Jurisdictional Statement — Florida East Coast Railway Co. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1967
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
‘
.
.
. ©
, >
rs) ®
s *
,
.
-
.
°
‘
» .
|
.
Se 8 ge ns
e
*
2
.
*@é +.”
.
.
-
e
a ! -
»
.
’ ‘
,.
~_—
‘
.
‘
-
‘ a
‘
-
>
o
.
PY
«
=<
a ~
- .
free ARYL octet ig6s
Pr ty. = $ :
©. ane THE
Syone Court of the United States
OcToBER TERM, 1966
| No. v4 l 718
| Fronpa E East Coast Rarway Company, Appellant,
v.
Utrep STATES OF AMERICA, INTERSTATE COMMERCE
. COMMISSION, et al., —*
On Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Middle District of Florida
JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT
~~ A, Atvis Layne |
“or Wu A. CHESNUTT fone
Pennsylvania Building
‘Washington, D. C.
Attorneys for Appellant,
Florida East Coast
Ratlway Company
FREDERICK H. Kent : apart
' - Florida National Bank Building
Jacksonville, Florida
' Of Counsel .
October 1966
Press or Byron S. Avams Pauvtine, Inc., Wasuineron, D.C.
=>,
en Di a a ee - s 2 |
>
.
°
’
.
a ce ;
.
° “ ‘
. . .
. ,
. . |
7 .
-
*
*
« oud
’
: ’
; t
.
. . ,
|
. .
“
’
“
-
SERS Mere ety meteny CTO)
Columbia Broadcasting System v. United States, 316
Eeéles v. Peoples Bank, 333 U.S. 496 (1948) «-.0......
. INDEX»
| ; ee '- Page
Opinions Below .......... rer Coe ceeeeoences oe. . 2
Jurisdiction -...... mish dase biaboedbaewl ER Pe A oe ae
Statutes Involved .....3..0......0065 rrr Terr 8
. TARE 5 6 sicic ink ce naneteccen cian ban 3
- Staternent of the Case .......... Fee errr ns aoe
The Question Is Substantial ....... Loseccveecctecces OT
CU, £55535 c hk chases one ees eccernsse sees 14
FE Appendix A (Opinion and Judgment of the United
States District Court for the Middle District of
Florida). ......... Dascccecendstasecwoetibopiec la
_ Appendix B (Report: of the Interstate Commerce Com
> mission) Ja éhsde be Rotebbs thd kesrcetecu weak: Ta
Appendix C (Order of the Interstate Commerce Com- a
— MIBSION) «06%. cece essen es eee aces iWedctheesees 19a .
Appendix D (Report and ‘Recommended. Order of the -
Commission’s Hearing Examiner) ........ eceees Zla
Appendix E (Statutes Involved) ..-......... Serre 4la
TABLE OF.CASES CITED * ~~ |
Alleghany Corp. v. Breswick & Co., 353 US. 151 (1957) . 10
_ Arrow Transportation Co. v. Cincinnati, N.0. & T.P.
me SS ge ks | rere 8
Baggett Transportation Co —Purchase—Bishop, 36.
ED hha boc o's bd nmeasare'ddecvecends 9fn.
- Chicago & N.W. Ry. v. Chicago, M., StP. & Pac. Ry., :
S80 US. 448 (1965) ool. cnc sesestececeaveecesce
U.S. 407 iB a ea el
ii _° Index Continued |
es | Page |
- Florida East Coast Ry. ‘tien, 170 LC. C. 171 .
| EO Ree eh. Fens ge” ee Pee Pee
Miami Municipal R.R. Extension, 170 1.C.C. 175 (1931) 4..
‘Northern Pac. Ry. —Construction, . 295 = I1.C.C. 281
SE ciaievetes hawecevsathoas 40 Oantbe oeaer -, 9fn.~<
Seaboard Air Line R.R. "Mer or—-hidlntic Coast Line
FER. 320 1.0.C. 122 (1968) .... 0. ecb c ccc cc eaee 4
te Seaboard Air Line R.R. v- United States, 382 U.S. 154 |
DE aie cc bin heh ate based weedseebaswkeba dn « <4,8
a a. v. Bliss ‘6 Laughlin, Ine., 371 US. 70
re Oe er er 8
Western Pac. R.R. v. United States, 382 U.S. 237 (1965) 2
viet - STATUTES CITED
:. Judicial Code (Title 28 United States Code) :
Teen ce uenbeanen 2
EES 2 ae Oe ICO 2
RE AR SS FO a 2
Sections 2321-25 2.0.2... . cece eee e cece eeeeees » 3
Administrative Procedure Act: © .
Section 10(c), 5 U.S.C. §1009(c) ............. cog OS
Interstate Commerce Act:
_ Sections 1(18)- (20), 49 U.S. C. §§1(18)- (20) . .3, 6, 8, 9,
oo , 12
Section 1(22), 49 US. C. 81 (22) Diss inie bein 3°
Section 3(5), 49 U.S.C. §3(5) ..... ole. .2, 6, 7; 89 13
INTHE:
Supreni Court of the Buited Staten
' OCTOBER ‘TERM, 1966
Fiona East Coast Ramway Company} Appellant, °
v. |
UNITED STATES OF ‘Kioteinn, INTERSTATE (COMMERCE .
. _ COMMISSION, et al., Appellees.
>
On Appeal from the United States District Court for dl
| Middle District of Florida ;
_ JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT
i
4
Florida East Coast Railway Company (East Coast)
appeals from the judgment of the United- States Dis-
trict Court for the Middle District of Florida, entered
June 24, 1966, dismissing a complaint to set aside
orders of the Interstate Commerce Commission. © Kast
Coast submits this statement to show, that the Supreme .
Court of the United States has jurisdiction of the —
appeal and that a substantial question is presented.
s
OPINIONS:
The opinion. of the three-judge District Court en-
tered-on June 24, 1966, is not yet reported. That.
. opinion and the judgment of the District Court aré
‘printed as Appendix .A (pp. la-6a, infra.). The report.’
‘of the Interstate Commerce. Commission, Division 3, _-
dated March 17, 1965, is reported at 327 1.C.C. 1 and
printed as Appendix B (pp. 7a-18a, infra.). The ,
’ order entered by the Commission in connection with
its report. is printed as Appendix © (pp. 19a-20a,. -
infra.). The report and recommended ‘order of the
Commission’s Hearing Examiner are printed as > .
i, pendix D (pp. ee tufra.).
JURISDICTION
This: action was brought under 28 U.8.C. §§ 1336
and 2321-25 to set asidé orders of the Commission
entered under section 3(5) of the Interstate Commerce _
Act, 49. U.S.C. §3(5). The United States-and the
Commission answered. Seaboard Air Line Railroad |
Company (Seaboard), -the Greater Miami Traffic As-
sociation, and - Dade County, Florida, intervened as .
parties defendant. ,
The judgment of the District Court was wid .
- June 24, 1966. Notice of appeal was filed August: 23,
1966: The Supreme Court has jurisdiction under 28
U.S.C. §§ 1253 and 2101(b) to review the judgment
below on direct appeal. This jurisdiction is sustained
by decisions in Western, Pac. R.R. v.. United States,
382 U.S. 237 (1965), and Chicago & N.W. Ry. v. Chi-
cago, M., St. P. & Pac. Ry., 380 U.S. 448 (1965).
a4
STATUTES INVOLVED <a
‘Section’ 3(5) of the Interstate Commerée Act, 49
. « Uy 8.0. § 3(5), is the ‘principal statutory provision in-
volved. Sections 1(18)-(0) and 1(22y of the Act,
49 U.S.C. §§ 1(18)-(20), 1(Q2), are also pertinent to
. the issues raised. Section 10(c) of the Administrative
‘Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. § 1009(c), specifies the type
of Commission orders that are properly the subject of —
judicial review. All of these statutory provisions are
set out i in: — E (pp. 41a-44a, wmfra.).* |.
‘QUESTION PRESENTED
Is an order of the Commission authorizing certain
rail operations final and ,properly the..subject of —
judicial review if the overall plan of rail operation |
pee requires the construction’ of connecting rail lines for
* which no certificate of public convenience and necessity |
under, section 1(18) of the Act has been sought or
issued, and the Commission has reserved decision on
the need for and issuance of any such certificate?
_ STATEMENT OF THE. CASE
East Coast and Seaboard are interstate railroads.
Both carriers: operate, main rail lines between Miami
and J. acksonville, Florida, including directly parallel
lines along the east coast of Florida between Miami «|
and West Palm Beach. East Coast’s line continues —
north from West Palm Beach along the east coast of
Florida to Jacksonville. This line and several short .
branch lines springing from it constitute East Coast’s:
entire railroad system. Freight traffic “moving to or
- from points beyond East Coast’s system is inter-
changed at Jacksonville with Seaboard, Atlantic Coast
Line Railroad:Company,.and the Southern Railway
ws =
- Company and its affiliates in the Southern Railway
~ System. Seaboard also eonnects at Jacksonville with
the latter two rail systems, as well as with its own
system of lines extending into the states of Virginia,
. North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Ala-
bama: East Coast and Seaboard are thus direct com-
petitors for rail traffic originating at or destinéd to
Miami ‘to: thé extent that such: traffic moves to and
' from points beyond Jacksonville, or points in Florida
commonly served by East Coast and Seaboard. See
‘Seaboard Air Line R.R.—Merger—Atlantic Coast
Line R.R., 320 1.C.C. 122 (1963), rev’d sub nom. Flor-. -
ida East Coast Ry. v: United States, 242 F. Supp. 14
(M.D. Fla.), vacated per curiam sub nom. Seaboard
, Air Tine R.R. v. United States, 382 U.S. 154 (1965),
aff'd sub nom. Florida’ East* Coast Ry. v. United ©
States, No. 64-64-Civ. J., M.D. Fla., June 8, 21966,
' appeal docketed, 35 U.S. L. Week 3141 (U. S. Oct. 18, ;
1966) (Nos. 638 and 641).~
“East Coast and Seaboard both ‘serve the existing
port at Miami by operating over tracks of the Miami
Municipal Railway. Plorida East Coast Ry. Opera-
tion, 170 1.C.C. 171 (1991) ; > Miami Municipal R.R. Ex-
tension, 170 I.0.C. 175 (1931). The Seaport Depart-
ment of Metropolitan Dade County proposes, however,
to transfer all port activities at Miami to’new port facil-
ities, which it is constructing at Dodge Island, located
- -in Biscayne Bay, south nd east: of the existing port
- (Tr. 29, 75-77).* «Parallel vehicular and _ railroad
bridges will join Dodge Island with the mainland to
—_—__oe
* Reference to the record will be indicated by’ the following
abbreviations : ~
Tr. “Transeripi of hedring before the Commiasion’s Examiner.
Ex. Exhibits received in, a at the hearing.
“soe | ema | sanemas | Is
; ;
ap RUE Be |
oo
L_Js
wWL/L_ILIL
oe oe
oY
_—— + + + + eo +
- 2 SS
_ PRESENT
yf °
. +++ Trocks of Florida East Coast Railwoy
>). BISCAYNE _
| BAY: |
“+++ Tracks of Miami Municipal Railway
+++ Proposed FEC connecting track to‘Dodge Isiond
+++ Tracks of Dade County Seaport Department
5
afford access to the port by motor and rail’ common
carriers (Tr. 84-85). The Seaport Department will
‘provide tracks on Dodge Ishand and .on the bridge to —
the mainland. The map opposite this page depicits ex- -
isting and proposed rail lines.in downtown Miami,
' showing their location ‘with — ‘to the two port _
facilities.
In August 1962, the Seaport Department requested
_-East Coast and Seaboard to’make arrangements for
providing rail service to the new port. East Coast re-
_ sponded with a proposal to reach the railroad bridge
to Dodge Island by building at its expense a short
corinecting track fromthe end of the spur that springs
from East Coast’s north-south main line at the inter-
section of 8th Street and 1st Avenue and continues
eastward between N.E. 6th and 7th Streets, terminat-
ing at the P&O Docks (Map): East Coast proposed
_to move its own cars and those of Seaboard to and
from the port via this route. Seaboard’s cars would .
ke moved betweem ihe carriers’ existing interchange
point at N.W. 11th Street and the port for a. charge
_ reflecting East Coast’s costs in performing such service
(Tr. 201, 203-205).
‘Seaboard responded to the Seaport Department’s
request with a proposal (1) to construct a connecting
track from a point on the line of the Miami Municipal
Railway west of the intersection of that line with East
Coast’s north-south main line to the main line track
of Kast Coast. in the vicinity of N.W. 11th Street and’
1st Avenue (Map), and (2) to construct at joint ex-
pense with East Coast the connecting track leading to |
‘the western abutment of thy Dodge Island railroad
bridge. Seaboard insisted that it be permitted to move
. its cars to and from the port with its own locomotives,
ie
using these two connecting tracks in conjunction with
-East Coast’s existing tracks, which constitute the
_ major portion of the route. Seaboard rejected East
' ° Coast’s proposal to move both carriers’ cars td and
_ from the port with East Coast locomotives and over
East Coast tracks.
Seaboard sought to implement its proposal by fling
with the Commission on February 25, 1963, an appli-
eation under section.3(5) of the Interstate Commerce
Act, 49 U.S.C. §3(5), for an order requiring East
- Coast to permit Seabgard to operate as a rail carrier
_ over the involved tracks of East Coast. Seaboard did
not at that time, and has not since, filed any application
seeking a' certificate under section 1(18) of the Act, 49
U.8.C. § 1(18), authorizing it to construct and operate
over the connecting ‘tracks essential to its proposed ~
route.’ East Coast protested ‘Seaboard’s application —
_ . under section 3(5). The Greater Miami Traffic ‘As- |
© sociation, on behalf.of Metropolitan Dade County and
_ the Seaport Fae sacra intervened in — of
Seaboard.
Hearings were ‘held before a ‘Commission Hearing:
Examiner, who recommended that the application be
_ grarited (Appendix D, pp. 21a-40a).. East Coast took
exception to the Examiner’s recommended order; Sea-
board and the Greater Miami ‘Traffic Association
replied.
1The basic prerequisite for approval of the quasi-condemnation
under section 3(5) is a finding by the Commission that the opera-
tiqnal plan is ‘‘in the public interest.””
2 The standard of proof required for a certificate under section
1(18) isa showing that ‘‘present or future public convenience and,
necessity require or will require’’ the Stet construction and
operatioc. .
+
%
—— ews
- .
| . 7 .
Division 3 of the Commission’ affirmed the result
recommended by the Examiner, concluding that use of .
East Coast facilities by Seaboard was reasonably re-
quired in the public interest, and that Seaboard’s pro-
posed operations would be practicable and would not
. substantialty impair the ability of East Coast tohandle
its own business (327 I.C.C. at 8; Appendix B, p. 17a).
_The Commission prefaced its conclusion with the fol-
lowing discussion : .
The application under sinictiiaaiibin constitutes a:
- portion of an overall plan to afford continued joint
service to the new port . . . However, no applica-
tion is pending for consideration of other essential
track: construction projects, nor is our approval
of the application here to be construed as author--
izing such construction (327 1.6.C- at 7; Appendix
B, p- 15a) (footnote omitted).
The Commission also conditioned Seaboard’s. use of
East Coast tracks (1) upon terms and compensation
to be agreed upon, by. Seaboard and East Coast, and
thereafter ‘found by the Commission to be just and
reasonable; or alternatively (2) upon such terms and
compensation as the Commission may fix .as-just and
reasonable after further hearing at the request of
East Coast and/or Seaboard (Appendix C, p. 19a).
-.Compensation and terms have not been fixed under
either alternative; nor has either party petitioned for
further hearing on these issues. |
East Coast petitioned for reconsideration by the full
Commission on the ground that the proceeding in-
volved issues of general iatligiememal importance.
The petition was denied. - ;
On May 26, 1965, East Coast filed its complaint in
_ the court below to set aside and enjoin the Commis-
sion’s order granting Seaboard’s section 3(5) applica-
eo
8
tion. The District Court dismissed the complaint and
' affirmed the Commission’s order if an. opinion and:
* judgment entered June 24, 1966. -The District Court
held that thé Comgission’s order was final and:
judicially reviewdble,-and that the Commission was -
empowered under section 3(5) to assume jurisdiction
over Seaboard’s application and to require East Coast
to permit use of its tracks by Seaboard (Appendix A,
pp. 3a, 4a). The District Court concluded ‘‘that the |
Commission’ S findings are amply supported by the.
record) considered as a whole” (Appendix A, P- me
THE QUESTION IS SUBSTANTIAL
71s an order of the Commission authorizing certain
rail operations final and properly the subject of judicial
review if the overall plan of rail operation,.requires
the construction of connecting rail lines for which no
certificate of public convenience and necessity under
section 1(18) of the Act has been sought or issued,
and the Commission has reserved decision on the need
_ for and issuance of any such certificate? It is the posi-
tion of appellant that the court below erred in answer-
ing this question &ffirmatively. It is also appellant’s
position that the lower court’s error may appropriately
be corrected by this Court summarily. See United
' States v. Bliss & Laughlin, Inc., 371 U.S. 70 (1962) ;
Arrow Transportation Co. v. Cincinnati, N.O: &
T.P.R.R., 379 U.S. 642 (1965); Seaboard Air Line
RR. v. United States, 382 U.S. 154 (1965).
Whe issue of finality is substantial, not merely
‘ academic. The only part of Seaboard’s overall pré-
posal that has been determined by :the Commission’s
order is whether it-is in‘the publie interest. to require
East — to permit use of its tracke ~~ Seaboard as
°“"@
a ec aeemeacaemaaeaaamaaaaaaammaaaaaaaaacaaaaaasaaaaaaaaaaaaacaaaacaasasaaas aaa
9
part of Seaboard’s route: to the new port. The Com-
mission concedes: that its determination covers only
part of an overall operational plan, which can be im-
plemented only after essential connecting tracks have
been constructed by Seaboard under a certificate ‘‘that
the present’or future public convenience and necessity
requiré or will require’’ construction and operation of
such tracks. The overall plan thus must be shown to
be required by “‘strong and urgent public need.’’* This
showing has not been made; in fact, the overall plan
has not even been presenteg, for adjudiéation.
The failure of Seaboard to present its-section 1(18) :
‘application and the willingness of theeCommission to ©
_ decide the section 3(5) application in a vacuum have
precluded sensible administrative determination of the
overall proposal in terms of the applicable standard
of. public convenience and necessity. East Coast, in
the action below and in this appeal, has sought to pre-
vent the Commission’s anomalous procedure °from
creating a roadblock to meaningful judicia] review
and further unnecessary litigation. East Coast was
compelled to challenge the Commission’s order to guard
against the apparent determination of legal rights in
. that order.’ The use of tracks pursuant to section 3(5)
would not be in issue in the Commission’s later separate
determination of the remaining portions of Seaboard’s
proposal. The lower court’s decision has not removed
the dilemma posed by the Commission’s severed treat-
ment of Seaboard’s overall proposal. This Court has,
in the past, provided for consolidated judicial review —
8 Northern Pac. Ry.—Construction, 295 I.C.C. 281; 295 (1956). .
The Commission has frequently defined public convenience and
necessity: a8 requiring a higher degree of proof than mere ‘con-
° sistency with the public interest. Baggett Transportation Co.—
Purchase—Bishop, 36 M.C.C. 659, 664 (1941).
oe:
10 |
_» of two separate Commission actions in which the later
action perfects and makes imminent the injury threat-
ened, but not perfected, in the first. Alleghany Corp.
v. Breswick & Co., 353 U.S. 151, rehearing denied;
353 U.S. 989 (1957). East Coast therefore appeals
to this Court to correct the error below by summarily
vacating the judgment of the District Court and re-
manding the case to that court with directions to review
the challenged order when and if it becomes final as a
result of further adjudication on Seaboard’s overall
plan. This relief will prevent unnecessary and incon-
clusive litigation and will assure meaningful and
simultaneous judicial review of all relevant legal issues .
raised by Seaboard’s overall ree to _— rail
service at the new port. :
The Commission’s -order states: “It t is further
ordered, that the Florida East Coast Railway Company
be, and it is hereby, notified and required to permit
. the- Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company to use that
portion of the tracks and terminal facilities, as de-
seribed in. the report. . .”’ (Appendix ©, p. 19a).
The track ‘‘described in the report’’ is that portion of
East Coast main track that Seaboard would reach via
‘‘a 585-foot connecting track in the vicinity of ‘N.W.
llth Stgeet and N.W. 1st’ Avenue,” which Seaboard
plans to construct, own, and maintain (327 I.C.C. at
5; Appendix B, p. 12a). The ae en track —
not now exist.‘ ;
A East Coast would have to reduce the length 0 two yard tracks.
by approximately 110 feet each to allow construction of a south-
bound switching track onto East Coast’s main line track at this
point. (Tr. 34). Seaboard has not-approached the City of Miami -
for a permit to construct this connection (Tr. 143), and has not
* contacted the two property owners (one of whom is East: Coast)
whose land ‘will be traversed by the proposed connection (Tr. 144).
'
a ea a ee
It .
Seaboard can not construct that connection—and ~
consequently use East Coast’s track—uniless and until
it obtains from the Conimisston, pursuant:to the pro-
viggons’ of section 1(18) of the Act, a certificate autho-
rizing such construction. . The Commission, moreover,
; _ has expressly withheld its determination. of the section —
1(18) construction issue: ‘‘no application is pending
for consideration, of other essential track construction
projects, nor.is bur approval of the application here
to be construed as authorizing such construction’’ (327
_LC.C. at.7; Appendix ‘B, p. 15a).
The District Court found neither the absence of this
connecting track, nor the possibility ‘that the Commis-
sion might ultimately withhold approval of the con-
struction of that track, a bar to reviewability of the
Commission’s order. The Court held: ‘‘Seaboard
would be able to serve the port by obtaining acceptance
of a different type of connection or by using a pre-
existing, though possibly less efficient, cpnnection” —
(Appendix A, p.5a). The first alternative perpetuates,
rather than settles, the question of finality of the Com-
mission’s order. If Seaboard is to obtain ‘‘acceptance
of a different type of connection,’’ ‘that will be ac-
complished through further adjudication by the Com-
mission, after which the challenged order, read in
light of the Commission’s further action, might be coh-
sidered to have become final. The lower court’s second
. suggested alternative can not lawfully be accomplished.
under.the existing order. The Commission has ordered
' East Coast to permit Seaboard to use that portion of
East Coast tracks. “as described in the report’? (Ap-
pendix ©, p. 19a). Seaboard has not requested, nor
has the Commission authorized, use of East Coast
tracks via any other connection. The only use autho-
POI IN AG OAT AY NOE merges we
12
rized must be accémplished via a connection, which |
does not exist and for which no certificate of public
convenience and necessity has been sought or issued..
~~ Mic District Court relied on -this Court’s decision
in Columbia Broadcasting System v. United States,
316 U.S. 407 (1942), to support its holding that the
Comrhission’s order is final and reviewable (Appendix .
A, p. 3a). This Hourt stated in Columbia Broadcasting a
System: | . od a
The ultimate test of guvlonabiilicy is not to be
found in an overrefined technique, but in the need
of: the review to protect from the irreparable in-
. jury threatened in the exceptional case by adminis-
trative rulings which attec
- action taken in advance of other hearirfgs and —
adjudications that may follow, the results of which
an * i yocatcaoaa i gl to control Beas US. at
' Neither of the criteria established by this Court in
Columbia Broadcasting System. is satisfied by the order
here. This order does not ‘‘attach legal consequences °
h: legal ‘consequences to *
- to action taken in advance of other hearings and -
7 adjudications. that follow’’ simply because the only
action giving rise to legal! . consequences—Seaboard’s
use of East Coast tracks—can not be taken unless and
‘until Seaboard is ‘authorized.to and does, in fact, con-
struct the connection essential for reaching East Coast
tracks. With respect to the criterion that the chal-
lenged order must ‘purport to control’ future hear-
ings and adjudications under section 1(18), the District
Court expressly found this not to be so:
.» Even if Commission approval is needed; we sions
- presume that the Commission will disregard its
es " give East Coast a fair ee and” -
ne
;
oe VW &
— ‘ 2 : ee eae ee
eS a eo?
to ii the stricter ‘standart f “public. con--
venience and necessity.”” After such a: hearing, if
one is needed, the Commission “could, consistent
with the order now under wees withhold. its
‘ approval of the construction. . + (Appendix. A,
p. 5a).
The test laid. down in n Columbia Rycedeasting System |
supports appellant’s contention that. the order of the
Commission i is not reviewable at this time. .
The fion-finality of the order is further emphasized
by the Commission’s explicit retention of. jurisdiction
‘to reopen the proceeding for further pbéaring looking
to a determination and préscription of terms and com-
pensation’”’ (327 I.C.C. at 9; Appendix B, p. 18a).
‘Section 3(5) provides that ‘terms and compensation ©
may be agreed upon by the parties® or fixed by. the
Commission, but in either event, “such compensation .
shall be paid ‘or adequately sécured before the enjoy-
. ment of the use may be commenced.’’..'Terms and com-
pensation have not been. set,. much, less “paid or
adequately secured.”’ As ,
The totality of circumstances surroundjig imiplemen-*
‘tation of the Commission’s order are these East Coast. ~
- must permit use of its tracks by Seaboard if the Com-
mission authorizes eonstruction of Seaboard’s connect- ~
ing track and Seaboard. does,in fact, construct that
~ track, or if the Commission authorizes Seaboard to.
reach East. Coast tracks via some other connection;
- and if terms and compensation are agreed upon by the
parties and found to be just and reasonable by the.
5 The Commission has ordered that, even if the parties agree on |
, terms and compensation, their agreement must be submitted to the —
Commission for a finding that.the provisions of that agreement —
are just and eee bas aap C, p. 18a). x
\ ; ' of
e ‘ e o ¢
14
>
' Commission, or.are fixed by the Cominission; and °
if such compensation is paid or adequately se--
_ eured prior to Seaboard using the East Coast tracks.
Cf., Eccles v. Peoples Bank, 333 U.S. 426, 432 (1948).
The concurrente ‘of these contingent events must await
further action by the Commission. Until thé Com-
mission takes such action, the challenged order is not
_ final, nox, ripe for plenary review.
. CONCLUSION
The judgment of the District Court should be —
cated and the case remanded to that court with direc-
tions to review the chaften ged ayfer*when and if it
becomes final. . \
Respectfully submitted,
=‘. Atvis LAYNE -
' Wiw1aM A. CHESNUTT
\ Pennsylvania Building
Washington, D.C. —
Attorneys for Appellant,
¢ Florida East Coast
3 » Railway Company
: »
-FrepericK H. Kent ore
Florida National Bank “Building |
Jacksonville, Florida d ral,
Of Counsel . | ee saa,
October 1966
me
« 2
Bie td ed penitent at A Miomee s Natl
Se ents eee
“&
la . ee
APPENDIX A
[oe Supp. —]
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
- MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
JACKSONVILLE DIVISION
No. 65-186-Civ-J
Frgripa East Coast Ratway Company, Plaintiff,
| a .
Unirep Srares or AMERIGA AND INTERSTATE COMMERCE
Commission, Defendants.
Opinion
Before Jones, Circuit Judge, and McRae and Young,
District Judges. —
McRaz, District Judge.
_ Florida East Coast Railway Company (East Coast)
brought this action, seeking judicial review of an order
of the Interstate Commerce Commission that requires
East Coast to permit Seaboard. Air Line Railroad Com-
pany (Seaboard) to operate trains over certain railroad
tracks owned and used by East Coast in Miami, Fldrida.
Currently, both Seaboard and East Coast provide rail ©
transportation to and from the present municipal port
in Miami, using the tracks of the Miami Municipal Rail-'
road. New port facilities are being constructed in Miami
on Dodge Island, however, and all Miami port activities
will be transferred to Dodge Island when these facilities
are completed. The Dade County (Miami) Seaport De-
partment has requested that both Seaboard and East Cosiat
provide rail service to the new port. j
The Seaport Department is constructing railroad track
from the island to the mainland, leaving a short. gap be-
ee
2a
tween the end of its track and an East Coast spur track.
_East Coast proposes to close the gap by building a con-—
necting track. Seaboard will have no access to the new
port without substantial track construction in downtown
Miami unless it is able to use 3220 feet of East Coast
tracks, some main line and some spur.
Seaboard, therefore, applied to the Interstate Commerce
Commission under § 3(5) of the Interstate Commerce Act,
49 U.S.C. §3(5), for permission to use these East Coast
tracks. Section 3(5) provides in part:
If the Commission finds it to be in the public interest
and to be practicable, without substantially impairing
the ability of a common carrier by railroad owning
or entitled to the enjoyment of terminal’ facilities to
handle its own business, it shall have power by order ._
to require the use of ary such terminal facilities, in-
cluding main-line track or tracks for a reasonable dis-
tance outside of such terminal, got any common carrier
by railroad, dete another such°carrier or other such
carriers .
Hearings were conducted before a hearing examiner, who
recommended approval of Seaboard’s application to use
East Coast tracks.’ The Commission agreed, finding, among’
other things, that Seaboard’s proposal was in the public
interest, was practicable, and would not substantially im-
pair the ability .of East Coast to handle its own business.
Before determining whether the record considered as a
whole supports these findings, we first should consider
certain preliminary issues raised by East Coast: it con-
tends that.the Commission’s order is not reviewable at.
_ this time, that the Commission had no jurisdiction to enter
’ the order, and that the order deprives East Coast.of prop-
erty. without due process of law.
3a
Section 3(5) of the Interstate Commerce Act provides
that the use of another railroad’s. track is to be ‘‘on such.
terms and for such compensation as the carriers affected
may agree upon, or, in the event of a failure to agree, ‘as
the Commission may fix as just and reasonable for the use
so required .... Such compensation shall be paid or ade-
qttately secured before the en; Joyment of the use may be
commenced.’’ In light of this provision, the Commission
retained jurisdiction for the purpose of reopening the pro-
ceedings and thereupon determining the proper compen-
sation if the carriers could not reach agreement.
’ .East Coast argues, therefore, that the Commission’s
order is not final and hence not now reviewable. We can-
not agree. ‘‘The true test [of ripeness] is the substantial-
ity of present or imminent harm which the administra-
tive action inflicts on the piaintiff.’”’ .3 Davis, Adminis-
trative Law § 21.07, at 176-77 (1958). See Columbia Broad-
‘ easting System, Inc. v. United States, 316 U.S. 407, 424-25
(1942). One key factor is whether the order determines
legal rights. 3 Davis, supra, at 177. The present order
clearly does so, ordermg one carrier to allow another car-
rier to use its track. This determination of the parties’
legal rights»may be the final action taken by the Commis-
sion in this dispute, as the parties may -agree upon the
terms of compensation. Most important, the effective daté
of the order does not depend on the establishment. of the
terms of compensation as long as the use of East Coast
' track is ‘‘adequately secured . . . before the said use shall
be commenced.’’ See also Missouri-Kan.-Tex. R.R. v.
Kansas City Terminal Ry., 198 I.C.C. 4, 5 (1933) (track used
for 4 years. before e>mpensation settled). —
East Coast’s argument that the Commission had no
jurisdiction under § 3(5) revolves: around the interpreta-
tion of the words ‘‘termimal:facilities’’. as used in that
section. A railroad must be one ‘‘owning or entitled’ to
\ 4a f
the enjoyment of terminal facilities’’ before it can be or!
dered to let another railroad use the ‘‘terminal facilities,
....imeluding: main-line track or tracks for a reasonable dis-
tance outside of such terminal.’’ East Coast contends that
the only terminal facilities involved in this case are those
owned by the Seaport Department, which facilities East
Coast neither owns nor is entitled to enjoy.
Such a construction, however, is much too narrow. The
statutory language explicitly indicates that the words ‘‘ter-
minal facilities’’ do not refer solely to the terminal itself,
since such facilitiés are said to include main-line track
outside the terminal. Certainly, if main-line track may be
part of the terminal facilities, spur track may be also.
The key is the use to be made of the track.
In the present case, Seaboard proposes to use the East
Coast tracks to transfer cars from the port to its freight
yards, where the cars will then be switeked around and
made into trains with destinations outside the Miami area.
East Coast will use portions of the tracks in the same way
and presently uses the tracks to serve industries near its
- Miami terminal. The fact that.East Coast also uses por-
tions of the tracks as main-line track is irrelevant. )
The: fact that ownership of the terminal and ownership
of the terminal facilities-sought to be used are in different
companies likewise is irrelevant. No policy has been ad-
vanced, and we cannot conceive of one, for limiting: the
statute’s operation to the single-owner situation..
Under these circumstances, the tracks own ry. East
Coast and sought to be used by Seaboard are ‘‘terminal
facilities’’ within the meaning of §3(5). Accord, City of
Milwaukee v. Chicago & N.W. Ry., 283 I.C.C. 311 (1951). -
_East Coast further argues that the order deprives it of
property without due process of law. In order for Sea-
board.to move its trains on and off the East Coast tracks
sought to be used, construction. of a short connecting track
da
will be desirable or possibly necessary: Hast Coast urges
that § 1(18) of the Interstate Commerce Act requires Com-
mission approval (using the more strict ‘‘public conven-
ience and necessity’’ standard) before the cénnection can
be built, that no request has been made to the Commission
for its approval, but that the present order conslusively
_binds the Commission to grant such approval in the future,
thereby depriving East Coast of the right to a full and .
fair hearing on Seaboard’s application. Seaboard con-
tends that connection comes within the §1(22) exemption,
obviating the need of Commission action.
We need not decide, however, whether the proposed con-
struction comes within § 1(18) or § 1(22), for East Coast’s
complaint of the lack of due process is premature. Even
if Commission approval is needed, we cannot presume that
the Commission will disregard its obligations to give East.
Coast a fair hearing and to apply the stricter standard of
‘*public: convenience and necessity.’’ After such a hear-
ing, if one is needed, the Commission could, consistent with
the order now under review, withhold its approval of the
construction, but Seaboard would be able to serve the port
by obtaining acceptance of a different type of connection
or by using a preexisting, though possibly less efficient,
connection. In any event, East Coast can complain about
the denial of a fair hearing and the use of improper stand-
ards only after they oceur. They presently have not.
+ On the merits, after considering Seaboard’s proposal,
East Coast’s counterproposal (to let East Coast move the .
Seaboard traffic te and from the port), and testimony sup-
porting various positions, including that of the intervenor
Greater Miami Traffic Association (on behalf of Dade
County and the Seaport Department), the Commission
made its findings, including ones that the proposed use
of East Coast track by Seaboard was in the public inter-
est, was practicable, and would not substantially impair
the ability of East Coast to handle its own business, After.
6a
reviewing the record, we conclude that the Commission’s
. findings are amply supported by the record considered
as a whole. The Commission’s order, therefore, should be -
approved and the complaint should be dismissed.
Judgment will be entered for Defendants ; in accordance.
with the present opinion. ,
: - Judgment ' >
In accordance with the Opinion filed herein this day, it is -
ORDERED AND Apsypcep that judgment is hereby entered
for defendants United States of America and Interstate
Commerce Commission, and this action is dismissed.
_ @nTeRED at Jacksonville, Florida, this 24th day of June,
1966. ;
fF
‘Ta
APPENDIX B
Interstate Commerce Commission
Reports—Motor Carrier Cases
FINANCE Dooxer ‘No. 22479
SEABOARD Arr Line Ratroap Company—UsE oF » Densarmas.
Facuities or Fiorwa East Coast Ratuway Company
Decided March 17, 1965
*
~
Use by Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company of certain
tracks and facilities of Florida East Coast Railway
Company at Miami, Fla., found to be reasonably re-
quired in the public interest and to be practicable with-
out substantially impairing the ability of the Florida °
- East Coast to handle its own business. Conditions
prescribed. |
Richard A. Hollander for applicant. .
Roland A. Smith for intervener in support of cuitians.*
"A. Alvis Layne for intervener in opposition.
' J.-W. Hayes, T. C. Bolin, J. R. Bailey, Ben E. LeFeat,,
Cecil Johnson, W. T. Kitt, Dale McLaine, John 8. Fetters,
Benjamin P. Weinstock, L. W. Hughes, E. A. Glenn, and
Hugh O. Van Arsdall, ‘Sr., for railway labor organizations.
REporT OF THE COMMISSION,
en 3, Commissioner TuceLe, MurpHy, aNd Wa.aaTa ,
Murpxy, Commissioner > ;
Exceptions to the examiner’s report and recommended
order finding that use by the Seaboard Air Line Railroad
of the Florida East Coasf Railway Company (the East
Coast) would be in the public interést, including a request
Company (the an Conf ans tracks and facilities —
< |
8a
for oral argument, were filed by the East Coast; and the
_ Seaboard and the Greafer Miami Traffic Asséciation (the
association) on behalf of Metropolitan Dade County, Fla.,
and of the Dade County Seaport eee (the —
ment), replied.
By: application filed Februay 95, 1963, under the -pro-
visions of section 3(5) of the Interstate Commerce Act,
the Seaboard requests an order requiring the East Coast
to permit it to operate over’ approximately 3,220 feet of
the East Coast’s track at Miami, Fla. Applicant also
requests that. we fix just'and reasonable terms and com-
“pensation for the use of such track. Use of the facilities
“allegedly will be. necessary in order for the Seaboard to
serve the new port facilities now under construction at
Dodge Island. The association intervened in support of
the Seaboard’s proposal. Hearings were held, and briefs
were submitted by the Seaboard, East Coast, and the asso-
ciation. Representatives of various railway labor organi-
Gations appeared: in the interest of.“railroad employees.
We do not believe that oral argument is necessary for a .
proper disposition of the issues in this proceeding. The
request of the Hast Coast, therefor is, accordingly. denied.
he positions of the parties and the facts pertinent.
- thereto are set forth in detail in the examiner’s report and _
- will be repeated only to the extent necessary for clarity |
- of discussion. His findings of fact as amplified herein
' are adopted as our own.
On. exceptions, the Fast Coast questions our jurisdic-
tion in this matter alleging that the involved East Coast
' tracks are not terminal facilities; and that the depart-
ment’s port facilities at Dodge Island, are not railroad
terminal facilities either owned by the East Coast or over
which the East Coast is entitled to handle its own business.
Similarly, the classification of the department 8 facilities |
? Unless otherwise indicated, “ points are in Miami.
>
7
as terminal facilities is 3 questioned bocnvne no authority
from this Commission for their construction as part of °
the, plant of a common carrier by railroad has been re-
quested or, obtained. As a result, the Kast Coast argues ~
that the basic prerequisite for a finding under section
3( 5), the existence of terminal facilities owned by. the car-,
rier against whom the order will become effective, is.
lacking.”
The department’ 8 facilities on » Radios faba are to be |
_ used primarily for serving users of a new port, and, in
this respect, the operation at the department’s facility will, “a
be little different from that conducted at the’old port. See
Miami Municipal R. Extension, 158 1.C.C.' 169 and 170
L.C.C. 175, and Florida East Coast Ry: Co. Operation, —
170.1.C.C. 171., Inasmuch as the use of the facilities, in
terminal operations, rather than their classification by the
parties is determinable, Clinchfield R.-Co. Abandonment,
. 295 I.C.C. 41, 44, for the purposes of this proceeding, we
find that the department’s trackage constitutes terminal
facilities as contemplated by section 3(5) of the act.
The fact that the East Coast. does not own the facilities
at the-port or that it is not entitled as a matter of right.
to enjoyment of these facilities. does not affect our juris-
diction under section 3(5)* of the act. The basis of: ‘the
‘East Coast’s opposition. to this’ application is that’ as :
the,sole rail carrier to have physical connections with the
new port, it can —— hangje 8 all rail traffic to and
Cw ee
" - #Seetion 3 (5), as pertinent, is as follows :
If the Commission finds, it to be in the public interest: and to
be practicable, without substantially impairing the ability of a
common carrier by railroad owning or entitled to the. enjoyment of —
terminal. facilities to handle its own business, it shall have power
by order to require the use “of any such terminal facilities, includ-
ing main-line track or tracks for a reasonable distance, outside of.
such terminal, of any common carrier by railroad, by another such
_ earrier 6r other such carriers.* * *. *[Emphasis supplied.]
ye
we
from the port, including the switching of Seaboard cars.
The plaris of the port authority and of the East Coast
contemplate the East Coast’s use of the port terminal. In
addition, the East Coast tracks involved herein, being used
as they are entirely for. serving shippers | in the city of
Miami and the area of the port, can thenjselves be con-
sidered terminal facilities; but whether they be considered
terminal facilities of the East Coast or main-line track
leading to the port’s terminal facilities, they are within
the scope of ‘section 3(5). It is not required ghat the
: terminal facilities and the tracks for a reasonable distance
outside of such terminal be owned by the same carrier.
Chicago ¢ Alton R. Co. v. Toledo, P. € W. Ry. Co., 146
I.C.C, 171, 177. We, therefore, conclude that determina-_
tion of the Seaboard’s use of the East Coast’s tracks as
proposed i is within our jurisdiction under section 3(5).sub-
ject to the prerequisite conditions and circumstances stated -
therein; namely, that the use sought be in the public in-
terest and practicable without substantially impairing the
_ ability of the East Coast to handle its own business. | See
- City of Hialeah, Fla., v. Florida East Coast-Ry. Co., 317
1.C.C. 34, 36; Use by. Erie of Niagara. Junction Ry.-Co.
Terminals, 269 L.C.C. 493, 499.
The present port of Miami, owned and operated by
Metropolitan Dade _ County, is located between N. E. 9th
. and 12th Streets, east of Biscayne Boulevard. ‘Over the
past 34 years, both the Seaboard and Easf ‘Coast have
served the: port over the ‘tracks of the county-owned Miami
' Municipal’ Railroad* which connects | with the Seaboard
tracks at N. W.-6th Avenue and 11th Terrace and to the
East Coast tracks at N. W« Ist Avenue and ‘11th Terrace.
The main ‘tracks of the Hast Coast run north-south’ on
N:W. 1st Avenue between 13th Street and the Mimi _—
‘ . €
\ For the histovical’ hetisiead « of rail service to the port, see |
Miami Municipal R. Extension, supra, and Florida East Coast Ry.
- . Co. Operation, supra:
. be y e
Rs
lla
about a mile to the south. Between N. E. 6th and 7th
Streets there is a wye turn from: the East Coast’s main
line to tracks running east-west for four blocks crossing
Biscayne Boulevard, with spur tracks to the P&O docks.
In: the early 1950’s, the city began planning a new
which is being constructed now at a cost of $20 million at
Dodge Island, approximately four or five city blocks south-
of the present. port site. Upon completion, all activities
of the department will be transferred to Dodge Island,
- and the present port will be converted to other ‘uses. In
the planning and designing of the new facilities, it has
_ always been intended that both the Seaboard and East
Coast would have direct access to the larger port and that
each carrier would be in a position to serve the port with.
its own equipment. In June 1962, the port director of-
ficially requested the East Goast and Seaboard to make an:
arrangement between them whereby both carriers would
jeintly serve the new port.- Since ‘the Seaboard did not
physieally connect with the new port, the Bast ‘Coast sug-
gested a plan under which it would handle cars for. the
Seaboard under a switching arrangement. This proposal
was rejected by both the port management and by the
‘Seaboard. Thereafter, the Seaboard presented a formal
operating plan which would necessitate the use of a portion
of East Coast tracks. by the Seaboard, The East Coast
objected to the plan for joint service and, in lieu thereof,
proposed an arrangement under which it would move Sea-
board cars at a stated charge from the interchange tracks
at N. W. llth Street to the new port with _— Coast
engines in coordinated movements.
Under its proposal, the East Coast would conatrest a
track from the present P&O dock spur to the East Coast
right-of-way line at its own expense, and the department
would build the adjacertit track to the port on.its own prop-
erty. The‘ East Coast would be the sole rail carrier with
physical connections to the new port, and all Seaboard. .
12a
traffic to and from the port would be ‘handled by the East
Coast. The latter would move cars between the Seaboard’s
interchange track at 11th Street and the port at the same
time it handled its-own poft traffic. Inbound freight 6n
East Coast trains, preclassified at Jacksonville, Fla., would
arrive in Miami at 10:30 or 11 p.m., and Seaboard traffic.
destined to Dodge Island placed on interchange tracks
would be picked up by an Kast Coast engine and delivered
to the new port around 1 a.m.
Under its plan the Seaboard would construct, own, and
' maintafaa 585-foot connecting track in -the vicinity of.
_N. W. 1l¢h Street and N. W. ist Avenue from the Mu-
nicipal RaWroad. to the East Coast main track. To allow
for the southerly switch under this plan, the Hast Coast -
‘would have to reduce the length of two yard tracks by
approximately 110 feet each. The Seaboard then proposes
. to operate a total distance of .0.609 mile over the East
Coast’s southbound main line from N. W. 11th Street,
through the crossover located at N. W. 9th Street, thence
_ over the northbound main line and north leg and stem of-
the wye track between 6th and 7th Streets to the east line
of Biscayne Boulevard. From that terminus, it is pro-
posed that the Seaboard and, East. Coast, at joint equal
expense, will construct ‘a ,290-foot connecting track to —
the westerly abutment of the drawbridge i in Biscayne Bay
leading into the new’ port at’ Dodge Island. The new
port. is connected with the mainland by a causeway and*
twin bridges (a railroad bridge and highway vehicular
bridge). owned by the department. |
- For the right to operate over the Rast Coast tracks,
the Seaboard proposes to pay annual: rental equal.to 2%
percent of the present valuation of. the jointly used track-
age, subject to adjustment. Additionally, the Seaboard
would pay the East Coast a portion of the total cost of
maintenance, taxes, and insurance on.a user basis. The
proposed agreement also contains the usual provisions
f
13a . vee
found in trackage right agreements in respect to responsi-
bility and‘ liability of the parties, arbitration, and con-
tintfance of the agreement during the time that the de-
partment’s rail facilities are operated. The agreement
would be subject to termination at any time by mutual :
consent of the parties. The Seaboard proposes to operate |
engines to and from Dodge Island twice a day—spotting
cars for unloading prior to 7 a.m. and removing loaded
“or empty cars prior to 4 p.m. or after 7 p.m. Additional
switches would be performed to accommodate shippers and
boat schedules. |
Hearing “examiner’s findings.—The on ‘examinee, me
recommending that the application be approved, found
inter alia that long experience with respect to joint service
at the port demonstrates the public interest inherent in
the Seaboard’s proposal; that the proposed plan of op-
erations would not cause delay to the East Coast’s own
movements or adversely affect the latter carrier’s shippers
along the route; that service at the port by both carriers
was generally favored by shippers; that the proposed joint
use would not aggravate traffic congestion, nor raise any
new traffic. hazard, but would obviate delays and assure
uninterrupted rail service essential to port operations.
With respect to-considerations of the public interest un-
der the East Coast proposal, ‘the examiner concluded that
the handling of Seaboard traffic by the East Coast involv-
ing interchange would result in undue delay, primarily
from use of an additional carrier; that without changes
in existing tariffs the Seaboard could not lawfully absorb
any part of the East Coast’s switching charges; that, as
_amatter of practical economics, the multiple-carrier move-
ment under the Hast Coast plan to serve Dodge Island
exclusively would entail intreased transportation and ter-
minal charges.” .
‘ The East Coast takes exception to virtually all the’ find-
ings and conclusions of the examiner, and urges that the
a ae ERAS ANSE AD AR RSIS tT Boe A A ttn
l4a
application be denied principally Rese the evidence of
record does not support the ‘findings necessary under sec-
tion 3(5); and that the Seaboard did not establish that
the East Coast plan is unresponsive to the public’s need
for service. The East Coast contends that the existence
of joint service at the old port is not sufficient to establish
that the Seaboard’s proposed use of its tracks is in the
_public-interest; that the Seaboard plan would tend to create
hazards to the safety of trains and their crews and would
result in delays and congestion of East Coast cars and
equipment; that the East Coast plan contemplates move-
ment of Seaboard cars to and from the new port under
’ a Seaboard bill of lading in through movement, not in-
volving an ‘‘interchange of traffic,’ or increased freight
rates to shippers and receivers; and that the charge as-
_ sessed would not be reflected in tariffs or absorbed 7 the
public.
It is seed that service to the port under the Seaboard
‘plan would be impracticable, primarily because of inade-
quate operational facilities. For example, it is stated that
there are no passing tracks at the port and that it has
been established that there is no room for two crews.
and two engines for spotting or removing cars at the docks
or other harbor facilities. The additional time the Sea-
- board would occupy the East Coast’s main-line tracks, -
in the opinion of the latter, constitutes a basic impairment
to the East Coast’s ability to handle its own business,
since on each of the Seaboard’s propésed two movements,
the tracks allegedly would have to be cleared of East Coast
traffic.. The East Coast stresses that its volume of traffic
over tracks between 1st Avenue and Biscayne Boulevard,
providing service to 14 industries, would be adversely
affected by the Seaboard’s use.
- The Seaboard states that service to the new pent will
not differ from that presently rendered except ‘that it will
not serve shippers intermediate to the new facility. It
Ss.
15a
assertedly seeks only to continue a longtime service. Exist-
ing traffic relationships are not affected. This prior serv-
ice, the Seaboard contends, demonstrates that the proposed
joint use of East Coast tracks is in the public interest,
citing Chicago d N. W. Ry. Co. v. Ann Arbor R. Co., 263
-I.C.C. 287, 296, and that since port operations require .
prompt loading and unloading of ships to keep their hold-
ing time in port to a minimum, it is imperative to have
_ears spotted at the port promptly. This service, the Sea-
board contends, cannot be provided if terminal interchange
of port cars is required. Moreover, the Seaboard states
that the argument that its movement over the East Coast
track (a straight through movement without service to
intermediate points) would entail delay of East Coast | |
traffic for from 14% to 5 hours has no support in the rec-
ord. The crossover movement, it argues, would vary de-
pending upon the number of cars but would require from
’ 8 to 20 minutes. The Seaboard denies that East Coast
tracks must be clear of traffic during use by the Seaboard
or that Dodge Island will take only. one engine, stressing
that the new port was designed for service by both carriers.
' Discussion and conclustons.—The application under con-
sideration constitutes a portion of an overall plan to afford
.continued joint service to, the new port identical to that
now provided by the Seaboard and East Coast to the éxist-
ing port. However, no application is pending for consid-
_ eration of other essential track construction projects, nor
_ iso proval of the application here to be construed as
aoe such construction.* ‘ Obviously, long-continued
prior service demonstrates a public need for maintaining ©
operations by both carriers to the new port. The East
Coast track involved would be ‘used by the Seaboard only
. * Likewise, sething Detitn th Ge Se ebieeesl 2 peste ‘coe
any abandonment of operations ‘or the acquisition of additional op-
erating rights by either the Seaboard or the East Coast that might
hereafter be necessary to effectuate the overall proposal.
16a
. for direct movements to the port, and: the track would be
occupied from 8 to 20 minutes—which time, in our opinion,
- does not appear to be unreasonable or burdensome. Nor
would the proposed use of the East Coast’s track substan-
tially interfere with this carrier’s traffic in downtown
Miami since an average of only 1.8 cars per day move over.
the line. The streets to be crossed by the respective car-
riers are the same under either plan. The municipal and
shipper support, as well as the lack of public opposition,
indicates that continuation of service proyided by both .
carriers since 1931 would be in the public interest. In
the judgment of the department’s director and others, .
the interchange arrangement proposed by the East Coast .
would not provide adequate service because of- delays,
increase in switching costs,.and congestion of vehicular -
traffic in ‘the interchange area. In the event that the
Seaboard should be denied use of the desired track, it
would appear that either the Seaboard or the. department
will be required to construct another track to the port in
order to meet the expected demand for the service of the
Seaboard. Such duplication of facilities in the circum- —
stances now present ‘would be patently wasteful and im-
practicable, and only add to the cngneens J of downtown
traffic in the city. :
In view of the ddevunatinees and alternatives presented,
we believe that the Seaboard can operate more efficiently
by physically serving the new port when compared to the
interchange operation proposed by the East Coast. Fur-
ther, we are of. the opinion, and the record supports the
conclusion that the use of a portion of East Coast track
from N. W. 11th Street to Biscayne Boulevard, as de-
- gseribed herein, would not substantially impair the ability
of the East Coast to handle its own business, but that such
use will be in the public interest. In determining what is
‘tin the public interest’’ we have considered, as gequired, °
the interests of the residents of the city of Miami, the
interests of the shippers using the service involved, the in-
17a
terests of the carriers, and the interests of the public in
general. See City of Hialeah, Fla., v. Florida East Coast
Ry. Co., supra. Moreover, we do sot believe that it would |
be impracticable for both the Seaboard and Kast Coast to
conduct operations at the Dodge Island port which was
designed for operations by both of these railroads, par-
ticularly since both carriers have operated at the present
smaller and more crowded port for 34 years.
We find that the use by the Seaboard Air Line Railroad —
Company of the railroad tracks and facilities of the Flor-
ida East Coast Railway Company in-Miami, Dade County,
Fla., in operating to and from the new port ‘under con-
struction, as described herein, is reasonably required in
the public interest; and such operation is practicable and
will not substantially impair the ability of-the Florida |
East Coast Railway Company to handle -its own business.
The language of section 3(5) clearly contemplates that
after the right of a petitioner‘to use the terminal facilities |
of another carrier has been determined, the interested car-
riers shall have an opportunity to agree upon the terms and
compensation for such use. A conscientious endeavor on the
part of each should be undertaken to work out an agreement
mutually satisfactory as to terms and compensation. In
such endeavors the parties should keep in mind that if
the Commission is called upon to fix the compensation it
must, under section 3(5), be ascertained on the principles
controlling compensation in condemnation proceedings.
Those principles are discussed in length in. Missouri-K.-
T. R. Co. v. Kansas City Term. Ry. Co., 198 I.C.C. 4, in
which decision compensation for the use of the facilities
there considered was determined upen ‘those principles.
A careful study of those principles should enable the Sea- _
board and East Coast to arrive at reasonable and just
compensation for the use of the tracks and facilities herein
required. If, however, they are unable to agree, they may
petition the Commission to reopen: the proceeding for fur-
18a
ther hearing looking to a determination and prescription
of terms and compensation. Jurisdiction will be retained
- for such purpose. See Use by Erie of — Junction |
Ry. Co. Terminals, supra.
Exceptions and requested findings not iia dis-
cussed herein have been given consideration and found to
be without merit, or without material significance. Pro-
vision for the protection of employees will be considered
when the terms for the operation here found to be re-
quired are established.
An appropriate order will be entered.
J
/
“198
APPENDIX C
eee
At a Session of the InTErstaTe CoMMERCE Commission, -
Division 3, held at its office in a D; C., on
the 17th day of March, A. D. 1965.
FINANCE Docker No. 22479
SeaBoarp Arr Line Renade ComPpaANy—USE OF “Pera: AL
Faciuities or Fiuorma East Coasr Rattway Company
ti
Investigation of the matters and things involved in this
proceeding having been made, a hearing having been held,
and the said Division on the date hereof, having made and
filed a report containing its findings of facts and conclu-
sions thereon, which report, and the report.of the hearing
examiner, are hereby referred to and made a part hereof:
It is ordered, That the request of Florida East Coast
_ Railway ‘Company for oral ae be, and it is hereby, .
denied.
It is further ordered, That the Florida East tit Rail-
way Company be, and it is hereby, notified and required
. to permit the Seaboard Air Line Railroad. Company to
use that portion of its tracks and terminal facilities, as
described in tlie report, to serve the new port under con-
struction at Dodge Island, Dade County, — subject to
the conditions stated therein.
It is further ordered, That the aforesaid use of a por-
tion of Florida East Coast Railway tracks shall be upon
such terms and for such compensation as the said carriers
may agree upon, and thereafter be found just and reason-
able by this Commission, or, if they shall be unable to agree
within a period of 30 days from the effective date hereof,
then upon such terms and for such compensation as the
Commission, pursuant to a further hearing upon request
of either the Florida East Ooast Railway Company or
the Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company, hereafter may
20a
fix as just and reasonable, as ascertdined in accordance
with section 3(5) of the Igterstate Commerce Act.
_. It is further ordered, That the enjoyment of the use of
said tracks and terminal facilities shall be subject to the
right of the Florida East Coast Railway to require that
the compensation paid for the’said use shall be adequately
secured to it before the said use shall be commenced; and
It is further ordered, That this order shall become effec-
tive 35 days from the, date of service hereof and shall
continue in force and effect until the further order of the
Commission. a ,
' By the Commission, Division 3.
| Bertua F’, ARMES, —
(Sav) : Acting Secretary ©
~e
21a -
APPENDIX D
INTERSTATE COMMERCE “COMMISSION
Served July 31, 1964
Notice to the Parties
Exceptions, if | any, must ‘be filed with the Secretary, In-
TERSTATE. COMMERCE Commission, Washington, D. C., and
served on all other parties in interest within 30 ‘dae
from the date of service shown above, or within such
further period as may. be authorized for the filing of
such exceptions. At th expiration: of said period for :
the filing of exceptions, ea recommended ord¢r will be-
come the order of the Commission and will become effec-
tive unless exceptions: have been seasonably filed or the
order has been stayed or postponed by the Commission.
If exceptions are filed, replies to exceptions may be
filed within 20. days after the. final date for filing of
exceptions. It should not be assunfed that the recom-
mended order has. become effective as .the order of the
~ Commission until a notice or order to that effect has
_ been served. .
- Finance Docket No. 22479
Szasoarp Arr Linz Rattnoap Company—Use or TERMINAL
Facruities oF Forma East Coast Rartway Company
Order entered authorizing operations by the Seaboard Air
Line Railroad Company over certain tracks and termi-
nal facilities of the Flotida East Coast Railway Com-
pany in Miami, Dade: County, Fla. Conditions -pre-—
sepsbed, = jurisdiction retained_for scares purpose.
if
o
o
>»
220 - ?
Richard A, a ollander for applicant.
| A. Alvis ‘Layne for intervener i in opposition.
Roland A. Smith for intervener in support of applicant. |
JW. Hayes, T. C. Bolin, J..R. Bailey, Ben E. LeFeat,
Cecil‘ Johnson, W. T, Kitt; Dale McLaine, S. Fetters,
Benjamin P. Weinstock, L. W. Hughes, E. . Glenn and.
Hugh O. VanArsdall, Rr. for railway labor organizations,
Report and Order
* RecomMENDED By Pavt Cc. Asus, Hearno EXAMINER
By application. filed February 25, 1963, the Seaboard
- Air Line Railroad Company (Seaboard)! seeks. an- order
‘ under Section 3(5) of the Interstate Commerce Act, here-
' inafter sometimes referred to as the act; which would per-
mit it to operate - over some 3220 feet of track. owned by
the Florida East Coast Railway Company (East Coast)!
at Miami, Dade County, Fla. The applicant also requests
the. Commission to fix just and reasonable terms and com-
" pensation for the use of such track which ‘is necessary in
order for the Seaboard to serve the new port facilities now
. under construction at Dodge Island ‘in Miami. East Coast |
opposes the application, and the Greater Miami Traffic
| Association intervened in support of the Seaboard. .
- Hearirigs were. held. at: Miami on. ‘September 30, 1963,
and on April 8-9, 1964. Briefs were filed. Unless other-
wise indicated, -all Pune - hereinafter mentioned are in
ok hace
its protest, “Bast Coast opposes the seitination upon
e grounds, among others, that the Commission has no
authority under section 3(5) of the act to grant the rights
sought by Seaboard; that the .public interest does’ not
require Seaboard to operate its trains over the tracks
7A earrier by railroad subject to part I of the act.
23a °
of East Gets that the public anu will be. sostetssly ,
disadvantaged by the proposed operation. of Seaboard over
and across public highways at grade; including the heavily
traveled 6-lane Biscayne Boulevard; and that the pro- _
posed operations are not practicable and will substan-
tially impair the ability of the East Co&st to handle its
own business. The jurisdictional question was not men-~
- tianed at the hearings, or further stressed on brief.
The present port.of Miami, which is owned and operated
by Metropolitan Dade County, is located between N.E. 9th
Street and N.E. 12th Street, east of Biscayne Boulevard.
It consists of an area of approximately 26 aeres of land,
3 slips, berthing space for 10 large ships, 305,000 square
feet of transit sheds, 10,000 square feet of refrigerated
space, 35,000 square feet of office space, 47,000 square feet
-of passenger terminals, 700 lineal feet of dock side rail-
way tracks, 5,800 lineal feet of railway tracks alongside ,
transit sheds, and parking space for about 200 vehicles.
The port presently owns and maintains approximately 6 —
miles of railroad tracks which connect with the Seaboard
tracks at N.W. 6th Avenue and 11th Terrace, and. with
the East Coast tracks at N.W. 1st Avenue and 11th Terrace,
and with the East Coast tracks at N.W. ist Avenue and .
‘11th Terrace.
The port was originally constructed by the city of Miami
which also built the Miami Municipal Railroad (Municipal
Railroad) to reach the dock area. When the line of
the Seaboard was extended to Miami in 1928, the munici-
pal duthorities approached the Seaboard in connection
with having that railroad connect with the Municipal
' Railroad and serve the port direct. The extension of the
Miami Municipal Railroad was placed in operation Janu-
ary 17, 1931, and both the Seaboard and the East Coast
have served the port since that time. See Miamt Municipal
Railroad Extension, 158 I.C0.C. 169, 170 I.C.C. 175; and
Florida East Coast Ry. Co. Operation, 170 1.C.C. 171. The
a
24a
historical background of rail service to the port is gon- -
tained in the cited cases and need not be restated. ,
In the early 1950’s the city of Miami began planning
a new port.. As a part of that planning in 1960 the port
facilities and«the Municipal Railroad were transferred
from city auspices to Metropolitan Dade County, and the-
county has operated the port properties since that time
under the: Dade County Seaport Department, hereinafter
_ referred to as the Seaport Department.
-The new port will be located on a man-made island,
‘ known as Dodge Island, approximately four or five city
blocks south of the present port site. It will be connected
with the mainland by a causeway 2nd twin bridges, one ©
for use asa railroad bridge and thé other for highway
vehicular traffic. The new port has an area of 300 acres
with 9,300 lineal feet of bulkheading capable of berthing
20 ships and aprohs of from 70 to 100 feet in width. It
will have 100,000 square feet of office space; 600,000
square feet of transit shed space; 4 passenger termina);
100,000 cubiefeet of refrigerated space; 18,500 lineal feet
‘of railroad: tracks:of which 3,500 lineal -feet will be dock-
side, and 5,000 lineal feet of make-up tracks; 100 acres:
for open storage; and 45 acres for trailer ship operations.
' The first phase of the development of the new port is
estimated to cost approximately $20 million of which ap-
proximately $10 million-of, constructidi has been completed
and another $2.5 million of construction is now in progress.
. It is expected that the new port will be ready for partial
operation by the end of the -current year or early in 1965.
Upon completion, all activities of the Seaport-Department
- are to be transferred to the Dodge Island port, and the
present port site is to be converted to other uses.
At all times during the planning. and: designing of the
‘new port facilities: it was contemplated that both rail-
roads operating into Miami would have direct access to
en
25a
‘the new port so that each carrier would be in a position
to serve the port with its own equipment. On June 21,.
1962, the director of the port wrote the Seaboard and
- . Kast Coast and officially requested that the two rail-
roads make an arrangement between them to permit both
railroads to continue to jointly serve the new port as they
had in the past. The Seaboard indicated a willingness to
work out such arrangements. East Coast advised, how-
ever, that since the Seaboard did not physically connect
with the new port, East Coast would handlé cars for the
Seaboard under a switching arrangement. Since such a
switching arrangement was satisfactory to neither the
port management nor the Seaboard, a meeting of all in-
terested. parties was held on September 26, 1962. At that
meeting Seaboard presented a formal operating proposal .
calling for the use of certain of the East Coast tracks by ©
the Seaboard to permit the continuance of joint service ‘at
the new port. East Coast indicated its objection to the
Seaboard’s proposal, and in substitution thereof proposed
switching arrangements which contemplated interchanging
traffic on the interchange tracks connecting with the Mu-
_ nicipal Railroad near N.W. ilth Street. No agreement
was reached and although East Coast advised it would
make a counter proposal to Seaboard and to the port au-
thorities setting out the details as to how Seaboard’s traf-
fic would be handled to the port, no such proposal was
offered. In.the absence of such agreement,: the Seaboard
filed the instant application. .
Section 3(5) of the Act provides:
(5) If the Commission finds it to be in the public .
interest and to be practicable, without substantially
impairing the ability of a common carrier by rail-.
road owning or entitled to the enjoyment of termi-
nal facilities to handle its own business, it shall have
power by order to require the use of any .such termi-
nal facilities, including main-line track or tracks for a
26a
reasonable distance outside‘of such terminal, of any ©
common carrier by railroad, by another sweh carrier or -
- other such carriers, on such terms and for such com-
‘pensation as the carriers affected may agree upon,
or, in the event of a failure to agree, as the Commis-
sion may fix as just and reasonable for the use so re-
quired, to be ascertained on the principle controlling
compensation in condemnation proceedings. . Such
, compensation shall be paid or adequately secured be-
fore the enjoyment of the use may be.commenced.
If under this paragraph the use of°such , Na fa-
cilities of any carrier is required to be given to an-
other carrier or other_carriers, and the carrier whose
terminal facilities are required to be so used is not
satisfied with the terms fixed for such use, or if the
amount of compensation so fixed is not duly and
° promptly paid, the carrier whose terminal facilities
~~ have thus been required to be given to another carrier
or other carriers shall be entitled to recover, by suit
' or action against such other carrier or carriers, proper
damages for any injuries sustained by it as the re-
sult of compliance with such requirement, or just
| compensation for such use, or both, as the case may be.
_ Under its proposal Seaboard wut mnawet, own and
maintain a 585-foot connecting track between the track
of the Seaport Department (Municipal Railroad) and the
East Coast main line in the vicinity of 11th Street. In
.effecting such construction, East Coast Would have to re- :
duce the length of two yard tracks by ‘a e
feet each in order to allow for the location of tie southerly -
switch of the proposed connection. Although East Coast .
would make this relocation, it would be.at the sole cost of
‘Seaboard. On the eastern end of the proposed -opera-
tion Seaboard’ and East Coast, at joint and equal ex-
pense, would construct a 1,250-foot connecting track be-
. tween the eastern boundary of Biscayne Boulevard and
- lh tne ip An it LI at ag BN BC a age NA alee tte
o
2 27a
the Seaport Department’s new track at the westerly abut-
ment of the drawbridge in Biscayne Bay leading into the
new port at Dodge. Island. The estimated cost of the
connecting track at 11th Street is $80,900; the estimated
cost of the relocation’ of the switches on the East Coast
is $4,720, and: the estimated cost of the joint track to
connect with the drawbridge is $15,000. No application |
is pending for approval of the proposed constructions.
Thus Seaboard proposes to operate a total ‘distance of
0.609 mile over the East Coast’s southbound main line,
through the crossover located at N.W. 9th’ Street, thence
over the northbound main line and north leg and stem of a
wye track between N.E. 6th and 7th Streets to the east.
line of Biscayne Boulevard. For the right to operate its
trains and engines over the tracks of East Coast, Seaboard
proposes to pay annually as rent a sum equal to 2% per-
cent of the present valuation of the jointly used trackage.
If, during the. continuance of the joint use, additions, bet-
terments or improvements are made by East Coast to the
jointly used trackage, the investment cost of such improve-
ments would be added to the valuation and Seaboard’s 24%
percent annual rental would be adjusted accordingly. The
expense cost of such improvements would be divided be-
tween the parties on the user basis set out below and pFro-
rated annually. . Valuation of the jointly used trackage
is to be determined by the original inventory of the Com-
mission, plus subsequent additions, betterments and re-
tirements.
East Coast is to.maintain the jointly ~ fe trackage in
good operating? condition and the Seaboard, in addition
to the annual rental based on the actual valuation of the
tracks, would pay to East Coast a portion of the total
' cost of maintenance, taxes and insurance to be apportioned |
between the parties on the percentage that the total number
of engines and cars (loaded or empty) bears to the total
number of all engines and cars (loaded or empty) handled
28a : S)
over the jointly used tracks; one diesel locomotive unit
to be counted as one car. Taxes and insurance would be
_ prorated annually and maintenance expenses’ monthly ex-
cept that maintenance expense in connection ‘with better-
ments would be prorated annually. The proportion,of the
maintenance cost would include the applicable percentage
charges for payroll taxes, health and welfare benefits, —
an ation and holiday time pay. |
In addition, the agreement would contain the usual pro-
_ visions. found in similar trackage right agreements be-
tween. railroads in respect to; (a) maintenance of equip-
ment used in accordance with standards set by industry,
Federal and State regulatory bodies; (b) the responsi-
bility and liability of the parties; (c) arbitration of dif- °
ferences of opinion and disputes; and (d) a statement.
that the agreement would continue during the time. that
_ the Seaport Department’s rail facilities are operated, ex-
. cept that the agreement may be terminated at any
time by mutual consent of the Hast Coast and Seaboard.
No attempt was made by East Coast to challenge the terms
and compensation proposed by Seaboard. . Its affirmative
evidence at the hearings was designed primarily al-
most exclusively to thé major proposition that rie in-
terest does not require direct service by ‘Seaboard® the
new port. | ;
Seaboard intends to operate engines to and from Dodge
Island twice a day. The first engine would place cars for
unloading prior to 7:00 a.m., and remove any loaded or
empty cars available for movement from the port. The
second engine would operate prior to 4:00 p.m. or after
7:00 p.m. Additional switches would be performed to ac-
- eommodate shippers and boat schedules. This. proposed
service- to Dodge Island would connect with Seaboard’s
scheduled freight trains to and from Miami. Seaboard
has trains scheduled into Miami at 10:00 p.m., between
3:00 and 4:00 a.m., 10:30 a.m., and one at 8:00 or 9:00 p.m.
293,
It has northbound freight trains leaving at 10:00 p.m., be-
tween 12:30 and 2:00 am., and a clean-up leaving at
Soam 8 § 8 84|.—te* by Se |
East Coast proposes to build a track from the present
P&O dock spur to the East Coast right-of-way line at its
own expense. The Seaport Department would build the
track on its own property, Under this proposal East
Coast would be the sole rail carrier with physical connec-
tions to serve the new port; and all Seaboard traffic to and
from the port would have to be handled in interchange.
As the East Coast train comes from the north it would
take this traffic from the interchange track to the port at
the same time it handled its own port traffic.
East Coast’s inbound freight, preclassified at Jackson- -
ville, arrives in Miami at 10:30 or 11:00 pm. A yard
engine then takes this traffic into the downtown area for
placement, arriving there around 1:00 am. This engine
would. also deliver incoming traffic to Dodge Island, pass-
ing the interchange track enroute. Bast Coast -states
\ that if Seaboard could place its traffic on the interchange
by the time the Kast Coast engine reaches the interchange,
East Coast would then pick up Seaboard’s traffic and all
of the cars would be placed at the port at the same time.
On outbound freight East Coast would switch the port
_ in the early evening and in the morning. If ‘any Seaboard
, cars, toaded or empty, were made available at either °
time, East Coast would pick up the Seaboard cars and
place’ them on the interchange track in time to make the |
Seaboard connections. On special or emergency switches
. for a particular car, East Coast would make the switch
as required by the customer whether it qame in on the
Seaboard or East Coast. The latter has engines working
in the vicinity of the interchange and they can be dis-
‘ patched to make pickups of special movements without
undue delay. . . 3 wae.
d | 30a | ‘
East Coast is prepared initially to charge Seaboard
$22.85 per car for switching Seaboard traffic to and from
the new port. This charge is equivalent to the amount
Seaboard charges East Coast to move East Coast cars-to--
and from points at this Miami International Airport Depot
industrial area reached only by Seaboard tracks. Hast
Coast is prepared, however, to revise the charge for mov-
ing Seaboard cars to and from- Dodge Island when sufficient
* operating experience has been gained to provide adequate
cost data. East Coast states that the charge, as finally
determined, would be evidenced by a private contract be-
tween it and Seaboard, and would not be contained in tariffs
- filed with this Commission; the present tariffs would
only be amended to change the name of the port property
from ‘Municipal Docks’’ to Properly identify the new
port on Dodge Island.
East Coast contends its proposal i is in the public in-
terest; that it is essential to the safe and efficient opera-
tion of its own facilities, as well as those on Dodge Is-
land ; and that it is the only practicable and efficient means
by which East Coast and Seaboard can serve the new
port. It further states that the Seaboard proposal is
vague in detail as to control and supervision of train
operations; that the Seaboard plan would create unnec-
essary traffic and safety hazards, damage lading compound
confusion and congestion, and cause inefficient operations
and increased costs at the new ‘port; and would substan-
tially impair East Coast’ 8 ability to handle its own busi- _—
ness,
In this: iil East Coast argues that Seaboard’s
plan would cause delay to East Coast’s own movements,
and further, that it would not be practicable for two rail-
réads to work the new port. It also says that because of
the need to flag street crossings the Seaboard’s proposal
would create a hazard to employees; and it urges that serv--
ice to East Coast customers located on its track between
ns 31la
% 7
1st Avenue and Biscayne Boulevard would be adversely
affected by Seaboard’s operation. Past experience in joint —
service to the existing iia refutes each of these con-
tentions. |
The procedure in n switching at the new port will differ
in no way from the present operation. Both railroads
‘now switch the port and none of the port'user witnesses .
made any mention of damage when asked if they had
experienced difficulties at the present port. There would
be no greater damage to lading under the Seaboard pro-
posal than now exists.
East Coast insists that its plan will not result in any ;
increase in charges paid by.the public on traffic moving
through the new port. While this may be true with re-
spect to East Coast traffic, the record shows that existing
Seaboard tariffs in many instances would prevent Sea-
board from lawfully absorbing the switching charge which
East Coast proposes. For example, without any change in.
the. existing tariffs; on water-borne -traffic which might
move through Dodge Island on-domestic rates to and
from non-competitive Seaboard local stations, the Sea-
board could not lawfully absorb. any. part of the East
Coast’s switching charge, regardless of what it might be.
Furthermore, as a matter of practical economics, under
the East Coast plan a movement which is single line in
nature today would become a multiple carrier situation
at the new port, and an interchange arrangement, with the
attendant increased cost and expense, would be involved.
If Dodge Island is ‘to be served exclusively by East Coast,
the total transportation and terminal charges on Seaboard:
movements will be increased over those now prevailing at
the port of Miami. Analysis of the tariff provisions cited
on brief by counsel for the Greater Miami Traffic Associa-
tion supports this conclusion,, not only on non-competitive
line-haul doniestic -traffic moving through the port, but °
| ae
32a ©
with respect to export traffic and cross-town » ital move-
arene as well.
' Bast Coast directly serves 7 industries along its main
line between N.W. 8th Street and the Miami River; 8
industries between N.W. 1st Avenye and-Biscayne Boule-. _
vard along the-P&O dock spur; and 6 industries on the
P&O dock. On the municipal dock lead track between N.W.
1st Avenue and Biscayne Boulevard it serves 12 indus-
tries, and 14 industries on the municipal docks. During the
> years 1961-62, East Coast handled 4206 and 4028 carloads
of freight, respectively, or an average of slightly over
11. cars*a day, to and from these industries. Several -of
the industries have discontinued rail service within the
past year. In addition East Coast maintains team tracks
at various locations on each side of. its mainline from -
N.W. 11th Street. south to its freight. station near the ,
river.
East Coast contends that the Riedie ethene would
‘create unnecessary traffie-and- safety hazards. It points
out that trains serving the new port facilities must
cross, at grade, some of the most heavily traveled ‘streets —
in downtown Miami, namely, Biscayne Boulevard, North
Miami Avenue, N.E. 1st Street, N.E. 2nd Street and N.W.
1st Avenue which, in order, had traffic counts on- October
25, 1962, of approximately 55,000, 10,000; 12,000, 13,000,
and 5,500 vehicles in a 24hour period. All train move-
ments over these streets must stop at each intersection,
and a trainman must flag” every crossing. The city has
. requested that train movements across Biscayne Boulevard ,
be made only during periods of minimum vehicular traffic .
flow, that- is, between 7:00 pm. and 6:00 am. East’
Coast states that under the Seaboard proposal, two train -
crews would be engaged in opposing movements in a con-
gested area and across busy vehicular crossings, and that
such a situation would create obvious safety hazards to
‘the crews and to the public. ,
-
33a-
p ee . ; - ‘
At the present time there are two railroad tracks across
“>, Biscayne Boulevard and the other ‘north-south vehicular
highways mentioned by East Coast between its main line
and the municipal piers. In serving the present piers, it.
is frequently necessary to switéh, back and forth across
Biscayne Boulevard to spot.cars at shipside. Such hazard- -
ous .operation would be eliminated because all crossings
of that-highway will be on a single track in‘a direct move-'
ment oyer the causeway to the new port. In addition,
municipal authorities contemplate opening the east-west
’ streets to vehicular traffic in the vicinity of East Coast’s
old passenger\station which, no longer required for rail-
road purposes, been dismantled. Most of Kast Coast’s .
tracks laid along. 1st Avenue between its interchange track
with the Seaboard at 11th Street south to Flagler Street
‘also are to be eliminated. When these changes are made,
the movement of vehicular traffic in the affected area should
become more fluid, and the congestion complained of by
East Coast in large measure should ‘be relieved. The con-
tention with respect to the congestion in the Miami down-
-town area appears to be overemphasized by East Coast
in view of thé fact that the city officials support, Seaboard’s
plan to serve the new port, something they would not do
if vehicular traffic would be.endangered or substantially -
inconvenienced.
.> .All the testimony adduced at the hearings, except that
submitted by officials of East Coast, favored dual rail serv-
ice to the new port. The director of the port, who had a ©
major role in the planning and development of the new
". facilities, testified that direct rail competition would mean
better service to the port users, as well as to the Dade
‘County area generally; that the impetus of such competi-
-. tion would insure prompt handling of switching, and re-
quests for cars; and that promptness is particularly vital
at the port because the,ships are generally on a very tight
schedule and must hold time’in port to a minimum. _ He
further stated that in the event of a national emergency,
service by each carriers handling its own equipment would
avoid delays and additional .switching; and that after the |
many years of dual service, to now permit operation by an
_ East’ Coast alone wotild effectively downgrade the rail
service available at the port.
The witness expressed grave concern over cessation’ of
activity in the event of labor difficulties. if only one rail-- |
toad served the port. On J anuary 23, 1963,.a strike by”
employees was called on the property of East Coast, and .
‘Seaboard handled all the rail traffic throngh the port of
Miami ‘until September of that year when Hast Coast
resumed freight service at the port. The strike was still
, going on at the time of the, hearings herein. If the port.
> had been served exclusively ‘by East Coast, it would have |
-- been closed to rail traffie for a considerable portion of 1963.
The director and the users of the port seek to avoid any
such disruption in connection with rail service to the new
facilities.‘on Dodge Island. Shippers and receivers of’
freight through the port supported the testimony of the
» port director, and‘ requested that: both railroads be per-
mitted -to serve the new port with its own engines and
crews. They particularly object to the delay which would -
“result from the use of an additional carrier involved in
-an.interchange movement. 7
The municipal and nee seid in - this proceeding,
as well as the lack of public opposition, indicates clearly
| that the public interest would best be served: by the con- »
ie tinuation of an operation rendered for many years toa .-
. port that is expected to increase in size and to require
added service for the future. It has been held that the term ~
‘public interest’? as used in the statute is not a mere
_. general reference to public welfare, but as shown by .the
-context. and. purpose of the act; has direct relation to the’
adequacy of transportation service, to its essential con-
ditions of economy and efficiency, and to appropriate pro- |
vision and best use of' transportation facilities. Texas v.
o A a NN AT la el aly SIN ts Ni a an eh wre Boee
35a
“United States, 292 U.S. 522. In determining whether a
proposed transaction is. in the public interest, considera-,..
C
- tion must be given to the public affected and-to the effect of “
the transaction on adequate transportation service to all
parts of the public which would be affected. Detroit, T. d
I.-R. Co.,.Control, 275 1.0.6. 455, 488; Chicago, B. d Q. R.
Co., Control, 271 LC.C. 63.. The. Contuniesion has always
recognized that the interests ‘of shippers ‘and users of .
tfansportation are matters of substantial importance in
determining the question of public interest and need. St.
- Marys R. Co:, Construction, 295 1.C.C. 677. Not only does |
the shipper testimony in this proceeding show that con- |
tinued ‘service by both railroads would be in the public in-
terest, but the director of the port has demonstrated: that
it is important that the port be kept open and in as vigorous
condition as possible so that water carriers may be attracted
to it and the public given the least expensive and most
efficient service. Compare Construction by W., B. T. é 8.
Ry., 124 1.0.C., 769, 802. — ‘
For many years the Seaboard has crossed the main-line
of East Coast at 11th Street, physiéally occupying the
' \tracks of the latter for a period of time in connection with
each movement. Under the suggested method of opera-
tion, the -East Coast: tracks would be occupied for two.
movements daily, each mow’ment requiring from 10 to 20
minutes. By comparison, today’s operation, and that which
has been going on for some ime, requires ‘at least half
that. amount of time in occupying ‘the crossing for each
_ of the two daily movements. The amount of additional
time which’ would be involved under Seabsard’s proposal
- cannot be said.to be unreasonable or burdensome. Nor is
- it logical for East Coast to urge that its use of the tracks
between 1st Avenue and Biscayne Boulevard would be
impaired as a result of the suggested operations. For many
years both of the railroads have served the 11 industries
now located on the Municipal Railroad tracks east of the
East Coast main-line and west of Biscayne Boulevard;
~
-- whereas under the applicant’s sieniiadh the Seaboard ar |
opérate straight through and would not serve any ofthe
8. industries located on the-East Coast track .which would -
be used to reach the new port. Equally unreasonable is
the East Coast argument ‘that it is impracticable for the
two railroads to work the new port. Aside from the*fact —
that both have operated jointly at the existing, smaller
port in a satisfactory manner for 35 years, the new and
larger port facility has been especially designed for serv-
- jee by both railroads. The’same number of cars still will
-. be moved to and from the port over a similar route. under
' either plan,’ and any hazard which is present will con-°
tinue meee. ee
. The record sie a finding that the joint use pro-
posed by the Seaboard would not materially change the:
method of opération which has long been followed, and
; would riot substantially impair the Eagt Coast’s ability
‘to handle its own business.. Compare Chicago € N.W. Ry. .
Co. v. Ann-Arbor R. Co., 263 I.C.C. 287. The long past '
. experience with respect to joint service at the port of:
Miami demonstrates the public interest with respect to
applicant’s proposal. A continuation of the existing joint
‘service obviously would be more efficient and economical
than the new interchange service proposed by East Coast.
Furthermore, continuation of the present method of serv-
. icing the port would assure its future operation without
discrimination ‘or favoritism, insuring better and more
dependable service, and ‘promoting proper development .
of the port. Joint service: would obviate delays, which
cannot: be tolerated in port operations, and would assure
the port of Miami an uninterrupted rail service. Past
experience has demonstrated that the joint use of a portion
of the East Coast’s terminal tracks would not substan-
tially impair the ability of that carrier to handle its own
business. In the past the Commission has exercised its
“power to require joint use of tracks where the operation
sought would be in the public interest and would be prac-
—s - . ~f a ee pee ee an
; .? we 37 a E ] F ‘. :
ticable without substantially i impairing the ability of the
owning line to handle its own business. Use by Erie of
‘Niagara Junction Ry. Co., 269 1.C.C. 493. The same ¢on-
clusion is warranted in this proceeding. The spur of com-
petition will- insure efficient and — service to the
new port.
The position. advocated by East Coast i in this proceeding
is similar to that. taken by it in Miami Municipal Railroad
Extension, supra, wherein the Commission, over the ob-
jection of East Coast, permitted operations by Seaboard to —
the municipal docks. The fact that the new port will be
publicly owned and operated, all carriérs serving ~Miami
should have direct access: to its terminal facilities. Com-
pare Illinois Central R. Co. Construction and Trackage,
307 I.C.C. 493, and the cases therein cited. Extension of
_ the Seaport Departmeht’s existing tracks to connect with
the new port is not practicable, and for the Seaboard to
construct its own line to Dodge Island would constitute
a wasteful and unnecessary duplication of railroad facil-
ities, particularly when the Same result can be obtained by
the expediShey of a comparatively short operation over the
tracks of East Coast. If there is any justification for the
enactment of section 3(5) of the ont, it ig to cover a situ-
ation as here presented.
- Representatives of railway: Tabor testified a the final.
héaring in this proceeding. A witness with seniority on
East Coast, but who’ has not worked on that railroad
since June 1962, opposed the application; and a former
East Coast employee now working for Seaboard supported
the application. The latter also requested protective con-
ditions for the ‘benefit of any employee who may. be ad-
versely affected in the event the instant application is de-
nied. It is questionable whether the Commission can im-
pose such conditions in a proceeding instituted under
section 3(5) of the act. Regardless of this fact, however,
if the recommendation of the examiner herein is adopted,
PROP AT RE A GI No ERE TREE
| | 88a
each carrier will continue to handle its own traffic with
its own crews to and from-the port, in which case employees ~
in no manner whatsoever will be adversely affected.
* Wena iiataaioe AND OnpeR P
The hearing examiner finds that the use by the Seaboard
er Air Line Railroad ‘Company of the railroad tracks and
facilities of the Florida East Coast Railway Company in
Miami, Dade’ County, Florida, in operating to and from
) the new port under construction, as described herein, would
in the public interest; and that such operation is prac-
*ticable and would not substanitially impair the ability of
the Florida. East Coast Railway Company to handle its
_ own business. Accordingly, an appropriate order should
be entered, conditioned upon such terms and such compen-
sation as the Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company and
the Florida East Coast Railway Company may agree upon, ©
or, in the event of d failure to agree,-as this Commission
may. fix as just and reasonable, to be ascertained in ac- ‘
cordance with the’ provisions of section 3(5) of the act;
and conditioned further that the enjoyment of the use of
said facilities therein prescribed shall be subject to the
right of the Florida- East Coast Railway Company to
require that the compensation for such use shall be paid
‘or shall be adequately, secured — the use under that
erder shall be commenced,
of another carrier has been determined, the interested car-
riers shall have an opportunity to agree upon the terms and
___ com ion for such use. A conscientious endeavor on
_the part of each should be undertaken to work out an agree-
ment mutually satisfactory as to terms and compénsation.
In such endeavors the parties should keep in mind that*
_. if the Commision is.called, upon to fix the compensation’
'- it must, under.section 3(5), be ascertained on the principle
controlling compensation in. condemnation prone.
‘The language of section 3(5) clearly contemplates,that —
_ after the right of a petitioner to use the terminal facilities
ee eee
Alrcasinssiling ini seditisien areca Mote. 78
Those principles are discussed at lng in Missouri-K. 7.
_R. Co. v. Kansas City Term. Ry. Co., 198 1.C.C: 4, in which a
decision compensation for the use of the facilities there —
considered was. determined upon those principles. A care-
ful study of ‘those pririciples should enable the Seaboard
and East Coast to arrive at. sregency” and just compen-
quired. If, however, they | are. unable to agree, they’ may -
petition the Commission to, reopen the proceeding for fur-
ther ‘hearing looking to a determination and prescription
.° of terms and compensation. . Jurisdiction should be re-
tained for such purpose. See Use by Erie of Niagara Junc-
tion Ry. Co. Terminals, 269 I.C.C. 493, 503. ter
Premises considered, it is the ~— of. the hearing
| examiner that:
‘The application of the Seaboard Air Line Railroad Com-
pany be, and it is hereby, granted; and that the use by
the said Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company of the rail-
road tracks and facilities of the Florida East Coast Rail-
way Company to serve the new port under construction |
at Dodge Island in Miami, Dade County, Fla., described
herein, be and it is hereby, approved and authorized sub-
ject to the conditions mentioned heretofore.
Within 30 days from the effective date of this order the:
_ Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company and the Florida East
Coast Railway Company shall submit for consideration and
approval of the Commission ‘a joint agreement containing
the terms and compensation covering the operation of the
tracks and terminal facilities the use of which is herein
authorized; and in the event such agreement for any rea-
son cannot be reached, a petition may be filed ‘requesting
the Commission to determine such just and reasonable
". terms and compensation.
The authority herein granted shall not be exercised prior
to the date of service of an order adopting this recommenda-
| 40a
‘tion as the order of the tntite: or of a notice stating
that this recommended. ms has become the order of. the
Commission. ;
, By the Commission, Paul C. Albus, Hearing Examiner.
Dated at: Washington, D. C., this 28th day of aay, A. ‘D.
Cc ee a: p= :
ean ts ‘ies
eect inde” Sse Secretary. —
»
©
.
params een eee oe
| ‘Ma
oe APPENDIX E
- ; , Interstate Commerce Act
Section’ 1(18),- 49 U.S.C. § 1(18)
No carrier by railroad: subject to this’ “chapter shall
undertake the extension of its line of railroad, or the
construction of a new line of railroad, or shall acquire .
or operate. any line of railroad, or extension thereof, or
. * shall engage in transportation under this chapter over
or by means of such additional or extended line of
railroad, unless and until there shall first have been
obtained from the Commission .a certificate that the
present or future public convenience and necessity’ re-
quire or will require the.construction, or operation, or
construction and operation, of such additional: or ex-
tended line of railfoad, and no carrier by railroad sub-
ae ject to this chapter shall abandon all or any portion
of a line of railroad, or the operation thereof, unless
and until there shall first have been obtained from the
Commission a certificate that the present or future: pub- -
lic 6onvenience and necessity permit of such abandon-
ment. .N othing in this paragraph or in section 5 of
this title shall be considered to prohibit the making of
* contracts between carriers by railroad subject to this
‘ chapter, without the approval of the Commission, for
the.-joint. ownership or joint’ use of spur, “industrial,
team, switching, or side tracks.
Section 1(19), 49 U. S.C. § 1(19)
The application for and issuance of any such cer-
tificate shall be under such rules and regulations as to
hearings and other matters as .the Commission may
from time to time prescribe, and the provisions of. this
chapter shall apply to all such proceedings. ‘Upon
receipt of any application for such certificate the Com-
mission shall. cause notice thereof to be given to and
‘a copy filed with the governor of such State in which
re ereeneuenwnecemens ~— me TERNS ee nate
- ~
420
such additional or extended line of railroad is pro: ae
_ posed to be constructed or operated, or all or any por-
tior: of a line of railroad, or the operation thereof, is
-. proposed to be abandoned, with the right to be heard
as hereinafter provided: with respect to. the hearing of
complaints or the issuance of securities; and said
notice shall also be published for three consecutive
weeks.in some newspaper of general circulation in each
county in or through which said line of railroad i is con-
structed 0 or operates. -
Section 1(20), 49 9 U.S.C. $ 1(20)
The Commission shall have power to issue such cer-
tificate as prayed for, or to refuse to issue it, or to
issue it for a portion or portions of a line of railroad,
or extension thereof, described in the application, or
for the partial exercise only of such right or privilege,
and may attach to the issuance of thé certificate such
terms and conditions as in its judgment the public
convenience and necessity may require. From and.
after issuance of ‘such certificate, and not before, the
carrier by railroad may, without securing approval
‘other than such certificate, comply with the. terms and
- eration, or abandonment. covered thereby. Any con- .
conditions contained in or attached to the issuance of
such certificate and proceed with the construction, op-
struction, operation, or abandonment contrary to the
provisions of this paragraph or of paragraph (18) or
(19) of this section may be’ enjoined by any ‘court
of competent jurisdiction at the suit of the. United
States, the Commission, any. commission or, regulating
body of the State or States affected, or any party in
interest; and any carrier which, or any director, officer,
receiver, operating trustee, lessee, agent, or person,
acting for or employed by such carrier, who knowingly
authorizes, consents to or permits any violation of the
provisions of this paragraph or of paragraph (18) of
re
a Sal Gay tpn i
. .
i tt Nh Albano asm
this ‘section, shall upon conviction thereof be punished
by a fine of not more tharf $5,000 or by imprisonment
for not more than three years, or both.
Section 1(22), 49°U.S.C. § 1(22) O25 acs -
4
The apthority of the.Commission conferred by para-
graphs (18) to (21) of this section, botlr inclusive, shall
not extend to the construction or abandonment of spur,
industrial, team, switching, or side tracks, located or
to be located wholly within one State, or of street,
suburban, or interurban electric railways, which are
not operated as a part or parts of a general steam
railroad ‘system of transportation. * ,
Section 3(5), 49 U. 8.c. § 3(5)
Wire ace ns one
If the Commission finds it to be i in the public interest
| and to be practicable, without substantially impairing”
| the ability of a common carrier by railroad owning or
entitled to the enjoyment of terminal facilities to handle
its own business, it shall have power by order to re-
quire the use of any such terminal facilities, including ©
main-line track or tracks for a reasonable. distance
outside of such terminal;.of any conimon carrier by’
railroad, by*another such carrier or cther such car-
' riers, on’such terms and for: such compensation as the
-earriers affected may agree upon, or, in the event of
a failure to agree, as the Commission may fix as just
‘and reasonable for the use so required, to be. ascer-
tained on the principle controlling compensation in.
condemnation proceedings. Such compensation shall
be paid or adequately secured before the enjoyment of
the use may be commenced. If under this , Paragraph
the use of such terminal facilities of any carrier is
required to be given to another carrier or other car-—
riers, and the carrier whose’ terminal facilities are -
required to be so used is not satisfied with the terms
fixed for such use, or if the amount of compensation
da
| so fixed is not duly and- promptly: paid, the carrier
‘. ‘whose terminal facilities have thus been required to
‘be, given to another carrier or other carriers shall be
entitled to recover, by suit or action against such other
carrier or carriers, proper damages for any injuries
sustained by it as the result of compliance with such-
requirement, or just compensation for such use, or
oe both, as the case may be. :
Administrative Procedure —_
Section 10(c), 5 U.S.C. $ 1009%c)
Except so far as (1) statutes preclude judicial re-
view .or (2) agency action: is by low committed to
‘agency discretion.
Acts reviewable
(c) Every agency action made reviewable by statute
‘and every final agency action for which there is no
other adequate remedy in any court shall be subject to
judicial review. Any preliminary, procedural, or in-
_ termediate agency action or ruling not directly review-
_ able shall be subject to review upon the review of the
final agency action. Except as otherwise expressly re-
quired by statute, ageney action otherwise final shall
be final for the purposes of this subseetion whether or
not there has been presented or determined any ap-
plication for, a pg, ern rdet, for any form of
reconsideration, or (unless the agency otherwise re-
quires by rule and provides that the action meanwhile
shall be inoperative) for an appeal to superior agency
authority.
Hon 7 .
P70 PR TREE greens x
+
- oo i ee
oP rerepanranes
PPO Om - Pree aie,
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.