Appendix — Owensboro On Air, Inc. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1959
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
: a ;
: la ae
APPENDIX A
- UNITED’ §TATES COURT OF QrPEALs
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
od *-
oe pes Siar No, 13776
Owenssoro ox tue At, INc., and
OweEnsporo PUBLISHING COMPANY, PETITIONERS,
te 7 | }
a
UNITED SraTes OF AMERICA and. a.
ina CoMMUNICATIONS Com S1ISSION, RESPONDENTS,
Aueatian BROADCASTING-PARAMOUNT THEATRES, Ixc.,
ork, ‘ INTERVENOR, — .
~. Min-AMERICA BroapcasTinG CORPORATION, INTERVENOR,
. ° -WEHT, -Inc., INTERVENO
©
n
Owensporo PUBLISHING COMPANY, APPELLANTS,
oie
® e
in “We | ;
- | : :
“ P 5 ‘ a
_ FEDERAL CoM UNICATIONS Com Mission,” APPELLEE,
pi BroaDCASTING- PARAMOUNT rn Ixc.,
° INTERVENOR,
.
Min- AMERIC A ‘Baoapcast1xé Corroratioy, INTERVENOR,
°
a
"s No. 14044
‘Owenssoro on THE At, Inc., and |
Owensporo PusLisHinc CoMPANY, APPELLANTS,
¥ ne , 5
American Broapcastine-Parayount THeatres, Inc.,
INTERVENOR, _ hit
‘Miv-America Broapcastixe CORPORATION, INTERVENOR,
WEHT, Ixc., ivteRvenonr,
No. 14046 -
_Evassvitte Tevevision, Inc,, aPPeLLANT,
Vv.
me ° 7 : ;
FeperaL ComMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, APPELLEE,
WEHT, Inc., ix rervenor,
3 No. tad
_Evansvitte Tevtvasion, Inc., rerrrionen,
Vv. .
~ ss U siren Sxagme-dr Amenica and
FeveRaL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, RESPONDENTS,
’ WEHT, I8c., INTERVENOR,
6 .* ee
a
Feverat Covimunications COMMISSION, APPELLEE, , .
: "
.
~~ ee ye kets Lente. Oe «
8 ‘Sa
No, 14049 : '
Qwanescns on Tur Arr, Lxe., and*- °
th — 4
Owensporo PUBLISHING Company, PETITION ERS,
v.
— Srares or AMERICA and
*PeveraL Commusicatioys Commission, RESPONDENTS,
AMERICAN Broavcasting-Pakamount THEATRES, Ixc.
INTERVENOR,
Mip-Amenica BroapcasTiInc*CORPORATION, INTERVENOR, —— —
a ap ete oe: eee
WEHT, Ixc., mxtervenon.
. On Petitions for Review and Appeals from Orders of the
Federal Communications Commission ;
S
_ Decided December 18, 1958
‘Mr. Joseph Zias for Owensboro on the Air, I) _ peti-
tioner in Nox*13776 and 14049 and appellant in N 3777
and 14044. Mr. Philip G. Loucks also entered an appear-
ance for ‘Owensboro on the Air, Inc., petitioner, in No.
13776 and appellant in No. 13777. Mr. Maurice M. Jansky .
also enterell an appearance for Owensboro on the Air,
Ine., appellant in No. 14044. ;
Mr. Robert N. Green, with, whom Seed Vincent B.
Welch, Harold E, Mott and Edward P. Morgan were oy
the brief, for Evansville Television, Inc., —* in No. i
14046 and petitioner in No. 14047. ae 5
Mr. Russell Rowell was on the brief for Owensboro Pub- /
lishing Company, petitioner in Nos. 13776 and 14049 and
2
ee
re ee
4a
_Appellant in Nos. 13777 and 14044. Messrs.’ Frank U.
"Fletcher atid Robert -H. licald also entered appearances
for Owensboro Publishing Company, petitioner in No.
14044,
’ Mrs. Ruth V. Reel, Counsel, Federal Communications.
Commission, with whom Messrs. Warren E. Baker, Gen-
eral Counsel, Federal Communications Commission, at
the time the brief was filed, Richard A. Solomon, Assistant
‘General Counsel, Federal Communications Commission,
Richard’ M. Zwolinski, Counsel; Federal Communications
Commission, and Daniel M. Friedman, Attorney,’ Depart-.
ment of Justice, were on the brief, for appellet-reapond-
ents. Mr. Charles C. McCarter, Attorney, Federal Com-
munications Commission, also entered an appearance for
appellee- respondent Federal Communicatiors Commission
in Nos. 14046 and 14047.
Mr J. Roger Wollenberg, with whom Mr. porn G.
Haley. was on- the brief, for intervenor Mid-America
- Broadcasting Corporation i in Nos, 13776, 13777, 14044 and
14049... ae 3
Messrs. James A. McKenna, Jr., and Vernon -L, Wilkin-
son were on the brief for interv enor American Broadeast-
See Theatres, Inc., in Nos. 18776, 13777, 14044
‘and 14049, “
Messrs.. Bernard Kotcen and Alan Y. Naftalin ‘were on
the brief for’ interv enor WEHT, Ine.
Before Fany, DANAHER and Bastian, Circuit Judges.
DANAHER,. Circuit Judge:. “We are here asked to review
another phase of the vexatious ‘*UHF-VHF conflict which
“has long engaged the ‘Commission and which on several
occasions has come to this court.’ This time we are con-
1 See, e.g., Coastal Bend* Television Co. v. Federal Communica. .
tions Commission, 98 U.S. App. D.C. 251, 234 F. 2d 686 (en bane,
1956) ; Greylock Broadcasting Compang v. nited ‘States, 97.U.S.
Pray Sees See ee
wy rehire
re
et eee eee ee ee
|
wast > abner
—5,—
‘cerned with Evansville, Indiana, and the “area: adjacent.
thereto.
“wens on the Air, Ine., and Owensboro Publishing
Company“ had. been engaged in adjudicatory proceedings
testing their comparative qualifications for an award of.
VHF Channel 9 in Hatfield, Indiana.’ The #ommission
‘had made no award. These parties will hereinafter be
referred to as. Owenshoro-appellants. Evansville Televi-
sion, Ine., herein referred to as Evansville-WTVW, is a
permittee which, since September 1956, has been operating
on VHF Channel 7 in: Evansville, Indiana.
Basically, the foregoing: parties here contend that the
, Commission’ s rule making is technically invalid and thus’
” that the deletion of VHF Channel 9 from. Hatfield Is
illegal. The Commission’s notice of prapos ed rule jnaking
in. Docket No. 11757 specifically prescribed @ contemplated
plan to require all commercial television opcrations”
emanating from Evansville to utilize UHF channels. It
was rr noticed that VHF Channe! 7.at Evansville
"App. D.C, 414,231 F. 2d 748 (1956). ‘Springfield Televi into
Broadeasting Corp. v. Federal Communications Commission, ——
U.S. App. D.C; ——, 259 F. 2d 170 (1958); and WIRL Television
Company v. United States, 102 U.S. App. D.C. 341, 253 F. 2d 863
(1958), cert. granted, judgment vacated on other grounds, ——-
US. —— (O@t. 20, 1958). By our order, the Clerk of this Court
directed all sictlee in the instant case to inform us as‘to the pos- .
sible existence of: circumstances such as caused the Supreme Court
to vacate our judgment in the WIRL case. We accept the assur-
ances of all parties that there are no such: circumstances here
present. Ns whee ©
*VHF Channel 9 was a S+a¥op-in”? channel not allocated to,
Hatfield, Indiana, under the Commission’s 1952 Sixth Report and
Order but was found thereafter to be permissible under lat?r-
evolved engineering limitations. Compare the Vail Mills Chan- -
nel 10~*drop=itr?-in—Greylock Broadcasting Company v. United
States, supra note 1, and Van Curler Broade ‘asting Corp. v. United
States, 98 U.S. App. D.C.%432, 236 F. 2d 727 (en bane, 1956), cert.
denied,-352 U.S.°935 (1956). : ;
a a ae
6a
—wan to be reserved for educational use, should the pro-
posal be adopted. .No construction permit had ever been
issued for operation on VHF Chanhel 9.at Hatfield, and
_ the notice of rule making did not .mention Channel 9.
Accordingly it is argued that the noti¢e was fatally «de-
fective because of the Commission's alleged failure to
comply. with the notice requirements of § 4(a of the
Administrative Procedure Act: which reads in ‘pertinent
part:
** See. on. ‘Notice.—General notice of proposed
rule making shall be published in the Federal Regis. |
ter (unless all persons subject thereto are named and
either personally served or otherwise have actual
notice tlireof in accordance with law) and shall in-
clude 7 (3) either. the terms or substance of the
proposed rule -@ Oy a description of the subjects ani
issues involr ed.’ ~~ beaut added. )
In Jac Sens ille Journal Co. vy. . Federat Commun. Com’n,
101. U.S.App.D.C, 12, 13, 246 F.2d 699, 700 (1957), we
noticed that the Commission’ 8s Report and Order in
Docket No. 11532 had follow ed our Coastal Bend decision.”
Therein the Commission had specified certain criteria
which were to be deemed cenerally applicable in dealing
with the problem of interim. ‘action. The Commission had
indicated that a.‘*basie choice’? in many markets might
‘require the elimination of VHF -channels in order: to
create improved. opportunities for UHF broadcasting. 1;
Pike.& Fiscuer Ravio Reo, 1571, 1581,1582. On the same
day, June 26, 1956, in Doeket No. 11757, 21 Fed. Reg. 4972,
the Commission gave motice of proposed rule making anid
‘ specifically called attention to: its Report and Order in
Docket No. 11532, in accordance with the general objec.
tives of which its interim program of channel reassign-
..ments was to be undertaken. The Commission propose:
* Supra note 1.
that VHF Channel 7 in Evansville be roserved for educa-
tional use and that UHF Channel 56 in Evansville be
teleased fromggducational reservation so that Evansville
would have UPTF Channels 50, 56 and. 62 for commercial |
use, The same. notices of rule making further kpecified
that: . 7 ,
‘t Any interested party who ix of the view that the
proposed améndment should” not be adopted, or
should not be adopted in the form set forth herew.
‘may file-with the Commission on or before September
10, 1956, a written statement setting forth his com-_
ments.’’ (Emphasis added.)
In addition, parties ubmitting comments were expressly
requested ‘to direct their attention to the matters dis-
‘cussed in paragraph 31 of the Commission’s Report and
Order issued today in Docket No, 11532."" Thus ineorpo-
~ rated by reference in No, 11757 were the criteria spelled
out in detail in Docket No, 11532. The Commission ex.
plained : / ; ;
***Bocauxe of the widely varying cireumstanees im
individual markets and the-numerons factors which.
hear on the choice of techniques in any individual .
community or area, it ix not possible to formulate
rigid criteria whose perfunctory application to indi-
vidual cases will automatically indicate ‘the -course
which would best serve the public interest in each
-* eommunity during the i:terim period. We have
. eluded, however, after exjensive review of al the
~ proposals which have been submitted te ns for the
elimination or addition of commercial VHF assign-
‘ments, that the following considerations All’ have.
important bearing on decisions in specific * nemuni-
ties or areas.”’* 21 Fed, Reg. 4958, 4962. .
Pursuant to the. Commission's invitation that comments
or counterproposals be submitted, on July 13, 1956, “Mid-
America Broadeasting Corp., intervenor herein, and per-
mittee of WKLO-TV, Channel 21 at Louisville, Kentucky,
_ —e
4 Docket No. 11532, 13 Prxe & Fiscnex Rapto Res. lore.
See 6
asked -that VHF ¢ Channel 7 be alloeated: # Louisville |
rather than be retained in Evansville on a reserved basis.’
: Eyansyille- WT'VW on August 24, 1956, requested with. *.
-drawal of the Commission's June 2ti,, 1956, notice of pro- '
posed rule making in Docket No. 11757. Evansville.
WTVW -correetly contended that as permittee of VHF
Channel 7 it was entitled tv. a full evidentiary hearing
_ under § 316 of the Communications Act. The Evansville... |
WTVW petition was denied* by the. Cominission in a
memorandum and order adopted November 28, 1956, re-
leased December 3, 1956.. The. Commission there noted -
that the ‘‘Notice of Proposed Rule Making in Docket No.
11757, to which petitioner objects, is merely a proposal
which may or'may not be adopted in the form aint
— Only ‘after consideration of the requested comments -and .
~ any counterproposals that may be submitted will we be in .
a position to judge the proposal on its. merits, both legal
and factual.’’ (Emphasis added.)
Thereupon,. under date of . December 3, 1956, Mid-
Ameriea filed its comments and counterproposal. that
Channel 7 be reallocated to Louisville, that Channel 9 be
- reallocated or be deleted froin’ Hatfield, Indiana, and that
certain UHF channels: be allocated to Evansville and Hat-
field. -The intervenors, Premier Television, Ina, permittee
of UHF Statica: WEFIE in Evansville and WENT, Ine..
permittee of UHF Station W EHT at Henderson, Kentucky,
‘also on December 3, 1956, jointly submitted comments urg-
ing that the Commission's original proposal be adopted
with “referenee to VHF Channel*7. They -specifically
further asked that commercial TV channels ‘‘in the Evans-
*On Ovtober 22, 1956, the Commission denied the Mid- Samovien
counterpropesal and similar proposals submitted by other Ken-
tucky residents. The. Commission indieated that such counterpro-
posgls would be considered in the Evansville de-intermixture’ pro-
ceeding and accordingly, there was no nee essity for ‘amending the
Notice of Rule Making or for instituting further rule making to
mit voaneed the Louisville proposal. 21 Fed. Reg. 8196.
*
ee ep aera Pee
‘ 4
Ya ; . |
+ ville, Indiana market"? he made exclusively U ng. These
‘intervenors additionally urged that VHF Charinel® 9,
allocated at Hatfield, Indiana, ‘*be reaerved for wuca-
tional use in the Hatfield-Owensboro area.’
Evansyjlle- -WTVW under date of December 28, 1956,
filed extensive conments not only with reference to the-
e Commission ‘s#proposal but to the comments, and counter-
proposals. of WFIE and WEHT. It argued the. demerits
of the plan to delete: ‘both VHF Channels. 7 and 9. |
The Owensboro- appellants, on the other. hand, chose not ©
to argue the merits. Instead, they contented themselves
with filing a motion. ‘‘15 strike comments or so-called
counterproposals filed in the above-entitled proceeding
relating to the removal, reservation for educational pur-
poses, or the deletion of Channel 9 ‘from Hatfield, In-
diana.’’ Their pleading discloses their complete awareness
‘ of the Commission’s proposal and of the counterproposals.
They filed no comments nor did they otherwise propose
participation in the rule. making proceedings: On the con-
trary, they stood simply on their claim that the Commis-
sion must strike all proposals and counterproposals look-
ing to the deletion or change in designation of VHF
Channel 9 at Hatfield solely on the ground, as they alleged,
that the June 26, 1956, notice of proposed rule making
had failed to comply with the requirements of §4(a) of
‘the Administrative Procedure Act. But they had actual
iotice both of the propose “i rule-making and of the
“subjects and issues involvetl,’’ just as § 4(a) requires.
The Cammission on March. 1, 1957, relegsed its Report
LOrder:* VHF Channel 9. was delet€&{ from Hatfield:
ant assigned to Evansville for use as a “noncommercial,
education station:—UHF Channel 56 was, allgcated : to
Owensboro for commercial telecasting; Ev anaviille- VW.
pursuant to the requirements of §316 of the Communic t-
tions: Act of 1934) was ordered to show cause why VhF |
e
629 Fed, Reg. 1499. ,
7YVS.C. §316 (1952). rae
10a
_ Channel 7 should not be reallocated to Louisville, and its.
entitlement to a hearing with reference thereto was recog.
nized; and—at the same time, UCHF Channel 31 was allo-
cated to Evansville,* there to be agailable for commercial
telecasting by Evansville- WTVW in the eyent that the .-
Commission should ultimately decide that Channel 7
should be reallocated to Louisville, (Other actions then _
taken are not hero pertinent.)
The. Commission noted in its Mareh a, 1957, ‘Report
and Order’’:
“Our June 26, 1956 Notice of Proposed Rule Making
stated. that the instant proceeding is being conducted
in furtherance of -our. program for improving the ,
opportunities fdr effective competition’ among a:
greater number of stations in specific areas, which
, program was enunciated in our June 26, 1956 Report
and Order in the general teldvision allocations pro-
.. ceeding (Docket. No. 11532)4* Since the need for
* \ area deintermixture was treated at some length in.the
\ Report and Order, all parties were or notice that the
_.. instant\ proeeeding, as well as the other deintermix-
ture proceedings; concern the need for and advis-
ability ‘of area deintermixture. |Unq¢estionably
Evansville and Hatfield, being only about 21 miles.
apart, are: in the same general area.” The untena-
i" Both of these June 26, 1956 releases (Notice in this pro-
ceeding and the Report and Order in Docket 11532) were duly
published in the Federal Register. This constitutes construc-
tive notice of all parties under prevailing statutes. -
12 The record discloses that Station - WTVW on Channel 7 r
in Evansville puts a Grade A signal over Hatfield; and that
both of the Hatfield Channel 9 apppeante propese to provide
Evansville with a\ Grade A —_ ™
* Compare. the WIRL situation, supra note 1, where as part of
this same 13 community. interim program, appellant desired the
Vi F Channel 8, not the UHF Channel 25 it received.
Hla.
bility of the Hatfield applicants’ motion to strike is
further demonstrated by the fact that the WFIE and
WEHT counterproposal to delete or reserve for
‘education Channel 9. was included as an integral part
of their initial comments in this proceeding, w ich
‘ ‘comments were filed on Degember 3, 1956. Reply
i ~ comments were timely if filed by December 28, 1956,
7 ‘ The Ghannel 9 applicants were thus afforded an ample
H
opportunity to submit comments in opposition to this
counterproposal. We need not decide whether these
Hatfield applicants had constractive notice of the
filing of the WFIE arid WEHT counterproposal, since
they unquestionably had. actual notice of this filing.
|.- 2 gome time’ prior to December 28, 1956. The Hatfield
. applicants could HL gferwise have filed their motion
to Strike on that ‘oe
) The Owensboro-appellants thus again had full oppor-~
|. tunity, then and there to act, With detailed knowledge of
all aspects of that Report and Order. They were already -
in the case as parties. Even were it to be granted that
there was some substance to their claim of lack of earlier
notice.of the full import of the contemplated rule making,
after. their: motion to strike had’ been denied and -the
Commission’s Report and Order had issued on March 1,
1957, they certainly were fully- advised in the premises.
They could have sought reconsideration under § 405 of the
Act.2” But they chose to takt no further steps.
It is clear that the Commission concluded, in its compe-
tence, to ‘‘de-jntermix’’ the Evansville area and ‘so allo- .
eated only UHF. channels for telecasting in that market,
thus seeking to achieve the objectives spelled out in’ detail
in itt Memorandum and Order. in. Doeket No. 11532." —
*47 U.S.C. § 405 (1952). The'petition for reconsideration filed —
_° by Evansville WTVW was denied by the Commission’s Memo- ¢
randum Opinion and Order released June 24, 1957.-~
1 We do not discuss, the. merits of the position of Evansville-
WIVW with reference to the ‘ aerenace of "VHF Channet. 7,
use-of the pending -hearing ‘
e:
_ mais . 12a
That the Commission in-a rule making proveeding inay
take such action is no longer open to question."
‘The case, then, ‘comes to this: is an otherwise valid | |
determination by the Commission to be voided ‘for ‘its -
failure to include in the original proposal a. suggestion
‘that its de-intermixture program might. require the de-
* letion of VHF Channel 9?- We answer in thé negative,
particularly on the facts of this case. ‘We have-no intention.
whatever of accepting a Commission’s plan of conyenience
as a substitute for compliance with the rule making notice
requirements of § 4 of the Administrative Procedure Act.
however, there., were both the actua: notice and a_
“description of the subjects and the issues involv ed as re-
quired by § 4(a), within our holding in Logansport -Broad-° -
casting Corp.,v. United States, supra note 11. Section
4(a), we there said, “requires only that the prior notice in-”
clude ‘a description. of the. subjects and. issues involved.’
We think the procedure follow ed by the Commission amply
fulfilled“this ‘requirement.. . Surely every time the Cont-.
. mission decided to take account of some additional factor
' it was not. required to start the proceedings all over again.
‘If such. were the rule the proceedings might never be
* terminated’? 93 U.S. App. D.C. at 346, 210 F.2d at 28.
.There was far more than the concise general statement
of the basis and purpose of the amended rules which we
approved in’ Van Curler Broadcasting Corp. v. United
States, supra note 2, required by § 4(b). There was no
“Menial of opportunity to the parties to participate as fully —
‘as theg chose. To void the Commission’s rule-making here
would be ‘an exercise in sheer stultification.. The facts -
compel a realistic appraisal of the background for the -
_action by.the. ‘Commission which we now affirm. -
= = ne Broadcasting Co. v. ‘United States, 93 U.S. App. De
78, 209 F. 29286 (1953) ; Zenith Radio Corp. vy. Federal Communi-
cations Cofn’n, 93 U.S, ~App. D.C. 284, 24L F: 2d 629 (19542;
‘Logaksport Broadcasting Corp. (v. UnisedStates, 93-U.S S. App..
DC: 342, 210 F. 2d 24 (1954) ; and see: notes 1 anda2 supra—
es
_ ee
* h
Sais canchninsestop stealing ESE
wa aeee
~~
>
=
NC Bites ed on WAST ome
Se
-
Hatfield, Indiana, is a comnunity of some © 2,500 popula-
‘tion. It may be supposed - will contend a listening
audience limited to that cor ity ean support a televi-
sion station. Owensboro on the Air, Inc., tells us. in its
brief that the VHF Channel 9 ‘‘drop-in’’ was the’ result of
its own engineering study: In seeking the allocation, it
represen'«d to the.Commissior that ‘‘the assignmerit ‘of
‘ Channel 9 to Hatfield ‘will result in the assignment. of a
a
“e Of course that was true. There were ‘td two VHF chan-
‘channel. to a communit® to which no assignment now:
“exists:and will provide a second channel to serve the needs
and: interests of Owensboro and its, environs, ‘thus ‘foster-
ing competition between television stations in the public.
‘interest as contemplated by the eC ommunications Act.’
(Emphasis added.)
nels allocated to. communities within. 75 ‘miles of Evans-
ville. One was VHF Channel 9 and the other was VHF
Channel 7. Any. action as to reallocation or use which
mighfaffect. ‘one inevitably would affect the other. Alloca-
tions of television channels were not to post office sites but
to the area to be served. Owensboro is only 10gniles frour
Hatfield. Evansville is only 21 miles from. Hatfielg. The
: Owensboro- appellants: themselves, Obviously,, sowzht | to
servg, not Hatfield as such, but ‘ Jwensboro and. its en-
virons,’’ and -both ‘actually proposed to put a Grade A
signal ower Ev@sville. That situation had long since
given rise. to a series of de-intermixtare proposals with °
reference to this very ‘area. -Commencing as early as
ketober; 1954, ‘the juxtaposition. of VHF Channels 7 in
‘Ansville and 9 in. Ow enghoro had been the subject of |
iallenge, followed by" Ae ommisgion ‘consideration and rule
making, eee
Finally, on Nove
missed the abana
.
Lon
.
1213 Pike & Fisc HER Ravio Rea. 1: SIt; ; 20 Ki ed. tie 8495 where’
it will be seen, appe'lants- ones her re with various of the in-
eT 10, 1955, ‘tHe Canlnatection dis- + -
ule oviiing proseedmnee, and at the
Sf get an at ae a 2 )
same time initiated ‘the: new vile making” proceeding,
' Docket: Na. 11532, supra. The Commission‘’s aétion was
then attacked in this. court with the appeals consolidated
under the’ caption ‘of -Geusfal: Bend Television Co.-v. Fed.
_- sustained the: Commission. W
Investment Co. ¥: Federal
“U.S. App.D:C. 379, 240 F.2d 410, on January 17, 1957.. All
"of these: actions antedated the Commission’s June 26, 1956,
Report and Order in Docket No. 11532 and its initiation
the same day of Docket No.11757, here involved. We need
not repeat -but merely refer to the. ateps- which followed,
narrated above. If the purpose of ‘notice when required
eral. Communications mign We supra note 1, There we -
in any case is to give notite, the® appellants-petitioners
hére hag it.” There is no showing that they were deprived
of. opportunity: in any measure to take whatever steps
their own situation, might suggest, -whetheg by. way of
counterproposal and comment or by evidence to establish
_.their own position. That they. dre not happy over the
result is clear. That they sustained legal i injury is not.
, > A firmed. .
9
tervendrs | ‘had been parties ‘to. rule making proceedings in Docket
‘No. 11334° involving these very channels and, in substance, - : ce
same proposals and counterproposals.
3 It has been urged that Hotch v_United thintia, 212 F: 2d ORI)
(9 Ci ir. 1954), should conte here. “There the court was not con-
cerned with the sufficiency of a notice of rule making which had
been published in the Federal Register, as happened ‘in this case. _
On the contrary the court pointed out *‘that since neither the pro-
oposed regulation nor the regulation itself... were ever published, *
' the’ regulation is not valid ....7 Id. at 284. Thus the failure
. to publish as a prerequisite to the issuance of a regulation making
- certain acts criminal was held to preclude a conviction. Clearly
- no such situation exists in the instant case.
a
Re *
«+
ae
‘80 again in Gerico -
Commun. Com’n, 99 ,
a
, Pan, °Circwit Judge, dissing: The Administrative
basiiens ‘Act' provides two important safeguards for
the: protegtion of private rights in agency rule making by
requiring, first, that there shall: he publication of notice
of proposed rule making, and secondly, that there shall be’
opportunity for participation by interested persons,
Section 4(a) providés that notice of proposed * rule
“anaking shall be published in the. Federal Register and
‘must include, among other things, “either the terms or
substance of thé proposed rule or a description of the
subjects and issues involved.’’ Section 4(b) provides that -
after notice has been “issued, ‘‘the agency shall afford
interested persons an’ opportunity to participate in the p,
rule making through en of written Gata, ¥ view iS, OF
ings the er as to aon and public participation
must be read together.
. Considering the requirements of g 4(a),- I am ‘ails _
construe the notice which was reledsed by the Commission
on June 26, 1956, as adequate to support the order of, the
_ ., Commission. * The notice, is entitled ‘‘Amendment of Sec-
tion 3.606, Table of? Assignments, Televi ision Broadcast
Stations (Evansville, Indiana)”’; its first’ paragraph states
that ‘Notice is hereby given of rule making in the above-
entitled matter.’’ The notice goes.on. in the segond para-
graph to announceathat the Cammission propo changes
in certain existing and nan hanes are to re-
main in Evansville while othérs will be reassigned else-
‘Where as specified. Neither blatfield, Indiana, nor channel
9 then assigned to Hatfield, is mentioned anywhere in the:
notice; yet. the Commission has ordered that the Table of
Assignments contained in Section 3.606 of its 9 and
‘Regulations be-amended to delete. V HF’ television channel
9 from Hatfield, and to reassign it to “Evansville for
, . 7 :
_—_—_— ——
160 Stat. 237.5 U.S.C. §§ 1001-11 (1952). ~*~
la”
”
educational purposes," The le ‘gislative history of the Ad-
ministrative Proceduré Act makes clear that the notice
‘issued by the agency in compliance with the mandate of:
§ 4(a) ‘‘must ‘bé sufficient to fairly apprise interested
ana of the issues involved, so- that they may present
‘responsive data or argument relating thereto,”’ and that
‘‘where notice is required, it. should’ be complete amd .
specific’,
| My view I ‘think i is fortified hy the fact that channel 9
yas sought to be brought, into the Evansville proceedings
J
by a counter-proposal. This counter-proposal, however,
_ was objected -to and the Commission delayed ruling on the.
objection until it was overruled simultaneously with the
order eliminating channel 9 from Hatfield. If -the Com-
inission was to, eliminate channel 9 it should -have ruled
on the objection to its involvement in the Evansville pro-
- ceedings before actually deleting it from Natfiéld. 7
Our review of the merits of Commission decisions is
Limited. One of the justifications for ghe linitation falls
‘away if the parties are not afforded a full opportunity
to be heard before the Commissipn itself. It TS important
therefore, that the Commission carefully comply with the
provisions Congress has provided for notice.
——-
7S. a No 248, 79th on 2d Sess. 200 (1946).
5. -
4
17a . -
APPENDIX B ‘
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPRALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Bnew - © gt Doren ee.
Sertemser Term, 1958
| No. 14,046
Evaxsvitte Tenevisiox, Isc., Appellant, -
6 v.
FeveraL Communications Commission, d pyellee,
*MiuAmerica Broapcastixe Corporation, Intervenor, [sic]
WEHT, Ixc., Intervenor- -
No. 14,047
Evatsvnz Tevevisiox, Ixc.,. Petitioner,
e =.
Unrrep States or America,
Feverat Coma usteations Commission, Respondent, <
WEHT, Isc.) Intervenor.
Before: Prettyman, Chief Judge, Eoorrtoxs, Wace K.
* Muse, Bazerox, Fany, Wasnixotoy, Dasxanen,
’ Bastian and Burcer, Circuit Judges in Chambers.
Order
‘Upon consideration of the. petition for rehearing in bane,
‘itis ;
Orvered by the court that the petition for rehearing in
hane i is denied.
Per Curiam.
Dated: February 2, 1959
Cireuit Judge Miller did not participate in. this order.
.
’
21 U8
-
. . . oe
. + ° 9°
Yo >
. .
18a
APPENDIX C
1958, Report of the Committee on Communications of the
ean ats Law Section, American Bar Association‘
Preface -. ” a
a ,
The Communications Committee 6f the Administrative — - L
2 . “ . , . | y
‘ Law Section undertook this year to consider and report ¢
on the following subjects: mee e
°* ee . :
' 2. The procedure gov erning the filing ond consideration
of counter-proposals in response to rule making proposals 4
of the Federal Communications Commission. J
.
In the report, infra, on each subject, there are presented
a’ statement ‘of the problem, discussion, and the. recom-
mendations of the Committee.
, a co
The procedure governing: the filing and consideration s
of coynter-proposals in*response to rule making proposals
of the Federal Communications Commission.
Statement of the problem. With stated_exceptions, Sec
tion 4 of the Administrative Procedure Act requi
cies to publish general notices of proposed rulé making -
in the Federal Régister containing, among other things,
the terms or substance of the proposed nile or a deserip-
tion of the subjects and issues involved. - -The Federal -
Communications Commission, while publishing notices of
proposed rule making in the Federal Register and deserib-
ing the substance of proposed rules, has followed ‘the prac-
tice of receiving ang considering counter- proposals con-
tairied in comments filed in answer tu notices of proposed
rule making, even though the coanter- proposals suggested
‘entirely new solutions to the problems involved .in_ the
proceedings. Such counter- proposals are hot published -
* Reprinted in 1958 Federal C ommunieations Bar Journal.
i 19a
in the Federal Register, nor is there any Commission re-
quirement that‘they be served on other parties interested
i -in the proceedings. The gjuestion arises, therefore, whether
Commission con:
the ambit of thé original notices of proposed rule making
APA.”
Discussion, The Attorney General's Manual on the Ad-
ministrative Procedure Act. 1947) states the purpose of
_ Section 4 as fotlows:
‘“‘In general, the purpose of Section 4 is te guaran-
Pf tee to the public an opportunity to participate in the
rule making process. With stated exceptions; each
agency will be required under this section to give pub-
Jie notice of substantive’ rules.which it proposes te
tunity to present their views to it. i (p. 26) |
Since notice to the public is the paramount ¢éoncern of
Section 4 of the APA, it is necessary to examine the prac-
tice of the Commission with respect to giving notice of
* eounter- proposals in rule making proceedings to ‘deter-
such counter-proposals.
or to amend existing ones, file petitions for rule making
ments and the reasons why they should be adopted. There
‘is no requirement, that the petitions be served on anyone.
However, public notice of the filing of such petitions is
announced by the Commission in a press release, and
diligent parties this way learn of such petitions and have
: an opportunity to oppose or support them if they so desire.
Any statements supporting or opposing petitioas to in-
petitioners. (Rule 1,204.) If the Commission is convinced
that there is sufficient ‘substance to the petitions, it issues
formal notices of proposed rule making which are pub-
lished in the Federal Register. Time limitations ure -set
eratign of, counter-proposals not within
is contrary to the letter and spirit al Section 4 of the .
adopt, and to grant interested persons ati oppor-
mine the yalidity of the consideration regularly giv en to ,
Persons desiring the Commission to adopt new rules;
\. ‘setting forth the nature of the proposed rules or amend-’
stitute rule making. proceedings must be served on the ~.
.
20a : °
for the filing of written comments and reply comments.
The average time for filing comments and reply com-
ments is 30 days and 15 days respecfively.. There is no -
Commission requirement that comments or reply comments
be. served on interested parties since it is difficult to ascer-
tain all of the parties who might have an interest in the
rule making proceedings. .
Parties opposed to the adoption of rigs rules eins
go further than merely explaining why th
adopted. They frequently offer variant solutions to the
~ underlying problems which bring in new issues not within
-the ambit of.the original notices of proposed rule making.
For example, the Commission. recently issued a notice of
proposed rule making raising the question whether tele.
-vision channel 3 should bealloeated to Ainsworth, Nebraska.
(Television channela@ware allocated geographically by rule —
making.) An existing station on channel 3 at» Omaha.
Nébraska opposed the suggested allocation, and . also
- petitioned the Commission to issue a supplemental notice
of proposed rule making to allocate channel 7 to =
rather than channel 3. By order released November 6,
1956 (21 F.R. 8821), the Commission held squarely that-
the counterproposal to allocate channel 7 rather than chan.
nel 3 to Ainsworth need not be the subject of further public
notice by amendment of the notice of proposed rule mak-
ing, but that the merits of the counter-proposal would _
receive full consideration in the proceeding. A channel
7 station in Omaha, which had no interest in the rule
making proceeding affecting channel 3 but hada definite
interest in the issue presented by the counter-proposal with
respect to channel 7, did not receive service of the counter-
proposal, was not notified of the counter-proposal by the
Commission directly through press release or’ otherwise,
and did not have constructive notice through amep Iment
of the original notice of proposed rule making to | xcom-
pass ‘the enlarged’ issue. (Fortuitously, the channel 7,
station at Omaha had actual notice. . See Report and Order.
Docket 11830, 15 Pike & Fischer, Radio Regulation, 1617,
1620).
Y a .
should not be .
| + Sie -. |
In the Evansville deintermixture case ( ket No. 11,757, —
15 Pike & Fischer, RR 1573), the Comiinission issued a
notice of proposed rule making which Was published in
the Federal Register suggesting that Chanuvl 7 at Evans-
ville be changed from a commercial, to a noncommercial
— educational channel. Comments were filed pro and con the
suggested, amiefdment. Some of the comments proposed
that in lieu of changing Channel 7 to a noncommercial.
statfis, the channel should be reallocated to Louisville,
Kentucky. Ofher, comments recommended that complete”
deinteranixture in ‘the Evansville area be effectuated by
deleting Channel 9 from nearby Hatfield, Indiana, and
reserving the channel for educational use at Evansville.
Neither of thee counter-proposals was ever published in
~ the Federal. Register. However, the proposals involved
had been the sabjeet of previous rule making proceedings.
The Commission adopted doth counter-proposals. The
question whether such action complies with Section 4 of —
‘the Aliministrative Procedure Act is now pending on appeal
in the United States Court of Appeals for the Distriet
of Columbia-Cireuit (Owensboro on the Air, Ine, et aly v.
United States of America, et - Nos. 13,776, et al.).
In view of the fact that Section 4 ofthe APA strives
to insure public notice of the substance of adniinistrative’
rule making (with, the exceptions listed in the Act), it
seems clear to this Committee that the genéral purpose
and meaning of Seetion 4 is vitiated by the failure of the
Commission to provide notice . of counter-proposals by
means. of publication in the -Federal Register or other
procedures sanctioned by Section 4. The Committee is
aware of the practical difficulties’ in this matter pointed
out by the Commission in-its Report and Order in’ the
Ainswo?th, Nebraska proceeding, referred to above:
‘ . .
‘*Rule making proceedings conld go on interminably
if an administrative agency such as thix Commission
should be requiréd, wherever a meritorious counter.
proposal is advanced in comments, to issue a Further
Notice of Proposed Rule Making and to extend the
time for filing comments for a reasonable period after
—e
g ,
~Tssuaneeof the farther “hotice.’ . (15 Pike & Fincher,
RR 1620).
, en er, the pasaibitity of interminable protraction of
rule making proceedings is not in itself justification for not
abiding by the requirements of the Administrative Pro-
cedure Act rather than providing a, procedural technique
which. would both permit compliance with the APA anid
serve administrative convenience. It also appears that
prodiefn confkenting ‘thee Commission in-the allocation of
‘television channels by ‘rule makirg,+rather .than apow
“pplications therefor, is not typical of the administrative
rule making: process.
nal a Recomme ndation. The Committee has given cansidera-
tion to techniques of notice which would both satisfy tHe
notice requirements of Section 4 of.the. APA but avoid
excessive delay in rule making proceedings of the Federal ~
Communications Commission, especially with regard to
television channel allocation rule making, but has not agreed
upon. any‘one of several alternatives suggested. Tt ix
‘recommended that the effort to reach agreement on‘a notice
_proeedure consistent with Section 4 of the APA and with
“administrativ ¢ cohvenience be yontinued by the new Coni-
; mittee.
V5
~~
a
ae 4
oe
‘ ~
_—
; ae ,
y=]
~ a
there iy -substantial basis’ for thinking that the acute -
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.