Supplemental Brief — Maine v. United States Environmental Protection Agency

Supreme Court brief1989

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

In the Supreme Court of the United States _

( ee ik Ae

a

Supreme Court, US, 5

6) FILED

b FER 24 eg |

No. 88-684 JOSEPH F. SPANIOL, JR,

LERK ;

+ Wheat. iy aE a ae

OCTOBER TERM, 1988

STATE OF MAINE, ET AL., PETITIONERS ‘

V.

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL

PROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM FOR

THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS IN OPPOSITION

WILLIAM C. BRYSON

Acting Solicitor General

Department of Justice

Washington, D.C. 20530 ‘

(202) 633-2217

a a RTE

eh Sta he

« ; * ; 2

ee ae Bee +

PE Ce Oe SE, On Ee ease EL

; 3 | 2

LEB 5: N

- aheaee Si Ss To.

a)

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Statutes and regulations: Page

Clear Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401 ef seq.:

© OoGiaes, 42 0S .C. POIIRRD) .. wc cece ene 2

§ 110(a)(2)(E), 42 U.S.C. 7410(a)(2)(E) ............ ae

ee FS errr ee rer er Try er errr 3

Miscellaneous:

en I NC UIUD ii k ec nas smh ds sae eee eka es 3

44 Fed. Reg. (1979):

48 Fed. Reg. (1979):

NT Deo oa oe 5 ea fee Sane cae vew ates 4

p.

SS SS ore rr er rrr lo ee eee

Pp

p

wwe ff hb WwW Ww

ES re re ere ee

53 Fed. Reg. (1988): %

ey ah ar cy on Re wae oe aE Awa,

pp. 40,423-40,425 ..............4: ee er Np en

se | BAe Seat eae ieke aA Ae Ae he

p. 46,608 (Gaily od. Nov. 18)... 2. owe cece nd.

oe PS UU SO ere rrerrrser rr cr

www kk

(1)

In the Supreme Court of the Cited States

OCTOBER TERM, 1988

No. 88-684

STATE OF MAINE, ET AL., PETITIONERS

v.

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL

PROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM FOR

THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS IN OPPOSITION

This brief is filed pursuant to Rule 22.6 of the Rules of

this Court to respond to statements made in petitioners’

reply brief that misstate the position taken by the federal

respondents before both this Court and the courts below.

1. Contrary to petitioners’ claim (Reply Br. 1), our op-

position to their petition did not include an argument “not

presented to the Court below.” As the court of appeals’

opinion makes clear, our brief before that court responded

in similar fashion to petitioners’ assertion that EPA’s con-

struction effectively reads Section 110(a)(2)(E) out of the

Clean Air Act; in both submissions we referred to in-

stances when EPA must determine that Section 110(a)(2)

(1)

2

(E)’s prohibition on interstate pollution has been satisfied.

See Pet. App. Al2 (“The Administrator’s review of

various SIP revisions submitted by states is an ongoing

process, and under the Administrator’s interpretation the

prohibition of § 110(a)(2)(E) is one of the requirements

that must be met before he can approve any initial SIP or

revision.”). On both occasions, moreover, we specifically

argued that one such instance is when a State submits a

SIP or revised SIP in response to EPA’s promulgation of a

new NAAQS or a revision to an existing NAAQS.' Com-

pare Br. in Opp. 10-11 (“In addition, whenever a new

NAAQS is promulgated or an existing NAAQS is revised,

EPA must ensure that all SIPs submitted for its review

conform to Section 110(a)(2), including paragraph (E)’s

prohibition.”) with Gov’t C.A. Br. 63 (“Similarly, when-

ever a new NAAQS is promulgated or an existing NAAQS

is revised, new State SIPS must be submitted, and the Ad-

ministrator is to apply the elements of section 110(a)(2),

including subsection (E).”).

2. There is likewise no basis for petitioners’ assertions

that “EPA’s claim that interstate pollution provisions are

implemented whenever air quality standards are adopted

or revised is false” or that the notion of “steady review by

EPA of interstate pollution has no basis in the agency’s

construction of the statute” (Reply Br. 1, 2). The views ex-

pressed in our brief in opposition and in our court of ap-

peal brief, which the court of appeals adopted, are long-

standing.

The three instances cited by petitioners (Reply Br. 2)

when EPA has adopted or revised a NAAQS are not to the

' Section 110(a)(1) of the Clean Air Act requires each State to sub-

mit a SIP or revised SIP “within nine months after the promulgation

of a [NAAQS] (or revision thereof) * * * for any air pollutant” (42

U.S.C. 7410(a)(1)).

3

contrary. None of those regulations purports to declare all

of the applicable requirements of the Clean Air Act trig-

gered by the new or revised standard; they describe only

those supplemental requirements peculiar to the pollutant

involved. See, e.g., 43 Fed. Reg. 46264 (1978) (emphasis

added) (“The regulations promulgated below, together

with the current requirements of 40 CFR Part 51, set forth

the requirements for States to follow in developing, adopt-

ing, and submitting acceptable implementation plans for

the lead national ambient air quality standards.”). Hence,

the Act’s general requirements for a SIP, including satis-

faction of Section 110(a)(2)(E), apply. See 40 C.F.R.

51.110(e) (“The plan for each Region must have adequate

provisions to ensure that stationary sources from within

that Region will not: (1) prevent attainment and mainte-

nance of any national standard in any portion of an inter-

state Region or any other Region * * *[;] (2) interfere with

measures required to be included in the applicable im-

plementation plan for any such Region to prevent signifi-

cant deterioration of air quality or to protect visibility.”);

see also 48 Fed. Reg. 46,152, 46,163 (1983) (listing Section

110(a)(2)(E) as statutory basis for 40 C.F.R. 51.110(e)).?

3. Finally, petitioners ignore that EPA has in fact dis-

approved proposed SIP revisions because of interstate im-

pacts. For example, EPA disapproved a portion of the In-

diana SIP because of the State’s failure to comply with

Section 110(a)(2)(E) (48 Fed. Reg. 5106, 5107 (1983) (pro-

posed disapproval); 53 Fed. Reg. 46,608, 46,612 (daily ed.

Nov. 18, 1988) (final disapproval)); and, in disapproving a

portion of the Illinois SIP, EPA relied, among other

? In the case of EPA’s revision of the Clean Air Act’s ozone stand-

ard, cited by petitioners (Reply Br. 2, citing 44 Fed. Reg. 8202 (1979)),

EPA determined that no SIP revisions were required because the

federal standard was being relaxed and “States may have more strin-

gent controls than necessary if they choose” (44 Fed. Reg. 8203).

4

things, on possible interstate impacts (see 48 Fed. Reg.

5110, 51 3 (1983) (proposed disapproval); 53 Fed. Reg.

40,415, 40,423-40,425 (1988) (final disapproval)).

For the foregoing reasons, and those stated in our brief

in Opposition, the petition for a writ of certiorari should

be denied.

Respectfully submitted.

WILLIAM C. BRYSON

Acting Solicitor General

FEBRUARY 1989

ka

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.