Appendix — Aetna Insurance v. Jeffcott

Supreme Court brief1942

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

35

Appendix I.

Partial List of Decisions and Text-Books in Which

Phillips on Insurance Has Been Cited.

In this Court: Insurance Company v. Transportation

Company, 79 U.S. 194, 196-7 ; Hooper v. Robinson, 98 U.S.

528, 536-7; London Assurance vy. ( ‘ompanhia De

Do Barreiro, 167 U. S. 149, 174-5; “We

selves in this respect by quoting the conclusion expressed

in 2 Phillips on Insurance,” Canada Sugar Refining Co.

v. Insurance Co. of North America, 175 U.S. 609, 618, 619,

(24-5; Hagan v. Scottish Ins. € 0, 186 U.S. 423, 430.

Moagens

shall content our-

In the House of Lords: “In Phillips on Insurance * * *

that very experienced author,” Aitchison v. Lohre, 4 App.

Cas. 750, 763-4; P. Samuel & Co. Limited v. Dumas (1924),

A. C. 431, 445; “That admirable writer on insurance law,

Phillips,” (Norwich Union Fire Insurance Society v. Wm.

H. Price, Ltd. (1934), A. C. 455, 466.

In the Court of Common Pleas: Dickenson vy. Jardine,

L. R. Common Pleas Cases, Vol. III, pages 639, 642; “Mr.

Willard Phillips’ highly valuable work

Denoon v. The Home and Colonial Assurance Company,

L, R. Common Pleas Cases, Vol. VII, pages 341, 347-8; “a

hook of the highest authority as to English as well as

American insurance law,” Harris y. Scaramanga, L. R.

Common Pleas Cases, Vol. VII, pages 481, 496; Daniels v.

Harris, L. R. Common Pleas Cases, Vol. X, pages 1, 6, 7.

on Insurance,”

Richards on the Law of Insurance, §417 (4th Edit.

1932), says:

“ * * it is worthy of mention that the English

Judges, as well as the American, often cite with

approval a text book on this subject [Phillips on

Insurance] written many years ago by a New Eneland

gentleman, which ranks in merit with the standard

work of old England by Mr. Arnouid.”

36

Arnould on Marine Insurance and Average, the leading

English text-book on marine insurance, cites Phillips con-

stantly as authority on American law. It is interesting

to note that in a footnote to Section 1117, which is cited

by the Cireuit Court of Appeals in the present case,

Arnould states that

“the 50% rule applies also in the United States jn

the case of damaged goods: see Phillips, s. 1608;

Washburn Manufacturing Co. v. Reliance Marine In-

surance Co. [1900], 179 U. S. 1.”

Accordingly, we have the rather curious situation that the

Cireuit Court of Appeals cites, as an authority on Amer.

ican law, an English text-book which, in turn, cites as

its authority the work of Phillips, whose authority the

Circuit Court of Appeals had declined to recognize,

37

Appendix II.

For

Mr. A. Gracie

Case & Opinion.

I have carefully considered the case of the Ship

Dauphin. It is a case not without difficulty from some

particular circumstances. But the result of my best reflee-

tions is this—(viz.)

The expences and the salvage decreed amount to not

a great deal less than half the whole ralue. I do not

think it can be said that it was the duty of the assured

to advance so large an additional sum of capital to

enable the vessel to prosecute her voyage (admitting that

ler condition at the time presented no serious obstacle

to its prosecution). If not the sale for payment of the

salvage Was a necessary consequence; which includes the

loss of the voyage as she did not reach her destination—

aid as I think would form a case proper for abandon-

ment and recovery as for a total loss. The cargo being

nearly absorbed in payment of salvage expenses,

If then the assured, when advise was received of the

capture, recapture and amount of the salvage, abandoned

or did what was equivalent to it, he ought to be satisfied

as for a total loss.

If he did not then abandon or do what was equivalent

he ought to be considered as having elected to take the

chance of the market at the place of sale—& this would

change the total into a partial loss—consisting of the

amount of the salvage and expenses of law proceedings,

repairs if any & other extra expenses,

A. HAMILTON,

Sep. 1, 1800.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.