Amicus Brief — Portland Cement Ass'n v. Train

Supreme Court brief1975

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

eS a aD)

Iw THE OCT 22. 1975

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1975

No. 75—415

PORTLAND CEMENT ASSOCIATION, An Illinois

Not-For-Profit Corporation,

Petitioner,

v.

ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL

PROTECTION AGENCY,

Respondent,

MEDUSA CORPORATION, NORTHWESTERN

STATES PORTLAND CEMENT CO.,

Intervenors.

BRIEF OF THE AMERICAN PAPER INSTITUTE, INC. AS

AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITION FOR

A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Cuartes L. STEWART

161 East 42nd Street

New York, New York 10017

Counsel for the

American Paper Institute, Inc.

Of Counsel:

MicHaet B. Wem

CurIsToPHER W. ConGALTON

Dunnincton, BartHotow & MILLER

161 East 42nd Street

New York, New York 10017

October 22, 1975

Supteme Court, U.&

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Interest Of The American Paper Institute, Inc. .....

Reasons For Granting The Writ ...................

I. The Clean Air Act Mandates That Stationary

Source Standards Be Reasonably Related to

Sacha eatedbkuk cekeihbwedeeeedeasaee esas

II. Failure To Observe The Statutory Mandate

That Standards Be Reasonably Related To Cost

Would Have A Serious Detrimental Effect ....

III. The Court Should Determine The Cost-Benefit

Issue Presented In This Case ................

IE tt Saleen ee ok a!

List oF AUTHORITIES

Cases:

Portland Cement Association y. Administrator, En-

vironmental Protection Agency, 513 F.2d 506

(D.C. Cir.), petition for cert. filed, 44 U.S.L.W.

—— (U.S. Sept. 15, 1975) .......... ccc eeuee

Union Electric Co. v. E.P.A., 515 F.2d 206 (8th Cir.),

cert. granted, 44 U.S.L.W. 3178 (U.S. Oct. 7,

in SICEVell ait deemed ns wadeWk wae ans ices con

Statutes:

Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 1857 et seq. .............

Miscellaneous:

“Excerpts From EPA Response To Remand,” Peti-

tion For a Writ of Certiorari, A-61 ............

PAGE

1

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1975

No. 75—415

+.

a

PortLanp CEMENT ASSOCIATION,

An Illinois Not-for-Profit Corporation,

Petitioner,

Vv.

ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,

Respondent,

Mepvusa Corporation, NoRTHWESTERN STATES PoRTLAND

Cement Co.,

Intervenors.

=

bs

BRIEF OF THE AMERICAN PAPER INSTITUTE, INC. AS

AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITION FOR

A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

INTEREST OF THE AMERICAN PAPER

INSTITUTE, INC.

The American Paper Institute, Inc. (‘‘API’’) is the

national trade association of the pulp, paper and paper-

board industry. Its 200 member firms provide more than

90 percent of all the pulp, paper and paperboard manufac-

tured domestically. The paper industry ranks among the

ten largest industries in the United States. Last year it

produced 61 million tons of paper and paperboard and

2

shipped $40 billion worth of goods. The industry em-

ployed more than 700,000 people, and in 1974, its outlay

in wages, salaries and benefits came to $9 billion.

The economy of the domestic paper industry could be

significantly affected by the standards imposed on paper

companies under the Clean Air Act.’ That industry

worked with Congress in drafting the 1970 Amendments

to the Clean Air Act and the industry continues to sup-

port the goals of this legislation. However, the API be-

lieves that the decision of the Court of Appeals in this

case* raises serious problems which may jeopardize ful-

fillment of the legitimate goals of the Act.

The court below affirmed the determination by the

Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency

(‘‘EPA”) that a cost-benefit analysis is not required in

setting stationary source standards under section 111 of

the Clean Air Act.’ The API believes this decision is in-

consistent with the purpose of the Clean Air Act and will

have serious adverse consequences for the paper industry.

Accordingly, the API addresses this brief to the Court in

support of the position of the Portland Cement Associa-

tion (‘* Petitioner’’) that in promulgating stationary source

standards under section 111 of the Clean Air Act, the

EPA Administrator must consider the cost of pollutant

control in relation to expected environmental benefit and

publie welfare.

*42 U.S.C. § 1857 et seq.

*513 F.2d 506 (D.C. Cir.), petition for cert. filed, 44 U.S.L.W.

—— (U.S. Sept. 15, 1975).

*42 U.S.C. § 1857¢-6.

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

The Clean Air Act Mandates That Stationary

Source Standards Be Reasonably Related to Cost.

Section 1ll(a)(1) of the Clean Air Act defines the

term “standard of performance” as follows:

a standard for emissions of air pollutants

which reflects the degree of emission limitation

achievable through the application of the best system

of emission reduction which (taking into account the

cost of achieving such reduction) the Administrator

determines has been adequately demonstrated.

The court below in this case acknowledged that the EPA

Administrator was required under that section “to take

into account the cost of achieving the emission reduction

he prescribes” ;* however, the court declined to require the

preparation of a quantified cost-benefit analysis. The

API concurs with Petitioner and the other industries

filing as amici curiae in this case in urging the Court to

recognize that failure to relate benefit to cost under sec-

tion 111 of the Clean Air Act will foster the imposition

of excessive cost burdens on the many industries subject

to the Act without providing a corresponding benefit

to the public.

There is virtually no guidance available in the form

of legislative history evidencing Congressional intent with

respect to consideration of cost under section 111(a)(1)

of the Clean Air Act. We are therefore compelled to

look solely to the terms of the statute in order to deter-

mine the degree of limitation which Congress intended

by the reference to cost in that section.

*513 F.2d at 508.

4

In this connection it is important to note that the entire

thrust of the statute is toward the imposition of pollu-

tion controls and the requirement that industry sustain the

cost necessary to provide such controls. The only section

in the Clean Air Act which explicitly recognizes the neces-

sity to temper that requirement with a consideration of

the costs involved is section 111(a)(1). Its solitary in-

clusion emphasizes a Congressional determination that

stationary source standards must be established with ref-

erence to cost; the clear import of that section should

not be diminished by overly conservative construction of

the statutory terms.

Section 111(a)(1) requires the EPA Administrator to

take into account the cost of achieving pollution reduction

in determining emission standards. Thus, the considera-

tion of costs is specifically mandated by the statute. Cost

cannot be considered in a vacuum; to do so is meaningless.

The only factor with which cost can be reasonably juxta-

posed in the context of a statute designed to reduce pollu-

tion is the measure of reduction achieved. The amount

of pollution control and the public benefit derived there-

from must be balanced against the expenditure required

to accomplish it. This reduces essentially to a cost-benefit

analysis.

The EPA Administrator acknowledges the validity of

a very limited application of the principle that benefits

must be weighed against the costs required to produce

them. He cites two conditions under which he would be

forced to abate a stationary source standard on the basis

of excessive cost. First, he admits:

Where the cost of meeting such standards would be

so great that the industry could not bear the cost and

survive, such standards could not be implemented. . . .°

°“Excerpts from EPA Response To Remand,” Petition For A

Writ Of Certiorari, A-61.

co. ez

b)

The API submits that consideration of cost only in relation

to the ability of the industry to survive ignores the only

rational test as to whether a particular cost is warranted;

i.e., that the benefit being derived merits the expenditure.

The EPA Administrator also concedes:

. . . Where a reduction in emissions that would be

achieved by a particular contro] technique would be

so grossly disproportionate to the cost of the control

technique . . . it would not be required.*

He does not reveal how, in the absence of a definitive cost-

benefit analysis, that test is to be applied. The API asserts

that it is totally meaningless to discuss the concept of

‘gross disproportion” between benefit and cost in the ab-

sence of a quantitative analysis measuring those factors.

If the concept of ‘‘gross disproportion’’ is to have any

meaning, it must be predicated upon a detailed measure-

ment of the elements involved.

By rejecting the cost-benefit data proffered by Peti-

tioner and recognizing only the two highly subjective tests

discussed above, the EPA Administrator effectively ignores

the statutory directive that cost must be considered in

determining appropriate stationary source standards.

Failure To Observe The Statutory Mandate

That Standards Be Reasonably Related To

a Would Have A Serious Detrimental

ect.

The term ‘‘stationary source” is defined under the

Clean Air Act to include ‘‘any building, structure, facility,

or installation which emits or may emit any air pollutant.’”

Thus, the emission standards applicable to stationary

* Id.

"42 U.S.C. § 1857c-6.

6

sources under the Clean Air Act directly affect a substantial

segment of the nation’s industrial facilities.

The importance of cost-benefit consciousness in develop-

ing standards of pollution control for stationary sources

is particularly critical since this section is directed at new

or modified industrial structures. New industrial construc-

tion to increase production capacity is necessary for a

healthy economy. The direct correlation between such new

industrial construction and business expansion, including

the creation of new jobs, cannot be disputed. If such con-

struction is seriously impeded or curtailed because of un-

realistic pollution control standards applicable thereto, the

nation will suffer a substantial and unjustified economic

blow.

To seriously handicap the nation’s productive resources

without providing a concomitant improvement in pollution

control would be antithetical to the express purpose of

the Clean Air Act:

to protect and enhance the quality of the Nation’s

air resources so as to promote the public health and

welfare and the productive capacity of its population.

(Emphasis supplied)*

That statement of purpose makes clear that the Clean Air

Act was intended to foster the public welfare in general,

including its economic vitality. Achievement of that goal

would be frustrated by the adoption of pollution control

standards which are not reasonably related to the costs in-

volved in meeting such standards.

Compliance with stationary source performance stand-

ards will obviously be a costly matter for the many indus-

tries affected. To a large extent the consumer will share

the burden of these costs, both directly and in the form of

product shortages. To the extent that the goal of re-

®42 U.S.C. § 1857.

7

ducing the serious pollution problems facing this country

is advanced, these costs are justified. Congress never

intended, however, that large expenditures be required to

achieve minuscule improvements in air quality.

The EPA Administrator is charged with the duty of

determining where the line of reasonable relation between

cost and benefit is crossed. The only means by which he

can make a reliable determination of this important matter

is by a quantitative analysis of the cost involved vis a vis

the benefit conferred. It is urgent that the Court make

explicit the EPA Administrator’s duty under section 111

of the Clean Air Act to consider the cost-benefit relation-

ship in the formulation of stationary source standards.

The Court Should Determine The Cost-Benefit

Issue Presented In This Case.

This case affords a strong factual context in which the

Court can establish the important principle raised by Peti-

tioner; i.e., that promulgation of appropriate standards

for stationary sources under the Clean Air Act must be

based upon cost-benefit analyses. The evidence presented

by Petitioner indicates that a twenty-percent increase in

cost would be required to accomplish an emission reduc-

tion of one-tenth of one percent required under the stand-

ard at issue; the ratio of cost to benefit thus adduced is

in excess of 100 to 1.

It is diffeult to contend, even on the basis of the mar-

ginal test which the EPA Administrator acknowledges

to be necessary, that these figures do not present a “gross

disproportion” between benefit and cost. The clear in-

ference must be that the EPA Administrator failed to

consider the cost-benefit evidence before him in this case.

The Court cannot condone such a clear refusal to give

meaningful consideration to the statutory mandate that

cost of pollution control be balanced against the benefit

to be derived therefrom.

The Court has implicitly recognized the importance of

including cost considerations as an element of administra-

tion of the Clean Air Act by granting certiorari in Union

Electric v. E.P.A.° The API submits that the instant case

presents another important aspect of the cost issue which

should receive direct clarification by the Court at this

time.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the Court is respectfully

requested to grant Portland Cement Association’s

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.

Respectfully submitted,

Cuartes L. Stewart

161 East 42nd Street

New York, New York 10017

Counsel for the

American Paper Institute, Inc.

Of Counsel:

Micuaet B. Wem

CuristoPpHEeR W. ConGaLTon

DunninoTon, BartHoLow & MILLER

161 East 42nd Street

New York, New York 10017

October 22, 1975

°515 F.2d 206 (8th Cir.), cert. granted, 44 U.S.L.W. 3178

(U.S. Oct. 7, 1975).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.