Petition — Conley v. Hampton
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
RE til eC NR tain tm dba Ia” Loans cosines ad eeu ae ahaa Gane
. " e baa “te 2 3 i Be : : dow: . pe - “ - x — et “ts
7 a fhe eer ia
* eae lk Ble
ae a Se a tae oe tail
Gapreme Cour, U.S.
' FILED
A APR 26 I9I6
y
H WAICHAEL RGOAK, JR., CLERK
!
a
v= ee
|
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October We Jt K ~
No.
LENA BOSA KNECHT CONLEY,
Petitioner,
Ve
Robert E. ——
Chairman and Commissioner,
Civil Service Commission;
Henry E. Kissinger
Secretary of Statex
Respondents
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS
POR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
LENA ROSA KNECHT CONLEY,
300 We 35th Street,
Post Office Box 6092,
Norfolk, Virginia 23508,
REQ ge-
Phone:
804-622-4951.
April 26, 1976.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Opinion Below 2
Jurisdiction 2
Question Presented for Review 2
Constitutional Provisions 3
United States Code 4
Rules of the Supreme Court 4
Statement of the Case 5
ARGUMENT :
Ie Constitutional Violations 11
iI. Other Violations 13
ITI. "Clean Hands" Doctrine 15
Efforts to Influence Legislation 16
Reasons to Grant Certiorari 17
Conclusion 18
Certificate of Service 19
APPENDIX
District Court Order A-l
Court of Appeals Judgment A-2
Essentials of Fair Procedure A-
Supreme Court Requirements A
UPI News Release, April 19, 1976 A-5
CITATIONS
CASES:
Ashwander ve. TVA (297 U.S. 288) 16,a-4
Chafin ve Pratt, 358 F.2d 349 15.17
McGlasson ve UsSe, 397 Fe2d 303 15,17
Scroggins Ve VseSe, 397 Fe2d 295 13,15
Constitutional Provisions vee
Title 5. U.S.Code, Section 702
Title 5, U.S.Code, Section 8347(c)2,4,16
Title 28, U.S.Code, Section 1254 4
ee eee ae
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1975
NO.
LENA ROSA KNECHT CONLEY,
Petitioner,
Ve
aE cena
aRobert E. Hampton,
Chairman ard Commissioner,
Civil Service Commission;
Henry E. Kissinger,
Secretary of Statef
Respondent
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TC THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIACUIT
To the Chief Justice and ithe Associate
Justices of the Supreme Court of the
United States:
Your petitioner, Lena Rosa Knecht Conley,
respectfully prays that a writ of certio-
rari issue to review the decision of the
United Stetes Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit of February
9, 1976.
OPINION BELOW
The United States District Court
for the District of Columbia on December
11, 1974, granted defendants' motion to
dismiss in Civil Action No. 74-654.
The District Court's Order appears
as Appendix A-l.
JURISDICTION
The United States Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit
affirmed judgment of the District Court
in No. 75-1057 (Civil Action No. 74-654)
on February 9, 1976.
The Court of Appeals' Judgment;
with no opinion and not to be published,
appears as Appendix A-2.
The jurisdiction of this Court is
invoked under 28 UeSeCe 1254(1) and 2101
(c) and Rules 13, 15, 22 and 33 of this
Court.
QUESTION PRESENTED FOR REV. "YW
Whether Title 5, U.S. Code, Séstion
8347(c), violates the United States Con-
stitution, particularly Amendments:
I. Right to petition for redress of
grievances.
IV. Right to be secure in person against
unreasonable searches.
Ve
Vi.
VII.
VIII.
IX.
XIV.
Freedom from harrassment by succes-
sive agency action for the same
"alleged" acts of misconduct;
Protection against self-incrinination
creating a zone of privacy which
government may not invade by re-
quiring psychiatric consultation;
Right to due process of law.
Right to be informed of nature and
cause of accusations;
Right to assistance of counsel.
Right to jury trial where value in
controversy exceeds twenty dollars.
Right to protection against cruel
and unusual punishment.
Bight to privacy in psychiatric
consultations and to follow compe-
tent counsel.
Protection against abridgement of
privileges or immunities of citizens
of the United States;
Protection against deprivation of
life, liberty, or property without
due process of law;
Right to equal protection of the
. law.
CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS
Article III, Section 2, United States
Constitution: "The judicial Power shall
extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity,
arising under this Constitution, the Laws
of the United States .. or which shall be
made.see"
Amendments, United Stateamggnstitution:
First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh,
Eighth, Ninth, and Fourteenth, as noted
under QUESTION PRESENTED FOR REVIEW.
UNITED STATES CODE
Title 5, UeS.C. 8 702: Right of review.
A person suffering legal wrong because
of agency action, or adversely affected
or aggrieved by agency action within the
meaning of a relevant statute, is entitled
to judicial review thereof.
Title 5, U.S.C. 8 8347(c):
eeeeThe decisions of the Commission
concerning these matters are final and
conclusive and are not subject to review.
Title 28, U.S.C. 8 1254: Cases in the
courts of appeals may be reviewed by the
Supreme Court by the following methods:
(1) By writ of certiorari granted upon
the petition of any party to any civilor
criminal case, before or after rendition
of judgment or decre@ece.
RULES OF
THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
13. Not more than ninety days after the
entry of the judgment appealed from.
15. Jurisdictional statement...
22. (2) A petition for writ of certicran
shall be deemed in time when it
is filed with the clerk within
the time prescribed by law.
4
33- (2)(a). If the United States is a
party, service shall be
made upon the
Solicitor General,
Department of Justice,
Washington, D.C. 20530.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Petitioner was cleared after thorough
FBI investigation and routine medical ex-
amination for employment as GS-5, Step 10,
Secretary, at the Department of State
(Bureau of Security and Consular Affairs)
i D. Ce, effective January 20,
Clearance for reassignment as an PSS-8
Step 9, Secretary, American Embassy, °
meme Re 9 pon Was granted after a
rig cal examinati
October 18, 1954, ee
Because of shortage of rsonnel -
tioner worked two Pre Bony aeaenhene te
Political Officer _— primary assignment)
and Secretary to Counselor (filling in
vacancy). Overwork, improper quarters,
and unsanitary food caused loss of weight
and fatigue, resulting in air evacuation
across Cight time zones February 21 - 22
1965, from Saudi Arabia to Bethesda Naval
Hospital for medical treatment.
(Coincidentally, misleading state
ments
basically to remove petitioner and provide
@ vacancy for Mary Minnick whose husband,
David, was reporting for dut
1965, had been prepared.) ,
5
Erroneous statements from the American
Embassy, Jidda, Saudi Arabia, resulted in
Dr. McGrail's permitting no bedrest and
no complete physical examination. In-
stead, petitioner--assigned to Ward 7E--
had to do manual labor in the closed sec-
tion and daily typing in the open, taking
massive doses of medications (includi
unnecessary sleeping pills) until April 10,
1965, when they were halted by Dr. J. A.
Pursch, who had relieved Dr. McGrail.
Always cooperative with no signs of
serious depression, petitioner was found
fit psychiatrically for return to work
April 21, 1965, and Dr. Pursch attempted
by — 7 to secure a part-time assign-
ment. e Department of State, however,
improperly assigned petitioner to a GS-4
Clerk-Stenographer desk April 22, 1965,
in the Bureau of Economic Affairs.
In October 1965, the Department of
State refused to grant clearance for pe-
titioner to accept offer of employment
as GS-7 Shorthand Reporter at the Naval
Station, Norfolk, Virginia.
Upon petitioner's objection, she was
told by Dr. Ce Ae Klwentz to see Dr.
William J. Stockton, a psychiatrist. The
latter told her to request a medical
clearance, which was issued by Dr.Klontz
of the Department of State Medical Divi-
sion on December 8, 1965.
In February 1966, the Department of
State again refused to t clearance
for reassignment to GS Secretary in
the Bureau of Public Affairs. Petitioner
6
Was so discouraged that she asked for a
leave of absence and was told by Dr. LeK.
Woodward, Medical Director, Department
of State, to see Dr. J. Ae Pursch again.
On February 17, 1966, Dr. Pursch re-
fused to support request for leave and
referred her to Dr. James J. Cavanagh,
Outpatient Clinic, Arlington Annex, for
appointment February 28, 1966, "to be
followed supportively for several visits."
Dr. Cavanagh agreed with Dr. Pursch
that no psychiatric disability existed
and suggested petitioner seek legal
assistance to obtain a more appropriate
assignment.
Petitioner consulted her Congressman,
who suggested grievance of April 7, 1966;
disability retirement was then offered
and refused.
After a year's work at the Department
of State following return from overseas,
annual physical examination revealed the
presence of two types of parasites and a
grapefruit-sized tumor.
In consultation May 25, 1966, Dr. D. E-
MacCarty recorded "one wonders in regard
to the clinical history of stool para-
sites whether the mass might be the re-
sult of a previous inflammatory episode."
Humatin series were prescribed by the
Department of State parasitologist May
26 = 31, 1966, and surgery was undergone
June 24, 1966, at Bethesda Naval Hospital.
Leave of absence from June 18 through
August 12, 1966, was approved.
7
Petitioner was cleared physically and
psychiatrically ty Bethesda Naval Hospital
for return to work August 15, 1966.
Petitioner was assigned to various GS-6
desks in absence of regularly assigned
employees, and on September 9, 1966, re-
ceived "Change in Assignment" memorandum
from Robert B. Sarsfield as follows:
"As noted earlier your assignment is
being changed from the Publications Cost
Project to one of assisting in the prep-
aration of the new alert lists for the
CERP. Your tabulation of CERP publica-
tions cost data covering the EUR bureau
Was a very substantial contribution to
that over-all project.
"In your new assignment you will report
to Mr. Leo Ryan on problems relating to
the alert lists and that effort is to
have priority. To the extent that you
have free time, however, it is requested
that you provide secretarial support for
Mire Kauffman and Mr. Prager. You are
assigned to a desk in their outer office--
Room 3826=--where a telephone has been ir-
stalled for your use. We have asked for
a typewriter that will produce excellent
copy; please inform Mr. Ryan immediately
if it does not do so."
It is difficult to believe the above
work was performed as of November 6, 1966,
by a GS-3 Clerk-Stenographer as stated in
Defendants! Exhibit No. 2 forwarded by
the United States Attorney on October 3,
1974. This Exhibit incorrectly shows
petitioner's assignment to GS-+ Clerk-
Stenographer as of May 24, 1965--
8
actually April 22, 1965, according to
Personnel EvalMdation of December 31, 1965.
On October 25, 1966, Mr. Leo J. Ryan
wrote Dr. Alexander Tish, Civil Service
Commission, that “From Tg 16, 1966,
for a period of approximately four weeks,
Mrs. Lena R. Ke Conley was assigned to
work with me. During this period she
displayed the conscientiousness and super-
ior standard of performance which I had
come to expect from previous experience
working with her."
Petitioner had been directed, upon her
return to work August 15, 1966, to report
to Dr. James B. Kludt for a "“fitness-for-
duty" examination. Dr. Kludt discarded
the entire medical file and conducted a
"“witchhunt" to obtain substantiation to
support involuntary retirement for
"alleged" disability.
Under Dr. Kludt's direction, physical
examinations were conducted by Dr. Wherry
and psychological tests by E. Lakin
Phillips, Phe De, including:
Ink Blots
Guilford-Zimmerman Temperament Survey
Mooney Problem Check List
Edwards Personal Preference Schedule
Kuder Preference Record Form CH
General Intelligence Test
Dre Kludt made his report September 15,
1966, but petitioner was never informed
of the case against her. On October 4,
1966, she was relieved of her Department
of State credentials and wrongfully dis-
9
missed, with no effort to effect appro-
priate reassignment.
Petitioner promptly appealed notifica-
tion of December 1, 1966, of total dis-
ability by referring to Dr. J. Je Cavanagh
among others.
Petitioner never ceased her efforts to
secure legal assistance and to discover
the nature of the "alleged" disability.
On January 4, 1971, the Civil Service
Commission issued a NOTICE OF RECOVERY
FROM DISABILITY based on statement of
November 12, 1970, »y Dr. James J. Cava-
nagh, confirming that he had never seen
any disability in any contact with peti-
tioner beginning February 28, 1966.
Petitioner immediately applied for re-
instatement at the Department of State
and locally. She was reinstated as GS-4
Clerk-Stenographer at the Naval Supply
Center, Norfolk, Virginia, July 12, 1971,
but was coerced into resigning July 13,
1973, because of her efforts to obtain
(1) comparable previous permanent status,
(2) clear record, and (3) impartial re-
view of performance ratings.
On August 20, 1973, she received NOTICE
OF DECISION from Welford M. Burrell,
Chairman, Performance Rating Board of
Review, that her performance justified
"an overall rating of Satisfactory under |
the applicable system" and that "The
Board unanimously and readily agrees that,
under the totality of the circumstances,
the appellant stood high in that category."
10
Defendants' Exhibit No. 1 of August 9,
1974, refers to Treasury Department check
dated August 2, 1973, which was entrusted
to an attorney. On February 5, 1974, he
returned it stating, "I wish very much
that I could represent you in your clain
against the Department of State and Naval
Supply Center, but I have said to you be-
fore, the burdens upon time sim
will not permit ite” - aid
Petitioner then worked to prepare and
file Civil Action No. 74-654 on April 30,
1974, with the check attached. The check
in the amount of 312,023.49 is attached
to the case filed with the United States
Court of Appeals for the District of Co-
lumbia Circuit.
ARGUMENT
I. CONSTITUTIONAL VIOLATIONS
Following the Congressman's advice to
submit grievance of April 7, 1966,
triggered efforts to retire petitioner
for disability, abrogating her right to
seek Congressional help, a violation of
the First Amendment.
Sending petitioner repeatedly to psy-
chiatrists was an unconscionable abuse
of the right to be secure in person
against unreasonable searches, a viola-
tion of the Fourth Amendment.
That the Civil Service Commission had
a psychiatric consultant on November 9,
1966, find petitioner totally disabled
11
“about Oct. 1964" not only was fraudulent,
but also harrassment by successive agency
action for the same "alleged" behavior, a
violation of the Fifth Amendment.
The Fifth Amendment guarantees a zone
of privacy which government may not invade,
and repeated psychiatric evaluations were
violative.
Petitioner was never informed of the
nature of the case against her or afforded
opportunity to respond to allegations or
confront witnesses, a violation of the
due process guaranteed by the Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendments.
Assistance of counsel has never been
provided, a violation of Sixth Amendment
rights.
Assigning petitioner manual labor in
Ward 7E with no bedrest and no physical
examination after jet flight across eight
time zones was cruel and unusual punish-
ment, a violation of the Eighth Amendment.
(It may be noted that strong, healthy
males have exhibited psychotic symptoms
when circadian rhythm is upset and require
approximately four days of complete rest
to recover.)
The government does not heve unlimited
power to invade rights not specifically
listed, and petitioner feels being or-
dered to report to a psychiatrist who
submits a report solicited by the agency,
without providing individual nature of
"alleged" illness and how to control it,
is an unconscionable abuse of the "right
to privacy."
12
“~
«/”
fhis is a violation of the Ninth Amend-
ment. (This "right to privacy" is also
protected by the First, Third, Fourth,
and Pifth Amendments.)
That petitioner should be deprived of
her right to work and marked with a
"badge of infamy" .
397 F.2d 295 (1968) at p. © prevent
her from obtaining appropriate legal
acsistance, reassignment, or return to
the graduate work interrupted by recruit-
ment by the Department of State, is an
abuse of discretion and violation of the
Fourteenth Amendment.
II. OTHER VIOLATIONS
A careful and thorough review of all
the circumstances surrounding this case
will reveal many instances where there
was substantial departure from important
procedural rights, misconstruction of
governing legislation, and like error
zoing to the heart of the administrative
determination.
Petitioner was never informed at the
American Embassy, Jidda, Saudi Arabia;
in the Bureau of Economic Affairs, De-
partment of State; or at the Naval Supply
Center, Norfolk, that her service was not
useful and efficient. Indications were
always that her performance, attendance,
and behavior were more than satisfactory.
There was never any indication of be-
havior irregularities or manifestations
of unsatisfactory service, rather evalua-
tion of December 31, 1965, stressed "she
13
gets along well with her fellow workers
and with the officers for whom she works"
and "is currently being considered by the
Bureau of Public Affairs for a GS-8 posi-
tion. She has, in fact, been the respon-
sible shorthand reporter for nine of the
thirteen Department of State noon press
briefings held thus far this January 1966."
There was no certification that there
was no suitable position vacant for which
employee was qualified and willing to
accept in lieu of retirement. The Depart-
ment of State did not transmit the entire
file to the Civil Service Commission--only
such portions as would support its agency-
filed application for disability retirement.
Placing employee involuntarily on Leave
Without Pay without consent was detrimental
to the interests of the government.
The government erred in not providing
the Civil Service consultant, Dr. Kleinerman,
with clearances previously issued by the
Department of State on August 17, 1964,
December 8, 1965,
February 17, 1966,
July 22, 1966,
and October 12, 1966.
The government should not be permitted
to assign a Foreign Service Staff Secre-
tary to a position, the top salary of
which is less than that to which she is
entitled, and make no attempt to reassign
her to an appropriate position.
,
The government should not be permitted
to indicate on paper an employee is per-
forming GS-4 Clerk-Stenographer duties
14
ccna
A AR. tt
Sr ee | —
and require her to fill in at GS-6 desks
and serve for six weeks on a trial basis
as a GS-8 Secretary reporting news con-
ferences.
III. "CLEAN HANDS" DOCTRINE
Petitioner's case differs from that of
Chafin ve Pratt, 358 F.2d 349 (1966),
beGlasson Ve VeSe. 397 F.2d 303 (1968),
ScrQgeins Ye Vase, 397 Fe2d 295 (1968),
in that she s never accepted any money
for alleged disability and refunded,
after her wrongful dismissal, $429.29 to
the Department of State, which alleged
it had overpaid her, and is willing to
Waive money judgment.
Petitioner refused to collude in the
fraudulent nature of the examination by
Dr. Morris Kleinerman, the Civil Service
Commission consultant, who on November 9,
1966, found her totally disabled "About
Oct. 1964" at a time when she had been
cleared for unrestricted assignment to a
hardship post; for GS-8 Secretary, a
height she has never attained; for the
diagnosis of "Involutional Psychosis,
Paranoid Type-Competent" no sign of
which was visible during 55 deys of ob-
servation at Bethesda Naval Hospital as
of April 21, 1965.
The Statute of Limitations is tolled
by the evidence of fraud. It could not
begin to run before January 4, 1971, the
date when there might be chance of
successful suit.
15
EFFORTS TO INFLUENCE LEGISLATION
Petitioner was successful in having
Congresaman Whitehurst introduce on June
5, 1974, He Be 15230, A Bill to amend
Section 8347(c), Title 5, United States
Code, by deleting "The decisions of the
Commission concerning these matters are
final and conclusive and not subject to
review."
Petitioner wrote all Members of the
Committees on the Judiciary, Subcommittee
on Constitutional Rights, United States
Senate, and Post Office and Civil Service,
House of Representatives, on July 15, 1974,
Calling attention to the fact that S. 1688
introduced May 2, 1973, by Senator Ervin
Was open to abuse because an agency could
still force an employee--cleared by a
physician/psychiatrist--to see yet another
who may elicit information or authorize
tests "where such physician deems such
information necessary to enable him to
determine whether or not such individual
is suffering from mental illness."
Petitioner's studies have led her to
the Essentials of Fair Procedure (Due
Process), Appendix A-3, which emphasizes
the necessity of establishing "an ascer-
tainable standard of conduct (pertinancy)"
or a clear interpretation of "mental
iliness" or “unemployability."
Petitioner has been cautious in her
approach to the Supreme Court, observing
carefully the requirements for certiorari
as outlined in Ashwander v. TVA, 297 U.S.
288 (1936), Appendix A-4.
16
That Congress is not free to provide that
administrative determinations are final
and not subject to review without losing
its oversight responsibilities is indicated
po release of April 19, 1976, Appendix
REASONS TO GRANT CERTIORARI
Petitioner sincerely believes this
"appeal unto Caesar" is appropriate and
is grateful to live under a system where
it is possible. She has not been guilty
of laches nor siept on her rights, but
has continued to assert them as best she
knew how.
To use Judge Skelton's words in his
dissent, heGlasson ve UsS. at p. 327,
"To require .e. to overcome suppositions
and allegations like these, would be a
heavy, unfair, and improper burden indeed
for her to bear."
Attention is called to the discussion
of the constitutionality of the congres-
Sional and administrative decision to
provide no hearing before retiring a
federal employee for disability found in
t, 358 Fe2d 349 (1966) at
Pe 3576
Is Congress free to provide that the
administrative determination of purely
factual matters by the CSC is final end
not subject to review where there is
evidence of fraud?
17
CONCLUSION
For these reasons, writ of certiorari
should issue to review judgment of the
United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit and remand
of case to the Civil Service Commission
and the Department of State for such
investigation as will lead to appro-
priate reinstatement of petitioner, or
credit for time and money involved with
immediate appropriate pension.
wherefore, the premises considered,
petitioner believes there are special
and important reasons for justifying
grant of a writ of certiorari in this
case.
Respectfully submitted,
Lena Rosa Knecht Conley.
pro se.
18
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that three printed
copies of the Petition for a Writ of Cer-
tiorari were deposited in the United States
mails, first class, to:
Solicitor General,
Department of Justice,
Washington, De Ce 20530.
‘s
s / P
Lena Rosa Knecht Conley, ~
REQ sce
19
APPENDIX
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
LENA R. K. CONLEY, Civil
Action
Plaintiff, No. 74-654
Vv.
)
)
FILED
ROBERT E. HAMPTON, et a.) DEC 11 1974
)
)
James F. Davey,
Defendants. Clerk
QRREE
Upon consideration of defendants' mo-
tion to dismiss and the entire record
herein, and the Court being fully advised
in the premises, it is by the Court this
llth day of December, 1974,
ORDERED that defendants’ motion be,
and it hereby is, granted, and that the
action be, and it hereby is dismissed.
/a/ aubrey E. Robinson, Jr.
UNITED STATES DistRicl JUDGE
A-1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED - SEE LOCAL RULE 8('b).
United States Court of Appeals
For tne District of Columbia Circuit
(No Opinion)
No. 75-1057 September Term, 1975
LENA ROSA KNECHT CONLEY, Appellant
Ve
ROBERT E. HAMPTON, Cheirman and Commissioner,
Ue Se Civil Service Commission, et al.
Appeal from the United States District
Court for the District of Columbia.
Before: WRIGHT and BOBB, Circuit
Judges, and BRODERICK,* District Judge.
JUDGMENT
This cause came cn for consideration on
the record on appeal from the United States
District Court for the District of Columbia
and briefs were filed herein by the parties.
While the issues presented occasion no need
for an opinion, they have been accorded full
consideration by the court. See Local Rule
13(c).
On consideration of the foregoing, it
4s ORDERED and ADJUDGED by this court that
the judgment of the District Court appealed
from in this cause is hereby affirmed.
Per Curiam
For the Court
/s/ Robert A. me
Robert A. Bonne
Clerk
*Of the United States District Court for
the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, sitting
by designation pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 8292(da)
(1970). “Prtgp FEB 9 «(1976
A-2
1.
Ze
9
10.
ESSENTIALS OF FAIR PROCEDURE
An ascertainable standard of conduct
(pertinancy).
A fair accusatory procedure: The
grand jury.
Jurisdiction over the defendant
(notice).
A hearings.
A fair tribunal:
&@e An unbiased judce.
bo. A fair jury.
Ce No trial by newspaper.
ad. <A prosecutor who acts within
reasonable limits.
e. The assistance of Counsel.
f. <A public trial.
Freedom from unreasonable searches
and seizures.
Freedom from compulsory self-
incrimination.
Bail.
Due process and no cruel and un-
usual punishment.
Fair remedies after conviction.
A-3
2e
5s
6.
7e
THE SUPREME COURT
The Court will not pass upon the
constitutionality ina friendly,
nonadversary proceeding.
The Court will not anticipate a
question of constitutional law in
advance of the necessity for
deciding it.
The Court will rot formulate a rule
of law broader than the facts of the
case require.
If possible, the Court will dispose
of a case on nonconstitutional
grounds.
The Court will not pass upon the
validity of a statute on complaint
of one who fails to show injury to
person or property.
The Court will not pass upon the
constitutionality of a statute at
the instance of one who has accepted
its benefits.
Whenever possible, statutes will be
construed so as to avoid a
constitutional issue.
(Ashwander y. TVA (297 U.S. 288:1936))
A-4
sweeping proposal thet
ruies handed dowe by
08 the RA. width was quichty approved by the
was
snsane Sollasly Comite, omnald test eapetion os
Congress oversight responsibilities lost over the years as
rule-making depertments increased. "
yey ope
view will subject congressmen tical presmeve from
specialinterest gpgups. . Sn
Een
90 days to veto 2 rule proposed by a Sedainl agency, lnctad-
ing under certain circumstances rate Gecisions such as
those made by the Civil Aeronautics Board fer airtines.
A majority vote by eiher house wogld be needed to
wetunamle .- = POL.
The veto power would be retroactive to the Rint rufe
ever set by Anat goes back to 1968 when Can-
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.