Petition — Seligman Development, Inc. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1977
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No sist 5
H JAN 20 1977
MICHABL ROOAK, JR., CLERK
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1976
No-__W6=-1007
SELIGMAN DEVELOPMENT, INC.,
IRVING R. SELIGMAN, STANTON
BOCKNECK, and CARABELL, BOCKNECK,
STRAKA AND JURACKS,
Petitioners,
UNITED STATES,
Respondent.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
J. LEONARD HYMAN).
LAURENCE ALLAN BERG
17117 W. Nine Mile
Rd., 16th Floor
Southfield, MI 48075
Tel. (313) 559-7500
Counsel for Petitioners
January 18 , 1977
INDEX
Opinicn Below. ....+-+-.-.
Jurisdiction ...+.e+-e«e-s.
Questions Presented .....
Statutory Provisions
Sl a a
Statement of the Case... .
Reasons for Granting the
ee a oe ee ae
1. The Decisions Of This
Court And The Courts
Of Appeals Are In Con-
flict As To The Proper
Interpretation of 28
WE SIZ9k ew ww ete
2. The Decisions Raise
Significant And Re-
curring Problems Con-
cerning Efforts To
Invoke Exceptions To
The Final Judgment
|) a ae ee ee
Conclusion ...+.«e-+««-
Appendix (Order of Court
of Appeals) ....-++-es-s.
CITATIONS
Alexander v United States,
201 US 117 (1906) .....
Cobbledick v U.S., 309 US
Lb errs]
1l
14
Cohen v Beneficial Loan
Corp., 337 US 541 (1949). .
Davis v U.S., 138 F2d 406
(CA5 1943), cert. denied
soa UB 77S CASGG) « « 2 oo
Dickinson v Petroleum Con-
version Corp., 338 US
Oey Guus @ oM@ tc ce 6
Doe v Rusenberry, 255 F2d
Bae Gaus Ape) 6 et te et
Eisen v Carlisle & Jacguelin,
417 US 156 (1974) .....
In re April 1956 Grand Jury
(Shotwell), 239 F2d 263
(CA7 1956), cert. denied
goa UB 997 (1957) « 2 « « «
In re Biaggi, 478 F2d 489
oy Fee
In re Grand Jury Proceedings,
309 F2d 440 (CA3 1962). .
In re Grand Jury Proceedings
(U.S. Steel, etc.), 525
F2d 151 (CA3 1975). ....
In re Holovachka, 317 F2d 834
- 2 ° Se
In re Special February 1971
Grand Jury v Conlisk,
490 F2d 894 (CA7 1973)...
Kaufman v Edelstein, 539 F2d
8 - 2 are ee
LaBuy v Howes Leather Co.,
35é US 269 (1957) . 2 2 oo
ii
10
Ll
Page
Martin v Chandis Securities
Co., 128 F2d 731
a Bees 60 eo 8 Oe 8 8 8 11
Perlman v United States,.
247 US 7 (1918) . « «© © « « 7, 9
Schlagenhauf v Holder, 379
US 104 (1964) ......-. 13
Swift & Co. Packers v
Compania Columbiana Del
Caribe, 339 US 684 (1950) . 10
U.S. v Doe (Ellsberg Grand
Jury Proceeding), 455 F2d
by Bs oy . See , 10
United States v Nixon,
418 US 683 (1974) ..... 6, 9,
12
United States v Ryan,
402 US 530 (1971) ..... 5, 6,
7, 8,
14
United States v Universal
Manufacturing Co., 525
F2d 808 (CA8 1975). .... 11
Westinghouse Electric Corp. v
City of Burlington, Ver-
mont, 351 F2d 762 (CADC 1965) 11
Will v United States, 389 US
ty) rrr ee 13
CONSTITUTION, STATUTES
RULES OF COURT
28 USC §1254(1) . ...- ses 2
iii
2B UBC $iZ9i. ws we we eee
Fourth Amendment, United
States Constitution... .
Fifth Amendment, United
States Constitution... .
ale 2766) Dies 0 © cele «
MISCELLANEOUS
Note, Supervisor and Ad-
visory Mandamus under
the All Writs Act, 86
Harv.L.Rev. 595 (1973)...
iv
13
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1976
No.
SELIGMAN DEVELOPMENT, INC.,
IRVING R. SELIGYAN, STANTON
BOCKNECK, and CARABELL, BOCKNECK,
STRAKA AND JURACKS,
Petitioners,
UNITED STATES,
Respondent.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
The petitioners -- Seligman Develop-
ment, Inc., Irving R. Seligman, Stan-
ton Bockneck, and Carabell, Bockneck,
Straka and Juracks -- pray that a writ
of certiorari issue to review the
order of the United States Court of
Appeals for the Sixth Circuit entered
in this proceeding on December 23,
1976.
OPINION BELOW
The opinion of the Court of Ap-
peals, not yet reported, appears in
the Appendix hereto. No opinion was
rendered by the District Court for
the Eastern District of Michigan on
the questions presented herein..
JURISDICTION
The order of the Court of Appeals
for the Sixth Circuit was entered on
December 23, 1976. A timely petition
for rehearing was denied on
, and this petition for certio-
rari was filed within 30 days of that
date. This Court's jurisdiction is
invoked under 28 USC §1254(1).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Whether exceptions to 28 USC
§1291 created by decisions of this
Court and the Courts of Appeals have
resulted in a conflict as to the
proper interpretation of the final
judgment rule.
2. Whether the promotion of the
administration of justice requires
this Court to resolve the obvious
tension between the final judgment
rule and increased appeals of inter-
locutory orders.
STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED
United States Code, Title 28:
§1291. Final decisions of dis-
trict courts
The courts of appeals shall have
jurisdiction of appeals fram all
final decisions of the district
courts of the United States, the
United States District Court for the
District of the Canal Zone, the
District Court of Guam, and the
District Court of the Virgin Islands,
except where a direct review may be
had in the Supreme Court.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On March 19, 1976 the District
Court sitting in the Eastern District
of Michigan issued three grand jury
subpoenas duces tecum to petitioners
seeking voluminous records pertaining
to an FHA insured apartment project
located in Ypsilanti, Michigan.
Petitioners, on May 6, 1976, filed
a Motion to Quash Grand Jury Sub-
poenas on the grounds, inter alia,
that the subpoenas were unreasonable
and oppressive contrary to the Fourth
Amendment and Rule 17(c), Federal
Rules of Criminal Procedure. Further,
petitioners argued that the records
sought had already been provided to
3
HUD and the FBI and at the end of the
FBI investigation petitioners were
advised that the FBI did not find any
criminal involvement at all and were
satisfied that no illegal activity
occurred.
Petitioners’ brief in support of
the Motion to Quash also asserted
their Fifth Amendment privilege
against self-incrimination arguing
that many of the records sought were
personal records of a fartnership
tantamount to an individual doing
business by himself.
The District Court reluctantly
denied petitioners’ Motion to Quash
by Order dated July 6, 1976 for
reasons stated at the oral argument.
The District Judge commented:
"I can certainly sympa-
thize with any citizen who is
put in a position where he must
deal with separate agencies of
the Federal Government and sub-
sequently discovers or realizes
that one agency doesn't talk to
the other one, anyway."
On July 14, 1976 petitioners filed
a Notice of Appeal from the July 6,
1976 Order denying their Motion to
Quash. On September 11, 1976 the
United States filed a Motion to Dis-
miss or Affirm. In its motion the In United States v. Nixon, 418 US
United States challenged appellate 683 (1974) this Court summarized the
jurisdiction... relationship between 28 USC §1291 and
. appeals of an order denying a motion
On December 23, 1976 the Court of to quash a grand jury subpoena duces
Appeals entered the following dis- tecum as follows:
missal order:
"The finality requirement
of 28 USC §1291 embodies a
strong congressional policy
against piecemeal reviews,
and against obstructing or
"Upon consideration, it
is ORDERED that the motion to
dismiss the appeal for lack of
jurisdiction be and it is
hereby granted, and the appeal impeding an ongoing judi-
is dismissed. Cobbledick v. : cial proceeding by inter-
United States, 309 U.S. 323 locutory appeals. See, e.g.,
(1940), reaffirmed in United Cobbledick v_ United States,
States v. Ryan, 402 U.S. 530 309 US 323, 324-326, 84 L Ed
(1971)." See Appendix, at l. 783, 60 S Ct 540 (1940).
This requirement ordinarily
promotes judicial efficiency
For the reasons urged below, this and hastens the ultimate ter-
Court should re-examine Cobbledick mination of litigation. In
and Ryan. applying this principle to an
order denying a motion to quash
and requiring the production
of evidence pursuant to a
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
l.
THE DECISIONS OF THIS COURT
AND THE COURTS OF APPEALS ARE
IN CONFLICT AS TO THE PROPER
INTERPRETATION OF 28 USC §1291.
Section 1291 of Title 28 provides
that the "courts of appeals shall
have jurisdiction of appeals from all
final decisions of the district courts
of the United States ...."
Subpoena duces tecum, it has
been repeatedly held that the
order is not final and hence
not appealable. United States v
Ryan, 402 US 530, 532, 29 L Ed
2d 85, 91 S Ct 1580 (1971);
Cobbledick v United States,
supra; Alexander v United
States, 201 US 117, 50 L Ed
686, 26 S Ct 356 (1906). This
Court has
‘consistently held that
the necessity for expe-
dition in the adminis-
tration of the criminal
law justifies putting
one who seeks to resist
the production of desired
information to a choice
between compliance with
a trial court's order to
produce prior to any re-
view of that order, and
resistance to that order
with the concomitant pos-
Sibility of an adjudica-
tion of contempt if his
claims are rejected on
appeal.' United States v
Ryan, supra, at 533, 29
L Ed 2d 85.
"The requirement of submit-
ting to contempt, however, is
not without exception and in
some instances the purposes
underlying the finality rule
require a different result.
For example, in Perlman v
United States, 247 US 7, 62
L Ed 950, 38 S Ct 417 (1918),
a subpoena had been directed
to a third party requesting
certain exhibits; the ap-
pellant, who owned the exhibits,
sought to raise a claim of
privilege. The Court held
an order compelling produc-
tion was appealable because
it was unlikely that the third
party would risk a contempt
citation in order to allow im
mediate review of the ap- —
pellant's claim of privilege.
Id., at 12-13, 62 L Ed 950.
That case fell within the
‘limited class of cases where
denial of immediate review
would render impossible any
review whatsoever of an in-
dividual's claims.' United
States v Ryan, supra, at
533, 29 L Ed 2d 85.
"Here too, the traditional
contempt avenue to immediate
appeal is peculiarly inap-
propriate due to the unique
setting in which the question
arises. To require a Presi-
dent of the United States to
place himself in the posture
of disobeying an order of a
court merely to trigger the
procedural mechanism for re-
view of the ruling would be
unseemly, and would present
an unnecessary occasion for
constitutional confrontation
between two branches of the
Government. Similarly, a
federal judge should not be
placed in the posture of is-
suing a citation to a Presi-
dent simply in order to invoke
review. The issue whether a
President can be cited for con-
tempt could itself engender
protracted litigation, and >
would further delay both re-
view on the merits of his
claim of privilege and the
ultimate termination of the
underlying criminal action
for which his evidence is
sought. These considerations
lead us to conclude that the
order of the District Court
was an appealable order."
418 US at 690-692. (Empha-
Sis added.)
In Perlman, supra, this Court crea-
ted an exception to the finality rule
for third parties. In Nixon, supra,
the Court created an exception to the
finality rule for the President. In
a civil class action suit this Court
created another exception to the fi-
nality rule for odd-lot traders,
stating in Eisen v. Carlisle &
Jacquelin, 417 US 156, 170-171 (1974):
"We know, of course, that
§1291 does not limit appellate
review to 'those final judg-
ments which terminate an
action... ,' Cohen v Bene-
ficial Loan Corp., 337 US 541,
545, 93 L Ed 1528, 69 S Ct 1221
(1949), but rather that the re-
quirement of finality is to be
given a ‘practical rather than
a technical construction.’ Id.,
at 546, 93 L Ed 1528. The in-
quiry requires some evaluation
of the competing considerations
underlying all questions of
finality -- ‘the inconvenience
and costs of piecemeal review
on the one hand and the danger
of denying justice by delay on
the other.' Dickinson v Petro-
leum Conversion Corp., 338 US
507, 511, 94 L Ed 299, 70 S Ct
322 (1950) (footnote omitted) ."
In Cohen, supra, and Swift & Co.
Packers v. Compania Columbiana Del
Caribe, 339 US 684 (1950) this Court
found further exceptions to the fi-
nality rule.
The Courts of Appeals have also
found exceptions to the finality rule.
Interlocutory orders involving Grand
Jury investigations where the courts
held appellate jurisdiction existed
include: In re Grand Jury Proceed-
ings (U.S. Steel, etc.), 525 F2d 151
(CA3 1975); U.S. v. Doe (Ellsberg
Grand Jury Proceeding), 455 F2d 1270
10
(CAl 1972); Davis v. U.S., 138 F2d
406 (CA5 1943), cert. denied 321 US
775 (1944). See also Westinghouse
Electric Corp. v. City of Burlington,
Vermont, 351 F2d 762 (CADC 1965);
Martin v. Chandis Securities Co.,
128 F2d 731 (CA9 1942).
It must also be noted that many
decisions have reached the merits
of interlocutory problems involving
the grand jury with little or no
discussion of jurisdiction, im
plicitly recognizing the gravity
and practical finality of the is-
sues raised. See, e.g., United
States v. Universal Manufacturing
Co., 525 F2d 808 (CA8 1975); In re
Biaggi, 478 F2d 489 (CA2 1973);
In re Holovachka, 317 F2d 834
(CA7 1963); In re Grand Jury Pro-
ceedings, 309 F2d 440 (CA3 1962);
Doe v. Rosenberry, 255 F2d 118
(CA2 1958); In re April 1956 Grand
Jury (Shotwell), 239 F2d 263
(CA7 1956), cert. denied 352 US
997 (1957); In re Special February
1971 Grand Jury v. Conlisk, 490
F2d 894 (CA7 1973).
2. THE DECISIONS RAISE SIG-
NIFICANT AND RECURRING
PROBLEMS CONCERNING EF-
FORTS TO INVOKE EXCEPTIONS
TO THE FINAL JUDGMENT RULE.
ll
Counsel has informed petitioners
of the foregoing exceptions to the
finality rule. Not unexpectedly,
petitioners think that it would be
"unseemly," Nixon, supra, for them
to disobey a court order merely to
trigger review. Likewise, peti-
tioners think that justice will be
denied if review is delayed, Cohen,
ra. Petitioners are particu-
larly frustrated and upset by the
fact that they voluntarily allowed
both HUD and the FBI months to re-
view and copy all the records now
sought. In addition, after its ex-
tensive review, the FBI, the inves-
tigative arm of the United States
Attorney's Office and used by the
prosecutor to present evidence to
the grand jury, gave petitioners
a clean bill of health. Now, the
judicial system seeks to slam the
doors of appellate review shut. ‘To
petitioners, the phrase "Equal jus-
tice under law" has a hollow ring,
Since their appeal was summarily
dismissed.
It is time for this Court to
comprehensively review, in light of
contemporary considerations, the
various judicially-created excep-
tions to the finality rule in order
to resolve the obvious and increasing
tension between the final judgment
rule and appeals of interlocutory
12
between the final judgment
orders. See Kaufman v. Edelstein, rule and increased use of
539 F2d 811, 817 (CA2 1976) where the prerogative writs to
Judge Friendly, speaking of an ° review orders that are in-
analogous situation with respect to terlocutory even in light
the use of prerogative writs, com of Cohen, which must be
mented: resolved on a more principled
basis than how much a court >
"The case against this of appeals disapproves the
is that these statements re- district court's ruling in
flected the narrow view with the particular case."
respect to the scope of the
prerogative writs which the = Similarly, in this case it is time
Supreme Court then enter- to resolve on a "principled basis"
tained but from which it has judicially~created exceptions to
since departed, notably in Cobbledick, supra, and Ryan, supra.
LaBuy v. Howes Leather Co.,
352 U.S. 249, 77 S.Ct. 309, .
1 L.Ed.2d 290 (1957), and CONCLUSION
Schlagenhauf v. Holder, 379
U.S. 104, 85 S.Ct. 234, 13 ' For these reasons, a writ of cer-
L.Ed.2d 152 (1964). See tiorari should issue to review the
also the dicta in Will v. order of the Sixth Circuit.
United States, 389 U.S. 90,
88 S.Ct. 269, 19 L.Ed.2d Respectfully submitted,
305 (1967), and Note, Su-
pervisor and Advisory Man-
damus under the All Writs
Act, 86 Harv.L.Rev. 595
(1973). That it has de- '
parted in some degree is Le ALD BERG
clear enough; what is un- 17117 W. Nine Mile Road,
clear is how far. Prob- 16th Floor
ably this cannot be cam- Southfield, MI 48075
pletely determined until Tel. (313) 559-7500
the Court speaks again;
there is an obvious tension
J. LEONARD HYMAN
Counsel for Petitioners
13 . 14
APPENDIX
No. 76-2104
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS ~*- i? E D
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
OFL 29 1976
IN RE: GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS -
SELIGMAN DEVELOPMENT, INC., JOHN v, Fe rwiAn Clerk
IRVING R. SELIGMAN, ; ORDER ,
STANTON BOCKNECK, and -
CARABELL, BOCKNECK, ;
STRAKA AND JURACKS,
Plaintiffs-Appellants
Before PHILLIPS, Chief Judge, WEICK and EDWARDS,
Circuit Judges.
a -
Upon consideration, it is ORDERED that the motion
to dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction be and it is
hereby granted, and the appeal is dismissed. Cobbledick v.
United States, 309 U.S, 323 (1940), reaffirmed in United
States v. Ryan, 402 U.S, 530 (1971).
ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on
January (4, 1977, three (3)
copies of the Petition for Writ
of Certiorari and Appearance
were mailed air mail, postage
prepaid to the Solicitor General,
Department of Justice, Washington,
D.C. 20530, and three (3)
copies of said Petition and Ap-
pearance were also mailed on that
same day by first-class mail,
postage prepaid, to Philip Van Dam,
United States Attorney, and Harold
Gurewitz, Assistant United States
Attorney, Room 704 Federal Building,
Detroit, Michigan 48226. I fur-
ther certify that all parties re-
quired to be served have been
served.
LAURENCE ALLAN BERG
17117 W. Nine Mile Rd.,
16th Floor
Southfield, MI 48075
Tel. (313) 559-7500
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.