Appendix — Velsicol Chemical Corp. v. Environmental Protection Agency
Supreme Court brief1977
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Supreme Court, U. S,
~~ FILED
Le
IN THE MICHAEL RODAK, JR., CLERK
Supreme Court of the United States
OctoserR TERM 1976
wo-9B71250
VELSICOL CHEMICAL CORPORATION, Petitioner,
v.
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, et al.
APPENDIX
EpWaARD BENNETT WILLIAMS
Rosert L. WEINBERG
Harotp UNGAR
Wru1aMs & CoNNOLLY
1000 Hill Building
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 331-5000
Attorneys for Petitioner
Passes or Brsow S. ADAMS Paintina, Inc., Wastineton, D.C.
INDEX
Page
Appenprxx A—Opinion of United States Court of Ap-
peals of November 10, 1976 ..............00005- 1
Apprenprx B—Supplemental Opinion on Petition for
Rehearing of United States Court of Appeals of
EEE PPT TT TTT TTT 26
Appenprx C—Judgment of the United States Court of
Appeals of November 10, 1976 ................. 40
Appenpix D—Recommended Decision of the Adminis-
trative Law Judge of December 12, 1975 ........ 42
Appenpix E—Decision of the Administrator of the En-
vironmental Protection Agency of December 24,
EL ESSELTE PTTTTTETOTTTT TET T 136
ee
APPENDIX A
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
No. 75-2259
EnvmonMeEntaL Derense F'unp, Inc., Petitioner
v.
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection AGENCY AND
Russeuy E. Train, Armrnistrator, Respondents
Vewsico. CHEemicaL CorPorRATION
PrveaprLe Growers AssociaTIon oF Hawani, ET AL.,
Intervenors
No. 76-1181
Eaazt L. Butz, Secretary or AGRICULTURE
or THE Unrrep States, Petitioner
v.
Rousset E. Trarn, ADMINISTRATOR OF THE
EwvrronMENTAL Protection Acency, Respondent
Vexsico: Cuemicat Corporation, Intervenor
No. 76-1245
Vetsico. CoemicaL Corporation, Petitioner
v.
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection AGENCY,
Rousseit E. Trarn, Apministrator, Respondent
2
No. 76-1247
Vetsico, CHemicaL Corporation, Petitioner
v.
Russevt E. Trarn, ADMINISTRATOR,
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection AcEeNcy, Respondent
Petitions for Review of an Order of the
Environmental Protection Agency
Argued April 15, 1976
Decided November 10, 1976
Jacqueline M. Warren, with whom William A. Butler
and John F. Dienelt, were on the brief for petitioner in
No. 75-2259.
Raymond W. Fullerton, Attorney, with whom James
Michael Kelly, Assistant General Counsel, Alfred R. Nolt-
tng and Margaret M. Breinhalt, Attorneys, Department of
Agriculture, were on the brief for petitioners in No. 76-
1181.
Robert L. Weinberg, with whom .John G. Kester, Rich-
ard M. Cooper and Kendra Heymann, were on the brief
for intervenor Velsicol Chemical Corp.
Michael H. Stein, Attorney, Department of Justice with
whom Rez E. Lee, Assistant Attorney General, Robert E.
Kopp, Attorney, Department of Justice Robert V. Zenn,
General Counsel, Environmental Protection Agency, Rich-
ard J. Denney Jr., Associate General Counsel, John E.
Bonine, Deputy Associate General Counsel, Lee C. Schroer
» chee’ OS —<
Ne ee eee ae et eS
3
and Ronald C. Hausman, Attorneys, Environmental Pro-
tection Agency, were on the brief for respondents.
Peter Barton Hutt and Clausen Ely, Jr., were on the
brief for intervenor, Pineapple Growers Association of
Hawaii, et al.
Before: Levenrnat, Rosrmsson and Wuxey, Circuit
Judges
Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge LevenTHAL.
LevenTHaL, Circuit Judge: This case involves the pesti-
cides heptachlor and chlordane. Consolidated petitions
seek review of an order of the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) suspending the registration of those pesti-
cides under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodent-
icide Act (FIFRA) for certain uses. The Administrator
of EPA issued an order on December 24, 1975. The order
prohibited further production of these pesticides for the
suspended uses, but permitted the pesticides’ continued
production and sale for limited minor uses. Even as to the
suspended uses, the Order tempered its impact in certain
respects: It delayed until August 1, 1976, the effective date
of the prohibition of production for use on corn pests; and
it permitted the continued sale and use of existing stocks
of registered products formulated prior to July 29, 1975.
One petition to review was filed by Earl L. Butz, Secre-
tary of Agriculture of the United States (U.S.D.A.). Sec-
retary Butz and intervenor Velsicol Chemical Corporation,
the sole manufacturer of heptachlor and chlordane, urge
that the EPA order as to chlordane be set aside on both
substantive and procedural grounds.? They contend that
17 U.S.C. § 136 et seq. (Supp. V 1975).
? Velsicol has voluntarily ceaced production of heptachlor for
the uses suspended by the Administrator, and has not really at-
tacked the Administrator’s decision suspending those uses. USDA
urges that this makes the heptachlor issues moot. Although we put
4
substantial evidence does not support the Administrator’s
conclusion that continued use of chlordane poses an im-
minent hazard’’* to human health, and that the Admini-
strator made critical errors in assessing the burden of
proof and in weighing the benefits against the risks of
continued use of chlordane.
The other petition, filed by Environmental Defense Fund,
urges that the Order did not go far enough to protect
against the hazards of heptachlor and chlordane use. EDF
sought an injunction against the provisions permitting con-
tinued production and use of the pesticides on corn pests
until August 1, 1976. EDF also challenges the Administra-
tor’s decision to allow continued use of the stocks of the
two pesticides existing as of July 29, 1975,‘ contending that
EPA should have provided for retrieval and controlled dis-
posal of such stocks. EDF also contends that the Admini-
strator erred in failing to suspend certain ‘‘minor uses”’
of chlordane and heptachlor.*
On the issue of retrieval of existing stocks, we remand
for further consideration. In all other respects, we affirm
the Administrator’s Order. In view of our conclusion, we
denied EDF’s request for a stay pending appeal of the
more emphasis on chlordane than heptachlor in this opinion, we
cannot agree with USDA that voluntary cessation of production
moots our consideration of the order of suspension as to heptachlor,
since this voluntary acquiescence does not bind Velsicol; nor
does it resolve the challenges EDF makes to EPA’s failure to recall
heptachlor stocks from the distributive chain and its refusal to
suspend heptachlor’s use on pineapples and for seed treatment.
*7 U.S.C. § 136d(¢e)(1) (Supp. V 1975).
‘July 29, 1975, was the day the Notice of Intent to Suspend
was issued.
* The Pineapple Growers Association of Hawaij and the Attorney
General and Department of Agriculture of the State of Hawaii
also intervened to defend the decision to continue registration of
one of the minor uses—control of ants on pineapples.
5
provision delaying the effective date for use on corn pests.°
In effect, we approved the delay of effective date (as to
corn) until August 1, 1976, and in this opinion we set forth
our reasons for that conclusion. (Part I, B, 1)
I. Srarvrory Framework anp Sranparp or Review
The issues posed by administrative action pursuant to
FIFRA are not new to this court,’ and we have previously
extensively described the statutory framework for such ac-
tions. What is involved here is a suspension of registra-
tion of two pesticides during the pendency of the more
elaborate cancellation of registration proceeding, initiated
in this case by a November 18, 1974, notice of intent to
cancel. This 1974 notice stated that there existed ‘‘substan-
tial questions of safety amounting to an unreasonable risk
to man and the environment” from continued use of hep-
tachlor and chlordane. Public cancellation hearings pur-
suant to that notice were not expected to commence for
some time.’ On July 29, 1975, the Administrator issued
a Notice of Intent to Suspend the registrations of most
use of the two pesticides. The Administrator then com-
mented on that expected delay in completing the cancel-
lation hearings, and cited ‘‘new evidence . . . which con-
firms and heightens the human cancer hazard posed by
*On February 13, 1976, EDF argued for a stay of the Admin-
istrator’s Order permitting continued use of chlordane and hep-
tachlor on corn unti] August 1, 1976; on February 17, 1976, this
court deferred ruling on that motion until oral arguments on the
merits. The motion for stay was denied April 16, 1976.
* See EDF v. EPA [Shell Chemical Co., et al.], 167 U.S. App.
D.C. 71, 510 F.2d 1292 (1975); EDF v. EPA, 160 U.S. App. D.C.
123, 489 F.2d 1247 (1973) ; EDF v. EPA, 150 U.S. App. D.C. 348,
. 465 F.2d 528 (1972); EDF v. Ruckelshaus, 142 U.S. App. D.C. 74,
439 F.2d 584 (1971); Wellford v. Ruckelhans, 142 U.S. App. D.C.
88, 439 F.2d 598 (1971).
* At the time the briefs in this case were filed, the hearings had
still not begun in the cancellation proceeding.
6
these pesticides.’’ On August 4, 1975, registrant Velsicol
Chemical Corporation requested an expedited adversary
hearing on the suspension question pursuant to §6 of
FIFRA, 7 U.S.C. §136d(c). Administrative Law Judge
Herbert L. Perlman presided over the cancellation hear-
ings beginning August 12. Evidence was limited to human
health issues and the benefits of continued use of hepta-
chlor and chlordane. The record was closed December 4,
1975, and on December 12, the ALJ recommended against
suspension, stating that he was unable to find that ‘‘hep-
tachlor and chlordane are conclusively carcinogens in
laboratory animals.’’* The Administrator reversed that de-
cision on December 24, 1975, and suspended most uses of
chlordane and heptachlor.
The Administrator is authorized to suspend the regis-
tration of a pesticide where he determines that an ‘‘im-
minent hazard’’ is posed by continued use during the time
required for cancellation. Section 6(c) of FIFRA, 7 U.S.C.
§ 136d(c)(1). An ‘‘imminent hazard’’ exists where contin-
ued use during the time required for the cancellation pro-
ceeding would be likely to result in ‘‘unreasonable adverse
effects on the environment.’’ Section 2(1) of FIFRA, 7
U.S.C. § 136(1). The term ‘‘unreasonable adverse effects
on the environment’’ is, in turn, defined as ‘‘any unreason-
able risk to man or the environment, taking into account
the economic, social, and environmental costs and benefits
of the use of any pesticide.’’ Section 2(bb) of FIFRA, 7
U.S.C. § 136(bb).
As in our previous suspension case involving aldrin/
dieldrin,” the primary challenge raised by Velsicol and
USDA goes to the adequacy of the evidentiary basis of
EPA’s finding that the suspended pesticides present an
* ALJ Recommended Decision at 86.
” EDF v. EPA [Shell Chemical Co., et al.], 167 U.S. App. D.C.
71, 510 F.2d 1292 (1975).
7
imminent hazard during the time required for cancellation.
The standard against which we test that challenge is de-
fined in Section 16(b) of FIFRA:
The court shall consider all evidence of record. The
order of the Administrator shall be sustained if it is
supported by substantial evidence when considered on
the record as a whole.
The standard of substantial evidence has been defined
as:™
something less than the weight of the evidence...
(T])he possibility of drawing two inconsistent conclu-
sions from the evidence does not prevent an admini-
strative agency’s finding from being supported by sub-
stantial evidence.
In applying this principle of review ™ in the specific con-
text of a suspension of pesticides, this court has reiter-
ated that ‘‘the function of the suspension decision is to
make a preliminary assessment of evidence, and probabili-
ties, not an ultimate resolution of difficult issues. We can-
not accept the proposition . . . that the Administrator’s
findings . . . [are] insufficient because controverted by re-
spectable scientific authority. It [is] enough at this stage
that the administrative record contain[s] respectable scien-
, — v. Federal Maritime Commission, 383 U.S. 607, 620
1966).
** The problem of applying the substantial evidence standard to
decisions made at the frontiers of scientific knowledge was com-
mented on in Industrial Union v. Hodgson, 162 U.S. App. D.C.
331, 499 F.2d 467 (1974). See generally Note, Judicial Review of
the Facts in Informal Rulemaking, 84 Yale L.J. 1750, 1760-68
(1975). Similar probiems are presented in review under the arbi-
trary and capricious standard. See, ¢.g., Amoco Oil Co, v. EPA,
163 U.S. App. D.C. 162, 501 F.2d 722 (1974),
tific authority supporting the Administrator.’’ Environ-
mental Defense F'und v. EPA [Shell Chemical Co., et al.],
167 U.S.App.D.C. 71, 77, 510 F.2d 1292, 1298 (1975) quot-
ing Environmental Defense Fund v. EPA, 150 U.S. App.
D.C. 348, 357, 465 F.2d 528, 537 (1972).
These decisions of our court also point out that the Ad-
ministrator is not required to establish that the product
is unsafe in order to suspend registration, since FIFRA
places ‘‘[t]he burden of establishing the safety of a prod-
uct requisite for compliance with the labeling requirements
... at all times on the applicant and registrant.’’™ Velsi-
col and USDA urge that this allocation of burden of proof
relied on by the Administrator is inconsistent with the ex-
plicit terms of FIFRA. They rely on FIFRA’s specific in-
corporation of subchapter II of the Administrative Pro-
cedure Act, which provides in relevant part that ‘‘ Except
as statutes otherwise provide, the proponent of a rule or
order shall have the burden of proof.’’ 5 U.S.C. § 556(d).
The EPA regulation governing the burden of proof in
suspension proceedings provides:
At the hearing, the proponent of suspension shall have
the burden of going forward to present an affirmative
case for the suspension. However, the ultimate burden
of persuasion shall rest with the proponent of the
registration. 40 C.F.R. § 164.121(g) (1975).
Assuming that the Administrator is the ‘‘proponent”’ of a
suspension order and is governed by § 556(d), the legis-
lative history of that provision indicates that it allocates
the burden of going forward rather than the burden of
ultimate persuasion and is consistent with the EPA’s ap-
portionment of burden:
“EDF v. EPA, 167 U.S. App. D.C. at 76, 510 F.2d at 1297,
quoting EDF v. EPA, 150 U.S. App. D.C. at 352, 465 F.2d at 532.
That the proponent of a rule or order has the burden
of proof means not only that the party initiating the
proceeding has the general burden of coming forward
with a prima facie case but that other parties, who
are proponents of some differert result, also for that
purpose have a burden to maintain. S. Doc. No. 245,
79th Cong., 2d Sess. 208, 270 (1946).
This allocation of the burden of going foward “ structures
evaluation of the factual evidence adduced for both the
Administrator and the reviewing court, and is consistent
with the traditional approach that this burden normally
falls on the party having knowledge of the facts involved.
In urging that the ultimate burden of proof in a sus-
pension proceeding rests on the Administrator, Velsicol
and USDA assert that the suspension decision is a dras-
tic step differing fundamentally from both the registration
and cancellation decisions made under FIFRA. Be we have
already cautioned that the ‘‘imminent hazard’’ requisite
for suspension is not limited to a concept of crisis: ‘‘It is
enough if there is substantial likelihood that serious harm
will be experienced during the year or two required in any
realistic projection of the administrative process.’’™
** See also NLRB v. Mastro Plastics Corp., 354 F.2d 170, 176
(2d Cir. 1965), cert. denied, 384 U.S. 972 (1966). In Stearns
Electric Paste Co. v. EPA, 461 F.2d 293, 304 (7th Cir. 1972),
Judge Stevens held that the 1964 amendments to FIFRA had
shifted the burden of proof to the registrant ‘‘whether in a pro-
ceeding for initial registration or in a cancellation proceeding.’’
In view of our decision that the EPA’s allocation of burden of
proof is consistent with the requirements of § 556(d), the 1972
general incorporation of APA standards into FIFRA did not
operate to shift the ultimate burden of proof away from the
registrant sub silentio.
* EDF v. EPA, 167 U.S. App. D.C. 71 at 76, 510 F.2d at 1297,
quoting EDF v. EPA, 150 U.S. App. D.C. at 360, 465 F.2d at 540.
Our en bane decision in Ethyl Corp v. EPA, —— U.S. App. D.C.
, F.2d —— (1976), slip op. at 29, n.28, cert. denied, 44
10
‘‘FIFRA confers broad discretion’’ on the Administrator
to find facts and ‘‘to set policy in the public interest.’’
Wellford v. Ruckelshaus, 142 U.S.App.D.C. 88, 91, 439 F.2d
598, 601 (1971). This broad discretion was conferred on
the implicit assumption that interim action may be neces-
sary to protect against the risk of harm to the environ-
ment and public health while a fuller factual record is de-
veloped in the cancellation proceeding. This avenue of pro-
tective relief would be effectively foreclosed if we accepted
Velsicol’s argument that the Administrator must prove im-
minent hazard **—apparently in some sense of weight of
the evidence, going beyond substantial likelihood. But as
we have already pointed out, the basic statutory directive
requires affirmance of the Administrator’s decision if sup-
ported by substantial evidence, and this requires ‘‘some-
thing less than the weight of the evidence.’’*” We reject
that renewed invitation to exercise increased substantive
control over the agency decision process, and turn to a con-
sideration of whether the Administrator’s decision to sus-
pend most uses of heptachlor and chlordane is supported
by substantial evidence.
TI. SusstantraL Evivence Support ror THE
ADMINISTRATOR’s DEcISION
To evaluate whether use of a pesticide poses an ‘‘unrea-
sonable risk to man or the environment,’’ the Administra-
tor engages in a cost-benefit analysis that takes ‘‘into ac-
count the economic, social and environmental costs and
U.S.L.W. 3719 (U.S. June 14, 1974), considered this standard as
more rigorous than the standard involved in Ethyl; we have not
sought to engage in a comparative analysis of the differences that
may be discernible in these two statutory standards, but have rested
with applying the ‘‘substantial likelihood’’ standard to the facts of
this case.
16 Velsicol Br. at 31.
1" See text at note 11.
11
benefits of the use of any pesticide.’’ 7 U.S.C. § 136(bb).
We have previously recognized that in the ‘‘preliminary
assessment of probabilities’ involved in a suspension pro-
ceeding, ‘‘it is not necessary to have evidence on... a
specific use or area in order to be able to conclude on the
basis of substantial evidence that the use of 'a pesticide]
in general is hazardous.’’ EDF v. EPA, 160 U.S.App.D.C.
at 130, 489 F.2d at 1254, quoted in EDF v. EPA [Shell
Chemical Co.], 167 U.S.App.D.C. at 80, 510 F.2d at 1301.
‘*Reliance on general data, consideration of laboratory ex-
periments on animals, etc.’’ has been held a sufficient basis
for an order cancelling or suspending the registration of
a pesticide. Jd. Once risk is shown, the responsibility to
demonstrate that the benefits outweigh the risks is upon
the proponents of continued registration. Conversely, the
statute places a ‘‘heavy burden’’™ of explanation on an
Administrator who decides to permit the continued use
of a chemical known to produce cancer in experimental
animals. Applying these principles to the evidence ad-
duced in this case, we conclude that the Administrator’s
decision to suspend most uses of heptachlor and chlordane
and not to suspend others is supported by substantial evi-
dence and is a rational exercise of his authority under
FIFRA.
A. Risk Analysis—Carcinogenicity of Heptachlor and
Chlordane
Velsicol and USDA contend that the laboratory tests on
mice and rats do not ‘‘conclusively’’ demonstrate that
chlordane is carcinogenic to those animals ; that mice are too
prone to tumors to be used in carcinogenicity testing in
any case; and that human exposure to chlordane is insuf-
ficient to create a cancer risk. They place strong reliance
* 167 U.S. App. D.C. at 81, 510 F.2d at 1302, quoting EDF v.
aa ne 142 U.S. App. D.C. 74, 86 n.41, 439 F.2d 584, 596
n. .
12
on the Administrative Law Judge’s refusal to recommend
suspension because he was ‘‘hesitantly unwilling at this
time to find that heptachlor and chlordane are conclusively
carcinogens in laboratory animals.’’ Rec. Dec. at 86 (em-
phasis in original). The ALJ recognized however, that on
the basis of the record made the Administrator ‘‘could
determine that the pesticides involved pose potential or
possible carcinogenic risk to man’’ and that he could ‘‘find
that heptachlor and chlordane are conclusively carcinogenic
in laboratory animals.’’** While adopting the ALJ’s fact-
ual findings, the Administrator concluded that the ALJ
had applied an erroneous legal standard in requiring a
conclusive rather than probable showing that the pesticides
were animal carcinogens, and concluded in any case that
the evidence showed heptachlor and chlordane to be ani-
mal carcinogens. We affirm.
1. Mice and Rat Studies
An ultimate finding in a suspension proceeding that con-
tinued use of challenged pesticides poses a ‘‘substantial
likelihood of serious harm’’ must be supported by substan-
tial, but not conclusive, evidence. In evaluating laboratory
anima] studies on heptachlor and chlordane there was suf-
ficient ‘‘respectable scientific authority’? upon which the
Administrator could rely in determining that heptachlor
and chlordane were carcinogenic in laboratory animals.
We start by rejecting Velsicol’s argument that the ‘‘can-
cer principles’? EPA relied on in structuring its analysis
of the mice and rate studies improperly biased the agency’s
open-minded consideration of the evidence.” In brief form,
1%” ALJ Recommended Decision at 86-87, n.25.
*° Velsico] also claims that ex parte contact between the enforce-
ments staff and the Acting Administrator on this point requires
reversal of the suspension order. After having been contacted by
the enforcement staff, the Acting Administrator issued a clarifica-
tion of the July 29 Notice to Suspend which made clear that
13
the principles accept the use of animal test data to evalu-
ate human cancer risks; consider a positive oncogenic ef-
fect in test animals as sufficient to characterize a pesti-
cide as posing a cancer risk to man; recognize that nega-
tive results may be explained by the limited number and
sensitivity of the test animals as compared to the general
human population; note that there is no scientific basis
for establishing a no-effect level for carcinogens; and view
the finding of benign and malignant tumors as equally sig-
nificant in determining cancer hazard to man given the in-
creasing evidence that many ‘‘benign’’ tumors can develop
into cancers. The Agency’s reliance on these principles did
not come as a surprise to Velsicol; they were included in
the Administrator’s Notice of Intent to Suspend; and as
recognized in EDF v. EPA, 167 U.S.App.D.C. at 77-78, 510
F.2d at 1298-99, form part of the Agency’s ‘‘scientific ex-
pertise.’’ Velsicol was properly given an opportunity to
put in evidence contesting those principles, but failed to
demonstrate anything more than some scientific disagree-
ment with respect to them. Velsicol’s principal complaint
—that mice are inappropriate test animals—was specifi-
cally rejected by the Administrator, citing statements by
the National Academy of Sciences’ Food Protection Com-
mittee, the World Health Organization, HEW’s Commis-
sion on Pesticides and their Relationship Environmental
Velsicol could challenge the cancer principles during the suspen-
sion hearing. These facts do not require reversal. We have indi-
cated that the prosecuting staff may consult with the agency head
concerning the initiation of a second related nroceeding or, where
emerging evidence requires it, the broadening *{ an existing charge.
Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. EPA, 167 U.S. App. D.C. 71,
84, 510 F.2d 1292, 1305 (1975). The consultations here, which were
intended to aid the agency head in his function of framing charges,
were of the same procedural type. While we are sensitive to the
danger of abuse in such consultations, there was clearly no unfair-
ness in the circumstances of this case, since the effect of the
resulting order was simply to recognize the registrant’s right to
present additional evidence.
14
Health, FDA Advisory Panel on Carcinogenesis, Interna-
tional Agency for Research on Cancer, and Director of the
National Cancer Institute’s Carcinogetiesis Program.”
Unlike the failure to adduce critical methodology that we
criticized in International Harvester,” EPA’s specific
enunciation of its underlying analytic principles, derived
from its experience in the area, yields meaningful notice
and dialogue, enhances the administrative process and fur-
thers reasoned agency decisionmaking.
The animal experiments the Administrator relied on
tested heptachlor, its chief metabolite heptachlor epoxide
and chlordane. Technical or commercial heptachlor and
chlordane both contain the substances tested.” Five studies
involved mice and one involved rats. Velsicol urges that
only the chlordane studies can be relied on to support a
finding of carcinogenicity for chlordane, and more broadly,
that there was insufficient objective evidence of carcino-
genicity in laboratory animals to find a cancer risk to man.
The objective evidence Velsicol charges is lacking is evi-
dence that the tumors induced during the feeding studies
had properties of invasion (spreading of a tumor into ad-
jacent tissues) and metastasis (spreading of malignant
cells into non-adjacent tissues)—characteristics two of
their witnesses considered essential definitional elements
of ‘‘cancer.’’ By contrast, the other pathologists consulted
during the suspension proceeding generally believe that
cancer can be reliably diagnosed by observation of tissue
cells under a microscope (histopathological evidence) with-
21 See also, EDF v. EPA, 167 U.S. App. D.C. 71, 78, 510 F.2d
1292, 1299 (1975); Synthetic Organic Chemica] Manufacturers
Association v. Brennan, 503 F.2d 1155, 1160 (3d Cir. 1974), cert.
denied, 420 U.S. 973 (1975).
22155 U.S. App. D.C. 411, 439, 478 F.2d 615, 643 (1973).
28 Technical chlordane was arbitrarily named, and actually is
made up of 13-15% alpha-chlordane, 13-15% gamma-chlordane,
and 5-8% heptachlor. ALJ Recommended Decision at 7.
15
out evidence, or very much evidence, of invasion or meta-
stasis. The Administrator concluded, on what we view as
respectable scientific authority, that evidence of invasion
and metastasis is not essential to the diagnosis of cancer
in mice, and also found that metastasis and invasion had
been reported in some of the studies where protocols for
the study did not preclude such analysis. That a low
percentage of metastasis was found in those studies was
also explained by the failure to use the more sensitive ex-
amination techniques developed since the studies relied on
here were carried out.
In reviewing and evaluating the studies relied on by
the Administrator, five EPA witnesses and fve Velsicol
consultants agreed that animals fed chlordane and animals
fed heptachlor/heptachlor epoxide in fact underwent cellu-
lar changes indicating malignancy. Dr. Reuber reeval-
uated the FDA C3H Mouse Study of 1965 and found ‘‘a
statistically significant increase in carcinomas”’ in the mice
treated with heptachlor/heptachlor epoxide. The ALJ con-
cluded that no substantial refutation of his results was
made.™ The 1959 Kettering CFN Rat Study tested hepta-
chlor epoxide ; five pathologists found that the original eval-
uation had underdiagnosed liver cancer, the biological
significance of which was found by Judge Perlman to be
; ‘especially significant because of the rarity of this find-
ing.’’* Histological review of the IRDC CD-1 Mouse
Study, using a hardy non-inbred strain of mice with low
incidence of spontaneous tumors, resulted in the finding
of ‘‘a highly statistically significant incidence of hepato-
cellular carcinomas”’’ for those mice fed heptachlor /hepta-
chlor epoxide,* and basically the same finding for mice
** ALJ Recommended Decision at 78, 82.
** ALJ Recommended Decision at 82.
7° ALJ Recommended Decision at 80.
16
fed chlordane.” After considering design problems of con-
trol group and dosages, the Administrator also relied on
the preliminary results of National Cancer Institute B6C3
F1 Mouse Studies of Heptachlor and Chlordane, showing
a highly statistically significant increase in carcinomas in
a strain of mice with a low spontaneous incidence of tu-
mors.” The Administrator has adequately explained his
reliance on these test results which show significant car-
cinoma development in treated animals. None of the tests
vielded negative results; chlordane was shown to be in-
dependently carcinogenic, as well as to contain a carcino-
genic component (heptachlor/heptachlor epoxide). We
think it plain that the foregoing establishes substantial evi-
dence supporting the Administrator’s result, and that Vel-
sicol cannot be said to have met its burden of overcoming
EPA’s prima facie case by showing that chlordane and
heptachlor are not carcinogenic in laboratory animals.
2. Extrapolation of Animal Data to Man
Human epidemeology studies so far attempted on chlor-
dane and heptachlor gave no basis for concluding that the
two pesticides are safe with respect to the issue of cancer.”
To conclude that they pose a carcinogenic risk to humans
on the basis of such a finding of risk to laboratory animals,
the Administrator must show a causal connection between
the uses of the pesticides challenged and resultant expos-
ure of humans to those pesticides. He made that link by
showing that widespread residues of heptachlor and chlor-
dane are present in the human diet and in human tissues.
Their widespread occurrence in the environment *® and ac-
27 ALJ Recommended Decision at 80.
2® Administrator’s Opinion at 23.
7? ALJ Recommended Decision at 86, n.25; Administrator’s
Opinion at 18-19.
3° EPA Ex. 20 (Carey); EPA Ex. 24A-C (Seba); VCC Ex. 6,
Tr. 3268 (Fink) ; VCC Ex. 7 (Feltz).
oe ~-
ee, =e
ei eet.
17
cumulation in the food chain ™ is explained by their chemi-
cal properties of persistence, mobility and high solubility
in lipids (the fats contained in all organic substances).
Residues of chlordane and heptachlor remain in soils and
in air and acquatic ecosystems for long periods of time.™
They are readily transported by means of vaporization,
aerial drift, and runoff of eroding soil particles.** The resi-
dues have been consistently found in meat, fish, poultry and
dairy products monitored in the FDA Market Basket Sur-
vey and are also frequent in components of animal feeds.
This evidence supports a finding that a major route of
human exposure is ingestion of contaminated foodstuffs.™
EPA’s National Human Monitoring Survey data shows
that heptachlor epoxide and oxychlordane, the principal
metabolites of heptachlor and chlordane respectively, are
present in the adipose tissue of over 90% of the U.S. popu-
lation.*
The population’s exposure to these pesticides, in large
part involuntary, can be divided into agricultural and non-
agricultural related routes. Seven million pounds of hepta-
"ALJ at 9-12, 18-19; EPA Exs. 16, 161, 16L (Cummings) ;
re = 17 (Munsen); EPA Ex. 23 (Sanborn); VCC Ex. 5
* USDA Exs. 5, 5A-5E (Nash); EPA Exs. 21, (Taylor); EPA
17 (Munsen) ; 23B (Sanborn); EPA Ex. 24 (Seba).
* VCC Ex. 13A at 1628-1675; USDA Ex. 5F, Tr. 5978 (Nash) ;
EPA Ex. 17 (Munsen) ; EPA Exs. 21, 21C-F (Taylor); EPA Ex.
74 ee VCC Ex. 7 (Feltz), 4106-13 (Polen); 3292-94, 3310
eitz).
** ALJ Recommended Decision at 18.
* ALJ at 9-11; EPA Ex. 18 (Kutz). Between 1970 and 1974,
heptachlor epoxide residues averaging .08-.09ppm were found in
94.8%, 96.2%, 90.3%, 97.7% and 96.3% respectively of the human
fat samples tested. Between 1971 and 1974, oxychlordane residues
averaging .10-.12 ppm were found in 93.3%, 92.3%, 98.3% and
98.6% respectively, of the samples analyzed.
18
chlor and chlordane were used as corn soil insecticide in
1975, producing residues which persist in the soil for sev-
eral years after application. These residues are taken up
by such food, feed, and forage crops as soybeans, barley,
oats, and hays typically rotated with corn.” By volatiliza-
tion the pesticides contaminate corn and other plant
leaves.*” And root crops like potatoes, carrots and beets
directly absorb the pesticides from the soil.** Other sources
of agricultural-related residues include exposure to con-
taminated dust particles and agricultural runoff containing
eroded soil particles.
Velsicol urges that the dietary exposure resulting from
agricultural uses of the pesticides is insignificant, and that
current exposure is well below ‘‘safe’’ dose levels as cal-
culated by the Mantel-Bryan formula, or by the World
Health Organization’s Acceptable Daily Intake figures.
Mantel himself criticized the use of the formula for a per-
sistent pesticide, and the Administrator rejected the con-
cept of a ‘‘safe’’ dose level defined by mathematical model-
ing because of ‘‘the incomplete assumptions made by the
registrant’s witnesses about the sources of human exposure
in the environment, the natural variation in human sus-
ceptability to cancer, the lack of any evidence relating the
level of human susceptability to cancer from heptachlor
and chlordane as opposed to that of the mouse, and the
absence of precise knowledge as to the minimum exposure
to a carcinogen necessary to cause cancer.’’** That expla-
%* EPA Exs. 21, 21B (Taylor); EPA Exs, 16C, 16E, 16G (Cum-
mings); USDA Exs. 5, 5H, 51, 5K, 5L (Nash).
“USDA Ex. 5K (Nash); EPA Exs,. 21, 21C-21F (Taylor) ;
EPA Ex. 24 (Seba).
*° EPA Exs. 16, 16B, 16C (Cummings) ; USDA Ex. 5K (Nash).
*° Administrator’s Opinion at 29; ALJ Recommended Decision
at 86; EPA Ex. 43 (Mantel) ; EPA Exs. 45, 45A at 16-17 (Schneid-
erman); Tr. 4948-53, 4967 (cross-examination of Carlborg); Tr.
8474-8482, 8525 (Mantel).
cep tn,“ ttt
Or ete wn te wkee ce dagen
19
nation is within the reasonable bounds of the agency’s ex-
pertise in evaluating evidence. And it is confirmed by the
common sense recognition that reliance on average ‘‘safe’’
dietary levels fail to protect people with dietary patterns
based on high proportional consumption of residue-con-
taminated foods (e.g., children who ingest greater quanti-
ties of milk than the general population).
There are several non-agricultural uses which involve a
large volume of heptachlor and chlordane as well as sig-
nificant human exposures. For example, the record shows
that approximately six million pounds of chlordane are
used annually on home lawns and gardens. The Admini-
strator found that these uses involve high risks of human
intake ‘‘due to the many avenues which exist for direct
exposure, through improper handling and misuse, inhala-
tion, and absorption through the skin from direct con-
tact.’ Velsicol asserts that the mice studies showing car-
cinogenic effects after ingestion of chlordane do not war-
rant an inference about the carcinogenic effects of inhal-
ing it or absorbing it through the skin, and that conse-
quently nonagricultural routes of exposure cannot be con-
sidered to present a cancer risk. They rely on Reserve
Mining Co v. EPA, 514 F.2d 495 (8th Cir. 1975) (en banc).
That reliance is misplaced. In that case, the court was con-
cerned with the propriety of the district court’s granting
the immediate relief of shutting down a plant discharging
asbestos fibers into the City of Duluth’s drinking water
source. It instead ordered cessation of dumping within a
*‘reasonable time’’ pursuant to the unstructured equitable
discretion given the court under the Federal Water Pol-
lution Control Act, even though it had concluded that con-
tinued discharge posed a hazard to health. By contrast, the
“EPA Ex. 19 (Kutz); VCC Ex. 4A at 22, Tr. 3124, 7366-67
(Duggan).
** Administrator’s Opinion at 47.
20
FIFRA statutory scheme mandates explicit relief—the sus-
pension of registration—when an unreasonable risk to
health is made out. We have previously held that it is not
necessary to have evidence on a specific use to be able to
conclude that the use of a pesticide in general is hazardous.
Once the initial showing of hazard is made for one mode
of exposure in a suspension proceeding, and the pesticide
is shown to be present in human tissues, the burden shifts
to the registrant to rebut the inference that other modes
of exposure may also pose a carcinogenic hazard for hu-
mans.** Velsicol has totally failed to meet that burden here.
Although it was put on notice in the Notice to Suspend of
EP<A’s intent to rely on direct inhalation and dermal ex-
posure as reasons to suspend household lawn and turf uses
of chlordane, it failed to offer even a medical theory as to
why the significant inhalation or dermal exposure associ-
ated with such uses would not pose a carcinogenic threat.
In view of the general failure to understand the mechanics
of carcinogenicity, the lack of hypothetical explanation may
be based on Velsicol’s own data that exposure to vapors
of chlordane and heptachlor in the work place, leads (as
dietary exposure leads) to storage of oxychlordane, hepta-
chlor epoxide, and other components in the fat tissue, and
to circulation of these compounds in the blood, with conse-
quent exposure to other organs in the body.** Nor did Velsi-
*? Velsicol asked this court to take judicial notice of the EPA’s
Interim Procedures & Guidelines for Health Risk and Economic
Impact Assessments of Suspected Carcinogens, 41 Fed. Reg. 21402-
05 (May 25, 1976), particularly § 3.5.3 that ‘‘[s]ome judgment
should be included regarding relevance of the mode of exposure.’’
In view of the no benefit finding from continued use of chlordane
and heptachlor in household lawn and turf care, and the pesticides’
characteristics of persistence, biomagnification and lipid solubility,
that standard does not appear to have been violated here, although
the Administrator was not explicit on the point. Cf. EDF v. EPA,
167 U.S. App. D.C. at 80, 510 F.2d at 1301.
** VCC Ex. 36A. We note that the reliance placed by Velsicol on
the Eighth Circuit’s distinction between modes of exposure in
sO tee. > ll
Deteoty mo
Pe ee ae
ee hte Ten ire
21
col focus on the individual user’s intense inhalation ex-
posure associated with lawn and turf uses in its response
to the point made in the EPA Staff’s exceptions to the
ALJ recommended decision, that the evidence showed that
an individual using these chemicals for lawn and turf ap-
plications is subjected to a marked intensity of inhalation.
Instead Velsicol attacked as inconsistent with the minimal
amounts of chlordane and heptachlor normally found in
ambient air, the EPA Staff’s proposed reliance on inhala-
tion as a major route of human exposure for the general
population. However, the Administrator did not proceed
on this basis. And if Velsicol hypothesized that chlordane
residues are safe so long as they reach the tissue only
through inhalation (even intense inhalation) it should have
presented witnesses expressing that hypothesis. Instead
they argue, in general and procedural terms, that the evi-
dence presented by the Administrator was not sufficient
to meet his full burden, and this in our view seeks to im-
pose a broader burden on the Administrator than is ap-
propriate in a suspension proceeing.
B. Benefits
Velsicol and USDA challenge the Administrator’s find-
ing that the benefits derived from the suspended uses of
chlordane do not outweigh the harms done. EDF urges that
the Administrator’s decision to continue some uses was not
justified by evidence that the risk of harm was outweighed
by benefits from the continued uses.
Reserve Mining fails to take into account as well the very different
chemical properties that characterize asbestos as opposed to the
properties exhibited by heptachlor/chlordane. Unlike the pesticides
at issue here, asbestos fibers are apparently not mobile or lipid
soluble, so it was possible that the ingested asbestos—the exposure
route where there was less evidence—would pass straight through
the digestive tract rather than being retained. There was no com-
parable hypothesis advanced for the inhalation exposure route ques-
tioned here.
22
1. Use on Corn
Heptachlor and chlordane were used on an estimated
3.5% of the total corn acreage in the United States in
1975, largely in an effort to control black cutworm. Cut-
worms sporadically infest 2 to 8% of total U.S. corn farms,
and occur most often in lowland, river bottom areas. Chlor-
dane and heptachlor are used as preplant treatments to
insure against possible infestations. The Administrator
found, with record support, that no macroeconomic impact
will occur as a result of suspending those pesticides. He
also found that crop surveillance or ‘‘scouting’’ for infes-
tations during the early weeks of plant growth, together
with application of post-emergence baits or sprays where
necessary, provide an effective alternative to the more in-
discriminate prophylactic use of chlordane and heptachlor.
Velsicol urges that this approach is not as effective as the
persistent protection provided by chlordane. Especially in
the absence of proof of a serious threat to the nation’s
corn, there is no requirement that a pesticide can be sus-
pended only if alternatives to its use are absolutely equiva-
lent in effectiveness. The Administrator reasonably took
into account that a transition period would be necessary
to implement post-emergent techniques of control and con-
cluded that the challenged pesticides cou'd continue in use
for corn protection until August 1, 1976.** This evaiuation
of alternatives and the time required to implement them is
supported by substantial evidence, and we find no basis
to disturb the Administrator’s balancing of costs and bene-
fits.
** EDF argues tha: it was illegal for the Administrator to delay
implementation of his suspension on corn. Such a delay is spe-
cifically authorized by the FIFRA, 7 U.S.C. § 136m(b) (2), which
provides that ‘‘the Administrator may provide a reasonable time
for use or other disposal’’ of a suspended pesticide.
23
2. Miscellaneous Agricultural Uses
The Administrator suspended a number of agricultural
uses where the record was insufficient to support any find-
ing that benefits outweigh costs of continued use of hep-
tachlor or chlordane on these crops.** Possibly the lack of
benefits evidence reflected readily available alternatives,
possibly a relative lack of interest in lesser-volume uses.
In any event, the registrant’s failure to carry its burden
of adducing sufficient evidence on benefits in effect leaves
the Administrator nothing to weigh in his cost-benefit
analysis except the evidence that the use of the challenged
pesticides in general is hazardous. That evidence of gen-
eral hazard is sufficient to support a suspension of uses.
3. Non-Agricultural Uses Suspended by the
Admimstrator
Chlordane is a common household, lawn, garden, and
ornamental turf insecticide, with over 7.5 million pounds
(36% of total use) so employed in 1974. The ALJ and
Administrator found on the basis of substantial evidence
that the ‘‘efficaciousness of the substitutes for control of
household and lawn insects is not really at issue’’“* and
** Velsicol also urges that the December 24, 1975, Order sus-
pended agricultural registration of chlordane and heptachlor for
corn pests alone, and that the Administrator lacked jurisdiction
to issue the January 19th order it views as suspending for the first
time more than 100 miscellaneous agricultural registrations of the
pesticides. We reject that contention. The January 19th order
merely clarifies the December 24th order. The Administrator’s De-
eember 24th decision noted that the ALJ determined that uses of
which no benefits evidence was presented should be suspended. We
cannot read the December 24th order as contemplating continued
use of hazardous pesticides in the absence of any reliable record
evidence of benefits to be derived from continued use.
**ALJ Recommended Decision at 102, EPA Ex. 26 at 32-34,
Ex. 26T, NPCA Ex. 1-5. There is of course no requirement that
substitutes for suspended pesticides be absolutely equivalent in
effectiveness for a particular use.
24
that when lack of evidence of substantial benefits from
continued use is weighed against the special hazards of
exposure presented by the possibilities of inhalation, der-
mal absorption, and the increased dangers associated with
improper handling, suspension of those uses was justified.
Similarly, on the basis of evidence in the record, the Admin-
istrator could reasonably find that the residual capacity of
chlordane was not necessary to control] either structural
pests or ticks and chiggers, given the existence of effective
alternatives to each of those uses.*
4. The Administrator’s Refusal to Suspend Certain Uses
EDF challenges the Administrator’s refusal to suspend
use of chlordane or heptachlor on strawberries, for seed
treatment, pineapples, the white fringed beetle, Florida
citrus, white grubs in Michigan, narcissi bulbs, harvester
ants, imported fire ant, Japanese beetle quarantine, and
black vine weevil quarantine in Michigan. Following the
recommendations of the ALJ, the Administrator found
that for each use the benefits outweighed the risks for the
limited time under consideration, effective alternatives
were generally not available, and that the exposure risk
arising from the use was minimal. EDF counters that the
total exposure resulting from these ‘‘minor’’ uses is in
fact significant, and that the Administrator continued these
uses whenever a ‘‘colorable’’ case of benefits had been
made out.
Once the Administrator has found that a risk inheres in
the use of a pesticide, he has an obligation to explain
how the benefits of continued use outweigh that risk. We
are satisfied that he has met that obligation here, and that
substantial evidence supports his decision. We note, how-
ever, that we come to this conclusion in the context of a
suspension proceeding where perforce the Administrator is
*? Administrator’s Opinion at 36, 48.
25
engaged in making a ‘‘preliminary assessment’’ of the
evidence; a more careful exploration of economic impact
and available alternatives would be required to support
continued registration in a cancellation proceeding.
C. Continued Sale and Use of Existing Stocks of Chlor-
dane and Heptachlor for Suspended Uses
Although we have no doubt that the Administrator has
the power under FIFRA to exempt from a suspension
order the use of existing stocks (in this case stocks existing
as of July 29, 1975), the Administrator acted arbitrarily
when he failed to even inquire into the amount of-stocks
left, and the problem of returning and disposing of them.
Some evidence must be adduced before an exemption deci-
sion is made, and it is the responsibility of the registrant to
provide it.“ It may be that the lapse of time has lessened
the current significance of this issue but we are in no posi-
tion to do other than remand for further consideration.
We affirm the Agency’s suspension order of December
24, 1975, as clarified by the order of January 19, 1976,
except for the exemption of the sale and use of existing
stocks. The record is remanded for further consideration
of that issue.
So ordered.
*® Some evidence on this question has since been made available
to this court by Velsicol, but we do not consider ourselves in &
position to evaluate it.
26
APPENDIX B
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
No. 75-2259
Environ MENTAL DEFENSE F'unp, Inc., Petitioner
v.
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection AGENCY AND
Russe.tx E. Trars, Apmrinistrator, Respondents
Ve sico: CHEemicaL CoRPORATION
PrvgappLe Growers ASSOCIATION OF Hawant, ET AL.,
Intervenor
No. 76-1181
Ear L. Butz, Secretary oF AGRICULTURE, OF THE
Unirtep States, Petitioner
Vv.
RusseE.u E. Trarn, ADMINISTRATOR OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection Acency, Respondent
Vewsico. CHemicaL Corporation, Intervenor
Supple mental Opinion on Petition for Rehearing
Filed January 6, 1977
Before: LeventHat, Rosinson and Wrxey, Circuit
Judges
27
OrpER
On consideration of the petition of Velsicol Chemical
Corporation for rehearing it is
ORDERED by the Court that the aforesaid petition for
rehearing is denied.
Supplemental Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit
Judge LEVENTHAL.
SuPPLEMENTAL OPINION ON
Petrrion ror REHEARING
LevenTHaL, Circuit Judge: Velsicol argues in its petition
for rehearing that in upholding the Administrator’s allo-
cation of the burden of proof to the registrant this Court
misinterpreted § 7c of the Administrative Procedure Act.
Velsicol points out that the interpretation adopted by this
Court was not advanced by any of the parties and that, in
fact, the problem of interpreting the APA—as opposed to
section 6(c)(2) of FIFRA—was not briefed or argued in
this proceeding.
In light of these contentions, we have reexamined our
analysis of the APA and FIFRA. After further study, we
are still of the view that the Administrative Procedrre Act
does not preclude the assignment of the burden of persua-
sion to the opponent of an order. So far as this case is con-
cerned, however, Velsicol’s position is undermined by still
another doctrine, that in any event the controlling statute
is FIFRA. We hold that in light of the legislative history
of FIFRA, and the numerous cases holding that its 1964
amendment was specifically intended to shift the burden of
proof from the Secretary to the registrant, this case is one
where the location of the burden of proof is, in the lan-
guage of the APA, ‘‘otherwise provided by statute.’’ 5
U.S.C. § 556(d).
28
I
As to the APA, our opinion holds that the ‘“‘burden of
proof’’ it casts upon the ‘‘proponent”’ is the burden of
coming forward with proof, and not the ultimate burden of
persuasion.
Velsicol claims that the precedents of this Circuit’ and
case law in other circuits? establish that under the APA
the proponent of an order bears the burden of persuasion.
We have examined the cited cases and find no support
for that view. Time does not permit discussion of each
case. We shall refer to a few as illustrations.
Velsicol calls attention to National Airlines, Inc. v. Civil
Aeronautics Board, 112 U.S.App.D.C. 119, 300 F.2d 711
(D.C. Cir. 1962). There we affirmed an order that held that
once a complaining City had demonstrated the inadequacy
of existing airline service, the airline bore the burden of
proving the economic infeasibility of expanding service.
The court explained:
Petitioner argues that the Administrative Procedure
Act, §7(c), 69 Stat. 241 (1946), 5 U.S.C. A. § 1006(c),
which places the burden of proof upon the proponent
of an order, prohibits the Board from placing the bur-
den of proving economic infeasibility upon the car-
riers. We think that once the Board has established
1 Velsicol cites National Airlines, Inc. v. C.A.B., 112 U.S. App.
D.C. 119, 123 n. 12, 300 F.2d 711, 715 n. 12 (1962); Schramm
v. Physical Therapists Examining Board, 129 U.S. App. D.C. 347,
394 F.2d 972 (1967), cert. denied, 390 U.S. 987 (1968), aff’g 219
A.2d 846 (D.C.C.A. 19-6) ; Philadelphia Co. v, S.E.C., 84 U.S. App.
D.C. 73, 175 F.2d 808 (1948), vacated as moot, 337 U.S. 901
(1949).
2 Velsicol cited United States v. Springer, 491 F.2d 239, 242
(9th Cir. 1974); Day v. National Trans. Safety Board, 414 F.2d
950 (5th Cir. 1969); N.L.R.B. v. Atlanta Coca-Cola Bottling Co.,
293 F.2d 300 (5th Cir. 1961); Kerner v. Fleming, 283 F.2d 916,
921-22 (2d Cir. 1960); Kirby v. Shaw, 358 F.2d 446, 449 (9th
Cir. 1960).
=
29
that existing service is inadequate to meet the needs of
a community, it has discharged its burden of proof.
Economi¢ infeasibility ig more like an affirmative de-
fense than an element of the Board’s case. Accord-
ingly we think that the Board properly placed the
burden of producing evidence of economic infeasibility
upon petitioner. |
112 U.S:App.D.C. at 123 n. 12, 300 F.2d at 715 n. 12. Far
from indicating that the APA governs allocation of the
burden of persuasion, this passage indicates that it was
the burden ef producing evidence that was the central
concern of the APA. )
Our examination of the precedents cited from other Cir-
cuits has similarly failed to disclose a case holding that
under the APA the proponent of an order bears the burden
of persuasion. Must of the cases cited by Velsicol appear
to think of ‘‘burden of proof’’ as the burden of producing
evidence. See, e.g., N.L.R.B. v. Atlanta Coca-Cola Bottling
Co., 293 F.2d 300 (5th Cir.) rehearing denied, 296 F.2d 896
(1961) ; United States v. Springer, 491 F.2d 239, 242 (9th
Cir.) cert. denied, 419 U.S. 834 (1974); Kirby v. Shaw, 358
F.2d 446 (9th Cir. 1966).* The one case cited by Velsicol
*The other decisions of this Cirenit do not detract from this
conclusion. In Philadelphia Co. v. SEC, supra at note 1, the SEC
had undertaken action with respect to the company by amending
its Rules. It had not apprised the company of the facts upon
which its action was based, ‘‘and it failed to introduce or receive
evidence, to hear witnesses, to permit cross-examination, and to
make a proper transcript of record.’’ 175 F.2d at 818. It was in
this context—in the total absence of an adjudicatory hearing—
that we held that the Commission had ‘‘erroneously failed to
assume the burden of proof in respect to the propriety of its
proposed action.’’ Id. In Schramm v. Physical Therapists Board,
supra, at note 1, we upheld a decision of the D.C. Court of Ap-
peals which found that an applicant had failed to meet her
statutory duty of ‘‘present[ing] evidence’’ of her qualifications.
219 A.2d at 847.
*In Atlanta Coca-Cola, for example, the court was concerned
30
that is explicitly concerned with the ‘‘burden of persua-
sion’’ is Kerner v. Flemming, 283 F.2d 916, 921-22 (2d Cir.
1960). Judge Friendly assumed arguendo (‘‘We may
agree’’) that under the APA and the Social Security Act
‘fan applicant for a disability pension has the ultimate
burden of persuasion.’’ This did not govern the result, for
the court did not affirm the denial of benefits but remanded
for the taking of further evidence.‘
As for American Trucking Associations v. United
States, 344 U.S. 298, 319 (1953), in holding that §7(c) of
the APA did not apply to the proceedings in suit, the Court
merely put it as an assumption for sake of discussion:
But even assuming that the Commission was a statu-
tory ‘‘proponent’’ of the regulation and that it did not
actively introduce the requisite degree of proof in sup-
port of its position, we think it plain that the require-
ment is inapplicable to the instant proceedings.
Our further research outside our circuit has yielded Old
Ben Coal Corp. v. Interior Bd. of Mine Operations Ap-
peals, 523 F.2d 25 (7th Cir. 1975), involving a situation and
a ruling like ours. Appellants challenged a regulation that
placed on the mine owner the burden of proving by a pre-
ponderance of the evidence the invalidity of the imminent
danger withdrawal orders issued against him. The court
held that in its view the Government bore the initial burden
with the Genera] Counsel’s failure to produce evidence of dis-
criminatory intent as to each of the individual employees, rather
than with the placement of the burden of persuasion. See, e.g.,
292 F.2d at 309 (‘‘This is not a case where conflicting inferences
of equal weight may be drawn from the record.’’)
‘That the court did not intend this passage to state doctrine
with respect to the allocation of the burdens of proof or persua-
sion is indicated by its appended footnote 8, which stated ‘‘Con-
gress has often spoken more clearly when it has desired to fix a
burden of proof. [citing statutes].’’
31
of going forward with the evidence, but_that once it had
presented a prima facie case, the mine owner would be re-
quired to bear the ‘‘ ultimate burden of proof.’’ 523 F.2d at
30.* The Court explained:
In practice . . . the burden of proof is split, with the
Government bearing the burden of going forward, and
the mine operator bearing the ultimate burden of per-
suasion. We think that this accords with the intent of
Congress as expressed in the . .. Committee comment
on section 7(c) of the Administrative Procedure Act
(now codified as 5 U.S.C. § 556(d)) [citations omitted]
The legislative history of § 7(c) of the APA confirms the
Seventh Circuit’s interpretation. We set out the whole of
the pertinent paragraph of the Senate Committee Report :’
That the proponent of a rule or order has the bur-
den of proof means not only that the party initiating
the proceeding has the general burden of coming for-
ward with a prima facie case but that other parties,
who are proponents of some different result, also for
that purpose have a burden to maintain. Similarly the
requirement that no sanction be imposed or rule or
order be issued except upon evidence of the kind speci-
fied means that the proponents of a denial of relief
must sustain such denia!by that kind of evidence. For
example, credible and credited evidence submitted by
the applicant for a license may not be ignored except
upon the requisite kind and quality of contrary evi-
dence. No agency is authorized to stand mute and arbi-
trarily disbelieve credible evidence. Except as appli-
cants for a license or other privilege may be required
to come forward with a prime facie showing, no agency
* Judge Pell dissented.
7S. Rep. No. 752, 79th Cong., Ist Sess. 22 (1945), reprinted in
S. Doc. 248 at 208.
32
is entitled to presume that the conduct of any person
or status of any enterprise is unlawful or improper.
Plainly, this is all concerned with the proponents being
required to show the burden of producing evidence.
The House Report * fully confirms this view. It contains
the language quoted above from the Senate Report, and
summarizes its effect:
In other words, this section means that every propo-
nent of a rule or order or the denial thereof has the
burden of coming forward with sufficient evidence
therefor; and in determining applications for licenses
or other relief any fact, conduct, or status so shown by
credible and credited evidence must be accepted as true
except as the contrary has been shown or such evi-
dence has been rebutted or impeached by duly credited
evidence or by facts officially noticed and stated. (Em-
phasis added).
Velsicol points out that an earlier version of 8.7 had
provided :
The proponent of a rule or order shall have the burden
of proceeding except as statutes otherwise provide.”’
(S.Doc 248, 79th Cong., 2d Sess. 11, 158, 300 (1945)).
A Senate Judiciary Print comparing the earlier and later
versions of the bil! stated:
The provision relating to burden of proof is the stand-
ard rule. Senate Doc. 248 at page 31.
Velsicol contends that this change in language was in-
tended to make clear that the proponent of an order would
also bear the burden of persuasion.
*H.R. Rep. 1980, 79th Cong., 2d Sess. 34 (1946), reprinted in
S. Doc. 248 at 270.
33
This argument is more revealing of the ingenuity of
counsel than of the intent of Congress. If the language of
the bill had been deliberately changed to govern placement
of the burden of persuasion, the Committee reports ac-
eompanying the bill would have made that point.
Lastly, we note that our interpretation of § 7(c) is sup-
ported by the Attorney General’s Manual on the Adminis-
trative Procedure Act, published in 1947 ‘‘primarily as a
guide to the agencies in adjusting their procedures to the
requirements of the Act.’’ (Intro. by Att. Gen. Tom Clark,
page 6). The Manual does not mention the change in lan-
guage as bearing on location of the burden of persuasion.
On the contrary, it states (at p. 75):
There is some indication that the term ‘burden of
proof’? was not employed in any strict sense, but
rather as synonymous with the ‘“‘burden of going for-
ward’’. In either case, it is clear from the introductory
clause that this general statement was not intended to
repeal specific provisions of other statutes which, as
by establishing presumptions alter what would other-
wise be the ‘‘burden of proof’’ or the ‘‘burden of going
forward’’.
II
Section 7(¢) of the APA provides that the proponent of
a rule or order shall have the burden of proof ‘‘[e]xcept
as otherwise provided by statute.’’ Because we held in our
panel opinion that §7(c) was not intended to govern the
allocation of the burden of persuasion, we found it unnec-
essary to decide whether suspension hearings held under
FIFRA might not qualify as a situation where the location
of the burden of proof was ‘‘otherwise provided by stat-
ute.’’ Velsicol’s challenge has led us to focus again on the
problem. We have examined the relationship between
FIFRA and the APA and conclude that suspension hear-
ings do indeed fall within the exceptions to § 7(c).
34
This court has repeatedly held that the 1964 amendments
to FIFRA were specifically intended to shift the burden of
proof from the Secretary (now the Administrator) to the
registrant. EDF v. Ruckelshaus, 142 U.S.App.D.C. 74, 93,
439 F.2d 584, 593 (D.C. Cir. 1971); EDF v. EPA [Aldrin
and Dieldrin], 150 U.S.App.D.C. 348, 465 F.2d 528, 532
(D.C. Cir. 1972); EDF v. EPA [Shell Chemical Co.], 167
U.S.App.D.C. 71, 76, 510 F.2d 1292, 1297 (1975). In EDF
v. Ruckelshaus, supra, the court explained:
Prior to 1964, the FIFRA required the Secretary to
register ‘‘under protest’’ any pesticide or other item
that failed to meet the statutory requirements. The
product remained on the market, and the Secretary
reported the violation to the United States Attorney
for possible prosecution. In 1964 the statute was
amended to eliminate the system of protest registra-
tion, and substitute the present administrative mech-
anism for cancelling registrations. The stated purpose
of the amendment was to protect the public by re-
moving from the market any product whose safety or
effectiveness was doubted by the Secretary.
The House Committee Report accompaninying the bill spe-
cifically stated:
The principal effect of registration under protest is
to shift the burden of proof from the registrant to the
Government. If the product is not registered, the pen-
alty or seizure provisions can be applied on that
ground. If it is registered under protest, the Govern-
ment has the burden of proving that the product does
not comply with the act.
Thus, at present, the Secretary can be required to
register a product even though he is convinced that it
is ineffective and dangerous to human life. He can
proceed against it in such case only after it has moved
in interstate commerce, and he then has the burden of
35
proving that it violates the law. The bill would correct
this situation and afford greater protection to the pub-
lic by repealing the authority for registration under
protest. In its place the bill provides that applicants
dissatisfied with the Secretary’s action in refusing or
canceling registration may have recourse to advisory
committee proceedings, public hearings, and eventually
judicial review. Thus the bill affords adequate protec-
tion to the public, and protects applicants for registra-
tion from arbitrary or ill-advised action by the De-
partment,
H.R. Rep. No. 1125, 88th Cong., 1st Sess. 2 (1964). Thus,
we found that ‘‘[t]he legislative history supports the con-
clusion that Congress intended any substantial question of
safety to trigger the issuance of cancellation notices, shift-
ing to the manufacturer the burden of proving the safety
of his product.’’ 142 U.S.App.D.C. at 83, 439 F.2d at 593.°
* We quoted in a footnote from additional legislative history :
34. See 110 Cong. Ree, 2948-49 (1964) (remarks of Congress-
woman Sullivan) :
I am strongly in favor of the legislation now before you
to require industry, rather than the Federal Government,
to shoulder the burden of proof in connection with the
marketing of pesticides which may be unsafe for use as
intended.
o ° > e
The burden of proof should not rest on the Government,
because great damage can be done during the period the
Government is developing the data necessary to remove
a product which should not be marketed.
See also H.R.Rep. No. 1125, supra; S.Rep. No. 573, 88th Cong.,
2d Sess. (1964). Our construction of the FIFRA also finds
strong support in a 1969 report of the House Committee on
Government Operations, reviewing the administration of the
statute. The Committee strongly criticized the administrators
for failing to take ‘‘prompt or effective cancellation action in
cases where it had reason to believe a registered product might
be ineffective or potentially hazardous. * * * A mistaken belief
36
Subsequent decisions reaffirmed this interpretation. In
the 1972 EDF case, we said (150 U.S.App.D.C. at 352, 465
F.2d at 532):
The burden of establishing the safety of a product
requisite for compliance with the labeling require-
ments, remains at all times on the applicant and regis-
trant.
In the 1975 EDF case, 510 F.2d at 1297, we reiterated this
principle in the context of a challenge to a suspension or-
der. Other circuits have similarly concluded that the regis-
trant bears the burden of proof. E.g., Dow Chemical Corp.
v. Ruckelshaus, 477 F.2d 1317, 1324 (8th Cir. 1973) ; South-
ern National Mfg. Co. v. EPA, 470 F.2d 194, 196-97 (8th
Cir. 1973) ; Continental Chemiste Corp. v. Ruckelshaus, 461
F.2d 331, 335 (7th Cir. 1972); Stearns Electric Paste Corp.
v. EPA, 461 F.2d 293, 303 (7th Cir. 1972).
Velsicol argues that ihe 1972 Amendments to FIFRA,
which provided that a suspension hearing ‘‘shall be held in
accordance with the provisions of subchapter II of Chapter
5 of Title 5’’, operated to shift the burden of proof to the
agency. See FIFRA §6(c)(2), 7 U.S.C §136d(c)(2)
(Supp. V 1975). In light of the clarity with which Con-
gress originally undertook to fix the burden of proof (per-
suasion) on the registrant, and the firmness of the courts’
interpretation of the 1944 amendment,” we cannot believe
that positive evidence of hazard—rather than simply a lack
of adequate assurance of safety—is necessary to support &
cancellation action appears to have been a factor in [the]
failure to initiate such action in cases where it was obviously
justified.’” H.R.Rep. No. 91-637, 91st Cong., lst Sess. 15-16
(1969).
1° Significantly, our decisions had made clear that the registrant
bore the burden of proof in suspension hearings even before the
1972 Amendments had been enacted. Our 1971 decision in EDF v.
Ruchelshaus noted:
Because the statute places on the manufacturer the burden of
—_
37
that the general incorporation of APA standards 1972
was intended to shift the burden of proof away from the
registrant sub silentio." As the ALJ pointed out, ‘‘It
would be strange indeed, that the 1972 amendment to the
act would chauge the cornerstone of the statute without
mention.’’ ALJ Recommended Decision at 73, n. 12. This
conclusion would be sound even if the APA, by itself, in-
disputably put the burden of persuasion on the proponent
of suspension. It is strengthened by our conclusion (Part
I) that the APA does not have that consequence.
Lastly, we do not discern in the statute an allocation of
burden of proof that is different for suspension hearings
than for registration or cancellation proceedings. While
the suspension proceeding is in progress, the public is sub-
ject to the same risks of injury that are present in the
cancellation context, the very risks which caused Congress
to shift the burden of proof to the registrant in the original
registration. Information relevant to the safety issues is—
or should be—in the possession of the manufacturer. Cf.
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico v. Federal Maritime
Comm’n, 152 U.S.App.D.C. 28, 468 F.2d 872 (D.C. Cir.
1972.) We agree with Judge, now Justice, Stevens that:
proving the continued safety of his products, see note 34 infra,
an administrative order of suspension is entitled to greater
judicial deference than an order denying suspension.
142 U.S. App. D.C. at 92 n. 22, 439 F.2d at 592 n. 22.
Our statement in EDF v. EPA, 150 U.S. App. D.C. at 352, 465 F.2d
at 532, that the burden of proof was ‘‘at all times on the applicant
and registrant’’ came 6 months before the enactment of the amend-
ments to FIFRA. The decision of the Seventh Circuit that the
registrant bore the burden of proof in suspension proceedings simi-
larly preceded the passage of the Act by 6 months. See Stearns
Electric Paste Co. v. EPA, 461 F.2d 293 (7th Cir. 1972).
™ Velsicol has not cited nor have we found any statements in the
legislative history suggesting that the incorporation of APA stand-
=" suspension hearings was intended to shift the burden of
38
‘“‘If a presumption of proper use at the end of a 5-year
period does not shift the burden of proof in the [re-regis-
tration situation], we think there is even less reason to
shift the burden in the middle of a 5-year term if the Ad-
ministrator should then become aware of previously un-
known risks associated with the use of a product.’’ Stearns
Electric Paste Co. v. EPA, supra, 461 F.2d at 305 n. 38
(7th Cir. 1972). To place the burden of proof on the agency
in suspension hearings would not be a reasonable construc-
tion of FIFRA.
Our view that this case is one in which the allocation of
the burden of proof is controlled by the scheme of FIFRA
rather than by the APA is firmly supported by, and inter-
related with, the doctrine set forth in Commonwealth of
Puerto Rico v. Federal Maritime Comm’n, supra, that the
general rule imposing the burden of proof on the propo-
nent of an order is ‘‘subject to reasonable construction and
limitation.’’ 152 U.S.App.D.C. at 37, 468 F.2d at 881. The
governing statute in that case provided that the burden of
proof was to be borne by the carrier in a proceeding in
which the proposed rates had been suspended, but did not
explicitly provide for the case where the Commission per-
mitted the rates, to go into effect. We held that even in the
absence of explicit statutory guidance, the burden of proof
was to be borne not by the shipper proposing a termination
of the existing rate, but by the carrier defending that rate
and the increases it wrought. In support of this conclusion
we noted the general regulatory pattern and the fact that
the carriers were the parties ‘‘naturally possessed of per-
tinent evidence.’’ Both of those considerations are relevant
with respect to the burden of proof in FIFRA suspension
hearings.
es @ se e
In summary, we find that in a suspension hearing con-
ducted under FIFRA § 6(c)(2), the burden of persuasion
rests ultimately on the registrant. In its 1964 amendment to
39
the Act, Congress made clear that the public was not to
bear the risk of uncertainty concerning the safety of a cov-
ered poison. In the absence of an equally explicit counter-
manding direction from Congress, we will not force the
public to assume it.
40
APPENDIX C
Unstrep States Court or APPEALS
FOR THE District or CoLtumsBia Cracorr
SepremBer Term, 1976
No. 75-2259
ENvmonMENTAL Derense Funp, Inc., Petitioner
v.
ExXvmRoONMENTAL Protection Acency, and Russeu E.
Tram, Administrator, Respondents
Ve tsico. CHEMICAL CORPORATION
Prveappte Growers Association oF Hawat, ET AL.,
Intervenors
No. 76-1181
Ear L. Burz, Secretary of Agriculture of the United
States, Petitioner
Vv.
Russett E. Trary, Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency, Respondent
Ve.tsico, CHemicaL Corporation, Intervenor
No. 76-1245
Ve.tsico. CHemicaL Corporation, Petitioner
Vv.
ENVIRONMENTAL Protection Acency, Russetu E. Trarn,
Administrator, Respondent
41
No. 76-1247
Vexrsico. CHemicaL Corporation, Petitioner
v.
Russet, E. Tram, Administrator, Environmental
Protection Agency, Respondent
Petrrions ror Review or an Orper oF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
Prorection AGENCY
Before: Levenruat, Rosryson and Wrixey, Circuit Judges
Judgment
(filed November 10, 1976)
These causes came on to be heard on petitions for review
of an order of the Environmental Protection Agency and
were argued by counsel. On consideration of the foregoing,
it is
OrpeRED anp Apsuncep by this Court that the Agency’s
suspension order of December 24, 1975, as clarified by the
order of January 19, 1976, is affirmed, except for the ex-
emption of the sale and use of existing stocks. The record
is remanded for further consideration of that issue, in ac-
— with the opinion of this Court filed herein this
te.
Per Curiam
For the Court
/s/ Georcz A. FisHer
George A. Fisher, Clerk
Date: November 10, 1976
Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge Leventhal.
42
APPENDIX D
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
BerorE THE ADMINISTRATOR
FIFRA Docket No. 384
Recommended Decision
In re
Vetsico. CHEemicaL CorPoRATION ET AL., Registrants
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
This is a proceeding under the Federal Insecticide, Fun-
gicide, and Rodenticide Act, as amended (7 U.S.C. 136 et
seq., 1973 Supp.). Pursuant to section 6(c) of the act (7
U.S.C. 136d(c)), the Administrator, on July 29, 1975, is-
sued a notice of intention ‘‘to suspend the registrations and
prohibit the production for use of all pesticides containing
heptachlor or chlordane other than those registrations ex-
empted from the heptachlor/chlordane cancellation order”’
(See 40 F.R. 34456). The notice of suspension also con-
tained detailed findings pertaining to the qvestion of ‘‘im-
minent hazard’’ as required by the act.? On August 6, 1975,
2 As explained in the July 29, 1975 notice, a final order of sus-
pension in this proceeding would not include the suspension of
registrations pending the completion of cancellation proceedings
for use of heptachlor or chlordane in subsurface ground insertion
for termite control and the dipping of roots and tops of nonfood
plants. See 39 F.R. 41298 as clarified (40 F.R. 30522). Also, the
July 29, 1975 notice of suspension permitted, pursuant to section
15(b)(2) of the act (7 U.S.C. 136m(b)(2)) ‘‘continued use of
those existing stocks of EPA registered pesticides containing hep-
tachlor or chlordane which have been formulated as of the date
of this notice.’’
? Section 6(c)(1) of the act provides that ‘‘If the Administrator
determines that action is necessary to prevent an imminent hazard
43
a document entitled ‘‘Clarification of Evidence Which May
Be Introduced in the Hearing On Suspension of Registra-
tions of Pesticides Containing Heptachlor or Chlordane’’
was issued (See 40 F.R. 34455).
Velsicol Chemical Corporation, the sole manufacturer of
the pesticides involved, filed timely objections to the notice
of intention to suspend and prior and subsequent thereto
many other registrants also filed objections. In addition,
the Secretary of Agriculture of the United States, Envi-
ronmental Defense Fund, Louisiana State Pest Control
Association, Mississippi State Pest Control Association,
Florida Nurserymen and Growers Association, Inc., New
England Pest Control Association, Georgia State Pest
Control Association, Long Island Pest Control Associa-
tion, North Carolina Pest Control Association, Alabama
State Pest Control Association, National Pest Control As-
sociation, Inc., United Pesticide Formulators and Distrib-
utors Association, Tennessee Pest Control Association,
Pest Control Operators of California, New Jersey Pest
Control Association, Maryland Pest Control Association,
the State of Hawaii and the Pineapple Growers Associa-
tion of Hawaii, were granted leave to intervene herein pur-
suant to section 164.121(e) of the rules of practice (40
CFR 164.121(e)).
Section 6(c)(1) of the statute further provides that ‘‘No
order of suspension may be issued unless the Administra-
during the time required for cancellation or change in classification
proceedings. he may, by order, suspend the registration of the
pesticide immediately.’’ The term ‘‘imminent hazard’’ is defined to
mean, in part, ‘‘a situation which exists when the continued use of
a pesticide during the time required for cancellation proceeding
would be likely to result in unreasonable adverse effects on the
environment .. .”’ (7 U.S.C. 136(1)). ‘‘Unreasonable adverse
effects on the environment’’ is defined in the act to mean ‘‘any
unreasonable risk to man or the environment, taking into account
the economic, social, and environmental costs and benefits of any
use of any pesticide.’’ (7 U.S.C. 136(bb) ).
44
tor has issued or at the same time issues notice of his inten-
tion to cancel the registration or change the classification
of the pesticide.’’ By order dated November 18, 1974 (39
F.R. 41298), the Administrator stated his notice of intent
‘‘to cancel all registered use of heptachlor and chlordane
... with the exception of the use of heptachlor or chlordane
through subsurface ground insertion for termite control
and the dipping of roots or tops of nonfood plants.’’ Ob-
jections to such notice were filed by Velsicol Chemical Cor-
poration and many additional registrants in 56 separate
proceedings which were consolidated for hearing.
Also on November 18, 1974, the Administrator imple-
mented his authority to register and control intrastate pes-
ticide products with regard to intrastate products contain-
ing heptachlor and chlordane, except those registered for
use in subsurface ground application for termite control or
for dipping of roots or tops of nonfood plants. (39 F.R.
41256). Subsequently, 17 additional proceedings instituted,
in effect, by the filing of objections and requests for hear-
ing by applicants contesting the denial of applications for
registration under the act of pesticide products containing
heptachlor or chlordane and intended for shipment in intra-
state or interstate commerce (see 40 F.R. 22587) were con-
solidated in the heptachlor/chlordane cancellation proceed-
ings (In re Velsicol Chemical Corporation et al., FIFRA
Dockets No. 336 et al.)
On August 4, 1975, Herbert L. Perlman, Chief Admin-
istrative Law Judge, Environmental] Protection Agency,
was appointed the Presiding Officer in the suspension pro-
ceeding. Prehearing conferences were held August 6, 7, and
11, 1975, and the hearing herein commenced August 12,
1975. All the registrants filing objections to the notice of
intention to suspend were consolidated into this proceed-
ing pursuant to section 164.121(f) of the rules of practice.
The Administrator ordered that the hearing herein take no
longer than 40 hearing days unless for good cause shown
45
and upon recommendation of the presiding officer he ex-
tends the hearing for not more than 10 additional hearing
days. The hearing lasted 43 hearing days and the hearing
closed December 4, 1975. The active participants at the
hearing were represented by the following:
Robert L. Ackerly, Charles A. O’Connor ITI, Joe G.
Hollingsworth and John D. Conner, Jr., Attorneys at
Law, Washington, D.C. representing Velsicol Chemical
Corporation and many intervenors and other regis-
trants,
Robert L. Weinberg, David Povich, John G. Kester,
Robert B. Barnett and Kendra Heymann, Attorneys at
Law, Washington, D.C., representing Velsicol Chem-
ical Corporation and several other registrants,
Bernard Lorant, Attorney at Law, Highland Park,
Illinois, and Neil R. Mitchell, Attorney at Law, Chi-
cago, Illinois, representing Velsicol Chemical Corpo-
ration,
Raymond W. Fullerton, Alfred R. Nolting, Margaret
M. Breinholt and Margaret Carlson, Office of the Gen-
eral Counsel, United States Department of Agricul-
ture, representing intervenor Secretary of Agriculture
of the United States,
Jacqueline M. Warren and William A. Butler, Attor-
neys at Law, Washington, D.C., representing inter-
venor Environmental Defense Fund, Inc.,
Clausen Ely, Jr., Attorney at Law, Washington,
D.C., representing intervenors the State of Hawaii and
the Pineapple Growers Association of Hawaii, and
William E. Reukauf, Jeffrey H. Howard, Frank J.
Sizemore, Lee Schroer, Kevin Lee and Thomas O. Mc-
Garity, Office of the General Counsel, Environmental
Protection Agency, representing respondent Assistant
Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency.
46
Subsequent to the close of hearing the parties filed briefs
and I hereby submit my recommended decision within the
exceedingly short period of time provided by the rules of
practice.
Frxpincs or Fact
1. Velsicol Chemical Corporation is a corporation whose
address is 341 East Ohio Street, Chicago, Illinois. Velsicol
Chemical Corporation is the sole manufacturer of hepta-
chlor and chlordane. Velsicol Chemical Corporation and
over approximately 400 other registrants filed objections
and are parties in this proceeding although Velsicol is the
only fully active registrant herein.
2. The intervenors in this suspension proceeding are the
Secretary of Agriculture of the United States, Environ-
mental Defense Fund, Inc., Louisiana State Pest Control
Association, Mississippi State Pest Control Association,
Florida Nurserymen and Growers Association, Inc., New
England Pest Control Association, Georgia State Pest
Control Association, Long Island Pest Control Associa-
tion, North Carolina Pest Control Association, Alabama
State Pest Control Association, National Pest Control As-
sociation,, Inc., United Pesticide Formulators and Dis-
tributors Association, Tennessee Pest Control Association,
Pest Control Operators of California, New Jersey Pest
Control Association, Maryland Pest Control Association,
the State of Hawaii and the Pineapple Growers Associa-
tion of Hawaii. The respondent herein is the Assistant Ad-
ministrator, Environmental Protection Agency.
3. Technical chlordane has been manufactured and sold
commercially since about 1947. Technical chlordane is a
complicated insecticidal mixture of chlorinated hydrocar-
bons. Technical chlordane was arbitrarily named by a joint
meeting of representatives of the United States Depart-
ment of Agriculture, the Food and Drug Administration,
and the 2 manufacturers at that time. The name was chosen
47
on the basis of the belief that this material was composed
principally of two compounds, alpha and gamma-chlordane
(CioHsCls), because these two compounds were initially
isolated in pure form from it. At present (and since about
1950), Velsicol Chemical Corporation is the only commer-
cial producer of technical chlordane. To assure consistency
of performance and biological potential, technical chlor-
dane has been standardized by Velsicol and, since about
1950, varies only within narrow limits in its composition.
The content of each of the chlordane isomers is 13-15 per-
cent and the heptachlor (C:oHsCL;) content is 5-8 percent.
The commercial technical product contains no heptachlor
epoxide. In addition, technical chlordane contains several
isomers of chlordene (C:oHsCle), and nonachlor (C:oH;Cls).
Technical chlordane, a viscous liquid, is a mixture of chlor-
inated hydrocarbons consisting of isomers of chlordane
(1,2,4,5,6,7,8,8-octachloro-4,7-methano-3a,4,7,7a-tetra-hydro-
indane) and closely related compounds in the presence of
minute concentrations of stabilizer (propylene oxide) and
by-products. About one-half of the composition consists of
two major constituents, isomers of chlordane; no other in-
dividual component exceeds about one-tenth of the total
product. Its structure corresponds to the empirical formula
C..HsCls having a molecular weight of 409.8. Some of the
= and chemical properties of chlordane are as fol-
ows:
Appearance: Amber, viscous liquid.
Solubility : Miscible in aliphatic and aromatic solvents;
insoluble in water : low solubility in glycols.
Combustability: Will not burn.
Chemical Stability: Stable to 160 degrees Fahrenheit
in stainless steel, nickel, passive iron, glass and
many other materials. Decomposes at very high tem-
perature. Sensitive to decomposition at elevated
temperatures in the presence of iron and iron oxide
dust.
48
Stability to U.V. light: Stable to U.V. light under nor-
mal conditions. Some components will isomerize un-
der the infiuence of high intensity U.V. light in the
presence of U.V. sensitizers such as ketones.
Odor: Mildly pungent.
Boiling Point: 118° at 0.66 mmHg.
4. Heptachlor has been manufactured since about 1950.
Technical heptachlor is essentially a ternary mixture con-
sisting of heptachlor (73 percent), gamma-chlordane
(about 21 percent) and delta-trichloro-chlordene (nona-
chlor-5 percent); other manufacturing impurities may oc-
casionally be present in concentrations of up to about 2
percent. Heptachlor can be converted to heptachlor epoxide
on plants and by the metabolism of animals. Heptachlor is
the common name which has been assigned to 1,4,5,6,7,8,8-
heptachloro-3a,4,7,7a-tetrahydro-4,7-methanoindene. It has
the empirical formula C..H:Cl:, corresponding to a molecu-
lar weight of 373.5. In pure form, heptachlor is a white
crystalline substance having a melting point of 95° to 96°C.
5. Heptachlor epoxide was found in over 90 percent of
the human adipose tissues analyzed in the National Human
Monitoring Program * at levels ranging from trace to 10.62
ppm with the geometric and arithmetic means ranging for
the 5 year period from 0.08 ppm to 0.09 ppm and from 0.10
ppm to 0.17 ppm, respectively, with trace values listed as
zero. The arithmetic means for each year from and includ-
ing 1970 are, respectively, 0.17, 0.12, 0.12, 0.12 and 0.10 ppm
and the geometric means for each year from and including
1970 are, respectively, 0.09, 0.09, 0.08, 0.09 and 0.08 ppm.
*It must be cautioned that 80 percent of th. samples in this
program are not subjected to confirmation and use of standard
EPA methods may lead to the failure to characterize coextractives
which could increase reported results. We do not now so conclude,
however.
49
Specifically the percent positive samples, and percent trace
samples are as follows :*
Year Percent Positive Percent Trace‘
FY 1970 94.76 3.61
FY 1971 96.23 3.47
FY 1972 90.26 2.86
FY 1973 97.71 1.92
FY 1974 96.33 3.45
The maximums for each of the five years shows a pro-
gressive decrease from 1970-1974 as follows: 10.62, 1.53,
1.21, 0.84 and 0.77 ppm. The mean residue concentrations
of heptachlor epoxide increased with the age of those sam-
pled and the frequency of detecting residues of heptachlor
epoxide also increased with age in every year with the
exception of the data collected during the fiscal year 1974
survey. There is little difference in the frequency of detec-
tion or in residue concentration between males and females
and between Caucasians and Negroes.
6. Oxychlordane was found in over 90 percent of the adi-
pose tissues analyzed in the National Human Monitoring
Program at levels ranging from trace to 1.87 ppm, with
the geometric mean ranging from 0.10 to 0.12"ppm for the
4 year period and the arithmetic mean at 0.15 ppm, with
trace values listed as zero. The percent positive samples
and percent trace samples are as follows:
*The master file of the National Human Monitoring Program
or survey, containing samples in addition to the design file reflected
above, has similar results.
* Percent trace means the percentage of the total number of
samples in which residues of the chemical were found but cannot
be quantified.
50
Year Percent Positive Percent Trace
FY 1971‘ 93.27 0.95
FY 1972 92.29 2.71
FY 1973 98.35 1.01
FY 1974 98.55 1.22
The concentration of oxychlordane in human adipose tissue
increased with age. The variable nature of the residue data
when stratified on a racial basis made trend detection dif-
ficult, although oxychlordane residues were found in high
frequency in tissues taken from both Caucasians and Ne-
groes. Both males and females displayed high frequency
of oxychlordane.
7. A total of 57 human breast milk samples taken in
fiscal year 1974 from 49 women residing in Arkansas and 8
women residing in Mississippi, upon analysis, showed that
quantifiable levels of heptachlor epoxide were found in
35.09 percent of the samples, with arithmetic and geometric
means, with trace values listed as zero, of 0.004 and 0.0017
ppm, respectively, and a range of trace to 0.03 ppm. Quan-
tifiable levels of oxychlordane were found in 45.6 percent
of all samples and the residue levels thereof ranged from
trace to 0.02 ppm with geometric and arithmetic means,
with trace values listed as zero, of 0.0054 ppm. One hun-
dred percent of the milk analyzed contained at least trace
amounts of both heptachlor epoxide and oxychlordane, that
is, a trace of heptachlor epoxide was found in 64.91 percent
* The capability to detect oxychlordane residues in human adipose
tissue was initially introduced into the multi-residue analytical
technique during the fiscal year 1971 survey. The sample size for
1971 oxychlordane analysis is less than for those other chemicals
detectable during the entire year and the results of this survey
year (FY 1971) should not be construed as representative of na-
tional level. The master file has results similar to those set forth
above.
51
of the samples and a trace of oxychlordane was found in
54.39 percent of the samples. A trace represents a positive
finding of residue which cannot be quantified. The presence
of heptachlor epoxide was not confirmed by analytical
techniques although attempts to do so were performed.
8. Heptachlor epoxide crosses the placental barrier and
enters the human fetus. A study of residues of various
chlorinated hydrocarbons in different tissues from still-
born infants found measurable concentrations of hepta-
chlor epoxide in parts per million (ppm) in adipose tissue
(range, 0.07 to 0.51; mean, 0.32), spinal cord (0.13), adren-
als (range, 0.46 to 1.00; mean, 0.73), lungs (range, 0.08 to
0.31; mean, 0.17), heart (range, 0.30 to 1.56; mean, 0.80),
liver (range, 0.03 to 1.67; mean, 0.68), kidney (range, 0.19
to 1.14; mean, 0.70), and spleen (range, 0.10 to 0.52; mean,
0.35). Heptachlor epoxide was identified in the cord blood
of 27 of the 30 newborn infants or normal neonates studied
at leveis from 0.2 to 4.3 ppb with a mean of 1.1 ppb.
9. The Urban Soils Monitoring Program indicates, in
connection with urban and suburban areas, that residues
of chlordane were detected in the soils of all 37 cities sam-
pled between fiscal years 1970 and 1974, heptachlor epoxide
was detected in 28 cities and heptachlor in 13 cities. For
many cities chlordane was detected in approximately 20 to
40 percent of the samples and in several cities heptachlor
epoxide residues were present in 10 to 20 percent of the
soil samples. The arithmetic and geometric means of resi-
due values and the frequency of positive detections of these
chemicals in most of the cities exceed those observed in the
surrounding cropland areas. The majority of occurrences
of residues of these chemicals are on lawn sites as distin-
guished from waste sites of the cities sampled.’ The resi-
* The criteria for defining sites as lawn include mowed grass in
close proximity to a house, factory or other structure, mowed
grass in municipal parks or other town owned or operated land,
garden or cultivated areas and a yard that is in obvious proximity
52
ues are most likely the result of chlordane applications
r control of lawn and garden pests, although some may
sult from chlordane use in structural pest control. The
he\ptachlor epoxide and heptachlor detected probably result
frdm the contamination of technical chlordane with hepta-
chivr. The data from the Urban Monitoring Program indi-
cate that residues of chlordane, heptachlor and heptachlor
epoxide are rather widespread in urban areas, indicating
and wit) particular attention to chlordane, established
pha and gamma isomers of chlordane were pres-
(dry weight)\ As part of the Chester River Study, labora-
tory experiments were performed exposing soft-shelled
clams and oystbrs in a flow-through Baywater system. These
experiments dimonstrated the shellfish readily accumu-
lated chlordane \o high levels from very low concentrations
in the water. en exposed to a level of about 1 part per
trillion in the watkr, the oysters concentrated the chlordane
160,000 times. Uhder similar circumstances, the soft-
shelled clams concehtrated the chlordane 35,000 times. The
chlorinated hydrocarbons were transported adsorbed to the
suspended particulat fraction in the water. The chlori-
nated hydrocarbons ajypeared to be entering the Chester
to a home. Waste areas are\vacant lots where grass is apparently
uncared for, small wooded l\ts, brush or overgrown fields, areas
such as power lines, gas lines\ etc., and exposed soil around con-
struction sites, eroded areas, etc.
53
River from the Bay rather than coming from sources with-
in the Chester River watershed.
11. The findings in the Chester River Study which sug-
gested that the chlorinated hydrocarbons were entering the
River from the Bay led to the Upper Bay Survey (1973 to
1975), a study of the rates, routes, sources, sinks and res-
ervoirs of chlorinated hydrocarbons in the Upper Chesa-
peake Bay. Residues of alpha and gamma chlordane were
found in all of the types of samples analyzed (air, rain-
water, storm-sewer water, zooplankton, suspended sedi-
ments, bottom sediments, and benthic organisms). The sum
of the alpha and gamma isomers of chlordane in the air
samples ranged approximately from 0.5 to 2.0 nanograms
per cubic meters of air.* The chlordane in rainwater ranged
from undetectable (less than 1 part per trillion) to 660
parts per trillion. The chlordane levels in the storm-sewer
water samples from a Baltimore residential area ranged
from undetectable to 97 parts per trillion. The average
chlordane levels found in the other sample types were as
follows: shellfish .060 ppm (wet weight); zooplankton .10
ppm (wet weight); suspended sediments .17 ppm (dry
weight) ; and bottom sediments .016 ppm (dry weight).
12. Relatively high levels of the chlorinated hydrocar-
bons (CHC’s) PCB, chlordane, and DDTR were found in
the samples from the Upper Chesapeake Bay; CHC’s in
bottom sediments from the Bay were two-to-four times
®*The following values are reported as technical chlordane in
order to be comparable to the Chester River Study values. The
chlordane values reported as technical chlordane in the Upper Bay
Survey Report are not directly comparable to those reported in
the Chester River Study Report due to a difference in the method
in comparing the environmental residue peaks to the technical
chlordane standard. In order to compare the technical chlordane
values from the Upper Bay Survey Report to the chlordane values
‘presented in the Chester River Study Report, the technical chlor-
dane values from the Upper Bay Survey must be divided by a
factor of 2.2.
54
higher than found in the Chester River. The bottom sedi-
ments from Baltimore Harbor were found to contain the
greatest amount of the CHC contaminants with values as
high as 3.7 ppm for PCB, .23 ppm for chlordane, and .19
for DDTR. The average concentrations of PCB, chlordane
and DDTR were highest in suspended sediments filtered
from the water in Baltimore Harbor, with high individual
values of 3.8 ppm for PCB, 1.7 ppm for chlordane, and .30
ppm for DDTR being found. When these data are pre-
sented as the amount of CHC present in the watercolumn
on suspended sediment, the average PCB and DDTR val-
ues show a decreasing trend going down the Bay with the
Harbor station not as high (in the case of PCB) or, in the
case of DDTR, about the same as the upper stations. The
chlordane is higher in the Harbor than elsewhere in the
Bay. The highest chlordane value in zooplankton was
found in Baltimore Harbor (.57 ppm), but no one station
had consistently high values of chlordane. A positive corre-
lation was found between the concentration of suspended
sediments in the water and the concentration of CHC’s in
the watercolumn on suspended sediments. A positive cor-
relation was also found between the zooplankton biomass
in the water and the CHC concentration in the watercol-
umn on zooplankton. Apparently, the CHC’s enter the Bay
attached to suspended sediments via the Susquehanna River
during periods of high river-flow. These suspended sedi-
ments appear to function as a reservoir from CHC’s in
the Upper Bay. The principle movement from this reser-
voir probably is into bottom sediments which could be con-
sidered sinks or traps for sediment-adsorbed chlorinated
hvdrocarbons. Resuspension probably represented the
greatest pathway for movement of sediment adsorbed
CHC’s from the sink, although re-working of sediments by
deposit-feeding organisms is a possible route which needs
further stndy. The amount of chlorinated hydrocarbons
passing into the zooplankton community appears limited
only by the zooplankton population density rather than by
55
fluctuations in the reservoir because the amount of CHC
present in the zooplankton standing crop never represents
more than a small fraction of that present in the suspended
sediment reservoir. Another major pathway from the res-
ervoir into the biological system is into the shellfish popu-
lations of the Upper Bay. The chlordane levels in the
brackish-water clam often approach the .30 ppm FDA alert
level for edible shellfish. Baltimore Harbor receives major
inputs of chlorinated hydrocarbons from the inflow of
Chesapeake Bay water and suspended sediment. Baltimore
Harbor receives localized inputs of CHC’s but probably
does not serve as a major source of CHC’s to the Bay
although the chlordane level in the suspended sediment res-
ervoir in the Harbor appears ‘‘enriched’’ compared to that
in the Bay.
13. The primary monitoring program for pesticide resi-
dues in the nation’s food supply are conducted by the
United States Food and Drug Administration and the
United States Department of Agriculture. There are three
major programs. The Food and Drug Administration has
two of these. One program, described as the surveillance
program, examines large numbers of samples of different
foods obtained when lots are shipped in interstate com-
merce. The other, known as the Total Diet Program, exam-
ines food prepared to be eaten. As a part of the surveil-
lance program, the U.S. Department of Agriculture ana-
lyzes samples of meats and poultry obtained from process-
ing plants throughout the United States. These three pro-
grams comprise the National Pesticide Monitoring Pro-
gram on Foods. The primary objective of the surveillance
program on raw agricultural products by the Food and
Drug Administration and the surveillance program on raw
meats and poultry by the Department of Agriculture is to
determine compliance with tolerances. The primary ob-
jective of the Total Diet Program is to estimate the dietary
intake of pesticide chemicals.
56
14. Heptachlor-heptachlor epoxide residues appear
most frequently in foods of animal origin, that is, dairy
products, meat, fish and poultry. Based on the total diet
program, the percent incidence of heptachlor-heptachlor
epoxide in all food classes has remained relatively un-
changed for the 1965-1974 period, but the calculated daily
intake in mg/kg body weight has gradually but steadily
declined during the same period. The food residue levels
of heptachlor, heptachlor epoxide and chlordane are low.
Heptachlor-heptachlor epoxide residues represent 0.8 to
2.0 percent of the ADI for 1970-1974. Chlordane residues
comprise less than 1/100 of 1 percent of the ADI. However,
chlordane findings in the surveillance program, although
still low, have increased recently due perhaps to improved
analytical techniques but more likely due to the recent in-
crease in the use of chlordane in agriculture.
15. Chlordane is a commonly used insecticide in agricul-
ture, industry, and the home, lawn and garden. About 21
million pounds were used in the United States during 1974.
Data provided by Velsicol Chemical Corporation indicate
the following approximate breakdown for chlordane use in
1973 and 1974:
Mil. Ib. Percent
Use 1973 1974 1973 1974
Corn 1.94 4.32 10.8 20.4
Potatoes 0.98 1.11 5.5 5.2
Other vegetables 0.06 0.07 0.3 0.3
Home lawn and garden 5.77 6.33 32.1 29.9
Turf 1.14 1.25 6.3 5.9
Strawberries 0.15 0.17 0.8 0.8
Tomatoes 0.30 0.33 1.7 1.6
Ornamentals 0.23 0.25 1.3 1.2
PCO 7.41 7.34 41.2 34.7
Total 17.98 21.18 100.0 100.0
57
The proposed suspension covers about two-thirds of total
chlordane use (65.3 percent in 1974), not counting some
PCO use which might also be covered.
16. Chlordane is a leading insecticide in the United
States, although it accounts for less than six percent of
total U.S. insecticide use. It is widely used in the home and
garden and industrial/commercial use areas, where in
1972 it ranked number 1 in each use with about 23 and 30
percent of U.S. use in those respective categories as indi-
cated below:
Amount Used
All
Use insecticides Chlordane
Mil. lbs. Mil. lbs. Percent
Agriculture 218.9 3.0 1.4
Home and garden 21.8 5.0 22.9
Governmental 7.0 ~ 0.5 7.1
Industrial/ commercial 21.5 6.5 30.2
Overall 269.2 15.0 5.5
17. According to USDA surveys, crop uses of chlordane
account for 70 to 85 percent of agricultural use of chlordane
in the United States and protection of corn from attack by
soil insects accounts for more than one half of agricultural
* use. There is no trend shown in the USDA surveys as to
changes in percentage breakdown among general types of
agricultural uses. However, there appears to be a trend
toward increased use of chlordane in agriculture generally,
inasmuch as the 1971 use level of nearly 1.9 million pounds
was more than three times that for 1964 and 1966, and
more recent estimates by Velsicol indicate that approxi-
mately 6 million pounds were used in agriculture during
1974. The suspension of aldrin/dieldrin will increase de-
mand for chlordane, along with other substitutes, leading to
increased production and use of chlordane beginning in
58
1975 or 1976. Government agencies use significant amounts
of chlordane. Annual use of chlordane has been estimated
at 0.5 million pounds for federal, state and municipal
agencies.
18. Heptachlor is used in a much smaller volume than
chlordane (about 2 million pounds in 1974 compared with
21 million for chlordane) and is used in fewer types of
applications. Data provided by Velsicol Chemical Corpora-
tion indicate the following approximate breakdown for use
in 1973 and 1974:°
Mil lb. Percent
Use 1973 1974 1973 1974
Corn 1.13 1.19 57.4 58.0
Seed dressing 0.19 0.27 96 13.2
PCO 0.61 0.55 31.0 26.8
Fire ants, misc. 0.032 0.04 1.6 2.0
Total 1.97 2.05 100.0 100.0
About three-fourths of heptachlor is devoted to agricultural
use, and that is largely for corn soil treatments. Corn ac-
counted for 91 percent of agricultural] heptachlor use in
1971, according to USDA’s survey. The remainder was di-
vided among several other crop uses (e.g., alfalfa, other
hay and pasture and vegetables). Heptachlor is not used in
connection with livestock producton as is chlordane. Agri-
cultural use of heptachlor is largely in the Corn Belt states,
with some use in the Lake States and the Northern Plains.
Heptachlor, with agricultural use of about 1.2 million
pounds in the early 1970’s, equals about 0.5 percent of U.S.
agricultural use of insecticides (more than 200 million
* The ‘‘Fire ant, mise.’’ category of use in the above table in-
cludes use on pineapple, which is estimated at about 10,000 pounds
annually. Velsicol Chemical Corporation also indicates that there
may be several thousand pounds of henrtachlor used on citrus to
replace suspended aldrin use in Florida.
59
pounds as of 1972). The PCO use estimate for 1974 of more
than 550,000 pounds equals less than 3 percent of U:S.
industrial/commercial use (approximately 21.5 million lbs.
in 1972).
19. Corn is subject to attack by a wide variety of insects
including corn rootworms, wireworms, and cutworms for
which chlordane/heptachlor has often been recommended
in the past. Chlordane and/or heptachlor have registrations
under the act for use against these pests and a number of
other lesser economic corn pests, Chlordane and heptachlor
are not generally recommended for use against rootworms
because resistance has developed. These chemicals are gen-
erally recommended by entomologists in the states for use
against wireworms and cutworms. The States of Illinois
and Iowa do not recommend pre-plant treatment of insecti-
cides against the cutworm and do not recommend hepta-
chlor or chlordane for this purpose. Chlordane and hepta-
chlor together are used on about 2.6 million acres of corn
in the United States as of 1975 (3.5 percent of total corn
acreage). They are used on about 27,000 farms equalling
about 3 percent of commercial corn farms in the United
States.
20. Chlordane is used on about 1.2 million acres of corn
equalling 1.6 percent of U.S. corn acreage and on about
12,000 farms equalling 1.3 percent of U.S. commercial corn
farms as of 1975. Heptachlor is used on about 1.4 million
acres of corn equalling 1.9 percent of U.S. corn acreage
and on about 15,500 farms equalling 1.7 percent of U.S.
commercial corn farms. With suspension of aldrin, the use
of aldrin declined from 9.6 percent of U.S. commercial corn
acreage in 1973/74 (average of 2 years) to 3.3 percent in
1975. Chlordane use increased to some extent (from 1.3
percent to 1.6 percent of U.S. corn acreage in 1975) while
heptachlor use increased somewhat more sharply, from 1.2
percent to 1.9 percent of U.S. corn acreage. Aldrin will no
longer be available. Total acreage of corn treated with in-
60
secticides in the United States declined from 27.9 million
in 1973/74 (average of 2 years) to 26.2 million in 1975 even
though commercial corn acreage in the U.S. increased
nearly 3 million acres. This decline in insecticide use may
be associated with the aldrin suspension as aldrin use has
declined from near 7 million acres in 1973/74 to near 2.5
million acres in 1975. Two-thirds of the corn grown in the
United States is not treated with any insecticide including
both soil and foliar applications. Most corn farms do not
use insecticides of any type in the production of corn (more
than 75 percent in 1975).
21. Several organophosphate and carbamate alternatives
to chlordane/heptachlor for control of corn soil insects are
in widespread use in the United States as of 1975. Alterna-
tives for rootworms and wireworms are used much more
frequently than for cutworms. Diazinon, the only recom-
mended pre-emergence alternative for cutworms, is used on
only 0.4 percent of corn acreage and rescue baits are used
on limited acreage. The leading states in use of chlordane/
heptachlor as of 1975 based on percentage of corn acreage
treated with these chemicals were: Missouri, 12.1; Illinois,
6.6; Indiana, 6.2; Iowa, 4.2; Ohio, 3.4; and Minnesota, 0.8
percent. Aldrin was used quite heavily in several of the
corn states in 1975 (in terms of the percentage of corn
acreage treated): Missouri, 17.9 percent; Indiana, 7.9 per-
cent; Ohio, 7.2 percent; Illinois, 5.0 percent; and Iowa, 3.3
percent. Missouri is by far the heaviest user of organo-
chlorines with 30 percent of commercial corn acreage so
treated in 1975. The next ranking state was far below (In-
diana with 14.1 percent). The number of commercial corn
farms in the United States dropped from near 970,000 in ©
1973/74 to slightly under 900,000 in 1975, even though total
corn acreage increased by more than 2 million acres. Farms
using insecticides are larger acreage corn farms than non-
users. This is true of organochlorines as well as other in-
secticides. Corn insecticide expenditures totalled nearly
61
$105.7 million in 1975, up considerably from $78.7 million
in 1973/74. Average expenditure per treatment acre was
$4.04 in 1975 compared with $2.82 per acre in 1973/74.
Organochlorine treatments are less expensive than organ-
ophosphate and carbamate insecticides.
22. Cutworms are the primary corn soil insect pest for
which chlordane and heptachlor are recommended to main-
tain yields. They are seldom recommended for rootworms.
For wireworms many alternatives are recommended. Cut-
worm infestations in corn are highly variable from year to
year. Since 1969 the number of farms reporting cutworms
as a major problem has varied from 19,000 to 71,000 in
the United States with an overall average of about 53,000.
This equals about 2 to 8 percent of U.S. corn farms. The
percentage of these farms treating for cutworms during
that period ranged from 52 to 71 percent with an overall
average of 61 percent. The number of farms treating dur-
ing 1969 to 1975 averaged about 32,000 and ranged from
13,000 to 48,000. The extrem» variability in cutworm infes-
tations frustrates attempts to project economic thresholds
for treatment. It is extremely difficult to determine in the
spring whether pre-plant treatment would be justified ex-
cept in high risk fields which have a history of cutworm
problems. Rescue bait and spray treatments must be de-
pended upon when there has been no pre-plant treatment
or pre-plant treatment has failed in the face of an outbreak.
The use of rescue bait and spray treatment requires scout-
ing techniques during the critical time when corn is subject
to cutworm damage after emergence from the soil. Scout-
ing is useful even with pre-plant treatment because such
treatments at times fail. Rescue treatments for cutworms
such as sevin (carbaryl) and dylox (trichlorfon) are in the
same cost range as chlordane/heptachlor. These rescue
treatments can be less expensive than broadcast aldrin or
chlordane/heptachlor treatment. They are not applied un-
less needed, which lowers costs to the farmer. However,
equipment costs may be a factor. Scouting can, in many
62
cases, be accomplished in connection with other field opera-
tions, such as cultivation and routine observation of grow-
ing crops. Trained scouts working under a pest manage-
ment project in Illinois in 1974 cost $0.55 per scouted acre
for the season plus an additional $0.44 for computer and
other support, bringing total costs to $0.99 per acre.
23. The existence and responsibilities of the Plant Pro-
tection and Quarantine Programs (PPQ) of the United
States Department of Agriculture are provided for by con-
gressional acts and by delegations made by the Secretary
of Agriculture. The Plant Protection and Quarantine Pro
grams operate under the following acts: (1) The Plant
Quarantine Act, (2) The Federal Plant Pest Act, (3) Or-
ganic Act of September 21, 1944, (4) Mexican Border Act,
(5) Terminal Inspection Act, (6) Mexican Pink Bollworm
Act, (7) Incipient or Emergency Control of Pests, (8) The
Golden Nematode Act, and (9) Cooperation with States
Act. The acts provide the Secretary of Agriculture with
authority to: (1) establish restrictive and prohibitory
quarantines and regulations against imports likely to be
the means of introducing plant pests not known to be
present or widely distributed in the United States; (2)
establish quarantines and regulations to carry out cooper-
ative Federal-State-Mexican programs for suppression, con-
trol, or eradication measures against designated plant pests
which become established in the United States or Mexico;
and (3) provide export certification of domestic plants and
plant products when requested by interested shippers and
parties.
24. A quarantine is a restriction imposed by duly-con-
stituted authorities whereby the production, movement, or
existence of plants, plant products, animals, animal prod-
ucts, or any other article or material or the normal activity
of persons are brought under regulation, to prevent or
limit the introduction or spread of a pest, or to control or
eradicate a pest already introduced, thereby reducing or
63
avoiding losses that would otherwise occur through damage
done by the pest or through costs of continuing control
measures.
25. The most significant uses by USDA for chlordane are
those involving soil insects under Federal-domestic quaran-
tines. The Plant Protection and Quarantine Programs staff
of the Department has quarantine regulations which re-
quire treatments, including soil treatments, with chlordane
for the Japanese beetle and the imported fire ant.
26. A nationwide survey is carried on each year for the
Japanese beetle in the noninfested portions of the infested
States and in all other noninfested States, with the excep-
tions of Alaska and Hawaii. Typically, those infestations
found outside of the area of natural spread of the pest are
delimited and control measures applied. The most effective
adulticide is carbaryl and the only effective and available
larvacide is chlordane. Each infestation is evaluated and,
if warranted, the Federal quarantine is extended to cover
the area of infestation where control measures are not
taken or a suppressive area is designated in those cases
where suppression or eradication treatments are being
applied. If Federal and/or State regulations are imposed
on a geographic area, regulated industry is notified and
appropriate certification treatments must be applied.
27. For the Japanese beetle, the movement of nursery
stock is considered one of the most hazardous articles mov-
ing in interstate commerce. Treatments are available to
allow movement of plant material not previously treated
to meet certification requirements. The most commonly
used treatment is either a dip or injection treatment using
ethylene dibromide or ethylene dibromide chlordane. This
type treatment is an individual plant treatment which is
time-consuming, laborious, and costly. The normal se-
quence of events in applying certification treatments to
field-grown nursery stock is to apply a granular formula-
64
tion of a residual pesticide to ground that had been plowed
and disked. After application, the material is disked into
the top 3 inches of soil. Three-year certification is obtained
by such a treatment. In the case of plant species which are
not harvested during a 3-year period, growers often wait
until the second or third year after planting and apply
chlordane to planted nursery stock free of weeds and follow
this application by normal cultivation. In the case of pot
or container grown nursery stock, the potting soil is nor-
mally fumigated or heat-treated to kill all existing insect
life forms as well as weed seeds and other organisms, and
the chlordane is added in prescribed amounts to act as a
residual insecticide until such container grown stock is
sold and moved from the regulated area.
28. Another important method of long distance artificial
spread of the Japanese beetle is by aircraft and railroad
cars. For some unknown reason, Japanese beetle adults
are attracted to aircraft, especially jet-powered aircraft.
The large sodded areas of airports are ideal sites for J ap-
anese beetles to deposit their eggs and build up to tre-
mendous populations. Two methods are available to reduce
this hazard of artificial spread. If the beetles occur in haz-
ardous numbers and are, in fact, present in airplanes
destined for points outside the regulated area, a treatment
is available using micronized DDT-carbaryl dust on the
interior of the airplane and baggage compartments. This
has not been necessary at many airports in the infested
area because residual treatments with chlordane and other
chlorinated hydrocarbon pesticides have been applied to
the turf areas on and around the airport. Retreatment with
chlordane may again be necessary. During the early 1970’s,
milky spore disease was distributed on areas either not
previously treated with a chlorinated hydrocarbon or where
such treatments were no longer effective. The milky spore
treatments have not yet proved effective in reducing popu-
lations to nonhazardous levels.
65
material currently authorized by the U.S.
pies 7 Agriculture for certification treatments of
nursery stock and the regulated items involving soil is
chlordane under the Japanese beetle quarantine. The ma-
jor substiute materials cited by the Environmental Pro-
tection Agency may not be suitable substitutes for soil
application for Janpanese beetle quarantine purposes.
, transporting of nursery stock and certain other
a prem bone mater is also a method of artificial spread
of the imported fire ant. The Plant Protection and Quar-
antine Programs Regulatory Manual currently lists only
chlordane or chlordane in association with mirex as a reg-
ulatory treatment for sod, nursery stock with soil, and sim-
ilar items. At this time, there are no alternative treatments
available for residual protection against imported fire ants.
Treatments of potting soil, nursery stock, or grass sod areas
for imported fire ant regulatory purposes are applied in
the same manner as the Japanese beetle treatments. After
an exposure period of 30 to 60 days, the soil or plants
growing therein are certifiable for 1 to 3 years.
31. The black vine weevil is a serious pest of the Japa-
nese yew. The larvae are of particular concern since they
destroy the root system of the host resulting in death of
the plant. Severe damage to the root system may occur be-
fore an infestation is evidenced to the untrained eye. When
nursery stock inspected under the State of Michigan s in-
spection and quarantine authority is found to be infested,
movement or sale is not permitted. The J apanese yew, due
to its many varieties, persistent green foliage, hardiness,
and soil and light intensity adaptability, is the most popu-
lar ornamental evergreen planted in the Lake States and
the Northeast. Millions are planted around homes, in parks
and in industrial landscapes.
32. The black vine weevil is the most destructive and dif-
ficult to control of Japanese yew pests. The weevil spreads
primarily through the movement of infested nursery stock ;
66
therefore, adequate inspection of nurseries to detect incip-
ient infestations and restrictions on movement of infested
plants are highly important. It is also important that a
means of eliminating infestations in nurseries and orna-
mental plantings be available. Currently, chlordane is the
only means of contro] recommended by the Michigan Ag-
ricultural Experiment Station. The recommendation is for
the application of one pound of actual chlordane in 100
gallons of water as a drenching spray to plants and the soil
surface beneath. On the average, such an application would
require 200 gallons of the dilute spray or two pounds of
chlordane per acre. Granular formulations are not recom-
mended because they have not proven effective. Without
chlordane, nurserymen in Michigan having infested and
restricted fields of Japanese yews will have no alternative
but to absorb a total loss. Presently, an acre of the Japa-
nese yews, 18-inch to 24-inch grade, has a conservative
wholesale market value of $20,000. During the last nine
years, the Michigan Department of Agriculture has re-
stricted more than 389 acres of yews from sale or move-
ment until weevil infestations were eliminated and certifi-
cation was possible.
33. The nursery industry includes wholesale growing op-
erations, landscape firms and retail garden centers. Retail
sales of the nursery industry for 1971 were $2.1 billion and
the wholesale value of these sales was $700 million. In that
year expenditures for chemical pesticides used by the in-
dustry including insecticides, herbicides and fungicides was
$14.8 million. Additional pesticides were purchased, but
these were for resale at garden centers. Most pesticide use
is at the grower or wholesale level. Pesticide expenditure
as a percent of sales to growers was 2.1 percent in 1971.
A summary of state recommendations for 15 states indi-
cates that chlordane is recommended for relatively few
ornamental insect pest combinations. In several states, it is
recommended for only one pest of ornamentals. However,
67
there are some problems with ornamental pests like the
black vine weevil for which chlordane is recommended and
for which alternatives are limited.
34. A native of Argentina, Chile, and Uruguay, the white-
fringed beetle was first detected in Okaloosa County, Flor-
ida, in 1936, in a peanut field. The following year damaging
populations were found around Florala, Alabama. White-
fringed beetle larvae so ravaged crops in the limited areas
of its distribution in the mid- to late 1930’s, that a federal
domestic plant quarantine was enacted in 1939 and contin-
ued through June 1975 in hopes of stopping the spread of
this insect. Despite these efforts, the insect has continued,
and will continue to expand its geographic distribution.
25. Three species of whitefringed beetles, Graphognathus
peregrinus Buch., G. minor Buch., and G. leucoloma Buch.
and 5 subspecies have been identified in the United States.
Based on limited data, the species appear to be biologically
and ecologically similar. All insects examined have been
females; thus parthenogenesis (development of the egg
without male fertilization) is the mode of reproduction.
The insects are univoltine (1 generation/year). Larvae
overwinter in the soil, moving closer to the soil surface in
spring as they become more active and require more food
when temperatures rise. It is during this period that dam-
age to crops planted in the spring, begins to occur. Larvae
feed on germinating seeds, on roots, and on underground
stems of young plants. Pupation begins at the end of April,
reaching a peak during the first 2 weeks of July, depending
on geographical location. Eggs are deposited primarily at
the point of contact between the soil and objects such as
sticks, gravel, and plant stems. The incubation period for
eggs oviposited in mid-July to late August averages 14.7
days. Emerging first instar larvae enter the soil and repeat
the above described cycle.
i i this
36. During the fall, larvae are quite small, and for
reason, damage to the root systems of small grains planted
68
in fall for pasture or seed has been considered insignifi-
cant. This belief was shown to be erroneous. Wet weight
yields of Elbon rye harvested in spring were reduced about
50 percent by whitefringed beetle larvae. It is because of
their relatively small size during the fall that larvae go
undetected even as land is disked after harvest. The larvae
continue to develop unheeded until spring when their in-
creased size may give away their presence during soil prep-
aration for planting. It is at this time or during planting
that contro] measures are instituted. The organochlorine
group of insecticides are extremely effective against white-
fringed beetle larvae when applied during this period. This
is true even though these insects are approaching the com-
pletion of their larval development, and, as a general rule,
the efficiency of insecticides applied against immature stages
of insects decreases as the insect approaches maturity. The
organochlorine group of insecticides, and particularly chlor-
dane, have had no difficulty in controlling larvae of white-
fringed beetle at this difficult-to-control developmental
stage. When chlordane is applied at rates of 2.5 to 5 pounds
Al/acre ‘‘broadcast’’ protection is extended during the ovi-
position period of the current year, thus reducing the prob-
ability of re-establishment by newly emerging larvae. Al-
ternatively, chlordane may be used to treat rows to be
planted. A ‘‘broadcast’’ treatment may be residually ef-
fective for as long as 3 years while a row treatment normal-
ly will retain its effectiveness for one year. This method of
control is the only chemical treatment method available. No
alternate insecticide is labelled for control of whitefringed
beetle larvae. Alternate methods of control, both chemical
and nonchemical, are not currently available as a practical
matter.
37. Currently, the whitefringed beetle is distributed
throughout Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Missis-
sippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee. Its
greatest infestation is in Alabama, Georgia, and Florida.
69
The extent of infestation of whitefringed beetle larvae is
very difficult to predict and predictions must be based sole-
ly upon previous occurrences. The whitefringed beetle at-
tacks practically all field and garden crops. The adult beetle
feeds upon the leaves of plants. The adults do not account
for a significant amount of economic damage. The larvae,
however, are known to feed upon 385 species of plants dis-
tributed in 41 plant orders. All significant economic dam-
age is done by the larvae. The larvae eat portions of the
soft outer root layer and underlying tissues and may com-
pletely sever the main root of the plant. This is particularly
common when the beetle attacks small seedling plants. Se-
vere injury to the root system causes the plant to yellow,
wilt, and die.
38. The reproductive potential of the whitefringed beetle
is very great. Adult beetles may crawl as far as one-fourth
mile in their lifetime. The beetles lay eggs from five to
twenty-five days after they emerge. The egg-laying period
ranges from 30 to 60 days. Adults may live as long as 150
days after emergence, but most die within 90 days. Eggs
are deposited in masses of up to 60, but the usual mass con-
tains from 11 to 14. The average length of the larval period
is about 10 or 11 months. Some of the larvae hatch in one
year. Some do not pupate during the summer of the first
year and carry over to the next summer. Larvae generally
hatch from eggs in August or September and become adults
between May 25th and September 6th of the following year.
39. The peanut industry is the most important agricul-
tural industry in the Alabama and Georgia area, and in the
peanut production area of Florida. During the 1975-1976
growing season 200,000 acres of peanuts will be planted in
Alabama, 520,000 acres in Georgia, and 55,000 acres in Flor-
ida. Total crop values in these states are estimated during
that season to total $86 million in Alabama, $302 million in
Georgia, and $25 million in Florida. The 1974 Georgia pea-
nut yield was more than 1,670,000,000 pounds which consti-
70
tuted 40 percent of the peanut production in the United
States. During the 1975-1976 growing season, approximate
totals of 20,000 acres in Alabama, 26,000 acres in Georgia,
and 10,000 acres in Florida of peanuts will be infested with
the whitefringed beetle, causing economic loss. Of these,
15,000 acres in Alabama and 13,000 acres in Georgia will not
be treated with chlordane even if available. A reason for
the increased destruction by the whitefringed beetle is the
effective weed control methods which have been developed
in the Southeastern United States. Because herbicides are
increasingly effective in destroying weeds which grow in
peanut fields, the peanut plant becomes its only host. It is
very difficult to predict accurately the level of infestation in
any given area. In Alabama, it is recommended that growers
treat only those fields, or portions of fields, where infesta-
tion by adult beetles is present.
40. Between 12,000 and 15,000 people are directly involved
in the growing of peanuts in Georgia. Peanuts are by far
the most important crop in Georgia. Many related indus-
tries, in the supply, processing and distribution phases,
are dependent upon the peanut harvest. Thousands of jobs
depend upon the crop. Many small towns survive because
of the peanut industry. The peanut crop, according to the
best estimates available, will significantly increase in 1975.
Chlordane and heptachlor are not cited as a recommended
treatment for peanuts in Georgia and Virginia, which states
account for nearly one half of U.S. peanut production, ac-
cording to 1975 recommendations. In Georgia, ‘‘insurance”’
treatment with any insecticide is not recommended. If white-
fringed beetle problems emerge, growers are encouraged to
check with their county agent.
41. The value to Georgia, in terms of income, acreage
and yield, of some of the other crops which may be attacked
by the whitefringed beetle is as follows:
71
Crop Acreage Yield Income
Tobacco 75,000 167,625,000 lbs. § $176,519,000
Corn 1,880,000 105,230,000 bu. 171,100,000
Cotton 410,000 200,900,999 lbs. 57,796,000
Soybeans 1,010,000 25,755,000 bu. 161,826,000
Approximately 12,000 to 15,000 persons are directly in-
volved with the Georgia tobacco industry. An equal number
grow cotton. As many as thirty to forty thousand Georgia
citizens grow corn, and an equal number grow soybeans.
As with peanuts, thousands of workers are employed in
related supply, processing and distribution industries. In
addition, truck crops. produce an annual income of more
than $76,000,000 in Georgia, but no acreage or yield esti-
mates are available. Chlordane may be used in the planting
of all of these crops in much the same way it is used to
treat peanut. acreage. The soil is treated before planting.
However, diazinon may be used in the treatment of tobacco.
Diazinon can be mixed with the water used in the trans-
planting of the tobacco plant. Diazinon is effective for a
shorter period of time than chlordane.
42. Florida produces over 75 percent of the United States’
supply of citrus, which represents approximately 28 per-
cent of the world’s supply. Citrus is grown on 877,000 acres
and is by far the most important agricultural commodity
grown in the State of Florida. Florida citrus has an annual
value of near one billion dollars.
43. There are 7 weevils considered pests of citrus in
Florida, all but one having in common an immature stage
that feeds on citrus tree roots. The exception, the Coffee
Bean Weevil, Araecerus fascilculatus (DeGeer), attacks the
fruit itself. The 6 root-feeding pests of Florida citrus are
the Little Leaf Notcher, Artipus floridanus (Horn), the 2
Citrus Root Weevils, Pachnaeus litus (Germar) and P. opa-
72
lus (Olivier), the Fuller Rose Beetle, Pantomorous cervinus
(Boh.), the West Indian Sugarcane Stalk Borer Weevil,
Diaprepes abbreviatus L., and Tanymechus lacaena
(Hbst.,), a species lacking a common name. The Little Leaf
Notcher was first reported on limes on the Florida Keys
and is now distributed along the east coast as far north as
Merritt Island. The Citrus Root Weevils have been associ-
ated with citrus in Florida for over a century. Prior to 1885,
P. opalus adults were caught in great numbers on the Keys
and by 1966 had been collected in 21 counties. P. litus distri-
bution was reported in 1825 as ranging from Cuba to Flor-
ida and by 1966 had been collected in 21 Florida counties.
Immatures were identified in the soil in 1915. Fuller Rose
Beetle was recognized as a pest of Florida citrus in 1952
when large numbers were observed in several groves in In-
dian River and St. Lucie counties. Since that time, this pest
has been collected from 30 counties in the State. The West
Indian Sugarcane Stalk Borer Weevil is the most recent
intruder, being found initially in 1964 and becoming estab-
lished in 1969 near Apopka, Florida, where it was confined
until recently within a 16,000-acre quarantine zone regulat-
ed by the U.S.D.A. and the Florida Department of Agri-
culture and Consumer Services.” Tanymechus lacaena was
first recorded for Florida in 1921 and has only posed an
occasional problem in newly set groves.
44. The life cycle of all 6 root feeding species adheres to
the 4-stage pattern inherent in beetles: the egg, larva, pupa,
and adult. Eggs are deposited above ground and larvae
*° Chlordane and heptachlor are not registered for control of the
West Indian Sugarcane Stalk Borer Weevil, and, therefore, their
use to contro] this insect is beyond the scope of this proceeding.
Some question exists as to whether these insecticides are registered
for use against the Fuller Rose Beetle, apparently the major soil
pest of citrus, although they were used for this purpose. This need
be resolved by administrative officials. To place matters in per-
spective, it should be stated at this point that the Fuller Rose
Beetle is a minor pest of citrus.
73
enter the soil to feed on roots. Pupation occurs in the soil
and adults emerge from the soil to remain above ground
feeding on foliage, mating, and laying eggs. All 6 species
are presently considered univoltine: producing but one
generation per year. The adults feed on the young leaves of
citrus and, when in great numbers, cause serious setback
of young trees. With the exception of Tanymechus, for
which no observations are recorded, adults also feed on the
flowers and on rind of young fruit, resulting in peel scars
when the fruit matures. Occasionally, young shoots are de-
voured. The most serious injury by the pests is produced
by the larvae which destroy the plant roots. Affected trees
have sparse foliage that may become chlorotic and wilt.
When larvae are numerous, young plants may be killed in
a short time or dwarfed; older trees are more resistant, but
do not grow well, are unthrifty in appearance, become poor
yielders of fruit, and occasionally die. Sinee the damage
caused by the larvae takes place underground, it often re-
mains unnoticed until the plants start to wither and ‘die
black.’
45. A variety of methods, including mechanical control,
biological control, chemical control, and cultural practices
have been attempted over the years to control the Fuller
Rose Beetle. Methods such as hand picking egg masses and
adults, trunk banding and such practices as root barring
were of temporary value and required continuous surveil-
lance. Chemical control required 4 to 6 foliar applications
to achieve season-long control. No method gave the control
of the weevil pests provided by soil application of the in-
secticides chlordane or heptachlor. The ea gsm pro-
gram today for controlling the citrus weevil complex is
a soil pec sar with chlordane or heptachlor and is based
on the fact that adults must, when emerging from the soil,
pass through the toxic barrier created at the soil surface
upon application of these insecticides. Newly hatched larvae
may also be killed when attempting to enter the treated
soil. Although 2 distinct periods of peak emergence occur
74
in the spring and fall, adult weevils will emerge from the
soil throughout the year in Florida.
46. Florida’s integrated pest control programs utilize a
combination of both biological as well as chemical methods
to control citrus pest infestations. The biological control
consists of several parasitic and predatory insect species
which have been introduced into the citrus groves. These
predatory insects control aphids and scale insects. The pur-
ple scale was at one time Florida’s number one pest in cit-
rus. Soil applications of chlordane or heptachlor do not
harm the beneficial predatory and parasitic insects. The
only alternative to soil applications of chlordane or hepta-
cblor is multiple foliar spraying to kill adult beetles. This
would require 4 to 7 foliar spray applications of insecticides
per year. Soil applications of chlordane or heptachlor on
the other hand are only required every two to three years
for the same control. The increased foliar applications
would be disruptive to the Florida citrus integrated pest
control program. The foliar applications required would
kill the beneficial parasitic wasps which have been intro-
duced into Florida’s citrus groves. These wasps are today
relied upon heavily for the control of scales and mites. The
introduction of these beneficial insects have greatly reduced
the use of pesticides in citrus cultivation. Scale insects,
which are under biological contro] as a result of these intro-
duced predators and parasites, could once again become se-
rious economic pests with their natural enemies killed off
by frequent foliar pesticide applications.
47. Without an effective soil insecticide, the only option
for beetle control is increased spraying of organophosphates
to control adult beetles as they migrate from the soil to the
foliage of trees. This option would probably not provide
the same level of control. Soil insecticides provide maximum
protection to citrus groves by interrupting the life cycle
as the larvae migrate to the soil and by providing control
over the number of adults who can move from the soil back
75
to the foliage. Foliar sprays can be effective in reducing
the adult beetle population at the time of application and
shortly thereafter; however, because of the variability of
the life cycle of the target insects, quarterly foliar applica-
tions would probably be required. In this event, the entire
spray schedule would have to be restructured together with
modifications in the current biological control programs.
48. If left uncontrolled, the damage caused by the Fuller
Rose Beetle could be severe with impacts distributed un-
evenly across the citrus growing regions of Florida. Citrus
District Five, made up of Atlantic Coast counties including
Brevard, Indian River, St. Lucie, Martin, Palm Beach, Bro-
ward, Dade, and portions of Volusia is characterized by
groves planted on artificially constructed beds, surrounded
by draining ditches, which were once partial swamp land.
High water tables limit the depth of the root systems; 90
percent of the roots are often concentrated in the top 18
inches of soil. In the central part of Florida, citrus roots
can penetrate up to twenty feet and average twelve to six-
teen feet. In the coastal counties, a greater portion of the
root system is available for larvae feeding. Thus, the same
level of beetle infestation can result in greater damage for
these trees than for inland groves. Disking in the inland
groves to a depth of 6 inches around the trees may interrupt
the pupation stage of the beetle thereby providing marginal,
non-chemical control. In the coastal regions, disking to this
depth would severely damage the root system. Without cul-
tivation, grass and weeds compete with the tree for avail-
able moisture. For this reason, coastal groves are more
susceptible to drought which in turn exerts a stress on the
tree and leaves it more susceptible to damage by any factor
that reduces the root system.
49. Without adequate control of root feeding beetles, cit-
rus production in coastal counties could prove unprofitable
for many groves. Using treatment history as a base to de-
fine infested acres (and assuming that treatment is made
76
every three to five years), 25 percent of Florida’s East
Coast county citrus acreage could be subject to root damage
if adequate control of soil beetles is unavailable. As a per-
centage of total Florida citrus, this coastal county acreage
would affect approximately 6 percent of current citrus pro-_
duction (1972 base).
50. Because of an inelastic demand for citrus at the farm
level, the market impact of a decrease in production would
be an increase in farm level income to citrus growers in
the aggregate. However, due to the greater potential for
insect damage in the East Coast region, these growers could
be subject to income reductions if an adequate control agent
is not available. Due to currently low income levels and a
lack of alternative employment, a significant production de-
cline would cause significant social impacts.
51. In 1976, about 8,000,000 new citrus trees will be plant-
ed in Florida. This planting will be for the purpose of re-
placing dying trees as well as starting new groves. Areas
of new planting in Florida may be subject to subterranean
termite attack. Chlordane or heptachlor are used to protect
these newly planted trees.
52. California use of chlordane on citrus is directed pri-
marily at control of the Argentine ant which interferes with
natural predators of scale insects. It has been estimated that
25,400 pounds of chlordane were used on 8,112 acres (3.2
percent of California citrus acreage) during 1973. A five
percent granular chlordane compound applied either aerial-
ly or with ground equipment at a rate of 100 pounds per
acre was the typical dose against Argentine ants during
this period. Substitute control programs use two to four
ground applications of diazinon for one application of
chlordane or foliar sprays to directly control scale insects.
One or two foliar applications of either parathion, mala-
thion, carbaryl, guthion or supracide would be needed as
an effective substitute for the chlordane treatment. Only a
7
small proportion of the California citrus acreage (3.2 per-
cent) requires treatment for control of Argentine ants and
the substitute control program has a small effect on citrus
production costs. The direct regional and national impacts
associated with a restriction in chlordane use for Califor-
nia’s citrus industry are expected to be small. The impact
of suspending this use would be felt primarily by the grow-
er. Such pesticides as parathion could upset pest manage-
ment programs and require a reorganization of foliar spray
schedules.
53. Seed treatment is used to decrease stand loss attrib-
utable to seed eating insects. It is intended to protect grain
and vegetable seed up to the germination period. It is esti-
mated that between 4 and 8.7 percent of all grain seed (1970-
1974) was treated with heptachlor in five midwestern states.
Similarly, between 8.6 and 20.2 percent of all seed was
treated with one cf five major insecticides including hepta-
chlor. Estimates are not available on the intensity of seed
insecticide treatment in other agricultural areas. Velsicol
Chemical Corporation estimates that about 269,000 pounds
of heptachlor were used for seed treatment or dressing in
1974.
54. Seed treatment provides temporary protection from
seed eating insects (seed corn maggot, seedcorn beetle, thief
ant, wireworms and false wireworms) during germination.
Major protection from heavy infestations is provided by
more costly and intensive soil treatments. Seed treatment
alone does not provide adequate protection under such con-
ditions. Commercial seed producers generally do not now
apply insecticides to seed for protection during germina-
tion. For many types of seed the alternative to commercial-
ly treated seed is planter-box or drill-box treating by the
farmer. These treatments are generally formulated with
from 12% to 25 percent active insecticide and, almost with-
out exception, contain a lubricant such as agricultural grade
graphite. Suspension of heptachlor seed treatment would
78
generally result in the use of lindane, diazinon, or a combi-
nation of lindane/diazinon. State recommendations consist-
ently recommend the above as seed treatment alternatives
to heptachlor. However, supplies of lindane are scarce and
a substantial portion of the heptachlor seed treatment use
could not be made up by lindane. For diazinon the outlook
is somewhat better as the volume needed for seed treat-
ment is smal] compared to total diazinon use.
55. Resistance of seed feeding insects to cyclodiene in-
secticides is prevalent in certain geographical areas. Seed
corn maggot and slender seed corn beetle, for example, are
resistant to aldrin, chlordane and heptachlor over the north-
ern and east central areas of Missouri. Iowa no longer rec-
ommends chlorinated hydrocarbons in the state because of
resistance in these insects. Illinois notes that, among other
insects, seed-corn beetles, seed corn maggots and possibly
wireworms are no longer effectively controlled by chlori-
nated hydrocarbons (lindane is included in this group).
56. Lack of efficacy and phytotoxicity data for diazinon
prevents an accurate appraisal as to whether that chemical
will be a good seed treatment substitute for heptachlor un-
der all conditions. As with lindane many factors may affect
its performance as a widely used seed protection.
57. Heptachlor removal as a seed treatment is most trou-
blesome primarily in the Southwest. It is estimated that
removal of heptachlor as a seed treatment may result in a
financial loss of greater than $22 million dollars in the State
of Texas. This estimate includes only the cost of replacing
and replanting sorghum, small grain and corn seed. Seed
replacement estimates vary between 10 and 20 percent of
the planted acreage dependent upon crop. Further detailed
economic assessments of additional loss due to reduction in
yield of quality or quantity have not been made. Wireworms
are the major seed eating insect problem in Texas. Diazi-
non seed treatment is considered to be generally ineffective
on wireworms. Though recommended as an alternative to
79
heptachlor seed treatment for seed corn beetles, seed corn
maggot and wireworms on corn and small grains, lindane is
reported to cause various degrees of phytotoxicity particu-
larly on sorghum. Neither chemical is considered to be an
effective seed treatment alternative in the Texas grain pro-
ducing areas. Cultural techniques are not believed to offer
protection against seed eating pests. Planting dates cannot
be delayed due to either climatic conditions or to the pres-
ence of other pests that can attack at other vulnerable
stages. Potential control from rotation is limited by the fact
that many grain growing areas in Texas are not adapted
to crops other than grains. Additionally, cotton/grain and
cotton/sunflower rotations in other locations are not always
plausible as the market for cotton may be uncertain and
sunflower seeds are a crop of limited demand. Insect infesta-
tions often exhibit densities directly proportional to the
seeding rate, therefore, an increase in the rate of seeding
will not necessarily produce the desired stand.
58. Low to moderate populations of wireworms are effec-
tively controlled by heptachlor seed treatments of .175 to
.25 ounces of active chemical per bushel of seed. Planter-box
applications of heptachlor formulations including .5 to 1
ounce of active chemical per bushel of seed have been equal-
ly as effective provided lubricants of some sort are included
in the formulation to remove the ‘‘planter drag’’ of the
added material so that uniform, expected seeding rates are
obtained. One bushel of seed is sufficient to plant 3 or more
acres of corn. Sorghum seed treated at one-half to one and
one-half ounces of actual heptachlor per 100 pounds of seed
will plant from 10 to 25 acres.
59. The Pacific Northwest is the production center of nar-
cissi, more commonly known as daffodills. Both bulbs and
cut flowers are distributed nationally. The narcissus bulb
fly is the principal insect pest of daffodils. Narcissus pro-
duction is a small acreage industry, but one that has high
per acre gross monetary value. Approximately 1800 acres
80
are grown in the United States with the major production
centers located in Washington, Virginia, New Jersey, Cali-
fornia, North Carolina and Oregon. Income is derived from
dry bulb sales, field-cut flowers and forced greenhouse flow-
ers. Washington and Oregon are the major supply sources
for dry bulb sales. Total value of the crop in these 2 states
approaches $2,000,000 annually.
60. Narcissus production is concentrated in geographical
areas with comparatively mild climates where winter and
summer extremes are tempered by winds from large bodies
of water. A normal cropping season extends from August
to the following July. Bulbs are planted to fields in rows
during August and September with specialized machines
that set the bulbs uniformly spaced in deep furrows (6’’-8”’
below the soil surface) which are then covered with drag-
bars or discs. Rows are hilled periodically to control weeds,
facilitate drainage and protect the bulbs from freeze dam-
age. In the late fall chemical weed killers are applied to
suppress weeds until the following spring when the soil
dries out enough to permit cultivation and post-emergence
herbicide applications. The bulbs sprout in late fall and
foliage emerges during mid-winter. Daffodils usually bloom
in late March or early April, depending upon the weather
and location. Cut flowers are harvested at bud stage from
some fields in March. The flower heads from nonharvested
fields are removed to maximize bulb growth. Fields are
rogued once or twice in the spring to remove off varieties
and diseased plants. Irrigation is often provided in May
and June to increase bulb yields. Harvesting commences in
July after the plants have matured and the tops have died
back. Bulbs are mechanically dug with grower-designed and
constructed machines which resemble potato diggers, but
contain additional components for preliminary field clean-
ing and grading. Bulbs are stacked in trays and field cured
for 7-10 days. They are then transported to sheds where
they are artificially cured, cleaned, graded and treated with
81
chemicals for protection against disease, nematodes and in-
sects. Bulbs are graded into planting stock and various sizes
for sale.
61. The principal insect pest of daffodils is the narcissus
bulb fly, Meredon equestris. It occurs wherever bulbs are
grown in Europe and North America and causes more trou-
ble than all other narcissus insects combined. While mainly
a pest of narcissus, it also attacks amaryllis, hyacinths,
lilies, tulips and other bulbous plants. The flies, which re-
semble bumble bees, are present from the middle of April
through June in Washington. Females lay separate eggs
on the foliage or soil near the base of the plants. Eggs hatch
in 10-15 days, and maggots, which are the destructive stage
of this insect, move downward to the base of the bulb where
they enter the bulb through the basal plate. The larvae feed
on the interior of the bulb and eventually create a cavity
filled with soft brown decayed tissue. The larvae develop to
mature size, about 34 inch long, by late September or Octo-
ber. Larvae remain in the bulbs during the winter and leave
them in March to form puparia in the soil. Flies emerge
from the puparia in late spring and begin the cycle again.
62. Since the 1950’s narcissus growers have effectively
controlled the bulb fly with heptachlor bulb dips prior to
planting. The bulbs are usually soaked from 10-60 minutes
in emulsions containing 0.8 pounds of heptachlor per one
hundred gallons of water. Bulb dips are an economical and
highly effective means of controlling the bulb fly on narcis-
sus. The heptachlor bulb dip is the standard control mea-
sure wherever the pest is an economic problem. No prac-
tical alternative to heptachlor exists at this time. Chlordane
is also an effective material as a bulb dip for the fly. How-
ever, this material was never recommended for commercial
use because it was incompatible with the mercuric fungi-
cides that were used in the dips for protection against bulb
rots. In recent years mercury fungicides have been replaced
with a modern organic fungicide, Benlate. Data are avail-
82
able which indicate that chlordane and this fungicide are
compatible in the dipping tank. Several new insecticides
show promise as bulb dips and may eventually become prac-
tical alternatives to heptachlor. The long-term impact of a
heptachlor suspension or cancellation appears less serious
than the immediate effect of such an action because poten-
tial alternative insecticides as bulb dip treatments do exist.
63. The adults (or June bugs) of the white grubs lay their
eggs in soil, in sod, or in grassy fields. The larvae (called
grubs) that hatch from these eggs feed primarily on the
roots of the grasses. The grubs will feed for two or three
years, depending on the species. When the field is broken
for planting, the grubs will feed on the roots of any crops
planted in that field. Their feeding can destroy the stand
and weaken plants, thus reducing yield. The grubs are rare-
ly distributed evenly across a field, and their damage usual-
ly appears as variously sized circular areas of poor stand
surrounded by stunted plants. Also, the root damage caused
by the grubs makes harvesting difficult. Grub damage has
occurred throughout the State of Michigan, but most of the
problems have been in the heavier soils in the southern half
of the Lower Peninsula. Grub problems increase with an in-
crease in opening of fallowed fields.
64. Good control of grass weeds in crops and maintenance
of high vigor in forages is emphasized as a means of keep-
ing grubs down in tilled land. An increased threat of insect
damage occurs in fields recently removed from sod or heavy
weeds. It is recommended that growers check plow furrows
for white grubs when they are fitting their lands. There is
no hard criteria for deciding when grub control is needed,
but it is recommended that the field be protected from grubs
when the grubs are easily found in the field. Treatments
are not recommended unless the grubs can be found in the
field because not all sod fields are heavily infested with
grubs. Sometimes grubs are not detected until after the
plants have emerged. The atfected areas are treated, disked
and replanted when there is time. This reduces the loss
but increases the cost of control.
65. The alternative to chemical control of grubs is clean
fallow of the land for one year following breaking it from
sod. This removes the land from production for that sea-
son. Clean fallow leaves the land open to wind and water
erosion.
66. A broadcast application of chlordane and mixing the
insecticide into the upper layer of soil prior to planting is
recommended for grub control. The insecticide can be ap-
plied as a spray or as granules. Broadcast granular appli-
cators are scarce in Michigan, and most of the applications
are made using weedkiller type sprayers. The mixing can
be done by the disking betore planting and is recommended
to prevent decomposition of ine insecticide by the sun and
hot surface of the soil, to reduce exposure of wildlife to the
insecticide, and to reduce run-off. The broadcast application
rather than a band application is required for control of
grubs. Soil fumigation, recommended in some states, is ex-
ceedingly rare in Michigan.
67. The State of Michigan currently recommends 4 pounds
active insecticide per acre of chlordane, parathion, or dia-
zinon for white grub control in field crops. Parathion and
diazinon were recommended to have something to reduce
the losses caused by white grubs in those crops where chlor-
dane cannot be used. Their lack both of specificity and re-
sidual effectiveness have given acceptable control only in
re-plant situations. Two newer insecticides, Lorsban and
CGA-12223, are reported to be promising for white grubs,
but they are still unproven.
68. The economic impact of a ban on chlordane in field
crops in Michigan would not be major on a state-wide basis;
however, the economic impact on a number of farmers would
be very significant. The estimated acreage infested annual-
ly in Michigan is corn, 10,000 acres; small grains, 5,000
acres; soybeans, 3,000 acres; and dry beans, 2,000 acres.
Re
69. Growers in New York State annually produce ap-
proximately four million pounds (two and two-thirds mil-
lion quarts) of strawberries. The annual value of this crop
at present is estimated to be at least 1 and %4 million dol-
lars. Among the insects most difficult to control in a straw-
berry planting are those that spend their immature or lar-
val stages feeding on the crowns or on the roots. Plants
attacked by these species usually die or at least remain
stunted and nonproductive. In New York State there are
at least five species of insects that may, and when not con-
trolled often do, injure the crowns and/or roots of straw-
berry plants. The most important species involved are:
white grubs—phyllophaga sp.; strawberry rootworm—Parta
canella (Paria fragariae) ; strawberry root weevil or crown
girdler—Brachyrhinus ovatus (Otiorhynchus ovatus) ; black
vine weevil—Brachyrhinus sulcatus ; and strawberry crown
borer—Tyloderma fragariae.
70. Strawberry plants are set in the spring in rows 4 feet
apart with the plants about 18 inches apart in the row.
These plants multiply by sending out runners which pro-
duce daughter plants to develop each row into a bed approx-
imately 3 feed wide. No crop is produced the first year.
Crops are produced the second year, and possible for 6 or
7 additional seasons, depending on cultural practices and
the degree of weed, insect, and disease contro] obtained.
Presently, some growers plan to fruit their beds 4 to 6
years.
71. The use of preplant soil treatment of a persistent in-
secticide protects the plants against the feeding of root
destroying insects species for several years. In the North-
eastern United States and Eastern Canada, chlordane is
generally, and in most cases the only, recommended mate-
rial for this purpose. Chlordane is specifically recommended
in Minnesota, Michigan, Ohio, New York, Connecticut, Mas-
sachusetts, Maine, Vermont, New Jersey, Maryland, West
Virginia, and in Ontario, Canada. New York State recom-
85
mends the use of chlordane in strawberry production only
if the land utilized had previously been in sod. The chlor-
dane formulation is incorporated in the upper 3 to 6 inches
of soil before planting for the control of white grubs and
other root-feeding species.
72. The larvae of rootweevils and white grubs are serious
pests in certain areas for which several states recommend
chlordane and for which alternative controls are limited.
Other chemicals such as diazinon and carbaryl reportedly
are effective controls but are not registered at sufficiently
high rates of application to provide eff
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.