Brief for King Packing Company — Mitchell v. King Packing Co.
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
‘\ . y . e
A _uibaaly ; i —
SSS .
ee p5.
| United States
. . \
“OCTOBER Tidar. 1955 :
No, gy
oe i oake A
yy” ;
e 4 ~~
James P. Miroir, Secretary of area
ny en aes Department of Labor, :
: ; Petitioner.
¥ vs.
KixG Packing Company, seh imate
; Responds wie ‘ : panned
On Writ of Cettiorari to the United States Court of Appeals
Siro 5: for the Ninth Circuit
are for Ming Pi acking C company.
- Ay %
aie Witrarp S, Jounxston
; ; .* Grorce H, Jonnstow.
. 256 Montgpmery; Street
° San ‘Francisco, California : »
Attorneys for Respondent
Ning Packing Company
SSS MN Sa NOS SOME - Wek” eel aa AR Sanat et Rn TORE De es alah
JG
PARKER PRINTING COMe@EARY eo PIeNST stReFT SAN FRANCISCO &
2
/ the Suprer eme Cc ourt off tlie — —
- INDEX
Qhiestion Presented soe intaces poe Sideesaeakonkuanes fee Nara mee Aker tae =
‘Supplenental Btteient of the Case..... n saeans i sk conlinyatpetaesaenene de
Summary of 0 Sebeta eae ee are ene eocoegeteceneneees sapere x
Argument, ee ee mveR peat coe Sia. poston CLERK eee, eel a
oe 4 - : 8 . . z ‘ . . “y n . . “ee
I. The knife sharpening here is included within the mean-
* ing of ‘fany’’ activity preliminary to the employee's prinss,
; ; a7
ww) |
=~]
- cipal activities and:so is non-compensable......................------ 7
A. Phe statute exe dudes all preliminary activities... ...-. 7
B. The T rial Court's findings. supported by evidpnes and
affirmed: by a unanimous Court of Appeals,:are eén- .
gh a ea sata Rese aR rd Sabet KO Seu uate amt ose apa nplscnces 10
IT. The petitioner’s argument -that ‘principal activities - int
7. eludes “indispensable activities’ is. without foundation.
tet Petitioner's construction would bring back the conditions
sought to be remedied by the Portal Act OR Gaeta A pe oe 13
A. Potitioner’s coniention that past and future e ‘laims are
treated diftere ntly jn the statute, with which we agree,
does not support his cone Jusion that only uunne eessary,
CviVARIED GiO CRON cna hcccecinrctiecetene neces
B. The history of the Portal Act in Congress shows that
: Congress intended Section 4+ to’ preclude claims like
those involved in-the Mt. Ciemens Pottery €o. case. °
: : : es «
and hete........... Wanker ce tectenere LOG OS iicies Rata ines eel 18
-C. The 1949 Améndments-to the Labor Standards Act
- are irrelevant’ fo petitione r’s interpretation of sthe
Por I SERRE ie eariccssatanes! Basalt ca Dieta oasis os kk 21
aera oe eX dee atdcbliene cutanth Gat teaoa ice bee oar ea ts ee Se 24
CITATIONS .
iy ae Cases — ? Pages
-Nddison v.. Holly Hill Pruit Products, 329 TS. 607, 64S. Ct.
"42975 (2944)..2........ YE AEE EN hs es oa eaters oes rk
Alstate Construction Cov. Durkin, 345 ' S.18, 73 8. €t. 565
Do.) ERRORS Aaa acm dick (eDecie “thane MER SaNP Nr Sas sk Res
Anderkog Vv. Mt. Clemens Pottery Co .. aoe US. 680, 66S. Ct.
RE Oe Nor aaa Nae SE SET SCS Coy! aa
Central Missouri Tel: Co. v. Conwell, 170-F.2d 641 (sth hi
1 eee eal aie co per :
* Cremnoezalowski vo Q. O. Ordna) ance Corp., 12 2 w if C ases 469,
65 A.b.C. 612 (April, 1953). «........3 =... ED TI eet IE
De Ganay v¥ Lederer, 250 U.S, 376, 39.8. Ct. 524. ( 1919)..:....::
Galvin v. National Biscuit Co., 82 F. SAPP: 539 (1949)......... Ate
. Maneja v. Waialua Agricultural Co.., 349 U.S. 254, S. Shes
TTR io ee LE Lae at era ee Ae RUIN SEE
Markert v. Swift & Co... 173 F.2d 597° (2d Cir., 1949) 00000000. aie
Martin, Glenn l.., Nebraska C ov € ulkin, 197 F ws (sth os
Cir., was see a i a ee Peet ern Mad sats ee So 2
MeComb a A. Swanson & Sons, 77 F. ONee 3 116 ef D. Neb..
Mite he i y. Southeastern’ Ci arbon Lager Co., 12 WH Cases 559,
(S5- AL.C. SIL (Sone, 955)... SRS. ta" eae S reat
ee mie
Packard Motor Car Co. v. N.LLR.B., 330 U.S, 485. 67 S. Ct.
'. 789 aap) ok. Setter EMS. ER ato Sa Peat NO
.* x %
Smith vi Cleveland Pneumatie Tool. Co.. 17s F.2d 77:
‘Cir 1949) 7 SE RE ere ot rene oaks
Smith v. Cudahy. Packing Co.. 76 F. Site: 575. aD. Mins
| 7S ae castle Aenean Aad SAE Taher APL eae PERN FSP MENS, APC RE
=a
St
—,
>)
—
—
~
. ed ° : cad + ~ ; i!
Steiner v. Mitchell, 2725 F.2d 171....... EAMES ACERS |
Stock, F. W. & Sons vo Thompson, 194 F.2d 493 (6th Cir.
SOS 3 ec a sae be ie tncts or SOBA Sa Pe Stl
United States vw Missouri Pace. am Co.. 278 US. 269, 49 ‘si Ct.
OE CRON pana, caine saat hea a a
United States Steel @o. v. Burkett, 192-F. 2d 4189 (4th Cir.,
eae Vela ahs Gphaen diet bbb Ranbexcsee iets
Se eines . >.
oa
44
CraATIONG . = - esa il
a. ee STATUTES cae ' | .Pages
‘Pair Labor Standards Amendments of 149. e. TSR, 63. Stat.
~ 9104 (29 US.C, 201, et seg.) : \6
ales rey. Ge itn oa ea Oa Ness ee. oe
‘ Sf, \ - . ‘ safer 7 9)
. Bee. 2 eee: PTE DT AAP PME HAN) SIS TOs AE AE DOES venigedenunce ene i ao.
Federal Rules ef Civil Procedure, 28 Us.C.A.- Rule 52 Sagile be 1S
9 ae
" Portal-to-Portal Aet of 1047, <. we. 61 Stat. 84 (29 U.S.C, 2k
et segy) : : .
AS aE AS soa Gutantlecoeie tide erodes inemedeseaaieie athe Bee ee ae 6. 17, 24
Dini ee 2 reo a eo 6p arena can ye cnensosveonnatendeaRnkeeterevens 17
93 Cong, Ree: . Meee ts, |
PT ES ee a ae Birra hana Nae Ty aOR / Sid Les Aes lye 14
=k, Nee iat Bag ra cree Pe a AE aR UNISON ed isbe a *
oS ~ RSP” eesit DOLNER ES oa cig Se 8 a ; :: > 24
eee ee eee eee eee eee ee aT)
ee ee eee eee ee ee re. ee reer eo
tg | oe pio
: | Peano a Ege be ME Bieaeecehe ete tobe 24
4269... Sh iene ae RN Re Pt ; - 90
4388-9 Eas 90
ee ead Bee HO eT ONE eT wen saene oise VE Seen Vic mei NAP 24
iv a ys — CITATIONS
*
«
General Statement as to the Effect of the Portal-to-Portul Act.
/ af 1917 on the Farr Laber Standards Act of 1938
‘ ; a |
29 C.F.R.790, 790.7 b), 12-F.R. 7655, 7658.00 ce OW
| a ves ;
29 CF.R. 790.7(h), @FR.7659
29-C.FUR. 790.8(a). 12 FR. 7659-60... ... oe :
S. Rep. No. 48, s0th Cong. Ist Sess... stn ow eae ee
5 x) ‘ i t
3 | |
re |
. : a
¢ , 7 ay ee ee
g aie \ cae ——— - as
is me
| e
a
%
.
.
-
®
. :
-
3
“
» 5
-
aS, ..
5 . |
2
: J
. | |
'
.
<
- 7
| -
| .
Ral oy * : 5 8 cag
s . > : ‘ NA 3
’ Be n ; bs ‘ . .
In the hice, one Court of the
~ United States
Oc TOBE no Pasi: 1955
“+ a8 ak: No. oY
“FAME s PL Mitcue., Secretary of Labor,
United States Department of Labor,
“3 7 Petitioner,
KiNG PacgKinc Company, : bs
nerd Respondént.
ee i
“ se Pee :
On Writ of Certiorari t to the United States Court of hogeals
a a for the Ninth Circuit
Brief for King Packing Company
.
: “,
Se
ue QUESTION PRESENTED
£ 2%; ie a Ry ie ah stata
sec iion 4 ad (2) ol ine rt tai. Act e Neqipts from the iishat
a
oe
um wage and overtime col Apensation require ments of thie
Labor Standards Asi “aay "activities * ‘preliminary fo or
postlimin: iv to” the & hmployee’ s principal activity: | Ddcs this
exclusion apply mereiy to those pre Jiminaty or postliminary v
activities which are incident! i and unnecessary to the: pr inc ~
pa} activity? - Bias ..
at
‘sarily re
SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF THE CASE.
The record. establishes without contr atic tion Fiat t the
custom for at least thedasf 20.veare at re sspondent’s plant .
has been that the &knifemen appear at work with sharpe
knives, and. that knifemen wre only Combe peated for that
work which Is eareody sik ones and required hy the em-
plover Cts. GO. 153-0 Their rate of comf@nsation Bees=
Hecting . custom is arrived at hy collective
bargaining (PL Ex. 11,°R. j2), The Secretary of Labor
charges that, this long-settled, cus stom is a violation” of the
Labor Standards Act (C qn iplaint, par; VI,R.5). — ;-
This Avr angement, Ww hich has proved nate Lor 20)
years, hal: InCES. the: needs 1 ind preferencds of the knifemen
against ‘those of the en plover. The knifemen liaye different
inethods of sharpening. their knives and prefer to sh: Irpen
aed use their own knives | eXe usive ly 1 | “le. ¥ Hl, R. W363,
mS
fe,
80, 102, 122, 1 1397. As respondent's. production manager
stated: * "LV Jou won't find two inch that sharpen knives
ahke.” (R. 71). *|T]hiey. don’t /want anybody sharpenings
their knives, each -secms to have a Hittle differe nt taste, each.
naan takes a wood deal of pride j in his knife aml he doesn’t.
‘are for anyone to gionkey with it... 2 . {SJome might ike
[the edge on ee knives] feathored, ans) some Like
smooth.” (R. 635. Hf they trade a knife “the Vv shape’ it up 4:
wav they like (R. 63). The testimony of the knifemen
clearly sh 1OWS that they consider the knives thei ir individual”
tools to care for and use J i, tele own way R. bee. 139),
The respondent itself owns more costly knives and so has
an’ emery stone and grinding’ wheel’ in the-plant (Fide. \ iH,
1. “Re ferences to the printed acsip of record filed with this
Court are designated ‘*R.’" Wheneve? in a. series of references a
- semicolon appears, references rer ding the semicolon are te the
findings or opinion-of the trial judge: SHECEE ‘ding references are to
J
the suppor ting evidence
>
R. 17: 48-49, 62-63% 105, 157, 162).*As-a convenic pice the
knifemen com: nonly use this ca sh nt tosharpen their own
“knives (Fdg. VI, R. 17; 48-49, 6268, 105, 157, 162).
Wnife AM rpre ning hy the e qiployees consumes an average
of 104 minutes per day (Pde. XI, RIS: 70). This: tine
varies from day to day and from man to nan. EF he men use
- different numbers of knives frenr day to day. (R. S88, R.110,-
R. 124, R. 481, R. 140, R. 148). Different men performings
different operations will use from 3-to 6 knives ’e day {R.
88, R. 110, Re 124, R. 131, PB. 140, R. 1483. Wnife sharpening
tine for different men varies ebesiis ‘de pending Wpoti their/_
skill —“the better butchers sharpen theik ktives I as litte
as 3 minutes and on down to the poor knife. man and/he
takes as long as. 20) minutes ora half hour "OR. 70, Nef also.
R. 74-75, R. 88, RL 1097110, R.-117, -R. 118, R120, 125,
R. 153, R. 141, Re 142, Ro 14s}. And the tact that ferent
men prefer diffe ‘rent edges will affect the ainount of knife
sharpening time “What One employee wight consider a
sharp ‘edge another might consider “dull? Yes siry that is
right” (R. S80). : | eon Te.
The knifemen are Free’ to sharpen Heir: knives. at ‘any
place, at ‘in ‘tine outside regul: inworking hours, and.in. any
manner or. ‘by avy nite thod the Vv choose (Fdgs. Vil Vins, Be.
Se 62-63, 105, ye 162 }.. opaared diees not specify
7 tlie: dégre ‘eof sharpness: of the sgh r the 4 of edge
‘the Anife should have (Fdg. VIII, ex: Re wt, 196, 169).
Responde nk exercises no dise ony or control whatsoever. .
over the sharpening room or the activities of the kmifemen
~ while they are sharpe fring their knives (Fdg. VET, R.177.
63, 67, 108, 120, 156). De eer ee
On the-basis ef these facts the, Trial Court found1) that
the principal, activity ¢ or activities which the responde nt’S,
-knifemen are employed: to pe form are * the killing, cle: aning ‘\
8
¢
a.
‘and cutting up of careasses of Gattle and hogs, and (2) that
the sharpening of knives by: the knifemen outside their +
regularity séehedtled shift time is jire 1: winary. and postlimi-
nary. to such, principal aetivity or ac fivities which they are
employed to perforny (Fdes. XTL XIV, R18, 19). Corie.
“inenting im tis opinion on-the evidence, supporting these
findings of fact, Jade Healy stated:
“The evidence is that [the khifemen] are » eniployed-
to perform work in the’killing and cutting rooms of the.
- plant in-the slaughter of cattle and boss, and in the |
cleaning and cutting. up of the ‘“arcasses. These are-
their ‘principal a@tivities. The¥ are obviously not em-
yloved to sharpen knives. The knives dre theit own
tools with which the@are required by the terms of their
emplovinent to equip themselves for’ the proper per-
formance ef the work thevare employed to do.” (R. 12)
—
o= *
‘He caceordingly concluded, after finding. further that off-
shift knife sharpening is hot Compensated by contract or
“eustom.in respondent’s plant and is materially different.
from other one rations pe rforiged | during regular working’
hours and customarily compe msated, that the time spent by
employees in sharpening their “knives otitsyde regularly
scheduled shift ‘time is not ccompensable under the Labor
Standards “Aet as modified by the Portal Act (Fdgs. IX,
XT, Conel. VT, R. 17-18; 20). ee
The, decision of the Trial Court was unanimously afiirmed
VWs
by the ourt of Appeais for t ie Ninth Cirenit (RL 49-182).
Jiadge (arr, <peaking for the Court, noted that tee Portal
Act Was passed by Congress subseque ‘nt to the decision in’
Anderson’: Mt. ¢ Ve Wiens Patter ry Co? “with the j purpose in
Mind, among other things, of making non -compensable cer-
tain 4% sopein activities, which the At, Clemens ease had
oe 328.1 S. 680.; 66 S.Ct. 1st +1946)
Pee
*
4 of the Portal Net.
eo. .
hel: to he compe neah jer (RR. 179 as oO aece pt the contention,
of the Seeretir vot] ahr that ails we fivities which are “indis-
pe nsable to the pe ropa ange of productive wo: kv are princi.
_ pal activities white hanust he ¢ ompensated in accordance Ww ith
the. Labor Standatds Aet. would, jie coneluded, “deny effect
to the’ intende dome aning o of thre Portaledo-Portal Act since
=" ull of tlie activities ee ated as ‘preliminary’ hv fhe -Su-
prente Court ‘in the Wt. PMS Case Can he considered
indispensable” (/d.), For ie. ret sons, “and on the basis of
the findings of the Trial Court that the knife sharpening
performed, by respondent's einplovees is in fact pre Jiminary
and postliminary to their principal activities, thaf it is. nat
compensable by contract or eustom, and that it is essentially
different from their evstonn Wily .cotnpens: thle Work, the
Court held that off-shift knife sharpening perfermed by.
responde nt’s employees 4 falls within the exclusion te the
provisions of the Labor Standards Act wreated by Section
> : aoe
: ; .
: ¢
7 ‘SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT |
1. Section 4 of fhe PortalAct expressly exéludes. from
the minimum wage and overtime require ments of therbsahor
Standards Act “any’ "activities “proliminary to or postiini-
nary to” the principal activities Siwhie h suc employee is
employed to perfornte” The statute should he’ construed
-accordingly to exclude the pre-shift Knife sharpe ning in this
(ase, The Portal Act. makes no distinction. hetween indis-
“pensable and dis pe snsable (ice. hetween nec essary’ and wninec
essary?) prelinins wr activities. 7 .
eltisa question’ of fact whether any partionlar ac tivity
i ; pein (or posthininary ) of principal, The Courts
below found on adequate. evidence that the knife sharpening
was preliminary. They also found that the einplovee’s prin-’
is | ! ie J ;
cipal activities were to work inthe killing room and cutting
oe
]
f
al : Ee ss ne
floor, killing’and butchering, and not to work at sharpening
“Knives: in ‘the knife, sharperving’ room, Finally, the facts
found sliow that the knife shiarpe ning Was not Foquired to’
he performed at the pleat and is indispensable only in the,
&
sense that: risit j, eatine and ‘travelling to the plant.are
i menbler” : mee 5 “. ae | cS? 4 i
_ Interpret Uflon. of the pike redording ‘to its common i
ah
sense meaning is also compelled BY its purpose as shown .
_ by Settion 1 of the Act and by its eeiul itive history. Phese
| show thi if Congress intended to prevent: future unexpec seus
claims as well asto deal with the * xisting emergency,
Congress wes not repudiating this purpose sub sllentia in
treating aceraed claims: ‘separately from future ¢liims. We
agree ‘that Section 2 of the Portal. Act- (relating to accrued -
claims} is broader than Section 4 (relating to future claitiy):
It does not follow as neste nded = petitioner, that Section
4 excludes only preliminary activities that are dtispen- rs
sable and unnecessary, Le. not indispe nsable: See tion 2 ex-.
Juded Tiabili tv fir ali non-principal activities ven thi rh
, CEU Ed ! 0 ( » Pay } hg NOUS
they occurree} dhiri ing the shift. Sec ‘tion 4 excludes only non’
(principal Activities oce urr ing hevere or after the shidt: but
" Section 3 excludes all such, non- principal preliginary or’
postliminaay net nv ities, whether.or not indispensable. > -
The Congressional histery affirmatively shows that.’
Seetion. 4 outlaws indispensable (as well.as. dispensable }
prehmingry and postliminary activities. The ‘reds an ahwun-
“dance of authority in ‘the & oneKession: il de hates so showing.
The few quotations taken out of context by pe titioner show
onty thi it Se nator Cooper | loosely used the term ‘indispen-
sable” tocmean “integral.”
a. The 1949 amendiye nts to thie Labor Standards Act do
not impty that the sti vute means anything other than what
° >
it Says. Se ction: 310) Ww as enae ‘ted to establish: that the activi-
‘9 fe ® © 2 ; >?
@ . i ca
.
.
4
;
ties de alt within collect ive Hargaining Contracts. yere not
~ thereby withadrs wn fromm the'exe ‘lusion of/Se re tion 4, Section:
tit (tions jiee’
l6(e) preserves existing ‘adhninistr: itiv¢ hirte npr
ineonsistortl with the statute. Petitionep’s pre st nteinterpres :
tion Is bath inconsiste nt with the sti apt em Wi gneonsiste nt
With. other® inter pretations’ of: the age mp Hen Ad
—nyuistrator.
ARGUMENT) 2. o
i. The baive sharpening: here is included within the nrecnjng of
"any" aciivity preliminary to the employee’ s principal o activi-
ties and so is non-compensable., Dye Sasey
A: THE STATUTE. EXCLUDES ALL PRELIMINARY AGTIVITIES
4,
.
The stativter, is not cbse ure. [at expressly, excludes from
_ the minima wage and ove tine “pay reajlirements “any”
> aetivities whiceare “preliminary to or postlianinary to” the
principal activity or-activities which, the employee is eim-
: a
ploved to perform, The sti tute specifies that the exchided. .
“yreliminary and j sostliminat Oy "ACI vifies ar® those “which
oceur either prior te the time of any? particilar work clay.
at which sue h employee CONMNETICES, or subseque nt to any
particular time af which he ceases such- Prine ipal ac tivity or
activities.” The statute saves ° iything, about “indispensakil-
“)
atv’ rit is not limited to pre Hiinin: ary activities that are jen
pe insable’ “or nnnec essary to the prince cipal activity, Cl fCRTIN
the ne liv ities exclude d by the langui ie: of Section rv mn ee
shumies of 20 ‘contrary contract orcustenyared// those activi-
fies W hie ‘l or “eur hefore or after the activities whieh the'ém-
ployee | Is hired to “porformn.
W hen, as liere , Congress uses words which are-in-coninormt
use Without providing a’special definition, it ix well settled
that these words ta regres: rned to de used in ‘thei ar ordinary
antl usual sense, and with the meaning commonly attribnt-
® - *
,
*¢
be]
a?
Se ai : Y ¢ . . ~ . | “e ‘ sym 70 ‘ ’ .
able ta seer De franay e. Lederer, 250 | ow. 046, 381, 39
8 . O°
S.Ct 524, 525 "(I9199, |
home After, all, legislation When not expressed j In technical -
terms is addressed to! the common run oftimen and ik
therefore to be understood, according to the sense af
the thing, as the ordin; ary Inman has a right to re ‘ly on.
ordinary Words addressed to him.” (4d. ae yt ie
AV Bruii Products. ¢ ozo U.S. 607. ee 64 S.Ct. 4215.
1221 (1944).), i ite
4
This C ourt in the Mt. Clemens Pottery. Ca, case specifi-
eally vehi araeserized * “she arpening tools”, as “preliminary”, :
BLS ULS. G80, 693, GOS. Ct. LEST, 1195 (1946). T&e Court in
Markert vs, Swift € Cq,.173 F.2d. 517, 520 4 2d Cir: 1949)
destribed tlie repairing or preparing tools of pac king house
employees for Use, as preliminary. anil postliminary ‘activi-
hes. The Court in Smith v. Cudahy Pachi glo: TOF. Supp.
Dee HTT (DD,
mdb Fag
Minn. 1947) deseribed as “prelimimary to. the
calls sad printipal activity” “sharpé ning knives’ and loing
; simile ir thi nes necessary te nite éarrying cut of [the em-
e
plovees’ ‘| work.” q .% % : 7
: : aA
This usage. accords with the yWre ‘aning fiven in Webster's’
New International Dic ‘tronary. which de fines: “preliminary” !
a6* hreceding the mi lin business, is “Prefatory,' “prepara-
tory,’
Judes Healey, found the knife sharpe ning in this cake to.
bea preliminary or postliininary activity, (TF ‘de. NIV, R: 19)
and Judges Orr, Pope and Y ankwich sitting as the Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Cireuit agreed, Surely the Trial.
Court in this case was entitled to. attribute &@ meaning to
‘preliminary: and* postiiminary” which accords with that
mrven ina standard dictionary‘and the Hsace of 16 members
of the federal Judici inary, a se 3
” Simil: nels, Congress, did not, in enacting the Portal Act,
det} ne the phre ase “prince pal activity or activities, whieh
Femplovecs are employed to perform.” Thowever, as was-
pointed out in MeComb 4. OC. A. Swanson & Sons, 77 Fo Supp.-
716, 731 (D. Neb 1948): ae
“Those words aredtiot abstruse, obscure or tincertain,
They refer ‘to the productive work in hehatt of the
employer Which he hires tlie worker tof do. Fer the
mnachimist, it is the w ork aut His hench or lathe: for the
store clerk, the sale of woods: for the carpenter the
labor in the erection or repair Of a: ‘building, And for
poultry eviscerator, it is the task to which he or she is
assigned in the eviscerating raom, be it the hanging of
birds, decapitation, dise mboweling, cleaning the requ:
Or any one or more the muluitude of operations Mm HES
room’s serviees, sa Se . oak
‘ ” ai
In this case, ee Work which “the e miplove a hires the worke ae
ix) do” as the Trial Judge found, | is the * ‘killing, cle aning and
cutting up of carcasses of cattle and hogs” (F ‘dg. XTH, I.
IS), and not any preparatory ae Aivittes the VOM he re 4) aired
—F
to do. Neither Record nor Findings Support the govern-
3
ment’s constant assertion of indispensability, True, the
knife niust be sharps But it ix not at all indispensable that
it be shar pe med at the plant or under the control of the Com-.-
pany, Moreover, the record affirmatively shows that the
sharpening is done at the plant only.in part and as a con-’
venience, not.as a requirement (Fdgs. VII, VII. R. 17).
Phusy the knife sharpening APas, indispensable solely in the
“Th
sense that rising, eating and-travelling to work were indis-
pensable, 8.
e
mes
G
B. “THE TRIAL CoOuRT'S. FINDINGS, SUPPORTED BY EVIDENCE - AND
10
AFFIRMED 8Y A UNANIMOUS COURT PF APPEALS, ARE CONCLUSIVE.
avery federal court whieh has hi: ud occasion to de ‘tertiine
eases particular preliminary o1 * postliminary activities
‘are
Portal Act has agreed that the question of what are the:
“pr
Porn
Within the exe ladian created by Section 4iad(2) of the
neipabaetivities” whie h emplovees are cin} loved TO per-
6
7 is, of nece Ssity, one of Paet th he resolved by the. 4% rial
Feces on the basis of the Cle tunstances in each indivi iduz i!
enke,
WQ,
Sim
Wil
Cire
As the Miehth Circuit pointed out in. ¢ id MitaT Dole, ri
a Ordnance Corp., 12 Wd Cases 469, De usin Ghz.
. 614-6745 | April 20, 1995).:. ray!
“Phe fact that the aren embraced within the term‘ prin-
‘cipal activity’ was not precisely defined hy Congress
necessariky re cndice in a relegation of the question to
the courts under facts peculi: ar to each case, ap plving
the general principles: laid down by Congress,
Whether a preliminary or postliminary activity, neces- |
sary.to. the performance of thesprincipal activ itv’ is an
Intexral | is of the principal activity is a question of
Pact to Ss determined from all the, re cle ‘vant evidence.”
& : ec aoe ;
larly, in Mitchell v. ‘Seathen sforn Carban Paper Co., 12:
Cases 19, 55 ALAC. 891, 894 thane 88, 1.955) the hitth |
‘uit cone Auded :
“Just as the Supreme Court stated in the Portal-to-
Portal, causes that a dete TmugyIon of whether clothes
‘anging and walking time, and like activities, were,
‘
prior to he enactment of the Portal-to-Portal Aet .
within the work week and thus ¢ ee Was a ques-
tn)
Cire
tion.of fact, so here the dete rinination as to whether the
sine activities are within the term * sade activities’
is one of faet.”’. Lie Se a ?
-
Sterne? r, Mitche i, now before this Court the Sixth
.
uit also recognized that the question of whether activi-’
; ep) ce eae e:
ties are “Principal” activities which employees a re eniploved
to perform is. necessarily dependent on the facts of each
individ ue case. Thus the {‘ourt stated (215 Pivd til at .
972) : es | |
“The use of the plirnse ‘principal acuivity oF activities’
in the Statute siiggests that the word ‘principal’ in some
situations, may apply to amore than a, single type of
activity, but, in view of the creat variety of industrial
conditions and various types of industries throughout
the nation, it wi as obviowisly not practic ‘able for the are a
embraced by the wofds ‘principal activ ity or aetivities’
to be preefsely de tined or marked out. Phe SCOpe Or.
-reach of the phrase was left tagbe measured by the facts
- tind cire umistance s involved in each indus try,” .
Inv the Ge veral Statement as hy the Eff etal ihe: Paradies:
Portal Act of IY 7 on the Fair Labor Standards Act of 193s
29 CFR. 790, 790.7 (b), 12/P.R 7653, 7058, the Admunistra-
tor stated: : ; oe
“No categorjeal jist ‘off ‘preliminary’ and *postliminary’
activities except those named -in fhe act can be made,
since activities which uader one set of .cireutustances
may be ‘preliminary’ or ‘postliniinary’saetivities, may:
under other conditions be ‘principal’ ak: tivities.”
Reiterating at ‘another point.in this ica Mone ae “an
activity which is a “preliminary” or “postliminary’ activity
sunder one set of circumstances’ may be a principal aetiValy
“under other conditions”, the Administrator gave as an iNus-
tration the following example:
WwW aiting before ‘the time established for the commence:
qent of work -would be regarded as a prelimin way
activity when the employee voluntarily arrives at his.
place of employment-earlier than he is ei ither re quired:
or expected to arrive, Where, however, an employee is
required hy his employer to report ata particular hour’
x
o%
12.
at his workhe twhor other place@vliere he pe for ix Jiis
it prine bpd ae tivity, ‘if the tense eis thereat that hour
CS aaa
Bs or ree Ady and willing to work hut for SOLE: hgason hevond
his contre! there is no work for him to perform until
some time has elapsed, waiting for work would be an
integral pant of the e iplovee's principal activ ities. The
diiference in the we situ tions is that In the second the
eniployee Vas eng fea tow: ait while in the first the
be ie waited to be ¢ ngage a; 29 Crk. TIO.T EL),
~ ie a. O09, : : Pe. +
These statements are In. strange contrast to the present
fosition of petitioner. Petitioner now contends that the
findings of the. Tri al Judge as to the grincipal activi
must be overturned, though admittedly supported by com.
petent evidence. ye the cireumstances of the inst: int case
bear a striking rese anblance to the example set forth above
ef the emplovee whe is “waiting ta hee won d°) Respond-
ent’s knifemen own their own knives and theinay sharpen
thei in any place, at any time,cand-in any manner they
choose. Respondent does not ‘require the knifemen ‘to he
oF jhy sic: iy present on its premises while the ‘woshe ar pon their
knives: and dacs nog specify the length of tine awhielr the
knifemen may spend in that operation. (See p..3 supra),
When the knifemen are using respondent’s equipment and
premises to sharpen their knives, they are.in the language
of the Administrator's example, “preparing-to he engaged’;
they are not “engaged to prepare’ ‘for their principal activi-
tes on the production lint..
* Albauthorities thus point to the conclusion that the task °
of delineating the “priweipal activit ie og” which particular
employees are employed to perform is essentially a question
facet dependent on the éireinstances of edch individual
case, The Trial Pudge in this case has found tha ' respond
ent's s km femie i} “are employed to perform productive work
13
on the ki ling floor and in the cutting room of responde nt’s
plant (supra, pp. 3-4); Fime spent in sharpening their’
knives is preparatory to and not one of thesrincipal activi-.
fies whic: respondé nt employs them to perfony (supra,
‘p. +). ? a ;
These findings of the ‘Trial Judze are, as the Court of
Appeals Tecognized, amply =rpported, hy the evide nee and
must therefore be acce ‘pted-as final. Ped, Rules of Civ i] Pro-
cedure, 28 U.S.C A. Rule a2. |
¢
°
¢
Al. The petitioner's argument that "principal activities" includes
/ indispensable activities” is without foundation. Petitioner's
_ construction would bring back the conditions sought to be
remedied by the Fortal Act.. :
The petitioner would have this Court believe that his eon. -
elusion is compelled by (1) the fect that the Portal Aet
treats past and future claims differently, (2) the legislative
‘history of the Act, and (3) subsequent ¢ Une nde ‘nts to the
Labor Standards Net. owner. the: pe titioner’s arguinent
disregards the purpose hehind the different treatment of
past.and future claims, would defeat the very purpose for
Which the Portal Act-was enacted, and is supported only by”
a few out-of-context: quotations from the history of tlre
Portal Act in Congress. = |
'
—
Ad | . bs - 7
ne = P
A. PETITIONER'S CONTENTION THAT PAST AND FUTURE "CLAIMS ARE
TREATED DIFFERENTLY IN THE STATUTE, WITH WHICH WE AGREE,
DOES NOT SUPPORT HIS CONCLUSION THAT ONLY UNNECESSARY |
ACTIVITIES ARE EXCLUDED. %
_ The Secretary, of Labor correetly stated that Section 2
Jof the Portal Act reliéyes an emploéyer from lability “On
saccount of aay activity” unless: the compoensability of such
activity had been fixed hy an express provision of contract
er by anestah lishe d custom. We agree that the exclusionary
standard of Section 9 ix. broader than that of Seetion 4. The
difference between Sections 2 and 4+ was repeatedly ex-
plained in Congress?
“The House bill bans all portal-to- ports ‘ claimas, past.
and future, re watdless: of whethersiuch ¢ Jaims are based
on netivities oshieh oceurred durmg’ the ‘workday!
‘whistle to o whistle’, The Senate uses this approach only |
ow. to past claims, As to future claims, however, activities
33 occurring w ithi in the ‘whist to whistle’ perrod are not
SAS affected | bs the Senate bill. Such activities are per-
initted to be treated.as they. have heen, under the Fair
Labor Standards Net. All activities,-preliminary to or
postlimuinary to the whistle-te-whistlet period are made
nogeonipensable, unless by custom’ or contract.” 93
Cong. Ree, 2084. | |
_Sen&tor Donnell, one 6f the members of the’ Subconnnittee
oft the Senate Committeeon the Judiciary Which drafted the
Portal Act’, had the saine understanding :
rie es ee ’ { .v ye SS +] . . ae : we
INOW Wer We collie to Une butiure Mier is ‘ure a ail-
+ ferent picture. Here we reaiize that it is: inyportant: that
the employe S. anid the emplovers-inay, soe far as pos-
sible, he oe fron the possibility of-injustice through-
out the romnlar werkingday “period, the.time from the
3. “Senators Donnell, Cooper and Eastland were the members of
the Stuibeomimitte> of the Conunittee on the Judiciary ‘which con-
ducted hearmes on the measure (98 Cong. ee e, 2124) and formue®
- lated the Senate version (93 Cong. Ree, 2131, 93°C ‘ong. Ree, 2293)
-
4
aaa 2 | % 15 | : : se :
whistle in the morning to the time of the whistle in the
- afternoon. Therefore we are not undertaking to legis-
late in Part [1-as to the workday proper; but we are
legislating solely with respect to the preliminary activi-
ties, before the beginning of the workday, and the post-
liminary activities, after the conchision of the workday,
the two classes of ¢laims with respeet to which this past
unce rtainty. has arisen in our economy. . . 27 98 Cong.
Ree. 2181. |
“It is also true that Part [ll which relates to future
claims, does not legislate with respect to the period of
the w orkday proper, -as .undersieed in-seemimaon par ~
~ Jane@793 C ong. Ree. 2182
° : @
‘The Coprts have construed Seetion > to allow: TECOVE rv
» for principal activities performed off-shift*. But this does
not imply that Section 4+ must exclude only those. activities
not “indispensable” to thetperformkneé of the employee's
principal activities. The essential ditference between .Sec-
tions ° and 4 is that Section 2 e xcludes incidental activities
performed on or off shift if there is no cus stom or contract
making such activity compensable’. *
Similarly, the treatment of pre. -1947 and post- 1947 claims
~ differently in other seetions of the Statute. does not illumi-
nate. this problem, Section 3 (See Pet. br. pp. BOY which
provided that past claims could he compromised or waived,
was inserted: te provide..s some relief as to past claims shoul {
og . 3
| :
fe Glean LoMartin Nebraska Co. vo Culkin’ 197 BF 2d G81 (8th
Cir. 1952); Central Missourt. Tel. Co, v. Conwell, 170-F22d 641
(8th Cir. 1948); United States Steel Co. 1. Burkett, 192 F 2489
(4th Cir., 1951): -F. IW. Stock & Sons v. Thompson. 194 F.2d .495
(6th Cir., 1952). re Sea ie
5: Smith wv. Cleveland Pneumatig ‘Tool. Co., 173 F.2d 775 (Oth
Cir.,1949).- = Sake ;
ond
ow
, vent such an eme reney from arising mn the future. i
“affected w age aibhmmspestiants,
ee
‘the courts dee ‘la tre Section 2 time onatitutional.' " Section U (see
Pet. br. pp. 37-38) allows emplovers to claim as a ood. faith
defense the rulings, recul: itions, orders, - Approve al or. inter:
pretation of any agency of the U nited State 's only for pre-
1947 claims. During’ the period -inunediately preceding
thetenactment of PF the Portal. Act the Pubjic Contracts’ Ad.
Ininistrator, the Maritime Commissioner, the War Shipping
Ad diinistration, thle Salary Stabilization Unit of the Treas:
uty Departivent, the War Labor Board and the. Interstate
_ Commerce Cointnission fiad all issued inter rpret: ations whieh
i.
a a *.
It as clear that there is nothing in the statute to"indieate
that Section + Jneans ant more or’ans Jess ‘than it says. The
other: pertinent seétions of the Portal Act rather confirm
. ‘ a o
that the conuion senye interpretation of Section 4avas the
one Congress intended. Contrary to the inplication of peti-
No
‘tioner’s brief, the Congressianal purpose In, enacting ie
Portal, Net was not limited tothe “existing eme ke ney
Whic hhad arisen as the result of the creat munber of ¢ Jains
whieh had-been filed prior to its caactiment-(Pet. br. p. 10).
Just as Section 2 of the: Portal Act was de ues to meet
the vexisting emergency’, so Section 4 was designed to pre.
=
Tn Section J of the Port: Act ongress found tinat if th the
Labor St andi irds Act continued to be inter pre ted jin accord.
anee with the
Wne certainty on the part of ‘nai try, mb employer and em-
, over, as to the financial condition of productive estabhish-
ments...” anplovees would receive windfall payme nts,
including liquidated. damages , Of sums for activities per-
¢ Fr
6, 93 (* ona: Ree. 2911S enator Donnell)
| 17
formed by the an without any expeetation of re esiard heyond
tht it ine Auded in theiragreed rates of$pay’, ‘and “there would
; OCCU the promotion of me TEASING ‘de mands for payment to:
employees for “engaging in- activities no cemperisation for
which had been contemplate ‘d by either the e mploye ror eM
plovee at the tine they were engaged in” (Section 1(a),
" emphasis added). :
To say. that See tion 4 was ‘designed to make noncompen-
kab le only. those preliminary and postliminary activities
whic hare une eossat y ta the perform: ANCE of the employees’
- principal activities is to’nullify the purpose for which the
statute was enac ted, as expressly stated in thot’ ongressjom ul
F indings of Fact and Declarations of Policy’ (Sectiog 1).
Moreover, the legislative history of the. Act, upon whiely the
Secretary iotucanally relies, even if it were proper. -to use
( ‘ongressional debates and reports to mullify the words of
the statute as enacted,’ does not Support the » petitione r’s
contention. - Pe ete : ; iat
7. ‘But where the language of an enactment is clear, atid eon-
struction aecording to its terms does not leat to-absurd or im-
practicable conseqhences, the® words employed are to be taken, as
the final expresston’ of the nteaning intended. And in such cases
legMlative history may not be used to support a construetion that
Tdds to or takes from the significance of the words Segtghapl
_ (Vnited States v. “Missouri Pac, R.-Co., 278 US. QAY, 278, 49 8.6
133. 186 (1929))2 See, also, Packard Motor Car Ca, vy N LEB. 330
U.S. 485, 492, 67 S.Ct. 789.793 (S47). :
1s
|B. THE HISTORY" OF TH PORTAL ACT IN CONGRESS SHOWS THAT
CONGRESS INTENDED SECTION 4 TO PRECLUDE CLAIMS LIKE THOSE
INVOLVED IN THE MT. CLEMENS! ‘ apidonsakd CO. CASE AND HERE. |
The Senate Re port accompany ng the Portal Aet eonthinis
that Congress was attempting to_ overrule the JW1, Clemens
“decisien, not extend it. This re port gives as ex: unples of non-
compensable: ¢ tivity. “[e|hecking i In or out and Waiting in. -
line ta dé so, chi inging chothes, washing up or showering,
waiting in line to receive pay checks, and, the performance
of other ac tivities océurring prior and subsequest to’ the
workday,’ such as the ‘preliminary activities which were:
involved in the Mt. Clemen’s case” tS. Rep. No. 48. 0th’
Cong., Ist Sess. p. 47). Following this, the Report states
that, “principal activity: or activities’ includes ‘all activities -
Which are an, integral’ part thereof, as lustrated by” the
examples of.dtie lathe \oper: ator who, mist pe form, inainte-
“nance work on his machine and the. garment worker who.
must come before the other employees te lay out work and
ready machines for Oper ration, These ex: anples, the Seere-
tary feels, “pe rfecthy dese vibe the case at bar’ (P et, br., p.
22). In the case of “tool shar pening” he weuld disregard the
cnany d lifferences between thie knifeanen in this case, and the
lathe operator inthe Sen: ite Report. He attaches no signifi-
eanee to the facts that the knives, mn contrast to the lathe,
helong to the employees (I ‘dg. VI, Re iG): that they can use
thein for whatever private purposes they choose. (F dg. VI,
R.16),. which naturally affects the amount of sharpening
they need; that they can sharpen their knives at any place,
: at any time outside 1 regular working hours, and in amy inen-
<8. ,*‘Tor purposes of alarity, this report uses the term” workday’
to mean that period of the workday between the commencement hy
‘the employee, and-the tertnination by the « to plovee, of the pring ‘ipal
activity or activities which such employee i is employed to per form.
S. Rept. No, 48, 80th Cong., Ist Sess. pp. sidlidas
&
| - 19. Ke 3
ner or method they choose’ (Fabs. Vil, Vil, It. 17); that.
respende nt does not specify: ‘the Wes of sharpness, the
type of edge or the manner ‘or method to be used in shar pen- |
ing the knives. (Fdg. VIII, R. 17). The petitioner would .
entirely disregard these manifest diffe ‘yences between the
lathe operator and the knifenian in-applying this example i in.
the Senate Report. It is entirely carrect that if: all knife
sharpening in any. industry comes within‘the example con-
tained in the Senate Report above, the word “integral” must .
: : ’ \
he expanded. to mean “indispensable.” But if the example
is_ confined .to workmen who as a part of their ‘principal
activities, must put i time as maintéaance men, the penate
Report does not imply ‘the broad definition of prineipal
activities contended for by petitioner.
Such a test weuld also bé inconsistent with the re ‘tared .
purpose ‘of the Portal jAct as set forth in thg Senate Report.
—*The public interest requires a correction of the condition
now presented hy the portal-to-portal claims, including those
in pending suits and safeguards against. futur. re petition of
such a condition” (S. Rep, No. 48, SOth Cong., Ist Sess., p.
“oe The test in the, Mtg lemens case, which ee was
-attempting to repudiate, was much narrower tha inclusion
of everything “indispe ‘ngable” to the performance of a prin-
cipal activity. Justice Marphy in Mt. Clemens at least eon:
fined the period of work tw the time “an employee is neces-
sarily required to be on the employer's premises, qn duty or
at a Spreseribed work place” and “exertion of a physical
nature, controlled or required hy the: employer and pursued
necessarily and primarily for the employer's benefit” (528
PS. at 691, 693, 66S. Ct. at 1194,.1195)! Any activity which.
is necessary for the worker to pertorm his job, may he con-
sidered ‘indispéensah » the performance of a principal &
°
20
activity but is not ipso fdeto an “integral part of the prin-
°
cipal activity.” ~ See ae.
Of course, we are not arguing that $f neress intended to
make the activities Which were involved in the Wt-Clemens
“case non- “CQMpe nse thle under all C inc aunistances: (ee Pet. br.,
p. 23). But Congress did make non- -COnIpe nsable, activities
like those found con ipensatble in the Wt. Clemens case, whe n
pe rformed under like.cire ulstanees, |
The knife sharpening in this case fits both the words, and
theawontext of the Mt. Clemens decision. There is a well-
established seers ‘aking ‘knife sharpening hon-compen-
sfhle (Compare 328 US. at 685). Jt consumes but a skort
time (Cempare 328 Us at O85, O96, G97). Tt is not produe-
tive work (Coinpare 328 U.S, : OST). Lt is mot even. ‘as:
“necessary” as those activities | 1 the Mt. Clemens ease, .—
heeause it need not he done on “the employer’ x premises
(Cotap: ire} OS U Svat GAL, G92, 693), ;
The C Ongre esjonal debates su port only this @ ourt’s Wis-
dom in re fusing to-look aut iol: ited re mi irks In Congress. to
find out what a statute means. In response. to Ne nator
U GOper’s comment whic h petitioner ‘relies’ pan 80 bedtvily
(Pet. brop. 18), Senator Boeke: sti ated: rig :
get the very stronz impression, if ann mistaken
I wish to he corrected, from reading the bill and the
re port, and listening. to the dise ‘ussion, that under the
al inition of portal to pottal activities, unless there
eee, eontr act, written or unwritten, or a custom under
which such activities are compe ‘nsable, all preliminary
and postliminary work. required by an employer is none
compe nsable.” 93 C ‘ong. Ree. Pp. 2350, 3
-¢ 7 .
Senators \ c( ‘arran (Td. at 2945), MeGrath (dd, ‘at 2259),
Thomas (diat 2268), Murray -¢/¢. at 2257), Wiley (/d, at
4969), 16 le ner | Id. at 2297). O'Mahoney (/d. at 2990) and
RPpresents tie Gwynne, one of the Conference ee inacre rs
4
pti 21.
for thie House of if epresentati¥ves dd. al pp. "4388- Gf), plac ed
the same-interpretation ‘on the Portal Act as Senator
Barkley. In th Face of this, the casual remarks. of Senator
Coopér, even though he w as one of the three-man. Subcom.
mittee which drafted thle hill’ do ‘not permit the conclusion .—
that Congress meant “prirtelpal activity” to imelude any-
thing ‘indispe sable” to the per rformance of the principal -
activity. and drastic ally restricting the se Qpe of Section 4.
.-: : $ oe
©. THE 3949 AMENDMENTS TO THE , LABOR STANDARDS act ARE
“IRRELEVANT TO PETITIONER'S INTERPRETATION OF Ls PORTAL ACT.
‘ Section 309) of the. Lahor Standards Net was ad led’ in 3
1949, and excludes from the heurs for which an epployee | iw
empleved any time spent in chawring clothes and w ashing
-at the hegimning or end of each workday w hieh was exe ‘luded
by a collective bargaining contract." The seetiony Was
ment from under-
-
enactedete prevent a very ingenious arg
entting the effdct of the Portal Act.
In Galein v.. Natianal Bisciut C'o:,
BF: Supp. DOO A
collective bargaining contract prov ided that 15 Ininutes of
_ clothes clanging. time would he vompensated for, but. the
employees actually took. more ‘than 15 minutes to change.
It was Argue ‘d that since a contrac 4 provid ided that this actiy-
itv was comppneable, this activity was éxempted from the
operation of the Portal Act and all the time spent. in the
activity should he compe nsated for. The argument did not
succeed in this case. . ks
ee .
9. Sénator Donnell’s remarks’ coneernit ig the éperation. of th
bill on future claims are quoted at pp. 14-14 supra. Senator Eastland:
also implied that future porta!-te-portal claims would be eliminated.
See colloquy between Senators MeGrath and Bastland at 93 Cong.
* Ree. p. 2249.
10. Section 3(07) is reprinted in petitioner's brief, p. 40.
“a
Vv
“ey
os
-.
secne“i So). was directed at fhis type of. aurgunaepit in
reference to Alothes changing and hathiz ng, as the apie
between Represe utatives Herte Y and Iacas. (quoted i its
entirety incthe brief for Petitioner, pp. 27-29, Steiner vr.
: >. > ey 2 x ~
Mitchell, ee 22) shows.’ . /-
See, Lote) of "the Laber St: antigay ee t, which provides. .
that any order, reg nilation or interpretation of the Adminis:
trator of theAWage and -hour Division. or of the Secretary
-of Labor, pursaianit: to, the l abar, siti aes ards ‘Net “Oxce "it to
the extent. that any s such order, “rewuli ition, iriter pretatioar ,
or eerectiient AAG bis inconsistent with’ the provisions, of
His Aet” remains in “¢ feet, 1 doesstiot ard ther petitioner's
pace The | interpretation rehed pon hy ‘Petitioner.
(Pet., br., 26-27) is inconsistent (supra, pp. 13-24). Mi ore.
over, the Petitioner has disregatded other statemenf that
appear in the SAG Jong and confusing statement:
wi he* pr incipal’ ac tivities refer red to in the Statute are.
activities which the emplovee. is *e smployed to perform’:
they de not. include noncompe ndable ‘walkingeriding,
ar ‘traveling’ of the type referred to in Seetion 4 of. the -
2 Act. Several guides to “determine what sineelieais. |
‘principal activities’ were suggestetl in the legis: ative | i
‘debates. One of the members of the conference ¢ onmniit-~
tee stated to the House of Representatives. that ‘the
realities of industrial life,’ rather than arbitrary stand- -
ands ‘areintended to be : applied ih defining the term
“principal activ ityeor activities,” ’ and that tliese words
°- should ‘he interpret ted with due re ‘card to oe neralestab- ..
lished ,compensation practices in the particular in-
dustry or trade?” 29 C.F .R. TM)Sta), 12. P AR. F659- G0.
s
-
‘Using these eriteria, the aetivities of. the knifeme mare not.
compe nsahle. ungler the’ Act:
. .
. ; i ne 0 Pf ;
oi 7m ‘ .
sisi iinaciteineiniondil : : ° ° {
° . o ;
.
2 ae Repr inte: odin Pet. br:, pp. 40-41. .
et ; , i aah bares ' ‘ am Bes
- ‘Congress cannot be) regarded as ratifving this-drastic
‘rainte rpret: ition ‘of the Portal Act merely beeaus: the Ger.”
eral ,¢ ‘ounsel of the “Associated Retail Bakers of America,
W illiam A. Quinlan, submitted. a letter to the Sube ommittec
of the Cominittee en Labor art P ublic We ‘Tare (see v et, br.
pe: ik: ee ak jy @ ;
The situation: i in this Case iS VERS becca fyom that whieh:
ees} Aistate Cons oiios Co. v ~Diuthin, 345), U.S.
13, 73 $ ts 565 (19 >). and | in) Vie v. Waiakua Agricul-
fitral ( 0, DAD US, 2 24,7 cos /719 (1955). In the Alstate
Constriction (0. CASE, the construe oo placed om theswords
production of goods * for comme ree? by the administrators
of the Iabor Standards Act was consonant With: judi¢ial .
‘inte r pretatjons which had not hoe, repudiated by Congrress:
And “| tyhe ne W inter pretation was reported to congress n-
7 comtittees on a number - of occasions. Interested em.
plovers severely critic ined. the Ndimink Te ater’s ch anges,
Specific ae nena nis were “urged to. neutralize tis infer pre as
¢ tation.” (B45 U.S. at 16,7 T3S.Ct. at O67 ). In light of these’
facts, nature@lly it is reasonah le to assume that ¢ ‘ongress |
‘was ratafying the adininist rative interpretation. In Mane jn
ae Waialua AgricadiaraleCompany, | spray) the wWdininis-
trator’ ~ interpret ation Was also changed to confarip~ to
judicial inte upretation of the Act, and. had.ceme to the notic 1
of the subeqminittees of both the House and Nemate which
“were considering amendnie mts tw the Labor Standards Act.
In ‘the instant case, the interpretation was not places Lacedghe fore
the sponsors of the, Portal Act. the C onunittee on the Judi--
ciaryin the House and Senate but before x Subeomuinee-ot
the € ‘ommnittee on Mdueation and Taber in the Senate (See
Pet. br, D., 27). % cee peat
D
.
side mi ation in setting
ee . 24
“f “CONCLUSION
In passing the Portal Act, ‘Congress Wanted to prevent
thie promotion of increasing deriands. fo¥ payment to em-
‘piovees for ongaging in activities no,compensation for whieh
_ the time they were engaged in’ and found lint “the Fair
Laber Standards Att of 1938, as amended, has been inter-
peted judicially W@isregard of long-established custonrs,
ees 7* (| Section I). What, Congress intended ‘to eliminate
were elaims for ‘prepar ntory activity whieh might he con-
sidered work heehuse they henetit the emplover, Dut which
the emplaver does not aaa » he done in a’certain way
halbheen conte mpl ited by the cniplovercor. the emplovee at: |
practices, and contracts betwen employers and émploy- .
or at ans particular time, ind uae hy. long custom and
pr actice have not heen von nensated for,
,
It is easy te hegate Cong. oss’ aetion in passing the Portal
Actyand say that eve rything iIndispens: ble to the perform.
arice of the job is compensable. It is nore diffic ‘ult to formu.
lite now rhkable definition. of ap Ineipal activity “which will
clearly delineste the common sense understandinwof “work”
!
4
Which ought ta he eompensated fody from rreparatory ac-
tivity whieh the: employer ought not tovhe compelled j
clock and:siipervise, T fis is not an instance of thee naployer’ I
not having wW comipensatte for this’ activity, That Es aise
must bir v the lajor ity of the knives they use, that the ‘Vonust
he rephaced re quently, thet amen rust spend. time proe uring
the knives, iat they must spend tine Sharpening the knives,
:*
tha i they | have spent tine aequiring the skills required to +
shar pede, knives and bnteher niet niust, he taken into CONE
the basic Wage rate, The Aimalgamated
‘12. See the ‘statements of Re presenlative Walter, 93 Cone. Ree.
Moe: Senator Donn iT, ‘ad, at besten’ 2119, 2122, 2IS2: Senator
SAtone, id, at Y3GR ~ SCrlator Wine rr, etl at PTay
. ty . re as
. : a
| .
; ere
25
Meat Cutte rs aed B hechor Workinen and ‘King Packing
Compans might have airreed to includ knife sharpening |
time Jn the collective bargaining agre ‘erent . But the union
vand Wing Packing Company delil ierately struck a bargain
which did not melude, knife sharpening Jas compensable
activity.’ This. contract must be. taken as the? workable
arrangement where hy the needs of both employer and em-
plovee are ‘deliberate ly considered and balanced, :
If the pe titloner were to succeed j in this case, Fespor ade mt
would either have ta hire someone to sharpen knives (R.
156), an activ ity whic +h the knifemen prefe r to do themse ves
(Supra, Peo We or Supervise | the activities i 1. the knife._
shi arponing room (R. 156), keep track of lrow mine ‘Hh time the
men actually: spent sharpening their knives, and, shorten
the Silt to aceo vmod: ate knife Sharpe ning tune. 4 The Portal
. Act was designed to guard against such an unforese “on dis-
| ription of the respondent's plant. S,
~~ The respondent respectfully submits fhat the “deci: ni
oof the District Court, affirmed by the Court of Anpe: ils,
should be affirmed here. } pen “
re ; . . “. "
Dated: November 3, 1995
° :
. * ‘
d &
Respectfully subnistted.
a cna : : / a
‘ Wiuiari S, Jorunxston
oe bey Grorce H, JOUNSTON
: 255 Montgom Ory Street
San Franciseo, California
Attorneys for Respondent
a | "King Packing Company
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.