Joint Abstract of Record — Wisconsin v. Illinois
Supreme Court brief1940
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
Nos. 2, 3 anp 4, Oricran.
Octoser Term, 46719 46
STATES OF WISCONSIN, MINNESOTA,
OHIO and PENNSYLVANIA,
Complainants,
v8.
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO,
Defendants.
STATE OF MICHIGAN,
Complainant,
v8.
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO, et al.,
Defendants.
STATE OF NEW YORK,
Complainant,
v8,
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO, et al.,
Defendants.
s
f No, 2 Original.
4
’
+ No. 3 Original.
wt.
. No. 4 Original.
JOINT ABSTRACT OF RECORD.
Votume II.
EXHIBITS.
Filed April 30, 1941.
THE GUNTHORP. WARREN PRINTING COMPANY, 210 WEST JACKSON,
2
Crrcaso
INDEX.
Illinois Exhibits
Numbers | Pages
4 Index Map of Illinois Waterway............ 3
5 Base Map of Sanitary District Showing Chan-
nels, Sewers and Sewage Treatment Works 4
10-D Future Construction Program—aAs of 6/1/40 7
10-E Futypre Contracts as of 1/14/41: NEES 7 Pe 8
10-F Future Construction Program as of 1/14/41.. 9
11-A Flow in Main Drainage Channel, yearly aver-
DS Ee cere ay ee 10
16 Report on Additions to Southwest Sewage
Treatment Works and Supplemental Treat-
ment for West Side Sewage Treatment
Works April 16, 1900... o66.6666 Ses 56s wee 10
17 Copy of keport of PWA Review Board to
Joshua D’Esposito, Resident Projects En-
gineer of PWA, Dated May 3, 1940....... 23
18 Letter—Woodhull from D’Esposito.,....... 27
23 Southwest Sewage Treatment Works, Flow
B.0O.D., D.O. and Suspended Solids, 1939-40 28
27-A North Side Sewage Treatment Works, Sum-
mary of Results of Opereztion—1929-1940.. 28
28-A Calumet Sewage Treatment Works, Summary
of Results of Operation—1936-1940....... 29
29-A West Side Sewage Treatment Works—Sum-
mary of Results of Operation—1931-1940.. 30
31 Table of Analysis and Chart Dissolved Oxygen
and Oxygen Demands Monthly Averages,
Locks, Mouth of Chicago River Station.... 30
33
34
37-A
li
Table of Analysis and Chart Dissolved Oxygen
and Oxygen Demands Monthly Averages—
Damen Ave. Station.................0.05.
Table of Analysis and Chart Dissolved Oxygen
and Oxygen Demands Monthly Averages—
SE INE) are cdiciche wk Oona wee eee
Table of Analysis and Charts Dissolved Oxygen
and Oxygen Demands Monthly Averages—
RINE CII ove ecko ib cdnc vueeeeiewus
Graph, ‘‘Main Channel at Lockport (292 Miles
from Grafton Ferry; 35 Miles from Lake
Michigan)’’, showing 5-Day B.O.D., D.O.,
Temperature of Water, Discharge........
Map of the City of Joliet...................
Main Channel Discharge at Lockport by
Monthly Averages for Years 1938-39-40...
- Chart: Main Channel Half-hour Discharge at
Lockport on 15th of each month 1939-40....
North Side Sewage Treatment Works—Flow,
B.0.D., D.O. and Suspended Solids........
Calumet Sewage Treatment Works-—Flow,
B.O.D., D.O. and Suspended Solids, 1940..
West Side Sewage Treatment Works, Flow,
B.O.D., D.O. and Suspended Solids, 1940....
Sonthwest Sewage Treatment Works, Flow,
B.0.D., D.O. and Suspended Solids, 1940...
Diversion from Lake Michigan—Monthly Dis-
charge for Respective Years—1938-39-40. .
Analyses of Samples from Main Channel and
Illinois River—Average Monthly Results,
Sept.-Dec., 1940 (Completes Data in Record,
Exhibits 31 to 36 and page 1840)
31
32
33
47
iii
ie
Mohlman Exhibits
14-D
14-E
17
18-A,
Determination of Chlorine Demand—Main
Channel—July 2 & 3, 1940....:...........
Editorial: ‘‘Oxygen Demand of Sludge De-
ee Satass SARE Fe go gee tg oe
Basis for Estimating Additional Diversion
be ee ne
WE e oc Cer Cs Weel b es ees Tier ee anes
Table II—Proposed Increase of Diversion—
Actual Increase to be Modified in Accord-
ance with Results of Sanitary District An-
alyses Submitted to U. S. Engineers—-Year
1941—Cubie Feet Per Second.............
Table I1I—Proposed Increase of Diversion--
Actual Increase to be Modified in -Accord-
ance with Results of Sanitary District An-
alyses Submitted to TU. S Engineer—Year
1942—Cubice Feet Per Second............
Basis for Estimating Additional Diversion
Needed in Summer for Ameliorating Con-
ditions in Brandon Pool, by F. W. Mohlman
Report on The Flushing Experiment An-
thorized by the United States Supreme
Court—Made to the Honorable Monte M.
Lemann, Special Master, by F. W.* Mohl-
man, Director of Laboratories, The San-
itary District of Chicago, January 13, 1941
Report on Analyses of Samples from Main
B,C,D Channel, Lockport to Summit, Month of
20
oamanry, THEO TIRE. is ie beahieess
Main Channel and Illinois River, Dissolved
Oxygen and Oxygen Demands, Station Lock-
port; Dates: January, 1941..............
57
58
58
81
oe Ge Cannes ar ausauem. e
iv j
“Pearse Exhibits
1-A Activated Sludge Sewage Treatment Works
oe Record of Air Used—Cubic Feet Per Gal-
lon of Sewage-Nitrites and Nitrates —
p.p.m. Average for Year 1928-1940........
7 Population in Sanitary District of Chicago
for 1940 and its probable Distribution to
Major Treatment Works of Sanitary Dis-
RE a ey ee
14 Sanitary District of Chicago—West-South-
91
91
west Sewage Treatment Works Extension .
Scheme A-II—General Layout — April,
BO SSN as oe eae noes Tae od ays awe
Ramey Exhibits
2 Time of Flow from Damen Ave. to Brandon
Es re so ees ou eee ie oe wes
Opponent’s Exhibits
6 Chart, ‘‘Communicable Diseases, Cases and
Deaths in Joliet and Will County’’........
7 Letter dated January 6, 1940, to Mayor, City
of Joliet, from Frank Witic, City Sanitar-
a hi eke EOE ey REE FA Cee dees cea
7 Analysis of Air in Vicinity of J aan
10 Sources of Oxygen for Prevention of Com-
plaints from Brandon Pool...............
11 Means of Reducing B.O.D. Load to Canal to
Ameliorate or Remedy Conditions Com-
plained of at Brandon’s Pool.............
12 Estimated cost of Measures to Alleviate or
Remedy Conditions Complained of at Bran-
I Ne ae cee a at
~“43 Sources of D.O. and B.O.D. of Canal at Lock-
WONG ioe Canvas Weaeaeiccsureveessegeeses
93
95
96
97
99
103
14
15
23
24
30
v
Sources of Dissolved Oxygen and B.O.D. at
Lockport. Average of June, July, August. .
Report of Dr. M. Start Nichols to Mr. Naujoks,
in re Joliet, Ill. Air and Water Pollution,
GROG TO Be MIS oiocae's s vvn clos nc kn
Reported Cases and Deaths from Commun-
icable Diseases, Will County and State of
Illinois, 1930-1939—Taken from Annual Re-
ports, Illinois Department of Public Health
Comparison of Communicable Cases and
Deaths of Will County, reported in Annual
Reports of Illinois Department of Public
Health—Compared with Total Cases of such
Diseases so Reported by State of Illinois. .
Letter from American Hospital Association,
signed by Dr. W. P. Morrill, on Average
Hospital Stay at St. Joseph’s Hospital fer
year 1939, and Average Stay of Patients
Admitted to General Hospitals in United
ee geen se wid
Andrew Exhibits
1
Photograph: Aerial View of Brandon Pool
et anit ca dyes cose shaw koe re
Howson Exhibit
6
Analysis of Pearse Exhibit 61A............
108
117
121
125
—_—___e seein
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
Nos. 2, 3 anp 4, Ortemvan,.
Octosgr Trrm, 1940.
STATES OF WISCONSIN, MINNESOTA,
OHIO and PENNSYLVANIA,
Complainants,
ve.
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO,
Defendants.
STATE OF MICHIGAN,
Complainant,
v8.
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO, et al.,
Defendants.
STATE OF NEW YORK,
Complainant,
v8.
STATE OF ILLINOIS and THE SANITARY
DISTRICT OF CHICAGO, ¢t al.,
Defendants. ]
> No. 2 Original.
\
> No. 4 Original.
JOINT ABSTRACT OF RECORD.
Vouume II.
EXHIBITS.
PREFACE.
The petitioner and respondents have endeavored to
set out, for the convenience of the Court, such portions
of the exhibits in these causes deemed material for
meee ne ewe, .
2
due consideration of the Court of the issues raised by
the petition of the State of Illinois and the return of
the opposing Great Lake States. It is agreed, how-
ever, that either party may, in oral argument or in
briefs, refer to any other exhibits appearing in the
record and not contained herein.
WAR DEPARTMENT
* be! vee
% Dow. %&,
7 ‘
ILLINOIS EXHIBIT WO. 4 REC. P.?
ILLINOIS WATERWAY
INDEX MAP
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS DISTRICT.
VU SCNGMEER OFFICE, CHICAGO. kimom. =) 20, oe
raw
—— ——_——— = =
TLLDOIS EXRISIT WO. S REC. P. 6
THE SANITARY DISTRICT OF CHICAGO
Showing
CHANNELS, SEWERS
AND
Ws SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS
>. ae Chicago, III. January 1849
n. Scale in miles
conan __o J \\ | —_—— ee
év. ON PS.
MORTON y
} LEGEND
SEWERS AND TREATMENT WORKS
@mme COMPLETED
, B68 FUTURE WORK
Y
44
. ' ~
xi >
ieee
~ Pg " EX kA
fx By cHicaco RIVER .
hak |e (que. CONTROLLING
Tae r co
& lz - a
: a
BS =
b a
2
.
ros 3?
LT CREEK INT. SEW. .
B WESTERN
SPRINGS P'S.
DISTRICT
SANITARY
3858
State or Inuwors Exuterr No. i0-D.
THE SANITARY DISTRICT OF CHICAGO.
Future Construction Program:
As of June 1, 1940:
27 existing contracts
Future contracts
Total
Sludge concentration tanks.
Oil storage tanks
Total completed :
Total future, as of January 14, 1941....
Under contract:
North Side Project—
Golf and Glenview sewers
Emerson Street sewer
Southwest Side Project—
Racine Avenue Pump. Sta. Pumps
Sewer controls, Salt Creek, etc
West-Southwest Treatment Plant—
Blowers
Conveyor tunnels
whi den nd edt Be RSS POE CP ee
eeeeeerveeeccesce
eee eee eevee
TRU PCIE CRE CS.0& ot 6's 0 6.6
eR Cee Oe ¢ ees
eeoeoeeeeeceseocesee
eeereceereeeesse
eeeeeeeceresresreeces
eens
ee ee ey
re
SCeoeceoeeeceeoseeseussecne
CED Cos visited Sowrso ek:
$2,003,000
Total under contract (some of which has been
SEY “sna dicehede ened ots sc oedoliciccs
titi teitt tote tee eee Pa ee ee
TEAS OMENS OO OU. 2 8 CSCO OOO eT OS Sb CRS
$ 912,192
12,056,900
1,212,192
$11,756,900
SPO AMIS SAPO 28 1 Te TTS SRL LP PY ep ey van Pe Pwr eae, Se.
3859 State or Iturnots Exursir No. 10-E.
Tue Sanitary District or CHIcaco.
‘ Future Contracts, as of January 14, 1941:
Calumet Project—
Additional sludge handl gauipment...... $ 250,000
Preliminary settling tanks................. 100,000
Stony Island Avenue sewers............... 260,000 $ 610,000
North Side Project—
North Side sewer siphons.............. TrTe ' 103,000
Southwest Side Project—
Racine Ave. Pump. Sta., roads, grounds, ete.
WUE SbedBeswedeseecevalsesecucteceeyes 100,000
West-Southwest Treatment Plant—
Final settling tanks, Bat. A & B............ $1, = 700**
Sludge concentration tanks................ *
» Aeration tanks, Battery C................. .93 ,600
Final tanks, Battery C.................... 1,256,200
CIPI SUI “OOo ccs cccccccccecee 682,600
Substructure, blower plant.............. ... 200,000**
Substructure, sludge handling plant........ 450,000**
Blower plant, remainder................... 452,800
Sludge handling plant, remainder.......... 1,679,400
Rn, ML GIL hi cove ca eccvaceveveus 90,600
EE Ci ce edentawae oudkO0 0 ous be 449,000*
Screenings, scum & grit removal, ete. bi etinnes 365,200
WEE Wadlanichb owes succeeuudetesckedouces 8,551,900
$ 9,364,900
* To be advertised for bids January 24, 1941.
** $1,870,500 to be let before March 31, 1941.
LE LE PONE RY AAO MALE IF GRE ARE (CRIS RT 9 DO NPE NAR INY S OT NMEA Fh POL Ct ALENT Art Ot na ANY OGE Sp nag hth) hen opey eens cepa enpertnns
aldhindls “nb dialed lelaledded
th NA atl il nce onc nil als at
** Work to be let in near future.
9
State or Inurois Exursit No. 10-F.
Future Construcrion Procram—As oF
January 14, 1941.
As of ;
June 1,1940 Asof January 14, 1941
Ex. Under
1-A,B,C Contract Future
Calumet Project: b.
Additional sludze handling
rc aie: $ 250,000 $ 250,000
Preliminary settling tanks.... 100,000 100,000
Sludge concentration tanks
ok ER a eae 27,000 $ 27,000"
Oil storage tanks WPA....... 25,000 25,000*
Cal-Beverly drop connection
WE WineWavbceGuncke cés sx 17,000 17,000*
Stony Island Ave, sewer...... 260,000 260,000
$ 679,000 $ 69,000 $ 610,000
North Side Project:
North Side sewer siphons..... $ 103,000 $ 103,000
Golf and Glenview sewers.... 200,000 $ 200,000
Emerson St. sewer, etc. WPA.. 66,000 66,000
$ 369,000 $ 266,000 $ 103,000
Southwest Side Project:
Racine Ave. P. S., 2 pumps...$ 100,000 $ 700,000
Racine Ave. P. §S., roads,
BOI. WER. cihcccccccecs 100,000 $ 100,000
Norwood Park sewer WPA... 31,000 31,000*
Sewer controls, Salt Creek &
WE ENE odes uw shou sens 23,000 23,000
$ 254,000 $ 154,000 $ 100,000
West-Southwest Treatment Plant:
Final tanks, Bat. A. & B...... $ 1,059,700 $1,059,700**
Aeration tanks, Battery C.... 1,714,600 1,714,600
Final tanks, Battery C........ 1,256,200 1,256,200
Conduits, tunnels, ete......... 757,600 $ 75,000 682,600
Sludge concentration tanks... 160,800 160,800**
Blower Plant:
MIN. du wei be Bio's oc ova e's 280,000 544,000
Substructure ............., 200,000 200,000* *
Remainder ................ 716,800 452,800
Sludge Handling Plant:
Equipment ....... Revduenes 590,000 703,000
Substructure .......... -+++ 450,000 450,000**
ey ee 2,473,400 681,000 1,679,400
Roads, grounds, etc........... 90,600 90,600
Fertilizer ‘plant ...... waveense 440,000 440,000**
Screenings, scum &. grit re-
SE SY. 68 own KK Ook-e Cokes 365,200 365,200
$10,554,900 $2,003,000 $8,551,900
Chicago River Controlling Works :
Addition to breakwater enclo-
ME acvgerledaweeviondvd ous -$ 200,000 ¢ 200,000*
nn dibanéetesabas eye . «+. $12,056,900. $2,692,000 $9,364,900
* Work completed.
nn ee
3631
95
96
10
Tuuinois Exurisir No. 114A.
Firow in Main DrarnacGe CHANNEL.
Yearly Averages 1930-1940.
Total Flow Infiow Domestic
from Main from Pumpage Net
Channel Des- Chicago Diversion
at Plaines Metropoli- from Lake
Lockport River tanArea Michigan
Year C.F.S. C.F.S. C.F.S. C.F.S.
1930 6 mo. (Jan. to June).. 8500 0 1680 6820
193° 6 mo. (July to Dee.).. 8216 0 1719 6497
SEE Cae er Uv anne sw ovawer uns 8180 0 1680 6500
BE avbvak vatsbne sede wens 8100 2 1650 6450
SN ak ee Varo cx edu VeeecKen 8005 45 1690 6270
St kbc dinnsvaueenwacse ae 8125 0 1692 6433
Tet toed oeeee ur eawats 8093 7 1602 6484
Se odie eae eee ae } 6607 33 1712 4862
BE Avevarcukhueikuneuadens \* 6677 23 1665 4289
MS akce neces cieeeeeneenes 6648 45 1604 4999
Cs Sines ween bude unease 3132 13 1620 1499
MO isc kde eed tate t ven 3319 49 1589 1681
* Includes 10-day test flow period.
Mr. William H. Trinkaus,
Chief Engineer,
The Sanitary District of Chicago,
Office.
Dear Sir:
At your request, we are presenting herewith a brief
report covering the necessary work required to com-
plete the Southwest Sewage Treatment Works and to
supplement the present West Side Works by addi-
State or Inuinois Exursit No. 16.
REPORT ON
ADDITIONS TO
Soutuwest Sewace TREATMENT Works
AND SuPPLEMENTAL TREATMENT FOR
West Sinz Sewace TREATMENT Works
April 16, 1940.
April 16, 1940.
11
tional treatment. Necessarily, this involves considera-
tion of these two plants as a whole. Consequently
the estimates have been based on a combined total
flow of 900 m.g.d. and the assumption that flows up to
150 per cent of average will be intercepted, but only
115 per cent of the average will be given complete
treatment.
Fiows:
The present sewage flows to the respective treat-
ment plants are somewhat less than originally esti-
mated in 1934. The future flows will depend on popu-
lation growth, the extent of metering, and the rate at
which meters are installed. For present conditions
(1940), the flow is estimated as follows:
Sew*ge Flow in M. G. D.
Tributary Area Avg. Max. (150% Avg.)
Mice i nddknne Gd oir etn bie e kine 400 600
i motte tees e eee eens @2 93
ISL a Se ae Ga SO tire 394 591
a, SS es Tics ee 856 1,284
Seasonal Variations in the average monthly flow
may occur approximately 87 to 117 per cent of the
average month, judging from the West Side record.
Pumpine Capacity:
The installed rated pumping capacity at the two
works is as follows:
Units
Capacity
Total
Works Number C.F.S. M.G.D. M.G.D.
, 0 Ee ee 2 100 65 130
: 5 200 129 645
Se 4 300 194 775
>
98
LE AE ESA EEO, WNT
12
The present hydraulic capacity of the West Side
Works does not exceed 700 m.g.d.
Erect oF METERING:
The population on the West-Southwest area may
grow moderately, but the flow may tend to decrease
somewhat, should universal metering occur. Conse-
quently, 900 m.g.d. seems a reasonable figure to adopt,
for the average flow to the combined plants, with
484 m.g.d: apportioned to the West Side-Salt Creek
area, and 416 m.g.d. to the Southwest. —
For the present, it is proposed to provide complete
treatment for only 115 per cent of the average flow,
and to care for flows between 115 and 150 per cent of
average by settling only in the existing Imhoff tanks.
Later on, when the flows are more exactly known, and
the rate of metering is indicated, consideration can
be given to the expansion of capacity to 150 per cent,
if need be.
These studies of treatment for the combined West-
Southwest sewage are therefore based on the follow-
ing flows:
Average for complete treatment...:...... 900 m.g.d.
Maximum for complete treatment......... 1035 m.g.d.
Maximum intercepted ..........-.---+-5+ 1350 m.g.d.
a eee eee ree ene 315 m.g.d.
PoPpuLATION :
Population estimates are based on the 1930 esti-
mates of the Sanitary District. However, in 1937,
some estimates prepared by the Chicago Regional Plan
Commission indicated a total population of the Sani-
tary District for 1940 about 90 per cent of the 1930
estimate. However, these two estimates indicate, over
the next twenty years, a possible growth in the Sani-
tary District as a whole ranging for 29 to 334 per
13
cent of the 1940 population. The 1940 census will
shed some light on the probable trend.
STRENGTH oF SEWAGE:
As yet, complete analyses of the Southwest sewage
are not available. It should prove stronger than the
West Side, both in B.O.D. and suspended solids, be-
cause of the Packingtown wastes. There will also be
greater hourly fluctuations through the 24 hours of
the day, as well as throughout the week.
For the purpose of design, the following averages
were used:
Parts Per Million
Source Susp. Solids 5-Day B.O.D.
West Side, raw sewage............ 120 95
West Side, Imhoff effluent......... 60 57
Southwest, raw sewage............ 170 145
Sotip Loap:
The solids arriving at the West-Southwest Works
are estimated to total 1,301,000 lbs. per day in 1940, and
1,626,000 Ib. in 1960. Included in these figures are
the North Side and the Packinghouse solids, which
should be handled at the Southwest Works.
SLupce Capacity oF ImHorr TANKs anp Dryine BeEps:
The existing Imhoff tanks have a total sludge diges-
tion volumes as follows:
as Sludge Digestion
Battery Cu. Ft.
BO se ce cick busiewunice duce wane eed 3,091,000
PA TREATS en Ba Cs BM Ope ed 3,091,000
| SRS els AE 5 ceed CE at 4,350,000
NR ERD ee fe REY SEF Sa Yn wae oe ee PO 10,532,000
The filtering area of the sludge beds totals 1,190,240
square feet. .
A
14
In all the schemes for which estimates were pre-
pared, this sludge digestion volume would probably
be adequate, including chemical treatment and filtra-
tion through fine grained filters. The existing drying
beds are inadequate, exeept for plain sedimentation.
100 EXPERIMENTAL Work:
From 1936 to 1939, various procedures were studied
to determine their value for supplementing the West
Side Works. Included were:
(a) Activated sludge process-short period aera-
tion.
(b) Chemical precipitation.
(c) Filtration on fine grain filters.
(d) Aeration with iron salts.
(e) High-rate trickling filters, single stage-Halvor-
son type.
(f) High-rate trickling filters, two-stage bio-filter
Jenks type.
The results of these tests have been analyzed, and
applied in the consideration of various alternative
procedures of varying efficiency, as measured by the
quality of effluent.
EstTIMATEs:
Detailed estimates were made on two schemes for
the activated sludge process; chemical precipitation;
and the filtration by fine grained filters of plain set-
> tled effluent and chemical precipitation effluent. Scru-
tiny of the remaining procedures eliminated aeration
with iron salts and high-rate trickling filters of both
types, as too expensive for the results obtained.
On the alternatives estimated in detail, the first
cost, operating cost, and total annual cost (including
interest and depreciation) were determined for com-
15
parison. Filtration on fine grain filters was elim-
inated at this stage because of the high cost, for the
relatively small benefit gained.
101 Stanparp oF Erritvuent Requirep:
“s
In the choice of procedure, the degree of effiuent
required hinges on the conditions to be maintained in
the Illinois Waterway. In the testimony given in the
socalled Lake level case, the tentative standard set by
various witnesses would seem to require at least 3
parts per million of dissolved oxygen in the Des
Plaines and Illinois Rivers. The maintenance of free-
dom from odor in the absence of sludge banks re-
quires the presence of some dissolved oxygen. The
margin of safety between complete de-oxygenation
and the presence of appreciable dissolved oxygen can-
not be estimated in operation so closely as to make it
possible to adjust the dilution so that 1 or 2 parts per
million of dissolved oxygen will always be present.
To maintain a factor of safety in preventing nuisance,
a minimum of 3 parts per million is required. This
may also serve to maintain f h life, although many
authorities now recommend somewhat higher figures,
such as 5 parts per million, because as low as 3 parts
per million presents practically no factor of safety for
fish life.
CoNTINGENCIES OvtTstpDE CONTROL OF THE SANITARY
District:
In studying the problem of maintaining the Illinois
waterway in a suitable condition, a number of unknown
factors, or contingencies, appear which are beyond the
control of the Sanitary District, such as—
(a) The development of water power wil! prac-
tically stop all reaeration of dams. Such reaeration is
of value in the self-purification of the Waterway. The
utilization of the power at Brandon Road and Dresden
16
Island would materially affect the condition of the
Waterway above Marseilles Dam.
102. (b) The effect of an ice sheet on reaeration is as
yet undetermined. The earlier data indicated that in
severe winters considerably more flow may be re-
quired than in normal summer conditions. Recent
data is somewhat at variance. However, extreme win-
ters occur but seldom
(c) The diversion allotted may be changed. The
. possibility of any further reduction in diversion ap-
pears remote. ad ;
(d) The growth of population and industry within
. the area of the Sanitary District.
(e) The requirements laid down for stream condi-
tions by authorities having jurisdiction thereover. At
present the power of regulation rests in the State of
Illinois. In the near future, judging from legislation
now proposed in Congress, control may be’ given also
to a Federal authority.
(f) The general trend of regulation seems to point
toward more vigorous standards for the sanitary con-
dition of waterways than was the case ten or twenty
years ago.
DIveErsIon :
The allowed diversion is an annual average flow of
1,500 c.f.s. To budget the flow over the year means
that for at least six months a diversion of 800 c.f.s.
may be in use. In general, this reduces the amount of
flow from Lake Michigan during the warmer months
of the year, at a time when the dissolved oxygen con-
tent of the lake water is lowest.
Court REQUIREMENTS:
In the hearings before the Special Master, Hon.
Charles E. Hughes, the Sanitary District indicated
that it expected to install works which would provide
an over-all efficiency of 85 per cent or better, on an
| .
annual average basis. In the opinion of the Supreme
Court (April 14, 1930), Justice Holmes states:
103 ‘‘The Master estimates that with efficient operation
the proposed treatment should reach an average of
85 per cent purification and probably will be 90 per
cent or more.’’
Oxycen Balance:
In a study of the oxygen balance in the Upper Jlli-
nois Waterway based on a diversion of 800 €.FS.
(such as may occur for at least 6 months per year),
with 500 m.g.d. passing through the Southwest Works
and receiving activated sludge tteatment, it appears
that a treatment greater than 82 per cent is reqnired
as an overall for the 400 m.g.d. passing through the
West Side Works, and that supplemental treatment
for the Imhoff tank effluent, making an overall puri-
fication of 90 per cent or better is required at the
West Side, to maintain 3 parts per million of dissolved
| oxygen.
SEASONAL EFFECT:
There is also a seasonal effect of importance from
two angles—first, the amount of dissolved oxygen
which can be introduced into the canal system by the
diversion 4rom Lake Michigan, and, second, the tem-
perature of the lake water and effluents and mixtures
thereof, in so far as temperature affects the rate of
satisfaction of B.O.D.
The temperature of Lake Michigan may vary from
32 deg. Fahr. in winter to 72 deg. Fahr. in summer,
with corresponding content of dissolved oxygen at
saturation, varying from 8.8 to 14.6 parts per million.
° ‘The rate of satisfaction of B.O.D. is slower at lower
temperatures and thus permits a longer time of flow,
and consequently greater effect of reaeration.
104 Aside from the effect of an ice sheet over the water-
LPL EL 2 SRG SY ATT Te mR TRENT Reet CRI Ln ge ee We Sa ee es
18
way, the above seasonal occurrences would point to
the need of the greatest reduction in B.O.D. during
the summer months. Again, this corresponds, in gen-
eral with the periods of lower diversions.
Liurts or CHorce:
The promises to the Supreme Court and its under-
standing of the program proposed, together with the
physical limitations on the problem in the Illinois
Waterway, clearly point to the need of ability in the
supplemental treatment of the effluent of the West
Side Works to produce a high-grade effluent such as
only an activated sludge plant can deliver.
For such purpose, chemical precipitation as a sup-
plement to the Imhoff tank treatment does not go far
enough. An estimate of the residual B.O.D. would
indicate—
5-Day B.O.D. 1x Erruvenrt.
5-Day B.O.D
Treatment p.p.m
Ee ES SER EE a ee. aan 57
Imhoff plus chemical a Se eel 38
hn an agin a Wadiciives waa bbe acide as 10
To meet the critical seasonal periods and the future
contingencies, a process is required to supplement the
Imhoff effluent which will deliver an effluent contain-
ing only 10 p.p.m. B.O.D.
105 The percentage reduction for the combined West-
Southwest Works with the following combinations is
estimated as follows:
Per Cent Reduction
Treatment—West-Southwest Susp. Solids 5-Day B.0.D.
Activated Sludge—Imhoff Tanks....... 76.7 73.7
Activated Sludge—Chemical Ppn. ...... 81.9 81.7
” Activated Sludge—All Plants .......... 915 916
19
QUESTION oF PoLicy: »
The question of policy concerned rests on the fact
that to satisfy the Court and complaining municipali-
ties along the Illinois Waterway, the Sanitary District
must act. The time for experiment or delay has
passed, if financing can be arranged. Consequently,
there is no opportunity for a tryout of the Southwest
activated sludge works with the West Side Imhoff
Works left as they are now, to test accomplishment.
Whatever is done must be adequate, with certainty.
In the choice of plant types, the development of a
uniform type of plant along activated sludge lines
seems better from an operating standpoint than to
introduce another and third type of plant for sewage
treatment into the works at the Stickney site.
ApvANTAGE oF ACTIVATED SLUDGE:
There is another advantage in the choice of acti-
vated sludge for supplementing the West Side Imhoff
plant, namely, the possibility of some revenue from
the sale of heat-dried activated sludge. Such a sup-
plemental plant may produce around 29,000 tons of
dried sludge annually suitable for sale as fertilizer ma-
106 terial. If that portion produced in eight months of
the year (19,500 tons) is sold, nets the Sanitary Dis-
trict a return of $4.00 per ton, a substantial revenue
would be obtained ($78,000). No such possibility is
inherent in any other alternative now available.
Operatinc Cost CONTINGENCIES :
Apparently the contingency of fluctuating labor
costs affects all alternatives. However, the added
labor cost for the 400 m.g.d. from the West Side will
activated sludge treatment.
For the activated sludge treatment, the other main
be $39,000 greater for chemical precipitation than for
Sale Ladeetomiaietle
107
itv seieiNeihetitiaaiiahataanacdliitalali the deed nada sh tMaltucs dies siabae bane eddiman sad’ ceca mation bart etiaeen aca eaie Se
20
items of cost are for coal and ferric chloride, totaling
$126,000, whereas for the chemical treatment, the cost
of chemicals is estimated at $331,000, or $205,000 more
than in the activated sludge alternative.
Thus on the main items of operating cost the extent
of fluctuation may be much greater on the chemical
treatment than fer activated sludge.
Costs CoMPARED:
From the foregoing, it is clear that the comparison
narrows down to two quite different schemes of dif-
ferent accomplishment, for supplementing the West
Side Imhoff tanks, namely: Activated Sludge as
against Chemical Precipitation. The plans proposed
for both alternatives include the increase in the capac-
ity of the Southwest Works to 500 m.g.d. on an ueti-
vated sludge basis.
The first costs on a complete ens are given in the
following table:
First Cost.
Extension Extension
Procedure for Addition SW Worksto West Side to Total for
to West Side 500 m.g.d. 400 m.g.d. 900 m.g.d.
Activated Sludge............ $3,879,800 $5,869,000 $9,749,700
Chemical Precipitation...... 3,879,800 1,300,500 5,180,300
If a comparison be made on the basis of adding
sufficient activated sludge treatment to produce a 5-day
B.0.D. discharge equivalent to thet derived from treat-
ing 400 m.g.d. by chemicai treatment, a capacity for
treatment of only 180 m.g.d. by activated sludge would
be needed, with the following results:
First Cost.
Extension West Side m.g.d. Cost
rr re 2.8 os ratedaver den ekecenrs 400 $1,300,500
MCE HI ioc oe cw ecnv'p ee asioe ead bvae peere es 180 3,662,000
Senn ante rf
k
‘This would materially reduce the annual cost of
activated sludge, were a lowered degree of treatment
satisfactory for the extension to the West Side Works.
108 The total annual costs of the two schemes are prac-
tically the same.
Extension Extension
Procedure for Addition SW Worksto West Side to Total for
to West Side 500 m.g.d. 400 m.g.d. 900 m.g.d.
Activated Sludge............ $ 579,400 $ 569,200 $1,148,600
Chemical Precipitation...... 579,400 555,800 1,135,200
In these figures no credit is shown for tho sale of
heat-dried sludge for fertilizer. Whatever net income
is obtained would reduce the cost of the activated
sludge. The possible revenue from the sale of sludge
from the West Side activated sludge treatment may
exceed $78,000.
If the cost of the activated sludge extension for the
West Side be corrected to a plant producing the same
5-day B.O.D. as the chemical precipitation, we have:
Extension
Procedure for Addition SW Worksto Extension
to West Side 500 m.g.d. West Side Total
Activated Sludge .............. $579,400 $320,600 $ 900,000"
Chemical Praevcipitation ........ 579,400 555,800 1,135,200**
* For 680 m.g.d.
** For 900 m.g.d.
In these figures, no credit is shown for the sale of
| heat-dried sludge as fertilizer.
109 ApvANTAGE IN FINANCING:
In the present status of financing for the Sanitary
District, there appears to be an advantage in keeping
down operating costs and thus réducing the corporate
tax levy. The higher construction cost under present
conditions can be financed at a low interest rate, thus
stabilizing that part of the fixed charges for the life
of the bonds on a low basis.
«
7 —_— FIRMS eI AN wenn 10 ETT ANE TIE MORNIN, BENE NONE AOL EIS, PRIMA, PERRI CPT INRIA YT ORO EERE ORI UR OA
22
RECOMMENDATIONS:
From the standpoint of utilizing the existing West
Side Works to the fullest extent, and also from the
standpoint of financing, we recommend that for the
immediate future tl 2 extensions of the Southwest
Works be designed to provide a complete plant which
will handle an average flow of 500 m.g.d., with a maxi-
mum around 600 m.g.d. In such plant, the necessary
dewatering, heat-drying, and incinerating equipment
should be installed to provide, in addition, for all the
eacess activated sludge from the North Side Works,
as well as from the supplemental activated sludge
plant to be installed on the effluent of the West Side
Imhoff tanks.
Following thereafter, the necessary additional acti-
vated sludge plant should be designed and built to
treat the effluent of the West Side Imhoff tanks, on the
basis that the vffluent will be mixed with the Southwest
Side sewage and the mixture treated in a consolidated
110 South-west-West activated sludge plant.
Respectfully submitted :
F. W. Mo#uman,
Director of Laboratories.
L. M. Jounson,
Engineer of Maintenance and
Operation.
Wm. A. Dunpas,
Engineer of Mechanical Design.
)
L. C. Wuirremore,
Engineer of Treatment Plant
Design.
Lanopon PEarseE,
Sanitary Engineer.
H. P. Ramey,
Assistant Chief Engineer.
23
112 Stare or Inurnors Exursrr No. 17.
FEpERAL EMERGENCY ADMINISTRATION
or Pusiic Works.
May 3, 1940.
Mr. Joshua D’Esposito,
Resident Projects Engineer.
Dear Mr. D’Esposiro:
Pursuant to your call the Board of Review met in
_ your office May 1-3 with all members present.
The Board had before it—
1. The completed summary of the investigations
made by the Sanitary District to determine the most
« _ effective method of giving secondary treatment to the
West Side Sewage
2. The letter transmitting this report, signed by
L.. C. Whittemore, Engineer of Treatment Plant De-
sign
3. A review of the report dated April 16, 1940,
signed by
F. W. Mohiman
Director of Laboratories
L. M. Johnson
Engineer of Maintenance & Operation
Wm. A. Dundas
Engineer of Mechanical Design
113 L. C. Whittemore
Engineer of Treatment Plant Design
Langdon Pearse
Sanitary Engineer
H. P. Ramey
Assistant Chief Engineer
4. An Independent review of the report prepared
by U. F. Turpin, Assistant Projects Engineer.
The Board has given careful consideration to these
cial Te ae
Seti, d - * - ne, SPN Serres - . PALER OED A OR LD ATELY POO Gore Pe me a
24
studies and is in general accord with the conclusion
that the best method of supplementing the treatment
now given to the West Side sewage lies in an enlarge-
ment of the Southwest activated sludge plant in the
manner contemplated by Scheme A-2.
While the Board agrees with the Engineers of the
Sanitary District as to the method of treatment, it is
not satisfied that the additional treatment capacity
, proposed in Scheme A-2 will all be necessary to secure
reasonably satisfactory conditions in the river below
Lockport.
The Whittemore report is a very comprehensive one,
bet it As based on a number of assumptions, that
though close enough for purposes of comparison,
should be checked or verified as far as possible before
114 definitely embarking on a construction program esti-
mated to cost $10,000,000. Whittemore, in his letter
of transmittal, points to one of these assumptions as
follows:
‘it cannot be too strongly emphasized that more data
should be secured on plant performance under the
conditions of operation which will eventually prevail,
before final designs for extensions are prepared.”’
In the report, propused treatment plant capacity is
based on an estimated sewage flow (West and South-
west combined) of 900 M.G.D. This assumption can
be checked by gauging the actual flow and at the same
time the assumed characteristics of the sewage can be
verified by sampling.
When the results of the 1940 census become avail-
able they will throw much light on population trends
and permit more intelligent planning for the future
than is now possible.
A water filtration plant is in course of construction
to serve the Sonthwest area and it is reasonable to
assume that eventually the supply of filtered water
25
will be metered. When this is done, the volume of sew-
age from this area should be greatly reduced.
At the request of the State of Illinois, the United
115 States Supreme Court has reopened the question as to
what constitutes a reasonable diversion of water from
Lake Michigan. If, as a result of this investigation,
the present authorized diversion should be altered even
though for a temporary period of three years, it would
' be wise to study the effect of such an increase before
fixing the treatment capacity of the combined West-
Southwest plant.
For the reasons just stated, the Board considers it
highly desirable to prosecute the wor outlined in
Scheme A-2 in two stages—
1. Increasing the capacity of the Southwest Plant
from 400 to 500 M.G.D., a task that will require two
working seasons, and ‘
2. Re-appraising the requirements as they will then
exist before undertaking the second stage. Such a
re-appraisal may show that part. of the proposed ex-
penditure of $10,000,000 is unnecessary.
The Board realizes that time may be saved by adopt-
ing Scheme A-2 in its entirety at this time, but the
advantages from an engineering standpoint, of the
two-stage plan seem to far outweigh any loss of time.
The Board invites attention to the many difficulties
116 that have been encountered in putting the 400 M.G.D.
activated sludge plant in commission and to the prob-
ability of encountering others in stepping up plant
capacity to 500 M.G.D.
A further increase in plant capacity to 800 M.G.D.
(or even to 900 M.G.D.) is indicated by the studies,
but the experience gained under the two-stage plan
will, in the opinion of the Board, be extremely val-
uable.
117
In recommending a two-stage plan of construction,
the Board does not have in mind a rigid adherence to
the line of demarcation between the 500 M.G.D. plant
and the proposed 900 M.G.D. plant as set up by the
Sanitary District. On the contrary, it recommends
that the extensions of the buildings to -house additional
pump, blower and sludge dewatering equipment be
made of the dimensions called for by Scheme A-2. To
apply the two-stage program to such features would
be economically unsound. For similar reasons it may
be advisable to include in the first stage of the pro-
gram 16 additional final tanks even though only 8 are
estimated as necessary for the 500 M.G.D. plant.
Contrrot Works Cuicaco RIver.
At the request of the Chief Engineer of the Sani-
tary District the Board examined several plans under-
consideration for stopping the leakage through the
basin walls that form part of the control works at the
mouth of the Chicago River.
In its opinion, the intrusion method does not give
sufficient promise of success as to warrant further
experimentation.
As between the plans calling for a clay blanket ‘pro-
tected by rip rap »nd the plan calling for a steel sheet .
pile diaphragm, the Board recommends the latter. It
notes, however, that the proposed diaphraghm is not
anchored to the concrete cap of the crib. Further con-
sideration of this feature is recommended.
Very truly yours,
DanitrL W. Meap,
C. W. Kurz,
W. B. Srorey,
Members of Board of Review.
27
118 Stare or Inurnois Exursitr No. 18.
FeperaAL EmMerGENcyY ADMINISTRATION
or Pustic Works
Office of
Resident Frojects Engineer Suite 300-302
Resident Projects Auditor 910 S. Michigan Ave.
For Sanitary District of Chicago Chicago, Illinois
May 3, 1940.
Mr. Ross A. Woodhull, President,
Board of Trustees,
The Sanitary District of Chicago,
910 South Michigan Avenue,
Chicago, Illinois.
Dear Mr. WoopnuLu:
I transmit herewith copy of report to me by the
Engineering Board of Review dated May 3, 1940,
covering the problem of the enlargement of the exist-
ing Southwest Sewage Treatment Plant together with
the additions necessary thereto for the secondary
treatment of the West Side sewage, also a recommen-
dation of the Board as to the best method of solving
the problem of water inflow from the lake at the
mouth of the river.
I concur in the recommendations of the Board, and
shall advise the Public Works Administration in
Washington to that effect.
x Very truly yours,
JosHua D’Esposiro.
28
170 Strate or Iuurnois Exuisir No. 23.
Tue Sanitary District or CHicaco
Soutuwesr Sewace TREATMENT Works
Fiow, B.O.D., D.O. anp Suspenpep Soups
5-day B.O.D. Diss. Oxyg. Susp. Solids
% &
3s a = c
Month ee a ge :. -. =e
1939 MG.D 2 § S85 8835 2 8 S&F
=] | b 4 Os
e.@ st st83 %— & 53
ss £3 Bte5 8 f Ae
pg ee
February .....-
BEE avis cceee
ME -edenseeeae
May -(1) 41
. are (2) 160
> RR Ee 216 59 12 79.6 96 12 87.5
ML eecexess 216 60 12 80.0 78 15 808
September ..... 313 9 #17 = 823 5.4 123 15 878
October ....... 313 1338 22 83.5 5.8 175 23 87.0
November ...... 326 141 11 922 . 8 100-716 911
December ...... 307 144 17 882 84 191 14 92,7
(3) 236
Average ....(4) 282 106 15 85.8 68 139 16 885
(1) Preliminary settling only.
(2) Started aeration, part of flow, June 9th.
(3) Average May list to December 3ist.
(4) Average July Ist to December 21st.
3642 State or Iuurois Exutspit No. 27-A.
Tue Sanitary District or CHIcaco
Nortu Sipe Sewace TREATMENT WorkKS
Summary or Resutts ‘or OPERATION
1929-1940
Flow 5-Day B.O.D. Susp. Solids Per Cent Reductfon
Year M.G.D. p.p.m. p.p.m. B.O.D. Susp. Solids
Se ve ee dees 58.8 5.8 14 95 92.5
Se sicc deus 139.4 8.5 16 92 88.1
> nee re 196.0 8 14 92.8 91.0
| ae Pe a 12 91.7 91.3
5 ere Br 199.4 13.1 14 88.3 89.2
| es er 14.1 14 89.4 90.5
19385 ....4.-- 199.4 10.1 13 91.0 90.2
: ae 6 8.5 i4 92.2 89.8
ee Pee |e 9.2 1= 91.5 91.5
De néeotke ee 200.1 8.6 10 92.2 93.0
De Savepeon 202.5 7.7 11 93.5 92.4
ee 188.2 7.0 11 04.6 92.4
29
3644 State oF Inurnois Exurpir No. 28-A.
Tue Sanitary YDistrrict or CHicaco
CaLtuMET Sewace TREATMENT Works
Summary or Resutts or OPERATION
1936-1940 :
‘
, Flow 5-Day B.O.D. Susp. Solids Per Cent Reduction
. Year M.G.D. p.p.m. p.p.m. B.O.D. Susp. Solids
TR 62.7 16 23 83.5 86.9
Daa 65.4 13 15 86.3 90.1
Se Aéivs us 61.8 14 13 83.1 90.2
Si caweews 71.6 12 12 87.0 90.6
Sr ons sccwe 67.2 10 12 90.7 90.1
3646
251
30
State or Inurors Exursirr No. 29-A.
Tue Sanitary District or CxHricaco
West Siwz Sewace TREATMENT WorkKs
Summary or Resvutts or Operation
1931-1940
Flow 5-Day B.O.D. Susp. Solids Per Cent Reduction
Year M.G.D. p.p.m. p.p.m. B.0O.D. Susp. Solids
1931 85.1 56 69 56.0 58.4
1932 125.7 59.2 60 42.0 51.2
1933 135.2 66.7 57 42 57.5
1934 128.4 65.6 56 47.5 61.4
(a) 1985 135.2 2 48 54.5 61.1
1936 197.6 49.3 57 49.2 52.9
1937 275.6 57 67 40.7 40.2
1938 305.7 50 55 47.4 54.5
1939 237.8 50 57 53.7 63.0
1940 361.5 64 15 50.0 58.0
Nore:
(a) Battery C placed in service April 29, 1935.
Srate or Inurnois Exuusit No. 31.
Tas_e I.
Tue Sanrrary District or CHICAGO
Main CHANNEL AND IuuINoIs RIVER
DissoLvep OxyGeN anp OxycGen DEMANDS
Station: Locks, Mouth of Chicago River
Dates: 1939-1940
Diss. Oxygen Demand, 20°C., p.p.m.
Date Temp. Oxygen
Month c° p.p.m. 5 days
Nov. 1939 8 11.9 3
Dec. _ 5 12.9 1.8
Jan. 1940 2 14.1 5 By
Feb. » 2 13.3 1.8
Mch. % - 3 13.3 1.4
Apr. ‘ - 7 12.0 1.2
May _ 11 10.5 1.3
June S 18 9.9 1.3
July : 9.6 1.3
Aug. i atert ‘A 8.7 0.9
31
253 Strate or Inurnois Exursir No. 32.
Tasxe II.
Tue Sanitary District or Cxrcaco
Marin CHANNEL AND ILLINoIs RIVER
DissoLvepD OxyGeN anp OxyGen Dremanps
Station: Damen Avenue Dates: Jan. 1938-May, 1940
Diss. Oxygen Demand, 20°C., p.p.m.
Temp. Oxygen
Er
p.p.m. 5 days
2 11.2 8.2
12 9.4 9.7
15 86 10.7
i7 69 105
21 51 80
22 55 68 9
19 5.7 79
15 55 120
8 83 185
5 101 185
5 75 171
19 15 363
16 0.5 1
19 2.0
22 0.2
23 0.0
21 0.1
4 9.5
CA
be
eoohehes SEERSRNE
ss
ay
$2 $9 ht 69 Se OD
C§rAanwoa
Naocaveowna
32
255 Strate or Inuinois Exutsir No. 33.
Tasue III.
Tue Sanrrary District or CHICAGO
Matin CHANNEL AND Ixuinois RIver
DissoLvepD OxYGEN AND OxyGen DEMANDS
Station: Summit Dates: Jan. 1938-May, 1940
Diss. Oxygen Demand, 20°C., p.p.m.
Date Temp. Oxvgen
Month C° py.m. 5 days
Jan. 1938 2° 98 268
Feb. 7 4 93 249
Mch. 6 8.2 23.4
Apr. 10 6.6 20.7
May 13 3.2 180
June 17 14 1486
July 22 0.6 15.2
Aug. 22 11 13.5
Sept. 20 18 128
Oct. 17 08 18.0
Nov. 10 Si Ws
Dec. 4 8.7 25.0
Jan. 1939 6 24 403
Feb. 6 39 38.8
Mch. 8 1.9 37.1
Apr. 11 0.0 47.9
May 17 00 G&D
June 20 0.2 48.
July 23 O 872.
Aug. 25 0.0 33.
Sept 23 0.0 35.
Oct. 19 0.1 36.
Nov 19 04 26.5
Dec 15 3.3 2%.
Jan. 1940 10 44 2.
Feb. . - 2.8 383.
Mch. — 43 82.
Apr. 10 17 @.
May 14 0.4 30.
June 20 0.0 42.
July 0.1 824.
Aug. 0.2 23.
33
257 Strate or I[uurnois —— No. 34.
Tase IV.
Tre Sanitary District or Cxtczco
Main CHANNEL AND ILLINors RIver
DissoLvED OxyGEN AND Oxycen DEMANDS
Station : Lockport Dates: Jan. 1938-May 1940
Diss. Oxygen Demand, 20°C., p.p.m.
Date Temp. Oxygen
Month C° ppm ¢ 5 days
Jan. 1938 6408 15 74 226
Feb. 7422 as - is
Mch. 7607 6.0 56 . 19.4
Apr. 7686 105 32 163
May 6311 15.0 O58 17.46
June 6701 190 O38 188
July 6814 23.0 01 185
Aug 6740 23.0 01 146
Sept 7247 205 O03 13.4
Oct 5512 17.0 02 186
Nov 5861 10.5 12 18.5
Dec 5469 45 43 218
Jan. 1939 2911 5.0 05 28.5
Feb. 3989 3.5 ° 22 266
Mch 3200 6.5 08 25.0
Apr. 2718 #185 O01 81.4
May 2623 175 O00 423
June 4227 =. 21.5 0.0 37.8
July 2880 245 0.0 26.5
Aug 2902 23.0 00 262
Sept 2826 240 0.0 23.0
Oct 3022 18.0 0.0 18.1
Nov 2820 115 04 13.8
Dec 3469 80 1383 18.2
Jan. 1940 2949 1.5 18 148
Feb. 2802 5.0 04 238.0
Mch 3167 55 10 22
Apr 3026 10.0 O02 266
May 3344 145 Gi 23
June 21.90 O00 27.9
July 0 18.7
Aug. 0.1 162
im
!
we j
am
ld a) Sey
; me |
: = Reece sere: SELL en RBer ie ae
> “7 |
TE >—<- -—s : . a ‘ -
2 ecocsceapen goes areeee | i
i: © nit Sal ;
{re < y mesooete tt nvesnossan H } ; vo.
j ” | T i a ' <
\~* } | pe =
jos ’ t —,. - .
7 RES RN Os Det haan "OE I Gs Ee _
i | > {
“3 | t ava Vix
a { oan. WE ae ee aan vee Weber |
| \ = i
’ ' ~ | | j
ve } | | e| it : Vale
: ’ bid ee F 6s .
" “>
‘ ; | 7
ey foo 5 te eee ,
—_ ‘ ¥
4434as2i°33
35 miles from Lake Michigan.)
PTT PERSE CSET Y TEES ESSE Fea Te eee
1
f
(292 miles From Grafton Ferry:
PPT FETE T FEET
ganqeecidsy
.
»
=
“yt "25
’
MAIN CHANNEL at LOCKPORT
PT RTO CREE RESET bt ae
wr
bars
SOL.)
Pane eer
CAwereer,r
E:
@
1
LV ITD AAD
MAaat
as
‘Ba
a4
Sag
° gh
a at
— is — ©
"sigh AGERE we FH
ve Be & Pee SO we oR SO oth et pet eb
o +e i. “SS eee oe ee ee Se
Foom
>) .
>
, ; 3
ame od be
1 ‘
a
— - -
Panty 2a7
—~ Cawsreer
Eset
3 rence
HU il
-—-
. Am wet ata — aon ; as ok -
TH Ta I
i-
MAP OF THE
CITY OF JOLIET ILL.
key Ccamiccnais QAO
ee ee HI aT
@certer of Beton Mik®
NT boty hit
og
ILLINOIS EXHIBIT NO. 40-A REC. P. 3672.
Sanilory bisticl of Chicago
dobinsian latte Charmne/ Yscharge of Lockporr
he Cor tre/ Sechiors ik
| 4/20104 FPTOow Aetval Pion
Pend |...>. GTS |
wad ida » gies e sls
BE NONSENSE
£ [Sse Sees 8 ess S388 S8yii x
, RSS NAVFE ze 8 STF x Ni
~
he
Q
w
N
%
y
yy
4
. CFS | CFS | CFS EFF
Mar | = ape | 4900 6408 | £08 6200: 2.0
6780 7422! $22\ 69006 2.)/
__| 7300, 7607, 307) 2300) 3.5/\
ce ay Lael 208, 286, 7400; 2.20
t G37 Aw lar: 6000} 3.20
9 i t
4.
fee. "1 asa" GS C746" Fo 1 $7981 7)
ae + G7/301 bass co G/0a" 52
3% fee S12; 5900, O77 @
"HR sae =a @/' $800 0.
p | mes 5428" F469. 269 52007 78.
=| eee ee
~go55gg5 2800 2917 738 P77F 22
\. |}... \48ee! 400! 2400" 9949 1559. 2430-196
| ~~ |2ige! 490! D400, 3200 72d 24%” 286 RSI
Ul | 2800 2800| 40d 2400, 2778 30/, 2di7, 322, eEES
* --+ $600 £504, Gbe 2340) 2623, F60, 2263 $66, a]
5003600 400 3200. 4287 | S236 57H er
"j 38003200 480: 2b0d| EL 178) 2762 276,
“T3500. aee6 620) 2600" JO" 20527
Sees 3/00 400.2700! 2026, 72 Po14, 049
Z 3/00, 202 172 28
2hoe 2900. . 00 2600 | F __&.
00, 9500, FOO F200
735" 733 Fes 2683
B j b.
a7 2960. Joo God Gots. es. ‘2507! SA SOME RN ANGST
Jeoe joce. 400 2600, 3348 922 9022: 516 i a
| 9200 5 $00 5 2800. PP 256730 A et ares
By Gos ons fool sane 9985, 246 3677, $5, ee a 8
: ‘300. 3300; eons 3/25 oe 3/48, P3/'
~~ — es _
+ 62t
j
Page Tightly Bound 2
di
ILLINOIS EXHIBIT No. 43 _—-REC. P: 1431
Sanitary District of Chicago
Main Chonnel Halt Hour Discharge at Lockport
On the (5% day ofeach Mort of yeor
O Lwisiorr :
rs det fs Control Section Yeor /937
. (ZA 2\ Mar. *| AIBY\ A ler) : , : ”
Time OLZACATACLAE ZA ere le Hedy | Aeg.| Seat) Oe Bev. cms
F27/ BO5| 3774 2650\3573| F495 FIFE GAPS 37H Se +
9O| 327/\ $693| 7P2/\ 3759 2952; 3563| $2/5| 36041 3233| 30ael| syaFl 4
F266, 5% ZE3/\ 3 7S2 Lf | 52e4| 82/5| 9599 f % | GB543\ YSI/
3013276 / | 7856| 405@2| | |3beol 2270 7 2 | 7e4b| 25/2| Yee
rm Y 4 7847\4037| \ |359e| #z7e 3233| 297/| 3497| 70)
Jo} tl 7 | 7@58 7 _| F600, 9205, —" [#272, 7: 2| 4528
cm \_ 1692) 7£53| FoF 52) 35 85| F205) FFAG) 32/2) TF. w,
36 J | s7eg EZ Cd 3 £29 3 297{\ E20 os
32 Z3Z5| ZF&77A SHS LS SIG 3227 * 132K A F602| #S//
36] 32 758B| 7F70\3069\ | | ¥985| 3227) 3529 32%| F023| ISIAYH FO
226/| §7/8 V\/867| \ | 2789 2399 3524) F206) F003) S$2/31b072
( |S 708 65294 /PP7 \ [2 4/39| 239/| 3272| 2329 3dozwHe,
? (ZEA A344 2O2/| 2 FUS| F/
26)| 5700| 6 e846) 7£77 234% 2e/ 'o Za
2240\ $6 2\ 2842) 2774\2/39| 272 eo 2/22 4 2/
Ya / ; 2/22 ar74 2/39 ze 2099 2090\ /§£$2\ 2/
/983\ 5695 2 Z 2/49\ 2043 36 a
30] /F83| $682) 5977 Jezs TT 2754 2/54, 20¥A, 2 fr 7857 De
/SF8 ZL YIN, /906| JERE 2/3 ¥3| 209/| 2092| /£37| Zé
36 a > el /ESss L. 12749 2/59 4 | ROW, 209/| /Ge7
a fF 7 5|/8S5| ( | H¥o a EZZA 37e7| /£37| 2/75
L.| $6 A+ (84 e \ 1276 2/ ©| 2094 2/07 ” Vez
D) 7/7\| 4¥?2. 2 | 44/4 2/ 2299\ /£37\ 2/
/8E93\ 4360 H#08| /Z¥ 2 2/53 2086 2094) 3462
W i 3 ” o = 7
74: 43S la FIZZ) ZEL| 2/ OF) [864] 2/57
Z2i#7 3S7| 3Fe2) 3D | 292 26| 2706| 209/ Zs L
L 4347| /£72| /£§e'\ 273 e774 LEGF .
\ 2 | 4382! (9671 /£7. ck 2/3 e 2/04 1869
. \ | 4365| 4382) /P57| 4 T2766) F. Z 2//3\ 2099| /7S8|_ J
7 12 Y2i {£72 2? o 099| /E4#7| QS)
SA HS) /868| JP80| 2786| 2/2) 20ff| </ey, /#52
4 L_| #282 GfeF! =] di 4
2&2: \_| wus2t FF0z 2/4/)\ * 27/ > | /£67
2, J | W285) /$ S50 5 3433) 29
2 F4\ WY10| /Z2S\ / 2/ ZEEE) 43
3258 w 7 AS3 TIF2
} z 2a6t| 2 97 rr
2632 20 ¥8\ 2/ 2 ites
| 2897 | aor S36) 3/7/| 3958
Lib | 2 22 °2] 37661 F968
el Zef2) 22725) 23 S$: | BDP%
44) 200 7) I290e| 3/8/ 3737
” 2A ZosF 2 /| 39 y; 4)
PHO; 2 22f. 4A4\ ZESF
73. 3 TY}
” $2) 2 35 MOO 77 2
2 YESH YI6Z 3568 337 P77)
Fe
> 4
Page Tightly Bound
| RCE ee aa
q:
‘
Sanitary District of Chicago
Main Chantel Halt Hour Discharge at Lockport
On the 15% day ofeach Month of year
0 Lwisior7 ;
FE OTe” hat Snction
Year /940
Time
Fes.
Jen.
ar.
<frs
MG,
oes
Af
SH45
2779
295/\ #/ 43
FI
At
c
3/74
ae
eer | Der.
eZ)
cry
Nev.
ows crs
crs
S465
260
2743| 257%
FOF
+923
2736 2593
Px-2 £4
272%, §
5092
2703 £93
507
27/3
652
434,
5005
27/3
50/2
Fo #5|
27/2
$
4997,
27/8
x8 93
2/00
2/7
LIOS
2/7
LE Ge
FL
/£72) 2/5.
2/493
/§72
2/43) 2/$3
/477
2/33) 3£83
L303
£473
2/4B 2/92) 2
f 12/72 $
7878
2/F/
/ 87%
$
/8$/
3797
220e/
2se0¢
=
2/6
2/749
2/7
2/7
2/75\ +
3Z/o
2/2
45
3647 State or Inuinois Exurpir No. 44-A.
THe Sanitary District or Carcaco
Nort Sime Sewace Treatment Works
Fiow, B.0.D., D.O. anp Suspenpep Soims
1940 s
5-Day B.O.D. Diss. Oxygen Suspended Solids
2 %o Final %
Flow Raw Reduc- Settling Raw Reduc-
Month M.G.D. Sewage Effluent tion Tanks Outfall Sewage Effluent tion —
174 160 9.6 94.0 AY 9.5 141 16 88.7
181 — 143 8.2 94.3 1.6 9.3 147 13 91.2 «
187 142 8.4 94.0 1.5 9.2 145 4% 13 91.0
189 136 84 , 93.8 2.1 9.1 145 12 91.7 |
220 108 fh 93.3 1.8 8.5 144 10 93.0 .
193 110 6.7 93.9 17 7.9 146 * 10 93.2 .
195 112 5.6 95.0 1.4 7.6 147 8 94.6 fi
200 1038 4.9 95.2 1.4 7.4 151 9 94.0 —
181 119 4.4 96.3 1.2 7.5 124 7 94.4
180 130 6.0 95.4 1.0 7.9 152 8 94.1
A 177 "145 6.5 95.5 1.0 8.4 142 12 91.5
Dec. 182 139 1.7 94.5 1.9 8.9 142 14 90.1
Average 188 129 7.0 94.6 1.6 8.4 144 11 92.4
3650 Strate or Iuurnors Exurpit No. 45-A.
'
THe Sanitary District »r CxHtcaco
* Catumet Sewace Treatment Works
Fiow, B.O.D., D.O. anp Suspenpep Soins
1940-
5-Day B.O.D. Suspended Solids
Dissolved
% Oxyzgen % .
Flow Raw Reduc- Outfall Raw Redu:.
Month M.G.D. Sewage Effluent tion Sewer Sewage Effluent tion
67 125, 10 92.0 8.4 121 14 88.4
72 118 9 92.4 8.5 123 12 90.2
62 106 9 91.5 8.7 123 13 89.4
61 101 9 91.0 8.6 120 11 90.¢
70 87 9 89.7 8.3 118 12 89.&
70 96 8 91.6 7.6 126 11 91.3
63 98 8 91.8 7.3 119 10 91.€
66 98 9 90.8 7.2 128 10 92.2
64 108 10 90.7 7.5 117 10 91.8
66 104 12 88.5 7.5 120 15 88.4
70 123 17 86.1 7.9 111 10 91.¢
76 115 11 90.4 8.4 120 12 90.
10 90.7 8.0 121 12 90.1
5 BE BP A BeOS AO EFA NERA ET RA APTA EEN fk PALIT RA Neate DE MPLS AE: Sais iil a Be itl cB
46 \
3652 Strate or I[turnots Exursit No. 46-A.
Tue Sanrrary District or CxHicaco
West Sinz Sewacr Treatment Works
Fiow, B.O.D., D.O. anp SuspenpEep Soups
1940
5-Day B.O.D. Suspended Solids
Dissolved
% Oxygen %
Flow Raw Reduc- Outfall Raw Redue-
Month M.G.D. Sewage Effluent tion Sewage Effluent tion
Jan. 168 129 62 51.9 152 65 57.2
Feb. 187 118 67 43.2 141 72 48.9
Mar. (a) 348 132 74 44.0 178 85 §2.2
Apr. (b) 394 137 75 45.2 171 85 50.2
May (c) 437 109 55 49.5 163 73 55.2
June (d) 391 133 64 51.9 217 74 613
July (e) 449 123 60 §1.2 178 75 57.8
Aug. (f) 449 116 48 58.6 182 58 68.1
Sept. (g) 383 130 54 58.5 4.6 193 67 65.3
: (h) 371 ( 141 60 57.4 5.1 214 71 66.8
Nov. (i) 374 142 75 47.2 5.3 192 86 55.2
Dec. (j) 385 128 76 40.6 8.6 167 4 49.7
Average (k) 362 128 64 50.0 5.9 172 75 58.0
(a) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 4 M.G.D., equivalent to %7 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(>) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 4 M.G.D., equivalent to 48 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(c) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 5 M.G.D., equivalent to 55 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(d) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 6 M.G.D., equivalent to 79 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(e) *Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 6 M.G.D., equivalent to 67 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(f) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 6 M.G.D., equivalent to 65 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(g) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 7 M.G. D.., equivalent to 68 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(h) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 7 M.G.D., equivalent to 69 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(i) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 6 M.G.D., equivalent to 43 p.p.m. susp. solids.
5) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 5 M.G.D., equivalent to 34 p.p.m. susp. solids.
(k) Prel. sludge received from SW. Wks. 5 M.G.D., equivalent to 46 p.p.m. susp. solids.
2
~<
47 \
3654 Srare oF Inuinois Exurerr No. 47-A.
@HE Sanitary District or Cxtcaco
Souruwest Sewace TrEaTMENT Works
Fiow, B.O.D., D.O. ann Suspenpep Soums
1940
5-Day 3.0.D. Suspended Solids
Dissolved
% Oxygea %o
Flow Raw Reduc- Outfail Raw Reduc-
Month M.G.D. Sewage Effluent tion Sewage Effluent tion
January 287 151 13 91.3 ge 217 15 93.1
February 267 142 10 93.0 8? 194 14 92.8
March (a) 197 — 26 — 25 34 :
Apri) (b) 252 172 62 64.0 7.4 242 63 ~" 74.0
May (c) 310 142 58 59.1 6.0 203 62 69.4
June (d) 365 154 71 53.8 4.2 191 69 63.8
July (e) 287 151 44 70.8 4.2 187 43 17.0
Aug. (f) 340 134 52 61.1 5.1 188 56 70.2
Sept (zg) 358 141 45 68.1 5.1 170 45 73.5
Oct. (h) 361 152 53 65.1 6 220 58 73.6
Nov. (i) 374 188 73 61.2 6.4 215 st 63.3
Dec. (j) 358 193 102 47.1 8.5 211 / 105 50.2
Average (k) 313 156 51 67.3 6.6 203 / 64 73.4
(a) Complete Treatment on 161 M.G.D. y
(b) Complete Treatment on 122 M.G.D.
(ec) Complete Treatment on 142 M.G.D.
(d) Complete Treatment on 130 M.G.D.
(e) Complete Treatment on 168 M.G.D.
{f) Complete Treatment on 176 M.G.D.
(g) Complete Treatment on 236 M.G.D.
(h) Complete Treatment on 248 M.G.D.
(i) Complete Treatment on 222 M.G.D.
(j) Complete Treatment on 139 M.G.D.
(k) Complete Treatment on 192 M.G.D.
‘ 48
3674 Strate or Iuurois Exursir No. 62.
Sanitary District or Curcaco
Diversion rrom Lake MIcHIGAN —
Total from Diversion
Total Des Plaines Lake Chicaguy and from
Average River Michigan Domestic Calumet Lake Precipitation
Tear Month ss tad Inflow Watershed Pumpage Rivers Michigan U.ofC.
2 3 4 5 6 7
CFS CFS CFS CFS CFS CFS Inches
938—Jan 6408 20 6388 1589 520 4279 2.02
Feb 7422 63 7359 1554 789 5016 211
Mar 7607 25 7582 1534 868 5180 3.51
April 7686 22 7664 1529 1006 5129 2.20
May 6311 13 6298 1563 460 4275 3.98
June 6701 28 6673 1649 1009 4015 6.78
July 6814 305 6509 1761 776 3972 3.90
Aug 6740 11 6729 1808 591 4420 2.12
Sept. 7247 25 7222 1683 1814 | 3725 5.29
Oct. 5512 11 5501 1577 194 3730 0.77
Nov. 5861 9 5852 1514 125 4213 0.95
Dec. 5469 9 5460 1491 138 3831 1.18
Average 6648 45 6603 1604 683 4316
Total
.939—Jan. 2911 10 2901 1488 251 1162
Feb. 3989 40 3949 1504 1829 616
Mar 3200 31 3169 1515 1250 AOE
April 2718 23 2695 1689 868 138
May 2623 18 2605 1532 906 167
June 4227 16 4211 1669 1986 556
July 2880 7 2873 1878 501 494
Aug. 2902 3 2899 1801 397 701
Sept. 2826 0 2826 1733 238 855
Oct. 3022 4 3018 1619 197 1202
Nov. 2820 4 2816 1518 131 1167
Dec. 3469 4 3465 1487 116 1862
Average 3132 13 3119 1620 722 T77
Total :
1940—Jan. 2949 19 2930 1566 257 1107
Feb. 2802 36 2760 1538 432 796%
“ Mar. 3167 68 3099 1521 582 996 ~
April 3026 66 2960 1523 292 1145
May 3344 118 3220 1528 837 861
Jane 2876 53 2823 1662 567 594
July 3609 38 3571 -1854 360 1357
Aug. 3923 47 3876 1750 307 1819
Sept. 3125 32 3093 1673 119 1301
Oct. 3186 27 3159 1525 159 1475
Nov. 2824 24 2800 1459 138 1203
*Dec. 2618 68 2550 1448 304 798
* Average 3138 49 3089 1592 363 1134
+Dec. 9890 41 9949 1501 225 8223
tAverage 3319 49 3270 1589 363 1318
Total
* Except period Noon of Dec. 2nd to noon of Dec. 12th
Enon of Dec. 2nd to noon of Dec. 12th
= t ear \ ‘
49
3677 State or Inurvois Exursrr No. 63.
ANALYsEs oF SamMpLes FROM MAIN CHANNEL AND
Iuuinors River
AveraGE MontTHLY Resutts, Sept.-Dec., 1940
(Complete Data in Record, Exhibits 31 to 36, and
Page 1840)
1940
-—Dissolved Oxygen—- ——6-day B.O.D._—— ——Temperature——
P.P.M. P.P.M. Deg. C
Station Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec.
Lake Michigan 8.8 9.8 11.9 14,1 0.9 1.0 1.5 1.6 18 15 8 3
Damen Ave. 42 49 79 114 35 45 44 39 | a oe
Summit 03 05 3832 75 2 2 3 @ 21 18 #10 5
Lockport 01 02 O08 49 143 142 136 24.7 ae” ae ee
Marseilles 44 54 93 114 $1 87 48 -&6 ae ee ee
Chillicothe 68 73 104 122 47 48 39 42 mm me Fe
1820 Moutmann Exursit No. 1.
THe Sanitary District or Cxicaco (1)
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Subject: Determination of Chlorine Demand—
Main Channel
Computation: July 2 and 3, 1940.
Parts per Million
July 2, 1940-—— —July 3, 1940-
Time Damen Ave. Summit Damen Ave. Summit Lockport
9:00 A.M. 2.1 5.0 2.0 4.5 3.7
9:30 1.6 5.0 2.0 4.5 3.7
10:00 1.6 4.5 2.3 4.0 3.7
10:30 1.3 4.5 23 3.5 3.7
11:00 1.6 5.5 20 4.0 5.0
11:30 1.8 5.0 2.0 4.0 5.0
12:00 1.6 4.0 2.3 4.5 5.0
12:30 P.M 2.3 4.0 2.3 4.0 5.0
1:00 2.3 3.0 23 5.0 5.0
1:30 2.3 4.0 2.0 4.0 6.2
2:00 2.0 4.0 2.3 4.5 5.0
2:30 2.0 4.0 2.3
3:00 2.3 4.0 2.3
Average 1.9 4.4 2.2 4.2 4.6
50
Mouuman Exuisir No. 8.
Eprroriau,
“~~
Oxycen DEMAND or Stupee Deposits.
The most objectionable feature of a grossly polluted
stream is the presence of floating, gas-lifted sludge,
foul in odor and nauseous in appearance. Abatement
of stream pollution should always be directed first to
the removal from sewage of the settleable solids, and
second to the reduction of the B.O.D. of the clarified
sewage. Although it is genera!ly accepted that clarifi-
cation accomplishes about 35 per cent reduction of
B.0.D. and complete treatment 90 per cent, the actual -
benefit to the stream by clarification may greatly ex-
ceed 35 per cent, particularly in the early months of
summer. ‘
Stabilization of sewage sludge deposits on stream
beds is accomplished at the expense of the dissolved
oxygen of the supernatant water. The well-known ac-
celerating effect of comparatively small increases in
temperature on the rate of oxygen demand of sewage
also applies to sludge, and when the water tempera-
ture reaches 15 to 20 degrees Centigrade in June, a
sudden increase in the oxygen requirement of sludge
deposits occurs. For a few weeks the sludge deposits
may erupt violently and the river surface may be cov-
ered with a carpet of bubbling sludge. Later in the
summer, the water temperature may reach 30 degrees
Centrigrade, and as the temperature mounts, the
sludge continues to putrefy, although not with the ex-
plosive violence associated with the onset of summer
weather.
For a long time it has been known that the oxygen
demand of freshly settled sewage sludge is far greater
51
than that of digested sludge, or of stream deposits
several years old, but there have been comparatively
few investigations of the rate of B.O.D. of sludge.
In the past few years, however, attention has been
directed toward this subject at a number of research
laboratories in the United States. Results of investi-
gations of B.O.D. of sludge and river mud have been
reported by Rudolfs, Fair, Theriault and Baity, the
latter in this issue (page 539). Studies have also been
under way since 1935 in the laboratories of the Sani-
tary District of Chicago and undoubtedly similar work
has been carried on elsewhere.
Dr. Baity’s paper oh the results of his work at
Harvard in 1925 is very interesting, and he has studied -
more phases of the problem, at one time, than other
investigators. He started with raw sewage sludge,
with a high volatile content, and with very thin layers,
ranging from .089 to 4.0 centimeters in depth. The
experiments were carried on for only 36 days. As Dr.
Baity states, it is recognized that this period was too
short to establish many factors related to the long-time
incubation required for the complete stabilization of
sludge deposits of appreciable depth. The curve of
oxygen in his Fig. 2 is ended with the statement
‘‘oxygen demand essentially satisfied,’’ but it seems
to the writer that this conclusion is subject to doubt,
and if the tests Hud been continued, the oxygen demand
might have continued indefinitely, and the total after a
year or two might have been double the 36-day total.
Other studies, on somewhat different bases, and with
deeper layers of sludge, have been continued to 400
days (Rudolfs) and 700 days (Sanitary District of
Chicago). The results of Dr. Rudolfs’ study are given
in an abstract in this issue (page 636). A somewhat
casual consideration of the results of both studies
shows the following:
a
52
Mem. 5-day B.0.D. per Gm.
Days at Volatile Solids
20 deg. C. Rudolfs San. Dist. Chi.
LA ae Ge VevsGacncceucues 380
Secures cuss eure as 6 a Cahn 270
PERI ee es Sas Beet td- 210
EERE APES. ce REA SS a eee 170
Msc cae acdacwunaeas BEE sic cite ec accents 140
We CiuGh eeeokusaces BO Sic cvnk ces ae 105
DO eiecn aver enes Ce Ae Cewaiene kee ck es 97
URS A pees see cowed FES eee Pere 96
f
-The rate after 40 days was approximately 70 per
cent of the initial rate in both cases, while even after
400 days, the rate was still 20 to 28 per cent of the
initial. During a summer period of about 120 days,
-the rate might therefore decrease to about half the
initial. During the following winter the sludge would
remain practically dormant, and through the following
summer the rate would again decrease to about one
half of the initial rate of the second year. After thi,’
the rate would apparently remain more or less con-
stant for a number of years, at 100 mgm. 5-day B.O.D.
per gm. of volatile solids. A number of well-digested
sludges from the Illinois River have averaged around
this value. The sludge beds studied by Rudolfs, in the
Connecticut River have below Springfield, Massachu-
setts, also averaged approximately 100 mgm. per gm.
volatile solids.
Dr. Baity gives a 10-day B.O.D. for the Brockton
sludge of 244 mgm. per gm. volatile solids, equivalent
to approximately 180 mgm. on a 5-day basis. This is
lower than the values found by Rudolfs and the Sani-
tary District of Chicago for fresh sewage sludge, but
higher than has been reported for sludge from river
~ bottoms. -
Notwithstanding these variations, which may be
53
ascribed to the effect of different techniques, the fact
remains that a procedure is being developed and data
are being accumulated that will enable us to evaluate
the effect of sludge deposits in stream studies. Even
with sewage treatment, sludge banks will be formed
from storm-water discharge. With data based on the
organic content of sludge, we can in time evaluate the
influence of such deposits.
The influence of sludge in the lower reaches of the
Illinois River has been discussed briefly by Wisely,
who states on page 569 of this issue that in the stretch
from Mile 162 to Havana (Mile 120), 50 per cent of
the tota) oxygen Cemand was exerted by sludge de-
posits. The Board of Review of the Sanitary District
of Chicago estimated that the sludge deposits in the
upper Illinois River exerted an oxygen demand in
summer that was equivalent to the total flow of sewage,
thus doubling the load on the oxygen resources of the
river.
The consensus of those who have studied the oxygen
demand of sewage sludge seems to be that by far the
greatest source of deoxygenation is caused by freshly
settled sludge, deposited during the winter months and
throughout the current summer. Such deposits, when
allowed to pass through another winter, will show a
greatly reduced rate of demand during the second sum-
mer. Dr. Imhoff once suggested to the writer that
under some conditions it might be desirable to skim
off the surface of lake bottoms early in the spring,
in order to remove sludge deposited during the pre-
vious winter. Such vacuum cleaning has not been ac-
complished, so far as the writer knows, but there is a
great deal of significance in this suggestion.
It is fortunate that so many investigators are study-
ing the oxygen demand of sludge deposits, with refer-
34
ence to stream conditions, and our efforts to abate
stream pollution will be on a sounder foundation when
we have more information on this important subject.
| F. W. M.
ae
MOHLMAN EXHIBIT NO. 14-a, B, C, D REC. P. 3530
83/8 for Estimating Additonal Oiversion <
Needed (11 Swrrrrmer
Mohliman Exhibit bs
CAART IT
Average Resu/1s of Arra/yses and low Srceras af Lockport.
40
| ete.
S r £000 i
x :
a
; é 6000 i
R é
SS 4 $ooe §
3 ;
Qo g
oO “v 2
Yeor (940
See 7zhle I
CAHART IT
Proposed (crease Of Divers/or |
C Aetvo/ rerease tobe based 2p Arralyses svitmitied fo US.£7grs)
) Moe0
o kia
§ 2000 =
d aw fon
o MSO | UFO | HBO | 110 | (20 | 2/50 | 2/66 | 2/40 | 2/60! 1880\ 4190
J F wfseA eee m A Ss o Vv OO
yeor/94/ Jee Joble IZ
CHART TT
Proposed /rcrease Of O1VErS10/7
» Actvel lncrease fo be based or7 Analyses svtinithed to US. Engrs)
+...
7 f;
OPTS
t-
q
St Ss
HO | 80 | HO | (He | 1260| 2/60 low 2/80 | 2/$0| (20 | 1/60
/ a wea wr v A s ° Nn 6
Coble Pwar par see
Year (942 : See Tobte II
57
Mouiman Exursir 14b.
Tasie I.
ANaALysEs aT Lockport anp Diversion, 1940.
Total
Dissolved Flow at
Oxygen Diversion Lockport
Month P.P.M. C.F.S. C.F.&.
1940 Aveyage Average Average
DET Gueska cudeiesbiavvedesan 1.8 1364 2949
Swell eidedadewsaeeceeies 0.4 1228 2802
MN eo dde Ceca eeen wonckcens 1.0 1578 3167
BE Ad cad ede erin s cues wekoe 0.2 1437 3026
nvdd ei onaes apev¥ee véeeeus 0.1 1698 3344
Cited ned awkrneéienseeoes 0.0 1161 2876
ches uwd ab haied goede te- 1% ee 0.0 1717 3600
MEE he Sed as s'e'e «0 600s 0:4 00 6 43 OF 2126 3923
EE” Waid ghieceedseavdoneds 0.1 1420 3125
ebbspanede esd 6 dew dece 0.2
DEE os beatin cwsn dks wblaee nee
a
Mouuman Exuersir 14.
Tasle LI.
Proposep IncREASE oF Drversion.
AotvuaL Increase To Be Mopiriep 1n ACCORDANCE WITH
Rzsu.ts or Sanrrary Disrricr AnaLyses SuBMITTED
to U. S. ENncrIneers.
Year 1941.
Cusic Feet Per Seconp.
Total
Flow at
budgeted Lockport
Diversion Additional (At 1,650
Month (By H.P. Diversion Total C.F-.S.
1941 Ramey) Proposed Diversion Sewage),
A agp scene Coeeen exes 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
oe BAe aww heme ee ae 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
BE alc, oo dae keben 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
San candawicgnsrees 1,150 1,000 2,150 3,800
DE chakecwensthan tein 1,250 3,000 4,250 5,900
Rin a dela edse enka 2,150 5,000 7,150 8,800
be dsbtvecebas seus 2,150 6,000 8,150 9,800
Ey ons cance vent Rane 2,150 5,000 7,150 8,800
0 Ee eer 2,150 3,000 5,150 6,800
ia oe see urge 1,250 1,000 2,250 3,900
NS ies ial aca aug 1,150 » © 1,150 2,800
ME ee at ee 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
Dt nucecsaveoeweaas 18,000 24,000 42,060 61,800
~
™
58
5 Mouutman Exursir 14d.
Tasie III.
ProbPgsep Increase oF DIveRsION.
t — wf
Aoruau Increase: To Bu. Moorrrep 1n ACCORDANCE WITH
Resuuts or Sanrrary District AnaLyses SusMirrep
to U. S. Encrneers.
Year 1942.
Cusic Freer Per Seconp.
Total
Flow at
Budgeted Lockport
Diversion Additional {At 1,650
Month (By H.P. Diversion Total C.F.S.
1941 Ramey) Proposed Diversion Sewage)
MES |nike cael eteude die ee 1,180 0 1,150 2,800
DL Ukaebnonedss oeeas 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
Nigh sco PRE Rios bE ees 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
| wa svurcueercuewens 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
DL Jdeavuwers pueden te 1,250 2,000 3,250 4,900
EE Dinws vob we ued aks 2,150 4,000 6,150 7,800
GE \ eiccev eettiecsavns 2,150 5,000 7,150 8,800
WG Cases tes caaWenaen 2,150 3,000 5,150 6,800
Dh be Cowevelerecudas 2,150 1,000 3,150 4,800
Ci Kebenuue ceddeewaeste 1,250 0 1,250 2,900
Bs.) db vaceséobesueent 1.150 0 1,150 2,800
MK et ceaeteas a6 eubar 1,150 0 1,150 2,800
EE onde tess bers zg: 18,000 15,000 33,000 52,800
Average for Year...... 1,500 1,250 2,750 4,400
3535 Moxuuman Exursirt 14-E.
Basis For Estimatine AppirionaL Diversion NEEDED IN
Summer ror AMELIonaTING ConpITIONS IN Branpon
Poot.
(By F. W. Mohlman.)
1. Table I and Chart I show results of analyses
for dissolved oxygen, and flow of water at Lockport in
1940. The October results are available only through
Oct. 20, 1940. The dissolved oxygen results have
started to increase, with an average.of 0.5 p.p.m. on
Oct. 15th.
?
.
59
2. Table II and Chari II show the diversion in
1941 budgeted to provide as much dilution as possible
in summ r, plus an estimated additional diversion ex-
tending from April througk October. The increase
extends up to 6,000 ¢.f.s. in Juiy, but the total pro-
posed additions average only 2,000 cu. ft. per second
on an annual basis which added to the authorized 1,500
c.f.s. gives a total annual average of 3,500.
It is impossible to estimate the exact amount of
increased diversion that will be needed in the summers
of 1941 and 1942, therefore, it is proposed that the
increases be based on the results of the actual analyses
made by the Sanitary District hourly, and now fur-
nished to the U. S. Engineers in Chicago as monthly
averages. The results could be transmitted daily, and
as soon as the dissolved oxygen began fo approach
zero, hext April, the diversion would be increased
within the limits of suggested increases shown in the
_ table and chart. The amount of additional diversion
required would increase markedly in June, reaching
a maximum in July, thereafter decreasing.
3. Table III and Chart III show suggested in-
creases in diversion in the summer of 1942. The total
increases shown average only 1,250 c.f.s. on an annual
basis, Which added to the 1,500 authorized gives a total
annual ayerage diversion of 2,750 c.f.s.
As a temporary working basis to avoid nuisance
during 1941 and 1942, it is proposed that a minimum
dissolved oxygen content of one part per million be
maintained in Brandon Pool, as determined hourly at
’ the outlet of the pool.
Actual chemical analyses, made in the summers of
1941 and 1942, will provide a much safer criterion for
determining the increase of diversion needed for those
years than estimates which can be made at the present
time.
60
3596 Mouuman Exuisir No. 17.
Summary anp CoNncLUSIONS.
Report oN THE Fiusuinc Experiment AUTHCRIZED BY
U. S. Supreme Court.
The flushing experiment authorized by the U. S.
Supreme Court extended from noon ou December 2,
1940 to noon on December 12, 1940. During the test
the total flow at Lockport averaged 9,973 c.f.s. and
the diversion (flow at Lockport less water pumpage
in the Chicago area) 8,430 c.f.s. This was the maximum
flow capacity of the Drainage Canal at the time of the
test.
Samples were collected at fourteen stations, the most
important being those at Cass St., Joliet, just above
Brandon Pool, and at Brandon Bridge, just below
Brandon Dam. A total of 8,970 analyses were made.
The suspended solids test shows the amount of
sludge suspended in and carried along with the cur-
rent. During the 10-day test a total of 84,010 tons of
total suspended solids, on the dry basis, of which
27,067 tons were organic, were carried into Brandon
Pool. During the same period a total of 21,123 tons
of total suspended solids (dry basis), of which 7,512
were organic, were carried out of the Pool. The dif-
ferences, 62,887 tons of total and 19,555 tons of organic
solids, settled in the Pool. The amount that settled
was 75 per cent of the total and 72 per cent of the
organic solids. Therefore the test did not scour
solids out of Brandon Pool, but resulted in deposition
of large tonnages in the Pool. However, the solids
washed out of the Pool were siightly higher in per
cent of organic matter than those wich entered, as
the incoming total solids contained 32 per cent volatile
matter and the outgoing solids contained 25.6 per cent.
-
Ee
61 ,
The results of the determinations of biochemical
oxygen demand showed a reduction of 52.8 per cent
from Cass St. to Brandon Bridge. Therefore 47.z
per cent was carried out of the Pool. This indicates
that putrescible organic matter was scoured out of the
Pool to a greater extent than shown by the record of
the total and volatile suspended solids.
Samples were collected and soundings made of the
sludge on the bottom of Brandon Pool, before and
after the test. Soundings indicated a fill of 2 to 23 ft.,
equivalent to about one-half million cubic yards of wet
sludge. Anaiyses showed that the sludge had a higher
avidity for oxygen after the test than prior thereto.
Therefore the potential ability of the sludge to create
odors in the Pool has not been lessened. Throughout
the winter the sludge lies dormant because the tem-
perature is too low to generate the foul gases which
produce odors.
The level of Brandon Pool at the Dam was lowered
one-half foot to induce the flow of 10,000 ef.s. A
further lowering in the Pool level of about one foot
on December 7 may have been the cause of a slight
increase in the solids discharged from the Pool. How-
ever, even on this day 5,680 fons of suspended solids
entered the Pool and only 2,861 tons were discharged.
The increased velocity in the Main Channel scoured
out a surprisingly large tonnage of sludge. With
cleaner bottom conditions in tke Main Channel from
Chicago to Lockport, it is probable that the oxygen
demand at Lockport will be somewhat less than if
the test had not heen made. ‘The results show that
the concentrated 10-day effort carried out of the Main
Channel about 245 times as much organic sludge as
would normally be transported in one dry-weather
winter day with 1,500 c.f.s. diversion, and 94 times as
much organic sludge out of Brandon Pool.
62
During the test some 5,365 tests were made for dis.
solved oxygen. This indicator of purity was nearly
zero at Lockport prior to the test, and increased grad-
ually during the test to a maximum of 10.0 parts per
million. The day after the test concluded, 10.7 p.p.m.
was found, which quickly dropped to around 1.0 p.p.m.
At the lower end of Brandon Pool the dissolved oxygen
also increased to a maximum of 10.3 p.p.m. on the last
day of the test, and thereafter dropped to an aver-
age of 0.9 p.p.m. on December 17. This rapid de-
erease, together with the observation of gas ebullition
from the Pool when samples were collected on Decem-
ber 27, plus the fact of increased deposits of sludge of
more putrescible character, leads to the conclusion that
with the approach of warm weather, Brandon Pool
will again become foul and odorous. The dissolved
oxygen at Lockport will certainly drop to zero long
before the summer of 1941 unless the diversion of
water from Lake Michigan is increased progressively
as the temperature of the water increases.
The more putrefactive sludge deposited in Brandon
Pool during the test will begin to decompose in the
early summer more intensively than the older sludge
present at the bottom of the Pool before the test was
made. The foul and odorous putrefaction will be con-
centrated in the Pool unless relieved by diversion of
sufficient water from Lake Michigan to maintain at
least 1.0 p.p.m. of dissolved oxygen in the water at
the lower end of the Pool, as requested in the modified
petition of the State of Mlinois.
The effect of the test on the [linois River was
measured by samples and analyses at Marseilles, 45
miles below Lockport, and at Chillicothe, 112 miles
below. The results showed only a very moderate in-
crease of stpended solids and oxygen demand. The
increase of suspended solids at Chillicothe was mostly
clay or silt.
63
Tue Sanrrary Drsraror or CHICAGO,
Report oN THE FLusHine Exprerrment AUTHORIZED BY
U. S. Supreme Court.
Decemsper 2-12, 1940.
By F. W. Mohlman,
Director of Laboratories.
The flushing experiment authorized by the U. S.
Supreme Court started at 12 noon Monday, Dee. 2,
1940, and ended at 12 noon Thursday, Dec. 12, 1940.
The average flows in the Main Channel and Des Plaines
River, and the diversion from Lake Michigan.*from
noon te noon for several days before the test, for
the ten ;s of the test, and for several days there-
after, were as follows:
DiscHarRGE AND DrvzrsIon.
Cubic Feet per Second
Des Plaine
Date Diversion River
1940 Main Channel Metropolitan from Lake (Enters Belo
Noon to Noon at Lockport Pumpage Michigan Lockport’
Before Test
Nov. 27-28 2,866 1,497 1,369 97
28-29 8,214 1,498 1,716 87
29-30 2,849 1,488 1,361 §
30- 1 2,994 1,432 1,562 75
Dec. 1- 2 2,70& 1,450 1,258
Duriag Test
Dee. 2- 3 10,770 1,539 9,231 75
3- 4 9,828 1,568 8,262 75
45 10,246 1,554 8,692 70
5- 6 9,857 1,550 8,307 67
6- 7 9,645 1,557 8,088 65
7-8 9,679 1,486 8,193 75
& 9 9,949 1,498 8,451 98
9-10 9,843 ~ 1,565 8,278 112
10-11 9,819 1,553 8,266 127
11-12 10,09" 1,551 8,539 155
After Test
Dee. 12-13 3,772 1,541 2,231 173
13-14 2,543 1,523 1,020 160
14-15 2,356 1,466 8890 135
15-18 4,534 1,545 2,989 115
16-17 3,148 1,637 1,511 90
Note: Des Plaines River enters below Lockport, but above Cass St.
wk
64
The flow at Cass Street (Joliet) and at Brandon
Dam was the sum of the flows from the Main Channe]
and Des Plaines River.
Samples were collected and analyses made at prac-
tically all stations, from noon Nov. 27 , 1940, until noon,
Dec. 17, 1940. The most important stations, were those
at Cass St. and at Brandon Bridge, the latter being
about a thousand feet downstream from Brandon Dam.
Results of analyses at Cass St. showed the condition
of the water just above Brandon Pool, and those at
Brandon Bridge showed the condition just below the
Pool. Samples at Lockport were collected from the
Main Channel at the Ninth Street Bridge, some 8,800
feet above the Power House.
Upstream from Lockport, samples were collected
in Chicago as follows:
“Locks, Mouth of Chicago River
North Branch, Chicago Ave.
South Branch, Eighteenth St.
South Branch, Halsted St.
Main Channel, Damen Ave.
Main Channel, Kedzie St.
Main Channel, Summit
Downstream from Brandon Bridge, samples were
collected from the Illinois River at Marseilles and
Chillicothe. Nine special samples were collected daily,
from Dee. 6 to 17, in Brandon Pool above the Dam,
for determination only of dissolved oxygen.
The sampling schedule at the more important sta-
tions comprised collection of samples for suspended
solids hourly; for dissolved oxygen hourly; for bio-
chemical oxygen and turbidity every four hours. The
total number of analyses made was approximately as
follows :
es
sgt sth ln, OED Sore 5,365
Suspended Solids-........................ 2,285
on BETS 727
soc yet, ony GER EE ERE PRT ICTs 573
Sludge Analyses ......................... 20
8,970
SusPenpep Soums anp TvuRsmrry,
As the purpose of the test was to flush sludge out
of the Main Channel and Brandon Pool by increasing
the velocity, determinations of suspended solids, and
especially volatile suspended solids, were of particular
importance. Therefore hourly samples were collected
at Lockport, Cass St., Brandon Bridge and Marseilles,
and at less frequent intervals at Summit, Chillicothe
and other stations.
Determinations of turbidity were made at intervals
of four hours, or less often. The results are of little
significance because the solids transported by the in-
creased velocities were for the most part too coarse
to be measured as turbidity, but their actual concen-
tration was shown by the results of suspended solids
determinations.
Suspenpep Soums.
Lockport, Cass St., Brandon Pridge. The results
for 24-hour averages, in parts per million, are shown
in Tables I, IT, and IU, and individual hourly results
are plotted in Fig. 1 for Cass St. and Brandon Bridge.
Results in tons per 24 hours are shown in Tables IV,
5 ee
66
AverAGE 24-Hour Resvu.ts
Tue Santrary District or CHiIcaco
Martn CHANNEL AND ILLINOoIs RIVER
Parts per Miuion
-Dissotvep OxyGEN anD OxYGEN DEMANDS
AND o
Svu@pPenvep So.ips
Station Lockport Dates Nov. 27-Dec. 17, 1940
> Tase I.
Oxygen Demand
Dis- Diss. 20° C., D.p.m. Susp. Solids
charge Temp. Oxygen
Date Hour Sec. Ft. C° p.p.m. 5 Days Total Volatile
Results Before Test
iP.M
Sov. 27-28 12 Noon 2,866 7.0 1.2 14.8 16 s
28-29 3,214 6.8 0.7 16.4 19 5
29-30 2,849 6.7 0.5 16.8 17 11
30- 1 2,994 6.9 0.8 13.0 15 8
yee 1- 2 2.708 6.9 0.5 15.5 18 10
Results During Test
Yee. 2-3 10,770 5.0 1.6 55 327 83
3- 4 9,828 3.5 5.6 59 491 168
4-5 10,246 3.5 6.6 46 489 147
5- 6 9,857 2.5 8.0 35 319 116
6 7 9,645 3.0 8.7 32 264 108
7-8 9,679 3.0 9.2 27 193 65
& 9 9,949 3.5 9.7 be KY 179 53
9-10 9,823 3.5 9.8 20 172 60
10-11 9,819 2.5 9.9 21 161 53
11-12 10,090 3.0 10.0 20 148 47
Results After Test
Dec. 12-13 _ 8,772 2.5 10.7 12.5 48 17
13-14 2,543 2.0 10.2 12.7 1% 6
14-15 2,356 2.5 7.9 15.1 17 8
15-16 4,534 3.0 3.1 22 89 20
16-17 3,148 2.5 2.6 18.0 23 13
67
Averace 24-Hour Resvurs
Tue Sanitary District or Cxurcaco
Main CHANNEL snp Iturnois River
Parts PER Mruion | : .
DissoLvep Oxycen anp Oxycen DEMANDS
P AND
SusPenvep Soutims
tation Cass St. Dates Nov. 27-Dec. 17, 1940
Tasie II.
Oxygen Demand
Dis- Diss. 20° C., p.p.m. Susp. Solids
charge Temp. Oxygen | ;
Hour Sec. Ft. C° p.p.m. 5 Days Total Volatile
; Results Before Test
1 P.M.
Nov. 27-28 12Noon 2.963 5.7 1.9 13.0 _— —
28-29 3,291 5.5 0.6 22.0 cee —
29-30 2,929 6.5 0.6 17.3 21 12
30- 1 8,069 6.9 0.6 15.6 22 13
Dec. 1-2 2,778 5.6 1.1 13.4 20 11
Results During Test
Dec. 283 10,845 4.0 0.7 59 440 89
3- 4 9,903 2.0 = 61 504 184
4-5 10,316 3.5 47 482 188
5- 6 9,924 3.0 6.8 84 379 138
6 7 9,710 43 7.5 31 282 95
7-8 9,754 4.0 8.4 26 216 74
&- 9 10,047 4.5 8.6 17.0 216 -71
9-10 9,955 4.5 8.8 ' 20 198 64
10-11 9,946 4.5 9.0 21 188 61
11-12 10,245 5.0 8.9 19.4 177 57
Results After Test
Dec. 12-13 3,947 4.5 9.7 12.4 63 25
13-14 2,703 40 10.0 9.2 30 13
14-15 2,491 4.5 8.6 14.8 ZB 14 -
15-16 . 4,649 4.5 3.9 18.8 46 24
16-17 3,238 4.5 2.8 18.5 380 16
a 4‘
a
68
. Averace 24-Hour Resvtts
Tre Sanrrary District or Cu1caco
Marin CHANNEL anv Ixitnots RIver
Parts pER Mrmu1on
DissoLvep OxyGEN aND Oxycen DEemanps
AND
SuspPenpzep So.ips
Station Brandon Bridge Dates Nov. 27-Dec. 17, 1940
Taste ITI.
} Oxygen Demand
Dis- Diss. 20° C., p.p.m. Susp. Solids
charge Temp. Oxygen
Date Hear Sec. Pt. C° p.p.m. 5 Days Total Volatile
Results Before Test
» 1P.M.
‘ov. 27-28 12 Noon 2,963 ~ 59 9.4 8.8 19 12
28-29 3,301 5.9 8.5 11.8 18 li
29-30 2,929 6.5 4 15.3 14 10
30- 1 3,069 7.3 8.1 13.5 15 9
ec. 1-2 2,778 6.3 8.5 415 14 7
>
Results During Test r
lec. 23 10,845 5.0 8.1 13.9 75 1
3- 4 9,903 2.5 10.3 14.5 65 23
4-5 10,316 3.0 11.0 16.9 73 24
5- 6 9,924 3.5 11.4 15.4 91 37
6 7 9,710 4.0 11.4 18.5 79 31
7-8 9,754 4.0 11.5 22.4 109 37
8- 9 10,047 4.5 11.9 14.3 78 28
9-10 9,955 4.5 12.2 12.6 69 25
10-11 9,946 3.5 12.2 16.1 64 21
11-12 10,245 4.0 12.1 14.9 77 34
= Results After Test
Yee. 12-13 3,947 4.0 12.2 12.0 31 13 |
13-14 2,703 3.5 12.7 9.2 21 6 |
14-15 : 2,491 3.5 12.0 12.1 23 10 |
15-16 : 4,649 45 9.9 17.9 36 19
16-17 3,238 4.5 8.8 18.7 48 20
69
J AveRAGE 24-Hour Resutts
Tue Sanrrary District or Curcaco
Marin CHANNEL AND ILLINOIS River
Tons per 24 Hr.
DissoLvep Oxycen anp OxycEn DemManps
AND
SusPeENDED Soups
Station Lockport Dates Nov. 27-Dee. 17, 1940
Tase IV.
Discharge Diss. Tons per 24 Hr.
Date Sec. Ft Oxygen Oxygen
Demand Suspended
20° C., p.p.m. Solids
5 Days Total Volatile
Results Before Test
Noy. 27-28 2,866 9.2 114 124 62
28-29 3,214 6.1 142 165 69
29-30 2,849 3.8 130 182 85
30-1 2,994 6.5 105 121 65
Dec, 1- 2 2,708 3.6 113 131 73
Total 14,631 29.2 604 673 354
Avg. 2,926 5.8 121 135 71
Results During Test
Dec. 2-3 10,770 46.4 1,596 9,490 2,408
3- 4 9,828 148.4 1,562 18,000 4,450
4-5 10,246 182.1 1,269 13,490 4,057
5- 6 9,857 212.5 ' 928 8,470 3,080
6 7 9,645 226.0 832 2,810
7-8 9,679 240.0 704 5,085 1,695
8-9 9,949 260.0 474 4,800 1,421
9-10 9,843 260.0 531 4,565 1,592
10-11 9,819 262.0 556 . 4,260 1,401
11-12 10,090 272.0 S44 4,020 1,276
Total 99,726 2,109.4 8,996 73,990 24,190
Avg 9,973 211 900 7,400 2,420
Results After Test
Dev. 12-13 3,772 108.8 127 478 173
13-14 2,543 70.0 87 130 4i
14-15 2,356 50.1 96 108 51
15-16 4,534 87.9 269 476 244
16-17 3,148 22.0 153 195 110
Total, 13-14, 14-15, 16-17 8,047 1421 336 433 202
Avg. 13-14, 14-15, 16-17 2,682 47.4 112 144 67
‘
ee
70
@
Averace 24-Hour Resv.ts
txt
Tue Sanitary District or Cricaco
Matn CHANNEL Anp [turnots Rrver
Tons per 24 Hr.
DissoLvep OxyGEN AND Oxycen Demanps
SusPeNDED So.ips
Station Cass St. Dates Nov. 27-Dec. 17, 1940
TABLE V.
Discharge Diss. Tons per 24 Hr.
Date Sec. Ft. Oxygen Oxygen
Demand Suspended
20° C., p.p.m. Solids
5 Days Total Volatile
Results Before Test
Nov. 27-28 2,963 15.2 104 rae’
28-29 3,301 5.3 195 —
29-30 2,929 4.8 137 166
30- 1 3,069 5.0 129 182
Dec. 1- 2 2,778 8.2 100 150
Total 15,040 38.5 665 498
Avg. 8,008 17 133 168
Results During Test
Dec. 2-3 10,845 20.5 1,724 12,850
3-4 9,903 115 1,612 13,450
45 10,316 144 1,306 13,400
5 6 9,924 182 910 10,145
6 7 9,710 197 813 7,400
7-8 9,754 221 683 5,680
8& 9 10,047 233 460 5,850
9-10 9,955 236 537 5,310
10-11 9,946 241 563 5,040
11-12 10,245 245 535 4,885
Total 100,645 1,834.5 9,143 84,010
| Avg. 10,065 183 914 8,401
Results After Test
Dec. 12-13 3,947 103 132 670
13-14 2,703 73 67 218
14-15 2,491 57.7 oy 188
15-16 4,649 48.8 236 576
16-17 3,238 20.0 162 261
Total, 13-14, 14-15, 16-17 8,432 150.7 828 667
Avg. 18-14, 14-15, 16-17 2,810 50.2 109 222
71 ty
Averacr 24-Hour Resutts
Tue Sanirary Visrrict or Cxurcaco
Matn CHANNEL AND ILurnors River
Tons per 24 Hr.
Dissotvep Oxycen anp Oxycen Demanps
Station Brandon Bridge Dates Nov. 27-Dec. 17, 1940
Tasie VI.
Discharge Diss. Tons per 24 Hr.
Date Sec. Ft. Oxygen Oxygen
Demand Suspended
20° C., p.p.m. Solids *
5 Days Total Volatiie ¥
Results Before Test
Novy. 27-28 2,963 75 70 152 96
28-29 3,301 76 105 160 98
29-30 2,929 66 121 110 79
30- 1 3,069 67 112 124 74
Dec. 1- 2 2,778 64 &6 109 52
Total 15,040 348 44 655 399
Avg. 8,008 70 99 131 80
Results During Test
Dec. 2-3 10,845 237 406 2,192 526
3- 4 9,903 275 387 1,735 613
4- § 10,316 306 470 2,030 668
5- 6 9,924 305 412 2,435 990
6 7 9,710 298 484 2,069 812
7-8 9,754 802 589 2,861 974
8- 9 10,047 322 387 2,112 758
9-10 9,955 #27 338 1,850 670
10-11 9,946 27 431 1,715 563
11-12 10,245 834 » 412 2,124 938
Total 100,645 3,033.‘ 4,316 21,123 7,512
Avg. 10,065 . —-_s804 482 2,112 751
Results After Test
Dec. 12-13 3,947 130 128 330 138
18-14 2,702 93 67 153 44
14-15 2,491 80 81 154 67
15-16 4,619 124 - 225 457 238 (Rain)
16-17 ‘ 8,238 q7 163 419 175
Total, 18-14, 14-15, 16-17 8,482 250 311 726 286
Avg. -14, 14-15, 16-17, 2,810 83 104 242 95
a PEF LELISS: Ye RLV R IMC fe TE et te DONE OH TINGE BROS VA" Bs BIg TLE MEE A IE LORI EES TNT a OMy CEN BN woh orern cannes MS WLIO
Lee ikon oe r ‘a : ; : ais 4 e
72
AVERAGE 24-Hour Resutts
Tue Sanitary Disrricr or CxHicaco
Main; CHANNEL AND Iturnors RIver
Parts PER Mriui0on
Drssotvep OxyGEen AND OxyGen Demanps
AND
SusPeNvED So.ips
Sation Marseilles Dates Nov. 27 to Dee. 17, 1940
Tapie IX.
Oxygen Demand |
Diss. 20° C., p.p.m. Susp. Solids* |
Temp. Oxygen !
Date Hour Cc? p.p.m. 4 Days Total Volatile
Results Before Test
Nov. 27 1A.M.-12 Mdn. 6 10.5 4.6 29 6
i, 28 5 11.0 4.3 25 6
29 4 11.2 43 19 7
30 5 11.5 3.8 19 7
Dec. 1 5 11.7 4.6 17 5
Results During Test
Dec. 2 3 11.4 4.5 86 18
8 3 10.1 8.0 75 2»
4 5 10.1 7.6 58 13
5 4 11.6 7.3 53 z
6 5 12.0 7.3 46 16
q 5 12.1 7.3 63 17
8 5 12.0 7.3 57 22
yg 5 12.0 8.1 51 18
10 5 12.3 7.3 57
11 5 12.3 5.9 53
Results After Test
Dec. 12 5 12.2 8.5 39
13 4 12.0 73 16
14 4 121 4.6 14
15 a 120 18
16 8 12.3 15
*1 P.M. to 12 Noon.
73
Averacre 24-Hovur Resutts
Tae Sanitary District or CxHrcaco
Matin CHANNEL AND Iuuinots River
Parts per Mruion
DissoLvep Oxycen anp Oxycen DEMANDS
AND
Suspenpep Soups
s
Station Chilli¢othe Dates Nov. 27 to Dec. 17, 1940
TasBLe X.
Oxygen Demand
Diss. 20° C.p.p.m. Suspended Solid
Temp. Oxygen - :
Date Hour Cc? p.p.m. 5 Days Total Volati
Results Befcre 1 2st
Nov. 27 4.1 11.9 5.1 —_— —
28 3.4 11.9 3.9 25 7
29 3.3 12.1 3.7 32 9
30 3.5 12.0 3.0 23 6
Dec. 1 2.3 12.5 4.5 24 5
Results During Test
Dec. 2 2.3 12.6 3.7 26 6
3 0.6 12.9 . 4.7 34 Z
4 1.4 12.7 5.2 73 12
5 1.7 12.8 6.4 59 11
6 2.5 12.2 6.0 49 9
7 3.8 11.5 6.5 61 12
8 3.4 12.1 — 5.0 52 11
9 3.7 118 $ 431 47 9
10 3.7 44.7 6.6 ~ 55 13
11 3.5 11.6 5.8 39 10
Results After Test ’
Dec. 12 3.8 11.4 5.3 43 10
13 2.8 12.3 4.0 31 7
14 » Be 12.6 8.5 21 6
15 2.2 12.7 2.7 17 5
16 2.1 12.6 8.1 35 8
74
DissoLvep OxyceN AND FLow at Lockport
DecemBeEr, 1938, 1939 axp 1940
Flow, Cu. Ft. per Second
Day Dissolved Oxygen, P.P.M.
Dee. 1938 1939 1940* 1938 1939 1940°
. 5) 44 02 05 4,922 3,279 2708
2 24 ee 16 5,113 3,348 10,770
3 am 0.1 5.6 6.475 3,059 9,898
4 1.3 0.1 6.6 4,737 3,282 10,246
5 11 0.3 8.0 4,763 3,559 9,857
6 26 0.8 8.7 5.301 3,184 9,645
7 1.0 0.5 9.2 5,239 3,073 9,879
8 1.0 0.3 9.7 5,146 3,841 9/949
9 0.9 on 9.8 5,133 3,543 9,843
10 mt 0.3 9.9 5,144 3,029 9,819
11 0.4 11 10.0 5,019 3,293 10,090
12 14 14 107 5.200 3,706 772
13 3.2 15 10.2 5,467 4,112 2543
14 29 0.6 79 5,426 3,746 2.356
15 4.1 17 3.1 4,659 3,537 4,534
16 3.5 a 26 5,175 3,171 3,148
17 x 0.9 3.7 5,743 3,082 2.795
18 5.7 0.9 3.9 6,030 (328 2.440
19 6.5 1.7 0.8 6,203 244 2.403
20 6.6 1.7 0.2 6,231 3,546 2375
21 6.9 14 os 6,213 4,082 2.190
22 7.5 1.4 0.1 6,223 3.720 2.147
23 68 » a pies 6,257 3,116 2.217
24 os a a 5,271 3,117 2,534
25 a a = 5,200 2.956 2.066
26 5.5 19 0.2 5,273 3,529 2.329
27 72 26 0.5 5,605 3,893 2,397
28 7.8 3.5 st 6,313 4,126 2.294
29 1.4 4.5 0.3 5,568 3,787 2.199
30 8.2 ee 0.4 5,445 3,667 2.325
31 oie on sink 4,998 3,569 3,399
Avg. 4.3 1.3 4.9 5,469 3,469 4,996
*D.O. and flows from noon to noon through Dec. 16, thereafter midnight to midnight.
-
75
TaBLe XIX.
Diversion TEst
Tue Sanitary District or CHIcAGo
BiocHEemicaL Oxycen DeMaANnpD
Tons 5-day B.O.D.
Period of Test Per Day
RMON, TR noe ecu eee 9,143 914
Brandon Bridge ........... - 4,316 432
' Reduction ............. 4,827
Per Ct. Reduction...... . 52.8
Per Ct. Transported.... ' 47.2
Summit, Mouth of River, North Branch, South
Branch. Average results of B.O.D. determinations at
Summit ang upstream stations are shown in Tables
XI to XVIII, inclusive. At Summit the sludge de-
posits were washed out fairly completely during the
first five days of the test, and thereafter the B.O.D.
dropped to a low average of 13 p.p.m., because of the
increased dilution, whereas the B.O.D. had averaged
from 30 to 40 p.p.m. prior to the test. At stations
above Summit, also, the B.O.D. results were consid-
erably lower during the test than prior thereto.
SLupcE 1n Branpon Poor
Samples of siudge were collected from the bottom
of Brandon Pooi before and after the test. The first
set of samples was collected afore 1, 1940, and
the second set on December 219940. The procedure
for sampling sludge from the depths of an Imhoff tank
was used, namely, a pitcher pump with a calibrated
suction hose extending down into the liquid. The hose
was lowered until sludge was encountered, then the
pump was operated until the sludge ran uniform in
consistency, and the sample was takén. The depth was
recorded. Then the hose was lowered farther and
"6,
pumping continued until the sludge was quite dense
and almost refused to flow, when another sample was
collected.
During the first test, on November 1, 1940, the iron
sounding dise used by the U. S. Engineer Corps was
lowered until it came to rest, and the depth measured.
The record of the samplings and soundings is pre-
sented in Table XX. Samples were collected at Me-
Donough St., in the center of the Pool opposite the
U. S. Moorings, and at the north, center, and south
ends of the Dam.
The results for November 1 show that in the Pool,
thin sludge was encountered at about 18} feet depth,
thick sludge about 20 ft., and the sounding disc sank
to 203 ft. The thick sludge at 20 ft. depth in the
sample at the center of the Dam contained 88.8 per
cent moisture. This is a dense sludge in sewage works
practice. The disc method of sounding is shown by
these results to measure only the depth at which g
dense, compact deposit is found, as the heavy disc
sinks through the ‘‘floceulent active sludge deposits”’
referred to in the stipulation for the test. In the
sample opposite the Moorings, the dise stopped at
sludge with 93.7 per cent moisture, but at the south
end of the Dam (left of Locks) it sank below 94 per
cent moisture sludge, and at McDonough St. it came
to rest at 87.3 per cent moisture sludge.
When sludge collections were made at the same sta-
tions on December 27, 1940, after the test ended, it
wes found that the sludge level had not changed at
McPonough St., above the Pool in the, narrower sec-
tion, but at the Moorings the level had risen 2 to 24 ft.,
at the center of the Dam, it had risen 1 to 14 ft., and at
the left of Locks (South End) it had risen 14 ft.
whereas it had fallen 2 ft. immediately north of the
Dam.
77
TasLe XX.
Tue Sanitary District or CHIcaco
SamMpies oF Stupce CoL.ectrep From Rranpon Poor
November 1, 1940—Before Test Dec. 27, 1940—After Test
f Depth
. Clear Sludge Sounding Sludge
Water Samples by U. 8. Samples
Location at—Depth at Depth Engrs. Disc at--Depth Remarks
1 2. 1. 25 Ft. Thin Sludge
McDonough St. 24, Ft. 2. 25 Ft. 25%, Ft. 2. 25% Ft. Thick Sludge
1. 16 Ft. 1. 18 Ft. Thin Sludge
North of Dam 5%F. 2 Yt ITFt. 2. I8%Ft. Thick Sludge
: 1. 19 Ft. 1 18Ft. Thin Sludge
Middle of Dam 1814 Ft. 2. 20 Ft. 20 Ft. 2. 184 FX. Thick Sludge
1. 181% Ft. 1 17Ft. Thin Sludge
Left of Locks 18 Ft. 2. 19 Ft. 19¥, Ft. 2. 17% Ft. Thick Sludge
1. Q2WFt. 1. 18 Ft. Thin Sludge
U. 8. Moorings 19¥, Ft. 2. 21 Ft. 21 Ft. 2. 1814 Ft. Thick Sludge
Samples collected by means of pitcher pump and hose. Depths given are from surface
of water. ite
S
Considerable gassing, large bubbles. Had trouble holding Tug Gilbert from swinging,
due to steady northeast wind.
These results indicate that over most of the Pool
the sludge level had risen about 2 ft., except for some
scouring action «at the north end of the Dam, possibly
because of local currents induced at this spot.
<Lhis estimate of 2 ft. more sludge introduced into
thePool checks with the tonnage shown by the tests
for suspended solids. Table VII shows 62,887 tons
(dry weight) of suspended solids deposited in the Pool.
The specific gtavity of the sludge averaged 1.17 at
88.9 per cent moisture. One ton of sludge containing
around 12 per cent solids occupies approximately one
cubic yard of space.,: At 88 per cent moisture, 62,887
tons of dry solids would produce 524,000 tons or cubic
yards of wet sludge. The area of the Pool below Mc-
78
Donough St. is 5,456,000 square feet. A deposit of -
524,000 cubic yards would-fill this area to a depth of
2.6 ft. or at afower moisture content of 85 per cent,
to 2.0 ft. Considerably more sounding and sampling
would be neesssary to give accurate data on the
amount of sludge deposited in the Pool during the
test, but present available data indicate a fill of about
2 to 23 feet.
Results of determinations of B.O.D. of the sludge
are presented in Tables XXI and XXII. A compari-
son of results before and after the test computed to
B.0.D. of dry sludge, total and volatile, is shown in
the last two columns of these tables. The results show
an increased B.O.D. after the test for all stations ex-
cept one. However, eight samples out of ten. had an
increased B.O.D. of the volatile organic matter after
the test, as shown below:
B.O.D. per Gram or Vouatite Soups.
These results indicate that the sludge deposited in
the Pool during the test was slightly more putrescible,
and not so well stabilized as the surface sludge present
in the Pool before the test was made.
McDonough North of Center of Left of U.S.
St. Dam Dam Locks Moorings
Sample Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottem
| Before 142 114 245 212 280 170 246* 168 222 181
After 154 127 204 273 307 219 287° 197 176 158
* Corrections. *
79
TasLe XXTI.
. Tue Sanitary District or CxHrcaco
SAMPLES FROM Branpen Poot Berore FLUsHING
EXPERIMENT
November 1, 1940
Oxycen Demanp or Situpce—Branpon Poor
=
Solids , Volatile B.O.D.
On Ve Mg. Meg.
Oxygen Oxygen
Moisture Per Per
Station and Per Cent Mg. Gram Gram
Depth (After Per Gm. Per Gm. Oxygen Dry Dry
(Ft.) Draining) Cent Dry Cent Dry -P.p.m. Used Sludge Volatile
McDonough St. : “
25 92.4 7.6 0.76 26.6 0.20 2830 28.3 37.3 142
25.5 87.3 12.7 1.27 27.8 0.35 4000 40.0 31.5 114
North of Dam
16 97.3 2.7 0.27 33.7 0.09 2200 22.0 81.5 245
16.5 95.1 4.9 0.49 33.3 0.16 3400 34.0 69.4 212
Middle of Dam
19 98.5 1.5 0.15 34.4 0.05 1400 14.0 93.3 280
20 88.8 11.2 Lz 32.8 0.37 6300 63.0 56.2 170
Left of Locks
18.5 98.0 4.0 0.40 33.2 0.13 3200 32.0 80.0 246
19 94.0 6.0 0.60 32.7 0.20 3350 33.5 55.8 168
U. 8. Moorings
20 95.0 5.0 0.50
34.5 0.18 4000 40.0 80.0 222 -
21 93.7 6.3 0.63 33.4 0.21 3800 38.0 60.4 181
Weigtt of Wet Sludge Used — 10 gms.
80
Taste XXT.
Tue Sanrrary Distaicn OF Cuicaco
SaMPLEs FROM Brannon Poot AFTER FuusHine
EXPERIMENT
December 27, 1940
Oxycen Demanp or Stupce—Branvon Poor
Solids Volatile B.O.D.
Mg. Mg.
Oxygen Oxygen
Moisture Per Per
Station and Per Cent Mg. Gram Gram
_ Depth (Sampleas Per Gm. Per Gm. Oxygen Dry Dry
( Ft.) Received) Cent Dry Cent Dry P.pm. Used Studge Volatile
McDonongh St. ;
25 98.2 1.8 0.36* 39.6 0.14* 2150” ~ 21.5 59.8 1534
25.5 87.9 12.1 LZ 40.4 0.49 6250 62.5 51.6 127
‘North of Dam
18 95.1 4.9 0.48 32.0 0.16 4700 47.0 96.0 294
18.5 92.3 7.7 0.77 31.8 0.25 6830 68.3 87.6 273
Middie of Dam
18 97.4 2.6 0.26 34.5 0.09 2850 28.5 110.0 307
18.5 86.7 13.3 1.33 31.0 0.41 9000 90.0 67.6 219
Left of Locks
17 96.6 3.4 0.34 34.9 0.12 3450 34.5 101.5 287
17.5 86.6 13.4 1.34 31.7 0.42 8300 83.0 62.0 197
U. 8S. Moorings
18 ' 94.7 5.3 0.53 33.0 0.17 3000 30.0 56.6 176
125 85.5 14.5 1.45 29.4 0.43 8800 68.0 46.9 158
Wt. of Wet Sludge — 10 gms.
* Wt. of Wet Sludge — 20 gms.
»*
~
4015
4016
81
Moutman Exuisir No. 18.
Tue Sanrrary District or CxIcaco
Report on
ANALYseEs oF Sampues From MAIN CHANNEL
Lockport anp Summit
Month of January, 1938-1941
By F. W. Moxntman
Director of Laboratories
At the request of the Master, a report has been pre-
pared on the results of analyses of samples from the
Main Channel at Lockport and Summit for the years
1938 to 1941. The tabulations are attached hereto,
marked, respectively—
Mohlman Exhibit 18a. Dissolved Oxygen and B.O.D.
at Lockport; January, 1938
and 1941.
Mohlman Exhibit 18b. Total Discharge at Lockport;
January, 1938-1941.
MohIman Exhibit 18¢. Dissolved Oxygen and B.O.D.
at Summit; January, 1938-
1941.
Mohlman Exhibit 18d. Dissolved Oxygen and B.O.D.
at Lockport; January, 1938-
1941.
The following notes are explanatory of these four
exhibits.
The actual conditions at Lockport in January, 1941,
when compared with J anuary, 1938 show that the dis-
solved oxygen was far less in 194] than in 1938, with
an average of 7.4 p.p.m. in 1938 and only 0.8 in 1941
(through January 21). The B.O.D. values were ap-
proximately the same, with an average of 21.2 p.p.m.
in 1938 and 18.9 p.p.m. in 1941.
The great decrease in dissolved oxygen in 1941 was
82
largely due to the longer time of flow from Chicago to
Lockport, with the discharge of 2,781 ¢.f.s. in 1941, as
compared with 6,408 in 1938. In 1941, the time from
Damen Avenue to Lockport was approximately four
days, as compared with about two days in 1938. There-—
fore, in 194i, the dissolved oxygen was depleted down
to an average of 0.8 p.p.m. in spite of the low tempera-
ture of the water. This dissolved oxygen content is
almost as low as in 1939, but because of the increased
operation of the Southwest Plant, the B.O.D. in 1941
(18.9 p.p.m.) was considerably less than in 1939 (28.5
p.p.m.). |
The complete data through January 21, 1941, are
shown in Mohlman Exhibits 18a, 18b, and 18d for
Lockport and Exhibit 18¢ for Summit, attached hereto.
The daily 1941 results are compared with daily results
in January in 1938, 1939, and 1940.
The very low dissolved oxygen content in January,
1941 is cause for alarm, with reference to the condi-
tions to be expected a few months hence, when the
temperature of the water rises. So far in 1941, the
4017 C.O. results are lower than in 1940, and. the B.O.D. is
higher, indicating a worse condition in 1941 than in
1940. This is partly explainable by the slightly lower
flow at Lockport in 1941 (2,781 c.f.s.) as compared
with 2,949 ¢.f.s. in 1940. The low average in Janu-
ary, 1941 is due to the effort to conserve diversion this
winter in preparation for the demands next summer.
The results given herein are actual, from the actual
analyses of samples collected at the respective points.
Although some of the sludge deposits in the Main
Channel were moved down into the Brandon Road Pool
during the 10-day tests with 10,000 c.f.s., with the fow
reduced again to the low discharge prior to the test,
83 =
the conditions at Lockport are bad, in fact, the worst.
of any January on record, except 1939. If the condi-
tions at Lockport are now worse than in January, 1940,
Brendon Pool is certain to be worse, because of the
sludge deposited therein during the flushing experi-
ment. This disturbing result indicates that the only
safe basis for determination of the amount of water
needed in 1941 and 1942 to prevent nuisance at Lock-
port and in Brandon Pool is the ‘‘actual’’ analysis of
the water.
The modified petition of the State of Illinois requests
diversion based solely on results of analysis and speci-
fies the maintenance of at least 1.0 part per million of
dissolved oxygen in the water of Brandon Pool. In
1938, routine analyses were not made in Brandon Pool,
but werc made at Lockport, just above the Pool, with
the dissolved oxygen and B.O.D. results as follows
(iiinois Exhibit 34):
84
4018 Awatyses aT Lockport, Main CHANNEL
Year 1938
Dissolved 5-Day
Month Oxygen B. O. D.
7P. P. M P. P. M.
BONS © 6b vcceswesee ME wale oe dats cate aes 22.6
ery NE Mid das Osioa.c an endive 21.0
MOE Wedxeucecvweu thaws hax ceatus eines 19.4
MEE: SuvuseecuWaeues bscnedstasticnusncess 16.3
Pererrrrr sr rr ce C cdeadous soeveuvenee 17.6
ME: <encesevevgnee ed Dieieudwdteaewdteda te 18.8
> «ivencadcecass te lec skedvece tu tas enue 18.5
MGR. weveove veces i REE eae Apeeran t 14.6
September .......... vivectveswipeavesoks 13.4
EE cucetecssanea AER i eter 18.6
eee pe TERE gar semen. 18.5
SOD ccasceeanas Moree cetcienie ee kau ies 21.8
MVCTRRE (660 cctecccss Mus wie RWS eek oles ty ewes 18.4
Occasional samples in Brandon Pool in the summer
of 1938 showed from 0.2 to 1.5 p.p.m. dissolved oxygen,
and usually around 1.0 p.p.m. Maintenance of a mini-
mum of 1.0 p.p.m. in 1941 and 1942 would therefore
result in conditions approximately the same as in 1938,
but better than in 1938 or 1940. It is impossible at this
time to compute the specific amount of diversion
needed to maintain this standard.
~ ‘Twp ew leew ~ vel wry my AM Cnet AM Waa 2 ee -
‘t PS cee eed Gee eee See Obs Pes bee Pre ber ereees ’ + + apie | og bre Oe Pd) Eee ©:
at £80 Ope bee Bet bee bf he pot S81 bee Fs
wrt ede heeds > bed bot aoe : n te .
oe ERS the Obe ow) S60 064 bot poe bbe bbs bos ane ins opt ba i tit -; (Ps sistitich
Mt b+ p44 ede Madge ede 44+ pe ii hostel be eee ré ? re Mu
PTEre Tit Pes Hb iber Pett ttady Sbbeb edb bed dite: ' 4 t
roe Bi f: t ehrebre +34 tht + H: pF He + t 44
tt . sit: Tit : t . ? be | “
Tr t 4 s T T t rn
[eee tet htl ped bos hee 1] GET , t atTh
t rite tr tire tittity be bee ¥ on
T eee t T T j HPs 7
qi en: ‘ in Tt: i biateens 1S 3
th 4 tint iheasean i ? }
Tileedethe : + + > t T T *
agi 68 tit 4 + He ° i
4+ rhe rely r rf +L + + + So. .
+ Segeteee eee coe res } 7 i res Ut. , . *T-t ; TT >
a THT 1 T tin th ph ow bi : beenene
+ + 4 t ie ; + boa re So n oa endear pos oo9 oF . tthe t a
or Th; TY TG Y — ’ : * , "
oa 3 he mete e} y el EE) boa git bao o8! cenees & hy eed bes he 8 v Mt Ba 1 bs be be) EE
baaene ti he 444 rite ~ hee 7 eee SRO . ’ Hy bs
itt iti + Lb See bas he M ase t tt beens om pitri: rirth) T yon aed bat 4 wi bee ea
4 4 S4h44 Hitt 43 +444 tether q tt te eo eeee pes n ++ }°
Moctiy tttit rn I thth 8 Ti itt t ith uth ttt
r *T ‘i ‘ + ; + > r he
I , ? T
yas es 5a) T ++ + , t - ‘ 4 rete N)
t hooks -- 4 + rie
i + t , H+} et h44 b4 aH tt tess By ; ttt tthe: A
+ ; {> re - T eons re * w
HEHEHE t miseteseas ea tasty
+444 a -
++ +4 4 r a. ae
poses + + pee $9 t H+
++ +5 7 pe eeeee ‘
. z
bee ++t+ fe + 4 p« - + . ’
z=
i. i +t 4 = r . " a 4
.. A. sk ; ’
t TT 4 e re pa ’ ‘7
oH Tart eee ae 4 b pee O08 pe LH ~3
ee pad reneee we n : pat + t N
{ + + pee eee es) +4 4+ : 2t seaae at + seedete ~
: ° ? TT ‘ ' A
3 . + ¢ Bcsses t H Q
. {i ; im Tint + ease y
Host ° ?T* ri
tees tT Tr?
ett bees + a eeee T r
ry t iT T t ir Trt vs ek .
i LALLA IL ) 880800 Sheseresss bead i seso °
= one +4
®
7 . e . 1
6TOP “d ‘omy fpf-OT ‘ON LIGINYS NVTIEON seetutent seats : og
Ht j + PUreereeeeuret tt eves rn tH} 58
° repane es : :
seeks f it I tt boxe 3 e oe =$$H3 ? sf
, i + i . ;
Head te LTT 333 ahs at
. a
ste 4 ; Be
et : eat :
Het HH . ++ +t
‘ ae aa 3 bed +h
IITA i ST RoE SARL aa Hutt
. ad .
i ritttr peaseed tirrhilt! Leh H Z
349 LOU YY 49S Rta, ] AS OBHIBHD
s -- ——_
oN 39¥q4 ‘GOOG Pe WabANC PAAsoss/ 7 Aub ee Ag O3L40°4
(%6/-@66/ A70OnUes OSVSIHS 4O LDINLSIO AMVLINYS, SHL LtQOLAw2O7
4020 Mouuman Exuisir 18-b.
| Tue Sanrrary District or Cxtcaco
Toran Damy DiscuarcE aT LocKport
January 23, 1941.
Month 1938 1939 1940 1941
C.F.S. C.F.S. C.F.S. C.F-.S.
January
1 6422 2774 2849 3573
2 6197 2674 2849 4196
2 6343 2830 2895 2812
4 6384 4525 2896 2450
5 6497 2952 2930 2327
6 6303 2807 2845 2418
7 6201 2793 2795 2463
8 6180 2872 2900 2381
9 8203 3360 2870 3196
10 6149 3020 2805 3007
11 6218 2759 2786 2326
12 6261 2835 2911 2242
13 6160 284) 2838 2339
14 6131 285 6100 3496
15 6236 711 4287 2679
16 6199 2797 3891 2471
17 7 2711 2876 3188
18 6080 2817 2751 2579
19 6218 2776 2715 2357
20 6157 2817 2553 2344
21 6112 2795 2647 3474
22 6027 2728 2640 3008
23 8055 2739 2673
24 9132 2788 2661
25 6976 2751 2672
26 7035 2693 2812
27 7060 2815 2704
28 6376 2751 2531
29 6150 2672 2542
30 6886 3302 2607
31 6235 2695 2641
Mean 6408 2911 2949 2781
(Jan. 1-22'
» -
88
“4
4021 Mouuman Exuisrr 18-c.
Tue Sanrrary District or Cxurcaco
Matin CHANNEL AND Iturnots Rrver
DissoLveD OxyGen anp Oxycen Demanps
* Station—Summit Dates January, 1938-1941
Dissolved Oxygen, P. P. M. 5-day B. O. D., P. P. M.
Date
Jan. 1938 1939 1940- 1941 1938 19398 1940 1941
2 = —_- 8.0 71 oo oe 18 34
3 9.5 6.4 6.3 6.1 21.0 26.4 24 47
4 9.9 6.2 4.5 os 29.6 47.0 21 —_—
5 10.2 7.0 45 3.6 28.5 29.8 28 26
6 10.5 5.8 4.4 4.4 35.0 40,1 — 29
7 9.9 — 6.0 5.2 28.9 a 27 37
8 ~ 0.0 5.2 5.1 — 37.1 24 39
9 10.0 11 4.2 5.2 22.6 28.0 25 41
10 10.4 2.1 2.1 6.1 20.7 42.0 27 36 |
li 9.3 1.0 1.4 a= 28.1 51.0 23 _
12 = 0.5 1.4 4.9 —_ 52.0 32 32
13 10.3 0.1 5.5 — 50.0 — 31
14 9.6 — 4.1 6.1 28.1 _ 35 37
15 — 0.2 6.2 5.4 a — 19 40
16 10.5 0.3 5.0 5.3 25.3 26.0 35 47
17 10.0 0.8 4.1 5.5 22.9 42.0 30
18 9.8 0.5 -- a 25.9 47.0 27
19 9.4 1.0 — 1.0 23.8 7.0 —-
20 9.9 0.3 we 3.2 27.7 52.0 —
21 9.6 —~ 4.6 4.6 25.8 — 22
22 — 0.5 4.8 mo 48.0 25
23 9.7 11 5.0 21.9 26.0 20
24 E. 2.2 4.9 35.9 53.0 23
25 10.0 3.9 3.5 26.5 40.0 29
26 10.3 3.7 2.1 29.0 51.0 25
27 10.3 21 — 30.1 51.0 22
28 10.3 — 3.0 30.0 _ 22
29 — 3.7 3.7 — 39.0 24
30 9.1 = 4.2 ae po an
31 10.0 6.9 3.0 ! y 2 *
(Jan. 1-21) Hess 3
Avg.
Jan. 1-17 49 26.8 38.9 26 37 (Jan. 1-16)
Avg. Month
9.8 2.4 44 — 26.8 40.3 26 - =
89
4022 Mouutman Exursrr 18-d.
Tue Sanitary District or CxuIcaco
Man Cuannet ann Inurnors Rrver
DissotvEp OxycEen AND Oxycen Demanps
Station—Lockport : Dates January, 1938-1941
Dissolved Oxygen, P. P. M. 5-day B. O. D., P. P. M.
Date
Jan. 19388 1939 1940 1941 1938 1939 1940 1941
2 94 46 ‘47 O58 13.3 140 10.7 181
3 9.0 2.6 5.3 1.8 12.0 15.8 10.3 11.6
4 7.7 1.4 5.1 — 20.5 18.8 &.9 —
5 7.8 0.7 3.0 1.0 26.3 24.3 12.2 23.8
6 7.9 0.2 _. 0.9 24.7 26.2 — 19.9
‘i 8.2 — 1.8 0.7 22.5 — 14.5 13.5
8 — 0.2 1.7 0.9 — 24.5 13.3 10.3
9 7.6 0.1 1 Be | 6.7 21.1 30.4 13.5 21.6
10 8.1 0.2 | 0.6 19.8 26.6 10.2 21.5
ll 8.0 0.2 0.9 —_ 19.9 22.5 14.5 _
12 7.1 0.2 0.4 1.0 25.0 25.4 17.9 16.4
13 7.3 0.2 a 0.5 23.4 33.6 se 24.3
14 7.7 — 0.6 0.7 22.3 — 22.4 20.7
15 — 0.2 1.6 0.8 — 33.8 20.6 25.0
16 6.1 0.1 2.4 1.4 24,2 38.3 15.7 17.1
17 7.7 0.2 4.0 0.6 18.0 32.5 18.0
18 7.5 0.2 1.4 os 21.2 23.4 17.9
19 7.0 0.2 1.9 0.7 21.3 32.2 15.6
20 §.8 0.1 0.4 22.7 34.4 —
21 5.8 --- 11 0.3 24.0 a 17.0
22 — 0.2 1.0 — 38.1 15.1
23 5.8 0.1 1.0 21.3 38.1 15.6
24 6.2 0.4 1.2 30.8 31.8 13.8
25 3.6 0.2 1.6 31.4 23.0 11.9
26 7.8 0.3 1.2 27.3 29.9 14.0
27 8.6 0.2 —_ 24.1 29.7 _
28 8.5 — 0.4 24.3 _ 17.9
29 —~ 0.2 0.5 — 34.0 16.3
30 7.9 0.1 0.4 25.7 36.4 15.5
31 74 0.5 0.7 20.4 21.7 12.8
Jan. 1-21)
Avg.,
Jan. 1-16 0.8 21.2 25.7 142 18.9 (Jan. 1-16)
Avg. Month
28.5 14.8 18.9 (Month)
7.4 0.5 18 _ 22.6
90
4466 MouuMan Exarstr 20.
Tue Sanrrary District or Cuicaco
Matin CHANNEL AND Inutnors River
Dissotvep Oxycen anp Oxycen Demanps
Station— Lockport Dater —January 1941
Diss. Oxygen Demand, 20°C., p. p.m.
Date Temp. Oxygen
td p. p. m. 5 days
1
2 7.0 0.5 18.1
3 6.0 18 11.6
5 3.5 1.0 23.8
6 3.5 0.9 19.9
7 2.0 0.7 13.5
8 2.0 0.9 10.3
9 3.5 0.7 21.6
10 4.0 0.6 21.5
12 5.5 10 —— 16.4
18 5.6 0.5 24.3
14 4.0 0.7 20.7
1h 4.0 0.8 25.0
16 4.5 14 17.1
17 4.5 0.6
19 4.0 0.7 22.9
20 4.0 0.4 31.6
21 4.5 0.3 29.9
22 5.0 0.2 30.2
23 5.0 0.4 21.7
24 5.0 0.4 19.1
26 3.0 0.4 30.6
27 4.0 0.2 34.5
28 4.0 0.2 26.7
29 3.5 0.6 15.4
$0 4.5 0.2 30.3
31 5.0 0.3 33.3
Average 4.5 0.6 22.9
91
3666 Pearse Exuusir 1-A.
Tz Sanitary District or Curcaco
Activatep Stupce Sewace TREATMENT Works
Recorp or Air Usep—Cusic Freer Per GALLON oF
SEWAGE
NITRITES AND NITRATES—pP.P.M.
AVERAGE For YEAR 1928-1940
Year North Side Calumet Southwest
Air Nitrite Nitrate Air Nitrite Nitrate Air Nitrite Nitrate
(a) 1928 0.97 0.2 4.5
1929 0.80 0.2 5.0
1930 0.52 0.7 2.0
1931 0.47 0.4 2.2
1932 0.44 0.4 3 3.3
1933 0.37 0.6 y hy § *
1934 0.38 0.3 2.3
1985 036 0.6 1.6 .
‘ 1936 0.36 0.3 1.0 0.41 0.5 1.3 .
1937 0.35 0.3 0.6 0.38 0.4 1.0
1938 035 03 LI 036 06 12 4
1939 0.37 0.2 - 07 0.38 0.7 1.9 (b) 0.46 (b) 1.2 (b) 1.2
1940 6.40 0.1 0.6 0.42 6.6 1.1 0.83 0.4 13
(a) Period 3 moaths, Octqber to December, inclusive.
(b) Period 6 months, July to December, inclusive.
33206 Pearse Exursir 7.
At the present time the U. S. Census figures for
1940 are not completely available. However, certain
figures released in the newspapers are indicative of
the probable population of The Sanitary District of
Chicago in 1940. The following comparisons are of
interest, from U. S. Census figures:
Locality 1930 1940 —s Increase
MEE cc ntidasdinckvieeceereo: ' 3,376,438 3,384,556 8,118
eee IR La ee eae cere 3,982,123 4,049,331 67,208
iad kat ............ ... 8,901,569
For 25 of the smaller municipalities within the Sani-
tary District (out of 61) a growth of 4.3 per cent was
92
shown since 1930 by the 1940 census figures given out.
Evidently this rate of growth was not sustained by the
entire Sanitary District, because this would make a
population estimate greater than Cook County, which
contains the Sanitary District.
Taking from the 1930 census the population outside
of the Sanitary District but within Cook County as
80,554, and assuming this as of 1940, the Sanitary Dis-
trict has in 1940 a population not to exceed 3,968,777,
with a growth not exceeding 67,208. This upper limit
is considerably under 4,815,000 estimated in 1930.
From the census releases to the press comes the
additional information on municipalities within the
Sanitary District:
Locality Growth
MN SC GRE Na ORY ERE L Asin a hades ns oe ov oo kool obs vee 8,118
Se I SE 8 69 ala wo no ved oo okvk elo ee hon 12,688
ME Ge SE MIMD ihids honk bos o4 sok bea roves codwcew. 3,986
Actual increase from 29 municipalities reporting............. 24,792
If 24,792 be added to 3,901,569, a low limit of 3,926,-
361 may be established. It is probable the true popu-
lation of the Sanitary District lies in between this
figure and 3,968,777 and may be taken at 3,966,569, or,
in round figures, 3,966,600.
The changes in the populations of the various proj-
ect areas may be estimated as:
Area 1930 Census Increase 1940 Estimate
CE 6 Heri eo S53 oS: 319,588 5,500 325,088
RI. GS a Use < webws 977,024 22.000 999,024
ES SY is we woos we tek 1,288,763 — 3,500 1,285,263
RE seg ae i re 1,311,637 40,031 1,351,668
Miscellanecus ............. 4,557 - 1,000 5,557
8,901,589 65,031 3,966,600
ced
i
, \ 5 ii
i \ nye
; \ men
} \ a Fil
cae 1‘ }
Bale es A \g
ee \
ib. : \
a = | NG
Diet ia \
ie > >
95
2220 Ramey—Exursir No. 2.
AVERAGE TIME oF FLow—DaMeEN Ave. To Brannon
Rp. Dam.
Lake Michigan Elevation—0.60
Average Lockport Discharge.................... 2200 C.F.S.
Damen Ave. to Gummilt.........cccccccccccuce.; 62 :22 Hrs.
UNOS Oo Lactert. 6 ooo s. ciceccccccsecencc’., 78:58 “
Lockport to Brandon Rd. Dam................. 24:48 *
Mei inkse oatad sored nes ow teu 166:08 “
Lake Michigan Blevation—0.60
Average Lockport Discharge.................... 2800 C.F-.S.
Damen- Ave: to Summit........................ 37 :34 Hrs.
«ie nttalhn Be mca, SOE Pr IE Rennes 61:13 “
Lockport to Branden Rd. Dam................. 19:21 “
Total..... pale ke Ook Oe <idis ald coe ne 118:08 “
Average Lockport Discharge 10,000 C.F-.S.
Lake Michigan Elevation—0.60
Se OO Cr sven ls enccecuxteieecne 9:32 Hrs
EE OD BMI yoo 650A bien c de enh debe cea 16:24 “
Lockport to Brandon Rd... 2.6... ccccccccecce, 5:39 “
Wr ivaveroesciscarcn becca: 31:35 “
96
t 92 a OL 0 62 I #8 ey ee ice ee ES. q#neg suydoog mM
0 OL 0 6 rs A 0 I 0 a se Oe ee ere wee ene I9AIT proqd4y,
ST 82 tg SCOTT. ir 2g Pr a Sh RO A ne oe ee S}SO[NIIIGN TL,
0 I rt) g 0 0 0 tL eo x0g eag
0 LOL T L112 g 99T 9 cee ee ee IdA0gq J1BIg
fl Zz T . $2 0 0 0 0 eee ee eee en enene SPTeAMOTIOg
62 OF bat) SIt 61 cI ry 9g ey Byuomneug
0 0 Oo 0 0 0 rt) 0 , eres Mmm ed ee gS eT St} JuyueRy
0 zZ 0 6 0 LLI I LIC ee sos vay
0 0 0 0 c c 0 L ee ee et BIB vA
iA ti SS 9¢ ¢ 4 OL Oot eee ee tee ee ete eaneeee Bzue Bu
[ £ I zZ 0 rt) 0 oO 0 eee eee eee ene eee sHTeqdeoug
) i £ I 8 s 5 2 Z F? Seoeeeeesesesseeeeees Bpleqidig
BUI SeSVO SUI SOSBD Sq sosuyQ syiq seseQ sqIg sesuy syiq saseO
yor "OO TIAA yor[or OO TIEAA yoror "OO TTA
Leet Seé6r 686T
Wve oqug :
jo yuoujredeg srourly Jo sjrodey penuuy wo,
(‘seinstg AJIQ epnypout seans1,y Ayun0g9)
‘ALNQOD TIM INV LAVIO£ NI SHLVAaG ANV SasvO
‘SESVASIG] TIAVOINANWOD
‘9 ‘ON LIMIHXW 8, LNANOdIO 9Z1Z
97
& OF € 19 1 62 a 0 oO 0 es ET oda ""q3no0p Auydooy
0 9g er I LI .: = L lz L _, WO aaa Witte A, ivA9q pjoqdAy,
Lt 6L 6L LST Zs «60 29 COLT 02 OL ee, Seat bah tld hg ea Satie S}sO[MIIOqGN,
0 I ® 0 I o ae a. Mot Mbeeeawek Aueaneaey xoq [emg
$ 8 9 O6I £ 4f8 OL 802 g 16 9 Bee oe en Pree nes 19A9T JIB
ee ee ae 0 0 os ee ee eee STI [eAMIOTIOg
ee 69 28s SET te 6989 18 sit ce 6S WHE oor te tennnren ** Byuounoug
b 8 48 ae ae S 3 a. ahi ey "Tes" sHsuyUOW
£ 28 a } OOF 0 £ 0 It So P 7 Zol eeeee ee eee eeeee ee eee So[svoy_
0 0 0 \ a Oo 0 T 0 0 yA 0 / eee er ee eee ew eee eee eee BIIVle
ol ut 4g 98 4 ie o 4 $9 98 eI SI of IF Re a ee Bzuenguy
payiodey JON , poyiodey 30N pezy10dey JON Caen tk
t g cg bd SE -g 8s 0 L g co Ceoeeeteeresrses eeeee Byleqidig
SHI SBD STIG SOSVD STIG Se8BQ STIG sesBQ syIG sesBO 8tId SasBQ
yyOL ‘00 1A. yoqjor OD TTA yror ‘OO THM
1861 . 286T S86T ’
831%
0 L I £9 +> 68 L goer t S eet Pe oak. ysnopH Zujdooqm
t a § t &@ 0 OL 0 0 € IL € a hberhigaek has 1040q proydéy,
it) ae 29 =o BET. $I 28 ‘SF OT8T 1% gs Ol Ge. Sate res Wisin S}sO[MIIEqnNy,
0 T 0 I 0 T 0 T bs O0OT T 881 ere ee ee ee etree eoeeeee x0d [eug
- © S8B GS ZHI Ss 69 b ve 0 02 See eens eras JaAaq JO[IBIg
0 I te - 0 oO Tt O 0 0 0 RRS hatha abt it. SI [PAMIOTOg
t 8¢ 98 TOT &% O88 ™ 08 % «6 os Se. er eet e oe eens ** Byuouneug
0 I 0 T g E g g 0 0 0 Z eeeeeoeeesseeneeeee STL sujueK
0 9¢ I C6I } $2z 9 Tss 0 £ 0 5 od eee eee eee ee een eeeaeee So[s boyy
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 rt) 0 0 oO 0 eee er eee eee eeereeneee ef BlIVleA
9 6 ct cI : oe $ ZI cl ot ae. Lereere eta Libaadi. ezuonguy
o oO 0 oO ae. $ F 0 oO BE, SE at agra sbe ct sHTeqdooug
t 6 a ‘an? | 9 $s Me TO he abdetieigdc. Begg
SUI SOSBD SUIC SSB SIC SesBD syIC sesvy syIq sesug squid sesep
yoror OO 11M yeT10L ‘OO TAL TOL "OD TILA
FE6T Geet 986T
LEIG
98 {
2129
1930
Will Co. Joliet
Cases Dths Cases Dths
DE ideas sedwke whew a eaeaton 34 2 21 %
NED wv watdueusevesseccnns Not reported
EO a eG acre wed 26 27 6 13
ME ad et ara oes © Bare oi a 0 0 0 0
PS ee rr eee ee 19 0 11 0
Meningitis ....... eee ere 3 0 2 0
ph OPES Rn pag eA et 117 +74 4 38
RRO. oo acces er crce seas 1 0 0
OO. sh ck crc cantante 84 4 41 1
MEO akc ons o Vaio ad bone awe er 1 0 0 0
<a Bem eR OR & 150 93 103 34
UE NOs caw cusc eee aowets 25 3 20 2
UE SPUN ys ks cu cceseseces 43 + 18 2 |
2133 OpponEnt’s Exutsir No. 7.
City or Jouiet.
State of Illinois.
January 6, 1940.
Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners,
City of Joliet, Illinois.
GENTLEMEN:
{ wish to submit my report for the year ending as
ef. December 31, 1939.
Communicable Cases Reported.
SN NS dep okua's saad Koubsmeda ee dnaee dicen 28
DE Ctckenkadené dav scaksusedccencLieinuck.. 5
EE I a rin oun dian ercale os Cece: 1
EE 84. tb Sniesn du secede cn gioedcundedece o 6
RL TRU be von'een hee hace dbeees cacils cast teks 1
ID Ctanty a wkd neal ela ens Ga eats titan. fh 31
EE Se eae ep nt pil esti ope 10
MOE TUE oda he cwg ab dacie\ a eecece ap ankees 9
CE ea hidaid ivan tdtic de uunactbaneun cukiul 1
EE SNS a co. ws Sona b eeaces Ae oe ve ae
EE chine Weba Guau ce badaskanen wns covucety? YY 41
ss x Gu tS haere dina Mas Racked sb bedi cues: 11
NE ahs Cine. cavedauvaawornd ci cco nk hke cee ck 1
ME Sekai sweat heen cet bbeu ehouaucinbldgocdexs 21
SSSI REND ghee ae see poem eee Sal 1
Miscellaneous Inspections and Complaints.......... 326
Dilapidated Homes Inspected............ eC ee 52
Barber Shops Inspected............... APE re pee 167
}
Yr
2641
2642
99
The health department also participated in a Weed,
and Rat and Mice Exterminating Campaign, both
proving very successful.
Respectfully submitted,
Frank WEDIc,
City Sanitarian.
FW.itm
*
and
OpponENtT’s Exnisit No. 7.
Culture plates were exposed to the air in the vicinity
of the Des Plaines River and the Sanitary and Ship
Canal from Lockport to Joliet. Ten locations were
selected along the banks of the waterway and six loca-
tions about seven miles west and six locations about
four miles east of the waterway. One plate of nutri-
ent agar and one plate of Sabouraud’s were exposed
at east location for periods of from 3} to 43 hours on
July 16, 1940. After exposure the plates were col-
lected, taken to the laboratory, and incubated for 48
hours at 37.5°C, after which colony counts were made.
Following is a description of the various bacteria
together with the time of exposure at each location and
results of colony counts:
100
Colonies on Agar Plates Hours of Bacterial
Nutrient Sabouraud’s Exposure Forms
No. 1 100 3 4.63 1-2-4-§-8
No. 2 36 10 4.21 1-8
No. 3 38 6 445 1-2-6-8
No. 4 0 3 4.21 8
No. 5 35 30 4.23 1-6-8
No. 6 90 10 417 1-6-7-8
No. 7 23 15 3.81 1-5-8
No. 8 52 7 3.77 1-5-8
No. 9 8 5 3.81 1-7-8
No. 10 35 0 3.83 1-8
No. 11 32 11 3.63 1-7-8
No. 12 5 2 3.58 1-8
No. 13 27 5 3.55 1-7-8
No. 14 91 75 3.48 1-7-8
No. 15 ‘5 12 3.51 1-7-8
No. 16 42 7 3.43 1-8
No. 17 0 13 4.83 8
No. 18 27 15 4.85 1-8 e
No. 19 147 2 4.85 1-3-7-8
No. 26 1s 125 4.85 1-7-8
No. 21 overgrown overgrown 4.91 18
No. 22 overgrown overgrown 4.88 1-8
_ No.1 Gram positive rods (Hay Bacillus)
No.2 Gram positive rods (Diptheroid)
No.3 Gram positive rods (Streptobacilli)
No.4 Gram positive cocci (Staphylococci)
No.5 Gram positive cocci (Staphylococci)
No.6 Gram negative threads
No.7 Gram negative rods :
No.8 Molds
DescrIPTION oF LOCATIONS.
1. Plates exposed on window ledge of vacant house
overlooking the Des Plaines River on the north side of
Jefferson Street, Joliet, at the west end of the Jef-
ferson Street bridge from 10:15 A. M. to 2:53 P. M.
2. Plates éxposed on west bank of Des Plaines
River south of Jackson Street bridge, Joliet, from
10:45 A. M. to 2:58 P. M.
3. Plates exposed en west bank of Des Plaines
River east of factory sidings southeast of Phoenix
Mfg. Co. plant, between Joliet and Lockport, from
10:35 A. M. to 3:04 P. M.
4. Plates exposed on top of concrete abutment out-
Ca _ —— a
101
side rails of bridge approach at west end of 16th
Street bridge over the Sanitary and Ship Canal on
the south side of 16th Street, Lockport, from 11:00
A. M. to 3:13 P. M.
0. Plates exposed on top of south concrete wall of
west approach to bridge over the Sanitary and Ship
Canal at 9th Street, Lockport, from 11:08 A. M. to
3:22 P. M.
6. Plates exposed on top ot concrete wall just-out-
side of railing on east bank of Sanitary and Ship
Canal just south of east end of 9th Street Bridge,
Lockport, from 11:10 A. M. to 3:20 P. M.
2643 7. Plates exposed on top of concrete wall just out-
side of railing on east bank of Sanitary and Ship
2644 Canal just south of east end of 16th Street bridge
Lockport, from 11:25 A. M. to 3:14 P. M.
8. Plates exposed on top cf concrete wall at east
bank of Des Plaines River at the locks, about one
mile south of 16th Street, Lockport, from 11:30 A. M.
to 3:16 P. M.
9.. Plates exposed on top of concrete wall just north
of Cass Street bridge on east side of Des Plaines
River at Joliet, from 11:45 A. M. to 3:34 P. M.
10. Plates exposed on roof of cabin of boat tied
in the Des Plaines River north of Jefferson Street
bridge on the east side of the river from 11:50 A. M.
to 3:40 P. M.
11. Plates exposed in depression in earth around
the base of a small tree on east bank of Plainfield-W.
of Chicago Road beside the first gravel parking space
just north of Troy Road, about six miles west of Joliet,
from 12:10 A. M. to 3:45 P. M.
12. Plates exposed on top of concrete culvert at
’
102
northeast corner 2f intersection of Plainfield-W. Chi-
cago Road and Black Road, from 12:15 P. M. to 3:50
P. M.
13. Plates exposed on top of concrete culvert at
northeast corner of intersection of Plainfield-W. Chi-
eage Road and ¢ross road one mile north of Black
Road, from 12:30 P. M. to 3:53 P. M.
14. Plates exposed on top of concrete culvert at
northeast corner of intersection of Plainfield-W. Chi-
cago Road and Caton Farm Road (175th St.) from
12:25 P. M. to 3:54 P. M.
15. Piates exposed on stump near northwest cor-
ner of intersection of Plainfield-W.’ Chicago Road and
2645 cross road 2 miles north of Caton Farm Road, op-
posite Bundy Farm, from 12:26 P. M. to 3:58 P. M.
2646 16. Plates exposed on top of concrete curb at the
rear of (east) Johnson’s Filling Station, Plainfield,
on the east side of Plainfield-W. Chicago Road near
Route U. S. 30, from 12:33 P. M. to 3:59 P. M.
17. Plates exposed in Pilcher Park about 34 miles
east of Joliet via Route U. S. 30, on top of sign read-
ing ‘‘Short Way Out’’, from 1:10 P. M. to 6:00 P. M.
18. Plates exposed on stone under tree at south-
east corner of intersection of Smith Road and Maple
Road, from 1:15 P. M. to 6:05 P. M.
19. Plates exposed on top of concrete abutment
east side of north end of bridge over Spring Creek on
road passing north and south through Gaugers, about
4} miles east of Joliet, from 1:18 P. M. to 6:10 P. M.
20. Plates exposed on step of transformer shed at
southeast corner of ‘‘Gaugers’’ road and 175th Street,
from 1:23 P. M. to 6:15 P. M.
21. Plates exposed on top of John Lane memorial
103
stone at northeast corner of intersection of ‘‘Gaugers’’
road and 167th Street, from 1:27 P. M. to 6:22 P. M.
22. Plates exposed on top of concrete culvert at
southeast corner of intersection of ‘‘Gaugers’’ road
and 159th Street.
2828 Opronent’s Exursrr No. 10.
Sources or Oxycrn
FOR me
PREVENTION or ComMpLAINTs FROM BRANDON Poor.
Pounds of
Oxygen per
24 Hours
1. Increase of diversion from 1500 to 5000 c.f.s.—3500 cfs
ER caver neenacinamnadededdtvrnacsito 150,000
2. Increased air used to produce 15 p.p.m. of nitrate and
nitrite oxygen and 7 p.p.m. of D.O. in effluents of N.
Side and Calumet plants 370 M.G.D. @ 18 p.p.m....... 55,000
3. Reaeration at Lockport over properly designed cascades.
Average flow 3130 c.f.s. D.O. pickup avera;e of 6%
eer ee MESS aRA LD ERTL ee ear 113,000
(equivalent to 2638 c.f.s. of lake water)
4. Reaeration at Lockport if flow is regulated to equalize
D.O. rather than flow. Summer flow == 4200 c.f.s. @
Ave. D.O. pickup of WW PNM Oa ci eee oe cea te 152,000
5. Regulation of annual diversion SO as to equalize pounds
of oxygen diverted rather than quantity of water. (Ave.
D.O. of Lake Michigan water 10.75 p.p.m.) Equivalent
to adding during the critical summer months......... 22,000
104
2832 Qpponent’s Exursit No. 11. :
Means or Repvucine B.O.D. Loap to Canau
TO
AmeELiornaTE on Remepy Conpitions ComMPpLaAINED
oF aT Branpon’s Poot.
B.O.D. of Brandon Pool 3130 ¢.f.s. @ 25 p.p.m. .420,000# /day
Major Sources of B.O.D. during summer of 1940
West ged —— (June) 391 MGD
YE BS Seperrirrerrer rete re 268,0004
Be Side ‘Gen 365 MGD @ Ti
she b4emedehdienk ecb shades 216,000#
ow. . 'N. Side sludge to canal 19,409 >
tons of total of 63,643 tons i.e.
30144% of — B.O.D. of 3,721,000
population @ .167# B.O.D./cap./
SE (vcmbbakekovatececdee sn verses 105,000#
529,000#
Ameliorating Measures other than more Oxygen
{Activated sludge plant effluents assumed in
oxygen balance)
1. Chemical treatment @ West Side reduce
B.O.D. 21 p.p.m.—437 M.G.D. (May) (April
71940 report) .....ccc-cccceccccececcvcens 76,000# B.O.D./day
2. Activate entire West Side Imhoff effluent at
DLW; OE: ccneetscvecesevesescccevsesuss 200,000# B.O.D./day
8. Eliminate by-passing of part of S.W. flow
after primary treatment only............. 81,000# B.O.D./day
4. Keep all sludge out of canal................ 105,000# B.O.D./day
5. Chlorination 2 p.p.m. B.O.D. removal per
p.p.m. of chiorine—6 p.p.m. chlorine on
entire canal flow of 3130 c.f ........... 200,000 # B.0.D./day
Total B.O.D. reduction by methods other than
wire and chemical treatment (Nos.
MMe GUAGN oc Gudescesdbectebbekoestetsienes
Roa oe oes aac eed ceeatevi ss hacaes
*
— RRS ROE age Shee
105
2847 OpponEnT’s Exursit No. 12.
EstTimaTEp Cost or MEasurEs To
ALLEVIATE oR REmEpY Conpitions CoMPLAINED
oF aT Branpon’s Poon.
Approx.
Approx. Annual
Cost to Operating
Description Instali Cost Time Required
1, Increased air used at N. Side and Calu-
met activated slidge plants
(a) Based on 5 mos. oneration.......... 0 $ 89,000 None
(b) Based on 12 mos. operation......... 0 216,000 None
(a) Based on 5 mos. operation.......... $1,300,500 200,000
‘ (b) Based on 12 mos. operation......... 1,300,590 481,700
3. Chlorination of Canal water............ 360,060 70,000 6 to 9 mos.
to
200,000
4. Aeration of Canal water above Lockport. 50,000 o* 3 to 6 mos.
to
100,000
5. Regulate annual diversion to .qualize D.O.
EE: CE ons ceo cuucawee nekak es 0 0 None
6. Dredge Brandon Pool to remove more
2. Chem‘cal treatment at West Side Plant
compact solids and some of the lighter
IEE ror iene oriei ole Wie cro ore anard wih eieeace 400,000 0
to
750,000
7. Flush Brandon Pool to remove active
sludge and flocculent material........... Nom nai 0 1 to 2 wks.
8. Divert all of W. Side effluent to S.W.
aeration plant—Conduit ................ 341,300(a) Nominal 6 months
| 16 Final settling tanks............... 1,059,700(a) 9 months
24 Final settling tanks............... 1,256,200 (a) 9 months
Conduits, gatehouses, etc. ............ 610,000 (a) 6 months
9. Chlorination of W. Side effluent for 150
DE Sd dee aaa Weed kek wis kine enw cians 100,000 105,000 6 to 9 mos.
(a) Part of Permanent program.
bg a eon of loss of power generated at Lockport @ $1,500/day for 100 days =
150,000. a
%
106
2853
OpponEent’s Exursit No. 13.
Sources or D.O. anp B.O.D. or Canat at Looxport.
1938 1989 1940 1941
“N SS rPenr
Blow (6.£.6.) (JUMO) occcssccvevsess 6,701 4,227 2,876 3,130
Diversion (Flow—1,650 c.f.s.)....... 5,051 2,577 1,226 1,480
D.O. in diversion water @ 8 p.p.m.,.216,000# 110,000#% 52,5004 63,500#
B.O.D. at Lockport (#per 24 hours).685,000# 860,000# 430,000% 150,000% +
D.O. at Lockport p.p.m. ave........ 3 0 0 -
Excess of B.O.D. in Pool over D.O.
in diversion water (Line 4-Line 3) .469,000# 750,000# 879,500#
Tons of sludge discharged to canal.. 4,744 4,316 2,287 Ti
Principal Sources of B.O.D.
A.
Am OO fw
Excess of B.O.D. over D.O. in effluents
Cay Fe TR PE voce qh ivecncvee 0 0 0 0
(ih) Colmenee MARE «ccc cesvccdsee 3,000 2,500 0 0
North Side sludge @ 60% raw sew-
OE. cats cceebeed Ceeheh ars tatevers 129,000# 139,000% 65,0004 0
8 ee oe Sree 410,000% 266,000(b) 216,0004 0
S.W. Side sludge to canal after
Ee eines rae ee ae 0 oO 40,000 (c) 0
i, ek eer or rr 115,000# 89,000#% 208,000# 169,000(a)
Calumet sludge to canai_ after
NE ok 5p ous 0b Seerktusaneuese 23,000 # 0 0 0
Total Principal Sources of B.O.D. ..680,000# 496,500# 529,000#(e) 169,000#
(a) 356 M.G.D. @ 57 p.p.m. with Imhoff treatment only.
(b) 160 M.G.D. activated for 21 days taken as half of flow for 70% of month. |
(c) 164% of total sludge 60% of raw sewage. |
(d) 130 M.G.D. in oxygen balance,
(e) 410,000% in July.
107
3030
Opronent’s Exursir No. 14.
Sources or DissoLvep Oxycen anv B.O.D. at Lockport.
(Ave. of June, July and August.)
1988 1939 1940 11941 1942
1. Ave. Flow—(c.f.s.) ....... 6,752 3,336 3,552 3,800 3,800
2. Diversion (Flow — 1650 ;
OO ES ERASE Sa BS 5,102 1,686 1,902 2,150 2,150
3. Dissolved Oxygen in diver-
sion water @ 8 p.p.m. ...220,000# 72,500# 82,000# 92,0004 92,000
4. B.O.D. @ Lockport (# per *
Me Ee ua cde oeeee ves 627 ad 558,000# 389,000# 150,000#+ 100, ,000# +
5. D.O. (p.p.m. average)..... 0 .03 Present Present
6.
(This line of Op. Exh. 13
omitted as of no signifi-
cance )
7. Tons of sludge discharged to
canal from treatment
NR hy brag mer he x. 11,893 15,731 4,468 0 0
Principal Sources of B.O.D. ex-
cept old sludge
A. Excess of B.O.D. over D.O.
in effluents (Ave.)
(a) N. Side Plant....... 0 0 0 0 0
(b) Calumet Plant...... 4,100# 3,4004 350% 0 rf
B. North Side Sludge @ 60%
SRE ONIN 2 os o-o's ac cs 102,000# 112,000% 39,000# 0 0
C. South West sewage @ .167#
ON rs es bc he 410,0004 240,000#% 156,300# 0 0
D. South West sludge to canal
after activation ........ 0 mye 21,4604 0 0
E. West Side effluent......... 106,000# — 224 "000% 160,000# 0
F. Calumet sludge to canal after
. activation pe dale s wes 23,000# 0 0 0
Total—Principal Sources of
B.0.D. other than old sludge.645,000# 539,400# 421,050#% 169,000% 0
I Te I LS IRAN IN AE PERE IG a RCE TS NP MONIES Fa IO 5 oe en ene Be QE 2 esr.
108
3104 OpponEnT’s Exuisit No. 15.
Strate Lasoratory of HyGriEene.
LasoraTory or THE State Boarp or Heauru.
Madison, Wis,, October 1, 1940.
Wisconsin, et al. vs. Illinois, et al.,
1940 Hearings.
Mr. H. H. Naujoks,
c/o Ekern and Meyers,
Ne. 1 La Salle Street,
Chicago, Illinois.
Dear Mr. Navsoxs:
Re: Joliet, Illinois, Air and Water Pollution.
On September 17, 1940, at your request Mr. L. F.
Warrick and I visited Joliet, Illinois, and took air and
water samples. The results of tests made on these
materials constitute aps aah of this report. There
on September 27 and 28, 1940, at your request for ad-
ditional data, air and water tests were conducted. Mr.
William Z. Fluck, Chemical Engineer for Wisconsin
Industrial Hygiene unit, accompanied me on this trip
and assisted in the collection of the samples. The
second part of this. report will cover the results of
tests made September 27 and 28, 1940.
Part I.
This part of this report covers work done at Joliet,
Illinois on,
(a) Amount and type of bacterial present in the
air near the canal and at other points somewhat dis-
tant;
(b) Nature cf scum present at certain points in
and adjacent to the canal waters, scrapings present
109
on the walls at Brandon Locks, and test made on ef-
fluent from Texas Company Oil Refinery Plant which
flows into a ditch adjacent to canal and enters Bran-
don Pool about 150 feet below the Lockport Locks.
(a) Bacterial Content of Air (9-17-40).
Culture plates containing both nutrient and malt
agar, respectively were exposed for four hour pericds
at designated points in J oliet, Tilinois; Lockport, Tli-
nois; and environs. These plates were then trans-
ported to Madison, Wisconsin, and incubated for 24
hours at 37 deg. ©. Colony counts were then made
using a ‘‘Quebec’’ counter. Stains were made on ten
separate colonies from each of the nutrient agar plates
and smears examined for bacterial types. No attempt
was made to identify species of bacteria which grew
on these plates. Satisfactory results were obtained
from five different locations as listed below.
3105 2. Joliet, Mlinois. Yard at F. C. Burrow’s home.
Off highway in woods. Plates exposed from 11:50
A. M. to 3:50 P. M., 9-17-40. Height above ground 5
fee. This location is about 1.5 miles air line from
Brandon Pool. Day bright. Plates on post top in
shade. Light wind. Air»temperature = 78 deg. F.
noon.
3. Joliet, Mlinois. Brandon Locks. In shade on
ledge at side of steps. N. side of Control House, 3
feet above ground. Locks Illinois Waterway. Plates
exposed, from 12:20 P. M. to 4:20 P. M., 9-17-40. Light
wind. Sh
6. Joliet, Illinois. St. Joseph’s Hospital. In shade
on wall 6 feet about street on North side of building.
Two blocks from canal. Plates exposed from 12:56
P. M. to 4:56 P. M., 9-17-40.
* 7 LL! ee TEE
— SE ES A SPILT IE NS OA BEE CELE LTO CONTE AIS REE ILI EE ENE AL LAT IEE, SEI: AT
SRE 8 SPO METER EW sane <a
110
12. Joliet, Illinois. In cornfield 1 mile west State-
ville prison. Plates placed on cardboard support on
ground in sunlight from 2:14 P. M. to 6:19 P. M,,
9-17-40.
13. Joliet, Mlinois. Guardian Angel home. About
three miles from Joliet Court House on U. S. 30.
Plates exposed in shade on window ledge from 2:20
P. M. to 6:30 P. M., 9-17-40.
In the following .able are given the results of bac-
terial counts on the plates exposed as above described,
the time of exposure, and the morphological type of
bacteria found.
Colonies on Agar plates grown
for 48 hours at 37.5 deg. C. *Bacterial Forms
Description of plate Nutrient : Malt Hoursof (See key below)
and location number. Bact. Molds: Bact. : Molds Exposure ,
No. 2 Burrow’s home 66 4) 35 50 4.0 6, 4, 1, 2, 10, 15
No. 3 Brandon Locks 63 37 5 110 4.0 7,1, 15, 2, 5,10
. No. 68t. Joseph’s Hosp. 292 1 110 12 4.0 7, 12, 4, 6,5, 10
; No. 12 Cornfield 560 + 100 Many 4.1 , 5, 1, 6, 7, 10, 2
- No.13 Guardian Angel Heme 350 0 0 10 4.2. 4,2,16,1,5
* Key to morphological types.
1.—Gram positive rods (Similar to B. subtilis).
2.—Gram positive rods (Similar to B. flexus).
3.—Gram positive rods (Diphtheroids).
4.—Gram positive cocci (Staphylococci).
5.—Gram positive cocci (Large diplococci).
6.—Gram négative rods (Similar to Escherichia coli).
7.—Gram positive threads.
8.—Gram positive cocci (Streptococci).
9.—Yeast like fungi (Resembling Monilia Candida).
10.—Molds.
12.—Gram positive coccus (Resembling Diplococcus pneumoniae).
13.—Tetragenes (Gram positive cocci) +
14.—Sarcina (Gram positive cocci). vw
15.—Gram positive bacillus (Streptobacillus).
16.—Gram negative threa@s.
17.—Gram negative bacillus (long rods).
18.—Gram negative cocci (similar to micrococcus catarrhalis).
19.—Small short Gram positive bacillus.
W
“4
111
(b) Chemical Tests on Scrapings, Scum, and Ef-
fluent.
1. Sample of scrapings removed from canal wall
just above upper lock gate at Brandon Lecks, Joliet,
Illinois. 6.8846 grams of moist scrapings yielded
3.5484 grams of dry substance of which 1.5044 grams
was an ‘‘oily tar-like’’ material. This amount of
chloroform soluble material represents 21.8 per cent
by weight of moist scrapings or 42.3 per cent of the
dry weight of the scrapings. Lab. No. 84100.
2. Scum inside future power development pool
at Brandon Locks, Joliet, Illinois, near northwest cor-
ner. 140 ml. of scum yielded 3.9138 grams of dry
oily tar-like material which amounts to 2.79 per cent
by weight. Lab. No. 84101. Sample of this ‘oily
tar-like’’ material saved.
3. Scum in eddy in ditch just below Texas Company
Oil Refinery. This ditch serves as the channel to carry
the effluent from this plant to a point about 150 feet
below the downstream lock gate at Lockport Locks,
Illinois Waterway near Lockport, Illinois. 130 ml. of
this scum and water yielded 1.74 grams of ‘oily tar-
like’’ material. This amounts to 1.34 per cent or 13,400
parts per million. Lab. No. 84103. Sample of this
“‘oily tar-like’’ material saved.
4. Sample of Effluent flowing away from Texas
Company Plant, Lockport, Illinois. This sample was
collected at 5:00 P. M., September 17, 1940, from near
the center of stream flow about 100 feet below wire
fence enclosure of plant. The fow borders the eanal
at and above Leckporit, Illinois, and enters Brandon
Pool about 150 feet downstream from Lockport Locks,
é
Ja
The sample above referred to yielded the follow- .
ing results:
112
Oily tar-like PIES I ae. .... 098.7 p.p.m.*
ON cae ona en ewe 62.8 p.p.m.*
Hydrogen Sulphide (H,S).............. 0 ‘p.p.m.*
Phenolic Substances ......... annealed aa 0.2 p.p.m.*
cnet eee eReTE SO ORL a a Se rnanaeeses 7.1
Part I.
The following report covers tests made on the air
and water at Illinois Waterway at Joliet, Illinois and
environs. Certain other air samples were collected
at points distant from this location for matter of com-
parison. The tests cover: 1. Chemical tests for
hydrogen sulphide made on the site at which the sam-
ples of water were collected. 2. Air Tests for the
number of live bacteria per cubic foot of air.
1. Chemical tests or the water collected at three
separate points as indicated in the following tabula-
tion yielded the result shown.
(a) Sample of water collected from west side of
canal one block above Jefferson Street bridge showed
0.2 parts per million of hydrogen sulphide (H,S). ,
3107 (b) Sample cf water collected from canal at Bran-
don Locks just above upper gate on west side showed
0.2 parts per million of hydrogen sulphide (H,8).
{c) Sample of water collected from canal at Lock-
port Locks just above upper gate on east side of canal
showed 0.1 parts per million of hydrogen sulphide
(H,S). |
2. Measured samples of air were examined for
bacterial life in accordance with a method described by
*p.p.m. = parts per million by weight. These results multiplied by
8.38 will convert these results to lbs. per million gallons.
113
Alexander Hollaender and J. M. Dalla Valle of the
United States Public Health Service as described in
Public Health Reports, Volume 54, Number 14 of
April 7, 1939. In brief, this method makes use of the
impingement principle in which a measured amount
of air drawn by an ordinary impinger pump through
an inverted funnel onto the surface of a sterial Petri
plate containing an appropriate solid bacteriologic
culture medium. The dust and bacteria are caught
on the moist surface of the culture medium. The
pump is calibrated to pump a definite volume of air
per minute. A six volt motor and storage battery for
power and a rubber hose connection of suitable length
completes the apparatus and permits samples to be
taken at convenient and suitable locations. Incubatjon
of such exposed plates permits growth of bacteria
caught and enumeration is then made by use of a
**Quebec’’ type of bacteria colony counter. Three
_ different sized air samples were taken at each sampling
point namely, 1, 3, and 5 eu. ft. samples. This permit-
ted enumeration of bacteria from air containing small
numbers per cubic foot per minute. The results given
are averages of the three determinations at each loca-
tion selected.
Physical data taken and Location of place at which
air samples were collected September 28, 1940.
* A. Joliet, Illinois. One block north of Jeffersou
Street bridge ah west side of canal. Air taken on
canal structure at point about 5 feet above canal water
level. Very slight SE wind. Sun shining. Cloudless
sky. Odor slight of tarry waste. Slight oil film on
canal water. 9:30 A. M., C. D. S. Time.
B. Joliet, Illinois. North end St. Joseph’s Hospi-
tal, about one block from canal (west side). Sample
ages
yas
114
taken 4 feet above ground about 15 feet from hospital
structure. No air movement perceptible. Ne pedes-
trians. One car passed on gravel road during collec-
tion of 3 cu. ft. sample. 9:50 A. M., C. D. S. Time.
C. Joliet, Illinois. Brandon Locks. West side of
upper gate. Samples taken above shelter block about
8 feet above surface of canal water. Lock chamber
empty. .No boats passed. Sun shining. Tarry odor
distinctly perceptible. Light wind from SW. 10:45
A*M., C. D. S. Time.
D. Joliet, Illinois. Brandon “dam at west end of
proposed power dam. Sun shining. Mild SW wind.
Odor negligible. Some oily scum on water below dam.
Temperature 70° F. at Lockhouse (outgide). 11:25
A. M., C. D. S. Time.
3108 E. Joliet, Illinois. Rural; five miles south of Hy.
66 then one mile west on Town line road to intersec-
tion with Ry. Sun shining, slight south wind. No
activity on either road or Ry. Cornfield 500 feet NW.
Gravel road 100 feet south of sampling point. Ry. 25
feet to west. 12:10 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
F. Joliet, Illinois. About three-fourths of a mile
east of Old Joliet Prison. in valley near Ry. and
ahout 200 feet N. of dusty street: Gravel road passed
~ hear sampling point. Rather untidy location. Sam-
“ples taken on concrete foundation and wind from
south fairly strong. Truck passed on gravel road
during collection of 5 cu. ft. sample of air. 2:05 P. M.,
C. D. S. Time.
fy G. Lockport, Illinois. Near stone school house just
** off Hy. 6 and one block off Main N. and S. street.
/ Four cars passed our location during the nine minute
sampling ae Slight south wind. Samples taken
115
' in shade four feet above street. 2:30 P. M., C. D. S.
Time.
H. Lockport, Illinois. Samples taken on east side
of Lockport Locks of canal near “upper lock gate.
Fairly strong wind. No traffic. Concrete walls and
walk. Air temperature 75 deg. F. 305 P. M., C. D.S.
‘Time. |
I. Romeo, Illinois. At canal just south of canal
bridge Air was sampied four feet from ground. Mild
breeze from south. No odors perceptible. Sun shin-
ing. 5:00 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
J. Plainfield, Ilinois. Samples taken along side
of Illinois street about 150 feet off Lincoln Hy. at a
height of about 4 feet. Very light air movement.
Very little traffic. 5:50 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
K. Aurora, Illinois. Taken in small park at en-
trance to city on Hy. 30 at site of elevated water tank.
Flower garden surrounding. No noticeable air meve-
ments. Sun still shining. 6:14 P. M., C. D.-S. Time.
L. Aurora, Illinois. On park side of street just
across street from Park Place Baptist Church. Dusk.
Not much traffic. 6:35 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
M. Rochelle, Illinois. Rural samples taken at
Junction of Hys. U. S. 30 and 51 north of city where
30 meets 51 from East. This location is in open coun-
try. No air movement. Very little dust. Tempera-
ture 63 deg. F. 9:00 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
N. Rockford, Illinois. About one-half mile from
business district toward N. side on U..S. 51. Four
cars per minute passed as samples were being taken
about 4 feet from ground on side of street. Location
definitely residential. No air movement. Very little
dust noticeable. 10:19 P. M., C. D. S. Time.
116
3109 The above locations for air sampling were selected
with care to ascertain the comparative bacterial pol-
lution of the air. No attempt was made to obtain very
clean air or very polluted air. At the locks very little
choice was to be had of sampling locations.
Table showing number of viable bacteria in air
at various locations in and near Joliet, Illinois, as
compared with numbers found in rural areas and
some other Illinois cities:
Bacteria count on Morphological
Description of Location Nutrient agar Re Types of
sampling (See criptive matter under cubic foot a Bacteria
Station Station letter for details) 24 hrs.—37.5 deg. C. Present
A Near Jefferson St. Bridge, Joliet, Til .. 21. 1, 5, 6, 3, 2, 19, 10
B St. Joseph’s Hospitai, Joliet, Tl. .... 13. 4, 19, 1, 5, 2, 7,10
C Brandon Locks, Joliet, Ill. .......... 2.1 17, 5, 18, 19, 6, 15,
1,10
D Brandon Dam, Joliet, Ill. ............ 1.9 7, 6,17, 2,1, 4,10
E Rural, 5 miles S. Joliet, I .......... 9.5 ce
F Lockport, Ill. Near school............ 47.0 19, 6, 7,1
G Lockport Locks, upper gate.......... 13.6 7, 4, 19, 6,
H Romeo, Ill., near canal bridge........ 1.3 17, 2, 19, 6
I‘ Plainfield, Ifl., side street............ 26.1 15, 6, 19,1
J ee Se RP eee 14.3 19, 4, 6,
K Aurora, Ill., Baptist Church......... ° 220 7,6, 5,3
L Rural, Jct. U. S. 30,and U. 8. 51...... 12.0 18, 2,17
10
M Rockford, Iil., U. 8S. 51 res. .......... 10.3 1, 17, 19
Drs.) “sucecsdnseCeneieaveethwascisadiaanaie 35.0 1, 15, 6, |
+-4onme
* For key to these morphological types kindly
<3
Se AE EA Poh oom, ve
stag can ae ace ee ee
refer to page 2 of this report.
117
3454 OppronENT’s Exursir No. 23.
Reportep Cases anpD Dratus FROM CoMMUNICABLE
DiskEasEs.
Wut County anp State or ILurors.
1930-1939 Inclusive.
From Annual Reports Illinois Department of Public
Health.
Rate per 100,000 calculated on basis of 1930 Popula-
tion. |
Dyphtheria :
WILL COUNTY ; STATE TOTAL
1930 Pop. 110,732 1930 PopeT,620,544
Year Cases Rate Deaths Rate Cases Rate * Deaths
1930 34 31.0 2 1.8 6843 89.8 543
1931 35 31.8 8 2.7 5413 71.0 8838
1982 58 52.7 3 2.7 3811 50.0 240
1933 25 22.7 8 2.7 1695 22.2 134
1984 18 16.4 2 1.8 2002 27.5 158
1935 18 16.4 2 1.8 2663 35.0 208
1936 12 10.9 0 0 1784 23.4 170
1937 8 7.3 1 4 1671 27.9 153
1938 7 6.4 2 18 1634 21.4 120
9 Yr. Ave, 24 21.8 2 1.8 ; 8067 40.8 234
1939 ~ 7.3 1 ae 1446 19.0 . 118
4 Encephaiitis
1980 \ Not Reported
1931 Not Reported
1932 Not Reported
1933 Not Reported
1984 0 0 0 0 297 3.9 81
1935 4 8.6 3 2.7 123 1.6 35
1936 0 0O 0 0 74 1.0 35
1937 2 18 1 9 103 14 36
1938 0 G 0 0 67 mt) 31
5 Yr. Av. 1 9 1 2 ae 1.7 44
1939 0 0 0 0 48 6 19
Influenza 4
1930 26 23.6 27 24.5 1239 16.3 946
1931 36 42.7 37 33.6 3562 48.7 1673
1932 86 78.2 63 57.3 3908 . 513 1900
1933 41 37.3 30 27.3 2179 , 28,6 1200
1934 15 13.6 15 13.6 1168 15.3 838
1935 12 10.9 23 20.9 20384 26.7 1255
1936 24 21.9 24 21.9 2065 27.1 1140
1937 56 50.9 43 40.0 3597 47.2 1331
1938 10 91 10 9.1 727 9.5 439
9 Yr. Av. 34 30.9 30 27.3 2295 30.1 1191
56 32.7 25 22.7 6445 84.6 967
118
55
4 Malaria
WILL COUNTY STATE TOTAL
ar Cases Rate Deaths Rate Cases Rate Deaths Rate
0 0 xi) 0 xi) 366 48 50 7
1 0 0 0 ri) 561 7.4 61 S
2 0 0 1 9 130 1.7 39 5
3 0 a 0 0 "53 3.3 62 8
4 0 mi) 0 ri) 322 4.2 60 8
5 0 0 0 0 378 5.0 71 9
6 0 0O 0 0 221 2.9 55 7
14 0 0 0 0 207 2.7 ° 38 5
% 1 m) 0 mi) 263 3.5 35 5
Yr. Av. ll 001 11 001 300 3.9 52 q
9 3 2.7 9 0 423 5.6 35 5
Measles
0 19 17.3 0 mi) 16678 218.9 91 1.2
1 400 363.6 4 3.6 39206 514.5 339 4.4
2 11 10.0 0 0 16070 210.9 51 a
3 122 111.0 1 9 + 1. 37 162.2 52 a
4 195 177.3 1 9 44679 586.3 210 2.8)
5 851 6 6 5.5 58108 762.5 286 3.8
6 4 6 0 0 1228 16.1 9 1
7 9 /82 0 0 12432 163.1 95 12
8 517 470.0 1 9 88150 1156.8 207 2.7
'r. Av. 236 214.5 1.44 13 32100 421.3 149 2.0
9 4 y 36 0 0 1269 16.6 3 0
Meningitis
0 3 2.7 0 mi) 445 5.8 208 2.7
1 4 3.6 4 3.6 490 6.4 257 3.4
2 1 9 0 0 323 42 153 2.0
3 3 2.7 2 18 557 73 208 27
4 1 9 0 r 337 44 119 16
5 5 4.5 3 2.7 554 73 207 2.7
6 2 18 0 0 436 5.7 175 23
7 0 0 0 0 226 3.0 95 12
8 0 0 0 0 91 12 21 3
‘yr. Av. 2 1.8 1 9 884 5.4 160 21
9 0 0 0 0 76 1.0 13 2
+ .
j TRON Rarer re te alee rc as ERE CAIN TARP CIC UN PMR ORILE Hp: OITA RN OENIAAS, 21
3456
\ Pneumonia
WILL COUNTY STATE TOTAL
Year Cases Rate Deaths Rate Cases Rate Deaths Rate
1930 117 106.4 24 21.8 11829 155.2 5179
1932 118 107.3 82 74.2 134@7 176.8 5564
1932 118 107.3 81 73.6 12295 161.3 5332
1933 101 91.8 79 71.8 10833 143.5 4966
1934 101 91.8 86 78.2 12423 163.0 5906
23 1985 80 72.7 61 55.5 13159 172.7 5984
1936 63 57.3 51 46.4 15926 209.0 6312
1937 113 102.7 64 58.2 14970 196.4 5512
1938 56 51.0 46 418 12834 162.5 4595
9 Yr. Av. %6 87.3 64 58.2 13095 171.8 5485
1939 85 77.3 35 31.8 13472 176.8 4193
Poliomyelitis
1930 1 9 0 0 402 5.3 61 se
1931 2 1.8 0 0 700 9.2 102 12
1932 0 _— 0 0 202 2.6 40 5
1932 0 0 0 0 207 2.7 29 4
1934 2 1.8 0 0 213 2.8 27 4
1985 0 0 1 2 243 3.2 40 5
1936 1 9 n oO 689 9.0 70 2
1937 4 3.6 1 9 779 10.2 90 1.2
1938 0 0 0 AY) 106 1.4 16 2
9 Yr. Av. 1 mR) .22 .02 393 5.2 52 7
1939 2 1.8 0 0 192 2.5 21 3
Scarlet Fever
S4 76.4 4 3.6 17352 227.7 306
190 172.7 6 5.5 16775 220.2 360
308 189.1 10 9.1 14876 195.2 263
231 210.0 6 5.5 16604 217.9 277
1042 947.3 5 4.5 21408 280.9 306
214 194.5 7 6.4 34727 455.7 407
79 718 0 0 22461 294.6 233
251.8 1 9 21525 282.5 160
486.4 6 5.5 18245 9 239.4 136
92.7 0 0 15060 197.6 74
289.1 5 4.5 20440 268.2 272
120
3457
Small Pox
j WILL COUNTY STATE TOTAL
year Cases Rate Deaths Rate Cases Rate Deaths Rate
‘930 1 29 0 0 3782 49.6 7 al
‘931 31 28.2 0 0 17866 23.2 4 Bx |
932 1 9 0 0 318 4.2 2 0
333 1 9 0 0 248 3.3 3 0
‘934 1 23 0 0 , 88 12 0 0
935 1 2 0 0 83 23 1 0
936 188 170.9 1 9 422 5.5 2 0
{937 3 2.7 0 0 919 12.1 0 0
938 14 12.7 0 0 965 127 1 0
> Yr. Av. 27 24.5 mt | 01 935 12.5 2 03
(939 0 0 0 0 376 4.9 0 0
Tuberculosis
1930 150 136.4 93 84.5 11179 146.7 4789 62.9
1931 137 124.5 79 71.8 10423 136.8 4799 63.0
1932 141 128.2 §2 56.4 10465 137.3 4291 56.3
1933 99 90.0 48 43.6 9193 120.6 4174 54.8
1934 134 121.8 62 56.4 9734 127.7 4124 54.1
1935 131 119.1 48 43.6 9911 130.1 4075 53.5
1836 88 80.0 60 §4.5 8506 111.6 4050 52.2
1937 111 100.9 54 49.1 9064 119.0 3995 52.4
1938 D6 87.3 45 40.9 8222 107.9 3686 48.4
} Yr. Av. 121 110.0 61 55.5 9633 126.4 4220 55.4
1939 ge 74.5 38 34.5 7752 101.7 3608 47.4
ad Typhoid Fever
1930 25 22.7 3 2.7 960 12.6 154 2.0
1931 9 8.2 1 mS) 804 10.6 127 17
1932 33 30.0 5 4.5 1045 13.7 125 1.6
1933 38 34.5 7 6.4 770 10.1 113 1.5
- 1934 23 20.9 1 9 1085 14.2 131 1
1935 20 18.2 0 0 775 10.2 91 1.2
1936 24 21.8 3 yay 566 7.4 7 1.0
1937 13 11.8 0 0 540 7.0 61 8
1938 7 6.4 0 0 §23 7.0 59 38
—p Yr. Av. 21 19.1 2 1.8 785 10.3 104 14
1939 8 7.3 1 9 906 11.9 105 14
(‘Ss
we
121
3458
Whooping Cough
WILL COUNTY STATE TOTAL
Year Cases Rate Deaths Rate Cases Rate Deaths Rate
1930 43 © 39.1 4 3.6 8573 112.5 181 2.45
1931 67 60.9 3 2.7 10911 143.2 223 2.98
1932 63 57.3 3 2.7 11786 154.7 228 3
1933 5 4.5 0 0 6439 84.5 81 i
1934 63 57.3 1 9 15352 201.5 307 4.
1935 132 120.0 7 6.4 11064 145.2 210 2.8
1936 39 38.5 2 1.8 10171 133.5 146 1
1937 76 69.1 1 9 7906 103.8 149 2:
1938 84 76.4 1 9 15137 198.6 169
9 Yr. Av. 64 58.2 2 1.8 10615 139.3 a
1989 56 50.9 1 9 12922 169.6 157
3460 OrponenT’s Exursir No. 24.
Will Co. Average compared with Will County 1939 compared
State Average—per 100,000 with Will County Average
Cases Deaths Cases Deaths
Over Under Over Under Over Under Over Unde
Whooping Cough..... 81.8 -
MEE Sa vinv'eaticveaue 8.8 4
Tuberculosis ......... 16.4 1
3, ee eee 12.0 .02
Scarlet Fever........ 20.9 9
Poliomyelitis ........ 4.3 .68 9
Pneumonia .......... 84.5 13.8
ae 3.6 1.2
eS a aie Sie 206.8 1.87
Ay ERE AR Ds 3.899 699 2.659
I 8 11.7 1.8
Encephalitis ......... 8 3
Dyphtheria .......... 18.5 1.3
—
Pa)
122
3985 Opronent’s Exuisit No. 30.
American Hosprrant AssoctaTIon,
Incorporated 1920
Eighteen East Division Street,
Chicago, Il.
Bert W. Caldwell, M. D.
Executive Secretary,
December 11, 1940
Mr. H. H. Naujoks,
Ekern and Meyers,
One North La Salle Street,
“Chicago, Ilinois.
° Received
Dee 12 1940
Ekern & Meyers
Dear Mr. Navsoxs:
Referring to our conversation of the 10th accord-
ing to the records of the 1940 issue of Hospital Service
3986 in the United States of the American Medical Asso-
ciation there were 9.018.316 patients admitted to gen-
eral hospitals in the United States during 1939 and
that the average census in these hospitals was 307.991.
Computed from this the average day stay of patients
was 12.46 per patient. From the same source the St.
Joseph’s Hospital at Joliet, Mlinois had 5.561 admis-
sions and an average census of 175 patients which
computed in the same manner would show an average
days stay of patients of 11.48.
Yours very truly,
W. P. Morrr,
M. D.
WPM :FSK
123
4476 Howson Exuisirt No. 6.
Atvorp, Burpicx & Howson
John W. Alvord Donald H. Maxwell
Chas. B. Burdick Louis R. Howson
ENGINEERS
Suite 1401 Civic Opera Building
Chicago ,
Feb. 18, 1941.
Mr. Herbert H. Naujoks,
c/o Hotel Monteleone,
New Orleans, La.
Dear Navsoxs:
I have analyzed Pearse’s Exhibit 61-A. It seems
to me it is just as much in error as the original. On
the enclosed table I have shown what I believe to be
a proper analysis of this table.
The first three years 1938, 1939 and 1940 have actual
recorded data of the C.0.D. at Lockport. This is
shown in my line 6. Pearse’s table has estimated the
total B.O.D. exclusive of sludge (my line 1) and the
B.O.D. of the sludge deposits (my line 2). The sum
4477 of these two is the total B.O.D. (my line 3). :
Pearse’s table also shows the sources of dissolved
oxygen (my line 4). Oxygen balance is the difference
between the total B.O.D. and the total D.O. That is
line 3 minus line 4 shown on my table as line 5. The
relation between the actual recorded B.O.D. at Lock-
port (my line 6) and the excess in line 7. The relation
of the actual to the computed has varied from 50%
to 61% with a year average of 57%.
If this average of 57% was applied to the critical
years of 1941 and 1942 as shows in my line 8, the re-
sulting B.O.D. at the pool would be 233,000 Ibs. in
124
1941, the equivalent of 13.5 p.p.m., and 198,000 lbs.
in 1942, the equivalent of 11.5 p.p.m.
Actually, Pearse for 1941 had a per cent of pool
B.O.D. to the excess which he computed in the ratio
of 361,500 to 409,000 or 884% and in 1942 the relation
of 303,000 to 347,000 or 674%. Ceitainly I see no
reason why for .these two years the percentage of
error should have been any Sreater than in the former
4478 years and certainly actuai experience as recorded by
analytical data in the past is the best foundation for
future predictions. I, believe the facts are closely
represented by the figures in line 8 of my table and
these you will note do not differ a great deal from
Pearse’s original Exhibit 61-A figures.
Another way to look at it would be to find what
Pearse’s error amounted to. That is, line 5 minus
line 6. These errors were:
1938 405,300 Ibs.
1939 559,800
1940 262,800
3 yr. Ave. 409,300
While the variation will be somewhat less than these
three years would indicate due to partial satisfaction
of the oxygen demand, there will certainly be a mate-
rial credit for reaeration in any period in the future
and that Mr. Pearse has wholly ignored. There is
much discussion of reaeration in part 3, appendix 1
of the 1925 investigation.
Yours very truly,
Atvorp, Burpicx & Howson,
By L. R. Howson,
LEH:VB
127
Respectfully submitted,
Georce F., Barrert,
Attorney General of the State of
Illinois,
Joun KE. Martin,
Attorney General of Wisconsin,
J. A. A. Burneuist,
Attorney General of Minnesota,
Tomas J. HERBERT,
Attorney General of Ohio,
CiaupEe T. Reno,
Attorney General of Pennsyi-
vania,
Harrincton ADAMS,
Deputy Atty. General of Penn-
sylvania,
Hersert J. RusHron,
Attorney General of Michigan,
James W. WILLiams,
Asst. Attorney General of Michi-
gan,
Joun J. Bennett, Jr.,
Attorney General of New York,
Timotny F. Conan,
Asst. Attorney General of New
York,
Hersert H. Navsoks,
Special Assistant to the Attor-
neys General.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.