Plaintiffs Brief — Utah v. United States (No. PC-00 10-74)

Supreme Court brief1967

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

—e fee RON ‘ oo. ,

»iLae® .

REMe COURT. LU. &

Allg 1 1969

Re EK

No. 31, Original

in the Supreme Court of the

United States

October Term, 1967

STATE OF UTAH,

; Plaintif,

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Defendant.

BRIEF OF THE STATE OF UTAH IN

SUPPORT OF THE NAVIGABILITY OF

THE GREAT SALT LAKE

COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF:

VERNON B. ROMNEY

Utah Attorney General

ROBERT B. HANSEN

Deputy Utah Attorney General

DALLIN W. JENSEN

Assistant Attorney General

RICHARD L. DEWSNUP

Special Assistant Attorney General

CLIFFORD L. ASHTON

Special Assistant Attorney General

EDWARD W. CLYDE

Special Assistant Attorney General

236 State Capitol Buildi

Salt Lake City, Utah 84114

August 1, 1969

CONTENTS

ig ee UE) TO a 1

A. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT ...... 1

B. FEDERAL. TEST OF NAVIGA-

a 4

By Rat I rane cnc cncaecnsacudovnsconencsecenes 13

a acetates shatsapich eininninsinnseiacitahanaisonbtiaes 13

2. Method of Reference .............................. 14

II]. SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE .................... 15

A. SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY ............ 15

1. Zillah Walker Manning .......0000.0000000.0..... 15

i I I 17

ee UI I 18

4. Claire Wilcox Noall ................................ 20

5. Francis W. Kirkham ................................ 21

RES aE En Oe ee 21

7. John Clawson Silver .............................. 22

8. Reese F. Llewellyn .................................. 23

RM we I cass ccicssnssescnsestsesaccs 23

a ee. ec OD 24.

11. Golden O. Peterson ............................... 28

Oe 29

13. William Paxton Hewitt ..............0.0......... 29

14. Donald G. Prince ..........cccccccccccccccccc..s 31

ii

A ne a nie 31

16. Helmut H. Doelling —.....0000000000........ 31

ile EEE ITU cetiachccinreosticnstacintatninennsnansenasenans 32

B. SUMMARY OF EXHIBITS ................ 33

C. SUMMARY OF PHYSICAL CHAR-

ACTERISTICS OF GREAT SALT

LAKE AT STATEHOOD 0... 42

Ill. PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT ..... 45

IV. PROPOSED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW. 51

Pe RAT An rae EE ee. EARS 52

CASES CITED

Case:

Daniel Ball, 77 U.S. (10 Wall.) 557 (1870) ........ 8

Economy Light and Power Company v. United

ae yh reer 10

Martin v. Waddell, 41 U.S. (16 Pet.) 367

TS RRO ASE SV ECST SAS SSN eae 3

Montello, 20 Wall. 430 (1874) 0.000... 9

Oklahoma vy. Texas, 258 U.S. 574 (1921) 00000000... 10

Pollard v. Hagan, 44 U.S. (3 How.) 212 (1845)... 3

Shively v. Bowlbey, 152 U.S. 1 (1894) 20000000... 3

United States v. Cress, 243 U.S. 316 (1917) ........ 10

United States v. Holt State Bank, 270 U.S. 49

1, RO PDES SEES OT Cae R aCe 3, 11-12

United States v. }'io Grande Irrigation Co., 174

FO | RU ere tO Oar ae 10

United States v. Utah, 283 U.S. 64 (1931) .... 3, 4-7

No. 31, Original

in the Supreme Court of the

United States

October ‘Term, 1967

STATE OF UTAH,

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Defendant.

Plaintiff,

BRIEF OF THE STATE OF UTAH IN

SUPPORT OF THE NAVIGABILITY OF

THE GREAT SALT LAKE

I. MEMORANDUM

A. Preliminary Statement

The procedural history of the instant litigation is

clearly reflected from the record of prior proceedings,

and there seems to be little point in again detailing

those procedures and events. Therefore, in this memo-

randum Utah will simply make a brief statement with

respect to the issue of navigation, and will then discuss

the applicable legal test of navigability.

The essential purpose of this litigation is to deter-

mine the respective claims of ownership asserted by

Utah and the United States to lands surrounding the

2

Great Salt Lake which previously constituted a part

of the bed of the lake but which are now exposed because

of the lower water level of the lake. As such, the basic

issue for determination is whether the common law

doctrine of reliction should be applied to permit the

United States to acquire title from Utah to certain

of the exposed lands. The question of navigability of

the Great Salt Lake is thus not the basic issue in the

litigation, but it is a necessary preliminary issue.

The reason it is a necessary preliminary issue is

because Utah is the plaintiff in this litigation and claims

that, prior to the quit claim conveyance by the United

States to Utah, Utah had a title superior to that of

the United States in and to the exposed lands. If so,

Utah received no title from the United States as a result

of the conveyance and is obligated to pay nothing to

the United States for such conveyance. Thus, as plain-

tiff, Utah has the burden of proving a prima facie case

showing that it acquired prior title to the bed of the

Great Salt Lake at statehood because it was a navi-

gable body of water; it will then be incumbent upon

the United States to prove its claim that the doctrine

of reliction somehow divested Utah of its ownership

of certain parts of the exposed lands that once con-

stituted part of the lake bed. Utah's claim of title is

basec on the equal footing doctrine, which, so far as

applicable here, holds that the United States Consti-

tution guarantees to each state, upon its admission to

the union and pursuant to its enabling act, equal sove-

reign rights and equal footing with every other state

in the union, including ownership of the beds of all

navigable lakes and rivers located within such state.

3

Martin v. Wadell, 41 U.S. (16 Pet.) 367 (1842) ;

Pollard v. Hagan, 44 U.S. (3 How.) 212 (1845);

Shively v. Bowlbey, 152 U. S. 1 (1894); United States

v. Holt State Bank, 270 U.S. 49 (1926) ; and United

States v. Utah, 283 U.S. 64 (1931).

The United States does not deny the validity of

the above doctrine, but has denied the allegations of

Utah's complaint, including the allegation of the navi-

gability of the Great Salt Lake on January 4, 1896,

which was the date that Utah obtained statehood. in

view of that denial, it was necessary for Utah to prove

that the lake was navigable at the date of statehood.

To simplify the proceedings, it was agreed by counsel

for Utah and the United States, and approved by the

Special Master, that a preliminary hearing should first

be held on the issue of navigability only. If the lake

should be determined to be navigable, then a second

hearing would be held to determine the applicability

of the doctrine of reliction. The hearing on navigability

was held May 19 through 21, 1969, in Salt Lake City,

Utah. Thus, the only question presently under con-

sideration is the navigability of the lake, and all other

questions pertinent to the litigation are to be reserved

for subsequent consideration and determination.!

1 In this regard, Utah raised certain issues at the hearing con-

cerning the propmety of taking judicial notice that the lake

was navigable at statehood. the applicability of the doctrine

of equitable estompel amainst the United States, and compromise

and settlement be‘ween the United States Congress and the

Utah Legislature. Utah furt)ver expressed the position that the

only possible ramifications ef a determination of navigability

related to ownership oi the exposed lands, ani not to owner-

ship of the water covered bed or minerais in solution in the

lake waters (see, generally, T. 6-11). Since these issues and

contentions appear to be moot if the lake is found to be navi-

gable, they are not further raised or argued in this brief. If,

for some reason, the lake should be found to be non-navigable

Utah then will determine when and to what extent it wishes

to press such arguments.

a PROS oe

Be i

%

ie

=

4

4

Utah believes that it is obvious that the Great Salt

Lake was navigable at statehood, that the record con-

tains uncontroverted evidence which more than satisfies

the federal test of navigability, that a finding of navi-

gability can be made with reasonable dispatch, and that

the litigation can properly proceed to a determination

of the questions relating to reliction. With that back-

ground, it would appear to be appropriate to proceed

to examine the legal test of navigability as laid down by

the United States Supreme Court.

B. FEDERAL TEST OF NAVIGASILITY

The federal test of navigability, for the purpose

of determining whether a state obtained title to the

bed of a body of water at statehood, is whether the

river or lake in its natural and ordinary condition was

physically capable of supporting commercial navigation,

aud thus serving as a useful highway of commerce. ‘iis

test was laid down by the United States Supreme Court

in 1879, and has been followed consistently in ail sub-

sequent cases.

Periiaps the leading case applying tie federal test

of navigability is United States v. Utah, 283 U.S. 64

(1951), which involved a determination of the navi-

gability of certain portions of the Colorado, Green and

San Juan Rivers in Utah, where the sections of the

rivers in question contained many impediments to navi-

gation and were only about three feet deep during

major portions of the year. Counsel for the United

States stressed the absence of historical data showing

ihe early navigation of the rivers by Indians, fur

traders or early explorers; that is, uses of the sort

5

sometimes earlier mentioned by the Court in consider-

ing ihe navigability of certain other streams. The Gov-

erament had argued (see pages 66-67) that evidence

of such lack of use in difficult days of overland travel

was weighty evidence of non-navigability, and that no

lake or stream had been declared navigable by the

Supreme Court unless it had appeared from the evidence

that the stream or lake had actually supported a sub-

siantial waterborne commerce.

The Court laid to rest the Government’s attempt

to read into the navigability test a requirement of actual

substantial navigation, and at the same time reaffirmed

the principles laid down by several earlier cases, with

the following language (at page 82-83):

“The question of the susceptibility (to use as

highways of commerce) in the ordinary condi-

tion of the rivers, rather than the mere manner

or extent of such use, is the crucial question. The

Government insists that the uses of the rivers

have been more of a private nature than of a

public, commercial sort. But, assuming this to

be the fact, it cannot be regarded as controlling

when the rivers are shown to be capable of com-

mercial use. The extent of existing commerce is

not the test. The evidence of the actual use of

streams, and especially of extensive and con-

tinued use for commercial purposes, may be most

persuasive, but where conditions of exploration

and settlement explain the infrequency or limit-

ed nature of such use, the susceptibility to use

as a highway of commerce may still be satisfac-

torily proved ... In Economy Power & Light

Co. v. U. S., 256 U.S. 113, 122, 123, the Court

quoted with approval the statement in the Mon-

tello, supra, that the ‘capability of use by the

public for purposes of transportation and com-

caihinieetia ae

ae

LTR Se Se aS

6

merce affords the true criterion of the naviga-

bility of a river, rather than the extent and man-

ner of such use.’ ”

The Government further attempted to argue that

this line of reasoning required a consideration of prob-

able future commerce, but that consideration was too

speculative to be entertained by the Court. It was held

that the State did not need to prove the probable need

for future navigation, because there was always the

possibility that such a future need could arise and (at

page 83):

“the possibilities of growth and future profit-

able use are not to be ignored. Utah, with its

equality of right as a State of the Union, is not

to be denied title to the beds of such rivers as

were navigable in fact at the time of the admis-

sion of the the State either because the location

of the rivers and the circumstances of the ex-

pleration and settlement of the country through

which they flowed had made recourse to navi-

gation a late adventure, or because commercial

utilization on a large scale awaits future demands.

The question remains one of fact as to the capa-

city of the rivers in their ordinary condition to

meet the needs of commerce as these may arise

in connection with the growth of the population,

the multiplication of activities and the develop-

ment of natural resources. And that capacity

may be shown by physical characteristics and

experimentation as well as by the uses to which

the streams have been put.”

Having failed in its attempt to read into the test

of navigability a requirement of actual substantial use,

the Government was forced to fall back on an attempt

to dispute navigability of the rivers by establishing that

-

they contained impediments to navigation such as logs

and debris, ice, floods, rapids, rapid velocities with

sudden changes in the water level, shallow depths, insta-

bility of channel, and sand and sediment which com-

bined with the tortuous course of the rivers to produce

a succession of shifting sandbars. The Court conceded

the presence of all of these impediments and entered

into an extensive discussion (at pages 85-87) of the

evidence regarding types and frequencies of the sand-

bars, which it felt to be the principal impediment to

navigation. Nevertheless. the Court held that the fact

of impediments was not equivalent to the fact of non-

navigable capacity (at page 86):

“Recognizing the difficulties which are thus

created, the Master is plainly right in his con-

clusion the mere fact of the presence of such

sandbars causing impediments +> navigation

does not make a river non-nayige’e. It is suf-

ficient to refer to the well-known conditions on

the Missouri River and the Mississippi River.

The presence of sandbars must be taken in con-

nection with other factors making for naviga-

bility. In The Montello, supra, the Court said

(p. 443): Indeed, there are but few of our. . .

rivers which did not originally present serious

obstructions to an uninterrupted navigation. Jn

some cases like the Fox River, they may be so

great while they last as to prevent the use of the

best instrumentalities for carrying on commerce,

but the vital and essential point is whetherthenat-

ural navigation of the river is such that it affords

a channel! for useful commerce. If this be so the

river is navigable in fact, although its naviga-

tion may be encompassed with difficulties by

reason of natural barriers such as rapids and

sandbars.”

Ue Re

8

The test of navigability thus applied in United

States v. Utah, supra, was simply a re-affirmation of

the same principles originally set forth by the Court in

The Daniel Ball, 77 U.S. (10 Wall.) 557, 563-64 (1870),

which involved a determination of the navigability

of the Grand River in Michigan for purposes of appli-

cation of a federal licensing statute. The Court, after

noting that the doctrine of the common law as to the

navigability of waters (i.e., that the ebb and flow of

the tide constituted the usual test of navigability) had

no application in this country, stated:

“A different test must, therefore, be applied

to determine the navigability of our rivers, and

that is found in their navigable capacity. Those

rivers must be regarded as_ public navigable

rivers in law which are navigable in fact. And

iney are navigable in fact when they are used,

or are susceptible of being used, in their ordi-

nary condition, as highways for commerce, over

which trade and travel are or may. be conducted

in the customary modes of trade and travel on

waur ..,

From the conceded facts . . . the (Grand

River) is capable of bearing a steamer of one

hundred and twenty three tons burden, laden

with merchandise and passengers . . . a distance

of forty miles.

The Court's opinion indicated that the crux of the

test of navigability was not whether the Grand River

was actually being traversed by commercial navigation,

whether of minute or substantial extent, but rather

_ whether the stream had a capacity to sustain such com-

mercial navigation, and whether it was susceptible of

being used as a highway for commerce. Since the appel-

9

lant had conceded that the stream was capable of bear-

ing a steamer of one hundred and twenty-three tons

burden for a distance of forty miles, laden with mer-

chandise and passengers, the Court reached the obvious

conclusion that the Grand River did have a capacity to

bear commercial navigation.

The navigability test laid down by T'he Daniel Bali

was subsequently relied upon by the Supreme Court

in The Montello, 20 Wall. 430 (1874). The Court

there applied the test to the Fox River in Wisconsin,

a stream which in its natural state was interrupted in

various places by rapids and falls, and yet determined

it to be navigable. The Court’s opinion again empha-

sized that the crux of the test is the capability of use

for navigation rather than the existence, extent, or

manner of such use. The Court stated (at page 441):

es

(T)he true test of the navigability of a stream

does not depend on the mode by which commerce

is, or may be, conducted nor the difficulties at-

tending the navigation . . .

It would be a narrow rule to hold that...

unless a river was capable of being navigated

by steam or sail vessels it could not be treated

as a public highway. The capability of use by

the public for purposes of transportation and

commerce affords the true criterion of the navi-

gability of a river, rather than the extent and

manner of that use. If it be capable in its natura!

state of being used for purposes of commerce.

no matter in what mode the commerce may

conducted, it is navtgable in fact...”

This test of navigability thus established by The

Daniel Ball and followed by The Montello, that a body

10

of water is navigable in law if it is navigable in fact,

has been subsequently followed and reaffirmed without

any significant modification on numerous occasions, and

a persuasive line of reasoning and authority has been

developed. See, e.g., United States v. Rio Grande Irri-

gation Co., 174 U. S. 690, 699 (1898); United States

v. Cress, 243 U.S. 316, 323-24 (1917) ; Economy Light

and Power Co. v. United States, 256 U. S. 118, 118

(1921); and Oklahoma v. Tevas, 258 U. S. 574, 586

(1921).

In Oklahoma v, Texas, supra, the Court (at page

586) noted it to be a:

“settled rule in this country that navigability

in fact is the text of navigability in law, and

that whether a river is navigable in fact is to

be determined by inquiring whether it is used,

or is susceptible of being used, in its natural

and ordinary condition as a highway for com-

merce, over which trade and travel are or may

be conducted in the customary modes of trade

and travel on water.” (citing the Daniel Ball,

The Montello, United States v. Rio Grande Ir-

rigation Co,, United States v. Cress, and Evon-

omy Power & Light Co. v. Uvilied States).

The Court concluded (at page 591) that the por-

tion of the Red River there in issue was non-navigable

because:

“trade and travel neither do nor ca:. move over

that part of the river, in its natural and ordinary

condition, according to the modes of trade and

travel customary on water; — in other words,

that it is neither used, nor susceptible of being

used, in its natural and ordinary condition as a

1]

highway for commerce. Its characteristics are

such that its use for transportation has been and

must be exceptional, and confined to the irregular

and short periods of temporary high water. A

greater capacity for practical and beneficial use

in commerce is essential to establish navigabil-

ity.”

The opinion indicates that, once again, the Court's

concern was that the river lacked a capacity to be used

regularly in commerce to at least some extent, rather

than whether commercial activity had been absent, mini-

mal, or substantial.

‘The next important case to deal with the question

of navigability was United States v. Holt State Bank,

270 U.S. 49 (1926). It was the first significant case

to apply the test of navigability to a lake, and involved

a bill in equity brought by the United States to quiet

title to the bed of Mud Lake in Minnesota, which had

been substantially drained at the time of suit. The out-

come of the case turned on the navigability of Mud

Lake. The test applied by the Court was the one

evolved from the earlier line of cases cited above, and

set forth (at page 56) as follows:

“The rule long since approved by this court

in applying the Constitution and laws of the

United States is that streams or lakes which are

navigable in fact must be regarded as navigable

in law; that they are navigable in fact when

they are used, or are susceptible of being used,

in their natural and ordinary condition as high-

ways for commerce, over which trade and travel

are or may be conducted in the customary modes

of trade and travel on water: and further, that

navigability does not depend on the particular

errno

12

mode in which such use is or may be had—wheth-

er by steamboats, sailing vessels or tHatboats—nor

on an absence of occasional difficulties in navi-

gation, but on the fact, if it be a fact, that the

stream in its natural and ordinary condition

atfords a channel for useful commerce.”

This test was applied to evidence which the Court

felt established, among others, the following facts:

“In its natural and ordinary condition the

lake was three to six feet deep... Early visitors

and settlers in that vicinity used the river and

lake as a route of travel, employing the small

boats of the period for the purpose .... Mer-

chants in the settlements at Liner and Grygla,

which were several miles up Mud River from

the lake, used the river and lake in sending for

and bringing in their supplies. True, the navi-

gation was limited, but this was because trade

and travel in that vicinity were limited. In sea-

sons of great drought there was difficulty in

getting boats up the river and through the lake,

but this was exceptional, the usual conditions

being as just stated. Sand bars in some parts of

the lake prevented boats from moving readily

all over it, but the bars could be avoided by

keeping the boats in the deeper parts or chan-

nels . . . Gasoline motor boats were used in

surveying and marking the line of the intended

ditch through the lake and the ditch was exca-

vated with floating dredges.”

The Court concluded that the evidence required

a finding that Mud Lake was navigable, pointing out

chat the lake was susceptible of being used as a highway

for trade and travel if there had been a need for trade

and travel on the lake.

13

It will thus be observed that at all times during

the last century the Uniled States Supreme Court

has consistently applied the same test of navigability

that was adhered to and emphasized in United States

v. Utah, supra, which is the most recent case of sig-

nificance on the subject, and where the Court found

water three feet deep sufficient to support navigation

(only about 10% as deep as the 30 foot depth of the

Great Salt Lake).

C. CONCLUSION

1. General

To satisfy fully the test of navigability as laid

down and consistently followed by the United States

Supreme Court over the 100 years last past, Utah need

merely show that the Great Salt Lake was susceptible

of commercial navigation on January 4, 1896, the date

at which Utah obtained statehood. It is believed that

the uncontroverted exhibits showing the lake at state-

hood to have had a depth of 30 feet, a length of more

than 75 miles, and a width of more than 30 miles, clearly

show such susceptibility. Further, it appears that the

United States does not deny this susceptibility, since

counsel for the United States explained during the

hearing that the “Queen Mary” and other “boats which

can cross the Atlantic could float in the Great Salt

Lake and maybe go—travel in the middle of the lake

to some degre ap and down the channel” ('T. 19), and

“»lmost any boat in the world, so far as I know, could

be used on the Great Salt Lake” (T. 280). The posi-

tion of the United States was that there was no com-

14

mercial reason or need to utilize the capability of the

lake for commercial navigation (T. 19).

As shown above, the United States Supreme

Court has clearly and consistently rejected argu-

ments claiming that either a commercial use or a

commercial need must be shown. 'The Court has made

clear that a showing of susceptibility is enough to vest

title in the state, because future possibilities of use

or need are too remote and speculative to be foreseen

with any certainty, and they cannot be discounted.

When and if the need should arise, the body of water

physically capable of supporting navigation will be

there to fill the need.

Even so, Utah believes that the record demonstrates

that the Great Salt Lake was used for commercial

navigation prior to statehood, at the time of statehood,

and at the present time. So, while Utah rejects any

argument that either a commercial use or a commercial

need must be shown, if such a novel standard should

be adopted, the evidence in the record clearly and un-

equivocally would satisfy that standard.

2. Method of Reference

Turning now to a different matter, it is believed

that some explanation will be helpful to the Court with

respect to the organization of the remaining contents

of this brief. Preceding the proposed Findings of Fact

and Conclusions of Law, there is a section entitled

Summary of Evidence, which contains a brief resume’

of the testimony of the witnesses, an identification of

the exhibits introduced, and a review of the physical

15

characteristics of the Great Salt Lake. This summary

is intended to serve as a review of the evidence prior

to presenting the proposed Findings and Conclusions.

The proposed Findings of Fact further contain direct

citations to the record, but the Summary of Evidence

will afford a preliminary and somewhat explanatory

reference for every citation to testimony or exhibits

referred to in the Findings of Fact.

The exhibits are identitied by the same designa-

tion and in the same manner as they were introduced ;

the two volume transcript of the testimony of witnesses

and other proceedings in open court is simply cited

by the letter “I”, followed by the appropriate page

number, Each witness is listed in the table of contents

at the beginning of the brief, along with the page at

which his testimony is summarized, so that the testi-

mony of any witness may be readily reviewed. Further,

each exhibit as listed in the Summary of Exhibits on

pages 33-41 of this brief contains a citation to that

part of the transcript where the particular exhibit was

first discussed or introduced.

It is hoped that this system of reference will expe-

dite use of the transcript in (1) reviewing the testi-

mony of witnesses and (2) obtaining foundation and

explanatory information relating to the exhibits.

Il. SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE

A. SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY

1. Zillah Walker Manning, called as a witness for

plaintiff, testified that:

a. She was born in 1891, five years before state-

hood, in Farmington, Utah, just east of Great

TUES Be Se SF AEM

16

Salt Lake ('T. 217); her family lived on Ante-

lope Island at the time of her birth, and she lived

on Antelope Island until she was 12 years old,

during which time her father was superintendeni

of livestock on the island ('T’. 217-18).

While on the island (until over 12 years of age j

she remembered livestock always moved to and

from the island aiid mainland “on a flat bottom

boat” (‘T. 219); and that her family would get

their supplies from Farmington by boat ('T.

220). She identified herself on a picture taken

on the island and marked as Exhibit P-39, and

admitted into evidence as Page 32-A of Exhibit

P-8, taken when she was 11 years old (1902)

T. 220); she also identitied a picture of a boat

that would frequently carry about 40 head cf

cattle and buffalo, and was powered by sail froin

the island to Farmington and back ('T. 221-

22, Exhibit P-8, page 32-A).

She remembered that a harvester, requiring: 12

horses to pull it, was taken to the island by boat

(‘T. 222); and that grain raised on the island

was shipped by boat. “lets of tines, about twice

a week in the summertime and once a month i:

the winter (T. 223).

‘ ’ . ’

. She remembered when her yather went by boat

to Salt Lake City and stayed two extra days to

celebrate Utah's statehood, and he brought her

a chrysanthemum, which she still has (‘T. 223-

24),

. She knew a Mr. George Frarey, who made h's

living with a boat by taking people around the

lake, from Antelope Island (‘T. 225}.

On cross-examination, she explained that White

and Sons owned the cattle boat used by her father

(‘T. 227); and that a Mr. Backman owned a bor!

which he used to ship others ranchers’ sheep

from Wenner’s Island (Fremont Island) to

17

~ er aga (T. 228) in Davis County (Exhibit

-1).

2. Leon L. Imlay, called as a witness for plaintiif,

testified that:

a.

He was born in 1893, three years prior to state-

hood, at Grantsville, Utah, near the southern

shore of the Great Salt Lake ('T. 61) and lived

there until 1939 ('T. 66).

b. His first recollection of visiting the Great Salt

Lake was in 1898, when he was nearly five years

of age, at which time he went to Garfield Beach

with his parents, where he rode as a passenger

on an excursion boat similar to the one pictured

at page 10 of Exhibit P-8 ('T. 62-63). He was

able to fix the exact year of that first visit be-

cause his mother was pregnant with a child which

was delivered August 15, 1898, which was shortly

after the boat trip (T. 64). He also recalled

that at that early age he had his hair in long

ringlets, and had a vivid recollection of some

passengers referring to him as a * beautiful young

lady” (T. 65).

». Many times thereafter he went to the Garfield

Beach for similar boat excursion rides (T. 63).

. He first visited Saltair Resort when he was sbout

15 years of age (12 years after statehood) ('T.

68), and remembered Saltair Beach as pictured

on page 13 of Exhibit P-8 and Saltair Resort

as pictured on page 14 of Exhibit P-8 (T.

67-68). During that first visit to Saltair,

he observed “many” boats, representing “every-

thing you could think of” snd including

sailboats, rowboats and powerboats (‘T. 68).

Ife lived at Grantsville for approximately 46

years (1893-1939) and during that time made

frequent trips to Salt Lake City, traveling on

Ce ae

18

a road that passed within 300 yards of the Great

Salt Lake; during these trips he saw many sail-

boats, rowboats and power driven boats of vari-

ous sizes on the Great Salt Lake; he observed

these boats as far out on the Lake as the center;

and he often counted the boats that could be seen,

and sometimes he counted more than 50 boats,

which were operating out of Garfield Beach

(T. 66-67).

. Beginning in 1928, as an employee of the Royal

Crystal Salt Company, he was assigned the re-

sponsibility of operating the pump station owned

by that company and located near Saltair Re-

sort, and used to pump lake brines to evaporation

ponds for production of commercial salt; he was

in charge of the pump station for about 11 years,

or until 1939; during this period he visited the

pump station one or two days each week, the

pump station being located in water about 8

feet deep; during these visits he would see a

number of boats, ranging in size from “tiny”

boats to large power boats; and, in fact, he and

his crew always had to use boats to operate the

pump station, carrying crewmen, gasoline for

the pump, fresh water and general supplies (T.

68-69, 73).

. He also visited Gunnison Island “with Charles

Stoddard on his sheep barge,” and “observed

where there had been operation of moving guano

from the island for fertilizer.” and the only way

to transport guano from the island was by boat

(T. 70-71).

3. Joseph S. Nelson, called as a witness for plaintiff,

testified that:

a. He is a lawyer, was born in 1897 (one year after

statehood), and began working at the Saltair

Resort when ten years of age because his father

19

was president and manager of the resort; and

he remembered Saltair as pictured at pages 13

and 14 of Exhibit P-8 (T. 83-84).

b. He said Saltair had a regular boat harbor and

a beach (T. 89) ; that part of his job was to col-

lect fees for the rental of boats on the lake; that

Saltair Beach operated a commercial excursion

boat called the “Alice Ann,” named after his

sister (‘T. 85); he remembered “many” other

commercial boats for hire, including the “Vista”

and the “Irene” (TT. 87-89); and said Saltair

entertained as many as 10,000 bathers a day

and 4,000 dancers at night ('T. 87).

c. He remembered a boat harbor at Sunset Beach

(T. 92) and a boat harbor at Garfield Beach

owned by Salt Lake County, identifying Ex-

hibit P-11 as a picture of one part of that harbor

and showing his brother's boathouse; he thought

the picture was taken during the 1930's (T.

91-92).

d. He remembered livestock barging operations

on the lake, including a boat named the “Ruth”

owned by John Dooley “that was a commercia!

boat used for hauling cattle back and forth from

the place they were raised and taken off Ante.

lope Island”; and that the owners of the live-

stock arranged to transport “their cattle and

sheep in boats, big barges to Saltair” (T. 85-

86), and that the barges would each hold over

50 head of cattle (T. 89); that the livestock

were shipped from Antelope Island to a rail-

head at Saltair, where they were unloaded from

the barges into chutes and then shipped by rail

(T. 85-86); and that he observed this livestock

barging operation each year between 1914 and

1920 (T. 93-94).

e. On cross-examination, he explained that the

“Ruth” was actually in the nature of a tug boat

SEO een eee

20

used to tow livestock barges (T. 96); that he

knew of other livestock barging operations from

Antelope Island to a Davis County boat dock,

but wasn't familiar with the details (TT. 97);

that the boats used for rental and commercial

excursions held from two passengers to fifty or

more (‘T. 94-95); and that Southern Pacific

owned a big 50 horsepower boat called the “E.

W. Marsh” which was used to patrol the Lucin

Cutoff trestle (T. 96).

4. Claire Wilcox Noall, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a.

b.

She was born in 1892, 4 years prior to statehood,

in Salt Lake City, Utah; received a B.A. Degree

from the University of Utah and completed the

M.A. Degree requirements in creative writing;

and has done considerable historical work and

had experience as a photographer (T. 75).

She was a neighbor of Captain Davis, and had

“several boating experiences” with him on the

Great Salt Lake (T. 75); and she specifically

remembered taking overnight excursions on the

“Cambria,” owned by Captain Davis, between

the vears of 1904 and 1906, when the Lucin Cut-

oif trestle was being constructed (T. 76); on

the overnight excursions 20 to 24 people were

on the boat, and 20 to 30 people were on the

boat during daily excursions ('f. 77); and after

Captain Davis discontinued operating boats, his

son took commercial excursions on the Great

Salt Lake (T. 78).

. Before she was 8 years of age she went to Saltair,

and remembered it “exactly” as shown or pages

12 and 14 of Exhibit P-8, and remembered see-

ing boats at Saltair ('T. 78-79).

21

5. Francis W. Kirkham, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a.

He was born in 1877, nine years before Utah's

statehood; was familiar with the boating activi-

ties at Garfield Beach before statehood; was a

paying passenger on the excursion boat pictured

on page 12 of Exhibit P-8; and the first such trip

that he took was before 1896 ('T. 233-35).

. Dr.Kirkham’s educational background included

an A.B. Degree from the University of Michi-

gan, an LL.B. Degree from the University of

Utah, and a Ph.D. from the University of Cali-

fornia at Berkeley (‘T. 233).

6. Phil Dern, called as a witness for plaintiff, testified

that:

a.

b.

He is 49 years of age; his father operated Sunset

Beach from 1934 until his death in 1957, and

prior to 1984 had operated Black Rock Beach;

and since 1957 he (Phil Dern) has operated Sun-

set Beach (T. 111).

‘Every year from 1934 to the present time Sunset

Beach has operated boats for hire, usually on a

concession basis whereby Sunset Beach receives

a percentage of the gross income from boat rides

and rentals, which percentage now approximates

$10,000.00 per year ('T. 112); the average boat

would carry 12 to 15 passengers, although the

present concessionaire (John Silver) also uses

several larger amphibious “army ducks” (T.

113).

. He operated a 28 foot Chris-Craft for about 5

years after World War II; Donald Newhouse, a

concessionaire, operated a 42 foot twin engine

diesel which carried about 35 commercial pas-

sengers and operated on a full time basis from

the middle of May to the end of September of

22

each year (T. 113-14); and his present boat rides

are typically from 20 to 30 minutes to aceommo-

date the time schedule of Greyline Motor ‘Tours

passengers, although other passengers can, and

do, take excursions anyplace on the lake ('T.

116, 121).

. He now has been awarded a contract by the Utah

Park and Recreation Commission to operate

boats on Antelope Island State Park at the north

end of Antelope Island; and this will require the

installation of a floating dock and related boat-

ing facilities, the sale of gas and oil to boaters,

and boat rides for hire (‘T. 114-15, 119).

. He personally observed commercial] shipment of

guano from Bird Island by a company which

used a 50 to 60 foot LCI landing craft, loading

the guano with a tractor with a front end loader,

and shipping it approximately 25 to 30 miles

from Bird Island to the Salt Lake County Boat

Harbor; the guano company operated on a reg-

ular basis each year from about 1947 to 1955, a

period of “eight or nine years” (T. 116-17, 123-

24).

7. John Clawson Silver, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a.

Since 1963 he has operated the Silver Sands

Beach on the Great Salt Lake for commercial

boat rides, and during that time his income from

boat passengers has increased from $8,000.00 to

$30,060.00 per year (T. 287-£3).

. He operates eight “army ducks” and a launch,

with each boat carrying 30 to 35 paying custom-

ers per trip; he has operated a 36 foot Chris-

Craft on the lake for 13 years for business promo-

tional purposes; and he is now considering pur-

chasing a boat 100 to 200 feet long for commer-

cial passenger service (T. 289-91).

23

c. He has operated several barges to ship salt crys-

tals and rock from Antelope Island and Stans-

bury Island to the mainland; these products were

not offered for sale but were used for decorative

purposes in his commercial appliance store (T.

289).

8. Reese F. Llewellyn, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a. He is a claims agent aad special agent of D &

RG Railroad; a member of the Utah State Bar,

and previously worked for Salt Lake County

Sheriff's office from 1935 to 1943 (T. 103).

b. His duties as a deputy sheriff took him to Sunset

Beach and Black Rock Beach and he identified

Exhibit P-11 as part of the Salt Lake County

Boat Harbor, built as “a big “I” shaped boat

harbor” (T. 104).

ce. The Salt Lake County Sheriff operated a tug-

like boat, 25 to 30 feet long, with a cabin and

powered by a diesel motor under the deck which

was used for law enforcement patrol and rescue,

operating continuously during summer months,

over substantial areas of the Lake (T. 105-06).

d. He frequently observed Eetween 40 and 50 boats

moored at the Salt Lake County Boat Harbor,

and as many as 75 to 100 additional boats out on

the lake. Also, other excursion and rental boats

were at Sunset and Black Rock Beaches. These

observations were made while he was serving on

the lake as a deputy sheriff from 1935 to 1943

(T. 106-07).

9. Harold J. Tippetis, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a. He is employed by the Division of Parks and

Recreation of the State of Utah and previously

24

served as the Director of the Great Salt Lake

Authority (T. 129).

b. The Division of Parks and Recreation has cre-

ated and is developing Antelope Island State

Park at the north end of Antelope Island, en-

compassing 2,000 acres of land; the park is con-

nected to the mainland by a recently constructed

causeway fill road 742 miles in length at a cost to

date in excess of $750,000.00 (‘T. 129-30, 137) ;

a boat ramp is to be constructed at the park and

$445,000.00 has been planned for marina facili-

ties (‘T. 130-31) ; there will be permanent berths

for 200 boats, ranging in size from small canoes

to 45 foot craft (T. 135, Exhibit P-16). The

major boating travel probably will be from the

southern part of the lake to the park, traveling

west of Antelope Island, but such travel could

cover the major portion of the lake (‘T. 132);

and there will be a boat concessionaire at the park

(T. 131-32).

c. Senate Bill 25 is now pending in the U.S. Con-

gress to establish a Great Salt Lake National

Monument on Antelope Island (‘T. 130, Exhibit

P-15); the National Park Service estimated that

the Utah State Park on Antelope Island would

attract 300,000 visitors the first year during the

5 year development period, and would attract in

excess of 840,000 visitors per year by the end of

such development period (‘T. 31).

d. The State of Utah, Salt Lake County and Hill

Air Force Base own and operate rescue craft on

the lake (T. 132).

10. Thomas T. Lundee, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a. He is a consulting engineer and naval architect,

licensed by the State of California, and owns

his own consulting company with offices in San

b.

ce.

25

Francisco (T. 166-67); he has designed many

small barges, large barges, off-shore drill rigs,

bulk carriers, tug boats, and dredges (‘T. 167-

68); he has obtained about 15 patents for marine

equipment design, including one for the “push-

tow process for large barges designed by him

for use on Great Sait Lake (T. 169) ; and, gen-

erally, has designed marine craft for over 30

years, is familiar with barge design, operation

and use, and is familiar with navigable waters,

including navigable waters of the United States

CT. 169).

He was engaged by Morrison-\Knudson Corm-

pany and International Engineers to design

barges and tug boats for use ou Great Salt Lake

to construct a rock fill causeway across the lake

for Southern Pacific Company (‘T. 170); he

studied the waters of the lake, finding them to

contain about 20°, more salt than ocean water,

thus resulting in a 20° “bonus” in carrying

‘apacity of barges and other craft because the

greater buoyancy resulted in a shallower draft

('T. 171-72); and he discovered that the heavier

salt concentration prevented the water from

freezing, thus permitting year round barging

operations (‘T. 172, 177), and that such salt

concentration presented no serious problems of

corrosion, operation or maintenance (‘T. 173-

74, 177).

Thirty nine boats were acquired at a cost of

about $7,000,000.00 ('T. 176) for use on the

Great Salt Lake causeway construction (T.

173) ; including barges and equipment designed

specifically for that particular job (‘T. 169,

175); and that the boats consisted of :

(1) Six large dump barges 250 feet long, 55

feet wide, and 12 1.3 feet deep, each cap-

able of carrying a per trip tonnage load

ees

26 a

equal to 90 railroad cars; with a draft of

13 feet (‘T. 175-76)5

(2) Six 1, orsepower tow boats to push the

rges ;

(3) Five deck barges 178 feet long, 48 feet

wide, and 10 feet high, with a per trip

carrying capacity of 1,600 tons each;

(4) ‘Two 600 horsepower twin-screw tour

boats;

(5) Three 220 horsepower tug boats;

(6) Two dredges;

(7) Fifteen miscellaneous boats, including

dredge tenders, anchor scows, anchor

barges, pile driving barges, crew boats and

scows (T. 176, Exhibit P-21).

d. The thirty nine boats were used on the Great

Salt Lake for about two years, from early 1957

to 1959 (T. 177), completing a job that cost

about $49,000,000.00 and required the removal

and placing of 41,000,000 cubic yards (over 70,-

000,000 tons) of fill, with over 90° of the fill

being placed by barges as the only feasible

means of hauling and placing such fill ('T. 178-

79); the tonnage of fill hauled by the barges

was “vastly cheaper” than that part of the fill

actually hauled by trucks and railroad cars

(less than 10°.) ('T. 179).

e. The Great Salt Lake was particularly economi-

cal for navigation, because:

(1) The water did not freeze in winter and the

causeway fleet operated day and night, six

or sever) days a week, twelve months a year

_ ae

(2) The herpor, dredged at Little Valley near

Promontory Point, was 400 feet wide and

27

1,500 feet long, and was unusually inex-

pensive because it was clay with very little

rock ('T. 181); due to lack of currents and

tides in the lake, the harbor did not silt or

fill and during the two years of continual

use no further dredging, cleaning or main-

tenance was required (‘I’. 182-84) ; and, in

general, the cost of harbor construction

and maintenance on the Great Salt Lake

was “appreciably less” than on other inland

waterways customarily used for navigation

('T. 184).

(3) ‘The greater buoyancy of the waters of the

Great Salt Lake made navigation more

economical than navigation on other inland

waters or oceans because there is at least a

20° bonus in carrying capacity (T. 171) ;

the dump barges that operated fully loaded

on Great Salt Lake with a 13 foot draft

would have required a 151 foot draft on

the Mississippi River, and since that river

has a 9 foot governing channel, could only

have operated there with a partial load (T.

175-76); all barges in commercial use in

1896 when Utah obtained statehood could

have successfully navigated on the Great

Salt Lake (T. 207-08); and barges in com-

mon use today, such as grain barges, cement

barges, petroleum barges and all other com-

mercial barges shown in a publication en-

titled “Commercial Transportation on the

Inland Waterways,” published by the So-

ciety of Naval Architects and Marine En-

gineers (Exhibit P-22), could operate fully

loaded on the Great Salt Lake (T. 206).

f. Additionally, Mr. Lundee stated that:

(1) After completion of the causeway on Great

Salt Lake, the barges and other craft were

in good condition and were sold at favor-

28

able prices for use elsewhere in the world

(some, loaded with smaller craft, were towed

across the Atlantic Ocean for use in Por-

tugal) (T. 173-74).

(2) It would be necessary to use boats to drill

for oil or gas underneath the bed of the

Great Salt Lake (T. 210).

(3) If the need should arise, the railroad trestle

and causeway could be modified at reason-

able cost to accommodate larger commer-

cial vessels, probably by constructing draw

bridges or swing bridges (‘T’. 206-07).

11. Golden O. Peterson, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a. He is employed by the Southern Pacific Com-

pany, owner of the railroad trestle and cause-

way across Great Salt Lake; he was first as-

signed to duty on the lake in 1942, and in 1956

was promoted to his present position as Assist-

ant Bridges and Buildings Supervisor ('P. 148-

49).

b. Since 1956, he has used boats exch weck on the

lake to inspect the trestle for safety; and pricr

to the construction of the causeway the boat

patrol trips to inspect the trestle were made

daily (‘T. 150); the boats now used for inspec-

tion and patrol include three 28 foot steel boats

with 12 foot beams (Exhibits P-19 and P-20,

'T’. 150-52) and one 25 foot steel boat (‘T. 153) ;

the trestle is about 12 miles long and a round

trip on patrol takes about 5 hours ('T. 150-51) ;

the 25 foot boat can go through the trestle and

the causeway culverts at ali times; but when the

lake level is high the 28 foot boats sometimes

have trouble with vertical clearance in the cause-

way culverts, and when the water is low the 28

foot boats sometimes have difficulty with lateral

29

clearance when passing through the trestle (‘T.

153-56).

12. Gail Sanders, called as a witness for plaintiff,

testified that:

a.

He is president of the Sanders Brine Shrimp

Company; has been engaged in brine shrimp

operations on the Great Salt Lake since 1953;

and he and his brother are employed on a full

iime basis by the business (‘T. 157).

. Most brine shrimp are harvested near Antelope

Island and require the use of boats, both for

harvesting and transporting; shrimp eggs are

blown to the shore and ordinarily harvested with

special equipment on a four wheel drive vehicle

(T. 158-59, 163); the shrimp and eggs are sold

for tropical fish food, and the eggs are vacuum

packed in cans and the shrimp frozen in plastic

bags and shipped all over the world (‘T. 160,

163); eggs usually represent the majority har-

vest, but conditions vary and this is not always

so ('T. 163-64); the largest annual harvest of

eggs was 200,000 pounds (‘T. 161) and _ the

largest annual harvest of shrimp was 90,000

pounds (‘f. 162), and they pay the Utah Di-

vision of Fish and Game a royalty of about

$5,000.00 per vear (T. 160).

"The company uses three air boats 18 feet long

and 6 feet wide (each capable of carrving about

1.200 pounds of adult shrimp) (T. 158-59) ;

other boats have been used in the past, but the

air boats are preferable because they can operate

in any depth of water (T. 158).

13. William Paxton Hewitt, called as a witness for

plaintiff, testified that:

ot

He is Director of the Utah Geological and

Mineralogical Survey (UGMS) and Professor

of Geology at the University of Utah (T. 139).

b.

Cc.

d.

30

=

The UMGS operates a fleet of five boats on

the Great Salt Lake, including three amphib-

ious ducks, a 21 foot motor dory, and a 42 foot

steel research vessel with a 13 foot beam (T.

130-40, 145, Exhibits P-14, P-24 and P-25);

these boats are used for scientific investigations

on the lake, and the only way this can be done

is through the use of boats ('.. 140); the in-

vestigative work includes study of the chemical

characteristics of, and variations in, the brines

(T. 140), and study of the bottom sediments to

determine the required support structures for

oil exploration drilling and possible mineral ex-

traction from bed sediments (‘I’. 141) ; other in-

vestigative studies have been performed by pri-

vate organizations (Exhibit P-i7, 'T. 142) by

renting the large UGMS boat for $550.00 per

day, by the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers for

a national defense mapping program in 1968

(T. 143), and both the Water Resources Di-

vision and the Topographic Division of the

United States Geological Survey use the UG-

MS craft for scientific work (T. 146); during

1969 the University of Wisconsin will use the

UGMS craft to perform seismic work on the

lake, in cooperation with the UGMS and the

Department of Geophysics at the University of

Utah (T. 145); and Hogel Zoo uses UGMS

craft each year to obtain birds from the lake

islands for trades and exchanges with other

zoos (T. 145-46).

The UGMS craft navigate all parts of the lake,

both north and south of the railroad causeway

(T. 143) ; and the studies being conducted now,

and in progress since 1965, are projected to con-

tinue indefinitely (T. 141-42).

There are commercial deposits of lithic sand or

lime sand, which is used as a flux in smelting

operations, on the south shore of the lake, on the

31

west side of the lake, and to the northwest of

Stansbury Island (‘T. 146).

14. Donald G. Prince, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

He has been employed for 15 years last past by

the Division of State Lands, State of Utah;

that there has been constant leasing of the bed

of the Great Salt Lake for oil and gas during

these 15 years, such leases covering about 600,-

000 acres; the State always charges a lease

rental fee; the lessees have been and are inajor

oil companies; leases are still outstanding; sev-

eral wells have been drilled; but no wells are

currently in the process of being drilled (T.

127-28).

15. John Nagel, called as a witness for plaintiff, testi-

fied that:

He is in charge of waterfowl] management for

the Division of Fish and Game of the State of

Utah, and has been so associated for seven years

(‘T. 212); there are 80,000 acres of developed

waterfowl habitat and an additional 80,000

acres of natural waterfowl! habitat on the Great

Salt Lake, plus habitat for many additional

birds (‘T. 214) ; there are 5,000,000 days use per

year of the lake by waterfowl] and marsh re-

lated birds ('T. 214).

16. Helmut H. Doelling, called as a witness for plain-

tiff, testified that:

a. He is an economic geologist at the University of

Ucaa, employed by the Utah Geological and

Mineralogical Survey, with a Ph.D. in geology

(T. 293-94); his thesis for his doctorate was on

the geology of an area west of the Great Salt

Lake (T. 294).

52

b. There are valuable lead deposits near the lake,

known as the Monarch Mine (T. 296); large

commercial oolite sand deposits near Lakeside

(T. 296) and north of the railroad causeway

(‘T. 297); and “very pure, very good” deposits

of dolomite and limestone all through the area

west of the lake (‘T. 297); ragonite deposits in

Grassy Mountains and Cedar Mountains near

the lake ('T. 297, 303) ; low grade, but potenti-

ally commercial, phostatic beds west of the Ter-

race Mountains (‘T. 298); deposits of metals,

dolomite, limestone and building stone in New-

foundland Mountains and Silver Island near

the lake (‘T. 298) ; and, in general, ihere is con-

siderable unexplored mineral potential north-

west of the Great Salt Lake (‘T. 299).

17. Elmer Butler, called as a witness for defendant,

testified that:

a. He was born in Grantsville, Uiah, near the

Great Salt Lake, and is presently employed

the Water Resources Division of the United

States Geological Survey (T. 246).

b. In connection with his employment, he partc!-

pated in a water resources survey of some of the

tributaries to the Great Salt Lake; this study

was performed in April, 1964, when the lake

was about 6.8 feet lower than at statehood and

about 3 feet lower than at the time of the hear-

ing in May, 1969 (247, 257-58) ; during his trip

along the lake in 1964 he observed large areas

of shoreland as “stretches of sand, marshy

areas, and particularly in those places “where

the lake had been” (T. 250); and “large areas

of flats — some places its mud and salt beds”

(T. 251); and, in general, that the area west of

the lake was very sparsely populated ('T. 247-

54).

~

33

c. He also testified that he was familiar with the

lake and was aware of the dolomite deposits near

the lake which were shipped to the Geneva

Plant of U. S. Steel for use as a flux, and that

he worked at the dolomite mine as a boy (‘T.

261); that he was aware of “very valuable de-

posits” of dolomite sands on Stansbury Island

which could only be shipped by boat during “‘ex-

pected” high cycles of the lake level ('T. 262);

that he was aware of valuable guano deposits

shipped from Gunnison Island and Hat Island

(‘T. 262); and knew that the livestock on Fre-

mont Island could only be shipped by boat “or

helicopter” and that the livestock on Antelope

Island, during high water levels, could only be

shipped by boat ('T. 263-64).

B. SUMMARY OF EXHIBITS

Ewhibit No.

P-1 U.S.G.S. map showing Great Salt Lake and

surrounding area (‘T. 26).

P-2 U.S.G.S. hydrograph showing gage read-

ings of level of Great Salt Lake from 1950

to present time (‘P. 27).

P-3 Diagram showing lake as it existed at state-

hood on January 4, 1896, including length,

width, depth contours, and perimeter (‘T.

27).

P-4 Diagram showing longitudinal section of

g & _—— : me

lake as to depth and variation in bed (T.

28).

P-5 Diagram showing longitudinal line illus-

s ~ a

trated in Exhib:i P-4, and to be correlated

with that exhibit (T. 28).

P-6 Early reconnaissance map of Great Salt

Lake (1849-50) (T. 31).

P-8

34

Early 1871 mining map showing lake and

location of General Connor's steamship

routes on the lake (‘T’. 32).

Historical Materials, as follows (‘I’. 30-60) :

Page 1

Page 2

Page 2-A

Page 2-B

Page 2-C

Pages 3-5

Use of boats in the early sur-

vey of Great Salt Lake in

1843 by John G. Fremont.

Newspaper accounts in 1854

of launching of ship “The

Timely Gull and in 1855 of

availability of sailboat “Dese-

ret’ for excursions “on rea-

sonable terms.”

Account of large shipments of

railroad ties on lake in 1869.

Account of late 1860's and

early 1870's where steamboats

shipped “great quantities of

ore’ from south end of lake to

northeast part of lake, and es-

cursion boats capable of czrry-

ing 300 passengers,

Pictures of “Lucin” as now

located in San Francisco har-

bor, but built for and used on

Great Salt Lake in construc-

tion of Lucin Cutoff trestle

by Southern Pacific Com-

pany in 1906.

Newspaper advertisements in

1875 and 1876 promoting

commercial passenger service

on ship “General Garfield.”

The advertisements also re-

flect the variety and volume

of commercial shipments, e.g.,

on page 4: “On and after Au-

Page 6

Page 7

Page 8

Page 9

a3

gust Ist the regular rates on

Ore, Bullion, Coke, Charcoal

and Coal will be\$2.15 per ton

between Salt Lake City and

Haifway House in lots of not

less than 12,000 Ibs. loaded

and unloaded by the company,

and $2.00 per ton when not

loaded or unloaded by the

company. Freight for the west

will be received on weekdays

only from 7 a.m. to 10 a.m.

and forwarded the same day,

while that received from 10

a.m. to 6 p.m. wil be forward-

ed the next day. or any fur-

ther information concerning

freight, apply to J. N. Pike,

Gen! Freight Agent, G. W.

Thatcher, Gen] Passenger

Agent, H. P. Kimball, Gen}

Superintendent.”

Newspaper advertisement in

1877 reporting resort activi-

ties, including row boats and

sail boats.

Newspaper advertisement and

sketch of “grand opening” of

Garfield Beach in 1887.

Newspaper advertisement of

resort activities at Garfield

Beach - including boating -

in 1896, the year of Utah's

statehood.

Photographs of steamship

“General Garfield” and ship-

ping dock at Halfway House

near Lake Point.

Page 13

Page 14

Page 14-A

Page 15

Pages 16-A

thru 16-D

Pages 18-A

and 18-B

36

Photographs of “General Gar-

field” on Great Salt Lake.

Photographs of boats at Gar-

field Beach.

Photographs of “General

Garfield” and Saltair, the lat-

ter being constructed in 1893,

three years before Utah's

hood in 1896. ,

Photographs of \Saltair and

Garfield Beach.

Photographs of Saltair.

Photographs of Saltair in

about 1909 and Black Rock in

about 1900.

Extract from publication dis-

cussing sheep, cattle, horses,

cedar posts and buffalo being

shipped on lake in 1870's.

Account of shipment of sheep

(300 head per boat load),

cattle, ore, salt, cedar posts

(3,000 on top deck) —- using

several boats, including “Lady

of the Lake,” a flat boat for

cattle, and a 75 foot salt trans-

port boat—and shipping much

cargo to a railhead in Davis

County.

Reference to “City of Cor-

inne’ carrying 400 sheep per

load, and a_ picture of the

Miller Brothers’ boat.

Extract from compilation by

Kate Carter, identifying and

Page 19

Pages 20-22

Pages 23-A

thru 23-D

—

a

as

_—

JS

fa)

te

or

Pages 26-A

thru 26-D

37

discussing several of the im-

portant early boats used on

Great Salt Lake, and explain-

ing that at one point the ship-

ment of gold ore was a com-

mercial incentive in addition

to passengers and other

freight.

Agreement whereby Central

Pacific Railway Company in

1903 paid $2,500.00 to owner

of Fremont Island as com-

pensation for — interference

with navigation rights by con-

struction of railroad trestle

across lake from Ogden to

Lucin.

Extracts from Journal of

Captain David L. Davis, who

for fifty years (beginning in

1868) continually operated

commercial and pleasure boats

on the lake.

Excerpts from an article writ-

ten by Mr. and Mrs. Stephen

L. Richards about navigation

experiences of Captain Davis

on the Great Salt Lake.

Copy of Constitution of The

Salt Lake Yacht Club.

Copy of certificate of member-

ship in Salt Lake Yacht Club,

signed by Captain Davis in

1874.

Various newspaper accounts

in 1870's and 1880's showing

Page 27

Pages 28-30

Page 31

Page 32

Page 32-A

Page 33

Pages 34-A

thru 34-D

38

illustrative commercial and

recreational boating activities

on the lake.

Newspaper account April 20,

1926 of the death of Captein

David L. Davis, ending “50

year Lake voyaging.

Pictures of boat referred to in

Journal of Captain Davis.

Account of Captain Edwin G.

Brown and his many boating

activities on the lake prior to

his death in 1937, including

heading the Salt Lake Yacht

Club, which then “owned over

forty craft on Great Salt

Lake.”

Photographs of Great Salt

Lake boats and dock facilities.

Photograph of boat used to

haul supplies, cattle and buf-

falo from Antelope Island to

mainland near date of state-

hood, and_ picture of Zillah

Walker Manning, a witness

(see T. 220-22).

Newspaper advertisement list -

ing “moonlight boating” by

Saltair Resort in 1909.

Newspaper accounts in 1909

of various boats and boating

activities on the Great Salt

Lake.

Pp-9

P-10

P-11

P-12

P-13

P-14

P-15

P-15

P-17

Pp-18

39

Photograph of steamboat “Promontory” (‘T.

60).

Specifications for ship “Promontory (‘T.

60).

Photograph of Salt Lake County Boat Har-

bor (‘T. 60).

Photograph of scow driver (derrick on a boat

on lake) (‘T. 109).

Publication of Brotherhood of Engineers’

Monthly Journal, discussing construction of

Lucin Cutoff trestle, and use of fleet of boats

consisting of seven tug boats, sternwheel

steamer, numerous small boats, and nine

gasoline launches, each capable of carrying

from 15 to 35 persons “for a sail on the

lake.” (T. 109).

Publication showing photographs of boats of

Utah Geological Survey currently in use on

the lake (T. 144).

Copy of Senate Bill 25 introduced in the 91st

Congress to create Antelope Island Na-

tional Monument on Great Salt Lake ae

130).

Map prepared by National Park Service

with respect to congressional hearings on

S_B. 25. and showing facilities of Antelope

Island State Park on Great Salt Lake (T.

136).

Copy of lease agreement showing rental of

Utah Geological Survey boat for scientific

purposes at the rate of $550.00 per day (T.

142).

Copy of Utah statutes creating Great Salt

Lake Authority and Utah Park and Recre-

ation Commission, and assigning jurisdic-

P-21

P-23

P-24, 25

P-26-28

P-29

40

tion over lake and boating activities. (‘T.

138).

Drawings and specifications of patrol boats

currently in use by Southern Pacitie Com-

pany on Great Salt Lake (T. 150).

Album of photographs of barges, tugboats,

other craft and operations during construc-

tion of railroad causeway on Great Salt Lake

('T. 185).

Pamphlet of specifications of barges and ma-

rine craft used in construction of railroad

causeway on lake (T. 189).

Article on Commercial ‘Transportation ou

the Inland Waterways, showing commercial

barges in common use today that could suc-

cessfully navigate Great Salt Lake (‘T. 205).

Motion picture with sound track showing

barge and marine operation during construc:

tion of railroad causeway (T. 204).

Photographs of 42 foot steel boat of Utah

Geological Survey, &s used for scientific pur-

poses (T. 211).

Photographs of sailboats during 1968. sail-

boat regatta on Great Salt Lake (T. 211).

Photograph of present appearance of Little

Valley boat harbor and dock area, having

been constructed for use during railroad

causeway project (T. 211).

Publication on Bird Life of Great Salt Lake

by William H. Behie (‘T. 215).

Copy, Senate Hearings on S.B. 265 (Great

Salt Lake Lands Act) (T. 287).

Copy, House Hearings on H.R. 1791 (Great

Salt Lake Lands Act) (T. 237).

P-33

P-34

P-35

P-36, 37

P-38

P-39

P-40

1)-1

D-2

+1

Copy, House Committee Report on H.R.

1791 (Great Salt Lake Lands Act) (T.

237).

Copy, Senate Committee Report on S.B.

265 (Great Salt Lake Lands Act) (‘T’. 237).

Copy, Utah Senate Bill 8, accepting federal

conditions of Great Salt Lake Lands Act

('T. 287).

Copy, documents showing federal recogni-

nition of state ownership of waterfow] areas

located on lake bed lands ('T. 238).

Documents relating to Willard Bay im-

poundment as part of Weber Basin Project,

showing purchase by the United States from

the State of Utah of portion of lake bed

lands (‘T. 238).

Copy, Utah statute and U.S. statute relating

to Bear River Bird Refuge, showing mutual

recognition by U.S. Congress and Utah Leg-

islature that Great Sale Lake was navigable

(T. 242).

Contract showing present mining and re-

moval of lime sand for flux from Stansbury

Island on Great Salt Lake ('T. 285).

Map of Antelope Island and southern part

of Great Salt Lake (‘T. 30).

Map of Great Salt Lake, prepared by U.S.

G.S. (T. 245).

ITistorical Materials relating to boating on

Great Salt Lake (‘T. 268).

Report by U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

concerning feasibility of building new boat

harbor on Great Salt Lake (‘T. 281).

a en ee

x 42

C. SUMMARY OF PHYSICAL CHARACTER-

ISTICS OF GREAT SALT LAKE AT

STATEHOOD.

The preceding summary of the testimony of wit-

nesses and the identification of exhibits illustrates the

clear capacity of the Great Salt Lake to support com-

mercial navigation and the many and varied uses made

of the lake for that purpose. This section of the brief

is simply a recapitulation of some of the highlights of

that evidence which shows the physical capability of

the lake at the date of statehood to support commercial

navigation, as demonstrated by some of the major

uses made of the lake at times when the water level

was lower than at statehood. In other words, if the

lake at a depth of approximately 26 feet successfull)

supported the fleet of commercial vessels used for the

construction of the railroad causeway, then the lake

certainly could have supported the same craft at the

date of statehood when it was approximately five feet

deeper.

This section of the brief, then, is only an abbre-

viated recital of some of the highlights contained in

the foregoing sections summarizing the evidence, and

those preceding sections should be reviewed in detail

for a much more complete picture of the navigation uses

on the lake and the lake's capability of supporting

such navigation. Therefore, in a nutshell, the following

are some of the most significant physical characteristics

and capabilities of the Great Salt Lake (at the date

of statehood) with respect to its navigability:

1. The Great Salt Lake, at statehood, was a reia-

tively large body of water, 77 miles long, 32.5 miles

43

wide, and 30 feet deep; the areas of the lake which

had a depth of 30 feet or more were not narrow chan-

nels, but were several miles wide and extended substan-

tially throughout the length of the lake; and some of

the world’s largest barges, as used during the railroad

causeway construction and when fully loaded drawing

13 feet of water, actually operated from east to west

across the width of the lake, and could have operated

over practicaily the entire length of the lake, as shown

on the area included within the contour line on Exhibit

P-3 at elevation 4185 feet (or a water depth greater than

15.8 feet at statehood). See, generally, Exhibit P-3 and

T. 175, et. seq., see also Exhibit P-2, which is the U.S.

G.S. hydrograph showing gage readings of the level of

Great Salt Lake from 1850 to the present date, and

showing the lowest level of the lake at a depth in excess

of 20 feet, the level at statehood at a depth in excess

of 30 feet, and the current level in May, 1969 at a

depth in excess of 26 feet.

2. The Great Salt Lake at statehood was suscep-

tible of serving as a useful highway of commerce and

supporting those types of commercial water craft then

in use, including all of the barges in use anywhere in

the world at that time (T. 207-08); the lake, at a level

five feet lower than at statehood, in fact supported

the causeway marine fleet that included deck barges

each capable of transporting 1,600 tons per trip (more

than 13 times the capacity of the steamer mentioned

by the Court in The Daniel Ball, supra,) and

larger dump barges each capable of transporting a

much greater per trip tonnage (equal to the tonnage

that 90 railroad cars would have been capable of haul-

ing).

SPE OE. Gar a.

44

3. The Great Salt Lake was and is particularly

economical for navigation, because:

(a) The water does not freeze in winter, as il-

lustrated by the fact that the causeway fieet op-

erated day and night, six or seven days a week,

twelve months a year (‘T. 177) ;

(b) Harbor and dock facilities are easy to con-

struct, as illustrated by the fact that the harbor

dredged at Little Valley near Promontory Port

was 400 feet wide and 1,500 feet long and was

unusually inexpensive because it was clay wiili

very little rock (‘T. 181); due to lack of currents

and tides in the lake, the harbor did not silt or fill

and during the two years of continual use no

further dredging, cleaning or maintenance was

required (‘T. 182-84); and, in general, the cost

of harbor construction and maintenace on the

Great Salt Lake was ‘

other inland waterways customarily used for navi-

gation (T. 184).

‘appreciably less” than on

(c) The greater bouyancy of the waters of the

Great Salt Lake make navigation more economic

than navigation on other inland waters or oceans

because there is at least a 20% bonus in carrying

capacity (‘T. 171); the dump barges that operated

fully loaded on Great Salt Lake with a 13 foot

draft would have required a 151) foot draft on

the Mississippi River, and since that river has a

9 foot governing channel, could only have operated

there with a partial load ('T. 175-76); and barges

in common ‘use today, such as grain barges, cement

barges, petroleum barges and all other commer-

45

cial barges shown in a publication entitled “Com-

mercial ‘Transportation on the Inland Water-

ways, published by the Society of Naval Archi-

iects and Marine Engineers (Exhibit P-22),

could operate fully loaded on the Great Salt Lake

('‘T. 206).

To emphasize again, the foregoing review of the

physical susceptibility of the Great Salt Lake for com-

mercial navigation does not include references to the

many actual navigational uses of the lake. The latter

are included in Sections II A and II B.

FINDINGS OF FACT

TVinding No. 1. The Great Salt Lake was located

entirely within the State of Utah on January 4, 1896,

the date at which Utah obtained statehood, and at all

times since has been and now is located entirely within

said State.

Reference: Exhibits P-1, P-2 and P-3.

Finding No. 2. The general physical character-

istics of the Great Salt Lake as of January 4, 1898,

may be summarized as follows:

a. The lake had a maximum length of 77 miles;

a maximum width of 32.5 miles; and a depth approxi-

mating 30 feet. The bottom of the lake was, and has

continued to be, relatively flat.

Reference: Exhibits P-3, P-4 and P-5.

b. ‘Phe lake has no outlet; is fed by a number of

4

Qype aniers ARUN AL Fa

at

46

tributary rivers, the principal ones of which are the

Jordan River, Weber River and Bear River; experi-

ences seasonal fluctuations averaging between one and

two feet in vertical elevation each year; and has a salt

or brine concentration in the water in excess of 20%.

Reference: Exhibits P-1, P-2, and T. 171-72.

c. The lake affords a more economic commercial

navigation than most inland navigable waters of the

United States because the salt concentration in the

water (1) gives a much greater buoyancy than either

fresh water or sea water, thus supporting greater loads

with less draft; and (2) permits ice from freezing in

winter months, thus permiting year-round navigational

uses. Further, harbor construction is less expensive

because the material dredged is clay rather than rock.

and harbor maintenance is less expensive because there

are no tides and currents to cause ‘Uiling or sedimen-

tation.

Reference: Thomas 'T. Lundee, witness for plain-

tiff, T. 171, 175-176, 177, 182-84.

d. The lake on January 4, 1896 was physically

capable of supporting those types of water craft which

were commonly used for commercial navigation on in-

land navigable waters on said date, including the larg-

est barges then in use anywhere in the world; and is

now physically capable of supporting barges and similar

craft in common current use for navigation on inland

navigable waters of the United States.

Reference: Thomas 'T. Lundee, witness for plain-

tiff. T. 206-08, Exhibit P-22. During the construction

47

of the Southern Pacific railroad causeway in 1957-59,

when the lake successfully supported some of the

world’s largest barges, the lake was five feet lower or

shallower than at statehood; and, further, in 1963-64,

at the lowest or shailowest point in the lake’s 119 year

history of recorded elevation readings, the lake had a

depth in excess of 20 feet (Exhibit P-2 (hydrograph) ).

Finding No. 3. Indicative of the fact that the Great

Salt Lake is and at the date of statehood was suscep-

tible of commercial navigation, it is found that the

Great Salt Lake either has been or currently is being

navigated for various purposes, including shipment of

cattle, sheep, horses, bufialo, ores and minerals, fence

posts, railroad ties, guano, commercial salt, decorative

salt crystals and rocks, farm machinery, grain, house-

hold supplies and pump station supplies; and has also

been navigated for the construction of a railroad trestle

and causeway, recreation craft for paying passen-

gers and for commercial hire or rental, private craft

for recreation, scientific investigative purposes, railroad

maintenance patrol, law enforcement patrol, rescue op-

erations, and the harvest of brine shrimp.

Reference: The early history of navigation on

the Great Salt Lake is illustrated quite well in the

compilation of historical materials contained in Ex-

hibit P-8. This collection covers a period of time

commencing more than forty years before statehood

and continues for a number of years after statehood.

Only limited references to that material will be made

here, but the entire contents are very enlightening

and should be examined in conjunction with T. 30-

60, which is an explanation by plaintiff's counsel of

the importance and relevance of that material. See

also the Summary of Exhibits contained in this brief.

48

The following references are cited with respect to

different types of navigational uses, although many

boats were used for several purposes, such as hauling

passengers, ore, livestock and other products. The

references include not only historical materials, but

also testimony from live witnesses and the evidence

contained within the various exhibits.

a.

b.

Livestock, including cattle, sheep, horses and

buffalo.

Joseph S. Nelson, witness for plaintiff, T. 85-

86, 89, 93-94, 96-97.

Zillah Walker Manning, witness for plaintiff,

T. 217-19, 221-22, 227-28.

Leon L. Imlay, witness for plaintiff, T. 70-71.

Exhibit P-8, pages 15, 16-A through 16-D, 17,

19, 32-A.

Ore and Minerals.

Exhibit P-8, pages 2-B, 4 (ore, bullion, coke,

charcoal, coal), 16-A through 16-D, 18-A and

18-B (gold).

Exhibit P-8, pages 9, 10.

. Fence Posts and Railroad Ties.

Exhibit P-8, pages 2-A, 15, 16-A through 16-D.

. Guano.

Phil Dern, witness for plaintiff, T. 116-17,

123-24.

Leon I. Imlay, witness for plaintiff, 'T. 70-71.

Elmer Butler, witness for defendant, T. 262.

.Commercial Salt.

Exhibit 8, pages 16-A through 16-D (special 75

foot salt transport barge).

’. Decorative Salt Crystals and Rocks.

John Clawson Silver, witness for plaintiff, T.

289.

49

g. Farm and Industrial Machinery.

Zillah Walker Manning, witness for plaintiff,

T. 222.

Phil Dern, witness for plaintiff, T, 124.

h. Grain.

Zillah Walker Manning, witness for plaintiff,

2. See.

i. Household Supplies.

Exhibit P-8, page 32-A.

Zillah Walker Manning, witness for plaintiff,

T. 220.

j. Pump Station Supplies.

Leon L. Imlay, witness for plaintiff, T. 68-69,

73.

k. Construction of Railroad Trestle.

Exhibit P-8, pages 2-C

Exhibit P-9

Exhibit P-10

Exhibit P-12

Exhibit P-13

l. Construction of Railroad Causeway.

Thomas 'T. Lundee, witness for plaintiff, T. 165-

210.

Exhibit P-20

Exhibit P-21

Exhibit P-22

Exhibit P-23

Exhibit P-29

m. Commercial Recreation Craft.

B, os, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11,

22. 23-

Exhibit P-8, pages 2. 2-

20- A through 23-D,

12, 13, 14, 14-A,

7

n.

50

26-A through 26-D, 27, 28-30, 31, 32, 33, 34-A

through 34-D.

Exhibit P-9

Exhibit P-10

Exhibit P-11

Exhibit P-13

Leon L. Imlay, witness for plaintiff, ‘I’. 62-68.

Joseph S. Nelson, witness for plaintiff, ‘I’. 83-92.

Claire Wilcox Noall, witness for plaintiff, IT’. 75-

79.

Francis W. Kirkham, witness for plaintiff, ‘I’.

233-34.

Puil Dern, witness for plaintiff, 'T. 111-116, 119.

John Clawson Silver, witness for plaintiff, T.

287-91.

Reese I’, Llewellyn, witness for plaintiff, 'T’. 104-

107.

Harold J. Tippetts, witness for plaintiff, ‘I. 129-

37.

Private Craft for Recreation.

Exhibit P-8, pp. 20-22, 23-A through 23-D, 24,

25, 26-A through 26-D, 27, 28-30, 31, 32-A

through 34-D.

Exhibit P-11

Exhibits P-26, P-27, P-28.

Leon L. Imlay, witness for plaintiff, T. 62-68.

Joseph S. Nelson, witness for plaintiff, 'T’. 83-92.

Claire Wileox Noall, witness for plaintiff, ‘i.

75-79.

Phil Dern, witness for plaintiff, TT. 111-116.

Reese F. Llewellyn, witness for plaintiff, 'T. 104-

O07.

Harold J. Tippetts, witness for plaintiff, T. 129-

37.

Craft for Scientific Purposes.

William P. Hewitt, witness for plaintiff, T. 139-

46.

51

Exhibit P-8, page 1, and T. 34.

Exhibit P-14.

Exhibit P-17

Exhibits P-24, P-25

p. Railroad Maintenance Pairol.

Exhibit P-19

Golden O. Peterson, witness for plaintiff, 'T.

148-56.

Joseph S. Nelson, witness for plaintiff, T. 96.

q. Law Enforcement Patrol.

Reese F’. Llewellyn, witness for plaintitf, 'T. 105-

06.

Harold J. Tippetts, witness for plaintiff, 'T. 132,

134.

Exhibit P-18.

r. Rescue Operations.

Harold J. Tippetts, witiess for plaintiff, 'T. 132.

Reese F. Llewellyn, witness for plaintiff, 'T. 105-

06.

s. Brine Shrimp Harvest.

Gail Sanders, witness for plaintiff, TT. 157-64.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Conclusion No. 1. The Great Salt Lake was sus-

ceptible of being used for commercial navigation on

January 4, 1896, the date at which Utah obtained state-

hood; and was therefore a navigable body of water,

and the State of Utah on that date received title to the

bed of the Great Salt Lake.

52

Reference: Findings of Fact and Summary of Evi-

dence, and cases cited in Memorandum.

{ unciaseun ovu. 2. Lssues of law raised by the plain-

tiff relating to equitable estoppel against the United

States and compromise and settlement between Utah

and the United States should be reserved for subse-

quent determination, if any such determination becomes

necessary. Likewise, all issues relating to the exact!

boundary of the bed of the Great) Salt’ Lake as of

January 4, 1896, as well as the ownership of lakebed

lands now uncovered by the receding waters of the

lake since said date of statehood, should be reserved

for subsequent determination,

Reference: Memorandum, including footnote No.

1 at page 3.

V. CONCLUSION

The Great Salt Lake, world famed for its resorts

and for the buoyancy of its waters, and one of the

largest lakes in the Western Hemisphere not inter-

connected to an ocean, is challenged in this proceeding

as to its navigability. The question is whether on Janu-

ary 4, 1896, the date of Utah’s admission into the union,

the lake was physically susceptible of commercial navi-

gation. The uncontroverted evidence shows that the

lake was not only susceptible of commercial navigation

at that date, but was actually used for commercial navi-

gation at, before, and after the date of statehood, and

is being so used at the present time. As an example,

from 1957 until 1959, when the lake was about 5 feet

33

lower (or shallower) than it was at the date of state-

hood, the lake supported some of the world’s largest

barges (cach capable of carrying the equivalent tonnage

of 90 railroad cars) as part of a marine fleet that con-

structed the Southern Pacific Company's causeway

across the lake, a $49,000,000.00 job which at that time

was considered to be one of the great engineering feats

in history. ‘The barges were so large that they could

not have navigated when fully loaded on the Mississippi

River, but they navigated without difficulty on the

Great Salt Lake, day and night, winter and summer,

during the two year construction period. The Great

Salt Lake was not only navigable, but was unusually

economic to navigate, because of greater buoyancy of

the water, the absence of ice, and the ease with which

harbor facilities could be constructed and maintained.

The Court should adopt the proposed Conclusions

of Law, as fully supported by the proposed Findings

of Fact.

Respectfully submitted,

VERNON BL ROMNEY

Utah Aitorney General

ROBERT B. HANSEN

Deputy Utah Attorney General

7

August 1, 1969

54

DALLIN W. JENSEN

Assistant Attorney Genera!

RICHARD L. DEWSNEP

Special Ascistant Attorney General

CLIFFORD L. ASITTON

Speeial Assistant Attorney General

EDWARD W. CLYDE

Special Assistant Attorney General

Counsel for Plaintiff

236 State Capitol Building

Salt Lake City, Utah 84114

55

CERTIFICATE OF Se&RVICE

I, Vernon B. Romney, Attorney General of, and

counsel for, the State of Utah, and a member of the

Bar of this Court, do hereby certify that copies of the

foregoing brief of the State of Utah were served upon

the Solicitor General of the United States of America,

Department of Justice, Washington, D.C.. 205230;

by mailing the same, air mail postage prepaid, this 30th

day of July, 1969, all in accordance with the Rules of

this Court.

VERNON B. ROMNEY

Utah Attorney General

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.