Appendix VolII — World Airways, Inc. v. Pan American World Airways, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1968
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
| i I en
Ses - VOLUME II |
‘Supreme Court nf the Buited States
| Ocroser Tena, 1967
. 2,
: : No. 800
Wortp Amwazs, Inc., Er At, Petitioners, .
a
Paw AMERICAN Wont Araways, Ino., Trans Wins
seca Inc. and AMERIoAN Ami, Inc., :
Respondents.
No. 946. ~
CrvIn esa bis Boarp, Petitioner,
2 ‘Vv.
Pan AMERICAN Wortp Airways, Ino., Trans Wena |
_ AIRLINES, Inc. and AMERICAN AIRLINES, Ino.,
—
“Ne, 969
American Sootety or Trave. Acents, Ino., Petitioner,
‘or Vv. RST ag a ~
vo
Paw Aacinroas Wontp Amways, Inc., TRANS Wontp |
— Inc. and marae Araiines, Lv
Respondents
—$— A
ON PETITIONS FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
Petition For Certiorari Filed In No. 800, November 7, 1967
- Petition For Certiorari Filed In No. 946, December 22, 1967
_ Petition For Certiorari Filed In No. 969, December 28, 1967
Certiorari granted and consolidated January 29, 1968
INDEX TO APPENDIX
Pages in
Certified Appendix
. VOLUME: I
Relevant Docket Entries ; Ta
: Docket No.’ 13795
- 115 Notice bysCAB- that it will proceed with
processing. of applications for-supplemental ;
air service, July 12, 1963 . | la
304 Order No. 20573 . 7 2a.
633 Report | of Prehearing Conference, June 2, |
: 1964 | 7 17a:
4108 Holiday Airways, Inc., HOL-T-4-. ae
' Testimony of Richard. D. Neumann .. 20a
"World Airways, Ine.: hes | a ra
> 6065. World—300 ne
3 6229 World Form -D—............ 23a*
La ai World W-5 .. Ma.
; 6622 _ Bureau of. Economic "Regulation, BER ;
Index ..... : | wees 208
‘7174 Joint Intervenors, JT-8 oo cscs 29a
SS 7386 Joint Exhibits of American Flyers Air.
line, et al., J+211 * 30a
7 _ Joint Intervenors: & /
7788 J1-1080 3la Seas
8084 JI-B ) : 37a
8847 Joint Intervenors’ brief to the Sieihien 2
* March 19, -1965 39a
“Docket No. 13795 (Continued) -
Ago
10269°
10878 ©
11275.
ih1359
11734
11982.
12008
12044
12093
+ 12129
12171
12181 -
12322
Order No. B-23600 ........... 7
Order No. E-24237 .....
Recommended Decision of Exaininer, Au-
gust es, ED Wikiiecadindennenn:
Exceptions of Joint Interve ors, , Septem- :
* le SI ican ih. Oe
Brief of Joixt a September 27,
1965 , ' eleianaih
_ Answer uf Joint’ Intervenors ns September “
27, 1965, 4 sutkcocqnenecceasdbeccscens
es
‘Oral Argome t October 13 and 14, 1965 ..
_Order No, E:-23350 :
‘Petition. for Pesiitiawetion by Joint In- ©
tervenors, April 4, 1966 .... s
Answer of Joint Intervenors, sain 11,
1966 ..... , Baeibiiisinienteksenes
Motion of Joint Tadervennit, April. 11,
Order No. E-24238
Order No. E-24239 -
Order No.. E-24431.
Certified ‘ ) | Appendix
Records A ‘ Pages
Docket No. 13795 (Continued) | :
12324 ER-478, November 22, 1966 2.00020... 6138
. 12327 _ER-479, November 22, 1966: eae 3 615a .
.s Docket No. 11908 | oe
|. .19385—~Order No. E-16028 .... oisiinatin OR
f— 12348 Notice of Proposed esecndiie ‘Novem-
ber 14,1960 (EDR-21) 0. (6198
12520 Order No. H-17190 2c mcesseenennen 636a
12703 Order No. E-17607 we. ee’?
Transcript of Transatlantic Charter
. Investigation:
15082 Cross éxamination of Phillip R. a
a: . (PAA) by Charles A. Hobbs of the - |
American Society ‘of — Agents, Inc. 648a
15338. Kenneth L. Briggs (TWA) -cecceecoin 651A
16308 United States Overseas Airways, Inc., ;
| USOA-106 a 652a
‘17575 : Trans ‘World Airlines, Inc., TWA 13 | sails | 653a. :
19438 Examiner’ s Decision-Transatlantic Char-
’ ter Investigation , -- 6d4a
19553 Appendix B to ‘Sieh Detision—
Transatlantic Charter . Investigation .... 755a
20642 - Orders Nos. E-20530 and E-20531 and Sup-
plemental Orders Nos. E-20530 and
E-20581 ...... penpecenyenecneinemieenne TTT
iv \
Pages in ; . .- .
_ Certified Rea . Append:
Records ; pan ; Pages
Docket No. 11908 (Continued)
20868 Petition to- Intervene by American .Air- |
lines and Others, March 23, 1964 ....:....... 884a
31179 Order No. 90000 3 889a a
21199. Order No. E220776 esectessescscsssweecteenese jueeee/ 9928.
a 21909 _Recommended Decision of Examine, Qe- :
org ot tober 8, 1964 : eoncedoes : 927a-
22609 Order No. B-21966 ......... Hf ii 94a
29954 © Order Nov E-22255 cccccccececscscon! 954a
- World Airways, Ine, : . |
27329. ° ~=World R-1 FOO 956a
27252 - . World 403 — a Se . ta
27352 World Bed nani nnnsnnees coves 959R
28299. Order No. E-28686 \..-n.- ee 9600
28389 Pan “American Airways’ Brief, October aay. |
Sy I pecan 968a_—-
“984490 Trans “World Airlines’ Brief, | October 8, .
1965. ! 968a
28743 Recommended Decision of ‘Examiner, , Ne ae
ee - eetber 22, 1965 ......;.......: _
| 99582 Order No. E-24240. on | 1060a
29611 Order No. B-24241 ..... darth SO:
99618 . Order No. E-24242 aes 10978
om
v ‘ .
_ INDEX Pen oO
eA apenas ear Bran ad Appendix
/ as we : Page -
' United States Court of Appeals for the Second
+ Cireuit ~ te ae | }
~ Opinion, July 20, 1967....... ; ‘111929 6
. Judgment, July 22 ,1967 NEES ae |
Order on Rehearing, Septémber 29, 1967 nr ‘
Bane, September 29, 1967 1148a
Order Granting Stay of Issuance of Mandate a
Under Rule 28(e), October 13, 1967 uuu. 1150a"
: 5 Ah - : _ : on ,
: .
. .
= a
.
i
‘
!
. .
“
we
bd .
.
. A. :
. >
«
..
.
> .
-
‘ wit
==
a Ce
- 2 .
.
‘ . ®
> °
©:
°
t
e
c
. e
©
o
*.
e .
. +5
® Ww
, s
‘
.
‘
.
. t . t
.
« ‘
.
PROM tices OU Os OT Ur ERIN oe erty e 6
6
° .
% .
.
‘
x *
. .
. °
. .
. *.
.
. . -
°
: e
.
. SY
- ":
‘ .
,
.
.
co
<- Ad ¢ ; .
: .
.
» .
.
v
a .
\
“ . .
. -
R .
oO = -
* . 5
"
\
° cdi,
.
.
‘
.
. . e
< .
S
‘ .
yt
- S
— od 4
-
‘
‘ ‘
e .
.
.
:
.
.
.
’
, .
. . 7
-
irs . \ som Neemt tropes
’ 4
‘ : °
. «
.
‘
.
. «i
. -
» -
.
.
ae . °
-* Ps
~~, 2
a
- .
.
‘ .
. .
,
.
.
+e “g
x
° = °
.
i
. .
" .
.
of.
‘
. .
:
¥ .
v,
¢
‘
.
.
.
”
’
+e /
&
is P
-” Shy:
an en)
&. : . li
‘ .
| \~ | Order No. 24237
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA |
Crvit Azronavrics Boarp .
WasxincrTon, D. C.
- Serged: September. 30, 1966
SuprLeme - Arm Service PRoceeping © } a
: ‘
R
.
.
mn
Pg ?
‘
Docket 18795 etal. Ok
- Decided:. March 11, 1966 fg
’ Certificate ‘authority to eng ge in overs 2s and fayeign
tific to enga 4
supplemental air. transportation, of persons .and prop-
erty. for a five-year period, subject to the terms, condi-
tions, and limitations of Parts 208 and 378 of the Board’s
Regulations, awarded to
(a) American Flyers Airline Corp., between the United: a
States, on the one hand, and points in Canada, Mex. | |
ico, and the Caribbean, on the other hand;
(b) J ohnson Flying Service aiid Purdue Aeronautics °°
Corp., between the. United States and points in.
(c) Modern Air Transport and Zantop Air Transport
_. hetween the United States, on the one hand, and
points in Canada and Mexico, on: the’ other hand;
fe (d) Capitol Airways and Saturn Airways betwéen the
'_ United States, and points in the Caribbean;
~ “~ ve
GP ON wT gore pe "
BA
me ae og ‘544a
@ (12129, 12130) . ”
(e) Southern Air Transport between the United States,
on the one hand, and points in the Caribbean. and
the Transpacific, on the other hand;
(f ) Trans International Airlines and World siinend’
between the United States, on the one hand, and
_points in the Caribbean, the Transpacific, and Cen-
tral and South America, on the other hand. .
American Flyers, Capitol, Johnson,” Modern, Pandas, Sat-
urn, Southern, TIA, World, and Zantop also authorized
for an indefinite wntind to provide: charters ‘of persons |
and property for the Department of Defense in ovér-
seas, foreign, and intraterritorial air transportation,
subject to certain conditions. |
APPEARANCES: <) . .
Same as set forth in Board’s ‘opinion ‘accompanying
Order E-23350, March 11, 1966.
12130
OPINION
By THE Boarp: o-
— our Opinion of ‘March 11, 1966 (Order E- 03350), we
disposed of the applications. consolidated into this pro-
ceeding insofar as they sought certificates of public con-
venience and necessity under section 401(d) (3) of the Act,
authorizing them to engage in supplemental-air transpor-
tation between the 50 States. We expressly excluded from
consideration there the portions of the applications that
sought authority: to provide supplemental air service in
overseas and fereign air transportation and which, under
re ae hee
'
) 3 — 12131).
sill 801 of. the Act, are subject to th approval of the
President.
- ‘In that decision, we found that ten of ‘the ditt
were fit, willing, and able, and should be awarded certifi-
_ ates authorizing them to operate civil and military char-
ters with respect to persons and property between the 50
States, with the right to provide split charters and inclu-
sive"tour charters in ‘addition to charters as traditionally
defined;? that three applicants were not fit, willing, and =
able, and their applications should be denied ;? and that the
record should be reopened for further hearings on the
qualifications of the three remaining applicants.’ Concur-
rently, we adopted regulations implementing the authority:
» seit and prescribing the limitations thereon.
12131
This opinion deals with the overseas and foreign issues.
in the case that we did not dispose of in our earlier deci-
sion. On those ‘issues, Examiner Robert L. Park, in his
recommended decision, found that (1) the qualified appli-
cants should* be issued certificates of public convenience
and necessity authorizing them to conduct: military and -
civil charter ‘flights in overseas, foreign, and intraterri-
Ss
1 American Flyers, Capitol,, Johnson,. Modern, Purdue, Saturn,
Southern, TIA, World, and Zantop.
2 Conner, Holiday; and Stewart. .
3 ONA, Standard, and Vance.’ Since the qualification issue upon
_- which we found further hearings necessary goes to the fitness,
willingness, and ability of the three carriers for issuance of any
type of supplemental authority, we deferred action on their ap-
_ plications for overseas and foreign authority as well as domestic. -
—
3
a .
ttt PORE LPO
(12131, 12132)
torial air transportation with respect to persens* and
property; (2) the authority should include the right to
provide split charters and inclusive tour charters; (3)-
rather than award ‘uniform authority to all applicants as.’
ea class, individual carriers should be selected to ‘selve
specified overseas and foreign areas; and (4) the authdri- ri
zations should be for a term of five years. ;
The areas which the examiner recommended that the
individual carriers be authorized to serve are- as follows:
(1) Johnson and Purdue—Canada; (2). American Flyers, |
Modern, Vance, and Zantop—Canada and Mexico; (3) -
American. Flyers, Capitol, Saturn, Southern, TIA, and
World—the Caribbean area;‘ - (4) TIA and World—Cen:
tral and South America; (5) Southern, TIA, and World—
the Transpacific area; and (6) Capitol and Saturn—the
| Transatlantic area (cargo). :
— 12182: :
_Exceptions to the recommended decision and briefs to
the Board have been filed by most of the parties to the |
proceeding and the Board has heard oral argument. Upon-
consideration of the record and the contentions of the
parties, we find that we are in agreement with the ex-
* The examiner’s finding did not embrace transatlantic passenger
charter authority. Such authority is an issue in the Reopened
Transatlantic Charter acta Docket 11908 et al,, but not
in this proceeding. a
5 As used by the examiner, the Caribbean area includes Jamaica,
the Bahamas, Bermuda, Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Puerto
Rico, the Virgin Islands, Trinidad, Aruba, the Leeward and Wind-
ward Islands, oy any | other — located in the ‘Gulf of Mexico or
the Caribbean Sea.
* The parties filing exceptions and briefs are listed in our earlier —
- opinion (Order E-23350).
the examiner.
547a
(12132, 12133)
transatlantic cargo authority.’ Accordingly, except ‘as
modified herein, we adopt as our own the findings, con-
clusions, 4nd recommendations of the examiner on the over-
-aminer’s findings and ‘conclusions, except in one respect. .
‘We have decided that no applicant should be awarded
seas, foreign, and intraterritorial issues contained in his »
decision.® o:
As we noted in: our opinion in the domestic phase, the |
examiner, in his thorough and well-reasoned decision, dealt
fully with the issues in the case. The arguments of the
‘various parties to the Board are, in major part, simply”
variations on the arguments they presented ‘to the exam-
iner, and which tie considered and properly rejected. We,
therefore, will confine our opinion here to a limited number
of matters raised on exceptions and’ the single matter on
which we have reached a conclusion different from that of
| Transatlantic Cargo Authority
We disagree’ with the examiner’s recommendation that
Capitol and Saturn, who now hold certificates authorizing
them to provide transatlantic passenger charters, also be
authorized to provide transatlantic cargo charters. The
transatlantic aa in our opinion, presents special consid-
: erations not applicable to the other'areas in which we are
granting cargo authority in addition to passenger au-
7 thority.
a
‘tT Consistent with our action in the domestic opinion, we do not
adopt the examiner’s findings on the qualifications of ON.A, Stand-
ard, and Vance for overseas, foreign, and intraterritorial authority.
® The recommended decision was attached in its entirety to our
earlier opinion (Order E-23350).
» :
+ RT PTS NP RE
548a
aes 12134)
‘The Board hee previously authorized —— World
Airlines to provide cargo only service across the north
. Atlantic, and the carrier has been engaged in developing
_ the cargo potential there without the benefit of passenger
authority or eligibility for subsidy. Seaboard ig not a_
large carrier, and even though only a small percentage of
its total revenues comes from civil cargo charters, the
transatlantic is the only area it is authorized to serve, and
. it is already competing for the cargo ‘traffic there not only
with two of our largest carriers,:Pan American and TWA,.
but with fourteen substantial foreign-flag carriers regu-
my larly flying the Atlantic.
We recognize that a grant of cargo authority to Capitol
_and Saturn might afford the two carriers some degree of
operating flexibility in their efforts to avoid excessive
ferry mileage in their passenger -services. However, there
is no showing here that this is essential to their passenger*
operations or that it would make a substantial contribu-
tion to the success of those ‘operations. ‘Further, each of
the carriers is being given significantly broadened author-
ity under our other awards to them in this case. We find
12134
_ that benefits which might accrue from the award of trans-
atlantic cargo authority to Capitol and Saturn are insuffi- |
cient, on balance, to warrant their grant.
Inclusive Tour Charters
In the interstate ‘phase of this proceeding, we affirmed
the examiner’s finding that the. supplemental ‘carriers -
should be authorized to operate inclusive tour charters.
?
549a
: (12134, 12135) ;
” Such authorization would enable tour operators to dian
_ aircraft ‘from the supplementals for the. -purpose of mar-
. keting packaged tours to members of the general public.
_ The examiner also recommended that, such authority be
| granted in foreign and overseas air transportation. ‘We---
-agree with this recommendation ‘and the reasoning on
which it is based. |
_——To a large extent, the exceptions to the recommended
décision do not distinguish between the domestic and for-
eign and overseas issues. These general. exceptions have
been treated in our domestic opinion, and since no purpose
would be served by a repetition of the considerations set _
forth therein, we will incorporate by reference the inclu- . ‘
sive tour portion of that opinion. We also find that the _
" examiner adequately disposed of the contentions relating
specifically to foreign and overseas operations. Indeed, we
| find it appropriate ‘to comment only on the issues of bal-
: ance of payments. :
The certificated route carriers argue i“ implementa-
tion of: inclusive tour: authority in foreign air transporta-
_ . tion will primarily stimulate ‘traffic originating ee
United States and destined. for foreign countries, oer
than bringing foreign visitors to this country, and conse-
quently the program would have a damaging effect on the
U. S. balance of payments position. The record offers no _—
_. support for this view. Indeed, it is not without signifi-- |
_ cance that the route carriers came forward with no evi- ae
dence to mubatentiats their claim. In sharp’ contrast, there
® Order E-23350, pp. 3-21. “The examiner’s discussion is set forth
in the recommended decision at pp. 43-65, 74-76, 81, and 120-130.
ra
(12135, 12136)
5508
-- is persuasive _ evidence in the record suggesting that the
balance of payments position will not be damaged and may
in fact be _improved. : .
The dimensions of the problem of liduaitve tours as re- .
: __lated to balance of payments can easily be exaggerated.
It must be remembered that we are dealing with a group
of small air carrier enterprises with limited resources and .
equipment, as compared with the U. S. and foreign flag
route carriers. The supplemental carriers’ total civil char- ©
ter révenues for the year 1964, including both: domestic
and foreign, amounted to only $17.5 million, and the evi-
dence inthis proceeding as to inclusive tours: indicates a
range of only $6.5 to $10.5 million in the initial year of
operations, of which most would be accounted for by. dd-
mestic tours.” Thus, even if we were to make the unlikely
assumption that inclusive tours would stimulate only U. S.
travel abroad with no foreign travel to this country being
generated, the amount of gold outflow involved .would_be
quite small. And when we consider the likelihood that in-
clusive tours will attract to our shores a vast market which
12136
~ remains to be tapped, it becomes clear that the balance of |
payments problem, when placed in proper er
has been considerably distorted. : |
-Turning to the generative effect which we believe inelu-
sive tours will have on foreign travel to the United States,
we start with the fact that such travel has historically
10 This of course excludes transatlantic operations. The Bureau’s.
forecast of foreign inclusive tours, excluding the transatlantic, was
$917,000 for the first year and $1.8 million for the third id of
operations. .
—«<BSla ee
(12136, 12137)
oe been much less in amount than U. S. travel abroad. How-
ever, foreign generated travel is growing at a faster rate
than U. S. generated travel abroad. As shown in Appendix
o.
A, this has been the case since at least 1957. In addition,
ts 1964, for the first time, foreign generated air- travel
grew at a faster absolute rate than U. S. air travel abroad,
- amounting to a growth of. approximately 700,000 foreign
_travelers as compared with 630,000 ‘U. 8. travelers.
‘There is considerable reason-to believe that the increase
in foreign travel to the United States has in significant ©
part been the result of a combination of two factors: higher
disposable per capita income in foreign countries, and
lower air fares. Since the'travel cost to the foreigner i is
~ higher in relation to his average income than it is. to the
_ American, the foreign traffic is more likely to’ respond |
sharply to fare reductions. And evidence submitted in the
record, based upon U. S. Department of Commerce sur-_
veys in numerous foreign countries, indicates a sizeable
demand for travel to this country which can be tapped by
-. lower fare services.
. Moreover, it seems clear that ica will be particu-
larly attracted by low fare services combined with an all-
- expense package such as would be available under inclusive
tour charters. By assuring lower predetermined travel
12187
costs, such tours would mitigate the foreigners’ fear of
unknown high costs which they might otherwise encounter
.in traveling in the United States.. The record in the pro-
- ceeding’ is replete with evidence as to the tremendous
popularity of inclusive.tours in Europe, a matter. which
has been considered by the examiner in great-detail in his
| | a: ” 552a°. a;
(12137, 12138) | cad ears o
- recommended decision and which therefore-need not : be’
repeated - ‘here.™ ..
' Thus, there is every indication that vigorous promotion
of lower fare services both here and abroad would generate
at least as many foreign originations as U. S. originations.
And there is. ng reason to believe that the foreign market
will.not be vigorously promoted. Evidence introduced into
the proceeding indicates that. U. S.- travel agents have
facilities available in foreign countries which would be
“used for promoting tours. Moreqger, the supplemental —
carriers will have strong incentives to develop foreign-
generated business. Their needs to maintain and increase
their utilization of equipment and expand their civil char-
ter revenues will constitute powerful economic. incentives
- to promote a maximum amount of foreign traffic. Further, ©
they will be way aware of the fact that the authority which
we are giving them is of a limited duration, and they will
have no asstirance of a renewal of that authority if it de-
velops that the tour operations do not — promote
travel to the United — ua
<4 ae 19188 so |
One final comment on. this subject appears appropriate.
If U. S. carriers’ efforts. to promote travel are to be re
- stricted in the interest of the balance of payments policy,
™ See soneeienetel decision, PP. ‘56-65.
= Moreover, regulations governing inclusive tour charters ¥
require the reporting of data which will enable us to assess
extent to which foreign-generated | travel is being promoted. If.
such data indicate that inbound travel is not being adequately pro-
moted, the Board will be. in a position ‘to take necessary action,
including the suspension of inclusive tour oumecas pursuant to
section 401(g) of the Act.
. ee cares et aN : " be EPIENIA SS GARI EEG LENE
553a
: (12138, 12139)
we ‘find it inappropriate and inequitable to single out the
supplementals as: the special target. These carriers are
small business enterprises struggling to gain a foothold
in air transportation markets, Their ability to compete. in
these markets .is réstricted by the limitations on their
authority, confined as it is to chatter services only. These
carriers have proved'to be an essential factor in our national
defense civil augmentation airlift system, making substan; .
tial contributions in time of national crisis. The United
States thus has a‘sizeable stake in their continued survival | |
and viability. Inclusive tour authority will make a contri- -
- bution to that continued viability. Finally, we believe that
' it is particularly inequitable to force these carriers to- ‘bear —
the brunt of the balance of payments policy, while the route
earriers remain free to promote and’ stimulate travel
abroad to an extent which completely dwarfs any likely
: future participation by the i tamaaeaal carriers in these
markets.
_, 12139
Landing Rights
The route carriers contend that a grant of the authority
‘recommended by the examiner would confront the govern-
ments of the world with a blanketing of new authority to
numerous carriers, that: such action would have serious
effeet upon current and future bilateral negotiations de-
~ signed to strengthen the operating rights of existing Amer- .
ican carriers, and would require bargaining away rights’
that ares necessary for the.,most effective . scheduled
American-flag transportation.
Obviously, any additional landing rights that may be
necessary will) have to be 5 obiainied, from various foreign
EN al aed aren Herey ict
554a
(12189, 12140)
"%
governments’ before the supplemental carriers can 'in- ‘
augurate service under the foreign authorizations. However,
this is not a new or unusual situation, but is, in fact, one
that has arisen in many past cases in which awards found |
required by. the’ public convenience and necessity have
involved operations for which we lacked requisite rights
' from ‘the appropriate foreign governments. The Board has
ee not withheld the grant of certificate authority to U. S. route
- applicants becausé ihauguration of the services would re-
quire additional rights. :
The precise effect that any given sent may ‘have on the
future course of bilateral negotiations or other govern- ”
mental arrangements must necessarily be conjectural. How-
| ever, there is: “fiothing here to indicate that. the authority ve
being granted the supplemental carriers will have the.»
repercussions that the route carriers fear. The fact is*
cn — s9140 op
- that only a limited number of carriers are being granted
authority to serve each of the foreign countries at issue in
the proceeding, . and these carriers, ‘by the very nature of ©
their authority, will not be operating over fixed routes or“
providing regularly scheduled ‘services. We find nothing. ©
that would make it necessary or appropriate in this case —
to depart from the practice that has long been followed in
—" new foreign certificate authority.
& :) Carter Selection.
| All of the applicants awarded foreign charter authority
_ challenge the examiner’s choice of carriers to serve the
BA,
(12140, 12141)
specific. geographic areas designated: Essentially, the
argument of the individual ‘applicants is not that they should
. be chosen in lieu of some applicant selected by the examiner,
but rather is that they should be given authority to serve
certain of the geographic areas in addition to the carriers :
sélected by the examiner,
In selecting the carriers to serve the various geographic
areas, the examiner took. into consideration such ° relevant
factors as the potential of the markets. involved;. the
operational capability of each applicant. as indicated by its-
size, scope of operations, financial posture, and equipment;
the historic experience of the applicant; and the need of a
_ given applicant for authority that would afford it a reason-
- able. opportunity bes future growth. We have carefully
12141
considered the objections that. Kave been raised and find :
that they present nothing that would require or warrant
conclusions different from those reached by the examiner.
We recognize that certain carriers will be authorized to
serve markets in which they have had little or no experience,
‘and other. applicants will not be authorized to serve coun-
tries they have served in the past.” However, a resolution
‘of the carrier selection question requires a weighing and
balancing of a number of considerations and the exeréise of
judgments based upon them. We are satisfied that the |
. The various applicants also cliallenge the examiner’ s failure
to award the qualified carriers uniform overseas and foreign char-
ter authority as a.class, We agree with the examiner’s conclusion “3
that “elass” authority should -not be granted.
18 We find unsupported and without merit the contention that
various carriers will have no interest in serving, or incentive to
sisemaae: charter een to certain of the countries or, areas.
Pte RT RPO
ie a - 56a,
=, a . | a
.
- examiner’s judgments were reasonable. and sound and should
not be disturbed. 14
Qualifications of diebtionite ae,
\
The route carriers, although not questioning the qualifi-
“eations of the applicants to provide domestic and trans- .
border eivil charters or worldwide military charters; attack
_ their ““gperational” fitness to provide overseas and the
more extensive foreign civil charters: They contend that the. -
applicants fail to meet the fitness ‘standards of section
401(a) (2 ). for the latter services, since they submitted no
‘plans o operation showing proposed frequencies, points
to be served, and estimated profit and loss by areas, and ©
5 _demonstpated an absence of both facilities and ‘personnel -
a: abroad and. (in most invtenees) | the availability of . jet
o
12142,
exaipmnset which they -assert. is required ¢ to ave interna-
tional. charters -public appeal.
It can hardly. be seriously contended that ‘the. ial.
mental carriers, who are admittedly qualified fo conduct
.. domestic charter operations, services for the military on a‘
_ worldwide basis, and, whose managements : the interveners. '
concede “to be exeellent, ” 25 are operationally. unfit to con-
| duct foreign and overseas charters.’ We are not here deal-
ing ‘with nonéperating: applicants seeking fresh entry into
. the field of air transportation, but with established carriers
| who have — ‘engaged i in air ae for. ms
14 'Phe argument by certain of the applicants for a | redescription
- of the geographic areas marked out by the examiner do not bg sae
any change in his sa
15 Oral an Tr. 308.:
FS. a le % ; : nee ‘
57a
number of years. The Board wn not conteaniatty ‘required
- that certificate applicants for new route authority. ‘establish
their qualifications in terms of separate and independent
proof pertaining to every kind of service they will be able-to
_ provide under their certificates. We find it neither neces-
sary .nor_ appropriate to require the applicants here to
submit detailed . plans | and estimates of their proposed
“operations . in overseas and: foreign air transportation . as
separate criteria of operational ability... -
Upon consideration of the record, we: conclude that those
' applicants which we found qualified in our opinion in the
domestic phase of the case to provide services ‘between the
50 States, are likewise fit, willing, and able to perform fhe
transportation — ws in the ee and fogeign
9
are: 99143 |
" 2 6 “Terms and Conditions eis
- The matter of the terms ‘and conditions ik be ittndied to
(12149, 12143) .
o- supplemental operating authority -was: considered at -
some’ length in the recommended decision and in. our de-
- cision in the domestic phase ofthe. case.. The certificates
issued contemporaneously herewith will be subject to the
same basic: regulatory. provisions as those applicable to
domestic operations. Accordingly, we are. concurrently.
issuing appropriate amendments to Parts 208 and 378 to
make them’ —— to the. foreign and ,overseas certifi-
& eates.. os 3 es :
o ‘ to : i) ~
16The applicants found ctmanlified for an award of seis
"authority are a:
more de ling overseas and — authority.
tori unqualified for an award of broatier and
arte ep ay entegiines dvr eras
_ States and points in Canada;
—-558a
ieee: 12144)
‘ . > iad
We have considered the remaining contentions of the
parties and their exceptions to the recommended decision:
and find that, except as indicated herein, they should not
alter the results we have reached.
Accordingly, in view of all of the foregoing, including
‘the findings. previously. set forth by the Board upon. the
issues heretofore determined herein, and upon consid-
- eration of the record, we find that the — convenience —
and necessity ‘require:
1. That certificate authority to engage in overseas and
foreign. supplemental air transportation of ‘persons and
| property for a five-year period he granted to |
(a) Johnson and Purdue between points in the United
." 2 12144 me Oas
(b) American Flyers, Modern, and Zantop between points
in the United States, on the one hand, and points i in —
and ‘Mexico, on the’ other hand ;,
(c) American Flyers, Capitol, Saturn, Southern, TIA,
~ and World between points in the age States and points
in the Caribbean ;”
~~ (d) TIA and World biktroen bina in the United rey
on the one hand, and points i in Central and: South America,
on the other hand;
11 For the purpose of this proceeding, the Caribbean shall be
defined to include points in Jamaica, the Bahama Islands, Bermuda,
Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico; the Virgin Islands,
' Trinidad, Aruba, the ‘Leeward ‘and Windward Islands, and any
i place located in the Gulf of Mexico or the Caribbean Sea.
ee -
559a
(12144, 12145)
.(e) Southern, TIA, and World between points in the
‘United States and points in the Transpacific.**
2. That the foregoing carriers also be authorized for an
' indefinite..period to provide charters of persons and
property. for the Department of Defense in overseas,
' foreign, and intraterritorial air transportation, subject ta
certain conditions.’®
We further find: - .
1. That the carriers listed above are each citizens of the
United States within the meaning of the Act, and are fit,
Or a a hee
willing, and able properly to perform the supplemental air -
transportation hereinabove authorized to be performed by
_ each of them and to conform to the provisions of the Act.
and the rules, regulations, and requirements thereunder.
2. That the public interest requires the amendment. of
Part 378 of the Special Regulations and Part 208 of the
Kconomic Regulations effective upon the effective date of.
the certificates to be issued hérewith. Vee
* 3. That, except to the extent otherwise indicated herein
and in our previous -order, all applications and motions
involved in this proceeding should -be denied.
3° For the purpose of this. proceeding; the Transpacific ‘shall be
defined to include American Samoa, Guam, Johnston Island, the
Marshall Islands, Okinawa, Wake Island, and points in Austra-
asia, Indonesia and Asia as far west as longitude 70 degrees west -
via a Transpacific routing.
_ 7° We are revising the certificates attached to the recommended -
decision so as to delete “on a planeload basis” in paragraph 2 since
charters for the Department of Defense are not limited to plane- |
load charters. ;
°
ee ee
=e s-
560a
(12148, 12146) his,
Appropriate orders will be. sheesh '
Vice Chairman Murpny and Member Mrnetr: concurred
in the above opinion. -Member GILLILLAND concurred and
dissented, filing the attached statement. Chairman Murray
and Member Avams did not take’ part in the decision.
12146 -
GILLILLAND, Member, CoNCURRING AND DissENTING:
For the reasons stated in the dissent attached to Order
E-23350, March 11, 1966, supplemental air carriers should
not be authorized to ‘operate all-expense’ tours in foreign :
air transportation.’ I will add two observations.
The Board concludes that all-expense tours will have
little or-no effect-upon balance of payments. If the new
program is to accomplish anything it will involve wide -
participation by tour operators and their agents ‘who have
little or no experience in generating foreign air travel to
the United States. These persons,acking knowledge, ex-
perience, facilities, and sufficient motivation: to overcome
such limitations, will certainly not produce as much travel
to the United States as from it; or as much expenditure of |
foreign funds within our country as of United States funds
abroad. Such results have not yet been reached. by the air
carriers long in the market, which suffer under no similar
disadvantages, and despite major efforts in that direction.
There can be no doubt that the program will. have a
significant adverse effect on the balance of payments. .
1 Examples of regularly scheduled transportation authorized to
tour operators under this decision are: New York-Caracas, Rio de
_ Janeiro, Buenos Aires, New York-West Coast-Honolulu-Tokyo.
4
g
~ 56la
(12146, 12147):
Furthermore, the Board ignores the effect upon bilateral
-air route negotiations, which are difficult’ enough .in.any
event. The complicating effect of existing supplemental
authorizations has already been made manifest in several
bilateral negotiations, as is well known to all participants
- therein. The new program will complicate the matter fur-
12147 |
ther, and to the —— of the foreign authorizations of
our. regularly. certificated scheduled carriers which are
essential to the integrity of our international route system. «+
/s/ WHItney GILLILLAND
62a
12148
APPENDIX A
(See opposite) <
Foreigners
Americans
‘Foreigners .
Ameri cans
280
563a
: | |
AIR TRAVELERS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES - an
AND OTHER COUNTRIES BY CITIZENSHIP - si‘
. . (thousands of -travelers both ways) 1/
~ 1,340 1,580 1,860 1,950. 2,240 2,390 3,058
2,450 2,760 3,040 3,110 oe,’ 4,598
\ Peas f > i es ie fe
INCREASES | | |
1958-59. 1959-60 1960-61 1961-62 1962-63 + 1963-04
ee ee a ee
| = 280 - 90|. | “~~ 400 ae 450° pies 638
VY Exclusive of travel over Land borders ‘teenies Nectoen | air travel since lansing 1958),
crewmen, military personnel, and travelers between the United States and its possessions.
. Sources U. S. Department of Justice, Immigration and Naturalization evinn:
&
a Use an %
; d64a copeaaer™
-(12149) Sods
AES > 12149
, Order No. E- 24237
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA °
Civ: Axponavttos Boarp . . ©
Wasuineron, D. C.
‘ Adopted by the Civil Aeronautica Board
at its office in Washington, D.C.
on the 11th day of March, 1966
Docket 13795 et al.
SuppreMenTAL Arr Service ProceepINc _
dD,
| ORDER .
’ A full.public hearing having been held in the above: -
entitled proceeding and the Board, upon consideration of |
the record, having issued its opinion containing its findings, :
| conclusions, and decision ;
Ir Is Cuninean:
1. That certificatés of public ¢ convenience and necessity
for supplemental air transportation inthe forms attached .
héreto be issued to American Flyers Airline Corp.,-Capitol
| Airways, Inc., Johnson Flying Service, In¢, Modern Air
Trangport, Inc., Purdue Aeronautics ' orn. .. Saturn. Air-
se x . ways, Ixc., Southern Air Transport, Inc., Trans Interna-
a SE oe Ine., World Airways, Inc., and en Air
ia? Transport, Inc. . A |
—~ ptt
5658
24s, 12150)
2. That said ssiiliiaiat shall be signed on- ‘behalf of the
Board by its Secretary, shall have affixed thereto the seal
of the Board, and, ‘subject to extension of. their effective
dates in accordance with. the provisions’ of said ecteseetad :
shall be effective on November 26, 1966.
_ 3. That-all applieations conustidina hevein for supple-
mental certificates insofar as such. applications seek au-
thority. for overseas and/or. foreign air transportation- and/
or air transportation between: places in the same territory .
’ or possession heretofore filed by Conner Air Lines, Ine., .
Holiday Airways, Inc., Stew art Air Set'vice, and United
. ~ States Overseas Airlines, Ine., be and they, hereby are -
denied. ae ; eta
-4, That, except to the extent. otherwise: indicated,” all =
applications consolidated herein for supplemental certifi-
12150
hes cates, insofar as such applications seek: authority for over-
_seas-and/or foreign air transportation and/or air trans-
portation between places in the same territory or posses-
sion, heretofore filed by the carriers listed in paragraph 1s
of. this order be and they hereby are denjed.
5. That this order shall be. effective upon the date of
its approval by ‘the President of the United States.
By the Civil Aeronautics Board: 7
| : ae ‘Hanowp R. SAnpERson
2 . Secretary
. (Szat) }
Tue Waite House *
"APPROVED:
Lynpon B. Jonnson |
September.27,1966 aoe ake
’ . . , \
Sd ° c 4
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.