Appendix — Nader v. Allegheny Airlines, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
_ Supreme Court, U. & )
fb. FILED
j
JOINT APPENDIX I AN_9 1976
MICHAEL RODAK, JR., CLERK
IN THE
Supreme Court of the Hnited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1975
No. 75-455
RALPH NADER,
Petitioner,
ALLEGHENY AIRLINES, INC.,
Respondent.
ON A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
EE
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 22, 1975
CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 11, 1975
(i)
INDEX TO JOINT APPENDIX
Note: The relevant orders and opinions of the United States
District Court for the District of Columbia in Civil Action
No. 1346-72 and the United States Court of Appeals for
the District of Columbia Circuit in No. 73-2243 are set
forth in the appendices to the Petition for Certiorari and
are not reprinted here.
ITEM Page
COMPLAINT FOR COMPENSATORY AND PUNITIVE
Ee ee ae
nn + «2 us « k ae & 6) 8) 4. e08°ece & ” OF
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES — District Court. . . . 10
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES — Court of Appeals .. 14
EXCERPTS FROM TRANSCRIPT OF TRIAL ..... = 16
DEPOSITION OF LESLIE O. BARNES (Pl. Exh. 24) . . 116
DOCUMENTARY EXHIBITS AT TRIAL ..... . . 138
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 4 — Allegheny Memorandum... . 138
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 5 — Allegheny Memorandum... . 139
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6 — Allegheny Passenger Service
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 14 — Correspondence re:
ee <6 6 6:6 = 24. 6)% 6 0 + 0 2 oe
Defendant’s Exhibit A — Crockett Letter to
ny « + « ¢ + 6 2 ee. ke + +
Defendant’s Exhibit D —- CAB Notice EDR-109 . . . 170
Defendant’s Exhibit E — CAB Regulation ER-S03 . . . 195
1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
RALPH NADER and
CONNECTICUT CITIZEN ACTION
GROUP,
Plaintiffs, Civil Action No.
v. 1346-72
ALLEGHENY AIRLINES, INC.,
Defendant.
Complaint For Compensatory and Punitive Damages
Plaintiffs allege as follows:
1. This action arises under the laws of the United
States regulating interstate and foreign air commerce,
U.S.C. Title 49, Sections 1301 et seq., and particularly
U.S.C. Title 49, Section 1374. This Court has jurisdiction
under U.S.C. Title 28, Section 1337 and U.S.C. Title 28,
Section 1332. The amount in controversy exceeds the sum
of $10,000, exclusive of interest and costs.
2. Plaintiff Ralph Nader is a citizen of the United
States and resides in the District of Columbia.
3. Plaintiff Connecticut Citizen Action Group (herein-
after referred to as CCAG) is a non-profit corporation,
organized and existing under the laws of the District of
Columbia and having its principal place of business at 57
Farmington Avenue, Hartford, Connecticut. Plaintiff
CCAG is a public interest advocate for environmental,
consumer and human rights issues arising throughout the
State of Connecticut, which has been supported and spon-
sored by Plaintiff Nader since its inception.
4. Defendant Allegheny Airlines, Inc., is a corpora-
tion, having its principal place of business at National Air-
2
» i levant herein
rt, Washington, D.C., and at all times re here
ccommasia’ business and maintained offices in the District
of Columbia, at 16th and K Streets, N.W., at Washington
National Airport, and at other locations within the said
District.
5. Defendant is an air carrier engaged in interstate
commerce pursuant to a certificate of public convenience
and necessity issued by the Civil Aeronautics Board and is
regulated by the laws of the United States relating to such
interstate commerce and by the rules, orders and regula-
tions promulgated by the Board in accordance with the
Federal Aviation Act of 1958.
6. Prior to April 28, 1972, Defendant advertised pub-
licized and published tariffs stating that it transported
passengers on a reservation basis by jet aircraft on sched-
uled flights between Washington, D.C. and Hartford, Con-
necticut.
7. Defendant knew or should have known that pas-
sengers and others alike rely heavily upon such representa-
tions and upon the confirmed reservations and tickets which
are sold by Defendant for transportation on particular
flights.
8. Several days prior to April 20, 1972 Plaintiff
Nader’s representative contacted Defendant and requested
a reservation for Plaintiff Nader for one seat on Allegheny
flight 864 from Washington National Airport to Hartford,
Connecticut, on the morning of Friday, April 28, 1972.
9. Defendant’s agent represented to Plaintiff Nader’s
representative that Defendant had made a reservation which
would assure him passage from Washington on Allegheny
flight 864 scheduled to depart on April 28, 1972, provided he
purchased his ticket at least 30 minutes prior to flight time.
10. Plaintiff Nader’s representative communicated to
Plaintiff CCAG the fact that Plaintiff Nader had a reserva-
3
tion on flight 864 on April 28, 1972 and would be arriving
at Bradley Field in Hartford, Connecticut on that flight.
11. Early on the morning of April 28, 1972 Defendant’s
agent, Ober Steamship and Tour Agency, issued a ticket to
Plaintiff Nader for Allegheny flight 864 to depart Washing-
ton National Airport at 10:15 a.m. on April 28, 1972.
12. At the time the ticket was issued Defendant’s agent
marked the symbol ‘‘OK’”’ in the status column of the ticket
thereby confirming the previously made reservation in
writing.
13. The Defendant intended by its representations
aforesaid to induce the Plaintiffs to rely upon its said
representations so that Plaintiff Nader’s travel arrange-
ments would not be made with any other competitor of
Defendant.
14. When Plaintiff Nader arrived at the gate at
National Airport where flight 864 was boarding on April 28,
1972 several people, some of whom had tickets and had not
yet been boarded, were also present at the gate.
15. Plaintiff Nader presented his ticket to Defendant’s
gate agent and was then informed by this agent that the
flight had been oversold and that all seats had been taken.
16. At this point Plaintiff Nader explained to Defend-
ant’s agents at the gate that he was due to speak to a fund-
raising rally organized by and for Plaintiff CCAG, which
was to occur at noon that day, and that if he didn’t appear
on schedule, the rally would be ruined.
17. The purpose of the rally was to organize citizen
opposition to utilities rate increases, raise funds for
CCAG’s public interest work and to give interested citizens
the opportunity to hear Plaintiff Nader speak on con-
sumer issues. Plaintiff Nader was to be introduced at
the rally by the Mayor of Hartford, Connecticut. The
rally and Plaintiff Nader’s appearance were heavily adver-
tised both on the radio and by leaflet distribution for several
4
; , — vor
rior to April 28, 1972. Plaintiff CCAG anticipa
oe well in excess of 2,000 persons and planned to raise
substantial funds through the sale of bumper stickers and
other similar items.
18. In making such plans and arrangements, Plain-
i intiff Nader
tiff CCAG relied on the expectation that Plain
aan be accommodated on flight 864 for which he had a
confirmed reservation.
19. After being informed that the flight had been over-
sold and he would not be accommodated, Plaintiff Nader
then asked Defendant’s agent, in view of his urgent cir-
cumstances, to ascertain whether standby passengers had
i in li holding con-
been improperly boarded in lieu of persons olding
firmed on My and to recheck whether Plaintiff Nader
could be accommodated.
20. Defendant’s agent refused to board Plaintiff on
flight 864.
21. Other persons holding confirmed reservations were
also denied boarding on flight 864.
299. Defendant’s refusal to accommodate Plaintiff
Nader on flight 864 was in breach of its contract with
Plaintiff Nader. |
93. Defendant’s refusal to accommodate Plaintiff
Nader was in violation of its published tariff.
94. Plaintiff Nader then requested Defendant’s agents
to explain his situation to the passengers already boarded
ld volun-
on flight 864 and ask if any such passengers wou
teer to take a later flight in order to allow Plaintiff Nader
to get to Harford in time for the rally.
95. Defendant’s agents refused Plaintiff Nader’s re-
quest described in paragraph 24.
i irli j available
26. No other certificated airline service was
at that time to transport Plaintiff Nader to Hartford in
time for the rally.
27. Defendant’s flight 864 departed Washington Na-
tional Airport approximately on schedule at about 10:15
a.m. on April 28, 1972, and said flight arrived at Hartford
approximately on schedule that morning.
28. Defendant in fact sold more seats for flight 864 on
April 28, 1972 from Washington to Hartford than were
available on the aircraft.
29. Plaintiff Nader was forced to take next available
flight to Boston, Massachusetts in order to arrive in time
for an engagement that afternoon in Storrs, Connecticut,
thereby incurring additional charges for airfare in the
amount of $3.00, plus other costs and expenses for Plain-
tiffs.
30. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s
conduct, the Director of Plaintiff CCAG had to and in
fact did appear before an expectant crowd of hundreds of
persons and inform the audience that Plaintiff Nader had
missed his flight and would not appear. Consequently, the
purpose of the meeting was frustrated, the large anticipated
turn-out failed to materialize, no funds were raised, the
publicity work of a large number of CCAG supporters and
volunteers went for naught and the reputation, esteem, and
fund-raising ability of Plaintiff CCAG was seriously dam-
aged and impaired.
31. Defendant knew that it could not assure passage to
Plaintiff Nader on flight 864 on April 28, 1972 or other
flights on Defendant’s system because such flights had been
and were being consistently over-reserved and oversold.
32. Defendant knew that ticket holders with confirmed
reservations were regularly being denied space on such
oversold flights and that any prospective passenger on any
such flight might be denied accommodation on such flight
despite holding a confirmed reservation.
33. Defendant failed to inform Plaintiff Nader, at any
time prior to his arrival at Washington National Airport to
take flight 864, of the possibility that his confirmed reserva-
tion might not be or would not be honored because of
Defendant’s practice of overbooking such flights.
34. Defendant arbitrarily and capriciously denied
Plaintiff Nader passage and at the same time afforded
passage on said flight to one or more persons holding
tickets issued subsequent to this ticket or to persons other-
wise not entitled to occupy the space reserved and con-
firmed for Plaintiff Nader by Defendant’s agent, thereby
subjecting Plaintiff Nader to unjust discrimination, or
undue or unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage.
35. Defendant regularly overbooks, on a confirmed
reservation basis, various of its flights including flight 864
with the result that said flights are frequently oversold, and
regularly subjects ticket holders with confirmed reserva-
tions on said flights to unjust discrimination or undue or
unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage by arbitrarily and
capriciously refusing passage to ticket holders with con-
firmed reservations without regard to their contractual
rights, and by arbitrarily and capriciously allowing passage
to other persons not entitled to the space which Defendant’s
had previously contractually reserved.
36. Defendant’s actions as aforesaid were knowing,
and were undertaken in such conscious and deliberate dis-
regard of the interests of its prospective passengers and
others that such actions were willful, wanton and accomp-
lished in willful disregard of the provisions of Defendant’s
own tariffs and the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 (49 U.S.C.
1301 et seq.).
Wuererore, Plaintiffs demand judgment against the
Defendant as follows:
1. Plaintiff Nader demands compensatory damages in
the amount of $10.00 and punitive damages in the amount
of $50,000.00 together with interest, costs of this suit, and
such other or further relief as the Court may deem proper.
7
2. Plaintiff CCAG demands compensatory damages in
the sum of $100,000.00 and punitive damages in the sum of
$100,000.00 together with interest, costs of this suit, and
such other or further relief as the Court may deem proper.
Piaintirrs Demanp TRIAL By Jury as To ALL Issvuzs.
[Names and addresses of
counsel omitted in printing]
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
[Title omitted in printing]
Answer
First Defense
The Complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief
can be granted against the Defendant Allegheny Airlines,
Inc.
Second Defense
The Complaint fails to state a claim upon which punitive
damages can be granted against Defendant Allegheny Air-
lines, Inc.
Third Defense
This action does not appropriately belong within the
jurisa.ction of this Court in that it challenges the legality
and propriety of Defendant Allegheny’s reservation and
denied boarding practices, which considerations are by law
assigned to the Civil Aeronautics Board and not to the
courts.
Fourth Defense
This action is barred for the failure of the Plaintiffs to
comply with Rule 40(B), Tariff C.A.B. 142, Local and Joint
Passenger Rules Tariff No. PR-6 in that they failed to pre-
sent to Defendant Allegheny a written notice of claim with-
in 45 days of the alleged occurrence of the events giving
rise to this claim.
Fifth Defense
1. Defendant Allegheny admits the allegations of para-
graphs 5, 6, 8, 11, 12, 15, 20, 21, 24, 25, 27, and 28 of the
Complaint.
2. Defendant Allegheny admits the allegations of para-
graph 4 of the Complaint except that National Airport is in
Washington, D.C. which Defendant denies.
3. Defendant Allegheny denies the allegations of para-
graphs 7, 9, 13, 18, 22, 23, 29, 30, 31, 32, 34, and 36 of the
Complaint.
4. Defendant Allegheny is without knowledge or infor-
mation sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
averments in paragraphs 2, 3, 10, and 17 of the Complaint.
5. Defendant Allegheny admits the allegations of para-
graph 16 of the Complaint except that it is denied that
Plaintiff Nader told the Defendant’s agent that the rally
would be ruined if he failed to appear.
6. Defendant Allegheny admits the allegations of para-
graph 19 of the Complaint and avers that Defendant’s
agent did take the actions requested by Plaintiff Nader as
described in said paragraph 19 of the Complaint.
7. In answer to paragraph 14 of the Complaint Defend-
ant Allegheny states that the time Plaintiff Nader arrived
at the gate from which Flight 864 was departing the board-
ing of Flight 864 had been completed. Two people were at
the gate at that time with tickets, but they had not been
boarded.
8. In answer in paragraph 26 of the Complaint Defend-
ant Allegheny alleges that Plaintiff Nader was offered
transportation on Allegheny Commuter Flight 145 from
Washington to Philadelphia connecting with Allegheny
Flight 906 to Hartford, Connecticut, scheduled to arrive in
Hartford at 12:10 p.m., 55 minutes after the arrival of
Plaintiff Nader’s ticketed flight.
9. In answer to paragraph 33 of the Complaint Defend-
ant states that Plaintiff Nader was already aware of the
possibility that a confirmed reservation would not be hon-
ored because of the reservation practices of airlines. and
Defendant avers that Plaintiff Nader was aware that the
possibility of such denied boarding increases when the
passenger arrives at the boarding gate after the conclu-
sion of the boarding of the airplane and at the time that the
flight was scheduled to take off, as Plaintiff Nader did in
this instance.
10. In answer to paragraph 35 of the Complaint
Defendant Allegheny states that Defendant, in an effort to
minimize the effect of «he no-show passenger problem upon
Defendant and the public, accepts a limited number of
reservations in excess of flight capacity based upon statisti-
cal studies of the percentage of likely cancellations and no-
shows on each flight. The remaind Dj
posse ainder of paragraph 35 is
11. The allegations of injuries and damages in the
Complaint are denied, as are all other allegations of the
Complaint not specifically answered above.
{Names and addresses of
counsel omitted in printing]
10
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOB THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
[Title omitted in printing]
1972
d—filed.
7—Complaint, appearance Jury Deman
rw Saiiemnain copies (1) and copies (1) of Complaint
issued serv. 7-13.
Jul 31—Stipulation enlarging time for defendant Allegheny
Airlines to answer complaint to 8-16-72.
Aug 8—First set of interrogatories of plaintiffs to defend-
ant; c/m 8-8.
Aug 10—Change of address of Don W. Crockett.
Aug 16—Motion of defendant for summary judgment; ex-
hibit A, B; statement; P & A; c/m 8-16. Appearance
of William A. Bradford Jr. . .
Aug 16—Motion of defendant for extension of time to an-
swer interrogatories; P & A; c/m 8-16.
Aug 22—Request of plaintiffs for production of documents ;
e/m 8-21. as ”
Aug 25—Memorandum of P & A by plaintiff in opposition
to motion for summary judgment; table of citations;
affidavit, exhibit A, B, C, D; ¢/m 8-24.
Aug 25—Request of plaintiffs for oral argument on defend
ants motion for summary judgment. ae ao
Aug 25—Memorandum of P & A by plaintiff in opposition
to defendants motion to delay answering interroga-
tories; c/m 8-24.
Aug 25—Motion of defendant for extension of time to re-
spond or object to plaintiffs request for production of
documents; P & A; c/m 8-25. M. C. 7
Aug 30—Memorandum of plaintiffs in opposition to delay
production of documents; c/m 8-29. .
Sep 1—Supplemental memorandum of defendant in sup-
port of its motion to extend time to respond to inter-
rogatories and to document requests; supplementary
memorandum of defendant in support of motion for
summary judgment; affidavit; attachment A; c/m 9-1.
11
Sep 20—Response of plaintiffs to defendants supplementary
memorandum ; c/m 9-18.
Sep 29—Order denying defendants motion for summary
judgment. (N) Richey J.
Sep 29—Order extending the time in which defendant
Allegheny Airlines, Inc., may respond or object to the
plaintiffs request for Production of Documents 20 days
after the Court has ruled on the defendants motion for
Summary Judgment. (N) Richey J.
Oct 6—Motion of deft to amend order of 9-29-72; P&A;
Exhibit; ¢/s 10-6-72 M.C.
Oct 12—Motion of defendant for amended order heard &
denied. (Order to be presented) (Reporter: T.
Dourian) Richey J.
Oct 12—Opposition of defendant to motion for an amended
order; c/s. Richey J.
Oct 12—Order denying motion of defendant for an amended
order. (N) Richey J.
Oct 12—Notice of defendant to take deposition of Ralph
Nader; c/m 10-12.
Oct 20—Response of defendant to plaintiffs request for
production of documents; c/m 10-20.
Oct 20—Answer of defendant to complaint; c/m 10-20.
Appearance of William <A. Bradford, Jr.; Hogan &
Hartson.
Oct 20—Answer of defendant and objections to plaintiffs
first set of interrogatories; exhibit 1; ¢/m 10-20.
Nov 21—Notice of defendant to take deposition of Toby
Moffett ; ¢/m 11-21.
Dee 11—Motion of plaintiffs to compel answers to inter-
rogatories and production of documents; P & A; ex-
hibits A & B; ¢/m 12-8,
Dec 15—Memorandum of P & A by defendant in opposition
to plaintiffs motion to compel; ¢/m 12-15.
Dec 29—Reply of pltfs to deft’s memorandum of P& A;
e/m 12-27.
12
1973
Jan 18—Recommendation allowing in part and denying in
part Pitf’s motion to compel answers to interrogatories
and for production of documents; Pretrial Examiner.
Jan 25—Opposition of Pitf’s. to recommendation of Pre-
trial Examiner; Appendix A: ¢/m 1-25.
Jan 29—Objection of deft. to recommendation of the Pre-
trial Examiner. c/m 1/29/73.
Feb 7—Reply of pltfs to deft’s objections to recommenda-
tions of Pretrial Examiner. ¢c/m 2/6.
Feb 16—Order affirming the recommendation of the Pre-
trial Examiner entered on 1/18/73. (N) Richey, J.
Apr 27—Deposition of Ralph Nader for the deft.
May 9—Supplemental response of deft to request for pro-
duction of documents; attachments. c/s 5-9.
May 9—Supplemental response of deft to pltf’s interroga-
tories. c/s 5-9.
May 10—Catenpar Catt: Withdrawal of Jury demand;
Trial set 9-7-73, 9:30 a.m. (Rep: T. Dourian) Richey,
J.
May 10—Order setting trial for 9-7-73, 9:30 a.m.; setting
out the courts instructions to counsel. (N) Richey, J.
May 14—Affidavit of verification by David B. Armstrong;
e/m 5/14/73.
Jun 8—Deposition of Anthony John Moffett, Jr. for deft.
July 13—Reqvest of pltff. for production of documents;
set II; ¢/m 7/13/73.
July 31—Deposirion of John McDonald for the pltffs.
Aug 9—Motion of deft. for protective order; P&A. c/m 8-9.
Aug 14—Opposirion of pltfs. to motion for protective order.
c/s 8-13.
Aug 15—Response of defts. to request for production of
documents. c/m 8-15.
Aug 16—Oxper denying defts. motion for a protective
order; directing Leslie 0. Barnes to appear 8-20-73 at
10:30 a.m. for deposition. (N) Richey, J.
13
Aug 30—Triau brief of deft. ¢/m 8-30.
Aug 30—Ossrctions of deft. to pltfs proposed documentary
exhibits. ¢/m 8-29, ,
Aug 30—Tariat brief of pltffs.
Aug 30—Lisrt of exhibits of pltffs.
Sept 4—Triat by Court begun; respited until 2:00 p.m.
9-10-73. (Rep: T. Dourian) Richey, J.
Sept 4—List of deft. exhibits.
Sept 10—Triat by Court resumed; concluded; taken under
advisement. (Rep: T. Dourian) Richey, J.
Sept 17—Prorosep Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law
by deft. ¢/m 9-17.
Sept 17—Post-Trial memorandum by pltfs. table of cases,
appendix A, B,C & D. e/m 9-17.
Oct 18—Finxpines or Fact, Concivsions or Law, and Orper
entering Judgment against the deft. and directing that
deft. pay to pltf. Nader $10.00 in compensatory dam-
ages and $25,000 in punitive damages and pay to pitf.
Conn. Citizens Action Group $51.00 in nominal damages
and $25,000 in punitive damages and pltf. shall have
"fe pique against deft. for costs. (N) Richey, J.
Nov 16—Norice of appeal by deft. from order of 10-18-73.
Copies mailed to Reuben B. Robertson, III and Don
Crockett. Deposit $5.00 by Roberson.
*_* *
14
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
12-28-73
1-25-74
1-28-74
1-28-74
3- 4-74
3-18-74
6-28-74
7- 5-74
7-25-74
7-25-74
8- 5-74
8-14-74
9-17-74
11-29-74
[Title omitted in printing]
Certified Original Record (2 volumes of tran-
script and one envelope containing Exhibits (n)
25-Briefs for amicus curiae (The Air Transport
Association of America)
25-Appellant’s Brief (m-28)
10-Appellant’s Appendix (m-28)
25-Appellees’ brief (p-4)
25-Appellant’s reply brief (m-18)
4-CAB’s motion for leave to file brief as amicus
curiae out of time (m-28)
4-Appellees’ memorandum in opposition to mo-
tion of Civil Aeronautics Board for leave to file
untimely amicus curiae brief (m-3)
Per Curiam order that the Clerk is directed to file
the brief of the C.A.B. as amicus curiae; the time
for filing appellees’ reply to the amicus curiae
brief, if any, is extended to August 24, 1974;
Fahy, Sr. CJ) and McGowan, CJ
25-Brief for C.A.B. as amicus curiae (m-28)
4-Appellees’ motion to extend the time to file
a reply to Amicus Curiae Brief to September
16th (Ok RB) (m-2)
Per Curiam order by the Clerk for the Court
granting appellees’ motion to extend time to
reply to the brief amicus curiae of the CAB and
the time for filing appellees’ brief is extended
to September 16, 1974
15-Appellees’ reply to Brief Amicus Curiae of
the CAB (m-16)
Clerk’s order sua sponte, placing this case on the
summary calendar
12- 6-74
12- 9-74
12-10-74
S- 2-75
S- 2-75
S- 2-75
5-16-75
6-23-75
6-23-75
7- 1-75
15
4-Appellees’ motion for full oral argument (p-6)
Clerk’s order denying appellees’ motion for
full oral argument
Argued before McGowan and Tamm, CJ: The
Court announced that Sr. CJ Fahy is a member
of this panel of the Court but is unable to be
present; the case will be submitted to him on the
briefs and tape recording of oral argument
Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit J udge Tamm.
Opinion filed by Senior Circuit Judge Fahy, con-
curring in part and dissenting in part
Judgment reversing and remanding case to the
District Court. (n)
11-Appellees’ petition for rehearing and/or sug-
gestion for rehearing en banc (m-16)
Per Curiam order denying appellees’ petition for
rehearing; Fahy, Sr. CJ; McGowan and Tamm,
CJ; Sr. Circuit Judge Fahy would grant the
petition for rehearing as to that part of the
case as to which he has filed a dissenting opinion
Per Curiam order by the Clerk for the Court, en
banc that appellees’ suggestion for rehearing en
banc is denied
Copy of opinion and certified copy of judgment
and bill of costs in the amount of $2,726.30
issued to District Court.
16
Excerpts From Transcript of Trial
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
[Title omitted in printing]
Washington, D.C.
September 4, 1973
The above-entitled matter came on for trial before the
Honorable Charles R. Richey, United States District Judge,
at ten o’clock a.m.
APPEARANCES
For the Plaintiffs:
Revsen B. Rosertson, Ese.
For the Defendant:
Frank Roserson, Esq, and
Wuuum A. Braprorp, Jr, Esa.
2 e e e e e e
[2] The Clerk: Civil Action 1346-72, Ralph Nader and
others versus Allegheny Airlines.
e eo @ ®@ e * @
[3] Mr. Robertson: Yes, Your Honor. There is no dis-
agreement with the defendant’s exhibits.
The Court: All right. All defendant’s exhibits may be
admitted?
Mr. Robertson: So far as I am concerned, that is fine.
[4] ‘Tne Court: In other words, as I understand it, Mr.
Roberson, on behalf of the defendant, would admit and
offer no objection to 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12?
Mr. Roberson: That is correct, sir.
The Court: All right. Let us go back to 2. You had
better argue that, because I am not sure I understand it.
[8] The Court: Let me say this, Mr. Roberson:
As you obviously know, the court is sitting without a
jury, and I believe the court can give it the appropriate
weight. It may have no bearing on any issue in this case,
17
and I am not ruling, by letting it in, that it does at this
point. I am going to receive it fo it i
= apa r what it is worth at
[9] (Plaintiffs’ Exhibits 1 i i i
in Sinan cobain through 13, inclusive, received
The Court: Now, let us go on to Exhibit 14.
Now, they admit the authenticity of letters of complaint
but Mr. Roberson says that these letters are objected to
on the grounds they have no relevancy to the plaintiffs’
experience on April 28th.
[12] The Court: All right. I will admit those, but these
ar eg that came afterwards, I will deny them
a ti , . . 7 . . . ‘
- Hae . s’ Exhibit No. 14 received in evidence, as above
[13] The Court: All right.
How about 23?
The Court: I do not think it is binding on the court
I can take judicial notice that such an order exists and
receive it for what it is worth. But I do not frankly, at
this juncture, see how it is going to help the court or
be dispositive of the issues in the case.
Mr. Robertson: No, Your Honor, and, indeed
The Court: I will receive it for what it is worth, [14]
= a —_ you have to convince me that it is worth
a whole lot, because I d it i
whe 0 not see where it is worth very
6 s @ e s e & e e e
(Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 23 received in evidence. )
‘ 6 e 3 oe 8 e eo es s
18
Ralph Nader
was called as a witness, and, having been first duly
sworn, was ey.amined and testified as follows:
Direct Examination
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Mr. Nader, would you state your full name for the
record, please? A. Ralph Nader.
Q. Are you a resident of Washington? A. Yes.
Q. What is your profession? A. Lawyer.
[15] Q. Mr. Nader, do you remember when you pur-
chased your ticket for Flight 864 on April 28th? A. Very
early in the morning.
Q. Had you made a reservation for the flight in ad-
vancet A. Yes, a reservation was made in advance.
Q. Do you remember how far in advance, approximately,
sirt A. Several days, about three days in advance.
Q. What was the purpose of this trip to Hartford?
A. It was to attend a fund-raising rally in downtown
[16] Hartford, as well as to attend a number of other
gatherings throughout the State of Connecticut.
Q. And when you say ‘‘attend,”’ did you have any
particular function to perform at those rallies? <A. Yes,
I was to speak at the rallies.
Q. How far in advance was this trip planned? <A. At
least three weeks. The day was planned for a number of
gatherings around the state on behalf of the Connecticut
Citizen Action Group.
oe e @ @ © eS @
Q. What is the Connecticut Citizen Action Group? A.
It is a citizens’ group that dedicates its effort in a non-
profit manner to consumer, environmental, legislative,
governmental rights.
19
ned. Q. What time did you get to the airport on April
’ Wie About four or five minutes after 10:00.
' ere were you at that time? A.
ells eee me?t A. At the Allegheny
. Q. That is upstairs, as you got out of the cab? A. Yes
it is on the ground floor of the airport.
Q. How de you remember that ti
t time? H 7
know it at that time? ody Fe
A. When I left downtown Washington at about 20 of
10:00, I noticed that it was taking longer than it usually
takes to get to the airport. Since the plane was leaving
at [18] 10:15, I looked at my watch when I arrived at
the Allegheny counter, pursuant to looking at the board
to a Wat tn, number the plane was leaving from.
\ at did you do after you got th
right to the gate. sei silat basae
Q. And how long did it take you
t
About three minutes. ; oe >
Q. What time did you arrive at the gate? A. About
10 after 10:00. My watch is usually a minute or a minute
and 2 half fast, but it was 10 after 10:00, I would say.
Depa time was the flight scheduled to leave? A. At
Q. Was the plane still there when you arrived? A Oh
yes, —
Q. What happened when you arrived at the gate? A.
There were people milling around in front of the ticket
lift desk, “ppodly nie. and the person in front of me was
a person ad known, John Koskinen, who w
to Senator Ribicoff. ee
van What happened when you presented the ticket to the
at py Fs When I presented the ticket to the agent
agent in ;
«ng indicated that there was no more room on the
Q. Do you remember exactly what the agent said? A.
He said, in so many words, there is no more room. The
ror tell him you had a reservation? A. I did.
Q. What did you tell the agent about the nature of
your trip? A. I told him that I had to make an no
speech in downtown Hartford, and it was very umpo
the plane.
Tae him if : would check to see if there were any
stand-by’s on the plane, because it has been my experi-
ence that stand-by’s are given secondary priority.
Q. Did he tell you whether there were any stand-by’s
or not? A. He indicated simply that the plane was full.
He had constantly repeated that phrase, and that he could
ing about it.
ais y nine. 8 him to do anything else to help get you
on board? A. Yes, I asked him if he would send his
representative or go to the plane—they were milling back
and forth at the [20] time—and ask if anybody on the
plane would desire to volunteer to take a later plane be-
cause of the urgency of the trip.
By Mr. Robertson:
her there were
. When you asked the agent to see whet
a volunteers on board who might take a later flight,
sir, so [21] that you could make your engagement, what
did he say to you then? A. He said he was sorry, but
he couldn’t do anything about that.
Q. Did he refuse to seek any volunteers? A. Yes, by
irtue of his statement.
ie Q. And at this time was the plane still at the gate?
A. Yes.
. t did you do then? A. Then I went to the
BAe et Bie to that I asked him what else could
be done, in effect, as other people were asking him, in
the same situation. He said he would possibly see; that
there might be another connection that could be made.
21
Q. What was the other connection that he told you
about? A. He said there might be another connection
via Philadelphia to Hartford, but that it was a close
scheduling problem.
Q. Did he say how close it wast A. I don’t recollect
exactly, other than it occurred to me that sometime in
that two- or three-minute span of frantic exchanges, and
so forth, there was indicated a ten-minute connection time,
if the plane from Washington landed as scheduled in
Philadelphia.
Q. Did he say whether or not he could assure that the
connection in Philadelphia would definitely be made? A.
No, he did not say he could assure it at all.
Q. Did he say he could not assure it? [22] A. He said
he could not assure it, in so many words. ;
Q. Do you recall what time this proposed connecting
flight was supposed to arrive in Hartford if it did make
the connection? A. At 12:15.
Q. That is the best of your recollection? <A. Yes.
Q. Would that be in time for the rally? A. No, it
would not.
Q. What time was the rally scheduled for? A. It was
my understanding that the rally was scheduled for 12:00
noon. A 12:15 arrival, with time to get a cab at Bradley
Field and time to get into Hartford, would have brought
me at the designated area no earlier than 10 or 5 of
1:00.
Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, I object to that and move
it go out. It is nut responsive.
The Court: Overruled.
Mr. Roberson: May I say that the actual time of the
rally—he was asked what was the time of the rally. Well,
the actual time of the rally was 12:15, not what he
thought it was. It was not noon.
The Court: Well, I think he said 12:15, if I understood
him correctly.
Mr. Roberson: No, he said he thought it was noon,
Your Honor.
[23] The Court: Now, what did he say, Mr. Reporter?
Did he say 12:15 or did he say noon?
(A portion of the record was read back by the re-
porter, as follows: ‘‘Question: What time was the rally
scheduled fort Answer: It was my understanding that
the rally was scheduled for 12:00 noon.’’)
The Court: All right.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Your recollection and your understanding upon which
you base your testimony was that the rally was scheduled
for 12:00? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you know exactly what time the rally was
scheduled for? A. My understanding is that it was a
noon rally.
Q. Did you know exactly what time the rally was
scheduled for? A. Yes.
[24] Q. Did you know exactly what time you were ex-
pected to arrivet A. Yes. At that point at the Allegheny
desk, ticket desk, it was my clear understanding that it
was a noon rally.
Q. Fine. What would have happened if the Philadelphia
connection had been missed? A. If the Philadelphia con-
nection had been ‘nissed, I would have, in effect, been
stranded in Philadelphia and would not have been able
to make other engagements in the State of Connecticut
that afternoon.
Q. Did you notify anyone about being bumped off the
flight? A. Yes, I called Mr. Moffett via Mr. Jacobs.
Q. Who is Mr. Moffett? A. Mr. Moffett is the director
of the Connecticut Citizen Action Group in Hartford.
Q. And who is Mr. Jacobs? A. My associate.
s @ @ @ @
Q. What was the nature of that conversation? [25] A.
To relate to Mr. Moffett that I could not obtain a seat
on the Allegheny flight; that the suggested connection via
Phil , , :
nace ps om a very tight one; and it had two risks
One, [ might not be able to get out of Phi ia i
a plane arrived late in Philadelphia for Pat
- deen and most important, even if everything went
~ ed and the plane arrived at 12:15, I would not
ve been able to get into downtown Hartford, which is
about 20 or 25 miles away, until just before 1 00 o’clock.
Q. Do you know how many calls were made to Mr
Moffett? A. I think two calls were made? ;
2 — at that time? A. Yes.
- Were there any later calls made to
A. Yes, there was a second call, again Suki ee
indicating that the best plan would be to take an Ame feats
Airlines flight to Boston and have somebody pick a
at Logan Airport. oene Ss
The Witness: And drive ;
: . me to Storrs in Co :
[26] which was my next engagement. nn
Q. And approximatel
y how much wa
long-distance telephone calls? A. About eo ee
A... What flight did you take, then? A. I did take the
on ae ge flight. It left sometime between 11:00
aly on’t know the exact time to Boston from
Q. Why did you not tak ; ,
Ver tite tenenie, e the air taxi connection? A.
One, there was no assurance i
, 3 no that it would get t
Allegheny flight in time that was leaving Philadelphia. 1
. believe there is about a 10-minute span there.
And, secondly, that even if it did, it would have arrived
too late for me to get a cab to go all the way down t
downtown Hartford in time for the lunchtime rally ‘
Q. What happened when you arrived at Boston? A A
representative of the Connecticut Citizen Action Group
picked me up in the car and drove me to Storrs in Con-
ecticut.
" Q. Were you in time for your engagement there? A. I
late.
- Do you remembor how late you were? A. About 25
inutes or so.
(27) Q. Were you informed by Allegheny prior to the
flight at any time that it overbooked its flights? A. No.
Q. Were you informed by Allegheny or warned in any
way that there was a risk of being denied boarding on its
flights? A. No.
. Were you warned in advance or told in any manner
on Flight 864, in fact, was overbooked for that day?
A. No.
Q. Were you aware of this? A. No, I was not.
Q. If you had known in advance of the risk that you
might not get on the flight, what action would you have
taken? A. I would have taken an earlier flight.
icipati to how you were
[28] Q. What was your anticipation as (
going to get to Hartford on the 28th of Aprilt A. Well,
since I had a confirmed reservation on that Allegheny
flight, I fully anticipated there would be a seat available
for me on the aircraft when I arrived at the gate.
Q. Did you rely on this, in fact, in making your plans
and your commitments? A. I certainly did.
Q. Were you ever bumped by Allegheny before? A. I
was not. - ;
Q. Were you ever bumped on any other airline flights?
A. Yes.
Q. How many times have you been bumped? A. Twice
before that, as I can remember. .
Q. On what occasions did this happent A. Abont six
months previously, an Eastern Airlines flight bumped me,
and five other people, on a flight to Miami. Just a few
days before the Allegheny flight, an American Airlines
flight bumped me.
Q. Did this not make you aware that Allegheny does
overbook its flights, and your reservation was subject to
this kind of risk? A. No, it did not.
Q. Well, why not? A. For two reasons:
[29] One, the two incidents did not relate to Allegheny.
They were not relevant to Allegheny’s behavior.
And, second, against all the flights that I had taken in
the past, these were the only two times, one of which
might have been understandable because of the fact of
an airline strike on a competing route to Miami.
The Court: There was not any strike in connection with
the American Airlines flight?
The Witness: And there was not any strike in connec-
tion with the American.
The Court: Did you have a confirmed reservation in
each of those instances?
The Witness: Yes, I did.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. In each of those cases were you put on another flight
that got you in time to your destination or shortly after?
A. Yes, there were some delays, however, obviously.
Q. So in either of those cases, were you given any
boarding compensation? A. No. To finish my answer
to your last question, against the number of flights that
I had taken, two flights in that type of situation certainly
were not enough to dismantle [30] my anticipation of
reliability.
Q. Well, did you understand from these incidents that
there was a pattern of systematic and intentional over-
booking throughout the airline industry? A. No, it was
always explained as accidental, or what have you, but
certainly not as policy.
Cross-Examination
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Mr. Nader, do you remember having your deposition
taken in this case on November 13, 1972, when you were
asked under oath certain questions with respect to this
incident? A. I do.
Q. Since that deposition, have you read the deposition
that was also taken of Mr. Moffett, the director of your
Citizen—Connecticut Citizen Action Group? A. Yes, I
have.
Q. Have you learned from reading Mr. Moffett’s depo-
sition that his recollection and his testimony was different
from your deposition testimony as to when the arrange-
ments were made for you to make a speech in Hartford?
A. Yes, I have.
Q. Is that why you changed from saying on your depo-
sition [31] that you had agreed at least three weeks in
advance with Mr. Moffett to now saying that it was some-
what less than three weeks? A. It was a refreshing of
my recollection. You see, there was an overlap here. The
agreement for the day’s trip was made at least three
weeks in advance, but the agreement for the particular
speech was made in less time. Reading that deposition
refreshed my recollection on that point.
Q. Well, you knew that I was not asking you about
some other speech; that I was asking you about che Hart-
ford speech, was I not? A. Yes.
Q. And you did testify unequivocally that you made
that at least three weeks in advance? A. There was a
confusion of the overlap, yes.
Q. To respond to my question—— A. Yes.
Q. (Continuing)—you did so testify without any equivo-
cation, didn’t you? A. I would have to see my testimony.
Q. Was this question asked, and did you answer this
way at page 13 of your deposition:
27
‘Question: How long ;
: ‘Ong in advance had you a
— [32] for this meeting, the speaking std
nswer: At least three weeks, I would Say.’’
Was that questio i
and q n asked you, and did you answer that
The Court: What
: page?
Mr. Roberson: Page 13, sir.
The Court: All right.
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Was that question asked you on your deposition
and did you i
_ you respond in the way that I just read it? A,
activities were discussed with Mr. Moffett general day’s
Q. Were you asked thi i
hes , 8 question at
deposition, and did you respond this mol ay
[33] ‘Question: Is he th
: eo i
that you agreed with to poten err a sain
‘‘Answer: Yes.”’
A. To speak during the day, yes, sir.
Q. And your answer was just ‘‘yes”’? A. Yos
ge 14 of your
[36] Q. Now, both of th ibi , , 1
Now, ese exhibits, F i
starting time of this rally as 12:15, do on P it ge
7 yo your word for it. acs Taio
- 1 would rather you would look at j
\ tit? A. Fine.
this one does not. Yes, it does. Fine. Both of ati .
28
Q. They both do, don’t they? A. Yes.
[37] Q. But, in any event, your information or your
understanding was that it would arrive at Bradley Field,
which is the name of the Hartford Airport, at about
12:15, isn’t that right, Mr. Nader? A. At about 12:15.
Q. You have later learned from your friend, Mr. Kos-
kinen, who at that time was an aid to Senator Ribicoff,
that it did arrive at about that time, isn’t that correct?
A. That is correct.
Q. You know that they did make the Philadelphia con-
nection, don’t yout A. They made an illegal Philadelphia
connection.
Q. Did I ask you anything about whether it was a
legal (38] or illegal connection? A. In the interests of
accuracy——
Q. Did I ask you anything about whether it was illegal
or legal, the Philadelphia connection? A. No.
Q. It did make its Philadelphia connection, did it not,
sirt <A. Yes.
Q. And it got to Hartford at approximately twelve——
A. Yes, that is correct.
Q. Wait until I finish the question. And it got to Phila-
delphia at approximately 12:15 A. As Mr. Koskinen
told me.
Q. And the distance, the airline distance, betweeen Con-
stitution Plaza where this rally was to be held and Bradley
Field is—I mean the direct route would be—eleven-and-a-
half miles, would it not? A. I don’t know the miles. I
know the time it takes from experience.
Q. You are a native of Connecticut, are you not? A.
Yes.
Q. Have you spent a good deal of time in Hartford?
A. Yes.
Q. Almost the entire route, whatever the distance, be-
tween Bradley Field and Constitution Plaza, you are on
expressways, [39] are you not? A. Well, certainly, ex-
cept until you get into the city, which is not expressway.
Q. Does not Interstate 95 go within a couple of bloc
rc Plaza? A. Yes, as it tev emit oe
Q. Was it in existence in April of 1972? A. Yes.
. * pod on. pp hawt traveled that distance, whatever
r4 San Pane ox way on expressways, wouldn’t you?
Q. Now, had you arrived at 12:10, could you not travel
the distance down on these expressways at that time of
day in time to have arrived at a
: rally start 15
before it broke up? A. No. y starting at 12:15
Q. You could not make it in 30 minutes? [40] A. It is
= Sag you about 10 minutes to get a cab, once you
step off the airplane and go up the labryinthi idors
i I pe p ryinthic corridors
Q. Sometimes it takes you ten minutes; sometimes it
— you less, does it not? A. My experience is ten min-
utes.
Q. Would it not be possible for you to have one of your
associates or the Connecticut Citizen Action Group there
on hand at the airport to meet you so you would not have
to wander around the airport looking for a taxi? A. That
— opt taken longer, because they would have had to
park the car. They do not allow any loitering at
narrow gate space. ‘ viii
Q. I did not ask you whether it would taken taken
longer. I asked you was it not possible. A. Could you
rephrase the question again?
Q. Read the question to the witness, please,
(The last question was read back by th
requested. ) y the reporter, as
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Would you answer that question? A. Yes.
[41] Q. You were not the only speaker down there at
this rally, were you? A. My understanding is that I was.
Q. Didn’t you understand that the mayor was going to
make a speech and some councilman was going to make a
speech, among others, at this rally? A. My understand-
ing is that they were to be just brief introductions.
Q. You knew they were going to say something to what-
ever audience was assembled, didn’t you? A. Yes.
Q. Have you learned, in fact, that the rally didn’t break
up until 12:451 A. I learned that the remnants of the
rally terminated at about 12:45.
Q. In other words, if you could have traveled the dis-
tance between the airport and the downtown site of the
rally in 30 minutes, Constitution Plaza, you would have
gotten there before everybody left, would you not? A. I
would have gotten there before everybody left. That is
correct.
* e ° e ° * ® ° . ws
[42] Q. As a matter of fact, vou were a half hour late
over at Storrs, Connecticut. it was supposed to start at
2:00 p.m., and you got there around 2:30, didn’t you? A.
Around 2:25.
Q. If Mr. Moffett testified 2:30, he is incorrect about
that? A. Most people do net, you know, have a bell on
their watch. My estimate is 2:25. If his estimate was 2:30,
then we have to take each estimate as to its value.
Q. To answer my question, if Mr. Moffett testified that
it was about 2:30 that you got there, then he was wrong
about that? A. No, about 2:30 could be 2:25.
Q. And the andience was still there when you arrived,
were they not, at Storrs, Connecticut? A. The college
audience was still there.
Q. Was the difference between those two rallys that
you were getting a fee at Storrs, Connecticut; whereas,
you were speaking free over in Hartford, or were to have
spoken free; was that a difference between those two
rallys? A. No, because I was not getting a fee in either
place, sir.
31
[44] Q. Well, if an announcem
, ent had been made to ith
gr ete. that Mr. Nader had been delayed, but etre
J ere before the rally was over, do you not think that
z t would have had some effect to hold the crowd? A
. I be ty because most of the audience—— )
’ id not ask you why. I j :
on ha a. a y. I just asked you: do you not
Q. You could have taken a fli
ght up to Hartford
night before, which would have made it certain that be
would be there both for your rally in Hartford and get
over to Storrs in time, coul
oe as d you not? A. If I were not
Q. Your answer is that
{ you could have taken a flight th
previous evening which would have gotten you sa in
= “s time, isn’t that right, sir? A. If I could have
ained a rese i
pon ead rvation, counsel, and [45] if I were not
Q. And there are other airline
s than Allegh
serve Hartford, are there not? <A. Yes. ceo
: Q. Now, are there also trains and buses that go to Hart-
ord? A. May I correct my answer. You said there are
other airlines that serve Hartford.
Q. Yes. A. I know there is one )
other scheduled airli
I don’t know if there are other ‘‘airlines’’, oe
Q. What is the other one? A. Eastern.
P.. There are also morning flights, earlier morning flights
0s 10:15, that would have gotten you there in time in
p enty of time for your rally, isn’t that so? A. Yes. a ain
subject to those two qualifications. rie
Q. What time was this Fli
ght 864 scheduled
arrived in Hartford? A. Again, I believe gb ba
an hour after it was [46] scheduled to d i
have made it roughly 11:15, shee dietitians
Q. Which would have made you only 45 minutes before
the time that you thought your rally was supposed to be-
gin, namely, noon? A. That is correct.
Q. And you say that you could not have gotten at that
time of day between the airport and downtown Hartford,
Constitution Plaza, in 30 minutes’ time? A. I could not
have gotten—to answer your question precisely, I could
not have gotten there before 30 minutes’ time.
Q. So you were cutting it pretty thin, even if everything
had gone well for you, were you not? A. There was 15
minutes’ leeway. I would not call chat thin.
Q. You think, then, that vou could have gotten down-
town in 30 minutes? A. I think I could have gotten down-
town before 12:00, I have no idea what the traffic problems
were at that time.
Q. Well, if you got down there at five minutes to 12:00,
you would not have been 15 minutes before you thought
the rally was going to start; you would have been there
five minutes ahead, would you not? A. I would have been
there in time for the rally.
Q. You would have been there five minutes before noon,
[47] would you not? A. Under what assumption?
Q. If you had arrived there at 40 minutes after you
left the airport? A. That is right.
Q. You know that airline schedules are not 100 per cent
certain to come off, do you not? A. Yes.
Q. Planes are sometimes late? A. That is right.
Q. Sometimes there are mechanical difficulties in get-
ting off the ground? A. Yes.
Q. If this rally were so important to you, why did you
not take an earlier flight, to take care of these possibilities?
A. For two reasons:
One, Allegheny has a policy of informing its people if
there are mechanical problems ahead of time—three rea-
sons, rather.
Second, I felt that I could rely on Allegheny’s schedul-
ing in this particular circumstance. It is a well-traveled
route, and they have back-up planes.
a thirdly, I had work to do.
Pe a. Airlines is a well-traveled route, is it not
- ] A. Between what points, counsel? )
b romaine Airlines is a busy airline? A. Yes
. noe y Airlines is a busy airline? A. Yes sir
rP A = a been denied boarding because of overbook.
ry n bot of these airlines in recent times, had vo t
Recent times, in what time frame—— -
. paper as of the 28th of April, 1972? A Yes
- AS a matter of fact, the incident ;
lines had ocurred on th uae d ion on
. a
isn’t that correct? A. — it ea aan
BP Boel pad no ony 4 — that sometimes airlines
, use 0 at, confirmed reservati
a ” you on the plane ; you knew that, didn’t ca 4
» because they did not tell me they were intentionall ,
“a bere or even overbooking iad
- Did they tell you that after
+7 r you arrived, a
mong bs rs ge I am talking about Eastern a,
rican i i
pa iriines, now. A. They did not use the
Q. Well, they tendered
\ you these denied- i
energy cards, didn’t they? [49] A. to. a yn
<k, describe it a little more precisely? ieee
- Do you not know that under the CAB i
. . vhs
nee gtd is denied boarding because of one
, airline 1s required, then and th =
what they call a denied boa i ‘aac,
-boarding card that explai
gr passenger’s rights? You knew that pe
= re oe given those by Eastern Airlines and Ameri
’ irlines, had you not? A. I know I was given it b
astern Airlines. I wanted to make sure you we “goed
ferring to the ticket. ——
Q. No. I am talki ; 7
A. Yee. ing about the notification of your rights.
3 pe knew that? A. Yes,
- And you got one of those from E
‘ astern, and
got one five days previously from American, did a hoe
34
A. I don’t recollect that I received it. It might a =
tendered or put in my ticket, you know, just stashed im
MS wel as a matter of fact, when this incident occurred,
Mr. Nader, involving Allegheny and Mr. McDonald, the
service representative of Allegheny, advised you — oa
fortunately, they could not get you on the plane -
of an oversale, didn’t he, than and there, tender you ~ s
denied-boarding notice card, [50] setting forth your rig s,
and didn’t you say, ‘‘Never mind, I have got one ws
American’’? Didn’t you tell him that, in substance? .
What I think I told him was that I had already been oe
fered one from American. I did not signify that I accepte
"9. pty event, you had on occasion read these
things, a you knew what your rights were in the event
of oversales, didn’t you? A. You will permit me to to
restrictively define your rereaaig of ‘‘rights’’. I knew
] id were my rights, sir.
“o stn ft that, pe reso rights, you were entitled
to denied-boarding compensation, didn’t yout A. Yes.
Q. So you knew, when you booked—— A. Excuse me.
Under certain conditions, rights to denied-boarding com-
Be aad knew, when you had a confirmed ticket on
Allegheny Airlines, that it was not at all certain pager
would be, in fact, boarded on that plane; you had wit
five days experienced org — on under similar cir-
ou not . NO.
“9 Dida’ a ‘ell us that on the 25rd of April, 1912,
(511 on an American Airlines flight from bear ne -
Boston, you were denied boarding because of an oversale
A. “Under the similar circumstances’? means that they
informed me that the plane was overbooked. They did not
inform me that the plane was overbooked, in so many
"o ter gave you a denied-boarding compensation =
which explained your rights; American Airlines did that,
did they not? A. Yes, but that did not indicate any over-
booking or any intentional overbooking.
Q. Whether it is intentional or not, you knew that you
Were entitled to denied-boarding compensation by virtue
of those recent experiences; didn’t you know that? A.
Yes, but I would not——
Q. And that is the reason you did not accept the denied-
boarding card from Mr. McDonald, or declined to take it,
isn’t that sot A. Because I already knew what it said.
Q. Mr. Nader, you did not personally file a notice in
writing with an official of Allegheny Airlines to the effect
that you were gcing to make a claim arising out of this
incident within 45 days of the incident, did you?’ A. Not
in writing, myself.
[52] Well, nobody did on your behalf within 45 days,
did they? <A. Not in writing.
Q. Your counsel that you retained to file a lawsuit is not
the same counsel that is trying the case here for you, is it?
A. That is correct.
Q. You had a Mr. Crockett? A. That is correct.
Q. And you placed the matter in his hands? A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And you are aware that it was not until June 19,
1972, that he wrote to National Airlines—not National,
but Allegheny Airlines, saying that he intended to file a
complaint arising out of this incident? A. That is right.
Q. On the morning of this flight, what time did you leave
your home, Mr. Nader? A. Sometime between 8:00 and
9:00.
[53] Q. Do you live in downtown Washington? A. Yes.
Q. And then what time did you actually depart down-
town Washington to the airport? A. Twenty of 10:00.
Q. This was on a Friday? A. Yes.
This was on a Friday, was it not? A. Yes.
4 You know Friday to be a heavy-travel day, do you
t? A. Not particularly in the morning. — .
""Q. Your answer is that you do not think it is on Friday
in the morning? A. No.
. Particularly heavy? A. No.
2 If you left downtown Washington at 20 minutes to
10:00 to catch a 10:15 flight, was that not, in itself, cutting
it a little thin? A. No.
[54] Q. And, in fact, it took you some 29 minutes to make
the trip on this morning, this Friday morning, isn t that
so? A. Yes, longer than I anticipated.
eo ® e * 3 eo * es e oe
The Witness: It took probably 25 or 24 minutes, to be
exact.
° o e @ e & e eo a
[55] Q. You learned that this particular flight was board-
ing at Gate 17, didn’t you? A. That is right.
Q. And that is some over 1000 feet and ona different leve
from the Allegheny ticket counter, isn’t it? A. I under-
stand from your calculations is was 1037 feet, sir.
[56] Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, there is a stipulation
that was entered into at the deposition that it is 1037 feet
between the Allegheny counter where he came in and Gate
17 where this flight was boarding. That was @ stipulation
between counsel at the time of the deposition.
The Court: All right.
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Did you walk or did you run that 1037 feet, Mr. Nader,
on this morning? A. I walked very fast.
Q. You were not worried about missing the plane? A.
o When you got to the ticket lift position at Gate 7—
incidentally, that was at the extreme end of a long corridor,
was it not? A. Yes.
37
Q. When you got there, you recognized John Koskinen?
A. Yes, I did.
[57] Q. How long have you known Mr. Koskinen? A. Oh,
about two years, prior to that time.
Q. In any event, he was already there at the scene ahead
of you, was he not? A. Yes.
Q. Did you learn later that, or did you learn at that time
that, Mr. Koskinen had already been denied boarding? A.
I learned that at the time of arriving at the ticket lift gate.
Q. And was there another young man—I don’t expect
you to remember his name—who was also denied boarding
on this flight? A. I could not say exactly. There were a
number of [58] people in that vicinity. I could not distin-
guish who was denied or who was just a relative seeing
somebody off or whatnot.
Q. You knew that at least one was denied boarding in
addition to you and Mr. Koskinen, though, didn’t you? A.
I would not say precisely. I knew there were some others,
but I did not know precisely how many.
Q. And you knew that the others had arrived at that
ticket lift position ahead of you, didn’t you? A. I would
assume some did, yes.
Q. You were the last one that was denied boarding to
arrive at the ticket lift position, were you not? A. So far
as I know.
Q. Did you learn the name of this Allegheny representa-
tive that you talked with there at the gate? A. At the time?
Q. Have you learned it at all? A. Well, you mentioned
Mr. McDonald.
Q. Yes. A. Yes.
Q. Mr. McDonald did not know until after he had already
told you that he was sorry, the plane was full, he did not
know anything about your having to make a speech, did he?
A. Well, he told me the plane was full, and then I pleaded
with him. So the answer to your question is: he knew =
after the first communication to me that the plane was ful,
“7 Then the answer is that at the time he first denied -
boarding, he did not know about it, did he? A. amend
Q. Did you mention the particular speech you ant g is
to make or the organization? A. I think I said — _
the extent of I have to make an important speech at a rally
” Q i. dan natn the Connecticut Citizen Action
' i i t A. No. om)
"a tes ode oll to know that Allegheny Airlines
ever heard of the Connecticut Citizen Action stg nee
this event, do you? A. I would suspect they a - ;
about it, because it had been very widely in the —e a
prior year through the Connecticut newspapers, ra " :
Q. You do not know it, do you; you do not know cr Oo
a fact: that Allegheny ever heard of it? A. No, I do no
i a fact.
wo You dude’ eventually not to take this—try to make
the connection by way of eget am and you flew in-
ston? A. That is correct.
“— hae ticket to Boston cost you about $3 more _
[60] the ticket to Hartford would have cost you? A. es.
Q. Mr. Nader, are you familiar with the fact that ony oA
men sometimes make reservations on more than one ~
in order to be sure that there will be a flight a od
conference ends or whatnot; are you aware of that? : ~
Q. You have never heard of any individual booking e 8
on more than one flight? A. I have heard of students, for
oing that. .
“Oo Yen “ that happens, do you not? A. I know it has
ar gre you know that is what is called a no-show, =
they fill only one of those reservations, do you not? , A. es.
Q. You know that has been a problem for the airline “
dustry for a long time, has it not? A. I know they think i
has been a problem.
Q. You do not think no-shows and cancellations are a
problem for the airline industry? A. No, because I know
that they can have appropriate remedies; and, indeed, one
airlines has already developed an appropriate remedy to
make it not a problem.
Q. What airline is that? A. Eastern.
[61] The Court: What do they do, just for my informa-
tion?
The Witness: They have a leisure class where, in effect,
they fill a plane, and the next person that calls is asked
if he or she wants to be in leisure class, and that means
that they go out to the airport, and if they do not get a
Seat, then they are put on the next flight, as I under-
stand it.
It is a little beiter than a stand-by status, Your Honor.
The Court: But the flight that they fail to show up for
leaves with a vacant seat?
The Witness: No, because the minute the plane is filled,
the next person calling Eastern Airlines is told that the
plane is full, but he can be put on what they call leisure
status, which is a little better status than stand-by.
The Court: I see.
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Mr. Nader, is one of the groups that you organized
called Aviation Consumer Action Project? A, Yes, I helped
organize it. Yes, sir.
Q. And you have your counsel, Mr. Reuben Robertson
here. He is the director and the secretary of that organiza-
tion, is he not? A. I believe SO, yes.
Q. Are you aware that, when Eastern Airlines was at-
tempting to experiment with this leisure class or conditional
[62] reservation, which you have indicated to His Honor
would be a solution to no-shows, that the Aviation Con-
sumer Action Project filed a complaint with the CAB, the
Civil Aeronautics Board, on May 21, 1971, saying that this
experiment would constitute a fraud on the consumers, is
i uld be an
ically unworkable, and in most cases wo '
_— pom Mr and a deceptive device to vietimize —_
gers; and that even though it might temporarily mene
the problems of no-show passengers at the expense . its
competitors, the solution could not be achieved without com-
itting fraud on many passengers ’
ws oye realize your group was doing that with respect to
this experiment that you now mention to His — as
being a solution to no-shows? Do you realize that? A. Yes.
May I make the distinction that they are ng
Q. I did not ask you for a distinction. I just asked oo -
you realize that they said that? A. If you want to sa F
precise, counsel, would you please read the question back,
I will take the opportunity to answer.
- "| on you answered it. A. Because I think you
characterized it.
ld was talking to you
H4 . Mr. Nader, when Mr. McDona t '
oll > possibility of making a connection via rope
phia, he told you that if the connection were made, it on
put you in Hartford about 55 minutes after your Flight 2
was scheduled to arrive, didn’t he? <A. I don’t reca
he was that precise, but——
"a Wel you knew it would arrive about 12:10 or 12:157
A. Yes, around 12:15.
Q ‘And you knew that your own flight was to arrive there
at 11:15, Flight 8641 A. Yes, I knew that the flight from
iladelphi ive at 12:15.
adelphia was scheduled to arrive at
"e in were you not interested in that when you first
heard about it? A. I was interested in seeing when the new
connection was supposed to arrive. I was no longer inter-
ested when I heard it was about 12:15.
i iti ion Group did not
65 . The Connecticut Citizen Action
sat a. ticket from Allegheny Airlines for you to come up
there on, did [66] it? A. No, they did not.
res
4l
Q. You bought your own ticket? A. That is right.
[67] The Court: What evidence do you have, sir, that the
action of the airline in refusing passage on the particular
flight that you were not allowed to board was intentional?
The Witness: The evidence is an admission by the de-
fendant that they have a systematic policy of overbooking,
and that they do not inform the consumer of that policy of
overbooking.
That they announce in their advertisements a clear impli-
cation that the airline company would honor reservations
and take people to their desired destination on scheduled
flights.
The Court: Anything else?
The Witness: And I think there is evidence in the deposi-
tion that was taken that there was an active attempt to
conceal—not only a non-disclosure of this practice to the
passenger or consumer, but an active attempt to conceal.
This is indicated in their instructions to employees as to
how to explain an overbooking.
The least that could be expected is for the passenger to
be told that the flight is full.
The Court: Those three things, then, are the factual basis
upon which you claim that there was an intentional act on
[68] the part of the defendant airlines to refuse you pas-
Sage on this flight?
Mr. Robertson: Your Honor——
The Court: Is that correct?
The Witness: I think there are three: the policy of over-
booking, the non-disclosure of that fact, the active conceal-
ment of that, and the promotion in their advertisements
indicating to the contrary.
Mr. Robertson: Your Honor, I assume that you are asking
this witness’ knowledge.
The Court: I am asking for this witness’ knowledge, yes.
Mr. Robertson: There are other facts of record that are in
the documentary evidence that substantiate this.
42
The Court: How do you know that there is a systematic
i f overbooking, Mr. Nader?
~ Witness: I think that was admitted by Mr. ae
if I recollect correctly, in his deposition. He is presiden
of Allegheny gop :
rt: All right.
a winnnee: And I think there is — material
has that supports that, as well.
ae ech Now, do you have any advertisements —
that imply that they will take people who reserve a
regardless of whether the reservations exceed the numbe
of seats? [69] Do you have any ads that say that? —
The Witness: I don’t have any ads with me, Your ” :
The Court: Or do you have any ads that imply that .
Mr. Robertson: We do have an admission by the presi-
Honor.
“Se Let me ask the witness, counsel. If you think
I am being improper or unfair, you can object. Do you have
4 normed
any ads with you that imp ”
Witness: Not with me, Your onor,
a Court: (Continuing) —that the airline will take +e"
ple who make reservations, regardless of the number o
seats available?
The Witness: I don’t have any ads with me.
The Court: Have you ever seen any?
Witness: Yes, I have. ae
= Roberson: Excuse me, Your Honor. I don’t think
“n Well, just let me——
Witness: Well, just le
a peo (Continuing) —and I would object to this,
because I certainly do not think that any such ad exists, at
least not by Allegheny.
The Witness: If you will just = finish.
Mr. Roberson: I don’t want any hearsay.
The Court: Your objection is noted. My function is [70] to
find the fact, and if he has any evidence of it, I want to
see it.
43
You say you have seen it, but you do not have it with you.
The Witness: What I am saying is my understanding,
when these ads are put in newspapers with schedules——
The Court: Yes.
The Witness: (Continuing) —you know, that there are ten
flights to Hartford a day——
The Court: Yes.
The Witness: (Continuing) —my understanding is that
if you make a reservation and the company agrees to give
you a seat, that you have a seat.
The Court: And you say that that implies that they will
take people, regardless of the number of seats on the air-
lines? Is that your position?
The Witness: No, it is not. My position is it implies just
the reverse. My implication is that if you reserve a seat,
you will get one.
The Court: Regardless of the number of seats on the air-
craft?
The Witness: That is my understanding. You see, my
understanding from these ads is that they would not give
you a seat if they do not have one available; that is, if their
capacity was not enough for it.
[71] The Court: All right. Then you wish to change your
testimony, I take it, to the effect that they would only give
you a reservation if, at the time of handing you a reserva-
tion or agreeing to give you one, they had a seat available.
The Witness: Yes, that is right.
The Court: All right. So the ads do not imply that they
would not give you a reservation unless, they, in fact, had
a vacant seat and had not been oversold?
Mr. Robertson: We have two double negatives there,
Your Honor. I am trying to figure out—
The Court: You will have all the opportunity you want,
sir, and I do not want the witness to feel, or you to feel, or
Mr. Robertson to feel, the court is taking advantage of this
or any other witness in this case or any other case.
44
But I think this witness would be the first to object, om
he has the right to object, and I want him to know that he
the right on his own.
od The Witness: I want to be certain that I was not
tripped up by a double negative.
Court: Pardon me?
es Witness: I just hope I was not tripped up by a double
negative.
s ® @ 6 e * ®
Redirect Examination
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Mr. Nader, based on the promotion and —
ments that we have been talking about, is it your 1 —"
standing that Allegheny, based on these ads, will no
a confirmed reservation to a passenger unless it has the
to sell, in fact? .
Pr. Roberson: Excuse me, Your Honor. I object to that
because there aren’t any such ads. I just do not think haan
he ought to say based on some ads when we do not have
any ads in evidence.
We can’t see what he is talking about, and, therefore, I
think it is an objectionable question. =——
The Court: Well, I think it is an objectionable question,
too, but, unfortunately, Mr. Roberson, I asked the question
and opened the door. baer
Now, if there is any blame, it is going to be on the [73]
court.
You may answer.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Is it your understanding that Allegheny is not going
to sell you a confirmed. reservation unless it really has the
space to sell on the plane? A. Yes, that is my understand-
ing.
Q. And that is based on the advertisements and the image
that you have? A. As I understand their advertising and
literature, the meaning of it.
45
Q. Mr. Nader, you testified before that the rally was
scheduled for 12:00 o’clock? <A. Yes.
Q. What was the basis of your knowledge of that? A.
It was communicated to me that that was the time for
starting the rally from Connecticut.
Q. And who told you that? A. It was communcated to
me through Miss Colmore.
Q. And did you learn later that the time for the rally was
changed to 12:15? A. Yes, after the incidents involving
Allegheny’s overbooking.
Q. You learned it after? A. Yes.
[74] Do you know why it was changed? A. Yes, it was
changed in order to give the crowd time to leave their
jobs in nearby offices and assemble in the Plaza and in
order to have just a few minutes to meet with the staff
at the Plaza of the Connecticut Citizen Action Group.
Q. Now, in cross-examination you testified that the
crowd could not be expected to stay until 12:45 or 1:00
to await your arival. What is the basis for that testimony.
A. That this was an audience that was assembling on
their lunch hour, and that their lunch hour is between
12:00 and 1:00, and they have to get back to work.
You see, there are many office buildings sort of sur-
rounding this plaza, and they have to get back to work
at 1:00.
[75] Q. Well, did you learn how close the connection
had been in Philadlphia for those passengers? A. Yes,
I think Mr. Koskinen indicated that it was a very close
connection.
Q. In fact, two or three minutes’ connection? A. Yes.
Q. Was this a legal connection that was offered to you
in Philadelphia?
Mr. Roberson: If it please the Court, I object to that.
I don’t think it is material. He did not decline to go be-
cause he thought it was legal or illegal. He just thought
it was too close.
t: Well—
a + ene In trying to accommodate these people,
held up a flight. .
a & Court: I assume by ‘“‘legal,’? he means was it
scheduled to leave at the time stated. Is that what you
rf |
— itil Well, there are some connections that
connect properly be made, that cannot properly be booked,
by [76] an airline because the connection 1s too tight.
is called an illegal connection. ; Ree
"The Const: Oh, well, then, I will allow it. The objection
is overruled.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Do you know whether that was a legal —
that was offered to you or an illegal connection? A. -
the airlines consistently say there has to be 30 minu es
between connections for them to schedule a second air-
craft to take you to your further destination.
Q. Was this a legal connection that was offered to you,
or was it not? A. No, is was not.
[77] Q. Mr. Nader, you asked Mr. McDonald at the gate
whether he could find out and make an announcement on
the plane whether anyone would step down and volunteer
to take a later flight so that you could make your im-
portant engagement.
Q. Why did you do it this time? A. Because it was
an extraordinary situation, to reach a gathering that
could not be postponed.
Q. Did you explain that to the agent? A. Yes, I con-
veyed that meaning to the agent, and I think he under-
stood it. He just felt that it was beyond his capability to
do anything about it.
Q. tg asking the agent to kick off anyone from
the flight who had a confirmed reservation? A. No, I
47
was simply asking if anybody would volunteer to take a
later flight.
Q. And what led you to believe that somebody might
conceivably do this? A. Because I had been on airplanes
where this had been [78] done. For example, a Congress-
man wanted to get on an airplane in order to meet a
situation, or one person in a family of five, and the re-
quest is often made under such circumstances by the
hostesses whether anybody would be on a sufficiently
leisure schedule as to take a later plane.
Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, I object to this. It is
hearsay. I don’t know whether this has ever occurred or
not.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Do you know whether it has ever occurred, per-
sonally?
Mr. Roberson: Well, it has not occurred, so far as I
am concerned, on my airline, and I think it would be
hearsay.
The Court: If he knows whether it has occurred on
Allegheny, I will allow it. Otherwise, I will sustain the
objection. Do you know whether it has ever been done
on Allegheny.
The Witness: Yes, it has been done on Allegheny.
The Court: All right. And on this particular flight?
The Witness: No.
[79] The Court: Now, gentlemen, I note the hour is 12:10.
What can we accomplish before our luncheon recess? We
are nearing our luncheon recess, but, of course, as I told
you I believe on Friday, whenever it was that you were
here last, I must finish this trial today.
[82] Mr. Robertson: Well, we have tried to limit the case
that we are going to put on in front of Your Honor. Most
of our case was documentary. We had to prove Mr. Nader’s
damages and the fact of the occurrence.
[83] "We are not going to put on any other direct case,
Your Honor.
is i i t for—
The Court: This is your direct case excep
Mr. Robertson: Except for Mr. Barnes and Mr. Moffett
and the documentary evidence.
e e@ ea
i I assume, Mr.
96] The Court: All right. Well, then, may
se Ace you would at this time move into the record the
ition of Mr. Barnes?
a + ehestinien The deposition of Leslie 0. Barnes, yes,
The Court: All right. That will be received, Madam
(97] Clerk, as plaintiffs’ exhibit what?
The Clerk: Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 24.
The Court: All right.
(Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 24 received in evidence.)
[98] The Court: I promise you I will read the whole thing,
f it.
99) The Ouert: And I will do that. Now what else do you
to offer?
4 ‘Sete Well, we have nothing further on our
direct case.
Ss e e es 2 s e 2 S e@
[108] The Court: Let us set a date for Mr. Moffett’s
testimony. aad
The Clerk: Monday, the 10th, at two o’clock.
The Court: All right.
e e @ @ s ® @ S @ 6
Jerome E. Puisentruit
was called as a witness, and, having been first duly sworn,
was examined and testified as follows:
Direct Examination
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. You are Mr. Jerome F. Huisentruit? <A. Yes, sir.
Q. And what is your occupation? A. I am an attorney.
[109] Q. Are you employed by one employer, or do you
practice generally? A. I am employed by one employer.
I am assistant general counsel for the Air Transport Asso-
ciation of America, sir.
Q. And what is that? A. That is a trade association
representing the certificated, scheduled U. S. airlines.
Q. When did you graduate from law school? [110] A. In
June of 1957.
Q. From what law schocl? A. Georgetown University.
Q. And what employment did you thereafter have?
A. After I was admitted to the bar, later that year, I be-
came employed with the Civil Aeronautics Board in Febru-
ary of 1958, and remained there until] February of 1968,
eleven years, sir.
Q. In connection with your duties with the Civil Aero-
nautics Board, did you become familiar with the jurisdiction
of the board? A. Yes, I became thoroughly familiar with
the jurisdiction of the board, having worked within the
board in several divisions, including the Bureau of Air
Operations, the Agreements Division thereof, dealing with
Section 412 agreements, with control and interlocking rela-
tionships.
I then worked for over two years with the Bureau of
Enforcement dealing with the jurisdiction of the board, or
with the enforcement activities of the board, covering the
various requirements that they enforce.
For the greater part of my time with the board, one
in 1963 through 1968, or February of 1968, I worked wit
the Bureau of Economics in the Rates Division.
e e sd 6
nection with your work before the board,
a nein ta to do with efforts to apne ong ce
overbooking problems of the airlines and the no-s fie
cancellation problems that they were having? Did you
anything to do with that? A. Yes, I did. oe
Q. Has the board ever banned overbooking prac ~ Ae
the airlines? A. The board has not banned over s ing
practices by the airlines. The board has, to the = rat
recognized the necessity for overbooking in the c a
which the airlines operate and has sought to =
harmful effects which may in certain instances result from
overbooking. But ee itself, has not been pro-
ibi ime by the board.
“a Ee ae a +e the this to be the fact? [115] A. —
as I mentioned, I spent the greatest part of my — wi r
the Rates Division of the Civil Aeronautics “~ —
during my tenure there—I believe it was in 1965—the —
proposed a rule-making proceeding relating to overbo
ing, which would—
The Court: When was that?
The Witness: In 1965, initially.
: All right.
™ Winans I believe it was EDR 95. I am not certain
of the number. I believe that was the number.
: That is all right. —
= ng And, as a member of the Rates Division
legal staff, I worked on the proposal, as a ore tee
proposal, with the formulation and the recommendation ~
that proposal to the board, which, if I may continue, wou :
have—the basic provision of which would have require
that in cases of overbooking the carriers notify all passen-
gers on each flight 12 hours in advance that their particular
flight has been overbooked.
51
This was issued as a notice of proposed rule-making, and,
as a result thereof, the interested persons had an opportv-
nity to file comments.
Comments came in from many parties, including the air-
line industry.
I was the person on the rates staff who analyzed those
comments, re-evaluated them, and recommended a subse-
quent [116] rule-making proposal. I do not recall the
number.
Q. You recommended it to who? A. Within the board,
to the general counsel’s office. We did the—the Rates
Division legal staff did the work on that matter, since it
involved an area within our primary expertise. That pro-
posal was to susbtitute a new rule for the former one.
This came out in January of 1957, and essentially that
proposal would have recognized——
Q. 1957 or 1967? A. I am sorry. It was 1967.
Q. Yes. A. (Continuing previous answer)—would have
recognized the overbooking necessity within the industry;
would have not required the carriers to notify their pas-
sengers of an overbooking situation; but would have re-
quired that in the unfortunate event that overbookings
actually resulted in oversales, that adequate compensation
must be paid to those passengers who are denied boarding.
Q. Was it left at ‘‘adequate”’ or did they actually set up
a schedule? A. Well, they set up a schedule which many
thought was more than adequate, if you wish me to explain
the schedule. It was roughly 200 per cent of the first re-
maining flight coupon, with a minimum of $50 and a maxi-
mum of $200.
[117] Now, this would not be in lieu of the ticket which
was purchased. It would be a compensation. In other words,
if you had purchased a $50 ticket and were denied board-
ing, your ticket would still remain good, but you would get
200 per cent of that ticket, or $100, as compensation for the
inconvenience caused you in being denied boarding.
Q. Ultimately, was that cut down somewhat to what the
board thought would be adequate compensation? A. Yes,
it was. There were several problems presented to the board,
principally with relation to the smaller carriers. It was felt
that the minimum of $50 was too high, and the board cut
that down to $25. Also, the maximum remained the same
of $200, but the general compensation would have been
100 per cent, rather than 200 per cent of the flight coupon
because of arguments that were made that beyond that
would be a pure windfall and might lead to further abuses
by passengers in the reservation process.
Q. And it is based on that experience, and knowing what
the board did in that connection, that you say that they have
never banned overbooking, but, in fact, have recognized it
and provided, rather than banning it, that the carriers
tender this denied-boarding compensation in the event of an
oversale; is that the situation? A. That is absolutely the
situation.
Q. Did they say anything in addition that the carriers
would have to do with respect to deciding among several
passengers? [118] Suppose three of them showed up who
were oversold. Did they undertake to provide for which of
the passengers should be boarded in the case where some-
body should cancel out at the last second? A. They did not
prescribe any method by which the carriers would have to
choose between those who would be denied boarding. What
the board did prescribe, in recognition of its obligation as
a regulatory agency to prevent unjust discriminations,
preferences, or prejudices, was to require that each car-
rier maintain a manual setting forth the manner in which
it will exercise its denial of boarding to passengers.
The rules which it will exercise must be stated in the
manual, and that manual must be filed with the Civil Aero-
nautics Board.
Q. So those priority rules differ between various carriers,
do they? A. It was left to the individual carrier, and they
do it differently between carriers. That is correct.
Q. Now, suppose that a carrier has a priority regulation
which it promulgates. Does the court in a civil action have
primary jurisdiction, or does the CAB, as to the reasonable-
ness of that rule, as distinguished from whether or not it
was violated? A. The question of reasonableness of that
rule, as would be true of any tariff rule or rule relating or
applicable to passengers and their transportation, would be
@ question under the primary jurisdiction of the Civil Aero-
nautics Board [119] or other utility that may regulate
that mode of transportation.
Q. Now, then, the documents that would reflect the board’s
policy decision with respect to overbooking, would that be
CAB economics regulation—let me show you.
a — I —— even go through this formality,
r Honor, because ther jecti
jh pen ha ere was no objection to these par-
I want Defendant’s D and E. These I wish to be offered
in evidence and received in evidence at this time.
The Court: There being no objection, they will be received.
(Defendant’s Exhibits D and E received in evidence
respectively.)
[120] Mr. Robertson: Your Honor, the entire document
will be in the record, am I correct?
The Court: Yes.
[121] Mr. Roberson: The first extract from this document,
dated January 10, 1967, is from this Notice of Proposed
Rule-Making in which the CAB recites the problem and its
tentative views.
From page 2 of that there is a recitation about the car-
riers’ view that they should not be required, when they have
an overbooking situation, to call up the passengers 12 hours
in advance. I want to read that extract.
‘‘The carriers unanimously oppose the rule proposed in
EDR-95, particularly the provisions of the new Part 250
54
requiring a notice to passengers of an overbooked condi-
M4 9?
Going over to page 2, in the second paragraph: ie
‘‘The oversales problem, therefore, is a severe ain
causes distress, inconvenience and damage to —
It impairs the public image of air carriers, — —
the integrity of their reservations practices. 7 — pote
incumbent on the board and the carriers to do . pe
their powers to eliminate oversales [quote] to the t
feasible [close quote].’’
* @ e@ 6 -_ * 6 8 &
[122] Mr. Roberson: Obviously, it is for the ——
illustrating what the witness has said: that they ha
banned it. They have not —
next page, page o:
= ene a pool gti st and other a
the board has tentatively determined not to finalize ~ - ;
Rather, we propose to deal with the oversale problem by
eans for the following reasons:
- Hl "The proposed notice requirement of EDR-95 em
have necessitated substantial changes in the oy yi -
practices and systems of carriers, and the as . yes
pared to require such change in a system whie ~~
balance worked reasonably well in the public interes ?
‘69. Various methods are available to the carriers to re-
duce the dimensions of the oversales problem by ee te or
curtailing certain aspects of their reservations ar ices. :
‘63. Finally, the board believes the oversales problem ca
be substantially reduced by proposals herein to require
carriers (a) to make prompt, effective, and adequate od
pensation to oversold passengers, (b) to establish — /
rules for determining which passengers holding =
reserved space shall be denied boarding on oversold flig s,
and (c) to file reports of unaccommodated =
The next thing I wish to read is from page 4, Your oye
[123] The Court: Let us assume that all of Exhibit D is
in the record. Do you still insist on reading them all?
Mr. Roberson: I do not insist.
The Court: I will read them. I will read them, Mr.
Roberson.
Mr. Roberson : Very well, sir.
[124] Cross-Examination
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Where did you attend law school, sir? A. George-
town Law School.
Q. And what was your area of specialization? A. I
specialized in administrative law in obtaining my Master’s
Degree in 1960, but in my undergraduate work I took the
general curriculum. Most of my courses were prescribed,
rather than electives.
Q. What was your employment after law school? A.
My sole employment after law school—in the legal field, I
assume you are asking me, because I was working between
[125] the period that I got my law degree and when I
passed the bar in a non-legal position.
But my sole employment in the field of law was with
the Civil Aeronautics Board, starting in February of 1958,
until February of 1968, as I mentioned, and then I was
employed by the Air Transport Association since that
time to the present.
Q. Have you ever worked for an airline? A. T have not
worked for an airline at any time.
The Court: You mean directly?
Mr. Robertson: Yes.
The Witness: That is correct.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Now, have you written any scholarly articles? A.
I don’t know whether I would call them ‘*scholarly’’, I
have written many memoranda while | was with the Civil
Aeronautics Board on regulatory problems within the
agency and within the jurisdiction of the agency which——
Q. They were not published? A. (Continuing )——have
not been published. No, they have not been published. I
have also written about six or eight papers which were as
part of my Master’s Degree at Georgetown University,
and which were not published, but were part of the degree
requirements.
Q. Have you made any study of the actual overbooking
practices of United Airlines?
[126] A. I have not.
Q. Have you made any study of the actual practices of
American in this regard?
A. Not that airline, nor any other airline, I might add.
Q. Well, do you know specifically what the overbooking
practices of these airlines are? A. I know that the prac-
tice which I became familiar with in my regulatory posi-
tion with the Civil Aeronautics Board, as represented to
us at that time, was that an analysis is made of a market,
that is, Points A and B, by each carrier. Based upon the
no-show and the late-cancellation experience in that par-
ticular market, a statistical analysis is made that there
will be ‘‘X’’ empty seats on the airplane, even if they book
it 100 per cent.
Q. Well, now—— A. On that basis the carriers book
‘‘X’’? number of seats more than they have in inventory
to compensate for the number of [127] no-shows and the
late cancellations.
Q. And you did that work and you learned that when?
A. This was in 1965—during the period of 1965 through
1967, during the rule-making proceeding.
Q. All right. So we are talking about—— A. I did not
get into the statistical exercise, mind you. I am just speak-
ing of the theory or the practice that was represented to
the board as having been done by the airlines.
Q. Six or eight years ago? A. That is correct.
57
Q. But you do not know what the i
practices are tod
bar ee A. Not personally. On hearsay, I do. a
e Court: Do you have any evidence that th
changed from when he testified? oo
Mr. Robertson: Yes, Your Honor.
The Court: You do?
Mr. Robertson: Yes.
The Court: Are you going to present that?
Mr. Robertson: Yes, Your Honor.
The Court: All right.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Were you an expert on these practices or their eco-
nomic necessity? A. I would consider myself an expert
- — "* to [128] the extent that any experts exist, at
east as the situation existed in th i '
inn e middle 1960’s and
Q. You are an expert on the economic aspects and the
ox aspects? <A. Yes, I think so.
. What is that expertise based on? A i
. My expertise
is based on the fact that I worked in the area of rate-mak-
ing and was familiar with the economic condition of the
carriers individually and as an industry. ;
I also worked in that rate area on tariff rules. I was
familiar with the problems with respect to no-shows. I was
familiar in my regulatory capacity with the attempts of
. carriers to have no-show penalties.
was counsel in a case involving the Puerto Ri
ico market
where an effort was made to alleviate the no-show problem
by forfeiture of the ticket, for example. This is a case of
record, I don’t have the citations.
Q. Well, I understand that you were an attorney in these
— a = that make you an economic expert? A. To
e extent that there are economic expert
myself out as one. sia iahiie ian
Q. Have you ever qualified as an ex i
| pert witness on these
matters? A. Today is the first time I have testified in any
proceeding with respect to this matter, Ep on i
i rd, an wo
as [129] adviser to the board, a
ace te would value by judgment as an expert during my
ith the board.
"9 Did you know approximately how many people were
actually denied boarding on domestic U. S. flights in 1970?
a Yea " In 1970 I did not keep up with the ar
changes in the overbooking problems since I soya ry °
Q. Is your answer no, that you do not know .
me "i ou know how many people were denied boarding
=®. S etal flights in 1971? A. I saw pce
I don’t recall them. I believe that the penne a .4 P
lishes them every so often. I don’t recall ved red se
Q. Do you know what they are so far as 1972 is “oun “~
sirf A. I can tell you what the industry averag
10,000. I can’t give you the total picture, no.
Q. You can’t give me the total? A. No. cai
Q. Well, is it accurate if I said that almost a qu
i i flights for which
ili eople were denied boarding on
oor ta inal reservations during these three years?
Mr. Roberson: May it please the Sat tale
he Witness: I have no way of kn b
i“ aeoen: May it please the court, I would object
; t is the very point. 2
5 oe baoan problem. It is not something that he testi
fied about on direct examination. His testimony panne
the CAB has made a policy decision not to ban overbook-
i is all he has testified about. .
ge ny don’t think that, therefore, becomes material, as
her 10,000 or 1000. tle
"me denies The objection is overruled. I think it comes
within the scope of the direct.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Are you familiar with the CAB actions — e-
the area of denied-boarding compensation and oversales
A. What period are you speaking of?
Q. Well, say, in the last three years, A. J am not deeply
familiar with those actions. I have not continued my——
Q. So if the CAB has changed the rules since you were
there seven or eight years ago, they might have done that
for all you know, right? A. J believe they have made some
changes, but I am not an expert as to what changes were
made after I left the board.
Q. You are not an expert as to what has happened in the
six or eight years—in the six years since you have left the
[131] board? <A. That is correct.
[134] Q. To whom do you report at the ATA, that is, the
Air Transport Association? <A. Right. Principally to Mr.
James Landry, who is general counsel of ATA.
Q. And to whom does he report? A. He reports to either
the president of ATA, Mr. Paul Ignatius, or to the chair-
man of the board, Mr. Tipton.
Q. And to whom is the staff ultimately responsible?
[135] A. The staff ultimately is responsible to the board
of directors of the Air Transport Association, which con-
sists of the presidents of the airlines,
Q. Who is Leslie Barnes? A. Mr. Barnes is president
of Allegheny Airlines,
Q. And is he a member of the ATA board? A. I believe
he is. I am not certain.
Q. Is he active on any of the committees of the ATA?
A. I have never met the man. I am not familiar with him
personally at all, except that he is the president of Alle-
gheny Airlines,
Q. How are the ATA’s expenses paid? A. By the
membership on a dues formula.
Q. And does Allegheny pay part of that? <A. Yes, in-
deed.
Q. Yes. A. I do not know for certain. I believe they
do. They represented to the board at the time I was there,
and working on [136] the problem, that they did, yes.
Q. How is the public informed of this? A. Well, I
assume, No. 1, that—well, I don’t assume, I know.
No. 1, all the matters that were involved in rule-making
becomes public documents and these are open to the public
at large.
Q. Well, do you know whether the airlines tell the pas-
sengers specifically about this practice? A. The over-
booking practice?
Q. Yes. A. Well, I would say, on the basis of their
representations in 1965, they did not want to advise the
passengers that they were overbooked, because this would
needlessly alarm them, on which the CAB agreed with
them.
I would say that they do not notify that they are over-
booked, sir.
Q. Is the overbooking practice and the circumstances
set forth in the airlines’ tariffs? A. Certain aspects of
_well I don’t know them. If I would answer you correctly,
I would say that—
The Court: Well, is it, or is it not, set forth in the tariffs,
the overbooking practices?
The Witness: The oversale compensation is.
The Court: The overbooking compensation practices?
[137] The Witness: Yes, the rules with respect to com-
pensation are set out in the tariff, itself.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Well, the compensation is available in many circum-
stances where an oversale has not necessarily occurred—
strik > that.
Isn’t it accurate that compensation applies to broader
circumstances than just an intentional overbooking? A.
It applies to all cases of denied boarding.
Q. Which may be because in certain cases of an equip-
ment substitution? A. If I am not mistaken, I believe
61
that a substitution of i i
equipment is an excepti
“? ao compensation rule. petirsaphies
. That exception is set forth i
! in th i
forth in that rule, Part 250. ean arena
Q. Or an unintentional error
that someone may have
—_ , yo tingeere 4 or mistakenly confirming a ntsc
” ‘ .
a r whatever reason the denied boarding may
Q) . A. I l l p
, °
Q. But that would be one of ,
A. Pardon? e of the circumstances, right?
Q. That would be one of the circumstances in whieh
[138] denied-boarding compensation could be paid
suant to this tariff, right? A. That is correct eee
Q. So the fact that a tariff exists that relates to a va-
riety of circumstances under which you are going to get
some compensation, that tariff does not tell the caeetine
that there is an intentional overbooking practice in th
airlines, does it, sir? A. It does not. :
Q. Okay.
The Court: Now, let me ask you a question:
You said a moment ago, at the time you were with the
board, all of the members of the ATA who intentional]
sold more tickets than they had seats did not inform the
public. Wasn’t that your testimony? ;
The Witness: That is correct.
The Court: Is that still true today?
The Witness: I don’t know. I believe it is
The Court: All right. )
The Witness: This was the proposal, Your Honor, in
EDR-95, to require them to inform the public
The Court: You believe this is true today
The Witness: I believe it is true today.
. The Court: Could I rely on that as a fact?
The Witness: I think you can, Your Honor
[139] The Court: All right,
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. You are an expert on the existing tariffs, right? A.
On tariffs which are filed today?
Q. Yes. Yes. A. I am an expert on the law of tariffs
and on the particular tariffs as they existed when I was
with the board, but in my duties within the Air Transport
Association I have not worked with individual carrier
tariffs.
Q. Well, let me ask you about an industry-wide tariff.
A. Okay.
Q. What is CAB Tariff 142? A. That sounds like a
rules tariff. Isn’t that the passenger rules tariff?
Q. That is my understanding. A. Yes.
Q. Are you familiar with Rule 66 in that tariff? A. Not
by number. If you give me something other than the num-
ber, I may be.
Q. Well, have you ever heard of a conditional reserva-
tion? A. Yes, indeed, I have.
Q. Well, when was this put into effect? A. This is a
proposal of Eastern Airlines. I believe the year was—it
was within the last two years, was it not?
[140] Was it approved by the CAB? A. Yes, it was.
Q. And what was the basis of the CAB’s approval of
this tariff. A. I don’t know.
Q. Are all tariffs approved by the CAB A. Well, the
use of the word—I have to give a little narrative explana-
tion.
Q. Fine. Go ahead. A. We use the word ‘‘approved’’
rather loosely. What actually happens is that the carriers
are required to file a tariff thirty days, at a minimum, in
advance of the proposed effective date.
If the board does nothing to that tariff during that 30-
day waiting period, it goes into effect.
Now, then, we call that: the board has approved it.
Actually, in certain cases it may not even have looked at
it or have analyzed it at all.
The Court: In those situations it would de where there
was no objection?
The Witness: Absolutel i
: y. If the jecti
board must look at a tariff. —— ne
Pen Court: But, generally, if a tariff does not go into
e ~ without objection during the 30-day period after it
“4 ee ror “~ because somebody objected and, there-
. e the board’s attenti it; isn’t th
ns dre 1on to it; isn’t that the
: The Witness: It works that way most times, Your Honor
a the board ’s staff in the Rates Division, at least while
- there, did a fairly careful job of screening tariffs
on their own motion and bringing problems to the atten-
tion of the board, e .
siolate, d, even though there were no public com-
The Court: I see. All right.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. But you do not know whether
’ er they are sti i
“- or not? A. (No response) J =
. Do you know? A. Well, si
: , Since the same ulti
ol works there who did when I was there T err
Say they do on that basis. Becau is 1
ne Pr Alert se that was his idea of
Q. But, in reality, an airline co
» In reality, ai uld file any sort of pro-
posed rule in its tariffs, and, unless it was challenged
eg by the staff or by another party, it would go into
e ect, is that right? A. If nobody challenged it, it would
go into effect. That is correct. )
Q. ot A. By “‘nobody.”’ I mean including the board.
. Q. Now, this conditional reservation that was introduced
y Eastern Airlines, what did this provide for? [142]
“‘. can tell you in general terms.
. Well, tell me as much as i
’ you know ab
much as I know about it. some ae aS
; Q. Yes. A. And I must say that I got most of this
rom newspaper readings and trade press readings my-
self, since I am not personal] pa
} —- - y familiar with, ’
worked with, individual carrier tariffs. a
Mr. Roberson: Just a minute. Your Honor, I object
this. I think we are going further afield. The stan in
this case is not whether there is some other supplementary
way to attack or ameliorate the no-show = _
The question is whether or not the board has bann
i the board has not banned it. 7
ay fact that they let Eastern Airlines experiment
for a short time on some kind of conditional reservation
i in this case.
have no probative value in t
“ court, in other words, with all — ase ag
i ll, althoug e
court would not sit here and say, we —
have overbooking, this cour de
pig eh gle ditional reservation
because you can have some con :
pa which would have some effect on no-shows, there
ilies anybody that doesn’t have the spn
i oa
i is violating the law, and I am going to
ay ip Athos because this airline or that airline has
° it. . . . . .
18) hat is the very point of primary jurisdiction. a
the fact that there are other approaches or supplemen a
approaches, which is what conditional reservation was, 1S
J . .
fore, irrelevant in this case.
"he here the evidence is undisputed that the a
has not banned overbooking, the airlines overbooking
a tes opted for requiring the airlines to tender
deferred-boarding compensation to rend pment pas-
id, ‘‘You must never ;
senger. They have not said, a a
They have said, ‘‘If you do, you m
dusted beneiien compensation, and you must advise =
of their rights at the time about denied-boarding compe
sation, and you must file a list of your oversales every
' with the board.” |
—*} pecs have not said, ‘‘You can’t do any —.
And, therefore, I think we are chasing —— a = pam
ing } yhether or not there
hen we are looking into whe |
an things that would help with respect to the oversale
problem.
The Court: What do you say to that?
Mr. Robertson: Well, Your Honor, we are investigating
what the CAB has done, I think, precisely, and that is
what I am trying to ask this witness.
Furthermore, as I understand the contention of the
defendant Allegheny, it is that they concede that the CAB
has [144] urged the carriers to do everything feasible,
everything in their power, to eliminate overbooking.
I think that is in the opinion that has been introduced
into the record here, and I think that is just what I am
trying to explore with this witness.
The Court: How long will this take?
Mr. Robertson: Another five minutes on this, Your
Honor. This is a very important point, though, what op-
tions are available and what options are now available to
the carrier and whether this is really an economic neces-
sity or whethe it is something less desirable.
The Court: All right. Well, I am inclined to agree with
Mr. Roberson, but I will try to keep an open mind and
give it such weight as the court feels it is entitled to re-
ceive, in view of the issues in the case and in view of the
fact that the court is sitting without a jury.
Mr. Robertson: Well, I understand, Your Honor, that
the defendant is arguing that this practice of selling more
seats than they have available on a flight is an economic
necessity, and I intend to show that it is not.
The Court: All right. You may proceed.
[145] By Mr. Robertson:
Q. It is a fact, is it not, that least three other carriers
besides Eastern have now instituted the conditional reser-
vation tariff? A. I do not know.
Q. Do you know, or are you aware of the fact that the
conditional reservation has now been extended for an
additional two years until 1975? A. I do not.
66
Q. You did not know that? A. No.
[150] By Mr. Robertson:
i i ights an economic
_In what respect is overselling flig
B45 for an airline? A. May I have the question read
back?
The Witness: Well, overselling flights is not an cconounie
necessity. You used the word ‘‘overselling”’ and not over-
booking’. I assume you are using that distinction in-
tentionally. a
By Mr. Robertson: Pile af
[151] 0. I am not aware of a distinction. A. Well, an
overbooking relates to the practice in the reservation sys-
tem of placing—of accepting more reservations than you
have seats in inventory. .
But if the system works at all, there are very few, if any,
ge question related to oversales and not to over-
ary a there are no oversales, as distinguished from
overbooking, is because the overbooking process takes into
consideration the fact, No. 1, that, unfortunately, many
members of the public make multiple reservations, ae
the intention of using only one of several reservations, an
ering to cancel the others.
— 1 am cancellations come at the last hour, and no
more requests for reservations or few would come —
that period. But if you had turned away previous requests,
you would have no manner of retrieving them. as
So, ideally, overbooking should result in very few.
relation to the universe that you are working with, very few
oversales.
And your question was related to oversales.
Oversales, itself, is not an economic necessity. Oversales
is an economic detriment. It is unfortunate when it happens,
67
and I am sure the carriers feel that way, too. Because the
[152] carriers are penalized, and penalized severely, for
that oversale to the tune of 100 per cent of the face
amount of the ticket, in addition the value of the ticket.
If the carriers intentionally engage in overselling, they
would go bankrupt very shortly by the simple laws of
economics, sir.
Q. So, in other words, the amount of overbooking that
occurs is much greater than the amount of oversales that
result? A. My goodness, yes.
Q. So that in a given period of time, if they oversell a
quarter of a million people, in that same given period of
time they might have overbooked four or five times as many,
is that right? A. Yes. And that is ihe whole justification
for overbooking, because yon—
The Court: What is the difference again between an
“‘oversale’’ and an ‘‘overbooking’’?
The Witness: Your Honor, overbooking is a statistical
exercise in which you accept reservations. Let us say you
have 100 seats. Now, you may realize on the basis of your
past experience that in this particular market, if you have
100 reservations, only 70 of those passengers wil] show up.
I am giving you a typical example.
The Court: Yes.
The Witness: Well, in that case you would overbook
[153] that flight by perhaps 25 seats to take into account
the fact that 30 of those reservations are bad reservations
from the public’s point of view. They are not going to show
up for the flight, and they are not going to bother to cancel
the flight, or cancel the reservation.
The reason you do that, No. 1, is economically for your-
self; but, more importantly, from the board’s standpoint,
when I was there at least, we took into consideration the
fact you are accommodating these 25 people, to whom, if
you did not overbook, you would just say, ‘‘No, I am sorry.
We are full. You cannot make a reservation.”
They would sit home, and your plane would take off with
95 or 30 empty seats.
That is really, from the Civil Aeronautics standpoint, one
of the primary justification for overbooking. It is an accom-
modation of the public because of the careless habits of
other members of the public in holding seats which they will
not use.
But the oversale occurs in that unfortunate case where
either your statistical analysis is in error, but even by the
law of average sometimes things are a little higher and
sometimes things are lower.
There may be one or two passengers for particular flights
in rare instances who exceed the capacity of the airplane,
and that is when you have an oversale: when you must
deny a [154] passenger with a confirmed reservation a
seat on the aircraft.
The Court: If I have learned anything from this case,
I have learned that if you have to be at a meeting or have
to be at any one point or place in the country or the world,
where the airline is under the jurisdiction of the CAB, you
had better jolly well take a week in advance to get there, to
make sure you are going to make it.
The Witness: I am sorry, but I can’t agree with you,
Your Honor.
The Court: The remedy, it seems to me, if it is over-
booked or oversold, is set forth in the tariff, according to
your testimony.
The Witness: Yes, sir.
The Court: And that may be a wholly inadequate remedy.
The Witness: Well, the fact is that such a small per-
centage—
The Court: That does not go to the problem of the im-
portance of an individual being a certain place in point of
time.
Suppose I have to give a speech, as I do, in Ohio at the
end of this week and I do not get there because of over-
booking. The fact that the tariff provides me with a remedy
9
= wes plus 100 per cent of the face value of the ticket, or
atever it is, is not going to compensate me for my lack of
presence [155] at this meeting, or a number of others ©
that I have to go to next month.
er Witness : But if that particular carrier had not en-
~ — gg they may not have given you a
rvation in the first place. Y i y ;
reef ~ Ai ou might have stayed at
= Court: That is not in accord with what the Civil
eronautics Board approves as a matter of policy. Th
can still overbook. ee
ns Brey preronn I i for all three of these trips, still
’ e worth a darn wh
te: Mary sl en I get to the airport and
The Witness: I would suggest, Your Honor, that if you
are there within a reasonable ti
me bef
you would be accommodated. ore Might departure,
In most cases the way—
Pncad vey Well, the implication is left from the testi-
ntti A or = today that if you get there a half
e flight time—that i irli
in ee at is what the airlines normally
The Witness: Well, we would li
: ' k
an hour before flight time. << mc meer
bo ae . stg eg is what they tell us, as I recall it
b ertson: There i i i 'g
ne aoe ne 1s no requirement in Allegheny’s
Ppp wy All right, but generally speaking, they do
a — “te a arrive there before the flight leaves.
certain security ae as oe ..
= spect to luggage, et
The Court: All right. But that does not mean that my
ticket is going to be hono
" red, or tha : :
going to be honored at all, dees it? 5 my seservetion fe
70
The Witness: Well, statistically it means that it will
99.999999—I don’t know how far you want to run it out—
per cent of the time.
. . ° . se
° ° °
The Court: I hope so.
By Mr. Robertson:
very airline free to file its own tariffs concerning
stots practices “—— the parameters set by this
ied-boarding rule? A. Yes.
ety Q. These are not fixed by the CAB? A. That is
em in fact, when the CAB passed this rule that you
have been testifying about, didn t they say that they =
going to decline to exercise jurisdiction to ear a
reservations practices? A. I don’t think they said it qu
icitly.
“- 7. an is what they were doing, isn’t it? ae
said they wished to permit each carrier maximum aa i e
in setting forth its own priority rules, but I think t : 0a ;
made very clear in that rule that it was going to ref
top of these rules, because it is responsible for unjust dis-
crimination, preference, and prejudice, and within its gah
latory function it would be governing the rules in
"ee ’* the upshot of what the board said, though,
that it was going to take a hands-off position so far ri =
erning the reservations practices was concerned? A. :
in that broad language. I could not accept that, because the
board said it is going to stand over these things and sa
cise its regulatory functions, if there were any ng
abuse, discrimination, preference, ty rg That is the
in requiring them to be filed. '
“t tks tr ta er Pon direct itself to PA
the jurisdiction of other bodies, such as the courts, to <a
with these problems of discrimination? [158] A. The
fact that the board regulated in that area, I would say yes.
71
Q. And has any court held to the contrary? <A. The con-
trary to what?
Q. To your testimony.
The Court: That the board has the sole and exclusive
jurisdiction to regulate disputes such as the one we have
here.
The Witness: I don’t know of any court having held to
the contrary. I would be most surprised, in view of the law
of primary jurisdiction, if any had.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Well, you are an expert on the jurisdiction of the
CAB in this issue? <A. Yes.
Q. Are you familiar with the Archibald ease, Archibald
v. Pan American World Airways? A. No, I am not familiar
with that particular case.
Q. Since 1971, have the air carriers conducted any meet-
ings among themselves on a periodic basis to deal with this
group of problems? A. Not to my knowledge.
[159] By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Did the CAB in its order, or in its regulations that
are now in effect, or have ever been in effect, seek to bar
means of judicial redress for denied boarding?
Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, those speak for themselves.
They are in evidence, Exhibits D and E.
The Court: Overruled.
The Witness: I think what the board did, in its initial
regulation, at least, is set out a means of compensation
which the carrier would be required to tender to the pas-
senger as liquidated damages, and which the passenger was
free to accept or not.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. That is right. And didn’t the board expressly provide
that the remedy is not non-exclusive, and the passenger
has option of undertaking litigation to achieve redress?
72
A. Well, with respect to the question of damages, com-
atory damages—
“— po ns the question I asked, please. A. I can’t an-
swer your question that broadly. Assuming that you are
attacking the reasonableness of the program, I would have
to disagree with you. -
What the board did in its penalty provisions or compen-
sation provisions is state:
This should more than adequately cover the damages to
an [160] individual for his inconvenience in being over-
sold. You must, Airline, offer this to the oversold passen-
ger, so that he does not have to bother with litigation.
The individual passenger is free, if he wishes, if his com-
pensatory damages exceed the damages stated in the tariff,
to seek his damages by litigation. But that does not *-
compass the attack on the reasonableness of the board’s
rule, itself, that is, on the question of—
Q. That is another question, but my question does not
reach that. My question is simply:
Does the board’s regulation say that passengers are eX-
cluded from going to court if they are denied boarding?
A. I think I answered that: No, not on the question of
damages.
Q. In fact, it contemplates that the passenger has an
option? A. To accept the money, or if he thinks his dam-
ages were greater than that—
. That is right, or to— |
» Tip -setind Let the witness finish his answer, Mr. Robert-
son.
Mr. Robertson: Oh, certainly, Your Honor. I am sorry.
The Witness: If he thinks his damages were greater
than that, he can go to court.
[161] By Mr. Robertson:
Q. If the passenger thinks his damages are greater than
that provided in the tariff, he can go to court, is that
right, sir? A. If his actual damages are greater than the
73
board has prescribed, he can go to court. That is correct.
The Court: This court, is that correct?
The Witness: Yes, that is my view.
The Witness: Your Honor, I want my last answer to be
clear. He can go to court on a question of damages. I did
not mean that he could go to court challenging the reason-
ableness of what the CAB has done.
The Court: Right.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. When an airline bumps a passenger because of an
oversale, does not the CAB provide that he has 90 days to
claim denied-boarding compensation?
[162] The Witness: I don’t know what the rule is today.
I recall that the carrier must that very day that the passen-
ger is denied boarding offer him the compensation.
At the time I worked with the rule, the passenger had
30 days in which to accept that voucher and endorse it. That
is the time period that I am familiar with. I don’t think
your question addressed that. I am not familiar with your
question.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. My question did not address whether he has 30 days
or 60 days to cash the check. My question is:
Has not the CAB said that the passenger has 90 days in
case he is not given the denied-boarding compensation, or
whatever he is entitled to after being bumped off a flight,
90 days to make a claim? A. I don’t think the CAB—the
carriers may have filed something in their tariffs with re-
spect to the time limitation rules, but I am not familiar with
that.
Ordinarily, the time limit for an individual bringing an
action against an airline for a loss or damage claim is
74
specific in the carrier’s tariffs. So I am not familiar with
that provision.
e a e . = @ *
[165] By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Are you familiar with something known as the Con-
sumer’s Guide that has been put out by the Civil Aero-
nautics Board? A. I am aware that such a guide wr
been put out, and this purports to be a reproduction 0
that guide.
Q. ‘ie well. Would you turn to page 2, please? A. Yes,
ir.
: Q. Do you see an item with Caption No. 2? A. Yes. :
Q. Would you read the caption there? A. ‘*Denie
ding Compensation.’’
“ And nebien read the—in the center of the column,
the third paragraph from the bottom under that caption?
A. The part that you have marked in oe
. Yes, sir. A. The whole paragrap a
4 Yes sir. A. ‘‘CAB regulations state that the airline
must pay you the money for denied-boarding compensation
within 24 hours. If you have not received the payment
within that period of time [within the 24-hour period], you
have 90 days to file a claim. The airline is required to keep
ticket records only three months, and if you delay, you may
t get the money due you.’’
ery Does that refresh your recollection about what amount
[166] of time is provided for making a claim after denied
boarding? A. No, it does not.
Mr. Roberson: Your Honor— -
The Court: He has already answered. ,
Mr. Roberson: We tendered him the denied-boarding
compensation, so there was no question of the 90 days.
Mr. Robertson: I have no more questions. F
75
[167] (Defendant’s Exhibits A, B, C, F, G, and H received
in evidence, respectively.)
[168] The Court: Do you want this list and the descrip-
tion as part of the record?
Mr. Roberson: I have just submitted that pursuant to
Your Honor’s pre-trial rule. I don’t know what Your
Honor wanted with that, but Your Honor specified
The Court: All right. It will be received as part of the
record in evidence in this case, along with the exhibits,
[169] themselves.
The Court: And so will the plaintiffs’ list.
Mr. Robertson: Yes. Your Honor, it is understood, I
assume, that the characterizations as to what the evidence
shows are purely that of counsel. Those are the conten-
tions made by the parties.
The Court: Obviously.
[170] Mr. Roberson: Your Honor, Exhibit C is two
pages from the Allegheny Passenger Service Manual. They
are needed in connection with the testimony of the next
witness.
The Court: All right.
Mr. Roberson: The first one, Exhibit C, tells what an
oversale is. It says: ‘‘An oversale is a passenger who
holds a confirmed ticket for a flight and who checks in for
the flight (this means appearing at our local ticket lift
point before the scheduled departure time), but who can-
not be accommodated on that flight because of insufficient
seats, or seats being blocked. Give every oversold passen-
ger Form SS-112.’’
On the next page I call Your Honor’s attention to para-
graph 5, where it says—this is in the procedure for what
you do when you have an oversale, priorities—it says:
‘“‘If the oversale is not known until the flight is being
boarded (this applies particularly where gate check-in is
used), the last passenger to arrive at the gate is the over-
sale and is not permitted to board. Selection is automatic.
Do not delay the flight seeking a passenger who would be
least inconvenienced.’’
Those two things have to do with Mr. John McDonald.
Would you call him in, please. He is the customer repre-
sentative who talked with Mr. Nader at the gate.
[171] John McDonald
was called as a witness, and, having been first duly
sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
Direct Examination
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Your name is John McDonald? A. That is correct,
sir.
Q. And what is your residence address, sir? A. 8 South
Ingram Street, Alexandria, Virginia.
Q. What is your occupation, Mr. McDonald? A. I am
a passenger service representative for Allegheny Airlines.
Q. At what airport? A. At Washington National Air-
port.
@ s se 6 e * 6 e > .
[172] Q. What are the duties of a passenger service
representative, just briefly, with Allegheny? A. I would
be supervising the ticket counter and gate operations and
giving information to all the passengers that travel with
us, helping with children, and so forth.
Q. Were you on duty at Washington National Airport
on the 28th of April, 1972, when Flight 864 was supposed
to depart? A. Yes, I was, sir.
77
Q. What time was it scheduled to depart? A. 10:15 a.m.
Q. And what time were passengers allowed to start
boarding on that flight? A. Approximately 10:05 that
morning.
Q. How many passengers were boarded on it? A. 100.
Q. About how long did it take to board that 100 pas-
sengers? A. Five to ten minutes.
Q. What time had your gate area opened down there
posse a could begin checking in, as distinguished
rom actually getting on the plane? A. A i
7 peg p pproximately
Q. What did you say the flight capacity was of thi
ticular airplane? <A. 100. are _—
[173] Q. And by what time had you fully filled up that
plane? A. Approximately 10:15—I am sorry, 10:10.
Q. Did anything out of the ordinary occur immediately
thereafter, after the flight was fully boarded? A. Yes.
We had passengers with confirmed tickets at the boarding
area after we boarded 100 people.
Q. All right. Then, after you boarded 100 people, did
anyone else show up? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you, afterwards, learn the name of the passenger
that first showed up, after you had boarded 100 people?
A. I believe it was a Mr. Koskinen.
Q. Was there also another young man that arrived at
or about the time of Mr. Koskinen that had to be denied
boarding, also? A. Yes, there was,
[174] Q. You did fill out a passenger denied-boarding
slip with respect to the passengers that were denied board-
ing, did you not? A. Yes, I did.
Q. And that would give his name? A. Yes, it would.
Q. What are you required to do when you have an over-
sale, that is, when somebody shows up after the flight is
i rs? A. My
fully boarded with confirmed passenge
— aiuiine would be to advise the passenger or
rene and find another means of transportation to ge
i as soon as possible.
"a = have to make out any report forms os your
(175] organization? A. Yes, there is a stan rdized
form used when a passenger is denied boarding. len
"Q Did you start filling out those fotms for Mr.
nen and the other man? A. Immediately. aa
Q. Did you complete those before a third sce
up? A. I completed the first, and I was half way
form.
“. aan occurred then? A. Then Mr. Nader came
ranni the hallway.
OS up ie was running. Do you know that he was
running or was he walking? A. Yes, he was a ,
Q Did you see him, or how do you know og :
caught a glimpse of him coming down the hallway ug
*"Q ‘we nae ‘oan it when he arrived at the ticket lift
iti A. At least 10:15.
ror where you were working? A. I was there
time, yes, sir. at ;
"1 hy ré wd desk were you working in — —
filling out these denied-boarding — on b “sagt Sm
i iti ilable at the .
two check-in positions availa Bara porns om
the denied boarding occurred, I m -
right-hand side in order to let the agent complete her writ
ing, her paper work.
ing i i ith Mr. Pulzur
. Did you do anything in connection wi
a te Koskinen with respect to seeing pag we by of a
ho had been boarded were properly q
- you could take somebody hy a prenyh st
ked thro the tickets, an
ech gh vee or white-listed passengers boarded.
The Court: That is, who had previously been boarded
prior to the time you were looking?
The Witness: Correct, sir.
The Court: And was that situation prior to 10:10 on
this particular day in question?
The Witness: Approximately 10:10.
The Court: All right.
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Then, when Mr. Nader came up, did he, too, have a
confirmed ticket, an okayed ticket? A. Yes, he did.
[177] Q. What did you do with respect to Mr. Nader?
A. I advised him of the situation: that he would be denied
boarding.
Q. What is a tare and balance sheet, a weight and tare
sheet? A. A weight and balance tare sheet is what we
call it.
Q. All right. A. It is a standardized form used to show
the weight of the passengers, fuel, cargo, and where it is
all located on board the aircraft.
Q. Does it have anything to do with the safety of the
aircraft? A. Yes, it does.
.Q. What is the connection? A. To make sure that the
flight is not overweight or unbalanced. y
Q. When is it sent out to the plane? A. Just before
departure time.
Q. Had you sent that out by the time Mr. N ader arrived?
A. Yes, that was already on its way out to the airplane,
sir.
Q. And did you offer these gentlemen alternate trans-
portation? A. Yes, I did.
Q. What did you propose in that connection? [178]
A. We had a flight goine from Washington to Philadel-
phia in the next 15 minutes, and I could offer a connection
in Philadelphia arriving in Hartford, Connecticut, fifty-
five minutes after the scheduled arrival time.
Q. Did you offer that to these three men? A. Yes, I
did.
Q. Did any of them accept it? A. At first all three
wy then what happened? A. Mr. Nader = s
few telephone calls and came back and said he = obo
cept that. I advised him to meet me at Gate eo —
rest of the paper work could be finished, and 4 — =
down, after making a telephone call. He _— op
I advised him he would have to take a bus ou
q. And then what did Mr. Nader say to that? A. He
asked me what type of aircraft it was.
s * - o o oe o >
Q. And what did you tell him? A. I advised him it
Beech 80.
"2 “And what is a Beech 80 plane? A. It is a commuter
ire aft, twin-engine turboprop.
1179] Q. It carrier how many passengers? A. Fifteen
~ if anything, did Mr. Nader say or do ——
you told him that this commuter aircraft was a Beech
id, ‘*C _”
‘a ‘A. At that time he started down the hall-
"(Q. Did you tender Mr. Nader this form that the airlines
are supposed to tender about the rights to denied-boarding
compensation in the event of an oversale? A. Yes, sir,
, © wll us about that. A. I gave wham a —
‘ - . e
t to the gate, and I advised im 0
mr He said, ‘‘That is all right. I already have yond
I still said, ‘‘You have to accept mine. You do not have
it, but you have to take it.””
a he tell you from what airline he had greed
had one of those denied-boarding compensation rights
cards? A. Yes, he said American Airlines. en
Q. Did he take the one from you! A. Yes, e did. ;
Q. What did he do with it? A. He put it in his pocket,
his coat pocket.
81
[180] Now, did Mr. Nader question you about whether
or not the commuter flight would be able to make the con-
nection to Philadelphia and get him to Hartford 55 min-
utes after the original flight, or did he cancel it after you
made the statement about the commuter aircraft? A. So
far as I remember, all he did Say was, ‘‘Cancel it.’’
Q. Before that, had you already explained about the
schedule in Philadelphia, the connection schedule? A.
Yes, I did.
The Court: Well, the implication of your testimony up
to this point is that, until the last question, when Mr. Na-
der was asked to meet you at Gate 16, he, in effect accepted
your proposition or offer to fly to Philadelphia and thence
to Hartford.
The Witness: That is correct, sir.
The Court: And he offered no objection to flying to
Philadelphia via this Beech 80 aircraft.
The Witness: I am sorry. Would you repeat that?
The Court: And he offered no objection to flying via the
Beech 80 aircraft.
The Witness: That is when he objected.
The Court: When?
The Witness: When he found out it would be a Beech 80.
[181] What time was this connecting flight scheduled to
arrive in Hartford, Connecticut? A. I think it was 12:10.
Q. Did Mr. Nader ask you, in substance, after you had
told him the plane was full, did he ask you to see if any-
body would volunteer to get off the plane and give up
their seat for him? A. Yes, he did.
Q. Did you agree to do that? A. N 0, I didn’t.
Q. Why not? A. The flight was already boarded and
ready to go, and [182] the selection is automatic once we
have 100 people on board.
Q. You are referring now to your Passenger Service
Manual, Mr. McDonald? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that says that the last person to arrive is the
Yes, sir.
i bn aniienl under that policy to delay the
flight, trying to find out who would be least convenienced
or inconvenienced? A. No, I am not permitted to do that.
Q. Did you say anything to Mr. Nader about-—after
he had decided not to make the flight, about being able to
pick up the deferred-boarding compensation at the ticket
counter, if he wanted it? A. Yes, I did, sir.
e e eo e @ ® e @ - e
Cross-Examination
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Mr. McDonald, what time, according to your testi-
mony, did the two other denied-boarding passengers ar-
dnl the gate, Mr. Koskinen and Mr. Pulzun? A. Ap-
imately 10:10.
*'Q. Not ‘0 12? [183]. A. Approximately somewhere
in that area?
Q. 10:10 A. 10:10, 10:12.
i tion was that the
[184] Q. Is it true that your recollec
two A. Lain arrived at about 10:05 or 10:10, when the
gate agent, the other agent at the gate, advised you ~
there were two extra passengers? A. I am not sure of
exact time, but that did happen. ;
Q. So you are not sure of the exact time? A. Not to
the second, no.
Q. Or to the five minutes? A. I could not be perfectly
sure, no.
"Q. Actually, Mr. Koskinen did arrive at the gate about
10:05, didn’t het A. Approximately.
Q. And Mr. Pulzun actually arrived at that gate about -
45 minutes to an hour ahead of time, didn’t he? A. That
i ssible.
y 6. In fact, wasn’t Pulzun one of the first ten or 11 people
who checked in? A. I don’t know.
Q. Well, wasn’t Pulzun actually allowed on the aircraft
and then put back off? [185] A. No, sir.
Q. You did not go out to the plane and make him get off?
A. I did not.
Q. And you do not know if anyone did? A. Nobody did.
Q. Are you aware that the company has gotten a state-
ment from Mr. Pulzun giving this account? A. No,
I am not.
Q. If he gave such a statement, would that be false?
A. I would believe it to be false.
Mr. Roberson: May it please the court, I don’t think he
ought to characterize what some other witness has given in
some self-serving statement.
The Court: Well, ask him whether it was the truth or not.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Was it the truth? A. To my knowledge, it was not.
Q. Are you still sure that Pulzun and Koskinen, as you
just testified, arrived about 10:10 to 10:12? A. At the
check-in position, yes.
Q. I thought you said that Pulzun may have arrived, it
was possible that he arrived, 45 minutes early? A. That
is possible.
Q. What time did Mr. Nader arrive? [186] A. Approx-
imately 10:15.
Q. You seem very exact about that? A. Yes, sir.
Q. How can you recall that so precisely? A. Because it
was right at the departure time. I try to be aware of the
time
Q. What was the scheduled departure time? A. 10:15.
Q. What time did the flight actually depart? A. Ap-
proximately 10:25.
Q. 10:25 <A. That is correct.
[188] Q. Well, this document shows that the plane de-
parted on schedule at 10:15, is that correct?
Mr. Roberson: Well, I don’t think he ought to paraphrase
the interrogatory answer. I don’t remember what it was,
what they did say. But if he is going to quote from it, I
think he ought to quote the answer to the interrogatory. It
may have said that. I don’t know.
Mr. Robertson: Your Honor, I read Question No. 25(g),
requesting, with respect to Allegheny Flight 864, on April
28, 1972, from Washington to Hartford, ‘‘the time at which
Flight 864 departed from the gate at Washington National
Airport.”’
The answer, as given: ‘‘Flight 864 reported 10:15 a.m.
departure.”’
Mr. Roberson: Well, that is not the same thing as he was
trying to paraphrase, Your Honor. They may have been
two minutes off in that, but they reported as 10 115 de-
parture. Now, whether that is a fact or not, as to actual
departure, that may have been different.
But he was trying to paraphrase it.
The Court: Well, I will read the interrogatory, and the
answer, and consider it in the light of all of the other
evidence.
By Mr. Robertson:
[189] Q. Mr. McDonald, isn’t it possible, based on that
record, that your watch might have been in error? A. I
don’t believe so.
Q. You do not believe it is possiblet A. That is correct.
Q. Has it ever been wrong! A. Of course, it has.
Q. Why would it be impossible for it to have been off at
this point? A. Because I had just checked it with our
operations office approximately 15 minutes before that.
Q. Well, since your recollection is not exact about the
time that Mr. Koskinen and Mr. Pulzun might have arrived,
and since your recollection disagrees with company rec-
ords as to the time the plane left by five or ten minutes,
might you not also be mistaken about the time that Mr.
Nader got to the gatet A. I don’t believe so.
Q. You do not believe it is possible? A. No, sir.
Q. Actually, if bx had arrived at ten-fifteen-and-a-half or
after the scheduled departure of the plane, he would not
have been an oversale, would het A. Technically, not.
Q. He would not have been eligi
rould eligible f ied- i
yp none 9p in that case, weal het [ a roa
4 ain sure I still would have taken him as a deni d-bo a.
ing nassenger, Ia cl
Fo Well, under Allegheny’s tariffs and rules you cannot
oe _ away the company’s money to someone who is not
gible for it, can youf A. I held this belief because I am
= — would have come out of it.
—Q. What do you mean, something would hav
it? A. Just bei i a
ms rete ae 15 seconds late or 30 seconds late, one
. All you do if he is late is tell hi
) , ‘I am sorry. Y
are late. The fl As > a that,
mathe e flight is closed.’’ A. I could have said that,
Q. And you would have, if it h
' , ad be f
“ =o of a4 flight? A. Not uodorewarne wang gual
. Did you have a discussion with Mr. Nad
whether there were any stand-by’s on board? 1 Yan he
asked me if any stand-by’s had been boarded j
Q. What did you tell him? A. No, sir.
. oy you make a check? A. Yes, I did
' you have a discussion with hia about i
ak
mer iin gs - “ree to see whether marae might
r _to take a later flight, so that th
would not be disappointed? A. He asked me if I cous
= . se so he could get on the flight
. He asked you if
Pye = you would make an announcement?
: ave did you say? A. I said no.
Q. You were aware that there was som in hi
= bon that flight at this point? A. ee cal oe. -
. You were not aware that sncy
tha dies oho tee at there was any urgency? A.
Q. Do you recall having your deposition taken and giving
testimony und ; .
A. Yes, 4 - er oath on July 6, 1973, in this matter? [ 192]
_ And do you recall the following question:
baer you understand from him that there was some
about getting there?’
ae)’ do vou recall giving the following answer:
“ did. I did.’ A. That was after “ asked me to see
body else would get off the airplane.
Q. Ten't it true that Mr. Nader got to the gate in more
than ample time to make the flight, and if the flight had not
been overbooked, he would have been puton it? A. No, sir.
_ It is not true? A. It is not true.
; And your testimony is that the flight did not leave
il 10:25 A. Exactly. ante
"6, That gave him ten minutes? A. I am saying if the
flight were leaving as scheduled he would not have got-
ten on. ;
i in’t i had gotten
. I am asking you: Isin’t it true that if he
“ls that day, based upon when he did get there that day,
if the flight had not been overbooked, he would have been
mmodated? A. It is possible.
“0. It is true, isn’t it? [193] A. It could have gone
either way depending on how fast the computer was send-
ing out the weight and balance tare sheet.
Q. Why did you refuse to check whether any passengers
might help out the situation, considering the circumstances,
the fact that the problem had been induced by overbooking?
A. By my Passenger Service Manual, or Allegheny 8 man-
ual, it is automatic. I am not to delay the flight any fur-
ther, looking for somebody who may possibly be lesser in-
ienced.
Q. Well how long would it have taken? A. Not very
er Not more than 30 or 40 seconds, would it? A. Iam
ot sure.
7 Q. Well, you are pretty sure, are you not? A. Consider-
ing the airplane was about 100 yards away from the gate
I was.
"O. Well would it have taken you 20 seconds or 30 seconds
to walk to the airplane? A. I would say for the total time
of going out and making an announcement it would be one
minute,
Q. One minute, nowt A. Right.
Q. All right. A. And also coming back into the lounge.
Q. I am referring again to your deposition, on page 64.
Do you recall being asked the question: ‘‘And how long
would it [194] have taken to do this,’’ referring to making
the announcement and asking for a volunteer, and your
answer: ‘‘I am not sure. It would all depend on how easy
or how hard it would be for somebody to get up,
‘*Queston: Well, for example, would it have taken you
30 seconds to walk to the plane?
‘Answer: Approximately,
‘Question: And another 20 seconds to make the an-
nouncementf?
‘‘Answer: Not even that, 10 seconds.”’
Do you recall that testimony? A. Yes, I do,
Mr. Roberson: May it please the court, he ought to finish
reading from that, because he stops——
The Court: Read the full question and the full answer,
and then ask him if those questions were asked and those
answers given,
Mr. Robertson: Well, Your Honor, the rest of it relates
to an objection that was raised by Mr. Roberson.
Mr. Roberson: No, it does not.
You asked a question. I made an objection. Then the wit-
ness made an answer, and I think it is all pertinent to this
about how long it would take to——
Mr. Robertson: Very well, Your Honor.
The Court: I just got done reading it, but the witness
has not heard it, so you had better ask him.
[195] Mr. Robertson; The question that I put to the wit-
ness originally had to do with how long it would take to
make an annoucement.
The next question that we get into is, if someone accepted,
it might take another three or four minutes to get them
off the plane,
An objection was interposed by Mr. Roberson. ‘*How
about getting their baggage out of the hold?
And I respond, ‘‘That is true.’’
And the answer of the witness: ‘‘That would be impos-
sible. I would not even try it. There are 200 pieces of lug-
gage in there.’’
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Do you recall that testimony? A. Yes, I do.
Q. So your prior testimony was that it might take you
30 seconds to make the entire trip out to the plane and
make the announcement, is that rightt A. And another
30 seconds or so to get back inside the lounge!
Q. Yes. A. Right.
Q. Another 30 seconds? A. Right. .
Q. So you are counting roundtrip, sirt [196] A.
"' aa it would not be necessary to take the baggage
off of the plane if someone wanted to volunteer, would it?
A. By company manual, it ic We are not allowed to
rate a passenger from his baggage.
. Well, saan someone has checked in for a flight and,
as the result of an oversale, it develops that they are over-
booked and don’t board it, and their baggage has already
been put on the plane. The baggage is going to go, is it not,
Mr. McDonaldt A. We will ask the passenger whether
wants his age back or not. |
~- But th frequently goes ahead to the destina-
tion, does it not? A. Most likely because we can get the
passenger there very quickly.
Q. So, all that would have been required was to tell who-
ever might volunteer that, ‘‘Your baggage will be waiting
for you in Hartford when you get there’? A. Yes.
[197] Mr. Robertson: I am through with that line, Your
Honor.
The Court: All right.
The Court: All right. I will overrule the objection and
give it such weight as the court feels it is entitled to.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Now, what is a‘‘PNL”’ or a passenger name list? A.
A “PNL”’ is a passenger name list.
Q. Well, what is that? A. It is a computerized listing of
the names of the passengers holding confirmed space on
a flight.
Q. This is used as a check-in tool, is it not? A. Not
necessarily,
Q. It is not used as a check-in tool? A. It does not have
to be.
Q. But it is used as a check-in tool? A. It is at times
used as a check-in tool.
Q. For the gate, right? A. Correct?
Q. But usually it is not used, is that correct? A. It de-
pends on the time of day and which flight and how many
agents are involved in boarding a flight.
[198] Q. So it is a tool that is often overlooked if there
is a press of passengers? A. It is not overlooked. The
PNL will be there. It may not be used to mark off every
passenger’s name as he checks in right then and there, but
they will have to use that eventually, sir,
Q. And this list of confirmed reservations is accurate up
to the time it is printed out and taken up to the gate, is
that right? A. That is correct.
Q. Now, the PNL was not used to check in Flight 864,
was it? A. It was there.
Q. It was there, but it was not referred to or used as
a check-in tool, was it? A. I don’t remember.
Q. You do not remember? A. Correct.
® @ ° ° * * @ * ® e
Q. Now, if over 100 persons were holding reservations
for Flight 864, this would show up on the PNL, would it
not? A. Yes, sir.
[199] Q. What is a ‘‘PBI’’? Do you know what that is?
A. Yes, sir. It is a Passenger Boarding Information read-
out or print-out from a computer.
Q. And what does this information provide? A. It will
give the information of all the passengers holding space on
the flight that have not been ticketed, plus passengers that
need assistance, plus the in-bound connections from both
Allegheny and other airlines.
Q. Well, it does give you that total number of passengers
who were booked out of your station, does it not? A. Yes,
it would.
Q. It also gives the status of the space out of each sta-
tion; in other words, if a flight is overbooked out of a par-
ticular airport, it would show ‘‘OB,’’ would it not? A.
Yes, it would.
Q. So doesn’t this provide you with a tool to find out
in advance whether a flight is overbooked or not? A. Yes,
it does.
Q. And isn’t this information made available to Alle-
gheny at the gates? A. It has to be picked up by the agent
who is working the flight, or that agent will ask for
somebody to get one. It is not a required piece of ma-
terial used for each flight.
Q. But it is available, is it not? A. Itis available.
[200] Q. And there are other tools available of the same
nature, such as the PMB, right A. That is correct.
Q. Therefore, isn’t it true that if a flight is heavily over-
booked, the information is in the computer and it is avail-
able to the agents at the gatet A. “hat do you mean by
‘heavily overbooked’’?
Q. Well, if a flight will hold 100 passengers and there are
107 or 108 booked with confirmed reservations on the flight,
this information is in the computer, and it is available to
the agents at the gate, is that right? A. That is right.
Q. Are they not supposed to know in advance the status
of the flight? A. Not necessarily. If an agent works 15 or
20 flights a day, it is hard to keep up with each flight.
Q. So, as a matter of course, sometimes it is just not
done? A. Which one are you speaking about now?
91
The Court: What is not done?
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. That the agents sometimes do not ascertain what the
ang tenaration in advance of the flight? A. They
usually know how many people are booked
rd ; number of ways of doing it, fanart
1] Q. Now, how was 864 actually ch i
W, ked
“a7 on this date? A. In what oye . mse
. Well, what happened when a passen
ger presented
himself to board the flight? A. At 9:30, the Ane made
a check-in announcement and started taking tickets and
stamping boarding envelopes for all the passengers.
Q. All right. A. That started about 9:30.
Q. And where were the passengers told to go? A. To
"- rena inside the lounge or in the Gate 17 area
, e stand-by’s wer i '
ny dao y e put in the same area? A.
Q. Then the door was opened to the ai
rplane and every-
one was sent out at once at that ti
“on tw dvwne trl ime to board? A. All
PR Fone they segregated? A. They were advised at
arding announcement t i i i
hte naw Oo remain seated until their
+ Se if more than 100——
e Court: Pardon me, sir. May I interrupt?
= — Of course, Your Honor. c
e Court: I may have missed somethi i
0 ieailleonh taker ething that is very
understood you to say earlier, sir, that all
: , Sir, the peopl
ome ow — the ship, Flight 864, by the a Mr.
skinen and Mr. Pulzun and Mr. Nad i
firmed reservations. 3 —tspeetaraatoame
The Witness: That is correct.
The Court: Well, now, from the an
, swer to the questio
he just asked, I gather that that may not have ta so
and that some of the °
ia of these people were stand-by’s that got on
i the
Witness: No. When we check in the passengers,
aante passengers, we hold on to their tickets at the check-
in desk. unin
The Court: Certainly.
The Witness: And, as the passengers are going out the
door, all the boarding envelopes are checked.
The Court: you mean, once a stand-by gets on, he be-
comes a confirmed reservation, the same as somebody who
called up six weeks in advance! é,
The Witness: Not for this particular flight, no, sir. 7
The Court: Were there any stand-by’s on this Flig
8641
The Witness: No, sir.
: Okay.
- at a Honor, if I may refer you to one
of plaintiffs’ exhibits that has been admitted into a
[203] Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 5—I refer specifically to -
first paragraph—I think you will see a company ~
that demonstrates the true answer to your question abou
whether any stand-by’s were boarded on the flight.
Q. According to the company’s records, there was at
least one stand-by boarded on the fight 1 si » sats
Mr. Roberson: Well, then, I submit it 1s immaterial.
would take at least three to get to Mr. Nader. He was the
third oversale, and if there were a stand-by on there that
shouldn’t have been on there, then Mr. Koskinen was en-
titled to it, or Mr. Pulzun. It was not Mr. Nader. They
could not skip them, Your Honor. . eee
So unless there were three on there, this is immaterial,
and I don’t think counsel is going to make any tender that
there were three. . bea
The Court: Well, you are a little bit late in objecting,
Mr. Roberson.
Mr. Roberson: I make an objection to the relevancy. If
there were a single stand-by, we are wasting time with this
witness, because it would take at least three for it to make
any difference in the outcome of this law suit.
[204] The Court: All right. You ought to look at that ex-
hibit, Mr. Roberson.
Mr. Roberson: I have looked at it, and I still say it does
not make any difference.
The Court: All right. Next question.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Well, now, you could have lifted more than 100 tickets
marked ‘‘Confirmed’’ at the time the flight was being
checked in, is that right? A. That is possible.
Q. Yes. And in that case more than 100 people might then
have walked out to the airplane when the gate was opened,
right? A. That is possible.
Q. And in that case somebody would have had to be sent
back, right. A. Yes, sir.
Q. The person sent back would be the guy, very likely,
who the least effective in shouldering his way on to the air-
craft, rather than the guy who was last in checking in for
the flight, is that right? A. That would be possible. Also,
at the same time, we try to keep a record of who was last
to check in, in case that does happen.
[206] Q. Now, was the reservations list or the PNL or
any of these tools actually used to see if passengers really
had reservations for the flight when they presented them-
selves? A. Yes, it was.
Q. It was? A. That is correct.
Q. And you ascertained, based on that, that all of these
passengers had an actual reservation for the flight? A.
All of these passengers had okayed tickets showing [207]
that they were confirmed.
Q. Right. That is not my——_ A. Except for one passen-
ger who had an open ticket.
Q. And which passenger what that? A. I don’t know.
I am pretty sure it was a group of four, or a family, and
the agent working the flight checked with the PNL, and
name was there.
7 My question was not whether you looked at the ticket
to see if it were in an okayed status, but whether you ac-
tually referred to the reservations list or the weight list
to see whether a person had a valid reservation? A. In
this case she referred to the PNL, and the name was there.
Q. How do you know that? A. I asked her.
Q. When did you ask her? A. Not too long ago.
Q. So it was after your deposition was taken, is that cor-
rect? A. Right.
Q. Now, ea are passengers supposed to be selected for
denied boarding? A. At Washington the selection is auto-
a Washington the selection is automatic? A. Any
area where there is gate check-in.
[208] Q. Well, the manual that I assume you are refer-
ring to really says that where the oversale is not known
in advance, isn’t that correct? A. That is correct.
Q. But here you knew in advance, or you could have
known in advance? A. I didn’t know in advance.
Q. And no one could have known in advance this flight
was oversold? A. They could have, but nobody advised
of it.
a * The company knew, didn’t they? A. Not necessarily.
Q. Not necessarily? It was in their computer records,
was it not? A. This is true.
Q. But you did not use the procedures that are applicable
where the oversale is known is advance? A. It is phys-
ically impossible.
Q. You did not use them, did you? A. At that time?
Q. Right. A. I was very busy that morning.
Q. All right, but you did not use them, did yout A. I
did not use the check-in tool?
Q. Excuse me. You did not use the procedures set forth
[209] in the manual for cases where a flight is known to be
oversold in advance? A. That is correct, because I did
not know the flight was overbooked.
Q. But by checking with any of the status tools, with
any of the check-in tools, you could have seen the flight
was overbooked, couldn’t you A. That is correct.
Q. Do you ever use these procedures for denying board-
ing and selecting passengers where the flight is known to
be oversold in advance? A. Yes, I have.
Mr. Roberson: Now, just a minute. Your Honor, counsel
is using ‘‘overbooked’’ and ‘‘oversale’’ as if they are the
same thing, and I think that is confusing and tricks the
witness. He could not know that there was an oversale
until the 101st passenger showed up.
He could know it was overbooked, but he is slipping
that ‘‘oversale’’ in when he should be saying ‘‘over-
booked. ’’
The Court: Well——
Mr. Roberson: I think it is important, Your Honor.
The Court: I think the witness is an expert witness in
the nomenclature of the trade. I doubt if he has been
tricked here. 3
Mr. Roberson: I think that Mr. Robertson knows the
[210] difference between those, and I think he ought to
be precise in his questions.
The Court: Well, I would agree. Counsel, if you can,
limit your questions to one of the two subject matters,
when you ask the witness a question.
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. How are you instructed to handle the oversold pas-
sengers? A. I don’t understand your question.
Q. Well, what are your instructions for handling an
oversold passenger? A. Via the manval
Q. Whatever instructions you have. A. First of all, to
keep the passenger calm.
Q. To keep the passenger calm? A. Right. Very often
passengers will get quite upset. And then to listen to the
passenser, of course, if he has anything to say, and then
advise him what I can do to get him to his destination
as soon as possible.
Q. Are you instructed to advise him the reasons why
he has been denied boarding? A. I am not sure if the
1 states that or not.
mO. I would like to show you an exhibit, Mr. McDonald,
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6. That is the manual used by Alle-
gheny’s passenger service agents, including yourself?
[211] A. That is correct.
[212] Are you instructed to advise the passengers what
happened and the reason for the oversale? A. I don’t
“ean right. A. I could not give you verbatim on that.
You have a copy of the manual there. That is a year
old now, and it is changed quite often.
Q. Are you advised to tell the passenger that an in-
tentional overbooking may have caused his oversale? A.
I usually would advise the passenger that there has been
a mistake; exactly what it is, I don’t know, unless, of
course, it is an equipment substitution, or something like
“. You would not advise him that an intentional over-
booking policy may have caused his distress? A. No, I
’t think I would.
“~~ boy that is because you do not think it is good
publicity for the company, do you? A. That is true. :
The Court: Is that the reason you did not do it in this
instance?
The Witness: I was not sure of the reason for it at
that time.
[213] By Mr. Robertson:
i t that
. Well, you did mark on the forms and the repor
m. filed the reason for the oversale being overbooking,
did you not? A. Yes, I did. That was the most obvious
reason, but I still was not sure. )
Q. Now, this is the last short series of questions. Con-
cerning this trip to Philadelphia with the possible con-
nection to Hartford, was this a legal connection in Phila-
delphiat A. No. Company-wise, it was not a legal con-
nection.
Q. It was an illegal connection, was it not? A. That
is correct.
Q. Was there some risk that the connection might be
missed? A. There would have been some risk.
Q. Did you guarantee that it would be made? A. No.
Q. Did you tell him it would be close? A. Yes, I did.
Q. And even if the connection had been made, the
second flight was not scheduled to arrive at Bradley Field
until almost an hour after the first flight, is that right?
A. Approximately 55 minutes.
[214] Q. All right. And you gave a report in writing
about this denial of boarding to someone in the company?
A. Just the required denied-boarding form.
Q. You did make a report? A. Yes, I did,
Q. Mr. Nader did not tell you at any time that the
type of aircraft that was offered to him had anything
to do with his decision, did het A. No, he did not.
Q. And, in fact, you had informed him of these verious
other features and problems with the alternative trans-
portation—— A. I advised him I would have somebody
meet him because it would be a close connection.
[215] Q. Was the flight actually held up in Philadelphia
for the connecting passengers? A. It did not have to be.
Redirect Examination
By Mr. Roberson:
Q. Does your company require you to board anyone
that has an okayed, ticket, everyone that has an okayed
ticket for a flight? A. Yes; if the ticket is written cor-
rectly, regardless of any other information, the passen-
ger is to be boarded.
Q. If it has an ‘‘okay’’ on the ticket, then you down
there board him, is that correct? A. That is correct.
Q. And that was the situation on this flight: that you
boarded the first 100? A. That is correct, sir.
oe @ e @ @ * eo * @ °°
[216] Recross-Examination
By Mr. Robertson:
Q. Is this program of checking in anyone with a con-
firmed okay showing on their ticket, is this set forth in
the tariffs? A. It is in the company policy manual, yes.
Q. Is it in the same section on denied-boarding priori-
ties that we have been taking about? A. I am not sure.
I don’t think so,
Q. You don’t think it ist A. It would be in a different
section.
Q. All right. A. There is a general section for pas-
senger check-in.
Q. But the section that is submitted to the CAB con-
cerning denied-boarding procedures, this is not contained
in that section? A. I don’t know,
Q. Thank you.
eo ® e@ eo @ oe
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.