Amicus Brief — EPA v. California Ex Rel. State Water Resources Control Bd.

Supreme Court brief1976

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

——————

Supreme Court, L. .

a FILED

iS75

In THE

Supreme Court of the Uni

OCTOBER TERM, 1974

No. 74-1435

THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, anp

RUSSELL E. TRAIN, As AcTING ADMINISTRATOR OF

THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, “

Petitioners, <

Vv.

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ex REL. STATE

WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD,

Respondent.

BRIEF OF STATE OF MARYLAND AS AMICUS

CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS

FRANCIs B. BURCH,

Attorney General,

State of Maryland,

Henry R. Lorp,

Deputy Attorney General,

WARREN K. RICH,

Assistant Attorney General,

Department of Natural Resources

Tawes State Office Building

Annapolis, Maryland 21401

Telephone (301) 267-1251

Attorneys for Amicus Curiae.

AN NR, SDR aS

The Daily Record Co., Baltimore, Md. 21202 ~~

In THE

Supreme Court of the United States

OcTOBER TERM, 1974

No. 74-1435

THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, anp

RUSSELL E. TRAIN, as A'icTiInG ADMINISTRATOR OF

THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,

Petitioners,

Vv.

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ex REL. STATE

WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD,

Respondent.

BRIEF OF STATE OF MARYLAND AS AMICUS

CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS

INTRODUCTION

The issue presented for determination is whether Title

33, Section 1323 of the United States Code requires federal

agencies, institutions, or enclaves to apply for and receive

a discharge permit issued by a state pursuant to Title 33,

Section 1342 of the Code.

2

The larger issue involved in this review is whether the

states may assume without exception their responsibility

to regulate discharges into their respective streams. In

order to “preserve and protect the primary responsibilities

and rights of states to prevent, reduce and eliminate

pollution . . .”, 33 U.S.C. Section 1251(b) (1973 Supp.),

there must be some assurance that the methodology and

enforcement tools to achieve those lofty goals are uniform

within all areas of the respective states.

Amicus curiae respectfully submit that the Ninth

Circuit Court of Appeals correctly decided this case by

holding that Section 1323 required compliance with the

procedures and substantive requirements of State issued

discharge permits under the federal law.

STATEMENT OF INTEREST OF AMICUS

On September 5, 1974, the State of Maryland assumed its

inherent responsibility to administer the National Pollut-

ant Discharge Elimination System permit program,

authorized pursuant to Title 33, Section 1342(b) of the

Code. Similar to the practice followed in the states of

California and Washington, Environmental Protection

Agency officials represented that federal installations

would not be subject to the state permit procedures. This

means that the proposed discharges would not be reviewed

through the mandated public hearing requirement under

state law, nor would there be a full review by all affected

state agencies.

According to the Memorandum of Understanding

between the Environmental Protection Agency and

Maryland, which evidenced “approval” of the state

program, federal applications for a discharge permit are

not forwarded to the state for processing. Prior to

publication for public notice, Maryland receives a copy of

the application together with a summary report prepared

3

by the Environmental Protection Agency. The parameters

for the discharges together with the monitoring require-

ments are included in this summary report.

There are are approximately 1,200 dischargers of

pollutants into Maryland’s waters, 48 of which are federal

installations discharging approximately from 101 point

sources into Maryland waters. Federal installations

discharge into water quality limited areas, tributary tothe

Chesapeake Bay as well as to Patuxent, Potomac and

Patapsco Rivers.

Because Maryland has no control over the procedures

utilized to issue discharge permits for federal installa-

tions, the priority in which the permits are issued and the

relationship ofdischarges from federal installations tothe

assimilative capacities of the streams are subject to

federal determinations only.

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

The Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended in

1972, was enacted to restore the integrity of the Nation’s

waters. The methodology to achieve that end relies

principally on the traditional police powers of the states

and, in fact, Congress recognized the primary responsibil-

ity and rights of the states to prevent, reduce and eliminate

sources of pollution. In furtherance of that goal, the

various States are charged to determine what streams

within their boundaries will require theimposition of more

stringent requirements than what is considered to be the

best practicable control technological standard. The

various assimilative capacities of these streams are

computed and the loading authorizations are part and

parcel of the discharge permit limitations. The permit

encompasses the discharge limitations and itself is a

limitation subject to review, monitoring, and the enforce-

ment procedures set out in the federal act. The permitisthe

4

end product of the various planning processes mandated

under the federal act. The administration of the program

and strategy pursued by the various states must relate the

processing, issuance, and compliance schedules of all

dischargers to achieve reduction of pollution in order to

restore the Nation’s waters.

The language of Section 1323 (Section 313) of the Federal

Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972 is

unequivocal in its requirement that discharges and

runoffs of pollutants must comply with the state and local

requirements. The attempted distinction between sub-

stantive and procedural requirements should not be

pursued in this case because of the interrelationship of

both. In order to lawfully administer the federal applica-

tions, the state may not actin such amannerastointerfere

with a federal prerogative and indeed federal review of a

state-approved discharge permit program can adequately

safeguard the federal interests.

ARGUMENT

I.

THE NINTH CIRCUIT CORRECTLY INTERPRETED THE PLAIN

MEANING OF THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT

IN DETERMINING THAT FEDERAL FACILITIES MUST COMPLY

WITH FEDERALLY APPROVED STATE DISCHARGE PERMIT

PROGRAMS.

(a) The 1972 Amendments should be construed broadly

to effectuate the remedial purposes of the Act.

Title 33, Section 1323 provides, inter alia:

Each department, agency or instrumentality of the

executive, legislative, and judicial branches of the

Federal Government (1) having jurisdiction over any

property or facility, or (2) — in any activity

resulting, or which may result, in the discharge or

runoff of pollutants shall comply with Federal, State,

5

interstate, and local requirements respecting control

and abatement of pollution to the same extent that

any person is subject to such requirements, including

the payment of reasonable service charges. The

President may exempt any effluent source of any

department, agency, or instrumentality in the execut-

ive branch from compliance with any such a require-

ment if he determines it to be in the paramount

interest of the United States to do so. . . (emphasis

added)

Petitioners argue that the term requirements relate only

to those substantive requirements such as, effluent

limitations or other water quality parameters which

would ordinarily be included with the permit. This Amicus

submits that there essentially is no difference between a

substantive or procedural requirement of a discharge

permit. If such a distinction existed, the “substantive”

requirements would be almostillusory. Theinseparability

of discharg: limitations and permit programs was

recognized by Congress in 33 U.S.C., Section 1342(K),

which provides that:

Compliance with a permit issued pursuant to this

section shall be deemed compliance, for purpeses of

section 1319 and 1365, with sections 1311, 1312, 1316,

1317, and 1342...

Section 1365 authorizes suit against the United States

for violations of effluent limitations. Subsection (f)thereof

entwines the substantive with the procedural by providing

that “for purposes of this section, the term ‘effluent

standard or limitation under this chapter’ means * * *a

permit or condition thereof issued under section 1342 of

this Title which is in effect under this chapter (including a

requirement applicable by reason of section 1323 of this

Title)”. See also, Committee for Consideration of Jones

Falls Sewerage System v. Train, 375 F. Supp. 1148 (D. Md.

1974).

rare

6

Considering the remedial purpose of the Act and the

congressional acknowledgment of responsibilities for

water pollution control, the language of Section 1323

unequivocably supports the conclusion that federal

facilities must com, ly with state permit procedures. In a

case involving sim ‘ar language under the Clean Air

Amendments of 1970, i.e., 42 U.S.C. Section 1857f, the

Court of Appeals of the Fifth Circuit rejected the argument

that “requirements” refers only to substantive air quality

standards:

They (defendants) argue that the phrase ‘require-

ments respecting the control and abatement of air

pollution means only requirements such as emission

standards, and limitations, which they label ‘sub-

stantive’ and does not include mechanisms, e.g.

permit systems for enforcing these semuboenila

Having affixed these new labels, defendants would

have us infer that while federal agencies must, and

will, comply with the ‘substantive’, it was not

intended that they be bound by the ‘procedural’, a

term which in defendants’ construct is sub-silentio

pejorative, impliedly denigrating the

Congressionally-mandated mechanisms of enforce-

ment to a status of less dignity and import. This

recharacterization of the statutory scheme is a

semantical red herring. Alabama v. Seeber, 502 F.2d

1238, 1245 (5th Cir. 1974).

The state discharge permit processis an essential part of

all substantive provisions. The Maryland discharge

permit program, approved by the Administrator of the

United States Environmental Protection Agency, 39 Fed.

Reg. 34601 (1974), illustrates the interdependence of the

socalled substantive and procedural provisions. The

permit procedure in Maryland, 1 Md. Reg. 08.05.04.08 and

.12, provides the only means by which water quality

standards and effluent limitations may be employed. The

State can only determine applicable standards and

—-

7

limitations for a particular facility during the administra-

tive process that begins after a permit application is filed. 1

Md. Reg. .08.05.04.08G (1974). The application forms also

provide the public with its major source of information. 1

Md. Reg. .08.05.04.08F (1974). Hearings are not discretion-

ary, but are required in every case. 1 Md. Reg. .08.05.04.08G

(1974).

The permits specify the allowable amount of discharge.

1 Md. Reg. .08.04.04.08H (1974). In cases wheredischarges

exceed allowab). limits, the permit provides a schedule of

compliance. 1 Md. Reg. .08.05.04.08H(3) (1974).

(b) Other provisions of the Act which specifically

exempt federal facilities indieate that federal facilities are

not exempted from state discharge permit procedures.

Specific exemptions for federal facilities appear through

the Act. For example, Section 1316 authorizes the

Administrator to regulate standards of performance for

new point sources. These standards may require the use of

the best available technology and may further prohibit

discharge of any pollutant. Under 33 U.S.C. Section

1316(c) (1973 Supp.), the states may adopt similar

standards and means of enforcement against all new

sources except for those owned and operated by the federal

government. The legislative history of the Act fails to

explain the reason for the exemption.

Section 1318 provides a similar federal-state exemption

procedure for monitoring and inspecting point sources.

Likewise, Section 1341 provides that an applicant for a

federal permit receive state certification. Section

1341(a)(6) expressly exempts federal facilities from the

state certification procedures.

The fact that Congress exempted federal facilities from

state operations in these three separate sections indicates

that the absence of an exemption in either Section 1323 or

8

Section 1342 was intentional. If Congress had intended

federal facilities to be exempt from state permit require-

ments, it would have expressly exempted them. Instead,

Congress provided only for the limited exemptions

authorized by the President. 33 U.S.C. Section 1323 (1973

Supp.).

It is apparent that any justification for exempting

federal facilities from state permit requirements cannot be

inferred from the statute. It is also apparent that the only

justification for the Administrator’s blanket exemption of

federal facilities would lie in the concept of federalism.

IT.

THE ISSUANCE OF STATE DISCHARGE PERMITS TO FEDERAL

FACILITIES WILL NOT UNDULY INTERFERE WITH THE

POWERS OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.

Although Congress appears to acknowledge the pri-

mary responsibilities of the states to control and prevent

pollution of the streams of this country, in authorizing the

various states to develop permit program procedures the

Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency is

given ultimate control to approve or disapprove a

program. 33 U.S.C., Section 1251(b), 1342(b)(1973 Supp.)

In formulating its procedures, each state must comply

with the guidelines established by the Administrator

pursuant to Section 1314(h). 33 U.S.C., Section 1342(c)(2)

(1973 Supp.). In adopting procedures for a permit program

under the act, specifically the states must additionally

comply with requirements established by regulation ofthe

Administrator which include pro forma provisions in the

permits, review of permits, enforcement, and agreements

for exchange of information. 40 C.F.R. Section 124. After

the state program has been approved, the state must

transmit each permit application received to the Adminis-

trator. Under certain conditions, the Administrator may

veto the issuance of any state permit. 33 U.S.C., Section

9

1342(d)(2) (1973 Supp.). The Administrator may also

withdraw “approval” under certain circumstances. 33

U.S.C., Section 1342(c)(3) (1973 Supp.).

The Federal Government, therefore, maintains ade-

quate control of state programs to insure that thenational

or federal interest is safeguarded. The various controls

and submissions required by state programs affect only

the incidental operations of a federal institution. The fact

that the requirements are not inherently inconsistent with

federal interests is evidenced by the statutory ability to

exempt federal agencies from these requirements when a

conflict can occur.

CONCLUSION

The Federal Water Pollution Control Act recognizes the

priority of state programs for water pollution control. The

language of Section 1323 echos the requirement that all

dischargers, including federal installations, adhere to

state requirements.

The specific exemptions within the Act which relieve

federal agencies from state enforcement and certification

procedures, support the premise that if Congress sought to

exempt federal agencies from state permitting require-

ments, Section 1323 would be totally superfluous. Of

course, that is not the case for every other sentence within

this section is to achieve some meaning, consistent with

the purpose of the Act. It should leave no doubt that federal

installations, agencies and enclaves are subject to the

same permitting requirements as every other discharger.

Respectfully submitted,

FRANCIS B. BuRCH,

Attorney General,

Henry R. Lorp,

Deputy Attorney General,

WARREN K. Ricu,

Assistant Attorney General,

Attorneys for Amicus Curiae.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.