Emergency Application — Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al., Applicants v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, et al.
Supreme Court briefOct 21, 2026
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX
Department of Homeland Security, Determination Pursuant to Section 102 of the
Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, as
Amended, 91 Fed. Reg. 34,831 (June 9, 2026) .................................................................. 1a
Department of Homeland Security, Determination Pursuant to Section 102 of the
Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, as
Amended, 91 Fed. Reg. 40,550 (July 2, 2026) ................................................................... 4a
Department of Homeland Security, Determination Pursuant to Section 102 of the
Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, as
Amended, 91 Fed. Reg. 46,939 (July 27, 2026) ................................................................. 7a
Defendants’ preliminary injunction hearing exhibits 2-5 (Oct. 2, 2026) ................................ 9a
Preliminary injunction hearing transcript (Oct. 2, 2026)..................................................... 26a
District court order granting preliminary injunction (Oct. 2, 2026) .................................. 202a
District court memorandum opinion (Oct. 14, 2026) .......................................................... 204a
Third Declaration of Paul Enriquez, D. Ct. Doc. 74-1 (Oct. 8, 2026) ................................ 218a
Declaration of Josh B. Barrett, D. Ct. Doc. 74-2 (Oct. 8, 2026) ......................................... 225a
District court order denying stay (Oct. 21, 2026) ............................................................... 233a
(I)
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 110 / Tuesday, June 9, 2026 / Notices
• Surgical Sciences, Biomedical
Imaging and Bioengineering
Integrated Review Group
• Vaccine Research Center Board of
Scientific Counselors National
Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Diseases
• Vascular and Hematology Integrated
Review Group
5. Justification that the information or
advice provided by the Federal advisory
committee or subcommittee is not
available from another Federal advisory
committee, another Federal Government
source, or any other more cost-effective
and less burdensome source:
All members of the CCRHB are
directly or indirectly associated with
biomedical research, and upon
acceptance of CCRHB appointment,
each member is fully introduced to the
unique aspects of the CC hospital which
exists to provide safe delivery of
patient-centric care in support of
scientific research aligned with public
health needs. Each year approximately
10,000 new research participants are
seen at the CC as active partners in
medical discovery, a partnership that
has resulted in a long list of medical
milestones, including the first cure of a
solid tumor with chemotherapy, gene
therapy, and the use of AZT to treat
AIDS. The CC differs from other
hospitals as it is not a general hospital,
nor is it a part of a health system. There
is no trauma care, no emergency room,
no labor and delivery and no billing
department. The mission of the CC is to
provide hope through pioneering
clinical research to improve human
health. With our patient partners, the
CC proudly is referenced as the ‘‘House
of Hope.’’ The Board members’
recommendations are invaluable
because the complex nature of the CC’s
clinical research mission requires a
unique balance and breadth of expertise
not available at NIH or from other
established sources. This advice and
unique, expert perspectives cannot be
obtained through other mechanisms.
6. If the consultation is a committee
renewal, a summary of the previous
accomplishments of the committee and
the reasons it needs to continue:
The CCRHB is the sole entity to
provide advice about hospital
operations aligned with the CC’s clinical
research priorities. As such, the
CCRHB’s focus is on the complementary
aims of achieving the highest standards
of safety for research participants and
the CC community, while fostering an
environment of cutting-edge highimpact research to improve the health of
Americans.
2016: The CCRHB recommended the
submission of regular reports to the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:00 Jun 08, 2026
Jkt 268001
Board addressing Patient Safety &
Quality Performance Metrics. This topic
became a ‘standing item’ for all Board
meetings and members continue to
receive a Current Executive Dashboard
Report on Clinical and Safety
Performance Metrics one week prior to
each meeting for review. The CEO
Presentation includes reference to these
standing reports; and the CEO solicits
discussion or questions from the Board,
then reports are posted on the CC’s
website for public review.
2016—Present: Annual reports to the
CCRHB are delivered by the Director,
Office of Research Facilities. These
reports generate discussions for planned
or ongoing facility changes that directly
or indirectly affect CC patients,
researchers, staff, and the CC
community. In October 2019, all Board
members signed a letter to the NIH
Director, ultimately shared with
Congress during budget discussions, to
address needed funding for NIH
maintenance issues and facility projects
to improve environment of care and
specialized capabilities requests,
including construction of the new
Surgery, Radiology and Laboratory
Medicine Wing.
A key accomplishment of the CCRHB
in 2022 was to provide a comprehensive
review and assessment of pediatric care
at the CC, focused on the delivery of
care to children, current clinical
research studies, and setting a vision to
consider for the future of pediatric
research. With the assistance of a
working group that included pediatric
leaders from across the country, the
CCRHB provided advice that identified
strengths and areas of focused
improvement to be considered going
forward.
7. Explanation of why the committee/
subcommittee is essential to the conduct
of agency business:
The CCRHB was created in 2016 as
recommended by the Advisory
Committee to the NIH Director
following results of an FDA visit and
review of hospital operations. Per the
CCRHB charter, the purpose of the
Board is to advise, consult with, and
make recommendations to the NIH
Principal Deputy Director (or designee)
and the CEO with respect to
maintaining excellence in hospital
operations, safety and quality, unique
clinical research care requirements for
CC patients, regulatory compliance,
clinical research, and hospital
leadership performance oversight.
Currently in its 9th year, the CCRHB has
provided expert guidance and
recommendations related to most
aspects of CC operations.
PO 00000
Frm 00026
In conclusion, this public interest
determination documents that renewing
the committee is in the public interest,
essential to the conduct of agency
business, and that the information to be
obtained is not already available
through another advisory committee or
source within the Federal Government.
Inquiries may be directed to Patricia
Brandt Hansberger, Acting Director,
Office of Federal Advisory Committee
Policy, Office of the Director, National
Institutes of Health, 6701 Democracy
Boulevard, Suite 1000, Bethesda,
Maryland 20892 (Mail code 4875),
Telephone (301) 496–2123, or
patricia.hansberger@nih.gov.
Dated: June 3, 2026.
Denise M. Santeufemio,
Supervisory Program Analyst, Office of
Federal Advisory Committee Policy.
[FR Doc. 2026–11519 Filed 6–5–26; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 4167–05–P
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES
National Institutes of Health
Center for Scientific Review; Amended
Notice of Meeting
Notice is hereby given of a change in
the meeting of the Molecular and
Structural Immunology Study Section,
June 25, 2026, 09:30 a.m. to June 25,
2026, 06:00 p.m., National Institutes of
Health, Rockledge II, 6701 Rockledge
Drive, Bethesda, MD 20892 which was
published in the Federal Register on
May 21, 2026, 91 FR 29973 FR Doc No.
2026–10231.
The meeting is being amended to
change the contact person from Velasco
Cimica to Katie Alexander. The meeting
is closed to the public.
Dated: June 5, 2026.
Bruce A. George,
Program Analyst, Office of Federal Advisory
Committee Policy.
[FR Doc. 2026–11541 Filed 6–8–26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4167–05–P
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
SECURITY
Office of the Secretary
Determination Pursuant to Section 102
of the Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996,
as Amended
AGENCY: Office of the Secretary,
Department of Homeland Security.
ACTION: Notice of determination.
(1a)Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\09JNN1.SGM 09JNN1
Fmt 4703
34831
34832
2a
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 110 / Tuesday, June 9, 2026 / Notices
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
SUMMARY: The Secretary of Homeland
Security has determined, pursuant to
law, that it is necessary to waive certain
laws, regulations, and other legal
requirements in order to ensure the
expeditious construction of barriers and
roads in the vicinity of the international
land border in the state of Texas. The
notice of determination was published
in the Federal Register on May 15,
2026. The project area description in the
May 15, 2026, notice of determination
was incorrect. This document is a
republication of the May 15, 2026,
document with the correct project area
description.
DATES: This determination takes effect
on June 9, 2026.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Important
mission requirements of the Department
of Homeland Security (‘‘DHS’’) include
border security and the detection and
prevention of illegal entry into the
United States. Border security is critical
to the nation’s national security.
Recognizing the critical importance of
border security, Congress has mandated
DHS to achieve and maintain
operational control of the international
land border. Secure Fence Act of 2006,
Public Law 109–367, section 2, 120 Stat.
2638 (Oct. 26, 2006) (8 U.S.C. 1701
note). Congress defined ‘‘operational
control’’ as the prevention of all
unlawful entries into the United States,
including entries by terrorists, other
unlawful aliens, instruments of
terrorism, narcotics, and other
contraband. Id. Consistent with that
mandate, the President’s Executive
Order on Securing Our Borders directs
that I take all appropriate action to
deploy and construct physical barriers
to ensure complete operational control
of the southern border of the United
States. Executive Order 14165, section 3
(Jan. 20, 2025).
Congress has provided to the
Secretary of Homeland Security a
number of authorities necessary to carry
out DHS’s border security mission. One
of those authorities is found at section
102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform
and Immigrant Responsibility Act of
1996, as amended (‘‘IIRIRA’’). Public
Law 104–208, Div. C, Tit. I, section 102,
110 Stat. 3009–546, 3009–554 (8 U.S.C
1103 note), as amended by the REAL ID
Act of 2005, Public Law 109–13, Div. B,
Tit. I, section 102, 119 Stat. 302, 306 (8
U.S.C. 1103 note), as amended by the
Secure Fence Act of 2006, Public Law
109–367, section 3, 120 Stat. 2638 (8
U.S.C. 1103 note), as amended by the
Department of Homeland Security
Appropriations Act, 2008, Public Law
110–161, Div. E, Tit. V, section 564, 121
Stat. 2042, 2090. In section 102(a) of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:00 Jun 08, 2026
Jkt 268001
IIRIRA, Congress provided that the
Secretary of Homeland Security shall
take such actions as may be necessary
to install additional physical barriers
and roads (including the removal of
obstacles to detection of illegal entrants)
in the vicinity of the United States
border to deter illegal crossings in areas
of high illegal entry into the United
States. In section 102(b) of IIRIRA,
Congress mandated that in carrying out
the authority of section 102(a), I provide
for the installation of additional fencing,
barriers, roads, lighting, cameras, and
sensors to achieve and maintain
operational control of the border.
Finally, in section 102(c) of IIRIRA,
Congress granted to the Secretary of
Homeland Security the authority to
waive all legal requirements that I, in
my sole discretion, determine necessary
to ensure the expeditious construction
of barriers and roads authorized by
section 102 of IIRIRA.
Determination and Waiver
Section 1
The United States Border Patrol Big
Bend Sector is an area of high illegal
entry. Between fiscal year 2021 and
fiscal year 2025, Border Patrol
apprehended over 89,000 illegal aliens
attempting to enter the United States
between border crossings in the Big
Bend Sector. In that same time period
Border Patrol seized over 87,574 pounds
of marijuana, over 867 pounds of
cocaine, over 1,156 pounds of
methamphetamine, over 12 pounds of
heroin, and over 94 pounds of fentanyl.
Since the President took office, DHS
has delivered the most secure border in
history. More can and must be done,
however. As the statistics cited above
demonstrate, the Big Bend Sector is an
area of high illegal entry where illegal
aliens regularly attempt to enter the
United States and smuggle illicit drugs,
and given my mandate to achieve and
maintain operational control of the
border, I must use my authority under
section 102 of IIRIRA to install
additional barriers and roads in the Big
Bend Sector. Therefore, DHS will take
immediate action to construct
additional barriers and roads in a
segment of the border in the Big Bend
Sector. The segment where such
construction will occur is referred to
herein as the ‘‘project area,’’ which is
more specifically described in Section 2
below.
Section 2
I determine that the following area in
the vicinity of the United States border,
located in the state of Texas within the
U. S. Border Patrol Big Bend Sector is
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
an area of high illegal entry (the ‘‘project
area’’): Starting at approximately GPS
point 29.325866, –104.046466 and
extending east to approximately GPS
point 29.728522, ¥102.683945.
There is presently an acute and
immediate need to construct additional
physical barriers and roads in the
vicinity of the border of the United
States in order to prevent unlawful
entries into the United States in the
project area pursuant to section 102(a)
and 102(b) of IIRIRA. In order to ensure
the expeditious construction of
additional physical barriers and roads in
the project area, I have determined that
it is necessary that I exercise the
authority that is vested in me by section
102(c) of IIRIRA.
Accordingly, pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA, I hereby waive in their
entirety, with respect to the
construction of physical barriers and
roads (including, but not limited to,
accessing the project areas, creating and
using staging areas, the conduct of
earthwork, excavation, fill, and site
preparation, and installation and
upkeep of physical barriers, roads,
supporting elements, drainage, erosion
controls, safety features, lighting,
cameras, and sensors) in the project
area, all of the following statutes,
including all federal, state, or other
laws, regulations, and legal
requirements of, deriving from, or
related to the subject of, the following
statutes, as amended: The National
Environmental Policy Act (Pub. L. 91–
190, 83 Stat. 852 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et
seq.)); the Endangered Species Act (Pub.
L. 93–205, 87 Stat. 884 (16 U.S.C. 1531
et seq.)); the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (commonly referred to as
the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1251 et
seq.)); the National Historic Preservation
Act (Pub. L. 89–665, 80 Stat. 915, as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287 (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 470 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 100101 note and 54 U.S.C.
300101 et seq.)); the Migratory Bird
Treaty Act (16 U.S.C. 703 et seq.); the
Migratory Bird Conservation Act (16
U.S.C. 715 et seq.); the Clean Air Act (42
U.S.C. 7401 et seq.); the Archeological
Resources Protection Act (Pub. L. 96–95
(16 U.S.C. 470aa et seq.)); the
Paleontological Resources Preservation
Act (16 U.S.C. 470aaa et seq.); the
Federal Cave Resources Protection Act
of 1988 (16 U.S.C. 4301 et seq.); the
National Trails System Act (16 U.S.C.
1241 et seq.); the Safe Drinking Water
Act (42 U.S.C. 300f et seq.); the Noise
Control Act (42 U.S.C. 4901 et seq.); the
Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended
by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.);
E:\FR\FM\09JNN1.SGM
09JNN1
3a
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 110 / Tuesday, June 9, 2026 / Notices
the Comprehensive Environmental
Response, Compensation, and Liability
Act (42 U.S.C. 9601 et seq.); the
Archaeological and Historic
Preservation Act (Pub. L. 86–523, as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287 (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 469 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 312502 et seq.)); the Antiquities
Act (formerly codified at 16 U.S.C. 431
et seq. and 16 U.S.C. 431a et seq., now
codified 54 U.S.C. 320301 et seq.); the
Historic Sites, Buildings, and
Antiquities Act (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 461 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 320301–320303 & 320101–
320106); the Eagle Protection Act (16
U.S.C. 668 et seq.); the Native American
Graves Protection and Repatriation Act
(25 U.S.C. 3001 et seq.); the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
551 et seq.); Section 438 of the Energy
Independence and Security Act (42
U.S.C. 17094); the National Fish and
Wildlife Act of 1956 (Pub. L. 84–1024
(16 U.S.C. 742a, et seq.)); the Fish and
Wildlife Coordination Act (Pub. L. 73–
121 (16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.)); the
Farmland Protection Policy Act (7
U.S.C. 4201 et seq.); the Wild Horse and
Burro Act (16 U.S.C. 1331 et seq.); 43
U.S.C. 387; the Wild and Scenic Rivers
Act (Pub. L. 90–542 (16 U.S.C. 1281 et
seq.); the Federal Land Policy and
Management Act (Pub L. 94–579 (43
U.S.C. 1701 et seq.)); the Wilderness Act
(Pub. L. 88–577 (16 U.S.C. 1131 et seq.));
the National Park Service Organic Act
and the National Park Service General
Authorities Act (Pub. L. 64–235, 39 Stat.
535 and Pub. L. 91–383, 84 Stat. 825 as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287, 128 Stat. 3094 (formerly
codified at 16 U.S.C. 1, 2–4 and 16
U.S.C. 1a-1 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 100101–100102, 54 U.S.C.
100301–100303, 54 U.S.C. 100501–
100507, 54 U.S.C. 100701–100707, 54
U.S.C. 100721–100725, 54 U.S.C.
100751–100755, 54 U.S.C. 100901–
100906, 54 U.S.C. 102101–102102)); 16
U.S.C. 156; 16 U.S.C. 157; 16 U.S.C.
157c; and 16 U.S.C. 157d.
This waiver does not revoke or
supersede any other waiver
determination made pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA. Such waivers shall
remain in full force and effect in
accordance with their terms. I reserve
the authority to execute further waivers
from time to time as I may determine to
be necessary under section 102 of
IIRIRA.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
Employment and Training
Administration
Modernizing Federal Workforce
Information Tools: Request for
Information (RFI) on Online Career
Tools and the Occupational
Information Network (O*NET) Program
ACTION: Request for information; request
for comments.
SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of Labor
Markwayne Mullin,
Secretary of Homeland Security.
(DOL or the Department), Employment
and Training Administration (ETA)
seeks public input to inform two related
modernization efforts that together aim
to strengthen the nation’s public
workforce information infrastructure.
First, ETA is soliciting input to inform
the design and implementation of a
modernized online career site, currently
delivered through CareerOneStop.org—a
public-facing workforce information
website that helps job seekers explore
occupations, locate training programs,
identify local services, and connect to
job listings. Second, ETA is soliciting
input to inform a modernization of the
Occupational Information Network
(O*NET) Program, which publishes
detailed descriptions of occupational
employment and serves as a
foundational data resource for
workforce tools and services across the
country. These two efforts are closely
linked: a modernized career site is only
as good as the occupational and skills
data that powers it. O*NET data informs
how CareerOneStop presents
occupations, skills, and pathways to
users—and improvements to O*NET’s
timeliness, granularity, and
interoperability will directly expand
what a modernized site can offer. DOL
is therefore seeking input on both efforts
together, and respondents are
encouraged to consider how
improvements in one area could
strengthen the other. Please note that
this RFI is issued for informationgathering purposes only; it is not a
solicitation or an offer for procurement.
DOL will not award contracts or grants
based on responses to this notice and
will not respond individually to
commenters. Comments may inform
program and policy planning, including
potential future notices and
procurement activities. DOL expects
that any possible procurement activity
will be posted on the GSA Multiple
Award Schedule.
[FR Doc. 2026–11473 Filed 6–8–26; 8:45 am]
DATES: To be ensured consideration,
BILLING CODE 9111–14–P
comments are due by August 10, 2026.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:00 Jun 08, 2026
Jkt 268001
PO 00000
Frm 00028
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
34833
in response to the RFI described in this
notice by one of the following methods:
Electronic submission: Submit
comments related to Online Career
Tools by email to:
OnlineCareerToolsRFI@dol.gov. Submit
comments related to O*NET by email to:
ONETRFI@dol.gov.
Postal Mail and hand delivery/
courier: Written comment submissions
may be mailed or delivered to Attn:
Steven Rietzke, Office of Workforce
Investment, U.S. Department of Labor,
200 Constitution Avenue NW, Suite C–
4510, Washington, DC 20210.
Instructions: This Request for
Information invites comments from job
seekers, workers, employers, HR
practitioners, state and local workforce
agencies, training and education
providers, credentialing bodies,
developers, researchers, and other
interested stakeholders. Respondents
may address either the Online Career
Tools or O*NET sections of this RFI or
may address both. Label all Online
Career Tools submissions with ‘‘Online
Career Tools RFI.’’ Label all O*NET
submissions with ‘‘O*NET RFI.’’ If you
respond to both sections, please provide
two separate submissions. Please submit
your comments by only one delivery
method (i.e., Email or postal mail; Email
is highly preferred).
Instructions for Submitting Comments
• Clearly label your submission with
the applicable subject line (see
Addresses section above) to indicate
whether your comments address Section
I (Online Career Tools), Section II
(O*NET), or both.
• Identify your stakeholder group
(e.g., job seeker, employer, developer,
state workforce agency) at the top of
your response.
• Focus on the questions most
relevant to your expertise. Respondents
are not required to address every
question.
• Include organization and contact
information if you are commenting on
behalf of an institution and are willing
to be contacted for follow-up.
• Do not include sensitive PII or
confidential information; all
submissions will be posted publicly.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Steven Rietzke, Office of Workforce
Investment (OWI), U.S. Department of
Labor, Employment and Training
Administration, 200 Constitution
Avenue NW, Room C–4510,
Washington, DC 20210, Telephone:
(202) 693–3912 (this is not a toll-free
number), Email: OnlineCareerToolsRFI@
dol.gov for questions about online career
E:\FR\FM\09JNN1.SGM
09JNN1
4a
40550
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 126 / Thursday, July 2, 2026 / Notices
The following laboratories are
voluntarily withdrawing from the
National Laboratory Certification
Program effective June 30, 2026.
Laboratory Corporation of America
Holdings, 69 First Ave., Raritan, NJ
08869, 908–526–2400/800–437–4986,
(Formerly: Roche Biomedical
Laboratories, Inc.)
Laboratory Corporation of America
Holdings, 1120 Main Street,
Southaven, MS 38671, 866–827–8042/
800–233–6339, (Formerly: LabCorp
Occupational Testing Services, Inc.;
MedExpress/National Laboratory
Center)
Carlos Castillo,
Public Health Analyst.
[FR Doc. 2026–13402 Filed 7–1–26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4160–20–P
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
SECURITY
Office of the Secretary
Determination Pursuant to Section 102
of the Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996,
as Amended
AGENCY: Office of the Secretary,
Department of Homeland Security.
ACTION: Notice of determination.
khammond on DSK9W7S144PROD with NOTICE
SUMMARY: The Secretary of Homeland
Security has determined, pursuant to
law, that it is necessary to waive certain
laws, regulations, and other legal
requirements in order to ensure the
expeditious construction of barriers and
roads in the vicinity of the international
land border in the state of Texas. The
notice of determination was published
in the Federal Register on February 17,
2026. This document amends the
February 17, 2026, notice of
determination by including additional
legal requirements that are being
waived.
DATES: This determination takes effect
on July 2, 2026.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Important
mission requirements of the Department
of Homeland Security (‘‘DHS’’) include
border security and the detection and
prevention of illegal entry into the
United States. Border security is critical
to the nation’s national security.
Recognizing the critical importance of
border security, Congress has mandated
DHS to achieve and maintain
operational control of the international
land border. Secure Fence Act of 2006,
Public Law 109–367, section 2, 120 Stat.
2638 (Oct. 26, 2006) (8 U.S.C. 1701
note). Congress defined ‘‘operational
VerDate Sep<11>2014
20:51 Jul 01, 2026
Jkt 268001
control’’ as the prevention of all
unlawful entries into the United States,
including entries by terrorists, other
unlawful aliens, instruments of
terrorism, narcotics, and other
contraband. Id. Consistent with that
mandate, the President’s Executive
Order on Securing Our Borders directs
that I take all appropriate action to
deploy and construct physical barriers
to ensure complete operational control
of the southern border of the United
States. Executive Order 14165, section 3
(Jan. 20, 2025).
Congress has provided the Secretary
of Homeland Security a number of
authorities necessary to carry out DHS’s
border security mission. One of those
authorities is found at section 102 of the
Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996,
as amended (‘‘IIRIRA’’). Public Law
104–208, Div. C, 110 Stat. 3009–546,
3009–554 (Sept. 30, 1996) (8 U.S.C 1103
note), as amended by the REAL ID Act
of 2005, Public Law 109–13, Div. B, 119
Stat. 231, 302, 306 (May 11, 2005) (8
U.S.C. 1103 note), as amended by the
Secure Fence Act of 2006, Public Law
109–367, section 3, 120 Stat. 2638 (Oct.
26, 2006) (8 U.S.C. 1103 note), as
amended by the Department of
Homeland Security Appropriations Act,
2008, Public Law 110–161, Div. E, Title
V, section 564, 121 Stat. 2090 (Dec. 26,
2007). In section 102(a) of IIRIRA,
Congress provided that the Secretary of
Homeland Security shall take such
actions as may be necessary to install
additional physical barriers and roads
(including the removal of obstacles to
detection of illegal entrants) in the
vicinity of the United States border to
deter illegal crossings in areas of high
illegal entry into the United States. In
section 102(b) of IIRIRA, Congress
mandated that in carrying out the
authority of section 102(a), I provide for
the installation of additional fencing,
barriers, roads, lighting, cameras, and
sensors to achieve and maintain
operational control of the border.
Finally, in section 102(c) of IIRIRA,
Congress granted to the Secretary of
Homeland Security the authority to
waive all legal requirements that I, in
my sole discretion, determine necessary
to ensure the expeditious construction
of barriers and roads authorized by
section 102 of IIRIRA.
Determination and Waiver
Section 1
The United States Border Patrol Big
Bend Sector is an area of high illegal
entry. Between fiscal year 2021 and
fiscal year 2025, Border Patrol
apprehended over 89,000 illegal aliens
PO 00000
Frm 00039
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
attempting to enter the United States
between border crossings in the Big
Bend Sector. In that same time period
Border Patrol seized over 87,574 pounds
of marijuana, over 867 pounds of
cocaine, over 1,156 pounds of
methamphetamine, over 12 pounds of
heroin, and over 94 pounds of fentanyl.
Since the President took office, DHS
has delivered the most secure border in
history. More can and must be done,
however. As the statistics cited above
demonstrate, the Big Bend Sector is an
area of high illegal entry where illegal
aliens regularly attempt to enter the
United States and smuggle illicit drugs,
and given my mandate to achieve and
maintain operational control of the
border, I must use my authority under
section 102 of IIRIRA to install
additional barriers and roads in the Big
Bend Sector. Therefore, DHS will take
immediate action to construct
additional barriers and roads in a
segment of the border in the Big Bend
Sector. The segment where such
construction will occur is referred to
herein as the ‘‘project area,’’ which is
more specifically described in Section 2
below.
Section 2
I determine that the following area in
the vicinity of the United States border,
located in the state of Texas within the
U. S. Border Patrol Big Bend Sector, is
an area of high illegal entry (the ‘‘project
area’’): Starting at approximately GPS
point 31.037623, ¥105.579877 and
extending south and east to
approximately GPS point 29.325866,
¥104.046466.
There is presently an acute and
immediate need to construct additional
physical barriers and roads in the
vicinity of the border of the United
States in order to prevent unlawful
entries into the United States in the
project area pursuant to section 102(a)
and 102(b) of IIRIRA. In order to ensure
the expeditious construction of
additional physical barriers and roads in
the project area, I have determined that
it is necessary that I exercise the
authority that is vested in me by section
102(c) of IIRIRA.
Accordingly, pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA, I hereby waive in their
entirety, with respect to the
construction of physical barriers and
roads (including, but not limited to,
accessing the project areas, creating and
using staging areas, the conduct of
earthwork, excavation, fill, and site
preparation, and installation and
upkeep of physical barriers, roads,
supporting elements, drainage, erosion
controls, safety features, lighting,
cameras, and sensors) in the project
E:\FR\FM\02JYN1.SGM
02JYN1
5a
khammond on DSK9W7S144PROD with NOTICE
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 126 / Thursday, July 2, 2026 / Notices
area, all of the following statutes,
including all federal, state, or other
laws, regulations, and legal
requirements of, deriving from, or
related to the subject of, the following
statutes, as amended: The National
Environmental Policy Act (Pub. L. 91–
190, 83 Stat. 852 (Jan. 1, 1970) (42
U.S.C. 4321 et seq.)); the Endangered
Species Act (Pub. L. 93–205, 87 Stat.
884 (Dec. 28, 1973) (16 U.S.C. 1531 et
seq.)); the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (commonly referred to as
the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1251 et
seq.)); the National Historic Preservation
Act (Pub. L. 89–665, 80 Stat. 915 (Oct.
15, 1966), as amended, repealed, or
replaced by Public Law 113–287 (Dec.
19, 2014) (formerly codified at 16 U.S.C.
470 et seq., now codified at 54 U.S.C.
100101 note and 54 U.S.C. 300101 et
seq.)); the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (16
U.S.C. 703 et seq.); the Migratory Bird
Conservation Act (16 U.S.C. 715 et seq.);
the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7401 et
seq.); the Archeological Resources
Protection Act (Pub. L. 96–95 (16 U.S.C.
470aa et seq.)); the Paleontological
Resources Preservation Act (16 U.S.C.
470aaa et seq.); the Federal Cave
Resources Protection Act of 1988 (16
U.S.C. 4301 et seq.); the National Trails
System Act (16 U.S.C. 1241 et seq.), the
Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. 300f
et seq.); the Noise Control Act (42 U.S.C.
4901 et seq.); the Solid Waste Disposal
Act, as amended by the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act (42
U.S.C. 6901 et seq.); the Comprehensive
Environmental Response,
Compensation, and Liability Act (42
U.S.C. 9601 et seq.); the Archaeological
and Historic Preservation Act (Pub. L.
86–523, as amended, repealed, or
replaced by Pub. L. 113–287 (Dec. 19,
2014) (formerly codified at 16 U.S.C.
469 et seq., now codified at 54 U.S.C.
312502 et seq.)); the Antiquities Act
(formerly codified at 16 U.S.C. 431 et
seq. and 16 U.S.C. 431a et seq., now
codified 54 U.S.C. 320301 et seq.); the
Historic Sites, Buildings, and
Antiquities Act (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 461 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 320301–320303 & 320101–
320106); the Eagle Protection Act (16
U.S.C. 668 et seq.); the Native American
Graves Protection and Repatriation Act
(25 U.S.C. 3001 et seq.); the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
551 et seq.); Section 438 of the Energy
Independence and Security Act (42
U.S.C. 17094); the National Fish and
Wildlife Act of 1956 (Pub. L. 84–1024
(16 U.S.C. 742a, et seq.)); the Fish and
Wildlife Coordination Act (Pub. L. 73–
121 (16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.)); the
Farmland Protection Policy Act (7
VerDate Sep<11>2014
20:51 Jul 01, 2026
Jkt 268001
U.S.C. 4201 et seq.); the Wild Horse and
Burro Act (16 U.S.C. 1331 et seq.); 43
U.S.C. 387; the Wild and Scenic Rivers
Act (Pub. L. 90–542 (16 U.S.C. 1281 et
seq.); the Federal Land Policy and
Management Act (Pub L. 94–579 (43
U.S.C. 1701 et seq.)); 33 U.S.C. 408; and
the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33
U.S.C. 403 et seq.).
This waiver does not revoke or
supersede any other waiver
determination made pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA. Such waivers shall
remain in full force and effect in
accordance with their terms. I reserve
the authority to execute further waivers
from time to time as I may determine to
be necessary under section 102 of
IIRIRA.
Markwayne Mullin,
Secretary of Homeland Security.
[FR Doc. 2026–13419 Filed 7–1–26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 9111–14–P
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
[Docket Number: FR–7106–N–32]
Privacy Act of 1974; Matching Program
AGENCY: Office of Single Family
Program Development, Department of
Housing and Urban Development.
ACTION: Notice of a new matching
program.
SUMMARY: In accordance with the
Privacy Act of 1974, as amended, the
Department of Housing and Urban
Development (HUD) and the Small
Business Administration (SBA) are
providing notice of a new computer
matching program. Under this program,
SBA will provide HUD with delinquent
debtor data for inclusion in HUD’s
Credit Alert Verification Reporting
System (CAIVRS). CAIVRS is a shared,
government-wide database that contains
information on individuals who are
delinquent or in default on Federal
debts. Participating Federal agencies,
their authorized contractors, and
approved financial institutions use
CAIVRS to prescreen applicants for
Federal direct loans or federally
guaranteed loans to determine whether
the applicant is delinquent in repaying
a debt owed to, or guaranteed by, the
Federal Government. This matching
program supports Federal credit
eligibility determinations and promotes
the integrity of Federal lending
programs.
DATES: Comments due date: August 3,
2026. The matching program will
commence no sooner than 30 days after
PO 00000
Frm 00040
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
40551
publication of this notice, provided no
comments are received that warrant a
change to this notice. The matching
program will be conducted for an initial
term of 18 months, beginning
approximately July 2, 2026, and may be
renewed for one additional year within
three months of expiration if the parties
make no changes to the matching
program and certify that it has been
conducted in compliance with the
computer matching agreement.
ADDRESSES: Interested parties may
submit comments as follows:
1. Electronically. Interested persons
are invited to submit comments
electronically to http://
www.regulations.gov. Commenters
should follow the instructions provided
on the website to submit comments
regarding this matching program. To
locate the appropriate notice,
commenters may search Regulations.gov
using the title of this Matching Notice,
the participating agency names, or by
viewing recently posted HUD dockets
and documents.
2. By Regular Mail. You may mail
written comments to the following
address: U.S. Department of Housing
and Urban Development, Office of
Single Family Program Development,
Home Mortgage Insurance Division, 451
Seventh Street SW, Washington, DC
20410.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For
general inquiries regarding HUD’s
participation in this matching program,
contact LeJorian Stewart, Management
Analyst, Single Family Program
Development, Home Mortgage Insurance
Division, U.S. Department of Housing
and Urban Development, at (202) 402–
2334 or LeJorian.J.Stewart@hud.gov. If
contacting either agency by email,
please state ‘‘Public inquiry: SBA CMA’’
in the email subject line.
For inquiries regarding the Small
Business Administration’s participation
in this matching program, contact
Jihoon Kim, Director, Financial Program
Operations, Office of Capital Access,
Small Business Administration, at (202)
420–0304 or Jihoon.Kim@sba.gov.
For SBA privacy or security-related
inquiries, contact Michael Post, Chief
Information Security Officer (Acting)
and Chief Privacy Officer (Acting),
Office of the Chief Information Officer,
Small Business Administration, at (202)
205–3645 or Michael.Post@sba.gov or
PrivacyOfficer@sba.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The
Privacy Act of 1974, as amended (5
U.S.C. 552a), establishes requirements
governing the use of computer matching
by Federal agencies when records in a
system of records are compared with
E:\FR\FM\02JYN1.SGM
02JYN1
6a
46939
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 142 / Monday, July 27, 2026 / Notices
are covered in OMB control number
0910–0014.
The primary purpose of this
collection of information is to determine
whether the research studies are being
conducted in accordance with
applicable statutes and regulations
specified under 21 CFR 361.1 and that
human subject safety is assured. If these
studies were not reviewed, human
submissions we received under the
regulations over the past 3 years.
In the Federal Register of April 17,
2026 (91 FR 20659), FDA published a
60-day notice requesting public
comment on the proposed collection of
information. No comments were
received.
FDA estimates the burden of this
collection of information as follows:
subjects could be subjected to
inappropriate radiation or
pharmacologic risks. Respondents to
this information collection are the
chairperson or chairpersons of each
individual RDRC, investigators, and
participants in the studies. The burden
estimates are based on our experience
with these reporting and recordkeeping
requirements and the number of
TABLE 1—ESTIMATED ANNUAL REPORTING BURDEN 1
21 CFR section and applicable form
Number of
respondents
Number of
responses per
respondent
Total annual
responses
Average
burden
per
response
Total
hours
§ 361.1(c)(3) reports and (c)(4) approval (Form FDA 2914:
Membership Summary) 2.
§ 361.1(c)(3) reports (Form FDA 2915: Study Summary) ¥3 .....
§ 361.1(d)(8) adverse events ......................................................
55
1
55
1 ..............
55
35
10
9
1
324
10
3.5 ...........
.5 (30
minutes).
1,134
5
Total .....................................................................................
........................
........................
389
.................
1,194
1 There are no capital costs or operating and maintenance costs associated with this collection of information.
2 https://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/ReportsManualsForms/Forms/UCM094979.pdf.
3 https://www.fda.gov/downloads/AboutFDA/ReportsManualsForms/Forms/UCM074720.pdf.
TABLE 2—ESTIMATED ANNUAL RECORDKEEPING BURDEN 1
Average
burden per
recordkeeping
Number of
recordkeepers
Number of
records per
recordkeepers
§ 361.1(c)(2) RDRC ..................................................................
§ 361.1(d)(5) human research subjects ...................................
55
35
4
9
220
324
10 ..............
.75 (45 minutes).
2,200
243
Total ..................................................................................
........................
........................
544
...................
2,443
21 CFR section
Total
annual
records
Total
hours
1 There are no capital costs or operating and maintenance costs associated with this collection of information.
Our estimated burden for the
information collection reflects an
overall decrease of 52 hours and a
corresponding decrease of 97 responses.
This is attributed to the Agency
receiving fewer submissions over the
last few years due to decreased subject
enrollment during the pandemic.
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
SECURITY
Grace R. Graham,
Deputy Commissioner for Policy, Legislation,
and International Affairs.
AGENCY: Office of the Secretary,
[FR Doc. 2026–15070 Filed 7–24–26; 8:45 am]
Determination Pursuant to Section 102
of the Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996,
as Amended
Department of Homeland Security.
ACTION: Notice of determination.
SUMMARY: The Secretary of Homeland
BILLING CODE 4164–01–P
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
Office of the Secretary
Security has determined, pursuant to
law, that it is necessary to waive certain
laws, regulations, and other legal
requirements in order to ensure the
expeditious construction of barriers and
roads in the vicinity of the international
land border in the state of Texas.
DATES: This determination takes effect
on July 27, 2026.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Important
mission requirements of the Department
of Homeland Security (‘‘DHS’’) include
VerDate Sep<11>2014
18:10 Jul 24, 2026
Jkt 268001
PO 00000
Frm 00046
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
border security and the detection and
prevention of illegal entry into the
United States. Border security is critical
to the nation’s national security.
Recognizing the critical importance of
border security, Congress has mandated
DHS to achieve and maintain
operational control of the international
land border. Secure Fence Act of 2006,
Public Law 109–367, section 2, 120 Stat.
2638 (Oct. 26, 2006) (8 U.S.C. 1701
note). Congress defined ‘‘operational
control’’ as the prevention of all
unlawful entries into the United States,
including entries by terrorists, other
unlawful aliens, instruments of
terrorism, narcotics, and other
contraband. Id. Consistent with that
mandate, the President’s Executive
Order on Securing Our Borders directs
that I take all appropriate action to
deploy and construct physical barriers
to ensure complete operational control
of the southern border of the United
States. Executive Order 14165, section 3
(Jan. 20, 2025).
E:\FR\FM\27JYN1.SGM
27JYN1
46940
7a
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 142 / Monday, July 27, 2026 / Notices
Congress has provided to the
Secretary of Homeland Security a
number of authorities necessary to carry
out DHS’s border security mission. One
of those authorities is found at section
102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform
and Immigrant Responsibility Act of
1996, as amended (‘‘IIRIRA’’). Public
Law 104–208, Div. C, Tit. I, section 102,
110 Stat. 3009–546, 3009–554 (8 U.S.C
1103 note), as amended by the REAL ID
Act of 2005, Public Law 109–13, Div. B,
Tit. I, section 102, 119 Stat. 302, 306 (8
U.S.C. 1103 note), as amended by the
Secure Fence Act of 2006, Public Law
109–367, section 3, 120 Stat. 2638 (8
U.S.C. 1103 note), as amended by the
Department of Homeland Security
Appropriations Act, 2008, Public Law
110–161, Div. E, Tit. V, section 564, 121
Stat. 2042, 2090. In section 102(a) of
IIRIRA, Congress provided that the
Secretary of Homeland Security shall
take such actions as may be necessary
to install additional physical barriers
and roads (including the removal of
obstacles to detection of illegal entrants)
in the vicinity of the United States
border to deter illegal crossings in areas
of high illegal entry into the United
States. In section 102(b) of IIRIRA,
Congress mandated that in carrying out
the authority of section 102(a), I provide
for the installation of additional fencing,
barriers, roads, lighting, cameras, and
sensors to achieve and maintain
operational control of the border.
Finally, in section 102(c) of IIRIRA,
Congress granted to the Secretary of
Homeland Security the authority to
waive all legal requirements that I, in
my sole discretion, determine necessary
to ensure the expeditious construction
of barriers and roads authorized by
section 102 of IIRIRA.
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
Determination and Waiver
Section 1
The United States Border Patrol Big
Bend and Del Rio Sectors are areas of
high illegal entry. Between fiscal year
2021 and fiscal year 2025, Border Patrol
apprehended over 89,000 illegal aliens
attempting to enter the United States
between border crossings in the Big
Bend Sector. In that same time period
Border Patrol seized over 87,574 pounds
of marijuana, over 867 pounds of
cocaine, over 1,156 pounds of
methamphetamine, over 12 pounds of
heroin, and over 94 pounds of fentanyl.
Between fiscal year 2021 and fiscal year
2025, Border Patrol apprehended over
1,410,330 illegal aliens attempting to
enter the United States between border
crossings in the Del Rio Sector. In that
same time period Border Patrol seized
over 277 pounds of marijuana, over 198
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:20 Jul 24, 2026
Jkt 268001
pounds of cocaine, over 353 pounds of
methamphetamine, and over five
pounds of fentanyl.
Since the President took office, DHS
has delivered the most secure border in
history. More can and must be done,
however. As the statistics cited above
demonstrate, the Big Bend and Del Rio
Sectors are areas of high illegal entry
where illegal aliens regularly attempt to
enter the United States and smuggle
illicit drugs, and given my mandate to
achieve and maintain operational
control of the border, I must use my
authority under section 102 of IIRIRA to
install additional barriers and roads in
the Big Bend and Del Rio Sectors.
Therefore, DHS will take immediate
action to construct additional barriers
and roads in a segment of the border in
the Big Bend and Del Rio Sectors. The
segment where such construction will
occur is referred to herein as the
‘‘project area,’’ which is more
specifically described in Section 2
below.
Section 2
I determine that the following area in
the vicinity of the United States border,
located in the state of Texas within the
U.S. Border Patrol Big Bend and Del Rio
Sectors, is an area of high illegal entry
(the ‘‘project area’’): Starting at
approximately GPS point 29.728522,
¥102.683945 and extending east to
approximately GPS point 29.449892,
¥101.058017.
There is presently an acute and
immediate need to construct additional
physical barriers and roads in the
vicinity of the border of the United
States in order to prevent unlawful
entries into the United States in the
project area pursuant to section 102(a)
and 102(b) of IIRIRA. In order to ensure
the expeditious construction of
additional physical barriers and roads in
the project area, I have determined that
it is necessary that I exercise the
authority that is vested in me by section
102(c) of IIRIRA.
Accordingly, pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA, I hereby waive in their
entirety, with respect to the
construction of physical barriers and
roads (including, but not limited to,
accessing the project areas, creating and
using staging areas, the conduct of
earthwork, excavation, fill, and site
preparation, and installation and
upkeep of physical barriers, roads,
supporting elements, drainage, erosion
controls, safety features, lighting,
cameras, and sensors) in the project
area, all of the following statutes,
including all federal, state, or other
laws, regulations, and legal
requirements of, deriving from, or
PO 00000
Frm 00047
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
related to the subject of, the following
statutes, as amended: The National
Environmental Policy Act (Pub. L. 91–
190, 83 Stat. 852 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et
seq.)); the Endangered Species Act (Pub.
L. 93–205, 87 Stat. 884 (16 U.S.C. 1531
et seq.)); the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (commonly referred to as
the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1251 et
seq.)); the National Historic Preservation
Act (Pub. L. 89–665, 80 Stat. 915, as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287 (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 470 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 100101 note and 54 U.S.C.
300101 et seq.)); the Migratory Bird
Treaty Act (16 U.S.C. 703 et seq.); the
Migratory Bird Conservation Act (16
U.S.C. 715 et seq.); the Clean Air Act (42
U.S.C. 7401 et seq.); the Archeological
Resources Protection Act (Pub. L. 96–95
(16 U.S.C. 470aa et seq.)); the
Paleontological Resources Preservation
Act (16 U.S.C. 470aaa et seq.); the
Federal Cave Resources Protection Act
of 1988 (16 U.S.C. 4301 et seq.); the
National Trails System Act (16 U.S.C.
1241 et seq.); the Safe Drinking Water
Act (42 U.S.C. 300f et seq.); the Noise
Control Act (42 U.S.C. 4901 et seq.); the
Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended
by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.);
the Comprehensive Environmental
Response, Compensation, and Liability
Act (42 U.S.C. 9601 et seq.); the
Archaeological and Historic
Preservation Act (Pub. L. 86–523, as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287 (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 469 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 312502 et seq.)); the Antiquities
Act (formerly codified at 16 U.S.C. 431
et seq. and 16 U.S.C. 431a et seq., now
codified 54 U.S.C. 320301 et seq.); the
Historic Sites, Buildings, and
Antiquities Act (formerly codified at 16
U.S.C. 461 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 320301–320303 & 320101–
320106); the Eagle Protection Act (16
U.S.C. 668 et seq.); the Native American
Graves Protection and Repatriation Act
(25 U.S.C. 3001 et seq.); the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
551 et seq.); Section 438 of the Energy
Independence and Security Act (42
U.S.C. 17094); the National Fish and
Wildlife Act of 1956 (Pub. L. 84–1024
(16 U.S.C. 742a, et seq.)); the Fish and
Wildlife Coordination Act (Pub. L. 73–
121 (16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.)); the
Farmland Protection Policy Act (7
U.S.C. 4201 et seq.); the Wild Horse and
Burro Act (16 U.S.C. 1331 et seq.); 43
U.S.C. 387; the Wild and Scenic Rivers
Act (Pub. L. 90–542 (16 U.S.C. 1281 et
seq.); the Federal Land Policy and
Management Act (Pub L. 94–579 (43
E:\FR\FM\27JYN1.SGM
27JYN1
8a
Federal Register / Vol. 91, No. 142 / Monday, July 27, 2026 / Notices
U.S.C. 1701 et seq.)); the Wilderness Act
(Pub. L. 88–577 (16 U.S.C. 1131 et seq.));
the National Park Service Organic Act
and the National Park Service General
Authorities Act (Pub. L. 64–235, 39 Stat.
535 and Pub. L. 91–383, 84 Stat. 825 as
amended, repealed, or replaced by Pub.
L. 113–287, 128 Stat. 3094 (formerly
codified at 16 U.S.C. 1, 2–4 and 16
U.S.C. 1a-1 et seq., now codified at 54
U.S.C. 100101–100102, 54 U.S.C.
100301–100303, 54 U.S.C. 100501–
100507, 54 U.S.C. 100701–100707, 54
U.S.C. 100721–100725, 54 U.S.C.
100751–100755, 54 U.S.C. 100901–
100906, 54 U.S.C. 102101–102102)); 16
U.S.C. 156; 16 U.S.C. 157; 16 U.S.C.
157c; and 16 U.S.C. 157d.
This waiver does not revoke or
supersede any other waiver
determination made pursuant to section
102(c) of IIRIRA. Such waivers shall
remain in full force and effect in
accordance with their terms. I reserve
the authority to execute further waivers
from time to time as I may determine to
be necessary under section 102 of
IIRIRA.
Markwayne Mullin,
Secretary of Homeland Security.
[FR Doc. 2026–15096 Filed 7–24–26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 9111–14–P
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Fish and Wildlife Service
[Docket No. FWS–HQ–IA–2026–1783;
FXIA16710900000–267–FF09A30000]
Foreign Endangered Species; Receipt
of Permit Applications
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service,
Interior.
ACTION: Notice of receipt of permit
applications; request for comments.
lotter on DSK8BHNXB4PROD with NOTICES1
SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (Service), invite the
public to comment on applications to
conduct certain activities with foreign
species that are listed as endangered
under the Endangered Species Act
(ESA). With some exceptions, the ESA
prohibits activities with listed species
unless Federal authorization is issued
that allows such activities. The ESA also
requires that we invite public comment
before issuing permits for any activity
otherwise prohibited by the ESA with
respect to any endangered species.
DATES: Comments will be accepted on or
before August 26, 2026. Comments
submitted electronically using the
Federal eRulemaking Portal (see
ADDRESSES, below) must be received by
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:20 Jul 24, 2026
Jkt 268001
11:59 p.m. eastern time on the closing
date.
To ensure your comment is received
and considered, you must submit it
using one of the methods identified in
the ADDRESSES section of this document.
Comments submitted through any
method not authorized in this
document, or sent to an address not
listed here, will not be considered.
ADDRESSES: Comment submission: All
submissions must include the docket
number [FWS–HQ–IA–2026–1783] for
this document. You must submit
comments using one of the following
methods:
• Electronic submission: Federal
eRulemaking Portal at: https://
www.regulations.gov. In the Search box,
enter FWS–HQ–IA–2026–1783, which is
the docket number for this action. Then
click the Search button. On the resulting
page, you may submit a comment by
clicking on ‘‘Comment.’’ Please ensure
that you have found the correct
document before submitting your
comments.
• U.S. mail: Public Comments
Processing, Attn: Docket No. FWS–HQ–
IA–2026–1783, Policy and Regulations
Branch, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
MS: PRB (JAO/3W), 5275 Leesburg Pike,
Falls Church, VA 22041–3803.
Comments submitted through any
method not authorized in this
document, or sent to an address not
listed here, will not be considered. We
will not accept comments via email, fax,
or hand delivery. We are not required to
consider comments that are submitted
after the comment period ends or that
are submitted via a method outside of
these instructions. Comments
containing profanity, vulgarity, threats,
or other inappropriate content will not
be considered.
We will post all comments at https://
www.regulations.gov. You may request
that we withhold personal identifying
information from public review;
however, we cannot guarantee that we
will be able to do so. For more
information, see Public Comment
Procedures under SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Timothy MacDonald, by phone at 703–
358–2185 or via email at DMAFR@
fws.gov. Individuals in the United States
who are deaf, deafblind, hard of hearing,
or have a speech disability may dial 711
(TTY, TDD, or TeleBraille) to access
telecommunications relay services.
Individuals outside the United States
should use the relay services offered
within their country to make
international calls to the point-ofcontact in the United States.
PO 00000
Frm 00048
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46941
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Public Comment Procedures
A. How do I comment on submitted
applications?
We invite the public and local, State,
Tribal, and Federal agencies to comment
on these applications. Before issuing
any of the requested permits, we will
take into consideration any information
that we receive during the public
comment period.
You may submit your comments and
materials by one of the methods in
ADDRESSES. We will not consider
comments sent by email or to an address
not in ADDRESSES. We will not consider
or include in our administrative record
comments we receive after the close of
the comment period (see DATES).
When submitting comments, please
specify the name of the applicant and
the permit number at the beginning of
your comment. Provide sufficient
information to allow us to authenticate
any scientific or commercial data you
include. The comments and
recommendations that will be most
useful and likely to influence agency
decisions are: (1) Those supported by
quantitative information or studies; and
(2) those that include citations to, and
analyses of, the applicable laws and
regulations.
B. May I review comments submitted by
others?
You may view and comment on
others’ public comments at https://
www.regulations.gov unless our
allowing so would violate the Privacy
Act (5 U.S.C. 552a) or Freedom of
Information Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
C. Who will see my comments?
If you submit a comment at https://
www.regulations.gov, your entire
comment, including any personal
identifying information, will be posted
on the website. If you submit a
hardcopy comment that includes
personal identifying information, such
as your address, phone number, or
email address, you may request at the
top of your document that we withhold
this information from public review.
However, we cannot guarantee that we
will be able to do so. Moreover, all
submissions from organizations or
businesses, and from individuals
identifying themselves as
representatives or officials of
organizations or businesses, will be
made available for public disclosure in
their entirety.
II. Background
To help us carry out our conservation
responsibilities for affected species, and
E:\FR\FM\27JYN1.SGM
27JYN1
9a
DEFENDANTS’
EXHIBIT 2
10a
Big Bend Sector Drug Seizures – 2023 to Present
FY
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
Month
APR
APR
APR
APR
APR
APR
APR
AUG
AUG
AUG
AUG
AUG
AUG
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUN
JUN
Drug Type
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Fentanyl
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Sum Qty (lbs)
0
0.0066
31.7198
0
611.6704
0.1168
1.6005
42.2829
0.0669
0.3007
281.8361
0.2065
1.2765
45.961
2.0481
0.0249
1386.335
0.3369
0.0073
28.3881
0.0022
2.2465
0.0022
1268.0753
0.1679
1.4167
0.0551
0.0088
2602.4162
30.8369
1.1866
29.2921
0.0088
9.1491
1.8739
1828.1138
3.2851
8.0379
13.5872
0.0059
11a
12a
Big Bend Sector Drug Seizures – 2023 to Present
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
2024
AUG
AUG
AUG
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUL
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAY
MAY
MAY
MAY
MAY
NOV
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
1019.8885
0.0597
1.4871
0.0176
5.3124
501.376
0.1746
2.1517
0.004
1134.4315
0.1246
5.8054
134.4843
0.1089
10.7846
585.352
10.0173
0.3178
0.1191
0.0141
1214.4037
0.085
1.7646
0.0238
0.0452
0.097
2.478
1780.955
0.3278
0.4261
0.0415
4.1093
1460.9701
2.2835
2.8191
0.0478
0.002
814.7259
0.123
170.7729
3.065
13a
14a
15a
Big Bend Sector Drug Seizures – 2023 to Present
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
2026
APR
APR
APR
DEC
DEC
DEC
DEC
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
FEB
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JAN
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
JUN
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAR
MAY
MAY
MAY
MAY
MAY
MAY
NOV
NOV
NOV
NOV
NOV
NOV
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Heroin
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
Cocaine
Ecstasy
Fentanyl
Marijuana
Methamphetamine
Other Drugs**
1325.2321
0.0489
2.3109
0.0371
2082.7041
35.6601
0.0877
36.3523
0.0077
1241.079
0.2535
1.1721
0.0343
0.0022
5.1146
509.515
183.5784
0.8264
0.0044
0.0187
356.6347
20.6823
1.461
0.0452
0.0024
0.013
2296.1742
1.261
0.4052
0.0033
0.0082
0.0137
724.3733
3.1333
0.691
25.1657
0.0022
41.9205
5602.8414
54.8763
0.8076
16a
17a
DEFENDANTS’
EXHIBIT 3
18a
Big Bend Drug Seizures FY23-Present
25,000.00
20,761.88
20,000.00
15,000.00
12,009.07
12,363.93
10,000.00
9,580.56
5,000.00
0.00
FY2023
FY2024
FY2025
Big Bend Drug Seizures FY23-Present
FY2026
19a
Source Data:
http://www.cbp.gov/document/stats/nationwide-drug-seizures
20a
DEFENDANTS’
EXHIBIT 4
21a
22a
Source Data:
1960-2018: https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/assets/documents/2019-Mar/bp-southwest-bordersector-apps-fy1960-fy2018.pdf
2019-2023: DHS Border Security Report - Fourth Quarter, Fiscal Year 2023 (January 9, 2025) (page 46, Appendix
C, Table B1) (ECF No. 38-2)
2024-July 2026: FY23 - FY26 (FYTD) Nationwide Encounters by Area of Responsibility – July, at
-08/nationwide-encounters-fy23-fy26-jul-aor.csv
23a
DEFENDANTS’
EXHIBIT 5
24a
Big Bend Sector Encounters – 1960 to 2026
YEAR
1960
1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
ENCOUNTERS
732
954
1,431
2,026
3,146
3,973
6,592
7,049
8,834
11,973
16,770
20,269
20,269
22,378
23,291
20,472
19,846
22,239
23,501
20,116
15,602
17,584
20,268
20,829
22,196
23,667
23,796
9,586
6,209
5,560
7,180
8,764
13,819
15,486
13,494
11,552
13,214
12,692
14,509
14,952
13,689
12,087
25a
Big Bend Sector Encounters – 1960 to 2026
YEAR
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026 (through July)
ENCOUNTERS
11,392
10,319
10,530
10,536
7,520
5,536
5,391
6,360
5,288
4,036
3,964
3,684
4,096
5,031
6,366
6,002
8,045
9637
8627
37266
31948
11823
4921
3096
1607
Source Data:
•
•
•
1960-2018: https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/assets/documents/2019Mar/bp-southwest-border-sector-apps-fy1960-fy2018.pdf
2019-2023: DHS Border Security Report - Fourth Quarter, Fiscal Year 2023
(January 9, 2025) (page 46, Appendix C, Table B1) (ECF No. 38-2)
2024-July 2026: FY23 - FY26 (FYTD) Nationwide Encounters by Area of
Responsibility – July, at https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/202608/nationwide-encounters-fy23-fy26-jul-aor.csv
26a
1
1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
2
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
3
EL PASO DIVISION
4
5
FRIENDS OF THE RUIDOSA
CHURCH, et al.,
6
vs.
7
MARKWAYNE MULLIN, et al.
)
) No. EP:26-CV-01099-KC
)
) El Paso, Texas
)
) October 2, 2026
8
9
10
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION HEARING
11
BEFORE THE HONORABLE KATHLEEN CARDONE
12
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
13
14
15
16
A P P E A R A N C E S:
17
FOR THE PLAINTIFFS:
18
19
20
21
MS. ZEYNEP GRAVES
Center for Biological Diversity
2100 Franklin Street, Suite 375
Oakland, CA 94612
FOR THE DEFENDANTS: MR. ALEXANDER J. YUN
Trial Attorney, U.S. Dept. Of Justice
Civil Division, Federal Programs Branch
1100 L Street NW
Washington, DC 20005
22
23
24
25
Proceedings reported by the court reporter.
Transcript produced via computer-aided transcription.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
27a
1
2
COURTROOM DEPUTY:
The Court calls case
2
EP:26-CV-1099, Friends of the Ruidosa Church, et al., vs.
3
Markwayne Mullin, et al.
4
THE COURT:
And could I have announcements?
5
MS. GRAVES:
Good morning, Your Honor.
May it
6
please the Court.
Zeynep Graves, Center for Biological
7
Diversity, on behalf of all plaintiffs; Friends of the
8
Ruidosa Church, Danny William Miller, Jr., and the Center
9
for Biological Diversity.
10
THE COURT:
All right.
And your name again?
11
MS. GRAVES:
Zeynep Graves.
12
THE COURT:
Okay. Thank you.
13
MS. GRAVES:
And would you like me to introduce
14
my co-counsel?
15
Shannon Eva Labuschagne from the Center for Biological
16
Diversity.
17
Rynders, Charlotte Weiss from Texas Civil Rights Project.
18
And we're also joined by Angelina Ramirez, a recent law
19
school graduate and fellow at Texas Civil Rights Project.
20
21
22
With me at counsel table are Emma Yip and
And then in the bench behind we have Dustin
THE COURT:
Okay.
And then on behalf of the
respondents?
MR. YUN:
Yes.
Good morning, Your Honor,
23
Alexander J. Yun for defendants.
And with me at counsel
24
table are Kristy Callahan and Pam Amaechi.
25
did just have two preliminary matters to address.
And defendants
We
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
28a
1
3
could do that now.
2
THE COURT:
3
MR. YUN:
Okay, go ahead.
First of all, counsel has -- we've
4
spoken and we've agreed that all witnesses should be
5
excluded from the courtroom other than party
6
representatives and experts.
7
THE COURT:
8
MR. YUN:
Okay.
And, secondly, defendants would just
9
like to note that all witnesses have submitted
10
declarations in this case and, therefore, any testimony
11
should be limited to extra declaration testimony and we
12
would hope that the Court could limit that to maybe 20 to
13
30 minutes if possible.
14
that they opposed that, however.
15
THE COURT:
Plaintiffs had -- have indicated
All right.
Well, let's go ahead and
16
identify the witnesses, bring them up since the rule has
17
been invoked, so that I can get them sworn in.
18
19
20
Are they all outside?
Is that it?
Yeah.
Go
ahead and bring them in.
MS. GRAVES:
I believe we have our experts in the
21
room and our party representatives if we would like to
22
start with them.
23
going to call them --
24
25
It's not in the order in which we're
THE COURT:
All right.
all -- all the witnesses.
But could -- could I have
Are they all present?
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
29a
1
MS. GRAVES:
Yeah.
2
THE COURT:
Okay.
4
If you'd all just come here,
3
line right up in front of the bench, that'd be perfect.
4
Right there.
And are we missing any witnesses or is this all
5
6
of them?
MS. GRAVES:
7
8
We are.
We are missing three
witnesses.
9
THE COURT:
And where are they? Are they --
10
MS. GRAVES:
Sorry --
11
THE COURT:
Okay.
12
Sorry, gentlemen.
Give us
just a second.
MS. GRAVES:
13
Your Honor, they're -- they're not
14
right out the courtroom right now because they have been
15
excluded and they weren't prepared to get sworn in at the
16
outset.
17
18
19
My apologies.
THE COURT:
Okay.
So my only concern is that
the -- you told me these are all experts, right?
MS. GRAVES:
No, it's -- so we have our two party
20
representatives and two experts and -- including our first
21
witnesses here.
22
Yeah --
THE COURT:
Okay.
Well -- and so the two party
23
representatives are going to be remaining in the
24
courtroom.
25
get to remain in the courtroom.
The first witness is fine and the two experts
So the only ones I'm
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
30a
5
1
worried about are the ones who are not experts or allowed
2
to remain in the courtroom and that's why we -- the rule
3
has been invoked.
4
know, they're not supposed to talk about the case and --
5
are they here in the courtroom or --
So I guess my only concern is that, you
MS. GRAVES:
6
And they've been informed of that --
7
well, the problem is they weren't allowed to bring their
8
cell phones in the courtroom, so -- my understanding is
9
one has just gone to their vehicle and -THE COURT:
10
All right.
How about we do this.
11
I'll go ahead and get these sworn in and then when you
12
know that the other ones are available, let's bring them
13
in and get them sworn in and -- and I'll explain the rule
14
to them.
Okay.
Whenever you're ready.
15
MS. GRAVES:
Okay.
16
(Witnesses duly sworn).
17
THE COURT:
18
My understanding is you all have various roles.
You can lower your hands, gentlemen.
19
The rule has been invoked.
It probably is not going to
20
apply to any of you, but I do want you all to be clear
21
that what that means is you cannot discuss the case,
22
certainly not with the other witnesses and not with people
23
in the audience, et cetera.
24
going to be allowed to remain in the room, but I do need
25
you, since you have been sworn in, to go ahead and give me
Now, I assume all of you are
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
31a
6
1
your name so that we have it on the record who's already
2
been sworn in.
3
So we'll start with you.
Okay?
4
MR. RENFROW:
Jeffrey Renfrow.
5
MR. MILLER:
Danny Miller, but I go by Billy.
6
THE COURT:
Okay.
7
MR. KRUMENAKER:
8
MR. GREEN:
Michael Wilber Green.
9
MR. ISACSON:
And Adam Isacson.
10
THE COURT:
All right.
11
All right.
And he is going to be your first
All right.
So you can come on up.
Robert Krumenaker.
Thank you, gentlemen.
12
witness?
13
gentlemen, you can resume wherever you are.
14
where everybody was.
15
And,
I don't know
And before we get started, I did receive the
16
posting this morning by the Government, I think it was
17
regarding the ruling by Judge Garcia out of San Antonio.
18
I've reviewed that.
19
case presents different issues, and -- so we will proceed
20
this morning.
The way this Court views it is this
21
So whenever you're ready, you can begin.
22
MS. GRAVES:
23
housekeeping matter, if I may.
24
we would like to actually move to admit Plaintiffs'
25
evidence P1 through P14 into the record to streamline our
And, Your Honor, one more
If it pleases the Court,
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
32a
1
7
proceedings this morning.
THE COURT:
2
All right.
And it is my
3
understanding those are pretty much agreed to.
4
there's some issues regarding some of the testimony.
5
reviewed that.
I think they're all going to be admitted.
objections?
8
MR. YUN:
9
THE COURT:
All right.
MS. GRAVES:
Thank you.
10
No objections, Your Honor.
They will all be
admitted.
11
ROBERT J. KRUMENAKER,
12
13
I've
Does the -- does the respondent have any
6
7
I know
having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
14
15
BY MS. GRAVES:
16
Q.
Can you please state your name for the record?
17
A.
Yes, my name is Robert Krumenaker.
18
Q.
And, Mr. Krumenaker, what is your current occupation?
19
A.
I am the volunteer chair of an organization called
20
Keep Big Bend Wild.
21
Park Service.
22
Q.
23
Park Service?
24
A.
25
National Park and Rio Grande Wild and Scenic River from
I am also retired from the National
And what were your responsibilities at the National
I was the national park superintendent of Big Bend
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
33a
8
1
2018 through 2023.
2
national park the size of the state of Rhode Island and of
3
245 miles of the U.S.-Mexican border, I was responsible
4
for all national park operations and management, which
5
included budget and personnel.
6
law enforcement, natural resources, cultural resource
7
management, all visitor services and all external
8
relationships with the community and the political world.
9
Q.
10
Border Patrol and other law enforcement agencies?
11
A.
12
agents that, at their maximum staffing, were stationed in
13
the park and they were our colleagues and force
14
multipliers for what we did.
15
I had first-name relationships with their bosses at the
16
Alpine subsector and the Marfa sector.
17
sector chief, we spoke on a regular basis and we also
18
worked with the county sheriff, all of the National Park.
19
In Brewster County, Texas, we worked with him and his
20
staff very closely.
21
Q.
22
enforcement carried out in the park?
23
A.
24
had the lead.
25
staffing, 18 to 20 law enforcement rangers and all of them
Thank you.
And as the superintendent of a
I was also responsible for
Did your work include coordinating with
Yes, very much.
There were eight Border Patrol
They lived in our community.
The Big Bend
During your time as superintendent, how was border
It was very cooperative and clearly the Border Patrol
The National Park Service had, at our full
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
34a
9
1
were patrolling the park, although obviously for somewhat
2
different purposes.
3
they often asked for our help.
4
people that came across someone who had migrated into the
5
park and and so, generally, whoever was closer was the
6
first on scene.
When Border Patrol had an incident,
Often we were the first
And it was very cooperative.
There was also a very large network of wireless
7
8
sensors in the National Park that were jointly operated by
9
the Border Patrol, the National Park Service and the
10
county.
11
the National Park Service.
12
pilot, and the Border Patrol also did aerial patrols.
13
Q.
14
effective?
15
A.
16
they were very effective.
17
the Border Patrol told me, was apprehended in the park and
18
that was always peaceful.
19
actually gave themselves up along existing roads.
20
it worked very well.
21
any Border Patrol officials say that they needed any
22
additional infrastructure at the scale that's being
23
contemplated right now.
24
Q.
25
apprehensions in the park?
And there were aerial patrols that were done by
We had our own plane and
And, in your experience, were those measures
There were some people that did cross the border, but
Almost everyone who crossed,
And most of those folks
And so
And never in my five-year time did
And during your time as superintendent, did you track
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
35a
10
1
A.
I -- the Border Patrol supervisor in the National
2
Park shared data with our staff and I compiled that in an
3
Excel spreadsheet on an annual basis and left that behind
4
when I -- when I retired.
5
Q.
And why did you do that?
6
A.
It was -- it was obviously of great interest to us
7
how much activity was going on in the border.
8
to understand what our partners were doing, we needed to
9
understand the magnitude of the -- of the issue.
10
was -- the Mexican border was always an issue politically
11
in Washington, so I needed to be able to explain what --
12
what was going on.
13
Q.
We needed
And I
I'm going to show you Plaintiffs' Exhibit 2 -MS. GRAVES:
14
Ms. Padilla-Yanez, could you
15
publish?
16
Q.
17
inside Big Bend National Park Per Mile Per Month" show?
18
A.
19
the left column.
20
National Park, those were the numbers that the Border
21
Patrol shared with us and, since my retirement, the
22
numbers came from a Freedom of Information Act request
23
that I filed on behalf of Keep Big Bend Wild.
24
the actual number of apprehensions inside the national
25
park.
(BY MS. GRAVES) What does the column "Apprehensions
That is a mul -- a division.
Let me take you over to
The Apprehensions Inside Big Bend
So that is
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
36a
11
1
The column that you have referred to, which is
2
the fourth, fifth column from the right, "Apprehensions
3
Inside Big Bend National Park Per Mile Per Month."
4
that number in the yellow left column divided by 118,
5
which is the number of miles of border inside the national
6
park divided by 12, number of months per year.
7
Q.
8
Exhibit 2 show about the level of unlawful migrant
9
activity within the national park?
10
A.
11
actually Department of Homeland Security, in their waiver
12
documents, aggregated data for the last five years.
13
the last row in there, 21 to 25, is the data comparable to
14
the numbers that -- that Homeland Security had.
Is
And what do the figures reflected in Plaintiffs'
It was extremely low.
The border -- CBP, in their --
So
So looking at the total number of people inside
15
16
the national park, 14,130 in that five-year period.
17
Compared to the entire sector, which is 89,000-plus, it
18
was very small.
19
section, third column from the right, is the percentage of
20
apprehensions inside the national park compared to the
21
entire border, and it was 0.016 percent, less than 0.2
22
percent over that five-year period that Homeland Security
23
is saying there is a national emergency.
24
Q.
25
different from the table you attached to your declaration
And the number in red in the right
In the table in Plaintiffs' Exhibit 2, is this
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
37a
12
1
supporting Plaintiffs' Preliminary Injunction Motion?
2
A.
3
Act response from the National Park Service had an error
4
in it for 2025.
5
they were inconsistent with one another.
6
looking at the the document, which was month by month, I
7
noted that they had made a mathematical error and pointed
8
that back out to the FOIA officer of the National Park
9
Service and said, "Can you update that with the correct
10
numbers?"
11
Yes.
Yes, the the original Freedom of Information
There they had given two documents and
And so when
So that was revised just recently.
And so what
12
you -- what we see in front of us reflects the updated
13
FOIA numbers.
14
The only difference was in 2025.
THE COURT:
Can I just clarify something?
It
15
says it's compiled by you, so I'm trying to understand:
16
Did -- did this come from --
17
THE WITNESS:
18
THE COURT:
19
20
Yes.
-- Washington?
Or is this something
you compiled?
THE WITNESS:
I put the numbers together in the
21
spreadsheet.
So if -- if you look below the table, there
22
are the sources for all the numbers.
23
spreadsheet, but the numbers in the left column inside
24
B&P, the yellow column, those came from the FOIA and --
25
and that came from the regional office in Denver, from the
So it's my Excel
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
38a
13
1
National Park Service, and all of the other numbers are
2
from publicly available sites that CBP has published.
THE COURT:
3
4
So you created the
spreadsheet?
THE WITNESS:
5
6
All right.
I created the spreadsheet.
I did
not create the data.
7
THE COURT:
8
THE WITNESS:
(BY MS. GRAVES)
All right.
Thank you.
You're welcome.
9
Q.
And we're bringing up what has been
10
marked as Plaintiffs' Exhibit 3.
Is this the FOIA data that you used to create
11
12
that spreadsheet?
13
A.
14
is the narrative explaining the data, but they also -- if
15
you keep going, there's probably the actual numbers.
16
these numbers are the ones in that leftmost yellow column.
17
So this came from the National Park Service.
Yes.
This is -- what you're showing in front of me
THE COURT:
18
Yes,
And it's the updated one, correct?
19
Because it says September 21st.
20
THE WITNESS:
Okay.
Thank you.
That's correct.
21
Q.
(BY MS. GRAVES) And are you familiar with the terrain
22
in Big Bend National Park?
23
A.
Yes.
24
Q.
And how about the Rio Grande Wild and Scenic River
25
corridor?
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
39a
14
1
A.
Yes.
2
Q.
And are you familiar with the terrain in Mexico
3
adjacent to the national park and can you briefly describe
4
those terrains?
5
A.
6
by river canyons, Some are as much as 1500 feet high, and
7
mountains that go up to 7800 feet high.
8
you're looking at incredibly rugged terrain, many smaller
9
canyons, arroyos, some steep cliffs.
10
terrain to traverse immediately along the river on both
11
sides.
12
very hard to get through, and then almost everywhere else
13
there's desert vegetation, which, while sparser, almost
14
everything is sharp and and extremely hazardous.
15
it is almost exactly the same on the Mexican side for even
16
more miles than on the American side.
17
Q.
18
through Big Bend National Park?
19
A.
20
and trails, it's fairly easy.
21
Legally or illegally is extremely difficult.
22
rough terrain.
23
complicated terrain.
24
and you think you can go on a straight line, when you
25
actually try walking it, you find that you can't.
I am, yes.
This is really remote area that is marked
And in between,
Very, very difficult
There's dense riparian vegetation, which is often
And so
And, in your experience, how easy is it to travel
Well, if you're a tourist and you stick to the roads
But going cross-country?
It is up and down.
It is just
It is deceptively
If you look from Point A to Point B
And
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
40a
15
1
there's -- there's arroyos and it's really hard to get
2
from one place to another safely and there's virtually no
3
water.
4
what we have here in El Paso, down by the river.
5
often 110 or 120 degrees in the summertime.
6
who's traveling cross country who is not well prepared
7
with good maps, GPS and all the rest is -- is going to get
8
themselves in trouble.
9
Q.
10
features make Big Bend National Park unique or
11
significant?
12
A.
13
physically wild, as I've described, but also
14
psychologically wild.
15
night skies in the Lower 48 that's been documented.
16
fact, it's part of the world's largest international dark
17
sky reserve, including the Mexican lands.
18
are in Big Bend National Park, even as what we call a
19
"windshield tourist", you can generally see virtually no
20
other signs of -- of -- of human development from where
21
you are at that time.
22
assemblage anywhere in the state of Texas and great
23
recreational opportunities on the river, as well as hiking
24
and -- and horseback riding, et cetera.
25
the park because it is so, so different from almost
And so this is a hot desert climate, not unlike
It's
And so anyone
And based on your experience as superintendent, what
It's one of the wildest places in the Lower 48.
Both
These -- this area has the darkest
In
And so if you
It's got the greatest wildlife
So people love
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
41a
16
1
everything else they've ever seen.
2
Q.
3
Grande Wild and Scenic River corridor?
4
A.
5
the national park and then it flows out of the national
6
park.
And so I'll describe the area outside the national
7
park.
Those are -- it's generally referred to as the
8
lower canyons, and I'm not sure the exact elevation of the
9
canyon rims, but it's well over 1,000 feet for most of it.
10
It is just as wild and remote.
11
are not as many tourist facilities, it's actually more
12
remote in many ways than it is inside the National Park.
And how would you describe the character of the Rio
Much of the the Wild and Scenic River begins inside
THE COURT:
13
And in fact, because there
Can I ask a favor?
I know one of
14
your exhibits is the map.
15
if, as he's describing these areas, we have the map.
MS. GRAVES:
16
Yeah.
It would probably be helpful
And we also have a
17
demonstrative in, like, a larger poster size, if that
18
would be more helpful?
19
THE COURT:
That would not be more helpful.
20
MS. GRAVES:
Okay.
We can pull up the digital
22
THE COURT:
Okay.
That would be perfect.
23
MS. GRAVES:
And can we publish this exhibit?
21
24
25
exhibit.
Thank you.
THE COURT:
Okay.
So could I ask you to sort of
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
42a
17
1
reiterate -- and the screen in front of you, actually, you
2
can touch and mark.
3
various areas, if you could mark what you're talking
4
about, that would be helpful.
5
THE WITNESS:
6
So Big Bend National Park is this, the area in
So as you're talking about those
Okay. Yes, thank you.
7
green.
The upstream boundary is right there, downstream
8
boundary is right there.
9
border where the entire Big Bend sector is 517 miles.
10
it's 23 percent of that.
That's 118-mile span of the
So
The Rio Grande Wild and Scenic River starts in
11
12
the park roughly there and extends to -- actually to the
13
sector boundary over here, that which is the county line
14
as well.
15
downstream point, I had some administrative
16
responsibilities for 245 miles of the border.
So between -- from this upstream point to the
17
THE COURT:
18
THE WITNESS:
Thank you.
You're welcome.
I should also
19
point out that Mexico has protected lands all over here
20
that many people would love to see it be an international
21
park.
22
also lands that, while there are private individuals that
23
live there, it's a little different than in the U.S.
24
It's -- it's generally wild land and there are no paved
25
roads anywhere in that vicinity.
It's a different paradigm there.
But these are
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
43a
1
THE COURT:
2
THE WITNESS:
18
Thank you.
You're welcome.
3
Q.
4
proposed border barrier construction within the park and
5
along the Wild and Scenic River corridor?
6
A.
Yes, I am.
7
Q.
And based on your experience as superintendent, how
8
would the proposed construction affect the character of
9
the park?
10
A.
11
so unique as an American landscape and protected area by
12
the Congress is the fact that there is so little visible
13
development.
14
trails, there are -- there are lodges and other things,
15
but they are in corridors in the park and everything
16
between the corridor is -- is pretty wild.
17
that this infrastructure that Border Patrol is -- or CBP
18
is proposing -- which I will also point out is very hard
19
to figure out what they're proposing because their
20
information has changed frequently and it's vague on their
21
websites.
22
barriers -- and, Judge, there would be some over here.
23
Some on this side of the canyon and on this side of the
24
canyon, and then right over here at the edge of the park.
25
(BY MS. GRAVES) And are you familiar with the
As I said earlier, a huge part of what makes Big Bend
I will say there are paved roads, there are
So the fact
But, nonetheless, 17 miles of vehicle
So the -- the two -- the east and most west
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
44a
19
1
section are partially in the park and partially out, and
2
the two in the middle are totally in the park.
3
vehicle barriers.
4
middle ones, there are no Mexican roads on the other side.
5
There's also very steep cliffs.
6
61 miles, I believe, of new patrol routes that would
7
parallel existing national park roads that the Border
8
Patrol currently uses.
9
river, one of those would go over this mountain right over
10
here, needing to climb 1700 feet to get over that
11
mountain.
12
that I'm familiar with have said there's no way you could
13
build that without blasting.
14
These are
And I will point out that in those
They are proposing about
In between those roads and the
And while they deny blasting, engineers that --
There are also a total of 205 miles of what are
15
vaguely called system attributes, which, as we best can
16
figure out, are -- includes the new patrol road and
17
upgrades to existing roads and buried communication
18
cables, power lines -- we don't know whether they'd be
19
buried or not -- possibly man camps, possibly wells that
20
would affect the -- the groundwater in the park, which is
21
fundamental to the administrative facilities as well as
22
several endangered species.
23
infrastructure.
24
that the park service has -- has very intentionally not
25
developed.
This is what I call massive
It would be major development in areas
It would impact wildlife, it would impact
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
45a
20
1
scenic views, It would have major impact on the
2
recreational experience of anyone who wanted to use the
3
river or anyone who's in the park and values the open
4
space and not seeing anything else.
5
Q.
6
affect the character of the Wild and Scenic River
7
corridor?
8
A.
9
there is a proposed vehicle barrier as well.
10
like it's proposed to be continuous.
11
And actually -- yeah.
12
Terrell County, which is this area here, who has 25 years
13
of experience with the Border Patrol has publicly said
14
that's an absurd thing.
15
expert than I.
16
top of canyon rims and there's just no way for a vehicle
17
to actually get from the river to the top of the canyon
18
rim.
19
Q.
20
physical border barriers within the park or along the Wild
21
and Scenic section of the Rio Grande?
22
A.
23
national park or the Wild and Scenic River in my tenure.
24
Q.
25
enforcement operations continue within the park?
Thank you.
And how would the proposed construction
There's -- I don't know the miles, but all along here
Sorry.
It looks
The judge -- oh.
The -- the sheriff from
I agree with that.
He's more
But most of those barriers would be at the
So it is overkill in -- in -- in the biggest way.
Thank you.
And during your tenure, were there any
There were no physical barriers anywhere in the
And despite the absence of barriers, did border
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
46a
21
1
A.
Yes, they did.
2
Q.
And based on your experience as superintendent, would
3
a temporary pause in construction impact how border
4
enforcement agencies operate within the park?
5
A.
I can't see how it would have any impact at all.
6
MS. GRAVES:
7
No further questions.
8
THE COURT:
9
All right, on behalf of the
respondent?
MS. AMAECHI:
10
11
Thank you.
Yes, we have some questions, Your
Honor.
THE COURT:
12
All right.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
13
14
BY MS. AMAECHI:
15
Q.
Hello, Mr. Krumenaker.
16
A.
I'm well, thank you.
17
Q.
Good.
18
Park from 2018 to 2023, correct?
19
A.
Yes.
20
Q.
You have never been employed by DHS or CBP, correct?
21
A.
That's correct.
22
Q.
You have never been trained as a Border Patrol agent,
23
correct?
24
A.
Correct.
25
Q.
You retired from the National Park Service in 2023,
How are you?
You were superintendent of Big Bend National
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
47a
1
July, correct?
2
A.
Yes.
3
Q.
And since July 2023, you have not had any official
4
role within the federal government, correct?
5
A.
Correct.
6
Q.
I want to show you the exhibit that you submitted
7
with your declaration.
Do you recognize what's on the screen?
8
9
22
A.
There's nothing on my screen.
THE COURT:
10
It will be in just a second.
11
A.
Yes, I recognize that.
12
Q.
(BY MS. AMAECHI) Perfect. Can you just tell the Court
13
again what this document is?
14
A.
15
to the judge a few minutes ago, from data that was
16
obtained through a Freedom of Information Act that --
17
that -- I submitted and received the data from the
18
National Park Service.
19
All the other data comes from publicly available sites
20
from CBP's websites.
21
Q.
22
up.
This is a spreadsheet that I compiled, as I described
That is the left yellow column.
Perfect. We'll just wait one second for it to come
So this is a chart of illegal migrant activity in
23
24
and around Big Bend National Park, correct?
25
A.
That is the title I put on it, yes.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
48a
23
1
Q.
And you compiled this, correct?
2
A.
I compiled the data from the Freedom of Information
3
Act data that had been supplied by the National Park
4
Service.
5
other data came from publicly available sites.
6
I put it on a spreadsheet myself.
7
Q.
Is it possible that the numbers are incomplete?
8
A.
Say again, please?
9
Q.
Is it possible that the numbers are incomplete?
10
A.
I have no reason to think that that the publicly
11
available data nor the data that the Border Patrol shared
12
with the National Park Service are not accurate.
13
simply reporting the data that they have provided.
14
Q.
15
apprehended in December 2024 in Big Bend National Park?
16
A.
17
knowledge of that.
18
Q.
19
migrants?
20
A.
21
Patrol agents have shared with the National Park Service,
22
then yes.
23
Q.
24
migrants that came over in December 2024, correct?
25
A.
Okay.
That data came from the Border Patrol.
But, yes,
I am
Do you recall four groups of migrants that CBP
I was not there in December 2024.
Okay.
All the
I have no
Did the data you compiled show those groups of
If that is included in the data that the Border
Okay.
So you were not aware of a group of 23
I do not have any knowledge of specific groups after
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
49a
24
1
I departed from the National Park Service.
2
simply the data that the -- that the Border Patrol agents
3
in the National Park Service have provided to the National
4
Park Service.
5
Q.
6
that CBP apprehended inside Big Bend National Park just in
7
December 2024, correct?
8
A.
9
so I -- I'm not denying knowledge of 163.
10
knowledge of that incident.
11
that the Border Patrol has shared with the National Park
12
Service and have no reason to think that, if there were
13
that number of people that were apprehended inside the
14
national park, they would not have shared that data with
15
the National Park Service.
16
Q.
17
for 2024 inside that second row titled "Inside Big Bend
18
National Park," that number says 102, correct?
19
A.
Yes.
20
Q.
Okay.
21
A.
The number is 102 because that's the number the
22
Border Patrol shared with the National Park Service.
23
Q.
Okay.
24
A.
I have simply taken the number that the Border Patrol
25
shared with the National Park Service that the National
Okay.
I am reporting
So you're not aware of a total of 163 migrants
I have no knowledge of whether that happened or not,
Okay.
I'm denying
I only know of the numbers
And the number that you listed in your exhibit
And that number isn't 163, correct?
And it's the number that you compiled, right?
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
50a
25
1
Park Service provided to me in a Freedom of Information
2
Act and put it on a spreadsheet.
3
Q.
4
the bottom -- if we could --
5
A.
One other question:
On the third to last row from
Scroll up, please, so I can see which row that is.
MS. AMAECHI:
6
Can we go back to Exhibit 1?
Perfect.
You can stop there.
The
7
same document.
Thank you.
8
Q.
9
to 2025 Total"?
10
A.
Yes.
11
Q.
And do you see the column that is labeled "Entire Big
12
Bend Sector"?
13
A.
Yes.
14
Q.
Is it right that from 2016 to 2025, Border Patrol
15
apprehended 127,732 people in the Big Bend sector?
16
A.
17
reporting what the Border Patrol -- what CBP has put on
18
their public websites.
19
Q.
20
listed here, correct?
21
A.
Yes, from publicly available sources.
22
Q.
Okay.
23
account for undetected border crossings, correct?
24
A.
These are apprehensions.
25
Q.
Okay.
(BY MS. AMAECHI) Do you see the row that says "2016
I believe it's the third column.
I have no personal knowledge of that.
I'm simply
But it's the number that you compiled and that you
You would agree that these numbers do not
So it's people who -- people who cross the
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
51a
26
1
border but were not detected.
This number doesn't reflect
2
that, correct?
3
A.
Correct.
4
Q.
You would agree that people who cross the border
5
sometimes carry drugs, correct?
6
A.
I have no knowledge of what those people carry.
7
Q.
Do you have knowledge of whether they carry guns?
8
A.
I have no knowledge of what they carry.
9
Q.
You have no knowledge of what they carry, correct?
10
But you said that you worked with CBP earlier when you
11
were superintendent.
12
A.
Yes.
13
MS. AMAECHI:
No further questions, Your Honor.
14
THE COURT:
All right.
15
MS. GRAVES:
Just one quick question.
Anything further?
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
16
17
BY MS. GRAVES:
18
Q.
19
Exhibit 3.
20
Exhibit 3 -- sorry, Page 4, Plaintiffs' Exhibit 3.
21
2024, can you read out the number that Mr. Rick Gutman
22
from National Park Service provided you for the number of
23
unlawful apprehensions -- migrant apprehensions in 2024?
24
A.
25
What I've circled?
I'm going to show you what is labeled as Plaintiffs'
And this is, I believe, Page 3 of Plaintiffs'
Under
Is this what we're talking about from the chart?
102.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
52a
1
Q.
Yeah.
27
Thank you.
2
MS. GRAVES:
No further questions.
3
THE COURT:
All right.
I have a quick question
4
for you and I would ask -- I don't know who has the map
5
that -- if you could put up the map.
Okay.
6
So on this map, what you drew on
7
previously, you'll note that there is -- it's labeled
8
BBT1, BBT22, BBT3. You see that correct?
9
THE WITNESS:
Yes.
10
THE COURT:
All right.
And you specifically
11
designated BBT4 as where the area of the Big Bend National
12
Park is, correct?
THE WITNESS:
13
Yes.
I -- I didn't label it, but
14
it's my understanding that BBT4 includes the national park
15
as well as a little bit of land outside -THE COURT:
16
17
Okay.
Do you know -- I'm sorry.
I
didn't mean to interrupt.
So do you know what these different areas are
18
19
specifically or do you only know where the Big Bend
20
National Park -- you didn't create this map?
THE WITNESS:
21
I did not create this map, but --
22
but I will say those -- the numbers are referring to the
23
contracts that CBP has issued.
24
boundaries are in the correct place.
25
them out.
I don't know if the
I did not compile
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
53a
THE COURT:
1
Okay.
28
Okay.
So if somebody could
2
display Exhibit 2 -- so in Exhibit 2 where it says "Inside
3
Big Bend National Park" and the numbers there, is that
4
referring to what's essentially labeled on that map as
5
BBT4?
6
talking about?
7
Are those -- those numbers, is that what we're
THE WITNESS:
These numbers would be within BBT4.
8
There is a little bit of BBT4 that is outside the park,
9
but this is the vast majority of BBT4.
10
THE COURT:
Okay.
Okay.
And then where it says
11
"Entire Big Bend Sector," does that then encompass all of
12
the rest of those BBTs that are labeled or do you know?
13
14
15
THE WITNESS:
Yes, it would be 1 through 5,
including 4.
THE COURT:
Okay.
So does BB -- I'm sorry.
Does
16
Entire Big Bend Sector not only include 1 through 5, but
17
it also includes 4 in there.
18
THE WITNESS:
19
THE COURT:
Yes, that's correct.
So 4 is twice.
20
individualized in the first column.
21
the second column.
22
23
THE WITNESS:
It's -- it's
It's also included in
That's correct, yes.
It is a
subset of what's in the second column.
24
THE COURT:
All right. Thank you.
25
MS. GRAVES:
No further questions.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
54a
THE COURT:
1
2
Government?
All right.
29
On behalf of the
Anything further?
3
MS. AMAECHI:
4
THE COURT:
5
You may call your next witness.
6
MS. GRAVES:
Plaintiffs call Adam Isacson.
7
THE COURT:
And he's already been sworn in, so
8
All right.
Thank you.
whenever you're ready.
ADAM B. ISACSON,
9
10
Nothing further.
having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
11
12
BY MS. GRAVES:
13
Q.
Please state your name for the record.
14
A.
Hi, I'm Adam Isacson.
15
Q.
And have you been retained to reach an expert opinion
16
in this case?
17
A.
Yes, I have.
18
Q.
And did you form an opinion about the unlawful entry
19
activity in the Big Bend sector?
20
A.
Yes, I did.
21
Q.
And we'll talk about your opinion in detail in a bit,
22
but first, let's talk about your qualifications to testify
23
as an expert in this case.
Where do you currently work?
24
25
A.
I work at a nonprofit and -- based in Washington
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
55a
30
1
called the Washington Office on Latin America.
2
Q.
3
organization?
4
A.
5
focus is security issues, including border security.
6
Q.
And how long have you served in that role?
7
A.
I've been at WOLA, the Washington Office on Latin
8
America, since 2010 and ran a similar project at the
9
Center for International Policy since 1995.
10
Q.
11
oversight involve?
12
A.
13
security assistance, foreign aid to military and police.
14
Since 2011, we have managed a project that monitors border
15
security throughout the entire U.S.-Mexico border as well
16
as how that relates to migration along the migrant route
17
through Latin America to the border.
18
America-focused organization, so we go from the border
19
south and we don't work very much in the U.S. interior.
20
Q.
21
America, where did you work?
22
A.
23
for International Policy.
24
Q.
And did you analyze data in that role?
25
A.
I analyzed data mainly about U.S. security assistance
And what is your current position at that
My title is director for defense oversight, where my
And what does your work as director for defense
It involves oversight, as you might imagine, of U.S.
We are a Latin
And before joining the Washington Office on Latin
I worked for a similar nonprofit called the Center
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
56a
31
1
in that role, yes.
2
Q.
And how long did you serve in that position?
3
A.
From 1995 to 2010.
4
Q.
And could you please describe your educational
5
background?
6
A.
7
from Yale University and a Bachelor of Arts in social
8
sciences from Hampshire College.
9
Q.
10
border security and migration?
11
A.
15 years since 2011.
12
Q.
And have you published any work about border security
13
and migration?
14
A.
Published numerous reports and book chapters, yes.
15
Q.
And you also publish a regular U.S.-Mexico border
16
update?
17
A.
18
rather popular product.
19
Q.
And what is that?
20
A.
We -- I basically am gathering information from all
21
sources, every source that I can, as well as what I
22
learned in meetings with people from up and down the
23
border.
24
trends and a lot of data.
25
heavy about what is happening up and down the border.
Sure.
I have a master's in international relations
And how long have you worked on issues relating to
We do.
We -- we publish a border update that is a
And every two weeks we put out a synthesis of
It tends to be sort of data
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
57a
32
1
Q.
And how frequently is that published?
2
A.
It's biweekly.
3
Q.
And approximately how many in-depth reports have you
4
authored or supervised concerning border and migration
5
issues?
6
A.
7
consequential enough, say, to list in my CV, I counted 28.
8
Q.
And how about articles?
9
A.
A much larger number than that.
10
Q.
Are you aware of any peer-reviewed journals that have
11
cited your work on migration and border security?
12
A.
13
Scholar to look at -- of those 28, at least five of them
14
have more than 25 citations.
15
Q.
16
analysis concerning border security, migration or related
17
issues?
18
A.
19
I have submitted declarations or had access to information
20
through discovery.
21
Q.
22
matters?
23
A.
Past cases, yes.
24
Q.
And how did you develop your knowledge and skills in
25
analyzing data?
Reports about border and migration that I found
Yeah.
I mean, I -- I -- I Googled -- I used Google
Have you previously testified or presented expert
I've never testified in federal court on this before.
That's about it.
And have you testified before Congress on border
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
58a
33
1
A.
I developed them mainly through -- it's going to be
2
very nerdy here, but collecting data using database
3
technology as it evolved over the years.
4
the MySQL, MySQL, database language, HTML to present data,
5
PHP and Python languages in order to extract data from
6
large datasets as well as just learning where, online or
7
elsewhere.
8
things -- things that Congress is able to report on, you
9
could find data quickly and then tabulate it.
10
Q.
11
and interpret quantitative data?
12
A.
13
the years as regular producers of hard-to-find numerical
14
data about security as well as, you know, producing
15
infographics and other visual aids to make it easier to
16
understand.
17
Q.
18
reviewed in this case.
I taught myself
And in CBP's datasets or in, you know,
And does your work regularly require you to analyze
Yeah.
I -- I think we've become known for that over
And let's talk briefly about the materials you
Did you review what's called "discovery" in
19
20
connection with this case?
In other words, the written
21
materials that were provided to plaintiffs by defendants?
22
A.
I did.
23
Q.
And do you recall what those materials covered?
24
A.
They did not cover a lot, to be honest.
25
provide a lot of new -- really very little that I could
I did.
They did not
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
59a
34
1
find useful in addition to what was already in the public
2
domain.
3
Q.
And what other materials did you review?
4
A.
I relied heavily on almost pretty much entirely from
5
CBP.
6
1925 when the Border Patrol was founded, but particularly
7
by sector since 1960 and then monthly data since 2000 --
8
2000, rather, and monthly data about apprehensions by a
9
whole range of characteristics like nationalities and
10
demographics, et cetera, since 2020.
11
Q.
Did you also review drug seizure datasets?
12
A.
I did.
13
back -- I have it since 2000 -- fiscal 2018, but you can
14
find the full dataset from fiscal 2020.
15
Q.
16
FOIA requests?
17
A.
18
since, I believe it's 2010, row by row tables where they
19
have -- show the characteristics of every single migrant
20
who was apprehended or encountered during those years.
21
Q.
22
case?
23
A.
24
25
CBP does produce its apprehension data going back to
CBP also publishes drug seizure data going
And did you review any information obtained through
I did.
CBP's FOIA page -- library page does include
And are you being compensated for your work in this
I am not.
MS. GRAVES:
Okay.
Your Honor, we'd like to
offer Mr. Isacson as an expert witness pursuant to Rule
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
60a
35
1
702 in the area of migrant trends along the U.S.-Mexico
2
border and analysis of government migrant apprehension
3
data.
4
THE COURT:
5
MS. AMAECHI:
6
THE COURT:
7
expert.
No objections, Your Honor.
All right.
He'll be recognized as an
Whenever you're ready.
MS. GRAVES:
8
Any objections?
And may I please copy -- provide him
9
with a copy of his report just to kind of refresh his
10
recollection as we walk through the data?
11
THE COURT:
12
exhibit? I'm not sure what --
13
MS. GRAVES:
14
His -- his report is different than
the -- than an exhibit.
THE COURT:
15
16
Is -- is it different than an
It's a little more comprehensive.
All right.
Does the Government have
any objections?
17
MS. AMAECHI:
18
THE COURT:
19
THE WITNESS:
No objections, Your Honor.
All right.
Yes, you may.
It's a lot of numbers to keep up
20
here.
21
Q.
22
as to the number of unlawful entries in the Big Bend
23
sector?
24
A.
Yes.
25
Q.
And do you have an opinion as to how it compares to
(BY MS. GRAVES) Mr. Isacson, do you have an opinion
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
61a
36
1
other Border Patrol sectors?
2
A.
3
nine geographic sectors.
4
last place among those nine sectors, it is in a very
5
distant last place.
6
Q.
7
sector is an area of high illegal entry?
8
A.
9
is not an area of high illegal entry.
10
Q.
And how did you reach those opinions?
11
A.
I reached those opinions by reviewing some of the --
12
all of the data from CBP that I mentioned already.
13
Q.
14
conducting that analysis?
15
A.
16
files, which are giant tables of -- of how many migrants
17
CBP apprehends every year from every sector, and then
18
turning those PDFs into spreadsheets, which I have shared
19
a few.
20
Section 4, Letter E, I just made a big Google spreadsheet
21
out of them and you'll -- they'll -- they'll be the exact
22
same numbers that you find.
23
how many people Border Patrol is finding, each of those
24
sectors in each year.
25
Q.
The Border Patrol divides the U.S.-Mexico border into
Big Bend sector is not only in
And do you have an opinion as to whether the Big Bend
My conclusion is that this is -- the Big Bend sector
And did you use a particular methodology in
Sure.
I mean, I was basically taking these PDF
If you -- if you go to -- in my declaration
Okay.
And then adding up by sector,
And is that methodology one that you regularly
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
62a
1
use in your professional work?
2
A.
Constantly, yes.
3
Q.
And how large is the Big Bend sector?
4
A.
The Big Bend sector is -- it covers about 517 border
5
miles, which is -- it's like driving from Richmond to
6
Boston.
It's very big and it is about 135,000 square
7
miles.
About the size of Germany or if you were to put
8
New York, Pennsylvania and Ohio together.
9
Q.
And does it include the state of Oklahoma?
10
A.
It goes all the way to Oklahoma, yes.
11
Q.
And what percentage of all U.S.-Mexico land border
12
miles are located within the Big Bend sector?
13
A.
14
in this sector.
15
Q.
16
you review data relating to "at large" and "at entry"
17
apprehensions?
18
A.
19
since, I believe, fiscal year 2024, as far as I can find
20
it.
21
Q.
And what does "at-large apprehensions" mean?
22
A.
That means that somebody was apprehended without
23
apparent evidence that they had recently crossed the
24
border.
25
stop or a checkpoint.
I believe it's 25.8 percent of all border miles are
And in formulating your opinion in this matter, did
I did.
The CBP has only started reporting that data
That they just found them probably in a vehicle
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
37
63a
38
1
Q.
And --
2
A.
Not always.
3
Q.
-- What does "at entry apprehension" mean?
4
A.
At entry means there are indications that this person
5
is a recent, very recent, border crosser.
6
Q.
7
at-large apprehensions?
8
A.
9
web page where only in the last few years that they
10
started breaking down what is "at large" and what is not.
11
But they only provided border-wide, so I don't have that
12
information for the Big Bend sector specifically.
13
Q.
14
of apprehensions that were classified at large?
15
A.
16
for the page exactly -- but it was a three-point-something
17
percent of the the total since 2024.
18
about 15-point-something percent in fiscal year 2026 so
19
far.
20
Q.
21
an at-large apprehension indicate about where an
22
individual was encountered?
23
A.
24
where the individual was encountered.
25
somebody whose visa expired, who lost their temporary
And what information did you review concerning
If you go to -- CBP has a nationwide apprehensions
And what did the data show concerning the proportion
It showed that at-large apprehensions were -- looking
That number rose to
And what does the at-large apprehension -- what does
It really doesn't tell us anything about whether -This could be
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
64a
39
1
protected status and Border Patrol just happened to find
2
them at a vehicle stop or something similar.
3
Q.
4
when an individual was encountered?
5
A.
6
were encountered.
7
Q.
8
person crossed the border, if at all?
9
A.
10
flown in on a legal visa.
11
Q.
12
person entered the country unlawfully?
13
A.
It does not.
14
Q.
What information about apprehended individuals was
15
included in the CBP data that you reviewed?
16
A.
17
sector where -- where along the border Border Patrol found
18
them, whether they were single adults or family members or
19
children, what country they came from.
20
limits there as well as whether they were -- we can get
21
into this -- whether they're processed under regular
22
immigration law or Title 42.
23
Q.
24
if anything, does the data indicate about the location of
25
an apprehension?
And what does an at-large apprehension indicate about
It really doesn't tell us anything about when they
They could have been here for decades.
And does an at-large apprehension tell you where a
It does not.
They could have -- they could have
And does an at-large apprehension tell you whether a
In the CBP data the information -- well, obviously by
Yeah.
Although with some
And we'll get to that in a minute.
But what,
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
65a
40
1
A.
It really only tells you the sector it happened in.
2
I don't -- it -- Border Patrol -- we'd requested, but CBP
3
would not provide data according to what station or what
4
subregion of the Big Bend sector people were apprehended
5
in.
6
news to me.
7
being that if they were to report it that granularly, that
8
organized crime might take advantage of it.
9
Q.
This -- this -- this new information from the park is
That's great to see.
The reason for that
And you had mentioned a highway checkpoint.
What is a Border Patrol highway checkpoint?
10
11
A.
Border Patrol maintains interior checkpoints.
12
Usually, you know, the -- somewhere within 100 miles of
13
the border where it's almost on just about every major
14
road or even minor roads leaving the border region into
15
the U.S. interior.
16
stop, asked if they're a citizen, maybe brought to
17
secondary screening or something like that.
18
of an extra layer of defense.
19
borderline that might be coming in further?
All motorists are going to have to
And it's sort
What did they miss at the
My understanding from a report, just looking at
20
21
the map, is that the Big Bend sector, at least in the late
22
2010s, had four checkpoints.
23
Q.
24
the highest percentage of apprehensions that occurred at
25
Border Patrol highway checkpoints?
And during the period covered by the data, what was
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
66a
41
1
A.
You know, I have to look at my declaration here.
2
Q.
And I'll refer to you to your supplemental
3
declaration for that.
4
A.
5
just don't want to get it wrong.
6
percent.
7
you know, I made -- I made flash cards and tried to
8
memorize it all.
Right.
And you have the exact paragraph number?
I
I believe it's nine
We pulled so much data out of out of this that,
9
But do you have the paragraph number?
Oh, I see.
10
No, that's -- yes, 99 percent during -- between fiscal
11
years 2013 and 2025, nine percent of Border Patrol's
12
apprehensions in the Big Bend sector happened at
13
checkpoints. In 2025, it actually jumped to 27 percent of
14
apprehensions for checkpoints.
15
Q.
16
a sector necessarily mean that those individuals cross the
17
border in that sector?
18
A.
19
count of people.
20
that sector.
21
they entered.
22
Q.
23
individuals had been present in the U.S. before
24
apprehension?
25
A.
And based on your review, do apprehension numbers for
No, it's just a -- it's a number.
It's not even a
It's a count of arrests that happen in
It doesn't indicate anything about where
And what did the data show regarding how long
The data about checkpoint arrests in the Big Bend
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
67a
42
1
sector showed that 42 percent of those apprehended at
2
checkpoints had been in the United States for a month or
3
more.
4
for a year or more.
5
Q.
6
apprehension statistics?
7
A.
8
who is apprehended may very easily have entered the United
9
States somewhere else.
10
that indicates -- and it actually reduces the likelihood,
11
in my view, that they would have crossed within the 517
12
miles of the Big Bend sector quite often.
13
are vehicle stops, for instance, on Interstate 10, which
14
goes from Los Angeles to Florida, and people could have
15
entered anywhere.
16
Q.
17
reflected in the CBP apprehension data that you analyzed
18
in this case?
19
A.
20
nationalities and their demographic characteristics.
21
Q.
22
individuals who seek asylum and those who do not?
23
A.
24
whether it does -- it doesn't separate people who
25
willingly turn themselves in, which most asylum seekers
Thirty-three percent had been in the United States
And why is that information relevant to understanding
I mean, that -- that tells you that the -- the person
They may -- there's nothing there
I imagine these
And what other categories of individuals are
Other categories would include whether -- their
And does the apprehension data distinguish between
The -- it does not.
It also does not indicate
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
68a
43
1
do, versus people who tried to evade capture.
2
Q.
3
the U.S.?
4
A.
5
who were waiting to be arrested, yes.
6
Q.
7
determination of whether border barrier is necessary?
8
A.
9
and Nationality Act says that anybody who is physically
10
present on U.S. soil has the right to ask for asylum if
11
they fear return to their country.
12
where the Rio Grande is always changing its course, you
13
always have some riverbank between the river and the wall.
14
So people routinely -- and I think you probably saw it
15
here at Gate 36 in El Paso -- for a long time will stand
16
on the riverbank and wait to be arrested south of the
17
wall.
18
Q.
19
apprehension data include individuals apprehended under
20
Title 42?
21
A.
22
42.
23
Q.
And can you explain what that is?
24
A.
Absolutely.
25
during the pandemic, the rules were changed.
So does it include individuals who sought asylum in
This number completely includes all asylum seekers
Are apprehension of asylum seekers relevant to any
No.
I mean section -- the -- the -- the Immigration
U.S. soil, especially
And prior, you mentioned Title 42.
So does the
Yes, it does include encounters under -- under Title
Between March 2020 and May of 2023,
Basically
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
69a
44
1
the right to ask for asylum was suspended and anybody who
2
was caught by Border Patrol was not processed under normal
3
immigration law.
4
weren't officially here in the United States.
5
easy to return them to Mexico or if they were from a
6
country that Mexico would -- would accept, they were
7
brought right back to the borderline quickly without a
8
record of having committed misdemeanor, improper entry,
9
into the United States.
10
their record, if they were caught again, there was no
11
extra consequence.
For all intents and purposes, they
If it was
That meant without anything on
They were not punished for that.
So what you had during the Title 42 period was a
12
13
lot of particularly single adults who were trying to evade
14
capture, who kept getting caught over and over again.
15
every time they were caught, they were counted as an
16
apprehension or rather technically an encounter over and
17
over and over again.
18
2023 -- this is not a count of individuals.
19
count of arrests, which are often multiple.
20
Q.
21
work in this matter, did you analyze CBP drug seizure
22
data?
23
A.
Yes, I did.
24
Q.
And what data did you review?
25
Q.
CBP -- if you go to CBP's drug seizures data page,
And
So this is not -- especially 2020 to
And let's talk about drug seizures.
This is a
As part of your
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
70a
45
1
they actually have a dataset of every month, sector and
2
type of drug since fiscal year 2020, since late 2019.
3
Q.
4
Big Bend sector?
5
A.
6
or 100,000 row table, and I used -- I made a database out
7
of it using MySQL and I made little web pages out of it
8
that generate tables so that I could see what was being
9
found in the Big Bend sector.
10
Q.
11
did you observe about the Big Bend sector's contribution
12
to total drug seizures along the southern border?
13
A.
14
Patrol drug seizures, seizures between the ports of entry
15
and then seizures at the ports of entry because all
16
drugs -- except marijuana, more than 80 percent of those
17
drugs are seized at the ports of entry.
18
nothing to do with border walls.
And how did you analyze the drug seizure data for the
Well, I took all of that data, which is roughly a 90
And after analyzing the CBP drug seizure data, what
All right.
We have to separate this into Border
So that's not --
Border Patrol seizures, the -- the Big Bend
19
20
sector accounts for one percent of non-marijuana drug
21
seizures and 15 percent of all drug seizures in the -- the
22
period for which we have data, 2020 to 2026.
23
Q.
24
drugs seized at interior immigration checkpoints?
25
Q.
And does the seizure data that you reviewed include
Yeah.
This is -- a significant -- actually, between
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
71a
46
1
a quarter and half of all nonmarijuana drugs border
2
wide -- I don't have it just for the Big Bend sector --
3
but border wide, between a quarter and half of all drug
4
seizures happen at checkpoints.
5
percent.
6
drug gets seized at checkpoints of all the Border Patrol
7
seizes.
8
Q.
9
seized at the border and drugs seized farther inland
10
within the sector?
11
A.
12
anywhere inside the sector.
13
Q.
14
between drugs seized by CBP from U.S. citizens and drugs
15
seized by the individuals who are in the U.S. unlawfully?
16
A.
17
arrested with drugs.
18
Q.
19
drugs that originated within the United States and drugs
20
that were unlawfully imported across the U.S.-Mexico
21
border?
22
A.
23
drugs came from.
24
Q.
25
that was seized at a CBP checkpoint?
Marijuana is normally 12
Actually, this year it's 36 percent of -- that
And does the seizure data distinguish between drugs
I mean, Border Patrol is just reporting what it finds
Okay.
And does the drug seizure data distinguish
I haven't seen data about the citizenship of people
And does the drug seizure data distinguish between
No.
There -- there's no estimate of -- of where the
So CBP's data could include marijuana grown in Texas
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
72a
47
1
A.
It could include -- yes, it absolutely could.
2
Q.
Or marijuana bought from a -- lawfully purchased at a
3
dispensary in New Mexico and seized at the CBP checkpoint?
4
A.
5
the four border states right now that still maintains
6
cannabis illegal, so it could come from one of the
7
other -- any state where there is legal cannabis.
8
Q.
9
determine how much of the seized drugs actually cross the
10
border in the Big Bend sector?
11
A.
There is no way to tell that, no.
12
Q.
And why not?
13
A.
Well, I mean, it looks like between checkpoints and
14
simple vehicle stops, we have to deal with the data that
15
we're given.
16
likely a majority of what is found is found on roads, in
17
vehicles and conveyances or in cargo trains or -- or
18
trucks.
19
somewhere else a significant portion of the time.
20
Q.
Sure.
We should keep in mind Texas is the only of
And based on the seizure data alone, can you
But a very significant portion -- most
And those may have entered the sector from
And do drug seizure figures tell us what -- sorry.
What do drug seizure figures tell us about
21
22
whether the Big Bend sector is an area of high legal
23
entry?
24
A.
25
not -- you're only finding trace amounts of drugs.
I mean, one percent of non-marijuana drugs.
You're
There
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
73a
48
1
is some marijuana found here and I'd like to know more,
2
frankly, about whether it's at checkpoints coming from
3
somewhere else or whether that many people are actually
4
putting it in backpacks and bringing it through the
5
terrain that Bob Krumenaker described.
6
to believe.
I find that harder
But, yeah, there is some marijuana found here in
7
8
the Big Bend sector, but that is also distorted because
9
nobody's bringing marijuana into the other three states
10
where it's -- you can buy it in a dispensary.
11
Q.
12
that you created, so let's talk about the migration
13
apprehension datasets that you reviewed.
Okay.
And I want to now pivot to some of the graphs
Is it accurate to say that the migrant
14
15
apprehension datasets go back to 1960?
16
A.
By sector, yes, we have it all the way back to 1960.
17
Q.
And in conducting your analysis, did you examine the
18
apprehension data over multiple periods?
19
A.
Yes, I did.
20
Q.
And what time periods did you examine?
21
A.
Let me find my graphics here.
22
it from 1960 to the present.
23
the present.
24
present and then just during the Trump administration.
25
Q.
But, yes, we -- we did
From this century, 2000, to
We did it, I believe, from 2020 to the
And on your screen, there should be a copy of
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
74a
1
49
Plaintiffs' Exhibit 4.
Mr. Isacson, can you see Plaintiffs' Exhibit 4 on
2
3
your screen?
4
A.
And my screen is still black.
5
Q.
Okay.
6
A.
There we go.
That's Figure 1.
Okay.
7
THE COURT:
And do you wish to publish?
8
MS. GRAVES:
Yes, please.
Please publish.
9
Q.
10
this data summarize?
11
A.
12
many miles are in each sector.
13
the entire data from 1960 all the way to the present.
14
can see each row is the -- the -- the sectors themselves
15
with Big Bend.
16
number of apprehensions.
17
number by the number of miles in each sector and then
18
dividing that by 12 to get how many people per mile per
19
month were found.
20
2000s, you know, the -- the -- the 21st century so far,
21
the 2020s and then the Trump administration at the bottom.
22
I just divide everything out.
23
(BY MS. GRAVES) So can you just tell us:
Okay.
What does
So the first column, of course, is just how
The next two columns are
You
In the last row, I looked at the total
I looked at then dividing that
And the same happens then for the
So here's the the percentage of border wide.
You
24
can see here that, for instance, Big Bend is 1.6 percent
25
of all migrant apprehensions during this time.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
75a
50
1
Q.
And from what sources did you obtain that data?
2
A.
That is entirely CBP data.
3
the sources in my report.
4
Q.
5
you reviewed?
6
A.
It's an exact replica, copy/paste.
7
Q.
And how did your analysis of CBP apprehension data
8
from 1960 to the present reveal about Big Bend sector
9
share of the total southern border apprehensions?
10
A.
11
accounts for less than two percent, 1.6 percent of all
12
migrants apprehended.
13
Q.
14
of southern border mileage?
15
A.
16
about how -- how does it compare to mileage?
17
it's -- if it's one quarter of miles and less than two
18
percent of migrants, that's a big difference.
19
you're -- you're -- you're talking about less than two,
20
1.9 migrants encountered in this sector over this entire
21
period in every typical mile in every typical month.
22
Whereas border wide, the number of apprehensions per mile
23
per month was 32.
24
Q.
25
Bend sector's apprehension rate per mile to the southern
And I include links to
And does this accurately summarize the CBP data that
I mean, from 1960, this 25, 26 percent of the border
And how does that compare to Big Bend's sector share
That would be -- you're basically -- you're talking
I mean,
I mean,
Quite a bit bigger than 1.9.
And what did you observe when you compare the Big
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
76a
51
1
border average?
2
A.
3
that is roughly one-fifteenth of what the rest of the
4
border or what the entire border sees.
5
Q.
6
Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 and
7
when -- I'm going to refer to that as IIRA -- when was
8
IIRA signed into law?
9
A.
It became law in 1996.
10
Q.
And I'm going to show you Plaintiffs' Exhibit 5.
You get -- you get a number of apprehensions per mile
And are you familiar with the Illegal Immigration
MS. GRAVES:
11
Could we please publish Plaintiffs'
12
5?
13
Q.
14
go -- start up, Page 2.
(BY MS. GRAVES) So from what sources -- and we can
From what sources did you obtain the data that's
15
16
analyzed in Plaintiffs' Exhibit 5?
17
A.
18
from 1960 to 2020, the monthly since 2000, and the
19
detailed dataset since 2020.
20
Q.
21
apprehension data?
22
A.
This is the data exactly.
23
Q.
Okay.
24
table?
25
A.
This comes from the same sources.
The -- the annual
And does it accurately summarize the underlying CBP
And what information is shown in each yearly
For each year here I showed, you know, breaking out
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
77a
52
1
for each individual year the number of people apprehended,
2
the number of people apprehended per mile per month and
3
the percentage of the border-wide total for each sector.
4
So for this one, 1996, you can see the Big Bend had 13,214
5
apprehensions -- I should not call this number of people
6
apprehended because you have multiple apprehensions.
7
it's the number of apprehensions, 13,214 apprehensions,
8
two apprehension events per mile per month, and then 0.9
9
percent of what was found border-wide.
10
Q.
And again --
11
A.
And then I made a pie chart just to illustrate that.
12
Q.
-- these apprehensions do not necessarily reflect the
13
number of apprehensions that were made of migrants that --
14
who actually crossed in the Big Bend sector, correct?
15
A.
16
sector. It doesn't indicate anything about how they
17
entered or whether they turned themselves in willingly.
18
Q.
19
represent?
20
A.
21
apprehensions in that sector, divide it by the number of
22
border miles in that sector, and then divide that by 12 to
23
get the -- the monthly average.
24
Q.
25
basis?
So
This just explains who they found in the Big Bend
And what does the per mile, per month column
Per month, you basically take the number of
And why did you calculate apprehensions on a per-mile
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
78a
53
1
A.
Because the -- it further illustrates just how remote
2
and how barely trafficked Big Bend is.
3
the other sectors, yet it sees significantly fewer migrant
4
entries that -- or apprehensions than the other sectors.
5
So this just further illustrates how sparsely crossed
6
or -- or entered this -- this -- this sector is.
7
Q.
8
Exhibit 5.
And I want to talk about 1996.
It is bigger than
This is Page 2 of
Approximately how many migrant apprehensions per
9
10
border mile per month occurred in the Big Bend sector in
11
this year?
12
A.
13
actually over this 30-year stretches is on the higher end
14
of what we were measuring -- or what the data shows.
15
Q.
You had 2.1 apprehensions per mile per month was --
Thank you.
Excuse me.
16
And in that same year, what percentage of all
17
southern border apprehensions occurred in the Big Bend
18
sector?
19
A.
Less than one percent, 0.9 percent.
20
Q.
And are you aware of which year recorded the highest
21
number of apprehensions in the Big Bend sector from the
22
data you analyzed?
23
A.
I want to say 2021.
24
Q.
And let's direct your attention to 2021.
25
Page 27 of P5.
And that's
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
79a
54
Approximately how many migrant apprehensions per
1
2
border mile per month occurred in the Big Bend sector in
3
2021?
4
A.
5
per month in that year.
6
since.
7
Q.
8
31 of Exhibit 5.
So Border Patrol is making six apprehensions per mile
It never got that high before
And directing your attention to 2025 -- this is Page
Approximately how many migrant apprehensions per
9
10
border mile per month occurred in the Big Bend Sector in
11
this year?
12
A.
13
one apprehension for every two months.
14
Q.
15
southern border apprehensions occurred in the Big Bend
16
sector?
17
A.
18
amount.
19
Q.
20
per border mile per month exceeded six?
21
A.
Six was the maximum.
22
Q.
And based on your analysis of the data, how does the
23
Big Bend sector compare to other southern borders sectors
24
in terms of unlawful entry activity?
25
A.
Zero point five apprehensions per mile per month.
So
And in that same year, what percentage of all
Big Bend accounted for 1.3 percent, a pretty typical
And since 1996, has the total number of apprehensions
It is an extraordinarily distant last place.
It --
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
80a
55
1
it doesn't play in the same league as the other eight
2
sectors.
3
that shows the overall number of apprehensions since 1960.
4
There it is.
5
Rio is about -- is -- is more than nearly one -- nearly
6
six times higher than Big Bend and there -- that's eighth
7
place.
8
dimension of -- of low illegal entry.
9
Q.
10
the northern Border Patrol sectors?
11
A.
12
apprehensions than what you see along the Canada border.
13
But, actually, things have dropped so far at the
14
U.S.-Mexico border in the last year and a half that Big
15
Bend has actually started to surpass some kind of border
16
sectors.
17
Ohio/Pennsylvania border to the end of Lake Ontario
18
actually is -- Border Patrol's apprehending more people
19
there than in Big Bend since, I believe, May or June of
20
this year.
21
Q.
22
unlawful entry in the Big Bend sector in absolute terms?
23
A.
24
area of non or low illegal entry.
25
Q.
In fact, if you look at the -- my first slide,
The next last place sector neighboring Del
So, yeah, I mean it's a completely different
And how does the Big Bend sector compare to some of
Historically, Big Bend sector has had more
Buffalo, NY, which goes from the
And what did your analysis reveal about the level of
In absolute terms, this is the very definition of an
And have you formed opinions to a reasonable degree
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
81a
1
of certainty within your field of expertise and what are
2
those opinions?
3
Q.
4
of high legal entry.
5
where it has even approached that definition by any way
6
you could define it.
7
MS. GRAVES:
No further questions for this
9
THE COURT:
Whenever you're ready.
10
MS. AMAECHI:
8
Yes, I have.
56
My opinion is that this is not an area
There have not even been periods
witness.
Thank you, Your honor.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
11
12
BY MS. AMAECHI:
13
Q.
Hello, Mr. Isacson.
14
A.
Hello.
15
Q.
Do you consider yourself an expert on border
16
security?
17
A.
Yes, I do.
18
Q.
What happens when there is barrier wall all along the
19
Texas border except for the Big Bend sector?
20
A.
Probably, in my view, not very much.
21
Q.
And, again, you do consider yourself an expert -- an
22
expert on border security, right?
23
A.
24
here, yes.
25
Q.
That's -- enough to have been invited to testify
Are you familiar with the cartel turf war in Ojinaga
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
82a
57
1
across Presidio?
2
A.
3
there's been recurring competition for that -- that Plaza,
4
although it is certainly not one of the hottest parts of
5
the border.
6
Q.
How long has the turf war been ongoing?
7
A.
I couldn't give you a date when it began, but it is
8
mostly a 20 -- well, it's mostly a 21st-century
9
phenomenon.
10
Q.
And does that turf war reduce illegal crossings?
11
A.
It's a different dynamic.
12
increase in violence, illegal crossings will go down.
13
People who, especially asylum seekers, will choose to go
14
somewhere else.
15
involved in migrant smuggling, yeah, I mean, they're going
16
to want things peaceful there in order to have that
17
happen.
18
Q.
19
in Big Bend One?
20
A.
21
between the Juarez cartel and the Sinaloa cartel.
22
know actually whether the Jalisco cartel has made any
23
roads lately.
24
Q.
25
crossings in Big Bend Two?
You know, Ojinaga, there have been recurring --
But often if there is an
However, if the organized crime group is
Do you know which cartel controls the legal crossings
In Big Bend One, I believe the competition has been
Okay.
I don't
And do you know which cartel controls illegal
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
83a
58
1
A.
I think the dynamic is pretty similar here.
2
the -- the Chihuahua Valley.
3
Q.
What about Big Bend Three?
4
A.
If there's a variation, it hasn't been reported.
5
Q.
And same for Big Bend Four?
6
A.
And Five.
7
Q.
And Five.
8
the United States through Big Bend Two and Big Bend Four?
9
A.
10
seen it in secondary sources and CBP has certainly not put
11
out any press releases that I'm aware of.
12
Q.
13
and security, right?
14
A.
15
areas and do mapping of organized crime presence across a
16
2,000 mile stretch of border?
17
expert, but I know of no expert who does that.
18
Q.
19
earlier.
Okay.
It's all
Are you aware of sicarios entering
I -- if there has been any report of that, I have not
But you do consider yourself an expert on the border
Am I somebody who is able to go into very dangerous
I still consider myself an
I want to ask about an assertion that you made
What is the basis for your assertion that no
20
21
marijuana is being illegally imported into United States
22
like certain states that allow marijuana?
23
A.
24
small amounts that -- well over 95 percent, I believe, of
25
marijuana that is being seized by Border Patrol at the
I didn't say no, but -- but the data show incredibly
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
84a
1
border right now is happening in Texas.
2
Q.
3
report now.
Okay.
I want to talk about your supplemental expert
Can you see what's on the screen?
4
59
5
A.
Not yet.
6
Q.
Okay.
Paragraph 20?
It's black.
7
THE COURT:
8
MS. AMAECHI:
And do you wish to publish?
Yes, I do wish to publish.
9
Q.
(BY MS. AMAECHI) Can you see it now?
10
A.
I sure can.
11
Q.
Okay.
12
fiscal year 2021 and fiscal year 2025, Border Patrol
13
apprehended over 89,000 individuals in the Big Bend
14
sector, correct?
15
A.
Correct.
16
Q.
And let's turn to Paragraph 25.
So in Paragraph 20, you noted that between
Can you see it on your screen?
17
18
A.
Yes.
19
Q.
In Paragraph 25, you said that in fiscal year 2025,
20
Border Patrol apprehended 3,096 people in the Big Bend
21
sector, correct?
22
sorry.
23
right?
24
A.
Yes.
25
Q.
And you agree that that number doesn't account for
And that 3,096 figure that represents --
That represents apprehensions in just one year,
An unusually low year, but yes.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
85a
60
1
those who came to the border totally undetected, correct?
2
A.
3
"gotaways" now.
4
Q.
I'm sorry.
5
A.
It does not account for what Border Patrol calls
6
"gotaways." People who got away.
7
Q.
8
about earlier, that also doesn't account for the people
9
who came to the border undetected, correct?
10
A.
11
rates across the border that show Border Patrol's
12
estimates of border-wide gotaways, and the effectiveness
13
rate is usually over 80 percent.
14
maybe another 20 percent.
15
different in Big Ben because we don't have the data from
16
CBP.
17
Q.
18
expert report, correct?
19
A.
The gotaway data, no.
20
Q.
All right.
21
supplemental expert report.
22
figure of 89,000 undocumented persons.
23
It doesn't account for what Border Patrol calls
Okay.
And that 89,000 figure that we also spoke
Correct.
Okay.
Could you repeat that?
We do have data, though, for effectiveness
So you would have to add
I don't know if the dynamic is
And you didn't include that data in your
Let's turn back to Paragraph 20 of your
I want to focus in on that
You said in Paragraph 20 the figures include
24
individuals encountered throughout the sector regardless
25
of where they cross the border, correct?
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
86a
61
1
A.
Right.
2
Q.
So, in other words, you -- you would argue that the
3
Big Bend sector numbers could reflect individuals who
4
entered from other sectors but were apprehended in Big
5
Ben?
6
A.
There's some likelihood of that, yes.
7
Q.
Wouldn't the inverse also be true?
8
individuals who entered from, for example, the Del Rio
9
sector, but were apprehended in Big Bend?
10
A.
11
found in the other sectors.
12
Q.
13
individuals who were lawfully admitted but later
14
encountered within the sector after overstaying or
15
otherwise lacking lawful status, right?
16
A.
17
stops, yes.
18
Q.
But it's part of the 89,000 figure, correct?
19
A.
Sure.
20
Q.
Overstaying a visa means that a person is no longer
21
in the U.S. legally, right?
22
otherwise lacks lawful status means the person is here
23
unlawfully, correct?
24
A.
25
do not have a documented status in the United States.
Couldn't there be
Possible, but unlikely because of the higher numbers
You also said that CBP's figure of 89,000 includes
That describes at large and checkpoint or vehicle
They are.
So an individual who
They're here -- yeah, I mean, they -- they
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
87a
62
1
Q.
So regardless of when they entered, these individuals
2
were still in the Big Bend sector without lawful status
3
when they were apprehended, correct?
4
A.
Correct.
5
MS. AMAECHI:
6
THE COURT:
Anything further of this witness?
7
MS. GRAVES:
No, Your Honor.
8
THE COURT:
All right. I'd ask you -- please
9
remain.
10
it's Exhibit 1.
11
All right.
No further questions.
I'd ask you to put up the map again.
I think
I have a question for you.
If -- and I don't know -- I think you have it in
12
front of you.
It's part of your supplemental expert
13
report, Mr. Isacson.
14
that you go fiscal year by fiscal year as part of your
15
attachment, correct?
16
THE WITNESS:
17
THE COURT:
And in looking through it, I see
Correct.
Okay.
So I'm looking at fiscal year
18
number, let's see, 2004 and I'm comparing it to fiscal
19
year 2021, right?
20
THE WITNESS:
Sure.
21
THE COURT:
All right.
22
And in fiscal year 20 --
2004, there were 10,000 apprehensions correct?
23
THE WITNESS:
Correct.
24
THE COURT:
25
37,000 in Big Bend, correct?
And in fiscal year 2021, there were
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
88a
1
THE WITNESS:
2
THE COURT:
63
Correct.
And for -- let's take El Paso in
3
fiscal year 2004.
There were 104,399, and in fiscal year
4
2021, there were 193,918, right?
5
THE WITNESS:
6
THE COURT:
Right.
Okay.
Correct.
So would you disagree with the
7
idea that these numbers are fluid?
8
are different reasons why people cross at different areas
9
at different times of the year because of different
10
circumstances and in different locations.
THE WITNESS:
11
In other words, there
Yeah, we found that organized crime
12
patterns on the Mexican side often have a lot to do with
13
it, too.
THE COURT:
14
15
So these numbers could change
in any given sector at any given time, correct?
THE WITNESS:
16
17
Okay.
They do, although we've seen on --
some real consistency in the Big Bend sector.
THE COURT:
18
All right.
Well -- and so part of my
19
my next question for you is one of the calculations that
20
you did was you took the sector land border miles and you
21
divided the number of crossings by that number of miles,
22
correct?
23
words, when we're talking about Big Bend, it's 517 miles,
24
right?
25
miles, so --
What information does that give me?
In other
But we're talking about San Diego, that has 60
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
89a
1
THE WITNESS: Right.
2
THE COURT:
64
-- how -- you wouldn't disagree with
3
me that there's not any way to know at any given time
4
where someone's going to cross Big Bend versus knowing in
5
a 60-mile area -- covering a 60-mile area where people are
6
going to cross, right?
7
THE WITNESS:
I'm not sure I got that question.
8
THE COURT:
Well, I'm -- I'm trying to understand
9
why -- when you say the -- when you're calculating the
10
number of crossings over 517 miles, you're comparing it to
11
the crossings in a 60-mile area -THE WITNESS:
12
I'm not sure I'm -- I'm just trying
13
to characterize high illegal entry or illegal entry at
14
all.
15
sectors of wildly different sizes, I think that would tell
16
us different things about the likelihood of high illegal
17
entry in both of them.
18
And if you had, say, 10,000 apprehensions in two
THE COURT:
Well, but, for example, in the El
19
Paso sector, there may be a whole lot of people that cross
20
right around El Paso and nobody that crosses in Hudspeth
21
County, for example, because of the terrain or whatever.
22
But that doesn't change the fact that in certain parts of
23
the El Paso sector, there could be a high volume of
24
crossings, correct?
25
THE WITNESS:
Right.
Correct.
And yet how urban
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
90a
1
65
an area is often does determine that.
THE COURT:
2
Okay.
So that's why I'm trying to
3
understand why this 517-mile stretch really gives me any
4
information because there may be sectors of that 517-mile
5
stretch that may have more crossings than others.
THE WITNESS:
6
Yeah.
I mean, I wish I had the
7
data showing that.
I wish that CBP shared it.
8
is any major population centers or major crossroads would
9
have vastly more and account for nearly all of the
10
apprehensions in the sector.
11
THE COURT:
Okay.
My guess
So we go back to that map that
12
you have in front of you and we're talking about that
13
whole 517-mile area as the border.
14
right?
15
don't know exactly where these apprehensions are
16
happening.
The Big Bend area,
And so those numbers that we're talking about, we
17
THE WITNESS:
I wish we did.
18
THE COURT:
Okay. Thank you.
19
MS. GRAVES:
Your Honor, if I may.
So, Your
20
Honor, we did -- plaintiffs did request data from
21
defendants breaking down the -- the sector-wide data to
22
station and even substation and they refused to give us
23
that data in discovery and that's why Mr. Isacson does not
24
have that data.
25
the record in discovery they did not -- they -- said that
And -- and I would also like to note for
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
91a
66
1
they tracked, you know, the data of individuals who evade
2
apprehension, but they -- they would also not release that
3
data to us.
THE COURT:
4
5
So noted.
other questions of this witness?
Thank you.
All right, any
You may step down.
6
You may call your next witness.
7
MS. GRAVES:
No -- no further questions.
Thank
8
you, Your Honor.
9
that our other three witnesses are waiting to -- to be
10
sworn in.
11
12
13
14
15
16
And I -- I was -- I've been informed
THE COURT:
Why don't we have them come in that
way they're covered.
If you would all come right forward in front of
the bench and raise your right hand.
(Witnesses duly sworn).
THE COURT:
You three have also been designated
17
as witness -- potential witnesses in this case and the
18
rule has been invoked.
19
witnesses, you cannot remain in the courtroom while
20
testimony is being given.
21
We'll call you in when it is your time is to testify.
22
And what that means is that, as
You have to remain outside.
While you're waiting, it is really important that
23
you understand that you cannot talk about the case.
24
can't talk about it with each other.
25
it with the audience.
You
You can't talk about
You can't talk about it with
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
92a
67
1
anyone.
2
it's really important you don't talk about the case.
3
that doesn't mean you can't talk.
4
anything else you like, just not about the case.
Everyone understand?
5
6
If you do, it will result in a mishearing.
you in just a minute.
Yes. All right.
8
Oh, excuse me.
I forgot to have you give out
your names of -- each of you that have been sworn in.
10
MR. JORDAHL:
11
MR. ADDINGTON:
Laiken Jordahl.
Bill Addington.
Guerra-
Addington.
13
MS. DEVINE:
Bernadette Devine.
14
THE COURT:
Thank you.
LAIKEN JORDAHL,
15
16
We'll see
Thank you.
You may call your next witness.
12
Now,
You can talk about
7
9
So
having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
17
18
BY MS. GRAVES:
19
Q.
20
record?
21
A.
Laiken Jordahl.
22
Q.
And where do you currently live?
23
A.
I live in Tucson, Arizona.
24
Q.
And where do you currently work?
25
A.
I work at the Center for Biological Diversity.
Mr. Jordahl, can you please state your name for the
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
93a
68
1
Q.
And what is your position at the center?
2
A.
I am currently a national public lands advocate.
3
Q.
And what do you do in that role?
4
A.
I advocate for protected public lands, wildlife and
5
endangered species across the Southwest.
6
Q.
7
position?
8
A.
9
advocate, also at the center, and prior to that I was a
10
borderlands campaigner dating back to 2017.
11
Q.
12
for Biological Diversity?
13
A.
14
National Park Service as a wilderness fellow.
15
reports assessing threats to wilderness character at five
16
different national parks, including Big Bend National
17
Park.
18
Q.
19
capacity as a wilderness fellow?
20
A.
21
Blocks" to wilderness stewardship.
22
I worked with ecologists, biologists, archaeologists and
23
park rangers to compile this report that looked at the
24
biggest threats facing the Big Ben wilderness.
25
Q.
And what position did you hold prior to your current
Prior to this, I was a Southwest conservation
And what did you do before you worked at the Center
Before I worked at the center, I worked for the
I compiled
And what did you do at Big Bend National Park in your
At Big Bend, I compiled a report called "Building
I assessed science --
And are you familiar with the area of west Texas
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
94a
1
commonly known as Big Bend -- the Big Bend region?
2
A.
69
Yes.
MS. GRAVES:
3
Can we get our exhibit on the screen
4
please and publish?
5
Q.
6
issued by the Department of Homeland Security for border
7
construction in the Big Bend region?
8
A.
Yes, I am.
9
Q.
And what waivers are you aware of?
10
A.
Last October, there was a waiver issued for the
11
entire sector.
12
contracting laws.
13
issued that covered our nation's most important
14
environmental laws like the National Environmental Policy
15
Act, the Endangered Species Act, and dozens of other laws.
16
There were a series of additional waivers for different
17
areas within the Big Bend sector following that March
18
waiver.
19
Q.
20
on what has been marked as Plaintiffs' Exhibit 1?
21
A.
Yes.
22
Q.
And you can actually annotate the map by running your
23
finger on it.
24
25
Thank you.
(BY MS. GRAVES) And are you aware of any waivers
That waiver covered procurement
Later on in March, another waiver was
And is the geographic scope of those waivers depicted
Can you point to the area that we refer to as the
the West Waiver and the -- the waivers covering the
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
95a
70
1
national park and the part of the state park and the Lower
2
Canyons waiver that -- depicted on -- in yellow on that
3
map?
Okay.
4
Thank you.
And can you describe the
5
geographic scope of those waivers?
6
A.
7
Bend sector and also stretch into the Del Rio sector.
8
They encompass all of the border in Big Bend National
9
Park.
10
They cover portions of the Big Bend Ranch State Park and
11
stretching downstream into the entire Lower Canyons area,
12
reaching all the way to Lake Amistad.
13
west, they cover the areas around Presidio and then all
14
the way up to Fort Quitman.
15
Q.
16
waivers authorize?
17
A.
18
30-foot-high border walls of vehicle barriers, of roads,
19
of staging areas and of other border infrastructure.
20
Q.
21
in the Big Bend region that have occurred pursuant to the
22
challenge waivers?
23
A.
24
couple of different areas where construction has occurred.
25
Q.
Yeah.
In totality, these waivers span the entire Big
They cover the Black Gap Wildlife Management Area.
Moving upstream or
And what kind of construction activities do those
Those waivers authorized the construction of
And are you familiar with any construction activities
Yes.
I have personally witnessed and documented a
And can you describe what you observed?
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
96a
Yeah.
71
1
A.
2
near Santa Elena Canyon where they had bulldozed native
3
riparian vegetation, desert willows, mesquites, Palo Verde
4
trees to build seemingly a new road alongside the existing
5
road.
6
seemed to stretch around four miles of -- of that
7
destruction.
8
park, I also visited and documented the area of Mariscal
9
Canyon where another stretch of seemingly roadway was
10
being built into the desert wilderness there.
11
Q.
12
Elena or near Santa Elena Canyon?
13
A.
14
August 15th and Santa Elena Canyon a couple days prior.
Between the existing road, the river.
And in addition to that in the national
That was the week of August 15th.
THE COURT:
Before you take the map off, could --
THE WITNESS:
Yeah. Is -- it -- it's not on.
18
Okay.
19
Canyon area is here.
20
MS. GRAVES:
Oops. Oh, sorry.
21
THE COURT:
Hold on, hold on.
23
I was in Mariscal
can you mark where you're talking about?
17
22
That area
And when did you observe the construction in Santa
15
16
In Big Bend National Park, I visited the area
Santa Elena Canyon is here.
and he can remark.
Okay.
THE WITNESS:
And then Mariscal
We can clear it
Go ahead.
Yeah.
The Santa Elena Canyon
24
area -- I would estimate that's about the area of road
25
that was cleared, and then Mariscal is down here.
VERONICA P. ESPARZA-BYLICKI, CSR, RPR
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS (EL PASO)
97a
72
1
THE COURT:
Thank you.
2
MS. GRAVES:
And I'm going to show you
3
Plaintiffs' Exhibit 6.
THE COURT:
4
Could you please publish?
It's not up yet.
Hold on.
There you
5
go.
6
Q.
7
at in this video?
8
A.
9
Canyon.
10
Maxie Adler, I believe on August 15th.
11
road to find this excavator and bulldozer working in this
12
desert wilderness.
13
Q.
14
area looked like prior to this construction?
15
A.
16
park.
17
Q.
18
at that time?
19
A.
20
There were no roadways, no infrastructure.
21
pristine.
22
A.
23
Plaintiffs' Exhibit 7.
This is an excavator clearing the roadway at Mariscal
This video was taken by my partner and fiancée,
We walked out the
And was
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.