Transcript of Record — Hughes Tool Co. v. Trans World Airlines, Inc.

Supreme Court brief1965

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

*

as ea! eee Se ee

Tears Wom Amunres, Ino. le

* . | ; Plaintif-Appellee,

= | against

ei 1 «| ance |

is 4 i ae: Howarp R. Hucues, |

4 | xf on ae Defendant,

. “ . and i . e 7

ae Huonss Toor Company and Rayfrop M. Hotsaar, :

; Defendants-Appeliants. E

“APPENDIX TO BRIEF OF DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS

HUGHES TOOL COMPANY and RAYMOND M. HOLLIDAY

a } Volume II —- Pages A-471 to End

—— Te

— 0. Davis, Esq., -

Attorney for Defendants-Appellants,

Hughes Toot Company and

‘Raymond M. Holliday;>

120 Broadway, .

New, ark: 6; N. )

Dated: September 9, 1963

oY

se prea” te rary pine ome

VOLUME II

INDEX

(Voume I INCLUDES paces A-1 to A-470

Vouume II inciupes pacrs A-471 To A-964)

a

/

. (. ; PAGE

Rule 15(b) Statement ............... Erna i

Pleadings: _

A Gees «x... <5... 5. «05 oc cccn.. Al

Tooleo Answer and Counterclaims.............. A-31

Holliday’s Answer .:..... rors he ec Suk aK ek A-144

Pretrial Orders and Opinions:

District Court Order, August 14,1961 .......... A-85

Pretrial Order, February 7,1962 .......... .... A139

Pretrial Order, March 5, 1962".......... ... oT

Pretrial Order, July 12,1962 .................. A-88

Pretrial Order, J onuary 10, 1963 .............. A-90

' Opinion and Order, February 7, 1963 .......... . A-118

Opinion and Order, May 3,1963................ A-132

Order of U. S. Court of Appeals, June 6, 1963 .. A-138

Pretrial Proceedings:

Before Special Master; September 15, 1962 ..... A-161

Before Special Master, October 25, 1962 ........ > A-166

Before Judge Metzner, February 6, 1963 ...... . AGS .

&

Miscellaneous: - .

Tooleo’s Notice of Position ......,....... ws... A-130

TWA Brief, October 2,1961 .................. A-279

CAB Orders:and Opinions ....... ee eee _A-173

_ CAB Examiner’s Report—1948 (Docket No. 2796) A-228

Deposition Testimony:

| Charles C. Tillinghast, Jr. ..... eae eee ee A-298

.

Deposition Testimony (cont’d)

Emmett O. Cocke

A. V. Leslie’ _.

Defendant's Exhibits: |

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Ixhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit 1

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit ,

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

. Exhibit

Exhibit 1:

Exhibit

Kaabibit.

Exhibit 2%

Exhibit 3

ee ee ee te ee ae ee oe es

A-960

A

A-471

Cocke Deposition.

[14683] a

[Testimony—October 18, 1962]

Q Let me read to you a portion of Mr. Pierson’s ©

[14684] testimony before the.CAB in the Further, Contrel-

case, Mr. Cecke, and-see if that will 1 refresh your recollec-

tion in any way, and also for the purpose of my asking you

a question as to whether or not you agree with the facts

there stated.

Mr. Hupper: Can you identify the date of this

testimony for my personal information? |

Mr. Davis: It is the first time I am referring

to it. It was a hearing which‘was held at the Federal

Building, in Los Angeles, on October 3, 1949. The

hearing inthis matter was convened at 10 o’clock that

morning of that date. This is in-the-matter of trans-

actions between Hughes Tool Company -and Trans-

continental Western Air, Inc., Docket No. 2796, which

was part of the record that was the basis for the

Examiner's report, which has already been marked

as Defendants’ Exhibit 130.

By Mr. Davis: | . a -

Q Mr. Cocke, I am going‘to start at page 25 of the

transeript.. This is Mr. Pierson testifying. He referred

first to the Finletter Committee report.

-Are you familiar with the Finletter Committee Feport

that was issued relating to the problems of airlines and the

financing of equipment by airlines!

[14685] A I don’t recall it, no.

Q After referring to that the witness said:

“Well. the part that interested me partieularly

in the report was what the committee had to say .

A-472

Cocke Deposition.

about airline finance: If I may read two very brief

paragraphs beginning at-the bottom of page 116:

‘The airlines have traditionally operated on low

working capital. Moreover, current assets accumu-

~~“ Tated during the war years were depleted by the pur-

chase wf new airplanes and by operating losses.

Loans secured by equipment are Uifficult to obtain in

the air transport field. Railroads are able to secure

financial aid to buy new equipment through the sale

- of equipment trust certificates at low interest rates .

without restrictions on their operations or finances.

‘It would. be desirable if the equipment trust

method of financing so successful with railroads could

be used for the purchase of air transport equipment.’

‘*Then the question Was ‘‘Has there been a sub-

stantial improvement in the condition of TWA since

April 1957?’ “cy

‘Yes, there has! I might, if I may, refer to some

. figures here, and make a more responsive answer.

The company’s net worth, Mr. Examiner, on Septem-

ber 30, 1945, was over $18.5 million. That net worth

_ had [14686] fallen by the end of 1946 to something

under $4 mill?on. By the end of 1947 there was a

- deficit figure of net worth, deficit in something sub-

stantially over $3-million. As of the first half of

- this year fhe net worth has returned ‘to something .

' in excess of $12 million, and, as of the present day,

the figure is somewhat better than that. So we have

» gone from $18.5 million in September 1945 down to

a deficit of $4 million, back td a net worth of some-

thing in excess of. $12 million. ts

.

Do you have any recollection whatever with respect to

the financial condition of TWA from 1945 through 1947, or

thereabouts, comparable to this testimony of Mr. Pierson.

A I would accept Mr. Pierson’s testimony in the case.

a>

&

VSB

se

eS

~AATR.. \ >

, Cocke Deposition:

' Q You don’t have any personal independent recollec-

tion of ‘these facts, is that correct?

A I knew this was true, yes. -

: Q Did you ever discuss with anyone at. TWA the

problem of the financing ‘of aircraft equipment?

_. A Only so far as the discussions that have taken place

at the board of directors meetings, and at this time, of

course, as vice-president of sales I wasn’t involved in the

financial problems of the company as part of my duties.

[14687] Q Turning to page 27, and continuing that same

. line of testimony, but skipping some—there is a reference

- there to a letter agreement of January 8, 1947 between the

~» Too] Company and TWA. Are you familiar with what that

relatesto? =. .

A No,Iamnot.

Q That related to that $10 million commitment sub-

scription, or that doesn’t mean anything to you, does it?

A No,I don’t recall that.

Q On page 27, still with Mr. Pierson, the question was:

‘‘Q > What in your opinion has that iene

been due to? .

‘*A Well, it has been due to several things. The

~ suecessful cartying out of our two major objectives,

cutting costs and i increasing our mail pay. We have

also improved our operating techniques during this

_ period. A.fourth item of particular importance has

been—or of major importance—has been the assis-

tance we have secured from Mr. Howard Hughes or,

rather, Mr. Howard Hughes’ company, the- Hughes

Tool Company.

‘*Since the time I have been with the company

we have had the wholehearted support of Mr. Hughes

_ [14688] and his company. The most important item

of that support being, of course, the purchase by

Hughes Tool Company of $10 million of convertible—

A-474

Cocke Degpsition.

$10 million stock following the original letter. of

, January 8th, which provided for a loan in that

. amount. :

‘*More recently—I believe it was February of

this year—there was an underwriting of some $4 .

- million sales value of our common stock, and in. con-

nection with that underwriting the Hughes Tool Com-

pany took its percentage which was—I guess it was .

in round numbers, $3 million.’’

Were you aware of the period when the objective was to

cut costs and seek to obtain an increase in mail pay?

A Yes, I was.

Q Can you describe how those shdnetives were de-

veloped?

‘A In the reduction of all possible necessary expense

that would not affect safety, would not cripple the sales

effort.

Q Do you know from whence those directives or ob-

jectives came—the origin of either me diréctive’ or the

objective?

A I believe they came from Mr. Seniens the chief exec-

utive officer of the company.

14689] Q That was not an objective during ‘the Frye

regime ?

; A Yes. We had several periods during the Frye re-

gime when the effort was made to reduce costs.

Q But is it your testimony that that objective was in-

' tensigfed with the Damon regime-as compared to the Frye °

regime?

+ A Idon’t recall any intensification, as you term it.

Q Let me refer a little more to Mr. Pierson’s testi-

_ mony, because it goes into ene. The next question

reads: .. ;

| *Q In connection with our ‘recent underwriting

of stock, when the underwriting was first proposed,

ty

"A475

Cocke Deposition.

did the underwriters say it could or could not be done

without the assistance of Hughes Tool Company?

“*A Well, they said it could not be done unless

Hughes Tool Company would agree to take its pro-

portion of the stock which was substantially three-

quarters.

“Q Did the underwriters believe that TWA

would be unable to market that common stock at $10

million unless Hughes Tool Company agreed.to take

its full portion of it at that price?

- os _ “A That was- their statement.”’

Did you have any knowledge or information whatever of any

[14690] kind ay | to the underwriting referred to by:

Mr. Pierson?

A Idon’t recall any. :

Q Did anyone at TWA ever desuns with you or tell

you about this underwriting or effort to obtain an under-

writing for $10 million wérth of stock?

_.. A I was certainly aware of it at the time, but I don’t

recall the details on it.

Q At the time you were aware of it but you just don’t

remember the details now, is that ‘it?

A That’s correct.

Q Do you recall diceusciens within the seeeaasinn

group of TWA to the effect that the underwriters were

‘taking the position that they could not or would not under- —

write re eer the assistance of the Hughes Tool Company?

don’t recall any discussions.

Q You do not recall any discussions to that effect?

A No.

Q You were never told that by anyone?

A I testified that-I am sure I was aware of it at the

time, but I don’t recall any discussions about it.

* Q Did anyone ever tell’ you anything inconsistent with

Mr. Pierson’s testimony that I have just read to you?

°

| A-476

~~ Cocke Deposition:

A Not that I recall.

' £14691] Q Let me read te you’ the next question and

answer of Mr. Pierson. I am still at page 28. The question

~ Was: bo. : i ‘

_“Q > But, in other words, it was Hughes Tool

. Company’s purchase of its full quota that supported

the market for the whole issue, and made-it possible

to sell the area issue of Stock at that: time, was it

not?

“A It was. I might go on with my answer as

to what has been done to help the company since

January '*—-we will put it of 1947. **We have carried

out an aggressive program of increasing our equip-

ment.

‘*In March of 1947 we added four Constellations

largely as a result of the funds which were advanced

_ by the Hughes Tool Company.

**Later in the year we purchased an additional

two Constellations. , In early 1948 we entered into

xn arrangement with Lockheed, financed by a group

of banks for the purchase of twelve Constellations

and, more recently, we have placed an order again

through Lockheed and substantially the same group

of banks for a further twenty Constellations, so since

January of 147, Mr. Examiner, we have added or

will have added, when we get delivery, thirty-eight

modern C oustellations to TWA'‘s fleet, international

and domestic.”

-»>

. TRAG92]) Then the examiner took a five-minute recess.

Are vou familiar with the program that was undertaken

on or about January 1947, relating to additions to the air

fleet of TWA! _

A The testimony you read me brings to mr recuilection

_ that these things happened, but I have no personal revol-

lection of discussions.

.

wae

_A4T7

ie Cocke Deposition.

{T aa ai iter 22, 1962]

-Q Dering the callie names regime ao you recall ”

some instances when Mr. Damon participated in any of

these discusions relating to aircraft acquisitions or plan-

‘ning for the acquisition of aircraft?

A Yes, we had meetings.-*

Q Can you describe some of them. for me? .

A I don’t recall the details.

.Q. Without going into the details,. can you give us

what your best recollection is?

A We would have a meeting. If everyone agreed, it

was fine. If there were Gisagreements, they were discussed

pro and cdn, try to come up.with the best recommendation

for the company. -

Q Do you have in mind any - particular meeting or a‘

particular time when this*process took place!

q It was a continuing process, to my recollection.

Q Do you recall-at any time anybody saying, *‘ Well,

there is no point in discussing this, because this is what ~

Mr. Hughes wants, and we have got to do what Mr. Hughes

[14906] says. and therefore why debate the question’’—

did that ever happen? :

A don’ + reeall that statement being. made.

Q Anything comparable tof which to you meant the

‘same thing? ~ .

A Certainly Mr. Hughes* interest in equipment was

well known.’ I don’t recall at any time anyone «aid, ** You

cant do this, rou ean‘t do that." * :

Q. So far as yon are concerned. Mr. Cocke, were the

‘recommendations whieh you made ‘always what you hon.

e~tir believed was in the best interest of TWA?

A My recommendations were, yes.

x

s

°

A-478

Cocke Deposition. .

Q And so far as you are concerned, no one ever tried

to influence you one way or-the other, other than to give

you whatever facts you obtained from others within‘ TWA?

A. No, I think. 1 would have to say that where I was in

elisagreement somebody tried to sell me whatsthey thought

were the benefits of what their recommendation was. -

Y Do you have any recollection of any instance when

Mr, Hughes or the Hughes Tool Company tried to sell you

something!

A Yes. 1 reeall discussing Constellations as opposed

to Douglas aircraft

» What do you have reference.to now!

WT] A 1 believe at one time there was a difference of

of

opinion as to whether we should buy Douglases or Con-

stellations.

Q. Can you identity then a little bit more specifically,

what kind of Douglas you are tind to, want type of

_ alreraft—

AL think they were the DC-6s, . .

Qe?!

A Yes.

Q Versus which ¢ ‘einstelbitton: “do sou recall!

A *T don’t recall which ome, whether it was the 1049

er the—1 believe it was 1049,

~Q > Now describe this difference of opinion which ex-

iste, and who held which point off yiew.

AL believe -in thisgprion | I think Mr. Hughes was

iuterested in, the DouglaSes. Tsrecall Mr. Damon and I

were opposed to Douglas, wanted to continue with the

Constellation live.

Q Which point of view prevailed!

A’ 1 don’t know of which point . prevailed. but wé

bought Constellations. .'

Q 1 didm't mean to say at which point ron prevailed.

1 was asking you whose peint of view in the ead prevailed.

,

A-479 ©

Cocke Deposition.

I gather from your last answer yours or Mr. [14908]

Damon’s point of view prevailed over that of Mr. agent

- A- Yes.

Q Do you recall any other time when Mr. Haghes or.

the. Hughes Tool Company, to you¥ knowledge, expressed

a preference. as fo the type of aircraft that TWA should

procurewr plan in procuring? ;

A I do'recall a question of a 1449 Constellation series,

( which were originally—which was originally conceived as

a turboprop airplane, . a

My recollection is Mr. Damon was opposed to that

‘airplane. I beliete Mr. Hughes, as I recall, and the Hughes

Tool Company members of’the Board were in favor of that

airplane.

ae en ) Q Can you tell me what happened then? |

| A The 1449s were purchased, they were ordered.

Sf Q By Hughes Tool Company?

AI believe so, yes.

Q Are you referring to the aircraft which subsequently

was modified to the 149 and thereafter to. the 1649?

A It finally came out as the 1649.

_ Q Did it come out aa turboprop airplane!

A It did not.

Q Were rou or Mr. Damon opposed to the acgnisition

(14999] of the 1649° |

‘A [think I tes}ifed that Mr. Damon, ‘as T recall, was”

opposed to the 1449: and I just don’t reeall whether he

passed away hefore the 1649 was aeqnired or not.

ae Q What do ron recall about the decia sion to aes lire the —

1649 in lieu of the 1449?

A Weill, the 1449) ae I stated, te my recollection,

was to be a turbo-propeller aircraft. Thé engines, tnrhe-

prop engines, did not develop.

As time went on, the airplane, I guess, to nae my

terms, drifted into a 1649: My recollection ia by that time

Pred

>.

2

aad

RS

; > ;

A-480

-Cocke Deposition.

the 1649 was the best we could see so far as delivery posi-

tions were concerned to acquire affaircraft that: we needed.

Q Can yu tell me’ what type of aircraft you or Mr.

Damon. were favoring in. lieu of the- 1449 at the: time that

the order ‘was: placed?

A ‘I was not opposed. to the 1449.

Q You were in favor of the 14481

A Yes. —

‘Q Can you damnation a little more feity what was taking

place at that time, the pros-and cons that were ag ad-

vanced?

- A I believe this was at the time of the question of

DC-7s or to continue the Constellation group. I personally

£14910] was opposed to changing from the Constellation

group. My recollection is that I believe Mr. Damon, I

think Mr. Rummel, favored the DC-7s.

Q Can you explain what reasons they advanced for :

favoring the DC-7 and the reasons that you had for being

opposed to the change, what views, if any, were being ex-

. pressed by Mr. — or anyone else in a fee differencé of

#irline.

the thinking. of your ——

% _ opinion? *

.A As I recall, it was a difference of opinion between

thyself. and Mr. Damon. 1 felt that TWA had-been operat-

ing Constellations since the first real four engine transport

came along.

That is the reason I was in favor of Constellations .

over DC-6s. I felt that, our omer was a. ‘Constellation

<t

were the -only tieiandniaitbaantat operator using

Constellations. I felt that.perhaps. the newer Constella-

tions would’ be tethnically as competitive with the Douglas

series. That did not turn out to.be righf.,

._Q Did anyone try to influence that point of view, the

point of view you held, which you just described, or was

that something which was a result of the development of

~

e . a

* A-481

Cocke pe,

A I think my feeling was shared by the Sales iii

[14911] ment. ~

_~ Q > My question is chile or not, to be. more, specific,

. Mr. Hughes or the Hughes Tool Company or any repre-

sentative of the Hughes Tool Company attempted. to in-

fluence your judgment or conclusions, and if so, how was. it .

done or who did it, the circumstances.

* A There were discussions at the Board meetings. I. |

' recall making my feeling known on the Constellations to

Mr. Damon and Mr. Collings, I recall discussing it with

Mr. Hughes, in which I took the position I felt we were a

Constellation airline, and our sales effort was beamed to

the Constellation.

I made my opiniéis known. Certainly people’ that

disagreed with me made their opinions known to-me.

Q You referred to a discussion with Mr. Hughes at

that time and thaking your opinions known. Can you tell

’ me what your complete recollection is of those discussions, *

if there was more than one, what you said and w hat he said,

what took place? -

A I recall making my pitch, if you want to call it that,

my feelings known, that we would be making a wnistabe:

to shift to Douglases. |

I believe at .one time Mr. en made. the comment

that perhaps the Constellation was going to be slower than

[14912] the Douglas.

I took the position; not Peing a technical person, I felt _

that the Constellations, if they weren’t as fast, would be.

so—it would be such a small amount of difference that-it

really wouldn’t affect the transcontinental schedule.

I recall Mr. Hughes saying that speed was extremely

important, with which I agreed, and as it. turned out, the

Constellations didn’t—weren’t as fast as at least I had

expected them to be. a

‘ >

x

a

A-482 |

_ Cocke Deposition.

Q Mr. Rummel has testified at some length as.to the |

fact that the 1649 did not turn out to meet the standards

which were anticipated at the time that they were pro-

cured or ordered. ‘

I am interested in the completeness, however, of your

recollection of what was said to you and what you said to

either Mr. Hughes or any other nepeeeeaes of the

Hughes Tool Company.

Have you given us now the total of your recollection—

A ‘My recollection, as I testified, it was based around

the speeg of the aircraft and my feeling that we shouldn’t

change our whole sales approach and go to Boeing—

excuse me—go to Douglas.

£14913] Q Can you, before we adjourn for the luncheon

recess, identify any other instance in addition to the two.

that you have testified about?

A I-don’t recall any.

| [Tetimony “October 23, 1962]

[15055] Q Can you tell me with whee you discussed your

views and the conclusions of your department as to TWA’s

needs? Can you tell me that ngach?

A Idiscussed it with thechief executive officer.

Q Mr. Damon? —

A Mr. Damon. I discussed it eortalely with the. other

members of management—Mr. Rummel, Mr. Collings. I am

sure I had discussions with Mr. Hughes, him asking me

- what I thought of the probable berths, and what the general

trend was, and I would give him, as others, the opinion I

had at that time.

Q Do you recall any particular discussion with Mr.

Hughes on this general subject,. other than what. you have

already identified or described?

A-483

A Cocke Deposition.

A No. There were numbers of ined that had to

do with the question of how attractive berths were, or

what I thought the public thought of this airplane or wat

airplane. I don’t recall the. discussions.

.Q Can you tell us what views, if any, Mr. Hughes ex-

pressed to you directly or indirectly in the area in which

you were interested?

A I had expressed my opinion. We would have some

[15056] discussion about it. ‘Sometimes he would agree

with me and sometimes he would not.

Q Cam you give me an idea of the nature of the dis-

agreement, and what happened when you asada

| A I don’t know.

Q You can’t recall any situation when there was a dis-

agreement between: you and Mr, Hughes as to the type ‘or’

quantity of equipment to be obtained, other than what you

have already identified to date? |

A I think thatisallIrecall,yes. .

Q Do you have any recollection of any discussion with

Mr. Hughes relative to what you were considering at this

time, namely, in the latter part of 1949 or early 1950, rela-

tive to the Boeings or DC-6Bs, or various types of Con-

stellations?

A Iam sure I discussed them with him, but 1 don’t

recollect the discussions.

-Q Do you recall any instance when TWA acquired

some aircraft, types of aircraft, to which you were opposed?

A No, Ido not.

‘cians aii acme 19, 1962]

£13929) Q oo refer there to an extended trip overseas.

Did that trip overseas involve in. any way an inquiry or

A-484

. Cocke Deposition.

investigation of available equipment? I have particular

reference to an entry in your diary which I note on Mareh ~

. 28th. x

Let me pursue it this way: I notice on March 28th

have an entry indicating that you rode in a Comet—on both

March 28th and March 29th. |

A -Yes.

Q My question still is whether or not prior to March

Ast, in connection with this extended trip that you had

overseas, did that involve looking at or inquiring into avail-

able aircraft from foreign sources?

A: No, it did mot.

Q Then see what entries, if any,in n your diary give

you any recollection which leads up to this event relating »

to Comets.

A It was decided early in this year that we would hold

a Board of Directors meeting in London. I felt that it

would be desirable to have the directors have an opportu-

nity of seeing the Comet and riding in the Comet, and

several flights were made. I was interested [15923] in the

possibility of perhaps TWA making some commitments for

the Comets at that time. Fortunately, they didn’t accept

my recommendation.

Q In other words, some time prior to that time you | -

had developed an interest in the Comet. as a possible type

of aircraft to be added to TWA’s fleet?

A Put it this way: It was the first jet transport, and

was being operated by BOAC out of London. Being the

“first jet it took the public fancy, naturally, and as thevice-

president-sales, I felt if we could find our way clear of get-

ting some Comets, we would have something that. would

have real value to it.

Q Did you try to arrange for a meeting of the Board

of directors in London so that they could have an oppor-

tunity of: eens at this new type of aircraft?

A485"

Cocke Deposition.

A No. I think it was just a coincidence that it hap-

pened. I had been anxious for our Board to hold a meeting

in Europe for public relations purposes. In fact, I think

that was the first meeting that an American company held

overseas, It just happened that*while we were in London,

-we were able to arrange with DeHavilland for the Board

members to take a flight in a Comet. ;

_. Q Did that happen both on Wednesday, March 28th,

and Thursday, March 29th?

[15924] A Yes. There were two flights operated, one on

Wednesday and one on Thursday. Some of the directors

_ rode on it one day and some the next day. |

-Q At that time did anyone arrange for meetings or

discussions or conversations with DeHavilland with respect

to the possible interest of TWA? .

A .I don’t believe it ever progressed that far.

Q ‘Do you recall whether or not any particular report

was made to the Board by anyone—Mr. Rummel?

A I don’t recall any.

Q Have you ever had any conversations or communica-

tions af any kind whatever with Mr. Hughes or M#® Dietrich

or anyone. whom you associated as a: representative of the

Hughes Tool Company, relative to this interest or possible

interest in the Comet? aes

A - I probably would have had with Mr. Dietrich. I be-

lieve he was on the Board at that time. I don’t recall .

whether he attended the London meeting or not. I don’t

recall any conversations with Mr. Hughes on the Comet.

[15925]-Q Did your desire for a jet transport, for a

Comet, reach thé point where you made a presentation to

the board with respect to it, or recommendation to anyone?

A I don’t think it. progressed that far.. '

Q It was just in the discussion stage within TWA

- management? ee

A Yes. At the same time— .

A-486

Cocke Deposition. _

Mr. Williams: The witness didn’t say that.

*Mr. Davis: He testified a moment ago that he

- made a recommendation which he was glad didn’t go

through, or something of the sort.

The Witness: Not accepted, yet.

Mr. Williams: I didn’t think there had been -

discussion at a Board of’ Directors meeting about it.

Mr. Davis: I said within TWA management.

By Mr. Davis:

Q Let me put the question to you this way: Will you

give us as full.a description as you can of What conclusion

or recommendation you made, and to whom, and what dis-

. cussions took place relative to the Comet?

A 1 think-I have stated before that there were no.

serious discussions, The very fact of our Board of Direc-

tors meeting in London, and riding i in the Comet gave TWA

.a lot of publicity. The British were proud of the air-

~ [15926] plane and were anxious to sell it. I, as vice-presi-

dent of sales, would have liked to have seen TWA buy some

‘Comets. an

My recommendation went no hstine than that. I don't

recall any detailed discussion of — possibilities, or

engineering studies.

' Q Do you recall any conversations or discussions with

either Mr. Rummel or Mr. Damon or Mr. Collings?

A Only that i felt that I would like to see TWA get

some C omets.

*. *. *

[15936] Q Mr. Cocke, during the recess have you had an .

opportunity to review Defendants” Exhibit 252!

Al have.

Q -Do you recall the request that was ‘made of you : to

prepare such a forecast of aircraft. requirements through

the vear 1995?

A-487

Cocke Deposition.

A I don’t recall the request. Specifically I was re-

quested to make equipment forecasts a number of times.

I don’t recall specifically this one forecast.

Q Was this something that reflected the independent

views and opinions which you had at the time?

A It does.

Q Was that something prepared by your group and

your department?

[15937] A. Yes.

Q And reviewed by you personally?

A Yes. ~

Q_ In connection with its preparation did you discuss

the matter with other department heads of TWA?

A Not, I don’t bélieve, from the standpoint of the

forecast of traffic. I no doubt discussed the types of air-

eraft with Mr. Rummel as to what would be available.

Q Prior to its preparation did you have any communi- -

cations of any kind with Mr. Hughes or Mr. Dietrich or

anyone whom yoy regardéd as a representative of the

Hughes Tool Company?

A No.

Q - In other words, these conclusions reflected in De-

fendants’ Exhibit 252 represent something which originate “dl

with you and your department! ?

A Yes.

Q. Do you recall whether or not this was something

which was the subject of discussion at Executive € ommit:

tee meetings, apart from directors’ meetings.

A It may have been, but I don’t recall any discussions.

Q You don’t recall any? .

A Nd.

[15938] Q I see you refer to the Korean incident. Wa-

that something which had a bearing on your. equipment

forecasting? ‘

.A It would, yes. Any. international disturbances affect

inte rnational travel.

A488 —tiéiB

' “Gocke Deposition.

Q I notice on the first page that you have a number of

assumptions there. Can you tell me where those assump-

tions came from? In other words, were they assumptions

. that you made, or were they assumptions that were given

to you by someone else?

A They were assumptions made mainly by discussions

with Mr. Fellows and myself.

‘ Q In other words, those were not assigned assump-

tions?

A No, they were not.

Q On page 2, the first paragraph starts out by stating

that ‘‘Our studies indicate that TWA should plan to add a.

‘total of 40 additional aircraft of the Constellation -1Q49C

type, or its equivalent to its fleet by 1955.’’

Can you describe or identify the basis of that conclusion?

A You would have to take, as I think I testified -to

several times before—you go back to the exhibits [15939]

and take the passengers forecasts of what volyme the in-

dustry will develop, our forecasted share of Hat ‘volume,

convert that-into aircraft capacity, a forecast rate of utili-

zation, and you come out with the number of ea mad you

need if this market forecast is correct. ~~

Q And. this referred to a total of 40 aircraft in addi.

tion to those already on order, is that correct?

A_ I believe so, yes.

Q I note that at the meeting of the Board of Directors .

- of June 29, 1959, Defendants’ Exhibit 251, there was a ref-

erence to the need ot developing « relatively long range

program for the acquisition of aircraft and financing.

“Will you look at Defendants’ Exhibit 251, and your report

to the board as reflected by the minutes which reads:

- **And emphasize the necessity for the develop-

ent of both the short range and leng range equip- ~

nient program adequately financed in order to main-

‘ r

\

~ A-489

Cocke Deposition. a

tain the position of the company in both interna-

tional and domestic operations.’’

-Do you see that?

.A-~ Yes.

Q That fairly summarizes what in fact you reported

‘tosthe board at that time, isn’t that right?

15940] A- That is correct.

-_Q Is this memorandum of July 25, 1951, an implemen-

tation of the reéommendation made to the board on June

29tht , .

A ILassume it would be, yes. ‘

Q Can you describe a little more fully than what ap-

pears in the first paragraph of page 2, the nature of the

conclusion you reached? I see some breakdown of these

40 additional aircraft—some reference to. air cargo and

some reference to DC-4 aircraft. Can you identify or de-

scribe a little more fully the nature of the conclusion you .

reached with respect to’ the short range and long range)

program for aircraft acquisition adequately financed, which’

you felt should be undertaken?

“A I don’t know how I can add.anything more to what

I have said. It is purely a function of forecasting the

volume in both domestic and international, and dividing

that out and finding how many airplanes it comes to.

Q This 1049G, is that the same thing as 1049As or

1049Gs or 1049Hs? .

A I am confused at the various letter designations

which, changed over. the years. I would assume that the

1049 is the version of the extended fuselage of the 749-049

type, and that the Cs, Gs and everything up to [15941] the

16494 would be about the same capacity aircraft that you ~

‘are talking about, with the exception of the ,ossibility of

changes in the power plants, whether they be piston driven

or turbo prop. |

° A-490

’ Cocke Depoqition.

Q Ai one -point when relemnen was made to 1049H,

Y docs ‘H’’ denote a cargo plane, or is the 1049H, as you

understand it, substantially the same type of aircraft as

-the 1049G or the 1049A?

A. There is some difference in aircraft. The ‘‘H’’ was

developed primarily as a cargo aircraft.

Q It was convertible into a coach?

A And also as convertible to cargo and pantengie air-

plane, and had some structural difference, T believe, as far

us floor loading: was concerned, so it could carry meavy e

cargo.

Q That 40 additional aircraft which you wére recom-

.. mending on July 25, 1951,-you break that down between 21

units for the domestic operation, and 9 units internationally,

‘ ora total of 30, and then you refer to the remaining 10

units—to be used in all cargo ‘service p ae. the DC+4

aircraft,

Can vou identify that aspect of it a little more fully’?

Were the D@-4s at that time being used in carge opera- ~

‘tions? Is that what was taking place?

Diss: 2J A Yes, they were.:

‘ Q And you were recommending an improvement. in the of

type of airerift to be used for this cargo operation! —~

A Yes. We had DC-4s in all cargo operation. This >

recommendation env isaged the replacement of, the DC-+s —

by modern cargo aircraft, and as it States, would serve to

get one type of an aireraft out of our operation. °

Q 1 notive in the next paragraph that rou say “It

might be well here to make a few genera! comments on the

overall equipment problem. There appears to be nothing

available prier to 1955, but the Lockheed 1449C and the

Douglas DC-6-B, both of which are conrertible to turbo

prop pewer plants. As there appears to be very little dif-

ference between the 149C and the DC:6-B. it @ould appear.

~

_—_

~ A491

Cocke Deposition.

logical that we — move ahead on the Constellation

route. _—

This decision could, of course, be influenced by substan-

- tial differences in price or delivery da

Can you tell us what was the basis for your conclusion

that nothing appeared to be available prior to 1955 but

these two types of aircraft? In other words, was that a

conclusion that you reached, or was that something that

you were told by someone, or was it based on ye gene -ral

knowledge of what was available!

[15943] A It wa conclusion reached from whet infor-

mation would be available to me. Probably discussions

with Rummel, or. my general know ledge of the manufac-

turers, and what was available.

Q Do you know of anyone who was supporting ‘the

idea of going to DC-6-Bs rathet than continuing with Con-

stellation at this time, in connection: with this report?

A Iam trying to get the sequence in mind.’ I believe

_ it was at this time that I understand Mr. Hughes was inter- ”

a

ested in the ste aircraft rather than the Constella- .

_ tions,

Q And the fection that Twa was to go the Constel-

lation route?

A Yes:

Q ‘And that is what in fact TW: A did get, isn't it?

A Yes. f

© . . ‘ 4

|, [Testimony—November 20, 1962]

(15988y +

. Q Can you descri

_ sions you either partici

going on at that time

ment, and the steps to

ted in or were aware e of hes were

ive to TWA’s, needs for equip-

en in connection therewith?

go

A-492

Cocke Deposition. |

A I recall nothing “ee what is completely outlined

in these documents.

Q Mr. Damon in his mémerentun reférs to American’s

. procurement of DC-7s and their speed advantage. Was that

‘something you were concerned about? .

A~ What page is that on?

Q I notice that on page 4.

Mr. Williams: Which exhibit?

P Mr. Davis: Exhibit 173.

A Yes, I would say that the DC speed advantage was

a worry to me, and I believe that is what brought about.

the development of fe 1649. -

ByMr.Davis: . -— ie,

Q Can you tell me what you said to anyone, or what

anyone said to you that you can recall, i in connection with

this matter?

' A Are yon speaking of at this time?

Q I will break it up into two questions. First I [15989]

would like to know what was taking place at that time,

namely, April to June ——, or the year 1962. :

A 1952.

Q 1952. .

A I can’t place the time of the conversations. Maybe’

in reviewing-the diaries it will come about. I did have some

discussions with Mr. ~eye onthe question of DC-7s speed

versus 1649s. I felt we should get the 1649s. Mr. Hughes

was concerned, and it was his belief that the DC-7s would

be faster than the 1649s that were then being built by

Lockheed.

I took the position that if it was a speed advantage

it would be so slight that it would not affect the scheduling.

I had confidence in Lockheed, and I didn’t believe that at

)

1)

A-493

Cocke Deposition.

this stage, with the last. of the platen aircraft, that we should:

go DC-7s. . ' 7

As it turned out, the 1649 was a disappointment. 4s far

as speed was concerned.

Q° Mr. Rummel explained that. Is that the only dis-

cussion of which you are aware with Mr. Hughes relating

to the*equipment program of TWA at or about that time?

A . Those are the only discussions that I recall--when

you mentioned DC-7 and the speed.

Q In connection with this aircraft requirement fore-—

[15990] cast that ; ou prepared on May 5, 1952, as reflected

by Defendants’ Exhibits 172 and 257, do those reflect. the

independent views and judgments of youresl! and your

- department at the time?

A - They do. .

Q Did you have any diecessions with either Mr. Hughes

or the Hughes Tool Company, or Mr. Dietrich, or anyone

you associated as a representative of the Hughes Tool Com-

pany, as to how it was to’ be prepared, or its contents, -or

~ anything of the like?

¢

. + .

A No, I did not.

[16015] Q I would like you to describe a little more fully, .

both what people told you, and what personal knowledge

you had as to the amount of time and effort that Mr. Hughes

' was spending on- ‘this equipment problem?

A I previously testified to'discussions with Mr. Hughes

on the relative speed of the DC-7 and the 1649.

Q - Anything else?

A I mentioned that-I had discussions with him on the

_ question of berths. His interest in the airplanes was cer-

tainly well know.

Have you finished?

A> Yes.

Q Nowas to what anybody told you.

A-494

Cocke Deposition.

_ A .I was aware of the Activities carried on by Bob

‘Rummel and Mr. Hughes in connection with discussions of

-airplanes. ‘8 ian

Q Does that fully identify and describe what you were

told? a

£16016] A I believe it does.

. * . * .

£16059] Q Do you have Exhibit 268 before you, Mr. Cocke?

A Ihave.” ; Sent

Q Would you read it very carefully, please? Have

you'finished reading it? a

A Ihave: ae ts *

Q Mr. Bradley was a director of TWA. in 1953, was

hénot. — eg | a

A He was. .

~Q > And so was Mr. Dietrich?

£16060] A Yes, I believe so... 7 si

[16061] Q You see Mr. Dietrich is replying to Mr. Bradley

and states on two separate and distinct occasions Howard

Hughes endeavored to divert Mr. Damon from the Lock-

heed to the Douglas airplane, and then the next paragraph

states that the first: occasion was prior to the time ‘‘we

placed the order for ten 1049s, The order was placed in

1950, and I think the conversations took place early in that

vear, a Pa

{t continues to say: , 3

. ‘*L remember particularly several conversations be-

' tween Howard .. .’’ referring to Mr. Hughes ‘. ...

and Ralph .. ."’ referring to Mr. Damon ‘‘. . . and

myseM ...’’ referring to Mr. Dietrich“. . . in which

Howard argued for the Douglas planes—and I finally

supported Ralph'on the Constellation program pri-

‘marily because we already had a fleet of Constella-_

tions:’’ . '

ad a caste eee eed

‘

A-495

Cocke Deposition.

That refers to the ten 1049As which are reflected on Defend- .

ants’ Exhibit 163, as having been contracted for in Decem-

ber 1950. Do you agree with that?

A Yes.

Q Do you recall anyone at TWA saying that Mr.

- Hughes at-that time was favoring — equipment over

Lockheed equipment?

A I think I have testified prev iously that Mr. Hughes

‘favored the Douglas equipment over Constellations. I don’t

[16062] know whether I specifically identified the time, but

I was-familiar with that fact.

Q Do you recall what top ‘management at TWA said

~ in that regard, either at Board meetings or out of Board

meetings?

‘A I think I have already testified as to my reasons

for favoring Constellations over Douglas.

Q Did anyone at the Board meeting in effect say,

‘‘Mr. Hughes may prefer Douglas, but we think we ought

to have Constellations, so we will BQ ahead and order Con-

stellations’’? '

A I don’t recall any: comments like that.

Q Have you given me now your total recollection of

what was taking place, or what consideration was given to

Douglas Aircraft over, Constellations?

A I don’t think I can add anything.

Q Will you look at the next paragraph in which Mr.

Dietrich says tq Mr. Bradley *

‘‘The second instance occurred prior to our

placing the order for the twenty Connies, whieh ill

be delivered this year... .’’ referring to 1955.

Then he continues :

‘*As I recall, the order was planed in the fall

of 1953, and these conversations occurred prior to.

[16063] the placing of the order. At. that time

A-496

Cocke Deposition.

Howard argued that the | Douglas airplane was

‘superior. He pointed out to Ralph that he was in a

position to secure preferred delivery of DC-7 equip-

ment which would have put us in possession of such

airplanes prior to the delivery of the Constellations

which are being delivered this year. I have my notes

which were made at the time of these last conversa- -

tions, and I am sure that Ralph will recall that both

Hewaed and I discussed the matter with him.’’

~~ Do you have any knowledge or renee of. any kind of

the occurrence described by Mr. Dietrich to Mr. Bradley?

A Not beyond what I have testified to.

Q Were you aware at the time that Mr. Hughes felt

that he could get good delivery positions from Douglas for ©

the DC-7?

A I don’t recall it, no.

Q Can you identify or pee discussions within

the management or personnel of TWA with respect to this

matter of the Douglas er versus sei Lockheed

equipment?

A I don’t recall anything beyond whit: I have said...

Q There was a time, was there not, when some concern

was expressed at the possible speed advantage that a DC-7

might have ‘over the Constellation. You remember that:

[16064] don’t you?

. & Tes.

Q Do you recall jn that comtectio: any discussion

unong the top viral op people of TWA, as to the av ail-

ability of DC-7s? ;

| A There were discussions of the DC-7. I think.I testi-

fied before that I had some discussions with M®: Hughes

on the question of speed differential between the DC-7 and

the 1649.

I wasn’t aw are that the DC-7 was involved in the con- |

sideration of the original Constellation orders of the 1049s

‘and the 1049Gs.

A-497

Cocke Deposition.

Q Can you identify or describe more fully the reasons .

advanced by the management of TWA for pursuing the ac-

quisition of Lockheed Constellations over the Douglas

equipment? »)

‘A ‘I can’t add anything to what I have already said.

Q Were you‘aware of these meetings between Mr.

Hughes and Mr. Damon and Mr. Dietrich, relating to that

_ Subject? ee

A I don’t recall them. I don’t recall exactly how

it came to my attention that Mr. Hughes was in favor of |

the Douglas. It could have been in discussions with Mr.

Damon, with Mr. Collings.

Q ‘I recall Mr. Rummel having testified at one point

[16065] to the effect that he was favoring or inclined to

_favor the DC-7. .Do you have any recollection of Mr.

Rummel’s position?

A I recall that he was in favor of the DC -7, as opposed

to the 1649.

Q: Can you'tell me how the decision \ was made to pro-

ceed with the Lockheed aircraft any more fully than you

have? Who made the decision?

~. A It was the management recommendation to the ~

Board of Directors that the Board of Directors approved.

Q The next paragraph reads:

‘‘] don’t: think the final decision in the matter

reflects on anyone involved. Frankly, I think that

back in 1950 Ralph was inclined to the same view

as Howard had, with respect to the comparative

” merits of the two airplanes, but it is my opinion that

he was influenced by the economic need of standardi-

zation.”’ 5 |

Do you have any recollection of Mr. Damon expressing

himself on the economic need of standardization?

A-498

Cocke Deposition.

A That was one of the factors that was considered by

Mr. Damon. The factors that affected or influenced my

recommendation’ were more on the sales side than’ the .

operating and cost side.

. £16066] Q Can you explain a little more fully what econo-

mic need of standardization was? What does that mean?

“A Ican’t explain it any | clearer than I think is outlined

in this memorandum.

Q -Does it have to do with the provisioning— |

A Mr. Collings took the position that you would have

additional training costs. The pilots would not be: inter-

changeable between Douglas and Constellation airplanes.

You would have to have separate crews, which would make

it difficult to integrate the fleet. There — be additional

spare parts.

Q Provi isioning and maintenance wa: spare parts in

many locations, was that an important factor?

A That’s correct. Training of people to handle two

' different kinds of airplanes.

Q The next paragraph of this letter reads:

‘Incidentally, I have in my files a memo of a

conversation with John Collings, which took place in

the early part of 1953, which followed conversations

between Howard and John with respect to the Doug-

las airplanes. John took the position that the ten

Douglas planes on which preferred deliveries were

offered to us would not be eompetitive in transcon-

tinental traffic. He expressed an objection to mixing

[16067] up Douglas and Lockheed planes in the fleet.

He pointed out that the training program would cost

an added $1 million minimum, and that an additional

$1 ‘million expense would be involved in the parts

program. He referred to psychological. disadvan-

tages, but did point to the fact that the DC-7 would

A-499

Cocke Deposition.

have a substantial speed and elapsed time advantage

transcontinentally over the new Connies.’’

Do you have any knowledge or information with respect to

the views expressed by Mr. Collings?

‘A Not beyond what he has: expressed here.

Q This fairly reflects cane views that Mr. Collings did

in fact express? _ i"

A Yes. lam not quite sure of the last sentence, whether

he is referring to the-DC-7 versus the 1649, or the 1049G.

Q. Mr. Dietrich appears to be referring to a conver-

sation with Mr. Collings, involving Mr. Hughes, ‘in the early

part of 1953. Were you at that time also, giving some con-

sideration to the development of what eventuated into the

1649s? -

A No. I think that clarifies it. He was referring to—

I assume he was referring to the G.

Q This refers to a preferred delivery position on ten

[16068] Douglas planes. Does that refresh your recol-

Jection in any way? |

A No, it does not. I am not sure just which ten Doug-

‘las airplanes he is referring to.

Q . Apparently Mr. Collifigs was taking the position that

-those Douglas aircraft would not be competitive in trans-

continental traffic. Is that something-you gave some thought

or consideration to?

A Idon’t understand his comment on ‘that. |

Q: Do you have any recollection of having given con-

‘sideration to the competitive advantages or disadvantages

of the Constellation versus the. Douglas type aircraft?

A -I don’t know what type of Douglas aircraft he’is

talking about in this ten.

Q This is a letter from Mr. Dietr{ch to Mr. Bradley,

a fellow director. . On its face it indicates it was a response

to comments of Mr. Bradley. Can you tell me if in that

‘ : A-500

Cocke Deposition.

period Mr. — expressed or made any oommnente that

you are aware of as to the manner in which TWA manage-

ment was making decisions with respect to aircraft equip-

‘ment, disregarding the counsel or wishes of the majority

stockholder?

Mr. Williams: Would you read that question,

please? Bt

[16069] Mr. Williams: I object to'so much of the

question as includes the comment ‘‘disregarding’’—

beginning with ‘‘disregarding.’’ I object to the ques-

tion in the form in which it is now.

~~. _I would not object to it if you leave off the qual-

fying clause at the end.

-Mr. Davis: My question at this point i is whether

or not he is aware of any comments of Mr. Bradley

to that effect. If he is not aware of any comments

by Mr. Bradley to that.effect, he may say so, and I

will ask him if he is aware of any other comments

made by Mr. Bradley.

' Mr. Williams: I don’t know that was Mr.

Hughes’ advice. We have a letter that may tend to

indicate that. We can ’t assume it.

Mr. Davis: May I ask him, as I think I am en-

titled to ask him, whether or not Mr. Bradley com-

plained to the management that Mr. Hughes’ views

were being disregarded.

Ms. Williams: I don’t object to that.

The Special Master: _ You may answer that.

A I don’t recall any such comments.

By Mr. Davis:

Q Do you recall any comments of Mr. Bradley as a

[16070] director to anyete in the top management group,

————- —-- —-

A-501

Cocke Deposition.

relating to the manner. in which TWA was pursuing its

policies relative to acquisition of aircraft! .

A I don’t recall any comments made by Mr. Bradley.

-Q Do you recall ever having a ‘discussion with Mr. .

Bradley with respect to this subject matter?

A’ I am sure there were many discussions with Mr.

Bradley in connection with the equipment discussions at the

_ Board of Directors. I don’t recall any strong position that

he took, or any position that he took.

Q You don’t recall any at all?

A. No, I do not.

Q Do you recall any discussions within the manage-

ment group of TWA relating to the extent to which, as a

management group, there was a need to give weight to the

views of Mr. Hughes with respect to the type of equipment

to be acquired, quantity, or related matters!

A I don’t recall any discussions along those lines, no.

Q Do you recall any discussion with: Mr, Dietrich to

the same effect I described to yor, namely, that manage-

ment of TWA should give weight or careful consideration

to the views of Mr. Hughes with respect to the type of

equipment? .

' [16071] A No, I don’t recall any discussions. _

Q. Do you recall any discussions at ary time with Mr.

Collings, with reference to Mr. Collings’ meetings with Mr:

Hughes, relative to the type of equipment which TWA man- -

agement was interested in? — roe

A I.don't recall any conversations regarding Mr.

Collitigs’ conversations with Mr. Hughes.

Q Or with Mr. Damon?.

A No Iwas aware that such conversations were going

on. They must have been mentioned, but I don’t recall

any instances that:I could quote as to ‘the conversations,

except I was aware that Mr. Hughes favored the Douglas

aircraft. —

or

Cocke Deposition.

Q And you were aware of that at the time TWA man-

agement decided to take sacthed, Constellations?

-A I was.

¢

[Testimony—December 4, 1982]

£16244] Q .At Kansas City, on Friday, September 14th,

you have a note ‘‘Meeting, re: syeipenent.”” What was

_ that about? :

A 1 don’t recall.

Q Do you recall a meeting in ‘Kansas City at or about

that time relating to the 880 Convair program?

[16245] A There was a meeting in Kansas City with Mr.

Collings and a group, at which, as I recall, the discussion

_ was as to the desirability of the Convair purchase based on

various prices for the airplane. ‘That may have been at this

time. I don’t recall. That was prior to the management

recommendation: that we purchase the Convairs: °

Q Mr. Rummel testified with respect to.a meeting at

Kansas City at this time. I would like to have whatever

recollection or knowledge of information you have'as to -

what took place at that time.

A My only recollection is that it was a diesen on

the question of the Convair 880, and I believe the part that

depreciation would play in the operating cost of the air-.

plane as gné of the factors in comparing the 880 with ad-

ditional Boeings. :

I believe there’were several prices discussed. _

There was a question of descalation in the price depend-

ing on the number of aircraft that Convair sold. After

the discussion I believe the group unanimously recom-

monpee the Convairs.

Mr. Davis: May I have marked at this time as

Exhibit 316 a confidential. memorandum from Mr.

7

A-503

Cocke Deposition.

Rummel to Mr. Collings, dated September 17, 1956,

with copies to a number of named individuals,

[16246] including Mr..Cocke and Mr. Leslie.

(Confidential memorandum from Mr. Rummel to

Mr, Collings, dated September 17, 1956, marked De-

fendants’ Exhibit 316 for identification, as e- this

- date.) .

By Mr. Davis:

Will you let me know after you have read Exhibit -316?-

A’ I have. ;

Q Exhibit 316 indicates that a copy of this confidential

communication from Mr. Rummel to Mr. Collings.was re-

_eeived by you, Mr. Cocke. Do you have a recollection of

having received a copy of this?

A Iam sure I received a eopy. I don't remember spe:

cifically receiving it.

Q You see Mr. Rummel refers to a telephone conversa-

tion with Mr. Collings of September 14th, to which he has

already testified, and itt which Mr. Collings gave him the

- statement as to” TWA’s management position on the Con-

vair 880 then known as the Golden’ Arrow project, which

Mr. Rummel in turn gave to Mr. Hughes, as he puts it.

‘*verbatim.’’

It is quoted there in this memorandum.

My first question to you is whether or not those items

1 to 4 which are listed there in fact reflect what was TWA’s.

management position at the time?

[16247] A They do.

Q Then look at the last paragraph which states ‘‘At-

‘tached is a list of the pros and cons which were arrived

at during your Friday afternoon meeting attended by

Messrs. Cocke, Busch, | Fellows, Fullerton, Rourke, Weller

and myself in- discussing the matter with Mr. Hughes I

pointed out while Pan American was showing considerable

interest in 30 Golden Arrows, there could be no positive

assurance at this time that they would buy. .

~

A-504

4 Cocke Deposition.

‘There is attached a list of pros and cons.

A Yes.

Q Do you have a recollection of that mesting taking

place?

A Yes.

Q At that meeting there were pros and cons discussed?

“A Yes, sir.

~Q > Will you look at the pros and cons that are attached

to this exhibit, and tell me whether or not so far as you are

. concerned they fairly and accurately reflect the pros and

cons that were discussed or advanced ‘at this meeting?

_ A I believe they do.

Q > Do you have any further” jeinieitien or knowledge

lor information of the number of jet aircraft to be acquired

[16248] by TWA, or what was going on at TWA in con-

nection with its jet equipment:program!? -

| A I don’t believe so.

[16261] Q Will you continue with your ‘diary? Where

are you up to now? ‘

A January 17th.

’ Q Is there anything there of any significance

_ A It indicates I had discussions with Hal Graham of

Resort Airlines, regarding aircraft. That was probably

the first discussion I had with Hal Graham on the possibil-

ity of leasing 1049Hs from Resort Airlines. ©

~ Q WR! you identify what that subject was?

- A It was about‘this time the economy service, a lower

class service than the’existing tourist service in the inter-

national field was either approved or being considered.

[16262] It was a question of trying to obtain aircraft that

were suited for that type of serv ice that was being consid-

ered.

Q I am interested in your contact with* Mr. Graham

of Resort Airlines, and how it came about, and what you

».

-

A-505

Cocke Deposition.

discussed. Is this a prelude to what eventuated into the

acquisition of these 1049Hs? __ =

A The lease of the 1049Hs.

Q That is what am interested in. How aid that origi-

nate, how did it come about t

A -I am not Sure whether I approached Hal Graham or

Hal approached me.- He was aware of the pending possibil-

ity of the economy service. I was aware of the possible .

need by TWA of aircraft to perform such service.

Q Then what happened?

A Eventually the Hughes Tool Cothpany leased, -I be-

lieve two aircraft from Resort. I may be mistaken in the |

number. - I think there were five aircraft that were -

eventually leased. I think two came from Resort, and

three came from’Transcontinental.

[16263] Q I am interested more-in the enenaiiniie

relating to the development of this thought or idea—the

’ availability of “those aircraft*from Resort, and related

-matters. I understand from your testimony you are not.

quite clear whether you approached Mr. Graham or Mr.

Graham approached you.

I gather that you had some dheceneion with him on or

about January 17, 1957.

I would like to understand what transpired in these con-

versations you had with Resort Airlines.

A Just a preliminary discussion if they possibly had

aircraft for lease, and would-we be interested.

Q Did you. report back to someone at TWA?

A TIamsure I must have discussed it w rith Mr. Burgess.

[16788].

[Testimony—December 6, 1962]

o >. .

Q Do you recall the matter referred to in Exhibit 320

being called to your attention or the management of TWA?

A-506

Cocke Deposition.

A. [don’t recall this memorandum. .There were dis-

. cussions that I was familiar with in connection with the -

1049Hs, with Lockheed, and I think I testified about Resott.

Q Mr. Weller is sending this confidential memorandum

to Mr. Burgess and you and others, on March 27th, and

referring to information. that he obtained frof® Mr.

Schwartz and Nelson of Lockheed at or about that date,

and which outlines certain terms ‘on which TWA could

‘obtain some 1049Hs. ‘It relates to possible methods of

financing. It rélates to the guarantee of the Hughes Tool

Company to be obtained, and it ends up with a statement

from Mr. Weller, or by Mr. [16789] Weller to the effect 4

that negotiations of these terms’ would be a matter -for

Mr. Leslie, TWA counsel, and. perhaps Hughes Tool Com-

pany, and that he was expressing no opinion as to TWA’s

possible interest in this sort of a proposal. —

_ What Tam. trying to find out, Mr. Cocke, is what took

place when Mr. Weller called the attention of top manage-

ment of TWA to the infornfation he had received or ob-.

tained from Lockheed.

A I don’t recall.

Q 1am not-asking you to remember this memorandum

particularly, but having read this memorandum, and with

yeur diary before you, I am trying to a what was

taking place.

A I think I have testified before, Mr. _Davis, that at

about. this tipie it appeared that the economy service was

‘going to be approved on the Atlantic most any time. I be-

lieve the economy service finally started in the spring of

1958, so that all during the vear of 1957 we were consider-

ing what equipment action would be called for in case the

economy service was approved by the International Trans-

port Association Rate Conference. -

Q What I am interested in primarily now is what com-

~munieations of any kind took place between anyone at

A807

Cocke Deposition.

TWA, and either Mr. Hughes or the Hughes Tool Com-

pany, or with [16790] the Equitable or the banks, relative

to financing, and what the management of TWA did in the

light of what you have described?

A There were many, many discussions and meetings

considering this problem.

Q Discussions and meetings among whom!

A Among TW:A’s management. Some place along in

a period beyond this I had a number of discussions with

Mr. Hughes, numbers of discussions with Hal Graham,

representatives of Transcontinental, Leonard Schwarts,

Lockheed, on this question of what should TWA’s action be

to obtain or convert existing equipment to configurations

that would comply with the conditions on the economy

service, which was to be a new type of service.

Q That.is exactly what I want you to identify and

describe as fully as you can, giving us not only your total

recollection, but also whatever Knowledge or information

you may have acquired up to today on this subject.

First may I ask you to describe the subject matter of

what you said and what he said in corse discussions with

Mr. Hughes.

A T don’t think"l can add any more to what | have

said. .The aircraft to meet the conditions of what it ap-

peared the economy conditiohs would finally, wind up to

[16791] be had certain requirements. I don’t recall con-

versations at the meetings, except to say to you generally

just what I have said. We were trying to determine the .

best course of action for TWA to take to be able to par-

ticipate in economy service on the Atlantic when and if it

was approved by the Rate Conference.

Q Tam trying to understand what it is that you were

trying to decide. ‘What, alternative action Was considered

eand how did you arrive at the decision to do whatever you

did? Can you describe that?

A-508

- Cocke Deposition. )

A The original concept of the economy service was an

extremely austere type of service. There would be no food

_ served. There would be extremely high density seating.

There would be no lounges. There would be no gallies [sic]

on the airplanes. - .

We had the pr oblem of dutoritialaae whether or not to

in effect strip some 1649s of their. present configuration,

the interior, and equip them with the economy seats, or we

had the option of. looking for 1049H aircraft that were in

existence, and that had been equipped with an interior con-

figuration that met pretty close what. it looked like the

economy service was going to wind up with.

These aircraft were aircraft that were convertible ‘be-

tween cargo. and: passengers. They had light seats on the

[16792] question of weight, and were being used in a non-

schedwe charter operations or for military contracts.

*.Q And that is the nature of the discussions that. you

were having with Mr. Hughes?

A Yes. I was indicating to Mr. Hughes the fact that

it was necessary for TWA to have some type of an air-~

plane with which to enter. into the economy service.

Whether that was at, this time or later, anes notes in

my diary might indicate aa

£16801] Q Now, Mr. Cocke, have you‘had an opportunity

to. review what has been marked as Exhibit 321, 322 and

5 aie ,

A Ihave.

-Q With respect to Exhibit 321, will you give. me ‘hat.

ever recollection, knowledge or information you have with

respect to the circumstances relating to its preparation,

and the recommendations which are reflected therein. .

A’ I} think this document reflects the problems that were

Ba

t

i

:

as

ge

od beads ah

A-509

Cocke Deposition. _

facing TWA, that I stated in my-deposition prior to the

recess. = ‘ J :

’

_ Q. Am I correct then that you have no knowledge or °

‘information of any kind with respect to the matters cov-

ered by Exhibit 321, other than what’ appears in Exhibit

3219

_ £16802] A . And what I have testified to previously. —

‘Q Does that refresh your recollection in any way with

_-réspect to the nature or scope af communications you may

have had with Mr. Hughes?

A Ibelieve it does. _

“Mr. Williams: Off the record.

‘ (Discussion off the record.)

By Mr. Davis:

Q This memorandum. indicates a recommendation that

TWA acquired by purchase or lease ten Lockheed 1049-Hs

for use in this ‘‘austerity’’ service.

"A And other uses which are outlined in the memo-

randum. ss, zr x fe eee

-Q = Can you give me the nature of what was said at con-

ferences or meetings of TWA management, views expressed .

‘by Mr. Burgess, Mr. Pierson, Mr. Rummel, or Mr. Leslie, -

or Mr. Hughes, if you have any recollection of any conver-_

‘ sation or communication with Mr. Hughes with respect to

this. |

- A I certainly concurred with this recommendation.

-Q Tunderstand that.. Do you have any recollection or

knowledge or information, however, with respect to the

others? — i

A I don’t. recall whether everyone concurred in it or

not. I believe they did. |

Q Can you explain the reason why it was recommended

[16803] that either there be purchased or lease’? C'an you

A-510

¥

Cocke Deposition.

explain why the consideration to a lease rather than a pur- —

chase? Can you identify the reasons why it was approached

’ from that point of view? ‘

_. A My recollection is that the reason the lease was’ con-

sidered was that—at least I felt if the airplanes could be

leased ‘on a relatively short term basis, under changing

conditions in the industry, and in the rate levels, if we got

a good lease it probably would be better to lease than to

commit for the airplanes.

Q Was that by reason of the uncertainty of the success

of this austerity service that was contemplated? |

A The whole picture. Nothing was certain. I felt

that the austerity ¢eonomy service would be a success as

it was contemplated.

Q At that point, as I unde: ‘stand it you had had dis-

cussions with.Resort Airlines; is that right, relating to the

availability of planes? =~

' A Yes, about this time.

Q Can, you identify or describe the 1iature of those

conversations? In other words, what was Resort offer-

ing—to lease, or sell, or either, or both?

A 1 don't recall whether they were interested in selling

. airplanes or not. My discussions were purely on a [16804]

relativel¥ short term lease basis.

Q Look at the top of page 2. It says **Before’ such

a lease could be consymmated approval would be required

boih from our board of directors and from the Equitable

Life assurance Society.’

Do you know whether or not an effort was made to

obtain a consent from the Equitable?

A 1 don’t reeall.

e

Q The next sentence | to our discussion or

Saturday, active negotiations with Lockheed and with pos-

sible lessors will be commenced immediately.’

Do vou know what that referred to?

* A511

Cocke Deposition.

A Probably it refers to the discussions with Resort

and Transcontinental. I might for purposes of clarification

at this time state that the lease was not with Transconti-.

nental, but with Cal-Eastern Corporation, who controlled

an airljne called Transcontinental. I notice that from notes

in my diary.

Q A proposal which is attached to Exhibit 321, page

v7, refers to a study as to the possibility of remodeling

preseutly owned aircraft in order to make such aircraft

suitable for this austerity service. You recall that, con-

sideration was given to that possibility?

A I think I so stated’ in my previous testimony,

- [16805] that we had the alternate choice.

() Am I correct in understanding that management .of

TWA concluded that such remodeling for one reason or

another would not be desirable or economic?

A That's correct.

@ Can you tell us whether or not that was basically |

"for ihe reasons set forth in Exhibit 321?

A Yes. =

- Q You see‘there is a heading entitled ‘* Acquisition

_ of Other. Aircraft,’? and states that consideration had

heen giver to the acquisition by purchase or lease of other

trpes of aircraft.

The two which appear most attractive eco. in.ically

for the service are the Bristol Brittania and the Lockheed

Super Constellation, Model 1049-H.

Then it goes ou to discuss the two aivcraft and other

matters. . ;

Will you give me your total recollection of whater ver |

knowledge or’ information you have with respect to the

consideration given to other possibilities for ac juiring

aireraft suitable for the service mentioned?

A Only that we had reviewed all possibilities to arriv:

at the best recommendation for TWA.

-

A-512

Cocke Deposition.

Q With particular reference to the Brittania, ca can you

[16806] tell us any more than you have as to the reasons.

A 1 wouldn’t recall the Teasons, except as pane

out-in this memorandum.

Q You see the portion of this Exhibit 321 ender the

heading ‘‘Conclusions’’—can you tell me whether or not in

fact those were the conclusions rea¢hed by TWA operating

management -personnel?

A I believe they do, yes.

Q While we are on that subject, . will you look ‘at

Exhibit 322. Refer first to Exhibit 167, Mr. Cocke, which

are the minutes of an Executive Committee meeting of

April 17, 1958. Do you have that before you?

A I have.

Q It notes that present by, invitation were yourself

* as senior vice-president-sales, Mr. Leslie, Mr. Duckworth

and Mr. Spater, counsel.

Do you recall attending that. aemned Executive Com-

mittee meeting?

A I don’t recall it, no.

Q Can you tell me why you were invited to attend this _

meeting of the Execdtive Committee? “4 we

A Only because being vice-president-sales, 1 was one

of the senior executives who was pressing for a solution

to our equipment problems in connection with the austerity

£16807] service.

Q Have you read these minutes?

A Yes, I have.

Q Do they correctly reflect the facts so far as vou are

‘concerned ?

A. 1 bi lieve they do, yes. .

Q. Will vou look at what has been marked as Exhibit

322. Have you read what is set forth there?

A I haven’t read ‘it word for word: I have looked ©

it over, _ :

A-513

Cocke Deposition.

Q Based upon whatever participation you had in con-

nection with this 1049-H program, do you have.any knowl-

edge or information contrary to what is described there?

A No, 1 do not.

Q Now you have been oriented as to what in fact took

place. Does that refresh your recollection in any way with ©

‘respect to the nature or scope of any communications that

- you had with Mr. Hughes, or any other representative of

_ the Hughes Tool Company relative to this?

A Nothing beyond what I hive previously testified to..

Q Now let us continue with your diary, having in-

mind what did in fact take place. See if there is any entry

or notation which you made in there which refreshes

[16808] your recollection in any way whatever. This meet-

ing on June Sth with Mr. Austin, Capitol Airlines, was that

a purely social occasion, or did it involve anything else?

“A It may or may not have. At about this time Mr.

Austin and I had some discussions in connection with the

possibility of us acquiring Viscounts, and the scheduling

of the Viscounts of Capitol and TWA in the New York-

Chicago market, so that between the two companies we ~

could have a fairly rounded pattern of service. But as we’

did not acquire the Viscounts, nothing came of it.

Q I see a note that Mr. Burgess was taken ill on-

Thursday, June 6th. Was that a prolonged iliness?

‘A He was away for about a week, I believe.

Q On June 14th you referred to a -board meeting,

personnel change. What does that refer to?

-A I don’t recall. what the personnel change was.

Q On June 20th you referred to 1649 prop trouble. |

I have a recollection of Mr: Rummel having testified that

Mr. Hughes had some concern with respect to the propeller

pitch. Can you identify what this entry refers to?

A My recollection is the 1649s were originally equipped

with -a hollow propeller, that is, a propeller made ‘in two

pieces.

' A-514

Cocke Deposition.

I believe about this time in Paris there was a [16809]

mechanical failure on the part of one of the. blades. We

then changed to's different type of propeller blade. on the

1649s.

Q What is this entry on June 25th “Meeting, 1049-G,

Burgess, et cetera.’’ What does that refer to?

A I don’t recall.

Q This entry on July 2nd refers to a meeting re:

Coverdale & Culpitts’ report, and 1049-H, ena sales air

craft.

What does that refer to?

_ AI believe the Coverdale & Culpitts report was an

industrial -engineering study they were making in connec- —

- tion with the salary structure of the company.

‘Lhe 1049-H and sale of aircraft was just more. discus-

sion in connection with the 1049-Hs.

Q In 1957, you may recall there was some additional

financing action by TWA, involving the issuance of addi-

tional shares of stock; and bank loans. -

Do you have any recollection of any kind with respect

to financing arrangements of TWA which took place in

1957? ‘ fae

A No, I do not.

Q Do you have any knowledge or. ‘information with

respect to the circumstances relating to the issuance of

additional shares of common stock of TWA by its pro-

“spectus [16810] of June -17, 1957?

A No, I do not.

~Q .What does sales of aircraft refer to, in that entry

of July 2nd?

A’ I don't.reca:] what that refers to.

Q Will you continue with your diary then. Do you

see the entry on June 3rd. two phone calls— Oe

A’ July 3rd. ie

Q Ilal Graham-Resort, Spater, schedule meeting.

A-515

Cocke Deposition.

A I don’t recall the phone calls. The entry would

indicate that we were discussing the 1049-H, and I was

talking to Hal Graham of Resort. I think I testified pre-

viously that Mr. Graham was also dealing with the Hughes

office on the West Coast.

Q Did this austerity service in fact go into effect?

A It Tid, but not in the exact manner in which we had

hoped it would.

Q Was it subject to CAB authorization “or. approval

before it could be put into effect?

A First it had to be approved by the International

Transport Association Rate Conference, and then subject

to the approval of all the govérnments involved.

Q Will you tell us what took place relative to this so-

called austerity service.

[16811] A The original concept of the austerity service

was, as I believe I have stated before, no gallies [sic] no

meals, high density seating.

I believe it was in thé spring of 1958 when. final agree:

ment was reached.. We tried to reach agreement in the

fall of 1957, but were unable to do so. |

One of the stumbling blocks was the desire of Pan

American and TWA that the austerity service be limited

té an all one class austere airplane.

The foreign flight carriers, because of lack of equip-

ment, were holding out.

Q Who was holding out?

A The foreign flag carriers "generally were holding

out for a provision which would enable them to offer this

type of service on a mixed class airplane.

: We were opposed to that, because hesnniibendie you

offered, it on the mixed class airplane, you would not gait

- the economies that you could. on an all economy aircraft,

because you have got the galley on a mixed class airplane

to serve the first class or tourist passengers.

A-516

Cocke Deposition. .

_My recollection is, that finally to obtain an agreement,

which must be unanimous agreement of all carriers, we

accepted a compromise of the ‘offering of this service on a

mixed class: airplane, that is, part economy [16812] ser-

vice, part tourist service, part first class service.

. The competitive aspects of economy service on a mixed

class. airplane was more desirable than one airplane that

had 100 some odd economy passengers.

It alsu opened the door, ag time went on, for the erosion

of the austerity .provisions, because as long as you had a

galley on the airplane, and the galley was large enough to

take care of-furnishing food for economy passengers, over

a few years we drifted into an upgrading of economy to

where it was just as good as the tourist service was. :

Q Do you recall the circumstances relating to CAB

action on this program?.

A ~They approved it as it was agreed to.

. Q Will you return to your diary?

A You will note on July 9th I was in Kansas City and

inspected the 1049H aircraf@ —

_ I believe that was the @rst airplane that we leased

' from Resort. There is a reference on July 29th.to a flight

that was made by TWA executives in b Brittania i in Mon-

treal.

' (16817) Mr. Davis: May I have marked for identi-

fication at this point as Exhibit 323 the minutes of

the Board of Directors of TWA which was held on

December 5, 1957.

(Minutes of Board of Directors of TWA held on

December 5, 1957, marked Defendants Exhibit 323

fur identification as of this date)

oo

eT eee en

By Mr. Davis:

~ A-D1T

Cocke Deposition. 2

Q. Will you look over the minutes of that meeting, Mr.

[16818] Cocke, with particular reference to what appears

under the heading ‘‘Report of Mr. John A. Collings,’’ and

- what appears under the heading of ‘‘Ratification of’ pur-

chase of one 1649A aircraft and spare perts,” and ** Equip-

| ment Prog?am.”?

Have you finished reviewing the minutes of that meet-

ing?

A I have.

Q That indicates you were present at that meeting?

SS eae

Q- Do those minutes fairly and accurately reflect what

‘took place at that time so far as you are concerned!

A I believe go.

Q. First look at what appears under the heading “Re

port of Mr. Collings.””

- My first question is, did Mr. Collings stay on the Board

of TWA after he resigned as an officer? Is that what hap. -

- pened, or did he come back to TWA?

A He remained on the Board after he resigned as an

officer and was employed as a consultant.

Q-Can you identify or describe what is referred to

under the heading ‘‘Report of Mr. John A. Collings’’, re-

ferring to the sale of eleven 202A Martin aircraft? What .—

happened with respect to those aircraft!

Mr. Zeller: . Are you asking him what was said

[16819] at the meeting?

Mr. Davis: No, I am asking him for all knowl-

edge or information which he has relative to efforts

to dispose of the 202 aircraft. an. what took place. ~

as well as what happened at the meeting,

A. Mr. Collings was engaged in the sale of aircraft that

TWA felt were no longer needed.

?

. A518

Cocke ‘Deposition.

I don t recall who these negotiations were with, or any-

thing about it, except that I know Mr.-Collings was active

in attempting to sell aircraft that were excess to TWA at

the time.

“Q > Do you know what i in fact took place, who they were

sold to, if they were sold at all?

A They have all been sold—sold and leased. I don’t

recall who all the purchasers were. Alleghany Airline

bought some.

Q Who was ix charge of that project of the disposal of

these planes?

A It was one of the functions that Mr. Collings carried

out.

- Q And that is all the ne f or information you

have on that subject?

A Yes.

Q Do you know whether or r not there’ were any comgnuni-

[16820] cations of any kind with Mr. Hughes or cago

representative of thé Hughes Toul Company in connection

with the disposition of the airplanes?

A I don’t know of any.

Q Now will you look at the minutes which appear

under the heading, or relating to’ the acquisition of addi-

.tional 1649A aircraft?

Will you give me all the knowledge and information you

have with respect to that matter?

: A LAT, an Italian airline which was assisted in its

organization and commencement of service following the

war, by TWA, had ordered four 1649As.

At about this time they were being consolidated with

- Alitalia, another Italian airline, so that there would de one’

international Italian airline.

Alitalia had gone the Douglas route, and they were

anxious to or were prepared to Telease their commitment

for the four 1649As.

CO eee eee

A-519

- Cocke Deposition.

TWA took over, I believe from Lockheed, the commit-

ment of LAI for these four aircraft. — .

Q Was that something that had been the subject of

action by the Executive Committee of the Board of TWA?

A lem sure it had been discussed, because’ we recom-

mended the avquisition of the aircraft.

[16821] Q ‘What knowledge or information do you wn

relating to that portion of the minutes which state :”

‘Subject to consummation of financing arrange-

ments ‘satisfactory to a committee of Messrs. .

soem, Leslie and Sessel ...”’

A Only what it says?

Q Do you have any knowledge or ieenitiin as to

what financing arrangements were made or discussed or

developed in that connection ?

A I don’t recall howsthey were finally financed.

Q Do you have any knowledge or information of any

communication of any Rind with Mr. Hughes or any other

representative of the Hughes Tool\ Company with respect

, to either the acquisition of those aircraft or the financing

of those aircraft?

A At one time I had a discussion. with Mr. Hughes,

1 believe it was when we renewed the lease on the Hs, and

I believe it was prior to the finalization of the four LAI

airplanes—whether or not these aircraft could be used

- as alternates for the Hs.

I didn’t feel they could and so expressed myself to

Mr. Hughes.

Q Do you have any recollection of what he said. at

that time?.

[16822] A After discussion he agreed that they weren't

interchangeable airplanes with the Hs or the 1649s, and we

had to know which we would get.

ee oc * 4-520

Cocke Deposition,

Q As that the sum total of your knowledge and infor-

mation on that subject? = :

A That is all I cam recall, yes. ~ ane Se

* > ) ae

_ [16873] Q You see, Mr. Cocke, that Mr. Rourke following ©

what is reflected by Exhibit 179-AA, relating to the meeting

of the jet planning staff of July 30th, refers to a study made

as to the alternative courses “of action, available to TWA

‘*To counter American Airline’s Convair 880 8ompetition,’’? —

_~ and he sets forth for alternatj##es, the first, one being to

order a limited numbegi Copvair 600s. 6008; later [16874]

vecame known as the 990s.

A believe that is true,°yes. *

Q Thé first alternative suggestion is to onder a limited

number of Convair 600s in. addition to the thirty 880s, to.

provide cdmpetition in those markets which are sensitive ©

to speed and where TWA meets American Airlines.

The second alternative: he refers to is to ‘‘Increase the

Ta, speed potential of the Boeing 120 or 130 to provide equal

or superior speed to the Convair 600.”’

' The third alternative he suggests is.-to coleen the order

for Convair 880s and substitute-a number of Convair 600s,

maintaining a total of 30 Convair aircraft,

The fowith alternative he suggests is to -increase the

_ speed of the Convair 880, by installing anti-shock bodies

and make other. structural modifigations. .

' Then. he proceeds’ to -describe the technical aspects of

. accomplishing alternatives 2.and 4.

You see at the bottom of page 1 he states if alternative

1, that is, the one of adding 990s to the thirty 880s, he says -

‘If alternative 1 cannofbe financed then the possibility of

. alternative No. 3 should be gees, ”

. *. A521.

“— Cocke Deposition.

# - , ‘ a es

‘‘It-is estimated that a minimum of 10 to 15 Convair

600s would be needed to Gompete ‘with American 10 those

, £16875] markets where TWA and American competc. This

* would involve changing the last 15 Convair 880s to 15 Con-

vair 600s, and would cause a delay i in delivery. Delivery

of the-600s is controlled by engine deliveries. It is probable.

we could not receive the aati 600 until May to Sepiem-

ber: of 1961.’”

Then you see at the elton of page 2 he. says “It is

proposed that Convair construct ‘the last 10 to 15 Convair

880s to the 600 configuration except for engines, " or

What I am interested in; Mr. Cocke, is your total vat

lection of what was taking place at that time at these Jet

A

_ Pianning Committee meetings attended by Mr. Teeetae and

‘others. ..

A The review of all of this material, and the possibili

ties of what actiofi TWA should take.

[16876] Q I understand that, but I would like to. know »

what discussion took place relative to these suggestions,

recommendations, alternatives that were sae: eee

by Mr. Rourke?

A I don’t recall the discussions. |

Q Do you recall what views Mr. Thomas expressed. as

to the desirability of cutting back on the 880 program so

as to take advantage of what appeared at the i at least, |

as a possibility of improved aircraft? — ~ re

A At some later period I recall that he felt that we:

should cut back the Convair order from thirty to twenty.

Q Now I am interestedyin what was being said with -

respect to the desirability of ordering, or having the’

Hughes Tool Company order some 990s?

A I don’t recall any-discussions on that. Mr. Thomas _

at a later date, I believe, discussed the cutback of the 880s “i

. from thirty to twenty. Tia not agree with him...”

After discussions with him he pointed.eut ‘that by re-

ducing the order from thirty to twenty, that our financing »

"problems would be eased, that it would leave room for

A522,

later Quenting for more: advanced models of the aircraft

that were being: considered. .

[16877] I think I finally agreed that in view of those factors

maybe we should cut back from thirty to twenty. .

Q It is a fact, is it not, that there came a point when,

the. Hughes Tool Company did place an order with Con-

vair for some thirteen 990s? .°

A Yes, I am aware of that.

Q Do you recall’ the discussion which took place at

these meetings of the Jet Planning Committee with re-

_ spect to the suggestion made by Mr. Rourke, that in order -

- to maintam TWA in a competitive position with American,

it might be desirable to plan for ten to fifteen 990s"i in lieu

of a similar number of 880s ?.

A I don’t recall the discussions, Certainly these

alternatives were’ discussed with the Jet Planning Com-

mittee. + ‘

_ Thave no recollection of-what went on in the discussions

beyond what I have testified to and I don’t know what

these minutes reflect.

Q Mr. Tillinghast testified at some ected that he or

. someone at TWA inquired into the circumstances relating

to the order placed by the Hughes Tool Company for 9908,

which took place some time in 1961. ;

Do you recall in that connection the suggestion being we

made by Mr. McCone as a director? Do you recall that ie

- taking place?

~ [16878] A. i recall a telegram that was. sent by Mr.

McCone which I believe in effect said that we ought to

review the backgrund of this. I just recall the telegram.

Q. In connection with this review of the background

of the circum ances relating to the orders placed for the

990s, can you tell us what consideration, if any, was given © |

to what-Has now been marked as Exhibit 327? |

A Idon’t know. a as |

|

|

A-523

Cocke Deposition.

-Q Is there anything else that you can tell us? Do you

have any other knowledge or information relative to this

_ matter of the number of 880s or 990s | that were to be

- ordered for TWA?

A I don’t believe beyond what I have testified.’

Q Can ‘you tell us any more than you already have

with respect to what in faet was done to further develop

these studies as to the alternatives identified, by Mr.

Rourke in this confidential memorandum to Mr. Rummel—

_ Exhibit 327?

A There were discussions as to whether we ought to

consider re-equipping some of the 131s with fan engines.

€> I recall that. I recall it was decided not to do that>

-¢ . Q Do you recall why?

. A T'was opposed to it because I felt it would take air-

planes out of service that we needed to use for a long

_ modification program, and we just-couldn’t afford to take *

[16879] that many airplanes. dut of service.

Q Do you have any other recollection relating to these

_ various’ alternatives that Mr. Rourke recommended for

consideration ?

A I think there was some work done on trying to

increase the speeds on the 131s. I don’t remember what

- technically was done, if anything. | .

Q Do you have any knowledge or information as to

— communication with Mr. Hughes or any representative of |

Sa the Hughes Tool Company relative to the subject matter

“covered by Exhibit 327?

A I don’t know of any.

[Testimony—December 7, 1962] .

[16925] Mr. Davis: May I at this point have marked

for identification as Exhibit 329 the minutes of the

board of directors held on June 26, 1959?

s

uw

A-524

Cocke Deposition. .

(Minutes of the board of divechere [16926] held”

. on June 26, 1959, marked Defendants’ Exhibit 329

for identification, as of this date.) ©

Mr. Davis: At this point, Mr. Special Master, I.

would like to point ovt that a page 6 of those minutes

is missing, probably through an inadvertence. May I

request TWA to furnish me with the missing page?

The Special Master: You may.

™Mr.’Williams: We will be glad to.

.

By Mr. Davis: Saf -

Q These minutes reflect you were present at that meet-

ing. ,

A Yes.

Q I world like you to re over those minutes and tell ‘as

me whether or not they fairly. and accurately teflect what

took place at that meeting so far as you are concerned.

A Yes.

Q I see under the report of the senior vice-president-

system general manager, that is you, that you presented a

report on, current operating performance and described in

detail the operating problems encountered with the Boeing

707 jet aircraft. »

What does that refer to?

A I don’t recall.

Q You can’t identify the nature of those problems?

[16927] A Only normal problems in connection with any

new airplane, so far as I recall.

Q I see Mr. Thomas made a report with respect to +

the operations of the corporation, compared it withthe loss

of over $12 million at the same date in 1958, and then he

referred to the fact that the international division was

currently operating at a substantial -_

_ basis?

A-525

Cocke Deposition.

_ Can you amplify. what appears in these minutes with

respect to what was taking place at that time with respect

to the operations of the international division? _

A I-don’t recall whether Pan American had their

Boeings in operation internationally by this time or not.

Y believe they did, and that would: affect our traffic inter-

_ nationally. .

Q Anything else that you can recall? cneeaetaatieanati

A No.

[16928] Q Will, you look at the minutes which appear

under the heading ‘‘Authority to lease three additional |

Boeing Model 707-131 aircraft from Hughes Tool Com-

pany,’’ which refers to the authority to lease additional

131s so as to bring the total up to fifteen, which could be

leased from*the — Tool Company on a day-to-day

Do those minntes in any way refresh your recollection

as to the circumstances relating to this day-to-day manag

arrangement, and the reasons therefer?

A I don’t believe it does, no.

Q. Will you look at the minutes which appear under the

heading ‘‘ Authority to lease Boeing’ Model 707 aireraft to

Northeast Airlines, Inc.” =

Do those minutes fairly reflect the facts as they then

existed?

A I believe they do, yes.

Q Now look at the minutes which appear under the

heading ‘*Consent to sale of six Model Boeing 707 aircraft

by Hughes Tool Company.”’

Do you see where it says:

‘**The president referred to the eighteen Boeing

Model 707-331 aircraft on order’ by Hughes Tool |

Company under contracts assignable to the corpora-

tion?’”’? |

A-526

Cocke Deposition. —

[16929] A Yes. ;

Q The line which reads:

“The president stated that he had advised

Hughes Tool Company that.the corporation had no —~

objection to and consented to such assignment.’’

-A I see that. ai) ties See F

Q Does those minutes aenqeetely reflect what took.

place at that time? P

A Yes.

Q Can you tell me what had eeuntied, what had de-

veloped in connection: with these Boeing 331st *

A I recall Mr. Thomas saying that there was an op-

portunity ‘to ‘transfer six of the Boeing 331s which the

Hughes Tool Company had on order, to Pah American. I

was opposed to it. a — a

“Q You were opposed? - , | a4

A I was opposed to it at the ‘beginning of the discus- e

sions. I felt that TWA had a need for the airplanes. Mr.

Thomas felt for the reasons I think I stated before, he may :

need financing ability to get later models of aircraft, and = f

that the sale of these six would ease the financial problems

that we had at the time of financing the Boeings.

- . After a great deal of discussion I agreed that [16930]

in view of those factors perhaps the wise thing to do would

be to sell the six Boeings.

Q Do you have any other knowledge or information or .

recollection of the circumstances which led up to this

action by the Roard?

: A Only that this action idiond funds to take up ad-.

ditional Boeings for TWA.

Q Was TWA paying for these sirplonee as. tiey were

_ being delivered? .

e -

‘

A-527-

Cocke Deposition.

No. They were leasing airplanes.

And were not paying even the rental on them!

That’s right.

I don’t follow your testimony then.

-POPOpP>

Tool Company in my mind...

It was a question. gf the Tool Company picking up the

Boeings from the Boeing Aircraft Company for TWA.

Q Do you,recall what views were expressed by any

other senior or key executive of TWA?

‘A I think I was the last one to be sold.

Q You were the last one?

+e “eee ee

Q .Can you tell me any more than you have about

what was said by anyone? er

___ £16931} —} don’t recall anything more.

-Q Let me refer you to what has already been marked

as Defendants’ Exhibit 155, which are handwritten notes

of Mr. Thomas, and which read as follows:

‘«The commaiteninie of the HTC for jet aircraft

at this time was for thirty-three Boeings 707s, and -

thirty Convair 880s. I had stated several times that

I thought the airlines had overbought. on jets, and

reconimended that the HTC cut back on some of -

these orders if they could.’’

Do you recall, or do you have any recollection at all, or

do you have any knowledge or information of any kind

with respect to the views expressed by Mr. Thomas, and

recommendations made ..

Mr. Williams: ~ What sail does that particular |

sentence refer to? Is it identified in the exhibit?

I am not clear in my mind, and I don’t know if

Perhaps I don’t separate TWA and the Hughes ~

. A-528

Cocke Deposition. ,

the witness is either, as to what date Mr. Thomas was

referring to'in that sentence which you just read.

Mr. Davis: What date?

Mr. Williams: Yes. _ |

Mr. Davis: . The only thing we have is the fact

([16932} that these are notes in Mr. Thomas’ ape

writing.

‘Mr. Williams :. No date. is given.

The Special Master: Mr. Davis, the first page;

- the fourth paragraph, may be some indication where

he refers to the leasing activity.

Mr. Davis: You can réad the entire document:

Mr. Williams: I think it would be well, Mr.

Davis, because the sentence has been taken out of

context, and I don’t have the exhibit in front of me,

and if there is a date there, that would be.important.

» Mr. Davis: It may be impértant so far as this

memorandum is concerned, but so far as I am con-

cerned I want this witness’ total recollection of what-

ever knowledge or information he has as of any date.

Mr. Williams: So do we. We don’t disagree

with that. ° ." :

By Mr. Davis:

Q_ Let me refer te what I think is helpful, Mr. Cocke.

Look at the first page —-. you will see Mr.“ Thomas in his

notes says:

‘*In January. 1959 the first Boeing 7 707: trainer.

was ready for exceptions.”” _

The Special Master: I think he means ‘‘accept-

16933] ance.’’ = Fo ta

' Mr. Davis: I think he may also mean that was ~

the time when .the acquirer can take es to

whatever—it is a squawk opportunity.

S\

al

4-599"

ene : Cocke Deposition. aes. /

q- (Continning) - YY

‘Messrs. Rowe and Cook paren before the

CAB and requested their consent for;fhe Hughes

Tool Company to lease.this plane to TWA on a daily

basis, cancellable on 24 hours’ notice by either side.

The CAB was assured that in so doing a permanent

financing plan was being worked upon and would be

completed by June 30, 19 ” e CAB approved -

this lease. At approxims this time . .-.”? I°

would assume he is referrixig to approximately June

1959 ‘*, . » the First Boston Corporation had been

cmnieghd by the HTC . . .’’ or maybe in January

1959—I don’t know when the. First Boston was

employed. y

Do you know, Mr: Cocke? -

“A No, I do not.

2. (Continuing)

“Yon’ had been eeihieal ‘by the Tool earner

to work on such a permanent financing plan but after

- about two months refused to proceed further because

Mr. Hughes would not negotiate with them [16934]

_ personally. o ,

Do you have any knowledge or information with respect to

that? sa : . Ue

A No,I donot. . > a"

Q (Continuing). .

‘‘Shortly thereafter Dillon, Read was engaged by

the Tool Company, to aad a permanent Gneneing

| plan. ” ‘

Then we have what I was sitereing you to before:

A-530 -

Cocke Deposition.

‘The commitments of the Tool Company for jet |

aircraft at this time was for thirty-three Boeing

707s, and thirty Convair 880s.’’

Thos Mr. Thomas continues by saying: . '

‘*T had stated several times that I thoight the .

airlines had. overbought on jets,.and recommended

that the Tool Company cut biick on some of these

orders if they could.”

_~

w«

Now I am back to where I was before:~ What en

or information do you havet What recollection do you.

have of Mr. Thomas ¢ expressing views comparable to what

I have just read to you? ie

A. I recall. Mr. Thomas expressing this view as part

of the discussion in connection with. the sale of the six

Boeing Model 707 aireraft. That was one of the [16935] -

reasons he used in our discussions. :

Q Then he continues by saying:

**This would make it pesaile to'start jet opera-

tions with a good basic jet fleet,.and then after a

year or 80, operating record and appraisal of the

market, know what additional jet planes were needed

of the type that best suited to keep TWA in the fore-

front of the industry.”’ © :

What knowledge or information or recollection de you have

of Mr. Thomas expressing views comparable to what I have

just read to you?

A I think-that about expresses what I stated a “few

moments ago in my deposition.

Q Does that refresh you in any way with respect to

the anal you made to the Board on June —— with re- -

A531

Cocke Deposition.

spect te the operational problems you were encountering

’ with the-jets? .

A It does not.

Q Then you ace the next paragraph which reads:

‘*When Dillon, Read started to work on a perma-

nent financing plan, Mr. Hughes sent word that

twenty-five Boeing 707s, and twenty Convair 880s

would be made available to TWA, and the financing

should be predicated on that basis.’’

[16936] Do you have any recollection of being informed by

anyone the number of jets to be made available to TWA

would be twenty-five Boeing 707s, fifteen 131s, and ten 331s?

Do you recall Mr. Damon in hi§ miemorandum' of December

1956 referring to the need of ten large jet aircraft for the

international division?. You remember that, don’t you?

A No/ My recollection is that ten considered -the use

of some pistons in the international operations: I may be

mistaken. I don’t recall it. ,

Q I will get that exhibit for you again, Mr. Cocke,

but at the moment I am trying to find out from you what

knowledge or information you have of any kind with respect

to being informed that the number of aircraft to be. avail-

able to TWA were twenty-five Boeing 707s, and twenty

Convair 880s, and that TWA, or the financing was to be

pfedicated on that basis. .

A I think I have stated.before that there: were -dis-

cussions as to the numbers of Convairs—twenty-five,

twenty. It is true that. Mr. Thomas finally predicated his

- scheduling and preparation on the basis of the fifteen 131s. _ my

I am confused about the numbers. ——

“Q Let me refer you to Defendants’ Exhibit 309, Mr.

Cocke, which is the memorandum of December.6, 1955 ty

Mr. Damon to the Board of Directors.

[16937] If you turn to page 6, where Mr. Damon is saying:

=

A-532

Cocke Deposition.

““Whether by 1960 the International’ Airline

business will have developed to a point where for. ~

competitive or traffic reasons we must supply, long

_ range jet équipment beyond the gateway point I

mentioned above, I do-not know, but to provide

truly competitive service and keep our place in the

sun at the important gateway enumerated will re-

quire a minimum of ten additional _—s range jets.’’

A I see that,

Q ‘At a total expenditure which I would estimate at

$60 million.’"” Do you know to what extent Mr. Thomas

reviewed Mr. Damon’s plans and recommendations?

A’ I don’t know that he did. “*

. Q Certainly by 1958 the development of passenger

_ traffic volume had not grown to the extent anticipated i in

ie or 19567 That is a fact, is it not?

Mr. Williams: Anticipated by whom?

Mr. Davis: By TWA; as reflected by their fore-

cast. 2h a :

A I don"t recall whethes it had or not.

Q Do you see the next sentence in Mr. Thomas’ notes

which reads :

£16938] ‘‘This reduction followed TWA manage-

ment’s recommendation and was perfectly accept-

able.’’ :

What knowledge or information do you s have with respect

to TWA’s management’s recommendation for the reduc-

tion in number of jets to twenty-five Bocings and twenty

Convair 880s? -*

A That was management’s recommendation.

A533

Cocke Deposition.

+ .Q Gin shh OM on eee ee i occurred, and hoy it

developed? .

| A I can’t add anything more to what I have already

said. Mr. Thomas felt that we.shquid conserve whatever

financing’ was available for newer types of jets. .

I recall him stating that he thought the industry was

overbought. After discussion management agreed that .

this wis the numbers of aircraft that we should plan on at °

that time.

-Q Do you have any knowledge or information whatever

with respect to the plans proposed or developed by —

Read during 1959

- A No, I do not..

—— Have you given me the sum total of your knowl-

. edge or information of any -kind which you now have

relating to the number of jet aircraft that TWA'’s manage-

ment recommended as best suited to TWA *s needs?

— a: I have: ‘

° S.:;*@

[16987] Q Do you mind going not to December 10th? I

see a reference to a meeting of the Board, and then you

refer to a Lockheed project. What was that about?

A I don’t recall. Some time along in this period there _

_ were some discussions of Lockheed Electras. That may

have been it. I don't recall.

Q Can you tell me the nature of those mute

* A I recall. Mr. Gross and Mr. Thomas discussing the

question’ of TWA acquiring ° some Lockheed Electras.

TWA’s management was not in favor of the Lockheed Elec- |

tras.

Q Mr. Thomas took that up at some management meet-

ing, did he?

A I don’t. recall whether he aia or not. IT remembér

the matter was under consideration. i 4

|

i

. A534

Cocke Deposition,

You do recall Mr. Thomas discussing that with Mr.

Gross at some point? ,,

A Yes. .

[16988] Q But you can’t tell us what the nature or extent

of their conversations. or meetings was?

A Icannot.

=

Q Will you opurtinue with your oT. Where are you . |

* up to now?

A December 93rd. ,

Q How about December 16th? You have an entry of

various’ meetings, and then, “Meeting Northeast Airlines,

Stretch, Austin,’’ and what is the next name!

A Probably Lane.

Q. Burke, re: lease.

A Farther discussions on the Northeast lease.

Q On the 17th you met -with Mr. ae on the adver-

‘tising budget?

A Yes. r

Q Andon Saturday. the 19th, you met with the Austins

again. Was that purely social?

A Yes, as far as I reeall. .

Q During this period of time were j seeing thie

Austins fairly iromntiy on & social wt Ge

A Yes.

Q. In connection with these’ social meetings was there

any occasion that you can récall when ae matters

came up for discussion?

[16989] A I assume on at various times 1 we talked Di

ness, yes.

Q Can you recall the nature of ¢ any of those discussions

without trying to identify exactly when they took place? .

A Nothing beyond the Northeast lease, the Northeast

merger, interline traffic.

Q Do you recall discussing this Northeast merger dur-

ing this period—1958, 1959?

e «

A-535 _

Cocke Deposition.

A 1 may have. |

Q. Can you give me whatever. sieatiaailinn you do have

as to what was “being said either . you or Mr. Austin ~

relative to a Northeast :nerger? ;

A ‘We did discusss my opinion and his opinion of the

desirability of a Northeast-TWA merger. Whe er it was

prior to the agreement or after the agreement, I would .

recall we ‘probably Touched.on it prior to the agrecment. —

Q- Can you tell me how the subject came up, and the

substance of what was said?

A .I think I had always or for some years felt that a -

Northeast- TWA merger would be.a good thing, and perhaps.

would eventually come about.

Q What was the reason for that poMAt of view on your

part?

[16990] A I felt it would be an advantage to twA to have

a route to Florida. I was aware of the fact that the Atlas 4

Corporation .controlled Northeast. That Mr. Hughes.was

hn largest principal stockholder of Atlas. = made me

hink it might happen. aes

~ °Q When and how did you become aware of, or how

were you informed that Mr. Hughes was the largest single

_ stockholder of Atlas? ©

A I don’t recall how I was informed of it. I probably

read it.

Q You do not have any recollection of when or ap-

proximately when? -

A. No, Ido not.

Q Would my suggesting that it was in corinection

with an RKO merger help you in any way?

A I believe that is how Mr. Hughes acquired-his inter-

est in Atlas, yes.

Q But you have no present recollectiont of approxi-

mately when that information came to your attention?

A No,J do not.

A-536

Cocke Deposition.

Q Can you describe a little more clearly what was in

fact said between you and Mr. ‘Austin relative to that? |

A Ian recall nothing more than I stated.

Q Do you recall what Mr. Austin said, in substance?

[16991] A I think he agreed with me.

[17003] Q Wiil you continue with your diary then. Do .

you see this- reference on Monday, Margh 14th, finance

problems, and lunch with Thomas.

_ A Yes.

Q March 16th, board of directors meeting, finance

crisis.

A Yes. |

Q Lunch at the Waldorf, Irving Trust.

A Yes.

Q And Thursday, March 17th, the board of directors

- still in session, finanée crisis.

A Yes, I see those entries.

Q Can you tell me what was going on at that time?

A Trying to arrive at some agreement on financing.

Q Can you tell me any more. than that?

A Idon’t believe I can.

[17004] Q Can you tell me what you were ‘bine at the

Irving Trust or at the Waldorf?

A I think a luncheon was given for the directors in

the suite that the Irving Trust maintains at the Waldorf. <:

Q - Was that by Mr. Sessel?

A Yes. | |

Q Can you tell me the nature of the crisis referred to .

in your diary?

A Only that the board and Mr. Thomas were working

on the quesfion of a finance plan to move ahead with the

acquisition of the equipment that was on order.

-N

A-537 |

Cocke Deposition. .

I see on March 21st I have an entry that Mr. Hughes

agreed to thé Dillon, Read plan, and the board voted

unanimously in favor of it.

Q Is it fair to assume that you don’t have any rd

edge or information.with respect to the circumstances lead-

-ing up to this so-dalled Dillon, Read plan?

A I just know that the Dillon, Read plan was hitine

‘worked on, and was approved by the board.

Q Let me refer you to what has been previously site

* Defendants’ Exhibit 168, Mr. Cocke, which is a memo-

randum from Mr. Rummel! to Mr. Thomas, dated Febru-

ary 8, 1960, entitled ‘‘Convair 880 Integration Into TWA

Bervier: ”

[17005] I particularly want to call your attention to what

appears under, the heading ‘‘Why Has The Convair 880

Program Been Delayed?’’

A What page is that on? © ,

Q It is the fourth page. Do you see where Mr. Rum-

mel is saying to Mr. Thomas ‘‘The Convair 880 program

has been delayed primarily because‘cf :

Roc” Vendor parts shortages.

‘‘2. Correction developed and instated during

Convair flight test program.

‘3. Convair’s decision to minimize overtime un-

til certification is at hand.’’

Do you recall that sonar by Mr. Summell . to Mr.

Thomas at or ahout that time?

A I don’t recall.it.. I see I was given a copy of the

memorandum, so I was no doubt aware.of it.

[17006] Q At the time that you received a copy of this

memorandum from Mr. Rummel, what did you do, Mr.

—

A-538

* Cocke Deposition.

[17007] Mr. Hupper: As I understand the testi-

mony of the witness, he doesn’t recall receiving it,

so I object to the question on the ground that you

haven’t established that he did receive it.

The ‘Special Master: I will ‘overrule the objec-

tion. He said he must have received it.

-A I assume what I did was to take this new estimated 2

delivery information to rework into our schedule pattern.

[17008] By Mr. Davis:

Q Do you now have any knowledge or information of

any kind, Mr. Cocke, which indicates that Mr. Rummel was.

wrong in the three reasons he gave? ~ :

Mr. Williams: I object ‘to the form of the ques-

tion. * 7 .

The Special Master: Sustained.

By Mr. Davis:

Q Do you have any knowledge or information with

respect to the extent to which the Convair 880 program

was delayed by reason of vendor parts shortages? .

A No, I do not. . |

Q Were-you ever aware of the fact that Convair had

_ vendor parts shortages?

A I recall we did, yes.

Q Do you have any knowledge or information. with

' respect to the corrections which were developed and -

-instated during the Convair flight test program?

A I recall there were corrections. I am‘ not familiar

with what the delays involved were.

Q But you were told that there were ‘delays: in con-

_ nection with making: corrections in the Convair 880?

A-539

Cocke Deposition.

A Yes.

Q Were you. ever told that Convair made a decision.

[17009] to minimize overtime until certification is at hand?

A I don’t recall that.

-Q Yow don’t have any knowledge or information

about that whatever? ;

A I don’t recall that.

Q Do you recdfl-ever discussing “with Mr. Banmel

this memorandum, or the substance of what I have just -

referred you to—the reasons for the 880. airplane om

being delayed? .

A Not this memorandum. I certainly discussed with

Mr. Rummel during this ie the question of the sted

to the Convair 880...

: 2 a : s . e- ; . i

[17010] Q What is the significance of the entries which

appear under date of March 28th?

.. - 4 It appears that is a notation of a phone call that

' Mr. Thomas had from Mr. Cook,.that the decision would

be settled today as to whether we reduce to twenty 880s.

Q What dots that mean?.

A My recollection is there was a parind of time where

we were considering twenty or twenty-five, and it had

something to do with having to advise the people work-

ing on the fimancing plan whether they should include

‘twenty or twenty-five.

. [17011] Q So that in faet the definitive decision as to

whethér it was to be twenty or twenty-five was not arrived

at until approximately the end of March 19601

Mr. Hupper: I object to the form of the ques-.

tion as calling for a conclusion—definitive decision.

The Special Master: Sustained. ©

By Mr. Davis:

&

A-540

Cocke Deposition. .

Q Will you tell me when a decision was made as to

whether the number was to be twenty or twenty-five?. |

A Some time after this day. ~

Q° What is this reference to “HH to ign Equitable

letter tomorrow’*t

A Just that I was told that = someone and entered

it in my diary.~~

Q What is the.meaning of the entties which appear

on March 29th?

A Only an entry that I made that I was told that

Equitable agreed to the financing, and that the next step

was to take it before the banks. .

[17035]

_(Tetimony—December 17, 1962]

Q Now will you continue with your diary! Where are

‘you up to now?

A May 4th.

Q_ What is that entry “Preliminary decision on Florida

route’?

A AsI — it; when we received the award of the

Florida route—

Q When TWA did? -

". A When TWA received the award of the Miami-St.

Louis-Chicago route, we operated through airplanes from

Miami to St. Louis to the West Coast. National Airlines,

I believe, and perhaps Eastern“Airlines filed a complaint

with the Board that the decision’ did not allow us to

operate a through airplane, and the decision was made by

(17036] the Board that it was necessary for us to break

the flights at St. Louis, that is, operate Miami to St. Louis,

and change airplanes, and originate a separate flight from

. By

A

asa

¢ _

Cocke Deposition. ‘\

\

St. Louis to the West Coast because of the pendency of the

Southern Transcontinental Route Case,

-Q What is this preliminary decjsion on Florida? A

decision by the Board, or was it a decision by TWA?

Whose decision was it? .

‘A I believe it was a preliminary Aicialen by the

Board.

Q Relating to TWA’s St. Louis-Miami route, or did it —

‘relate to a preliminary decision in the Southern’ Trans-

continental Case?

* A My recollection is that maybe-preliminary isn’t the

proper term, but it was the decision by the Board to con-

tinue to operate the Florida-St. Louis route. We would

have to break the flight in St. Louis and not operate

through airplanes from Florida to the West Coast via St.

* Louis.

'Q At or about that time the CAB, the Examiner’ s

tabi or some decision by the CAB on that subject

came down on that date? .

A That is my recollection, yés.

Q Then I see the next date, Thursday, May ‘5th, you

[17037] had lunch with Mr. Crimmins. Mr. Crimmins at

that time was counsel for TWA. Did he deal primarily with

CAB matters.for TWA at that time?

A Yes.

Q Then you have an entry ‘*Florida route si North-

east Airlines interchange.’*

Can you tell me what that was about?

A That was probably a discussion with Mr. Crimmins

in connection with the Florida route case, in which TWA

was an applicant. °

Q You are referring to-some application by TWA for

a Florida route other than the St. Louis-Miami matter?

A Yes. That was an application that TWA filed in

connection with the New York-Florida route. We filed an

_ application for the route.

A-542

| Cocke Bepasition.

» |

Q Can you tell me a little bPnore | about that matter?

A I believe, as I recall it, our application was based

on’ the request of. TWA to be awarded the route if an

additional carrier was to be certificated. That if Northeast

was to be merged with any-other carrier, that TWA was .

the logical carrier to merge with Northeast. I believe that

_ Was our position in the New York-Florida route case.

. ° *

£17041] Q Sunday, May 8th. I see an entry ‘‘Meeting,

4:00 p.m.,’’ and you name Mr. Odlum, Stretch, Austin, and

you have the initials of Mr. Thomas, Mr. Leslie and your-

self, and you mention ‘Mr. Raymond —— and Mr.

‘Raymond Cook:

. Now tell me what that i is all about.

A .Qn the previous Friday, I believe, Mr. Thomas

advised us that there had been discussions between the

Atlas Corporation and the Hughes Tool Company with

reference to a merger of Northeast Airlines and TWA, and

that we were to have a meeting Sunday at Mr. Odlum’s

apartment to discuss it. This was the meeting on Sunday,

May 8th, when the agreements that ‘had been reached in the

discussions between the Atlas Corporation and the Hughes

[17042] Tocl .Company were gone over with the TWA

group and Jim Austin, who was president of Northeast

Airlines.

Q Give me now your total recollection of what took

place at that meeting?

A It was a general discussion. I don’t recall anything

significant except Mr. Thomas took the position ‘that this

was brand new to him, in effect, and that TWA would have

to, review the merger terms that had been agreed upon

between Atlas and the Hughes Tool Company for TWA to

make its decision as to whether the terms that had been

agreed upon would be satisfactory to TWA.

—

%

A-543

Cocke Deposition.

-Q Was anything else discussed? Have you any other

_recollection of what took place at that meeting?

A No,I do not. . " |

Q .You recall that we were going to consider entries

_in your diary for the :purpose of attempting to refresh

your recollection of prior occasions when you may have had

some conversations or knowledge of conversations, with

either Mr. Austin or others, relating to a possible TWA-_ :

Northeast merger. Has your recollection been refreshed in |

any way? a AAS ee )

In other words, Mr. Cocke, I am trying to understand ~

_ your testimony in the light of Mr. Austin’s testimony before

the CAR, and other. evidence.

My question to you now is, can you now tell me [17043]

what your total recollection is, whatever knowledge or

information you now have with respect, to the initiation of

the discussions or conversations between anybody, or in-

volving anybody, at Atlas, Northeast, the Hughes Tool

Company, Mr. Hughes, or TWA, relating to the possibility _

of a merger of Northeast Airlines with TWA, the desirabil-

ity or lack of desirability of such a merger?

- & TI don’t believe I can add anything to what I have

already testified. I stated that I had one conversation with

Mr. Odlum, I think at or about the time the Eastern

Colonial merger was being-in the process of being heard

or completed, which would have been 1955, 1956. °

I am sure that Mr. Austin and I had off and-on talked

about a Northeast merger. I think I stated previously that

one of the thoughts in my mind in connection with the

lease of an @rcraft to Northeast, that it would assist them

in obtaining a permanent certificate. I think I stated that

all before. — :

I don’t think I have anything to add to that.

[17051] Q Let us return to your diary then. I see on

May 9th, following this Sunday’s meeting at Mr. Odlum’s

A-544 | eee

Cocke Deposition.

apartment, you had a meeting with Mr. Thomas and Mr.

Leslie regarding Northeast. Can you tell me what that was -

about? : :

A My recollection.is that after the meeting on Sunday, .

we discussed: the merger agreement as it was presented

tous. .

I expressed my opinion, that I was in favor of the

merger. |

_ I believe Mr. Leslie expressed the game opinion. .

Mr. Thomas felt that we had had very little previous -

time to consider the terms; that TWA should [17052].

analyze independently the merger agreement.

I believe Mr. Leslie in a group, which probably included

‘Mr. Fellows, were asked to review the terms and come up

with a recommendation following their study as to what

action TWA should take.

Q Did you express reasons for your position in favor

of.such a merger at that time?

A Yes. © oe Z :

_ Q Can yon identify the reasons that you advanced to

support the opinion you were expressing to Mr. Thomas?

‘A I don’t think I can add’ much more to the reasons

than I believe I have testified to already. But the North-

east system, with its north-south routes, and the seasonality

of our Atlantic operation would enable us to use equipment

time that would be available when we cut hack on the inter-

national routes in the wintertime. That that equipment

could be used in the Florida market. _

*Q Do you recall or can you identify whatever reasons, ’

if any, Mr. Lesle advanced in connection with the views he

was expressing to Mr. Thomas at or about that time?

A I think, as I recall, his reasons were about the same

as mine. . .

_Q I understand from your testimony that Mr. Fellows

was asked to make some studies or evaluations?

° ™ A-545

Cocke Deposition.

17053] I think Mr. Fellows and some of Mr. Leslie’s staff,

I don’t recall who—I believe others in TWA—reviewed the

possible savings of the consolidation. —

Q Can you identify and describe the’ nature of the

report or evaluation that Mr. Fellows or others made at or

about that time?

_ A I don’t recall any details of the report. The report

was favorabl® to the merger.

Q Was this reported to Mr. Thomas

A Yes.

Q Do you have any other knowledge or information re-

lating to any studies or evaluations ‘that were made or

views that were expressed by any other senior or key

officers of TWA at or about that time?

. A °My recollection is that a committee of the Board

was set up to review the merger proposal, and studies that

had been made by TWA.

-I don’t recall who was on this committee, but this com-.

mittee of the Board. recommended the cggrers of the .

merger to TWA’s Board of Directors.

‘ QQ You can’t identify who the members of the Board

that acted an that committee were?

‘A. I believe I was on it. I believe Mr. Leslie was on it.

I think Raymond Holliday. I am not sure just [17054] who

was on the committee.

Q . Will you continue with your diary? I see that on

Tuesday, May 10th, there is an entry reading, ‘‘Discus-

sions, Northeast Airlines.”

A We had many meetings after the meeting of Sun-

day, _ 8th, to discuss the studies that were being made.

17056) By Mr. Davis:

Q Mr. Cocke, have you suriveel the minutes of the

Board of TWA ‘held on May 13, 1960, which has been

marked as Exhibit 365%

f

A-546

Cocke Deposition. .

A I hove, snd E one Shak tap italien: te the dtney of

the Board of Directors Northeast Airline, must have re-

ferred tg the fact that the Northeast merger was taken up

at this meeting.

Q I will first ask you if the minutes of that meeting

fairly and accurately reflect what took place so far as you

know!

A They do.

’

Q Referring to the minutes which appear ‘under the

heading, ‘‘Trans World Airlines-Northeast Airlines Mer-

ger,’’ do those minutes refresh your recollection in any way

as to what took place with respect to recommendations or

conclusions or action by the management of TWA relating

to the Northeast merger?

A Nothing. beyond what I have already testified.

- Q."Do you see this reftrence to the report presented by

Mr. Leslie which states that he reviewed the benefits avail-

able to each company if the merger ‘went through, et

cetera? Does that refresh you-any further than what you

have testified to?

017057] A It does not.

Q I see there was some discussion, and that Mr.

Sessel moved a committee be established to review all

aspects. —

You testified about some action being taken. Is that

the committee you were referring to, the one elected at

_ that meeting?

“A Yes: 5

“It stated, ‘“The commit consisted of Mr. Diase,

Mr, Thomas, Mr. Cocke, Mr“Weslie and Mr. Holliday. *

A Yes.

Q Can you tell me to what extent that committee

functioned, what it did?

A Idon’t reczll how many meetings were held by this

committee. I know at least one was held ‘at which this

material referred to by Mr. Leslie was reviewed. The com-

rd

A547

"Cocke Deposition.

‘> ee. . :

mittee reéommended approval of the merger to the Board

of Directors. ,

@ re + . .

[17060] Q On Wednesday, May 18th, you referred to

news of Odlum’s retirement. Then you have an entry read.

ing, ‘‘Meeting; Board of Directors, Advisory Committee

[17061] on.Northeast Airlines merger.’’ .

A Yes. kaht UN

Q What does that refer to? :

A That was a meeting of the Advisory Committee of

irectors who had been appointed at the previous Board

meeting to review the Northeast merger.

Q Can you tell me what:took.place at that time?

A A review of the material that had been prepared as

’ to the advantages of ‘the merger. Whether the decision was —

reached at this meeting to approve the presentation to the

Board, I don’t recall. .

~ ' Q*Can you tell me what view Mr. Thomas expressed

Sef or about that time, or after the studies had been made or

evaluated? !

. A Mr. Thomas was in favor of the merger after the

material had been studied. by TWA; and the discussions”

* with the Board of Directors: Advisory Committee.

2

: . « c |: C .

[Testimony—December 18, 1962]

. [17206] ; ) ,

. . * e ;

Q I-see you have a Board meeting on June 2Ist, and

i a lunch with Irving Trust Company, at the Waldorf.

“hat. took place at that time?

A Lunch at the Waldorf was just a luncheon for the

[17207] Board members at the Irving Trust suite at the

Waldorf. I don’t recall anything specific at this Board

meeting. :

|

2

» A-548

Cocke Deposition.

Q Do you recall at or.about that time some’ discussion

or conversation relating to élaims which TWA@might have

against the Hughes Tqol Ggmpany or anyone else?

A It may have been at this Board meeting. I don’t

recall just exactly at which meeting it was discussed.

Q Leaving aside whether or not it was at this meeting

or some other meeting, can you now give me.your complete

and total recollection of what was said? ~

A, I think at this Board meeting or a later Board. meet-.

- ing, the recommendation was made by Cahill, Gordon that

TWA had a cause for action against the Hughes Tool Com-

pany. I believe the Board then authorized Mr: Tillinghast

to file such action when he felt it was necessary. ;

Q What I am interested in now is what knowledge or

information you have. with respect to any discussions

- between members of the Board, or between the officers of.

TWA who discussed what the facts were relating. to this

cause offacti8n. |

Did’ that take place at all, to your knowledge! Was

there any such discussion ? .

A TI believe it took sla at one of the Reord meet-

: aa and also at an ‘Executive Committee meeting when Mr. °

17208} ‘Tillinghast and the Executive Committee reached :

the decision to file the action.

QI understand that. What I want-to have you tell

us) Mr. Cocke, is what was said, what facts were mentioned,

what discussion took place.. °

A °I believe Mr. Sonuett reviewed the causes for ac-

tion, and it was their opinion that TWA had a valid | cause

for action. ’ 3 ;

Q What I am referring. to, Mr. Cocke, is any coaversa-

tion or discussion between ‘the Board of Directors among

themselves, or: between the officers, or between .the -officers

and the Board of Directors, identifying or describing what |

the facts were, w raat had taken. place. Did that occur at all?

dl

a

Ne a eae

—A-549

Cocke Deposition.

A My recollection is that Mr. Sonnett, and I assume

. other members of Cahill, Gordon—I think I testified to

earlier, had talked, to Mr. Rummel. There was a copy of °

the complaint shown to me a few days, I think, before this

Board meeting or Executive Committce meeting. ©

I was asked if I had any comments on it. -The only -

commegt I made to’ Mr. Tillinghast was that I could not

understand the Atlas-Northeast question, and suggested to

him he ‘should call Mr. Stretch, because we had had very

close relationships with them .before—Mr. Tillinghast

[17209] should call Mr. Stretch and advise him beforehand,

which I believe he did.

edge . or information with ‘respect to any meetings or dis- :

iv

Q Anything else?

A Ihad no comment on the balance of the items in the

complaint.

Q My question to you still is, do you have any knowl-

cussions between or among any of the officers or pee

‘of TWA, or among the Board. |

A I only recall that the general basis of the complaint

"was reviewed with the Board. I believe Mr. Sonnett

reviewed it with the Executive Committee.

Q What is this meeting of June -23rd, involving Mr. oo

Tillinghast, Mr. Leslie and Mr. Rummel?

A ‘I believe that was a meeting to review the various

reports that were being made in the company,in an attempt

to reduce their number, to make, them more efficient.

Q At that time was there any discussion among your-

selves as to the report that had been received from special,

counsel?

A I don’t believe So.

Q. To your knowledge did Mr. ‘Tillinghast ever _in-

quire of you or anyone else at TWA as to what the facts

were with respect to what had happened in prjor years that

[17210] justified this complaint, or anything of the sort?

A-550-

Cocke Deposition.

A l don’t. recall that he did.

Q_ Do you know whether or not he made any inquiry of

anyone, if not of yourself, of anyone’ else at TWA?

A I don’t know.

Q Isee on Thursday June 29th you have an entey of

the Executive Committee meeting, re: HTC suit. That is

the one you referred to? -

A Yes, that must have been the Executive Committee’

imeeting that I -réferred to previously.

Q Mr..Cocke, let me refer you to the testimony of Mr.

‘Tillinghast w idle appeare at page 4680 and 4681. You can

‘ look at my copy. I am réferring to what appears beginning

on line 14 at page 4680.

. Do you fecall such a conversation ‘with Mr. Tillinghast?

A I believe Ido, yes.

Q- Does that refresh you recollection in any way as

to what you said and what he said, and what discussion you

‘had with respect to this complaint? -

A Except for the addition that I have made, that I

- raised the question with him of the Northeast- Atlas inclu-

sion in the complaint, which I testified: to before. I ex-

pressed concern, as. I believe’Mr. Tillinghast states here,

(17 2] 1] that being involved in litigation could perhaps

affect TWA's s image, and thereby its praffic.

Q Is there anything else you rolls

A 1 don't recall. anything else.

Q Do you know if anyone at TWA ever made an effort ;

to write down or summarize what they knew of what had

taken place in the past, involving either Mr. — or the

Hughes Tool Company?

A Yes. I believe Mr. Rummel did: I recall reading .

a paper that he had prepared.

| Q Do you recall approximately when? Can you

identify this piece q@f paper in some other way! |

-A- I believe it was after this period.

A-501

)

_ * Cocke Deposition. i

Mr. Williams: I think. Mr. Cocke may be refer-

‘ring to the paper that was prepared by counsel,

which Mr. Rummel has already testified that counsel

went over with Mr. Rummel.

Mr. Davis: I don’t know.

, ’Mr. Williams: I don’t know either, any more

« than what this witness has just said. I suggest it

was that, because I know of no euiiel that me.

’ Rummel has prepared.

Mr. Davis: Perhaps counsel doesn’t know every-

_ thing. .

[17212] Mr. Williams: I am perfectly willing

to admit that. I am the first to concede that, and you

may inquire further of this witness. |

I am merely trying to help you. I think that is

the paper he refers to. |

_ By Mr. Davis:

Q Do your know what Mr. Williams is talking about?

.A The paper I am referreing to was prepared, I as-

sume, by Mr. Rummel, which was a historical’resume of the

various equipment procurement activities. I believe it

is the same paper that Mr. Williams is referring to. ,

-Q You think it is the same piece of paper?

A Ido.

Q Did you have any coriversation or ‘distussion with

Mr. Rummel! with respect to what was in that piece of

' paper?

A No

Q Did Mr. Rummel tell you it was something that he

had prepared? a

A I believe so, yes. ?

-~ Q Do you know if that piece of paper was discussed

with anyone at TWA? ©

A-552

_ & Cocke Deposition.

‘A’ I don’t know.

ve * an

[ Testimony—January 3, 1963]

[17770] Q Now I would like to turn to your meetings or

conversations or communications with Mr. Duckworth.

First identify what communication you had with Mr.

_ Duckworth, and then I will ask you to tell us the substance

_ of what took place. ,

A I talked to Mr. Duckworth in “eemnection with the _

Executive Committee meeting at which the decision was

reached to file the suit. ase.

I guess I would have to say that his secelloctioln was not

’ a great deal more than mine, although I would like to am-

plify my testimony in that connection.

After reviewing the minutes and reviewing the work-

papers which I believe you presented to me during the de-

position, and the workpapers indicated that Mr. Rowe had

expressed some difference of opinion as to whether this suit

should be filed as an antitrust suit, or whether it should. be

filed as a civil suit.

I have searched my mind to try to recall the discussions

at that meeting. It was a relatively short meeting that

lasted for two hours. There were two other items discussed

- at the meeting.

I have a revollection of things that I have [17771] said:

I am just not certain whether they were at that meeting

or whether they were at other times.

I believe I covered the fact that I did not. understand

the question,of conspiracy on the Northeast merger.

* Iam sure I said it had been discussed and talked about

by myself that the merger was subject to the approval of the

majority of the minority stockholders of TWA.

That my recollection was that it had to be approved °

* by the Securities and Exchange Commission. It, of course,

had to be approved by the Civil Aeronautics Board.

~~

A-553

Cocke Deseition.

I am under the impression that i in approval of mergers

by the Civil Aeronautics Board, that one of their functions

is to determine the proper financial arrangements between

carriers on amerger. ,,

In other words, the CAB, I believe, ,has the right to

say that the financial basis of the exchange is not proper.

I guess I could just say that I had said to Mr. Tilling-

hast, and I am sure I said to others that I could not,.as I

see it, find dny conspiracy. At least I hadn’t been in any

conspiracy.

[17772] The other matters, I had talked about the question

that one time Mr. Hughes wanted to buy DC-7s, and the

management wanted to buy Constellations.

I believe I testified to that effect. I personally wanted

Constellations, and Mr. Hughes’ suggestion that we pur-

chase DC-7s was not followed.

I am sure I must have stated the fact that the manage-

ment was anxious to build an overhaul base for the jet

engines.

That Mr. Hughes’ advice was esguced to such a pro-

gram. That we should try to farm the. enginés out, and

that we should try to fit them into our overhaul base as —

the requirement for space for the overhaul of piston engines

-decreased. We did not build an overhaul base. 7

- I think at one time, it may have been at this meeting I

mentioned these things, I believe it was to Mr. Sonnett, |

- who told me that whether the decisions were right or wrong

in any antitrust action, that it wasn’t a question of whether

the things were right or wrong. —

I am just trying to give the substance of what the dis-

cussions were:

Further, in this Executive Committee meeting, in read-

ing the minutes carefully, and the workpapers, there isn’t

much in the workpapers except the comments of O73)

Mr. Rowe in the workpapers that I reend.

i>

A-sot :

Cocke Deposition.

There was the comment that. this matter had heen re- | -

viewed by Mr. Tillinghast with a number of directors in-

- formally, and that they had agreed that this action should

be taken.

I poh ¢ don’t remember further dinonssions at that meet-

ing.

~ [17827] Q Mr. Cnabe, I would like to dispose of what took

lace following the time when you first saw this draft of

complaint. My first questio& to you-is whether or not you

have any knowledge or information of any discussion of any

kind with respect to the ‘subject matter covered by that

complaint, prior to this Executive Gdmmittee meeting of

June 29th. In other words, between ‘the time you first saw .

_ the draft arid this Executive Committee meeting.

Do you have any recollection of any kind in that area?

A I think I testified that after I read the complaint

I talked to Mr. Tillinghast about the question of the North-

east merger, and I couldn’t understand it, and I felt that

in view. of my close personal relationship with James Austin

and Dave Stretch, and the many discussions we had, I felt

it was only courtesy. that Mr. Tillinghast should call on

_ Mr. Stretch and tell him, and he. agreed to do so, and I

believe did so..

[17828] I believe that is the: ‘only comment I made in that

area.

_ As I said before, T have the recollection of making thie

comments that I-testified to this morning. Whether they

were made in that period, at the Executive Committee meet-

ing or afterwards, I am just unable to limit it to that period

of time: The only clear recollection I have is that when

I read the complaint, that I talked to Mr. Tillinghast about

the Northeast question, which was something that I was

personally familiar with and personally had much to do

with.

- A-555

Cocke Deposition.

As far as the balance of the complaint i is concertied, I

made the comments that I testified ‘to this morning, but I

just cannot say for sure when I made those comments.

Q Other than this conversation with Mr. Tillinghast,

do you have any recollection of discussing the subject mat-

ter covered by the complaint with anyone else that you

have not already referred to?

Mr. Daly: During what period of time?

Mr. Davis: I. am not asking him to. go into the

Executive Committee meeting of June 29th, which we

are going to go into. I am trying to cover the period

of all times, but I understand he has already covered

the period from March Ist to the date he received the

[17829] complaint. The only time open now is the

time he received the draft of the complaint, and the

_- Executive Committee meeting of the 29th of June.

Because he has difficulty, which I can understand,

in identifying particular conversations in a particu-

lar period, I am now asking‘him if he has any recol-

lection of any kind, or if he has any knowledge or |

information of any kind, with respect to any discus-

sions relating to any of the events or matters referred

to in this complaint, which he has not yet adverted

to.

; Mr. Daly: That is the reason I asked you for

the time, because obviously he discussed it with me.

You have put no time limit.oh it. Do you want it

that way? He certainly discussed it with me.

Mr. Davis: Jam still referring to the time up

to and including the Executive Committee meeting

of June 29th. ate

Mr. Daly: That is what I am trying to find out.

Mr. Davis: I am not asking him to. address. him-

self to that particulas committee meeting yet.

A556. 4

Cocke Deposition. _%

The Witness: Mr. Davis, I think that I have

given you all the information I recollect. I may be

- able to recall other things as we have further dis-

17830] cussion.

By Mr. Davis:

Q I recall that this morning you referred to some dis-

cussion with Mr. Tillinghast when you in effect said that

you did not understand what this conspiracy claim was,

or words to that effect. Do you remember your testimony

along those lines? oh | |

A Yes, Ido. “yn

Q Addressing yourself now to that testimony, will you |

give me as fully and as completely as you can, not only what

you said to Mr. Ti!!inghast, but more importantly, what Mr.

Tillinghast said to you when you told him whatever you

_told him. ae eee Tiley.

Mr. Zeller: About the Northeast question? _

Mr. Davis: About the conspiracy, or lack of

conspiracy, about the complaint. ~

Mr. Zeller: You mean about the complaint gener-

ally? | .

_ Mr. Davis: About any of the facts covered by

the complaint. So far as my recollection is—he

only identified comments he made to Mr. Tillinghast

relating to his lack of understanding. of this con-

spiracy talk: . . | .

-If in fact he discussed some other aspect of

(17821) tke complaint with Mr. Tillinghast, my ques-

tion is intended to elicit whatever knowledge he has

with respect to any other area. Do you understand

_ my question?

9

A-557

Cocke Deposition. :

The Witness: I believe so, Mr. Davis. I made

these comments to Mr. Tillinghast on the question of

conspiracy. I don’t recall what-Mr. Tillinghast said.

In substance, that this was a legal question, and no

matter what I said—he appreciated my comments,

e but as far as my recollection is concerned, that this

was the legal aspect of it, that I don’t understand

the legal problems i in this. I think he said ‘‘That is a

legal question.”’

-I don’t recall that he disagreed with what I told

him, or I don’t “recall that he explained in detail

why it was a conspiracy, even though I made the -

comments that I did.. All I can recall is that he

listened. I just don’t recall what he said. * There

was no discussion that I remember as to ‘This is a

conspiracy because of this or that.’’ I don’t recall:

By Mr. Davis a :

Q cat you tell me a little more specifically or clearly

what it is that you said to Mr. Tillinghast relating to this

conspiracy? .

A I-told Mr. Tillinghast that I had had talks with

[17832] Austin. These discussions, so there is no mis-

understanding, were not in the context of negotiating the .

merger.

We were talking about the merger mainly from a traffic

standpoint. -

I believe I. mentioned to him the conversation which

I had with Mr. Odlum, which I believe was back in 1955

and 1956.

I told him that my understanding was s that the merger

agreement as it was drawn, required the majority vote of

the minority stockholdrs. That it still had to be approved “—

by the Securities and Exchange Commission. It had to be

approved by the Civil Aeronautics Board, and my impres-

A-558

Cocke Deposition.

sion was that the Civil Aeronautics Board had the author-

ity to rule. on thé exchange.

I gon’t think I can add anything to that. I was just

trying to express to Mr. Tillinghast my feeling that I just"

couldn’t. understand ‘t.:

Q. Did Mr. Tillinghast say to you in words or substance

‘*Why don’t you tell your story to counsel’’?

A I don’t recall that he did. I am sure I made this

same comment to, whether it was John Sonnett or other

members of the Cahill firm—I am sure that I have said

this to them. 1 e

[Testimony—January 4, 1963]

£17988)

* . *

Q Do you recall any statements made by anyone re-

lating to the desirability of trying to obtain some kind of

a divestiture of the Tool Company’s holdings in TWA?

« A Iam familiar.that the question of divestiture is in

the complaint. I recall being told or of reading some place

that under an antitrust action was the only way in [17989]

which divestiture could be accomplished.

Again, whether it-was talked about at this meeting or

if I read it some place, or if someone told me, I am familiar °

with and remember the fact that in an antitrust ‘action

that. was the only action in which Mr. Hughes could’ be

forced to divest himself of his stock in TWA. »

Q Do you have any recollection of anything that was

said relating to the desirability or lack of desirability of

filing the complaint under seal?.

* A There was some discussion as to whether or ‘not the

complaint should be filed under seal, and it was felt in the

best interest of the corporation, and I certainly agreed

with this, that if there was any a of avoiding a\

A-559

Cocke Deposition.

litigation—and before this timé I did not know such a

process was possible—that it was possible that the suit

could be filed and sealed. .

‘As I recall, from what.I was told, or what my knowledge

of it is, i? the casa was sealed and there was no publicity

on it, in that kind: of situation, which I can well under-

starid, it would_be a great deal simpler to reach a settle-

ment of the differences of the two parties rather than

after it had been umsealed and the case had: started, and

things had happ ed, where people said things. That it

would certainly wake it more difficult to reach a settle-

[17990]: ment than when it was sealed.

Whether it was at this time—I certainly felt that ‘filing

it under seal, if that should be done, it certainly would be

fine as far as I realized it, because I felt that I did not like

to see TWA as an airline become involved in litigation.

Q In your/Answer you have referred to how you felt.

Ian understand that. What I am inferested in. knowing,

Mr. Cocke, is whether you are able to testify as to what _— .

was said, or the substance of what was said by anyone

there present atthe meeting? rem

Mr. Daly: Could you ask him whether‘he ex-

pressed that feeling to ey at the meeting?

A Iam sure: I éxpressed . that aaias I can’t say

whether it was at this meeting that I expressed the feeling.

In listening to whatever discussion someone was telling

me about the fact that it would be filed and sealed, I don’t

recall anyone objecting to filing it under seal.

I think it Was the consensus of everything that I ry

‘anyone say that this would be the best thiy& to do-in the

hopes that this litigation could be avoided dnd a settlement

could be reached before it broke-~gpen to £17991] public,

knowledge.

A-560 —

) Cocke Deposition,

By Mr. Davis:

Q What.was said with sila to the possibility of ob-

taining a settlement? Do you have any recollection ofswhat

anyone said at that meeting relative to that subject

A’ I would like, ‘Mr. Davis, td say that these recollec-

tions, I would not be characterized or have it said. that it

actually happenéd at this meeting.

' I am trying to give my best recollection to the ques-

tions that you ask me. In the discussions as to how the

settlement was to be arrived at, whether it was at this

time.or laters there were many discussions and many ideas

or proposals to settle the litigation. » .

_ I remember that there was, I believe, a settlement, where

it appeared it was going to be settled the day before.

Mr. Daly: The day béfore what? “=

The Witness: The day before the suit was un-

sealed, if that is the proper term. I recall in re-

~ viewing this material that there was a deadline set

by TWA of acceptance, I believe, at 9:00 o’clock in

_ the niorning, before it was unsealed.

- I recah there was a difference of opinion between

Mr. Bautzer and Mr. Davis. In the notes that I

_ [17992] reviewed—I was either told or read some

place that Mr. Bautzer indicated he would be willing

to settle on that basis, and Mr. Davis said he would

7 not be willing to settle on that basis. No agree-

ment was reached, and the decision was made by

TWA to unseal the suit. ac \

By Mr. Davis: :

Q Lam primarily interested in the discussion that took

place at the time this decision was ‘made on June 29th, Mr.

Cocke. Do you have any_recollection of what, if anything,

A-561

Cocke Deposition.

was said about what efforts would be made‘to obtain the

deposition of Mr. Hughes.

A Again I am not limiting- myself to this meeting.

There was discussion ‘that I recall, that one of the reasons —

TWA wf to-file the suit first was to obtain the right of ~

prior depositjon.

I am not completely familiar with these legal terms,

but .I can only say that.it was obvious if TWA had the

right of prior deposition, that the deposition of Mr. Hughes

would be taken before the deposition of any of the TWA

witnesses.

“ Q What I am interested in is. what was said in that

~ ection, if anything was said in that connection. Is

anything else you recall?

nreea For example, did anyone say anything to the effect

that if a eourt order was obtained for the deposition of

Mr. Hughes, that would: insure a settlement on particular

terms, or anything like thatf

A There had been discussions that if it was necessary .

for Mr. Hughes to make the deposition, that there would

be a probability that it would be easier to reach a settle-

ment, yes.

Q Do you recall anyone sayingyanything about Mr.

Hughes’ attitude about taking his deposition, or what he

would do or not do depending on whether or not his deposi-

tion was ordered? —

A There have been discussions as to the opinion, and

I believe Mr. Slick made‘the statement, that if Mr. Hughes

would not want to make a deposition, and that if he was.

forced to make a deposition, or that when that time came,

the possibility of settlement would be greater. _

Q Did anyone say anything at-that time with respect

to what tendencies or inclinations Mr.. Hughes had dis-

played in the past, or was anything said in that area as to

what wo be likely to happen, what Mr. — would

be likely to-do? .

el 562

‘Gaile —

sii people—I think Mr. Slack, and I am not sure

who else—had the feeling that Mr. Hughes would not want

[17994] to make a deposition.

I recall, in thinking over this, that I pinesenend with

- that opinion. I bronght up the fact that Mr. Hughes had

made a deposition in Washington many years ago in con-

nection with Senator Brewster, and I didn’t have the same

- opinion, that Mr. Hughes would feel that a settlement would

be made if it"was necessary. for him to make a deposition.

Q Do you recall anything being said'about the pos-

_ sibility Of Mr, Hughes had changed, and,was no longer the

same kind of person he had been at the time that he ap-

pearéd in these’ Brewster hearings—any physical or men-

- tal disability about testifying, or any ee

Mr. Daley: Don’t ask too many ‘questions in

-one. Let him go along. You. will get the witness:

all confused when you tack’ on all these things.

' A There have been discussions as to the question of

_ whether Mr. Hughes was, I guess to characterize it, the

same man he was when he took on Mr. Brewster. Oe,

- Q > Can you tell me a little bit more as to what was said

in that connection, and by aie if you can fanaa who

said what? | ;

A’ As I gaid, I recall Mr. Slack made a comment such

was ‘that. I hesitate to say just who else made statements.

17995] I said, and I repeat. that I expressed the opinion

that Mr. Hughes, to ‘use my own words, was [not] afraid

of a deposition. i

Q You keep referring to Mr. Slack. Mr. Slack wags

_ not at that meeting, was he?

4+ * “A No, he was not, Mr. Davis. I am trying to give you

*the best of my recollection to your questions, and I haven’t

understood that your questions to me since’ this time have

been limited to this meeting. ‘

‘ A-563

Cocke Deposition.

Q I understand that. How about Mr. Sessel? Do

- you have a.recollection of what views Mr. Sessel expressed

-along this general area as to Mr. Hughes, and his prob- ,

able action: or eourse of co..duct if ordered to be deposed?

A. [would:say that I can recall Mr. Sessel in substance

agreeing with the feeling that Mr. Hughes would not want

~ to make a deposition.

_ Q-+Can you recall more specifically the substance of

what Mr. Sessel said? .

A’ I don’t think I can think of anything. The ques-

tion which is in my notes here—excuse me, Mr. Special

Master, that is nother subject. _

Q Let me refer you to what has been previously

‘.marked ‘as Defendants’ Exhibit 117. I want to caution

you that [17996] these are handwritten.notes purporting

to refer to. a telephone conversation between two other

people.

Mr. Daly: Sut sad it to him and a him, to

read it. é

. _ By Mr. Davis:

: a, |

Q You are not to assume anything in there to be true.

Mr.. Daly: Ask him if anything ‘in’ there re-

freshes his recollection.

Mr. ‘Davis: May I be permitted to direct him

‘to a’ particular portion of the document.

Mr. Daly: ao.

By Mr. Davis:

Q. Look at what appears under item 2:

‘‘May not tell other banks. Knew HRH:

Seared by Cahill lawsuit, but worse than expected.

y A-564

Cocke Deposition. | -

- They have concluded if get him on stand would keep

him there for two or three months.”’’

Mr. _ Does that — your recollection? .

e By Mr. Davis:

Q Does that refresh your recollection in any way as to

. what else, if anything, was said at or about that time?

A I think this covers just about what I said. I didn’t

use the term ‘‘scared.’’ I think the substance of this is

there was a feeling—I see these notes are of’ a conver-

17997], sation with Mr. Sessel—that Mr. Hughes would’

just not want to give a deposition.

Q How about this reference if they could get him on.

the stand would keep him there for two or three months?

Do you have any recollection of anything being said as to

what would be likely to happen? |

A I don’t recall any reference to the length of time

_ that Mr..Hughes could be kept on the stand. My comments

‘are limited—not limited, but my recolleétion is the discus-

sion of the fact that Mr. Hughes did not want to make a

deposition, and ‘that everything would be done: to avoid

him making a deposition. |

-Q Do you recall. anyone saying anything as to why it

was, to be assumed that Mr. Hughes would not want to —

have his deposition taken?

‘A 1 think, as I recollect, thegfeeling that Mr. Hughes

had over recent years become more and more—not a re-

cluse, but made less and fewer public appearances—and

* perhaps in view of his tendencies in the past few years of

avoiding public appearances, aWoiding meetings with peo- ®

ple, performing his bufsiness over-the telephone—that he

probably would not want to make a deposition.

Q Can you recall any more specifically what was ‘said

in connection with this tendency or desire of Mr. Hughes

[17998] to avoid meeting people?

A-565

Cocke Deposition.

Do you have any more of a recollection as to what was ~

said in that area? .

Mr. Daly: - I don’t think he said that.

Mr. Davis: I think his expression was ‘‘avoiding

meeting with people.’’

pa Mr. Daly: I do object to characterizing the tes-

-. tifhony of the witness. <“ °

Mr. Davis: I don’t think it will change his tes-

~ timony, Mr. Daly.

Mr. Daly: I don’t either, but I am here to pro-

tect the witness, and I-intend to do it.

The Special Master: Answer what you recall

about this particular subject matter. .

A Only discussions over the years, and this is true to.

my knowledge, that Mr. Hughes formerly met more freely

with people, had more contact with meetings and appear-

ances; that to my knowledge for the past several years

Mr. Hughes has not been—has not appeared in public as

- much as he used to.

Why that is, I don’t know. I have my own opinions, but

I have no knowledge of it.

Q It isn’t so much of your knowledge about Mr.

Hughes. I am interested in what anyone said they knew or

. thought [17999] they knew about Mr. Hughes.. .

-A I would like to think a minute, Mr. Special Master.

The Special Master: Why don’t we take a short

recess,:and then you can answer that.

(Whereupon, a short recess was taken) .

£18000] The Special Master: Will you read the last

question to the witness?

(The question was read.)

A I don’t believe that I can add anything to what I

have said.

A-566

Cocke Deposition.

By Mr. Davis: : |

Q Do you recall anything being said by anyone to the

effect that an antitrust action would be the only solution to

the problem, or words to that effect?

A Only the discussions that the knowledge where I

read or heard that the antitrust suit would be the only type

of an action that would force Mr. Hughes, or could force

Mr. Hughes.to divest himself of his TWA stock. I don’t

recall anything further than that. I am not sure just what

you mean by your question: as to the problem.

Q Iwas trying to refer to whatever anybody may have

* said identifying or describing what the problem was, if

there was one. The relationship of the Hughes Tool Com-

pany being a large stockholder of TWA, or anything in

that area. °

Mr. Barr: I think the witness’ inquiry was a

- fair one. I think Mr. Davis ought to say what prob- .

lem he is referring to when he asks the question.

Mr. Davis: I am referring to the testimony of

[18001] Mr. Tillinghast.

Mr. Zeller: That is fine, except I don’t have Mr.

Tillinghast’ s testimony in mind, and I have much

doubt if the witness has. ‘

Mr. Davis: I am not trying to wet ve to affirm

or not affirm Mr. Tillinghast’s testimony. I am ask-

ing this witness if he has any recollection if anybody

said that a divestiture of the Tool Company stock in

TWA would be the only solution to something which

- ’ was either described as a problem or Something.

Mr. Daly: I think it would help the witness more

when yoti pin it down to something rather than say

a problem.

Mr. Davis: That is the way Mr. “Tillinghast

identified the reasons for deciding to go the antitrust

_ Youte rather than the other. That was one of the

A-d67

Cocke Deposition. y

ways he did. I thought that was a word [sic] of art

among the management group at TWA.

Mr, Daly: You might ask him that. Maybe he

will say yes.

A . Would you read the question back, please?

(The question was read.) °

By Mr. Davis:

Q I will rephrase the question this way. Do you

[18002] have any recollection of what was said by anyone

relating to the desirability for obtaining a divestiture

order, or the reasons for wanting a divestiture order, or

anything in that area?

A I believe the reasons that I recall was the fact that

Mr. Hughes controlled 78 per cent of TWA, and that there

were problems that had been involved in connection with

the control of TW-A dy the Hughes Tool Compary.

Mr. Davis: May I have the answer read to. me?

(The answer was read.)

By Mr. Devin:

Q Can -you identify what was said with respect to

either the problems or control?

A I would in substance say that the pechlom bissinne .

of the fact that Mr. Hughes or the Hughes Too! Company

would not agree to the financing was that had been

offered by the lenders. : . :

Mr. Daly: This was the substance of what was

said by somebody to you at some time, is that right?

Is that what you want to know?

Mr. Davis: I want to know what was said. I

don’t want your interpretations.

A-568

: Cocke Deposition.

A In substance I recall that comment being made.

- Q You don’t know by whom? °

[18003] A I don’t know where or who made the comment.

It was a discussion of the Hughes’ problem. That to the

best of my recollection is the substance of what was told

me of the Hughes’ problem.

. Q Do you recall anything being said as to whether or

not there would be more or less social stigma or social

-opprobrium in bringing an antitrust action rather than

some other kind of action?

A No, Ido not.

Q In your prior answers you made a number of refer-.

ences/to Mr. Slack. Can you identify more clearly what

- your recollection is as to what Mr. Slack said that relates

to the testimony you gave with reference to Mr. Slack?

A Idon’t believe I can. I think, as far as my recollec-

tion is concerned, I testified in substance as to the comments

Mr. Slack made as to the various questions that came up.

Q Can you identify more than you already have the

nature or substance of what Mr. Slack said, when, to whom?

A As T recall it, I have stated that I recall Mr. Slack -

had stated that he didn’t feel that Mr. Hughes would agree ___

to any settlement of the litigation-until he was called upon.

to make a deposition.

I think-I have also said—I may not have—Mr. [18004]

Slack, I think as I recall it, commented that he did not feel

that the antitrust actior was the right action to have filed.

He felt that it wasn’t an antitrust suit, tha

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — Hughes Tool Co. v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. · 380 U.S. 248 | Frix