Petition for A Writ of Certiorari — Selby v. United States

Supreme Court brief1959

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

a

CBO

ine oe

Win! 4

; 2

[ :

a

| Supreme Court. of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1958 .

No, 92

~

HUBERT N. SELBY, Jn.

Pitttioner,

¢ : , .

i : von aqaiust . 5

UD (TED STATES + Me AMERICAN,

Ltespond we.

\

PETITION FOR WRIT OF: CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT.OF APPEALS FOR THE

one ~ SECOND CIRCUIT

ee |

————

Kupiin & .Lyise,

Jacop Rass SER,

huomMas i FRAWLEY,

of Course l,

Proctors for Petitione Pa

=

yeme2 Court, US.

pe

#?

oa

INDEX ‘TO BRIEF ¢

a 2 ie ie

: .-

Opinions Below Pee er rere ee Shae ee See ewe ww

Jurisdiction ...... Ee Peers ee edt

. . ‘ : r - —-

° ra : J _ sot? ;

Question ee ae Sere re rT ee

ig Serr? 2 5 .

Reasons for Grating the Writ a bie ad verre i

Statement of Tht COME oes of ssa see weds Peery er.

ees ep CEE rey Sere, “Perec ee ony

; vA >.

. Argument’ .s....... YF REALE ES eee i» WS

‘s - 4 ff es

ca Ap "PENDIX : eae 7

is Opinion of U sh States Court of Appe ‘als for thie

Second Cirguit ........-. je sebesagbecenennds paws

aor se ae ures ce cde ens aes ‘eis

ee Table of — Cited -

Bd v. Blue Ridve Rural Electric Co- rape rative, 306

th B26, 76M, Ot. WE 50 eee seasaensiein

Pa Kelley v. Everglades Drainage District, 319 .,

y ES OCA ore aS ey cere

/ + ‘Kweskin v. Finkelstein, 7 CC. A oe Ped 2a Gs...

Major a Co. v. Gibson Refrigerator Sales

tee, & CO: A, Ss Pe, Sd... eutue

% re Lat Highlands Canning © Tompany, 309

310, GOS. Ct. 517. Seeere Pega teh ct ¥

r. S. v.-¢ ‘ausby, 328 U.S. 256, 268, 66S. (tt. 1062

- ?

Statute Cited baa. ies

WO 0 WS a ees

_- “

< * . y way 7 . >

Conelusion ........ an A CAPE LEN ar ee Po ra tea ee

i P

? .

7

‘Supreme Court of ie Huited States.

| - OCTOBER TERM, _-

see No.

t)

Vv

ae .

~Husert N. Sezsy, Jr.,

fap ai Petitioner,

@ ‘against

Unrred States oF AMERICA, es

; : Respondent.

_ a

aN”

Vv

¢

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF. APPEALS F OR THE

3 SECOND CIRCUIT sgh bo ala

4

"The petitioner prays that a per of certiorari issue to

review the judgment of the United States Court of Appeals

for the Second Cirenit entered in the above cause on March

6, 1959. . Sagebe

_ Opinions Below

The opinion of the U nited State 's District Court for the

Eastern District of New” York, dated May 9,°1958, is’ re-

ported at 161 Fed. Supp. 689.

“The opinion of the Court of. Appeals in this case _.

; i Appendis, ae 11- 14) is not reported as yet.

2 4

Jurisdiction

The judgment: of the Court of Appe als Was entered

on March 6, 1959.° The Jurisdiction of. this Court is invoked

under hates aa C, 1254 (1). |

eo.

ony CRM eee | ig

ce y: oN ‘ «

. Question Presented .

Ix the exereise of the power of supervision by ‘the

Supreme Court of the U nited States mnder Rule 19 of, thas:

‘Court: required) in the furtherance of justice to declare

“mandatory the provisions of Admiralty, Rule 4613, Avhege

‘a Trial Court anda ¢ Sreyif Court of \ppedls he ive refused

to ‘make any: findings of taet or conclusions of law in a

seaman’s ; personal i injury action; partic arly where ne ‘ither

4 ‘ourt has passed nyoN the most material and baste fSsues

involved?> 4” .

Reasons te Grasiting the Writ

‘ /

1. The Thial.Gourt has refused to, comply with* Ruly

4615 of the Admiralty Rules. Brame

- 2..The United Siates ¢ ‘vurt of Appeals Yor the Second

Cireuit likewise has totally, disregarded “thie provisions of

Rule.46t.. The Trial -Court’s decision Was affirmed by the

Court be ca on the opinion of the Trial Court; disregard-

ing the f ‘act that:the TMal. Court had’ failed to comply, with .

the applic able law.

2 3: Wien a. Trial Court tails to make a decision in

accordance. with the Rules of Ndmiralty, the decision by a

~Cirenjt Court of Appei als sustaining kuch a finding is such

a radical departure from the established practice as‘ fo

require the’ intervention of the. United Stites Supreme

Court to correctssuch abmise. ad ;

P eras eineniaais of-the Case

History *

Petitioner was a vouth, 17 years of sige, whose lungs

were coynpletely destroved by conditions prevalent aboard

responde nt’s ve sel, the S.S.** Rocke axp Vierory’’, which

was the dire ef ands peoximite! cause of his injuries, as,estal

lished hy: the: uncontradicted te stimony at the trial,

.

- Petitioner: nstitufed this admiralty action for personal

injuries in! the United States District’@onrt: for the Eastern

District of New York to recover damiayes for a tubercular

conditidn alleged to have resulted. from the negligence. of

respondent and, or failure to furnish pe titione r With a-sea-

worthy Nessel. P : :

| « 2

The 1 respondent denied AL allegations of neglige nee,

unseaworthiness, proximate causafion and a: imagtis,

'

« The cause ‘proceeded ‘to trial and resulted in the libel

being dismissed. Petitioner took an appea) from the ‘judg-

ment te the Unitéd States € ourt of 2 5 for the Second

Circuit and the. judgment was affirmed. is

ca

Recovery was sought at the trial. hecanse of the -negli-

- gence ‘of the respondent and ‘or for failure-to furnish the

rs libelant with a. seaworthy vessel on two grounds: ;

E because the respondent failed. to furnish: pe titloner

with-a safe place to work axl because the ship was

unseaworthy as, operated and uigtatained by teepead-

ent; and, : ' - pa

2. because respohdént negligently aces Ripted: for trans.

portation and carried : a slripload of sick and dying

- horses and compellee: petitioner’-to dive in close

.. proximity. to such stek and ‘dying. horses and’ their:

excreta and because respondent fubtiished: pe titioner.

with an unseaw: ‘orthy _—— ae

in his beeom-

ing tubercular. . |

. ~ a

The Trial C ourt defermincd the { first ‘od of negli-

gence and unseaw orthiness | in favor of respondent but failed?

to make any finding’or dete rinination of any ema ax to the

second ground. ‘

ines . j

A man has bec en, ‘dented the opportunity to have his

claim for personal injuries heard and determined bya

Court of Admiralty and the United States Court of Appeals

| :

\ ‘

’

Pc} : s ee idee.

forthe Se cond Circuit by .the arbitrary failure of seach

court To pass upon ‘the material issues litigated at the °

etrial. — . es cae

. awd (a). The Trial ( ‘ourt fi nailed to pass upon a claim:

wee & Hnseaworthiness | predice ated upon

~Athe st fact that sick auch dying horses were ageepted

. for transportation ant carried “on .a vessel uirder

conditions which required the petitioner ‘to be.in

continous close proximity to euch sick? dying and

dead-Horses and their excreta, resulting mm his sub-

.

neque nt taibe srewlosis.

qv ) The lower Court failed to pass upon

a?) such elaim of ne elit ence oF savcawoitr

Ra ee predicate “«. upon, such acee prapc e and trans: «

: portation of such sick and dying. horses ; and

(2) thie alaim of petitioned that sueh respond:

“en's negligent acts or Sue h unseaworthy condi-

tion. of such vessel Was a competent procter

auuse of his tuberculosis.

The T al Cott and the ited States Court of Appe: als .

for the Second Cireuit not haying’ determined the most

material and lasic issties as required by Rule 461, of the

a sotdisinalty ‘Rules. Abe ——— must be reversed.” ‘i

' tn all trials im scdinitts dey the testimony ‘oi witnesses shall he

as otherwise provided by statute,

| necessary by the court wot the

taken’ orally mm open court, except |

cr aghen phe at ypuat ties. When, deemes

aficer taking the testimony. or by the mae. ¢ stenographer may

vl who shall tuke down the testimony in shorthand ¢

he eqfurt orgeither party, ae =

= a taxed as costs.

l - Co-operative, 330 1, §. SB,

Gf ste ts B.S. Cantsby, aps ©. 5 256, 208, 66.5. Ct. 1062 ; *

Kelle, © Brerclades Drandec strict, 10 U. 3-415, 420, 42? 63

Ss. Gr a4; Mayo ¥ Lakeland ‘uhlands Canning Co yipany,: 30?

© 6510. S17 AOS. A al? “mceskin Vv. Finkelstem, 7a. 0 ae

3 fred, 2d 6774 Vaior Trppliaike Gay. Gibson Nefrigerator Sales

Corp, 8. 6. A. BH, Ped 2

be, cmaploye

-oeherwise and, if reque sted dv

‘the ‘Same. Phe ate may be is

int v die Rr !

e?

\

Such findings are obviously ‘ne¢essary fo. the

intelligent and orderly presentation and proper dis-

position of an appeal.”

Mayo v. ag ge Highiants: eye 4 ompant,

309 U. . 310, oni, ae S, C4 ANT, 320.

The petitione r, age 17, signed on as an oiler on the

SS. Rockranp Vacrory in January, 146, New York City

for a voyage to Houston, Texas, and then to Europe for the

carriage of a cargo of horses,

7 Before signing on, he was given a physical examination

by a Dr. Dugdale in behalf of respondent and was the Te.

after accepted as a member of the crew. +

hie log under date of Mareh’ 14th shows:

© Total number of dead horses, 132. Mortality

, . a fale 16% a cent’? CR, oat) ‘ Pi

Of these 792 a the, log proves that only $1: 3 were

ee ee iW}. peaches

The log prov es that on February 1th one "dea horse

* was remoyed from to lower “twee ndeck and another one.

from *tweendecek. . Ps

‘Horses died of pneumonia’? (RR. 272).

®:° , i /

a ee EE _— a — — =

The entries continue: - - :

. pees? 20, **four horses dead, died of pneumonia’

(R. 273). eas vers

‘Pebreary 21, ‘five horses dead, dic dof pneumonia’

(Rh. a ;

F ebrit ary 22 2 (still at Houston) $6 ‘leve 1m horses dead,

died of pneumonia’? (R. 272- 5) ae

’ February. 25 (still at Nouston), “*six horses dead,

died of pneumonia’? (R. 273). i ea et eee

>>

-Februaty 23, ‘tswabbed down decks?’ (R. 274).

6 ‘

February 24th log discloses that Anderson live stock

attendant beeame ill with chills, slight pains in

various parts .of body and that radiogram Was-

cent seeking medieal’ advice as to his’ iIness (R.

»

Jit) alao—'* removing -dead horses’? (R. 276).

-Bebruary 26th ‘seven dead horses’? ‘discharging

dead horses’? (Re 207). ,

’ ry 4 . ® ‘ et .

February Mth ‘removing dead horses*’ ‘five dead

—trevses’?? CR. 277).

February 28th “sixteen dead horses" ‘discharging = *

déad horses’? (R. 278). '

Mareh Ist, ‘seven dead hogses discharged”.

Mareh 2nd *fseven dead horses discharged’? (RR. 27S).

Viareh Brd ‘three dead horses discharged’? CR. 278).

Mareh 4th ‘tsix dead horses discharged” (R. 279).- *

Mareh Sth ‘*four dead Norses discharged’ Cit. Je

{

March 6th ‘terght dead Horses discharged *? (R. 20).

March 7th ‘three dead jrorses discharged’? (R. 279).

March Sth “eight dead horses discharged’? (R. 279).

Ma veh, ith sone dead horse discha reed’ * three men

‘discharging dead horses’’ (IR. 280) + |

March 10th ‘one dead’ horse discharged”? ‘three men

dixeharging dead horses” (R. 280).

.March lth ‘two dead horses discharged” (R: 280). |

March th three dead liorses discharged”? (R, 280).

Mareh ith sfour dead horses discharged’? ‘horses

discharged 471, four dead’? (R. 280) also ‘fone

mule colt’? (R. 281), “*at 1800, a further discharge

of 403 horses. 1 which three were dead’? (R. 281).

March 4th ‘finished ischarssiys horses. Horses:

dead, three’? (R. 283). #

e

oo

During the voyage the average death rate was over 5

. horses a ‘day a total of 104 horses for the 19 day voyage

with the high figure of sirteen dead inorses on February

28th. - ‘

< >

Petitioner was compelled to live in close proximity to

the filth, dirt, sickness, disease and death of these horses

aboard the vessel. The mucus ‘and phlegin from the si¢k -

horses even before leaving Houston was sprayed. upon

and stuck to his body and face. Sick and dying aud dead *

horses were permitted to remain on deek until they were

thrown overboard, The manure, blood and urine were per-

mitted te pile up on the’ deck and in°the holds and the

stench was continuous, nauseating, Increased at all times

by the dying horses.

These. conditions preve nted- him from e: ating and skeep-

ing properly, he was upset emotionally, all of which tended

to and did lower his physical stamina and resistance.

He was well when he left ‘New York, but because of —.

his inability to properly nourish ‘his holy, the dormant

tubercular bacilli gained the ascendeney with the resultant

tuberculosis, : ‘

The Rockiaxy Vicrory sailed to Trieste. Tt returned

‘to Houston and petitioner sailed again on the Roc KLAND

VicPory for Greece on April 2 th. The ship earried seme

814 mules on this second trip of which only ten died.

in August, 1946. After three days on this last trip he

started hemor rhaging and spitting blood. The vessel arrived

in Bremen on Labor Day ‘and he was then taken to the

Army Hospital and “altimately transferred to the Army

- Hospital at Bremerhaven. At the end of two weeks he

was put, in a hospital there and arrived in New York on

November 5th and was taken to the U.S. Publie Health

Service Hospital at Staten Island and a féw. hours ‘later

was. transferred to Neponsit Hospital acular Wing.

. 9

ae Petitidner returned home in’June.and went to sea again |

lle

It was conceded that the first diagnosis: of tuberculosis

Was In Germany. ,

. X-rays were tion of the pe titloner om November Tth,

M6, and the Government Hospital recom disclosed. that

there was an invélvement of both lungs.

X-rays were’ taken of libelant’s dunes @gi April 24, 1945"

by the U.S. Maritime Commission and the records of the

Coimnission, state. that such "x-rays Were negative. |

This likewase is the opinion of Dr. Lang who interpreted

“them, bs De. Zismore, who took them and: by Dr. Wein.

warten, W ho examined them. : + oe ‘

Al ot, these ddctors we recalled as’ witnesses dy peti

tioner and all ot them were or had been connected owith

the Government Lealth Service at U.S. -Publie Health

Service Hospital, Staten Island,

Dr. Lang, ¢ fonneeted with the-hospitat at the time OF the |

_trial testified that the x-ray takenoot libe lant's lungs as of

November 6, 1946, two days after his return from Germany,

showed that both lungs: were then involved and’ that the

conditions then disclosed indieated that it had-taken from

siX to ninesnionths to develop.

.

Dr. Lang toad that tube re sulosi s cont \ be caused hy om

tt JoWw erect Fesistance. because of living conditions, —__ —

Dr. Zismore and Dr. Weingarten both testilic vd that it?

was their opinion that the conditions on, the ship, the sick.

and dying horses and the resultant exereta, could and eid ”

cause the tubereular condition of libelant.

The Trial Court did not pas. upom the litigated issue’

as to’whether defendant was negligent in accepting ance

transporting these sick and dying horses with their sneez-

ing, coughing, Aving of phlegm and other exereta. Neither *

did it: pass upon the issue of the unseaworthiness of: the

ship because of such conflitions during such voyage.

jack ane ee

- t

-

. .

The vpinion states as to damages;

;@ “He has: not) demonstrated ’ ‘by the weight of

credible evidence that the Roekland | Was not operated

as a trausportevessel carrying 700 or more horses, ;

so that a member of her crew was not provided with —

a reasonably sate place to work, whereby he was. .

caused to becume a Victim. of tuberculosis.’

Q

Dy this statement the: Trial Court avoided the responsi-.

bility of determining whether the sick and dying horses

and their exereta was a conmpetent producing cause of

libelant!s tuberculosis, ;

At the end of the trial there is finding of fact and no

statement at any kind in the opinion that’ passed upon.

Sither the responsibility of respondent. to’ the petitioner ;

for its acceptance as cargo “and transportation at —whether——~

such cargo af such siek-and- dving horses re ‘sulted in his +

_ tubercidosis.

Ta pian speaks Tar ita, 4d BeeHthtes tre ftirtirer: ~

e splanatioy.

The. decision of the* bani States Court of) Appeals

for the Second Cire Wit is nothing more than review of

factual claims With the statement that the lecision of the

‘ 1: FT Comrt: that the condition of the ship itself was not

a seaworthy Was” not clearly erroneous, ~ Alege a Lemna Xiph eee ee ee ar

It does not pass upon the. negligent acceptance of the

cargo of sick and dying horses: nor ‘does dt discuss whether

the ship Was unseaworthy because of its such cedirgo,

It dées not pass at all tpon the issue of damages,

. The decision that there was no ne gligence and no un-

Penne ii Was a finalif¥ in itself so that: any discussion

as to damages was unnecessary and mere surplysage.

But it cannot. be “agserted by respoudent that) sueh .

opinion meets the material Issues involved. On the eon-

trary it evades them. me |

- 10

- CONCLUSION |

For all the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully sub-

mitted that this petition for a writ of certiorari should

be granted. es

Respeetfully submitteds

‘ , VeCcaob ‘LASSNER :

and Kurren & LEVINE,

Proctors for Petition r.

JACOB RassNeEk, ?,

Jf Thomas I. I RAWLEY),

ee Seeartel a of Counsel. —

. x : oes » .

¢

7 : ,

ve ; i

‘ ’ No. dd50- Octobor Term, Ios.

a

fe

11

aire APPENDIX 2

Opinion of United States Sit of Appeals

for the Second Circuit

UNITED STATES COURT ¢ MP APPIALS

« —¥v

—

\

FOR THE Skconp Crgecrr, Se

. (Argued February 6, Sd the ‘ided Mare ‘Ah 6, 1959.)

Docket, Now mea LY

S

ee 1 pee ee Qe ewe 4

PY

ag 7 Wetperr N. Senay, Je

. Liihe lant- dina ant,

v.

Usirep Nrarks of America, | eo:

‘ : Re Sponddeut-. [ppellee,

————$_— 4)

Before: * : poe

° 8 *

Mampen, Judge, United Stat s Court of ¢ lame, and -

Tixe Kx, C ireuit Swi ge.

Appe al from. the United States Distriet © court for the

Eastern District of New York, Mortimer W, Ive rip ( Thief

Judge,

‘ @

. .

‘Hubert X. Se the, Jr, appeals froma decree dismissing |

his libel. B®, MN. I). N. Y., (161 KF. Supyr 689.

?

* Sitting by desig ana ion r urstant to the pre visions p.28 &, S€,

N “I (a).

“

CL ARK, Chict Jud lye. fb UR A cree

12

. Thomas FL Ppawnry, New York City (Kupfer & Levine

*s and Jacob Rassner, New York City, on the brief),

for libelant- appellant, one ‘ ees:

Ispwarp J, BEHRENS, of Gas & Behrens; New York € ity

. ‘ornelius Wi W ickersham, Jr., U.S. Atty., K. D:

X.Y. Brooklyn, N. Y¥., on the brief), for re spuinde nt-

nance

M ALDEN, ge: a a mt

The Tibelant- inn appeals from’ a decree of the

United States District Court for the Mastern District of .

New York, sitting in- Admiralty, ‘dismissing pei libel. '

The libelant sought, in the District Court, id reeover

damages under the dones Act, 41 Stat. 1007, 46 UL S/C

“GSS. because of having been. ‘texposed to contagion and 4IL 4

ness’ while serving @& an oiler on the S.S.Rocknasxp

Vierory, a ship owned, managed, operated and controlled

—__$§hythe- respupdent, the United $ States. _ fie

The libelant, then eighteen years old, signed: on as an

oiler on the RopKLaNp in January of 1946, at the port- of

New York; “for a esti to be sins at —— — cas for.

‘many others died at sea; that the ‘condition of the pres

was so filthy and nause ting beeause the horses’ ‘stalls were

not cleaned and the qlead horses were not promptly. yhrown

overboard, and beeanse the live horses coughed, sneczed

and discharged flying sputum into the air, that. the libelant

lost his appetite and was nnable to nourish his: body. The-

libelant claims that*beeause of his vundernonrishment and,

lowered resistance © to disease, tuberculosis germs whieh are.

+

dormant in the bodies of most persons were aide. to. gain

“ihe ase endeney and disable him.

?

The hotses were earricd to Trieste, Italy, the ship re-

turned to Houston and the crew Was paid off on April 5. .

The libelant signed on the same ship tok a second livestock .

carrying voyagé on. April 22. The ; ship left Houston’ April Be.

254 ¢ arrying a cargo of ial and mares to Greece) from

whence the ‘ship returned to Norfolk, Virginia, on June &,

After six weeks at home, during which the libelarit: was

eated, for a mouth- condition, he signed on the Kyska,

aship of the Wate rman Steamship Comipany, tor a voyage

‘to Bremen; Germany. After three days ‘at sea on the

/Kyska the libelant began to hemorrhage and spit blood.

At Bremerhaven he was, transferred to an Army hospital. '

After two weeks, he was put.aboard a hospital ship and Tai

carried to. New York, where’ he arrived on, November 5, fae

1946, and was placed in the Tubercul: uw Wing of! 'Nepotisit

Hospital, seriously afflicted with tuberculosis, whieh has

greatly impaired his- earning ability. ines ee)

Fhe—pistrict Ss Hit Y: Supp. GST, that ‘the

libelant had not sustained his burden of proof that the S.S.

~ReckLAND Was. unscaworthy or that it was neglige ‘tly

‘yperated and thereby caused the libelant’s: harm. There

Was no evidence of unscawortliness of the ship, as such.

The only respect in which ‘the ship was claimed to have

___ been negligently maittained sas Uiat, the filelant testified

the handlers of the horses were not required to dajly clean

the stalls, nor- to promptly threw the dead animals over-

board. The Judge concluded, from entries made in the

_ship’s log, from the fact that uo other member 64 the erew

suffered ill effect from the voyage, and from the facet that

the libelant signed on for the second voyage on the same

« ship with another. ‘argo of antmals, that the Ipbelant’s testi- -

“mony as to thé conditions om the ship was ‘greatly exag-

gerated, and that in fact there was io negligence in’ the

Operation of the ship, in the respect im which the libelant

asserts that it Was negligently operated,

&

°

The libelant had the burden of proof. Se cabodrd Sad &

Gravel hy orp. V. Americ t Steredores, Inc., 101°F. Yd S46

(CG, A. 2). As to ‘*the re bcs: of she appellate court to |

a disturb what the trial court with its better opportunities

had determined,’ as ‘appli@@® to a suit in Admiralty, sce

Petterson Lightcrage and Towing. Corp. vy. New York

Central R. Co., 126 F. 2d oe (Ce\, 2). See also James’

Richardson & Sons ve € onne rs Marine fs. L4l~ ., 2d 226,

2 ().

, : *

7 He: findings of the District Court were: not clearly.

erroneous, and its judgment is

Aflirmed.

i‘

a

Judgment’ .... as

At a‘stated term of the Uulied States Court

“of Appeals, insand for the Second Cirqut,

held at the: United States ‘ourtieouse in the

City of New York, on the sixth lay of March,

“one thousand nine hundred dnd fifty-yine,

\

z ‘

Present:

‘Hox. Cnarces E. Cuauk, ; . ;

Chief Judge . ; {ae

Hfon. J.) Warren ‘Manners, ‘ ‘

Judge, Uniterl States Guat

of. Claims.

Hox. Carrote’ C. Hixens, soe es

Circuit Judge,

: v

&

Lr AL 4

TIUBERT aNG SEL i. Wi. Se

‘Libelant. Ape ‘lant,

UNITED ea 4 MERICA,

‘ { = we ‘Respondent- Appellee,

Ripon bet the United States Dis Ariet Court for the

- Eastern District of New York. :

This cause game on to ‘he. heard won the transcript of»

record: from the. United States District © ourt for the East-

* ern Distriet of New York, and was argue vl ‘by counsel],

On consider ‘ation whereof, it is now ordered, atid judged,

and decreed that the decree of said District Court be and

it he ‘reby is affirmed ; with costs to the appellee,

eh ee _/ de DANE, Fusaro,

‘ Seas ra Clerk.* .

or

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.