Appendix — Air East, Inc. v. National Transportation Safety Board

Supreme Court brief1975

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

éupreme Court, U. $.

FILED

JUL 9 1975

/

CAAEL RODAK, JR..CLERK

In THE t.

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1975

AIR EAST, INC., d/b/a ALLEGHENY COMMUTER,

AIR EAST, INC., CHARLES ALLAN McKINNEY,

JAMES AVERY TALLENT, JEFFREY H. WILKIN.

SON and THOMAS REDDECLIFF,

Petitioners,

vs.

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD

and ALEXANDER P. BUTTERFIELD, Administrator

of the Federal Aviation Administration

Respondents.

TL

APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT

a)

Water E. Ruruerrorp

Attorney for Petitioners

One State Street Plaza

New York, N. Y. 10004

a ee

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PAGE

Appenpix A—Statutes Involved .................. Al

Appenpix B—Opinion of the Court of Appeals ..... A4

ApPpEeNnDIx C—Opinion of the National Transportation

EE, onc kuendks onnéeeuns éenberenedees Al19

AppenDix D—Opinion of Administrative Law Judge

EE Ghd dib beh bkaponeennsueutbncdaieces A67

Appenpix E—Deposition of Thomas Reddecliffe .... A135

Al

APPENDIX A.

Statutes Involved.

49 U.S.C.A.—

§ 1429. Reinspection or reexamination; amendment,

suspension, or revocation of certificates; noti-

fication; hearing; appeal to Board; judicial

review

The Administrator may, from time to time, reinspect any

civil aircraft, aircraft, engine, propeller, appliance, air

navigation facility, or air agency, or may reexamine any

civil airman. If, as a result of any such reinspection or

reexamination, or if, as a result of any other investigation

made by the Administrator, he determines that safety in

air commerce or air transportation and the public interest

requires, the Administrator may issue an order amending,

modifying, suspending, or revoking, in whole or in part,

any type certificate, production certificate, airworthiness

certificate, airman certificate, air carrier operating certifi-

eate, air navigation facility certificate, or air agency cer-

tificate. Prior to amending, modifying, suspending, or

revoking any of the foregoing certificates, the Administra-

tor shall advise the holder thereof as to any charges or

other reasons relied upon by the Administrator for his

proposed action and, except in cases of emergency, shall

provide the holder of such a certificate an opportunity to

answer any charges and be heard as to why such certificate

should not be amended, modified, suspended, or revoked.

Any person whose certificate is affected by such an order

of the Administrator under this section may appeal the

Administrator’s order to the Board and the Board may,

after notice and hearing, amend, modify, or reverse the

Administrator’s order if it finds that safety in air com-

merce or air transportation and the public interest do not

require affirmation of the Administrator’s order. In the

A2

Appendiz A.

conduct of its hearings the Board shall not be bound by

findings of fact of the Administrator. The filing of an

appeal with the Board shall stay the effectiveness of the

Administrator’s order unless the Administrator advises

the Board that an emergency exists and safety in air com-

merce or air transportation requires the immediate effec-

tiveness of his order, in which event the order shall re-

main effective and the Board shall finally dispose of the

appeal within sixty days after being so advised by the Ad-

ministrator. The person substantially affected by the

Board’s order may obtain judicial review of said order

under the provisions of section 1486 of this title, and the

Administrator shall be made a party to such proceedings.

Pub.L. 85-726, Title VI, § 609, Aug. 23, 1958, 72 Stat. 779.

§ 1485. Orders, notices, and service—Effective date

of orders; emergency orders

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, all

orders, rules, and regulations of the Board or the Ad-

ministrator shall take effect within such reasonable time

as the Board or Administrator may prescribe, and shall

continue in force until their further order, rule, or regula-

tion, or for a specified period of time, as shall be pre-

scribed in the order, rule, or regulation: Provided, That

whenever the Administrator is of the opinion that an

emergency requiring immediate action exists in respect

of safety in air commerce, the Administrator is authorized,

either upon complaint or his own initiative without com-

plaint, at once, if he so orders, without answer or other

form of pleading by the interested person or persons, and

with or without notice, hearing, or the making or filing of

a report, to make such just and reasonable orders, rules,

or regulations, as may be essential in the interest of safety

in air commerce to meet such emergency: Provided fur-

A3

Appendiz A.

ther, That the Administrator shall immediately initiate

proceedings relating to the matters embraced in any such

order, rule, or regulation, and shall, insofar as practicable,

give preference to such proceedings over all others under

this chapter.

A4

APPENDIX B.

- Opinion of the Court of Appeals.

Am East, Inc., d/b/a Allegheny Commuter,

et al., Petitioners,

v.

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SaFETY Boarp and Alexander P.

Butterfield, Administrator of the Federal Aviation Ad-

ministration, Respondents.

Nos. 74-1542 and 74-1914 to 74-1918.

United States Court of Appeals,

Third Circuit.

Argued Feb. 7, 1975.

Decided March 13, 1975.

Walter E. Rutherford, Haight, Gardner, Poor & Havens,

New York City, for petitioners.

Carla A. Hills, Asst. Atty. Gen., New York City, William

Kanter, Anthony J. Steinmeyer, Morton Hollander, Ap

pellate Section, Civ. Div., Dept. of Justice, Washington,

D. C., for respondents.

Before Apams, Rosenn and Weis, Circuit Judges.

OPINION OF THE CouRT

Weis, Circuit Judge.

In legislating on air travel safety, Congress has recog-

nized that the duty of air carriers is to perform their serv-

ices “with the highest possible degree of safety in the pub-

lie interest,” 49 U.S.C. §1421(b). With that standard as

a backdrop, we consider these appeals from the revocations

: ee

A5

Appendiz B.

of certification of an air taxi line, several of its pilots, and

its chief mechanic. A review of the record establishes to

our satisfaction that the action of the National Transpor-

tation Safety Board is supported by substantial evidence,

and we affirm.

Air East is a commuter airline authorized to furnish

passenger and mail delivery service to a number of com-

munities in western and central Pennsylvania, including

Pittsburgh, Johnstown, Altoona, Bradford, and DuBois. It

was certified by the Federal Aviation Administration

[F.A.A.] on August 29, 1969. Petitioners Charles Allan

McKinney, James A. Tallent, and Jeffrey H. Wilkinson

were senior pilots with Air East who held pilot’s licenses

issued by the F.A.A.' Additional petitioners are Air East

(Repair Station), a separate corporation which operated

an aircraft repair facility in Johnstown pursuant to a cer-

tificate issued on August 21, 1970, and Thomas Reddecliff,

an F.A.A. certified mechanic who supervised the repair

station operations.

Air East operated without mishap until the evening of

January 6, 1974, when a flight originating in Pittsburgh

crashed on its approach to the runway in Johnstown, kill-

ing twelve of the occupants. Although there had been prior

anonymous complaints to the federal authorities about

some of Air East’s practices, the crash precipitated a gen-

eral investigation’ of the carrier’s operation in addition to

1Tallent held an Airline Transport Pilot certificate, and Me-

Kinney and Wilkinson had Commercial Pilot certificates.

2 This probe was authorized by 49 U.S.C. § 1429(a), which em-

powers the Administrator of the F.A.A. to ‘‘reinspect’’ periodically

any licensee’s conduct and to ‘‘reexamine’’ any civil airman. The

result of reinspection or reexamination, if ‘‘safety in air commerce

or air transportation and the public interest requires,’’ may be the

‘‘amending, modifying, suspending, or revoking’’ of any certificate

issued by the F.A.A.

A6

Appendiz B.

the inquiry specifically directed to the cause of the acci-

dent.* During the period from January 18 to March 4,

1974, the F.A.A. interviewed a number of witnesses, de-

posed twenty-five persons, including present and former

Air East employees, and examined the company records

of aircraft maintenance and pilots’ operations. On March

7, 1974, the Administrator issued an “emergency” order

revoking the air taxi certificate held by Air East d/b/a

Allegheny Commuter, the repair station certificate, the

pilot certificates of McKinney, Tallent, and Wilkinson, and

the mechanic certificate of Reddecliff.*

Petitioners immediately filed an appeal, and on March

21, 1974, a hearing commenced before an administrative

law judge of the National Transportation Safety Board

(N.T.S.B.]. After twenty-five days of testimony and argu-

ment, on April 24, 1974 the administrative law judge issued

his oral decision, sustaining the revocation. The Board

affirmed in an opinion issued on May 10, 1974,’ and peti-

tioners appealed to this court. 49 U.S.C. 4 1486.

°49 U.S.C. § 1441(a)(2)-(5) requires the Administrator to in-

vestigate accidents involving civil aircraft, report the facts of each,

and take steps to remedy such incidents and prevent their recur-

rence.

* This action was taken pursuant to 49 U.S.C. § 1429 which per-

mits immediate revocation in an emergency and provides that an

appeal to the licensee shall not stay the Administrator’s order when

he advises the National Transportation Safety Board ‘‘that an

emergency exists and safety in air commerce or air transportation

requires the immediate effectiveness of his order.’’ The Board is

then required to finally dispose of the appeal within sixty days.

‘The administrative law judge upheld 15 of the 19 charges

against Air East, 9 of 9 against McKinney, 7 of 8 against Tallent,

8 of the 9 against Wilkinson, and the 2 charges against Reddecliff,

as well as 3 of the 4 charges against the repair station. The Board

sustained the administrative law judge except for one of the charges

against Tallent which it reversed.

A7

Appendix B.

Petitioners were charged with the improper operation of

aircraft, including, inter alia:

1. allowing overloaded planes to take off;

2. permitting planes to fly without certain instruments

being in proper working order;

3. permitting planes to fly after improper repairs;

4. flying below minimum approach altitudes ;

5. using approaches to the airports at Johnstown and

Altoona which were not approved by the F.A.A.;

6. deviating from assigned altitudes without permis-

sion; and

7. operating without current weather reports.

Derelictions in record keeping were also alleged, including

failing to prepare accurate weight manifests and computa-

tions of centers of gravity before take-off; falsifying rec-

ords concerning flight checks given to pilots; falsifying

records designating the supervisory mechanic responsible

for repair of aircraft; and failing to enter mechanical defi-

ciencies in the log. It was also charged that there were

instances in which aircraft were put into service after im-

proper repairs.°

* Other additional charges included :

Against Air East:

1. instituting company practices which:

a. prohibited pilots from logging inoperable instruments

and equipment;

b. required flight personnel to report such deficiencies on

—_ pieces of paper or orally to maintenance per-

sonnel;

e. prohibited maintenance personnel from entering repairs

in the log until such repairs were completed;

(footnote continued on following page)

A8

Appendix B.

Petitioners contend that:

1. the emergency revocation of the licenses without a

prior hearing was a denial of due process;

2. the hearing which was granted denied due process;

(footnote continued from preceding page)

d. allowed the operation of unairworthy craft; and tore-

ing employee compliance by coercion and intimidation.

scheduling pilots for excessive duty without adequate rest;

improperly maintaining pilot flight time records;

utilizing pilots as required flight crew when they had not

received initial flight training;

authorizing pilots to fly who had not completed proper

flight, instrument and route checks;

failing to provide equipment so that pilots engaged in IFR

and multi-engine operations could properly maintain and

demonstrate their ability to conduct such operations;

7. failing to deliver summary reports to the Administrator

relevant to propeller feathering in flight;

8. preventing pilots from attaining proficiency in more ad-

vanced flying techniques.

Against McKinney, Tallent and Wilkinson:

1. failing to maintain minimum distances from clouds under

VFR conditions;

2. continuously serving as pilots-in-command without current

instrument checks;

3. accepting assignments in excess of the maximum allowable

hours and without required amounts of rest.

Against McKinney and Wilkinson:

1. serving as pilots in aircraft and under conditions for which

they had not been checked.

Against McKinney and Tallent:

1. operating unairworthy planes and continuing flights when

they discovered the craft to be so.

Against Reddecliff:

1. performing inadequate repairs on aircraft and permitting

their return to service in substandard condition.

o- fF Sw

A9

Appendiz B.

3. the charges were not supported by probative and

substantial evidence; and

4. the sanctions were excessive.’

I,

Tre Emercency Revocation Dip Not VIOLATE

Dvr Process

This investigation began on January 18, 1974, and dur-

ing the following six weeks, F.A.A. officials interviewed

present and former employees of Air East. Several poten-

tial witnesses were reluctant to have their roles made pub-

lice, and they preferred that the investigators meet them

privately at the witnesses’ homes during nonbusiness hours.

Some of the witnesses had experienced personal differences

with the Air East management; some were hesitant to in-

volve friends in the inquiry; several were themselves guilty

of violations which might expose them to possible sanc-

tions; and others, still employed by Air East, did not wish

to incur the animosity of management. The preliminary

investigation, therefore, was not open but was somewhat

covert.

However, the F.A.A. did issue subpoenas to Air East for

the production of records, and on February 19, 1974, an

’ Petitioners also allege that, in the absence of a finding that

safety in air commerce or air transportation 1s involved, there is a

lack of jurisdiction to revoke under 49 U.S.C. § 1429. However,

the Board in its decision stated :

“Upon consideration of the briefs of the parties, and the entire

record, the Board has determined that safety in air commerce

or air transportation and the public interest require affirma-

tion of the Administrator’s orders revoking the certificates of

all six respondents.” . .

There is evidence to support that finding and we will not disturb it.

Al0

Appendix B.

investigator deposed Reddecliff in the presence of his at-

torney. While the petitioners did not know all that was

transpiring, certainly they were aware that a much broader

investigation was underway than that focusing solely on

the accident of January 6, 1974.

Petitioners assert that the Administrator’s decision to

revoke the certificates on an emergency basis denied them

ihe opportunity for a hearing before being deprived of

their livelihood. Unquestionably, as a result of the loss of

certification, Air East was put out of business, and the

pilots could not pursue their customary occupations with-

out their licenses.

But under 49 U.S.C. §1429(a), emergency revoca-

tion has an effect limited in time to a period of sixty days.

While no hearing is required before revocation, tl. statute

provides that an appeal by the licensee must be decided

within sixty days. If the hearing establishes that the Ad-

ministrator’s action was not justified, the licenses can be

restored immediately. Thus, while the action is termed an

“emergency revocation,” it is for all intents and purposes a

suspension for sixty days or less. We point this out, not to

invoke a de minimis concept, but to demonstrate that the

statutory procedure does afford a prompt adjudication

after revocation. We do decognize that the suspension of

a business for sixty days or a forced unemployment for

that period is a grave matter which should not be treated

lightly.

* Indeed, petitioners assert that they did not have sufficient

time to prepare their defense and appeal to the Board. But, the

expedited disposition mandated by the statute is for the benefit of

the licensees, and they were free to waive it. Probably, for eco-

nomic reasons, petitioners chose not to do so. While recognizing

their difficulties, we are not persuaded that prejudice resulted or

that a hearing at a later date would have produced a different

result.

i nh rene nn

All

Appendia B.

Due process is flexible and must be analyzed in the

context of its application. What is reasonable in one situa-

tion where there is time to pursue a leisurely and reflective

study of the circumstances may be impractical and danger-

ous to life itself in another situation. Here, the stakes

were high indeed—a threat to the lives of passengers who

entrusted themselves to an air carrier which they had every

right to assume was in compliance with the strict regula-

tions of a specialized government agency. Even though the

loss of the privilege of operating aircraft, albeit tempo-

rary, is critical to those who are certified, that hardship is

outweighed by the disaster that could befall the passengers.

When the balancing of the public interest in safety

against a licensee’s right to a hearing before revocation

involves factors such as we have here, no extensive discus-

sion of authority is necessary. We need only remark that

in this instance we are not concerned with such relatively

less critical problems as the desirability of the collection

of a judgment by an individual against the holder of a

driver’s license,® or the possible difficulty of recoupment

when a welfare payment is erroneously made.’ Indeed,

here the consequences of inaction may be even worse than

where the seizure of misbranded food products before hear-

ing has been sustained,” or where the justification for sum-

mary action was prevention of a bank’s failure.” And

surely, if the summary seizure of property to collect taxes

® Bell v. Burson, 402 U.S. 535, 91 S.Ct. 1586, 29 L.Ed.2d 90

(1971).

1° Goldberg v. Kelly, 397 U.S. 254, 90 §.Ct. 1011, 25 L.Ed.2d

287 (1970).

11 Ewing v. Mytinger and Casselberry, Inc., 339 U.S. 594, 70

S.Ct. 870, 94 L.Ed. 1088 (1950).

12 Fahey v. Mallonee, 332 U.S. 245, 67 S.Ct. 1552, 91 L.Ed.

2030 (1947).

A12

Appendix B.

meets constitutional standards,"* there can be no doubt of

the result where the threat to life is real. See also Aircrane,

Ine. v. Butterfield, 369 F.Supp. 598 (E.D.Pa.1974).

We do not mean to imply that an agency like the

F.A.A. is to be given carte blanche to exercise its power

arbitrarily and capriciously. If these were only minor

violations of a bookkeeping or technical nature or more

serious charges of dubious authenticity, obviously dif-

ferent considerations would apply. But here, the accu-

sations went to grave wrongdoing which jeopardized pub-

lic safety and were supported by statements of apparently

knowledgeable individuals.

Petitioners complain that, since the Administrator

took six weeks to collect evidence and review it before

ex parte revocation, the lack of urgency was patent. But

that argument cuts another way as well. It demonstrates

that the revocations were not hasty or ill-considered and

took place only after serious efforts had been made to

establish the validity of the charges. Once the Admin-

istrator concluded that irreparable harm could result at

any time, withdrawals of operating privileges were justi-

fied, if not demanded, by the public interest. The reality

of the safety hazard was sufficiently established by the

preliminary investigation to justify the emergency pro-

cedures utilized here.

The petitioners were aware that an investigation was

underway because they had been deposed and the com-

pany’s records had been subpoenaed. To some extent,

therefore, they had been given an opportunity to present

explanatory material before the revocations occurred.

There is no necessity, therefore, to consider under what

** Phillips v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 283 U.S. 589,

51 S.Ct. 608, 75 L.Ed. 1289 (1931).

i l

NER Oe tee ee Ee.

re

Se ee ee ee ee

Al3

Appendiz B.

circumstances an invitation to submit exculpatory mate-

rial might be necessary before summary action by the

Administrator.

The petitioners urge that the statute is unconstitu-

tionally vague in authorizing the Administrator to dis-

pense with a prior hearing when “he is of the opinion

that an emergency requiring immediate action exists in

respect to air safety in commerce,” 49 U.S.C. § 1485(a).

They assert that “safety” is too general a term or, at

the least, that some appropriate regulations should have

been drawn to delineate the Administrator’s discretion.

But, the congressional intent is clear from the language

of the statute. The primary concern is that of public

safety, and in order to carry out the purpose of the legis-

lation, the scope of authority was necessarily couched in

broad terms. To limit the exercise of this discretion

would be to frustrate the ends to which the statute was

directed.

Tl.

TserE Was Dvr Process aT THE HEARING

Petitioners assert that they were denied a fair hear-

ing because of procedural irregularities which occurred

during the course of the administrative process. They

cite as an example the Board’s regulations which re-

quire the production of “a concise and complete statement

of the facts relied upon.’"* The record reveals, how-.

ever, that the administrative law judge at a pre-hearing

conference ordered the filing of a more specific statement

by the Administrator. In response, the government sub-

mitted its so-called “Bill of Particulars” which, though

415 C.F.R. §§ 421.4(d), 421.23.

Al4

Appendix B.

not completely satisfactory to the petitioners, set forth

in greater detail the various acts claimed to support the

individual charges. Additionally, the names of witnesses

who were expected to testify as to each count were in-

cluded. Moreover, the government was required to de-

liver to petitioners’ counsel copies of the depositions

secured during the investigation period. The administra-

tive law judge’s orders effected a more comprehensive

disclosure of the government’s case than is customary in

the normal civil or criminal cases in the district court.

A reading of the transcript reveals that the administra-

tive law judge was conscious of the burden imposed upon

the petitioners by the stringent time limitation and, ac-

cordingly, ordered the government to do all but write a

script for the hearing.

The petitioners pressed strongly for specific dates and

times for each of the violations cited by the Administra-

tor. In some instances, this was not possible because the

witnesses had no independent means of fixing the precise

day or hour when some of the incidents oceurred. Un-

derstandably, this posed difficulties for the petitioners

who might have desired to produce such data as weather

reports to discredit testimony with respect to flying condi-

tions. Nevertheless, it appears that the witnesses did their

best to pinpoint dates when possible and narrowed times

to weeks or months when no other data were available.

If only a single witness had provided this type of evi-

dence, there might be difficulty in determining whether it

was sufficiently probative to sustain the burden of proof.

However, the cumulative effect of the testimony of the

many witnesses who appeared and their complementary

corroboration made it possible for the fact finder to de-

cide the contested issues. In this proceeding as in most

instances where oral testimony is important, absolute pre-

—

Al5

Appendiz B.

cision, desirable though it may be, was simply not possible.

The generalizations were not more prevalent and, in fact,

less so than in other proceedings. Cella v. United States

208 F.2d 783 (7th Cir. 1953).

Other alleged deficiencies in the hearing process have

also been urged upon us. We have examined them in the

light of the record and find no prejudicial error.”

III.

THERE Was SuBSTANTIAL EvIpENCE TO SUPPORT THE

FINDINGS OF THE BoarpD

In reviewing an appeal from the Board, we are bound

by its findings of fact if supported by substantial evi-

dence. 49 U.S.C. §1486(e). We will not abdicate our

function by defining “substantial” as a scintilla, Doe v.

Dept. of Transportation, 412 F.2d 674 (8th Cir. 1969),

see Davis, Treatise on Administrative Law § 20.01, but

nevertheless, we must rely on the ability of the hearing

officer to make judgments on witnesses’ credibility. In that

spirit we have evaluated the record, a voluminous one,

and find that the substantial evidence test has been more

than satisfied. What the petitioners urge, in effect, is

to reverse the hearing officers findings on the credibility

of witnesses. We decline to do so.

15 Petitioners allege that (1) investigators destroyed their notes

on ae with Aa (copies of the statements were pro-

duced); (2) the Administrator sent a letter to the Board —

ing allegedly prejudicial information (we do not find it so); (3)

the findings of the administrative law judge did not comply wi ;

the regulations (we find the oral decision to be ee —

unusually well-detailed) ; and (4) oral argument before the —

should have been granted and the Board should have disqua

itself (we find no merit to these).

Al6

Appendix B.

Although it is true that a few of the witnesses may

have had personal differences with some of the petitioners,

not all did. Some of the witnesses had reason to fear

FAA. proceedings for their own violations occurring

while in the employ of Air East, but the fact that any

of them had been promised consideration by the agency is

not, in and of itself, sufficient to discredit their testimony.

The possibility of bias was repeatedly drawn to the atten-

tion of the administrative law judge by petitioners’ able

counsel, and we have no doubt that this factor was prop-

erly evaluated before the decision was announced.

The only evidence presented in favor of the petitioners

was their own testimony, and obviously, that had to be

evaluated in the light of self-interest—certainly, as potent

an element in credibility judgments as those which the

petitioners find applicable to the government witnesses.

It is not necessary to review the evidence in detail.

Instead, we will cite only a few examples to illustrate the

nature of the testimony which petitioners would have us

reject. For example, the petitioners denied all violations

of overloading the aircraft on scheduled flights; yet, seven

pilots testified that they had been ordered by petitioners

McKinney and Talient to ignore the weight limits so that

flight schedules could be met. One of the witnesses

related an incident which took place on August 13, 1973,

when, as the result of an improper load balance, the plane

nearly fell on its tail as passengers boarded.

Five pilots testified that they were instructed by the

company to use unauthorized approaches at Johnstown

and Altoona and that they, along with petitioner pilots,

sometimes did so. Similarly, ten pilots detailed the com-

pany policy of flying below F.A.A.-prescribed minimnm

descent altitudes while under instrument flight conditions.

Al7

Appendia B.

Although petitioners deny such conduct, there is credible

evidence to the contrary.

A telling example illustrating the difficulties of peti-

tioners’ case involved Air East’s own weather observer.

He testified that between the dates of May 22 and May

25, 1973, he was a patient in the hospital on self-care

status.° Although he stated that he had prepared the

weather and visibility reports at the airport during this

period, the medical librarian from the hospital produced

records indicating that the weather observer was actually

in the hospital at those hours. The administrative law

judge characterized this Air East employee as “a man

who the evidence shows as worthy of absolutely no belief

whatsoever.”

Recitation of other instances described in the testimony

would unduly lengthen this opinion. We think it sufficient

to say that a careful review of the record reveals that

the test prescribed for appellate review of adminisira-

tive proceedings has been met.

IV.

Tue Sanctions WERE Not Excessive

We need only summarily treat the petitioners’ conten-

tion that the sanction of revocation was not appropriate.

The evidence of numerous incidents in which the public

safety was compromised justifies the substantial depriva-

tions imposed. They were within the scope of the au-

16 Self-care patients were permitted to leave the hospital after

hours only with their doctors’ permission. In doing so, they were

required to sign in and out, noting the times and dates.

A18

Appendiz B.

thority granted to the Board and we find no error in the

revocation orders.”

In summary, we find that the action of the National

Transportation Safety Board was supported by substan-

tial evidence and that the petitioners’ procedural rights

were not violated. Therefore, the decision of the Board

will be affirmed.

‘There is a difference of opinion as to whether the enforce-

ment provisions are intended to be remedial or punitive in nature.

See Sabinske v. C.A.B., 346 F.2d 142 (5th Cir. 1965); Nadiak v.

C.A.B., 305 F.2d 588 (5th Cir. 1962); Pangburn v. C.A.B., 311

ton 349 (Ist Cir. 1962). That debate does not affect our decision

ere.

We have been advised that after one year petitioners may ask

for reinstatement. We echo the caveat in Nadiak v. C.A.B., supra,

that passing upon such an application is a matter entrusted to the

discretion of the Administrator and that nothing we have said or

have implied in this opinion is intended to apply in that context.

Al9

APPENDIX C.

Opinion of the National Transportation Safety Board.

Servep: May 13, 1974

NTSB Order No. EA-581

Unrrep States or AMERICA

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD

Wasuinoton, D.C.

Adopted by the Nationa, TRANSPORTATION Sarety Boarp

at its office in Washington, D. C.

on the 10th day of May 1974

ALEXANDER P. BUTTERFIELD,

Administrator, Federal Aviation Dockets SE-

Administrator, 9509, 2511,

Complainant, 9519, 2512,

ve. 9513, and

2522

Arr East, Inc., et al.,

Respondents.

Opinion AND ORDER

This proceeding involves emergency orders of —

tion issued by the Administrator against the fo tar

certificates: The air taxi/commercial operator certifica

of Air East, Inc., d/b/a Allegheny Commuter ; the =

mercial pilot certifiate of Charles A. —s ( rl

President of Flight Operations for Air East) ; oe —,

transport pilot certificate of James A. Tallent (Chief Pi

A20

Appendiz C.

for Air East); the commercial pilot certificate of Jeffrey

H. Wilkinson (Training Officer for Air East); the repair

station certificate of Air East, Inc., and the mechanic

certificate of Thomas Reddecliff (Chief of Maintenance for

Air East). Following motions by both the Administrator

and respondents, all six cases were consolidated for hearing

before Administrative Law Judge Fred L. Woodlock. The

hearing commenced on March 21, 1974. spanned 25 con-

secutive working days, and concluded with the final

presentation of testimony and with oral argument on April

24, 1974. On April 26, 1974, Judge Woodlock issued an

oral decision in which he affirmed all six orders of revoca-

tion but dismissed certain charges in the various com-

plaints.’

With respect to Air East, d/b/a Allegheny Commuter,

the law judge found that the following charges where estab-

lished by the preponderance of evidence:

(2)? Air East, as a matter of policy on numerous oc-

casions, operated, caused, or permitted to be

operated, aircraft in operations under Part 135

of the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR) when

such aircraft either exceeded the maximum ecertifi-

cated takeoff weight and/or were outside the ap-

proved center of gravity limits, in violation of

sections 91.9° and 91.31(a)* of the FAR and sec-

‘An excerpt from the hearing transcript containing the in-

itial decision is attached.

*The paragraph numbers herein correspond to the

number as set forth in the complaint (or order). At the end of

each charge is a reference to the transcript pages on which the

law Judge discussed the evidence supporting that particular charge.

* Section 91.9 reads as follows:

‘$91.9 Carless or reckless operation.

(footnote continued on following page)

A21

Appendiz C.

tion 610(a)(4) and (5) of the Federal Aviation

Act of 1958° (hereinafter referred to as the Act).

(Tr. 3849-3861)

(3) Air East, when conducting the operations de-

scribed in Paragraph (2), directed or permitted

its flight personnel to insert false and fictitious

computations on the required load manifests so

that they falsely showed such aircraft did not ex-

ceed the approved maximum takeoff weight and/or

that the loading fell within the center of gravity

limits, in violation of section 135.43(c) of the

FAR.* (Tr. 3861-3863)

(footnote continued from preceding page)

No person may operate an aircraft in a careless or reckless

uaa as to endanger the life or property of another.

* Section 91.31(a) provides as follows:

‘$91.31 Civil aircraft operating limitations and marking re-

ne ireraft shall comply with

Each person operating a civil aircraft shall comply wi

the pe Ben od Nimitations for that aircraft prescribed by the cer-

tificating authority of the country of registry.

j i llows :

® Section 610(a) (4) and (5) of the Act provides as fo

‘““§ 610. [72 Stat. 780, as amended by 84 Stat. 234, 49 U.S.C.

1430]

(a) It shall be unlawful—

* * > * * >

i i ithout an

4) For an rson to operate as an air carrier wit

air poe. eauune certificate, or in violation of the terms of

any such certificate; -_

5) For any person to operate aircraft in air comme ,

amie of any other rule, regulation, or certificate of mm ey

retary of Transporation® under this title; . . . ( Footnote omitted.

® Section 135.43(¢) provides as follows :

‘*§ 135.43 Recordkeeping requirements.

(footnote continued on following page)

A22

Appendiz C.

(4) Air East, on numerous occasions, failed to prepare

or cause to be prepared as required at takeoff time,

and to retain, load manifests for operations in-

volving the carriage of mail by aircraft under

contract with the U.S. Postal Service, in violation

of section 135.43(c) of the FAR.” (Tr. 3863-3864)

(5) Air East, on numerous occasions, knowingly en-

couraged or permitted or instructed and required

its pilots, when conducting operations under Parts

91 and 135, to use instrument approach procedures

at Johnstown—Cambria County and Martinsburg

—Blair County (Altoona) Airports, which had

not been approved by the Federal Aviation Ad-

ministration (FAA) in FAR Part 97, in violation

of sections 91.116(a)* and 91.9° of the FAR and

section 610(a)(5) of the Act.” (Tr. 3864-3867)

(footnote continued from preceding page)

(ce) For multiengine aircraft for which two pilots are required

by this chapter for operations under VFR, each certificate holder

shall prepare or cause to be prepared a load manifest containing

the following information concerning the loading of the aircraft

at takeoff time—

(1) The number of passengers;

(2) The total weight of the loaded aircraft;

(3) The maximum allowable takeoff weight for that flight;

(4) The center of gravity of the loaded aircraft; and

(5) The center of gravity limits for the loaded aircraft.’’

"Id.

* Section 91.116(a) provides as follows:

“*$91.116 Takeoff and landing under IFR: General.

(a) Instrument approaches to civil airports. Unless otherwise

authorized by the Administrator (including ATC), each person

operating an aircraft shall, when an instrument letdown to an

airport is necessary, use a standard instrument approach proce-

dure prescribed for that airport in Part 97 of this chapter.’’

® See footnote 3, supra.

#© See footnote 5, supra.

A23

Appendix C.

(6) Air East, on numerous occasions, knowingly en-

couraged or permitted or instructed and required

its pilots, when conducting operations under Parts

91 and 135, to use altitudes and/or visibility

minimums at the airports described in paragraph

(5) which were below those prescribed in the FAA

approved instrument approach procedure as de-

scribed in FAR Part 97, in violation of sections

91.117(a) and (b)™ and 91.9% of the FAR and

section 610(a)(5) of the Act. (Tr. 3867-3873)

(7) Air East operated or caused or permitted to be

operated under Part 135 numerous flight opera-

tions into and out of the Johnstown—Cambria

Airport in weather conditions less than the VFR

(visual flight rules) minimums when the Johns-

town Flight Service Station (FSS) was not in

operation and without the pilots being given

weather reports from an accredited weather ob-

2 Section 91.117(a) and (b) provides as follows:

‘*§91.117 Limitations on use of instument approach proce-

dures (other than Category II). es

(a) General. Unless otherwise authorized by the Adminis-

trator, each person operating an aircraft using an instrument

approach procedure prescribed in Part 97 of this chapter shall

comply with the requirements of this section. This section does

not apply to the use of Category II approach procedures.

(b) Descent below MDA or DH. No person may operate an

aireraft below the prescribed minimum descent altitude or con-

tinue an approach below the decision height unless—

(1) The aircraft is in a position from which a normal approach

to the runway of intended landing can be made; and

(2) The approach threshold of that runway, or approach lights

or other markings identifiable with the approach end of that run-

way, are clearly visible to the pilot.’’

12 See footnote 3, supra.

18 See footnote 5, supra.

A24

Appendiz C.

server, in violation of section 135.65,"* 135.111, (a)*®

and 91.116(c)** of the FAR and section 610(a) (5)

of the Act.” (Tr. 3874-3879)

(8) Air East initiated, adopted, or permitted the use

of company policies, practices, or procedures

which:

** Section 135.65 provides as follows:

‘“*$ 135.65 Weather reports and forecasts.

_ Whenever a person operating an aircraft in operations to which

this part applies is required to use a weather report or forecast,

he shall use that of the U.S. National Weather Service or an

accredited observer. However, in the case of operations under

VFR, the pilot in command may, if such a report or forecast is

not available, use weather information based on his own observa-

tions or on those of other persons able to supply appropriate

observations. ’’

*® Section i135.111(a) provides as follows:

**§ 135.111 IFR: Takeoff, approach, and landing minimums.

(a) No pilot may begin an instrument approach procedure if

the latest weather report indicates the weather conditions at that

airport are below its authorized IFR landing minimums.’’

*® Section 91.116(c) provides as follows:

‘*§91.116 Takeoff and landing under IFR: General.

(c) Civil airport takeoff minimums. Unless otherwise author-

ized by the Administrator, no person operating an aircraft under

Part 121, 123, 129, or 135 of this chapter may take off from a

civil airport under IFR unless weather conditions are at or above

the weather minimums for IFR takeoff prescribed for that airport

in Part 97 of this chapter. If takeoff minimums are not prescribed

in Part 97 of this chapter, for a particular airport, the following

minimums apply to takeoffs under IFR for aircraft operating

under those parts: .

(1) Aircraft having two engines or less: 1 statute mile visi-

bility.

(2) Aircraft having more than two engines: One-half statute

mile visibility.’’ , R r , : P

17 See footnote 5, supra.

A25

Appendiz C.

(a) Prohibited its pilots from logging inoperative

or malfunctioning aircraft instruments, engines,

or equipment in the appropriate spaces in the air-

eraft flight log; (Tr. 3879-3880)

(b) Contrary to the Air East company manual,

required its flight personnel to report such mal-

functions as described in subparagraph (a) above

on a separate sheet of paper or orally to main-

tenance personnel. (Tr. 3880-3882)

(c) Prohibited its maintenance personnel from en-

tering such flight personnel reported discrepancies

in the flight log until such time as the required

parts or repairs could be accomplished (Tr. 3882-

3885)

(d) Permitted, required, or caused the falsifica-

tion of aircraft maintenance records required to

be maintained by Air East. (Tr. 3885-3886)

(e) Permitted, required, or caused the return to

service for operations under Part 139 aircraft

which had not had required airworthiness inspec-

tions and/or maintenance required by the FAR.

(Tr. 3886-3887 )

(f) Permitted, required, caused, or allowed opera-

tion of aircraft under Part 135 when required in-

struments and/or equipment were inoperable. (Tr.

3887-3889 )

(g) Permitted, required, caused, or allowed the

operation of aircraft when such aircraft were not

in an airworthy condition. (Tr. 3889-3892)

By reason of the actions described in paragraph

8, Air East repeatedly violated sections 91.9,"

18 See footnote 3, supra.

A26

Appendiz C.

91.29(a),** 91.165,” 135.60(¢),”* and 135.143(a) and

(b)* of the FAR and sections 610(a) (1)** (4)** and

(5)** of the Act.

** Section 91.29(a) provides as follows:

“$91.29 Civil aircraft airworthiness.

(a) No person may operate a civil ai it is i

airworthy condition.’’ . ne

*° Section 91.165 provides as follows:

“*§91.165 Maintenance required.

_ Each owner or operator of an aircraft shall have that aircraft

inspected as prescribed in Subpart D or § 91.169 of this part, as

appropriate, and § 91.170 of this part and shall, between required

inspections, have defects repaired as prescribed in Part 43 of this

chapter. In addition, he shall ensure that maintenance personnel

make appropriate entries in the aircraft and maintenance records

indicating the aircraft has been released to service.’’

*? Section 135.60(g) provides a sfollows:

‘$135.60 Approved aircraft inspection program.

7 > >. 7. + 7

(g) Each certificate holder who has an approved aircraft in-

spection program shall have each aircraft that is subject to the

program inspected in accordance with the program.”’

*? Section 135.143(a) and (b) provides as follows:

‘“*$ 135.143 General requirements.

_(a) No person may operate an aircraft in operations to which

this part applies unless that aircraft and its equipment meet the

requirements of applicable regulations.

_(b) No person may operate an aircraft in operations to which

this part applies, unless the required instruments and equipment

in it have been approved and are in operable condition’’

*8 Section 610(a)(1) of the Act provides as follows:

“so; 610 [72 Stat. 780, as amended by 84 Stat. 234749 U.S.C,

(a) It shall be unlawful—

(1) For any person to operate in air commerce any civil air-

craft for which there is not currently in effect an airworthiness

certificate, or in violation of the terms of any such certificate; . . .”

** See footnote 5 supra.

25 Td.

A27

Appendiz C.

(10) Air East maintained its pilot flight time records

in accordance with the maintenance “Time in Serv-

ice” definition (wheels-off to wheels-on) rather

than pilot flight time (block-to-block). As a result

thereof, Air East failed to keep the flight time

records for all of its pilots in sufficient detail to

determine compliance with flight time limitations,

in violation of section 135.43(a)(4)(vil) of the

FAR®* and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.” (Tr.

3893-3895 )

(12) From April 12, 1973 to date, Air East knowingly

utilized the services of at least one pilot as pilot-

in-command in Part 135 operations when such

pilot or pilots had not completed the routes and

airports flight check given by the Administrator or

an approved check pilot, in violation of section

135.122(a) of the FAR* and section 610 of the

Act. (Tr. 3895-3896)

26 Section 135.43(a) (4) (vii) provides as follows :

‘*§ 135.43 Recordkeeping requirements.

(a) Each certificate holder shall keep at his principal business

office and make available for inspection by the Administrator the

following :

* o * * > *

(4) An individual record of each pilot used by him in opera-

tions subject to this part, including the following information:

7 * * . * 7

(vii) The pilot’s flight time in sufficient detail to determine

compliance with the flight time limitations of this part.”’

2? See footnote 5, supra.

28 Section 135.122(a) provides as follows:

‘*$ 135.122 Pilot-in-command qualifications: Routes and air-

ports.

(a) The certificate holder may not utilize a pilot, nor may any

person serve as pilot in command of a flight under IFR unless,

since the beginning of the 12th calendar month before that service

(footnote continued on following page)

A28

Appendiz C.

(13) From April 29, 1973 to date, Air East knowingly

and continuously used the services of at least one

pilot in a Beechcraft Model 99 aircraft when he

had not passed a flight check in that type aircraft

given by the Administrator or an authorized check

pilot in that type aircraft since the beginning of

the 12th calendar month before that service, in

violation of section 135.138(b) of the FAR” and

section 610(a)(2)*° and (5)°* of the Act. (Tr.

3896-3899 )

(footnote continued from preceding page)

he has passed a flight check in one of the types of airplanes that

he is to fly, given by an approved check pilot who is qualified in

the aircraft, or by the Administrator, consisting of at least one

flight over a representative airway or approved off-airway route,

or portion thereof, over which he may be assigned to fly.”

*® Section 135.138(b) provides as follows:

“§ 135.138 Initial and recurrent pilot testing requirements.

(b) No certificate holder may use the services of a pilot, nor

may any person serve as a pilot, in any aircraft unless, since the

beginning of the 12th calendar month before that service, he has

passed a flight check given to him by the Administrator or an

authorized check pilot in that class of aircraft, if single-engine air-

plane other than turbojet, or that type of aircraft, if helicopter,

multiengine, or turbojet, to determine the pilot’s competence in

practical skills and techniques in that aircraft or class of aircraft,

including at least the maneuvers that are set forth in § 61.117

(b)(2), except (iii) (f); §61.117(b)(3), except (i), (ii) (iii),

(v), and (vi); § 61.117(s); § 61.121(b(1) and (2); § 61.121(e) (2)

and (3) of this chapter, and related advisory circulars for pilot

certification in the class of aircraft the pilot is to operate. How-

ever, a pilot who holds an instrument rating need not demonstrate

the instrument flight maneuvers in § 61.117(c).”

%° Section 610(a) (2) of the Act provides as follows:

“SEC. 610.. [72 Stat. 780, as amended by 84 Stat. 234, 49 U.S.C.

1430] (a) It shall be unlawful—

(footnote continued on following page)

A29

Appendix C.

(14) From April 30, 1973, to date, Air East knowingly

and continuously used the services of at least one

pilot-in-command under IFR (instrument flight

rules) when he had not passed an instrument check

given by the Administrator or an approved check

pilot, in violation of section 135.131(a) and (b) of

the FAR®™ and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.”

(3899-3900)

(15) Air East knowingly falsified, or caused or per-

mitted the falsification of, numerous pilot training

records to show that flight crewmembers who had

not been trained or tested were trained or tested

and thereby failed to make available the true and

(footnote continued from preceding page)

(2) For any person to serve in any capacity as an airman in

connection with any civil aircraft, aircraft engine, propeller or

appliance used or intended for use, in air commerce without an air-

man certificate authorizing him to serve in such capacity, or in

violation of any order, rule, or regulation issued under this

title; ...”

808 See footnote 5, supra.

%1 Section 135.131(a) and (b) provides as follows:

“§ 135.131 Pilot in command: Instrument check requirements.

(a) No certificate holder may use a pilot, nor may any person

serve as a pilot in command of an aircraft under IFR unless, since

the beginning of the sixth calendar month before that use, he has

passed an instrument check and the Administrator or an author-

ized check pilot has so certified in a letter of competency.

(b) No pilot may use any type of instrument approach proce-

dure under IFR unless, since the beginning of the sixth calendar

month before that use, he has successfully demonstrated that pro-

cedure and the Administrator or an authorized check pilot has so

certified in a letter of competency.”

82 See footnote 5, supra.

A30

Appendiz C.

correct information, in violation of sections

135.43(a)(4)(vi) and (x) of the FAR.™ (Tr. 3900).

(16) Air East, by reason of its actions as described in

paragraphs (12), (13) and (14), failed to provide

aircraft and facilities to enable its pilots, who

were engaged in IFR and multiengine operations,

to maintain and demonstrate properly their ability

to conduct such operations, in violation of section

135.37 of the FAR.“ (Tr. 3901)

(17) Air East, on at least one occasion, failed to mail

or deliver to the appropriate representative of the

Administrator a summary report concerning at

least one of its multiengine aircraft, reporting the

required information relating to propeller feather-

** Section 135.43(a) (4) (vi) and (x) reads as follows:

“§ 135.43 Record keeping requirements.

(a) Each certificate holder shall keep at his principal business

office and make available for inspection by the Administrator the

following:

* . aa * * >

(4) An individual record of each pilot used by him in opera-

tions subject to this part, including the following information :

(vi) The date and result of each of the initial and recurrent

proficiency tests and instrument and route checks required by this

part and the type of aircraft flown during that test or check.

(x) The date of the completion of the initial phase and each

recurrent phase of the training required by this part.”

* Section 135.37 provides as follows:

‘“§ 135.37 Aircraft and facilities for recent flight experience.

Each certificate holder shall provide aircraft and facilities to

enable each of his pilots who is authorized to engage in IFR and

multiengine operations to maintain and demonstrate his ability to

conduct those operations.”

leh a Na gine a UR Mosh se SI nd Ag

A31

Appendiz C.

ing in flight, in violation of section 135.59(b) of

the FAR.*

(19) Air East, through its officials, put into effect and

accomplished the company policies, practices, and

procedures described hereinabove by intimidating,

coercing, or threatening its pilots and maintenance

personnel who refused, or were reluctant, to com-

ply with such unapproved, illegal, or unsafe polli-

cies, practices, or procedures. (Tr. 3904-3907)

The law judge dismissed the following charges included

in the Administrator’s complaint against Air East:

(9) Air East, on numerous occasions, scheduled pilots

for duty in excess of the maximum allowable 14

hours in any 24 consecutive hours sip talaga

required 10 hours of continuous rest in an}

poe period, in violation of section 135.136(b)

and (f) of the FAR® and section 610(a) (9) of the

Act.” (See Tr. 3892-3).

5 Section 135.59(b) provides as follows: a

“§ 135. Mechanical interruption summary report.

Be certificate holder shall mail or deliver, before the -s

the 10th day of the following month, a summary oly =

following oceurrences in multiengine aircraft for each month to .

FAA District Office having jurisdiction over the area in which the

certificate holder’s principal business office is located :

* . 7 . . = .

ber of propeller featherings in flight, listed by

am. 7 pode and for and airplane on which it was in-

stalled... .”

36 Section 135.136(b) and (f) provides as follows:

“§ 135.136 Flight and duty time limitations.

i i i ber, and

ertifieate holder may assign a flight crewmemt , a

no Set prone may accept an assignment, for duty during

(footnote continued on following page)

A32

Appendiz C.

(11) Air East knowingly utilized pilots as required

flight crewmembers when such pilots had not re-

ceived initial flight training, as required by section

135.137 of the FAR.** (See Tr. 3895)

(18) Air East continuously permitted, instructed, or

knowingly authorized its pilots to use unsafe or

unapproved practices or procedures in the opera-

tion of company aircraft as follows:

(a) Pilots were prohibited from using reverse

pitch of propellers during landings. Such prohibi-

tion prevented the pilots from becoming proficient

in the use of reverse propeller pitch in the event

that its use was required in an emergency; (b) As

a general rule, first officers were not permitted to

execute takeoffs or landings and therefore did not

(footnote continued from preceding page)

flight time unless that assignment provides for at least 10 con-

secutive hours of rest during the 24-hour period preceding the

planned completion of the assignment.

(f) No certificate holder may assign any flight crewmember,

and no flighterew member may accept an assignment, for duty

during flight time if he has been assigned to any duty with the

certificate holder in connection with operations under this part

during any required rest period.”

7 See footnote 5, supra.

** Section 135.137 provides as follows:

“§ 135.137 Initial and recurrent training requirements.

No certificate holder may use the services of, nor may any per-

son serve as, a pilot or flight attendant crewmember in operations

under this part unless that crewmember has completed the appro-

priate initial or recurrent training phase of the training program

appropriate to the type of operation in which he is to serve since

the beginning of the 12th calendar month before that service.

This section does not apply to a certificate holder who uses only

himself as a pilot.”

5 AOR ae aes Mo SIN:

A33

Appendiz C.

maintain the proficiency expected of a pilot being

utilized as a first officer. (See Tr. 3413)

on of all of the circumstances pertaining

” oP agente of aircraft as alleged in the or"

going paragraphs (in the entire complaint), an

in violations of the FAR or the Act specified

therein, Air East repeatedly violated sections

605(a) of the Act. (See Tr. 3907-3908 )

concluded that safety in air commerce or

PP inet and the public interest require the ee

cation of the air taxi/commercial operator certificate °

Air East (Tr. 3908), and he thereupon affirmed the Admin-

; b

wie eae to respondents Tallent, McKinney, and Wil-

kinson, the law judge found that the following charges were

established by a preponderance of the evidence:

While serving as captain and pilot-in-command for

Air East in the operation of aircraft carrying yanee-

gers and/or cargo under Part 135 and/or while = ing

as pilot-in-command on operations under Part 91:

merous occasions, while operating such

pode hr IFR, each respondent used —

approach procedures at J ohnston-Cambria aod a

tinsburg, Blair County (Altoona), Airports w +" -

not been approved by the FAA in FAR Part 9,

j llows :

” ion 605(a) of the Act provides as fo

ann oa 72 Stat. 778, 49 U.S.C. 1425] (a) It o- - =

duty of each air earrier to make, or cause to be made, - : -_ “

tion, maintenance, overhaul, and repair of all equipm —-

i transportation as may be required by this Act, A A —

lara of the Seeley of Tenn eae

. And its e

pan oy inspecting, maintaining, or overhauling equipment to

( footnote continued on following page)

AMA

Appendiz C.

violation of sections 91.116(a)* and 91.9" of the FAR

and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.** (Tallent (Tr. 3910-

3911); McKinney (Tr. 3917-3918); Wilkinson (Tr.

3925-3926) ).

(b) On numerous occasions, while operating such air-

eraft under IFR, each respondent used altitude and/or

visibility minimums at Johnston-Cambria and Martins-

burg, Blair County (Altoona), Airports which were

below those prescribed in the FAA-approved instru-

ment approach procedures as described in FAR Part

97, in violation of sections 91.116(a)* and (b),** 91.117

(a) and (b),* and 91.9 of the FAR and section

(footnote continued from preceding page)

observe and comply with the requirements of this Act relating

thereto, and the orders, rules, and regulations issued thereunder.’’

(* Footnote omitted.)

*° See footnote 8, supra.

*2 See footnote 3, supra.

42 See footnote 5, supra.

*® See footnote 8, supra.

* Section 91.116(b) provides as follows:

“§91.116 Takeoff and landing under IFR: General.

(b) Landing minimums. Unless otherwise authorized by the

Administrator, no person operating an aircraft (except a military

aircraft of the United States) may land that aircraft using a stand-

ard instrument approach procedure prescribed in Part 97 of this

chapter unless the visibility is at or above the landing minimum

prescribed in that part for the procedure used. If the landing

minimum in a standard instrument approach procedure prescribed

in Part 97 of this chapter is stated in terms of ceiling and visi-

bility, the visibility minimum applies. However, the ceiling mini-

mum shall be added to the field elevation and that value observed

as the MDA or DH, as appropriate to the procedure being

executed.”

*° See footnote 11, supra.

*® See footnote 3, supra.

|

|

A35

Appendia C.

610(a)(5) of the Act (Tallent (Tr. 3911-3912) ;

McKinney (Tr. 3918-3920) ; Wilkinson (Tr. 3926)).

(ec) On more than one occasion while operating such

aircraft under IFR, each respondent deviated from an

ATC (air traffic control) clearance that had been ac-

cepted and acknowledged, without obtaining an

amended clearance, in violation of sections 91.75(a)“

and 91.9” of the FAR and section 610(a)(5) of the

Act.” (Tallent (Tr. 3912-3913) ; McKinney (Tr. 3920-

3921) ; Wikinson (Tr. 3926-3927) ).

(d) On more than one occasion, each respondent

operated an aircraft under VFR when he did not main-

tain the minimum distance from clouds as prescribed

in, and in violation of, sections 91.105(a)* and 91.9"

of the FAR and section 610(a) (5) of the Act.” (Tallent

*T See footnote 5, supra.

«8 Section 91.75(a) provides as follows: . .

“$91.75 Compliance with ATC clearances and instructions. .

(a) When an ATC clearance has been obtained, no pilot in

command may deviate from that clearance, except in an emergency,

unless he obtains an amended clearance. However, except in _

tive controlled airspace, this paragraph does not nog he _

cancelling an IRF flight plan if he is operating the VFR weather

conditions.”

© See footnote 3, supra.

50 See footnote 5, supra.

51 Section 91.105(a) provides, in pertinent part, as follows:

“§91.105 Basic VFR weather minimums. 2

t as provided in § 91.107, no person may operate an

a5. VFR when the flight visibility is less, or at a dis-

tance from clouds that is less, than that prescribed for the corre-

sponding altitude in the following table: (Table omitted. )

52 See footnote 3, supra.

58 See footnote 5, supra.

A36

Appendiz C.

(Tr. 3913-3914;); McKinney (Tr. 3921); Wilkinson

Tr. 3927)).

(e) On more than one occasion, respondents Tallent

and McKinney™ each operated an aircraft which was

not in an airworthy condition and failed to discontinue

such flight or flights when unairworthy mechanical con-

ditions existed, in violation of section 91.29(a)** and

(b)** of the FAR and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.*

(Tallent (Tr. 3914) ; McKinney (Tr. 3921-3922) )

(f) Each respondent operated aircraft on numerous

oceasions when such aircraft either exceeded the maxi-

mum certificated takeoff weight and/or were outside

the approved center of gravity limits, in violation of

sections 91.31(a)** and 91.9% of the FAR and section

610(a)(4) and (5) of the Act. (Tallent (Tr. 3915) ;

McKinney (Tr. 3922); Wilkinson (Tr. 3928) ).

(x) Between April 29, 1973, and the present time, re-

spondents McKinney and Wilkinson” knowingly and

‘4 Respondent Wilkinson was not charged under this paragreph.

55 See footnote 19, supra.

56 Section 91.29(b) provides as follows:

“$91.29 Civil aircraft airworthiness.

(b) The pilot in command of a civil aircraft is responsible for

determining whether that aircraft is in condition for safe flight.

He shall discontinue the flight when unairworthy mechanical or

structural sonditions occur.

5? See footnote 5, supra.

5° See footnote 4, supra.

5° See footnote 3, supra.

*° See footnote 5, supra.

61 Respondent Tallent was not charged under this paragraph.

A37

Appendiz C.

continuously served as pilot in Beechcraft model 99

aircraft when each had not passed a flight check in that

type of aircraft, given by the Administrator or an

authorized check pilot in that type of aircraft since the

beginning of the 12th calendar month before that

service, in violation of section 135.138(b) of the FAR®

and section 610(a)(5) of the Act® (McKinney Tr.

3922-3923) ; Wilkinson Tr. 3928-3920) ).

(h) From April 29, 1973, to date, respondents McKin-

ney and Wilkinson knowingly and continuously

served as pilot-in-command of a flight under IFR when

each had not passed a routes-and-airports flight check

given by the Administrator or by an approved check

pilot in violation of section 135.122(a) of the FAR®

and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.®° (McKinney (Tr.

3923-3924) ; Wilkinson (Tr. 3929)).

(i) From April 30, 1973, to date, each respondent

continuously and knowingly served as pilot in com-

mand under IFR when he had not passed an instru-

ment check given by the Administrator or by an

approved cheek pilot, in violation of section 135.131(a)

and (b) of the FAR” and section 610(a)(5) of the

62 See footnote 29, supra.

63 See footnote 5, supra.

* Respondent Tallent was not charged under this paragraph.

® See footnote 28, supra.

66 See footnote 5, supra.

67 In the case of respondent Tallent, this period ran from April

30 to October 18, 1973.

68 See footnote 31, supra.

A38

Appendix C.

Act. (Tallent (Tr. 3915-3916) ; McKinney (Tr. 3924) ;

Wilkinson (Tr. 3929)).

The law judge dismissed the charge against the above

three respondents regarding the alleged exceeding of crew

duty and rest times prescribed by section 135.136(b) and

(f) of the FAR.

The law judge then affirmed the orders revoking the

airman certificates of respondents Tallent, McKinney, and

Wilkinson.

With respect to Air East (the repair station), the law

judge found that the following charges were established

by a preponderance of evidence:

(2) Air East, in performing maintenance or altera-

tions on aircraft under authority of its repair station

certificate, on several occasions, approved such air-

craft for return to service without having performed

such required work in such a manner, and using mate-

rials of such quality, that the condition of such air-

craft was equal to its original or properly altered con-

dition, in violation of sections 43.13(a) and (b)”,

®° See footnote 5, supra.

7° Section 43.13(a) and (b) provides as follows:

“§ 43.13 Performance rules (general).

(a) Each person maintaining or altering, or performing pre-

ventive maintenance, shall use methods, techniques, and practices

acceptable to the Administrator. He shall use the tools, equip-

ment, and test apparatus necessary to assure completion of the

work in accordance with accepted industry practices. If special

equipment or test apparatus is recommended by the manufacturer

involved, he must use that equipment or apparatus or its equiva-

lent acceptable to the Administrator.

(b) Each person maintaining or altering, or performing pre-

ventive maintenance, shall do that work in such a manner and use

(footnote continued on following page)

" Den et

ome Dall = .

we or

- a Oot

—_e—7"— —_— — —— ——— |

A39

Appendiz C.

43.15(a)” and 145.57(a)” of the FAR (Tr. 3930-3931).

(a) Air East, in exercising the authority and privi-

leges of its repair station certificate, on numerous

oceasions, required, permitted, or caused aircraft, air-

frames, engines, instruments, or accessories which Air

East had maintained or altered to be approved for

return to service without such articles having been

inspected and determined to be airworthy by a quali-

fied inspector. This was accomplished by nonquali-

fied personnel and the subsequent making of fraudulent

or intentionally false entries and certifications in the

aircraft records. By reason of such actions, Air East

(footnote continued from preceding page)

materials of such a quality, that the condition of the aircraft, air-

frame, aircraft engine propeller, or appliance worked on will be at

least equal to its original or properly altered condition (with regard

to aerodynamic function, structural strength, resistance to vibration

and deterioration, and other qualities affecting airworthiness) .”

1 Section 43.15(a) provides as follows:

“§ 43.15 Additional performance rules for inspections.

(a) General. Each person performing a 100-hour, annual, or

progressive inspection required by Part 91 of this chapter or an

inspection required under Part 123 of this chapter, shall perform

those inspections in such a manner as to determine whether the

aireraft concerned meets all applicable airworthiness require-

ments.”

72 Section 145.57(a) provides as follows:

“$145.57 Performance standards.

(a) Except as provided in § 145.2, each certificated domestic

repair station shall perform its maintenance and alteration opera-

tions in accordance with the standards in Part 43 of this chapter.

It shall maintain, in current condition, all manufacturers’ service

manuals, instructions, and service bulletins that relate to the arti-

cles that it maintains or alters.’’

A40

Appendix C.

repeatedly violated sections 145.59(a)”, 43.5% and

43.11(a)” of the FAR. (Tr. 3931-3932)

8 Section 145.59(a) provides as follows:

‘“*§ 145.59 Inspection of work performed.

(a) Each certificated domestic repair station shall, before ap-

proving an airframe, powerplant, propeller, instrument, radio, or

accessory for return to service after maintaining or altering it,

have that article inspected by a qualified inspector. After per-

forming a maintenance or alteration operation, the station shall

certify on the maintenance or alteration record of the article that

it is airworthy.”’

7 Section 43.5 (a) provides as follows:

‘“§ 43.5 Return to service after maintenance, preventive main-

tenance, rebuilding, or alteration.

(a) No person may return to service any aircraft, airframe, air-

eraft engine, propeller, or appliance, that has undergone mainte-

nance, preventive maintenance, rebuilding, or alteration unless—

(1) It has been approved for return to service by a person

authorized under § 43.7;

2) The maintenance record entry required by § 43.9 has been

made;

(3) The repair or alteration form authorized by or furnished

by the Administrator has been executed in a manner prescribed by

the Administrator ; and

(4) If a repair or an alteration results in any change in the

aircraft operating limitations or flight data contained in the ap-

proved aircraft flight manual, those operating limitations or flight

data are appropriately revised and set forth as prescribed in

§ 91.31 of this chapter.”’

78 Section 43.11(a) provides as follows:

‘$43.11 Content, form, and disposition of annual, 100-hour,

and progressive inpection records.

(a) Maintenance record entries. The person approving or dis-

approving for returu to service an aircraft, airframe, aircraft en-

gine, propeller, or appliance after any annual, 100-hour, or pro-

gressive inspection required by Part 91 of this chapter shall make

(footnote continued on following page)

eee 5 | octet TET Tn

A4l

Appendiz C.

(4) On numerous occasions, Air East, when perform-

ing work and inspections under authority of its repair

station certificate, failed to maintain proper and ade-

quate records, naming the persons who supervised

and/or inspected that work, in that the records main-

tained by Air East failed to name the person actually

supervising and/or inspecting that work and then

fraudulently and/or intentionally falsified the record

to show that such supervision and/or inspection had

been performed by an authorized and qualified person,

(footnote continued from preceding page)

an entry in the maintenance record of that equipment, containing

the following information :

(1) The type of inspection (and for progressive inspections,

a brief description of the extent of the inspection).

(2) The date of the inspection and aircraft time in service.

(3) The signature (and if a certificated mechanic, the certificate

number) of the person approving or disapproving for return to

service, the aircraft, airframe, aircraft engine, propeller, or ap-

pliance.

(4) For annnal or 100-hour inspections if the aircraft is ap-

proved for return to service, the following or 4 similarly worded

statement—‘I certify that this aircraft has been inspected in ac-

cordance with (insert type) inspection and was determined to be

in airworthy condition.’

(5) For annual inspections, if the aircraft is not approved for

return to service because of needed maintenance, noncompliance

with applicable specifications, airworthiness directives or other

approved data, the following or @ similarly worded statement— I

certify that this aircraft has been inspected in accordance with an

annual inspection and a list of discrepancies and unairworthy

items dated (date) has been provided for the aircraft owner or

lessee.’

(6) For progressive inspections, the following or a similarly

worded statement—'I certify that in accordance with a progressive

inspection program, 4 routine inspection of (identify whether air-

craft, or components) and a detailed inspection of (identify com-

ponents) were performed in accordance with a progressive in-

M4 ae 2

spection and the aircraft is approved for return to service.

A42

Appendiz C.

in violation of section 145.61 of the FAR” (Tr. 3932-

3933).

The law judge dismissed a general charge, based on the

above actions, alleging a violation of section 610(a)(7) of

the Act.

The law judge thereupon concluded that the order re-

voking Air East’s repair station certificate should be

affirmed.

Finally, in regard to Respondent Reddecliff, the law judge

found that the following charges had been established by

a preponderance of the evidence.

(4) On numerous occasions, when serving in his ca-

pacity as chief of maintenance for Air East, Redde-

cliff :

(a) Performed, and/or supervised the performance

of, work on aircraft in such a manner and/or used

or permitted the use of materials of such quality that

the condition of such aircraft worked on was not at

least equal to its original or properly altered condi-

tion, and he permitted such aircraft to be returned

to service in such condition, in violation of section

43.13(a) and (b)” of the FAR and sections 605(a)”

and 610(a)(2)" of the Act (Tr. 3935-3936).

® Section 145.61 provides as follows:

§ 145.61 Performance records and reports.

Each certificated domestic repair station shall maintain ade-

quate records of all work that it does, naming the certificated

mechanie or repairman who performed or supervised the work, and

the inspector of that work. The station shall keep each record for

at least two years after the work it applies to is done.”

7? See footnote 70, supra.

7§ See footnote 39, supra.

7? See footnote 30, supra.

A43

Appendiaz C.

(b) Knowingly authorized, permitted or caused air-

eraft on which Air East repair station had performed

maintenance or alterations to be inspected, certified

as airworthy and returned to service by persons who

were not authorized and qualified to perform such

functions. In this connection, he instructed or allowed

unqualified persons to perform such inspections and

to return such aircraft to service by fraudulently or

intentionally forging his signature or that of another

qualified inspector in the aircraft records. By reason

of the foregoing actions, he violated section 43.5(a)*

of the FAR and section 605(a)" and 610(a) (2) of

the Act® (Tr, 3936-3937). The law judge thereupon

affirmed the order revoking Reddecliff’s mechanic

certificate.

Both the Administrator and the respondents have ap-

pealed from the law judge’s decision, and each party has

submitted an appeal brief. The Administrator argnes that

the law judge erred in dismissing charges regarding (1) the

scheduling of pilots for duty in excess of the maximum

allowable 14 hours in any 24 consecutive hours and/or

without the required 10 hours of continuous rest in any 24-

hour period, and (2) the utilizing of services of pilots in

Part 135 operations who had not completed the appro-

priate initial or recurrent training. The Administrator

also urges the Board to consider the various offers of

proof which were made by the Administrator during the

course of the hearing but which were excluded from con-

sideration by the law judge in reaching his decision.

Finally, the Administrator urges the Board to uphold the

law judge’s affirmation of the orders of revocation.

8° See footnote 74, supra.

81 See footnote 39, supra.

82 See footnote 30, supra.

a ee

A44

Appendiz C.

Respondents have submitted a voluminous (120-page)

brief in which they allege a number of procedural and

evidentiary defects in the Administrator’s case, in the

entire proceeding, and in the initial decision. They urge,

in conclusion, that the findings of the law judge are not

supported by substantial, reliable, and probative evidence

and should be reversed and the charges dismissed. The

specific arguments raised on appeal by respondents are

discussed in seriatim hereinbelow.

Respondents have also moved to dismiss the Admin-

istrator’s appeal on the grounds that said appeal was

untimely filed. Board rules provide that a notice of ap-

peal must be filed within 2 days after the initial decision

has been orally rendered. In this instance, the due date

was April 28, 1974, but the Administrator’s appeal wa

not filed until April 29, 1974. :

The Administrator in turn has replied to the motion to

dismiss, arguing that the due date for the notice of ap-

peal was April 29 since April 28 fell on a Sunday;** that,

in any event, no prejudice to respondents would result

from the Board’s consideration of the Administrator’s

appeal; and that the Board should follow its often stated

preference of disposing of appeals on the merits rather

than on a procedural ground.

The Administrator has also filed a reply brief in op-

position to respondent’s appeal.

Finally, respondents have submitted a reply brief in

which they renew their motion to dismiss the Admin-

istrator’s appeal and further urge, in the alternative, that

** Part 421.7 of the Board’s rules provides that Sundays shall

be counted in the computation of time in emergency cases. That

provision further provides that the last day of the period so com-

puted is to be included unless it is a Saturday, Sunday, or holiday,

in which event the period runs until the end of the next day which

is neither a Saturday, a Sunday, nor a holiday.

¢ :

ee ee

|

:

A45

Appendiz C.

the law judge’s dismissal of the specified charges should

be upheld.

Respondents have also requested oral argument before

the Board. Their request is denied on the basis that the

issues in this proceeding have been exhaustively litigated

and, in our view, no useful purpose would be served by

further argument. .

Upon consideration of the briefs of the parties, and the

entire record, the Board has determined that safety in air

commerce or air transportation and the public interest Te-

quire affirmation of the Administrator’s orders revoking

the certificates of all six respondents. Except as modified

herein, we adopt as our own the findings of the law judge.

The specific points argued in respondents’ brief, and the

Board’s disposition thereof, are as follows:

Point I—The complaints herein should have been dis-

missed for failure to comply with the Board's

rules and the law judge’s orders to supply

specific factual information.

At the prehearing conference and again at the com-

mencement of the hearing, Judge Woodlock directed the

Administrator to file bills of particulars setting forth spe-

cifies (e.g., names, dates, places, aircraft numbers, ete.)

regarding the charges in the complaints. Bills of particu-

lars were filed, and throughout the hearing the law judge

restricted testimony from the Administrator’s witnesses

to conform to the bills of particulars. At the conclusion of

the presentation of evidence, the law judge, in rejecting

respondents’ proposed finding of dismissal, found that the

complaint as supplemented by the bill of particulars while

concededly not a masterpiece of legal drafting is sufficient

to advise the respondents of the charges against them and

to meet them.’’ (Tr. 3848.)

A46

Appendix C.

We agree with the law vudge on his above assessment

of the complaints and with the conclusion that the com-

plaints, as supplemented by the bills of particulars, were

sufficient in their specificity to comply with the Board’s

rules.“ We recognize that specificity regarding dates, air-

craft numbers, ete., was lacking in some respects by the

inability of the former Air East pilots and mechanics who

were called to testify at the hearing to recall specifics.**

As the law judge apparently concluded, however, the Ad-

ministrator was as specific as the nature of the evidence

allowed him to be. Moreover, and most important, it ap-

pears to the Board that respondents were sufficiently

apprised of the Administrator’s case to allow them to pre-

pare their defense adequately.” Finally, respondents’

argument that no emergency existed, since the Adminis-

trator himself did not personally so certify, is lacking in

merit in view of the fact that the Associate General Coun-

sel, who signed the orders of revocation, has been delegated

the authority by regulation to take certificate action*’ and

thereby acts as the representative of the Administrator.

* Section 421.23(b) of the Board’s rules provides that “If the

Administrator claims that respondent lacks qualification as an

airman, the order filed as the complaint, or an accompanying state-

ment, shall recite on whieh of the facts pleaded this contention is

based.”

** Efforts to refresh recollection were to some extent hampered

by (a) the fact these pilots and mechanics naturally did not record

acts which were in violation of the FAR, and (b) Air East records

were in some ‘astances falsified to hide violations.

** We also note that the law judge directed the Administrator

to provide respondents with copies of the depositions of those wit-

nesses who had been deposed prior to the hearing. Respondents

were thus aware of the heart of the Administrator’s case in advance

of the hearing.

** See Part 13.19(b) of the FAR.

ie ee a at rt | na dee» sale

A47

Appendiz C.

Point I11—Revocation of respondents’ licenses without a

prior hearing was a violation of due process

of law.

As respondents recognize in their brief, the —

tor has the clear statutory authority to issue a revocat =

order without a prior hearing where an emergency exis :

and safety in air commerce or air transportation —

the immediate effectiveness of his order. The a ht

consistently held that it lacks authority to review -

ministrator’s decision to invoke his emergency . —

We would nevertheless point out that the fact ; a =

East operated without incident during the ew sag ns

of the Administrator’s investigation does not be “ : =

istence of an emergency within the intendmen 0 =

statute. Moreover, with respect to the length of this 7 nal

tigation, it would be irresponsible for the — - _

to invoke such extraordinary authority unless grounde

a thorough investigation.

Point 111—Respondents herein have been denied procedu-

ral due process of law.

Respondents’ first argument under the heading of on

process regards lack of specificity of the —_— bane

argument is basically the same as that made — oe

and our view is likewise the SS ae oa bw

ree of specificity of the complaints, as

the bills ft cesteuinen, met the due process requirement of

Senedd next argue that —_ jer 7 bras

defense an

amount of time to prepare a 7

initi i In emergency procee

1 from the initial decision. (

nan “the Board is required by statute (section 609 of the

8 Section 609 of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958 (49 U.S.C.

1429).

A48

Appendiz C.

Act) to dispose of the appeal within 60 days after being

advised that an emergency exists. This time constraint was

designed to assure that an airman, whose certificate would

be immediately affected by an emergency order, would re-

ceive an expedited hearing and a speedy disposition of his

appeal. The Board’s Rules of Practice governing emer-

gency cases*® contain procedures and compressed time

limits which are necessary to assure disposition of the

appeal within the allotted period. In this particular in-

stance, the hearing commenced 14 days after the emer-

gency orders were served on respondents. As found

hereinabove, the specificity of the charges met due process.

We are further satisfied that the rights of respondents

were consistently upheld throughout the hearing by the

law judge, whose rulings strictly limited the Administra-

tor to the matters described in the bills of particulars.”

We recognize that the unusual length of the hearing (25

days) produced a record of such proportions that prepara-

tion of an appeal brief, particularly within the compressed

time limits, became a difficult task. Nevertheless, adher-

ence to these time limits is necessary if the Board is to

dispose of the case within the statutory period. We might

also add that the Board has seen few briefs which can

compare with respondents’ in terms of a thorough, detailed

presentation of all the relevant issues.

Point 1V—Many of the alleged violatwons are over &

months old and should have been dismissed for

staleness.

The Board’s rules contain a provision which subjects, to

a motion to dismiss, allegations of offenses which occurred

5® Section 421.38, et al.

* In denying an interlocutory appeal filed by the Administra-

tor, the Board affirmed the law judge’s ruling so limiting the testi-

mony of the Administrator’s witnesses. NTSB Order No. EA-569,

April 8, 1974.

ee ey ae eee, ee

A49

Appendiz C.

more than 6 months prior to the Administrator’s advising

respondent as to reasons for the proposed action under

section 609 of the Act.** A motion to dismiss a complaint

as stale does not apply, however, where an issue of lack of

qualification would be presented if the allegations are as-

sumed to be true. In this instance, the allegations in the

complaint clearly presented an issue of qualification and

therefore the law judge acted properly in denying respond-

ents’ motion to dismiss.”

Point V—-The Administrator made an improper attempt

to influence the Board and the law judge by sup-

plying them with prejudicial material outside of

the record.

Respondents’ argument on this point is based on a letter

sent by the Administrator to the Chairman of the Safety

Board on March 22, 1974, which led the Chairman to dis-

qualify himself from any further participation in this

proceeding.” As the four undersigned Memvers have pre-

viously stated,“ nothi.g can be discerned regarding the

aforesaid letter, or indeed any other matter, which would

constitute grounds for disqualifying them from adjudicat-

ing the merits of this case. Accordingly, and without con-

doning the action of the Administrator in sending the let-

ter, it cannot be concluded that the letter in itself provides

a valid reason for dismissing the complaints.

* Section 421.25 of the Board’s Rules of Practice.

* Lack of qualification can be established by regulatory viola-

tions sufficiently serious in nature to demonstrate a lack of the

degree of care, judgment, and responsibility required of a certifi-

eate nolder.

* See NTSB Order No. EA-568, April 8, 1974.

* Td.

A50

Appendiz C.

Point VI—Respondents have been prejudiced by the delib-

erate destruction of notes taken by the Board

and FAA employees of witnesses’ oral state-

ments.

A Safety Board investigator, to whom several Air East

pilots gave oral statements during an aircraft accident

investigation,” took notes of these conversations and later

destroyed the notes after briefing the Board. At a subse-

quent meeting among Board and FAA officials, one of the

latter took notes and also later destroyed them. Obvi-

ously, any destruction of notes is “deliberate”: however

there is nothing to indicate that the destruction of these

notes was for any other reason than that said notes were

of no further use to the individuals who took them. Cer-

tainly, there is no inference in the record that the destrue-

tion of the notes was somehow designed to frustrate re-

spondents’ defense against the charges. Nor can we agree

with respondents that the above individuals were under a

duty to preserve this type of note and that destruction

thereof is therefore tantamount to a denial of due process

of law.**

* The relationship between the accid i igati

hp ent investigat

immediate proceeding is explained in Order BA-568, ge ”

* It should also be noted that, wi

( , with respect to former state-

anaes of witnesses which might be of use in impeaching those 4

r sses, respondents were provided copies of their depositions taken

ore SS + ./ tage sneer of Air East. Moreover, the judi

"ision cited by respondents in su rt of this int is

inapposite since it involved a criminal piauniben ee an

item at issue was the recordation of a conversation between de-

f mm 7

TT aud an undercover agent. U.S. v. Bryant, 439 F. 2d 642

11 eae Nr AE Ae Sadho A he ee

ee CL = ee ee

A51

Appendiz C.

Point VII—The findings by the law judge are not in accord

with section 421.32(b) and new findings are

required.

Section 421.32(b) of the Board’s rules reads as follows:

‘“(b) Contents. The initial decision shall include a

statement of findings and conciusions, as well as the

reasons or bases therefor, upon all material issues of

fact (including credibility of witnesses, where such

finding is material), law, or discretion, presented on

the record, and the appropriate sanction or denial

thereof.’’

In our judgment, the initial decision, which covers some

91 transcript pages, clearly meets the requirements of the

above section in that it disposes of all legal and procedural

arguments made by the parties, makes unequivocal findings

of credibility, and spells cut the evidence of record which

supports each of the charges found to be established by the

law judge. Consequently, there is no need to remand the

case to the law judge for more specific findings.”

Point VI1I—The findings must be supported by a prepon-

derance of reliable, probative, and substantial

evidence.

We, of course, agree with the above proposition and will

deal below with the ultimate issue of whether the findings

of the law judge regarding the charges against respondents

are so supported by the record.

* The law judge’s findings on the charges are discussed in

detail hereinbelow; where the record warrants modification of these

findings, or new findings, our opinion so states.

A52

Appendiz C.

Point IX—The law judge failed to gwve proper considera-

tion to the responsibility of the puot-in-com-

mand.

Respondents, in effect, maintain that Air East manage-

ment cannot be held responsible for violations committed

by a captain who, as pilot-in-command, ‘‘is directly respon-

sible for, and is the final authority as to, the operation of

that aircraft.’ Although management personnel were

not present in the aircraft when the violations by nonman-

agement pilots were committed, we nevertheless find that

management of a company can be held accountable for

pilot violations which are the direct product of manage-

ment-inspired policies and procedures. Thus, when man-

agement instructs its pilots in the use of improper and

unsafe techniques, and permits and encourages such prac-

tices to flourish, it cannot escape responsibility by hiding

behind the authority of the pilot-in-command. To hold

otherwise would be to render meaningless the entire regu-

latory concept under which the vperator of a flight must

assume responsibility, particularly for those violations of

which it was gware or which it initiated.

Point X—The law judge took a totally unrealistic view-

point on the issue of credibility, improperly

limited examination on the issue, and his findings

relating thereto are unworthy of consideration

by the Board.

With respect to the examination by respondents’ attorney

of the FAA lawyer who conducted the investigation of Air

Kast, the law judge limited the interrogation only when this

. ** The quoted language is taken from section 91.3(a) of the

AR.

to eee in a Oe eee * RU nd teat

|

A53

Appendix C.

witness was asked whether he would recommend that en-

forcement action be taken against the certificate of former

Air East pilots and mechanics who gave testimony damag-

ing to Air East. The law judge, in our view, did not abuse

his discretion in so ruling, particularly in light of the fact

that he permitted respondents’ attorney considerable wr

way in questioning this same witness, and indeed many 0

the former Air East pilots and mechanics, about _

promises of immunity made by the FAA. The thrust of the

answers to these questions was that no immunity wer

granted but that the individual witness’ cooperation wou

be taken into consideration by the Administrator in age

mining whether enforcement action would be taken. in

our judgment, such an approach was neither — od

calculated to elicit false testimony. Furthermore, we _

concur with the law judge that the manner in — e

Administrator investigated and developed his case ; -

not constitute grounds for rejecting the credibility of the

ri king up that case. —

payee soo a the record that witness ge soap

was a key element to a resolution of the charges, — :

testimony of respondents Tallent, McKinney, Wi —

and Reddecliff was, in large part, diametrically =

on key points to the testimony of the 17 pilots .- 4 . :

mechanics who appeared for the Administrator. : : :

judge clearly and unequivocally chose to rege e oe .

mony of respondents and to accept that of the A ——

tor’s witnesses. Respondents have cited nothing in oo

brief that would prompt us to overturn rethon ju “

finding on credibility. Judge Woodlock preside yy

days of testimony, observed firsthand the demeanor ) =

witness, and therefore was in the best — b “ -

their veracity. The fact that his acceptance 0 ; ec =

bility of the Administrator’s witnesses was = ae

his rejection of respondents’ testimony, does not di

Ad4

Appendiz C.

the strength or logic of his findings, but rather reflects the

convincing nature of the Administrator’s case and the basic

consistency in the testimony of numerous witnesses in

describing a pattern of conduct on the part of Air East.

We share that view of the evidence.

Point XI—The charges against Respondent Air East (Re-

pair Station) are not supported by reliable,

probative, and substantial evidence.

The law judge’s finding that Charge 2 was established

was based on an incident which occurred on January 11,

1974. A designated inspector for Air East (Agnello)

testified that Respondent Reddecliff instructed him on that

date to sign off a then overdue inspection as if it had been

performed on January 10th. In fact, the inspection was

not accomplished until January 12th. Respondent Redde-

cliff denies that he so instructed Agnello. The law judge

chose to accept the testimony of Agnello, and we can dis-

cern no valid reason to overturn that finding.”

Charge 3 was established, in the law judge’s findings, by

the testimony of two mechanics (Orlowsky and Panarella)

who testified that they signed Respondent Reddecliff’s name

on the aircraft logs as certifying that the aircraft was air-

worthy for return to service." Orlowsky testified that

* Testimony by Respondent Reddecliff that he was informed

by an FAA inspector that the aircraft was within a 10-hour grace

period was uncorroborated hearsay and therefore entitled to little

weight. We also note that Agnello’s testimony was corroborated

lou an Air East pilot at the time of the incident (Tr.

560-

° Their testimony was corroborated by an FBI agent who

concluded, based on an examination of the pertinent records, that

not all of the signatures of Reddecliff were made by the same

person.

Wade Pel in:

es

natal

Pichh te

—

a

A55

Appendiz C.

Reddecliff instructed him to so sign, while Panarella stated

that he signed Reddecliff’s name when the latter was not

available and that Reddecliff was aware of this fact.

Respondents argue nevertheless that Orlowsky and

Panarella, as holders of mechanics certificates with air-

frame and powerplant ratings, were authorized under the

regulations and the manual to return an aircraft to service

as airworthy. We do not agree with respondents’ in-

terpretation of the regulations. The maintenance and

inspection of work performed was accomplished as part

of a function of the Air East repair station and, under

section 145.59 of the FAR, the inspection and certification

as airworthy must be accomplished by a qualified in-

spector. Orlowsky testified that he was not authorized

to sign off the aircraft, since he was not an inspector, and

that what he did was improper. The import of the regula-

tions is to assure that only a qualified inpector certifies that

the plane is airworthy. In these instances, there is no

guarantee that the aircraft were airworthy since they were

not inspected and certified by a qualified inspector.”

Charge 4 was established by the same basic evidence cited

above in regard to Charge 3—namely, that the records were

falsified by persons not qualified as inspectors signing

Respondent Reddecliff’s name. Reddecliff averred that

following Agnello’s termination of employment,'” Redde-

cliff designated Orlowsky as an inspector. Orlowsky, on

the other hand, stated that he was never so designated, and

it is apparent that the law judge chose to believe Orlowsky.

101 We agree with Judge Woodlock that an Air East mechanic

was authorized to sign off as airworthy only the work he himself

performed.

102 We also note that Orlowsky testified that, when signing

Reddecliff’s name, he did not always check the work of other

mechanics to determine if it was airworthy.

108 Only Reddecliff and Agnello were designated as inspectors.

A56

Appendix C.

In sum, the record with respect to the repair station

reveals a practice of intentional falsification of records to

cover up improprieties regarding the overdue date of an

inspection and the fact that aircraft were being certified

as airworthy by unqualified personnel. In our judgment,

these practices demonstrate that Air East lacks the req-

uisite qualifications to hold a repair station certificate

which is therefore subject to revocation.

Point XII—The charges against Respondent Thomas

Reddecliff are not supported by reliable, probative,

and substantial evidence.

In support of Charge 4(a) against Respondent Redde-

cliff, the law judge cited the operation of aircraft 133AE

with an inoperative PN 101 (course director). Mechanic

Panarella testified that portions of this system were re-

moved and sent out for repair or overhaul but that the

aircraft still flew during this period. Reddecliff’s testi-

mony again conflicted with that of Panarella, but again

it is apparent that the law judge chose not to credit the

former’s version. Panarella also testified that on aircraft

125AE the altimeters were reported to have a 150-foot

difference between them and that this problem was worked

on over a period of 1 to 2 weeks during which the air-

craft continued to be flown. A number of pilots testified

that they had been instructed by Respondent Reddecliff,

inter alia, not to enter ‘‘no go”’ items in the log book, but

rather to report these items orally or on a separate piece

of paper. In addition, Air East mechanics stated that

such items were not entered in the log book until they

were corrected and signed off.

The charges against Respondent Reddecliff under Charge

4(b) are basically the same as those listed under Charges

3 and 4 against the repair station, which are discussed

hereinabove and need not be reiterated except to state

ee ee en

A57

Appendiz C.

that such charges (basically, falsification of records to

cover up the fact that inspections were done by un-

qualified persons) were established.

As the person in charge of maintenance, Respondent

Reddecliff clearly was derelict in his duties and the fact

that he was directly responsible for the practices discussed

above demonstrates that he lacks the qualification to hold

a mechanic certificate.

Points XIII, XIV, and XV—The charges against Re-

spondents Tallent, McKumney, and Wilkinson are not

supported by reliable, probative, and substantial

evidence.

Testimony from numerous Air East pilots clearly es-

teblished that Respondents Tallent, McKinney, and Wil-

kinson, as a regular practice, conducted unauthorized ap-

proaches to Johnstown and Altoona Airports (Charge

4(a)), and, while operating under IFR on such approaches,

used altitude and/or visibility minimums below those pre-

scribed in approved procedures (Charge 4(b)).% As part

of a management-initiated policy, these respondents con-

ducted circling or straight-in approaches not depicted on

the approach plates and descended to “company mini-

mums” well below the prescribed MDA (minimum descent

altitude) under actual instrument conditions. Further-

more, the pilots describing those incidents made no men-

tion of ATC clearances, weather conditions, or visual

sighting which might have justified otherwise unauthorized

procedures.

104 In view of the similarity of the charges against these three

respondents, they will be treated together.

? h air-

105 The fact that approved approach procedures for eac

port are ‘on published in section 97 of the FAR does not render

‘sion invalid nor does it mean t

apt ape ven As stated in section 97.10, and as understood

by all pilots, standard instrument approac

trayed on individual charts or approach plates.

A58

Appendiz C.

Pilot testimony also established that Respondents Tal-

lent, McKinney, and Wilkinson, while operating under IFR,

deviated from an ATC clearance without obtaining an

amended clearance (Charge 4(c)). These deviations often

involved use of company prescribed ‘‘alpha altitudes,”’

which in effect allowed an Air East pilot to cruise at 500

feet above or below the assigned altitude in order to pro-

vide the passengers a smoother ride. Former Air East

pilots further testified that the three respondents, while

operating under VFR, flew through clouds or failed to

maintain the minimum separation from clouds prescribed

by section 91.105(a) of the FAR (Charge 4(d)).

Testimony of numerous Air East pilots also establishes

that Respondents Tallent and McKinney operated aircraft

which were not in an airworthy condition and failed to dis-

continue flights when unairworthy conditions existed

(Charge 4(e)) and that all three respondents operated

aircraft in excess of the maximum certificated takeoff

weight and/or when the center of gravity was outside ap-

proved limits. These violations were obviously part of Air

East practices whereby aircraft would be operated even

before ‘‘no go’’ items could be corrected and whereby fuel

and baggage weights would be ‘‘fudged’’ to come within

limits or the center of gravity would not be computed until

after takeoff.

Finally, the record establishes, during .ertain specified

periods of time, Respondents McKinney and Wilkinson

served as pilot-in-command under IFR when they had not

passed the instrument check required by section 135.131(a)

of the FAR; that Respondents McKinney and Wilkinson

served as pilot-in-command under IFR when they had not

passed a routes-and-airports flight check required by sec-

‘* With respect to Respondent Tallent, Luther recalled that he

had given Tallent an instrument check ride (Tr. 2564), but Luther’s

search through aircraft logs did not reveal such a flight (Tr. 2605).

On balance, we believe the evidence is insufficient to support this

charge, which is therefore dismissed.

NP Ae! Oe Mes on.

ules ated a BOS 7. Dab be es. ks

A59

Appendiz C.

tion 135.122(a); and that Respondent McKinney served as

pilot in Beechcraft Model 99 aircraft when he had not

passed a flight check in that type of aircraft, as required

by section 135.138(b). Testimony in support of the a

charges was supplied by Luther (the only designated ¢

pilot in the employ of Air East) who testified that he ”

not give respondents the various check rides which wou

have made it legal for them to operate during the periods

in the complaints. .

ie comentints denied the various charges against them,

and during their testimony offered explanations of an eX-

culpatory nature.” The law judge rejected their testimony

in favor of the testimony of the numerous Air East pilots

who described the incidents in which regulatory violations

were committed by respondents. Again, we have no reason

to overturn the law judge’s findings on credibility. In this

connection, we note, as did the law judge, that many of the

former Air East pilots were highly qualified and would not

likely have been unaware of circumstances which, as re-

spondents alleged, justified the deviations. Furthermore,

the fact that these witnesses could not, in all instances, re-

eall the specific dates of the occurrences does not, in our

view, diminish the overall weight to be accorded their testi-

Based on the foregoing, it is clear to the Board that —

three respondents regularly engaged in practices hyn

were not only in contravention of the regulations u

: sé = 9? as the

_ ample, they described ‘‘company minimums

iaie 1 ak pilots could descend after runway environment

had been sighted and which was to be maintained until the runway

itself was sighted.

i d (b)

368 ndents contend that sections 91.9 and 91.29(a) an

are cttahaiy vague. The short answer yew a _

tion is that the Board lacks authority to mS . ade os

ek ae A ae Ay pda sn my A ane regulations

e . *,*

ed io fel hen sufficiently specific to support = Pr

of a sanction against an airman for failure to rer e :

See Administrator v. Galloway, 1 N.T.S.B. 2104 ( :

A60

Appendiz C.

which were patently unsafe. It therefore follows that these

respondents have demonstrated that they are unqualified

to hold a pilot certificate.

Point XVI—The findings with respect to Air East d/b/a

Allegheny Commuter are not supported by

reliable, probative, and substantial evidence.

Charges 2, 3 and 4 concern aircraft weight and center of

gravity. Numerous former Air East pilots testified that

there was a consistent policy, perpetrated by Air East

management, whereby weights would be ‘‘fudged’’ in order

to bring the aircraft weight and/or center of gravity within

prescribed limits at the time of takeoff. For example, on

an IF'R flight carrying 15 passengers, pilots were instructed

to list only certain specified weights regarding fuel and

baggage, even though the actual figures were in excess of

those weights. Thus, the load manifest was falsified and

the aircraft departed at a weight above the maximum

certificated takeoff weight.

Pilots also testified that they were instructed by man-

agement, when operating on a mail cargo run, to stick to

the schedule and, if necesary, not to recompute the aircraft

loading until after takeoff. These pilot therefore had no

way of knowing whether the center of gravity of the plane

was within limits at the time of departure.

The fact that weight and balance is predicated on ap-

proximate rather than actual weights does not, in our view,

invalidate the charges described above. Nor can we accept

respondents’ construction of section 135.43(c) as a mere

recordkeeping requirement which could be met by filling

out a load manifest after takeoff. We concur in the law

judge’s interpretation of that provision—namely, that

preparation of a load manifest is meaningless unless ac-

complished prior to takeoff so that a pilot knows whether

A6l

Appendiz C.

the aircraft is within the prescribed limits. Moreover,

management’s explanation that the standard fuel and bag-

gage figures were nothing more than precomputed amounts

to fit a flight profile was rejected by the law judge. Again,

we have no reason to overturn that finding of the law

judge, which rests on credibility. .

Charges 5 and 6 concern use of unauthorized approach

procedures and of a minimum altitude and visibility below

the prescribed figures. These charges were discussed

hereinabove with respect to similar charges made against

Respondents McKinney, Tallent, and Wilkinson. lt will

suffice to say that not only does the record establish that

such practices were commonplace at Air East, but that

they were initiated and encouraged by management.

Another commonplace Air East practice was that

described under Charge 7—namely, that Air East made

numerous flight operations into and out of Johnstown Air-

port during weather conditions less than the VFR mini-

mums when the Johnston FSS was not in operation and

without the pilots being given weather reports from an

accredited observer. The FSS was closed from 11 p.m.

until 7 a.m., a period during which Air East had scheduled

arrivals and departures.” The regulations require, dur-

ing such a period, weather reports from an accredited

observer when IFR conditions prevail. Although Air Kast

employed one such observer, pilots on inbound flights

testified that they never secured weather reports from

him. In addition, mechanics on night duty stated that

they never saw this individual at the field.” Rather,

109 A mail flight arrived at 2:30 a.m. and a passenger flight

departed at 6:50 a.m. _ -

110 Generally, he did not come in until the beginning of the

normal me tt day, when he would be seen filling out forms pre-

sumably containing weather observations purportedly made during

the preceding night.

A62

Appendiz C.

pilots would receive their reports from the mechanics via

company radio or they would obtain no weather at all.

Similarly, on departures, when they took off prior to the

opening of the FSS, the only weather observations relied

on by the pilots were their own.** There was even some

testimony that some inbound flights would delay their

arrival at Johnstown, and that some outbound flights

would expedite their departure, to avoid exposure to FSS

personnel going off or coming on duty.

Turning to Charge 8, both pilots and mechanics alike

testified that it was a standard practice at Air East for

flight personnel to report discrepancies (particularly, “no

go’’ items) either orally or on a separate sheet of paper

and for entries of such discrepancies not to be entered in

the aircraft log until they had been corrected. Further-

more, the aircraft would continue to be operated during

the period that these items were in a state of disrepair. It

is therefore apparent, and several pilots stated they so

understood, that the above practice was designed to avoid

grounding an aircraft on which a no go item was in-

operative or which was unairworthy. |

The record also indicates that Air East falsified records

to indicate that required inspections and certifications of

airworthiness had been accomplished by a qualified in-

spector, when in fact they had not.*”

We cannot agree with respondents that section 91.165

of the FAR does not require entry of discrepancies in the

aircraft log book. Rather, defects can only be properly

repaired and aricraft released to service, as prescribed by

that provision, if entries are made in the log book as each

discrepancy occurs and then signed off as each such item

™! Many of these arrivals and departures were made in IFR

conditions.

112 Evidence thereof is discussed hereinabove with respect to

the charges against the repair station.

A63

Appendiz C.

is corrected. In other words, the above regulatory provi-

sion was designed to avert the very practice prepetrated

by Air East—viz., the operation of aircraft with required

equipment inoperative.

Respondents have in considerable detail attempted to

undermine the testimony and evidence of record relied on

by the law judge in affirming Charge 8. We are uncon-

vniced by their characterization of the record, however,

and therefore find that the weight of the evidence sustains

the conclusions of the law judge.

With respect to Charge 10, it is undisputed that Air Kast

flight time records were maintained on a time-in-service

basis (wheels-off to wheels-on) rather than on a pilot

flight-time basis, as that term is defined in section 1.1 of

the FAR (block-to-block). Nevertheless, we agree with the

law judge that this violation is basically technical in nature,

inasmuch as the Air East practice was set forth in the com-

pany manual which in turn was subjected to review by the

FAA before being put into effect. |

In regard to Charges 12, 13, 14 and 15, numerous Air

East pilots testified that they were not given flight-check

rides required under Part 135, even though records filed

with the FAA by Air East indicated such checks had been

accomplished. Furthermore, the single designated check

pilot (Luther), who alone (apart from an FAA representa-

tive) was authorized to administer such checks, testified

that many of the checks entered in the records by him

were either never given or given at a later date and then

back-dated in the records. He further stated that although

Respondent McKinney never directly instructed him to

falsify the records, he understood that he was expected

to do so in order to keep the pilots flying. We agree with

the law judge that such an inference is inescapable and

that Respondent McKinney must have been aware of what

was going on.

A64

Appendix C.

We further find that Charge 16—failure to provide air-

craft and facilities to allow Air East pilots to remain

proficient—is established by the same evidence discussed

immediately above, although said charge is basically

redundant to Charges 12 through 15.

In support of Charge 17, the law judge cited an occasion

on which Air East failed to report to the FAA an incident

involving the feathering of » propeller in flight due to loss

of oil pressure. Althougi: the pilot-in-command did not

state precisely that he informed Respondent Reddecliff of

the feathering when the matter was discussed by telephone,

he did testify that “I told him what we had happened [sic].”’

It is difficult to conceive how a description of the incident

could have omitted the feathering. Nevertheless, even if

Reddecliff were not advised of the feathering during the

phone call, he specifically advised the pilot not to make an

entry in the log book. Thus, if Air East remained unaware

of the feathering, it was only because of their improper

practice of not logging discrepancies, which obviously is

not a valid defense to the violation listed under Charge 17.

Finally, with respect to Charge 19, there is in the record

some evidence of harassment, intimidation, and threats

utilized by Air East management to influence pilots to

comply with some of the improper and unsafe practices

described hereinabove."* One pilot, for example, testified

that ‘“‘any time that you did not go by these unwritten

policies, you’d be threatened with being back as first officer”

(Tr. 1923) and that he was called into the office and

harassed, embarrassed, and “told how they wanted things

113 As respondents point out in their brief, the law judge mis-

takenly referred to the date of this incident as February 20, 1974,

whereas the actual date was December 7, 1973.

114 Other testimony, not directly pertinent to this charge, de-

scribed hard feelings on the part of management, sometimes carried

to extremes, when pilots quit or sought employment elsewhere.

A65

Appendiz C.

done” (Tr. 1924). Another pilot interpreted an accusation

made against him by Respondent McKinney as “‘a threat so

you would do it the way they wanted you to do it” (Tr.

1835). Although no regulatory violation was cited in con-

nection with this charge, we agree with the law judge that

it reflects on the insistence of Air East management that

the pilots accept irregular practices without dispute.

In summing up the charges against Air East, what

emerges from the record is the profile of a company which,

through its management, initiated and fostered practices

that are in violation of numerous provisions of the FAR

and that have compromised safety in every phase of the

company’s operational and maintenance functions. Air

East has thereby demonstrated that it does not possess the

care, judgment, and responsibility required of the holder

of an air taxi/commercial operator certificate and that

revocation thereof is warranted.

Point XVII—The sanctions imposed on Air East were

entirely inappropriate.

Respondents maintain that the continuing surveillance of

the FAA, GADO office, as well as the SWAP team inspec-

tions conducted in 1973, have uncovered only minor dis-

crepancies and demonstrate that Air East is a well-qualified

operator. The results of these inspections, however, can-

not offset the overwhelming weight of the evidence de-

veloped in this proceeding. Moreover, it is apparent that

the failure of these inspections to uncover the violations

established herein is in large measure attributable to the

record falsifications designed to assure that such violations

would not be detected.*””

15Jn any event, the capability of GADO surveillance, and

even SWAP team inspections, to detect the types of violations

committed by Air East is open to serious question.

A66

Appendia C.

For the reasons spelled out hereinabove in this opinion,

it is the Board’s ultimate conclusion that the findings of

Judge Woodlock, with respect to each of the six respond-

ents, are supp. rted by a preponderance of the substantial,

reliable, and probative evidence”* and that each of the re-

spondents has thereby demonstrated lack of qualifications

to hold his or its certificate. It therefore follows, in im-

posing sanctions consistent with the statutory guidelines of

air safety and the public interest, that revocation of those

certificates is appropriate and indeed required.”

ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1. Respondents’ appeal be and it hereby is denied ;

2. The initial decision, as modified herein, be and it

hereby is affirmed; and

3. The Administrator’s emergency orders revoking the

certificates of respondents, as modified herein and by the

law judge, be and they hereby are affirmed.

McApams, THayver, Burcess, and Hatey, Members of the

Board, concurred in the above opinion and order, Reep,

Chairman, not participating.

(Sea)

116 The single charge found established by the law judge, which

we have dismissed, is that involving the allegation that Respondent

Tallent did not receive an instrument flight check required by

section 135.131 of the FAR.

117 In view of our disposition of the case on the basis set forth

above, we find it unnecessary to reach the issues raised by the

Administrator’s appeal or to rule on respondents’ motion to dis-

miss that appeal. Our ruling in this regard should be taken as

neither an adoption or rejection of the law judge’s findings dis-

puted by the Administrator’s appeal.

, — —

ER RRR Se

A67

APPENDIX D.

Opinion of Administrative Law Judge Woodlock.

Unirep States oF AMERICA

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD

Wasuineton, D.C.

a

v

Avexanper P. BurrerFietp, Administrator

Federal Aviation Administration

vs.

Am Fast, Inc., d/b/a ALLEGHENY COMMUTER,

Docket SE-2509

James Avery TaLLent, Docket SE-2511

Jerrrey H. Wuixrnson, Docket SE-2512

Tuomas ReppecuirF, Docket SE 2513

CHartes AtLAN McKinney, Docket SE-2519

Am East, Inc. (Repair Station), Docket SE-2522

’%

4

Service: Air East, Inc., d/b/a Allegheny Commuter,

Respondent

Johnstown-Cambria County Airport

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

James Avery Tallent, Respondent

431 Luzerne Street

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

Note: This is a copy of the oral initial decision rendered

at the conclusion of the hearing in this proceeding,

April 26, 1974, by Administrative Law Judge

Fred L. Woodlock.

SERVICE:

A68

Appendix D.

(Continued )

Jeffrey H. Wilkinson, Respondent

117 Melvin Street

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

Thomas Reddecliff, Respondent

c/o Air East, Ine.

Johnstown-Cambria County Airport

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

Charles Allan McKinney, Respondent

431 Bellmont Street

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

Air East, Ine. (Repair Station), Respondent

Johnstown-Cambria County Airport

Johnstown, Pennsylvania 15904

Walter E. Rutherford, Esq.

Haight, Gardner, Poor and Havens

Counsel for Respondents

One State Street Plaza

New York, New York 10004

John J. Keyser, Esq.

Assistant Chief Counsel

Federal Aviation Administration

and

Patrick G. Geraghty, Esq.

Counsel for the Administrator

Federal Aviation Administration

800 Independence Avenue, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20591

and

John E. Marsh, Esq.

Federal Aviation Administration

800 Independence Avenue, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20591

and

A69

Appendiz D.

Robert W. Katz, Esq.

Federal Aviation Administration

800 Independence Avenue, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20591

OraL Initia, Decision oF JupGE FRED L. WoopLock

Jupce Woopiocx: As I am required to do in emergency

actions, I will now give my oral decision in each of the

matters which we have brought to conclusion.

The various respondents have each and all appealed

from the emergency order of revocation issued by Ad-

ministrator through a duly designated member of the

staff on March 7, 1974.

Y’ll not set forth the charges at this point but I do

intend to discuss each one separately during the course

of my decision and think that will be sufficient to apprise

anyone who has enough interest to read it, what the

charges are and what the various defenses are.

At the outset, the respondent has filed proposed findings

and conclusions and I will address some of them at this

time, and others during the course of discussion on the

various charges subsequently.

Now, the first proposal is that the complaint lacks a

concise and complete statement of the facts relied upon

which it is claimed was not improved by the bill of par-

ticulars submitted by the Administrator and that therefore

the complaint as supplemented by the bill of particulars

does not comply with the requirements of Section 421.4(d)

of Title 14, CFR and should therefore be dismissed.

To avoid any confusion, these various findings and con-

clusions are proposed in connection with each respondent’s

defense and what I say here applies to each one of them.

I'll diseuss each of the charges separately, of course, but

as to the general proposed findings and conclusion, I can

discuss them as one.

A70

Appendix D.

I find that the complaint as supplemented by the bill

of particulars while concededly not a masterpiece of legal

drafting is sufficient to advise the respondents of the

charges against them and to meet them.

The second proposed finding: that the Administrator’s

complaint lacks a recitation of the pleaded facts upon

which the Administrator relies in support of the conten-

tion that the respondents lack qualification, which is not

improved by the bill of particulars, and the conclusion

which follows therefrom that the complaints should be

dismissed as not complying with the performance of sec-

tion 421.23, Title 14, CFR, and should therefore be dis-

missed, is refused as is proposed finding 3 with its accom-

panying conclusion that the complaint and evidence are

vague and consist of unspecific general allegations of vio-

lations on the parts of the several respondents which have

made it impossible for respondents to present a defense

that therefore he is denied—they have been denied their

Constitutional right to due process.

In connection with that latter proposed finding and

conclusion, I do not, of course, have authority to declare

a statute of the United States unconstitutional.

The proposed finding that the Administrator has had an

adequate opportunity to discover violations occurring

prior to 7 September 1973, within six months of their

alleged occurrence has been previously disposed of when

a similar motion based upon similar statements was made

at the beginning of the hearing.

The proposed finding that the respondent has not com-

mitted or the respondents have not committed wilfull vio-

lations of any regulation or wilfully disobeyed any order

of the Administrator, nor exhibited an unwillingness to

act in accordance with applicable regulations is not made.

I think those are the proposed findings and conclusions

which relate broadly to the various complaints and the

A7l1

Appendix D.

others are addressed specifically to the individual charges

in each complaint.

I turn now to the order issued to Air East, Inc. d/b/a,

Allegheny Commuter.

Charge number 1, Air East, Inc., d/b/a Allegheny Com-

muter is now and at all times mentioned herein, was the

holder of Air Taxi Commercial Operator Certificate No.

14-EA-69 issued August 21, 1969, pursuant to part 135

of the Federal Aviation Regulations (hereinafter referred

to as the FAR’s.)

This charge was admitted.

Charge 2, Air East, Inc., as a matter of policy, on nu-

merous occasions, operated, caused or permitted to be op-

erated aircraft in operation under part 135 of the Federal

Aviation Regulations, when such aircraft either exceeded

the maximum certificated takeoff weight and/or were out-

side the approved center of gravity limits in violation of

Sections 91.9 and 91.3(a) of the FAR’s and Section

610(a) (4) and (5) of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958,

as amended (hereinafter referred to as the Act) on each

such occasion.

There were bills of particulars, of course, made to all

of these, but I’ll not refer to the bills in my discussion

because I’m relying, I believe, and depend only on the

evidence which was admitted and not on any of the evi-

dence which was proffered—made as an offer of proof.

Donald Wright, a commercial pilot, was a First Officer

with the respondent from October, 1972, to December,

1972, and thereafter a Captain to March, 1974.

He flew air mail schedule for ten weeks and testified that

when mail was loaded or offloaded at each stop in the

schedule, a new weight and balance sheet and center of

gravity computation would be required.

According to his testimony, Allan McKinney told him

to complete the forms in the air if time and schedule

interfered.

A72

Appendiz D.

His air mail run from June 18, 1973, to July 20, 1973,

was for a particular five-week period.

Shoemaker, another former pilot with Air East said

that in twenty-three flights as First Officer with the mail,

he never had an opportunity to calculate the center of

gravity.

Robin Mangold, the holder of an air transport pilot cer-

tificate, was with the respondent from April 31, 1973, to

September 1, 1973, as a First Officer.

In that capacity he made out the load manifest and the

Captain, he stated, would look at it and sign it.

If, he testified, there were enough passengers to con-

stitute a problem with the gross weight for takeoff he

would insert three hundred pounds of baggage and eight

hundred pounds of fuel in the appropriate places on the

form.

On August 13th, 1973, he was First Officer to one Cap-

tain Graff on Flight 319 which had a full load of people

and considerable cargo, although he testified he did not

know how much.

While the right engine was running the aircraft came

very close to teetering on its tail with the door still open.

At the time, he said there were passengers still outside.

The Captain, in an effort to keep the aircraft from

going on its tail, started the left engine and Mangold

stated he lost the tickets in an effort to keep the pas-

senger door above the pavement, although in that respect

he was unsuccessful, and also to keep it from landing on

its tail.

The load manifest prepared on this occasion showed

that the weight and balance and center of gravity were

within legal limits although he testified he was sure they

were not.

After he had been with the company for some four

months, Captain Wilkinson told him to increase the take-

A73

Appendiz D.

off weight to 10,800 which was 400 pounds above the legal

limit.

He further describes the difficulty he had with Allan

McKinney after he returned to Johnstown, and found him

quite disturbed that the tickets had been lost, and unsym-

pathetic to his explanation.

John W. Trotter, holder of an air transport pilot cer-

tificate, certified flight instructor with considerable expe-

rience as an instructor in ROTC program, was with Air

East from July, 1970, to December, 1972.

He was a “irst Officer up to May, 1971, and thereafter

Captain.

One of the subjects he taught to pilots at Air East

during the term of his employment was weight and bal-

ance computation.

He, too, was assigned to the mail run and described

about ten takeoffs and landings required. Mail was

loaded and offloaded and the weight and center of gravity

could change on each occasion.

New computations were required therefore, each time.

During the first week of August, 1972, he stated that

Allan McKinney told him not to worry about weight and

balance on load manifests but to stick to the published

schedule and complete forms during the run.

He was on the mail run one week at a time and did that

each time during his tour of duty.

The procedure he followed was to determine when the

basic operating weight plus the fuel on board plus actual

weight of cargo and passengers, On passenger runs, ex-

ceeding 10,455 pounds, he could use the “fudge factor,”

so-called by Allan McKinney when he authorized such use.

He even testified he complained one time when told

that the weight was close to 11,000 pounds and was in-

formed by Allan McKinney the company used what fuel

was needed and then used the specific figures on the

weight and balance form to make it appear legal.

AT74

Appendiaz D.

If more fuel were needed it could be put on but he

was instructed not to go over 10,800 pounds total gross

weight, but the form would show only 804 pounds of

fuel and 200 to 300 pounds of cargo, so the figures would

be legal.

Trotter brought discrepancies in the manifest to Allan

McKinney and Tallent’s attention, warning them that there

was a possibility that the FAA might discover this

procedure,

He used this proedure from his first two or three months

of employment and during his entire stay with Air East.

Wayne Dewitt, an air transport pilot certificate holder,

who now has some 5500 hours of flight time also used

the “fudge factor’? when he had fifteen people on board,

and he testified that 90 percent of the time he had fifteen

people on board, especially while going to Altoona.

He also testified that Allan McKinney told him to use

between 800 and 900 pounds of fuel and 350 pounds of

freight to make the forms come out properly.

Robert Underwood, who impressed me with his honesty

and forthrightness, the holder of an air transport pilot

certificate with some 900 hours as a certified flight in-

structor, was a co-pilot with Air East for two weeks and

Captain for the rest of the term of his employment.

He volunteered to be the permanent mail pilot and

testified that to receive full pay for the mail runs the

company had to be on time 96 percent of the time but

could refuse mail for more fuel and would get paid full

amount as if the full load had been carried.

He testified that he was never overweight on the mail

run but he was never certain of the proper location of

the center of gravity.

He did not always prepare the forms prior to takeoff.

Montague testified to the same effect, and that he was

told to do so by Allan McKinney and J. Tallent. He

A75

Appendiz D.

bumped passengers on one occasion but was reprimanded

by the agent at the time and was spoken to later by both

Allan McKinney and J. Tallent about the practice.

On cross-examination he testified that he falsified the

weight and balance anytime that the aircraft exceeded

maximum gross weight and not only when there were fif-

teen passengers aboard.

During the period he was First Officer he always told

the captain that he did this and recalled having told J.

Tallent. This, of course, would have been done, as he

testified was done, under IFR conditions where the need

for fuel was greater.

Gerald Knouff, the holder of an air transport pilot cer-

tificate, who is still employed by Air East, testified that

he was on the flight with Captain Brannan on January

6, 1974 which crashed after deparature from Pittsburgh

and during the course, apparently, of its landing at Johns-

town, the evidence to me isn’t clear where the crash

occurred—he was taken through the information in

the logbooks indicating the amounts of fuel purchased

during the course of that schedule and agreed if they had

been added properly the aircraft at the time of the takeoff

from Pittsburgh, would have had in excess of 1200 pounds

of fuel on board.

He himself prepared the load manifest before takeoff on

flight 617, which is the one that crashed, and that form

indicated that there were fourteen passengers on board,

and the total weight was 10,793 pounds, with 804 pounds

of fuel. This form was left with the ticket agent at the

counter in the terminal building, and before their departure

another passenger boarded who was »»t shown on the

manifest.

He computed another manifest but this was kept in the

aircraft and showed fifteen passengers with, of course,

three children, two teenage girls and some women, and

that there were 800 pounds of fuel on board.

A76

Appendix D.

The form given to Collins during the course of the in-

vestigation of the crash by Allan McKinney was not,

according to Gerald Knouff, the one he had prepared,

although his initials appeared thereon.

Collins had been unable to find a form at the crash site

and what was represented as a copy of that prepared by

Knouff and left at Pittsburgh, had been furnished him by

Allan McKinney. That is the one that Knouff denied com-

pleting prior to takeoff. The inference is most unfavor-

able to the respondents and particularly to Allan Mc-

Kinney.

B. F. McKinney testified that National Transportation

Safety Board in a report which he identified as a final

report, but which clearly is not a final report, indicated that

the amount of fuel necessary to fly from Pittsburgh to

Johnstown with a 45 minute holding period sufficient to

go to an alternate was 750 pounds. He neglected, or over-

looked, referring to instructions given to the pilots at Air

East to purchase as much fuel at Pittsburgh as they

could during the energy crisis. I think I can take notice

of the fact that the energy crisis was critical, which is a

somewhat redundant expression, but nevertheless it was

critical on January 6, 1974. There is, therefore, sufficient

evidence from Knouff to indicate how much fuel was on

board.

The finding by the Board, also testified to by one of

the respondents, that some 790 odd pounds or less than

800 pounds of fuel were on board at the time of the crash

is worthy of no belief at all because at that time the only

information the Board had was that furnished by them

by Allan McKinney, that showed 800 pounds of fuel were

on board at the time of departure from Pittsburgh.

I think it is a matter—it is an obvious conclusion that

in arriving at their determination as to amount of fuel

at the time of the crash, that figure was used, there can

A77

Appendiz D.

be no other way to determine how much fuel was on board

an aircraft after it crashed.

Paul Sayther also testified still on the second charge

under Air East—he was with the company for ten months

from May 7, 1973, through March 15, 1974. He also holds

an air transport pilot certificate and was hired by Air

East as a Captain.

He was told the same thing by J. Tallent concerning

the fuel to show on board, and the baggage, when fifteen

passengers were carried.

Silas Fuller, also an air transport pilot certificate

holder, was a First Officer with Air East for some five

months, December, 1972, to May, 1973. He also testified

to the practive and his custom of showing the fuel and

gross weight of the aircraft.

He was so instructed, he testified, by both Allan McKin-

ney and J. Tallent, and testified also that he did so quite

often, and particularly when he flew with Captain Wilkin-

son in 1973, February.

He stated that it happened so frequently it was a daily

occurence, according to him,—and this should be apparent

in each of these instances,—it was impossible to determine

the center of gravity prior to takeoff since computations

hadn’t been completed.

One of the respondents, I believe it was Tallent, testi-

fied that he could complete the load manifest on the air

mail in two or three minutes at the most and that there

was no difficulty in maintaining schedule, so there was no

need to fill out forms after takeoff.

However, Luther also the holder of an air transport

pilot certificate stated that with the ten minutes on the

ground at the stops there was not enough time to do the

paperwork, since it was necessary for both crew members

to handle loading and un'oading where considerable mail

was put on.

A78

Appendix D.

He did state that at Harrisburg twenty minutes was the

scheduled stop and that this was not enough.

He did deny that anybody in the company told him to

use this system, but stated that, apparently, it was his

own idea in an effort to maintain the schedule.

David Dunn testified to the same effect.

All of these flights which I have been discussing were

taken in a Beech 99 or Beech 99A where the apparent

gross weight given is applicable.

The denials by the respondent on the fact of testimony

of these and other employees, both former and present, of

Air East, is unworthy of belief.

There is a problem, however, in connection with the

charge of making a finding that the aircraft exceeded the

maximum certificated takeoff weight. There are some in-

dications, particularly, the one where First Officer Knouff

flew with Graff on January 6, 1974, that the aircraft was

clearly overweight.

However, it is obvious that the aircraft center of gravity

had not been computed and therefore was not known prior

to takeoff.

Aircraft clearly operated without compliance with the

operating certificate in violation of Section 91.31A of the

FAR’s and such operation was in violation of section 91.9

of the regulations and the deliberate nature of such method

of operations compels a finding that the company was

reckless and such operation did endanger lives and prop-

erty of others.

Some consideration should be given at the outset, not

particularly in connection with this charge two, but in con-

nection with the testimony of the various witnesses and

their credibility or lack of credibility.

It has been suggested that various pilots testifying dur-

ing the course of the Administrator’s case in chief were all

parties to a conspiracy directed towards removing the

A79

Appendix D.

McKinneys from control of Air East and inserting some-

body else.

There is no evidence at all to support such insinuations.

Much also was made of the fact that during the course of

the various depositions which were obtained from witnesses

by the Administrator, each witness was told that he would

not get immunity by testifying but his cooperation would

be taken into consideration by the Administrator in deter-

mining any sanction imposed on him or any enforcement

action taken against him, and that therefore each witness

came in and exposed himself as having committed these

various violations on the strength of a representation that

he would be released from any obligation in connection

with them.

It is an interesting theory but not a very realistic one.

It implies that the Federal Aviation Administration con-

spired with these various witnesses and encouraged them to

falsify their testimony so that charges could be made

against Air East and the other respondents.

That is the only extension of such a defense I can reach

and I find the argument without any merit whatsoever.

These witnesses, many of them, are holders of air trans-

port pilot certificates. They were not novices. They were

not new pilots in the sense that they had just obtained their

authority to solo, but many of them had had considerable

experience, more so than some of the officers of Air East.

I note particularly that Allan McKinney was the holder

of only a commercial pilot certificate. He was, without

authority, checking other pilots with the company who had

higher ratings than he did.

If there was resentment on the part of the other pilots

toward Allan McKinney for this assumption of authority,

it is understandable.

I, also have cause to comment on the deposition which

the respondents offered into evidence from Alexander, a

A80

Appendiz D.

deposition which was taken by the Administrator but which

was not used nor was the witness called to testify.

This witness stated that it was known, I believe, that

Allan McKinney lacked judgment and the technical capacity

to obtain an air transport pilot certificate and in fact had

failed to obtain one when he had attempted to do so.

Turning now to charge 3: when conducting the opera-

tions described in paragraph 2, Air East, Inc., directed or

permitted its flight personnel to insert false and fictitious

computations on the required load manifests so that they

falsely showed that such aircraft did not exceed the ap-

proved maximum takeoff weight and/or that the loading

fell within the center of gravity limits and that by such

action Air East, Inc., violated Section 135.43(c) of the

FAR’s on each such occasion.

The charge leveled in paragraph 2 is of a violation of

Part 91 of the regulations. Paragraph 3 extends that to

a violation of part 135 of the regulations.

There may have been occasions under charge 2 where the

operation was under part 91, and of course, if there were,

they cannot sustain or support a violation under charge 3.

I note that Gerald Knouff testified that one of his trips

was a part 91 trip and, of course, it could not be used to

support the charge 3.

However, Captain Trotter, Captain David Dunn, Dewitt,

Fuller, Knouff, and Montague all testified as indicated

under charge 2 in a 135 operation.

It is true the company policy manual required load mani-

fests to be completed prior to takeoff on every flight, and

the various witnesses for the respondent denied any knowl-

edge of this practice.

The testimony is otherwise and I find the charge sup-

ported by the evidence. The argument that Section 135.43

(c) does not require a load manifest to be completed prior

to takeoff may be technically—it may technically have some

© et outs Aad e

ee we een Se ne

A8l1

Appendia D.

merit but practically is without any. The heading of that

section of the regulation is ‘‘record keeping requirements,”’

and in great part it does deal with record keeping require-

ments. Subparagraph C under that section goes beyond

record keeping and states that each certificate holder shall

prepare or cause to be prepared a load manifest containing

the following information concerning the loading of air-

craft at takeoff time. That section was violated.

The section charged, of course, does not state—nor does

the section under the charge which is the same one—does

not state the regulation as it reads and it requires only

that the manifest be prepared containing certain informa-

tion.

If the manifest was not prepared containing the infor-

mation the regulation was violated.

It is clear, although again the absence of appropriate

words is to be criticized, the regulation does not say that

the manifest or information will be completed before take-

off, but only that the information be shown on a load mani-

fest, the information which existed at takeoff. There is,

of course, no meaning to the regulation if it is interpreted

as permitting completion of the form after takeoff, showing

what the condition was at the time of takeoff. Pilots need

information concerning the center of gravity before takeoff,

not after, and as respondent points out, the policy manual

itself required that the load manifest be completed prior to

takeoff.

Concerning charge 4: Air East, Inc., on numerous occa-

sions failed to prepare or cause to be prepared as required,

at takeoff time, and to retain, load manifests for opera-

tions involving the carriage of mail by aircraft under

contract with the U. S. Postal Service. Air East violated

section 135.43(c) of FAR’s on each such occasion.

Testimony on this charge has been given by Trotter, Wil-

liam Shoemaker, Wright, Underwood, and Merle Luther.

A82

Appendiz D.

Much of the testimony is the same as that established in

charge 3 and it is found established by the greater weight

of the evidence, notwithstanding the blanket denial of the

respondents individually that such in fact was the prac-

tice, and that if it was, they were ignorant of it.

Charge 5, Air East, Inc.: on numerous occasions, know-

ingly encouraged, or permitted, or instructed and required

its pilots, when conducting operations under part 91 and

135, to use instrument approach procedures at Johnstown-

Cambria County, and Martinsburg-Blair County (Altoona),

Pennsylvania Airports, which had not been approved by

the Federal Aviation Administration in FAR part 97. By

each of such operation, Air East, Inc., violated sections

91.116(a) and 91.9 of the FAR’s and section 610(a) (5) of

the Act.

There is considerable evidence to support the charge in

the record.

Shoemaker was a holder of an ATP certificate, was

instructed to use other than published approach at Johns-

town by Allan McKinney and his father, B. F. McKinney.

He was told this within the first month of his employ-

ment. This unauthorized and unpublished procedure was

drawn for him by Allan McKinney.

Dewitt specifically described an unauthorized approach

into Johnstown by Allan McKinney on February 1, 1973,

and testified that Allan McKinney showed him a 33 ap-

proach to Johnstown which was not published and it

should be pointed out Louis Petersen from the FAA Flight

procedures and air space section stated that there was no

localizer approach to runway 33 to Johnstown before June

of 1973. There was considerable questioning on this mat-

ter but that’s the only reliable testimony that establishes

the date when the localizer approach was legal.

Dewitt, feturning to his testimony, was told by Allan

McKinney that he could not use this approach for three

A83

Appendia D.

or four months and he testified that he never did, in fact,

use it. He also testified that he was with Allan McKinney

when he used it in a 135 operation under instrument

conditions.

He was also shown an unpublished approach into Al-

toona by Tallent on March 7, 1973, with fourteen pas-

sengers on board at this time. He again, when he de-

scribed the procedure used by Tallent, it did not conform

to any legal approach.

Robin Mangold, also the holder of an air transport pilot

certificate, while attending ground school given by Air

East, was shown deviations which were permitted at

Johnstown, deviations, that is, from the published and

legal approaches.

He described his flight with Allan McKinney on May

20, 1973, when he shot a zero-zero approach at Johnstown.

Trotter told of Allan McKinney’s having instructed him

to use “company approach’’ to runway 33, Johnstown,

when it was not a published approach. He drew a diagram

of such approach and that’s Administrator’s Exhibit A-61.

This was after Trotter checked out as a Captain, which

was on May 7, 1971, and he himself used this procedure

in IFR conditions with paying passengers aboard and did

so from July of 1970 to December of 1972.

He also described Tallent as having given him an un-

authorized procedure at Altoona after September 15, 1971,

and stated that he also used that procedure. He used it

only a couple of times as stated, but did not like it and

stopped using it.

Fuller testified that he saw several Captains use other

than published approaches to Johnstown. He was with

Wilkinson when he used it under IFR conditions in a 135

operation in February, 1973.

He described Tallent as having used it in January, 1973,

and related specifically one instance, although not the date

of such instance, when Tallent asked him to look up the

A84

Appendiz D.

3-3 approach, and he couldn’t find one in the charts in

the aircraft. His description of Tallent’s activities there-

after are graphic and he described the laughter and state-

ment that there wasn’t one but it was just one the company

made up and that only certain pilots were allowed to use it.

The respondents testified that they knew of no illegal

approach procedure used at Johnstown. The only ex-

planation they could offer was that the pilots without

much experience were apt to confuse a certain approach

to runway 3-3 which has been initiated in compliance with

published approaches with the actual legal approach.

Review of the qualifications of the various pilots who

testified otherwise reflects, or would reflect if this testimony

of the respondents is to be believed, seriously on the

method of qualifying pilots for air transport pilot cer-

tificates, because many of those testified to the use of un-

published approaches. Their qualifications certainly are

sufficient to have enabled them to determine the difference

between a legal approach and what they unanimously

ealled an illegal 3-3 approach without any difficulty.

In this connection there is no indication on the record

that any of the witnesses called by the Adminstrator co-

ordinated their story or consulted with each other on

practices or procedures. In fact, there is definite evidence

to the contrary.

Pertaining to charge 6: Air East, on numerous oc-

easions, knowingly encouraged, or permitted, or instructed

and required its pilots, when conducting operations under

Parts 91 and 135 of the FAR’s to use altitude and/or

visibility minimums at the airports described in paragraph

5 which were below those prescribed in the FAA approved

instrument approach procedures as described in FAR part

97. Air East, Inc., conducted each such operation in viola-

tion of sections 91.116(a) and (b); 91.117(a) and (b); and

91.9 of the FAR’s and section 610(a)(5) of the Act.

A8

Appendia D.

The record is full of testimony relating to this charge.

Trotter again testified that he was told after May of

1971 to use company minimums, and that he did so under

IFR conditions with paying passengers.

He was also told by Allan McKinney and Tallent to use

IFR minimums at Altoona lower than those published.

Shoemaker, who although not fitting into respondent

Tallent’s image of a pilot, was the holder of an air

transport pilot certificate and testified that he actually went

into Johnstown in actual IFR conditions after the flight

service station was closed, between April 27, 1970, and

April 19, 1973, knowing that to accomplish a landing it

was necessary to go below published minimums. He de-

scribes Allan McKinney as having done so when he was

Captain.

He also testified that Allan McKinney frequently ob-

served approaches made by other pilots to make sure that

they were done as he wanted it, and that would include

descending below published minimums.

Dewitt testified as to going into Johnstown below the

published minimums.

Mangold had what obviously was, to him, a frightening

experience on May 20, 1973, when Allan McKinney was

Captain and shot an approach into J ohnstown under zero-

zero conditions.

He supports his recollection by a log entry indicating

that weather was down to the minimums but of course he

did not put into that log entry that the weather was below

minimums.

He testified that he never saw anything until he landed,

after which he could see perhaps one runway centerline

mark ahead, a distance of perhaps 200 feet, and that he did

not see the ground until after landing. It was a 135 opera-

tion from Pittsburgh to Johnstown.

The witness described an approach into Johnstown with

Allan McKinney on February 20, 1973, at which time they

A86

Appendiz D.

descended to below the minimum descent altitude au-

thorized. He could not, he stated, have kept ground contact

if they remained at minimum descent altitude. Weather re-

port for February 20, 1973, Johnstown, which is Exhibit

A-5, indicates an estimated ceiling of 12,000 feet overcast,

visibility ten miles in a special report for 0200 and 0300.

This was offered by the respondents as destroying the

credibility of Dewitt on this particular occasion but in

closer examination of this refutation, it indicates that the

19th of February was a legal holiday in Pennsylvania, so

testified to by Dewitt—the 19th of February was a legal

holiday, and the evidence reflects that no mail run was

instituted on that date. A mail run that was instituted on

the 19th of February would have landed at Johnstown at

0230 on schedule. If the run had not been operated, then

of course, there was no landing at 0200 or 0300.

Dewitt corrected himself and, as did other pilots, re-

ferred to the confusion where a flight originated on one

day and went through midnight into the next day and the

problem of separating the days. As he explained it, his

explanation was credible. The flight that occurred on said

date took off on the 20th of February and the landing was

the morning of the 21 February 1973.

Another aspect of this defense is the weather report

itself on February 20th at 0200. If there was no mail flight,

what was the weather report, ostensibly taken by Warren

Krise, doing in the record and, secondly if the ceiling was

12,000 feet, why was Krise out there taking a reading on it?

He testified that the only times that he took weather

observations were when instrument conditions prevailed.

Again, the inferences do not favor the respondent’s ex-

planation.

Montague testified to the illegal approach at Johnstown.

Fuller did also. This is an example of the problem in

establishing such charges as were made against the re-

spondent.

A87

Appendix D.

Counsel for the respondent argues and properly so, that

it was difficalt to defend charges which were not specific

because then it would resolve into an issue of credibility.

Here is a case where specific dates were cited and we still

come down to an issue of credibility. Each respondent who

was operating the aircraft on these occasions denies there

was any violation of procedures.

Sayther also testified on this practice, as did Fuller and

also Luther.

Luther, whose character everybody attested to as excel-

lent, stated that when he was hired by B. F. McKinney,

B. F. McKinney told him that approaches at Johnstown

would be at Minimum descent altitude, 200 feet above air-

port elevation and that he did this with passengers while

still in IFR conditions.

Before the schedule was commenced to Altoona, Allan

McKinney advised him he could fly to less than published

minimums and he did so in actual IFR conditions.

Again, Luther is the holder of an ATR and the only

authorized check pilot with Air East, and again I refer to

the deposition of Alexander, where it indicates that Allan

McKinney attempted to become check pilot but he was

denied that honor.

Marzick testified that on February 4, 1974—this in-

cidentally is a month after the accident,—he was flying

with a Captain whose name I don’t have at the moment and

was calling out altitudes as they descended and did so

while they were still at minimum descent altitude, while

they were still in solid IFR, in clouds, and that he was

unable to see the ground. This appears at page 3017 of

the transcript.

Captain Tallent describes the appropriate procedure for

making low approaches to fields and while it is consistent

with their defense, it is not consistent with what the com-

pany policy manual says is the proper procedure nor which

other pilots who testified said was the better procedure,

A88

Appendiz D.

and that is that the co-pilot remain outside the cockpit and

the Captain inside until the co-pilot states that the runway

was assured or the runway was in sight and landing was

assured.

There was no testimony on the dangers of a Captain on

instrument at low altitude who attempts to control the air-

eraft by reference to instruments and at the same time

makes efforts to make contact visual, that is, with a run-

way or runway environment.

Captain Tallent’s explanation of the term company mini-

mums again shows ingenuity if nothing else, and in de-

scribing approach at Johnstown, where the minimum de-

scent altitude permitted by the regulation was 2,940 feet,

he stated that if the pilot was required to maintain that

until he picked up the runway, he’d be too high to handle

it.

The explanation is incredible to me. It frankly does not

make sense. He indicates an abysmal ignorance of the pur-

pose of the minimum descent altitudes.

Charges contained in charge 6, violation of section

91.116(a) and (b); 91.117(a) and (b); and 91.9 of the

FAR’s and section 610(a)(5) of the Act are established.

Mr. Geracuty: Your Honor, could I—are we back on the

record, sir?

Jupce Wooptock: Not yet, but what do you want?

Mr. Geracuty: I would like to speak to you when we are

back on the record.

Jupce Woopiock: All right.

Mr. Geracury: Sir, I may have misunderstood your

findings as you were going along, but I’m referring to spe-

cifically charge 5, and I may not have heard you, if you

said something, Your Honor, I apologize for not hearing it,

but I believe you said there was considerable evidence to

ge

Shen EBS PIE ees AP ONE St SE RTS RIS REIN! Or

;

A89

Appendix D.

support the charge in the record, but I do not believe you

made a specific finding after you made that statement, sir,

because I have no notes to it. I may be in error and if I

am, I apologize.

Jupce Woopitock: If you are, the record is going to

have two findings on it.

Mr. GeraGuty: Yes, sir.

I don’t believe there were any findings stated—

Jupce Wooptock: Because I’m about to make such a

finding, and I thank you if I failed to do so.

I now do so and find that violations of section 91.116(a)

and 91.9 of the FAR’s and section 610(a)(5) of the Act as

charged in charge 5 are established.

Mr. Geracuty: Thank you, sir.

Jupce Wooptock: Thank you.

Turning to charge 7: Air East, Inc., operated or caused

or permitted to be operated under part 135, numerous flight

operations into and out of the Johnstown-Cambria Airport

in weather conditions less than the VFR minimums when

the Johnstown flight service station was not in operation

and without the pilots being given weather reports from

an accredited weather observer, in violation of section

135.65, 135.111, 91.116(c), 91.9 of the FAR’s and section

610(a)(5) of the Act on each such occasion.

The character of the hearing was established in some

ways by the testimony of Warren Krise, a man who the

evidence shows is worthy of absolutely no belief whatso-

ever.

He has been a certified weather observer since June of

1972; and has been with Air East since April of 1970.

He testified that he made observations every night since

June of 1972, when IFR conditions existed at Johnstown

Airport. June of 1972, of course, is the time Air East ob-

tained the mail contract from the Post Office.

A90

Appendix D.

The flight service station operated from 0700 to 2300

hours daily.

If, he stated, it was needed, a phrase which has occurred

frequently throughout this proceeding, he would go to the

airport at 0100 and stay until 0400 hours and then return

home.

He testified then on May 22 to the 25th, of 1973, he was a

patient in the Conemaugh Valley Memorial Hospital, and

that patients in such unit were not required to remain over-

night, and that he did not remain overnight during those

dates.

Exhibit A-5 shows the weather observations, he says, he

made on those nights, and that he checked the barometric

pressure himself when he took the weather reading.

To thoroughly discredit this man’s testimony we have

testimony of various employees of the Conemaugh Valley

Hospital who stated very definitely that self-care patients

are not permitted to leave the hospital after hours except

with their doctors’ permission, and that if they do so, they

were required to check out and check in. They could not

remain overnight if they left the hospital and the one occa-

sion where the testimony indicates, according to the medi-

cal records at the hospital, that Krise did, in fact, leave the

hospital during that period, he signed out on May 26 and

signed back in again at 8:30 p.m.

The two nurses on duty during that period, Adeli Ober

and Dorothy Rok, were completely convincing in their tes-

timony that they checked the rooms during the night and

that Krise, whom they admitted they did not know person-

ally, but whose bed was occupied by the man they knew as

Krise at th

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appendix — Air East, Inc. v. National Transportation Safety Board · 423 U.S. 863 | Frix