Appendix — Miree v. DeKalb County
Supreme Court brief1977
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Los. |
kL.
ee mem
Supreme Court, US.
Oe oe
MAK 2
JOINT APPENDIX
IN THE
D
TMICHAEL RODAK, IR, CLERK)
Vi)]
Faye &
— |
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1976
GEORGE HENSON MIREE, ef al.,
Petitioners,
v.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, et al.,
Respondents.
JUDITH ANITA PHILLIPS,
Petitioner,
v.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, et al.,
Respondents.
FIREMAN’S FUND INSURANCE
COMPANY,
Petitioner,
v.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, et al.,
Respondents.
WILLIAM MICHAEL FIELDS,
Petitioner,
v.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, et al.,
Respondents.
|
No.
76-659
76-700
No.
76-722
ON WRITS OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
PETITIONS FOR WRITS OF CERTIORARI
FILED OCTOBER 30 AND NOVEMBER 10,
19 AND 23, 1976
CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 17, 1977
JOINT TABLE OF CONTENTS
Joint A
Page No.
PART A
Appendix in Miree, No. 76-607
ied on ivinanenndesncd dune tseeder 1
Complaint, Filed November 5, 1973............... 8)
Answer of Defendant, DeKalb County, Georgia,
ee SE ood cdiccoedescccdcessess 40
Motion of DeKalb County, Georgia to Dismiss,
Filed Romminge @, MB ree. 6 i oodieccacecccceccs 49
Motion to Strikeof Defendant, DeKalb County,
Georgia, Filed January 4, 1974................. 51
Pisintiffs’ First Amendment to Complaint,
ee GRD Ta, Be oo kv obc cde ccccccccccens 53
Motion of DeKalb County, Georgia to Dismiss the
Amended Complaint, Filed February 15, 1974... .78
Motion of DeKalb County, Georgia to Strike
Allegations from the Amended a
Filed February 15, 1974...........-cbeccceeees 80
Answer of DeKalb County, Georgia to First
Amended Complaint of Plaintiffs,
a ec cundobaeens 82
Plaintiffs’ Second Amendment to Complaint,
a re ne ceeeane ees 86
Answer of DeKelb County, Georgia to Second
Amended Complaint of Plaintiffs,
Se ec ke phen eneneeaweed 87
ae
JOINT TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued JOINT TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
Joint Appendix Joint Appendix
Page No. Page No.
PART A—Continued PART C—Continued
Motion to Dismiss and/or Motion to Strike re sens hesbasetenceenceeiese 175
Allegations from the Second Amended ee ied eee he aenkeers 179
Complaint of Plaintiffs, Filed May 14,1974....... 89 Plaintiff’s First Amendment of Complaint
Motion of Southeast Machinery, Inc., Machinery Se oa eee eee die se kW os-b.e 182
Buyers Corp. and Fireman’s Fund Insurance Motion to Dismiss the Amended Complaint........ 243
Company to Vacate, Set Aside, Alter and Motion to Strike the Amended Complaint......... 244
Amend the Orders entered on June 27, 1974,
and for Reconsideration, Rehearing and
; , PART D
New Trial, Fil Rear gles EE iene Be ca ied
oo TE, RES SEY & Sore - Appendix in Fields, No. 76-722
ht eaptel B ee OL ene edenenebausveres 247
Appendix in Phillips, No. 76-659 ees hd cntsdacbecstcevanvastveusns 253
FOE SALE LALA OT PEE Ee 99 eS ec ece Cen eeseawoucebe veces 293
i oa ee og a cle 107 Motion to Dismiss.............------+++ssseees: 296
: Answer of DeKalb County, Georgia, and the
f DeKalb County, Georgia............... ; ‘
— : — County, Georgs od Chairman and Members of the Board of
ee ok oe eck adh obe 125 Commissioners of Road and Revenues of
Amendment to Motion to Dismiss and Strike. .... .127 SE GHEE o pbb tdccedcneveveresenedsceess 299
Exhibit A—Affidavit of Cal M. Sandman
with attachments............... tLe ee 128 PART E
Reference to Orders and Judgments
PART C in all cases
Appendix in Fireman’s Fund, No. 76-700 i i i sb cg cd edeeasbsesdsvivocsecsenns 309
' icc ec abs enncccevcotsensveuns 309
Docket — Siac icd da data mM daideen wae wade ae 131 Fireman's Pond, Mo. 76-700..........0..csc000e: 31]
Complaint... ..........0.cecececscececeeeeeneess 136 se i in das da newwvaianeues 312
PART A
APPENDIX
IN
NO. 76-607
GEORGE HENSON MIRERF, et al.,
Petitioners,
v.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, et al.,
Respondents.
Pe eee ae
;
iis cane i. ate ar mene oanioe hn ee
CINE. Deke
CNR STATES Dis citte ) COUNT in diene ital
© tee BN. 168 Bee 1/4/74 deft. 4, tt sso deits,.°
* eS ee i : 12.7 aS t 5. 4 “1 em OO -2? rs of 7;
TITLE or CASE ATTORNENS
For pluintut
ee Tn oa
- . _* .
oe *Zterme Ihe
aN taneet), Tost, “str? .
yO oye “eees **0°-angg
—
ee ee ee et oe:
=
>»
os
3
tybest "L toheeten
Trei ie Sie Label
Teas eae 169% ° . 4 « fc Vaviuewe 33°.
reat a or. Se 7 ee tr hes, @, %%299
rquctey “ett TNT, «eS.
be end threuch 1°? 7 4. “Ta°T,
ome GS VAT.. SB. TSTLS,. FRep
So-3uIritars of salt “inors
—_—S St ese ee
For defendant.
even H
fF editen ®, “allies
, *net ’ - .
Sites SP°vEt of LS TC4;
StCUL Tag 3eTRS Cc Loo. : ey
SOUPYENRT PATTY, INC.; gro me ruta.
>'?4) Beh SS aE 2. RATE p+ 5+ eet, Atlant Me or ~ a
° DKA CRU, GRRL 4/05/74 rf AP il ah ine, >
he auc Pit beds M GALS OLS Seq DEWDs1"
Wer 1 K. wallara—
/ Harvey, Willard & Elliott
, 12S Tr ity Place -** >;
= | Decatur, Georcielalso Sen Revalh Cr .-
SeeSheet | 1A for additional counse!.
ees ss r ee on 7s -- y i a) ; e i -
STATISTICAL RECORD costs spate | gicciee een. eee | lest
0 oe ee eee . - —2-=2-¢ = - -= - se .
(S58 maid 11/5/73 Clerk ie nm |r secerraey ta es
| i om vodaey 4S.
t . | Lue ’ “Treas. uF. nep, «>! sone
'S 6 muta Marsal 40 5
oct TBP 4 Ahi vane 2, frat
tase of Action “Penslul P pocket fee | 20% ‘ | Stee ;
wath - alreraft crash | Scr 1) mo74 a b
Witness fees J P Treak, U.S. DoD. 34 Seo
. ‘ i
’
. . : i |
\ction, arose at: ' Depositions | j \ ‘
, Pon
' | i } 4
vy ae a ae
DC Wate. (us
aera". 2. -
Lda
ATC Trews
~ — “S*2orra = -. = 2. . S42
ADDITIONAL OMIM:SEL FOR DEFSXDAYTS
J. Arthur Mozlev
Snith, Cohen, Pingel, Kohler,
fartin & Lower
2509 First National Bank Tower
Atlenta, Georcia 30303 658-1200
(for defts., Machinery Buyers Corn. “ow known as Semac
Industries, Inc.) and Southeast Machinery, Inc.)
George M. Fleninre
Torts Section, Civil Division
Department of Justice
902 Safeway Building
Washington, D.c. 20530
For: United States
Long, ‘'cinberg, Ansiey & “Wheeler
Meade Burns & Edward D, Stone
3000 The Fquitavle Building
Atlanta, Georgia 30303 (525-5903)
and
NYendell K, ‘Villard
Harvey, ‘Yillard & Elliott
125 Trinity Place
Decatur, Georgia (377-3851)
(For DeKald County, Georgia)
‘e
esses ~~ a °° wee se
yA Ove c
JURY DEMAND
ee -——>
j PROCEEDINGS
-— ae
il Comalatat with tse svete, ?* led.
“T vs re7s t°sue* wm? celtys-* ts“. °. “arghal.
wece 35
19
21
$250.00 bond for costs, filed.
P1°t's Yenuest for ndmiseio a@dres-ed t7 deft, “**, ffl’.
PIft*s remuest ts a-oduer 14 permit inesect*on a-4 coov's:
eddressed *%0 the deft, “3°, fled.
Pifts' first ‘nterrocs. aidresse4 to deft “t1, “1-4,
Plfts* renueets for adaice!on ettpesced +9 “cft. ¥'ald %o.,
Sifte® *enusst to ee-de7 ond carmit “neseetimn asd ecspvin= ¢'*---
to deft. TeYalb Countv, “les.
Plfts' first tnterrors. afdresset to 74°°%t “evalb Trarnty, fled.
Requests for a4*a{ssiton addresse? to éeft. Sait*east Yac*'ner:, °
f? ied,
P1°ts’ request t- crcduce ad cernit 'nevecties er¢ conyine 2° '-
to deft. Sout*erist Fachirery, Inc., %* le. ;
Pifts® first Interrors. adecresses to deft. Snitheast “ach'rer~,
Ine., f° led.
Plfts' reouest for admission eddressed to ceft. “actinery Fuvers
Coro., filed.
to deft. “ac nery Sayers Corp., fled. ;
Plfts’® first Interre=*. addressed to deft. YVachinery Buyers or>.,.
filed. (all of stove attached to co~rlaint)
Consent order extending time thru 12-24-73 for deft. DeKalb Co. Ga.
to answer, etc. the complaint, to respond to pltf's lst interrogs. %«
request for admissions, filed. C. furn.
ORTER by the Court ux0n emrent of oarties ext. time for defts.
Machinery Buyers Coro. and Southesst Machinery, Inc. shall have to
;end thes 12/24/73 to file ans., interrovs., etc., filed. (¢. furn.'
Case reassignea to Judge O'Kelley
Marshal's returns on service as to Dekalb Co., Ga.( Horis A. Ward),
. M, Coolidge, Jr.)(Robert J. Morris) (tioke Clayton Smitn)(T. HM.
laway, Jr)(William A. Williams)(A.C.Guhl) all on 11-6-73; as to ©
Southeast Mechinery, Inc. & USA(U.S. Atty) both on 11-6-73; as to ,
Machinery Byers Corp. on 12-13-73, filed.
Corp. & Southeast Machinery, Inc. to file pleadings & response to
Pltf's complaint, interrogs., requsts for admissions & requests for
production of documents, filed. C. furn.
|
ORTTR that deft. “evald County s**11 have thru 1/j/7: within which
te Sle ans., ans. to ‘nterroes., etc., Siled.(c. ev.s12e1)
ORNS thet deft. USA shell Seve thru 2/15/7k to resoord or sbject
to noifts' requests fer d!scovery, flled.{c. urn.) |
14 7Yan & | ANSWER of Deft. DeKalb County with JURY DEMAND, filed. |
_ 42" | Deft. DeKalb County's Motion to Dismiss, filed. |
_4> | Deft. DeKalb County's Motion to Strike, filed. _-
7.4! Brief_in Support of DeKalb County's Motions to Dismiss & Strike,filed.
~~) Deft. DeKalb County's Responses and Objections to Plt{'s First
Interrogs., and Motion for Protective Order, filed. :
Deft. DeKalb County's Pesponses and Objections to Pltf's Request for
Admissions and Motion for Protective Order, file.
Bricf In Support of DeKalb County's Objectionsto First Inter: gs,
ft led.
Pifts’ request to orsduce and vern!t tnscection and co0z7ire adirerce:
Consent Order extending time thru 1-11-74 for defts. Machinery Puyers
1
098 2° 2 et ctl
=. eT od ?
vs
UNITCD SYATiCS OF AI RICA et.al. JUSY DAs
DC tea Mew CD eet eremcerce
ee “wasic f -Semsce:: oe as ef
an
— — Sects - =~ %
recy ois
Brief in Support of DeKalb County's Objections to Pltf's Requect
for Admissions, filed.
Consent Order ext. tire tnru 2-15-74 for deft United States to respond to t:.-
cozplaini, filed. (cozy to counsel 1-9)
ll
2 3y¥
31
Fed. 11
13
1s
Consent Créer ext. tine thru 1-J31-7L for pltfs’ to file responses and tric:
deft De..alb County's sotion to disaios, deft Dekalb County's motion to 5
objections of ceft Dekalod to pltfs' first interrogs., and objections of de!
kalb to pltcs" requests for acdsission, filed. (copies furn)
ANSWER of defts. Machinery Buyers Corp. and Southeast Machine
- P ~ 4 a . - r ; I
& DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL, filed. ”
te Nachinery Buyers Corp.'s answers to pltfs' requests for admis j
ed.
pete Machinery buyers Corp.'s answers to pltfs' first interrozcs.,
ec.
_e ne Buyers Corp.'s response to pltfs' request to produ,
Ces i c *
ft. Southeast Machinery, Inc.'s answers to pltfs' requests
dmission, filed. , , ee ve
te Southeast Machinery, Inc.'s answers to pltfs' Ist interrogs.,
ed.
ft. Southeast Machinery, Inc.'s response to pltfs' request to pre
@, etc., filed.
Pltf's mov‘ton to arend & add e party, brief in support % proposed
Order, f**«<. (lst emendment to cotplaint.atteched.)Quww-... « |
Deft, DeKalb County's Supplemental ari Yh ;
Y Brigit of pitfs' in tppost tan to wren wrAS* a. F248, County to disaiss |
and to strike, filed.
* Motion to require deft. Dekalb County, Ga. to answer pore fully certain of
pitis' figs: interrogs. and to anseur certein of such intesioys. which
Were MOt answered with brier, ralea.
Motion of pltfs' to determine the sufficiency of deft. Dekalb Coun:;'s
odjactions to pltfs' requests for adzission, for an order overruling said |
odjections and requiriog deft. to respond to said requests and for an i
award of expenses with brief, filed. |
‘-
4 -*
}|_Order_ allowing Ockalb County up to and including Feb. 11 in which to
file responses and briefs to Motion to anend and add party dfts. and '
responsive pleadings to pltf's amended compliant, filed. Counscls |
Response of detts. Machinery Buyers Corp. and Southeast machinery, Inc. to
pitf's motion to amend and add a party and pitfs' Ist. amendermt to cor).
filed.
SUGMITTEO G@: DEFT. DEKALB COUNTYS MOTION TO DISMISS, MOTION TO STRIKE;
MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
Consent Orcer by Clerk exteadin: timenthru 2-15-74 for deft. Dexc
Co. to re-n7nd to pltf's motion to emend & add party defts. & resr =
sive pleadings to pltf's amended-complaint, filed. C. furn. ico
Pltfe’ secon? inte=mas. to deft Mechinesy Buyers Cor-., filed. To 129
Deft. U.S.A.'S ANSWER, Crossclaim and Gounterclain, filed.
Deft. U.S.A.'s Answers to Pltfs' First Interrogs.,filed.
Deft. U.S.A.'s Resnonse to Plt{s' Request to Produce...,filed.
Deft. U.S.A.'s Response to Pltfs’ Request for Admission, filed.
Deft. U.S.A.'s First Interrogs., to Aubrey S. Mirce, Jr. and Cl aude
H. Estes, Jr., filed. (all above to WO)
|
'
'
qis creee
=e ee ee eee - os oe et ee ee ee
Date PROCEEDINGS
Fed. 1S AM AL 27 of Dekalb County, G. to firet arended corplaint of pitfs, filru,
T Wier in opnositio- to pitfs' motion to determine the sufficienc o.
Dekalb County's objections to pit{'s requests for admission and notion
to rore fully answer certain of pltf's interrogs., filea.
a4! Brief of Dckalh County, Georgia in opposition to pitf's motion to anerd
and add a party, filed.
»| Dekalb Countys Motion to dismiss the arended complaint, filed.
>i} Dekalh Countys rotion to strike allegations from the arcnded conplaint,
: ‘filed. :
dt pekait ZSountys second supplerental brief with exhibits, filed.
20|Pltf's 2nd request to produce & permit inspection and copying ac¢re:-.
to the deft. United States of America, filed. 79 woo
2 <SUCER of pltf's to courter-clain of ceft. U. S. aA., filed.
Pa sus:ttTeD or PLTF"S MOTIC! TO IED ASD ADD A PARTY; PLIPS. MOT IO? To
REQUITE DTNALS COUNTY TO ANSUER MORE FULLY PLTFS. ‘1st. interroos.& D TO
ANSWZu CERTAIN OF SUCH IVTERROGS; MOTION: OF PLTF. TO DETERNINE TIT
SUFFICIE:CY OF DF¥T. DEKALB COUTTYS OWECTIO’S TO PLTFS. REQUESTS For -
ADMISSION, FO AX ORDER OVERRULING SAID O-JECTIONS AND REQUIRING DGFT. Zo |
RESPOND TO SAID “EQUESTS FOR AN AWARD OF EXPENSES.
22 | AXS.TR of Machinery Cuyers Corp. and Southeast Machinery, Inc. to the
cross-clain of Deft. Uniteo States of Anwrica, filea. "co i
25 | Memorandum in opposition to Dekalb County's motion to dismiss as to the
cross-clain of the U. S. filed, by U.S... WCO
Pltf's brief in opposition to motions of deft. USA to consolicate,
filed.(motion filed tn companion cases & referers to this case) To #2) ©
2) 4Pitf's brief in response to beiéf of Dekalb Co., Ca. in opposition
———“T to pltf's motion to amend and add party, filed. ToWCO
27 Arcotcect of “Pesponse of Defts. Machinery Buvers Corp. and Southeast
© Seeirdted yy Doce tS M2255" aotias to arcrd end sSS a pesty sre gicie® offset
ndwnt to complaint, filed. WCo
weet of eealh Comey, Comrgis to Cmons-Clria ef 4eft USt, filet.(-44% PY |
i
:
j
|
'
Te") To ¥CO
March 5 Notice of appearance of George M. Flezing, Torts Section, Civil Section, o. s.
t of Justice, Washington, dD. Cc. as additional counsel for the U. wer
filed. To ¥CO :
12 SUBMITTED ON DEKALB COUNTY'S MOTION TO DISZISS THE AMENDED COMPLAIS
& MOTION TO STRIKE ALLECATIONS FROM THE ANENDED COMPLAINT
15 |Consent Order extending time thru 4-1-74 for deft. Machinery Buyers
Corp. to answer pltf's 2nd interrogs., filed. C. furn. To “CO
18 nswers of pitf's to first interrogs. propounded by deft. U.S.a.
th exhibits, filed. WcCOo }
25 | Response to pitfs' 2nd. request to produce and permit inspection an
opying addressed to the deft, United States of America, filed
27 Deft. Machinery Buyers Corp. ANSWERS to pitf's szcond interrog's.
filed. woo
Deft's MacSinery Buyers Corpl & Southeast Machinery, Inc. response
in opposition to motions to dismiss & strike filed by DeKalb Count,
To WcO
Next sheet
MINN, Bi” Ale errs & 3
UNITED QATVS CF AMLEICA, et a
D © 110A Ree Ciel! De tet Continuation
= _ iad? >
a TE ee ee M2 ot. Bees oe ee —-- ears PRoce: pinus
rhe | PROCEF DINGS ie Da . 2 See Sa a
1976 —— _ es st, July 12 [Srief of Dekalb Co., Ga. in onposition to the rotions o° ©o
APRIL 2 | Second int ’ Tw sean die ais ——————- ——==—| Macninery, Inc., Machinery Buyers Corp., and Pireran's "urd
of the f retniee Prccngee gone ay the Gott, CEs, surenaet te ale to set eside, Vacate, Anemd & alter the orders er for reco:
e federal rules of civil procedure, to pltfs Aubrey S. Mire. - . tone . 6-27-75, £
Jr., and Claude if. Estcs, Jr., filed. To WCO : ade rehearin7, and new trial on tne orders ertered on 6-27-"", fo.
aro 8 Deft, Pealb County, Ga's 3rd supplenental brief, filed. To ">. 15 7 to pltf's 2nd request for admission addressed to ce:
10 | Further AvSVERS of pltfs to first interrogs mronouneded by defers ° “5 22 Supplenental brief of DeKalb Go, t in oppositien to various rotions ¢
12 ‘Deft. USAS Tirst Request toProduce and permit Inspection and Co- "Ty Southeast ‘achinery, Inc., etal, filed, (vith attachrent)
Addressed to Pltfs., filed, CO sa 23 | Pltfs’ third interroas to deft US of A, filed.
‘ = s° Hrs ' TEAS ° soe 7% 1 : io °
23 |Pltfs' Second Interroms., to deft. U.S.A., filed. WwCO 29 UBMITTED Ox DEPTS SOUTHEAST KACHIXERY, DiC, MACHINERY, 3hC.» 3
Pltfs' Second Requests for Ad ’ a NERY BUYERS CORP., ® FIARSMAN'S FUND INSURANCE CO.'S MOTION To
os eq or Admission to deft. U.S.A., filed. *C3 ET ASIDE, ALTER AND AMEND THE ORDER OF 6/27/74 AND POR RicCrsleu..-
- | svers of plefs. to second interrogs. of deft. U.S.A., filed. TION REKFARL IG AND NeW TRIAL. ie
_2/71 Pltfs' Motion To Amend, with Brief, Proposed Order & Pltfs' 2nd a> -.- 31 | Deft USA's Request fo Produce & Permit Inspection and Copying, fil !.
‘ent to Complaint, riled. (woo)
__2 SS Plt{s'! Supplemental Brief in opposition to motions of deft to dis-::: Deft USA's 3rd Interrogs. to the Miree Pltfs', filed. WCO '
to strike, filed. Aug. 1 Southeast Machinery, Inc., Machinery Buyers Corp, & Fireman's furs |
30 jAnswer and Response of Defts Machinery Buyers and Southeast | Insurance Co's notice to take depositions, filed, WCO a7)
Machinery, to Pitt's Second Amendment to Complaint, filed. To WCO 2 Defts' Supplemental Notice to Take Depositinons, w/exnidit A, “'oe:. |
May 2 yee rder by Clerk extendinr, time thru %-20-7% for DeKalb Co. - | 5 Deft. U.S.A.'s answers to pltfs' Miree's interrogs., filed. “Oo
i € response to pltf s motion for 2nd amenduent to complaint,file:. | 19 | Deft U.S.A.'s memorandum in support of the mction of Southeast ta°
14 1) Deft USA's ANSVER to pltfs' 2nd Amended Cen ,
s4° Deft DeKalb County, ceoveie*s Motion To Siaehen alate aaenan to
trike allerations from the 2nd amended complaint of pltf., with
inery, Inc., Machinery Buyers Corp., & Fireran's Pund Insurance ~-.
to vacate, set iside, alter and amend the orders entered on 6/27/77 +
and for reconsideration, rehearing & new trial, filed. WCo
20 Response of Machinery Buyers Corp., and Southeast iachinery, inc., = |
aes filed. ¥CO | " Firenan's Fund Insurance Co, to the request to produce and permit tr!
Coch sume ait 4 eek a to 2nd arended complaint of pltfs.., spection and copying filed by the USA, filed. WCO
. wm whatily ed. i i > 4 ANT eS ¢ ee Qr4 tnterresz ‘ .
15 | Amendment of deft. Machinery Buyers Corp. and Southeast Machinery. Inc sad leaas-- 2 “25 — pregeunded ty Coft., Unite
| ot previouslv-filed answers to pltf's reoueste far adviceiane sn4 cea te aie >. Mae te , , . : cu |
- Pitfs' lst. interrogs., filed. woo 27 United States’ ANSWERS to the Miree pltf's 3rd interrog., fice!. J}
16 rbd ere | Buyers Corp. and Southeast Machinery, Inc.'s Asendment to Ansver. Sept. 4 eft's request for production of documents, filed. #CO ;
2g by a on ae ae) te te counsel To WCO ts 44.25 rd os mation oe ee ® Yaeh*nery S.yers “-*>. |
SUR: PS' MOTION TO AMEND. . e se aside ortor order @ismier'ne Deiixzl>h Co. is fe?, t*er?
30 | Consent Order extending time thru 6-12-74 for deft. USA to respo:? {> pnear to de substantial rrounds for differine ontnions, wm fs" oO"
J b pitf's interrocs. & request for admission, filed. c. furn, CO moeal aaah Lhe sdvanee...litisation, the Cl>ra t+ dfrestd *s -~
une SUNSITTED Oi: D=ST. DEZALB COULTY, GEORGIA'S MITICN TO DISMISS AND/ inal jucerent a*saissine Dexald County from thin case, P*lec. *.*
7 awed ALLZCATIONS FROM THE 20D AMENDED CO:PIAINT. sb op. iy "T filed and entered that the pla’ntif’ tse acre t--, *hn"
onsent ORDER by WCO ext. time thru 6/26/74 for deft. U.S.A. to etior ce zis=iere* + * 2. 6 ata FTP AN ‘nA that ote i oe.
Pree ped ng Py pitfs' ey and Request for : i : b Pes. 30 “a9 eost to be toxed ven final juts. to, 21) ptys. Tie.
, A fons, ed. (copies to counsel 6/12) To wco : oct ah o La, 0 caehes an anen © Gets — Tee
st 20 r+ Deral> County's supplemental brief in support of rotions to @ - oo Tr a of lng gp he hs po oe hg he SET MAST SSS SES
miss and strike, filed. ‘JCO ; ~ Sone Om At PtAt ao aes 88 SS py couns fix
Be Tere ees en eeee nee Ge*e GUthiD Ge sectee Sevtians oe ieee ee"; ie Deposition of HENRY F. MANGET, IP, filed.
Sieben of cuebboman, eeneaeae & aes tend og wen “real 16 Deft, U. S. A's Motion for 7) Judgment w/memorandum and exnidits, filed.
. ’ ° ract; Dr pitis’ ' 4
x mone or Rn paged od a and DOVYING pltfs' discovery motioens with: 4 a aig A ely MOS Seesment. fied “c 2, 1974 for pitts to
udi to refile. (c t : ; - ° .
Beaalb County still guating a a oe : Letter from pltf's —— rerarding ee > Somes of
26 ent Order 3 , Election to defer Appendix which tney sent to USCA, ed.
. oan protien wag may Povey! rte > aa pte ee 18 Pitf's response to deft, United States of Anerica’s Request for Production of
.¥ . , . .
JULY 3 _ |¥otion of Southeast Machinery, Ine., Machinery Buyers Corp. and Fir: 24 Br TITS te sos ton, Barton, Proctor, Sweclaw & sat"
ae yey oe vacate, set aside, alter and amend the or °. Withiroposeu srcord On appear, files.
eree on June 74 and for reconsi i » ep és
ond ate 1a cunport, filet sideration rehearing and new *: eenttened
¥ - " ae oe CONT,
Pret.
. ee ee =. aS 2["2= -3—=Sa=P =2 -
pare antes be
A974 ‘ a a ee
Oct. 29 | Letter from Long, Weimbers, Ansie sneeler tc w *
-ong, #eimberg, Ansley & Wheeler to A
‘ . Re: items to be placed in record on apoeal, files. sag occas
ov. Deft. U.S.'s Interrogs to Machinery 53 C “
oo, me ‘ ¢ y ouyers Corp and Southeast Mice
2N0 Stipulation of parties to record
2>6_ Stiow La on appeal pursuant to Rule LI(f *<!
a 2 CeO.R to forward copies of pleadings in accordance 1p
decifnation of record on appeal, filed. c. counsel.
TTEST? A TTUE Cus
ERtIFI“S tuts “*
i= 1¥-9¥
onl’. Courter, Cle-x
yi } Ne Ui
Deputy Clers
[9]
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR
THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
ATLANTA DIVISION
|Filed in Clerk’s Office Nov. 5, 1973,
Ben H. Carter, Clerk; By: P.J.E. Deputy Clerk.]
GEORGE HENSON MIREE, :
CLAUDE ESTES MIREE and |
DOROTHY ESTES MIREE, Minors, -
by and through AUBREY 8. MIREE, JR.
and CLAUDE H. ESTES, JR..,
Co-Guardians of said Minors,
Plaintiffs, | CIVIL
vs. y ACTION
‘ y -.. NO.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA: one
MACHINERY BUYERS CORP.;
SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, INC.; and
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT
Allegations of Jurisdiction
1.
Jurisdiction herein is based upon 28 U.S.C. $§1346(b),
and 2671, 2674, and 2675.
2.
Jurisdiction is further founded upon diversity of
citizenship.
3.
The minor Plaintiffs herein, GEORGE HENSON
MIREE, CLAUDE ESTES MIREE, and DOROTHY
ESTES MIREE, are all residents and citizens of the State
9
[9]
of Alabama and are represented herein by AUBREY S.
MIREE, JR. and CLAUDE H. ESTES, JR., who were
duly appointed Co-Guardians of said minors by the Pro-
bate [10] Court of Jefferson County, Alabama. Both of
said Co-Guardians of said minors are residents and citi-
zens of the State of Alabama.
4.
Defendants herein are as follows:
(a) UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Appropri-
ate claims for damages for the deaths of RICHARD-
SON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES MIREE were
submitted to the United States Department of Trans-_-
portation, Federal Aviation Administration, Southern
Region, 3400 Whipple Street, East Point, Georgia, on
May 4, 1973. Since that time, said agency has failed to
make a final disposition of the claims within six (6)
months, and this Complaint is brought in accordance
with the provisions of 28 U.S.C. §2675(a).
(b) DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA. Said COUN-
TY is located within the Northern District of Georgia
and within the jurisdiction of this Court. Said Defen-
dant will hereinafter be referred to as DEKALB
COUNTY. The fiscal affairs of DEKALB COUNTY
are committed to a Board of Commissioners, consist-
ing of A. C. Guhl, Chairman, and William A. Williams,
T. M. Callaway, Jr., Hoke Clayton Smith, Robert J.
Morris, W. M. Coolidge, Jr. and Horis A. Ward. They
will be referred to hereinafter as County Commis-
sioners.
(c) MACHINERY BUYERS CORP., a Georgia
corporation, with its principal office and place of doig
business at I-20 East Access Road, Conyers, Georgia,
with an agent for service, WILLIAM J. RIALS, at
said address.
10 ?
; vais
> (11)
(d) SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, INC., a North
Carolina corporation, which can be served by serving
STANLEY E. GALKIN, Attorney at Law, at Equita-
ble Building, Atlanta, Georgia 30303. [11] Said Attor-
ney, STANLEY W. GALKIN, will accept service on be-
half of said Defendant SOUTHEAST MACHINERY,
INC.
The matter in controversy exceeds, exclusive of interest
and costs, the sum of TEN THOUSAND ($10,000.00)
DOLLARS.
Cause of Action
1.
Plaintiffs herein are GEORG. HENSON MIREE,
CLAUDE ESTES MIREE, and DOROTHY ESTES
MIREE, all minors. Plaintiffs show that the Defendants
herein are jointly and severally liable to Plaintiffs for the
full value of the life of their mother, LUCY ESTES
MIREE, in the sum of ONE MILLION ($1,000,000.00)
DOLLARS, and are jointly and severally liable to Plain-
tiffs for the full value of the life of their father, RICH-
ARDSON F. MIREF, in the sum of FOUR MiLLION
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND ($4,500,000.00) DOL-
LARS,
2.
RICHARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES
MIREE died on February 26, 1973, when the Gates
Learjet Airplane on which they were riding crashed near
the DeKalb Peachtree Airport in DeKalb County,
Georgia.
3
Said Gates Learjet Airplane, Model #24, designated
“N454RN,” was owned by Defendant SOUTHEAST
11”
(11)
MACHINERY, INC. Defendant SOUTHEAST MA-
CHINERY, INC. was and is a subsidiary corporation of
Defendant MACHINERY BUYERS CORP., which
operated said Gates Learjet by and through its pilot,
Ernest F. Sellfors, and its co-pilot, David E. Phillips. The
said Sellfors and Phillips were agents and servants of
both SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, [12] INC. and MA-
CHINERY BUYERS CORP., and all acts of said Sell-
fors and Phillips referred to herein were inputable to
Defendants SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, INC. and
MACHINERY BUYERS CORP.
4.
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is located within the bound-
aries of DeKalb County on land owned by the County.
Said Airport has paved runways and airport hangers,
servicing and parking facilities, a control tower with
radio facilities, instrument landing system control center,
and access to other radio and navigational aids. The Air-
port is operated for the public welfare and benefit of the
citizens of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and is
operated under the jurisdiction of the Federal Aviation
Administration.
5.
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, acquired the
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport by way of quit-claim deed
from the Generai Services Administration of the UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA on February 15, 1960. The
County’s personnel operated the control tower at the
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport from March, 1959, until
January, 1963, when they were replaced by Federal Avia-
tion Administration Air Trafic personnel. On February
12
' 7 ‘
7
[13]
i f herein
26, 1973, the date of the fatal crash complained of herein,
the tower was operated by Federal Aviation Adminis-
tration Air Traffic personnel.
6.
inning in 1962, a portion of the land constituting
ane Airport site was used by DEKALB COUNTY as &
landfill. In 1964 the dump was closed and remained
closed until March, 1966, when it was reopened. Since
that time DEKALB COUNTY has [13] utilized the Air-
port site for dumping refuse.
7
Employees of DEKALB COUNTY at said DeKalb-
Peachtree Airport have observed and reported a signifi-
cant increase in the number of birds in the vicinity of the
Airport following the utilization of the Airport site for
garbage disposal.
8.
Prior to February 26, 1973, DEKALB COUNTY had
been using the Airport site as a sanitary landfill or gar-
bage dump where large quantities of raw garbage, re-
fuse, offal, filth, waste and trash by the truck loads were
dumped and deposited upon the Airport site numerous
times during each day by personnel and vehicles con-
trolled by said DEKALB COUNTY through its Sanita-
tion Department and under the ultimate direction and
control of the County Commissioners of DeKalb County.
9.
The said untreated raw garbage, refuse, trash, offal,
filth and other waste material deposited by the Defen-
dant DEKALB COUNTY as aforesaid have created,
13
[13]
and will create, a large area constituting an attraction to
immense flocks of birds which are located about said
Airport, the runways, ends of runways, and other areas.
Said birds at certain times remain, walk, and run upon
said runways and adjacent grass areas at the sides and
ends of the runways, and congregate in the numerous
trees at the end of said sides of said Airport area and run-
ways. Said birds when located upon the Airport grounds
often flew aloft in large flocks many times each day as
aircraft would take off, approach, land [14] or fly near said
Airport and constituted a continuous hazard at said
Airport to the safety of said aircraft and to the safety
and lives of the crews and passengers therein and to
persons residing and located upon the ground in the
vicinity of said Airport.
10. 4
All of the foregoing was known to the Defendant,
DEKALB COUNTY, and to the County Commissioners
thereof and their_predecessors, and to the Defendant
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, and to the pilots
of the Gates Learjet reierred to aforesaid.
11.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, through the
Federal Aviation Administration, maintained a control
tower at said Airport and directed the takeoff and land-
ing of aircraft on February 26, 1973.
12.
The personnel employed by the Federal Aviation Ad-
ministration operating said control tower un February 26,
1973, did negligently and recklessly allow the Learjet
“N454RN” to take off by reason of knowledge that great
14
(15)
flocks of birds were flying in, around and about said Air-
port site.
13.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, by and
through the Department of Transportation, Federal
Aviation Administration, had the responsibility for the
, administration of the Federal Airport Development Aid
Program and its predecessor, the Federal Airport Act of
1946. Involved in the administration of the programs was
the responsibility of enforcing the provisions of the various
Grant Agreements issued in accordance with the provi-
sions of these Acts. These Grant Agreements |15] included
provisions under which the airport owners maintain and
operate said airports in accordance with the standards
said forth in these Agreements.
14.
In addition, the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
had the responsibility for and jurisdiction over the safety
of DeKalb-Peachtree Airport to the extent that it was
the duty of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, as a
condition precedent to the granting of funds for Airport
development, to receive assurances from the owners of
the Airport that airport hazards would be mitigated.
15.
Beginning in June, 1962, the Federal Government has
enter into six (6) Grant Agreements with DeKalb County,
pursuant to which $1,025,224.06 has been paid to the
County for the purpose of assisting the County in the
improvement and development of DeKalb-Peachtree
Airport.
15
[15]
16.
Associated with the various Grant Agreements is an
airport layout plan developed by DeKalb County and
approved by the Federal Aviation Administration which
graphically illustrates the development and proposed
development of the airport facilities and the use of the
land included within the airport boundaries. Such use
does not include a sanitary landfill or any other dumping
ground for garbage.
17.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, through the
Federal Aviation Administration, recognized that the
existence of a sanitary landfill on which garbage was
dumped constituted an attraction of birds of various
species, and that birds [16] constitute a definite hazard
for aircraft taking off and landing.
18.
From March 9, 1970, through February 14, 1972, the
Federal Aviation Administration communicated with
officials of DeKalb County, both by letter and by con-
ference, relative to alleviation of the bird hazard caused
by the existence of the sanitary landfill and the dumping
of garbage thereon. Subsequent to said date of February
14, 1972, and for more than one (1) year prior to the date
of said fatal crash on February 26, 1973, no further com-
munications, either by letter or by conference, were had
by the Federal Aviation Administration with officials of
DeKalb County directed toward the alleviation of such
bird hazard.
19.
Said letters and conferences were of no avail, and both
16
- [17]
the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and DEKALB
COUNTY failed to mitigate the hazard.
20.
On the 27th day of June, 1967, the Federal Aviation
Administration and the UNITED STATES OF AMERI-
CA entered into one of a series of similar agreements with
DEKALB COUNTY, by and through the Chairman of
the BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF ROADS AND
REVENUES. A copy of said Agreement of June 27, 1967,
is attached hereto, marked Exhibit “A,” and made a part
hereof by reference.
21.
Said Agreement, in Paragraph 12 of the Project Appli-
cation, provided as follows:
[17]
“The Sponsor will keep up to date at all times an
airport layout plan ...Such airport layout plan,
and each amendment, revision, or modification there-
of, shall be subject to the approval of the FAA, which
approval shall be evidenced by the signature of a
duly authorized representative of the FAA on the
face of the airport layout plan. The Sponsor will not
make or permit the making of any changes or altera-
tions in the Airport or any of its facilities other than
in conformity with the airport layout plan as so ap-
proved by the FAA, if such changes or alterations
might adversely affect the safety, utility, or efficiency
of the Airport.”
22.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and the Fed-
eral Aviation Administration allowed changes in the air-
port layout, contrary to the official layout plan, when
17
[17]
they knew of the existence of said sanitary landfill or
garbage dump, and when the UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA had the power and jurisdiction to have miti-
gated said Airport hazard.
23.
With further reference to said Agreement marked Ex-
hibit ‘‘A,’’ as a part of the consideration for the sums paid
by the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA to DEKALB
COUNTY, said DEKALB COUNTY, as Sponsor, agreed
as follows:
‘« .. These covenants shall remain in full force
and effect throughout the useful life of the facilities
developed under this Project, ...” (Project Appli-
gation, Sponsor’s Assurances, Paragraph 1).
[18] and
“The Sponsor will operate the Airport as such for
the use and benefit of the public. . . . That the Spon-
sor may prohibit or limit any given type, kind or
class of aeronautical use of the Airport if such action
is necessary for the safe operation of the Airport or
necessary to serve the civil aviation needs of the
public.” (Project Application, Sponsor’s Assurances,
Paragraph 2).
and
“The Sponsor will operate and maintain in a safe
and serviceable condition the Airport and all facili-
ties thereon and connected therewith which are neces-
sary to serve the aeronautical users of the Airport
other than facilities owned or controlled by the United
States, and will not permit any activity thereon
which would interfere with its use for airport pur-
poses.”’ (Project Application, Sponsor’s Assurances,
Paragraph 6).
18
[19]
and
“In addition, the Sponsor will not erect or permit
the erection of any permanent structure or facility
which would interfere materially with the use, opera-
tion, or future development of the Airport, in any
portion of a runway approach area in which the
Sponsor has acquired, or may hereafter acquire, prop-
erty interests permitting it to so control the use made
of the surface of the land.” (Project Application,
Sponsor’s Assurances, Paragraph 7).
[19] and
‘... The Sponsor will not make or permit the
making of any changes or alterations in the Airport
or any of its facilities other than in conformity with
the airport layout plan as so approved by the FAA,
if such changes or alterations might adversely affect
the safety, utility, or efficiency of the Airport.’
(Project Application, Sponsor’s Assurances, Para-
graph 12).
and
“Insofar as is within its power and to the extent
reasonable, the Sponsor will take action to restrict
the use of land adjacent to or in the immediate vi-
cinity of the Airport to activities and purposes com-
patible with normal airport operations including land-
ing and takeoff of aircraft.” (Project Application,
Sponsor’s Assurances, Paragraph 13).
24.
The Defendant, DEKALB COUNTY, violated the pro-
visions of said contract by willfully permitting the exis-
tence of a garbage dump and bird hazard on the Airport
site. Said contract having been made for the benefit of the
public, RICHARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES
MIREE, deceased, and Plaintiffs herein were third party
19
[19]
beneficiaries of said contract and any other contracts and
agreements similarly made between DEKALB COUN-
TY, represented by the County Commissioners, and the
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. The Defendant
[20] DEKALB COUNTY is liable for breach of said con-
tract and any other similar contract, and is liable for the
wrongful deaths of RICHARDSON F. MIREE and
LUCY ESTES MIREE resulting from negligence and
recklessness growing out of the breach of said contract.
25.
On February 26, 1973, at approximately 10:10 A. M.,
E.S.T., air traffic control personnel of the Federal Avi-
ation Administration of the Department of Transporta-
tion of the United States who were operating the control
tower gave clearance to the Learjet airplane designated
“N454RN”’ for takeoff from runway 20L at the DeKalb-
Peachtree Airport. Prior to takeoff and at the time of
takeoff there were thousands of birds in the vicinity of
the Airport and in the vicinity of runway 20L. The exis-
tence of the birds was known to both the employees of
DEKALB COUNTY who were operating the airport and
to the Federal traffic air control personnel operating the
airport control tower. Immediately after takeoff, the en-
gines of Learjet ““N454RN” ingested birds into both
engines. The ingestion of the birds into both engines was
the cause of the crash of said Learjet airplane which
resulted in the deaths of RICHARDSON F. MIREE
and LUCY ESTES MIREE.
26.
The pilot of the Learjet airplane, ““N454RN’’, Ernest L.
Sellfors, and the co-pilot, David E. Phillips, were the
20
(21)
agents, servants and employees of Defendants SOUTH-
EAST MACHINERY, INC. and MACHINERY BUY-
ERS CORP. Said pilot and co-pilot were experienced and
knew, or should have known, [21] that the existence of
thousands of birds constituced a deadly hazard to a jet
aircraft. Said pilot and co-pilot ‘new, or should have
known, on the day in question prior to the takeoff of said
Learjet airplane that there were thousands of birds in the
vicinity of said Airport and particularly runway 20L.
Said pilot and co-pilot should not have begun a takeoff of
said Learjet airplane under the conditions existing at
approximately 10:10 A.M., ..8.T., on February 26, 1973.
27.
By reason of the existence of said garbage dump prior
to and on February 26, 1973, the operation of DeKalb-
Peachtree Airport by DEKALB COUNTY and the
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA constituted a public
nuisance and a hazard to public safety.
28.
The maintenance of said garbage dump at said DeKalb-
Peachtree Airport constituted an airport hazard as de-
fined in 49 U.S.C. 1101, 49 U.S.C. 1711, and was a vio-
lation of 49 U.S.C. 1110(3) and 49 U.S.C. 1718(3).
29.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, by and
through its agents and employees, was guilty of negli-
gence which proximately contributed to the deaths of
RICHARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES MIREE
in the following particulars:
(a) In failing to require DEKALB COUNTY to
remove and mitigate the Airport bird hazard by reason
21
[21]
of the dumping of garbage on DeKalb-Peachtree Air-
port, the same being negligence per se and negligence
as a matter of fact;
[22]
(b) In allowing jet propelled aircraft to operate in
and out of DeKalb-Peachtree Airport when birds were
a known hazard by reason of the existence of the gar-
bage dump;
(ec) In clearing Learjet ‘‘N454RN” for takeoff on
February 26, 1973, in spite of the known existence of
thousands of birds which were located in the vicinity
of runway 20L at DeKalb-Peachtree Airport;
(d) In failing to give reasonable and adequate notice
to pilots and airport operations personnel of the danger
of birds to aircraft at the DeKalb-Peachtree Airport;
(e) In allowing DEKALB COUNTY to accomplish a
change in the Airport layout plan of DeKalb-Peachtree
Airport by establishing a garbage dump thereon, the
same being in violation of the airport layout plan
which had been previously approved by the UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA.
30
Defendants DEKALB COUNTY and COUNTY COM-
MISSIONERS, their predecessors in office, and their
agents, servants and employees, were guilty of breach
of contract and negligence arising out of breach of con-
tract with the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, all
of which contributed proximately to the deaths of RICH-
ARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES MIREE in
the following particulars:
(a) By permitting changes in the DeKalb-Peachtree
Airport and its facilities, other than in conformity with
the airport layout plan as officially approved by the
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, where such changes
adversely affected the safety of the Airport;
22
[23]
(b) In operating the DeKalb-Peachtree Airport for
the benelit of the public, and in connection therewith
failing to prohibit the use of jet propelled aircraft where
a [23] portion of the airport was utilized as a garbage
dump attracting large flocks of birds;
(c) In permitting activity at the Airport and facili-
lies thereon which interfered with its use for airport
purposes;
(d) In failing to restrict the use of land adjacent to
runway 20L of the Airport to purposes compatible
with normal operation of the Airport;
(e) In failing to abide by the specific warnings of
the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA with respect
to the hazard created by the garbage dump and the
requests made to remove said dump;
(f) In dumping and depositing untreated garbage,
trash, refuse, offal, filth and other waste materials on
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport property ;
(g) In failing to specifically warn airport personnel
and jet aircraft owners and pilots of the danger created
by flocks of birds located in and about the vicinity of
the Airport;
(h) In recklessly and wantonly continuing to use
Airport property for a garbage dump after receiving
notice of the bird hazard.
dl.
Defendants MACHINERY BUYERS CORP. and
SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, INC. were guilty of gross
negligence which proximately contributed to the deaths
of RICHARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES
MIREE in the following particulars:
(a) In taking off from DeKalb-Peachtree Airport
23
[23]
when thousands of birds were located in and about
runway 20L;
(b) In failing to inquire of airport control personnel
respecting the safety of a takeoff of a jet airplane on
February 26, 1973, as such takeoff might relate to the
(24] existence of birds in and about the Airport;
(c) In utilizing a jet aireraft for the carriage of pas-
sengers from DeKalb-Peachtree Airport when it| was
known, or should have been known, that a garbage
dump existed which attracted large flocks of birds to
the area.
32.
At the time of his death, RICHARDSON F. MIRIEE
was 36 years of age and had a life-expectancy of 35.78
years in accordance with the Commissioners 1958 Stan-
dard Ordinary Mortality Table, and a life-expectancy of
38.90 years in accordance with the Annuity Mortality
Table 1949, Ultimate. He was carning at the time of his
death in excess of $130,000.00 per year. Plaintiffs herein
show that the full value of the deceased, RICHARD-
SON FF. MIRED, was FOUR MILLION, FIVE HUN-
DRED THOUSAND (34,500,000.00) DOLLARS.
33.
At the time of her death, LUCY ESTES MIREE was
32 years of age and had a life-expectancy of 39.43 years
in accordance with the Commissioners 1958 Standard
Ordinary Mortality Table, and a life-expectaney of 47.77
years in accordance with the Annuity Mortality Table
1949, Ultimate. She was a faithful and dutiful housewife
and mother. Plaintiffs herein sue for the full value of her
life in the amount of ONE MILLION ($1,000,000.00)
DOLLARS.
24
[25]
WHERFFORE, Plaintiff pray:
(a) That all of said Defendants be required to appear
a ro this Complaint within the time allowed by
aw; an
- (b) That Plaintiffs have judgment against the [25]
Defendants in the total amount of FIVE MILLION,
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND ($5,500,000.00) DOL-
LARS, with costs of this action.
HANSELL, POST, BRANDON & DORSEY
By: /s/ Huon M. Dorsey, JR.
Hucu M. Dorsey, Jr.
/s/ Jue W. Ferton, IR.
JuLE W. FELTON, JR.
3300 First National Bank Tower
Atlanta, Georgia 30303
658-9600
JOHNSTON, BARTON, PROCTOR,
SWEDLAW & NAFF
By: /s/ GiLpert E. JOHNSTON
GILBERT E. JOHNSTON
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Twelfth Floor
Bank for Savings Building
Birmingham, Alabama 35203
205/322-0616
25
Page 1 of l poms
FEOLIAL Avisviiom ACEMCY
(26)
> Ba 7. O JUS PH VES, Sos FON
CUiAi tm be Piretebinssles
Pert 1-Offcr
Date of Oller IV 24 33:
eNalo-Teechtree Alrpers
Atlent2, Coorsin
Project No. 9-09-0,9-D(U5
Contrect No. FA-67-50-!,.61
TO: Tae County of Dekalb, Georgio
(here!n referred to 7s the “Sponsor™)
FROM: The Uniiid States of America (acting through the Federal Avistion Agcy, herein re-
ferred to <5 the “FAA")
WHEREAS, the Sponsor has sulmitted to the PAA a Project Applicstion cated May %9, 19957
» for agrant of Federal iui is for a project fov tevcinp
ment of the Deleld-Peechtree — . Airport (Me cn ede
the “Aizsput"), tegether with pians and specifications fox such project, which Project Apoucation,
as approves Ly the PAA is hereby incurpors.te! herein and mace a port heicol; and
WHEREAS, the PAA has approved a project fer cevelepment of the Aieport (hoses ented 209
OP ence ca ating of ane fosowing-deseribed airport devclopment;:
Acquire land for I" cleur zone end approach to rwivay 2h-COL (reimbursement for
Parcel 51, inclvdirs duwiletnz relocetion o- recoral ar. ges Mine reloctacion plus
esatiz:fectory sronerty interests in Aree C era related trensitioral areas);
Behetilitate Atca intensity ligating, rut sy 9-?7 (50,5 onsis); instell r-dius
intensity ligiiing systcn, runvay 16-3); cleur approaches to rumwey 2i-20u.
all os more prrticulul. Covered in the property map and plans and specifications inca: yaactee ba
the said Project App leation;
eo ee ee ee ee | ee ee rac. 1
EXHIBIT "A"
26
BEST COPY AVAILABLE
Page 20f ho pece
ROW CEEOL LORD, porresee te ay hee ts pte of earning amt the paolo nef tc bet aot
Aiport Act, ay amceted (99 US G. Tet aad ba ome onto of (a) the Spur en's adage cet
Balilicatinns we the beget OE teeth cal tie Os cotta an sad Maeepect Agel Hoot, are!
acceptin of ths Caton oe Deven eties ’ doaseetons, ty) the Varela tee aeetoe tee th Unit Soa,
and the goulsle Pron tho accent ef the Piccet ated tho Opn tees eb pert peenee ot ah
Aint ay bev prose ted, TUL PLE ME AVENTIS AGENCY, PO" NNDON Litt ae
THE UNITED SPS, BOE OVERS AND AGH
the slow eble cots micused on eccotiplestiens the Mio, oot,
project costs.
Sto pop, os thee Unie Stan come of
9
99 porecnt of all eovihls
This Offer is made on and subject to the following temas and conditions:
bh. The masxionm oblizstion of the United States payable wncer this Offen shall be
$ 200, 366.
2. The Spunor shall,
(a) Legin accomplisnucnt of the Projet within stety (49) days
° after acceytance of thas Offer or such lower time as may be prevonotd by the TA
with failure to Co so Comsttings pout cause for tenmunation of tne obligations of the
United Stans hereunder by the FAA,
(UW) Gait, OFX BH Comyn’ Hh Propet witout tiue Coley ate i AGO. twee
terms hercof, the Dederal Airpoit Act, and Scetwans 19b49 151.5% of the Paget ois
of the Tederal \viction Ageney (14 CHW 151) an effect ot of the date of accept ice of
this Offer, which Regulations are heremalt-¢ selerred to as the “Veguletions”,
(c) carry ont and complete the Project in accordance with the plons and spcahe non
and property mop, mecorporered boven, as they may be revised OF modiacd wrele the
approval of the LAA.
8S. The allow able costs of the project vill not include any com determine 1 Ly the PAY te
pro) y /
be ineligible for conmderiion as to allowabilay under Section PSLAD (by) of the Deed,
tions.
4. Payment of the Uirited Stores shore of the allowshie project cons will be tice pours ont
to and aa accordomee wath the puevitous of Sections bol 57 -151.65 of the Bee atin
Final deicrmnction as te the allowability of the costs of the projet wall be mode ote
time of the final geo posart poursoet to Scotian Poh G) of the Megudees
that, inthe event asco hil pea ponent is mode porwdant to Section Tob:
Resulonons. fool desctemitian as te the cHowabiley of thee Coots te whats suche on
fival porymcot relates wall be miede at the tance of such somi favid payee
PAA FOAM OTE ETE OTe he CN be te ee ACs
a
[28] [29]
Page Sof pages Pace 32 oF EL es
S&S. “Vhe Sieenwen shall eperate aud maintain the Aig et as Provided in the Project Apy the
Wine Greene porated even anal yas He ally andra ane the appindbes Acvariance with ws contrasts ed Pederally essistet constrecsios eoatvacts pursuant to
Assurane chin Psed Tet eet crud Peejeet Npgencion, that Ha tis apetation aint the ty Hace Pert 11, Suii.a6 Loos bkieesdve Goce io. 1UPL5.
of all facilisis Choreet, mouher i ner any pono Gr otnanizetion occuring spo oe oe Leal
ties thereun will dictummare agaist aay pomon or chiss of poten by tcawns of tare, culo, (c) Ceszy Out evel: ti.ckious est mereltiesr for violztica of the ecurl
Creal or national vtigin aa tle use of any of the Laciliies provided for the public oa the Opprrwusis; cleurs Gs ray Le duzosel] woo contrectors end subsorntrss.
airpent tors by the PA eri the Scurstizy Of Leics prversucat to Fert If, Suc.
pars Doe wacutive Cider No. ee oud in tie event thus the spunssr
Go Vhe FAA iccves the right to ancnd or withdraw this Offer at any time privt to iss fails cr resuscs tu curply with dts uniertetiinss, the MA cay exnced,
acceptance by the Sponsur. tercinate or Ssuep?..d in wi.ole or in part any contractual esrence..ut
40 may hove with the scrousor, eu.y revrain fro: ¢ sending any 4 furth.:
7. This Offer vill expire amd the United Stores shall not be obligated te pay aay part of ihe @ssistance utce eny OF its progzus suejeet te ivesutive Order - “15
cuss of the Proscet anlos this Olice has Leen accepted by the Sponsor on or before until catisicciesy eccuranes oF fyiure esevlian-e has bern received
yw 29, 1967 of such subsequent date as may be prociibed ia writing from such cpolteant, or ety refer the ezse to tne Dezartasat of
by the FAA, Justice for appropriate legtl procecdings.
ae 9. Tne sponsor's fine .:cinl records of the project, estrvl'sincd, maintetine? od
& In edition the egenee? Guses ° made evailzble to persoracl of the Fi. in confurzity to Section 151.55 ef
(a) Incorporate or cuuse to be incorporeted in cach contrect for the Requistio:.s of the Fecorml Aviation Aveucy (14 Cia 151) Will also be
construction work uniter tis progect, or any rotification thereof, availeble to representutives of the Cosptroller Cereral of the United State
the eqvel opportunity clucec? es est ferth in Section 202 of 10. It is unierstool] and emeed that the terns "Adrinistrator of the Felere)
Erecutive Order io. 1i2h5 of September 2b, 1955, or such Aviation Acgcacy,” “Administrator” or “Feder2l Aviation /cency" wherever
modificction thereof as rey be epproved by the Secretery of they apocer in tinis Acreeucnt, in the svebert Apriicavion, plans eni ep2cl-
Labor. fications cr other dotuctnts constituting c part of this Agreereny choli te
@eem\ed to rean the Folercl Aviation Jdscinistrator or the Federal Avinztion
(b) Incorporste or cous. to te incorporsted in ereh bid er propose) Adninistratic: a3 the ccse nuy be.
me subnitted by presjective contracters fer constriettion wert: -
wes AUgect’ the Provisions preserived by Section 1. Motwithstaniing the provision of Poregraph 3, Part ITI, of the Preject
151. Sh(a) (1); Part 151, Federe] Avietion Regulations. Applicetior, the spuasor covenants end roves that ic will not rent cv
F permit any exclusive rignt forbidtes by S22 cum gvola) or the Fedevel
(c) Ee bo.rd by said equal opportunity cloure in ary coustreetion Avietion Jct of dyad (49 U.S.C. 1349) at the wirport, or et any other air-
-WOrk uncer the project which it perfor.s itself other than port now or hereat*er ovre? or controlled by it. Jn furtherance of tne
through its own perrenent work force direetly employed or policy of th: FAA unicr this coveaant, the sponror agrees tat, unless
through the permanent werk force directly employed by cnothe> euthorized by tne Aaminiscrator, it vill — either directly or inuirceetly,
agency of government. @rant or perait any person, firm, or corporation the cxclusive rignt at cae
@irpor. or at any other eirport nov or mot recster onc) or controlles by it,
(4) Cooperate ectively with the FAA end the Secretery of Lauber in to conluct eny aeronzuticc] activities, including, but not linited to,
obtaining tie corplicnee of contrectors and subcontractors vith charter flights, pilot training, ecircrafi rental and sightseeing, atrial
the equel cpjertunity cleurc end the rules, regulations, and photography, crop dusting, eerie] edvertising end sursevirg, air eorricr
relevent orders of the Sec.etary of Labor. Operations, circraf:s sales ani services oor of tviation potroleus proivets
2 whether or not condusied in conjure tion with Other acrontutical activity,
(e) Furnish the PAA and the Seretery of Ledor such informetion 4s repair end crinserencys of airernft, ste of aircralt ports, end ony other
they mty require fer the sup rvision of such cozplicnce ene activities which beccuc> of their relations!t{p to tne opcration of afreiaft
Will othciwice ecriet the FAA im the discharge of its prisary can be regsrdel] es en aotronnuticz. ectivity. Te spousor further agrees
Fesponsivtility for securing cor pliance. that 4% will terminate any such evclusive ricgit (inch ting tny exelssive
right to ensece in the scle of gasoline or ofl, or doth) nov existing at
(tf) Refrain fron enterirg into any contrect or contract rodification the eirport, or et any other airport nov er hevescter ovnm J or controlled
subject to Exceutive Order No. LI2k6 with o centractor deborrd by it, at the cerliest rert.c1, cancellation, or exsiritton dcie anvlicsele
frou, or wid has not deronstreted eligibility for, Coveriwesnt to the ecres:ent thet estcdliched tne exclucive: rigi.t, ani certifies that
there is no exclusive right mot suvject to teriinsiion uncer this provision.”
PAR FOUN 125k FE COD OTSTMOY PP CHIOUS BuLtion PACE S
28 . 29
[30]
2.
Pace 3b of 4 Pages
e Felers1] Govermiont Cres roc nov pla or ccuionpiate the coustructi«an
oe ony? sirvrtwwes possvens to Povecrach 9 of Tert TXT © Ssencsos's Assvve
QNCCS OF Vrs Projcst epvlier.4c%ea Cod oy 355, OST, end, ti=vezore it
e's
8 wndersvess a.n eorisd Ghat the Sross0r ds witty ro oblis:.ticn to
furnish c:.7 ar225 or rich ts without cost to the Pederet Covesiwsst waer
this Grant Asrcernonte Muvever, rot! a “2 sca heroin choll We con.
etrue] es elverirs or ehongins the vishts ef the Urdtsd Suctes ant/os
the ovlicvticss o: the Svo:ser u:ter nye yee Acrionints to fucnaisa
rent-free space fer tbe celivitics specified in such agreements.
==
[31]
Vase dof be ye.
The Sponsor's recep onere of Cite Cover awd artificetion end etytica of the Project Napticutins
Incorpan ied heecin sictl bes evita by exceuticn of this iesteaace by Ube Spumer, ie ae...
after provided, cee! gol Oiter aon Aeeepioes se Gent abe os £ Geant “Stee. rarity As Prusala +
the Felssci Annort Ack, ce titwairg the ulations and bis Lis ed hs Unie dikes and Lee S;
sor wil we arect i sa setae Crees GS Cine Pose oad Us ejects. Mo Wad eabeteas ees OF Mee alee
port. Such Gr: pteeetliitt alhad boca efrecting aye ing Seow sor’s acceplouce of this Odded ¢
sliall remcin in re se cow ci.ccl Ubwuar out tie uss ful hte of the f. cities € treatin rol unmacr lie
Project bul in any eveui 10% to cacced tweety years frum tire cate of sind accep tance.
“"
UNITED STATIS OF AMERICA
FLD. .L PA LtiO denateattha’
ADI ATTIS ATIC:
(E>. i 2 7”
By ne TL “Zo. AILS a
(THTL™:
Arce lenager, /tleats
Part LU-Acccptance
The Councy of DeNalb Cou:ty, Georgia does hereby ratify and adopt cll statement,
representations, Warrantice, covenants, and eorecucnts comlained in the Project Apyicution a
Incorporate | weatccisls refered to an the fores oing Oster and dues hereby accept saul Chics sim
by such acceyinnce agrees ty all of the tering and conditions thereof,
» r
Exccuted this... wow 7 fi, _ dzy of . TP a wm, F FE
County of Do! tald/ Geoscia
ff, ,, Homnet Sponge)
. Fa, }.
o*® a vit fags °He . ,
(SEAL) Se cbnee ie Haoning, Wr. dite <
ae i he Gaeake on, Borrd of Cenmissicar.:
\ i. 7 eas : a of Reids and hRevenees
Attest: PE Sg icy POPE LP LOSE .
‘James E. Carroll
Title: Clerk, kocrd of Co:maissioners
CERTIFICATE OF STONSON'S ATTORNEY
~ . , sce
Lag /f oss ge 74460 Cee Cacting as Attorncy for COMAty Of Deralb, Grorgis:
(herein arate to as the “Sponsor’) do hereby certify:
That IT hoxe exer iced the fovezoing Grant Aciecment and the procesdings taken by sal
Sporsor re'ating the cto, “saad find that the Accemarce thereof by said Srome or has been dels auth.
orized ond that the exceut.ou thereof is ia all respucts due and propor cad in accordance ¥ an tine
laws of the Stuie of Georgia , and further tiat, inimy opinion, seit Grn
Agreement constituies a legal and binding obligation of the Sponsor in eccordance with she levine
thercos. QO
Dated at Decatur, Georgia... this 2.7. day of .Sf.4.--- 4 Qe 7
<Z. «* ¥ ne cone tae
_ is
- one ‘gy’ - 4 é
PARA FONT 46972 192d YOR OM WhOUE CoHTION PLOt «4
31
“4 1¢/ do966 i oe
(32)
orm A oprery.
Reeret Perma a Of R34
UNIO STANES OF BMCIITA
FIDERNY ANUATIO.LAGINCY
ws ? aod ° ~
I vv ers ~~ IOL's: yy
SS ee aes a OF yes y
(For Federe! Aid for Deviloposeat of Public Aivports)
Part I-PPOJSo¢ WFONRATIGN
- i TT ee
The - Pears Count (herein entices!
the Sponsor ) hereby makes application to the Iedersl Aviation Aseney (heroine ftor
called the FAA"). fer a ceont of Feceral funds persurnt to the Federal Airport Art
and the Perwistions ic:ced thereunder, for ths Warpo 92 Of sidies in fintneing 2 preject
(herein called the “Frojezt") for development of the _NthAlh Peacityrcs:
Airport (hercia called the “A * cate
rs ya P ( cc Airport’) located
State of Cos G14
a is proposed that the Project consist of the fullowing-described airport develop.
ment:
Acquire land for zpproaches - ruavay 2R-20L including
reimbursenent for trict 51; r1chabilitate hich ntens ity runs
lighting, runwoy 9-27; install meciun intensity lighting
System, ruuwey 16-34; clear approaches to runway 2k- 291.
oft os more perticutariy doscribcd on the propsrty map ettached (hereto as Ex!ibit
A ds ache Eki tal fo ProjcstAppliestion d2*cad for
Project Di d-2n+emene eres cmeea=)%, and in the pinns and specifications suh-
mitted i the FAA on 232-5, DIE 2 end pss avas sth xe are 8 which are
made a prri herco!.
a
*Sthint Oct the Inaoprope'ate el iuece
Ar -- -
FAS Foo is Poo: 4 (900) OTLETE Files toe «1
32
- Pe. 2
Tur Pewocnig Mss Secerssny of tar Esvistcenn Cogs oo air Tare:
“a pies —aA io A dai odd
Esvetavt> Psvinsvet"
TOT, SPuKs2a'S Sake FROTLAL Seater
rv ESTi*. \179 OF Cont | OF COST
oss Tc ecxe ert | went | oe og
ASIOUNT cone! oad seeptheancltshs cry
1. Laxu Corrs 361,732 160,066 ‘S86 | 185,066 59
pron, = —rs —— a re cmeeee ©
#2. Conszucrims Costs | 24,900 |
3. LNGINY w8s ANY | j i
Survie C39 3 3,000 ! '
4. Avrisisccin7 Coe] 990 ,
0G. Tota! of 2,2, ni 4 a, aS er ig oapy BAR
akove 22,000 17,090 50} ,009 5)
Sanne sme L000 tS SEO! 50 z $4506 190,
q% Sota Aww Esiistavid
Prosrcr Cosas
(Items 1, | 5, one C) __ 199,73? | 200,36¢_ | 200, 386 . a
*fhese items vill \ Vary ror County ond PAN £anrG Of COS hie:
258/75% for N.I. Ruwway lighting syste costs are cetermincsa.
Part H-REVACSLIVSATIONS
The Spousor hereby represents and certifies as follows
1. Legal Auth orit ty: .—The Sponsor has the legal power and authority :,.€1) to do ell
things neceseery in oreer to urdirishe ane carry Ot te Peugest in conformuaty wath the
Act eed the Mosohitisny, (2) by acacpt, receive, aud visyurse grants of tunds froin the
United Sizics in sid of the Project, on the terms and condit.ons sted in the Act and ihe
Regvletions; and (5) tocerry out ail of the provisions of arts Il and IV of this Project
Application.
2. Fuinde.—The Sponsor now has on deposit, or is in a position to secure,
$200,265 ___ for use in defraying the costs of the Project The present status of
these funds is as follov.s:
Airport construction and improvement func
3. Compatitts Ls +e Usre.—The Sponsor hrs taken the following actions to ass.irc
compatible uscce of land edjaccat to or in the vicinity of the airport:
Airport zoning has been passed en? approved by the Federal
Aviation Agency.
Adeavet> property interssts are being acuuired in clear
WON.
eer
Bai. os20.0 3% oe 6 e208 ean aun
wruaecanauret
[34] [35]
«3
‘ “reli ee i ‘rej . " (L) The Epoutve wil evyuire within a re:cynabl: tira, Bat in any event pri i" tu
. we rel td cr etse The Project hos been ry proved by BN boned ecesnl the stert of sry eonstrecticn work under the Mroject, the following preperty imine. ie
agensles Whoes nprrovel is sequined, nacaely: the feller b:.38 atts Of Lond’ en wileh such comsireciion work. is to be poriornied, all of
which ere<s sre ileatilied ca the alerementionsd propery mep @ezignaied as Leh.uit
“A”:
NONL 29Ul.D
NOME ROU)
6. Dzisutis.—The Sponsor is not in default on sry oblivation to the Uniled Etnies or
eny ezency of Us Uniied Stvtcs Governinent relative to the development, operation, or
tisintenance of cny airport, eccecyt as st:ied herewith:
NONE
6. Pessibls Disabilities. — There are no facis or circumstancis (including the exist-
ence of cl{cctive or proposed leases, use agreements, or other Jere! instruments affecting
use of the Airport or the existence of ponding litigation or ether legs! procecdings)
which in rezsoncblic probsbility might make it impocsilic for the Sponsor to carry out
ivi i 2 will sequire withi conzb's tine, and if fessible prior to tic
and coniplete the Project or carry out the provisions of Parts lil and 1V ofstie lroject {c) Th Syorsor on oo hag tors bn — serena gee bys
Applicution, cither by limiting its legal or financis! rbilily or otherwise, except as foliov's: corr piciion of all cerct: ueston werk CNTs ene a open dl alten tn ennee «
the following sracs ef teed! which cag ty be Gov eicycidl oF Wass bap oe OO oe BS tated ware
with (he Air faa ih «ii be epom completion of the Projeci, all of which ercas are ic.n-
NONC
tified on the sforezacntioncd properiy imap designated ss palibit “A”:
Satisfuctory property interests in Area C end related transitioral arces.
7. Lavd.—(a) The Sponsor holds the following property interest in the following
areas of Jend’ which are to be developed or usec as part of or in connection with the Air-
port, subject lo tne following exceptions, encumbrances, and adverse inicreasts, al! of whieh
areas arc identified on the eforementioned property map Cezignated as Exhibit “A”:
There has been no chance in property interests in tracts No's.
1,2 2nd "i." since submittal of report of Latvyers Title Insurance
Co. dated Merch 14, 1962 and Title Examination by Yobert E. Hosiey
dated June 5, 1963, for Project No, 9-009-050-0402. Fee Simgle tite
to tract 51, subject to terms and conditions contained in Quit-clain
Deed dutcd Oct. 14, 1965 from General Services Admin. to Dakeld Co.
Fee Sirple Title to tracts B-1,C,D,f,F,G,i,1,0,0,3,U,32,34,34A and
35 wes acoquir:d uncer -02,93,ane 04 projects.
The Sponsov further ecrtifics that the above is based on « tithe examinztion by a qualified
atlerncy or tile company and that such atlorney or title company has determined that
the Spensorv holds tie above property intercats.
*
‘she on ow — See + ote nee Ore Bast 0d Oret'ty Ber Oem 290 Ore. HiRe « enemEmeran Ee. OO"
Osa tee tite See ete bed ar Ss atte, teeta tens bet) eosene na bee gw ete, The espatate Atese of toad fee eer s&s “se Se eo dione Gane be Qfeyerty & ty.
Only be editelite el bee by Une ane Pembete eee OH the pregerty tity @alp be Moetlo d » ts by bow Cee Bethe te Bee OM Ee bie,
en
‘cc
a* ees ere Paes & as
— Tel ee ~ sn
FAN Venu! 43°. 533 we) «sco . FAY Fiona it eee
fon ec ae neee
Wer ac ee ntee
itm --- --
[36]
(37]
’
1 42% See. SPai oe
or s abiees ee & eas is
° ‘ cet te furs Be rt ‘m—° su 3
Ud fi athe § the ae- owe yore
wited Sui wpe Ae ‘at iteGe boeqe et
ise, Oo sie 7 Ces sRuni -@ ty ¢%
' . furtw sa: THUAis wd oaee 4 Act ood
. The -3 wath the OCcr sp is
ae coven aad e-: . epret
ents het eatin er 7. cin. fst
~* af: b.--e- ste
« . ro effects » ap Fem coven, ot 8 , =. a hin ou geese end
$e ° ne _v ty Cones .
tho? rt oid for ce seve pV € a8 prvviced fer t . t . %@ owe . . ’ t:.: 6e wre of re reanslty _ {hbo
. 1 A tint 6 sit Ady, er tthe public en e ese any of an = eet; & ag 13 oF 7 f. pit Be + } mangtry fies te £
» ae — ; Sine i..ét? @ - b. Thet in on mes Apu 2 th: 3:- — 7.9 oo o. end orf wr te: ee eo: y ° rd C+ ature elst ro
s® sewusth . ced: % ore « aoe oo ee wires of. “eo eheotie® Y ~ Art J ore? ‘
ance of an oflcr of tb. “sey “4 she Gad a + cen ot une y anna oneed. t ares ef F dn On alk eg ar ehotis® OF S°- *te,° > An “+ : - =. poe 22 88 Udee-
‘Poe ra tune etaner ie > onthe ure fet. arch net, Ieaw, oF 0” anc! s+. of tue @ re oe get mec ened?
sfaté “d a eo ¥ erent . Poale « ¥ PCr en oe Gt peste » OF Gi? a2 ste ra “ crate fe rs @ #.0T9%.% te . 8G." cs o'tds, & _° -— 2
Zt The a sue the Prepect { sand aves rt ony weds, . r\.2¢ he de Ny eur*4 oe Bs the .at: ~ * rt wale Bre . r’ . ae se oe a lh sal cS Sy - 8: ead 1 rs ‘ort wat » OF tsne g*
an . ere . ww @e> - ser cue * th ‘ -#t to ’ ~ base © . -° - se a. hry .
Sy! : WLS OF the A onsets the A ineert a eee of heme be tetad, on all ig Mi A, vier Re ae ae ay £.. Toes po eo the A Riot. ere? ee ert.e : °
Sponsor anes the ty - hs dorian wrt as such fo v4 enforces seouainn the 4 a “ety eine 3a.% he a foe & we) So 8 on ae ah Cocetecut. AA, Ezra reqerrs, “a ton 2. “ear © 3
ell oe eh 0 leet — Jan tape pony « of th r the [1008 Paguiring ° “$: pore atts = tr n*" oe Ge ‘e" £0 €ege of «
oe cad enn V 3t gh uy Rye meg 9 t (1) te furris quiring "Se Corti: Ais on ww’ bys : : a R ." toed 11. THe S cities
- Siren oe? ° . "ie" ae wl e."t ae “te 4 2.22 . ane ‘ » . 4 ae
Thatnee § belweat to's att Gs EETONS ate Se Aer wb, Hos vajes'\; srid sorvice uture G.. =. te piaieett obs re Sirweeiure OF . wo.bie autre will ast
j pone ah typae nouree at 7. Gin gy diver. cecnafl wey?) ws €% ef tic m:.@ 6..¢ @: fac. ( te Co? enter in
gusty Seer eent wr Mas ¢ ri se G4. ond OF wee Wehnous " an cumatery bes: vino egal, er? here: sre tte ates ues oe seit, ort, on Kat @5-88e: 5) necetraty to 3 oO, THve aos st ts pny trite!
ne . os ; ™ t - <@ 20% . eg - = ° . °e —— cede he - = Ses ; m ** bs a. fh °
deport as say tery ce weoaas is £00 ¥ .: ianited A ng Fy et: i =p ayhy se, #2 rat : Sporsor $ Ad et o wnlecs by ad ms tay or al ty of tee r+" one ye
tien of the A y le = ety tte by 9.98 yw. |, ond au se, (2) to % a’ de.0 2 ust tasle . pe ecru! p Oe ° eox.tat te , for ; «be eo 082" 8 Om ee
may ee yet Aupers, + y bur the 3..f $ by cI’ 6 tun charre frie one 3, of 3 FAA? ff er zitesat . o te ogee
bavlic 1 “on b od hy - Dew dteslé gufe oom € ~ sts of the ¢riminctory 7 , rensonadle, an’! s. 4 iz uh Vo 89 Cer such prs Ne e. 2 bet ee e - epseett ¢' S
2 ‘ nee ers ’ ee eo pde “ . ™ ° ae >" . > ef esse ,
ate 0,023 Of bie Ae; a on iene, bond Tra: the Sokaese 2 Vist te > ee for each e at unjust! and he frei ss eh heh euul res: sai ogo ot weg Wesal to ve. 9%
evistics | eve: tl ; af sack sc, heed, or cf Smeaser on: Lie sitaths ‘et ers a = Pe a hingort d » pent steers jus
2 oved ertp net a Cine @§ 2 bat le and me o may 2 Ot we, will be 7 sfortre ts . tae 4 cnt is o .@ : P :
3 of tn port er ne bs Hegessvey i nero. es, of ot! ome eerie . 2 eexw€ p . 2 wsuthiay elrrncdre2! : sity Fed-r:! any tte aos [O° 0.02 of i
aT e pubs stesety to verenn, by the voluinc Kae he gua ieoun et On teh A iy One. vs" . ner Une? $3.4: - : ath 3 Tush GF gster’ . ig eves
he cw oils. price tee ey th o.cr y Metta? s-<42 of at S, oneer, tt 7 Sere &
for t.> Sponsor will . ¢. Tha SEUTS.4 oO nmavalar .- erst, enece — end masil 6 ost authors to < . . ut ;
Federal Ac. of the - not grantor lege +. oh it will ret as to such von of Sn | ; ~ et ui the pa b, er mainrtine’ Ar wees tues Oe & t. ies ‘cone CR "+0
) . $8 . ort . everc 4, hy = cane aan ett . ste ‘ & dt%g% i
all ar. virtose Ac port forted A rmit any exch corpor: wh ¥ ould ao ercise er promt 8> sed, ef t:.> ec tcf erecet fe ets jf moelicry ed thee: covensn’ cee or ce Wiki fp vie vet! "he on 2.1
Pylvedte sto. i nb clueive rt tion ger atn rent cue no b: ov chore ants. i the A t:
eut Genleis w laws. Ja te ~ ane’ will » Sette Jes right formuns: ay shies ee = on se rishoe PAA, or oh: « evepes = ahaa ak he x} et, the begetet e ?°
2 > ‘ tte -* ‘ *hhe © ~ . te Ps ms : . i a ‘ - . : ais ed eitet giatesrt, &
: ite scuttal 2p: cance of tn: Secsan Genaniee t'.: plesees. dine grees om ts ton the: i.” Scat, On « @? egenrs, substont Cail — wine Ceters §:.c0232°.8 12. Th '
proce nat ‘cn va Souetty pens (set Ly pair) that ia oe eg, bet net be a riceraie s "a3 jeem : — ws'l &: ilhwee cf! on cur SHOraee ot j a by tre layoe! ¢! Sporeer ys Thee p
Bee ‘ . 8 with. os t henuted ir at a iret Conse" ort & . "7 = Se oe ef ao ° = tnd
° eve: d C*S Duihyrrs tect), the & . sy chovse ‘ tor its om aft are cord te y tubes Vorr Airy: \r @-« doterts’
a dy tet oo derccutly reed by we OTonTe 2 to per Wah et * FAA mi cccr @xs.t vt? ry end n ne rpert: aa al ties
. wit t%s *. oF i wy ve ud - the A r d. sgre. erce a , voull “ . oF tars : . error svat bound eit ,ee; 2-74 stm (1) the seterne
nz be 2: © : uri wn aie ducetly, —e In the > Of- ethe rt weal: ¢ Yate © ors 6! undzr.5 of aan ' we Lowe e
2 bet ret! 4 . wi iwe rianl or » rig l event ts r eutheric.c yerfore wit - = wn: er + ce 2 g0ef alt effs-2 ot pg bi teat gir, of :
renul luted aus sCiutive Piste. sts and pr 2 Syor zc enezal ona eof the) yries ef Ue fercr ° ow 3; oO. P , & ce 2
; antl : we ee sere regs sees p, wil . sor its-lf ore + tre ar wan 2) tre: pert per > hiw © Poe
giv htee tter 2 wrt ser inve! nte te oak sctlf ¢ a vrors nee? ‘- <8 of fr courte.
serial rcverti hisesiye, 32 fips ska, Pew’ SA Up bday HS tse Woes vs wal b: ferzet tam Seng ty Page 4 . - oo Fi any ce'eneor me Abode, port {= , von Pad fate ne prose le? . .%
craft sste; trans and s ce.al plete vi trcim.ee . 6.606 .- PM spyly tu t prod .d en subs ctr & tt! oo ver le Five (5) of tr pain teat epre- chives ond re re eof: et eyes tes GP i3.—q0e %
vreeyer re - “s were ar 2: pie! ’ . on +" . yor . ag ileal —@ 3°
wheib er or to —— pp “s. Oo te crop na ef such subsection oo ESF Owe ona, CIA : aig dosed ot the —hny ‘tnry or nivel a prope: awh at ¥e- mae (iets 2° 5am Ae
wot On tected om o FN poowry Ger st NRe cut + OF ate : ee hey oy ; . or irersft t Sez orn 8s, "tg te 8°
eds veo yeratior vhon b “2 ae on bane are Wr es, and : an rc ¢ ,
« nec" » , i. ‘Ss. Alt. - . f Gg *?° ec “nV ° { ! ‘5 ‘ a.
grate yrs ard > vation w a. . prew ae S. Nothi . tees GS OSs & amore tetal ruc ber jncent Shereso, oF avintinn A} : ron of oe ext of S suse , on = *
st reict ee @:her -e of : t*cr. ere: . th ine ¢ 1 “esr th ‘rel m - eitpect iy . : . Puce *? ‘
. bo veh r ett. aireaal on rw. egray a“ ontrine ” puiit- exomont ro? ave? ven"s ait Isyeut : Sagres jem? er
onete cuca oe - «per aan tire which b . vale of on in,- of ae or ever : hove n shall be tf OF BAe! - fanch ties », (count: ac: each land fiction tices nnd are ate, — a" te — 3
be st the gra. Petisetes Ff of airerod .au-e of th ners cre Ait tien prod of an exelus cotrtrucé te p A vateiiee 8 vee ta2ees es e@ moe “ whieh saaeeeel a , suath be sulre. rent, ¢ ms e *
trein in oor Pp. Pre vérd tern be cir ctonautical provits end we rch se? i irport (:* oe + OS teste: ace ae te 3) 3 quitheete =| stsrah b tteth: on :
lies & eeamhen’ alter : te’ on pan Png tre a eset ate parieulae nates ge 00 an vie 27 wt §.2 Ce i: . guvltiticd e ie pacriean, e of raya deiinng eo. -@ vor a $ t:; shak b. aver ne dk: wens et'the } ,
whic’ vrplus pe * no case rsine ponte t thetw nenttre et : ty get , la oo) = , a : of multe’ eresk vou vet otea FF rive ef M2 3° Sarre 2%.@ .
surol eye 300 at hertiors < os eet a reutical az Se e1i@ ©. f excess of eerinfeed ver vt akirs Ody & Bremgd pe ea.?76
Unit 4 Mus > sme ecto" offer acre no fiee weights tate «: * . " é ,
‘ preps: vrumn at ovsoftheS th c T wc atu so fur milven yp sels sive ott any chore o-* By _
(er > poy ve ard aah oe cer me hy ne'er po Soersor -' service eo Goanuee ott ¢ t the Aupor. ° wr poen’s weh esreraii) e c! af ~~ tiles ober oy o alte en* naan ame Ol t. —
tr » ser 2 > ~ = Bn ates we Nerpers
d. 68 cmerded. e Surples P the Sporser - to and cow: CUMC ible t's ‘Ne te and m™ furnish encver 0 reyaneted teratic: 5 30 sanroved by ef oat wet \irsers oF
. rovert sr be the °° OCF ctea the itrort ais.tein in eh vstiout ert 4 by th i prright & oy the PAA, thie orp ert!
4. The S$ w Act of 19; or ons utes) users of tia whch and stl fre B - erfe ::° tion, eyerene et int! bee FAA, the $ ciency of tne A Se etecly afiest a cath Ob On8 :
the uc A ronser cores oo eor.tee'ked by 4 of he Rises are reets.ct tee 3 ees eontrcl ect...t ord pereaters — 1 Govesrt - ee wil wporkl “ “ cadete, wictet a
terms 1. benefit ~ og Ht will & {\ ay © e988 tt.- United _— viher th... = Oe oree? % a epiastien oat? , OF ve ay ef fests ~ fo ae Oe | 33. 3 — =
this coven wit! cut ur { the pulte porate Ue A i purys oe wa ho \eur od teen ond i Zac tars of lind or pe Stew iinn s gat ted t eres. > ect e Gin th. ice chic, iy ma cots vith:
ead enant (bet eh haces en fare ; ivnert fo © eerste : Procuted ‘4 wterfere * Sione* pea th: S eter, or ev? J toc tre! tivstres ona ths Spoons nits pore
effecs), Baw wintest bn rene ton L- tp etc Ai aaetionl wed to rere - fact eeth: ev.th its ure 2 . for ened oe the 3 . *e Georeen ba - cosine! onal Cus ed,.« i r+ a wall tats € “ ven to th: ex t29"
« . se te tre - ba nd . 2 * »~'*\* ° : ia c.'2 bes
Sper-ee ster a wrtheras et’: ~ vice du tthe A 2 conta! * ers’ auc. A s ery ix‘’s are>s ectivil wm the wean > 1¢° ee eT?
ef sprees ts general = rose @ ther efiisnhe bice® Cec Auccor te such trou at Pec covsfer re butic >> Ts ee a-scdiate * a@% ti¢ “a
&. That in it ‘really guven — cy skencaity - o V oy — = on oa pone ete rates 2: host of eres roars ber prr-e a anan uty ere .< teams Ut, land re5 CET cee s bay way of om li
on the ai its or: ~ms ond az : shail! ple 0 » nt fare s Gre; ore he $ tie g- Srptes Nitele {spare er feeds : é.nz and y eared? yer. 3
© Birp enorstior wrecs i b* ce Vowen’ fare werd ¢ will be s- J vy ety ow 6:90 cul ie: trleof!! oe .
ot, neil nv ond the s te steucd a ve a Perch or -? ee 97h fest wtesee s ef rea off of arent p-t. epers:
. thee oper. atreon Ff as rej a er, ‘tes of.tet ect. S: o Naa tas Gree 9 SN OF ‘ as o7d tt 4. Wf oft
Woeor any ey ef all focibti — a oy acerrrke ae : tert WR ae tenwes f ar ae ry or step a et Arrccor:crt a» . ne so rete y is eny pad _ tire it is ect> ¢
om Of Orgs: “7 ms hee cond AMA veU O sv Steuciart - eco. ponte . aequ Rere.a wt} ba dmereas - 9 = tothe i 2 property Meng ~r.chte reused by the
“cauen s son r ds eer tas yucst from , 4 i) he ors ° - eke t reine! FAA ed tt
, Pensor. Ob cHtcemstar famed Gun Oo a0 oni of G* whe BAA. sonths efter ree dh ) tibd, end 7 “mn thee set piles im op 30! :
«ec beyond tb. srrtet C : eccipt of wr..tt rick of wte “ J Tied, to ex hg fersh wy Var -_— ts
© control 30. The Sp — porfer teefererce vt istenee of vr 4 oF. gatss
o: 3 or sprcint ; sear 8 tt a . ace ae 6? ve pcoveh the of trttion = i oa .
be reat Bnd r3 fomcue ‘ the FAA 4 BIE, EMV He erase Of te ae .
me " malend yA eth se ma mans Pd mea? s Port.
forma f Ff cad. & ayveet » such one wer acces 4 anal t need
wrasse by te Sccis tepotis? } renests 2s —_ : vble to the ‘FAA » teght of cloiss we
AA, eov be ae? x ¥ : of 9°:
" oe ms) ve 5 subwastes en 1$ Uniers th
e< yublensited fe such in there ec 2 context otter .
Section 77-73 ' Seaclotions abate vpich oF > a requires. 2" 40
7 of on on 31 sae ave the ™ ins fined um tet i. a ured
Pr ~ TT of t: Lied t> Can? CSNiNSes etsice ee ee n
- c ~ - ott t
reeer ction -. & ta hem *
a> Avix s on Re 1T-2T7 16. Bb cm +
y . «- &S a“ . »! °
PEA Yori Galatisns. » “hibst “7,”
tice Po72S ‘ontiserininc’ » Spoons or —
Pe o— a” "= = he - .
76% nade e por ion, is othe ear nies <«f
art herve’. hed nerete &
7A
FA% Fess i092
° iy 3G
- wen
he on”
36
37
[38]
-Moe 7
We LM ede be eon on™
Par: } EU? eo wok good | At :
DAR By
hee Pecicet oF spy : ° ne
if hong Projes* or ovv postion thereot is eppreved oy ts : FAA, anden offer of led
eral cid fer such ipprovet Peoicet fs cccepisd be Ure Bee: ide wateortool ond sero
wf - is ’ . ° “ts . PW OHS Be OG
tha: ail al poses Cevalu: mn ..% 42 elu .e t in nuech }¥ re} a ili po ree omy:
with the Act ord the Mrevkt
approved bs Ue PF
mw] in eccod ine:
one, tes plias cud cpecifiextions fur such @ velopnacat, 2%
AS, and the Grant Agreement wich respect to the reject.
IN WITNESS WUE OT, the yl ™
‘7 r hes caused this Projcct Apyiicstion te be duly
executed ia its name, this Red 5 de day of ee Te hi 19 ak
— Dekalb Cowity, Croreii
(Reme of Lyonser)
7?)
_—-" oy * °
By<*: “Ne aire “4 wtf 3 i> Beoerer? VV
4 ’
——-s =~ ee ee -*
Brince li. Nanning, Jt. Ty
Chairmen, Roard of Connissionsrs
Of Bezts ep fryvenue
¢Tstie)
OPENICN OF SPONSOR'S ATTOUNLY
B mreecy cetticy that all statewerts of '>1
mede iz ais Vroiest Arwlicsiion ccs elt lecs!
Conclesio worst which Obs sew enmentinn —
gcoveaants contained herein arg based, ere in
My opinion trve end correct.
George > PF. Dillare
DeKeld County attoracy
(Teele)
.
ee - . , ~ ©
"2 ¢ ‘ °*« ; - se
~ ’ / ‘ z ‘ ‘
7 eee ee See Bet
sic
en
oe
SVM GIR LODWLLCS 6 foo. NIST
am
POR A ChaAtr CS FUT Tn Te NALIOE 2 Me Oi. Titoli OS Siw
eh ~ her NO. goers, S%° £2 SY So. 7
* T= i . @ 6 ri
— ATAMWAT
Koss ery: ’ Site Sa rete 7 rs ees Set * «f (2 T Se Tn orucr Oo
Boor SOP So te ee ee Me SS 5 aguuling a> >. ann Se
Tuctis Uo esenra C25 Toate. VF Sheds 74 GO. GY Be peg greabeer Ci
WOSk, end ty Pct 19 oF *s Posen Avristion Kegadteio:s, a3 fo omted, *.*
Hoialh Cove’, Grorceir (i eorsineftier e:lice tic
qqymenee ees a0 =o te sown elo aan + © mmm» Catena ES 4
Sasacer p ocreey Cv. Ties Orcs View the Uncved otetes (hercinalier
eall2i tre "Cover.cent”) is rollow.:
Yne Srovnor in the oter.t.icn end we o the PeKelh Peacnht:
Airport, vill not on % vaits Of Pees, COlw, CF Noesowth Oeil, Gite
: : hy! ): c = r
gn eny Cuucs prohibited oy Fare 15 of tie Federa) Aviat.ca Rogvlsavicens.
Gn2 Sor.cor vill ircluce, oF Fequa
eovens.t in every S5oeR%.27 % OF CGus
,
persous, ote: thar tie Sporsor, ope
fecllit, o1 the fairy,ore Provaas
granting the Syctser ths Paces
@irect to enforce such covencns.
nd : ? + - oe ae
Norceomolicrze with the cbove acsure!
and in tne event of suc soncompl:
action to enforce courliance, I
5 te
this coven=nt relates, cr scex gure
on CP Erces ws F-F
re the inclution of, the fore 3=9i1.%
cesslen pussutut to wilels eny FoSLon oF
erates os has th2 right to ogerctve =",
se public, and % pravisicn
yes the Goverimrcns 1-3
~ - 4 ‘ ‘,. . > ‘
reas candi coustitute # eaterial bi ty
nee Ane Coversacint sty tee @25e%o lu t
‘ cc . "4 . - >
yrurcie whe Grert #orecc.nt to wuss
**
2e.% *_*
~*~ — awe ~s we
Pee Cote tee SHALL Eeecos eslTecelve UpoA crecution ef ea Grant Agreensnt
pursucnt to the above identifiec rreject er iicsticn end shall constet.-
pert of the Sront roreqecn’ 20 vaien 1% relates ond sacl] re:ain in ful?
force end efrect sc lors ou vie cirport eo’ersa by cuca @gsvencnt con-
tinues to be used anc operand as & public sivper’.
$0 FOI SiGQ-2 (4-66)
DeKalb County Georsain
A: mM Gy or Spor3cr)
er ey, Sf a
- a ‘ * ¢ e 0
By oa ‘ 4 FT . o ¢
.
niece EE Le AD TOS
Brince ih, GsUP-MANG pws e ; ’
+. . s ‘mess 4 & i¢ - .
tle Ciheirren, pone 0¢ Es issivurrs
o @ Pe ay FL pS Seo ¢ th
of Moudas and *evenee
——— —--—— ow
(i.< . wy: SOF
ee = ee ee ee
39
[147]
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR
THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
ATLANTA DIVISION
[Filed in Clerk’s Office Jan. 4, 1974,
Ben H. Carter, Clerk; By: P.J.E., Deputy Clerk.]
GEORGE HENSON MIREE,
CLAUDE ESTES MIREE and
DOROTHY ESTES MIREE,
Minors, by and through
AUBREY 8. MIREE, JR. and
CLAUDE H. ESTES, JR..,
Co-Guardians of said minors, CIVIL
Plaintiffs, } PON
vs. NO.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA; 19293
MACHINERY BUYERS CORP.;
SOUTHEAST MACHINERY, INC.;
and DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA,
Defendants. |
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT,
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA |
Comes now DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, and
responds to the Complaint of Plaintiffs as follows:
RESPONSE AS TO ALLEGATIONS
OF JURISDICTION
1.
DeKalb County, Georgia is without knowledge or in-
formation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
allegations contained in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the
40
[148]
Complaint of Plaintiffs as relates to allegations of juris-
diction.
"
“
DeKalb County, Georgia admits the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 4 (b) of the Complaint of Plaintiffs
as relates to allegations of jurisdiction. Responding fur-
ther, DeKalb County, Georgia is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the remainder of the allegations contained in paragraph
4 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
[148] RESPONSE TO CAUSE OF ACTION
a
DeKalb County, Georgia denies the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 1 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
2.
This Defendant admits the allegations contained in
paragraph 2 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
3.
This Defendant is without knowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations
contained in paragraph 3 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
4
Responding to paragraph 4 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, this Defendant admits DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is
located within the boundaries of DeKalb County on land
owned by the County and that said Airport has paved
runways and airport hangers, servicing and parking fa-
cilities, a control tower with radio facilities, instrument
41
148]
landing system control center and access to other radio and
navigational aids. Responding further, DeKalb County,
Georgia admits the airport is operated under the jurisdic-
tion of the Federal Aviation Administration and avers
that the airport is operated for the use and benefit of the
public. Further responding, all other allegations contained
in paragraph 4 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs are denied.
5.
This Defendant admits the allegations contained in
paragraph 5 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
6.
Responding to paragraph 6 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, this Defendant admits only that beginning in 1962,
a portion of the land contiguous to the land utilized as an
airport was used by DeKalb County as a landfill. [149]
Further responding, the landfill was closed in 1964 and
remained closed until March, 1966. Responding further,
DeKalb County admits that since March, 1966 the land
contiguous to that land utilized for airport facilities was
utilized again for landfill purposes. Further responding,
all other allegations contained in paragraph 6 of the
Complaint of Plaintiffs are denied.
7.
Defendant denies the allegations contained in para-
graphs 7, 8 and 9 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
8.
DeKalb County, Georgia denies those allegations of
paragraph 10 of the Complaint directed to it.
42
ne
CS ooo
[150]
9.
This Defendant admits the allegations contained in
paragraph 11 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
10.
The allegation of paragraph 12 of the Complaint of
Plaintiffs is directed to the United States of America and
a response is not required of this Defendant.
11.
Responding to paragraph 13 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia admits that the United
States of America by and through the Federal Aviation
Administration had the responsibility for the administra-
tion of the Federal Airport Development Aid Program.
Responding further, this Defendant avers that the vari-
ous Federal Grant Agreements speak for themselves in
respect of the provisions of such Federal Grant Agree-
ments and the remainder of the allegations contained in
paragraph 13 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs are denied.
(150) 12.
This Defendant is not required to respond to paragraph
14 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs as the allegations con-
tained therein are directed to the United States of America.
13.
This Defendant admits the allegations contained in
paragraph 15 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
14.
Responding to paragraph 16 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia admits the existence of an
43
[150]
airport layout plan and avers that such airport layout
plan includes ‘industrial use’. The remainder of the alle-
gations contained in paragraph 16 of the Complaint of
Plaintiffs are denied.
15.
The allegations contained in paragra,h 17 of the Com-
plaint of Plaintiffs are directed to the United States of
America and an answer is not required of this Defendant.
16.
Responding to paragraph 18 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia admits that from March
9, 1970 through February 14, 1972, the Federal Aviation
Administration and DeKalb County, Georgia communi-
cated both by letter and by conference in respect to land
usage of the land utilized as an airport facility and that
land contiguous thereto in respect of the sanitary land-
fill. Responding further, the remainder of the allegations
contained in paragraph 18 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs
are denied.
17.
DeKalb County, Georgia denies the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 19 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
(151) 18.
DeKalb County, Georgia admits the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 20 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
19.
. Responding to paragraph 21 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia avers that paragraph 12
of the Project Application will speak for itself in respect
44
[152]
of its contents and no further answer is required of this
Defendant.
20.
Responding to paragraph 22 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia avers that the United
States of America and the Federal Aviation Administra-
tion has authority to allow changes in the airport layout
plan and admits that the United States of America and
the Federal Aviation Administration had knowledge of
the existence of the sanitary landfill contiguous to the
land utilized as an airport facility.
21.
Responding to paragraph 23 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia avers that the contents,
provisions and agreements contained in Exhibit “A” of
the Complaint of Plaintiffs are set out within said Exhibit
and no further response to this paragraph is required by
this Defendant.
22.
DeKalb County, Georgia denies the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 24 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
23.
Responding to paragraph 25 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, this Defendant admits the first sentence thereof
wherein it is alleged the personnel of the Federal Aviation
Administration gave clearance to the [152] Learjet air-
plane for takeoff from runway 20L at the DeKalb-Peach-
tree Airport. Responding further, DeKalb County is with-
out knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief
as to the truth of the allegation that the engines of the
45
[152]
Learjet aircraft ingested birds into both engi
the ingestion of the birds caused the crash of pat noe *
aircraft resulting in the deaths of Richardson F. Miree
and Lucy Estes Miree. Responding further, this Defen-
dant denies the remainder of the allegations contained in
paragraph 25 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs.
24.
DeKalb County, Georgia is without knowledge or in-
— lon sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
allegations contained in paragraph 6 >
of Plaintiffs. rare Coen
25.
oe wine May gr denies the allegations con-
G in paragraphs 27 and 28 of »
en of the Complaint of
26.
No response is required of DeK (
) alb County, Georgia
= pe ee contained in paragraph 29 a the com.
plaint of Plaintiffs as such allegati ;
gations are d
United States of America. —
27.
DeKalb County, Georgia denies the allegations con-
tained in paragraph 30 of the Complaint of Plaintiffs and
denies each and every sub
. -paragraph of pa
the Complaint of Plaintiffs. ‘ iets
28.
DeKalb County, Georgia is not requi
, Ge quired to respond to
or a the Complaint of Plaintiffs as ne alle-
gations are directed to Machinery B
Southeast Machinery, Inc. ee ee
46
Bie
(153]
29.
Responding to paragraph 32 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia is without knowledge or
information sufficient [153] to form a belief as to the truth
of the allegations respecting the age, life expectancy and
earnings of Richardson F. Miree. Responding further,
DeKalb County, Georgia denies the remainder of the al-
legations contained in paragraph 32 of the Complaint of
Plaintiffs and denies the allegation respecting the full
value of the life of Richardson I’. Miree.
30.
Responding to paragraph 33 of the Complaint of Plain-
tiffs, DeKalb County, Georgia is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the age, and life expectancy of Lucy Estes Miree. Re-
sponding further, DeKalb County, Georgia denies the
remainder of the allegations contained in paragraph 33
of the Complaint of Plaintiffs and denies the allegations
in respect of the full value of the life of Lucy Estes Miree.
47
[153]
WHEREFORE, having fully answered, DeKalb County,
Georgia demands trial by j
jury and
charged without ability.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ON ALL ISSUES
HARVEY, WILLARD & ELLIOTT
/s/ WENDELL WILLARD
WENDELL WILLARD
125 Trinity Place
Decatur, Georgia
LONG, WEINBERG, ANSLEY & WHEELER
/s/ MEADE Burns
MEapE Burns
/s/ Epwarp C. Stone
EDWARD C. STONE
3000 The Equitable Building
Atlanta, Georgia 30303
Phone: 525-5903
(Certificate of Service omitted in printing)
48
ee le ee re i a, aR wp ee Rom Le
[156]
(Caption omitted in printing)
[155] Filed: Jan. 4, 1974
MOTION TO DISMISS
Comes now DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, and
pursuant to Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., Rule 12, 28 U.S.C.A.
moves the Court that it be dismissed as a named party
defendant in the above-styled action, showing the Court
as follows:
1.
The Complaint of Plaintiffs fails to state a claim or
cause of action against DeKalb County, Georgia upon
which relief can be granted.
2.
Relief can be granted on none of Plaintiffs’ claims
against DeKalb County owing to the latter’s govern-
mental immunity.
3
In particular, DeKalb County, Georgia, shows the
Court that the Complaint of Plaintiffs fails to state a
claim upon which relief can be granted in the following
respects:
(a) In Georgia, no right of action will lie against a
County for the creation and/or maintenance of a nui-
sance;
[156]
(b) There is no right of action in plaintiffs, as third-
party beneficiaries, on any alleged breach of any Fed-
eral Grant Agreements entered into by and between
DeKalb County, Georgia and the Federal Aviation
Administration because there is no intent made mani-
fest within such Federal Grant Agreements to confer
49
[156]
upon third persons i
2m ose as _ the type- af benefit claimed by plain-
_ (c) Even if the Federal Grant A
into by and between DeKalb Pewene, tae 7.
Federal Aviation Administration were intended to ben-
efit the public in the manner claimed by plaintiffs, the
Complaint shows on its face that these Federal Grant
Agreements have not been breached by DeKalb County
- a, a sanitary landfill on property contiguous
o Kalb-Peachtree Airport in that the Federal Avi-
pe roe 7 anyone is alleged to have had knowledge
us to have consent
the maintenance of said landfill _ ar
(d) Even if plaintiffs otherwise had the ri
as third-party beneficiaries for an alleged hee ot the
: ederal Grant Agreements entered into by DeKalb
ounty, Georgia and the Federal Aviation Adminis-
tration, plaintiffs cannot recover damages for any al-
leged wrongful deaths stemming from the alleged breach
because a third-party beneficiary’s rights under an
contract are no greater than the rights of the pasties
themselves, and the Federal Grant Agreements which
plaintiffs allege to have been breached confer no right
on any party to recover damages for personal injur a
ay death in the event of their breach: 7
e) Plaintiffs cannot recover against DeKa
= Nor Dek ee as a matter of = pene
efendant’ ’
suit based on such a — —
WHEREFORE, Defendant, DeKalb County, € 1eorgia
prays that this Motion to Dismiss be inquired into and
sustained, and that DeKalb County, Georgia be dismissed
as a party defendant hereto. , _
(Signature and Certificate of Service omitted
in printing)
50
[160]
(Caption omitted in printing)
[159] Filed: Jan. 4, 1974
MOTION TO STRIKE OF DEFENDANT,
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA
Comes now DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, named
Defendant in the above-styled action, and pursuant to
Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., Rule 12 (e), 28 U.S.C.A., moves
the Court to strike certain allegations from Plaintiffs’
Complaint, showing the Court as follows:
1.
Defendant moves to strike Paragraph 27 from Plain-
tiffs’ Complaint on the ground that said paragraph fails
to state a claim upon which relief can be granted in that
in Georgia, an action will not lie against a County for the
alleged creation and/or maintenance of a public nuisance.
2.
Defendant moves the Court to strike Paragraph 24
from Plaintiffs’ Complaint on the ground that said para-
graph fails to state a claim upon which relief can be
granted in the following particulars:
(a) Plaintiffs cannot be third party beneficiaries to
the contracts claimed in said paragraph to have been
breached by this defendant since there is no intent in
such contracts [160] to confer upon third persons the
type of benefit claimed by plaintiffs in this action;
(b) Plaintiffs cannot recover as third party benefi-
ciaries for the breach of said contracts on the basis of
their Complaint, the allegations of which, considered
as a whole, clearly fail to allege any breach of contract;
51
[160]
(c) Plaintiffs cannot recover damages for wrongful
death as third party beneficiaries to the contracts
because a third party beneficiary’s rights under any
contract are no greater than the rights of the parties
themselves, and the contracts which plaintiffs alleged
to have been breached in said aragraph confer no
right on any party to recover amages for personal
injury or wrongful death.
3.
Defendant moves to strike from plaintiffs’ Complaint
all portions of paragraph 30 and all subsections thereof
which allege negligence on the part of Defendant on the
ground that said allegations fail to state a claim upon
which relief can be granted in that a County in Georgia
is not subject to suit based on negligence owing to gov-
ernmental immunity.
WHEREFORE, Defendant DeKalb County, Georgia
prays that this Motion to Strike be inquired into and
sustained.
(Signature and Certificate of Service omitted
in printing)
52
BO Ce ee ee
[181]
(Caption omitted in printing)
[180] Filed: Jan. 22, 1974
PLAINTIFFS’ FIRST AMENDMENT
TO COMPLAINT
Plaintiffs amend Paragraph 4 of the Complaint 4
adding a sub-paragraph to be known as sub-paragrap
(e) as follows: Fi a
“(e) AMERICAN HOME: ASSURANCE _
PANY is a New York corporation, having an office
and place of doing business in Fulton County, ( jeora :
service may be had by serving its agent for nervice,
ROY OVERSTREET, at 1819 Peachtree Road, Suite
610, Atlanta, Fulton County, Georgia.
2.
Plaintiffs add a new paragraph to be numbered 34 and
to read as follows:
624
Defendant AMERICAN HOME: ASSURAN( re
‘OMPANY issued a policy of liability insurance
Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, insur-
ing said DEKALB COUNTY, a, ee
liability for bodily injury or death with limits :
$100,000.00 for each person and $1,000,000.00 for —
accident, and containing the following waiver 0
Governmental Immunity:
“ i ight to
‘It is agreed that the company waives any rig
jh liability under the policy or to refuse ~———
within the limits thereof by reason of the go
bility of the insured political subdivision for the
wrongful or negligent acts of its agents and em-
53
[181]
ployees and its immunity from suit as an agency of
the State performing governmental function.
Said Defendant AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE
COMPANY and Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, are liable to Plaintiffs herein by reason of
the provisions of said policy and by reason of the facts
hereinabove set forth. A copy of said insurance policy
is attached hereto, marked [exhibit “B”’, and made a
part hereof by reference.”
3.
Plantiffs amend their Complaint by adding the follow-
ing new paragraphs number 35 through 57 to read as
follows:
“35.
The UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, through
the Department of Transportation and the Adminis-
trator of the Federal Aviation Administration, (here-
inafter referred to as “F.A.A.”’), has been direeted by
Congress in the Federal Aviation Act. of 1958, as
amended, to assume responsibility as follows:
‘to develop plans for and formulate policy with
respect to the use of the navigable airspace; and
assign by rule, regulation, or order the use of the
navigable airspace under such terms, conditions and
limitations as he may deem necessary in order to
insure the safety of aircraft and the efficient utiliza-
tion of such airspace. He may modify or revoke such
assignment when required in the public interest.’
49 § 1348(a).”
[182] “36.
The United States of America, through the Depart-
ment of Transportation and the Administrator of the
F.A.A., is further authorized by Congress in said Act
to assume responsibility as follows:
54
[182]
‘(1) to acquire, establish, and improve air-naviga-
tion facilities wherever necessary ; —
(2) to operate and maintain such air-navigation
facilities; ... _ -
(4) to provide necessary facilities and re or
the regulation and protection of air trafic.
48 U.S.C. § 1348(b).”
“37.
, state rica, through the Depart-
The United States of America, 1g,
ment of Transportation and the conan sagan pig
F.A.A. is further directed by Congress in said Act to
as; me responsibility as follows:
‘to prescribe air traffic rules and ee =.
ing the flight of aircraft, for the aes A sae
tion, and identification of aircraft, for : re ” —
of persons and property on the ground, an wa
efficient utilization of the navigable a ? ha
cluding rules as to safe altitudes of fligh: gyn shew
for the prevention of collision —= ( » a ~ ~
between aircraft and land or water ve ue wy: IY
tween aircraft and airborne objects. 49 U.5.0,
§ 1348(c).”
“38,
ioned direetions to and placement of
he aforementioned lire ctions : ment of
reeponeibility on the United States of pam =
ursuant to the ¢ ‘ongressional oar norman — 4,
9 USC. § 1303 that the United States o merica,
pe fs om Bnet of the F.A.A., 1 consider
the following as being in the public interest: :
| ree | ‘+h manner
‘( » regulation of Air commerce in such ann
” py A best promote its development and —
and fulfill the requirements of national defense;
(b) The promotion, encouragement, and develop-
ment of civil aeronautics;
5d
[182]
(ec) The control of the use of the navigable airspace
of the United States and the regulation of both
civil and military operations in such airspace in
on interest of safety and efficiency of
oth;
(d) The consolidation of research and development
with respect to air navigation facilities, as well
as the installation and operation thereof;
(e) The development and operation of a common
system of air traffic control and navigation for
both military and civil aircraft.’ ”
“39.
The United States of America, through the Depart-
ment of Transportation and the Administrator of the
F.A.A., is further given the duty by Congress in said
Act as follows:
‘to promote safety of flight of civil aircraft in air
commerce by prescribing and revising from time to
time:...
(6) Such reasonable rules and regulations or mini-
mum standards, governing other practices,
methods, and procedure, as the Administrator
may find necessary to provide adequately
for . . . safety in air commerce.’ 49 U.S.C.
§ 1421(a)(6).”
“40.
Pursuant to the aforesaid authority and directions
from Congress the United States of America adminis-
ters air traffic control of civil air operations within
United States airspace; operates F.A.A. air route
traffic control centers, airport traffic control towers,
flight service stations, and related communications
equipment required for control of air traffic; and col-
lects and disseminates information relative to civil
aeronautics and safety of flight.”’
56
[184]
“41,
Also pursuant to said Congressional authority and
directions the United States of America has established
as being necessary and operates air navigation facili-
ties, including an Airport Traffic Control Tower
(ATCT) at DeKalb-Peachtree Airport and a flight
service station in Fulton County, Georgia, which
flight [184] service station serves the geographical area
in which DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is located.”’
“42.
An ATCT is a central operations facility in the ter-
minal air traffic control system, consisting of a tower
eab structure, including an associated IFR room if
radar equipped, using air/ground communications
and/or radar, visual signaling and other devices, to
provide safe and expeditious movement of air and
ground traffic.”
“43.
The ATCT at DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is operated
by the F.A.A. and is ‘responsible for the safe, orderly
and expeditious flow of air traffic in the vicinity of an
[the] Airport.’ 30 F.R. 3395, as amended; 16 F.R. 2975,
2979, revised 19 F.R. 2098, §24.”’
“44.
Said ATCT is manned by personnel (employed by
the United States of America) ‘who are responsible for
the safe and orderly flow of air traffic in the vicinity of
the Airport.’ Their principal duties are as follows:
(a) “To issue instructions to pilots for taxiing, take-
off, approach for landing, and landing of air-
craft.
(b) ‘To inform pilots regarding field and weather
conditions, air navigational facilities, emergency
landing areas, restrictions to flight, regulations,
57
[184]
and other matters which may be of assistance to
the pilot.
(c) ‘To relay messages between pilots, airline opera-
tions offices, Air Route Traffic Control Centers
Weather Bureau offices, Communications Sta-
tions and other appropriate agencies concerning
the operation, dispatch, and control of aircraft.
(d) “To invoke emergency procedures when any
emergency occurs or appears likely to occur to
aircraft under tower control.
[185]
(e) ‘When equipped with airport surveillance and
precision approach radar, to monitor aircraft
arriving and departmentfrom an airport on
instruments, and, in an emergency or upon re-
quest, issuing ground controlled approach in-
structions (GCA) for a let-down.’ 16 F.R. 2974
2979, revised 19 F.R. 2098, §24. pte
“45,
Pursuant to the authority and directions of
the United States of America, through the = tae
of Transportation and the F.A.A., prior to the crash in
question had issued Advisory Circular No. 150/5200-3A
dated March 2, 1972, entitled ‘Bird Hazards to Air-
craft,’ in which the United States of America through
said agencies stated in part as follows:
‘Migratory birds, particularly waterfowl, are a hazard
to aircraft due to their size and weight. In recognition
of this potential hazard, F.A.A. Air Traffic Control
and Flight Service Station facilities issue advisory
information on bird activities when they are reported
or when they have knowledge of such activities.
Information given to pilots includes the position,
species or size of bird if known, and thei
eir Col
altitude.’ ” veils
58
ee ee eee
(186)
“46.
The F.A.A. in said Advisory Circular also admitted
that the birds of greatest potential hazard to aircraft
because of size, abundance, or habit of flying in dense
flocks, include starlings; that birds of these species are
considered particularly hazardous during spring and
fall migrations and when they are concentrated in
wintering areas; and that at some airports there are
large flocks of certain birds which could be a problem
during certain seasons. DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is
not named or referred to in said Advisory Circular.”
[186] “47,
To cope with these admitted flight hazards, the
Advisory Circular states that the United States of
America, through the F.A.A., is operating as follows:
‘F.A.A. Air Traffic Control and Flight Service Sta-
tion facilities coordinate with airport management
for either appropriate alerting action by a Notice to
Airmen when flocks of birds are noted to remain in
the airport vicinity or for possible closing by a
Notice to Airmen when flocks roose on runways.’ ”’
“48.
The Federal Government personnel providing ter-
minal air traffic control services at airports, including
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport, are required by the United
States of America to be familiar with the provisions of
the Terminal Air Traffic Control Manual, 7110.8, one
of the air traffic control manuals referred to in Part 65
of the Federal Aviation Regulations, in which Manual
are set forth the following duties and responsibilities
of air traffic control personnel:
‘If you observe or are informed of any condition
which affects the safe use of a landing area:
59
[186]
(a) Relay the informatio i
pee Mi n to the airport manager
(b) Issue a Notice to Airmen icizi
> & IN publicizing an unsaf.
condition if you are unable to pecan the pe mma
manager (or if there is 10 airport manager desig-
nated) and then inform the
practicable. .. .’ manager as soon as
‘122. BIRD ACTIVITY
ADDNL SVC
_ ‘a. Issue advisory information on the positi
if known, species or size of birds, and 9 ean
flight and altitude if you believe that the safety of
flight in that area may be affected. Do this for at
least 15 minutes after receipt of such information
a i or a adjacent facilities unless visual
or subsequ ivi
Pastaeee oe ent reports reveal the activity
[187]
‘1552. BIRD ACTIVITY INFORMATION
A. Issue advisory information pi
i pilot-reported
radar-observed and pilot-verified bird salinity. In-
clude position, species or size of birds, if known
course of flight and altitude. (E)
Phraseology:
FLOCK OF (Species, if known)/(size, if known)
BIRDS, (number) O’CLOCK
MILES (direction) BOUND: eee
LAST REPORTED AT i
from pilot report). (altitude, as determined
or
ALTITUDE UNKNOWN.
FLOCK OF (species, if known)/(si tk
BIRDS (direction) BOUND ALONG: (flyway
geographical route): LONG (flyway or
60
ae * whe
[188]
LAST REPORTED AT (altitude, as determined
from pilot report).
or
ALTITUDE UNKNOWN.
FLOCK OF/NUMEROUS FLOCKS (species, if
known)/(size, if known) BIRDS, VICINITY (loca-
tion) :
LAST REPORTED AT (altitude, as determined
from pilot report).
or
LATITUDE UNKNOWN.
b. Relay bird activity information to adjacent
facilities and to FSS’s whenever it appears it will
become a factor in their areas.’ ”
“49,
The Defendant UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
by and through its agents and employees, was guilty of
negligence which proximately contributed to the death
of RICHARDSON F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES
MIREE in that the Atlanta Flight Service Station
personnel and the DeKalb-Peachtree Airport air traf-
fic control tower personnel negligently approved the
IFR flight plan filed by the crew of the LEARJET and
negligently cleared the LEARJET for takeoff from
[188] Runway 20L, contrary to the provisions of the
Terminal Air Traffic Control Manual referred to in
paragraph No. 48 above, and the Advisory Circular
referred to in paragraphs Nos. 45, 46 and 47 above,
and the provisions of the Federal Register referred to
in paragraphs Nos. 43 and 44 above.”
‘ec 50.
The Defendant UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
by direction of Congress, is responsible for certification
61
[188]
of aircraft as airworthy and for issuing t a
duction certificates for aircraft, inciadiet tis Lectin
Model 24. The Defendant UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA, by and through its agents and employees
was guilty of negligence which proximately contrib-
uted to the death of RICHARDSON F. MIREE and
LUCY ESTES MIREE as follows:
(a) In issuing a type certificate, production certi
cate and airworthiness pr sn Bo for the cone
Model 24, including the accident aircraft, without
“aed fancy sy as 2 == the aircraft in areas of
bird hazards, when Defendant UNI
STATES OF AMERICA knew that the tre
was capable of ingesting birds and that bird inges-
tion on takeoff would cause a power loss and a re-
sulting dangerous hazard to the safety of the airplane
and all persons aboard the airplane;
(b) In failing to place restrictions
on the t
certificate, production certificate and slewtethiaaes
certificate of the Learjet Model 24, forbidding opera-
tion of the aircraft in areas of known bird hazards;
(c) In failing to prohibit o
| peration of Le
Model 24 aircraft at DeKalb-Peachtree a
when Defendant UNITED STATE OF AMERICA
“ae that a bird hazard existed at said airport; and
(d) In failing to devise a system or pr
whereby Learjet Model 24 dimedl onda = ‘be
cleared for takeoff at DeKaib-Peachtree Airport
when a bird hazard was known by Defendant
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA to exist at said
urport, without first determining whether at the
time of takeoff birds were present in sufficient quan-
tity to be a menace and hazard to safety of flight.”
“51.
(a) Georgia Code Section 11-402(2) defines an ‘air-
62
[190]
port hazard’ as any structure which is hazardous to the
use of an airport for the taking off and landing of air-
planes.
(b) Georgia Code Section 11-403 declares that an
airport hazard endangers the lives and property of
users of the airport and is therefore not in the interest
of the public health, public safety or general welfare.
(c) Georgia Code Section 11-9902 declares that the
violation of any airport zoning regulations shali con-
stitute a misdemeanor.
(d) Section 1(b) of the 1960 DeKalb County Airport
Zoning Resolution concerning DeKalb-Peachtree Air-
rt defines an ‘airport hazard’ as any structure or use
of land which is ‘hazardous to such landing or taking
off of aircraft.’
(e) Section 5 of the 1960 DeKalb County Airport
Zoning Resolution declares that no use may be made of
land within any airport approach surface zone, horizon-
tal surface zone, conical surface zone or transitional
surface zone at DeKalb-Peachtree Airport, in such
manner as to endanger the landing, taking off or
manuevering of aircraft.
[190}
(f) Section 8 of the 1960 DeKalb County Airport
Zoning Resolution declares that no material change
shall be made in the use of land at DeKalb-Peachtree
Airport and no structure shall be erected, altered,
planted or otherwise establish in any airport approach
surface zone, horizontal surface zone, or conical sur-
face zone unless a permit therefor shall have been
applied for and granted. Said Section 8 also declares
that no permit shall be granted that would allow the
establishment or creation of an airport hazard or per-
mit a non-conforming use or structure to become a
greater hazard to air navigation.
(gz) Section 14 of said 1960 DeKalb County Airport
Zoning Resolution also declares that every violation of
63
[190]
said Resoluti | ome
ment, or a shall be punishable by fine or imprison-
_ (h) The open garbage dump in question i
a ay > hazard, as defined & Georgia Code Sec.
a Pg and Section 1(b) of the aforesaid Zoning
re ution. No permit was ever applied for or granted
respect to the establishment and operation of said
— garbage dump. The maintenance of said open
ow a Se > roca by Georgia Code Section
‘ y Sections 5 and 8
oe her: rox memes DEKALD CoO
‘ » In establishing and operati
garbage dump violated the dumaaa oo a Genue
and the aforesaid Zoning Resolution, and per
negligence per se proximately contributing to the death
of RIC
ae F. MIREE and LUCY ESTES
“52.
Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, G
‘ , GEORGIA
also guilty of negligence per se proximately pear nie
ng - the death of RICHARDSON F. MIREE and
iain Gan MIREE in that Defendant [191]
creased the bird. rh Shh Bn mpnicnerige id pe clpenn Han
bird-attracting nature of said o arb:
dump by failing to place a compacted oma pogo
= inches of clean earth over all exposed solid waste at
1e ys of each day’s operation, and by failing to
_— pry hay in uniform layers not over two feet
, and by failing to compact solid waste pri
covering with earth, and by otherwise steglhe
maintaining said open garbage dum in vininte a
violat
a a cae hy licen Act. (Georgia
s 43- , et. seq.) and the Rul
aoa of the Georgia Department of poe
esources, Environmental Protection Division, con-
cerning Solid Waste Management (Rules and Regula-
64
A ede wh
[192]
tions of the State of Georgia, Sections 391-1-1-.1 et.
seq.).””
63.
At all times relevant it was the duty of Defendant
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, to operate and
manage DeKalb-Peachtree Airport in a safe condition.
Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, was
guilty of negligent acts and failures to act and derelic-
tions of duties proximately contributing to the death of
RICHARDSON F. MIREE and DOROTHY ESTES
MIREE, in that Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, at all times relevant had actual, personal
knowledge of the bird hazard and unsafe condition that
existed at the Airport, and in that Defendant DEKALB
COUNTY, GEORGIA, had ample opportunity either
to remove the bird hazard and unsafe condition or to
prohibit the operation of jet aircraft at the Airport,
and in that Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEOR-
GIA, failed to heed the warnings of the F.A.A. and
others concerning such bird hazard and unsafe condi-
tion, and in that [192] Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, willfully, wantonly, recklessly and negli-
gently failed either to alleviate the bird hazard and
unsafe condition, or to prohibit operation of jet air-
craft at the Airport, or to warn the flight crews of jet
aircraft of the bird hazard and unsafe condition, or to
devise a system, plan or procedure for the warning of
jet flight crews of the bird hazard or unsafe condition.”
‘54.
The willful, wanton nature of the negligence and
dereliction of duties of Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, and the seriousness of the negligence and
carelessness of Defendant UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA are exemplified by the fact that prior to
the fatal crash in question, Defendant DEKALB
COUNTY, GEORGIA, and Defendant UNITED
65
[192]
STATES OF AMERICA had recei i
ved notic
ee bird-strike or near bird-strike err td —
e airport boundaries, but despite this knowledge of
prior incidents Defendant DEKALB COUNTY
GEORGIA, and Defendant UNITED STATES OF
ailed to t i
a recurrence of such — siesta casioae
“55.
(a) DeKalb-Peachtree Airport is not
on ye A ne _~ Defendant "Oknaeg
ry, JR , aS a governm 1
enterprise, but, instead, is po winrar prone yoda
tained and managed by Defendant DEKALB COUN-
Sl GIA, as a proprietary or ministerial [193]
con or enterprise. In this connection, Plaintiffs
show that Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEOR.
GIA, leases substantial portions of the Airport to
— companies engaged in commercial operations
or profit; that some of such leases are for fixed rental
amounts and the remaining leases are for fixed rental
ee plus a percentage of the revenues or income
lerived by the genants from their commercial opera~
Monon that the revenues thus obtained by Defendant
KALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, are not insignifi-
—_ - F yeonenon 5 and that the Airport is
, Operated, managed and matintained b -
dant DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, oot the ag
3 source of revenue for Defendant DEKALB COUN-
, # GEORGIA. In effect, with respect to ownershi
operation, management and maintenance of the Air’
port, Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA
acts as a privat
pos Aa private landlord and not as a governmental
(b) Plaintiffs show that prior to the date of the
crash in question, Defendant DEKALB
, De 3 COUN
GEORGIA, purchased the policy of liability oad
66
4
:
[194]
from Defendant AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE
COMPANY which is referred to hereinabove, provid-
ing bodily injury liability insurance to Defendant
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, with respect to the
ownership, operation, management and maintenance
of DeKalb-Peachtree Airport by said Defendant
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, said policy con-
taining a ‘Waiver of Governmental Immunity’ which
is set out hereinabove.
(ec) Defendant DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, is
not entitled to the benefit or protection of the doctrine
of sovereign immunity with respect to the claims of
Plaintiffs herein.”
[194] 56.
Plaintiffs show that by virtue of the operation of
DeKalb-Peachtree Airport by Defendant DEKALB
COUNTY, GEORGIA, under the Uniform Airport
Act (Georgia Code Section 11-204, et seq.), and under
the Federal Airport and Airway Development Act
(49 U.S.C. §§$ 1711, et seq.), and its predecessor, the
Federal Airport Act (49 U.S.C. §§ 1101, et seq.), and by
virtue of the Grant Agreements and payments of
Federal funds referred to earlier in this lawsuit, and by
virtue of the application of the provisions of the Geor-
gia Solid Waste Management Act and the Rules and
Regulations of the Georgia Department of Natural
Resources, Environmental Protection Division (Solid
Waste Management) to the facts of this case, and by
virtue of the application of the 1960 DeKalb County
Airport Zoning Resolution to the facts of this case, an
express or implied statutory waiver of the doctrine of
sovereign immunity exists with respect to the claims of
Plaintiffs against Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA. In the alternative, as a result of the acts
and failures to act of Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, as alleged herein, and as a result of the
67
[194]
acceptance and retention of benefits by the Defendant
DEKALB COUNTY, GEORGIA, under the various
statutes, rules and regulations and Grant Agreements
referred to herein, Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA, either expressly or impliedly has waived
any defense based upon the doctrine of sovereign im-
munity, with respect to the claims of Plaintiffs herein.”
(195] “BT,
Plaiutiffs allege that Defendant DEKALB COUN-
TY, GEORGIA, is not entitled to the defense of
sovereign immunity because Ga. Code Ann. § 23-1502,
which reads
“A county is not liable to suit for any cause of action
unless made so by statute’,
is unconstitutional in that such statute violates the
equal protection and due process clauses of the Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution of
the United States and of Article I, Section I, Para-
graphs II and III of the Constitution of Georgia by
reason that such statute, on its face and as applied to
the Plaintiffs and Defendant DEKALB COUNTY,
GEORGIA:
1. denies Plaintiffs due process of law,
2. denies Plaintiffs equal protection of law, and
3. creates an arbitrary classification which con-
travenes the due process requirements of the federal
and state Constitutions.”
(Signature Omitted in Printing)
68
senicans efit HOME
ASSURANCE COMPANY
wee YORE SEW FORE «4 Carirat STOCK COMPANY FOL FORD TOES
[196]
AVIATION INSURANCE POLICY
Issued Through
“<= WESTMINSTER ==
INSURANCE MANAGERS, INC
275 FOREST AVENUE
PARAMUS, NEW JERSEY 07652
TELEPHONE WESTERN UNION
Anta COOE 20! Teex
265.4515 13-4928
PLEASE READ YOUR POLICY
1. Get immediate first aid for all injured parties.
2. Protect the oircraft whether the loss is insured or not.
3. Give no statements to anyone except police officers,
F.AA. officiols (or other government officiols having
jurisdiction over civil aviation) ond your Insurance Com-
pony representative.
Pitta ene a
IN EVENT OF ACCIDENT
4. Secure oll possible information including nomes and
addresses of those involved and witnesses.
5 Report all accidents to Westminster insurance Managers,
Inc. promptly. If BODILY INJURY is involved Telex or
Telephone ond follow with written report
"The ar to an even greater extent than the 104, i terribly unforgiving of any carclessmess, incapacity on weglect
AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
{A stock company. here natter called the compony) = —
Agrees ed nomed in the declarations made o port hereol, in consideration of the payment of the premium ond in reliance upon stotemenhy tela
ranons SS Sa po port to the Limits of Liebility, Exclusions, Conditions ond other terms of this policy to atlord insvrance only with respect
mony of the following coverages oF are indicated by specitic premium charge of charges a8 set forth in the decloratons.
Iusuring Agreements
1. Insurance Coverage: Defined
Airerett Uebility, To poy on beholl of the Insured al! sums which the Inwred sholl
become legally ob! gored ‘0 poy 01 domoge: becouse a
Coverage A — Bodily injury wwstaned by ony person excep! o pamenger
Coverage & ~ Preperty Domege, iniwry to property of others
Coverage C — Pomenger, siwry tvitoned by ony powenger
Coverage D — Single Limit, injury sustained by ony person ond inwury to property
of orhers.
Coverage E~ Single Limit; injury wetoined by ony perton excep! o panenger
ond inwvry to property of others, :
covsed by on occurrence ond arising out of theownerthip. manienonce or vie oO
the oreroft
Coverage . — Medica! Coveroge Te poy ol! reasonable expenses incurred ethin
one yeor from the dote of accident, for recemary medical wrgice!, dente’. omby
s
$
z
8
fed os .ncluded in the Declorotons
Hull Coverages — To pay for direct low of or domage to the aircraft, whiject to
the exclunons conditions ond other terms of the policy when coused by,
Coverage G — Ail Risks of Physice! Low or Damage te the Aircraft The areraft
shell be prewmed los in thght ¢ it duoppears after takeoff ond is nor located
nor ts whereabouts reported aithin waty doys therectter
Coverege 1 — All Bishs of physcal low or domage to the aircraft while nat in
motor
Coverage | — All Risks of physica! loss or damage to the oircratt while nat in
High?
Coverage | — As endorsed hereon
69
[197]
u. Deolense Serrl . Suppl y Peyments (Coverages A. 8 C.D end &).
As respects such insurance os is afforded by the other terms of thus poley, the
compony thal! (a) defend on his nome ond behalf any suit again the insured
alleging weh inwury, sickness, dieose or destruction ond teebing damages on
ectount thereot, even f wuch suit 19 groundless, fale a fraudulent, but the com.
Bony shall hove the right to make such investigation nego’ otion and settioment
o any claim oF wit os may be deemed expedient by the company, (b) poy of!
premiums or bonds to release attachment for an amount not in excon of the
opplicable lim of lability of this policy, al! premiums on appeal bonds required
" ony weh celerded we all cous tosed agony the revered any wath evit off
erpertes ‘ncurred by the company. all interest occry oq ofter entry af ivdqment
vetl the company has pod tendered or depovted © court weh part of weh
ivdgmert o) does -oF exceed the lmw of the compar, + hab!lty thereon erpenem
neurred by the cwred, in the event of bod !y inury webrem or duenwe. for such
wmmediate ~ed.col and twergral rolel to others as shalt be «*perctive of the time
of the ccrurrence, and (c) remburse the insured for expenses other thar low of
corn ngs incurred of the company's request
The company ogress to poy the amounts incurred under this Inwuring Agreement
encept sertioment of cloums and wits, in addition to the applicable limit of Sabitiny
of this policy
mw. Definition of “Ineured” (Coverages A. 8 C.D. f end F) The unqualitied
word “insured” wherever used incivdes not only the nomed ‘nwred but olso
pertan while using the aircraft and any person oF org hon legally rep
for its wee provided the actual vie is with permission of the named insured
The provisions of this paregraph do not apply, (9) to ony person of organ
Htotion with respet to bodily injury, sickness, disease or who
0 @ med insured (b) to any employee oF official of an insured with respect to
ory action brought against sold employee or \
vicknewm, duveose or death of another employes of the
courte of weh employment in an occurrence arising ovt
wie of the cireralt in the business of such insured, (c) to
Non, OF to ony agent or employee thereo!
named inwured) engaged in the manviacturing of airerali, aircralt engines,
<7
presente of weh named insured on such other mrcraly Ths imtwnerg agreenen’ does
rot apply (a) to any areralt weaned in tull or nm part by leorwd in the name
of, hired as port of « trequert use of bwed aueralt by. oF furnished for regular
wie to the named imwred or a member of bie homettoud, tb) to ony otcurrence
arivng ovt of the operation of an airport. awerale repo thap henge: aireraty
wales agency, Nying shool, Mying clu or the manulacture of ai-cealt ovcdh
erg res oF arerott ac comernes
V. = Temperory Use of Substitute Aircraft (Coveroges A.B. C.D. fond F) Wile
on aircralt wed by the named inwred is withdrawn Wom normal use becouse
of i breakdown, repair, servicing. loss oF destruction, woh insurance as 0 af.
forded by this policy with respect to weh aircral applies with respect to nother
cireralt of similar type, horsepower ond seat Copacity not s owned while
temporarily vied ov the substitute for such airer This insuring agreement does
nat cover oF an insured the owner of the whititule aireralt er any agent o om-
ployee A wreh owner
ewnernhip of onather arcralt of wmilor type, horsepower and seating capacity
ond w notifies the Company enthn ten doys following the date of its delivery to
him, weh insurance as is olforded by this poly applies oho to weh aircraft os
of weh delivery date (io) 4 # reploces an arcralt dewrbed in thu policy, but
only to the estant the inwrance applicable to the reploced aircratt, or ib)
#8 on additional aircrult and W the campony invures oll aircralt owned by the
named inwred at wrh delivery date
Unies: otherwise agreed in writing between the nomed Inwred ond the Company,
the Coverages Limits of Liobility and Amount of Inwerance for woh sewly acquired
oireratt shall be os respects
) Liability ond Meduo! Coverages — not to exceed the liminy orig:nathy prowded
for ony owned mrcratt,
(b) Mull Coverages - the actwal cost of the aircratt to the named inwred, but now
fo esceed the highest amount of immronce on ony dewribed oivcralt ond wh
ject to the some deductibles
cralt accesories. oF on aircralt rapolr shop, airport, hanger, oircratt
soles agency, fy. og et yh Ths “coring Ogreement dows not epply (a) 1 ony low againes which He named
out of the is or the ope therect, (d) to any person oF erganisation inwred has other valid and collectible inwurance, or (b) except during the policy
‘other than the named insured) operoting the aircralt under the terme of ony peried. but 4 weh delivery date is prior to the oMective daw of this policy. the
rental agreement or to any persion er Grgonization or ony agent or employee inwrance apples as of woh eflective date
thereat [other thon the named insured. its agents and employees) operating the The named inwred shall pay ony additional premium required becovie of the
oirerolt under the terms of amy Waining pragram which provides ony ep! of the to weh other oireralt The inwrance terminates upon
to the named inured for the use of said aircraft @ replaced aircralt on the delwery time ond dote
Iv. Use of Other Aircratt (Pleasure end Business or Industriel Ald Uses Only— vi. Ocevrrences, Polley Perind, Territory, Purpose of Use This policy apples
A 8.6, 0. band #) Such Insurance ot is afforded by this policy with only to cecurrences during the policy periad while the aircralt is within the United
rewpect to the ovcralt applies to the named inwred i an individual ond the owner Stotes of America ‘eecluding Alaska) Canada, or the Bepublic of Mexico, or is
of such oiveralt «th rexpect to the operation of any other oircralt of wmilor type, beng tranwpo led between ered! ond © owned mairtaned and vied tor
horsepower ond seating capacity by wch named insured or with respect to the
This policy dows no! opply:
1 to bodily injury, vicknew, disease or death of ony employee of the inwred
while engoged in the duties of his employment or to
i
ii
#f
i
fs
li
i
1
i i
!
:
l
}
;
iy
{
i
i
a1
a
i 8
=
ij
i
ij
a
e
7
7
oi
i
t
i
f
i
HH
i*s
ty
ij
8 (Note)
(e) to low or damage or ony liability of the Insured rewiting trom. arising
out of, oF in any woy connected with Aircraft Moise mvisanre and/or com
oF not), avil wor, rebellen, revolution o ection, including
oct: in furtherance of any of the loregoiny,
(b) any hostile detonation of ony weepen of employing stoma
nuclear fission ond/or fusion or ether lhe reaction o redicediwe force
more.
(c)_ony act of one oF more permam, whether or not agent of © sxersign
power, tor political or terrors purpose end whether the low or demage
rowing theretrom is actidentel or ,
(d) contixcation, nationalisation, seizure, restraint, detention, eppropriation,
requimtion for title or wae by or under the order of ony government (whether
cw mivtory or de fact) or public or local ewthority
10 ads c
(0) to low or devruction of or damage te ony property whatsoever or
low or expense wharnever resulting or urising theretrom er oxy conamquentiel
om
(>) ony legal liability of whatever nature divecthy or indirectly caused or
Contributed te o eriang from ionizing radiators or contemination by
radiowttivity tram any wurie wheteeve
[198]
+ MOS eM eusori ~~ cu of Conenia 94UHNOCT ew Us Dew mets CO /
~ [ | INO VinwaL i | | COMPORATION | | PARTNER wore
2 Addew: os Valo Couaty Courthouse, vwecatur, Gourcla uSSs
i * 1 “ ‘ ' > ‘ , ~* -
val Policy Peron. From 42:01 HAM. + 1 PM. mugcuSe uu, lv. ” otk 1S &, 1973
WOIAMW & enue Ot «aura of *
- Business Go: snsurea ‘ “unicipaliry #8 Staten Here.
_ Insurer. 1
‘ 9 Aiecralt bared at re yr ‘ tes nee
ry + — -- — ee ne - - _ a - : : : -
LIAGL.TY COVERAGES LIMITS OF LIABILITY I LIABILITY , MUL. COV). A.CES
. Fach Person Each Occurence | PRE Mis | __16e Nie ISa: a
__& Body inary 7 cept Pamengers s s 5 ' GA Pres
__ © Praperiy Camage : a !
. —— En et , | 1. All Ricks not in moven
'
i
___D. Singia er mim ‘cluding Pansengers® niet e a a - | 1. Al Pisses nat in tyne
5 Sngle Lima-encogs Pemengere KM xX Ch \ 4 Ascenders
/ r Medicei Payment | inet. [ } onel. Crow NS } .
— ji \ aa sao ~§ WS | ye OEOUC TiaLes
* The tim of Habilty for amy one s Totert LY : : Bach Aircrate Fach Lows j
i Pemenger shail not exceed ee oe we 1569. Fncapt Fire, That, Lyhtaing,
t 2 OESCAIFTION OF AIRCRAFT & HULL COVERAGES HEREYNAER™ ae
- ——" 7“ ee i ee |
oe FAA. Reginvetion | + | ner pe — Mult Net In In t
Mocel Number Rotary Wi. _ Medel ~ Coma > age ineurense Premiurm Monon Metion '
7 : - eS ees —
‘ “Oo AZ 5 s s s |
f Siieiee - hd
w~Oss a Cc Vv
i A
' CN v Apply
AX,»
A \ ¢ - 5 - ! j
i — PRAARNTL. y
i FAM Catecory: EpNeme 1) Rewrierea Breech of Warranty Premium | aot —____|____
\S © I Uniiey | Acrometic "s — 68 waiay
i —_—_—_—- -—-<- —=-——— | Premium ® 15439 ;
‘ FAA. Class { } Stendera { | Transport L— a2 2...
{ J kimited [{ | Experimental That when not requieriy hengered at home sirport.
—
©
Cc
|
Does
. !
9 Pilots Not ’
t : '
j '
; : Agely
, !
i
|
'
Is Exceptions if any (se below)
r 7 oe
| i? il ae ‘
= J
" devariong herein are tly teoeae ee sa ase ae an inaaranee pervaining Yo on eintion Vek Yor te ested Wovaoi ws Vlad DOOCw FOU COOER
; names exeve lm, ey caer eater ret, sntem other site stated in Thame & end 30 soave, Ne mertgegse eonotnne tanec ot een
| “mw Ove (eum Ov, ene” eavaragne , 1 67 4 chee Savane to Ge semed immed and te muon eottene mene es nS
’
f “wmer@rene Tairfax Underwriters Services, Inc. 127 w. 10th St., Kansas City, so.
| Mh 30 Mew, 472 (Kane) See Reverse side for Polley Oefinitions For the Company
71
‘BEST COPY AVAILABLE
[199]
the ft . leabclty fee sections §. it, HM, and iV of this endorsement ore os specifies in this schody. +
etiorded oy vs endorsement is only with respect te such end se mony of the coverages end sections os ore on
by specific premium cherge or cherges for such cevereges end sections.
.
Liebility Coverages fre i 5 Limits of Liebility
A re | aw 4 Eoch Person Each Accident
ine” ° 163,02 1,959,52°
Bodily Iniury. -. «+> eeerrrrrTTy Tritt Ce ckeeudeueen ft habs. $ Sccamanll ¥
Property Camoge ona eo hes 66866 SSSO600086 066900906850 4880099908
Single Limit - Including Pessengers. .-- +++ + +>
1 $39.00 Pe
Zaesgaes Sit
xxXXKXKXK S$
SECTION I PREMISES - OPERATIONS | ie PREMIUMS
Lecetion of premises end purpose for which premises ere used Port Occupied by Insured Bodily Injury eperty Danece
$ om 5 e
Ds BRalu-Peacatres Airport Satire 236. 253.
Cancice, seorgis
SECTION PRODUCTS Rates per $1,000 of Soles ESTIMATED PREMIUMS
lone luding Completed Operations) = Description | Estinated Seles [i aiily inj. [Piop-Demege| _Gedily Inivey | Denase
New Aireralr Seles $ $ $ $ $
Used Aircraft Sales
Aircraft fuel end lubricents
Repeir end Service
Ports and Accessories - not instolled
qregete
imits - B.1.$ P.D.$ Single Limit $
MAT PREMIVUAL
SECTION II! CONTRACTUAL ~ Identification of Controcts aie MATEO pens —
$ $
Aggregote Limits P.D. $
ESTIMATED PREMIUAAS
SECTION IV ALTERATIONS - Description " Sie aor Wes Smays
s $
Aggregote Protective Limits P.O.$
PREMIUM
SECTION V HANGARKEEPERS LEGAL LIABILITY Sedily teiwy |? -)
LIMITS OF LIABILITY: Any One Avvereft $ Any One Lees § x x Xx $
Airports Lesetion Heagers:
0 Including Tossing (L) Excluding Texiing Oedverible Eock Aircraft, Each Loss 5
LMNIMUM PREMIUMS ~ Seer. ' Sect. Il Sect. tl Seer. IV TOTAL PREMIUMS
Bodily nivry «$US s $ $
Property Damage 5 <2V- s . $
Single Lim
$230. |s 252.
of ie effective on
isswed by
Name of beewred
$s 5 s s
This endorsement, including ol! provisions ond stetements set teorth hereon ond on the second poge here-
* - -“ ~ o , a”
Ascust ver 1” 7z hed to end terming pert ef Policy Ne. 214033
*orivcas Menace Assurance Conptny
woard of Coc.issioners of Vo “ald County
Westminster
Inswrence Mors... inc.
Fa the Compeny .
nd. Ne Page!
Ne. 26/ 945
72
eee ee
= hee nh ees
spn ctelins + ESE
ee eo
wb A a
[200]
le «0 hevety understood ond agreed that oniy os respects the coveroges etlorded by the ear-ous sett ons of this endersemer
(1) the words “excluding possengers’” shell be deleted tor “Bedily injury Liab. tity - Cociuding Posse sors”
eqeenmen's of the polecy end policy decleratrens (2) es rospects Property Damege sot ty. the wer ‘» ”
yee «© the porey shell be deleted and the «ord ‘ecerdent’™’ substituted ae hie P y does mot cov
imposed wpon the emeured by any Federal, Stote of Lece! Sterute reloring to the selling, ge mg of o sPene
hqvors
Sector! Prem sen — Avepert Leability
1, Tre Povey ended to epply wth respect to the ownership. mantenance oF vse for the purposes stated on schedule. of
the prem 88 des groted therern, end oll eperotions of the named insured at oF ower from the premises which are cecesenr
eo eotel te such per peses.
2. Cetin ton of ineured."" As respects Section | of thes endorsement, the unqvalitied word “insured’” meane ony partner
eercut<@ off-cee or derector of the nomed insured while acting within the scope of his dutres of such
3. Ace » Eeclusrons The Policy does rot epply under Section | of this endorsement to
ier @ » ceralt owned by, hired by oF fer, or leened te the .reured of to ony eucratt on tight by oF on the enterest of the
se e0
one Qemeet, a race, demonstrator or show
any grandstand of © sup sPeting structure of ony hind where the highest seating surface +s in emcees of sin feet from
e ound,
5. «cterccalt while ewoy trom the premises, of power driven lend vehicles ond vehicles etteched thereto, includ ng leod
, ond wn coding thereo!, while ewoy from the premises of the woys smmediotely odjornng,
eo) ony elevotor other then on elevator which is not operated, mointained of controlied by the Insured ond +s lecoted in @
ou iding of which the Insured 9 not the owner, general lessee of sole tenont,
+, bgecbty woth respect to which imeurence is of con be offorded under the printed provisions of the Poly or any other
secton of thie endorsement,
—_—_ 3) operations on oF from other premises which ore owned, rented of contralled by the Insured,
cn) ory of the following im so for os any of them eccur on of from premises owned by or rented to the named insured ond
vey ot destroy buridings of contents thereel ond ore not due to fire: (1) the discherge, leokage of overtiow
© steom from plumbing, heoting, relrigeroting of Gir-conditioning systems, standp: pes for fire hose, of industri) of
dor este appliences, of any substonce from eutometic sprinkler systems, (2) the collapse or fall of tanks of the com-
ponent parts or supports thereol which form @ part of automatic sprinkler systems, o- (3) rein oF snow admitted directly
to ne buriding interior through defective roots, leoders of spouting, of open of defective doors, windows, skylights,
tronsoms of venti letors,
) om cry to or destruction of premises eliencted by the nemed Insured out of which the accident or:ses,
— oo ty @ssumed by the insured under ony contract or ogreement.
Section | ~ Prodwets Liobslity
1, Tre Po.cy extended to apply with respect to:
Le) tre nondiing or use of, the existence, of ony condition in of @ worronty of goods o products manvloctured, sold,
nongied or disterbuted by the nomed Insured, other than equipment rented to of locoted for use of others but not sold,
in connection with the operetions conducted by the nemed insured ot the premises, if the occ dent occurs after the
avored hes relinquished possession thereof to others ond ewoy from premises owned, rented or controlled by tne
sured or on promises for which the clessificotion stored in the company's menue! excludes ony port of the foregoing,
'b) operations, in connection with opereiens conducted by the named insured at the premices, if the ccerdent occurs after
sccm eperorens how been completed o* ebendoned at the place of occurence thereot and ewoy from premises owned,
revved ov controlled by the Insured, except (@) pick-up and delivery and (b) the ex:stence of tools, uninstolled eauip-
mers ond ebondened or unused materials, provided, operations shell not be deemed incomplere becouse improperly or
cerect:vely performed of becouse further operations mey be required pursuant to © service of maintenance ogreemen.
All comages orssing out of one prepared of ocquired lot of goods of products shell be considered o8 crising out of one
ece:dent) 7 me oggregere limit of lebility of set forth on Section fi of schedule is the toro! limit of the Compony's labslity on
eecoun! ov | accidents which oceur during the policy period.
2. Delinvt oo of ““insured.”’ As respects Section |i of this endorsement, the unquelified word “ineured”™” means any portner,
enecutive of cer or director af the named Insured while acting within the scope of his dutves os such.
3. Addtions Exclusions. The Policy does not epply under Section Ii of this endorsement to:
le) , to, of destruction including lose of use, of ony eircrolt of products, monuloctured, sold, handled of distributed
or wore completed by or for the named Insured ovt of which the accident “rises,
(eo) corlity ossumed by the insured under ony contract uf agreement other than o worranty of goods or products.
4. Premium. The eormed premium under Section Ii shell upon terminet.on of the Policy be computed in accordance with tne
Compe os's (ules. rates, rating plons, premiums end minimum premiums applicable to thes insurance. If the earned premium
thus comoviec exceeds the estimored premium paid, the named Insured shall poy the excess to the Company, sf less. the Com
peny snus return to the nomed insured the unearned portion poid by such Insured.
$. Wren used os @ premium besis, the word ‘soles’ shall meon the gross amount of money chorged by the nemed insured or
by others troeing under his name for oll goods ond products sold or distributed during the policy period, ond charged during
the policy ceroa for instelletion, servicing oF repar, ond includes toxes, other then toxes which the nomed insured end such
ethers collect os © separate stem and remit directly to @ governmental division
6. Inspection ord Audit. The Compory shell be mitted to inspect the insured premises, operations, end avcroft and te
erom.ne i 2 ccdu the Insured’s books ond records of eny time during the Policy perred and eny extension therool and «thin
@ne “emi © Deve tote ese Sh ythee Palen, SebG havtduring Ue Haithy greed ako vey ore abd hee esd Ged oe atlein
ene peor ce toe Tene! termmatien of this Poley, os for os they relote to the premium besis oF the subject motter of this
insurer @
Section til - Contractve! Liability
1. The coveoge provided by the Policy is extended to include liability ossumed by the nomed Insured under such contrects os
he aera coder Section ill of the schedule of this endorsement, subject to Policy Terms, Conditions, Limitotions ond
velusvors.
2 Additione: Excivavons. The Policy does not epply under Section Ill of this endorsement ro:
(e) loarity Ossumed under eny contract of agreement not stemaed in the schedule,
{b) ony of he following om se for es ony of them occur on of from premises owned by or rented to the nemed Insured ane
inicr@ OF Gestrey buvleungs or contents thereof end ore not due to fire: (1) the discherge leakage of overtiow of worer
or steam trom plumbing, hearing, refrigeroting of exr-conditioning systems, stondpipes for five hose, oF industriel or
domest:< eppliences, of any substence from automatic sprinkler systems, (2) the collepse of fal! of tenks of the com-
ponent ports or supports thereol which form og of evtemetic sprinkler systems, or (3) rem or snow edminted directly
s, le
te the busiaung interior through defective roo ede é y
ee eas a coeds ver +8 @ spouting, or open or defective doors, windows, skylights,
le) inpery 10 oF destrvervon of promises olienared by the named Insured out of which the eccsdent arises,
d) voqwtr te, of destevetron of any ewcrolt of prodyct ‘
: bor the named Insured ot of which the ece Sao. SEER, Gal, CREED & CRD CaP CERES SY eS
The egaregete bem ef lvebstity ser forth in Seervon ttl of the schedule is the tore! limi of the Compeny’s labs lity on
eccount of oli demeges ersing out of sniury to or destruction of property with respect to each controct.
continved on reverse side
Mo. 26.2 Rew. 61970 Sat, to. Pr?
73
(201)
issuedte -. cen Of Commissioners Of De Naso COUrry
This encorsement, effective August G, 197. forms o part of policy No. 214033
(12:01 A.M,, stenderd time, ot oddrese of the insured)
in Consider- [ 1Additional Premium |} of $ Wil for days %e
4 \
ation of __) Return Premium \ ie of $
It 1s hereby Understood and Agreed thot
2. Jae presius for Lhe policy is duc and payable as follows:
August 6, 1972 $500.
August 6, 1973 $500.
August 6, 1974 $500.
Be Waiver of Goveranental In.unity
‘It is agreed that the company waives any right to cony
licbility under the policy or to refuse paycent wituin the
Liaits taereof by reason of the non-liabiiity of the in-
sexed political subdivision for the wrongful or necligeat
acts of its agents and esployces and its isuunity fro.
ecit as an agency of the State performing governscntal
zunctioa.®
The provisions of the following pages, if any, are @ port of this endorsement. All other terms and conditions of
this policy remcin unchenged.
Westminster insurance
Manegers, inc.
For the Compony
End. No. 2 Pegel_
sO. 6-64-69
74
3 eee
[202]
issued to... COmuissiouers of vo Ralb County
This endorsement, effective August 6, 197 f ' 2d
(12:01 A.M. etenderd tims, e ze of the maa” — “ os aihias 21606”
In Consider- [_] Additione! Premium of $ for doys 5
stion of Cj Return Premium ie of $
It is hereby Understood and Agreed thet:
AWIUAL REVICT
Tais policy as subject to automatic notica of
vancellation to take effect upon anniversary cate (s).
The provisions of the following pages, if ony, ore a part of this endorsement. All other terms and conditions of
this policy remain unchanged.
Westminster insurence
Meonegers, inc.
For the Compony
a
nO. @ 6-69 End. Ne. m— Pege 2
75
[203]
1, Definitions
in Averett «herever used in this policy shall wear the oircrott dewrbhed
herein inctv “9 engines propellers, operating ond navigator imetruments ord
redo equip ert stocked or usvolly ottached thereto including parts detached
ond not -ep acet by ofher emlor parts When two or more aircraft ore inwred
hereunder. te ‘ems of the poly sholl apply seporctely to each
btn Plight -*erever used in this policy shall meor the perod from the time
the avrerolt oc oe #0" @ rotercraft: moves forward in taking off oF in attempting
to take off ‘o + onet while 9 the ai, ond wntt the arcralt completes its
landing on: ‘2-4 7g run alter contact with the lend or iwhen eq peed with
flotane- 9° * woter A rotorcrate sholl be deemed to be “in flight” wher
the rotos coe * motor os o rewlt of engine power, the momentum generoted
the efrom oo "cof shen
‘te Motion “2208 off mimes when the ovrcraft is “in fight” and in addinen
wherever '°* 4 9 mowing under itt own power of the momentum gener ed
hereby
4 Pive eee used is thie policy shell mean fire lighting, explosion. self
gr tor ir au '°@ oF explonon is caused directly or indirectly by colliman of the
girera’? # ** “8 od woter or ony object
‘eo Thelr see vsed in the policy sholl weon theft robbery larceny or
eieroge *:.7°9 comnge done by theves
1 Pleawwre ond Bunnew « defired os persona! pleawre fomly ond buwness
“oe 9 2+ eperetion for which o cherge a made excep? that shored
expenses ~ 4: *o ‘ve! costs ond storoge fees for a particular flight sholl not be
c3oered = > yf
@ Industriel Ad + cet ned os the Hansportation of officials, employees, guest
mercharce = uses erumercted 9 the defininon of Pleawre and Buviren
but eat'.c -3 operation for whe! o charge «4 made except thor shoe?’ oF
perves lm ee eo! cos ond storage fees for o particular Might shal? not be
Gee~et > 3
bh Instruction ond Mental 9 defined os used principolly in the buwness of the
imwred. * 3 wudert instruction, rental to others ond Pleawre ard Businew
ovrposes >." ec. 3 °Q DOmenge’ Corrying for hire
( Umvved Commerciet is defined as vied principally in the buwnen of the
awed + “9 romenger or freight carrying for hire and Pleasure and Buynesns
sven but ee rg *struchon to of rental to others
) Commercial -cudes ol! uses enumerated in the defistons of lnuruction ond
Pentel ons . ~ “03 Commertiol
Passenger vholl meon ony person o- persons while in. entering oF leaving
the. @irc*e **e purpose of flight other than the pilot, copilot. members of
the crew > 100s ofd officals while in the course of their employment by the
ewe
Occurrence 45°: ot oreident, of ao continuous of repeated expcwre to
conahers reu'ts on inwry during the policy period provided the injury
ved 4!) damages areng ovt of such exposure to substantially
os one shol! be consicered os orinng ovt of one occurrence
=) “@spects ony person. means bodily inyury. sckness including mentol
2rgvis*. crecre of death resulting therefrom. ond os respects any property. eon
mury? sv ucton of the property including low cf use thereof
= <Asteu't ond Battery shall be deemed on orcurrence but when committed
by of ct “eo eto e of the neured shall not be deemed on occurrence unless
comm tes + purpowe of preTBring dangerous interference with the operation
of he Oo
> Feeders’ Avotion Agency of “FAA” shall alm include the Civil Aeronoy
*s Bor : *-@ oy consetuted Notonal Authority hawng jurisdiction ower civil
ov "0" © og* ted country
2. orice of Occurrence, Injury, Damage or Cloim (Coverages A, 8. C, D, E ond
#) Wher o> cor.crence inwry, damage or claim tokes ploce, written notice shall be
g ver by © cr behalf of the insured to the compony or any of its authorited ayents
os soot os coach cable Such notice shall contain particulars wificient to identify
the intured ood also reasonably obtainable information respecting the time, place
ond circumwarces of the occurrence, the names ond addresses of the injured ond
of ava'ab > « termes
3. Notice of Claim or Suit (Coverages A, 8, C. 0. E end F). If claim is mode or
twit broug’? ogons? the insured, the insured shall immediotely forward to the
company et) demand, notes, summons or other process received by him or hie
reprevento’
4. —_ Limits of Liability (Coverages A. B,C, 0. E and F). The limit of liability stated
n the decorations is the limit of the company’s licbility for off domoges arising
ovt of the one occurrence
The |= + of liability stoted in the declarations for coverages A ond C os op
” ony one The inch herein of more than one insured thull not
operate to increase the lim ts of the company's babi lity
5. — Assistonce ond Cooperetion of the Invured. The inwred shall cooperate with
the company ond vpon the company’s reqver. shall attend hearings ond Wiel ond
shall cwist in effecting settiemenn securing ond giving evidence, obtoining the
ottendence of witnenmes ond in the conduct of wits The insured shall net, except
ot his own cost voluntorily make ony payment otume any obligation o incur any
expenses other than fur wwch immediate medico! ond surgical relief to others ov
shall be imperotive of the time of accident
6. Action Ageinst Compeny. No action shall he ogoinst the compony under cow
eroges A. 8 C.D and £. unlew os @ condition precedent thereto, the inwred shall
hove fully complied with oll of the terms of this policy, nor until the amount of
the inwured’s obligation to poy shall hove been finally determined either by jvdg-
actual trial or by written agreement between the
i!
te
sh
to recover uncer the terme of this policy in the some monner ond to the some
extent os the inwred Nothing contained in thie policy shell give any person or
orgoniszetion ony righ! to join the company as a
t
if
uF
itt
28
j ue
itl
:
z
i
it
i
i
r
u
my
:
|
rear
ably require
The company may pay the injured person or any person of organisation render.
ing the services and weh payment thol! reauce the amount payable hereunder for
such injury. Poyment hereunder shall not constitute admission of ‘iebility of the
insured or, except hereunder, of the compary
9. Other Inrurence. If the insured hor other insurance ogolns! @ fom covered
by ‘his policy the company shall not be lable under this policy for o
portion of such low than the applicable lie t of hability stoted in the declarations
beort to the toto! applicable |r of liability of all valid and collectible inwrarce
agoirst such fom, provided. however, the insurance under Inwring Agreements V
ond Vi sholl be exces inturance over any other valid ond co!
available to the insured. ether os on insured under a policy applicable with respect
to the aircraft or otherwine agoinst a los covered under either or both of said
Insuring Agreements
10, insured’s Duties When Loss Occurs (Coverages G, H. | end J). When low ox-
curt, the insured sholl. fo protect the orcratt, prowded the insured is able to
10. whether or not the low « covered by the policy ond ony further loss due
the inwwred’s failure to protect shall not be recoverable under this policy, however,
where the low or domage witered constitutes o claim under thy
reosonable expense incurred 9 affording such protechon shall
'
Fe
under ths policy, (>) give notice thereo! os sonn on pr ible to the pany or
any of its authorized agents ond also, in event of theft, larceny, robbery or pilfer-
og*. to the police bur shall rot, except ot bis own cost, offer or poy ony reward
for recovery of the aircraft ic) file proof of tou with the company wo! wary
doys after lov. unless such time is extended in writing by the company. ir form
ti
id8
of @ torn statement of the insured setting forth the interest of the
of ait others 9 the property affected. any encumbrances the
_
ae eye
TU, Umit of Linbility, Mo Abendonment (Coverages G. 4. | ond J). The limit of the
company’s liability for low shall not exceed the ortval cath valve of the areratt
at the time of low nor what it would then cost to repair or reploce the oucralt
© ports thereo! with other of like kind ond quality nor shall it exceed: io) on the
cow 0f & totul low the amour? of inronre oF oy orcratt the wwhert a « «len
thi in the cove of portal lowe whee ropa rs ove wade by the inered the artue!
coe of any ports oF materials recewuory to erfert eps “+ Or replorement plus 199”
af the actual cow to the inevred of labor @xclveve of averteome lahar ond overhead
when the ropa: ore mate by other fron "he caved Mme actyal cous os endenred
by bills rendered to the nevred ‘em ory Pecowr’ grorted to the owed eerluiog
cov of overtime urien prewauty agreed "so by *e compory fn oo event all the
lability of the compory for partic! low esteed the amount for which the company
would be boble were the low payable os © tote’ tow
In the event of either @ total lows or @ partia! low. there can be no abandonment
of any property to the company however, ony salvage remaining shal! inure to the
12. Deductible (Coversges GO. H | ond J) The omouet of the deductole per
fed in the declororors shall be deducted from the amount othereue payable
woder hia policy
The “In Motor Deductible” os stated i¢ the Oeclaraton: shell apply to earth
lows ocrurring while the oireralt in motion
The “Not in Motion Deductible” os sioted in the Derluratons sho! apply to
each lows occurring while the aircraft ie not in motor except no deductib'y wl!
apely to ony such lon coved by fire eeplowon. lightning theft, except theft of
or piterage of on aircraft rot regularly hangored af ty home apart. oF or
octident to the conveyance if oF on which the areratt «hoe demartied « berg
transported
13. Approise! (Coverages G. 4. I ond J). If the insured ond the company fai! to
at to the amourt of loss, each shall. on the written demand of either mode
within siaty dove after receipt of proof of low by the compory, select o competent
and disinterested appraiser, ond the opproisa! shall be mode at @ reasonable time
ond plore. The appraisers shall first select o potent ard d d umpire.
ond failing for ‘ite0n days to agree upon wuch umpire ther on the request of the
insured oF the compory such umpire sholl be selected by o vdge of o court of
record in the county ond state in which such appraisal is pending. The opproisers
shall then appraise the lors, stating separately the actual cosh value ot the time of
loss and the amount of los, ond falling to ogres sholl submit ther differences to
the umpire Ar oword in writing of any two shall determine the amount of low
The insured ond the company shall each pay his oF its choser appraiser and shal!
bear eavolly the other expenses of the appraisal! and ump re
The compory tha! cot be held to hove woived any of its rights by any act reiot
ong 9 appro! o”
14, Cost of Tromsportotion (Coverages G. 4. | ond J) The cost of transporting
new of domaged ports of of transporting the domaged arcraft to the pince of
pair and return to place of accident, or home airport, whichever be the nearer
shall be | ited to the least expensive method of reotonah'e transportation
In case of low arising outside the continental limits of the United States of
America, the let of the compory’s lability for salvaging the aircraft including
the trarsportation therea! and/or the transportation of new or damaged party to
the place of repo’ ond return to the place of accident or home arport, whichever
be the nearer, shall be limited to the lear expentive methods of rensorable trons
portation and .n fo event shol! exceed 15°. of the clam otherwise payable
1. A te Re (Covereges G. 4, | ond J). in the event of lon,
whether or not covered by the polity, the amount of insurance in respect to ony
aircralt shall be reduced as of the sme and date of low by the amount of such
lows ond wh reduced valve shall comtiove unt! repars ore commenced when the
amount of insurance thal! automancally be increased by the value of the completed
repoirs until the Amount of insurance is fully renstoted oF the policy hos expired
[204]
16. In the overt of any payment under this palty, the company
shall be whragated to oll the insured’s right) of recovery therefor agent any
pe-wn and the imwred thal! eserute ond deliver instruments ond papers ond do
awhotever else is necessary to secure guth rights
17. Chenges. No rorce % ony ayent of knowledge powened by ony agent or by
any other person shall be held to effect o waver oF change (7 ony port of thw
policy nor estop the company from amerting any right under the terms oH this pol
cy, nor tholl the terms of this policy be woived oF changed escent by entone
ment inwed to form port herent! waned by o duly authorised Aical A the
Compary
1B, Assignment No assignment of interest under this policy shall bind the com
pony until its consent ic endorsed hereon, i. however, the named invred shall
de of be adwdged bork snot oF insolvent within the
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.