Reply Brief — Beamer v. Virginian Railway Co.

Supreme Court brief1944

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

La ERNE a GMOS NS et MOEN TAROT 7g . ip SOI ha PIR RR LORE AGENT

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

No. 530

NELLIE FAYE BEAMER, ADMINISTRATRIX

OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT P. BEAMER,

DECEASED, Petitioner

Versus

THE VIRGINIAN RAILWAY COMPANY,

A CORPORATION, Respondent

REPLY BRIEF OF RESPONDENT TO PETITION

FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI, AND TO BRIEF

FOR PETITIONER IN SUPPORT THEREOF.

LEWIS A. NUCKOLS

Room 811 Boxley Building

Roanoke, Virginia

Counsel for Respondent

HALL, NUCKOLS & HALL

Roanoke, Virginia

Of Counsel

December 30, 1943

HAMMOND’S PRINTING & LITHO. WORKS, ROANOKE, VA.

ti

we

nealab

es

ISOM DIFC M ERE

Subject Index

The Petition for Writ of Certiorari should be

denied for the following reasons: —

First: A failure to comply with Rule 12, para-

graph 1, and Rule 38 of the Rules of

ERG sricre res warsas vito een es

Second: There was no federal question of substance

raised in the State Court, which was

decided adversely to the petitioner by

ai pes sa eke es tesa ees

Third: The evidence of record in this case supports

the action of the State Court in holding

that there was no proof of negligence

on the part of the respondent........

Page

il

Alphabetical List of Cases

Page

B. & O. Ry. Co. vs. Carroll, 280 U. S. 491, —-]

Sat Ge Oe aaa ca eh onan ees 12

B. & O. Ry. Co. vs. Groeger, 266 U. S. 521,

fo | Res Mara ee rr eee te 13

C. & O. Ry. Co. vs. Butler, 163 Va. 626,

oe 2 ey Peer rrr ere rk Le 11, 13

39 C. J. Sec. 965 (f). P. 766, notes 46, eS ccs 11

Crosswhite vs. Southern Ry. Company.

Se | eee er eee eo 13

Davis vs. C. & O. Ry. Co., 179 S. W. 422.......-. 11

Galloway vs. U. S., 87 L. Ed. DE ue aL tiena 4

Grammer vs. Mid Cont. Pet. Co.,

iQ. ye See eo 11

Grosscup vs. C. & N. W. Ry. Co.

14 Fed. Sup. 276. ....... 2-0. ssc cecseeesees 11

Lang vs. U. S. Reduction Co. 110 Fed. (2d) 441... 11

Lloyd vs. N. & W. Ry. Co., 151 Va. 409,

Ee ae. ee eee 11

L. & N. Ry. Co. vs. McCoy, 110 S. W. (2d) 433.. 11

L. etc. Ry. Co. vs. Sawyer, 169 Ky. 671, 675,

a ae ) > Sen ere re eae 11

L. & N. Ry. Co. vs. Williams, 165 Ky. 386,

me Se. Ye: eee 11

Rules of U. S. Supreme Court (Rules 12 and 38).. 2,4

Southern Ry. Co. vs. Bell, 114 Fed. (2d) 341, 343. 12

Southern Ry. Co. vs. Chadwick, 144 Va. 443, 452. 13

DETROIT IF, SI IE ab i Sha Natal RMI ae NE! RET AN et aa

ik Se

ili

Alphabetical List of Cases —Continued

Page

Southern Ry. Co. vs. Lewis, 113 Va. 117......... 13

Southern Ry. Co. vs. Verelle, 57 Fed. (2d) 1008... 13

Sumney vs. Southern Ry. Co. 89 Fed. (2d) 437... 13

Swieg vs. C. M. & St. P. Ry. Company,

MR Is es pin oe Sado Gok wks 11

Tiller vs. Atl. Coast Line Ry. Company

a ESTE EG ae ao 2

Toledo, etc. Co. vs. Allen, 276 U.S. 165,

Pee as es Ga oad Suk w vin aw ae aw v8 13

Wyatt vs. C. & P. Tel. Co. 158 Va. 472,

fF 4 Se ee ere ere 12

-

RUA SD Nit SEATON ART ORL TNE: RARER IP OLED PRIMM

PAN STAG MRD iA SESSILIS ASA OO AER RA OCW TAO PAI ID TIRE ASE EOE

ITE a ABIX ah GE SP ANY

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

No. 530

NELLIE FAYE BEAMER, ADMINISTRATRIX

OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT P. BEAMER,

DECEASED, Petitioner

Versus

THE VIRGINIAN RAILWAY COMPANY,

A CORPORATION, Respondent

REPLY BRIEF OF RESPONDENT TO PETITION

FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI, AND TO BRIEF

FOR PETITIONER IN SUPPORT THEREOF.

To the Honorable, The Chief Justice And Associate Justices

Of The Supreme Court Of The United States: —

May it please the Court:

We submit that the petition for a writ of certiorari

herein should be denied, for the following good and

sufficient reasons:

FIRST: This is a petition for a writ of certiorari

seeking a review of a state court judgment, and neither

that petition nor the brief in support of it, specifies the

stage in the proceedings in the court of first instance and

in the appellate court, at which, or the manner in which,

the federal questions sought to be reviewed were raised;

2

the method of raising them; or the way in which they were

passed upon by the court; or pertinent quotations of

specific portions of the record, or summary thereof, with

specific reference to the places in the record where the

matter appears, as will support the assertion that the

rulings of the court were of a nature to bring the case

within the statutory provision believed to confer juris-

diction on this court. (Rule 12, paragraph 1, and Rule

38 of this Court.)

We believe that the omissions above referred to

are easily accounted for by the fact that no federal

question was raised by the petitioner in either the court

of first instance or in the state supreme court which was

decided adversely to her. As will appear from the

record, no sort of federal question was raised by the

petitioner and decided against her in the court of first

instance. The case was tried in that court on the theory

that the 1939 Amendment of the Federal Employees

Liability Act did not apply to this case. This is evi-

denced by Instruction No. 3, found at page 172 of this

record, which was given by that court without any objec-

tion or exception by the petitioner. So there was no

federal question raised and decided adversely to her in

that court.

After this case was completed in that court and

pending its appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeals of

Virginia, the case of Tiller vs. Atlantic Coast Line Ry.

Co. 87 L. Ed. Adv. Opin. No. 18, page 1221 was decided

by this court.

The claim that assumption of risk was not available

as a defense in this case under the 1939 Amendment to

the Federal Employees Liability Act was :nade for the

first time by the petitioner in her “Memorandum of

Authorities” in support of her petition for writ of error

to the state supreme court (R. p. 13, at p. 16)

The state supreme court might well have ignored

that claim, then and in that way raised for the first time,

on the ground that such question had not been raised and

passed upon by the court of first instance and that it had

not been specifically set out in the petitioner's Assign-

ment of Errors to that court (R. page 8). Instead of

doing that, however, that court, in view of the opinion

of this court in the case of Tiller vs. Atlantic Coast Line

Railway Co., supra, fully considered the question raised

by the claim made by the petitioner in her ‘‘Memorandum

of Authorities’’ and, in accordance with the opinion in

the Tiller Case, held that the said 1939 Amendment had

abolished the defense of assumption of risk in this case.

The petitioner's claim in this respect was not decided

adversely to her by the state supreme court. (Opinion

of the state supreme court. R. page 177, at page 180

et seq.)

That Court, however, held that although assumption

of risk was not available as a defense in this case under

the 1939 Amendment, still the petitioner must prove, by

a preponderance of the evidence, that this respondent

had been guilty of some negligence which resulted in

injury to the deceased. It quoted from the Tiller Case

(R. page 181) and said:

“There is nothing new in the test in the

Tiller Case to determine when a case should go to

the jury or when it should be withheld. For

many decades this court has been announcing

that disputed questions of fact are for the jury.”

That court then proceeds with a fully considered

review of the evidence and reaches the conclusion that

ELIS RPM DOS AAPA IIT Hit AE RE A EE -_ —

he SPB AN BANG Cb RAS IEA TIE PIRATES) AS AIPA: AONE LE LATTER

4

this respondent's defense of non-negligence has been

sustained in that the evidence did not show any negligence

on its part. This was the only question which was

decided adversely to petitioner by that court. No

question as to the state supreme court's right to pass on

that question was raised, or could have been raised, by

the petitioner. Nor do we understand that such a

question is a federal question, or puts in issue any federal

right. The right of courts to pass upon the sufficiency

of the evidence, and to direct verdicts was upheld by this

court in the recent case of Galloway vs. United States,

87 L. Ed. Adv. Opin. No. 16, page 1042.

SECOND: The only federal question of substance

decided by the state court, viz.: that the 1939 Amend-

ment to the Federal Employees Liability Act was appli-

cable to this case, was decided in accordance with the

opinion of this court in the Tiller Case. We submit

that no one other than the parties to this case has any

interest in its final outcome. That the ‘public is not

interested in the only question involved in it, and that no

principle, or proposition of law, the decision of which

will have any bearing upon any other case, is involved,

(Rule 38, paragraph 5 of this court's rules.)

THIRD: The evidence of record in this case sup-

ports the action of the state supreme court in holding

that there was no proof of negligence on the part of this

respondent.

This proposition, of course, necessarily involves a

consideration by this court of all of the evidence in this

record.

5

Statement of Facts and Argument Upon Them.

We submit that such a consideration of the evidence

will show the following as to the facts of this case: —

(a) In order to provide for the electrification of

its line from Roanoke, Virginia, to Mullens, West Virginia,

the defendent employed the firm of Gibbs and Hill of

New York City to design, construct and supervise the

construction of its electrical system, including the power

plant at Narrows, Virginia. The standing of Gibbs and

Hill in the profession as electrical engineers was very

high, they having designed and constructed the most im-

portant high-tension electrification systems in the

eastern part of the United States, including the electri-

fication of the Pennsylvania Railroad from New York to

Washington, the New York, New Haven and Hartford

Railroad and the electrification of a portion of the Norfolk

& Western Railway system and other important elec-

trical projects for high-tension electrified systeius of.

railroads. (R. pp. 117, 118, 145, 160.)

The plant at Narrows, Virginia, was completed and

turned over to the defendant November 15, 1925. This

plant is in a large building about 80 feet by 150 feet and

consists of two stories, a basement room some 30 to 35

feet high, and a turbine floor room which is about 45

feet high. The basement room is below ground level

| and only a few feet of it is located above ground level.

Just how much is above ground level is not shown. In

it are located a number of pumps and other machinery.

Its outside walls are of solid concrete and there is a brick

partition between the basement room and the turbine

floor room and the boiler room for the entire length of

the building, cutting these rooms entirely off from the

boiler room in which are located the furnaces and steam

RR NE EET 6 ST ae

Se MRE IAS IIE ABR ER ES RO I

6

boilers for the operation of the plant. In the turbine

room there are located four large turbines which are used

-in the generation of electric power. The .basement room

contains the most of the piping necessary to conduct the

steam from the boiler room to the steam turbine gener-

ators, all of which piping is covered with asbestos in

order to prevent the escape of heat in the pipes leading

to the turbines. This steam piping is against or near the

ceiling of the basement room. The turbines stand on

the floor of this turbine room and there are openings in

the floor under each turbine through which the pipes

supplying steam to the turbines extend up into the

turbines. Between the four turbines there are two large

openings extending from the basement floor to the top of

. the building. These openings are between turbines 1 and

2 and between turbines 3 and 4, and are each about 30

feet long by 18 or 20 feet wide.

Robert P. Beamer, the deceased, was employed by

Gibbs and Hill as a pipe or steam fitter in the construction

of the plant and in the installation of all piping in the

building, including that which serves the turbines. Be-

cause of his familiarity with the piping and the work to be

done in connection therewith the defendant, when it

took over the plant from Gibbs and Hill, in November,

1925, employed Beamer as a pipe fitter. He was more

familiar with the pipe layout than anyone about the plant,

(R. page 149 and 118). He continued in defendant's

employ as a pipe fitter from November, 1925, to the date

of his death on July 26, 1940.

On account of the nature of the plant and the purpose

for which it is operated, there are places in which the men

employed have to work from time to time which are above

normal temperature and at times are very hot. (R. p.

119). In order to make such places as comfortable as

~ Merc hen We Md a aan Tinh GR CNR, iio aR aoe SS -=

7

possible for men who have to work therein, the defendant

supplies a compressed air hose with attachments at

convenient locations, so that the men, by the use of such

hose, can bring about a circulation of air and thus reduce

the temperature of such places. This was well known to

the deceased, as well as to all other employees at the plant,

and on various occasions Beamer had used the hose for

this purpose. (R. pp. 119, 149). There also prevailed a

custom at the plant which permits the men who have to

do work in these hot places, to come out of such places

to cool off, and under this custom the man who is doing

the work is permitted to be the judge as to when he will

come out for the purpose of cooling off. The matter of

how often he will come out and how long he will stay out

is left entirely to the discretion of the employees at the

plant. (R. pp. 119, 121, 56, 59)

’ Beamer had entire charge of repairs and replacements

to the steam pipes and he had one helper, Wimmer, who

was employed as his helper for a period of about thirteen

years. (R. pp, 55, 56, 118). The Superintendent of the

plant would sometimes tell Beamer where a leak had

: developed or that a change should be made, and he would

go ahead and make the necessary repairs or changes.

When the repairs or changes were not familiar or were

out of the ordinary routine, Beamer and the superinten-

dent would talk the matter over and Beamer would then

do the work. (R. pp. 118, 119). On the morning of

Beamer's death the vacuum under turbine No. 1 was

slightly low, that is, its efficiency was reduced, and the

machine was shut down about seven-thirty, a. m., and

not again put in operation that day. (R. p. 122).

Bowser, the superintendent, told Beamer to correct this

defect and he and his helper started to work on the

turbine about noon of that day. They found that there

was a break in a large expansion joint in the steam line,

8

which joint was located below the turbine floor and just

below the ceiling of the basement room. Beamer got a

new joint for the turbine from the store room and he and

his helper proceeded to replace the broken joint with the

new joint. (R. P. 120). In order to get at the place

where the work was to be done, they removed a plate 28

inches by 50 inches from the side of the turbine and

above the turbine floor and the helper, Wimmer, went

down to the place of work through that opening. Beamer

went down on an elevator from the turbine room to the

basement floor and then climbed a stairway from the

basement floor about 30 feet up to a landing near the

place where the work was to be done. While doing the

work they stood on a temporary platform across steam

pipes. (R. pp. 44, 45). It took them about 21% hours

to complete the job. While doing the work they did not

use the compressed air hose, although it was convenient

for use had they desired to use it. (R. pp. 48, 49, 55, 56).

They did come out from the place at least twice for the

purpose of cooling off. (R. p. 45). After they finished

the work, Wimmer came out through the opening in the

side of the turbine and Beamer handed him the tools with

which they had been working. Then Beamer went down

the stairway to the basement floor and came up the

elevator to the turbine room. Then he walked through

that room some 140 to 150 feet and sat down on an out-

side platform at the far end of that room for a short time.

He then walked into the machine shop on the same floor,

a distance of about 80 feet, and died suddenly while he

was standing in that shop. The work that Beamer and

his helper did on that day was nothing new or out of the

ordinary, (R. page 52). During the 15 years that he

worked as pipe fitter at the plant, the job of changing

joints under some of the four turbines, all of which were

of the same construction, would occur about once every

ees PA RS

9

three to six months. Very few days went by that Beamer

did not have to get under the turbines to do some work,

(R. page 121). A short time before the day Beamer

died, he and his helper had brazed or repaired a crack in

the same expansion joint which they replaced that day,

(R. pp. 54, 59-60). An hour to a hour and a half after

the death of Beamer the temperature of the place they

were working was taken and found to be 132° F. Prior

to the taking of the temperature no one about the plant

knew what it was. As to the foregoing facts, there can

be no controversy or dispute.

(b) The claim is made by the respondent that the

deceased, Beamer, was required by the plant superinten-

dent to finish the installation of the new expansion joint

in the pipe by four o'clock in the afternoon of the day he

was making the installation. In making this claim

petitioner relies solely upon the statement of the witness,

Wimmer. That witness stated that Beamer said he

“wanted” to finish that work on that shift (i. e. by 4:00

p.m.) (R. p. 45); and, on R. p. 56, that Beamer said he

had to finish by that hour. No witness testified that the

superintendent instructed him to complete the work by

4:00 p.m. On the contrary, the superintendent testified

that he gave Beamer no orders to that effect, that there

was no necessity for finishing that work that day; and

that the only reference to 4:00 was made by Beamer

when he said that if the joint was repaired instead of

being replaced the job could not be finished by 4:00 p.m.

(R. pp. 121, 122)

(c) The accumulation of dust under the turbine

being repaired and the time required to remove this dust

so that the air hose could be used in doing the work in

which Beamer and Wimmer were engaged are sought to

be established for the purpose of excusing Beamer from

10

using the air hose for the purpose of cooling off the place

in which the work was being done. The whole of the

testimony of Wimmer, on whose statements these facts

are sought to be established, shows that there is no merit

in these contentions. The testimony of the superinten-

dent, Bowser, if read as a whole, shows also that these

contentions are without merit, and that it was left

entirely to the discretion of Beamer to take the neces-

sary precautions to make the place safe for the work to be

done therein. On page 126 of the Record, Bowser, refer-

ring to the matter of cleaning the dust from the piping by

blowing with the air hose, stated: — ‘‘Q. Who does that

blowing? A. Usually the pipe fitters would do that.”’

The only pipe fitters at the plant were Beamer and

his helper, Wimmer. These pipes were located next to

the ceiling of the basement room which was approximately

35 feet in height, and the only employees at the plant

who had any work to do on those pipes or any occasion to

be about them were Beamer and Wimmer. If it was

necessary to remove the dust from them it was the duty

and responsibility of Beamer alone to do that. This

even though it might have required an hour or more to

remove the dust. He had plenty of time to doit. There

was no reason that the repairs to the piping had to be

finished by 4:00 p. m. that day (R. pp. 120, 121). There

were four turbines in the plant and three would take care

of the load (R. pp. 121, 122). The mere fact that there

may have been dust on the pipes affords no excuse for

Beamer’s failure to use the air hose to improve the con-

dition of the air in the place where he worked. It was

also his duty to take other precautions for his own safety,

in that it was left entirely to his discretion as to how often

he would come out of the place in which he was working

for the purpose of cooling off and how long he would stay

out for that purpose. Under these circumstances he

11

cannot recover on the alleged ground that the place of

work was in an unsafe condition for the work to be done.

L. & N. Ry. Co. vs Williams (Ky.) L. R. A. 1915 E. 613,

165 Ky. 386; 39 C. J. Section 965 (f) p. 766, ibid note 46,

46 (a); L. & N. Ry. Co. vs McCoy (Ky.) 110 S. W. (2d)

433; Davis vs C. & O. Ry. Co. (Ky.) 179 S. W. 422: Gross-

cup vs C. & N. W. Ry. Co., 14 Fed. Supp. 276; Gram-

mer vs Mid Continent Petroleum Co. (C. C. A. 10th.)

71 Fed. (2d) 38; C. & O. Ry. Co. vs Butler, 177 S. E. 195,

163 Va. 626.

(d) Also the principle that an employee is neces-

sarily the best judge of his own strength and power of

endurance, and if injury to him results from his failure to

correctly judge his own strength and power of endurance

the employer cannot be held liable on the theory that

there was negligence on its part, seems well established.

L. etc. Ry. Co. vs Sawyer, 169 Ky. 671, 675, 184 S. W.

1123; Lloyd vs N. & W. Ry. Co., 151 Va. 409, 145 S. E.

372, 376; Lang vs N. S. Reduction Co. (C. C. A. 7th.)

110 Fed. (2d) 441; Swieg vs C. M. & St. P. Ry. Co. 216

Fed. 750, 753. Under these authorities it seems clear

that if Beamer was adversely affected by the heat it was

because he overtaxed his powers of endurance, and the

respondent cannot be held liable on the theory that

negligence on its part has been established which, under

the law, entitles the petitioner to recover.

This principle of law is especially applicable to this

case in view of the fact that, during the entire 15 years

that the plant had been in operation under the same

condition it was in the day of Beamer’s death, and during

which time work similar to that which Beamer was

doing on the day of his death was prformed by him every

three to six months, no employee at the plant had ever

12

been injuriously affected by the heat. (R. pp. 58, 122,

148).

The respondent was not required under the law to

foresee and guard against casualties which were not

reasonably to be expected to occur, and which could not

have been reasonably anticipated in the exercises of

ordinary care. Wyatt vs C. & P. Tel. Co. 158 Va. 472,

82 A. L. R. 396; Southern Ry. Co. vs Bell, (C. C. A. 4th.)

114 Fed. (2d) 341, 343; B. & O. Ry. Co. vs Carroll, 280

U.S. 491, 74 L. Ed. 566.

(e) The respondent’s plant was properly designed,

equipped and operated. The undisputed evidence given

by men who had wide and varied experience in the con-

struction and operation of and acquaintance with, such

plants, shows that to be a fact, and especially with

relation to that part of this plant at which Beamer worked

on the day of hisdeath. (R. pp. 129, 136, 147, 160, 161).

The petitioner bases her claim of defective construction

of the plant in that there were no windows in the base-

ment room and no mechanical ventilation system was

instal'-d in the plant. The evidence shows that it would

have been impracticable and unsafe to have put windows

in the walls of that room. Practically that entire room

is below ground level. The plant stands on the bank of

New River and any windows which might have been put

in the walls of the basement room would have subjected

the basement to the grave danger of flooding the entire

basement in the times of flood waters in the River. Such

windows would be below flood level (R. pp. 131, 148,

154). If such windows had been put in the basement

walls, or if a mechanical ventilation had been installed,

and if the effect thereof had been to reduce the tempera-

ture around the turbines where Beamer worked, that

would have reduced the efficiency of the operation of the

— (CO = CP FE KK YO

cot +

ee ee a

13

turbines. (R. pp. 133, 147, 152, 154). This evidence is

not disputed.

Of the large number of such plants with which the

witness Reich was familiar, no one of them had windows

in its basement (R. p. 164); nor was there any arrange-

ment for mechanical ventilation or otherwise in that part

of the equipment under the turbines where Beamer

worked. (R. 161).

The customary practices and usages as to plant

equipment, machinery and methods of operation are

determinative of the question of negligence as applied

to any particular line of business, especially where there

is no evidence to the effect that different practices and

usages prevail in any similar line of business that are

shown by the evidence to be safer or more suitable. The

undisputed evidence is that no different practices and

usages have been adopted in the construction and opera-

tion of power plants similar to that of respondent,

Southern Ry. Co. vs Lewis, 113 Va. 117; Southern Ry.

Co. vs. Chadwick, 144 Va. 443, 452: C. & O. Ry. Co. vs

Butler, 163 Va. 626, 177 S. E. 195. F urthermore the

standards in respect to the engineering, architectural,

mechanical and other scientific questions as to plant

methods of operation are not to be left to the uncertain

and varying judgments of juries. Toledo etc. Co. vs

Allen, 276 U. S. 165, 72 L. Ed. 513, 516; Southern Ry.

Co. vs Verelle (C. C. A. 4th.) 57 Fed. (2d) 1008; Sumney

vs Southern Ry. Co. (C. C. A. 4th.) 89 Fed. (2d) 437;

B. & O. Ry. Co. vs Groeger, 266 U. S. 521, 69 L. Ed. 419;

Crosswhite vs Southern Ry. Co., 181 Va. 40, 46.

If juries were allowed to establish standards with

respect to such questions, for instance as to whether a

plant of the nature of the large and complicated power

ERMC A TOP

—

14

plant of the respondent was properly constructed and

operated, an intolerable situation would be presented.

In such cases the standards in such matters would vary

according to the peculiar temperaments and views of

juries trying each case, and there would be no fixed rule

applicable to all cases that might be submitted to the de-

termination of juries.

SUMMARY

In this case we have a man (Mr. Beamer) who had

taken part as a pipe fitter in the installation of the piping

system ir. this large power plant when it was constructed.

Wher the plant was completed and turned over to the

respondent in 1925, the respondent employed him to

work for it in the same capacity as pipe fitter, especially

because of his familiarity with the piping system in this

plant, and with the work to be done in connection there-

with. He was placed in charge of the pipes and the work

to be done in connection therewith, and he and his helper

did all of the work that was done in connection with those

pipes. This continued for a period of fifteen years, and

during that period, every three to six months he and his

helper performed the same sort of work under the same

conditions that they did on the afternoon of the day of his

death. He was allowed to be his own judge as to when

and how often he would go out of his place of work for

the purpose of cooling off, and as to how long he would

stay out for that purpose, and as to whether he would use

the air hose for improving conditions in his working places.

This without any interference by the superintendent.

During all of that period neither he, nor his helper who

worked right along with him, nor any other person had

been injuriously affected by the heat.

PMO S ECA SF AM ERA ATS

15

We respectfully submit that, under the circumstances

of this case, the petition for a writ of certiorari should be

denied.

LEWIS A. NUCKOLS

811 Boxley Building,

Roanoke, Virginia.

Counsel for Respondent.

Hall, Nuckols & Hall

Roanoke, Virginia.

Of Counsel.

A EERINS Pt SS ea ry ly

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Reply Brief — Beamer v. Virginian Railway Co. · 321 U.S. 763 | Frix