No Transcript of Record — Dresner v. City of Tallahassee
Supreme Court brief1963
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
YS
® LIBRARY, ~ ’
e
" aNsePPOF HEED D
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 168
No. 35
ISRAEL DRESNER, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
vs.
CITY OF TALLAHASSEE.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
STATE OF FLORIDA, SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1963
No. 35
ISRAEL DRESNER, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
vs.
CITY OF TALLAHASSEE.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
STATE OF FLORIDA, SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
INDEX
Record from the Municipal Court, In and For the
City of Tallahassee, A Municipal Corporation of
Florida
Affidavit of James Messer, Jr. and Edw. J. Hill
setting forth the charges against the petitioners
Transcript of proceedings of June 22, 1961 (ex-
| i RNa nae ees ener aneN
Appearances
Motion of defendants to quash and to dinmies
the charges
Testimony of James Messer, Sin
direct pastiek
CTOSS ___...
redirect
Paul Cannedy—
direct
Cross - M
Raymond J. Lewis—
direct -
cross
Original
oS »->
x
38
40
ReEcorD Press, PRINTERS, NEW York, N. Y., JUNE 26, 1963
ii INDEX
Origina) Print
Record from the Municipal Court, In and For the
City of Tallahassee, A Municipal Corporation of
Florida—Continued f
Transcript of proceedings of June 22, 1961 (ex-
cerpts )-—Continued
Testimony of Frank Stoutamire—
SETS SD 86 42
EE eae 94 47
I Toccata S| 102 52
James F. Bennett—
ES ri ES vn 105 54
~ tg SEES" a 118 62
RII sche cies adlchee tance 127 68
SRR I aero 128 68
Orville Hopkins—
direct Fi tec nasi ekaed oe 130 69
cross eee Joes 131 70
W_ D. Hopkins—
direct Te ae 148 71
cross. aie 151 74
James Messer, Jr.—
(recalled )—
Re eran Re ee 152 74
Sei ncchatistieee a, 153 75
Plaintiff rests ; 153 75
Renewal of motion of defendants to quash and
to dismiss the charges and denial thereof 153 75
Testimony of J. W. Collier, Jr.—
te | ee 77
cross mekanbeseems sce 173 87
Martin Freedman-—
en AL a pes 184 94
RE IA A ea 190 98
redirect ce 193 100
Hubert A. Isdell—
direct al Arata che eee 196 101
Offer in evidence 200 104
Testimony of Hubert A. Isdell—
CTOSS - = 204 107
Offer ir evidence | eck cs RAD re 205 108
INDEX
Record from the Municipal Court, In and For the
City of Tallahassee, A Municipal Corporation of
Florida—Continued
Transcript of proceedings of June 22, 1961 (ex-
cerpts )— Continued
Testimony of Arthur L. Hardge—
direct
Offers in evidence and refusal thereof
Testimony of Arthur L. Hardge—
' @ross
Robert McAfee Brown-—
direct
CTOSS
Arthur L. Hardge—
(resumed ) —
cTOss :
Ralph Lord Roy—
GND picnccestpiecencct keene
CTOSS :
Israel Dresner—
direct ___.
CTOSS
Austin M. Warner—
direct _
cTOss
redirect -
Robert J. Stone—
direct
CTOSS
redirect
Wayne C. Hartmire—
direct
cross
redirect -
recross
redirect
Petty D. McKinney—
direct
CTOSS
Original
lil
Ly
iv INDEX
Record from the Municipal Court, In and For the
City of Tallahassee, A Municipal Corporation of
Florida—Continued
Transcript of proceedings of June 22, 1961 (ex-
cerpts )—Continued
Testimony of Orville Hopkins-——
(recalled )—
direct
Wayne C. Hartmire—
(recalled )—
direct les
I Se he el ae
Ruling of court Ea SE pe ce Sta Rn A
Defendants’ Exhibit “1A” for identification
and admitted in evidence as Defendants’ Ex-
hibit 2—
—Statement of James Messer Jr. ;
—Attachment—Stipulation of counsel as to
Tallahassee Municipal Airport . :
Clerk's certificate (omitted in printing)
Assignments of error © _..
Proceedings in the Supreme Court of the State of
Florida __. ; :
Stipulation to sapplenignt recodd on : append
Opinion, Thornal, J.
Order affirming judgments canned by the. Circuit
Court of the State of Florida, Second Judivial
Cireuit in and for Leon County
Order allowing certiorari _- Notts
Original Print
263 136
273 142
274 143
274 143
278 144
299 146
300 146
301 147
302 147
307 150
307 150
311 153
316 156
328 165
[fol. A]
IN THE MUNICIPAL COURT, IN AND FOR THE CITY
OF TALLAHASSEE, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OF FLORIDA
Case Nos. 77900-77912
Ciry or TaLuanasser, Plaintiff,
Vs.
IsraceL Dresner, Austin M. Warner, Rosert M. Brown,
Petry D. McKinney, Martin Freepman, Artuur L.
Harpce, Ropert J. Stoner, Wayne C. Harrnire, J. W.
Cour, Jr., Racpu L. Roy, Cuas. A. Hunter, Jonn J.
Potanp, Jr., and Priscitta G. StepHens, Defendants.
ArFipavit—June 20, 1961
Before me, John A. Rudd, Judge of the Municipal Court
of the City of Tallahassee, Florida, personally appeared
James Messer, Jr. and Edw. J. Hill, who, being duly sworn,
say that on, to-wit: the 16th day of June, 1961, upon prop-
erty owned and operated by the City of Tallahassee,
Florida, and located in Leon County, Florida, namely, the
Tallahassee Municipal Airport, Israel Dresner, Austin M.
Warner, Robert M. Brown, Petty D. MeKinney, Martin
Freedman, Arthur L. Hardge, Robert J. Stone, Wayne C.
Hartmire, J. W. Collier, Jr., Ralph L. Roy, Chas. A. Hun-
ter, John J. Poland, Jr., and Priscilla G. Stephens:
Count I
Did then and there unlawfully assemble in that they did,
and they being more than three (3) persons, met together
to commit a breach of the peace, acting together and con-
ifol. B] certedly to occupy and to continuously occupy
certain chairs and seating facilities in the Tallahassee Mu-
nicipal Airport, making and cancelling group airline reser-
vations on the two (2) operating airline schedules depart-
-
2
ing Tallahessee on the said date, and on June 15, 1961,
and meeting together in concert attendant with circum-
stances calculated to excite alarm, endanger the public
peace and excite fear, and in such nature as to inspire
well-grounded fear in persons of reasonable courage, of
riot, or other breaches of public peace, and while so un-
lawfully assembled a police officer of said City did go
among these persons so assembled, and making himself
known to them and each of them, @id, in the name of the
State and City, command those so unlawfully assembled to
immediately and peaceably disperse, and they and each of
them did then and there refuse and/or neglect to obey
such command when given, contrary to the laws and or-
dinances of said City in such cases made and provided,
and against the peace and dignity of the said City of Talla-
hassee, Florida. ;
James Messer, Jr., City Attorney.
Edw. J. Hill, City Solicitor.
Sworn to and Subscribed before me this 20 day of June,
A.D. 1961.
John A. Rudd, Municipal Judge, City of Tallahassee,
Florida.
[fol.C] Clerk’s Certificate to foregoing paper (omitted
in printing).
[fol. D] !
In tHe Munictpan Covrt,
Ix AND FoR THE City oF TALLAHASSER,
A Menicipat Corporation or Forma.
Case Nos. 77900-77912
Crry or Tauianasser, Plaintiff,
—_vVvVs.—
- Isrart Dresnern, Austin M. Warner, Rosert M. Brown,
Petry D. McKinsey, Martin FreepMax, Artuer L.
Harper, Rosert J. Stone, Wayne C. Harrmire, J. W.
Coiuier, Jr. Racpu L. Roy, Cuas. A. Hunter, Jonny J.
Potanp, Jr., and Priscrta G. Steruens, Defendants.
Transcript of Proceedings of June 22, 1961
Transcript of proceedings had and testimony taken in
the above-entitled cause before the Honorable John A.
Rudd, Judge of the Municipal Court, Tallahassee, Florida,
on Thursday, June 22, 1961, commencing at 9:10! o'clock
a.m.
APPEARANCES:
James Messer, Jr., City Attorney, City Hall Buid-
ing, Tallahassee, Florida, and
Edward J. Hill, City Prosecutor, City Hall Build-
ing, Tallahassee, Florida, on behalf of plaintiff,
Tobias Simon, Esquire, 706 Ainsley Building, Miami,
Florida, and
[fol. E]
Howard W. Dixon, Esquire, Seybold Building, Miami,
Florida, and
Alfred I. Hopkins, Esquire, 1701 Meridian Avenue,
Miami Beach, Florida, By: Tobias Simon and
Howard W. Dixon, Esqs., on behalf of defendants.
\
4
{fol.4} The Court: These defendants were arraigned on
a docket entry Saturday morning, a brief description of the
charge being unlawful assembly except Priscilla G. Stephens
is charged in addition to unlawful assembly with interfering
with a police officer in performance of his duties and re-
sisting arrest.
Does the defense care to have a formal arraignmeat at
this time? j
Motion oF DEFENDANTS TO QuUASH AND TO
DisMiss THE CHARGES
Mr. Simon: At this time, if Your Honor please, the de-
fense will move to quash and to dismiss the charges against
[fol.5] these defendants on the following grounds:
First, that the charges of the City of Tailahassee do not
state an offense.against the defendants under the ordinances
of the City of Tallahassee or the statutes of the State of
Florida.
Second, the alleged offenses occurred beyond the city
limits of the City of Tallahassee and this Court is with.
out jurisdiction to try these offenses.
Third, the statute pursuant to which the defendants
were arrested and with which the defendants are charged
and which they are charged with having violated, namely
Florida Statutes, Chapter 61-237, is invalid and is uncon-
stitutional, constitutes a denial of rights under the Declara-
tion of Rights of the Florida Constitution and constitutes
a denial of rights under the Federal Constitution to the
United States and the !st and 14th Amendments thereto
and as a consequence these arrests were unlawful and the
charges based thereon are without foundation.
Next, the defendants with constitute a party of negroes
and whites who were located in a municipally owned air-
port in the City of Tallahassee and were attempting to use
the public facilities of this airport on a racially unsegre-
yrated basis acted at all times in a peaceful and dignified
manner; their arrests constitute a denial to the defendants
of the equal protection of the law under the 14th Amend-
\ ment to the Federal Constitution and 2 denial of due
[fol.6] process of law, a denial of privileges and immuni-
ties of State citizenship guaranteed thereby; a denial ot
the privileges and immunities of Federa! citizenship since
they were at all times on and in an instrumentality of the
municipality of Tallahassee and were attempting to use the
facilities thereof, which facilities are required by Federal
law to be made available to all citizens without regard to
their race or color.
Next, the defendants at the time of the arrests were
passengers in interstate commerce awaiting departure at
the Municipal Airport of Tallahassee of their plane from
Tallahassee to points beybnd the State of Florida and their
arrests constitute a violation of their rights of unfettered
travel free of racial discrimination under the Interstate
Commerce Clause of the Federal Constitution, nafmely Arti-
cle 1, Section 8, Clause 3, and a violation of their privileges
and immunities of Federal citizenship, a violation of the
Federal Aviation laws and a violation of the Federal
Aviation Act of 1958 and, in particular, Secticn 404 of said
act, same being 72 Statute 760, 49 U.S. Code, Section 1574-B.
The arrests of the defendants and their prosecution con-
stitute a violation of their liberty of contract as guaranteed
by the 14th Amendment to the Federal Constitution.
Next, the acts of the city officials in arresting and in
participating in the arrests of these defendants and these
prosecutions based thereon and the coneomitant failure of
|fol. 7| the city officials to arrest certain other persons in
the vicinity who were threatening to exhibit acts of viobence
because of the defendants’ presence at the aforesaid airport
and because of the defendants’ endeavor to use the airport
facilities on an unsegregated basis constitutes racial dis
crimination in violation of the due process clause—
The Court: Hold on a minute.
Are you making a motion, arguing a motion or are vou
testifying? ,
Mr. Simon: I am making a motion.
The Court: Leave out vour facts and make the motion
according to law.
Mr. Simon: (Continuing) —in violation of the Due
Process Clause and the Equal Protéetion Clause of the 14th
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States and
6
corresponding provisions of the Florida Constitution where-
by the defendants respectfully neve this Court to quash
end dismiss the information and charges herein filed.
{fol. 20] Thereupon, James Messer, Jr., called as a wit-
ness by and on behalf of the plaintiff, having been previ-
ously duly sworn, was examined and testified on his oath
as follows:
* ° e ¢t
Direct examination. ¥
By Mr. Hill:
(). State vour name for the record.
A. My name is James Messer, Jr.
Q. Are you a resident of Tallahassee, Leon County,
Florida? ,
A. T am.
‘fol. 21] QQ. What is your oceupation?
A. i am an attorney ai law; | am City Attorney of the
City of Tallahassee and a special police officer of the City
Tallahassee.
Sinon: | object to that answer and move tliat it be
stricken on the grounds that it is not responsive to the ques-
tion.and further that tne best evidence of that faet would
be his license.
The Court: Objection overruled.
The Witness: If the Court please. | have this (indieat-
ing).
Mr. Hill: If the Court please, | have here a letter from
the City Manager of the City of Tallahassee appointing Mr.
James Messer as a police officer.
The Court: Mr. Messer just testified nnder oath he was
these things and it is up to the defendants if they do not
believe him to impeach him.
| see no need to support your own testimony.
Mr. Hill: Aib right.
Q. Were you such a police officer on the 15th and 16th
davs of June, L961?
~]
A. I was.
Q. Were you on duty as such a police officer on these
days?
(fol. 22] <A. I was.
Q. Did you on the 15th and 16th days of June, 1961 see
these 13 defendants here (indicating) ?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. Where did vou see them on either of those days or
both of them?
A. On the loth I saw the defendants with the pan-rrn
of Priscilla Stephens and John Poland at the Greyhound
bus terminal Tallahassee.
Q. You were a sterminal?
A. There are one or tw4 others that 1 didn’t see. They
are named in the charges.\ | believe Hunter is one.
Q. You do not remembey seeing Hunter?
A. | do not remember sé#eing Hunter; at least | couldn’t
identity him.
Mr. Simon: | can’t heap you.
Mr. Hill: If Your Horfor please, | believe that Mr. Simon
can hear me.
If vou are trying to harass me I will vell just as loud
as I can.
Mr. Simon: I think you know that isn’t the case. |
slply can’t hear you. You are speaking in too low a tone.
(Q). What were the circumstances under which these de-
fendants were seen by you at the bus station on the 1th
i fol. 25) day of June?
I was requested by the Mavor, the Chief of Police—
Mr. Simon: I object on the ground the same is hearsay.
The Court: T will rule on your objection when he gets
through answering.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, that would destroy the
effect of the hearsay rule. He is about to testify—
The Court: He hasn’t said anything what he has been
instructed about, Mr. Simon. Mr. Messer is familiar with
the pracy rule, | ani sure, and will avoid that.
I was requested to go to the Grevhound bus terminal
on a 15, to be there at approximately 11:50.
>
Q. Did you go there?
A. I did.
Q. What did you do?
A. I went into the bus termina,. There were very few
persons there. Some apparently elderly people were waiting
for buses and some people were seated in the lunch counter
‘but very few people were present at the time I arrived
with the exception of police officers of the City of Talla-
hassee, i member of the State Highway Patrol, a repre-
sentative of the Sheriff’s Office and representatives of the
[ fol. 24] Sheriff’s Bureau of the State of Florida.
Q. Did you receive advance information that these people
or these defendants or other people similarly situated would
come into this bus station at or about that time?
A. Well, it was announced on television and I received
other information which | consider to be reliable that they
were to arrive about 11:30.
Q. Did they so arrive? ,
A. They did.
Q. Would you describe the circumstances under which
they arrived, Mr. Messer?
A. There were two buses that entered the bus terminal
from the entrance off of West Tennessee Street. They
came in the west entrance from what is commonly referred
as the loeding platform and went into the bus terminal.
Q. Do you know about how many people were involved
n this group and if that group was composed of these
defendants?
A. 1 only observed their entrance. I was on duty outside
of the terminal, the main entrance there at the intersection
of Adams and Tennessee.
I would judge there were about some 20, maybe 25. I
didn’t make an actual count.
Q. Were these ten defendants that vou have just re-
ferred to excluding the three that vou excluded earlier in
[fol. 25] vour testimony, were they present?
A. Yes.
Q. What were the circumstances surrounding the bus sta-
tion at that time other than the large crowd of people that
you have just referred to?
A. About | would say 15 or 20 minutes before they ar-
\
9
rived a rather large crowd gathered in front of the bus
terminal, across from the bus terminal, that is across Adams
Street and those that Officer Daws—he was on duty inside
the front deor and I was outside—turned away, they had
gone around and gotten in the back way some way.
There was quite a crowd in there and the police of-
ficers succeeded in getting them to leave. Then there was
a group that came up to the entrance of the terminal, the
front door, and attempted to go in and they were turned
away.
There were rather vile epithets or rather vile language
used and criticism against the Police Department for per-
mitting the bus company to serve the Freedom Riders with
food.
Q. Were these people provided with every protection
that you know that was available to the City and the com-
munity?
The Court: What people? “These people” you say.
Q. This group of people that you are referring to which
includes these defendants.
The Court: These ten defendants?
[fol. 26] The Witness: That’s right.
A. Yes. As I pointed out there were several uniformed
ofticers of the Police Department, there were a number of
them in plain clothes, there was ai least one member of
the Highway Patrol and the Sheriff of Leon County was
present. He had with him at least two deputies and there
were representatives of the Sheriff's Bureau. I understand
there were representatives of the FBI present but |
couldn't identify them, but there was ample police protec-
tion afforded.
Q. I believe vou have testified or if you have not may
Task you: These ten defendants you have referred to, did
they come into this community or to this City in one
group?
A. There were two buses. T don't know whether all
of the defendants here (indicating) were riding on tlie same
bus or not but there were two buses of the so-called Freedom
Riders of which these defendants were a member.
Ses a
10 i
r/
-
ao
Se
ee
{ Q. Did those buses arrive in Tallahassee at or about the
same time?
A. One was following the other.
Q. Is the Greyhound terminal within the corporate city
limits of Tallahassee, Florida?
A. Yes.
Q. Did this assembly or this meeting of the so-called
Freedom Riders, was it in any way in your opinion—was
[fol. 27] the assembly of these people, this group, these ten
and those that were arriving with them, was is assembly
attended with any circumstances that excitéd any alarm
in your opinion?
Mr. Simon: I object on the grounds the witness hasn’t
shown to be properly qualified to render opinion evidence
and further it calls for a conclusion of the witness; further
that it is based, obviously, upon hearsay evidence.
Mr. Hill: May I answer that? One of the elements of
common law and statutory crime or offense, that is of
unlawful assembly, is whether or” not in the opinion of
firm and rational people in the community this assembly
is calculated to excite, alarm and to inspire fear or other
breaches of the peace and therefore it is perfectly com-
petent for a man of this kind to give his opinion as to
whether or not it is. Otherwise, Your Honor, no law en-
forcement officer or anykody under the statute could be
authorized to disperse an assembly, would never have any
right or authority on which to make a move.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, we respectfully sub-
mit even if that is the case the proper predicate hasn't been
shown in this instance.
The witness has already testified ample police protec-
tion was available.
The Court: The qualifications or predicate vou would
have to lay for a person to testify under this statute would
[fol. 28] be that which establishes him as a responsible,
level headed citizen and member of the community and
knowing Mr. Messer as long as I have and as well as I do
the Court takes judicial knowledge of the faet that he is
such a person and the objection is overruled.
Mr. Hill: Will the Reporter please read that question
back? I would like him to answer it.
11
(The question referred to was read back by the Re-
porter.)
Mr. Simon: Just a moment. I believe, Your Honoy, that
two witnesses for the defense have just come into the room.
They were not aware of the invocation of the Rule and |
would like them to be called before the bar at this time and
sworn and instructed in the Rule. cD
The Court: All right. Call them up.
(Addressing the two witnesses) You will remain out-
side the courtroom and don’t talk about the case with any-
one except the City Attorneys’ and the defense attorneys
and we will administer the oath at the proper time.
A. As I stated before, there was a considerable number
of people assembled on the northeast corner of the inter-
section of Adams and Tennessee Streets just across the
street from the main entrance to the bus station. A group
had assembled at the front door of the bus terminal build-
[fol. 29] ing. Rather vile language was used toward the
defendants and efforts made by some of those assembled
to enter the bus station. One of them claimed that he had
special permission from the Mayor and the Mayor hap-
pened to arrive at that time and the Mayor denied having
given any such permission and finally it became necessary
for me to call my assistant, a uniformed member of the
Police Department who was Lieutenant Gasaul (phonetic
spelling), and to offer him to order a dispersal of the
crowd.
Q. Did they so disperse?
A. After Lieutenant Gasaul moved in. I had dispersed
three or four prior to that but this large group, the one
that seemed.anost indignant about the actions of the City
of Tallahassee—
Mr. Simon: I object. I don’t think that the witness
is properly qualified to describe a crowd as being indignant.
He ean tell what he saw. I object to the conclusion.
The Court: Objection overruled.
Q. Mr. Messer, is it four opinion there was a possibility
of danger to the peace and tranquility of that neighborhood
at that time?
12
Mr. Simon: Same objection as I made before.
The Court: Objection overruled.
A. There was.
I might add that I was present at most of the sit-ins that
(fol. 30] took place at the dime store and restaurants—
Mr. Simon: I object. It is immaterial and irrelevant to
describe prior matters not involving these defendants.
The Court: Objection sustained. =
Q. What else did you do there at that time, Mr Messer?
A. I did nothing other than keeping people from enter-
ing the bus station that had no business there. In other
words, they were not travelers, they were not going in
to buy a ticket, they were not going in to take a bus.
Q. Would you say the peace was maintained at that time?
A. Absolutely.
Q. Did you at any other time on this day see these ten
defendants? -
A. Yes. I saw them at the Tallahassee Municipal Air-
port that afternoon.
Q. At about what time, please, sir?
A. I would judge about around 4:00 o’clock.
Q. Wat were the circumstances at that time, Mr. Mes-
ser?
A. I received a telephone call I believe from you in
which you suggested—
Mr. Simon: I object. That is hearsay evidence.
[fol. 31] The Court: The statement was you received a
telegram?
The Witness: I received a telephone call and in response
to that call went out there. :
The Court: You can testify as to what you did in
response but not what the call was.
The objection is overruled.
A. I was taken out there. I believe the Chief of Police,
Mr. Stoutamire, took me.
Q. This was Thursday afternoon, June 15th?
A. Yes.
Q. What were the circumstances in attendance at that
time?
’
13
A. Well, it appears that the defendants who ate or
finished eating about 2:20 or I judge around 2:20 went out
to the airport and wanted to eat again.
Q. And were these ten defendants there at that particu-
lar time when you arrived there?
A. Yes.
Q. Were the other three defendants that you have here-
tofore testified were not present there?
A. I don’t recall seeing them at that time, no.
Q. Were there other groups there in attendance at that
time?
(fol. 32] A. No, other than passengers at‘ the airport.
There were a number of people at the entrance to the
airport. I recall distinctly when we arrived there were
two cars that the police officers had stopped. They were
not permitted to enter the airport.
Q. Would vou say that adejuate police protection was
being provided at the airport at that time?
A. Very definitely.
Q. Were there other law enforcement agencies there
other than the Tallahassee Police Department?
A. Yes. There were members of the State Highway
Patrol and members of the Police Department of the City
of Tallahassee.
Q. Since you testified that these ten defendants were
there, where were they within the premises of the Munici-
pal Airport at that time?
A. They were seated on a bench there approximately in
the center of the lobby of the airport terminal building.
Q. Do vou know how long they had been there?
A. No, I don’t. They hadn't beens there too long because
I saw them leave the bus terminal. I would judge that
they were tiere approximately an hour or an hour and a
half, about an hour and a half.
Q. Did you see them later on June 15th, 1961?
[fol. 33) A. LT staved out to the airport until about 5:10.
Q. Do you know whether or not any scheduled airplanes
helonging to the two airlines that have facilities here,
whether any of them had departed the airport after these
defendants arrived?
~
14
A. No—let me state this: There was a much larger group
of these—I identify them as Freedom Riders—at the bus
terminal than there were at the airport when | arrived.
I arrived—it was the departure of the three twenty-five
Eastern Airlines plane. Whether they took off on that or
not, that is something I can’t testify to.
Q. Did you see them any further on June 15th?
A. Not after leaving the airpo®. shortly after 5:00
o'clock. — ° -
®. Did you see these ten defendants or these 13 defen-
dants on June 16th, 1961?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. Under what circumstances and at approximately what
time, Mr. Messer?
A. I arrived at the airport at approximately, I would
say, between 12:15 and 12 :20—
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, I move to strike the
answer on the grounds that it is just not responsive to the
question. Of course, I don’t know how the answer could
[fol. 34] have been made responsive fd the question because
the question was “These ten or these 13 defendants, did you
see them?” I don’t know how he could answer that question
just plain “Yes.”
The Court: The question was whether or not he had
seen these ten defendants or, rather, these 13 defendants
on the 16th.
~ Mr. Simon: Yes, sir. Which is it? IT think the record
is entitled to show whether he saw the ten or the 13 defen-
dants.
The Court: He corrected the ten and said 13, T believe.
Mr. Simon: Is that a correction?
A. Let me clarify it.
The Court: Clarify the question first. You asked him
about ten defendants or 13?
Mr. Hill: Lasked him about 13.
The Court: Now answer the question.
A. I do not recall seeing a defendant by the name of
Hunter. I don’t recognize him. I did see Priscilla Stephens
ee)
15
and I did see the defendant Jeff Poland. They were in
the lobby of the airport terminal building.
Q. Are those two persons that you have just named in
distinction from the other Freedom Riders as you have
referred to them? Are they additional people that you saw
{fol. 35] on the 16th from the ones you left there on the
evening of the 15th?
A. Yes. They could have been there but I didn’t see
them. . ; as
Q. But they were there on the 16th? -
A. Yes. 3 Pe
Q. What time did you say you ayxived there, Mr. Messer?
A, I arrived there at approxithately eithet—I would say
between 11:15 and 11:20. Waita minute. I begyour pardon.
That is 12:15. © rie
Q. I believe vou heretofore testified that you are a police
officer of the City of Tallahasgee and Were such on this
date? - :
A. That’s correct. * 4 47. |
Q. What did you do then+with respect to these 13 defen-
dants?
A. I went /into the city office at the airport and after
conferring with the Mayor and the City Manager. and the.
Chief of Police-4T believe there was also a representative
of National Airlines from the office of .the airport man-
ager’s that the City has out there—I went out into the lobby
to ascertain the number of persons’ assembled there or the
identity of the persons assembled and went into the Men’s
Room. Then I came by the telephone booths which gre
in a corridor there and then went by—returned back by
{fol. 36] the telephone booths to ascertain there were no
persons in there and then I went back to the office of the
airport manager and following that, accompanied by the
Chief of the Police Department of the City of Tallahassee '
and Officer Bennett, [ believe it is Lieutenant Bennett, f
read to those assembled in the 'ebby, the defendant: here
(indicating) and—I believe Priscilla Stephens was there
at that time I approached Jeff Poland who was there—I
read to them the proclamation and requested them to dis-
perse. °
"
SS
16
Q. Did you identify yourself?
A. I first—the first thing I did was to inquire as to who
was the leader of their group. A person stood up and
identified himself as the Reverend James W. Collier. I
said, “I want to identify myself.” I said, “1 am—my name
is James Messer, Jr. I am City Attorney and a police
officer of the City of Tallahassee.”
I then took from my pocket a police badge. I said, “This
is evidence of my authority. I am going to read to you a
proclamation.”
Q. Did he attend to the reading of this proclamation?
A. He did. He stood up. I read to him the proclamation.
I have a copy of the proclamation here (indicating)
which I read to him with some additions [ made which I can
| fol. 37] deseribe to the Court.
Q. Will vou tell us what vou said?
A. In the proclamation I said, “My name is—”
Mr. Simon: I object to the witness reading from any
document which is not in evidence.
The Court: Those are notes you used at the time, Mr.
Messer?
The Witness: Yes, This is a blank form which was filled
out just prior to my reading it to the group assembled at
the terminal. °
The Court: You may testify from it-if vou like.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, I respectfully repre-
sent that a witness is required to testify from memory
without the aid of notes unless it can be established that
his memory is faulty. If he is going to read a document
the document should be in evidence for the benefit of the
Court.
The Court* *If the witness made notes prior to an act and
used those notes in the course of this act and retains those
notes for the purpose of perfeetion and brevity he is al-
lowed to read it into the record as a part of the testimony,
Go ahead.
A. The proclamation that T read is as follows: “My name
is James Messer, Jr. | am City Attorney and a special
netics olesk of the City of Tallahassee. T am advised that
[fol. 88]/ vour assembly here will tend to create a disturb-
17
ance or incite a riot or disorderly conduct within the City
of Tallahassee,” and at that point I added, “at the Munici-
pal Airport of the City of Tallahassee.”
Then I also added that pursuant to an act of the legis-
lature we had police jurisdiction over the property owned
and operated by the City of Tallahassee even though lo-
cated outside of its corporate limits. I also mentioned the
incidents which the defendants were familiar with which
occurred the nighf before and that we had good reason to
believe that even-a more substantial number of persons
were present at the airport that night.
Then I continued: “Therefore, as a special police officer
of the City of Tallahassee and in the name of the State of
Florida and the City of Tallahassee I command all of you
who are here assembled immediately and peaceably to dis-
perse.” I there added, “And that means from the airport
property of the City of Tallahassee.” I continued: “If you
not immediately and peaceably disperse I shall cause
be arrested for unlawful assembly.”
Q.‘Did the Reverend Collier you were speaking to as
spokesinan for these defendants and all of them, did he
hear what you said and did he attend and did he respond?
A. I might state that I gave—I concluded by saying,
“T will give you 15 seconds to disperse.”
{fol.39] Reverend Collier who was standing said, “But
we are interstate passengers.” I replied to him in the
presence of all of the defendants, possibly with the excep-
tion of Poland and Huntee and Priscilla Stephens, that “I
did not consider you a bona fide interstate passenger. You
made and cancelled at least three airline reservations.”
Actually I waited until about a minute, between a minute
and a quarter and a minute and a half, and then» turned
to the Chief of Police who was standing on my right and
remarked to him, I said, “Chief, you can earry out your
orders.”
Q. During the time that you were discussing with the
spokesman that you didn't consider them to be interstate
passengers and the conversation between you did they have
time to respond to vour request?
A. Yes. There was some—for instance, there was a per-
son in the audience there, Dan Speed, when I got about
18
two-thirds through with the proclamation he headed for the
door and there were two young boys, negro boys, follow-
ing him.
Just as I finished the proclamation or maybe shortly
afterwards he came back and said to the Chief of Police
who was standing just to my right, he said, “Chief, I am
trying to get out of this thing and get out of the building,”
and he said, “they got the door blocked.” The Chief said
or turned to one of the officers present and said, “Tell Offi-
[| fol. 40] cer Kelley—” I believe he was on the door—"to
let Speed and his companions out.”
(). Did the Reverend Collier acknowledge your procla-
mation in any way}
A. Other than he saying that he was an interstate pas-
senger and he started off to say that we had no right to
order his removal from the airport. I .replied to him, I
said, “I don't intend to argue with you.’
Q. Did he disperse or refuse to ‘disperse?
A. He sat down and as I recall opened his newspaper and
started reading from it.
Q. Did the other members of the group, the ones for
whom he was the spokesman, did they respond to your
proclamation? .
A. I did not see—
Q. In short, did they leave?
A. No, they did not.
Let me clarify that: I did not see in the group arrested
the defendant Jeff Poland. I don’t know where he was,
nor did I see Priscilla Stephens that was taken into custody
inside of the terminal, the lobby of the airport terminal.
Q. You say they did disperse, those two?
A. I don't know. Frankly, I was reading and I did see
Dan Speed disperse and the two rather young boys that
were with him. I say “young boys’’—they looked like they
| fol. 41] were around 19 or 18.
Q. Did you then see Lieutenant Bennett place these de-
fendants under arrest?
A. Yes. Lieutenant Bennett said, “You are all under
arrest,” and he immediately got up and some had baggage
with them and some didn’t and they were escorted out to
the police cars outside of the terminal.
; 19
Mr. Hill: I have no further questions.
Mr. Simon: May I have about two minutes to confer
with my associate? .
The Court: The Court will take about a five minute
recess.
‘
(A short recess was taken.)
The Court: Call your next witness.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, we reserve the right
of cross examination.
The Court: Excuse me. J am sorry. I overlooked that.
Go right a d
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Mr. Messer, other than the reading of the proclama-
_ which you have previously identified did you have any
Onversation with any of the 13 defendants?
A. Not prior to their arrest.
Q. Did you have any conversations at all during the
{fol. 42] 15th and 16th of June with the representatives or
personnel of the Federal Bureau of Investigation?
A. No, I did not.
Q. Did you during the same period have any conversa-
tions with any United States Marshals?
A. I did not.
Q. During the same period did you have any conversa-
tions with the Governor of the State of Florida or any
representatives of his office?
A. Yes. I had two conversations by telephone with the
Governor of the State of Florida on Friday, June 16th.
Q. Was that prior to the arrest?
A. That was prior to the arrests. , .
Q. What was the substance of that conversation?
A. I was in the—
Mr. Hill: I object to that. It is hearsay.
Mr. Messer: This is cross examination.
Mr. Hill: It is not cross examination. I didn’t bring that
20
up on direct examination, any conversations with the Gov-
ernor.
Mr. Simon: | propose the witness act as a witness and
not to instruct you as to what objections to make to the
questions.
The Court: If you have an objection, Mr. Simon, address
(fol. 48] it to the Court. Mr. Hill has objected to a tele-
phone conversation as being hearsay.
Is that vour objection, Mr. Hill?
Mr. Hill: 1 will withdraw it.
Go ahead.
The Court: The objection is withdrawn. Proceed.
A. 1 was at a conference in the City Manager’s Office
along with other members of the City Commission and the
Governor called me on the telephone and as he started the
conversation he said, “Excuse me.”’ He said, “The Attorney
General of the United States is on another line and | will
eall you back.”
The second time he called—do you want the substance
of that conversation?
Q. Yes, sir.
A. This was at approximately—because I looked at my
watch—approximately three or four minutes after 10:00.
Q. This is on Friday, June 16th?
A. This is on Friday, June 16th.
Q). In the morning? : }
A. Inthe morning. “J
He stated that he talked with the Attorney General and
that the Attorney General had stated that during the next
two hours he would endeavor to get in contact with the
defendants and the leader of the group of the defendants at
fol. 44] the Munieipal Airport and ask them to cease their
activities in Tallahassee and to leave and he suggested
that we withhold any action during that two hour period.
(). Was that the end of the conversation?
A. I might add at that time Commissioner William Mayo
came into the conference. He was not there when we first
started. He verified the conversation that I had with the
Governor, the fact that he was there when the Governor
had talked to me and he talked with the Attorney General.~
( 21
Whether he heard any conversation between the Govy-
ernor and the Attorney General | don’t know because it
was then agreed—at least | was requested to be back
by quarter of 12:00 in the morning, Friday, the 16th, in
the City Manager's Office.
Q. You were requested by the City Manager?
A. The City Manager and the Mayor. .
Q. At the time that vou read your proclamation did you
see the defendant Poland seated in the terminal at the
airport?
A. As I reeall Poland was standing but he was in the
group. Now, that was the time that | went out into the lobby
prior to reading the proclamation.
Q. Do you know whether or not the defendant Poland
obeyed the statement you made to leave the terminal?
A. Frankly, Mr. Simon, I don’t knew. | did not see
Poland when the oflicers placed those seated in the lobby
| fol. 45] under arrest. .
Q. So, then, vou don’t know whether he obeyed or dis-
obeyed vour statement?
A. No, 1 donot, frankly.
Q. With regard to the defendant Priscilla Stephens, do
you know whether she obeved vour statement to her?
A. {| did not see her taken into custody in the lobby.
Q. Then you don’t know whether she even heard your
statement?
A. Ydon’t know whether she heard all of it or not.
Q. You don’t know whether or not she obeyed or dis-
obeved it?
A. No. Frankly, when I finished reading I was looking
at the paper and I don’t know whether shejleft. I did see
Dan Speed and these two boys take off and she may have
done that and Poland may have done that, I ust don’t know.
1 did see Priscilla Stephens outside in the entrance to
the airport while the defendants were taken into custody
or arrested and observed her activities out there.
Q. With regard to the defendant Charles A. Hunter, do
vou know whether he heard the proclamation that you
read to the group?
A. J don't believe T can identify Hunter. If he is pres-
22
ent, if you will have him stand, | will see if 1 can identify
[fol. 46} him.
. You don’t know whether he obeyed or disobeyed your
statement?
A. 1 don’t know the names of these various defendants.
I mean, | couldn’t call them by name. | can identify those
that were there and did not obey. Which one is Hunter
here (indicating) | couldn't say.
Q. You stated that there were two hours in which the
defendants were to be given time to cease their activities,
is that correct?
A. No. | was advised by the Governor that the Attorney
General had asked for two hours in which to contact the
defendants or their leader.. In other words, the request
from the Governor was that no action be taken during that
time.
Q. What activities of the defendants were mentioned?
A. Mentioned by the Governor?
Q. Yes, sir.
A. Their presence out at the Municipal Airport, making
reservations and cancelling them and just sitting there.
Q. Did | understand you to say in your testimony, sir,
that somebody wanted to leave the terminal and wasn’t
able to?
A. Dan Speed whom | have known for vears who is
seated over there (indicating) was present when I walked
up to the group and started to read the proclamation or
(fol. 47] order of dispersal and as | started reading it he
left very hurriedly accompanied by two young boys, | would
judge they were around 19 or something like that.
After I had finished the proclamation he came back to
the Chief of Police who was standing about favo or three
feet to my right and said, “Chief, I tried to get out of the
door and the officer won't let me out.”
Q. Who said that?
A. Speed, Dan Speed.
The Chief immediately turned to another officer and
said, “Ask Officer Kelley to let Dan Speed and his com-
panions out.”
(). Was there a cordon thrown around the airport for
the purpose of preventing people from leaving?
23
A. I think there was—the purpose was preventing people
from entering as well as leaving. I didn’t know they were
going to prevent them from leaving but apparently the
officer on duty did aot immediately permit people to leave.
[ think the principal thing was to prevent persons from
coming in there who had no business in there, | mean air-
port business.
Q. Do you know whether all e¢ the facilities 0° the ter-
minal were in operation on the 15th and i6ti of June?
A. What facilities do you have reference to?
Q. All of them.
[fol.48] A. Well, of course, there are a lot of facilities
out there. There are radio communication facilities, restau-
rant facilities, rest rooms. I assume you have reference
to the restaurant or cafe?
Q. I] am not asking you to make any assumptions, Mr.
Messer. | am interested in whether vou know whether or
not all of the facilities at the airport were in operation
during these two days, the 15th and 16th of June.
A. You mean facilities open to the public?
Q. Yes.
A. The restaurant on the 15th and 16th during the time
that | was there was closed. The ticket counters of the air-
lines appeared to be opens The car rental service was open.
The rest rooms were open. The telephone booths were avail-
able and as far as | know the airlines were functioning
normally in their customary operation.
Q). Were you present at a conversation in which the
person in charge of the restaurant was instructed to close
the restaurant?
A. No, I was not.
Q. Do vou know who was?
A. No, I don't. 1 don’t even know who the manager or
the person in charge of the restaurant is.
Q. You did know that such a conference had taken place
[ foi. 49] though, did vou not?
A. No. The only information I had was at,the bus
terminal station someone told me that a group Was going
to take the 3:25 plane, | believe it is an Eastern plang, to
Atlanta for connections in New York. >
24
The-Court: The question was whether or not you knew
about any order to close the restaurant facilities. ls that
right?
Mr. Simon: I believe so, ves, sir.
The Court: Answer it.
A. I knew of no order being given, no.
Q. You were about to tell us that information concern-
ing such an order had come to you at the bus terminal, is
that correct?
A. No. There was no order—
Mr. Hill: Just a minute. I object at this time as being
improper cross examination and I withdrew an objection
just a little while ago for the benefit of Mr. Simon and
now he is going far afield. If 1 am not mistaken he has
issued a subpoena for someone in connection with the
restaurant facilities who I assume he is interested in hav-
ing testify. .
I did not examine Mr. Messer on direct examination
relative to anv restaurant facilities. | merely interrogated
him directly relative to the conduct of these people, the
‘fol. 50} poiice protection that had been afforded them while
they were in our City, the manner in which he read his
prociamation to them at the time he did, how the arrests
were made and items of that nature.
All of this is beyond the-realm of cross examination. If
he wants to make Mr. Messer his own witness then I would
not press it.
The Court: Objection is sustained on the basis or on
the ground it is not proper cross examination, not brought
out on direct and on the further grounds that any con-
versation he had about any such order would be hearsay
ahd not quite proper.
Mr. Simon: Then at this time we will reserve the right
to eall Mr. Messer as an adverse witness as being one of
the officers of the plaintiff.
The Court: You can eall him as a witness. You will have
to establish his adversity at the time.
Q. You stated, Mr. Witness, that vou had » proclamation
in your hand that vou read to these Freedom Riders, is
that correct?
A. Yes, that’s correct.
Q. May | see it, please?
A. Let me explain that that is the entire statement that
was read (handing document to Mr. Simon). There was
other matters mentioned which I testified to.
Mr. Simon: May I ask the Court Reporter to have this
identified as Defendants’ Exhibit “1-A” for ide: tification?
{fol.51] The Court: I don’t know about introGucing any
document on cross examination.
Mr. Simon: I haven’t introduced it. I want to have it
marked for identification so that if we do offer it at the
time of our case in chief it will be recognized as being the
same document that was delivered to us.
The Court: All right, so admitted for purposes of iden-
tification.
(Proclamation referred to was marked Defendants’ Ex-
hibit “1-A” for identification. )
(). Mr. Messer, is this one of a number of similar docu-
ments that were prepared?
A. Yes. Those were prepared séme days prior to the
arrival of the defendants in the City. As a matter of fact,
they were prepared during the session of the legislature.
Q. That would be sometime during the month of May,
1961?
A. Yes.
The Court: Any further questions, Mr. Simon?
Mr. Simon: Just a moment, if Your Honor please.
We have no further questions.
The Court: Any redirect, Mr. Hill?
Mr. Hill: Yes.
[ fol. 52] Redirect examination.
By Mr. Hill:
Q. Mr. Messer, vou indicated in response to some of Mr.
Simon's questions on cross examination that there was a
door at which Dan Speed was not a'lowed out. How far
was that door from where vou were standing and talkidg
to this group? ;
26
A. I would say about possibly 40, maybe 50 feet. It was
one of the doors to the entrance to the airport.
Q. Did these defendants here (indicating) make any move
to go towards that door to your knowledge other than what
you already stated?
A. I cannot testify that Priscilla Stephens did not at-
tempt to leave.
Q. I am asking you, the fact that you have testified that
Dan Speed said that he couldn’t get out of that door, was
that door barred to these ten defendants that you have re-
ferred to excluding Poland, Stephens and Hunter?
A. Not that I know of because they sat down. They just
remained seated and more or less turned their backs on me.
Q. Is your answer that that door did not exclude them
from leaving?
A. If they had gotten up to leave they would have been
permitted to leave:
.
Mr. Hill: I have no further questions.
[fol. 53} The Court: Call your next witness.
(Witness excused.)
Thereupon, Pavt Cannepy, called as a witness by the
plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn, was examined
and testified on his oath as follows:
Direct examination.
a
By Mr. Hill:
Q. Mr. Cannedy, this air conditioner is making a little
noise. We will all have to hear you. Speak loud.
Will you state vour name for the record?
A. Paul Cannedy.
Q. How old are you?
A. 41.
Q. Do you live in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida?
A. Yes, sir. .
Q. What is your occupation?
A. Station manager, Eastern Airlines. ,
@ 27
Q. Were you the station manager for the Eastern Air-
lines on the 15th and 16th days of June, ‘961?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 54] Q. Where are you stationed?
A. Taliahassee Municipal Airport.
Q. Do you know whether or not you had a block of 18
reservations to leave on your Flight 268 to leave on June—
Mr. Simon: I object. ‘He is leading the witness.
The Court: He asked him whether or not he knew.
Mr. Hill: I asked him did he have a block of tickets.
The Court: Answer the question yes or no.
A. Yes, sir, I knew it.
Q. You did have such a block of tickets?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What happened to that block of seat reservations or
tickets?
A. The reservations were held in good faith, booked
by our New York office. The parties that held the reserva-
tions checked in at normal check-in time and just a few
minutes before scheduled flight—
Q. On what date?
A. On the 15th, the afternoon of the 15th, Thursday
afternoon.
A few minutes prior to flight departure eight of the
gentlemen elected to ride and ten of the parties cancelled
their reservations.
[fol.55] Q. Could you tell us the names of the ten parties
who cancelled?
A. Yes, sir. I think I have ali of those here (indicating).
Just a moment, please.
(After examining records) The gentlemen that cancelled
are Brown, Collier, Dresner, Freedman, Hartmire—
Mr. Simon: Wanld you spell that, please?
The Witness: <H-a-r-t-m-i-r-e. That is what.is on the
eard.
Q.-@@uld that be Hartmire or are you reading from some-
body’. notes?
A. I am reading from the teletyped copies as it was re-
ceived from our printer. It says H-a-r-t-m-i-n-e. That is
the way it came off the printer.
28
Q. What are the initials that precede that nam?
A. M.
(Continuing) —Hardge, Roy—we had two parties of
Smith, one had been previously cancelled as I recall from
the reegrd—Warner and Stone.
Q. Mr. Cannedy, are you reading all 18 of those reserva-
tions?
A. No. I am just reading the names of those that did
not ride.
Mr. Hill: May I ask the Court Reporter to check those
(fol. 56] or read those back to me, please, sir?
Q. That did not ride?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Hill: May Ihave that?
The Court: Yes, sir.
Read that back ( addressing the Reporter).
(That portion of the record referred to was read back
by the Reporter.) 4
Q. Mr. Cannedy, that is nine. Were there any other
cancellations out of that 18? Did you read the name Me-
Kinney?
A. What?
Q. McKinney, M-ce-K-i-n-n-e-y.
A. There was 17 on one reservation and another one to
make it 18. — |
(After examining documents) No, sir, I don’t see a Me-
Kinney in this reservation here. The reservations that we
had bodked ‘originally by the New York office do not show
a McKinney in the names. a
Q. All right. You said eight rode and ten did not?
A. Yes, sir, eight rode and ten did not because we held
a block booking of 18 reservations.
Mr. Hill: Just a moment, please, Your Honor (examin-
ing ducument).
Q. Mr. Cannedy, how soon before departure time of your
(fol. 57} flight that you just referred to were those cancel-
lations made?
Ot
A
{
|
sk
Oui
|
ef
“~)
29
A. It was some seven or eight minutes. It wasn’t too
long before scheduled departure.
Q. Was this time for you to notify any stand-bys?
A. We had some stand-bys which we were able to clear,
yes, sir. :
Q. Did those ten that youshave referred to make further
reservations on your airlines? -
AY Yes, sir, they did. |
Q. W).ich reservations and when were they?
A. Gur records indicate that after departure of Flight
268 on Whursday, the 15th, these gentlemen requested space
for Flight 954 on the morning of the 16th which was Fri-
day, scheduled to depart Tallahassee at 8:30 a.m.
At the time that they made the request we were unable
to-confirm the group booking of ten and we assured them
we would attempt to get the space cleared and at the same
time we booked the same space for Flight 954 on the 17
which is Saturday morning as protection until we could get
the space cleared for them on the flight they wanted on
Saturday morning.
Q. When you say “one seven” is that airline language
for the 17th?
A. Yes, sir. ©
[fol. 58] Q. What were the names of the passengers you
booked for Flight 954 on Friday, the 16th and on the 17th?
A. Our records on a group booking of this kind, we gen-
erally as far as the records are concerned on a block book-
ing to start with, the group as originally booked by New
York was called the Alstock group and our reservations
agents used the same name in our original booking for the
block booking, Alstock group.
Q. Can you answer my question?
A. At a later time we changed the card then to show
the names of the gentlemen that we actually had on the
flight at a later time.
Q. That is 954 on the 16th?
A. 954 on the 16th and 954 on the 17th was requested
on the afternoon of the 15th after the departure of Flight
268.
Q. When you say 954 you are referring to one of your
flight numbers?
30
A. Yes, sir. :
Q. Would you give me the names of those reservations,
please, sir? ”
A. At 9:35—let me back up just a minute. At about 6:30
on the afternoon of the 15th we were able to confirm five of
the original requests for ten and our agent Frizen con-
tacted Mr. Freedman and advised him at that time that we
[fol. 59] had five seats confirmed and he instructed Mr.
Frizen at that time that they did not want the five seats
unless they could clear all ten of them on the same flight.
We told him we feit sure that we could clear it a little bit
later on if they could jrive us a little bit more time to work
on it. At approximately 8:35 p.m. on the 15th we got the
balance of the seats confirmed making a complete party
of ten. é
Q. Will you give me the names of those ten, please, sir?
A. Yes, sir. Our records indicate that we held at 8:35
p.m. on the 15th the reservations for M. Brown, J. Collier,
I. Dresner, M. Freedman, W. Hartmine, R. Stone, A.
Warner, L. Roy, A. Hardge, and A. Smith.
I might clarify one point here: That eight of this party
had requested continuing space to New York, Hardge and
Smith desiring to deplane in Washington but requesting
space from Tallahassee to Atlanta all on the same flight
preferring the same space together on a specific flight from
Atlanta to New York which would stop in: Washington
where Hardge and Smith could deplane and the balance
of the party proceed to New York. nf
Q. What*happened to those reservations, Mr. Cannedy?
A. At 8:35 P.M. when we confirmed the space to Mr.
Freedman we asked him if we could have the tickets for the
group to be reissued because there was a fare differential
(fol. 60] in the tickets from the space they had rebooked
because their original reservations called for a tourist
flight connection out of Atlanta and the flight on which they
were rebooked was a first class fare flight which meant we
had to collect an additional amount of money on each
ticket.
We were instructed at that time that they did not want
to give us their tickets at that time but would wait until
the next morning.
31
Q. What was the date of the next morning?
A. The next morning would be the 16th.
The following morning on the 16th these reservations, all
ten of them were cancelled at OS15,
Q. All right. Did you have time to notify stand-bys. in
that instance? :
A. We had no stand-bys for that particular flight because
everything had cleared up.
Q. Then on each of the flights that you have referred to
this party of ten remained and you had available seating
space and airlines in the air, is that correct?
A. Yes, sir. The flights on the morning of the 16th had
space available for this party, yes, sir, out of Tallahassee.
Q. And the afternoon of the 15th?
A. On the afternoon of the 15th, yes, sir, space was avail-
able for this party.
[fol.61] Q. I believe that you testified that you spoke to
a spokesman named Freedman?
A. I did not converse with him. The counter agents
handle most of the transactions and they did all the work.
Mr. Simon: ‘then I move to strike the testimony of the
witness relating to his conversation with the defendant
Freedman on the ground the same is hearsay.
The Court: Objection sustained.
Q. Did you see your agent discussing these reservations
with any of this group?
A. ¥es, sir, I did. I had occasions several times to see
them discussing it across the counter at various times with
various members of the group, yes, sir.
'Q. In your position as station manager you were aware
of what was taking place, that they were making these
reservations?
A. Yes, sir, that is my responsibility.
Mr. Hill: No further questions.
32
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Is your name Cannedy?
A. Yes, sir, C-a-n-n-e-d-y, Paul J.
Q. I understand your position is station manager here
in Tallahassee?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where do you work?
[fol.62] <A. Tallahassee Municipal Airport, Eastern facili-
ties.
Q. How long have you had this job?
A. I have been in Tallahassee since October, 1947. I
have been station manager for Eastern in this City since
June of 1948.
Q. Do you work at the Tallahassee terminal?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Am I correct in assuming that the terminal at which
you presently work is not the terminal at which you worked
some months ago?
A. That’s correct, yes, sir. We worked the old airport
and moved thisspring, that’s correct.
Q. This iy a new air terminal?
A. Yes, sit, that’s correct.
Q. How long have you worked this new air terminal?
A. We moved\in, I believe it was the 30th of March if
I remember correetly. It was right in that particular period
of 1961.
Q. How many days a week do you work?
A. I am scheduled to—as far as my time is concerned
I am on duty 24 hours a day seven days a week. I am on
duty whenever I am available. Normally I put in five to
six eight to nine hour days’ per week. That is my normal
work schedule.
Q. This 40 to 50 hour work week is spent at the airline
[fol. 63] terminal?
A. Yes, sir, in our facilities at the airport, yes, sir, that’s
correct.
Q. Are you familiar with the airline terminal?
A. Yes, sir.
' «88
Q. Can you, generally speaking, describe the airline ter-
minal for the purposes of this record so that we would
know what it looks like, what facilities aie available for
interstate passengers and so forth?
A. The terminal building itself, as you approach it from
the City, faces east. As you enter the building from the
east side’ of the terminal there are three entrances that
can be used on the east side and one on the north end of the
lobby space and as you enter these areas you approach
either the Hertz or Avis car rental facilities and then the
Eastern Airlines ticket counter facilities and then the Na-
tional Airlines ticket facilittes and then there is a blank
counter space which was built in for future expansion.
When you enter the building that area is to the right off
of the main lobby. The ticket lobby space is away from the
main lobby space off to the right.
Q. At the present time there are just two airlines having
space in this terminal?
A. That's correct, ves, sir.
[fol. 44] Q. That is Eastern Airlines and National Air-
lines?
A. That’s correct.
~ Q. Both of these airlines are interstate carriers?
A. Yes, sir, that’s correct. The main lobby thea is di-
rectly ahead and to your left as yeu enter the main doors
of the terminal building. There is considerable seating
space in the main lobby area.
The dining room area is on beyond the left of that which
is—it has a glass enclosure going into it.
Q. Did you say dining room area or areas?
. A. Dining room areas. There is two dining room areas,
two dining areas. The Savarin Restaurant area, the main
dining room of the terminal, is on this area.
Q. You say the Savarin Restaurant is a glass enclosed
area?
A. It controls the whole dining facilities, the whole ter-
minal.
Q. What is the other area?
A. There is a small counter space off to the—as you go
into the terminal and turn to your left it would be off to
34 *
your left. There is a small counter there that is set up for
colored eating facilities.
Q. Is it so designated?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol.65] Q. Go ahead.
A. As you enter the terminal building, on vour left, be-
fore you proceed directly through the terminal to the load-
ing finger you have telephone booths on your right as you
turn left, then on your left you have your rest room facili-
ties.
(y. How many rest room facilities are there?
A. Four. First is designated White Ladies, White Men;
then as you turn aroundsa little aleove—I don’t remember
the exact order but it is Colored Ladies and Colored Men
on the other side,
Q. Did you also indicate that there were two waiting
room areas?
A. There is, ves, sir,
(). How are they located with regard to each other?
A, The main waiting room is as you enter directly to
your left. Then the area designated as the colored waiting
room is just off to the left of that as vou turn to your left,
it would be on your left again back: by the small lunch
counter.
Q. Are these facilities which you described utilized for
and by the passengers of your company and National Air-
lines?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are all of these rest rooms and waiting rooms and
eat facilities housed under one roof?
[fol.66] <A. Yes, sir.
Q. Would you say that they are an integral part of the
air terminal itself?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is the ticket office opened 24 hours a day?
A. No, sir, the ticket office is not opened 24 hours a day.
We maintain 24 hour coverage in our facilities but our
ticket office closes at 11:45 or 11:30 p.m. after our last
evening departure.
Our reservations office facilities close at that time. We
maintain one man on duty in the Operations Department
35
basically for security reasons because we have an aircraft
that remains overnight which originates for us as a flight
here the next morning. To keep fire and insurance regula-
tions valid we have to have an employee on duty around
the clock.
Q. Are you open every day?
A. Seven days a week, 24 hours a day. -
Q. Is the air terminal open every day?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are the rest room facilities available on a 24 hour
basis?
A. As faras | know they are, yes, sir.
Q. Seven days a week?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 67] Q. How about the restaurant facilities for the
interstate passengers?
A. It closes after the last departure of National’s flight
which is scheduled out about 11:30 at night. They close up
after thattime and open the next morning.
Q: At what time do they open?
A. I believe it is 7:30. I can’t say for sure. I haven’t
paid too much attention to their6pening and closing hours.
Q. Are they open every day?
A. Yes, sir, seven days a week.
Q. How about the lobby space, the waiting room space,
is that available and open every day of the week?
A. Yes, sir, it is open.
Q. On the 15th and 16th days of June did you happen—
to be working at the terminal on those days?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you notice whether or not the restaurant facili-
ties were open or closed?
A. They were open part of the day and closed part of
the day.
Q. On the 15th of June which part of the day were the
restaurant facilities open and which part of the day were
the restaurant facilities closed?
A. They were open in the morning as I recall and they
[ fol. 68] were closed about 1:00 p.m.
Q. Did they reopen?
A. On the 15th?
i 7
On the 15th.
No, sir.
Were they open en the 16th?
No, sir.
The 16th was a Friday, was it not?
That’s correct, a Friday. .
Did they open on the 17th?
I 'was out of the City on the 17th. 1 can’t answer you.
Were you at the terminal on the 18th of June?
No, sir. | was in the City of Tampa on the 18th.
. Were you at the terminal on the 19th of June?
..Monday, ves, sir. ©
Was the restaurant open on that date?
. Yes,sir.
Were you in the terminal an the 20th of June?
Yes, sir.
Was the restaurant open on that date?
Part of the day, ves, sir.
Which part of the day?
I think it closed about 3:00 p.m.
[fol. 69} Q. On the 21st day of June—
Mr. Hill: I object at this stage. We are getting into the
areas over which the issues do not portend. The Com-
plaints are framed around the dates of the 15th and 16th.
Mr. Cannedy said he was out of the City on certain other
dates. Mr. Simon is continuing on and I assume he is
going to work his way up to the present.
I contend it is improper and was not brought out on
direct examination relative to that. Mr. Cannedy was only
directly examined relative to reservations in connection with
his job as the Eastern Airlines representative. I do not
know what Mr. Simon is seeking, if the Court please.
The Court: It is kind of obvious but don’t you think vou
have carried it far enough past the 16th to establish the
pattern vou want to establish?
Mr. Simon: I think I have, yes, sir.
The Court: All right.
Per Crer Prat erererere
*Q. Mr. Cannedy, prior to the 15th day of June wasn’t
it a fact that the restaurant was open every da, from 7:30
in the morning until sometime late at night?
~
37
A. To the best of my knowledge, yes, sir.
Q. With regard to these ten people who cancelled their
reservations, were they in possession of airline tickets on
your airline?
{fot 70] A. Yes, sir. It was my knowledge they had
tickets for the flight at 3:25 on the afternoon of the 15th.
Q. That was carrying them fri m points in Florida to
points out of Florida, was it not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. To your knowledge did they ever caficel their tickets?
_ A. They did not cance! the tickets but when they cancelled
their reservations the ticket was automatically cancelled
for that particular flight.
Q. Yes, sir, but they were in possession to your knowl-
edge at all times of tickets from points in Florida to points
beyond the State of Florida, were they not?
“A. To the best of my knowledge they were, ves, sir.
Q. The first flight upon which they were booked out to
vour knowledge was Flight 268 on Thursday, June 16th at
3:45 p.m., is that correct?
A. Thursday, June 15th. “
Q. I accept the correction, Thursday, June 15th.
A. 3:25, that’s correct. Those reservations were booked
originally by our New York office on June 9th according
to the records that we have here (indicating).
Q. They were booked on a tourist flight, were they not?
(fol. 72] <A. Booked first class Tallahassee, Atlanta as we
have no tourist service through this City and they were
connecting to a tourist section of a flight from Atlanta to
New York, ves, sir. ;
Q. The other arrangements that were nisl for them
‘were first class flights from Tallahassee to the finai destina-
tion?
A. That’s correct.
Q. You were not able to afford them equivalent flight
service both first class and tourist as they had on other
flights, were you?
A. Not at the time of the day they were requesting it.
At that time, no, sir.
Q. Were you in a position during the 15th and 16th
davs of June to observe the conduct of the defendants?
38
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Can you describe how they. acted?
A. We have no complaint with their actions and*centact
with our people. They were very polite and very co-opera-
tive asking for what they wanted and how they wanted it.
& 6 « * * e . °
{fol. 79] Thereupon, Raymonp J. Lewis, called as a wit-
ness by the plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn,
was examined and testified on his eath_as follows:
=
Direct examination.
By Mr. Hill:
Q. State your name for the record, please, sir.
A. Raymond J. Lewis. . 8
Q. Do you live in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What is your business?
[fol. 80! A. Senior agent, National Airlines.
Q. Are you stationed in Tallahassee with National Air-
lines?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long have you been here as such agent?
A. Since 1948, September.
Q. How tung have you worked for this airline or any
other uirline?
A. April of 1946, all with National.
Q. So you have been with the airiines some 15 or 16
years?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were vou on duty with National Airlines on the
15th and 16th of June, 1961 in Tallahassee, Florida?
A. I was. .
Q. Were you on duty at the Municipal Airport which
is known as the Tallahassée, Municipal Airport?
A. I was on duty.
39
Q. Is that the same airport at which Mr. Cannedy works
and operates for Eastern, the gentleman who was just
here testifying?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. On the 15th, Mr. Lewis, did vou make a reservation
for ten members or a ten member group to depart your
Flight 362?
{fol.81] A. Not on the 15th. 1 believe the correct date is
the 16th.
Q. On the 16th? What day of the week was that? Was
that Friday, Friday the 16th? :
A. Friday the 16th, I believe that’s correct.
Q. Do you know the names of those people who jade
those reservations?
A. I have my records with me.
Q. Would you tell us the names of those who reserved
the flight on the 16th day of June, 1961?
A. The names | received were Dresner, Hardge, Smith,
Hartmine, Roy, Stone, Collier, Brown, Werner and Freed-
man. . :
Q. Did you talk to your passenger Smith?
A. I do not know the passengers by name.
Q. Would you give us his initials if you have them?
A. [have no initials.
Q. You do not have initials for passenger Smith?
A. No.
Q. When were these reservations made, Mr. Lewis?
A. The record I have from National Airlines shows
at 8:20 a.m. the morning of the 16th.
Q. Did these passengers hold tickets on your airlines?
A. They did not hold tickets on my airline.
Q. How did you then proceed to process these reserva-
[fol. 82] tions?
A. The passenger that contacted me was told that I
would request the space, that it would probably be avail-
able and we would contact him or he could stop by in the
next few minutes and contact us and was given until 12:00
noon on the 16th to—we would hold those reservations until
12:00 noon on the 16th for ticket reissuance and_a definite
confirmation on the reservation.
40
Q. Did-you say “ticket reissuance’’?
A. That’s correct.
Q. What is ticket reissuance, Mr. Lewis?
A. When a passenger holds a ticket on another air-
line it has to be reissued for the airline on which he is
traveling.
Q. In effect then, you swap the dollar value of the ticket
and give the man a ticket on your line and he, then, uses
your reservations and the ticket together to make the flight?
. That’s correct.
What time was this flight to leave on the 16th?
. It was scheduled to depart Tallahassee at 1:49 p.m.
Were these reservations used ?
. No, they were not.
What time were they cancelled?
Prior to 12:00 o’clock by several minutes.
[fol. 83] Q. Do you know the name of the spokesman that
you were talking to?
A. | don't know his name but I would recognize him.
Q. Would vou point him out to this group?
A. The gentleman sitting between these attorneys (in-
dicating).
POrOroDy
Mr. Simon: Let the record indicate that the witness
identified Rabbi Freedman.
Q. The man you indicated, then, he was the one who
cancelled as well as made the reservations?
A. That’s correct.
Mr. Hill: I have no further questions,
Cross examination.
Ny Mr. Simon:
Q. Mr. Lewis, did you ultimately sell tea tickets to these
ten people you just mentioned?
A. Ata later date. eo
Q. What date was that?
A. It approximately could have been Saturday the 17th.
I am not cerrect on that date. The best I can remember is
the 17th, Saturday.
TES
——
Q. You didn’t bring these records with you?
A. No, I do not have those records with me.
Q. These ten tickets were from what point to what des-
tination?
{fol. 84] A. From Tallahassee to New York City.
Mr. Simon: No further questions.
The Court: Any redirect?
Mr. Hill: No further questions.
.«.The Court: May Mr. Lewis be excused from further
attendance?’ “~""
Mr. Simon: The defendants do not object, Your Honor.
Mr. Hill: That is all right. oN
The Court: You are excused from further attendance
today. Thank you.
(Witness excused.)
Mr. Hill: May we have a minute or two recess? We have
been going since about 9 :00 o'clock.
The Court: All right. We will take one more five minute
recess.
(A short recess was taken.)
The Court: Call your next witness.
Mr. Messer: If the Court please, counsel for the de-
fense and Mr. Hill and myself representing the City con-
ferred with the defendants Jack Poland and Hunter and
we would like to move at this time to nol. pros. the cases
pending against those two defendants.
The Court: That is John Jefferson Poland, Jr.?
{fol.85] Mr. Messer: Yes, sir.
I might state for the information of the Court that they
took the same action fhat Speed did except I believe that
both of them got on the outside and possibly in the con-
fusion they were apprehended by the officers.
The Court: All right, then the defendants Hunter and
Poland, the cases are nol. pros. on motion of the City.
You are released from further custody and the charges
and bonds are cancelled.
» Mr. Hill: May we have them removed from the defen-
dants’ roll?
42
The Court: Yes.
Is the defendant Hunter in court?
(Defendant Hunter approached the bench.)
The Courf: Pid you understand the case is nol. pros.
against you, there are no charges pending?
Defendant Hunter: Thank you, sir.
The Court; Call your next witness.
{fol. 86] Thereupon, Frank Stroutamirg, called as a wit-
ness by the plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn,
was examined and testified on his oath as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Messer:
Q. Your name is Frank Stoutamire?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Mr. Stoutamire, what official position, if any, do you
occupy with the City of Tallahassee?
A. I am Chief of Police.
Q. How long have you served as Chief of Police of
the City of Tallahassee? —
A. Since September, ’53.
Q. Were you present at the Tallahassee Municipal Air-
port on the evening of Thursday, June 15th?
A. T was.
Q. What time did you arrive at ‘the Municipal Airport?
A. Possibly—I went out to the Municipal Airport on that
day about 7:00 or 7:20 that morning. I mate several trips
¥ out there during the day, some three or four trips out there
during the day.
Mr. Simon: I cannot hear you.
A. I say I made several trips out there during the
day from 7:00 o’clock to noon.
[fol. 87] Q. Mr. Stoutamire, I am referring to the night
of Thursday, June 15th.
A. On the 15th?
te a nee eee anne
43
Q. Yes, sir. '
A. I went to the airbase or airport that afternoon about
3:00 o’clock.
Q. Who accompanied you?
A. You did.
Q. Did you remain at the airport until the airport was
“closed?
A. I did.
Q. Were there any persons or groups of persons com-
ing onto the airport property in front of the airport ter-
minal in automobiles?
A. There were.
Q. Do you know approximately how many?
A. I would not be able to say how many but there was
a great many of them.
Q. Prior to the time that you became Chief of Police
of the City of Tallahassee did you hold. any position with
the State of Florida or County of Leon as a law enforce-
ment officer?
A. I served five years as Chief Deputy Sheriff of this
County and I served 30 years as Sheriff of the County.
Q. You became Sheriff after being Chief Deputy?
{fol.88] A. That’s correct.
Q. Were the defendants-here seated on this front row
present in the air terminal building during the night of
. Thursday, June 15th?
A. They were.
Q. Did any persons come into the airport other than the
defendants—
A. They did.
Q. (Continuing) —and excluding the law enforcement
officers?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did vou hear of any threats against the defendants
by am of those persons who entered the airport build-
ing?
Mr. Simon: Objection on the ground it is hearsay, Your
Honor.
Q. The defendants, I helieve you stated, were presert
in the terminal building?
44
A. They were.
The Court: Objection is overruled then.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, the building is a large
building. I feel there may be some basis for considering
the testimony of third persons if the statements are made
in the presence of the defendants but there is no testimony
as to that.
[fol. 89] The Court: I will hear you on that, Mr. Messer.
Mr. Messer: If the Court please, I am not asking the
exact language that took place but the question was whether
threats were made in the presence of the Chief of Police
when the defendants were present in the lobby.
The Court: Not that they could hear but that they were
there?
Mr. Messer: That they were there.
The Court: Why wouldn?t that be hearsay?
Mr. Messer: I think it is part of the res gestae, that it
is something that occurred in the immediate presence of the
defendants.
I would like to inquire further of the witness whether
or not they had an opportunity to hear it.
The Court: I think it would be admissible if they heard
it. I know it. would if they heard it or had an opportunity
to hear it and I feel further it would be admissible if the
purpose of such testimony is. to establish circumstances
that would tend to show the attitude, disposition or the
safety or lack of safety for the visitors, the defendants.
Q. Were any statements made in your presence in the
airport terminal building that caused apprehension on your
part for the safety of the defendants?
Mr. Simon: Same objection, Your Honor, on the ground
[fol. 90] of hearsay.
The Court: Overruled.
A. It was generally talked around the terminal that
there was possibly going to be some violence if the defen-
dants continued to stay there. I never or don’t know that
any one particular person told me they was going to do
anything but it was generally talked around.
. 45
Q. Did you advise the defendants that the airport ter-
minal would be closed down at approximately 11:45 p.m.
on the night of June 15th?
A. I did.
Q. Did any of the defendants make any request of you
in that connection?
A. J. W. Collier and Dan Speed both asked me if they
would receive protection from the airbase to the City of
Tallahassee.
Q. Did you tell them that they would receive that pro-
tection?
A. I told them that as far as the airport property was
concerned, that I had jurisdiction there but that as I under-
stood it I would not have jurisdiction from the airport
property to the city limits but at the city limits I would have
authority but that they would be protected.
They was led by one police car, one Highway Patrol car
[fol. 91] and followed by a Highway Patrol car and two
police cars to the City of Tallahassee and to their destina-
tiote where they asked me to follow them to.
Q. When you say “Highway Patrol car” vou are referring
to patrol automobiles of the Department of Public Safety of
the State of Florida?
A, That’s right.
Q. The police cars which you referred to are police cars
for the City of Tallahassee?
A. On arrival at their destination where they had asked
us to take them, they asked us then if we would give them
protection the next morning back to the airbase or airport.
We told them that we would. One Highway Patrol ear or
one car belonging to the Department of Publie Safety of
the State and one police car followed them back to the air-
port. I was in the police car that followed them to the
airbase.
Q. Mr. Stoutamire, ihe defendants had cars of their own
or cars that were provided for them, is that correct?
A. I understood that they had local people’s automobiles
here who were taking them backwards and forward.
Q. From the requests you received from Dan Speed and
Reverend J. W. Collier and from other perdgns other than
the defendants and law enforcement officers’ who entered
46
the lobby of the terminal building and those persons who,
{fol. 92] in automobiles, passed by the entrance to the ter-
minal building, did you base on your experience as a law
enforcement officer both as Sheriff of Leon County and
Chief of Police have reasonable cause to bélieve that the
continued presence of the defendants in the lobby of the
airport terminal building might precipitate a riot or cause
disorderly conduct?
Mr. Simon: Same objection, Your Honor. The witness
is being catled upon to give a conclusion.
The Court: Objection is overruled.
Mr. Simon: I would like to continue, if Your Honor
please. :
The Court: All right.
Mr. Simon: The conclusion is based upon hearsay; fur-
ther, the question is irrelevant and immaterial unless it can
be established that there was an unlawfu! assembly and
there is nothing in the evidence or in the hypothetical
question or in the question presented to this witness which
indicates the existence of an unlawful assembly so even if
there was an apprehensien of riot his concern should be
with the rioters and not the persons who were engaged in
lawful assembly.
The Court: Mr. Simon, you know as well as I know that
the law provides that a lawful assembly can become an un-
lawful assembly: when certain things occur, when certain
facts exist, and because of that law then his conclusion as
[fol. 93} a reasonable, prudent person in the community and
particularly with his vast experience make it a part of
the res gestae and &dmissible.
The objection is overruled.
Q. Mi. Stoutamire, the question was rather long but,
in effect, it was did you have reason to believe that the con-
tinued presence of the defendants at the airport building
would tend to incite a riot, cause a disturbance and dis-
orderly conduct?
Mr. Simon: Same objection based on the same grounds.
The Court: Overruled.
47
A. I did, based on the facts that on Thursday night,
what happened there then, and what the defendants re-
quested, that they be protected and that they had requested
protection the following morning back to the airport and
when I got there with the Freedom Riders they there asked
if I would give them protection while they was there.
I told them that I had other matters to attend to, thai I
wovld not be able to stay there myself during the day but
that I would leave police officers there for their protection
and that I would be in touch with those police officers by tele-
phone and by radio and if anything should exist, that those
officers wanted me to come out there, that I would be avail:
able at any time.
I also told them that the Department of Public Safety
[fol. 94] would have an automobile in that vicinity at all
times for any protection that they might need.
I saw the next morning, which was on the 16th, after this
instance I told you about, that I had taken them out to the
base and they requested help—requested protection—|
came back to town and made a trip or two out there during
the morning and each time that’ 1 would make trips out
there I would see cars and people in cars that | didn’t
see that they had anything at the airport to do unless it
was for some unlawful purpose.
Mr. Messer: Your witness.
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Chief, I believe that you stated that you went out to
the airport on several occasions on the morning of Thurs-
day, June 15th, the first one being at 7:00 o'clock and several
times thereafter?
A. No. I thought he was talking about Friday. It seems
he was speaking of Thursday. I went out there Thursday,
not Thursday merning because they only arrived here
about noon Thursday.
Q. Your testimony was inadvertently in error beeause —
you understood he was talking about F riday, not Thursday?
A. That's right...
48 >
Q. Can you tell us what was the first time or when was
the first time that vou went out to the airport?
[fol. 95) A. On Tharsday?
Q). Yes, sir.
A. About 3:00 o’clock in the afternoon.
(. Were these defendants already there?
A. They were.
Q). Did you attend a conference of any City officials or
State officials with regard to the closing of the restaurant
in the terminal?
A. I had nothing to do with the closing of the restaurant.
I was in several meetings with some of the City Commis-
sioners. | do not have anything to do with the closing
of the restaurant.
Q. Do you know who arranged for the restaurant to
he closed?
A. I do not know who made the arrangements with the
restaurant operator.
Q. Do you know whether or not it was one of the City
Commissioners or the City Manager?
A. Not that I pe -rsonally iknow, no, I don’t know. I was
not with them when there was such a request made.
Q. You do know that such a request was made, however?
A. | understood there was but I don’t know it.
(). Your testimony was that you feel you have jurisdic-
ticn over the facilities at the airport, is that correct?
(fol. 96] A. That’s right.
Q. To vour knowledge, are there people stationed on
duty at the airport all day and all night? ;
A. No, sir. 1 have a policeman that stays at the airport
during the time that*it is open. When it is closed we don’t
have a policeman there. They have a guard there when it
closes, —_
| might sav ths: It is not in reference to a question but
in many years ak/a law enforcement officer and seeing
many instances Where, in my judgment, they would be—
there would possibly be a riot, it has always been my prac-
tive, it has always been my purpose to avoid it the best
| could using my better judgment and my judgment has
always been to move the cause and protect the cause and
get them away from wheré | thought the violence might
oceur.
49
Q. Did you have the oceasion to observe these defendants
in the terminal on the times you took trips out to the ter-
minal on Thursday and Friday?
ety
Would you describe what they were doing there?
A. They was sitting on seats in the waiting room.
Q. Was that the white waiting room?
A. It was. They was using the toilets and just around
but as a usual thing they were sitting on seats.
[fol. 97] Q. Were they using the white toilets?
A. They were.
Q. What else were they doing?
A. Well, as I told you they was just in and around but
mostly they had a regular headquarters in the waiting room.
Q. Do you know from your own knowledge whether or
not these people had tickets to travel on an airliner?
A. Only that I was advised so.
Q. Do you know whether or not they were waiting to de-
part on an airplane?
A. It was my understanding that they had tickets to
ieave the airport on Friday. Tiiey cancelled, so I am told,
that reservation. ;
(). Were vou told why they cancelled_it?
A. I do not know.
Q. Do you know whether or net they had made a further
reservation?
A. I understood they made reservations then for the
following morning, some two or three reservations, and
cancelled those.
Q. Do you know whether or not at the time of the arrest
that they had a reservation to leave Tallahassee on an air-
plane?
A. As I understood it, they did not.
Ifol. 98] Q. You don’t know?
A. | don’t handle the airbase. I don’t handle tickets. 1
don’t know about that.
(). You stated that vou were w orried that if these people
continued to stay in the airport there would be violence.
A. I came to that conclusion from the people that I
saw there and things that I heard.
50
. Did you come to any conclusion as to why these par-
ticular ten people would cause other people to become
violent?
A. Yes.
Q. What conclusion did you come to?
A. I came to that conclusion because of several things.
I had read in the newspapers, | had heard on the radios
of trouble that Freedom Riders had had in otter cities
and I felt that I was using that for a basis and people I
seen in and around the airport and rumors that I would
hear, that it was necessary that we take such steps to move
the cause.
). You weren’t concerned with whether or not these peo-
ple were or were not passengers or interstate passengers
on an airliner, were you?
A. L was under the understanding that they were there,
had refused several reservations and that they was there
creating a disturbance among the local citizens here.
I based my judgment on-that and just what I would see
[fol. 99] from the general public. | also thought that from
what they had asked—when they asked for protection, I
base ‘hat on that, too.
@. Now, | understand from your testimony that it was
the locai citizens that you felt would Yecome violent.
A. I saw citizens—I mean, I saw people both at the bus
station and at the airbase that | didn’t know who they was
but mostiy it was local citizens.
(. Did you arrest any of them?
A. I did not.
). Did you arrest any of these people that vou testified
were milling around the air terminal? :
A. I did not.
Q. Did vou order them to disperse?
A. We did at the bus station. We did not—at least that
Was my instructions for them to do that at the bus station.
(). Was there any violence at the bus station?
A. | am told that there were not but I was not there.
I took my time surrounding the bus station in an automobile
just to keep my eve on what was existing and whether
there was danger or whether the®e was not so I would
have first hand information about it.
51
4
Q. How many police are there working in the City of
Tallahassee?
{fol. 100] A. [have a personnel of 75.
Q. What is the population of the City of Tallahassee?
A. A little less than 50,000.
Q. Did the Governor of this State put State Troopers at
your disposal or have them available for working with*you
for the protection of these people?
A. I don’t remember what the Governor did but I do
know the State Troopers was with me,
Q. Were they acting under your command or indepen-
dently of your command?
A. I might say this: That when we begin to get the pub-
licity and hear the publicity that the Freedom Riders was
coming here, in order to protect—both the Department of
Public Safety and my Assistant Chief anc the Captain of
the Detectives Department and the Sheriff’s Office of Leon
County all had a meeting to determine what protection we
was going to give them and it was agreed that we would
all give them protection, we did not want incidents to hap-
pen in the City of Tallahassee and in the County of Leon
that had happened in other towns.
Q. You therefore did make protection available to these
people from any abuses or excesses by the local citizens?
A. We did and in speaking to John W. Collier after the
arrest the following day he told me that—that the Police
Department has certainly been nice to him and that ga
(fol. 101] preciated the protection that we had given them. \
Q. The defendants themselves, these Freedom Riders
you mentioned, vou did not see them actually creating a
disturbance themselves, did you?
A. I did not.
Q. Lam sorry?
A. I did not.
Q. How long have vou lived here in Tallahassee?
A. I was born and raised in this County.
Q. Then I won't ask you how long ago that was.
A. I don’t mind telling that either. ' am 70 vears old.
Q. That is wonderful.
Mr. Stoutamire, ean vou from your experience as a public
officer and as an individual who ha- studied people in this
o
ee
area for 70 years tell us what there was.in the fact that
these ten people were sitting in the municipal términal in
Tallahassee that would cause people in this County. and in
this City to become upset and riotous and to act in an
illegal and unlawful manner? E
A. As I stated before the publicity that had beer in the
newspapers and on radios prior tc them coming to Talla-
hassee about what had happened in other towns, the news-
papers and radios that was giving the information that they
[fol. 102] would be here at a certain“time, people in my
opinion in the City and in the eae was somewhat en-
raged about the fact that they wére coming. Therefore,
for that reason I felt that it was Necessary to give them
proper protection because I did not want to have any in-
stances in this City that had happened in other cities. _
Mr. Simon: We have no further questions.
_ Redirect examination. \_
By Mr. Messer:
Q. Mr. Stoutamire, just to clear the record on one mat-
ter, I believe you went out to the airport the first time
around 3:30 on June 15th. That was the time I accom-
panied you, is that correct?
A. That was the time I went—yes.
Q. Then the times you were there, several times during
the morning, and, of course, you were there that night, that
evening as you testified—
A. That’s right.
Q. (Continuing) —then were you in the group that es-
corted them, the defendants, to the airport that morning?
A. I was.
Q. Mr. Stoutamire, did you have any reason or informa-
tion to the effect that on the night of Friday, June 16th
that there would be a very substantial group of people com-
ing to the airtport from places other than the City of Tal-
lahassee?
Mr. Simon: I object on the grounds it is not proper re-
(fol. 103] direct; it is leading and necessarily based on
hearsay and a conclusion of the witness.
53
The Court: Objection sustained on the basis that it is not
proper redirect.
Q. Did you have any reason to believe that if the defen-
dants had been permitted to remain at the airport terminal
subsequent to their arrest and | am referring particularly
to the night hours that there might have been some vio-
lence?
Mr. Simon: Same objection and a further objection that
this is bevond the scope of the charges that are’ involved
here because it is referring to a time that took place be-
yond the hours of the arrest and it is clearly not within
the seope of redirect examination.
The Court: Objection sustained.
Mr. Messer: Let me make this one point and I Ao it very
respectfully: It is like a police officer taking a jun away
from a man and somebody contending that he ought to have_
waited until he let the man shoot somebody with the gun/’
The point I am making is that I think it is proper as
part.of his opinion thet their presence there constituted
a menace or might ténd to incite a riot.
The Court: I understand the purpose of it but you ex-
plored that on direct examination and on redirect I don’t
think it would be proper to explore it further. For that
| fol. 104] reason the objection is sustained.
Mr. Messer: I have no further questions.
Mr. Simon: Could I ask the Court to inquire of Chief
Stoutamire if the witness subpoena that we have asked the
police to serve has been taken care of?
The Court: Do you know yet about that?
The Witness: Maybe I can find out.
(Diseussion off the record. )
Mr. Simon: Would Your Honor ask him to do that and
report back to the Court?
The Court: We will do that.
Is there any reason why the Chief can’t be excused from
further attendance?
Mr. Simon: No, sir.
The Court: All right.
(Witness excused.)
The Court :) Call your next witness.
54
[fol. 105] Thereupon, James F. Bennett, called as a wit-
ness by the plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn,
was examined and testified on his oath as follows:
Direct examination.
\
By Mr. Hill:
Will you state your name for the record, please?
James Bennett.
Are you also known as Billy Bennett?
¥es, sir. ~~
What is your occupation?
Lieutenant with the Police Department. ‘
City of Tallahassee Police Department?
Yes, sir.
How long have you been a police officer?
Approximately 20 years.
. Was most of those 20 years in the City of Tallahassee,
Florida? |
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you on duty on the 15th and 16th days of June,
1961, Mr. Bennett?
A. I was.
Q. Will you tell us what your duties were or your assign-
ments were on those dates?
{fol. 106] A. On Thursday the 15th around noon or a little
before I was assigned or given an assignment in and around
the Greyhound bus stationsto keep law and order and to
give protection to those who might need’ it.
Q. Were you given specific instructions with respect to
any definite group of people?
A. I was. I was instructed that there was a number of
IS Freedom Riders coming into the City by Greyhound bus
arriving about 12:30 or 12:35 noon that day.
Q. In addition to those duties were you ever assigned to
the Tallahassee Municipal Airport?
A. I was. I had an assignment at that same time that the
information was that that special gronp was going to the
airport and at about 1:30 I did go to the airport.
Q. What did you do and observe ont there, Lieutenant
Bennett ! \
~
OPO PrO ro ro re
if
55
A. I arrived there before any of this group which I had
seen and recognized at sight and they came out there and
entered the airport, gathered immediately in front of the
ticket counter and they went in a huddle there and they
would talk with the ticket agent, then they would go in a
huddle themselves and talk to one another. First one would
talk and then the other one and they would hold up their
hands as if they were voting on seme decision.
[fol. 107] They were milling— ~
.
Mr. Simon: I object and move to strike the conclusion of
the witness.
The Court: The conclusion that they appeared to be vot-
ing on something?
Mr. Simon: If he saw them raise their hands—
The Court: He said as though you would vote on some-
thing. It is just a figure of speech.
Objection overruled.
A. They were milling around the airport, to the tele-
phone, back into a haddle, talking to the ticket agent con-
tinuously time after time: ‘Then, two and three at a time
they would move from one position in the air terminal to
another.
Q. What time was this?
A. This was after 1:30; from 1:30 until 5:00 I observ ed
them O. Were airport building.
ere you present at the time _Eastern’s 3:25 p.m. air-
ais departed?
A. I was.
Q. Did you see any of the group that you have just re-
ferred to leave on that plane?
A. Yes, sir. Fight out of this group left on that plane.
Q. Did you count them?
[fol. 108] A. Yes, sir, I did.
Q. Do you remember how many remained?
A. There were ten.
Q. What did they do then?
A. They came back in and took a seat in the lobby. Most
of them were carrying baggage and they sat down close
together and took a seat in a close huddle right in about
the center of the lobby of the airport.
“
56
Q. If I am not mistaken your testimony is referring to
the 15th day of June, that is Thursday?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long did you stay at the airport?
A. I stayed until 5:00 o’clock, 5:00 p.m. that afternoon.
Q. Did you have any other duties at the airport that day?
A. I did not.
Q. Did you ever go back to the airport that day or any
subsequent day?
A. I was assigned—on the 16th, Friday morning, I was
advised that this group was going back to the airport and
I was assigned to see that they had protection from Tal-
lahassee to the airport and while at the airport.
Q. ‘Were you with anybody?
[fol. 109] A. I was riding in the car with Chief Stouta-
mire.
Q. Did you go to the airport?
A. We did. At approximately 7:00 o’clock we followed
this group which were traveling in either four or five cars
out to the airport.
Q. Did you speak to any members of the group at the
time?
A. At arrival at the airport Chief Stoutamire stepped
out of the car and talked to Dan Speed.
Q. Why did he talk to Dan Speed or do vou know that?
A. Yes, sir, I heard the conversation. The Chief told
Dan )
Mr. Simon: Just a‘moment. We object. This is not a
conversation between any of the parties to this cause.
Speed is not a defendant.
The Court: If the conversation was not overheard by
the defendants it will be hearsay and not admissible.
Q. Lieutenant, did*~Dan Speed approach Chief Stouta-
mire in connection with the matter that they discussed or
did the Chief call Dan Speed to him or do you know?
A. At that time he was approached by Dan Speed.
Q. Hgwas approached by Dan Speed?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know Dan Speed?
[fol. 110] <A. Yes, sir, I do.
57
Q. Did-you see him in connection with this group at any
time on the 15th and 16th? ~
A. Yes, sir. Off and on ail during the day most times.
Q. Did he appear to be a part of them or acting in con-
cert with them in any way?
A. He appeared to be part of them.
Mr. Simon: I object on the grounds it calls for a con-
clusion and it is immaterial and irrelevant. There is no
charge against Dan Speed for acting in concert or in con-
spiracy.
Mr. Hill: Before you rule on that, Your Honor, I am
attempting and will show this by its materiality that Dan
Speed, by his conduct, was associated with this group in
some way and at. that time purported to act as a spokes-
man for them and, if so, then any statements made to him
are relevant and material to this cause.
His name has been brought vee sree into this record.
Mr. Simon: Not by us and I move to strike all references
to his name.
Mr. Hill: It is a little late to make a motion to strike
Mr. Simon: Regardless of whether he has been named
he hasn’t been made a party to this cause. No charges for
[fol. 111] him are outstanding.
The Court: What was the question?
Mr. Hill: I will have to ask the Court Reporter to read
that back.
(The question referred to was read back by the Re-
porter.) ;
Mr. Hill: Before you rule may I ask this witness one
more quéstion?
The Court: All right.
Q. You say you followed this group to the airport at
about 7:00 o'clock on the morning of the 16th? rs
A. Yes, sir.
~*Q. Was Dan Speed driving éne of the cars that was part
of this group?
A. I’m not sure.
Q. Was he with part of the group?
58
A. I did not recognize Dan Speed until I saw him out of
the car and on the ground at the airport right in front of
the entrance to the airport.
Q. Did you see him with tats group at the bus station the
day before?
A. I did, sir.
Mr. Hill: Now, Your Honor, would the Court like to rule
on the objection? ~~
ffol. 112} Mr. Simon: All that shows is he may or may
not have been a chauffeur. This doesn’ t mean he is an inter-
state passenger. —
The Court: The question now before the Court is whether
or not he appeared to be a part of the group or a member of
the group andthe objection was it calls for a conclusion
of this witness.
I am going to sustain the objection.
Q. Did you see or were you present at the time that
Chief Stoutamire talked to a member of this group?
A. I was.
Q. Who was he?
A. I would say at least an hour*or an hour and a half
after arriving and talking to Dan Speed, inside of the ter-
minal after the flight that we had information that this
group was to leave on did not go, Chief Stoutamire contacted
the group for a spokesman of the group. One of the mem-
bers named Collier stood up and said he was and the Chief
told him he had protected them, given’ them protection—
Mr. Simen: I object on the grounds these are self-serv-
ing declarations. Chief Stoutamire is here, he can testify
as to what he said.
It is hearsay and it is also repetitions.
The Court: Objection overruled.
[fol. 113] Q. Proceed.
A. The Chief told Collier that he had been with them for
mere than—from roon the day before until about approxi-
mately midnight that night and had been out that morning,
followed them out that morning and he had other duties to
perform in the City. and that he was going back to town
but that he was going to leave two officers out at the air-
‘ 59
port to observe and see what was going on and to keep law
and order, but in that conyersation Collier asked him if he
was going to give them protection. The Chief told him he
was going to leave the two officers out there.
Q. Did I understand you to say that one of ‘the airline
planes departed while you were there*
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know which airline it was?
A. We had information it was to leave at 8:38 and be-
lieved to be Eastern Airlines.
Q. Did you see that plane leave?
A. I did.
Q. The defendants obviously did not get on it?
A. No, sir. I was on the “inside of the buildin, but I
could see very easily the plane depart from the inside.
Q. “ad you stay there all day or did you leave?
A. Shortly after that plane left which was 8:35 I came
back to town.
({fol. 114] Q. Did you ever go back to the airport?
A. I did.~About noon information was receivd through
the Police Department and by myself and the Department
decided to go out to the airport so about noon or about 12:30
Chief Steutamire went back to the airport.
He and Mr. Messer were talking in the air terminal.
Shortly after -that at approximately 12:35 we made the
arrest of the defendants who are here today.
Q. Were you standing there at the time he was reading
this proclamation?
_ A. I was an arm’s length away from him.
Q.: Did he tell them who he was?
A. Yes, sir. Mr. Messer read from this piece of paper or
proclamation and told them who he was and told them his
name and who he was, that thev were unlawfully assembled
and asked them to disperse.
Q. How many did disperse, if any?
A. There was 13 in the group and three of them immedi-
ately’ dispersed as ordered by Mr. Messer.
The rest of them shuffled around just a little bit. While
he was reading this proclamation they all gathered in a
close huddle so they could hear. “Immediately after he told
them—after he finished reading it he told them he would
60
give them 15 seconds to disperse. They shuffled around and
(fol. 115] moved around. Some of them came up nearer and
sat down and some backed off. In general, it was a general
shuffling of the group at that time.
Mr. Messer checked the time and longer than 15 seconds,
I am sure—I would say it appeared to be a minute or two
minutes—he said the time was up and ordered that all of
them was arrested, arrested the group.
Q. Did they have time to comply or obey?
A. Yes, sir. They had ample time, more than time to
have left the building and the premises which they were
ordered to, in that length of time.
Q. All who elected to disperse did so, is that correct?
A. Yes, sir. Dan Speed was in the group. He and two
boys immediately left the building and I didn’t see them
any more.
Q. Did you make the actual arrest of these ten people?
A. I did along with Chief Stoutamire and Mr. Messer.
There was other officers in the building and they were taken
into custody by, I would say, six or eight police officers.
Q. Were you present at the arrest of one Priscilla
Stephens?
A. Iwas.
Q. Would vou describe what happened there, please?
A. At the time the group was arrested they all went out
of the building in a group with, I would say, six or eight
{ fol. 116] police officers.
I was standing near the back of the group so I followed
them out aad came out the door about the last one. When
I got outside the officers had the police cars lined up in
front of the door.
Priscilla was just ahead of the group and had not gotten
in a car so she was standing right near a car. I walked up
to her and asked her to get in the car. She told me she
was not getting in. I opened the door and asked her to get
in the ear again. She started to walk away so I opened the
door and took her by the arm and led her back up to the
car with the door open and asked her to get in. She told
me she was not getting in so I held her to keep her from
either walking or running away and with the assistance of
Officer Daws put her in the ear.
61 ©
Q. Did she make any overt act to resist you or oppose
you other than what you testified to?
A. No;sir, just an attempt to walk away. ;
At the car, we had to use just manual force to get her
in the car.
Q. What do you mean by “manual force”?
A. Had to hold her right near the seat where she could
get in. She didn’t make any effort at all to get in herself.
She just stood with her body real stiff up against the car.
She finally sat down from outside with her feet out and
[fol. 117] would not put her feet in as she was told. We had
to lift her feet up and sit them around in the car.
Q. Did you notice at any time over the period that you
have testified to that you were present at the airport any
large crowds of people there?
A. There was. On Thursday people were gathered and
were screened at the driveway to the airport by police
officers.
As I left there was a group that gathered up right at the
entrance that were not allowed to enter the airport ter-
minal or the grounds.
Q. As a police officer of some 20 vears experience, Mr.
Bennett, did you have any feeling that there would be a
breach of the peace at this time?
A. Yes, sir. I felt that without the police protection that
there surely would be.
Mr. Dixon: Excuse me, Mr. Hill. What time was this,
Thursday or Friday?
Q. Thursday or Friday?
A. I was describing the incident Thursday about 5:00
o’clock when I left the airport but Friday the same thing
or worse—a bigger crowd had gathered on Friday. There
was a bigger crowd on the grounds of the terminal and
inside the building because Thursday they were screened
at the driveway, at the entrance to the air terminal.
[fol.118] Mr. Hill: You may cross examine.
62
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Officer, where was Priscilla Stephens at the time that
Mr. Messer read this proclamation?
A. She was in the group that was assembled inside the
bus station.
Q. Did you see her leave?
A. I did not. The group was pretty large with the
spectators and the police officers and I did not pick her:
out of the group as walking out but the group went out
together and she was in the group.
Q. It was your testimony that she was ahead of the
group?
A. I did not see her go outside. I don’t believe that I
said she was ahead. I don’t know exactly who was ahead,
Q. When vou got outsyde I believe your testimony was
that she was already out there.
A. She was.
Q. Were you with the group or behind the group?
A. I was behind the group, just right one step behind
the group as it went out the door.
Q. Then you don’t know whether or not Priscilla
Stephens left in obedience to Mr. Messer’s suggestion or
not?
A. I know she did not.
[fol.119] @Q. How do you know that?
A. Because she did not immediately leave the bus ter-
minal—the airport terminal. The only three that immedi-
ately left was Dan Speed and two other boys and the group
went out together. That is the only three that left immedi-
ately. Then there was considerable time, one or two minutes
or more elapsed.
(). Was it your testimony that vou don’t know whether
John Poland left?
A. He did not leave immediately after Mr. Messer had
ordered them to; within the period of time he gave them,
neither one of them did leave.
Q. Neither one of who?
A. Poland or Stephens.
Q. But they did leave before the arrests were made?
A. They did not.
63
Q. It is your testimony that they were taken into cus-
tody in the terminal?
A. I carried Poland out of the building myself but the
group went out ahead of me. What time he went out or
where he went out—l carried Poland out of the building
mnvself.
Q. He was behind the group thent
A. ‘No, sir.
Q.. You told me you were just walking behind the group.
[fol.420] A. He had stopped. When | got a hold of him he
was standing still about half way from where the group
was seated and tlre front door.
Q. Then he left the group?
. A. He was standing still but he wasn’t out of the group
because I was right at the back of the group.
~ . Do you mean he wasn’t out of the terminal but he left
the group?
A. No, sir, he hadn’t left the group. When I got to him
he was standing still and I just continued to carry him in
the group so he didn’t get out of the group. The group
didn’t leave him.
Q. The group caught up te him—
A. That’s possible.
Q. (Continuing )*—is that correct?
A. That’s possible. I didn’t see him when he stopped.
Q. It is possible that the group could have caught up to
Priscilla Stephens outside of the terminal, too?
A. Iam sure she did. She got out before I did and there
was—we had the group put in cars and there were several
put in the police carg or Voluntarily Went and got in them-
selves before she got in.
Q. Do you know Charles A. Hunter?
A. I do.
[fol. 121} Q. Did you see him leave?
A. He left in the group.
This group was so large, out of the 13 thaf we arfested
‘and the police officers and the spectators until I couldn't
keep my eye on any particular one. My main thought was
to keep the group together as it went outside and see that
they got transportation from the airport back to the city
limits so I did »vt keep my eye on anyone from the time
they were arrested until they got in the car.
64
Q. When you say “spectators” do you mean people in
the terminal who had no business being there—
A. That’s right.
Q. (Continuing) —is that correct?
A. That’s right.
Q. How did you know they didn’t have any business be-
ing there?
A. I didn’t stop and ask them but from the group that
was there they were not there for the purpose of catching
a plane or getting out.
Q. That is what you surmised?
A. That’s right.
Q. Did you ask any of them to leave the terminal?
A. Right at that time I did not.
Q. At any time?
[fol. 122] A. The day before, Friday, we had.
Q. The arrest was made on Friday, Officer.
A. I mean Thursday I had. At the time the arrest was
made, I was only at the airport a few minutes before the
arrest was made at that particular time.
Q. You were there in the morning you said.
A. Yes, sir. 93
Q. Were there any spectators there at that time?
A. Very few. That was—I left there soon after 8:50.
Q. Well, then, it would be your testimony that the police
did not stop people who had no business at the terminal
from coming onto the terminal property during the Friday
morning?
A. I don’t believe they did, sir.
Q. I’m sorry?
A. They did not.
Q. The police made no effort to ask these people to
disperse either, did they?
@ A. There was two police left at the terminal but from
the time that I went back out there Friday morning until |
made the arrest I did not ask any of them to leave.
Q. None of the other police officers did either?
A. I don’t knew.
Q. As a matter of fact, at the time the arrest was made
there were a large number of police officers there?
{fol. 123] A. Not a large number. There was at least six
or eight.
65
Q. To your knowledge did any of these people ask any of
the spectators to leave or disperse?
A. The two that was left out there was to observe and
keep order out there and when the group went out there,
when they went out there for the purpose of removing this
group that was causing the trouble, that we thought would’.
cause the troukie if we didn’t do something about it—
Q. Which group caused the trouble, Officer?
A. The group that was caught—-we received the most talk
about and what was probably causing the trouble was the
group we arrested.
Q. Do you know whether they had any airline tickets?
A. I am sure they did but I did not see them buy them
or see the tickets but I am sure that thev did.
Q. Can you tell me why you think they were causing
trouble?
A. Their being there was the talk about town and the
groups that were gathered there were talking about them
and there was considerable resentment among the people.
Q. Aren’t there usually people with airplane tickets at
the airport terminal? <
A. I am sure there are.
(fol. 124] Q. Why were these people causing trouble?
A. The fact that these people were there and the people
—the publicity they got about this group that was coming
to town. I don’t know what caused the resentment or the
groups to gather.
Q. It was the resentment that was causing the trouble,
wasn’t it?
A. I don’t know exactly what was causing the trouble
but it was the groups that were beginning to gather and
there was certain talk and rumors there might be trouble
if we didn’t dé something about it.
Q. Did vou explore these rumors and this talk? ,
A. We did.
Q. Did you arrest any of the people who were making
threats?
A. Not Friday but Thursday there was sooekl of them
questioned about it.
Q. Were there an‘ arrests made?
A. Not to my knowledge.
66 ah
4
Q. There weren't any arrests on Friday made of anybody
that made any threats, were there?
A. I beg your pardon?
Mr. Simon: Read the question back (addressing the
Reporter).
| fol. 125] (The question referred to was read back by
the Reporter.)
A. There was not, to my knowledge.
Q. Did you hear any of these defendants make any
threats?
A. I did not.
Q: Can you tell me in what manner they were making
trouble?
A. From the Thursday that they arrived, that I received
information they had arrived, we planned to give them
protection and keep law and order in the City. From that
moment on the crowds began to gather as though there
might be trouble. The talk among the people was that
there might be trouble so we were just being sure.
Q. From whom did you expect the trouble, Officer?
A. From out of this group and the people that were
gathering.
Q. From the ten people?
A. Yes, sir—
Q. What kind of trouble did you expect from them?
A. (Continuing) —and their followers.
Q. What kind of trouble did you expect from these ten
pepple?
A. We wasn't—we didn’t expect any certain kind but
[fol. 126] we expected there might be trouble out of them,
diserderly conduct and a riot or whatever might arise.
Q. Caused by them?
® A. Caused by them and their followers and the other
groups that were gathering.
- Q. Do you mean the spectators?
A. Yes.
Q. (Continuing) —the people that had no business in the
first place, is that correct?
A. 'That’s right.
67
Q. You have been a police officer in this County for about
20 years?
A. Yes, sir, approximately.
Q. Do you know of anything unusual about these ten
people that would have caused resentment against them
by the townspeople in this community?
A. I am not sure of what caused it but’it did cause it.
Q. You don’t have any idea at all?
A. No, sir.
Q. Officer, your statement is after living in this com-
munity and working as a police officer for 20 years you
don’t have any idea why these ten people sitting in an air-
port terminal should cause trouble in this community, do
you?
A. I got my own ideas about what happened but I am
[ fol. 127] not sure what theirs were.
Q. 1 am asking you for your ideas, Officer.
The Court: Mr. Simon, you are on cross examination
and you can lead the witness a great deal and even suggest
if you like, if you were trying to get one particular answer.
If you would ask him and save 30 minutes of beating around
the bush the Court would appreciate it.
Mr. Simon: If I had an idea I would be pleased to help
him but I assure vou I do not.
The Court: You don't have any idea at all yourself?
Mr. Simon: No, sir. I don’t live in this community.
The Court: Well, go ahead.
¢-
Q. Can you answer the question?
A. Give it again, please.
Q. What is vour idea as to what was causing this diffi-
culty?
A. I haven't got any idea what they theught about it,
other people thought.
Mr. Simon: All right. No further questions.
.
Redirect examination.
By Mr. Hill:
Q. Lieutenant Bennett, could it be because of the ad-
vanced publicity and the manner in which these people
[ fol. 128] came to our town?
A. That is what led me to believe that there would be
trouble. It is possible that is what led the rest of the
people.
Mr. Dixon: I move that be stricken as completely lead-
ing and suggestive.
The Court: And repetitious. He already testified that
that would have a large bearing on it.
Objection sustained. ‘
Q. Did all of the people who could have possibly caused _
trouble, were they dispersed by you or by any other police
officers ?
A. They were.
Q. This is the only group that refused to disperse upon
order by a police officer?
A. That’s right.
Mr. Hill: No further questions.
o
Recross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Did vou hear Mr. Messer read this statement to
these ten people?
A. i did.
Q. Did you hear him read it to the other spectators
standing there?
A. There was more than ten; there was about 16 in the
[fol. 129] group that he read it to.
Q. Did you hear him read it to the other spectators?
A. No, sir, I did not.
Q. They still stayed there, didn't they?
A. Not after the arrest of this group they did not.
a
69
Q. They dispersed by themselves after this group was
arrested?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Simon: That is all.
Mr. Hill: I have no further questions at this time.
The Court: Any reason why the Lieutenant can’t be ex-
cused to go back to his duties?
Mr. Simon: No, sir.
(Witness excused. )
The Court: Do your people intend to testify?
Mr. Simon: Yes, sir.
The Court: At great length? j
Mr. Simon: Well, I think that the way we have set it
up there will be three people testify about the events and
the others will be testifying just in terms of identification.
I think that will just be corroborative and won't take very
long. 4
1 will say this: There is a large dispute as to the testi-
mony regarding the Priscilla Stephens affair and that might
[fol. 130] take a considerable lena of time. We discussed
that with Mr. Messer.
Thereupon, Orvitte Hopkrys, called as a witness by the
plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn, was examined
and testified on his oath as follows:
A
Direct examination. is
By Mr. Messer:
Q. Your name is Orville Hopkins?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What position do you. hold with the City of Talla-
hassee?
A. City Manager.
Q. Were you present at the Tallahassee Municipal <Air-
port: during the afternoon of June 15th, 1961, Thursday
afternoon? ;
A. Yes, sir, part of the time.
70
Q. Were you present when these defendants were at the
airport?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have occasion to use one of the food vend-
ing machines?
{fol.131] <A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did you use it for?
A. I used it to purchase a sandwich and also tc purchase
a cold drink, I believe an orange drink.
Q. What coin did you deposit in the machine to receive
the sandwich?
A. I deposited a quarter in the machine to receive the
sandwich. I purchased a ham sandwich. It was made with
a kind of bun affair with ham in the middle; very good.
Q. You received the sandwich?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How much were you required to deposit in the ma-
chine or how much did you deposit in the machine to pro-
cure the cold drink?
A. 10 cents.
Mr. Messer: Your witness.
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. You are the City Manager of the City of Tallahassee?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long have you been so engaged?
A. Nine and a half vears.
(). Are part of your duties the control and operation of
the Tallahassee Municipal Airport?
[fol. 132] A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you present at the conversation between City
officials and the operators of the restaurant whereby a deci-
sion was reached to close the restaurant gf these Freedom
Riders came out to the airport?
A. I discussed it with them, ves. I don’t think we had
any meeting of any kind. We discussed it back and forth,
ves.
Q. Who is “we”?
71
A. Myself and the operators of the restaurant.
Q. Is that Mr. Isdell?
A. Yes.
Q. When did this conversation take place?
Mr. Messer: If the Court please, I am going to object
to that line of cross examination. I asked Mr. Hopkins
questions relating to the vending machines.
Mr. Simon: If Your Honor please, I am going to tie
this in to the use of the vending machines. The reason we
are contending why the price went up is because the restau-
rant was closed.
The Court: Nobody said the price went up but you, Mr.
Simon, and Mr. Hopkins testified about the operation ‘of
two vending machines on direct examination and you know
that your cross examination is limited to those things
brought out on direct.
Objection is sustained.
[fol. 133] Mr. Simon: Then at this time we will ask no
further questions of the City Manager and we will request
the Court order he stay here so he can make himself avail-
able as a witness, an adverse witness, on behalf of the
defendants at such time as we are able to present our case.
The Court: You will be around until 5:00 o'clock?
The Witness: Yes, sir. My office can contact me any time
vou need me.
(Witness excused.)
Mr. Hill: For the record, this is a new witness who has
not been sworn and who has been outside of the courtroom
and this court for the entire proceeding.
. | ° @ e © * °
[fol. 148] Thereupon, W. D. Hopkrys, called as a witness
by the plaintiff, having been first duly sworn, was examined
and testified on his oath as follows:
>irect examination.
By Mr. Hill:
Q. State your name for the record, please.
A. W.D. Hopkins.
72
Q. What is your occupation?
A. I am State Attorney, Second Judicial Circuit, State
of Florida.
Q. How long have you been such State Attorney?
A. I have been State Attorney for approximately 15
years.
Q. Were you at the Tallahassee Municipal Airport on
Thursday night at or about 11:00 p.m. or in that neighbor-
hood?
A. I was.
Q. Would you tell us how you happened to be there?
A. I have a radio in my car and I got a radio call ask-
ing m® to come to the airport.
Q. Who is your radio connected with, the Tallahassee
Police Department or the Sheriff's Office?
A. Sheriff's Department.
Q. So then, your call emanated from some aspect of
[fol. 149} the Leon County Sheriff's Department then?
A. From the jail; that is part of the Sheriff's Depart-
ment, yes.
Q. Did you go to the shiviain at that hour? |
A. I arrived there, I assume, about 10:30 to 11:00 p.m.
Q. Did you notice or find anything unusual out there,
Mr. Hopkins, at that time?
A. I found an abnormally large crowd of people there
upon arrival.
Q. Was the atmosphere there such as to indicate to you
that there might be serious breaches of the peace, Mr.
Hopkins?
Mr. Simon: I object on the grounds that this calls fora
conclusion of the witness. There is no testimony showing
any predicate for this type of conclusion.
Mr. Hill: If Your Honor please, I think a man of Mr.
Hopkins’ stature who has been the State Attorney for
this Judicial Circuit as long as he has is certainly predi-
cate enough to ask him a question as simple as that.
The Court: We have had the same argument on every
witness so far.
Objection is overruled.
lee
Q. Answer the question, please, sir.
A. I hate to ask it but will you repeat the question?
Q. I said did you find anything out there that was in
{fol. 150] your opinion likely to cause serious breaches of
the peace?
Mr. Simon: Same objection.
A. My answer to that is yes.
Q. Have you talked to me about this on the telephone
yesterday? .
A. I have talked to you about it.
Q. Would you tell this Court and this record what you
told me at that time?
Mr. Simon: I object to that, Your Honor. I am not
interested and this Court isn’t interested in what he told
Mr. Hill vesterday on the telephone.
The Court: He is interested in what you found that led
you to conclude that (addressing the witness).
Mr. Simon: Could I have the question clarified for the
purpose of the record? I think that is what he meant but
I would like to have a proper question there.
The Court: The question is what facts and circumstances
he found that caused him to conclude as he did. )
Mr. Simon: If that is the question, all right.
A. Upon arrival at the airbase I found a number of
people sitting inside on the benches and chairs where they
normally sit. I saw a number of police officers both inside
and outside of the building. I also saw some Highway
Patrol officers there at the scene. .
[fol. 151] I saw parked out in front some three or four
automobiles containing from three to five, maybe six people.
Some of their faces I recognized and some I didn't.
From talking to the people there and seeing the scene
I knew that those people outside would have given trouble
if the officers had not been present to take care of the situ-
ation.
Q. Mr. Hopkins, in order to clear the record when you
say airbase you are referring to the vernacular in Talla-
hassee, that is the Tallahassee Municipal Airport?
A. That’s right.
74
Mr. Hill: Mr. Simon, your witness.
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. This is what you saw Thursday night?
A. Thursday night. I was out there only on Thursday
night.
Mr. Simon: No questions.
The Court: He can be excused, is that right?
Mr. Simon: Yes.
(Witness excused. )
The Court: How much do you anticipate longer this will
take?
Mr. Hill: I would like to recall Mr. Messer.
Mr. Simon: You are recalling Mr. Messer?
[fol. 152] Mr. Hill: Yes, sir. May I?
Mr. Simon: No objection.
Mr. Messer: It will be very short.
The Court: Is this your last witness before resting?
Mr. Hill: Yes, sir.
The Court: Go right ahead.
Thereupon, JamMrs Messer, JRr., recalled as a witness by
the plaintiff, having been previously duly sworn, resumed
the stand and testified further on his oath as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Hill:
Q. You are Mr. James Messer, Jr. who has heretofore
testified today ? |
A. Yes.
Q. Did you buy any food or cigarettes at the airport, at
the Municipal Airport, any time Thursday or Friday?
A. I bought a package of Salem cigarettes Thursday
afternoon and again on Friday morning.
75
Q. How much did you pay for them?
[fol. 153] A. 30 cents. I paid 25 cents, a quarter, and a
nickel in the machine.
Q. Oncach occasion or on one occasion?
A. On each occasion.
Q. That was an automatic vending machine?
A. Yes.
Mr. Hill: Your witness.
Cross examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. You bought two packs of cigarettes?
A. One pack on Thursday and one pack on Friday.
Q. Then you believe that Mr. Spencer who said he only
sold one pack made a mistake?
A. He must have because | got the cigarettes.
Q. Either you or Mr. Spencer is making a mistake, is
that correct?
A. Evidently.
Mr. Simon: Thank you.
PuaintTirF Rests
Mr. Messer: If the Court please, the City will rest its
case.
RENEWAL OF Motion OF DEFENDANTS TO QUASH AND
To DisMiss THE CHARGES AND DENIAL THEREOF
Mr. Simon: At this time, if Your Honor please, the
defendants will renew their motion to dismiss made before
the State put on its case and at the conclusion of all the
State’s testimony we renew our motion on exactly the self
same grounds as heretofore stated.
[fol. 154] The Court: Motion is denied.
How long do you anticipate in the presentation of your
case?
Mr. Simon: About two hours.
Mr. Dixon: That all depends upon the length of cross
examination by City’s counsel.
76
Mr. Simon: That includes reasonable cross exa. *‘nation
except, Your Honor, I will say that the single issue that
remains as I regard it is the greatly disputed fact as to
one of these defendants.
The Court: [ had several other matters to try this after-
noon.
Mr. Messer: Excuse me, Your Honor. May I interject
this? I have reference to the case against Priscilla
Stephens; it may be that we will have to set that for an-
other date.
Mr. Simon: Possibly.
The Court: Well, the Court will recess now until 2:00
o’clock and, Mr. Clerk, all the cases that are previously set
for this afternoon, let me check my calendar for tomorrow
and see if I can try them tomorrow afternoon instead of
this afternoon and I will make an announcement on that at
2:00 o'clock.
(Whereupon, at 1:00 o’clock p.m. a luncheon recess was
taken until 2:10 o'clock p.m.)
[fol. 155] AFTERNOON SESSION
Mr. Simon: Your Honor, the Everett case is tied into
these events somewhat. I don't think it would take very
much additional testimony to present the case for or against
him. We have been retained to represent him and I would
appreciate it if he could be heard in conjunction with these
matters.
The Court: I don’t see where it has any connection with
these cases at all.
Mr. Simon: He was picked up outside the bus terminal.
He was taking people out there.
The Court: His case will have to be heard tomorrow at
2:00.
Mr. Messer: The City has rested its case. It is possible
there may be some rebuttal testimony only as to the hour
of the arrest of the defendants, that is the time.
Some of the witnesses for the City want to know if they
can come into the courtroom. Do you know of any reason,
Mr. Hill, why vou intend to recall anybody?
Mr. Hill: Not right now.
77
Mr. Messer: We don’t know now—
The Court: If there is any possibility that something will
develop they ought to stay under the Rule.
Mr. Hill: There is that possibility.
[fol. 156] Mr. Simon: Are any of these people that are
coming in going to testify?
Mr. Messer: No, none of them have testified and will not
be called to testify.
The Court: The City has rested. A motion for a directed
-verdict has been denied. °
Mr. Simon: The defense calls as its first witness Reverend
J. W. Collier, Jr.
The Court: You were sworn this morning?
Defendant Collier: I was.
Thereupon, J. W. Cottier, Jr., defendant, called as a
witness in his own behalf, having been previously duly
sworn, was examined and testified on his oath as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Simon:
Q. Please state your name and your address.
A. John W. P. as in Paul Collier, C-o-]-l-i-e-r, Jr., 310
Meeker Avenue, Newark, New Jersey.
Q. What is your occupation or profession?
[fol. 157] A. Tama minister of the gospel.
Q. What denomination?
A. African Methodist Episcopal Church.
Q. How long have you been so engaged?
A. The past 23 years.
Q. Have you had any educational training for this posi-
tion?
A. Ihave. I completed college at Wilburforce University
receiving the degree of Bachelor of Science and Social
Administration. I did my graduate work at Paine Theo-
logical Seminary at Wilburforce receiving a degree of
Bachelor of Divinity. I did my residence work for Master
of Arts degree at Drew Theological Seminary.
z
*
78
Q. Do you presently hold an active pulpit?
A. Ido.
Q. Where and for what church?
A. The Israel Memorial African Methodist Episcopal
Church in Newark, New Jersey.
Q. On or about June 12th, 1961 did you arrange for
yourself with others to become an interstate passenger in
a trip that was to originate in Washington, D. C.?
A. I did.
Q. Did you embark upon this trip?
A. I did.
[fol. 158] Q. What was the date of, embarkation?
A. The 13th of June which was Tuesday.
Q. 1961?
A. 1961.
Q. At that time did you have in your possession tickets
on common carriers from Washington, D. C. to other des-
tinations?
A. We did.
Q. Which tickets did you hold, on what carriers, and
what was your destination?
A. Bus tickets issued by the Greyhound Bus Company
from Washington, D. C. to Tallahassee, Florida.
Q. Did you also have ai the time of your embarkation
from Washington, D. C. in your possession or did you have
arrangements to secure airline tickets from Tallahassee,
Florida to other points?
A. We did. From Tallahassee, Florida back to Newark
or New York, one or the other.
Q. On what airline?
A. Eastern Airline. é
Q. Where was that flight to originate? ' y
A. That flight was to originate in Tallahassee, Florida.
Q. That flight was to terminate either in Newark or
[fol. 159] New York?
A. Newark or New York.
Q. Were you at the time of your embarkation in the
company or presence of other persons whose destinations
were the same as yours?
A. I was.
79
Q. Are these other persons or were there among these
other persons the nine defendants who are here with you
today who are designated as Freedom Riders?
A. These nine (indicating) were with us in a part of
our group.
Q. Did you ultimately arrive at Tallahassee, Florida?
A. We did.
Q. In what manner of transportation did you arrive in
Tallahassee, Florida?
A. Wearrived by Greyhound bus.
Q. What was the date of your arrival?
A. We arrived on the morning of Thursday, June 15th.
Q. How many persons were there in your group alto-
gether?
A. There were 18 of us in our group altogether.
Q. Did you have an express purpose in making this trip?
A. We did.
Q. What was that purpose?
[fol. 160] A. There was a two-fold purpose: First, we
wanted to ascertain whether or not there were facilities
available on an integrated basis to interstate passengers in
waiting rooms, in rest rooms, in eating facilities in the ter-
minals through which we would pass.
Secondly, we wanted to bear our witness as ministers,
rabbis and clergymen to the struggle to obtain these rights
guaranteed at the Constitution.
Mr. Dixon: Would you talk to the Judge?
The Court: I can hear all right.
Q. Through what cities did you“pass from the time that
you left Washington, D. C. on June 13th until you arrived
in Tallahassee, Florida on June 15th?
A. We passed through Richmond, Virginia, through
Raleigh, North Carolina, through Sumpter, South Carolina,
through Savannah, Georgia, through Jacksonville, Florida,
through Lake City, Florida and eventually to Tallahassee.
Q. Did you test whether or not the facilities of the ter-
minals ix each of these cities were available to you and
your group on an integrated basis in each of these cities?
A. We did.
Q. Was the group that left Washington, D. C. both negro
and white in its composition?
x0) :
A. It was so constituted.
[fol 161] Q. Are the defendants presently before this
Court both negro and white in their composition?
A. We are.
Q. What is your color?
A. Negro, negro American.
Q. Did you on Thursday, June 15th, 1961 arrange to
be transported to the Tallahassee Municipal Airport in or
near Tallahassee, Florida?
A. We did.
Q. About what time did you arrive at the Tallahassee
Municipal Airport?
A. Approximately 1:30 in the afternoon of Thursday,
the 15th. &
Q. Did yeu at this time have in your possession an air-
port tieket on any carrier?
A. 1 did; 1 had an airplane ticket on Eastern Airlines
to Newark, New Jersey.
Q. Did you have a reservation for a flight out?
A. 1 did.
Q. What time was that fight to leave?
A. That flight was to leave in the afternoon at 3:25 p.m.
Q. What was your purpose in going to the Tallahassee
Municipal Airport at the time and on the dafe I have just
indicated?
{fol. 162] A. We went to the airport in order to board the
plane. 4
Q. Did vou have any other purpose?
A. Our perpose was, inasmuch as there was time prior
to the departure of the plane and since I among others had
not eaten, taeat prior to leaving and to test the facilities as
1 indicated earlier.
\. Dri vou test the facilities of the Tallahassee Municipal
Airport terminal?
A. Those ghat were available to us.
Q. Which facilities were thos@?
A. The waiting room, and the rest reoms.
Q. Md vou ascegtain how many rest rooms were avail-
able in the terminal!
A. 1 did. T noticed that there were four rest rooms.
Q. How were they designated?
81
.
A. White Ladies, White Men, Colored Ladies, Colored
Men or designations to that effect. + °
Q. Did you ascertain how many waiting rooms there
were?
A. I did. There were two.
Q. Were they designated in any manner?
A. The sign pointing to the smaller was marked Colored
Waiting Room.
Q. Did you ascertain whether or not there were any
restaurant facilities at the terminal?
{fol. 163] <A. I did.
Q. What did you ascertain?
A. That there was one large glass enclosed restaurant.
Around the corner was a counter in front of which were
five or six stools. On the counter was a sign “Colored.”
Q. Were you able to secure any food to eat at this time?
A. I was not.
Q. Why not?
A. The restaurant door was closed and the sign on the
panel next to the door marked “Closed.”
Q. At the time that you arrived did you see any persons
eating in the restaurant?
A. Yes. There were four or five persons eating in the
restaurant when we arrived.
Q. Were these white or negro persons?
A. They were white persons.
Q. Can you describe the sign that was put on the door?
A. The sign was approximately 12, I would say, by 20
inches, a gray sign with “Colored”—I mean “Closed”
marked on in black letters.
Q. Was that a printed or handwritten sign?
A. Handwritten sign.
Q. How many in. your group arrived at the Tall&hassee
[fol. 164] Airport at the time that you indicated?
A. All of us, 18.
Q. Did any of vour group leave on the Eastern Airlines
Flight that you had reservations for?
A. Yes, a part of our group did; eight, in fact.
Q. What time did they leave?
A. At 3:25, the scheduled time of departure.
Q. Did the remaining ten leave at that time?
82
A. No. The remaining ten remained.
Q. Did you cancel your reservations?
A. We cancelled our reservations.
Q. Were arrangements made for additional reservagons?
A. Reservations were made additionally at the tinre of
the cancellation.
Q. For what time did you make reservations to leave?
A. There was a firm reservation made for Saturday
morning of the 17th with a request for an earlier reserva-
tion and the assurance given that earlier reservations
would be sought.
Q. You were one of the people that remained?
A. I was one of those that remained.
Q. What was your reason for cancelling your reserva-
tion?
A. In the first place, we were denied entrance into the
restaurant facility. We were told by the manager that the
restaurant would reopen at 4 30 and we were waiting so
{ fol. 165] we might be se
~ Q. Did the restaurant open at 4:30?
A. The restaurant did not reopen.
Q. How long fd you remain in the terminal?
A. Until approximately five minutes before midnight
when we were informed that we would have to move.
Q. Did you at that time leave the terminal?
A. I did.
Q. At that time did you have reservations for flight out-
side the State of Florida?
A. I did, the reservation being for the next morning,
Friday, the 16th, leaving at 8:38.
Q. Were these reservations for all ten persons of your
group?
A. For all ten persons in the group, yes.
Q. Did you subsequentiy return to the Tallahassee Munic-
ipal Airport?
A. We did.
Q. When was that?
A. On Friday morning at approximately 7:25 or 7:30.
Q. What was your purpose for returning to the Talla-
hassee Municipal Airport on this occasion?
,
83
A. To board the plane on which we held reservations
leaving at 8:38.
(fol. 166] Q. Did you have any other purpose?
A. To be served in the restaurant prior to leaving.
Q. Did you secure service f — restaurant? .
A. We did not.
» Q. Why not?
A. The sign still indicated that the restaurant wast¢losed.
Q. Did you leave oy the flight for which you had’ reserva-
tions at the time that you arrived at the airport.o1 von Friday
morning t ce
A. I did not. A
Q. Did any of your group leave on that fight 4 y
A. None of our group left on that flight. ‘Zi
Q. Did you cancel your reservations? © * 4”
A. We did. 4
Q. Did you secure new reservations?
A. We did. The reservation for Saturday morning was
oN
,
a
still available to us so we were at no time without reserva- °
tions.
Q. What was your purpose in cancelling the reservation?:
A. Awaiting service in the restaurant facility in ac-
cordance with the promise of the manager that it would be
open.
Q. During the morning of Friday, June 17th, did you
make any other reservation for a flight beyond the State
of Florida?
A. You said Friday, June 17th.
[fol. 167] _ Q. Friday, June 16th, I mean.
A. I am not certain. I know another reservation was
made. I think it was the afternoon flight.
Q. Did you subsequently cancel that flight?
A. We subsequently cancelled that flight.
Q. What was your reason for cancelling that flight?
A. Service had still been denied us in the restaurant
in the airport terminal.
Q. Were you in the Tallahassee Municipal Airport ter-
minal on the morning of Friday, June 16th, 1961 at ap-
proximately 12:00 o’clock?
A. I was.
-
84
Q. Were the other nine members of your group with
you?
A. They were.
Q. During the period of time that ensued from the mo-
ment you first arrived at the airport until that time will you
describe your conduct to the Court?
A. We sat in the lobby, in the waiting room; we read the
newspapers; we read books which members of our party
had with us and we quietly conversed among us.
Q. Were you loud, noisy or boisterous in any manner?
A. At no time in any way.
Q. Did you at any time threaten any person or persons?
A. We did not.
{fol. 168] Q. What is the profession or occupation of the
remaining nine members of your group?
A. All are rabbis or clergymen; two are rabbis, eight
are clergymen.
Q. Did you meet Mr. James Messer at the Tallahassee
Municipal Airport on or about 12:00 or 12:30, approxi-
mately noon on Friday, July 16th, 1961?
A.'I did. .
Q. Did he make any statements to you?
A. He did.
Q. Do you recall, to the best of your recollection, what
was the statement he made to you?
A. Yes. I jotted down the substance of the statement
that he made at the time as the statement was read.
The statement said, in effect, that our presence there at
the airport would tend to ingite to riot on the property
owned by the City. We were commanded to disperse, the
alternative being arrest for unlawful assembly. We were
given 15 seconds to make our decision.
Q. Did you within that period of time make a 1 decision
as to whether or not you would leave the premises?
A. I did.
Q. What was that decision? :
A. To remain.
{fol. 169] Q. Did the other nine clergymen with you at
this time make a decision with regard to whether or not
vou should leave the premises?
A. They did. .
Q. What was that decision?
A. To remain.
Q. At this time and place had the terminal become filled
with a number of other persons? ,
A. Not filled. There were a number of police officers who
came in with Mr. Messer, with Mr. Stoutamire and with the
Lieutenant. There were a few persons who were not
police officers nor members of our group.
Q. Were there with you or seated with you at the time
Mr. Messer read his announcement any other persons?
A. There were.
Q. Who were those persons?
A. Miss Priscilla Stephens, Jeff Poland, the Reverend
Mr. Speed and two young men. Their last names are Steele.
I am sorry, | don’t remember their first names.
Those are the persons whose names | recall. There are
possibly two or three others. I’m sorry, also the Reverend
Mr. Hunter.
Q. Do you know whether or not they remained with your
group following Mr. Messer’s announcement or whether or
[fol. 170] not they removed themselves from the terminal?
A. They removed themselves from the terminal.
Q. What happened to you and the other nine clergymen
when you refused to relinquish your seats il the lobby of the
terminal?
A. We were placed under arrest. We were told to pick
up our luggage and “let’s get going.”
Q. Did you comply with that request?
A. We did. ’
Q. What happened next?
A. We went out of the front door, the entrance to the
terminal, where the police cars were lined up. We were
ordered to get into the police cars. We did.
(). You were then taken to the jail?
A. Brought to the City Jail.
Q. Did you have the occasion to notice whether or not
when you arrived at the Tallahassee Municipal Airport on
Thursday, June 15th, there were in (ie terminal vending
machines which dispensed food, cigarettes or Coca Colas?
A. There were two machines; one dispensing sandwiches,
the other dispensing Coca Colas.
86 “
Q. Were you able to ascertain at what price?
A. I did. The prices were 25 cents and 35 cents on the
sandwiches and 10 cents fot Coca Colas, | believe.
{fol. 171] Q. How mueh for the cigarettes?
A. There was no cigarette vending machine in there at
the time.
Q. Between the time that you first entered the terminal
and the time that you were arrested and left was a cigarette
vending machine brought to the premises?
. <A. The cigarette vending machine was brought to the
premises,
Q. Was the price of the cigarettes announced on the
cigarette vending machine?
A. Yes. There was a sign placed inside the glass read-
ing “Cigarettes, 60 cents.”
Q. Were there any changes made in the cost of sand-
wiches and soft drinks that were sold through the other
vending machines?
A. The price of sandwiches went up to 55 cents for all
of the sandwiches. There was no change in the price of
the Coca Cola machine but the sign was placed on it “Plenty
of cokes, ice making machine temporarily out of order.”
Q. Do you recall in what manner the machines were ad-
justed to increase the price of the sandwiches?
A. The vending machine operator as he opened the ma-
chine manipulated the coin mechanism. What was done I
don’t know but there was a manipulation that was visible
to me.
Q. By whom?
[fol. 172] A. By the vending machine operator or service
man—
Q. Some person did this?
A. (Continuing) —that brought the machine in.
Q. When was this?
A. That was on the afternoon of Thursday.
Q. You were in the courtroom this morning when you
heard the testimony of the various witnesses on behalf of
the State of Florida and the City of Tallahassee?
A. I was.
Q. You have heard them on a number of occasions use
the word Freedom Riders, did you not?
.
87
A. I did.
Q. Did you comprehend and understand what those
words meant?
A. Yes.
Q. What did they meant
A. A group of persons traveling on an interstate basis
integrated.
Q. Do you understand that the term was properly ap-
plicable to yourself and to the nine other persons with you?
A. Yes, we were Freedom Riders.
Q. You heard the testimony also, did you not, of Mr.
Paul J. Cannedy, the manager for Kastern Airlines?
A. I did.
[fol. 173] Q. bid vou hear his testimony to the effect that
all of the facilities of the terminal were under one roof?
A. I did. ;
Q. Are you able to advise us as to whether or not from
your observation that testimony was correct?
‘A. That testimony was correct from my own observation.
Q. Did you hear him testify to the effect that the restau-
rant, rest rooms and lobby facilities were an integral part
of the terminal and were for the purpose of serving inter-
state passengers on the airlines?
A. I did.
Q. From your observation of the terminal wes that state-
ment correct ?
A. That statement was correct from my observation.
Mr. Simon: You may inquire, sir.
Cross examination.
By Mr. Messer:
Q. Reverend Collier, I believe that you stated that you
are the pastor or minister of the Lsrael Methodist Episcopal
Church. I didn’t catch the town.
A. Israel Memorial African Methodist Episcopal Church
in Newark, New Jersey.
Q. Is that a chureh in which the doctrines of Christianity
<are advocated by you as minister ?
A. Very definitely.
88
[fol. 174] Q. I was a little confused at the term “Israel”.
You are a Christian minister?
A. Yes, I am. {I can tell you one of the founders of our
church was a man whose last name was Israel and it was
named ip honor of him.
Q. How long have you known the other nine ‘iefemdaste
» that elected to stay over at the Tallahassee Airport?
«A. Since last Monday, since Monday, the 12th.
Q. How did you happen to meet them?
A. We met in the City of Washington, the point from
which our trip started.
Q. You had never known them before?
A. I had not known them hefore, that’s correct.
Q. ‘AWVho arranged for your meeting?
_ A. The Congress of Racial Equality,’ an organization
known as CORE.
Q. In effect, then, CORE or the Congress of Racial
Equality arranged for this trip in which you were the
leader?
A. I was one of the members.
Q. You were the spokesman for the group?
A. I was the spokesman for the group after we left—
after we arrived in Tallahassee.
Q. Do you recall the time of your arrival at the Taila-
hassee bus station?
{fol. 175] <A. We arrived in Tallahassee at the bus fer-
minal at 12:40 p.m. on Thursday, the 15th.
Q). What did you and the members of your group do upon
arrival at the Greyhound bus terminal?
A. We went into the terminal, some went into the waiting
room, some went into therrest.rooms, others went to the
restaurant facility, that counter.
Q. 1 believe that you stated that you did not eat at the
bus terminal?
A. I had something to eat. I had a cup of coffee. I did
not have a meal.
Q. Why didn’t you eat with the rest of your group?
A. All of us didn’t eat. There wasn’t time. We knew
our flight departure was near at hand and we had to check
in and contirm the flight and we wanted to have time for
that. (
89
Q. Do you know of the time that you left the bus terminal?
A. It was approximately 1 :30.
Q. Then you proceeded to the Tallahassee Municipal Air-
port?
A. Correct.
Q. By private transportation?
A. Cars.
Q. Do you know how far the Tallahassee Municipal Air-
({fol. 176] port is located from the Greyhound bus terminal?
A. I do not.
Q. Several miles?
A. I would agree.
Q. Do you know approximately the time of your arrival
at the Municipal Airport?
A. I would say between 1:45 and 2:00 o’clock.
Q. 2:00 o’clock is usually rather late for a lunch time,
isn’t it?
A. Not for me. ,
Q. It would be for those who already had lunch, wouldn’t
it?
A. I would not be prepared to say. It depends on how
much lunch they had and what they wished.
Q. Now, do you recall the approximate hour or time
of your arrest by the Police Department after I had read
the proclamation or order of dispersal?
A. 12:45.
Q. 12:45?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you have a long distance telephone conversation
with 15, 20 or 10 minutes prior to your arrest?
A. I did.
Q. With whom did you have that long distance conversa-
[fol. 177] tion?
Mr. Simon: Just a moment, please. Excuse me, Mr.
Messer. Am I incorrect in assuming that some of the wit-
nesses for the City are presently in the courtroom?
Mr. Messer: None that we are going to use or none that
we-have used. __.
Mr. Simon: I \think the City Manager is here if I am
not mistaken.
90
Mr. Messer: Is the City Manager in the courtroom?
Mr. Simon: I may be in error then. I am sorry.
Mr. Messer: That’s all right.
Q. With whom did you have the long distance telephone
conversation?
A. With Mr. Bert Marshall, the Assistant Attorney Gen-
eral in Washingtgn.
Did you place that call?
. I did not.
He called you?
. He called me.
How long did you talk with Mr. Marshall?
. | would say not more than two minutes.
How was that conversatiog terminated?
. The conversation was terminated by me indicating—
by me.
[fol. 178] Q. Was it a voluntary termination?
A. On my part?
Q. Yes.
A. Yes, it was. .
Q. There was no interference on the part of anyone in
connection with your termination of the call?
A. I would not have terminated the conversation had
it not been for the fact that the policemen were coming in
and as a member of the group and the leader of the group I
wanted to be with the group.
Had it not been for their entranée I would not have
terminated the conversation.
Q. As a matter of fact, you were informed that the police
officers were arriving at the airport but you did not see
them arrive while you were in the telephone booth?
A. I did not.
Q. A member of your group gave you the information?
A. That's correct.
Q. There was no effort on the part of anybody, whether
connected with the City of Tallahassee or not, that forced
the termination of that long distance conversation?
A. By a physical act?
Q. By word or act or anything.
rOr>OPOPOE
91
A. The entrance of the policemen into the terminal to
[fol. 179] apprehend us was the factor that caused the ter-
mination of the conversation.
Q. But you did not see the entrance of the policemen
into the terminal while you were on the telephone?
. I did not see that, no.
You were informed of that—
. Yes.
(Continuing) —by one of your group?
. One of our group.
You voluntarily terminated the conversation?
. Yes.
. Were you interfered with in any way, or your group,
in using the seating facilities at the waiting room in the
lobby there of the Municipal Airport—
A. At no time.
Q. (Continuing) —until the police officers caused your
arrest on Friday morning?
A. At no time.
Q. You were not interfered with in any way with the
use of the rest rooms that you chose to use?
A. We were not.
Q. Now, the facilities at the restaurant out at the air-
port where you described that the sign read “Closed”, were
there any persons admitted to the facilities while that sign
was there?
[fol. 1801 <A. Not that I saw.
Q. Irrespective of race, whether they were white or
negro?
A. Not that I saw. '
Q. If there was discrimination in regard to the avail-
ability of the restaurant facilities it was discr
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.