Appendix — National Labor Relations Board v. Enterprise Ass'n of Steam, Hot Water, Hydraulic Sprinkler, Pneumatic Tube, Ice Machine & General Pipefitters
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX :
Supreme Comet of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1975
No. 75-777
NATION’'t LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
Petitioner,
—
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, Hot WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VICIN-
ITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638, ETC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COUFT OF
APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED NOVEMBER 28, 1975
CERTIORARI GRANTED FEBRUARY 23, 1976
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1975
No. 75-777
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
Petitioner,
_—
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, HoT WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VICIN-
ITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638, ETC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE ' NITED STATES COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
INDEX
Page
cs ac ncassenesevenecncevenssecesecaccssscensenens 1
Board Case No. 29-CC-336
a - tia v. ot "aot ini A an RO 2
a sspuannbensusburcscceccnseusenouses 5
a cesasaaenanese 0 ER 13
Excerpts from transcript of testimony in Case No. 29-CC-336.. 15
Excerpts from transcript of testimony in Case 72-Civil 1393.. 18
Witnesses :
a ccenecesnonnnanenenaeaonne 19
A 31
ii INDEX
Page
EERIE era eR ne MD Roce ot ta 36, 50
ne I So oO 44
UG ae 48, 52
Plaintiff’s Exhibits:
ee. ae I Oe Sk OO etintncintencice ee ee ee 54
we Eg BR ara Se Sone, 58
Sk Uh mceinhieniatnctianstenndeinaaaed toe ee eee 67
eg Brrr eet See 72
ee Se I aii perenne tobe tare Saale 77
BUN SUP oncsueccaseninieeutnditeiadicad tidiaviidadiet ee ee 79
Sela “Tt Ce to aie 83
a seaieans atiekansaddoubdecoonnniamieiee eas corsets 90
Defendant’s Exhibit:
OUI TE ccassnesplbvvnnaniendlichtinnesstatcsencsaceeesod cn en ee 98
Order of the Supreme Court granting certiorari... 101
(The decision of the Board and the decision and judgment
of the Court of Appeals were printed in the petition for writ
of certiorari and thus need not be reprinted. )
CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF RELEVANT
DOCKET ENTRIES
Date Docket Entry
10/6/72 Charge Filed, NLRB Case No. 29-CC-336
10/26/72 Complaint and Notice of Hearing issued
10/31/72 Order Rescheduling Hearing issued
11/2/72 Hearing in Section 10(1) Proceeding, Case No.
72-Civil-1339
11/9/72 Respondent Union’s Answer in NLRB Case No.
29-CC-336
11/15/72 Hearing opened in NLRB Case No. 29-CC-336
11/15/72 Hearing closed in NLRB Case No. 29-CC-336
3/30/72 Administrative Law Judge’s Decision issued
4/11/72 Respondent Union’s Exceptions to the Decision of
the Administrative Law Judge, received
4/12/73 General Counsel’s Exceptions to the Administrative
Law Judge’s Decision, received
7/5/73 Decision and order issued by the National Labor
Relations Board, dated
8/30/73 Order Correcting Decision and Order, dated
7/1/75 Decision of Court of Appeals
7/1/75 Judgment of Court of Appeals
2/23/76 Order of Supreme Court granting certiorari
(1)
2
FORM NLRB 508 Form Approved
(12-65) Budget Bureau No. 64-R003.12
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
CHARGE AGAINST LABOR ORGANIZATION OR ITS AGENTS
DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE
Case No.: 29-CC-336
Date Filed: 10-6-72
INSTRUCTIONS: File an original and 3 copies of this
charge and an additional copy for each organization,
each local and each individual named in item 1 with the
NLRB regional director for the region in which the
alleged unfair labor practice occurred or is occurring.
1. Labor Organization or its Agents against which
charge is brought
a. Name: Enterprise Association, Steam Fitters,
Local No. 638, U.A., AFL-CIO
b. Union Representative to Contact:
William B. Daley
ce. Phone No.: 674-3937
d. Address (Street, city, State and ZIP code):
841 Broadway, New York, New York
e. The above-named organization(s) or its agents
has (have) engaged in and is (are) engaging in
unfair labor practices within the meaning of
section 8(b), subsection(s) 4/i) (ii)(B) of the
National Labor Relations Act, and these unfair
labor practices are unfair labor practices affect-
ing commerce within the meaning of the Act.
bo
Basis of the Charge (Be specific as to facts, names,
addresses, plants involved, dates, places, etc.)
3
Since on or about August 7, 1972, the above des-
ignated labor organization, by its officers, agents
and/or officials has engaged in, or induced or en-
couraged individuals employed by The Austin Com-
pany, Ine. Hudik-Ross, Inc. and other persons en-
gaged in commerce or in an industry affecting com-
merce to engage in a strike or a refusal in the course
of their employment to use, manufacture, process,
transport, or otherwise handle or work on any goods,
articles, materials or commodities or to perform any
services and/or has threatened, coerced or restrained
The Austin Company, Inc. Hudik-Ross, Inc. and
uther persons engaged in commerce or an industry
affecting commerce, where in either case an object
thereof is forcing or requiring the Austin Company,
Inc. and Hudik-Ross, Inc. to cease using, selling,
handling, transporting or otherwise dealing in the
products of Slant, Fin Corporation, or to cease doing
business with Slant/Fin Corporation.
Name of Employer: The Austin Company, Inc.
Location of Plant Involved (Street, city, State and
ZIP code): 450 West lst Avenue, Roselle, New Jer-
sey 07203
Type of Establishment (Factory, mine, wholesaler,
ete.) : General Contractor
6. Identify Principal Product or Service:
7. No. of Workers Employed: 300
10.
Full Name of Party Filing Charge:
) The Austin Company, Ince.
Address of Party Filing Charge (Street, city, State
and ZIP code) :
450 West Ist Ave., Roselle, New Jersey 07203
Telephone No.: 201-245-4000
11. Declaration:
I declare that I have read the above charge and that
the statements therein are true to the best of my
knowledge and belief.
By .s/ (illegible)
(Signature of representative or person making charge)
District Superintendent
(Title or office, if any)
Address 450 West lst Ave., Roselle, N.J. 07203
(Telephone number): 201-345-4000
(Date): October 6, 1972
Willfully false statements on this charge can be punished
by fine and imprisonment (U.S. Code, Title 18, Section
1001)
5
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
REGION 29
Case No. 29-CC-336
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, HOT WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VICIN-
ITY, LOCAL UNION NO, 638 OF THE UNITED ASSOCIATION
OF JOURNEYMEN AND APPRENTICES OF THE PLUMBING
AND PIPEFITTING INDUSTRY OF THE UNITED STATES AND
CANADA, AFL-CIO
and
THE AUSTIN COMPANY, INC.
COMPLAINT AND NOTICE OF HEARING
It having been charged by The Austin Company, Inc.,
herein called Austin, that Enterprise Association of
Steam, Hot Water, Hydraulic Sprinkler, Pneumatic Tube,
Ice Machine and General Pipefitters of New York and
Vicinity, Local Union No. 638 of the United Association
of Journeymen and Apprentices of the Plumbing and
Pipefitting Industry of the United States and Canada,
herein called Respondent, has engaged in, and is engag-
ing in, certain unfair labor practices affecting commerce
as set forth and defined in the National Labor Relations
Act, as amended, 29 U.S.C., Sec. 151, et seg., herein called
the Act, the General Counsel of the National Labor Re-
lations Board, herein called the Board, on behalf of the
Board, by the undersigned Regional Director for Region
29, pursuant to Section 10(b) of the Act and the Board’s
Rules and Regulations Series 8, as amended, Section
102.15, hereby issues this Complaint and Notice of Hear-
ing and alleges as follows:
1. The Charge in this proceeding was filed by Austin
on October 6, 1972, and served by registered mail upon
Respondent on or about October 6, 1972.
6
2. (a) Slant/Fin Corporation, herein called Slant/
Fin, is, and has been at all times material herein, a cor-
poration duly organized under, and existing by virtue of,
the laws of the State of New York.
(b) At all times material herein, Slant/Fin has
maintained its principal office and place of business at
100 Forest Drive at East Hilis in the Town of Greenvale,
State of New York, where it is, and has been at all times
material herein, engaged in the manufacture, sale and
distribution of heating, ventilating and air-conditioning
units, and related products.
(c) During the past year, which period is represen-
tative of its annual operations generally, Slant/Fin, in
the course and conduct of its business operations, manu-
factured, sold and distributed at its place of business,
products valued in excess of $50,000, of which products
valued in excess of $50,000 were shipped from said place
of business in interstate commerce directly to states of
the United States other than the state in which it is
located.
(d) Slant, Fin is, and has been at all times material
herein, a person engaged in commerce and in an industry
affecting commerce within the meaning of Sections 2(1),
(6) and (7), and 8(b) (4) of the Act.
3. (a) Austin is, and has been at all times material
herein, a corporation duly organized under, and existing
by virtue of, the laws of the State of Ohio.
(b) At all times material herein, Austin has main-
tained its principal office and place of business at 450
West First Avenue, in the City of Roselle, State of New
Jersey. It is, and has been at all times material herein,
engaged in the business of providing and performing en-
gineering and generel contracting services and related
services at various building and construction jobsites in
various states of the United States, including the states
of New Jersey and New York.
(ec) During the past year, which period is repre-
sentative of its annual operations generally, Austin, in
the course and conduct of its business, purchased and
caused to be transported and delivered, inter alia, to its
place of business, in Roselle, New Jersey, and to various
7
building and construction jobsites in the State of New
York, building supplies and other goods and materials
valued in excess of $50,000, of which goods and materials
valued in excess of $50,000 were transported and deliv-
ered to its place of business and to said jobsites in inter-
state commerce directly from states of the United States
other than the states in which said place of business and
jobsites are located.
(d) Austin is, °nd has been at all times material
herein, a person enga, . in commerce and in an industry
affecting commerce within the meaning of Sections 2(1),
(6) and (7) and 8(b) (4) of the Act.
4. (a) Hudik-Ross Co., Inc., herein called Hudik-Ross,
is, and has been at all times material herein, a corpora-
tion duly organized under, and existing by virtue of, the
laws of the State of New York.
(b) At all times material herein, Hudik-Ross has
maintained its principal office and place of business at
251 West 42nd Street, in the City of New York, State
of New York. It is, and has been at all times material
herein, engaged in the business of providing and perform-
ing heat, ventilation and air-conditioning contracting
services and related services at various building and con-
struction jobsites in the State of New York.
(ec) During the past year, which period is repre-
sentative of its annual operations generally, Hudik-Ross,
in the course and conduct of its business, purchased and
caused to be transported and delivered to its place of
business, and to various building and construction job-
sites in New York State, heating, ventilating and air
conditioning supplies, and other goods and materials
valued in excess of $50,000, of which goods and materials
valued in excess of $50,000 were transported and deliv-
ered to said place of business and to said jobsites in
interstate commerce directly from states of the United
States other than the state in which said place of busi-
ness and jobsites are located.
(d) Hudick-Ross is, and has been at all times ma-
terial herein, a person engaged in commerce and in an
industry affecting commerce within the meaning of Sec-
tions 2(1), (6) and (7) and 8(b) (4) of the Act.
8
5. Respondent is, and has been at all times material
herein, a labor organization within the meaning of Sec-
tion 2(5) of the Act.
6. William Daley is, and has been at all times ma-
terial herein, the business agent of Respondent, acting
on its behalf, and as agent thereof.
7. (a) At all times material herein, Austin has been
the engineer and general contractor for the construction
of the Norwegian Home for the Aged located at 1250
67th Street, Brooklyn, New York, herein called the Nor-
wegian Home jobsite.
(b) At all times material herein, Austin, in its
capacity of engineer, prepared the engineering job spe-
cifications for the construction of the Norwegian Home.
The said job specifications, prepared by Austin, require
the installation of heating and air-conditioning units at
the Norwegian Home jobsite known as climate command
units, which units are manufactured by Slant/Fin. Said
job specifications further require that the main water
flow and condensate assembly for the above mentioned
units shall be factory installed as an integral part of
said units manufactured by Slant/ Fin.
(ce) Pursuant to an agreement with Slant/Fin, and
in accordance with the Norwegian Home job specifications
described in subparagraph (b) above, Austin has, at all
times material herein, purchased from Slant, Fin and
caused to be delivered to the Norwegian Home jobsite,
climate command heating and air-conditioning units to
be installed at said Norwegian Home jobsite.
8. In or around Apri! 1972, Austin subcontracted to
Hudik-Ross the heating, ventilation and air-conditioning
work to be performed at the Norwegian Home jobsite,
including the installation of the climate command heat-
ing and air-conditioning units with factory installed main
water flow and condensate assemblies, manufactured by
Slant Fin.
9, At all times material herein, Hudik-Ross and Re-
spondent have been parties to a collective bargaining
agreement covering employees of Hudik-Ross and Hudik-
Ross has employed individuals at its various building
and construction jobsites, including the Norwegian Home
9
jobsite, who are members of, or are represented by, Re-
spondent.
10. At no time material herein have Slant/Fin and
Respondent been parties to a collective bargaining agree-
ment and the employees of Slant/Fin are not members
of, or represented by, Respondent.
11. At all times material herein, Respondent has been
engaged in a labor dispute with Slant/Fin because Slant/
Fin is not a party to a collective bargaining agreement
with Respondent and does not employ individuals who are
members of, or represented by, Respondent, and because
the main water flow and condensate assemblies for the
command control heating and air-conditioning units man-
ufactured by Slant/Fin for Austin, to be installed at the
Norwegian Home jobsite, have been factory installed by
employees of Slant/Fin who are not members of, or
represented by, Respondent, and have not been installed
at said jobsite by employees of Hudik-Ross, who are
members of, or represented by, Respondent.
12. (a) On or about June 22, 1972, and on various
other dates presently unknown during the months of
July, August and September 1972, Respondent, by Wil-
liam Daley, its business agent at the Norwegian Home
jobsite, in furtherance of its dispute with Slant/Fin, as
described above in paragraph 11, threatened Austin that
it would refuse to permit its members employed by
Hudik-Ross at the Norwegian Home jobsite, to handle,
work on or install the climate command heating and
air-conditioning units manufactured by Slant/Fin and
scheduled to be installed at the Norwegian Home jobsite.
(b) On or about September 21, 1972, and on vari-
ous other dates presently unknown during the months of
September and October 1972, Respondent, by William
Daley, its business agent, in furtherance of its dispute
with Slant/Fin, as described above in paragraph 11,
threatened Hudik-Ross that it would refuse to permit its
members employed by Hudik-Ross at the Norwegian
Home jobsite, to handle, work on or install the climate
command heating and air conditioning units manufac-
tured by Slant/Fin and scheduled to be installed at the
Norwegian Home jobsite.
10
13. Since on or about September 15, 1972, Respond-
ent, in furtherance of its dispute with Slant/Fin as de-
scribed above in paragraph 11, has engaged in a strike
among individuals employed by Hudik-Ross at the Nor-
wegian Home jobsite, and has caused such individuals
employed by Hudik-Ross at the Norwegian Home jobsite
to refuse to work on, install, or otherwise handle the
climate command heating and air-conditioning units
manufactured by Slant, Fin and scheduled to be installed
at the Norwegian Home jobsite.
14. Since on or about September 15, 1972, Respondent
has engaged in a strike, as described above in paragraph
13, and by such conduct and by other means including
requests, appeals, orders and instructions, Respondent
induced and encouraged individuals employed by Hudik-
Ross, and other persons engaged in commerce and in
industries affecting commerce, to engage in a strike and
a refusal] in the course of their employment to use, manu-
facture, process, transport and otherwise handle and
work on goods, articles, materials and commodities, and
to perform services for their respective employers.
15. By the conduct described above in paragraphs 12,
13 and 14, Respondent threatened, coerced and restrained
Hudik-Ross, Austin, and other persons engaged in com-
merce and in industries affecting commerce.
16. Respondent engaged in the conduct described above
in paragraphs 12 through 15, in furtherance of its dis-
pute with Slant/ Fin, as described above in paragraph 11,
and with an object or objects: (a) to force and require
Hudik-Ross, and other persons, to cease using, handling,
transporting, and otherwise dealing in climate command
heating and air-conditioning units with factory installed
main water flow and condensate assemblies or other re-
lated units or products manufactured by Slant/Fin, not-
withstanding that Hudik-Ross was required to install
said climate command heating and air-conditioning units
at the Norwegian Home jobsite pursuant to the terms of
its contract with Austin, as described above in paragraph
&; ‘b) to force and require Hudik-Ross and other per-
sons, to cease doing business with Austin, Slant/Fin and
other persons; and (c) to force and require Austin and
11
other persons to cease using, handling, transporting or
otherwise dealing in the products of Slant, Fin, and other
producers or manufacturers, and to cease doing business
with Slant/Fin and other persons.
17. By the acts described above in paragraphs 12
through 15, and by each of said acts, for the objects de-
scribed above in paragraph 16, Respondent engaged in,
and is engaging in, unfair labor practices affecting com-
merce within the meaning of Section 8(b) (4) (i) and
(ii) (B) and Section 2‘6) and (7) of the Act.
18. The acts of Respondent described above in para-
graphs 12 through 16, occurring in connection with the
operations of Slant, Fin, Austin and Hudik-Ross, de-
scribed above in paragraphs 2, 3 and 4, respectively,
have a close, intimate and substantial relation to trade,
traffic and commerce among the several states and tend
to lend to labor disputes burdening and obstructing
commerce and the free flow of commerce.
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on the 8th day of No-
vember, 1972 at 11:00 a.m. at 16 Court Street, fourth
floor, in the Borough of Brooklyn, City and State of
New York, a hearing will be conducted before a duly
designated Administrative Law Judge of the National
Labor Relations Board on the allegations set forth in the
above Complaint, at which time and place you will have
the right to appear in person, or otherwise, and give
testimony. Form NLRB-4668, Statement of Standard Pro-
cedures In Formal Hearings Held Before The National
Labor Relations Board In Unfair Labor Practice Cases,
is attached.
YOU ARE FURTHER NOTIFIED that, pursuant to
Sections 102.20 and 102.21 of the Board’s Rules and
Regulations, the Respondent shall file with the under-
signed Regional Director, acting in this matter as agent
of the Natioinal Labor Relations Board, an original and
four (4) copies of an answer to the said Complaint
within ten (10) days from the service thereof, and that
unless it does so, all of the al'egations in the Complaint
shall be deemed to be admitted by it to be true and may
be so found by the Board.
Dated at Brooklyn, New York, this 26th day of Octo-
ber, 1972.
12
/s/ Samuel M. Kaynard
SAMUEL M. KAYNARD
Regional Director, Region 29
National Labor Relations Board
16 Court Street, Brooklyn, New
York 11241
13
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
Case No. 29-CC-336
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, HoT WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VI-
CINITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638 OF THE UNITED ASSO-
CIATION OF JOURNEYMEN AND APPRENTICES OF THE
PLUMBING AND PIPEFITTING INDUSTRY OF THE UNITED
STATES AND CANADA, AFL-CIO
and
THE AUSTIN COMPANY, INC.
ANSWER
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION, etc., the Respondent
herein, answers the Complaint in the within case as
follows:
1. Admits the allegations contained in paragraphs
1, 2(a), 2(b), 2(c), 2/d), 3fa), 3(b), 3(e), 3(d), 4(a),
4(b), 4(c), 4(d), 5, 6, 7(a), 9 and 10 of the Complaint.
2. States that it is without knowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allega-
tions contained in paragraphs 7(b), 7(c) and 8 of the
Complaint.
3. Denies the allegations contained in paragraphs 11,
12(a), 12(b), 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 of the Com-
plaint.
14
Dated: New York, N. Y.
TO:
November 9, 1972.
DELSON & GORDON
By /s/ Ernest Fleischman
ERNEST FLEISCHMAN
Attorneys for Respondent Union
230 Park Avenue
New York, N. Y. 10017
Samuel M. Kaynard, Esq.
Regional Director
Region 29
National Labor Relations Board
16 Court Street
Brooklyn, N. Y.
The Austin Company, Inc.
450 West First Avenue
City of Roselle
New Jersev
15
BEFORE THE
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
Second Region
Case No. 29-CC-336
In the Matter of:
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, Hot WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VI-
CINITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638 OF THE PLUMBING &
PIPEFITTING INDUSTRY OF THE UNITED STATES AND
CANADA, AFL-CIO,
AND
THE AUSTIN COMPANY, INCc., Charging Party.
16 Court Street
Brooklyn, New York
November 15, 1972
BEFORE:
RAMEY DONOVAN, Administrative Law Judge
Appearances:
HOWARD EDELMAN, ESQ.
Counsel for the General Counsel
DELSON & GORDON, ESQS.
230 Park Avenue
New York, New York
Appearing on behalf of the Respondent
BY: ERNEST FLEISCHMAN, ESQ., of Counsel
16
[3] PROCEEDINGS
JUDGE DONOVAN: The hearing will be in order.
This is a formal hearing in the matter of the Enter-
prise Association of Steam, Hot Water, Hydraulic
Sprinkler, Pneumatic Tube, Ice Machine and General
Pipefitters of New York and vicinity, Local Union Num-
ber 638 of the United Association of the Plumbing &
Pipefitting Industry of the United States and Canada,
AFL-CIO, and the Austin Company, Inc., Case No. 29-
CC-0336.
Mr. Edelman, you may proceed.
MR. EDELMAN: Your Honor, this matter was tried
in a 10L proceeding before Judge Bruchhausen on No-
vember 2, 1972.
The facts brought out in the trial of that case [4]
would be the facts that would be brought out in the
trial of this complaint.
There were no issues of credibility with respect to
the 10L proceeding, and there are no issues of credi-
bility with respect to this case.
The facts really are not in dispute.
That being the case, your Honor, General Counsel
would like to propose that the record in the 10L proceed-
ing constitute the record in this proceeding, and that
would include—well, the record is from page 1 to page
142.
The particular case is Kaynard versus Enterprise,
Local 638, 72 Civil 1339.
The exhibits in connection with that case would be
part of the record.
Those exhibits would be Petitioner’s Exhibits 1
through 11 and Respondent’s Exhibit B.
* * * *
‘7! JUDGE DONOVAN: Now, Mr. Fleischman, do
you join in the proposed stipulation of Mr. Edelman
with respect to Exhibit 2, the transcript in the District
Court proceeding as constituting the record in this case?
MR. FLEISCHMAN: I do.
JUDGE DONOVAN: All right.
17
I’ll receive General Counsel’s Exhibit 2 into evidence,
which includes the transcript of testimony and the ex-
hibits referred to therein.
(Document referred to marked General Counsei’s
Exhibit 2 in evidence.)
& * * *
18
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
72-C-1339
SAMUEL KAYNARD, REGIONAL DIRECTOR OF REGION 29
OF THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, for and
on behalf of the NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
PETITIONER,
—against—
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, Hot WATER, Hy-
DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VI-
CINITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638 OF THE UNITED Asso-
CIATION OF JOURNEYMEN AND APPRENTICES OF THE
PLUMBING AND PIPEFITTING INDUSTRY OF THE UNITED
STATES AND CANADA, AFL-CIO, RESPONDENT.
United States Courthouse
Brooklyn, New York
November 2, 1972
10:30 o’clock A.M.
Before:
HONORABLE WALTER BRUCHHAUSEN,
U.S.D.J.
EMANUEL KARR
Official Court Reporter
'2| Appearances:
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
Attorney for Petitioner
BY: HOWARD EDELMAN, ESQ., of Counsel.
MESSRS. DELSON & GORDON,
Attorneys for Local 638
BY: ERNEST FLEISHMAN, ESQ., of Counsel.
* * + *
19
[26] MR. EDELMAN: Your Honor, the petitioner
will call as its first witness Robert Grand.
ROBERT S. GRAND, called as a witness on behalf of
the petitioner, having been duly sworn by His Honor,
Judge Bruchhausen, testified as follows:
Direct examination by Mr. Edelman:
Q Mr. Grand, are you employed by The Austin Com-
pany?
A Yes I am.
Q What is your position?
A District superintendent.
Q How long have you been employed by Austin?
A Going on thirty-nine years.
Q How long have you held the position of District
superintendent?
A Going on twenty-eight years.
Q Will you describe for us your job, which would
include the duties that you carry out.
[27] A _ Yes.
I plan the project, I schedule the project, I assign
the Austin key personnel to the project, I remove them
from the project at the proper times; I visit the project
on a regular basis, discussing with the superintendent
regarding the problems that come up regarding the
progress of the work, I conduct and arrange for meet-
ings between Austin personnel and subcontractors on
the project in order to tie in the work of the various
people.
THE COURT: Let me just come back a ways.
What position is Austin in, what do they do?
MR. EDELMAN: They are the general contractors,
they are building it and they are also the engineer, they
design it.
THE COURT: I see.
A (continuing) And finally I see to it that the job
is properly completed and turned over to the union.
Q In your capacity as district manager or district
superintendent, do you supervise more than one project
at a time?
A Yes I do.
20
Q Have you been supervising, among other projects,
the construction of the Norwegian Home?
A Yes.
[28] Q In connection with the Norwegian Home job,
can you describe in general the duties of The Austin
Company in connection with its capacity as general con-
tractor of the job.
A The duties of The Austin Company are actually
passed on through me as the head of construction, with
duties similar to what I have stated, plus the prepara-
tion of the drawings and the specifications which are
put out for bids.
Q Well, let me ask you, what does Austin actually
do in connection with the job, do they contact any of the
operations on the job itself?
A Yes. We bill the complete project, and as such we
ourselves are employers of labor, carpenters, bricklayers,
cement finishers, ironworkers and operating engineers.
We sub-contract electrical and mechanical trades, the
mechanical trades including plumbing, the sprinkler
work, the heat, ventilation and air conditioning. We
also sublet specialties such as the asbestos tile flooring,
ceiling work, carpeting and various things similar to
that.
Q You have already indicated that Austin has drawn
up the plans and specifications for this job.
A Yes.
(29; Q Can you tell me what the plans and specifica-
tions for a job include, describe them so that a reader of
the record might get a visual picture of them.
A Yes.
The Austin Company is responsible for the design of
the complete project. In doing this they prepare draw-
ings and specifications for all of the various subcon-
tractors, plus the specifications necessary for the pur-
chase of material. The drawings are quite elaborate on
a project such as this. I haven’t counted them, but it
could consist of forty or fifty drawings, specifications
could consist of two hundred pages of material, the par-
ticular specifications for the HVAC—
21
Q Excuse me, HVAC, what would that mean?
A Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning.
HVAC, for example, is basically a 65 page specifica-
tion and it does call for supplements to those specifica-
tions for items of equipment purchased by others which
will be incorporated to the work by the heating, ven-
tilating and air conditioning subcontractor, and those
pages might add twenty or so pages to the work in
question.
Q With respect to the HVAC specifications, was there
a section of those specifications which related specifically
to room heating and air conditioning units?
A There is a reference in the basic heating, venti-
lating {30] and air conditioning specifications which
refer to another specification as part of the contract of
work to be performed by this contractor, although pur-
chased by others, and there were the specifications cover-
ing the Slant/Fin units.
Q In other words, part of the engineering specifica-
tions drawn up by Austin covered specifically the Slant,
Fin units.
A Yes, sir.
MR. EDELMAN: I would like to have this document
marked as petitioner’s exhibit 1 for identification.
THE CLERK: Five page document headed, Specifica-
tion 202 for room heating and air conditioning units for
the Norwegian Christian Home Health Facility is marked
for identification petitioner’s exhibit number one.
So marked.
BY MR. EDELMAN:
Q Mr. Grand, I show you exhibit one for identifica-
tion and ask you if you have ever seen it before and do
you recognize it?
A Yes, I think these are the specifications drawn up
by the Austin engineering department for the purchase
of these units and for shipment to the heating, ventila-
tion and air- {31]| conditioning contractor as part of his
work, namely, the installation of these units.
22
Q In other words, this would cover the type of units
to be used on the job and how it is to be installed and
the specifications that the units shall cover?
A Yes, sir. 4 " 3
THE CLERK: Document marked for identification
plaintiff's exhibit one now received in evidence.
BY MR. EDELMAN:
Q Mr. Grand, I would ask you if you were to read
aloud the first paragraph in the specifications.
A It reads:
“furnish at the job site Slant/Fin Climate [32] Com-
mand Air Conditioners. The unit shall be complete with
cabinet, filters, cooling chassis, heating coil, fans, main
water flow and condensate assembly, controls, vent door,
outdoor air plenun and outdoor air grille.”
Q Now, turn to the third page of the exhibit, as part
of the specifications which relate to the main water flow
and condensate assembly, I would ask you if you would
read that section, please.
A The part reads:
“the main water flow and condensate assembly shall
be factory installed as an integral part of the unit by
the manufacturer. The assembly shall be of copper con-
struction tested to 150 psi leakage. Two shut off valves
shall be provided to isolate the cooling chassis from the
main line water supply for servicing. An automatic
three-way valve shal! be incorporated in this assembly to
respond to the contro] panel’s demand for cooling or
heating. It will be directing water flow either through
the water cooled condenser of the cooling chassis or to
the hot water coil mounted in the lower part of the
cabinet.”’
THE COURT: Do I take it that not only does the
Slant/Fin manufacture but the specifications call for
them to install, too: is that it?
MR. EDELMAN: In other words the specifications
[33] set forth the particular type of units to be used,
the model number, full and in detail, and the specifica-
tions further provide that the internal piping of main
23
water through the condensate assembly shall be piped
and connected by employees of Slant/Fin.
THE COURT: I see.
{837} Q Is Austin performing the HVAC work on the
job?
A The Austin Company has subcontracted the HVAC
work—
THE COURT: He is asking whether the company
itself, I think counsel is not asking at the moment about
the subcontractor.
A The Austin Company is not performing the work
of the subcontractor.
[38] Q Was this work subcontracted?
A Yes it was.
Q And to whom was it subcontracted?
A To the Hudik-Ross Company, Inc.
Q Was there a written subcontract executed between
Austin and Hudik-Ross?
A Yes, there was.
Q Were employees of Hudik-Ross members of this
Union?
A Yes, as I understand it.
MR. EDELMAN: I would like to have this document
marked as Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.
THE CLERK: Six-page document headed the Aus-
tin Company, Lump Sum Sub-Contract, marked for iden-
tification as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 2.
MR. EDELMAN: Is it correct that Hudik-Ross em-
ployees were members of Local 638, Mr. Fleishman?
MR. FLEISHMAN: Yes. That is correct. They were
members oi Local 638.
* * * -_
THE CLERK: Purchase order from the Austin [39]
Company dated January 14, 1972, marked for identifica-
tion as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 3.
+ * * o
THE CLERK: Two-page letter from Slant/Fin to
Mr. Walter Bogucki, dated January 19, 1972, marked
for identification as Plaintiff’s Exhibit number 4.
24
[40] Q Is it your statement that the three docu-
ments that you have, Exhibits 2, 3 and 4, constitute a
subcontract between the Austin Company and Hudik-
Ross?
A Yes, sir.
+ 7 eo o
(42) Q All right.
Mr. Grand, in connection with the sub-contract, was
it Hudik’s responsibility to purchase the required unit?
A It was not.
Q And who purchased the required units?
A The Austin Company.
* aa * o
[43} Q Mr. Grand, I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit
marked for identification number 5 and ask you if you
recognize it?
A I do recognize it but—
Q@ Can you tell me what that is?
A That this is a change order to the original order,
which is attached, and really should be marked as a
separate exhibit because that precludes the other one
(indicating).
This (indicating), the original purchase order, that
is the original purchase order, the other one (indicat-
ing) is a change to that purchase order.
Q Would it be fair to say that the second page of
ine Exhibit is the purchase order?
A That is correct.
Q And that the first page is an amendment to the
purchase order?
A Correct.
Q And that the third page is also part of the [44]
original purchase order?
* * a o
THE CLERK: Document marked for identification
as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 5, now received in evidence.
* * > *
Q With respect to the Slant/Fin unit and in con-
nection with the sub-contract between Austin and Hudik,
what was Hudik’s responsibility concerning the unit?
25
A Hudik should receive, unload, new to place of in-
stallation, install and pipe to it and try it.
Q In other words, connect up the unit so that it
was operable?
A Correct.
Q Basically then, would you say its job was one of
installation?
A Yes, sir.
Q By the way, how did Hudik come about being
awarded the sub-contract?
[45] A By competitive bidding.
MR. EDELMAN: Id like to have this document
marked as Petitioner’s Exhibit 6.
THE CLERK: Installation instructions marked for
identification as Exhibit number 6.
* * * *
Q Mr. Grand, have you ever seen Petitioner’s Ex-
hibit marked for identification 6?
A Yes, I have.
Q Can you tell me what that is?
A It is prepared by Slant/Fin and submitted to the
Austin Company giving a general description of the
unit, of their units furnished.
Q_ Is it the Slant/Fin climate command unit?
A Yes, it is.
Q Are those the units that were used on the job?
A Yes.
Q_ I see.
The accompanying diagram, is that a diagram of the
unit used on the job?
A Yes, sir.
Q With all the installation instructions?
A Correct.
(46] Q Would the main water flow and condensate
assembly be set forth on that diagram?
A The piping shown, it is not diagramed to say—
it does show the gate valves, it does show the couplings,
it does show the control.
Q In other words, there are certain pipes—
26
A The pipes that are visible are the water and con-
densate connections.
* * * *
THE CLERK: Diagram marked for identification as
Petitioner’s Exhibit 6, now received in evidence.
me * _ *
[47] Q Now, referring to that document, you indi-
cated that there was certain piping that was part of the
main water flow and condensate assembly that was rep-
resented on the diagram at page 3; is that correct, sir?
A Yes, sir.
MR. EDELMAN: Your Honor, I wonder if we can
mark off that piping that represents part of the main
work flow and condensate assembly so it may be re-
ferred to and be referred to it by myself.
THE COURT: You may do it.
Q Mr. Grand, would you circle the area that rep-
resents the main water flow and condensate assembly
piping?
A All right.
(The witness encircled the point indicated,)
MR. EDELMAN: May the record indicate that the
diagram on page 3, the top diagram on page 3 has been
circled twice in red ink by Mr. Grand as the areas
which indicate the piping which is a part of the main
water flow and [48] condensate assembly.
* * * *
Q I say did there come a time when the Slant, Fin
units were delivered to the Norwegian job site?
A Yes, sir.
Q And when did that take place, on or about?
[49] A On or about the middle of June.
Q That would be 1972, I assume?
A 1972.
Q What was the purpose of these units?
A These units provided the heating and cooling of
a majority of the rooms in the building, the rooms
occupied or to be occupied by the residents of the build-
ing.
* * * *
27
Q Is there a unit in each room?
A There is a unit in each of the rooms that I
described.
[50] Q In connection with the Norwegian job site,
does Austin employ members of the steamfitting trade?
A No, we do not.
Q Does Austin have any contact with Local 638 or
any other steamfitting labor organization?
A The Austin Company does have a national agree-
ment with UAS, of which Local 638 is a part, but this
is not for this type of work.
Q What type of work is it for?
A It is mainly process installation.
Q What is process installation?
A Process as differs from comfort, heating of a build-
ing, cooling of a building is all part of comfort work;
processing involves machinery and equipment feeding
any kind of gases, water, steam or anything else.
Q Was there any contract with Local 638 to per-
form any of the work, did Austin have a contract with
Local 638 to perform any work on the Norweigan job?
A We had no contract with Local 638.
[52] CROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR. FLEISHMAN:
Q When Hudik-Ross bid on this job, the specifica-
tions were made available to Hudik-Ross?
A Yes, sir.
Q And the specifications called for Slant/Fin units?
A Yes, sir.
Q So Hudik-Ross knew that as part of the heating
maintenance and air conditioning work, if the contract
was awarded to it, it would have to install Slant/Fin
climate control units?
A Yes, sir.
Q And this matter of the Slant/Fin unit wasn’t
brought to Hudik-Ross’ attention after the contract was
awarded to it; am I correct?
28
They knew about it before they got the job that this
was part of the work they were going to do?
[53] A Yes, sir.
Q Now they also had the specifications given to them
which related to the Slant/Fin units?
A Yes, sir.
Q And are these (indicating) the specifications?
I show you Plaintiff's Exhibit number 1.
A These are the specifications covering the Slant,
Fin units.
Q And these specifications were drawn by Austin?
A Austin Engineering.
Q Now, in the specifications there are certain words,
sentences, which are underlined.
Were they in the original specifications?
A They were not.
Q They were not?
A The underlining, the words were in the specifica-
tions, the underlining was not.
* * * =
[54] Q Now I call your attention to page 201-3 of
Petitioner’s Exhibit 1 in evidence and ask you, does that
relate to the work in dispute at this time?
A Would you repeat that, what part of it are you
asking me about?
Q The parts that are underlined.
A It does relate to the dispute in question as it has
been shown to me.
THE COURT: This was Exhibit 1?
MR. FLEISHMAN: That is correct, page 201-3.
Q And that states that this work is to be factory
installed?
A Correct.
[55] Q This was part of the specifications on which
Hudik-Ross bid on this particular job?
A Yes.
Q And the job was awarded to Hudik-Ross in Jan-
uary 1972?
A Correct.
29
[58] Q Mr. Grand, I show you Respondent’s A for
identification, and in general terms what would you call
it?
[59] A A bulletin put out by Slant/Fin showing their
climate command self-contained heating and cooling unit.
* * * *”
{60} Q I ask you to turn to page 3 of Respondent’s
Exhibit A for identification and to turn to page 3 of
Petitioner’s Exhibit 6 in evidence and cumpare the two
and tell me whether they refer to the same unit.
A They don’t appear to me to talk about the same
unit.
Q Will you read me the numbers of the models as
set forth in Petitioner’s Exhibit 6?
A The WC6, WC9, WC12 and WC16.
eo * * *
Mr. Grand, I ask you to look at Petitioner’s—
Respondent’s Exhibit A, on page 3, and they have the
model numbers there.
Can you read the model numbers which this brochure
{61] covers?
A The model numbers are WC6. WC9, WC12 and
WCl16.
Q And those are exactly the same numbers that ap-
pear on Petitioner’s Exhibit 6?
A That is correct.
* * * *
Q Mr. Grand, I ask you to look at page 4 of Re-
spondent’s Exhibit for identification and read it, Re-
spondent’s Exhibit A, and read the last paragraph on
that page.
A It reads:
“Monoflo tees by-pass and three-way valves shown are
an integral part of each unit and are factory-installed
within the cabinet.”
Q Did you leave out a word there?
A_ I don’t believe so.
Q What is the first word in that paragraph?
A “Note.”
30
Q I don’t think you read that.
A Well—
Q Now, this was called to the attention of people,
wasn’t it, wasn’t it, this is something special?
A Yes.
{63} MR. EDELMAN: Your Honor, I am going to
object to this whole line of questioning, there is nothing
in the complaint that specifies, and [64] as a matter of
fact we concede that the steamfitters have performed
other work in connection with their subcontract except
the work related to the Slant Fin units.
-_ * * *
Q Let us clarify this one point.
The Austin Company has a contract with the In-
ternational Union?
A Yes, sir.
Q But it doesn’t cover this type of work?
A No, sir.
Q So that in effect the Austin Company has no ~!
lective bargaining agreement with this or any other
steamfitting union covering this type of heating, ventilat-
ing and [65] air conditioning?
A Correct.
& e a &
Q Directing your attention to Petitioner’s Exhibit 1,
page 3, and the paragraph referring to the main water
flow and condensate assembly which has been underlined,
you say the original specifications did not contain that
underlining; is that correct?
A Correct.
Q Other than that, that is an exact photocopy of the
original specifications?
A Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know who underlined that particular sec-
tion?
A I did.
e * + a
[66] Q And in what connection did you underline it?
A In connection with this dispute now.
eal
31
Q In other words, to point out the places that are
in dispute. : . ,
[72] PETER PLATH, called as a witness, having heen
first duly sworn by the Clerk of Court, testified as
follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. EDELMAN:
Mr. Plath, are you current employed?
Yes.
And your employer’s name?
The Austin Company.
How long have you been employed by Austin?
Since 1959 with the exception of two years in the
What is your present position with Austin?
Project superintendent.
Are you connected with the Norwegian job?
Yes. ; :
What is your position in connection with this job?
Project superintendent.
73] Q Have you been project superintendent from
the inception of this project?
A Yes.
Q When was that?
A Late September in 1971.
Q Can you describe for us your duties as a project
superintendent in this job?
A To direct Austin employees on the job, coordinate
activity of sub-contractors and assure that the job is
done according to plans and specifications.
Q In connection with your authority and duties, do
you have authority to hire and fire employees if need be?
Yes.
Are you a member of Local 638?
No.
Are you a member of any labor organization?
No.
be]
Zro po>oOs pOrore
> OPO Pp
32
Q Did there come a time in connection with your
job as the superintendent of the job when the Slant Fin
units arrived at the job site?
A Yes.
Q When did this take place?
A They came in two shipments, one on the 14th of
June, 72, and the second shipment was on the 21st of
June, ’72.
(74) Q How many units in total were on both ship-
ments?
A In total it was 114.
Q_ Individual units?
A Yes,
Q Identical units?
A Not identical. I believe there are three or four
different types.
Q Did they all contain the same prepiped water main
flow and condensate assembly?
A Yes.
Q I direct your attention to the latter part of June,
say the last week in June, and I ask you if you can
recall having a conversation during this period with a
Mr. William Daly.
A Yes.
Q Can you tell me who Mr. William Daly is?
A The business agent of the Steamfitters local in
New York City.
Q Have you ever had any dealings with Mr. Daly
before this conversation?
A No. I had met him before, but that was it.
Q Were you informed that he was a representative
or an agent or delegate of Local 638 on those occasions?
(75; A Yes,
* * * *
Q You indicated that you had a conversation with
Mr. Daly.
Can you teil me where the conversation took place?
A On the job site outside of the building.
Q As closely as you can, when did this conversation
take place?
A The 22nd of June.
33
On or about the 22nd of June?
Yes.
Morning or afternoon?
Shortly before noontime.
Can you describe the conversation that took place?
[76] A He stated that his men would not install the
Slant Fin units as the piping inside those units was
steamfitter’s work.
Q Do you know George Zimmerman?
A Steamfitter foreman for Hudik-Ross.
* * * *
Q Do you have any—do you know whether he is a
member of any labor organization?
A_I believe he is a member of the Steamfitters Union
of New York City.
OPO PO
Q Would that be Local 638?
A Yes. .
Q You said he is employed by Hudik-Ross’
A Yes.
Q Is he on the job site, the Norwegian Home?
A Yes.
Q Does he work there every day?
A Yes.
Q In connection with the Slant Fin units, do you
recall having any conversations at any time with (77)
Mr. Zimmerman?
A Yes.
Q Was it one conversation or more?
A It was almost on a regular basis.
Q When you say “regular basis,” how regular, daily,
weekly, monthly?
A At times daily, at other times twice a week, other
times weekly.
Q Over what period of time did you have these
conversations?
A In about the end of June to the present time,
with the exception of the period while they were on
strike, which was between the first week of July to
August 7th. ;
Q Were these conversations that you had with Mr.
Zimmerman concerning the Slant Fin units, were they
similar conversations or did they widely differ?
34
A No, they were always the same.
Q Well, tell me as best you can, what the sum and
substance of these conversations were?
A I would ask the question when are you going to
start hooking up the Slant/Fin units, and the answer
in general would be, I haven’t got the go ahead from
the unit.
(78| Q As project engineer, would you know when
the unit should have been installed?
A As project superintendent.
Q I'm sorry, project superintendent.
A The original schedule called for installation to
start the first week in July and run over a period of
five to six weeks.
The fact that they did go on strike on the 1st of July,
they came back to work on August 7th. At that time
they should have started installing the Slant/Fin units.
Q Had there been no strike, the installation should
have taken place in July?
A Exactly.
Q But the strike intervened?
A Yes.
Q But was concluded in August?
A Right.
Q And you claim thereafter the installation should
have taken place?
A Yes.
* * * e
(79| Q Mr. Plath, I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit
marked No. 7 for Identification, and ask you if you ever
have seen that before.
A Yes.
Q Can you tell us what it is?
A It’s a schedule which indicates the progress of
the various major items on the job.
Q Who prepared it?
A I did.
Q Is there any reference on this schedule to Hudik-
Ross in connection with the Slant/Fin unit?
35
A Yes. On the second page under H.V.A.C., the item
marked “Permimeter radiation and fin units.”
Q That would be abbreviated “Per. rad. & fin units’”’”
A Right. . .
[80] Q Bearing in mind that the strike ended on
August 7th, when then should, based on this chart, when
then should the work have begun and when should the
work have been concluded?
A It should have started on the 7th of August and
continued for six weeks, which would bring us to the
last of the week of September 11th.
Q By the middle of September, the work would have
been concluded?
A That’s right.
* * * *
{82} Q Mr. Plath, I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit
marked for identification No. 8, and ask you if you have
ever seen that before?
A Yes.
Q Will you tell us what it is?
A It is the minutes of the meeting held on the 29th
of June, ’72.
Q Did you prepare those meeting minutes?
A Yes.
Q Is there any reference to the Slant/Fin units in
those minutes?
A Yes, on the third page, paragraph B.
Q Would you read that?
A “Slant/Fin units 114, by Austin. On-job hookup
of same being handled by F. Hudik. Steamfitters Union
[83] states they will not hook up same as they are pre-
assembled.”
Q On what—how did that statement come to be in
the minutes—
MR. FLEICHMAN: I object. But anyway, I will
stipulate that that was so.
36
(88] FRANK HUDIK, called as a witness, having been
first duly sworn by the Clerk of the Court, testified as
follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. EDELMAN:
Q Mr. Hudik, are you connected with the corpora-
tion, Hudik-Ross?
A Yes, I am.
Q What is your connection with that corporation?
A Iam the president of that corporation.
Q What type of corporation is Hudik-Ross?
A Mechanical contracting company that does heat-
ing, ventilating and air-conditioning work.
Q Are you in any way connected with the Norwegian
Home for the Aged job?
A Yes,
Q And what is your connection?
A We are performing the mechanical contracting
work such as heating, ventilating and air-condition.
Q Is that under a sub-contract?
A Yes, with The Austin Company.
Q I show you Petitioner’s Exhibits 2, 3 and 4, and
ask you if you will look at them and tell me if you
ever have seen those before and if you have, tell me what
|89| they are.
A Sub-contract for the particular job known as the
Norwegian Christian Home for the Aged.
* * * *
Q How did you become to be awarded this sub
contract?
A We bid for the job and we were the low bidder.
(90; Q As part of your sub-contract with Austin,
were you required to install Slant. Fin climate control
units?
A Yes, we were.
Q In connection with this unit, what was the sum
and substance of the work you were required to per-
form?
37
A There were plans and specifications stipulated for
the job. The specifications stipulated that we were to
receive and install the Slant, Fin units in the building.
Q You are talking about the—is this your sub-
contract which required this?
A With The Austin Company, yes, to receive and in-
stall these units.
Q Were there also specifications, job specifications,
in connection with your work as H.V.A.C. contractor?
A Yes.
Q Did these job specifications also relate to the
Slant/Fin unit?
A Yes.
Q Did you look at the job specifications in this con-
nection?
{91} A When we did the job?
Q At any time.
A Yes.
Q And did the job specifications require Slant, Fin
units?
A The job specifications stipulated that somebody
else, The Austin Company, would furnish the units, the
Slant/Fin units to us for installation by us.
The specification so stipulated.
Q Do you recall the specification stipulating any-
thing concerning the main water flow and condensator?
A The specifications stipulated that the main water
flow and assembly was to be fabricated, installed and
pretested at the factory.
Q Did you have any authority to substitute any
other unit to replace the Slant/Fin unit?
A No.
Q Did you have authority to alter in any way the
job specifications for this job?
A No.
Q Did you have authority to take apart and re-
assemble the main water flow and condensate assembly
in the field?
A No.
[92] Q I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit 6, a diagram
of the Slant/Fin unit, and I ask you if you can identify
38
on that diagram on page 3, the visible parts of the main
water flow and condensate assembly.
A Basically as outlined in red with the addition of a
line running through the unit from the left-hand side of
the illustration to the right-hand side of the illustration.
Q Using again this diagram, as a guide, what would
be your job in connection with the installation of this
unit?
A To connect to an inlet on one side of the unit ex-
terior to the casing and connect to the opposite side of
the unit, exterior, to the casing.
Q Would it be a fair description to say that in the
room the unit was to be installed with two pipes, ap-
preximately in a space between the two pipes the width
of the unit and these pipes were to be connected to the
unit?
A That’s correct.
Q Can you mark on that diagram where the pipes
would be connected?
A Well, the other one because of the isometrics here.
MR. EDELMAN: Let the record show the [93] wit-
ness has indicated his answer by a black “X” on the
diagram.
Do you have a regular complement of employees?
Yes.
About how many in your complement?
Are you referring specifically to steamfitters?
I am referring specifically to steamfitters.
Anywhere between 10 and 20 steamfitters.
And that would depend on the number of jobs un-
der construction?
A That’s correct.
Q The size of the job?
A That’s right.
Q These steamfitters you have in your employ, are
they represented by any labor organization?
A Yes.
Q And that labor organization is what?
A Local 638.
Q Do you have a collective bargaining agreement with
Local 638?
A Yes, we do.
OPO PO PO
a
a
39
Q Is there a present collective bargaining agreement
with Local 638?
A Yes.
{194} Q Have you had a prior series of agreements of
collective bargaining with Local 638?
A Yes.
Mr. Hudik, I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit,
marked for identification, Nos. 9 and 10, and ask you to
look at them, and I ask you if you have seen them efore
and if you have, tell me exactly what they are.
A Exhibit No. 9 is the working agreement, a work-
ing [95] agreement that we had with the Enterprises
Association, Local Union 638. It is dated ’66 and then
’69. ’69 terminates.
Exhibit No. 10 is an interim agreement which we
signed with the Local 638 to allow us to work during a
period of June 30, 1972, to June 30, 1973.
Q Would the ’66—’69 agreement, is that incorporated
and part of your present agreement?
A Yes.
Q The addendum just modifies the working agree-
ment to bring up the wage schedules and other amend-
ments to date?
A Yes.
Q You had a similar amendment to the agreement
which expired in 1972?
Yes.
And when did the agreement expire in 1972?
In June.
Of 1972?
Yes.
Q I direct your attention to the working agreement,
specifically directing your attention to Rule 9 of the
working agreement, and I ask you to look it over.
A ° Yes, I am familiar with it.
[96] Q Is Rule 9, as it is contained in this exhibit,
in your present contract?
A Specifically?
Q Yes.
A I don’t know how to answer the question.
PO POP
40
We don’t get an additional contract, we get just amend-
ments and the amendments specifically spell out just the
changes in the contract.
Q Has the amendment changed Rule 9?
A No, it has not.
Q Did the prior amendment change Rule 9?
A No, it has not.
* * * *
Q Did there come a time when the Slant Fin units
arrived on the job site?
A Yes.
Q Do you recall approximately when they arrived?
A I thought they arrived in August but I was cor-
rected [97] and I know they arrived in June.
Of 1972?
Yes, 1972.
* * eo *
Who is Arthur Chersin?
Arthur Chersin is an employee of ours.
What is his position?
Project engineer.
And what was the conversation—
An estimator.
* * * *
POPOPO PO
I direct your attention to September 15th on or
about that time and ask if you had knowledge whether
the Slant /Fin units had been installed as of that date?
A They had not been installed as of that date.
[98] Q And should they have been installed as of that
date?
A They should have been started. The installation
of the Slant/Fin units should have been started in ac-
cordance with the progress of the job.
* * * *
[100] Q Mr. Hudik, * * * I direct your attention to
September 22nd, on or about that date, and ask if you
recall having a conversation with Mr. Daley at that
time?
A Yes, I co.
Q Where cid the conversation take place?
A It took place in a restaurant in New York.
41
What was the name of the restaurant?
Downey’s.
Can you tell us what the conversation was?
Mr. Daly and I were discussing the job and Mr.
Daly said that we were in violation of the contract,
the units received on the job were in violation of the
contract, [101] and that he could not allow us to install
the units as they existed on the job.
I told him that this was part and parcel of the plans
and specifications, and I had no choice in the matter,
but he insisted that we were in violation of Article 9,
and that he could not allow us to proceed.
Q Have the units been installed to date?
A No.
PO PO
CROSS-EXAMINATION
BY MR. FLEICHMAN:
o o * *
Q Were you the individual, Mr. Hudik, who checked
the plans and specifications on this job, prior to bidding
on the same?
A No.
Q Who did the estimating for you?
A Chersin.
Q Mr. Chersin?
A Yes.
[102} Q Did you bid the job personally?
A No.
Q You weren’t in charge of the bidding?
A That is a broad question.
Q Did you know what the job called for in the way
of heating, ventilation and air-conditioning?
A When we bid the job?
Q Yes.
A No.
Q When did you first find out about that you had
bid on the job?
A Just after the job was bid and we were told that
were [sic] were in the running.
42
Q Did you inquire as to what was called for in the
way of heating, ventilating and air-conditioning work?
A When? .
Q At anytime prior to the awarding of the job
to you.
A No.
Q And who was in charge of that?
A Mr. Chersin.
+ a & e
[104] Q Did you know whether there was any work
to be done there by the manufacturer at this factory
rather than at the job site, that is, piping, branch
piping, convectors, condensate assemblies, etc.?
A At what time are you asking me this?
Q Shortly after you obtained the contract.
[105] A _ I did know.
Q You did know?
A Of course I did.
Q But Mr. Chersin had read the specifications before
the contract was awarded to your company?
A I can’t tell you what Mr. Chersin did.
Q Who signed the bid letter? .
A I don’t recall.
Q How many men are in the administrative end
of your business?
A About 10.
Q And who signs the bid letters, usually?
A Usually the estimator signs the bid letters.
Q And he is authorized to do that?
A Yes.
Q And in accordance with the practice in your busi-
ness, the estimator reads the plans and specifications
and calculates how much he can do the job for, and then
signs the bid letter; is that correct?
A Yes.
Q And in this particular job, Mr. Chersin did the
estimating?
A That’s correct.
5 ei lille
43
[108] Q You had had collective bargaining agree-
ments with Local 638 for many, many years?
A Yes.
* * * *
Q I show you Respondent’s Exhibit B for Identifica-
tion and ask you whether that is your signature.
{109} A _ Yes, it is.
Q And this contract covers the period ’69 through
June 30th, I think, of 1972?
A June 30, 69 to ’72, oh, yes. Right.
Q This agreement, that is the one which is Re-
spondent’s Exhibit B in Evidence, incorporates by ref-
erence, does it not, Rule 9 which appeared in the 1966-
69 agreement, Petitioner’s Exhibit 9?
A Yes.
Q Petitioner’s Exhibit 10, which is the interim agree-
ment, effective July 1, 1972, contains or incorporates
all of the provisions of the old Rule 9, plus a few other
relating to identification of work done in the shop?
{110} A That’s correct.
Q So that from at least 1966 until the present time,
Rule 9, as originally set forth, has continued?
A That’s correct.
Q And when you met with Mr. Daly on September
22nd, he told you that your company was violating Rule
9 of the agreement?
A That’s correct.
& * * o
[111] Q Your estimator has the authority to sign bid
letters?
A Yes.
44
[115] GEORGE ZIMMERMAN, called as a witness,
having been sworn by the Clerk of the Court, testified
as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. EDELMAN:
Are you currently employed?
Yes.
Who is your employer?
Hudik-Ross.
How long have you been employed by Hudik-
OPO PO
Ross?
A About 13 years.
Q What is your present capacity with Hudik-Ross?
A The man in charge of the job of the Norwegian
Home.
Q Would that be a job foreman?
A Similar. We don’t specify foreman.
Q Have you been on the Norwegian Home job site
[116] since Hudik began working on it?
Yes.
Presently working on this job site?
Yes.
Are you a member of Local 638?
Yes.
How long have you been a member?
Twenty-two years.
Is there a shop steward on the Norwegian job
™”
SOPOLPOP,OD
OPO POLO PO p®,
Yes.
Is he a regular employee of Hudik-Ross?
Yes.
Is he there every day?
Yes.
What is his name?
George Zimmerman.
You are the shop steward?
Yes, I am.
I assume then, well, why don’t you state your
functions in connection with your capacity as a shop
steward?
ie A i: i ee
45
A Represent the union as far as our working agree-
ment goes.
[117| Q If a problem arises at the job site, do you
get in touch with the union?
A I notify the business agent.
Q Who would that be?
A Bill Daly.
Q Do you recall the time coming when the Slant/
Fin units arrived on the job site?
A Yes.
Q Did you unload them or take part in the unload-
ing?
A Yes, I did.
Q Had you connected them as yet?
A No.
Q Can you tell why you have not connected them?
A Well, the piping to me was in violation of our
contract.
Q That is why you didn’t connect them?
A Yes.
Q Did you tell any representative of Austin or
Hudik-Ross that you were not going to connect the
units because it was a violation of your contract?
A I notified my business agent first.
Q Mr. Daly?
[118] A Yes.
Q And did you receive any instructions from Mr.
Daly?
A To hold off until there was a decision made.
Q A decision made by whom?
A His superior or anyone further on.
Q Did you inform either representatives of Hudik-
Ross or Austin as to the union’s position?
A After Bill Daly was informed, yes, sir.
Q Who did you inform?
A Pete Plath, the job superintendent, and Art
Chersin.
Q You informed these individuals?
A Right.
46
Q Is it a fact that from time to time they asked
you whether or not you would be able to install the
units?
Right, yes.
Did you answer them on each occasion?
I answered them, yes.
And what was your answer?
That I couldn’t proceed with it.
And did you indicate a reason why?
Because it is the usual procedure that I had to
wait for a decision.
[119] Q Did you ever tell either Mr. Plath or Mr.
Chersin that the units were prepiped and that you
couldn’t install them for that reason?
A That is what the original thing was.
* & + *
CROSS-EXAMINATION
POPO POY
BY MR. FLEICHMAN:
Q Mr. Zimmerman, how long have you been a steam-
fitter?
A Twenty-two years.
Q How long have you worked for Hudik-Ross?
A Approximately 13 years.
Q And during all of this period, was Hudik-Ross
in contractural agreement with Local 638?
A Yes, he was.
Q Now, with respect to the Slant/Fin climate com-
mand unit, I show you Respondent’s Exhibit A, and ask
you to turn to page 3 and state whether this is a fair
representation of the unit?
(120) This is the unit of our job.
Q This is the unit?
A Right.
[121] Q Are there any other units on the market
similar to these?
A Yes, there is.
47
[122] Q Have you worked on any of these units?
A_ I worked on most of them.
Q And can you give me the name of, say, one unit?
A American Standard.
Q American Standard?
A Right.
Q Does it have an air-conditioning unit?
A Yes, it does.
Q Does it have hot water generated in the base-
ment?
A Yes, it does.
Q Does it have a bypass arrangement?
A No.
Q Does it have a condenser?
No.
Q Does it have a fan?
A Yes.
Q Now, the piping in that unit that is for the
connecting of various parts, who did that work?
A It was prefabricated on the job.
Q And what was done by Local 638 men on the job?
A All pipings to the stubs which is the final con-
nection [123] on the unit.
Q Was this done while you were employed by Hudik-
Ross?
A Yes.
A
* o o *
I show you Petitioner’s Exhibit 9 which is [124]
the 1966-69 contract and call your attention to Rule 9.
First of all, what is the title of that rule?
A “Cutting pipe and making up fittings.”
Q Under what language does the test of cutting
and connecting fabricating the water main flow and
condensate assemblies come?
A Under the heading ‘Radiator branches, coil con-
nections shall be cut and threaded by hand on the job,
in accordance with Rule 5.”
Q And Rule 5 refers to what?
A Two-man trade.
Q So that can you state whether or not this rule,
as you read it, has been applied consistently, to the
48
best ha your knowledge, in connection with work of this
type:
A On all jobs I have ever been on, it has been ap-
plied all the time.
Q As part of your duties, do you have to work in
accordance with plans and specifications?
A Yes, I do.
Q And did you have—and this applied also to this
particular job?
A Yes.
Q And were you able to—did you also have [125]
copies or a copy of Respondent’s Exhibit A?
A Yes.
Q And did you have any other material relating to
Slant /Fin units?
A Yes, the complete breakdown of the unit.
Q When the units were delivered, did you do any-
thing with respect to the units?
A Yes. I distributed them on the job and started
mounting.
Q Did you examine what was behind the faceplate?
A Yes, I did.
Q How did you do that?
A Taking the front cover off.
Q And then you saw the parts which you claim
came within Rule 9?
A Right.
Q What was the time juxtaposition or relationship
between when you took the cover off and saw what was
there, and you called Mr. Daly?
A The next day, that night. I couldn’t say exactly
= It was within the period of time that I unloaded
them,
[129] WILLIAM J. DALY, called as a witness, having
been first duly sworn by the Clerk of the Court, testified
as follows:
49
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. FLEICHMAN:
Q Are you associated with Local 638?
A Yes.
Q How long have you been a member of Local 638?
A Thirty-four years, excluding time in service, five
years in service.
Were you ever a working steamfitter?
A Yes, I was.
Q How many years?
A Twenty-two or twenty-three years.
Q What is your present position with the union?
A
Q
A
©
I am a business agent.
How many years have you been a business agent?
Eleven years.
. * . *
[130] Q Was the Norwegian Home for the Aged with-
in your territory?
A Yes, it is.
Q When did you first hear of the dispute in con-
nection with this Slant/Fin unit?
A Well, I had a call from my foreman that a truck-
load of these units came in and he asked me if I would
stop out to look at them.
The following day I was out on the job and there was
another truck there. They were unloading. Whether
it was the same truck or a new one, I am not sure.
Q When was that?
A The dates I am not too sure of.
Q Was there then a dispute as to certain work to
be done—
A Well—
[131] Q (Continuing)—with respect to the unit?
A With respect to the unit, the piping that was on
it, I met the superintendent there, Pete there, and I
mentioned there was a violation here.
Q What violations were you referring to?
A The violation of Rule 9 of the agreement.
50
And who was the agreement between?
Between 638 and Hudik-Ross Company.
Was the dispute with Hudik-Ross?
With Hudik-Ross, yes.
Did you have occasion to examine the unit?
Yes, I did.
Did you do that in connection or accompanied
by Mr. Zimmerman?
A I did.
Q What did you do in connection with the examina-
tion of the Slant/Fin unit? What did you see?
A I seen all the internal piping that was hooked
up to the coil which is usually done by the steamfitter
at the job site over the years I have been around.
Q Were there branches there?
A Branches, correct.
Q Did you inform Hudik-Ross as to whether any
provisions of the agreement was being violated?
(132) A Yes, I did.
Q Who did you inform?
A The first one I informed was the superintendent,
John Guilfoyle, and after that I informed Frank Hudik
himself.
Q What particular portion of the trade agreement
did you rely on?
A I relied on Rule 9, that all branch work should
be done on the job site.
Q Was this an innovation on the part of Local 638
or was it traditional?
A Well, in the years I have been around, I have
seen it happen once before with one of our contractors
and it was corrected. That is the only other time I ever
ran into it.
Q Otherwise, all other instances, who did the work?
A The steamfitter on the job site did it.
[133] FRANK HUDIK, called as a rebuttal witness,
having been previously sworn by the Clerk of the Court,
resumed the stand and testified further as follows:
OPO PO PO
neaataak
~ ew
TE ers. Mer
51
[135] CROSS-EXAMINATION
BY MR. FLEICHMAN:
[136] THE COURT: You may bring out what is the
situation with one and what are the specifics as to the
other.
Q All right. Let’s get down to this:
Did you tell Mr. Daly that Rule 9 did not apply to
this unit because of the nature of its construction?
A Yes.
Q Did you say that was so because the work had
been pre-assembled in Slant/Fin’s factory?
A Yes.
Q That was the reason why you told Mr. Daly [137]
that, because it had been pre-assembled in the Slant/
Fin factory?
A Pre-assembled and pretested.
Q In the Slant/Fin factory?
A Correct.
Q But you didn’t tell him that it wasn’t the work of
Steamfitters Local 638 because the contract didn’t pro-
vide for such work?
A Would you give me that again, please?
Q As I understand it, Mr. Daly told you that this
particular work was work belonging to the steamfitters,
in accordance with Rule 9 of the contract.
A Correct.
Q And your reply to him was, but it had already
been done at the factory?
A And pretested.
Q And pretested?
A Correct.
Q And that removed it, did you say, from Rule 9?
A I don’t remember whether I said anything like
t.
Q That’s right, you don’t remember that.
All you said is that it had been pre-assembled and
pretested?
A That’s correct, I think so.
52
[138] Q And Mr. Daly said but the contract is clear
that that—that this type of work has to be done on the
job?
A Mr. Daly said that we were in violation of Rule 9.
Q And your only reply to that was that the work
had been pre-assembled and pretested at the Slant/Fin
factory?
A I believe so. Words to that effect.
* * * +
[139] WILLIAM J. DALY, recalled as a witness, hav-
ing been previously sworn by the Clerk of the Court,
resumed the stand and testified further as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. FLEICHMAN:
Q Mr. Daly, when you had this conversation with
Mr. Hudik and you maintained that having the work
done in the Slant/Fin factory was a violation of Rule
9, what was Mr. Hudik’s reply to that?
A Well, the only thing I can recall is that he did
mention it wasn’t bought by him, the equipment, and
that was the end of it. He did not buy the equipment.
* * * -
What did he say with respect to Rule 9, any viola-
tion of Rule 9?
A I don’t know whether he agreed or disagreed. The
only reason he stated—the only statement that he made
to me was the fact that he did not buy this equipment.
He didn’t say whether it was a violation or wasn’t a
violation [140] one way or the other.
Q Did Local 638 at any time have a labor dispute -
with Slant/Fin because Slant/Fin does not or did not
have a collective bargaining agreement with Local 638
or employed members of 638?
A To my knowledge, never.
Q Did you ever speak to anybody of Slant/Fin?
A Never did. Definitely not.
me
eee
53
Q Did you ever attend any meeting at which a rep-
resentative of Slant/Fin was present?
A No, I did not.
Q Did you ever tell Mr. Hudik that you wanted a
collective bargaining agreement with Slant/Fin or you
wanted Slant/Fin to employ members of Local 638?
A Never did.
* + & *
54
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 1 ev. 72C1393
SPECIFICATION 201
ROOM HEATING AND AIR CONDITIONING UNITS
THE NEW HEALTH RELATED FACILITY
NORWEGIAN CHRISTIAN HOME FOR THE AGED,
b.OOKLYN, NEW YORK
THE AUSTIN COMPANY ROSELLE, NEW JERSEY
GENERAL
Furnish at the jobsite Slant/Fin Climate Command Air
Conditioners. The units shall be complete with cabinet,
filters, cooling chasis, heating coil, fans, main water flow
and condensate assembly, controls, vent door, outside
air plenum and outdoor air grille.
Each unit must fit in the space allowed and in no case
be greater than 9 inches in depth.
Materials, equipment—shall be first quality and in strict
accordance with all of the governing codes local and
state, laws, regulations, and ordinances including the
City of New York Building Code, Underwriters Labora-
tories, Inc.. NFPA, NEMA and Providence Washington
Ins., Co.
CAPACITY
Unit capacity shall be as indicated on the schedule on
sheet 204 dated 11-20-71 and on the drawings.
CABINET
Cabinet will be constructed of 18 gauge zinc coated cold
rolled steel that has been thoroughly degresed and
finished in a standard factory
55
FILTER
An expanded aluminum mesh washable filter will be
provided with the unit, so located that it can be re-
moved for cleaning without removing the Front Panel.
COOLING CHASSIS
The cooling chassis will be constructed of 18 gauge zinc
coated cold rolled steel with a baked prime coat grey
finish. This chassis will contain an evaporator coil of
aluminum fin and copper tube construction, a capillary
tube refrigerant flow control, a fully hermetic reciprocat-
ing R-22 compressor, a copper and steel construction
tube-in-tube water cooled condenser, an evaporator fan
and drain pan assembly, and associated electrical con-
trols.
The condensate drain pan wil! be constructed of 18 gauge
cold rolled steel, protected with a zine coating, with the
water collecting surfaces coated with a non-metallic
waterproofing compound.
The evaporater fan motor shall be a two speed, shaded
pole, thermally protected motor designed to operate on
115 volt or 208 volt CPS, single-phase, AC electrical
service, @s required by unit size.
There will be two aluminum forward curved centrifugal
blower wheels, one mownted on either end of the fan
motor, enclosed in blower housings. The blower wheels
shall be statically and dynamically balanced for quiet
operation.
The evaporator drain pan, fan motor and blower wheels
and housings will be assembled in such a manner as to
permit installation and removal as a unit for ease in
cleaning the drain pan.
MAIN WATER FLOW AND
CONDENSATE ASSEMBLY
The main water flow and condensate assembly shall be
factory installed as an integral part of the unit by the
manufacturer. The assembly shall be of copper con-
56
struction tested to 150 psi leakage. Two shut-off-valves
shall be provided to isolate the cooling chassis from the
main line water supply for servicing. An automatic
three-way valve shall be incorporated in this assembly
to respond to the control panel’s demand for cooling or
heating, thereby directing water flow either through the
water cooled condenser of the cooling chassis or to the
hot water coil mounted in the lower part of the cabinet.
The hot water coil shall be of copper tube and aluminum
fin construction.
& o @ 7
PIPE COVE MOLDING
Pipe cove molding will be installed in each room con-
taining Climate Command units to provide concealment of
piping along wall at floor level. Molding will run from
unit to wall and from unit to unit in rooms containing
more than one unit.
Pipe cove molding shall be constructed with 22 gauge
steel and shall be provided with mounting brackets to
support 114” copper tubing of the main loop, 34” con-
densate line and the cover. Finish shall be factory stand-
ard baked enamel in shell white.
ELECTRIC MOTORS
Motors shall be of General Electric Co., Westinghouse or
approved equal, induction types and shall be designed,
wound and built for quiet operation.
Motors shall be of the 40 degree C. ambient type and are
to be rated in accordance with the American Standards
for Rotating Electrical Machinery “(A.S.A.—C50 and
are to comply with the regulation of the National Elec-
trical Code.)
Motors below |. horse power shall be wound for 120
volt, 60 hertz single phase, alternating current; and
motors of !. horse power and above shall be for 208
volt, 60 hertz, 1 phase, alternating current.
Motor speeds shall not exceed 1800 RPM.
— ee
57
Name plate ratings shall not be less than brake HP of
equipment to be driven, in full range of operation con-
ditions.
Two speed motors shall be of the induction type, single
wound.
EXCEPTIONS
Any exceptions to this specification shall be listed in writ-
ing along with alternate prices listed in bid.
GUARANTEE
Manufacturer shall furnish a written guarantee for a
period of ome year after completion of installation and
start-up covering any defects in materials and work-
manship resulting from his work.
W.O. 70-1012 November 29, 1971
Room Heating and
Air Conditioning Units
58
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 2
THE AUSTIN COMPANY
LUMP SUM SUBCONTRACT
THIS SUBCONTRACT entered into this 14th day of
January, 1972, by and between THE AUSTIN COM-
PANY, an Ohio Corporation of Cleveland, Ohio (herein-
after called “CONTRACTOR”), and Hudik-Ross Co.,
Inc. (hereinafter called “SUBCONTRACTOR” ), for cer-
tain work to be performed by Subcontractor in connec-
tion with construction work being, or to be performed
by the Contractor for Norwegian Christian Home for
the Aged, Inc. (hereinafter called “OWNER”), at:
1255 Ovington Avenue, Brooklyn, N.Y.
WITNESSETH: That it is hereby agreed by and be-
tween the parties hereto as follows:
ARTICLE 1. Subcontractor shall provide all the neces-
sary materials and perform all of the following work, to
be installed on the premises of Owner in accordance with
terms and requirements of covering Purchase Order No.
1012-27, General Requirements, dated 1/4/71. The Spe-
cifications for pages SEE THE PURCHASE ORDER,
inclusive, dated And drawings SEE THE
PURCHASE ORDER.
ARTICLE 2. (a) The price to be paid by Contractor
and accepted by Subcontractor for the performance of
this Subcontract is Two Hundred & Sixty Nine Thousand
Five Hundred & Fifty & 00/100 Dollars ($269,550.00)
subject to deductions and additions as herein provided.
Payments on account shall be made: On the 20th day of
each month, following the month of performance, eighty-
five (85°: ) per cent of the cost of the work in place, as
approved by Contractor, and proportionate to the amount
of this Subcontract, for labor and materials acceptably
incorporated into the work up to the last working day of
the preceding month, less the aggregate of previous pay-
ments, provided that Subcontractor shall have paid in full
Re aaand
59
all bills for labor and materials, and if requested by
Contractor, shall have submitted to it receipted invoices
as evidence of payment of all accounts in full. The bal-
ance shall be paid thirty (30) days after entire comple-
tion and final acceptance. No certificate given or pay-
ment made (except the final certificate or the final pay-
ment) shall be evidence of the performance of this Sub-
contract either wholly or in part, and no payment shall
be construed to be an acceptance of defective work or
improper materials.
(b) No extra work shall be performed or paid for un-
less Contractor shall have issued, prior to the beginning
thereof, its written order therefor. No increase or de-
crease in the price of the work to be performed shall be
made, nor shall any claim be made for damages or antic-
ipated profits except upon the written approval of Con-
tractor.
(d) Contractor may disburse from monies owing by
it to subcontractor such sums as it may determine to
be necessary to pay for materials, equipment, labor or
supplies used, ordered, or delivered for incorporation into
work to be performed by subcontractor.
Should subcontractor, in case of dispute, fail to pay
claimed obligations for such materials, equipment, labor
or supplies, subcontractor shall post bond or securities
sufficient to protect Owner and Contractor against filing
of any lien or encumbrance against property of Owner.
(e) Subcontractor shall procure Contractor’s written
approval before subletting any portion of this Subcon-
tract for a sum exceeding five hundred ($500.00) dollars.
(f) Subcontractor, at Contractor’s option and expense,
shall furnish an approved Surety Company’s bond for
the performance of this subcontract.
ARTICLE 3. (a) Subcontractor shall substantially com-
plete the work under this Subcontract to the entire satis-
faction of Contractor and Owner, within ninety (90)
working days after the date Subcontractor begins, or is
instructed to begin, said work, whichever is earlier.
Time is of the essence of this Subcontractor.
60
(b) A working day is a day, exclusive of Sundays,
Saturdays and legal holidays, on which Subcontractor is
able to employ effectively more than fifty per cent (50% )
of the usual daily man hours (Job Staff excluded) for
regular working hours.
(ce) Should Subcontractor be delayed in the substantial
completion of said work by Contractor or Owner, fire,
strikes, lockouts, acts of public officials, embargoes or
war, then said time shall be extended for a period equiv-
alent to the time lost by reason of any of said causes,
but no such allowance shall be made unless a claim
therefor be presented in writing to Contractor within
twenty-four (24) hours of the occurrence thereof.
ARTICLE 4. Subcontractor shall submit for approval 3
copies of all shop or setting drawings and schedules re-
quired for his work. Contractor’s approval of such
drawings or schedules shall not relieve Subcontractor of
responsibility for errors of any sort in such shop draw-
ings nor of responsibility for deviation therein from
drawings and specifications furnished by Contractor un-
less Subcontractor has, in writing, advised Contractor of
such deviation.
ARTICLE 5. Guarantee—Subcontractor shall repair and
make good any damages, defects, or faults in Subcon-
tractor’s work or materials, including materials or equip-
ment partially or completely covered by manufacturer’s
guarantee, together with work of other trades disturbed
as a result of such repairs, that may appear within one
years after date of final acceptance. Subcontractor shall
also, within guarantee period, make any corrections or
adjustments necessary to meet specified performance re-
sults.
ARTICLE 6. (a) Contractor, at any time before com-
pletion of the work, may order additions, omissions or
alterations to or in the said work, materials or equip-
ment, but no such changes shall be made except by a
written order signed by Contractor in which the addi-
tional amount to be paid by it therefor or to be deducted
ee ee ry
oe ee
ee ee ee eee
tame > Shee
61
from said contract price, together with additional time,
if any, for the performance thereof, shall be stated. Unit
prices, if any are named in this Subcontract, shall be
used in determining the value of such changes.
(b) All clauses of this Subcontract shall apply to any
changes, omissions or extra work in like manner and to
the same extent as the work contracted for, and no
changes, omissions or extra work shall annul or invalidate
this Subcontract.
(ec) Should Contractor request Subcontractor to work
overtime in order to expedite the final completion of the
work, Subcontractor shall do so, and Contractor shall
pay therefor only the actual labor cost over the rate of
regular time for said overtime. Time slips covering said
overtime, must be submitted to, checked and approved
by Contractor at the site of the work. No commission or
overhead shall be paid to Subcontractor for or on ac-
count of said overtime. lf Subcontractor, in the opinion
of Contractor, unduly delays the progress of the work,
then, if requested by Contractor, Subcontractor shall at
its sole expense perform such overtime work as may be
necessary to finish said work within the specified time.
Contractor’s decision governing the necessity of said
overtime shall be final.
ARTICLE 7. (a) Subcontractor shall provide proper
facilities at all times for the inspection of the work by
Contractor, Subcontractor, within twenty-four (24)
hours after receiving written notice from Contractor to
that effect, shall proceed to remove from the ground or
buildings all material, whether worked or unworked,
condemned by Contractor, and take down all portions of
the work which Contractor shall by like written notice
condemn as unsound or improper, or as in any way fail-
ing to conform to the drawings and specifications.
(b) Subcontractor shall cooperate with Contractor and
all other subcontractors and materialmen employed on
the work in order to avoid complications and insure first-
class workmanship in every respect, and in the manufac-
turing, assembling and erection of the work shall em-
62
ploy only workers who are qualified, careful and efficient,
in strict conformity with the best standard practices.
ARTICLE &. (a) Subcontractor shall comply with all
laws relating to workmen’s compensation, occupational
diseases, wages and hours, taxes and contributions in
respect to unemployment insurance and all other laws
and regulations, state and federal, applicable to persons
directly or indirectly employed by said Subcontractor and
other persons on said work. Subcontractor shall main-
tain in force insurance protection in amounts agreed
upon covering Subcontractor’s liability under workmen's
compensation and occupational disease laws, Subcon-
tractor’s general liability (bodily injuries and property
damage) including contractual coverage for undertakings
under this Article and Subcontractor’s liability with re-
spect to the ownership and operation of automobiles. It
also agrees, when required by law, to make payments to
Subecontractor’s employees or their dependents and to
save Owner and Contractor harmless from all liability
for such payments. Should any part of this subcontract
be sublet, Subcontractor shall, in addition-to the fore-
going types of insurance, maintain Owner’s and Con-
tractor’s Protective Liability Insurance in the same
amounts, except that Owner’s and Contractor’s Protec-
tive Liability Insurance need not be maintained to the
extent that its subcontractors maintain the same cover-
ages required for Subcontractor. Certificates of all such
insurance shall be furnished to the Contractor.
(b) Subcontractor agrees to indemnify and save harm-
less Owner and Contractor against all liability for per-
sonal injuries, including death resulting therefrom, sus-
tained by any person directly or indirectly employed by
Subeontractor or its subcontractors, caused or alleged to
have been caused, directly or indirectly, by an act or
omission, negligent or otherwise, by Owner or Contractor
or persons directly or indirectly employed by them, and
to assume the defense of any action brought by persons
so injured or their personal representatives against
Owner or Contractor to recover damages for such in-
juries.
(c) Subcontractor also agrees to indemnify and save
harmless Owner and Contractor against all liability for
personal injuries, including death resulting therefrom,
and against all liability for property damage, sustained
by any other persons or corporations whatsoever, includ-
ing Contractor’s or Owner’s employees, caused or alleged
to have been caused, directly or indirectly, by any act or
omission, negligent or otherwise, on the part of Subcon-
tractor, or its Subcontractors, or persons directly or in-
directly employed by them and arising out of the per-
formance, or In any way connected with the performance,
of this contract, even though some act or omission, negli-
gent or otherwise, of Owner or Contractor or persons
directly or indirectly employed by them may also be a
cause or an alleged cause of such injury.
(d) The extent of the Subcontractor’s obligation un-
der Article 8 shall be governed by the law of the State
of Ohio.
ARTICLE 9. (a) Subcontractor agrees (1) to pay all
federal or state sales and use taxes or similar levies on
all material, tools and equipment furnished under this
subcontract, and (2) to assume all risk and liability for
loss or damage, however caused, to Subcontractor’s ma-
any such damage or injury suboccurring, without any
expense whatsoever to Contractor or Owner.
ARTICLE 10. (a) Subcontractor, for itself and all per-
sons, partnerships or corporations performing labor, do-
ing work or furnishing materials in and about the erec-
tion and construction of said work, hereby expressly
waives any and all liens of every kind or nature to which
it and/or they are or may be entitled under any A
Statute or otherwise. oo
64
(b) Subcontractor shall disclose this provision of this
Subcontract to all said persons, partnership or corpora-
tions before any such labor or work is performed or ma-
terial furnished and before any agreement with refer-
ence thereto is made by Subcontractor.
(c) Upon completion of all work required hereunder,
Subcontractor shall submit with its invoices an affidavit
by a qualified representative, to the effect that all obliga-
tions for labor and materials have been paid in full, ac-
companied by a waiver of lien rights.
ARTICLE 11. Subcontractor has thoroughly familiar-
ized itself with the building site conditions and with the
request for quotations, instructions to bidders, bulletins
issued prior to the date for receiving of proposals, form
of proposals, plans and specifications for said work, ma-
terial and equipment, and is familiar with the shipping
and delivery facilities and all other matters and condi-
tions which will affect the operation and completion of
said work and it assumes all risks therefrom.
ARTICLE 12. No assignment of this Subcontract or
any money due, or which may become due hereunder shall
be made without the written consent of Contractor.
ARTICLE 13. If Subcontractor becomes insolvent, or if
a petition in bankruptey be filed by or against it, or if
it should make a general assignment for the benefit of
creditors, or if a receiver should be asked or appointed
for it, or if it should refuse or fail, except in cases for
which extension of time is provided, to supply enough
properly skilled workmen or proper materials, or if it
should fail to make prompt payment to its subcontrac-
tors or for material or labor (except where the liens of
all such parties have been waived) or disregard laws,
regulations, ordinances or the instructions of Contractor,
or otherwise be guilty of a substantial violation of any
provision of this Subcontract, or should the Subcontrac-
tor at any time refuse to start said work promptly, neg-
lect to supply a sufficient number of properly skilled
workmen, or sufficient materials of the proper quality,
—_—— ~~ ee
—_——_ en ee ee
65
or fail in any respect to prosecute the work with prompt-
ness and diligence, or if Subcontractor fail in the per-
formance of any of the agreements herein contained.
Contractor may, after twenty-four hours’ written notice
to Subcontractor, provide any such labor or materials,
and deduct the cost thereof from any money then due
or thereafter to become due to Subcontractor under this
Subcontract; and at its option may terminate the em-
ployment of Subcontractor for the said work and ter-
minate this Subcontract and may enter upon the prem-
ises and take possession, for the purpose of completing
the work comprehended under this Subcontract, of all
materials, tools and appliances thereon, and employ any
other person or persons to finish the work, and provide
the materials therefor; and in any such case of such
termination of Subcontract or discontinuance of the em-
ployment, Subcontractor shall not be entitled to receive
any further payment under this Subcontract until the
said work shall be wholly finished, at which time, if the
unpaid balance of the amount to be paid under this Sub-
contract shall exceed the expenses incurred by Contrac-
tor in finishing the work and all other charge, expense
or damage, such excess shall be paid by Contractor to
Subcontractor; but if such expense and damage shall
exceed such unpaid balance, Subcontractor shall pay the
difference to Contractor.
ARTICLE 14. (a) ARBITRATION. In the event of
any disagreement arising under this Subcontract, it shall,
upon written notice of either to the other party, be sub-
mitted to three arbitrators for decision. Each party shall
choose one arbitrator within ten days after receipt of
such notice, the third to be chosen within ten days by
the two thus selected. However, if within the time stipu-
lated the two arbitrators appointed by the parties do
not agree upon a third or a party who has been notified
of a disagreement fails to appoint an arbitrator, then
a third arbitrator or an arbitrator to represent the party
in default, or both such arbitrators, may upon petition
of either party be appointed by a Judge of a Court of
general jurisdiction where the work is performed. The
66
decision of a majority of said arbitrators shall be final
and binding upon both parties to this contract. Such
arbitrators’ decision shall be delivered to each party in
writing on or before ten (10) days (or such further
time as the arbitrators may fix) after the submission of
any matter to them for their decision. Each party shall
pay the cost and expense of the arbitrator it selects, but
the cost and expense of the third arbitrator and the
remainder of the expense of the arbitration shall be borne
equally by the parties hereto, Arbitration proceedings
shall not take place until after the completion or alleged
completion of the work, except in a case where either
party claims that the disagreement is of such nature as
to make immediate arbitration proceedings necessary
while the evidence is available. Without the consent of
any interested insurance carrier, the foregoing provi-
sions of this Article shall not require arbitration of any
disagreements arising hereunder where any such dis-
agreement has to do with any claimed liability of either
party hereto which is protected in whole or in part by
insurance.
(b) This entire agreement shall be and become a part
of said purchase order by Contractor to Subcontractor
as fully as though the terms hereof were written in said
purchase order.
The foregoing agreement is binding upon the under-
signed, their successors, executors, administrators and
assigns.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have hereunto
subscribed their names the day and year shown in said
Purchase Order.
By
Subcontractor
THE AUSTIN COMPANY
By (illegible)
Contractor
——
67
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 8
FROM
THE AUSTIN COMPANY
450 W. First Ave.
Roselle, New Jersey 07203
PURCHASE ORDER No, 1012-27
On Each Package and Invoice
Name of Job
Norwegian Christian
Home for the Aged, Inc.
CHARGE TO or
Work Order No. 70-1012
Date of Delivery
Attn: Mr. Frank Hudkik,
Pres,
Tele: 212-L.W-4-2630
Date of Order January 14, 1972
NAME of
VENDOR Hudik-Ross Co., Inc.
Address 251 West 42nd Street, New York, N.Y. 10036
Deliver or Ship to The Austin Company
1255 Ovington Avenue
Brooklyn, New York.
Care of Norwegian Christian Home for th
Via Railroad or Truck ¥ TERM’ 5 agin Inc.
PLEASE FURNISH SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS BELOW:
68
PURCHASE ORDER AND SUBCONTRACT
Furnish all necessary labor, mechanics, tools equipment
and materials required for furnishing and _ installing
complete the Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning
work for the building we are constructing for the Nor-
wegian Christian Home for the Aged, Inc., Brooklyn,
New York in strict accordance with the Austin Company
Drawings 70-1012 sheets 201 to 208 inclusive all revised
1/7/72, Specification 200, Heating, Ventilation and Air
Conditioning, Pages i, ii, iii, 200-1 to 200-65 inclusive
all dated 11/19/71, addendum No, 1. Pages 200—addl 1
to 200—addl 16 inclusive all dated 11/20/71.
The following allied specification, indicating equipment
furnished and delivered by others for installation by this
sub-contractor are incorporated into this subcontract:
A. Specification 201 — Room Heating and Air Condition-
ing Units, Pages 201-1 to 201-6
inclusive all dated 11/29/71.
B. Specification 202 — Cooling Tower, Pages 202-1 to
202-3 inclusive all dated 11/9/71.
C. Specification 208 — Self Contained Air Conditioning
Units, Pages 203-1 to 203-5 in-
clusive all dated 11/30/71.
D. Specification 204 — Hot Water Gene: «tors, Pages
204-1 to 204-6 inclusive all dated
10/15/71 and addendum No. 1
Ada. 1-1 and Add 1-2 both dated
11/9/"*.
E. Specification 205 — Evapora:ive Coolers, Pages 205-1
to 205-4 inclusive all dated
10/15/71. Addendum No. 1 add
—l-1 dated 12/17/71.
F. Specification 206 — 10,000 Gallon Fuel Oil Tank,
Pages 206-1 and 206-2, and
Sketch 206-2.
69
G. Specification 207 — Heating and Ventilating Units,
Pages 207-1 to 207-5 inclusive all
dated 11/30/71.
“he above stated drawings and specifications initiated by
» th parties signing this subcontract are to be consid-
ered as subcontract drawings and specifications.
Not included in the scope of this work are the following
items:
A. Excavation and backfill.
B. Furnish and install linen chute.
C. Electrical Work
D. Furnish and install stack for Hot Water Gen-
erator.
E. Sales and Use Tax.
The hand written objections, Pages 1 and 2 affixed to this
purchase order and subcontract, is included and becomes
part of the subcontract documents.
Included in the amount noted in Article Two of the sub-
contract are the various changes as discussed on Janu-
ay 7th 1972 at the time the Letter of Intent was signed
y representatives of both The Austin Com
Hudik Ross Co., Ine. —
In accordance with the Austin Company Letter of Intent
dated January 7, 1972, a copy of the Slant Fin Commer-
cial Division Letter of January 13, 1972 addressed to
the Austin Company stating the Guarantee as requested
by this subcontractor is affixed to this purchase order and
subcontract. This document is incorporated into and
becomes part of this purchase order and subcontract.
The Honeywell recommended Climate Command Control
System attached hereto (noted in Slant Fin Letter of
January 13, 1972) is also included as part of the sub
contract documents.
Terms of Payment: Per Article Two of this Subcontract.
Equal Employment Opportunity Clause attached hereto
70
is incorporated into and becomes part of this Purchase
Order and Subcontract.
This subcontractor agrees to comply with all safety and
health standards as required by the Williams-Steiger
Occupational Safety & Health Act.
The attached conditions and General Requirements of
the Purchase Order shall be incorporated into and be-
come part of this Purchase Order and Subcontract.
In the event that The Austin Company authorizes this
subcontractor to perform additional work on a Time and
Material basis the following shall apply:
Actual cost of Material, Equipment and Labor in-
cludes Insurance, Taxes and Fringe Benefits plus
10°% for overhead and 10% for profit.
Tax Exemption Certificate is affixed to this purchase
order and subcontract.
HES/emk
The following Conditions form a part of this Order:
1 SHIPPING NOTICE—shall be mailed as soon as Material has
been forwarded, giving Order Number, Car Number and
Initials, also condensed description of Material otherwise
Vendor is liable to demurrage.
2 INVOICE IN TRIPLICATE. To mailing address above.
3 CAR LOADS—shall be loaded to minimum capacity—if not, the
Vendor agrees to pay the excess freight.
4 PATENTS—Vendor agrees to protect and hold harmless Pur-
chaser and Owner from and against aii and every demand or
demands of any nature or kind by reason of the use of any
patented invention, article or appliance, that has been or may
be adopted or used in the construction of any of the Material
or Articles called for on this Purchase Order.
5 CARTAGE OR PACKAGES—no charges will be allowed for
either.
6 INSURANCE—It is understood that Vendor will carry Public
Liability, Workmen’s Compensation and Property Damage or
other necessary insurance and agrees to protect and indemnify
The Austin Company against all claims for damages, lawsuits,
etc. which may arise in connection with the fulfillment of this
Purchase Order. Any limitation of the liability or responsi-
WR ead a ee eee ve et Bets
71
bility of Vendor by provisions of Vendor's delive tickets
other instruments, shall be entirely ineffective. ” 7
7 It is agreed that goods or services furnished under this Purchase
Order shall comply with all Federal,
pe eel an State and other laws ap-
/s/ H. E. Stillwell
H. E. STILLWELL,
Proj. Purch. Agt.
PURCHASING AGENT
72
DISTRICT PURCHASING
FROM
THE AUSTIN COMPANY
PURCHASE ORDER NO. 1012-23A
On Each Package and Invoice
Name of Job
Norwegian Christian
Home for the Aged, Inc.
CHARGE TO or
Work Order No. 70-1012
Date of Delivery
Date of Order March 22, 1972
NAME of
VENDOR MECHANICAL SALES CORP.
Address P.O. Box 321, Passaic, New Jersey 07050
Deliver or Ship to .
The Austin Company, 1250 - 67th Street, Brooklyn,
New York
Care of Norwegian Christian Home for the Aged, Inc.
Via Railroad or Truck TERMS—
PLEASE FURNISH SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS BELOW:
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 5
CHANGE ORDER “A”
Refer to our original Purchase Order No. 1012-23 dated
January 4, 1972 and make the following changes:
1. Change name of Vendor to:
SLANT FIN CORPORATION
c/o Mechanical Sales Corp.
P.O. Box 321
Passaic, New Jersey 07055
oO beeen ema
ee ee
es me ane om
teeth eae es eer =
73
2. Delete the furnishing and delivery of Stamped Alum-
inum Exterior Grilles (114), Wall Boxes (114), and
Baked Enamel Finish for Exterior Grilles.
PRICE | A _.$741.00 (CREDIT)
This Change Order shall be incorporated into and be-
come part of our original Purchase Order No. 1012-23
dated January 4, 1972. All other terms and conditions
shall remain the same except as detailed herein.
The following Conditions form a part of this Order:
1 SHIPPING NO™ICE—shall be mailed as soon as Material has
been forwarded, giving Order Number, Car Number and
Initials, also condensed description of Material otherwise
Vendor is liable to demurrage.
2 INVOICE IN TRIPLICATE. To mailing address above.
3 CAR LOADS—shall be loaded to minimum capacity—if not, the
Vendor agrees to pay the excess freight.
4 PATENTS—Vendor agrees to protect and hold harmless Pur-
chaser and Owner from and against all and every demand or
demands of any nature or kind by reason of the use of any
patented invention, article or appliance, that has been or may
be adopted or used in the construction of any of the Material
or Articles called for on this Purchase Order.
5 CARTAGE OR PACKAGES~—no charges will be allowed for
either.
6 INSURANCE—It is understood that Vendor will carry Public
Liability, Workmen’s Compensation and Property Damage or
other necessary insurance and agrees to protect and indemnify
The Austin Company against all claims for damages, lawsuits,
etc. which may arise in connection with the fulfillment of this
Purchase Order. Any limitation of the liability or responsi-
bility of Vendor by provisions of Vendor’s delivery tickets or
other instruments, shall be entirely ineffective.
7 It is agreed that goods or services furnished under this Purchase
Order shall comply with all Federal, State and other laws ap-
plying thereto.
W. M. Bocock!
PURCHASING AGENT
74
DISTRICT PURCHASING
FROM
THE AUSTIN COMPANY
PURCHASE ORDER NO. 1012-23
On Each Package and Invoice
Name of Job _
Norwegian Christian
Home for the Aged, Inc.
CHARGE TO or
Work Order No. 70-1012
Date of Delivery
Attn: Sam Jaffe
Tele: 773-7040
Date of Order January 4, 1972
NAME of
VENDOR Mechanical Sales Corp.
Address P.O. Box 321, Passaic, New Jersey 07055
Deliver or Ship to
The Austin Company
1250-67th Street, Brooklyn, New York
Care of
The Norwegian Christian Home for the Aged, Inc.
Via Railroad or Truck TERMS—
PLEASE FURNISH SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS BELOW:
PURCHASE ORDER
Furnish and deliver all of the required room heating and
air conditioning units as shown and called for on the
Austin Company Specifications 201-1 to 201-6 dated
November 29, 1971, and The Austin Company Drawing
number 204 revised November 20, 1971.
" ‘
ee he ee
75
The above revised drawing ard specifications are now
all in your possession.
The Mecianical Sales Corporation quotation number
SF 107-471 dated December 13, 1971 is incorporated into
and becomes part of this Purchase Order.
Fifty four (54) Slant/Fin Climate Com-
mand WC9—unit “B”
Fifty (50) Slant/Fin Climate Command
WC12—unit “C”
Ten (10) Slant/Fin Climate Command
WC16—unit “D”
All the above for the sum of Bs $51,100.00
Include Painted baked enamel exterior
louver to match exterior of building,
add the sum of $ 285.00
Include Insulated pipe cove moulding,
add the sum of . ——<CssS—S—s $ 3,712.00
TOTAL AMOUNT OF THIS PUR-
CHASE ORDER —— $55,097.00
The prices stipulated above includes the following:
Freight
Fresh air intake with aluminum louver, natural
color
Motorized damper door with on-off switch
Pipe cove (uninsulated) moulding with accessories
Seven (7) master control units with eleven (11)
Slaves, including wall mounted thermostat and
automatic changeover control
Special N.Y.C. code electrical plug in recepticles and
prewired
Five (5) year compressor warranty
Factory assembled and prepiped units with gate
valves for mono-flow series loop installation
76
Self-contained thermostats and push button control
board
It is agreed that you shall submit in triplicate to the
Austin Company, 450 W. First Avenue, Roselle, New
Jersey—07203, three (3) copies of shop drawings and
engineering data for formal approval by the Austin
Company within three weeks from date of this Purchase
Order.
Shipment shall be made complete within 8 to 11 weeks
after date of receipt of approval of the shop drawings.
This purchase is exempt from Sales and Use Tax. At-
tached hereto is a copy of the Tax Organization Certi-
ficate.
The following Conditions form a part of this Order:
1 SHIPPING NOTICE—shall be mailed as soon as Material has
been forwarded, giving Order Number, Car Number and
Initials, also condensed description of Material otherwise
Vendor is liable to demurrage.
INVOICE IN TRIPLICATE. To mailing address above.
3 CAR LOADS—-shall be loaded to minimum capacity—if not, the
Vendor agrees to pay the excess freight.
4 PATENTS— ‘Vendor agrees to protect and hold harmless Pur-
chaser and Owner from and against all and every demand or
demands of any nature or kind by reason of the use of any
patented invention, article or appliance, that has been or may
be adopted or used in the construction of any of the Material
or Articles called for on this Purchase Order.
CARTAGE OR PACKAGES—no charges will be allowed for
either.
6 INSURANCE-—It is understood that Vendor will carry Public
Liability, Workmen's Compensation and Property Damage or
other necessary insurance and agrees to protect and indemnify
The Austin Company against all claims for damages, lawsuits,
etc. which may arise in connection with the fulfillment of this
Purchase Order. Any limitation of the liability or responsi-
bility of Vendor by provisions of Vendor's delivery tickets or
other instruments, shall be entirely ineffective.
th
ou
7 It is agreed that goods or services furnished under this Purchase
Order shall comply with all Federal, State and other laws ap-
niving thereto.
/s/ H. E. Stillwell
H. E. STILLWELL,
Purch. Agt.
PURCHASING AGENT
mer 19L faawt.cé's Exhb
—
a
main power supply wire
— screw
é condensate tube
3 way valve wire -——
retaining strap
}
unions
gate |, a
}
thermostat bulbd
If sesired, the entire air conditioning chassis may be removed from
‘ne cabinet. Shut water off by closing gate valves at each end of
unit. Kemeve 2 screws and retaining strap, uisconnect 2 unions,
unplug main power supply wire, unclip thefmostat bulb and push
: > recess unce: chassis. ir conditioning chassis is now free
*o csiide out of cabinet.
e “onnment electrical cable to receptacle in handy box inside cabinet.
.ir conditioning chassis was removed for installation, reinstall
reversing steps outlined above.
«?t
PLONG-WALL PIPING: 1 1/4" supply tubing and 3/4" condensate line
may ce concealed within prefabricated pipe-cove molding (available
‘ir. 5" lengths only).
|
= 24" "
koe
on 2' centers (3 per 5' length). Rest bottom of
tshed floor line; use spacers if working on sub-
t 1 1/4" supply tubing on lower arm of bracket; in-
vr iCKk
ah g
‘
—
mr
c
a
er
. wa
fc. +
es . .
wt ie Re
“4.1 3/8" condensate line on upper arm of bracket. Install
CG .aneing valve at beginning or end of each loop, and install flow
-- sting (B & G Thermoflo, Taco #737, or similar) in each loop,
t accurate balancing after installation is complete. After
X AK RK
LL
= re, ee
os Lee ees Same oe
79
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 8
CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS MEETING NO, 12
W. O. 70-1012
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK
NORWEGIAN CHRISTIAN HOME
A meeting was held on the job site on Thursday, 6/29/72
PRESENT:
Mr. A. Churson—Hudik-Ross, Inc.
Mr. A. J. Desiderio—A. J. Desiderio, Inc.
Mr. R. S. Grand—The Austin Company
Mr. P. D. Plath—The Austin Company
Mr. J. Puchalski—The Austin Company
DISCUSSION:
ELECTRICAL—P & T ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.
1) Manpower—1 +- 9
2) Percentage complete—50
3) Purchasing
a)
b)
c)
d)
Motor Control Center & Switchboard—ITE—MCC
back boxes on job—MCC panels delivered 6/12—
Switchboard—has slipped—originally not delivered
on 6/23 as promised—EXPEDITE
Nurses Call System, Paging and TV System—
Roughing material is in stock—fabrication of bal-
ance of order to be completed by 6/22—P & T
to confirm if this is complete
Fire Alarm, Smoke Detector and Door Release
Systems—All materials and equipment are in
stock.
Light Fixtures—major items are in stock—re-
mainder are being fabricated—no delivery prob-
lems—fixture schedule was mailed to Austin week
of 6/5
80
Construction
a) Basement Slab Conduits—95° complete—balance
consists of work in the Electrical Equipment
Room—This work is proceeding very slowly—
P & T will concentrate on this item—need mini-
mum of one week to complete
b) Switchgear—estimate one week to install and two
to three weeks for Con Edison to complete serv-
ice hook-up—P & T may be able to get a tempo-
rary hook-up if the permanent hook-up is too late
—The ITE equipment will be required for a tem-
porary hook-up.
c) Conduit in dry wall—estimate 3 days/floor—more
men will be added in order to maintain this
schedule.
PLUMBING—A. J. DESIDERIO, INC.
1)
2)
Manpower—1 + 12—workforce will be reduced by 2
on 6 /30—Union Agreement expires end of July 1972
Percentage complete—45 %
a) Fire Hose Cabinets—being installed
b) Kitchen Equipment—a coordination meeting will
have to be held to clear up questions on roughing
and installation—to be set up for week of July 3rd.
c) Sanitary risers—complete through roof
d) Water risers—all risers are completed with the
exception of P-9—to be completed by July 6th.
e) Insulation—3 men on job—expecting strike on
July 1st.
f) Basement Cast Iron—complete except for kitchen
connections,
g) Street Connections—started 6/26—work is pro-
ceeding slowly—A.J.D. to expedite.
81
H.V.A.C.—HUDIK-ROSS, INC.
1)
2)
Manpower—Sheet metal workers—2, Pipefitter—
1 + 6—Austin feels that a minimum of 12 pipefitters
are required on the job. H. R. stated that they have
sufficient manpower at this time
Percentage complete—40
a) Fuel Oil Tank—Approval to proceed was mailed
to H. R. on 5 26—estimate 3 days to install pip-
ing. H. R. will coredrill necessary holes in the
basement walls—This work to be completed week
of July 3rd
b) Slant Fin Units (114)—by Austin—on job hook-
up of same being handled by F. Hudik—Steam-
fitters Union states that they will not hook up
same as they are preassembled
c) Roof fans—by Hudik-Ross—no delivery dates—
H. R. to inform Austin of delivery dates by July
6th
d) Cooling Tower and Evaporative Cooler—by Aus-
tin—Baltimore Air Coil. Rigged on roof on 6, 5—
no work has been done on these units to date.
e) Sheetmetal—all S.D. have been approved with the
exception of the 5th floor and the Mechanical
Equipment Room, and have been released for fab-
rication. Suna Sheetmetal to resubmit S.D. on
ductwork in Central Wash Areas—H-R will sub-
mit S.D. to Austin by 7/7 on future in the Me-
chanical Equipment Room—This area is still on
hold because of this item
f) Emergency Generator Exhaust Stack—H-R stated
that this is not included in their contract—re-
quest for extra sent to Austin on 6 26—PUR-
CHASING PLEASE NOTE
g) Automatic Controls—D.D. returned approved to
H-R on 6/27—type of valves are still in ques-
tion—J. Puchalski to advise
82
h) Starters for Equipment—H.R. questioned loca-
tion of same
i) Construction Schedule—H.R. will send a copy of
their schedule to the job and to Austin/Roselle
week of 7/3
FIRE PROTECTION
GOULD AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER
1) Manpower—2—back on job as of 6/27
2) Percentage complete—25 %
a) Basement Piping—-complete except for Mechani-
cal Equipment Room which is on hold.
b) Shop Drawings—Ist thru 4th floor are approved
—5th floor $.D. will be completed by 7/7 provid-
ing coordination drawing is transmitted by A. J.
Desiderio to Gould by 6/30
¢) Ist Floor Piping—work started on 6 27—estimate
3 days to complete
d) Street Connections—to start week of 7/3—esti-
mate one week to complete
P. D. Plath
Project Superintendent
ce:
All Present
V. Napoli
. Churson
. Desiderio
Ottman
. Stenger
Plath
Bennett
. Rumzie
. Bandtlow
MacDonald
Ernst
Schaeffer
Grand
DAOOM AS UMA > >
83
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 9
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION — LOCAL UNION 638
WoRKING AGREEMENT
Effective July 11, 1966 Terminates June 30, 1969
This WORKING AGREEMENT made and entered
into this day of , 196, by
and between ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF
STEAM, HOT WATER, HYDRAULIC, SPRINKLER,
PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE AND GENERAL
PIPE FITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VICINITY,
LOCAL UNION NO. 638 OF THE UNITED ASSO-
CIATION OF JOURNEYMEN AND APPRENTICES
OF THE PLUMBING AND PIPE FITTING INDUS-
TRY OF THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA
(hereinafter referred to as ENTERPRISE, 841 Broad-
way, New York City, N.Y.), and HUDIK-ROSS CO.,
INC. |Full Name of Employer—(If a partnership give
names of all partners and firm name)| of 230 West
41st Street, New York, N.Y. 10036 | Business Address!
(hereinafter referred to as the EMPLOYER),
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, ENTERPRISE is a Labor Union repre-
senting steamfitters and apprentices engaged in the
steamfitting trade and its allied branches in the area
comprising the City of New York and Nassau and Suffolk
Counties, State of New York; and
WHEREAS, the EMPLOYER has occasion to employ
steamfitters and apprentices in connection with such
work and desires to enter into an agreement with
ENTERPRISE with respect to such employment and the
terms and conditions governing the same;
NOW, THEREFORE, it is mutually agreed between
the parties hereto as follows:
84
ARTICLE ONE
WORKING RULES—WAGES AND HOURS
The parties agree that during the term of this agree-
ment, the attached Rules, numbered “I” to “XXIV” in-
clusive, governing wages, hours, Welfare Fund, Pension
Fund, Educational Fund, Vacation Plan, Security Fund,
Industry Promotional Fund and other conditions of em-
ployment shall apply to the hiring and employment of
all steamfitters and apprentices and shall be in full force
and effect and constitute part of this agreement. The
parties hereto agree to observe and enforce all of the
terms and conditions contained in said Rules.
ARTICLE TWO
STRIKES OR LOCKOUTS
It is further mutually agreed that no strike against
the EMPLOYER shall be ordered by any officer of or
entered into by any member of ENTERPRISE, nor shall!
any lockout against members of ENTERPRISE be de-
clared by the EMPLOYER, so long as this agreement
and the rules hereto attached are conformed to by both
parties,
ARTICLE THREE
JOINT ARBITRATION PLAN
It is further mutually agreed that both parties to this
agreement shall abide by a Joint Arbitration Plan that
may be agreed upon by the representatives of the several
employers’ associations and a majority of the unions
of the building trades of New York City.
It is mutually agreed between the parties hereto that
in event of disputes between trades, and disputes rela-
tive to question of jurisdiction of trade, the parties will
abide by previous decisions as to jurisdiction published
in the latest issue of the B.T.E.A. Handbook, commonly
known as “The Green Book.”
It is mutually agreed between the parties hereto that
disputes between trades, and disputes relative to juris-
diction of trade not covered by decision in the latest
85
issue of the B.T.E.A. Handbook, commonly known as
“The Green Book,” shall be adjusted in accordance with
the principles of the New York Plan for the Settlemen:
of Jurisdictional Disputes as set forth in the Joint Arbi-
tration Plan of the New York Building Trades as adopted
on July 9, 1903 and amended on April 22, 1905, and as
thereafter amended, except to the extent that Section 3
of the said Joint Arbitration Plan requires the employer
to employ only members of the union directly or indi-
rectly through subcontractors or otherwise.
Pending determination of any dispute under the New
York Plan for the settlement of jurisdictional disputes
as stated in the preceding paragraph the members of the
union shall remain at work on the project without change
in status.
ARTICLE FOUR
TERM OF THIS AGREEMENT
It is further mutually agreed that no change in this
agreement shall be asked for by either party hereto, to
take effect prior to the first day of July, 1969.
ARTICLE FIVE
It is understood and agreed that this agreement is
based upon the Principles for Trade Agreements as
set forth in the printed annex to this agreement, and
nothing in the Rules of the Enterprise Association at-
tached hereto, or within this agreement shall be in-
terpreted to contradict or nullify any of the said Prin-
ciples.
Tt is understood and agreed that in case any provision
of this agreement shall be found to be contrary to law,
such finding shall not in any way affect the other provi-
sions of this agreement, which shall, notwithstanding,
continue in ful] force and effect.
In the event of change of applicable Federal laws af-
fecting this agreement, by virtue of which change it shall
become legal for the Enterprise Association to demand
that only members of Enterprise Association be employed
in the performance of work under its jurisdiction, or to
86
institute what is commonly known as the “closed shop,”
the Employer agrees that in such event and on the giving
of ten (10) days’ notice to the Employer by Enterprise
Association in writing by registered mail, this agreement
shall be deemed amended to the end that on and after
the conclusion of the said ten (10) days period only mem-
bers of the Enterprise Association shall be employed by
the Employer in the performance of work coming with-
in the jurisdiction of Enterprise Association and only
members of the Metal Trades Branch of Local Union 638
shall be empioyed in the performance of service work
more particularly described in Rule XVI of this agree-
ment.
ARTICLE SIX
This agreement shall supersede and replace all previ-
Ous agreements entered into between ENTERPRISE
and the EMPLOYER, upon the understanding that the
EMPLOYER shall continue to be responsible for any
moneys heretofore payable with respect to the Pension
Fund, Welfare Fund, Educational Fund, Vacation Plan
and the Security Fund.
IN WITNESS THEREOF, this agreement has been
signed by a duly authorized officer of ENTERPRISE
and the EMPLOYER the day and year first above
written.
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION, LOCAL UNION 638
By /s/ John J. Tracey
Business Agent-at-Large
Hudik-Ross Co., Inc.
By /s/ Frank Hudik
Employer
Date Signed 3-14-67
(Full Individual, Firm or Corporate Name)
Business Agent
Address :
87
RULES
Rules of the Enterprise Association applying to worl:
at the steamfitting trade and its many branches, in
the City of New York and in Nassau and Suffolk Coun-
ties, New York.
RULE I
WORKING DAY
SECTION 1. The hours of labor shall be seven (7)
hours per day, to be performed between the hours of
eight (8:00) o’clock A.M. and four (4:00) o’clock P.M.,
as designated by the employer, every day except Satur-
day, Sunday and legal holidays.
SECTION 2. No steamfitter or apprentice shall be al-
lowed to apply to any shop or office for employment
except between the hours of eight (8:00) o’clock A.M.
and four (4:00) o’clock P.M.
SECTION 3. If a steamfitter is employed on Tempo-
rary Heat, the twenty-four hour day shall be divided
into three (3) shifts of eight (8) hours each. One or
more of these shifts may be used.
SECTION 4. Each shift shall be known as the work-
ing day for temporary heat, every day including Satur-
day, Sunday and legal holidays.
SECTION 5. The working days above named shall
be known as regular time and shall be time actually em-
ployed at work.
* a & &
RULE V
MEN TO WORK IN UNITS OF TWO
All work to be performed within the jurisdiction of
Enterprise Association must be performed by journey-
men steamfitters or apprentices working in units of two,
88
one of whom must be a steamfitter. A unit shall be
composed of:
A. Steamfitter with a steamfitter, or
B. Steamfitter with an apprentice.
RULE VI
WHERE STEAMFITTERS AND APPRENTICES
ARE TO BE AT 8:00 O'CLOCK A.M.
Each steamfitter and apprentice shall be paid from
the time at which he arrives at his work within the terri-
tory of Greater New York and all of Long Island and
there shall be no board or carfare paid to steamfitters
or apprentices working in said territory.
A steamfitter who is sent to work outside of the
above noted territory shall take the boat, train or car
leaving either of the extreme points of the territory, as
directed by his employer, going on boat, train or car
leaving nearest eight (8:00) o’clock A.M. and returning
take the boat, train or car arriving nearest four (4:00)
oclock P.M.
RULE VII
EXPENSES ALLOWED TO STEAMFITTERS
Each steamfitter working outside of the limits de-
scribed in Rule No. VI shall receive from his employer
traveling expenses to and from the place at which thc
work is located for as many trips as he is directed by
his employer to make. He shall also receive a reason-
able amount of board paid by him and he shal! receive
regular wages for all regular time consumed in traveling.
If the steamfitter leaves his work before it is com-
pleted and without the consent of his employer, it shall
be at his own time and expense.
RULE VIII
In going from his shop to his work, or from his work
to the shop, a distance of more than one (1) mile, each
a —
89
steamfitter or apprentice shall receive from his em-
ployer the necessary fare.
RULE IX
CUTTING PIPE AND MAKING UP FITTINGS
Pipe up to and including four inches (4”) diameter,
with the exception of sprinkler work, radiator branches,
convector branches and coil connections shall be cut,
threaded and have fittings screwed on by hand or ma-
chine either on the job or in the shop of the direct
employer at the option of the employer. If the pipe is
cut and threaded on the job the work shall be done
in accordance with Rule V.
If the pipe is cut, threaded and fittings are screwed
on in the shop of the direct employer and said shop is
equipped with permanently installed pipe cutting and
threading machinery and it has been the practice of the
employer to cut and thread pipe and screw on fittings
in said shop, then the work shall be done by a steam-
fitter working alone. When a direct employer who has
had no permanently installed pipe cutting machinery in
his shop desires to do this work in his shop, such work
shall be done in accordance with Rule V.
Radiator branches, convector branches and coil con-
nections shall be cut and threaded by hand on the job
in accordance with Rule V.
All fittings on sprinkler work five inches (5”) and
under shall be made up according to Rule V.
All pipe used for temporary radiator connections hav-
ing been cyt by hand on the job and returned to the
shop may be used again.
RULE X
WELDING
Acetylene, electric or other forms of cutting or welding
shall be done either in the shop or on the job of the direct
employer at the option of the employer.
90
If welding is done in the shop of the direct employer,
the work shall be done by a steamfitter working alone.
All welding work done on the job shall be done in ac-
cordance with Rule V.
The fabrication of van stone joints, the making of
hammer welds, or the welding of boiler headers, street
steam headers, circular coils, trombone coils, zigzag coils,
trunk coils, double pipe refrigerating machine coils, at-
mospherie type condensers, absorbers, weak liquor coolers
and rectifiers of refrigerating machines may be done by
the employer without reference to any jurisdiction by
Enterprise Association. All other pipe welding is to be
performed by journeymen steamfitters.
RULE XI
TEMPORARY HEAT
SECTION 1. Steamfitters working alone shall have
jurisdiction in the operation and or maintenance of all
temporary heat work at all times whenever temporary
heat is on a building regardless of the source of heat
supply. If the fire is banked or if no heat is in the
radiators, steamfitters shall have no claim for temporary
heat operation and or maintenance. Steamfitters shall
have no claim for temporary heat operation and or main-
tenance in any building or structure or addition there-
to that will have a total of 1,500 sq. ft. of radiation
or less, exclusive of mains and risers installed in said
building or structure or addition thereto when com-
pleted.
* = * .
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 10
INTERIM AGREEMENT
IT IS AGREED AND UNDERSTOOD, by and be-
tween the undersigned Employer and ENTERPRISE
ASSOCIATION, STEAMFITTERS LOCAL 638, herein-
after referred to as the Union, that
91
1. Except as specifically modified herein the agree-
ment between the Employer and the Union which ex-
pired on June 30, 1972 shall be extended for an addi-
tional period of one year and shall terminate on June
30, 1973.
2. Rule XXIV (Industry Promotion Fund) and Rule
XXV (Urban Affairs Fund) shall be deleted.
3. Rules II, II, IX, X, XI, XVII and XXIII shall be
modified as follows:
(A). Rule II (Rate of Wages)
From July 1, 1972 to June 30, 1973 inclusive the
hourly wage rate of $8.115 shall be increased by .685¢
per hour. This sum of .685¢ per hour shall be deposited
weekly in an escrow bank account opened and main-
tained by the Employer in the Employer’s name as
Escrowee, to be paid to Steamfitters and or Apprentices
and to the Steamfitters Local 638 fringe benefit funds
when the increase is approved by the Construction In-
dustry Stabilization Committee. The bank book show-
ing such deposits and all supporting data shall be fur-
nished to the Union from time to time on the Unions
request. In the event the full increase is not approved
in its entirety so much as is approved shall be disbursed
by the Employer out of the escrow account at the
Union’s request and the parties shall renegotiate the
wage increase at the discretion of the Union.
The Union shall have the right to allocate the wage
increase among the wage rate and the Steamfitters Local
638 fringe benefit funds.
Section III shall read as follows:
“Section III]. Apprentices shall be paid a progressively
increased schedule of wages for five years based on the
following percentages of the wage rate payable to jour-
neymen steamfitters, and subject to the provisions of
Rule XX with respect to payments to Apprentices for
attendance at classes:
lst half of lst year 40% of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
92
2nd half of 1st year 45° of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
Ist half of 2nd year 50% of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
2nd half of 2nd year 55% of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
Ist half of 3rd year 60° of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
2nd half of 3rd year 65° of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
Ist half of 4th year 70% of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
2nd half of 4th year 75% of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
5th year 85° of a journeyman
steamfitter’s rate of wage
In addition to the hourly rates above, contributions to
the Welfare, Pension and Vacation Funds shall be made
at the same percentage of Fund payments for Steam-
fitters as the percentage of wages. The other Funds
shall be at the same rate as for Steamfitters.”’
As so modified Rule II shall continue in effect for the
period of this Agreement.
(B) Rule III (Rate for Overtime and Holidays)
A new Section III shall be added: There shall be no
overtime worked unless consented to by the Union.
(C) Rule IX (Cutting Pipe and Making Up Fittings)
New paragraphs shall be added to Rule IX reading
as follows:
“All pipe which is cut, threaded, grooved or has fittings
made up in the shop must be labeled before leaving the
shop. Labels shall be obtained by the employer by written
application to the Union. Labels shall bear, both the
Employer’s and Employees’ names before the label is
affixed. Unlabeled work shall not be installed.
All Pipe hangers, except sprinkler work made of
manufactured and, or fabricated components, shall be
assembled and erected on the job in accordance with
Rule V. Sprinkler hangers shall be assembled on the
job or in the shop of the direct employer.
93
All hanger rods shall be cut on the job or in the shop
of the direct employer.
The erection of all hangers, supports, stands and
structural attachments for work covered by this agree-
ment is the work of steamfitter and/or apprentice work-
ing in the geographic jurisdiction of the Union.”
As so modified Rule IX shall continue in effect for
the period of this Agreement.
(D) Rule X (Welding)
A new paragraph shall be added to Rule X reading
as follows:
“All pipe fabrication performed in a shop must be
labeled before leaving the shop. Labels shall be
obtained by the Employers by written application
to the Union, and labels shall bear the employers
and employees names before use. Unlabeled work
shall not be installed.”
As so modified Rule X shall continue in effect for the
period of this Agreement.
(E) Rule XI (Temporary Heat)
It is specifically understood that the within Rule XI
shall also apply to air conditioning and all references
to temporary heat shall be deemed to apply to air con-
ditioning as if the same were set forth at length in this
Rule.
(F) Rule XII (Care of Tools)
The within Rule XII shall be rewritten so as to sub-
stitute the following language for the priod language
in Rule XII:
“RULE XII, TOOLS AND SHANTIES
Section I. The Employer shall provide all neces-
sary tools required for the fitter to perform the
work. The fitter shall comply with all Employer
rules and regulations in the use and care of these
tools, and promptly report any that are missing,
destroyed or in need of repair.
Section II. The Employer shall provide suitable
shanties and dressing facilities on al] jobs. These
94 : 95
shall be heated during winter months. Where these
are prefabricated for job assembly, they shall be
assembled by fitters.
The Employer agrees not to discriminate in any
way against any person so designated as Job
Steward, either due to his being designated or to
his activities in behalf of Enterprise Association
1
Section III. In the event an employee’s working
clothes are destroyed by fire during other than work-
ing hours, the Employer shall compensate the em-
ployee for the replacement of these articles, but in
no event shall the amount for replacement exceed
Fity Dollars ($50.00) per man. In the event per-
sonal property, including street or dress clothes of
an employee, are destroyed due to fire, during work-
ing hours, the amount of damage shal! be limited to
and its members.”
(H) Rule XXIII (Surety Company Bond)
The within Rule XXIII shall be rewritten so as to
substitute the following language for the prior language
in Rule XXIII:
“RULE XXIII. BONDING AND FUND PAY-
MENT REQUIREMENTS AND
.
7
|
Seventy-Five Dollars ($75.00) .” ADMINISTRATION
(G) Rule XVIT (Job Stewards) Section I. Each Employer shall furnish a bond to
ithi ( — ; the joint benefit of the Trustees of the Steamfitters’
The within Rule XVIF shall be rewritten $0 as to sub | ites Welfare Fund, the Steamfitters’ Industry
- ead pe language for the prior language Pension Fund, the Steamfitters’ Industry Educa-
in Rule } ,
“RULE XVII—JOB STEWARDS
Where the Employer employs four (4) or more units
(as defined in Rule V) of Enterprise Association
members on a job, then the members of Enterprise
Association on the job shall select from one of such
units a Job Steward, who shall be a working steam-
fitter and who shall act in behalf of the interests
of the Union and whose duties shall not interfere
with the work he is employed to perform by his
Employer.
When the Employer of a Job Steward has four (4)
or more units working overtime on the job where
the Job Steward is employed, the Job Steward and
his partner shall be included in one of the units
working overtime.
The steamfitter in charge shall be the Shop Steward
whenever less than four (4) units are employed
on the job.
tional Fund, the Steamfitters’ Industry Vacation
Plan, the Steamfitters’ Industry Security Benefit
Fund, guaranteeing payment to said Trustees,
jointly and severally, of any and all amounts due
from said Employer to each of all of said Funds or
Plan, pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
Such bond shall be in form and substance satis-
factory to the said Trustees, jointly.
The aggregate amount of the bund shal! be deter-
mined by the following:
0to20 Local 638 Employees $ 5,000.00
21to70 Local 638 Employees $10,000.00
Over 70 Local 638 Employees $30,000.00
Section II. Each Employer will make the required
Fund payments provided for in this Agreement
within fourteen (14) calendar days following the
close of the work week, i.e., for a work week end-
ing on Wednesday the Fund payments must be paid
no later than the second following Wednesday ex-
cept where Trustees have, in writing, authorized
other terms.
96
Application for such less frequent payments should
be made in writing by the Employer and shall, upon
approval require a bond for double the amount re-
quired in Section I.
Reporting of Fund payments by employees name
shall be submitted at the same time as payments.
Section IV. The Trustees may at any time direct
a payroll audit of any Employer to verify the Fund
payments.
The Trustees shall notify the appropriate Enterprise
Association officials of all delinquent Employers for
action as provided below. All Bonds furnished un-
der this Rule shall provide for the payment of in-
terest at 8° per annum on any delinquent Fund
payments or wages in addition to the principal
amount and shall also reimburse the Funds for the
reasonable expense of collecting such delinquency.
The Union may remove the men from a contractor
who has been found delinquent in his Fund pay-
ments.”
4. Where the prior agreement, which terminated on
June 30, 1972 made references to the “Association”
such references shall be modified or deleted insofar as
they are inconsistent with the intention of the parties
to enter into an agreement which is independent of
and separate from any “Association” contract.
5. If an agreement is reached prior to June 30, 1973
by the Union with the Associations, this agreement
shall terminate and the parties automatically be bound
by the terms of such Association agreement and a full
agreement embodying such termis shall be executed by
the Employer and the Union. However, the wages due
and payable and other conditions of employment as set
forth in this Agreement shall not be affected for the
periods in effect prior to the date of the Association
contract.
97
6. The parties agree to incorporate this Agreement
in a full contract if so requested by the Union.
For the Employer
/s/ \Mlegible}
Hudik-Ross Co., Inc.
251 W. 42nd St.
NY, NY 10036
For The Enterprise
Association
Local 638
By /s/ John J. Tracey
Business Agent at Large
Dated July 1, 1972
98
DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT B
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION
Of Steam, Hot Water, Hydraulic, Sprinkler, Pneumatic
Tube, Compressed Air, Ice Machine, Air Condition-
ing and General Pipe Fitters of New York
and Vicinity
A.F.L.-C.1.0.
STEAMFITTERS LOCAL UNION 638
OF THE UNITED ASSOCIATION
{Union Label 285 |
SECRETARY'S OFFICE MEETS AT
841 BROADWAY ROOSEVELT AUDITORIUM
New York, N.Y. 10003 100 East 17th Street
Phone ORegon 4-3937 New York City, N.Y.
The undersigned hereby agrees to continue in force
the Working Agreement that expired on June 30, 1969
with the following modifications, it being understood
that this Agreement will be continued until a more
formal and detailed agreement is drawn and executed.
All the Articles and Rules enumerated in said Work-
ine Acreement are to remain the same excent Rules IT,
(Waces). XXIII. (Surety Bond) and XXIV. (Industry
Promotional Fund). A new Rule, XXV. (New York
City Buildine and Construction Industry Board of Urban
Affaivs Fnnd) will he added.
From July 16. 1969 to December 31, 1969, inclusive,
rerular time for a steamfitter shall be paid for at the
rate of $6.31 per hour plus 6% Welfare, 7% Pension,
9° Voeeation. 50¢ ner hour Security Benefit Fund, 3¢
ner hour Educational Fund, 3¢ per hour Industry Promo-
tional Fund and le per hour Industrial Board of Urban
Affairs. (See Rules XVIII, XIX, XX, XXI, XXII,
XXIV, and new Rule XXV).
99
Thereafter, from 1-1-70 to 7-1-70, inclusive, the Em-
ployer shall pay an additional 45¢ per hour to cover
Wages and Fringe Benefits.
Irom 7-2-70 to 12-30-70, inclusive, the Employer shall
pay an additional 50¢ per hour to cover Wages and
fringe benefits.
From 12-31-70 to 6-30-71, inclusive, the Employer shall
pay an additional 60¢ per hour to cover Wages and
fringe benefits.
From 7-1-71 to 12-29-71, inclusive, the Employer shall
pay an ac itional 65¢ per hour to cover Wages and
fringe beneiits.
From 12-30-71 to 6-30-72, inclusive, the Employer shali
pay an additional 65¢ per hour to cover Wages and
fringe benefits.
The usual percentage of the Steamfitter’s Wage plus
Fringe Benefits will be paid for the operation and/or
maintenance of temporary heat and in the employment
of Apprentices.
Rule XXIII is modified to require Employer to make
Fringe Benefit payments within 14 days after they be-
come due and if any Employer is delinquent in making
these payments, he will be required to post a $10,000.00
bond; in addition, he will be required to pay a late
charge at a rate of interest to be agreed upon by the
parties hereto and such Employer will be required to
produce his payroll records for an audit so that a veri-
fication of the correct amount due may be obtained.
Rule XXIV will be jointly administered when Federal
Law so permits.
Rule XXV (new). A new Fund will become part of
this agreement, said Fund to be known as the New York
City Building and Construction Industry Board of Ur-
ban Affairs Fund.
The term of this agreement shall be three (3) years
and no change will be asked by either party hereto, to
take effect before July 1, 1972, except that from January
1, 1970 through the term of this agreement, the parties
will agree to the allocation of the increases mentioned
herein, all of which shall be incorporated in the more
100 101
formal agreement to be drawn and executed by the SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
arties.
4 ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION No. 75-777
LOCAL UNION 638
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, PETITIONER
BY: /s/ Hudik-Ross Co., Inc. v.
ENTERPRISE ASSOCIATION OF STEAM, HOT WATER, Hy-
/s/ John J. Tracey | DRAULIC SPRINKLER, PNEUMATIC TUBE, ICE MACHINE
B.A. at Large AND GENERAL PIPEFITTERS OF NEW YORK AND VI-
CINITY, LOCAL UNION No. 638, ETC.
/s/ [Illegible} ORDER ALLOWING CERTIORARI. Filed February 23, 1976
Employer
July 16, 1969 The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit is granted.
UU. S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFicE, 1976 206293 247
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.