Appendix — Bayside Enterprises, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board

Supreme Court brief1977

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court, ¥. S

PILE @ *

JUL 2 186

APPENDIX

MICHAEL RODAX, JR., C!

In the

Supreme Court of the Uniteh States

Octoser Term, 1975

No. 75-1267

BAYSIDE ENTERPRISES, INC.,

PENOBSCOT POULTRY COMPANY,

AND POULTRY PROCESSING, INC.,

PETITIONERS,

v.

NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,

RESPONDENT.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT

OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT

a

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED MARCH 8, 1976

CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 19, 1976

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Chronological List of Docket Entries ............... 1

Stenographic Transcript of Proceedings

cde hese ede eth a res etek ds owe’ 4

Testimony of :

Carl Fenwick, ............... Rs 5

Redirect ........ 7

Herbert Hutchins, ....——s—s.... ee 7

Voir Dire... 12

(Resumed), Direct.......... 13

Voir Dire....... 15

(Resumed), Direct.......... 16

Pee 24

Redirect ........ 34

Recross ........ 35

Examination... 35

Further Recross ........ 36

John E. Philips,............. Direct .......... 36

ae 38

Redirect... _... 39

Robert Desrosiers, ........... ee 40

ee 43

Redirect ........ 44

William Plamondon, ...... Tet 0600 eee 44

ME cca cde os cs 47

Redirect ........ 49

Robert Desrosiers, ........... SN ak-4s coon 50

Clarence McKenny, .......... Direct .......... 52

Larry McAuley, ............. eee 56

Clarence McKenny (Recalled), Direct.......... 58

Respondents’ Exhibit:

ES Peet k Ca VF eve POS Vive beep ceweneees —

il Table of Contents

Page

ey Me Does eh bane ea ai aes Bet a ae 62

NP er Te rrr yee 64

Administrative Law Judge’s Decision .............. 66

Employer’s Exceptions to the Administrative Law

Judge’s Decision and Request for Oral Argument .. 66

Decision and Order of the National Labor Relations

Rr oP oe eee POM Ry ery ee TT 77

Opinion of the United States Conrt of Appeals for the

ee Ee cs oe nh 6a eee ee eeebens 77

Decree of the United States Court of Appeals for the

RE oS Cc peya kun uuckwasaen PTE

Unirep States or AMERICA

BrErorE THE NATIONAL Lasor RELATIONS Boarp

Division oF JUDGES

Washington, D.C.

Case No. 1-CA-9721

Bayswe Enrerprises, Inc.

Penosscot Pouttry Company

Pouutry Processina, Inc.

and

Truck Drivers, WAREHOUSEMEN AND HeEupers Union,

Loca, No. 340 a/w INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF

TEAMSTERS, CHAUFFEURS, WAREHOUSEMEN AND HELPERS

oF AMERICA

CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES

3.26.74 Charge filed.

5. 3.74 Amended Charge filed.

5. 7.74 Complaint and Notice of Hearing, dated.

5.14.74 Answer of Respondents, dated.

6.20.74 Amendment to Complaint, dated.

6.21.74 Amended Answer to Complaint and Amended

Complaint dated.

6.26.74 Hearing opened.

6.27.74 Hearing closed.

9.24.74 Administrative Law Judge’s Decision issued.

10.15.74 Respondents’ exceptions to the Administrative

Law Judge’s Decision and Request for oral argu-

ment, received.

2. 5.75 Board’s Decision and Order, dated.

2

Unrrep Sratres Court or APPEALS

For THE First Crrcuit

Case No. 75-1070

NationaL Lasor Rexiations Boarp,

PETITIONER,

v.

Bayswwe Enterprises, Inc.,

Penosscot Pouttry Company, and

Povuttry Processine, Inc.,

RESPONDENTS.

No. BELow: 1-CA-9721

DaTE OF JUDGMENT: February 5, 1975

NorTice OF APPEAL FILED: [Application for Enforcement]

19

25

DOCKET ENTRIES

Application for enforcement filed.

Appearance of Alan Levenson for respondents

filed.

Petition to transfer filed by respondents.

Appearance of Eliott Moore filed for petitioner.

Order (Coffin, Ch.J.) transferring case to Fifth

Circuit upon motion of petitioner. Notices mailed.

File transferred to the Fifth Circuit along with

certified copy of docket entries.

Opposition of petition filed as a motion for re-

consideration. Order (Coffin, Ch.J.) setting aside

order of March 11, 1975. Notices mailed. File

returned from Fifth Circuit.

Order (Coffin, Ch.J., McEntee and Campbell,

JJ.) reinstating order of March 11, 1975 and

transferring case to Fifth Circuit. Opinion of

the Court per curiam. Notices mailed. File trans-

ferred to the Fifth Circuit along with certified

copy of docket entries.

16

17

Aug. 11

20

22

Sept. 4

25

29

Oct. 7

8

Dec. 10

22

1976

Jan. 6

Mar. 12

June 1

Record on transfer from Fifth Circuit filed and

case reactivated.

Certified list filed.

Motion filed. Order (Coffin, Ch.J.) enlargiag time

for filing brief for petitioner and appendix to

and including August 13, 1975. Notices mailed.

Appendix to briefs filed.

Certified record and two reproduced copies of

transcript of testimony filed.

Motion filed. Order (Coffin, Ch.J.) enlarging time

for filing brief for petitioner to and including

August 20, 1975. Notices mailed.

Brief for petitioner filed.

Certified copies of two pamphlets of U.S. Dept.

of Agriculture filed.

Motion filed. Order (Coffin, Ch.J.) enlarging time

for filing brief for respondents to Sept. 25, 1975,

and directing that case remain on October list.

Notices mailed.

Brief for respondent filed.

Assigned for hearing at the October, 1975 session.

Heard by Coffin, McEntee & Campbell, J.J.

Appearance of Robert A. Giannasi, filed for

petitioner.

Decree: The orders of the National Labor Rela-

tions Board are hereby affirmed and enforced.

Opinion of the court by Coffin, Ch.J. Notices

mailed.

Verified bill of costs filed.

Taxation of costs entered. Notices mailed.

Notice of filing petition for certiorari 3/8/76

(75-1267).

Order of Supreme Court allowing certiorari

5/19/76.

4

STENOGRAPHIC TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

[1] BEForE THE NATIONAL Labor RELATIONS Boarp

First Recion

Case No. 1-CA 9721

In the Matter of:

Baysiwe Enterpnuises, Inc.

Penosscot Poutrry Company

Pouurry Processine, Inc.

and

Truck Drivers, WaAREHOUSEMEN AND HeE.Lrers Union,

Loca, No. 340 a/w Internationa, BrorHERHOOD OF

Teamsrers, CHAUFFEURS, WAREHOUSEMEN AND HELPERS

or AMERICA

District Courthouse

Congress Street

Belfast, Maine

Wednesday, June 26, 1974

The above-entitled matter came on for hearing, pursuant

to Notice, at 10:00 o’clock a.m.

BEFORE:

Davi 8S. Davinson, Administrative Law Judge

APPEARANCES:

S. Anrnony DiCiero, Esq. National Labor Relations

Board, Region 1, 15 New

Chardon Street, Boston,

Mass., appearing as Counsel

for the General Counsel.

Daviw Couen, Esq., Law firm of Preti & Flaherty,

443 Congress Street, Port-

land, Maine, appearing for

the Charging Party.

4)

[2] Avan Levenson, Esqa., Law firm of Levenson and

Levenson, 187 Middle Street,

Portland, Maine, appearing

on behalf of the Respondent.

[18] CarL Fenwick

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the General

Counsel and, having been first duly sworn, was examined

and testified as follows:

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. Fenwick, would you state your

full name and address for the record, please? A. Carl

Fenwick, R.F.D. 1, Oakland, Maine.

Q. Are you familiar in any way with Fort Halifax Pack-

ing Company? A. Yes, I am.

Q. What is your capacity there?

° e e

[19] Q. Just briefly tell us what is Fort Halifax Packing

Company, Mr. Frenwick? A. It’s a poultry processing

company. It is involved in raising and processing poultry

in the State of Maine.

Q. And does Fort Halifax Packing Company have a feed

mill operation? A. No, it does not.

* e e

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Withdraw that question. Does Fort

Halifax Packing Company have chickens that are raised

by independent farmers around the State of Maine? A. Yes,

they do.

Q. Is Fort Halifax Packing Company obligated to supply

feed to those chickens. A. Yes.

Q. You have no feed mill operations? A. No, we don’t.

Q. From whom does Fort Halifax Packing Company get

6

its feed? A. We purchase our broiler feed from Penobscot

Feeds.

[20] Q. Do you know where that is located? A. Thorndike.

Q. Who delivers the feed? A.We have a contract hauler.

His name is Richard Hodges.

Q. And where is he from? A. Unity, I believe.

Q. Unity, Maine? A. Yes.

Q. Tell us what that operation involves. A. He picks

up feed at the mill in Thorndike and delivers it to our

farms throughout the area where we raise birds.

Q. Have you checked your records, and the records that

are with you today, can you tell us how many pounds of

feed Fort Halifax Packing Company has purchased from

the period January 1, ’73 through today? A. Yes, I can.

The amount purchased from January 1, ’73 through I think

it’s June 13 of this year is 120,000,000, slightly in excess of

that figure, 120.9 million pounds—I believe.

Q. Do you know what the total value in dollars was that?

A. Yes, that’s about $9.9 million dollars.

Q. And what percentage is that of the total feed require-

ments for Fort Halifax Packing Company? A. At the

present time it’s 100% of our broiler feed requirements.

We did have another source of feed, but I don’t believe

we’re using it presently. So I believe at the [21] present

time its 100% of the broiler feed.

Q. You get from Penobscot Feed in Thorndike, Maine?

A. That’s correct.

Q. Is there also something Fort Halifax Packing Com-

pany sells to the Thorndike mill? A. Yes, it’s a by product

of our poultry operation, offal and feathers.

* * o

[22] Q. Does Fort Halifax Packing Company have any-

thing to do other than as you have described, with Mr.

Hodge, the contract hauler? Is that an independent opera-

tion? A. Yes, sir, it is.

7

Q. It’s not a part of your company at all? <A. No, it isn’t.

o ® @

[26] Redirect Examination

Q. (By Mr. DiCiero) Mr. Fenwick, you were talking on

cross-examination and you mentioned a farm company and

a processing company. Fort Halifax Packing Company, is

that the parent corporation? I’m confused—do you have

different corporate names? A. We have two corporate

entities.

Q. What are they? A. Fort Halifax Packing Company

is the processing plant, and we have Fort Halifax Poultry

Company, which is the grower or the farm operation, the

operation on which we raise the birds on a contract basis.

Q. Are these two corporations, are they owned by the

same group? A. The poultry company is a subsidiary,

a wholly owned subsidiary of the packing company.

Q. So when you say that they sell birds to the processing

[27] company, there is actually a contract and they actually

pass money back and forth? A. We do write a check for

it, yes, sir.

Q. Is it part of your bookkeeping operations? A. Yes.

oe e oe

Judge Davidson: Do you know if there is separate man-

agement or common management?

The Witness: Common management.

a * o

[29] Hexrsert HvutcHins

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the Respondent

and, having been first duly sworn, was examined and

testified as follows:

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Hutchins, you are employed

by whom? A. Bayside Enterprises.

8

[30] Your office is where? A. 153 High Street.

Q. Could you tell us briefly, or not briefly, what Bayside

Enterprises is and what it does and all of the preparations?

A. Bayside Enterprises is a corporation that grows meat

poultry—broilers, roasters, capons and produces hatching

eggs from breeder flocks for production of the meat breed-

ers. To accomplish this, we operate a pedigree breeding

operation which is a grandparent operation and its basic

function is to select or breed lines of birds; they may be

cross-mated to produce the parents that produce the eggs,

broilers and roasters. With this function, they produce

breeding stock for themselves and they produce hatching

eggs for themselves, as well as buying hatching eggs from

other people when we don’t have enough.

Some of the production of this unit is sold to other

poultry companies, either breeding stock or hatching eggs.

After the eggs are laid or produced on the farm, they are

collected and moved to one of two hatcheries, either the

pedigreed breeding hatchery or a commercial hatchery,

which would produce the meat type chicks, broilers or

roasters.

The hatchery hatches these and moves them to growing

farms. We have somewhere around 139 farms that we

function with. A portion of these are company owned

operations. From here the birds are grown and fed feed

that we purchase [31] from Penobscot Feeds, or some other

location. We also buy feeds from other companies.

These birds are grown and they are sold to Poultry

Processing or some other persons. We sold some to the

person who was here this morning. We sold some in Canada.

[32] Q. Would you clear up this question for us about

who is who here—Penobscot Poultry and Poultry Process-

ing? A. Poultry Processing Incorporated is a corporate

9

structure that operates the processing plant and its pro-

curement system, which means the trucking operation at

this plant and out from the plant. And it has related oper-

ations like a garage that just functions as a supplement

to Poultry Processing.

The poultry is sold as Penobscot brand poultry and it

operates and does business as Penobscot Poultry Company.

Q. But who is it really? A. It’s Poultry Processing,

Incorporated.

e e e

Q. And what about this Penobscot Feed? A. Penobscot

Feeds is a feed milling operation that produces feed for

sale to Fort Halifax Poultry Company and for sale to

Bayside Enterprises.

Q. My question is, who is Penobscot Feeds? Is that a

trade name? A. Penobscot Feeds is a trade name; it’s

Poultry Processing.

Q. So is it a fair statement to say Poultry Processing

is both [33] Penobscot Feeds and Penobscot Poultry

Company? A. Yes.

* . a

Q. We'll let that pass.

You have spoken about the fact that you sold live poultry,

as a matter of fact, that’s all you sell is live poultry?

A. Yes.

Q. When end where does title pass? A. The live poultry?

Q. Yes. A. Live poultry is sold to Poultry Processing

or, in tonight’s case, to Fort Halifax Packing Company,

at the growing farm. And it’s loaded on trucks at that

point. The volume of the trade is determined when it’s

weighed on the scale, either in Belfast or in an agreeable

location. That’s when title passes.

Q. But in any event, Poultry Processing picks up the

poultry at the farms of Bayside, is that right? A. Yes.

10

Q. And the same with these other processing plants?

[34] A. What do you mean?

Q. Well, how do these other processing plants get their

live poultry? A. The processing plants pick the poultry

up on the farms, I believe.

Q. You said that the operation consists of two hatcheries?

A. Yes.

Q. One hatchery for pure bred? A. It’s a pedigreed,

grandparent type operation.

Q. Pedigreed birds and what is the other? A. It produces

meat-type chicks, broiler hatchery, breeder.

Q. Could you just give me a little detail about what

happens on these particular hatcheries? A. The breeder

hatchery serves as a part of a primary or base breeding

operation, and its function is connected with four or five

primary breeding farms which breed and select strains or

lines of birds. It could be that we’re breeding four strains

of birds, two on a male side and two on a female side,

so that you will produce four lines of birds to be mated

with each other to come out in the end with what we would

call a strain cross breeder.

A strained cross breeder is a type of breeder that is used

in the broiler or roaster production business. The function

of the grandparent operation with the primary farms, the

pedigree farms and the hatchery are to produce parent

[35] lines for the broiler and roaster operations.

Q. To do this, don’t you have to have somebody who is

an expert? A. Yes, we have a geneticist, Mr. Richard

Coscoe, and he has people that work for him that manage

the farms, plus a fellow that helps with the selection work.

Q. Selection of what? A. Selection of the basic breeders

and the traits they would like to select.

Q. So Mr. Coscoe works out which types of strains to

produce, is that a fair statement? A. He controls the

11

genetic composition of the strains through his selection

program and computer program and mathematical work.

e * o

A. The pedigree primary breeder operation was estab-

lished probably in 1948 by buying eggs or chicks of strains

from other breeders. Since this time its been basically a

closed operation where the selection has gone on within

these strains and the genetic rearrangement has gone on

within these [36] strains. At times, you might buy an

outside breeding stock to try to select or extract certain

genes out of the other strains and inject them into your

own. But basically it’s a straight closed strain breeding

operation and you get genetic rearrangements through

your selection.

Q. What about the other one? A. The commercial

hatchery?

Q. Yes. A. Its only function is to take in eggs and

hatch chicks.

Q. And they get the eggs from where? A. They get the

eggs from what we would call commercial breeder farms

or broiler breeder farms or roaster breeder farms, or they

might purchase the eggs from someone else. At times we’ve

purchased eggs from the gentleman who was here before.

Q. So you have breeder farms producing eggs? A. Yes.

Q. Would you tell us a little bit about those? You said

you’ve got 137— A. That includes the total farm oper-

ation, I believe. I believe we’re involved with 17 egg pro-

ducing operation, 6 of which are part of the operation

we just discussed and 11 produce eggs from breeding stock

that we have purchased from someone else or gotten from

our pedigree operation.

Q. So of the 136 farms you have 12 commercial breeders

and [37] 5 pedigree? A. Five or six, yes.

Q. Five or six pedigree breeding farms. That will make

approximately 119 farms. What goes on there? A. These

12

produce or grow broilers and roasters for Bayside Enter-

prises.

Q. What type arrangement do you have with these farms?

A. We have a growing agreement with the owners of the

firm which basically pays them for use of the facility, ser-

vices rendered.

Q. Mr. Hutchins, I show you this exhibit marked for the

purposes of identification, Respondent’s Exhibit 1, and ask

if you can identify it?

(The document above-referred to was marked Re-

spondent’s Exhibit No. 1 for identification. )

A. Yes, this is a Bayside Enterprises broiler-roaster and

capon production contract for agreement.

o * o

Voir Dire

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. Hutchins, is this a complete

contract? [38] A. Yes. The only thing that would be in

addition to this with the growers would be a specification

sheet and a management directive on how the birds should

be handled.

Q. And how about schedules for costs and so forth, isn’t

that usually a part of that? A. I guess I don’t understand

what you mean.

* a *

[39] Q. I’m saying a schedule of how it’s supposed to be

paid? A. You mean an explanatory type thing?

Q. That is correct, sir, yes. A. An example of how a

calculation would be made?

Q. Yes. A. ‘It might or might not be attached. It’s not

usually attached, no.

* o *

13

Direct Examination (Resumed)

[40] The contract states that medicaments or medicine—

what type of service, how does that actually work on the

farms? A. Bayside employs a broiler-roaster produc-

tion manager who has under his direction three or

four field supervisors which call periodically on these farms

on a routine basis or on a basis as the grower feels that

he has a problem and needs their attention. And he will

observe the particular case and, if necessary, transport

specimens to a diagnostic [41] laboratory and he and the

diagnostician or a veterinarian would prescribe what medic-

ament might be necessary.

Q. Is it a fair statement to say that if the flock gets sick

that some action is taken on your part? A. Yes.

Q. Would you tell us about what happens and give us

an example? A. If the serviceman or field supervisor

recalled or the parent rehad a case of clinical cocksidiosis,

which is a protozoan disease, he would recommend a thera-

peutic treatment for this which would be provided either

through the water or through diet.

Q. Does that require a different type of feed? A. Yes,

it would.

Q. On that subject, are there many different types of

feed? A. Yes.

Q. Would you tell us about that? A. Feeds are basically

formulated or designed nutritionally to fit the type of bird

in age that is being fed to, for example, let’s talk about

broilers. Feed is given to broilers, a feed from zero to

two weeks of age. Another feed from two to five or six

weeks of age, a different feed from six to nine weeks of

age, a feed for a period of time five days prior to slaughter

which is a different feed. And then, if they weren’t slaugh-

tered, and went beyond this point, they would [42] receive

14

a feed until 12 or 13 weeks of age and then a feed prior

to slaughter. The types of medicaments or additions of

drugs to feed are controlled by the food and drug regu-

lations.

. -_ &

Q. I know that there are many different ingredients.

How would you classify what goes into this feed? A. There

are several protein ingredients, animal protein ingredients.

There are vegetable protein ingredients plus [43] basically

energy sources which would be corn and yellow grease plus

minerals, vitamins, amino acids, trace minerals plus a

growth stimulator.

Q. Do you have occasion to change the formula for other

reasons than what you just listed? A. Yes.

Q. Would you tell us what reasons you might have to

change the formula? A. The formula would be changed to

meet different nutrient specifications which might be de-

termined by the strain of birds being utilized, by the age

of birds being utilized, by the general health situation of

the birds, by the temperature and by the availability of

these ingredients or substitutes and the price.

Q. Would the weather have anything to do with whether

or not you would change? A. Yes.

* * *

[44] Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Hutchins, would you ex-

plain to us [45] the set up with regard to the purchase

and the milling of the grain at the Thorndike Mill for

Bayside? A. Bayside Industries pays Penobscot Feed a

total milling charge for mixing a specified diet. Bayside

Enterprises purchases the inventory for such a formula on

the basis of your own projected requirement which is based

upon the number of birds and their age on the farm.

Q. So it’s a fair statement to say Bayside purchases the

major ingredient, which I suppose is the corn — A. Corn

and soy make up on this diet 80%.

15

Q. And in addition what about the medicine, who pur-

‘chases that? A. Bayside would purchase it.

Q. And the charges made against Bayside in favor of

Poultry Processing to mill it at the Thorndike mill, is that

the way itworks? A. Yes.

(The document above-referred to was marked Respon-

dent’s Exhibit No. 4 for identification.)

Q. | show you this piece of paper marked for purposes

of identification Respondent’s Exhibit 4 and ask that you

would identify it. A. This is a broiler, roaster, capon

feeding schedule effective June 3, 1974 and it specifies the

type of feed to be fed and the quantities of the various

agents of the birds [46] listed here.

s * ®

Vor Dre

_ a e

The Witness: Bayside Enterprises feeding schedule

bears the initials RLD, which is Robert L. Desrosiers,

who is a broiler meat production manager for Bayside

Enterprises. He decides what will be fed to these birds.

He sends a copy of this [47] to HCH, which is Herbert

C. Hutchins, general manager of Bayside.

He sent a copy to Richard A. Coscoe, who is the breeder

department manager and geneticist for Bayside. He sent

a copy of the letter to Russell Lord, who is Penobscot

Feeds manager. He sent a copy to Bayside dispatcher at

the feed mill.

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Who is what? A. William Pla-

monden, And he sent a copy to a service man which would

include four people not listed here which are broiler

roaster and breeder service men.

Q. Do you know each of those names?

a a eo

16

Direct Examination (Resumed)

[48] Q. It is important that a particular farm get the

right crumble pellets or mash. A. Yes, very important.

Q. Why? A. It’s very important when the birds are

young they get a pre-starter or a starter feed which carries

added fortification as far as vitamins and trace minerals

and the quality of ingredients, which is the higher priced

diet. And maybe a medicament if we have had a problem

in the breeder hatchery over [49] the breeding starts.

As the birds become progressively older, which is described

on this schedule, then the form of the feed and the com-

position changes.

Mr. DiCiero: By ‘‘this record’’ I think he is referring

to Respondent’s Exhibit No. 4.

The Witness: These changes are described on the left,

are changes in composition or formulation and nutrient

density as they go down the page. It is also quite important

legally that they get the right feeds because there must be

a withdrawal period here where no restricted component

is being fed to the birds before processing for human use.

For instance, this feed has a narcinical in it which cannot

be fed within five days of processing. And, if so, the birds

could be condemned.

[51] Q. Maybe it would be clearer if you could describe

what happens when a driver reaches a farm? A. When he

reaches a farm, he either drives or backs into the location

where he is going to discharge his feed, which might be a

single or multiple location, depending on where the farmer

tells him to put it. And he is supposed to put his boots on

and scrub his feet before he walks around the farmer’s

yard to hook up his equipment.

He connects the equipment and it’s an air delivery unit

17

or he raises the boom if it’s an auger delivery unit, and

then engages the power to discharge the feed which takes,

I don’t know, maybe 2-1/2 or 3 minutes per ton.

And when he has discharged his feed, he disassembles

his equipment that he had to set up, washes his boots in

this material and get back in his truck and goes to another

location, or back to the feed mill.

When he gets back to the feed mill presently he would

be washing the running gear and his truck with a disin-

fecting [52] solution.

eo es e

[53] Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Hutchins, you have men-

tioned previously that there are approximately 136 farms?

A. Yes.

Q. Where are they located? A. Over 2/3 of them are

in the Waldo County area, ali within an average of 12 to

15 miles from the feed mill.

Q. Mr. Hutchins, how many people are employed in the

processing plant, approximately? A. In Poultry Pro-

cessing or in the plant itself?

Q. Poultry Processing. A. Poultry Processing has got

almost — over 400.

Q. Over 400? A. Yes, I don’t know the exact number.

Q. As a matter of fact, Poultry Processing is unionized,

isn’tit? A. Yes.

Q. By that I mean, the qualified people in the processing

plant are unionized? A. Yes.

Q. How many people in Bayside Enterprises? A. Rough-

ly 80.

Q. Would it be closer maybe to 100? A. It could be.

[54] Q. Now with regard to the processing plant, does

ithaveamanagerf A. Yes.

Q. What’shisname? A. Gilbert Knight.

Q. That’s a name that has previously been mentioned.

And what is his function? A. His function today?

18

Q. Yes. A. He’s a production manager at the pro-

cessing plant which he supervises the foremen and threugh

the foremen, the employees that take the feathers off the

birds and remove the vicera and process the birds into a

saleable form.

(58! Q. You’ve said that there are truck drivers on

Penobscot Poultry Company, attached to it. There are

drivers that deliver the grain to the farm. Are there any

other truck drivers involved in Bayside. Let me put it

this way — are there truck drivers attached to the hatch-

eries? A. The breeder hatchery, I don’t believe we have

a truck driver per se attached to it, no. They have a

limited amount of transportation.

Q. Are there truck drivers attached to any other ele-

ment? A. The broiler hatchery would have operators of

two vehicles or two types of vehicles, the chick vehicle and

the egg vehicle. One would be refrigerated and the other

might be heated.

Q. And those designate Bayside on the side? A. Yes.

Q. Would you explain for the record the distances be-

tween these various locations? A. The processing plant

is on Cross Street, which is at the east end of Belfast and

offices on High Sreet, which is the other side of Belfast

on the west side of Belfast, the feed plant we’re discussing

is in Thorndike which is probably 22 miles, more or less,

to the west of here. And the hatchery is beyond this by

six miles, the big hatchery. The breeder hatchery, which

is Waldo, is four or five miles outside Belfast. The farms

are spread all over Waldo County.

[59] Q. Turning to the people employed in Bayside En-

terprises, could you give us somewhat of a breakdown as

to generally who they are? Would this be of any help to

you, this list? A. Yes.

19

Mr. DiCiero: Just a minute. What is that you just

gave him?

Mr. Levenson: It’s a list of the names and people at

Bayside.

[60] [{A.] The company owned farm managers would in-

clude Steinort, Bailey, Brewster, Hamm, Harriman, Man-

ning, Small and Smith. Farm employees, which would work

on farms or farm crews would be Betty Hamm, Shute, Ms.

Smith and Mrs. Steinort. Farm crews which move poultry,

grade the poultry, clean the poultry houses, company

owned poultry houses and sometimes other poultry work,

vaccination work and blood testing and do some of the

breeder selection work include a Mr. Riley, Hustus, Gibbs,

Reberts, another Hustus, another Riley, a Tibbetts and

two Tripps.

[61] Mr. Levenson: At this time I would like to offer

Respondent's Exhibit 5.

Judge Davidson: I receive Respondent’s 5.

(The document above-referred to, heretofore marked

Respondent’s Exhibit No. 5 for identification, was

received in evidence. )

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Hutchins, in your testimony

about Respondent’s Exhibit 5, you mentioned that there

were some employees giving blood tests. What does that

mean, giving blood [62] tests to who, chickens? A. Yes.

And the crew, that has to do with the farm crew. Poultry

is blood tested for certain transmittable diseases and these

crews wouid be involved in drawing the blood sample, sub-

mitting it to the testing laboratory in the Maine Depart-

ment of Agricultural, which is a part of the five disease

control program of the state.

Q. Do these crews go to all the farms? A. Those crews

— that particular crew would go to all the breeder farms

20

during the year and to all the farms that were raising

replacement pullets. And they might go to some of the

broiler farms if we had to vaccinate.

Q. As an ordinary course of conduct of the business,

do you vaccinate all poultry? A. If the condition varrants

it, yes. Right now, yes.

Q. And for that reason you have your own crew that

does vaccination, is that what you said? A. Yes. Well,

routine vaccinations, yes. If we had to vaccinate 3-1/2

million birds in a week, we’d have to hire some outside

heip.

Q. Does anyone do debeaking? <A. Yes.

Q. Who does that? A. One of the farm crews and the

hatchery.

Q. And they debeak all of your chickens, all Bayside’s?

[63] A. The chickens are either debeaked at the hatchery

or on the farm. |

Q. And for that purpose, you have a crew tHat does it?

\

A, Yes, \

e o e

Q. With regard to the delivery of the grain, you deliver

you said approximately how many times a week does an

average farm get a delivery of grain, of feed? A. It

would vary on some on the size of the bin that the farm

has or bins, the age of the bird and when they are to be

processed. We like to have bin capacity so feed is delivered

once a week, a full truckload.

Q. What is actually the case? [64] A. Both. Large

farms obviously would have bin space enough to handle

a weeks supply of feed, yet they would have binage for

more than one truckload. Small farmers a week’s supply

might be less than a truckload.

Q. Is it a fair statement to say that every farm receives

a Bayside grain truck at least twice a week? A. Probably.

21

Q. Is it probable that many farmers see a Bayside truck

more than once a week? A. A number of them would, yes.

Q. When a driver arrives at the farm, approximately

how long is he there, on an average? A. It will depend

on the size of the delivery, but the delivery time probably

runs between 2-1/4 to 3 minutes per ton. So if it was a 15

ton load, he might be there up to 45 minutes.

Q. How many farms does an average driver reach a day?

A. Well, last month we delivered 388 loads of feed, with

six or seven truckdrivers. So that means if it were six

truck drivers then that means it’s something like 58 loads

divided by 4, about 58 loads a week, so that means he’s

on three or four farms a day.

Q. Is it a five or a six day week? A. It’s hard to

answer. It depends on the weather, the number of birds °

you have and whether we had a problem in the feed mill

and they couldn’t produce feed. We try to have it a [65]

five day week.

e a 2

[66] A. Bayside operates feed trucks that have a capacity

of 14 to 22 or 25 tons. One is a tractor trailer unit. Two

of them are tandem axle bulk feed carrying units which

have aluminum bodies. One is a large tri-axle unit. These

have one function. They are a body that has a conveying

device on the bottom and some kind of unloading device,

either an air pump or audit, and they basically can be

used alone. They could be utilized to pick up some ingre-

dients, if it were necessary.

& ® 7

[67] Q. Why? A. You might have two types of birds

on a farm. If you’re raising capons, you could be sending

capon feed and broiler feed.

Q. Would it be important for the driver to know which

goes with which? A. Yes.

22

Q. What would happen if he made a mistake? A. Well,-,

if one of the feeds happened to be a drug feed, it could

get into the wrong birds, for instance, if it were on a

capon farm where we have capons and young birds that

are broilers, he could put our medicinal feed in the broilers

that were supposed to be taken off that farm tomorrow

morning and they would carry drug residue.

Q. Is it the function of the driver to be present when the

unloading operation takes place? A. He has to be, yes.

Q. What happens when one bin is empty if the farmer

isn’t there? A. The farmer would probably leave a note

for him or tell him which bin to put the feed into. On the

capon farm, for instance, the driver would have to get the

information from the farmer on which bin each type of

feed should go into.

e 7 o

[68] Q. When a flock, a group of birds, comes to maturity

and there is grain left over, what happens? A. Normally

it’s removed from the farm and taken to another farm.

Q. How is that done? A. You have a unit that come

pick up the feed, like a vacuum cleaner type deal and put

it inv a compartment of a truck, measure it and take it

to another farm.

Bs 2 e

Q. What kind of a truck dees that? A. It has a special-

ized accumulator and air lock to move the feed in the

opposite direction as when it was delivered.

Q. Is that one of the Bayside trucks? A. Yes.

Q. Is there any scale on the farms to measure how much

graincomesin? A. No.

[69] Q. How does the farmer know how much grain is

coming in? A. It’s weighed, the truck.

Q., And who weighs it? A. The dispatcher or the driver.

Q. The driver then is told to deliver it to a farm, is that

right? A. Yes.

23

Q. And how does the farmer know that he is getting

that? A. Bayside has two ways, or three ways, of deter-

mining when the feed should be delivered. Is this what

you want?

Q. No, what I asked is, how does the farmer know that

the amount that the driver is told to deliver is actually

what is being delivered? A. It’s a weigh ticket that goes

with the load.

Q. And that is given to t)e farmer? A. Yes.

Q. When the weigh ticket is given to the farmer, is any-

thing else given to him? A. (No response.)

Q. Would it refresh your recollection to say that a

sample of grain? A. Yes. Each load carries a feed sample

with it.

Q. Why? A. So that we have a back up sample in case

we have a preblem with the flock or the feed, and the

farmer has a sample [70] of the delivery.

Q. So the driver hands him not only the weighing ticket

but the sample of what he has given him? A. (Witness

nods)

[72] Judge Davidson : Why don’t we ask him what his

testimony is?

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) What is your testimony as to

how Bayside knows how much feed to deliver initially to

the farmer? A. When the birds are placed on the farm,

that’s when they [73] are a day old, the hatchery deter-

mines from a precalculated schedule that is developed

through experience with Bayside managers that it should

require this amount of feed of a certain type, and it is so

designated, basically on that schedule.

Q. The schedule marked Respondent’s Petu &%

A. That schedule is a condensation of a daily fee’ stuns

program.

24

Q. And subsequent to that time? A. This schedule here

is then used in conjuncture with an automatic calculation

of how much feed should be required if the farmer doesn’t

have enough feed he has to call in or send a message in

with the driver to the dispatcher that he is going to be

short. '

[79] Cross-Examination

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. Hutchins, do you hold any

office with Poultry Processing? A. How do you mean?

XQ. Well, you say you are general manager for Bay-

side. Are you perhaps vice-president of Poultry Process-

ing? <A. No. I hold no title in Poultry Processing.

XQ. But you do have authority over the plant manager?

A. Yes.

XQ. Bayside Enterprises is considered to be the parent

corporation, isn’t it? A. I believe so.

XQ. And the corporate officers for all three — two or

three, whichever you wish, corporations — that is, Bay-

side, Penobscot and Poultry Processing is 153 High Street?

A. Bayside and Poultry Processing?

XQ. Yes A. Yes.

* eo .

[80] XQ. There is a mill at Thorndike, correct? A. Yes.

XQ. And that mill supplies all of the feed requirements

for the birds which are ultimately processed by Poultry

Processing, is that not correct? A. That mill does not

supply all the feed requirements of [81] Bayside.

XQ. All right. What are the additional requirements?

A. We purchase feed from other locations.

XQ. About how much do you purchase from other loca-

tions? A. About 15% — 12% to 15%, as high as 20%.

XQ. And does that feed go directly to the mill? Is that

feed delivered to the mill? A. No, sir.

25

XQ. Where is that delivered? A. It is delivered to the

farms.

XQ. And are you talking about deliveries from KLF

directly to your breeder farms? A. And some meat farms.

o * -_

XQ. Your feed requirements for the breeder farms,

which you say are owned by Bayside? A. Yes.

XQ. Your feed requirements there are serviced by KLF,

is that [82] not correct? A. Yes.

XQ. And that is delivered specifically by KLF drivers,

is that not correct? A. Some of it is and some of it could

be dilivered by Bayside drivers.

XQ. What would the percentage be? A. I don’t know

at this point.

XQ. Well, is it not a fact that KLF drivers deliver most

of if not all of the feed requirements for your breeder

farms? A. They deliver the biggest majority of it.

s * *

[83] XQ. Do you buy feeds from anyone else other than

KLF? A. Not in recent years, no.

XQ. So that all goes to the breeder farms? A. How

recently?

XQ. Let’s go back a year. A. In 1972 we bought our

feeds from Ralston Purina Company.

eo s *

[84] XQ. Just a moment. I haven’t finished my question.

How many tons totally does Penobscot Feed mill produce

a year? A. Penobscot Feeds produce a year?

XQ. The Thorndike mill. A. Oh, approximately 120,000

tons.

XQ. 120,000 tons? Were you here when Mr. Fenwick

testified today? A. Yes.

XQ. He testified that in an 18 month period they pur-

chased — I’m sorry — A. He said about 40,000 tons.

26

XQ. I’m sorry, he put it in pounds and we’re talking

tons. Excuse me. You say that 120,000 tons of feed a year

is produced by the Penobscct mill — rather, the Thorndike

mill? [85] A. Somewhat in the neighborhood, yes.

XQ. And how much of that is sold, then, to third parties?

A. About a third.

XQ. Some of that goes to Fort Halifax, we’ve heard

that testimony. Who else buys feed from the Thorndike

mills? A. I believe only Fort Halifax.

XQ. Port Halifax buys about a third of your output?

A. Yes, sir.

[90] XQ. When did the mill in Thorndike open, when

was that mill? A. 1970 and ’71, I believe.

XQ. And after the building of the mill in Thorndike

Bayside then began to derive all of its — well, within the

grounds we talked about — its feed requirements, derive

its feed requirements from the Thorndike mill, is that

forrect? A. At the time it started to operate, it was pur-

chasing a bigger proportion from KLF than it is now.

XQ. It is not down to the proportions that you testified

to a short time ago? [91] A. Yes.

. * *

XQ. Now what about MidCentral Fish Company that

you mentioned earlier. Where do they fit into this? A. They

operated the Thorndike mill for a period of time.

XQ. Was that a corporation owned by Bayside? A. I

don’t know.

XQ. Was that in the corporate family? A. I believe so.

XQ. They operated the entire mill, didn’t they? A. Yes,

they did.

XQ. When was this? A. Well, if I recall correctly, it

was in 1972, part of °73.

XQ. This was right after it was built? A. No.

27

XQ. No? Who built the mill? A. Pine Safe Beef Com-

pany. }

[92] XQ. For their own use or for your use? A. They

built it for a lease.

XQ. To whom did they lease it tof A. Ralston Purina

Company.

XQ. And then how did Poultry Processing acquire ovu-

ership? A. Poultry Processing doesn’t own the mill.

XQ. Who owns it? A. Pine Safe Beef.

XQ. And Poultry Processing merely leases it? A. That’s

correct.

* * *

[97] Mr. DiCiero: On the record, Counsel for the Re-

spondent and Counsel here have, I think, resolved this.

Apparently, as I understand, we have a stipulation which

will satisfy and I will offer the stipulation as I understand

it.

That up until May 1, 1974, Poultry Processing, Inc.

operated the mill and owned all the feed. Of this, two

thirds of the feed was sold te Bayside and one third was

sold to Fort Halifax. After May 1, 1974, Bayside now

purchases its own ingredients and these ingredients are

delivered over to Poultry Processing, Inc. for milling, and

for which there is a charge, charge back on this.

Poultry Processing, Inc., then in its own name pur-

chases the remaining portion of feeds, which is then sold

off to third parties including Fort Halifax.

. e *

[98] Mr. Levenson: Your Honor, that is a stipulation

we would agree to.

Mr. DiCiero: One further thing. My understanding is

the purpose for this changeover was for purely corporate

accounting purposes, is that correct, Mr. Levenson?

Mr. Levenson: I would stipulate that Bayside Enter-

prises is on a cash basis. Poultry Processing, Inc. is on an

28

accrual basis. I think one of the reasons for it is that, as

I said, an accounting basis and it makes more sense that

way.

Judge Davidson: I take it both before and since May 1,

1974, the method of delivery has been the same, that there

is no change in terms of who delivered the feed?

Mr. Levenson: That is correct.

Judge Davidson: That stipulation is received.

o . s

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Now you testified, Mr. Hutchins,

that there are 109 grower farms — 119 farms, is that cor-

rect? A. Yes.

XQ. And I believe they are all farms with which there

is a contract similar to Respondent’s Exhibit No. 1, is that

correct? My question is, the 119 farms, are they all contract

farms, if you understand what I mean? A. Yes, Yes, they

are.

e o o

[99] XQ. I think you testified earlier that there is a

disease going around now, do they call it LT? A. Yes.

XQ. Is that the technical name for it? [100] A. Laryngo-

trachetis.

XQ. Now when there is a loss of birds, what actually has

Bayside lost? A. When birds are lost?

XQ. Yes. A. Bayside loses the investment they have in

the birds and the cost of sold items that have been delivered

te that farm.

XQ. What would the value of a bird be? A. At what age?

XQ. You say 74% to 9 weeks for a broiler. Let’s say a

disease develops in the 7th week, which would be almost

a full grown bird? A. If it developed in a full grown

bird today?

XQ. Yes. A. Probably $1.00.

XQ. It would be about $1.00. Now, what would be the

normal weight for a so-called full grown bird? <A. At

eight weeks or so?

29

XQ. Yes. Well, we’re talking about the same bird.

A. About 3.8 to 4.4 pounds.

XQ. Between 3 to 4 pounds, right?

Now if the bird died in, the seventh week, you say the

company had about a dollar invested in it. What does a

farmer make on a bird, full grown bird? A. It would vary

on his production — average on a broiler [101] about

2-3/4¢ to 2-8/10¢ per pound,

XQ. So that is around 10¢ per bird? A. That is correct.

XQ. How many birds does— A. Well, that’s not really

correct because you’re spreading it over the whole flock

base.

XQ. Isn’t that how you derive the $1.00 figure? A. Yes.

XQ. So if we are incorrect, if we are in error, we are

in error on both sides? A. The grower would get a portion

of the payment in most instances, even if that bird dies.

Q. What portion? A. Well, it’s in the contract. It would

be paid at the ratio of 1-22/100¢ and a little bit more

per square foot for period of occupancy, plus he could be

paid a bonus on a poundage.

XQ. All right, so if a full grown bird anco~t know we're

only talking about one bird—if a bird dies, the farmer

loses some money, doesn’t he? A. Only in relationship to

what the average loss is in the growing operation.

XQ. I thought we were talking about disease and an

abnormal situation that would take 1,000 birds at a time.

That’s an abnormal situation, wouldn’t you call it, or is

1,000 birds a [102] small amount. I don’t know. A. It

depends on how big the flock is. If it’s 50,000 birds,

that’s 2%.

XQ. All right. So let’s take 1,000 birds out of a 50,000

flock. The farmer has a substantial investment in those

1,000 birds, doesn’t he? A. At maturity.

XQ. Yes at maturity, yes. That’s exactly what we’re

taiking about, isn’t it. Se if a bird dies before he can

30

bring it to market or before it’s transported down here to

the processing plant, then he’s lost a substantial amount

of money, hasn’t he? A. He would lose a minor portion

of the investment, yes.

XQ. What do you mean a minor portion? A. Well, at

the ratio of about 2-1/2 cents to abeut 30 cents or 25 cents,

he has about 10%.

XQ. He’s lost 10%, is that what you’re saying? A. He

has abou. 10% of the investment in the birds.

XQ. Well, if he loses 1,000 birds. If you place 50,000

birds with that farmer, isn’t that how you figure it, place

so many birds with a farmer? A. Yes.

XQ. And then at the end of 7-1/2 to 9 weeks you go by

and you collect them and you count how many birds—you

clean out a flock at a time, don’t you? [103] A. Yes.

XQ. You don’t take half a flock today and leave the rest

for another two weeks or something, you clean out a flock

atatime? A. Normally, yes.

XQ. So you count up how many chickens he’s got left at

the end of 7-1/2 to 9 weeks, whatever it is, and that’s

what he’s paid on, isn’t it? A. No. He’s paid on the square

footage that he has plus a bonus on the pounds of poultry

he has produced.

e o oe

XQ. So if he’s lost 1,000 birds that would decrease the

total poundage, wouldn’t it? [104] A. It depends on what

his relationship of loss is to the rest of the growers.

XQ. Is that figured out each time? A. Yes, sir.

XQ. That’s how you figure your bonuses? A. His pay-

ment would be in relationship to his production costs with

the rest of the growers.

eo * o

[110] Judge Davidson: Let me ask you this, Mr. Hut-

chins. One thing that may be clear to Mr. diCiero but isn’t

clear to me. You have indicated that in computing the

31

bonus currently for farmers rausime flocks that have beem

affected by the LT disease there is an alternative method

of computing the bonus based wpon the performance of

the previous three flocks. Is that correct?

The Witness: That’s the method we use, yes.

Judge Davidson: Is that a method that is provided by

your agreement or is that something that you have agreed

upon apart from the written contract with the farmers as

a method of settling present problems?

The Witness: This is a method that we have devised to

keep the farmer from being injered in an abnormal loss

situation, which this LT is, which he may not have had

any control over, so that he wouldn’t lose his income

producing capability. On the LT situation we have basic-

ally accepted the risk here, totally.

Judge Davidson: Under your contract, however, I take

it under your written agreement with the farmer under

which he took the flock in the first place,.you had no

obligation to [111] settle this way, is that correet? —

The Witness: That’s correet. The contract was wriften

so he was in a normal operating situation with normel

mortalities, then his income would be influeneed by bs

capabilities.

Judge Davidson: Isn’t ineluded in what you are telling

me the inference that but for settling for the alternative

means of compensefimg the farmer, he would have sustained

a rather substantial Woes.

The Witness: Yes, hie would have.

Mr. DiCiero: Thank you.

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Who is Mr. Merle Weymouth?

A. He is an employee at the feed mill.

XQ. He is what? A. He is an employee at the feed mill.

XQ. Is he just am employee? A. Yes,

XQ. Does he not have a supervisery function of some

sort? A. Yes.

32

XQ. As a matter of fact, he’s in charge of the feed mill,

isn’t he? A. He works under the direction of Mr. Lord.

XQ. Mr. Lord is in charge of the feed mill? A. The

whole feed operation, yes.

XQ. And Mr. Merle Weymouth is under him? (112)

A. Yes.

XQ. And Mr. Merle Weymouth is an employee of what

corporation, sir? A. Poultry Processing.

XQ. Is it not a matter of fact, Mr. Hutchins, that these

drivers, these feed drivers, you say are employed by Bay-

side Enterprises, is it not a fact that they never come in

contact with the chickens, the birds? A. Yes.

XQ. They report to work at the feed mill, isn’t that cor-

rect? <A. Yes.

XQ. And they are given their assignments to make de-

liveries to the contract farmers. And they make these

deliveries and they, as you suggested either by an auger

method or a blow in method, make the deliveries to the

proper Iecation on the farm, correct? A. Yes.

XQ. And is it not correct that sumetimes they also

pick up feed at various lecations and deliver it back to

the mill at Thorndike? A. What do you mean various

locations?

XQ. Well, isn’t it a fact that if a driver ends up with

an empty bulk truck let’s say in Rockland that he might

pick up a load of grain at KLF down there and haul it

back to Thorndike rather than dead head. Isn’t that a fact?

[113] A. I wouldn’t think he’d haul mixed feed from—

XQ. Would he haul anything from Rockland? A. Occa-

sionally he might, yes.

XQ. Back to the mill at Thorndike? A. He might, but it

would be the exception.

XQ. It would be the exception. What about going down

to Gloucester, Massachusetts and picking up fish meal?

Haven’t Bayside drivers done that? A. Yes, they have.

33

XQ. And hauled that back to where? A. The ingredients

that were purchased in Gloucester, the fish meal, were

purchased by Bayside.

Judge Davidson: Where do they bring the fish meal?

The Witness: Fish meal is a storable item and fish that

was bought in Gloucester was bought by Bayside and

stored, at times, or sold at times to the feed mili operation.

[114] Judge Davidson: Well, physically they take it back

to the feed mill?

The Witness: Well, the majority of it was probably

not hauled back to the feed mill, no. It was hauled to

storage and used later.

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) As a matter of fact, sometimes

they go down in a tractor-trailer arrangement, don’t they

and bring it back that way— A. Yes,

XQ. They then come back—the driver might come back

and drop the trailer or the rig off here in Belfast at the

plant? A. He would probably not drop it at the plant, no.

XQ. Or at the storage facility? A. He would drop it

someplace where it could be unloaded, yes.

XQ. And eventually that would arrive at the mill, some-

where? A. Yes.

XQ. And who would take it from the storage facility to

the mill? A. Most of the stuff that was hauled from the

storage facility to the mill was hauled by truck.

XQ. Whose truck? A. I guess I can’t answer that hon-

estly. I assume it’s hauled by Bayside drivers.

XQ. By the way, I note in your listing of employees you

scratched off the name Edward Hodgeton. Is that because

[115] he is no longer employed there? A. Yes.

XQ. I am referring to Respondent’s Exhibit 5% A. Yes.

XQ. Tell us, what job did Ed Hodgeton have when he

was working? A. His job was a spare driver to haul

ingredients like fish mea} from storage.

34

XQ. Is that all he had to do? A. And he hauled some

poultry meal.

XQ. What is poultry meal? A. It’s a visceral by-

product.

XQ. Is that what they call PBM? A. Yes.

XQ. Is that not the end residue of the viscerating pro-

cess of the chickens? A. Yes.

XQ. And that’s collected at the processing plant in

Belfast? A. Yes.

XQ. And then is transported to the feed mill, is that not

correct? <A. Yes.

XQ. And that’s done by Bayside drivers? A. It’s done

by various drivers.

XQ. Well, all feed mill drivers, if you will? A. No.

[116] XQ. Who else besides Hodgeton did it? A. Hodge-

ton has done it for a time and Poultry Processing people

have done it.

e @ e

[124] Redirect Examination

e oe e

[125] Q. You mentioned the fact that if you were a

farmer, you would want to be there when the delivery

occurs, whether it’s night or day because it influences his

payment. A. Yes.

Q. Would you explain what you mean by that? A. Well,

the bonus system is based on production cost and feed

represents somewhere between 60% and 70% of the input

in that. So since it represents such a big part of it, I guess

I would want to check and see I got the feed I was supposed

to, and if the bins were full.

a +s 2

[127] Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mention has been made of

KLF. Is KLF a farm cooperative? A. Yes. It’s a farmer

owned cooperative.

35

* o eo

[128] Recross-Examination

se a e

[132] XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Is that correct? Has

Mr. Hodge, an independent contractor, has he not made

some delivery of feed to contract growers for Bayside

since December, 1973? A. Yes, he and other people would

make deliveries when we have an equipment problem, since

we only have three trucks.

XQ. You hire these on a need basis? A. When we have

a breakdown we would utilize them. We have an option.

We might utilize someone else, which we have.

s s

Examination

Q. (By Judge Davidson)...

e e

[133] Q. Now do you know what percentage of the chickens

grown by Bayside went to Poultry Processing for process-

ing? A. The exact percentage, no, but the majority.

Q. When you say majority, it is somewhere slightly in

excess of 50% or— A. Slightly less than 100%.

8 e S

[135] Q. When discussing the drivers, you said they were

responsible [136] for the sanitation of the truck and the

sanitation practices on the farm. Would you tell me what

you meant by that? A. Well, they could be the vehicles

of transmission of communicable disease for poultry from

the fact that they could track it on their feet or on their

clothing and equipment. They are under directives to clean

this equipment on the farms to try to eliminate as much

chance of it as possible.

Q. Clean which equipment? A. Well, I’m not sure

whether they scrub their feed pipe or not. And when they

36

are back at the plant, they are responsible for washing

the running gear on the truck so there is less chance of

transfer.

Q. By sanitation on the farms you mean—- A. Only in

relation to the feed delivery.

Q. Only in relation to their own equipment? A. Yes.

@ os —

[139] Further Recross Examination

8 e o

[140] XQ. He reports to you as well. Do you have super-

visory management responsibility over the operations of

Bayside Enterprises and the two aspects of the Poultry

Processing Incorprated business, is that correct? A. Yes.

XQ. And you, in turn, report to— A. Mr. George

Lewiston.

® @ *

[141] Joun E. Pxuuiuips

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the Respondent

and, having been first duly sworn, was examined and testi-

fied as follows: |

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Your name is— A John EF.

Philips.

Q. And what is your position? A. Controller.

Q. You are controlier for both Bayside Enterprises and

Poultry Processing, Inc., is that right? A. Yes.

Q. Now, Bayside Enterprises—the testimony has been

that Bayside Enterprises selis the chickens or the poultry

to Poultry Processing, Inc. at the farms, is that correct?

A. Yes.

Q. Now how do you handle that transaction? A. The

flock records which report the cost of the items that go

37

into the flock, such as the contract payment and the feed

[142] and the fule is accumulated on a flock sheet. These

flock sheets are accumulated for the month and totalled,

and chis total plus a figure for administrative expenses,

and a margin percentage is added to this cost, which then

becomes, so to speak, the invoice wherein Bayside Enter-

prises invoices the poultry to Poultry Processing.

Q. Now Poultry Processing mills the grain, your testi-

mony is Poultry Processing mills the grain that belongs to

Bayside, is that correct, as of May 1? A. Yes. Poultry

Processing mills the grain for—well, it does all of the

grain milling.

Q. Now, how do you handle that transaction between

Poultry Processing and Bayside? A. The milling of the

grain is handled on the basis of a fixed cost per ton charge.

Q. So that you make a charge against Bayside?

A. Correct.

Q. Now are there any other items like this with regard

to charge off against Bayside or Poultry Processing?

A. In each company we have certain warehouse or supply

areas which have certain supply commodities and in some

eases the use of which would be common to both companies.

Now, for instance, there could be disinfectant at our ware-

house purchased by Bayside Enterprises in the warehouse

by them, and mainly used by them. In certain cases the

processing plant or [143] Poultry Processing would need

some of this, in which particular case we would invoice

them so much of this. We have fuels, gasoline and diesel

fuel. In some cases, some of these tank inventories are

purchased by and owned by Poultry Processing. If these

were used by Bayside vehicles, then this becomes part of

our fuel allocation wherein this is charged over.

Correspondingly, it is possible that some of Poultry

Processing’s vehicles could be drawing fuel from Bayside’s

pump, in which case there would be an allocation over.

38

Q. Now is there a charge against Poultry Processing

or Bayside for Mr. Hutchins’s services? A. The allocation

of the administrative people, so to speak, is done by the

public accountant at year end. We go over the general

standard of what the office has done for the year and

whether it is consistent with previous years and so forth.

He interprets what shall be the allocation, if any, and I

don’t know—I don’t see it beyond that so I don’t know.

Q. Am I correct in saying that the basis of what you

have testified there is a conscious attempt by you to sepa-

rate the expenses of the one against the other? A. Yes.

. ao 7

[145] Cross-Examination

[147] XQ. Now in any of these transactions involving

the transfer or the sale of chickens to Poultry Processing,

does any money actually change hands? A. Yes.

XQ. How is that handled? A. By writing checks.

XQ. By writing checks for the transfer of funds from

one checking account to the other? A. Well, you call it

transferring. In a sense, to me it’s two corporations.

You have two cash receipts books, two cash disbursement

books. Through disbursements here you’re writing the

check to, let’s say if this was Poultry Processing, you’re

writing a check to Bayside Enterprises Corp. Correspond-

ingly, the clerk handling cash receipts at Bayside Enter-

prise would handle it like any normal check.

XQ. Are they both signed by the same person? Who signs

the Poultry Processing check? A. Who signs them? The

check signers are myself, Clayton Downer, Herbert Hut-

chins, Bernard Lewis, George Lewis and David Lewis.

XQ. Who are the check signers for Bayside Enterprises?

A. They are the same people.

a . y

39

XQ. And all of these corporations, I believe you testied,

are under the control of the Lewis’, is that correct? I can

go down through all of them: Bayside, Poultry Processing,

[148] and so forth? A. Yes.

7 * .

XQ. Are you aware of a checking account open in the

name of Penobscot Poultry Company? A. Penobscot Poul-

try Company is a trading name for Poultry Processing,

Inc. Poultry Processing, Inc. trades as Penobscot Poultry

Company.

[151] Redirect Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Philips, you have testified

about various corporations and, as I understand it, Cum-

mings Brothers is a feed wholesaler, is that right? A. To

my knowledge.

Q. Cumiaings Cold Storage and Riverside Freezer are

freezer companies? A. To my knowledge.

Q. What else was there? A. Coastal Fisheries.

Q. What are they?’ A. To me they are a fish processing

plant.

Q. All of those companies have the Lewis’s as president

and treasurer?

Judge Davidson: Well, I’m not clear, and I’m not even

sure if it’s necessary, but did you indicate they were

separate corporations or that they were operating divisions

of Poultry Processing?

Mr. Levenson: I stand correct. =e did say that, and

instead of using the word ‘‘corporations’’, I should have

used the word ‘‘divisions.’’

[152] Judge Davidson: Is that what they are?

The Witness: These are divisions of Poultry Process-

ing, Ine.

40

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) So they do all of these different

things that you have specified? <A. Yes.

Q. And they all have Bernie Lewis as president and

David Lewis as treasurer? A. To my knowledge, yes.

. * +

[153] Rosert DEsrRosIERS

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the Respondent

and, having been first duly sworn, was examined and testi-

fied as follows:

[154] Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Desrosiers, would you tell us

your full name, address, and what the nature of your job is?

A. My name is Robert J. Desrosiers. I live in Hope, Maine.

I am employed by Bayside Enterprises as a broiler depart-

ment manager.

Q. Would you tell us what that job entails? A. It in-

volves being in charge of growing poultry. From the stand-

point of growing I mean poultry grown for the prime

purpose of meat production. It involves the health of that

poultry, and the scheduling of feed programs and so forth.

Q. In the course of your job performance, do you have

occasion to communicate with the farmers, the contract

farmers? A. For the most part yes, that’s correct.

Q. And what is the manner of your communication?

A. I function as the manager of what has been referred to

as the service men or field supervisors. As the manager

of that department, which is referred to as service depart-

ment, I am in close relationship with the growers, and the

scheduling of poultry onto those farms. I initiate the

scheduling of feed programs onto those farms. I am in

charge of the poultry health on those farms.

.

41

[156] Q. I’m sorry to belabor this point, but would you

tell us what type of requirements you require with regard

to feed distribution, as far as sanitation goes with your

drivers? A. I’d have to go back to the intent of the letter

to begin with. First of all, we make an attempt to enlighten

our growers as to the problems in regard to the spread of

disease. The first paragraph would indicate how many

breaks we’ve had, in what areas.

And then it goes on to outline what areas of sanitation

procedure that we, as a company, have set out for our own

people, which includes feed delivery truck drivers who

carry out strict sanitation methods. ‘‘The truck under

carriages will be sprayed between loads,’’ in that very first

letter.

Hopefully, if this isn’t being done, it would be reported

back to me from a grower who would or might observe it.

And we would make sure the correct procedure is taken

care of and it’s done on the next trip.

Q. You ask the grower to report to you any violations

in sanitation practices? A. Yes, in essence. In fact, I’m

not sure but one of these letters—in one letter I did write

and asked them to report to [157] me if these practices

were not being carried out.

Q. Now mention was made in previous testimony about

a sample of grain that gets distributed to the farmer with

each delivery. Would you tell us what the exact function

is with regard to sanitation, if it has any? A. Well, not

in the area of sanitation. It would more likely be in the

area of contamination. Should there be a contaminant in

the feed, we would have that sample to fall back on in order

to pinpoint the day in which the ingredient might have

gotten into that particular day’s feed.

In other words, we can go back and trace if we have

a sample. There is also a follow up sample in the feed mill.

42

From the standpoint of sanitation, I would think it would

function more in the area of contamination.

Q. Now with regard to the grain itself, much discussion

has been made on the approximate ingredients of this cer-

tain amount of grain.

Q. Do you regard the grain itself as an agriculture

product? A. Absolutely. It’s a source of protein.

7 * ”

[159] Q. Does the driver have any obligation to prevent

any of the moldiness or wetness or mixing that you just

spoke about? A. Yes. He has a lot of responsibility other

than that of a driver. He gets onto the farm, for instance,

and let’s say it’s snowing real hard or raining. When he

goes up on the top to open the shute, to be certain the bins

are empty, he will only open one at a time, as opposed to

all of them on a good day.

Disease control, with regard to LT, for instance, might

be another area. He wants to put his truck in a specific

area, knowing full well that he can suck with his cyclone

at the base of the truck, can actually suck the virus, should

it be there, out of the buildings from the fan operations

up through the truck and contaminate another farm from

the interior of the truck.

They are guided in this area by the dispatcher and the

mill supervisor. ,

* * *

[160] Q. Why doesn’t Bayside use Hodges on a regular

basis rather than its own truck driver?

* 2 -_

A. Yes. With our own people delivering feed on our

farms, we have control in regard to sanitation, where those

vehicles have been prior to the delivery of feed they are

now making. [161] Whereas, with Hodges, Dick Hodges

I believe his name is, we do not have that control. We don’t

know where that vehicle has been prior to delivering one

43

of our loads and we feel in the area of sanitation control,

disease control, rather, we just can’t chance that situation.

* * *

[162] Q. (By Mr. Levenson) How much of the time of

the drivers is spent on the farm and how much on the road?

A. I would have to estimate probably 50% based on the

average mileage to and from our farms.

Q. You say 50% on the farms, 50% on the road, is that

your testimony? A. Yes, I would estimate that.

* * .

[164] Cross-Examination

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. Desrosiers, it is your duty,

then, you have direct contact with the contract farmers,

isn’t that right? A. Yes, sir.

XQ. Is it up to you to get new contract farmers as needed

and evaluate the ones you have, and that sort of thing?

A. Yes, sir.

XQ. Do you have anything to do with the hiring or the

firing or the directing of the feed drivers? A. Not directly.

XQ. You don’t give them any orders? You don’t tell

them where to deliver things? A. I do not.

XQ. I think your testimony was on Respondent’s 6 and 7

that you give some general instructions on making sure

that certain disease control measures are taken care of?

[165] A. This would be through the supervision at the

feed mill.

* o *

[166] XQ. These feed drivers—strike that. Hodges, when

he is being used as you explained why he is not—when he

is being used, essentially does the same thing as the feed

mill drivers do, doesn’t he? A. Yes.

XQ. And that’ll all he does, he delivers the feed grain?

A. Yes.

XQ. And you say that the drivers spend about, you esti-

44

mate [167] that they spend about 50% of their time on

the farm and 50% of the time on the road? A. That’s

correct.

XQ. Now somewhere in there they have to spend some

time in the mill, don’t they? A. Yes.

XQ. So the percentages probably would have to be cut

down on both ends, wouldn’t it? A. Probably.

*

[168] Redirect Examination

A. The driver has in each vehicle a foot pan that’s like

a 12 quart pail. He has a bottle of a base disinfectant.

He has [169] a water bucket and a sprayer, which he

uses in the function of his sanitation procedures.

Q. And that’s in each truck? A. In each vehicle.

[174] WILLIAM PLAMONDON

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the Respondent

and, having been first duly sworn, was examined and testi-

fied as follows:

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Would you please give your full

name, address and your position? A. William Albert

Plamondon, City Point, Belfast. A:d I am a dispatcher

for Penobscot.

Q. Mr. Plamondon, is it a fair stateneut—how many feed

drivers are there? A. There are six.

Q. And there are two shifts? A. Right.

Q. When do the shifts begin and end? A. Three to one

and from one to usually nine or when the feed is finished

delivering.

45

Q. You have to tell me, morning or afternoon? A. Three

in the morning to ‘one that afternoon. Then from one to

nine o’clock that night.

Q. Does each driver regularly haul to the same farm?

[175] A. No.

Q. What is the practice? A. If a driver comes in and

if the farmer isn’t out of feed or something, I give him this

list and they go to that farm. They don’t go to the same

one all the time.

Q. Who is Mr. Weymouth? A. He is in the mill, super-

visor.

Q. And what is his principal function? A. He is in

charge of making sure that the feed is made.

Q. What is your principal function? A. I take care of

the farms and make sure that the feed is delivered to the

farms.

Q. In the course of your duties, do you ever have contact

with Mr. Desrosiers? A. Right. He tells me if there is

any change in the schedule or something comes up, he tells

me. Like the servicemen, they tell me what to do, like

medication or something like that. I am in touch with him

most of the time.

Q. How many times a day do you get in touch? A. Exact

amount I don’t know, but at least 10 times, sometimes, or

vice versa.

Q. Could you explain a little bit what the telephone

conversations are about so we understand? A. If they

don’t pull a flock the night they’re supposed to, he’ll tell

me that. They need a little bit more — and he [176]

usually tells me the amount, how many he’s going to pull

on one floor, or vice versa. He’ll tell me ‘‘deliver a ton’’

or something like that, whatever it is.

Q. When you say deliver, you are talking about feed?

A. Right.

46

Q. Do you have contact with the hatchery? A. Right.

The hatchery, they make what we call a placement sheet.

It gives me a week’s advance of what chicks are going

in the following week. And I line it up, when they’re sup-

posed to get their feed, and then I take care of the schedule

from there on what type of feed to deliver to them. And,

like I says, if something happens I call the farmer and

ask if he’s ready or something like that.

Q. Do you tell the truck drivers which farms to go to?

A. Right. Usually the slip does. We have slips and the

name of the farmer is right on there, and they’ll go to

that farm.

Q. Do you make up the slips? A. Right.

Q. Besides the contact with the hatchery, do you have

any contact with field supervisors? A. You mean service-

men?

Q. Right. A. If a flock is sick or something, they’ll

usually call me and tell me what kind of medication to put

in. Or if there’s [177] trouble or something, or mainly

sick birds or something like that, he’ll tell me what kind

of feed to put in.

Q. Mr. Plamondon, were you a former truck driver your-

self for Bayside? A. Right.

Q. Who loads the trucks, Mr. Plamondon? A. If I have

the time, I load them, or the drivers will load them. And

most of the drivers know where the bins are. On top of

the slips I put the bin number. We get them in letters;

A and B is a certain type of feed and so on.

* * *

Q. Mr. Plamondon, do you have any function with regard

to feed samples on the farms? I understand that there is

a feed sample picked up by the truck driver? A. Right.

Every day I take these samples on every type of feed that

goes out of the mill. And the driver, of course, has a sample

47

for the farmer. And if there is something wrong with the

feed or something happens, we have a sample to go back to.

Usually if something happens it takes a little while, so

I have she'ves downstairs where [ have the samples saved

for a [178] certain length of time with a date on it on

when it was pulled out of that mill.

Mr. Levenson: I have nothing further.

Cross-Examination

XQ. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. Plamondon, who is your

supervisor? A. Herb.

XQ. Herb whot A. Herb Hutchins.

XQ. Herb Hutchins is your supervisor? A. Right.

QX. Is Herb Hutchins at the mill every day? A. No,

not every day.

XQ. Who is your supervisor day-to-day? A. Day-to-day

Merle Weymouth.

XQ. Merle Weymouth tells you what to do? A. No.

Well, if something comes up like he wants to change or

something, like on a truck or something, he does. But day

to day work, I take care of it.

XQ. When the truck drivers—when I’m talking about

truck drivers, you know who I’m talking about? A. Bay-

side.

XQ. The feed mill drivers? A. Right.

XQ. When they want some time off or they’re not going

to be in for some reason or other, looking for a vacation

er something, [179] they check with Merle Weymouth,

don’t they? A. No. They check with me, sir.

XQ. And then you check with Merle Weymouth? A. No.

Usually, on vacation or something, we have a chart and

then I get their pay lined up and all, and I make the

arrangements to take someone’s place when they’re on

vacation.

48

XQ. Who do you make the arrangements with? A. With

the drivers, with the other drivers or something like that.

We run two shifts. Now an afternoon shift has a week off

or vacation, usually that driver I ask them to come in at 7.

Or sometimes he will run a long shift. It all depends on

how much feed is going out that day.

XQ. So you have to check with Merle Weymouth first,

don’t you? A. No.

XQ. You don’t check with Merle Weymouth? A. No.

XQ. You don’t bother to find out how much, what orders

or anything like that? A. You see, the way it’s set up is

I have a book and I have the farms, and I have a small

filing cabinet. And we are on an automatic system, so I

know exactly when that farmer should run out of feed.

So I put him down on the following week, and I keep a

record. That’s the way I keep my records and I know what

type of feed that farmer should get. And that’s the way

it’s run.

[182] XQ. Is it more usual that the driver loads the truck

than you? A. If I’m busy, they usually load it, but if

I have time like if we have to empty a bin or something,

I help them, [183] because usually we like to get them out.

What I do is I clean them out.

XQ. In other words, you bang on the sides to make

sure the feed falls down? A. Right.

XQ. But most of the time, doesn’t the driver himself

go out and load the trucks? A. Like I said, right, sir.

XQ. Isn’t that a faet, that’s a majority of times, isn’t

it? A. It all depends. I can’t say a majority of the time

because I go out as much as I can. But, like I say, if I’m

busy or if I’m figuring something and a truck comes in,

I give the driver the slip and, like I says, the bins are

marked and they load the truck.

49

[185] A. One time we used to deliver our own farms,

breeder. But we don’t do that because KLF takes care of

it now.

XQ. KLF takes care of the breeder farms now?

A. Right. But, like I says, those are our own farms. We

used to do it at one time. I don’t know how long ago.

It was quite awhile ago.

XQ. Insofar as the hatchery, the only contact that you

have with the hatchery is for them to let you know how

many chicks are going to be placed on farms, isn’t that

right? A. Right. Unless there is a change, they’ll notify

me they’re going to take something off and put something

else in its place, or something like that. But they give me,

like I says, a weeks advance on what birds are going to be

placed that week.

XQ. So you will know when to start deliveries to the

contract farm? A. Right.

XQ. These drivers don’t make any deliveries to the

Hatcheries? A. No.

XQ. There’s no feeding at the hatchery at all, is there?

A. As soon as the bird is born, out it goes, and the feed

is waiting for it at the farm.

® eo *

[186] Redirect Examination

Q. (By Mr. Levenson) Mr. Plamondon, do you have an

indiyidual office at the mill? A. Right.

Q. And does Mr. Weymouth have one? A. Yes, he does.

[188] Rosert Desrosiers

was recalled as a witness by Judge Davidson on behalf of

the Labor Board and, having been first duly sworn, was

examined and testified as follows:

50

Direct Examination

Q. (By Judge Davidson) I would like to show you what

has been marked as Respondent’s Exhibit 7 and ask you

to look specifically at Paragraph C, with the letter C in

front of it. Please read it to yourself.

Would you tell me now what that refers to? A. O.K.

It refers to pick up crews that are part of the poultry

processing group. In other words, when we have to pick up

poultry to get it into the plant —

Q. That’s the finished bird? A. That’s the finished

bird, ready for marketing. And what this refers to is the

fact that these people are using the same precautions that

have been discussed in regard to the truck drivers, serub-

bing of the boots and they are wearing laundered cover-

alls. In other words, these coveralls are [189] laundered

every day and the boots, for that matter, are laundered

every day. They go right through a washer and a dryer

system, rather than take the chance of them contaminating

a farm from something we didn’t know about the day

before. These people are into coveralls and boots to elim-

inate chances of contamination.

Q. Do they also wash down their trucks and take precau-

tions of that kind? A. In the case of the routine farm

where there is no known Laryngotrachetis, that truck is

sprayed every day before it leaves the plant, and it goes

to dispatch unit and from the dispatch unit it goes to the

farm without first being sprayed. However, in the case of

a known place, the truck is broken down and washed,

every coop is washed individually and they actually pin-

point the crews.

In other words, we’ve got people that separate flocks.

That crew never goes near an LT flock. We call it Lt —

it’s easier than Laryngotrachetis.

51

Q. Where do those crews work, at the plant, or are they

out at the farm? A. They generate out of the plant.

They are called pick up crews.

Q. And they go from the plant to the farm? A. That’s

correct, but they don . work in the plant. They merely

pick up poultry.

{190} Q. Are they Poultry Processing? A. I believe

they are Poultry Processing.

Q. The procedure described in Paragraph C, is that a

retained procedure that goes on all the time, or is it a

special procedure? A. As you know, the letter was written

in regard to the control of Laryngotrachetis. This was not

a routine procedure. A portion of this, the washing of the

boots, and using the foot pans is normal and routine.

However, this is extraordinary circumstances.

4 a e o

Mr. DiCiero: The stipulation that I offer is that the

[191] roaster and broiler pick up crews described in Re-

spondent’s 7, paragraph C therein, are employees in the

bargaining unit represented jointly by the Teamster Local

340 and the Amalgamated Butcher’s Union Local 385.

Mr. Levenson: I would be agreeable to that if part of

the stipulation is that you also agreed Mr. Desrosiers has

a farm group and is therefore concerned with the health

of the farm group and with running the farms.

Mr. DiCiero: Why do I have to stipulate to that? He

has already testified to that?

Judge Davidson: I think that is clear from the exhibit

itself.

Mr. Levenson: All right, to that extent it is clear.

Mr. DiCiero: You will stipulate that these pick up

crews that we talked about in paragraph C are repre-

sented jointly in that bargaining unit?

e

52

CLaRENCE McKEenny

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the General

Counsel, and having been first duly sworn, was examined

and testified as [192] follows:

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. McKenny, would you state

your full name and address? A. Clarence William Mce-

Kenny, R.F.D. 2, Thorndike, Maine.

Q. Mr. McKenny, were you formerly employed at the

Thorndike mill at Penobscot feeds? A. Yes, I was.

Q. When did you stop working there? A. It was just

a few days before Christmas. It was in December of ’73.

Q. When did you start working at that location — you

know what I’m talking about, the Thorndike Mill? A. I

worked there abovt a year and a half, somewhere around

May of ’72.

Q. And who was your employer at that time? A. My

employer?

Q. Yes, who was signing your checks? A. At that time

it was Mid Central Fish.

Q. Now what were you doing there at that time? A. I

was unloading cars out back, grain cars.

Q. Grain cars? A. Ingredients like gluten, fish meal,

stuff like that.

Q. Now did there come a time while you were so em-

ployed that you had a conversation with Mr. Merle Wey-

mouth about continued [193] employment? A. Right.

Q. Now about when did this take place? A. It was

around July or August.

Q. Of ’72?

[198] Q. (By Mr. diCiero) When you became a driver,

a feed mill driver, did you speak to anyone else other

53

than Mr. Merle Weymouth about this job? A. No, I

didn’t.

. * .

Q. What were you duties as a feed mill driver? A. When

I first started, I was on the night shift and we would go

in at one o’clock —

Q. That’s one o’clock in the afternoon? A. Right. And

we might work until eight o’clock, or we might [199] work

until one o’clock in the morning. You never could tell.

It would all depend on how much grain was left to haul.

And we’d go in, get the trucks, sometimes it was loaded

before we got there, sometimes we’d have to load it. If we

had to load it, we would drive underneath the scales and

they have what they call a portable scale, it moves right

back and forth under these bins. And Bill Plamondon

would give us the slip, and we’d go out, put so much, like

the bin would hold three ton, and we had five compart-

ments on the truck. We’d put three ton in each one.

And after we got the scale filled out, we got a slip of

paper. You’d run in there and you’d stamp it. It would

stamp the weight down, then you’d put it in the truck.

And after the truck was full, you’d go to the farm that

was on the slip.

Q- That description that you have given us, is that a

typical day? A. Right.

Q. What you would do in the mill? A. Right.

Q. How often did you load the truck and — strike that.

Did anyone else ever load the truck for you? A. Yes,

William Plamondon did.

Q. Can you tell us how often you loaded it and how

often he loaded it? A. Well, I would say we would load

it probably two thirds of [200] the time.

Q. Whodid? A. Us drivers.

54

Q. What would you do when you got to the farm?

A. When you get to the farm, you knew where to go. If

he had pipes hanging down the side of his building, that’s

where you had to blow the feed off. And most generally

he had a little jar with a cover nailed on the wall. It had

a slip on there telling how much he wanted there and how

much he wanted there.

Q. You mean in which bin he wanted you to deliver it?

A. Right. If he didn’t have a slip there and he wasn’t

around, you put it in the bins to your own discretion.

Q. How long would it take you to deliver a load on a

farm?

Judge Davidson: What do you mean by deliver? Does

that include loading?

Q. (By Mr. diCiero) When I say deliver, 1 mean once

you’re on the farm — [201] A. Unloading time?

Q. Yes. A. It could be anywhere from half an hour to

an hour.

Q. When you did see him, did the farmer tell you how

to unload the grain, the feed, rather? A. No, he didn’t

tell us how to. He asked if we’d put so much feed here or

so much feed there, but he never told us how to do it.

* * *

[202] Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Tell us, have you ever made

any haulings with the trucks? A. Yes, I have.

Q. Tell us when, where and what? A. If I were going

to Rockland, Thomaston, or anywhere in the locality,

every so often they’d send me to K&L farms, Knox Lin-

coln farmers co-op to pick up a load of capon feed or

breeder farm feed and bring it back and deliver it.

Q. To whom? A. Bayside’s breeder farms or capon

farms.

Q. The contract farms? A. Yes.

55

Q. Did you ever deliver any of this back to the mill, to

the Thorndike mill? A. Yes, I’ve hauled ingredients

back to the mill before.

Q. From KLF? A. I’ve hauled some from KLF and

I’ve hauled some from DeCosta out in Camden, Maine, in

Turner, Maine.

Q. What was that you hauled of DeCostat A. DeCosta,

I think it was either corn meal or it was alfalfa, and I’m

pretty sure it was alfalfa.

[203] Q. Let’s go back just a bit. How often did you haul

feed from KLF to the breeder farms, to the capon contract

farms? A. You might get a load maybe once a month,

maybe twice a month.

Q. Is that usual for you, about once or twice a month? -

A. You could figure once a month.

Q. And this is from July of ’72 when you started as a

driver until December of ’731 A. Yes.

Q. And how often did you make the deliveries? Did

you haul from the KLF farms — KLF location in Rock-

land to the Thorndike mill? A. I think I did that once,

maybe twice, but I think it was once.

Q. Now what about the alfalfa that you hauled from

Turner, Maine from the deCosta? A. I did that just once.

Q. You did that once? A. Right.

Q. And how about — where did you haul that? A. To

Thorndike.

Q. Was that a full load? A. As I recall, I think it was

15 tons.

Q. That’s a full load, isn’t it? A. Right.

[204] Q. That’s five bins, three tons per bin? A. Right.

Q. Was that the same thing when you hauled from the

KLF? A. Sometimes you might get a whole load, other

times you might get a half load.

Q. Have you ever done any other hauling? A. Yes,

like during the summer, this would be the last summer.

56

Q. 19731 A. I would leave the mill, go up to Belfast,

pick up a tractor and trailer and go to Gloucester, Massa-

chusetts for a load of fish meal. And that would be on a

Friday night and we returned back on a Saturday before

noon and drop off the trailer and the tractor and then go

home.

Q. You’d drop it off at the storage area? A. Either

the storage area or at the mill.

Q. Now the tractor-trailer that you drove, whose tractor-

trailer was that? A. It belonged to Bayside.

Q. And what name was on the side? A. I think it was

Bayside.

Q. Would you tell us where in Gloucester you went?

A. Gloucester, Mass.

Q. Do you know the name of the company? A. Lipp-

man Fish Meal, I think it was.

[205] Q. Lippman Marine Products? A. Yes, something

like that.

Q. How often did you do that? A. I made probably

six or seven trips down around the summer.

Q. During the period of 1973, the summer of ’73?

A. Right.

Q. That was a whole tractor-trailer load, was that a

40 foot trailer? A. Right, 20 tons.

Q. How were you assigned those trips? A. Massachu-

setts. Merle Weymouth asked us if we’d like to go for the

extra time, and we’d say ‘‘sure’’. We needed the extra

time.

[ 207 } Larry McAvuLey

was called as a witness by and on behalf of the General

Counsel and, having been first duly sworn, was examined

and testified as follows:

57

Direct Examination

[208] Q. (By Mr. diCiero) Mr. McAuley, would you state

your full name and address for the record? A. Larry

McAuley, Fall River Avenue, Belfast, Maine.

Q. And by whom are you employed, Mr. McAuley?

A. Bayside Enterprises.

Q. And what do you do for Bayside? A. Truck driver.

Q. Where are youemployed? A. Thorndike.

Q. At the Thorndike mill? A. Right.

o * oe

[219] Q. Have you ever done any kind of work at all as

an employee of Bayside on any of the farms? A. No.

Q. Did you ever catch any chickens? [220] A. No.

Q. Have you ever done any work in the plant, in the

mill while you were an employee of Bayside? A. If we

finished early one night, we might go down and clean a

load up there.

* . 7°

[223] Judge Davidson: You described your duties. I

wonder if you could tell me about how much time — well,

first, strike that. About how many farms do you make

deliveries to in the course of a day?

The Witness: Three or four, sometimes more.

Judge Davidson: How many hours would you work a

day in which you visited three or four farms?

The Witness: An average day probably around nine

hours, sometimes more.

Judge Davidson: Could you tell me how that nine hours

breaks down in terms of where you are? How much of the

day, in other words, are you at the mill, how much are you

on the road, how much are you at the farms?

The Witness: I’d be out at the farm probably anywhere

from 45 to 50 minutes, maybe an hour.

Judge Davidson: Each farm?

58

The Witness: Yes.

Judge Davidson: So that would be perhaps somewhere

between three and four hours a day on the farms?

The Witness: Yes, somewhere around there. It all de-

pends. You might have trouble unloading or something

like that, the truck.

[224] Judge Davidson: And the rest of the time how

much is at the mill and how much is on the road?

The Witness: You’re not at the mill too long if you

don’t have to wait to get loaded. If there’s trucks in front

of you, you have to wait awhile to get loaded, but not

very often.

Judge Davidson: Do you have any motion on how many

miles you drive each day?

The Witness: On the average, it’s over 100 miles a

day, probably 120, sometimes more and sometimes a little

bit less.

[225] CLARENCE McKenny

was recalled to the stand by and on behalf of the Charging

Party and, having been first duly sworn, was examined

and testified as follows:

Direct Examination

Q. (By Mr. Cohen) Mr. McKenny, are you working for

Bayside at the present time? A. No, I’m not.

Q. When did you terminate your employment with Bay-

side? A. Last December.

Q. How did that come about? A. Merle Weymouth

called me into his office and he said that because of the

energy shortage, and they were going to let go one of the

sucker trucks and the sucker truck is one they take to the

farm, any feed that is left over after the birds are gone

they suck back into the truck. And you take it to another

farm; most generally you take it to another farm. And he

59

said he’d have to let me go because I was the youngest

man on [226] the seniority which, at the time, I didn’t

think I was.

RESPONDENTS’ EXHIBIT NO. 4

BAYSIDE ENTERPRISES, INC.

BROILER * ROASTER * CAPON

FEED SCHEDULE

Eff. Jane 3, 1974

Brorers :

Starter WF-180 .666 Ibs. O-2wks. Mash

Starter Robenz + 3 N. 24 Ibs. 2-5wks. Crumble

Broiler Ration Robenz +3N. 3.7 Ibs. 5-—Swks. Pellets

Ration ZZB-10 15 Ibs. 8-9 wks. Pellets

RoasTERs :

Starter WF-180 .666 lbs. O-2wks. Mash

Starter Robenz 3.4 Ibs. 2-—6wks. Crumble

Ration Robenz 2.7 Ibs. 6-—S8wks. Pellets

Ration ZZB-10 15 Ibs. 8-—9wks. Pellets

Finisher Robenz 5.4 Ibs. 9-12 wks. Pellets

Ration ZZB-10 2.1 Ibs. 12-13 wks. Pellets

Capons (Illegible) :

Starter WF-180. .666 lbs. O-2wks. Mash

KL S40K Amprol + 200 gm Aureo 2-6wks. Mash

Bayside Capon Zoa Mix 6-16 wks. Pellets

Bayside Capon Finisher (Zoa)—3 wks. prior to mkt. Pellets

Capons (Illegible) :

Starter WF-180 .666 Ibs. O-2wks. Mash

Starter Robenz + 3 N. 24 Ibs. 2-5wks. Crumble

Bro. Ration Robenz + 3 N. 3.7 Ibs. 5-S8Swks. Pellets

; (to withdr.)

Ration ZZB-10 15 Ibs. 8-—mkt. Pellets

RLD :bf

ee: HCH

RAK

R.L.

Dispatch — Feed Mill

Servicemen

R.E.

60

RESPONDENTS’ EXHIBIT NO. 5

BAYSIDE

GENERAL MANAGER

Breeper Dept Mor

‘Brorer Dept Mor

Povu.ttry SERVICEMEN

Orrice CLERICAL

HatcHery MANAGER

HatcHery ForeEMEN

HatcHery CLERICAL

BAYSIDE

Farm MANAGERS

Dietrich Steinort

Leslie Bailey

Ralph Brewster

Ralph Hamm

Farm EMPLoYEEs

Betty Hamm

Arthur Shute

Farm Crews

ENTERPRISES, INC.

Herbert Hutchings

Richard Koski

Robert Desrosiers

Clair Lewis

Henry Chalmers

Merle Grass

David Kinney

Barbara Flood

Minnie Raven

Nannette Way

Rebecca Trafton

Robert Eldridge

James Fernald

Albert McCormick

Alton Reynolds, Jr.

Patsy Berry

ENTERPRISES, INC.

Lloyd Harriman

George Manning

Lilford Small

Allan Smith

Lucille Smith

Karen Steinort

Lewis Riley — Foreman Grading Crew

Dean Hustus — Asst. Foreman Grading Crew

Melroy Gibbs — Foreman Farm Crew

Joseph Roberts — Foreman Blood Testing

Dale Hustus

Edward Riley

Odber Tibbetts

Dennis Tripp

Larry Tripp

Bulk Feed Delivery — Thorndike

DIsPATCHER

William Plamondon

Drivers

Steven Brown

Joseph Harriman

Leroy Harriman

Larry McAuley

Clyde Rolerson

Winston Thomas

Breeder Hatchery — Waldo

MANAGER

Leon Gallant

EMPLOYEES

Norma Eynon

Jean Glover

Deane Wood

Hatchery — Unity

Ecc Processine

Albert Curtis

Charles Curtis

Erving Curtis

James Curtis

Mark Curtis

Lena Dakin

Emerson Doughty

Cuick Processine

Eva Ames

Helen Bacon

Linda Bartels

Charles Hartley

Dale Hartley

Joseph Hartley

Wilfred Letourneau

Hillard Parsons

Venlon Vanchough

Linda Ward

Donna Erskine

Sally Fernald

Doris Nickless

62

Cuick Processine (Continued)

Shirley Bumpus Edith Parsons

Crystal Clark Marilyn Pelkey

Terry Constable Lorene Pushor

Jacqueline Day Madeline Ward

MAINTENANCE

Dwight Furrow

Drivers

Egg Truck: Chick Truck:

Blaine McCormick Walter P. Roberts

HELPER

Henry Curtis

RESPONDENT’S EXHIBIT NO. 6

Baysipe ENTeERpRIsEs, Inc.

153 Hich Street

Beurast, Marne 04915

December 14, 1973

Dear Bayside Grower:

In June of 1971 I wrote to inform you of a Laryngo-

tracheitis (LT) break on one of our farms. Again today

I write to inform you of a break in a cage operation in

Carmel. Although we have no business contact with this

operation we will consider the situation as though it were

one of our farms. By taking steps in that direction, hope-

fully, we can be as successful in avoiding a crisis as we

were in 1971.

These of you who have been through this type of problem

understand the situation and for those of you who have

not been through it we will attempt to enlighten you.

This disease is caused by a virus which cost the Maine

Poultry Industry millions of dollars during the last epi-

demic in the mid 1960’s.

63

There is no medication to cure the disease. Only strict

sanitation programs can serve as a preventive to keep

this one case from becoming an epidemic. We have taken

steps at a company level to ward off the possibility of

this:

A.) All crew vehicles will be washed every day.

B.) Pullet separating crew will be in sanitized uni-

forms just prior to arriving on your farm.

C.) Feed delivery truck drivers will carry out strict

sanitation methods and truck undercarriages will

be sprayed between loads.

D.) All work crews will step up their sanitation pro-

cedures.

E.) All feed will be left on farms. Estimate your last

feed order carefully.

Should Bayside have a single farm break the following

steps will also be initiated :

A.) All live haul trucks will be sprayed daily.

B.) All weigh stations and feed loading areas will be

washed daily.

C.) Service personnel will answer emergency calls

only.

These things, along with your complete cooperation, are

necessary. The following is to refresh your memory in

the steps that should be taken at the farm level.

A.) Complete footpan management to be carried out

By Att Personne. — Inciupinec You. These

footpans must be changed Dary.

B.) Absolutely No Visrrors — and certainly do not

visit.

C.) Equipment lending — Do Nor borrow or lend

equipment (if necessary, notify your fieldman and

he will advise you).

D.) Sereen all openings immediately with 1”x1”

screening. Most of you have this now — please

check — you may have one missing.

64

E.) Get rid of all outside ‘‘poultry’’ including water-

fowl. There is no better vector of disease.

F.) Rodent control is a must.

G.) Do not leave dead poultry in grain rooms. In-

cinerate immediately.

H.) Dispose of litter properly.

I.) Do not allow litter or oil delivery people in your

buildings.

We are asking you to check yourself in these above

areas of greatest importance. If you see any signs of

respiratory condition in your flock, call immediately. Don’t

wait.

Thank you for your future cooperation which I am cer-

tain will keep us all in a better competitive position.

(s) Rosert L. Desrosiers

Rosert L. Desrosiers

Broiler Department Manager

RLD/mr

RESPONDENT’S EXHIBIT NO. 7

Baysipe Enrerprisss, Inc.

153 Hicu Srreer

Beurast, Marne 04915

April 10, 1974

Dear Bayside Grower:

At the time of our last letter regarding Laryngo-

tracheitis, there had been six flocks that had come down

with the disease. We then went through a period of about

20 days without a break, and then ‘‘the roof came in’’.

We now have had twenty-five flocks break with the

disease in Maine as of this date, of which nine have been

in the last twelve days — a sign that our sanitation pro-

grams and safeguards have dwindled to some extent at

the farm as well as inter-company and intra-company.

Ler’s Review Boru Sanitation PROGRAMS:

65

A. Our Pullet crew is using coveralls and boots.

B. They are sanitizing their suburban and equipment

every day.

C. The Roaster and Broiler pickup crews are wash-

ing their boots, and wearing laundered coveralls

prior to entering your buildings.

Their equipment is also being washed each day.

Bayside Fieldmen are limiting their in-building

calls to emergencies, or respiratory situations,

ete.

F. Feed truck drivers are washing their boots upon

entering and leaving your farm.

G. Before re-entering the feed mill the wheels of

trucks are being sprayed with disinfectant.

H. A special program has been set up to handle

khown L.T. farms.

Should you know of any of the above programs not

being adhered to, I would appreciate knowing about it.

Let me review the areas which you as a Grower should

be responsible for in order to control L.T.

A. Footpans — A Must — changed daily, used by all

individuals — (there should be a brush by the pan). To

dip the soles of your shoes is not adequate; boots that

allow you to step into the footpan and to brush off any

mud or adhering material, is what is necessary. A clump

cf material on the sole or heel of your boot Cannot Be

SANITIZED.

B. Traffic in your buildings — should be limited to the

caretaker. Under no circumstances should you allow a re-

pairman in your buildings without his being dressed in

clean coveralls and boots.

C. Loaning equipment — should be taboo. If it is ne-

cessary, be certain it is washed and disinfected properly.

D. Do not visit other poultry buildings.

mo

66

We realize that going over these points may become a

drag to the individuals who do, in fact, carry on a thorough

sanitation program. However, for those people who are

lax in any of the above mentioned areas, please take heed.

It has long been thought that Laryngotracheitis is air-

borne. However, in recent years that has been considered

Hog Wash, and we consider that to be a fact. It must be

carried on shoes, boots, clothing, equipment, trucks, and

the like, an.d is airborne only to the point of moving with

dust.

If we all carry on our business considering these methods

of transmission, we can beat this thing.

I suggest we keep at it.

(s) Rosert L. Desrosiers

Rosert L. Desrosiers

Broiler Department Manager

RLD :bf

[The Administrative Law Judge’s Decision is omitted

from this Appendix as it is printed on pages A-9 through

A-22 of the Petition for Writ f Certiorari.]

| TITLE OMITTED IN PRINTING |

EMPLOYER’S EXCEPTIONS TO THE

ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE’S DECISION

AND REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT

I. Statement of the Case

Baysiwe Enterprises, Inc. is a Maine corporation whose

principal office is located in Belfast, Maine. It employs

approximately 80 people (53) in various jobs all having

to do with the raising of poultry. Bayside owns all of

the stock of Poultry Processing, Inc. (144) another Maine

corporation who employs approximately 400 people (53)

in various jobs having to do with both the processing of

poultry and the milling of the feed for poultry.

67

The Bayside operation grows broilers, roasters, and

capons; produces hatching eggs from breeder flocks; and

conducts a pedigree breeding operation. It also buys hatch-

ing eggs when it needs them and sells both breeding stock

and hatching eggs to other poultry companies (30).

Almost all of Bayside’s poultry is sold to Poultry Pro-

cessing, Inc. (100) although some has been sold to Fort

Halifax Packing Company, another processing plant, and

some Canadian canneries in Nova Scotia and New Bruns-

wick (31, 122).

There are two hatcheries — a pedigree hatchery and a

commercial hatchery. The small breeder pedigree hatchery

is located in the town of Waldo, 5 miles outside of Belfast

(58). This breeder hatchery is connected with six primary

breeding farms which breed and select the strains or lines

of birds of the type that is used in the broiler or roaster

production business (34). It is necessary for Bayside to

employ a full-time geneticist, Richard Koski, who is Gen-

eral Manager of the Breeder Department. He, with another

man, helps select the basic breeders with the traits desired.

This primary breeder operation has gone on since 1948

when it was established by buying eggs or chicks with the

essential strains from other breeders (35).

The commercial hatchery is located in Unity, about 28

miles west of Belfast (58). There are eleven farms con-

nected with it that produce eggs from breeding stock.

This commercial hatchery’s only function is to take in

eggs and hatch chickens (36).

Besides the six breeder farms and the eleven commer-

cial egg farms, Bayside has a contracted relationship with

119 independent farmers (37) for the growing of broilers

and roasters. (Bayside itself owns approximately seven

farms (130, 30) all of which at the present time are being

used for the parent-grandparent operation (133-4).

68

Generally the farmer’s responsibility is to supply the

poultry house and to feed and look after the birds (78)

while Bayside furnishes the chicks, the feed, fuel, medica-

ments and vaccines (39). Bayside also does the debeaking

either at the hatchery or on the farm (63) as well as the

blood testing (62). The farmer is paid on the basis of a

guarantee for square footage plus a bonus based on the

pounds of poultry he has produced (103).

The Bayside Broiler Department Manager Robert Des-

rosiers is directly concerned with what happens on each

farm (134). He is in charge of the whole growing of

poultry for meat production, the health of the poultry

and the scheduling of both feed and poultry onto the farms

(154).

He is superior to four poultry servicemen employed

by Bayside (134) to regularly check on the flocks of the

various farmers and take care that the poltry is fed and

free from disease (175-176) (40-41).

Bayside also has eight farm managers and four farm

employees that work on company-owned farms. There is

also a special farm crew that move and grade poultry,

clean the poultry houses, do vaccination and blood testing

work and some of the breeder selection work.

The large commercial hatchery at Unity has a 14 person

egg processing crew and a 14 woman chick processing

erew. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 5) This hatchery has

two types of vehicles connected with it — a refrigerated

vehicle for transporting eggs and a heated vehicle for

transporting chicks (58). Each has a truck driver.

Besides a few office clerical people and a few employees

at the breeder hatchery, the only other employees of Bay-

side are the six truck drivers employed in the feed move

operation that are the subject of this controversy and

their supervisor-dispatcher, William Plamondon.

69

Poultry Processing, Inc., the subsidiary of Bayside En-

terprises, Inc., is divided into two distinct operations each

under a different trade name (33). First there is the pro-

cessing plant at a separate location at the east end of

Belfast (58) about 1/4 mile from the central office (54)

with its own procurement trucking system (32) for bring-

ing in the live poultry from the farms in coops on flatbeds

and it has other drivers that deliver the processed poultry

to locations outside the state in refrigerated units (56-57).

This operation goes under the name of Penobscot Poultry

Co. (32).

The second operation is the feed mill located at Thorn-

dike, Maine, 22 miles west of Belfast (58). This goes

under the trade name of Penobscot Feeds (32).

The testimony is that the processing plant has a set

of offices in which the manager, Gilbert Knight, in addi-

tion to a Mr. Dow, the operations manager; a Mr. Black,

the personnel manager; and two salesmen are located.

There are also offices for the Federal Inspection Service

(55). All of the non-exempt personnel in the processing

plant are represented by the Meatcutters and the Teamsters

under a joint certification (9, 191, 53).

The feed mill at Thorndike, operated by Poultry Pro-

cessing, Inc., has only two customers. Of the 120,000 tons

per year (84) Fort Halifax Poultry Co. takes 1/3 of the

production. The other 2/3 goes to the farms of Bayside.

The 1/3 that Fort Halifax receives, constitutes 100% of

its broiler feed (20). The 2/3rds that Bayside gets from

the mill amounts to 80% to 85% of its total feed require-

ments (81-82). The balance comes from Knox-Lincoln

Farmers Co-op (KLF) and is mostly feed for Bayside’s

breeder farms (81, 82).

Up to May 1, 1974, Poultry Processing owned all the

ingredients that went into the feed and sold the feed to

both Bayside and Fort Halifax. After May 1, Bayside

70

began to purchase all of its own ingredients (94) and

Poultry Processing milled it on a fixed cost per ton (142)

and charged Bayside for the milling. However, Poultry

Processing continues to buy the ingredients for Fort

Halifax and sell the manufactured product to it (97).

Feed is a manufactured agricultural product (23, 157).

It is the source of protein to the poultry (157). It is made

up of 80% corn and soy (45) and has approximately 25

other ingredients such as drugs, vitamins, minerals, amino

acids, trace minerals and a growth stimulator (43). Fort

Halifax makes up its own specifications for the type feed

it uses (24) and Bayside also dictates to the mill the

type of feed formula it requires (45).

Mr. Desrosiers, The Broiler Department Manager, de-

cides what formula will be fed to the birds (46) depending

upon certain variables. There is different feed requirement

depending upon the type of bird being raised (broiler,

roaster, capon).

Feed is categorized according to its composition (mash,

crumbles, and pellets). Mash is the composition fed with-

out further physical change in a blend (47). Crumbles (42)

are round pellets broken up into small parts by a cracking

roll. Pellets are the result of putting the mash into a

steam pressure die system called a pellet mill (47).

It is very important when birds are young that they

get a starter feed that carries higher fortification as far

2s vitamins and trace minerals. The quality of ingredients

make for a higher price diet (48). As the birds become

older, the form and the composition of feed changes (49).

For example, one type of feed is used from 0 to 2 weeks;

another from 2 to 6 weeks; another from 6 to 9 weeks;

and 5 days prior to slaughter, a different feed where no

restricted component such as a narcincal is used (41,49).

The feed is very expensive. It was testified to that at

71

the time of the hearing it was costing $160.00 per te

(127).

Besides the specie and age of the bird, the amount of

feed consumed by the bird is affected by the general health

situation of the flock and the temperature (when it is hot

they eat less; when cold they eat more) (43, 65).

Just as Fort Halifax does not have a feed mill today,

in the past Poultry Processing, Inc. did not have one and

operated from a bulk receiving station located in Belfast

(89,222).

A Mr. Lord is the manager of the feed mill (111). His

second in command is Merle Weymouth. Weymouth’s job

is to see that the feed is made (175). These two men work

for Poultry Processing, Inc. In another office (186) is

William Plamondon who is the Bayside dispatcher (174).

His job is to make sure the feed is delivered to the farms

(175). His immediate supervisor is Desrosiers who speaks

to Plamondon at least 10 times a day (175) with regard

to feed delivery. Plamondon also must be in constant con-

tact with the hatchery. The hatchery gives him a chick

placement sheet so that he can make up a feed schedule

for the truck drivers so that they will know which farm

to deliver the feed. Plamondon also must be in touch with

either the farm servicemen or the farmers themselves in

case they are short of feed (73). Plamondon must speak

to Weymouth about the mill’s disease control because of

the possibility of transmission of disease through the

feed (137).

Plamondon must speak to Weymouth about the mill’s

disease control because of the possibility of transmission of

disease through the feed (137).

Plamondon who is a fomer truck driver himself (177) is

in charge of lining up the pay of the 6 truck drivers, making

up a vacation schedule, seeing the feed trucks are loaded,

and directing the drivers where to go and what to take there

72

(177, 216). The drivers themselves recognize that Plamon-

don is their immediate supervisor (220).

The biggest problem in the poultry raising industry is

disease (24). Two of the most prevalent in Maine are the

protozoan disease—cocksidiosis—and the virus—laryngo-

tracheitis (Lt) (50). Disease control is extremely impor-

tant (126). A diseased flock could have a mortality rate

of as high as 20% although more usual is around 2% (99).

As early as the breeder-hatchery, medicaments are ad-

ministered if there is a disease problem (48). The mill

keeps a pail of disinfectant for all employees and visitors

to prevent the transmission of disease through the feed

(137). The corporate policy is to keep everyone away from

the flocks including the truck drivers (127, 112) since par-

ticularly LT is spread mechanically by tracking it on boots

or tires or by wild fowl (52, 50).

The truck drivers are responsible for sanitation control

of themselves and their equipment while on the farms to

prevent the transmission of communicable disease from

feet, clothing, or equipment (136). In each Bayside truck

there is a 12-quart pail, a foot pan, a bottle of disinfectent,

a water bucket, and a sprayer, all used in the sanitation

procedure (168). A driver must wash his boots before

getting out of the truck (163). When he leaves the farm,

he must spray his tires (163) and scrub his boots (51).

Back at the feed mill he must wash his running gear with

disinfectant (51, 164).

Mr. Desrosiers testified that the reason he does not use

an independent trucker like Hodges is because to do so

would forfeit his control over sanitation procedures in

knowing where the independent driver has been prior to

visiting one of his farms and being able to oversee the

activities of the drivers and their vehicles (160). He said

that he feels that you just ‘‘can’t take the chance’’ in

sanitation control (161).

73

The testimony with regard to the practice in the poultry

industry as it concerns the transportation of feed is not

consistent. Fort Halifax which bnys its feed from Penob-

scot Feeds does not have feed drivers but hires Richard

Hodges, an independent trucker, to pick up and deliver its

feed (20). Bayside delivers 85% of its own feed in its

own trucks with its own drivers but has the balance deliv-

ered by the drivers employed by the Knox-Lincoln Farmers

Co-op. In the past, however, and even sometimes today,

Bayside drivers pick up the feed in Rockiand and transport

it to the farms (185, 82, 218). Bayside, unlike Fort Halifax

today, used its own drivers even when it didn’t have a

feed mill (222, 89). Some fully independent growers who

own their own poultry have their own feed trucks and

send them to KLF for the feed instead of having it deliv-

ered by KLF (75-76). The choice of the method of trans-

portation of feed varies.

Bayside owns four feed farms (63) with capacities of

14 to 25 tons (66). Each truck has several compartments

so that different feeds or split loads can be delivered by

the same driver (66). Each compartment holds about 3 tons

(163). The trucks have a conveying device on the bottom

and an unloading device—either an air pump or auger

(66, 51).

The Bayside farms are mostly in Waldo Couaty and all

within a 12 to 15 miles average from the feed mill (53).

Bayside has its own fuel pump for its trucks (143). The

Bayside trucks all carry the logo ‘‘Bayside Enterprises,

Inc.’’ The Poultry Processing trucks all say ‘‘ Penobscot

Poultry Co.’’ although they are registered to Poultry

Processing (57).

The six Bayside drivers work in two shifts. Three from

3 a.m. to 1 p.m. while the other three work from 1 p.m.

to 9 p.m. (174). A driver goes to three or four farms a day

74

(64) but not necessarily does he regularly haul to the same

farms (175).

His time is divided roughly equally between driving on

the road and unloading on the farms with a much smaller

amount loading the feed at the mill (162, 167). The average

farm receives a feed delivery once a week although some

see a feed delivery more than once a week (63-64). The

driver spends on the average from % to 1 hour on each

farm (201).

While the Poultry Processing truck drivers are hired

by a personnel man at Poultry Processing (57), the respon-

sibility to hire a new truck driver for feed delivery for

Bayside would fall on the Broiler Department Manager

since that department is so vitally concerned with what

happens on the farms (134). Poultry Processing drivers

both haul the live poultry to the processing plant after

picking it up at 9:30 p.m. for processing at 7 a.m. the

next morning (55, 190) and also drive the processed birds

to market (55). There is a driver named Smart who works

for Poultry Processing whose only job is to transport

certain animal by-products of the processing plant to the

feed mill for inclusion in the formula (137). Fort Halifax

Packing also sells feathers to the Penobscot Feeds (21, 117).

The routine of a Bayside driver after reporting to work

at the feed mill (112) which is at a central location is to

get his schedule (73) from the dispatcher, load his truck

from the specified bin with the type of feed indicated on

his delivery slip (177). (Sometimes the truck is already

waiting for him preloaded (168). The feed is weighed on

the scale at the mill (69). There is no scale on the farms

to measure how much feed is coming in (48). Then the

driver takes the weight ticket along with a feed sample

to be left with the farmer (for the purpose of pinpointing

the day of any possible contamination) (69, 157, 177) and

drives to either one or two farms with his load (217).

75

After going through the sanitation procedure on the

farm, the driver either asks the farmer if he has multiple

bins where he wants the feed and how much in each, or finds

a message left for him concerning this (67, 51). The driver

then connects the equipment either by air delivery or by

auger and the feed truck is unloaded at about 2% to 3

minutes a ton (51). The driver must be present at the

unloading to change compartments on the truck and see

that there is no difficulty (67). When the unloading is

finished, he presents the feed sample and the weight slip

to the farmer, sometimes having coffee with him; dis-

assembles the unloading equipment; washes his boots;

gets back in his truck and leaves either for the mill or

another farm (51).

The responsibility of the drivers to the farmer is ex-

tremely great. The evidence shows that the farmer has no

way to check to see if he is getting the amount of feed

that the weight slip the driver presents to him indicates.

It is therefore a matter of trust between the driver and

the farmer that the driver doesn’t deliver the feed some-

where else (70). This is particularly important since the

bonus system is based on production costs and feed repre-

sents 60-70% of input (125).

The Bayside driver fills the farmer’s bins in his own

diseretion if the farmer is not around (200) and with the

specific type of feed that that age and type of poultry

demands (158). A mistake could ruin the whole flock (67).

The driver’s responsibility for proper sanitation cannot

be overemphasized. Besides the procedures already indi-

cated the wrong placement of his truck near the poultry

house can suck the virus out of that building through the

truck and contaminate another farm from the interior of

the truck (159).

The feed must be of a specific moisture content. If it is

snowing or raining the driver must be careful to open one

76

bin at a time so as to prevent excess moisture (159).

To prevent mold he must make sure that the old feed is at

the bottom of the bin before he unloads new feed (158-159).

In addition there is a responsibility in the very driving

of the truck onto the farm. The birds in the poultry house

are very dense (14% broilers per square foot; 1 roaster per

square foot) Any undue or extraordinary light or noise

could make the birds stampede which would have the effect

of their piling into a corner and smothering. It is for this

reason that the driver must drive the shiny metal feed

truck in such a manner as to prevent a reflection into the

windows of a poultry house (73-74). There is evidence that

at least one of the drivers is also an independent contract

grower (138).

The only other factual matter in the record that has not

been fully commented on is the relationship between Bay-

side and Poultry Processing. As has been previously re-

ported, Bayside is the farm company and is recognized as

such by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (128) as well

as being a member of the Knox-Lincoln Farmers’ Co-

operative which makes being in the business of farming

one of the qualifications (75). Poultry Processing buys

live birds from other suppliers besides Bayside although

Bayside is the major source (56). Title passes at the

growing farm (33) contrary to the Administrative Law

Judges finding on page 4 line 2 of the decision.

There is a conscious attempt to separate the two corpo-

rations (143). The main office in Belfast is the point in

which there is some crossover, but even here an allocation

of expenses is made to reflect the true cost situation as to

each (143).

For example, there are 12 in the accounting office; 2 on

the clerical payroll of Bayside; 7 on the clerical payroll

of Poultry Processing; and 3 who do joint work for each.

These 3 are John Phillips, the controller of both corpo-

rations (141); an office manager and an accountant (152).

77

The only other man involved in both corporations is

Herb Hutchins, to whom the plant managers of both Penob-

scot Poultry and Penobscot Feeds report (139) as well as

the top Bayside personnel. :

Money actually changes hands between Bayside and

Poultry Processing by writing checks. There are two cash

receipt books and two cash disbursement books. There are

invoices between the two for various charges including the

sale of the poultry (141), feed, fuel, and an administrative

expense charge (14 *. This type of arrangement is not

uncommon (25).

Bayswwe ENTeRprises, Inc.

Penosscot Pouttry ComMPANy

Pouutry Processine, Inc.

By (s) Aan J. Levenson

Aan J. Levenson

Portland, Maine

October, 1974

LEVENSON AND LEVENSON

187 Middle Street

Portland, Maine

Attorneys for Respondent

[The Decision and Order of the National Labor Relations

Board are omitted from this Appendix as they are

printed on pages A-7 and A-8 of the Petition for a Writ

of Certiorari.]

[The Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for

the First Circuit is omitted from this Appendix as it is

printed on pages A-1 through A-5 of the Petition for a

Writ of Certiorari.]

78

[The Decree of the United States Court of Appeals for

the First Circuit is omitted from this Appendix as it

is printed on page A-6 of the Petition for a Writ of

Certiorari. ]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appendix — Bayside Enterprises, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board · 429 U.S. 298 | Frix