Appendix — National Bus Traffic Ass'n v. United States

Supreme Court brief1968

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

arn Bustanes, Ixo. aera : tale

|. = S slabs roe

la. .

teat a i i a

ms | APPENDIX A

; UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

_ | NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS |

“RASTER; DIVISION

679265

Meisnead Bus TRAFFIC aaieiieaiai iwc. Gxisraousp aie

- Inc. Transcontmentat Bus Svsrma, Inc., AMERICAN

"Pe Upsrrep Nii OF Abemarda ool THE Iwrenstare-

Commerce-ComMission, Defendants, - - eis oo ee

* Lous RosenBauM, d/b/a Ex Paso-Los. hsia: -

LIMOUSINE EXpREss, eee: Defendant. o:

Before “HASTINGS; Cireuit . Jude, and WILL and .

LYNCH, District Judges: |

aa Curiam. The plaintiffs seek to, vacate “mail perma-

nently enjoin a decision and order of the Interstate. €om: -

merce Commission which granted a certificate of ‘public

convenience and necesfity to Louis Rosenbaum, doing busi-

ness as El Paso-Los Angeles Limousine Express, of. El.

Paso, Texas (hereinafter referred to as Rosenbaum). The —

. certificate authorizes the operation of a limousine ‘service

&

for carrying passengers and their baggage between El Paso - ~ ;

and Los Angeles over. regular routes in nine-passenger _

vehicles, serving -no intermediate points. Rogenheum. ‘has

intervened as a defendant.

. 2 a

On J anuary 5, 1965, Rosenbaym filed: ‘an application with

the Commission for a certificate of public conyéhience and -

necessity utder Section 207 of the Interstate Commerce —

Act, 49 U.S.C. §307 (1964). The plaintiffs protested the.

- application and a hearing thereon was held on October £6, * .

1965, at El Paso, Texas, before an examiner. In his repert,

9

ao a ae he

oa |

the ¢ examiner recommended that the applicant’ he granted

the authority sought. The plaintiffs filed exceptions to the

_examiner’s report.and the applicant filed a.reply. The mat-

- ter was reviewed by the Commission and on April 28, 1966,

the Commission adopted the examiner’s report in its de-

cision and order and granted the certificate. Subsequent -

petitions by the plaintiffs for reconsideration of the matter

. have been denied and the defendants admit that the plain-

tiffs have exhausted their, administrative remedies and that, ey i

this case is therefore ripe for judicial 1 review. ©. oie:

The applicant proposes to furnish a passenger, trans-'

portation service between El Paso and Los Angeles, using

‘nine-passenger. station wagons operated by drivers who

speak Spanish. Twenty-seven witnesses appeared before the

hearing examiner in support of the application. Their

‘testimony disclosed that persons of Mexican ancestry who ~

reside in E] Paso, or at nearby points in Mexico and who

a occasion to travel between El Paso and Los Angeles,

confronted by a language r. These persons are”

confused although the e ne carriers maintain “

Sugeteh-anpaking personnel at their terminals and an-

nouncé their departures and arrivals in both English and

Spanish. They also testified that the passengers’ baggage.

are 4

‘ , sometimes did not arrive with the passengers. Several

witnesses testified that they found a limousine service more

. comfortable than a bus service and that they preferred the 7 eS | |

faster service offered by the applicant. The testimony dis- |

closed further that various wildcat limousine services are

-currently operating between Juarez, Mexico and Los Ange-

les, and that a number of persons use these illegal services _

rather than the existing bus service. The examiner found

' ° that the limousine service proposed by. the applicant is —

' “distinetive.” This finding of distinctiveness was based on

four elements: more comfort, movement of baggage on the -

same sce hard 4 with rs, faster. service, and drivers

who speak e examiner also found that the. 4 s

pena y sof potential market “consistéd largely of those

a ee ee

<7, Sone 3 ins

persons whom plaintiffs had already lost to thé wildeat

operations and that, therefore, plaintiffs’ operations would ©

not be adversely affected by the applicant’s guccess.

The Commission adopted the report of Ahe“examiner. It

. found that the existing carriers provided an adequate

service to the exent that they were able to do so, but that

the distincitive type of service that was proposed justified

a grant of authority to Rosenbaum ‘despite the existence

of the other passenger carriers. It also considered evidence

thaf the applicant’s operations would have an adverse effect

on the wildcat cérriers and concluded that the issuance. of a

- certificate of public convenience and necessity to the appli-

cant might tend to curb such illegal operations. ©

The United States Supreme Court has frequently held .

that orders of the Interstate Commerce Commission should

‘not be set aside, modified, or disturbed by a court on

* review if they lie within the scope of the Commission’s .

statutory ‘authority and are based upon adequate findings

'- which are supported by substantial evidence upon the

record as a whole, even though the court might have reached

. a different conclusion on the facts presented. Gilbertville

Trucking Co., Inc. v. United States, 371 U.S. 115, 126 (1962) ;

United States v. Pierce Auto Freight Lines, 327.U.S. 515,

535-36 (1946) ; Mississuppt Valley Barge Limes Co. v. Umited |

Seana, 292 U.S. 282,. 286-87 (1934).

The courts have recognized that Congress has delegated

to the Commission a broad discretion in determining what

constitutes “public convenience and necessity” under Sec-

tion 207(a) of the Interstate Commerce: Act. 49 U.S.C.

§307 (a) (1964). Interstate Commerce Commission v. Park-

er, 326 U.S. 60, 65 (1945) ; United States v. Detroit & Cleve-

+- land Nawigation Co., 326 U.S. 236, 241 (1945). It.is for the

’ Commission to ‘ddtermine whether‘ the public convenience

and necessity réquire the issuance of a certificate authoriz-

_ing interstate motor carrier operations. Accordingly, the -

instant action should be testéd by the norm which jimits our

f > .

° é .

* * a

consideration and: review to a determination of whether .

there was a “rational basis . . . supported by~substantial

evidence.” A. L. Mechling Barge Lines, Inc. v. United

States, 218 F.Supp. 837, 839 (N.D. IIL’ 1963). We conclude

that such a basis exists here for the order entered. "i

, The Commission determined that*a certificate of public. .

" eonvenience and necessity should be issued to the applicant.

It concluded that the certificate was justified by the dis-

tinctive type of passenger service which was proposed. The

record discloses that the proposed service was designed:

to be faster, to overcome the language barrier encountered

by Spanish-speaking people, to assure arrival of luggage

~ along: with the passenger, to be more comfortable than - .

travel on buses, and-to be more advantageous to Spanish-

-spéaking people. The proposed service might also be: ins,

strumental in curbing existing illegal passenger services

operating in the area. This record provides substantial evi-

dence to support the Commission’s conclusion.

. Plaintiffs urge that the elements considered by the Com-

mission, particularly the fact that Spanish-speaking drivers

will make travel more conveni¢nt for Spanish-speaking :.

‘passengers, are improper grounds for issuance of a cer-*

tificate. They contend, in terrorem, that if these are rele-

>- vant factors; they would equally support the issuance of a

» @ertificate to an applicant who proposed using Italian- .

_ . speaking drivers in a service between New * York and Pitts-

Bbargh or other compe rable. applicatigns.

_ Each case must, of course, stand on its own facts. Service

between El Paso, situatedon the Mexican border just op-

posite the city of Juarez, and Los. Angeles, is a substantially

_ different question than -service between New York :and

Pittsburgh: We hold ‘only, that the Commission’ 8 action

here was within its statutory power; that its order is based’ .

upon adequate findings supported by substantial evidence,

and is in accordance with the applicable léw. Accordingly,

we conclude that the order and ‘decision of the Commission

5a

bé affirmed and that the Complaint should be dismissed.

An. appropriate order will be entered. .

le

Dated: December 11, 1967

Ame

/s/ Joun S. —

John S. Hastings |

Circuit Judge, United States -

Court of Appeals for the

Seventh Circuit

/s/ Husert L. Wa

Hubert L. Will

United States Distrij dge

Northern District ois

_ /8/ Wits J. Lyxce

~ William °J. Lynch Rent

United States District Judge

Northern District of Illinois.

| ee

‘ JUDGMENT ORDER

- ‘The above cause came on regularly for hearing before the

Court on the 9th day of November, 1967, and was duly

submitted for consideration and decision, and the Court on

‘the 11th day of December, 1967, made its decision and filed

_ its per-curiam opinion. Now, therefore, ——— thereto, ;

itis hereby -

- ORDERED AND ADJU DGED that the Interstate Com-

merce Commission’s order of April: 28;°1966, be and it

-hereby i is —* and that the anes be and it hereby ae

is dismissed> —

Dated: December 11, 1967

/s/ Jonn S. Hastrnes |

' John’ S. .Hastings :

Circuit Judge, United States

Court of Appeals for the

Seventh Circuit

/s/ Husert L. Wau

- Hubert. L. Will |

‘United States District Judge

_- Narthern District of Illinois

/s/ Wuitam J. Lyncu

- William J. Lynch

. United States District Judge

Northern District of Illinois —

i malas

7a

APPENDIX B | eo

| Service Date

: May 9, 1966

— AND OxpER re :

At . Session of the InrerstaTe ComMEnce Comnassion,

-- Operating Rights Review Board Nuniber 3, held at its

office in Washington, D.C. on the 28th. day of .

‘We ANC-196115 (Sub-No. 2)

Lovts, Rosmiraatne Common Canner Avetacarson

5 ae Paso, Tex.)

ion of the application ont the record

itled proceeding, including the report and

recommended order of the examiner, the exceptions thereto :

‘filed separately by: National Bus Traffic Association, Inc., ”

_and by Greyhonnd Lines; Inc., and jointly by Transcon-

tinental Bus System, Inc., and -American/ Buslines, Inc., “

protestants, and the ied to the — filed hy —

cant; and

It appearing, That, exept as en below, the chiiiice -

pleadings raise no. new'er material matters of fact or law -

_ not adequately considered and properly disposed of by the >>

* examiner in his report, and are not of such nature as to —

require the issuance of a-report —_— the evidence in

the light of the Pleadings ; ie mess

It paren appearing, That the examiner recommended -

the granting to applicant of a certificate of public con-

venience and necessity authorizing the operation, as. modi-

filed herein, described in the appendix to this order;

And it further appearing, That the evidence warrants the |

“imposition of a restriction limiting applicant’s proposed

limousine service to the’ transportation of not more than |

-eight passengers in any one: vehicle (not including -_

driver thereof: ); :

° .

iva)

8a

" ” Wherefore, and good ¢ause appearing therefor:

We find, That the findings of the examiner ‘should be, and

: they are hereby, modified for the reasons stated in the -

third appearing paragraph above, and in order to correct

~--- @-malnor.error jn the route Sa requested in the.

instant application; :

And we further find, That the evidence actions’ in the

light of the pleadings does not: warrant a result substan-

tially different from that reached by the examiner; and

that thé statement of facts, the conclusions, and the findings

of the examiner, as modified herein, being proper and cor-

rect in all material respects, should be, and are hereby,

_affirmed and adopted as Our OWN; and -

It is ordered, That said application, exeept to the extent

granted herein, be, and it is hereby, denied. «

It is further ordered, That upon compliance by applicant:

with the requirements of. sections 215, 217, and 221(c) of

the Interstate Commerce Act and with the Commission’s

‘ rules and regulations thereunder, within the tinie specified

in the next succeeding paragraph, an appropriate certificate

will be issued. ’

And it is further ordered; That unless cainiplianes i ismade

by applicarit with the requirements of sections 215, 217,

and 221(c) of the act within 90 days after the date of service

‘hereof, or within such additional time as may be authorized .

“by the Commission, the grant of authority made herein

shall be considered as null and void and the application

shall stand denied in its entirety effective upon the expira-

tion of the said compliance time.

By the Commission, Operating Rights Revibe Doara ,

os Number 3, Members a Morris, and Mulhern.”

pe |

H. Neu. Garson, |

‘Secretary.

| 9a ‘ . on : : °

APPENDIX |

No. MC-125115 (Sub-No. 2)

Louis Rosewsaum Common Carrier APPLICATION

- (El. 7 Tex.)

Service Authorized :

Operaticn by: applicant, in interstate or foreien: com-

_ Merce, asa common carrier by motor vehicle, over regular

‘toutes, of passengers and their baggage, limited ‘to the

_ transportation of not more than eight passengers in any one

vehicle, (not including the driver thereof), ig limousine

service, between El Paso, Tex., and Los Angeles, Calif,

from El Paso over Interstate Highway 10 to Las Cruces,

N. Mex., thence over U. S. Highway 80 through Lordsburg, /

'N. Mex., to junction New Mexico Highway 14, thence over

New Mexico Highway 14 to the New Mexico-Arizona State

line, thence over Arizona Highway 86 to Benson, Ariz.,

thence-avgr U..S. Highway 80 to Tucson, Ariz., thence over

Arizona Highway 84 to Gila Bend, Ariz., thence over U.S. .

Highway 80 through Yuma, Ariz., to junction California

. Highway 98, thence over California Highway 98 to Calexico,

_ Calif., thence over California Highway 86 (formerly U.S. .

. Highway 99), to Indio, Calif., thence over Interstate High-

- way 10 to Los Angeles, and. return over the same route,

serving no intermediate points. |

Serenata

ssvitinte © hits,

_ . INTERSTATE COMMERCE ‘COMMISSION

Served January 6, 1966 yi |

Norice To Tae Parriss -

Exceptions, if any, must be filed with the ntinn: In-

. TERSTATE COMMERCE ComMIssION, Washington, D.C., and

' ,served on all other parties in interest, within 30 days from ~

- the date of service shown above, or within such. further

n

oe

“

10a.

* period as may be authorized for the filing of exceptions.

. At the expiration of the period for the filing of exceptions,

the attached order will become the order of the Commis-.

- gion and will become effective unless exceptions: are filed

seasonably or the order is stayed or postponed by the Com-

misaion. To be seasonably filed, exceptions must reach the

Commission on or before the date they are due.. If excep- -

tions are filed, replies ‘thereto may be filed within ” days

_ after the final. date for exceptions.

Any new operation to be atthorized @y the recommerided ;

‘order herein if it becomes effective may not be commenced.

until such time as the certificate, permit,\or license has ac-

tually been issued. The certificate, permit, or ‘license will

not be issued until the applicant has complied with the pro-

visions of the Interstate Commerce Act and the require-

ments of the Commission thereunder. It should not be as-

‘sumed that the fecommended order has become effective

as the order of the Commission until a notice to- that ef-

fect, signed by the beatae of the Commission, thas. been

received.

No, MC-125115 (Sub-No. “ees \:

Lovis Rosexpavn, Common Cannrnit APPLICATION .

ee

Issuance of a certificate of public convenience and neces-

as sity authorizing described operations as‘a cormon cara

rier by motor vehicle *approved . upon —- by |

applicant with certain conditioris. °

' M. Ward ‘Bailey for applicant. .

D. Paul Stofford and Craig McAtee for protestants

. 4

Ma"

Report AND ORDER

' Recommenvep By Bernagp J. Hasson, Jn,

'. \Hfearrnu Examiner 7

By application filed January 5, 1965, -Louis Rosenbaum,

doing business as EF Paso-Los Angeles Limougine Express,

of El Paso, Tex., seeks a certificate of publie convenience.

and necessity authorizing operation, in interstate or for-.

' eign.commerce, as a common carrier by motor yehicle, over

regular routes, of passengers and their baggage, i in limou- —

gine service, between El Paso, Tex., and Los Angeles, Calif.,.

_ - from El Paso over Interstate Highway 10 to Las Cruces, i

N. Mex., thence over U.S. Highway 80. through Lordsburg, 4

' ‘Mex, to the New Mexico-Arizona State line, thence .

over Arizona Highway 86 to Benson, ‘Ariz., thence over

‘U.S. Highway 80.to Tucson, Ariz., fhence over Arizona

Highway 84 to Gila Bend, Ariz., thence over U:S. Highway

80 through Yuma, Ariz., to junction California. Highway

98, thence over California Highway 98 to Calexico, Calif,

: thenes over California Highway 86 (formerly U.S. High-

way 99), to Indio, Caiif., thenee over Interstate Highway ,

- 10 to Los Angeles, and return over the same route, serving

. no intermediate points. b,

_. The application was referred to the examiner for hear-

ing and the recommendation of an appropriate order there-

on. Hearing was held October 4, 5, and 6, 1965, at El —

7 Tex. .,

Applicant i is presently i in:

ness in E] Paso. He asserts Aervices identical to that he

here proposes now exist, on a \purported’ expense-sharing

- basis, and that some four to six perators openly advertise 2

sthound schedule leaving

‘" Bl Paso at 6 pm, (M.S.T.), stopping at Lordsburg, N

Mex.,. for dinner). changing ‘drivers at Gila Bend, Ariz.,

stopping . at Calexicg. for breakfast, arriving Los Angeles

nw

e real estate and abissein’ busi-.

ae

_ vide lodging in Gila. Bend... Drivers wil

.

‘

» @

‘12a

.

at g :45 a.m. (P.S.T.). An dita sithoidule _" i the »

same thing, stopping at Calexico for dinner and Lordsburg:

for breakfast. The exact distance between applicant’s two

planned terminals is 848 miles. Applicant selected the route

sought to avoid heavy traffic over the shorter route through

Phoenix. His proposed running time is 14 hours, 50 minutes,

_ with stops of 30 minutes at Lordsburg, for dinner (west- -

bound), 15 minutes at Gila Bend to.gehange ree vas

-10-minutes at Calexico for breakfast. -

Applicant will use five new 9-passenger Aelinn wagons,

‘to be purchased for $17;000 cash. He will handle baggage -

» below the seats and on a roof rack. They will be air-con-

--Githeaed, with individual eats belts, if available, and ear- —

— radio attachments for each passenger.

| Applicant proposes to transport not over eight passen-

gers in a vehicle, and is: willing to limit the application

accordingly. If more than eight . prospective passengers

> are available, he will dispatch a second car. He proposes

‘ to allow a'10 percent discount on round-trip tickets, provide

half-fare tickets for children under 12, and charge 1 no fare .

for infants.

‘ Applicant hopes in ‘the tana 3 to: make’ arrangements -

with one of the four Mexican bus lines serving Juarez for .

through transportation to and from points beyond Juarez.

» Applicant will pay his drivers’ $2.50 an hour, and pro-

lay over 24 hours

> at Gila Bend, and one car will be tationed at Gila Bend

in case one of the eon} schedfiles should eo a

breakdown. — 3 5 | Wes

‘Applicant knows that some ‘fee cars a i now leave

Juarez in the existing unauthorized service, and therefore .

- anticipates no difficulty i in obtaining traffic.

Applicant’s proposed fare is $25.80, which matches what — 7

he believes the unauthorized operators. normally: charge.

(ioweres, ‘Gey vary fares — — one or two

N

2

/

passengers). He estimates annual. expenses at $92,654, in-

cluding depreciation and reserves of $5,000 for unfdreseen

expenses and $2,500. for spare parts ‘and ‘repairs. These . |

expenses include two*employees in Los Angeles and one

each in Juarez and El] Paso. With an average of 6 passen-

gers per trip, he estimates an annual gross operating rev-

‘enue of $13,004, and a net profit of $20,349. Applicant’s

personal net worth as of December 31, 1964, was $208,360.

In July 1963, applicant filed an application seeking the

same authority here ‘sought. An Operating Rights Review

Board reversed the examiner therein and: denied the ap- .

plication, oe that , service was adequate and

that

“Although the features which applicant jeanbe offer .

‘might be ‘attractive to a limited portion of the travel-

ing public, we-are not persuaded that they are so.dis-

tinetiye as to transform what is essentially a regular-:’

route, int-to-point service into a new an ‘here.is a

type A yes otor carrier operation for which there is a

* public demand.” 7 7

Applicant’s petition. for further hearing. was denied Oc-

tober. 28, 1964, and the instant applieation was. filed shortly

. thereafter. oie

i: Applicant will arrange to snateieitiie _passengers

picked up in Juarez by a taxi company which proposes to

charge 50 cents per passenger, assuming he has more ©

than one passenger per trip. For a single passenger he

will charge 75 cents or $1.00. The cab driver presently

takes passengers to Greyhound and Trailways Terminals

in- Et-Paso. He cannot transport pane from El Paso

to J uarez. .

Another taxi. company, epinaiind 45. taxis with Srhvend” Nae

- who speak Spanish, plans to provide service between down-

town Juarez and applicant’s departure point, charging .

$2.00 for each trip regardless of number of: passengers.

i

fy

- l4a

Estrella Blance Auto Buses serves hetween Juarez and

‘four States of Mexico, using large buses. It sells tickets

to Juarez, but not to or from United States points. The

witness does not know if hig company will. arrange-

ments with applicant, but it. has no other coMMection at_

present. It has 11 arrivals in Juarez daily. Both cn

and Trailways have connecting, lines in Mexico.

'. A merchant and wrestling referee from Juarez travels

to Los Angeles six to eight times a year, sometimes in con-

nection with bouts he'referees in Tijuana.. He takes about

18 pounds of clothes and his referee uniform with him,

and sometimes travels.with three or four wrestlers. About -

- once a year he takes his wife and six children with him.

He has used. the services_which -advertise in the Juarez

newspaper. for the past three years. Before that, he. used:

_’ Greyhound, but the trip took 20 hours as compared with

shout 15 hours by car. He also used Trailways and rail

“service?” ‘He will use*the proposed. service because he be-

Nieves it has the advantages of (1) being safér, with new.

ears’ (2) having heated and air-conditioned cars; (3) being

faster; and (4) providing insurance. He expects to travel

_more often than at present if this service id thade available.

He prefers to go to Tijuana frofn Los Angeles because he

ean obtain car ‘transportation, whereas ‘if he ‘went from

Juarez to San Diego he would have to take a bus from oa

’ Diego to Tijuana. ; ;

A merehant frdm Monterrey | travels * “Los S hago”

through, El Paso éight to ten times a ‘year, one of these |

trips being a pleasure trip. He takes ‘about 22 pounds of

baggage with’ him, and goes mostly by means of the car

_ trips adver in the paper. He does not understand

English and\considers it important that the driver speik

Se: Spanish. He Greyhound | but found it inconvenient be-

“case baggage ‘on the rack above the seatd may ‘be stolen;

. and it is difficult\to sleep on the bus. ‘He prefers car travel:

_ because, in addi on to” overcoming those two deficiencies,

/

/ le e , ; é

yp Paws ' ” sa \

° ‘ , \ PL, ol

i

1

an

- Same

‘it is faster. Also, bus windows do not open, and sometimes

the air-conditioning is not working properly. He does not

prefer reclining seats because of his long legs.. Although

the advertisements offer to share expenses, the witness

states that he does not really share expenses; the driver

tells the passengers _ much the fare ‘is ne board

the car.

‘ A. ibeteaviiet owner in El Dis aint to hes —

. eight to ten times a year, carrying 15 to 20 pounds of bage

gage. Sonte of these trips are business trips, some to visit -

relatives. He has not used Greyhound since an incident two

years ago: in which he considered a remark by the driver.

to be “discriminatory.” He also used Trailways until two

_ years ago; and used it many times. The Trailways buses

were clean, andthe drivers were courteous, “sometimes”;

however, sometimes they would not answer r the witness

. when he asked a question. ¢

we Bet Juarez ‘attorney makes 10 to 12 trips to tie Angeles

_ ‘a year, principally on business, carrying 25 pounds of lug-

gage. He travels with his wife and 3 children. Some trips’

are made in his own car,. others in the cars advertised in \

. the paper. He has used Trailways and Greyhound, hut con-

siders the service unsatisfactory because he must stand ip

line to buy a ticket,:then stand in line to board the bus, and

then spend more time in transit than with a car. The buses

were clean and comfortable, and their being equipped with

.& toilet was an advantage. In. 1965 to the date of the hear-

ing, he had made three trips in advertised cars and five

trips i in his own car. He expects to be picked up at his house.

A Lt. Colonel in the Mexican Army stationed at Chihua-

hua makes two trips a month to Los Angeles carrying 20

to 25 ‘pounds of luggage. The actual purpose of the trips,

which are made. in the company of two companions, is. to

- perform military duties at Tijuana; and the routing through

. Los Angeles is shorter and cheaper than any royte within

Mexico. °

énd ‘his _—_ use tlie autos advertised fee |

o = 168

- in the paper. He used Greyhound on three occasions eme

two years ago, but the buses do not have reserved seats,

_ the-drivers leave the lights on and make if difficult to sleep;

the drivers do not speak Spanish, and on one: occasjon his

luggage was lost and he waited “in the terminal 544 hours —

until it arrived. He nes not ne the _rralluays serv-

ice. |

A jeweler from Guideiitarn | busine to Los Angeles six

to eight times a year, with 18 to 24 pounds of baggage. He

has used Greyhound, Trailways, and the advertised autos. —

' Greyhound was used as recently as four months prior to

. the hearing; Trailways 7 or 8 months before the hearing.

Greyhound lost his baggage and it took two days:to retrieve °

it. He also has difficulty understanding the announcements

of departures at bus terminals. He believes applicant will ©

provide pillows, as Greyhound does. The cars he now uses

pick him up and take him directly to his destination, and

he believes applicant wil) provide the same. service. He

‘ gometimes buys in both Los Angeles and El Paso, which

_ is one reason for making the trip through El Paso.

It: was stipulated. that 14 residents of Juarez, two from

- Aguas Calientes, and one each from Guadalajara, El Paso, - .

-Terreon, San Luis Potosi, and Monterrey, would, if called,

testify substantially: the same.as the foregoing public wit-

nessés both on direct and cross examination. Only one of

these 21, and one of the witnesses testifying, supported

applicant’s prior application seeking this authority. -

National Bus Traffic Association opposes the applica-

tion bécause it would provide direct’ competition to inter-

city bus carriers even-though a ‘limousine and Spanish-

speaking drivers would be used. Its membership includes

all intercity regular- route carriers, ineluding limousine

services, possibly rail subsidiaries, operating in the United

States, Canada, and Mexico. The witness admits one .dif- —

ference in this application is en drivers, b but

- considers this _ a “frill”. |

17a

It publishes a tariff on behalf of the other _protestants

herein naming a one-way fare of $28.40 between El Paso

and Los. Angeles. The family plan fare (one full fare plus

one 75 percent fare), is $49.70. Children’: s fare (12-22 years),

are 75 percent of the regular fare and (under 12) 75 per- -

- cent of that amount. A mid-week round-trip fare of 1%

times the normal one-way fare, or $42.60, is also available.

Transcontinental Bus System, Inc., and American Bus--

lines, Inc., are members of the Trailways system, serve El

Paso, and operate between El Paso and Los Angeles, both

over the route here sought (as far as Yuma, thence through ~

San Diego), and over a ‘50-mile shorter route through ~

. Phoenix, Ariz., and Blythe, Calif. The route through

Phoenix and Blythe is - mules; the route through. Yuma

is 856 miles.. :

The evidence relates only to American Bus Lines, as

_ these are its routes. The Trailways system has 5 schedules

a day in each direction between El Paso and Los Angeles,

using approximately 40 Silver Eagle buses. Also, it has

standby equipment at major points between these termini.

These schedules are designed to leave and arrive at times

considered most convenient. :

It has empty seats and can. transport more passengers; .

the average number of empty seats on its five westbound

schedules, per day, during May, 1965, leaving El Paso

and arriving at Los Angeles, respéctively, were 27.4, 31.2,

22.3, 18.9, 22.6, 27.3, 21.5, 28.6, 28.5, and 32.8. In the reverse

direction, the departure and arrival averages were 41. 8,

36.1, 32.1, 32.1, 35.9, 31.6, 29.4, 30.1, 31.2, and 25.4.

Elapsed times on ‘its schedules vary. from 17 hours 55:

minutes to 21 hours 5 minutes, depending both on the route |

of movement and the amount of time spent at rest and meal

stops.. nae es

Between Rietieitiies 1, 1964 and June 30, "1965, it sold:

-at El Paso a total of 368 one-way tickets and 87 round-trip -

tickets to. Los — Between January 1 and o— 31,

& 1965, at Los Angeles, it sold 209 one-way and 42 round-trip

tickets to El Paso.

It announces all ae - departures in ‘anaes at

its El Paso terminal, and has done so for five years. Four-

_ teen of its 18 El Paso employees speak fluent Spanish.

It connects: with Omnibus de Mexico Fletcha Rojan at

El Paso. Its representative is aware of the unlawful pas-

| _ senger car operations and in fact some of these operators

solicit in the Trailways” terminal. It. has reported this to the

Commission.’

‘~It advertises in. n. newspapers, on the radio one on televi-

sion, and it employs city solictors.

Greyhound Lines, Western Division operates between

El Paso and Los. Angeles over a.route through Phoenix

and Blythe, and also operates between El Paso and San.

Diego, and between Los Angeles ‘and San Diego. It operates -

8 schedules in each direction each day-between Los Angeles

and El Paso, having an elapsed time of between 17. hours |

50 minutes and 20°hours 20 minutes.

It has two pools of buses licensed to operate through the

four States involved, totaling 380 buses. All are equipped

with lavatories, air conditioning, and reclining seats. It ©

also has drivers stationed along the route.

Greyhound connects with Transportes Chihuahuences in

El Paso, and also has a vice-president ‘whose sole duty is

the stimulation of Mexican traffic. It advertises in Spanish

on the radio in Los Angeles, El Paso, San Diego, Phoenix,

and Tucson, and has definite plans to advertise in Spanish

_ on television, in Los Angeles. It has a Spanish-speaking, em-.-)”

ployee always on duty at each terminal on this route, and °

all arrivals and departures are announced i in Spanish.

Tts witness does not believe applicant’s proposed run-

ning time attainable, since he would have to average 57 |

‘mp.h., to travel 848 miles in 14 hours 40 minutes, = night

—_ limits would be in effect.

©

ac etl apse ter rine sie BENE oe a

During doiaiiees 1965, buses arriving in El Paso from

a west contained a total of 30,258 seats, 9,982 of which

were empty. In the reverse direction, buses departing El

Paso contained 28,905 seats, 11,691 of which were empty. —

The same relationships exist for. the months of November

- 1964, and February.and May, 1965, except that the totals

are considerably lower (e.g., 16,898 total seats arriving and.

16,773 departing in November), —" a —_—

increase in passengers.

Greyhound ean and does put on paren sections iced,

and asserts it never dispatches a schedule from a terminal

point with standees. The evidence shows that it generally

operates two sections on all of its El Paso-Los ——

schedules, and sometimes three.

It asserts that travel by private uBaeinctitie has increased

rapidly, and that air travel, and particularly a new military |

air standby. policy, have seriously affected its traffic. Ris-

ing labor costs and: rising cost of new equipment also con-

tribute to its financial burden. It believes still another

source of diversion would be quite serious.

The examiner agreed to take official notice of the gross

and net operating revenues of American Buslines and, West-

ern Central Greyhound Lines Division for the year 1964, -

and the first two, quarters of 1965. These figures are as fol-

lows: ;

Year: 1964 ' American Greyhound

Operating Revenue $14,391,943 $147,923,321

Net Operating Revenue 896,855 —§ 25,047,030

Net Income | * -§49,563- 15,312,926

“Ast Q. 1965 a ans

Operating Revenue . $- 2,607,325 $ 30,770,461

Net Operating Revenue (382,431)* 1,317,425

Net Income ~—_ co ~ 1,024,935

2nd Q. 1965 ee.

Operating Revenue $3,805, 291 $ 37,513,558 _~

_ Net Operating Révenue — 333,115 4,936,609

_NetIncome 336,244 “3,156,407

* Denotes Deficit ee,

semsecrrareneent. ns ere ae , > soem ry | ear

. é . : 20a

It is stipulated that both companies handle mail and

‘express. Thus; an unidentifiable percentage e the above

atari is produced by such traffic,

"DISCUSSION AND CON CLUSIONS

Applicant’ s prior application seeking this authority was

denied upon the ultimate conclusion that:

Although the features which applicant would offer

_ might be attractive to a limited portion of the travel-

‘ling public, we are not persuaded that they are so dis- _

tinctive as to transform what is essentially a regular-

route, point-to-point service into a new and specialized

type of motor carrier operation for which there is a ; ‘e

public demand. D. C. Transit System, Inc., Exten- -

sion—Limousine Service, 81 M.C.C. 737. oe oe

The quoted sini is, except for the final phrase, a direct ee oe

' quote from the D. C. Transit case cited. The finding is, ,

therefore, that the two cases are-identical. Whatever the

evidence was-in the prior application, the evidence in the .

* -present case does not warrant the conclusions.in the D.C.

. Transit case. The D. C. Transit application was denied on | :

the grounds (1) that there were only five witnesses support- _

ing ‘the luxury limousine service proposed and that there .

was no substantial public demand. for it; (2) that the wit-

. ness had not tried the existing service sind found it want-

ing; (3) that the service proposed ‘was, theréfore, simply a eer

point-to-point service and not a ‘‘new and distinctive type xe

of service,” and (4) that a grant would jeopardize the exist-

-’ ing services because the proposed competitive fares would | a

attract the same passengers as were Now using the existing

services.

’

ren Seren eet eer te Sane ern Cl wees

' In the instant weoniilieie. 27 witnesses a suqpnet the appli- “a

cation and some. of them travel with their families or |

_ associates. They have used the existing bus service and

found it wanting in many respects (although tlie evidence

= 21a

_ establishes that naraeeern do announce arrivals a jo

‘. °. partures in Spanish, contrary to the understanding of one

witness). ‘The language barrier is, nevertheless, real.. It -

is not difficult to picture the frustration attendant upon ~

waiting in a bus terminal five hours for one’s luggage, and |

not being able ‘to speak English. Nor is it. difficult to.

' imagine the feelings of one not able to speak English when

other Paseengets laugh at a driver’s comment about that

' person’s country. The evidence leaves no doubt but that

there is a definite need simply for a more considerate serv-

‘ice; all the reasons advanced by the witnesses for no longer.

using protestants are valid and indeed compelling ones,

But beyond that, the service proposed i is in fact distinc-

- tive. It will assure the witnesses and those they are repre- .

sentative of that their baggage will arrive with them; it .

will afford them more comfort than a. bus, it will afford =

faster service. In this latter connection, protestants offered

opinion evidence that applicant céuld not maintain his pro- .

posed schedules because his vehicles would be operating —

under night-time speed limits. This grave opinion was un-

‘accompanied by evidence of what those speed limits -are.

Speed limifs are matters of common knowledge in ‘the

motor carrier industry, however, and are published in. the:

Rand-MecNally Road Atlas. ._The examiner -will therefore

_ take official notice from the Rand-McN. ally Road. Atlas, 1965,

that the night speed limits in Arizona and New ‘Mexico are .

60 mp.h, and i in California and Texas, as ‘pertinent, are —

65 m.p.h. ° Applicant’ '8 proposed average speed of 57 m.p.h., |

is attainable, and, in fact, part of the reason for the route _

’ chosen by applicant is to avoid having to traverse Phoenix.

Applicant has traversed the route and — a that

speed and transit time.

- Arrangements will be made for taxi ‘iene to and from

applicant’s departure point in El Paso; the drivers: will

speak Spanish—a feature which appears necessary here— _

and applicant will have a definite fare, in effect; an ad- : { | i.

| vantage over the existing unlawful limousine operators.

Applicant will also carry insurance, which the unlaw-

_ ful operators ‘probably do not. And, finally, the success of —

_ applicant’s operations may tend to reduce the amount of

unlawful operations. At the same time, his success will in

no way affect the protestants adversely, as they have al-

ready. lost. all the passengers who comprise applicant’s.

potential. While they no doubt provide adequate bus

‘service, it has been a tenet of this Commission from the -

earliest days of regulation that a distinctive type of pas-

'* senger. service would justify. a grant of authority despite

the existence of other passenger carriers. Pan American

Bus Lines Operations 1 M.C.C.,190 (1936). In short“ts -

to passenger operations, ‘‘available service’? does not -

. equate with ‘‘adequacy of service,’’ and the emphasis must

"be oa ‘*public convenience’ rather than mere ‘‘necessity.’’

All American Bus Lines, Inc., Common Carrier Application,

18 M.C.C. 755, 776 (1939). The examiner concludes that the

‘ application should be granted..

' One. further matter requires comment. .The question 4

was raised whether the five/vehicles applicant proposes to

purchase will meet the reqhirements of this Commission’s

Motor Carrier Safety Regulations governing passenger-. |

carrying vehicles. Section 190.3 of those regulations defines

' ‘bus’? as ‘“‘any motor vehicle designed, constructed, and

used for thé transportation of passengers, including. taxi-

cabs.’’? While applicant’s exhibit shows his proposed Vista-

Cruiser station wagons to be less than 80 inches wide, and.

_, hence not subject to the lamp and reflector requirements

of section 193.12, they will be 9-passenger.vehicles. Section

193.61 of the regulations, relating to window area. and.

vehicle escape facilities, excepts from its provisions vehicles

‘having a seating capacity of eight or less, -but required

_ stated glass area ‘‘for each seated passenger space pro-

vided, inclusive of the driver. -It.is clear, therefore,

that even’ — one of the nine ; seats. is based by the

ee ee i en a

Se

Miver,t the regulation applies to the vehicle. It cannot be

determined from the evidence herein whether the vehicles

applicant proposes to purchase meet. the requiremente of

this section, b ot, then another type of vehicle must be

_ used. pee a :

™

“ah,

Other sections of the reguiniiéns : be except oN

having a seating capacity of eight or less, but without stat-

ing that the driver must be included: in the count. While

applicant proposes to ‘transport not ‘more than eight

passengers, he is advised that the use of none-passenger

station wagons will subject him to all of. the safety regula-—

tions; in particular sections 193. 95 and 193. 96."

FINDINGS | serra Ni

- Upon iaiiaiiibiie of all evidence of sail, the éx-

aminer finds that the present and future public convenience

and necessity require operation by applicant as a common

_ carrier by motor vehicle, over regular routes, in ‘interstate

or foreign commerce, of passengers and their baggage, in

limousine service, between El] Paso, Tex., and Los Angeles,

Calif., from El Paso over Interstate Highway 10 to Las -

Cruces, N. Mex., thence over JJ. S. Highway 80 through

- Lordsburg, ‘N. Mer., to the New. Mexico-Arizona State line,

thence over Arizona Highway 86 to Benson, ‘Ariz., thence‘

- over U.S. Highway 80 to Tucson, Afiz., thence over Avleoea soe

Highway 84 to Gila Bend, Ariz., thence over U. 8. Highway

80 through Yuma, Ariz., to junetjon | California Highway 98,

- thence ‘over California Highway 98 to Calexico, Calif,

thence over California Highway 86 (formerly U. 8. High. .

way 99), to Indio, Calif., thence over Interstate Highway :

10 to Los Angeles, and return over the same route, erving

no intermediate points.

The examiner further finds that applicant i is fit, willing,

and able properly to perform such service and to conform

__ to the requirements of the Interstate Commerce Act and

- with ‘the Crietabinion*s rules and regulations thereunder ;

and that an appropriate certificate shqnld be issued.

In view of the findings. herein, the examiner. ay caacea

_ that the appended order be entered. . at

By Bernard J. Hasson, Jr, Hearing Examiner

-: (Signature) Berna J. Hasson, JR.

Recommended by Bernard J. saan, Jr.,

: Hearing Examiner

e- Rie ce BERNARD J. sete, JB.

iat ORDER» <=

Ata ‘tie of the INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION,

Division 1, held at .its office in , Washington, D. C., on the

day of on" ,A.D., 1966. :

“No. MOC-125115 (Sub-No. 2)

' Lous RosENBAUM, Common CARRIER AppLicaTion

_ Investigation of the matters and things involved in this

. proceeding having been made, said application upon due

notice having been heard.by the examiner, who has made.

- and filed a report herein containing his findings of fact ©

and conclusions thereon, which report is hereby made a

part hereof, and said paar — been duly sub-

mitted :

It és ordered, That upon full sities with the require-

- ments of sections 215, 217, and 221(c) of the Ynterstate

‘Commerce Act, and with our rules and tions there-

- under, a certificate be issued to applicant authorizing opera-

tions, in interstate or foreign'commerce, as a common

carrier by motor vehicle of passengers and their baggage, .

between the points, over the routes, and in the manner .

described .in the findings i in the said report.

It is further ordered, That the application in - other .

respects: be, and iti is hereby, denied. .°

~ ptt

+

See AAAS WD <A hi jini eS tt at HE Pah Nee det REO aie

.

25a -

It ts further ordéred, That unless’ compliance i is made by ve

applicant with the requirements of sectiong 215, 217, and -

221(c) of the act within 90 days after the date-of service of

_ @ notice to the parties that this order has become effective

as the order of the Commission, or within such additional

time as may be authorized by the Commission, the grant of

authority made in said report shall be considered as null

and void and the application shall stand denied in its.

entirety effective upon the expiration of the — compliance |

time.

8 And it is further ordered, That this order shall be fee. 2h

tive on — ;

By the Commission, Division 1. a ee ae

| yf . - N. Nem. Garson,

7 | Secretary.

(SEAL) ees

APPENDIX D wrest

7 aS Service Date

November 9, 1966

ORDER:

At a Session of the IyTerstate Cisnmmce Commassion,

_ Division 1, Acting as an Appellate Division, held at its

Office in Washington, D. C., on the 6th day of September, +

A. D. 1966. -

‘No. MC-125115 (Sub-No. 2)

Louis RosenBatm Common Currier APPLICATION

- (El Paso, ‘Tex. )

Upon consideration of the record in the above-entitled

. .proceeding, and of: :

(1) Petition of Naticfia]l Bus Trafic Anncciation, Inc.,

- protestant, filed June 6, 1966, for Teconsideration; .

(2) Petition of Greyhound Lines, Inc., protestant, filed

June 22, 1966, for reconsideration ;

. a

i W%,

, alle’

‘fs -.(8):S oint petition of ‘Aupatheai Seiten, Inc., and Prané-

att ‘ _ continental Bus System, Inc., protestants filed June

| i Pe 22, 1966, for reconsideration ;. Hace

eh teiy oy applicant, filed August’ 1, 1966; -

ee - and good ¢ cause appearing therefor: | *! ek

; \it is ‘ane, ‘Phat the.said petitions be, and they are

hereby, denied, for the reason that the findings of Operating

a .

ho.

' ts Review. Board Number 3 are in accordance with the.

beri | one and the applicable law;

wl Wie further ordered,. ‘That, unless connplia iance’is’ made by

applicant with the requirements | of Sections. 215, 217, and

eo 221(c) of the’ Interstate Commerce Act,’ within 90 days.

’ after the date of service of this order,-or within such addi-

‘tional time as may be. authorized by thé Commission, the

yo grant of authority made i in the decision and’ order entered

’_’ “herein on April 28, 1966 shall be considered as, null and .

» ~ void and the applicatio ir shall’ stand denied in its entirety .

gee upon t the ‘piration of the said compliance time. .

ee aie

a “By the Commission, 1 Division 1, — as. an. Appellate

; "Division, a ee \: |

SS ie GN Ye peas B New Gunso, |

a Pi (seat) 9 c° wetange *s, ¢

i < - 74 . + —

2 ; TAD ‘ 7° ;

° ae \ .

ce ‘

ng, “\ o *

et ces 2 ‘ | Per

: “34 4's ae / te ‘

2 - ‘ y q

2 Ae eee f ’

"4 ss . . x . :

“AI a ee

- a i \ oo meg, i

“4, 2 ge ?

ma ORDER * :

Ata General Session of ‘the Iwrenstatz’ Commerce Com-

missin, held at its office in Washington, Bb. C, on the 14th =

_ day of December, 1966..

. No. MC-125115 (Sub-No. ay"

\) - Lours Rosewsaum Common Cannrer APPLICATION - |

| i (El Paso, Tex.) “

Ss Upon consideration of the record in the above-entitled

a and of: |

—

“Q) Petition of the N ational Bis Traffic pra Inc,

protestant, filed Noyember 21, 1966, for a determina-

*, tion and announcement that the proceeding involves

% an issue of general transportation importance; .

(2) Joint petition of Greyhound Lines, Inc., American _

‘Bus, Lines, Inc., and Transcontinental Bus: System

Inc., protestants, filed November 25, 1966, for a’

. determination and announcement that the proceeding

involves an issue of general transportation. i impor-

tance, or in the alternative, for further hearing;

(3) Alternate joint petition of Greyhound Lines, Inc.,

' American Bus. Lines, Inc., and Transcontinental Bus —

System, Inc., protestants, filed November 25, 1966, —

for et whites and ee ;

~ and good cause appearing therefor:

It is ordered, That the petitions be, and they are hereby,

. denied for the reasons (1) that in the judgment of the

Commission no issue of. general. transportation importance

' is involved in this proceeding and (2) no sufficient or proper

ca

a

"cause: appears for reopening this Proceeding £ for further

- hearing or rehearing.

By the Commission.

s (SEAL) ™ 4 i os : ‘

H. Nex. Garson,

Secretary.

6 "a3

APPENDIX F

NATIONAL. TRANSPORTATION POLICY

- [September 18, 1940.] [49 U. 8. C., preceding §§ 1, 301,

901, and 1001.) It is hereby declared to be the national

transportation policy of the Congress’ to provide for fair:

and impartial regulation of all modes of transportation

‘subject to the provisions of this Act, sd administered as to

recognize and preserve the ¢nherent advantages of each; to

promote‘ safe, adequate, -ecunomical, and efficient service

. and foster sound economic conditions in transportation and

among the several carriers; to encourage the establishment

and ‘maintenance of reasonable charges fort r-transportation

services, without unjust discriminations, 1 undue preferences »

or advantages, or unfair or destructive competitive prac-.

- tiges; to cooperate with the several States and the duly

- authorized officials thereof; and to encotrage fair wages —

‘and equitable working conditions: ;—all to the end of de-

“veloping, coordinating, and preserving a- national trans-

portation system by water, highway, and rail, as well as.

other means, adequate to meet the needs of the cémmerce

of the United States, of the Postal Service, and # the na-

‘tional defense. All of. the provisions of this Act shail be.

administered and enforced with a view to carrying out the \_

above declaration of policy.

ISSUAN CE OF CERTIFICATE

: So. 207. [August 9, 1935.) [49 U. 8. C. § 307.) (a) Sub-

to section 210, a , certificate shall be issued to any quall-

Ans nna es

ee pote to os | | :

fied applicant therefor, authorizing the whole or any part of

. _ the operations covered by the application, if it is found that’

the applicant is fit, willing, and able properly to perform

the service proposed and to conform to the provisions of

this part and the requirements, rules, and regulations of

the Commission thereunder, and that the proposed service,

to the extent to be’ authorized by the certificate, is or. will

be required by the present or future public conyenience and

necessity ; otherwise such: application shall be denied: Pro-

vided, however, That no such certificate shall be issued to

any common carrier of passengers by motor vehicle for op-

erations over other than a regular routé or routes, and

between fixed termini, except as such carriers may be au-

thorized to engage in special or charter operations.

e

APPENDIX G |

This report will not be printed in the permanent series |

of Motor Carrier hentai of the Commission.

| INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION

Service Date - :

May 4, 1967

No. MC-128601

‘GLYNN Ss. Botzs Common Caren APPLICATION

Decided April 27, 1967

Public conveniente and necessity found not shown to re-

quire operation by applicant as a common carrier by

moter vehicle, over irregular routes of passengers: ‘and

their baggage, in round-trip charter operations; be-

. tween Gréenwood, S. C., and Atlanta, Ga. —

denied. ‘Ur ”

Frameis B. Nicholson for applicant. |

Joseph P. Tiiohy for protestant. —

30a ce

" REPORT OF THE COMMISSION

Orznatina Ricuts Review Boarp NumBer 2

MEMBERS (CHANDLER, BOYLE; AND Miy

By THE Boarp:

__ The modified Lenihadiaie has been followed, and the matter

. has been assigned to the Board for disposition.

By application filed September 13, 1966, Glynn 8. Boles

of Greenwood, S. C., seeks a certificate of public conveni-

-ence and necessity authorizing operation, in interstate or

=

foreign commerce, as a common carrier by motor vehicle, |

over. ‘irregular routes, of passengers and: their baggage,

in round-trip, charter operations, between Greenwood, 8. C.,

and Atlanta, Ga. si ea Lines, Inc., opposes the

| er

Applicant holiis authority from ‘the South Carolina Publice 3

Service Commission to provide charter service (1) for

school and church groups, from points and places in Green-

wood County, S.'C., to points and places in South Carolina,

"and. (2)° for_other- groups (a) between points and places

in Greenwood County and Charleston, Orangeburg, Colum-

- bia, and Atlantic Beach, S. C., and (b) between points and,

-. places: in Greenwood County ‘and points and places within

60 miles thereof. .In addition, applicant has a municipal _

bus franchise to transport passefigers within Greenwood,

' §. C. He teaches high school auto mechanics and shop

courses and owns and operates an automobile service sta-

tion, a wrecker service, and a bus service. He has received .

- from several individuals and: groups requests for bus trans-

portation to major league baseball games‘in Atlanta, Ga.,

- and attributes the frequency of these requests to his being

a Negro, as are those who have approached him for service.

. Her believes that the proposed service would be used ex-

clusively by persons of his rac¢, who would not hesitate to

deal with him but woul be reluctant to use existing: car-

riers because’ of the difficulty’in making advance arrange-

mente and in obtaining the required minimum number of —

°

3la

‘passengers. He doubts that these persons will use aatior

service if the application i is denied and that a grant thereof

would deprive existing carriers of any traffic.

Nine public. witnesses support the - application. They ye

include an elementary school principal, a high school

teacher-coach, a funeral director, a textile worker, and a.

‘contractor. The principal of the school where applicant

teaches: describes him as a person: of outstanding moral

character. An oil distributor, who has dealt with: appli-

cant for several years, describes him as. an able and sub-

stantial business man. Eight witnesses describe them- -

. gelves-as residents of the Greenwood area, and seven de- _

scribed themselves as Negroes. Right believe the proposed.

service would be used by. a substantial number’ of Green-

_ wood ‘residents, and that: it would be Particularly respon-

sive to the needs of the Negro community. All nine believe :

the proposed service needed for es to and from

baseball games in Atlefita, Ga.

’ Greyhound Lines, Ine., holds motor common carrier au-

‘thority to transport passengers over, and incidental au-

thority to provide charter service in the area surrounding,

’ -& specified regular route between Greenwood and Atlanta.

Over this route ‘it provides daily, scheduled service. It

has in the considered area 648 buses. From 1951 to 1965

its revenne from passenger operations declined from 99:3

percent to 77.1 percent, and its revenue from charter opera-

tions increased from 1.9 'pereent to 5.2 percent. It adver- ”

tises in an Atlanta newspaper its charter service to ‘Aflanta

baseball games and has provided such service for groups -

at Newberry, Columbia, and Charleston, S. €C. In-the two |

years before the instant proceeding, Greyhound performed .

eight charter movements for the schoo] winare applicant

teaches and thereby earned’ $3,677.50.

Since the dawn of motor carrier regulation the Commis-

sion, before authorizing additional motor service, has given .

careful consideration to the existing carriers’ authority,

willingness, _ ability to perform the oe service.

°

‘In 1936, shortly after Congress had extended the. Com-

mission’s jurisdiction to interstate for-hire’ motor carriers,

the Commission said:?

‘The question, in substance, is whether the new opera- :

tion or service will serve ‘a useful public purpose, re- |

_ sponsive to a puplic demand or need; whether this

or carriers; and whether it can be served by applicant —

with the new operation or service . proposed without

endangering or impairing the operations of existing.

carriers contrary to the pamie: interest. :

While it.is not absolutely essential that an is estab-

lish that existing ( transportation are inadequate, this is

normally one of the ingredients basic to the determination,

of public convenience and necessity.* The Commission has

repeatedly indicated that i in the absence of exceptional cir-

, cumstances, existing carriers are entitled to all the traffic

’ they can handle adequately, efficiently, and economically

within the limits 6f their authorities before a new, nae

ing. service is authorized.

In this proceeding, the evidence establishes that pro-

' testant has appropriate authority and adequate equipment, |

and fails to establish that protestant i is unable or unwilling

to provide the desired service. Protestant has performed

: passenger charter operations, apparently without com-

plaint, in the involved area in general and, in particyplar, |

for the school with which applicant and one of the sup-

. porting witnesses are connected. In the cifcumstances, we -

. cannot conclude that there is any’ justification for depart-

ing from the general rule that existing carriers should be

allowed to handle the available traffic without added com-

petition if they are able té’provide-adequate service. The

_ public support for the application stems wholly. from the

2 Pesiaasidn: Bus Lines Operation, 1 MC. 190, 208.

2 See Hudson Transit Lines v. United States, 82 F. Supp. 153, 157.

purpose can and will be served as well : by existing lines : *

33a

| iti’ of a group of Negroes to patronize applicant’s -

service. There is no showing, or even a suggestion, that

protestant has discriminated against ‘any of these persons, —

and our rules expressly forbid any such treatment.2 We

have no alternative, therefore, but to deny the application.

| We find that applicant has: failed to establish that the

prese nt and future public convenience and necessity re-

quire! the proposed operation ; ; and that the a

should be denied.

An si inland will be entered.

~ ORDER

At a Bension of the InTerstaTE COMMERCE Commassiox,

Opérating Rights Review Board Number 2, held at its ©

office in ‘Washington, D.C. on the 27th’ aa of April,

1967... | |

No. MC-128601

uses s. Bouzs ComMon CARRIER APppLicaTiow

'- Investigation of the matters and things involved in this -

procesiiiie having been made, and said review board, on the ~

date hereof, having made and filed a report herein contain-

ing its findings of fact and conclusions thereon, which re-

port is hereby made a part hereof:

It is ordered, That said application be, and it is hereby,

| denied. aS:

By the Commission, Operating Rights Review Board

Number 2. —

H. Nem Gases, ,

. : _ Secretary.

(Szat) , ie ees ee

ome hee ae ! _@ " OP-OR-14

8 Disorimination—Interstate Motor Oarvteve of Passengers, 86 M. ec. 743,

aff’d. sub nom. Georgia ¥. -ngaaaina saa 201 F. Supp. 813, aff’d. per curiam,

371 U.S. 9; 49 C.F.R, $ 180s. :

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.