losses of pay approaching $500, 000, were in-
volved as Stich could no longer tolerate the
continuing deaths fostered by a government
supported gang of thugs controlling the Fed-
eral Aviation Administration in an illegal
manner.
The United States District court has ju-
risdiction to adjudicate the second and third
cause of action from authority arising in sev-
eral statutes. This jurisdiction is not discret-
jonary, it is mandatory.
Ya
The statutory and case law authorities for
the United States District court's jurisdiction
over actions for job reinstatement have been
stated within these pleadings, and title 28
USCA 2401 refers w this authority, This juris- °
diction has existed for years, Within the last
few years, this exclusive jurisdiction was |
changed, in that jurisdiction was also confer-
red upon the United States Court of Claims
when that court was also hearing actions for
back pay,
Until that change in jurisdiction was made,
a federal employee secking both back pay and job
job reinstatement had to file an action in the
United States Court of Claims for his back pay,
under authority which includes 28 USC 2501,
and another claim, being a mandamus action,
in the United States District court for job re-
instatement, under jurisdiction which includes
28 USC 2401,
Mandamus actions for job reinstatements in
the United States District courts are still proper.
240 a
There are still other authority showing that
appellant Stich's second and third cause of act-,
ton was filed in the proper court, the United
States District court, and that the district Court
has the obligation to take jurisdiction.
Under ancillary jurisdiction, described in
42 USC 1985, it states: "Ancillary jurisdiction,
The United States District courts have ancillary
jurisdiction to hear all matters when part of the
claims are within its jurisdiction, "
And in Moore's Manual of Federal Prac-~-
tice und Procedures, it states of ancillary
actions: "When a federal court has jurisdic -
tion over the main cause of action, it also
has jurisdiction over any procccdings ancillary
to that action, regardless of the amount of
money involved, the citizenship of the par-
tics, or the existance of a federal question
in the ancillary suit, "
The primary cause of action is the man~
damus action secking district court writs/
orders directed to the Federal Aviation Ad-
Zia
ministration, The allegations pleaded confers
nondisc retionary jurisdiction upon the district
court.
The cause of action secking back pay would
also fall within the ancillary jurisdiction, though’
it would attach to either the mandamus action
seeking a writ ordering the FAA to comply with
the law; or the mandamus action seeking job
reinstatement,
As previously explained by appellant Stich
in the pleadings, the United States District
court has jurisdiction over the first cause of
action which is nondiscretionary; the district
court has jurisdiction over the second cause
of action--job reinstatement, in a mandamus
action, and algo from ancillary jurisdiction;
and the district court has jurisdiction over the
third cause of action--back pay, as ancillary
jurisdiction to the first cause of action, or as
ancillary to the sccond cause of action. Accept-
ing jurisdiction is not discretionary,
224
As to these lasi two causes of action, the
United Statcs Court of Appeals deliberately
- ignores these statutory and case law citations
and in dismissing them and the cause of action,
states: ‘The claim should have been made in
the Court of Claims, not the district court. "
Ignoring for a moment that the United _
States District court did have, does have, non-
discretionary jurisdiction over the sccond and
third cause of actions, if these two actions had
been filed in the wrong court and should have
instead been filed in the United States Court
of Claims under authority of title 28 USC 1406,
Referring to Moore's Manual of Federal Prac-
tice and Procedure, section 7,13 (C), it states:
"(c) If a case within the exclusive jurisdic -
tion of the Court of Claims is filed in a dis-
trict court, the district court shall, if it
- be in the interest of justice, transfer such
case to the Court of Claims, where the
case shall proceed as if it had been filed in
the district court. "
23 a
As this section points out, and the court
of appcals well knows, by dismissing the action
as was done by the appeals court, appellant
Stich is improperly denied his statutory and
constitutional rights and smacks of gross abuse
of discretion upon the part of the United States
Court of Appeals,
It is difficult to comprehend how the United
States Court of Appeals could be so ignorant
as to these basic statutory and case laws, es-
pecially since they were cited in appellant's
pleadings. They are so basic to the operation
of federal court matters,
In the light of the scandalous nature of
this action, in the light of the repeated block-
age encountered by appellant Stich as he
sought to expose this fraud, questions about
the motives of the appeals court are natur-
ally raised,
For the jurists to misstate the alleged
justification for dismissal, in light of all
the errors, it would be like a pilot of an air
24a
carricr aircraft taking off without sufficient
fucl to rcach his destination. Neither situation
appears to have any merit.
In summary, the dismissal action of the
three causes of action by the next to the highest »*
court in the land; the United States Court of
Appeals, has onerous implications. |
Certiorari will be sought from the United
States Supreme court, a petition to Congress for
a review of the court's action in light of the ser-
ious implications, and reaching the public via
other means to show how they have been victim-
ized, are planned actions.
Appellant Stich is requesting that the United
States Court of Appeals reconsider, and reverse
its dismissal action as to all three causes of
action,
Dated: April 18, 1977
o
Rodney F. Stich
In Prdpria Persona
25 a
APPENDIX c
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT FILED
RODNEY F, STICH, MAY 9,, 1977
Plaintiff-Appellant No, 75-2300
Ve
ORDER
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION,
Defendants- Appellees,
Before; CHOY and KENNEDY, Circuit Judges, and
FERGUSON, * District Judge.
The panel as constituted in the above case has
voted to deny the petition for rehearing. The petit-
ion for rchearing is denicd,
26a
APPENDIX D
CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES
Amendment 5
No person shall be... deprived of life, liberty,
Or property, without due process of law; .. .
Amend 5, This clause protects vested rights
from destruction by the federal government,
Darlington v. Board of Councilmen of City of
Frankfort, 1940, 140 S,W. 2d, 392, 282 Ky,
778.
27 a
APPENDIX E
28U.S,C. 1331 (citing FCA 28 USC 1331). Jur-
isdiction: Court could not properly dismiss
suit unless record created a legal certainty
that controversy within its jurisdiction was
not involyed, (1886) Barry v. Edmunds, 116
US 550, 29 L,ed 729, 6 SCR S501.
Note 238: Jurisdiction of district court is to
be determined by allegations of complaint.
Moore v Chesapeake & O.R.R. Co, (1934)
291 US 205, 78 L Ed 755, 54S Cr 402,
Note 238: Allegation of complaint generally.
"Where bill sets up violation of federal con-
stitution, federal court must take jurisdic-
tion where it determines that question made
in good faith is presented to it for its deci-
sion. Illinois C, R. Co. vy. Adams(1901)
180 US 28, 45 L. Ed 410, 21 S Ct 251;Hays
v Port of Seattle (1920) 251 US 233, 64 L Ed
243, 40S Cr 125.
28 a
28 U.S.C.A. 1361
Note 34. EMPLOYMENT, MATTERS RELAT-
ING ‘tO
A procedural avenue to reinstatement for
an ex-employee of the federal government
claiming to be the victim of improper dis-
charge is petition for mandatory injunction
or writ of mandamus directed to head of
agency concerned commanding the reemploy-
ment of the petitioner, Beale v. Blount, C.A,
Fla. 1972, 461 F, 2d 1133.
Note 17, ‘Federal court could grant manda-
tory rclief under this section in action brought
by discharged civilian employce of the Nat-
ional Guard who alleged that his dismissal
was un abuse of discrction, Chaudoin v.
Atkinson, C.A, Del, 1974, 494 F, 2d 1323."
246 U.S.C, 1361 Mandamus action, Compels an
officer or employee of the United States or
any agency thereof to perform a duty owed
to plaintiff. "
29 a
28U.S.C.A. 1361 Action to compel an officer
of the United States to perform his duty.
"District courts are open to prevent an ad-
ministrative body, exercising police power,
from exceeding its jurisdiction and from
taking arbitrary and unreasonable action,
and no special provision of law is necessary
to confer upon the courts authority already
possessed by them under the Constitution,
Rights of judicial review exists by statute
and under general powers of the court con-
ferred upon them by the Constitution, "
Federal Aviation Act, Public Law 85-726 (72
Stat. 797), Section 1007, "If any person
violates any provisions of this Act, ...
any party in interest, may apply to the dis-
trict court of the United Statcs...for the
enforcement of such provision of this Act
or of such rule, regulation, ...
3U a
Improper Venuc: 28 U.S.C. 1406 (Moorc's
Manual Federal Practice and Procedures).
(c) If a case within the exclusive jurisdic -
tion of the Court of Claims is filed in a
district court, the district court shall, if ’
it be in the interest of justice, transfer such
case to the Court of Claims, where the
case shall proceed as if it had been filed
in the district court.
The similarity of language and purpose
of section 1404 and section 1406 have
caused the courts to give parallel construc -
tion, for example, to the question whether
the “interest of justice’ will be served by
transfer(Dubin v. United States (CASth,
1967) 383 F2d, 813; Internation -Rotter-
dam v. Thomsen (CA4th, 1955) 218 F2d
514) and to the question of the applicability
to special venue situations. But under sec -
tion 1406, unlike section 1404 (a), the trial
judge theorctically and under the statutory
language has the discretion to choose between
3la
dismissal and transfer even when there is
another federal forum available. Neverthe-
less, the Supreme Court has made it quite
clear that transfer, where feasible, is the
proper choice * except for extraordinary
circumstances(Goldawr vy. Heiman (1962)
369 US 463, 82S Ct 913, 8 L ed2d 39; Bur-
nett v New York Central R.R. (1965) 380
US 424, 85 S Ct 1050, 13 L ed2d 1491), And
this is the usual disposition. Also in contra-.
vention of the plain meaning of the language,
courts of appeals have also assumed the auth-
ority of transfer (Koehring Co. v. Hyde
Construction Co, (1966) 382 US 362, 86S,
Ct 522, 15 L ed2d 416; Panhandle Eastern
Pipe Line Co, v. FPC (CA8th, 1965} 343
I'2d 905; Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co,
v. FPS (CA8th, 1965) 343 F2d 905; Panhan-
-dle Eastern Pipe Line Co. y, FPC (CA10,
1964) 337 F2d294).,
The underlying rationale of the judicial
decisions under this section is that dismigsal
32 a
for improper venuc is a severe penalty;
transfer to a proper venuc permits the act-
ion to go forward in the right place; it is in
line with the practice of most state Courts;
courts should strive to decide and dispose
of cases on the merits rather than on pleas
in bar and pleas in abatement, Transfer’
also saves the plaintiff from the bar of the
statute of limitations, if the period ran out
after the filing but before the attack on ven-
uc. (SD Ga, 1972)346 F Supp 968. ) Dismiss -
al, therefore, should be reserved for that
action where its institution in the wrong ven-
uc smacks of harassment or some other ele-
ment of bad faith on the plaintiff's part. For
cxainple, in Parham y, Edwards, the plain-
tiff instituted suit in a district in which nei-
there venue nor personal jurisdiction of the
‘defendant could be obtained. The only proper
district was one in which the applicable
statute of limitations had already expired,
33 a
Holding that the plaintiff had no right to beg-
efit by the more liberal statute of limitations
of the district in which suit was instituted,
the court denied transfer and dismissed the
action. - vg .
28 U.S.C.A. 2201, note 96 states of a "justiciable
_ controversy:" | 7
_ "The test of a 'justiciable controversy’ within
this section is whether the facts alleged under
all the circumstances show there is a gubstan-
tial controversy between the parties having ad-
verse legal intercst of sufficient immediacy and
reality...
A "controversy" to be "justiciable" within
former section 400 of this title, had to be
definite and concrete, touching legal relat-
ions of partics having adverse and substan-
tial controversy admitting of specific re-
| lief through decree of conclusive character,
Maryland Casualty Co. v. Hubbard, D,C,
Cal. 1938, 22 F. Supp. 697. "
34a
42 U.S.C. 1985: Ancillary jurisdiction. The |
United States District courts have ancillary
jurisdiction to hear all matters when part
of the claims are within its jurisdiction, "
Moore's manual of Federal Practice and Pro -.
cedures states of ancillary actions: "When —
a federal court has jurisdiction over the
_ main cause of action, it also has juris-
diction over any proceedings ancillary to
that action, regardless of the amount of
money involved, the citizenship of the par-
ties, or the existance of a federal question
in the ancillary suit."
Under Jurisdiction and venue, section 7366,
chapter 86, it states: "Under the concepts
of pendent or ancillary jurisdiction a fed-
cral court in a proper case will assume
jurisdiction over and dispose of matters
- which could not be brought before it if
standing alone. The doctrine expands the
jurisdiction of federal courts over subject
matter and is anologous to the ‘logical
* ~.
| 35 a
relationship" doctrine applied to compulsoyy
counterclaims and to the "clean-up" policy
followed by courts of equity. "
* Underscoring added for emphasis,
: Dismissal Order of District Court i iat
In the United States District Court. |
The matter haying come regularly on for tie. Vinaig
hearing before the Court on the defendants’ |
motion to dismiss or in the alternative for | 7 aie
summary judgment, and the respective par-
tics having been afforded the opportunity of
being hcard and the Court fully advised in the
premises, and the matter duly submitted;
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED
AND DECREED that:
1. The defendants's motion to dismiss
be and it is hereby granted;
2. The complaint and action are hereby
dismissed as to said defendants, ,
37 a
3. ‘The respective parties shall bear
their own costs herein.
Dated: Feb 28 1975
/s/ bert H, Schnake _
Dnited States District Judge *
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.