Appendix — REA Express, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
———— = _ SS nee 5S.
me +&F i 8
In The
MAR \ST6
Supreme Court of the Ynited States -
| MICHAEL RODAX, 8. CINK
October Term, 1975
75-1233
REA EXPRESS, INC., a Bankrupt,
Petitioner,
VS.
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD,
Respondent,
AIRLINES PARTICIPATING in AIR EXPRESS SERVICE,
AIR FREIGHT FORWARDERS ASSOCIATION,
AMERICAN RETAIL FEDERATION, BROTHERHOOD of
RAILWAY and AIRLINE CLERKS, NATIONAL SMALL
SHIPMENTS TRAFFIC CONFERENCE, DRUG and
TOILET PREPARATION TRAFFIC CONFERENCE, and
EASTERN INDUSTRIAL TRAFFIC LEAGUE, PET
INDUSTRY PARTIES, EMERY AIR FREIGHT,
Intervenors.
APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND
CIRCUIT
ARTHUR M. WISEHART
WISEHART, FRIOU & KOCH
219 East 42nd Street
Sixth Floor
New York, New York 10017
(212) 557-8800
Counsel for Petitioner
(RR?)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
APPENDIX
Order Denying Petition For Rehearing ..............+.+. la
Order Denying Motion to Dissolve the Stay Order ....... 3a
Fk fT TTT Trt ri Sa
Opinion of Court of Appeals .........0 ccc cece ee eceeees Ta
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975) .......... cece eens 23a
Gates of CAD Temes AGU D, FFF ccceccvcccccccceceses 3la
Order of CAB Dated June 26, 1974 .... 0... cece eee eees 46a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974 ..........c cece eeees Sla
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7 1973 .87a
Order of CAB Dated July 23, i970 of Investigation and
BUUPOMIGR cc cccccccccccccccseseccccesescescecesecesse I3la
la
APPENDIX
ORDER DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARING
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
SECOND CIRCUIT
At a stated term of the United States Court of Appeals, in
and for the Second Circuit, held at the United States Court
House, in the City of New York, on the first day of December,
one thousand nine hundred and seventy-five.
Docket No. 74-1611
REA EXPRESS, INC.,
Petitioner,
BROTHERHOOD OF RAILWAY AND AIRLINE CLE®&&S,
et al.,
Intervenors,
v.
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD,
Respondent.
AIR FREIGHT FORWARDERS ASSOCIATION, et al.,
Intervenors.
2a
Order Denying Petition for Rehearing
A petition for rehearing containing a suggestion that the
action be reheard in banc having been filed herein by counsel for
the petitioner, and no active judge or judge who was a member
of the panel having requested that a vote be taken on said
suggestion,
Upon consideration thereof, it is
Ordered that said petition be and it hereby is DENIED.
s/ Irving R. Kaufman
Chief Judge
IRVING R. KAUFMAN
3a
ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISSOLVE THE STAY
ORDER
74-1611
B iS
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
Second Circuit
Filed November 24, 1975
A. Daniel Fusaro, Clerk
At a Stated Term of the United States Court of Appeals, in
and for the Second Circuit, held at the United States Court
House, in the City of New York, on the 24th day of November,
one thousand nine hundred and 75
REA Express, Incorporated,
Petitioner,
v.
Civil Aeronautics Board,
Respondent.
Airlines Participating in Air Express Service, Air Freight
Forwarders Association, American’ Retail Federation,
Brotherhood of Railway and Airline Clerks, National Small
4a
Order Denying Moiicn to Dissolve the Stay Order
Shipments Traffic Conference, Drug and Toilet Preparation
Traffic Conference and Eastern Industrial Traffic League, Pet
industry Parties, Emery Air Freight,
Intervenors.
Dec. 3, 1975
It is hereby ordered that the motion made herein by counsel
for the respondent dated November | 1, 1975 to dissolve the stay
order filed July 16, 1974 and continued by order filed October
10, 1975 be and it hereby is denied without prejudice to renewal
upon a showing that operations will not be resumed.
s/ J. Joseph Smith
J. Joseph Smith
s/ Paul R. Hays
Paul R. Hays
s/ Walter R. Mansfield
Walter R. Mansfield
Circuit Judges
Sa
STAY OF MANDATE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
Oct. 15, 1975
REA EXPRESS, INC.,
Petitioner,
BROTHERHOOD OF RAILWAY AND AIRLINE CLERKS,
et al.,
Intervenors,
-against-
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD,
Respundent,
AIR FREIGHT FORWARDERS ASSOCIATION, et al.,
Intervenors.
No. 74-1611
Counsel for petitioner (“REA”) having advised this Court
that REA intends to petition for rehearing of this Court's
6a
Stay of Mandate
decision of October 6, 1975 and, if that is denied, to petition for
a writ of certiorari to the United States Supreme Court, in a
timely manner, and upon consideration of the showing of
irreparable injury made by the affidavits submitted on behalf of
petitioner and the stay previously entered by this Court on July
16, 1974,
IT IS ORDERED that the mandate herein be and hereby is
stayed pending determination of petitioner’s petition for
rehearing and, if that is denied, petition for a writ of certiorari.
If the petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the stay shall
continue until final disposition by the Supreme Court in
accordance with Rule 41 of the Federal Rules of Appellate
Procedure.
Dated: New York, New York
October 10, 1975
s/ J. Joseph Smith
J. Joseph Smith
s/ Paul R. Hays
Paul R. Hays
s/ Walter R. Mansfield
Walter R. Mansfield
Circuit Judges
Ta
OPINION OF COURT OF APPEALS
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
For tHe Seconp Circuit
No. 380—September Term, 1974.
(Argued: November 21, 1974
Remanded for Reconsideration:
December 23, 1974
Decided after Remand and
Reconsideration: October 6, 1975.)
Docket No. 74-1611
Oe
REA Express, Inc.,
Petitioner,
BroTHennoop or Rarway anp Arriine CLEpKs, et al.,
Intervenors,
—against—
Civir Aeronautics Boarp,
Respondent,
Aim Freicut Forwarvers Association, et al.,
Intervenors.
Before:
Samir, Hays and MansrFie.p,
Circuit Judges.
+o
Petition for review of orders of the Civil Aeronautics
Board terminating the authority of REA Express, Ine.
as an indirect air carrier to provide “air express” service,
8a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
but authorizing it te act as an air freight forwarder, and
denying its application for independent rate-making au-
thority.
The orders are affirmed.
wows
ee at
Bert Reix, Esq., Washington, D.C. (Kirkland,
Ellis & Rowe, Washington, D.C., Arthur
M. Wisehart, Esq., John J. C. Martin, Esq.,
Peter G. Wolfe, Esq., New York, N.Y., An-
derson, Russell, Kill & Olick, P.C., New
York, N.Y., of counsel), for Petitioner REA
Express, Ine.
Perer R. Sreexcanp, Jr., Attorney, Civil Aero-
nautics Board, Washington, D.C. (Thomas
J. Heye, General Counsel, C.A.B., O. D.
Ozment, Deputy General Counsel, Glen M.
Bendixsen, Associate General Counsel, Rob-
ert L. Toomey, Attorney, C.A.B., Washing-
ton, D.C., Thomas E. Kauper, Assistant At-
torney General, Howard EK. Shapiro, At-
torney, Department of Justice, Washington,
D.C., of counsel), for Respondent Civil
Aeronautics Board.
Louts P. Harrer, Esq., Washington, D.C. (Rob-
ert N. Meiser, Esq., Haffer & Meiser, Wash-
ington, D.C., of counsel), for Intervenors
Air Freight Forwarders Association.
Sotomon I. Hirscu, Esq., Rosemont, Tl. (Wil-
liam J. Donlon, Esq., Brotherhood of Rail-
way, Airline & Steamship Clerks, Rose-
mont, Ill., Reilly, Fleming & Reilly, New
York, N.Y., Highsaw & Mahoney, Washing-
9a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
ton, D.C., of counsel), for Intervenor Broth-
erhood of Railway, Airline and Steamship
Clerks.
Jerry R. Ryay, Esq., Washington, D.C. (Reavis,
Pogue, Neal & Rose, Washington, D.C., of
counsel), for Emery Air Freight Corpora-
tion.
Evcexnet Wauiman, Esq., New York, N.Y. (N.
Marshall Meyers, Esq., Washington, D.C.,
of counsel), for Intervenors Pet Industry
Joint Advisory Council, Association of Ani-
mal and Fish Distributors, Inc., National
Pet Dealers and Breeders Assn., Inc., Pet
Producers of America, Inc., Florida Trop-
ical Fish and Farm Assn., Inc., Safari An-
imal Imports, Inc., Gators of Miami, Inc.,
A-1 Animal Ranch, Inc.
Wititiam Keeway, Esq., New York, N.Y. (Mar-
tin S. Snitow, Esq., Arsham & Keenan, New
York, N.Y., of counsel), for Intervenors
National Small Shipments Traffic Confer-
ence, Inc., Drug and Toilet Preparations
Traffic Conference and Eastern Industrial
League, Inc.
Ricnarp A. Hype, Director Legal Proceedings,
United Air Lines, Inc., Chieago, Ill., for
United Air Lines, Inc., one of Airlines par-
ticipating in Air Express Service.
Russet, 8S. Bernuarp, Esq., Washington, D.C.
(Macleay, Lynch, Bernhard & Gregg, Wash-
ington, D.C., William C. Burt, Esq., Koteen
& Burt, Washington, D.C., of counsel), for
10a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
Airlines participating in Air Express Ser-
vice.
—————————————9- > -—___—
Mansrreip, Circuit Judge:
REA Express, Ine. (“REA”) has petitioned for review
of several orders of the Civil Aeronautics Board (“Board’’)
affecting REA’s operations, the most important of which
are orders (1) terminating REA’s authority as an indirect
air carrier to provide “air express” service under an agree-
ment with some 33 United States airlines' but authorizing
REA to act as an air freight forwarder in lieu of provid-
ing “air express” service, and (2) denying REA’s applica-
tion for authority independently to set rates for air ex-
press services, free from any veto power by the airlines.
The orders bad been entered in the Board’s Express Ser-
vice Investigation (Dkt. 22388) which had been instituted
in 1970 following REA’s filing of a complaint with the
Board seeking independent rate-making authority and aid
in REA’s stalemated negotiations with the air carriers.’
By order dated July 16, 1974, we stayed the Board’s orders
pending our review.
1 The authority was derived from the Board's 1941 decision to the
effect that REA, as an indirect air carrier, was granted a temporary
exemption pursuant to §1(2) of the Federal Aviation Act of 1938
(which later became (101(3) of the Act of 1958, 49 U.S.C. §1301(3)).
See Railway Express Agency (Grandfather Certificate), 2 C.A.B. 531,
541 (1941). In 1943 the Board approved the agreements between REA
and the air carriers subject to certain modifications. See Railway Ez-
press Agreements, 4 C.A.B. 157 (1943). The temporary exemption was
thereafter extended from time to time and renewal agreements were
approved at five-year intervals, The last air express agreement so ap-
proved was entered into in 1964 and expired in 1969.
to
A 1970 agreement, which was subject to Board approval of a new
higher tariff, collapsed when the Board suspended the tariff and insti-
tuted its proceeding entitled “Investigation of Air Service Rates”
(Docket 22387).
lla
Opinion of Court of Appeals
Upon the argument of this appeal on November 21, 1974,
we were informed that on that very date an agreement
had been reached between REA and all but six or seven of
the air carriers, which would meet most of the Board’s
objections to the continuation of the air express service
as operated jointly by REA and the air carriers. Since
friction between REA and the air carriers and their in-
ability to reach a new agreement had been a facter in-
fluencing the Board’s decision to terminate REA’s air
express service, we remanded the case to the Board for
reconsideration in the light of this new development, re-
taining jurisdiction over the appeal which hed been briefed
and argued. By orders dated April 9, 1975, and May 23,
1975, the Board disapproved the latest REA-airlines agree-
ment as not in the public interest and reaffirmed its earlier
decision. Thereupon the parties filed additional memo-
randa directed toward the Bvsard’s decision after remand.
We affirm the Board’s urders under review.
“Air express,” the oldest method of shipping air cargo,
is a door-to-door priority air cargo service offered only by
REA which, pursuant to its agreements with United States
air carriers, functions as the single agency responsible
for all ground services required to make the shipment, in-
cluding pick-up, terminal handling, interline transfers, and
delivery to the consignee. In addition to single carrier re-
sponsibility, it features single documentation, expedited
priority air service, a simplified rate structure, and wide
geographical coverage throughout the United States, par-
ticularly in small cities which do not generate enough busi-
ness to support a larger scale air cargo service. Under its
arrangements with the airlines, REA issues a single uni-
form express bill of lading and bills the customer at spe-
cial air express tariffs which cover door-to-door charges at
simplified rates based essentially on commodity and dis-
12a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
tance and which are shared by REA and the air carriers.
The airlines dispatch the customer's shipment on the first
available flight to its destination. For the purpose of han-
dling this business REA maintains offices at some 69 air-
ports. At the remaining 500 airports or so REA’s ground
services are provided by airline personnel.
For many vears REA’s air express service represented
the only method of shipping merchandise by air carrier.
Fo!lowing the Board’s decision in Railway Express Agree-
ments, 4 C.A.B. 157 (1943), however, the air carriers be-
gan offering to the public airport-to-airport “air freight”
services to be rendered by the carriers on their own at
tariffs posted by the airlines. The shippers and con-
signees were required, respectively, to deliver and pick
up their shipments at the airports involved. In 1948 a
third ferm of air cargo service known as “Air Freight
Forwarder” service was authorized by the Board, see Air
Freight Forwarder Case, 9 C.A.B. 473 (1948), whereby
indirect carriers known as air freight forwarders were
authorized to pick up freight from shippers at a given
point, assemble and consolidate the shipments for transfer
by direct air carrier and, upon arrival of the consolidated
shipment at its designation, perform break-bulk and dis-
tribution functions.
,
The introduction of competition by direct carrier air
freight service and by forwarders resulted in air express
eventually developing primarily into a door-to-door small
package service, with the average shipment weighing only
27 pounds and moving approximately 500 miles. Air
freight forwarders attracted larger size shipments (80-
nound average) while the airlines’ own air freight ser-
vice averaged 300 pounds per shipment. Unlike REA the
forwarders for the most part could not provide single
carrier responsibility and single documentation except for
l3a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
shipments between pick-up and delivery zones of uirports
covered by their tariffs. As a result most forwarders
have tariffs based on the point-to-point tariffs of the di-
rect air carriers with only a few publishing door-to-door
tariffs.
Air express service is available at cvery airport city
covered by scheduled air carriers. Although REA main-
tained at one time 3,000 office or agency locations per-
forming its operations throughout the country, this num-
ber has been considerably reduced in recent vears. However,
the number of cities and towns covered by its services
far exceed the facilities offered by forwarders, which
generally maintain no facilities at all at the smaller air-
port cities except for some “destination” agencies which
do not originate shipments,
By the late 1960’s the amount of forwarder business
was increasing enormously (168% during the period 1966-
70) in contrast to REA’s air express business, which was
virtually at a standstill (3% increase during 1966-70).
REA, furthermore, was experiencing acute financial ad-
versity, resulting in substantial annual losses from 1966
to 1974, which led to its institution of Chapter XI bank-
ruptcy proceedings in 1975. The cooperation between REA
and the air carriers, which was essential to the success-
ful operation of air express service, faltered. As the
airlines increased their own competing air cargo freight
service, their negotiations with REA stalemated and REA,
because of its financial plight, had difficulty making pay-
ments due the airlines.
In the Express Service Investigation REA argued that
in order to survive it needed (1) independent rate-making
3 Emery Air Freight Corp., however, has surface freight authority from
the ICC which allows it to provide pick-up and delivery service anywhere
in the United States, and thus to provide single carrier responsibility
and documentation to the same extent as REA.
l4a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
authority, (2) dual authority to provide both air express
and air freight forwarding service, and (3) permanent
status as the exclusive air express carrier. Fundamental
to REA’s position was the assumption that air express pro-
vides a priority service over a larger geographical area
and at a lower cost to the public than air carriers or for-
warders and that continuance of air express was therefore
in the public interest. However, while the airlines conceded
in the Express Service Investigation that there was a pub-
lie need for the existing form of air express service at
least with respect to certain types of small shipments (e.g.,
“life or death” commodities, highly perishable products,
animals), the forwarders urged abolition of air express
service on the ground that, in view of the increasingly
comparable service being provided by them and by the
carriers, air express was no longer needed and had the
adverse effect of stifling competition and the growth of
these other services. The forwarders argued that they
could match the service in terms of speed, commodity and
geographical coverage. Various shippers, on the other hand,
who preferred or were currently dependent on air express
service, urged its continuation.
In an initial decision dated May 4, 1972, the Administra-
tive Law Judge (“ALJ”) found, among other things, (1)
that air express service as represented by the partnership
between airlines and REA as a single ground agency had
a utility distinguishable from the other air freight services
and was in the public interest, (2) that as long as REA
engaged in air express service it would be contrary to the
publie interest to grant it forwarder status, and (3) that
the establishment by REA of a special tariff for air express
tariff was unnecessary. Based upon limited elapsed time
surveys made by the parties, the ALJ found that, while
the bulk of shipments handled by all three services (air
Sa
Opinion of Court of Appeals
express, air freight, and forwarder) were delivered within
48 hours of orig:nation, REA handled the highest percent-
age of those shipments delivered within 24 hours, with the
possible exception of Emery. He further found that REA’s
priority air express offered the shipper an advantage dur-
ing holiday seasons and peak traffic occasions, assuring
shipment by the first available flight regardless of the time
of origination. He further coneluded that because of REA’s
wide commodity coverage and simplified single carrier re-
sponsibility and single documentation REA was able to
handle small shipments at a lower éost than other services
and was able to ship small commodities, such as animals
and high security shipments, between points not served
by the other services,
The ALJ coneluded that if air express should be abol-
ished many shippers would be faced with substantially
higher costs for small shipments and small airport cities
would be left with the airport-to-airport service of direct
air carriers since there would be no air forwarder repre-
sentation at these points. With respect to REA’s request
for dual air express-forwarder rights the ALJ reasoned
that such authority was not in the public interest because
it would give REA an unfair advantage over competing
services. Thus in effect the ALJ recommended mainte-
nance of the status quo.
Upon appeal the Board affirmed the ALJ's finding that
it would not be in the publie interest to grant REA dual
air express-forwarder rights or independent rate-making
power. These powers, the Board concluded, would enable
REA to dominate the indirect air carrier industry, would
have an adverse impact on the development of the air
freight business, would cause customer confusion, would
divert REA’s energies from the small shipment-small com-
munity service 2nd would lead air carriers to refuse to
16a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
enter into agreements with REA for carriage of cargo
originated by REA. Independent rate-making power
would, because of lack of cost data and the conflicting
interests of REA and the airlines, lead to insoluble regula-
tory problems and irreconcilable differences between REA
and the airlines. It also appeared likely to the Board that
REA could through cross-subsidization burden certain types
of shipment with costs attributable to others, thus gain-
ing an unfair advantage over other air freight services,
enabling it to obtain some of their longer-haul heavier
shipments.
The Board further concluded that air express service
was no longer in the public interest. Based on its analysis
of the record it found that as the nation’s general air
freight industry had grown many of air express’ historical
advantages had “withered away.” REA’s air express busi-
ness, in contrast to that of the airlines and forwarders,
had not increased substantially. Its service was no longer
nnique since it was not faster than that of the forwarders,
which had developed operational techniques comparable
and in some instances superior to express service, as re-
flected by elapsed time surveys. The Board found that
with the increase in air cargo space air express’ priority
rarely had any impact. Although a small percentage of
shippers found air express’ highly expedited service use-
ful, the Board decided that this need could better be han-
dled by requiring the air carriers to develop a new highly
expedited priority service under special tariffs that would
be available to all shippers demanding priority service
rather than to permit it to be handled ates by REA
as a coordinating ground agent.
Conceding that in the past REA had provided broader
gceographical coverage than the other air freight services,
the Roard expressed the belief that with the demise of air
. 17a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
express the larger forwarders would probably expand
their existing coverage, which had already been inereased
to include virtually every carrier airport city. Further-
more, in view of REA’s worsening financial condition the
Board believed that REA would be forced to pull out of
many small conaunilies and to consolidate its services.
With respect to eommodity coverage the Board similarly
eoneluded that, in view of the very few items presently
handled solely by REA and the likelihood that other air
freight services would expand their coverage to handle
those commodities, the termination of air express would
neither preclude any commodity from moving by air nor
result in any community being unserved in the handling
of such merehandise. Furthermore, without an economically
viable REA and an agreement between it and the airlines,
which provided the essential air transportation and at 85%
of the airports the necessary ground services, air express
service simply would not be able to function.
Having concluded that air express service, which had
been handled exelnsively by REA, must be terminated, the
Board decided that it would nevertheless be in the public
interest to grant authority to REA to function as an air
freight forwarder, since this would enable it to handle
the types of trafic with which it could deal most effectively
and to operate without dependeneyv on an agreement with
he airlines, Insum, the Board (1) disapproved the REA-
airlines agreements for air express service on the ground
that such serviee was no longer in the public interest and
accordingly denied REA’s requests for dual air express-
air freight forwarder authority and for independent rate-
making power, (2) terminated REA’s temporary authority
as the exelusive indirect air carrier for air express, (3)
authorized REA to operate nationwide as an air freight
forwarder, and (4) directed the air carriers to introduce
BEST COPY AVAILABLE
18a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
a new high-priority cargo service designed for shipments
requiring highly expedited carriage and delivery.
DiscussIon
REA’: first contention is that in terminating air express
service the Board violated the mandates of the Federal
Aviation Act of 1958, 49 U.S.C. §$1301(3), 1302 and 1382(b),
and of the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. §$701-
706, by limiting itself to consideration of selected ad-
versarial contentions and by failing to apply “public in-
terest” criteria specified by Congress as the standard in
deciding the issues before the Board. See F PC v. Texaco,
Tne., 417 U.S. 380, 394-97 (1974). The effect, REA argues,
was to “execute” it as a carrier and to harm the shipper
interests by distorting the geographic and commodity cov-
erage that would be available to them in the future and
by foisting a more expensive forwarder service upon the
public. We disagree.
The Board’s decision, supplemented by its order on re-
mand, discloses that it observed its responsibilities to REA
and to the public, making its “public interest” determina-
tions only after weighing and balancing the essential rel-
evant factors which it was obligated to consider: the ship-
pers’ needs, the cargo offered for transport, the nature and
extent of the markets and commodities affected, and the
characteristics of the three competing services.
The record reveals substantial evidence supporting the
Board’s findings to the effect that with rare exceptions
REA’s service is not faster than that of the other types of
service, that its priority treatment has become almost en-
tirely meaningless, that its broad geographic coverage is
no longer unique in comparison to that of competing for-
warder services and that its exclusivity in the transport
of certain commodities has disappeared. Being supported
19a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
by substantial evidence, these findings ust stand. Federal]
Aviation Act of 1958, (1006(e), 49 U.S.°'. (1486(e); Ad-
ministrative Procedure Act, ‘10(e), 5 U.s.. *706(e);
Universal Camera Corporation v. NLRB, 340 U.S. 474, 488
(1950).
Although the Poard, in carrying out its duty to deter-
mine whether a particular form of service will promote
“adequate, economical and efficient service by air carriers
at reasonable charges,” 49 U.S.C. $1302(¢), may be obli-
gated, as REA argued, to consider the “comparative eco-
nomics” of the various types of air service offered, we do
not believe that this requires the Board to conduct an in-
vestigation in depth into the costs of each type of service
of the kind that might be required for a rate determination
under 49 U.S.C. 1482(e), or for a determination as to
whether an entirely different kind of service should be ini-
tiated, see, e.g., Schaffer Transportation Co. v. United
States, 305 U.S. 83 (1957). Here the Board, acknowledg-
ing that REA offered lower rates to small-package ship-
pers for some commodities, concluded that the public need
for such service would best be served in the future by
opening up air express markets to all indirect air carriers
and relying on competitive forces to provide a dependable
air freight service for all classes of commodities. We can-
not say that its conclusions are unreasonable. Indeed, the
Board’s conclusion was reinforeed by REA’s filing in No-
vember 1974 of a new tariff (Appendix B to Board’s An-
swering Memorandum dated June 16, 1975, following its
adherence upon remand to its earlier decision) raising its
rates on many commodities, thus eliminating much of the
advantage claimed on the basis of lower rates. Although
we are advised that it has since filed still another tariff
lowering the rates on some commodities, the interim higher-
rate proposal raises questions as to its ability to operate
20a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
an air express service economically at present rates and
as to whether the rates would not be revised upward if
REA should continue to operate air express as a monopoly.
We agree with REA that if the public interest mandated
the continuance of the present air express system the
Board could not properly confuse that issue with the prob-
lems inherent in REA’s precarious financial condition. On
the other hand, in deciding whether the public interest
would be served, the Board was not precluded from consid-
ering, among other factors, REA’s dire straits, at least
in the absence of a showing that some other carrier might
conceivably be willing and able to provide air express
service. Here, unlike the situation in Northeast Airlines
Inc. v. CAB, 331 F.2d 579 (1st Cir. 1964), upon which REA
so heavily relies, no carrier other than REA would pro-
vide air express service. Indeed, REA, operating under
the umbrella of a CAB-granted monopoly, is the only ecar-
rier that has ever provided that service. In any event,
although the Board took REA’s uncertain future into con-
sideration, its decision was based firmly on the ground
that the public need for air express service had all but
vanished with the advent of substitute services.
Having concluded that the Board’s decision to terminate
air express service must be upheld, we see no purpose to
be served in reviewing the Board’s denial of REA’s appli-
cation for independent rate-making authority and dual air
express, freight forwarder status except to note that the
Board’s conclusion that the grant of such authority would
not be in the public interest appears, for the reasons stated
by the Board, to be reasonably grounded and well within
the proper exercise of its powers. Furthermore, there was
no need for the Board to postpone its decision with respect
to termination of air express service until it had finally
determined the issues pending in the Air Express Rates
2la
Opinion of Court of Appeals
Investigation (Docket 22387) or until the airlines had put
into effect the new high-priority service as directed by
the Board’s order. Deferment of the orders presently
under review until completion of the rates investigation
would unduly delay a step believed by the Board to be
essential, i.e., the termination of air express service, with-
out any assurance that the investigation would yield find-
ings requiring a change in the Board’s decision. Since the
high-priority service contemplated by the Board is not
intended as a replacement of air express service but as
an entirely new type of fast, airport-to-airport service
not presently available, continuation of air express would
not provide an interim substitute for the high-priority
service sought by the Board. A further evidentiary hear-
ing of the type ordered in Ashbacher Radio Co. v. FCC,
326 U.S. 327 (1945), is therefore not required in this case,
where the Board has already held one evidentiary hearing.
Lastly, for the reasons stated by the Board in its Order
on Remand disapproving REA’s November 21, 1974, agree-
ment with most of the airlines, that agreement does not
change the basic findings upon which the Board based its
termination of air express service.
The Brotherhood of Railway and Airline Clerks
(“BRAC”) supports REA’s application, arguing that the
Board failed to make suitable provisions for the welfare
of employees who would be displaced by termination of
air express service. However, since no proposal was made
to the Board for imposition of labor-protective conditions,
the matter may not be considered initially by us, Federal
Aviation Act of 1958, §1006(e), 49 U.S.C. §1486(e). Fur-
thermore, the record reveals that the Board, apparently
recognizing employee welfare as a factor to be considered
in deciding what course would be in the public interest,
Air Line Pilots Assn. v. CAB, 475 F.2d 900, 905 (D.C. Cir.
22a
Opinion of Court of Appeals
1973), granted air freight forwarder authority to REA
specifically on the ground that its operations as a freight
forwarder would provide the best opportunity to benefit
its employees.
The Board’s orders are affirmed.
s»--------
23a
ORDER OF CAB DATED MAY 13, 1975
Order 75-5-98
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Adopted by the Civil Aeronautics Board at its office in
Washington, D.C., on the 23rd day of May, 1975
Dockets 22387, 22388, 26238
Docket 27193, Agreernent CAB 24824
EXPRESS SERVICE INVESTIGATION ET AL
AIR EXPRESS AGREEMENT,
REA EXPRESS, INC.
AND CERTAIN PARTICIPATING AIRLINES
ORDER
In Order 75-4-54, the Board, at ihe direction of the United
States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, reexamined its
decision in the Express Service Investigation in light of the air
express agreement and revised tariff filed subsequent to the time
of the Board’s earlier decision.' The Board concluded, upon
reexamination, that the fundamental legal and policy issues
1. See Orders 73-12-36, 74-5-25, and 74-6-118.
24a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
which led to the Board's origina! decision were not altered by the
subsequent agreement and tariff, and, therefore, the subsequent
agreement was adverse to the public interest and should be
disapproved. The Board's earlier decision was reaffirmed. REA
Express, Inc.. has filed a petition for reconsideration of Order
75-4-54. The Pet Industry Parties have filed an answer in
support of the petition and Emery Air Freight and the Air
Freight Forwarders Association have filed answers in
opposition. We shall deny the petition.
REA makes five basic arguments. First, the petitioner
contends that there is no showing that the air freight forwarders
or the airlines can fully replace air express service. In this
connection, REA _ claims that the Board's failure to
comparatively evaluate its proposal with priority cargo service
violates the Ashbacker doctrine.? Second, REA argues that the
Board’s most recent order improperly evaluated express rates
vis-a-vis the rates of forwarders by comparing ordinary
forwarder rates (based on consolidation of shipments) with
REA’s expedited service rates, and failed to consider likely rate
increases. Third, REA claims that a hearing is required in order
to resolve certain factual disputes associated with its transition
from air express to air freight forwarder service. Fourth, REA
asserts that the Board’s concern that forwarders are excluded
from various types of markets is obviated by the new tariff
which allows forwarders to use REA’s airport-to-airport express
rates. Finally, REA makes an equitable argument that
elimination of its express authority at this time would be unfair
2. Ashbacker Radio Corp. v. FCC, 326 U.S. 327 (1945).
25a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
to shippers and REA’s employees, and that the Board should
defer its decision pending the outcome of REA’s Chapter XI
bankruptcy proceeding.
Most of REA’s arguments and contentions are, in essence,
repetitions or variations of earlier contentions advanced to, and
rejected by, the Board. Nothing in the petition for
reconsideration establishes error in the Board’s earlier decision
or presents any matters that otherwise would warrant grant of
the relief sought.
1. We see no basis for REA’s assertion that it is entitled,
under the Ashbacker notion, to yet another hearing. The Board
has already completed a massive investigation of air express
service in which it specifically compared, in detail, REA’s service
with ordinary air freight service. On the basis of the record
established at the hearing, the Board concluded that REA’s
monopoly air express arrangement no longer offered any unique
public benefits which would justify continuation of its special
regulatory treatment. In addition, the Board concluded that
there was a need for a new, but different, type of high-priority
cargo service offered directly by the airlines. These two matters,
although clearly related, are nevertheless distinct. While we
recognize that the carriers have not, as yet, filed the necessary
interline agreements and associated tariffs so as to be ready to
fully implement this new service (on-line tariffs are in effect for
certain carriers), we have every anticipation that they will do so
once the uncertainty surrounding REA’s express service is
resolved by the Court of Appeals. REA’s assertions that the
26a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
Board should not end REA’s service “before its hypothetical
replacement has appeared on the scene so that the pros and cons
of each can be measured...,” and that the need for its
particular service has not been filled because the airlines have
not developed their high-priority interline service, misconceive
this fundamental distinction. The Board retains full regulatory
authority to require the establishment of appropriate high
priority service if affirmative Board action becomes necessary.
More importantly for present purposes, further regulatory
action to insure the implementation of the new service would
not, in any event, include a reactivation of REA’s express
monopoly as a “substitute.”?
We find it unnecessary, at this juncture, to pass upon REA’s
further arguments that high priority service rates are likely to be
higher than existing air express rates, and that the difference
between express rates (if retained) and freight rates are likely to
increase. The new high priority service will be different from
REA’s current service and may well be a higher cost service.*
3. We are not persuaded by REA’s attempt to elevate the priority freight issue to
one of major decisional significance. In the context of the overall case, it was merely a
minor part of our conclusion that air express service, per se, had outlived its usefulness.
To the extent that the petitioner may also argue that its new airport-to-airport service is
entitled to a comparative evaluation with the new high priority service, suffice it to say
that, as discussed more fully infra, we are not prepared to place pnority service in the
hands of a single carner
4. REA points to the increases recommended by Judge Present in the Domestic Air
Freight Rate Investigation, Docket 22859. Judge Present’s decision is now before the
Board for review.
5. Tariffs filed by individual carners show a ¥ percent increase in rates when
compared with the airlines’ existing standard line-haul freight rates. See, e.g., Order 75-5-
34, May &, 1975. These tariffs are the subject of a Board investigation and hearing in the
Prionty Reserved Air Freight Rates Investigation, Docket 26838.
27a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
However, the Board has power to insure that such rates are
reasonable. While ordinary freight rates may increase in the
future, there is no showing that the relationship between
forwarder rates and REA’s rates, which are now more or less the
same, would change appreciably.°®
2. The Board properly evaluated REA’s new express rates
vis-a-vis the rates of other air freight forwarders. We compared
the rates for REA’s service with the rates for the forwarders’
standard service in view of our earlier determination that REA’s
service offers no advantage in terms of speed of delivery. Thus,
the fact that the forwarders offer an even faster service is
immaterial. Indeed, REA shares the Board’s view of the
appropriate competitive comparison since Appendix B to Order
75-4-54, which detailed our comparison, was taken, in terms,
from REA’s justification filed with its proposed November 4
tariff.
3. No further hearing is required to resolve any conflicting
evidentiary matters. As noted above, an extensive evidentiary
hearing has already been held, and we do not read the court’s
remand order — which was the impetus for the reconsideration
of our earlier decision — as requiring a new evidentiary hearing.
Nor is one justified. Our original decision concluded that, with
the possible exception of air express rates for small package
shippers, express service no longer offered any unique public
6. REA makes an argument that its costs will continue to be lower than those of the
air freight forwarders and that this will inure to the benefit of the shipping public. The
recent changes in REA's rates belie this argument.
28a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
benefits. Subsequently, we noted that even the rates advantage
had evaporated. Whether or not particular shippers would
continue to favor REA — and we have no reason to doubt that
some shippers will prefer REA’s forwarder service — does not
change our fundamental conclusion that REA is no longer
entitled to a preferred position in the air cargo business.’
4. Our original decision concluded, inter alia, that the
elimination of the REA monopoly and the opening up of air
express markets to all indirect carriers, including REA, will best
promote the future growth of a dependable air freight serv ce,
particularly with respect to small-package shipments. REA
points out that its more recent tariff now includes airport-to-
airport as well as door-to-door rates, and argues from this that
forwarders may now expand into new markets by utilizing
REA’s air express service on an airport-to-airport basis. We do
not believe that this factor obviates the fundamental problem.
Under REA’s proposal, the carrier's monopoly would be
continued despite the Board’s conclusion, reiterated in Order 75-
4-54, that continuation of this arrangement runs contrary to the
spirit of the antitrust laws and is not justified by any counter-
balancing public benefits. Moreover, REA would, under its
proposal, retain control over all express shipments, including
those of its competitors, and this appears to us to be counter-
productive to the fullest development of priority service.
Moreover, adoption of REA’s approach would simply subject
7. We are unimpressed by REA's apparent confusion over our finding that it has
already made the transition from air express to air freight forwarding. The carrier's
argument, reduced to fundamentals, is simply a restatement of its historic position that
its service continues to be unique. That position is simply wrong.
29a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
priority service to all the historic and potential uncertainties
associated with REA’s monopoly.*®
5. Finally, we see no equitable basis for a deferral in the
implementation of our earlier decision. We do not believe that
the possible effect on REA’s employees or shippers, or the
pendency of REA’s bankruptcy proceeding, warrants further
delay. We must point out, again, that the Board has never
contemplated the elimination or demise of REA, with any loss
of jobs for its employees. Rather, the Board seeks to expand the
development of air freight service generally and permit REA to
play a constructive role in that development, with all the rights
and opportunities for successful operation enjoyed by existing
forwarders. Such action should work to the benefit of REA’s
employees. Significantly, REA does not request, as a remedy,
the imposition of conditions to protect its employees. Rather, it
argues that considerations of employee security should override
all other public interest factors so as to “require the continuation
of Air Express....” Although we are sympathetic to any
difficulties which may be faced by REA’s employees, we do not
believe either that our action has been a major contributing
factor to employe dislocations’ or that the problems faced by
REA’s remaining employees justifies a complete reversal of our
8. REA asserts, citing Order 74-9-4, that the Board has found that high priority
service is a “replacement for air express.” That characterization is misleading insofar as it
suggests identity — rather than overlap — between the two forms of service. It is the
Board's position, notwithstanding use of the word “replacement” in Order 74-9-4, that
the record established that air express is not comparable to high priority service. See
Order 73-12-36.
9. REA has already severely contracted its operations and staff although the Board's
decision is yet to take effect.
30a
Order of CAB Dated May 13, 1975
original decision. Similarly, as fully detailed in our earlier
decisions, we believe that the transition of REA from express
operator to forwarder, and the entry of direct carriers and
forwarders into the priority cargo market, -will eventually inure
to the benefits of the shipping public.
In like fashion, we do not believe that our decision should
be deferred pending completion of the bankruptcy proceedings.
First, we believe that REA’s best hope for survival as part of the
air cargo system is by operating as an air freight forwarder. The
formal transition from express operator to forwarder should be
completed as promptly as possible. Second, we believe the
bankruptcy court is entitled to the benefit of the Board’s
judgment in this respect so that it may move forward to remedy
REA’s financial difficulties in the most productive fashion. Any
deferral of action on the Board’s part might be improperly
viewed as a vacillation with respect to the Board’s determination
of REA’s future role.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT: REA’s
petition for reconsideration be and it hereby is denied.
By the Civil Aeronautics Board:
EDWIN Z. HOLLAND
Secretary
(SEAL)
3la
ORDER OF CAB DATED APRIL 9, 1975
Order 75-4-54
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Adopted by the Civil Aeronautics Board
at its office in Washington, D. C.,
on the 9th day of Apmil, 1975
Dockets 22387, 22388 and 26238
Docket 27193, Agreement CAB 24824
EXPRESS SERVICE INVESTIGATION ET AL
AIR EXPRESS AGREEMENT,
REA EXPRESS, INC.
AND CERTAIN PARTICIPATING AIRLINES
ORDER ON REMAND AND DISAPPROVING
AGREEMENT
INTRODUCTION
The Board once again has before it the question of the on-
going relationship between the airlines and REA Express, Inc.,
with regard to air express service. In the original decision in the
Express Service Investigation, Docket 22388, the Board (a)
32a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
disapproved, as contrary to the public interest, the existing air
express service arrangement (Agreements CAB 12866 and 17935)
between the airlines and REA and cancelled REA’s existing air
express exemption, (b) issued air freight forwarder authority to
REA, and (c) concluded that each scheduled air carrier has an
obligation to offer priority freight service as part of its duty to
provide adequate interstate and overseas air transportation. In a
related proceeding,' the Board authorized _inter-carrier
discussions of priority air cargo services. REA petitioned the
United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit to review
the various Board decisions and the court stayed the Board’s
decision in the Express Service Investigation insofar as it
ordered an end to the existing air express arrangement. By
Order 74-11-11, November 1, 1974, the Board allowed a new air
express tariff structure to become effective, although it did not
deal with the underlying question, at issue here, concerning the
continued approval or disapproval of the agreements and
exemption which provides for air express service.
Thereafter, on November 22, 1974, a new air express
agreement was filed with the Board for approval. The new
agreement, if approved by the Board, would become effective
the day after Board approval, would be of continuous duration,
and would supersede the old Air Express Agreement (Agreement
CAB 17935, Docket 22388) which would be terminated.2 On
1. See Orders 74-2-118, 74-4-1, 74-5-74, and 74-11-26.
2. Answers with respect to this agreement were tiled by tic Air Freight Forwarders
Assocation, Emery Air Freight Corporation, the Brotherhood of Railway, Airline and
Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers, Express and Station Employees (BRAC), and the
(Cont'd)
33a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
December 23, 1974, the Court of Appeals remanded the judicial
proceeding to the Poard in order that the Board might
reconsider its earlier decisions “in light of the Board’s disposition
of the Air Express Agreement executed and filed on November
22, 1974, and other relevant circumstances, including the revised
Air Express Tariff effective November 4, 1974... .”
In general, the arguments made in support of approval of
the new Air Express Agreement are that it would allow for the
continuation of service which some shippers desire; that it would
eliminate the problems associated with the old agreement as they
were described by the Board in the Express Service
Investigation, Docket 22388, particularly when viewed together
with the new air express tariffs; that it would permit REA to
achieve a healthy financial status; that the new agreement is the
best method of providing the public with priority air express
service; and that it would limit competition to the extent
necessary to achieve the efficiencies of a single ground agent for
air express. The arguments presented in opposition to approval
are that the new agreement would not really change the nature
(Cont'd)
Pet Industry Council, and a reply was filed by the applicants. In addition. informal
“protests” or “objections” to the new agreement were received from four humane
associations, including the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
Also, a reply was filed by the Drug and Toilet Preparation Traffic Conference and the
National Small Shipments Traffic Conference, Inc., together with a motion for leave to
file an unauthorized document. This filing will be treated as a late-filed answer and will
be accepted. Finally, United submitted, in Docket 22388, a motion to file an otherwise
unauthorized document, accompanied by “Comments” purportedly directed to matters
pending in Docket 22388. REA, in response, argues that since the Board has not
requested comments in Docket 22388, United's submission is, in effect, an untimely
response to the new Air Express Agreement. We shall deny United’s motion.
ee ee
34a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
of the air express arrangement; that it would not controvert the
Board's previous findings that the anticompetitive aspects of this
arrangement are not overcome by a serious transportation need
or important public benefits; that REA would retain control
over all air express shipments, even those of its competitors; that
the possibility of future air express crises would not be
eliminated by the new agreement; that the air express rate and
revenue division structure unfairly favors REA over other
indirect carriers and possibly the airlines; and that this
agreement would not make a feasible form of air express service
available to other indirect air carriers, but would prevent the
establishment of the high-priority air cargo service which the
Board has directed the airlines to offer to the public. Another
argument in opposition is that the agreement does not
specifically provide for the proper care of animals shipped in air
express.
In view of the matters presented, and in compliance with
the court’s directive, we have considered the new agreement and
related tariff— both independently and in connection with our
earlier decision— and have concluded that the agreement of
November 22 is adverse to the public interest and should be
disapproved and that the Board’s earlier decision should be
reaffirmed.
SUBSTANTIVE MATTERS
The fundamental legal and policy issues which underlie the
present manner in which air express service is performed—i.e.,
35a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
pursuant to an agreement among the airlines (Agreement CAB
12866) and an agreement between the airlines and REA as the
monopoly airexpress indirect carrier (Agreement CAB 17935)-
were fully examined in the Express Service Investigation, where
the Board concluded that the existing air express arrangement
did not offer any unique public service benefits which would
justify its continuation. On the contrary, the evidence
conclusively showed that the original air express format
developed prior to 1938 had been rendered obsolete by more
recent developments, including particularly, the expansion of air
freight forwarder operations and air cargo operations by the
airlines themselves. Based on the extensive record in the Express
Service Investigation, the Board found that air express no longer
offered the public superior speed or commodity and geographic
coverage which once distinguished it from other air cargo
services and thereby justified its unique treatment by the Board.
Only in the area of rates to small package shippers was there
some evidence that REA had maintained its historic advantage.
In addition, the Board found that air express service under the
existing regime would remain in constant danger of sudden
suspension and that such uncertainty was clearly adverse to the
public interest. Finally, the Board concluded that elimination of
the REA monopoly and the opening up of air express markets
to all indirect carriers, including REA, will best promote the
future growth of a dependable air freight service, particularly
with respect to small-package shipments. The modifications to
the air express arrangement recently submitted do not
undermine-nor, indeed, address-these fundamental bases for the
Board’s earlier-decision. (The major differences between the new
36a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
and old agreements and tariffs are set out as an appendix to this
opinion and order.) On the other hand, recent developments
generally reinforce the Board's earlier determination. In sum, we
see no basis for approving the current agreement or altering our
earlier decision.?
Nothing in the current submissions warrants any change in
our earlier finding that the existing air express arrangement no
longer provides any unique public service advantages. On the
contrary, it now appears that any alleged benefits have
materially deteriorated. Significantly, Delta, Southern, United,
Piedmont, Pan American, and Ozark have already withdrawn
from the express arrangement. Thus, the nationwide coverage
which was a principal public benefit of REA’s service has been
ended. Furthermore, REA’s air express tariffs and pickup, and
delivery service are now similar to those of forwarders and other
air freight carriers. The recently established air express rate
structure, effective November 4, 1974, is also not materially
different from that of freight forwarders in general, particularly
with respect to smaller packages. Reductions proposed in
3. We are sympathetic to the concerns of the humane societies, but since our action
herein is to disapprove the agreement, we will not deal specifically with the matters
raised by the humane societies in this order. In Docket 26310 the Board is conducting an
investigation of the rules and practices relating to the acceptance and carriage of live
animals in domestic air freight transportation. Any changes in the treatment of animals
which that Investigation shows to be necessary would seem to be appropriate for any
type of air cargo system in effect at that time, and it is suggested that the humane
societies direct their attention to Docket 26310. See Orders 74-1-79 and 74-7-26.
4. See Apendix B to this order. See, also, Order 74-11-11, November |, 1974.
37a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
numerous rates, marked to become effective April 30, 1975, will,
if permitted to become effective by the Board, bring the express
structure even closer to that of forwarders. And, as the Board
noted in its original decision, the designation of a shipment as
air express does not, in practice, result in any faster service than
if the package were sent as air freight. Finally, REA has, in
essence, already made the transition from air express to air
freight forwarding so that any change in formal authorization
will have virtually no effect on the type of service available to
the public. The only remaining distinction btween REA and air
freight forwarders is in nomenclature and privilege which do not
translate into any meaningful benefits to the shipping public.
There is little doubt that the strength of the REA/airline
arrangement has been further eroded since the time of the
Board’s original decision. As noted earlier, various airlines have
withdrawn from the basic air express agreement. Furthermore,
the conflicting interests of REA and its remaining airline
“partners” nonetheless continues, even under the new
arrangement. Also, under that new arrangement air express
services would end ten days after any default by REA to the
airlines. Moreover, section IV of the new agreement plainly says
that all adjustments and increases in air express rates can be
vetoed by either REA or the airlines. Equally important,
subsequent to the time of the Board’s earlier decision REA filed
a petition initiating a bankruptcy action in the Federal courts. In
all these circumstances, we can only conclude that the new air
express agreement is no more stable than the earlier
arrangement was at the time of our original decision.
38a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
Finally, and importantly, we continue to believe that the
future development of air freight, including the benefits to the
public of a reliable form of cargo service, can best be achieved
by allowing other indirect carriers to participate in priority
service so that a dependable service can be established. As we
indicated in our Supplemental Opinion and Order 74-5-25, at
pp. 12-13:
“The air express agreements are plainly
anticompetitive, and have the effect of
eliminating competition between airlines and
excluding airfreight forwarders from various
types of markets... [T]he air express
agreements do not produce counter-balancing
public benefits, but rather stand in the way of the
establishment of an improved air cargo
system .... Disapproval of the air express
agreements is fully in keeping with the spirit of
the antitrust laws. It is the perpetuation of them
that would have been contrary to that spirit. And
we are not aware of any supervisory
responsibility imposed on us that requires us to
attempt to aid an unhappy partner to an
arrangement that has outlived its time... .”
Not only will our new approach remove the ever-present threat
that the only available express service may suddenly disppear,
but it will foster the usual competitive interplay which we believe
ES SA nc
<n) ie Cee es
ON i es a ok
39a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
desirable in bringing about improved air freight service to the
public.®
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Board has also reexamined its earlier determination
regarding the need for a new high-priority air cargo service since
this was a part of the Board order remanded by the Court in
light of the proposed new air express agreement. After careful
consideration, we find nothing in the new agreement to alter our
earlier conclusion that there are a limited number of
commodities requiring the fastest possible service, that air
express does not fill the need for priority service, and that,
accordingly, each air carrier has an obligation to meet this
limited need with a high-priority service of its own. In
connection with the proposed agreement, we find no indication
that air express service would be any more successful than under
the current agreement in meeting the need for high-priority
service.
In order to establish high-priority service, we permitted the
airlines to hold discussions concerning the development of
interlining procedures and the like for this new service.® The air
carners have now had more than one year to conduct those
discussions, but most have not yet filed with the Board their
tariffs and any necessary interline agreements. While such
5. See, generally, Household Goods Air Freight Forwarder Investigation, Order 72-7-33,
July 10, 1972.
6. Orders 74-2-118, 74-4-1, 74-5-74 and 74-11-26.
40a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
reticence may be understandable in light of the court order
staying this and other aspects of the Express Service decision, it
must be emphasized that the public interest requires the
establishment of this service as soon as possible. Accordingly, we
will grant the pending request in Docket 26238 and authorize
further discussions by the airlines. This authorization will expire
fourteen days after the issuance of the court’s mandate in REA
v. CAB, No. 74-1611. Moreover, by that fourteenth day, the
Board expects the airlines to have submitted the tariffs for high-
priority service as well as whatever agreement or agreements are
necessary t® accomplish the essential interlining aspects of the
service.’ The tariffs and agreements should be marked to become
effective no later than 90 days after the issuance of the court’s
mandate.
In this fashion, the status quo protected by the court’s stay
is not disturbed, for vuile the carriers are free to discuss and
formulate whatever procedures are necessary, no action will be
taken and no new industry-wide service will begin until after the
dissolution of the stay. At the same time, this directive will have
the beneficia! effect of implementing our earlier determination
on the need for high-priority service as soon as possible.
Finally, as noted above, REA and the participating airlines
have filed, on March 27, 1975, a new air express tariff marked
for effectiveness on April 30, 1975. That tariff, inter alia,
7. We note that the airlines participating in the discussions essentially agreed on an
interline agreement on June 11, 1974. Very little additional work would seem necessary.
The Board will expect that the agreement provide for an interline service which is
consistent with the public interest.
APC SAREE NEE ws wee
on
See oe
4la
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
provides for price reductions at sixty-three cities which REA
estimates would recapture traffic lost since implementation of
its November increases. Since the Board has not yet passed upon
the new tariff, in detail, we of course offer no views upon it
except to note that the new filing provides no reason for the
Board to stay its decision here.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. Agreement CAB 24824 be and it hereby is disapproved;
2. The reply of the Drug and Toilet Preparation Traffic
Conference and the National Small Shipment Traffic
Conference is accepted;
3. The authorization granted in Order 74-2-118, as
extended by Order 74-11-26, be and it hereby is further extended
until 14 days after the issuance of the mandate of the United
States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in REA v. CAB,
No. 74-1611.8
4. Except to the extent granted herein, all applications,
motions and requests be and they heredy are denied.
By the Civil Aeronautics Board:
(Seal) EDWIN Z. HOLLAND
Secretary
8. The discussions shall be subject to the conditions imposed in Order 74-11-26.
42a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
APPENDIX A
Page | of 2 pages
Major differences between the new and old Air Express
Agreements and Tariffs
1. The new agreement would have no termination date; the
old agreement expired after 5 years.
2. Withdrawal by any party from the new agreement would
require 12 months’ notice; the old agreement required only 6
months’ notice for withdrawal.
3. In case of default by REA on any payment due the
airlines, the airlines’ obligations under the new Air Express
Agreement would be terminated, and all money owed the
airlines by REA would become due 10 days after default; the old
agreement merely provided for termination of the agreement in
the case of certain bankruptcy actions by any party.
4. REA, under the new agreement, would pay the airlines
for the airlines’ services in ground handling of air express
shipments when no REA employees are at an airport ($4 per
shipment; $5 for animals); the old agreement had no similar
provision.
5. The procedures for the provision by REA of substitute
service (surface transportation of air express shipments in those
cases where air service is, or is alleged to be, unavailable or
insufficient) would be clarified in the new agreement; they were
less clear in the old agreement.
43a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
6. The new agreement vould specify that no changes in the
air express tariffs would be made without the written
authorization of the airlines; in the old agreement this was not
clearly requived. (In both the new and old agreements, air
express rates are to be set jointly by REA and the airlines).
7. Im the new agreement, air express revenue would be
divided among REA and the airlines twice a month; under the
old agreement REA allocated and paid the airlines their share of
the revenue once a month.
8. The new agreement specifies that the airli s and REA
would waive the right to request the CAB to chai... the new Air
Express Agreement, and to retroactively readjust the air express
revenue divisions between REA and the airlines. Also, REA
would request the CAB to dismiss REA’s request for such
readjustment in docket 22387.
9. The new air express tariffs provide separate charges for
airport-to-airport air express service, on the one hand, and
pickup and/or delivery of air express shipments, on the other
hand. REA retains the full pickup-and-delivery charges, if any,
on particular shipments, and REA and the airlines divide the air
shipment charges, in accordance with an agreed-upon-
allocation-of-revenue schedule. The old tariff only provided for
door-to-door air express rates.
10. The new air express tariffs provide for three categories
of city-pair markets, with the rates for large city to large city
44a
Order of CAB Dated April 9, 1975
(column A) shipments the lowest, the rates for small city to
small city (column C) shipments the highest, and the rates for
large city to or from small city (column B) shipments in between,
for each category (mileage/weight) of shipment. The airlines’
share of the total charge is the same regardless of which column a
shipment falls into, while REA’s share (and thus the total
charge) is higher in column B and A, and in C and B. The old
tariff had no similar provision.
CCLUMN A
FROM - TO
Atlanta, Ga. - Charlotte, N.C.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
Buffale, N.Y. - Boston, Mass.
Aic Express
Esciy
Ai.borne
Baltimore, Md. Ind.
Airc Express
iuery
Alroorne
- Ft. Wayne,
Cleveland, Chio - Hartford, Conn.
Alr express
Euery
Allrborne
New York, N.Y.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
- Chicago, Ill.
Columbus, Neb.
Ait
Ohio - Omaha,
Express
Airborne
Chicago, Ill. - Dallas, Tex.
Air Express
En2ry
Airborne
* REA Explanation of Proposed Ctanges in Rates and Charges, Official
950
747
711
950
747
711
950
747
963
9590
747
972
9350
1037
1020
350
747
973
950
747
939
950
747
1031
330
747
999
COMPARISON OF PROPOSED
AIR EXPRESS CHARGES WITH
CHARGES OF AIR FREIGHT FORWARDERS
WEIGHT IN POUNDS
10 25 50 70 100 200
CHARGE IN CENTS IS
1500 1550 1550 1654 1959 3346
1600 2000 2444 2690 3017 5128
1452 1913 2576 2747 3005 6010
1590 1571 1908 2204 2653 4932
1609 2033 2530 2818 3209 5490
1473 1365 2633 2397 3219 64393
1500 1681 2156 2536 2998 3302
1643 2097 2670 39017 3523 6263
1557 2179 3112 3499 4073 3156
1500 1757 2330 2744 3134 5576
1690 2033 2539 2818 3209 5499
1473 19655 2683 29597 3219 64393
1500 1901 2576 2973 3594 $922
1690 2118 2764 3170 3772 6440
1494 2019 27990 3943 3433 6366
1500 1991 2576 2973 3584 5922
1600 2181 2929 3432 4181 7454
1578 2231 3219 3649 4292 8594
1500 1943 2698 30395 3325 6039
1600 2141 2929 3432 4181 7454
1515 727072 2897 3198 3649 7293
Appendix B *
300
4821
7554
8031
7197
8064
3697
7614
8454
11376
9025
3064
8697
8235
9027
9469
8235
9795
12042
3334
9795
10035
CAB No. 1 and Pronosed Air Fxpress Pickup & Delivery Tariff No. 1, CAB No. 2
Submitted September 30, 1994
Service
Provided
in both
Directions
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
tes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
EXHIBIT 3
ZONE [I
Pickup Delivery
Charge in Cents IS
335 275
335 275
235 275
330 350
350 350
205 325
490 300
400 300
300 250
330 350
339 350
300 250
$25 375
525 375
525 300
265 275
265 275
250 250
375 306
375 300
300 300
Air Express Tariff No. l,
COLUMN A - Continued EXHIBIT 3
WEIGHT IN POUNDS ZONE I
Service
l 5 10 25 50 70 100 200 300 Provided Pickup Delivery
in both
FROM - TO CHARGE IN CENTS IS Directions Charge in Cents IS
New York, N.Y. - Jacksonville, Fla. ;
Air Express 950 950 1500 1943 2633 3095 3325 6030 A334 Yes 525 315
Emery 1037 1037 1643 2260 3107 3499 45693 8394 11645 Yes $25 3i3
Airborne 711 «#1041 1599 2285 3326 3793 4506 9012 12714 Yes 525 250
Denver, Colo. - Cnicago, Ill.
Air Express . 950 350 1550 2054 2828 3200 4088 6292 8727 Yes 355 375
Emery 747 747 1600 2039 2708 3936 3637 €240 8333 Yes 335 375
Airborne 711 999 1515 2072 2897 3193 3649 7293 10035 Yes 305 309
Houston, Tex. - Dayton, Ohio
Airc Express 950 3930 1550 2054 238238 3200 4033 6292 3727 Yes 490 265
Enery 747 747 #1690 2076 2650 2939 3499 6976 #8619 Yes 490 265
Airborne 711 1041 +1599 2285 3326 3793 4506 9012 12714 Yes 300 250
Kansas City, Kans. - Phoenix,Ariz.
Airc Express 950 950 1573 2034 2843 3373 4377 6708 ~ 9366 Yes 350 250
Emery 747 747 1599 2200 2438 3524 4322 7790 10167 Y2s 3590 250
Airborne 7ll 1031 1578 2231 32193 3649 4292 8534 12042 Yes 300 250
Tulsa, Okla. - Los Angsles,Calif. / :
Sir Express 930 950 1650 2331 3151 3305 4955 3184 10635 Yes 260 350
Ewery 747 747 1600 2210 3031 3599 4433 78283 410374 Yes 260 350
A.roorn? 711 #1031 1578 2231 3219 3649 4292 3594 12042 Yes 250 359
P.+tsbirgn, Pa.— Salt Lake City,Ut.
Air Express 950 950 1725 2533 3533 4249 36738 9344 12387 Yes 300 270
Emery 747 747 1600 2302 3310 4039 43107 9234 12459 Yes 350 279
Aicborne 71l 1073 #1662 2444 #%3649 4249 53151 10302 14719 Yes _ 280 259
ew York, N.¥.-Los Angeles, Calif.
Air Express 950 950 1730 2834 4121 5190 5747 #+%11722 15606 Yes $25 350
Emery 747 747 1600 2481 3828 4815 6284 11698 16026 Yes 525 350
Airborne 7ll 1994 1704 2559 3363 4549 5580 11160 16059 Yes $25 350
Miami, Fla. - Portland, Ore.
Air Express 950 930 1819 3010 43833 5516 7207 12959 7637 Yes 350 390
Emery 747 747 1609 2431 3328 4315 6234 11698 6026 Yes .” in 300
Airborne 7ll 61115 «17456 «26356 4978 493359 60035 12013 17394 Yes 325 300
COLUMN 5
F2OM-TO
Roche ster,N.Y. = Lansing,!ich.
"ir Express
Emery
Airborne
Nllentown,Pa. - Buffaio,N.Y.
\ir Express
hoery
,irborne
Elmira,N.Y. = Boston,Mass.
‘ir Express
onery
,irborne
Bal: imore,'Naryland - Lexington, KY.
ir Express
very
‘irborne
Marc ester,N.H.-Cleveland, Qh.
.f Express
tnery
..rborne
Binghamton,U.¥. - Chicago, Iil.
ir Express
boery
“irborne
Charloctte,'\C.- Peoria, Ill.
“ir ocxpress
Enery
‘.irborne
-
AIR EXPRESS CHARGES WITH
COMPARISON OF PROPOSED
CH/.KGES OF AIR FREIGHT FORWAKDESS
10
1525
1718
1536
1525
1643
1452
1525
1643
1452
1525
1643
1557
1525
1674
2473
1525
16.3
1578
1525
1643
1557
WEIGHT IN
25
50
70
POUNDS
100
CHARGE IN CENTS IS
1700
2105
2125
1700
2100
1913
1700
2100
1913
1826
2097
2179
1930
2306
2965
1938
2145
2231
2053
2282
2179
2029
2636
3095
1850
2695
2576
2029
2695
2576
2479
2670
3112
2680
2902
3683
2680
2810
3219
vin
Ee Oo
—-a oOo
NUIT nh
2249
2946
3348
1954
3057
2747
2249
3057
2747
2916
3017
3499
3156
3763
3897
3156
3230
3649
3419
3792
3499
2615
3454
3863
2159
3590
3005
2615
3590
3005
3448
3523
4078
3604
3871
4219
3604
387i
4292
4122
4706
4078
200
4794
6218
7726
3946
6420
6010
4794
6420
6010
6098
6268
B1SE
6412
70€O
8438
6412
6986
8504
6810
8672
8156
300
6972
9327
10704
$72)
8661
8031
"6972
8661
8021
8757
8454
11376
9220
10590
11697
9228
9513
12042
9471
12060
11376
Service
Frovided
in both
EXHIBIT 3
ZONE I
Pickup
Delivery
Directions Charge in Cents IS
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
325
325
300
250
250
250
350
350
305
350
350
325
250
250
250
330
330
300
375
375
300
250
250
250
COLUFN B - Continued
FROM - TO
tiami,fla.- New Bern,N.C.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
Des Moines, Ia. - Houston, Tex
Air Express
fnerv
\irborne
Houston,Tex. -Lincoln, Neb.
Air Express
Emery
“irborne
Omaha,Neb.- Midland, Tex.
ir Express
Emery
Alrborne
Pittsburgh, Pa.- Fort Smith,
i aia
Alc Express
Emery
\irborne
St. Louis, Mo.-Las Vegas,Nev.
ir Express
Enery
Airborne
1525
1909
2557
1525
1600
1620
1525
1988
1599
1575
1988
155”
1600
2090
2494
1725
1636
1€83
2053
2358
3179
2136
2140
2337
2136
2495
2285
2214
2495
2179
2302
2650
3019
2534
2313
2497
2962
2981
#112
3091
2824
3433
3091
3204
3326
3252
3204
3112
3269
3450
3790
3688
3269
3756
WEIGHT IN POUNDS
70
CHARGE
3419
3367
4499
3559
3258
3948
355%
3683
3796
3879
3683
3499
3879
3999
2048
4479
3953
4399
100
200
IN CENTS IS
4122
4006
5078
4399
3918
4722
4399
4431
4506
5034
4431
4078
5034
4855
4433
6039
4968
5365
6819
7352
10156
6934
6616
9444
693¢
£190
901?
7806
8190
6156
7806
9046
8066
964€
9190
10730
300
Service
Provided
ia Both
Directions
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Yos
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
EYHIBIT 3
ZONE I.
Pickup
Charge in
350
350
325
250
250
250
Delivery
Cents 'IS
300
300
250
400
400
300
265
265
250
250 -
250
250
300
300
300
350
350
350
COLUMN B - Continued
FROM - TO
Madison,Wisc,- Portland, Ore.
Airc Express
Emery
Airborne
. 1100
1032
711
Rochester,N¥Y. - Bakersfield, Calif.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
1100
1926
711
1800
1636
1683
1850
2315
1746
2734
2334
2497
3111
3134
2556
WEIGHT IN POUNDS
50
70
100
200
CHARGE IN CENTS IS
4070
3326
3756
4739
4417
4078
4885
4044
4399
5865
5314
4850
6530
5111
5365
7759
6710
6009
10768
9466
10730
13480
12808
12018
300
Service
Provided
in Both
Directions
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
EXHIBIT 3
ZONE
Pickup
Charge in
Delivery
Cents IS
300
300
300
250
250
250
FROM - TO
Pensacola, Fla.-South Bend, Ind.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
Pensacola, Fla. - Amarillo, Tex.
Aic Express
Emery
Airborne
Moline, ILL. - Sheridan, Wyo.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
Fargo, N.D. - Lynchburg, Va.
Air Express
Emery
Airborne
Albuquerque, N.M. - Spokane, Wash.
Air Expres¢
Emecy
Airborne
Tucson, Aria. - Aberdeen,
Airc Express
Enery
Airborne
Wash.
Richmond, Va. - Alamogordo, N.M,
Airc Express
Emery
Airborne
Elmira, N.¥. - Walla Walla, Wash.
Air Express
Emecy
Airborne
1600
1822
1041
1600
1822
1920
1600
13935
2052
1600,
1747
10352
1600
.1932
1952
1690
1822
2031
1600
1926
2094
1600
arf
COMPARISON OF PROPOSED
AIR EXPRESS CHARGES WITH
CHARGES OF AIR FREIGHT FORWARDERS
WEIGHT IN POUNDS
10 25 50 70 4 8=6100 0 =—200
CHARGE IN CENTS IS
1925
2150
1599
4973
5111
4596
7849
9563
9012
4024
4183
3793
3494
3602
3326
2523
2740
2235
5314
5111
4973
8180
95693
8156
19590
2150
1557
3675
3602
3112
4160
4188
3499
2621
2740
2179
5314
5494
5722
1950
2269
2620
4160
4488
4948
3676
3353
4433
8180
10340
11444
2621
2903
3337
2974
2595
2337
2100
2035
1620
4096
3355
3433
4579
3394
3948
6046
4706
4722
10348
8772
9444
3968
3269
3433
2075
1536
1620
2834
2313
2337
4801
3953
39493
6333
4363
4722
10528
9190
9444
2993
2740
3231
2150
2150
2578
4159
3602
4219
$964
4183
4649
$6326
S111
5292
10904
9568
10584
3234
3020
3550
2275
2290
2704
4601
4155
4353
5522
4938
5549
7381
6158
6386
3478
7009
12174
11696
13160
2320
2315
2746
3554
3134
3656
$327
314
5350
View
oer
~eS)
Qo ~w0
300
10833
14352
12714
11346
14352
11376
11346
15510
16380
13125
13158
13380
13476
12846
13380
14220
14352
25042
16104
17529
19059
fiat 18
Service
Provided Pickup
in both
Directions
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes —
EXHIBIT 3
ZONE I
Delivery .
Charge in Cents IS
250
230
250
250
250
250
325
325
290
350
350
250
EXHIBIT 3
COMPARISON OF PROPOSED
AIR EXPRESS CHARGES WITH
CHARGES OF ATR FREIGHT FORWARDERS
t
WEIGHT IN POUNDS | ZONE I
Service
1 5 10 25 50 70 100 200 300 Provided Pickup Delivery
in both
FROM ~ TO CHARGE IN CENTS [3 Directions Charge in Cents Is
ijpokane, Wash. - Pendleton, Ore,
Air Express 1600 1690 1925 2009 2050 2154 2417 4359 632) Ye 6 300 250
Pouery 1436 1436 1696 2065 2546 2352 3319 $942 4913 No 300 250
Aj roocne 171) 2010 2536 3125 4905 4343 4363 9726 13794 No 300 250
ws Moines, Iowa - Springfield, Mo.
Air Express 16900 1690 1925 2000 2248 2534 23956 5418 7881 Yes 250 250
Emery 1549 1549 1305 2204 2745 3065 3590 6496 9744 Yes 259 250
Airborne 711 1020 1557 2179 3112 31499 4079 31356 11376 No 250 250
{\ egon, Mi. = Burlington, Iowa
\ic Express 1600 1600 1925 2000 2249 2534 12955 $419 7951 Ye s 275 275
Emery 1464 1464 1719 2105 2636 2946 3454 6219. 9327 No 275 275
\irborne 171) 2010 2535 3125 4005 4348 4°63 9726 13704 No 275 250
\.istin, Tex. = El Dorado, Ark.
‘ir Express , 1600 1600 1925 2018 2480 2865 3449 6412 9357 Yes 300 250
ery 1663 1663 1942 2409 3059 3472 4151 7626 11439 fes 390 250
rborne 711 1010 1536 2125 3995 3348 3863 7726 19704 No 250 250
4 ee, ba. - Charleston, S.C.
ic Express 1609 1600 1925 2426 3349 3365 4559 7693 10770 Ye $ 250 300
ery Y 1522 15922 1772 2163 2697 3919 3523 6368 9552 Yes 250 390
irborne A711 2020 2557 3179 4112 4499 5078 10156 14376 Yes 250 275
. ocy, Ll. «- Grand Forks, N.D. ;
r Express 1699 1609 1925 2283 3929 3567 4974 7249 19444 Yes 275 250
ery 1663 1663 1942 2409 3059 3472 4151 7626 11439 No 275 250
borne 1711 2020 2557 3179 4112 4499 5078 19156 14376 No 265 250
jceenville, S.C. - Fayetteville,Ark,
s’r Express 1690 1690 1925 2523 3494 4024 4973 7840 10833 Yes 3]2 269
Crecy 1951 1951 2184 2792 3437 4292 45245 9840 14760 Yes | 369
Airborns 711 1020 1557 2179 3112 3499 4078 815€ 11376 No 250
BEST COPY AVAILABLE.
46a
ORDER OF CAB DATED JUNE 26, 1974
Order 74-6-117
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Adopted by the Civil Aeronautics Board at its office in
Washington, D.C. on the 26th day of June, 1974
Docket 22387
INVESTIGATION OF AIR EXPRESS RATES
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR STAY
By Order 74-5-23, entered in the above captioned
proceeding, the Board found, inter alia, that the issue of the
lawful future rates for air express service had been rendered
moot by its decision in the Express Service Investigation (Order
73-12-36) to terminate REA’s exemption authority to conduct
air express service. In addition, the Board found that although
the issue of whether it should attempt to retroactively
redistribute between REA and the direct air carriers air express
proceeds for prior periods was still ripe, the record and analyses
developed by the parties on this issue was far from adequate for
an informed judgment as to what the just, reasonable, and
equitable divisions would be, or as to the Board's jurisdiction to
prescribe such divisions. In this posture, the Board found it
appropriate to request the interested parties to meet under the
47a
Order of CAB Dated June 26, 1974
chairmanship of the Director of the Bureau of Economics, and
to endeavor to reach agreement “with respect to such matters as
the detailed air express traffic and revenue data for calendar
years 1971, 1972, and 1973; methods of evaluating the divisions
made under the formula outstanding during the period April
1970 forward; and,...,an overall conclusion on the
appropriate divisions for the period.”'
REA has now filed a motion requesting that the Board stay
Order 74-5-23 pending completion of judicial review.? Answers
to the motion have been filed by the airlines participating in air
express service (“Airlines”), Emery Air Freight Corporation
(Emery), the Air Freight Forwarders Association (AFFA), and
the Pet Industry Parties (Pet).’
Upon consideration of the motion and answers, the Board
has determined for the reasons set forth below to deny the
request. While REA apparently seeks a stay pending judicial
review of the Board's order, it does not articulate the reasons
why a stay is warranted, and we are unable to find that a stay is
appropriate.
|. Order 74-5-23 at 9.
2. REA's Motion also seeks a stay of the Board's decision in the Express Service
Investigation, Docket 22388. By Order 74-6-118, the Board denied the Motion as applied
to the Service proceeding.
3. On June 11, 1974, REA filed a reply to the answers of Emery and AFFA
accompanied by a Motion For Leave To File An Otherwise Unauthorized Document.
We will grant REA’s motion
48a
Order of CAB Dated June 26, 1974
The Rates proceeding order which REA now seeks to stay
principally involves two distinct findings: first, that the issue of
lawful future express rates is moot as a result of the decision to
terminate REA’s express monopoly; and second, that the
existing record is inadequate for determination of the issue of
retroactive redistribution of express revenues from prior periods
and that further procedures are necessary. REA’s motion
completely fails to support any claim that either of these two
findings will result in any irreparable injury to REA.
Accordingly, we cannot find any basis for grant of the stay. In
addition, the findings on the state of the record with respect to
retroactive divisions do not constitute a final order of the Board
on this issue and, therefore, are not ripe for judicial review.
Hence, no basis for a stay pendente lite of this aspect of the
order exists.
In our original order, we had sought to promote resolution
of a number of issues underlying the retroactivity question
through discussions between the interested parties. A meeting
for this purpose had been scheduled for May 28, 1974, but was
subsequently canceled at the suggestion of counsel for REA,
who expressed the opinion that the meeting might not be
productive in view of the pendency of the motion for stay. The
Airlines in their answer took note of the cancellation of the
meeting and suggested that rather than proceed with a meeting
in accordance with the procedure outlined in Order 74-5-22, the
Board first direct the parties to file briefs directed to the
jurisdictional issue, and to consider the remaining issues only if
the Board decides that it has jurisdiction.
49a
Order of CAB Dated June 26, 1974
We do not agree. There are several different resolutions that
can be made of the retroactive redistribution issue regardless of
the ultimate finding on the jurisdiction issue. Accordingly, for
the foregoing reasons as well as the reasons expressed in Order
74-5-23, we will direct a rescheduling of the meeting in
accordance with the procedures outlined in our previous order.
The procedural dates will be determined by the Bureau Director.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. REA's motion to stay of Order 74-5-23 be and it hereby
is denied.
2. The ordering paragraphs of Order 74-5-23 be amended
to read as follows:
“1. An informal conference be convened by the Director,
Bureau of Economics, for the purpose of assembling factual
material and attempting to reach agreement on the divisions of
revenues pursuant to operations conducted under Agreements
CAB 12866 and CAB 17935, as amended, as set forth in Order
74-5-23;
“2. At the termination of the conference by the Director, he
shall forthwith file with the Board a report, accompanied by
such stipulations as have been agreed upon by parties to the
CAB agreements cited in paragraph one; and
50a
Order of CAB Dated June 26, 1974
“3. If the parties to the above-listed CAB agreements
cannot reach agreement on a stipulation of the divisions of
revenue prior to the termination of the conference, the Director
shall establish a procedural timetable for the filing by the parties
with the Board of briefs and reply briefs addressed to the issues
discussed in Order 74-5-23.”
By the Civil Aeronautics Board:
EDWIN Z. HOLLAND
Secretary
(SEAL)
|
Sla
ORDER OF CAB DATED MAY 6, 1974
Order 74-5-23
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Adopted by the Civil Aeronautics Board
at its office in Washington, D.C.
on the 6th day of May, 1974
Docket 22387
INVESTIGATION OF AIR EXPRESS RATES
ORDER
This investigation was instituted by Order 70-7-109, July 23,
1970, to determine the lawfulness of the air express rates and the
divisions of such rates and charges as between REA and the
direct air carriers. At the same time, in a companion order,' we
instituted the Express Service Investigation, Docket 22388, to
explore, among other things, the future role of express or
priority cargo service in air transportation and whether the
existing concept of an air express agreement between the direct
air carriers and an express company should be maintained.
1. Order 70-7-110. That order also deferred action on an amendment of the air
express agreement between REA and the airlines which provided, inter alia, for new
divisions of rates.
52a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
The Board has now, in Order 73-12-36, issued December 7,
1973, in the Service Investigation, authorized REA to operate as
a domestic air freight forwarder, ordered the termination of
REA’s exemption authority to conduct air express service, and
indicated that separate rates for expedited freight should be
established? independently, by direct air carriers and air freight
forwarde:s, rather than pursuant to agreements. In the light of
that decision the instant Air Express Rates Investigation has
been rendered moot in most respects. Because of the change in
REA’s mode of operation foreshadowed by our decision that it
shall henceforth be an air freight forwarder rather than maintain
its air express monopoly, no useful purpose would be served by
our passing on the lawfulness of air express rates or attempting
to resolve the disagreement between REA and the direct air
carriers concerning the amounts to be paid over to the latter
from revenues to be received under lawful prospective rates for
express.
There remains, however, the question whether the Board
should attempt to redistribute air express proceeds between the
REA and the direct air carriers on a retrospective basis. This
matter was within the scope of the hearing conducted by
Administrative Law Judge Milton H. Shapiro, his Initial
Decision, and our Order 72-7-15 undertaking review. Briefs have
been fi'ed and oral argument conducted, and the question was
submitted for decision. However, as discussed more fully below,
2. Subject, of course, to the normal rate procedures ir volving review and possible
investigation and suspensions. The order also disapproved the agreements covering air
express services, rates and divisions. Express operations will continue for a “wind-up”
period through July 31, 1974. Order 74-5-25.
53a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
we are not satisfied with (1) the analyses made by the parties
concerning the Board’s power to order a retroactive adjustment
of the revenue divisions heretofore made by REA and the
airlines or (2) the state of the record on REA and airline costs
and revenues, and we are uncertain at this time whether, under
all the circumstances, it would be in the public interest for the
Board to exercise its discretion (assuming our jurisdiction) and
attempt to redistribute the air express revenues. We do know,
however, that there are major gaps in the data necessary to an
informed judgment as to what the just, reasonable and equitable
divisions would be, and that we have serious doubts with respect
to the jurisdiction question which were not resolved by the
parties’ presentations.
REA contends that it has been denied its fair share of air
express revenues in the past and argues that the Board can and
should require an adjustment of these revenues for the past
period beginning April 9, 1970, the date of REA’s Petition and
Complaint seeking reformation of the agreement and relief with
respect to the revenue allocation reflected in the existing
agreement.’ Its argument is based on section 1002(h) of the
3. See Orders 70-7-110, 70-8-48 and 71-2-68. The Board originally dismissed REA's
pleading since the reform and relief requested were the subject of the broader ranging
Express Service and Express Rates cases, but when the carrier raised the issue of the
legal effect of dismissal prejudicing its positions with respect to the date of any
retroactive action under section !002(h) of the Act, we reinstated the Petition and
Complaint for the limited purpose of preserving our legal option to grant relief
retroactive to the April 9, 1970, filing date, and consolidated that limited reinstatement
with the instant investigation. The Board also announced that it refrained from taking
any position on its power to grant such relief or the need for the relief, stating that it
intended only to preserve such legal option should the Board decide to exercise it under
proper circumstances.
54a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
Federal Aviation Act, which provides that when the Board
prescribes just, reasonable, and equitable divisions of joint rates
between the air carriers parties thereto it may require the
adjustment of divisions between such air carriers from the date
of the filing of a complaint or such later date as it finds just,
reasonable and equitable.* REA claims that, under a proper
division formula,’ the airlines owe it over $1 million a month
from April 9, 1970, forward, and that hence retroactive
adjustment is needed to restore to REA its rightful entitlement.
At the threshold, the airlines have challenged the Board’s
jurisdiction to make retroactive adjustments of the divisions.
They take the position that (1) while the Board can prescribe
divisions prospectively through its power to condition approval
of REA-airline agreements under section 412 of the Act, it
4. Section 1002(h) reads as follows:
“Whenever, after notice and hearing, upon complaint or upon
its own initiative, the Board is of the opinion that the divisions of
joint rates, fares, or charges for air transportation are or will be
unjust, unreasonable, inequitable, or unduly preferential or
prejudicial as between the air carriers or foreign air carriers parties
thereto, the Board shail prescribe the just, reasonable, and equitable
divisions thereof to be received by the several air carriers. The
Board may require the adjustment of divisions between such air
carriers from the date of filing the complaint or entry of order of
investigation, or such other date subsequent thereto as the Board
finds to be just, reasonable, and equitable.”
5. Under the formula proposed by REA, airline divisions from air express are to bear the
same relationship to airline air express costs as airline freight revenues bear to airline
freight costs and the airline costs are to be computed on the basis of by-product costing.
55a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
cannot alter the agreements themselves® and (2) the Board lacks
the power to prescribe divisions of revenues between REA and
the airlines pursuant to section 1002(h), since express rates are
not “joint rates” between REA and the airlines. They assert that
joint rates may exist only between connecting carriers operating
through routes (i.e., airlines) and not between indirect air
carric.s and direct air carriers. The airlines state that REA does
not operate “through routes” in air transporation, but only pick-
up and delivery services, which are terminal services rather than
line-haul or through route services.
In his Initial Decision Judge Shapiro did not reach the
jurisdictional question under section 1002(h). Contemplating
divisions for the future, he determined, in the then existing
circumstances, that jurisdiction is conferred by section 412. That
section of the Act allows the Board te approve or disapprove
agreements between REA and the airlines and has been the
vehicle for Board control of REA-airline relationships, including
the method of dividing revenues, since the inception of the air
express service. In the Judge’s view, although the power to
prescribe rate levels does not coincide with the power to
prescribe divisions, once the rate levels are prescribed according
to the costs of the carriers for air express, the parties could
proceed, as in the past, to negotiate an agreement with respect to
divisions to reflect the prescribed rates, and the Board can offer
the parties the choice of Board approval if they conform to the
6. The carriers argue that if the parties to an agreement do not accept a condition the
Board can disapprove the agreement, but not re-write it. Withholding approval of an
agreement because of a deficiency would not here serve to change the distribution of
express revenues for past periods.
S6a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
conditions relating to divisions, or of disapproval if they fail to
accept them. As to the retroactive adjustment issue, Judge
Shapiro held that the rates and divisions he found reasonable
showed that rather than there having been an overpayment to
the airlines by REA from the proceeds of the air express
revenues, the airlines had been underpaid. He found that the
evidence did not support REA’s contention that it is entiiled to
reimbursement for overpayments to airlines under existing
divisions; that the airlines had made no claim for retroactive
payment or alterations of the divisions, because of their view
that neither Section 412 nor section 1002(h) grants authority to
make retroactive adjustments; and that in all the circumstances
no such adjustment was required. Accordingly, he found that
there was no need to require retroactive adjustments of the
divisions as a condition of approval of any REA-airline
agreement to be reached regarding air express rates.’
As the Board currently views the matter, a major difficulty
with the conclusion of the Administrative Law Judge is that the
existing record does not appear to contain sufficient factual
7. In the light of the Board's decision in the Express Service Investigation, its power
under section 412 to attach conditions to approval of the REA-airline agreement is no
longer available as a means of prescribing divisions as a practical matter (absent
consensus), since we are terminating the agreement in any event. Whatever the merits of
conditioning approvals of agreements having future applicability on acceptance of
prescriptions of divisions of revenues for past periods, the sanction of disapproval is lost
where the agreement is not of a continuing nature, and we have no basis directly to
reform an agreement between the parties. As Judge Shapiro correctly stated, under
section 412 the Board is empowered to offer the parties a choice of approval if conditions
are accepted or disapproval if they are refused, cf McManus v. C.A.B., 286 F.2d 414 (2d
Cir., 1961).
57a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
information to permit us to conclude whether or not the existing
revenue divisions, which could extend over a period as long as
from April 1970 to 1974, are equitable. Although Judge Shapiro
exercised a great deal of patience and persistence in attempting
to determine the costs incurred by REA and the airlines, this
task proved to be what he called “a prickly and elusive
challenge.” This was especially true so far as REA’s financial
results and operating statistics were concerned.
The problem stems in part from the fact that REA does not
report on a recurrent (or even sporadic) basis any detail for its
air express revenues, expenses and investment, nor such basic
data as air express shipments, pieces and pounds, separately
from such information for its surface express operations, much
less on a more refined basis which would for example
differentiate between system and domestic air express, or general
commodity-rated and _ specific commodity-rated _ traffic.*
Apparently, it also keeps its books on a system basis only,
although air express is handled by a separate operating division
of the company. Quite obviously, this history and practice of
aggregate accounting and reporting both emphasizes the need
for accurate allocations and makes the allocations more difficult
to accomplish and to assess. When this deficiency was coupled
with a fundamental revision of REA’s system of accounts,
effective July 1, 1970, the result was to render it extremely
8 The general commodity-rated traffic and the specific commodity-rated traffic are
somewhat different in terms of volume, weight and prices per shipment, and weigh: per
piece. See Initial Decision, Appendix J. The ALJ's costs were based on those for the
general commodity-rated traffic, since marketing considerations would normally have a
greater impact on the SCR's than on the GCR's.
Ska
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
difficult, if not impossible, to compare data for this first half of
1970 with data for the second half of that year, or to reconcile
the data for the two halves of the year with the carrier's report to
the Interstate Commerce Commission for calendar 1970, much
less to make dependable comparisons with earlier years or
projections to later years. Yet, REA was insistent that 1970 was
the only feasible base period, since it had made two cost studies
during that year which it deemed crucial to its allocation of
costs. REA further asserts that, because of a number of variable
factors, the studies could not be applied to 1969 data to develop
cost allocations for that prior period (which had been designed
earlier as the base year), and that even the costs REA itself had
developed .or 1969 were merely the product of what it
characterizes as a “meaningless mathematical exercise.” In that
posture, and because of “the quality of the evidence actually
furnished at the hearing” (1.D. p. 12), the Judge determined, in
effect, to accept 1970 as the base year. However, it must be
noted that the variables which were asserted by REA to make its
costing inapplicable to 1969 data would appear to make equally
questionable the application of its methodology to later periods.
Moreover, as indicated in the initial decision, the evidence
presented at the hearing was not of the highest quality, to say
the least. The exhibits were revised and recast on various
occasions, not only to alter findings from the studies, but also to
change fundamental statistics, such as number of shipments, and
the result is a morass of seemingly conflicting figures. The
problem is greatly aggravated by the absence of basic data for
traffic and revenues subsequent to the hearing in this case. Judge
59a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
Shapiro directed REA to furnish monthly reports of air express
traffic data until the Board's final decision in this investigation.
In July 1971 REA requested permission to be relieved of this
requirement. The request was denied by the Judge, but
nevertheless REA _ unilaterally discontinued submitting the
reports. Whatever the other difficulties of determining the
proper divisions for years subsequent to 1970, the continued
absence of basic information needed to allocate costs would
make the task impossible.
Within the limits of the data the Administrative Law Judge
has made cost findings for 1969 and 1970 which satisfied him
that the airlines, rather than REA, had been underpaid and that
REA had not proven that it was entitled to reimbursement for
overpaying the airlines under the divisions. REA has challenged
these findings, alleging that the Initial Decision contained errors
involving over $26 million of claimed costs denied to it and
almost $36 million of airline costs mistakenly allowed. While a
preliminary review indicates that at least $22 million of claimed
errors respecting REA costs are unsubstantiatea’ and that most,
9. REA has claimed “inflation” of $14.5 million but, quite apart from the fact that this
item has no bearing on 1970 costs, the record support will not bear scrutiny. The primary
bases for the claim are (1) its two forecast !5% payroll increases, predicated on asserted
increases in that amount in the railroad industry, plus (2) a projection for economic
inflation, footed on an overall forecast in the Survey of Current Business. But REA
stated on brief tothe Board that it had not paid its union employees increased wages
since June 1970 and a national forecast is too speculative a basis to apply to the costs of
any particular company. Further, there is no reason to believe that REA experienced
inflation any more severe than the airlines with whom the air express revenues are to be
divided.
(Cc ont'd)
i ee
60a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
if not all, of REA’s theories pertaining to the airlines’ express
costs are invalid,'® the Board is unwilling to undertake an in-
(Cont'd)
The second major “error” asserted was the disallowance of $7 million in return and
taxes. However, this figure rests on the theory that @ particular amount of money — here
$3.5 million--is required to attract capital, Neither the theory nor the amount is
adequately supported. As a means of reaching the sum in question, REA applied a
claimed 15°% capital to a constructed investment which would produce the result. This is
4 totally unacceptable approach. We will not inflate investment to make up for losses
incurred prior to the institution of this investigation, nor attempt to provide a return on
investment covering the cost of capital for REA's entire system, nor provide capital
directly, as opposed to a return element affording the means for attracting capital and
the return element is not intended to make up for operating inefficiencies, failure to
adjust costs to revenue, or lack of receptivity to service needs and customer
requirements. See Tr. 515-517,
The remaining items are questionable, REA's Posture on these rest on such factors
as allocations based on unsupported judgment which are inconsistent with statements in
tariff justifications on file with the Board: retroactive revisions of accounting for bad
debts, insurance allocation ratios twice as high in one period as in another; and a
mistaken view of the impact of a shipment coun: on the costs for general commodity-
rated traffic. Problems of evidentiary support also inhere in the allocations of “other
revenue” and accounting for value charges, C.O.D. fees, and other accessorial charges.
10. The first error ($3.74 million) attributed by REA to the initial decision was the use of
4 joint product rather than a by-product basis for allocating airline-costs as required by
our decision in the Domestic Passenger-Fare Investigation, Docket 21866-7. But the ALJ
did not misread our decision as asserted by REA. In contrast to our tentative view with
respect to freight rates, we stated that we had no reason to believe that mail and express
rates could not cover a fully allocated share of capacity and noncapacity costs. Our view
has not been altered by the record in the instant investigation, which strongly suggests
that REA's past problems with contracting shipment volumes were attributable to a
reputation for poor service rather than to its prices. These prices remained advantageous
competitively vis-a-vis air freight in the short-haul markets where the vast bulk of REA's
traffic is carried. The repeated post-hearing filings for rate increases by REA are not
inconsistent with a belief that express traffic is relatively price-inelastic Moreover. for
division purposes, costs should not be altered by price elasticity considerations: divisions
(Cont'd)
6la
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
depth review of REA’s contentions with respect to 1970 in the
absence of, at the least, more data for the remaining years which
aid be cost-based, and where the respective percentage aga revenues are fixed in
Nn to respective costs, inability to price at cost is irrelevant.
aon the a that the airlines’ share of express revenues should have the same
relationship to their express costs (based on by-product “costing™) as their freight rates
bear to freight costs was properly rejected by the ALJ. If it is true that the airlines cannot
recover full costs from their freight operations (a question still to be determined in the
Domestic Air Freight Rate Investigation, Docket 22859), it still does not follow that they
should therefore lose money on express or should therefore be awarded a low share
(assertedly $3.79 million less) of express revenues.
The next alleged error, labeled “priority and density,” actually involves the theory
and mechanics of capacity cost allocations: that is, the so-called weight versus space
dispute, as well as the weighting factors used. REA states that over $14 million is at
stake, but does not segregate the elements involved. Our tentative view is that the ALJ
correctly used the space basis of allocation. That method requires the use of relative
density as a conversion factor, and the ALJ properly preferred on-board density over
dock-side density. He also properly followed precedent by using a priority weighting to
allocate costs, since some costs are incurred because of reserving capacity in recognition
of the priority agreement and the priority does result in some preference to express on
some flights. Cf Nonpriority Mail Rate Case, Order 70-4-9. However, we do not here
pass on the validity of the priority weighting chosen. On the other hand, although REA
made no evidentiary showing as to the proper cargo load-factor standard and failed to
address itself to a passenger load-factor standard, it would appear that airline capacity
costs are overstated for at least part of the division period if passenger load-factor
standards developed in the Passenger-Fare Case are not applied. . |
Finally, REA makes a broadside attack on the ALJ's noncapacity costs, asserting 8
$14.3 million error. The difficulty with REA's presentation is that it relies very heavily on
an unsubstantiated judgment that the airlines’ cost of handling express traffic is one-sixth
that of handling freight. The record shows that at many airports the airlines perform all
handling functions, and that even where REA does play a significant role, there are
countervailing influences such as the size of express pieces and the expense of runners.
As in the case of REA's costs, we shall not here explore the contentions of the
parties with respect to airline express costs. We do note, however, two apparent problem
areas: (1) the initial decision disallowed all reservations and sales expense, but some costs
in this function do appear to be entailed, as the ALJ appears to have recognized, and (2)
a straight-line approach to capacity cost allocations ignores the problem of taper in the
short distances common for express shipments.
62a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
would be involved, and prior to resolving our heretofore stated
reservations concerning jurisdiction.'!
In this posture the Board deems it appropriate to request
the interested parties to meet in an informal conference, with a
view to reaching agreement with respect to such matters as the
detailed air express traffic and revenue data for calendar years
1971, 1972, and 1973; methods of evaluating the divisions made
under the formula outstanding during the period April 1970
forward; and, if possible, an overall conclusion on the
appropriate divisions for the period. REA and the airlines
collectively are requested to specify the amounts they
respectively received under the air express rate levels in effect,
during the periods April 9 - December 31, 1970, calendar year
1971, calendar year 1972, and calendar year 1973, bearing in
mind not only the several rate increases but special payments or
credits'? and deficiencies.') We are hopeful that, with a full
understanding of the difficulties, the conferees will be
1}. Similarly, it would be inadvisable at this time to review the countervailing
contentions of the airlines which claim REA's costs were overstated and their own costs
understated by the ALJ; those of Bureau Counsel, who claims that both airline and REA
costs were overstated by the ALJ; or those of the Air Freight Forwarder Association
which urges that the ALJ has understated the costs and hence the rates for this
competing service. Indeed, as stated above, the airlines have urged that we lack
jurisdiction to revisit the past period divisions, and the freight forwarders have at most
an extremely attenuated interest in a conrfikeny limited to divisions.
12. Eg. $1.5 million in 1970 and again in 1971 was credited and paid to REA
notwithstanding other provisions of the division agreement.
13. It is our understanding that REA may have deferred payment of some $7 million to
the airlines as of the end of 1973
63a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
constrained to resolve their own differences and present a
stipulation to the Board. If, however, a consensus cannot be
reached, then the parties are requested to file briefs with the
Board. These briefs are to be addressed to (1) whether the Board
has jurisdiction over retroactive adjustments of the divisions of
air express revenues, (2) whether assuming jurisdiction, the
Board should exercise its discretion to require such
adjustments,'* (3) whether further procedures are necessary,
short of final decision by the Board, and (4) what divisions
should be established and the basis therefor.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. An informal conference shall be convened within thirty
day from the date of this order, to be presided over by the
Director, Bureau of Economics, for the purpose of assembling
factual material and attempting to reach agreement on the
divisions of revenues pursuant to operations conducted under
Agreements CAB 12866 and CAB 17935, as amended, as
discussed above;
2. At the termination of the conference by its chairman, he
shall forthwith file with the Board a report, accompanied by
such stipulations as have been agreed upon by parties to the
above-cited CAB Agreements; and
14. In this connection the parties should address themselves to (a) whether REA has the
burden of proof to establish that the divisions under investigation are unlawful and (b)
assuming that the answer to the foregoing is in the affirmative, whether the investigation
should be terminated without further proceedings on the ground that REA has not
sustained its burden.
64a
Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
3. If the parties to the above-cited CAB Agreements have
not agreed upon a stipulation of the divisions of revenues prior
to the termination of the conference, they may file with the
Board within fifteen days of such termination date, briefs
addressed to the issues as described above.
By the Civil Aeronautics Board:
EDWIN Z. HOLLAND
Secretary
(SEAL)
65a
SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER OF CAB DATED MAY 6, 1974
Order 74-5-25
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D. C.
Adopted by the Civil Aeronautics Board
at its office in Washington, D. C.,
on the 6th day of May, 1974
Docket 22388
EXPRESS SERVICE INVESTIGATION
SUPPLEMENTAL OPINION AND ORDER
BY THE BOARD:
In Order 73-12-36 the Board determined to (1) disapprove’
the agreements among the airlines inter se and between the
airlines and REA providing for air express service; (2) terminate
REA’s exemption authority to act as the exclusive indirect
carrier for air express; and (3) award REA nationwide air freight
forwarder authority and give REA six months to make the
switch from air express to air freight forwarder service. The
Board also found that the scheduled air carriers were under an
obligation to offer highly expedited air freight service.
66a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
REA is the only party to seek reconsideration of Order 73-
12-36. REA’s petition for reconsideration is supported by the
National Small Shipments Traffic Conference,' and opposed by
all of the airlines that are parties to the air express agreements,
the Air Freight Forwarders Association (“AFFA”), and Emery
Air Freight.
REA has also filed a “motion for extension” that “requests
the Board to permit air express to continue until January 31,
1975, so that the express partners may be afforded additional
time for negotiations looking towards continuation of the air
express system.” Twenty-four of the 28 airlines participating in
the air express system support REA’s motion,’ as does the
National Small Shipments Traffic Conference, . United Air
Lines, AFFA and Emery oppose it.’
The Board has determined to deny REA’s petition for
reconsideration and motion for extension. However, for reasons
explained hereafter we shall delay the implementation of our
decision to terminate the air express arrangement until August I,
1974.
1. We will grant the NSTC’s motion for permission to file its reply late.
2. The four airlines that did not join in that answer are Delta, North Central, Southern
and United.
3. REA’s motion for extension and the varicus answers in support of, or in opposition
to, the motion are accompanied by motions for leave to file otherwise unauthorized
documents. The motions for leave to file otherwise unauthorized documents shall be
granted, except for the motion filed on April 16 by the Brotherhood of Railway and
Airline Clerks (See, infra, n. 22).
—_—
67a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
REA’s Pleadings
REA’s petition for reconsideration and motion for
extension overlap in many respects. Neither takes issue with the
Board’s decision to grant REA domestic airfreight forwarder
authority (REA in fact has long sought such authority) nor in
terms seeks reconsideration of our decision to end air express.
Rather, both purport to urge no more than that the termination
date of air express be extended, with the petition for
reconsideration also asking that REA be given additional
authority in the interim period. In point of fact, however, REA’s
petition for reconsideration, and to a lesser extent, REA’s
motion for extension, contend that Order 73-12-36 is in error in
a host of respects.
Taken together, REA’s two pleadings present three basic
contentions:
First, that the record shows that air express will continue to
be a viable arrangement given appropriate action by the Board,
and that the continuation of air express would be in the public
interest.
Second, that circumstances arising since the close of the
record in this proceeding further evidence air express’s continued
viability and its importance to the public.
Third, that even if the Board persists in its determination to
end air express service (and REA’s position as the exclusive
68a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
ground agent for air express), the termination date should be
extended by at least 18 months, and perhaps considerably
longer, and REA should be accorded dual air express-air freight
forwarder authority in the interim.
Each of those three arguments refers to the claimed
importance of air express’s priority rights to air cargo space, to
REA’s broad geographic and commodity coverage, and to
action the Board should take to enable REA and the air express
system to return to financial health. It is to those issues that we
now turn.
Priority Service
By joint agreement between all U. S. certificated route
carriers and REA, REA is the only indirect aii carrier that is
accorded priority treatment. We found that notwithstanding
this arrangement, air express generally is not faster than air
freight forwarder service and is often slower; that the priority
rights of air express service only rarely have any effect; and that
to the extent that extra-quick transportation and priority rights
are useful to shippers, they can best be provided by airline tariffs
sO providing, without being tied, as they are now, to door-to-
door air express service offered solely through REA. REA not
surprisingly disagrees. REA claims that the priority service that
air express offers is important to shippers, and that it is
necessary to set back the termination date of air express at least
4. The agreement provides, however, that the airlines are required to give priority only to
a “normal” amount of air express traffic.
—-
69a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
18 months, and perhaps indefinitely, in order to assure that
shippers continue to have priority service available.‘ In part
REA’s claims in this respect are based on views previously
heard, considered and addressed by the Board. And while REA
also raises arguments not advanced earlier, none merit
reconsideration of Order 73-12-36.
REA argues that Order 73-12-36 is inconsistent because the
Order finds little value in air express’s priority feature but at the
same time determines that airlines are under an obligation to
offer highly expedited air freight service. We perceive no
inconsistency. The record shows that a priorty air cargo system
that enabled a shipper to purchase extra-quick service would be
valuable to some shippers (albeit a relatively small number). We
accordingly found that airlines are under an obligation to file
tariffs providing for such service.
That is not inconsistent with our finding regarding the
significant value of the priority rights of air express for the
reason that even with such priority rights, air express is not
particularly fast. Air express—with its priority rights-is generally
able to deliver a shipment no faster than a forwarder can using
non-priority air freight services.* The new service contemplated
5. REA also argues, at least implicitly, that because of the importance of air express’s
prionty service, air express should not be ended at all.
6. REA claims one of the air express rules by which the airlines jointly divide up the air
express business is a cause of this paradox. REA's point, apparently, is that we should
have approved the continuation of air express, while conditioning our approval on the
cimination of that rule. We discuss this general consideration infra, p. 13..
70a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
in the Order, on the other hand, will assure truly fast deliveries,
im large part because it will be a system that will benefit from the
competitive efforts both of the direct air carriers and of the many
forwarders who have made it their business to achieve the fastest
deliveries that direct air carrier operations permit.
REA next argues that recent circumstances specifically the
ongoing fuel shortage--require that air express service be
continued at least for the duration of that shortage. REA’s
theory apparently is that capacity reductions stemming from the
shortage have already and will continue to substantially increase
the likelihood that any given air freight shipment will be delayed
by reason of insufficient cargo space. Air express shipments will
not be delayed, the theory goes, because of air express’s priority
rights. Thus shippers who need prompt deliveries will benefit by
extending air express’s life for the duration of the shortage. REA
offers no factual support for its position, however, and reports
on file with the Board fail to establish a dearth of cargo capacity
stemming from the fuel shortage.’
Moreover, f it be assumed that the fuel shortage will
ultimately result in cargo demand outstripping cargo capacity,
the appropriate course is not to attempt to prolong REA’s
7. Thus in 100 of REA's top markets (see REA Ex-209) air cargo load factors — that is,
percent of available air cargo space filled by air express, air freight, and mail — during
the three-month period November and December 1973, and January 1974, averaged
about 37%, up only about five points from the same period last year. These figures are
compiled from service segment data reported to the Board by the airlines. (January 1974
data are the last currently available.)
7la
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
monopoly over priority rights to cargo space. Rather, it is to
ensure that the airlines offer priority service to all. For if limit-
ations on airline capacity stemming from the fuel shortage were
in the months or years ahead ultimately to make it difficult to
obtain cargo space, it would plainly be contrary to *% public
interest to perpetuate the present arrangement, in which those
shippers unable to accept the delays inherent in such
circumstances would have to deal with REA because of REA’s
exclusive right to priority treatment.
Geographic Coverage
REA argues that air freight forwarders will not be able to
match the geographic coverage now provided by air express.®
REA also claims that even if the Board remains of the view that
the forwarders have the wherewithal to expand their coverage,
termination of air express should nevertheless be delayed in
order to determine if the air freight forwarders will in fact
expand the geographic scope of their operations sufficiently, and
in order to give the forwarders the time to effectuate the changes
in their operations that such expansion requires.
Upon consideration of the pleadings, the Board has
determined that no error has been shown in the findings and
conclusions made in Order 73-12-36 concerning the geographic
coverage of air express and the forwarders’ abilities and
intentions.
8. We note, however, that REA’s authorization as an indirect carrier is not being ended,
but rather being changed from air express ground agent to air freight forwarder.
72a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
We note, at the outset that, as discussed in Order 73-12-36,
REAs historic broad geographic coverage is a relic of the past,
and that even if air express were to continue, the future would
inevitably bring retrenchment in its scope of operations. No
pleadings dispute these findings, and no party, including REA,
has pointed us to new circumstances that would call these
findings into question.®
In any event, and apart from the foregoing considerations,
deferral of the date at which our authorization of air express
ends would almost surely serve merely to delay still further the
geographic expansion of air freight forwarder service. Our
understanding of air freight forwarder economics convinces us
that the forwarders are unlikely to take the risks inherent in
substantially expanding the geographic scope of their operations
as long as air express is in operation. The combination of thin
markets (essentially all markets in which relatively large
amounts of air cargo move are already served by forwarders),
established REA customers, and the substantial level of nonline-
haul services performed for REA by the airlines at most of the
country’s airports,'® present market entry difficulties that could
9. REA suggests that the withdrawal of Santa Fe Airfreight and Domestic Air Express
from air freight forwarding undercuts the Board's conclusion that the forwarder industry
will be able to fill voids created by the withdrawal of REA from many markets.
However, neither forwarder played a large or crucial role in the nation’s air freight
system, and we do not consider their departure material to this case. Moreover, air
freight forwarders with nationwide systems, such as Emery, remain willing and able to
fill such service voids, and we note that eleven long-haul motor carriers (many of which
are nationwide companies) have recently filed for renewal of their air freight forwarder
authority.
10. The airlines perform all ground services (receiving and delivery of over-the-counter
shipments, routing of shipments, etc.) for air express shipments at about 85% of the
nation’s airports: See Order 73-12-36, at 24.
73a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
too easily dissuade forwarders from undertaking the necessary
investments.
As we said in Order 73-12-36, irrespective of the action
which the Board takes here some uncertainties are inevitable in
the days ahead for air cargo service to small communities. But
we remain of the view that the effectuation of Order 73-12-36
will redound to the benefit of the country’s small communities as
well as to the nation as a whole.'! It should also be pointed that
REA, as an air freight forwarder, will be able to offer priority
handling at all of its present outlets. However, REA will no
longer be the exclusive agent for priority cargo handling.
11. Similar considerations apply in respect to commodity coverage. In fact, the record is
even clearer that the airlines and the forwarders will be fully able and willing to
efficiently handle all of the commodities that now move on air express. REA claims that
transporting some kinds of cargo presents difficult operational problems, referring
particularly to the transport of live animals at a time when capacity has been cut because
of the fuel shortage. But REA adds nothing beyond that already considered by the Board
in Order 73-12-36 andaboveatp. 5 with the exception of a reference to a finding of a
Congressional Committee (as reported in 4 newspaper article) that the Board and other
agencies should “monitor” domestic animal shipments. The Congressional document
cited indirectly by REA is a report of the House Committee on Government Operations,
House Rept. No. 93-746, “Problems in Air Shipment of Domestic Animals,” 93rd Cong.,
ist Sess. (1973). As indicated, REA refers to the report as supporting its claim that air
express should be continued in order to assure proper treatment of live animals being
transported by air. In fact, however, the Report states that animals shipped by air
express apparently often fare worse than animals shipped via air freight, that there are
delays in the shipment of animals moving by air express, and that it appears that “REA
in many instances is not equipped to handle animal shipments.” Moreover, the Report
specifically proposes that REA’s handling of animal traffic “be monitored”: Report at
pp. 9-11, 18.
Cee
74a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
Relative rate levels of air express and air freight
REA claims that a decision in the Rates case'? is needed to
provide a comparision between air express rates and the rates
offered by alternative services, and that the Board cannot
reasonably take action ordering the end of air express until the
conclusion of the Rates case.
The Board does not share REA’s views. To begin with, as
discussed in our opinion in the Rates case, the question of lawful
express rates for the future is now moot by reason of the Board's
decision in this proceeding to terminate the air express
arrangement, and, accordingly, has not been considered in the
Rates proceeding by the Board.'?
Moreover, relatively low express rates, standing alone,
cannot be the basis for perpetuating the air express system (even
assuming that it could in fact be perpetuated). The Board
recognizes that in many instances air express rates for small-
package, short-haul shipments are less than air freight rates.
However, as we stated in Order 73-12-36, this factor does not
12. Investigation of Air Express Rates, Docket 22387.
13, We note that in any event it is evident that the record in the Rates case could not
provide a meaningful comparison between express and other freight rates. For, as Order
74-5-23 establishes, the record in that proceeding is woefully deficient, and, largely
because of REA's failure to comply with evidence requests, does not contain basic
information needed for the comparison that REA now insists upon. In this connection,
AFFA, in its answer to REA's petition, argues that the Rates case should be abandoned
beca se the record is stale. REA has moved for leave to file an otherwise unauthorized
reply to AFFA's argument, in which REA strongly opposes abandonment of the Rates
case. The airlines have moved for leave to file an otherwise unauthorized answer in
opposition to REA's reply. We shall grant the motions of REA and the airlines.
75a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
outweigh other important public interest considerations that
point to the termination of the current air express arrangement.
We also note that in recent years air express rates have been
substantially increased a number of times.'* One resuit of these
increases is that in many instances it is now less expensive to
ship even the smallest package on an airport-to-airport basis via
the airfreight services of the airlines, and in some instances, the
forwarders. (More than 20% of all express shipments were
airport-to-airport shipments.)!°
Finally, we cannot accept REA’s argument that the Board
should wait and see what rates the airlines and forwarders will
publish for priority service before terminating air express. First,
as previously discussed, REA’s relatively low rates are not
sufficient reason, in and of themselves, for perpetuating the air
express system. Second, even apart from the Board’s power to
control rates, there is no basis for REA’s suggestion that the
rates for the new priority service will be unreasonably high. In
fact, as noted in Order 73-12-36, it is the Board's view that
competition for priority shipments among the direct air carriers
14. In the past few years alone there have been numerous and substantial increases in air
express rates. In fact, since January |, 1974, REA has increased its general commodity
rates by 10% and certain special commodity rates (and related minimum charges) far
more than 10%. The total additional revenue derived from these rate increases has
accrued almost exclusively to REA, and not to its express partner, the airlines.
15S. Air express service has always been a door-to-door service under a single rate which
includes pickup and delivery service. Air express customers preferring to ship on an
airport-to-airport basis (to avoid the delays inherent in pickup and delivery services, for
instance) must nonetheless pay the full rate.
76a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
and all indirect air carriers, including REA, will result in an
optimum balance of price and service. Third, and as also
previously discussed, an extension of the life of the air express
arrangement would hamper the institution of the new, and what
we believe to be, superior, priority service.
Air Express’s Viability
As detailed in Part V of Order 73-12-36: (1) air express is a
joint arrangement that hinges on the maintenance of an
agreement between two parties (REA, onthe one hand, and, on
the other, the airlines as a group) whose interests have long been
divergent and are becoming ever more so, with the result that air
express service remains in chronic danger of being interrupted or
ended; (2) while the Board has sufficient authority to compel the
airlines to provide line-haul services for REA under an
arrangement that would resemble the present air express system
in certain respects, the Board could not insure that the airlines
would continue to perform ground services on behalf of REA
that are an integral and important part of the air express
arrangement; (3) REA, upon which the air express system
depends, is in serious financial trouble which could only be
alleviated, if at all, by a substantial increase in air express traffic
volume; and (4) the kind of traffic volume increase REA needs
could only occur if REA were granted expanded authority, but
that such authority would have a detrimental impact on the
public interest and, in any case, would not work.
As we understand the thrust of REA’s two pleadings insofar
as they deal with this aspect of Order 73-12-36, REA is arguing
77a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
that the Board could and should have taken steps to increase the
chance of air express’s continued viability by imposing various
requirements, all beneficial to REA. on the airlines; that, as a
result of current developments, there is a greater chance that
REA and the airlines can work out their differences if given an
extra eight months to do so; and that since determinations to be
made in the Rates case will substantially affect REA’s continued
viability, it would be error on our part not to delay termination
of air express until a final order issues in the Rates case.
We turn first to REA’s argument that the Board’s earlier
approval of the air express agreements created “block bargaining
power” on the part of the airlines; that the airlines-utilizing that
power—have discriminated against REA; that the Board should
have acted to prevent that discriminatory treatment; that if
theBoard had in fact done so it would have gone far toward
returning REA and the air express toward viability; and that by
not doing so the Board has acted contrary to antitrust policy.
We cannot conclude that REA’s claims in this respect
require reconsideration of Order 73-12-36. The air express
agreements are plainly anticompetitive, and have the effect of
eliminating competition between airlines and excluding air
freight forwarders from various types of markets.'® As we have
i6. REA takes issues with the Board’s characterization of air express as a monopoly. In
our view, however, REA's arguments do not warrant our reconsidering our position in
this respect. First, as touched on above, REA's unique arrangement with the airlines goes
far toward assuring that air freight forwarders will be precluded from serving the
country’s smaller air cargo markets. Second, as we also touched on earlier, of the many
indirect air carriers only REA (as air express's sole gro: ad agent) has a claim to priority
(Cont'd)
78a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
elsewhere discussed, the air express agreements do not produce
counter-balancing public benefits, but rather stand in the way of
the establishment of an improved air cargo system. REA
nonetheless argues that notwithstanding the foregoing, Order 73-
12-36 runs afoul of the antitrust laws by failing to order the
continuation of the arrangement, and that as part of its
“supervisory responsibility” the Board has to permit the air
express arrangement to continue while taking steps to protect
one of the willing participants to the agreement from its
partners.'’ We cannot concur. Disapproval of the air express
agreements is fully in keeping with the spirit of the antitrust
laws. It is the perpetuation of them that would have been
contrary to that spirit. And we are not aware of any supervisory
responsibility imposed on us that requires us to attempt to aid
an unhappy partner to an arrangement that has outlived its time.
(Cont'd)
treatment by the airlines. The fact that this exclusive right (granted by all of the
certificated route carriers acting jointly) does not seriously limit the air freight
forwarders’ ability to compete with air express shows only that an intended monopoly
service has for various reasons not worked that way in practice Even here, however,
there is littke doubt that some shippers distinguish between REA and other kinds of air
freight service however mistakenly on the ground that air express has priority
claim to cargo space. Moreover, REA's exclusive claim to priority service could become
a matter of real significance if the fuel shortage were ultimately to result in cargo load
factors climbing to high levels. Further, the existence of air express tends to prevent the
institution by airlines of highly expedited service readily useable by air freight
forwarders.
17. REA argues that the Board's decision to deny it independent tariff authority is
inconsistent with views expressed by the Board in the Air Freight Forwarder Case, 9
CAB 473, 486 (1948). In thet case the Board noted that a dispute between the airlines
and REA could be eliminated if they agreed to participate in a system whereby REA
would publish an express tanff based upon charges imposed on REA by the airlines for
(Cont'd)
79a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
Moreover, our power to require the airlines to treat REA in
any specified manner is in many respects limited. Thus the
Board can not force any party to enter into a contractual
relationship. In this regard, as discussed earlier, it is unlikely
that the airlines and REA would be able to work out an
arrangement continuing air express even if the arrangement were
approved by the Board as is. Imposing the kinds of new
conditions urged by REA would almost surely preclude
continuation of air express by reason of the unwillingness of the
airlines to become parties to an agreement so conditioned.
It is true that the Board probably could license REA to
operate independently of an airline-REA agreement, and could
compel the airlines to publish an air express tariff covering rates
to REA. But as Order 73-12-36 points out, we are unaware of
any authority by which we could require the airlines to continue
to provide the many ground services that they presently perform
(Cont'd)
their services to REA. The Board's views therein are not inconsistent with its decision in
this proceeding. First, the Air Fre.» Forwarder Case supports the airlines’ position
which, as noted by the Board in Order 73-12-36, is that the airlines should be permitted
to charge REA enough to cover their full costs. Second, Order 73-12-36 agrees with the
Board's earlier conclusion that the Board does have the authority to permit REA to file
its own tariff based upon rates charged REA by the airlines. However, the Board
concluded in this proceeding that under existing circumstances a grant of the tanff auth-
ority REA seeks would not in fact serve to perpetuate the air express system in its
present form. REA also has argued during the course of this case that, as an alternative
to the beforementioned complementary tariff system, it should be permitted rate freedom
in the sense that it would publish the only express tariff and the airlines would receive a
division of the rates REA would charge to the public. It is in this sense that the Board
stated at page 27 of its Opinion that “. .. it is understandable that the airlines have
refused to enter into an arrangement whereby the rates to be charged for such shipments
would be within the control of another company (REA) whose interests and cost
structure vary considerabiy from those of the airlines.”
80a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
on behalf of REA at so many of the nation’s airports. REA
points us to none and indeed does not dispute the concerns
expressed on this point in Order 73-12-36.
REA’s claims (in its motion for extension) that the June
termination date for air express ordered by Order 73-12-36
ought to be extended eight months in order to permit the airlines
and REA to work out their differences and arrive at a new
agreement. REA bases its request on, among other things, newly
instituted negoitiations between REA and the airlines, that,
according to REA, show signs of possibly bearing fruit.
We cannot agree to this request for postponement. In the
first place, the decision to end the air express arrangement was
by no means predicated on the inability of the airlines and REA
to come to an agreement. Our point was that any agreement
hetween the two sides would necessarily be unstable due to the
parties’ divergent interests. Moreover, even that was but one of
several concerns that led the Board to conclude that the air
express agreements should be ordered ended.
Second, there is no basis for concluding that there is any
real chance that REA and the airlines will be able to work out
the fundamental differences between them.'* All of the airlines
participating in the air express arrangement filed a pleading
supporting Order 73-12-36, and opposing REA’s petition for
reconsideration. Thereafter, 24 of those airlines appeared to
reverse course and supported REA’s motion for extension.
18. REA has so argued. See oral arg. tr. at 29-30.
8la
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
United, for one, argues that that change in direction by the 24
direct carriers is prompted more by the hope that an extension
would result in their collecting a greater percentage of the
amounts due them by REA than by matters more directly
related to the public interest. We need not speculate on the
motivations of those 24 carriers, however, since the fact of the
matter is that four airlines did not join in that response to REA’s
motion, thereby adhering to the position they espoused in the
airlines’ opposition to REA's petition for reconsideration. In
1973, those four carriers — Delta, North Central, Southern, and
United — accounted for 35 percent of all air express traffic. Of
the 500 or so points in the United States receiving certificated air
service, about 100 receive such service only from one or more of
those four carriers.'*a
In these circumstances, we can only conclude that the
possibility of continuing the air express arrangement in anything
like its present form — that is, a consensual arrangement
providing broad geographic coverage — has not been shown to
be any less free from doubt than it was at the time of issuance of
Order 73-12-36, or that this state of affairs is likely to change for
the better by January or thereafter.
REA’s other argument in respect to continuing air express’
viability appears to be that REA’s financial problems — which
I8a. Ft. Wayne, Ind. is served only by Delta and United; Meridian, Miss., by Delta and
Southern; and Flint, Lansing, Muskegon, and Saginaw/ Bay City) Midland, Mich., by
North Central and United. Each of approximately 90 other points are served only by one
of the four carriers.
82a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
have been a major source of weakness in the air express system
— could be greatly ameliorated if the division of air express
revenues between REA and the airlines were appropriately
adjusted in REA’s favor. REA points out that this question of
divisions is at issue in the Rates case and that accordingly the
Board cannot reasonably make any determination about the
viability of air express until the conclusion of that case.
We cannot agree, however, that delaying action here to
await the final outcome of the Rates case would serve any
purpose, much less benefit the public interest. To begin with,
and as discussed in our accompanying Rates opinion, the record
in the Rates case does not now permit a determination of
reasonable divisions, and it is not completely clear that it will
ever do so despite our order there.'? Further, as discussed in
Order 73-12-36 and concurred in by REA, in order for REA to
attain financial health as the air express ground agent it would
have to greatly increase its traffic volume. A change in divisions
would not be enough to render air express viable” unless it were
accompanied by extensive changes in REA’s authority that
would be neither feasible nor in the public interest.
The Mechanics of the Changeover
REA claims that it needs more than six months to change
from air express ground agent to air freight forwarder. It points
19. Of course that case will in any event consider division questions only on a
retrospective basis. Moreover, the authority of the Board to order divisions is itself
contested.
20. As noted earlier (at n.14 above), REA’s share of each dollar of air express revenue
has been steadily increasing. Yet the carrier's financial health remains unsatisfactory.
83a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
to such matters as the need to instruct its employees in air
freight rates and the need for specialized equipment, including
containers, certain types of vehicles, and so forth. In our view,
however, REA has utterly failed to show that the six months
grace period granted to REA by Order 73-12-36 is insufficient. A
‘“rompt switch by REA from air express ground agent to air
ireight forwarder should present no undue difficulties. It is
already an air freight forwarder in international markets. REA
has long claimed it badly needs air freight forwarder authority,
presumably on the basis of careful consideration by its
management of how REA would conduct air freight forwarder
operations. It has its many long standing customers. It appears
that a very considerable portion of its buildings and equipment
are suitable for air freight forwarder operations. And its
management and employees are intimately familiar with the air
cargo industry. Moreover REA provided no factual support that
it needs more time.?!
For reasons expressed earlier herein and in Order 73-12-36,
the nation’s shippers will be better served when air express is
ended. For that reason prompt termination is in order. REA
claims that it will suffer badly if it has to switch to air freight
forwarder status on June 5.22 However, in our view, even if that
21. While its pleadings are replete with generalized allegations in this respect, we are
provided with no specific data that could lead us to conclude that we should reconsider
the determination in Order 73-12-36 that six months is sufficient time for the changeover.
22. On April 16th the Brotherhood of Railway and Airline Clerks sought leave to file an
answer in support of REA’s motion for extension, arguing that termination of REA’s air
express authority would cost many of REA's employees their jobs. REA’s petition for
(Cont'd)
84a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
were the case, there has been no showing that REA would be in
a materially different position after a deferral than it is now.”
In sum, the evidence is that a prompt termination of the air
express system is in the public interest. However, the Board
appreciates the complexity involved in setting up a new priority
system for handling air freight. In this connection, we note that
while the airlines have met for the purpose of establishing a
priority system, they have not, as of this date, filed tariffs that
would offer priority service by June 5, 1974. In order to give the
carriers time to present the Board with a new system for priority
handling of air freight and file the appropriate tariffs, the Board
has decided to extend its approval of the air express agreements,
and REA’s exclusive express authority, through July 1, 1974.
Contd ®
reconsideration also refers to the impact our decision would have on its employees, and
the Board has, of course, taken this consideration into account as a public interes factor,
but has found that the public interest will, on balance, be favored by the actions we have
ordered. Moreover, it is our belief that since the air cargo industry will be strengthened
by the termination of air express, the net impact on the industry's employees will be a
favorable one. Further, BRAC's position is predicated on the view that the possibility
exists that the present air express system can continue. However, we have concluded to
the contrary. Since BRAC is not a party, and has not shown good cause for late filing,
we shall deny its motion.
23. REA also claims that the airlines and forwarders, need substantially more than six
months to adjust to the Board's decision to terminate air express. Again, REA provides
no factual support for its claim and has otherwise failed to support its argument. In
fact, the airlines and forwarders, speaking for themselves, dispute REA’s contention, and
further state that they will have no difficulty making whatever adjustments are required
by the Board's order.
Was
85a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
Our decision not to extend the termination date of air
express as requested by REA to all intents and purposes moots
REA’s request for dual authority. Even apart from that,
however, we would not grant the authority REA wishes. As
discussed in Order 73-12-36, such dual authority would present a
variety of problems, including the possibility of serious
confusion on the part of the public. Moreover the grant to REA
of dual authority would be a meaningless gesture since the
airlines have made it more than plain that they would not
continue to deal with REA as air express ground agent if REA
obtained air freight forwarder authority.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. The petition for reconsideration and the motion for
extension filed by REA Express, Inc., be and they hereby are
denied;
2. The motion of the National Small Shipments Traffic
Conference for leave to file an untimely reply to REA’s petition
for reconsideration be and it hereby is granted;
3. The motion of REA Express, Inc., for leave to file an
otherwise unauthorized motion for extension, and the motions
of the Air Freight Forwarders Association, Inc., Emery Air
Freight, Inc., the National Small Shipments Traffic Conference,
the participating airlines, and United Air Lines, for leave to file
otherwise unauthorized answers to REA’s motion for extension
be and they hereby are granted;
86a
Supplemental Order of CAB Dated May 6, 1974
4. The motion of REA Express, Inc., for leave to file an
otherwise unauthorized reply to the answer of the Air Freight
Forwarders Association to REA’s petition for reconsideration,
and the motion of the participating airlines for leave to file an
answer to REA’s reply, be and they hereby are granted;
5. Ordering paragraph “3” of Order 73-12-36 be and it
hereby is modified to read as follows:
“3. That the exemption authority of REA Express, Inc., to
conduct operations in air transportation initially granted by
Order Serial Number 941, dated March 13, 1941, as amended
(the most recent amendment authority being granted by
exemption Order E-22273, dated June 4, 1965) be and it hereby
ic terminated on the date that REA commences air freight
forwarder operations pursuant to an authorization issued in
accordance with our decision herein, or on August 1, 1974,
whichever date occurs first;”
6. Except to the extent granted herein, all motion,
applications and requests involved herein be and they hereby are
denied; and
7. This Order shall be served on all persons on whom Order
73-12-36 was served, and the Brotherhood of Railway and
Airline Clerks.
TIMM, Chairman, GILLILLAND, Vice Chairman, and
MINETTI, Member, concurred in the above opinion and order.
WEST and O’MELIA, Members, did not take part in the
decision.
EDWIN Z. HOLLAND
ta
(Seal) Seenanty
87a
CAB EXPRESS SERVICE INVESTIGATION DATED
DECEMBER 7, 1973
73-12-36
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD
WASHINGTON, D. C.
Docket 22388
EXPRESS SERVICE INVESTIGATION
Decided: December 7, 1973
1. Agreements providing for air express service between
REA Express, Inc., and participating scheduled airlines and
among the participating airlines disapproved, and prior
approvals withdrawn.
2. Exemption authority of REA Express, Inc., to conduct
air express service terminated.
3. REA Express, Inc., awarded air freight forwarder
authority.
4. Scheduled air carriers found to have obligation to offer
priority service as part of their duty to provide adequate
interstate and overseas air transportation.
88a
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7, 1973
OPINION
BY THE BOARD:
I. INTRODUCTION
This is a proceeding to explore the role of express service in
air transportation. The crucial issue in the proceeding, from the
start, has been what action the Board should take in respect to
the indirect air carrier authority of REA Express, Inc., and the
related agreements between the various airlines and REA.
Administrative Law Judge James S. Keith concluded, after
presiding at a lengthy hearing on the matter, that express service
in its present form serves a useful public purpose and should be
maintained basically without change. In support thereof he
found (1) that there are important differences between air
express and other forms of air freight, i.e., that air express is
cheaper, faster, provides more comprehensive geographic and
commodity coverage, and enjoys the exclusive benefit of priority
treatment by the airlines; (2) that the present type of inter-airline
agreement and the type of agreement between the airlines and
REA are essential to the existence of air express service and
should therefore be continued; and (3) that REA is the only
qualified ground agency willing and able to enter into agreement
with the airlines to provide air express service, and should
therefore be continued as the exclusive indirect air carrier of
express.
By Order 72-6-27, June 6, 1972, the Board exercised its
right of discretionary review. Briefs were filed by Allied
89a
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7, 1973
American Bird Co. (Allied), Bureau of Operating Rights (BOR),
REA Express, Inc. (REA) and Southern Pacific Air Freight,
Inc. (SPAF). The Air Freight Forwarders Association (AFFA),
Emery Air Freight Corporation (Emery), the National Industrial
Traffic League (NITL), and the Participating Airlines (airlines)
adopted their briefs to Judge Keith as their briefs to the Board.
The airlines generally agree with the findings and
conclusions of Judge Keith.
REA agrees with Judge Keith’s conclusions concerning the
utility of air express and REA’s role as the exclusive indirect
carrier thereof. But it contends that the judge failed to take steps
necessary to insure the continuation of REA and express service.
REA claims that if the Board maintains the status quo, as
recommended by the administrative law judge, it will not be able
to continue to provide service in many markets. In order to
avoid this result, it urges the Board to adopt three courses of
action. First, the Board should award REA permanent authority
as the exclusive indirect carrier of express. Second, it should
reform the airline-REA agreement so as to (1) eliminate rules
therein that require REA to divide up shipments among all
available air carriers; (2) permit REA to offer the shipping
public air express tariffs free of airline control; and (3) permit
REA to consolidate and containerize air express traffic. Third,
the Board should award REA air freight forwarder authority in
addition to its exclusive air express authority. In this respect,
REA maintains that it needs air freight forwarder authority in
order to spread the costs of air express over a greater volume
of business than air express is capable of generating.
90a
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7, 1973
The two shipper parties, NITL and Allied, agree that there
is a need for air express service. NITL supports the findings and
conclusions of the Initial Decision. Allied wants the Board to
take steps to eliminate the threat of a discontinuance of air
express service resulting from the inability of the airlines and
REA to agree to terms.
BOR and AFFA urge the Board to cancel the air express
agreements and to terminate REA’s exemption. In their view: (1)
there are no material distinctions between air express service and
air freight service provided by the airlines directly or by the
forwarders indirectly, and that accordingly, there is no basis for
affording REA different regulatory treatment from the
forwarders; (2) the present air express arrangement is otherwise
contrary to the public interest. BOR and AFFA generally agree
that there is a need for air freight services of a highly expedited
character to handle freight involving life or death commodities,
highly perishable products, or articles that must reach
consignees particularly rapidly for various reasons. To
accommodate this type of traffic, BOR recommends that the
direct air carriers file tariff rates and rules providing for
whatever special handling may be required. Such tariffs would
be available not only to the air freight forwarders and the
general public, but also to REA, which should be given air
freight forwarding authority under Part 296 of the Economic
Regulations. !
1. Emery and SPAF generally agree with the BOR position. However, Emery
would limit the high pnonty tariff to “humanitarian commodities” and those critical to
the national defense. SPAF is willing to accept BOR’s proposal, but, if the concept of air
express is maintained, SPAF urges that a limited number of forwarders now offering an
express type service also be granted air express authonty.
9ia
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7, 1973
Oral argument has been heard, and the case stands
submitted for decision.
Il. SUMMARY
Earlier Board decisions established air express as a separate
service, apart from all other air cargo services, and granted REA
a monopoly to conduct that service. For some time, however,
REA’s operations have been on the brink of extinction. In the
first place, the very existence of express service today is wholly
dependent upon a 1970 court decree requiring REA and the
airlines to continue service. Not only have the parties been
unable to agree on the terms of express service, but their long-
smoldering disputes threaten to erupt again in the future, thus
jeopardizing the express scheme. Secondly, REA is financially
impoverished and, by its own statement, does not want to
continue service under the present regime.
The real issue, therefore, is not whether to continue the
separate service known as air express, but whether to attempt to
change it — or to replace it entirely. Neither choice is inviting.
The first alternative requires strengthening REA’s monopoly
position at the expense of the airlines and forwarders and, quite
likely, shippers as well. The second alternative is to let air
express become part of the general air cargo business and, by
licensing REA as a forwarder, allow REA and other forwarders
to serve all or most of this market, probably at somewhat higher
rates. Either alternative entails some risks and uncertainties
about the future. As we see it, the latter choice is the best
available to us.
92a
CAB Express Service Investigation Dated December 7, 1973
REA seeks to expand its present authority because it cannot
continue air express service unless it returns to profitability. To
accomplish this, REA insists that it not only be allowed to
maintain its stranglehold over air express, but also be given an
air freight forwarder’s license. But the Board cannot find that
REA’s possession of dual air express-air freight forwarder
authority would be in the public interest. On the contrary, it
would place REA in a position to domin
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.