Jurisdictional Statement — United States v. City of Chicago
Supreme Court brief1970
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
— oe
.
.
° > e
»
‘
Memotfandum in Support of Motion on Mandate nen .
tioned “the interdependence of Cé& El’s segment
of the *Gogreian’ trains, with the ‘Hummingbird’
trains * * *” in-arguing for a remand of~the “Hum-
mingbird — case” (Memorandum, p. 3). The court in
rvemanding -for “ consolidated.’ proceeding tersely
stated that “* * * sucli service ‘is so interwoven
and entwined between the various railroads that only
in a consolidated proceeding ean ‘a just and fair de-
‘ _ vision be reached” (App. A, infra, p. 13).
DISCUSSION -
The district court’s apparent | reason for vacating -
the Commission’ § order in this case was its coticlusion
that the ease should be consolidated and considered to-
gether with the appeal involving the “Georgian”
trains. We consider this conclusion error for twa, rea-
sons (apart from the error in the underlying **Geor-
gian” case): first, it constituted action’ on the merits
of the appeal, and thus ought not to ‘have heen taken
in ady ance of. briefing and oral argument; second, it
is inconsistent with the Section’ 13a(1) requirement of |
cx peditious proceedings to make discontinuance of the
“Hummingbird” await completion of all proceedings
relative to the “‘Georgian”’ where, as here, the Com-
mission had already considered the relationship be-
tween the two trains and determined that, even if the
one were continued, the other would continue to suffer
losses warranting discontinuance (App. C, infra, p. 31).
These errors, we concede, may: not in themselves — -
have the general importance warranting plenary re--
view in this Court, since their effect beyond the pe-
» &
_F
at
rimeters of this case is open ts doubt. However, the
district court’ s order is associated with au@ dependent .
‘upon its disposition of, City of Chicago, supra, \ in
which we are filing a Jurisdictional Statement Aen
does, we believe, set forth contentions warranting
plenary review in this Court. In the event the district
court’s judgment is ‘reversed iti ‘thot proceedings, -
summary disposition here — he appropriate.
CONCLUSION ae
For the foregoing reasons, action: oft this Jurisdic-
tional Statement should be postponed pending final
action on the Jurisdictional Statement in [ J nited States
v. City of Chicago, filed contemporaneously herewith.
wi Rexpocthally submitted. bs Os
; Erwin N. Griswoip,
oe = Solicitor General.
. . Ricuarp W. McLaren,
Assistant Attorney General.
Grecory LB, Hoyenpon, ~
: Rowerr B. NICHOLSON,
| rer say Attorneys.
Rosert W. GINWANE,* | ats | Ade
General Counsel,
Jerome NELSON,
InterY®ate Commerce Commussion.
Juri¥-1970.
; . °
cae
a
-_
ee ee
APPENDIX A
Uniited States District Court for the Northern District - |
.* of Illinois, Easterp Division /
- No. 68 C 956 Be ee
Ciry OF CHICAGO, ET AL., PLALNTIFES,
4 .
“ae - Pe
? 74). i.
- Usrrep States or AMERICA, ET Aly DEFENDANTS. | ~
. ’ . . , |
No. 68 C 1666 <3
:
TENNESSEE: PuBLIC Service COMMISSION, ET AL.,
PLAINTIFFS, i .
| uv,
Unrrep States op AMERICA, ET AL.y DEFENDANTS.
ORDER
Followimg the filing ofa copy of the mandate ‘of
the Supreme Court of the United States herein with:
the Clerk of the Distriet Court; tliis three-judge court
on February 5, 1970, entered an order wherein it (1)
remanded both. causes numbered 68 C 956 and 68 €
1666 to «the Interstate Commerce Commission
((“LC.C.”) for further proceedings and (2) held under.
advisement the motion made by plaintiffs and .inter-
vening plaintiffs to reinstate the temporary restrain-
ing order in case 68 C 1666 until the conclusion of
the proceedings before the I.C.C. j ;
Thereafter the various parties filed various motions
and the three-judge court now has before it (1) mo-
o -°
398-045 —70——-2
at’
Pesige
a
10
tion of. defendant Chicago & Eastern Illinois Rail-
road Company (“Q&ET’ *) for rehearing or amend-
ment of said order of February 5, 1970;° (2) Sasase
of defendant Louisville and Nashville Railroad Com-
pany (“L&N”) for rehearing’ and amendment-of said
order; (3) motion 6f- defendants United States of
America and I.C.C. for a new trial in both cases with
memorandum in support thereof; (4) motion of plain- _
tiffs and intervening plaintiffs for reconsideration and
amendment of said February 5 order with memoran- ,
dum in support thereof; (5) response of plaintiffs and
intervening plaintiffs to the aforesaid motions of de-
fendants; (6) response of defendant C&EI to plain-:
_ tiffs’ and intervening plaintiffs’ motion, and (7) re-
sponse of defendant L&N to plaintiffs’ and ° interven-
ing plaintiffs’. motion. '
The Court has consideréd all the foregoing motions,
‘the responses and memoranda of the parties hereto
and the opinion of- the-Supreme-Court herein and is
of ‘the opinion that.it.should reconsider - Ats\ order of
February 5, 1970 and should modify aid amend aaa
order ‘as. ‘thadtnadien: -set-forth in-view of the addi-
- tional facts and law presented to the Court. .
It is, therefore, ORIVERED, that the order of this
Court entered herein on February 5 d, 1970 be and the
"same is hereby vacated. '
The Court also has hefore it a intotion by plaintiffs
to consolidate cause No. 68 C 1666 with cause No. 68 C
956 on the ground that the two actions involve a com-
mon question of law and fact. Said motion was filed -
_ September 6, 1968, briefed and argued before the three-
* judge court on November 4; 1968. The Court reserved
its ruling on same. The Supreme Court of the United
_States consolidated these cases for hearing and it is
“the opinion of this Court that ‘the plaintiffs’ mofion
to consolidate should now be granted.
)
om
‘.
.
ha OS tlt ae Li Tite AM
a
; 11 |
‘It is, therefore, ORDERED that cause No, 68°C -
, 956 and cause No, 68 C 1666 be and they are hereby
‘consolidated.
The Court-is of the opinion that it is equitable and
in the best interest of the general public to maintain |
the status quo which existed on ‘September 6, 1968 un-
til further determination of these causes, as was orig-
inally done by entry of a restraining order in case
No. 68 C 1666 by Judge Edwin A. Robson on that:
"* date, immediately after fhe filing of this suit, and —
which restraining order against discontinuance of “the
“Hummingbird” trains by the L&N was continved in
full force and effect on September 12, 1968 by Judge
Joseph Sam Perry. The temporary, restraining order
was heretofore dissolved by the Court in its order of
January 8, 1969 granting the motion of LEN to’:
slismiss. ’
Plaintiffs and intervening plaintiffs gllege-in their-
_ memorandum, filed February 16, 1970, that the L&N
promised “restoration of the train service to the Cir-
cuit Justice” and that allegation has not been denied.
The Court finds that the LEN, in its Memoranduin
in opposition to application to stay, represented to the
Circuit Fae ‘on January 10, 1969 the ‘following :
, petitioners will ‘have full right to pursue
theit statutory appeal to this Court, and if this |
Court should determine, upon full considera-
. tion, that the question of the o ration of the
trains should he ¢xamined by the Court below
the respondent railroad company will be fully
answerable. In other words, the respondent rail-
road company will promptly resume the opera--
tion of the trains if required to do so by law-
to the Application to Stay, p. 8)
The LEN also submitted to this three-judge court at
the September 12, 1968 hearing an affidavit stating:
ful order.”’ (L&N: Memorandun in Opposition - |
“Trains Nos. 6-and 7 can: be put back in, op-
- eration within a matter of less than twenty- |.
four hours upon the dissohition of. the court’s
order, since none of the equipment that is used |
in- operating ‘these trains will now be. disposed
of, and it will be kept in operating condition.’
(Affidavit of Fack Small, 9/10/68, pp. 1-2)*-:.
Defendants United States of America and T.C.C. —
have not interposed. any, objection to the motion of
plaintiffs and intervening plaintiffs for, reinstatement
of the aforesaid restraining order against the L&N. -
- The Court finds thatim a recent (December 3, 1969) —
“the 1.C.C., 336 T.C.C. at 85, the Commis: -
decisi
sion states i:
“In Missouri Pac. R. Co—Control—Clicago
“& ELR. Co., 327 1.C.C. 279 (1965), sustained .
sub.nom. Illinois Central Railroad Company V.
United States, 263. F. Supp. 421,‘affirmed per .
curiam 385 US. 457 (1967), C&ET’s’ Chicago- |
Evansville line was awarded to L&N rather -
. than Illinois Central one of theeémportant con- °
siderations in fie Commission’s determination
being thc anticipated maintenance and improve- -
ment. of through passenger service between Chi-
| cago and the South via the CHa&ET ‘and L&d:N
route...” (Emphasis supplied) |
The Illinois Central Railroad continues to run
trains to and from the South and so should the LAN
continue to_operate the “Hummingbird” trains-pend- —
ing final determination herein.
The Court-finds that the 1.C.C. is without. jurts- -
‘diction to order interim relief beyond a four month
period in connection with the. ‘Hummingbird”’ trains
pending the Commission’s further proceedings herein.
The Court itself does haye jurisdiction to reinstate
operation of the “Hummingbird”’ trains’ pending the
‘opimission’s further proceedjngs herein. Ne
? $
.
+
.
sy
“13
‘Tt is, ale tgeie ORDERED that the yestraining -
‘order entered herein on September 6, “1968; ‘and con-
tinued September 12, 1968, be and the same is’ hereby
reinstated to become effective within ten (Up) days. of .
the date of this order. ae
‘The three-judge court also is of the. opinion that
the I.C.C. should also reopen its investigations in ~
the matter of the “Geol ‘ian’? trains (Chicago-Evans--
ville) invelyed in case No. 68 C 956, with- ‘due. am
proper notice to’ all parties in interest, and that
-the matters involved. in ‘cases 68.C ‘956. and 68 C '
< 1666. should be consolidated by the L€.C, in further
- proceedings.
The Court finds ‘that in the. proc sodings het ore the —
—“L.|e. yelating*to the discontinuance. of .the C&EI’s
fe Feorgian”’ trains the public did not rec eive adequate ,
notice from the railroads or of the J. C.C. proceedings;
and, further, although’ the residents of the States of.
Kentucky, ‘Tennessee and-Geor ela were vitally inter- °°
ested in continued. through — passenger service by the _
railroads and the respective governors of those States
were entitled to notice of the proceedings: before the
‘L.C.C., no notice was given them beforehand.
The Court is of the view that through passenger
service from Chicago’to and throughout the South-
’ eastern’ part of the United States might or could be’
vital to the general. public interest _and that such wi
ese ‘service Is. so interwoven and ‘entwined between the
various railroads that only in a consolidated proe eed-.
- ing can a just and fair décision be reached. x
- It is, therefore, ORDERED that the- sadiciie ‘of: oe
_L.C.C. in its Finance Docket Nos. 24725, and 25047,
so far as such orders discontinue the respective’ in-
vestigations, be and they hereby_are -vacated_and that
both causes numbered 68 C 956 and 68 C 1666 he and
they hereby are remanded to the LC.C. and consoli-
Re . tae ae Pal Tis
ae, sepreocacrzete: Ltn a sesscaiecad? " rz AERIS . ~e ae oy panne
< ¥-
; dated for. further ‘proceedings: in accordance with the es
statutes: so made and provided.
The Court enters the abov Po in conformity
with the opifiion of the Supreme Court of the United
: States and for the purpose ‘of earrying. out the ate :
preme Courtis mandate. Re.
a ae ee ie (S 3) WIN G. Kor, ;
oe eee _ Circuit Judge. eae
| fees “4¢S) J: Sam: PERRY, ses ee
: oN RR aR aly ORIN, dary ve District Judge. .
fra ire a (8 Y: -Epw IN A. Rosson,
ee anne : wsstrict 1809.
eau: Tsaxors, March 19, 1970.
: / Se ee ar
. a Tae j
3 % | © < ,
+_— at . —
ae
A
q : \ é
3 ‘. ?
rd
"In the United States District Court for the Northern.
.@ ;
» District of. Illinois sr Division
. : . P ; l. os ;
Civil Action No. 68° C © 1666
‘TeNNEssEE Pustic SERVICE. Commasito%, # ET Alu,
“ee ¢ PLAINTIFFS, :
° ° iy v. .
_ Com MISSION, DEFENDANTS. —
APPENINX Bo es)
a Unirep Staves or AMERICK AND Ieiaonare Ne
Nowak OF “APPEAL TO THE is ceeesie CourRT OF THE = -
-UNyrEp States: BY THE UNITED- STATES OF AMERICA.
i
Court of the United States from the judgment entered
arch 19; 1970, ‘setting aside orders of the Interstate
Commerce Commission entered 1 in Finance Docket No.
ene
the Rules of ‘the Supreme Court of the United stain
the Clerk of this Court is hereby requested to certify
the entire record 1 in this. cause and provide for is
3 (15) : poe
,
Notice. is hereby given that the United States of :
America, a defendant herein, appeals to the Supreme
i BA arcs
& =
ar
/
\
esr e j- Ueno tain See Department of Justice, a9)
tee L John H. D. ripe, one of the attorneys for - ;
-fendant* United States of - America, appellant hereil
- follows:
\
2. 16 / ; 4 : : : j i =
ission..to | the Clerk of the Supreme Court ‘of
the Un cd States. | one
‘Ricwarp W. Mc LAREN,”
Assiabent Attorney General.
| aa * Tuomas -A. Foran, : p
/ oe — United States Attorney,
= JOuN H. D: Wicarr,
9 Ree enna Sa peer rere Attorney,
cf - Chicago, Minois 60604. -
a Washington, D.C. 20530. :
Attorne ys for the United States Ot Americ a,
PROOF OF SERVICE |
Ls
\
and a member of the. Bar of the Supreme Court of
the [*nitgd States, hereby certify that on ‘the 15th day .
of May, 1970, served-coptes oft the foresome Notive —
of Appeal on the several cap ape to this - action ips ay
‘1, On ‘the plaintiffs hérein, by mailing copies in duly 7
addr éssed envelopes, to attorneys of record as follows;
ae.
With air mail postage pr epaid to Wendell Ww.
Wright, ‘Esq:, and. Marion E. Wright, Esq.,
106. } North Vermilion Street, Danville, Tlinois
. 61832; William E. Nelson; Ksq., Dyer Building, .
Hoopeston, Illinois 60942; Robert P. Doolittle, Ae
Jr, Esq., 801 Busseron Street, Vincennes, Indi-
ana 47591; Eugene W. Ward, Esq., Cordell Hull
-, Building, Nashville, Tennessee 37219; Richard .
'L. Curry, Esq. and, Bernard Rane, Esq., 511
‘City: Hall, Chicago, Illinois 60602; Neil], ‘Ss.
Brown, Esq. and Rohert &. Kendrick, Esq., 204.
Metropolitan Céurthouse’ Building; Nashville,
Tennessee ; oe B. ia chat 17 Harding:
i
| | Rene a [- 17 er | | :
Goria Fe et ons, seg T faute, Fndiana 47801 ; and Keith ©
ras eee Sy BE. Roberts,/ Esq., 120 South LaSalle Street: -
. a f | I “ Chicago, Tllinois 60603. , < | —— a
tp: |, 2 On. the intervening plaintiffs by mailing copies
; in duly addréssed: gnvelopes to their attorneys of rec-
_ lord as follows: a eS fe =
.
With, air mail postage prepaid to" William F.
. Black, State Office Building, Montgomery, Ala-
bama 36102; Anthony Haswell, Esq., 2517 N.
RRS Fe eae eee Burling, Chicago, ‘Hlinois 60614; Weldon A.
ae is \. , S. -23-Cousins, Esq.; 737 National Bank of Com- —
| ee rae _ merce, New Orleans, Louisiana 701125 Chester —
| - LL, Rigsby, Esq, Kentucky. Railroad Commis-
\; . . “sion; State Office* Building, Frankfort, Ken~
eines “tucky 40601; Robert S. Matthews, Esq., 1018.
Wit ee Southern Securities Building, Evansville, Indi-
CAE ~ ana 47708; and Bennett E. Smith, Esq., Assist- -
- ‘ant Attorney General, State of Mississippi,
~—~~State Office Building, Jackson, Mississipp1 ,
39201; Leon M. Despres, Esq., 77-W. Wash-
wf ad st Oy Chicago, Illinois 40602; Henry C. Neel,, °-
o. Esq., Foran Credit Building, Henderson, Ken- -:
2: tucky 42420; Sheldon A. Taft, Esq., 111 N-
High .Street, Columpus, Ohio 43215; J: Robert
' Coleman, Esq., 132 State’ Judicial Building,
* Atlanta, Georgia 30334;'and Carl E. VanDorn, ©
Ksq., 807 State’ Office Building, Indianapolis, .°
fndiana 46204. i mont
With first-class mail postage prepaid to Gor-
don P. MacDougall; Esq.,°705 Ring Building, |
_ Washirigton,’ D.C. 20036 and William B..Ma- /—
honey, Esq., 620 Tower Building, Washington,
— 7.6. 20005. Porgy.” A dite he
3. On the intervening defendant by mailing copies
a 4
398-035—70-——3
r
<>
' * MISSION
Qe 18 °
in duly addressed env elopes to his attorneys of record
as follows:
With air mail postage prepaid to ‘Albert E. -:
Jemer, Jr., Esq. and Keith F. Bode, Esq., 135
South LaSalle Street, Chicago, Illinois 60603;
and Harry R. Begley, Esq., 72 West Adains-
’ Street, Chicago, Illinois 60603.
4. On def¢ndant Interstate Commerce Commission
by mailing copies with first-class postage prepaid to
Robert W. Ginnane, General Counsel, and Jerome
Nelson, Attorney, Interstate Commeree Commission,
Washington, D.C. 20423.
Joun H. D. Ww IGGER,
~ ‘Attorney,
Pe. “. / Department of Justice,
: Washington, D.C. 20530.
. (Filed, May 18, 1970,), 5» «°° fs
, in The United States District Court For The North-
we ern District of Hlinois Fastéfn Division
Civil Action, No. 68 C 1666
Tennessee Pusiic Service Comission, ET Al..,
PLAINTIFFS
v..,
Unirep Srares or America anp Interstate Com-
merce. Cox pIoN, DEFENDANTS
g ~ <i: . .
Notice or Apreat, 10 THE Supreme Court oF. THE
Unirep Staves sy tHe Lyterstate Commerce Com-
L
oa”
Notice is hereby given that the Interstate Commerce Y
‘
ie
.
ig
Commissior?, a defendant herein, appeals to the Su-
preme Court of the United States from the judgyient
entered March ‘19, 1970, setting aside orders of the
Interstate Commerce Commission entered in Finange
Docket No. 25047.
ul.
In accordance with the provisions of Rule 12 of the
Rules of the Supreme Gturt of the United States, the
Clerk of this Court is hereby requested to certify the
_entire record in this cause afd provide for its trans-
missionto the Clerk of the-Supretnhe Court of: the
United States.
~ Roper W. Gixnane,
General Counsel,
JEROME NEISON, ,
- | Attorney,
| Interstate Commerce Commission,
Washington, D.C. 20423.
Proor or Skéxvicr.
$
I, Jerome Nelson, one of the attorneys for defend- ‘
ant Interstate Commerce Commission, appellant here-
‘in, and a member of the Bar of the Supreme Court ;
of the United States hereby certify that on the 12th
day o# May, 1970, I served copigs of. the foregoing
_ Notice of Appeal on the several ir se to this action
as. follows: :
1. On the plaintiffs Hrein, by naling’ copies in
duly addressed cartlepes to attorneys of rgeare as
follows:
With air mail postage prepaid to Wendell
W. Wright, Esq. and Marion E. Wright, Esq.,
106 North Vermilion Street, Danville, Illinois
61832; William E. Nelson, Esq., Dyer Build-
ing, Hoopeston, Ilinois 60942 ; + Hobert P. Deo- .
es
_ 2
little, Jr, Msq.2 801) Busseron Strect, Vin-
cennes, Indiana 47591; Eugene W. Ward, lsq.,
Cordell Hull Building, Nashville, Tennessee
87219; wy L. Curry, Ksq. and Bernard
Brome Sage iS. Brown, Esq. and Robert F:
Kendrick, ‘Kin: 204 Metropolitan ComThouse
suilding, Nashville, Tennessee; Geors we WS.
Tofaute, Esq, 17° Harding Avenue, Terre
Haute, Indiana 47801 f-and Keith KE. Roberts,
Esty., 120 Sonth LaSalle Street, Chicazo, I1-
ois 60605.
2; On the intervening plaint! ffs boy matting. copies
‘in duly addressed envelopes totheir attorneys of ree-
ord as fojlows:
*
With air mail postage prepaid to William FP.
Black, State Office Building, Montgomery, Ala-
bama 36102; Anthony Haswell, Esq. 2517 N.
Burling,. Chicago, [linois “60614; Weldon A..
Cousins, Exq., 737 National Bank of Commerce,
New Orleatis; (ouisiana ‘70112; Chester L:
Rigsby, Esq., Kentucky. Railroad Commission,
State Office Building, Frankfort, Kentucky
40601; Robert S. Mafthews, Esq., 1018 South-
ern Securities Building, Evansville, Indiana
47708: and Bennett E. Smith, Esq., Assistant
Attorney General, State of Mississippi, State
Office’ Building, Jackson, Mississippi 39201;
Leon M.,Despres, Esq., 77 W. ‘Washington,
Chicago, Tilinois 60602; Henry @. Neel, Esq:,
Foran Credit Building, Henderson, Kentucky
42426; Sheldon <A. aan. 2 N. High.
Street, Columbus; Ohio 43215; J. Robert Cole-
man, Esq.,.132 State Judicial Building, At-
lanta, Georgia 30334: and Carl E. VanDorn,
Rane, ee City Hall, Chicago, [Hinois :
21
Kxq., 807 State Office Building, Indianapolis,
Indiana 46204. | ;
With first class mail postage prepaid te
Gordon P. MacDougall, Esq., 705 Ring Build-
ing, Washington, D.C. 20036 and’ William B.
Mahoney, Esq., 620 Tower Building, Washing-
ton, J.C, 20005, 7
% Ou the intervening defendant. by mailing. copies
in duly addressed, envelopes to his attorneys of record
as follows: . |
With air mail. postage prepaid to Albert BK. ¢
Jenner, Jr, Esq. and Keith F. Bode, Fsi., ae
" South LaSalle Street, Chicago, [inois 606083 ;
and Hatry R. Begley, Esq., 72 West Adams
‘Street, Chicago, [lineis 6060°.
4. On defendant United States of America by mail-
ing copies with first-class postage prepaid to the Hon-
‘erable Erwiti Ni Griswold, Solicitor G neral of the
United States, Department of Justice; Washington, -
D.C. 20530; to the Honorable Thomas A. Foran,
United States Attorney, Chicago, J}linois 60604; to.
the Honorable, Richard W. McLaren, Assistant °At-
torney General ofthe United States and the Honor;
~. able John H. D. Wigger, Attorney, Department of.
Jiistice, Washington, D.C, 20530.
eer ‘ Jenone Newson, /
. Attorney,
TiPerstate Contmerce Commission.
[Filed May 14, 1970.]
oO ;
ee APPENDIX C .
‘Finance Docker No. 25047
__ LOUISVILLE AND ‘NASHVILLE RAILROAD
—COMPANY: DISCONTINUANCE OF TRAINS
NOS. 6 AND 7 BETWEEN NEW ORLEANS, _
2 ‘LA., AND CINCINNATI, OHIO. eee
a ietoeetiee
*
Decided September 3, 1968
Upon invéstigation, found’ that the continuance ‘of
operation by the Louisville and Nashville Railroad
Company of its passenger trains Nos. 6 and 7 be-
ttveen New Orleans, La., and Cincinnati, Ohio, is’
‘not required by -public convenience and necessity
and that the continued operation thereof will un-
duly burden interstate commerce. Investigation
cs diseontinned.
Clifford T: -Coomes, Charles B. yee IT:
-, Thomas S. Lawson, Jr., James E. Simpson, David M. —
’ Keeble, and’ Robert T. McConaughy for the Louis-
ville and Nashville Railroad Company.
Weldon” A. Cousins, Langdon D. Bell, Nat K.
Knight, Bennett E. Smith, ‘Robert A. Jones, Eugene
..W. Ward, James Kenneth Atkins, and Chester, L.
.
ial
Med Pole
* Rigsby for regulatory agencies of the States of Loui-
‘siana, . Mississippi, Alabama, Tennessee, Kentucky,
and Ohio, protestants. .
Louis A. Schwartz, Lawrence F. ‘ Daspit, Horace.
Perry, William .A. Thompson, Robert E. Kendrick,
Rom MeGrath, Raymond F. Simon, and Bernard.
Rane for protestants.
(22)
23
S. F. Walker, F. T. Edwards, Olin’ B. Brooks, Les-
lie Stiflemiré, P. A. Young, Clifford H. Rex, Joe
Hester, Henry E. Risner, John B. Mullins, Jr., J. W.
Faust, J. G. Griffin, Alex E. Little, Harry T. ‘Smith,
W. R: Selby, A. L. Shepherd, and Robert C. ‘Tyler
‘for P railway-! labor. organizations; protestants. —
Reporr OF THE ComMIssion
Division 3, ComMissioners TuccLe, Busn,
AND DEASON
Tu cal &, Commissioner: °
‘Pursuant to the provisions of scttion 13a(1) of the
Interstate Commerce Act, the Louisville and N ash-
ville Railroad Company (L&N),. a common carrier -
by railroad subject t6 the provisions of part I of the
act, filed a notice and statement on April 3, 1968, in —
wliich it proposed to discontinue, effective May 7, 1968,
- the operation of its passenger trains Nos. 6 and 7 op-
erating between New Orleans, La., and Cincinnati, -
_ Ohio, a distance of 927 miles. Copies of the notice were
served and posted in the manner prescribed by section
_13a(1)_of the_act-and_related—rules-and--regulations.
Upon receipt Of numerous’ petitions and letters. of. .
protest, an investigation of the proposed discontinu-
ance of service was instituted by our order dated
April 24, 1968, which required continyed operation of
the trains for a period not: exceeding 4°months beyond.
the date when the discontinuance would have become
effective. Because of the statutory limitation upon the —
time availablé for investigation. and decision, the order
provided for the omission of a report and recom-
- Inended order by the hearing examiner. and for
certification of the record to-us for initial decision.
Hearings were held at New Orleans, La., Mobile,
Montgomery, and ES Ala., Nashville, Tenn., .
/
—~- - =~
a ee
rs
Louisville, Ky., and Cincinnati, Ohio. Briefs ‘have
been filed.
The trains.—YVrain No. 6 operates northbound daily
from New Or leans to Cincinnati departing New Or-
leans 8:15 a.m.’and arriving Cincinnati 8:10 a.m. the
next merning. Train No. 7 operates southbound daily.
‘from Cincinnati departing Cincinnati 7:40 p.m. and .
arriving New Orleans 8:10 p.m. the next evening. The
schedule of the trains, the points served, and their
populations are set forth in appendix A.
Train consists and crews.—The regular. consist of
northbound train No. 6 is one doulile-unit diesel loco-
motive, one coach, one sleeping car, and one baggage-———
express car, New Orleans to Cincinnati, daily.; one
. dining car, New Orleans to - Nashville, daily; one
dormitory car, Montgomery to. Nashville, daily ; one. —
coach, Montgomery to Louisville, 3 days a week; from
one to four express cars, Nashville to Cincinnati, 4
days a w eek; one ‘storage-mail ear, Louisville to Cin-
cinnati, 4 days a w ek
Louisville to Cinemnati, 3 days a week: °
the regular consist of southbound train No. 7 is one
double-unit diesel locomotive, one coach, and one
‘sleeping car, Cincinnati to New Orleans, daily ; one or
more express cars, Cincinnati to, Louisville, at irregu-.
lar intervals; one storage-mail ear, Cincinnati to
Nashville, daily; one baggage-mail ear, ‘Cincinnati to
Montgomery, daily’: one mail-express car, Louisville.
to Nashville, 6 days a week; one express car Louis-
ville to Nashville, 3 days a Week; one coach, Loujsville
to Montgomery, 3 days a week; one dining car, Nash-
ville to New Orleans, daily; one dormitory car, Nash-
ville to -Montgomery, daily; one storage-mail car,
Nashville to New Orleans, 5 days a week; one storage-
mail car, one bageage- -mail ear, and one coach, mont.
gomery to New Orleans, daily.
; and one mail-express car,
s
25
The equipment is deséribed’ as modern and well |
‘maintained and ‘the. passenger cars are the newest
owned by the carrier. The locomotive equipment would
he retired and the car equipment transferred to other
trains as replacements of older equipment. | -
Train No. 6 employs 6 engineers, 6 firemen, 5 con-
ductors, 5 flagmen, 2 haggagemen, 2 coach attendants,
3 dining car employees and’a pullman porter for a
total of 30 crew members. Train No.:7 employs the
same number of employ ees in eac h of-the ‘same cate-
—gories except, t tess conductor for al total ‘of “29 crew
- members.
~~ Other persons required for the ne of the
trains include:station and terminal employees who sell -
tickets, operators and dispatchers chargéd with actual
operation of .the trains, yard-crews .who form the
-trainsjand work on train equipment, car department
cnployeés who inspect, maiitain, and clean the car
equipment, and. mechanical he Ie who maintain
' the required motor power. ‘
One position in each pullman car would be elimi-
~ nated; the personnel involved-are not employees of —
carrier.
Following the proposed dise ontinuance, the on-train
crews would be employed’ in other services; they all
‘maintain freight seniority and could be used in freight
related positions. Those with insufficient -seniority
might be assigned to extra boards. |
Use of passenger service.—In the respective periods
.of 1966, 1967, and 1968 (the last, annuahzed on the
basis of data for February 1 to April 30, 1968), the
passenger ‘miles of the trains were 52,848,271, 48,668,-
| 491, and 22,035,336. In the respective periods of. No-, .’
vember and Pecasbes - 1967, January, Februayw,
March, and April 1968, the average number of pas-
sengers per train-mile on train No. 6 was 47, 82.6,
.
.
cw iain a sigetic des Boe tee 8
.
;
ae a
+ Bad, 30.4, 96.4, and 35.7. During the same periods the
average number of passengers per train-mile on train _
No. 7 was 43.3, 85.4, 50.7, 30.9, 31, and 34.3. at
Appendix B reflects the daily average oR" and,
“off” counts at all stations between New Orleans and
Cincinnati for a 6-month period November 1, 1967 to.
April. 30, 1968. The symbols (OC) and (L&N byd)
refer to passengers transferring from other railroads
‘and passengers transferring to other L&N trains. On
‘
train. No. .6, the: only intermedidte points having an
average of 8 or more passengers per ‘day ‘‘on” or ;
‘‘off” were Pascagoula (10), Mobile (15), Montgomery
(24), Biaminghain (25), Decatur (8), Nashville (32),
and Louisville (12). On. train No. 7 the only inter- —
mediate points having a- daily average of 7 or more
\ wefe Louisville (20), Bowling Green (15), Nashville
(30), Decatur (7), Birmingham (22), Montgomery
(20), and Mobile (17). : : de
Alternate transportation.—In addition to the trains
proposed for discontinuance, . L&N operates daily °
trains Nos. 8 and 9 (the Pan Américan) between New
~. Orleans and Cincinnati, serving the same intermediate
‘points, except Rigolets, La., a conditional ‘stop on . ©
train No. 7. Train No. 8-departs New Orleans at 8:45 *
p.m., as compared with train No, 6's morning depar-
ture, and arrives Cincinnati at 9:30 p.m.; the follow- —
ing evening. Train No. 9 departs. Cincinnati 9:15 a.m., ©
as compared with’ train No. 7’s evening departure,
and arrives New Orleans 7:55 am., the following
morning. L&N also opérates trains Nos. 15 and 16 (the
. South Wind) every other day, between Louisville and
Montgomery, serving the same inte@mediate points as
its other four trains. In connection with the Penn
Central Railroad+and the Seaboard Coast Line Rail--
-‘yoad,: the South Wind provides through service be-
tween Chicago, Ill., and certain Florida points, in-
get
2
27
| ‘biden Miami and St. Petersburg. riseiihs service
would remain between New Orleans and Atlanta, Ga.,
by change of schedule by the Atlanta and. West Point -.
Railroad (A&WP) between Atlanta and Montgomery,
the latter an interchange point with the L&N, where- |
by A&W P would connect with L&EN train No.9 rather
than with L&N No. 7 as at present. -
All L&N stations here involyed, except Rigolets,
have direct daily bus service between New Orleans rs
and Cincinnati. There are as many as 21 bus sched-
. ules between the various. points, depending upon the
ulations. -
rice_is ivailablo between
_ Cincinnati, Louisville, Bowling Green, Nashville, Bir-
mingham, Montgomery, Mobile, Paseagoula, Gulfport,
Biloxi, and New Orleans. ’ .
Official highway maps.of the States involved herein .
— .indicate numerous combinations of Federal highways
including’ several segments: of. the interstate @ystem .
hetween New' Orleans and Cincinnati and the princi-
-pal initermediate points served by: the trains.
Financial data.—The carrier’s balance sheet. as of
~ March 31, 1968, shows assets of $1,003 million, includ-
ing current assets, of $97.4 million, ‘special funds $4.3
million, investments $34.8 million, total properties less -
“yveserves for depreciation and amortization $857.3 mil-
lion, and other assets and deferred charges $9.1 mil-
lion. Liabilities were: Current $53.6 million ; Jong-term >
debt, due within 1 year, $27.7 million; long-term debt,
due after 1 year, $407.8 million ; reserves $5.8 million ;
. other liabilities and deferred ‘credits $16.6 million; .
capital stock $123.9 million ; capital surplus $22.1 mil-.
lion; and retained income unappropriated $345.4 mil- ,
lion. L&N’s income statements for the years 1966, 1967, °.
and the first 3 months of 1968, show, respectively, rail-
A way = revenues. of $292. 2 — $285.3 mil-.
e
be "
Ba a
'
raven Mave en
SRE SPO re)
RYE ne ter eran
po men cere
a
a
seemed to adlenanns Drone roe to 6
p
7 4 .
- ae 28
lion, and $7: 35 million; net railway oper ‘ating: income
$38.2 ‘million, . $31.4 million, and $6.6 million; net in-
come after fixed charges and other deductions $28.5
million, $19.9 million, and $4.9 million, — : :
. The earrier’s‘exhibits and testimony, as revised, de- 3
pieting revenues, expenses, -and out-of-poe ‘ket Sonses~
pertaining to the operation of the trains indicate net
-_ losses in 1966, 1967, and-the first 4 months of 1968, of oe
$9,318, $505,361, and $309,461, respectively. :'The esti-
mated net loss for 1968, hased. on the month of April.
1968, is $909,667. Net. annual ‘savings to the earrier,
‘ayatemwi ise, upon discontinuance of the trains, are esti-
mated to be $1,610,473. Apperidix C reflects the actual
revenues and expenses for the vear 1967 and the first
4, nionths of: 1968 in the first and second columns. The
third colunin reflects the revenues and expenses for
the vear 1968 based upon the. operating results for the
month of April 1968, Column four reflects an estininte
‘of the reyenues that would be refained on other L&N
trains and the’ ndded expenses of handling the traffic’
on other trains. Column five is an estimate of revennes.
that would he lost and the expenses to he saved by
handling the.traffie on other trains, should the dis- .
continuance of trains Nos. 6 and 7 be approved,
The revenuesand costs,‘as set forth in appendix C,
were computed by the earrier in, accordance with gen-
erally accepted methods pr eviously approved: by the
Commission as appropriate in’ train discontinuance
cases and are not under dispute.. +
The operating expenses for 1966, 1967, the first 4
months of 1968, and the. projection for the year 1968.
were shown on an out-of-pocket basis. Wages of train-
erews and enginecrews are the actual wages paid the
‘crews, increased. for the appropriate payroll taxes,
_meals, lodging, vacation, holiday, and health and wel-
“fare allowances, Locomotive fuel, water, lubricants and
-
Cec ae At A NM Mn Ban
\ ;
‘ \ ’
os ' \ soe ’ \ 4
, | maa
eather supplies, locomotive depreciation; \and personal i a
vinjury gnd. livestuck damage, aré on system ‘averages~ ht
-with appropriate allocations. to these trains according ©
to the actual units involved. Dining expenses is. the
actual cost incurred and. ‘pullman deficits’ are the’
amounts billed by the Pullman Compi “ee Wie
- Locomotive repairs and enginehour expenses are
hased on system average unit costs applied to the
number of units involved in these trains, decreased
by 21 percent for overhead costs: which. inélude: such
items as labor costs and maintenance of facilities which
~ would remain. constant even thoughgtrains, Nos. 6 and
7 were discontinued, | Roa nae }
Car repairs ,and train’ supplies. and expenses are
similarly determined and subjectedto a’21-percent
decréase for overhead, costs angky elimination of the
costs for’ deadhead cars on tins Nos. 6-and 7.’ Car
dépreciation and. cost for“rental of: passenger cars
were adjusted to climinate.deadhead equipment. -
The joint terminal expenses shown to be avoidable
as a result of. the discontinuance were computed in,
the manner-approved by the: Commission in Chicago,
RT. & P.R. Co. Discontinuance of Trains, 328 1.C.C.
978, 286. They include. only the. amount by which the.
carrier’s share of. the: total: expenses would be. di-
“minished by virtue of its lesser use of the terminals.
The.costs shown ‘as- savable do not include amounts
attributable to deadhead equipment carried on trains
‘Nos. 6 and 7 in and out of the terminals.. ea
— Evidence in opposition.—Thirty-nine public wit-
nesses appeard at hearings in opposition to the dis-—
continuance of the trains of whom 6 appeared at New
Orleans, 9 at Montgomery, 16 at Birmingham, 6° at
~ Nashville, and 2 at: Louisville. No public witnesses
appeared at Mobile or Gincinnati. par
“Among those expressing” opposition weré represent-.
. ;
on i ‘ ; ee?
‘- ‘ . * ” ‘ ° ‘i
n
pee Qe oe —— ed ry
*
2 on
lot D---.
atives of United States ‘Congressmen, a representative .
of e Governor of Alabama, a State legislator,
members representatives of the Public Service
Communi. of, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and
Tennessee, a member of the Kentucky Railroad Com-
mission, mayors, city and county officials, a sepre-
sentative of a college, a mortician, carrier employees,
a pullman porter, and members of the public. Of the —
total witnesses, 14 were past and prospective. patrons: “°
of the trains,
Public officials opposed the disc -ontinuance of the
trains onthe stated ground that the economy and the
industrial growth in the area is dependent upon con-
tinued service by all means of transportation, and par-
ticularly rail passenger service. They were also. con-
cerned with the general disappearance of passenger
trains through dise vontinnances and the likelihood that .
all rail passenger service may become extinct. They,
regular passengers, and others contend that alternate
trapsportation services are not adequate.
enerally the passenger witnesses testified ‘that at
fimes there weré equipment failures, that on time
“performances were poor, that overcrowding, particn-
larly on weekends and holidays, had oceurred,.and
that the employees were not as courteous as those of
other common carriers. Criticism was also directed to
a lack of advertising by the carrier. On the other
hind, severm of the pateins praised the carrier as
' being first class as compared with other railroads, All
of such witnesses were desirous of having the trasns
for their future usé‘and most preferred ‘rail _trahs-
‘ Porfation to bus travel and-some indented Tear
of air trayel. Saag
; “Discvssox axp Coxciustoxs :
nee factors to be considered in Pater ve
— under section 13a (1) of the act to ascertain whether ;
a
? bee 31 ‘ae
operation. of the passenger trains is required for the
public convenience and necessity and will not unduly —
burden interstate commerce are the population served,
- thé effect on the communities on their route, the ex-
tent of the use mnde by the public of the service
sought to be discontinued, alternate transportation . .
service available in the area, the costs incurred and
financial losses sustained by the carrier in providing
the service under consideration, and the carrier's
; financial‘ condition. No-one of such factors-by itself
is conclusive or controlling. The burden imposed upon
the carrier and upon intérstate commerce must be —
weighed against the need for the service. It is possible
that the need for the service under certain circum-
stances may be so great as te waryant its continuation
even at a loss to the carrier. ‘This could Arise where
the loss of the service would inflict serious injury on
the communities, while continuance of the service |
would impose a relatively slight financial burden on
the earrier. The facts in this proceeding do not dis-
' lose such an overriding need for’ the continuance of
the involved trains. ee . -
_ L&N began incurring substantial losses on these
trains in 1967 ($505,361) even with mail revenues of
_ over $1 million, express revenues over $300,000, and
‘ additional ‘révenues from passengers interlined a
Evansville, Ind., with Chieago & Eastern [linois Rail-
road Co. (C&EL) trains Nos. 93 and 54 and connect-
ing with L&N’s trains Nos. 6 and 7 at Nashville, via
intermediate L&N trains Nos, 5 and 10. The C&ET.
trains were discontinued February 1, 1968, Chicago &
_E.LR. Co. Discontinuance—Chicago & Evansville,
331 L.C.C, 447. .
If the carrier were required to operate the subject
trhins for another year, it would suffer out-of-pocket
_ Josses in excess of $900,000 (computed on the basis of
32
1968 costs and revenues). Nothing in the reeord indi-
‘ eates that the deficit could be abated in future years.
In addition to the loss of connecting passengers, rail-
way post office cars have been eliminated, reducing
_mail revenues, and on April 1, 1968, railway express
- (from one to four cars daily) was diverted to truck
over the highway. - i.
The full burden of the trains can be better visual-
ized by considering the total economies attainable _
upor their discontiniance, As shown in appendix C,:
by retaining a portion of their traffie through diver-
sion to other’ L&N trains (estimated to produce
revenues of $939,500) and incurring thereon. costs
estimated at $238,700, the carrier could avoid more
than #2.3 million of its present costs and thus effect
economies in the range of $1.6 million per year. This
brings us face to face with the questién of whether —
the publie’s need for these trains is so great that the
nation’s private enterprise carrier ‘system must be
required to provide for it at an annual out-of-pocket
deficit exceeding $900,000 while foregoing the oppor-
tunity to effect economies of more than $1.6 million
per vear. Je
Before discussing this issue, we turn to a prelimi-
nary matter, raised in the briefs filed by the city of .
Chieago, Ah and the metropolitan government of ©
Nashvfe and Davidson County, Tenn., dealing with
the decision in Chicago &'E.1.R. Co. Discontinuance—
Chicago & Evansville, supra. These litigants and
others have instituted an action in the United States
* District Court for the Northern District of Illinois,
. entitled, City of Chieago, et al. v United States, et al,
to-set aside the said decision of the Commission, The
parties here ask that we request LAN to continue the
operation of trains Nos. 6 and 7 voluntarily, pending
full judicial review of the C&ETI decision, and, in the
i)
event of a refusal by LEX, that we seek a temporary
restraining order prohibiting the discontinuance. of
the trains pending full judicial review.
It is clear that pursuant to the provisions of section
18a(1) of the act, once having entered upon an in-
vestigation, we must make the statutory findings
needed either te sustain a discontinuance of the in-
vestigation, or to support an order vequiring contin-
uance of the service within the time limit prescribed
by section 13a(1). The evidence before us clearly es-
- tablishes that the operation of these trains is not re-
cnired by public convenience and necessity, that the
continned operation thereof will unduly burden inter-
state. commerce, and that the investigation should be
discontinued; and we so find. Ufider these circum-
stances we have no lawful basis for ordering a con- ie
tinnance to await (perhaps longer than a year) de-.-
velopments which, in the end, might or might not —
_ change the picture. gs eS;
The people who have heen. using the trains for
travel have done so largely on an occasional or stand-
hy basis. Their primary means of conveyance are the
automobile and other nonrail modes, The testimony
of the governmental Jeaders, business representatives,
and others is clear proof of that. Many gave opinions
about a need for rail passenger service in the interest
of ‘community and commercial growth, but few hard,
realistic facts were advanced by them in support. On -
‘the other hand, the earrier’s difector of industrial
development testified that of 1.726 new industries:
located on L&N lines in the past 8 vears, 843 were
at points that had no rail passenger service. ae
He specified .the factors that industry in general
considers in selecting a new site—mainly, availability
of such things as labor, lower wage rates, lower taxes.
utilities, freight transportation (rail, truck, air, and
i
34
—weter), economical freight rates, access. to raw ma-
terials, and cultural facilities—but availability of rail
passenger service was not.among them. He kriew of
not a single instance where rail passenger service was
even mentioned. This testimony stands uncontroverted
by the factual evidence of record. .
Even for the individual traveler who calls upon the
_ L&N for his oceasional trip, the demand for the serv-
ice of these trains is minimal, As,shown in appendix
“B, an average of but 2.4 petson¥;per day use train
No. 6 for through service, froin” New Orleans to Cin-.
Ss . s"@ ae & ar 4
<->--—“innati, and only 2 per day use train No. 7 for the
through run in the opposite direction. The same is
true for the usage to and from the ,intermediate
points: for example, from Mobile, arcity of a quarter
million, to Birmingham (popujation 325,000) there
are only 4 passengers per day, and to Nashville (pop-
ulation 250,000), only 4 per day, 7 :
Local traffie between points on the 490-mile seg-
ment between Louisville. and. Montgomery constitutes
a third of the total number of passengers—about 50.
of the approximately 150 daily average who, board
and deboard at the various points along the 927-
mile route. This area, which includes Nashvulle, will
continue to have daily service by trains Nos. 8 and 9,
the Pan American, and every-other-day service by
trains Nos. 15 and 16, the South Wind, The Pan
American will also be available for through pas-
sengers and for service at all points on the Humming-
bird schedule, Also available ‘are the six daily through
schedules each way by bus serving practically ‘all the
points on the line, numerous bus runs on segments of
the line and airline services, heretofore described.
From this record we conclude that these alternate
services are reasonably adequate to meet the public
need for common carrier transportation services. In
2 ee
the face of this conclusion, notwithstanding that some,
inconvenience to travelers smay be encountered at
times, we cannot overlook nor disregard the enormous
and ever increasing losses to the carrier. This is plain-
ly a case where there are too many trains for the .
diminishing needs of the public on this line. With
former sources of traffic and revenue unalterably
foreclosed while costs continue their upward spiral,
‘the carrier cannot be expected to continue running a
train upward of 1,000 miles each day for service along
~ the ae about 150 persons—many of whom travel
only short distances ’—while subsidizing their travel
at the rate of $14.50 out-of-pocket per passenger. ©
Shippers of express will have adequate service re-"
maining by over-the-highway truck transportation,
and by L&N trains Nos. 8 and 9. Buses operating over .
the highway also render express service.. The Post
Office Department will continue the mails, including
parcel post, to all points by use of airplanes, trucks,
and the L&N trains Nos. 8 and 9. : ;
Considering, among other things, the sparing use
now made of these long-ling trains—not only by
travelers, but also by the Post Office Department and
shippers of express—the abundance of alternate trans- ’
portation by rail and other modes, and the magnitude
of the financial burden which the carrier would have
to bear if the,trains were continued, this is precisely
the kind of circumstance for which Congress designed
‘ the relief of section 13a(1). Efforts have been made
to have the law amended, including recommendations
to. Congress by this Commission, to provide a statu-
tory plan for solutions to the passenger train prob-
lem under modified criteria. However meritorious
‘For example, of the 1.763 boarding at Pascagoula during
the 6, months covered by appendix 5, 1497 deboarded at
Mobile, 40 miles away. ~ : .
eget oe *
36
' Congress may find those ‘efforts to be, they cannot he
embraced as elements for decision of the matter now
before us, As an administrative agency. we are hound
"by the lay as it stands and must be governed by the
intendment of Congress in its enactment. ~~
Employee representatives have requested that ap-
propriate conditions be imposed for protection of
employees who, may be affected’ hy the discontinn-
ance. It is well-established that we have no authority’
to impose employee protective conditions in a seetion
13a diseontinnance case, The adverse effect of a dis-
continuance upon employees is a factor to be con-
sidered in evaluating publie convenience and neces-
sity. Having weighed such factor, we éonelude that
any possible adverse effect upon the carrier’s em-
ployeés,. when considered with all other facts dis-
cussed herein, does not justify the findings we would
have to make before we could lawfully order con-
tinued operation of the involved trains. .
Contentions of the parties as to fact or Jaw not
specifically discussed herein have heen considered and.
‘found to be without material significance or not
justified. sie 4 ae
We find that the operation by the Louisville and
Nashville Railroad Company of passenger trains Nos.
6 and 7 between New Orleans, La., and Cincinnati,
Ohio, is not required by the publie convenignee and °
necessity and. that continued operation thereof. would
unduly burden interstate commerce. ’
An appropriate order will be entered discontinuing -
the investigation herein. : —
_CoMMISSIONER Busi concurs in the result.
- ’ ‘ ’
4
© ’
ak Sr te Lge Arietta A Gite hE Oe -_
s ‘
5 >
“APPENDIX A
‘No. ’ here 0.7. ‘ opulation
(read down) ee os ” Need ap) ae a
er ee 0 Lv. New Orleans, La.....------- Ar. 8:10 p.m... 665, 000
8B0 A.M... -'------- oe eee Lv. Carrollton Avenue...-------- Ly. 7:50 p.m..---. J wcnccscelagrosere .
scapkveiebeconaxe $6 18, BGM... -nccceccocetccces WWeonconcondacontorapenencrrnree sans
era Ee 53 Lv. Waveland, Miss..-...------- LA ..2-0teoyone-n0092 1, 106 fe
9:29 a.m... - 67 Lv. Bay St. Louis..------------- Lv. 6:25 p.m. 403° . ‘
kee 72 Lv. Gulfport. .------------------ Lv. 6:00 p.m_-:.---- 33, 000 '
ee PS o- 79 Lv. Edgewater Park... Lv. 5:48 p.m -- ‘ 7
10.07 a.m. ....--- 85 Lv, Biloxi......------------=---- Ly. 5:40 p.m....-.-- 47,000 P
10:41 a.m 105 Lv. Pascagoula. - Lv. 5:10 p.m... .- ss 20, 800 4
11:25 a.M....--------- +--+" Ar. Mobile, Ala... .------- Ly. 4:15 p.m 220, 900 a
11:40 a.m 145° Lv. Mobile; Ale... --.------.---- Af- 880 D.M,-s-------07r--"- yogebnes
“A Ah BEE 169 Bay Minette........+.-...--> Lv. 305 p.m-.------ 5,197 3
12-56 pM... -<------ _.-. Ar. Flomaton....-----.- Ly. 2:20 p.m.------- 1,454 ‘
1:00 p.m_-_..- 4 205 Ly. Flomaton..-.------°-- Ar. 2:20 p.m... se
ape ge 218 Brewton..-- Lv. 153 p.m .----,-- , 6,30
rt a3 Evergreen... .- Lv. 1:24 p.m... 3, 708 7
2:29 p.m - 279 Greenville... .-..------ _ Ly. 12:53 p.m.----- 6,894
340pm-_...: Ar. Montgomery .. ‘ _. Lv. 12:05 pm 146,000
4:10 p.m 323 Lv. Montgomery... . Ar. 1030a:M.....------------------- - s
6:10 p.m. - te nee Ar. Birmingham... Lv. 8:15 a.m_.... 325,000
6:25 p.m 421 Lv. Birmingbam...-. Af. 7:45 8.M....------------ 0-00-77"
ae se $7 ~Lyv. Cullman, Ala..--. eoccece AM occccncccccesveces * 1,900
8:15p.m.......- - 506 Lv. Decatur ..--.----. auetus Deeb Lv.5608.M...-.-s-- 33,800
10:50 p.m. .---- _ Ar. Nashville, Tenn... --------- Lv. 320a.m...:..-:- 250, 837
11:45 p.m M 626 Lv! Nashville, Tenn... -- ot Ag. 2:25 ath. Te pesedaebanntannenne
1:00 a.m = _ Ar. Bowling Green, Ky---------; Lv. 12:45 a.m...-.--- 32,800
1:20a.m.. 699 Lv. Bowling Green, Ky - fo” Ae. 1220O.M.....--------2----teeee-
230 a.m. A ae Lv. Elizabethtown - ------------- Lv. 11:06 p.m..-....- 10,900
ee eee ___.. BF, Louleville.......2------------ LW: WMO PM-.----- 392,000 i!
5:00 a.m 13 Lv. Louisville. -..-----.- PSaERL "Ar. 10:45 p.m... Te semi :
7:408.1..-------- . , 922 Ly. Latonta (Covington) .------- Lv. 7:58 p.m. ------- 57,000
8:10a.m...------- » 92% Ar. Cincinnati, Ohio..----------- Lv. 7:40 p.m....--.- 495, 500 -
(37) nie
i
.
APPEN DIX. B
Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company, passengers handled on L &N Train No. 6 for 6 cine — November 1, 1967, to Apiril 30, 1968
Bay 5}. " Pasca- Floma-
Louis’ Gulfport Biloxt oui Mobile i
ee ee
wee ee eee eee eee
wee ee sgt cg sceeesssesesess
OS FOSS 6S Sc OS So OS SC UHSSSSHESSSS SH SSHSSSSSHSSSS SeSsSqesoesaseseseseossse
ee ee ee ee
eee ee eee ee
cou etn66b 6b. 0b 46666066 05 06 SUSE we Seee SeSeehawandeDa GSE Cpeese Se ne wevquesetesssseEReP FOU SESE SESE Se s SUR
SeSSeeedeccceen sacs Sqee_SsegeSecesgecesseesposseepebesesasseesonssesssoes cosas ceseposnsnesseneooss
wate ccc sees se ce cece cece seecsceeseseseessosesescesesess
cSSe SESS SOR OD6 a SSDS Op 6S S66ESS PO SESS SHEER s SOSSER OOS YES Sh ced geste sesOsaP essen sens saseseseseseses senses
ay eee. Ser Sew ° ee ee os a et
. .
}
* From On
Dhoer Qebee, Dlicccdc cccescscessics 3, 404
New Octeans (OC)........5....5...- Bso
Carvelbten A Wome <<. ccs ccc sc. e cece ec cn ccc c cece scape ceesescccccncsocess ee hand y= o
eee 275
Gulfport, Miss.............---.---+- 758
Biloxi, Miss... ..........- R..2.. 1, 083
Pascagoula, Miss... ........--.-.---- 1, 763
Wea BW von os cchactccceeveusses 2,778
; RIO, BOM. « cncaqcccencesiteeses 1,3
“_. Flomaton (L&aN byd) ape RAT a9
& Greenville, Ala:...............--- out 3
~— Montgomery, Ala................-.- 4,329
Montgomery (OC)... ..............3. vo
ee \ 4.519
Birmingham (OG)................-. 168
Cle, BG cas ticassstswncensaues 309
em Oe no vic cceccnannees 1,544
Decatur (OC).......... divevsodowetes OE OER eS
Nashville, Tenn.. . aaa 863
« "Nashville, Tenn, (L&N byd).. eeaisses 656
Bowling Green, Ky..............--- 266
Bowling Green (L&N byd) ieee hres 1,143
Elizabethtown, Ky... .”......- deeres 5
Sonbiete: Bee. ii cesdiescacceds Co ee
Lewisville (OC)... .ccevecenesssenes pa edaatiarste pba
Latenta, Ky....:............0..08-:- cassobugugsiseneqes
» Cee: Ged ccnetsctncnes wk chan ccubeencekeuen
Cincinnati (OC)... ......- a aieenbid an
Ce |
*
“% q j ‘ 4
ee ee a
oh
ee
Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company. passengers handled on L & N Train No: 6 for 6 months period, November 1, 1967, to
April 39, 1968—Continwed > * : ; ;
: Daily * patty Bir- Bir "De Nash-'Bowl- Eliza _ __ Louts- Cin- “Cin
From On ~~ aver- Off — aver ming- ming: Cull- De-— catur Nash- ville ing _beth- Louis- vitle - La- cin» cin-
: age age ham ham man _ catur (OC) ville (L&N Green town _ ville: (OC) tonia { mati
Ys “* byd) fi f.
New Orleans, La......-.--- eked 3,404.
New Orleans (OC).......-:----- aso
Carualibesl AVGER......c.eeeseseesesenssnnnesocnensssnnsnetatanersansstarssecgonspenesre rs:
Bay St. Louis, Miss. ......------ 275
Gulfport, Miss. . ....----------- 758
‘Biloxi, Miss. . ....--.----- cane 1,081
Pascagoula, Miss )..-......------ 1,763
Mobile, Ala... ndvesohace RE
Flomaton, Ala.......----- 1,033
Flomatan (L&N byd) .~ ... ----- 919
Greenville, Ala.....-.. 442
Montgomery, Ala......--------- 4,329
Montgomery (OC) -. 90
B . gphaseunsetuses 4,519
Birmingham (OC) .......------- 168
Cullman, Ala...-.-.:----------- 309
Decatur, Ala.........-.---.---:- 15M
Decatur (OC)......---+---2s--2eg2eeeeeetee eee
Nashville, Tenn.........---.--- 868
Nashville, Tenn (L&N byd)..... 656
Bowling Green, Ky.....------ <o
* Bowling Green (LAN byd).....- 1,143
5
Loulgville, Ky .....----- ieeseets ye ae
Louisville (OC) .. .2..-.-:-----+-222eeeteetrttt
Cincinnati, Ohio. ..........---- ee Salad
‘Cinstanatl (OC)...-2----.----00500020+
_ Total......- , 27,058.
Sm, Se | ; : ‘ .
*, 4 , | . c
i . 7
. a .
.
b
ee
1
7
&
w\
. - >
weds eqye* Se clayenebenmnlenlbiihe wth oats oie -_ . NX ‘ v ‘
Ae N . ’ ; 7 Y
: : : -
. : > x . e ‘
| ; ee ° ‘ : “
\ @ _ 5 »
. L ouisville and Naghvile Railroad Compan y, passenger handled on Train No. ? for 6. months period, N wana 1, 1967 through Apri 3 30,
; € '. 1906
, 2 “ Bowl- - Nash- ite Bir-
e8 t Louis- —— Louis- Eliza- Bowl- , ing Nash- ville - Deca- Deca- Cull- » Bir- ming-
From * .On .D/A*. Off D/A*. ville ville’, beth- = ing. Green Ville (L&N ° -tur tur man - ming-: ~ ham- ._
" ; Pah (OC) town * Green (L&N byd) (OC) ee. | See
. : byd) eae Fe
Cineinnat!, Ohio. -__...- oi Ec <tc uhnkat rinks Mn veh aseass 3 120 36 00CMD a et es em te (By
* Cineinnati (OC)... -.... 3,960 21.8 482° Rg ae 4 310 “285 235 175° _ 38 848 81
Latonie, Ky... 2 3: ARs carggicssocs gues it 12 1. 3 < Pawan UekghheAakN & ho MCRAE No, 2 a pieces
, Te By... RM OD OB es 161,334 516 195 413. 136 1 4 333 68
‘Louisville (OC)......-. tb. O06 MW OL. - en 1 2 10 ok one ei: ze
ences OR A WER os ehin cadens. : 26 7\: 8 espe ctivacs 6, 4:
Bowling Green, Ky..:....) 117 0.6 QI, 520 8.4 : 19 40 5 1 7 a
Bowling Green (L&N i‘ . . ° : d rs
» Pv bs Dies ac tecuisd Vink dhdiretgnia Mee 6.6 waghenunuens his DCR eR partic cece sete ee eee eee ee see eee Rie an womnied ‘oS
Nashville, Tenn:.......:.. @4.°. 28 - 816 ..48,..2.2).......: jm eee BP eaten oie eee {M4
REIAGR 8 RO) MB oh oe ee Cae, = 727 1 138-1, 661. 144
Decatur, Ala............ ee >I) a ee * eee eae te ve me 3 _ 3 10
Decatur (OC)... ..-. mew oe ‘Qt. pupal An ADU Rwabgsvewciseul aa gwked sec nkodea ge an inate nates eckreekemscnlah Coa: eedbeeaacks 2 4
Culiman, Ada.” ..........- oe es mm, 1&8. <7 sahivienaca Unbennh Men si NB iin snulduonscsabuntnacih ends shunnerpadsar ll eketensas W ecextwew
_ Birmingham, Ala......_.- 1,559. 86 3,560 19.6 : BUTS Be RBG bor eters ak age oe OL, PDR ARS POs at Ror Cee nee
Birmingham (OC)_./.-... 239 oS. ae) “Be.. : Med tac Aas EDO SS Ae ten SE ENDS Oe SEM, SRT 2S Sk ope (Cee LANE
Montgomery, Ala... ..... 1,364 . 7.5 3,601) 19.8 .....%.000.... Rass. cel BRN SSCL Rasa 6d) CRN ahh eee ara Fh ca baconcuindeekeance
Montgomery (OC)... .... °° $567." 1058 Wd ce CER cee CU RUA CK aaah aie ee kaye seueewue
NG, BNR acces | TE OS.’ SOB. BO W202... Satin nn Tig airy sia sb U eigen evening aioaar wartobanasnmeel. eaimen bck da sau uiiocsimeue ni caid be beens ie
Evergreen, Ala............ oe ae a SR 1 0 rein slpias song an Awhionn San etic an Ghana omen aek as pieatasteaeon clap hg anitemneaas faa ten udalaiie ke eis nana yi
Brewton, Ala............. 100 =0.5 "242 Petre sels maceuvcus cocuer® NE Mao srk ee neira ne G idakia ones Meda demaee ber ake eee a Lete ie eC ee nee
I iscsi icekc UE OME OR cos i ay a splbcasarth unalthine Napucy Sead cho stubeags taser genie aitaseuls <cae avalon tt ey
pn COMO Uae 95ND Ue a ca ak kre ee ae demebein nk bers nhvaiaah ceeds siecle dnbsattn ates dace ciate ERE
- Bay Minette, Ala......... ere Be AN, REED gn Enid tna hap cewbicinceesinia Madaaeede Seeolad Sit oaae ighitereatelentiab adieu cL ates coe ee
DI, Mees s kcscc. BR RG OO A ce ek Pb Nis ssnek Sepang ee iineg sens Peek Soap ean acemcmagecominnn bike tue nn ae rae
Pascagoula, Miss... ..... RT OR ca siienenn cig vd cyuplcas bie PasaeveR att gelateaikepey mene Re thence Licwgntvenantihes- - Kgluaweneowernie aabuep
i e 7 é ab .
. -« = @ » -
” a . bs
<
~ ;
.
.
.
.
° 5 . ; ft -
~ . . . . ;
. : ‘ ig . : a . - ‘
¥ al . : . .
ae sats k : . ’ . 1 ‘ 5 .
. * . . ° ae «
: M4 ° . : = . aa - ‘
i 2 . : ;.
ae . . te . Ss ©.
ee ee ee ce ieee | peer SEIS lets Ea See a savcnstameon bese Ee Redescita an etal neo a ae See: verweies
* Edgewater Park, Miss...,..,..--- obteren We Bin cddnennwewenieat ee cee EPA LGPL OAL LER LL Dt ean hw ee Cawcereceesececesenteees eo
Gulfport, Miss.....0.....: 485-24 : ; :
Bay St. Louis, Miss....... 321 1 :
Waveland, Miss,.......... ° 4. OF oe eaitte Paideaigs a “tds ia
7
Carrollton Avenue. ............-..-.----- aouenuttgvacnaqwuihis washsoagedqusgeghyedgeseuntdacgeLussedsqaonlptaponajepeinnetytebaabuen Vuxcubnenwass pa crn bageaew ena cautulin oyer
New Orleans, La..:..,-..------ Pe aE SENS ew OOS | 6 ........... wanna een e cen eeese egress egtreeseesteeees SS See DE ae oN ganeeceeecee ne eceee ete emececeesceeeeteneeesers
’ New Orleans. (OC)... ......- Picea stances 944 ee eccdediccenaswaeds iecwtaen bee Mt Beet hee A Mee Ee PR ee ee Seen rakenate RRR ery at open en tee
’ ‘ oe oe 816 - 836 ive . #& _214 3,.560 .v Sl
DP iscsi ids 27,508 151.1 27, 508 151.1 * 879 14 23 «1,520
? ; . . : out
bes 1
. $ > *
“D/A daily average » 2
: . ae ° . * . ;
- < . i . 2¥ 5
. ° bd
~
. « .
P ‘
~ ®
. s :
*.
. .
. <
. j ° ‘ 3
+ « 3
. :
. 3 a f c
\ ba ~ ° e { >
*s .
. . ‘ o 2
; f ~ .
\ 7 e :
— ' * ‘
a 2
. -
? ‘ : }
¢ * ad 5
. x
‘ . ys a .
be: . e s s
- . .
. t ..
‘ ~ > ‘
. P @* d
' ¥
? ® . , *
e * e e - 0
- & bas
; « -
,
ASOT IE APNEA YS om Bey pm mage
ite
| 2}
ied ae
| i.
o 2
ee
P 3 :
pi ae
“ a
Sl a
ie
| a8
“- ¢
ol 2 @
; 7a: jas ,&, ae) er egr on
Sane “s . ;
“ ” ”
a -7 8 ~ ror
‘ s ate <a" agers
; wmmso any | EE |
. 1 é td
- [ ; TTT Ty rol ae
WW esa E EERE ELE EE
_—— x ee
pemeeeg” oe > & $ 5% 3 9 & Sw am a DW ig
ARMEATASZERESARERE SSE
a EE i a ee = ae a -
" ay ee 18 ft jmw fegie
i ; eere ; ; 34
; wer ie hog Seu aa : ; 33
is : SERRT ; 3 34
— —_ =. >_> « —w—-— 2 sc a ~ = ~~ _—_? oe
4 . o -
> + 2 | aegis * Hye mnegge | ©
Le iy
7 Pa. fe 2 ;
, gna mmanion | Niiiiiteniit
, ; ; ; :
conus eaters ASSSE EK x ee
; [ar ine ~ege- azage- @
, ee - , “4 ‘
4 ' a ,
— lm ae a al 2 ~: ——
~ ¢ las 2 ("gs -s*age
eee { ’
¥ Te , cS
Ny ; p
(gg a7-* sgd-"geggs “a
r nf ’ ° ” 4 ‘
—— = =< Se a7 .
“* 7 ae - 5 “
; ovemet ing \* A
‘ .
—_ — a ee 2;
"| 8g 2°" 29° Bsege
‘ . ; a ")
ota nop wovemng | ; ots 7
— a: éuminen és Sea Lak
emu | 22297" ” BES “yiag°-8
. wee, 62°C :
, 3 " ; , -
i” : bd Ape cos
. ry ce
| 22°.° -E7 "9° Be: .
oe Sl ae a
, 4 . : ;
' ee. CEty Lee Sie Bee
Geeikseeg , ° § 3 ss
J : ow ‘ : »
—— oe ofieememmenemel —|~-
: pes -asa :* : “ht, B2Rs
+ mee oi oe : ’
" “ . * -
: ~ aT o2 8 is
_* -* @gi:i:397 iiss
| 490) Aammatveegs | ae Brit iaidd
_— — Eri
i P qr"s 2E2°age - “
hiemaPmoom - ; ,
= y - J 4
Pind See a -—_—— ee oo ar Ren ier ; ~ Py “\
‘ a % LZeeueeoren :
4 3 33 Be ear &: gS
o » 7 4 : ; : :
’
a 7
. © 2
7 * ——
o
+ ’
Ps
’
Meb@s, Abe. SS SSeeeceses
Pecegeels, Mie .........
. Mas
SSt ces. SSSetece
+
:*
.
Sots
+3 as
siete
se
iets “ates bed
a rer -
. .
.
.
.
>.
.
. >
>.
.
. >
. >.
5 a
, mot
. - *s ss *
.
Suess
.
a fee ee
eGo te SS ce ceSeaps Bese see essese
SS SSS SSeeeletcec ewefcececs
.
eee Seeeee)
* S St Seeeq otetecs
aseeGece
Stee cee
*
SSe wees
Sts yee
ee eee
B nccccececcesl
w eae Bee.
Ste eeec
Je qeecsiagees
e..
.
2 Seeetee sseses
—— es .
“TR WEA
SS te eeegese
ssheecdke
*.
sapestecs
"
SSeSs See cteces
BD. ncnns cevces) AS
SO. cecca tteeceue
. ; . Be . *
Sct coccece SVctat sesevehcece Scsle states bie “@reryoee eee t8eeeO.s
. : . |
’ .
ee Se. oe Ce Sle ee he oo
’ ¥ 4 :
. —_ ho ' — i : : Ms
+ : . : J
. . nce
. . = : ‘ :
. .
. >
\ . . P .
. ‘ . £ .
. \ . . : .
" e .
>. 7 >.
. . P 7 . . .
. . e e
. *
t s >. 5 . ba >.
; ; . ' . % .
. \ . .
. >.
. ~ .
. ® .
° . . . ba
‘4 : : :
. 7 .
. . .* ox . , :
. . x . e .
o. s . ° : . -
.
2 -
be .
. ° *. .
. . e*
. - . . .
. .
_
. .
“ .
“Ne Z . .
~ ; so . .
. © “* . ~~ .
. ’ > .
, . , ~ . .
~
oe Ae:
(or
12. Lacompetive depreciation .. S
13, Cor repairs... —
M. Car deprectation....... %
1. Rent fer passenger cars + .
- 2 ee ee a — ——S eee a ee ee 2 ee = ee se ee
‘APPENDIX (©
ms Progeetedt year tae ~N
Fens _— . FE —
Year? eatin tt ition Bistirmatocd
@andt e@arte eae. geetneae trates a = oe
Nee » Nes. ¢ and t
tend? . .
Sa Mears eee, Ss Sra
s) See Nee se Pe see Sl ote
om A ea Ms 24 aw
- J Ae TA 1 Ma™2 ~~
. a) ane — pabenetind
2. ._™ Ast. . ‘.- aan
= sare =e ehh ot oA Se
. : .
Tat, AR ~AS 6, No an Ne
=. “a. 7 me
A “am oa TS : ' mh
. a 11, ts Ren nay
MM. ie ua $a, @2>
“« Mee a ee
=m he BN ne 1m em
a= = IA oa aim Me
a] Ne SUNN ccunnatielemnanienchenhnch winain am
Tv! he a™ 13 4 - “aa 104, 27%
wie Am sa 3M . > caenana a
rae se ost et at 1 Men
MALY ~~ hs | Ime
Me tale “es ™. és ° roe rel_ote
th ‘
>. ; : - % = . . —
. ° ba
, tds : :
22. Decatur jolt terminal expenses... .... seasiepaiieian ., 2a ait ee) - @GRR Ts
23. Montgomery jotat terminal eapenees.. . de aM. Au™ vu : wea wes
24. New Orivans joint terminal expense... necsies 2 _ a1 née ate * - MSO
gM Bok a oc kcemadcecheeraiemes — SMe awe. a ett)
2. Net euv-pectet (ae) gan... eek ek oe ee > Seetere (6a, wt) ° Gas (a em .... .'- ———— ee ee seetee
Sn, bast euch pechet Game efter fede Gite. fe oi cccsces 6 ORD ..: SD ae SFG eet Dat Ra tee EE cael
eeeecneeqpennsuscocwocysonseesesces : notievsenvevencupsalabusbhodes psaseveceseecssccsssceiccessssencssccece: MnSOD =I BRUNO... 2, $m, Sa .
Ose snes sseneeateneees a os asec scwnigucesonecocess - . Revynase—eqneel projection. . G2, 38
. we ee ee
siheadnleaceee unre Sguplinenbveesehed ; ROE ti pe sevdiisuticdsenniae ~ Sacogs to & N, Raton a
PLS Be ae cer on ON SN mR ates Ss OEE eo SE RAEEE dasa eetadednden Low profctct der fee a
o. —--- nue gain - :
puaenenien eaeaesdsivennn uement * snnbesbndnbueaensvetesesuconenes wunnuncebesccccdesseceuccecccesscee Net annual savings to L. & N. * 1,610,473 Gre
—_ ~ — —- — = —— ;
‘ . * . .
<! “d : . >.
: ; o is .
. .*
. ° : .
Poe “ . .
. . : “es Sovennentt paumtine OFrice vere
. % * 7 .
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.