Report of Special Master — Wisconsin v. Illinois
Supreme Court brief1940
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
FILE COPY a
APR. 2
"Any
i
uP se FP
’ ' ty
avi ~
’ [ OLERK
IN THE ;
Supreme Court of the United States
-~
Nos. 2, 3 and 4, Original
OCTOBER TERM, 1940
States of Wisconsin, Minnesota, Ohio and )
Pennsylvania, Complainants,
vs. -N o. 2, Original
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, Defendants.
4
State of Michigan, Complainant, )
* .
~ No. 3, Originai
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, et al., Defendants.
State of New York, Complainant,
v8.
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, et al., Defendants. :
-No. 4, Original
REPORT OF THE SPECIAL MASTER ae
March 31, 1941
INDEX
4 Pace
I.
ee TN oi civccntitemmsicraliptiabeinicaiimiigentadaealsackacnaaa= 1
History of Litigation ——_______.._.... 1
Modification of the Petition of Illinois pintado anes 4
Conduct of the Hearings ae Siaipies : 5
Il.
Historical and Physical Details Concerning Waterway and
Diversion from Lake Michigan 6
General Description of I[linois Waterway 6
Brandon Road Pool a
Diversion from Lake Michigan ce)
¢
Ill.
Complaints and Health Conditions Along Waterway ————_—__- 11
Complaints of Lay Witnesses at Joliet 11
Testimony from St. Joseph’s Hospital 17
Testimony of Principal Civilian Assistant to United States
District Engineer 19
Testimony of Physicians at Joliet bitchiotitn 21
Health Statistics of Joliet SE SEs 23 e
Testimony from Residents of Lockport - ~—e 24
Master’s Inspection of Conditions at Joliet and Lockport —— 26
Weather Conditions at Joliet in 1939 and 1949...» ___ 29
Discharges of Sewage and Oil Into Waterway Between
oe Chicago and Jolteg RE at rman acd a 31
Objections to Increased Diversion by Illinois Communities
Beléw Joliet tare iced $2
Expert Testimony as to Health Conditions . _ 50
General Authorities on Sewage Odors ———————-—-_--_____ 46
Condition of Waterway in Earlier Years — ~~~ ~~... 47
Conclusions as to Health, Conditions iinsphiviotanenipecebiddenmasinetat 50
IV. :
Present Status of Sewage Treatment by Sanitary District;
Outlook for Summers of 1941 and 1942 - peeneneesesengnenshmnennenn 54
Meaning and Importance of the Terms “Sludge”, “B.0.D.”,
and “Dissolved Oxygen” —— 54
General Description of Sanitary District Treatment Plants— 57
Cost of Sewage Treatment Plants and Progress Made in
Their Construction and in Treatment of Sewage ———— 59
Probable Conditions at Lockport and Joliet in the Summers
of 1941 and 1942 ——- ee
¢
«*
INDEX—Continued
Pace
V. og
Available Remedial or Ameliorating Measures ___. ae 72
Dredging, Draining or Flushing Brandon Road pS 72
Results of Experimental 10- ced ——- RES eo cea 78
Chlorination of Waterway — ae =. See ee aE ad los 82
Cascades at Lockport 91
Supply of Additional Oxygen through Production of Nitrate
by Increased Use of Air at North Side and Calumet
Peete —eceneeerewecnes _ 96
Chemical Treatment er t West. Side Sent EAE ct eens DROS A 97
Chlorination of West Side Imhoff Effluent 99
Planned Use of Water Permitted Under Decree of boar
Sen SP aie scalplladucsca 99
Metering of Chieare. ‘Denutic Water Supply _ panirediesiar 102
Activated-Sludge Treatment at Southwest Plant for West
RR DS URSA LAN ah nt i 105
VI.
Summary and Recommendations for Decree ee
nc acne th BARI Ea ec 110
Recommendations for Decree _..._—s—S ee Nee.
©
“a
=, a aS < +s -
\
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
Nos. 2, 3 and 4, Originai
OCTOBER TERM, 1940
States of Wisconsin, Minnesota, Ohio and }
Pennsylvania, Complainants,
. Vs. No. 2, Original
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, Defendants. | og
State of Michigan, Complainant, :
ee | No. 3, Original
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, et al., Defendants.
/
State of New York, Complainant, )
A
set No. 4, Original
State of Illinois and the Sanitary District
of Chicago, et al., Defendants. J
—
REPORT OF THE SPECIAL MASTER
March 31, 1941
I.
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
History of Litigation
- On May 9, 1922, the original proceeding in this cause
was begun when the State of Wisconsin moved for leave
2
to file a bill for an injunction to prevent the State of
Illinois and the Sanitary District of Chicago from divert-
ing water from Lake Michigan at Chicago. The States
of Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan and New
York subsequently joined as complainants or filed inde-
pendent bills. After a reference to Charles Evans
Hughes, Esq; as Special Master, the Court on January
14, 1929, rendered an elaborate opinion through Chief
Justice Taft (278 U. S. 367), holding the diversion of
water from Lake Michigan to be illegal, except -insofar
as it might be required to maintain navigation in the/*
Chicago River. one
The case was again referred to Special Master
Hughes for a report upon the practical measures nev-
essary for the disposition of the sewage of the Sanitary
District through other means than the diversion of
water from Lake Michigan, the time which would be
required therefor, what reduction in diversion would
meanwhile be practicable, and the diversion which would
be permanently necessary to maintain navigation in the
Chicago Rifer.
On April 21, 1930, following the report of the Master
upon this reference, a decree was entered pursuant to an
opinion of Mr. Justice Holmes (281 U. S. 696), enjoin-
ing the State of Illinois and the Sanitary District of
Chicago from diverting any of the waters of the Great
Lakes-St. Lawrence System or watershed through the
Chicago Drainage Canal or otherwise in excess of the fol-
lowing annual averages, in addition to domestic pumpage:
From July 1, 1939 to December 31, 1935... 6500 c.f.g.1
From December 31, 1935 to December 31, 1938__.__._ 5000 c.f.s.
From December 31, 1988 —— = ——- 1500 c.2.s.
On October 10, 1932, (287 U. S. 568) upon the ap-
1C.f.s. will be used in this report as an abbreviation for cubic feet
per second. One cubic foot per second is approximately two-thirds of
@ million gallons per day.
3
plication of the complainants, Illinois and the Sanitary
District were ordered to show cause why they had not
taken appropriate steps to effect compliance with the
requirements of the decree of April 21, 1930. After a ref-
erence to Edward F. McClennen, Esq., as Special Master,
the Court, through Mr. Chief Justice Hughes, handed
down an opinion enlarging its original decree by direct-
ing the State of Illinois to take all necessary steps, in-
cluding the provision of necessary moneys, to secure the
completion of adequate sewage “disposal plants, together
with any necessary controlling works to prevent reversals
of the Chicago River (289 U. S. 395).
On Ja@uary 11, 1940, Illinois applied for a modifi-
cation of the decree entered on April 21, 1930, to permit
a temporary increase of the diversion to 5,000 cubic feet
per second, in addition to domestic pumpage, until De-
cember 31, 1942. After a hearing upon this apylication,
the Court on April 30, 1940, rendered a per curiam opin-
ion (309 U. S. 569), in which it said:
“The State of Illinois has failed to show that
it has provided all possible means at its command
for the completion of the sewage treatment system
as required by the decree as specifically enlarged
in 1933 (289 U. S. 395, 710). No adequate excuse
has been presented for the delay. Nor has the State
submitted appropriate proof“that the conditions
complained of constitute a menace to the health
of the inhabitants of the comp!aining communities
or that the State is not able to provide suital.
measures to remedy or ameliorate the alleged con-
ditions without an increase in the diversion of
water from Lake Michigan in violation of the
rights of the complainant States as adjudged by
this Court.
“In order, however, that the Court may, be
satisfied as to the actual condition of the Illinois’
‘
4
Waterway by reason of the introduction of un-
treated sewage, and as to the actual effect, if any,
of that condition upon the health of the inhabi-
tants of the complaining communities, and also
with respect to the feasibility of remedial or ameli-
’ orating measures available to the State of Illinois
without an increase in the diversion of water from
Lake Michigan, the Court appoints a Special Mas-
ter to make a summary inquiry as to such condi-
tion, effect and measures, and to report to this
Court with all convenient speed.”
Modification. of the Petition of Illinois
After the hearings before me had been completed,
Illinois in the: brief which it submitted to me and the
findings which it requested me to enter, modified its pe-
tition so as to ask for an additional diversion during the
months from April to October, in each of the years 1941
and 1942 to the extent necessary to provide a minimum
of 1 part per million’ of dissolved oxygen in the water
above the dam at Brandon Pool at Joliet, subject to the
~ following maximum increases above the 1500 c.f.s. now
permitted:
1941 1942
April 1900 0
May 3000 2000
June 5000 4000
July 6000 5000
August 5000 3000
September 3000 1000
October 1000 0
According to the schedule set out by Illinois in its
modified petition, the total increase in diversion of water,
if the modified application were granted, would amount,
on an annual basis, to 2,000 c.f.s. in 1941 and to 1,250
c.f.s. in 1942. :
iParts per million will be hereinafter referred to as p.p.m.
5
Conduct of the Hearings
On July 8, 1940, accompanied by counsel for all
parties, I went by automobile from Chicago to Joliet, IIl.,
a distance of about 45 miles by road (the distance by
rail is about 40 miles), and there at a point below the
Brandon Road Dam, took a boat provided by the Sanitary
District and proceeded through the Brandon Road Pool,
a distance of about 5 miles. On July 10th, accompanied
by counsel, I made an inspection of the sewage disposal
plants situated on the West Side and the Southwest Side.
The taking of testimony was begun in Chicago on July
11, 1940 and continued through July 12. Beginning July
22, 1940, I spent four days at Joliet, where the te.cimony
of a large number of vVéitnesses was,taken, and upon this
visit I again took a boat and made an inspection of the
Waterway from the Brandon Road Dam to the Lockport
Dam. I also drove by automobile along the Canal to
Lockport. While the testimony was being taken at Joliet,
I resided at the Louis Joliet Hotel, which is four blocks
from the Canal.
The taking of testimony was resumed in Chicago
in September, 1940, and hearings were had from time
to time in September and October. Another hearing was
held in Chicago in January, 1941, primarily for the pur-
pose of recording the results of the experimental flow of
10,000 c.f.s over a period of ten days which was author-
ized by the Court’s order of November 25, 1940, as well
as for the purpose of receiving final reports as to the
status of the sewage disposal works and the conditions
in the Waterway.
Argument was heard in New Orleans on February
20, 21 and 22, 1941. Additional documentary evidence
was then received. Full briefs and reply briefs
6
were filed on both sides. The record comprises approx-
imately 4,000 pages. The total number of witnesses heard
aggregated 161. A large number of exhibits were re-
ceived.
Il.
HISTORICAL AND PHYSICAL DETAILS CONCEFN-
ING WATERWAY AND DIVERSION FROM
7 LAKE MICHIGAN ;
General Description of Illinois Waterway
Full historical details with respect to the Waterway
are to be found in the original report of Special Master
Hughes filed on May 23, 1927, some of the facts stated
in which are summarized in the opinion of Chief Justice
Taft reported in 278 U. S. 367.\Only a few of the more
important facts will be noticed here.
The Ill:nois Waterway extends from Lake Michigan
at Chicago to the Mississippi River at\Grafton, Ill, a
distance of approximately 327 miles. It comprises the
Chicago River, the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal
(an artificial channel constructed by the Sanitary Dis-
trict of Chicago') and the Des Plaines and Illinois Rivers.
The Canal Section was constructed between 1892 and
1900 and was opened for use on January 17, 1900. Up
to that time the Chicago River flowed into Lake Mich-
igan, carrying with it the sewage of Chicago, which
was discharged into the river. The river before 1865
“in its natural state was a sluggish stream, especially
in its lower reaches. Receiving the sewage of a rapidly
1The Sanitary District was organized under the Illinois Act of
1889 and its organization was completed in 1890. Its area comprised
185 square miles extending from the Illinois State line on the south
and east to the northern boundary of Cook County on the north, with
about 34 miles of frontage on Lake Michigan, thus embracing the
metropolitan area of Chicago, consisting of Chicago and its suburbs.
The area now Comprises 442 square miles.
~*
7 ,
growing city, together with the waste of industrial plants,
* it became very offensive”; see 1927 report of Special
Master Hughes, page 12. In 1872 “the canal was grossly
polluted”, ibid, page 13. In 1891 “as the city continued
to grow the nuisance along the canal was at times as
bad as ever’, ibid.
After the Canal was opened, the flow of the Chicago
River was reversed so that it was made to flow away
from Lake Michigan. All sewage in the District was
turned into the main channel, completely untreated.
In January, 1900, the State of Missouri filed a suit
in this Court against Illinois to restrain the discharge of
sewage by Chicago into the Illinois River on the ground
that it came from the Illinois River to the Mississippi
River at a point about 43 miles above the City of St.
Louis and might endanger the health of the inhabitants
of that City. A demurrer to the bill was overruled ;
Missouri vs. Illinois, 180 U. S. 208; decided January 28,
1901. The case was then heard on the merits and a
decree entered on February 19, 1906, dismissing the bill
on the ground that the complainant had failed to estab-
lish the allegations of the bill, particularly in view of
~the considerable distance from the origin of the sewage
to Missouri and the oxidizing qualities of the water from
Lake Michigan and the Mississippi River; Missouri v.
Illinois, 200 U. S. 496.
The Canal Section of the Waterway extends from
the Chicago River at Damen Avenue (sometimes called
Robey Street), which is about 6 miles from Lake Mich-
igan, and extends thence 30 miles to Lockport. Two miles
west of Lockport the Canal connects with the Des Plaines
River,’ Further south the stream is joined by the Kan-
kakee River and becomes known as the Illinois River.
Since 1930 a controlling works and lock hayé& been
8
constructed by the Sanitary District at the mouth of
the Chicago River to prevent reversais into Lake Mich-
igan.
From Grafton to just below Lockport (a distance of
approximately 290 mil 3) the Waterway is generally 300
feet wide and 9 feet deep. From Lockport to Chicago
Harbor, the channel is generally 160 feet wide and 21
feet deep. \ |
A series of dams and locks with resulting pools above. .
the “ams have been constructed in the Waterway in order
to assist navigation by eliminating rapids in the stream.
In the order in which they are approached from Chicago,
these are situated at Lockport, Brandon Road Pool, Dres-
den Island, Marseilles, Starved Rock, Peoria, LaGrange
and Alton. All of these are now operated by the federal
government. At the time of the rendition of the 1930
decree of this Court, the Lockport Dam and Pool were in
existence, but not the others. The section of the Water-
way directly involved in the present controversy contains
only the pools at Lockport and Brandon Road. The
Brandon Road Pool is situated at Joliet and appears to
be the chief source of the complaints at this time. Fur-
ther details with respect to it are accordingly here noted.
Brandon Road Pool
ia The construction of Brandon Road Lock and Dam was
begun by the State of Ilinois but taken over by the fed-
eral government in 1930. It was completed in 1933.
Prior to its creation there was. an old dam at Jackson
Street in Joliet, and the Des Plaines River between that
point and the Brandon Road Bridge flowed rapidly over
rocks, creating considerable turbulence. The channel was
comparatively narrow, varying in depth from a minimum
of 1 to 2 feet to a maximum of 6 to 8 feet, and naviga-
tion was possible only through the old Illinois and Michi-
°
9 g
gan Canal. As technically defined by the United States
Engineers, the Brandon Road Pool extends from the power
- house of the Sanitary District near Lockport to the Bran-
don Road Dam just below Joliet, a distance jof approxi-
mately 5 miles. For the greater part of the distance, how-
ever, the Pool is not much wider than the Waterway.
At a point below the McDonough Street Bridge at
Joliet, the width expands from approximately 270 ft. to
a maximum of 1,400 ft, The maximum width extends
for about half a mile. The Joliet city map indicates that
this wide section of the Pool is at the southern end of
Joliet, for the most part outside the corporate limits, ’
and it appears to be one to two miles from the residences
of most of the Joliet witnesses. It is this lower, wide
section that is generally referred to as the Brandon Road
Pool.
Diversion from Lake Michigan
Including domestic pumpage, the water directly ab-
stracted from Lake Michigan by the Sanitary District
in earlier gears ranged from 2,990 c.f.s. in 1900 to 7,839
c.f.s. in 1912 (1927 report of Special Master Hughes, p.
22). The quantities thus abstracted substantially exceeded
the amounts authorized by permits issued from time to
time by the Secretary of War. In October, 19¥3, the
United States brought suit against the Sanitary District
in the District Court for the Northern District of Illinois,
to enjoin the Sanitary District from diverting more water
than that authorized by the permit then outstanding,
which allowed a maximum diversion of 250,000 ft. -per
minute, equal to 4,167 c.f.s., including domestic pumpage.
After many years of delay, a decree was entered in favor
of fhe United States on June 18, 1923, which was affirmed
by this Court in an opinion rendered on J anuary 5, 1925,
by Mr. Justice Holmes; Sanitary District of Chicago vs.
-
10
United States, 266 U. S. 405. The decree was without
prejudice toeany permit that might be issued by the Sec-
retary of War.
Following this decision, on March 3, 1925, the Sec-
retary of War issued a permit authorizing the diversion
of an amount not exceeding 8,500 cf.s. in addi-
tion to domestic pumpage. This permit expired by
limitation on December 31, 1929, mand the Secretary of
War then issued a permit for 8,500 c.f.s., including do-
mestic pumpage, to expire June 30, 1930. This permit
was in effect set aside by the decree entered by this Court
on April 21, 1930, in the injunction suit filed by Wiscon-
sin and other Lake States (281 U. S. 696), and the
Secretary of War on June 26, 1930, issued a permit to
conform with the Court’s decree, which provided for
a reduction of the flow as stated, supra, page 2.
The decree of April 21, 1930 provided that the
amount to.be diverted was to be determined by deducting
from the total average flow at Lockport: the amount of
domestic pumpage, i. e. water pumped from Lake Michi-
gan by the City of Chicage into its water mains. During
the years 1938, 1939 and 1940 the (a) total average
monthly flow at Lockport and (b) Chicago domestic
pumpage were as follows in c.f.s.:
1988 1989 1940
Average total flow at Lockport... 6,648 3,182 3,319
Domestic pumpage 1,604 1,620 1,589
Inflow from Des Plaines River—._....._ 45 13 49
Net water taken from Lake Michigan,
exclusive of domestic pumpage—.. 4,999 1,499 1,681
The 1940 figures: were increased by the temporary
flow of 10,000 c.f.s. for a period of ten days from De-
cember 2 to December 12, 1940, permitted for experi-
mental purposes in accordance with the stipulation of
¥
2 ae PET ears
° . 2
11
the parties, by the Court’s order of November 25th, 1940
to which further reference is hereinafter made. Exclud-
ing this 10-day experimental period, the 1940 total flow
at Lockport averaged 3,138 c.f.s., and the domestic pump- |
age 1,592 c.f.s., leaving*a net amount diverted from the
Lake, in addition to pumpage and excluding the 10-day
experimental flow period, of 1,546 c.f.s.
ITI.
COMPLAINTS .AND HEALTH CONDITIONS ALON
”
WATERWAY :
Complaints of Lay Witnesses at Joliet
The complaints as to the Waterway which were pre-
sented to me emanated entirely from residents of Lock-
port and Joliet, and chiefly from the residents of Joliet.
Lockport is situated on the Waterway about 35 miles
from Chicago. Jpliet is similarly situated about 40 miles
from Chicago.
The population of Joliet was reported in-the last
three censuses as follows:
1920 38,414
1930 ° 42,993
1940 42,365
The’ Health Commissioner of the City estimated the
number of people living in Joliet and surrounding terri-
tory who were likely to be affected by health conditions
in and near Joliet at 50,000. A number of large indus-
tries are situated in the city and several important rail-
a» Toads traverse it. The Des Plaines River joins the Water-
way just below Lockport, three or four miles above Joliet.
The Waterway flows through Joliet and is crossed b
eight bridges there. |
12
No water from the Waterway is used for drinking
purposes and there is no swimming in it. All of the
complaints were based upon the offensive odors from the
Canal and the effects ascribed thereto. The complaints
proceeded almost entirely-from persons residing alongside
the Canal or near it.
A total of 127 witnesses appeared before me during
the four days of the hearings at Joliet, made up as fol-
lows:
Lay residents of Joliet =a
Physicians residing in Joliet ; 15
Nurses and employees of St. Joseph’s Hospital at
Joliet 24
Lay residents of Lockport i |
127
On the fourth day of the hearings at Joliet, in order *
to avoid cumulation of testimony, it was stipulated that
if 200 additional witnesses were called, they would testify
substantially along the same lines,
Of the 81 lay witnesses residing at Joliet who ap-
peared before me in person, 38 were men and 43 were .
women. The residences of these witnesses with ‘respect
to the location of the Canal may be thus Summarized:
Within two blocks of the Canal eae
Within three blocks _ 10
IL TUNE TIE Sertcinifstts Sissi cir ete L N 4
NE I I oa Gsasidaciniccee scandens ten 2
Within one-half mile “ees 7
Within one mile 4
More than one mile 4
Not stated 3
81
Thus, approximately three-fourths of the witnesses
1Included in the Lockport figure are the United States Lock Master
at Lockport and his assistant, whom I encountered upon. a tour of
inspection. They were not subpoenaed by Illinois, but I tcok their tes-
timony on my own initiative as to the conditions at Lockport; they
Hf no cause for complaint. :
13
resided within four blocks of the Canal, and more than
half within two blocks. Their residences were within
one to two miles of the wide portion of the Brandon
Road Pool, which, below the McDonough St. Bridge,
extends to a width of 1400 feet for a distance of approx-
imately half a mile.
The complaints were generally to the effect that the
Canal in the hot summer months of 1939 gave off ex-
tremely offensive odors, which, in the case of many of the
witnesses, caused them or members of their family to
suffer from nausea, lack of appetite and inability to
sleep. Some who complained of nausea had no trouble in
sleeping; others complained of inability to sleep and not
of nausea.
\
A substantial number of ‘the witnesses who com-
plained that the odors caused lack of appetite or nausea
appeared to be overweidht. A number of the witnesses
said that they suffered no ill effects themselves, but tes-
tified as to the ill effects suffered by members of their
family. 2 : " |
The character of the odors was described by various
witnesses as the odor of sewers or outhouses or of rotten
eggs. Many witnesses used the general terms, “terrible’’,
“vile”, “very offensive”, “unbearable”.
All of the witnesses agreed that the Canal had
always given off objectionable odors (as wowlg be ex-
pected from a stream into which untreated sewage has
for many years been deposited), but, with practically no
exceptions, they testified that in 1939 the odors were muck
more offensive and disturbing than they had been in
previous years’
‘
‘
1In their brief before me counsel for Illinois said (p. 17):
“* * the State of Illinois admits that conditions were never
wholly satisfactory even prior to 1939, but insists that the con-
ditions did not become acute or serious until December 31, 1938
when the diversion was cut from 5,000 c.f.s. to 1,500 ¢.f.s.”
14
A former lieutenant governor of Illinois testified that —
he had lived within about 3 blocks of the Canal for about
34 years; that there had been “disagreeable odors”
from the Canal from time to time in the past “but —
the odor now seems to be a combination of unpleasant,
disagreeable and nauseous odors”. The witness further
testified :
“I have believed that we who are here locally
are becoming somewhat immune to this condition,
that it is more noticeable when strangers, vis- ~
itors, come to the place. I believe that there is a
feeling that residence within the close proximity
to this channel is not desirable and, maybe, pos-
sibly affects the valuation of property in the im-
mediate vicinity of the channel.”
Asked if he had ever known of any illness or tem-
porary discomfitures traceable to this condition, the wit-
ness replied:
“No, I don’t think so, save the psychological
effect that it would have on a person who might
attribute his illness to that and, believing in it,
would, perhaps, become more or less of an invalid
from a psychological effect, perhaps a state of
mind.”
_ Practically all of the witnesses were agreed that the
odors from the Canal were much worse in the summer of
1939 than in 1938, which was ascribed by the witnesses
to the fact that the diversion from Lake Michigan was cut
on December 31, 1938, from 5,000’c.f.s. to 1,500 c.f.s.
There was some difference of opinion as to how the
conditions in 1940, when the witnesses were testifying,
compared with those in 1939, but the great weight
of the testimony was that conditions in July, 1940,
when the testimony was. given, were better than
they had been in 1939. Some of the witnesses
15
ascribed this to the fact that the weather had not
been as hot in i940 as in 1939, without referring
to the fact that the treatment of sewage at the
plants of the Sanitary District had advanced substantially
since 1939. A number of witnesses were of the opinion
that the odors were as bad in 1940 as they had been in
1939, and a few thought that they were worse in 1940.
All witnesses examined on the subject agreed that
the odors were worse when the weather was hot. A num-
ber testified that they were worse when the weather was
humid and sultry and after rains. The witnesses were
also agreed that the odors were intermittent, not con-
stant; that they were more noticeable when boats or
barges moved through the water and stirred up the
water; and that they were also worse at night or in the
early morning than during the day.
A number of the witnesses testified that the water
was dirty and black and that they had observed thick
scum on the Canal in 1939. A photograph offered by
Illinois taken in June, 1939, at a point between Summit
and Willow Springs (about 20 miles above Joliet) showed
considerable scum. A photograph taken by the opposing
States at the same point in September, 1940, showed no
scum. The testimony indicated that scum was also
noticed in earlier years, but not to the same extent as in
1939.
There were approximately a dozen complaints of
sore throat and nose or sinus trouble. -
Two witnesses testified that their children had
asthma.
The family of one witness had diarrhea; the children
of another had a summer complaint. The grandchildren
of another had dysentery. »
‘ Another witness testified that his children became
16
sick from the odors without specifying the nature or
duration of the illness.
One witness who jumped into the Canal to rescue a
man who was trying to commit suicide, had skin trouble,
which cleared up under treatment. The pilot of a deck- -
boat had some sores on his lips, which were made worse
by water or spray splashing against his lips and “the
doctor thinks it might have been that water”. Apparently
the sores cleared up and no time was lost from work
because of them. The witness testified that during the
six years he got “sick to my stomach” every once in a
while. It was not entirely clear from his testimony
whether he thought conditions much worse in 1939 than
in other years.
A diver employed for many years by the United
States Engineers to work upon the Waterway testified
that the gases were worse than they had been and the
water was blacker and contained more muck. The brass
on his diving suit had turned black. His health is good.
A lockman employed at Brandon Road could not eat
his lunch on two hot days in July, 1940; the water is
black since they cut the flow and the fish die. “Oh, my
health is pretty fair, only when them obnoxious gases and
odors come up once in a while, it pretty near turns your
stomach. We work right along the locks though.” He
has had no sick leave for several years.
A young woman employed as a school teacher had a
sear on her foot that she received from a fly infec’ion
which she blamed upon the water though it does not
appear that she had had any direct contact with the
water.
A-teacher of sixth grade children, of the average age
of eleven, at a school situated about 3 blocks from the
Waterway, testified that the odors were terrible in June,
17
1939, and the children were made very restless and hard
to keep at work. Another teacher, the principal of the
McKinley Public School situated within 600 feet of the
Canal, where the children are in the first six grades,
ranging up to an average of 12 to 13 years old, testified
* that the odors were very offensive in 1939, and the teach-
ers complained that they had to shut the windows in
order to keep the children’s minds on their work, and
they were restless. Children have become suddenly sick
with nausea. Two or three at a time would be taken out
of their classes, sent home and were kept home for a
day or so. The witness thought that the conditions were
worse in 1939 than in other years.
A woman who lived about half a block away, testi-
fied that the gas from the Canal had ruined the paint on
the homes in the neighborhood, turned it all black; this
happened in 1939 and some cf her glassware had been
discolored.
The witnesses agreed that the odors were not as
noticeable at a distance from the Canal as near it. Some
of the witnesses drove out at night during the summer
to avoid the odors. Many of them testified that they
kept their windows closed to keep the odors out.
Only a small proportion of the witnesses testified
that they had had any occasion to consult a doctor, and
it did not appear that anyone was confined to bed by
illness which could be attributed to the Waterway. Most
of the witnesses were working people and members of
their families. Most of them rented the houses in which
they lived, under leases running from month to month.
No coat
Testimony from St. Joseph’s Hospital
St. Joseph’s Hospital is situated in Joliet about a
block and a half to two blocks from the Canal on the west
side. It covers an area of about two square blocks and
4
te
18
has about 220 beds. It is operated by the Franciscan
Order of the Sacred Heart and has been in its present
location since 1875 or 1876. The Silver Cross Hospital
is also located in Joliet, but apparently not close to the
Waterway; no witness from it appeared before me.
In the hearings at Joliet, testimony was given
by 15 Sisters occupying various positions at the hos-
pital and*also by 7 lay nurses and 1 resident intern.
Their testimony was to the general effect that the odors
from the Canal were extremely offensive in 1939 and
caused to many of them, and to many of the patients,
nervousness, nausea, vomiting, inability to sleep and head-
aches. Some of the patients are anxious to go home.
because of the odors, and some of them are so anxious to
leave the hospital that they go before their sutures have.
been removed. Some of the Sisters and nurses complained
that their throats became sore or dry, and some had sinus
trouble. Windows in operating room have to be kept shut
to keep odors out. Windows also have to be kept shut at
times in the maternity ward and in the nursery, espe-
cially when a boat goes by.
The odors are noticeable chiefly in the summer.
They are worse at night or in ‘the early morning and
when the weather is sultry or after rains and when
boats go through the Canal; stirring it up. A few
of the witnesses were not themselves affected, and
some cf those affected by inability to sleep were not
affected by loss of appetite, and vice versa. With very
minor exceptions, no one loses any time from work.
Several of the witnesses referred to the fact that hot
weather also oppresses people and makes sleeping diffi-
cult and affects their appetites.
_ The patients in rooms on the east side of. the hospital
adjoining the Canal were more trou dled than those on the
Rica
other side and some asked to be transferred, but not all
did so. The odors have a worse effect upon new. patients,
those with delicate stomachs or very sick patients. Some
patients are not susceptible.
One of the Sisters who entered the hospital in 1917,
testified that the odor from the Canal had always been
very offensive. Another Sister who came to Joliet first
in 1910, said: “Well, whenever there was an odor, we
would say to each other, ‘What is the smell?’ ‘It is the
old dirty Canal.’ ”
The average period of stay in St. Joseph’s Hospital
during 1939 was about one day less than the average for
general hospitals-in the country as shown by the records
of the American Hospital Association.
Testimony of Principal Civilian Assistant to United
States District Engineer
Mr. C. R. Andrew, the principal civilian assistant
of the United States District Engineer at Chicago, has
worked along the Illinois Waterway continuously since
1925. He testified that prior to the building of the locks
in the Illinois River, there were concentrations of pollu-
tion at Lake Joliet, which is a short distance below
Brandon Road and also at the old Marseilles Dam and
Peoria Lake, which are, respectively, about 50 and 120
miles below Joliet. He was first located in 1925 at
Starved Rock Lake, (about 60 miles below Joliet). At
that time the odors from the river at that point and at
the old Marseilles Dam were extremely offensive. The
odors in Joliet at that time were also very offensive.
Conditions had improved greatly in 1930. In 1933, when
_ the dams were put into operation, the water continued to
improve year by year, and from 1938 to 1938, generally
speaking, there was no nuisance of any kind, that is no
odors except at times when the water was shaken
*
20
up with a strong wind, and close by the dam where
you got the spray. In 1939 the conditions in Joliet were
considerably worse than in 1938. In 1925 up to 1932 the
mater at 9 oliet flowed rapidly over rocks and the odor
was worse than when the water was quiescent. It
was the witness’ opinion that the odor conditions in Joliet
in 1925 and 1939 were about the same. Summarizing, u
to 1925, the conditions were very bad; from 1925 to 193 a
they were improving and in 1938 they were the best they
had ever been; in 1989 they were worse. The witness had
made comparatively few trips in 1940, but thought 1940
was not as bad as 1939.
At my request, Mr. Andrew compiled figures as to
the number of sick jeave absences during the years
1938, 1939 and 1940 of the employees of the ‘United
States Engineers employed along the Waterway in the
Joliet area, which covers a stretch of about 60 miles
from Lockport to Starved Rock and in which during the
3-year period there was an average of about 170 em-
Ployees. In accordance with my suggestion, Mr. An-
drew included in the tabulation for comparative pur-
poses similar data with respect to the employees in the
Chicago, Peoria and Calumet Harbor areas. The tabula-
tion showed that the percentage of days absent on such
Jeave to total work days sick leave in the Joliet area in
the three years in question was 4.34, which was prac-
tically the same as in the other areas, except in Peoria
where the percentage was slightly under 3. The per-
centage of sick leave days in 1939 was higher than
in 1938 in all areas except Peoria, but the 1939 percent-
age for Joliet was slightly less than for the Chicago Dis-
trict Office (which includes office employees). The sick
leave absences were also slightly less in the Joliet area in
1939 than in the area known as Calumet Harbor and Blue
Island, which covers sections of the Waterway north of
yes RFA EN IO Ape Se
S = 3 oon ,—
21
Lockport, from which there was no proof of any com-
plaint of conditions along the Waterway. In 1940 the
percentage of sick leave absences was slightly more in
the Joliet area than in the Calumet Harbor-and Blue
Island area, vut substantially less than in the District
Office area. The percentage of sick leave absences in the
Joliet area in 1940 was substantially less than in 1939.
The.total number of men employed on non-govern-
ment craft moving over the Waterway through Brandon
Road was estimated at 75 to 100. Only one person em-
ployed on any boat appeared before me as a witness; he
was the pilot above referred to. There was no suggestion
from any quarter that nuisance conditions at Joliet and
Lockport or elsewhere along the .Waterway had inter-
fered with or impeded navigation.
Testimony of Physicians at Joliet
Fifteen physicians residing in Joliet, including the
Health Commissioner of the City, testified before me.
The Health Commisstoner testified to receiving hun-
dreds of complaints in June, July and ‘August, 1939.
These were from persons who resided not far from
the banks of ‘the Canal. He personally had not observed
any evidence of temporary illness resulting from the
odor, but in his opinion there was danger of an epidemic
by flies and mosquitoes lighting on the scum and carrying
away germs which might mean dysentery or typhoid
fever. “The stench is nerve-wracking and by producing
nausea, loss of sleep and loss of appetite might bring on
a condition of degeneration.” Gases from the odor may
set up irritation of the mucous membrance of the nose,
throat and sinus. However, the health conditions in Joliet
are “very good, very.” They were not any worse in 1940
or 1939 than in 1¥38. “The only difference in the canal
is the odor. That is all.”
al
'
22 ¢
The testimony of the other doctors was substantially
to the same effect. In general terms they all considered
the Canal a menace to health for the reasons given by the
Health Commissioner. One of them suggested that germs
from the Waterway might be blown through the breeze.
Another thought the Canal might be responsible for strep-
tococcic sore throat. Another thought sinus trouble’ might
be due to it. One of the physicians testified he was
a government surgeon and took care of the men working
on the Canal for the government and had many cases
of skin diseases, making it necessary to take them off
their jobs for a while, attributable to the foul water
they came in contact with. This witness testified:
“I must honestly state that I don’t -believe it
is a menace to the health of the average healthy
individual, but it certainly is a menace to the
health of the individual who is not strong and is ill
‘ from other causes. It certainly shortens their life.
It menaces their after-health in every way. kt
can’t help but do it.”
No cases of specific illness clearly attributable to the
Canal were cited by the physicians. The few cases to
which they referred were chiefly of persons /!] from other
eauses whose illness was thought by them to be aggra-
vated by the odors from the Canal. .
The Joliet city chemist and bacteriologist testified
that samples of the water in the Canal taken in June,
1940, showed bacilli coli ranging from a low of 10,000
per c.c. to a high of 40,000 per c.c. No tests or analyses
were made in earlier years. United States Public Health
standards for potable water permits presence of 1 bacillus
coli in. 100 c.c. Joliet is situated on a limestone bed. The
10n this point the testimony does not seem to be supported by the
statistics of the office of the United States Engineers at Chicago here-
inbefore reférred to.
23
faet that the Waterway was constrycted by blasting led
the witness to believe that fissures have been created in
the rock, through which it would be possible that water
might leak into wells. If the flow were increased to 5,000
ef.s., there would still be a source of contamination
from the water, although the danger would be reduced;
it would not be possible to sterilize the Waterway so as
to kill all the B. coli in it. Joliet gets its water from
two deep wells, which are not in close proximity to
the Waterway. The water from them is as safe as any
water can be. All requirements of the State Health
Department have been met. If the city needed more
water, it could build more wells at a safe distance from
‘the Waterway. It would be correct to say that there had
always been a potential menace with sewage carried in
an open Canal like this and theoretically it is very undé-
sirable. :
, Health Statistics of Joliet
The annual reports of the Illinois Department of
Public Health show, with respect to certain communicable
diseases, the number of cases and deaths in Joliet, Will
County (in which Joliet and Lockport are situated) and
other counties in Illinois. The diseases reported upon are
diphtheria, encephalitis, influenza, malaria, measles, men-
engitis, pneumonia, poliomyelitis, scarlet fever, smallpox,
tuberculosis, typhoid fever and whooping cough. In 1939
the rate of rerurted cases per 100,000 inhabitants was
less in Wills County than the average for the State of
Illinois as to every one of the enumerated diseases except
poliomyelitis, malaria and influenza. In 1939 the
death rate was lower in Will County with respect to
every one of the diseases than bie average death rate for
the State as a whole.
In 1939 the typhoid case rate per 100,000 inhabitants
for Will County was 7.3 while the rate for the State as a
24
whole was 11.9. In the 9 years from 1930 to 1938 typhoid
cases in Will County were at the rate of 19.1 per 100,000,
whereas in 1939 the rate had declined to 7.3. The
typhoid case rate in Will County was less in 1939 than in
any year beginning with 1930 except in 1938, when it was
6.4. The typhoid death rate in Will County in 1939 was
-9 per 100,000 inhabitants as compared with an average
of 1.8 for the years 1930 to 1938, and a rate of 1.4 for
the State as a -whole.
With respect to Joliet proper, no separate evidence
was offered as to fates of typhoid cases and deaths, but
proof was offered as'to the number of typhoid cases and
deaths in Joliet from 1930 through 1988 and also as to
the number of cases in 1939. There were 9 reported
typhoid cases in Joliet in 1939 as compared with 1 in
1938, 10 in 1937, 11 in 1936, 10 in 1935 and as many as
20 in 1930. Thére appear to have been no typhoid
deaths in Joliet since 1936, when there were 3; in 1933
there were as many as 7.
A comparison of rates of reported typhoid cases and
deaths per hundred thousand population in (a) 22 Illinois
counties adjoining the Waterway and (b) 80 counties not
adjoining the Waterway, shows tie following:
Rate Per Hundred Thousand Population of
Reported Typhoid Cases and Deaths
Counties Not
Counties Adjoining Adjoining
Waterway Waterway
Cases Deaths Cases Deaths
Average from 1923 through 1939 0.9 3.9
Year 1939 2.9 0.4 12.0 3.1
Year 1938 4.1 0.4 11.5 1.4
Year 1937 3.3 0.4 13.4 1.5
Testimony from Residents of Lockport
Lockport is a small community located about four
miles north of Joliet. Its population in 1930 was 3,383 ;
in 1940 it. was 3,433. Four of its residents appeared
ite «
25
before me. They included the Mayor, the secretary of
the Chamber of Commerce, the superintendent of a grade
_School and an employee of the Texas Company. Testi-
mony was also given by the engineer of an oil plant sit-
uated between Lemont and Romeo, some distance above
Lockport. In addition, I took the testimény of two gov-
ernment employees residing at Lockport.
The Mayor of Lockport testified that he had had
numerous complaints of odors, but knew of only one
resident leaving Lockport because of conditions and this
was a family which lived “very, very close” to the Canal
bank. The secretary of the Chamber of Commerce tes-
tified that the Canal had always been a source of com-
plaint as they had always objected to it being “a cesspool
for the City of Chicago or any other territory”. Odors
at Lockport from the Texas Company’s oil refinery are,
he said, “slightly disagreeable, but not intense”.
An employee of the Texas Company who had lived
in Lockport 35 years and was a former Mayor, testified
that conditions in the warm months of 1939 were ‘ter-
rible”, due to the very bad odor. There was no current
and there was a lot of sludge on top of the water. Asked
what effect the odors had upon the people, he said:
“Well, not very pleasant * * * I would not say
it actually made them sick. It was not very pleas-
ant to breathe. * * * You could not sleep when it
was working real good. * * * The only way you
could sleep was by closing the windows.”
The superintendent of grade schools at Lockport tes-
tified that during April and May of 1939, children hau
to be sent home “because they were sick to their stomachs,
had headaches and threw up at school; some of them had
dysentery. They were absent just a day or two”. Also
in May, 1940, as many as 10 or 12 children would be
26
absent, just for a day, with nausea and dysentery. The
witness said that the odors did not affect her ability to
sleep, but “it was very disagreeable—it would be very
much nicer to have fresh country air’.
The chief engineer of the Globe Oil Company, which
has a plant situated about 314 miles out of Lemont, some
distance above Lockport, testified that his company takes
wate: out of the Canal for cooling condensing equip-
ment and its men have to clean the sediment out of con-
censer boxes. Some of the men doing this work have to
lie down, sick and blue, and have to be sent home. Men
with open sores who have come in contact with the water
have had infections. His plant gives off a malodorous
odor to one who is not accustomed to it, but people who
know the plant is there get accustomed to it.
Master’s Inspection of Conditions at Joliet and Lackport
On Monday, July 8th, 1940, I went from Chicago to
Joliet by automobile and we took a boat below the Bran-
don Road Dam and proceeded to the Lockport Dam. On
. that day at Joliet the maximum temperature was 88°
and the minimum temperature 65°. I did not at that time
observe any very offensive odor.
On July 23, 1940, after the adjournment of the hear-
ings at approximately 6 P. M., I visited the Lockport
Grade School of Lockport, accompanied by counsel and
the court reporter. At 6:25 P. M. it was 92° in the shade
on a wall thermometer in the school. I noted that at that
time there was no perceptible odor in the office of the
principal, that the day was very hot and there was no
breeze in motion.
From the school I went to the 9th Street Bridge in
Lockport leading across the Canal, which was about
3/4ths of a mile from the Lockport Grade School. I
27
.
walked across the bridge with counsel and noted that
there was a very slight odor with a good breeze from the
Southwest and a perceptible current. I observed some
scum floating down which contained also logs and sticks
of wood and was apparently only on the surface of the
water. There seemed to be a greasy, oily substance on
the surface of the water. I noted a perceptible odor along
the wall of the Canal, which appeared to me slight.
I then proceeded in an automobile on the road along
the side of the Canal to the Lockport lock. Driving along
the Canal I noted a slight odor. Arriving at the lock
there was a good breeze blowing, but I could observe very
little odor, notwithstanding the water was dammed at
this point.
At the lock I found the United States Lockmaster,
Edward P. Callaghan, whose testimony I took. 5
Mr. Callaghan has been employed as Lockmaster
continuously since 1932. In 1930 he painted the towers
adjoining the dam. He said:
“* * * At that time the water out there was
so thick you could almost paint with it.* * * We «
almost had to get clothes pins to put on our nose.
* * * Conditions are nowheres near as bad as they
were then. They have been clearing up that water.
Cleared it up, I would guess, at least 60%.”
The odors have not affected his health nor that of his
wife or of his grandchildren who visited him recently in
the summer.
I also took the testimony of the Lock Mate. He
thought conditions better in 1940 than in 1939. His
family, wife and daughter, live about three-fourths of a
mile away and had suffered no ill effects. He thought
you got used to the odor. He had fallen inte the water
oN
28
several times and su*fered no effect. A young woman
who had fallen in it had also been pulled out without
ill effects.
On Wednesday, July 24th at 7:39 P. M. I took a
speedboat.above the Jackson Street Bridge at Joliet. I
was accompanied by counsel for the opposing States and
by two employees of the Illinois Waterway Division. The
attorneys for Illinois were unable to attend because of
conferences with witnesses. I dictated my impressions
to the court reporter as we went along. We proceeded
under the bridges crossing the Waterway at Cass, Jeffer-
son and McDonough streets, through the Pool to the
Brandon Road Dam. We then turned about and pro-
ceeded north to the Lockport lock, which we reached at
8:30 P. M. We then turned back to Joliet, which we
reached at 9 P. M. The thermometer outside the hotel
at this hour registered 92°.
My notes show that in this inspection trip I could
detect an odor from time to time but only intermittently;
it would last for a few seconds or a minute and then I]
would lose it for several minutes and then catch it again.
It seemed to be more noticeable as I came under bridges,
and it was suggested by one of the Waterway representa-
tives that the odor would have been more noticeable if we
* had stayed along the walls continuously than it was in the
middle of the stream. While it was perceptible, it did
not seem to me terrible or particularly bad at any time.
I noted that it would not bother me very much, although
it might bother others and I would not call: it pleasant,
although it was not strong. It did not seem to be any
worse at the wider section of the Pool than at other
- points. I did not ohserve any flies and had only one
mosquito bite, although it was dusk. At times there was
a good breeze, which at other times died ovt. I saw a
ud
29
number of bubbles on the water, which I was told repre-
sented operation of gas from sludge underneath the
surface. At first I saw little seum. Then as we proceeded
I saw along the walls a rather thick surface layer, which
appeared to be scum and which contained pieces of wood,
paper, miscellaneous debris and a good many grease spots,
which might have been due to oil. This scum varied in
extent at different points. At one point it was 2 or 3 feet
in width; at others perhaps 10 to 20 feet; it was usually
on the side along the walls, but I observed it also at
points in the middle of the Waterway. Bubbles were
apparent for the whole width of the Waterway. At one
point I detected an oily odor.
After returning from this inspection trip I noted at
11:30 P. M. in my room et the hotel (which was about
4 blocks from the Waterway) an odor which lasted a min-
ute or two; a few minutes later I got another odor for a
minute or two, and then detected no more odors. I slept
four nights at Joliet and was not troubled by odors.
The only trouble I had in sleeping was due to the heat,
which was so great that I kept an electric fan constantly
going all night. The City Hall, in which the hearings
were held, was about three blocks from the Canal on the
east side; I detected an odor only on one day and then
only for a few minutes. The four days I spent in Joliet
were the hottest of the summer, the temperature reach-
ing 103 degrees on July 25th.
Weather Conditions at Joliet in 1939 and 1940
The maximum, minimum: and mean temperatures
according to government records, at Joliet during the
months of May to September, inclusive, in 1939 and
1940 were as follows: :
o~
30 |
1939 1940
Highest Lowest Mean Highest Lowest Mean
April 82 21 46.1 76 23 8646.8
May 90 30 = 63.5 86 28 3=«2B 6.4
June 93 44 172.3 91 40 70.2
July 96 62 73.6 103 43 74.2
August 90 oo tue 98 45 1738
September 100 4i 69.2 91 31 63.2
The departures from normal in temperatures at
Joliet in the months from May to September in each of
the years 1939 and 1940 were as follows:
1939 1940
April “67 —2.0
May .. +3.7 —3.4
WE piccaticctianiontcsncibicamied avant +1.6
July +0.1 +0.7
August - 0.2 +1.4
September Pee I: +4,2 “5
Thus, May, June and September were hotter in 1939
than in 1940 while July and August were hotter
in 1940 than in 1939. In the four days during which
testimony was taken in Joliet (July 22nd to 25th) the
maximum temperatures in 1940 were 94, 97, 100 and
103, while minimum temperatures were 75, 70, 65 and
80. On the same days of 1939, the maximum tempera-
tures were 86, 86, 90 and 82 and the minimum tempera-
tures were 60, 61, 63 and 69. :
The departures from normal in precipitation at
Joliet in the months from April to September in 1939
and 1940 were as follows:
1939 1940
i, ger ie ON Braet ye +0.26 +0.17
UE ce —1.89 +0,51
* Spe RRS HISD, ee ON aE +5.03 —1.03
| SORES See aie —0.81 —3.08
.
31
In the chemical processes which are responsible for
the development of gases and odors, the temperature of
the water is controlling, not the temperature of the air.
It was testified that actual sulphate decomposition does
not occur when the temperature of the water falls below
62° Fahrenheit. The mean temperature of the water at
Lockport in the months from April te September, in the
years 1939 and 1940, according to the Sanitary District
records, was as follows:
1939 1940
April 56 ; 50
May 64 58
June 71 70
July 76 74
August el Wt | 73
September . 75 72
Thus, water teinperature was lower at Lockport in
1940 than in 1939 in each of the summer months.’ It
seems clear, however, that the susceptibility of human
beings to anioyance from odors increases with higher
temperature of the air.
Discharges of Sewage and Oil into Waterway
Between Chicago and Joliet
The Texas Company has an oil refinery at Lockport
which discharges its waste into the Canal two miles below
Lockport. The oil refinery odors are “slightly disagree-
able, not intense”. The waste from the refinery con-
tributes to the oily appearance of the surface cf the water
below Lockport. A number of the witnesses testified to
detecting the odor of oil along the Waterway, and it
appears that scum and grease on the surface of the
Waterway are due in part to discharges of waste from
the oil refinery.
1The records of the Sanitary District indicate that the water
temperature was higher at Lockport in 1939 than in many years.
~
“%
32
Lockport, with a population of about 3,500, empties
its sewage into the Waterway below the locks,
The old Illinois State prison outside of Joliet and
the new Illinois State prison at Stateville, about two miles
north of Joliet, discharge their Sewage into the Water-
way. These two prisons have an aggregate population
of about 6,400, which includes inmates and employees.
Lemont, a town of about 2,500 people, situated in
Cook County. above Lockport, empties its sewage into
the main channel of the Waterway. ;
The City of Joliet, with a population of about 42,000
discharges its sewage into the Waterway below the Bran-
don Road Dam. Various small communities above Lock-
port, including Lemont with a population of about 2,500
people, Argo and Summit, also discharge this raw sewage
into the Waterway.
Objections to Inereased Diversion by Illinois
Communities Below Joliet
Four witnesses who were not subpoenaed by any of
the parties appeared before me and asked to be heard.
These were George P. Moore, Thomas H. Detweiller, Dr.
J. P. Kerr and Harry F. Goodell.
Messrs. Moore and Detweiller reside at Peoria, which
has a population of about 105,000 and is situated on the
Waterway about 120 miles below Joliet. Mr. Moore is
Secretary of the Pleasure Driveway and Park Distriet
of Peoria, and Mr. Detweiller is a Park Trustee at Peoria.
They objected to any increase in the diversion from Lake
Michigan on the ground that it might bring more sewage
down to Peoria. Sewage has been comi:.; down the
Waterway for thirty years, but conditions have materially
improved in recent years. Fish life has begun to reappear
.
q
33
and offensive odors formerly present have nee absent in
the last year or two.
The testimony of Dr..Kerr was along the same lines.
He is President of the Association of the Drainage &
Levee Districts of Illinois, comprising people owning
property and farms in the Hlinois River Valley. He has
represented these people for twenty years and has con-
stantly opposed the introduction of sewage into the Illinois
River or increased diversion from the Lake. His Associa-
tion has adopted resolutions urging that increased diver-
sion be not permitted. He testified. that in former years
“great islands of floating untreated sewage” were dis-
cernible all the way down from Joliet through Marseilles,
Ottawa and Peru and even down to Peoria. Particles of
untreated sewage were discovered on the surface of the
water at Peoria, and conditions were indescribably worse
than at Joliet today. Bathing in the Waterway is now
practised all the way up to Peoria, when it was formerly
not possible. Peoria treats its sewage, but other towns
’ along the river as far down as Penreatowe empty their
sewage into the river.
‘ Mr. Goodell is a graduate in civil engineering of the
University of Illinois and is employed by eleven Drainage
and Levee Districts in southern Illinois Counties. He
resides at Beardstown, a town of about 6,000 population,
situated about 80 miles downstream from Peoria and
about 200 miles from Lockport by river. He began to
work and live on the river in 1918. The river was pol-
luted then and there seemed to be more or less of a boil
in it. People were advised not to swim in it although
they did occasionally. During the year 193@ there was
a great improvement of the water conditions and fish
ufe has returned. While the water condition in Beards-
town is now much improved and there are bathing
4
34
beaches, they do not meet the requirements of the Public
Health Department. In his opinion, conditions at Joliet
are no worse than they were during the ’20’s and may
be better. He had worked upon and in streams polluted
by sewage giving off highly offensive odors, but he never
observed any ill effects, although the pollution was suffi-
cient to discolor the paint on houses situated «near the
streams. Peoria formerly discharged its sewage into
the Waterway but has recently completed a ‘treatment
plant. The Illinois River during past years has been
a menace to the health of the residents of areas tribu-
tary thereto and is still a menace to those residents
notwithstanding the improvement. It would be prac-
ticable to periodically flush the Brandon Road Pool, and
he did not think that the organizations which he repre-
sented would offer any objection thereto as material
from the Pool would be fairly well decomposed when it
passed Starved Rock, but they objected to increased
. diversion from the lake which might bring down fresh
sewage.
Expert Testimony as to Health Conditions
On August 8, 1940, Willard L. Bergman, a chemist
employed at Rush Medical College, at the request of the
opposing States, made tests for hydrogen sulphide (1)
under the Ninth Street bridge in Lockport and (2) along-
side the Jackson Street bridge in Joliet. In each case
he took a 3-gallon sample of air. These tests disclosed no
trace of hydrogen sulphide. He discerned no odors except
one of lubricating oil. The temperature was about 90°
or so.' —? ae
The methods employed by Dr. Bergman were criticized as inade-
— by Dr. Clarence W. Muehlberger, a toxicologist, who testified for
35
On July 16, 1940, tests to determine bacteria in the
air in the vicinity of the Sanitary Canal from Lockport
to Joliet were made by Dr. Josiah J. Moore and Robert
C. Jenkins, a clinical laboratory technician. Dr. Moore
is a graduate of the University of Chicago and Rush
Medical College, has taught bacteriology and pathology
at the University of Illinois and is pathologist for several
hospitals. The tests were made at ten locations along the
banks of the Canal, six locations about seven miles west
and six locations about four, miles east. The tests
showed no pathogenic bacteria. -present at any of the
loéations. The bacteria found were the usual bacteria
one might find in air at any place. Dr. Moore testified
that germs and bacteria present in scum on the surface
of the Waterway or along the sides of banks or walls
could not be blown through the air in such a way to
cause a hazard producing disease to people along the
Waterway. It would not be possible for an epidemic to
break out in a community adjoining the Waterway by
the transmission of germs or bacteria by air. In the
opinion of Dr. Moore, based upon his analysis of the air,
there was no danger to the health of people along the
Waterway. He testified that there is no basis for any
suggestion that germs from the water might cause strep-
tococcic infection in the throat without drinking the
water; you could not get a streptococcic sore throat by
living along the banks of the Canal and breathing the
air. Disease could be contracted only by eating food con-
taminated by germs carried by flies or other insects.
Flies usually alight only on solid material* If insects
had gotten on the culture plates, that would have been
shown. In only one case was there a form of insect
shown on the plate, and this was away from the Pool.
The presence of B. coli in the Canal indicates presence
of fecal material, but would not indicate pathogenic bac-
Te
36
terla. Even the smallest amount of.B. coli in water
makes it unfit for human consumption.’
The testimony of Dr. Moore was confirmed by that
of Dr. Norbert R. Enzer, Director of Laboratories at Mt.
Sinai Hospital, a graduate in medicine of McGill Univer-
sity. In his opinion any bacteria that may be in the
scum formed from sewage are not the bacteria with
pathogenic qualities; these have been destroyed long
since.” Flies lighting on the surface of that water would
not pick up anything very damaging to carry away and
deposit on people’s food or hands. Flies ordinarily alight
on dry surfaces, not wet ones; there are many thousands
of times more flies on a refuse or garbage heap than on
the surface of a stagnant pool. If it could be assumed
that the Waterway presented a menace, increasing the
flow to 5,000 c.f.s. would not change it.
Testimony substantially to the same effect was given
by Drs. James E. Perkins, Edward R. Krumbiegel and
Edwin B. Gute. Dr. Perkins holds the degrees of Master
of Public Health and Doctor of Public Health from the
Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health
and is Director of the Division of Communicable Dis-
eases of the New York State Department of Health. Dr.
Krumbiegel holds the degree of M. D. from Marquette
1Mr. Langdon Pearse, Sanitary Engineer of the District, testified
that since the water in the Canal was not used for drinking, he did
not concern himself with B. coli figures. He said, “Our work pri-
marily is not concerned with destroying bacteria. As I have said, we
want them in the stream, such as they are, to help us do the work of
self-purification.” ,
Compare Missouri vs. Illinois, 200 U. S. 496, where the court said
at page 525: A
“It seems to be conceded that the purification of the
Illinois by the large dilution from Lake M chigan (nine parts
or more in ten) would increase the danger, as it now gen-
erally is believed that the bacteria of decay, the saprophytes,
whi flourish in stagnant pools, destroy the pathogenic
germs.”
2The Jo’iet city chemist and bacteriologist testified that the scum
was acted on by the sun, which was germicidal to a certain degree, and
in his opinion the scum was less likely to contain organisms than the
water under the scum. >
37
University and is Commissioner of Health for Mil-
waukee. Dr. Gute is a graduate of Rush Medical. School,
Commissioner of Health for the Villages of Whité Fish
Bay and Fox Point, Wis., and Chairman of the Mil-
waukee County Association of Suburban Health Com-
missioners.
On September 17, 1940, an examination of the bac-
terial content of the air at (1) points in Joliet and Lock-
port both along the Waterway and removed therefrom and
(2) points in other Illinois towns a considerable dis-
tance from the Waterway, was made by Dr. M. Starr
Nichols. Dr. Nichols is professor of sanitary chemistry
at the University of Wisconsin, and is employed by the
Wisconsin State Board of Health as chemist and bacter-
iologist, specializing in sewage chemistry; he is the author
of numerous papers. He testified that the number of
bacteria found at the locks at Brandon Road and Lock-
port were only approximately 1/10th as many as those
found at the other stations. Otherwise there was no
remarkable difference between the number of bacteria in
Joliet and those at other points. No attempt was made
to isolate any pathogenic organisms or to identify the
species of bacteria. Typhoid germs are destroyed more
quickly in polluted water than in pure water.
On September 17, 1940, Dr. Nichols also examined
scum taken from the Canal walls at Brandon Lock and
from the Waterway near the lock, also below the Texas
Oil Refinery at Lockport. In ali of these samples oil-like
material was found. On September 28, 1940, he took
samples of water from the Canal at the Brandon Locks
below the Jefferson Street bridge in Joliet and at the
Lockport Lock and tested them for hydrogen sulphide.
They showed 0.1 and 0.2 parts per million.' The tem-
perature in Joliet that day ranged from 34° to 74°.
1No tests for hy nm sulphide in the area above the waters of the
Canal have been made by the Sanitary District.
38
Testimony as to the effect of hydrogen sulphide in
the air was given for the opposing States by Drs. Nichols,
Enzer, Krumbiegel, Gute ,and Perkins, and also, particu-
larly, by Dr. Wm. H. MeNally.
Dr.“ McNally is a toxivologist, a graduate of Rush
Medical College and a member of its faculty, and the
author of two books and a large number of articles
on Toxicology. He testified that nausea can be pro-
duced'sin many individuals with as low a concentra-
tion as 60 ppm. of hydrogen sulphide in the air. A
concentration of 100 p.p.m, might cause local irritation
and depression of the nervous system; he did not think
it would be possible to get such a concentration in the
open-air from a stream polluted with sewage wastes. A
concentration as small as 25 p.p.m. might cause disco!
orgtion of paint, which is the most delicate test there is,
Alice Hamilton and Drinker of Boston believe that not
more than 20 p.p.m. should be tolerated in industry and
this is the figure adopted by the Massachusetts code.
One would have to be right over floating particles of
Sewage to get a concentration of 100 p.p.m. When you
get 500 or 1,000 feet away from the Waterway, the con-
centration of hydrogen sulphide would be diluted many
thousand times. Some people are more sensitive than
others to the smell of hydrogen sulphide. Also one may
become accustomed to the odor. In the literature of
toxicology there is no recorded instance of damage to
health from hydrogen sulphide in a waterway like the
Illinois Waterway.
The testimony of the other witnesses for the oppos-
ing States was substantially to the same effect. These wit-
nesses included all the doctors above named and also
Messrs. Louis F. Warrick and Louis R. Howson, sani-
39
tary experts. Mr. Warrick holds the degree of Master
of Science from Cornell University and is the State
Sanitary Engineer of Wisconsin. Mr. Howson is a con- -
sulting sanitary engineer who has specialized in sewage
treatment work.
All the physicians, health authorities and sanitary
experts who appeared as witnesses for the opposing
States—nine in all—testified that it was their opinion
that the Waterway-did not constitute any menace to the
health of persons living along it. This opinion was also
shared by Mr. Joseph W. Ellms, Commissioner of the
Division of Sewage Disposal of the City of Cleveland,
Ohio. Mr. Ellms testified that upon his visit to the
Brandon Road Pool, it appeared to him to be in better
shape than the Cuyahoga River.’
Testimony for Illinois on the particular question of
the effect of hydrogen sulphide was given by Dr. Clar-
ence ‘W. Muehlberger, a graduate of the Armour Insti-
tute of Technology and of the University of Wisconsin,
holding degrees of Master of Science and Doctor of Phil-
osophy. He is a lecturer on Toxicology in the
medical schools of the Universities of CMicago, Ili-
nois, Loyola and Northwestern and the author of
a chapter in Dr. McNally’s book on Toxicology. He
1It appears from the testimony of Mr. Elims that the Cuyahoga
River, which is 300 to 400 feet wide, and perhaps wider, and has a very
low velocity, is grossly polluted by sewage and industrial waste from oil
refineries for a distance of about 10 or 12 miles in the metropolitan dis-
trict of Cleveland. A nuisance condition obtains there today aud has
obtained there for many years. For a distance of 9 miles, no dissolved
oxygen was found in the water in samples taken by Mr. Ellms in Sep-
tember, 1940. Mr. Elims testified thai the Cuyahoga River is a foul
(alth he did not think the odors “are so particularly notice-
able”) but id not consider it as a health menace unless people in-
on bathing in it. Nor did he consider the Sanitary Canal a health
as it was not used for drinking or for bathing.
appears also that the Ohio River is grossly polluted daring six
t
months of the average year; see 104 Transactions of the American So- -
eiety of Civil Engineers (1939) p. 873.
.
40
°
had read the transcript of the testimony of the
Joliet witnesses and was of the opinion that the
nausea, headaches, insomnia and loss of appetite of which
they complained “may have been caused by hydrogen sul-
phide”. He could:noi refer to any case recorded in med-
ical literature of any individual having been overcome
in the open from the air from a waterway polluted by
untreated or partially treated sewage. He had no idea
how fast the gas might be diluted in the air; it would
depend on how strong the breeze was and how fast the
gas was coming off the Canal. To the average person the
Symptoms produced by exposure to over 20 p.p.m. but
under 50 p.p.m. would be irritation of the mucous sur-
faces of the eyes, nose and throat. Some persons are more
susceptible than others. Decomposing Sewage gives off
organi¢ sulphide compounds, including indol, skatol, mer-
captans and cadavrin, all having offensive odors. The
intensity of odor is an unreliable test of gas present,
especially hydrogen sulphide, because the nerve ends in
the nose become paralyzed by use. In his opinion the
conditions surrounding the Waterway constitute “a very
definite menace” to the health of the people of the region
of Joliet. People have not died or been rendered so ill as
to require hospital treatment necessary but “they might
have been rendered very uncomfortable and very un-
happy”. “I believe that people are entitled to a decent
place to live, comfortable surroundings -where the air
that they breathe is perfectly good, healthy air, and I
believe that anything that can be overcome which con-
taminates»the air, so that they aren’t in a good, sound
state of health, is a menace.” —
Dr. Muehlberger testified that the odor of the Canal
in 1939 had irritated his throat and nasal passages. He
knew that the Waterway prior to 1939 always gave off
4]
odors, especially in summer, hut would not say that he
had ever noticed this irritation before.
The principal witness on the health issue for
Illinois was Dr. Anton J. Carlson. Dr. Carlson received
the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in physiology from
Stanford University in 1903 and the degree of Doctor of
Medicine from the University of Lund in 1917. He has
never practiced medicine privately, but has trained over
5,000 doctors. Since 1904 he has been on the medical
faculty of the University of Chicago and for the last
twenty-five years has been professor and chairman of
the department of physiology in that university. He is
a member and officer of many medical and scientific so-
cieties, a member of the Public Advisory Committee of
the United States Public Health Service and a consultant
to that service, advisor of the Department of Public
Health of Chicago, and for the last twenty-five years
Chairman of the Public Healih Committee of the City
Club of Chicago.
Dr. Carlson inspected the Waterway on October 13th,
1940, and had read much of the testimeny given at Joliet.
He testified that in his opinion “the present condition
is more than a menace to health; it is inimical to health”’.
-Asked what factors he would consider in determining
what constituted an actual mendce to health, he an-
swered:
“Why, an ‘actual menace to health to me means
that conditions exist in that pool that through
accidents or any ordinary course of human events
in the district can lead to health injury—injury
to health. We don’t have to prove actual injury
to health. We have got to prove that conditions
exist there which, through accidents or any ordi-
nary course of human events, business and life,
may result in injury to health’.
42
Dr. Carlson further indicated his view that there
was also an actual menace from dysentery bacilli, from
typhoid bacilli and from the amoeba of dysentery.
“" * * the water doesn’t have to be used for
drinking or cooking to constitute such a menace,
and it doesn’t have to occur either for 10, 15, or 5
years. It is still a menace. * * * the highly polluted
body of water may through accident, through flies
or mosquitoes, or spray or wind get on the surface
of man, on his clothes, on his skin, or in his food,
or even in his drinking water, even in his lunch
pail, and anything—we know anything. that gets
on our skin anywhere— * * * flies don’t have to
bite, mosquitoes don’t have to bite, they don’t have
to settle on the water. This stuff splashes up on
the sides when the boats go through, when they
empty their locks and fill them and when the wind
blows. Such a polluted, highly infectious body of
water of that extent is an actual menace, if I
have made my answer clear.”
Dr. Carlson testified that the fact that the present
communicable disease rate in Joliet is no higher than
in other places is no factor whatever in determining
whether the Canal is a menace to health. Either they
have been lucky or the medical statistics are not what
they are supposed to be. It is unimportant that the
water is not used for drinking purposes or bathing.
“People will drop in by accident and the children will
jump in by choice, no matter what you say”. Bacteria
can reach them by flies and mosquitoes carrying this
stuff mechanically and “under extreme conditions might
reach them if they walk close by the Canal in a spray
in a high wind.”
Dr. Carlson has been familiar with’ the Waterway
for many years. It has constituted a menace to health
since 1934, but now it has been increased. He agreed
43
that when he used the words “menace to health” he was
using them in a scientific sense as a theoretical danger
which cannot be measured in any statistics or even in any
outward observation by a physician.
“The policy that guides us and you and the
courts is to take all measures to minimize all
these, any or all of these unfavorable conditions,
that we can do within the practicability of our
knowledge and our civilization. * * * The amount
of water asked for by the State of Illinois, tem-
porarily or even during the summer, could not con-
ceivably have any health significance for the
other States, and I think it insignificant and
uneconomic.”
Dr. Carlson agreed that if the diversion from Lake
Michigan were restored to 5,000 ¢f.sy°there would still
be a menace to health, but, he said, it would be less.
He also agreed that carbon monoxide in Chicago from
automobiles is a constant detriment to the health of the
people in Chicago. |
Testimony substantially to the same effect was given
by Dr. Carlson’s associate, Dr. Andrew C. Ivy, who holds
degrees of Bachelor of Science, Master of Science and
Doctor of Philosophy from the University of Chicago
and the degree of Doctor of Medicine from Rush Medical
College. Dr. Ivy has taught physiology and pharmacology
at the Medical Schools of Loyola, University of Chicago
and Northwestern University. He is President of the
American Physiological Society and the American Gastro-
interiological Society, and a member of the Public Health
Committee of the City Club of Chicago, and has had occa-
sion to study questions relating to sewage disposal, pro-
cural of water from Lake Michigan, and water pollution.
He had visited the Waterway with Dr. Carlson and read
the transcript of testimony given at Joliet. The testi-
44
mony that the odor had caused nausea, disturbances of
appetite and sleep, showed, in his opinion, an unhygienic
condition working as a detriment to the health of the
people that the odor so affects. This would be particu-
larly true of children with poor appetites, convalescent
patients in a hospital and invalids. He considered that
the Brandon Road Pool and the Sanitary District Canal
constitute an actual menace to the health of the com-
munity of Joliet. He explained his answer by saying:
“I am convinced of the truth of the dictum
7 genera principle that pollution of the air or
streams is unhygienic, or unhealthful, and that
they should be abated, if possible. All the time
or continuously in society we are trying to improve
unhygienic conditions of living because we regard
them as being unhealthful. We abate smoke; we
abate noise; we abate dust; we try to abate pollen
distribution because of the hayfever sufferers;
we abate stray dogs because of the threat of rabies
. and the spread of disease by stray dogs, and when
a water supply is even threatened with pollution,
there is any question that the water supply might
be polluted, we immediately take steps to take care
of the situation, and it is on the basis of general-
izations and principles of that sort that I believe
that there is an actual menace to health existing
there now.”
Dr. Ivy further testified that diluting the water
would not eradicate the menace, but, he said, it
would decrease it. Any stream polluted with un-
treated sewage is a menace to health. Oil odors are at
times detrimental to health and should be abated, but they
do not affect one psychologically as sewage odors. The
odors of stockyards may contain hydrogen sulphide, which
should also be abated. Noises in the city such as that
caused by the operation of elevated railroads constitute
45
a menace to health because an unhygienie condition,
which should be reduced. Dr. Ivy knew of no recorded
case of an individual being overcome by hydrogen sul-
phide from a waterway. Generally; his testimony was to
the same effect as that of Dr. Cavrlson.
Dr. Hugh Alister McGuigan accompanied Drs. Carl-
son and Ivy on their visit to the Waterway on October
13th. Dr. McGuigan holds the degree of Ph. D. in phys-
iology and chemistry from the University of Chicago,
and the degree of M. D. from Rush Medical College. He
was professor of pharmacology at Northwestern Uni-
versity for seven years, and since 1917 has been pro-
fessor of pharmacology and therapeutics at the College
of Medicine of the University of Illinois. He is a member
of various professional societies and has written several
books on pharmacology. He is not a practising physician
though licensed to practise and having some consulta-
tions. His field is pharmacology, which deals with the
application of drugs to the treatment of disease. He
had read or heard the testimony of Drs. Carlson and ivy
and agreed in the main therewith. He added that hydro-
gen sulphide which had been dwelt on so much was not
the only thing in the air adjoining the Waterway. “The
cadaverin, putrescin and all the other things mentioned
in there, those are positive things, but there are many
other things that we don’t know anything about in there
which may be even more toxic than the hydrogen sul-
phide. We simply don’t know.” ~
No representative of the Illinois Department of
Health or any sanitary officer of the State of Illinois
appeared before me. The Chief of the Illinois State
Waterway Survey, Dr. A. M. Buswell, was placed upon ~
the stand by the opposing States in support of their
contentions as to several ameliorating measures,’ but
1Dr. Buswell’s testimony is referred to infra at pages 84, 96, 97.
i
46
gave no testimony with respect to the existence of any
health menace. ;
General Authorities on Sewage Odors
_In a report of the Committee on Sewage Disposal of
the Public Health Enginsering Section of the American
Public Health Association, on “Chlorination in Sewage
Treatment” (of which Mr. Langdon Pearse was Chair-
man and Dr. Mohlmann was a member) it is said:
“A long prevalent theory that sewage odors
are directly responsible for’ disease has been def-
initely refuted. It is now realized that the physio-
logical effect, if any, is indirect. Odors, by caus-
ing worry, loss of sleep, loss of appetite, etc., may
be a contributory cause of ill health, and certainly
cause discomfort. The courts, in general, have held
that the creators of an odor nuisance are respon-
sible therefor, and as far as municipal sewage
disposal is concerned, the odor hazard appears to
have been:shifted from the public health to the
public pocketbook.’”?
In his work on Preventive Medicine and Hygiene,”
Professor Milton J. Rosenau of the Harvard Medical ~
School, says:
“While odors may be unpleasant, they are not
known seriously to influence health; contrary to
common opinion, they are not by any means a
reliable sign of danger. * * * ( p. 898).
“The odors from marshes and from decompos-
ing organic matter are not apparently hurtful. One
of the most famous stenches that has been re-
corded, if not the most famous, was that which
arose in 1858 and 1859 from the Thames, which
1Report of Committee on Sewage Disposal of the Public Health
ree Section, on “Chlorination in Sewage Treatment” (1934),
p. 30.
*See Rogenau, Preventive Medicine and Hygiene, Sixth Edition, |,
(1935) pp. 898, 899, 900, 928. >
47
at that time was grossly polluted with the sewage
of London (Sedgwick). It was commonly be-
lieved to be the cause of pestilence. Budd insisted
that no serious results followed. After giving his
proof, Budd states, ‘Before these inexorable fig-
ures, the illusion of half a century vanished in a
moment.’ We now know that odors in the air
bear no reference to contagion or infection and!
however unpleasant, need not be feared as sources
of disease. * * * (p. 899).
“The effect of odors upon health is not well
understood.» When we sense a pleasant smell, we
involuntarily take deeper breaths; on the other
hand, unpleasant odors tend to diminish the res-
piratery exchange. Odors influence thé nervous
system in various ways; some stimulate, others
depress psychic activity. Some odors have a well
known influence upon sexuality. Occasionally,
odors are so disagreeable that they induce nausea,
even vomiting. It is remarkable how quickly we
may become acgustomed to odors, but the fact that
our sense of smell has been dulled is no guarantee
that the cause of the odors may not continue to
produce its effects. * * * Winslow and Palmer
found that ‘odors’ of vitiated air have an unfavor-
able influence upon appetite.” (p. 900).
“Sewage gas, once a hygienic bugaboo, is
now not seriously regarded by sanitarians. Sewer
gas became the residual legatee of Murchison’s
pathogenic theory, namely, that typhoid fever was
‘produced by emanations from decaying organic
matter.’ People naturally cling to the notion that
anything that smells bad must be detrimental to
health. Sanitarians know, however, that our
sense of smell is a poor sanitary guide.” * * *
(p. 928).
; Condition of Waterway in Earlier Years
In considering the weight to be given to the claims
of Illinois that the situation in Joliet and Lockport pre-
48
sents a menace to health which makes imperative an in-
crease in the diversion, it seems pertinent to consider
2° the situation which has prevailed in past years.
The Waterway has always been a polluted stream
due to the discharge of untreated sewage from Chicago.
‘ft appears from the first (1927) report of Special Master
Hughes, quoted swpra, pages 6, 7, that the Canal was
grossly polluted in 1872, and that in 1891 the nuisance
along the Canal was at times as bad as ever. The 1925 re-
port of the Engineering Board of Review of the Sanitary
District gives particulars of offensive conditions in 1911,
1912, 1913, 1919 and 1921. In September, 1911, the water
of the DesPlaines River at Lockport had a “grayish look
and a filthy smell’, and its organic contents were evi-
dently in an advanced state of decomposition. In 1919
there was a marked septic action, at all points of the
river from the head as far, as Ottawa (about 60 miles
below Joliet). At Morris (about miles below Joliet),
“there was considerable scum and there were numerous
patches about 12 inches square of semi-solid, black sludge
which had the appearance of being ‘throw-ups’ from the
bottom”. Seen from a distance as from a bridge, the
water had a deep black, foul appearance. At Marseilles
(about 50 miles below Joliet),
“the river had_a very bad appearance,—-practically
covered with black, slimy scum accompanied by
very strong septic action. This scum had the ap-
pearance of being sludge from the bottom which
had been softened and disintegrated. There was a
marked septic sewage odor at all points as far as
Marseilles, where it was the worst, being very
noticeable in the business district of the town, at
a distance of a quarter of a mile from the river.”
Between Peru and Spring Valley (about 70 miles
below Joliet), “the septic action was so violent as to be
49
fairly boiling, forming a thick scum from shore to shore,
with the whole surface covered with patches of sludge
from a few inches to 3 feet square.”
In 1921 the water in the west arm of the Chicago
River was almost black and the surface was covered with
a thick seum. In May, 1922, large amounts of dead
fish were observed floating on the surface of the stream
at Lockport and there was a moderate odor. At Brandon
Bridge in 1922 thousands of dead minnows were noted
along the margins of the stream, and odors were given
off from these dead fish; there was a slight sewage odor.
Mr. Langdon Pearse, Sanitary Engineer of the Dis-
trict, testified before Special Master Hughes in 1927:
“The condition in the canal and rivers is now
bad. It constitutes a condition of nuisance and has
been going on for a number of years; in fact, ever
since I have been connected with the District
there has been a passage of solids from the canal
down the rivers lodging behind dams and creating
consequent nuisance in the water pools, and the
water behind the dams can be smelled for a dis-‘
tance of half a mile. Fish have been driven out
of the upper river as far down as Chillicothe, and
conditions of odor are noticeable at Chillicothe,
a distance, roughly, of 110 miles from Lockport.””!
Note has already been made of the testimony of
Mr. C. R. Andrew, principal civilian assistant to the
United States Engineer at Chicago, that conditions in
Joliet were as bad in 1925 as in 1939, and of the testi-.
mony as to conditions in eawlier years at Joliet and ‘points
further down the .Waterway which was » given by Dr.
Kerr and Messrs. Moore, Detweiller and Goodell.?
1Abstract of evidence on re-reference, page 720. .
*See supra, pages 19, 20, 32-34.
50
Conclusions az to Health Conditions
I summarize the facts as found by me regarding
health conditions as follows:
The present complaints as to the condition of the
Waterway are confined to residents of Joliet and Lock-
port and proceed chiefly from persons living in close
proximity to the Canal. Health conditions in Joliet are
very good. Fewer communicable diseases exist in coun-
ties adjoining the Waterway than in other Illinois coun-
ties. The typhoid rates for Will County and the other
counties adjoining the Waterway have substantially de-
clined since 1930. The typhoid death rate for Will County
in 1939 was not much more than half that for the State
as a whole. No water from the Canal is used for drinking. ,
There is no swimming in the Waterway. Germs cannot
be blown through the air from the Waterway and, in
order for germs in the Canal to ense illness, one would
have to drink the water or germs would have to be car-
ried by flies or other insects and brought into contact
with foed, There is no evidence that flies or other insects
“have in act carried any germs which have contaminated
food ‘caused illness. On the contrary, the health
, “@tatistics indicate that no illness has in fact been caused
_ in this Way.
“The complaints as to the condition of the Waterway
7/4 are based entirely upon the very offensive odors given
ef 4 off by it in the summer time and the effect of such
b
are due in part to hydrogen sulphide and in part to
other unidentifiable gases. The dilution of such gases
in the open air is very great. The odors from the Canal
are intermittent but extremely unpleasant and disagree-
f \
\
~~ —— deentene —_
11
able to those living in close proximity to the Canal on
hot and sultry days and nights in summer, particularly
when the water in the Canal is stirred up by boats. Ner-
vous persons or invalids are especially susceptible to
the odors. On hot and sultry days school children have
been nauseated and caused to lose a day from school.
Many persons living alongside the Canal are not affected
by the odors and have become accustomed to them, but a
substantial number are disturbed by them. Independently
of odors, hot and sultry weather makes sleep difficult
and affects the appetite.
For many years the Waterway has been an offen-
sive stream containing Chicago sewage wholly untreated
or only partly treated. There have always been odors from
the stream at Joliet and Lockport. In 1925 when the
river at Joliet flowed over rapids in the stream, the odors
were very offensive. From 1930 to 1938 conditions at
Joliet improved, notwithstanding reductions in the flow
from Lake Michigan because of the added treatment
which the Chicago sewage gradually received. The peopie
at Joliet had become accustomed to this improvement.
When the flow from Lake Michigan was reduced on
December 30, 1938, conditions retrogressed and com-
plaints ensued from residents, who compared the 1939
conditions with those prevailing in 1938 and immediately
prior thereto. They had either forgotten the conditions
prevailing prior to 1930 or, not unnaturally, felt that the
improvement should continue. The nuisance conditions
in 1939 were much worse than in 1938. They were not
as bad in 1940 as in 1939.
The foregoing statement sufficiently discloses the
facts as found by me. Whether these facts constitute a
“menace to the health” of the inhabitants of the com-
plaining communities within the meaning which the Court
_ UT
62
intended that phrase to have, requires a decisicr as to
which I have no certain guide. Counset have gone to the
dictionaries for definitions of menace, but it seems to
me beside the point to cite uch definitions to the Court
Which itself used the phrase and will itself determine what
it meant. In this report I can only give the phrase the
meaning and scope which it seems to me that it was
intended to have in this case. I do not believe that the
Court intended to use the expression “menace to health”
in the sense in which it was employed by Professor Carl-
- 8on and Professor Ivy. On such a view it woul! not have .
been necessary to refer the case to me because it was
apparent on the face of the papers that the sewage
treatment program of the Sanitary District had not been
completed and that untreated and incompletely treated
Sewage continued to be discharged into the Waterway.'
Under this condition, if the test is to be that which was
urged by Professors Carlson and Ivy, it is clear that a
menace would necessarily be found to exiét. Accepting
this definition the increase of the flow to 5,000 cfs.
would not eliminate the menace, as these witnesses
agreed; the stream would continue a menace within the
Suggested definition as long as any untreated sewage
'This comment is also applicable to the argument urged upon
me by Illinois that the opinion and decree os ay 21, 1980, did not
& final decision that additional diversion should not mon be permitted
unless shown bg convincing evidence to be required by paramount
53
is discharged into it.' It is obvious that the presence of
untreated sewage in an open stream is not in accordance
with proper standards of sanitation and shagld be abated.
So also, as pointed out by the scientists, sho@ld be abated
excessive noises in large cities, vibrations from elevated
trains, c%rbon monoxide from automobiles, offensive
odors from stockyards and oil plants, and, one might
doubtless add, dust, smoke, soot, and other impurities
in the air, inadequate milk control and numerous other
undesirable conditions present in many communities.
The improvement of these conditions is a local responsi-
bility upon which too much emphasis cannot be placed.
The suggestions made by Professors Carlson and
Ivy as to possible danger to children swin ning in the
Waterway without authority and the possibility of water
seeping by accident through fissures in the rock to wells
from which Joliet obtains its drinking water, present
possibilities too remote for consideration. Conclusions
must be rested upon consequences reasonably and
naturally to be anticipated and not upon mere possibili-
ties, The record leaves no reasonable room for doubt as
to the safety of the water supply of Joliet and Lockport.
Nor can the effect of odors upon invalids and persons of
less than average health be accepted as any test of health
1According to the Sanitary District estimates there will be some in-
completely treated sewage going into the Canal even in 1943 and 1944,
# which years are not included in the present applicati f Illinois for a
modification of the decree of April 21, 1930. Even age completely
treated by the activated sludge system is not completely sterilized; see
Report of Special Master Hughes on re-reference (1929) d&p. 30. Even
when the Sanitary District program is completed, tne ter in the
Waterway will not be fit to drink.
Apparently it is uncertain whether there may not still be some
(though doubtless tly moderated) nuisance condition in the sum-
mer months at Joliet and Lockport even when the Sanitary District
treatmert plants have been completed. Mr. Pearse testifying in Jan- >
uary, 1941, said: “I think we testified in the beginning, and there
was very little cross-examination, if any, that we believed the condi-
tion would improve in the Pool in ’41 and ’42 and that after ’42 with
the equipment that we expect to put in, that the conditions would be
as good as our plant and the like could produce; in other words, that
they should be relatively free from nuisance down there * * * ”,
>
,
' , ee
Whig) saleXrubiadele Ue ee apd Uh LAibeeiised nen euaa et ada b ae ke ue
ae
54
menace; even in cases of private nuisances the test is
the effect of the acts complained of upon persens of ordi-
nary sensibilities and in normal health. In the present
case it is Illinois itself which is creating the nuisance
of which it complains and of which it seeks to be relieved
by water which has in effect been adjudged by the Court
to belong to the opposing States.
My conclusion is that the facts proven do not
establish any menace to the health of the inhabitants of
Joliet and Lockport or elsewhere along the Waterway
requiring an increase in diversion in water from Lake
Michigan. However, as the issue is one which only the
Court itself can determine, I necessarily proceed to dis-
cuss the other points covered by the order of reference.
IV.
PRESENT STATUS OF SEWAGE TREATMENT BY
‘SANITARY DISTRICT s OUTLOOK FOR SUM.-
Se MERS. OF 1941 AND 1942
Notwithstanding the importance of condensing this
report, it seems impossible to discuss adequately the pres-
ent condition of the Wateryay or the various ameliorat-
ing measures (other than diversion of water) which
have been put forward for consideration, without a state-
ment with respect to the sewage treatment plants of
the Sanitary District and the work which they are doing.
This in. turn requires some explanation of terms used in
sewage treatment. . ..
Meaning and Importance of the Terms “Sludge’’,
“B.O.D.” and “Dissolved Oxygen”
The term “sludge” as used in sewage disous-
sions means the so-called’ solids removed from Ee
sewage by sedimentation. These are not solid at all
as the layman would understand that term. They
contain from 90 to 98 or 99% water, which is
55
difficult to remove because of the very slimy, greasy
nature of the solids. The term “solids” in a chemical
sense means undissolved material or material in sus-
pended form. The solids containing organic matter are
known as volatile. The term “sludge” as used in this
case includes only~ material settled out in settling
tanks. It does not include putrefactive material con-
tained in effluents of incompletely treated sewage
from sewage treatment plants. Since October 1, 1940, no
more sludge is being deposited into the Waterway, but
putrefactive material in suspended solids continues to
be deposited in effluents from the plants, particularly
from the West Side and Southwest Plants.’
The standard test to determine the strength of
sewage is the ascertainment of.-its five day biochemical
oxygen demand. This is a chemical test by which samples
of sewage are incubated for five days at 20 degrees
Centigrade. The loss of oxygen within this period is
gaara as the five day biochemical demand, abbreviated
as 5 day B.0.D.?_ The percentage of reduction of B.O.D.
is the test of efficiency of sewage treatment. According
to Dr. Mohlman, the removal of settleable solids in Imhoff
tanks accomplishes a reduction of from 35 to 45% of the
: B.0.D., chemical treatment removes 60 to 65% and acti-
vated sludge treatment 90 to 93%.
1It appears, however, that in the discussions of the continuing
nuisance effect of deposits of “sludge” in past years, the term as
used in the record would include incompletely treated sewage which
was discharged into the Canal in effluents and formed sludge banks.
2Water containing much dissolved oxygen and suitable for drink-
ing may have a slight B.O.D. The evidence in this case shows B.O.D.
of water in the mouth of the Chicago River at Lake Michigan in June,
1940, to have been 1.3 p.p.m., although the water contained 9.9 p.p.m. of
dissolved oxygen :
The B.0.D. of raw sewage varies according to its strength, rang-
ing in this case, on 1940 averages, from a low of 107 at the Calumet
Plant to a high of 193 at the Southwest a where the stockyards
sewage is received. The 1940 average B.O.D. of the effluents from the
treatment plants ranged from a low of 7 at the North Side plant to
a high of 64 at the West Side, where-the treatment is only by Imhoff
f/™
56
.
Special Master Hughes found that the proposed
sewage treatment plants of the Sanitary District should
attain an annual average of not less than 85% purifica-
tion of the sewage treated, and that it was probable that
the degree of purification would be 90% or ‘more.’ In
fact, on the 1940 performances in all the sewage plants,
the weighted average of percent reduction in 5 day B.O.
D. was only 67.8, although at the Calumet and North
Side plants it was 90.7 and 94.6 respectively; see infra,
page 62 and table 8 in appendix.
The 5 day B:O.D. indicates the avidity for oxygen.
The supply of oxygen contained in a stream to meet this
demand is determined by the amount of dissolved oxygen
in the water.’ The relation between B.O.D. and available
oxygen is known as the oxygen balance. If the dissolved
oxygen is less than the oxygen demand, the water is
putrescible. However, so long as dissolved oxygen is
present, the water is not actually in a putrefactive state.
When the dissolved oxygen is exhausted, putrefaciion sets
in, accompanied by offensive odors.* Mr. Pearse, the
Sanitary Engineer of the District, arid Dr. Mohiman, its
Director of Laboratories, in this case contend that at
least 1 p.p.m. gf dissolved oxygen is necessary to prevent
nuisance; and that is the basis for the modified petition
of Illinois (supra, page 4). The weight of opinion,
however, seems to be that the presence of any dissolved
oxygen is sufficient; compare New York v. New Jersey,
256 U. S. 296, 311, decided in 1921. In the complete
1Report of Special Master Hughes on re-reference (1929) p. 35.
2The dissolved oxygen in Lake Michigan water ranges from a
minimum of less than 8 p.p.m. in summer to a maximum of approxi-
mately 14 p.p.m. in winter. The percentage of saturation ran from
90 to 105%; see Report of Engineering Board.of Review of Sani-
tary District of Chicago, (1925), table 10, page 43.
—e oxygen is from time to time in this report referred to
as D.O.
*This explanation is taken from page 43 of Report of the Engin-
eering Board of Review, cited supra.
A
-
"67
absence of dissolved oxygen, an odor nuisance may be
expected in the presence of- a substantial B.O.D.!
General Description of Sanitary District Treatment Plants
A general description of the treatment works and
methods of the Sanitary District, including those then
complete and those then planned, will be found in the
1929 reports of Special Master Hughes on re-reference
at pages 8, ff. The following summary of the plants as
actually constructed, is taken from the testimony of Mr.
H. P. Ramey, Assistant Chief Engineer of the Sanitary
District. ;
The Sanitary District comprises 442 miles of area.
It is divided into four projects: 3
1. North Side Plant. This plant is of the activated
sludge type, originally designed for an average flow of
175 m.g.d. with a maximum of 263 m.g.d. It went into
service on October 3, 1928, but was not in complete opera-
tion unti] June 28, 1930. On May 19, 1937, an aver-
age capacity of 250 m.g.d. was obtained by the addition
pf twelve new settling tanks. The effluent passes to the
North Shore channel. The excess activated sludge and
the preliminary sludge from the preliminary settling
tanks are pumped 17.5 miles te the Southwest works for
ultimate disposaf> :
2. Calumet Plant. This is also of the activated
sludge type, designed for an average flow of 136 m.g.d.
anda maximum of 200 m.g.d. and has been in service
since September 3, 1935. The effluent is discharged into
the Calumet-Sag channel, east of Blue Island. The excess
1The extent of B.O.D. rather than the amount of diss’ :ved oxygen
is the final test of extent of Pollution. But there may Fe a B.O.D. in
drinking water which contains much dissolved oxygen. Thus the water
at the mouth of the Chicago River in June, 1940, had a B.O.D. of 1
‘it contained 9.9 p.p.m. of dissolved oxygen.
58
sludge is conditioned, de-watered, dried for burning or
sold for fertilizer.
v
3. West Side Plant. This is of the Imhoff tank
type, designed for an average flow. of 472 m.g.d. with a
maximum of 700 m.g.d. From these tanks sludge is
pumped to drying beds. After the sludge is dried to a
workable condition, it is cleaned off the beds by stripping
machines and hauled three miles to a dumping area. The
effluent is discharged into the main channel. The result
is poorer than that obtained at the North Side and Calu-
met plants because treatment by the Imhoff tank method
does not provide a complete degree of treatment. Pres-
ent plans call for giving activated sludge final treatment
to West Side sewa t the Southwest plant now to be
known as the West-Southwest plant.
4. Southwest Side Plant. This is now known as
the West-Southwest plant, but in this report is usually
referred to as the Southwest plant. It is of the activated
sludge type, and said to be the largest sewage treatment
plant in existence. It was originally designed for an
average flow of 400 m.g.d. with a maximum of 600
m.g.d. Final plans contemplate its enlargement to a
capacity of 900 m.g.d., of which 600 would be completely
treated and 300 partially treated; the West Side sewage
would be given secondary treatment. The first battery of
activated sludge was put in service on June 27, 1939,
and de-watering and incineration of sludze has operated
continuously since August 28, 1989. The Racine Avenue
pumping station, which handles about half the sewage
in the project, was not put into service until March 20,
1940. The effluent is discharged into the main Canal.
To 4his plant comes all industrial waste from the stock
The excess activated sludge is mixed with the
North Side sludge, concentrated into sludge concentration
\
e 59
tanks, treated, de-watered, dried for burning or sold
as fertilizer. The Southwest plant is known as the West-
Southwest plant because ultimately it will provide com-
plete treatment for the Southwest Side sewage, and
final treatment for the West Side Sewage. So far the
only sewage treated is the Southwest side sewage (and
that only incompletely).
Cost of Sewage Treatment Plants and Progress
Made in Their Construction and in Treatment
of Sewage
Up to December 3lst, 1928, thé™ Sanitary District
had expended on sewage treatment works $63,355,422
and the District then estimated that the additional cost
of completing the program would be $176,166,000.! The
grand total cost of the program would, upon these fig-
ures, have been $239,521,422. At January Ist, 1941, the
District estimated that the total cost would be $178,075,-
611. This is about $61,000,000 less than the 1928 fig-
ures. The difference is due to a number of changes in the
plans of the Sanitary District as well as to savings in
cost,
Of the total of $178,075,611 there was incomplete
at January 14, 1941, work estimated-t®cost $11,756,900,
of which $2,392,000 had been contracted for on that date
and $9,364,900 had not yet been contracted for.
The work to be done after January 14, 1941 is
chiefly at the West-Southwest plant, the largest item
being for additional fina] settling tanks and aeration
_. tanks and completion of the sludge handling plant.
"Some changes in the program of the Sanitary Dis”
trict were made as a result of recommendations in 1934
by a Commission appointed by the PWA (Federal
1The figures appear in the report of Special Master Hughes, on re-
reference at p. 6, ff.
ig
—
60
Emergency Administration of Public Works), from whom
the Banitary District obtained a loan and grant. After
these recommendations were made the District made
studies and tests with reapect to treatment of West ‘Side
effilueht which axtended over three years. In May, 1940,
follfime «a feport from the District a Board of
Review of the PWA recommended that the heat method of
supplementing the treatment now given to the West
Side sewage lay in enlarging the Southwest activated
sewage plant. Grants made by the PWA to t anitary
District aggregate $16,692,000 and there is oledine an
application for an additional grant of $1,900,000.
On July Ist, 1940, the Sanitary District Rad on hand
in cash and debt incurring capacity, monies estimated
to be sufficient to pay for 90% of all future work, and
if assessed valuations remain the same, the District's
debt incurring capacity will increase at the rate of about
five million dollars a year. The District's financial re
‘sources are now adequate to assure the completion of its
am without further interference because of finan-
cial difficulties, but this was not true until May, 1940.
when for the first tim in the past three years the bonds
outstanding were substantially leas than the debt incur.
ring capacity. The record cuntaine numerous statements
by Mr. Pearse, Sanitary Engineer of the District, indi-
eating that the progress of the work uas been constantly
delayed by lack of funds up to as recently as May, 1949.
At the outset of the hearings, I stated that [ under.
stood the per curiam opinion of the Court handed dewn
on April 3, 1940 (309 U. S. 56%), to be u final odjuth-
cation that Illinois had “failed to show that it had pro-
vided all possible means at its command for the compl-
tion of the sewage treatment system” as required by the
Court’s decree of April 21, 1930, as specifically ex-
ae ft — * os AACN Ren ee 2 fn “en mepees <n —— ener es
61
larged in 1983, and that “no adequate excuse had been
presented for the delay”, and that I did not construe
the reference to me as authorizing any inguiry into
excuses for delays. I did not, therefore, inquire into the
reasons for delays in making applications to the PWA
or the reasons for the delays ia letting contracts or the
circumstances justifying the delay of three years in mak-
ing studies for a definite program following the PWA
recommendations in 1984,
The various tables which accompany this report as
appendices show the following pertinent facts:
(1) The flow at all the treatment works in millions
of flions daily increased from 67.9 mgd. in 1928 to
338.38 m.g.d. in 1981. There was then comparatively
little increase until 1936, when the flow became 464.9
mg.d. In 1937 there was a further increase in flow
of about 80 m.g.d. with little Change in 1938. In 1939
the flow became 669.9 m.g.d. and in 1940 it reached 929.9
m.g.d.' The system today is stated to collect all but 40
mgd of a total sewage flow of over 1.000 m.g.d.
(2) Volatile solids didcharged into the Canal amoun-
ted in tons in 1938 to 123,100 and in 1939 to 115,658.
In 1940 the figure had declined to 76,472 and in 1941
it is estimated that it will be 40,910, or only about
one-third of the 1939 total.°@ Volatile solids represent
organic matter and most of the putrescible materia] in
the sewage.
(3) The total sludge and grit discharged into the
Cana] aggregated 53,970 tons in 1939. This was more
than in any of the three preceding years; in 1938 it was
44,198. In 1940 it was only 20,224. Sinee the’ end of
‘See Table 2 in appendix. See also Table 3 showirg inérease in d
Solids removed from 54.1 tons in 1929 to 422.7 in 1940 7 A ?
*See Table 4 in appendix. ‘s
ae ae
62
September, 1940, no sludge and grit has been discharged
into the channel.'
(4) The efficiency of the various plants in the last
three years, as reflected in reduction of B.O.D., is as
follows:
1938 1939 1940
North Side 92.2 93.5 +» 94.6
~ Calumet 83.1 87.0 90.7
West Side 47.4 53.7 50.0
Southwest 67.3?
The weighted average percentage of B.O.D. reduc-
tion jn all plants for 1940 was 67.8.°
The particularly poor result at the West Side plant
is due to the fact that the treatment there is only by
Imhoff tanks and not by activated sludge. The poor
result at the Southwest plant appears to be due af feast
in part to the inadequacy of the present = of
the plant.
(5) The report of the Southwest treatment plant
by months for 1940 shows a striking decline in efficiency
of result, as indicated by the following summary :*
Total Flow Complete B.O.D. Re-
Month m.g.d. Treatment duction
January 287 287 91.3
April 252 122 64
July 287 168 70.8
October 361 248 65.1
December 358 139 47.1
Average 313 192 67.3
1See Tables 5 and 6 in appendix.
PP ig was the first year of complete operation of the Southwest
plant. ;
See Table 8 in appendix.
*See Table 7 in appendix.
63
In argument it was suggested that one reason for
the decline in results was that the Racine Avenue pump-
ing station, which carries stockyards sewage, had been
cut in only on March 20, 1940. As the stockyards sew-
tage is strong, this would explain a decline in B.O.D. re-
duction from January to April, but it would not explain
the decline in total flow between those months, nor would
it explain the extreme further decline in B.O.D. reduc-
tion from 70.8 in July to 47.1 in December. It was also
suggested that the strength of the raw sewage B.O.D.
had increased within these months. However, the strength
of the raw sewage in December was not substantially
greater than in November, while the percentage of reduc-
tion in December was only 47.1 as compared with 67.2
in November. The strength Bf the raw sewage in October
was substantially the same as in January, but the per-
centage in reduction in B.0.D. in October was only 66.1
as compared with 91.3 in January. It may also be noted
that at the Southwest plant the total number of gallons
receiving complete treatment in December was only 139
as compared with 222, 248 and 236 in the three preceding
mogths.’
>
Mr. Pearse said in answer to my inquiry as to the
poor recent showing at the Southwest plant, “we are
hoping for better and more consistent operation during
1941” and “I think that it will necessitate a closer
watch on the operators in the plant than we have had
heretofore by those of us in the main office. That is the
best explanation I can give you.”
Mr. Pearse explained the deficiencies of operation
at the Southwest plant chiefly on the ground that there
was not sufficient blower capacity to carry continuously
a flow of 400,000,000 gallons per day. He said,
1See Table 7 in appendix.
64
“I am afraid that we are under-blowered be-
cause our money did not go far enough to buy
sufficient blowers with a nominal capacity of
400,000,000 gallons, and as a matter of fad, I
believe the PWA, if I am not mistaken, cuf*out
one blower that we urged them to buy at the
time.”
There is also a shortage of colupressors, which were
“advertised for. within the last few months probably.”
Mr. Pearse could not answer offhand why contracts were
- not let sooner, °“I think one answer was that we were
waiting until the end of the winter, early spring, to find
out how much money would be available and to what
extent they should go ahead.” Following the action of
the Poard of Review of the FWA, steps were taken to
get vit the specifications and advertise for the hlowers.
There is also a need for additional vacuum filters and
eight now are under contract, bringing the total up to
82. “We are trying to put in vacuum filters in con-
nection with the other equipment as fast as we can get
the money. We have got eight on order and we will be
buying more.”
The deficiency in equipment is particularly at the
end of the treatment process in that portion thereof
which consists of de-watering, heating and drying the
residue of the sludge and making it marketable fcr fer-
tilizer. The shortage of equipment at this point makes it
impossible to run all the sludge through the plant. A
substantial part of the sewage flow was discharged as
sludge into the channel without completé treatment, i.e.,
only after a short period of preliminary settlement. Thus,
in the first six months of 1940 there continued to be a
substantial amount of sludge discharged into the channel
from the Southwest treatment plant.
In August, 1940, shortly after the hearings before
4
65 ’
me had begun, arrangements were made to send to the
West Side plant the sludge which was then being dis-
charged into the channel from the Southwest plant. This
sludge is now being run through the Imhoff tanks at the
West Side plant and then placed into lagoons. In the last
few months of 1940 lagoons were constructed on the
site of the West and Southwest works covering an
area of 37 acres. The cost was about $38,000 as a
WPA project, of which the Sanitary District con-
tributed about 38%. There is available at this location
a further area of about 20 acres on which additional
lagoons might be constructed. Based upon the present
short period of preliminary settling (13 minutes) given
at the Southwest works to the flow which is then sent
over to the West Side plant, the lagoon capacity available
should suffice into 1943. If a longer period of settling
be employed, the capacity would be exhausted in the
winter of 1941-42. Further land for lagoons is available
at a point four miles removed. These lagoons are situated
in an industrial area and their use will create no nuis-
ance complaints.
As a result of this lagooning (but only since the
hearings before me began) the discharge of sludge into
the Waterway by the Sanitar; District has entirely
ceased. Other putrefiable material, however, continues
to be discharged into the Waterway, chiefly in suspended
solids contained in the incompletely treated effluents of
the West Side and Southwest plants.
Probable Conditions at Lockport and Joliet in
the Summers of 1941 and 1942
In prognosticating the situation at Lockport in 1941
and 1942, the experts on both sides agreed that there
were to be taken into account, on the one hand, the
66
sources of B.O.D. and, on the other hand, the sources of
dissolved oxygen.
The liability side (sources of B.O.D.) is made up in
part of the demand asserted by the old sludge deposits in
the Canal and in the Pool. All the experts agreed that it -
is impossible to evaluate precisely the demand exerted by
these deposits in pounds of B.O.D. One can only guess
at this. As previously noted, all of the experts agreed that
the B.O.D. of sludge decreases about one-half after four
months of summer, that at the end of the second sum-
mer, it will be only about one-fourth the initial demand
and at the end of three summers, possibly only 3 to 5%
thereof. Therefore, the B.O.D. exercised at Lockport in
41 by old sludge deposits will be materially less than in
1939 because the sludge deposits of the two years pre-
ceding 1939 materially exceeded in volume the deposits
for the two years preceding 1941.1 In 1942 the situation
as te the influence of old sludge will be further improved
by the considerable further reduction” of deposits in the
channel jn 1941. ,
According to the estimates of the Sanitary District,
the chief source of B.O.D. at Lockport in 1941 and 1942
will be the B.O.D. from the West Side and Southwest
effluents.”
The Sanitary District concedes that the B.O.D. de-
mandg at ‘Lockport in the summers of 1941 and 1942 wil]
be far less than they were in 1939, which is the summer
in which. the complaints at Joliet were the most pro-
1See record of volatile solids deposited in channel in appendix,
Table 4.
2This will be due to (a) incomplete treatments afforded by Imhoff :
tanks. at West side and (b) inadequacy of equipment at Southwest
plant to permit complete treatment of the plant’s ne ye flow and
the consequent necessity of discharging into the Canal effuent incom-
pleteiy treated. ;
sludge deposits __._.__.
B.O.D. demands from cur-
rent deposits of sludge
and/or effluents... __ _- 763,800
519,000
67
1939 1940 1941 1942
Total............. 1,282,900
Flow—c.f.s. . ... Sonenees 6,752
5-day B.O,D
—— asic acalhiatinreiak “is 17.3
—lIbs. per day........... 630,800
Dissolved Oxygen—
edna e aw advicass 0.2
—lbs. per day. .......... 6,07
After submitting his
nounced, and also far less than in 1940.1 A comparison of
the years upon the revised figures submitted by the
Sanitary District is as follows :? .
Sources of B.O.D. lbs. per day— :
1938
B.O.D. demands from old
475,000 237,000 118,500 60,000
749,000 529,000 406,000 406,000
1,224,000 766,000 524,500 466,000
3,336 3,469 3,200 3,200
30.2 20.6 21.0 17.6
562,300 386,000 394,500 303,000
0.0 0.0 0.0 0,0
0 0 0 0
revised figures Mr. Pearse
testified that he would be disposed to again revise them
so as’ to reduce to 346,000
ing in the 1941 and 1942
the figure of 406,000 appear-
columns (as B.O.D. demands
from current deposits of sludge and/or effluents) in order
td give proper weight to.
probable decre&ses in B.O.D.
from West Side and Southwest effluents.
The accuracy of the Sanitary District figures is chal-
lenged by Mr. Howson, who contends that the conditions
1[llinois os rgd put in evidence estimates which showed much
greater anticipa
improvement in the B.O.D. at Lockport in 1941 and
@ 1942. At the time of oral argument it was stated that these estimates
had been made up in error and the estimates shown in the text were
substituted.
2The District’s revised figures appear in full in the appendix,
Table 9.
»
68 ‘\
at Lockport in the summers of 1941 and 1942 will be
materially better than estimated by the Sanitary District.
It would take too much space to attempt to set out
a full analysis of the conflicting views. Mr. Howson’s
figures are apparently based upon his view that by
proper diligence in completing work at the Southwest
plant, no effluent from it would contribute B.O.D. in 1941
and 1942 and that the West Side effluent would also be
completely treated in 1942. fn the actual present status
of the Sanitary District program, it seems clear that
this expectation cannot be realized as to 1941 and
doubtful if it will be accomplished by 1942. Mr. Howson
also contends that the Sanitary District has overestimated
the B.O.D. effect of old sludge deposits and has failed to
give sufficient weight to the re-aeration which will be
acquired through the flow to Lockport, particularly in
view of the scouring of the channel as a result of the
10-day experimental flow. Here again are presented
issues upon which a layman must have difficulty in re-
solving a conflict between experts;* It is probable that
1Mr. Howson originally calculated that in the three summer months
of 1941 and 1942 the B.O.D. at Lockport would be 7.3 p.p.m. and 4.8
p.p.m.
On the figures originally submitted by the Sanitary District, the
B.0.D. at Lockport in 1941 was not extended, but on the other figures
shown, Mr. Howson calculated that the B.O.D. in Lockport would have
been 10.3 p.p.m. as compared with the figure of 21.0 p.p.m. which appears
in the revised District figures.
Even upon the revised figures of the District, Mr. Howson contends
that the B.O.D. at Lockport in the summer months of 1941 and 1942
should be determined by taking that proportion of the estimated sources
of B.O.D. in those years which (a) the actual B.O.D. at Lockport in the
earlier years was to (b) the total sources of B.O.D. in earlier years. On
this basis, even upon the revised figures of the District Mr. Howson
claims that the B.O.D. at Lockport in the summer monihs of 1941 and
1942 will be 13.5 p.p.m. and 11.5 p.p.m. instead of the District’s revised
estimates of 21.0 and 17.6. ; »
*I considered from time to time whether I should call experts of my
own selection, but concluded not to do so, in part, for the reasons as-
signed for a similar conclusion by Special Master Hughes in his report
upon re-reference (1929), p. 127, and in part, because such employ-
ment would have occasioned additional delay in an inquiry which I
have already found it difficult to make “summary”, as directed in the
order of reference.
69
Mr. Howson’s figures are too optimistic, while those of
the Sanitary District go too far in the other direction.
However, it seems sufficient to note that even upon the
Sanitary District’s figures, the total sources of B.O.D.
demands in 1941 in pounds will be less than half of
the 1939 figure, and the 5-day B.O.D. (which Dr.
Mohlman agrees to be the final test of pollution) will
in 1941, in parts per million, be only two-thirds of
the 1939 figure. In ,1942 there will be further sub-
stantial reductions qccording to the District estimates.
The figures, therefore, seem to make it clear that the
pollution at Lockport (and correspondingly at the Pool)
will be materially less in 1941 and 1942 than in 1939.
This result would indeed seem to be the necessary con-
sequence of the great reduction in tons of volatile solids
discharged into the Canal in 1940, and to be discharged
in 1941 and,1942, as compared with amounts discharged
in 1939 and earlier years.! This is further confirmed
by the testimony given before me by the experts for
Illinois, who at the outset of the hearings, agreed that
conditions in 1941 at Joliet and Lockport would be better
than in 1940, and a fortiori substantially better than in
1939. They also agreed that an additional improvement
w&s to be expected in 1942, when further pfogress will
have been made in sewage treatment and the effect of
past sludge deposits will have been further reduced.
It is true that there will be, according to the Sanitary
District estimates, no dissolved oxygen at Lockport in the
summer of 1941 or 1942. There was also none in the
Summer of 1939 and even in the summer of 1938 there
ss
~
1See appendix, Table 4.
70
was only 0.2.'. This 1938 figure would fall below
the minimum of 1 p.p.m. of D. 0. which the Sanitary
District in its modified petition claims to be essential.
Yet in 1938 the authorized diversion from the Lake was
5,000 c.f.s., the actual flow at Lockport was 6,702 c.f.
(including domestic pumpage), and there were no spe-
cial complaints in Lockport or Joliet (although annoy-
ance + discomfort from the odors have always been
experiénced and expressed).
\
The following are the average D.O. and B.O.D. fig-
ures at Lockport for January of the last four years :°
1938 1939 1940 1941
Dissolved Oxygen 00 7.4058 0G
IUD. senssinpnenmennnisinicamansoce GR De ee | ee
_ The dissolved oxygen for the month of January in
1941, was substantially the same as in 1939, but mater-
ially less than in 1940,’ and greatly less than in 1938,
when the diversion was larger. The B.O.D. for January
was, however, substantially less in 1941 than in 1939,
and about the same as in 1938 (wh€n the diversion was
‘Dr. Mohiman testified, “I do not think conditions prior to 19389
are by any means satisfactory conditions. We had zero dissolved
oxygen at port. We are merely keeping up with what we have
had for many years, and we are not im roving conditions down there
after the expenditure of all this meaey for our treatment plants.”
*The Sanitary District has records’’of the L.O.D. and dissolved
oxygen at Lockport ee back as far as 1925. These records show
in 1939 a higher B.O.D. a more extended period of no dissolved
oxygen than in any other year. However, in every other year there
was a period in the summer in which the dissolved oxygen went down
to zero for a few months; in many of the years the dissolved
oxygen in che summer was actually zero for a part of the time.
1940). The District states that the low average in 1941 is due to the
effort to conserve diversion this winter in preparation for the demands
next summer,
71
6,752 c.f.s.)' :
Insofar as one can reason from January to June,
the B.O.D. figures seem to support the view that condi-
tions in June, 1941, will be a great deal better than in
1939. The dissolved oxygen figures indicate that June,
1941, will be no better as to odor conditions than 1939;
but, as has been noted, the District representative testi-
tied that the B.O.D. figures are the controlling evidence
of degree of pollution. | ,
As a subsequent statement shows, the 10-day flushing
in December appears to have cleaned much sludge out of
the channel as a whole, while at the same time leaving
more in the Pool than there was before flushing.? To the
extent that more pu ible material has been deposited
in the Pool, conditions in 1941 will be adversely affected.
A counterbalancing influence will be the cleaning out of
the channel above the Pool, which should reduce the
B.0.D. in the water on the way to the Pool and enable
it to contribute more dissolved oxygen. In the opinion
of Dr. Mohlman the hopes entertained in this, regard
are @enied by the fadt that the dissolved oxygen at Lock-
port in January, 1941, was less than in January, 1940,
and not much more than in January, 1939.
I conclude that while it is reasonably certain that
the B.O.D. conditions in the summers of 1941 and 1942
will be better than those in 1939, it *s also most probable
that there will be no dissolved oxygen 2t,the Pool in the
summer of 1941 and that there are likelf again to be
offensive odors at Joliet and Lockport. Weather condi-
tions will undoubtedly have a large influence fot only
upon the existence of odors but also upon the susegpti-
bility of individuals to them. >
'For the full years 1938, 1939 and 1940, the average B.O.D. and
D.O. figures at Lockport were as follows:
iemicwm M
ved 2. 4
B.0.D 18.4 26.0 20.1
72
Vv.
AVAILABLE REMEDIAL OR AMELIORATING
MEASURES
The opposing States pointed out that the first step _
in the improvement of conditions in the Waterway would
be to discontinue the discharge into it of sludge. As
shown by the statement supra, page 55, this was actually
accomplished as of the end of September, 1940, after
the hearings before me had begun, but a considerable
quantity of putrescible material continues to be deposited
into the Canal in the form of partly treated effluents.
Other possible remedial measures which were sug-
~~gested in the hearings before me are now taken up in
~ order,
Dredging, Draining or Flushing Brandon Road Pool
As the complaints which ied to the present hearing
emanate chiefly from those residing along the banks of
the Waterway at Joliet, within one to two miles of the
Brandon Road Pool, it seems quite clear that they are
attributable chiefly to the conditions at the Pool. I there-
fore gave particular attention to various suggestions as
to what might be done to ameliorate conditions there.
As noted at page 9, the wide section of the Bran-
don Road Pool, which reaches a maximum of 1,400 feet,
exterds for about half a mile at the southern end of
Joliet, between one and two miles from the residences
of most of the complaining witnesses. The depth of the
Pool varies from 10 to 20 feet below the water surface
to the sludge deposits; in the center this depth was esti-
mated by Dr. Mohlman of the Sanitary District at 18%
73
feet and by Mr. Andrew of the United States District
iingineer’s office at 19 to 22 feet. The elevation of the
Pool is 539 feet above sea level. It contains a water
volume of about 120 million cubic feet. The original
volume was about 151 million cubic feet. ~
The United States Engineers made soundings in
1934, 1936 and 1939. Beiween the 1934 and 1936 sound-
ings and those made in 1939, Mr. Andrew estimated
that there had accumulated in the Pool from 1,250,000. ,
to 1,500,000 cubic yards of deposited material. Of this
about 107,000 cubic yards represented materials depos-
ited by the United States from dredging, and the balance
represented accumulated sludge deposits. The deposited
material extends at some points for 2 feet and at other.
points from 6 to 10 feet. At other points in the Sanitary
Canal, there are deposics ranging from 2 to 4 feet, but
nothing comparable to those in the Pool.’
Mr. Andrew testified that in his opinion an increase
in the flow to 5,000°c.f.s. would not remove this accumiu-
lated deposit, nor would it flow out by opening the gates
of the locks. It would have to be taken out by hydraulic
dredging, the moisture content ranging from 60 to 99%.
Most of this material is in the lower quarter of the Pool.
The dredging would cost about 40 cents per cubic yard or
between $500,000 and $750,000; it would take from 6 to
9 months. The material removed would have to be depos-
ited on adjacent land. Several hundred acres would be
required, but there is vacant land available for this
purpose.
. 1The sludge deposits accumulated even while the authorized diver-
sion from Lake Michigan was 6,500 c.f.s. and 5,000 c.f.s.
}
|
Sree
oe
-
ra
74
Mr. Howson, the expert for the opposing States,’
thought that the dredging of the material referred to by
Mr. Andrew might not cost more than $400,000. The
material would probably have to be lagooned on spoil
banks. A nuisahee condition might be caused at the
point of lagooning. This might be controlled to some
extent by the use of chlorination at a further expense,
no figures as to which were furnished me.
The experts on both sides agreed that the denser
material deposited in the Pool represents accumulations
of previous years which have largely lost any potency to
cause nuisance, Studies which have been made indicate
that after four months of summer, the B.0.D. of sludge
decreases about one half; that at the end of a second sum-
mer, the B.O.D. will be only about one fourth of the ini-
tial rate; and after three years, the rate is reduced to
possibly 3 to 5% of the initial rate. It appears that the
hydraulic dredging of the deposited material in the Pool
would remove for the most part material no longer the
cause of offense,
While Mr. Howson said that “some good” might be
accomplished by dredging this material, he had his
“doubts about its practicability as compared to mfre
iMr. Howsori-was the leading sanitary expert witness for the oppos-
ing States. He is di graduate of the University of Wisconsin, and since
1918 has been a member of the firm of Alvord, Burdick & Howson, who
specialize in hydraulic and sanitary engineering, including sewage and
sewage
city of Tlimois and came to the Sazitary District in 1919 as Chief Chem-
ist. Mr. Ramey is a graduate in civil engineering of the University of
All these gentlemen testified also™jn the hearings before Special
Master Hughes on re-reference. x
es
»*
75
effective and positive methods such as chlorination and
methods of that type.”
Dr. Moh!lman thought that the dredging of the Pool
would dislodge sludge deposits and disseminate the sludge,
bringing it. to the surface of the water and thereby inten-
sifying odors. Dredging might remove some of the large
bulky deposits, “but whether it would’ remove the actual
putrefactive material, I think, is questionable, and it
doesn’t seem to me a practical method of getting
rid of the odors and the putrefaction in those channels
there and the pool.” If the sludge is deposited on spoil
banks, “there would be odors wherever it was deposited,
even if it was covered with water, and the escaping
gases would cause a nuisance.”
Mr. Pearse deemed it impractical to accomplish much
by dredging and removing material which had been de-
composing for two or three years. He thought it an “in-
tensely speculative question. * * * “I would think a good
many times before I would want to spend the public’s
money on such a venture.”
in view of the foregoing and particularly of the
agreement of the experts on both sides that most of the
material that would be taken out by dredging is the old
material which has largely lost its potency as a cause of
nuisance, I do not think that hydraulic dredging of the
Pool could be counted upon to eliminate the odors com-
plained of at Joliet. Dredging would also raise a new set
of problems as to odors from material deposited on spoil
banks.
J
After hearing Mr. Andrew’s original statement, I
abandoned for the time being any further inquiry as to
7
the possibility of draining the Pool by opening the looks
since it appeared from hia teatimony that the material to
which he referred would nob flow out if the looka were
opened, Tt developed, however, from aubacquent testimony
of the aanitary engineera that the material in the Pool
Which they cotaidered feaponaible for the odora com
plained of waa light floesulent material containing from
) to PR or PH) molatite, whieh they. believed would
flow out of ita own Weight if the locka at Mrandon Road
were opened and the Pool drained, Mr. Howson was
atrongly of the view that the draining of flushing of the
Pool would be beneficial in renieving active sludge rep:
resented by the floeculent material, He thought that the
objectionable material would cause no trouble dowh the
river as it could be deposited in the Dreaden Island Pool,
which ia several times larger than Rrandon Pool and
in a very sparsely settled area, and that the balance
would yo downstream, The other experts shared the view
that this foceulent material would flow out upon a flush
ing or draining.
I thereupon renewed my inquiry as to the feasibility
of draining the Pool. The United States Engineers were
of the opinion that this was not feasible for a variety
of reasons. They were of the opinion that the operation
would have to be repeated two or three times as the floc
culent material would not come through at one time. The
gates could not be opened completely without causing risk
of damage to navigation. The opening of the gates
Brandon Road would necessitate operations at the lock:
and dams at Dresden Island and Marseilles. If the gates
were only partly opened and the Pool drained only in part
from time to time, operations would be necessary at the
locks at Dresden Island and Marseilles. They feared
that the flocculent material carried down to other points
7 77
might cause nuisance conditions at those points.’ It was
also Suggested that the Government wquid then be re-
quired to do mere eredging down the river to maintain
navigation channels at increased expense and poasible inci-
dental interference with navigation, particularly at the
pools at Dresden Island and Marseilles. To empty the
Brandon Road Poo! or even to reduce its level would inter-
fere with water intakes of several industries. The opinion
Was expressed by the Government engineers that to com-
pletely drain the Pool at one time by cutting off the flow
from the Sanitary District might result in reversals of
flow in the river and pollution of the lake water at the
mouth of the Galumet River. Even a reduction in
the diversion to a total flow of 1,700 cis. (includ-
ing domestic pumpage), it was suggested, might make
difficulty in the event of a rainfall or if seiches occurred
in Lake Michigan materially lowering the lake levels dur-
ing that period. Draining the Pool would not remove
the sludge deposits other than the flocculent material and
Such other ‘material could be removed only by hydraulic
dredging. The Government engineers stressed their view
that the removal of the flocculent material, if it could
be accamplished, would not give complete relief as long
as additional] materia] continued to be deposited in the
channel from the treatment plants of the Sanitary
District. ?
Ut appears that the region immediately below Joliet is relatively
sparsely settled. The nearest large town is Ottawa with a2 population of
adeut 16.000, at a distance of about 56 miles south of Joliet. Other tewns
0 the Waterway below Joliet, and their approximate pepulations and
stances from Joliet, are -
: Approximate
Approximate Population Distance from Joliet
in Miles
oe 60
LaSalle —-—. 13,000 65
Peoria _.._____.105,000 130
Beardstown -.... 6,500) 260
Additional water from the convergence of the Kankakee and Fox
Rivers between Jolict and Peru affords additional dilution in the Water-
way. |
v
78
For all of these reasons the Chief of Engineers stated
definitely his unwillingness to agree to the drainage of
the Pool at this time.
Notwithstanding the views thus expressed by the
Chief of Engineers, reference continued to be made dur-
ing the course of the hearings to the possibility of reliéy-
ing nuisance conditions by removing from the Brandon
Road Pool some of the flocculent material of recent origin
which was arrested there as in a catch basin. The sug-
gestion finally developed that a 10-day flow of 10,000
e.f.s, would be of material benefit in washing out this
material without necessitating any opening of the locks,
All of the experts agreed that such a flushing of the
Waterway would be helpful and desirable. At my sugges-
tion counsel for the opposing States stipulated that the
Court might enter such an order upon the understanding
that their position in the case would not be in any man-
ner prejudiced by the agreement. I ascertained from
the Chief of Engineers that the War Department would
offer no objection from the standpoint of interference
with navigation. Accordingly on November 25, 1940,
the Court entered an order permitting a flow of 10,000
c.f.s., in addition to domestic pumpage, for 10 days
beginning on December 2, 1940.
Results of Experimental 10-Day F. lushing
During the test the totul flow at Lockport averaged |
9,973 c.f.s. and the diversion flow at Lockport, less water _
pumpage in’ the Chicago area, was 8,430 ¢.f.s. This was |
less than the amount permitted by the stipulation and the
order of the Court, but was the maximum flow capacity
of the drainage Canal at the time of the test. The weather
in the experimen:al period was very cold, which decreased
the flow from tributaries, and, accordingly, the expected
stages in the lower reaches of the Waterway were not
— a i
79
reached and damages to low lying lands, which: had been
feared, were not suffered.
The level of the Pool at the Brandon Road Dam was
Jowered half a foot to induce the flow. The experts had
thought that a lowering of the level by about 5 feet would
make the experiment more effective. The War. Depart-
ment was unwilling to permit a lowering to this extent
because of suggested difficulties with the intake pipes
of various industries. A further lowering of the level
by one foot was, however, permitted for 36 hours over
the weekend of December 7th and 8th.
The flushing appears to have scoured out the Water-
way above the Brandon Road Pool pretty well. However,
much of the material deposited in the upper reaches
of the Waterway, which was swept down the stream by
the increased flow, | id not carry through the Pool. The
figures are shown as follows in the report upon the test
prepared by Dr. Mohlman:
Total tons suspended sclids carried into Pool___.84,010
Total tons suspended solids carried out of Pool—.21,123
Balance deposited in Pool -™ 62,887
Percent deposited, —.........__ —— 74.8%
Percent transmitted ar —— 25.2%
The above totals include both volatile and nbd volatile suspended
solids. Figures as to the volatile suspended solids aft as follows:
Deposited in Brandon Pool 27,067 tons
Transported out of Pol — aaa
Percent transported 27.8%
The volatile material is that which is the chief source
of nuisance as it represents chiefly organic matter.!
1Volatile solids are determined by heating dried solids to a tem-
—_ of 650° C.; the loss of materia! is the volatile or organic
matter.
¢
80
Thus, of the offensive material carried into the
Pool by the flushing, a larger percentage was taken out
than of the total material taken into the Pool. This was
confirmed by the fact that 52.8% of the tons of B.O.D.
carried into the Pool were carried out of it.
The average velocity in the middle of the Pool during
the experimental flow ranged only from .47 to .55 feet
per second. The maximum velocities ranged from 1.33
to 1.58 and the minimum velocities near the banks ranged
from 0 to 0.07. Mr. Ramey estimated that velocities in
the Pool are generally about one-third or one-fourth of ‘
the velocities in ¢he main channel.
Dr. Mohlman estimated that the additional deposits
of material carried into the Pool by the 10-day flushing
amounted to as much as 2 to 21% feet and perhaps aggte-
, gated 524,000 cubic yards. Mr. Andrew said that sound-
ings indicated increased deposits of as much as 9 feet at
certain points, but that there is still a minimum depth of
13 feet in the channel, which is in excess of the minimum
required of 9 feet and more than that at other points
in the Waterway, and the government does not anticipate
more dredging at this time.
Opinions were in conflict as to whether a lowering
of the level of the Pool by 5 feet while the flushing
was in progress would have resulted in sweeping out
more flocculent material. Mr. Howson thought it would
have done so, but this view was not shared by Messrs.
Andrew and Ramey, who felt that, in view of the low
velocity in the middle of the stream, a lowering of 5 feet
would have been of no appreciable benefit. Mr. Howson
frankly said that there could be no certainty on this
point without a series of prolonged experiments and more
data than was available.
I ‘inquired of all the experts as to why their expecta-
81
tions as to the effect of the flushing in removing the
flecculent material from the Pool had not been realized.
Mr. Andrew felt that he had been mistaken in his esti-
mate as to the character and extent of the flocculent
material and had thought that there was more light
material that would be carried through readily at ex-
tremely low velocities. Mr. Ramey thought it was be-
cause there had been “such a tremendous quantity of
material scoured out ‘of the main channel above the
Brandon Road Pool and not scoured out as quickly as
hoped”, which had retarded the movement through the
Pool. Dr. Mohiman had hoped that there would: be more
localized velocity. Mr. Howson thought that the trouble
was due to the fact that the material was 4 or 5 times
as dense as he had expected.
The result seems to indicate the degree of uncer-
tainty which must attend all expert opinion, even where
it is in accord.
Opinions differed as to the results accomplished
by the flushing experiment. All witnesses agreed
that taking the stream as a whole from the peint where
’ the sewage enters the channel through the Brandon Road
Pool, a considerable benefit had been accomplished since
a very considerable amount of deposited material was
taken out of the Waterway between these points. All wit-
nesses also agreed that the effect of the extensive scour-
ing out of the channel above the Brandon Road Pool
should have a beneficial effect on the conditions in the
Pool“ since the water in the upper stretches of the
Waterway would come to the Pool removed from the
effect of the sludge deposits which had been swept out,
and therefore richer +r oxygen content. Mr. Huvuwson
felt that this would offset the disadvantage of the deposit
in the Pool of the material which had been brought down
¢
82
from the upper stretches. Mr. Ramey and Dr. Mohlman
conceded a beneficial effect from the relative purifica®
tion of the water above the Pool, but Dr. Mohlman was
doubtful whether this would offset the effect of the addi-
tional material deposited in the Pool, The difficulty of
prognostication is indicated by the fact that the dissolved
oxygen at Lockport in January, 1941, is less than it was
in 1940, notwithstanding the fact that the flushing ex-
periment’ scoured out of the channel at Lockport so much
of the material that had been accumulated at and above
that point. During the experimental flow and for about
a week thereafter dissolved oxygen at Lockport was
considerably in excess of the year before, but thereafter
the dissolved oxygen declined.
If the flushing experiment should in fact prove to
have made the conditions in the Pool any more unfavor-
able in 1941 than they would otherwise have been, the
rights of Illinois should not be enlarged or those of the
opposing States diminished by that fact, as it was under-
stood that the experiment was for the benefit of Illinois
and should not prejudice the opposing States in any way,
and counsel for those States agreed to the flushing upon
that understanding. Illinois had all the chance of gain
by the additional diversion, to which the opposing States
consented for the ten day period of the test, and it took
whatever risks were involved. The additional water
which during the test came through the wheels of the
Sanitary District powerhouse at Lockport generated pow-
er worth $12,500, of which the District had the benefit.
Chlorination of Waterway
The opposing States urged the use of chlorine to
eliminate the odors complained of at Lockport and Joliet.
On this point their leading witness was Mr. Linn H.
83
Enslow, a sanitary engineer and chemist, editor of a
trade magazine known as “Waterworks and Sewage”,
and consultant and adviser of the Chlorine Institute,
which is composed of chlorine manufacturers. He is a
graduate of the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and at-
tended Johns Hopkins University for two years; he is a
member of various professional societies and has partici-
pated in numerous studies of the use of chlorine.
Mr. Enslow said that the sludge condition at Bran-
don Pool presented “a bad situation”. By that he said
he meant that it might require from three to four times
as much chlorine to do the same work than if the sludge
were not there. He favored the use of chlorine at the
Southwest plant and also at Lockport. He thought 3
p.p.m. would be sufficient at the former point, but 6
p.p.m. would be required at Lockport, although 3 might
be enough. These estimates were based on the assump-
tion that no new deposits of sludge came into the Pool.
If sludge continued to go into the Pool, it might take
12 p.p.m. or even More—-“It would be anybody’s guess
"7 * *” “In that situation all you would have would
be a giant septic tank served from Chicago. I would
not know whether it would take 15 parts or 25”.
If the discharge of sludge to the Canal were discon-
tinued by January 1, 1941, Mr. Enslow (testifying in
September, 1940) still thought it would take 3 p.p.m. of
chlorine at Lockport in addition to 3 p.p.m. at the South-
west plant or a total of 6 p.p.m., to relieve the odor con-
ditions at Joliet and it might take more. At one point
he said, “It is a speculation; it is a speculation in any-
body’s sense.”
Mr. Enslow estimated the cost cf chlorination at a
minimum of $700 and a maximum of $3,000 per day,
based upon a unit price of $43.20 a ton; 3 p.p.m.
viene
would be equal to 25 tons. This would have to be con-
tinued through the summer months. In addition to costs
of chlorine, there weuld be a cost for equipment. For
this Mr. Enslow made a “rough estimate” of $85,000,
and thought it would probably cost $115,000 at Chicago
to complete the construction of the necessary plant and
auxiliaries. He recommended one plant at the Southwest
treatment plant and another larger one at Lockport.
Dr. A. M. Buswell, Chief of the Illinois State Water-
way Survey, thought that the sludge in the Brandon Pool
had received undue emphasis from a technical standpoint
in view of its age. He believed an application of 2 to 3
p.p.m. of chlorine below the dam at Lockport costing
from $700 to $1,000 a day over a period of not over 100
days would be sufficient to remove odorous substances.
In the wider portions of the Brandon Pool, which was a
more or less stagnant basin, he thought a chlora-boat
(which would “probably” not cost over $16,000) might
be used to apply 1 p.p.m. per day in that Pool, which
would be adequate there. Thus, it was his “checked opin-
ion” that an average of 3 p.p.m. per day should take
care of the situation if sludge were no longer dis-
charged into the Canal, but if sludge continued to be
discharged, he thought an average of 5 p.p.m. would be
required. Later he estimated that the expenditure of
between $1,000 and $1,200 per day for chlorine for a
summer’s operation would “very largely alleviate the
conditions.” He said that these were estimates only, not
based on accurate survey as he had not expected to tes-
tify with respect to the use of chlorine, but it remained
his opinion that the use of chlorine to the extent indicated
would be as effective as increased diversion in relieving
the odor conditions.
Mr. Joseph W, Ellms, Commissioner of the Division
85
Z
of Sewage Disposal in Cleveland, testified with respect
to the use of chlorine at Cleveland. Mr. Ellms was edu-
cated at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and
has been consultant at various plants. Cleveland has
three sewage treatment plants and a total sewage flow
of about 125 m.g.d., or about one-eighth of that of Chi-
cago. Cleveland discharges its sewage effluents into the
same water from which it draws its water supply (Lake
Erie, directly or through the Cuyahoga River) and has
used chlorine since about 1922 “as a sanitary protection
to a certain extent to the water supply”, but also “to
keep the marginal waters in as clean a condition as
possible during the bathing season and to prevent any
odors which may arise from sewage entering the plants.”
The application has been at the plants, not to the Cuya-
hoga River or to the sewers : atering the river. 5 to 6
tons a day of chlorine are used in all for about 100 days
during the summer months, and the chlorine contracts
generally run from about 1,000,000 to 1,200,000 pounds
per season. Mr. Ellms said that the cost of a 150-ton
plant would be “considerably less than $300,000” and
would take 6 to 7 months to build. He agreed that
it would be better to apply chlorine before septic condi-
tions had developed and it would be helpful to apply
it in several places rather than one since the effi-
cacy of chlorine wears off. Mr: Ellms was familiar
generally with the Sanitary Canal and the Brandon
Pool and thought that chlorine- “could reduce, perhaps
eliminate”, the odors from hydrogen sulphide that may be
produced as a result of decomposition of organic matter
in the Brandon Road Pool, “but the continuous feeding
in that Pool of partially decomposed organic matter is
going to provide a continuing source of hydrogen sul-
phide, which is, perhaps, the chief cause for complaints
at, in and around that Pool.” pe
86
Mr. Warrick, the State Sanitary Engineer of Wis-
consin, testified that he believed chlorination “would
have a decided beneficial effect” upon the Waterway.
He said it was not possible to determine how long the
effect of chlorine would last as this would depend upon
sludge, temperature and other conditions. “As a very
rough statement” he though the effect of chlorine applied
at the Southwest plant might last as much as half an
hour, but it might last two hours or “considerably longer”.
This also would be true of its application at other points,
From the standpoint of Brandon Pool, the most benefi-
cial effect would be chlorination at or above the Pool, but
it would also be advantageous to put in chlorine at sev-
eral places above the Pool.
Mr. Howson, the chief expert witness for the Oppos-
ing States, testified generally to the opinion that chlor-
ination “is a very effective and positive method of con-
trolling odors”, and that he believed it would be prac-
tical and effective to relieve the conditions complained of
at Joliet and Lockport. However, his testimony on the
subject of chlorination was based chiefly on that of Mr.
Enslow. He calculated that 6 p.p.m. of chlorine would
remove a total of 200,000 lbs. of B.O.D. at Lockport.
The cost of installing chlorinating equipment at two
points (as recommended by Mr. Enslow), one of 25 ton
capacity near the Southwest plant and the other of 50 ton
capacity near the Lockport powerhouse, would aggregate
$360,000. Construction would require from 6 to 9 months.
The cost of operation would range from $70,000 to
$300,000 for the summer months. He said this was a
range of figures given by Mr. Enslow, the application
of which would depend upon the quantity of chlorine
used. The $300,000 was figured on the continuous appli-
cation of 9 p.p.m. of chlorine over a 100-day period.
12 p.p.m. would cost one-third more, or $400,000. It
seems clear that these estimates are very rough.
87
The witnesses for Illinvis testified that the must
important use of chlorine was to protect drinking water
by destruction of bacteria. They said that they had
never given any consideration to its use for that purpose
and were not concerned with it because no community
along the Waterway used any water from it for drinking.
The Illinois experts conceded that chlorine is in many
situations effectively used to prevent odors. The Sani-
tary District uses it to a limited extent in two of its
small plants for odor control and also uses a small quan-
tity at the Southwest plant, where, however, there is
little or no trouble with odors. But, in view of the large
accumulations of sludge from past deposits of partially
treated sewage and the continued deposit of only partially
treated sewage, they were of the opinion that chlorine
could not be effectively used in the Waterway to elim-
inate the odor conditions complained of by the residents
of Joliet, even if large quantities were used at great
expense,
Dr. Mohlman testified that he had made studies of
the use of chlorine fourteen or fifteen years ago and had
made chlorine demand tests in the Canal in July, 1940.
Laboratory tests could not be depended upon for results
in practice. In view of the
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.