Amicus Brief — Train v. Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1976
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
N THI
Supreme Court of the United States
RUSSELE PRAIN, A\pxisistesior or tim PN vires
MENTAL PRotic rion %« cli
Pertoners.
COLORADO PuBtic INtoerst Rist vpou Group Ine
et al.,
Respondents.
Brief of 14 Named States as \mici Curiae in
Support of Kespondents
bevitti J. Younare
lilo OV Greve cf thie S/ We
al ¢ alitoviaia
Ronivt dd OBery
Assistant AUtteric, General
NiIcHoLtas ©. Yoss
C bostin KNiait
Paneuodl. Mouwis
Departs i// / Csgollcrdl
Plo West \ St Site OOW)
San DD C oil ry]
(7}4)
| ‘ i ( fidale
(Nan yal cocdaty ' ij hooting CONET)
Parker & Son, I | |’ i | 1.66".
SUBJECT INDEX
Page
ee os ) |
Statement of Interest of Amici Curiae | 4
Summary of Argument ___. : 5
ee | 7
I
The 10th Circuit Correctly Interpreted the Plain
Meaning of the Federal Water Pollution Con-
trol Act in Holding That the Act Governs
Pollution From Byproduct, Source and Special
Nuclear Materials ...................... 7
A. The Definition of Pollutant Is Clear and
Unambiguous ...... ian 7
B. Legislative History Is Not a Reliable In-
dicator of Congressional Intent in This
ee ee on = K
Il
The AEA and the FWPCA Were Enacted for
Entirely Different Purposes ___. cic
A. The Atomic Energy Act Was Enacted
to Promote Growth of Nuclear Power for
Peaceful Purposes... 9
1. The AEA Was Not Enacted to
Regulate Pollution Caused by the Dis-
posal of Nuclear Wastes | 10
2. The Problems of Waste Disposal
Recognized in the Atomic Energy
Act Are Not the Same Problems
Sought To Be Cured by the Federal
Water Pollution Control Act... 12
il.
Page
B. The Federal Water Pollution Control Act
Implicdly Amended the Atomic Energy
Act nitninemeaiines ae
C. The EPA Is the Federal Agency Most
Qualified to Regulate Radioactive Efflu-
ents Into Our Nation's Waters aie: ae
1. The FWPCA Has as Its Sole Function
the Elimination of Water Pollution — 19
2. The EPA Has the Required Expertise
to Regulate All Radioactive Efflu-
ents ......... | EER Dd 20
D. Regulation of Nuclear Effluents by the
EPA Will Not Result in Unnecessary
Duplication or Inefficient Regulation
15
'
i]
E. The Northern States Case Does Not Pre-
clude EPA Regulation of Byproduct,
Source and Special Nuclear Materials ... 25
Conclusion , ae
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED
Cases Page
Alabama v. Seeber, 502 F.2d 1238 (1974) 9
California v. EPA, 7 ERC 1667 (1975) 9
Colorado Public Interest Research Group, Inc. v.
Train, 507 F.2d 743 (10th Cir. 1974) 2
Ely v. Velde, 321 F.Supp. 1088 (1971) 18, 26
Lietz v. Flemming, 264 F.2d 311 (1959) 26
Northern States Power Co. v. State of Minnesota,
447 F.2d 1143 (171) affd 405 US. 1035
(1972) .. 4, 5, 19, 20, 25, 26
Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference v. Callaway,
370 F.Supp. 162 (1973) 16
United States v. Oregon, 366 U.S. 643 (1961) 7
Statutes
Code of Federal Regulations, Tithe 10, Sec. 71.1(b)
a a 23
United States Code, Title 18, Secs. 831-835 a
United States Code, Tithe 46, Sec. 170 23
United States Code, Title 49, Secs. 1421, 1430,
1472(h) =
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1251
3, 5, 15, 16, 26
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1251
(a) : 7 20
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1251
(f) ' 24
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1252
16, 21
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1254. 21
iv.
Page
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1313.. 26
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1314. 21
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1317. 21
United States Code Annotated, Title 33, Sec. 1342.. 16
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1342
(g) ... Re 25
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1361. 21
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1361
(f) | —
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1361
(h) .. lta cialciel, ae
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1362
a
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 33, Sec. 1362
(b) | a fo
Atomic Energy Act of 1946 : 12, 13
Atomic Energy Act as amended 1954, 1959, 1970
12, 15, 17, 18, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2011. 9
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2011
(b) Siete (oe ae 9
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2012. 9
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2012
(c)(d)(e) ata ae
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2012
Page ea ae Slee a TO 10
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2013. 10
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2014
(q) iieeiliainey ae
Page
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2021
eo : 10, 15, 18
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2021
(b) | 10, I1
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2021
11, 12
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2021
PO 20
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 2210 10
United States Code Annotated, Tithe 42, Sec. 4371 2
Energy Reorganization Act of 1974 (PLL. 93-438)
aL Tes | 12, 17, 18
Federal Power Act 16
Federal Water Pollution Control Act as amended
Se 12, 15, 16, 17, 18
19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25, 26, 27
Miscellaneous
Reorganization Plans 3 and 4 of 1970, 35 Fed.
Reg. 15623 2, 3, 19
Federal Environmental Law (Dolgin & Guilbert)
(1974) rae 13, 14
Committee Print——Legislative History of FWPCA
ee ee ee io 8, 9
Proposed Standards for Environmental Protection for
Nuclear Power Operation, 40 Fed. Reg. 23419
5-29-75 ........ 1, 14
Memorandum of Understanding (3-22-73) 38 Fed.
Reg. 8466 24
Western Interstate Nuclear Board, Report of Com-
mittee on Transportation of Radioactive Materials
(1974) : a 24
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1975
No. 74-1270
RUSSELL TRAIN, ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRON-
MENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, ef al.,
Petitioners,
vs.
COLORADO PUBLIC INTEREST RESEARCH Group, INC.,
et al.,
Respondents.
Brief of 14 Named States as Amici Curiae in
Support of Respondents
Introduction
The Environmental Protection Agency has succinctly
stated the nature of the radioactive water pollution
problem presented in this case:
“ .. A number of long-lived radionuclides are now
discharged [into the nation’s waters| from various
fuel cycle operations which carry a potential for
build-up of environmental levels and irreversible
commitments for exposure of populations that may
persist for tens, hundreds, or thousands of years.
._. 2” EPA, Proposed Standards for Environmen-
tal Radiation Protection for Nuclear Power Opera-
tion, 40 Fed. Reg. 23419, — (May 29, 1975).
axles
The question very simply put is who has regulatory
control over the discharge of radioactive pollutants into
the nation’s waters. Is it EPA, as the express language
of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (FWPCA)
of 1972 provides? Or is it the Nuclear Regulatory Com-
mission (NRC, formerly AEC) as contended by the
petitioners? Amici curiae believe that the 10th Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals correctly decided this case by
holding that EPA has such regulatory authority. Colo-
rado Public Interest Research Group, Inc. v. Train,
507 F.2d 743 (10th Cir. 1974).
In 1946, the Atomic Energy Act presented the only
conceivable statutory authority for the regulation of ra-
dioactive emissions into water. From the Act’s inception
there was a question as to the full extent of such au-
thority. The beginning of the resolution of the problem
was presented in 1970 with Reorganization Plans num-
bers 3 and 4 in connection with the enactment of na-
tional environmental legislation (42 U.S.C.A. §§ 4321
et seq.). These Reorganization Plans transferred sev-
eral functions of the Atomic Energy Commission to the
Environmental Protection Agency. In particular, the
duty to establish “generally applicable environmental
standards for the protection of the general environment
from radioactive material” (Reorganization Plan No. 3
of 1970, 35 F.R. 15623, 84 Stat. 2086) and the re-
sponsibility “for establishing . . . emission limits for
radioactivity .. .” (Reorganization Plan No. 4 of 1970,
35 F.R. 15627, 84 Stat. 2090) were transferred to the
EPA. Under these plans the AEC retained “responsibil-
—_ =
ity for the implementation and enforcement of radiation
standards through its licensing authority.” /d. (Empha-
sis added. )
According to Reorganization Plan No. 4, not only
was the authority to set generally applicable standards
to be transferred to the EPA, but also, the AEC’s au-
thority to set specific standards in accordance with such
general standards was transferred.
“The Atomic Energy Commission is now re-
sponsible for establishing environmental radiation
standards and emission limits for radioactivity.
Those standards have been based largely on broad
guidelines recommended by the Federal Radiation
Council. The Atomic Energy Commission’s au-
thority to set standards for the protection of the
general environment from radioactive material
would be transferred to the Environmental Protec-
tion Agency. The functions of the Federal Radia-
tion Council would also be transferred. AEC
would retain responsibility for the implementation
and enforcement of radiation standards through its
licensing authority.” Reorganization Plan No. 4 of
1970, 35 F.R. 15627, 84 Stat. 2090.
Thereafter, some question lingered as to the dividing
line between the establishment of standards by the
EPA and the implementation by the AEC. The uncer-
tainty was resolved by Congress in the FWPCA of
1972 through the express reaffirmation of the EPA’s
regulatory authority over radioactive pollutants dis-
charged into the waters of the United States. 33
U.S.C_A. §§ 1251, 1362.
entices
Statement of Interest of Amici Curiae
The relative roles to be played by the NRC and
the EPA in regulating the discharge of liquid radioac-
tive wastes is an important concern to amici curiae.
Amici believe that the protection of the health and safe-
ty of the people of this nation requires a clean en-
vironment, including the goal of water free from radio-
active pollution; amici believe that the EPA is the fed-
eral agency best able to determine proper effluent
standards with a view toward this goal. EPA expertise
in pollution matters and its lack of any responsibility
to promote the nuclear industry best permit an objec-
tive examination of radioactive discharges under the
FWPCA.
The health and safety of their citizens is a tradi-
tional concern of the states, and the hazards of radio-
active materials have long been of particular concern.
When private industrial utilization of nuclear energy
was made possible by the Atomic Energy Act of 1954,
however, the role in safety and health regulation that
remained to the states was left unclear. An amendment
to that Act in 1959 addressed the states’ role, but un-
certainties still remained. Finally, when the state of Min-
nesota attempted to apply radioactive effluent regula-
tions to a federally licensed nuclear industry facility,
the courts held that the 1959 Amendment had been in-
tended to preclude such state radiation regulations, ex-
cept pursuant to formal agreements with the Atomic
Energy Commission (AEC) as authorized by that
amendment. Northern States Power Company v. State of
Minnesota, 447 F.2d 1143 (8th Cir. 1971), aff'd with-
out opinion (two Justices dissenting), 405 U.S. 1035
(1972).
—
Subsequent to the Northern States Power decision,
Congress addressed the problem of water pollution by
radioactive materials (as well as other types of water
pollution ) by enacting the Federal Water Pollution Con-
trol Act Amendments of 1972 (FWPCA). 33 U.S.C.A.
§ 1251, et seq. The FWPCA affords to the states a
major role in imposing and enforcing environmental
health and safety regulations concerning water pollu-
tants with the approval of the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency. Thus, the inclusion
of radioactive materials in the FWPCA’s definition of
“pollutant” has important ramifications for states
wishing to participate in protecting their citizens and
environment against radiation pollution. In other words,
to the extent that radioactive materials are embraced
within the FWPCA, the states may now participate in
the regulation of radioactive materials discharged into
their waters.
Summary of Argument
The Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amend-
ed in 1972, was specifically enacted to protect the na-
tion’s waters from pollution of every kind. The Ad-
ministrator of the EPA has the duty to carry out this
Act and is encouraged to seek state cooperation in
achieving this end. This single major purpose of the
FWPCA serves as an assurance that environmental
problems will receive priority consideration in water
quality evaluation, as clearly intended by Congress.
The Atomic Energy Act, on the other hand, was en-
acted in order to stimulate the growth of the nuclear
industry. The concern for public health and safety ex-
pressed in the Act is in reference to nuclear explosions,
over-exposure of individuals to radioactive materials,
—
and problems of theft and sabotage. The Act is not
specifically concerned with the long-term accumulation
of noncritical amounts of radioactive emissions in the
enviroment and the effects thereof.
Enacted to serve completely distinct functions, the
two acts involve only a coincidental overlap in the
regulation of radioactive effluents. Congressional will,
as expressed in the 1972 amendments to the FWPCA,
indicates a strong desire te clean our national waters.
All previous legislative enactments must and can be
interpreted so as to fulfill this desire.
The plain meaning of the word “pollutant” as used
in the FWPCA was correctly interpreted by the iOth
Circuit to include byproduct, source, and special nu-
clear materials. Congress’ failure to specifically exclude
these materials, in light of other specific exclusions in
the Act, should preclude any other conclusion. Even
more persuasive of congressional intent is the fact that
the inclusiveness of the term “pollutant” is discussed
numerous times in the legislative history of the
FWPCA, yet no attempt was made to incorporate the
exclusions proposed by petitioners. The legislative his-
tory of the Act is ambiguous and is not a reliable
indicator of congressional intent. Thus, the clear word-
ing of the Act and its impressive objective, mandate
a finding that by-product, source, and special nuclear
materials are to be regulated by the EPA under the
FWPCA.
enfiun
ARGUMENT
I
The 10th Circuit Correctly Interpreted the Plain Mean-
ing of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act
in Holding That the Act Governs Pollution From
Byproduct, Source and Special Nuclear Materials
A. The Definition of Pollutant Is Clear and Unambiguous
Congress carefully defined the terms used in the
FWPCA (33 U.S.C.A. §1362). As petitioners point
out, a great deal of legislative history discusses the in-
clusiveness of the term “pollutant” as used in the Act.
The term is precisely defined in 33 U.S.C.A. section
1362(b):
“The term ‘pollutant’ means dredged soil, solid
waste, incinerator residue, sewage, garbage, sew-
age sludge, munitions, chemical wastes, biological
materials, radioactive materials, heat, wrecked or
discarded equipment, rock, sand, cellar dirt and
industrial, municipal, and agricultural waste dis-
charged into water. .. .” (Emphasis added. )
In fact, the definition is the most lengthy of all
those contained in the Act. Had Congress intended to
exclude byproduct, source, and special nuclear materi-
als from the operation of the Act, this would have
been the obvious place to do so. In light of the nu-
merous discussions on this matter, it cannot be said
that the failure to specifically exclude these materials is
a result of congressional oversight. The plain meaning
rule (United States v. Oregon, 366 U.S. 643, 81 S.Ct.
1278, 6 L.Ed.2d 575 (1961)) is particularly appli-
cable in this case.
tiie
B. Legislative History Is Not a Reliable Indicator of Con-
gressional Intent in This Case
Petitioners rely primarily upon certain excerpts from
the legislaive history of the FWPCA in making the
argument that byproduct, source, and special nuclear
materials are not included in the Act’s definition of
“pollutant.” Respondents cite other excerpts from the
legislative history which lead to the opposite con-
clusion. In particular, the comments of Senator Muskie,
one of the Act’s authors, are convincing as to
EPA authority over these debated materials (Com-
mittee Print, “A Legislative History of the Water Pollu-
tion Control Act Amendments of 1972 Together with
a Section-by-Section Index,” prepared by the Environ-
mental Policy Division of the Congressional Research
Service of the Library of Congress, 93d Cong., Ist
Sess. (1973); 1 Leg. Hist. 161, 198):
“. . . [T]he Senator is asking whether EPA, in
its authority to set effluent limitations controls
with respect to the subject matter which the Sen-
ator has raised, can set those limitations and
whether the AEC has to accept them. The answer
is yes.
“ . . We considered that this kind of authority
should be in EPA and not in AEC, and in order
to put the authority there, we put it in this act,
and that is where it is.
“ . . The whole concept of EPA is that environ-
mental considerations are to be determined in one
place by an agency whose sole mission is protec-
tion of the environment. It did not occur to us
—9—
that AEC might be more conscientious in this
respect than EPA, so we have given EPA the total
authority on the assumption that the risk from
AEC was not of the nature described by the Sen-
ator but, rather, the opposite, as history demon-
strates.”
This background provides ample reason for this Court
to refuse to rely upon the legislative history for the
determination of congressional intent behind this stat-
ute.’
Il
The AEA and the FWPCA Were Enacted for
Entirely Different Purposes
A. The Atomic Energy Act Was Enacted to Promote Growth
of Nuclear Power for Peaceful Purposes
Throughout the Atomic Energy Act of 1946 (42
U.S.C.A. § 2011, et seq.) the intention to promote the
growth of nuclear power is clearly dominant. Section
2012, the congressional findings, repeatedly refers to
production and utilization of source, byproduct, and
special nuclear materials and the operation of nuclear
facilities. 42 U.S.C.A. § 2012(c)(d)(e). In its recog-
nition that “[a]tomic energy is capable of application
for peaceful as well as military purposes,” Congress
declared national policy to direct the “development,
use, and control of atomic energy . . . so as to promote
world peace, improve the general welfare, increase the
standard of living, and strengthen free competition in
private enterprise.” 42 US.C.A. §2011(b). (Em-
phasis added. )
'See also California v. EPA, 7 ERC 1667, 1671 (1975)
cert. granted; and Alabama v. Seeher, 502 F.2d 1238, 1246
(Sth Cir. 1974).
anffien
“It is the purpose of this chapter to effectuate
the policies set forth above by providing for—
“(c) a program for Government control of the
possession, use, and production of atomic energy
and special nuclear material. . . .” 42 U.S.C.A.
§ 2013. (Emphasis added. )
The government's desire to harness nuclear energy
for peaceful purposes is further demonstrated by those
sections of the Act which limit liability for nuclear ac-
cidents and authorize federal indemnification for the
atomic energy industry. (42 U.S.C.A. §§ 2012(i),
2210.) The Act, as a whole, clearly was meant to
foster nuclear growth, deeming the general welfare and
nuclear energy to go hand in hand.
1. The AEA Was Not Enacted to Regulate Pollu-
tion Caused by the Disposal of Nuclear Wastes
Section 2021 of the Act, “Cooperation With States,”
sets forth a procedure whereby the Atomic Energy
Commission (AEC) (now the Nuclear Regulatory Com-
mission (NRC)) may enter into an agreement with any
state providing for discontinuance of AEC (NRC) regu-
latory authority with respect to byproduct, source, and
special nuclear materials. 42 U.S.C.A. § 2021(b) Sub-
section (b) states:
“(b) Except as provided in subsection (c) of
this scction, the Commission is authorized to enter
into agreements with the Governor of any State
providing for discontinuance of the regulatory au-
thority of the Commission under subchapters V,
aufiftinn
VI, and VII of this chapter, and section 2021 of
this title, with respect to any one or more of the
following materials within the State—
“(1) byproduct materials;
“(2) source materials:
“(3) special nuclear materials in quantities
not sufficient to form a critical mass.
“During the duration of such an agreement it is
recognized that the State shall have authority
to regulate the materials covered by the agree-
ment for the protection of the public health and
safety from radiation hazards.”
The AEA gives only passing concern to the problem
of disposal of nuclear wastes. In only one section of
this lengthy legislation is the issue of disposal men-
tioned. Subsection (c) states:
“(c) No agreement enicred into pursuant to
subsection (b) of this section shall provide for
discontinuance of any authority and the Commis-
sion shall retain authority and responsibility with
respect to regulation of —
“(1) the construction and operation of any
production or utilization facility;
“(2) the export from or import into the
United States of byproduct, source, or special
nuclear material, or of any production or utiliza-
tion facility;
“(3) the disposal into the ocean or sea of
byproduct, source. or special nuclear waste ma-
terials as defined in regulations or orders of the
Commission;
= =
“(4) the disposal of such other byproduct,
source, or special nuclear material as the Com-
mission determines by regulation or order
should, because of the hazards or potential haz-
ards thereof, not be so disposed of without a
license from the Commission.” (Emphasis
added. )
This passing reference to disposal of nuclear ma-
terials is interesting in that this is the sole reference
to disposal in the entire Act, clearly indicating that
this was not a major concern of Congress in enact-
ing this legislation.
The Atomic Energy Act as amended in 1954, 1959,
1970, and by the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974
(P.L. 93-438), adds nothing further in regard to dis-
posal of nuclear wastes. The Nuclear Regulatory Com-
mission (NRC) has assumed the AEC’s duties in re-
gard to nuclear licensing, but the basic regulatory duties
are unchanged.
2. The Problems of Waste Disposal Recognized in
the Atomic Energy Act Are Not the Same Prob-
lems Sought To Be Cured ky the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act
Enacted shortly following the first uses of the atom
bomb at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the Atomic Energy
Act of 1946 displays a recognition of the fearful mag-
nitude of atomic power. Although those bombings
taught the potential health hazards of using nuclear
energy, their primary lesson was the massive destruction
which could be wrought through the non-peaceful use
of nuclear power. The safeguards of the Atomic Energy
Act are directed at the possibilities of a major nuclear
==
catastrophe by theft, sabotage or mishap. Protection
of public health from radiation hazards is discussed
several times, but in a context which implies a connec-
tion to such a catastrophe as mentioned above. For
example, public protection against “nuclear incidents”
is one goal of the Atomic Energy Act. As defined by
42 U.S.C.A. section 2014(q), the term “nuclear in-
cident” means:
“. . amy occurrence, including an extraordinary
nuclear occurrence {42 U.S.C.A. § 2014(j)] .. .
causing . . . bodily injury, sickness, disease, or
death, or loss of or damage to property, or loss of
use of property, arising out of or resulting from
the radioactive, toxic, explosive, or other hazard-
ous propertics of source, special nuclear, or by-
product material... .”
From this definition it can be seen that the gradual ac-
cumulation of radioactive material in the environment
over a period of several decades would most likely not
be classified as a “nuclear incident.” Yet, this slow de-
terioration of the environment caused by radioactive
pollution over an extended period may seriously en-
danger human life. The Atomic Energy Act does not
seem to be geared toward safeguarding against such a
protracted process.
Serious criticism has been directed toward the AEC’s
role in protecting public health and safety:
“In other areas, such as food and drug regula-
tion, for example, products may not be used until
their safety has been adequately demonstrated; in
the radiation area, however, the reverse is true.
since the approach ts to permit exposures to radi-
ation until adverse effects have been demonstrat-
—*
ed.” Federal Environmental Law (ed. Dolgin and
Guilbert), Environmental Law Institute, West
(1974) at 1029.
On May 29, 1975, the EPA issued its Proposed
Standards for Environmental Radiation Protection for
Nuclear Power Operation, 40 F.R, 23419 [40 C.F.R.
Part 190]. The narrow scope of protection of “public
health and safety” previously afforded by the AEC is
demonstrated by the comments accompanying the pro-
posed standards.
“Radiological protection of the public from
nuclear power industry operations has been based
to date on guidance which has had as its pri-
mary focus the general limitation of dose to the
most exposed individual, rather than limitation of
the total population dose from any specific type of
activity. The proposed expanded development of
the nuclear power industry requires, however, the
use of a broader environmental perspective that
more specifically considers the potential radio-
logical impact on human population of radioactive
effluents from the industry; rather than just that
on the most exposed individual. A number of
long-lived radionuclides are now discharged from
various fuel cycle operations which carry a poten-
tial for build-up of environmental levels and irre-
versible commitments for exposure of popula-
tions that may persist for tens, hundreds, or thou-
sands of years.”
“Protection of the public from the environment-
al accumulation of long-lived radioactive materials
may require some changes in regulatory require-
ments.”
==
The Federal Water Pollution Control Act as amend-
ed in 1972 is specifically aimed at restoring and main-
taining “the chemical, physical, and biological integrity
of the Nation’s waters... . (1) [I]t is the national
goal that the discharge of pollutants into the navigable
waters be eliminated by 1985; .. .” 33 U.S.C.A. § 1251.
The FWPCA’s purpose, environmental integrity of our
navigable waters, is entirely different from that of the
Atomic Energy Act. (See Argument II C. | for further
discussion of the FWPCA. )
B. The Federal Water Pollution Control Act impliedly Amend-
ed the Atomic Energy Act
Petitioners claim that
“|p|rior to the decision below, the Atomic Energy
Commission . . . exercised exclusive authority to
regulate radioactive effluents released from NRC-
licensed clectrical power plants and from govern-
ment research and production facilities operat-
ed by contractors for ERDA.” (Brief for the Peti-
tioners, No. 74-1270, p. 19.)
It is interesting to note that petitioners used the word
“exercised” in regard to the Commission’s alleged ex-
clusive authority. Nowhere in the Atomic Energy Act is
such exclusive authority expressly granted. Section 2021
of the Atomic Energy Act expresses a contrary position
in setting out a plan for cooperation between the AEC
and the states. As discussed supra, this section provides
the authority for state regulation of certain effluents
from byproduct, source, and special nuclear materials.
As also mentioned supra, the Atomic Energy Act,
both in its original form and as amended, deals only
minimally with disposal of noncritical amounts of nu-
—"
clear waste. Petitioners’ statement that source, byprod-
uct, and special nuclear materials are “. . . already
regulated comprehensively by the NRC pursuant to the
Atomic Energy Act” is misleading. (Brief for the Peti-
tioners 74-1270, p. 33.) (Emphasis added.) Any pro-
gram currently imposed by the NRC for the licensing of
radioactive effluents is of a voluntary nature; nothing
in the Atomic Energy Act forces the NRC to regulate
ordinary, noncritical emissions.” Regulation by the
EPA under the FWPCA, on the other hand, is manda-
tory for any pollutant entering our nation’s waters. 33
U.S.C.A. §§ 1251, 1252, 1342.
In Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference v. Calla-
way, 370 F.Supp. 162 (S.D.N.Y. 1973) it was claimed
that the Federal Power Act granted exclusive jurisdic-
tion to the Federal Power Commission in the licensing
of hydroelectric plants. The court stated:
“.. . Con Ed points to no Power Act provision
that would require the FPC to satisfy literally or
even substantially the demands of § 404. On the
other hand, § 404 conditions discharge of dredged
or fill materials on approval by two federal agen-
cies, granted pursuant to specific guidelines de-
signed to protect the environment. Their approval
is mandatory under the 1972 Amendments [to the
FWPCA]|, whereas FPC compliance with § 404
would be merely voluntary. To this extent, the Acts
are inconsistent.” 370 F.Supp. 170.
A parallel situation is presented by the facts before this
court. Although the NRC may have taken upon itself
the regulation of ordinary radioactive emissions for en-
vironmental protection, it is charged with no such duty.
“As stated in Argument II, infra. the statutory language of the
AEA refers to possession, use, and control, rather than discharge
of materials after use.
==
One particular historical fact is pertinent in respect
to the status of nuclear regulation at the time the
amendments to the FWPCA were enacted. In 1972, the
Atomic Energy Commission was the regulatory agency
implementing the AEA. There was widespread concern
for the Commission’s failure to adequately regulate the
same industry which it had a duty to develop, as evi-
denced by the comments accompanying the Energy Re-
organization Act of 1974, P.L. 93-438, 88 Stat. 1233.
“(C) The Congress finds that it is in the pub-
lic interest that the licensing and related regula-
tory functions of the Atomic Energy Commission
be separated from the performance of the other
functions of the Commission. . . .” P.L. 93-438
Section 2.
“The Energy Reorganization Act of 1974... .
will consolidate the Federal Government's frag-
mented and uncoordinated energy research and
development functions and, at the same time, up-
grade the regulation of nuclear power.
“
.
“The reorganization established by this legis-
lation has the additional purpose of separating
the regulatory functions of the AEC from its
developmental and promotional functions—a_re-
sponse to growing criticism that there is a basic
conflict between the AEC’s regulation of the nu-
clear power industry and its development and pro-
motion of new technology for the industry.
“Unfortunately, the present Regulatory Divi-
sion of the AEC, from which nearly all of the new
Commission’s personnel and functions are drawn,
has been weak and undernourished in relation to
the vast resources of the development side of the
AEC.” P.L. 93-438, Legislative History, Senate
Report No. 93-980. (Emphasis added. )
This concern alone may have been sufficient reason
for members of Congress to wish to place another agen-
cy in control of radioactive water pollution. Such a
conclusion is no more conjecture than petitioners’ in-
terpretation of the legislative history of the FWPCA,
and, in view of the Act’s language, is far more con-
sistent.
In addition to the congressional intent to amend the
AEA, it should be noted that the Act itself recognized
the possible need for future amendment. Specifically,
section 2021, governing cooperation with states, pro-
vides:
“(a) It is the purpose of this section—
“(6) to recognize that, as the States improve
their capabilities to regulate effectively such ma-
terials, additional legislation may be desirable.”
42 U.S.C.A § 2021.
The FWPCA provides for a gradual increase in state
authority, under the guidance of the EPA Administra-
tor, in regulating pollution into water. This form of
state cooperation would appear to correspond with
the plan set forth in the Atomic Energy Act. Thus,
should this court determine that the AEC (and the
NRC) did, at one time, have exclusive jurisdiction to
regulate effluents of byproduct, source, and special
nuclear materials, it is suggested that this court also
find that the FWPCA, as a later expression of con-
gressional will, has impliedly amended that provision.
Ely v. Velde, 321 F.Supp. 1088 (E.D.Va. 1971).
— =
C. The EPA Is the Federal Agency Most Qualified to Regu-
late Radioactive Effluents Into Our Nation’s Waters
1. The FWPCA Has as Its Sole Function the Elimina-
tion of Water Pollution
During this decade both federal and local govern-
ments have responded to the awakening of environ-
mental consciousness throughout our nation. The time
has arrived when it is recognized that all future life is
intrinsically tied to the maintenance of an ecological
balance in the world in which we live. Navigable
waters play a fundamental role in our ecosystem.
The Environmental Protection Agency was esta-
blished for one purpose—to protect our nation’s environ-
ment. (Reorganization Plan 3 of 1970, 35 F.R. 15623,
84 Stat. 2086, eff. Dec. 2, 1970. See also Reorganiza-
tion Plan 4 of 1970, 35 F.R. 15627, 84 Stat. 2090, eff.
Oct. 3, 1970; 42 U.S.C.A. § 433.) That agency has
no interest in promoting or protecting a_ particular
industry (i.e., the nuclear power industry), and is able
to establish and enforce regulations from an interdis-
ciplinary base so as to insure the best possible protec-
tion of our environment. No other federal agency meets
this qualification.
The Atomic Energy Act, as amended, has several
purposes. The development of the nuclear industry re-
mains the most important. Although the development
and research functions have been separated from the
regulatory function by the forming of The Energy Re-
search and Development Administration (ERDA) and
the NRC, the NRC still has an interest in the con-
tinued use of nuclear power, that being the subjet of
its regulatory authority. This interest of the NRC is
well demonstrated by language in Northern States
—20—
Power Company v. State of Minnesota, supra, 447
F.2d 1143 (8th Cir. 1971) aff'd 405 U.S. 1035
(1972):
“Thus, through direction of the licensing scheme
for nuclear reactors, Congress vested the AEC
with the authority to resolve the proper balance
between desired industrial progress and adequate
health and safety standards. . . . Were the states
allowed to impose stricter standards on the level
of radioactive waste releases discharged from
nuclear power plants, they might conceivably be
so overprotective in the area of health and safety
as to unnecessarily stultify the industrial develop-
ment and use of atomic energy for the production
of electric power.” 447 F.2d 1153, 1154.
Now that Congress, through the FWPCA, has expressed
its unqualified intention to clean up the nation’s water,
new environmental considerations must be weighed by
the agency setting pollution standards and that agency
must be able to view objectively the needs for nuclear
energy and a clean environment. Compromise of health
and safety in favor of nuclear growth is not tolerable in
light of Congress’ expressed intention to ultimately
achieve zero water pollution. 33 U.S.C.A. § 1251(a).
2. The EPA Has the Required Expertise to Regulate
All Radioactive Effluents
Section 2021(h) of the Atomic Energy Act requires
the Administrator of the EPA to develop expertise in
radiation matters.
“The Administrator shall advise the President with
respect to radiation matters, directly or indirectly
affecting health, including guidance for all Fed-
— Ss
eral agencies in the formulation of radiation stand-
ards and in the establishment and execution of
programs of cooperation with States. . . .” (Em-
phasis added ).
Thus, by the terms of the AEA, the EPA Administra-
tor is required to play a major role in setting radiation
standards and to guide the NRC (a federal agency)
in establishing the same.
This cooperation between the EPA and NRC is
further mandated by terms of the FWPCA (e.g., 33
U.S.C.A. §§ 1252, 1254, 1314, 1317, 1361). The Ad-
ministrator of the EPA is required to consult with ap-
propriate federal agencies in setting pollution stand-
ards, conducting research on pollution technology and
in other related areas. In addition, the Administrator
may seek the assistance of other agencies in carrying
out the purposes of the Act. 33 U.S.C.A. § 1361(h).
Petitioners agree that close cooperation is required
between the AEC (NRC) and the EPA (Brief for the
Petitioners 74-1270, p. 53). The problem appears to
be in setting the point at which the authority of the
two agencies is divided. Amici curiae suggest that the
division logically must be correlated to the purposes of
the two Acts involved. Since the Atomic Energy Act
deals primarily with the possession and use of radio-
active materials, its regulation is logically in those
areas. The Federal Water Pollution Control Act deals
with pollution of waterways. In the context of this case,
the concern is radioactive waste materials (effluents of
byproduct, source, and special nuclear materials )—an
aspect arising after the use of nuclear materials. The
EPA is charged with regulating such effluents.
—_, |;
Amici curiae in support of petitioners claim that
“.. . regulation of liquid nuclear wastes from nuclear
power plants is inextricably intertwined with [NRC's]
regulation of other radiological aspects of such plants.”
(Brief Amici Curiae 74-1270, p. 21.) While this state-
ment may be true, it misses the crux of the issue. It is
exactly that dependent relationship between the con-
struction and operation of nuclear power plants and
the emission of liquid nuclear wastes which leads to
the conclusion that proper consideration to environ-
mental protection can best be made by the EPA (see
Argument II B). This is not to say that nuclear growth
should or must cease; rather, strong regulatory control
must be given to the environmental effects of this
growth. Such objective control is best attained through
an agency with expertise in the environmental field.
The EPA, specifically formed to provide such expertise
and expressly requiicd by the AEA to acquire ex-
pertise in radiation matters, is the proper agency to de-
termine allowable nuciear effluent levels consistent with
public health and environmental quality.
D. Regulation of Nuclear Effluents by the EPA Will Not
Result in Unnecessary Duplication or Inefficient Regulation
The authority over radioactive materials discharges
that is given to the EPA by the FWPCA is not incon-
sistent with the continued authority of the NRC to
enforce radioactive materials discharge restrictions
through its licensing program. This can best be illus-
trated with respect to the transportation of nuclear ma-
terials. Under its power to impose conditions to pro-
tect health and safety in conjunction with NRC Ili-
censes, the Commission prescribes standards for the
packaging and transportation of radioactive materials,
including fuel for nuclear reactors. The transportation
4
=~ =
of these same materials is regulated, in addition, with
regard to the same radiation hazards, by other federal
agencies under the Transportation of Explosives Act,
18 U.S.C. §§ 831-835 (rail and highway); under the
Dangerous Cargo Act, 46 U.S.C. § 170 (water); and
under the Federal Aviation Act, 49 U.S.C. §§ 1421,
1430, and 1472(h), as well as by the Postal Service.
The NRC (and its predecessor, the AEC) has never
denied the fact that, while NRC plays a significant role
in nuclear materials transportation regulation with re-
gard to radiation hazards, the preeminent regulatory
power over such transportation with regard to such
hazards is vested in these other federal agencies, pri-
marily the Department of Transportation (DOT). A re-
actor Operator cannot secure a license from the NRC
without conforming to NRC’s radiation hazard control
requirements concerning nuclear fuel transportation;
but DOT regulations designed to control those same
hazards in nuclear fuel transportation must be com-
plied with as well. NRC’s own regulations acknowledge
this multiplicity of control over radiation hazards in
transportation. 10 C.F.R. § 71.1(b).
The transportation example serves to make the
point not only that the Atomic Energy Act is not neces-
sarily exclusive of concurrent regulation by other fed-
eral agencies, but also that the jurisdiction of those other
agencies over matters which are at the same time within
the scope of the NRC is to be ascertained by reference
to other appropriate statutes and not by reference to the
Atomic Energy Act. Moreover, the cases indicate that
where those other applicable federal statutes counte-
nance regulation by the states, state regulations as well
as the regulations of one or more other federal agency
may apply concurrently with NRC (AEC) requirements
concerning radioactive materials transportation. See
—24—
Western Interstate Nuclear Board, Report of Committee
on Transportation of Radioactive Materials (1974).
Such a scheme of overlapping jurisdiction does not
necessarily result in needless duplication of regulatory
effort; rather, it makes possible collaboration and co-
operative application of expertise while insuring greater
opportunity for safeguarding public safety. A provision
of the FWPCA, 33 U.S.C.A. § 1251 (f), states that
“to the maximum extent possible the procedures
utilized for implementing this chapter shall en-
courage the drastic minimization of paperwork and
interagency decision procedures, and the best use
of available manpower and funds, so as to pre-
vent needless duplication and unnecessary delays
at all levels of government.”
This, however, is not a disavowal of overlapping or
concurrent jurisdiction; rather, it is a directive that
when agency jurisdictions do overlap the proce-
dures worked out by the agencies should aim at ef-
ficiency. An example of agency cooperation in an area
of concurrent jurisdiction is the Memorandum of
Understanding dated March 22, 1973, 38 F. R. 8466,
by which the AEC and DOT recognize the DOT’s pre-
dominant authority over nuclear materials transportation
but outline cooperative measures for meshing DOT ac-
tion with concurrent controls of the AEC.
Another example of dual regulation specifically con-
templated by the FWPCA concerns standards of per-
formance for “steam electric powerplants.” Steam elec-
tric powerplants in which the heat from nuclear reac-
tions rather than the heat from fossil-fuel combustion
is used to manufacture the steam, are of course licensed
by the NRC under the Atomic Energy Act, and NRC
demands certain performance standards as a condition
to such licensure. Yet the FWPCA specifically re-
quires EPA nonetheless to impose “national standards
of performance” upon “steam electric powerplants.” Still
another example of dual regulation specifically contem-
plated by the FWPCA (although not having to do with
radioactive pollutants) occurs in 33 U.S.C. section
1342 (g) (Supp. 1973) providing for concurrent EPA
and DOT regulation of pollutant discharges from ves-
sels or other floating craft.
Plainly, therefore, there is nothing in the FWPCA to
repel the conclusion that derives from the plain mean-
ing of the words of the statute. Although the NRC may
have power to limit radioactive materials discharges in-
cident to its authority to regulate construction and op-
eration of nuclear facilities, the FWPCA gives independ-
ent regulatory power over such discharges to the EPA.
If there is a possibility of inefficiency in this congres-
sionally chosen scheme, the solution is administrative
accommodation, as for example by AEC enforcing
through its licensing proceedings the more stringent reg-
ulations that other agencies having jurisdiction might
impose. The solution is not to ignore the important re-
sponsibility conferred by Congress upon EPA for the
public benefit.
E. The Northern States Case Does Not Preclude EPA Regu-
lation of Byproduct, Source, and Special Nuclear Materials
The issue in controversy in Northern States Power
Company v. State of Minnesota, supra, 447 F.2d 1143
(8th Cir. 1971), aff'd 405 U.S. 1035 (1972), was:
“. . . whether the United States Government has
the sole authority under the doctrine of pre-emp-
tion to regulate radioactive waste releases from
nuclear power plants to the exclusion of the states.”
Id. at 1144.
—— | EEE eee
—26—
As has been discussed by petitioners and by amici
curiae in support of petitioners, the court found that
the states were pre-empted from setting effluent emis-
sion standards.
Regardless of the correctness of the court's finding
with regard to state regulation, the Northern States
case does not hold that the EPA may not regulate
radioactive water pollution. The decision refers to a
need for uniform control and federal regulation; the
EPA would provide both. Moreover, the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act, being a later expression of legis-
lative intent, must control over the AEA and _ the
Northern States decision as to both EPA and state
regulation of nuclear effluents. Lietz v. Flemming, 264
F.2d 311 (6th Cir. 1959); Ely v. Velde, supra, 321
F.Supp. 1088 (E.D. Va. 1971).
The FWPCA established a federal program to achieve
a national goal (33 U.S.C.A. § 1251). Throughout the
Act, procedures are created whereby the states may
participate in this program, but such participation is
conditioned upon the approval of and continued sur-
veillance by the Administrator of the EPA. For example,
section 1313 deals with state requirements for meeting
water quality standards. All state programs must be ap-
proved by the Administrator, and if a state fails to sub-
mit a satisfactory program, the Administrator has au-
thority to establish regulations for the state. Additional-
ly, section 1361(f) provides for the detailing of EPA
personnel to the states in order to help carry out the
purposes of the Act; thus, any possible lack of state ex-
pertise in this area is resolved by federal assistance.
— =
Conclusion.
The Atomic Energy Act and the Federal Water Pol-
lution Control Act were enacted for different purposes.
Regulation of all radioactive effluents into navigable
waters is mandated by the FWPCA. The EPA, as the
administrative agency of the FWPCA, must impose and
enforce effluent standards in this area and coordinate
State programs for the achievement of this goal. The
Nuclear Regulatory Commission must cooperate with
the EPA in this move to protect our environment. Si-
multaneously, the NRC will be achieving part of its stat-
utory duty to protect public health and safety. Mean-
while, the NRC can focus upon its primary duty, that
of regulating atomic materials throughout the period
when they are possessed, controlled, and used.
Thus, the NRC regulates nuclear materials in their
operational, or functional, periods. The EPA, under the
FWPCA, regulates radioactive materials which are no
longer being used, but rather, are being discharged into
our national waterways. A clear holding by this court
that EPA has regulatory authority over such nuclear
effluents will afford the best possible protection to the
national environment and public health and safety.
Respectfully submitted,
Eve ie J. YOUNGER,
Attorney General of the State
of California,
Ropert H. O'BRIEN,
Assistant Attorney General,
NIcHoLas C. Yost,
C. Foster KNIGHT,
Janet I. MoTLey,
Deputy Attorneys General,
Attorneys for Amici Curiae.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.