Supplemental Brief — Philadelphia v. New Jersey

Supreme Court brief1977

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court, U. S.

FILED

MICHAEL RODAK, JR., CLERK:

Supreme Court of the United States

Ocroszr Tzrm, 1975

No. 75-1150

CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, CITY OF GLEN COVE, LANDFILL

AND DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, MAC SANITARY LAND-

FILL. INC. KINSLEY’S LANDFILL, INC., and DeLORENZO-

INTERSTA WASTE REMOVAL CO. INC. (now INTER-

STATE WASTE REMOVAL CO., INC.)

Appellants,

STATE OF NEW JERSEY, DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL

PROTECTION OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY and RICHARD

Q SULLIVAN, Commissioner of the Department of Environmental

of the State of New Jersey,

Appellees.

On Appeal from the Supreme Court of New Jersey

SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF FOR APPELLEES

Wruam F. Hyianp,

Attorney General of New Jersey,

Attorney for Appellees, State of New Jersey,

Department of Environmental Protection of

the State of New Jersey and Commissioner

of the Department of Environmental Pro-

tection of the State of New Jersey,

State House Annex, ‘

Trenton, New Jerscy 08625.

STerHen SKILLMAN,

Aw Le p the Brief.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PAGE

= Pre.trMrmnary STATEMENT ........- a 2

ArcumMent—The Resource Conservation and Recov-

ery Act of 1976 does not pre-empt New Jersey’s

prohibition against the disposal of waste originat-

ing out of state, but rather supports the conclusion

that waste disposal does not involve the national

interest in the maintenance of an open economy

which the Commerce Clause was designed to protect 2

CHOICE ATGBOTE “acececaceoeccooecsecccceccesesseseccsreccssecsecereciiinesnseccocnyeceowes 16

Cases Cited

Askew v. American Waterways Operators, Inc., 411

U.S. 325 (1973) "ac

Cardinale v. State of Louisiana, 394 U.S. 437 (1969) 3

Colorado Anti-Discrimination Commission v. Conti-

nental Air Lines, 372 U.S. 714 (1963) svccvscccoce=- 812

Florida Lime & Avocado Growers v. Paul, 373 U.S.

132 (1963) ; 2

Huron Cement Co. v. Detroit, 362 U.S. 440 (1960)... 2

United States v. New Jersey State Lottery Commis-

sion, 420 U.S. 371 (1975) .. a

Welch Co. v. New Hampshire, 306 U.S. 79 (1939) ... 8,12

&)

ii TABLE OF CONTENTS

PAGE

Statutes Cited

N.J.S.A. 13:11-10 14

Resources Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976

(Pub. Law 94-580) 2, 3, 5-15

Sec. 1002(a) (4) 5

See. 1002(b) +

Sec. 2003 6

See. 2004 7

See. 3001-3011 9

See. 3001 7

Sec. 3002-3005 7

See. 3006 7

See. 3009 .. —vs

Sec. 4002(a) 10, 11, 13

See. 4005 13

Sec. 4006(a) 10, 11

Sec. 4006(b) 11

Sec. 4006(c) 10, 11, 13, 14

See. 4007(b) .... 11

See. 7007 ‘ 7

Sec. 8001 ....... 7

Sec. 8004 7

Regulation Cited

40 Fed. Reg. 42993 (1975) 8

TABLE OF CONTENTS

122 Cong. Ree. (1976):

11069, Senator Randolph

11071, Senator Stafford

11072, Senator Baker

11094-11095, Senator Dole - dis

H. Rep. No. 94-1491, at 33

S. Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess. 3 (1976) ....

14

$

S. Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess. 11 (1976) .. 6,13

S. Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess. 16 (1976) ..”

1 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Proceed-

ings 1975 Public Meetings on Hazardous Waste

Management 8 (1976)

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

Octoser Term, 1975

No. 75-1150

—

CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, CITY OF GLEN COVE,

LANDFILL AND DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, MAC

SANITARY LANDFILL, INC., KINSLEY’S LAND-

FILL, INC., and DELORENZO-INTERSTATE WASTE

REMOVAL CO., INC. (now INTERSTATE WASTE

REMOVAL CO., INC.),

Appellants,

Vv.

STATE OF NEW JERSEY, DEPARTMENT OF EN-

VIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OF THE STATE OF

NEW JERSEY and RICHARD J. SULLIVAN, Com-

missioner of the Department of Environmental Pro-

tection of the State of New Jersey,

Appellees.

On Appeal from the Supreme Court of New Jersey

>

SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF FOR APPELLEES

wk

Ve ape aa

Preliminary Statement

By order dated November 15, 1976, the Court granted

the appellants’ motion for leave to file a supplemental

brief to consider the impact, if any, on this appeal of the

enactment of the Resource Conservation and Recovery

Act of 1976 (Pub. Law 94-580). The order further allowed

each side twenty-one days within which to file such a

brief.

ARGUMENT

The Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of

1976 does not preempt New J s prohibition

against the disposal of waste originating out of state,

but rather supports the conclusion that waste disposal

does not involve the national interest in the mainte-

nance of an open economy which the Commerce

Clause was designed to protect. ,

It is now well established that an intent to pre-empt

state legislation should not be inferred unless there is

“an unambiguous congressional mandate to that effect.”

Florida Lime & Avocado Growers v. Paul, 373 U.S. 132,

147 (1963). The Court has been particularly reluctant to

find an intent to pre-empt state legislation which has been

enacted to serve environmental interests. Askew v. Ameri-

cam Waterways Operators, Inc., 411 U.S. 325 (1973);

Huron Cement Co. y. Detroit, 362 U.S. 440 (1960). There-

fore, the appellants must bear the heavy burden of demon-

strating an unambiguous congressional mandate that the

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (herein-

after “the Act”) pre-empts New Jersey’s statute prohibit-

ing the disposal of waste originating out of state.

3

Preliminarily, note should be taken of the procedural

route by which the appellants’ pre-emption claim comes

before the Court. Since the Act was not signed py the

President until October 21, 1976, the state courts had

no opportunity to consider its effect. Furthermore, there

was no claim of pre-emption raised by the appellants

either in their jurisdictional statement, initial brief on

the merits or in. oral argument. These circumstances

ordinarily would bar the appellants from raising the claim

at this late date. Cardinale v. State of Lowtsiana, 394

U.S. 437 (1969). However, an exception to the ordinary

practice is recognized where there has been a supervening

change in the law which may obviate the need for the

Court to reach the issue initially projected for review.

United States v. New Jersey State Lottery Commission,

420 U.S. 371 (1975). Therefore, if it could be concluded

that the Act on its face totally pre-empted the New Jersey

legislation, it might be appropriate to dispose of the case

on those grounds.

However, it is clear that the main sections of the Act

have no operative effect at this time and that the con-

tours of future federal regulation are contingent upon

implementing administrative action, the form of which

cannot now be predicted. Therefore, there is no substan-

tial basis on which it can be argued that the Act on its

face pre-empts or in any way undermines the validity of

New Jersey’s prohibition against the disposal within the

State of waste originating out of state. On the contrary,

the only sense in which the Act bears on this case is that

it contains express congressional recognition of the prin-

cipal premises on which defense of the validity of the New

Jersey statute rests.

First, the Act contains an express congressional recog-

nition of the fact that solid waste disposal is rot a sub-

4

ject of ordinary commercial dealings controlled by the

free market principles of the Commerce Clause but rather

a subject which directly affects the environment and public

health. Thus, section 1002(b) states that:

“(b) Exvmoyment anp Heautra.—The Congress

finds with respect to the environment and health,

that—

“(1) although land is too valuable a national re-

source to be needlessly polluted by discarded mate-

rials, most solid waste is disposed of on land in

open dumps and sanitary landfills;

“(2) disposal of solid waste and hazardous waste

in or on the land without careful planning and man-

agement can present a danger to human health and

the environment;

“(3) as a result of the Clean Air Act, the Water

Pollution Control Act, and other Federal and State

laws respecting public health and the environment,

greater amounts of solid waste (in the form of

sludge and other pollution treatment residues) have

been created. Similarly, inadequate and environ-

mentally unsound practices for the disposal or use

of solid waste have created greater amounts of air

and water pollution and other problems for the

environment and for health;

“(4) open dumping is particularly harmful to

health, contaminates drinking water from under-

ground and surface supplies, and pollutes the air

and the land;

“(5) hazardous waste presents, in addition to

the problems associated with non-hazardous solid

waste, special dangers to health and requires a

5

greater degree of regulation than does non-hazard-

ous solid waste; and

“(6) alternatives to existing methods of land dis-

posal must be developed since many of the cities in

the United States will be running out of suitable

solid waste disposal sites within five years unless

immediate action is taken; .. .”

Secondly, the Act constitutes an express congressional

recognition that the problems of solid waste disposal are

primarily of state and local, not national, concern. Thus,

© §1002(a)(4) states that “. . . the collection and disposal

of solid wastes should continue to be primarily the func-

tion of State, regional and local agencies. .. .” This point

is underscored by the comments during deliberations on

the bill on the floor of the Senate. The co-sponsor of the

bill, Senator Randolph, stated:

“In developing this legislation, the members of

the Committee on Publie Works recognized that

solid waste is a uniquely local problem and that.

programs in this area should be developed and man-

aged at the local government level.

“This is not an area which lends itself to exten-

sive planning and operation from the Federal level.

The role of the Federal Government in solid waste

activities should be one primarily of providing finan-

cial and technical assistance. Guidelines authorized

by this legislation are to be descriptive “of the op-

tions available to local and regional bodies respon-

sible for solid waste management. These guidelines

should not be taken as directives from the Federal

Government for a position by the local authorities.

“Guidelines should provide the States and area

planning agencies with maximum flexibility, while

6

assuritg that such agencies or organizations have

adequate information to effectively implement the

planning provisions.

“To assure that the Federal Government adopts

a proper place in this program, I emphasize the

Administrator of the Environmental Protection

Agency is required to notify the Congress before

the publication of guidelines, information or model

codes, ordinances or statutes. The agency is re-

stricted under the provisions of the bill from advo-

cating specific policy alternatives at the State or

local level. These matters are best left—and I

emphasize this—to local choice since they involve

substantial regional variations. It is not appropri-

ate for the Environmental Protection Agency to

become involved other than in the provision of tech-

nical assistance on request.” 122 Cong. Rec. 11069

(1976) (remarks of Senator Randolph).

These views were echoed by Senator Stafford of Vermont

(Id. at 11071), Senator Baker of Tennessee (Id. at 11972)

and Senator Dole of Kansas (Td. at 11094-11095). No

‘ contrary view was expressed. See also S. Rep. No. 94-988,

94th Cong., 2nd Sess. 11 (1976).

A review of the individual subsections of the Act also

shows that its overall design was to foster the waste dis-

posal programs of the states rather than to pre-empt the

field at the federal level. The Act represents a significant

new federal commitment to participate in solving the

problems of solid waste collection and disposal. However,

with limited exceptions discussed below, the Act does not

purport to override state legislation dealing with the prob-

lems of solid waste management. The Act provides in

§2003 for the establishment by the Administrator of the

7

Environmental Protection Agency (hereinafter “EPA”)

of “Resource Conservation and Recovery Panels”, con-

sisting of technical, marketing, financial and institutional

specialists, which will have the responsibility of providing

“States and local governments upon request with technical

assistance on solid waste management, resource recovery

and resource conservation.” 42004 establishes a program

of federal grants to assist private and public purchasers

of tire shredders. §7007 authorizes federal grants to train

State and local personnel to carry out solid waste and

resource recovery programs. Federal funding of research

and development and demonstration projects are author-

ized by $8001 and 48004. The sections are all elements

of an overall congressional design to leave the responsi-

bility for dealing with the problems of solid waste at the

state and local level but at the same time to provide fed-

eral financial and technical assistance.

The one area in which the federal government has as-

sumed a direct regulatory responsibility is with respect to

hazardous waste. The Administrator of EPA has the

responsibility under $3001 for identifying the character-

istics of hazardous waste and listing particular hazardous

wastes not later than eighteen months after enactment of

the Act. The Administrator is required within the same

period to promulgate regulations governing the genera-

tion, storage, transportation and disposal of hazardous

waste. §3002-3005. The Administrator also may delegate

the responsibility for regulation of hazardous wastes to

state authorities. §3006.

Although the exact parameters of tlie eventual federal

regulation of hazardous waste are difficult to predict at

this time, it is clear that the assumption of federal regu-

latory control over the subject has no immediate impact

upon New Jersey’s prohibition against the disposal of

8

waste originating out-of-state and only a limited potential

long range impact. First, these sections of the Act are

not self-implementing but rather are dependent upon the

promulgation by the Administrator of EPA of a list

of hazardous wastes and of regulations governing their

generation, storage, transportation and disposal. Since

the Administrator has eighteen months within which to

promulgate such lists and regulations, the federal regu-

lation of this area probably will not become operative at

all for nearly a year and a half. It is firmly established —

that such potential future regulation of a subject matter

by a federal agency does not pre-empt present regulation

by the states. Colorado Anti-Discrimination Commission

v. Continental Air Lines, 372 U.S. 714, 723-724 (1963);

Welch Co. v. New Hampshire, 306 U.S. 79, 84-85 (1939).

Secondly, even when the federal regulatory program be-

comes operative, it will be limited to “hazardous wastes”.

This term is generally understood in the field of solid

waste management to apply soiely to industrial wastes

which are inherently dangerous to plant and auimal life.

The Senate Committee on Public Works noted in its re-

port on the Act that “[mJaterials of major concern are

arsenic wastes, insecticide and pesticide residues, waste

oil, explosive wastes, sludge contaminated with metals

such as chromium and zine, and radioactive wastes.” S.

Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess. 3 (1976); see also

40 Fed. Reg. 42993 (1975); 1 U.S. Environmental Protee-

tion Agency, Proceedings 1975 Public Meetings on Haz-

ardous Waste Management 8 (1976). In the Act, “hazard-

ous waste” is defined as:

“... a solid waste, or combination of solid wastes,

which because of its quantity, concentration, or phy-

sical, chemical or infectious characteristics may—

9

“(A) cause, Or significantly exntetbote to an

increasé in mortality or an increase in serious

irreversible, or incapacitating reversible, illness;

or

“(B) pose a substantial present or potential

hazard to human health or the enviror ent when

improperly treated, stored, transport¢d, or dis-

posed of, or otherwise managed.” aa

In addition, the Administrator is directed, in listing the

“hazardous wastes” which will be subject to federal regu-

lation, to take into account “. . . toxicity, persistence, and

degradability in nature, potential for accuniulation in tis-

sue, and other related factors such as flammability, cor-

rosiveness, and other hazardous characteristies.” $3001.

It seems clear that ordinary household’ and commercial

waste, or garbage, would not fall within’these criteria for

defining “hazardous waste” and thus would not be subject

to federal regulation under 43001-3014 of the Act. This

conclusion is confirmed by the Report’ of the Senate Com-

‘mittee on Public Works on the Act which expressly states

that the permit system for hazardous wastes “. . . is not

to be used to control the disposal of hazardous substances

used in households or to extend control over general mu-

nicipal wastes based on the presence of such substances.”

S. Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess., 16 (1976). Since

the New Jersey statute as limited by its implementing

regulations (App. 92-96) i8-primarily directed towards

general municipal waste and the appellants apparently

are engaged solely in the disposal of such waste, it would

appear that the federal regulation of “hazardous waste”

would have no effect upon the subject matter of this ease

even when that regulatory program becomes operative.

- Finally, even as to “haphrdous wastes”, the Act indi-

cates that state regulation-may continue so long as it is

10

not “less stringent” than federal regulations. §3009. Since’

the eventual promulgation by the Administrator of regu-

lations which wouid conflict with the prohibition against

the disposal of waste originating out of state is a matter

of pure conjecture, it is uncertain at this time whether

there will be any conflict between the New Jersey statute

and federal regulation even with respect to the limited

area of “hazardous wastes”. Therefore, the provisions of

the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 re-

garding “hazardous wastes” do not undercut the validity

of the New Jersey statute.

In addition to providing for direct federal regulatiozi

of the subject of “hazardous waste”, the Act also estab-

lishes a system of incentives for regional planning with

respect to the reclamation or disposal of other solid

wastes. The Act contemplates joint federal-state action,

first, to identify regions appropriate for solid waste plan-

ning, and second, to adopt regulations for solid waste

management in such regions. First, §4002(a) provides

that within 180 days after enactment of the Act, the Ad-

ministrator of EPA “. . . after consultation with appro-

priate Federal, State, and local authorities, shall by regu-

lation publish guidelines for the identification of those

areas which have common solid waste problems and are

appropriate units for planning regional solid waste man-

agement services.” §4006(a) provides that within 180 days

after adoption of the federal guidelines, “. . . the Gover-

nor of each State, after consultation with local elected offi-

cials, shall promulgate regulations based on such guide-

lines identifying the boundaries of each area within the ©

State which, as a result of urban concentrations, geo-

graphic conditions, markets, and other factors, is appro-

priate for carrying out regional solid waste management.”

§4006(c) also provides that such regions may embrace more

than one State in which event “. . . the Governors of the

11

respective states ... shall enter into agreements identify-

ing the boundaries of such region.” §4006(b) provides

that within a third 180 day period the State shall “. . .

(A) identify an agency to develop the State plan and

identify one or more agencies to implement such plan,

and (B) identify which solid waste functions will, under

sich State plan, be planned for and carried out by the

State and which such functions will, under such State

plan, be planned for and carried out by a regional or local

authority or a combination of regional or local and State

authorities.” Second, with respect to the solid waste re-

gions established under §4002(a) and §4006(a), (b) and

(c), eighteen months after enactment of the Act, “. . . the

Administrator shall, atfer consultation with appropriate

- Federal, State, and local authorities, promulgate regula-

tions containing guidelines to assist in the development

and implementation of State solid waste management

plans.” The Act does not contain any specific time period

within which State solid waste management plans should be

submitteu, but it authorizes appropriations for solid waste

planning and provides that a State must have a State

plan which has been approved by the Administrator in

order to be eligible for such federal financial assistance.

$4007 (b).

Although the exact future scope of federally super-

vised regional ®olid waste planning by state and local

agencies, like the direct federal regulation of hazardous

wastes, cannot be forecast with any assurance, it is clear

that it has no iyimediate impact upon New Jersey pro-

hibition against the disposal of waste originating out of

state and that any long range effect upon the prohibition

is purely conjectural. First, the regional planning provi-

sions of the Act are not self-implementing but rather will’

become operative only after administrative action at both

federal and state levels. The Administrator of EPA has

180 days after enactment of the Act to publish guidelines

for identifying regional solid waste planning areas, and

thereafter the Governors of the States have two further

180 day periods for identifying the boundaries of regional

planning areas and the agencies to carry out such plan-

ning; there is thus an overall period of nearly eighteen

months before regional planning areas and implementing

agencies even will be identified. The Administrator of

EPA has the same eighteen month period within which

to promulgate guidelines for State solid waste manage-

ment plans. Although the Act sets no deadline for the

actual submission of regional plans, it must be assumed

that some additional period will be required for this pur-

pose beyond the eighteen months allowed for identifying

planning regions and implementing agencies. Consequent-

ly, it will be several years before regional plans under the

Act become operative. Therefore, assuming arguendo the

possibility that New Jersey’s prohibition against the dis-

posal of waste originating out of state could conflict with

such plans, such possible future action by a federal regu-

latory agency does not undermine the present validity of

New Jersey’s law. Colorado Anti-Discrimination Commis-

ston v. Continental Air Lines, supra; Welch Co. v. New

Hampshire, supra.

Secondly, there is no express indication in the Act that

a State is required to participate in the program of re-

gional planning provided thereunder. Rather, it appears

that the sole consequence of a failure to engage in such

regional planning is the loss of federal financial assist-

ance under this subsection of the Act. If this reading of

the Act is correct, then it is a matter of conjecture

whether New Jersey will even subject itself to these provi-

sions of the Act.

Thirdly, assuming the federal scheme of supervision of

regional planning becomes operative, the only way in

13

which there could be a conflict between the New Jersey

statute and a regional plan under the Act is if the plans

of New Jersey and its neighboring states include “inter-

state regions” pursuant to 44006(c). There is of course

no way of knowing at this time whether the guidelines to

be promulgated by the Administrator under 44002(a) will

suggest the appropriateness of any interstate region en-

compassing New Jersey. Furthermore, the Act contem-

plates that the identification of interstate regions and

planning agencies shall be by “agreement” between the

Governors of the respective states. The essentially volun-

tary nature of such regional planning is confirmed by the

numerous statements in the legislative history of a con-

gessional intent that “. . . States and areawide solid waste

management planning agencies have free choice in select-

ing the elements of their solid waste management plans.

S. Rep. No. 94-988, 94th Cong., 2nd Sess., 11 (1976). See

also 122 Cong. Rec. 11069 (1976) (comments of Senator

Randolph) ; 7d. at 11071 (comments of Senator Stafford) ;

Id. at 11072 (comments of Senator Baker); Jd. at 11094-

11095 (comments of Senator Dole).* This point is stated

with particular clarity in the Report of the House Com-

merce Committee:

“Tt is the Committee’s intention that federal as-

sistance should be an incentive for state and local

authorities to act to solve the discarded materials

problem. At this time federal preemption of this

problem is undesirable, inefficient, and damaging to

local initiative.

* One exception to the general design of local option with respect

to state plans is the requirement that open dumps be eliminated. See

§4005.

14

“Simply, the discarded materials problem is one

of planning and the Committee anticipates that fed-

eral guidelines for planning will foster the neces-

sary cooperation between the federal government,

states, and local regions, to meet very broad and

flexible objectives of this act. If those objectives

are not met, the states and local authorities within

thé states will lose the federal or technical assist-

ance. However, the provisions of this legislation,

specifically do not authorize the federal government

to take over the responsibility for discarded mate-

rials disposal planning.” H. Rep. No. 94-1491, at 33.

The extent to which “interstate agreements” might be

reached pursuant to §4006(c) and the form they would

take is therefore a matter of conjecture. Furthermore,

even if the procedures of the Act eventually were to re-

sult in an agreement between the Governors of the respec-

tive states which was inconsistent with a total ban on the

disposal in New Jersey of out-of-state waste, this would

not result in an invalidation of the New Jersey statute.

Rather, it would simply provide an appropriate occasion

for a further exercise by the New Jersey Commissioner

of Environmental Protection of his power to adopt excep-

tions from the total ban where that can be done “. ,.

without endangering the public health, safety and welfare.

.--” N.J.S.A. 13:11-10.

In sum, the enactment of the Resource Conservation

and Recovery Act of 1976 does not pre-empt or in any

way undercut the validity of the New Jersey legislation

prohibiting the disposal of waste originating out of state.

Rather, it reflects congressional concurrence with the view

that the disposal of waste does not involve the national |

interest in maintenance of an open economy which the

15

Commerce Clause was designed to protect, but instead the

discharge by government under the police power of a

fundamental responsibility to provide for the disposal of

waste generated by its inhabitants with the least possible

adverse impact upon health, the environment and land

use. Furthermore, recognition of the fact that a political

subdivision of a state, such as the appellant City of Phila-

delphia, cannot invoke the negative implications of the

Commerce Clause to force the State of New Jersey to

dispose of its waste and to suffer the resulting environ-

mental harms, does not mean that interstate approaches

to solid waste management problems are inappropriate.

Nor does it mean that Congress lacks the authority to

compel the states ander appropriate circumstances to deal

with waste disposal problems on a regional or national

basis. It simply recognizes that the problems of waste

disposal, like the problems associated with the investiga-

tion and prosecution of crime, are governmental prob-

lems, rather than ordinary commercial transactions, and

that regional approaches should be the product of agree-

ment between the responsible stete officials, or the man-

date of Congress, and not an unplanned by-product of the

whims of the marketplace. The Resource Conservation

and Recovery Act of 1976 provides a congressional legis-

lative framework for just such cooperative governmental

arrangements by agreement between the states and, to a

limited extent, by direct regulatory activity of the federal

government. However, the main provisions of the Att will

not become operative for several years and even when the

Act does become fully effective, it is purely conjectural -

whether there would be any conflict between the ini

_tration of the Act and enforcement of the prohibition

against the disposal within New Jersey of waste originat-

ing out of state. Therefore, the’ Act does not impair theQy

facial validity of the New Jersey legislation.

16

CONCLUSION

It is respectfully submitted that for the reasons

expressed in our principal brief on the merits and in

this supplemental brief the judgment of the Supreme

Court of New Jersey should be affirmed.

Respectfully submitted,

Wim F. Hytanp ied

Attorney General of New J ersey

Attorney for Appellees, State of

New Jersey, Department of

Environmental Protection of

the State of New Jersey and

Commissioner of the Depart-

ment of Environmental Pro-

tection of the State of New

Jersey

SrepHen SKILLMAN

Assistant Attorney General

Of Counsel and On the Brief

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.