Petition — Porter County Chapter of the Izaak Walton League of America, Inc. v. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
MICMAEL RODAK, JR.,CLERK
In Tue
Supreme Court of the United States
Ocroser Term, 1976
No. 76- 76-291 {
PORTER COUNTY CHAPTER OF THE IZAAK WALTON
LEAGUE OF AMERICA, INC., et al.; and THE PEOPLE
OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, Ex Rel. WILLIAM J.
SCOTT, Attorney General of the State of Illinois; and THE
CITY OF GARY, INDIANA,
Petitioners,
va.
THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION, THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
[Signatures on Conclusion Page]
————————
Printed by Authority of the State of Illinois
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
OPINIONS BELOW AND PRIOR OPINION OF
fT 2
I ecitctatintseniniicetiens apaaiaaaieas 3
QUESTIONS PRESENTED ...cccssocososssnnsssnesesnessneesee 3
STATUTES INVOLVED ..cccsscossssessscssseessesesnsetsnsenee 4
STATEMENT OF THE CASE ..cccsscoossossssnssssnsseneeeen 5
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT «0.00.00... 13
I,
The Specific Statutory Authority of the Com-
mission to Issue Licenses Neither Directly Nor
by Implication Confers the Power to License Ac-
tivity Which Will Cause Adverse Impacts on a
National Park under the Specific and Exclusive
Jurisdiction of Interior for Preservation, Protec-
ae ID oi iinscelincsstniscnisnaicsisssihinateiabineitinanisisisisies 14
A. The Authorizing Legislation of the Com-
mission Does Not Grant It the Authority to Per-
mit Activity Which Will Damage or Interfere
with a National Park Except in Extraordinary
Circumstances Not Present Here .................cc0cceeceeeeee 14
B. Congress has Delegated Specific and Ex-
clusive Jurisdiction over the National Park Sys-
tem, Including the National Lakeshore, to the De-
eee 17
IT
NEPA Does Not Confer Authority upon the
Commission to Permit Intrusions into a National
Park Nor to Decide the Amount of Harm to Be
I 20
RP OPIIEE | cevtsnminnsssnninicnimnmsamninemnennieennne 24
APPENDIX OF STATUTES ...........cc-cscscecssssssesesssssssserees la
il
TABLE OF CITATIONS
Cases
Ex Parte Endo, 323 U.S. 283, 300-802 (1944) ...0....cccesee 14
Jones v. Lynn, 477 F, 2d 885, 890 (1st Cir, 1975) .......... 21
Phelps Dodge Corp. v. Labor Board, 313 U.S. 177, 193-
BG CIGD ccceccesccccccenssscrssenvsececnscennecnevsnuscsnvesseessneucseee: waauedes 14
Shuttle Corp. v. Transit Comm’n., 393 U.S, 186, 187
EET csenncesevesicnanisianneinnesssncatessesiitnataismnnensiansicienemeenneanes 19
State of New Hampshire v. Atomic Energy Commis-
sion, 406 F, 2d 170, 174 (1st Cir. 1969); cert. den,
Se es Se CITED scetneiceccnnssereeannseacentetindtgeintenintenmmvsienons 1, 21
Udall v. Washington, Virg'nia and Maryland Coach
Co., 398 F. 2d 765 (D.C. Cir. 1968) .0..........cssscserereees 19
United States ex rel. Roughton v. Ickes, 101 F, 2d 24s,
BD CTE. Gae. BBD ccccccsccecscrecccasnsctneesenstsesssenrecnsevmnsacscsnes 19
United States v. SCRAP (SCRAP I), 412 U.S. 669,
GE CITE) ccccecccecesscccesencrccccsncccnsvsscssesescesesssonsesscsesoussocessscences 21
United States v. Stoeeco Homes, Inc., 498 F. 2d 597, 607
EE TIED ecccssianentemnincemsannenmnnstenmseemmniaamaremsens 21
Statutes
he | acre ee 3
Atomie Energy Act of 1954, as amended
BUTE. GEBIEL 60 GOR. ccccececssscseseszcscsnsssenee 4, 5, 14, 15, la
8 eer 15, 16, la
42 U.S.C. $§2131-2140 ............... CS ennmanenaniia 15, 2a-Va
is Se ceternccceteerneenncctemensesctnmesemnsnianan 15, 9a
iii
Clean Air Act
42 U.S.C. $$1857-1858(a) .......cceccccccscecccecsecesesserereseesere 22n.
Endangered Species Act
Be Was FREED ceccecsceszesvscececescncscenscnssssssnansesusumns 22n.
Energy Reorganization Act
GB UEC, GRBBOL GGA aoncecececnscscceccccccsesecescsscsecsesecccevoveces 5n.
EA ee ae 5n.
_ 1 SE Ta ee 5n.
EL ae 5n.
Federal Power Act
EE 22
Federal Water Pollution Control Act
Amendments of 1972
i 22n.
Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore Authorization Act
16 U.S.C. §§460u-460u-9 oo. 4, 17, 19, 23, 19a-25a
16 U.S.C, $460u ............... inbanielinieicsbinpibianisiabasieapemtuanin 5,17, 19a
5, 18, 23a
Re 18, 24a
Marine Protection Research and Sanctuaries
Act of 1972
BE 22n.
National Environmental Policy of 1969
ER FS 4, 9n., 26a
A Ee Te 21, 29a
Noise Control Act of 1972
i le OTD sisccrnicdnsstnceenestecientenpnatnincenesntameseeiniatiies 22n.
Organic Act of the National Park Service, as amended
| SARE 4, 7, 17, 18, 19, 23, 29a
| eee 4, 17, 19, 23, 32a
iv
Public Law 91-383, August 18, 1970
(National Park Service)
EEE 4, 17, 18, 19, 23, 30a
it 0.2 ° 4, 17, 18, 19, 23, 30a
Wild and Scenic Rivers Act
ISG U.DB.C. GISTL-1GF nnn 22
Wilderness Act of 1964
CN yyy—————————————EEE 22n.
Regulations
Oe os 2) Sf) ee x
ee, 2) ) | |) a Ss
Tee BU OM) x
ey, £2) s
Compilation of Administrative Policies for National
Parks and National Monuments of Scientific Sig-
nificance (Natural Area Category), Revised 1970,
i nN ee 7n.
In THE
Supreme Court of the Gnited States
Octrosper Term, 1976
No. 76-
PORTER COUNTY CHAPTER OF THE IZAAK WALTON
LEAGUE OF AMERICA, INC., et al.; and THE PEOPLE
OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, Ex Rel. WILLIAM J.
SCOTT, Attorney General of the State of Illinois; and THE
CITY OF GARY, INDIANA,
Petitioners,
V8.
THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION, THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
Petitioners! pray that a Writ of Certiorari issue to
review the judgment of the United States Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit entered on April 13,
1976.
' Petitioners are Porter County Chapter of the Izaak Walton
League of America, Inc.; Concerned Citizens against Bailly
Nuclear Site; Businessmen for the Public Interest, Inc.; James
E. Newman: Mildred Warner; and George Hanks; all of whom
were petitioners in the court below and intervenors in the
agus proceeding under review; and the People of the State
of Illinois; and the City of Gary, Indiana, both of which were
petitioners-intervenors in the court below.
-
OPINIONS BELOW AND PRIOR
OPINION OF THIS COURT
This opinion of the court below, reported at 533 F. 2d
1011, is reproduced in the Appendix to this Petition at
pp. 1-13. The order denying petitions for rehearing and
suggestions for rehearing en banc is reproduced in the
Appendix at p. 14.
The Initial Decision of the Atomic Safety and Licen-
sing Board of the Atomic Energy Commission of April
5, 1974, reported at RAI-74-4, 557, is reproduced in the
Appendix at pp. 65-186. The Atomic Safety and Licen-
sing Appeal Board decision of August 29, 1974, which is
the final agency decision under review and is reported
at RAI-74-8, 244, is reproduced in the Appendix at pp.
187-219.
The order of the court of appeals of October 16, 1974
staying construction pending judicial review is repro-
duced in the Appendix at pp. 63-64, and its order and
opinion of April 1, 1975, setting aside the decision of the
AEC, reported at 515 F. 2d 513, is reproduced in the
Appendix at pp. 22-61. The opinion of this Court of
November 11, 1975, reversing the court of appeals deci-
sion and remanding to the court for consideration of
other contentions, reported at 423 U.S. 12, is reproduced
in the Appendix at pp. 15-21.
= =
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the court of appeals was entered on
April 13, 1976 (App. p. 1). Timely petitions for rehear-
ing and suggestions for rehearing en banc were denied
on June 1, 1976 (App. p. 14). This Court has jurisdiction
to review the judgment by Writ of Certiorari pursuant
to 28 U.S.C. § 1254(1).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
The decision of the court below, affirming a decision
of the Atomic Energy Commission (“Commission”), in
which the Commission purported to exercise authority
over a National Park by permitting construction of a
nuclear power plant on a site immediately adjacent to
the National Park, even though the Commission found
that the plant would cause intrusions into and impacts
upon the Park, presents important and continuing
questions of federal law regarding the authority of an
administrative agency, which have not been, but should
be, settled by this Court.
More specifically, the questions which this Court
should decide are:
1. Whether the Commission may, in the absence
of a specific statutory grant, exercise authority over
a National Park—here the Indiana Dunes National
Lakeshore which is the subject of special statutory
protection—by permitting a private company to
engage in an activity which the Commission has
found will impact within the boundaries of the
_
National Park and by purporting to determine
what measures shall be taken within the Park to
mitigate the damage, where the Department of the
Interior has specific and exclusive jurisdiction to
preserve, protect and manage the National Park.
2. Whether the National Environmental Policy
Act of 1969 (“NEPA”) confers authority upon the
Commission to determine what intrusions into, im-
pacts upon, and damage mitigating measures
within the National Park shall be permitted or be
taken, where all such activities are otherwise
prohibited.
STATUTES INVOLVED?
Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, 42
U.S.C. §§ 2011 et seq.
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, 42
U.S.C. §§ 4321 et seg.
Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore Authoriza-
tion Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 460u-460u-9.
Organic Act of the National Park Service, as
amended, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1, 2.
Public Law 91-383, August 18, 1970 (National
Park Service), 16 U.S.C. §§ la-1, le.
* Due to the length of the provisions of the statutes involved,
their pertinent text is set forth in the Statutory Appendix at
the end of the Petition.
=
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
The court below denied a petition to review final
decisions of the Commission,* which authorized issuance
to Northern Indiana Public Service Company
(““NIPSCO”) of a construction permit for a nuclear
power plant to be built on NIPSCO’s Bailly site in
Porter County, Indiana on the southern shore of Lake
Michigan.
The Bailly site shares a common boundary with the
Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore, authorized by Con-
gress in 1965 to be established as a unit of the National
Park System by the Secretary of the Interior “in order
to preserve for the educational, inspirational and
recreational use of the public certain portions of the In-
diana Dunes and other areas of scenic, scientific and
historic interest and recreational value .. .” 16 U.S.C.
§ 460u.
% In 1974, after the agency decision and while this case was
pending in the court of appeals, Congress separated the
promotional and regulatory functions previously performed by
the Atomic Energy Commission (“AEC”) *, enacting the
Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, Pub. L. No. 93-438, Oc-
tober 11, 1974, 42 U.S.C. §§ 5801-5891. The legislation abol-
ished the AEC and transferred its research and development
functions to the new Energy Research and Development Ad-
ministration. 42 U.S.C. § 5814(c). The AEC’s regulatory func-
tions were transferred to the new Nuclear Regulatory Com-
mission (“NRC”). /d., § 5841(f). Also transferred to this new
Commission were the responsibilities of the Atomic Safety
and Licensing Board and the Atomic Safety and Licensing
Appeal Board. /d., § 5841(g).
For convenience of reference throughout this Petition, the
agency will be referred to as the “Commission”.
~
The National Lakeshore was found by the Commis-
sien, and by the court below, to be one of the best
remaining areas of the Indiana Dunes—“a natural area
difficult to equal anywhere in the Nation” (App. pp. 28-
29: 109). As the Commission’s Atomic Safety and Licen-
sing Board concluded (App. pp. 109-110):
“The location of the proposed facility on the shore
of Lake Michigan to the north and bounded on the
east by the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore is
characterized by its proximity to an environment of
special qualities.
x * *
That portion of the Indiana Dunes National
Lakeshore adjacent to the Bailly site and consisting
of some 1,200 acres is one of the best remaining
areas in the Indiana Dunes.
x * *
The dynamic nature of the Indiana Dunes has at-
tracted scientists as an ideal outdoor laboratory to
study the principles of ecological succession. . . .
On the south of the dune complex, and to the
north of the ancient shoreline of the Calumet stage
of Lake Michigan ... is a unique wetland area
known as Cowles Bog which contains an undrained
pond or depression filled with water and largely
covered by a relatively thick mat of vegetation.”
Prior to the passage of the act authorizing the
National Lakeshore, then Senator Paul Douglas ex-
pressed his views of the area:
‘ Similarly, the Commission’s Atomic Safety and Licensing
Appeal Board stated:
“The Lakeshore . . . encompasses beaches, sand dunes,
marshes, and bogs and is generally dedicated to public
recreational purposes. Some of its features, the dune
ridges and Cowles Bog National Landmark in particular,
are undoubtedly unique.” (App. p. 200)
Hearin before the Subcommittee on Flood Control—
Rivers nal Slashers of the Committee on Public Works, U.S.
Senate, 89th Cong., Ist Sess., April 20-23, 1965, 389.
~~
“The Indiana Dunes are one of nature’s great gifts
to this country. As Carl Sandburg has written:
‘The dunes are to the Midwest what the Grand
Canyon is to Arizona and Yosemite is to Califor-
nia. They constitute a signature of time and eter-
nity: Once lost the loss would be irrevocable.’
The proposed Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore
would provide a badly needed beach playground,
along with nature areas of high scientific value, for
the millions of people living in the crowded Gary-
Chicago region.”
The Department of the Interior (“Interior”), which has
exclusive jurisdiction over the National Lakeshore, has
classified the 1,200 acres immediately abutting
NIPSCO’s Bailly site as Class IV lands: “those which
contain unique natural features”. . . “which must have
the highest order of protection” ... and on which
“nothing in the way of human use should be permitted
. . . that intrudes upon or may in any way damage or
alter the scene.” (App. pp. 109-110; Int. Ex. 23).®
As a unit of the National Park System, the use of the
National Lakeshore is under the jurisdiction of Interior’s
National Park Service which is obligated to promote
and regulate its use to conform to the fundamentai pur-
pose of the Park (16 U.S.C. § 1). That fundamental pur-
pose is:
“to conserve the scenery and the natural and
historic objects and the wild life therein and to
provide for the enjoyment of the same in such
manner and by such means as will leave them un-
impaired for the enjoyment of future generations.”
(ibid.)
i)
Compilation of Administrative Policies for National Parks
and National Monuments of Scientific Significance (Natural
Area Category) Revised 1970, p. 34.
=
The power plant which NIPSCO seeks to build at the
Bailly site includes a building for the nuclear reactor
located 800 feet from the National Lakeshore boundary
(Staff Ex. 5, p. Il-1), turbines, generators and. equip-
ment for handling and storing radioactive wastes. The
plant would include a massive cooling tower ap-
proximately 450 feet high, 440 feet in diameter at the
base, and 350 feet in diameter at the top (App. pp. 129;
201).
Commission safety regulations require that there be
an area around the plant under the complete control of
NIPSCO, the “exclusion area”, which the Commission
determined should be 107 acres extending to the boun-
dary of the National Lakeshore. [App. p. 27; 10 CFR
§§ 100.3(a), 100.11(a)\(1)|. In addition, the safety
regulations required a “low population zone” immediate-
ly surrounding the exclusion area, intended to serve as a
buffer zone, in which the population is such that “there
is a reasonable probability that appropriate protective
measures could be taken” in the event of a nuclear acci-
dent [10 CFR §§ 100.3(b), 100.11(a)(2)]. The Commission
determined that this buffer zone for nuclear accidents at
the Bailly site should extend 1.5 miles into, and encom-
pass some 640 acres of, the Class IV area of the National
Lakeshore. (App. pp. 52, 71, 203).
The Assistant Secretary of the Interior for Fish,
Wildlife and Parks clearly articulated Interior’s opposi-
tion to the issuance of the construction permit to
NIPSCO. The Assistant Secretary informed the Com-
mission's Licensing Board of Interior’s responsibilities
for preservation and maintenance of the National
Lakeshore, of the adverse impacts which the Bailly
anion
plant would cause to the Lakeshore, and of Interior’s op-
position to those impacts. He stated that it was accurate
that “the Department is completely against the Bailly
site irrevocably.” (App. p. 46).’
On August 29, 1974, the Commission issued its final
decision authorizing the grant of a construction permit
to NIPSCO. The Commission found as a matter of fact
that a number of adverse impacts upon the National
Lakeshore would occur from the construction and opera-
tion of the nuclear power plant, although it sought to
minimize their significance. The first impact would be a
drawdown or lowering of ground water in the National
Lakeshore during the lengthy period of construction due
to site dewatering, with irreparable injury to the fragile
ecology of the Lakeshore. The Commission’s Licensing
Board regarded this impact as “insignificant” but
The Assistant Secretary's communication was the fourth in
a series which consistently informed the Commission of In-
terior's opposition to the plant at the Bailly site because of the
reoung adverse impacts upon the National Lakeshore. First,
the Field Representative of the Secretary of the Interior has
so informed the Commission's Licensing Board. (Tr. 227 et
seqy.). Second, Interior’s comments dated October 19, 1972 on
the Commission's draft environmental statement under NEPA
(42 U.S.C. §§ 4321 et seq.) detailed the reasons for its opposi-
tion and concluded that “construction of the proposed Bailly
Generating Station Nuclear-1 on the border of the Indiana
Dunes National Lakeshore does not serve the ._—; public
interest”. (Reg. Staff Ex. 5, pp. D-12—D-18; pp. & 46).
Third, Interior’s subsequent comments dated April 16, 19738
on the Commission's final environmental statement reiterated
its opposition. (App. Ex. 35; Appendix to Petitioners’ Motion
for Stay Pending Judicial Review, Doc. 3)
=
nevertheless approved a _ dewatering monitoring
program to detect adverse effects of dewatering and to
mitigate such effects (App. pp. 116-117).° %
The Commission found that the cooling tower
“constitutes a man-made, visual intrusion which is an
adverse environmental impact of the Bailly plant”. (App.
p. 132). In addition, it found that the interaction of the
vapor plume of the cooling tower with the emissions
from the smokestack of an existing fossil fuel plant at
the Bailly site would cause sulfuric acid misting in the
National Lakeshore. (App. pp. 120-22). The Com-
mission’s description of these impacts as not “signifi-
cant” or “negligible” or “little” (App. pp. 124, 125, 127)
does not alter the fact that it found they would occur
within the boundaries of the National Park.
Moreover, such descriptions are inconsistent with the
Commission's requirements of monitoring programs to
detect the seriousness of the damage caused to the
In a subsequent administrative proceeding, permitted to be
held by the court of appeals, the Commission approved a
modified construction technique which it found would have a
high probability, but not a certainty, of substantially reducing
or eliminating the need for extensive dewatering at the site.
(NRCI-75/12, 858, 864-865).
* The Licensing Board's confidence in the reliability of the
dewatering monitoring program is striking, in view of
NIPSCO’s admission that it had no criteria to determine
whether a dewatering effect has occurred and that it could
not distinguish between a seasonal fluctuation and an actual
drawdown during construction, (Dunn, Tr. 9474, 9478)
National Lakeshore (App. pp. 116, 117, 124, 125, 127),
The Commission’s decision also authorized NIPSCO and
the Commission's staff to determine what measures
should be taken within the boundaries of the National
Lakeshore “to eliminate or significantly reduce the
detrimental effects of damage”, if “harmful effects or
evidence of irreversible damage are detected by the
monitoring program”. (App. 176-177).
Following denial of a stay of construction by the Com-
mission (App. pp. 214-219), the court of appeals on Oc-
tober 16, 1974 imposed such a stay pending judicial
review (App. pp. 63-64). As of the time of the filing of
this Petition, there has been no resumption of construc-
tion activity on the site.
On April 1, 1975 the court below entered its judgment
setting aside the Commission’s decision on a ground un-
related to the questions presented here. The court held
that the Commission had failed to comply with its own
regulations regarding the required minimum distance
between nuclear reactors and areas of dense population.
(App. p. 22). On November 11, 1975, this Court granted
certiorari and reversed that decision of the court of
” The Licensing Board also found that there would be a dis-
charge of filter backwash and demineralized regenerant
wastes and sanitary wastes to the existing ash ponds, and
seepage from those ponds (at approximately 1 million gallons
per day) into the ground water which flows into the nearby
interdunal ponds in the Lakeshore, as to which the Board con-
cluded that the “incremental effect” is likely to be “insignifi-
cant”. (App. p. 140). The Licensing Board said that an in-
crease either in the amount of surface water runoff into the
Lakeshore, or in the amount of contaminants in the water due
to construction and operation of the plant would not be a
“meaningful impact” and that “in the event that surface water
runoff problems arise eet there are ample means to
correct the situation.” (App. p. 113). There was no indication
as to what those “ample means” might be.
=—
appeals on the ground that the lower court had not
properly interpreted the Commission’s regulations. This
Court remanded for consideration of other contentions
against the issuance of the construction permit not
decided by the court of appeals (App. p. 18).
On April 13, 1976, the court below rendered its judg-
ment denying all other contentions and denied the peti-
tion for review of the Commission's decisions. (App. p.
1). With respect to the questions presented by this Peti-
tion for Certiorari, the court below held that the Com-
mission had authority to make the determination
whether the environmental impact of construction and
operation of the plant upon the National Lakeshore will
be substantial enough to require disapproval of the site.
(App. p. 5). In reaching that conclusion the court
referred to the failure of the Department of the Interior
to either participate as a party in the Commission's
proceedings and the judicial review thereof, or to in-
itiate separate litigation seeking an injunction. (App. p.
4). The court could find nothing in the authorizing
legislation for either the Commission or Interior which
suggests that the views of the latter were to be con-
trolling in this situation. (App. p. 5). It said that the
Commission has “considered” Interior’s comments and
“has given attention to” the environmental effects of the
Bailly plant upon the National Lakeshore, “as the law
requires”. (/bid.)
Timely petitions for rehearing, filed by all petitioners,
were denied by the court below on June 1, 1976 (App. p.
14).
= =
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
The decision of the court below establishes a precedent
of far-reaching consequences. Without considering the
specific authority, express or implied, granted by Con-
gress to the Commission, the court has permitted the
Commission to exercise broad environmental powers,
quite contrary to its Congressional purpose. The court
below reached its decision through an application and
interpretation of NEPA which is inconsistent with
decisions of this Court and other courts of appeals. If the
interpretation rendered by the lower court is permitted
to stand, NEPA may well be turned into a statute for
environmental degradation, rather than one for en-
vironmental protection.
The subject matter of this litigation is the protection
and preservation of a National Park, and it presents the
question of whether, having found that the action it was
asked to license would adversely impact upon a National
Park, the Commission had any authority to issue that
license. Only incidentally does it involve the subject of
nuclear power plants. It presents no technical questions
within the expertise of the Commission.
We respectfully submit that review by this Court of
the important and continuing questions of federal law
presented by this case is warranted.
—Eifes
THE SPECIFIC STATUTORY AUTHORITY OF THE
COMMISSION TO ISSUE LICENSES NEITHER
DIRECTLY NOR BY IMPLICATION CONFERS THE
POWER TO LICENSE ACTIVITY WHICH WILL
CAUSE ADVERSE IMPACTS ON A NATIONAL PARK
UNDER THE SPECIFIC AND EXCLUSIVE JURISDIC-
TION OF INTERIOR FOR PRESERVATION, PROTEC-
TION AND MANAGEMENT.
A. The Authorizing Legislation of the Commission
Does Not Grant It the Authority to Permit Activity Which
Will Damage or Interfere With a National Park Except in
Extraordinary Circumstances Not Present Here.
As a federal agency created by Congress, the Commis-
sion can exercise only that authority explicitly conferred
or necessarily implied from the Congressional purpose
in creating it. This court has repeatedly held that ad-
ministrative authority, like that asserted by the Com-
mission here, must be measured in light of the purpose
for which it was conferred. Refer, for example, to Phelps
Dodge Corp. v. Labor Board, 313 U.S. 177, 193-194
(1941); Ex Parte Endo, 323 U.S. 283, 300-302 (1944).
The Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended'', 42
U.S.C. §§ 2011 et seq., is the authorizing legislation for
the licensing of construction and operation of commer-
cial nuclear power plants. The legislative history of the
Act demonstrates that the Congressional purpose behind
the creation of the Commission was to assure that the
licensing of the construction and operation of commer-
cial nuclear power plants not be inimical to the common
defense and security or to the health and safety of the
public. As the history of the 1954 legislation reveals,
'' As amended and in force at the time of the agenc
proceedings, and as further amended transferring the AE
regulatory functions to NRC. Footnote 3, p. 5, supra.
anita
“the Congress, in thinking of the public’s health and
safety, had in mind only the special hazards of radioac-
tivity”. State of New Hampshire v. Atomic Energy Com-
mission, 406 F.2d 170, 174 (1st Cir. 1969); cert. den., 395
U.S. 962 (1969). In enacting the Atomic Energy Acts of
1946 and 1954, in overseeing their administration, and
in considering amendments, Congress confined the
responsibilities of the Commission under its authorizing
legislation to scrutiny of and protection against hazards
from radiation. State of New Hampshire v. AEC, supra,
at 175.
No provision of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as
amended, confers upon the Commission the authority to
issue a nuclear power plant license, as here, permitting
an activity by the licensee which causes harm to a
National Park. Neither the sections dealing specifically
with the licensing authority (42 U.S.C. §§ 2131-2140),
nor the sections describing the general authority of the
Commission (42 U.S.C. § 2201), confer that authority.
The sole authority granted the Commission to intrude
upon or interfere with a National Park is conditioned
upon extraordinary circumstances not present here.
Thus in the chapter of the Atomic Energy Act dealing
with prospecting, mining and removal of source
material, Section 67 (42 U.S.C. § 2097) provides:
“Sec. 67. Operations on Lands Belonging To The
United States.—The Commission is authorized, to
the extent it deems necessary to effectuate the
yrovisions of this Act, to ic ue leases or permits for
prospecting for, exploration for, mining of, or
removal of deposits of source material in lands
belonging to the United States: Provided, however,
That notwithstanding any other provisions of law,
such leases or permits may be issued for lands ad-
ministered for national park, monument, and
=
wildlife purposes only when the President by Ex-
ecutive Order declares that the requirements of the
common defense and security make such action
necessary.”
Regardless of the significance of the intrusions resulting
from these activities, Congress has clearly specified that
they cannot take place absent an Executive Order
declaring them necessary for requirements of common
defense and security.'”
There is thus no explicit authority in the Commission’s
authorizing legislation, and no Congressional purpose
from which the authority can be implied, for the Com-
mission to do what it purported to do here—authorize
NIPSCO to cause irrevocable harm to the National
Lakeshore. Having once found, as it did, that there
would be any adverse impact on the National Lakeshore,
the Commission was without authority to issue the per-
mit. Yet that is precisely what the Commission did.
There is no factual dispute that construction and
operation of the Bailly nuclear power plant will result in
impacts on the National Lakeshore. The Commission,
while it sought to minimize those impacts, nevertheless
found that they would occur. The court below did not
disagree. (pp. 10, 11 supra; App. p. 5)
The purported exercise by the Commission of authori-
ty over the National Lakeshore clearly is manifested by
the physical effects of potential ground water lowering,
acid misting and salt deposition inside the boundaries,
and the visual intrusion of the cooling tower. Moreover,
‘2 The fact that Congress dealt specifically with National
Parks and other public lands in other contexts within the
Atomic anata? Act further rebuts any inference of implied
authority of the Commission in the present context where
there has been no explicit consideration by Congress.
=— =
the Commission directed as one of the conditions of its
permit that NIPSCO and the Staff of the Commission
determine what action should be taken to eliminate or
significantly reduce the detrimental effects or damage
within the boundaries of the Lakeshore (App. p. 177).
Even assuming that the “irreversible” damage to which
the Commission referred could be mitigated, the Com-
mission had no authority to do so, or to direct such ac-
tivities.
B. Congress Has Delegated Specific and Exclusive
Jurisdiction over the National Park System, Including the
National Lakeshore, to the Department of the Interior.
The legislation authorizing creation of the National
Lakeshore, and the Congressional grant of exclusive
jurisdiction over the National Park System to Interior in
order to preserve and maintain its natural qualities for
future generations (16 U.S.C. §§ 1, la-1l, le, 2, 460u-
460u-9, precludes any inference that the Commission has
implied authority to permit intrusions into the National
Lakeshore, or into any other unit of the National Park
System.
In 1966, Congress authorized the Secretary of the In-
terior to establish the Indiana Dunes National
Lakeshore “{i]n order to preserve for the educational, in-
spirational and recreational use of the public certain
portions of the Indiana Dunes and other areas of scenic,
scientific and historic interest and recreational value
... 16 U.S.C. § 460u, The clear Congressional intent
behind this legislation was to preserve and protect the
unique natural values of the National Lakeshore. In-
deed, so explicit was this Congressional mandate that
the Secretary of the Interior was even restricted in the
development of the park. As Section 6(b) of the statute
provides:
~_ =
“In order that the lakeshore shall be permanently
preserved in its present state, no development or
plan for the convenience of visitors shall be under-
taken therein which would be incompatible with the
preservation of the unique flora and fauna or the
physiographic conditions now prevailing or with the
preservation of such historic sites and structures as
the Secretary may designate ...” [16 U.S.C.
§ 460u-6(b)}.
In order to safeguard the uniqueness of the National
Lakeshore, Congress specifically celegated to the
Secretary of the Interior the power to utilize the full
scope of his authority for the National Park System and
for conservation and management of natural resources
to preserve the National Lakeshore (16 U.S.C. § 460u-6).
The authority thus delegated to the Secretary is ex-
tremely broad. (16 U.S.C. §§ 1, la-1, lc, 2). As explained
by the Assistant Secretary of the Interior for Fish,
Wildlife and Parks. to whom the Secretary has
delegated authority with respect to the National Park
Service:
“The Secretary of the Interior is responsible for the
stewardship of our National Park System, having
been directed by Congress to preserve and manage
it for the benefit and inspiration of all the people of
the United States. The System includes any area of
land and water administered by the Secretary
through the National Park Service for park, monu-
ment, historic, parkway, recreational or other pur-
poses. The Secretary’s stewardship comprises super-
vision, management and control over these Federal
areas or units of the National Park System. It
further includes promoting and regulating the use
of the units of the National Park System in confor-
mity with their fundamental purpose which is to
conserve their scenery, natural and historic objects
and wildlife, and to provide for the enjoyment of the
units in such manner and by such means as will
leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future
generations.” (pp. 1, 2 following Tr. 7528)
—19—
The Secretary, in short, is the trustee for the people of
the United States over the public lands, including the
National Lakeshore. As the court of appeals for the Dis-
trict of Columbia Circuit said in United States ex rel.
Roughton v. Ickes, 101 F.2d, 248, 252 (D.C. Cir., 1938):
“Congress has created the Land Department, under
the supervision and control of the Secretary of the
Interior, to which is confided the execution of the
laws which regulate the purchase, selling, and dis-
position of the public lands. U.S. ex rel. Riverside
Oil Co. v. Hitchcock, 190 U.S. 316, 23 S. Ct. 698, 47
L. Ed. 1047. ‘The secretary is the guardian of the
people of the United States over the public lands.
The obligations of his oath of office oblige him to
see that the law is carried out, and that none of the
public domain is wasted or is disposed of to a party
not entitled to it...”
The jurisdiction of the Secretary over National Parks,
and indeed all units of the National Park System, is
both broad and exclusive. Shuttle Corp. v. Transit Com-
m'n., 393 U.S. 186, 187 (1968); Udall v. Washington,
Virginia and Maryland Coach Co., 398 F.2d 765 (D.C.
Cir. 1968); 16 U.S.C. §§ 1, la-1, 1c, 2. As the court below
recognized in its prior decision in this case: “Congress
has delegated its authority over the public lands of the
Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore to the Secretary of
the Interior, 16 U.S.C. §§ 460u-460u-9”. (App. p. 46).
This delegation specifically and exclusively vests in the
Department of the Interior the duty of guardianship
over the National Lakeshore. There is no statutory
authority and no room for any statutory interpretation
to infer that any other federal agency, including the
Commission, has any jurisdiction whatsoever over the
National Lakeshore.'*
‘The plain and consistent opposition of Interior, in the exer-
cise of its exclusive jurisdiction over the National Lakeshore,
to the intrusions which would result from the Bailly plant, ob-
viously precludes any theory that Interior somehow acquiesed
in the Commission's decision which accorded “no special
weight” to the testimony of the Assistant Secretary (ap. p.
203) and purported to “overrule” Interior (App. p. 175
atin
In sum, no provision of, or inference from, the Atomic
Energy Act authorizes the Commission to permit in-
trusions into public lands absent the extraordinary cir-
cumstances noted supra, pp. 15-16, which do not exist
here. Once the Commission found, as it did, that the ac-
tivity which it was asked to license would have an
adverse impact upon the National Lakeshore, the Com-
mission could not, consistent with its own limited
statutory authority and the exclusive jurisdiction of In-
terior, issue a construction permit to NIPSCO.
Il.
NEPA DOES NOT CONFER AUTHORITY UPON
THE COMMISSION TO PERMIT INTRUSIONS INTC A
NATIONAL PARK NOR TO DECIDE THE AMOUNT
OF HARM TO BE INFLICTED ON THE PARK.
Since the Atomic Energy Act plainly does not confer
the authority, the holding of the court below that the
commission had “authority to make” the determination
that “the environmental impact of construction and
operation of the nuclear plant (upon the National
Lakeshore) will not be substantial enough to require dis-
approval of the site” (App. p. 5), must have been based
on NEPA." Indeed, it has been held that prior to
'§ The court below also referred to the fact that Interior has
asserted no contention that the Commission lacked authority
and that Interior had not sought injunctive relief against con-
struction. (App. p. 4) We know of no logic, or authority, by
which the failure of Interior to litigate, either before the Com-
mission or in court, and the court below referred to none, can
either expand the authority of the Commission or reduce the
exclusive jurisdiction of Interior over National Parks. Indeed,
Interior may still seek injunctive relief to prevent the adverse
impacts from the Bailly plant, but surely the bizarre result
encouraged by the court below, of an executive branch of the
——_ suing to enjoin activity which has been licensed
y an administrative agency, should not be necessary.
- =
NEPA, the Commission’s sole duty was to consider
radiological effects on public health and safety, and not
general environmental impacts, in its licensing process.
State of New Hampshire v. AEC, supra, p. 15. Thus,
when the court said that the Commission had “given
attention to the environmental effects of the Bailly plant
upon the National Lakeshore, as the law requires” (App.
5), the “law” to which it referred was NEPA.
NEPA by its terms is supplementary to the statutory
obligations of federal agencies. Section 105 provides that
“‘It]lhe policies and goals set forth in this chapter are
supplementary to those set forth in existing
authorizations of Federal agencies” (42 U.S.C. § 4335). It
is clear that NEPA is not a general empowering act and
cannot enlarge the jurisdiction of any federal agency to
take action in violation of another statute. United States
vr. SCRAP (SCRAP I), 412 U.S. 669, 694 (1973); Jones v.
Lynn, 477 F.2d 885, 890 (1st Cir. 1973); United States v.
Stoeco Homes, Inc.. 498 F.2d 597, 607 (3rd Cir. 1974). As
this court noted in SCRAP I, supra:
“The statutory language, in fact, indicates that
NEPA was not intended to repeal by implication
any other statute. Thus, 42 U.S.C. § 4335 specifies
that “(t]he policies and goals set forth in [NEPA]
are supplementary to those set forth in existing
authorizations of Federal agencies,” and 42 U.S.C.
§ 4334 instructs that the Act “shall [not] in any way
affect the specific statutory obligations of any
Federal agency... .”
In holding that the NEPA consideration authorized
the Commission to permit the impacts and intrusions
which it found would occur to the National Lakeshore,
the court below has misinterpreted NEPA in a manner
that threatens every unit of the National Park System,
as well as other specially protected environmental
resources throughout the country. Under the court’s
fies
reading of NEPA any “major federal action” (as that
term is used in NEPA) could be used to thwart the in-
tent of Congress in affording special protection to any
area.
For example, under the “Wild and Scenic Rivers Act”,
16 U.S.C. §§ 1271-1287 (1968), federal agencies may not
“assist by loan, grant, license or otherwise” a project
having a “direct and adverse effect” on “wild,” “scenic”
or “recreational” rivers so designated by the Deaprtment
of Interior or Agriculture. The Federal Power Commis-
sion has authority to issue licenses for dams across
navigable waters when found to be “for the use and
benefit of interstate or foreign commerce”, 16 U.S.C.
§ 797(e). Under the rationale advanced by the court
below, the Federal Power Commission, by relying on
NEPA, could issue such a license for a dam across a
“wild” or “scenic” river claiming that the beneficial use
of said dam would outweigh the “direct and adverse
effect” on said river. Such a balancing is not con-
templated by the “Wild and Scenic Rivers Act”, but
would result from application of the decision of the court
below. Further examples may be found in the licensing
and funding of other major federal actions.'®
'’ The Federal Government is engaged in licensing and
funding the construction of highways, hospitals, housing pro-
jects, airports, dams, and pipelines. These projects are to be
constructed or operated in compliance with various en-
vironmental laws and regulations adopted thereunder such as
the Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972
(33 U.S.C, $8 1251-1376), the Noise Control Act of 1972 (42
U.S.C. §§ 4901-4918), the Marine Protection Research and
Sanctuaries Act of 1972 (33 U.S.C. 1401-1444), the
Wilderness Act of 1964 (16 U.S.C. §§ 1131-1136), the En-
dangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C, gO and
the Clean Air Act [42 U.S.C. §§ 1857-1858(a) (1970)]. The
vitality of each of these major environmental laws is seriously
easerennes by the construction given to NEPA by the court
velow,
—23—
No court has ever held prior to the decision below that
NEPA, by requiring consideration of environmental
effects, enlarges an agency’s authority to allow activities
which are otherwise prohibited. The decision below
reverses the thrust of NEPA, making it read as a
statute for environmental degradation rather than en-
vironmental protection. If NEPA is to be read, as we
submit it should not be, to expand the authority of an
agency to permit activities inconsistent with the
jurisdiction of an executive department, such a decision
should come from this Court.
In light of this Court’s decisions, it is obvious that
NEPA should not be read as reducing the protection af-
forded to the National Lakeshore under the statutes
authorizing its establishment and protected status as a
unit of the National Park System (16 U.S.C. §§ 1, la-1,
le, 2, 460u-460u-9). NEPA gives the Commission no
authority to determine the extent of harm to be in-
flicted upon the National Lakeshore. Once the Commis-
sion determined under NEPA that there would be in-
trusions into and impacts upon the National Lakeshore
from the licensing action requested by NIPSCO, the
Commission was legally precluded from permitting
them.
—24—
CONCLUSION
In view of the far reaching consequences of the deci-
sion of the court below on the National Park System and
on the role of NEPA, for the reasons set forth above, it
is submitted that Certiorari should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
WituaM J. Scorr Ronert J. VoLLEN
Attorney General 109 North Dearborn Street
State of Illinois Chicago, Illinois 60602
Ricuarp W. Cosny Epwarp W. Osann, Jr.
Assistant Attorney General One IBM Plaza - Suite 4600
State of Illinois Chicago, Illinois 60611
Environmental Control Division Ronerr L. GraHam
188 West Randolph - Suite 2315 " int
Chicago, Illinois 60601 Chicago, Tilineke oe
Marvin N. Benn J. Ropert Miertscuin, Jr.
Special Assistant . 4
Attorney General First City Attorney
- 3 City of Gary
State of Dlinois
134 North LaSalle Street Gary, Tndiews 66408
Chicago, Illinois 60601 :
Attorneys for Petitioners
Of Counsel;
Micnae. I. Swycert Micuae, A. Benepetro, Jr.
25 East Jackson Boulevard Assistant Attorney General
Chicago, Illinois 60604 State of Illinois
Environmental Control Division
188 West Randolph - Suite 2315
Chicago, Illinois 60601
Crarites A, RucKMAN
Corporation Counsel
City of Gary
401 Broadway
Gary, Indiana 46402
August 1976
APPENDIX OF STATUTES
—la—
APPENDIX OF STATUTES
Atomic Energy Act Of 1954, As Amended
§ 2011. Congressional declaration of policy
Atomic energy is capable of application for peaceful as well as
military purposes. It is therefore declared to be the policy of the
United States that—
(a) the development, use, and control of atomic energy shall
be directed so as to make the maximum contribution to the gen-
eral welfare, subject at all times to the paramount objective of
making the maximum contribution to the common defense and
security; and
(b) the development, use, and control of atomic energy shall
be directed so as to promote world peace, improve the general
welfare, increase the standard of living, and strengthen free
competition in private enterprise.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 1, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68 Stat.
921.
*_* * * *
§ 2097. Operations on lands belonging to the United States
The Commission is authorized, to the extent it deems necessary to
effectuate the provisions of | s chapter, to issue leases or permits
for prospecting for, exploration for, mining of, or removal of depos-
its of source material in lands belonging to the United States: Pro-
vided, however, That notwithstanding any other provisions of law,
such leases or permits may be issued for lands administered for na-
tional park. monument, and wildlife purposes only when the Presi-
dent by Executive Order declares that the requirements of the com-
mon defense and security make such action necessary.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 67, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 934.
—2a—
§ 2131. License required
It shall be unlawful, except as provided in section 2121 of this ti-
tle, for any person withir the United States to transfer or receive in
interstate commerce, manufacture, produce, transfer, acquire, pos-
sess, use, import, or export any utilization or production facility ex-
cept under and in accordance with a license issued by the Commis-
sion pursuant to section 2133 or 2134 of this title.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 101, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 936, and amended Aug. 6, 1956, c. 1015, § 11, 70 Stat. 1071.
§ 2132. Utilization and production facilities for industrial
or commercial purposes
(a) Except as provided in subsections (b) and (c) of this section,
or otherwise specifically authorized by law, any license hereafter is-
sued for a utilization or production facility for industrial or com-
mercial purposes shall be issued pursuant to section 2133 of this ti-
tle.
(b) Any license hereafter issued for a utilization or production
facility for industrial or commercial purposes, the construction or
operation of which was licensed pursuant to section 2134(b) of this
title prior to enactment into law of this subsection, sha!l be issued
under section 2134(b) of this title.
(c) Any license for a utilization or production facility for in-
dustrial or commercial purposes constructed or operated under an
arrangement with the Commission entered into under the Coopera-
tive Power Reactor Demonstration Program shall, except as other-
wise specifically required by applicable law, be issued under section
2134(b) of this title.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 102 as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 936, and amended Dec. 19, 1970, Pub.L. 91-560, § 3, 84 Stat.
1472.
§ 2133. Commercial licenses—Conditions
(a) The Commission is authorized to issue licenses to persons
applying therefor to transfer or receive in interstate commerce,
manufacture, produce, transfer, acquire, possess, use, import, or ex-
port under the terms of an agreement for coc, vation arranged pur-
suant to section 2153 of this title, utilization or production facilities
—3a—
for industrial or commercial purposes. Such licenses shall be is-
sued in accordance with the provisions of subchapter XV of this
chapter and subject to such conditions as the Commission may by
rule or regulation establish to effectuate the purposes and provi-
sions of this chapter.
Nonexclusive basis
(b) The Commission shall issue such licenses on a nonexclusive
basis to persons applying therefor (1) whose proposed activities will
serve a useful purpose proportionate to the quantities of special nu-
clear material or source material to be utilized; (2) who are
equipped to observe and who agree to observe such safety standards
to protect health and to minimize danger to life or property as the
Commission may by rule establish; and (3) who agree to make
available to the Commission such technical information and data
concerning activities under such licenses as the Commission may de-
termine necessary to promote the common defense and security and
to protect the health and safety of the public. All such information
may be used by the Commission only for the purposes of the com-
mon defense and security and to protect the health and safety of the
public. License period
(c) Each such license shall be issued for a specified period, as
determined by the Commission, depending on the type of activity to
be licensed, but not exceeding forty years, and may be renewed upon
the expiration of such period.
Limitations
(d) No license under this section may be given to any person for
activities which are not under or within the jurisdiction of the Unit-
ed States, except for the export of production or utilization facili-
ties under terms of an agreement for cooperation arranged pursuant
to section 2153 of this title, or except under che provisions of sec-
tion 2139 of this title. No license may be issued to an alien or any
any! corporation or other entity if the Commission knows or has
reason to believe it is owned, controlled, or dominated by an alien, a
foreign corporation, or a foreign government. In any event, no li-
cense may be issued to any person within the United States if, in
the opinion of the Commission, the issuance of a license to such per-
son would be inimical to the common defense and security or to the
health and safety of the public.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 103, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 936, and amended Aug. 6, 1956, c. 1015, §§ 12, 13, 70 Stat.
1071; Dec. 19, 1970, Pub.L. 91-560, § 4, 84 Stat. 1472.
'Soe in original.
—4a—
§ 2134. Medical therapy, research, and development licens-
es; limitations
(a) The Commission is authorized to issue licenses to persons
applying therefor for utilization facilties for use in medical therapy.
In issuing such licenses the Commission is directed to permit the
widest amount of effective medical therapy possible with the
amount of special nuclear material available for such purposes and
to impose the minimum amount of regulation consistent with its ob-
ligations under this chapter to promote the common defense and se-
curity and to protect the health and safety of the public.
(b) As provided for in subsection (b) or (c) of section 2132 of
this title, or where specifically authorized by law, the Commission is
authorized to issue licenses under this subsection to persons apply-
ing therefor for utilization and production facilities for industrial
and commercial purposes. In issuing licenses under this subsection,
the Commission shall impose the minimum amount of such regula-
tions and terms of license as will permit the Commission to fulfill
its obligations under this chapter.
(c) The Commission is authorized to issue licenses to persons
applying therefor for utilization and production facilities useful in
the conduct of research and development activities of the types
specified in section 2051 of this title and which are not facilities of
the type specified in subsection (b) of this section. The Commis-
sion is directed to impose only such minimum amount of regulation
of the licensee as the Commission finds will permit the Commission
to fulfill its obligations under this chapter to promote the common
defense and security and to protect the health and safety of the
public and will permit the conduct of widespread and diverse re-
search and development.
(d) No license under this section may be given to any person for
activities which are not under or within the jurisdiction of the Unit-
ed States, except for the export of production or utilization facili-
ties under terms of an agreement for cooperation arranged pursuant
to section 2153 of this title or except under the provisions of section
2139 of this title. No license may be issued to any corporation or
other entity if the Commission knows or has reason to believe it is
owned, controlled, or dominated by an alien, a foreign corporation,
or a foreign government. In any event, no license may be issued to
any person within the United States if, in the opinion of the Com-
—5ja—
mission, the issuance of a license to such person would be inimical
to the common defense and security or to the health and safety of
the public,
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 104, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 937, and amended Dec. 19, 1970, Pub.L. 91-560, § 5, 84 Stat.
1472.
§ 2135. Anti-trust provisions governing licenses; reports to
Attorney General
(a) Nothing contained in this chapter shall relieve any person
from the operation of sections 1 to 13, 14 to 19, 20, 21, 22 to 27, 41
to 46, and 47 to 58 of Title 15 and sections 52 and 53 of Title 29. In
the event a licensee is found by a court of competent jurisdiction,
either in an original action in that court or in a proceeding to en-
force or review the findings or orders of any Government agency
having jurisdiction under the sections cited above, to have violated
any of the provisions of such sections in the conduct of the licensed
activity, the Commission may suspend, revoke, or take such other ac-
tion as it may deem necessary with respect to any license issued by
the Commission under the provisions of this chapter.
(b) The Commission shall report promptly to the Attorney Gener-
al any information it may have with respect to any utilization of
special nuclear material or atomic energy which appears to violate
or to tend toward the violation of any of the foregoing sections, or
to restrict free competition in private enterprise.
(c) (1) The Commission shal! promptly transmit to the Attorney
General a copy of any license application provided for in paragraph
(2) of this subsection, and a copy of any written request provided
for in paragraph (3) of this subsection; and the Attorney General
shall, within a reasonable time, but in no event to exceed 180 days
after receiving a copy of such application or written request, render
such advice to the Commission as he determines to be appropriate in
regard to the finding to be made by the Commission pursuant to
paragraph (5) of this subsection. Such advice shall include an ex-
planatory statement as to the reasons or basis therefor.
(2) Paragraph (1) of this subsection shall apply to an application
for a license to construct or operate a utilization or production fa-
cility under section 2133 of this title: Provided, however, That
paragraph (1) shall not apply to an application for a license to op-
erate a utilization or production facility for which a construction
—tha—
permit was issued under section 2133 of this title unless the Com-
mission determines such review is advisable on the ground that sig-
nificant changes in the licensee's activities or proposed activities
have occurred subsequent to the previous review by the Attorney
General and the Commission under this subsection in connection
with the construction permit for the facility.
(3) With respect to any Commission permit for the construction
of a utilization or production facility issued pursuant to subsection
(b) of section 2134 of this title prior to December 19, 1970, any per-
son who intervened or who sought by timely written notice to the
Commission to intervene in the construction permit proceeding for
the facility to obtain a determination of antitrust considerations or
to advance a jurisdictional basis for such determination shall have
the right, upon a written request to the Commission, to obtain an
antitrust review under this section of the application for an operat-
ing license. Such written request shall be made within 25 days aft-
er the date of initial Commission publication in the Federal Register
of notice of the filing of an application for an operating license for
the facility or December 19, 1970, whichever is later.
(4) Upon the request of the Attorney General, the Commission
shall furnish or cause to be furnished such information as the At-
torney General determines to be appropriate for the advice called
for in paragraph (1) of this subsection.
(5) Promptly upon receipt of the Attorney General's advice, the
Commission shall publish the advice in the Federal Register.
Where the Attorney General advises that there may be adverse anti-
trust aspects and recommends that there be a hearing, the Attorney
General or his designee may participate as a party in the proceed-
ings thereafter held by the Commission on such licensing matter in
connection with the subject matter of his advice. The Commission
shall give due consideration to the advice received from the Attor-
ney General and to such evidence as may be provided during the
proceedings in connection with such subject matter, and shall make
a finding as to whether the activities under the license would create
or maintain a situation inconsistent with the antitrust laws as spec-
ified in subsection (a) of this section.
(6) In the event the Commission's finding under paragraph (5) ts
in the affirmative, the Commission shall also consider, in determin-
ing whether the license should be issued or continued, such other
factors, including the need for power in the affected area, as the
Commission in its judgment deems necessary to protect the public
interest. On the basis of its findings, the Commission shall have
wipe
the authority to issue or continue a license as applied for, to refuse
to issue a license, to rescind a license or amend it, and to issue a li-
cense with such conditions as it deems appropriate.
(7) The Commission, with the approval of the Attorney General,
may except from any of the requirements of this subsection such
classes or types of licenses as the Commission may determine would
not significantly affect the applicant's activities under the antitrust
laws as specified in subsection (a) of this section.
(8) With respect to any application for a construction permit on
file at the time of enactment into law of this subsection, which per-
mit would be for issuance under section 2133 of this title, and with
respect to any application for an operating license in connection
with which a written request for an antitrust review is made as pro-
vided for in paragraph (3), the Commission, after consultation with
the Attorney General, may, upon determination that such action is
necessary in the public interest to avoid unnecessary delay, establish
by rule or order periods for Commission notification and receipt of
advice differing from those set forth above and may issue a con-
struction permit or operating license in advance of consideration of
and findings with respect to the matters covered in this subsection:
Provided, That any construction permit or operating license so is-
sued shall contain such conditions as the Commission deems appro-
priate to assure that any subsequent findings and orders of the
Commission with respect to such matters will be given full force
and effect.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 105, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 938, and amended Aug. 26, 1964, Pub.L. 88-489, § 14, 78 Stat.
606; Dec. 19, 1970, Pub.L. 91-560, § 6, 84 Stat. 1473.
§ 2136. Classes of facilities
The Commission may—
(a) group the facilities licensed either under section 2133 or
2134 of this title into classes which may include either produc-
tion or utilization facilities or both, upon the basis of the simi-
larity of operating and technical characteristics of the facili-
ties;
(b) define the various activities to be carried on at each such
class of facility; and
(c) designate the amounts of special nuclear material availa-
ble for use by each such facility.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 106, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 938.
—
§ 2137. Operators’ licenses
The Commission shall—
(a) prescribe uniform conditions for licensing individuals as
operators of any of the various classes of production and utili-
zation facilities licensed in this chapter;
(b) determine the qualifications of such individuals ;
(c) issue licenses to such individuals in such form as the
Commission may prescribe; and
(d) suspend such licenses for violations of any provision of
this chapter or any rule or regulation issued thereunder when-
ever the Commission deems such action desirable.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 107, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 939.
§ 2138. Suspension of licenses during war or national emer-
gency
Whenever the Congress declares that a state of war or national
emergency exists, the Commission is authorized to suspend any li-
censes granted under this chapter if in its judgment such action is
necessary to the common defense and security. The Commission is
authorized during such period, if the Commission finds it necessary
to the common defense and security, to order the recapture of any
special nuclear material or to order the operation of any facility ii-
censed under section 2123 or 2134 of this title, and is authorized to
order the entry into any plant or facility in order to recapture such
material, or to operate such facility. Just compensation shall be
paid for any damages caused by the recapture of any special nucle-
ar material or by the operation of any such facility.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 108, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 939, and amended Sept. 23, 1959, Pub.L. 86-373, § 2, 73 Stat.
691.
§ 2139. General licenses; export licenses
With respect to those utilization and production facilities which
are so determined by the Commission pursuant to section
2014(v)(2) or 2014/cc)(2) of this title the Commission may (a) is-
sue general licenses for activities required to be licensed under sec-
tion 2131 of this title. if the Commission determines in writing that
such general licensing will not constitute an unreasonable risk to
—9a—
the common defense and security, and (b) issue licenses for the ex-
pert of such facilities, if the Commission determines in writing that
each export will not constitute an unreasonable risk to the common
defense and security.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 109, as added Aug. 20, 1954, c. 107%, § 1, 68
Stat. 939, and amended Aug. 29, 1962, Pub.L. 87-615, § 9, 76 Stat.
411; Oct. 13, 1966, Pub.L. 89-645, § 1(b), 80 Stat. 891.
§ 2140. Exclusions from license requirement
Nothing in this subchapter shall be deemed—
(a) to require a license for (1) the processing, fabricating,
or refining of special nuclear material, or the separation of spe-
cial nuclear material, or the separation of special nuclear mate-
rial from other substances, under contract with and for the ac-
count of the Commission; or (2) the construction or operation
of facilities under contract with and for the account of the
Commission; or
(b) to require a license for the manufacture, production, or
acquisition by the Department of Defense of any utilization fa-
cility authorized pursuant to section 2121 of this title, or for
the use of such facility by the Department of Defense or a con-
tractor thereof.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 110, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 939.
8 2201. General duties of Commission
In the performance of its functions the Commission is authorized
to—
Establishment of advisory boards
(a) establish advisory boards to advise with and make recom-
mendations to the Commission on legislation, policics. adminis-
tration, research, and other matters, provided thet the Commis-
sion issues regulations setting forth the scope, procedure, and
limitations of the authority of each such beard;
Standards governing use and possession of material
(b) establish by rule, regulation, or order, such standards
and instructions to govern the possession and use of special nu-
—o
clear materia source material, and byproduct material as the
Commission may deem necessary to desirable to promote the
common defense and security or to protect health or to mini-
mize danger to life or property;
Studies and Investigations
(c) make such studies and investigations, obtain such infor-
mation. and hold such meetings or hearings as the Commission
may deem necessary or proper to assist it in exercising any au-
thority provided in this chapter, or in the administration or en-
forcement of this chapter, or any regulations or orders issued
thereunder. For such purposes the Commission is authorized to
administer oaths and affirmations, and by subpena to require
any person to appear and testify, or to appear and produce doc-
uments. or both, at any designated place. Witnesses subpenaed
under this subsection shall be paid the same fees and mileage
as are paid witnesses in the district courts of the United
States:
Employment of personne!
(d) appoint and fix the compensation of such officers and
employees as may be necessary to carry out the functions of the
Commission. Such officers and employees shall be appointed in
accordance with the civil-service laws and their compensation
fixed in accordance with chapter 51 and subchapter III of chap-
ter 53 of Title 5, except that, to the extent the Commission
deems such ection necessary to the discharge of its responsibili-
ties, personnel may be employed and their compensation fixed
without regard to such laws: Provided, however, That no offi-
cer or employee ‘except such officers and employees whose
compensation is fixed by law, and scientific and technical per-
sonnel up to a limit of the highest rate of grade 18 of the Gen-
eral Schedule) whose position would be subject to chapter 51
and subchapter HI of chapter 53 of Title 5, if such provisions
were applicable to such position, shall be paid a salary at a rate
in excess of the rate payable under such provisions for positions of
equivalent difficulty or responsibility. Such rates of compensa-
tion may be adopted by the Commission as may be authorized by
chapter 51 and subchapter III of chapter 53 of Title 5, as of the
same date such rates are authorized for positions subject to such
provisions. The Commission shall make adequate provision for
administrative review of any determination to dismiss any em-
ployee;
—lla—
Acquisition of material, property, ete.; negotiation
of commercial leases
(e) acquire such material, property, equipment, and facilities,
establish or construct such buildings and facilities, and modify
such buildings and facilities from time to time, as it may deem
necessary, and construct, acquire, provide, or arrange for such
facilities and services (at project sites where such facilities
and services are not available) for the housing, health, safety,
welfare, and recreation of personnel employed by the Commis-
sion as it may deem necessary, subject to the provisions of sec-
tion 2224 of this title: Provided, however, That in the communi-
ties owned by the Commission, the Commission is authorized to
grant privileges, leases and permits upon adjusted terms which
(at the time of the initial grant of any privilege grant, lease, or
permit, or renewal thereof, or in order to avoid inequities or un-
due hardship prior to the sale by the United States of property
affected by such grant) are fair and reasonable to responsible
persons to operate commercial businesses without advertising
and without advertising! and without securing competitive
bids, but taking inte consideration, in addition to the price, and
among other things (1) the quality and type of services re-
quired by the residents of the community, (2) the experience of
each concession applicant in the community and its surrounding
area, (3) the ability of the concession applicant to meet the
needs of the community, and (4) the contribution the conces-
sion applicant has made or will make to the other activities and
general welfare of the community.
Ltitization of other Federal agencies
(f) with the consent of the agency concerned, utilize or em-
ploy the services or personnel of any Government agency or any
State or local government, or voluntary or uncompensated per-
sonnel, to perform such functions on its behalf as may appear
desirable ;
Acquisition of real and personal property
(g) acquire, purchase, lease, and hold real and personal prop-
erty, including patents, as agent of and on behalf of the United
States, subject to the provisions of section 2224 of this title,
and to sell, lease, grant. and dispose of such real and personal
property as provided in this chapter;
—1]2a—
Considernmiion of Heense applications
th) consider in a single application one or more of the activi-
ties for which a license is required by this chapter, combine in
a single license one or more of such activities, and permit the
applicant or licensee to incorporate by reference pertinent in-
formation already filed with the Commission,
Regulations governing Restricted Data
(i) preseribe such regulations or order. as it may deem nec-
essary (1) to protect Restricted Data received by any person in
connection with any activity authorized pursuant to this chap-
ter, (2) to guard against the loss or diversion of any special nu-
clear material acquired by any person pursuant to section 2072
of this title or produced by any person in connection with any
activity authorized pursuant to this chapter, and to prevent any
use or disposition thereof which the Commission may determine
to be inimical to the common defense and security, and (3) to
govern any activity authorized pursuant to this chapter, includ-
ing standards and restrictions governing the design, location,
and operation of facilities used in the conduct of such activity.
in order to protect health and to minimize danger to life or
property ;
Dispesition of surplus materials
(j) without regard to the provisions of the Federal Property
and Administrative Services Act of 1949, as amended, except
section 488 of Title 40, or any other law, make such disposition
as it may deem desirable of (1) radioactive materials, and (2)
any other property, the special disposition of which is, in the
opinion of the Commission, in the interest of the national secu-
rity: Provided, however, That the property furnished to licen-
sees in accordance with the provisions of subsection (m) of this
section shall not be deemed to be property disposed of by the
Commission pursuant to this subsection;
Carrying of firearms
(k) authorize such of its members, officers, and employees as
it deems necessary in the interest of the commen defense and
security to carry firearms while in the discharge of their offi-
cial duties. The Commission may also authorize such of those
employees of its contractors engaged in the protection of prop-
erty owned by the United States and located at facilities owned
-#e
by or contracted to the United States as it deems necessary in
the interests of the common defense and security to carry fire-
arms while in the discharge of their official duties;
(1) Repealed. Pub.L. 87-456, Title HI, § 303(c), May 24,
1962, 76 Stat. 78.
Agreements regarding production
(m) enter into agreements with persons licensed under sec-
tion 2133. 2124, 2073(a)(4), or 2093(a)(4) of this title for such
periods of time as the Commission may deem necessary or desir-
able (1) to provide for the processing, fabricating, separating,
or refining in facilities owned by the Commission of source, by-
product, or other material or special nuclear material owned by
er made available to such licensees and which is utilized or pro-
duced in the conduct of the licensed activity, and (2) to sell,
lease, or otherwise make available to such licensees such quan-
tities of source or byproduct material, and other material not
defined as special nuclear material pursuant to this chapter, as
may be necessary for the conduct of the licensed activity: Pro-
vided. however, That any such agreement may be canceled by
the licensee at any time upon payment of such reasonable can-
cellation charges as may be agreed upon by the licensee and the
Commission: And provided further, That the Commission shall
establish prices to be paid by licensees for material or services
to be furnished by the Commission pursuant to this subsection,
which prices shall be established on such a nondiscriminatory
basis as, in the opinion of the Commission, will provide reason-
able compensation to the Government for such material or serv-
ices and will not discourage the development of sources of sup-
ply independent of the Commission;
Delegation of functions
(n) delegate to the General Manager or other officers of the
Commission any of those functions assigned to it under this
chapter except those specified in sections 2071, 2077(b), 2091,
2138, 2153, 2165: b) of this title (with respect to the determina-
tion of those persons to whom the Commission may reveal Re-
stricted Data in the national interest), 2165/f) of this title and
subsection (a) of this section;
—l4a—
Reports
(0) require by rule, regulation, or order, such reports, and
the keeping of such records with respect to, and to provide for
such inspections of, activities and studies of types specified in
section 2051 of this title and of activities under licenses issued
pursuant to sections 2073, 2093, 2111, 2133, and 2134 of this ti-
tle, as may be necessary to effectuate the purposes of this chap-
ter, including section 2135 of this title; and
Rules and regulations
(p) make, promulgate, issue, rescind, and amend such rules
and regulations as may be necessary to carry out the purposes
of this chapter.
Easements for rights-of-way
‘q) The Commission is authorized and empowered, under
such terms and conditions as are deemed advisable by it, to
grant easements for rights-of-way over, across, in, and upon ac-
quired lands under its jurisdiction and control, and public lands
permanently withdrawn or reserved for the use of the Commis-
sion, to any State, political subdivision thereof, or municipality,
or to any individual, partnership, or corporation of any State,
Territory, or possession of the United States, for (a) railroad
tracks; (b) oil pipe lines; (c) substations for electric power
transmission lines, telephone lines, and telegraph lines, and
pumping stations for gas, water, sewer, and oil pipe lines; (d)
canals; (e) ditches; (f) flumes: (g) tunnel<x: h) dams and
reservoirs in connection with fish and wildlife programs, fish
hatcheries, and other fish-cultural improvements; (i) roads and
streets; and ‘j) for any other purpose or purposes deemed ad-
visable by the Commission: Prorided, That such rights-of-way
shall be granted only upon a finding by the Commission that
the same will not be incompatible with the public interest: Pro-
vided further, That such rights-of-way shall not include any
more land than ts reasonably necessary fer the purpose for
which granted: And provided further, That all or any part of
such rights-of-way may be annulled and forfeited by the Com-
mission for failure to comply with the terms and conditions of
any grant hereunder or for nonuse for a period of two consecu-
tive years or abandonment of rights granted under authority
hereof. Copies of all instruments granting easements over pub-
lic lands pursuant to this section shall be furnished to the Sec-
retary of the Interior.
—l5a—
Sale of utilities and related services
(r) Under such regulations and for such periods and at suc!)
prices the Commission may prescribe, the Commission may sell
or contract to sell to purchasers within Commission-owned com-
munities or in the immediate vicinity of the Commission com-
munity, as the case may be, any of the following utilities and
related services, if it is determined that they are not available
from another loca! source and that the sale is in the interest of
the national defense or in the public interest:
(1) Electric power.
(2) Steam.
(3) Compressed air.
(4) Water.
(5) Sewage and garbage disposal.
(6) Natural, manufactured, or mixed gas.
(7) Ice.
(8) Mechanical refrigeration.
(9) Telephone service.
Proceeds of sales under this subsection shall be credited to
the appropriation currently available for the supply of that util-
ity or service. To meet local needs the Commission may make
minor expansions and extensions of any distributing system or
facility within or in the immediate vicinity of a Commission-
owned community through which a utility or service is fur-
nished under this subsection.
Succession of authority
(s) establish a plan for a succession of authority which will
assure the continuity of direction of the Commission's opera-
tions in the event of a national disaster due to enemy activity.
Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, the person
or persons succeeding to command in the event of disaster in
accordance with the plan established pursuant to this subsec-
tion shall be vested with all of the authority of the Commis-
sion: Provided, That any such succession to authority, and ves-
ting of authority shall be effective only in the event and as long
as a quorum of three or more members of the Commission is un-
able to convene and exercise direction during the disaster peri-
od: Provided further, That the disaster period includes the pe-
riod when attack on the United States is imminent and the
post-attack period necessary to reestablish normal lines of com-
mand ; ‘
—l6a—
Contracts
(t) enter into contracts for the processing, fabricating, sepa-
rating, or refining in facilities owned by the Commission of
source, byproduct or other material, or special nuclear material,
in accordance with and within the period of an agreement for
cooperation while comparable services are available to persons
licensed under section 2133 or 2134 of this title: Provided, That
the prices for services under such contracts shall be no less
than the prices currently charged by the Commission pursuant
to subsection (m) of this section:
Additional contracts; guiding principles; appropriations
(u)(1) enter into contracts for such periods of time as the
Commission may deem necessary or desirable, but not to exceed
five years from the date of execution of the contract, for the
purchase or acquisition of reactor services or services related to
or required by the operation of reactors;
(2)(A) enter into contracts for such periods of time as the
Commission may deem necessary or desirable for the purchase
or acquisition of any supplies, equipment, materials, or services
required by the Commission whenever the Commission deter-
mines that: (i) it is advantageous to the Government to make
such purchase or acquisition from commercial sources; (ii) the
furnishing of such supplies, equipment, materials, or services
will require the construction or acquisition of special facilities
by the vendors or suppliers thereof; (iii) the amortization
chargeable to the Commission constitutes an appreciable portion
of the cost of contract performance, excluding cost of materi-
als; and (iv) the contract for such period is more advanta-
geous to the Government than a similar contract not executed
under the authority of this subsection. Such contracts shall be
entered into for periods not to exceed five years cach from the
date of initial delivery of such supplies, equipment, materials,
or services or ten vears from the date of execution of the con-
tracts excluding periods of renewal under option.
(B) In entering into such contracts the Commission shall be
guided by the following principles: (i) the percentage of the
total cost of special facilities devoted to contract performance
and chargeable to the Commission should not exceed the ratio
between the period of contract deliveries and the anticipated
useful life of such special facilities; (ii) the desirability of ob-
taining options to renew the contract for reasonable periods at
—17a—
prices not to include charges for special facilities already amor-
tized: and (iii) the desirability of reserving in the Commission
the right to take title to the special facilities under appropriate
circumstances; and
(3) include in contracts made under this subsection provi-
sions which limit the obligation of funds to estimated annual
deliveries and services and the unamortized balance of such
amounts due for special facilities as the parties shall agree is
chargeable to the performance of the contract. Any appropria-
tion available at the time of termination or thereafter made
available to the Commission for operating expenses shall be
available for payment of such costs which may arise from ter-
mination as the contract may provide. The term “special facili-
ties” as used in this subsection means any land and any depre-
ciable buildings, structures, utilities, machirery, equipment, and
fixtures necessary for the production or furnishing of such sup-
plies, equipment, materials, or services and not available to the
vendors or suppliers for the performance of the contract.
Contracts for production or enrichment of special nuclear material;
domestic licensees; other nations; prices; materials of forcign
origin; eriteria for availability of services under this subsection;
Congressional review
‘v)(A) enter into contracts with persons licensed under sec-
tions 2073, 2093, 2133 or 2134 of this title for such periods of
time as the Commission may deem necessary or desirable to pro-
vide, after December 31, 1968, for the producing or enriching of
special nuclear material in facilities owned by the Commission;
and
(B) enter into contracts to provide, after December 31, 1968,
for the producing or enriching of special nuclear material in fa-
cilities owned by the Commission in accordance with and within
the period of an agreement for cooperation arranged pursuant
to section 2153 of this title while comparable services are made
available pursuant to paragraph (A) of this subsection: Pro-
vided, That (i) prices for services under paragraph (A) of this
subsection shall be established on a nondiscriminatory basis;
(ii) prices for services under paragraph (B) of this subsection
shall be no less than prices under paragraph (A) of this
subsection; and (iii) any prices established under this subsec-
tion shall be on a basis of recovery of the Government’s costs
over a reasonable period of time: And provided further, That
—18a—
the Commission, to the extent necessary to assure the mainte-
nance of a viable domestic uranium industry, shall not offer
such services for source or special nuclear materials of foreign
origin intended for use in a utilization facility within or under
the jurisdiction of the United States. The Commission shall es-
tablish criteria in writing setting forth the terms and condi-
tions under which services provided under this subsection shall
be made available including the extent to which such services
will be made available for source or special nuclear material of
foreign origin intended for use in a utilization facility within or
under the jurisdiction of the United States: Provided, That be-
fore the Commission establishes such criteria, the proposed cri-
teria shall be submitted to the Joint Committee, and a period of
forty-five days shall elapse while Congress is in session (in
computing the forty-five days there shall be excluded the days
in which either House is not in session because of adjournment
for more than three days) unless the Joint Committee by resolu-
tion in writing waives the conditions of, or all or any portion
of, such forty-five-day period.
License fees for nuclear power reactors
(w) prescribe and collect from any other Government agency,
which applies for or is issued a license for a utilization facility
designed to produce electrical or heat energy pursuant to sec-
tion 2133 or 2134(b) of this title, any fee, charge, or price
which it may require, in accordat.ce with the provisions of sec-
tion 482a of Title 31 or any other law, of applicants for, or hold-
ers of, such licenses.
Aug. 1, 1946, c. 724, § 161, as added Aug. 30, 1954, c. 1073, § 1, 68
Stat. 948, and amended July 14, 1956, c. 608, 70 Stat. 553; Aug. 6,
1956, c. 1015, § 4, 70 Stat. 1069; Aug. 21, 1957, Pub.L. 85-162, Title
II, §§ 201, 204, 71 Stat. 410; Sept. 4, 1957, Pub.L. 85-287, § 4, 71
Stat. 613; July 7, 1958, Pub.L. 85-507, § 21(b)(1), 72 Stat. 337;
Aug. 19, 1958, Pub.L. 85-681, §§ 6, 7, 72 Stat. 633; Sept. 21, 1959,
Pub.L. 86-300, § 1, 75 Scat. 574; Sept. 6, 1961, Pub.L. 87-206, § 13,
75 Stat. 478; May 24, 1962, Pub.L. 87-456, Title III, § 303(c), 76
Stat. 78; Aug. 29, 1962, Pub.L. 87-615, § 12, 76 Stat. 411; Oct. 11,
1962, Pub.L. 87-793, § 1001(g), 76 Stat. 864; Aug. 26, 1964, Pub.L.
88-489, § 16, 78 Stat. 606; Dec. 14, 1967, Pub.L. 90-190, § 11, 81
Stat. 578; Oct. 15, 1970, Pub.L. 91-452, Title II, § 237, 84 Stat. 930;
Dec. 19, 1970, Pub.L. 91-560, $$ 7, 8, 84 Stat. 1474; June 16, 1972,
Pub.L. 92-314, Title III, § 301, 86 Stat. 227.
1So in original.
—19a—
Indiana Dunes
National Lakeshore Authorization Act
§ 460u. Purposes; authorization for establishment; de-
scription of area
In order to preserve for the educational, inspirational, and recrea-
tional use of the public certain portions of the Indiana dunes and oth-
ec areas of scenic, scientific, and historic interest and recreational val-
ue in the State of Indiana. the Secretary of the Interior is authorized
to establish and administer the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore
‘hereinafter referred to as the “lakeshore”) in accordance with the
provisions of sections 460u to 460u—9 of this title. The lakeshore shall
comprise the area within the boundaries delineated on a map identi-
fied as “A Proposed Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore’, dated Sep-
tember 1966, and bearing the number “LNPNE-1008-ID", which
map is on file and available for public inspection in the office of the
Director of the National Park Service, Department of the Interior.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 1, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1309.
§ 460u-1. Acquisition of property—Authority of Secre-
tary; manner and place; negotiation for In-
diana Dunes State Park; exchange of prop-
erty; fair market value; appraisal; cash
equalization payments
(a) Within the boundaries of the lakeshore the Secretary of the Inte-
rior (hereinafter referred to as the “Secretary”) is authorized to ac-
quire lands, waters, and other property, or any interest therein, by do-
nation, purchase with donated or appropriated funds, exchange, or
otherwise. The Indiana Dunes State Park may be acquired only by
donation of the State of Indiana, and the Secretary is hereby directed
to negotiate with the State for the acquisition of said park. In exer-
cising his authority to acquire property by exchange for the purposes
of sections 460u to 460u—9 of this title, the Secretary may accept title
to non-Federal property located within the area described in section
460u of this title and convey to the grantor of such property any fed-
erally owned property under the jurisdiction of the Secretary which he
classifies as suitable for exchange or other disposal within the State
of Indiana or Illinois. Properties so exchanged shall be approximately
equal in fair market value, as determined by the Secretary who may,
—20a—
in his discretion, base his determination on an independent appraisal
obtained by him: Provided, That the Secretary may accept cash from
or pay cash to the grantor in such an exchange in order to equalize
the values of the properties exchanged.
Liability of United States under contracts contingent
on appropriations
(b) In exercising his authority to acquire property under subsection
(a) of this section, the Secretary may enter into contracts requiring
the expenditure, when appropriated, of funds authorized to be appro-
priated by section 460u-9 of this title, but the liability of the United
States under any such contract shall be contingent on the appropria-
tion of funds sufficient to fulfill the obligations thereby incurred.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 2, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1309.
§ 460u-2. Establishment of lakeshore; publication in
Federal Register; continuing acquisition of
lands
As soon as practicable after November 5, 1966, and following the ac-
quisition by the Secretary of an acreage within the boundaries of the
area described in section 460u of this title which in his opinion is effi-
ciently administrable for the purposes of sections 460u to 460u-9 of
this title, he shall establish the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore by
publication of notice thereof in the Federal Register. Following such
establishment and subject to the limitations and conditions prescribed
in section 460u of this title, the Secretary may continue to acquire
lands and interests in lands for the lakeshore.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 3, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1309.
§ 460u-3. Suspension of condemnation power during ex-
istence of zoning ordinance; improved prop-
erty defined
(a) The Secretary's authority to acquire property by condemnation
shall be suspended with respect to all improved property located with-
in the boundaries of the lakeshore during all times when an appropri-
ate zoning agency shal! have in force and applicable to such property a
duly adopted, valid zoning ordinance approved by the Secretary in ac-
cordance with the provisions of section 460u—4 of this title.
—2la—
(b) The term “improved property”, whenever used in sections 460u
to 460u-9 of this title, shall mean a detached, one-family dwelling, con-
struction of which was begun before January 4, 1965, together with so
much of the land on which the dwelling is situated, the said land being
in the same ownership as the dwelling, as the Secretary shall desig-
nate to be reasonably necessary for the enjoyment of the dwelling for
the sole purpose of noncommercial residential use, together with any
structures accessory to the dwelling which are situated on the lands so
designated. The amount of land so designated shall in every case be
not more than three acres in area, and in making such designation the
Secretary shall take into account the manner of noncommercial resi-
dential use in which the dwelling and land have customarily been en-
joyed: Provided, That the Secretary may exclude from the land so des-
ignated any beach or waters, together with so much of the land adjoin-
ing such beach or waters, as he may deem necessary for public access
thereto or public use thereof.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 4, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1309.
§ 460u-4. Zoning regulations—Standards for approval of
ordinances; amendments; approval of ordi-
nances; revocation of approval
(a) As soon as practicable after November 5, 1966, the Secretary
shall issue regulations specifying standards for approval by him of
zoning ordinances for the purposes of sections 460u-3 and 460u-—5 of
this title. The Secretary may issue amended regulations specifying
standards for approval by him of zoning ordinances whenever he shall
consider such amended regulations to be desirable due to changed or
unforeseen conditions. The Secretary shall approve any zoning ordi-
nance and any amendment te any approved zoning ordinance submit-
ted to him which conforms to the standards contained in the regula-
tions in effect at the time of adoption of such ordinance or amend-
ment by the zoning agency. Such approval shall not be withdrawn or
revoked, by issuance of any amended regulations after the date of
such approval, for so long as such ordinance or amendment remains in
effect as approved.
Commercial and industrial use prohibition; acreage, frontage, sethack,
and other requirements
(b) The standards specified in such regulations and amended regu-
lations for approval of any zoning ordinance or zoning ordinance
—
amendment shall contribute to the effect of (1) prohibiting the com-
mercial and industrial use, other than any commercial or industrial
use which is permitted by the Secretary, of all property covered by the
ordinance within the boundaries of the lakeshore: and (2) promoting
the preservation and development, in accordance with the purposes of
sections 460u to 460u-—9 of this title, of the area covered by the ordi-
nance within the lakeshore by means of acreage, frontage, and setback
requirements and other provisions which may be required by such reg-
ulations te be included in a zoning ordinance consistent with the laws
of the State of Indiana.
Adverse provisions and absence of notice for variance as
requiring dixapproval of ordinances
‘c) No zoning ordinance or amendment thereof shall be approved by
the Secretary which (1) contains any provision which he may consider
adverse ty the preservation and development, in accordance with the
purposes of sections 460u to 460u-9 of this title, of the area compris-
ing the lakeshore: or (2) fails to have the effect of providing that the
Secretary shall receive notice of any variance granted under and any
exception made to the application of such ordinance or amendment.
Termination of suspension of authority for acquisition by condemnation
because of nonconforming variances and uses
(d) If any improved property, with respect to which the Secretary's
authority to acquire by condemnation has been suspended according to
the provisions of sections 460u to 460u-9 of this title, is made the sub-
ject of a variance under or exception to such zoning ordinance, or is
subjected to any use, which variance, exception, or use fails to con-
form to or is inconsistent with any applicable standard contained in
regulations issued pursuant to this section and in effect at the time of
passage of such ordinance, the Secretary may, in his discretion, termi-
nate the suspension of his authority to acquire such improved proper-
ty by condemnation.
Certificate of suspension of authority for acquisition
by» condemnation
(e) The Secretary shall furnish to any party in interest requesting
the same a certificate indicating, with respect to uny property located
within the lakeshore as to which the Secretary's authority to acquire
such property by condemnation has been suspended in accordance with
provisions of sections 460u to 460u -9 of this title, that such authority
has been so suspended and the reasons therefor.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 5, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1310.
er a Se
—23a—
§ 460u-5. Owner’s retention of right of use and occupancy
for residential purposes for term of years—
Conveyance or lease of right; adjustment of
compen sation
(a) Any owner or owners of improved property on the date of its
acquisition by the Secretary may, as a condition to such acquisition,
retain the right of use and occupancy of the improved property for
noncommercial residential purposes for a term of twenty-five years, or
for such lesser time as the said owner or owners may elect at the time
of acquisition by the Secretary. Where any such owner retains a
right of use and occupancy as herein provided, such right during its
existence may be conveyed or leased for noncommercia! residential
purposes. The Secretary shall pay to the owner the fair market value
of the property on the date of such acquisition, less the fair market
value on such date of the right retained by the owner.
Termination of use and occupancy inconsistent with zoning
ordinance and upon payment of sum for unexpired right
(b) The Secretary shall have authority to terminate any right of
use and occupancy retained as provided in subsection (a) of this sec-
tion at any time after the date upon which any use occurs with respect
to such property which fails to conform or is any manner opposed to
or inconsistent with the applicable standards contained in regulations
issued pursuant to section 460u—4 of this title and which is in effect
on said date: Provided, That no use which is in conformity with the
provisions of a zoning ordinance approved in accordance with said sec-
tion 460u-4 and applicable to such property shall be held to fail to
conform or be opposed to or inconsistent with any such standard. In
the event the Secretary terminates a right of use and occupancy under
this subsection, he shall pay to the owner of the right so terminated
an amount equal to the fair market value of the portion of said right
which remained unexpired on the date of termination.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 6, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1311.
§ 460u-6. Administration—Utilization of authorities for
conservation and management of natural re-
sources
(a) In the administration of the lakeshore the Secretary may utilize
such statutory authorities relating to areas of the national park sys-
tem and such statutory authority otherwise available to him for the
conservation and management of natural resources as he deems appro-
priate to carry out the purposes of sections 460u to 460u-9 of this ti-
tle.
—24a—
Preservation of lakeshore; incompatible visitor conveniences restricted;
provisions fur public enjoyment and understanding;
developments for public uses
(b) In order that the lakeshore shall be permanently preserved in
its present state, no development or plan for the convenience of visi-
tors shall be undertaken therein which would be incompatible with the
preservation of the unique flora and fauna or the physiographic condi-
tions now prevailing or with the preservation of such historic sites
and structures as the Secretary may designate: Provided, That the
Secretary may provide for the public enjoyment and understanding of
the unique natural, historic, and scientific features within the lake-
shore by establishing such trails, observation points, and exhibits and
providing such services as he may deem desirable for such public en-
joyment and understanding: Provided further, That the Secretary
may develop for appropriate public uses such portions of the lakeshore
as he deems especially adaptable for such uses.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 7, Nov. 5, 1966, 80 Stat. 1311.
§ 460u-7. Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore Advisory
Commission—Establishment; termination
(a) There is hereby established an Indiana Dunes National Lake-
shore Advisory Commission. Said Commission shall terminate ten
years after the date of establishment of the national lakeshore pursu-
ant to sections 460u to 460u-9 of this title.
Membership; cppointment; term of office; recommendation or
designation of appointees
(b) The Commission shall be composed of seven members, each ap-
pointed for a term of two years by the Secretary, as follows: (1) one
member who is a year-round resident of Porter County to be appoint-
ed from recommendations made by the commissioners of such county ;
(2) one member who is a year-round resident of the town of Beverly
Shores to be appointed from the recommendations made by the board
of trustees of such town; (3) one member who is a year-round resi-
dent of the towns of Porter, Dune Acres, Portage, Pines, Chesterton,
Ogden Dunes, or the village of Tremont, such member to be appointed
from recommendations made by the boards of trustees or the trustee
of the affected town or township; (4) one member who is a year-
round resident of the city of Michigan City to be appointed from rec-
ommendations made by such city; (5) two members to be appointed
from recommendations made by the Governor of the State of Indiana;
and (6) one member to be designated by the Secretary.
- cena iecieam einai mmuebniiiriae
—25a—
Chairman; vacancies
(c) The Secretary shall designate one member to be Chairman.
Any vacancy in the Commission shall be filled in the same manner in
which the original appointment was made.
Compensation and expenses; vouchers
(d) A member of the Commission shall serve without compensation
as such. The Secretary is authorized to pay the expense reasonably
incurred by the Commission in carrying out its responsibilities under
sections 460u to 460u-9 of this title on vouchers signed by the Chair-
man.
Consultation of Secretary with Commission
(e) Tne Secretary or his designee shall, from time to time, consult
with the Commission with respect to matters relating to the develop-
ment of the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and with respect to the
provisions of sections 460u-3, 460u-4, and 460u-5 of this title.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 8, Nov. 5. 1966, 80 Stat. 1311.
§ 460u-8. State jurisdiction
Nothing in sections 460u to 460u-9% of this title shall deprive the
State of Indiana or any political subdivision thereof of its civil and
criminal jurisdiction over persons found, acts performed, and offenses
committed within the boundaries of the Indiana Dunes National Lake-
shore or of its right to tax persons. ‘rrvrations, franchises, or other
non-Federal property on lands includec therein.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 9, Nov. 5. 1066, 80 Stat. 1312.
§ 460u-9. Authorization of appropriations
There are hereby authorized to be appropriated not more than
$27,900,000 for the acquisition of land and interests in land pursuant
to sections 460u to 460u—9 of this title.
Pub.L. 89-761, § 10, Nov. 5, 1966, 89 Stat. 1312.
—26a—
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
§ 4321. Congressional declaration of purpose
The purposes of this chapter are: To declare a national policy
which will encourage productive and enjoyable harmony between
man and his environment; to promote efforts which will prevent or
eliminate damage to the environment and biosphere and stimulate
the health and welfare of man; to enrich the understanding of the
ecological systems and natural resources important to the Nation;
and to establish a Council on Environmental Quality.
Pub.L. 91-190, § 2, Jan. 1, 1970, 83 Stat. 852.
§ 4331. Congressional declaration of national environmental
policy
(a) The Congress, recognizing the profound impact of man’s ac-
tivity on the interrelations of all components of the natural environ-
ment, particularly the profound influences of population growth,
high-density urbanization, industrial expansion, resource exploita-
tion, and new and expanding technological advances and recogniz-
ing further the critical importance of restoring and maintaining en-
vironmental quality to the overall welfare and development of man.
declares that it is the continuing policy of the Federal Government,
in cooperation with State and local governments, and other con-
cerned public and private organizations, to use all practicable means
and measures, including financial and technical assistance, in a
manner calculated to foster and promote the general welfare, to cre-
ate and maintain conditions under which man and nature can exist
in productive harmony, and fulfill the social, economic, and other
requirements of present and future generations of Americans.
(b) In order to carry out the policy set forth in this chapter, it is
the continuing responsibility of the Federal Government to use all
practicable means, consistent with other essential considerations of
national policy, to improve and c_ordigate Federal plans. functions,
programs, and resources to the end that the Nation may—
(1) fulfill the responsibilities of each generation as trustee
of the environment for succeeding generations ;
(2) assure for all Americans safe, healthful, productive, and
esthetically and culturally pleasing surroundings;
—
—2a—
(3) attain the widest range of beneficial uses of the environ-
ment without degradation, risk to health or safety, or other un-
desirable and unintended consequences;
(4) preserve important historic, cultural, and natural aspects
of our national heritage, and maintain, wherever possible, an
environment which supports diversity and variety of individual
choice;
(5) achieve a balance between population and resource use
which will permit high standards of living and a wide sharing
of life’s amenities; and
(6) enhance the quality of renewable resources and approach
the maximum attainable recycling of depletabie resources.
(c) The Congress recognizes that each person should enjoy a
healthful environment and that each person has a responsibility to
contribute to the preservation and enhancement of the environment.
Pub.L. 91-1990, Title I, § 101, Jan. 1, 1970, 83 Stat. 852.
§ 4332. Cooperation of agencies; reports; availability of in-
formation; recommendations; international and
national coordination of efforts
The Congress authorizes and directs that, to the fullest extent
possible: (1) the policies, regulations, and public laws of the United
States shall be interpreted and administered in accordance with the
policies set forth in this chapter, and (2) all agencies of the Federal
Government shall—
(A) utilize a systematic, interdisciplinary appreach which
will insure the integrated use of the natural and social sciences
and the environmental design arts in planring and in decision-
making which may have an impact on man’s environment;
(B) identify and develop methods and procedures, in consul-
tation with the Council on Environmental Quality established
by subchapter II of this chapter, which will insure that pres-
ently unquantified environmental amenities and values may be
given appropriate consideration in decisionmaking along with
economic and technical considerations ;
‘C) include in every recommendation or report on proposals
for legislation and other major Federal actions significantly af-
fecting the quality of the human environment, a detailed state-
ment by the responsible official on—
—28a—
(1) the environmental impact of the proposed action,
(ii) any adverse environmental effects which cannot be
avoided should the proposal be implemented,
(ul) alternatives to the proposed action,
(iv) the relationship between lecal short-term uses of
man’s environment and the maintenance and enhancement
of long-term productivity, and
(Vv) any irreversible and irretrievable commitments of re-
sources which would be involved in the proposed action
should it be implemented.
Prior to making any detailed statement, the responsible Fed-
eral official shall consult with and obtain the comments of any
Federal agency which has jurisdiction by law or special exper-
tise with respect to any environmental impact involved. Copics
of such statement and the comments and views of the appropri-
ate Federal, State, and local agencies, which are authorized to
develop and enforce environmental standards, shall be made
available to the President, the Council on Environmental Quali-
ty and to the public as provided by section 552 of Title 5, and
shall accompany the proposal through the eXisting agency re-
view processes ;
(D) study. develop, and describe appropriate alternatives to
recommended courses of action in any proposal which involves
unresolved conflicts concerning alternative uses of available re-
sources;
(E) recognize the worldwide and long-range character of en-
vironmental problems and. wrere consistent with the foreign
policy of the United States, 'end appropriate support to initia-
tives, resolutions, and pregrams designed to maximize interna-
tional cooperation in anticipating and preventing a decline in
the quality of mankind's world environment:
(PF) make available to States, counties. municipalities, imsti-
tutions. and individuals, advice and information useful in re-
storing, maintaining, and enhancing the quality of the environ-
ment -
G) initiate and utilize ecological information in the plan-
ning and development of resource-oriented projects: and
(H) assist the Council on Environmental Quality established
by subchapter II of this chapter.
Pub.L. 91-190, Title I, § 102, Jan. 1, 1970, &3 Stat. #52.
—29a—
§ 4333. Conformity of administrative procedures to nation-
al environmental policy
All agencies of the Federal Government shall review their present
statutory authority, administrative regulations, and current policies
and procedures for the purpose of determining whether there are
any deficiencies or inconsistencies therein which prohibit full com-
pliance with the purposes and provisions of this chapter and shall
propose to the President not later than July 1, 1971, such measures
as may be necessary to bring their authority and policies into con-
formity with the intent, purposes, and procedures set forth in this
chapter.
Pub.L. 91-190, Title I, § 103, Jan. 1, 1970, 83 Stat. 854.
§ 4334. © Other statutory obligations of agencies
Nothing in section 4332 or 4333 of this title shall in any way af-
fect the specific statutory obligations of any Federal agency (1) to
comply with criteria or standards of environmental quality, (2) to
coordinate or consult with any other Federal or State agency, or (3)
to act, or refrain from acting contingent upon the recommendations
or certification of any other Federal or State agency.
Pub.L. 91-190, Title I, § 104, Jan. 1, 1970, 83 Stat. 854.
§ 4335. Efforts supplemental to existing authorizations
The policies and goals set forth in this chapter are supplementary
to those set forth in existing authorizations of Federal agencies.
Pub.L. 91-190, Title I, § 105, Jan. 1, 1970, 83 Stat. 854.
Organic Act Of The National Park Service,
As Amended
§ 1. Service created; director; other employees
There is created in the Department of the Interior a service to be
called the National Park Service, which shal! be under the charge of a
director. The Secretary of the Interior shall appoint the director, and
there shall also be in said service such subordinate officers, clerks, and
employees as may be appropriated for by Congress. The service thus
established shall promote and regulate the use of the Federal areas
known as national parks, monuments, and reservations hereinafter
—30a—
specified, except such as are under the jurisdiction of the Secretary ot
the Army, as provided by law, by such means and measures as con-
form to the fundamental purpose of the said parks, monuments, and
reservations, which purpose is to conserve the scenery and the natural
and historic objects and the wild life therein and to provide for the
enjoyment of the same in such manner and by such means as will
leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.
Aug. 25, 1916, c. 408, § 1, 39 Stat. 535; Mar. 4, 1923, c. 265, 42 Stat.
1488; Mar. 3, 1925, c. 462, 43 Stat. 1176; Ex.Ord. No. 6166, § 2, June
10, 1933; Mar. 2, 1934, c. 38, § 1, 48 Stat. 389.
Public Law 91-383, August 18, 1970
(National Park Service)
§ la-1l. National park system: administration; declaration
of findings and purpose
Congress declares that the national park system, which began with
tstablishment of Yellowstone National Park in 1872, has since grown
to include superlative natural, historic, and recreation areas in every
major region of the United States, its territories and island posses-
sions; that these areas, though distinct in character, are united
through their inter-related purposes and resources into one national
park system as cumulative expressions of a single national heritage:
that, individually and collectively, these areas derive increased national
dignity and recognition of their superb environmental quality through
their inclusion jointly with each other in one national park system
preserved and managed for the benefit and inspiration of all the peo-
ple of the United States; and that it is the purpose of this Act to in-
clude all such areas in the System and to clarify the authorities appli-
cable to the system.
Pub.L. 91-383, § 1, Aug. 18, 1970, 84 Stat. 825.
“es * *
§ Ic. Sume; general provisions—Definition
(a) The “national park system” shall include any area of land and
water now or hereafter administered by the Secretary of the Interior
through the National Park Service for park, monument, historic, park-
way, recreational, or other purposes.
—3sla—
Specific provisions applicable to area; uniform application of sections th
te 1d and other provisions of this title to all areas when not in conflict
with specific provisions; references in other provisions to national parks,
monuments, recreation areas, historic monuments, or parkways not lim-
itation of such other provisions to those areas
(b) Each area within the national park system shall be adminis-
tered in accordance with the provisions of any statute made specifical-
ly applicable to that area. In addition, the provisions of sections 1b to
ld of this title, and the various authorities relating to the administra-
tion and protection of areas under the administration of the Secretary
of the Interior through the National Park Service, including but not
limited to the Act of August 25, 1916 (39 Stat. 535), as amended (sec-
tions 1 and 2 to 4 of this title), the Act of March 4, 1911 (36 Stat.
1253), as amended (section 5 of this title) relating to rights-of-way,
the Act of June 5, 1920 (41 Stat. 917), as amended (section 6 of this
title), relating to donation of land and money, sections 1, 4, 5, and 6 of
the Act of April 9, 1924 (43 Stat. 90), as amended (sections 8 and 8a
to &c of this title), relating to roads and trails, the Act of March 4,
1931 (46 Stat. 1570; section 8d of this title) relating to approach
roads to national monuments, the Act of June 3, 1948 (62 Stat. 334),
as amended (sections 8e to 8f of this title), relating to conveyance of
roads to States, the Act of August 31, 1954 (68 Stat. 1037), as amend-
ed (section 452a of this title), relating to acquisitions of inholdings,
section | of the Act of July 3, 1926 (44 Stat. 900), as amended (sec-
tion 12 of this title), relating to aid to visitors in emergencies, the Act
of March 3, 1905 (33 Stat. 873; section 10 of this title), relating to
arrests, sections 3, 4, 5, and 6 of the Act of May 26, 1930 (46 Stat.
381), as amended (sections 17b, 17c, 17d, and 17e of this title), relat-
ing to services or other accommodations for the public, emergency sup-
plies and services to concessioners, acceptability of travelers checks,
care and removal of indigents, the Act of October 9, 1965 (79 Stat.
696: (sections 20 to 20g of this title), relating to concessions, the
Land and Water Conservation Fund Act of 1965, as amended, and the
Act of July 15, 1968 (82 Stat. 355), shall, to the extent such provi-
sions are not in conflict with any such specific provision, be applicable
to all areas within the national park system and any reference in such
Act to nationa! parks, monuments, recreation areas, historic monu-
ments, or parkways shall hereinafter not be construed as limiting such
Acts to those areas.
Aug. 8, 1953, c. 384, § 2, 67 Stat. 496; Aug. 18, 1970, Pub.L. 91-383,
§ 2(b), 84 Stat. 826.
—32a—
§ 2. National parks, reservations, and monuments; super-
vision
The director shall, under the direction of the Secretary of the Inte-
rior, have the supervision, management, and control of the several na-
tional parks and national monuments which on August 25, 1916, were
under the jurisdictica of the Department of the Interior, and of the
Hot Springs National Park in the state of Arkansas, and of such oth-
er national parks and reservations of like character as may be created
by Congress. In the supervision, management, and control of national
monuments contiguous to national forests the Secretary of Agriculture
may cooperate with said National Park Service to such extent as may
be requested by the Secretary of the Interior.
Aug. 25, 1916, c. 408, § 2,.39 Stat. 535; Mar. 4, 1921, c. 161, § 1, 41
Stat. 1407.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.