Brief for the Secreatary of Labor — Steiner v. Mitchell
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ax
Opinions below
INDEX
‘Jurisdiction 00...
. - Argument: 4 2 a, ee i
-weeeuites wnivoived .2.-.. 22
Question presented® .
‘Statement. . ay...
‘Introduction and sumypisry
Changing of clothe: 's and taking ‘of shower baths to
guard aguinst- the serious occupational hazards |
inherent in the production of storage’ batteries
are functions integrally and indispemabiy re-°
lated to the: employees”. productive work. They
accordingly constitute’ “principal activities”
“within the meaning. of the Portal-to-Portal Aet.
_— under the Fair Labor -Standards
MR gers k os EE PE EE ee eee
Conclusion. ...... aA ree 5 See ene Ener eet
me CITATIONS:
Cases: 5;
; Alstate: Construction Co. ¥. Durkin. 345 i. <8.
O04 NEA eae AR aD Eee Gree |e ga SN SLs MO Ge Nee ae
Maneja v. Waialigi Agricultural Co., 345 US.
__. SPS. nee: Le OS as eaee i pemet ih
Mitchell v. King Sartell Ce. No. 3a. ‘etober
2erm A965 4, :: ae clear hy gate a Lae
Schweginanu Bros. vy. ¢ alert Distillers Corp: 341
"US. | SS ea Sg ieee eens meat are
Steiner v. Spencer, w4 Senn, sits sala J8Y, ats S.W.
Sa Gay 3 or OE ot ee ves Bee ge el pte oN a
Statutes:
Fair Labor £ Standards. Act of 1938, as amended. c-.
676, 52 Stat. ‘1060: c. 736, 63 Stat. 910 (29...
US.C. 201 ef seq.): b
DS aU ah hos See rye, oe
DM MON ey ei re tee ae
S%@. 15(a9(1) ASTER SORE eure Se ene
; (1)
~
-
‘ r
“ ° ~
~ Rote =
°
jo st it
a«
- “
4389
Seneral Statement .as to.
ee
Statutes—Continaga, ; a. “ s Page
Faiy Labor Standards’ Atnendnyenys of 1949 -(c.. -
#36, 63 Stat. 910, 29 UAC. QOB. et -ség.)
Me Wee ee 17, 18, 20
PR SREP hs A ba View Sew 8 Wee faa
Portal-to-Portal Act: of 1947, ©. 52, 61 Stat. ‘84 }
(29°US.C. 261. ef sé@qg.):
dec ‘Tiar (bs eeteat, 7 LOS hee eee ior
i NG ee 10, #1, 14,15
Bake eee panes aha ek fi vere pas 10, 13,15
Ser: (av) 2s oe: Bee eee rs. 12,18
Sec. »4(a) (2) ie evens pee See Rk 8,18
; es BAM eee ey ce ce eae 18
Bee. SG) 2 Lule anes Wie auh ats eaten 18
PP OP Se ieee ie oe ee le gees 41
. sca GO RARER ETRY LORRI RN ERA Gere il
af cnc S| SE TY EEE Cee ERs Se Co oe 1]
‘Tennessee Code Ann. (Williams, 1934), 1952.
“Supp.: ‘ " «& .
Phe eR ens. hr th cy eee 16,
Reh Is 5 css hele ey ce spate ee. * 7
es NURS iach Clos. OW tat ee ees 7
ee IN a te a Ae Pa 2 ee 7
. Miscellaneous:
93 Cong. Rec. 7 :
9194 REPT ee I Net Es
Cara SP oe een Aan he aR RR RES 7 WwW
OE. 6 Segoe oe eats eee 15
ENE Gu sce ip Aes Ss ab a ae eee 12
Wha) Se a Sel SEE Se NE 12,13
WE he eee eareek eae eui brute, Se ah eta tee oe 12
“pee®
the effect of the Portal-
to-Pegtal Act of 1947 on the Fair Labor Stand-
ards Act of 1938. (29 C.F_R. 790, 12 P R. 7650). .
Hearings before a Subcommittee of the Committee
Pubhie
ist
Labor and.
Sist pp
. 190, 8
on
a e,
. 92, S: 105, §
. 248, and S. 653
Bott Report No 326, 80th Cong.,
Senate Report No. 48, 80th Cong., ‘Ist Sess....
Oi
of
Welfare, United States
Sess., on S. 08, >
lat Sess... :.
“@
Bnthe Supreme Cour of the ited Sites
OeTOBER TERY, T9354
Ny. 22
“Morris STEINER, Harry Licurm AN, ; MITCHELL
MaGip; AND B. B. STEINER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS
(o- PARTNERS oie: BUSINESS “AS CUMBERLAND
SATTERY: MANUFACTURING COMPANY, AND Cum-
BERLAND Battery MANcFACTU RING €¢ ‘OMPANY, ‘A
PARTYERSHI, PETITIONERS
v,
Janes P. MrircHetn, SECRETARY OF LABOR, Unirer
: _ STATES DEPARTMENT OF J.ABOR
Ga e
(ON WRIT. OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED ST:
COURT-OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
Ss
BRIEF FOR THE SECRETARY OF LABOR
?
OPINIONS | BELOW ee a pee ee
The opinion.of thdistriet court’ (R. 218-222) is
reported at 111 F. Supp. 546. The opinion of the
court of appeals (R. 265-272) appears at 215 F. 2d,
E42. , oe
. (i)
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the United States Court of hes:
ees for the Sixth Circuit. was ente ‘red on August
10, 1954. . A petition. for veliearing was denied
without “opinion on September 17, 19: D4, J. “213)..
The petition fora writ of ¢ ertiorari was filed on De-
cember 199-4, and was granted on April 25, 1955 i
(R273). Phe jurisdiction, of this” Court. rests on
(28 US. i 12a4(1),
»-
: : ae
STATUTES INVOLVED? roe .
J
The* ‘pertinerit provisions of the Fair Labor
Standar™s Act of 1938, ¢. 676, 52 Stat. 1060,as
amended by the Fair Labor Standards Amend- é
ments of 1949, ¢, 736, 63 Stat. 910 (29 UW S.C. 201:
et seq.), and of the Portal-to-Portal Act of 1f47, ¢.
02, 61 Stat. 84 (29 U.S.C. 257 ef seq.,.), are set forth
in ‘the appendix to the Government’s briaf in -
e Mitchell y. King Packing Co., No. 39 (to he. a. *gued
with this ROG) |" oe
6 . ——_—_——_
se ory Cee eee ae i
eR PRESENTED
Ww here workers in. a battefy plant must make ex-
‘tensive use of dange “rously caustic and toxie mate-
rials and are compelled by eine umistances, inelud-
ng vital ¢ considerations of lie alth and hygie ne, to
change clothes and to shower in fae ities wehictr >
Poin baer
State law Fequires their employ er to provide, are. |
these “principal,” rather than ‘pr eliminary’’ or +”.
- ¥‘postliminary,” activities within the meaning of
‘We Portal-to-Portal Act, sb that they. must he
#ottrited in measuring thé work- time for which eom-
pensation is i, saeco: by the Fair Labor Standards
Act?
i ‘ : ‘ 3
Z STATEMENT <:
“e te : “ id
er Phe Seeretary iy Loeshor brought this alin te!
¥, enjomn petitioners fron Violating: He ove ‘tine and
} record-keeping retyuire ments of See tions 7 and MW
fe) of the Fair: Labor Standards Act of 1938, rib:
amended, inv the employment off prodiie ‘tion work-
: ers, and from violating Seetion (a) (1) of. the
Acteby making interstate shipments of. the goods
produe ‘od by such workers, hes ;
}> etitioners own and oper rate a plant located
Nashville, Tétinesseé, where, they are engaged i
oo mut eTUPINg automotive-type wee stor age fe Fe
— teries. which, thet sell in inte rstate commerce: AH
of the company’s produe tion employ ees Customar-
Hy work with or near-the varietis chemicals used’
‘in the- ‘plant (fdg. 4, R. 215)... These include Jead
metal, le ad oxide, lead silph ite, lead perdxide, and
me sulphuric acid (ibid.). Some of these are in Hiquied
‘form, Some are WL po nvder form: aid some are slid
ER: 102, 103, 118 . 154, 181-183)-) In the manufeac-
turing process some of the materials go thro 4
various changes (R. 26) and’ give off ‘dangerous -
fumes (R. 47-48, 60, 70,:98-99, 126-12 27 J. Somevare
spilled or dropped and thus become a part. of tht.
“dust in the air (R27. 71, 108, 117, 154). .In general,
_ + the rhemicals permeate the entire plant and eyery-
thing ; and everyone in it (R. 26, 238).
Lead and lead emmpounds are toxie to, human
eings (fag. 6, R. 214). «Thus, regular exposure to
atmosyihe) re containing: as much as 1.5: milligrams
of lead per ten cubie meters is regarded by the medi-
cal profession as hazardons and itvolving the possi-
bility of lead intoxication or lead poisoning (ibid.).
ie B
Lnbatters jlarits, i Is Sahmost Inpossible’* te Keep
lend concentration in the ‘air ‘twithin absolutels
site limits’? (fdg. 7, R. 214), . In petitioners’ pli inh,
dead oxide was on the floor and in the airand on
a
the plates which ner handled” (dist. et. op.
Re 21). Moreover, ‘abnorme il concentrations ae 7
lead have-been discovered in the hodies of some“of
petitioners’ | emploxeos and’ [petitione rs" } imsur-
ance doctor has, recommended thuxt such, employees
; De segregated from their custone try duties’ ’ (fg.
14. R. 2P6; seo'also A. y 2G
3 ‘The: primary ways in whieh lead poisoning is
ae
eomtrae ted are by inhalation and ingestion (i.
Pere
48, O0, De 237). ie., by taking in particles througir
Ahe nese or Aoutiy @ an open Cut er sore, or any athe wr
‘ hady: eavitt (R, 238-239)! The risk is “‘tve ry
great’? (dist. et. op., R. 220) and even exists outside
the plant. beeause the lead dust and_leadfumes,
whie h aye prevale ut in.the' plant, attach themselyos
to the .skin, clothing, and hair of the émptpy “ees”
(ibid.: RR. 246-249). K ven the families of battery
workers mi iy he plae ed in some danger if lead par-
ti Jes are hroug cht home in the workers’ ¢ lothing or
shoes CR. 248-249). te eearte
Sulphuric acid in the plant is also a lineman: It:
is irritating to the Skin and can cause severe burns:
(fdg..5, R. 213-214; dist. ct. op: R. 220). When
the acid eontacts clothing, it cnuses disinteers ation
‘apid deterioration (dist. et. op., R. 220; R. j2-
ae ). Moreover, the effects of sulphuric acid make
the employee more susceptible Than he would other-.
a . .S
While ledd may also be absorbed through the skin, the
danger of becoming poisoned in this manner is slight (R. 48).
“« Oe @
+ 8
ee
* a eed : ae
> > aa ~ .
- ‘
Wise be te coritanination, by Lop dpesacn of lead aud’
leadeompounds | (fdg. 95 ; 4b 914).
Battery manufacturers, including petitioners,
try to mitimize hazards by plant ventilation, but.
a
industrial ‘and medial experts are-in ‘agreenic nt
that ventilation ajonetis not sufficient. to avoid the
- dangers oftlead poisoning (dist. et. op. R. 220).
~ Safe operation.also requires the removal ofcloth--
‘ ¥ . ° 4 r ‘ ; ad e be
jing and showering at the end of the work Heriod
(ibid. also, R. 50-52, 243-245, 258-261).° Aecord-
ingly, in crder to make their plant as safe a place:
to wor kas possible under the cire umstane es and
the reby ine rease thee fficie ne V of its operation, peti-
‘floners liave equipped it.w ith shower facilities and
t boeker room with separate lockers for work and
street clothing. © Also, théy furnish without charge
old Init clean work clothes which the. emplofees
‘wear (R. 175). Eriployees regularly change into.
wor k- “¢ ‘lothes befor e the beginning of the pr odie tive
work period and show er and change back into
street clothes at the end of that period CR. 10, 33-
34). Allof the preduction employees- vho testified
stated that they changed their clothes at the begin-
hing and end of the productive work period, and,
with a 1 single exception, that they: showered * or:
Washed before leaving tle plant CR. 308 +2, 81,
* G4-G5. WS », 119, 128, 146, 156-157). | .
Although’ petitioners have not issued written in
structions requiring: their employees te change ¢
clothes and use the shower facilities that ‘have
. ? The exgeptfon is an pe Viet whe has a wounded foot
_ ang ie fearful “of an infection if he uses a ¢ommon shower.
“This employee’ therefore. bathes at his home, “about five
“blocks” from. the plant. (R. 145- 5-146). <2)
ra
heen made available 4 to them, varivius einplivers:
772, 92, 97, 104,152, 158).
testified that thé poliazit SL er ain had InStYUe ted
them that they ° alldiid to : ike a bath’ CAR. WN,
2c. om, AS and thi uf “he tole l- the: awhole shop a
to pees aR. rh. -132).-* On ‘account. of lead’.
“ Rt. Tha). oN signed statement oft the foreinan 2)
oe ) declared, | Ty the. afternoon the me y are re-
quired isy the comrpangeto take a bath bée ‘aise les ue
oxide might be absorbed Into the ploodstrepm. : fr
protects the company and the e mploy e esboth.” **Se 1,
‘also R. 168-169..172.
The chi inging: of clothes is especially needed by
those who work. w ith sulphi rie acid, because the:
acibeats wearing apparel. Ttis, of course, possible
_for th- employees to work in their own clothes? but,
as one Of them testified, if he did. he ‘might gO
home naked’? (R. 130). Furthermore, the cost of:
providing their awn-work clothing would be pro-
hibitive for the employees CR. 131, 126.7139), ‘sine “*
the acid causes such rapid deterioration that the
clothing sometimes lasts ondy a few. days’ CR. 38,
Fhe changing of clothés@nd showering are at
‘ree ognized part « of tinal Ul liygiene programs
in the stor age “battery industivy (fdg. 8. A. 214).
Moreove rr, a Teinessee statute requires thi Wie
Di, ee every employer shall provide adequate
cand sanitary shower facilities’ when the
workers are exposed to excessive he: ‘to
skein contamination with infectious, irr itatine.
tdxie ‘materials. [‘Tentiessee Code Aun,
Walliams 1954), 1952 Pes = See, 9788, 1 4:
‘[Fdg. 9, R. 214.] — Sar a
<te
h,
ted
te . “ +; P €
* we ,
4.
Pradditions t the Tennessee ve vrhamei. & OM pe Lisa
tion Aet Te tinessee, Code Aan, OW Liars, Ts
1957 Supp. Sees, GS51-GOOT), Which covers, peti-:
fioners, make SY lead polsoning a: compensable
‘oud pational disea: se 4 Neetion 6852 (1) ), In érder
toe omply with this sti nfute,|
wetityone rs ¢ ary V dustr-
ance, unde 4) See tion 6895, to protect, agaitist liabil-
(fd. 10, R.214-215), Thei ‘Ins -insurane e carrier
ase not accept the ISurance - risk if de fond: ants
refused to provide showering aind clothes. changing
‘facilities for their ehiplavees (file 1 Ss ERASER,
69),
i otittone rs cone cededty ile not record Or pay for
the time which their employees spend iii clothes.
-changing aud showering, which’ was found to
amount fy thirty matintes a day‘ éten minutes in
the morning and twenty minutes in the afternoon )
for each engloyee CR, 221). Helding that these
activities “tare made nec essuryv by the natare of
the work + performed.” that they. fulfill mutual
- obligations” between petitione rs and. their em-
splovees, that they “direc ‘dy henefit’’ petitioners in
the operation of. their business, and that the ve are
so closely rel: ited to othe re duties jaerformed hy:
{ petitioners’ } employees as to be an integral part
.
thereof and. ane, therefore,. included among the *
principal activ ities of said employees, ‘ the trial
court ‘concluded that. the time therehy consumed
is nat excluded from coverage by Section, 4 of the
Porta]-te- Portal Act, buf constitutes time worked
within the meaning of the Fair Labor Stand: ards
Act (ronchisions of laay oand 4, R: 16. 217). The
coyrt of-appeals affirme d, likewise helting that. the
te rm ‘principal activity. or activities’’ in Sectinyr
Ne.
Seabees °
~*
? 4 embraces *salk activities whit) h ate an integriil
and indispensable part’ of -< L principal. activity,
CR. 272)-and that. the activities in question fall
within this ategory. gs ae ee
; bs
INTRODUCTION ‘AND SUMMARY = ae
| ‘Petitioners do not challenge the eoncurre fitggind=
ing, of the: courts below that the clothes-c hanging
and s showering activities of the battery, plant em-
ploy ood (men who work with’ or near dangerously
toxig materials) are indispensable to the per form-.
ance “of | productive work ‘and Intesrally related |
thereto, See Pet. Bra p. 832. Basically, it is peti- :
| floners’ position that activities of this desc ription.
fall outside the. convept of. ‘principal activity’
(Portal-to- Pe tal, Act, Section 4(a)(2))° and
hey ond the protec tion of the Fair Laber Standards
Act if ‘they ; wre per formed off the production line
and before fy after ve gular shift Sat This con"
‘teution raises the same issues inv. olved int. Mitchell
v. King Packing C 0., No. 39 (to be argued with this, e
case). cei at? ; <
In the ¢ Governme nt’s brief in No, 39, we de velop
at. some length the following three propositions ;
(1) Under, the Portal-te-Portal Act's
criteria relating to future (post- 1947) liability,
_ activities performed off shift are Sompemne vic:
if they fall within the scope of the employ ees
“principal a¢tivity or activities.” ae
(2) The Jjegislative history - éstablishes the
_ purpose of Congress to a eompensation
for activities which are a tegral part of the
employee's principal ea hether sue by activ oS
ities are pertornied before, during, /or atter the ;
scheduled workday: ee
ow
foes | wae
< ee,
. ’ "Se
. ° .
So ee The 1949 Amendments to ‘the Fair
Labor Standards Aet<contirm the coneltisioy
that Section, 4 of thes Portal- to- Portal Net did
rot exclude -f fret CAVE rage All activities pa
Ae formed utside the ours spent on the produy
ee
tia dine. Aas | City @ : . ds
¢
In the instant brief, we-'do not repeat, if ertense,
the arguments in support of these prepositions brit
briefly restate them With a view to emphasraing
their partic ular: ap 1s ication to the established facts
“and. -circumstane es of thie case at bye, ‘We em-.
* phiuisize partienlarl: that the: sponsors Y the
Portal. -ty-Portal Act eXpressed the ir intention to
cover clothes chi anging and showe ring-when, as in
the case of chemical plant emphytees, such activi-
ties are. indispe tisable to. produc aie work. | We ass.
point ot, mn respouse to petitioners’ contentions
conce ring Section 360), added in. 1949, that. this -
section, which deals in terms with clothes chang:
ing and showering. is necessarily premised pol.
th assumption that such activities may fall. Within
tlre seOpe of. the rats ih s-prineipal “aetivity.
« o
© s z 4 ‘ N
~ oo . ’
& ARS 3UMENT 3
Anite of . Clothes: and Taking of Shower ‘Baths. to
Guard Against the Serious Occupational Hazards In- - .
herent in the Production of Storage Batteries Are Funic-
tions Integrally and Indisperisably. Related to the, Em-
_ ployees’ Productive Work, ‘They Accordingly, Con-
stitute “Principal Acéivities”, Within the Meaning of.
_ the Portal-to-Portal | Act, Compensable Under the Fair
Lahor. Standards | “Act,
‘
. The thrust of petitioners’ argument is that under
the I artal-to-Portal Act Gnly work on the prodiic -
tion line, ~shoulde be considered a ‘*principal,
a «
i 3 ° 7
a +
ae ae 10 co ie
activity’ and that other activity, even though
functionally or r indispensably related to the pro-
é -duetive process, is, he deemed embraced by the
terms “preliminary.” and ‘nostlimihar vy?" Thei air
ew of the statute is based an the erroneous as-
sumption that Section 4 {dealing with future com-
pensat mn rights and the one involved he re) has the
sames levist ative sweep and me aning as Section 2
(dealing with past compensation rights) (Bro pp.
15-16): The Interpretation at which-they arrive Is
inconsjstent with the language Of the’ Portal to”
Portal. AC and plaitly contyad Yeted by the legis-
dative histar Yoof that Act. aswell aseky the content
got “subseq lent ne ee to the Fair Labor
a Standards Act. >
Criteria under. the Portat. to. Portal Act :—The
Portal. te Portal Act was adopted’ in 1947 pri-
mar ily to meet an **e ‘Misting eme rgency’ resulting
from claims Which, if allowed, would have created’
‘Wholly unexpected liabitities, iame nse in amount,
and Reson peek we in operation.’ See. fa) (h),
29 U.S.C. 251 (a)(b). However r,a sharp distine-
tion must be drawn between the broad excelusionar y
standard adopted in relation to suits for back pay
for alleged pre-Portal-to- Poftal Act violations
(See, 2) and the discrete, more liberal set of criterta
governing future ( (.1.6., post-enactment) rights of
compensation (Sec. 4), i :
The ‘preliminary’? or.** posthininary activities
+ excluded from. future’ coverage by Section 4 are
- only those whi: ‘h fall outside the sv ope of the em-
ployee’ < “principal activity or activities.” Thus.
it lp not decisive, as petitioners urge, that an em-
ployee activity is one required to be performed
butside of 2 regular shift hovirs, If that had been
they purpose AE Congress, it would: Lave oon aes”
simple matter fo saVv so, Thar & ongress ot) use, in:
stead, to exelide- onl thay. which fonds before or
‘after the COMMTENCE ment or te rmingtion of the ene -
ploy Ce Spr Ineipal ac ty ities, i Vesstrony indice ation,
on tlre face of the statute, that the lawim kers were?
well aware that ifm: IY instane es emplorees might -
be required to perforin, before or after regular
hours, work for which they should he « ompensated.,
Ta striking & ontrast, it Should be noted, Congress
pre vided in Sec tion 2. relating fo: Rability for back
pre PMG) pay, that the employer would not he
lalde on Account of any activity unless its % COM.
peusilility. had heen fixed by contract ov estwh-
lished custom, v. 3 ram
‘ Other provisions of the Portal-te-Portal - Act
similarly shotv that Congress, in dealing with the
declared ““exIsing emergency, did nat propose to
alte vy drastiv ally or permanently the future opera-
tion of the F air Labor Standards Act. Note See-
“Stion. 3 and compare ‘it with Section 1: note also
.
t
7. Sec ‘tions Yand 10. And-see the Gover yament's bri iet
"ia 'No. 39. pp. 12-133 eS ee
Mt is thas plain bees the scheme and struetire of
the Portal-to-Portal Act that the broad exe ‘lusion.
QEV St: undaird adopted in relation to past claims is:
not to he carried ver inthe adjudication of « la ig)s
arising ‘subsequie nt to that Act. fice ta
Legislative history. sarge fh “key words" of See-
tion 4 (93-€ ong. Rec. 43 389)}—* principal activity
or activities’’—were delilerately chosen hy Con-
cress with a view to assuring Compensation tor all
employee activitiés which are an. integral part of
the joh, The Senate Re port accompany 1g
12
Portal-fto-| ortal Act ON, Rep. 48, 80th Cong., Ist-
Sess:) declared ( p.- Sf that Ft Jhe term ‘principal
ac tivity or activities” includes all activities which
are an integral part thereof * * *'.* It was re-
peae ‘diy emphasized, by the sponsors of Section
“that in the use of the words ‘ principal’ activity?
we have preseryed to the emplovee the rights ‘and’
the benetits and the. privilegés which have been
given té him under-the F air Lahor Standards Act,
because it isoumopinion. that those activitjes which —
are so closely Fe ‘lated and are an integral part of
pO principal activity, Indispensable to its .per-
. formance, must be included in the tite a of
a>
principal activity
pages 29S, v 300).
—_a—*
(95 Cong, Ree. 2297-; see also
The legislative history tnakes clear that the termi
preliminary’ * and “postlitninary” refer not to’.
activities: Which are iittegrally or indispensably
related to performance of praductive work, but
only to incidental activities similar in nature te
the walking, riding, or- traveling” expressly men-
tioned in Section “4(a) (1) —checking in or outs
waiting in line to receive pay’ cliecks: changing
clothes or “washing upras a matter of convenience,
See. S. Rep. No. 48, supra, p. AT. While, con.
cededhy. clothes changing and showering ne
ordinarily constitnite ‘prelimihary’’ or ‘host
liminary’ * activities, the coiirts below correctly |
.
*"Though the Portal- to-Portal Act had its origin in «a bill:
‘introduced hy Congressman Gwy nne, Section 4, the provision
here involved, was added .bv the Senate. - T hee ovlainal
Cavvnne bill contained no comparable section (H. Rep. 326
80th Cong., Ist Sess.y p. 124. . a hank
nee
“-
~~
e
a St.
held that they may not: he so classified dutomati.
cally and under all circumstances asa matter of law,
W he ‘n, as in the instant case, the clothes eh: mging
and showering are wit: lly and closely related to
the safe and effee tive: performance of the em-
pPlovees” principat work, they are “an “integral
part” of “principal “activity within the letter and’
Intent ef Section 4.) :
One-of the examples of * ‘principal’? aetivities
specifically diseussed in the. debates was the clothes
changing and shawe ring which might he ‘re quired’
of “chemical plant workers.” Tn oa coloquy be
“tween Senator © poper, a sponsor of, the measure,
adi Senator Me (irath, the intent to cover the se
“ne tivities, whet nn Heir performance is necessitated
by the conditions of productive work, was made
perfectly explicit (93 C ong, Ree, 2298):
Mr. MéGrath, There are, inmamerable
stances of ope rations which have to he per-*
formed that are not covered in these two: par-
henlar examples, [ think ‘of one’ at thre mes
ment. Tn certain of-our chemical. pl: Mts work-
ers are required fo put on speeial clothing 2nd
totake off their ¢ lothing at the end,of the wor!
day. and in some ‘of the plants they are 33
quired te te tke shower baths before they le: ve
Does the Senator regard such activity js th wat
as comming within the compensable workday ¢. .
- Mr.-C boper, [am very happy that the Se; hae
tor has asked the que stion, because | believ® it.
vives, the -oppertunity of drawing a firte dlis-
tinetion between the type ‘of achivity whieh Wwe
consider compenpable 3 and the type wh teh
o
3 - 14
should not be compensable. “In accordance
with ourtntention ds to the definition of ‘pri m- -
“etpul activity,” if the employee could not per-
form fis activity without putting On erties
clothes, then the ttme used in changing bute
fhose clothes would be éompensable ts part « af
“Ris principal activ ity. On the other hand,
changing clothes were merely a convenience 2
the emiplovee anil hot-direetly related: to the
scree work, it wound not be considered.a pat
“his principal activity, and it follows that
a time would not he compensable. Em-
? hasis added. |
*
~)
lin: short, while Section 2 was designed,-as one
Senator stated it, to. wipe out pending portal-to-
portal cases so far as ‘humanly possible, Section
4 aimed to cn: irantee the future compensability of
all significant and. productive work integrafly re-
lated to the job. For further examples of work
covered hy the phrase ‘principal activ itv or ae tivi
ties, see the Gove Trament’s brief in No. 39, pp.
* 14-19. .
Senator € “voper’s explanations of the terms used
inSection 4 and his examples of compensable off-
shift activities cannot be brushed aside as ‘easual
statements" (Pet. Br p. 22). As pointed out,
supra Cp. 12, noted), although the Portal-to- Portal
Aet haul its’ origin in a dill introduced by Repre-
sentative Gwynne, Section 4 was added by the Sen-
ate, The original Gwynne bill contained no com."
parable section. “Senator Cooper not only sup-
ported the legialation, as petitioners Fecognize ( Br.
p. 22), but he Was a meyber of a three- -man subeom-
o
os,
mittee of the © omimilttee On the Judiciary which
conducted hearings on the measure (93 Cong: Ree
2124) and formmnlated the Senate version (G2: ong.
Ree 2121, 2293). Senator Cooper, not Representa-
tive Gwynne, is the eeealn to Wham ctwe
[should] look [if | the Meaning of the st: hirtars
words Is In doubt, a Se e Sei wegin fiddl by vos: ¥.€ al-
vert Mistillers Corp, 341 U. i Os, o 94- 395, | ca
It is time that Represent; itive Gwynne stated,
after Section 4 had hee i added hy the Senate, that
amemployver could not: he subjee ted to li: ibility. in
the absence of an agreement or custom, for aetivi
hes preceding © the moment of employment. sueh
asthe laving out of clothing to herworked on bv.
garment workers. Pet. Br.. Pp. 23. But this vein
‘example appears In the Senate Report, Supra, as Ta 7
case Tn which compe nsation would be required. See
the Government's brief. j In No. 39, p. 14.- Here.
agaith it is to be emphasized ¢] vat aa Senate stb. :
committee added Section 4, and that Representa-
tive Cwy nne’s originak hill had ro equivalent. To
the extent that - Representative Ciwynne’s state-
ments suggest that the standards in Sev Chyns? anid --
4 are the same, they are refuted both. by the statue
tory language and by the re peated statements of
those who sponsored Section 4. See the Govern.
Inent’s brief In No. 39. pp, 19-21, , |
Petitioners” battery. plant fits precise iy ‘the.
chemical plant example, which was used by Senator
‘Cooper in explaining when. elothes cha nging and
showering would be an integ ‘al part of a prine ipal
activity. T he manuf icture of wet storage batteries
- involves the extensiv® use of chemicals and chemical]
_ compounds, including caustic sulphurie acid and
; ‘ies eae ee
“o
toxie lead and lead vompaunds It is ace OMY plished
“by dusty proe esses Which: fnake! it atinost dinpassi ble
toe ontrol within absvhitety site Tinavitts {reveoncen- e
tration of head in the plant aitiiysphere, Safe op
eration requires the meyer al of work clothing dnd ’
showering &t the end .of the working period. So
iniportant is it that batter y plant employees ¢ hadige:
out of their work clothes und hb: athe at the end of the
workday that the carrier of petitioners’ workmen's
compehsation insurance would not assume the risk
involved if the necessary facilities for these in-
dispensable precautionary measures Were net pro-
vided. The necessities of the situation are further
“attested hy ‘Tennesse e's statutory réquirenent that
cmployers: in’ petitioners’ classification ~ furnish
shower facilities for their employees. * Thus, the
concurrent tinding that the elothes-changing arid
bathingywctivities of petitioners’ employees are™ ans
integral and indispensable part”? of the production
of batteries (R, 272) was not only. warranted put
e compelled.’ nie , Sa:
The 1940) Amendments: sthe courts DelOw ex-
pressly Tee ‘ognized, the Fair Labor. St; ludards:
Amendments of 1949 “pS the ‘view ‘that the
Poytal-to-Portal Act doés not ‘automatic sally eX-
_clude from coverage all activities performed out
. —
— oe ne gee
°
4 The indispensability of clothes shatadie’ and bathing in a
‘battery plant. is. also’ de monstrated by Steiner v. Spencer, 24
Tenn. App. 389, 145.8. W. 2d 5477a workmen's compensation
case invelving’ petitioners’ plant. .. It is to be noted that one
of the. defenses raised, by these, petitioners in that ease wis’
that the employee ~was guilty of cantributory negligence in
that lie was “eareless about washing the Jead ‘dust from his.
body-’ at the end of the: workday (24 Tenn. App. at 396;
" 145 S. W. 2d ‘at 552). Saastar be
17
side the hours spe nt On the production line, Thus,
Hew Section 360) pov ided that in « omputing hours
of employment “there shall be exeluded any tinie
spent in changing clothes or w ashing at the begin
Jing or end of each workd:; iy which was e ve larded
from measured Working time during iin: week ite.
volved by the e xpress terms of or custom or prac Piie
ander a hona fide ¢ ective-hi argaiming agreement
‘applicable to the particular employee.” he ex--
c lusion, in certain defined circumstances, of clothes
chi inging and showering activities demonstr: utes
that, in other cfrenumstane es, these activities ma
meet the test of compensahility, To suggest othien 2
Wise Is to Suppose that © ONgTess Eni veted aus Chess
und Ineaningless provision in Section 3(o),
Petitioners would have the courts Const rie See
tion 3fo) as indicating that élothes eh; aN “any
showering awe Invariably, within the statutory
, terins “pre limin: ary and * nostlimin: ry’ hat thet,
neve ‘rtheless, these activities WEY, Be vale. dis’
_, —eenmpetisable time bi ee. ‘or practice at the
establishment’? (Pet. Br. p. 38). To change the
inns imbiguenus sti atutory unde ‘shall lie excluded”
to pe titioners* words “may be ine luded"’ ix net to’
const rte the statute but to rewrite it--nind to re-
write it bv going 180 degrees around the circle,
Moreover, sue ho ‘eonstraection’ ip would make
‘ponsense of the statutory scheme.” That scheme
may he recapitulated as follows: f :
o |
- (1) The Pair Labor Standards Aat of 1928
- undertakes to guarantee compensation for all.
swork performed by the émplovee, ie
(2) The Portal-to-Portal Act Of 1947, in
\
° .
*
Tea SNES a
dealing with future liability of the emplover,
‘states im substance. (See. 4(a)) that inciden-
tal, non-productive: activity, not part of the
emptlovee’s) principal) work, néetk, hot, as a
matter of’ statute, he paid: for (though such
activity may, of course, be made subject to
the. requireme nt of ‘compensation hy volun
—taryv-act of the parties expressed in contract
A estabGphed custom, Seats).
aS oy Séction 3(0), added Sy. T9449, declares
“that chothe 's changing and showering may be,
$e éxeluded from Ineasured working time Pure,
stl ant to. ie ‘ehevtive- ne agreement so .
oe providing. 4
_
Ne ites ee
As is evide nt, the only assumption tipon whic ia
Section 3(0), servest a purpose is that the ry
may be clreumstances in which ¢ ‘lothes © hare.
‘ing and. showering j are compe nsable as iv fant:
ter of statutory requireme nt. ¢ certain, there.
Was no need, in 1949, to provid¢ that employers
and employees éould agree to.make’ clothes
vhapging and showering compensable, The
Compe nsability of ae ‘tivities made compensable?
by contract had heen Yully confined, two
years. previously, by Section 4(b) of the Por
tal-to-P ortal Act.
ee ‘ *
.
i
9
“Of eourse, the extent to which. activities, ‘al otherwise
compensable, are made so by contract depends upon the
terths of the contract. Tiras. Section 4(¢) states:
For the purposes of subsection: (b),-an activity sh: a be
considered as compensable under such contrat provision |
or such custom or practice only when it is engaged in
a during the portion of the day with respect tg which it is
- so.made compensable.
ee tee & Ps
s e ’ -
’ Bm
°
= .
ase ee eS
: a
_ The legislative history to which petitioners refer
(Br. , pp. 27-31) does not support their argument.
The nub of. the’ history appears in the flowing
paragraphs (set forth in petitioners’ brief at- p.
28) from a statement by Representative Herter,
f sponsor of the: provision which bec came Sectian
30):
st e os
Let me be specific. In the hakery: industry,
for instance, which is,'75 percent organized,
there are- eollective- bargaining- ‘agreements
- the e country whic ‘h detine ex actly what Is tn
“A
uy
with various lnions—in different sections of.
— ponakiaate a working day. In seme of: those ,
collective- bargaining agreements the time
taken :to. change clothes and to take on the
clothes at the end of the day is conside ‘red i
part of the working day. In other collective ea
bargaining agreements it isnot so conside red.
| But in either gase the matter has been care-
fully threshed out. between the employer and
the employee and apparently- beth are com-
pletely satistied with respect to thei ‘ir bargain-
ing agreements.. oe eS Ces
The difficulty, however, is that suddenly
some. representative of the Department .of —
Lalior may step inte one of those industries
and say, “You have reached a collective-bar-
gaining agreement which. we, dé not approve,
* Henee-the employer must pay. for bark years
the time which everybody had consider “dl was
excluded as part of the working day.’ That
situation may arise at any mément. This
*° amendment is offered merely to prevent, such’
: 20
3 a-sitwation arising and to give sanctity. once,
_again to the collective- bargaining agreements
as being a determining faetor | in finally ad-
judicating that type of. Arrangement. It
sounds wordy, but in efféct it is a very simple
amendment. Sige
It seems s perfectly plain that Representative Her-
ter meant f provide that tlothes changing. and
showering’ might be ereluded from statutory cov-
erage by virtue of a collective- hargaining agree-
ment, notwithstanding the facet that such. activ-
ities. might otherwise he deemed covered.’ in the |
particular circumstances, as being part. of the em- -
' ployee’s pyneipal ‘activity. His express aim was
®; nfford employers and employ eps latitude to deal
by contract with ‘a-.sifuation whieh: might other-
Wise lead to controversy. They “alre “adv chad /au-
thority to inelude; his bill gave. authority. Ao ex-
clude: As stated’ earlier, the legislation presipy-
poses that there thay he cireunistancves in which
clothes changing and showering ee he eempen-
sable under Section 4,
In this light, the Government's position, mn the
- Instant ¢ase is a simple. one. Here, as foung on
the basis of tompelling - evidence, there Were cir-
cumstances showing that clothes: changes er and
showewing are’an integral and. essential. part. of
productive work; and, concededty, there is he gpl
lective hargaining agreement excluding them. thin
“the re quirement of compensation, ea
Petitioners do not: diseuss Section 16(¢ ) of the
1949 - Amendments. That statutory prevision, like
-
“- an ; .
geese
|
new Section 30), confieas the conclusion that
“the Pépfal-to- Portak® Act does. not automatically
e xelude fromycoverage all off-shift.activities, Vhus.
Section 16(¢) declarés that existing adininistra-
tive interpretations, noi inconsistent with the
Améndments, * shall remain in effect.” Outst: id=
ing at thectime was the Adniinistr: ator’s Interpre-
‘tation that certain ‘* preparatory activities, which
the Administrator has always regarded as work
and as compe nsable under the Fair Labor St: ind
ards Act. remain so under the P ortal ‘Act a
Among such activities the Administrator expressly
included Sen: itor Cooper's ex: imiple of necessary
lothes-¢ hanging and bathing’ activities in a éhem-
‘ical plant. See General Stateme nt-as to-the effect
of the Portal-to-Portal Act of 194% ‘on the. Fair
an exception, as obser ved above, nec essarily pre
Labor Stajidards: Aet of 1938, . p.: 13 ( (29 Cc E.R.
790, at 790.8, 12 F.R. 7655). This administrative.
interpretation Was specifically brought to the at-
tention of Congress iit comection ‘With proposed
Section 3(0),% Congiréss made*no change afféct-
ing this interpret ation save for the limited eXcep-
tion from coverage, written into Section 3(o0)-
’
“inised upon the view of. the law expressed in the
inte rpretation. The Administra ter’s interpreta:
tion, thus ratified by Congr ess, retained in fore,
*See letter of William A. Quinlan, Generai Counsel, An-
‘seciated Retail Bakers of America, printed in Hearings be-.
fore a Subcommittee of {the Committee on Labor and Public
-W _— poggmoihe St: niin Senate, 8Ist.Cong., Ist Sess. on S:.
a8, 67,8. 92, . 105 8: 190, S. 28, and 8.643. p- 1173,
at 1195-2170
>
an
ko
firmed.
Section 16¢¢ ).
“Dirkin, 345 U. 13, 16-17:
Ayrie ultural C
.
The | judeme
Oy
a Alstate Construction Cs. vy.’
Maneja vy. Waialua
0. a U. 8. 254, 270, :
* CONCLUSION
o
° >
ut of gest court below: should be af-
: Respectfully submitted,
SIMON KE. SoRELOrr.
Solicitor @eneral.
Rarer: S. SPRITZER,.
as Assistant to. the
enue: General.
Srvart Roruay, - ae ice
. Solicitor,
Bessie Maree
Assistant
/ Attorney,
LIN, fen tape
Solicitor, . Ries eet
-SyLvia S, ELLIson,
‘ . a = ; @.
a Department of Labor.
SEPTEMBER, 1955-
¢
t he.
ES Py
—
-~ —
!
=)
'
i. a
. ” q
s ae
. x ef re
' \
wus GOVERNMENT -FRINTING OFFICE te55
Bese, 376
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.