Transcript of Record — Binks Mfg. Co. v. Ransburg Electro-Coating Corp.
Supreme Court brief1961
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
\
|
Ee COPY.
VOLUME |
¥
7 TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
ie, ; - 3
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1960 2
Zi
No. 501]
BINKS MANUFACTURING CO.,
RETITIONER,
’
d Vs,
RANSBURG ELECTRO-COATING CORPORATION,
ON WRIT OF TERTIORARI TO THE | NITED) “~“TATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SEVEN THE CIRKEUNI
) _ PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED OCTOBER 24. 4960
. CERTIORARI GRANTED DECEMBER 19, 1960
fos "&
RIBS =
$2.
Tad ated? Haar
.
>
eS Ses S-
meee
2
<a? BES Bs pad 5s
-
seit hes (BR
~ .
ee AE | SSSA aie
INDEX.
ra ities. ;
Substituted Counterclaim .......... |
Substituted Supplemental Counterclaim ¢.....0...... 3
Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer to Substituted Counter-
WO okays comes os eeu ahs hes ain pareh kg eis ee a!
Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer to Substituted Supple.
mental Counterclaim ..2........0..c0 cc cece eee eees 16
Plaintiff’s Substituted Croxs-Counterclaim ........ “ss On
Defendant's Substituted Answer to Substituted Cross. :
Counterclaim’
Interrogatories and Answers ....... i ate TPT eee 465
Exhibit A—Licensees of’ Defendant which have
licegses under both the air afid airless process (in
answer to Plaintiff’s*Interrogatory No. 2(a)).. 1
Exhibit B—Identification of all licenses granted by’
fhe Deféndant up to the date of ‘the filing of the
Complaint (in answer to Plaintiff’s Interroga-
bee Be. BIO os kei [Meee seen. 85
» Exhibit C—Identifieation of Defendant's licensees
whose agreements have been modified (in answer
to Plaintiff’s Interrogatory No, 7(¢))..... en
Exhibits D-23, D-25, 1:26, D-29, and D-35—KFive of
, Defendant’s license agreement forms from
among the forty-five forms supplied in answer
to Plaintiff's Interrogatory No. 8 ............. 114
Exhibit K—List of Defendant's licensees identify-
ing the specific license form applicable to each
licew&ee (in answer to Plaintiff's Interrogatory
Oe Rr ery Oran ee ne re tery 152
ee a = en ee ee + ween
Volume I, pages 1 to 719; Volume II, pages 721 to 1148.
ii
Exhibit F--Patents and patent applications iden-
tified 1 certain of Defendant's licenses (in an-.
swet to Plaintiff’s Interrogatory No. 34)....... 178
Exhibit G—Record of-shipment of typi¢al equip-
ment supplied by Defendant to a licensee (in
answer to Plaintiff's Interrogatory No. 36)°... 182
Exhibit H—Identification of licenses taken over
by»Defendant from its predecessor (in answer
to Plaiggiff’s Interrogatory No. 37(b) (e) (d)
MMS SSA aU aie weg ne ace Meare tone woes 184
Exhibit K—Identifieation of foreign licensees of
Defendant (in answer to Plaintiff's Interroga-
* tory No. 90(b))... 0... agers ene Tie 192
' Exhibit M-—List of Defendant’s agreements under
which articles were painted for the U. S. Gov-
ernment (in answer to Plaintiff’s Interrogatory
We. 100 (hy ai GO) co oe ci cs Ce cscs ie wears 193
Request for Admissions and Answers .......%...... 194
Memorandum Opinion on Defendant’s Motion for Sum-
I IE ooo occa oie) os roe een oko 219
Order denying motion for Summary Judgment... 226
Stipulation re: Patents and Exhibits AVR ER aS 226
Order for production of ee err eee 228
Stipulation re: Publication, ete............. 0. ...000. , 230°
Stipulation Rt IG aiin aa cca eeeas ena cuweicens 231
Letter Mar. 4, 1955, Trageser to Amstus. . is ee 232
Gtipebation rq: CAR, Oe, oo... cee cee cee can 233
stiri ee eT eee eee 235
Stipulation re: Defendant’s knowledg@of Prior Art... 236
Letter Feb. 19, 1948, Ranspurg to Simmons....... 237
Letter Sept. 21, 1953, Stellman to Ransburg ...... 238
ee PN ls oa Wed Ga Sa dias odie x sida onan 239
Stipulation regarding: Patent Rights . pies Liao ast eee
a na ee | ee a ——— ne ee Se
Volume I, pages 1 to 719; Volume II, pages o 721 t to > 1148.
iii, o
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDING. ° ‘
Colloqay 0... eee ee on eevee ee DMT, 997, 412
oe ; ‘
; WitNesses FoR DEFENDANT.
Testimony a | * \.
Darrah, William (Deposition of) ©. 0............ 394
Pe I os os oo eos os as ows nes 391 .
Miller, Emery P. .............. ers Pin caant aes 250
I, SE sie paps aed ccm okie eS 408, 419
Plaintiff’s Exhibit KKKK-—Deposition hdwin M.
Ranebere «oo... ceca Nadie tid Csr aoe eica eae hares 490
Plaintiff's Exhibit LL.LL—Deposition of Hareld P.
el circadian wakes Coup eek nae Gh enen at 535
Plaintiff's Exhibit MMMM—Deposition of Emery P,
ci) See ee ee eee Paar ee ae bak 552
Plaintiff’s Exhibit NNNN—Deposition of Donald C.
ME © + Thai er awt See hed a eeeya swans teneen ess cus 570
Deposition of Milton F. Pleva................05. 610
Deposition of Elmer Houlberg.................. 628
Deposition of Paul Rothe.......... 5.6.0.6 .e eee 634
Deposition of Clarence FE. a 636
Deposition of Andrew G. Hubbard............. 6. 646
Deposition of Clarence Goltermann......~ si nin ay
Plaintiff’s Exhibit O00O0—Deposition of William <A.
Dont eer te ee Ae eae
Plaintiff’s Exhibit LLLLL—Deposition of Burke
IND ince oc nuw dba eiaac ee as cccves © 6h8 672
Deposition of John W. Baur... ........0... 05.05. 686
Deposit of Benjamin J. Hedger.......2...... 694
Plaintiff’s Exhibit MMMMM—Deposition of James i.
Rice . Ao Wikdchnee we aea ke eee «Reena ks Pa eae in 698
ee — — ee
wa es a
Ween I, pages 1 to 7119; Volume i, pages 5721 | to 1148.
iW
Piainrire’s Kx iiners,
"JosRave 4 of Laboratory, Notebook
"2 Pave Yof Lahorgtory Notebook. 000.2... 66
3 Page 11 of Laboratory Notebook... .. De rere cea
V.-4—- Page 12 of Laboratory Notebook... 00.0.0...
V-5--Page 13 of Laboratory Nofebook. . CRE re re ste
V-6—Sheet dated May 11, 1044 of Laboratory Note-
Ne as cena Tata RM eats ek a oa PN ek 8 eon 726
V-7——Page 15 of Labtratory Notebook......... tiie eae
i —Memo of March 22, 1951 of Gregg Ransburg. .... 729
~ S—Letter July. 15, 1953, Ransburg to Se ey eee 730
Z-1—Letter May 27, 19% 53, Ransburg to Ainsworth. .... 731
BB-1—LettereMay 9, 1955, Maxwell to All-Steel Equip-
Me Cl cy Sale Wp ides vce a Fink Ve serene 732
FF- 1—Letter Sept. 22, 1953) Maxwell to AKSteel
Ett eae ie POL ah MOM ET Ae ND 733
FF:3—Letter May 21, 1954, Maxwell to General sElec: :
eae WR es viens Cmte sinc teeees @. ket ae 734
FF-5—Letter Mareh 20, “1952, Stone to eine al Eke os
SO en gine it rlaeneteanatnnncaniececn yA 9 he area 735
FF -6—Letter March 4, 1952, Mailly to Ransburg...... 736
FF-9—Letter Oct. 4, 1955, Hughes to Body. .2........ 736
FE-10-—Letter July 28, 1954, Miller to General Elee-
trie Co, | 738°
LI-1—Letter Get. 19, 1956. Johnson to Wadsworth. .-.. 7
TT-2—-Memo, Oct. 24, 1955, Re? General Eléetric Cor,
a Arn ere ster Na nent Eg RO gnc
I-4—Hughes Memo re: General Electrié, dated Dee.
We We xe ae Soaks Warr renters BEN pmo
‘Hef —Letter Ang: 20, 1951, © reps to’ Air-Way Seale
I ree ie ig reek VL weuinie
(1-6—Letter Apr. 30, F956, Millefto Creps. ot. 01.0.4,
I[-7—Letter May 7, 1953, Johnson to Ransbyrg ae ss ie
KK—Sales Bulletin of Jannary 19, 1958. Sie Rd RE PS ot
es
Voluroah pages | to 719; Vohane iM, ai ra to 1148,
V
2
NN—Sales Bulletin Noo-100, dated May 27, 1953—
EERE Se ee Pe eReY VLEET e ee: ee
», OO—Pricing schedule, dated Aug. 5, 1S 152. naa aye -, 106
SS—Assignment of Pugh Patent to Ranmsburg....... 762
TT—Assignment between Ransburg and Brush Devel,
zz NE Cs ncecnd vacnee ans ga ATS TOR beige ee
1 , UN reement between, Ransburg and Be ‘hr-Manning
ACY ane ene Mike ed Sm Ran a Caan 771
-VV—Agreement between Ransburg and Research ,
CIN os ve ckcacce avs ree a pare fos ee
XX—Miller Memo to Patent Attorneéys............ ©
7Z-7-—Agreement aogna Ransburg and Kastern ,
TUR TOR ins nk oe BE iis sane ', 793
_*ZZ-8—-Agreement betw een Ransburg and DuPont ere 800
* G@GG—Drawing from Ransburg Servi ice Manuel for ¥°
Se err EET Po Ot Ew ORE ry eer are awry ae 807
III-1—Sales Bulletin No. 132, dated: June 15, 1954.... 809
_ ITI-83—Price Wérk Sheet, datedsNov. 3,.1954....... alte git
I{]-4 Letter hee 3, 1954, Howarth to Zadoff..... , os oo
JJJ-2—Pricing Guide for No. 2 Spray Process, dated
I, 6. 20h gs ac koe ee es oy sccesetes OLE”
KKK—Letter May 27, 1953, Ransburg to General Elec-
MR Ci aaa anak ea ee Se ee a ee 819
LLL-1—Letter Mar. 23, 1954, Maxwell to Webster-
i a EN ge cicero ca rawh Feb econ cae Wives. 822
LLL-2—Letter May 27, 1953, Ransbarg to W ebster- |
I BOG Bey Wie eG ao bade tn caathies 4s R24
LLL-3—Letter June 3, 1953, Webster-C hicako ( orp. to
Ransburg Ly FR Cre Ee Chek ung kiana 825
LLL-4--Memo of June 26, 1953, Pleva to Ransburg. ... 26
NNN—Letter June 17, 1955, Ransburg to W estinghouse
Electric + ee ert ee PAY . 827
O00—Letter July 26, 1955, ee to Chicago Rawhide
Mfg. cans bares te Cee ea were cyan ores ks R28
i. nee oe ne eng yee ee ee ne ee = — re Es oe on
Volume I, pages Ty to 719; When ry pages 7m to 1148,
f
}
\ : “s
’ .
va
‘ ae
.
x i age
%
\
XXNX—Letter Jan, 18, 1954, Ransburg to A vr
vi >
4
PPP-1 Chicago Rawhide Purchase Order—No. 100410,
Rated: Wag: 1b, Fie i tacks os ea kere eins veeweees 832
PPP-2—-Letter Nov, 4; 1955, Downer to Chicago Raw- .
ME ee ak ORR Cae eee eas a3F
PPP-3—Ransburg Drawing No. 23) B49, dated Aug.
i. Oar Syd a6 30k Sb AED Se Re eee 835
SSS—:; Agreement hets ween Ransburg and Hotpoint, Ine. 837
EEEE—Booklet entitled--‘‘Ransburg Coating Proc-
‘tsses” dealing with the No. 1 system and the detear-
_ ing pr A SER AE aay an eae aaa ai 847
[11f—KEarly brochure on the Ransburg No. 2 process. . .861
PPPP—Correspondence with Behr-Manning Corpora-
ena a SEA a a baat aa RES 862 °
TTTT—Letter Apr. 6, 1955, Miller to Pee Parts ©
INE ag S iain y cp eR are x et Oey Pee. 876
UUUU—Booklet entitled tiene No. 2 pve”
° CopPright 1956, 1957 0s. eee eee eee cena 877
VVVV—Letter Aug. 14, 1951, aac to Cleveland Weld-
INT CO. ore ebiec eee Var cece eceensececepeeeee 881
-WWWW-Letter July 9, 1951, Maxwell to Aluminum
RGN Bs Ses ag See S ieee tker as eee 882
OU Bos Go rice cuch pease cr area 886
YYYY— -Cat] Report dated Mar. 11, 1949, signed io
DION iaicacy cilvusiwbinwsses Ktovsenas ,-- 892
V#7.Z-1—Letthr July 3, 1956, Baur to eee apn 894
‘ ZZZZ-2—Letter July es 1956, Ranshurg to Binks Mfg
BU pases Ads Fe Ard eA ae Ce aa ee Cee ek 895
7III-3—¥ erm for Electro-Spray eiiees.. cere ees 896.
7227-5—Form for Ransburg Electro-Spray Agreement 899
.. ZZZZ-7—-Letter July 25, 1936, Baur to Ransburg...... 904
Z7778—Binks Drawing—SK 661 .2....... ‘eateagax ae
LLLL.- 9—Letter Aug. 16, 1956, Ransburg to Binks Mfg. ?
CMO cena a Cy Pleas os Poaceae: ee eee 907
¥
WL 10—Letter Aug. 2 22, 1956, Baur to Ransburg. . . 908
Vaqume i, pages % to 719; ‘Volume i, pages m1 to i
ae
os
m& vii
“”
Ne ere MP Te Sh ee ar ry
ZZZZ-12—-Letter Sept. 12, 1956, Baur to Ransburg..... {
ZZZZ-13—Letter Sept. 21, 1956, Ransburg to Binks
‘ ZZZZ-11—Letter Aug. 31, 1956, Ransburg to Binks =
NE a eS fewrit cea nn adn eekes Pee Peery 911
AAAAA—Letter Dee. 11, 1956, Ransburg to rene
Ludlum Steel Corp. ..........- 5.4, SEIT aro BR - 912
CCCCC—Letter May 16, 1952, Ransburg to General
Sa OSS ERE Oe a Me al a So 917
GGGGG—Article by Boys appearing in ‘* The aaa
Edinburgh apd Dublin Philosophical Magazine” Vol.
| SE EE 656 as 462s An eee ewes
Article by’ Zeleny appearing in Proceedings of
Cambridge Philosophical Society— Vol. 18, pages
71-83 (1915) ........ _ SRE partes ae
Article by Zeleny appearing in ‘‘The Physical
Review’’-—2rld. Ser. Vol. X,-No. 1, pages 1-6
RN I ee cause chance
Article by Nolan and O’Keeffe appearing in Pro-
ceedings of Royal Irish Academy, Vol. XXXIX,
~~” «nage 21 (1999) ....-......00. Dieta oe ae
NNNNN—Expenses of Midwest Research Institute. .
QQQQQ—Midw rest Research Institute proposal R,230. .
RRRRR—Midwest- Research ‘Institute Progress Re-
port No. Pree ha ae ee Wee viasGediwes
XXXXX*_Letter Oct. 17, #956, Herman E. Miller to
Ne SN cc hoc ta ced oes eenanr ew een es Pe
: ‘DEFENDANT’ s Exusits.
No 10. A—Photo of physical exhibit No. 9 showing
side view Dic are sdorarn ie vuiw we Wen wig ann A wt See nea
No. 10-D—Photo of physical exhibit No. 9 showing
paint streaming from emitter... 0.0.0 00.....00005.
No. 1- A—Chart of head. atomizing uuit Jae GE ae nAtne fF
Volume 1, pages 7 to ‘79; Volume ul, pages 721 to 1148.
+
918
921
934
941
. 943
945,
951
955
-
“vail : /
No. 17-B—Chart of Reciprocating (isk atomizing unit’. 960
No. 17-C—Chart of tifting disk atomizing unit ....... ‘961
No. 18-A—Photo of SK-661-emitting OR ener 962
No. 18-B—Photo of SK-661 emitting paint ..... aes 963
No. 41—Letter ey 1,,1958, Downer to Aveo Mfg. Go... 960
— Letter Oct. 7 1948, Redfield to Downer ......... 966
- Letter Oct. ‘2: 1958, Dow ner to Redfield ......... 967 ©
Findingsof Fact ...:...6 5.1 e eee “og Serre & 968
Con@usions ee ke eae i Gin ha ee kos CA 1014
Order amending Conclusion of Law No, 9.. a eeraD Ey. 1016
Judgment, entered June 18, 1959... . eae "it ake 1017 *
Notice of Appeal ......... a ‘i lo igh PSE TOO EE eS, 1019
Order extending time ....... nee sare s te ‘vees go ee
ts
Unitrep States LETTERS PATENT. .
"No, 2,685,536-—W. A. Starkley, et al, Aug. 3, 1954..,..1021
No. 2,794,417-—W. A. Starkley, et al., June 4, 1957..... 1029
Re. No. 22419—-J. S. Smyser, Jan. 11, 1944........... 1037
7 1,360,654—-E. E. Littlefield, Nov. 30, 1920......... 1049
Nd. 1,475,995—L. Heis, et al., Dee. 4, 1923......... 9 £1057
No. 1,854,475—KE. E. Littlefield, Apr. 19, 19382......... 1067
- No. 1,855,869—BE. Pugh, Apr. 26, 1932............... 1078
No. 1,958,406—W. A. Darrah, May 15, 1934. . arene 1081
No. 2,221,338—H..A. ‘Wintermute, Nov. 12, 1940..... 4. ,. 1087
No. 2,247,963—IT. P. Ransburg, et al., July 1, 1941..... 1095
No, 2,270,341—H. P. Ransburg, Jan, 20, 1942......... 1105
No. 2,359,476—C. K. Gravley, Oct. 3, 1944...... eae 1113
No. 2,417,798—H. P. Ransburg, et al., Mar. 18, 1947... 1123
No. 2,651,287-—-R. H. Turner.Sept. 8, 1953............ 1135
No. 2,658,009.—F. M. Ransburg, Nov. 3,1953.......... 1141
hd
‘Yeluane I, pages | to 719; Volume il, piges 721 to 1148.
¢ . ¢
. ’
°
° 7
\ : :
INDEX ( , x
* eee oe
e , Original Pant ¥
Proceedings in the Uniteil States Court, of Appeals for the =
Seventh Circuit Mu
Appendix, to brjgf for oneal, Volumes I and H, see
separate indices .
Appendix to brief for defendant: ue V lume III, see sepa- 4
rate index ca the :
Record from the United States District Court for the Southern
District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division - 511 bll ¢
excerpt of transcript of testimony of Emery’ P. Miller « on , ;
redirect examination iccal 512 511
« Plaintiff's Exhibit i1111—Judgment in the case of U.S. v.
Minnesota Mining. and Mangfacturing Co. et al., C. A, 8119
filed in the U.S.D.C. for the District of Massachusetts, ‘dated
November 6, 1950...) ~4 514512
Plaintiff's Exhibit JJJJJ—United States Letter rs Patent om 533
Number Issued ‘Title
RE20,660 Feb, 22, 1938 Method of Coating and Appara-
tus Lherefor and Product _.. 536” 543
2027087 =Jan. 7, 1936 ‘Abrasive Sheet and Process of
, ‘Making the Same, 548548
2027308 * Jan. 7, 1936 Manufacture of Abrasive Art# ° ;
9 cles * 551 548
2027309 = Jan. 7, 1936 Abrasive Material. 5%. 554551
2082182 | June 1, 1937 Manufacture of Abrasive Arti- a
: are aa cles ea 562 559
2245301 June 10, 1941 Manufacture of Abtasive Arti-.
. cles 565 62. +
2279361 Arpril 14, 1942 _ Electrostatic Coating a 569. SAG
* 2287837 = June 30,1942 Method and Apparatus for Ap-
ae plying Coating Materials 574 571
2318570 May 4; 1943 Manufacturgof Abrasives» “. 5384 581
2318571 May 4, 1943 Manufacture of Abrasives 600 597
2328577 Sept.7,1943 Process and Apparatus for Grad-
or" ae ing and for Coating with Com-
minuted Materials 0. 614 611
2376342 May 22, 1945 Manufacture of—Abrasivts 625 624
%
@
x
~~
Record from the United States District Court for the Scuthern.
INDEX
District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division-—Continuea
Defendant’s Exhibit 5A (Excerpts)
Page 10 of Applicant’s Amendment filed Juhe, 28, 1945 °
‘Pages 14 and 29 of Applicatit’s Board of Appe als Brief tiled
January 5, 1951 . : EE a S44 SNe Ra AOE
Defendant’s Exhibit 5B (Bxcerpts). a
Affidavit of Gilbert Isgrigg filed March 20, 1953
Affidavit of Donald C. Howarth filed March 20, 1953
Page 15 of Applicant’s Board of Appeals Brief filed May 25,
: 1953 .
Page 5 of Board of Appeals decision dated Dev " mber 18, 19538
Defendant's Exhibit 6 (Excerpt) ible oa
Amendment C, filed August 3, 1956 ‘
Defendant's Exhibit 21— United States Letters Patent .
Number:
1854071
: a
2047525
2087260
2152077
2146385
2173032
2173078
2174328
2217126
2218445
2222539
2223476
Issued
April 12,1932
July 14, 1936"
%
f)
July 20, 1937
March 28, 1939 >
July 18, 1939
Sept. 12, 1939
Sept. 12, 1939
Sept «26, 1939
Oct. 8, 1940
Oct. 15, 1940
Nov. 19, 1940
—
Dee. 3, 1940
Title
Method, of Manufacturing Abra-
"eee
Insulating Method dor ‘Blectri-
cal and Thermo-Technica] Pur-
poses, and Apparatus for
Accomplishing the Same
Homogenous Piled Surtave
Production of Piled Surfaces in
Pattern Form .
Determining Electrical Charac-
NINN i cccdsesCorcasaisacs
Production of Pile Surfaced
Materials _.
Production of Piled Surfaces
Piled Surface in Pattern Form
Piled Surface in Pattern Form .
Onginal Print
ei.”
%
637
637
638
640
640
643
646
* 647
649
649
652
652
Production of Pile Surface 2
Materials ............
Method of and Apparatus ‘tor
Making Pile-Surfaced Sheets
Method for Making Pile Falies
‘649
654 _-
659
663
' 673
' 677
687
694
_ 699
708
712:
718
INDEX xi
Original Print
Record from the United States District Court for the Southern
District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division—Continued
Detendant’s Exhibit 21—United States Letters Patent—Con-
tinued
Number Issued : Title
2231324 Feb.11,1941 °©Apparatus for arfd Method of
. Making Hat Bats — 728 725
2248064 July 8, 1941 Coating, Particularly for Manu.
‘ facture of Abrasives / 732° . 729
2248853 July 8, 1941 Abrasive Article and: Method of
Making Same 748 745
2281558 May 5, 1942 Manufacture of Abrasive Arti-
>. cles and Apparatus Therefor 763 760
2356489 + Aug. 22,1944 | Apparatus for Coating 7740771
— 23706386 ‘Marca 6,1945 Manufacture of Abrasives 787 784 |
2371605 March 20,1945 Coating, Particularly for Manu-
* facture of Abrasives | 800-797
2376343 May 22. 1945 Manufacture of Abrasives 815 812
, 2876922 May 29, 1945 Method of and Apparatus for :
Making Pile Fabrics .. ' 824 821
2447374 Aug. 17, 1948 Method of Applying Coating 7
id. <i Materials ....... .. 833 830
Opinion, Castle, J. ..... ; hai root : 84] 838
Judgment cies : ; ' 855 852
Clerk’s cé@rtificate rere in printing) ! 856 852
Order allowing certiorari | 857 BSS
: «3
o
a
q
SUMMARY OF PERTINENT DOCKET ENTRIES.
Datowog: , | Butry
October 11. 1956—Complaint filed and Summons issued,
October 26, W56--Plaintiff files amendment to complaint.
Plaintiff files Interrogatories Nos, 1 to 32 to Defendant.
‘ October 8€, 1956—Defendant files Notice of Taking deposi-
tions,
November 8, 1956 ~Defendant, files Interrogatorieg Nos. 1
» to 9 to Plaintiff.
November 15,.°1956-—Defendant files answers tg Plaintiff's
Interrogatories Nos’ 1 to 82.
November 23, 1956—-Plaintiff files answers to Interroga-
tories 1 to 9.
a _ December 3, 1956—Defendant files Answer and Connter-
( claim. O°
' December 10, 1996 Plaintiff files Answer to Counterelatm
q and files cross-counterclaim,. Plaintiff files motion for
order of Dismissal by Court under Rule 41(a) (2).
December 26, 1956—-Plaintiff files Interrogatories Nos.. 83
e = to 59. 2 zi
January 14, 1957--Defendant files answer to Tnterroga-
tories Nos, 38 to 59, n!
January 29, 1957—-Court sustains Plaintiff's motion for
, order of dismissal pt its Complaint; Complaint ordered
~ dismissed. Court grants Plaintiff leave to five Cross-
counterelaim tendered ta the Caurt with the above
motion on December 10, 1956. Plaintiff files Cross-
counterelaim,
og February 18, 1957)" Defendant files answer to Plaintiff's
} Cross-counterclaim, |’
| August 28, 1957—-Plaintitf filos Notice of taking depasitions,
‘ November 20, 1957-—Defendant files Tnterrogatories Nos. 10
° | ty 24 inclusive to Plaintiff
. Date ne Entry
ee ne
December 10, 1957—Plaintiff files In¥rrogatories Nos. 60
* to 88 to Defendant.
December 13, 1957—Plaintiff files answer to Defendant's
i” Interrogatories 10 to 24.
January 16, 1958—Defendant files answers to Interroga-
tories Nos. 60 to 88,
February 19, 1958—Plaintiff files motion for leave to amend
answer to Counterelaim and Cross-counterclaim,
February 20, 1958--Defendant files depositions of Roche,
Baur, and Hedger,
March 5, 1958——Court grants Plaintiff leave to amend an-
swer to Counterclaim and Cross-counterclaim, Plain-:
tiff files amendment to Plaintiff’s Answer to Counter-
claimand its Cross-counterelaim,
March 31, 1958 Defendant files Supplement to Defend-
ant's answer to Plaintiff's Cross-counterelaim,
April 3, 1958—Plaintiff files Interrogatories Nos. 89 to 92
to Defendant. |
April 18, 1958—Defendant files Answers to Interrogatories
Nos. 89 to 92 inelusive of Plaintiff.
May 14, 1958—Plaintiff files Requests for Admissions Nos,
— 1 to 24.
May 26, 1958—Defendant files Answers to Plaintiff's Re-
quests for Admissions. Defendant files Motion for
Summary Judgment with anvaffidavit of HK. M. Rans-
burg. :
June 9, 1958—Plaintiff files Motion for order for produc-
tion of documents under Rule 34,
June 11, 1958-—P laintiff, files Answer to Defendant's Sup-
plemental ( ounte relaim.
June 13, 1958-—Plaintiff fites depositions of Howarth, Pleva,
° Houlberg, Rothe, Wallin, Hubbard and Goltermann,
ra)
Date Entry “
June 18, 1958—Plaintitf files additional Interrogatories
Nos. 93 to 133. Plaintiff files Requests for Admissions
Nos. 25 to 78,
June 30, 1958—Defendant files answers to Plaintiff’s fur-
ther Requests for Admissions Nos, 25 to 78.
July 1, 1958—Plaintilf files depositions of Downer, Miller,
EK. M. Ransburg and H. P. Ransburg. 2
July 3, 1958—Defendant files answers to Interrogatories
Nos. 93 to 133.
August 7-8, 1958—Pretrial conference held, » *
August 25, 1958---Court enters order for produetion of
documents under Rule 84 by the Defendant. Court
enters order of pretrial conference held, Hearing held
, on Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment; said
motion taken under advisement. |
September 2, 1958—Court files memorandum opinion;
ordered and adjudged that the Defendant's Motion for
Summary Jrdgthent is denied,
September 16, 1958< Teintin” files Interrogatories Nos, 134
to 199 and Requtsts. for Admissions 79 to 110.
September 18, 195%—Defendant files depositions of Rice,
Gustafson, Johnson and Stephens. |
October 10, 1958--Defendant files Interrogatories Nos. 25
to 223 to Plaintiff and Requests for Admissions Nos.
1 to 59. Defendant files answers to Plaintiff's Requests
for Admissions Nos. 79 to 110 and Answers.to Plain-
tiff’s Interrogatories Nos, 134 to 199,
October 30, 1958—Plaintiff files answers to Defendant's
: Request for Admissions.
November 6, 1958—Plaintiff files answers to Defendant's
Interrogatories Nos. 25 to 223.
’ , . wit & ‘
November 12, 1958—Defendant filex.4abstituted Counter-
claim and substituted Supplemental Counterclaim,
Date ; Ent ry
November 14, 1958—Plaintiff files Motion for Order to
conipel compliance with paragraphs oO and 6 of Order
: for Production of Pocuments under Rule 84) or in the
alternative, to produce the papers and records claimed
to be privileged for the Court's determination,
ry November 19, 1958——VPlaintill files substituted: Auswer to
, Defendant's Sabstituted Counterclafna with proof of
service, Praigtit! files Substituted: Cross-counterelaim,
9% November 26, 1958--Parties file stipulations regarding
patent rights of Defendant; stipulation “under Rule
42()); stipulation relating to kaxhibits (1 to Dedd and
Exhibit E; also file sfipulation regarding Defendant's
knowledge of prior art. Defendant files substituted an-
swer to Plaintiff's substituted Cross-counterclaim,
December 14, 1958—Plaintitt files deposition of Darrah,
Cause submitted for trial on Defendant's Counter:
claim. Piaintilf’s Motion te Compel Compliance with
paragraphs 5 and 6 under Rifle 34 withdrawn, De-
fendant voluntarily complies with alternative request
afid tenders Defendant's Exhibit No, 1, which theCourt
exqmines and finds it toche privileged. amd de tideseaal-
. ternative motion, orders dixhibit T sealed and not dis-
closable to anyone except the Judge and Defendant
Opening statements of partres heard in part and con-
tinued. |
December 16, 1958 to December 19, 1958 Trial resumed but
‘
not concluded,
January 5, 1959 to Japuarys, 10 Pital resumed and eon
cluded,
April 16, 1959--Order of the Court assigning cause for
final argument on June 16, 1950, »
June 3, 1999— Parties file Stipulation waiving final argo.
ment,
June 4, 1950—-Conrt approves stipulation waieng final
argument.
© Q' Date “ Entry
- June 16, 1950-—( ‘ourt files its Hindings of Fact and Con-
* clusions of Law.
dune 1s, 1950 Court files coriee dag entey relating to Cone
olusion of Law No. 9 Court enters Judgment for De-
fendant. Court enters Jddgment that Patents Nos,
2,685,586 and 2,794,417 are valid and infringed 4
Plaintiff. Plaintiff enjoined from use, sant
or sale of process or device covered by claims in said
4 : patents or infringement thereon, Defendant to re-
cover damages for infringement ‘of Said patents too
2 gether with reasonabie attorneys fees and costs, Cause
continued as to issues covered in stipulation of parties
a vg Rifle 4205). 2P laintiff's © ross,counterclain «lis
missed and Dete) dant to recover its Posts thereon,
July 2.1959) Plaimtiff files Notice of Appeal,
\
ne
mo : %
SMOstififled Counterclaim, * 4
APPENDIX.
‘ $ ‘ ‘ ~
R14 United Staves Dasraior Coury,
Southern Distriet of Indiana,
Indianapolis Division,
Binks Manufacturing Company (a
corporation of the State of Dela-
ware), ‘ F
| a Mawlf. | ciyit Action No.
_ IP 56-0262 |
Rausburg Electro-Coating Corp. |
(2 worporation of the State of |
Tndiana), !
: Defendant, |
, ' ”
SUBSTITUTED COUNTERCLAIM,
MOriginal Filed December 3, 1956.)
Now comes: defendant-countercomplainant, Ransburg
Klectro-Coating Corp. an [idiana corporation having its
principal office and place of business at Tudianapolis, In-
diana, and files .this its counterclaim, against plainti?-
counter-defendant, Binks Manufacturing Company, a Dela-
ware corporation having its principal office and place of
business at Chicago, Tlinois, and in support of its eause
of action avers:
1, This action arises under the Patent Laws of the
United States, 35 U.S. C., See, 271,281 et meg.
2, On August 3, 1954, United States Letters Patent No.
2,685,536 were duly and lopally - issued te defendant-
countercomplainant for an invention of a Method for
Electrostatically Coating Articles; and since that date de-
fendant-countercomplainant has been and still is the owiler
of those Letters Patent. |
3. Plaintiff-counterdetendant has since August 8, 1954,
°
» Substituted Counterclaim.
infringed those, Letters Patent -by practicing the process
covered thereby, and will continue to do so unless enjoined
by this Court. a 5 j
Wherefore, defendant-countercomplainant prays. for
judgment against the plaintiff-counterdefendant :
815 a, Foran injunction against infringement, direct or
contributory, by plaintiff-counterdefendant and those
controlled by it. |
b. For damages as provided by Title 85 U. S.C, See.
284-285, including reasonable attorneys’ fees, costs and
interest, and for an accounting to ascertain the amount
thereof. —* a
e. For such other and further relief as this Court may
deem just.
‘Ransburg Electro-Coating,
By Verne A. Trask,
, 801 Hume Mansur Building,
Indianapolis 4, ‘Iydiana, ’
Attorney for Defendant and
Countercomplainant,
0
Of Counsel:
Elbert R. Gilliom,
340-1344 Consolidated Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana. ste, ,
Harry T. lee,
451 Consolidated Building,
ndianapolis 4, Indiana.
James P. Hume,
First National Bank Building,
38 South Dearborn Street,
Chicago 3, Illinois.
4
7 Receipt of copies of the foregoing Substituted Counter:
claim (original filed December 3, 1956) acknowledged this
12th day of November, 1958. .
@
|
- Harold B. Hood, !
‘Attorney for Plawtiff.
e v
we
Substituted Supplear veal Counderclaim.,
i
\
S16 Usirep Sraves\ Distaier Coun. ,
=a (Caption 0-22) °° & ,
SUBSTITUTED SUPPLEMENTAL COUNTERCLAIM,
(Original Filed May 2), 1958.)
Now comes the defendant, Ramsburg Klectro-Coating
Corp., and supplements its cause tof action against the
plaintiff’ Binks Manufacturing Company, as asserted in
its counterclaim, by making the following allegations ;
4. On June 4, 1957,"United States Letters Patent No,
2,794,417 were duly and lovally issued to defendant, Rans
burg KBleetro-Coating Corp,, for an invention covering an
Apparatus for Blecaoccatically Coating Articles, and since
that date defendant has been, and still is, the owner of
said Letters Patent. |
5. Since June 4, 1957, and prior to the filing of this
supplemental counterclaim, plaiftift, Binks Manufacturing
Company, has been, and: still is, dufringing, as presently
advised, at least claim ™ of said Letters Patent, and will
continue to do so unless enjoined by this Court, .
Wherefore, defendant-countercomplainant prays for
judgment against the plaintiff-counterdefendant :
a For an injunction against infringement, direct or
contributory, of said) Letters Patent No. 2,794,417 by
plaintiff-counterdefendant or those controlled by it.
bh. For damagessas provided in Title 85 U.S.C,
S17 $$ 284-285, including reasonable attorneys’ feos, costs,
and interest, and for an accounting to ascertain the °
amount thereof with respect to said Letters Patent No.
2,794,417. |
\ sf
4. ° Substituted Supplemental Counterclarm.,
e. For such other and further relief as this Court may
deem just.
Rauisburg Electro-Coating Corp.,
By Verne A. Trask,
801 Hume Mansur Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana,
Attorney for Defendant-
Countercomplainant.
Of Counsel:
Elbert R. Gilliom,
, 1340-1344 Consolidated Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana.
Harry T. Iee,
951 Consolidated Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana.
James FP. Hume,
First National Bank Building,
38 South Dearborn Street t, |
Chicago 3, Illinois. ;
=
Receipt pf copies of the foregoing Substituted Supple-
mental Counterclaim (original filed May 21, 1958) acknowl-
edged this 12th day of November, 1958.
. Harold B. Hood, oe
. Attorney for Plaintif-
«7
£ Counterdefendant.
in
Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer, ete, . §
\;
818 Ix cue Unirep Srares District Court.
* * (Caption—56-C-262) * °
PLAINTIFF’S SUBSTITUTED ANSWER TO _
DEFENDANT’S SUBSTITUTED COUNTERCLAIM.
(Original filed December. 10, 1956.).
Plaintiff, Binks Manufacturing Company, answers the
substituted counterclaim as follows:
First Defense.
J. Plaintiff admits the allegations of paragraph 1.
2. Plaintiff admits that United States Letters Patent
‘No. 2,685,536 was issued of August 3, 1954 and the De-
fendant is owner as alleged in paragraph 2, but Plaintiff
denieg=that said Letters Patent were duly and legally
issued.
¢
3. Plaintiff denies the allegations of paragraph 3.
p ‘ .
Second Defense,
4. The Plaintiff alleges that the following listed refer-
ences clearly evidence that the claims of the Starkey. °
. 819 et al., Patent No. 2,685,536 are devoid of invention:
__ As Anticipation.
Heis et al, U. ‘8. Patent No. 1, 475,995 of Dee. 4, 1923
_ Littlefield, U.S: Patent No. 1,360, 654 of Nov. 30, 1920
Littlefield; U.S. Patent No. 1,854,475 of: Apr. 19, 1932
Pugh, U. S. Patent No. 1,855,869. of Apr. 26,.1932
Darrah, U. S. Patent No. 1,958,406 of May 15, 1934
Wintermute, U. S. Patent No. 2,221,338 of Noy. 12; 1940
Ransburg et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,247,963 of Wuly -1, 1941
Gravley, U. S. Patent No. 2,359,476 of Oét. 3, 1944
<
(j Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete.
‘ Y .
THe London, Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophieal. Maga
“zine, Volume XXIII, page 490 (1887).
Electrical Hxperinghits by Francis, page 87 (1850).
Zeleny, The Phy cal Review, Secoad Series, Vol. TE, “om
1 " '
2 (Febr uary? 114), pages 69-91,
Zeleny, Proceedings of ‘the Cambridge Philosophical Soo
ciety, Vol. 18, pages 71-88 (1915).
Zeleny; The Physieal Review, Second Series, Volume X,
-No. 1, pages 1-6 (July, 1917). ° | .
Zeleny, The Physical Review, Second Series, V olume XVI.
No. 2, pages 102-125 (1920),
Zeleny, Journal of the Franklin Inssitute, Volume 219,
No. 6, pages 659675 (June, 1935), ¢
Proceedings of the Royal Trish Academy Volume XNXIX,
Page 21 (1929). .
; wt
420 To Show the State of the Prior Art.’
Smyser, U.S, Patent No. Re, 22,419 of Jan. 11. 1944
DeVars, U. S. Patent No. 398,327 of Feb, 19, 1889
Simpson, U. S. P@tent No. 601,594 of Mar, 29, 1898. .
_Morton, U. S. Patent No. 705,691 of July 29, 1902
Wickson, U. S. Patent No. 735,638 of Aug. 4, 1908
Cooley, U. S. Patent No. 745,276 of Nov. 24, 1903 °
Fitzgereld, U.S. Patent No. 805,719 of Nov. 28, 1905
Althouse, U. S. Patent No. 1,153,004 of Sept. 7, 1915
Gentile, U. S. Patent No. 1,454,376 of May &, 1928
Fraser, U. S. Patent No. 1,478,113 of Dee 18, 1928
. Wille et al, U. S. Patent No. 1,638,757 of Aug, 9, 1927
' Hampton et al, U. S. Patent No, 1,740,981 of Dee. 24, 1929
, Collins, U. S. Patent No, 1,911,808 of May 30, 1933 e
Formhals, U. S. Patent No. 1,975,504 of Oet. 2, 1934
Morton, U. S. Patent No. 2,048.051 of July 21, 1936
Ronzi, U. S. Patent No. 2,095,651 of Oct. 12, 1937
Meston, U. S. Patent No. 2,097,233 of Oct. 26, 1937
Russell et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,128,327 of Ange, 30, 1938
Wise et al, U.S. Patent No. 2,173,741 of Sept. 19, 1930
Foymhals, U.S. Patent No. 2,187,306 of Jan. 16, 194
Benner et al, U. S. Patent No. 2.191.827 of Feb, 27, 1940
Hill, U. S. Patent No, 2,217.444 of Oct. 8, 1940
Huebyger, U. S. Patent No. 2,224,391 of Dee. 10, 1940
ry
Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer, ete, 7
Gundelfinger, U. S. Patent No. 2,251,93T of Aug. 12, 1941
Rooney, et al, U. 8. Patent No. 2,268,622 of Jan. 6, 1942.
Branston-Cook, U. S.. Patent No. 2,302,289 of Nov. 17, 1942
$21 ; .
Kimball et al, U.S. Patent No, 2,354,688 of Aug. br, 1944
Wind et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,431,629 of Nov. 25, 1947
Kearsley, U. &. Patent No. 2,438,561 of Mar. 30, 1948
Huebner, U. S., Patent No. 2,451,288 of Qet. 12, 1948
Bennett et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,491,889 of Dee, 20, 1949
5. Each of the claims of the Starkey et al patent Ne.
2,685,486 is void and invalid and the Defendant is barred
from enforcing the same on the following grounds :
(a) As lacking invention over what has long ‘been
ns to be all in the art as set forth hereinabove.;
(b) As lacking novelty over the prior art heréinabove
set forth which constitutes full justification for the Plain-
tiff’s devices such as that shown in Plaintiff's Drawing
‘ SK-661 dated 5-12-54, a copy ‘of which has been furnished
Defendant.
(c) <As being indefinite, ambiguous and incomplete con-
trary to the statutory requirement of a full, clear, concise
. e . . . .
and exact disclosure and definition of the alleged invention.
(d) As involving claims not supported by the specifica-
tion of said Starkey.ct al Patent No. 2,685,536, 2 |
(e) As involving claims directed to mere aggregations
and old combinations of well known features and steps
set forth inthe prior art hereinabove specified.
v (f) As ‘embracing claims constituting a fraud on the
publie beeause of the deceptive and misleading character
of the description of such claims.
(g) As lacking in originality in ‘the light of the refer-
ences hereinabove cited which clearly indicate that the
Commissioner of Patents exceeded his legal authorfty in
granting said Letters Patent. ,
~
doctrine of “estoppel by imitation
‘
s ‘Plaintiff's Substitided Answer, ete,
S22 (hh) OAs cmbracigg claims broaderethan the patent
' diselosure and involving nothing more than ordinary
mechanieal skill and even at that ofa very low order,
(i) As embraging claims wherein the patentees know:
ingly patented the ideas of others, . ;
-o( J) As embraciiy claims constituting a double patent-
ing of the alleged inyention and especially in view of the
Defendant's Ramsburg Patent No. 2,658,009 issued on No-
vember 38, 1998 or almost a year before the issnanee of
Starkey et al. Patent No. 2,685,586. |
(k) As embracing claims so limited and confined during
the proseeution of the application in- the United States
Patent Office that a contention herein that they are’ in-
fringed Dy the use of Plaintiff's device, sueh as that of
Plaintiff's Drawing SK-661,, requires the invoking of the
75 Ss
Third Defense,
6. Defendant has and is presently granting licenses
under the aforesaid Starkey et al. patent No. 2,685,536 for
using the method or process thereof and whieh process is
known as the ‘*No, 2"' or airless type process.
The Defendant, in granting such licenses uidery its
aca incMding the aforesaid. Starkey et al. Patent No.
2,685,036 represents to the trade and-in interstate com-
meree that it exclusively -owns the patent monopoly for
‘olectrostatically depositing airlessly atomized (without
compressed air) liquid spray particles’
x25) 8. The Defendant, in granting its aforesaid licenses
under the aforesaid Starkey et al. Patent No, 2,685,536
conples with such license agreements a leasing agreement
in which it leases equipment for use in practicing the
patented proe ess of Starkey et al. Pa tent No. 2,485,536.
4 The Plaintiff, in its marketing of spray equipment,
has nseertaiied that there issn demand in the trade and
.
‘ 14
-
4
Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete, )
in interstate commerce for a paint sprayer whieh will elec:
trostatically atomPe paint Without making use of air, and,
accordingly, fully developed a paint sprayer whieh it: is
capable of manufacturing and selling in order to meet the
market demands,
10.* The Defendant, in a letter dated July 12, 1956, sub-
mitted to the Plaintiff its license form Nos. 489,and 440
as being standard forms of Defendant pertaining to the
spraying of paint by a sprayer which will cleetrostatieally
atomize paint without making use of air.
11. Obdi formation and belief, the Plaintiff understands
that the Defeadant has, in its licensing and leasing program
pertaining to electrostatic spraying and beginning about
Jannary of 1948 to the date of the commencement of this
action, employed $5 different forms of agreement.
12. On information and-belief, the Plaintiff understands
that up to the filing of the original complaint herein the
Defendant has granted 733 licenses on electrostatic spray-
“ing, of which 463 were-in foree and effect on the date of
the filing of the complaint herein.
424 12. (a) -Up to the date of the filing of the eom
plaint herein, the Defendant has ineluded in all of its
licensing agreements relating to airless electrostatic spray
coating @ provision requiring the Mefendant, as licensor,
to furnish to licensee af least some of the equipment’ em-
ployed it the spraving and ¢ : ,
(hb) Defehdant has furnished sneh equipment pursuant
to said license agreements. .
14. (a) The Defendant, as a part of its “aforesaid |
licensesy renders engineering and technical services to its
licensees at least to the extent necessary for the use of the
licénsed spraying proeess, and
(hb) Such licensees are required to compensate the
Defendant licensor for ‘such engineering, and technical
services by fees and:
(c) Such fees have heen paid by licensees to Defendant.
‘
10 Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, etc.
15. The Defendant, after restricting its Starkey et al.
Patent No. 2,685,536 te only method claims in the prose-
cution of the application from which the patent issued,
thereafter wrongfully used such patent contrary to the
anti-trust lags for the purpose of tying in with licenses”
under the method claims of said Starkey et al. patent,
leases for unpatented spraying equipment.
16. The Defendant is Hlegally and in violation of the
anti-trust laws employing its Starkey et al. method patent
No. 2,685,536 to require the leasing of equipment of De-
fendant as a condition for a licensee taking a license
825 under the method claims and in so doing has committed
acts of unfair compétition to the detriment of the
public and to the damage of the Plaintiff,
17. The Defendant's entire program of licensing and
leasing of electrostatic spraying. equipment not only in-
volves an abuse of its patents, bat contravenes the spirit
and: intent of the antj-trust laws in that it enables the
Defendant to extend its monopoly in sueh manner as to
monopolize substantially the field of electrostatic spraying
‘rd especially that of electrostatic atomization without the
use of air, °
18. The Defendant is wrongfully using its Starkey et al.
Patent No. 2,685,536,
(a) To coeree the public into leasing equipment from
the Defendant, all to the detriment of the public ayd ulti-
mate consnmer ‘of products processed under the Starkey
et al. patent by licensees and lessees and -
(b) To coerce manufacturers of spray equipment, such
as the Plgintiff, into not making and selling sueh equip-
ment as ISg@for example, shown in the aforesaid drawing
SK-661 of the Plaintiff.
19. The Defendant, its officers and aforesaid alleged
inventors of Starkey et al. patent No. 2,685,536, individually
and collectively, have conspired with each other and with
9.
Plaintif’'s s Substitiked Ansiver, ete. ee
others in restraint of trade and monopolizing, through
patents antl illegal agreements, of the cleetrostatic spray
equipment business in interstate commerce, contrary. to
the anti-trust and anticmonopoly laws of the Vhited States,
and in so doing have committed itlegal acts of unfair
R26 competition, all to the detriment of the public and to.
the damage of the Plaintiff.
20. It is further alleged that Défendant should be held
estopped from asser ing the hforesaid Starkey et al. Patent
No. 2,685,536 against the Plaintiff by virtue of the Detend-
ant’“unelean hands in Jits aforesaid wrongful aets in illegal
restraint of trade and in contravention of the anti-trust
(laws of the United States of America,
21, (a) Defendant’ has kubstantially a’ peakaiee- monop-
; oly in the United States of airless electrostatic
liquid spray coating systems in its leasing pro-
gram ; i
(b) in which it has coupled the granting of an equip-
ment lease with the granting of a patent license
ws a single package deal;
(c) in which it has never leased equipment without
- also requiring the lessee to take a patent
ul license ; -
7 - (d) in which it has never gganted a patent license
without at the same time leasing equipment;
(c) Gt which it has required, lessees as a condition
to receiving leased equipment to pay an initial
fee of thousands of dollars which more_ than
compensated Defendant for the cost of manu-.
facturing the equipment furnished ;
(f) in whiechgt has required Igsseon to turn over to
Defendant patent Tieenges on inventions made
or acquired by such lessees relating to the leased
sy stem;
) (¢) in which it has in its composite lease and license
forms of agreement required recognition of the
validity of not only patents taken out by De-
fendant but also of any patent rights aequired
by Defendant from third parties;
r
“
I:
R27
(h)
(k)
(1)
(11)
(1)
Plamtif's Substituted Answer, ele,
in which it has required’ lessees to accept a
termination provision in leases which required
the lessee, upon termination of the lease, to
surrender to Defendant all of the leased equip-
ment without receiving any refund for ‘the
initial fee of thousands of dollars paid by the
lessee ;
in which Defendant has provided in its com-
posite lease and license agreement forms for the
furnishing by Defendant of services and. replace-
ment parts to the lessees ;
in which Defendant has included in the leased
equipment numerous unpatented parts not em-
braced by the claims of the Starkey et al. letters °
patent No. 2,685,536;
in which in its leases, Defendant has received
full compensation, dollar wise, for the manu-
facturingd cost of the major item of the equip-
ment leased, namely the power pack, which is.
not covered by any of the claims of the Starkey
‘ot al. letters*patent No. 2,685,536;
in which Defendant has, in certaigeof its leases,
granted more favorable terms tor paint or ef
ing material manufacturers who in turn reetf-
mended the Defendant's leased system in their
advertising ; we
in which Defendant has refqsed to grant spray
equipment manufacturers, such as the Plaintiff
a
herein, a license under the Starkey et al. patent
No. 2,685,536, unless such manufacturers sell
the Heensed spray equipment only to customers
licensed by Defendant ;
in which Defendant in its license-lease agree. «
ments did not specifically identify by number
any of its patents which applied direetly to the®
equipment being leased, thus requiring licensees
to recognize the validity of any patents con-
sidered by Defendant to he applicable, even
though not identified; and
,
2S
are
STE EE BED te
Praeny Substituted Answer, ete, BD
S28 (o) in whieh Defendant has required the payment
of a feevfor the use of reeiprocators in’ its
» ’
leased systems even where Defendant did not
supply such reciprocators to the lessee. :
22. The Defendant has
- * (a) engaged in interstate commerce; and
(b) im the Course of. such commerce leased ‘electro:
static spray coating equipment for use within
the United States ;
(¢) said leasing being on the condition, agreement,
or understanding that. the lessee,should not use
or deal in ihe equipment of & conipetitor or
competitors of Pefendant ; and
(ad) thereby lessened competition or tended to cre-
ate a monopoly in the field of electrostatic spray
, coating eyuipment,
23. Defendant has illegally exploited the Patent System
of the United States by ecauiring patent vights from out.
sidé the Defendant's organization for the purpose of re.
stricting Yutry of competitors into the field of cleetrostatice
spray coating equipment,
24. - Defendant has extended its monopoly ino the field
_Of -electrostatic spray coating equipment by requiring lie
consees, as a condition for receiving a license, to leense
back to Defendant, royvalty-free,@patent rights in inventions
made in the airless electrostatic spray coating field) by
such licensees, ,
25. Defendant has secured patent rights from outside
parties for the purpose of intimidating and overwhelming
and coercing the trade into dealing omy with the Defend
ant.
829 26.) Defendant's predecessor, Harper J. Ransbure
Company, entered into an agreement in restraint of
trade with the Behr-Manning Corporation dividing the
field of electrostatic coating between the parties thereto,
Defendgarit has sueceeded to all of said predecessor's rights
under said agreement, and in furtherance of the purposes
| WW
S
14 Plamtipe’s Substeirted Answer, ete,
thereot, las coerced the trade into dealing only with De
fencant in the field of electrostatic spray coating of liquids,
27.) Defendant, by licensing its patents only as a pack
age, has enlarged the patent monopoly of particular
patents for the exploitation of the monopoly of its other
patents,
YS. Defendant. by ticensing its qatents only as a pack-
aye, has conlarged the patent monopoly of particular
patents for the exploitttion or promotion of a business,
not Within the patents,
JO. Defendant, through its license and lease agrge-
ments, has ereated a perpetual monopoly in the field) of
electrostatic spray coating equipment, said monopoly ex.
tending bevond the term oof any of Defendant's patents
Which may apply to such equipment,
SO. As a as Plaintiff is advised, Defendant owns
1WO'; or substantially 1006) of all airless. electrostatic
spray coating Systems imuse inthe United States, Defend:
ant does not sell sueh svsteme to users,
Sh. By its poliey of leasing, but not) selling, airless
electrostatic spray coating systems, and imposing the
conditions recited’ in such leases, Defendant has re-
SSO strained the development and growth in the United
States of business in:
(a) making and selling repair and replacement ‘parts
for such systems; and :
(b) buying and selling used airless clectrostatic spray
coutings systems,
&
82. Defendant, incits leases, exerts substantially com
plete monopolistic control over its lessees by:
(a) requiring lessees to teense back to Defendant,
rovalty-free, all iiveiitions made in the field of
vlectrostatic spray coating by such lessees
(b) retaining the right to cancel such leases and re-
move the leased equipment from the premises of
the lessee, without cause
~
: Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete, i)
(¢) retaining the right to make changes in the equip-
ment supphed to lessees |
(dl) making it economically impossible for iano to
procure replacement parts for the equipment on
the open market
(e) making it economically Impossible for lessees to
secure servicing of such equipment in the open
market -’
(f) making it impossible for its licensees to iii
themselves of defendant's equipment Without suf-
fering a complete loss of their investment in suche
equipment,
Wherefore, Plainti® prays:
That the Defendant take nothing by its Substituted Coun-
terelaim,;
That the Defendant be ordered to purge itself of its
wrongful and illegal conduct invits licensing and Jeasing
program with respect to electrostatic spraying by dissipat-
ing the effeets of its wrongful conduet ;
431 That the aforesaid Starkey et al,” patent No.
2,685,536 be held non-infringed by any of the Plain-
tiffs spraying equipment ; |
That the aforesaid Starkey et al., patent No. 2,685,536 |
he held invalid and a nullity from its ineeption ;
° That the Court grant to the Plaintiff such other and.
further relief as it may deem just and equitable.
Harold B, Hood,
1001 Hume Mansur. Building,
_ Indianapolis 4, Indiana,
Charles F.”Meroni;
Otto R. Krause, x
Hill, Sherinan, Meroni, Ciroxs & Simpson,
53 West Jackson Blwd.,-
Chicago 4, Illinois,
' Attorneys for Plautiff.
MARS Brn
« ‘
lt Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete,
-
Reeeipt of four (4) copies of the above and foregoing
substituted Atygwer to Defendant's Counterclaim is here-
hy acknowledged this. Ath day of November, 1958,
a je Trask,
Attorne y for De feudant.,
.
.
Nis2 * Tn rik Unirep States Disriicr Court,
* * (Caption—36-C-262)® * * . ‘
; ‘ .
PLAINTIFF'S SUBSTITUTED © ANSWER TO) DE-
FENDANT’S SUBSTITUTED SUPPLEMENTAL
COUNTERCLAIM %
(éoriginal filed June 11, 1958.)
Plaintitt,: Binks Manufacturing Company, answers. the
Substituted Supplemental Counterclaim: as follows: ,
\
: Kirst Defense,
a. ae
38. Answering paragraph 4, Phiintiff. admfts that
United States Letters Patent No. ye, 417 was issued on
June 4, 1957 and that Defendant is.the owner as alleged,
but denies that such Lettérs Patent were duly and legally
issued, ,
834. Plaintitf denies the allegations of ‘paragraph h,
.
cy
Second, Defense. ®
. ee 8 ’ , é‘ ; a4
3). The Plaintiff alleges that the following listed refer-
ences clearly evidence that the claims of the Starkey et a?
yor
patent No, 2,794,417 are devoid pf invention:
433 As Anticipation,
Keis et al, U. S. Patent No. 1,475,995 of Dee. 4, 1923
Littlefield, U. S. Patent No. 1,360,654 of Nov. 30, 1920
Littlefield, U. S. Patent No, 1,854,475 of Apr. 19, 1932
Plaintiff's Substituled Answer, ete. 17
Pugh,'U, S. Patent No, 1,895,869 of Apr. 26, 982
Darrah, U.S. Patent No. 1,958,406 of May 15, 1934 :
Wintermute, U.S. Patent’ No, 2,221,338 of Nov. 12, 1940 ,
Ransburg et al, U.S. Patent No. 2,247,968 of July 1, 1941
Gravley, U.S. Patent No. 2,359,476 of Oct. 8, 1944
The a Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical. Maga.
zine, Volyne XXIII, page 49Q (1887); te
* Kleetrieal Experiments by Franeis, page 87 (1850),
Zeleny, The Physical Review, Second Series, Vol. IIT, No.
2 (February, 1914), pages 69-91, Ss
Zeleny, Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical So-
ciety, Vol. 18, pages’ 71-85 (1915). °
Zeleny, The Physical Review, Second Series, Volume /X,
No. 1, pages 1-6 (July, 1917). ~
Zeleny, The Physical Review, Second Séries, Volume XVI"
No. 2, pages 102-125 (1920). :
‘Zeleny, Journal of the Franklin Tnstitute, Volume, 219,
No. 6, pages 659-675 (June, 1935).
Proceedings of the Royal Trish Academy, Voluiie XXNXIX,
Page 21 (1929). a
834 To Show the State of the Prior Art.
Smyser, U.S. Patent No, Re, 22,419 of Jan. 11, 1944
* DeVars, U. S. Patent No. 398,327 of Feb. 19, 1889 —
Simpson, U. S. Patent No. 601,594 of Mar, 2991898
Morton, U. S. Patent No. 705,69] of July 29, 1902
Wickson, U. S. Patent: No, 735,638 of Aug. 4, 19038
Cooley, U. S. Patent. No. 745,276 of Nov. 24, 1903 .
Fitzgerald, U. S. Patent No. 805,719 of Nov. 28, 1905
Althouse, U..S. Patent No. 1,133,004 of Sept. 7, 1915
Gentile, U..S. Patent No, 1,454,376 of May &, 1923
Fraser, U.S. Patent No. 1,478,113 of Dee. 18, 1923
Wille et.al, U. S. Patent No. 1,638,757 of Aug. 9, 1927
Hampton et al, U. S. Patent No. 1,740,981 of Dee. 24, Yo29
Collins, U. S. Patent No, 1,911,808 of May 30, 1933
Formhals, U". 8. Patent No. 1,975,504 of ‘Oct. 2, 1934»
Morton, U. S. Patent No. 2,048,651 of July 21, 1936
-Ronzi, U. S, Patent No.:2,095,651 of Oct, 12, 1937:
Meston, U. S. Patent No, 2,097,238 of Oct, 26, 1937
Russell et al, U. S. Ratent No. 24128,327 of Aug. 30, 1938 --
é
a
i Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer, ete.
Wise et al, U.S. Patent No. 2,173,741 of Sept. 19, 1939
Formhals, U. S. Patent No. 2,187,306 of Jan. 16, 1940
Benner et alg U. S. Patent No. 2,191,837 of Feb. 27, 1940
Hill, U. S. Patent No. 2,217,444 of Oct. 8,-1940
Huebner, U. S. Patent No. saga of Dec. 10, 1940
Gundelfinger, UV. S. Patent No. 2,251,931 of Aug. 12, 1941 ,
Rooney et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,268,622 of Jan. 6, 1942
Branston-Cook, U. S. Patent No. 2,302,289 of Nov. 17, 1942
Kimbal et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,354:688 of Aug. 1, 1944
Wind et al, U.S. Patent Now: 2,431,629 of Nov. 25, 1947
Kearsley, U. S. Patent.No. 2,438,561 of Mar. 30, 1948
Huebuer, U.S. Patent No: 2;451,25 % of Oct 12, 1948 -
Bennett et al, U.S. Patent No. 2,491,889 of Dee. 20, 1949
Starkey et al, U. S. Patent No. 2,685,536 of Aug. 3, 1954.
36. Each of the claims of the Starkey et al. patent No.
2,794,417 is void and invalid and the Defendant is barred
f rom enforcing the same on the following grounds:
835 (a) “As lacking | invention over what has long been
known to be old in’ the art as set forth hereinabove.
(b) As Tacking novelty over. the prior art. hertinabove. ;
set forth which constitutes full justification for the Plain-
tiff’s devices such as that’shown in Plaintiff’s Drawing
SK-661 dated 5-12-54, a copy of which has aie ‘n furnished
Defendant. e-
(c) - As being inglefinite, ambiguous and incomplete ¢on-
trary to the statutory requirement of a full, clear, cohcise.
and exact disclosure and definition of the alleged inven-
tion. : 6
(d) As invelving claims not supported by the specifica-
tion of said Starkey et al. patent No. 2,794.417.
(e) As involving claims directed to mere aggregations _
and old combinations of well known features and steps set
forth init the prior art hereinabove specified.
(f) As embracing claims constituting a fraud on the
public because of the deceptive and misleading character
of the description of such claims.
“
©
6 Platgi's Substituted Answer, ete, ‘Wy
(g) As lacking in‘originality in the light of the refer
ences hereinabove cited which clearly’ indicate that the
Commissioner of Patents exceeded his’ legal authority in .
granting said Letters Patent. ip .
(h) As embracing claims broader than the patent dis.
closure and involving nothing more than ordinary mechan: ;
ical skill and even at that of a very low order.
(i) "Ss embracing claims wherein the patentees . know-
ingty patented the ideas of aghers. 7
(j) As embracing claims ia Patent No. 2,794,417 which
tonstitute a double patenting of the alleged invention in
view of the earlier issued Starkey — et. at. pateyt No.
> 2,685,536. roy ca t
4360 (k) As embrykite claims which set forth nothing
° ~more than they#fvious apparatus for carrying out the
method claims in pateut No, 2,685,536. °
(1) As embracing claims constituting an illegal exten
sion of the monopoly provided by the earlier issued pate mt > 4
No. 2,685,536.
(m) As embracing claims which are non-statutowy in
nature in view ‘of the method limitations in claims pur- «
portedly direeted to apparatus. ” ¢
(n) As embracing claims so |jmited and confined dur-
ing the prosecutioif of the application tn the Unit&d States”
Patent Office that .a contention herein that they are in
Tringed by themase of Plaintiff's device, such as that- of
Plaintiff's, drawing "S#.661, requires the invoking of the
ities ENS Heth saS RR
%
3
<
:
a
g
4
i
¥
-s
q
> ; %
%
doctrine of ‘estoppel by limitation” a “
Third Defense. Q
OT: Plaintitt further alleges that “Defendant received
knowledge of prior r aac, anticipating Gne or more claims of
the application which issued as Patent No. 2,794,417 prior
to the issuance of said patent and withheld suc ‘h knowledges
from ‘the -United States Patent Office, and that in the
. >
.
, ~.
HM) > Plaintiff's Substituked Answer, etc.’
absence of such knowledge, the y atent Office issued an
invalid pate nt, to the eit Aled of the public.
38. Plaintiff further alleges that Defendant in failing
to disclaim, one or more Claims of Patent No, 2,794,417 in.
view of its knowledge of? anticipating prior art, is ¢ stopped
from asserting said patent against Plaintiff. 2 * |
837 «39. “Plaintiff further alleges” that Defendant is —
estopped from asserting any. interpretation’ of the
clainis in;Patent No. 2,794,417 which would cover the Plain-
tiff’s airless electrostatic spray coating emitter identified
as SK-661 in view in the Defendant's voluntary eancellation
of certain claims in the application w hich issued as Patent
No. 2,794,417 and in the earlier comparvion Patent No.
2,685,536. ed
9 Fourth Defense. © Seo '
§
5 4. Defendant has and is presently grantin licenses
under its patents, including Patent No. 2,794,417 for the
practice of a ‘process known as the ‘No, 2’’or airless type
process , i
41. The Defendant, in granting such licénses under its
patents, represents to the trade, and in interstate commerce
that it exclusively owns the patent monopoly for *‘electro-
statically depositing airlessly atomized (without com-
pressed air) liquid spray particles,”
42, The Defendant, in granting its aforesaia licenses
under the aforesaid Starkey et al. patent No, 2,685,536
couple with such license agreen.ents 9 leasing agreement .
in which it, leases: equipment for use’ in practicing the ,
patented process-of Starkey et al. patent No, 2,685, 536.
43. The Plaintiff, in its marketing of spray equipment,
has ascertained that there is a demand in the trade and in
interstate commerce for a paint sprayer which will electro-
statically atomize paint without making use of air, and,
accordingly, fully developed a paint sprayer which it is
Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete, 21
capable of manufacturing and selling ini prder | to meet the
market demands.
838 44. The Defendant, in a letter dated July 12, 1956,
. “submitted to the Plaintiff its license form Nos, 439 and
440 as being standard forms of De fendant pertaining to the
spraying of paint by a sprayer which will elect rostatically
atomize paint without making use of air. + >
45. On information and belief, the Plaintiff understands
jfhat the Defendant has, in its licensing and. leasing pro
“gram pertaining to electrostatic spraying and beginning
about January of 1948 to the date of the commencement
of this action, employed 45 different, forms of agreement.
46: On information and belief, ‘the - Plaintiff ‘under-
stands that up to the filing of the original complaint herein |
the Defendant has granted 733 licenses on electrostat! c
spraying, of which 463 were in force and effect on the date
of the filing of the complaint herein.
47. (a) Up to the date of the filing of the saeenaeine
herein, the Defendant has included in all of its licensing
agreements relating to airless electrostatic spray coating |
a provision requiring the Defendant, as licensor, to furnish
_a licensae at least some of the equipment employ ed fn the.
spraying nd (b) Defendant ‘has furnished such bquip
ment. pursuant, to said license ‘agreements.
48. (a) The Defendant, asa ‘part of its aforesaid
licenses, renders. engineering and technical. services to its
licensees at least to the extent necessary for the use df the
* licensed spraying process, and
(hb) Sueh licensees are required to eémpeniaate the De
fendant licensor for such engineering and technical serv-
ices by fees and ‘
fe) Such fees haye been paid by liecasees to Defend-
ant. \ “4 .
439 49. The Defendant, after restricting ‘its Starkey
_ et al: patent No, 2,685,536-to only method claims in the
2
,
7 Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete.
prosecution of the application from which the patent -
issued, thereafter wrongfully used such patent contrary to
theeanti-trust laws for the purpose of tying it with licenses
under the method claims of said Starkey et al. patent, leases
for unpatentad spraying TT i, Se
0. The Defendant is illegally and in violation of the
anti-trust laws employing its Starkey et al. method patent.
No. 2,685,836 to require the leasing of equipment of De
fendant as a condition for a licensee taking a license nnder
the method claimsand in so doing has committed aets of un-
fair Competition to the detriment of the public and to the
damage of the Plaintiff.
D1. The Defendant's entire program of licgnsing and
leasing of electrostatic spraying equipment not only in-
volves an abuse of its patents, but contravenes the spirit
and intent of the anti- -trust laws in that it enables the De-
fendant to extend its monopoly in) sueh manner as to
monopolize substantially the field of electrostatic spraying
and especially that of electrostatic atonsization without the
use of air.
52. The Defendant is wrongfully using its Starkey et
al. patent No. 2,685,536: 3 .
(a) To coeree the public into leasing equipment from
“the Defendant, all to the detriment of the public and ulti-
mate consumer of products processed under the Starkey
et al. patent by licensees and Yygsees and
(b) To coerce manufactprers of spray equipment,
S40 such as the Plaintiff, into nét making and sellings such
equipment as is, for example, shown in the aforesaid
drawing SK-661 of the Plaintiff. «
a3. The Defendant, its officérs and aforesaid alleged in
ventors of Starkey et wv. patent No. 2,685,556, individually
and collectively have/cohspired with each other and with
others in restrainy of trade and . monopolizing, through
patents and illegal agreements, of the electrostatic: spray
©
: A
£ : be oo ;
Plaintiff’s Substituted Answer, ete, . 23
‘on | :
equipment business in interstate commerce, contrary to
the anti-trust and anti-monopoly laws of the United States,
and in so doing have committed illegal acts of unfair com-
petition, all to the detriment of the publie and te the dam
age of the Plaintiff.
‘It is further alleged that Defendant should be held .
estopped from asserting the aforesaid Starkey et al. Patent
No. 2,685,536 against the Plaintiff by virtue of the Defend.
ant’s unclean hands in its aforesaid wrongful acts in il-
legal restraint of trad® and “in contravention: of the anti-
trust law of the United States of America. *
od. (a) Defendant has xnbst: intially a complete mon. °
opoly in thet, Lnited States of airless electro:
static liquid spray coating systems jn its leasing
program ;
(b) in which it has coupled the granting ot an equip-
7 ment lease wifh the granting of a’ patent license
as a single package deal;
(c) in which it has never leased equipment without
© also requiring the lessee to take a patent license;
(d) in which it has never granted a patent license
without at the same time leasing equipment ;
841 (e) in Which it has required lessees asa condition
to receiving leased equipment to pay an‘initial
; ‘fee of thousands of dollars which more than
> compensated Defendant for the cost of mann-
facturing the equipment furnistiesd;
(f) in which it has required lessees to turn ‘over td
: Defendant patent licenses on inventions made or
acquired by suchdessees relating to the leased
system ; Pn
(¢) in which it has jp its composite lease and license
forms ef agreemént tequired recognition of the
validity of not only pateyts taken out by De-
fendant but also of any patent rights aequired
by Defendant from third parties;
(h) in which i@@has rmmiired lessees to accept a
termination provision in leases which required
* the lessee, ‘upon termination of the lease, to
24
S42
.
(i)
(k)
(1)
Plamtiyfs Sulstiiuted dnswer, ete,
m *
surrender to Defendant all of the leased equip
ment without receiving any refund fog the in tie!
fee of thousands of dollars paid by the lessee;
in Which Defendant has provided in its com
posite lease and dicense agreement foun. for
the furnishing by Defendant of services and
replacement parts to the lessees ; :
in Which Defendant has dneluded ®) the leased
equipment numerous unpatented parts not en
braced by the claims of the Starkey et al. Letters
Patent No. Y 685,536 ;
in Which in its: leases, Defendant liars received
full compensation, dollav-wise, for the raanu-
facturing cost of the major item of the equip
ment leased, namely the power pack? which ia,
not covered by any of the claims of the Starkey
etal. Letters Patent No, 2,685,536 ; ; o
in which Defendant has, in certaii of dts leases,
granted more favorable terms to paint or coat-é
ing material manufacturers who in turn reeom-
mended the Defendant's leased xysten in their
advertising ; y ® ;
(m) in which Defendant Itas refused to grant spray
(1)
(0)
equipment manufacturers such as the Plaintiff
herein, a license under the Starkey ef al. patent
No, 2 2,685,536 unless such manufacturers sell the
licensed spray equipmenteonly to eqstomers
licensed by Defendant ;
in which Defendant in its license-lease agree.
ments did net specifically identify ly number
any of its patents which ripplied dire thy to the
equipment heing leased, thus requiring licensees
to recognize the validity (of any patents cons
sidered by Defendant: toe he apploables even |
though not identified’; and
in which Defendant has required the payment
off a fee for the use of reciprocators in its
ledsedasystems even where Defeudant did not
supply’ such ‘reciproeators to the Jessee,
g 0
“»
’
a
Plaintiff w Substitute d Answer, eth, 2h
56. The Defendant has
(a) engaged ip iiterstate commences ated
Ab) in the conpse of such gommioree leased: electro
static spray coating equipment for use within
the United States; ioe See, 8 :
(¢) said leasing being on the condition, agreement,
or ynderstanding that the lessee Should lot use
or de alin theequipment of a competitor or com-
petitors of Davondant; and
(dl) thereby lessened competition or tended toe renee
wee a monopoly in the field of electrostatic spray
Q
egating equipment, “
57, Defendant. has illegally exploited: the Patent Sys
tem of the United States by acquiring patent rights from
outside the Defendant's. organization for the purpose of
restricting entry of competitors into the field of electro
static spray coating equipment, ' ‘
58, Defendant has extended its monopoly in the field of
- electrostatic spray coating equipment by requiring licen
Sees; AS agxondition for: receiving A license, to license. back
to Defendant, rovalty-free, patent rights in’ inventions
made in the airless clectrostatic spray qpating field by such
licensees, °° % . |
443 59. Defendant has sceured patent rights from out-
side parties for the purpose of intimidating and over-
Whelming and. coercing thg trade into dealing only with |
the Defendant. ‘
660. Defendant's predecosson, Harper J. Ransburg Com-
pany, entered into an agreement in restraint of trade with
the Behr-Manning Corporation dividing the field of elce
trostatic coating between the parties thereto, Defendant
has succeeded to all of said predecessor's rights under said
agreement, dnd in furtherance of the purposes thereof,
has coerced, the trade into dealing only with Defendant in
the field of electrostatic spray coating of l@uids. |
61. Defendant, by licensing its patents only as a | pack.
u
2 Plaintiff's Substituted Answer, ete,
—_—
age, has enlarged the patent monopoly of particular pat-
‘ents for the exploitation of the monopoly’ of its other
~ patents. ®
+ 62. Defendant, by licensing its patents only as a package,
‘has enlarged the patent manopoly of particular patents
for the exploitation or promotion of a business not within
the patents. °,
63. Defendant, through its license and lease agreements,
has created a perpetual monopolytn the field of electro
statie spray coating equipment, said monopdly extending
beyond the term of any of Defendant's patents which may
apply to such equipment. ‘
64. As far as Plaintiff if advised, Defendant owns 1006
or sithstantially 100% of all airless electrostatic apray
ecoating &ystems in use in the United States. Defendant
does not sell such systems to users.
R44 «65. By its poliey of leasing, but not selling, airless
electrostatic spray coating systems, and imposing the
conditions recited in such leases," Defendant tms resirained
the development and growth in the United States of busi-
ness in:
(a) making and selling repair and replacement parts
for such systems; and
(b) buying and selling used airless electrostatic spray
coating systems. '
66. Defendant, in its leases, exerts substantially com.
plete monopolistic control over its lessees by: |
(a) gyquiring lessees to license back to Defendant,
rovalty-free, all inventions made in the field) of"
| electrostatic spray coating by such lessees
(b) retaining the right to cancel such leases and remove
. the leased equipment from the premises of the
lessee, without cause
‘(e) retaining the right to yake changes in the equip.
ment Supplied to lessees
°
One eee
as =
Plainthifhe® Substituted Answer, ote, uy
(d) making it economically inipossible for Jeosseee to
procure replacement parts for the equipment on
the open market en,
(al makingit CCOTOTELOATLY imiposstble for lessees te
secure servietiw of vel equipment int the open
market :
(1) making it imiptssible for its licensees te divest
_themselves of defendant's eq tl pane ne gigi thout suf
fering acomplete toss of their inve as in ste
equipment,
hifth Defense
HZ, (\,) As admitted by the Defendant, tt reeemved
Plaintiff's Jetter dated July 25, 1056, towether With a eopy
of Plaintiff's drawing SIOO6T, showing theurless eleetre
static emitter whieh had heen developed by Plaintiff, and
(hb) shortly after receipt of said letter by Defendant
845 on or about July 26, 19596, Defendant conmiifiicated the
sieject matter of said Plaintiff's SK-GEL electrostatic
emitter to its patent eounsed, Schroeder, Hofgren, Brads
and Wegner
68. Following Plaintiff's disclosures of the SIS G61 air
less electrostatic emitter of Plaintiff to Defendant's patent
counsel (the law firm’ of Sehroeder, Hofgren, Brady and
Wegner), William J. Stellman of said: firnryon behalf ot
Defendant went to Washington and intesviewed the By
oaminer in charge of the examination of the Starkey et al.
application, Serial No. 454,366, from whieh Defendant's
apparatus patent No. 2.794)417 in suit issued, an 1 (dy) pur
suant to such interview ne an Amendment oC" te
such application, dated Augtist 29, 1956, adding to the ap
plication Claim ITS, which vow corresponds to Clafm 4 of
the patent, whieh is the only claim of seid patent specifienty
alleged herein by the Defendant to be infringed by Plain
tiff, which infringement is denied by Plaintiff,
60. That oral instruetions were given to Defendant's
Gat
’
Js Plamtiff’s Substituted Answer, ete,
patent coihsel by Defendant's vice president, BE. M. Rans-
burg, between August S and August 21, 1956, as to the filing
Amendment "Co" presenting Claim 18 in the Starkey
et al. applieation, Seriaf No, 484,366, from whieh the
Starkey et al, Patent No. 2704417 issued with such claim
as Claim 4,
70, That prior te the filing of Amendment OC" on or
Yabout August 28, 1996, in connection with application Serial
No. 454,966, from which the Starkey et al. apparatus patent
Noo 274417 issned and in which amendment Claim 0s,
(corresponding to Claim 4 of the patgat in suit), was
S46 presented, ne claims had ever been presented in that
application or any other patent application of the
Defondant on an airless electrostatic spray coating appa
ratus wherein in describing the spaced atomizing points,
the expression ‘sufficiently close to permit) the coating
material to bridge the spaces therehetween'’’ was employed,
(b) that Defendant did. not adopt such language yr any
patent claims until after Plaintiff's SK-661 airless gelec-
trostatie emitter devetopment had heen diselosed to De
fondant on er about Puly 26, 1956, and (¢) that even then
such vane andindetinite: language was only adopted as
a means of obtaining an additional claim: with whieh te
harass Plaintiff? with an unwarranted charge of infringe
ment. | . ,
71.) Defendant, nerd having had diselosed to Woon or
about Fuly 26, 1996, by Plamtit® the SKAG61 airless elee
trostatic emitter ee proprictury to Plaintitl, pre
cooded in seereey to present for the first time a claim: in
a then pending patent application of Defendant (Claim 1s,
how correspomling to its apparatus patent’ Claim 4), claim.
trig’ spraying apparatus oa vague and indefinite manner
never claimed before by it and in the light of Plaintiff's
disclosure to Defendant, ‘
72. (a) Plaintiff's specifie design of SK-661 dirless
_<
a
‘ ’ A} .
a! Plant} Ss Substituted Answer, ete. PAT
electrostatic Cmitter was developed by Plaintif! as a result
of a research and development program over a period of
several vears costing in excess of F40,000,00, and Cb) such
emitter and information as to the structural details of the
same Was proprietary to Plaintiff and (A) was, at the
time of its disclosure to Defendant, the subject of a
S47 patent application (Serial) No. 440,697, filed August
18, 1954) pending and maintained Gn seeret in’ the
United States Patent’ Office. \
73. In 1956, as well as at the time of its disclosure te
Defendant, Plaintiff's SIK-O6] airless eleetrostiatic emitter
Was not generally known publicly, as it had wot as “vet
been sold or publicized by Plaintitt,
74. The disclosure @ Plaintiff's SK-661 emitter, which
was the subject of aepending seeret patent application of
Plaintiff, wats made to Defendant in 1956 as a new, conti.
dential proprietary development of Plaintiff only for the
specifie purpose of ascertaining whether Defendant claimed
it had any patents covering same, and if so, whether a
license to manufacture and sell such an emitter Could be
had by Plaintiff.’ ;
7. Defendant acted inequitably and ino an unethical
business manner in its surreptitious and seeret activities,
takmg unfair competitive advantage of Plaintiff's coi
fidential disclosure in good faith of its proprictory SWK-661
development: in’ Defendant's wrongful appropriations of
such disclosure to its own ddvantage in the drafting and
procurement of patent Claim 4 of patent No. 2.794417, in
the light of such disclosure, =a
76. The aforesaid wrongful activities of the Defendant:
ju its procurement of its patent Now 2794417 are all part
of the plan of the Defendant to monopolize illegally the
market, and to extend and unduly protract. patent
S48 monopolies in the field of airless electrostatic spraying
to the ultimate end of discouraging all competition,
77. Defendant is estopped by its Proresnid inequitable
o~
30 Rlaintiff’s Substituted sLaswer, . .
f
and unconsaionable conduct from enforcing such Claim
4 of its patent No. zi M4417 against Plaintif, and (b) it
should not be permitted ‘to profit by “its wrongful and
inequitable conduct,to the detriment and damage of Plain.
tiff. ‘
Wherefore, Plaintiff prays:
That the Defendant take nothing by its Substituted
Supplemental Counterclaim ; wee
That the Defendant be ordered to purge itself of its
wrongful atid illegal conduet in the licensing and leasing ,
program with respect to electrostatic spraying by dissi-
pating the effects of its wrongful conduct;
That the Starkey ct al. patent No. 2,794,417 be held non-
infringed by any of the Plaintiff's spraying equipment ;
That, the Starkey et al. patent No, 2,794,417 be held in. —
Valid and a nullity from its inception;
That Defendant be held equitably estopped from assert:
ing Claim 4 of its Patent No. 2,794,417; ;
The the Court grant, to the Plaintiff sueh other and
further relief as it may deem just and equitable,
Harold B. Hood,
1001 Hume Mansur Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana, ¢
Charles F, Meroni,
Otto R. Krause,
Hill, Sherman, Meroni, Gross &
Simpson,
53 West Jackson Blvd.,
Chicago 4, Illinois,
Attorneys por Plaintiff.
Receipt of four (4) copies of the above and foregoing
substituted Answer to Defendant’s Counterelaim is hereby
acknowledged this 19th day of November, 195s,
V. A. Trask,
Attorney for Defendant.
’
‘
Plaintiff’s Cross-Counterclaim, 3]
848 os tuk Unirep Srates Disrrier Cour,
poe 6 & © (Caption—-56-C-262) ° °
55s PEAINTLIFE’S SUBSTITUTED CROSS.
COUNTERCLAIM. ws
(Original filed Decentber: 10, 1956. )
Now comes the Plaintit? Binks Manufacturing Gompany,
a Delaware Corporation, having its principal office and
or of business at Chicago, Hlinois, and in support.of
its®CFoss-Counterclaim avers:
1; Jurisdiction of this court as to the subject matter
of the Cross-Counterclaim is founded under the antitrust
aitd anti-monopoly laws of the United States (15 U.S. ¢
» see. 1, 2, 14 and 15). °
2.: The acts herein complained of were and are being
comand \ ithin this Distric. and elsewhere in the United
States and in interstate commerce and the amount in con-
troversy is in excess ‘of three thousand dollars.
3. The Plaintiff, Binks Manufacturing Company, is a
corporation organized and existing ‘under the laws of the
State of Delawaré and hag its principal office and place
of business at 3114-40 West Carroll Avenue, Chicago 12,
lllinois. =
4. Defendant, Ransburg Electro-Coating .Corpora-
8oU tion, ix a corporation organized and existing under the
laws of the State of Indiana and has its principal
office and place of business at Barth and Sanders Streets,
Indianapolis 7, Indiana.
do. The Plaintiff, has for many years and is presently
manufacturing and selling spraying equipment for paint
and other materials in this Distiget and elsewhere in the
United States.
6. The Defendant has for a number of years and is
™
°
\
%
4
32 Plamtiff’s Cross-Counterclaua,
presently licensing under its Ututed States Letters Pat-
ents processes for clectrostatically spraying pain and leases
equipment adapted to practive such processes, the products
made under such licenses. and by such equipment being
widely used in.interstate commerce throughout the U nited
States. -— ; .
7. On August 3, 1954, the Defe ndant was issued United
States Letters Patent No.’ 2,685,536, ‘entitled. ‘* Method
For Electrostatically Coating Articles” ,on an application
for patent filed on September 29, 1944, in the names of
William A. Starkey and Edwin M, Re Ee — ‘h patent
ix owned by Ngfendant. Z
8. On June 4, 1957, the Defendant yas ixxvied Vnited
States Letters Patent No. 2,794,417, entitléd ‘‘ Apparatus
For Electrostatieally Coating Articles’? on an application
filed June 4, 1954, based ‘upon the aforesaid application
filed September 29, 1944, in the names of William A.
Starkey and Kdwin M..Ransburg, which patent is salen
by Defendant. : . .
9. Defendant has and is sieneatty gganting licenses
under the aforesaid_Starkey et al. patents:for using the
method of process thereof and.which process is known
851 as the ‘‘No. 2”’ or airless type process. — -
> 10, The Defendant, in granting such licenses under
its patents,°ineludi.‘: the afpresaid Starke yet al. patents,
represents to“the trade and in- interstate ‘commerce. that
it exehisively owns the patent monopoly for ‘‘clectrosta-
tically depositing airlessly atomized (without compressed
air) liquid spray particles’’, 7
* 11. The Defendant, in. granting its aforesaid «licenses
under the aforesaid Starkey et al. patents, couples with
such license’ agreement a leasing agreement in which it,
leases equipment for use in practicing its aforesaid pat-
ented process of Starkey et al. patent No. 2,685,536.
p° 12. The Plaantiff, in its marketing af spray equipment,
¢
.
‘
‘
ee ee Plaintiffys Cross-Counterclarne.
oer
. ode?
~
‘ has ascertained th&t there is a dematid in the ives anil
in interstate commerce for a paint sprayer which, will
electrostatically atomize paint without mfking Use of air,
2 and, aceordingly, fully developed a pant sprayer w hieh it |
is capable of manufacturing and selling in 5 Wechasiien
the market demands. ¢
13. -The Defendant, in a letter dated July 12. 1956,
suymitted to the Plaintiff its license forms Nos. 420 and’
440 as being standard fornis of Defendant pertaining to
the spraying of paint by a sprayer which will electro
= | statically atomize paint without making use of air.
substi eked eA Ass
14. On information and belief, the Plaintiff ufiderstands
that the Defendant has, in its licensing and leasing pro
gram pertaining to-electrostatic spraying and begin
$52 ning about January of 1948 to the date of the con
mencement of this action, employed 45 different fon Hs
of agreement. f
15. On information and belief, the Plainti® wader
stands that up to the filing ‘Of the oyiginal complaint here.
‘in the Defendant has granted 733 licenses on the electro
static spraying, of which 463 were in foree and effect on
the date of the filing of the complaint herein,
16. (a) Up to the date of the filing of the complaint
s/ herein, the Defendant has included in all of its licensing
4 agreements relating to airless electrostatic spray coating
a a provisioR requiring the Defendant, as liceisor, to furnish
to licensee at least some of the equipment employed in the
spraying, and (b) Defendant has furnished such equipment
pursuant to said license agreements. “4
17. (a) The Defendant, as a part of its ntowemicl
5 - ‘licenses, renders engineering and technical services to its
‘ licensees at least to the extent necessary for the use of the:
* licensed spraying process, and ‘
, (b) such licensees are required to compensate the De
HY
5
34 Plaintiff ’s Cross-Counterclaim,
we,
fendant licensor for such engineering and technical services °
by fees, and
~ (e) such fees have been paid’ by licensees to Defendant,
18. Plaintiff is advised that it is the Det fendant’s posi-
tion that the use of the Plaintiff’s equipment shown in
Plaintiff's drawing SI<-661 for the electrostatic airless
atomizafion of? liquid spray particles constitutes an in-
on of Defendant’s Starkey et al. patent No.
4,685,536. ae iS
19. The Defendant; after restricting its: Starkey
et al. patent No. 2,685,536-to only method claims in the
prosecytion of the: application from which the patent
issued, thereafter wrongfully used such patent contrary
to the antitrust liws forthe purpose “of tying in with
licenses under the method’ claims of said - Starkey ¢t,al.
patent leases for unpaténted spraying equipment. .
20. The Defendant is illegally atid in violation of the
antitrust laws employing its Starkey ct al. method patent
to require the leasing of equipment of Detendant as con-
dition for a licensee taking a license’ under the method
claims and in so doing has committed acts of unfair compe-
tition to the detriment of the public and to the damaze of
the Plaintiff.
21, The Defendant’s entire program of licensing and
leasing of electrostatic spraying equipment not only in-
volves an abuse of its patents, but contray enes the spirjt’
and intent of the antitrust laws in that it “enables the De-
fendant to extend its monopoly in such manner as to
monopolize | substantially the field of electrostatic spraying o
and espedially that of electrostativ atomization without
the use of air.
22, Yhe Defendant is wrongfully using its Starkey et
al, patents Nos. 2,685,536 and 2,794,417
(a) to coerce the public into leasing equipment from
the Defendant, all to the detriment of the publie and ulti-
mn
; ,
\\
Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclarm, , oo
mate consumer of products processeq under the Starker
(b) to coerce manufacturers Ff spray equipment, such
as the Plaimtiff, into not makmy and selling such
84 equipment as is, for example, shown in. the aforesaid
drawing SK-661 of the Plaintiff. :
23. The Defendant, its officers and aforesaid allewed
inventors of Starkey ‘et al. patents, individually and col-
lectively, have conspired with each other and with others
in restraint of trade and monopolizing, ‘through patents.
and illegal agreements, of the electrostatic, spray equipment
business in interstate commerce, contrary to the antitrust’
and anti-monopoly laws of the United States, and in so
doing ‘have committed illegal acts of unfair competition,
all to the detriment of the publt and to the damage of the
Plaintiff.
24. It is further alleged that Defendant should be
held —— from asserting the aforesaid, Starkey et al.
Patent Nos. 2,685,536 and 2, 794,417 against the Plaintiff
by virtue of the’ Defendant's aforesaid wrongful acts
in illegal restraint of trade and in contravention \pf the
antitrust laws of the United States of America.
20. (a) Defendant has substantially a complete mgnop-
oly in the United States of airless cl0Trostatice
liquid spray coating systems in its leasing pro-
— grath; <><
(b) in Which it has coupled the granting of an equip-
ment lease with the granting of a patent license
© as a single package deal;
(¢) in which it has never leased equipment without
also requiring the lessee to také a patent license;
(d) in which it has never granted a patent license
without at the same time leasing equipment ;
855. (e) in which it has required lessees as a condition to
receiving leased equipment to pay an initial fee
of thousands of dollars which more than com-
&
36
kdb
: ay a
Plaintif?’s Cross-Counterclaim,
pensated Defendant tor the cost of manufactur-
ing the equipment furnished ; :
(f) in which it has required lessees to turn over to
Defendant patent ticenges on inventions made or
acquired by such lessees relating to the leased
sy stein ; iy
(g) inw hich it has | in its composite lease and license
forms vf agreement required recognition of the
validity of not only patents taken out by De-
fendant bat also of any patent rights acquired
by Defendant from third parties;
(hi) in which it has . required lessees to accept a
termination provision in leases which ‘required
. the lessee, upon termination of the’ lease, to .
surrender to Defendant all of the leased equip-
ment without receiving any refund for the initial '
_fee of thousands of dollars. paid by the le: see;
(i) in which Defendant has provided in its compos-
ite lease and license agreement forms for the
furnishing by Defendant of services and replace-
ment parts to the lessees ;
(j) in which Defendant has included in the leased
equipment numerous unpatented parts not em-
braced by the claims of the Starkey et al. Tetters
patents in suit;
(k) in which ‘in its leases, Defendant has received
full compensation, dollarwise, for the manufac-
turing cost of the major item of the equipment
leased, namely the power: pack, which is not
covered by any of the claims of the Starkey et
al. letters patents in. suit;
(I)gin which Defeadant has, in certain of its leases, ,
granted. more favoable terms to paint or. coat-
ing material manufacturers, who in turn ree-
ommended the Defendant's leased system = in
their advertising;
(m) in which Defendant has refused to grant spray
equipment manufacturers, such as the Plaintiff
herein, a license under the Starkey et al. patents .
in suit unless such manufacturers sell the licensed
spray equipment only to customers licensed by.
defendant; .- «
» \
v
, ee
Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclaim, 37
(n) in which Defendant in its license-lease agree-
ments did not specifically identify’ by > number
any “of its patents which applied directly to the
equipment being leased, thus requiring lieensees
fo recognize the validity of any patents con-
sidered by Defendant to be applicable, even
though not identified; and
* (o) in which Defendant has required the payment of
a fee for the use of reciprocators in its leased |
systems even wheae Defendant did not supply
stich ree iprocators to the lessee,
26. The Defendant has
4a) engaged in interstate commerce; and ip
(b) in the course of such commerce leased electro-
statie spray coating equipment for use with 4
the United States;
(c). said leasing being on the condition, agreement,
or understanding that the lessee should net use
or dealan the equipment of a competitor or com.
petitors of Defendant; and
(d) thereby lessened competition or tended to create
a monopoly in the fleld of clectrostatie spray
coating equipment.
27. Defendant has illggally exploited the Patent System
of the United States by acquiring patent rights from outside
the Defendant's.organization for the purpose of restricting
entry of coapetitors into the field of electrostatic spray
coating ‘equipment.
28. Defendant has extended its monopoly in the field of
leetrostatic spray coating equipment by requiring lieen-
sees, as a condition for receiving a license, to license
857 back to Defendant ro¥alty-free, patent rights in inven-
tions made in the airless electrostatic spray coating
Hield by such licensees, ;
29. Defendant has secured patent rights from outside
parties for the purpose of intimidating and overwhelming:
and coercing the trade into derling only with the Defend-
Q
ant. =”
al
\
eS A an ; . of 4
: ae Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclaim,
‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ .
30, Defendant's predecessor, Harper sl, Ransburg Com-
pany, entered into an agreement in restraint of trade with
“the Bohr-Manning Corporation dividing the field of eleetro-
static couting between the parties thereto. Defendant has:
succeeded to allot sail predecessor's rights, under said
agree vent, and in furtherance of the purposes thereof, has
cogreed the trade into dealing only with Defendant in the
field of electrostatic spray couting of liquids, ;
31. Defendant, by dicensing its patents only isa pac kage,
his enlarged the patent monopoly of particular patents for:
the exploitation of the monopoly of its other patents,
32. Defgndant, by licensing its patents only as a packs,
age, has enlarged the patent monopoly of particular patents’
for thegexploitation or promotion of a busingss not within
the patents. nett oO
3. Defendant, through its license and Tease Ayre ements,
has created a perpetual monopoly in the field of electro-
static spray coyting equipment, said monopoly extending?
hevond the tarm of any of Defendant’ x patents whieh may
apply Raeaed equipment. ) , : |
B44. As far as Plaintitf issadvised, Defendant owns’ s
.
SOs 100% or substantiafly 100% of all abridss Clectrostatic
spray coating systems in-use in the U nited States. De°
feudant dot not sell such’ systems to Wsers,
35. By its policy of leasing but not. sodling, airless
cloctrostatic spray coating xustemis, and 4 imposing the condi-’
“tions reeited im sneh Jeases, Defendant has restrained the
development and growth in the United States of.business in: -
(a) making and selling repair and replacenyent parts
for such systems; and ‘
(h) buying and selling used air lows hinheoataki spray
coating systems. a ‘,
36. Defendant, in its leases} exerts Substantially com:
Hlete monepolistic control over its lessees by :
(a) requiring lessees to iteense’. baek to “Defendant,
rovalty-free, all inventions made in the field of
niles electrostatic spray:coating by sueh lessees ;
.
- a
ee td
;
4?
Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclawm, 39
(b) retaining the Ment to cancel such leases and _ re-
move the leased equipment from the premises of
‘the lessee, without cause;
(c) retaining the right to make changes in the équip-
; ment supplied to lessees;
(dl) making it economically impossible for lessees to
. procure replacement parts for the equipment on
the open market;
(e) making it economically imposs@le for lessees to
secure servicing of such equipment in the open
, market;
(f) making it impossible for its Heensees to divest
themselves of defendant's equipment without suf-
fering @ complete loss of their investment.in such:
equipment.
37. Plaintiff further alleges Defendant wrongfully pro-
cured its Letters Patents Nos, 2,685,536 and 2 2,794,417
89 by untrue representations in “connection with their
procurement, all to the end of furthering its program
of unfair competitions illegal restraint of trade, and viola-
tion af the United States antitrust laws.
38, Defendant's licensing programéin airless clectrosta-
tie spray coating to: the extent that it is based upon the
Starkey et al. patents Nos. 2,685,536 and 2, 794,417, “is. in
violation of the Uwited States antitrust laws, since said
“patents are jnvalid: ba
(a) As lacking novelty over the prior art;
(b) As being indefinite, ambiguous and incomplete ;
(c) As involving claims not supported by the specifi-
cations of said patents;
(d) As iffvolving claims directed to mere aggregations
and old combinations;
(e) As embracing claims constituting a fraud on the
public heeause of the deceptive’ and misleading
_ character of the desertptions ef.such clainis ;
(f) As embracing claims broader than the patent dis- °
closures; ’
(¢) As embracing clainis w eesti the. patentees know-
ingly patented the ideas of others; and
a
&
4) Plamtiff’s Cross-Counterclam,
(hy As embracing claims constituting double patent
Ig aver previously issued patents,
Wherefore, Phacntill prays:
Ao ‘Thatan injunction be issued by this Court restrain
ing the Defenedwnt, their agents, officers, servants, en
plovees, ond attorneys from using the Defendant's patents,
‘including the said Starkey - ale Patents in suit, from inone
polizing and restraining trade in interstate commerce,
SOO fron: wrongfully employing said patent. ‘by threaten
ine toon suing Plaintiff or amy of its customers for
HW ringement thereot, and fron: attempting te enjoy the
mouapely of sat patents bys oan ayreegation thereof or
otherwise and from: interfertag or attempting to jaterfere
with or damage the business of the Plaintiff in interstate
commerce contrary to the antitrust, autiamonopoly and re
straint of trade laws of the United States,
B. Fora judgment under the provisions of Section 1,
Title 1h, of the United States Code for three-fold) the
damages sustained: by the P laintitl, the costs of this suit,
wud reasonable attorneys’ foes as provided,
(That the Defendant be required to aecount to the
Mlaintifl for loss of profits and damages sustained by rea
-onof Defendant's unlawful conduct,
D. The Court grant the Plaintiff! sueh other and fur.
ther relief as it imey deem just and equitable,
Harold B. Hood,
1001 Hume-Mansut Building,
: Indianapolis 4. Tneliana,
Pcs (Warles BL Meron,
Otto Ro Kranse,
Hill, Sherman, Menont, (ross KY
Simpson,
53 West Jackson Boulevard, |
Chicago 4, Hlinois,
Attorneys for Plan tiff.
~*~
“a
* Defendant's Substituted Answer, ete, 4)
Receipt ot four (4).capies of thy above and foregoing sub
stituted Cross -Counterehiinn is acknowledged this 19th day
wil November, 158,
V. A. Trask,
Attorney for Defendant,
RS Usxirkp Siratis Disthier Covi
or ee (Caption 6-("962) ° °
DEFENDANT SS SUBSTIEPUTED ANSWER TO PLAIN
TIFE'S SUBSTITUTED CROSS-COUNTER-CLAIM,
(Original Filed February D8, 1957),
-
7 Kirst) Defense,
For its First Defonse, Defendant Ransburg Electro.
Coating Corp. answers Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclaimy as
follows:
1, Defendant admits the averments of Paragraph 1,
2. Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 2 that
‘the amount in controversey is in excess of three the sand
dollars,’ and denies the vemaining averments of Para
eraph 2.
—
8. Defendant admits the averments of Paragraph :
4, Defendant admits the avernients of Paragraph 4.
Defendant ‘o. the averments of Parhgraph 5.
ss
(Defendant adits the avernent in Paragraph 6 that
“The Defendant has foo a number of vears and is presently
heensine under its United States Letters Patents processes
for eleetrostationlly "spray painting articles “and
SRO Jonses equipment adapted to practice such processes,
the products made under sueh licenses and by such
banipment being widely nsed in interstate eommerce
42 Defendant's Substituted Answer, ete.
throughout the United States.’ Defendant denies the re-
maining averments of Paragraph 6
7. Defendant admits the averments of Paragraph 7,
& Defendant admits the averments of Paragraph &.
% Defendant admits the averment in) Paragraph 9
that ‘* Defendant has and is presently granting licenses
under the aforesaid Starkey et al. patents,’’ and that such
licenses under Starkey Patent No, 2,685,536 are ‘for using
the method or procesigghereof and which process is known
as the ‘No, 2’ or airless type process.’’ Defendant denies
the remaining averments of Paragraph 9,
10. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 10,
11. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 11,
12. Defendant admits the averment in| Paragraph 12
that the Plaintiff has ‘developed a paint sprayer which
it is capable of manufacturing.’’ Defendan lenies the re-
maining averments of Paragraph 12.
13. Defendant ddmits the averment in Paragraph 138
that **The Defendant, in a letter dated July 12, 1956, sub
mitted to the Plaintiff its license forms Nos, 439 and 440
as boing standard forms of Defendant.’ Defendant denies
the remaining averments of Paragraph 13,
14. Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 14
that **On information ig belief, the Plaintiff understands
that the Defendant has, in ‘its licensing and leasing pro-
gram’ and © heginning about January of 1948 to the date
of the commencément of this action, employed 45 different
fortis of agreement.’’ Defendant denies the remaining
averments of I aragraph 14.
lo, Defendant admits the averment 4n Paragraph 15
that *'On information and belief, the Puaintif! understands
that up to the filing of the original complaint herein the
Defendant has: granted 738 Hieenses"' y and- ‘tof whie ‘h 463
re)
©
Defendants Substituted Answgr, ete. 433
\
were in force and effect on the date of the filing of the com. -
plaint herein’? Defendant denies the remaining averments
of Paragraph. 15,
f Paragraph 16.
—
16, Defendant admits the overments ¢
17. Defendaht admits the avernments of Paragraph 17,
18. Defendant denies the averments in Paragraph 18,
19, Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 19.
20. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 20,
21, Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 21,
22. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 22.
23. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 23,
“4. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 24.
25, Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 25 (d)
that ** it has never granted a patent license without at the
same time leasing equipment ;"'
Defendant admits the averment in unten 25 (hh) that
‘Ut has required lessees to aecept a termination provision
in leases which required the lessee, upon fermination of the
lease, to surrender to Defendant all of the leased equip
@ment without receiving anv refund for the initial fee of
thousands of dollars paid by the lessee;
Defendant admits the averments in Paragraph 25. (i)
that ‘Defendant has prov ‘ided in its composite lease aud
license agreement forms for the furnishing by Defendant
of servicessand replacement parts to the lessees ;"
Defendant denies the remaining averments of Paragraph
mt). ‘
26. Defendant admits the averments in Paragraph
26(a) and (b). Defendant denies the averments of: Para-
etaphs 26(¢e) and (d).
27.) Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 27.
‘
—_
ca
44 Defendant's Substituted Answer, ete.
28. Defendant denies the averments. of Paragraph 2%.
29. Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 29
‘that ‘*Defendant has segured patent rights from outside
s
9
parties.’’ Defendant denies the remaining averments of
Paragraph 29. 9 sg hy '
30. Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 30
that ** Defendant's predecessor, Harper J. Ransburg Com-
pany, entered into an agreement?’ * * * ‘‘with the Behr-
Manning Corporation,’’ and that ‘*Defendant has sue-
ceeded to all of said predecessor’s rights under said agree-
ment.’’ Defendant denies the remaining averments of
i Paragraph 30. e 7
31. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 31.
32.. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 32.
33. Defendant d®nies the averments ‘of Paragraph 33.
34. Defendant admits the averment in Paragraph 34
that .“‘Defendant does not sel! such systems ‘to users.’’
Defetidant denies the remaining averments of Paragraph
34. : ews °
$0.. Defendant denies the averments of Paragraph 35.
36.0 Defendant denies the averments.of Paragraph 36.
“7. Defendant denies: the averments of Paragraph 37.
38. Defendant denies fhe averments of Paragraph 38.
¢
Second Defense.
or its Second Defense, Defendant answers Plaintiff's
Cross-Counterclaim as follows:
1: The relief sought in Paragraph B of, the Praver of
Plaintiff's Cross-Counterclaim for treble damatés undér
the provisions of Seelion 15, Title 15, of the United States
Code, being an action to recover a penalty, the same is
harred by the statute of limitations to the extent to which
Defendant's Substituted Answer, ete. Sy
said cause of action accrued more than two years prior
to December 10, 1956, the date of the filing of aaid) Cross
_ Younterclaim herein.
Ransburg Ie bine ( oating Cdrp)
By Verne A. Thask,
SO1 Hume-Mansur Building,
Indianapolis 4, Indiana,
Attorney for Detendant
Of Counsel: 3
Klbert R. gilliom,
1340-1344 Consolidated Building,
Indianapolis, 4, Indiana,
Harry T. Ice,
951 Consolidated Building,
Indianapoli> 4, Indiana,
James P, Hume,
First National Bank Building, «+
38 South Dearborn Street,
Chicago 3, Dlinois.
Acknowledgment of Service.
Service of copies of the forégoing Defendant's Substiz
tuted Answer to Plaintiff’s Substituted Cross-Counterclainy
(Original Filed February 18, 1957) is acknowiedyed this
' 26th day’of Novetnber, 1958. | !
| Harold B. Hood, by CDE
Counsel for Pkiintif},
kb
we
a a
46 _ _Interrogatories and Answers.
INTERROGATORIES AND ANSWERS.
1 f.
Plaintiff's Iuterrogatories .
2.°(a) Has defendgut, in ‘its licens-
ing program, grauted any licenses
in whieh the licensee was licensed
under both patents relating to elec-
trostatic spraying with air and with-
out the use of air and, if so,
(b) what is the identity and date
of each of such licenses? . )
3. (a). How many licenser ian been
granted by defendant on electro-
(b) how many of those licenses are
still in f and effect and
if what are the dates -of all li-
censes that have been granted and
the names of the licensees of all
such licenses?
4. (a) Has the defendant ever
re
eer Answer “
a) Certain of defendant's Hcen-
have held or now hold, con-
curfently, licenses from defendant
to electrostatically spray t both
with air and without the use of air. °
(b) See list, Exhibit “A” attached.
3. (a) 732, up to the date of the
filing of the complaint.
,
(b) 463, up to the date of the filing
of the complaint.
(ec) Exhibit “B”, attached lists the
names and locations of the licen-
sees and the dates of ‘all ‘licenses.
granted by defendant up to the date
of the filing of the complaint for
celectrostatic spray coating or arti-
cles. In addition to the licenses
identified in Exhibit “B,” defend-
ant on commencement of business
acquired from its predecessor in
business a number of licenses with
companies engaged in electrostatic
spray coating of articles. 6
4. (a), To date all agreements by
granted a patient license relating a whieh? defendant has licensed the
to airless"electrostatic spraying as
to.which it did not enter into a lease
agreement with the licensee and,
if so,
7. (a) Is it not a fact that the de-
* fendant, in its licensing and leasing
m, repeatedly made changes
in its licenses and leases and, if so,
(b) did existent licensees get the
benefit of such changes and
(c) who were such licensees?
8. (a) How many different forms of
. Heenses and leases has the defend-
ant used in its licensing and ieasing
program,
(b) what is the date that actly
the same was adopted and
(c) what is the number or other
identity given to each form of lease
and license?
use of its airless electrostatic spray
coating process contain a provision
requiring defendant to furnish to
thé licensee some, but not all, of the
_ equipment for using the process. .
7. (a) Yes.
(b) In certain instancés.
(ce) See list, Exhibit “C” attached.
8. (a) (b) and (c) All of defend-
-ant’s agreement forms relating to
‘electrostatically spray coating of
articles are attached as Exhibits
D-1 through D-+45 and such exhibits
are self-explanatory.
Cy
Interrogatories
PA ;
_ Plaintiff's Interrogatories
10. What part of the defendant's
cost of each piece of leased equip-
ment is recovered by the defendant
at the time of its granting a lease
and a license under its patents?
- (a) Does the defendant, as a
part of its patent licenging and
leasing program, render engineer:
ing and technical services to its li-
censees and, if so,
ob) to what extent and
(c) wherein ts defendant compen-
sated for same?
12. (a) Does the defendant know of
any other supplier in the trade in
oe ae ae States of America of @ir-
ectrostatic spraying equlp-
aod and if 80,
(b) What is the name or names of
such other supplier or suppliers and
(c) where.is such supplier located ?
14. (a) Does the defendant apply
any patent markings to its leased
electrostatic. spraying equipment
and, if so,
(b) what does the marking suitahe
_in each instance?
16. (a) Does the defendant know of
‘anyone else in the United States of
America that is manufacturing and
selling electrostatic spraying equip-
ment for atomizing liquid into dis-
crete particles without the use of
air and, if so,
(b) what is the name of such mannu-
facturer and
(c) where is such manufacturer lo-
cated?
17. (a) Has the defendant, in addi-
tion to leasing its electrostatic
equipment for atomizing liquid into
discrete particles without the use of
- air, also sold snch equipment to the
trade and, if so,
(b) to whom
(c) when was such sale made and
(d) did such equipment have a pat-
.ent marking indicating Starkey Pat-
ent No. 2,685,536?
a
and Answers. .
. Answer
°'10. AH of it. «
11. (a) Yes.
(b) To all licensees to the extent.
necessary for their | effective use of
the process.
SS From fees paid by licensees. > ;
}2. (a) No, not as a unit.
‘
A. :
(b) “No answer required.
(c) No answer required..
14. (a) No. e
«
(b) No answer required.
>* 8
16. (a) No. \
* .
s . e
(b) No answer required.
(c) No answer required.
17. (a) No.
(b) No answer
(c) No answer
(d) No answer
required.
required.
required.
‘
.
epi ae.
3 : ace -
Plaintiff's Interrogatories
20. (a) Has any licensee of defend-
" ant under the Starkey patent No.
(b) that generally the voltage re
2,685,536 ever paid any royalties to
defendant on a practicing of the
_ patented Starkey process with any
“equipment other than what was, ,,
leased by defendant and, if so,
(bd) who made such payment or pay-
ments and
* (ce) when?
‘21. (a) What is the lowest voltage
the defendant has ever used in con-
junction ‘with .airless electrostatic
spraying equipment at which it ob-
tained atomization of the particular
liquid being sprayed,
(b) when and
(c) where was such sprftying con-
ducted?
22. (a) What was the highest volt-
age the defendant has ever used in
conjunction with its air type of
electrostatic spraying equipment,
(b) when and
(c) where was such equipment
operated ?
23. (a) Is it not a fact that the
Voltage at which atomization oc-
‘curs in the use of defendant’s afore-
said airless electrostatic spraying
process depends upon the nature of
the liquid being “sprayed and
a
.
quired increases with the viscosity
of the liquid and
Interrogatories and Answers.
.
. Answer *~
20. (a) All licensees under Starkey
patent 2,685,536 who have paid
royalties to defendant have~ been
furnished by defendant some equip-
ment for use in the Licensed process.
_l0 all instances such licensees also
obtained from other sources addi-
tional equipment for use in the li-
censed process.
(b) No angwer required.
(c) No answer required.
21. (a) Defendant has electrostati-
cally atomized conventional liquid
coating materials commerciaily at
a yoltage as low as si dcilaarecsimae!
20,000 volts.
(b) December,
quently.
(c) 1234 Barth Avenue, Indianapo-
lis, Indiana and a at
1955 and subse-
- other places.
22. (a) Defendant’s electrostatic
coating processes using compressed -
air spray have been operated com-
mercially at a voltage as high as
‘ approximately 90,000 volts.
(b) July, 1951 and subsequently., —
(c) Roberts Manufacturing Com-
pany, Cleburne, Texas and subése-
quently atcother places.
23, (a) Electrostatic atomization of-
a’ given liquid pccurs over a wide
range of voltages, all other condi-
tions being the same. The size of
the particles so atomized depends
to ‘an’ extent on the nature of the
liquid, under conditions of constant .
voltage and with all other factors
- constant. »
(b) The degree of ‘atomization usu-
ally. suffers i.e., the particles be-
come largér, as the viscosity of
liquid being electrostatically. atom-
_ ized increases, other factors being
maintained constant. However, it
does not follow that deterioration
of atomization resulting from in-
creases in viscosity can be over-
come merely by increasing thé volt-
age applied. ~
a *
PH
4 \
Plaintiff's Interrogaturies
(23 vont’d).
(c) what are the upper and lower
limits of the voltage at which atom-
ization can occur in the use of said
process: in the spruying of all dif-
ferent types of liquid’ handled,
thereby? :
24. (a) Wil defendant's aforesaid
airless electrostatic spraying proc-
ess atomize all kinds of known
liquid and, if not,
(b) what are the limits of the range
of liquids that can be atomized by
such spraying process?
* .
25. (a) Does temperature constitute
a factor in the spraying of a liquid
by defendant’s aforesaid process of
airless electrostatic searing and,
if so,
(b) to What extent and
ae
(ce) if a range of temperatures is
involved, what is the range?
26. In the use of defendant's afore
said process af airless electrostatic
spraying, when is a liquid particle
a discrete particle from the stand-
point of the practice of defendant's
process?
@
27. (a) What is the earliest date of
invention as to Starkey Patent No.
2,685,536 that defendant will rely
‘upon herein and |
(b) what are the activities there
involved and °
(c) the dates of same that will be
relied upon by defendant to estab-
lish such earliest date?
29. Can the afgrementioned "Starkey
patented process produce a coating
of paint, on an object which is held
stationary with respect to the atom-
oats Read? .
Interregatories
and Answers.
Answer
(23 cont'd)
(c) As indicated in the above an-
swer to portion (a) of this inter-
rogatory, electrostatic atomization
of a given liquid occurs over a wide
range of voltages, the extreme lim-
its of which defendant has hot ex:
plored.
24. (a) No.
(b) Defendant dues not know the
limits of the range of liquids which
can be atomized by such spraying
process.
25. (a) Temperature of the tijuid
constitutes a factor in the spraying
.of the liquid in defendant’s process
of airless electrostatic spray coat-
ing.
(b) To the extent that influences
viscosity.
(c) Defendant has explored the
limits of the range Hf temperatures
involved.
26. In the use of defendant's proc-
ess of airless electrostatic spray
coating, the liquid particles formed
as a result of atomization are dis-
crete particles since they are sepa-
rate, individually distinct, minute
entities.
27. (a)vAs at present advised, on-or
about October 8, 1943.
(b) and (c) Experiment involving
electrostatic atomization of paint
on or about October 8, 1948; dis-
closure to others on or about ‘Octo-
ber 8, 1943 and subsequently ; note-
book entry and sketch by October
29, 1943; further tests on November
5 and 9, 1943 ; drawing of apparatus.
in operation on November 1), 1943;
and Additional operations of the ©
process and testing of various ap-
paratus thereafter.
29. Yes.
e :
————
cogiyiaieen,
5 7 atk
Plaintiff's Interrogatories
33. (a) Which of the forty-five
forms of license. previously filed
herein by the defendant, in its an-
sewers to plaintiff's interrogatories,
was used in ‘the case of each of the
782 licenses granted by the defend-
* ant as set forth in the answer to
Interrogatory 3, :
(b) what was the name of the li-
censee appearing on each form,
(c) what was the date of each aud .
(d) which of said licenses, in each
fustance, licensed the use of air-
less electrostatic spray coating o
articles? '
34. With further regard to the sub-
ject of Interrogatory No. 33, what
patent numbers or patent applica-
tion numbers were referred to or
ang in each of the licenses, if
any .
\
35. (a) @Vith further regard to the
foregoing Interrogatory No. 33,
which of the listed licenses was re-
stricted only to airless electrostatic
spray coating of articles and
(b) ywhich of the aforesaid licenses
comprise the 463 that Are alleged to
be still in force and effect?
°
36. With further regard to the li-
censes referred to in Interrogatory
_ 83, eS was furnished
in the c of each of them by the
defendant as set forth in the an-
swer to. Interrogatory 4?
¢
87. In. connection with the defend-
ant’s answer to Interrogatory 3,
(a) what was the nanf® of the de-
fendant’s predecessor or predeces-
sors and, =,
(b) what was the identity of the
licenses acquired from such prede-
cessor with respect to the
(c) name of the party,
(d) the licensee,
(e) date and
Interrogatories and Answers.
°
Answer
33. (a' (b) (c) and (d) See Ex-
hibit E attached.
u
38
”
a 7 “
34. No patent or patent application
numbers were listed or referred to
in any license agreements of the
defendant except as shown on Ex-
hibit F attached.
35. (a) With the exception of the
ligense dated May 25, 1951 to
Chrom-Craft Corp. (Exhibit E—
' Page 8), all licenses indicated. in
Column III of that Exhibit are re-
stricted to airless electrostatic spray
coating. f :
(b) The licenses referred to in In- .
terrogatory No. 35 (a) which are
still in force are indicated in Col-
-umn IV on the list attached hereto
as Exhibit E. .
36. In the cases of the various 1i-
censes referred to in plaintiff's In-
terrogatories Nos. 38 and 4, the
equipment furnished by :defendant
was similar in character but varied
as to quantities, attachments and
fittings, dependent upon the size
and character of the installations.
In each case the equipment fur-
nished was listed in. a record of
shipment, an example of which is
attached hereto as Exhibit G.
37.
(a) Harper J. Ransburg Co., a
partnership. :
(b) (c) (d) and (e) The licenses
referred to in defendant’s answer
to Interrogatory No. 3 as having
been taken over from defendant's
predecessor are identified in Ex-
hibit H attached.
\
‘
Intprrogatories and Answers. . $i
6 7
Plaintiff's Interrogatories ° Answer
(37 cont'd) (47 cont'd)
(f) patents or applications inyolved (f) In each license listed in Ex-
in each of such licenses? hibit H, the licensee was “licensed
+ : for a particular uée wherein atomi-
zation is effected by compressed ‘hir
and the licensee thereby obtained a
; license under all patept rights then | ,
© held or thereafter acquired by Har, |
& per J. Ransburg Co. to the extent
that such rights applied to,’ such
use, without express identification
. of any specific patent or patent ap
as ° + plication in the Hcense agreement.
40. (a) How many licenses were 40. (a) 171.
granted by the defendant prior fo
the issuance of the Starkey patent
on August 3, 1954 for airless elec-
trostatic spray coating (without the :
use of air), and
(b) what was the date of the first (4) March 21, 1949.
one granted? ?
41. (a) When did the defendant 41. ya) July 26, 1961.
\
a
first publicly demonstrate its elec- ~
~ trostatic airless “pray coating proc- ~
e88,
(b) where and {b) 12384 Barth Avenue, Indianapo-
‘ lis, Indiana.
(c) to whom was same first*¥emon- (c) Approximately 25 representa-
strated? tives of trade journals. Prior to
_ the date in (a) above, private dem-
° onstrations were given to selected
individuals on various occasions, .
44. With further regard to defend-‘ . .
ant’s answer to Interrogatory %1, |
(a) do the licenses and/or leases (a) No. The only specific provision
that have been granted specifically for a technical service fee is the
provide for technic] service fees to provision, as in Form 489 (Exhibit
be paid in each instance, and not, D-36), that if defendant's installa-
tion supervisor is delayed in licen-
see's plant for any reason not
chargeable to defendant, the licen-
, ; see pays to defendant a per. diem
‘ : of $75.00 during such delay.
(b) on what percentage of the li- (b) Defendant has been paid such
censes or lenses did the .defendant ‘per diem in respect to approximately
obtain such service fees from the 1) pér cent of its licenses.
licens@es ? . °
?
47. (a) In the light of depositions 47. (a) No. ? @
tuken by defendant herein, will the g
defendant contend that ther@ was
any confidential or secret disclosure
of ‘the subject matter of the appli-
cation from which Starkey Patent
2,685,536 issued to representatives
of the plaintiff prior to the issuance
of the Starkey patent .and, if so,
a e
52 Interrogatories and Answers. i
. : © £ a
7 :
Plaintiff's Interrogatories Answer.
(47 cont) (47 cont'd)
‘(b) . when, (b) No answer required.
. te) where and (¢) No answer required.
(d) to whom was disclosure or
disclosures made?
coating process,
(b) to whom was such representa-
tion made, . «
(c) in what form and 4
(d) by whom?
52. (a) Has the defendant ever sub-
mitted a license under its Starkey
patent alone without an accompany-
ing proposed agreement for the fur-
nishing of equipment”by the defend-
ant and, if so,
(b) to whom was such license form
sent and
(c) when?
53. (a) Has the defendant ever
offered to. I , under the Star-
key Patent No. 2,685,536, any manu-
facturer of spray coating equipment
capable of practicing the process of
the Starkey patent with the right
to make and sell electrostatic erait-
ters and, if so, ’
id to whom waa such offer made
‘ :
(c) ,.when?
54. With further reference to the
subject of the previous interroga-.
tory, No.
(a) has the defendant ever offered
to license any supplier of spray
coating equipment with the right to
make and sell such equipment for
practicing the process of Starkey
Patent No. 2,685,536 without, at the
same ‘time, requiring that such li-
censee sell only to users or cus-
neg licensed by defendant and,
80,
(b) when and
(c) to whom? |
(d) No answer reqpired.
51. (a) Karly in 3008, «©
«2
(b> William Halker of Blectric
Auto Lite Co.
(c) Orally.
(d) E. M, Ransburg.
: \
52. (a) Defendant has never sub-
mitted any license limited to its
Starkey, et al, patent alone.
ew
(b) No answer required.
(c) No answer required.
53. fa) No.
(b) No answer required. .
(c) No answer required.
(a) No.
eo
(b) No answer required.
(c) No answer required.
4
oa
Interrogatories and Answers. ° 33
8
Plaintiff's Interrogatories’
5@, (a) Have any of thé, licenses
nted by defendant deen
gra under
its Ransburg Patent No. 2,658,000"
and, if so,
(b) what is their identity?
61. Has Defendant, in its licensing
spray
licenses such as its forms Nos. 428
and 430, requiring licensees to grant
back to Defendant, a royalty-free,
non-exclusive cattgnatte license,
, With right to sub-license, * such li-
* cense to be irrevocable ex upon
voluntary surrender by .,
any inventions, ensovenente, or
any rights from any source under
letters patent, domestic or foreign.
pertaining to methods and a ~-¥
tus for electrostatic atomizatlo
liquids?
' 62. If the answer to the —
Interrogatory is in the a ——e
(a) what is the date of each such
whom was * such license
-
Answer
50. (a) Yes. —
(b) Without a review of all license
agreements and a search of ali of
Defendant's files, a complete list of
all persons licensed under the par-
ticular patent could not be pre-
pared, but the following are licensed
under the patent referred to:
Scoville Manufacturing Co.
Taylor Wharton Iron & Steel Co.
Thomas Industries, Inc.
61. Defendant has entered into li-
censes under its forms Nos. 428,
429, 430, 431, 432, 483, 434 and
434-2 (Exhibits D-23 thru D-29 and
defendant has entered into certain
D-81 respectively), and in addition
special experimental licenses, which
licenses contain a provision gener-
ally similar to that set out in In-
terrogatory 61.
62. (a) and (b). Exhibit E to de-
fendant’s answer to plaintiff's In-
terrogatory 33 contains the dates
and licensees of each license granted
on the form numbers specified in
answer 61 above. The dates and
licensees of such special experi-
mental licenses referred to in an--
swer 61 are as follows:
Date of
Licensee License
All Steel Equipment, Inc. 8-31-56
Anderson-Hickey Co., Inc. 6-12-57
Hugh J, Baker & Co. 5-1-57
Baxter Steel Equipment Go. 9-11-56
Bethlehem Steel Co., Inc. 11-30-56
Baugher Mfg. Co. 6-83-57
Colson Corp. 104-57
Eastern Venetian Blind Co. 6-14-49
E. Fr. DuPont de Némours_&
Inc. ° “se 4-26-56
Ferro Corporation 12-18-56
General Electric Co. R-2-55
3-12-56
*
“a ,
uN
4 Interrogatories and Answers.
.
9
: Pluintiff's Interrogatories fs,
(2 contd)
(ec) which of such licehses are still
in force and effect?
°
63. Has the. Defendant’ acquired
patent rights in the field of elec-
trostatic spray coating from par-
ties. outside the Defendant's organ-
ization, including licensees?
64. If the answer to the preceding
interrogatory is in the affirmative,
what are
(a) the thames of the parties from
whom such rights were obtained .
(b) the numbers of the wdieate i in-
volved, and
(ce) the datés on which such ‘rights
were acquired?
ttsburgh Plate Glass‘ Co. 7-1-55
lantation Patterns 6-26-57
Seymour Tool & Engfneer-
ing.Co. 11-17-50
Speed Queen Division. A
McGraw Edison f 10-11-57
Stewart-Warner Corp. 10-7-57
Studebaker-Packard Corp. 4-1-57
Superior Coach Co. 3-26-57
(c) All in Exhibit E listed as ac-
tive if column IV and which used
the form numbers specified in an-
awer 61 above and all those listed
in answer 62(ay) and (b) sabove, ex- °*
cept the following which have been
terminated since Commencement of
suit:
° Date of
Licensee License
Chromcraft Corp. $-25-51
Heintz Mfg: Co. a 12-18-53
Houdaille-Hershey Corp. 11-1-54
Miller Company 10-16-53
Norris-Thermador Corp. T4-54
» . Progress Mfg. Co., Inc. 9-17-53
‘ Whirlpool-Seeger Corp.
° 12-4-52
63. Yes.
tH. (ad(b) and (ce).
Other than patent rights acquired
at the time of defendant's organi-
zation from its predecessor, Har-
per J. Ranasburg Co., the defend
has acquired rights in patents.
the fleld of electrostatic spray coat-
ing from parties other than defend-
ant’s officers, employees and consult-
ants in the following instances :
Research Corp. 2,097,233 and 2,221,-
, 338 acquired 10-7-48
oh Kahan 2,548,477, acquired
i Ley
te Answer
(62 cont'd) ;
« Juee ¢ Date of
Licensee License
Hardy Division, Shelier
Mfg. Co. 7-20-57 |
Hetherington & Kerner 3-22-57
SHillenbrand Associates (27-57 ’
' [linois Power Co. . §-16-57 .°
Indiana Gear Works > 7-16-57
King .Seeley 11-77-87
Monroe. Auto Equipment
Co. 1-25-51
Murphy-Miller, Inc. 7-16-57
Pacific Paint & Varnish 6-13-55
Paramount Fabricating Co. 10-11-57
Pemco Corp o8-21-56
Pittsburgh < Corning. Corp. , 719-5
3
7 Interrogatories
10
laintiff’s Interrogatories
67. Has Defendant ever granted Il-
to paint or other coating, ma-
terial manufacturers in which
(a) initial fge payable by such
manufacturers was less than the
initial fee charged. to other
re for the same type of equip-
t, or
(b) ee minimum monthly fee pay-
able by such. manufacturers was
leas than the minimum monthly’ fee
- charged to other users for the same
type of equipment? °
68. If the answer to either or both
portions of the _—— interrog-
atory ig in the affirmative, what are
a) the names of such paint or
ting manufacturers
(b) the dates on which such licen-
oes were issued :
»
Na 8
°
69. Has any paint or other ,coating
material manufacturer ever adver-
tised its paint or coating material.
for use with a coating process or
apparatus of Defendant?
Ti. (a) Does the Defendant own in
excess of substantially two and one
quarter million dollars’ worth of
leased. electrostatic spray coating
equipment plus replacement parts,
and
(b) if do, is at least 75% of such
equipment designedafor the airless
type of electrostatic spray coating?
¢
78. Did the Ford Motor Company
ever negotiate with Defendast.for a
paid-up license under ne of De-
/ Sendant’s? ’
av
*
and Answers, ee)
-
“48. (a) and (b). an
Ditzler Color Division, : Pittsburgh
Plate Glass Co. 10-4-50 ,
Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. 7-1-55
Pacific Paint & Varnish Co. 6-13-55
E. I. DuPont deNemours & Cf. 4-7-40
and 4-26-56 .
Pemco ‘Corp. 8-21-56
Ferro Corp. 12-18-56
69. Yes.
71. (a) and (b).
(a) No: The aggregate approximate
cost of equipment and replacement
parts when shipped was in excess
of $2,250,000.
(b) On the* basis of cost, at least
75% of such equipment was de-
signed for the airless type of _elec-
trostatic spray coating.
73. No, but a quotation was re-
quested by Ford Motor Company on
July 6, 1956 for a- paid-up license
~ with equipment.
e.
i)
Gg
Interrogatories and Answers.
\ .
11
Plaintiff's Interrogatories
74. If the answer to the preceding ©
imterrogatory is in the affirmative,
what are
(a) the dates of such negotiations,
ib) the amount which Defendant
proposed fo charge Ford for such, 4.
license? .
> to 2.5 mills
Answer ;
.74. (a) The quotation was _ sub-
mitted on August 14, 1956.
(b) The quotation submitted was |
as follows, as set forth in the “Pro-
posal tm Ford Motor Company for
Equipment ‘to Paint Hvods,” a copy
of which has heretofore been fur-
nished ‘to Plaintiff :
“Ransburg will’ supply :
“(a) one unit to apply finish
enamel on the outside only to hoods
for $32,500.00 to product (sic.) a
omaximum of 50,000 hoods per year,
or “(b) one unit to apply finish
enamel on the outside only to hoods
for $267,000.00 without annual max-
imum limits. It is estimated that
this unit is ble of applying 2.0
m thickness at ap-
proximately three hoods per minute,
or, on a three-shift basis, approxi-
mately 720,000° hoods per year, or
“(c) sufficient units to apply finish
enamel on the outside only to all.
hoods produced by Ford in_ the
. U.S.A, for $700,000.00 plus $15,000.00
for each unit required.
“A single unit consists of two re
ciprocating 25” disks,. one yoltage
pack and controls, two insulated
paint pumps, electricakh cables and
polyethylene tnbing to supply cur-
rent and paint to t disks, as
shown Ree ee. 3 No. 231823, and
‘engineering drawings. Ford will
supply nveyors, hangers, the
metal enclosures, ventilation, and
the reciprocating mechanisms to
“meet Ransburg’s requirements.
“Feansburg will aleo run the cus-
tomary test demonstrations and in-
‘stallation supervision and inatruc- :
tion. : ;
“This proposal is subject to the pro-
tective clauses: in Ranshure’s regu-
lar, agreement.
“Terms of payment and shipment
dates subject: to agreement.”
Subsequently, ‘at Ford's request, Yn
September 11, 1956, defendant
mailed to Ford its standard printed.
forms for licenses both, with and
without equipment. . ¥ °
75. No, other than the licensees.
6
Interrogatories and Answers. — 57
Praintift’s Interrogatories
75. Does the Defendant know of
any concern or party other than De-
fendant which renders any servic- -
ing for Defendant's electrostatic
spray coating equipment. in the
hands of Defendants licensees? —
12
78. Beginning in about May, 1953
did Defendant send out a forin let-
ter to ita licensees identical or.sub-
stantially identical in content to
the letter to Altex Corporation
dated July 15, 1953, a copy of which
is attached hereto as “Exhibit A”?
79.’ Did Defendant, in letters trans-
mitting license and lease agreements
after May, 1953 include in s et-
ters a statement reading -
tially as follows:
“We understand that you wish this
type of agreement rather than one
under which we do not furnish these _
additional items.”
80. (a) Does Defendant know of
any prior writings from recipients
of the letters referred to in the
(b) what are the dates of such writ-
ings, and .
(c) from whom were they received?
e
81. (a) Has Defendant issued any
licenses relating to electrostatic
spray coating in which the duration
of payments to be made by licensees
was confined expressly by the terms
of such license to the life of any
patent or’ patents under which sach
license was granted, and if so, -
(b). who were the lfcensees involved
in each such transaction, and -
fc) what were the dates thereof?
82. (a) Has Defendant issued any
license in the fields of manufactur-
ing abrasive articles, flock coated
articles, and/or articles coated with
fiber-shaped particles, and if so,
(b) what is the identity of each»
such licensee, and
(c) what is the date of each eAioh
_Heense?
Answer
va
7s. Yes.
79. Yes; but said letters transmitted ”
posed contracts for execution
than consummated agree-
2
. 80. (a) No, although there may be
some s writings which might be
found upon‘a search of the files.
\
Q
(b) and (c). No answer required. =
e- re
81. (a). No * ;
© : .®,
(hb) an@? (c) No angwer required.
*
*R1. (a) No.
(b) and (ce) Np answer required.
+
58 Interrogatorics and Answers. §
13
Plaintiff's Interrogatories o: Answer
53. (a) Has Defendant received any 83. (a) No, but on occasion dgfend-
inquiries for licenses in the fields
of manufacturing abrasive articles,
flock coated articles, and/or articles
coated with fiber-shaped particles,
and if so,
(b) what disposition was made of
such inquiries?
- &4. In the list of equipment supplied
by Defendant appearing’ as Exhibit
“G" in Defendant's Answer to Piain-
tiff’s Interrogatory No. 36,
(a) what is the identity of the
claim or claims of each patent un-
' der which. Defendant has acquired
. -rights from outside parties as men-
tioned in Interrogatories 638 and
-which apply to such equipment or
the use thereof in the electrostatic
spray coating of liquids?
‘85. What is the amount of royal-
ties and fees received year by year
by the Defendant*to the present
‘date on the licenses which it has
granted in the electrostatic spray
coating field? ie
86. What is the amount of» royal-
ties and fees received year by year
to the present date by the Defend-
ant on its licenses for airless elec-
trostatic spray coating? |
ant has received inquiries as fo
whether its processes’ and equip-
ment are suitable for one or more
of these, purposes. '
Y
°(D) Defendant hag replied in sub-
stance that its process and equi
ment are primarily for electrostatic
painting, and has informed the in-
quirer that Behr-Manning Company
might be able to furnish the desired
information. | 4
84. None.
4
“end
85. and ok
Total fees received year by year by
defendant (and by defendant's pred-
ecessor) for its compressed air
spray process (No, 1 Process) and
for sits airless process (No. 2 Proc-
ese) since the commencement of the
marketing of its electrostatic spray
coating processes in 1944 are ap-
proximately as follows:
No.1 No. 2
Year Process Fees Process Fees
1943 _ i $s —
* 1044 47,000 —
0045 165,000 —
1946 2 270,000 —
1947 880,000 --
1948 555,000 _
1949 665,000 —
1950 810,000 , 6,000
1951 880,000 | 210,000
1952 820,000 585,000
* 19653 . 890,000 700,000
1954 Bf20.000 1,075,000
1955 830,000 1,485,000
1956 720,000 2,220,000
630,000 2,640,000
u
14 wa:
Plaintiff's Interrogatories
Sv. (a) Has Deéfendant or anyone
else evet sold or offered for sale
any second-hand or used equipment
of Defendant for airless electro-
static spray coating, and, if so,
(b) to whom was such sale or offer
to sell made? ve
1). (a) Does Defendant license its
electro-static spray coating process
in foreign conntries, and, if so,
(b) in each instance what is,
(1) the date of each, such license
(2) the identity of the licensee in
each such license and
(3) the terms under which such li-
cense Was granted.
. Does Defendant own any for-
ign patents corresponding to Star-
key et al., U. 8. Patent No, 2,68f,-
536, and if so,
(a) in what foreign countries have
such patents issued, and
(b) what is the filing date
issue date
numbér of each such: patent.
a
93. As to its charge of infringement
of its apparatys patent 2,794,417,
does defendant
(a) rely upon any structure used
by plaintiff not already “embraced
in the charge of infringement’ un-
der defendant's @yethod patent No.
2.685.536, and
(b) if the answer is in the affirma-
tive, what is the additional atrue-
ture which is relied upon by de-
fendant?
»
dnterrogaiories and Answers,
a
‘59
ie
Answer P
Si. (a) No,
~~,
(b)gNo answer required.
WO. (na) Yen,
(b) beet: ,
(1) and (2) See Exhibit K
(3) Either a copy of the license
agreement identified in Exhibit K
is, attached or its terms in = sub-
stance are identified in Exhibit K
by reference to forms comprising
Exhibit D, previously given to plain. °
tiff in answer to plaintiffs interrog-
atories. .
02. Yes,
(a) Canada
(b) September 20, 1945 °, ~~
September 21, 1948 y
No. 451,277
93. A
(a) No. |
ww
(b) No answer required.
t
%
sl
60 ‘Interrogatories
1S.
Plaintife’s Interrogutortes
wh. Did the defendant in connection
with the prosecution of ite alleged
earlier application Serial Number
“500,300, from which’ its process pat-
ent No. 2,685,536 iasued,
(a) ever file an appeal or a Bhi
of Complaint tony. of the courts
based on the Board of Appeal’s de-
cision dated December 18, af-
tirming the Examiner's final rejec-
tlon of apparatus claims 63, 65, 87.
und 05, and * .
(b) df eo, what was the identity
und date of such procéedings, and
_ fe) what disposition was made of
same, and ' =
(da) when?
°
*
06. In any of the proveedings in-
volving the earlier application Se-
rial No. 556,390, from which proc-
ean patent 2,685,536 issued,
(a) did the Patent Office ever make
a requirement for division as be-
tween process and apparatus claims
and ,° 1°
(b) if ao, when?
_{71. Who in the defendant organi-
zation made or approved of the de-
. cision to cancel all, the apparatus —
claima No, 40, 44, 68, 65, 87, 94-and
nt — the earller application Se-
rial No, 556.390, from which the
process patent , 2,685,536, issued?
8. (n) When did the defendant
first claim in a patent application
drown airless electrostatic spraying
apparatus the specific feature of
having spaced atomizing points “suf-
ficiently close. together to permit
the coating material to bridge the
apaces therebetween” and
(by) what was the identity of such
application wherein such feature
was claimed.an
(c) what. waa-the identity by num- |
her ‘of the first claim or claima
claiming such feature? R
ruary 15, 10954,
. Serlal No. 800
=~
and Answers.
2
° Answer
95. (a), (b), (c), and (d). On Feb-
defendant filed in
the District. Court for the District
of Columbid, a complaint in an ac-
tion entitled “William A, Starkey,
Edwin M. Ransburg, and Rans-
burg Electro-Coating Corp. vs. Sin-
clair Weeks Secretary of Commerce,
and Robert C. Watson, Commis-
' sioner gf Patents,” ©. A. No. 625-54,
‘seeking; in effect, reversal of the
decision of the Board ‘of Appeals
of December 18, 19538, affirming the
final rejection of apparatus claims
63, 65, 87, and 95 .and ‘ certain
method claims in said application
. On March &,
1954, following allowance by the
Patent Office on February 18, 1954,
of said application -as amended,
such action was dismissed by stip
ulation,
96, Oe
(a). No,
(hb) No answer required.
97, BE. M.\Ransburg, Vice President.
.
q
'
18. (f) August 21, 1956 was the .
earliest date on which Sozongant
presented in a patent. application
any claim to an airless electrostatic
apray coating apparatus using the
expression “sufficiently close to-
gether to permit the coating mate-
_ Mal to bridge the spaces therebe-
tween", to describe the atrangement
of points at which atomization—oc-
curs.
(b) Serlal No, 434,366, on which
patent No, 2,794,417-t suit issued.
‘(c) lath 18 of the application
Which became claim 4 of said pat-
ent.
-
‘
?
* leased
spraying equipment for applying |
\
%
16 ’
Platnotiff’s Interrogatories
102. As far as the defendant knows,
has any of its airless No. 1 electro-
static systems been used for
. (a) coating with abrasives,
(b). coating with flocking, and
(c) If the ‘answer to a or b fa in
the affirmative, when and
(d) by whom ‘and
(e) where?
104. As far as the defendant knows,
(a) has its licensee, Behr-Manning
Corporation ever made, old or
airless type electrustatic
Po particle coating materials and
80°
ib) when and
(c) to whom was such equipment
furnished?
‘105. Under the’ cross license agree-
ment (Ex. VV) with Behr-Matining
Corporation, dated September 26,
1944, how does the defendant deter-
thine when*a coating is considered
to be of the
(a) “liquid particle type” as to
which At is licensed and °
(b). when it is considered 40 be of
the' “solid particle type’, as to
which Behr-Manning is licensed?
ve, ¢
{
106., Under the cross license agree-
ment with Behr-Manning dated Sep-
tember °26, 1944, which party ,has
_ the right to operate in the fleld of
coating materials such as
~~
(a) wax
_ (bd) tars
(c) plastic resins and
(d) rosins?
“
* |
“interrogatories and Answers. 61
’ Answer
102, (a) and (b). No.
(c), (d), and (e). No answer re-
quired, \
104. (a) No.
. ' | :
(b) and (c). No answer required
105. (a) Under the terms of its
agreement with Behr-Manning Corp.
dated September 26, 1044; the de-
fendant considers that a coating is
of the “liquid particle type” as to
which it is licensed ynder the Behr-
Manning patents if such coating is
a liquid at the time of atomization
and is not. used in the manufacture
of abrasive articles” or of flock-
coated article or arti@les coated
with fiber-shaped particles.
(b) Defendant has had no occasion
in connection with said agreement
to consider whether any given coat-*
ing is of: a “solid particle type”
inasmych as Behr-Manning Corp.'s
license under defendant's listed pat-
ents is not determined by the type
of coating used, but is determined
by the nature of the article manu-
factured.
106. Under the terms of defendant's
ment with Behr-Manning Corp.
datet September 26, 1944, defendant
has the right to use the patents and
applications covered by/ the. agree-
ment with respect to coating mate-
rials such aq
(ay wax
(b) tars
(c) plastic resins, and °
(d) rosins to the extent that such
‘ materials are liquids when atom-
62
17
Plaintiff's Interrdgatorles
( LUG. cont'd)
111. As far as the defendant knows,
have the parties to the cross license
ugreement dated September 26,
144, between Ransburg and Bebr-
Manning Corp. whereby the electro-
static deposition fleld was divided
into one of liquid particle coating
und another of solid particle coat-
ing
(a) lived up to the provisions of
such agreement, and
(b) is such an agreement still of
force and effect, apd
(c) if not, when was it terminated?
115. Referring to the answer to In-
terrogatory 83a, b,
(a) what is the identity of all in-
quiries referred to therein and
J :
(b) the identity of all responses
thereto?
W7. (a) Was the defendant ever
advised by Dr. Emery P. Miller or
anyone else that prior to October
1948, it was old in the scientific
arts to use an electrostatfe fleld for
effecting’ atomization and spraying
of liquid particles and If so
(vb) what was the name of —_
person,
(c) the identity of such prior “ne,
and
(da) the date when such advice or
knowledge was received?
“p¥Fidge, Mass.,
Interrogatories and Answers.
Answer
(106, cont'd) .
ized and are not used for the
manufacture of abrasive articles or
flock-coated articles or articles
coatéd with fiber-shaped particles,
and Behr-Manning: Corp. hag the
right to use such patents with re-
spect to such materials when used
fo. the purpose of manufacturing
such articles.
‘
111, Without adopting plaintiff's
characterization of said contract,
defendant answer Interrogatory 111
us follows:
(a) Yer,
(b) Yes,
(c) No unswer required,
115. The identity of all inguthies
and) responses. referred: to in de-
fendant’s answer to plaintiff's In-
terrogatory 83 of which defendant
knows, are - follows:
(a) Inqui
latter ye at December 17, 1952
from American Wringer Co., Ine.
Woonsocket, R. I. to defendant.
Letter dated February 10, 1955 from
Dewey and Almy Chemical Co. Dt-
vision of W. R. Grace & Co., Cam-
to defendant.
(b) Reaponses
Letter dated December 29, 1952 from
gas to American Wringer Co.,
ne,
Letter dated February 15, 1955 from
defendant to Dewey and = Almy
Chemical Co,
117. (a), (b), (e), and (d). Since
comin \into existence, defendatt ,
has khowl that it was old, prior to
October 1948, to use’an electrostatic
fleld for effecting atomization and
spraving of liquids, At least one of
the officers of defendant possessed
such knowledge at the time of de-
aa incorporation on. January
1,
Interrogatories and Answers.
18
Plaiptif’s Interrogatories *
122. (a) Who in the defendant com-
pany authorized oF approved of its
counsel adding to its patent appli-
cation, from which the a ratus
patent 2,704,417, issued Claim 18 of
Amendment C (which now corre-
. sponds to Claim 4, charged to be in-
o
fringed by plaintiff herein) and
(b) what was the identity of such
authorization?
123. (a) Who in the defendant's
company, or employ, divulged around
July or’ August, 1056, to its counsel
(prosecuting the application from:
which its patent 2,704,417 issued)
the subject of plaintiff's electro-
static sprayer apparatus which had
been disclosed in plainfiff’s letter
of July 5, 1956, to defendant re
ferred to in the complaint herein
(b) on what date,
(¢) who was present at the time of
disclosure, and
(d) what Was the identity of any |
letters or record made bearing in
any way on such disclosure?
124. (a) Did defendant at any time
during the more than twelve years,
pendency of its applications from
which its two patents 2,658,536 and
2,704,417 issued, ever assert prior
to August 1956 any claim on airless
electrostatic spraying in any pend-
ing application in tha Patent Office
wherein it. was specified that the
atomizing space points were ‘‘suffi-
clently close together to permit the
coating material to bridge the spaces
therebetween”
(b) if the answer is in:the affirma-
tive, what ia the identity of each
and every said claim?
125. (a) Who in the defendant com-
pany authorized the filing in the
United States District Court for the
District of Columbia the Complaint
in the case of Wm. A. Starkey,
Edwin M. Ransburg and Ransburg
Electro-Coating Corp. va. Sinclair
Weeks, Secretary of Commerce and
Robert «. Watson, Commissioner of
Answer
22. (a) BE. M. Ransburg.
‘(b) Oral, at some time between Au-
gust 8 and Au 21, 1966.
123, Defendaft received no letter
from plaintif! dated July 5, 1056
disclosing the nature of plaintiff's
xprayer, but did receive the letter
duted July 25, 1056 referred to in
the complaint herein, enclosing a
drawing of the sprayer designated
Ss ‘1, and afswers as follows with
reppect to said letter and sprayer:
(a) Defendant does not now know
who communicated to its counsel
the subject matter of said sprayer.
(b) Shortly ‘after the receipt of
said letter, on or about July 26,
1956
(¢) Not now known.
(d) Defendant kréws of no letters
or records bearing on sald = dis-
closhre.
124. (a) No.
(b) No answer required.
(a) FE. M. Ransburg.
‘ '_ a
ee
»
64 o
19 . )
# Plaintiff's Interrogatories
(125. cont'd)
Patents, C. A. 625-54 involving a
suit under Section 4915,
(b) to whom was such authority
Riven,
(c) when,
(d) was the authority referred to
in any way on a written paper, and
(e) if so, what was the date and
identity of such paper or papers?
126. Referring to Starkey et al vs.
Weeks et al, C. A. 625-54,
(a) who in the defendant company
authorized dismissal of such suit on
or about March 1954 -
(b) when, A
(c) to whom was the, authority
given and
(2) if in writing, whee was the date
of any and all paper writings or
correspondence on such subject?
127. (a)-Did the defendant on or
about March, 10954, enter into and
file a stipulation of dismissal in
Starvey ve. Weeks, C. A. 625-54
wherein it was recited:
“the Examiner having found allow-
able the claims now presented in
plaintiffs’ application here in suit,
and the Notice of Allowance thereof
having issued, ‘It is hereby stipu-
lated that the present action be dis-
missed’.”
and .-
(b) was the applic ation Serial Num-
ber 556,300 field Sept. 29, 1944, from
which the Starkey et al process pat-
ent No. 2,685,536 was later issued
on Aug. 3, 1954, the application that
was in suit.referred in the stipula-
tion and
(c) at the time of the sigiing and
filing of such stipulation were any
of the apparatus claims 63; 65,87
and 9 of said application Serial
Number 556,390 on which a patent
tion?
128. Is it not a fact that at the time
of the filing of the stipulation of
dismissal in the month of March
1984
(na) all of the apparatus claims in-
cluding claims 40, 55, 63, 65, 87, 94
and 95 had been eancelled by an
amendment.dated Jan. 27, 1954, to
application Serial Number 556,390
and
was prayed unger section 4915 in
said suit all in such applica-
Interrogatories and Answers.
Answer
°( 125. cont'd)
?
(b) The law firm of Schroeder,
Hofgren, Brady and Wefner,
¢c) Sbortly prior to the filing of:
said complaint.
(d) No.
(e) No answer required.
126.
(an) EK. M. Hansburg.
(b) At some time between Febru-
ary 18 and Margh 8, 1954.
(c) The law firm of Schroeder,
Hofgren, Brady and Wegner.
(ad) Not in writing.
127. Yen,
a
(a)
(hy Yes,
(c) No,
oO
128,
(a) At the time of the filing of
raid stipulation of dismissal in
Mar. 1954, all of the apparatus
claims, including claims 40, 55, 63,
15, 87. 94 and 95, of. said applica-
tion Serial No. 556,390 had been
cancelled by an amendment dated
Jan. 27, 1954, expressly without
P prejudice to applicant's right to file
a divisional or continuation appli-
cation directed to the apparatus
features of their invention.
o
&
Interrogatories and Answers. 65
20
Plaintiff's Loterrogatories
(128. cont'd)
(b) no application of defendant was
then pending in the Patent Office at
the time of the dismissal embodying
any such apparatus claims?
129. Is it not a fact that following
the Court's dismissal of Starkey vs.
Weeks, C. A. 265-54, brought under
Section 4915 R. 8S. for the grant of
a patent, the defendant requested
on or about Feb. 15, 1954 the hn-
pounding of the records of such
suit and
(b) if the answer is in the atfirma-
tive, what*was the date of such re-
“‘yuest for impounding and
(c) what was the date of the order
entered ordering the record of the
suit to be impounded against access
to the public, and
(e) who in the defendant company
authorized such impounding, and o
(f) to whom was such authoriza-
“tlon addressed and
(zg) 9 what form, one
(h) when?
183. (a) Has the defend@ht con-
ducted any experimentation with
regard to airless electrostatic coat-
ing to determine how large or how
low the number of liquid particles
‘should be to effect a serene
coating and
(b) if so, when were such testa
made, ’
(c) by whom.
(d) with what liquids, and
(e) what if any was the range of
size of particles developed by such
testa?
134. Does the defendant in its No. 2
Airless electrostatic system (which
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit), °
(a) employ an electrostatic atomiz-
ing head from which liquid’ par-
ticles are emitted in an electrostatié
field_of-sufficient strength to charge
the particles for deposition on an
article, and
(b) if the answer is in the affirma-
tive, what “strength” iff terms of
units of eléctrical measurement ix
considered “sufficient” {n such
(c) if there is a range of “strength,”
what is that range?
Answer
(128. cont'd)
(bo You
ta) Yes,
th) On or about Mar. 15, 195-4.
(ce) Mar, 15, 1404.
bid » M. Ransburg authorized the
est.
(ny Schroeder, Hofgren. Brady and
Wegner.
(gz) Oral.
(h) At some time between Feb. 15
and Mar. 15, 1954.
*%
(a) No.
(b), (ed, (4d) and (e) No anawer
required.
134.
(a) Ye@® in the sense that the
atomizing head supports the liquid
from which the particles are atom-
ized. :
(b) ‘An average potential gradient
on the order of 8,000 volts per inch
between the atomizer and the work.
(¢c) from about 5,000 volts to about
18000 volta per inch average po-
tential gradient.
a
66 Interrogatories
21
“Plaintiff's Interrogatories
135. Does the defendant in its No.
2 airless electrostatic system (which .
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) create an electrostatic charge
differential between the rticles
and the article of a strength to move
the particles toward the article
A
and Answers.
Answer
135.
rs bs
bond e
(a) Yes,
sufficiently rapidly to deposit them .
thereon while still in a liquid state,
and
(b) if the anawer is in.the affirma-
tive, what is that “strengtt#i” in
units of electrical measurement,
and.
‘‘ic) if there is an allowable range
of “strength,” what is it, and
6
a
(d) what is considered in units of
measurement to be satisfactory for
a sufficiently rapid movement of the.
pagticles toward the article?
136. Does the defendant in its No.
2 airless elegtrostatic system (which
it reli pon for commercial suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) use an atomizing applicator
head to form liquid into a body
having a plurality ‘ osely spaced
aligned exposed termini of rela-
tively small area, and
(b) if the answer is in the affirma-
tive, how close in terms of measure-
ment do the termini have to be
%
(b) That resniting from the mainte-
nance of an average potential gra-
dient on the ordemof 8,000 volts per
= ‘the atomizer and the
wor
(4¥ An allowable range of strength
8 such as results from maintenance *
of an average potential gradient of
from about 5,000 volts to about
10,000 volts per inch between the
atomizer and the work.
« (@) That resulting from the mainte-
nance of an average potential gra-
dient’ on the order of 8,000 volts per
~ between the atomizef and the
wor
136. - \
(a) Yes.
(b) Im most cases, leas than one-
tenth inch apart.
spaced for satisfactory coating, and °
(¢) if there is an allowable range
of closenens, what is the same, and
(d) what is cansiieaiin in such sys-
tem in terms of units .f neasure--
ment, to be a “relatively small
area’?
187. Does the defendant in its No. 2
airless electrostatic system (which
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit), °
(c) ,An allowable range is from
enth to one-hundredth of an
) The area of a terminus having
a diameter of a few thousandths of
an inch.
1387.
i)
Interrogatorivs and Answers. .
Plaintiff's interrogatories
(137. cont'd)
(a) have means for feeding liquid.
_ in a relatively narrow stream to an
upplicator head and means at the
head for spreading the stream to
fourm it into a body of liquid cugt-
ing material having an extent many
times the maximum cross-sectional
dimension of the stream, dnd
(b) if so, inecterms of measurement,
what does “many times" comprise,
and
(c) if there is a rang@, for said
“many times,” what is that range’
138. Does the defendant in its No. 2
tirless electrostatic system (which
ft! relies upon, for conimercial suc-
cess to its Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) provide for t!@ moving of an
article past and (a spaced ‘relation
fo a zone of atonization, and
(b) if the answer ie in the affirma-
tive, af what rate in terms of units
of measurement must the article be
moved to effect satisfactory coat-
ing, and
(c) what spaceomest there be pres-
ent between the article being moved
and the zone of atomization, and
(d) if there is a range of dimen-
sion ax to either of the foregoing
(b) and (c), what is that range?
\ 2
140. Does the defendant in its Ng, 2
“airless electrostatic systen? (which
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as to ita Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) distribute dispersed particles of
liquid over a rea having each of
its dimensions many times greater
than the minimum , cross-sectional
dimension of the ‘stream at the
"ie or termini of atomization,
an :
‘<i
Py
“04
Anawer
(1387. cont'd)
tur Ves
> °
#
OD er
thy About 25 or more.
(ey From aboutges to Ne
138
ia) Now but Defendatit's customers
lo.
g (bp) At a rate whieh will result) in
"the desired coating aul which de-
» pends on the rate of coating-mate-
rial zation. F
(c) Enough &pace%o prevent spark-
ing between the atomizer and the
work at the voltage maintained.
(d) Since the rate of article move-
ment depends upon the rate of coat-
ing-material atomization and since
the latter rate ix controlled by the
customer, Defendant does got know
the extremes of article 1 em;
ployed by its customers. Defendant
knowsf one speed as low as about
two and one-half feet per minute
and another of over SO) feet per
minut}. So far as Defendant knows,
the space maintained by its cus-
~ tomers between atomizer and work
varies between about @ee inches.
and about 24 inches.
6r ~ Interrogatories and Answers.
23 | :
Plaintiff's Interrogatories Answer
(140: cont'd) im (140. cont'd) .
(b) if the answer is in the affirma- (>) Usually about two to four
tive, whet ie the minimum cross ‘housandths of an inch.
somone dimension of the stream, ’
8
(c) how many times greater than ‘¢) Each dimension of the area
said milnimum dimension is the
- over which it is distributed,
a
(dad) if there is a range of either of
the foregoing dimensions of (b)
and (c), what is such range? «
142. Does the defendant in its No. 2
airless electrostatic system (which
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as ayy its Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) have a high enough voltage
gradient to establisit a corona dis-
a eee ee
to the atomising field,
(b) Sora a
liquid occur generally in the area
the corona discharge would
normally occur, and
(c) is that area generally at or in
close proximity to a sharp edge on
an applicator head? :
144. In defendant's No. 2
electrostatic system (which it re-
, lies upon for 1 success as
to its Starkey et al patents in suit),
22 a ae
a a te of atomization
and the article being coated, and
‘(b) If the angwer is in the affirma-
tive, is the alr quiescent through-
out the entire space separating the
——— point and the article,
a
(c) does the centrifugal action of
the atomizing head in the No. 2 sys-
tem cause any turbulence whatso-
ever of air bet ween the head cud
the article?
over which the dispersed particles
‘of liquid are distributed is
several hundred times the minim
crose-sectiona
1 dimension of the
stream.
(d) The r has never been de-
termined by Defenggnt
142. :
‘ad Yea.
“ye
©
(c) Yes.
144.
(a) Yes, as “quiescent” is defined
in the file wrapper of Patent No.
2,685,596 in suit.
(b), Yes.
$
Interrogatories
24
‘Plaintiff's Interrogatories
145. Does the defendant in its No. 2
airloes electrostatic system (which
it relies for commercial suc-
cess as to me Gunchey et' al patents
in suit),
(a) ‘atomine and disperse particles
toward a surface to be coated
spaced a substantial distance from
the atomizing head, and
(b) if so, what is: considered to be
a stbetantial distance in ‘terms pf
units of distance, and
it)
(c) if there.'le a range for such”
distance, what is that range?
146. Does the defendant in its No. 2
airless electrostatic system (which
it relies upon for commercial suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit),
(a) employ a plurality of aligned
ae closely spaced
ant ‘Gupereiag liguid material, and
(b) if so, how close must the points
be spaced in terme of units or dis-
tance to he sufficiently closely
spaced for effecting coating of the
article?
147. Does the defendant in its No. 2
airless electrostatic system (which
it relies u for com 1 suc-
cess as to its Starkey et al patents
in suit), c
(a) employ more than one step or
operation. for effecting atomization,
dispersion and deposition of the
coating liquid, and
(b) if so, what are the steps or
operations that are employed?
-
and An
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.