Emergency Application — National Park Service, et al., Applicants v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States
Supreme Court briefAug 13, 2026
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX
District Court Memorandum Order Denying TRO (Dec. 17, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 17) ..................................................................................................................... 1a
District Court Memorandum Opinion Denying First Preliminary Injunction
Motion (Feb. 26, 2026) (Dkt. No. 47) ................................................................................ 5a
Memorandum Opinion Granting Second Preliminary Injunction Motion
(March 31, 2026) (Dkt. No. 60) ....................................................................................... 27a
Order Granting Second Preliminary Injunction Motion
(March 31, 2026) (Dkt. No. 61) ....................................................................................... 62a
Declaration of Elizabeth S. Merritt (Dec. 12, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 2-2) .................................................................................................................. 65a
Declaration of Alison K. Hoagland (Dec. 12, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 2-3) .................................................................................................................. 71a
Declaration of Jessica Bowron (Dec. 15. 2025)
(Dkt. No. 14-1) ................................................................................................................ 78a
Supplemental Declaration of Jessica Bowron (Jan. 15, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 30-3) ................................................................................................................ 83a
Second Supplemental Declaration of Jessica Bowron (March 23, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 55-2) ................................................................................................................ 87a
Declaration of John Stanwich (Dec. 15, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 14-6) ................................................................................................................ 95a
Declaration of Tammy Stidham (Dec. 15, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 14-9) .............................................................................................................. 103a
Supplemental Declaration of Tammy Stidham (March 12, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 52-1) .............................................................................................................. 105a
Declaration of Matthew C. Quinn (Dec. 15, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 14-11) ............................................................................................................ 112a
Supplemental Declaration of Matthew C. Quinn (Jan. 15, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 30-5) .............................................................................................................. 115a
Declaration of Joshua Fisher (Jan. 15, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 30-1) .............................................................................................................. 118a
Declaration of Heather Martin (Jan. 15, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 30-2) .............................................................................................................. 124a
Supplemental Declaration of Heather Martin (March 12, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 52-2) .............................................................................................................. 141a
Second Supplemental Declaration of Heather Martin (March 23, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 55-3) .............................................................................................................. 144a
National Park Service, Finding of No Significant Impact (Aug. 28, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 14-2) .............................................................................................................. 148a
National Park Service, White House East Wing Modernization and State Ballroom
Environmental Assessment (Aug. 2025) (Dkt. No. 14-3)............................................. 165a
National Trust, Annex of Past White House Construction (Dec. 29, 2025)
(Dkt. No. 20-1) .............................................................................................................. 196a
Court of Appeals Order Denying Stay Pending Appeal (Apr. 11, 2026) ........................ 211a
Second Supplemental Declaration of Matthew C. Quinn (Apr. 13, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 69-1) .............................................................................................................. 228a
District Court Amended Order (Apr. 16, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 73) ................................................................................................................. 231a
District Court Memorandum Opinion (Apr. 16, 2026)
(Dkt. No. 72) ................................................................................................................. 234a
Declaration of Daniel P. Driscoll (Apr. 17, 2026) ........................................................... 244a
Court of Appeals Order (Apr. 17, 2026) .......................................................................... 256a
Court of Appeals Opinion (Aug. 7, 2026) ........................................................................ 259a
Court of Appeals Judgment (Aug. 7, 2026) .................................................................... 395a
Declaration of Marco Rubio (Aug. 12, 2026)................................................................... 396a
Declaration of General John Daniel Caine (Aug. 12, 2026) ........................................... 400a
Declaration of Christopher G. Raia (Aug. 12, 2026) ...................................................... 402a
Declaration of Garrett R. Hoffman (Aug. 13, 2026) ....................................................... 408a
Declaration of Stephen Miller (Aug. 13, 2026) ............................................................... 411a
Declaration of Jeremy Eichberger (Aug. 13, 2026) ........................................................ 418a
Declaration of Sean M. Curran (Aug. 13, 2026) ............................................................. 422a
Declaration of Daniel P. Driscoll (Aug. 13, 2026)........................................................... 430a
Declaration of Jay Clayton, John Ratcliffe, Kashyap Patel, and
Markwayne Mullin (Aug. 13, 2026) ............................................................................. 434a
Declaration of Joshua Fisher (Aug. 13, 2026) ................................................................ 441a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 17
(1a)
Filed 12/17/25
Page 1 of 4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 17
2a
Filed 12/17/25
Page 2 of 4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 17
3a
Filed 12/17/25
Page 3 of 4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 17
4a
Filed 12/17/25
Page 4 of 4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
5a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 1 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
6a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 2 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
7a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 3 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
8a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 4 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
9a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 5 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
10a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 6 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
11a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 7 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
12a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 8 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
13a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 9 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
14a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 10 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
15a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 11 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
16a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 12 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
17a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 13 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
18a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 14 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
19a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 15 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
20a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 16 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
21a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 17 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
22a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 18 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
23a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 19 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
24a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 20 of 22
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 47
25a
Filed 02/26/26
Page 21 of 22
26a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
27a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 1 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
28a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 2 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
29a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 3 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
30a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 4 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
31a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 5 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
32a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 6 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
33a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 7 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
34a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 8 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
35a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 9 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
36a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 10 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
37a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 11 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
38a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 12 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
39a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 13 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
40a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 14 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
41a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 15 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
42a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 16 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
43a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 17 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
44a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 18 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
45a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 19 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
46a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 20 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
47a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 21 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
48a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 22 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
49a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 23 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
50a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 24 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
51a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 25 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
52a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 26 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
53a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 27 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
54a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 28 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
55a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 29 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
56a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 30 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
57a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 31 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
58a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 32 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
59a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 33 of 35
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 60
60a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 34 of 35
61a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 61
62a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 1 of 3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 61
63a
Filed 03/31/26
Page 2 of 3
64a
65a
66a
67a
68a
69a
70a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 2-3
71a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 1 of 7
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Civil Action No. _________________
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
DECLARATION OF ALISON K. HOAGLAND
I, Alison K. Hoagland, declare as follows:
1.
The facts set forth in this declaration are based upon my personal and professional
knowledge, and if called as a witness in this proceeding, I could and would testify competently
thereto under oath. As to those matters that reflect an opinion, they reflect my personal and
professional opinion on the matter.
2.
I am a member of the National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States
(“National Trust”). I have been a member of the National Trust for more than 40 years. I am
currently a Trustee of the National Trust and serve on its Executive Committee. In that role, I
advise on the governance and policy-making of the organization. I have also previously served as
an advisor to the National Trust on matters relating to Washington, D.C.’s interests in the formation
of Trust policy.
3.
In addition to my work as a trustee and advisor, I am an active individual member
of the National Trust. The National Trust’s members, including myself, use, enjoy, derive benefit
from, and have a substantial interest in preserving and protecting historic and cultural resources in
Washington, D.C., including the White House and President’s Park, which have been impaired by
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 2-3
72a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 2 of 7
the destruction of the East Wing of the White House by the defendants in this action, and will be
impaired further by the construction on the East Wing’s former site of a ballroom substantially
similar to that which the defendants propose to build.
4.
Apart from my work with the National Trust, I am professor emerita at Michigan
Technological University, where I taught history and historic preservation from 1994 to 2009. I
received my BA from Brown University and my MA in American Studies, with a concentration in
historic preservation, from George Washington University. I have written six books on various
aspects of American vernacular architecture; my most recent is The Row House in Washington,
DC: A History (University of Virginia Press, 2023).
5.
Prior to my professorship, I was the senior historian at the Historic American
Buildings Survey of the National Park Service, where I worked from 1979 to 1994. The Historic
American Buildings Survey (“HABS”) documents significant historic buildings with measured
drawings, large-format photographs, and written histories, which are then made available to the
public at the Library of Congress and online. Buildings documented by HABS are located
nationwide and include major monuments and memorials in Washington, as well as the White
House itself.
6.
In my past capacity as a volunteer and also Vice President of the DC Preservation
League (formerly Don’t Tear It Down!), I oversaw projects, undertook research, and prepared
landmark nominations concerning downtown Washington. Designation of the Downtown Historic
District and the Fifteenth Street Financial Historic District (adjacent to the White House) resulted
in part from my work. Alterations and demolitions of buildings in these historic districts, just as
for any locally designated historic landmark, must be reviewed by the Historic Preservation
Review Board before permits are granted.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
7.
Document 2-3
73a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 3 of 7
I have previously served on the boards of various organizations engaged in history
and historic preservation work, several of which have a particular focus on historic preservation in
Washington, D.C. Among these, I have chaired the board of the Delaware Historical Society,
chaired the Keweenaw National Historical Park Advisory Commission in Calumet, Michigan, and
served as president of the Vernacular Architecture Forum. I have also served on the boards of the
National Council on Public History, the Michigan State Historic Preservation Review Board, on
the Committee of 100 on the Federal City, and on the board of the DC Preservation League.
8.
I have also given walking tours for the Smithsonian Institution and public
presentations to local groups on various aspects of Washington’s historic architecture. In addition,
I have published scholarly articles on the topic, including “Nineteenth Century Building
Regulations in Washington, D.C.,” Records of the Columbia Historical Society 52 (1989): 57-77,
and “The Washington Public Library on Mount Vernon Square,” Washington History 2, No. 2 (Fall
1990): 74-89.
9.
I live on Capitol Hill, about 2 miles from the White House. I first moved to DC in
1977 and stayed until 1994, then returned in 2009 and have been here ever since. I travel to the
White House neighborhood frequently to attend meetings, view exhibits, and have medical
appointments. In the past year alone I have attended two rooftop gatherings with views of the
White House. I regularly walk through portions of President’s Park, including Lafayette Square,
in order to enjoy the historic buildings, the beauty of the L’Enfant Plan (which placed the
President’s House on axis with 16th Street), and the innovative preservation project concerning the
buildings surrounding Lafayette Square (overseen by Jacqueline Kennedy). I also regularly view
the White House from the south side, whether driving by on Constitution Avenue or walking on
the Mall.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
10.
Document 2-3
74a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 4 of 7
Built beginning in the eighteenth century, the White House is one of the most
historically significant buildings in the country. The White House was designed to be a symbol of
the new nation, and debates occurred about its style, size, precedents, and name. As built, the
“President’s House” was a neoclassical building, akin in size to an English country house. The
selection of this design through a competition shows George Washington’s preference for a fairly
modest building, not a palace. As such, the White House in its current form embodies some of the
ideals on which the nation was founded. Architectural historians look for meaning in architecture,
and the White House is one of the clearest examples of a building constructed with the explicit
intention of imparting meaning with its style, size, and scale. The symbolic nature of the White
House never fails to impress me, my students, and my out-of-town visitors.
Further, the
preservation of its essential nature—its republican simplicity—through many alterations and
renovations of the building also reflects the attitudes and beliefs of subsequent occupants.
11.
The White House affects my own research on more locally focused architecture in
two ways. As one of the first prominent government buildings in the new capital city, it drove
development around it, helping to define commercial and residential areas while also serving as a
landmark defining L’Enfant’s plan for the city, and attesting to the promise that city construction
would follow. Secondly, as the most important house in the city, the White House was also on the
leading edge of all improvements—running water, water closets, electricity, etc. A study of
Washington’s architecture without the White House as a reference point would be incomplete.
12.
As a resident of Washington, D.C., I intend to continue to travel to the area around
the White House, to walk through Lafayette Square, to attend functions in neighboring buildings,
and to continue to be impressed by this iconic building. In the past I have had reason to be in the
area about once a month, and I expect that pattern to continue. In addition, when the National
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 2-3
75a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 5 of 7
Trust holds its board meetings in Washington, which it does at least annually, it usually holds them
at the Decatur House on the northwest corner of Lafayette Square. I plan to attend those meetings
in 2026.
13.
If a ballroom were constructed, similar to that which the defendants in this action
have proposed to be built on the former site of the East Wing, it would cause permanent and
irreparable harm to the White House and President’s Park. To have an adjacent structure
overshadowing the White House, exceeding it in height and massing, would diminish the primacy
of the White House, which makes its architectural statement through its singularity on the
landscape. No longer would the eye be drawn to the jewel of the building in the center, declaring
to viewers that our president lives in a house.
14.
Accordingly, I would suffer both professional and personal injuries, including to
my aesthetic, cultural, and historical interests, if a ballroom of the proposed form and scale were
constructed on the site of the former East Wing.
15.
In the past, I have personally participated in public comment periods and public
review meetings—across a variety of venues—considering building plans that would alter or
impact sites of historic significance. As an example, I submitted comments to the National Capital
Planning Commission and the D.C. Historic Preservation Review Board in 2013 and 2014 when
those agencies were considering alterations to the Carnegie Library at Mount Vernon Square to
accommodate the Spy Museum, a project that ended up not happening. I would intend to
participate in any public review processes and comment periods made available for any project of
significant scale at the White House, including the ballroom project that has been discussed by the
defendants in this action, to provide insight and express concern regarding the adverse impact of
such a project on a site of such historical import to its local and national community.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
16.
Document 2-3
76a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 6 of 7
As with the rest of the American public, I have so far been denied the opportunity
to participate in or comment on this project in any formal setting. The abrupt demolition of the
East Wing has both deeply saddened me personally and affronted my professional work. But in
particular, the project’s proceeding without any of the legally mandated consultations and
opportunity for public input presents a unique and irreparable harm to the public, one that I feel
acutely as an architectural historian who has dedicated her career to studying the relationship
between local people and their buildings.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 2-3
77a
Filed 12/12/25
Page 7 of 7
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-1
78a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 1 of 5
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
DECLARATION OF JESSICA BOWRON, COMPTROLLER OF
THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE EXCERCISING THE DELEGATED
AUTHORITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
I, Jessica Bowron declare as follows:
1. I am the Comptroller for the National Park Service (“NPS”) and am exercising the
delegated authority of the Director of the NPS pursuant to a January 20, 2025 delegation
of that authority from the Acting Secretary of the Interior, and subsequent extension of
that authority by the Secretary of the Interior. I have been employed by NPS since 2007
and served as NPS comptroller since 2017.
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. In my current position as Comptroller, Exercising the Delegated Authority of the Director
of the NPS, I oversee the management and operation of all units within the National Park
System nationwide, as well as all NPS programs, NPS directorates, and regional offices.
The White House and President’s Park (“the Park”) is an administrative unit within the
National Park System in the NPS National Capital Region (“NCR”) comprised of the
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-1
79a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 2 of 5
White House, Lafayette Park, Sherman Park, the First Division Monument, and the
Ellipse.
4. NPS’s mission is to preserve unimpaired the natural and cultural resources and values of
the National Park System for the enjoyment, education, and inspiration of this and future
generations.
5. Under the NPS Organic Act of 1916, the NPS was authorized to “promote and regulate
the use of the National Park System by means and measures that conform to the
fundamental purpose of the System units, which purpose is to conserve the scenery,
natural and historic objects, and wild life in the System units and to provide for the
enjoyment of the scenery, natural and historic objects, and wild life in such manner and
by such means as will leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.”
54 U.S.C. § 100101. This authority generally extends to historic preservation and
construction activities at individual park units in furtherance of the purpose of the park
unit at issue.
6. The NPS Organic Act also supplies NPS with the authority to accept donations, including
“patented land, rights-of-way over patented land or other land, buildings, or other
property within a [National Park] System unit” and “money that may be donated for the
purposes of the System.” 54 USC § 101101.
7. In 1961, Congress enacted the Park’s enabling legislation and directed that the
President’s Park enclosure, which includes the White House, its wings, the grounds
within the White House fence and facilities located on those grounds, be administered
pursuant to the NPS Organic Act. Pub. L. No. 87-286 (1961). Congress directed that in
carrying out NPS’s responsibilities under its Organic Act, “primary attention shall be
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-1
80a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 3 of 5
given to the reservation and interpretation of the museum character of the principal
corridor on the ground floor and principal public rooms on the first floor of the White
House.” Id. However, Congress further directed that “nothing done under [the Park’s
enabling legislation] shall conflict with the administration of the Executive offices of the
President or with the use and occupancy of the buildings and grounds as the home of the
President and his family and for his official purposes.” Id.
8. In my current position, I have been and continue to be regularly briefed by John
Stanwich, the NPS Liaison to the White House, and members of the Park’s staff
regarding the East Wing Modernization and State Ballroom project (“the Project”), the
purpose of which is to establish a permanent, secure event space within the White House
grounds that meets presidential priorities for capacity and dignified official functions and
eliminates reliance on temporary tents and associated infrastructure strains.
9.
On August 28, 2025, and pursuant to the requirements of the National Environmental
Policy Act (“NEPA”), I signed and approved a Finding of No Significant Impact
(“FONSI”) for the White House East Wing Modernization and State Ballroom
Environmental Assessment. The FONSI determined that that the selected action,
establishing a permanent, secure event space within the White House grounds by
replacing the then-existing East Wing of the White House with a new building that will
house the White House State Ballroom, will not cause significant adverse effects
requiring the preparation of an environmental impact statement. A Non-Impairment
Determination prepared in compliance with NPS’s 2006 Management Policies and the
NPS Organic Act was attached as Appendix A. The FONSI, together with Appendix A,
are attached to this declaration as Exhibit A and available online on the NPS’s Planning,
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-1
81a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 4 of 5
Environment & Public Comment (PEPC) website at: ParkPlanning - White House East
Wing Modernization and State Ballroom Environmental Assessment.
10. The conclusions in the FONSI were based on the analysis in an August 2025
Environmental Assessment (“EA”) prepared by NPS for the Project. A copy of the
August 2025 EA is attached to this declaration as Exhibit B and available online on the
PEPC page for the Project.
11. NPS also documented compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation
Act (“NHPA”) for the limited activities associated with the East Wing Modernization
Project that would take place outside of the White House and its Grounds. The White
House and its grounds are exempted from the NHPA. 54 U.S.C. § 307104. A
Memorandum to File documenting, pursuant to 36 CFR 800.3(a)(1), a finding of no
potential for those activities to cause effects on historic properties is attached to this
declaration as Exhibit C and available online on the PEPC page for the Project.
12. NPS also documented compliance with Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act. A
Memorandum to File finding that the East Wing Modernization Project had no effect on
federally listed species or their habitats is attached to this declaration as Exhibit D, and
available online on the PEPC page for the Project.
13. The Executive Residence at the White House is handling project management for the
Project, which means that that it is in control of all aspects of the day-to-day execution of
the Project, including its scope, schedule, budget, design, and completion. However, the
Executive Residence is coordinating with NPS staff regarding the Project, in particular
with respect to potential impacts on NPS operations at the White House.
4
82a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-3
83a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 1 of 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF JESSICA BOWRON, COMPTROLLER OF
THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE EXCERCISING THE DELEGATED
AUTHORITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
I, Jessica Bowron, declare as follows:
1. I am the Comptroller for the National Park Service (“NPS”) and am exercising the
delegated authority of the Director of the NPS pursuant to a January 20, 2025 delegation
of that authority from the Acting Secretary of the Interior, and subsequent extensions of
that authority by the Secretary of the Interior. I have been employed by NPS since 2007
and have served as NPS Comptroller since 2017.
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. In my current position as Comptroller, Exercising the Delegated Authority of the Director
of the NPS, I oversee the management and operation of all units within the National Park
System nationwide, as well as all NPS programs, NPS directorates, and regional offices.
The White House and President’s Park (“the Park”) is an administrative unit within the
National Park System in the NPS National Capital Region (“NCR”) comprised of the
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-3
84a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 2 of 4
White House, Lafayette Park, Sherman Park, the First Division Monument, and the
Ellipse.
4. NPS’s mission is to preserve unimpaired the natural and cultural resources and values of
the National Park System for the enjoyment, education, and inspiration of this and future
generations.
5. Under the NPS Organic Act of 1916, NPS was authorized to “promote and regulate the
use of the National Park System by means and measures that conform to the fundamental
purpose of the System units, which purpose is to conserve the scenery, natural and
historic objects, and wild life in the System units and to provide for the enjoyment of the
scenery, natural and historic objects, and wild life in such manner and by such means as
will leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.” 54 U.S.C. §
100101. This authority generally extends to historic preservation and construction
activities at individual park units in furtherance of the purpose of the park unit at issue.
6. The NPS Organic Act also authorizes NPS to accept donations, including “patented land,
rights-of-way over patented land or other land, buildings, or other property within a
[National Park] System unit” and “money that may be donated for the purposes of the
System.” 54 U.S.C. § 101101.
7. In 1961, Congress enacted the Park’s enabling legislation and directed that the
President’s Park enclosure, which includes the White House, its wings, the grounds
within the White House fence and facilities located on those grounds, be administered
pursuant to the NPS Organic Act, Pub. L. No. 87-286 (1961). Congress directed that in
carrying out NPS’s responsibilities, “primary attention shall be given to the reservation
and interpretation of the museum character of the principal corridor on the ground floor
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-3
85a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 3 of 4
and principal public rooms on the first floor of the White House.” Id. However, Congress
further directed that “nothing done under [the Park’s enabling legislation] shall conflict
with the administration of the Executive offices of the President or with the use and
occupancy of the buildings and grounds as the home of the President and his family and
for his official purposes.” Id.
8. In my current position, I have been and continue to be regularly briefed by John
Stanwich, the NPS Liaison to the White House, and members of the Park’s staff
regarding the East Wing Modernization project (“the Project”), the purpose of which is to
establish a permanent, secure event space within the White House grounds that meets
presidential priorities for capacity and dignified official functions and eliminates reliance
on temporary tents and associated infrastructure strains.
9. The Project is intended to meet the functional goals and operational needs of the
Executive Office of the President (“EOP”). NPS determined that the Project was
consistent with the Park’s enabling legislation. Pub. L. 87-286. The Project will directly
benefit the American people in a number of ways, including by: (1) expanding the White
House’s ability to host large indoor events; (2) reducing reliance on large tents that
damage turf and infrastructure and necessitate costly repairs; (3) celebrating America's
history through new interpretive opportunities; (4) maintaining public access to key
interpretive areas and ensuring preservation of the museum character of the principal
ground floor corridor and State Floor public rooms of the White House; and (5) creating
a symbolic space for events of national importance, reinforcing shared civic identity and
pride.
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-3
86a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 4 of 4
10. The Executive Residence at the White House (“EXR”) has unique expertise in fulfilling
the operational needs of the President and providing for the use of the White House for
official ceremonial purposes as well as the President’s home. EXR is also best positioned
to coordinate with all agencies that have equities in the White House that may be affected
by the Project. Accordingly, NPS determined that it was in the best interests of the United
States for EXR to contract for and directly manage the Project.
11. EXR is therefore handling project management for the Project, meaning that it is in
control of all aspects of the day-to-day execution of the Project, including its scope,
schedule, budget, design, and completion. However, EXR is coordinating with NPS
staff regarding the Project, in particular with respect to potential impacts on NPS
operations at the White House.
12. Pursuant to NPS’s donation acceptance authority, 54 U.S.C. § 101101, on November 13,
2025, the agency accepted a private donation for the Project.
13. Pursuant to the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. § 1535, and for the reasons articulated in
Paragraphs 9 and 10above, on November 17, 2025, NPS entered into a reimbursable
agreement with EXR under which the donated funds were transferred to EXR to fund the
Project.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on January 15,
2026.
_________________________
Jessica Bowron
4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
87a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 1 of 8
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF JESSICA BOWRON,
COMPTROLLER OF
THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE EXERCISING THE DELEGATED
AUTHORITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
I, Jessica Bowron, declare as follows:
1. I am the Comptroller for the National Park Service (“NPS”) and am exercising the
delegated authority of the Director of the NPS pursuant to a January 20, 2025, delegation
of that authority from the Acting Secretary of the Interior, and subsequent extensions of
that authority by the Secretary of the Interior. I have been employed by NPS since 2007
and have served as NPS Comptroller since 2017.
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. In my current position as Comptroller, Exercising the Delegated Authority of the Director
of the NPS, I oversee the management and operation of all units within the National Park
System nationwide, as well as all NPS programs, directorates, and regional offices. The
White House and President’s Park (the Park) is an administrative unit within the National
Park System in the NPS National Capital Region (“NCR”).
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
88a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 2 of 8
4. The Economy Act, currently codified at 31 U.S.C. § 1535, is a longstanding authority
under which agencies may order goods or services from other federal agencies or major
organizational units within the same agency. It promotes efficiency by allowing
interagency acquisitions when it is in the government’s best interest, funds are available,
and the service cannot be provided as conveniently or cheaply by the private sector.
5. The Government Accountability Office (“GAO”) is a nonpartisan, independent agency
within the legislative branch. The GAO publishes a treatise titled “Principles of Federal
Appropriations Law,” which is referred to as “the Red Book.” The third volume of this
treatise, available online at https://www.gao.gov/assets/2019-11/203470.pdf, provides
detailed information and guidance to federal agencies regarding Economy Act
transactions. Agencies regularly consult this document regarding appropriations issues,
including Economy Act transactions, as well as the Office of Management and Budget’s
(“OMB”) Circular No. A-11 “Preparation, Submission and Execution of the Budget,”
which also discusses Economy Act transactions. OMB’s Circular No. A-11 is publicly
available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/a11.pdf.
6. The Red Book explains that “the subject of an Economy Act transaction must be
something the ordering agency is authorized to do and the performing agency is in a
position to provide. Also, there must be direct benefit to the paying agency. Apart from
these general prescriptions, the Economy Act makes no attempt to define the kinds of
work, services, or materials that can be ordered. This is in apparent recognition of the
great diversity of tasks and functions one encounters in the federal universe, and the fact
that these tasks and functions are subject to change over time.” Red Book, Third Edition,
Volume III at page 12-64.
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
89a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 3 of 8
7. The Red Book provides examples of transactions in which the Economy Act “has been
used,” or at least “recognized as available [authority] for,” including an agreement
between the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of the Navy under
which the “Navy would execute and superintend a contract for the construction of the
Corregidor-Bataan Memorial.” Red Book, Third Edition, Volume III at page 12-67.
8. To establish an Economy Act agreement with another federal agency for the other agency
to provide goods and services, the NPS initiates an order in the Department of Treasury’s
system that documents key data elements, including identifying 31 U.S.C. § 1535 as the
statutory authority for the transaction. A fully executed order constitutes an obligation of
funding under 31 U.S.C. § 1501(a)(1). This obligation is similar to obligations recorded
for contracting actions with a non-federal vendor. The Economy Act authorizes advance
payments to the seller as well as reimbursement for costs already incurred by the seller
pursuant to the agreement.
9. The NPS often relies on federal partners that provide valuable support and assistance to
the NPS to accomplish projects that the NPS has the statutory authority to perform, but
lacks the capacity or expertise to accomplish on its own. The NPS often uses Economy
Act agreements to accomplish such projects.
10. For instance, the NPS often relies on the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) to
provide design, assisted acquisitions, and construction management services to execute
large road projects on NPS lands. The NPS holds statutory authority under its Organic
Act to conduct those projects. But without the assistance of FHWA subject matter
experts, the NPS would lack the capacity and expertise to execute the volume of complex
road projects needed to maintain National Park System roads. FHWA uses its expertise to
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
90a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 4 of 8
develop the acquisitions strategy and quality assurance requirements, conduct source
evaluation, award and administer the design-build contract, and inspect and accept the
construction contractor’s work.
11. As one example, in 2021, the NPS entered into a $184 million Economy Act agreement
with FHWA to reconstruct 7.5 miles of the George Washington Memorial Parkway
between Spout Run and the I-495/Capital Beltway, reconfigure the existing roadway
geometry at the Route 123 interchange, and rehabilitate the Central Intelligence Agency
interchange. This important project is nearing substantial completion.
12. Another example of an NPS Economy Act agreement is an agreement with the U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers to replace a seawall on the west shoreline of Sandy Hook at
Gateway National Recreation Area. This seawall provides protection for NPS assets—
including the adjacent multiple use path, sewer line, sewage lift station, Hartshorne Drive
and historic officer row houses—but it has exceeded its service life and is in a state of
failure. Although this project falls within the NPS’s statutory authority, the Army Corps’
subject matter experts have superior knowledge to provide the design, contracting and
project management services needed to successfully execute this $14 million project.
Partnering with the Army Corps increases the NPS capacity to protect NPS assets and
execute projects that require specialized knowledge and experience.
13. At the White House and President’s Park, the NPS has entered into multiple Economy
Act agreements with other federal agencies with responsibilities at the park, including the
Executive Residence at the White House (“EXR”) and the U.S. Secret Service (“Secret
Service”). The NPS currently has an Economy Act agreement in place with the Secret
4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
91a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 5 of 8
Service to reimburse the NPS for costs to maintain security booths and to support security
closures of park areas.
14. Starting in 2015, the NPS entered into a series of Economy Act agreements with the
Secret Service to execute a project to replace the existing perimeter fence that
encompasses the White House grounds with a more protective perimeter barrier. In this
instance, the NPS was the servicing agency rather than the ordering agency. The NPS
Denver Service Center provided project management and contracting support for design
efforts and the construction phase of this project. This means that the NPS acted as the
design and construction agent for this project and engaged contractors to complete the
project, in consultation with the Secret Service and at the request of the Secret Service.
More than $80 million was transferred to the NPS by the Secret Service to fulfill this role
and construct and install the fence. The project was substantially completed in 2024.
15. As explained in my previous declaration dated January 15, 2026, EXR has unique
expertise in fulfilling the operational needs of the President and providing for the use of
the White House for official ceremonial purposes as well as the President’s home. EXR is
also best positioned to coordinate with all agencies that have equities that may be affected
by the East Wing Project.
16. Accordingly, the NPS determined that it was in the best interests of the United States for
EXR to contract for and directly manage the Project. consistent with the Economy Act
and the park’s enabling legislation, Pub. L. No. 87-286, which provides that NPS
management of the park shall not “conflict with the administration of the Executive
offices of the President or with the use and occupancy of the buildings and grounds as the
home of the President and his family and for his official purposes,”
5
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
92a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 6 of 8
17. In general, the NPS demonstrates compliance with its Organic Act for individual projects
by preparing a nonimpairment determination—a document that demonstrates in writing
that “in the professional judgement of the NPS decision-maker” the selected action “will
not result in impairment to park resources or values.” NPS’s “Guidance for NonImpairment Determinations and the NPS NEPA Process” is publicly available at
https://www.nps.gov/subjects/nepa/upload/Guidance-for-Non-ImpairmentDeterminations-andthe-NEPA-Process-Apr-2025_508.pdf.
18. The NPS’s 2006 Management Policies provide guidance to the NPS regarding the
management of the National Park System. The Management Policies are publicly
available at https://www.nps.gov/orgs/1548/upload/ManagementPolicies2006.pdf. In
Section 1.4.2 of the NPS Management Policies the NPS explains that it interprets
“impairment” under the Organic Act of 1916 and “derogation” under the Redwood
Amendment to be a single standard, as follows:
Congress intended the language of the Redwood amendment to the General
Authorities Act to reiterate the provisions of the Organic Act, not create a
substantively different management standard. The House committee report
described the Redwood amendment as a “declaration by Congress” that the
promotion and regulation of the national park system is to be consistent with
the Organic Act. The Senate committee report stated that under the Redwood
amendment, “The Secretary has an absolute duty, which is not to be
compromised, to fulfill the mandate of the 1916 Act to take whatever actions
and seek whatever relief as will safeguard the units of the national park
system.” So, although the Organic Act and the General Authorities Act, as
amended by the Redwood amendment, use different wording (“unimpaired”
and “derogation”) to describe what the National Park Service must avoid, they
define a single standard for the management of the national park system— not
two different standards. For simplicity, Management Policies uses
“impairment” (or a variation thereof), not both statutory phrases, to refer to
that single standard.
Management Policies at 10.
6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
93a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 7 of 8
19. Before entering the Economy Act transaction with EXR, the NPS complied with its
Organic Act, including the Redwood Amendment, by determining that the East Wing
Project would “not cause impairment of, or unacceptable impacts to, the park’s resources
or visitor experience” and the changes to the park from the Project would be “consistent
with the ongoing historical significance of the White House and its grounds.” The NPS
further concluded that the impacts from the Project would “not prevent the [NPS] from
fulfilling the park’s purpose.” The NPS documented these determinations in its NonImpairment Determination, attached as Appendix A to the NPS’s Finding of No
Significant Impact (FONSI), which was attached to my initial declaration in this case in
December 2025.
20. In the FONSI itself, the NPS determined that the East Wing Project “aligns with the longstanding functional goals of the Executive Office of the President, meets the current
operational needs of the Executive Office of the President, and is consistent with the
White House’s historical evolution and the park’s enabling legislation.” FONSI at 10.
21. EXR is therefore handling project management for the Project, meaning that it is in
control of all aspects of the day-to-day execution of the Project, including its scope,
schedule, budget, design, and completion. However, EXR is coordinating with NPS
staff regarding the Project, in particular with respect to potential impacts on NPS
operations at the White House.
22. As explained in my January 15, 2026 declaration, the NPS accepted a private donation
for the project on November 13, 2025, pursuant to its donation acceptance authority for
projects that are authorized by the NPS Organic Act, 54 U.S.C. §§ 100101, 101101.
7
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-2
94a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 8 of 8
23. Pursuant to the Economy Act, and for the reasons articulated above and in my previous
declarations, on November 17, 2025, the NPS entered into a reimbursable agreement with
EXR under which the donated funds were transferred to EXR to fund the Project.
24. On February 4, 2026, the NPS accepted a second private donation for the project, again
pursuant to its donation acceptance authority, 54 U.S.C. § 101101.
25. On February 9, 2026, pursuant to the Economy Act, and for the reasons articulated above
and in my previous declarations, the NPS modified the reimbursable agreement with
EXR to add funding. These additional donated funds were then transferred to EXR to
fund the Project.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on March 23,
2026.
_________________________
Jessica Bowron
8
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
95a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 1 of 8
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
DECLARATION OF JOHN STANWICH, NATIONAL
PARK SERVICE LIAISON TO THE WHITE HOUSE
I, John Stanwich declare as follows:
1. I am the National Park Service (“NPS”) Liaison to the White House. I have been in this
position for approximately 11 years. Prior to that time, I served as the Deputy NPS
Liaison to the White House for approximately 5 years. I have been employed by NPS
since 1992. In my current position, I report to the Deputy Regional Director of the NPS
National Capital Region (“NCR”).
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. As NPS Liaison to the White House, I supervise approximately 60 employees and
oversee NPS daily operations at the White House and President’s Park (“the Park”) as
well as at the White House Visitor Center and the Executive Support Facility. I function
as and have the line authority of a park superintendent, but, due to the unique nature of
the Park, I also have additional responsibilities of coordinating with other executive
branch entities that have responsibilities in and around the Park. My role also includes
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
96a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 2 of 8
planning for and executing major national events such as Presidential Inaugurations, the
National Christmas Tree Lighting, and the White House Easter Egg Roll.
4. The Park is an administrative unit within the National Park System comprised of the
White House, Lafayette Park, Sherman Park, the First Division Monument, and the
Ellipse. The Park is unique within the National Park System in that it serves as a private
residence, the seat of the executive branch of the U.S. government, a military installation,
a museum, and a public park.
5. In my role as NPS Liaison at the White House I regularly meet and coordinate with
representatives of several federal entities with responsibilities in and around the Park
including: the Office of Administration, Executive Office of the President; the Executive
Residence at the White House (“Executive Residence”); the White House Curator’s
Office; the National Capital Region of the U.S. General Services Administration; the U.S.
Secret Service; and the White House Military Office. I also perform on-site oversight of
NPS activities in and around the Park and am present on site on a daily or near daily
basis.
6. As the home of presidents, the White House must serve the needs of the presidential
family, just as any American home serves its occupants. Additionally, the White House
must serve the president as the location for official and ceremonial functions. In my role
as NPS Liaison to the White House, I coordinate closely with the Executive Residence at
the White House, within the Executive Office of the President to provide NPS support for
day-to-day official activities at the White House, to ensure that NPS’s maintenance and
preservation activities on site do not interfere with planned official functions, and to
support the White House tour program. The Executive Residence at the White House
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
97a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 3 of 8
provides for the use of the White House and its grounds as the official home of the
President and his family, supports the official ceremonial functions of the President, and
works with the NPS and other entities to promote the preservation and public
appreciation of the White House and its contents.
7.
The White House currently lacks a secure event space to host large events, such as State
Dinners. To accommodate such events, large tents are typically erected on the South
Lawn of the White House. In the past, these tents have caused substantial damage to NPS
resources on the grounds, particularly the turf, which then must be repaired or remediated
by NPS. The use of stakes to secure these tents also risks damaging irrigation systems
and other NPS infrastructure elements on the ground.
8. The Executive Residence is managing the White House East Wing Modernization and
State Ballroom Project (“the Project”), which requires extensive coordination with not
only NPS, but also with other government entities with management responsibilities in
and around the Park. Members of my staff and I have been closely coordinating with staff
at the Executive Residence and supporting the Project since early spring 2025. I have
personally attended, and continue to attend, coordination and planning meetings, and I
personally observe activity on site in the performance of my official duties. I, or members
of my staff, also attend weekly meetings with the general contractor engaged by the
Executive Residence at the White House for the Project, Clark Construction, that provide
regular updates on the Project’s status, identify potential issues that arise in connection
with the Project, and resolve those issues. Since the selection of Shalom Baranes
Associates as the Project architect, representatives of Shalom Baranes Associates have
also attended these meetings.
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
98a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 4 of 8
9. On August 18, 2025, I signed a Categorical Exclusion Documentation Form to document
compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”) for NPS activities on
site in anticipation of the commencement of construction activities, including removal of
museum objects from the White House and East Wing, limited relocation of trees and
shrubs, and survey and historic documentation actions at the White House. A copy of this
Form is attached to this Declaration as Exhibit A, and available online on the NPS’s
Planning, Environment & Public Comment (“PEPC”) website at ParkPlanning - White
House East Wing Modernization and State Ballroom Environmental Assessment.
10. The Park’s enabling legislation, Public Law 87-286, expressly addresses the
management of artifacts and stipulates that furniture, fixtures, and decorative objects
declared by the President to be of historic or artistic interest shall be considered
inalienable and property of the White House. Pub. L. No. 87-286 (1961). Items not
currently in use or on display are curated or stored at the NPS’s Executive Support
Facility and may be returned to the White House when required. NPS routinely transfers
museum objects and other materials from the Executive Support Facility to the White
House for use or display there and removes such objects from the White House for
storage or curation at the Executive Support Facility.
11. The Executive Support Facility is an off-site facility that houses utilitarian property for
use at the White House, as well as parts of the White House historical collection not in
use and other artifacts.
12. In late August 2025 through September 2025, I and members of my staff coordinated
closely with the White House Curator’s Office to identify and remove museum objects,
including paintings and historic furniture, from the East Wing, East Colonnade, and the
4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
99a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 5 of 8
Ground Floor State Rooms of the White House to be stored or curated at the Executive
Support Facility.
13. NPS’s Heritage Documentation Programs completed Historic American Building Survey
(“HABS”) documentation of the East and East Colonnade in late August 2025, including
3D/LIDAR scanning and photo documentation. NPS’s Heritage Documentation
Programs, including HABS, document historic sites and structures across the United
States through the creation of measured drawings, large-format photographs, and
historical reports. NPS’s Heritage Documentation Programs are prepared to provide
ongoing photographic documentation during the construction process to document the
Project for posterity.
14. The Executive Residence and the office of the White House Curator also performed
similar documentation including photography and 3D scanning to create a digital twin of
the East Wing and East Colonnade spaces for future preservation and interpretive
purposes.
15. During summer 2025, my staff and I worked closely with Clark Construction to identify
and plan to preserve historic building elements. Beginning in late-August 2025 through
early-October 2025, Clark Construction performed historic preservation work salvaging
historic materials within the East Wing and East Colonnade. Clark Construction removed
and is storing the stone columns, doors, and other items that are planned to be
reincorporated into the new facility. In addition to museum objects, NPS is also storing
historic items removed from the East Wing and East Colonnade by Clark Construction,
including the East Wing cornerstone and plaque, historic fencing, historic windows, light
fixtures, and the IM Pei-designed pergola from the East Garden.
5
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
100a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 6 of 8
16. I have been informed that abatement activities related to certain hazardous materials
within the Project area were performed by Clark Construction during the months of
September and October 2025. After Clark Construction completed the planned historic
preservation work and abatement activities, structural demolition of the East Wing and
East Colonnade commenced on October 20, 2025.
17. On November 6, 2025, members of NPS Cultural Resources Planning and Science
directorate visited the East Colonnade to consult with Clark Construction and review
plans regarding the removal of the portion of the East Colonnade immediately abutting
the Executive Mansion. Substantial care and consideration was given to ensure that the
removal of this last portion of the East Colonnade did not harm the Executive Mansion
and that the vibrations from construction activity were monitored so that the
deconstruction effort did not impact the artifacts and objects inside the Executive
Mansion. Removal of this portion of the East Colonnade was completed on November
21, 2025.
18. The White House tour program, which NPS supports in furtherance of its mission for the
Park, was suspended on August 30, 2025 to accommodate on-site Project activities. The
tour program resumed on December 2, 2025. Prior to the resumption of tour activities, a
need was identified to install a temporary modular pavilion and walkway on the North
Grounds of the White House to provide an entryway for guests and to house restroom and
coat check facilities that will likely otherwise be unavailable until the Project is complete.
On November 20, 2025, I signed a Categorical Exclusion Documentation Form to
document compliance with NEPA for the installation of this temporary tour facility, a
6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
101a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 7 of 8
copy of which is attached to this Declaration as Exhibit B, and available online on the
Project’s PEPC page.
19. As of December 5, 2025 above grade structural demolition of the East Wing and East
Colonnade has been completed by Clark Construction. Below grade structural demolition
has begun and is expected to be completed during December 2025. Below grade
excavation activities throughout the site continue.
20. At present, I anticipate that Clark Construction will commence work on the footings and
below-grade structural concrete in the East Colonnade area in January and in the East
Wing area in February. Above grade structural work is not anticipated to begin until
April 2026, at the earliest.
21. The architectural design for the above grade elements is still in progress but has been
coordinated in a manner to allow the below grade elements to be constructed as planned
while the above grade design is finalized.
22. I am coordinating with the Executive Residence and staff at the NPS National Capital
Region on submitting materials regarding the Project to the National Capital Planning
Commission. I understand that the Executive Office of the President intends to engage
with the U.S. Commission on Fine Arts at its discretion when the Commission has a
quorum and that plans are underway to appoint new members to the U.S. Commission on
Fine Arts. The NPS will provide whatever support is needed to advance these efforts.
23. Due to the impacts of the Project, spaces that were previously included in tours of the
White house are occupied by staff as office spaces, including the Vermeil Room, the
China Room and the Library, and thus no longer included in tours. Until the Project is
complete, Park visitors will not have the opportunity to enjoy and benefit from seeing
7
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-6
102a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 8 of 8
historic items in their historic context, such as the White House China Collection in the
China Room. Additionally, the East Colonnade, which will be reconstructed as part of the
Project, provided opportunities for Park visitors to view the South Lawn and its gardens.
If progress on the Project were halted, this would prolong these impacts to the
experiences of Park visitors.
24. I have also been informed that the below-grade waterproofing and structural concrete
work that will be occurring over the next four months is critical to bringing the temporary
construction state of the site into a more permanent condition, particularly in areas where
the existing-to-remain elements have been temporarily exposed.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on December
15, 2025.
_________________________
John Stanwich
8
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-9
103a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 1 of 2
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES, ,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
DECLARATION OF TAMMY STIDHAM, ASSOCIATE REGIONAL DIRECTOR,
LANDS AND PLANNING, NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, NATIONAL CAPITAL
REGION
I, Tammy Stidham declare as follows:
1. I am the Associate Regional Director for Lands and Planning for the National Park
Service (“NPS”) National Capital Region. I have been in this position for approximately
two years. Prior to that time I served as the Deputy Associate Regional Director for
Lands and Planning at the NPS National Capital Region. All together, I have been
employed by the NPS for over thirty-six years.
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. In my current position I represent the Secretary of the Interior as an ex officio member of
the National Capital Planning Commission. For the National Capital Planning
Commission, the National Capital Planning Act (40 U.S.C. § 8701 et seq.) sets aside
seats on the commission for certain officials. I serve as the Secretary of the Interior’s
designated alternate which authorizes me to serve on the commission in his place. As
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-9
104a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 2 of 2
such, I fully participate in the business of the Commission including making motions and
voting on Commission actions.
4.
In my capacity as an ex officio member of the National Capital Planning Commission,
on December 15, 2025, I received notification from Heather Martin, the Chief Financial
Officer for the Executive Office of the President, and Josh Fisher, the Director of the
White House Office of Management and Administration, expressing interest in meeting
to discuss plans for the Project. The National Capital Planning Commission is working to
set up this initial meeting with Commission staff.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on December
15, 2025.
_________________________
Tammy Stidham
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
105a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 1 of 7
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF TAMMY STIDHAM, ASSOCIATE REGIONAL
DIRECTOR, LANDS AND PLANNING, NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, NATIONAL
CAPITAL REGION
I, Tammy Stidham declare as follows:
1. I am the Associate Regional Director for Lands and Planning for the National Park
Service (“NPS”) National Capital Region. I have been in this position for approximately
two years. Prior to that time, I served as the Deputy Associate Regional Director for
Lands and Planning at the NPS National Capital Region. All together, I have been
employed by the NPS for over thirty-six years.
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. In my position as Associate Regional Director, and my previous position as Deputy
Regional Director, I have worked to plan and implement a substantial portfolio of NPS
projects across the region involving many different types of buildings and structures,
including comfort stations, offices, maintenance and operational facilities, law
enforcement facilities, stables, visitor-use and recreational facilities, utility and
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
106a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 2 of 7
infrastructure-related structures, large buildings, and nationally significant memorials.
My experience includes seeking and obtaining the approval of the National Capital
Planning Commission (NCPC) for NPS projects in the National Capital Region and
obtaining review by the Commission on Fine Arts (CFA) for NPS projects in the National
Capital Region.
4. Additionally, in my current position I represent the Secretary of the Interior as an ex
officio member of the NCPC. As such, I fully participate in the business of NCPC
including making motions and voting on Commission actions.
5. Due to my position, I am generally familiar with the buildings, structures and other
facilities on NPS managed lands in the District of Columbia, including their history and
condition. I am also generally familiar with NPS history and authorities.
6. Under the NPS Organic Act of 1916, the NPS is required to “promote and regulate the use
of the National Park System by means and measures that conform to the fundamental
purpose of the System units, which purpose is to conserve the scenery, natural and historic
objects, and wild life in the System units and to provide for the enjoyment of the scenery,
natural and historic objects, and wild life in such manner and by such means as will leave
them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.” 54 U.S.C. § 100101. This
authority extends to historic preservation and construction activities at individual park units
in furtherance of the purpose of the park unit at issue.
7. The National Park System has evolved over time and now includes more than 400 parks
across the country, covering more than 85 million acres. Systemwide, NPS infrastructure
includes more than 75,000 assets, such as historic buildings, visitor centers, comfort
stations, NPS administrative and maintenance facilities, trails, roads, bridges, and utility
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
107a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 3 of 7
systems. There are over 5,500 miles of paved roads, 17,000 miles of trails, and 25,000
buildings managed by the NPS. This unique infrastructure has evolved over time in
response to the NPS mission. Maintaining that infrastructure is a key NPS responsibility
8. In general, the NPS plans and approves projects to construct, rehabilitate, and maintain
the wide variety of buildings, structures, and other NPS facilities that support park
operations, resource protection, visitor use, public safety, resource interpretation, or park
administration. The NPS has long performed this role on parklands in the District of
Columbia.
9. NPS Administrative units in D.C. include Rock Creek Park, the White House and
President’s Park, the National Mall and Memorial Parks, National Capital Parks – East
and parts of the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal National Historical Park and the George
Washington Memorial Parkway. These administrative units manage individual park units
in D.C. such as the Lincoln Memorial, Ford’s Theatre, and the National Mall.
10. The NPS has substantial park infrastructure in D.C., including recreational facilities, such
as the NPS’s three public golf courses, administrative and maintenance facilities, visitor
centers, comfort stations, historic structures, and interpretive waysides and kiosks, as well
as other types of facilities in furtherance of the NPS’s mission.
11. The NPS may carry out construction, rehabilitation or maintenance projects itself using
appropriated funds through the NPS’s annual construction appropriation, if funds are
available. The National Capital Region headquarters and the recently constructed U.S.
Park Police substation, discussed below, were constructed using appropriated funds.
12. The NPS also uses its donation acceptance authority, 54 U.S.C. § 101101, to carry out
projects on parkland, including the construction of facilities. Such projects may involve
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
108a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 4 of 7
the donation of funds to NPS for the NPS to complete the construction. Examples of
privately supported construction or rehabilitation projects on NPS-managed lands in D.C.
include the repairs to the Washington Monument after the D.C. earthquake, the
Washington Monument elevator modernization, the Lincoln Memorial roof restoration,
the Lincoln Memorial undercroft project, and the Thomas Jefferson Memorial
museum/accessibility improvements. In some instances, these privately raised funds were
provided through authorized philanthropic partners such as the National Park Foundation
or the Trust for the National Mall and used in combination with appropriated funds.
13. Alternatively, the NPS uses its donation acceptance authority to accept donations of
completed projects. In such cases, the NPS authorizes a donor to construct a project on
NPS-managed land to NPS’s specifications, and the completed project is then donated to
the NPS. The U.S. Park Police Stables and Tennis Stadium, both discussed below, were
constructed by donors and donated to the NPS.
14. My office is located in the National Capital Region headquarters campus on Hains Point,
in East Potomac Park, managed by the NPS as part of the National Mall and Memorial
Parks. The NPS constructed the National Capital Region Headquarters, the U.S. Park
Police Headquarters, and additional administrative facilities at this site between 1963 and
1969 as part of the Mission 66 program (“National Capital Region Campus”).
15. In 2016, the NPS proposed renovation of the existing National Capital Region Campus to
consolidate NPS administrative offices, including park and regional headquarters, and the
construction of a new 13,000 square foot facility for the U.S. Park Police substation to
move the existing facilities out of the floodplain. The construction of the substation was
submitted to NCPC and CFA for review and approval.
4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
109a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 5 of 7
16. Below is an image of the campus as it existed in 2016 when the proposed substation
construction was submitted to NCPC for approval.
17. Below is a photograph of the newly constructed substation.
18. The tennis stadium in Rock Creek Park is another example of a large facility constructed
under NPS’s authority on parkland in D.C. The tennis stadium, large enough to seat
7,500, was constructed in the late 1980s by Washington Area Tennis Patrons Foundation
and donated to the NPS after construction was completed.
19. An image of the outside of the tennis stadium, which is the home of the annual DC Open
tournament, is below:
5
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
110a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 6 of 7
20. The recent U.S. Park Police Stables project on the National Mall is another example of an
NPS construction project in D.C. The stables were originally constructed in 1975 as a
temporary structure, adjacent to a maintenance yard and water treatment plant for the
Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool, to house park police horses. The project was submitted
to NCPC and CFA for review and approval.
21. In 2023, the NPS opened a 13,542 square foot U.S. Park Police facility that includes
public paddocks, educational areas, stable space, training and medical paddocks,
administrative areas, support, and employee parking. This project was constructed as a
donation from the Trust for the National Mall.
22. Below is an image depicting the newly constructed U.S. Park Police facility:
6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-1
111a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 7 of 7
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on
March 12, 2026.
_________________________
Tammy Stidham
7
112a
113a
114a
115a
116a
117a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
118a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 1 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
119a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 2 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
120a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 3 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
121a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 4 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
122a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 5 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-1
123a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 6 of 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
124a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 1 of 17
125a
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
126a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 3 of 17
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
127a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 4 of 17
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
128a
EX. 1
Filed 01/15/26
Page 5 of 17
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
129a
Filed 01/15/26
Page 6 of 17
NATIONAL CAPITAL PLANNING COMMISSION
+ + + + +
COMMISSION MEETING
+ + + + +
OPEN SESSION
+ + + + +
THURSDAY,
JANUARY 8, 2026
+ + + + +
The meeting convened in the Commission Hearing
Room at 401 9th Street NW, Washington, D.C., and
via videoconference, at 1:00 p.m., William Scharf,
Chair, presiding.
NATIONAL CAPITAL PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBERS
PRESENT:
WILLIAM SCHARF, Chair
Presidential Appointee (At-Large)
STUART LEVENBACH, Vice Chair
Mayoral Appointee
LINDA ARGO, Mayoral Appointee
MICHAEL BLAIR, Presidential Appointee
EVAN CASH, Office of the Chairman of the Council
of the District of Columbia
ANITA COZART, Office of the Mayor of
the District of Columbia
ARRINGTON DIXON, Mayoral Appointee
ED FORST, Administrator, General Services
Administration
WILLIAM HENDERSON, U.S. Senate Committee on
Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
ELLIE McGOWAN, U.S. House of Representatives
Committee on Oversight and Accountability
PHIL MENDELSON, Chairman, Council of the District
of Columbia
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
130a
90
Filed 01/15/26
Page 7 of 17
91
1
COMMISSIONER HENDERSON: Yes.
2 Commissioner Schaefer. Commissioner Cozart?
2
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner McGowan?
1 made by Commissioner Dixon and seconded by
3
COMMISSIONER COZART: Yes.
3
COMMISSIONER MCGOWAN: Yes.
4
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Schaefer?
4
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Thank you. The motion
5
COMMISSIONER SCHAEFER: Yes.
5 carries unanimously.
6
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Stidham?
6
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you very much, Madam
7
COMMISSIONER STIDHAM: Yes.
7 Secretary. We're now moving on to Agenda Item 7A,
8
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Argo?
8 which is an informational presentation on the East
9
COMMISSIONER ARGO: Yes.
9 Wing Modernization Project.
10
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Vice Chairman Levenbach? 10
11
VICE CHAIR LEVENBACH: Yes.
11 that Commissioner Cash was going to be leaving us
12
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Chairman Scharf?
12 and that Commissioner Mendelson was going to be
Quick logistical item. My impression was
13
CHAIR SCHARF: Yes.
13 taking his place virtually. Is he with us online
14
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Blair?
14 right now?
15
COMMISSIONER BLAIR: Yes.
15
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Yes.
16
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Administrator Forst?
16
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Yes, I am.
CHAIR SCHARF: Okay, perfect. Thank you,
17
COMMISSIONER FORST: Yes.
17
18
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Dixon?
18 sir. With that, do you want to proceed?
19
COMMISSIONER DIXON: Yes.
19
20
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Cash?
20
EAST WING MODERNIZATION PROJECT
21
COMMISSIONER CASH: Yes.
21
MR. FLIS: Hello. Thank you. Good
22
MS. HOTTEL-COX: Commissioner Henderson?
22 afternoon, members of the Commission. As was
1 mentioned, this is an informational presentation
92
INFORMATION PRESENTATION
1 including the Eisenhower Executive Office Building,
93
2 and overview of the proposed White House East Wing
2 which is to the west, shown on the image on the left,
3 Modernization Project.
3 and the main Treasury Building, which is located
4
4 to the east. Mixed used development frames the
Before I turn it over to the applicant team
5 I'm just going to provide you a brief background.
5 entire area, as it is located within the central
6
6 core of Washington, D.C.
The purpose of the project is to establish a
7 permanent secure event space within the White House
7
8 grounds that provides increased capacity for
8 within the District of Columbia. The National
9 official state functions.
9 Capital Planning Act requires Commission approval
10
10 for all federal buildings and open space around such
I think everybody is familiar with the
The project is located on federal land
11 location of the White House, but here on the screen
11 buildings within the District.
12 is a map view showing President's Park and the
12
13 surrounding context. The National Mall is located
13 other projects at the White House. Most recently,
14 here at the bottom of the screen. Pennsylvania
14 the White House fence in 2016 and 2017, and the
As you know, NCPC has reviewed several
15 Avenue is located to the north of the White House.
15 tennis pavilion in 2019.
16
16
And E Street is located to the south, just north
17 of the Ellipse. The project is proposed to be
In terms of the review of projects, NCPC
17 uses guidance from the federal elements of the
18 located between the Executive Mansion and the
18 Comprehensive Plan for the National Capital,
19 Treasury Building.
19 including policies related to urban design, parks,
20
20 and open space, as well as visitor experience, among
In addition to the Executive Residence,
21 the vicinity of President's Park obviously also
21 others. As you're aware, the Commission takes a
22 includes a number of significant buildings,
22 holistic approach when applying the Comprehensive
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
131a
1 Plan policies in the context of each project's needs
94
Filed 01/15/26
Page 8 of 17
1 and guests to the White House and grounds.
2 and objectives.
2
3
3 staff will work with the applicant to understand
One of the primary areas of interest for
95
As the design proceeds for review, NCPC
4 the review of this project is how the public will
4 these components, as well as any other comments
5 see and experience the Modernization Project from
5 raised by the Commission today.
6 the surrounding public spaces. Most notably, from
6
7 Pennsylvania Avenue to the North, as shown here on
7 it over to Josh Fisher with the White House, who
8 this image, or from E Street to the south, as shown
8 will begin their presentation. Thank you.
9 here. These are really the only publicly
9
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you.
10 accessible streets in the vicinity, as others are
10
MR. FISHER: Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman
11 located within a secure perimeter.
11 and Commission staff. My name is Josh Fisher. I'm
12
12 the Director of Management and Administration for
The public experience extends to several
And so, with that, I am going to now turn
13 aspects of the proposed project, which will be
13 the White House. We appreciate y'all allowing us
14 helpful to understand as the design advances,
14 the opportunity to discuss the East Wing
15 including how the pedestrian level-views from the
15 Modernization Project and the reason we believe it
16 north and the south may or may not change from
16 to be so vitally important.
17 current conditions; how the connector or colonnade
17
Every day, people from across the country
18 between the Executive Mansion and the new East Wing 18 and around the globe visit the White House and
19 Modernization Project will be designed; how the
19 surrounding grounds. They look to it as a
20 landscape will be designed, restored, or improved;
20 representation of the values that we, as Americans,
21 and how perimeter security and the associated
21 stand for. It is our responsibility to ensure that
22 infrastructure might be beautified for the public
22 the guests, those given the opportunity to come
1 inside the fence and those viewing from Lafayette
96
1 existing East Wing was not feasible for many
2 Park or the Ellipse, experience the pride and the
2 reasons. We found significant deficiencies and
3 powerful symbol of American democracy, leadership,
3 overall poor structural design and construction.
4 and history.
4
5
97
The colonnade was structurally unstable, the roof
While we are only discussing the ballroom
5 systems had exceeded their service life, and the
6 today, our efforts extend beyond the 18 acres so
6 underpinnings were not sufficient to support the
7 that every school group, family trip, marriage
7 necessary upgrades.
8 proposal, or birthday photo allow people to enjoy
8
9 the beautiful pride of our nation's capital and the
9 intrusion, accelerated deterioration, and mold
10 White House complex.
10 contamination. The electrical infrastructure was
11
11 obsolete, deemed undersized and noncompliant with
As you all know, U.S. presidents have been
12 renovating, expanding, and modernizing the White
In the East Wing, there was chronic water
12 current code. Facilities were also noncompliant
13 House to meet the needs of the present day, including 13 with both ADA and Secret Service requirements.
14 terraces built in the 1800s, the Truman Balcony in
14
Because of this and other factors, the cost
15 1948, the original East Wing built in 1902 and
15 analysis proved that demolition and reconstruction
16 rebuilt in 1942, as well as numerous other projects.
16 provided the lowest total cost ownership and most
17
17 effective long-term strategy. As part of this
When President Trump decided to build a
18 grand ballroom and modernize other aspects of the
18 overall process, we also took great steps to ensure
19 East Wing, we began researching. After careful
19 that we preserved extraordinary history features,
20 study and consultation with engineers, architects,
20 including parts of the original colonnade, the
21 historians, and other experts, we determined that
21 Kennedy Gardens, and the movie theater, amongst
22 modifying or renovating the colonnade in the
22 other items.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
1
Document 30-2
132a
98
In choosing to carry out the East Wing
1
Filed 01/15/26
Page 9 of 17
99
As I'm sure you're aware, historically,
2 Modernization Project, we are achieving life
2 when visitors come to the White House for events,
3 safety, ADA, environmental, and federal compliance.
3 that tour begins at passing through temporary
4
4 double-wide trailers to gain entry onto complex.
We are enhancing mission-critical functionality
5 and eliminating systematic infrastructure
5
6 failures. We are making necessary security
6 take place in a tent on the South Lawn. These tents
7 enhancements and delivering resilient, adaptative
7 affected more than just the world leaders; their
8 infrastructure aligned with future mission needs.
8 use destroyed large portions of the South Lawn,
9
9 degrading its appearance for overall visitors and
Importantly, the addition of the
State dinners or events with world leaders would
10 modernized facility also significant reduces
10 creating a reoccurring expense to replace and
11 negative impacts on the truly historic Executive
11 cultivate new grass.
12 Mansion and South Lawn. The hosting of large
12
Beyond the ballroom, we have plans for
13 events, the size of which were not contemplated when 13 beautifying visitors' experience in the area, such
14 it was designed and reconstructed, drastically
14 as Lafayette Park, and creating a superior, more
15 increases the rate of deterioration on the East Room
15 efficient visitor security screening center. In
16 and the State Dining Rooms, stressing the aging
16 the coming weeks and month, both NPS and Secret
17 structural components of that specific building.
17 Service will be submitting their plans on those two
18
18 topics.
In addition to consequential structural
19
19 and safety considerations, the East Wing
Inside the White Houses, spaces such as
20 Modernization Project will significantly improve
20 the ballroom, are just as important as the grounds
21 the experience of the American people and foreign
21 outside. The ballroom is where leaders will
22 dignitaries when they visit the White House.
22 gather, important decisions will be discussed, and
1 history will be made. It is a place that will bring
100
101
1 schematic design work that had been undertaken by
2 people together for diplomacy, celebration, and
2 McCrery Architects.
3 unity. A beautiful, well-maintained, and
3
4 historically-designed ballroom will show respect
4 2025, involved a fairly comprehensive evaluation
5 for these moments and emphasize the significance
5 of programmatic needs and design alternatives,
6 of collaboration and tradition in our government.
6 including multiple massing configurations, and, of
7
7 course, a whole series of elevational studies.
Now I will turn it over to Shalom, the
That earlier phase, which spanned most of
8 architect on this project, to discuss the ballroom.
8
9
9 continue to evaluate various sizes and
As you guys know, Shalom is no stranger to this
Following the transition to my firm, we
10 Commission. His work has been transformative
10 configurations for the project. Today, I'd like
11 across the D.C. region. So, we're excited to see
11 to report that the ultimate decision in late
12 what he can bring to the table.
12 November was not to continue exploring options for
13
13 increasing the size of the project; instead, the
MR. BARANES: So, good afternoon. And
14 thank you for the opportunity to appear before the
14 decision was made to advance one of the earlier
15 Commission. Today I'll provide a very high-level
15 schemes that had been developed prior to our joining
16 overview of the White House East Wing project. A
16 the team.
17 more detailed and fully developed submission will
17
18 be presented in one of your subsequent hearings.
18 contextual relationships. The addition's cornice
19
19 aligns and does not exceed with the cornice height
And I'd like to begin here with a brief
That scheme is calibrated to respect key
20 discussion of the evolution of the current design
20 of the White House. And the building mass is set
21 approach. I joined the project team approximately
21 back approximately ten-and-a-half feet from the
22 60 days ago, in early November, following the
22 White House's primary north facade on Pennsylvania
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
133a
102
Filed 01/15/26
Page 10 of 17
1 Avenue. These measures, I think, are essential to
1 to rationalize these functions in a manner that will
2 maintaining the visual primacy of the White House.
2 relieve the stress by increase connectivity,
3
3 operational efficiency, and by enhancing overall
The program includes a ballroom of
4 approximately 22,000 square feet. It's designed
4 security. The changes will allow the White House
5 to accommodate approximately a thousand seated
5 to be experienced and to age, I think, at a much
6 guests at a formal dinner. The total area of the
6 more graceful way over time.
7 two aboveground visible East Wing floors, that's
7
8 two floors, including the colonnade and the ballroom
8 to land in a thoughtful middle ground by adapting,
9 structure, is just slightly over 89,000 square feet.
9 as I mentioned earlier, one of the earlier 2025
10
103
In advancing this proposal, we have aimed
Below the ballroom, and included in the 89,000
10 designs that meets the thousand-seat requirement
11 square feet, the project incorporates a series of
11 for the ballroom. And also, as I mentioned earlier,
12 functions, which I'll show you on the boards shortly
12 further consideration of enlarging the size was
13 here.
13 abandoned in late November.
14
14
One could generously describe the current
Our primary focus has been on refining the
15 functioning of the White House support areas, such
15 exterior facades through the re-proportioning of
16 as loading, waste handling, general deliveries,
16 windows, masonry detailing, revisiting the exterior
17 food service, as being quite labyrinthian in
17 terraces, and further developing the interior
18 character. And I think that's a kind description.
18 spaces, of course.
19
19
These conditions reflect incremental adaptations
This scheme does require a two-story
20 over time, and they place ongoing operational stress 20 colonnade connecting the East Wing -- I'm sorry,
21 connecting the East Room in the White House to the
21 on the historic structure.
22
The proposed East Wing Modernization seeks 22 new ballroom. We believe it's appropriate to
1 evaluate this condition within the context of the
104
2 broader White House campus.
2
3
3
The White House is, therefore, considering
105
1 down.
The grade drops as we come around this way.
And there will be an entrance through a portico
4 the idea of a modest one-story addition to the West
4 here into a foyer with a grand stair that will take
5 Wing colonnade, which would serve to restore a sense
5 you up one level to the ballroom, and essentially
6 of symmetry around the original central pavilion.
6 meet where the other guests will be coming from the
7
7 other direction.
It will be considered as part of a future overall
8 planning framework which will be presented at a
8
9 future hearing here.
9 terraces on three sides of the building. On the
10
10 south side of the colonnade we have a terrace that's
So, with this context, I'll now just walk
The new structure here has a series of
11 you through, briefly, some of the boards that we
11 about 12-feet wide with a stair that leads down to
12 have here. So, here, of course, you have
12 the lawn panels. And then that terrace continues
13 Pennsylvania Avenue to the top here. Thank you.
13 around to the west side of the ballroom, along here.
14
14
You have Pennsylvania Avenue here; it's
And, actually, that's a very important life safety
15 at the upper part of the board. So the White House
15 egress point for the whole project.
16 complex. And, of course, the colonnades with the
16
17 (audio interference). There will be two priority
17 also lands at the lower level grade. Halfway down
And that leads down to a stair here, which
18 access points to the ballroom. And we are talking
18 that stair you can make a left and access a terrace,
19 about a large crowd here of a thousand people. One
19 which is underneath this colonnade roof. And that
20 of them will be through the White House, through
20 also has a stair leading down to the lawn.
21 the colonnade, to a foyer that will serve the
21
22 ballroom. And then the other one will be one level
22 drawings next time with viewsheds, but, for today,
We will show you much more detailed
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
134a
1 I'd just like to point out that there is a very dense
106
Filed 01/15/26
Page 11 of 17
107
1 as many of the guests will be entering from the other
2 cluster of trees here, which will remain, which
2 side, you will come up a few stairs here through
3 really affects your view from the south, the public
3 a portico, and that would give you access -- you'll
4 view from the south looking at this, just as there
4 be coming up here actually in a lower level -- that
5 is a dense cluster of trees that protects the view
5 will give you access to this hall here, the foyer,
6 of the West Wing. And we also have the same
6 and then up a grand stair which would land you right
7 condition on the north side, where we have a dense
7 in the same area here. And, again, giving you
8 cluster of both evergreen and deciduous trees, which
8 access to the ballroom.
9 will really frame the view of the central pavilion
9
10 of the White House.
10 we have are this large space, which is devoted to
11
11 food service. That's basically a commercial
These are very schematic drawings of the
On the lower level, the other uses that
12 two primary levels. On your right here is the
12 kitchen. And it will not only service the ballroom,
13 ballroom level, which is the upper level. And on
13 but also service events inside the White House
14 the left is the level below the ballroom.
14 itself.
15
15
So, well, let's start at the upper level
Opposite that, we have an office suite for
16 here. So if you're entering the ballroom from the
16 the First Lady. And then, on the lower level of
17 White House, the East Room is right here. You'll
17 the colonnade itself, we are rebuilding the movie
18 come across the colonnade, adjacent to the stairs
18 theater that had been there.
19 here, enter this foyer area, and then make your way
19
These are north and south elevations of
20 into the ballroom, which has windows on three sides, 20 the White House complex. We removed all three
21 facing east, west, and south.
21 trees. No landscaping at all is shown; just wanted
22
22 you to see the building very clearly. And I think
If you're entering from the other side,
1 the most important thing here, perhaps, is what I
108
109
1 elevation of the ballroom, which is directly across
2 mentioned earlier, which is the alignment of the
2 from the Treasury. This portico sits pretty much
3 cornice of the ballroom directly aligns with the
3 directly across from a portico that abuts the
4 cornice and the balustrade of the White House. The
4 Treasury.
5 heights will match exactly.
5
6
6 level, right through here. And the eight windows
Here you see the upper level of the East
The floor of the ballroom is at this upper
7 Colonnade. And I did mention the potential for a
7 that you see here are basically centered on the
8 future addition, a one-story addition, to the West
8 ballroom. On the opposite side we have the same
9 Wing. And that would occur right here. And you
9 condition, with the eight windows there centered
10 can see that the reason to think about that is so
10 on the ballroom.
11 that we would reinstate the symmetry around the
11
12 central pavilion of the White House. We have not
12 lower level here you're seeing windows that face
13 looked at that at all yet, but hope to do so in the
13 into -- they serve the First Lady's office suite.
14 future.
14
15
15 combination of stone and precast. It will all be
So, here is the view from the south.
This is the west elevation. And on the
We intend to develop all of this with a
16 Again, you have the rear elevation of the White House 16 painted white to match the White House. A very
17 itself. We have the ballroom with the portico.
17 similar finish as you see on the White House. And,
18 The terrace at the half-level. And then, of course,
18 of course, you know, the windows and all of the
19 here the West Wing, two-part with a colonnade.
19 masonry details are things we are working on right
20
20 now.
These are larger elevations so you can
21 start to understand the character of the building.
21
22
22 board. And this is just the north elevation, which
So, what we have at the top here is the east
And then, finally, I just have one more
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
135a
1 you saw a minute ago. But here we've added in the
110
Filed 01/15/26
Page 12 of 17
111
1 take a moment to thank my designee, Evan Cash, who
2 street trees, which are shown as a darker green.
2 comes to all the meetings. And I just want to thank
3
3 him publicly. And I also want to thank those who
And then we've put in transparent outlines of the
4 larger trees, which are behind the street trees
4 gave the presentation.
5 inside the fence line. So the trees pretty much
5
I do have a number of questions. The first
6 match the height of the proposed ballroom. So
6 is, how is this proposal consistent with the
7 you'll start to get a sense, when I show you at your
7 Comprehensive Plan's urban design requirements,
8 next hearing some photographs, the extent to which
8 which include, I think it's B.1.4 in the Urban Design
9 these will frame the view of the central pavilion.
9 Element, visually reinforce the permanents of the
10
So, that's all I have. And happy to open
10 Capitol Building, White House, and other
11 it up to questions if you like.
11 nationally-significant resources by protecting the
12
12 visual frame around them; and B.5.10, visually
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you very much for
13 that presentation and for showing us this diagrams
13 reinforce the special importance of the White House
14 and images. I'll open it up to the Commission now
14 and its grounds by protecting the existing spatial
15 for questions and clarifications.
15 relationship of the White House and the mass and
16
16 scale of adjacent buildings?
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Mr. Chairman,
17 I'll have some questions. This is Commissioner
17
18 Mendelson.
18 proposal is consistent with those comments of the
19
19 Comprehensive Plan.
CHAIR SCHARF: Please proceed,
20 Commissioner.
21
22
20
So my question pertains to how this
MR. BARANES: Thank you for those
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Oh, thank you. 21 questions, Mr. Mendelson. We are being very, very
22 careful, first of all, to maintain, I think, a fairly
I hope you can all hear me. I do want to just first
1 sufficient distance from the central pavilion of
112
1 already begun?
2 the White House. And by proposing that the
2
3 colonnades be developed in a matching way on both
3 work, there is some foundation work, but that's
4 sides of the central pavilion of the White House,
4 really not the limiting issue in terms of whether
5 I think we will actually be in concurrence with the
5 things can be changed or not.
6 paragraph that you just cited.
6
7
7 this gets further refined, the footprint could
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: All right.
MR. BARANES: There's been excavation
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Okay. So, as
8 That probably will come up again at future
8 conceivably be reduced a little bit, the work on
9 presentations.
9 the foundation, so far as not that significant?
10
10
Can the size, footprint, or location of
MR. BARANES: Well, as I said, the
11 the ballroom, the location of the ballroom on the
11 footprint has been studied fairly extensively
12 site, be changed at this point?
12 already, and many different massing options were
13
13 studied before we even came onboard. So, at this
MR. BARANES: I mean, certainly, anything
14 is possible. It all depends on schedule and money.
14 point, we've continued working with that, with the
15
15 product of all those studies, and we are primarily
But this particular location has been studied
16 pretty carefully by the previous architect, as well
16 refining the scheme.
17 as myself. And it's been determined that this is
17
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: So, I appreciate
18 the best location in terms of getting access to it
18 that the cornice line will not be higher than the
19 from the East Room of the White House.
19 historic structure, but is it possible that the
20
113
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: But part of my 20 height of the ballroom, which of course determines
21 question was the size or footprint. So, has
21 the cornice line, that that could be reduced
22 construction work on the ballroom foundation
22 somewhat? Because it still seems to me that it's
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
136a
1 overwhelming the existing building.
2
3
114
MR. BARANES: You know, it's interesting.
Filed 01/15/26
Page 13 of 17
1 addition to the Cannon Building where we increased
115
2 the height by one story. That was reviewed pretty
I mean, it is the same height. I think you're
3 extensively. And, you know, you could look at it.
4 familiar with the addition that we built to the
4
5 Wilson Building that you're in?
5 know, with the original historic structure, despite
6
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Yes.
6 the additional height.
7
MR. BARANES: So, you know, I mean, I bring
7
I mean, I think that, too, works really well, you
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: But my sense of
8 it up because this size -- this question of size
8 it is that there are two levels here. One is, I'm
9 and relationship of an addition to an historic
9 going to say the lower level, and then there is the
10 building comes up with almost every project I've
10 ballroom level. And I can't remember what the
11 ever worked on over the last 40 years. And we're
11 height. What is the height for the ballroom level?
12 essentially doing the same thing here we did at the
12
13 Wilson Building.
13 the front driveway, where the portico is of the White
14
14 House, we're approximately 51 feet above that
We're building an addition. Although at
MR. BARANES: Well, if you measure it off
15 the Wilson Building it really contrasts. It's a
15 elevation.
16 very modern addition; it contrasts very strongly
16
(Simultaneous speaking.)
17 to the neoclassical building. But, even there, we
17
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: That's roughly
18 matched the height. You know, we did match the
18 the level of the ballroom?
19 height of the existing building. And I think it
19
(Simultaneously speaking.)
20 works quite well. And we've done that on many, many 20
MR. BARANES: That's the roof of the
21 other structures.
21 ballroom. That's the height -- I mean, that's the
22
22 height of the balustrade around our ballroom
You know, we're just finishing up an
1 structure. I'm sorry, is that what you're asking?
2
116
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: No. I think I'm
1 project, which was not part of the NCPC process.
2
117
CHAIR SCHARF: And let me note just for
3 not asking it well. The ballroom is going to be
3 the record, if it's okay with you, Commissioner,
4 like a 20-foot ceiling or 40-foot ceiling?
4 it's long been the view of NCPC's Counsel's Office
5
MR. BARANES: It's about 38 to 40. Yes.
5 that the National Capital Planning Act does not give
6
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: And could that
6 us authority to review demolition or site
7 be reduced?
8
MR. BARANES: It's possible. Not
9 impossible.
10
7 preparation work. So, while many projects do come
8 before us at that stage, that's not a requirement
9 of the National Capital Planning Act, and review
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: I had one other 10 of demolition is not something that we have the
11 question, which I think is probably for Mr. Fisher
11 authority to do as a Commission.
12 and not you. And that is, why didn't the project
12
13 come to us a whole instead of after the demolition?
13 that. And I've actually read that legal opinion.
14
14
15
MR. FISHER: Thank you for that question.
Yeah, we've been -- we've begun work on this
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: I appreciate
And I'm not arguing with it. It's just that I don't
15 know the last time that a project has been presented
16 project. There are two phases to this project.
16 before NCPC or Zoning Commission or any of the
17 I think that you've alluded to it with Shalom here.
17 planning agencies where it wasn't presented as a
18
18 whole: this is what we're going to do and we will
There are some things regarding this project that
19 are, frankly, of Top Secret nature that we are
19 proceed with the demolition as we move forward.
20 currently working on. That does not preclude us
20 As opposed to here, where the demolition occurred
21 from changing the above-grade structure, but that
21 first.
22 work needed to be considered when doing this
22
I don't have any other --
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
1
Document 30-2
137a
118
CHAIR SCHARF: The Air and Space Museum
Filed 01/15/26
1 door of the White House.
2
2 addition is one example of that, where they
Page 14 of 17
COMMISSIONER DIXON: Oh. So the other
3 proceeded with demolition of the old addition, I
3 entrances will not accommodate --
4 believe, prior to presenting plans for the new
4
5 addition to this Commission. I think that's the
5 there for egress purposes, for fire code purposes.
6 nearest historical analogy. I could be wrong.
6
7
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: I just want to
MR. BARANES: The other stairways are
And they are stairways, so a wheelchair would have
7 to really go in the other direction.
8 conclude my -- I have a lot of respect for Shalom
8
9 Baranes. He's done a lot of great projects in the
9 be a concern, I would think. I mean, we want
COMMISSIONER DIXON: But I think that may
10 city over the decades and I just want to acknowledge
10 handicapped people to be able to egress, too.
11 that. Thank you.
11
12
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
12 believe me, we are looking very closely at all of
13
Do any other Commissioners have questions
13 the codes.
MR. BARANES: Oh, absolutely. No, no,
14 for the presentation team? Yes, Commissioner
14
15 Dixon.
15 -- there hasn't been any discussion of the new
16
119
COMMISSIONER DIXON: Secondly, there was
COMMISSIONER DIXON: One. The stairway, 16 security process that we used to go through, that
17 that's going to be handicapped accessible also, I'm
17 we have gone through, with the labyrinth of
18 assuming? You had mentioned stairways on the
18 different corridors to get cleared to get into the
19 building, but they were -- they're going to be
19 White House. How is that going to be addressed in
20 handicapped accessible, obviously?
20 this process?
21
21
MR. BARANES: The primary handicapped
22 access into the ballroom will be through the front
MR. BARANES: I'm sure they'd let you in
22 at any time, but -120
1
COMMISSIONER DIXON: No, I doubt that.
2
(Laughter.)
2 public, how this process may work. But one of the
3
COMMISSIONER DIXON: I haven't been back
3 detractions from the historical structures was the
1 it's a sensitive area to even put it -- make it
121
4 for a while.
4 complicated clearance process and the hodgepodge,
5
5 if you will. So I'm assuming you will present to
MR. FISHER: Thank you for the question,
6 sir. We are currently looking at a new visitors
6 us how that will be handled in the future --
7 entry facility that would be part of this project.
7
MR. FISHER: Yes, sir.
8
8
COMMISSIONER DIXON: -- so we can look at
Again, as we look at this, it's not just the East
9 Wing Modernization, it's not the ballroom; we are
9 that? Good. And I do hope we do something with
10 looking at a totality experience for the White House
10 the handicapped issue. Thank you.
11 complex.
11
12
12 Commissioners have questions for the project team?
As I mentioned earlier, historically, when
13 you come to the White House you go through
13
14 double-wide trailers, tents, out in the cold. We
14
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you. Do any other
Yes, Commissioner -COMMISSIONER HENDERSON: Clarification
15 don't think that that's befitting of what the White
15 from something that was presented. There was talk
16 House should be or could be, quite frankly. So
16 of adding, potentially, an additional level on the
17 those plans are under review. We're trying to put
17 West Wing side of the building. Is that to the West
18 them together, make sure that we've got our i's
18 Wing structure itself or just to the walkway or what
19 dotted and our t's crossed before we bring before
19 --
20 this Commission so that you guys can hopefully see
20
21 and enjoy what we've produced.
21 colonnade.
22
22
COMMISSIONER DIXON: Yeah, I think that
MR. BARANES: It would be just to the
COMMISSIONER HENDERSON: Okay.
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
138a
122
1
CHAIR SCHARF: Any other questions before
1
Page 15 of 17
123
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Vice Chairman
2 Levenbach. Commissioner Blair?
2 we proceed to deliberations?
3
Filed 01/15/26
Hearing none, I'd like to thank, as always,
3
COMMISSIONER BLAIR: I would just say I
4 our Staff and the presentation team here. Vice
4 think that, you know, it looks like it's going to
5 Chairman Levenbach, would you like to kick things
5 be very beautiful, but the utility, I think, for
6 off?
6 those of us that spend a lot of time there, is fairly
VICE CHAIR LEVENBACH: I think what
7 obviously. Winston Churchill said to the House of
8 strikes me about is this, you know, some people here,
8 Commons, when they were going to rebuild it, that
9 some of the Commissioners, have participated in
9 we shape our buildings and they shape us thereafter.
10 White House events more than I have, but I'm struck
10
7
The White House is a special place, but
11 at how much this expands the utility of the compound. 11 people come there to gather and to work. I would
12
I mean, I think about the Hanukkah party
12 tell you that we've seen times where simply doing
13 I just went to you. You start the north end of
13 something like getting the Congress together to have
14 Lafayette Park and you walk through one set of
14 a meal and break bread is not something that the
15 trailers and you walk through another set of
15 current structure of the White House really
16 trailers, and there's a coat check. And then when
16 accommodates in any way with the President of the
17 you get inside it's pretty crowded and there aren't
17 United States. That's a problem.
18 that many people there. And this is going to just
18
19 open up access to people at a much higher level.
19 the President of the United States, of any party,
20
20 is invited all over the world and goes and gets to
I think that it's going to be enjoyed for
When foreign dignitaries visit, you know,
21 generations to come, so I'm really excited to see
21 see the best of whatever the country has to offer.
22 how this project develops.
22
And I think the President's view would be that he
1 would -- he thinks the American people deserve that
1
Commissioner Mendelson?
2 same opportunity to have grand gatherings for
2
3 visitors to our country and show them what American
3 was muted. Let me say that I think that elevation
4 has to offer.
4 we saw from Pennsylvania Avenue was not as
5
5 disturbing to me as the elevation from the Ellipse.
124
So I think it has a obvious utility. I
COMMISSIONER MENDELSON: Yes. Sorry, I
6 think it's very considered in its design. And I
6
7 look forward to seeing the progress of the project,
7 this addition overwhelming the original historic
8 and appreciate your presentation and look forward
8 building.
9 to working with you.
9
10
11
12
And as I said in my questions, I'm concerned about
I appreciate that the architect, Shalom
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner. 10 Baranes, has really good taste with regard to
Administrator Forst?
COMMISSIONER FORST: Thanks so much,
11 dealing with historic structures, but I do think
12 that -- it sounds to me like the height could be
13 Chairman. James read from my notes, so I --
13 lowered without jeopardizing the footprint. I
14
(Laughter.)
14 don't think that the footprint -- that is, 89,000
15
COMMISSIONER FORST: Thanks.
15 square feet -- should be the goal in and of itself.
16
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Administrator
16
So maybe it can be and needs to be shrunk a little
17 Forst. Commissioner Dixon?
17 bit more. Again, looking at the elevations from
18
18 the south, it's just so -- it's just so imbalanced.
COMMISSIONER DIXON: I appreciate the
19 presentation and look forward, as this moves
19
20 forward, to more deliberation. Thank you, Mr.
20 is disturbing to me that we are looking at an
21 Chairman.
21 addition to this historic structure, but we're
22
125
The other observation I have is that it
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner. 22 looking at what appears to be an overall plan in
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
139a
1 a very segmented approach. So is there going to
126
Filed 01/15/26
1
2 be some changes with the visitor center? Is there
2
Page 16 of 17
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
Commissioner Cozart?
3 going to be some changes with Lafayette Park? Is
3
4 there going to be some changes with the West Wing?
4 staff for their work on this and for the
5
5 presentation. And I look forward to when it comes
But rather than looking at this as a whole, we're
7 concerning as well.
7
8
8
10
COMMISSIONER COZART: Yes. Thanks to the
6 before the Commission again.
6 going to be looking at it piecemeal, and that's
9
127
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
9
Commissioner Henderson?
COMMISSIONER HENDERSON: I would just
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
Commissioner Schaefer?
COMMISSIONER SCHAEFER: So, again, my
10 thank you as well. This is -- it's exciting. It's
11 suggest, to those of us who don't work in that
11 a great job overall with the architectural features.
12 complex every day, that it would be probably be
12
13 worthwhile and beneficial to our consideration to
13 since I echo the same comments as has come before
14 take some opportunities to go and see the site, see
14 me, as well, because I think this is a great
15 the facilities as they are, between now and future
15 opportunity for us to continue to expand upon the
16 considerations.
16 importance of our entire nation. So, thank you.
17
17
18
19
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
18
Commissioner McGowan?
COMMISSIONER MCGOWAN: I don't have any 19
And looking forward to see how this progresses,
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
Commissioner Stidham?
COMMISSIONER STIDHAM: Thank you. And
20 additional comments or questions, but thank you all
20 thank you for the overview. It is really helpful
21 so much for the presentation. It was very
21 to get a sense of the project.
22 informative.
22
And I should lead with that Secretary
1 Burgum, who I sit as a delegated position here, and
1
COMMISSIONER ARGO: Yeah. I want to
2 the Department of the Interior, supports the East
2 associate myself with my next door neighbor's
3 Wing Modernization without reservation. We
3 comments. And seeing, you know, how seeing how this
4 appreciate the designs that were shown here today
4 progresses. I have some concern about size and
5 and we look forward to seeing more detail,
5 scale in a number of ways, but we can talk more about
6 especially when it comes to the landscaping and
6 that, as I said, as the design and the work on this
7 understanding how the temporary facilities will be
7 progresses. Thank you.
8 -- how the uses that currently happen in this
8
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
9 temporary facilities are taking shape in the new
9
Speaking for myself, just a few things that
10 facility, to really understand how that replacement
10 I'd say. First of all, Commissioners, if you want
11 is taking place.
11 to come over to lunch, you're welcome anytime. I'm
12
12 happy to show you around.
128
As well as understanding clearly, you
13 know, it's important in those views, you know,
13
More seriously, though, I think every
14 anyone who is coming to visit who does not have the 14 project that comes before this Commission is
15 opportunity to be inside the fence to be able to
15 ultimately determined, in large part -- or is
16 understand and to view the White House. And so
16 shaped, in large part, by its function. And I think
17 understanding those views will be really helpful
17 it's worth emphasizing a point that Commissioner
18 when you come back, as well as the design choices
18 Blair made, which is the vital nature of the function
19 you make and the materiality. So we look forward
19 that I believe this project is intended to advance.
20 to much more detail and appreciate the overview.
20
21
21 to, frankly, travel around the world with the
22
CHAIR SCHARF: Thank you, Commissioner.
Commissioner Argo?
It's been a distinct honor for me to get
22 President and visit foreign countries and be hosted
129
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 30-2
140a
1 by the leaders of foreign countries. And I think
130
Filed 01/15/26
Page 17 of 17
1 that there is a real programmatic need for a building
2 it's notable that when the President of the United
2 like this.
3 States of American flies to the United Kingdom he's
3
4 hosted at Windsor Castle. And when, next year, the
4 then, is a lot of the issues that Shalom in
5 King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and North
5 particular was addressing in his presentation,
6 Ireland comes to the United States, more likely than
6 which is, given the programmatic need, given this
7 not, he will be hosted in a tent on the South Lawn
7 size that that programmatic need necessarily
8 with porta-potties.
8 requires for this project, how do we ensure that
9
9 this project accords with what we, as a Commission,
That, to me, is not a good look for the
131
So I think what we're really talking about,
10 United States of America. And I think that, when
10 care about? How do we ensure that the viewsheds,
11 you think about the long history of planning for
11 the way that the public will experience this
12 a state ballroom on White House grounds, if you think 12 building, won't detract from the way that the public
13 about the number of times this project has been
13 experiences what I believe is one of the, really,
14 suggested historically, it speaks to that
14 two or three most important buildings in Washington,
15 programmatic need. This isn't a new idea.
15 D.C., and in the region that we have jurisdiction
16
16 over, which is the White House.
I've been interested to see that even in
17 the press reports that have been -- or the press
17
18 articles that have been very, I'd say, agitated
18 elevations, particular from the south, in light of
19 about the way that this project has progressed,
19 Commissioner Mendelson's comments, what this would
20 there has been a recognition by previous occupants
20 look like with the tree line, because I think that
21 of the White House from both parties, people who
21 the elevation that we see there, just based on my
22 have worked in the White House from both parties,
22 knowledge of that the property looks like, that's
1 very stark and I don't think really represents how
132
133
1 planning materials in the weeks and months ahead.
2 the public would experience this building.
2
3
3
I think it's important that this is framed
I'd be interested to see more detailed
So, thank you.
Are there any other Commissioners that
4 between the White House and the Treasury Building,
4 have questions or comments before we adjourn for
5 which is a building of significant massing. And
5 the day?
6 I'd be interested to see an elevation that extends,
6
(No response.)
7 essentially, further to the left, or further to the
7
CHAIR SCHARF: In that case, unless there
8 east, to encompass sort of the full viewing
8 is anything else for us to address today, if there
9 experience from Pennsylvania Avenue.
9 is no other business, that concludes the open
10
10 session agenda for this meeting of the National
And, as many Commissioners have said, I
11 just look forward to seeing more details in the weeks 11 Capital Planning Commission. Our next regular
12 and months ahead. And I'd like to thank, as always, 12 Commission meeting will be on Thursday, February
13 our staff for the collaboration, the work they're
13 5th, at 1:00 p.m.
14 already put in on this issue. I think they can be
14
15 a real resource to the project team, particularly
15 to exit the chambers. If you can please hold your
16 as you start thinking about the visitor experience,
16 seats while they do so, that would be a great help.
17 visitor entrance, other aspects of the broader
17
18 modernization of the White House complex. In
18
19 particular, how the public interacts with it.
19 went off the record at 3:10 p.m.)
20
But, again, just speaking personally, I'm
20
21 really excited to see how this project develops.
21
22
22
And I'm excited to, hopefully, see more detailed
I believe the Commissioners are now going
And thank you all for being here today.
(Whereupon, the above-entitled matter
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-2
141a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 1 of 3
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF HEATHER MARTIN
I, Heather Martin, declare as follows:
1. I am a Deputy Assistant to the President, a Presidentially Commissioned Officer. In
addition, I serve as the Chief Financial Officer and Deputy Director of the Office of
Administration, Executive Office of the President. I serve as a senior official supporting
the East Wing Modernization Project (“the Project”).
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. I submit this declaration to supplement the testimony in my earlier January 15, 2026
declaration submitted in this matter, Dkt. No. 30-2.
4. Since the filing of my prior declaration, the following factual developments have
occurred which bear on this litigation:
5. First, EXR removed the triangular pediment above the south portico of the ballroom in
response to comments from the Commission of Fine Arts (CFA) and the National Capital
Planning Commission (NCPC). In prior designs, the pediment’s peak had been
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-2
142a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 2 of 3
approximately nine feet higher than the pediment on the north elevation of the White
House. Its removal and replacement with a balustrade aligned with the existing White
House balustrade allows the ballroom roofline to match that of the White House.
6. Second, the CFA approved the Project on February 19, 2026 at its public meeting. The
CFA’s approval letter can be found at www.cfa.gov/records-research/project-search/cfa19-feb-26-1.
•
“Expressing enthusiastic support for the project,” the CFA approved the
submission for a new addition to the White House to accommodate a ballroom
and other official uses. [See CFA Approval letter - cfa.gov/recordsresearch/project-search/cfa-19-feb-26-1]
7. Third, the Project was discussed at a public NCPC meeting on March 5, 2026. The staff
presented the Project and recommended that the Commission approve “the preliminary
and final site and building plans for the East Wing Modernization Project located on the
grounds of the White House.” https://www.ncpc.gov/docs/actions/
2026March/8733_East_Wing_Modernization_Project_Staff_Report_Mar2026.pdf.
Notably, the NCPC staff recommendation report found that, “per the viewshed study
provided in the submission, the existing landscape will substantially screen views of the
project from the surrounding public spaces” and “the main views of the Executive
Mansion . . . will largely be maintained.” The architect and landscape architect for the
Project gave a presentation, followed by 30 public comments about the Project, including
a public comment from the President and CEO of the Trust. In addition, 36,300 written
public comments were submitted. While EXR does not believe it must obtain approval
of NCPC to proceed with the Project, the NCPC is scheduled to vote on the Project
during its next public meeting on April 2, 2026.
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 52-2
143a
Filed 03/12/26
Page 3 of 3
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on March 12,
2026.
_________________________
Heather Martin
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-3
144a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 1 of 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
NATIONAL TRUST FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN THE UNITED
STATES,
Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE, et al.,
Defendants.
SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF HEATHER MARTIN
I, Heather Martin, declare as follows:
1. I am a Deputy Assistant to the President, a Presidentially Commissioned Officer. In
addition, I serve as the Chief Financial Officer and Deputy Director of the Office of
Administration, Executive Office of the President (“EOP”). I serve as a senior official
supporting the East Wing Modernization Project (“the Project”).
2. I have personal knowledge of all facts stated in this declaration, and if called to testify, I
could and would testify competently thereto.
3. I submit this declaration to supplement the testimony in my earlier declarations submitted
in this matter, Dkts. No. 30-2 and 52-2.
4. The Economy Act, currently codified at 31 U.S.C. § 1535, is a longstanding authority
under which agencies may order goods or services from other federal agencies or major
organizational units within the same agency. It promotes efficiency by allowing
interagency acquisitions when it is in the government’s best interest, funds are available,
and the service cannot be provided as conveniently or cheaply by the private sector.
1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-3
145a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 2 of 4
5. The Government Accountability Office (“GAO”) is a nonpartisan, independent agency
within the legislative branch. The GAO publishes a treatise titled “Principles of Federal
Appropriations Law,” which is referred to as “the Red Book.” The third volume of this
treatise, available online at https://www.gao.gov/assets/2019-11/203470.pdf, provides
detailed information and guidance to federal agencies regarding Economy Act
transactions. Agencies regularly consult this document regarding appropriations issues,
including Economy Act transactions, as well as the Office of Management and Budget’s
(“OMB”) Circular No. A-11 “Preparation, Submission and Execution of the Budget,”
which also discusses Economy Act transactions. OMB’s Circular No. A-11 is publicly
available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/a11.pdf.
6. The Red Book explains that “the subject of an Economy Act transaction must be
something the ordering agency is authorized to do and the performing agency is in a
position to provide. Also, there must be direct benefit to the paying agency. Apart from
these general prescriptions, the Economy Act makes no attempt to define the kinds of
work, services, or materials that can be ordered. This is in apparent recognition of the
great diversity of tasks and functions one encounters in the federal universe, and the fact
that these tasks and functions are subject to change over time.” Red Book, Third Edition,
Volume III at page 12-64. It is my understanding that funds transferred under the
Economy Act are “available for the purposes for which the appropriation from which
transferred are available, and also subject to the same limitations fixed in the
appropriations from which the funds are transferred.” 18 Comp. Gen. 489, 490-91 (1938).
7. The Red Book also provides examples of transactions in which the Economy Act “has
been used,” or at least “recognized as available [authority] for,” including an agreement
2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-3
146a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 3 of 4
between the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of the Navy under
which the “Navy would execute and superintend a contract for the construction of the
Corregidor-Bataan Memorial.” Red Book, Third Edition, Volume III at page 12-67.
8. EOP regularly enters into agreements under the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. § 1535. The
Economy Act is commonly used at EOP when an agency determines that it does not have
the appropriate resources to execute an action of work, services or materials that EOP, as
a servicing entity, is in the position to provide more conveniently. Once a formal
agreement between the agency and EOP is executed, EOP assumes responsibility for
carrying out the acquisition, activities, and necessary support for the goods and/or
services that are being sought by the requesting agency. This includes developing
requirements in coordination with the requesting agency, conducting market research as
needed, and securing qualified vendors through appropriate competitive procedures. EOP
also issues solicitations and awards contracts to companies capable of delivering required
goods and services.
9. Over the past decade, components of EOP have entered into approximately 2500
Economy Act agreements, which is an average of 21 agreements per month or an average
of 250 per year.
10. The Office of the Executive Residence (“EXR”) has often served as the servicing entity
for construction projects at the White House. In these instances, EXR has received
funding from other government agencies to manage permanent improvements to the
Executive Residence at the White House. EXR is uniquely suited to carry out such
projects given its close relationship with the President and its substantial expertise in
providing for (1) the preservation and maintenance of the White House structure and its
3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 55-3
147a
Filed 03/23/26
Page 4 of 4
historical contents, and (2) the use of the White House for official ceremonial purposes as
well as the private home of the President.
11. Past Economy Act agreements with EXR concern, for instance, installation of security
windows on behalf of the U.S. Secret Service, improvements to the North Portico paving
on behalf of the National Park Service (“NPS”), a 1.5-million-dollar renovation of the
White House press room on behalf of NPS, and rehabilitation of the fire alarm systems on
behalf of NPS.
12. Other examples include personnel details—in which EOP staff will temporarily work for
another agency to provide specific expertise—and temporary construction for events
taking place across the country that involve an EOP principal. Like other examples, EOP
components act as the servicing agency and receive reimbursement for their services
from the ordering agency.
13. As the above examples make clear, use of the Economy Act has long been standard
operating procedure at EOP. The Economy Act agreement concerning the Project, in
which EXR acts as the servicing agency for NPS, is consistent with this precedent.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on March 23,
2026.
_________________________
Heather Martin
4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
148a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 1 of 17
National Park Service
US Department of the Interior
The White House and President’s Park
Finding of No Significant Impact
White House East Wing Modernization and State Ballroom
Environmental Assessment
Washington, DC
NPS-25012
Recommended:
_____________________________________________________________________________
Frank Lands
Deputy Director, National Park Service
Approved:
_____________________________________________________________________________
Jessica Bowron
Comptroller, Exercising the Delegated Authority of the Director, National Park Service
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
149a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 2 of 17
Introduction
The National Park Service (NPS) prepared an environmental assessment (EA) consistent with
the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.), the Department of the
Interior (DOI) NEPA regulations, 43 CFR part 46, and the 2025 DOI Handbook of NEPA
Implementing Procedures (516 DM 1 Handbook). This Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI)
documents the final determinations and approvals for NPS actions related to the East Wing
modernization and State Ballroom construction. The statements and conclusions reached in this
FONSI are based on documentation and analysis provided in the EA and associated decision
file.
Congress established the White House and its grounds as a unit of the National Park System in
1961 and it is managed by the NPS through President’s Park. The White House itself has
expanded since its original construction and has been subject to many major and minor
renovations since its first cornerstone was laid in 1792. Although the White House has
undergone expansions and many presidents have proposed large changes to the White House,
its design remains a timeless representation of stability and resilience in our nation (Bushong
2005). The White House sits within President’s Park, which includes Lafayette Square, the First
Division Monument, Sherman Park, and various sites in and around the Ellipse.
Purpose and Need for Action
The purpose of the proposed action is to establish a permanent, secure event space within the
White House grounds that meets presidential priorities for capacity and dignified official
functions, eliminates reliance on temporary tents and associated infrastructure strains, and
protects the historic integrity and cultural landscape of the White House and its grounds while
maintaining a high-quality visitor experience.
The Comprehensive Design Plan for the White House and President’s Park (2000) identified the
need for expanded event space to address growing visitor demand and provide a venue
suitable for significant events. Successive administrations have recognized this need as an
ongoing priority. To meet this need, the Executive Office of the President outlined three
functional goals for any permanent event space: (1) immediate adjacency to the Executive
Mansion (2) a direct ceremonial procession from the East Room into the venue, and (3) secure
second-story access from the Executive Residence.
Selected Action
The selected action will establish a permanent, secure event space within the White House
grounds. This will be accomplished by replacing the existing East Wing of the White House with
a new building that will house the White House State Ballroom.
Deconstruction and Design
The existing East Wing and East Colonnade will be deconstructed. Prior to deconstruction, the
NPS will remove all museum collections, artifacts, and paintings (collectively “museum objects”)
from the East Wing and some museum objects from the Executive Mansion. Museum objects
Page | 1
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
150a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 3 of 17
from the East Wing may be relocated to other areas within the White House, which could result
in temporary removal or modification of interior designs or museum objects in those spaces. If
removed from the White House, all items will be stored in accordance with White House
standards to ensure proper preservation and accountability.
The interiors and exteriors of the East Wing and East Colonnade have been evaluated to
identify historic fabric with potential for salvage and possible reuse. Both buildings will be
documented as outlined in the Documentation section below prior to removal of any features
or finishes. Selected interior features will be documented, removed, and stored for potential
reinstallation including wood paneling, light fixtures, movie theater elements, and interior
columns. Selected exterior features, such as exterior columns, Seneca sandstone, the East Wing
commemorative cornerstone and bronze plaque from the 1942 renovation, wrought iron
fencing and gate, the Kennedy Garden arbor, two fanlight windows from the East Colonnade,
and cobblestone paving, will be documented, removed, and stored for potential reinstallation.
Some interior and exterior features will be reinstalled at and around the new building.
The new building will be approximately 90,000 square feet and will be connected to the
Executive Mansion through the East Colonnade. The East Colonnade will be renovated to
include an enclosed second story that will provide direct access from the East Room to the
State Ballroom, while maintaining ground-floor access to and from the Executive Mansion.
Limited portions of the east façade of the Executive Mansion will be carefully removed to tie in
both levels; stones removed for this work will be cataloged and reinstalled.
The exterior design of the new East Wing building will be compatible with the Executive
Mansion through classical elements such as columns and pediments. Materials will include a
white painted exterior, historically compatible windows and doors, and an architecturally
compatible roof. Interior finishes will include stone slab flooring, decorative plaster moldings,
and high-quality finishes for elevator cabs. Mechanical, electrical, and plumbing (MEP)
upgrades will include custom chandeliers, fixture updates, and architectural grilles, along with
advanced audio-visual (AV) system enhancements.
The second floor will contain the State Ballroom with capacity for over 1,000 guests, depending
on final design configuration. The State Ballroom will allow flexible staging on the south or east
sides and provide views to the west, south, and east. A flat tray ceiling with decorative
chandeliers is proposed. The first floor will continue to serve as the visitor entrance to the
building with monumental stairs to the ballroom and will house storage, mechanical
equipment, and mission space. Ground-floor restrooms will support events on the South Lawn.
Construction and Staging
A temporary construction zone will be established near the East Wing until project completion
(summer 2028). This zone will close Madison Place NW from H Street NW to E Street NW and
portions of Pennsylvania Avenue NW, extending approximately 260 feet east and 350 feet west
from the Madison Place NW centerline to non-construction or emergency vehicles. The
construction area will extend south from the East Colonnade, with the South Drive as the
western boundary and East Executive Drive as the eastern boundary. The construction zone will
Page | 2
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
151a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 4 of 17
extend south to Hamilton Avenue. The construction will not impede visitation to other parts of
President’s Park.
A tower crane will be erected on site, with its final location determined upon completion of the
final design documents. Other heavy construction equipment will be used, and contractors will
employ ground protection to prevent turf and utility damage. Given the project's size and
duration, turf replacement and ground remediation, such as decompaction of compacted
topsoil, are expected to occur during project closeout, along with the repaving of affected
roadway areas.
Landscaping
The selected action will expand the footprint of the East Wing, resulting in adjustments to
landscaping in the project area. To accommodate the larger building, a variety of ornamental
trees and shrubs will be removed from the project site. The commemorative Southern
Magnolias on the east front of the East Wing will be removed due to the proposed footprint of
the building (north magnolia planted in 1947, south magnolia planted in 1942 by Franklin D.
Roosevelt). The East Garden will be carefully removed during construction and reinstalled
similar to its existing design. The arbor in the East Garden will be removed, restored, and
reinstalled in the East Garden once exterior construction is complete.
The brick pavers along the garden paths will be carefully removed. The bricks will be stored and
ready to be relaid as part of the garden reinstallation. The fountain, including its statue, a
centerpiece of the garden, will also be carefully dismantled and preserved for future
reinstallation. Meanwhile, the Laura Bush Silver Linden Tree will be fenced and protected with a
rigid barrier to ensure its safety throughout the construction period.
Documentation
The NPS will continue to survey and record the current interior and exterior conditions of the
East Wing, East Colonnade, and Jacqueline Kennedy Garden (East Garden) of the White House.
The documentation consists of two components:
1. Digital Survey: A 3-dimensional digital survey of the property using Light Detection and
Ranging (LiDAR) laser scanning equipment will be completed. Scanning will be
conducted using Leica P50 and RTC360 terrestrial laser scanners. A Leica TS16i total
station will be used to create a control network for the scanned data. A single threedimensional model of the building and site will be completed.
2. High-Resolution Digital Photography: The NPS will capture high-resolution digital
photographs of the building and site to include the primary interior and exterior spaces,
significant features, and contextual views. Photographs will be taken using a Phase One
medium-format digital system and a Canon R5 full-frame digital mirrorless system.
Page | 3
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
152a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 5 of 17
Finding of No Significant Impact
A description of all potential environmental effects associated with the selected action and no
action alternative is included in the EA, incorporated by reference herein. Consistent with the
DOI NEPA Handbook, Section 1.2(b), the NPS evaluated the significance of the selected action,
identified as the proposed action in the EA, by analyzing the potentially affected environment
and the degree of the effects of the selected action. Significance is determined solely in relation
to reasonably foreseeable adverse effects. The degree of effect is considered by evaluating
both short-and-long term effects, both beneficial effects and adverse effects, effects on public
health and safety, economic effects and effects on the quality of life of the American People.
The NPS only completes a significance determination for the selected action and does not
determine the significance of unselected alternatives.
The EA discloses the reasonably foreseeable effects of the selected action, including the
combined effects of the selected action with those of past, ongoing, and anticipated future
actions on the park’s cultural resources and on visitor access and experience. While other park
resources may experience some effects, those effects are minimal and were determined not to
warrant detailed analysis in the EA. Accordingly, these resources are not discussed further here,
as the anticipated effects are so minor that they have no potential to reach a level of
significance. For a detailed description of impact topics considered but dismissed, see Appendix
A of the EA.
Potentially Affected Environment
A more detailed description of the potentially affected environment is included in the EA under
the subheadings Current and Expected Future Conditions of the Environment if No Action is
Taken.
The White House is the oldest public building in the District of Columbia and has served as the
home and office of every U.S. president except George Washington. Together with its wings
and grounds, the White House functions as the residence of the First Family, the workplace of
the President and staff, a national park, and an evolving museum.
The White House and President’s Park include three distinct cultural landscapes that were
identified as contributing features to the L’Enfant Plan of the City of Washington, DC, a historic
district listed in the National Register of Historic Places (NPS 1997): Lafayette Park, White House
Grounds and The Ellipse. These cultural landscapes are fundamental to the park and provide
the setting for the “President’s Park” as defined by Pierre L’Enfant in 1791. Situated on a high
point within the city, the White House is a focal point on the principal north-south axis of
L’Enfant’s plan. Views and vistas were among the most essential features of L’Enfant’s plan. The
White House grounds are dynamic, changing with the seasons and the needs of the Executive
Office of the President. Vegetation is frequently moved or removed, and at times temporary
event tents obstruct views of the White House and other features of President’s Park.
Page | 4
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
153a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 6 of 17
The Executive Mansion encompasses approximately 55,000 square feet, not including the West
and East Wings and colonnades. This historic main building is organized into three primary
sections: the Ground Floor, the State Floor, and the Executive Residence floors. The East Wing,
constructed in 1942, has undergone multiple renovations and provides office space for the First
Lady and her staff, including the White House Social Secretary, Graphics and Calligraphy Office,
and correspondence teams. It also serves as the public entrance for White House tours and
special events held at the White House.
The White House hosts major public events such as the Garden Tours, the Easter Egg Roll, and
the National Christmas Tree Lighting. President’s Park offers open space for recreation, First
Amendment expression, and community programming. The NPS provides visitor access,
interpretation, and educational services throughout these areas (NPS 2014).
Short and Long-term Beneficial and Adverse Effects
Cultural Resources 1- Cultural Landscapes
Under the selected action, the White House Grounds Cultural Landscape, which was originally
designed by Thomas Jefferson and later modified by the designs of Andrew Jackson Downing,
Frederick Law Olmsted Jr., and others, will be altered through an expansion of the White House
footprint and the addition of a larger structure on its east side. These changes will result in
long-term adverse effects on the cultural landscape. Similarly, views of the White House from
Lafayette Park and the Ellipse will be permanently altered due to the modifications to the East
Wing. In the short term, construction activities, including the presence of equipment and the
removal and replanting of vegetation, will result in temporary adverse effects on these
landscapes. However, the EA also identifies long-term beneficial effects from eliminating the
need for temporary tents and other temporary facilities to support large events.
Despite the adverse impacts identified in the EA, the selected action will not result in significant
adverse impacts to the park’s cultural landscapes. The selected action will not permanently
alter the park’s most critical view, the long vista connecting the White House, Washington
Monument, and Jefferson Memorial. In addition, mitigation measures such as replanting
historically significant trees, salvaging and reusing historic materials, and preserving or
reinstalling garden features will help maintain continuity between the site’s historic character
and its contemporary functions. These measures ensure that significant elements of the
landscape are preserved and adapted for continued use, supporting the conclusion that the
selected action will not result in significant impacts to cultural landscapes. Finally, the historical
significance of the park’s cultural landscape reflects its continuous adaptation to meet the
evolving needs of the Executive Office of the President. The selected action continues a longstanding tradition reflected in the park’s enabling legislation of adapting the White House
This Decision Document does not address compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.
Section 106 does not apply to the White House or its grounds, because 54 U.S.C. § 307104 expressly exempts the
White House grounds (along with the Supreme Court and Capitol) from all requirements of that
statute. Undertakings occurring outside the White House or its grounds may be subject to Section 106 review.
1
Page | 5
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
154a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 7 of 17
grounds to accommodate essential executive functions. Thus, changes to the landscape for this
purpose are consistent with its historic character and are not considered significant.
Cultural Resources - Historic Buildings
The White House is designated as a National Historic Landmark (NHL). Under the selected
action, the existing East Wing will be deconstructed and replaced with a new building, resulting
in the permanent loss of a component that has been integral to White House operations since
1942. This change will disrupt the historical continuity of the White House grounds and alter
the architectural integrity of the east side of the property. The new building’s larger footprint
and height will dominate the eastern portion of the site, creating a visual imbalance with the
more modestly scaled West Wing and Executive Mansion. Adding a second story to the East
Colonnade will further modify the setting, contrasting with the single-story design of the West
Colonnade and changing the traditional spatial organization and sightlines of the grounds.
These changes will adversely alter the design, setting, and feeling of the White House and the
grounds over the long-term. In addition, construction activities will also introduce temporary
risks to the historic building, including noise, vibration, and potential settlement effects, which
could affect the structural stability or finishes of the Executive Mansion and adjacent features.
The selected alternative will also provide long-term benefits by reducing reliance on temporary
event infrastructure, minimizing wear on the grounds, and improving functionality for large
gatherings through the addition of a permanent ballroom.
The selected action will result in a substantial change to one portion of the NHL. However, the
essential features that make it nationally significant, particularly its role in establishing the
nation’s capital and its resilience during the War of 1812, will remain unchanged. Moreover, the
NHL documentation identifies the period of significance as 1792-1955, a period that saw
significant changes in the configuration of the White House, namely the addition of the East
and West Wings. Therefore, the overall impact will not significantly affect the property’s
significance as an NHL and it retains the qualities that caused it to be designated as an NHL.
Further, mitigation measures, including documentation of the current East Wing as well as
salvage and storage of some of the existing historic building materials, will be reused in the new
modernized East Wing, and to ensure their availability for future preservation or restoration
projects at the White House or for other significant buildings in the district. These efforts will
support preservation efforts by providing hard-to-replicate or replacement building materials
that can be used at the White House and other historic buildings in the area, including the
Smithsonian Castle, limiting potential significant adverse impacts to these resources in the
future.
The White House is also unique in that, while it is a historic structure, it continues to evolve to
meet the operational needs of the Executive Office of the President. This ongoing adaptation is
part of its historical significance. Thus, the selected action will not result in a significant adverse
impact to historic buildings.
Visitor Access and Experience
Page | 6
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
155a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 8 of 17
President’s Park, excluding the White House and its grounds, is open to the public without the
need for a scheduled tour, however, temporary area closures may be in place due to events
and activities. U.S. Secret Service operations may also temporarily affect access to areas of the
park to ensure necessary security and safety for the adjacent White House grounds, its
occupants, and the public. These closures are frequent, given the high level of activity that
occurs in and around the park.
Under the selected alternative, certain areas within both President’s Park and the White House
and its grounds will become temporarily inaccessible. Visitors to these areas will also
experience increased noise and visual intrusions, resulting in adverse effects. However, these
impacts are expected to be temporary and will conclude with the completion of construction,
anticipated to be summer 2028, limiting the duration and extent of the adverse impacts.
Construction will interrupt normal tour flow through the East Wing, necessitating rerouting
(e.g., alternate entry point) or postponement. Historically, tours have been suspended or
altered during renovations or heightened security conditions. At the time of the EA’s
preparation, new tour bookings have been paused while a collaborative group of White House,
NPS, and U.S. Secret Service staff work to determine the best way to ensure public access to the
White House as this project begins and for the duration of construction. While the selected
alternative will temporarily alter the existing White House tour route and potentially reduce
tour availability during construction, tours will continue in some capacity and will include access
to the State Floor of the Executive Mansion. This will help minimize the overall impact on
visitors seeking to tour the interior of the White House. Because these closures are temporary,
limited to the construction period, and consistent with previous renovation practices, they do
not constitute significant adverse impacts.
The removal of the current East Wing will result in a permanent adverse impact for those who
value the experience of this specific space. However, in the long term, the selected alternative
will provide a modernized East Wing and a permanent ballroom designed to enhance
functionality, accessibility, and visitor amenities, while reducing reliance on temporary event
spaces. Additionally, the documentation of the East Wing before deconstruction and potentially
during the construction process will provide a new interpretive opportunity in the future. As a
result, the loss of the existing structure is not considered a significant adverse impact.
Collectively, these improvements will strengthen the White House’s capacity to host large
indoor events, reinforce its status as a national landmark, and contribute to an improved longterm visitor experience.
Effects on Public Health and Safety
The selected action will not result in significant adverse effects on public health and safety. As
detailed in Appendix A of the EA, the project’s limited grading area, short duration of
construction equipment use, and minimal vehicle trips will not significantly affect regional air
quality. Emissions will remain below applicable pollutant thresholds.
Page | 7
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
156a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 9 of 17
Vehicle traffic is already restricted on streets near the project area, and additional restrictions
will be clearly marked and enforced to ensure public safety. Pedestrian access may also be
limited or rerouted in certain areas, as described in the EA under Visitor Access and Experience,
to maintain a safe environment during construction. Finally, the selected action does not
involve the release of hazardous or solid waste or other hazards to human health.
Economic Effects
NPS considered socioeconomic impacts but dismissed them from detailed analysis, as explained
in Appendix A of the EA. While White House tours and visits to President’s Park offer valuable
experiences, they are not major economic drivers for the region. These sites are typically one of
many stops for visitors, and temporary changes to tour availability or site access are not
expected to significantly affect the regional economy, tourism sector, or local employment.
Although construction may generate some limited opportunities for local businesses, these
effects are expected to be minor and likely undetectable.
Effects on the Quality of Life of the American People
As described in the EA, the selected action will affect visitor access and experience, resulting in
both adverse and beneficial impacts. In the short term, temporary site closures and reduced
tour capacity will create adverse effects. However, over the long term, these areas will reopen
and remain accessible, benefitting the American people. The selected action will not
significantly alter educational opportunities or public understanding of the park. As noted,
White House tours will continue, allowing visitors to engage with the park’s purpose and unique
resources. The modernized East Wing and new State Ballroom will directly benefit the American
people by expanding the White House’s ability to host large indoor events, celebrate America's
history through new interpretive opportunities, and create a symbolic space for events of
national importance, reinforcing shared civic identity and pride. It will also directly benefit the
American people by providing comfort facilities that may be used for outdoor events on the
South lawn. The selected action will also indirectly benefit the American people by providing
modern office space for the Executive Office of the President.
The selected action will not restrict the public’s ability to consume, purchase, or use products
from public lands. It will also have no impact on public services, traditional land and water use
practices, or the cultural heritage of Native American communities. Additionally, the selected
alternative will not affect passive recreational use of ecosystems.
Rationale for the Decision
The proposed action to modernize the White House East Wing and construct a new State
Ballroom is the selected action. The EA evaluated two alternatives: a no action alternative and
proposed action, which is the selected action. In addition, the Executive Office of the President
and the NPS considered several other options for renovating the East Wing and creating space
for large events. These alternatives were dismissed from detailed analysis because they did not
adequately support the functional goals identified by the Executive Office of the President. The
no action alternative was not selected because it does not meet the project’s purpose and
Page | 8
Case 1:25-cv-04316-RJL
Document 14-2
157a
Filed 12/15/25
Page 10 of 17
need, as it lacks a
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.