Appendix to Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — Maneja v. Waialua Agricultural Co.
Supreme Court brief1955
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
in Thi
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1954
. - i>
No. Po. 7. a
Waiatcua AGrmicuLtTurRaL Company, Limitrep, Petitioner
¥.
Cinaco Manisa, eT aL., Respondents
APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CER-
TIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Rurvus G, Poote,
1625 IK Street, No W.
Washington 6, D.C.
LiviNGston JENKS,
Bank of Hawaii Bide.
Honolulu l, TLE.
Mitton CC, Denso
1625 K Street, N. W.
Washington 6, D.C.
Puitie Levy
1625 IK Street, N. W.
Washington 6, D.C.
Ernest C. Moore, Jr
302 Castle & Cooke Bldg.
Honolua, TH.
Attorneys tor Petitioner
—
INDEX
PAGE
OPINION OF UNITED STATES COURT OF AP-
PEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT, DATED
DUE Ts Oe hee eee 1
JUDGMENT OF UNITED STATES COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT,
te FS GE Sap ERE Net smn ea ae oe
OPINION OF UNITED STATES COURT OF AP-
PEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT, DATED
JUNK 24, 1954, UPON PETITION FOR) RE-
EE RS, OSIM Srey, ve 22
ORDER OF UNITED STATES COURT OF AP-
PEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT, DATED
JUNE 24, 1954, DENYING PETITION FOR
MEIN siete in cs co 23
OPINION OF UNITED STATES DISTRICT
COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF HAWALTLI,
ey OF gh Ge |, ob nemesis 24+
OPINION OF UNITED STATES COURT OF AP-
PHKALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT, DATED
FOP Y AP RP EE Ry. WP a cctrcdisnvnceentapintsnicapsseisiccwapnseswcen 9S
* The Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law of the District
Court are printed at pages 190 et seq. and 308 et seq. in the rec-
ord used in the Court of Appeals, nine copies of which have been
filed with the Clerk of this Court pursuant to Rule 21(4).
“y
i
~
i
®
-
_ se
In THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1954
WalaLua AGricutruraL Company, Luairep, Petitioner
Vv.
Crraco Manesa, ET AL., Respondents
e
—_——
APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CER.
TIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
Opinion cf United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit, Dated May 5, 1954
No. 13,114—Opinion—May 5, 1954
Watatva AGricuLturaL Company, LrMiTep, Appellant,
vs.
Ciraco MANeEsA, ET AL., Appellees.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the District of Hawaii
—
efore HEALY, BONE, and FEE, Circuit Judges
)
JAMES ALGER FEF, Circuit Judge:
This case must be reversed for error in approach. Waia-
lua initiated the procedure by petition for declaratory
judgment. The trial court, misled by the nature of the
cause and the attitudes of the parties, decided the wrong
issue.
The status of Waialua was tried out. It was contended
by Waialua that it was engaged in agriculture, and there-
fore all of its employees were exempt from application of
the statute. The trial court, in its first declaration, which
was reversed for lack of findings, and in its present dec-
laration and judgment, took the converse position. It has
held that Wailua, through corporate affiliations, interlock-
ing directorates and factor relationships, was a manufac-
turer of refined sugar on the mainland, and there engaged
in interstate and foreign commerce.’
By agreement of all parties and the Department of La-
bor, that Court finds that all employees of Waialua ex-
cept one group’ “are engaged in commerce or ih the pro-
duction of zoods for commerce.” Therefore, it was con-
cluded that every employee of Waialua on Oahu, Territory
of Hawaii, was subject to the drastic provisions of the Act
for each work week in which he did not spend every em-
ploved hour in an activity such as planting, irrigating,
cultivating, ratooning or cutting and loading ecane.* In
pursuit of the fallacy so induced, the Court refused to
describe each employee who harvested the crop by redue-
1 The trial court found that Waialua does not “directly engage in
any sugar refining operation.” 97 F.Supp. 198, 203.
2This group is composed of employees who perform the work
of repairing and maintaining dwelling houses in the mill village.
These employees the Court found, independently of agreement,
were employed in the production of goods for commerce. 97 F.
Supp. 198, 226-232.
3These activities are particularized by the trial court at 97
F.Supp. 198, 219, paragraph [3].
om)
wv
ing cane to raw sugar and molasses, an operation essen-
tial to its preservation, as an agricultural worker.‘
Thus the trial court did not give effect to the language
of the statute which excludes from its operation anyone
“employed in agriculture’® and defines “agriculture” to
include “farming in all its branches and among other
things * * * the cultivation and tillage of the soil, dairy-
ing, the production, cultivation, growing and harvesting
of any agricultural and horticultural commodities * * *
and any practices * * * performed hy a farmer or ona
farm as an incident to or in conjunction with such farming
operations, including preparation for market, delivery to
storage or to market or to earriers for ‘ransportation to
market.” ®
After a remand upon a previous appeal,” on motion of
Waialua, the International Union was eliminated and its
Secretary, Jack Hall, stricken from the defendants. The
representative character of the original proceeding was
* The trial court, disregarding an express direction of this Court,
allowed the processing exemption, which is beside the point. The
activity was excluded by the terms of the Act. In its previous
opinion, 178 F.2d 603, this Court stated: “Not only was it the
desire to exempt processing as a part of the harvesting done by a
farmer or on a farm, but also processing done by a third party.
These provisions are not alternative or mutually exclusive, and
should be liberally construed for the reasons given by this Court
in McComb vs. Hunt Foods, Inc., 9 Cir., 167 F.2d 905, 908.” (page
609). The processing exemption, 29 U.S.C.A. § 207(c), is directed
primarily toward that “processing done by a third party.” See
also Walling vs. Peacock Corporation, 58 F.Supp. 880, 883; Red-
lands Foothill Groves vs. Jacobs, 30 F.Supp. 995, 1006.
°29 U.S.C.A. § 213(a)(6). “* * the raising and harvesting of
sugar were specifically given consideration by Congress on ac-
count of the immense importance to the ecoromy of this country
as a whole.” Waiaiua Agricultural Company, Limited vs. Maneja,
9 Cir., 178 F.2d 603, 608, paragraph [6-8].
*29 U.S.C.A. § 203(f).
* Waialua Agricultural Company, Limited vs. Maneja, 9 Cir., 178
F.2d 603, cert. den., 339 U.S. 920.
bea
also abandoned. The individual workers, most of whom
Were retainers and dependents of Waialua although union
members, were permitted to file a so-called cross-complaint,
praying for relief in sums of money, and this time several
of these individual employees gave testimony as to the
kind of work each did. None of these devices, adopted to
meet criticism of this Court, changed the fundamental
character of the proceeding. The individual employee
cross-complainants still seem “pawns in this battle of the
demi-gods.” Waialua seems to act to preserve relations
with the Union and a federal bureau, as a policy. Prae-
tically all facts are agreed and, as above noted, constitu-
tional and jurisdictional conclusions as to coverage were
accepted. Thereby, emphasis was placed upon the wrong
problems.’ This conjugation by consent removes the cause
from the class of “eases and controversies” and is an
abuse of declaratory judgment procedure. The only bit-
terly partisan litigant is an executive bureau not named
in the record as a party. Notwithstanding a plain warning
of this Court upon the last appeal that such evidenee was
impertinent to the whole question as to whether the in-
dividual employee was an “agricultural worker,” the par-
ties introduced at this trial and the Court adopted as a
basis for decision two treatises. These were entitled, re-
spectively, “Labor in the Territory of Hawaii, 1959” ° and
“The Economy of Hawaii in 1947,” *° studies made under
the supervision of a department of the government,
—__- -__-_~
8 The suggestion of the trial court in one opinion that the ex-
clusion of agriculture would free farmers from the “oppressive
child labor” provisions of the Act need not be too much regarded.
Such a problem does not exist. And we have come a long way
from sound thinking in America if it be suggested that a farm
boy should not work on a farm. Of course, the bureaucrats could
take much Letter care of him.
® James H. Shoemaker, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, United
States Government Printing Office, 1940.
1° Bulletin No. 926, United States Department of Labor, United
States Government Printing Office, 1948.
~
7]
which, as noted above, took an active pert not only in the
trial court, but on both appeals.
Thus a false issue was created. Instead of concern with
the question of who was employed in agriculture, the at-
tention of the Court was deflected to a consideration of
membership of Waialua in a non-profit sugar refining and
marketing; cooperative ealled “California & Hawaiian
Sugar Refining Corporation, Ltd.”, of California, which
was engaged in the manufacturing business of refining
raw sugar, marketing the product, and transporting the
refined sugar to the consumers.” But all the activities of
the latter were carried on upon the mainland. No one of
_
"A similar contention was made by the Administrator of the
Wage and Hour Division. as a bitterly partisan litigant under the
guise of amicus curiae in Miller Hatcheries, Inc. vs. Boyer, 8 Cir.,
131 F.2d 283, 285, where Judge Johnsen, in an illuminating opin-
ion, held that employees of a commercial hatchery were excluded
because “employed in agriculture.” There the Administrator con-
tended “that the hatching of baby chicks by a commercial hatchery
is an industrialized and highly specialized activity which does not
itself have any direct connection with ‘farming operations’: that
the economic function of such an urban establishment is completely
disassociated from the agricultural activities,” that “thus trans-
posed from a farm to a commercial establishment it ceases to be
a technical farming activity’ and that “the attributes of farm
labor which justify its exclusion * * * ought not to be regarded’
as extending to a commercial operation.
This compares with the contentions of the Administrator here:
“To accomplish its purpose of producing raw sugar, appellait
plainly engages in many separate and distinct enterprises appro-
priate to that end, including manufacturing and transportation, as
well as farming. This integration of business operations neither
conceals the essential nonagricultural character of appellant's
manufacturing functions nor submerges the fact that appellant,
in operating a hybrid type of business, has assumed the functions
of a manufacturer and a railroad company, as well as those of a
farmer. * * * Just as the chain store cannot obtain the retail ex-
emption for its central office and warehouse merely because the
services of those units are restricted to exempt retail outlets, so
here. appellant cannot achieve exemption for its separate manufac-
turing function and its railroad activities simply because it utilizes
them only for the products of its farm.”
6
its employees is here involved. None of the workers of
Waialua was employed by the cooperative.
If the pertinent question of employment in farming had
been considered instead, then the lanzuage of the statute
defining such emplovees would have been civen effect.”
The decisions of this Court bear out the breadth of the
exclusion of agricultural workers. Dofflemyer vs. Na-
tional Labor Relations Board, 9 Cir., 206 F.2d 815 (Judge
Healy) shows that technical distinctions should not be
used to circumscribe the words “farmer” and “farm” as
used in the Act. The necessity for immediate processing
of a farm product is of great force in emphasizing the
scope of the agricultural exclusion, according to Judge
Bone, writing for the majority in MeComb vs. Hunt Foods,
9 Cir, 167 F.2d 905, where the interpretations of three
different district courts in widely separated agricultural
areas of the mainland are followed. There the Court
said:
“*The policy of protection to the growers of “per-
ishable and seasonal fresh fruits” is of as much force
as that of the protection of general industrial workers.
The objective of a uniform rule for hours and wages
in manufacturing should not be allowed to prevail
over the paramount necessity of garnering and pre-
serving fruits and grains when Congress equally ree-
ognized both in the Aet. The hypertechnical reasoning
concerning “exceptions” and “exemptions’’ has no
place here. A direct expression of non-applieability
constitutes neither.’
12 In an interesting case parallel to this in another food supply-
ing industry, the Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit held, in
an able opinion by Judge Maris, that all employees necessary to
carrying on a fishery and fish processing activities were “exempt
by the plain language of Section 13(a)(5) of the Act.” McComb
vs. Consolidated Fisheries Co., 3 Cir., 174 F.2d 74, 78. It should
be marked with red on the margin of this case that the Adminis-
trator was there contending that all employees of a farmer, includ-
ing those engaged in first processing, were excluded by the lan-
guage, but that the exemption to fish processors was much nar-
rower.
“This is but another way of saving that if the busi-
hess operations claimed to be exempt are found to
fall within the exempt classifieation, the statute is, as
to them, a ‘remedial’ statute. We agree With the lower
court that no formalistic characterization should be
permitted in dealing with any of these clauses since
the plain intention of the statute should be earried
out.” (page 906).
The trial court was thus in error in requiring Waialua
to prove beyond peradventure the affirmative of the propo-
sition that each worker was employed in agriculture and
in activities by a farmer and on a farm. By an unwar-
rantedly strict construction, Waialua was required to es-
tablish exemptions beyond a reasonable doubt, as though
it were negativing a jurisdictional proviso in an indict-
ment.
Upon the former appeal, to which reference has been
made, the Court questioned the aptness of the declaratory
proceeding, but remanded because the findings were not
sufficient to support any judgment. The findings before
us are now meticulous and exact as to the hours and type
of work performed by each worker defendant during each
work week in question. However, the trial court failed to
find many vital facets which the record, as we view it,
bears out, and made many findings which are clearly erro-
neous. For these reasons alone, the cause must be re-
versed.
A vital finding contains the implication that sugar cane
ean be stored in Hawaii three or four days without spoil-
ing.’* In fact, a delay of three or four hours is apparently
deleterious, and for best results the cane, after cutting,
should move continuously from field to crushing mill.
1397 F.Supp. 198, 203.
1¢“Sugar cane is highly perishable * * * and starts to deteri-
orate immediately after harvesting. To avoid serious losses, it
must be processed into sugar, syrup or molasses within a few
hours after it has been burned or severed from the ground.”
Stipulation of Fact, Part I, § 4.
8
The Court coneludes that no worker at the erushing mill
is employed in agriculture but is exempt only insofar as
he assists in first processing. If necessity for immediate
treatment tor preservation liad been found, the Court
would have been impelled to find an employee at the rill
Woes engaged ino “harvesting” an agricultural product.
The Court found transportation of cane from fields to cars
was farming, but carrying of cane on cars drawn by a
locomotive from loading points to the mill was “railroad-
ing” and transportation in commerce. Again, the railroad
and its crew performed no other kinds of transportation,
and therefore what each did was “harvesting.’’ The com-
plete operation was vitally necessary to put the crop into
a form in which it would not spoil and, as “raw sugar,”
could be transported to the mainland for manufacturing.
Any activity of any employee which assisted in this opera-
tion, whether furnishing power to the mill or hauling cane
from field to mill, fell within the express word “harvest-
ing’ used in the enactment. Such a finding was not made,
Those which were made were erroneous.
Even if it could have been concluded that these activi-
ties were not “harvesting,” they were nevertheless carried
on by a “farmer.” Furthermore, such activities were
performed “on a farm.” On either of these independent
grounds, workers so employed were excluded by the en-
actment.
But the Court failed to find that Waialua was a farm-
er.” The record and stipulations show conclusively that
15 Employees of a “farmer” who work in or out of a store, trans-
porting, packing and selling plants in connection with a wholesale
and retail outlet located in a city four miles from the “farm” are
held to be employed in agriculture. Walling vs. Rocklin, 8 Cir., 132
F.2d 3. “The raw products were at most being prepared for mar-
ket in connection with the business of producing them.” (page 6).
1* The trial court held, contrary to the stipulations and evidence,
that Waialua “assumed a variety of functions, including those of
farmer, carrier, manufacturer, shipper, and operator of village
communities.” 97 F.Supp. 198, 218.
U
all activities of Waialua upon the island of Oahu were
concerned with growing, cultivating and harvesting sugar
‘ane. Tt should have been found that Waialua was a
farmer, and all workers performing functions for it. on
the plantation were employees of a farmer. It should
have been found that transportation of cane to the mill
and the crushing and drying of the raw sugar therefrom
Were activities performed by a farmer as ineidents to and
in conjunction with farming operations, including harvest-
ing, preparation for market and delivery to storage. Find-
ings of fact which have contrary implications are clearly
erroneous,
The trial court also found neither railroad nor erushing
mill were “on a farm.” ?? The admissions, maps and other
exhibits indicate all the activities of empleyees of Waialua
were carried on within the boundaries of a single parcel
of land described as a “plantation.”
The railroad and the miil’* were located upon a_ plot
of ground and appurtenances all of which were in exclu-
sive possession of Waialua. Practically all the area was
also in its “ownership,” ’ although seme acreage was
leased and one field was connected with the main body by
a right of way for moving its agricultural equipment,
supplies and sugar cane. By far the greater percentage
ef the ground in the area was devoted to raising and har-
vesting of sugar cane in a vear round process as an inte-
—
'? The trial court apparently confines the meaning of the word
“farm” to the fields upon which cane is actually grown, for it is
pointedly said in the opinion, “Obviously cane is not grown on
the right-of-way occupied by the fifty-six miles of permanent main
line railroad track.” 97 F.Supp. 198, 222. Cane probably does not
grow on roads where ox teams hauled cane.
‘* The trial court’s opinion states that the mill was on the plan-
tation. 97 F.Supp. 198, 204.
'’ Discussion of the peculiar land system of Hawaii is not neces-
sary.
lu
grated operation. This situation dictates that the locus
in quo be found to be a “farm.” *°
If then the particular activity of an employee was
neither “cultivation and tillage of the soil’? or “the pro-
duction, growing and harvesting” of this crop, he was
engaged in a practice performed “by a farmer or on a
farm” under the conditions set up in the statute.”
Misled by the apparent wholehearted agreement as to
the constitutional and jurisdictional conclusion regarding
preparation of goods for commerce, the trial court in-
ferred that a worker engaged in any operation or practice
20 National Labor Relations Board vs. John W. Campbell, Inc., 5
Cir., 159 F.2d 184, 187: “The argument that Respondent has 1,000
acres planted in tomatoes and grows packs and markets many car-
loads in a season and, because of ine very nature and size of its
operation, should be held to be engaged in an industrial enterprise
as distinguished from the pastoral pursuits of a farmer, will rot
do. The exemption was not restricted to the forty-acres-and-a-mule
farmer. It is rot measured by the magnitude of his planting nor
in the prolificacy of his harvest. In Larson v. Ives Dairy Co., 5
Cir., 154 F.2d 701, 702, we said: ‘Here, however, there is but a
single enterprise, and that a dairy farm. * * * ‘The size of the
farm, of course, does not matter—it is still a dairy farm.’ Here,
also, the growing, harvesting, packing and selling are all a part of
@ single enterprise.”
21 “Congress, as well as this Court, has recognized that the pack-
ing and preparing of agricultural products for the market is a
necessary incident to any agricultural operation, for no farmer,
dependent upon that which he produces to sustain his operations,
could long exist if he could not market that which he produces, and
so long as the operation of washing, packing, and preparing for
market by the employees of a farmer is on that only which he
has produced on his farm, it is a necessary incident to farming
and is agricultural labor. The wheat farmer must thresh his
wheat; the cane grower must cut his cane and make its juice into
syrup; the cotton grower must gin and bale his cotton; the citrus
grower must pick and pack his oranges; and the tomato grower
must do likewise. So long as these undertakings are in the prepa-
ration and packing by him for market of that which he has grown
on his farm, the labor necessary thereto is agricultural labor.” Na-
tional Labor Relations Board vs. John W. Campbell, Inc., 5 Cir.,
159 F.2d 184, 187 (emphasis added).
Which was considered noy farming by the strictes! classi-
fication was covered by the enactment. We eliphasize
that, if it had been found that reduction of cane to raw
sugar or molasses almost ntmnediateiy after cutting is an
Hinperative necessity, the palpable falsity of such sequela
would have been patent. The integrated operation re-
quired making of repairs on the erushing mill while shut
down for three months for that purpose, the repair and
overhaul of the various machines used in cultivating, cut-
ting and hauling, and the furnishing of power for the
mull, including the hauling and burning of bagasse 2? jn
the furnace thereof.
In order tu show how obviously it was on the wrong
path, it may be observed the trial court concluded em-
ployees assisting in repair and maintenance of houses and
the operation of services and facilities of villages on the
plantation, where some of these agricultural workers lived,
including the street sweeper and those who picked up
wood for cook fires, were engaged in the preparation of
goods for comunerce. In this conclusion, Which even the
Department of Labor does not attempt to defend in its
current argument, the trial court betrays emotional aver-
sion for the semi-feudal relationships whieh still exist in
a dependeney where the perquisite system abolished by
Waialua under pressure still exists.’ The fact that <ome
of the retainers have lived in these houses of the overiord
for life or for more than forty-five vears*' is not good
reason te apply the Fair Labor Standards Ae: even if
this Court also disapproves of the condition.
*? The end residue of the cane after abstraction of the juices.
** The District Court describes the perquisite system at 97 F.
Supp. 198, 214. By a collective bargaining agreement effective No-
vember, 1946, this system was abolished and the value of per-
quisites previously allowed was converted into cash wages.
“* See the tabulation prepared by the trial court. 97 F Supp. 198.
215.
The furnishing of housing and facilities for a purely
agricultural community is local in its nature.” Perversion
of concepts and language is essential to tramsmute irriga-
thon of a grewing crep, harvesting by performing proe-
esses uintmediately necessary for crop preservation, or
furnishing essential fiousing to farm workers, into the
production of goods for commerce. Mere rationalization
Will net metamorphize the practice of furnishing housing
to Wovkers so engaged into manufacturing. Such conven-
lenees are traditionally fee cshed in the several states in
larger operations of farms, ranches, orchards and planta-
tions. In any event, here the furnisiing of quarters for
such of its workers whe desired to live on the plantation
on ground owned by Waialua was a convenient adjunct
of farming.
We are forbidden by statute, custom and rule from
taking new findings of fact, even where we believe these
are demanded by the reeord. This prohibition does not
Vanish where, as here, comprehensive agreemen.. of facets
are made on writing and much of the proof is documentary
While the testimony does not bear on the contested issues.
Writings and agresments of the parties are notoriously
meretricoous in dealing with jurisdietional or constitutional
questions. Where some findings are clearly erroneous, oir
duty is oo reverse.
“In « case waere the employer was engaged in manufacturing,
it was said, “* * * the plaintiffs were not covered by the Act while
encaged exclusively in ‘the construction, maintenance and repair
of the residences in the mill village owned by defendant and oc-
cupied by its employees’; or, to state the matter differently, while
the plaintiffs were so employed they were not engaged in the pro-
duction of goods fer commerce as that term has been defined.”
Morris vs. Beaumont Manufacturing Co, 84 F.Supp. 909, 910-911.
Soomer vs. Durham, 93 F.Supp. 526, is an interesting case wherein
builu;ing and repair of houses by employees of a coal mining com-
pany engaged in the production of goods for interstate commerce
under the Fair Labor Standards Act is discussed.
13
This brings us to a consideration of a constitutional
question of some magnitude. Should a statute of general
appheation throughout all the states be given special con-
struction in order to cure economic abuses indigenous to
Hawaii? Congress has almost autocratic power over a
territory, The commercial status and labor problems of
Hawaii might well be settled by specific statute” But the
** The thesis that the peculiar problems of a territory should not
be permitted to affect construction of an act designed to protect
farmers in the states is well illustrated by the progress of affairs
in Puerto Rico, where the situation is even more bizarre than that
in Hawaii.
Congress has approached the problem of labor in possessions
pragmatically by means of extended investigations and reports. As
a result of a realistic awareness of the ideochromatic characteris-
tics of each dependency, the Sugar Act of 1937, Act, September 1,
1957, c. 898, 59 Stat. 903 ff.. was enacted, which differentiated ex-
plicitly between sugar produced on the mainland and that produced
in the dependencies, territories and protectorates, and that pro-
duced in the latter between the Separate areas. The Court of Ap-
peals for the First Circuit necessarily reconciled the provisions of
the Fair Labor Standards Act with the clauses of the Sugar Act
applicable to Puerto Rico, Vives vs. Serralles, 145 F.2d 552. Legis-
latively, the requirement that there be special enactments relating
to Puerto Rico has been recognized by the passage of the Act of
August 8, 1947, ¢.519, Title II. § 202, 61 Stat. 924, as amended
September 1, 1951, ¢.379, § 1, 65 Stat. 318. The enactment by
Congress of legislation am ndatory of the Fair Labor Standards
Act, relating particularly to Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands,
Act of Getober 26, 1949, ¢.736. § 8, 63 Stat. 915, indicates con-
formity to the strict letter of the former statute might unhinge
the economy of these islands.
When the Act was new, the Wage and Hour Division interpreted
the harvesting of the raw sugar from cane as “preparation for
market” if done by a farmer. Subsequently, because of a series of
decisions relating exclusively to Puerto Rico, the Administrator
said the Wage and Hour Division had made a mistake in this in-
terpretation, and that harvesting resulting in molasses and raw
sugar Was not excluded by the Act. This opinion was advanced
with no consideration of the special conditions and !ogislation re-
lating to the territory and with the intent that the construction be
applied to the statute within the several states to which the special
provisions of the enactments did not apply.
As noted previously (178 F.2d 603, 611). the Puerto Rican cases
are generally distinguishable in that they are not related to activi-
14
same regulation of agriculture in the states en the inain-
land would be unconstitutional. In each of the ‘wo opin-
ions of this case,’ the trial court reviewed the whole eco-
nomic sirveture of the Territory of Hawaii, the faetor
system of marketing native products, the vestiges of feu-
dal incidents, the peculiar land system and the dependency
of the islands upon the inainland. To crown all, the theory
of appellees is that Congress, in passing the Fair Labor
Standards Act, did not have in contemplation such an
agricultural giant ** as this tarming corporation in a sea
island of the Pacific, and therefore the Court refused to
exclude its workers emploved in agriculture. This premise
is obviously based upon the idea that the language of the
Act clearly exciudes employees of such a corporation, but,
if Congress had contemplated Waialua, the law would
have placed such workers under the wages and hours pro-
visions. But, disregarding all logical econelusions from its
premise, the trial court applied the drastie overtime pro-
ties performed by a farmer or on a farm, but are either coopera-
tive enter>rises or are done by some outside agency. On the other
hand, certain judicial interpretations, if viewed as interpretations
of the general act binding on farmers on the mainland, are excres-
cences as foreign as gargoyles on a classic temple. McComb vs.
Puerto Rico Tobacco Marketing Co-op Assn., 80 F.Supp. 953, af-
firmed, 1 Cir., 181 F.2d 697; McComb vs. Del Valle, 80 F.Supp.
945; McComb vs. Casa Baldrich, Inc., 80 F.Supp. 869: McComb
vs. Super-A Fertilizer Works, 1 Cir., 165 F.2d 824.
27 Found at 77 F.Supp. 480 and 97 F.Supp. 198.
28 The Supreme Court expressly recognizes that largeness is not
the test. In Addison vs. Holly Hill Fruit Products, Inc., 322 U.S.
607, 614-615, the Court adopted with approval and applied in the
solution of a like problem an expression uttered in a debate in the
Senate. “Senator Schwellenbach frankly stated that the largest
apple packing plant in the world would be exempt if the ‘work
done in that plant is as described in the amendment’.” The Court
summarized its position as follows: “Where Congress wanted to
make the exemption depend on size, as it did in two or three
instances not here relevant, it did so by appropriate language.
Congress referred to quantity when it desired to legislate on the
basis of quantity.”
15
Visions in all their rigor to the peculiar corporation which
Congress had not considered.
It we were drafting a specific law to deal with labor con-
ditions of Hawaii, emotional sympathy for some of the
attitudes of the trial court might be given effect. But we
are construing a general statute binding in all the states
as well as this territory.
Everyone who remembers the history of this legislation
knows that the mainland farmers were alert when these
bills were in Congress. The Congressional Record indi-
rates how changes in the language were required by them
and that the legislators debated and explained the effect
of each provision.*” The statute which was written seems
plainly to protect all possible phases of agricultural pur-
suits from regulation.“” But the drive of a motivated bu-
rean, Which appe:-ntly considers the interests of labor
utterly inimical to any protection of the farmer, has dis-
torted the language used by some of the courts.
Do some opinions mean that the plain expressions of
Congress in the statute excluding those employed in agri-
cultural pursuits are to be overridden by some higher
policy. The expressions of Congress were dictated not
only by the pressure of the farmers, but by the realization
that the federal constitution left local concerns such as
agnicult’ + whoily in the governance of the several states.
One of these perversions which might be allowable in a
statute applicable to a territory alone is the attempt to
29 See 81 Congressional Record 7648 et seq., 83 Congressional
Record 7393, 9162-9163, 9253 et seq., H.R. No. 1452, 75th Con-
gress, Ist Session, pp. 4-5, 11; H.R. No. 2182, 75th Congress, 3rd
Session, p. 2.
8° The agricultural! exclusion “is drawn in far reaching language
which shows the intent of Congress to make the term ‘agricul-
ture’ cover much more than what might be called ordinary farm-
ing activity and that is wnat now controls.” Damutz vs. William
Pinchbeck, Inc., 2 Cir., 158 F.2d 882, 883.
16
make the farmer prove aflirmatively that the particular
activity falls within the statutory exclusion. The use of
the word “exemption” in a heading of the enactment has
been seized upon by the bureau and followed by the lan-
guage of some of the courts.”
But agriculture is not conmmerce, interstate or foreign,
nor does agriculture affeet such commerce in a constitu-
tional sense. Most agricultural products eventually get
into interstate transportation, But growing and harvest-
ing of such produets is not preparation of goods for com-
merce, The statute sets this out in immutable terms by
expressly stating that preparation of goods for market
by a farmer or on a farm is excluded.
So we must go further and direct the proceeding be dis-
missed for abuse of discretion in entertaining a petition
for declaratory judgment here and attempting to settle
3! This Court, in the former opinion, 178 F.2d 603, 609, indicated
that the workers in agriculture were completely excluded from the
provisions of this Act. The language of the statute makes it
abundantly clear that, since agriculture is a local enterprise and
eanno*, without distortion be called commerce or preparation of
goods for commerce, the manifest intention was to exclude work-
ers on farms and those employed in agriculture from the sweep
of the Act. The use of the words “exempt” and “exemptions” in
the regulations and by the courts is justified by the text. But the
words of the statute, “shall not apply with respect to”, indicate a
policy of exclusion of such employee no matter what the business
of the master. With regard to agriculture, this policy of exclusion
was as powerful as the policy which dictated the general provi-
sions controlling employees in industrial pursuits. There is no
ground to invoke the theory of technical, narrow construction of
the Act to cover this basic food supplying industry. Walling vs.
California Conserving Co., 74 F.Supp. 182, affirmed, 9 Cir., 167
F.2d 905, cert. den., 335 U.S. 845.
** Federal regulation of agriculture invades the reserved rights
of the states. United States vs. Butler, 297 U.S. 1, 68 But cf.,
Wickard vs. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111.
li
a question of jurisdietional and constitutional construction
therein.”
It is true the statute was not passed with the peculiar
economic situation of Hawaii in mind. Probably no spe-
cifie contemplation of an organization such as Waialua
Was in the foreground, But no one can deny that the posi-
tive clauses of the Act were to assure the farmer in the
several states of the continuance of his untrammeled way
of life. It was the intention that no bureau should dictate
the hours of his work “'—traditionally from sun to sun—
in the vitally essential task of feeding this nation and
foreign peoples to whom aid has been extended in the
form of foodstuffs. It has been a platitude of American
politics that the farmer is required to pay higher prices
for those things which he buys than he can obtain for the
products which he raises and sells. It was in the effort
to prevent the specialization of labor employed in agricul-
ture, where every man must he able to do all of the multi-
tudinous tasks, that these sections were adopted. It was
to the end that the farmer could use in the operations on
the farms unskilled and migrant labor, so that his eco-
nomic. burden might in one respect be lessened. These
provisions of the statute were included to prevent placing
innumerable restrictions and crushing burdens by bureau-
cratic supervision upon the American farms of the main-
land.
“This Court is without power to give advisory opinions. It
will not decide constitutional issues which are hypothetical, or in
advance of the necessity for deciding them, * * *.” Asburn Hos-
pital vs. Cass County, 326 U.S. 207, 213.
“* Speaking of the Fair Labor Standards Act and other acts, the
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit states: “* * * that exemp-
tion seems to have been a part of a general legislative pattern of
those times which clearly indicates that the purpose of Congress
was to relieve distressed farmers from burdens which it well knew
they were not equipped to carry.” National Labor Relations Board
vs. John W. Campbell, Inc., 5 Cir., 159 F.2d 184, 187.
Is
There has been an attempt to use the Farmers Reser-
voir case as a precedent here.’ The gist of the decision
there was that release of water from a headgate by the
field men of the reservoir company was not farming, (as
actual application of the water to a growing crop would
have been); it was not an act done by a farmer in con-
nection with farming and it was not done on a farm. The
decision on these specifie ¢rounds must be followed. Be-
sides, there is no reason to question its logical validity on
the basis above set out. It is true that the majority un-
fortunately accepted the acquiescence of the parties as
establishing the constitutional and jurisdictional factor
that the emplovees of a local irrigation company were en-
gaged in a “process or occupation necessary for the pro-
duction of goods for commerce.” Thereby the longstand-
ing principle of decision that a constitutional and juris-
dictional issue will not be debated or considered unless
actively raised by the parties was abandoned. Nor can
we accept as an explanation that rationalization leads to
quaint results.*
However that may be, in this case in a declaratory judg-
ment proceeding in a territory, all parties and the De-
partment of Labor acquiesce in the proposition that farm-
ing itself is production of goods for commerce. We re-
pudiate consent of the parties as a basis for decision.
Upon this fallacious theory, the trial court arrived at its
findings and conclusions here accused. We hold that a
farming operation such as growing the crop or harvest-
ing is not commerce. By no dialectics can it be shown
that irrigation, cultivation, plowing of the ground, prun-
ing of the trees or any of the processes before harvest,
—
35 Farmer’s Reservoir and Irrigation Co. vs. McComb, 337 U.S.
755.
36“Both in the employments which the Fair Labor Standards
Act covers and in the exemptions which it makes, Congress has
cast upon the courts the duty of making distinctions that often
are bound to be so nice as to appear arbitrary in relation to each
other.” Id. at 770 (concurring opinion).
1)
\Waether performed by a farmer or on a farm, are other
than purely local concerns relating to the production of a
crop. Cominon sense forbids it. Jurisdiction to regulate
farming on the ground that the products thereof may
eventually go into commerce cannot be conferred by con-
sent of the parties even in a particular case, sv definition,
any process essential to the growing, production or har-
vesting of crops is neither interstate or foreign commerce
nor preparation of goods therefor, nor yet again a process
or occupation necessary for the production of goods for
commerce. Farming in the several states cannot be regu.
lated as commerce even if it does constitute preparation
of farm products for market. To hold otherwise would
violate the express exclusionary language of the agriecul-
tural clauses of the statute and the public policy of cheap
production of foodstuffs above noted.
The public welfare requires that this statute be not
given a local interpretation to fit the needs of any terri-
tory, and that such special interpretations be not applied
to agriculture throughout the several states.” The Jan-
guage of the exclusion interprets a constitutional guaran-
tee, It is a charter for the mainland farmer. So far as
possible, in raising food for our widespread peoples, the
farmer should be exempt from higher cost of labor, He
should be able to plow, cultivate, irrigate, seed and har-
vest his crop without paving tribute. These processes,
essential to all, should not be made to cost more.* The
*’ This warning was expressed in our former opinion, 178 F.2d
603, 613: “The danger is that, by agreeing to this course of con-
duct, a precedent might be established for the settlement of prob-
lems on the mainland which does not have the peculiar problems
of Hawaii.”
**“Tt does not take a long memory to recall that in the midst
of the depression of 1935, and for a time before and since, the
farmer was the object of the deepest solicitude by Congress. It
furnished abundant evidence that it believed that no class of citi-
zens of the country was in greater need of Congressional aid than
the farmer.” National Labor Relations Board vs. John W. Camp-
bell, Inc., 5 Cir., 159 F.2d 184, 186.
LU
farmer in California should be able to run the heads of
wheat through a thresher or combined harvester and shell
out the grain, clean it, test it for protein content and
store it. He should be able to transport it on the farm
to the thresher or to storage or market, whether by his
own railroad or by trucks or by airplane. The stock raiser
in Idaho should be able to use ali forms of transportation
carrying calves or other stock to spring pasture or feeding
grounds. The stock rancher should be able to use his
vaqueros to repair barns, fences, corrals and even bunk-
houses, where his employees sleep, without becoming a
master carpenter. The raiser of peas should be anle to
make repairs and changes in his tractors, viners and mow-
ers by his own employees without becoming a master me-
chanic. He should be able to transport the fresh peas
many leagues from his land to the canner for essential
immediate processing by his trucks driven by farm hands
without becoming a trucker.
The sheepman can have a worker employed by him run
the system of gas or home-generated electricity which
lights up innumerable farm buildings and feed the chick-
ens he sells without becoming subject to the higher costs
under the industrial provisions of this law. The orchard-
ist of Washington should be able on his own land to pare
and core the apples, transport the meat thereof to market,
press out cider from the corings and peelings in a steam
driven rnill on his own land, and apply the residual pom-
ace as dressing to his land without becoming a manufac-
turer.” The operations described in processing raw sugar
from eane in Louisiana are in the same class.“
39 The si .vestion that this argument permits the farmer to carry
on extraneous manufacturing of such articles as automobiles on a
farm is vacuous.
4° As in the case of Miller Hatcheries, Inc. vs. Boyer, 8 Cir., 131
F 2d 283. 286, “We are dealing with a situation where there has
been ‘a contemporaneous construction of a statute by the men
charged with the responsibility of setting its machinery in mo-
ol
The authorities adverse to the maintenance of this de-
claratory proceeding are set out in the previous opinion.*!
The territorial institutions of Hawai: had provided the
protection for these workers almost identical with that
Which is the subject of this proceeding.” It is agreed by
the parties that this Act requires Waialua to pay and it
does pay as much or more than the minima of wages re-
quired per hour by the federal law. Perhaps, if local con-
ditions compel, the territorial legislature will require the
same work week in farming as is exacted by the Fair
Labor Standards Act, but without federal bureaucratie
control, which would necessarily he renounced if. state-
hood were attained.”
Each of these emplovees had an adequate remedy by
action at law if any thought he was aggrieved.*4 The
matter could have been tried on the facts relating to his
emplovment without the misleading background.
tion; of making the parts work efficiently and smoothly while they
are yet untried and new’.”
The Wage and Hour Division, on August 21, 1939, interpreting
the Act when it was new, said:
“Section 13(a)(6) renders the wage and hour provisions of the
Act inapplicable to employees employed in ‘agriculture’ * * *
“(b) The term ‘preparation for market’ must be treated differ-
ently with respect to various commodities. The following activities
among others, when performed by a farmer, seem to be included
within the term: * * *
“4. Sugar—-Manufacturing raw sugar, cane or maple syrup
and molasses.” Interpretative Bulletin No. 14. (Emphasis added.)
* 178 F.2d 603, 613-614, notes 16-28.
*? During each workweek involved herein, Waialua’s employees
received wages in excess of the Act’s requirements. They received
overtime pay for hours worked in excess of 48 hours a week. Thus
defendant employees are seeking a maximum of 8 hours overtime
pay for any of these workweeks.
** Perhaps for this reason Congress has never passed special
provisions of this law applicable only to Hawaii. as it did for the
Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. See Note 26, supra.
**29 U.S.C.A. § 216(b).
»)»
The cause is reversed for proceedings in accordance
with this opinion.*
(Endorsed:) Opinion. Filed May 5, 1954.
Paul PL O'Brien, Clerk.
Judgment of United States Court of Appeals for the
Ninth Circuit, dated May 5, 1954.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Distriet of Hawaii.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of
the record from the United States Distriet Court for the
Distriet of Hawaii, and was duly submitted:
On Consideration Whereof, It is now here ordered and
adjudged by this Court, that the judgment of the said
District Ceurt in this cause he, and hereby is reversed
for proceedings in accordance with the opinion of this
court, without costs to any party in this court.
(Endorsed) Judgnient.
Filed and entered May 5, 1954.
Paul P. O’Brien, Clerk.
Opinion of United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit, dated June 24, 1954, upon Petition for Rehearing.
BEFORE: HEALY, BONE and FER, Cireuit Judges
JAMES ALGER FER, Cireuit Judge:
The opinion of the Court needs no clarification. The
cause Was reversed, the final orders set aside and the cause
remanded with directions to dismiss Waialua’s declara-
‘> Arguments advanced by appellees and amicus curiae which
are rendered immaterial because of the Court’s decision are: (a)
that the processing exemption, 29 U.S.C.A. § 207(c), applies only
to the “place” in which processing is carried on and only during
such time as processing is actually taking place; (b) that any
employee who engages in a non-exempt activity for any portion
of a workweek is covered by the Act during such workweek.
23
tory petition. The Court construes what is called the
cross-complaint as a petition also for dee ‘laratory relief,
This is left undismissed by this Court. If the appellees
believe this to be a counterclaim at law, they may take
further proceedings as suggested in the latest opinion of
this Court. The parties and the Trial Court, however,
should be mindful of the fact that this Court has held
that the entire cause was tainted by apparent collusion
between the parties in the atte mpt to obtain an advisory
opinion upon constitutional questions. The considerations
of expense in futile proceedings are, of course, the concern
of the parties.
Rehearing denied.
(Endorsed:) Opinion on Petition for Rehearing. Filed
Jun. 24, 1954. Paul P. O’Brien, Clerk.
Order of United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit, dated June 24, 1954, denying
Petition for Rehearing.
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
NINTH CIRCULT
Excerpt from Proceedings of Thursday, June 24, 1954
Before: HEALY, BONE and FEF, Cireuit Judges.
ORDER DIRECTING FILING OF OPINION ON
PETITION FOR REHEARING AND
DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARING
ORDERED that the typewritten opinion this day ren-
dered by this Court on petition for rehearing in above
cause be forthwith filed by the Clerk.
Pursuant thereto and on consideration of the petition
of appellant, filed June 2, 1954 and within time allowed
therefor by rule of court, for a rehearing of above cuuse,
TF IS ORDERED that said petition for rehearing be,
and hereby is, denied.
24
Opinion of United States District Court
for the District of Hawaii, dated May 3, 1951
In The United States Distriet Court for the
Territory of Hawaii
Civil No. 787
Waratua AcricutruraL Company, Ltp.,
Plaintiff and
Cross-Defendants,
Vs.
Ciraco Manesa, et al.,
Defendants and
Cross-Claimants.
Opinion and Decision of Court (May 3, 1951)
Containing Findings of Fact and
Conclusions of Law
Merzcer, J.
Part I.
Statement and Findings
I
Nalure of Action. Controversy Involved,
and Jurisdiction,
This action arises under the Fair Labor Standards Act
of 1988 (the Act of June 25, 1938, 452. Stat. 1060, 29
USC Sections 201, ef seq.). Plaintiff sought a declara-
Oe
J
tory judgment, and the defendants filed a counter-claim
under Section l(b) of the Aet to recover unpaid over-
time compensation for work performed by them as em-
plovees of plaintiff, and to reeover liquidated damages,
costs and attorneys’ fees,
Following an earlier trial herein, a decision and judg-
ment of this court (reported at 77 F.Supp. 480), and an
appeal to the United States Court. of Appeals for the
Ninth Circuit, this action was remanded to this court for
further proceedings by a judgment of the Court of Ap-
peals rendered November 10, 1949 (reported at 178 F.2d
603).
Following the remand, all pleadings heretofore filed in
this action were amended by the parties, so as to drop
certain parties defendant from the litigation, to eliminate
the representative character of the case, and to limit the
action to the peried from November 20, 1946, to and in-
cluding September 14, 1947.
Under the amended pleadings, the following issues arise
With respect to that period of time:
A. Were the defendants or any of them exempt
from the provisions of the Act by virtue of
Sections 13(a)(6), 7(¢), or 13(a)(2), during all
or any workweeks falling within the aforemen-
tioned period?
B. Were certain of the defendants, while perform-
ing work of repairing and maintaining plain-
tiff’s dwelling houses, and while furnishing re-
lated facilities and services to plaintiff’s em-
ployees and others oceupying such dwelling
houses, engaged in commerce or in the produe-
tion of goods for commerce, within the meaning
of Section 3(1) of the Act?
(. What, if any, amounts are any of the defendants
entitled to recover from plaintiff pursuant to
Sections 7(a) and 16(b) of the Act?
|
4
These issues are raised by (a) the amended complaint
of plaintiff and defendants’ answer thereto; and (b) de-
fendants’ counter-claim, cross-claim and cross-complaint
under Section 16(b) of the Act, and plaintiff's reply and
answer thereto. In addition, defendants seek awards of
liquidated damages, and recovery of costs and attorneys
fees, pursuant to Section 16(b). By its reply and
answer, plaintiff seeks to defeat the request for liquidated
damages, as well as overtime wages due for the period
prior to May 14, 1947, by appealing to the good faith de-
fenses contained ir Sections 9, 10 and 11 of the Portal-
to-Portal Act of 1947 (Act of May 14, 1947, Public Law
49, ¢. 52, 80th Cong., Ist Sess., 61 Stat. 84, 29 USC See-
tions 251-263).
Ail issues have been presented and tried in a single
trial. The evidence consists of a lengthy stipulation to
certain facts, the testimony of plaintiff’s office manager,
the testimony of 22 of the defendant employees of plain-
tiff, and certain exhibits received in evidence, to which
reference will be made later.
This case does not involve waiting time, clean-up time,
travel time, or any of the types of activity whose con-
sideration occasioned in part the passage of the Portal-
to-Porta! Act of 1947. Defendants have atleged, it is not
disputed by plaintiff, and it is found by the court, that
the work performed by defendants for plaintiff, for which
recovery is sought in the counter-claim, was the principal
work performed by them, was compensable both under
an express contract and under custom and practice within
the establishments and places where the defendants per-
formed such work, and was performed during portions of
the days with respect to which the same was so made
compensable; that all such work was in fact paid for by
plaintiff, but the dispute between the parties is whether
the amounts so paid were sufficient to discharge plain-
tiff’s obligations under the Act for overtime compensa-
tion.
This court has jurisdiction of this action and of the
parties hereto pursuant to (ay Section U4 of the Judicial
Code as amended, 28 USC) Section IST. Ub) Seetion
Ji4id) of the Judicial Code, 28 USC Section 2201: and
(¢) Seetion Toth) of the bau Labor Standards Act of
1938.
7
Party ‘ and Period at LT tme luivoli ed.
Plaintiff is a corporation organized under the laws o:
the Territory of Hawaii en December 14, 1948. This
action Was instituted ou April 9, 1947, by a predecessor
corporation to the plaintiff?) bearing the same name. On
December 14, 1948, plaintiff acquired certain of the assets
and business, and assumed certain of the abilities, of
the predecessor corporation, including all rights, inter.
ests and liabilities in, or which might arise out of, this
action, By stipulation, piaintiff has been substituted as
the party plaintiff in this action fer the predecessor
corporation. All subsequent references to “plaintiff”
refer either to the predecessor corporation or to the new
corporation substituted herein, depending on whether the
Inatters to which they relate oecurred prior or subse-
quent to December 14, 1948.
Defendants are 42 individuals who were employed by
plaintiff during the period from November 20, 1946, to
September 14. 1947, inclusive. Each of then: appears in
this proceeding on his separate behalf only. and in’ no
Way as representative of any other persons or legal
entities. Uniess otherwise specified, each performed his
work on the plantation.
Summary of Plaintiff's Business.
Plaintiff operotes a sugar plantation located in_ the
District of Waialna, City and County of Honolulu,
Island of Oahu, Territory of Hawaii. In 1945, it was the
third largest producer of raw sugar in the Territory.
2S
At othe present time the plantation grows and produces
sugar cane on 9,065 acres of land owned or leased by it.
Substantially all of the land now devoted to sugar eane
production has been owned or leased by the plantation
und used by it for this purpose sinee 110.
As of approximately the commencement of the period
covered by this litigation, plaintiff had a total of 959 non-
supervisory emplovees,
inintiff’s business consists of (a) growing, cutlivating,
gad harvesting sugar cane on the lands owned or leased
hs its (hb) operating a system of railroad transportation
ever whieh harvested cane is hauled to plaiatiffs mill;
fe) processing such cane inte raw sugar and molasses at
the mili: Gd) shipping such raw sugar te a refinery
situated on the eontinemtal United States, where sueh raw
sugars refined and subsequently sold under the eireum-
stances dater diseussed herein: Ce) shipping molasses in
bulk to the continental United States; (f) operating a
series of shops for the purpose of maintaining, repair-
ing and overhauling plaintiffs batldines, machinery,
equipment, vehicles, and rolling stock; (2) maintaining
mill villawes and housing in which plaintiffs emplovees
ane their families dwell.
Plaintiff processes ne cane except that grown by itself
on its plantation. Neither dees it directly engage in any
suenr refining eperation. Towever, plaintiff and 30 other
COMPPIN TES engaged ino the production of raw sugar in
the Termtory, eonstitute the tetal membership of an
yesoeiation ealled Californin & Tlawaiian Sugar Refining
Corporation, Tatd. (@ & WW). a California eorporation.
(8 Toi. opalified as a cooperative marketing association
nnder the federal Capper Volstead Aet and under the
npplienble laws of the State of California. During the
hore inyvelyved in this litigation the meswhers of Co& Hl.
were under contract te deliver, and did
nolidinge pinne oft
~ :
29
deliver, to Co & H, all of the raw sugar produced by them
in the Territory, except for inconsequential amounts sold
for consumption as raw sugar in the Territory.
In this same period, C & H operated a sugar refinery
at Crockett, California. Under the mentioned contract,
( & H was entitled to process all raw sugar delivered to
it by its members, and to sell the refined sugar resulting
therefrom, 2s well as to sell in the ferm of raw sugar
any quantities delivered by the members of @ & H
Actually, © & H processed inte refined sugar more than
90° of the raw sugar delivered to it by its members, sell-
ing the balance as raw sugar,
The proceeds received by C & H from its sale both of
refined sugar and of raw suear, as well as any by-
products produced by it, were distributed in the following
manner. After first deducting the operating expenses of
("& H, the remainder was paid over to the members of
C & Hy, ineluding plaintiff. partly in the form of divi-
dends at 6% on the shares of eapital stock of C & H,
all of which were owned by the aforementioned 31 Hawaii
companies “substantially in the sane proportion as the
tonnage of raw sugar which they ship te C & HH” (Def.
Ex. 2) -and the balanee was paid over to the same eom
panies, in direct proportion to the amounts of raw sugar
delivered hy them to C & iH.
Plaintiff's Plantation Operations.
Sugar cane is highly perishable. To avoid serious
losses it is processed into sugar, svrup or molasses within
a relatively short time after heing harvested—usually, as
the reeord shows, the practice of processing is between
4 and 16 hours. Tt “eannot he stored more than 2 or 3
days without spoiling” (Def. Fx. 3B, p. 36).% It does
" For this reason and hecause of the great weight and bulkiness
of cane as compared with raw sugar. it must be processed within
a few miles of where it is grown
30
not move into interstate commerce in its natural state.
Except for small amounts which are used as seed cane,
it is grown fcr the purpose of producing sugar, syrup
and molasses. It is these products, which result from
the processing of cane, that become articles of interstate
commerce,
Substantially all of the cane-growing land of planta-
tien, its buildings and vard area, and other lands owned
or leawced by it, but unsuited for cane growing, ineluding
a wooded area from which firewood is eut for use for
fuel by plantation employees living in the plantation vil-
lages, forms a contiguous and compact area. Al! Jands
devoted to the growing of cane are managed and oper-
ated by plaintiff as an integrated farming unit and single
enterprise with identical cropping, cultivation and har-
vesting practices, and with the same labor and equip-
ment.
The growing and harvesting of cane, its processing in
the mill, and the shipping of raw sugar to the refiner,
take place continuously for a period of approximately
7-9 months. Annually, the harvesting and processing of
‘ane are Wholly suspended for the remaiaing 3-5 months,
for the purpose of completely reconditioning the mill
and equipment, and installing machinery and improve-
ments.
Plaintiff's buiidines, including the mill where eane is
processed inte raw sugar, and a number of buildings
whieh house repair shops for the maintenance of field,
transportation and mill equipment, warehouses for plainta-
tion supplies, and other buildings having funetional rela-
tion to the entice plantation operations, are centrally lo-
ented in the lowlands of the plantation in a eomnpact
aren,
Plaintiff. cane field operations are highly mechanized.
Speo TO there has heen x gradual reduetion in. the
nitber of man davs required te produce a ten oef raw
dl
sugar on plaintiff's plantation. This reduction was
brought about through mechanization and the application
of scientific methods. To a large extent hand labor and
the use of horse-drawn equipment and vehicles have been
eliminated, and motorized equipment substituted in their
stead,
The transportation system of plaintiff is also highly
mechanized, and this is likewise true Gf the processing
operations in the mill.
There is a high degree of coordination between field
operations, transportation, mill processing, shipping, and
all other aspects of plaintiffs activities.
“Operational problems on a sugar plantation are
comparable to those of a Detroit factory rather than
to those of a large lowa farm. The Primary ob-
jective of the management is to maintain ‘belt-line
production’ of sugar by so scheduling the various
field throughout the piantation for harvesting and
transport to the mill that full-scale raw-sugar pro-
duction will be continuous, 24 hours a day. To do
this it is necessary to maintain a fleet of large trucks,
mechanical harvesting equipment, a system of nar-
row-gage rathways (or other means of transporting
cane to the mill), a laboratory for scientific observa-
tien to determine the water and fertilizer needs with
an organized force of workers to implement. thes«
findings, and large pumping stations and = gravity
<vstems for contraliing irrigation.” (Def. Ex. 3B,
pr. Ob.)
During the vear 1945, plaintiff's direct operating ex-
penses amounted to one and three-quarter million dollars.
Of this sum, manufacturing costs approximated five hun-
dred thousand dollars, and an additional sum of approxi-
mately two hundred thousand dollars was expended on
transportation, in major part for main line hauling of
eane into the mill. The record does mot disclose the
wniount expended for operation of the repair and service
re)
©) ws
shops, or for maintenance of employee housing and
Village facilities.
It appears that plaintiff’s railroad system was valued
at more than three-quarters of a million dollars (Def.
nes 2).
Activities Occurring From the Time Cane Fields
are Prepared for Planting Up to
the Time of Harvesting.
In the preparation and plowing of its cane fields, a
so-called “stone boat” sled is used to clear the fields of
stones, rocks, and similar obstructions. Conerete irriga-
tion flumes and pipes are moved to their proper loca-
tion. Sugar cane seed is then planted. The tields are
then “ratooned”, this being an operation performed after
a cane field is harvested to prepare it for the growing
of another erop. In the eultivation, herbicides and in-
secticides are applied, by means of spraying equipment ;
in the fields, along irrigation ditches and flume areas,
and along cane field roads. Weeds are removed, fertilizer
is applied to the fields, and water is supplied by a net-
work of irrigation ditches, canals, siphons, concrete pipes,
fluines, water sto ige reservoirs and pumps, all of which
plaintiff owns, operates and maintains. Ultimately the
eane is harvested, loaded into cane cars on portable tracks
in the fields, and then moved (o the main line railroad.
Throughout the plantation, plaintiff maintains a net-
work of field reads for the transportation of 'nhor, field
supplies and equipment.
Intensive irrigation throughout the vear is required for
the acreage devoted to eane production. Trrigation fre-
queney ois uiided by soil moisture samples collected
weekly from each field. Approximately 97-98 of the
water received by plaintiff ts utilized for irrigation of its
cane fielis. "The degree to which water is used by plam-
tiff for irrigation purposes is shown by a tabulation re-
ceived in evidence. In the year 1040, for example, plain-
tiff applied 50,548 million gallons; this was a daily aver-
age of S4 million gallons. By way of comparison, the
city of San Francisco used 65 million gallons daily in
the same vear (Def. Ex. 3B, p. 43).
Plaintiff also uses substantial quantities of water to
supply its mill, to operate locomotives used on plaintiff’s
railroad, for the domestic water needs of plantation vil-
lages and plaintiff's employees living therein, for sale to
small farmers whose produce is consumed locally, and for
plaintiff's system of fire protection. The amount so eon-
sumed averaged two million gallons daily.
Harvesting Operations.
To insure a balanced flow of cane to the mill, harvest-
ing operations are coordinated with the needs and ca-
pacity of the mill, and the potential of its transportation
system.
Fields ready for harvesvding are first burned over, to
increase efliciency ino removing the cane and to reduce
trash carmed to the mill. In preparation for burning,
fire brakes are cut through the cane by a tractor bull-
dozer rake. This tears eane stalks from the stools and
pushes cane off to the side.
After the cane ts burned, the bulldozer rake opens up
lines for the laying of portable track. A portable track
plow or lteveler follows through these lines to take
proper beds for the track. Portable track rail cars,
londed with seetrons of track, are drawn into the cane
fields by tractors. Lifting machines hoist the track see
tions from the lended ears and lay them oon the track
beds. Ranpty cane cars are then hauled from the main
line of plaintiff's radroad onto a siding thereef into the
field for donde parppeses, amd are placed inte position
J4
for loading. Cane is loaded on the cars by machines,
Which are cranes equipped with a boom and a finger-like
grab; these pull or grab the cane loose from its growing
position and load it direetly into the cars. Plaintiff owns
9 such caneloading machines. Full cars are hauled out
of the field to the main line fer transportation to the
mill, A ecarload of cane averages slightly less than 5
tons per car, gross cane.
Cane pieces along the portable track are later picked
up by a ground crew and thrown into ears drawn by
tractors. Full carts are dumped near the cane loading
machines for subsequent lifting into cane ears. Cane
dropped in the fields is bulldozed into piles, and these are
later lifted by machine into the ears. This operation is
referred to as “brooming cane”. Where the main line
railroad passes adjacent to the eane field, harvested cane
is loaded directly into ears spotted on the main line
tracks.
Main Line Transportation.
From the time of its organization plaintiff has owned
and operated a narrow-gage railroad svstem. This svs-
tem is constructed, located and operated exclusively on
the plantation. It hauls no cane or freight for anyone
other than the plantation. It is used predominantly to
haul suwar eane from points where cane cars have been
concentrated to the mill. It is alse used to haul portable
rails and other supplies and equipment from the planta-
tien’s warehouses and shop vards to and from the fields,
bunt most of this type of hanling is handed by the planta-
tion trucks. The plantation has a spur traek approxi-
mately three thousand feet in leneth running from its
mill and warehouses, and connecting with the railroad
line of the Oahu Railway & Land Company. This spur
troek was used by the plantation to deliver box sand tank
ears Jonded with suyar and molasses to the 1). R. AN 1.
eid
Company, and to receive incoming supplies delivered to
the plantation by the O. RL & L, Company. The OL RO & L.
Company discontinued its operations at the end of 1947,
Since that time the outgoing and incoming freight of the
plaintiff has been handled by an independently owned
and operated trucking company.
The plaintiff’s railroad network consists of 56 miles of
permanent main iine track, hereinafter freauently re-
ferred to as “plaintiff's main line railroad”, and slightly
more than 9 miles of portable track.*
The plantation railroad equipment consists of six 25-
ton steam locomotives, one 17-ton steam locomotive, one
I2-ton steam locomotive, one 12-ton gasoline locomotive,
and one 14-ton diesel locomotive, 200) stec! ‘ane cars
meastving approximately 1] feet hy 6 feet by 5 feet, and
O12 wooden cane cars measuring approximately 10° feet
by 6 feet by 5 feet.
For the functioning of th’- railroad system, plaintiff
maintains a roundhouse, employs section men to maintain
the main line trackage, employs 10 crossing watchmen te
protect the pubbe at government road crossings. employs
Workers to spray the railroad rights of way With a herly
cide, employs workers whe together with field men pick
Up cane spilled along the railroad rightsof way, and
employs personnel to operate the trains. Six te hine
train erews, with an average of seven. are required daily
to handle eane an? incoming and outgoing freight. A
train crew cons'sts of four men. including a locomotive
engineer, a fireman, a front brakeman and a rear brake-
* Portable track laid in the field for harvesting operations lacks
Proper readbed for the locomotives. The Primary reason for the
use of the portable track for harvesting is that permanent track
cannot be laid in the field Secause of interference which would
otherwise result in plantin and cultivating eperations During
the short perieds when such track in the fields is in use it is an
inteyral part the rattread system over which cane cars move
directly from the fields te the mill
La ,.
ov
man. <A cane train averages at least 60 cars, though
this number sometimes goes up to SO or even 90 cars.
Working in the roundhouse are a hostler and an engine
wiper, who wash the locomotives and steam boilers, oil
and grease the locomotives, fire and steam the locomo-
tives preparatory to the day’s operations, and assist in
minor repairs to locomotives.
During the off-season, when cane is neither being har-
vested nor processed, the section men, supplemented by
approximately 12 brakemen and 5 firemen, are used in
repair and maintenance of main line trackage. Wateh-
men are used for cleaning and weeding the rights-of-way.
Usually one locomotive engineer, two firemen, and three
brakemen are assigned to assist the electricians on mill
work primarily. One fireman and two brakemen are gen-
erally assigned te the welding shop to assist in off-season
factory repairs and installation of new equipment. Two
more brakemen are sometimes assigned to repair work in
the boiling house. One yard engine crew, consisting of
an engineer and several brakemen for the diesel loco-
motive, is maintained during the off-season. Locomotive
engineers not otherwise used assist in locomotive repairs.
Voi dpi rations.
At its till, plaintiff processes cane into raw sugar and
molasses. Raw sugar is there bagged for shipment to the
Co Ho orefiners ato Crockett, California. Molasses is
either loaded for shipment ote the com inental United
States, or stored temporarily in molasses tanks. Bagged
sugar and molasses were loaded into railroad bex and
tank cars of the Onhu Railroad & Land Company, a ear-
rier, which then proceeded with the transportation of
these commodities to prornt of sh pene nt for the mainkane
The term “moll’ means the badding and equipment of
plaintiff _— ¢4,,. eeeetatey | Pygres seu steer A. mtaersen eshte inte
.? ’
H atria ii
raw osuvar. This ineludes ao eane-cleaning plant and
Ot
scales, uull carrier, crushing plant, boiling house, fire-
room, power plant, sugar warehouse, molasses tank, and
all equipment located therein.
Mill operations commence when loaded cane cars are
delivered by locomotive on the plaintifi’s main railroad,
to the mill yard and moved up to the mill. Here the cane
is Weighed, unloaded, washed, and as much trash is re-
moved as is mechanically possible. These operations take
Place in the cane-cleaning plant.
After being cleaned, the eane is moved by iill carrier
fo the crushing plant, is there erushed. and the juices
extracted, Sugar juices are then clarified and ervstallized
in the boiling house. The chief product, whieh is raw
sugar, is then bageed and shipped. or temporarily stored
and dater shipped." Molasses js pumped inte a sterage
tank at the mull, and later shipped.
The cane fiber which remains after the extraction of
the juice from the cane stalk is known us bagasse. It
serves as an economical souree of fuel for the production
of power. Bagasse produced at his Plantation has no
marketable value, but is lurned in the fire ream, jocated
in the mill, and preduces steam. This in turn is used te
drive the mill eneines and cane Processing equipment, to
heat and evaporate suear iniee and ervstallize the raw
agar, and te fenerate eleetric rawer mt the mill's power
plant. Steam used for the latter purpose, after passing
through generating tanchimery, j- conveyed through lines
fer further use in processing operations,
The power plant generates eleetric power. This. how.
ever, supplies comtsy sabssent tyes thords af the purWerp needed
hy plait tf, sae it pirre ligase. eegpe third of the proWer tse]
* The plaintiff's te mporary storage of ;aw sugar is never mo-
tivated by economic considerations. but is due only to the limited
number of cars and limited storage space at the pert wharves and
occasional interruptions im ship schedules
38
by it from the Hawaiian Eleetric Company, Ltd., an in-
dependently owned and operated publie utility.
There are times when plaintiff's power system generates
more power than it has need of. Because of an existing
tie-in between its power system and that of Hawaiian
Electric Company, on rare occasions plaintiff feeds back
power into the system of Hawaiian Eleetrie. Credit for
such power is given to plaintiff in the same manner as
though a sale had oeceurred.*
Power generated by plaintiff, as well as that pur-
chased by it, is distributed by transmission lines to all
the various operations on the plantation, and also. to
several non-plantation users living in the plantation com-
unity. The total amount of power used by non-planta-
fon users is about one-half of one per cent of all the
power distributed by plaintiff. None of it is used for or
in connection with the production of goods for eommerce,
or to operate any instrumentaiities of interstate eom-
Ineree, or transmitted into interstate commerce.
In the off-season, when the steam and eleetrie power
equipment in the moll are overhauled, plaintiff generates
ne electric power, purchasing all the power it needs from
the Hawanan Electric Company.
. We. theond Shutdown In the M///
Prodaetion in the unll operations is keved basically to
a6 day week with continnous and around-the-clock opera-
tens divided onto three S-heur shifts. The mill steps
grinding cane at 2 pan. Saturday and starts up at the
same time on Sunday. The cessation of grinding opera-
tions on Saturday dows Part, however, restit in the stop.
prides of all mill operations. As show n Inter, in the deserip
* Power is not fed back te the Hawaiian Electric lines for the
purpese of selling power but only beeause it is a necessary. con-
venient and economical methed of disposing OF the exvess powe!
39
tions of work performed by various defendants, the week-
end shutdown period does not extend for 24 hours in
regard to the beiling house, the fireroom, and the opera-
tions of the power plant.
The weekly, shutdown for mill operations is necessary
to perform cleaning and minor repair work,
Off-Season
Although sugar cane can be an? is grown the year
round in the Territory of Hawaii, efficiency of operations
dictates the closing down annually of sugar mills so that
extensive general repairs, reconditioning. and installation
of improvements can be had. That part of the vear when
the mill is shut down for repairs is termed the “off-
season”. While the off-season usually lasts 3-5 months, in
the period covered by this litigation it extended only from
December 22, 1946, to and including February 9, 1947,
During the off-season, plaintiff conduets no harvesting,
cane transportation, or cane processing operations, Field
operations continue,
Most of the off-season repair work in the mill is done
by emplovees who, during the grinding season. operate the
mill machinery, However, some of this repair work is
done by emplovees of the machine shop. welding shop.
blacksmith shop, carpenter shop, and electric shop
Just as many man dav. of work are perforiced during
each 24 hour period in the mill during the off-season as
during the grinding season.
Repair anal Nervice Shop ?
Both field and gill operations necessitate the epupping
and maintaininer of complete service shops for prempt
miner repairs and emergenes work and majer everhaul.
40
Plaintiff operates and maintains a number of repair
and service shops which are plysically distinet from the
mull, housed in separate buildings, and located in an area
extending up to S00 feet from the mill building. These
shops emplov typwards of 100 men, plus necessary fore-
men and supervisors. These shops are: machine shop,
welding shop, blacksmith shop, tinsmith shop, caneloading
machine repair shop, tractor repair shop, garage, electric
shop, carpenter shop, paint shop, plumbing shop, and
roundhouse.
1. Machine Shop
The machine shop is staced by S&S emplovees working
under supervision of a machine shop foreman. Prac-
tieally all of plaintiffs machining work, except heavy
work required by the ral ratirend and shops, is dene im
the machine <hom. The crinding of erankshatts for ears,
trueks. tractors, and erames, the machining of emergencs
parts for such equipment, and nigehine werk om irrign
tion pumps are performed in this shop. Major locomotive
repairs are inade by machine shop personnel working
with a heavy crane in the welding shop,
Approximately 466 of ell machine shop werk i- fer
the mill. amd AO for other service denmartinents, ireland
ine repmirs te stenm: engine driven irrigation pumps.
Daring the off-season. mill work done by the machine
shon aeeounts for from S50 tg OOF oof the tetal man
hoors’ werk performed
Work in the machine shep is fairly uniform throughedut
the veur. with peaks in eases of emergeney nll repairs
and during the mill off sensonm. Loeemetive omerhant ps
enrried out toa Umited exten: during the erimding seasen
te relieve punchine shen off sensan work. Steam engin
driven water piunans are seheduled for overhaul acter the
mill overhaul has heen completed and after grinding oner
ations are resumed
%
a
41
A large portion of the work done by the tachine sheep
personnel is performed within the shop. utilizing shop
tools, These tools include lathes, liodrautie press, drill
press, planer, boring machine and eranksnaft orinder.
From time te time machine shop personnel are called inte
the mill to perform repairs, regroovine of mill rolfs,
and such other work as cannot be expeditiously landed
by mill workers,
ya Welding Shop.
This shop employs 5 men under supervision of a weld
ing shop foreman. About 46° of its work os for the gail,
In the off-season, welding shop work for the mill repre
sents approximatels GC oor mere oof the total muman-
hours. Most of the welding repairs te mel) equipment
are made in the shop. althoneh Personnel gre setiuet ies
dispatched tos the pom! ef breakdown.
Steel cane ear repairs are made alongside the shop
building bw the shey personnel. Welding Shop eniplowecs
also operate pipe rells located im the pope polling <hed.
The pipe which is rolled i. eo erally Grrmgation pope TS
inches in diameter or larger. Welding of this piper is
performed bya thie shop welders, In hix~ wark the weld
ing shop emplovees are assisted by employers from the
aecksmith shep oor canmelonding machine reneit shape.
Welding shop equipment consists of hemvy pipe relis,
several sets of acetylene and euttine ontfits> acetylene
veneraters, and beth stationary and portable welding
vrenerators,
3. Blacksmith Shop.
“his shop employs 2 blacksmiths and 2 helpers under
supervision of the ennelonding machine repair shop fore
tan. Ahent twe davs eneh week are spent by the Mack
smiths and helpers on mill work, conmsistine pryveipaliv
of constructing and reconditionme of cane carrier level-
Ing and preparation knives. Cane car repair work, such
as straightening of bars and channels, and repair of
tractors and caneloaders, and field implement work,
eceupy the yvreat percentage of the tman-lours in the
shop. The werk of this shop ix uniter throughout the
vear. Equipment in this shep includes 2 forges, an elee-
triecally operated hanmuner. and a variety of stall tools,
4. Tinsmith Shop.
This shop employs a tinsinith journeyman and 2 help-
ers. Mill repair work liere is negligible, although light
sheet steel work, including maintenance and reps of
roof gutters and down pipes, is performed by the shep
personnel. Repairs of auto, truck, traetor and caneloader
radiators are performed by the shop personnel.
The main work of this show is the making and reecon-
ditioning of tim irrigation SCOOPS. These scoops are used
in quantity in the field for the purpose of deflecting water
from conercte irrigation thoes to field irrigation lines,
». Caneloading Machi Be pau Shop.
Twelve cmplovees and a foreman work here. They per-
form all major repairs and overhaul of caneloaders,
grabs and miscellaneous field equipment. Men from this
shop are oeeassonally called pon to assist In emergency
mill repairs. They alse eo inte the field to repair cane-
landing machines during the course of harvesting opera-
TIONS,
An important funetion of this shop is the construction
ef auxiiars field equipmern’. sach as sub-soilers used in
plowing, cane [ne reshapers used to maintain irrigation
water fines on the field) and portable track line leveler
attachments used in leveline che lines for laving portable
tracks. Repairs on such auxihary field) equipment are
ae)
te
alse made in this shop, with Hssistanmee fron, personnel
of the traetor repair shop,
In the off-season, at least & of the Y canelouding tia
chines are completely dismantled and reconditioned, The
“th machine is peconditioned after harvesting has been
resumed. In the off-season, 10 te 12 operators of cane-
loading dachines are brought in to supplement the regu-
lar employees of this shop, and to assist. in overhaul,
Five cane grabs are overhauled and reconditioned during
the off-season, and all other cane vrabs are repaired.
During the harvesting season, 3 new cane vrabs are
usually built.
equipment in this shop includes 4 portable welding
renerators, and 2 portable welding generators mounted
on trucks for field) repairs. A hydraulic press, over-
head crane, motor-driven grinders and a variety of small
fools complete the shop equipment. Four welders in the
shop take care of welding repairs in the field, and re-
pairs to, and building of, new field equipment.
6. Tractor Repair Shop.
Seven employees normally work here, but in the off-
season this number is supplemented by 12 te 15 tractor
operators who are brought into the shop from the
fields, to assist in repairs. All tractors used in. the
harvesting field are overhauled in this shop during the
offseason. Tractors used for towing cane line” re-
shapers are also overhauled during the off-season, Other
tractors which cannot be overhauled during the off-
season are scheduled for overhaul at a later date. This
may mean that 6 or 7 out of a total of 48 traciors are
left for operating season overhaul. Tractor engines are
overhauled at recular periods,
Minplovees of this shop are sometimes dispatehed for
repair of tractors in the fields. They also assist in repair
44
of field implements in the caneloading machine repair
shop.
«2 Garage.
Personnel employed here numbers 24.) Primarily work
of the garage is to maintain and keep in repair plaintiff's
YS motor vehicles, consisting of 1S passenger vehicles, 45
pick-up trucks up to one ton, 27 heavy trucks from 1},
to 7 tons, 1 motoreyele, 2 fire trucks, and 2 panel trucks.
Sixty-four of these vehicies are assigned to operations in
the field, 12 to the repair and service shops, 1 to the
mill, 1 to the hospital, 2 to the plaintiff's retail store, 7
for administration, 2 are fire trucks, and 9 to the motor
pool.
Overhaul of cars and trucks is scheduled throughout
the vear, except that pick-up trucks used by the harvest-
ing men are overhauled during the off-season. ‘Truck
drivers are not used to assist in truck or auto repairs,
since there is generally a spare truck to drive when
others are being repaired. All such work is performed
by the garage mechanics.
Shop equipment consists of 4 overhead cranes, a hoist,
‘ralve grinding machine, brake drum lathe, boring ma-
chine, tire tools, and a variety of special tools.
Complete servicing equipment is also maintained, to-
gether with necessary personnel. Seven full-time em-
plovees and om part-time employee perform the lubri-
eating and was'ng of vehicles. One employee dispenses
gas and oil at the yard service station. Six persons are
emploved as helpers to garage mechanies when there is
no service work.
Field service covers the daily lubrication of all equip-
ment and the replenishing of fuel tanks. Tractors, cane-
loading machines, portable air compressor, diesel and
45
gasoline locomotives, and all field equipment are serviced
daily by a total of 6 men. Two completely equipped
service trueks manned by 2 men each service all field
equipment, except that in the harvesting fields. In. the
latter case, a two-wheel trailer, tractor-drawn, is kept in
each of the two harvesting fields. Oil, gasoline, diesel
oil, greases and water are carried on the trailer. to-
gether with pewer-operated grease guns. One man as-
signed to each trailer services the eranes and. tractors
in the harvesting fields. In this way service work ean
he done during lunch hour and slack periods without
serious interference with harvesting operations.
8. Electric Shop.
Fifteen employees work in this shop. Three of these
are mill electricians who divide their time between the
mill and the shop, working two weeks in the former, then
one week in the latter. The shop maintains electric
pumps and transmission lines and performs domestic wir-
ing repairs, including wiring of houses, and the building
of new electrical appliances. Employees of this shop per-
form necessary work on electrical machines located in
the other shops.
In addition to mill repair work done by the employees
assigned as electricians to the mill, electrie shop per-
sonnel may assist them in case of major electrical repairs
required, About half of the work in this shop is for
the mill. During the off-season, about 70% of the work
is for the mill.
9, Carpenter Shop.
Twenty-five carpenters and two supervisors comprise
this Shop’s personnel. They perform all carpenter work
on the plantation, whieh includes construction of mill
seaffoldings, construction and maintenance of railroad
+b
trestles and wooden gates for flumes, and construction
and maintenance of cane cars. In addition, they perform
necessary maimtenance work on the plantation buildings
and houses. ‘They also instail and maintain steel and
concrete pipe lines and siphons. Miscellaneous con-
struction, such as construction of tool lockers, scrapers
and strainers, is performed in this shop. Field work,
including work on the flumes, railroad trestles, siphons
and pipe lines, accounts for about 254c of the work of
the employees. Mill secaffoldings and mill building re-
pairs, construction of tool lockers, scrapers and strainers,
account for another 10%. Maintenance and repair of
plaintiffs buildings and housing account for another
45%c. The remaining 20° of the work consists of con-
struction and repair of cane cars. The work is uniform
throughout the year, with little change between grind-
ing season and off-season. During the off-season, addi-
tional nen averaging from 10 to 15 may be brought in
from the fields to assist in cane car overhauling and
general carpentry work.
10. Paint Shop.
Here are emploved 5 painters and a supervisor. They
perform all painting work on plaintiff's buildings, includ-
ing housing, and they also occasionally paint siphons and
railroad trestles. As a general rule, they do not paint
for the mill, this work being done by mill employees.
Most of the time of the paint shop crew is devoted to
painting of plantation buildings and housing throughout
‘he vear. During the off-season, an average of two
additional employees brought in from = the fields may
assist in the work of this shop.
HW. Plumbing Shop. .
Six pluinbers and one supervisor work here. Thev
perform all plumbing work on the plantation, ineluding
the construction and maintenance of sewer and water
40
systenis and plumbing for buildings and housing. Ap-
proximately 10° of the time is devoted to will plumbing
work, lo‘ to field work and the remainder to buildings
and housing. Assignments varv little throughout the
year. During the off-season, an average of two field
employees may be assigned to the plumbing shop as
helpers.
12. Roundhouse.
Reference to the roundhouse has already been made.
It regularly employs two inen in the shop, who perform
the servieing, cleaning and firme of plaintiff's locomo-
tives, Additional employees are occasionally assigned to
this shop to assist in minor locomotive repairs.
Laboratory.
In a separate building, plaintiff operates a laboratory.
Various chemical tests are made by the laboratory per-
sonnel in the course of all field and mill operations. This
work is performed under the supervision of a chief
chemist with the assistance of 13 chemists, testers and
samplers, By performing careful analysis of various
kinds relative to the cane and materials in the course of
growing, cultivating and harvesting of cane, and the
extraction of the sugar juices, all operations are con
trolled pursuant to scientifie methods.
Determinations of the cane fiber in each field, or
Variety of eane, are made during each shift. Figures
obtained are used in ealculating bagasse weights, field
distribution and extraction percentages,
Cane leaf analysis is made from samples of cane tops
brought in each day and analyzed for green weight mix-
ture, totai sugars, nitrogen, potash and phosphate.
Daily tests are made for a variety of other purposes.
Tests are made to determine the amount of field trash in
48
harvesting brought ts the mill. Continuous samples are
taken from the feed roller of uie first mill each hour,
and also at each change of harvesting, and records of
ratios of cane to available sugar are obtained. Extracted
Juices are sampled to determine the sugar obtained from
‘ane by the miiling process. Extracted juices are used to
ealenlate the weight of bagasse. Every three hours
samples from clarified juice are taken, to reveal the rela-
tive amount of solids being removed by the lime and heat
treatment of quices. Purity of svrup is cheeked., Samples
of bagasse are taken every two hours, and ash determi-
nations are also made twice daily, to determine the in-
fluence of different fields on the fireroom. Mix‘ures of
sugar and molasses are tested to determine the amount
of sugar lost in the filter cake,
Tests are also made of the mill boiler water, loeomo-
tive boiler water, steam pump boiler water, and pump
water. Pump water from eleetric pumps and well water
are sampled once each month. Wash water frew the
cleaning plant and condenser water are also analyzed each
shift.
Concrete Products Plant
In a separate building, plaintiff operates its own eon-
crete products plant. Six men ordinarily staff it, although
the number varies from 4 to 10. Work is usually per-
formed on a single shift basis, but occasionally two shifts
are maintained.
This plant is engaged primarily in producing eonerete
irrigation flumes and water supply pipe. It also makes
blocks, footings, sidewalk slabs and various other ineci-
dental concrete products required by the plantation.
Crushed rock used in the manufacturing process is pur-
chased locally, but from 80% to 90° of all cement used
is obtained from the continental United States. The work
40)
consists of setting up forms, mixing and pouring con-
creve, removing the previous day’s products and arrang-
ing thin ti storage. Cement used is stored in cars which
are set on the siding near the plant, or the cement. is
stored in the cement shed as part of the inventory of gen-
eral supplies warehousing. In the latter case, unloading
of cement tis done by the warehouse personnel. Various
activities requiring the flumes, pipe and other produets
receive them direct from the storage area where the prod-
ucts are stored,
The operations do not have any off-season. During the
off-season, however, additional personnel may be brought
in from the fields. In 1946, the plant produced approxi-
nately 46,000) concrete pieces, ineluding flume sections,
pipe and other products.
Storage of Supplies
Materials and supplies purchased for plantation opera-
tions are warehoused or stored in several separate build-
ings located in the plantation buildings and vard area.
Value of supplies on hand averages $500,000, The total
Value of goods proeured during a year, including stoex
and special order materials, averages over $1,000,000,
Most of the materials received were shipped to the
plantation from Tonolulu on the O. R. & LL. Purehases
nav be either local or by order and direct shipment from
continental United States. Freight received is placed in
the proper warehouses by the warehousing personnel. In
almost all cases railroad sidings permitted placement of
the OO RL & LL. cars next te the warehouse receivine the
materials. The warehonsing personnel is not responsible
for, nor does it engage in, delivering materials to the
various operations or shops.
The principal buildings in which the supplies and mate-
rials of the plantation are stored are the general sup-
50
plies warehouse and the heavy supplies warehouse. They
house electrical goods, building hardware, paints, window
screening, tractor and caneloading repair parts, copper
tubing, pipe stock, metal shapes stock, galvanized sheet-
ing, steel sheets and many other items.
The oil storage warehouse contains lubricants and a
limited amount of paint.
Gasoline, fuel oil, diesel oil and kerosene were dis-
charged directly from the O. R. & L. tank cars inio stor-
age tanks,
Most of the automotive parts and tractor, caneloading
and miscellaneous parts are stored in the garage.
Cement is stored in a separate warehouse. Lime is
stored in the mill in the lime room after being unloaded
by warehousemen.
Lumber is stored in the open lumber yard adjoining the
general supplies warehouse. Herbicides are also stored
there.
Fertilizers are usually trucked directly from = railroad
ears to the field as needed; but if temporary storage is re-
quired, they are placed in the sugar warehouse.
The warehousing operations are handled as one unit
under a warehouse superintendent with 13 > employees.
Five clerks perform the bookkeeping and handle aecounts.
The remainder of the warehouse personnel is employed
in the unload'ng and storing of stocks and materials, keep-
ing stock reeord ecards and taking inventory.
Main Administration Office.
The main administration office is located about 1500
feet from plaintiff's buildings and vard area. The man-
ager, assistant manager, and staff assistants have their
offices here, Employees include the cashier, bookkeeper,
ol
head timekeeper, 6 assistant timeke: pers, S clerks, 5 stenog-
raphers and typists—a total of 22 employees working
under the office manager and his assistant. Four time-
keepers keep the time of the field employees; 2 keep the
time of the shop, store, mill, hospital and village mainte-
nance employees, These offices are where payroll records
are maintained, and salaries and services paid.
Also housed in this building are the offices of the civil
engineer, one assistant surveyor, 2 Junior surveyors, and
< rodmen, who work alternately in the field and in the
office. There is also a draftsman emploved in this office,
The agrieulturist and indus‘rial relations sections are also
located in the same building.
Stahles.
The plantation has one main stable near the plantation
buildings and yard area. It uses 38 horses and mules.
Horses are used by the harvesting overseer to ride in the
fields. Pack mules are used upon occasion to pack seed,
fertilizer, broken concrete flumes and other things in and
our of the cane fields. The plantation has several feeding
stations for horses and mules where they are kept tem-
porarity while work is being performed in a particular
area. Three empiovees are assigned to the work of the
stables,
Firewood,
Plaintiff maintains a splitting station in the mill yard.
This is equipped with saw and splitting machinery gener-
ated by electric power, Firewood, cut by plaintiff's em-
Plovees at var ous places on the plantation, is brought
to the station to be sawed and split into pieces of appro-
priate sizes. The uses of such firewood are: sale of fire-
wood to employees and pensioners, for cooking and heat-
ing purposes; for heating water at the village bathhouses;
and for starting small boilers and heating walls within the
furnaces and pumps used to supply water for irrigating
eane fields and for domestic and other uses in plantation
Villages.
Macadamia Nut Trees.
Macadamia nut groves are operated by plaintiff in an
area approximating 121 acres. Such area is not suitable
for sugar cane. Duving the period covered by this litiga-
tion, the trees had not vet reached maturity and no nuts
were hrvested. A nursery for culiivation of young ma-
cadamia trees is maintained on the plantation.
Plantation Villages.
At the time plaintiff was originally organized, there
was no established community housing, or other facili-
ties, in or near the area which plaintiff proposed to de-
vote to the production and processing of cane. To estab-
lish a stable labor supply and house it at places conve-
nient to plaintiff's purpose, plaintiff undertook to ereate
a community, and to suppiy jiousing and other necessary
services and facilities for its employees. Plaintiff eon-
structed houses, developed services, and built up and es-
tablished various facilities to serve the needs of perma-
nent living, in plantation villages, of its required number
of employees and their families. This was done over a
period of years, resulting in the development of Waialua
village and several small villages.
Waialua village has all the physical and visual charac-
terisiics of an established community and is similar to 4
typical small town of a farming community center. The
area is crisscrossed with government road= and roads
eonstrucied and maintained by plaintiff. The community
offers the usual services and typical commercial estab-
lishments to be found in any small town. There is a
—
-—~
company store, or retail store, with .wo branches; an
automobile service station; and a hospital. These are
owned and operated by plaintiff for plantation employees
and their families and non-plantation persons. Plaintiff
also built in this area two gvinnasiums, one clubhouse,
one athletic field, one beachhouse, one swimming pool,
and two tennis courts, which are available to an athletic
association, membership of which is composed both of
plaintiff’s employees and others in. the community.
Additional serviees and establishments located in. the
community, which are independently operated, include ten
general stores, two restaurants, two fish markets, one
eandy store, one hardware store, one clothing store, four
barber shops, one beauty shop, one pliotographie studio,
two automotive service stations, two motion picture thea-
‘ers, and one bank. :
“Tt must be remembered that the whole plantation
area, including the town, is owned by the plantation
company, and although there are frequently many
shops, such as drug stores, tailor shops, shoemaker
shops and the like, that are privately operated, they
rent their sites from the plantation and ean remain
only as long as the plantation permits them to do so.
Anyone on any part of the plantation is a trespasser
unless he has the permission of the management to
be there. * * *” (Def. Ex. 3A, p. 71.)
Also located in the village are a post office, publie 1i-
brary, five churches, one intermediate sehool, one high
school, and one day-care center operated by the terri-
torial school system.
For many years, plaivtiff’s employees occupied plain-
tiffs dwellings pursuant to a svstem = of perquisites,
Under this system, employees recived housing, housing
maintenance, water, firewood and kerosene fuel, electricity,
tnedical care, recreational facilities and various mainte-
nance services, including garbage disposal and street clean-
oF
ing, as a part of their regular compensation as employees
ef plaintiff. This system was abolished by an agreement
dated November 19, 1946, between plaintiff and the In-
teimational Longshoremen’s and Warehousemen’s Union,
Local No. 145-7, which acted as collective bargaining rep-
resentative for most of plaintiff's non-supervisory em-
ployees. As part of the change thus inaugurated, the
value of the perquisites previously allowed to employees
Was converted, at scheduled rates, into cash wages to be
paid by plaintiif by way of wage increase, and thence-
forth the employees commeneed to pay cash, at scheduled
rates, as non-employees do, for the continued furnishing
by plaintiff of the aforementioned facilities and services,
except that no charge, either to employees or others, was
designated for garbage collection, sewage disposal, fire
protection, maintenance and cleaning of village roads and
similar village services, which continued to be provided
by plaintiff. Neither was any charge desiguated for con-
tinned use of parks, playgrounds, plaintiff’s clubhouse
and gymnasium and recreational facilities generally.
An undisclosed number of plaintiff's dwelling houses
are not equipped with tub or shower facilities. For the
inhabitanis thereof, plaintiff maintains bathhouses. From
November 20, 1946, when perquisites were terminated,
until April 30, 1947, no charge was made for use of the
hathhouse, except as this was included in the rent paid
hy employees for the dwelling houses. Commencing May
1, 1947, and throughout the balance of the period covered
by this litigation, plaintiff instituted a system of charges
for use of the bathhouses: 50¢ per family per month, and
2¢ per month in the case of a single man without de-
pendents.
At the present time, the dwelling houses owned by
plaintiff number 820, all located on the plantation. Most
of them surround the buildings and vard area located
d9
near the mill. These houses, together with the business
establishments of the community, constitute the Village of
Waialua. There are 335 houses which are scattered over
the plantation, but these too are located in clusters and
form small villages.
No employee covered by the existing collective bargain-
ing agreement, including each employee defendant herein,
is required as a condition of employment to live on the
plantation or in plantation houses or to use any service
or facility that the plantation may be in a position to ren-
der its employees. The relationship that exists between
the plantation and its emplovees who live in plantation
liouses is that of landlord and tenant. However, of. the
total number of 959 nop-supervisory etuplovees of plain-
tiff, only 16 live off the plantation in houses not supplied
or owned by plaintiff. The remaining employees and
pensioners, together with their families, an aggregate of
2902 persons, all inhabit dwellings owned by plaintiff and
generally located in Waialua village, or one of the other
plantation villages owned by plaintiff. Plaintiff also rents
'o ron-employees, totaling 421, dwellings not oceupied by
employees of plaintiff. Some of these persons work off
the plantation altogether: others are persons who own,
operate or are employed in the independently controlled
businesses located in plaintiff's plantation villages.
The relationship between an individual's employment
with plaintiff, and his occupation of a company-owned
house, is shown, as testified to by 22 of the defendants, in
the following tabulation:
ry
oh
How long
employed by How long has lived in house
Deferdant plaintiff owned by plaintiff
Claunan 2) vears 20 vears
Crisostomo 26 years 26 vears
cumlat Over 10 years 20 vears
Faria 40 years 44 years: bought own home in
June, 1950
Fujiwara 12 years Lives with her family, which has
occupied company-owned house
for over 30 years.
Hayashi Over 15 years 25 years
Holmberg 23 years (Not testified to)
Izawa 22 years 36 years
Kobota 23 years 23 vears
Koshiwabara 26 vears 26 vears
Lorenzo 14 years 14 years
Maneja 23 years 23 vears
Mori 16 years 34 vears
Oato 14 years 30 vears
Pacheco 75 years 27 years
Reyher 25 years 29 vears
Robello (S) 28 years 45 vears
Sunihara 20 years 26 years
Takata 20 years 239 vears
Tanaka 11 years All his life; was born in
company-owned house
Watanabe 17 years 5 vears
Yamada 24 vears All his life: was born in
company-owned house; father
was employee of plaintiff.
Plaintiff has established a fire protection system at the
village of Waialua, and as part of that system operates
two fire trucks. It also maintains fire hydrants in and
about the village, the mill, various buildings in the yard
area, and at various other locations.
There is a cemetery, located on plaintiffs property,
for its employees and their families.
Prior to the abolition of the perquisite system, em-
plovees of plaintiff performed the work of maintaining
and keeping in proper repair the dwelling houses owned
by plaintiff, and the village area, and in’ supplying the
usual services necessary to the operations of a cominunity.,
vi
This has continued without change. Under the mentiosecad
collective bargainnge agreement, plaintiff eXpressly m4.
dertakes te provide dwelling Man enhance and repairs,
and village services: and in this connection. net “to make
°
housing a profit-making veature, as such.’
Organization of Plaintiff's Plautation.
At all times invelved herein, plaintiff has been a merm-
ber of the Hawaiian Sugar Planters’ Association (HSDPA),
an organization of Hawaiian suger-producing planiations.
The association publishes a manual, portions of which
were received in evidence as Defendants’ Exhilat 2. Majer
enterprises of the association, as set forth in this man-
nal, are quoted tn a publication of the United States De-
partment of Labor, entitled “The Economy of Hawaii in
47", Bulletin No, 926, prepared and transmitted to the
Congress of the United States pursuant to a requirement
contained in the Organic Law of the Territory of Hawaii,
1900, as amended April 3, 1904, 53 Stat. 164. A copy of
the publication was received in evidence as Defendants’
Exhibit 3B. An earlier report of the Department of
Labor, also rendered pursuant to the provisions of the
Oreanic Law of the Territory, was published uader the
title, “Labor in the Territory of Hawait— 1959", Bulletin
No. OST, House Document S48, 76th Cong. 3rd Sess. A
copy of this report was received in evidence as Defend.
ants’ Exhibit 3A.
As described in the manual issued by HSDPA, its fune-
tions are these:
“The Hawaiian Sugar Planters’ Association is an
organization of plantations and individuals united for
the purpose of cooperative improvement of the island
sugar industry as a whole... The asseciation’s major
enterprises are divided into the following depart
ments: Experiment station, bureau of laber ard
statisties, labor saving devices committee, boiler in-
oe
spection committee, public relations committee, labor
relations committee, legislative committee.
“The asseciation acts as a clearinghouse for all ae-
vites of the industry, making possible the freest
and quickest interchange of information among the
plantation executives. Tt maintains an office in Wash-
ington, D.C.) witeh handles all relations of the
Hawaiian sugar industry with Government depart-
ments and the Congress.” (Def. Ex. 3B, pp. 34-35.)
This statement of che functions of HSPA is supple-
mented as follows:
“The plantations are organized in an association
Which has planned for the Hawaiian sugar industries
as a Whole and which has developed the whole frame-
work of economie relations necessary to their exist-
ence on oan industry wide basis, including shipping,
the purchase of fertilizer, equipment and other sup-
plies, th development of mainland refineries and mar-
keos, the SUperviscon of tuanagement labor policies,
the maintenance o, research laboratories and the for-
mulation of commen programs of action for combat-
ing plant diseases, insect pests, and soil problems.”
(Def. Ex. 3B, p. 33.)
A further aspect of plaintiffs organization is found in
its relationship to Castle & Cooke, Ltd., an ageneyv or
factor with which i is connected (Def. Ex. 2). Coneern-
ing the relationship that exists between plantation and
factor, the HSPA manual declares as follows:
“While each of the 36 plantations in the Tlawaiian
Islands is a corporate enmity, all their affairs, except
the actual operation of sugar growing, are centralized
in What are known as factors, general agents offering
a multitude of ervicees to their chents. There are
five principal factors: Alexander & Baldwin, Ltd.,
American Factors, Ltd. C. Brewer Co., Ltd., Castle
& (‘ooke, Lted., 7. iH. Davies AN (‘o., Ltd.” (Def. Ex.
3B, p. 35.)
oy
The functions of the factors are summarized as follows
in the HSPA manual:
“Financial. All fiscal matters of the plantations are
handled by specialists in the offices of the factors.
Moneys are received and disbursed, tax statements
prepared, water and land rents paid or received,
surpluses invested, or deficits advanced.
“Experimental._-Engineers and other technicians are
constantly seeking ways to improve the output of the
various client plantations.
“Shipping.—-All the multitudinous detail of shipping
huge quantities of sugar by water to the mainland
ix in the hands of the factors.
“Merchandising.—Through their mainland buyers, the
factors previde a steady flow of needed merchandise
to plantation stores and to the plantations them-
selves. Because of the size of their operation, every-
thing a plantation and its personnel need is pro-
vided at a minimum cost.” (Def. Ex. 2)
The significance of the factor system is stated as fol-
lows:
“The long-run result of the agency system was thus
to deprive the plantations of their independence and
to transfer control to the factors, a control which has
heen further unified by the coordination of policies
and planning in the central offices of the Hawaiian
Sugar Planters’ Association.” (Def. Ex. 3B, p. 35).
These developments, as weil as many other aspects of
plaintiff's operations, would seem to be unique to the Ter-
ritory of Hawaii.
“In the sugar-producing areas of Louisiana, Puerto
Rico, and Philippines, and the sugar beet States, a
farming system had heen established before the de-
velopment of the sugar industry. As the farmers in
those areas already owned the land, sugar produe-
tion grew along the lines of the established farming
system.
G0
“The Hawaiian sugar industry, on the contrary, be-
gan on land which was undeveloped. * * * The land
tenure system in Hawaii is different from that in any
other part of the United States. It is a complex
outgrowth of the feudal system which existed before
annexation, under native Hawaiian royalty.” (Def.
Ex. 3B, pp. 32-33.)
The typical Hawaiian sugar plantation has been
described as a “small world in itself” (Def. Ex. 3A,
p. 70), whose “structural organization and functioning
* * * i, not unlike that of an army, with its clear cut
lines of authority and its careful program for attaining
given objectives” (Def, Ex. 3A, p. 14).
In immediate charge of plaintiff’s plantation is its plan-
tation manager, who is shown in a chart appearing under
the designation “Plantation Organizations” in the pub-
lished manual of HSPA (Def. Ex. 2), to have over-all
control of all plaintiff’s operations on the plantation, in-
cluding conduct of plaintiff’s villages. The designation
of the manager, and the authority exercised by him, have
been described as follows:
“The manager of the plantation is appointed by the
controlling ‘factor’ or agency. He has wide author-
ity over the plantation and the mill and exercises &
considerable influence over all community activities.
* * *#
“The plantation manager was the chief official and
central authority on all aspects of plantation life. In
addition to his technical knowledge regarding sugar
production, he had final responsibility in the diree-
tion and operation of sewerage and water system, of
the fire-protection systems, police force, the railroads,
and perrormed many of the functions that a mayor
would perform. He even sat as an informal judge on
eases involving minor disturbances and petty lar-
cenies.” (Def. Ex. 3B, pp. 36, 39).
61
Departmentalization of Plaintiff's Operations.
Plaintiff maintains an elaborate system of keeping de-
tailed records of all its costs and expenditures. All
pumps, locomotives, trucks, tractors, machines and im-
plements of machinery are given identification number,
and a record is made of the hours of work performed in
their maintenance, repair, and utilization. For each em-
ployee a daily timesheet is kept showing in detail what
his work consisted of, and to which operation or piece of
equipment it pertained. This information is transferred
to a weekly time record, which also carries data concern-
ing the employee’s rate of pay for the jobs performed by
him and his total compensation for the week. By use of
a further series of numbers, plaintiff records whether a
given piece of work represents a capital improvement or
a running expense charge.
[t appears from the testimony of plaintiff’s office man-
ager (Tr. 45-53) that its practice for nearly 20 vears has
been to keep separately identifiable sets of employee
records for its several departments. The main depart-
ments were described by him as follows:
1. Service Department, which includes the railroad and
truck operations, and the various shops: “. such as
the track shop (section repair shop), the P & H shop
(caneloading machine repair), the welding shop, machine
shop, paint shop, electric shop * * *”,
2. Factory Department, which covers employees of the
mill, commencing with “the emplovee who, when the cane
ear comes alongside the mill, weighs it and participates
in the job of releasing the cane from the car into the
container, the conveyor,” and ends with the loading of
sugar into freight cars or the warehouse adjacent to the
mill,
+. Warehouse Department.
62
4. Field Department, which embraces “preparing for
plowing, plowing, planting, ratooning, cultivating, irrigat-
ing, fertilizing, up to the time that the cane was
put on the main line of the plantation to take to the mill
*"* "in other words, where the permanent transportation
line took over.”
9. Village Facilities Department, covering painters,
plumbers, carpenters, and others who repaired, main-
tained and serviced plaintiff's villages, and the dwellings
locaied therein and occupied by plaintiff’s employees.
In addition to these main departments, there are a
number of others, also separately maintained. These
were identified as the office department, laboratory, civil
engineering, hospital, truck department, and agricultural
control and research.
The foregoing lengthy statement of the extent, nature,
and methods of operation of this large agricultural in-
dustrial enterprise is culled from testimony and largely
from a detailing written stipulation between the parties
of 771 pages, to which is attached a printed contract be-
tween the company and ILWU Local 145, Unit 7, together
with numerous maps, charts, and tabulations, all of which
is a material part of this trial.
This corporate enterprise was organized over a half
century ago and has shown continuing expansion and de-
velopment. With the exception of a few vears, it has
heen quite profitable to its agents and shareholders.
Part II
Commerce Coverage.
The activities of plaintiff described above constitute
the operation of an industry which is engaged in com-
merce and in the production of goods for commerce. In-
wey
(5
cluded in these activities are a number of separate and
distinct enterprises appropriate to the production of sugar
and molasses under the many and unique circumstances
out of which plaintiff's operations have developed and
taken form. In the conduct of these enterprises, plaintiff
has assumed a variety of functions including those of
farmer, carrier, manufacturer, shipper, and operator of
village communities. Plaintiff is, and the court finds it to
be, subject to the provisions of the Fair Labor Standards
Act.
Coverage under the Act for employees, so as to entitle
them to the benefit of minimum wage protection, and
payment of overtime for hours of work in excess of 40
per workweek, depends on whether they themselves are
engaged in commerce, or in the production of goods for
commerce (Sections 6(a) and 7(a) of the Act). Whether
an employee is to be held covered as one engaged in the
production of goods for commerce, depends on whether
he was employed either (a) in producing, manufacturing,
mining, handling, transporting, or in any other manner
working on such goods; or (b) in any process or oceupa-
tion necessary to the production thereof (Section 3(j) of
the Act). By Congressional amendment in 1949, the
words “closely related” have been inserted in the afore-
mentioned section before the word “process”, and the
words “directly essential” have been substituted for the
word “necessary”; but this amendment was not made re-
‘roactive, and has no application to the issues of this case.
Plaintiff does not dispute that its employees, with the
exception of a single group, are engaged in commerce or
in the production of goods for commerce, within the
meaning of the Act. The exception referred to relates to
the work of certain employees who perform the work of
repairing and maintaining plaintiff’s dwelling houses, and
furnishing related community facilities and services to
64
those who occupy such houses, these being in the ma
employees of plaintiff. As to such maintenance and 1
pair employees, the contention of plaintiff is that, wh
so engaged, they are not in any process or oecupati
necessary to the production of goods for commerce. D
termination of this aspect of the case is deferred to a su
sequent place in these findings. It is appropriate to fi
at this point, and it is found by the court, that all actin
ties of the defendants other than those coneerning whit
the issue of coverage under Section 3(j) is raised, a
and have been within the coverage of the law, such e1
ployees being either engaged in commerce or in the pr
duction of goods for commerce.
Recovery under the Act has two aspects. An employ
ix excluded if his activities are such that he is engage
neither in commerce, nor in producing goods for econ
merce (or engaged in an occupation necessary to produ
tion). On the other hand, an employee may be coveré
by the Act because he is engaged in the production «
goods for commerce or in an occupation necessary te suc
preduetion, but may not be entitled to the overtime pr
tection of the Act because of the applicability of one ¢
another of the exemption provisions. In this ease, plait
tiff relies on the following exemption provisions: Sectio
13(a)(6) (agricultural activity), Section 7(e) (suge
processing), Section 13(a)(2) (retail or service establisl
ment) and, in one instance, Section 13(a)(1) (administrs
tive or supervisorial activity),
The record shows that in numerous weeks various d¢
fendants worked for hours beyond 48, and in all such it
stances, hours of work beyond 48 were compensated a
overtime rates; this includes employees engaged in agr
cultural activities. Overtime was also paid for hours ji
excess of S per day, for work on certain designated hol:
davs, and when an emplevee was called to work on hi
Oo
scheduled day off. Since 1943, office and warehouse em-
ployees have received overtime for hours excess of 40 per
week; and during the off-season, overtime has been paid
for hours in excess of 40 per week to mill and shop em-
plovees.
The recovery of overtime pay sought in this action by
defendants is limited to hours in excess of 40 per week,
up to and including 48,
Agricultural Activities.
Plaintiff contends that all of. its employees are em-
ployed in agriculture, as the term “agriculture” is defined
in the Act, and are therefore exempt from the entire
operajons of the Aet, pursuant to Seetion 15(a)(6)
thereof. The definition of “agriculture” contained in See-
tion 3(f) is sufficiently broad to cover every operation of
preparing the soil, cultivation, growing of the sugar cane,
harvesting, and any practice performed by a farmer or
on a farm either as an incident to or in conjunction with
such farming operations, including preparation and de-
livery to market where this is done by farmers. An em-
ployee is therefore exempt from the protection of the Act
by virtue ef Section 13(a)(6) if, but only if. his work
falls within the specifie language of Section 3(f). Such,
too, has heen the interpretation expressed by the Admin-
istrator of the Act (Interpretative Bulletin No. 14).
Under this definition, activities exempt from applica-
tion of the Act with reference to the growing of sugar
eane at plaintiff's plantation, inelude the preparation of
suitable seedbed in the eane fields: planting: ratooning:
cultivating, spraving of fields with insecticides and herhi-
cides: elimination of competing weed growth: clearing of
stones: spreading of irrigation water and operation of
irrigation controls; laying, moving, or removal of. field
irrigation flame: patroling of irrigation diteh tines: clean-
66
ing and weeding of irrigation reservoirs, drainage ditches
and tunnels; fertilizing and other activities to improve
the physical condition of the soil; fire protection; activi-
ties designed to guarantee or improve the growth of the
crop; grading of cane fields; filling of holes, gulches and
ditches in fields; and harvesting operations performed to
remove the crop from its growing position in the fields.
These constitute farming operations, together with those
activities of an incidental and conjoint nature, such as
the picking up and reloading of cane stalks which have
fallen from cars, the laying and shifting of sectional
tracks in the fields, and the loading and moving of cane
cars placed upon movable tracks and assembling the har-
vested crop at centralized points on the main line rail-
road, to commence transportation to the mill. Employees
engaged in such operations, or in activities incidental to
or in conjunction with them, are eliminated from the pro-
tection of the Act while engaged in such practices.
In accordance with these findings, the work of defend-
ants which falls into one or another of the categories spe-
cified above, is exempt from operation of the Act, up to
and including the point at which the crop is harvested.
That point, which terminates the agricultural aspect of
plaintiff’s operations, occurs with the concentration of
cars loaded with cane, upon the main line railroad oper-
ated by plaintiff, for transport, through intermediate
processing, to the sugar refinery.
Transportation.
Plaintiff contends that the operation of its main line
railroad, and the work performed by its locomotive engi-
neers, firemen, brakemen, and other employees connected
with its railroad transportation system, are exempt both
under the agricultural exemption of Section 13(a)(6) and
the sugar processing exemption of Section 7(¢). The
67
latter section exempts employee: engaged in the process-
fu
ing of sugar cane into sugar (but not refined sugar), but
only when they are employed in a place of employment
Where the emplover is engaged in the act of processing
cane. The Administrator has interpreted this section to
exempt employees who directly engage in processing ac-
tivities, or who perform operations so closely associated
thereto that they cannot be segregated for practical pur-
poses, and whose work is also controlled by the irregular
movement of commodities to the establishment: provided
that sach work is performed in the place where the proc-
essing actually occurs (Interpretative Bulletin No. 14).
Congressional debates show that the purpose of the see-
tion was to relieve processors of seasonal agricultural
commodities from the hour provisions of the Act so as to
enable them more easily to conduct their operations dur-
ing the peak seasons (Interpretative Bulletin No, 14).
Neither Section 13(a)(6) nor 7(e) applies to the activi-
ties of plaintiff’s railroad employees. The train crews
are not engaged in any act of producing sugar cane, or in
any act incidental to or conjoint with the production of
sugar cane; nor in processing cane into sugar at the mill,
Where the processing oceurs. It is immaterial that they
are einployed by the same company which employs the
lfarmhands and processing crews, since the determination
of coverage must turn on the work of the employee.
“The mere fact that in this case the owners of the
farms are also the owners of the mill and the trans-
portation facilities does not make transportation inci-
dent to farming.
“There seems no rational basis for saving that sim-
ply because the ownership of the mill and the farms
is in the sane hands tha’, therefore, those employees
Who are engaged in an activity which is separate and
distinct from agriculture are exempt from the provi-
Os
sions of the Act.” (Calaf v. Gonzalez, 127 F.2d, 934,
937, £38.)
In determining whether an employee is exempt from the
Fair Labor Standards Act either under Section 7(e) or
Section 13(a)(6), the sole criterion is the character of
the work performed by the employee, as disclosed by the
record (Walling v. Jacksonville Paper Co., 317 U.S. 564;
A. B. Kirschbaum Co. vy. Walling, 316 U.S. 517; Walling
v. Snyder Min. Co., 66 F. Supp. 725). Section 7(c) does
not embrace activities which, though related and neces-
sary to mill operations, are not performed conjointly with
processing at the establishment where processing takes
place.
Railroad operation is a systematic business calling for
the employment of skilled, experienced men, trained to
quick, keen perception (not farmhands or mill hands) for
handling locomotives and moving cars (not the goods in
transit), and for the maintenance of roadbed, track and
structures, and roundhouse care and servicing of locomo-
tives—all specialized technical work. Railroading is not
farming or processing, nor intended by the Act to be a
part of either. Here, the transportation operations are
very substantial, occurring over many miles of trackage,
and hauling hundreds of thousands of tons each year;
and the investment in the railroad system, amounting to
nearly a million dollars, is quite considerable. Tt is no-
torious that in years past some sugar plantations in
Hawaii hired a common carrier utility company, whether
from economy or lack of capital, to install a railroad sys-
tem, to perform the work of hauling cane from fields to
mill vards.
If Congress had said that raw sugar production should
be given an exemption from the operation of the Aet, a
different situation would be presented. That Congress
saw fit not to do this, is in itself significant. The parts
69
of the Act here dealt with exempt agricultural or farming
activities on the one hand. and processing on .ne other.
The exemptions are separzte and different, one of them
applying both to minimum wages and. overtime hours,
and the other applying only to overtime hours, The
transportation system of plaintiff is such that it consti-
‘utes a separate activity, so distinct in its nature that it is
not reached by either of the exemptions.
Evidence given by plaintiff's office manager establishes
that the employees of the railroad svstem are not attached
to the Field Department or the Factory (Mill) Depart-
ment, but instead are carried on the payroll records of
the Service Department. Plaintiff has not treated the
railroad employees as within the exemption o° Section
15(a)(6), for during off-season these emplovees have been
paid overtime after 49 hours of work. Subsequent find-
ings on the activities performed by the railroad employees
disclose that they are not ordinary farmhands, and do not
perform agricultural activities. The railroad system is
operated as a year-round pursuit: the element of season-
ality does not enter into sugar production in the Territory
of Hawaii. “Continuity of employment in the production
of Hawaiian sugar is comparable to employment in man-
ufacturing operations that have minor seasonal fluctuations
rather than to typical mainland agricultural operations,
The equable climate of Hawaii makes possible the contin-
uous growth of sugar and it is technically possible to
9
carry on every type of operation every day in the year’
(Def. Ex. 3B, p. 64).
The operation of the railroad, as disclosed by this ree-
ord, is not a practice performed “in conjunction with”
farming operations. The activities of the railroad crew,
and of those employed in activities relating to mainte-
nance, upkeep and operation of the main line railroad
system, occur subsequently to and independently of the
70
farming activities, albeit coordinated thereto. On its rec
ords of operating costs, plaintiff distinguishes between
harvesting and iain line transportation.
Nor is the operation of the main line railroad “inciden-
tal” to the farming activities. The Administrater of the
Act regards transportation as more closely linked to
processing operations. This has been his view since 1943
(Administrator’s Release G-322). This view finds support
in several decisions of the United States Court of Ap-
peals for the First Circuit dealing with the Puerto Rico
sugar industry (Bowie v. Gonzalez, 117 F.2d 11; Calaf v.
fonzalez, 127 F.2d 934: Vives v. Serralles, 145 F.2d 552).
In those cases it is held that the transportation of case is
not incidental to farming and therefore not exempt under
Section 13(a)(6) (Calaf v. Gonzalez, supra, 127 F.2d at
936-937.} In Vives v. Serralles, supra, the agricultural
exemption was held to end at the point of concentration
of harvested cane, and this poin: was fixed as of the time
when eane loaded into cars was moved from portable
track onto the main line permanent tracks; at this point
the dividing line was fixed between activities exempt
under Section 13(a)(6), and activities not so exempt.
This seems a useful, logical and necessary point of
cleavage. Tt is also in accord with plaintiff’s long-estab-
lished practice, in the maintenance of its records, of
separating field activities from transportation at the point
where cane cars are placed on the main line railroad.
The sole object of plaintiff's operation is the production
of sugar and molasses: and as these are manufactured in
its mill, it might well be argued that operation of the mill
is the dominan: element, and that the growing of the raw
material, sugar cane, is the subordinate or incidental ele-
ment. It serves no purpose to resolve such an argument,
for it is clear that plaintiff engages in many separate en
terprises which, taken tocether, constitute a hvbrid type
al
v1
of business (see Phillips Co. v. Walling, 324 U.S. 490, at
495).
Hauling cane on the main line railroad is not a part of
harvesting operations, since the gathering of the crop is
completed on the fields on which it is grown prior to trans-
portation; and such transportation constitutes neither a
storing of such crops, nor transportation either to storage
or market. Transportation, as plaintiff engages in it, is a
necessary preliminary to the operation of plaintiff’s proe-
essing business in its mill, where the cane undergoes a
substantial change in order to create raw sugar, from
which state it is later further transformed into refined
sugar, the main product which is sold.
Portable track is laid on the fields where cane is grown;
but the permanent main line transportation is not located
on the farm in the same sense. True, it is located on the
plantation property, but the word “plantation” refers
simply to the geographical area of nearly ten thousand
acres on which plaintiff conducts all its operations. Ob-
viously cane ix not grown on the right-of-way oecupied by
the fifty-six miles of permanent main line railroad track.
Land is set aside exclusively for railroad purpose.
The point where the main line track is joined by the
portable track is the point at which harvested cane is
concentrated for transportation, and at this point the
agricultural exemption activity ceases and the railroad
operation commences,
The court finds that employees who are employed in
or on the roadbed, track, structures, cars and locomotives
of plaintiff's main line railroad system, including round-
house and rolling stock, repair and building shops, and
flagmen, watchmen and dispatchers, are not exempt from
the overtime provisions of the Act.
ad? |
i_
m Mill.
Plaintiff contends that employees whose work is per-
formed in the mill are exempt under both Sections 15ca)
(6) and 7(c). Mill activities commence immediately after
the produce has been delivered into plaintiffs storage
vard and brought alongside unloading platforms. Proe
essing begins with the weighing, unloading and cleaning
of the cane, and continues through crushing, juice treat-
ments, crystallizing, and the bagging of the product and
its removel from bagging and sewing machines, and its
deposit in an adjacent warehouse, bins, tanks, or directly
into cars or trucks for shipment. With these several
operations through the factory, the processing is begun
and finished in the place where the processor is so en-
gaged; that is to say, the entire operating plant devoted
to processing usage, whether within the mill itself or in
the open vard, and whether the work there performed is
mechanical or manual.
Such activities are not exempt under Section 13(a)(6).
The mill operations are so conducted as to assume the
character of a distinct business enterprise of an indus
trial nature; hence the mere fact that the processor is also
engaged in producing a farm crop, and is processing only
commodities grown by him, does not bring all of his opers-
tions within the Act’s definition of “agriculture”. The
processing of sugar cane is surely no Jess an industrial
operation than the stemming and fermenting of leaf. to-
bacco: these activilies were held to be non-agricultural
because they changed the form and nature of the erop
(McComb vy. Puerto Rico Tobacco Marketing Coopera-
tives Ass’n., 80 F.Supp. 95°. affirmed 181 F.2d 697).
The mill operation is not a subordinate part of farming;
it constitutes a large operation that follows the pattern of
the industry in the Territory of Hawaii. A separate
work force is employed for the processing operation in the
oy AE
mill; it does no work in the fields: it is paid in aceordance
with a seale of hourly rates which are different and dis-
tinet from tie system used, partly at contract rates and
partiy at hourly rates, to pay farm labor. On its payroll
records, and ia the Keeping of its accounts for purposes
of making income tax returns, jp aintiff segregates mill
employees from those ongaged in Celd activities. During
off-season, plainciff pay< overtime after 40 hours to em
plovees of the mill, but not until after 48 hours to em-
plovees engaged in the farm work,
The Court of Appeals for this ecireuit) has warned
against enlarging the term “acricultural laborer” bevond
the usual idea that it suggests. Enlargement bevond com-
on Usage would produce only confusion. The tes: laid
down is Whether the produet has been subjected to indus-
trial activity. Industrial activity commonly means the
treatinen. or processing of raw products in) factories
(North Whittier Heiqhes Citrus Assn ve NLRB. 100 F.2d
6, certiorari denied, 310 00S. 622. rehearing denied, 311
(oS. 724). This decision, although interpreting the agr’-
cultural exemption of a different act, has heen widely
followed iv its basie reasoning, and has reo thy been re-
affirmed in Willer v. Burger. V6) F2d 992,
The determination of this court. is superted lw the
Views recently eX pressed hoch hy the Solicitor ol Pr r
and the Administrator of the Wage-Hour Division (2
CCM L068 14071). Sinee 1941, the Administrator has
taken the pesition that the exemption for agricultural em
plovees “does net apply to sugar mill emplovees, even if
the only eane ground in sueh a mill is eane grown by the
savar mill owner in his own fields” ( Administrator’-
Release RSG, published in 1942 ed. WEE Mannal, p. 408)
I is also the enurreni view of the Board whieh adm nis
ters the National Labor Relations Set, which by Conere-
= ¢
ia
«nal direction contains the same definition of “agrieul-
uve” that is to be found in the Fair Labor Standards
Act (Im Re Imperial Garden Growers, 26 L RRM 1652, 91
NLRB No. 167). See also Vives, Bowie, and Calaf cases,
supra.
It is clear, hewever, that the activities under discus-
sion are covered by the sugar processing exemption. —Ae-
cordingly the work of employees which takes place in the
mill, im connection with the operation of processing ma
el nery and activities closely and intimately connected
therewith, are exempt under Section 7(¢).
Several activities, while occurring in the mill, are not
exempt because they do not constitute a part of the proe-
essing operations. Activities performed on bagasse, a
by-product which is used for fuel, are not exempt because
such activities do not constiute the processing of cane to
obtain sugar or svrup, nor is it processed to obtain
bagasse. The exemption is limited to the processing of
cane into sugar or into syrup. This finding coincides with
the long-established view of the Administrator (Interpre-
tative Bulletin No. 14).
Where an emplovee’s activities are connected with gen-
eration of electricity, seme of which is used in the mill,
but also in many other operations, including the lighting
of employees’ houses, administrative offices, repair and
service shops, and the sale of surplus amounts te a public
utility company, the exemption does not apply because
of the commingling of exempt with non-exempt activities
in the same workweek. The matter of commingling ils
later discussed in greater detail in these findings,
Wrekend Shutdown.
At the earlier trial, the defendants eontended and the
eourt held. that the activities in and about the mill during
weekend shutdown, whieh consist of cleaning and minor
« oper 4
ey
repairs, Were not exempt under Section 7(¢), for the rea-
son that they occur at a time when no processing is tak-
ing place. In consequence, an employee who performed
4) hours of exempt work in connection with processing
operations, and additional hours of work during the week-
end shutdown, was held to be non-exempt for the entire
week,
Upon additional evidence and a new record in this re-
trial, and reconsideration of this issue, it would appear
hat the week-end activities in the mill should not be held
to defeat the exemption provided by Section 7(c). While
the shutdown period consists of 24 consecutive hours,
processing Operations are not completely suspended dur-
ing that interval. The ervystallization processes of sugar
remaining in the machines continue. Key employees in
the firerooom, boiler room, and power house remain en-
gaged in their regular activities. Though it is impossible
to crreumseribe with exactness the period during which
no processing of sugar, in the literal sense, takes place,
it would seem tha’ such period comes to but a few hours,
less perhaps than a full working shift, and partaking
partly of the end of one shift and partly of the early por-
tion of the next.
Eimplovees who engage in the weekend cleaning and re-
pair activities, work solely within the mill, and upon the
very processing machinery which they operate during the
remainder of the week. These employees also do the
same kind of work while the mill is in operation, as an
incidental activity connected with processing. In- such
‘ireinastances, and in light of the exemption which Con-
rress intended should be enjoved under Section 7(e), the
non processing activities in the mill during weekend shut-
down would appear to be too ineidental and subordinate
2 factor ta defeat exemption
76
Acveordingly, the court finds upon this record that the
activities performed during weekend shutdown in the mill
are no: such as to defeat exemption, if it is otherwise
applicable.
Off-Season.
The annual shutdown of the mill during the so-called
off-season is a period when there is a total cessation of
processing operations. Machinery and equipment located
in the mill are completely overhauled, major repairs are
made, and new machinery is insteited. Generally the mill
is shut down for a period ef between 3 and 5 months.
According to the evidence, plaintiff's off-season lasted 5
months in 1941; 314 months in 1942; 3’ months in 1943;
4 months in 1944: 3% months in 1945. In 1946, it ran
from December 22 to February 9, a period of 7 weeks;
this was an unusually short off-season, and doubtless re-
lates to the occurrence of a strike lasting from September
1 to November 19, 1946.
During the off-season, mill employees engage exclusively
in major cleaning and repair work, in overall preparation
for the subsequent reopening of the mill. Additional mea
are brought in from other departments to participate in
the overhaul which occurs in and about the mill, its ma-
chinery and equipment. Field employees are brought into
the repair and service shops, to supplement the regular
erews, because of the increased load of work. These facts
not only establish the substantial nature of the off-season
operation in preserving and enhancing capital invest-
ment*, but also account for the maintenance by plaintiff
of a stable labor supply throughout the year, during
*“In October 1947 the HSPA Plantation News stated: ‘Esti-
mates of the amount of money being spent in 1947 and 1948 for
improvements and new equipment or sugar plantations run as
high as $20,000,000 and actual outlays may be even higher.’ ” (Def.
Ex. 38, p. 40.)
which the nun ber of man-days of work performed does
not vary, regardless of season.
Not a particle of sugar is processed in the off-season.
[t is plain, and the court finds, that the work which
takes place in the mill during off-season is not exempt
under Section 7(c). This holding produces no ineconsis-
tency with the finding in regard to weekend shutdown,
inasmuch as the two differ vastly in purpose, nature,
scale, and duration.
It has long been the Administrator’s view that the
exemptions provided by Section 7(¢) do not apply during
any dead season or off-season, when processing activities
are suspended entirely for a substantial and prolonged
period of time (Administrator’s Release R-1892: Jan. 25,
1943). This view has been uniformly upheld by the
courts. Such was the ruling in the sugar industry in
Puerto Rico in the ease of Maisonnet v. Central Colosso,
Inc., 2 WH Cas. 755: and the decision has been the same
in reference to the cotton seed processing industry
(Heburg v. Independent Oil Mill, Inc. 5 WH Rents. 777
(W.D. Tenn.); Abram v. San Joaquin Cotton Oil Co., 49
F.Supp. 393, 6 WH Repts. 312 (S.D. Cal.)).
It is also worthy of note that plaintiff has paid, for a
“umber of years, and throughout the period covered by
this action, overtime for hours of work in excess of 40,
‘© all mill hands, employees of the repair and = service
‘hops, and others who participate in the off-season work
in and about the mill.
Repair and Service Shops.
Plaintiff claims that the employees of its repair shops
ire exempt both as agricultural emplovees and under the
‘ugar processing exemption.
18
The agricultural exemption of Section 13(a)(6) is in-
applicable. Machine shop men, welders, electricians,
painiers, carpenters, and others employed in the repair
shop department, perform no work of an agricultural
nature, or at a time or place conjoint with or incidental
to the farming process, or on a “farm” in the sense in
which that term is used in the statute. Plaintiff itself
has always regarded these employees as a unit separate
from the field employees. In the structure of plaintiff’s
business, agricultural workers comprise the Field Depart-
ment; employees of the repair shops comprise the Serv-
ice Department. Workers in these respective categories
are carried on separate and distinct pay-rolls. For cost
accounting and income tax return purposes, plaintiff makes
the same distinction in its records between these depart-
treated repair shop employees as falling under the agri- —
cultural exemption, inasmuch as, during off-season, repair
shop employees have been paid overtime for hours of |
work in excess of 40 per week; this, of course, is a pay-
ment not required to be made to employees engaged in —
agricultural work, whether it be off-season or grinding —
season.
Neither is Section 7(c) applicable to exempt these em-
ployees. Their work is not that of engaging in process:
ing, or in any part of processing, nor is their work so |
integrated with processing as to be a portion thereof,
incapable of segregation. Plaintiff has not treated the
repair shop employees as part of its mill operations. —
Pavrolis and cost accounting records for income tax pur-
poses show the employees of repair shops separately from
the mill hands. The activities of repair shop employees
relate not alone to the mill, but to all aspects of planta-
tion operations, including the field, village facilities, ad
ministration huiding, ete.
79
Repair shop employees are not occupationally attached
to the mill, The headquarters out of which they work
is in each instance a separate structure, in. which they
generally perform the major portion of their work, to
which they regularly report each day, and in which they
receive supervision and instructions. These structures
are located at varying distances, up to 300 feet, from the
mill. When occasion requires them to be elsewhere than
in their shops, they perform services for every operation
on the plantation, not the mill exclusively. Most of them
do not generally perform work inside the mill building,
except during off-season, when processing is suspended.
They are under separate foremen and supervisors. There
is no interchange shown, during the grinding season, of
personnel, equipment, or materials between the mill and
the repair shops.
It is plain that the repair shops constitute, and they
are found to be, self-sufficient units, operated not as an
incident to any other operation exclusively or dominantly, |
but rather as an integral part of the over-all combination
of separate enterprises jointly conducted by plaintiff. If
the employees of an independent machine repair shop per-
formed the repair activities under discussion, they would
not be exempt from the overtime provisions of the Act.
The fact that such work was done by employees of plain-
tiff, under the circumstances here presented, affords no
stronger basis for applying the exemption.
This determination coincides with the view expressed by
the Administrator, both in his official releases (Interpre-
tative Bulletin No. 14) and in the position asserted in a
brief filed by him in this case with the Court of Appeals.
Judicial authority treating of the same issue likewise sup-
ports this finding. In Walling v. Bridqgeman-Russeli Co.,
2 WH Cas. 785, (District) Judge Bell held that the term
“place of employment” as used in Seetion 7(¢), means
Sd)
those portions of the establishment devoted by the em-
plover to the actual processing operations, hence the ex-
emption does not apply to employees who perform their
duties at places not devoted to processing operations. He
held th. exemption inapplicable to electricians, carpenters,
tinsmiths, firemen, engineers, garage employees who
washed and greased trucks, watchmen, janitors, ware-
housemen, and laboratory technicians, although the de-
gree of separateness and specialization in that case does
not appear to approach the situation in the instant ease.
In Walling v. DeSo'o Creamery & Produce Co., 51 F.
Supp. 9388 at 943 (D.C. Minn.), employees who worked at
grading, packing and leading poultry, in a room adjacent
to the one where slaughtering and dressing operations
occurred, were held not employed in a place of employ-
ment where the exempt processing activity was per-
formed; this was the holding despite the fact that the
activities held non-exempt were performed on the proe-
essed product. In the case at bar, the employees under
discussion do not handle cane, sugar, syrup, or molasses;
their activities are confined to working on machinery,
equipment, and structures.
The crucial point is that Section 7(¢) does not exempt
entire industries from the overtitne provisions of the Act,
but only the specific processes therein mentioned. Thus,
while the activities of employees engaged in handling,
slaughtering and dressing operations in a meat packing
plant were held exempt, employees in other departments,
such as those engaged in meat-curing and sausage-mak-
ing, were held outside the scope of the exemption provided
in Section 7T(c) (Fleming v. Swift & Co., 41 F. Supp. 825,
affirmed 131 F.2d 249). To the same effect, see Colbeck
Dairyland Creamery Co., 17 NW, 2d 262 (S.D.). See
also Shain v. Armour & Co., 50 FL Supp. 907° and Mc-
Comb vy. del Valle, 15 Lab. Cas. 74,679 (D.C. P.R.).
Sl
Vill Village Main‘enance.
Plaintiff contends that its employees who perform re-
pair and maintenance work on company dwellings occu-
pied by plaintiff's emplovees, and who supply village serv-
ies and facilities to the employees living in the planta-
tion villages where these houses are located, are excluded
from coverage under the Act upon the ground that they
do not work in anv process or occupation necessary to the
production of goods for commerce. Alternatively, if this
contention is overruled, plaintiff invokes the exemptions
of Sections 13(a)(6) and 13(a) (2
The question of coverage is plainly one that must be
decided upon the facts peculiar to each case. The Ad-
ministrator has expressly left the question of coverage
open, evidentiv recognizing that decision might well vary
with the given situation. No court decision has been
found that passes squarely on facts similar to those here
present.
Work of a repair and service nature has frequently
heen held covered by the Aci as a type of activity neces-
sary to the production of goods for commerce. A few
decisions of this kind may be noted: Repair of boats used
in interstate ecommerce (Walling v. F. S. Lowe & Son
Boatways, 5 WH Cas. 937); mechanical work for an in-
dependent machine corporation whose chief business con-
sisted in servicing the tools and equipment of a company
engaged in mining and shipping of coal in interstate com-
merce (Princeton Mining Co. v. Veach, 5 WH Cas. 734) ;
pain ing, repairing, and reconstructing trucks which were
brought to the emplover’s plant and by customers who
owned them, and which were used in the interstate trans-
portation of goods (Walling v. Sturm & Sons, 6 WH Cas.
131): maintenance men, mechanics, and mechanics’ help-
ers who worked at garages on trucks leased by their em-
plover to eustomers making subsiantial use of the trucks
82
in interstate commerce (Skidmore v. Casale, Inc.. 6 WH
Cas. 33). Also to the point are Claudio y. Sobrinos De
Portilla, Inc., 5 WH Cas. 484, holding the Act applicable
to employees of a corporation operating a factory and
machine shop, the greater part of whose business was the
repair and servicing of industrial concerns producing
sugar for commerce; and Agos'o v, Rocafort, 5 WH Cas.
176, holding the Act applicable to a mechnic engaged in
repairing and overhauling trucks operated by an employer
in a trucking business used chiefly to transport cargo
from concerns producing sugar, to be shipped in com-
merce.
Maintenance workers, watchmen, and similar employ-
ments have also been held covered. These employments
were held covered in McCombl v. Russell Co., 17 Lab. Cas.
76,781: by the United States Court of Appeals for the
Fourth Cireuit in Slover v. Wathen, 140 F.2d 258; by the
United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cireuit
in Engebretsen v. FE. J. Albrecht Co., 150 F.2d 602: and
by the Supreme Court in Walton v. Southern Package
Corp., 320 U.S. 540, anc in A. B. Kirschbaum Co. Vv.
Walling, 316 U.S. 517.
These decisions are readily distinguishable from the
situation at hand, in that the employees involved therein
performed work or services in, upon or directly relating
to the very buildings, equipment, or instrumentalities
which were used in the production of goods for com-
ineree, The ease here presented is one step removed, in
that the repair and maintenance work is performed in
and upon, and the service is rendered for the dwelling
houses inhabited by plaintiff's production employees.
A series of cases, which have come to be known as the
cookhouse or cafeteria cases, deal with an analogous sit-
uation. In Consolidated Timber Co. vy. Womack, 132 F.2d
101, the United States Court of Appeals for this cireuit
83
held the Act applicable to a baker emploved in one of two
cookhouses operated by a corporation engaged in logging
and lumbering. It was held that the cookhouse was a
necessary part of the company’s production of goods for
commerce, operated not with the intent or purpose of
showing a profit to the owners from the sale of food or
service, but rather to render a necessary assistance to the
company’s business, which was tha: of producing logs in
interstate commerce:
aad |
‘he cookhouse was not a separate or independent
establishment; it was actually a part of the company’s
facilities—a link in the chain—whereby it operated
its business and a means whereby it accomplished
the purpose of its existence. Neither ecookhouse was
in competition with any private restaurant for there
is no evidence of an effort to secure the patronage
of the general public; the service was sold at cost to
those whom the cookhouse was intended to serve:
the loggers. The principal activity of the eookhouse
definitely was not to furnish service to the consuming
public, as such, but was to serve the emplovees of the
company.” (Page 107)
The job of the cookhouse employee was held to assist the
activities of the loggers by keeping their board close to
their place of work, thus rendering it easier for the cor-
poration to maintain a proper organization of its loggers,
and forwarding their work by furnishing the food where-
by the men were given the strength to pursue their labors.
Many cases are in accord with this deeision. The
United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Cireuit,
in Hanson v. Lagerstrom, 133 F.2d 120, followed our cir-
eut, holding the Act applicable to one who assisted in
preparing and serving meals, and maintaining a kitchen
operated to benefit employees of a concern engaged in
handling pulpwood, which was then eonverted into prod.
ucts sold in interstate commerce. A federal distrie: court
in Indiana held the Aet appl eable to a nicht Inanacer
S4
employed by the owner of a cafeteria located in a war
plant, to serve employees working in the plant who manu-
factured war materials shipped in interstate commerce;
the cafeteria, though independently owned, was held an
integral part of the organization of the manufacturer, and
a necessary part of the facilities used by the manufac-
turer (Ferguson vy. Prophet Co., 6 WH Cas. 284). A
federal district judge in Massachusetts similarly applied
the Act to employees working in their employer’s commis-
sary, which was located in a railroad stetion and served
as a kitchen and storeroom for the employer’s retail
stands and train service Gepartment in the same station,
and for the employer’s retail stands in railroad stations
in other cities (Walling vy. Arms/rong Co., 5 WH Cas.
474). Employees in a canteen and cafeteria operated, on
premises of Republic Steel Corporation, by an independ-
ent restaurant concern were held covered in McComb v.
Factory Stores Co., 81 F. Supp. 403; coverage of the Act
was there decided in favor of cooks, assistants, counter
girls, dishwashers, and porters. The Supreme Court of
Michhigan held the Act applicable to employees engaged
in preparing food at plant cafeterias owned and operated
by a large industrial corporation which sells food solely
to plant workers during their lunch and rest periods
(Basik v. General Motors Corp., 5 WH Cas. 1061).
The foregoing decisions turn on the finding that the
work performed by such service employees is itself a
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.