Jurisdictional Statement — United States v. City of Chicago

Supreme Court brief1970

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

peas: a e . - stom eeReten ken ort ft D> wear: ee .n- 1

3 .

° 2 =

. ‘ P p

a the Saye Court of te Gaited sits

OcToBER TERM, 1970

_ No.

Unrrep States oF AMERICA AND INTERSTATE ~

COMMERCE COMMISSION, APPELLANTS

We “

aS City oF CHICAGO, ET AL.

+ “i ™ :

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT -COURT FOR

“ THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF Lt ¥Ors

Ne. ee semua STATEMENT

OrrNTOn®, =EAw LY

The ordér of the district court (App. A, infra: pp.

11-16) is not yet reported, The teport of the Inter-

state Commerce Commission (App. C, be ha pp. aia!

_.is published at 331 I.C. C. 447.

JURISDICTION ve?

the par parle of thé three-judge court (App. A

infra) was entered’ on’ March 19, 1970. Notices of ap- |

peal (App. B, infra)ewere filed by the Interstate-Com-

merce Conimission -and: he United States on May 14,

- 1970, and May 18, 1970, respectively. The jurisdiction

‘of this Court is conferred by. 28 U.S.C. 1253. City of

Chicago v. United States, 396 U. S. 162. |

(1)

.

398-034 O-—-70——-1

‘

| a

_ QUESTION ‘PRESENTED

Whether Section 13a(1) of the lattes Gia:

merce A requires | a railroad seeking to discoritinue -

its segment of a through passenger train\operated i in

-eonjunction with another railroad) to give notice of the

" proposed discontinuance’ in stapes served only wy, ‘the

other railroad: Ne,

‘ STATUTE INVOLVED a as

in,

Section 13a(1) of the Interstate pains Aet (49 .

Pe iy 0) 13a(1)) provides: ae hoes : 3

A carrier or -¢arriers. siibject: to this part, if.

“their Tights with respect to the discontinuance —

Sas change, in whole or in part, of the operation| ?

or service. of any train or ferry operating from.

-a point in one State to a point in any other ‘ ~

State or in the District of Columbia, or froma

point in the District of Columbia to a point in

any ‘State, are subject to any provision of. the

constitution or statutes of any State or any

regulation or order of -(or are the subject of -

- any proceeding pénding before) any court or

' an administrative or regulatory agency of any .

State, may,-but shall not be required to,. file

_ with the Commission, and ®pon such filing shall

. ,mail to: the Governor of each State -in whjch :

such train’ or ferry “is operated, and post in

every ‘station, depot or other “facility served .

~ thereby, notice at least thirty days in advance

. of any such proposed discontinuance or change.

: . The earrier or carriers filing such notice may

; a discontinue ér change any such operation or

~~ service pursuant to suclfnotice except as other- |

- “wise ordered hy the Commission pursuant to

this paragraph, the laws or constitution ‘9 any

: State, or the decision or. onger of, or thy/ pend

ency ‘of any prosséding’ before, any: are or.

_. State authority to the contrary notwithstand-

_ ing. ‘Upon the filing of such notice the Com-

mission: shall have authority during said thirty *

days’ notice period, either upon complaint . or

upon its own initiative without complaint, to ~

~ enter upon an investigation of the proposed dis- .

continuance or change. Upon the institution of

- such investigation, the Commission,. by. order

‘served. upon the carrier or carriers affected

thereby at least ten days prior to the day on »

which such discontinuance or change “would.

otherwise’ become effective, may require such

train- or ferry to bé continued in operation or

“service, in. whole-or in part, pending hearing

and decision in such investigation, but not fora _

‘longer period than four months ° ‘beyond the

date when such discontinuance or change would

otherwise have become effective. If, after hear-

fore or after such diseontinuance or change has

- hecome effective, the . ape finds that.the

operation or service of Such train or ferry is re-

quired by public convenience and nécessity and

‘ will not unduly burden interstate or foreign’

‘ecommerce, the Commission may by order re-

“quire the continuance or. restoration of opera-.

tion or service of such train or ferry, in whole ,

or in part, for a period not to exceed one year

from the date of such order. The provisions of

this. paragraph ‘shall not supersede the laws of

any State or the orders or regulations’ of: any

administrative or regulatory body of any State . -

applicable to such discontinuance or change un-

Jess notice as in this paragraph provided is filed

with the Commission. On the expiration of an.

of ‘

r

,

°

_ ing in such investigation, whether concluded he-@

?

—."

’

ee a ee GAT AAP I Me SG OP GIANT 88 x v

Pee oe

‘ ‘ $ ee ee ;

a 4, /

. A ‘ P a

° * ? ‘ ig

4°.

order by the Commission after such investiga-

tion requiring the continuance or restoration of

operation or servict, the jurisdiction of an

State as to such -discontinuance or change shall.

no longer be supers@ied unless the procediire

. provided by this paragraph shall agein be in- j

voked om the carrier or carriers.

< STATEMENT ‘.

On “August 31, 1967, the Chicago & Resi Illingis

Railroad Co. (C&EI) filed a notice under Se¢tion 13a _

(1) of the Interstate ‘Commerce Act (49 U.S.C, 13a.

)) proposing to dise ontinue a pair. of trains,“knowri

as the ‘Georgian,”’ operated by it between Chicago,

Illinois and Evansville, Indiana. These trains operated ; -

in conjunction with trains of. the Lonisville & Nash- ©

‘ville Railroad (L&N), which ran between Evansville

anid Atlanta, Georgia. A passenger could thus ride be-

- tween. Chicago and Atlanta, over two railroads, with-

out’ changing cars.’

On January 25, i968, after. ‘heels the Commis-

‘sion authorized C&EI to diseontinue the trains, find-

ing that continued operation was not required by pub-

‘lie convenierice and necessity, and wotld wnduly bur- .

_ den. interstate commerce.” Chicago & Eastern Illinois

Railroad Co. —Discontinuarice of Trains,” etc., 381

L.C.C, 447 (App..C infra). The C&ET trains stopped,

running on February 2, 1968, and have not operated

since. |

1 C&EI and L&N also operated*in the same manner’ between —

. Chicago and Montgomery, Alabama, However, no issue was

raised below as to on operation.

A suit seeking review of the Commission order was

filed in the court below’ in May 1968. That court dis-

‘missed the action. in‘ Jamiary 1969, holding that the

Commission deci ‘ision was not reviewable. City of Chi-

cago vV. United”, States, 294 F: Supp.:. 1103. That deci-

sion was subsequently reversed by this Court, which

remanded the case to the — below. City of. Chicago —

v. United States, 396. U.S. 162. ee

The plaintiffs below then renewed -an earlier biotion

. (previously briefed and argued) seeking reversal on |

the ground that-C&EI had not.properly: given notice

. in accordance with Section 13a(1). Speeifically, they

contended that C&EI was required to post notices at

various points served by the connecting L&N trains,

and to mail notices to the governors. of states: served :

by the L&N trains. On February 5, 1970, the lower

court entered an order summarily remanding the éase

- to the Interstate Commerce Commission. On March 19,

1970, after various motions, the court vacated its or

order and entered a new judgment remanding the he

ter to the agency for further proceedings’ (App. A,

infra). This order was accompanied by a brief opinion

whieh stated, without explanation, ‘that “the: public

did not receive adequate notice from the railroads or

the I:C.C, proceedings ;,* * *”’ (App. A, infra, p. 15).

- In addition, the court-held that the residents and Gov-

ernors of Kentucky, Tennessee, and Georgia should -

have been given notice of the Commission proceedings .

(ibid. ).

a

6 ee

The merits of the Commission’s decision’ authorizing —

discontinuance. were not 4 eview red and are not in issue

here? Sf : |

‘ THE ‘QUESTION Is sunsTANTIAL

"The decision below, requiring that a railrogd give

- hotice of proposed discontinuance in areas served not

by it, but by connecting roads, has: “ifportant paet

‘on the administration of Sect ion 13a(1). The aan |

sion has always read the ‘notice requirements of this

statute as ‘applying only tothe stations and states

ts actually served by the road seeking discontinuance. ‘Al-

thotigh settled administrative interpretation, is a con- °

sideration entled to great weight on review, see, ¢.9.,-

Udall vy. Tallman, 380 U.S. 1, the court below failed

even to take cognizance of it.Many, prior cases, proc-

essed under this administrative interpretation, cod

.bow. be open to challenge under’the court’s reading, .

_ there being. no time limitation (other than the uncertain »

doctrine 6f laches} applicable to review of Commission

orders.’ In addition, numerous through passenger trains

2In the same order, the court also remanded to the Commis-

“sion the matter of its separate authorization for discontinuance of

another related L&N train, on the ground that that discontinuance

could not properly be considered apart from the instant ease.-We .

have ‘separately appealed from that remand (there being a separate .

case in the district court) and are filing a Jurisdictional Statement

_ with respect thereto contemporaneously herewith (United States,

et al. v.-Tennessee Public Service Commission, et al.).

*It can -be argued that the lower court’s notice theory, if

valid, exposes a jurisdictional defect int

Section 13a(1), the Commission acquires power over the/trains, ~

thus supplanting state regulatory authorities, only “upon the. =

filing of such notice”.

“2

— 4 s dr a Ae LT PRGA DOD Ge

* are. presently operated by twi or more railfoads on a -

_ cooperating basis.‘ The proper handling of any case |

"involving such trains, when one of. the participating :

roads seeks to-discontinue-only its segnient, is rendered ~ ,

,uncfrtain by the result below. Definitive inte pretation,

_ ofthe statute’s notice roquitements by this Court would

Harify the matter, “" -™ .- ; ee

/Z In our view the decision below is ‘erroneots oe

. the. statute. The . mechanism~of Section 13a(1). i

triggered by a “carrier or carriers * * * if fiir rile

rights with respect to the dise ofitinuance * * * [of an:

interstate train] -are subject to * * *” state sagt:

tion. To seek. Commission relief, the carrier must give

notice “to the Governor of each State in which. such

train * * *«is operated,” ahd post notices at various

points ‘‘served” by the train. -." te

Here the C&EI operated only between Chicago and

Evansville. To hold that C@EI must ‘post notices in

‘Kentucky, Tennessee, and Georgia i is incoysistent with

the statute’s language and purpose. C&EDs ‘“‘rights”

‘These inélude .operations bet ween ‘ork and Montreal ———

ae Penn Central and Delaware and adaoks between Boston,

New York and New Orleans via Penn Ce@tral and Southern:

several daily trains between the Northeast and. Florida points

via Penn Central and Seaboard Coast Line; trains between,

Chicago and Florida via “Illinois Central, Central of Georgia

and Seaboird, and ‘via Penn Central,. L&N and. Seaboard:

trains between Louisville, New Orleans and Florida points via.

L&N and Seaboard; trains. between Chicago and California:

“points via Milwaykee, Union Pacific und ‘in some _instanéces,— ——~—

- Southern Pacific; and the current version of the former “Cali-

fornia Zephyr” operating. between Chicago and Sap Francisco

via Burlington, Denver & Rio Grande Western, an \ Southern

Pacific,

|

|

eo :

. : i : : a ‘: : S ° - - -

P a . Me é ;

* -_ Saar EPO Fy 9 ‘ . eer; o~ J ; :

I LP LALLA LOGE BF ’ ‘

— . * c d

c 2 ? - - “5 \.

: : i + \

s 2 : |

- a . ° . ;

s<~g

. ‘ . * . . : ; < ‘ iy

.

. 4

*

- were in no way “subject to”? regulation by those states

No train was “oper ated’ by C&EL i in those states; no ~

C&EI train “served” those states.’ * 3 ,

The. decision below might be ai ‘guably nae “i

Section 13a had’ been intended ‘to’ assist states and *

localities seeking to preserve. long-haul passenger

‘ service. But. the statute was designed to aid railroads

in cireurnventing unresponsive, state’ regulator y com- |

missions. Southern R: Co. v. North Carolina, 376 U.S

93; Cityof - Chicageny. United, States, 396 U.S. 162.

As expressed in the House Committee Report, ‘** * *

- it is- proposed to add a new. Sectton 13a_to the : act,

whereby the railroads, at their option, may have the In- 2

. terstate Commetce Commission, rather than State Com-

missions, pass upon the discontinuance ‘oP change: in

.the operation of. service of any, train or ferry? ’ House

Report No. 1922, 85th Cong... 2d Sess., p. 12 (1958).

Respect. for the statutory scheme suggésts. that the -

Commission: would replace state commissions - only” to

- the extent that they could have defeated a carrier’s

attempt to discontinue-a train: Hence there. should -:

be no requirement as to notice in states which had no

regulatory power over the earrier.

*For other purposes, a carrier is not normally regarded as

“serving” points where it does not physically operate. Se

Texas & Pacific Ry. Co. v. Gulf, C. & S8.F. Ry. Co., 270 Us

266; Btate of Georgia v: United States, 156 F. Supp. fat (N.D

iE," afd per curiam, 356 U.S: 273; £'hicago & Eastern Ii-

nois R. Co. v. IMlinois Central R. Co., 261 F. Supp. 289 (N.D.

-TiL.)¥ nag Fie Pie} Disre.

>

* ¢

©. For Nice foregoing .reasoys,

» Should -be noted. , ae

Respectfully submitted. 2

ERwin N. Cikisworn, ide ee

“¢. Rote men Ric HARD W. McLaren, y

Spee . | Assistant Attorney General.

- GREGORY

Rosert W. GINNANE, ~_

General Counsel,

JEROME NELSON,

B. HoveNDon,: | .

RoBERT ‘B. NiCHOLSON,

Attorneys.

Ce

Attorney, ee

7 Interstate € ‘ommere cf Commission: ~~

JULY 1970., oye Ser

?s >} : eer ° fi :

- 2 f ee. 4 :

, : ns ats Ne

, - ae

‘ . ; —— so 2

cee ™ 4

v. ‘ a ee

. 898-034 O—70-—2

"7 CONCLUSION

o Ny tai ss ae

‘probable, jurisdiction

- Solicitor G eneval.

2 = 2 — * poe *, Sted, po

“ Oe Ps DOE Potent 5% eke a8 Mitel LEIS Ls

2 tuiodc 5

. oF id = ’

.g, “APPENDIX. A Des

United States District: ‘Goart for the Northern

_ Migteict. of Illinois a Division: are if

No. 68 C 956 se ead

a Crry or Curtcaco, ET AL., PLAINTIFES:

TA? 3s ope eas fils ae

UNITED lens OF -Aneeerca, Er AL., DEFENBANTS ~

No. 68 C 1666,

‘Pex wesse Pusiic SERVICE- Commission, Er P\ Aare

, "PLAINTIFFS Be

‘9g : : 2 , Vv. , /

“

Unité States OF Aarenica, ET AL., DEFENDANTS,

| >

, :

Mi Ctr ner ce

: Petiakine the filing of a copy of the raginaaks of |

the Supreme Court of the United’ States herein with

the Clerk of the Distriet Court, this three-judge court

on, February 5, 1970,. entered an order wherein it

a i remanded both: causes numbered 68 C 956 and

68 C. 1666 to the Interstate’ Commerce Commission *

| §

(“I.C.C.”’). for further proceedings and (2) held

undér advisement the motion made by ‘plaintiffs and: }

. intervening plaintiffs to. reinstate the temporary re- :

he

straining order in case 68 C 1666 until the conclusion

of the proceedings before the I.C.C. .

Thereafter the various. parties filed various n mo- °

tions ‘and. the,three-judge court now has before it (1).

' * motion. of defendant Chicago & Eastern ‘Hlinois: ‘Rail-

r: A 11) |

road Company. (8O&ED), for reheari ine or. ajnend:%

mént of: said order of February 5, 1970; (2) motion of

‘defendant Louisville and Nashville Railroad. Com-

“pany (“L&N’’) for rehearing and amendment of said

“orden, (3) motion of: defendants United States “of

“America and,I.C.C. for. a riewe tr ial in both cases witli

menarigju in: - support. thereof; (4) - motion | of".

< plainti eee

tion ,and amendment of said February 5 order with —— g -

and’ intervening plaintiffs for reeonsidera~

‘iemorandum in support thereof; (5) response of

plaintiffs: and intervening plaintiffs to the aforesaid: Ee

motions ‘of defendants; . (6) resporise of defendant;

a -C&EI to plaintiffs’ and intervening plaintiffs’ mno-

ef tion; and. (7), response of: defengant L&N to plain-

of the opinion that it should reconsider its x of

tiffs’ amd intervening plaintiffs’ motion:

~The Court has. considered ‘all the for egoing motions; a 3

the. responses ‘and memoranda ‘of the pirties- clay

and the. opinion of the Supreme | Court herein -an

February 5, 1970 and should modify and amend said

-. order as hereinafter set forth in view of the addi-

‘tional ‘facts and law pr resented tothe Court. abet

It is, therefore, ORDERED, that thé: order of this

Court entered ‘herein on Febr “ary, 1970 he and the

same is hereby. yacated. wh

The Court also has before it a aeition by plain-

tiffs’ to consolidate ‘cause No. 68 ©: 1666’ with cause

No. 68 C 956 on the. ground that the’ two actions ams

volye a common question, éf law and fact. Said“mo- ~

tion was filed September. 6,” 1968, br iefed and argued: ~

re before the. ‘three-judge court on” ovember 4,.1968:° |

The Court reserved ‘its ruling on same. The Supreme

_ Court of the United States/ consolidated these cases _

- for hearing ond it is the opinion of this Court that -

“the plaintiffs’ Motion, to consblidate should now be _

ene

| PS

-¢

in aa

>. bm,

CUh : e.

ay

| 1

7. is, Mievstane, ntl ahiat « cause No. 68 On

= in: the hest interest of the general public to maintain

_ “the status quo ‘which: existed on ‘September 6; 1968

until further .détermination of thesé causes, as” was

"OF iginally done ‘by entry. of a restraining order i In case’... °

No, 68 C'1666 by Judge Edwin: A. Robson on that —

- date, immediately after the filing ‘of ‘this suit, and —

: which restraihing order against discontinuance: of the’

%

Xo

\

956 and | cause No. 68. C: 1666 ‘be: _ they. are hereby “

3 lidated, a ; :

meee a oak cof the % opinion: that. it is ‘equitable and mre

“Hummingbird” trains. by the L&N was continued in :

: ~~ full force and effect on September’ 12, 1968 by J udge

Joseph Sam Perry. The temporary restraining order’

-was heretofore dissolved by the Court, in its order of: *.

January 8, 1969 eee the motion ‘of seid to

“disthiss. ~ ce a:

3 Plaifitiffs and heasroediiie plaintiffs allege. in their -

‘memorandum, filed. February 16, 1970, that the L&N -

/ premised -‘restoration: of the train-service to. thre Cir-|

cuit J ustice”’ and that allegation has not been denied.

_ The Court: finds that L&N, in. its Memorandum in

ge opposition to applicagion ty stay, represented to. the’

: i cies: Justice on. January 10, 1969 the following:

6

site ‘their statutory appeal to this Court, and if

_ this Court should determine, upon ;full- con-

_ sideration, that the question of the operation of

ote ; ‘the trains should be examined hy the Court —

‘below, the respondent railroad company ‘will be |

. petitioners ab have full. right to’ pur- |

fully ‘answerable. In other words, the-respond- °

ent railroad company will promptly resume the

». , operation of the trains if ¥equired to do so by .

- lawful order.” (L&N Memorandum in‘Opposi- -~ -°

‘tion to esog ee to. odd p. oy

” sec:

Peeper irea | 14

“The L&N also submitted to this three-judge court at

the September 12, 1968 hearing an affidavit stating:

Trains Nos. 6 and 7 can be put back in op-

tion within a matter of less than twenty-four

hours upon the dissolution of the court’s order,

, since ‘none’ of the equipment that is used in

operating these trains will now be disposed of,

and it will be kept _in Operating condition.”

4 (Affidavit of Jack Small, 9/10/68, pp. 1-2)

Defendants United States of America and LC.C,

have not interposed any objection to the motion of

plaintiffs and intervening plaintiffs for reinstatement

of the aforesaid restraining order against the LEN.-

. The Court finds that in a recent (December 3,

1969) decision of the 1.C.C., 336 L.C.C. at 85, the

Commission states:

Tn Missouri Pac. R. Co. ee ee - °

_« & EIR. Co., 327 LCC. 279 (1965), sustained

sub nom. Illinois Central Railroad Company is

v. United States, 263 F. Supp, 421, affirmed per

' curiam 385 U.S. 457 (1967), ‘C&ET’s Chicago-

Evansville line was awarded to L&N rather

than Illinois Central one of the important con-

siderations in the Commission’s determination

being the anticipated maintenance and improve-

ment of through passenger service between Chi-

- cago and the South via the C4&EI and L&N

route ...’’ (Emphasis supplied) ~| *

The Illinois Central Railroad continues t6 run

trains to and from the South and so. should the

LEN continue to operate the “‘Huinmingbird”’ trains °

pending final determination herein. :

“The Court finds that the LC.C. is without juris

diction to order interim relief-beyond a four month.

period in connection with ‘the ‘‘Hummingbird” trains ©

- pending the Commission’s further proceedings herein-

The Court itself does have jurisdiction to reinstate

d

-

operation of the “Hummingbird” trains pending the:

‘* Conimission’s further proceedings herein.) |

- It: is, therefore, ORDERED that the restraining

order entered herein on September 6, 1968, and con- .

tinued September 12, 1968, be and the same is hereby

’ reinstated to become ‘effective within ten (10) mh of

the date of this order.

The three-judge court also is of the soiiaie. “ao \

' the L.C.C. should. also reopen its investigations in

the matter of the “Georgian trains (Chicago-Evans-

ville) involved in. case No. 68 C 956,.with due and

proper notice to all parties in intérest; and that the

matters involved in eases 68 C 956 and 68 C 1666 ~

‘should be. consolidated by the LCC, in further

proceedings.

The Conrt finds that in the proceedings beféires the

LC, relating to the discontinuance of the. C&EI’s

“Georgian” trains the public did not receive adequate

otice from the railroads or of the L. C.C. proceedings ;

and, further, although the residents of the States of

Kentucky, ‘Tennessee and Georgia were vitally inter-

ested in continued thyough’ pdssengex-service by the

- railroads and the respective governors of those States

‘ were entitled to notice of the proceedings before the

I.C.C., no notice was given them beforehand. ee

The Court is of the view-that through passenger

service from Chicago to and throughout the South-

eastern part Wr the United States might or could be

‘vital to the general public interest and that such sery-

ice is so interwoventand entwined between the various

railroads that only in a consolidated proceeding can a

- just and fair decision be reached.

It is, therefore, ORDERED. that the orders of the

LC.C. in its Finance Docket Nos. 24725 and 25047, in

so far as such orders discontinue the respeetive investi-

gations, be and they hereby are vacated and that both

|

4

causes numbered 68 C 956 sat 68 C 1666 be and they

“hereby are remanded to the I.C.C. and. consolidated

for further proceedings in accordance with the statutes

so made and provided. oe

‘The Courf. enters the above orders in conformity’

with the opinion of the Supreme Court of the United.

States and: for the purpose of carrying out the Su- -

preme Court’s mandate. -

(S) Wis G. Knocn,

Circuit J udge.

(S) J. Sam Perry, °

District Judge.

(S) /Epwin A. Rosson,

District J udge.

Dated Chie ‘ago, Illinois, March 19, 1970. 3

ks aiciaceaead B

a

In the q nited States District Court toy the Northern

‘District of Illinois Eastern Division |

* Civil Action No. 68 C 956 ~ —

Crry. or CHICAGO, ET AL., PLAINTIFFS

’ v- | ’

Unrrei? Staves or AMERICA AND ENTERSTATE CoM MERCE

COMMISSION, DEFENDANTS:

,

‘NOTICE OF APPEAL_TO THE SUPREME ¢ COURT OF. THE UNITED

STATES BY THE UNITED STATES OF | AMERIC ‘A

z

Notice is hereby given that the United States of

America,‘a defendant herein, appeals to the Supreme

— Court of the United States from the- judgment entered

March 19, 1970, setting aside orders of the Interstate.

Conimerce Commission entered in Finance Doc ket —

No, ‘24725. =

~ - I

In accordance with the provisions of Rule 12 of the

Rujes of the Supreme Court of the United States, the |

Clerk of this Conrt is hereby requested to certify

the entire record in this cause and provide for its

(17) -

298-074 O—J0——-3

18

transmission to the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the

United States! . ‘oe

Rich®rp W. McLaren, os

Assistant Attorney General,

Joun H..D. Wiccer, |

_- - Attorney,

Department of Justice, ©

Washington, D.C. 20530—

| THomas A. Foran,

i fe United States Attorney, “

’ Chicago, [llinois 60604

ag Attorne ys for the United States of América,

‘6

PROOF OF SE RVICE

T, John H, D. Wigger, one of the attorneys for de-

fendant United. States of. America, appellant herein,

4nd .a member of grant of the Supreme Court of the

United States, hereby certify that on the 15th day ef

May, 1970, I served copies of the foregoing Notice of

Appeal on the several parties to this action ‘as 1 follows:.—

1. On the plaintiffs herein, by mailing copies in duly

— addressed envelopes, to attorneys of rec ord as follows:

With air mail. postage prepaid to Wendell

W. Wright, Esq. and Marion E. Wright, Esq,

106 North Vermilion Street, Danville, Illinois

61832; William E. Nelson,, Esq. .. Dyer Building,

Hoopeston, Illinois 60942; Robert P. Doolittle,

Jr.; Esq., 801 Busseron. Street, Vincennes, In-

3 . diana 47591; Eugene W. Ward, Esq., Cordell

j Hull Building, rigs ea Tennessee 37219;

Richard L. Curry, and Bernard Rane,

; Esq.,, 511 .City Hall, " Ghicaco, Illinois 60602;

Neill S. Brown, Esq. and Robert E. Kendrick,

. Esq., 204 Metropolitan Courthouse Building,

. Nashville, Tennessee; George B. Tofaute, Esq.,

‘17 Harding Avenue,’ Terre Haute, Indiana

io: ies tee a,

47801:.and Keith E.. Roberts, Esq., 120/South

LaSalle Street, Chicago, Illinois 60603. —.

2. On the intervening plaintiffs by mailing copies.

in duly addressed envelopes to their attorneys of rec-

ord as follows: Fogg’ (Sit

With air mail postage prepaid te William F.

Black, State Office Buikding, Monteomery; Ala-

bama 36402; Anthony Haswell, sq, 2517 N.

Burling, Chicago, Hlinois 60614; Weldon A.

Cousins, Esq., 737 National Bank of Com-

meree, New Orleans, Houisiana T0112; Chester.

L. Rigsby, Msq., Kentucky Railroad Commis-

sion, State Office Building, Frankfort, Ke*

tucky 40601; Robert S. Matthews, Esq., 1018" .

_

Southern Securities Building, Evansville, Indi-

ana 47708; and Bennett E. Smith, Esq., Assistant

Attorney General, State of Mississippi, State Of-.

fice Building, Jackson, Mississippi 39201; Leon

. M. Despres, Esq., 77 W. Washington, Chicago, .

[inois 60602; Henry C. Neel,” Esq., Foran

Credit Building, Henderson, Kentucky 42420;

Sheldon. A.—Taft, Ksq., 111 N. ‘High Street,

‘olumbus, Ohio 43215; J. Robert. Coleman,

Esq. 132 State Judicial Building, Atlanta, .

Georgia 30334; and Carl 1. VanDorn, Esq., 807 .

State Office Building, Indianapolis, Indiana

46204. Fue Seige St

With first-class mail postage prepaid ‘to’ Gor-

don P. MacDougall, Esq., 705 Ring Building,

Washington, D.C. 20036 and William B. Ma-

honey, Esq., 620° Tower Building, Washington,

- D.C, 20005. oni |

‘3. On the intervening defendant by mailing copies in

duly addressed envelopes/to his attorneys of record as

follows: : :

a=

Jenner, Jr., Esq. and Keith F. Bode, Esq., 135

South LaSalle Street, Chicago, Illinois 60603;

With air mail postage prepaid to Albert E.

and Harry R: ‘Begley, Esq., 72 West Adams —

- Street, Chicago, Illinois 60603.

gee

$$

7: |

4. sti defendant to ae Ribu Duitiiheatons >

by mailing copies with first-class. postage prepaid to

Robert W. Ginnane, General Counsel, and- Jerome

Nelson, Attorney, Interstate Commerce Commission,

ees D.C.°20423. .

JOHN H. D. WIcGER,

Attorney, ~

- Department of Justice,

oo ag DC. (205 30.

’ [Filed, May 18, 1970] “

.

4 .

. aS »

ay Ed Sb alt at heovthd Oa OE OE OF Bs EES

-* *

In the United States District Court for the Northen

District. of Illinois Eastern Division |

. Civil Action No. 68 C956

[| Orry or CHICAGO, ET. AL., PLAINTIFFS

} _ ee

; H 7" ¥ ; ; < oe

“Unirpp States oF AMERICA AND INTERSTATE Com-

" MERCE COMMISSION, DEFENDANTS ©

o . .

NOTICE OF APPEAL TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE

UNITED “STATES BY THE INTERSTATE COMMERCE COM-

MISSION ox . | re

ise y

Commission, a- defendant: herein, . appeals to the Su-_

preme Court of the United States from the judgment

. entered March 19, 1970,-setting aside orders of the

- Interstate Commerce Commission entered in Finance

Docket No. 24725. . * Ana ate

Fl eT Grn ee | :

In accordance with the provisions of Rule 12 ofthe

Rules of the Supreme Court of the United States, the

‘Clerk of. this Court is hereby requested to certify the .

_ entire record in this cause, and provide for its trans- -

mission to the Clerk ‘of the Supreme Court of the

‘United States. “bias bs Peo |

| Rospert W.- GINNANE, |

"tas i General Counsel,

_ JEROME NELSON, ui

eee a tales, a) Attorney,

_., Interstate Commerce Commission, . °'

- Washington, D.C. 20423.

(21) :

“- : ie, .

Nice is hereby given that the Interstate Commerce ..

REO oe —

. * aH.

~ 22

PROOF OF SE RV ICE

| Tue ome : Maun: one of ithe attorneys for defend-

ant. Interstate Cotamerce Commission, appellant here- .

in, and a member of the Bar of the Supreme Court |

.. of the United States, hereby certify that on the’ 12th

day of May, 1970, I served copies of the foregoing |

Notice of appeal on the several parties to this action

eas follows: “

1. On the’ plaintiffs herein, . ve readline copies ‘in

duly addressed envelopes, to attorneys of record as

- follows: / be °

Ww ith air nhail. lisa eT to Ww Vendall

V. Wright, Esq. and Marion EK. Wright, Esq.,

106 North Vermilion Street, Danville, Illinois

/ 61832; William FE. Nelson, Esq., Dver Building,

©.

+

Hoopeston, Illinois 60942; Robert P. Doolittle, — .

Jr., Esq., 801, Busseron Street, Vincenhes,

Indiana 47591; Eugene W. Ward, Esq. ., Cordell

Hull Building, Nashville, Tennessee 37219;

- Richard 1. Curry, Esq. and. Bernard Rane,

’ Esq., 511 City Hall, Chicago, Mlingis 60602 :

- Neill S. Brown, Esq. and Robert E. Kendrick,

Esq., 204. Metropolitan. Courthouse Building,

‘Nashville, Tennessee; George B: Tofaute, Esq.,

17 Harding Avenue, Terre Haute, Indiana

47801; and Keith KE. Roberts, Ksq.,- 120 South °

LaSalle Street, Chicaga, I llinois 60603.

2. On the intervening plaintiffs by mniling ‘copies

in duly addressed envelopes to their attorneys of

record as follows:

_.. With air mail postage. pr ‘epiaid to William F |

fe Black, State Office Building, Montgomery, Ala- —

_ bama 36102; Anthony Haswell, Esq., 2517 N.

- Burling, Chicago, Tllinois 60614; Weldon A.

_ Cousins, Esq., 737 National Bank of Commerce,

_ New Orleans, ‘Louisiana 70112; Chester « L.

Rigsby, Esq., Kentucky Railroad Commission,

State Office Building, Frankfort; Kentucky

40601 ; Robert. S. Matthews, sss @ 1018 South-

oki

BLE RIOD BELT Or 8 FE o

2 tt 4

ern Securities Building, ‘Evansville, Indiana. .

ry» 47708; and Bennett, E. Smith, Esq.,’ Assistant

Attorney» General, State of Mississippi, ‘State

Office Building, Jackson, . Mississippi 39201;

_ Leon M:. Despres, Esq., 77 W. Washitigton, Chie’ |

cago, Illinois 60602 ; : Henry ©. Neel; Esq. Foran

Credit Building, Henderson, Kentucky 42420 ;

Sheldon A..Taft, Esq., 111 N. High Bincet, Co-.. |

_« _lumbus, Ohio 43215; J. Robert Coleman, Esq.,

:* £32 State Judicial Building, Atlanta, Georgia

30334; and Carl EF. VanDorn, Esq., 807. State

Office. Building; Indianapolis; ‘Indiana 46204.

- With fifst class mail postage prepaid-to-Gor-

don P. MacDougall, Esq., 705 Ring Building, -

a0 Washington, D.C. 20036 and William B. Ma-

honey, Esq., 620 Tower pene N AeIngtOn, | ue

D.C. 20005.

em) On the intervening defendant by ae copies |

in duly addressed oe to his attorneys of record

as follows: ~ F

With air toatl vaselbaie ES to ‘Albert E.

- Jenner; Jr., Esq. and Keith F. Bode,. Esq., 135

- South LaSalle Street, Chicago, Tilinois 60603;

and. Harry” R. Begley, Esq., 42 West Adams

Street, Chicago, Tllinois 60603. -

4, On defendant United States of America bysniadl: ie

- ing cdpies with first-class postage prepaid to the Hon-

orable Erwin N. Griswold, Solicitor General’ of the

United States, Departinent/ of Justice, Washington, -

D.C. 20530; to the Honorable Thomas A. Foran,

United States ‘Attorney, Chicago, Illinois 60604; to-

the Honorable Richard W. McLaren, Assistant “At-

torney General of the United States and the Honor-

able John H. D. Wigger, Attorney, tiaamempee of

Justice, bihcwsss cand D.C. 20530.

2 JEROME NELSON,

oaike: Attorney,-

Interstate ‘Commerce Commission.

- (Filed, — 14, 1970)

.

4, od

oye?

.

(24

APPENDIX C:

aaa Served Me mr 31, 1968

F-04490, ee se ae

~ INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION.

: FINANCE Docket No. 4725

is CHICAGO & EASTERN ILLINOIS RAILROAD CO. _DISCONTINU-

ANCE OF TRAINS NOS. 93 AND 54 BETWEEN CHICAGO, ILL.,

AND: EVANSVILLE, IND. \

Q< o:®

' Decided January 26, 1968. :

”

, &

Upon investigation, found that ‘operation ‘by the Chitago & Eastern Illi-

nois- Railroad Company of passenger trains Nos. 93 and 54 between >

Chi ,IIL., and Evansville, Ind., is not required by plblic conveni-

“ence. a necessity, and that the continued operation thereof will un-

‘ duly burden interstate commerce. Investigation discontinued.

oe

Nee James H. Durkin‘and Edwin’ Richardson for rail carrier.

di. Fred Parker for Googgis Public Service Commission, protes-

’ tant.

William H- Wilson. for Public Service Commission of indiana,

protestant. pnts

Mary Louise. Wolford for the, public of the State of Indiana, pro-

testant.

_ Edward G. Finnegan, Leon J, Heidgen and James A. Parker for

Illinois Commerce Commission, protestant.

Harold Cowenand Bernard Rane for city of Chicago, Ill.,. protes- .

tant.

” Robert S. Matthews and Ronald Worrum for city ” Evansville,

Ind., protestant.

KeithE. Roberts for village of Milford, Hl., and city of Watseka,

protestants.

. « William E. Nelson for city of Hoopeston, Iil., protestant.

- * Marion E.Wright for city of Danville, IIl., protestant. -

Robert F. Doolittle, Jr. for city of Vincennes, Ind., protestant.

_ Frederick T. Bauer for gity of Terre Haute, Ind:, protestant.

Raymond J. Kearns for Sisters of Providence, St.. Mary of the © |

Woods, Ind., protestant.

William P. Byroad,. Gordon E. Coz, B. ‘ Diiiiiiek, Thomas J.

, Duggan, George B. Lee, J. Thomas McNeal, William E. sascr

831 L.C.C. wae '

o

S

” . °

e

Earl G. Quinn, Sal pea J. H. Smith, ind baanee P,

Sheahan, for various railway labor organizations.

(2 5) ieee es _ REPORT OF THE COMMISSION

Division 3; COMMISSIONERS TUGGLE, Buss, AND BTAFFORD

*

(3 TUGGLE, Comisinstoners

Pursuant to the provisions of section 13a) of the Interstate

Commerce Act. as amended, the Chicago & Eastern Illinois

_ Railroad’ Company (C&EI), a common carrier by railroad subject

to the provisions of part I of the act, on August 31, 1967, filed -

notices and supporting statements in which it. propdsed to dis-

continue, .effective October . 1, 1967, service by its interstate

passenger trains Nos. 93 and 54 between Chicago, Ill., and- Evans-

_- Ville, Ind., a distance of 287 miles, Copies of the notices were.

duly served and posted in the manner required by , section 13a(1)

_and. our rules and regulations thereunder.

_- By petition filed concurrently in Finance Docket-No. 24726,

’ . C&ET seeks. authority under section 13a(2) to discontinue service

‘by its intrastate passenger trains Nos. 3 and 4 between Chicago

and Danville, Il. That proceeding ds the subject of a report and .

- recommended order! of the hearing examiner served separately. .

‘C&EI’s application filed with the Dlinois Commerce Commission

for authority to discontinue trains Nos. 3 and 4 was denied by that

_ body on September 20, 1967. Appropriate notice of the petition

' . filed here in Finance Docket No. 24726 wasberved on the Governor.

of the State of Dlinois.

Protests to C&EI’s proposal in the titled ssecaouine were filed

by communities along the line and State, civic, business, and rail-

way labor interests, as well as lise s of the trains. By order.of

September 18, 1967, we instituted an investigation and required

continued ‘operation of trajns Nos. 93 and 54 pending a hearing

and decision (up to the statutory maximum of 4 months). Because

| Of the ‘statutory limitation on the time available for investigation

and decision; our order provided for omission in the titled pro-

ceeding of a report and recommended order by the examiner as

part of the decisional process and for. certification/of the repqre

to us for initial decision.

of that matter with this procveeding. Replies thereto were tiled by certgin p

as denied.

. IBy petition filed December 14, 1967, C&EI sought omission of the examin

report and recommended order in Finance Docket No. 24726 land donsol man:

tostante, and by order .ente J January’ &, 1968 the petition

31 1.C,C: id

3 . l

at, . Sali |

9 26. as

as

Public thearings were held in Chicago, Momence, Watseka,

Hoopeston and Danville, Ill., and Evansville, Vincennes, and Terre

Haute, Ind., on @ consolidated record with the section 13a(2)_

proceeding in Finance Docket No. 24726. Briefs were filed by.

C&EI, the Illinois Commerce Commission; and jointly by the

_ village of Milford, the cities of Watseka, Danville and Hoopeston,

lll., and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen.

At'the hearing protestants moved for dismissal of the proceed-

‘ings on several grounds, principally that since Missouri Pacific

Railroad Company (MoPac) controls C&El, use of financial data

relating only to C&EI and excluding MoPac is grossly misleading

- amd contrary to the provisions of the act. Other relief sought

included suspensiog or termination of the proceedings and oral

argument on the motion. C&EI replied in opposition, and thes

motion was taken under advisement. The protestants pursue the —

“A argument on brief.

y ‘The motion is denied. Oral argument is not warranted. By,

contending MoPac a necessary party to these proceedings,

protéstafits ignore plaih language of section 13a of the act,

a eteb aaitigh ann'bee Gomaneae jurisdiction over proposed

. Passenger train discontinuances by “‘a carrier or carriers sub-

ject to this chapter.”’ Clearly, C&EI falls within the term “‘a

» carrier’’ subject to part I of theact. Whether or not the statatory. _

Standards for ordering .a continuance of servige are met is a

matter which, in this case, does not depend (as will later be made

clear) upon the corporate relationship of MoPac and C&EL

Piercing the corporate veil may be warranted in some situations,

as for example, where false and misleading representations are ;

made or where some unlawfulness may be involved, and perhaps

ye cry amg pdaarse no éuch question is raised and

no substantial reason is advanced to pursue that course. The

record indicates that C&EI is the proper party in interest and

that it haé fully cooperated in presenting the data required for

our action.

P Trains Nos. 93 and S4 operate on’ the following schedules:

: 331 LC.C. , .

.

/

27

Train No. 93 8 Milled Stations Train No. 54

daily pele daily

P P.M, ‘ A.M

j 3:45 0.0 Jv, Chicago, Mi-------eeeeeeee Af. 10:86

3:59 6.6 Chicago (63rd St.) --+-++++- 10:35

A430 246.8 Steger ---+- Seeeeereeseses BE O:44 ;

oreeeeereens 77.5 Wateeks~+++ enn ewww nwnnns CG 6:49

6:10 123.2 Danville-« «++ eeeenwwewnne 7:66

7:16 177.6 Terre Haute, Ind-«-++-++%-~ 6:40

BT:46 203.7 Sullivan ~-+-++++++- ee eewwwee G 6:11

6:16 234.7 Vincennes «+++ +e ene rwnnn 5:40

D6:60 259.0 Princeton: «scene seen eenne 5:05

0:65 267.2 Ar. Evenevilie-: eee nw ennnnnne Ly. 4:30

A—Stope to receive passengers.

B—Stops to discharge revenue passengers from Chicago and Meger.

D—Stops to discharge or receive revenue passengers.

E-—Stopes to discharge passengers.

C-—Btope to receive revenue passengers for Chheago.

pe i gece Red panei with trains of the Louisville .

& Nas

Railroad (L&N) similarly designated, which operate

between Evansville and Atlanta, Ga., and Montgomery, Ala. The

interghange is at Evansville. The L&N splits its southbound No.

93 at Nashville, Tenn., with one sectionterminating at Atlanta and

the other ‘at Montgomery. L&N originates one section of its

northbound train No. 34 at Atlanta and the other at Montgomery,

and consolidates the two at Nashville. ,

diner, lounge, sleeper and twocoaches originaging at Atlanta daily

a@ coach originating at Evansville on Friday, Saturday and Sunday;

passenger-carrying equipment is air-conditioned. ,

Due to @ restructuring of mail service by the U. S. Post Office

Department, the mail cars were discontinued as of June 10, 1967,

that car. The mail handled in the baggage-mail car is minimal.

P 331 1.C.C.

4

*.

23

Train No. 93 still carries express traffic for the account of

Railway Express Agency, Inc., destined to Chattanooga. These

trains do not handle the express to or from C&EI — south of

Chicago.

Alternate passenger transportation ‘service to and from the

communities served* by C&EI betwetn Chicago and Evarisville,

and south thereof served by L&N is available by bus and by air

at most points. There are four flights daily southbound gnd three

northbound between Chicago and Danville; two flights daily south-

bound and three northbound between Chicago and Terre Haute; and

four flights daily southbound and five northbound between Chicago

. and Evansville. Numerous flights are scheduled between Chicago,’

on the one hand, and, on the other, Atlanta, Chattanooga, Bir-

mingham, Nashville, Montgomery, ‘and Mobile, and between

Evansville and Atlanta. Watseka and Hoopeston, Ill., Sullivan,

Vincennes and Princeton, Ind., have sio air service.

A major bus line operates three southbound and four northbourfé

buses daily between Chicago apd-fvansville, with stops at all

intermediate points served by the subjecttrains. Rail transporta-

tion is available, though limited, (a) by C&EI trains Nos. 3 and 4

between Chicago and Danville (but those are the trains involved in

‘Finance Docket No. 24726, the discontinuance proceeding referred

to ‘above) and (b) by Dlinois Central Railroad (IC) between Chicago

and Carbondale, I11., and points south thereof (four trains daily in

each direction). Highway distances between communities served

by C&EI and those served by IC in Dlinois vary from 12 to’35

miles. Bus fares are lower than rail fares between Chicago and

all points served by the subject trains, except Sullivan, Ind. Air

fares are higher than rail or bus.

C&EI maintains that it has lost patronage to the private pas-

senger automobile (as a mode of intercity transportation), and,

as evidence thereof, introduced statistics showing the increase

the number of registered automobiles in the counties of

and Indiana traversed by the subject trains. Considering

_ five Dlinois.counties (Cook, Will, Kankakee, Iroquois, and Ver

million) and. the six Indiana counties (Park, Vigo, Sullivan, Knox,

Gibson, and Vanderburg) it was shown that in 1960 the Mlinois, f-

counties had 1,653,520 registrations while the Indiana counties

had 132,253, and that by 1966, there was an increase of about

20 percent—to ‘itis 751 in the Dlinois counties and 158,186 the

331 LC.C.

29

For the benefit of automobile users, Dlinois Highway 1 between

Chicago and Danville and U. S. Highway 41 between Danville and

Evansville are adjacent to and parallel the line of C&EI. Also

_U. S. Highway 41 continues northward in Indiana east of Dlinois

Highway | to Chicago. Both are first class highways and U. S.

Highway 41 has substantial segments with four lanes. A number

of witnesses testified to the effect that driving on the highways

is dangerous. South of. Chicago and its suburbs the roads traverse

sparsely populated areas, are generally straight and the —

is flat.

The population? at the points served by the sub ject trains was

shown as follows: Chicago -3,550,404, Chicago Heights 41,000,

Watseka 5,219, Hoopeston 6,606, Danville 41,856, Terre Haute

72,500, Sullivan 4,979, Vincennes a aan 7,906; and

Evansville 141,543.

A number of those points have conmencial or service areas

extending beyond their corporate limits and the population re-

flected by such areas is larger than for the point involved.

During the periods 1965, 1966 and first 6 months of 1967, train

"No. 93 carried 84,259, 82,213 and 31,913 passengers, respectively,

of which 53,344, 56,230, and 20,952 were delivered to L&N at

Evansville. The daily average numbers of revenue passengers”

transported by that train for the same periods were 230, 225,

and 176, respectively, of which 84, 71, and 60, respectively, were

local passengers (traveling between C&EI stations). During the

same periods, train No. 54 carried 76,854, 75,271, and 28, 186

revenue passengers, respéctively, of which 57,983, 60,063 and21,- - :

682, were received from L&N 2 Evansville. The daily average

numbers of revenue passengers ‘transported by that train for the

same ‘periods were 210, 205,/and 153, of which 51, 40, and 33,

respectively, were local. The foregoing data were determined

from analysis of records of tickets collected by conductors, cash

farés received, and tickets honored but not collected, apportioned

to the subject trains a A to the number of miles traveled

or

The supporting studies also show the numbers of passengers

boarding and deboarding at eachséetation. Considering the last 6

months of 1967 as representing the present level of patronage, of -

the 176 passengers on train No. 93, an average of 156 boarded at

Chicago, | 12 at Steger, 5 at Danville, 2 at ‘Terre Haute and | at

"ideas an on the cepsus taken in 1960. Since that time, some of the areas

served have hed population increases.

331 LC.C..

4 Vincennes, and 17 left the train at Danville, 20 at Terre Haute, |

at Sullivan, 7 at Vincennes, 2 at Princeton, 13 at Evansville, and

116 continued’on the L&N.~+ Of the 153 passengers on train No. ,

54 an average of 120 were through passengers from the L&N,

_12 boarded at Evansville, 2 at Princeton, 6 at Vincennes, | at

Sullivan, 11 at Terre Haute, 4 at Danville, and | at Watseka,

and 3 left the train at Terre Haute, 3 at Danville, 8 at Steger

and 139 at Chicago. Thus, the ‘record shows that the C&EI

points south of Chicago have had few passengers boarding or

leaving the trains.

C&EI’s balance sheet statement as of July 31,4967, shows

assets aggregating. $119,182,901, including current assets of

$10,220,039, special funds $484,841, investments $10,941,671, total _

properties less depreciation and amortization $96,182,478, and

other assets and deferred charges $1,353, 872. Liabilities were:

current liabilities of $9,631,117, long-term debt of $53,494,944

(including $3,103,470 due within 1 year); reserves $659,983, other ©

liabilities and deferred credits $619,844, capital stock $29,837,372,

capital surplus $112,522, and retained income $24,827,119. Its

income statements for 1965, 1966 and first 7 months of 1967, show

railway operating revenues of $40,578,936, $41,780,952, and $23,-

604,275; net railway operating income of $3,486,070, $4,091,786,

and a deficit of $1,005,900; and net income after fixed charges and

other deductions of $1,736,086, $2,853,372, and a net deficit of.

$1,757,265, respectively. .

C&EI has incurred annual net railway operating deficits in its

' passenger service in amounts in excess of $1 million for the

“years 1962- * through 1966, inclusive. More than 20 percent of ~

freight net income has been required to subsidize these rail

passenger deficits in each of the years 1957 through 1966, except

1959 when the percent of freight net income so required exceeded

12 percent.- C& ET estimates that the national award of September

16, 1967 to the shopcraft employees, retroactive to January 1,

1967,. will increase its labor costs by $210,000 in 1967 and by

$321,000 in 1968. Further, a recent agreement with the Brother-

hood of Locomotive Engineers will result in payment of $100,000

to C&EI locomotive engineers in backpay. None of those additional

expenses were included in determining the cost of operating the

subject trains Guring the first 6 months of 1967, or in projections

made.

C&EI shows data respecting the financial results of the opera-

tion of the trains for the years 1965, 1966, and the first 6 months

331 1.C.C..

* Bl

of 1967. In 1965, train No. 93 had revenues (passenger, diner,

express and mail) of $1,096,607 and out-of-pocket expenses of

$1,001,950 for a net income of $94,657. For the same year, train

No. 54 had similar revenues of $811,156, and out-of-pocket ex-

penses of $862,270 for a net out-of-pocket loses of $51,114. In

1966, the corresponding figures for train No. 93 were $1,083,494

revenues, $1,125,287 costs, and $41, ,793 Gefielts for tx: train-WNo, 54.

they were $816,863-revenues, $1,022,127 costs, and $205,264

deficit; the combined net loss for both trains was $247,037. In

the first 6 months of 1967, the corresponding figures for train No.

93 were $420,167 revenues, $522,421 costs, and $102,254 deficit,

and for train No. 54, $311,281 revenues, $477,387 costs, and

$166,106 deficit; the combined net out-of-pocket loss was $268,360.

Details of: the revenues and expenses for those periods indicated

as computed by the carrier are shown in the attached appendix A.

As indicated, actual revenues from these trains, including car-

hire revenue are reflected in the data presented. The following

actual expenses were also employed: Train engineman expense,

traincrew expense, sleeping car expense, insurance, expenses

‘incurred in clearing wrecks, baggage loss and damage claims,

injuries to persons and dining car and buffet car service. Other

expenses and savings data were computed using methods approved

by the Commission in prior proceedings. ‘Increases in expenses

for .1966 over those of 1965 occurred in four accoungs (a) pas-

se train cars—repairs, (b) equipment depreciation—passenger

_ cars, (¢) train supplies and expenses, and (d) joint facility accounts.

’ These were the subject of detailed inquiry. On (a) anaccidentto .

train No. 93 at Hoopeston in April 1966, were required ‘extensive

repairs to passenger cars ($59,506),- Expeas¢s charged tothat ac-

count in 1965 were abnormally low. On(l)C&EI did not, until 1967,

retire its head-end equipment used on other trains in 1965 and

1966, having made such equipment available tothe U. S. Post Office

Department for use in trains Nos. 93 and 54, Retirements of

head-end equipment in 1967, when mail was remdved-from all

° C&EI passenger trains amounted to $365,549, but this increase in

expense was not reflected in the financial results discussed above.

In projecting revenues: and expenses involved in operating the

subject trains without the mail revenue equipment, depreciation on

only those cars which would be required ‘to operate the subject

“tfains without any head-end business was considered. On (c) the

total passenger portion of the account actually decreased in 1966,

but _— 7” — over fewer trains thanin 1965, resulted

: _ $31 LC.c.

*

‘

~ ppc mm +f

32

in an increased allocation to the remaining trains. On (d) the

increase in joint facility expenses in 1966 was due to the discon-

tinuance of passenger trains by other railroads. using such facili-

ties, which added ~jeepaead to the expense burden on the

remaining trajns. -

Trains Nos. 93 and 54 ‘use joint facilities ‘at ee with four

other railroads, and with one other at Terre Haute, Vincennes,

and Evansville. During the first 6 months of 1967, no C&EI pas-

senger trains, other than the subject trains usedthe Terre Haute,

Vincennes and Evansville facilities, and as a result,. all of the

amounts paid for use of those facilities ($25,356, $18,136, and

$104,328, respectively) are savable. Joint facility costs were*

computed in accordance with those methods* and standards ap-

proved in Chicago, R. 1. & P. Co., Discontinuance of Trains, 328

~LC.C. 278.

The foregoing data reflect revenues received na C&Elfor trans-

portation of mail. Projected annual revenues and ‘out-of-pocket

expenses, exclusive of mail traffic, using 1966 revenue data, —

* show that C&EI would incur an annual loss of $242,850 in the _

operation of train No. 93 and $191,780 in the operation of train

No. 54. In projecting equipment depreciation and other expense

items only the equipment that actually would be used was con-

sidered. The projected annual revenues and. out-of-pocket ex-

penses, exclusive of mail traffic, were shown as follows:

ww 2 _ a.

—— ae

Train No. 93 - Train No. 54

Revenues: . .

302 Coach! ~-+ +++ 00-00 - deen eee eee eeneeee $532,953 $468,549

102 First class!------+-++---0--20-0-2--- . 87,680. 113,593

‘ 103-108 Baegece and other!--------------- - 3,270 ‘ 1,153

107 Expressé -------<--0-0- 000 nnn en nnnne - 587 34,909

131 Dining and buffet! --------------- tee 47,844 47,844 —

Total revenue-------- wecdcccccccccceces 671,334 666,048

505-538 Car-hire, net3-------- a eeecceccces 4,785 4,785

Revenue and income Aone www www www wn wwnne 676,119 | 670,833

Total expense ~-.+--.----------0++----- 918,969 862,563

Profit or loss--------+---+--+1-----e------ (242,850) (191,730)

Expenses: :

Maintenance of equipment— - : , : °

311 Repairs, diesel locomotives - eeeeeeeeee . 53,406 . ° + 53,390

317 Passenger train car repairs5----------- 141,817 " 141,817

331 Equipment depreciation—locomotive® --- 8,760 8,760

331 Equipment depreciation—cars! --------- 30,103 30,103

335 Employee health and welfare benefits §-- ~- s 2,502 2,502

Traffic: ae ° °°.

351-360 PasSenger traffic4---------------- 21,996 - “ 16,036

331 LC.C,

33

— Train No. 93 Train No, 54

eanaportntions “ iy

373 Station employees4--- + -------------- $15,650 $14,568

376 Station supplies and expense4~---- Hele 3,062 " 2,768

378 Yard conductor and brakeman® --------- ‘ 5,532 5,532

392 Train onginemén” weer ewww www nnn 50,193 52,987

394 Train fuel! t-+----------------------- - 80,400 30,400

397 Water for shal locomotion! !....------- 1,781 1,781

398 Lubrication for train locomotian!!------ 3,709 « 3,709

399 Other supplies for train locomotion! 1.--- 168 168

400 Enginehouse expense —train!!--.--- wee 8,108 §,108

- 401 Trainmen! ore e eee ee eee eeeeenee 67,844 67,134

402 Train supplies and “expenses !2 . ceeceeee 88,308 88,308

403 Operating sleeping cars4---------- ore- 49,060 37,392

+ 409 Employee health and welfare benefits 5- - ° 5,163 5,222

Insurance !° --<--<+-+-0- 2000000000048 16,405. 16,405

419 Loss and damage baggage !4- acer eeee 550 480

420 Injuries to perbene“*-><3es-seseresses 41,044... 2,754

- 44f Dining and buffet service 4------ ww cccce _ Fh188 ° 71,188

General: O-. ees

452 Closke. aecounting4 ~-+---- #ee eee Ye

456 Employee health and welfare benefits 4-- x 360 “~ "996

All joint facility accounts !5--- ------ woeee 170,720 170,720

532 Railway tax accruals!6-.... ..-- waeeee 21,958 E 21,542

Total expenses ----:--------+- + ------ 918,969 862,563

11966 actual. The number preceding-each item is the account number in the

Commission’s Uniform System of Accounts.

2Projected based on current traffic.

3 Projected ased on car @ssignwmwents.

4 Projected sed on first 6 months 1967 expenses. 5

5Projected based on estimated car miles @ first 6 months 1967 cost per car mile.

- 6Based on two unit assignment. ;

TBased on cars required. ~

SBased on current G.M.A. rates applied to wane only..

9 Based on current assignment. :

LO Based on 1966 payments plus wage ivisieassioits

11 Based on 2 unit assignment @ first monthg\@67 cost per unit miles.

12Based on estimated car mile @ first 6 months 1967 cost per mile plus crews’

lodging and meals at current costs.

13 Based on current premiums.

"l4Based on 2.5 year average.

15Based on estimated car assignments. :

16 Based on current rates applied to labor only. -

-

It is thus apparent that C& EI has incurred substantial losses in

the operation of the trains Nos. 93 and 54 and that the losses will

stantially increase as a result of the Post Office Department’s

‘removal of mail from those trains and the consequent discon-

tinuance of passenger trains of other railroads using the Chicago

terminal facility, although the latter factor was not ——- in

making the above ian aware

331 1.C.C.

a ie ad |

\ ae

ore

veo 34

*

Bight communities on the line served by the subject trains inter-

vened in -opposition: Chicago, Watseka, Milford, Hoopeston, and

‘Danville, Ill., and Terre Haute, Vincennes, and ‘Evansville, Ind.

The trains -do not serve Milford. Althoughsome Dlinois residents ©

who ride C&EI train No. 4 northbound returnon train No./93 south-

bound, the witnesses testifying at communities in Dlinois were

' primarily interested in the continued operation of trains Nos. 3 and

4. The latter are the subject of the section 13a(2) proceeding in.

Finance Docket No. 24726 and, under the provisions of that section,

are being dealt with inthe reportofthe hearing-examiner. Indiana

intérveners and witnesses testifying at Indiana points were con-

cerned with continued operation of the - Subject trains.

Of the 144 public witnesses who testified on, the consolidated

record; 90 directed their testimony in whole orin part to the sub--

_—Ject trains. Not all-use the services of the trains. Thirty-one

testified on behalf .of State, county, city govetnment or municipal ”

organizations, civic or trade organizations, and colleges or uni- .

versities, and \ one presented the views of a Congressman. A

number were’ concerned with rail passenger service generally,

though they themselves did not use the services provided by the

subject trains. With few exceptions the public witnessés desire

the trains continued in what would be a standby service for use ©

. as convenience in bad weather, at holiday periods and for shopping

trips. No public witnesses testified at Chicago.

At Watseka, the mayor and representatives of the chamber of

commierce and the County Farm Bureau indicated that, although

they do not use the subject trains, there is need for rail pas-

senger service in inducing industry to locate in the area. A .

‘surgeon testified to using the trains 20-24 times a’year to and

from Chicago where, he indicates, an increasing number of his |

patients require medical service. He owns an automobile, but

- does not use it on long trips.

At Hoopeston, the mayor and the president of fhe chamber of

commerce expressed concern over rail passenger service.

_ Testimony was given by a department store buyer and a beattician.

_Two personnel managers of large corporations indicated that

prospective employees inquire about transportation facilities to

.and from Chicago. One could express no opinion as to whether

discontinuance of the sub ject trains would have a detrimental ef- ©

fect on recruiting employees in Hoopeston; the other usés other

trains of C&EI and was more concerned with their retention.

The president of the Bese ie Industrial Corporation points out

331 1.C.C.

\

. . . ’

¢> ‘ P - . ee: \

“ty a ‘ \

° .

. e . : . %

a

wubsr . ee | rr tent rr Ot ree yen

rei

35

that every prospective industry mentions transportation.. Arepre-

sentative of a corn festival held annually each September in

Hoopeston urges continuation of the service, but of the 100,000

persons attending the last occasion, he knew of only four who came

by rail. The foregoing witnesses ‘themselves rarely patronize the

subject trains. Another witness: rides train No. 93 during un-

“usually heavy snowstorms when other means of travel are not

available. ,

At Danville, municipal, commercial 7 otter organizational

spokesmen were concerned with rail passenger service generally :

and specifically C&EI trains other than those here involved.

Several other witnesses proved to be only occasional patrons of

trains Nos. 93 and 54—a bookkeeper, a number of railroad em-

ployees (who rated their on-time performance as poor), a house- ‘

wife (who finds them crowded and often late), another housewife

whose children sometimes use the trains going to and from

colleges (particularly in bad weather), and an architect who ex- -

. pressed the view that the discontinuance would hamper Danville’s

development: Another witness who uses C&EI trains about once

a month, occasionally drives his automobile to Chicago, but would

not go by bus because he considers the bus routes circuitous and

‘the service time consuming. Support for continued operation was

- voiced by a "a

_ members. testified that he the trains only once, but that

_ the majority of the membership use all C&EI trains; and by the

chamber of commerce (representing 116 manufacturing firms) as

part of its program to promote improvement in transportation.

Several manufacturing organizations indicated that some of their

employees occasionally use the trains... Spokesmen for three

civic organizations use the trains several times a year, particu-

larly during inclement weather, but also have used alternate

transportation, including private automobile. A number of the

witnesses testified that the northbound train is frequently late and _

dirty, that this was reported to. _ railroad and that there was

little effective response.

At Evansville, the mayor and a State senator opined that dis-

continuance. of the trains would be detrimental to the growth of ,

industry and commerce in the community. The mayor uses ajr

service on many occasions. and uses rail service about once every

6 months. The senator does not have occasion to use C&EI’s

service. The chamber of commerce spokesman urged that the

discontinuance be.deferred until L&N acquires the eastern side of a

331 1.C.C.

or chamber df commerce spokesman fogykl0 _

36

° .

C&EI’s line, although the transportation division which he repre-

sents voted six to three against opposing discontinuance. An aide

to a member of Congress from Indiana presented the Congress-.

- man’s views that rail passenger transportation service is vital to

the economic growth of the community, and that: all modes of

transportation.‘must be: kept available. Other witnesses testified

to‘ a preference for rail over alternate modes for the occasiqnal |

trips they take, though some of them found the-rail cars crowded, |

dirty and sometimes unheated. Among them was the representa-

tive of a ‘religious community: having 30 nuns stationed at Evans-

ville. She indicated that her order’s recent ‘transportation re-

quirements were accomplished \through use of charter bus service,

and that the sisters have sufficient automobiles at their disposal. ‘

- At Vincennes, the mayor opposed the discontinuance but, in so

doing, was not supported. by the city council. The chamber of

commerce mailed 475 questionnaires to area residents regarding

the proposed discontinuance; 82 were returned showing a 3 to 1

_. prefererice for’ keeping the trains on. A survey at Viricennes |

University yevealed that 22 of the 2,243 students use the trains. .

Members of the faculty use them twice a year. Seven students

said they hope to use them more frequently, particularly during

bad weather. A number of other witnesses—all of them only

‘occasional users—complained. about the condition of the trains and

the’’station ‘at Vincennes, about a poor on-time record, ‘crowded

and dirty equipment. All of the above witnesses urge ———

of the service with improvement of quality. >

At Terre Haute, the mayor pressed the view that passenger

train service is needed in the development of industry and com-

merce. On his six trips to Chicago in the past year he used train —

service once when his air flight was grounded on account of bad

‘weather. The chamber of commerce cited statistics showing

growth in population, commerce, efrollment -in the. universities

and retail sales as yardsticks of a demand for improved service.

_ Aware that loss of mail revenues has precipitated discontinuance.

of passenger rail service, it argued that the railroad should con-

sider providing complete sérvice, freight and passenger, and-

should look to the passenger market as any other business man

looks at a-.new market. . Further, that a successful company

expects to absorb departmental losses within its gross earnings

in order. to provide a complete service. ° Professors and students

_ Of a local university, opposing the discontinuance, testified to their

_use of the trains variously from regular weekend use to once or"

331 1.C, C.

* ment at the local i

_ or 7 years, use of the trains, at Terre.Haute has continued to

decline. ©

has a- number of automobiles at’ its disposa\ and h

tots “elen

‘

‘

an a year: pes inclement weather. ‘Student ownership of |

automobiles by upper classmen is permitted and some of the

students use the trains nly when they cannot obtain autompbile~

transportation. Student/use of tHe trains is primarily on holidays

and at the beginning nd end of summer vacation. While enroll

versity has more than doubled in the past 6

\' 7

. A religious ae with national headquafters atearby St. Mary

of the Woods has 350 members who ride the trains to. Chicago

. The order

used them.

twice. annually ‘for connéctions east and post ta

and bus service for Chicago trips. In advertixing. for its college

the order would like to be in a position to advise prospective

students that easy access is available via rail among other modes. |

It has had some difficulty with on-time performance of’ the trains, °

- particularly in’ making ‘confections. The college has: -about 400

students, a number of whom are from the Chicago area,

Some evidence was presented to show the caxprér’ scar-cleaning ~

program and the problems inyolved. Somppttnes delay in arrival

at Chicago requires quick turnarouridy“and cleaning of the cars .

leaves much to be desired, The retord indicates that C&EI has

made some effort to overcome the problem but must deal with

C&WI which maintains the Chicago terminal facility.

Discussion and conclusions. ~Numérous factors are onaiahond .

in determining whether‘to order the continuance of service under

section 13a(1) of the .act. Among them are public yse of the

service, population of the area, effect of a train discontinuance

upon the communities served, available alternate transportation,

_ financial results of thé operation, prospects for the future, and

the carrier’s financial condition. The weight to be given each

factor depends on the circumstances in a particular case. No

_ one factor is necessarily controlling. ‘The intent of Congress

in enacting section 13a was to enable carriers to discontinue

train services that no longer pay their way, and for which there

is “no longer sufficient public need to justify the financial loss -

involved. “See Southern Ry. Co. v, North Carolina, 376 U.S. 93.

At one time the passenger train was the pride of the transporta-

tion system. This was especially so in the United States where:

there was vast wilderness to be tamed, rich deposits of natural.

resources to be tapped, and large, widely-separated cities to be.

connected. _ The railroad and its Sapa trains provided the

4

$31 EC.

0/

. a

,

F e ; '

strands for tying the far-flung areas together, and the channels

for ; efficient communication and transport. Time and +

e genius created more efficient means for performing a

number of the functions for which we formerly relied on the rails.

Electronics provide instant communication, and airplaines cut

transport time tremendously for people, mail and express. The

automobile and the supper “provide particular convenienc® whit

have a special fascination—provide particular conv which

other modes cannot duplicate. :

The evidence tow befoke: es: ghows that the subject traiés 20

longer are used by express shippers (except for some movements _

between Chicago and Chattanooga), or by the Post Office Depart-

ment for mail (once a highly remunerative source of traffic and a~

- primary source of sustenance for passenger trains). Passenger

traffic has been dwindling. In the meantime, costs continue Up-

ward inexorably. The general.rise in costs throughout the eco-

nomy are reflected in the railroad’s.expenses for employees,

equipment, fuel, supplies, facilities and services. With the loss

of mail revenues making a d change in the financial re-

sults of the operations CHE! wou have to absorb an out-of-

pocket deficit well over ,000 per year in order to continue

trains Nos. 93 and 54. B bs WilgirtBat the deflate Hout gp boyent.

a half million dollars.

Financially, sds cieasior to ‘ct host waluinis. It has a history ~

of deficit operation and is beset with numerous problems flowing

therefrom regarding rehabilitation of its line and recovery of .

traffic. See Missouri Pac. R.Co.-Control-~Chicago& E. I. R. Co.,

, 827 LC.C. 279 (1965). .The blender profit shown on this record

for 1965 and 1966 occurred at the height of a record breaking

period of national prosperity. The relatively slight slowdown

in the national economy during 1967 had an immedjate and felling

effect on C&E(s operation, creating a net deficit of nearly $2

million in the first 7 monthe of the year. C&El is an important

link in the national rail system and from the point of service in its

own afea and as an integral part of the national syatem, its

viability is a thing much to be desired. of the subject

‘trains would militate against that objective re t& no reason- °

“able prospect for relief from the {inancial burdens imposed by

- those trains. To the contrary, Indications are that the burdens

would mount. And this, inturn,’ are

malaise, all to the detriment of the

ca

‘The people who have been using Senta Sf tonwi hoes Gane ,

so largely on an occassional or standby basis. Their primary

331 L.C.C.

a

ae Cate d 39

Y ate

means of conveyance are the automobile and other nonrail modes. -

Fam eacimony ot the governmental leaders, business representa~ —

tives, and housewives is clear proof of that. The wit-

nesses themselves appear to prefer air and automobile travel.

' Many gave opinion’ about a need for rail passenger service in the

interest of community dnd commercial growth, but few hard,

realistic facts were advanced by them in support. The passenger-

+ use Statistics stand as stark proof that, regardless of what is

felt and said, *the people along the C&EI’s Evansville-Chicago

line are not using the trains. Their patronage is minimal.

For those who must depend upon public transportation, bus

‘service is far more- plentiful than the train service—at all

points on the line. Use of the buses will require an adjustment,

but whatever inconvenience might ,be experienced does not out~

weigh, on the scale ‘of the public interest, the tremendous

burden continued operation of the trains would involve. We con-

clude that discontinuance by C&EI of trains Nos. 93 and 54 is

consistent with the purpose of, section 13a(1) of the act, and the

objectives of the national transportation policy.

' Certain railway employees seek imposition of the Burlington

or similar conditions in the event the discontinuance is authorized.

Similar requests have. been considered in prior proceedings of

this nature, and the Commission has uniformly held that we do

not possese authority to impose conditions for the protection of

° railway employees who may be adversely affected as a result of

the discontinuance of passenger service under section 13a(1).

See Great Northern Ry. Co. Discontinuance of Service, 307 LC.C.

59. However, the probable efféct of such discontinuance on em~

ployees is a matter to be considered in determining whether the

public convenience and necessity require the continuance of such

service. We have considered that factor, and, in our opinion, the

probable adverse éffect upon employees does not afford sufficient

grounds to order continuance of the service.

‘Contentions of the parties as to fact or law not specifically dis-

cussed herein have nevertheless .been considered and found to be —

without merit or material significance.

_ We find that the operation by the Chicago & Eastern

Railroad Company of passenger trains Nos. 93 and 54 between

Chicago, Ill, and Evansville, Ind., is not required by the public

convenience and necessity and that continued operation thereof

would unduly burden interstate or foreign commerce.

An egpecpeiate exter will Se entered Cleecatiauing the investi

gation herein. ‘

° 331 LC.C.

|

~o 9 ees

Bi Gat a ere

~ Bs Hi i

41

ORDER

At a Session of the INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION,

Division 3, held at its office in Washington, D. C., on the

25th day of January eed

.

x i Docket No. 24725

CHICAGO & EASTERN ILLINOIS RAILROAD CO.—DISCONTINU-

ANCE OF TRAINS NOS. 93 AND 54 BETWEEN CHICAGO, ILL.

AND EVANSVILLE, IND.-

Investigatton of the matters and things involved inthis proceed-

ing having been made pursuant to the order of said division, dated

September 18, 1967, a hearing having been held and the said

- division on the date hereof having made and filed’ a report con-

taining its: findings of fact and conclusions thereon, which report

is hereby referred to and made a part hereof:

That this investigation be, and it is hereby dis-

continued, and that this order shall Je effective 35 days from the

date hereof.

By the Commission, division 3.

H. NEIL GARSON,

(SEAL) Secretary.

U9, COVERNMENT PROFTING OFFICE ; 1970 © - 398-024

6

oe 7 eT

Sucrevre Court, US

—

- Ae - mmmatehioa) - 2,

: : “JUL 15 1970

| SUPREME COURT OF THE U

October Term, 1969

No. 396 €

2 ROB. Rf ScAVER, CLERK

LOUISVILLE AND NASHVILLE RAILROAD Pie tas sg

COMPANY, - - - -.- - Appellant,

Vv.

TENNESSEE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION,

ETAL, - Soe eee Sate barton

On Appeal From the United States District Court ~—

’ For The Northern District of Ilinois

_ JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT

HARRY R. BEGLEY,

72 West Adams St.,

- Suite 1500,

Chicago, Illinois 60603,

JOSEPH L. LENIHAN,

CLIFFORD T. COOMES, .

JAMES W. HOELAND, ' >

(Counsel of record. on ‘whom

service is to be made)’

908 W. Broadway,

oe Kentucky 40201,

_ Attorneys for Appellant,

‘Louisville and Nashville

. Railroad Company.

Due Date: July 17, 1970. —

7

WESTERFIELD-BONTE CO., INC., 619 W. KENTUCKY, LOUISVILLE, KY

£\

\. SUBJECT INDEX

—_——— s

PAGE

Opinion Below . 4 poesia Ghar aggete earn. yeaa ae

Surisiiction .ni.,s.. Ngieseeceeaee ceases 2

Questions Presented ... . . . aA AR re Pe : OE re ane

Statutes Involved . . : reey pM adapts ees ESe HO

Statement ..........e.eceeee eed Se Seitseese 3.

| The Questions Peisaeted Are Substantial LPP seeee. 6 ;

| I Gos réecedsahenaes pmo ae ogee PONE

| Appendix A... sees None re oh ees

Appendix B... Rte ere or cote eens Z Apeeees 21°

| Appendix ©... 0.2.2.0... pt Am anes ay,

MEO oi cis hos cvesssgtes Wijk ae

Appendix EB... ....... pie Ate ee Nee yi cheaweaoe: Wa

mae Say |

v

+ Ce ee fT eh a net ae pies

»

PT ee PT ee eee ee ee

.

4/4

gh |

Aberdeen and Rockfish RR: v. ‘United States, 270 F.

Supp. 695 (D.C.,La. 1967), modified and aff’d sub

nom., Baltimore & O. RR. v. Aberdeen & Rockfish

ae ME NO OF Ni oe Sos ce: ve

American Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 231 F,

6 MOI MID) ooo oie so sie cis sushi ia 7

Arrow Transp. Co. v. Southern Ry., 372 U. S. 658 ©

(RPPOIs oe See vege sess ties Oe rues ees On tey 13, 14°

Ayrshire ome v. United States, 331 U, S$. 132 (1947) 4)

Boston and Maine R.R. v. United States, 208 Il. Supp.

661 (D.C. Mass. BE koro sk as ange ee OS tae ot i ee

Chas. Pfizer & Co. v. Ze ith Laboratories, fae sg .e 9 _ eer

24.429 (3d C ir. ee eas ee aoe ae

City of Chicago v. United States, 396 U.S, 162 (1969). 6; 7

City of Chicago v. U nited States, 294 FP. ‘Supp. oie

CS eee ean asad oe roks hare as VY pe Rea Ka . /4

. Dire. Cayviork Inc.-v. United State 8, 301 U. S.. 56

*(1956). . peg PMc rate ara ea Ea iy eos oan 2

Ettelson'v. Metropolitan Ins. Co., 317 Us .188 (1942). 11

Federal Communications Comy’ nN. v. Pottst ille Broad-

casting Co., 309 U.S. 184 (1940). .7... Pe 1,

Federal Power Comm'n. v- Idaho-Power Co. , 344 U.S.

Se CAIUS et tapes Vines kas sce cebin Cee

1.C.C. v. Jersey City, 322 U. 8. 503 (194). Prot, «jae

Illinois C. R.R, v. . Literstate Com. Comm’n., 206 U. S. 3

443 C1907). . i555). eles a tug the ee Faas Coie 8

Intérstate Com. Cotnn’ n. v. Union Pac. R.R., 922 U.S...

Eo. + | Rei eee Wace ak ees keer seas a)

Louisville & N.R. Co. Discontinuance -of Trains, 333 :

' LC.C. 720 (1968). .. (ici heo ped aon vans Oe

Mayo v. Canning Co., 309 U.S. 310 (1940) - aha awe

Miss. Va ley Barge tine Co. v. United States, 292 U. »

DRE. ones er ERS as kine CS ae ae

‘cae v. United States, 304 U. 8.1 (1938).-..... ae

Securities Comm'n. v. se ig Corp. G02 U.S. 194 t

TORT a occ occ ediemnpevcevcevees iss vpeess eel ee

Sims « v. Grecke, 161 F. 2d A 87, (3d Cir.. m4). ee

- PAGE * ;

7

wn UI geen toate Ye vis asc —_—

; eee

eee id Rae sane ea

_ Sims v. Greene, 160 i“ 2d 512 (1947) ry aie ees 11

a Sprague w. Ticonic Bank, 307.0; 8. 161 (1939) ieee Ne

Tennessee’ Public Service: Commission v United -

States, 294 F. Supp. 1106 (1969)........ PO ne

Tribune Review: Publishing Co. v.. Thomas, 133 f.

3 Supp. 486. (W.D. Pa.. 1957)... 1. sri. ee ees. 12

-Union.Pac. R. R, v. Johnson, 249 F. 2d 674 (9th Gir:

cL RE Ane pap san gigl Corre itr ten it Meinl Tea NT See 7

. United States v. Drum, 368 U.S. §. 370 (1961). ene a ae

Vnited States v. Saskatchewan PEMNAreE Ale U.S. 94

| Bsa ae ck oe wa ao lle a Sten Gaca 4 Spee wake ‘16

: 8 : : 3 y ’ Ae ’

” e :

a . <

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.