Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Gary Pisner, Petitioner v. Attorney Grievance Commission of Maryland
Supreme Court briefJan 20, 2026
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 26IN THE
Supreme Court of tlje fHniteb States
GARY PISNER,
Petitioner,
v
ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE COMMISSION OF
MARYLAND
Respondent.
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
Maryland Supreme Court
APPENDIX
Gary Pisner, Pro Se
10561 Assembly Drive,
Fairfax, Virginia 22030
Tel: 703-665-4220
gpisner@outlook.com
Pro Se Petitioner
APPENDIX TO THE PETITION FOR A WRIT
OF CERTIORARI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Opinion of the Maryland Supreme Court of July
14, 2025
A-01 Appendix A
Order denying Petition for Rehearing of August 4,
2025
A-38 Appendix Al
Petition for Rehearing (July 26, 2025)
A-39 Appendix B
Notice of Removal of September 27, 2025 A-56
Appendix C
Transcript of Hearing of the Montgomery County
Circuit Court #427983 od September 28, 2017
A-70 Appendix Cl
Request for Reconsideration of the Montgomery
County Circuit Court of July 7,2019 # 427 983
A-122 Appendix D
1
EXHIBIT A
Attorney Grievance Commission ofMarylandv. Gary Pisner, AG No. 23, September Term,
2023. Opinion by Killough, J.
ATTORNEY MISCONDUCT - DISCIPLINE - DISBARMENT - Respondent Gary
Pisner violated Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct 1.1 (Competence),
1.15 (Safekeeping Property), 3.1 (Meritorious Claims and Contentions), 3.4 (Fairness to
Opposing Party and Attorney), and 8.4(a) and (d) (Misconduct). These violations arose
from Respondent’s representation of himself in various matters relating to the Marion E.
Pisner Revocable Trust in which he engaged in the intentional misappropriation of trust
assets, failed to comply with court orders, and engaged in a persistent pattern of vexatious
and frivolous litigation, causing harm to others, and burdening the judicial system.
The Supreme Court of Maryland ordered that Respondent be disbarred.
APPENDIX A
A-001
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF MARYLAND
AG No. 23
September Term, 2023
ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE COMMISSION
OF MARYLAND
v.
GARY PISNER
Fader, C.J.
Watts
Booth
Biran
Gould
Eaves
Killough,
JJ.
Opinion by Killough, J.
Filed: July 14, 2025
A-002
The Attorney Grievance Commission of Maryland (the “Commission”), through
Bar Counsel (hereinafter referred to collectively as “Petitioner”), filed a Petition for
Disciplinary or Remedial Action (the “Petition”) against Respondent, Gary Pisner.
Petitioner charged Mr. Pisner with violating several provisions of the Maryland Attorneys’
Rules of Professional Conduct,1 specifically: Rule 1.1 (Competence), Rule 1.15
(Safekeeping Property), Rule 3.1 (Meritorious Claims and Contentions), Rule 3.4 (Fairness
to Opposing Party and Attorney), and Rule 8.4(a) and (d) (Misconduct).
The misconduct that is the focus of this disciplinary proceeding stems from
Respondent’s conduct in connection with a series of legal disputes involving the Marion
E. Pisner Revocable Trust, a trust he shares with his sister, Marla Pisner Rubinstein. By
order dated December 14, 2023, this Court designated the Honorable Louis M. Leibowitz
(the “Hearing Judge”) of the Circuit Court for Montgomery County to consider the matter
against Respondent and render findings of fact and conclusions of law. A two-day
evidentiary hearing was held on June 10 and 14, 2024, and upon consideration of the
evidence presented, the Hearing Judge found, by clear and convincing evidence, that
Respondent violated each rule of professional conduct as alleged by Petitioner: Rules 1.1,
1.15, 3.1, 3.4, and 8.4(a) and (d). Petitioner did not file any exceptions and recommends
1 Effective July 1,2016, the Maryland Lawyers’ Rules of Professional Conduct were
(“MLRPC”) renamed the Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct (“MARPC”)
and recodified without substantive changes in Title 19 of the Maryland Rules. The conduct
in this case spans both before and after the recodification. For ease of reference, we use
the shorter MLRPC-style citations (e.g., Rule 1.1 rather than Maryland Rule 19-301.1).
A-003
that the Respondent be disbarred. Respondent filed exceptions on September 18, 2024.
After oral argument, on March 5, 2025, we ordered Respondent disbarred.
We explain the reasons for that sanction here, agree with the facts and conclusions
reached by the Hearing Judge, and overrule the exceptions filed by Respondent.
I.
Findings of Fact
We summarize below the Hearing Judge’s findings of fact.
Respondent was admitted to the Maryland Bar on June 14, 1989, and, at all times,
was an attorney in good standing in the State. Respondent also holds law licenses from the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the Commonwealth of Virginia, and the District of
Columbia.
The Marion E. Pisner Revocable Trust (the “Trust” or the “Pisner Trust”) was
established on December 12, 2008, in Montgomery County, Maryland. Upon the death of
the settlor, Marion E. Pisner, on January 2, 2009, her children—Respondent and Marla
Pisner Rubinstein—became the beneficiaries and co-trustees of the Pisner Trust. Pisner
Trust assets included several residential properties located in Maryland and Washington,
D.C., as well as funds held in accounts at BB&T,2 TD Bank, and SunBank.
In the fall of 2010, Respondent and Ms. Rubinstein met in Bel Air, Maryland, to
conduct an audit of the Pisner Trust’s finances (the “Bel Air Meeting”). Although they
2 In 2019, BB&T merged with SunTrust Banks. The merged company officially
became known as Truist Financial Corporation. The Truist account (formerly BB&T
account) was opened by Marion Pisner before her death in 2009.
2
A-004
disagreed on certain details of the meeting, both agreed that Ms. Rubinstein confronted
Respondent about his use of Trust funds for personal expenses, and that Respondent
promised to provide documentation regarding those expenditures. They also agreed that
Ms. Rubinstein would assume day-to-day management of the Trust going forward.
However, according to Ms. Rubinstein, Respondent never provided the documentation or
financial information necessary for her to fulfill that role.
The Hearing Judge found Respondent’s testimony regarding the Bel Air Meeting to
be inconsistent. Respondent initially testified that he had provided Ms. Rubinstein with all
relevant Trust documents, stating that she “walked out of the meeting with all the
documents. Everything.”
Later, however, he acknowledged—and Ms. Rubinstein
confirmed—that he had brought only a ledger to the meeting.
Based on these
inconsistencies, the Hearing Judge concluded that Respondent did not, in fact, relinquish
control of the Pisner Trust to Ms. Rubinstein following the Bel Air meeting.
The ledger maintained by Respondent reflects approximately 70 personal
transactions between November 2009 and August 2013. These include tens of thousands
of dollars in payments related to Respondent’s divorce, personal credit card charges, and
self-designated “loans” from the Trust. Ms. Rubinstein had no access to the Trust’s bank
accounts and was unaware of these transactions until she obtained the relevant bank
statements from BB&T during the litigation described below.
3
A-005
A.
Marion E. Pisner Trust v. Rubinstein Case No. 427983V
in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County
On December 13, 2016, Respondent, identifying himself as “Attorney for & Co
Trustee of the Marion E. Pisner Trust,” filed a Petition for a Declaration of Rights under
Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 3-408 in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County.
He asserted that, in his view, the Pisner Trust had “ceased to function” in accordance with
its terms and requested that the court provide “binding guidance” on its administration.
Respondent signed the petition both as counsel and co-trustee.
In response, on May 24, 2017, Judge Sharon Burrell issued a Show Cause Order to
Ms. Rubinstein. On July 31, 2017, Ms. Rubinstein filed a substantive response requesting
an independent audit of the Pisner Trust from its inception. She cited Respondent’s failure
to cooperate with an accounting and his refusal to provide personal credit card statements.
She further alleged that Respondent had used Trust funds for personal expenses, including
attorney’s fees related to his divorce.
On cross-examination in this disciplinary matter, Respondent admitted to using
Pisner Trust assets for personal obligations but testified that he had previously loaned the
Trust money, suggesting that some of the withdrawn funds were owed to him. However,
he presented no documentation to support this claim, and the Hearing Judge did not find it
credible.
On August 24, 2017, Judge Anne K. Albright issued a second Show Cause Order,
directing both parties to explain why the court should not assume judicial control of the
4
A-006
Pisner Trust and remove them as co-trustees. Ms. Rubinstein responded substantively;
Respondent, by contrast, did not respond on the merits, and instead filed a motion to strike
Ms. Rubinstein’s response.
At the Show Cause hearing on September 28, 2017, Judge Albright removed both
parties as co-trustees and appointed Robert McCarthy, Esq., as successor trustee. Mr.
McCarthy had no prior relationship with either party.
On November 13, 2017, Respondent filed an interlocutory appeal of Judge
Albright’s order and moved for reconsideration and a stay. Both motions were denied on
January 16, 2018. The Appellate Court of Maryland dismissed the appeal on February 21,
2018, and this Court subsequently denied certiorari.
Judge Albright also granted Mr. McCarthy’s request to hire an accountant and
expand the scope of the audit. A status hearing was set for January 25, 2018. On the eve
of the hearing, Respondent filed another interlocutory appeal and sought a stay. The
Appellate Court assumed jurisdiction, halting the hearing.
On January 26, 2018, Mr. McCarthy mailed a letter to Respondent at his residence
in Fairfax, Virginia, again requesting Trust documentation and advising that his conduct
potentially violated the Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct. Respondent
replied with documents that Mr. McCarthy deemed unresponsive. Mr. McCarthy thereafter
filed a suggestion of contempt on February 1, 2018.
On February 9, 2018, the court issued a Show Cause Order requiring Respondent to
appear on March 15, 2018, to explain why he should not be held in contempt. Instead of
responding on the merits, Respondent filed a three-part motion seeking a more definite
5
A-007
statement, a continuance, and access to trustee records. Judge Ronald Rubin denied the
motion in full on April 13, 2018.
On March 5, 2018, Respondent filed an Answer to the contempt petition, asserting
that he had produced 81 documents and was under no obligation to produce more. Mr.
McCarthy responded by reiterating his request for full compliance with the October 2,2017
order. Two days before the contempt hearing, on April 2, 2018, Respondent submitted an
affidavit in support of his motions and in opposition to the contempt petition, affirming
under penalty of perjury that the documents provided in January 2018 were the only
documents in his possession dating back to January 2015.
The contempt hearing was held on April 4, 2018, before Judge Harry C. Storm.
Judge Storm denied the contempt petition on the ground that the court’s October 2, 2017,
order lacked specificity. Judge Storm ordered Respondent and Ms. Rubinstein to produce,
“in paper format or electronically, [certain] documents within Gary Pisner or Marla
Rubinstein’s possession, custody, control or access related to the [Pisner Trust] for the
period January 1, 2009 - October 2, 2017,” by April 27, 2018.
Before the April 27 deadline, on April 24, 2018, Respondent moved to remove Mr.
McCarthy as substitute trustee, alleging a “breach of trust” based on Mr. McCarthy’s
interpretation of his fiduciary duties. Judge Jill R. Cummins denied Respondent’s motion
on May 21, 2018.
Respondent failed to meet the court’s deadline to produce documents, and on April
30, Mr. McCarthy filed a renewed contempt petition seeking incarceration. The court
issued another Show Cause Order on May 4, 2018, requiring Respondent to respond and
6
A-008
appear on June 7, 2018. Again, rather than substantively responding, Respondent filed a
motion for a more definite statement, asserting that he had produced everything he
“deemed” responsive. In total, he provided Mr. McCarthy with 944 pages of documents.
The court denied the motion on June 6, 2018.
Judge Michael D. Mason presided over the June 7, 2018, hearing.
After taking
testimony from Respondent, Judge Mason found him in contempt, noting that Respondent
had failed to provide source documents or ledgers and stating that it was “inconceivable”
that, as an attorney and fiduciary of the estate, he would not retain documentation
supporting Trust expenditures.
Judge Mason imposed a 60-day sentence but stayed
execution until July 20, 2018, to allow Respondent another opportunity to comply.
On July 11, 2018, Respondent filed a notice of appeal and a motion for
reconsideration of Judge Mason’s June 7 contempt finding, asserting that he had fully
complied with the court’s orders and alleging that Mr. McCarthy’s accountant, Dana
Evans, made false statements during the contempt hearing. At a follow-up hearing on July
20, 2018, Judge Mason reaffirmed the contempt finding and denied Respondent’s motion
for reconsideration but, at Mr. McCarthy’s request, declined to impose the 60-day
incarceration sentence.
On November 19, 2018, Respondent filed a notice of appeal challenging eleven
separate orders. While those appeals were pending, Mr. McCarthy moved for approval of
the final Pisner Trust distribution. Mr. McCarthy argued that Respondent’s failure to
7
A-009
maintain records violated his duties under Md. Code Ann., Est. & Trusts (“ET”) § 14.5-
802(b).3
Mr. McCarthy proposed distributing the Pisner Trust’s remaining net balance—
minus $50,000—to Ms. Rubinstein, with the withheld amount to be released to Respondent
upon execution of a general release and cessation of further litigation.
On February 19, 2019, Respondent filed a notice of opposition to the proposed
distribution, asserting that it was based on “false” facts. He again accused Mr. McCarthy
and Ms. Evans of ethical violations and of improperly dissipating approximately $500,000
in Trust funds.
On March 11, 2019, the circuit court mailed notice of the distribution hearing to all
parties, including to Respondent at his long-standing address in Fairfax, Virginia—the
3 Section 14.5-802 of the Maryland Trust Act states, in pertinent part:
(b) Subject to the rights of persons dealing with or assisting the trustee as
provided in § 14.5-909 of this title, a sale, an encumbrance, or any other
transaction involving the investment or management of trust property entered
into by the trustee for the personal account of the trustee or which is
otherwise affected by a conflict between the fiduciary and personal interests
of the trustee is voidable by a beneficiary affected by the transaction unless:
(1) The transaction was authorized by the terms of the trust;
(2) The transaction was approved by the court;
(3) The beneficiary did not commence a judicial proceeding within
the time allowed by law;
(4) The beneficiary consented to the conduct of the trustee, ratified the
transaction, or released the trustee in compliance with § 14.5-907 of
this title; or
(5) The transaction involves a contract entered into or claim acquired
by the trustee before the person became or contemplated becoming
the trustee.
Md. Code Ann., Est. & Trusts § 14.5-802(b).
8
A-010
same address he had consistently used throughout the proceedings.
Despite having
received notice, Respondent did not attend the hearing.
At the hearing, both Mr. McCarthy and Ms. Rubinstein testified. Relying on their
testimony and noting Respondent’s prior contempt findings, Judge James A. Bonifant
concluded that an inference could be drawn that Respondent had wrongfully distributed
excess funds to himself. The court found that Mr. McCarthy’s proposed distribution was
appropriate and long overdue, stating: “10 years while this has been pending ... that is just
totally inappropriate. It’s time for this matter to come to a close.” Accordingly, Judge
Bonifant granted the motion to approve the Pisner Trust distribution and memorialized his
findings in an order signed on April 9, 2019.
On April 11, 2019, Mr. McCarthy filed a response to Respondent’s previously filed
notice of appeal (dated November 19, 2018), moving to strike it from the record.
In
response, Respondent filed a 15-page pleading titled “Answer to Robert McCarthy’s
Motion to Strike Notice of Appeal, Request for Reconsideration of this Court’s Order of
April 9,2019, with a Request for a Stay, If Necessary.” In that filing, Respondent renewed
claims previously rejected by the court, reasserted his authority as the Trust’s attorney, and
alleged that both Mr. McCarthy and Ms. Rubinstein had perjured themselves at the June 7
contempt hearing.
Judge Bonifant denied Respondent’s motion for reconsideration
without a hearing on May 21, 2019.
In the interim, on May 13, 2019, Respondent filed another notice of appeal to the
Appellate Court, incorporating the April 9, 2019 order along with the eleven previously
9
A-011
challenged orders.
The Appellate Court later consolidated the pending appeals into a
single case.
On June 11,2019, Judge Robert A. Greenberg issued a Show Cause Order requiring
Respondent to explain in writing why the appeal should not be dismissed for failure to
comply with the rules.
On June 24, 2019, Respondent filed a response that largely
reiterated the same arguments presented in his April 29, 2019 Answer. He also moved to
recuse Judge Greenberg, citing his role as administrative judge of the Montgomery County
Circuit Court and his history of appointing Mr. McCarthy in other estates and trusts cases.
On August 9, 2019, Judge Greenberg denied Respondent’s motion to recuse and set a
hearing on the motion to strike.
B.
Proceedings Before the Appellate Court ofMaryland
On March 18, 2020, the Appellate Court issued an unreported opinion thoroughly
reviewing and affirming each of the challenged rulings, including the contempt finding
against Respondent.
Pisner v. McCarthy, Nos. 1037 and 3041, Sept. Term, 2018, 2020
WL 1303623 (Mar. 18,2020). Respondent filed a motion for reconsideration and a petition
for writ of certiorari to this Court, which we denied on July 20,2020. Pisner v. McCarthy,
469 Md. 670 (2020).
Following these denials, Respondent sent a letter to the Clerk of the Appellate Court
of Maryland criticizing the opinion’s structure and alleging “procedural failure.” The Clerk
responded that the Appellate Court would not comment further and noted Respondent’s
failure to copy opposing counsel.
10
A-012
Proceedings Before the Superior Court of the District of Columbia
While the trust litigation remained pending in the Maryland state courts,
Respondent, in his personal capacity, initiated a separate lawsuit against Ms. Rubinstein in
the Superior Court for the District of Columbia on January 14, 2019. Pisner v. Rubinstein,
No. 2019 CA 000229 B (D.C. Super. Ct.). The complaint asserted claims for breach of
contract, fraud, abuse of process, defamation, and breach of fiduciary duty. The abuse of
process claim was based entirely on Ms. Rubinstein’s filings in the Montgomery County
Circuit Court—filings made in response to Respondent’s own earlier suit.
As a result, Ms. Rubinstein retained counsel and, on April 18, 2019, moved to
dismiss the case, arguing that the District of Columbia was an improper forum in light of
the still-active litigation in Maryland. Judge Florence Y. Pan granted the motion to dismiss
at a hearing held on June 14, 2019. Respondent sought reconsideration on July 12, 2019,
and filed a notice of appeal three days later. On August 7, 2019, Judge Pan denied the
motion for reconsideration, noting that Respondent had failed to articulate any procedural
or legal basis for relief. The District of Columbia Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal
in an unpublished per curiam opinion issued on February 25, 2021. Pisner v. Rubinstein,
246 A.3d 156 (D.C. 2021).
11
A-013
D.
Pisner v. Rubinstein in the U.S. District
Courtfor the District ofMaryland
On January 4, 2021—approximately six weeks before the D.C. Court of Appeals
issued its opinion—Respondent filed a second lawsuit against Ms. Rubinstein, this time in
the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland. See Pisner v. Rubinstein, No. CV
TDC-21-0020, 2022 WL 294826 (D. Md. Jan. 31, 2022), aff’d, No. 22-1294, 2022 WL
3681660 (4th Cir. Aug. 25, 2022). The allegations were nearly identical to those asserted
in the earlier D.C. case. This time, Respondent sought $3.7 million in compensatory
damages and $2 million in punitive damages.
Ms. Rubinstein again retained counsel and moved to dismiss, arguing that the claims
were either resolved or precluded by the ongoing Montgomery County litigation. Rather
than substantively responding, Respondent filed a motion to strike the motion to dismiss.
On January 31, 2022, Judge Theodore D. Chuang granted Ms. Rubinstein’s motion
to dismiss, holding that the breach of contract and fiduciary duty claims were barred by res
judicata, and that the remaining claims failed to state a plausible basis for relief.
In response, Respondent filed a notice of appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Fourth Circuit on March 16, 2022. The following day, he filed a 37-page submission
styled as “objections” to Judge Chuang’s ruling, accusing the court of “judicial lethargy”
and misapplication of the law. The Fourth Circuit affirmed the dismissal in a one-
paragraph per curiam opinion, finding “no reversible error.” Pisner v. Rubinstein, No. 22-
1294, 2022 WL 3681660, at *1 (4th Cir. Aug. 25, 2022).
12
A-014
E.
Pisner v. McCarthy et al. in the U.S. District
Courtfor the District ofMaryland
On January 5, 2022, Respondent initiated another lawsuit in the U.S. District Court
for the District of Maryland, this time naming Mr. McCarthy, Kevin McCarthy (Mr.
McCarthy’s law partner and son), and Ms. Evans as defendants.4
The complaint largely recycled claims Respondent had previously raised in the
Montgomery County proceedings. All three defendants moved to dismiss, arguing that the
claims were barred by res judicata and collateral estoppel and otherwise failed to state a
claim upon which relief could be granted.
On September 26, 2022, Judge George Hazel issued a memorandum opinion
granting the motions to dismiss. Pisner v. McCarthy, 630 F. Supp. 3d 690 (D. Md. 2022),
aff’d, No. 23-1655, 2024 WL 1615012 (4th Cir. Apr. 15, 2024). The court concluded that
Respondent’s claims were both legally barred and substantively deficient.
Following the dismissal, on December 27, 2022, Respondent filed a “motion for
relief’ pursuant to Rule 60(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Judge Stephanie A.
Gallagher denied the motion in a written opinion issued on March 27, 2023. Respondent
then filed a motion to alter or amend that ruling, which the court also denied on May 17,
2023.
On June 16, 2023, Respondent noted an appeal to the Fourth Circuit.
An
4 The Hearing Judge specifically noted that Kevin McCarthy had no meaningful
involvement in the underlying Montgomery County litigation but was nonetheless named
as a defendant.
13
A-015
unpublished per curiam opinion was filed on April 15, 2024, affirming Judge Gallagher’s
decision.
II.
Hearing Judge’s Conclusions of Law
The Hearing Judge concluded that Respondent violated MARPC 1.1, 1.15,3.1,3.4,
and 8.4(a) and (d). Petitioner did not file exceptions. Respondent noted several exceptions
to both the Hearing Judge’s findings of fact and conclusions of law.
III.
Standard of Review
“This Court has original and complete jurisdiction in an attorney disciplinary
proceeding and conducts an independent review of the record.” Attorney Grievance
Commission v. Portillo, 473 Md. 584, 598-99 (2021) (quoting Attorney Grievance
Commission v. Hoerauf, 469 Md. 179, 207-08 (2020)). Pursuant to Md. Rule 19-728(b),
Respondent filed exceptions to the Hearing Judge’s factual findings and conclusions of
law, however, we leave undisturbed the Hearing Judge’s findings of fact “unless those
findings are clearly erroneous.” See id. Md. Rule 19-740(b)(2)(B) provides:
[This Court] shall determine whether the findings of fact have been proved
by the requisite standard of proof set out in [Md.] Rule 19-727(c). Th[is]
Court may confine its review to the findings of fact challenged by the
exceptions. Th[is] Court shall give due regard to the opportunity of the
Hearing Judge to assess the credibility of witnesses.
We assess the Hearing Judge’s legal conclusions under a de novo standard of review.
Attorney Grievance Commission v. Moody, 457 Md. 90, 110 (2017); Md. Rule 1914
A-016
740(b)(1) (“The [Supreme Court of Maryland] shall review [de novo] the circuit court
judge’s conclusions of law.”). We retain “the ultimate authority to decide whether a lawyer
has violated the professional rules.” Attorney Grievance Commission v. Harrington, 367
Md. 36, 49 (2001) (citation modified). Respondent’s exceptions are addressed below.
IV.
Exceptions
Pursuant to Maryland Rule 19-728(b), “each party may (1) file exceptions to the
findings and conclusions of the hearing judge, (2) recommendations concerning the
appropriate disposition under Rule 19-740 (c), and (3) a statement of costs to which the
party may be entitled under Rule 19-709.” Here, Respondent filed a 70-page document
titled “Exceptions.” Respondent’s Exceptions primarily challenge the Hearing Judge’s
factual findings and procedural rulings but do not meaningfully address the merits of the
misconduct or the appropriate sanction. He disputes the sufficiency of the disciplinary
petition, alleges investigatory and discovery misconduct, and contests the credibility of
witnesses, yet he offers no evidence to support these claims. Respondent’s contentions in
the Exceptions fall into four broad categories: (1) the sufficiency of the Petition for
disciplinary charges; (2) alleged misconduct by Petitioner during its investigation; (3)
alleged discovery deficiencies; and (4) challenges to the Hearing Judge’s factual findings.
Each exception lacks merit and is overruled.5
5 As noted herein, Respondent’s contentions in the Exceptions primarily challenge
the Hearing Judge’s factual findings and procedural rulings. As we discuss herein, we
overrule the Respondent’s exceptions to the Hearing Judge’s findings of fact and
15
A-017
1. Sufficiency of the Petition
Respondent first argues that the Petition failed to provide sufficient notice of the
charges against him.
A disciplinary petition is a notice pleading and is “deemed sufficient [s]o long as
the petition informs the attorney of the misconduct charged in language which is clear and
sufficiently specific to enable the attorney to prepare a defense.” Attorney Grievance
Commission v. McDonald, 437 Md. 1, 43 (2014) (quoting Attorney Grievance Commission
v. Tanko, 408 Md. 404, 420-21 (2009)). This Court requires no particular form or detail
beyond this threshold. Id. A review of the Petition in this case reveals that the charges
were clearly and sufficiently pleaded.
The Petition states, in relevant part:
58. Between January 2009 and 2017, the Respondent disbursed
$1,383,486.83 to Ms. Rubinstein and disbursed an additional $1,976,750.72.
Of the $1,976,750.72, $1,158,217.05 was disbursed to the Respondent or for
the Respondent’s benefit and the remaining $818,533.67 was unaccounted
for - the Respondent claimed that the funds were disbursed for the benefit of
the Trust. Because the Respondent failed to provide any proof to substantiate
his claims, the entire $1,976,750.72 was charged toward the Respondent’s
share.
59. While acting as attorney and co-trustee of the Trust, the Respondent
failed to properly account for the funds disbursed from the Trust, including
failing to maintain appropriate records to substantiate the purpose of
disbursements made from the Trust and disbursing funds to himself in excess
to those distributed to Ms. Rubinstein.
procedural rulings. To the extent that Respondent’s 70 pages of exceptions are directed to
any conclusions of law, they are also overruled.
16
A-018
We have held that even where a petition is not the “model of clarity,” if the
allegations make clear the alleged wrongdoing, then the petition will be deemed sufficient.
See Tanko, 408 Md. at 422. These paragraphs more than clear this threshold. These
paragraphs alone make clear the alleged misconduct and describe how said conduct
violates professional standards. We overrule this exception.
2. Allegations ofInvestigative Misconduct
Respondent next asserts that Petitioner engaged in misconduct during its
investigation, including the claim that the substitute trustee, Mr. McCarthy, drafted the
Petition. This allegation is unsupported by the record. Bar Counsel represented in the
Commission’s reply that Bar Counsel “drafted, signed and filed” the Petition in December
2023.
Respondent also alleges an improper relationship between Mr. McCarthy and
former Bar Counsel. However, he offers no evidentiary support, and the record contains
none.
These allegations were raised before the Hearing Judge and explored during
Respondent’s cross-examination of Mr. McCarthy. In response, Mr. McCarthy testified
that Bar Counsel had previously prosecuted a disciplinary matter in which he was
reprimanded: “I do not consider [Bar Counsel] a dear friend of mine in any stretch of the
imagination. Then she became Bar Counsel, and I’ve had no relationship with her since
that hearing 11 years ago.”
The Hearing Judge considered and rejected these allegations, finding Respondent’s
testimony to be “incredible”:
17
A-019
This Court notes that Respondent testified and argued that Mr. McCarthy had
it out for him, alternately because Mr. McCarthy was conspiring with Ms.
Rubinstein or because Mr. McCarthy assisted the Attorney Grievance
Commission in consideration of more lenient treatment in his own
unspecified Attorney Grievance Commission investigations. Respondent did
not produce any evidence of any of these things. Accordingly, this Court
finds that Respondent’s allegations on this front were meritless. However,
none of this Court’s findings rely on Mr. McCarthy’s credibility. His
testimony was largely duplicative of the court records in the various cases
filed by Respondent. Other evidence of the Commissions’ allegations was
corroborated throughout the case, including by Respondent’s own
admissions.
We likewise find Respondent’s allegations to be without merit and overrule this
exception.
3. Alleged Discovery Deficiencies
Respondent contends that Bar Counsel failed to comply with discovery obligations
and withheld exculpatory evidence. He further alleges that Mr. McCarthy conspired with
the Commission and Bar Counsel to conceal such evidence.
These allegations are
unsupported by the record. Respondent offers no documentary or testimonial evidence to
substantiate claims of misconduct or collusion.
In contrast, Petitioner affirms that every allegation set forth in the Petition was
supported by documentary evidence, and the Hearing Judge found that all relevant
materials were disclosed to Respondent during discovery and introduced at the hearing.
Respondent was also afforded ample opportunity to cross-examine both Bar Counsel and
Mr. McCarthy and did so extensively. The Hearing Judge explicitly rejected Respondent’s
misconduct allegations, finding his testimony not credible.
18
A-020
We have also explained that “[w]e will not substitute our judgment for the judgment
of the hearing judge with regard to credibility determinations.” Attorney Grievance
Commission v. Bonner, 477 Md. 576, 613-14 (2022).
Considering the absence of
corroborating evidence and the Hearing Judge’s credibility determinations, we overrule
this exception.
4. Exceptions to the Hearing Judge’s Factual Findings
Respondent’s remaining exceptions to the Hearing Judge’s factual findings are
similarly unavailing. “If the hearing judge’s factual findings are not clearly erroneous and
the conclusions drawn from them are supported by the facts found, exceptions to
conclusions of law will be overruled.” Tanko, 408 Md. at 419.
Respondent’s exceptions span over 40 pages but do not identify any clear error.
Instead, he offers alternative interpretations of the evidence or reiterates arguments already
rejected by the lower courts.
Respondent challenges the Hearing Judge’s conclusion that he intentionally
misappropriated Pisner Trust assets, arguing that there is no evidence that he intended to
permanently deprive his sister of funds or that he acted secretly for personal gain. He
contends that the Hearing Judge failed to consider relevant testimony and alternative
explanations for disputed expenditures, including his belief that the payments were
permissible distributions or reimbursements.
Respondent also contests the Hearing Judge’s credibility determinations,
particularly his reliance on the testimony of Ms. Rubinstein and Mr. McCarthy. He claims
that their statements were conclusory and self-serving, and that Mr. McCarthy lacked
19
A-021
personal knowledge of the transactions at issue. He further contends that the court failed
to explain why it did not credit certain evidence, including bank records and his own
testimony.
Finally, Respondent takes exception to the Hearing Judge’s findings that he failed
to maintain Trust records and knowingly disobeyed court orders. He asserts that he
produced all documents in his possession and made reasonable efforts to obtain others from
third parties, including a former accountant. He denies willful disobedience, maintaining
that any noncompliance was due to circumstances beyond his control.
These arguments do not render the Hearing Judge’s findings clearly erroneous. As
we have consistently held, challenges that merely offer alternative interpretations of the
record or reiterate arguments previously rejected do not suffice to disturb findings
supported by clear and convincing evidence. See Attorney Grievance Commission v.
Vanderlinde, 364 Md. 376,384 (2001). “[T]he hearing judge is entitled to ‘pick and choose
which evidence to rely upon’ from a conflicting array when determining findings of fact.”
Attorney Grievance Commission v. Kane, 465 Md. 667, 676 n.4 (2019) (quoting Attorney
Grievance Commission v. Guida, 391 Md. 33, 50 (2006)).
The Hearing Judge was
similarly entitled to credit Ms. Rubinstein’s and Mr. McCarthy’s testimony over
Respondent’s testimony, see Bonner, 477 Md. at 613.
We therefore overrule these
exceptions.
V.
Conclusions of Law
20
A-022
Based on our independent review of the record, we agree with the Hearing Judge’s
legal conclusions that Respondent violated MARPC 1.1, 1.15, 3.1, 3.4, and 8.4(a) and (d).
Rule 1.1 - Competence
The Hearing Judge found by clear and convincing evidence that Respondent
violated Rule 1.1 by (1) failing to maintain financial records during his tenure as attorney
for the Pisner Trust, and (2) refusing to produce those records when ordered by the court.
Rule 1.1 provides: “An attorney shall provide competent representation to a client.
Competent representation requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and
preparation reasonably necessary for the representation.” This Court has recognized that
“sound record-keeping is an essential part of competent representation, and [that] an
attorney’s failure to keep or produce records can itself lead to a violation of the M[A]RPC.”
Attorney Grievance Commission v. London, 427 Md. 328, 345 (2012).
Following the death of Marion Pisner in 2009, Respondent assumed responsibility
for the administration of the Pisner Trust and served as its attorney. He retained exclusive
control over the Trust’s records and operations. Respondent managed the Pisner Trust’s
accounting software, received bank statements, prepared and filed tax returns, and oversaw
the management of Trust-owned properties. He alone had access to the Pisner Trust’s
financial documentation.
Despite holding himself out as the Pisner Trust’s legal representative and fiduciary,
Respondent failed to maintain adequate records of Pisner Trust transactions and refused to
21
A-023
produce the required documentation when ordered by the court. His refusal significantly
impeded the efforts of the court-appointed substitute trustee, Mr. McCarthy, to complete a
fiduciary accounting of the Trust and fulfill the duties assigned by the court.
The Hearing Judge appropriately analogized the Respondent’s conduct to that of the
attorney in Attorney Grievance Commission v. Woolery, where we held that an attorney
violated Rule 1.1 by failing to disclose material information about estate assets in his
possession. 462 Md. 209, 232-33 (2018). We emphasized that the attorney’s withholding
of information obstructed the special administrator’s ability to perform a fiduciary
accounting—an additional violation of Rule 1.1. Id. at 232.
Respondent’s misconduct here was similarly obstructive. By his own admission,
Respondent actively concealed Pisner Trust records to avoid disclosing them during his
divorce proceedings. Respondent also testified that he transferred the records to an
accountant for “safekeeping” during the litigation so that his former spouse could not
obtain them. Even after the divorce concluded in 2010, Respondent never attempted to
retrieve those records. Despite multiple opportunities—including informal requests and
three separate court orders—Respondent failed to produce sufficient documentation to
permit an accounting of the Pisner Trust.
The Hearing Judge further concluded that Respondent’s fiduciary obligations as a
trustee, governed by ET §§ 14-405(e)(l) and (i), imposed a separate and continuing duty
to maintain complete records of all Pisner Trust property and transactions. We agree with
the Hearing Judge that Respondent violated of Rule 1.1. At bottom, Respondent had an
obligation to preserve and organize the Pisner Trust’s financial records in a manner that
22
A-024
would ensure accessibility and his decision to withhold, obscure, or destroy these records
constituted a clear violation of the duty of competent representation.
Rule 1.15 - Safekeeping Property
The Hearing Judge concluded that Respondent violated Rule 1.15(a) by failing to
maintain adequate records and by disbursing Trust funds to himself for personal use
without authorization or consent from his co-trustee, Ms. Rubinstein.
Rule 1.15(a) requires attorneys to properly safeguard client or third-party property
in their possession. To comply with the rule, such property must be kept separate from the
attorney’s personal property, complete and accurate records of all funds and other assets
must be created and maintained, and those records must be preserved for at least five years.
In Woolery, we held that an attorney violates Rule 1.15 by depositing estate funds
into a personal attorney trust account and later using those funds for litigation expenses
and self-reimbursement, without authorization. 462 Md. at 241. We explained in Woolery
that an attorney misappropriates funds when he disburses funds to himself that he was not
authorized to collect or retain. Id. at 243.
In the instant matter, Pisner Trust records, once obtained, revealed that Respondent
received distributions in excess of his share: in 2009, he distributed approximately $1.19
million to himself while Ms. Rubinstein received $1.06 million, and in 2010, he received
$136,410.93 despite a lack of supporting source documentation, while Ms. Rubinstein
received $54,894.78. The record further demonstrated that many of these unauthorized
distributions were used for personal expenses, including legal fees, credit card payments,
23
A-025
and educational costs, none of which were justified or approved. We agree with the
Hearing Judge’s conclusion that Respondent violated Rule 1.15.
Rule 3.1 - Meritorious Claims and Contentions
The Hearing Judge found, by clear and convincing evidence, that Respondent
violated Rule 3.1, which provides:
An attorney shall not bring or defend a proceeding, or assert or controvert an
issue therein, unless there is a basis for doing so that is not frivolous, which
includes, for example, a good faith argument for an extension, modification
or reversal of existing law. An attorney may nevertheless so defend the
proceeding as to require that every element of the moving party’s case be
established.
Comment 1 to Rule 3.1 explains: “The advocate has a duty to use legal procedure
for the fullest benefit of the client’s cause, but also a duty not to abuse legal procedure.”
Here, Respondent repeatedly misused the judicial system by initiating four separate
lawsuits, filing more than eighteen motions and appeals across three jurisdictions, and
advancing legal theories that lacked merit. In nearly every instance, his filings were denied,
and he demonstrated a pattern of continuing litigation after adverse rulings, often
accompanied by accusations that the courts had engaged in “improper” legal work.
The Hearing Judge compared Respondent’s conduct to that which we held
sanctionable in Attorney Grievance Commission v. Mixter, where we held that Rule 3.1 is
violated where an attorney continued to litigate a matter after the absence of a good faith
basis for the matter became apparent. 441 Md. 416, 511 (2015). Respondent’s behavior
24
A-026
here is analogous.
He persisted in litigation despite repeated adverse rulings, and
frequently reasserted claims that had already been adjudicated.
Similarly, in Attorney Grievance Commission v. Sloane, we sustained a Rule 3.1
violation where the respondent raised baseless issues that had already been ruled upon.
483 Md. 131,157 (2023). Similar conduct is reflected in Respondent’s filings in this case.
The Hearing Judge identified a specific pattern in Respondent’s litigation: when
unsuccessful in Maryland state court, Respondent filed a nearly identical suit in the District
of Columbia Superior Court. When that was unsuccessful, Respondent filed the same
claims again in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland.
Respondent pursued identical claims in multiple forums without curing a plainly
fatal legal defect, indicating an absence of any good faith basis for relief and no effort to
seek a legitimate change in the law.
These violations were not without consequence. The Hearing Judge found that
Respondent’s frivolous filings caused actual harm to others. Ms. Rubinstein incurred
substantial legal expenses in defending multiple actions.6 Mr. McCarthy and Ms. Evans
both experienced increased liability insurance premiums as a result of being named in the
litigation. While Respondent failed in every action, he imposed significant financial and
6 Ms. Rubinstein testified that she spent approximately $130,000 in legal fees.
However, the Hearing Judge explained that she provided no corroboration of that amount.
Consequently, the court made no findings as to the amount of fees Ms. Rubinstein incurred
or paid. The Hearing Judge made clear, however, that “[t]he amount is hardly the point.
That she had to pay anything to defend multiple frivolous lawsuits and appeals is an
aggravating factor.”
25
A-027
emotional burdens on the other parties and expended judicial resources in multiple
jurisdictions.
Accordingly, based on these findings, the Hearing Judge concluded that Respondent
violated Rule 3.1 by initiating and maintaining multiple meritless proceedings in bad faith,
and by continuing to litigate matters long after he had lost on the merits. We agree that
Respondent’s conduct constituted an abuse of the judicial process and caused concrete
harm to opposing parties and the courts in violation of Rule 3.1.
Rule 3.4 - Fairness to Opposing Party and Attorney
The Hearing Judge found, by clear and convincing evidence, that Respondent
violated Rule 3.4(c), which prohibits attorneys from knowingly disobeying a tribunal’s
directives unless they make an open refusal based on a good faith belief that no valid
obligation exists.
In this case, Respondent was ordered by multiple judges—Judge
Albright, Judge Storm, and Judge Mason—to produce specific documents relating to the
Pisner Trust, in a matter that Respondent himself had initiated. Despite these orders,
Respondent failed to provide the required documentation and was ultimately held in
contempt of court by Judge Mason.
In Attorney Grievance Commission v. Storch, the attorney failed to produce estate
property at a court hearing, left the hearing without permission, and was held in contempt
by the court. 445 Md. 82, 86-87 (2015). Despite multiple opportunities, the attorney never
turned over the estate property. We held that her repeated failure to follow explicit court
orders demonstrated a knowing disobedience toward court orders and rules and constituted
a clear violation of Rule 3.4(c). Id. at 89-90.
26
A-028
In the instant matter, Judge Mason emphasized the gravity of Respondent’s
misconduct, stating it was “inconceivable” that an attorney and fiduciary would not retain
the source documents related to trust disbursements.
Judge Mason also found it
implausible that Respondent, as both a trustee and attorney, did not maintain
documentation to demonstrate that expenditures were made on behalf of the Pisner Trust,
rather than for personal use.
Throughout more than eighteen months of litigation, Respondent made no
meaningful attempt to comply with the court’s discovery orders. He testified that he
believed he had already turned over the appropriate documents and made no effort—even
in the face of potential incarceration—to retrieve responsive documents. The Hearing
Judge found that Respondent never seriously attempted to obtain or produce the required
documents, and that this prolonged noncompliance constituted a knowing violation of a
tribunal’s order in contravention of Rule 3.4(c). See Attorney Grievance Commission v.
Edwards, 462 Md. 642, 704 (2019) (holding that an attorney violates Rule 3.4(c) by
repeatedly failing to produce documents as directed by court order).
Rule 8.4 - Misconduct
The Hearing Judge concluded that Respondent’s conduct also violated Rule 8.4,
which governs attorney misconduct. Pursuant to Rule 8.4 (a) and (d), it is professional
misconduct to violate the Rules of Professional Conduct and to engage in conduct
prejudicial to the administration of justice. Respondent violated both subsections by
breaching multiple ethics rules, including Rule 1.1 (competence), Rule 1.15 (safekeeping
property), Rule 3.1 (meritorious claims), and Rule 3.4 (fairness to opposing party and
27
A-029
J
attorney). Based upon our de novo review, we agree with the Hearing Judge’s conclusion
that Respondent’s failure to comply with multiple discovery orders violated Rule 3.4(c).
Respondent repeatedly made baseless accusations and pursued frivolous litigation
against Ms. Rubinstein, Mr. McCarthy, Ms. Evans, and even Mr. McCarthy’s son (Kevin
McCarthy)—which the Hearing Judge noted had nothing to do with Respondent’s alleged
grievances against Mr. McCarthy.
Respondent’s claims lacked any factual or legal
foundation and were often resubmitted after being rejected by trial and appellate courts.
The Hearing Judge also found that Respondent misappropriated Pisner Trust assets for
personal use, failed to maintain proper records, and concealed assets in a divorce
proceeding in Virginia by evading a discovery order. By engaging in this pattern of
conduct, the court concluded that Respondent not only violated specific ethical rules but
also committed serious acts of professional misconduct that undermined the integrity of
the legal system. Based upon our independent review of the record, we agree with the
Hearing Judge’s assessment that Respondent’s conduct was prejudicial to the
administration of justice in violation of Rule 8.4(d).
VI.
Sanction
The primary purpose of attorney discipline in Maryland is to protect the public, not
to punish the attorney. Attorney Grievance Commission v. Rheinstein, 466 Md. 648, 720
(2020) (quoting Attorney Grievance Commission v. Hodes, 441 Md. 136, 205 (2014)).
Sanctions serve this purpose by deterring similar misconduct and by removing attorneys
who are unfit to practice law. Attorney Grievance Commission v. Framm, 449 Md. 620,
28
A-030
665 (2016). In determining the appropriate sanction, this Court considers the nature and
severity of the misconduct, the attorney’s mental state, the actual or potential harm caused,
and any relevant aggravating or mitigating factors. Attorney Grievance Commission v.
Taniform, 482 Md. 272, 316 (2022).
Aggravating and Mitigating Factors
During an attorney grievance matter, the circuit court may consider the existence of
aggravating and mitigating factors. In Attorney Grievance Commission v. Shuler, we
articulated the following aggravating factors that should be considered in an attorney
disciplinary proceeding:
(1) prior attorney discipline; (2) a dishonest or selfish motive; (3) a pattern
of misconduct; (4) multiple violations of the M[A]RPC; (5) bad faith
obstruction of the attorney discipline proceeding by intentionally failing to
comply with the Maryland Rules or orders of this Court []; (6) submission
of false evidence, false statements, or other deceptive practices during the
attorney discipline proceeding; (7) a refusal to acknowledge the
misconduct’s wrongful nature; (8) the victim’s vulnerability; (9) substantial
experience in the practice of law; (10) indifference to making restitution or
rectifying the misconduct’s consequences; (11) illegal conduct, including
that involving the use of controlled substances; and (12) likelihood of
repetition of the misconduct.
443 Md. 494, 506-07 (2015) (alterations in original omitted). Petitioner has the burden of
proving aggravating factors by clear and convincing evidence. Md. Rule 19-727(c).
Petitioner alleged the existence of the following aggravating factors, as articulated
and numbered by this Court in Shuler: (2) a dishonest or selfish motive; (3) a pattern of
misconduct; (4) multiple violations; (7) refusal to acknowledge the wrongful nature of the
conduct; and (9) substantial experience in the practice of law.
29
A-031
The Hearing Judge found clear and convincing evidence to establish each of the
alleged aggravating factors. Respondent displayed a selfish motive since the death of
Marion Pisner in 2009 by misappropriating trust funds for his personal expenses. Between
February 2009 and July 2010, “when it is undisputed that Respondent was managing the
day-to-day activities of the Trust,” there was a pattern of misconduct and multiple offenses
evidenced by Respondent’s repeated misappropriation of trust funds, frivolous litigation
and motion practice to prevent the appointment of a successor trustee and, when one was
appointed, to prevent that trustee “from gaining access to the Trust records or outright
retaliating against Ms. Rubinstein, Mr. McCarthy, and/or Ms. Evans for attempting to
enforce valid court orders against Respondent and obtain access to the financial records for
the Trust.” The consequences of Respondent’s actions were severe. Ms. Rubinstein
incurred substantial legal fees as a result of Respondent’s frivolous litigation and Mr.
McCarthy’s and Ms. Evans’s liability insurance premiums rose. Respondent demonstrated
a pattern of misconduct through his multitude of civil suits against Ms. Rubinstein in both
state and federal court in both Maryland and the District of Columbia.
Respondent
repeatedly made frivolous claims in multiple jurisdictions that were not supported by any
facts and not sustained by the law.
Respondent’s misconduct violated Rule 3.1
(Meritorious Claims and Contentions) and Rule 3.4. (Fairness to Opposing Party and
Attorney). The Hearing Judge found that the Respondent did not demonstrate any remorse
for either his personal use of funds contained in the Pisner Trust or for his frivolous filings.
Finally, the Hearing Judge found that Respondent has substantial experience in the
practice oflaw, having been a member of the Maryland bar since June 14,1989, and having
30
A-032
obtained bar membership in the Commonwealths of Pennsylvania and Virginia and the
District of Columbia.
This Court “always consider[s]” mitigating factors “in deciding a disposition in an
Attorney Grievance case.” Attorney Grievance Commission v. Coppola, 419 Md. 370,401
(2011). In Hodes, we provided a list of possible mitigating factors:
absence of a prior disciplinary record; absence of a dishonest or selfish
motive; personal or emotional problems; timely good faith efforts to make
restitution or to rectify consequences of misconduct; full and free disclosure
to disciplinary board or cooperative attitude toward proceedings;
inexperience in the practice of law; character or reputation; physical or
mental disability or impairment; delay in disciplinary proceedings; interim
rehabilitation; imposition of other penalties or sanctions; remorse; and
finally, remoteness of prior offenses.
441 Md. at 209 (citation omitted). Respondent has the burden of proving mitigating factors
by a preponderance of evidence. Md. Rule 19-727(c).
We find that Respondent established the mitigating factor of absence of prior
attorney disciplinary history.
Turning to the sanction, Respondent committed numerous and serious violations
of the MARPC, including intentional misappropriation of Trust assets, failure to safeguard
client property, frivolous and vexatious litigation, disobedience of court orders, and
conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice. These violations, considered both
individually and in the aggregate, demonstrate that Respondent is unfit to continue
practicing law in this State.
The Hearing Judge found, by clear and convincing evidence, that Respondent used
his position as a trustee to exert exclusive control over the Pisner Trust, failed to maintain
31
A-033
adequate financial records, and misappropriated Trust assets for personal use. These
findings were supported by testimony, accounting records, and judicial inferences drawn
by multiple judges who reviewed the matter.
Respondent’s failure to provide
documentation—particularly source records for substantial distributions to himself—
violated both his fiduciary duties under trust law and his ethical obligations under Rule
1.15. The misappropriation included the use of Trust funds for personal expenses,
including credit card payments, tuition, and legal fees.
We further credit the Hearing Judge’s finding that Respondent failed to comply
with multiple court orders directing him to produce Pisner Trust documents, resulting in
a contempt finding by the circuit court. Respondent admitted under oath that he made no
meaningful attempt to retrieve the requested documents and did not undertake reasonable
efforts to comply with discovery obligations. This conduct supports a violation of Rule
3.4(c). See Edwards, 462 Md. at 704 (holding that failure to comply with court orders
constitutes a violation of Rule 3.4(c)).
In addition to his financial misconduct, Respondent engaged in a sustained pattern
of litigation conduct that the Hearing Judge concluded was frivolous and intended to
obstruct or delay resolution of the underlying trust dispute. Respondent filed actions and
appeals in Maryland, the District of Columbia, and federal court, asserting claims that had
already been adjudicated or were barred by res judicata or collateral estoppel. The
Hearing Judge found that Respondent’s filings lacked a good faith basis in law or fact and
violated Rule 3.1. The record reflects that Respondent did not prevail on a single
substantive claim across these proceedings, despite the expenditure of significant judicial
32
A-034
and party resources.
We also agree with the Hearing Judge’s findings that Respondent’s conduct caused
tangible harm to multiple parties, including his co-trustee, who incurred substantial legal
fees, and two professionals whose liability insurance premiums increased due to the
ongoing litigation.
Moreover, Respondent’s actions taxed judicial resources across
multiple forums and delayed resolution of the trust proceedings for more than a decade.
The Hearing Judge identified five aggravating factors supported by the record and
one mitigating factor—the absence of prior disciplinary history.
In this case, the
aggravating factors compel the conclusion that disbarment is warranted. This Court has
consistently held that intentional misappropriation of client or fiduciary funds is among
the most serious professional violations and typically warrants disbarment. Woolery, 462
Md. at 254-55. Likewise, attorneys who persist in vexatious litigation or misuse the
judicial process in violation of Rule 3.1 may also face disbarment, particularly when such
conduct is compounded by other serious violations. See Rheinstein, 466 Md. at 722-23;
Attorney Grievance Commission v. Smith-Scott, 469 Md. 281, 324 (2020). Respondent’s
misuse of the legal process did not occur in a single case or over a brief period; rather, it
spanned nearly a decade, involved two jurisdictions, and extended across multiple state
and federal courts.
Nowhere in his Exceptions did Respondent address what the appropriate sanction
should be or explain why his admitted misconduct—use of Trust funds for personal
expenses, failure to produce trust records, non-compliance with the October 2, 2017 court
order culminating in contempt, and repeated filings barred by res judicata or collateral
33
A-035
estoppel—falls outside the scope of sanctionable conduct under the MARPC. As reflected
in the Respondent’s 70-page Exceptions, and as the Hearing Judge expressly found at the
hearing, Respondent neither acknowledged any wrongdoing nor demonstrated remorse at
any point during these proceedings. The absence of remorse weighs heavily against
mitigation. We have long recognized that a lack of contrition is a significant aggravating
factor, for it allays nothing as to “the likelihood of a repetition of the conduct.” Attorney
Grievance Commission v. Kovacic, 389 Md. 233, 240 (2005); cf. Attorney Grievance
Commission v. McClain, 373 Md. 196, 212 (2003) (“[A]n attorney’s voluntary termination
of the charged misconduct, when accompanied by an appreciation of the serious
impropriety of that past conduct and remorse for it, may be evidence that the attorney will
not again engage in such misconduct.”).
Although indefinite suspension has been imposed in some cases involving
frivolous litigation, those cases did not involve intentional misappropriation of client or
fiduciary funds. See Attorney Grievance Commission v. Whitted, 487 Md. 501 (2024).7
Considering the totality of his conduct, the serious harm inflicted, the presence of multiple
aggravating factors, and a dearth of mitigating factors, we conclude that disbarment is the
only sanction adequate to protect the public and preserve confidence in the profession.
Respondent’s actions are fundamentally incompatible with the responsibilities of an
7 Unlike the attorney in Whitted, who engaged in abusive litigation conduct but did
not misuse entrusted funds, Respondent here committed one of the most egregious
violations of professional responsibility—knowingly converting trust property for personal
use. That fundamental breach of fiduciary duty, when combined with repeated misuse of
the courts, compels disbarment.
34
A-036
attorney licensed to practice law in this State.
VII.
Conclusion
For the reasons discussed above, we concluded in a March 5, 2025 order that
Respondent violated Rules of Professional Conduct 1.1 (Competence), 1.15 (Safekeeping
Property), 3.1 (Meritorious Claims and Contentions), 3.4 (Fairness to Opposing Party and
Attorney), and 8.4(a) and (d) (Misconduct), and ordered that Respondent be disbarred.
35
A-037
EXHIBIT C
*
ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE
COMMISSION OF MARYLAND
*
*
*
*
GARY PISNER
IN THE
SUPREME COURT
OF MARYLAND
AG No. 23
September Term, 2023
*
ORDER
Upon consideration of Respondent’s motion for reconsideration of the Court’s
opinion and disposition in this matter, it is this 20th day of August 2025, by the
Supreme Court of Maryland
ORDERED that the motion for reconsideration is denied.
ffv/r
•
/
/s/ Matthew J. Fader
Chief Justice
EXHIBIT Al
A-038
EXHIBIT B
ATTORNEY GREVEINCE
COMISSION OF MARYLAND
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MARYLAND
SCM-AG-0023-2023
Petitioner
vs.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
MONTGOMERY COUNTY
Case No. C-15-CV-23-004631
GARY STEVEN PISNER
Respondent
MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OFTHIS
COURT’S OPINION OF JULY 14, 2025, PURSUANT TO MD RULE
8-605
COMES NOW Respondent Pisner, (hereinafter “Pisner”) Pro Se, hereby
respectfully moves this Court to reconsider its Opinion of July 14, 2025.
This Motion is timely under Md Rule 8-605 because it has been filed within
the 30 days post-opinion and falls under (see Md. Rule 8-605(b)(l),
605(b)(2)) and 8-605(b)(3).
I.
Concurrent Proceedings
This court declined to hear the constitutional due process issues that
existed in this case (see Pisner’s Motion to establish a Briefing
Schedule of August 8, 2024, which was denied and remanded to
APPENDIX B
Hl
A-039
federal court, those due process issues are being addressed by the
Federal 4th Circuit and the issue of this court’s order of March 5,
2025, where Pisner was improperly disbarred before the outstanding
due process issues were addressed: A petition for Certiorari has been
filed with the U.S. Supreme Court.
So those constitutional issues are before the Federal Courts, but, as
will be shown, the July 13, opinion has its own problems, i.e., the
stated facts in the opinion, which appear to be largely taken from Bar
Counsel’s draft finding of facts and conclusions of law, which were
accepted at the Circuit Court level, and which was used by this court.
The record does not support the alleged gross factual errors.
II.
Correcting the Facts
1. The ledger
In exhibit 1, the “Marion E. Pisner Revokable Trust Agreement
“paragraph 2(a) in 2008 named two beneficiaries unless they
violated. Rubinstein and Pisner paragraph 6(e) of exhibit 1, in
which case that person would no longer be a beneficiary. For
the Trustees there were Pisner and Marla Rubinstein
(hereinafter “Rubinstein.” See paragraph 3(b).
Each CoTrustee has a duty to maintain the documents in
[2]
A-040
charge. There has never been any caselaw presented that
requires each CoTrustee to maintain duplicates of the entire
trust file and as such the maintenance of the documentation
was divided between Rubinstein, Pisner and the Trust
Accountant, who needed to prepare tax payments and fulfil the
requirements of 6(a)(1). That included paying the $132, 000
estate tax and paying off outstanding debts.
1. The BB&T ledger
The BB&T account ledger was maintained by Pisner and that
was simply a response to overdrafts occurring every month for
the first year because two people were writing checks. That
was not an encumbrance because the bank statements went to
Rubinstein. One. can see that for the Belair meeting, it was
Rubinstein that brought the bank statements and that was
because statements were sent to the granter’s house as was
every other correspondence, in addition, the personal property
of the granter was controlled by Rubinstein because she owned
the house that the Granter lived in; in addition, Rubinstein
controlled personal property of the trust because that property
was in the Granter’s house which had been transferred to
[3]
Rubinstein via paragraph 6(1 )(c) of the Trust agreement;
moreover, the stock certificates and bonds were in the
Granter’s house so Rubinstein held those too (the Granter’s
house was 10718 Douglas Avenue, Silver Spring MD and that
is the reason why Pisner had so few documents, especially
after the Belair meeting because the new account that became
the default TD Bank account seeded with the entire contents of
the BB&T account, which was $28,000. The BB&T account
after the TD account became vestigial, mainly used for
collecting rent in the houses that were owned in the Baltimore
Metro area and paying for maintenance in those houses. The
Baltimore houses lost money. The Maryland and Virginia
houses were distributed equally, and they ceased to be money
makers for the trust.
1. Court findings regarding the BB&T account is misleading. The
court states that:
The ledger maintained by Respondent reflects
approximately 70 personal transactions between
November 2009 and August 2013. These include
tens of thousands of dollars in payments related to
Respondent’s divorce, personal credit card
charges, and self-designated “loans” from the
Trust.
[4]
A-042
Given that Pisner was a beneficiary, it should not surprise
anyone that there were these distributions to Pisner.
The Hearing Judge found Respondent’s testimony
regarding the Bel Air Meeting to be inconsistent.
Respondent initially testified that he had provided Ms.
Rubinstein with all relevant Trust documents, stating
that she “walked out of the meeting with all the
documents. Everything.” Later, however, he
acknowledged—and Ms. Rubinstein confirmed—that
he had brought only a ledger to the meeting.
On page 3 of this court states the following:
The Hearing Judge found Respondent’s
testimony regarding the Bel Air Meeting to be
inconsistent. Respondent initially testified that he
had provided Ms. Rubinstein with all relevant
Trust documents, stating that she “walked out of
the meeting with all the documents. Everything.”
Later, however, he acknowledged—and Ms.
Rubinstein confirmed—that he had brought only
a ledger to the meeting. Based on these
inconsistencies, the Hearing Judge concluded that
Respondent did not, in fact, relinquish control of
the Pisner Trust to Ms. Rubinstein following the
Bel Air meeting.
/
Reviewing the Circuit Court Transcript, 14 -24 P 73 19) the problem is
clear. In the transcript Pisner said:
I brought to that meeting a printout of the ledger, and that
was it. Marla Rubenstein had every other document in
her possession. She had everything. She had the bank
statements. She had everything. I had nothing. I had
sent her my credit card statements, she had them. She
[5]
A-0-
had been working on them for about a week. That's why
we set it up a week — a week after the settlement. She
had to write up on a
One can see that the Author simply failed to check the
transcript.
In the opinion we have a second mistake, where the court
states:
The ledger maintained by Respondent reflects
approximately 70 personal transactions between
November 2009 and August 2013. These include tens of
thousands of dollars in payments related to Respondent’s
divorce, personal credit card charges, and self-designated
“loans” from the Trust. Ms. Rubinstein had no access to
the Trust’s bank accounts and was unaware of these
transactions until she obtained the relevant bank
statements from BB&T during the litigation described
below.
First thing to note, during the Circuit Court trial (this is in
the Transcript and in the opinion, there were three Trust
accounts- the BB&T account, the TD account after the
Belair audit, and the SunTrust bank account, which used
to pay the taxes, like the $132, 000 estate tax and those
debts. Pisner has no access to the TD bank account, nor
did he receive statements: This was consistent with the
Belair Agreement that Rubinstein would run the trust.
Ironically, during discovery, there were no statements, no
tax payments, no checks from tenants- nothing and given
that Rubinstein was a CoTrustee, she had a duty to
maintain her records; one would also expect that the
stock documents were be available- but nothing;
appraisals of personal property -nothing.
[6]
A-044
The Circuit Court looked at the actual number of distributions using
McCarthy’s accountant’s numbers from their exhibit:
BY THE COURT:
Q Okay. I'm looking at Petitioner's Exhibit 47, bates
number 403, reimbursement for educational expenses, or
what?
A Yeah.
$3,600?
A Distributions to Marla Pisner Rubinstein. This is
from the BB&T account adding —
I see.
A -- 10,138 comes out to 54,000.
Q Right, almost 55,000.
A Right.
Okay. What else do you want to tell me?
So, that was being done back and forth. If you, if
you look at the, in fact, the Sun Trust on account of
transaction, it says 16-723.
What page are we talking about?
The same one.
Q I'm sorry, $49,000 is what?
A Is, is my, the amount of money I took out for
education, for legal fees and for loans was 49,000
something,
like 800, and Marla took out 54,894; and based on the
2010
audit that we did, we were about $2,300 off between the
two of us.
Q Your number 49,800 is as of 2010?
A This was pre, this was, this was what came out during
the audit in 2010.
Q Right.
A So, it didn't include anything after the audit.
Q Meaning after the Belair meeting is —
A After the Belair meeting, remember, Marla told me I
couldn't do anything.
[7]
A-045
So the alleged 92 transactions that Pisner took (don’t know what was
included) are not particularly useful given that both beneficiaries were
taking distributions from the trust before the Belair audit- that was in
distributions and loans. Under the trust agreement that was proper. As you
can see using the accountant’s own numbers show that Pisner received
$$49,000 and Rubinstein received $54,000.
Please Note: transcript 14-24 p 192, the court states:
Mr. Pisner put on some, I don't know if I can find evidence
that perhaps $133,000 of it was not mishandled or that was
actually paid in taxes. Let's assume for a moment that at
least as to that money, I think maybe the, the Commission
didn't meet its burden of clear and convincing evidence.
The Court opinion appears the have mistakenly failed to deduct the
$133,000 in estate taxes. Treating that as a distribution is to much, even for
the Circuit court.
First, the court indicated that on July 31, 2017, Rubinstein filed a
“response.”: The “response” had not been served so Pisner had no idea what
had been filed. What the court does not acknowledge is that on September
25, 2017, that July 31, 2017, was recanted and Rubinstein’s request for the
appointed trusted was withdrawn, (see Exhibit 2)
As you can see, she claimed that she had not received credit card statement,
which she had before the Belair meeting, but at the next hearing all the
[8]
A-046
credit cards were presented to Rubinstein and to the court, also with
correspondences which proved that Rubinstein had receive the credit card
statements shortly before the Belair audit:
’
09/28/2077 #:S MOTTON, APPROPRIATE RELTEF
TYPE: MOTION STATUS: DENIED
PLAINTIFF’S ORAL MOTTON TO SEAL PLAINTIFF’S
(ALBRIGHT, J.)
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
og/28/2ott #35 MOTION, WITHDRAW (CASE NOT CLOSED)
TYPE: MOTION STATUS: GRANTED
PLAINTIFF'S ORAL MOTION TO WITHDRAW PLAINTIFF'S
WITH LEAVE OF THE COURT. (ALBRIGHT, J.)
Judge: A ALBRTGHT
oe/28/20L7 #37 EXHrBrr SHEET FrLED
TYPE: DOCKET
EXHIBIT SHEET, FILED.
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
os / 28 / 2017 #3 B COURT SETS 684 R1
TYPE: DOCKET
couRT (ALBRIGFIT, J.) SETS A STATUS HEARTNG ON NOVEMBER
22,
1:30P.M. F'OR 1 HOUR BEFORE THIS MEMBER OF THE BENCH.
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
The 9/28/ Motion to Withdraw, allowed Pisner to withdraw his credid card
related exhibits because of the extensive confidential information and
because of Rubinstein’s documented failure to comply with confidential
agreements: Rubinstein’s claims about credit cards were debunked.
One should also note that given that after Exhibit 2 was filed by Rubinstein,
no beneficiary wanted a new trustee appointed, so both Pisner and
[9]
A-047
Rubinstein waited for a response from the court and that response was not
issued until 1/18/2025: Those filings has not been delt with by the court for
months.
1/18/2018 c #60 ORDER, STRTKE 481, DH
TYPE: RULING STATUS: DENTED MOTION: 23
MODIFICATION ORDER OF COURT (ALBRIGHT, J.) THAT
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO
STRIKE THE RUBINSTEIN RESPONSE TO THE TRUST'S PETTTION
FORA
DECLARATION RIGHTS PURSUANT TO SECTTON 3-408 (DOCKET
ENTRY NO. 23) IS
DENIED, ENTERED. (COPIES MAILED)
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
Why0t/l-8/zorc #60 oRDER, STRTKE 481, DH
TYPE: RULING STATUS: DENTED MOTION: 23
MODIFICATION ORDER OF COURT (ALBRIGHT, J.) THAT
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO
STRIKE THE RUBINSTEIN RESPONSE TO THE TRUST'S PETTTION
FORA
DECLARATION RIGHTS PURSUANT TO SECTTON 3-408 (DOCKET
ENTRY NO. 23) IS
DENIED, ENTERED. (COPIES MAILED)
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
0t/tB/201-B #51 ORDER, LEAVE TO 802 DH
TYPE: RULING STATUS: GRANTED MOTION: 27
MODIFICATION ORDER OF COURT (ALBRTGHT, ,J.) THAT
DEFENDANT'S MOTTON FOR
LEAVE TO ACCEPT LATE FILING OF MOTION TO STRTKE FOR
DOCKET 25 (DOCKET
ENTRY NO. 27) IS GRANTED, ENTERED. (COPIES MAILED)
Judge: A ALBRIGHT
Ot/18/zota #52 Order, RECONSTDERATTON t7s4 DH
[10]
A-048
TYPE: RULING STATUS: DENIED MOTTON: 44
MODTFICATION ORDER OF COURT (ALBRIGHT,.].) THAT
PLATNTIFF'S REQUEST
FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE COURT'S OCTOBER 2, AND A9,
2077 ORDERS AND
NOTTCE OF OBJECTIONS FOR APPEALS TO THE MARYLAJTD
COURT OF SPECIAL
APPEALS (DOCKET ENTRY NO. 44) IS DENTED, ENTERED.
(COPIES MAILED)
,fudge: A ALBRTGHT
01-/t8/zote #53 oRDER, FOR APPROPRTATE RELTEF 977 DH
TYPE: RULTNG STATUS: DENIED MOTION: 45
MODIFICATION ORDER OF COURT (ALBRIGHT, J.) THAT
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR
STAY (DOCKET ENTRY NO. 45) IS DENIED, ENTERED. (COPTES
MAILED) were we waiting:
1. The Trust
The Trust assets vanish.
On January 14, 2019 Pisner filed a complaint because of evidence that
McCarthy was disposing of assets and that the properties all in the District
of Columbia were being transferred to Rubinstein or the proceeds of the
sales were being paid to Rubinstein: Rubinstein had put out for rent signs
and the real estate agent indicated that the owner was Marla Pisner’s
personal trust and that had been the case since late 2017.
In late 2017
McCarthy, the trustee, refused to communicate with Pisner, the beneficiary
[11]
A-049
1. The contempt issues.
Pisner had supplied three years of as required of records as required in
Judge Albright’s order required Pisner to supply trust documents back to
January 2015, this was what Judge Albright had ordered.
McCarthy had a fiduciary duty to communicate with the trust’s beneficiary.
The order coming from April 8, 2018, hearing required Pisner and
Rubinstein to supply trust documents back 10 years rather than just 3 as was
required by the court.
Pisner served every document that he had in compliance with Judge Storm’s
order.
Along with the documents Pisner requested that McCarthy notify him of
any deficiencies so he could correct those deficiencies, Pisner was never
contacted before 11AM the next business day, without reviewing the
thousands of pages of documents, McCarthy filed a suggestion of contempt
contrary to his fiduciary duty. Pisner had no idea what was missing.
On June 7, 2018, there was a hearing before Judge Mason, but there was a
problem, the accountant claimed that she had not received documents that
she had received. Her false statement under oath regarding Pisner, the
beneficiary of the trust, resulted in Pisner being found in contempt. That
order finding Pisner in contempt contained a paragraph requiring McCarthy
[12]
A-050
to serve Pisner by email any document that Pisner had supplied by a
deadline. Once Pisner received those documents, it was clear that the
accountant’s claim that Pisner had failed to supply documents was false
because the documents that McCarthy had returned to Pisner contained
every document that the Accountant had testified, under oath, that they had
not received.
Based on the Pisner filed a Motion for reconsideration with
irrefutable evidence, including documents that McCarthy’s accountant had
committed perjury (See Exhibit 3).
Judge Masion, on July 20, 2028, indicated that he was leaving the matter to
the appellate court.
So, the Accountant’s perjured testimony, which McCarthy now knew to be
false, rather than disclose this to the court. That is why the Petitioner’s
attempt to conceal the source of the numbers that they used was so
improper. Moreover, Petitioner was aware of this, and it did nothing,
1. The Maryland Appellate Court
The opinion miscarriages what happened in the appellate court. Pisner was
faced with a problem, i.e. McCarthy practiced in three jurisdictions:
Baltimore City, Baltimore County, and Montgomery County. There were
certain odd characteristics in the proceeding that were unusual. First, there
was no real appeal because McCarthy, in his reply brief in the appeal had
[13]
A-051
made alternative questions for review that were unrelated to the appeal and
the court used his- so the appeal issues were not addressed at all. Next, even
•stranger was the fact that the judge had complained about Pisner not having
an opening brief, but the court had barred the filling of the opening brief via
order, finally the court praised McCarthy’s expertise in Trust and Estate law
in its opinions. Finally, the judge that was allegedly writing the opinion
was from Baltimore County, and researching the matter, I had to determine
if Pisner had a recusal problem or a law clerk/contractor problem. It was
reasonable to ask for information from the clerk’s office: perfectly
reasonable.
1. The D.C. Superior Court
The opinion is confusing in the Rubinstein filed a Motion to Dismiss after
long delays. There were multiple grounds for dismissal raised and all were
rejected, but Rubinstein was facing a Motion to Compel and Rubinstein and
McCarthy’s approach was to secretly clean up the record of the Maryland
Circuit Court, by getting an order issued by a circuit court judge, while the
court had no jurisdiction to sanitize the Maryland Circuit Court record and
maybe get the D.C. Superior Court Case settled for $50,000 of Pisner’s
money. The problem was that it was on the record that the trust has no
assets in late 2017; this is how McCarthy and Rubinstein de It with the
[14]
A-052
problem with documentation being acquired through discovery. The Court
received a copy of the distribution order months after the case was filed.
Judge Pan assumed that there were still ongoing proceedings in Maryland
and that is why the court ordered the case refiled in Maryland.
1. The Federal Courts
It was the D.C. Superior Court and the D.C. Court of Appeals that
encouraged Pisner to refile in Maryland. In fact, the Court of Appeals
retained jurisdiction over the case, to protect Pisner from statutory bars.
The Maryland Federal District Court
What happened with Rubinstein is simple. A scheduling order was issued
by the court, which required approval for motions. Rubinstein submitted a
motion to dismiss with hundreds of pages of attachments, including the
contempt order, which was acquired through perjury and the distribution
order from the circuit court, which was done ex parte, based on the perjured
testimony contempt order, while an appeal was underway, so the court
lacked jurisdiction. Pisner requested a Fed. Rul. Evid. 201 (e) hearing - it
was denied. The Motion to Dismiss that had been heard in D.C., which had
ruled on every ground for dismissal alleged in Rubinstein’s new Motion to
Dismiss had already been ruled on, so there was collateral estoppel, but the
court would not let Pisner use the D, C, court’s opinion- inexplicable.
[15]
A-053
The 4th Circuit’s opinion was terse- “it’s a trust matter.” Not very
informative.
As for the District Court case against McCarthy, that case is before the U.S.
Supreme Court, so it is non final, despite what is alleged in the opinion.
CONCLUSION
So for these matters, disregarding the Due Process issues, which are now in
the Federal 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, there are numerous factual errors
that need correction, please consider correcting those errors.
Given the word limits Pisner could not address the legal argument, which
also has numerous errors.
August 11, 2025
Gary Pisner
Gary Pisner, Esq.
10561 Assembly Drive
Fairfax, VA 22030
Tel: 703-597-6447
Fax: 1-866-268-1771
Email: gpisner@outlook.com
[16]
A-054
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that I have served a copy of this notice on Counsel for
Petitioner today, on August 11, 2025, electronically and I certify that
this filling has 3,264 words.
Gary Pisner
[17]
A-055
Exhibit 1
EXHIBIT A
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE COMISSION OF
MARYLAND,
Case No.:____________
NOTICE OF REMOVAL
Petitioner,
V.
Removed from:
GARY PISNER,
Maryland Supreme Court,
CN: SCM-AG-0023-2023
Respondent.
TO:
Clerk of the U.S. District Court for The District of Maryland Southern Division:
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT Respondent Gary Pisner (hereinafter, “Pisner”) hereby
removes to this Court the State court action described herein, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1332, 1441,
1446, and 1447. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1446(d) and this Court’s Local Rules, copies of this
Notice of Removal are being served on all parties at the electronic addresses listed in Petition of
Petitioner’ state court electronic filing system and are being filed in the Supreme Court of
Maryland.
I.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. How the Constitutional due process errors accumulated.
A formal disciplinary proceeding, by the Maryland Attorney Grievance Commission (hereinafter
“Bar Counsel”) against Pisner was initiated, by Bar Counsel, in 2023 (the complaint had been filed by
Pisner sister approximately in 2020 while Pisner was suing her in the District of Columbia to recover
missing assets, which were in her possession). Pisner had been a beneficiary of a trust managed by a
court appointee a Robert McCarthy, Esq., (hereinafter “McCarthy”) who has been a court appointee for
over a decade in Montgomery, Baltimore, and Anne Arundel Counties and Baltimore City: It appears
that he has been the default court appointee for trustee and guardianships, with 500 plus court
appointments over a ten-year period. Under McCarthy’s management the trust assets disappeared.
Pisner filed ethics complaints against McCarthy and his accountant. Pisner also filed a lawsuit against
APPENDIX C
1
A-056
McCarthy and his accountant1.
The constitutional deficiencies that had been raised in the circuit court investigative stage were:
•
Bar Counsel engaged in behavior that is unconstitutional (according to the caselaw, this
is a form of prosecutorial misconduct) in that Bar Counsel, after a discussion with
McCarthy, exonerated McCarthy and permitted him to be the main source for an
investigation into Pisner and made him the main author of the issued Petition.
•
This means that the person who had been accused of numerous ethical violations and
was sued, was put in charge of an investigation against the person who had sued him
and who had filed an ethics complaint against him. Not surprisingly, this has led to
numerous procedural and constitutional failures.
•
The Petition gave inadequate notice: What appears to have happened is the petition
is a “flow of consciousness” diatribe of McCarthy containing some real and some
unreal statements. Pisner objected to the petition in his answer because of a lack of
notice.
•
Although Marla Rubinstein (hereinafter “Rubinstein”) had filed the complaint and
had participated in the panel review hearing, it was McCarthy’s related “flow of
consciousness” complaints that predominated: This led to even more confusion.
•
Bar Counsel had been served with discovery and apparently, because McCarthy had
prepared the material for the petition, Bar Counsel’s ability to respond to discovery
was limited, so bar counsel had a limited response to discovery.
•
The listed exculpatory evidence identified was non-existent; even Md. Disciplinary
R. 19-726(c), the equivalent of the Brady Rule, was ignored by Bar Counsel.
•
The Complainant, Rubinstein totally failed to respond to a subpoena Duces Tecum,
but was allowed to testify at the investigative hearing, although a Motion for the
Court to Issue a Rule to Show Cause had been filed against her.
1 The same accountant that was sued for embezzling trusts funds and who a ethics complaint was filed because the
accountant committed perjury; the same accountant that bar counsel relied on in the investigation and petition.
2
A-057
•
McCarthy failed to respond to a subpoena Duces Tecum but was allowed to testify
although a Motion for the Court to Issue a Rule to Show Cause had been filed
against him.
•
Pisner could not raise McCarthy unethical behavior because McCarthy had been
exonerated by Bar Counsel; therefore, Rule 19-707(b) applied, and the evidence was
deemed to be confidential.
•
There was evidence that McCarthy had concealed exculpatory documents during the
investigation.
II.
BASIS FOR REMOVAL
A. The District Court proceeding.
Clearly- there are several overt due process errors and procedural errors that,
normally would be addressed prior to any evidentiary proceeding. The above
deficiencies were raised repeatedly but there were two cited impediments to
correcting the procedural deficiencies at the investigative level: First, Rule 19727(d) requires that “[T]he hearing shall be completed within 120 days after
service on the Attorney. The Second Rule 19-725(c), which states that
.. .Motions to dismiss the proceeding and motion for summary judgement are
not permitted.” The conclusion of the court was that it lacked the authority to
act because the court lacked the time and/or the authority, but the Maryland
Supreme Court did.
Pisner preserved all is objections, for the Maryland Supreme Court through
notices of objections, request for reconsideration, and motions.
Because the circuit court believed it could not fix the procedural and
evidentiary errors, the product of the circuit court, i.e., its Finding of Facts and
Conclusions of Law contain so many factual and legal errors — seemingly an
obvious migration of McCarthy’s errors to the final product, it is legally
3
A-058
useless.2
B. The Maryland Supreme Court takes Control.
The case was transferred to the Maryland Supreme Court on July 30,
2024. On August 8, 2024, Pisner filed a Motion to Establish a Briefing
Schedule (Exhibit 1), to address the procedural and due process errors,
that the circuit court had failed to remedy.
The Maryland Supreme Court responded to the above Motion on
August 28, 2024 (see Exhibit 2), with a response “Denied.”
The message is clear- the Court will move forward without addressing
the constitutional issues that permeate this proceeding: That is simply
constitutionally improper.
THEREFORE- Removal is Proper Because This Court Has Subject
Matter Jurisdiction Pursuant to U.S. Code sec 1441(1) (c)(A), because
the above issues constitute a claim arising under the U.S. Constitution
of the United States; moreover, it appears the above referenced
Maryland rules related to Maryland disciplinary proceedings act as a
unconstitutional constitutional impediment, and this Court intervention
can remove that impediment.
Finally, any bias found in present proceeding, which has largely been
commandeered by a court appointee-McCarthy, will be mitigated.
III.
Respondent Has Satisfied the Procedural Requirements for Removal.
1. Respondent filed his motion that would have permitted the review of the constitutional
deficiencies on August 8, 2024 (see Exhibit 1). The Court refused to hear those constitutional
issues, pursuant to its order on August 28 (see Exhibit 2). Accordingly, this Notice of Removal
is timely filed within 30 days [(September 28)] after the receipt through service, a copy of the
2 Pisner discovered that the trial judge has used McCarthy’s services but failed to disclose it.
4
A-059
initial pleading/order setting forth the claim for relief upon which such action or proceeding is
based.
2. This action is being removed “to the district court of the United States for the District and
division embracing the place where such action is pending,” pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1441(a).
3. Additionally, both parties are subject to personal jurisdiction in this court. As set forth above,
Respondent is a citizen of Virginia and Petitioner is in Maryland.
4. No previous application has been made for the removal requested herein.
IV.
Preservation of Rights and Defenses
•
All rights are reserved, including, but not limited to, defenses and objections as to
venue and personal jurisdiction and the right to move for dismissal of the Petition for,
e.g., failure to state a claim for relief and failure to sue the appropriate parties. The
filing of this Notice of Removal is subject to, and without waiver of, any such defenses
and objections.
•
Pisner also reserves the right to amend or supplement this Notice of Removal.
WHEREFORE, Respondent Pisner respectfully gives notice that the above-captioned civil
action pending in the Maryland Supreme Court is removed to this Court, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§
1332, 1441, 1446, and 1447.
Dated: 9/26/2024
By:
Gary Pisner, Esq. Pro Se
10561 Assembly Drive
Fairfax, Virginia 22030
Tel: 703-597-6447
Fax; 1-866-68-1771
Email: gpisner@outlook.com
5
A-060
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on September 27,2024, the foregoing Notice of Removal, and all
exhibits thereto, were paper filed and that copies of same were served upon the Maryland Court and
the Petitioner electronically, through their court system.
6
A-061
ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE
COMMISSION OF MARYLAND
*
IN THE
*
SUPREME COURT
*
OF MARYLAND
*
AG No. 23
*
September Term, 2023
v.
GARY STEVEN PISNER
ORDER
Upon consideration of respondent’s motion to establish briefing schedule, motion
to recuse, “Expedited Motion for Extension of Time to File His Exceptions or Brief,” and
“Expedited Rule 1-204 Motion to Extend Time Requirements to File His Exceptions or
Brief,” it is this 28th day of August 2024,
ORDERED by the Supreme Court of Maiyland that the motion to establish briefing
schedule is denied; and it is further
ORDERED that the motion to recuse is denied as each Justice has determined that
their disqualification under Maryland Rule 18-102.11 is not warranted; and it is further
ORDERED that the respondent’s “Expedited Rule 1-204 Motion to Extend Time
Requirements to File His Exceptions or Brief’ is granted and the date for filing of
exceptions is extended from August 30, 2024 to September 16, 2024; and it is further
ORDERED that the respondent’s “Expedited Motion for Extension of Time to File
His Exceptions or Brief’ is denied as moot.
/s/ Matthew J. Fader
Chief Justice
A-062
Gary Pisner, Esq.
10561 Assembly Drive
Fairfax, VA 22030
703-597-6447 | Fax: 1-866-268-1771'
ATTORNEY GREVEINCE
COMISSION OF MARYLAND
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MARYLAND
SCM-AG-0023-2023
Petitioner
vs.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
MONTGOMERY COUNTY
Case No. C-15-CV-23-004631
GARY STEVEN PISNER
Respondent
MOTION TO ESTABLISH BRIEFING SCHEDULE
The Respondent respectfully requests that this Court enter an order setting
a briefing schedule to address those objections raised and referenced in
Pisner’s, Notice to Preserve Objections filed on Jul 15, 2024 (see Exhibit 1
and pages 8104 to 8107 of the record).
I.
Why this Briefing Schedule is Necessary
Respondent proposes a schedule that would permit briefing, relating to cited
errors, to be completed and oral arguments to be permitted on the matters,
prior to the filing deadline, for the parties to file their exceptions to the
Circuit Court’s Finding of Facts and Conclusions of Law, which was
submitted on July 30, 2024.
This should be done because those numerous cited due process
deficiencies, rule compliance failures, and the legal defects may make
[1]
A-063
further proceedings moot. Moreover, this Court will have a clearer
understanding of the facts in this matter and how the alleged facts proffered
by Bar Counsel and apparently adapted by the Circuit Court, in its Finding
of Facts and Conclusions of Law, came into existence and how the record was
created.
On the 31st of July (last week) this Court proffered a schedule that,
Respondent proposes that this Court modify to permit a briefing schedule
and, if necessary, a hearing to review those errors on the record.1
II.
Conclusion
For the foregoing reasons, the Respondent proposes that the date now
scheduled for filing the exceptions to the Circuit Court’s Finding of Facts and
Conclusions of Law, now scheduled for August 30. 2024, be, instead, the date
for filing the Respondent’s brief to address those errors cited, that a brief in
opposition would be permitted within two weeks thereafter, by Petitioner, a
reply brief should be permitted two weeks thereafter, a hearing, if necessary,
should be scheduled on the matter and the exceptions, if necessary, should
be filed thereafter. The date for oral arguments, for the matter, now set for
October 1, 2024, should be rescheduled to accommodate the revised briefing
schedule.
1 It is also noteworthy that, given the number of errors of record, 30 minutes for oral arguments would be
insufficient, unless the errors have been already addressed and disposed of, by this Court, prior to a final
hearing.
[2]
A-064
August 8, 2024
Gary Pisner, Esq.
10561 Assembly Drive
Fairfax, VA 22030
Tel: 703-597-6447 Fax: 1-866-268-1771
Email: gpisner@outlook.com
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that I have served a copy of this Motion with Exhibit on Counsel for
Petitioner today, August 8, 2024, and August 9, 2024, electronically.
[3]
A-065
Gary Pisner, Esq.
10561 Assembly Drive
Fairfax, VA 22030
703-597-6447 | Fax: 1-866-268-1771
EXHIBIT 1
ATTORNEY GREVEINCE
COMISSION OF MARYLAND
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MARYLAND
SCM-AG-0023-2023
Petitioner
vs.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
MONTGOMERY COUNTY
Case No. C-15-CV-23-00463 1
GARY STEVEN PISNER
Respondent
NOTICE TO PRESERVE OBJECTIONS 1
Defects in the Petition form and process.
The Respondent, Gary Pisner, hereinafter, “Pisner” notes, to preserve his
objections, for potential review by the Maryland Supreme Court: said alleged
errors disclosed in Pisner’s Motion to Dismiss and Answer, supported by or
disregarded by the court are objected to and may be presented to the
Maryland Supreme Court for review.
Respondent incorporates by reference the following documents in support of his
objections:
•
Answer
•
Motion to Dismiss of 5/16/2024 and
1 Please note that this is a listing of objections; therefore, there is no requirement for this court to file a
response. This is simply informational.
[1]
A-066
Motion for Reconsideration of the Court’s May 22 Order.
Comments of this Court during the hearing (see 14 Tr 198).
As an ancillary problem, given that Robert McCarthy, Esq. (“McCarthy”) a
person who was sued by Pisner and, who had an ethics complaint filed against him
by Pisner, the use of the confidentiality rule to restrict the boundaries of the
proceedings was improper and are objected to. The Court noted this tension
between the confidentiality rule as it is applied to McCarthy and that the
underlying driving force in this matter, could be equivalent to the “snitch” problem
in criminal cases, yet the matter was not resolved, still the proceedings were
encumbered.
Defects in the Discovery Process.
The Respondent Gary Pisner, hereinafter, “Pisner” notes, to preserve his
objections, for potential review by the Maryland Supreme Court; said alleged errors
disclosed in Pisner’s Motion to Compel, supported by or disregarded by the court are
objected to and may be presented to the Maryland Supreme Court for review.
Respondent incorporates by reference the following documents in support of
his objections:
•
Motion to Compel 5/2/2024
•
Reply Brief 5/13/2024
•
Motion for reconsideration 5/19/2024
[2]
A-067
Especially of note is the failure of Petitioner to supply exculpatory
documents, narratives of exculpatory communications, and to comply with
Rule 19-726(b).
Failure to Comply with Discovery by the two principal witnesses.
The Respondent Gary Pisner, hereinafter, “Pisner” notes, to preserve his
objections, for potential review by the Maryland Supreme Court; said alleged
errors disclosed in Pisner’s Motion for Clarification relating to witnesses’
failure to comply with Subpoena Duces Tecums, supported by or disregarded
by the court are objected to and may be presented to the Maryland Supreme
Court for review.
During the prehearing on June 10, 2024, in its response to Pisner’s Motion
for Clarification, the court cited to scheduling restrictions as limiting its
ability to cure two of the witnesses’ failure to comply with discovery requests.
Regardless of the schedule in the rules, due process should have been the
driving force behind the process rather than schedule, nevertheless, though
there were issues related to the failure of two of the witnesses to comply with
discovery, the court improperly permitted the two witnesses to testify in
violation of Rule 19 726(a)(5). Said actions were highly prejudicial and are
objected to.
[3]
A-068
Respondent incorporates by reference the following documents in support of
his objections:
Motion for Clarifications 6/6/2024.
Transcript excerpt of the pretrial hearing.
Gary Pisner, Esq.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that I have served a copy of this notice on Counsel for Petitioner today,
July 15, 2024, electronically.
[4]
A-069
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR MONTGOMERY COUNTY, MARYLAND
----------------------------- X
MARION E.
PISNER TRUST,
:
Plaintiff,
:
V.
:
MARLA RUBENSTEIN,
:
Defendant.
Civil No
427983
:
----------------------------- X
HEARING
APPENDIX Cl
FILED
Rockville, Maryland
DEC 26 2017
September 28, 2017
Clerk of the Circuit Court
Montgomery County, Md.
DEPOSITION SERVICES, INC.
12321 Middlebrook Road, Suite,
Germantown, Maryland 20874
(301) 881-3344
22
1
relevant to the matters before me today.
2
whether or not Ms. Rubenstein received those documents.
3
don't think that's relevant to the issue of the propriety of an
4
audit at this time.
5
the record is made with regards to those exhibits.
6
did you have want to have the next exhibit marked?
In other words,
I
So I am going to sustain the objection but
7
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
8
THE COURT:
Okay.
What is --
Why don't you please hand it to
9
the clerk. , And ma'am, do you have the exhibits that we handed
10
you or your brother handed you earlier?
11
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
12
THE COURT:
13
I do.
I have these.
We need to retain those for the record,
please.
14
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
15
THE COURT:
All right.
Even though I have declined to admit
16
them, they are part of the record.
17
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
18
MR. PISNER:
19
believe they are appropriate.
20
THE COURT:
Thank you. Your Honor.
Your Honor, please note my objection.
I'm sorry.
You are the moving party and
21
your sister was the one who objected.
22
are objecting.
23
24
25
MR. PISNER:
So I'm not clear why you
Objecting to the Court not moving it
into evidence.
THE COURT:
I
Me not accepting it into evidence?
A-071
21
1
going back eight years is deemed necessary.
That's a lot of money and you run into statute of
2
Forgive me. Your Honor.
Benning v. Reese
3
limitations issues.
4
says for a situation like this where Rubenstein is actually
5
asking for damages, it's a three-year statute of limitations.
6
Why am I raising this point?
7
cash for the trust.
8
month to keep the account the trust account from bouncing.
9
now we are going back to an issue where we have to pay an
10
accountant for eight years of review.
we need to basically preserve
We have no money.
I am putting in $10 a
And
11
And the reason why we have to do this and why during
12
the last hearing it appeared that this is necessary was because
13
of the very statements that were made by Ms. Rubenstein.
14
did not receive the credit card statements.
15
audit in 2010.
16
is incapable of reviewing things as a trustee herself.
17
incapable of doing her own review and audit because she doesn't
18
have access to the documentation and to the websites, the bank
19
websites.
20
If you look at it and I think to summarize where this whole
21
thing was back in July of 2016 I have another exhibit which
22
contradicts everything she says.
23
THE COURT:
She
It was not a full
She had been requesting audits for years.
She
She is
The problem here is it's a simple, simple review.
Okay.
Sir, I'm going to rule on the
24
admissibility of the last exhibit.
25
what is in that exhibit, I'm not clear as to how that's
Based on your proffer of
A-072
24
1
MR. PISNER:
2
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
3
No.
She was given a copy.
I was given a copy of that.
That is
marked 2 now and not B?
4
THE COURT:
5
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
6
THE COURT:
Okay.
7
MR. PISNER:
Yes, Your Honor.
8
THE COURT:
Ma'am, look at that and tell me if you
It's 2.
Thank you.
Could you step back, sir?
9
have an objection to that being admitted as part of this
10
hearing.
11
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
12
I would need time to review this.
13
I object to this being admitted as evidence at this time
14
considering it is the first time I am seeing it.
THE COURT:
15
16
17
are.
No.
Your Honor, I object.
Its pages and
Its pages, Your Honor.
And
Tell me generally what these documents
I'm asking Mr. Pisner that question.
MR. PISNER:
This -- basically this document lays out
18
the status of the audit that was ongoing as of July 2016.
And
19
there was an ongoing audit being done by Marla Rubenstein.
She
20
had documents.
She was working on at that point in time.
She
21
had she claims in this document.
22
THE COURT:
23
it bank statements?
She had --
Sir, what kind of a document is it?
is it an e-mail?
Tell me what it is.
24
MR. PISNER:
This is an e-mail, Your Honor.
25
THE COURT:
From who to who?
A-073
is
23
1
MR. PISNER:
Not accepting it.
2
THE COURT:
Okay.
3
MR. PISNER:
Okay.
4
THE COURT:
If you could step back.
5
MR. PISNER:
Yes, Your Honor.
6
THE COURT:
What is -- I'm sorry, sir.
8
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
9
THE COURT:
What is the document that you have in
7
10
I understand, sir.
Could you
step back?
your hands?
is that something that you handed to Mr. Clerk?
11
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
12
THE COURT:
Has it been marked?
13
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
14
THE COURT:
So it is.
15
THE CLERK:
This is (unintelligible) so you have to
16
It has.
mark this one 2.
17
MR.-PISNER:
This is just my copy.
18
THE CLERK:
Oh.
19
THE COURT:
But what is the -- I think we are now on
20
Exhibit No.
Okay.
2.
21
THE CLERK:
Yes, Your Honor.
22
THE COURT:
Is that the Petitioner's No. 2.
23
THE CLERK:
That is Petitioner's No. 2
24
THE COURT:
Okay.
25
No.
Could you please hand Petitioner's
2 to Ms. Rubenstein so she can see it.
A-074
26
1
Okay.
2
that are in the show cause order.
3
MR. PISNER:
Thank you, sir.
You may continue addressing the issues
I think you can see from this exhibit
4
that Marla Rubenstein had full access to all the accounts.
5
was in the process of doing her own audit.
6
documentation available.
7
her pleadings before this Court, her basic premise is that she
8
was deprived of documentation to review.
9
indicates unambiguously that that was untrue.
10
that she wants to have a review of things.
11
She
She had all the
Contrary to what she claimed in all
This communication
I understand
I understand that she wants to go back all the way to
12
the beginning because she has in her mind come up with these
13
ideas that there were things missing in the original audit,
14
that it was in some way defective, and that she was deprived of
15
information to make things correct.
16
Court the credit card statements.
17
she had total access to everything and, in fact, ironically she
18
claims that the only thing that she was really missing was
19
2011, 2012, 2013 BB&T statements.
20
I know I submitted to this
That was one of them.
But
Well, I can tell you in my in my pleadings I point
21
out that during that period -- this was after the original
22
audit -- she took over everything.
23
that audit was over that she was going to take charge.
24
reason for that is because she did not want any reimbursement
25
for trust expenses.
She indicated that when
And the
She did not want me to bill the trust for
A-075
25
MR. PISNER:
1
2
Rubenstein and me.
3
4
These are communications between Marla
THE COURT:
And the date on them you said is July of
MR. PISNER:
Well, you have July 6 and you have a
2016?
5
6
running narrative here going all the way back to June.
7
started on June and then went all the way to July 3rd.
THE COURT:
8
9
look at those.
10
case?
Okay.
It
Ma'am, would you please take a
Are there discovery request pending in this
11
MR. PISNER:
No.
12
THE COURT:
I'm asking your sister that.
Were their
13
discovery requests that you had directed to your brother such
14
that the production of this kind of document would have been
15
required prior to today?
16
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
No.
There was no discovery request,
17
Your Honor, but if I could just state that my brother and I are
18
both in agreement that —
19
20
21
THE COURT:
Now we're talking about the admissibility
of this document.
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
22
requests, Your Honor.
23
THE COURT:
Okay.
No.
There were no discovery
I am going to admit this document
24
as it is communication between the parties from last summer as
25
to the issue of the audit.
May I see it please?
thank you.
A-076
Z.LO-V
28
1
depriving the other trustee of access to the system, to the
2
books.
3
documentation as I do.
4
She has just as much of the requirement to review the
And what I'm telling the Court is that was not true.
5
It was not true from the very beginning.
6
understand.
7
underlying facts that resulted in that rule to show cause order
8
were untrue.
9
that an audit would be appropriate.
10
two years, three years.
11
years is a little extreme.
12
audit done in 2010 and it was a complete audit.
13
be even extreme given the fact that during 2011, 2012, 2013
14
Rubenstein was in charge of the books basically --
And, Your Honor, I
Again, you have wide discretion.
But the basic
It was based on her statements to you.
And I believe one year,
But going back all the way back eight
Given the fact that there was an
15
THE COURT:
Do you mean Ms. Rubenstein?
16
MR. PISNER:
Ms. Rubenstein.
17
THE COURT:
Thank you.
18
19
I believe
And it would
Please refer to people by
their formal' name.
MR. PISNER:
Sorry, Your Honor.
So, again, we are
20
dealing with a couple of years one would hope because that
21
would limit the cost of the audit.
22
defects that she claims that were in the original audit again
23
there wasn't any.
Now, as far as all these
24
THE COURT:
That's not the subject of the show cause
25
order at this time.
If you could please, address who you think
A-077
27
1
my expenses and she said she would do it all by herself.
2
she walked out saying I'm taking over.
3
and 2013 until I was contacted by holders of liens on
4
properties in Baltimore, she was basically taking care of
5
things.
interesting.
8
documents, to keep records.
9
she has been given.
10
Where are they?
THE COURT:
11
You know, it's very
She talks about my duty as a trustee to keep
7
12
So between 2011, 2012,
She has all those documents.
6
So
She has lost just about everything
She lost the credit card statements.
Sir, could you please confine your
comments to the issues that are before the Court.
13
MR. PISNER:
14
of the audit itself.
15
all the documentation that she required.
16
she was deprived of documentation is false.
17
Court was interested in requiring an audit because of the
18
statements that she made that she lacked documentation to do
19
things herself.
20
information at all.
21
along.
Again, I'm going back to the necessity
You look at this document.
She has on
Her assertion that
That is why this
This document says that she didn't lack any
She had the documentation to review all
She had access to the online accounts all along.
I understand that this Court has the right to require
22
You have wide discretion.
23
an audit.
24
eyes open as to why we're doing this we are doing this because
25
there is a perceived defect that basically was one trustee was
One needs to keep one's
A-078
30
1
THE COURT:
No, ma'am.
I have given each of you an
2
opportunity to be heard in regard to the show cause order and
3
I'm prepared to make a decision.
4
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
Thank you.
JUDGE'S RULING
5
6
Okay.
Thank you, everybody.
The parties are here
7
today and they represent themselves.
8
pursuant to a show cause order that the Court issued back on --
9
it was signed on the 24th of August.
10
docketed until the 30th of August at Docket Entry 20.
11
Court issued that show cause order after having had or started
12
a hearing in regard to the petition for declaration of rights
13
pursuant to 3-408 of Courts and Judicial Proceedings.
14
filed by Mr. Pisner.
15
parties were afforded an opportunity to be heard in regard to
16
the matters listed in the show cause order and they were heard
17
today.
18
And they are here today
I believe it was not
The
That was
That was back on December 13, 2016.
Both
I have now considered their arguments in regard to
19
the show cause order and what I'm going to do now is make some
20
preliminary factual findings and then move forward.
21
parties are brother and sister.
22
the Marion E. Pisner revocable trust, a copy of which I believe
23
is attached as an exhibit to the original petition to declare
24
rights.
25
grantor, Ms. Pisner, who is the parties' mother, has died.
So the
They are also trustees under
And it seems to me from everybody's comments the
A-079
And
29
1
I should appoint as a trustee, if anybody?
2
MR. PISNER:
I have no suggestion, Your Honor.
3
THE COURT:
Okay.
Thank you, sir.
Is there anything
else you would like to say about the issues that are within the
5
scope of the Court1s show cause order?
MR. PISNER:
Your Honor, I would like to know for the
7
record that what was before this Court originally was a
8
requirement that the Court review the trust documents and make
9
determination as to interpretation.
10
disregarded.
11
with.
12
we will do here as far as an audit is concerned.
That has been totally
And it's unclear when that ever will be dealt
Those questions that were raised are pertinent to what
And I would respectfully request that this Court
13
14
respond to those.
15
initiated this entire process.
I understand we have this audit
16
issue but that's a sidetrack.
There were questions that were
17
raised from the very beginning.
18
property.
19
a certain amount of money.
20
That has nothing to do an audit.
So that issue was posed in
21
the questions that were raised.
Can she have a house?
22
there self-dealing here?
23
her?
Respond to what is actually before it.
What
Ms. Rubenstein has asked for a
She has asked for the Court to give her property for
That was not before the Court.
Can the Court hand over a house to
That's what it is.
24
THE COURT:
25
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
is
Thank you, sir.
Your Honor, may I respond?
A-080
32
1
parties.
2
are spelled out not only in the declaration of rights but they
3
have been discussed by the parties before me both today and on
4
our prior occasion in our prior hearing.
5
based on the parties' representations that, while the trust
6
does not have substantial liquid assets, it does have some non
7
liquid assets.
8
claims against the trust or at least the trust assets and those
9
seem to me to be issues that are also the subject of dispute.
10
So based on all of that, it seems to me that, first
11
of all, that these parties at this juncture are unable to work
12
together to manage the trust.
13
in part what motivated Mr. Pisner to start this case and ask
14
the Court to declare that he had the right to act unilaterally.
15
Beyond that, it seems that there are a number issues that
16
require resolution.
17
to me that, without the Court's administration of this trust,
18
that these issues will not get resolved.
19
And those disputes are spelled out or some of them
So it also appears
And it also appears that there may be some
That inability in my judgment is
I have just outlined those.
So it seems
And because these issues will not get resolved, the
20
beneficiaries, who are the parties themselves, will not be able
21
to move forward.
22
that it is in the interest of them and the trust itself to
23
fashion a remedy which would allow this matter to move forward
24
and in my judgment that remedy will be the removal of these
25
trustees for the time being and the appointment of a substitute
So it seems to me that both beneficiaries --
A-081
31
1
so under the trust the parties are the trustees or at least
2
appear to be at this time.
And looking at paragraph 2, the beneficiaries of the
3
The primary beneficiary was Ms. Pisner
4
trust are as follows.
5
herself, Marion E. Pisner.
6
beneficiaries were to be Ms. Pisner's children, Gary Pisner and
7
Marla Pisner Rubenstein, who are, in fact, the parties today.
8
So the parties today essentially stand as trustees and as
9
beneficiaries at this time, given the fact that Ms. Pisner
10
herself has passed.
11
today but over the course of the case so far it seems to me
12
that the parties have broad disputes.
And then following her death, the
So in listening to everybody not only
13
They dispute a number of things, not only the
14
construction of the trust document itself but also how
15
particular trust assets should be disposed of.
16
these disputes touch a property known as the Gorman Street
17
property and another property known as the Georgia Avenue
18
property.
19
disposed of.
There are disputes about whether accountings are
20
necessary.
There are disputes about whether Ms. Rubenstein has
21
received documents that Mr. Pisner claims to have sent her.
22
There are disputes about whether Ms. Rubenstein should have
23
been more active in looking at the trustee's bank -- the trust
24
bank accounts herself.
25
These assets --
They are disputes about how these assets should be
These are just some of the disputes between the
A-082
34
So what I am
1
because of course accountings are expensive.
2
going to do at this point is I am going to direct Mr. McCarthy
3
to retain an accountant.
4
the accountant to make a report to the Court as to the breadth
5
of the accounting that they think is appropriate once they have
6
made their preliminary review.
I'm going to direct Mr. McCarthy and
7
And so I will rely on them to tell the Court what
8
they think is in order given what they see and I'm going to
9
order them to report back to the Court on those matters in 60
10
days.
11
to payment of the trustee fees and the accountant's fees, I am
12
going to defer that matter at this point.
13
of course.
14
me that that issue is something that wants further
15
investigation based on what they find.
And I will issue an order to that effect.
With regard
They will be paid,
The question is who will pay them.
And it seems to
16
Finally, I understand that there are pending matters
17
before the Court, particularly the petition to declare rights.
18
I am going to defer a decision on that because it seems that,
19
by removal of both of these trustees, that many of the issues
20
that are raised in the petition for declaration of rights may,
21
in fact, be moot.
22
all of the outstanding motions at this time until we have that
23
next hearing in 60 days.
24
please at one hour please.
25
In fact, I am going to defer disposition of
THE CLERK:
Could we find a court date in 60 days
I think that1s adequate.
Wednesday the 22nd.
A-083
33
1
trustee,
I have afforded both parties an opportunity to
2
3
identify individuals who they think would be good for serving
4
as a substitute trustee.
5
anybody.
6
And the person that I will select is Robert McCarthy.
7
lawyer who practices in our legal community.
8
in Bethesda.
9
broad experience in matters such as these.
Neither of them have identified
And so I will for that reason select someone myself.
He is a
His offices are
I know from other kinds of cases that he has
And I also know that he frequently is appointed to be
10
11
a guardian of the property of individuals whose assets are
12
meager and while of course he is not being appointed as the
13
guardian of a property in this case, the skills that adhere in
14
that role are very similar for this.
15
serves as guardian of the property, he is frequently in
16
situations where they are disputes among the family members and
17
so he is well skilled at handling those matters as well.
18
so it seems to me that he is well skilled to handle matters of
19
this kind.
20
I know that when he
And
With regard to an accounting, it seems to me that,
21
for all of the reasons that I have just outlined, that an
22
accounting is also in order.
23
going to make a decision as to the full breadth of that
24
accounting because it seems to me that some review needs to
25
occur prior to making that decision as a final matter.
At this time, however, I am not
And
A-084
36
1
include provisions ordering both of you to cooperate with and
2
communicate with Mr. McCarthy so that he may do the work that
3
is required in this case efficiently.
4
provisions of the order that Mr. McCarthy thinks that he needs
5
in order to carry out his work in this case specifics, then I
6
imagine that he will propose an additional order to supplement
7
what I have just said.
8
Does anybody have any additional questions about what will be
9
ordered as of today?
11
Honor.
12
be ---
Do you have on -- I'm sorry, Your
Do you have a phone number for Mr. McCarthy?
THE COURT:
13
14
And we will take that up as it comes.
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
10
be in the order.
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
16
THE COURT:
Thank you.
give you both his telephone number.
18
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
19
THE COURT:
East-West Highway?
21
23
Thanks
If you want to wait for a moment, I can
17
22
will that
His contact information is all going to
15
20
If there are other
Thank you.
Would you look for Robert McCarthy on
I think it's 301-654-something.
THE CLERK:
What kind of hearing is it going to be in
THE COURT:
We’re going to call it a status hearing.
60 days?
24
What I expect is that Mr. McCarthy will be able to tell us at
25
that time whether he thinks that the breath of the accounting
A-085
35
1
THE COURT:
Of December?
2
THE CLERK:
Of November
3
THE COURT:
Of November.
4
THE CLERK:
At 8:30.
5
THE COURT:
Is that acceptable, Mr. Pisner?
6
MR. PISNER
Yes.
7
THE COURT:
Is that acceptable, ma'am?
8
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
I believe it is, Your Honor.
Your Honor, as you know, I have to
9
spend the night because I live in Cherry Hill.
10
later time possibly on that date?
Is there any
11
THE CLERK:
12
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
13
THE COURT:
Is that acceptable, sir?
14
MR. PISNER
That's a little difficult for me.
15
1:30.
130.
Better.
Thank you so much.
I
will try to arrange my schedule on that date to fit that in.
16
THE COURT:
Okay.
17
MR. PISNER
That's cutting my day in half.
May I
18
address the issue of the declaration of rights just for a
19
moment ?
THE COURT:
You may, sir, but I am not ruling on it
22
MR. PISNER:
I understand, Your Honor.
23
THE COURT:
Okay.
20
21
today
Thank you, sir.
24
will issue an order t o this effect.
25
Mr. McCarthy as well.
All right.
I
I will direct the order to
You may expect that the order will also
A-086
38
1
forever.
It could go 10 years.
It could go 15 years.
2
This preliminary review that's going to be done by
3
this attorney and perhaps accounting is going to cost money.
4
We only have one property.
5
We owe property taxes.
6
house by DCRA.
7
the city of the District of Columbia because --
e
9
There is not very much money there.
We are being fined for having a vacant
I have brought in copies of the assessments by
THE COURT:
Sir, if you can address those questions
to Mr. McCarthy, I'm sure he will be able to take care of them.
10
MR. PISNER:
I understand, Your Honor, but we have
11
immediate needs and Your Honor is saying that he will be the
12
one to make the decision about the disposition of the Gorman
13
Street property?
14
THE COURT:
He is the trustee.
15
MR. PISNER:
Okay.
Yes.
And as far as the cost, is there
16
any way that we can get a determination as to how much this is
17
going to cost?
THE COURT:
18
You need to discuss that with him.
It
19
depends on how much he has to do.
20
MR. PISNER:
Will he be charging for this preliminary
THE COURT:
Yes, sir.
21
review?
22
You about given an opportunity
23
to try to resolve the matters among yourselves.
24
to do so.
25
seems to be not a lot of other options here.
You are unable
So I have determined that this is, quite frankly, it
Thank you, sir.
A-087
37
1
that he thinks is appropriate and that's really what we're
2
going to be talking about.
3
THE CLERK:
301-654-3780.
4
THE COURT:
His office is I believe about half a
5
block from the Bethesda Metro station.
6
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
7
THE COURT:
8
Okay.
Thank you.
On the corner of Old Georgetown Road and
Route 355 in Bethesda.
9
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
10
MR. PISNER:
Your Honor, you asked if we had any
12
THE COURT:
Yes, sir.
13
MR. PISNER:
I want to address the -- my petition
11
Thank you.
questions?
14
briefly but I am somewhat concerned about the cost of this
15
whole matter.
16
to keep the cost in containment.
17
There are not that many assets to basically pull money from.
18
Marla Rubenstein has indicated that there is a tenant in the
19
Georgia Avenue property.
20
And I am trying to get a grip on how we're going
And get this out of hand.
However, in response to Marla Rubenstein's concern
21
and her instruction, I gave him 30 days' notice to pay or quit.
22
That's what you do in the District of Columbia.
23
indicated that he is going to pay.
24
know, we have -- it's not -- it's not going to be as simple as
25
one would expect.
He has
So that means that, you
It's a five year lease.
This could go on
A-088
40
1
designate.
2
THE CLERK:
Yes, Your Honor.
3
THE COURT:
Okay.
By way of proposal only, would it
4
make sense then to seal that only for general -- seal them
5
which means prevent general inspection except as to Mr. Pisner,
6
Ms. Rubenstein, and Mr. McCarthy.
7
MR. PISNER:
Your Honor, I would like there to be put
8
a limit on the distribution of those credit card statements.
9
99 percent of those credit card statements are not relevant
10
when we --
11
12
THE COURT:
Hold on a second.
When you say
distribution, what are you talking about?
13
MR. PISNER:
14
out of the courthouse.
15
those credit card statements were originally turned over to
16
Marla Rubenstein, there was a confidentiality agreement.
17
what happened was she started distributing irregardless of what
18
was in those confidentiality agreements.
19
distributing my credit card statements to various people.
20
is shaking her head but that is not what happened.
Copying.
Things like that.
Taking them
The problem is when
Distributing.
And
She started
She
And I am --
This is --
21
THE COURT:
Okay.
22
MR. PISNER:
-- concerned that she is going to walk
23
out me copies of the credit card statements.
24
irrelevant stuff and distribute it.
25
THE COURT:
Okay.
Walk out with
That's what concerns me.
The state of the record is as
A-089
39
1
2
MR. PISNER:
May I address -- may I address the
Yes.
one issue of the declaration of rights?
3
THE COURT:
4
I am not ruling on it today.
5
this time.
I have already determined that
No, sir.
It is not before the Court at
6
MR. PISNER:
Thank you, Your Honor.
7
THE COURT:
Thank you.
8
(Recess)
9
THE COURT:
Let1s go back on the record.
10
THE CLERK:
We are back on the record, Your Honor.
11
THE COURT:
For the oral motion to seal, do you have
12
any objection to the oral motion to seal?
13
14
We will be in recess.
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
Honor?
Will have access to that, Your
because I'm not an attorney.
15
THE COURT:
You are a party to the case though.
Once
16
we seal them, the only way anybody can get them is if they file
17
a motion.
18
except for the parties themselves?
So that becomes more difficult.-
Can we seal them -
is that possible?
19
THE CLERK:
I would have to check, Your Honor.
20
THE COURT:
The parties --
21
MR. PISNER:
Your Honor --
22
THE COURT:
Excuse me, sir.
23
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
24
THE COURT:
The parties and Mr. McCarthy?
25
and any
accountant that Mr. McCarthy may designate or the Court may
A-090
42
1
MR. PISNER:
I will withdraw it.
2
THE COURT:
Do you have any objection to Mr. Pisner's
3
withdrawing Plaintiff 's Exhibit No. 1?
4
into evidence.
5
6
7
8
This is the first exhibit.
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
the accounting.
it was not admitted
Your Honor, those are relevant for
So will the -- will the --
THE COURT:
I have already ruled that they are not.
They are not.
9
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
10
THE COURT:
They are not --
I'm sorry.
I have already ruled that
11
they were not relevant to the decision before me today.
12
terms of relevance to the accounting later on, they may or may
13
not be relevant to the accounting later on.
14
because they are withdrawn today does not mean that they cannot
15
come into evidence later.
16
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
17
THE COURT:
Okay.
In
I mean just
I have no objection.
Thank you.
We are going to let Mr. --Mr.
18
Clerk can we do that can we allow Mr. Pisner to withdraw
19
Exhibit No.
1 since it was not admitted?
20
THE CLERK:
Withdraw with would leave of the Court?
21
THE COURT:
I'm sorry?
22
THE CLERK:
Withdraw with leave of the Court?
23
THE COURT:
With leave of the Court.
24
THE CLERK:
Yes, Your Honor.
25
THE COURT:
Okay Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 1 will be
A-091
41
1
follows.
2
Exhibit No.
We're talking about Petitioner's No. 1.
Correct?
1?
3
MR. PISNER:
Yes.
4
THE COURT:
Okay.
5
into evidence, sir.
6
confidential information in that, it was incumbent upon you to
7
redact that information prior to moving it into evidence.
8
so, quite frankly, the fact that we are taking up an oral
9
motion to seal an exhibit that you propounded is unusual.
10
am not inclined to take up an oral motion to essentially
11
restrict anybody's behavior based on what they had done in the
12
past on this.
13
happy to take it up.
14
MR. PISNER:
Very good.
15
THE COURT:
But your choices at this point are as
That was an exhibit that you moved
And so to the extent that there is
And
So I
If you want to file a motion in writing, I'm
You can either withdraw the exhibit because it is not
16
follows.
17
been admitted.
You may do that if you wish.
18
MR. PISNER:
19
THE COURT:
I --
Excuse me.
I'm still speaking.
Or if
20
you wish we can seal it along the lines that I have proposed.
21
I imagine that you would not obj ect to that.
22
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
23
THE COURT:
I would not object.
But, beyond that, I am not going to take
24
up the matter further because it is not before me.
25
would be you like for me to do, sir?
So what
A-092
44
V Digitally signed by E. Prettyman-Guay
DIGITALLY SIGNED CERTIFICATE
DEPOSITION SERVICES, INC. hereby certifies that the
attached pages represent an accurate transcript of the
electronic sound recording of the proceedings in the Circuit
Court for Montgomery County in the matter of:
Civil No. 427983
MARION E. PISNER TRUST
V.
MARLA RUBENSTEIN
By:
Transcriber
A-093
43
1
withdrawn.
2
then please make sure that the contents of the exhibits comply
3
with the court rules regarding confidential information,
4
identifying information.
5
everybody.
6
Thank you.
In the future, if anybody wants to submit exhibits
The court rules are available to
I believe they are in volume 2 of our court rules.
7
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
8
THE COURT:
9
MS. RUBENSTEIN:
10
THE BAILIFF:
11
(The proceedings were concluded.)
Thank you. Your Honor.
We will be in recess.
Thank you.
All rise.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
A-094
EXHIBIT A
Gary Pisner
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
maria pisner <marlapisner@hotmail.com>
Monday, August 22, 2016 2:52 PM
gpisner@aptcs.com
Re: Documents that you requested
Gary,
You continue to reference evidence that you have once not produced. If you continue to insist that I am lying
then you need to provide me with documentation that speaks to your claims. You reference something from
2010- which I have no record of, but what about the requests I have been making for the past six years? You
keep asking me for proof and documentation of things I never received. Therefore I am demanding that you
produce both all of your credit card and bank statements since the inception of this trust and provide me with all
the "proof' you insist you have but have not sent me.
1 have been asking for this information for years and instead of simply providing me the requested information
you insist that I have the documents. We both know this is not true. You cannot continue to withhold documents
from me.
We both want this whole ordeal to end and the only way for that to happen is if you actively participate in this
accounting and produce the documentation I do not have.
Marla
Sent from my iPhone
On Aug 22,2016, at 11:00 AM, Gary Pisner <gpisner@aotcs.com> wrote:
You asked me to forward the agreement to you RE my credit card statements (see communications
below from July 2010.
From: maria pisner fmailto:marlaoisner@hotmail,coml
Sent: Thursday, July 15, 2010 11:28 AM
To: gary pisner
Subject:
I would rather not have to wait a few weeks, so please send all the bank statements an credit card
statements to me in the next few days so I can review them before our meeting.
I agree to keep your credit card documents confidenb’al, not share them with anyone, and destroy them
when you request me to do so.
I don't want any delays.
From: Gary Pisner Imailto:apisner@aDtcs.coml
Sent: Wednesday, July 14,2010 10:14 AM
To: marlapisner@hotmall.com
Subject: Documents that you requested
A-095
Marla,
I am putting together the documents related to the expenditures of the trust, for your review, as you
requested.
There is, however, a problem In my turning over my credit card documents: Most of the information
that they contains has nothing to do with this trust audit that you requested.
I can either take a few weeks of redact most of the irrelevant entries, from around 200 pages, or you can
agree to keep my credit card documents confidential, not share them with anyone, and destroy them
when 1 request you to do so.
Most of the content of my credit card statements are noneof your business and that concerns me.
You can understand my concern.
Gary
ReadNotlfv.com E-mail Posting-Time Digital Certificate. The above e-mail arrived from aoisner@aptcs.com. was
assigned sequence number #30788464 and ReadNotify reference 68ee86eec1898658932036797e9edf73, digitally
signed, and subsequently relayed. NB: This certificate irrevocably links the body and headers of this email to the date and
time they were sent. The following signature is now published online: to view it, verify it, or for more information, please
visit www.ReadNotifv.com.
—BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE—
Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (ReadNotifv.com TimeStamp Server v2.2)
Comment: Certificate #30788464, created Mon, 22 Aug 2016 15:00:36 GMT
iQBvAwUBV7sTIDanThAdit3tAQGp3wLPfsY3fYQBaAXvZYJ5JembleJzfWBLL0ox
KKvK+IMaUCOJRznJwoBIRPuE7MN7DrbC8+142iSGDoSloCPnQnZfKERwpVFMFES
UOGTj2gNE9t2WHXcgfUZhu5b
=BAu9
—END PGP SIGNATURE—
A-096
$280.76
EXHIBIT B
■
iJSat - 7)F** B**«<A»c*cnkBc*d^iiw«ft»Wu«ll/V2tn» U«V3QI7
|P«»»
iMs/an '.»** «a
isasKMGKwMtEsaval
(
ooflo
i
ansi
A-097
■> Usm * ^Hter Bar* tfdfl*c4a*Xc*dVdA, WM2D1VH/B72D17
fAzreo
I Date
CHK7IS
8/15/2013 BMkdAsauctedlcadWte
Pwied
r | PayeeA4a^o^«eQer>/T««Mtei
cyy,".
IStteii Iftataart
________
7180
KCI42M ame/ayaa
!un«
lOepaai
—
|
-r*
2isa
Mi
owns
Rated
CHS 712
1/15/2013 lafAdAnwMtt«dtc«ldV<te
ace R42S4 2348 2m5?94
Bit
S/1VM13 lankdAnaricaciadicatdVUa
«e 14264294028* 5784
Ui
R
72W
W
XS2
■251.W
KB
•TO»
2B29
«...
CHKG55
Pwwa
5/W2W3
CM CM
RrteU
yiS^CIJ “--‘I r' n-B~---irf ~TaT*--
CM€82
2/1V2OU B** dai—ii. ywfc
Vrta
oatfl cad »«wt lor Goa^ w«14284 2M8 SO* STM
Mi
1M
4/|5f2W1 finl rtf Hi mrjriMI c>J‘*iW
cw9 c«d MRMrt tai 42M 29(8 2915 S956 ScrnwiSttml CO«Ot
450 50
P*W!
acc«42S4 2M 28295784
S*
otdl cadMnaa I® MmavnmtfiMZSlSBnSTM
1^14 »
m
A-098
[^r>
■■ ~
--------------------------------------
llirt»r
pw» r
CHK655
fthtsd
£HKM7
RrSHl
CHK645
ftr^
—.......
- • ------------------------ ^5r ’
-------- -wal
IJ
. i. •'/
"?K’P‘#.' I.
!■/ .yX'l-'^.^
»* .m-u*.
ram Mute.tH’
M/2OT2
B«rii9tAtr£fe6»inMtBK«dltLAt
jec.S4«£32Z?«7j65y ftn TtsSahwu
Bi»
4/2S/2OT1 BvfctfAflWKMinuteK«tfQu4
N«rt«c*i •M54£h2ZM7U»59ta TttSdktw
i-...-
1—<-——..
—-- --------- -1
55045.
-X6D
!ffl®
■4g 73
1.CBL0D
4aan
8te
4/1/311
IvAd AnM(i|nwi>ue«dMt
iteMfMA *tt546K222<7iSK3 (t> G49M RiotM
A-099
NirrtB
| Dale
’ |5v*
fw*Kt
l‘6e?
JUfc___________ _
n
CMK671
ftmd
6/1/2912
B«u ej Ar9<6» Madcwtd
Maxatwocc 5*6632224646 2561
Bit
54.95
•132.951
CWl 661
ftrtad
2/1/2012
3«ti d AMrida
MaAacart«ccM66 32224671 6553
Mt
2420
•21715'
CHK 636
Ptrttd
2/i/zni
Barit d fearis* Madatcatd
MwMeM mc 5*90351305533174 natMsatai Mkm WOK
Mr
0900
«!'
A-100
EXHIBIT c
Gary Pisner
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
maria pisner <marlapisner@hotmail.com>
Monday. August 22,2016 12:41 PM
gpisner@aptcs.com
Re: Documents that you requested
Gary,
This email relates to credit card statements, and in no way limits my ability to share any information about other
aspects of the trust. It is also not a signed letter as you indicated, but that's neither here nor there. Finally, I
never received any credit card statements, however 1 have continued to ask forthem. I am requesting again you
send them to me in order to finish the accounting.
Thank you,
Marla
Sent from my iPhone
On Aug 22,2016, at 11:00 AM, Gary Pisner <goisner@aDtcs.com> wrote:
You asked me to forward the agreement to you RE my credit card statements (see communications
below from July 2010.
From: maria pisner rmailto:marlapisner<a>hotmail.com1
Sent: Thursday, July 15, 2010 11:28 AM
To: gary pisner
Subject:
I would rather not have to wait a few weeks, so please send all the bank statements an credit card
statements to me in the next few days so I can review them before our meeting.
I agree to keep your credit card documents confidential, not share them with anyone, and destroy them
when you request me to do so.
I don't want any delays.
From: Gary Pisner fmalltoiaDisnerOaotcs.coml
Sent: Wednesday, July 14, 2010 10:14 AM
To: marlaoisner<aihotmail.com
Subject: Documents that you requested
Marla,
I am putting together the documents related to the expenditures of the trust, for your review, as you
requested.
1
A-101
I
)
'
'
■ There is, however, a problem in my turning over my credit card documents: Most of the information
that they contains has nothing to do with this trust audit that you requested.
I can either take a few weeks of redact most of the irrelevant entries, from around 200 pages, or you can
agree to keep my credit card documents confidential, not share them with anyone, and destroy them
when I request you to do so.
Most of the content of my credit card statements are none of your business and that concerns me.
You can understand my concern.
Gary
ReadNotifv.com E-mail Posting-Time Digital Certificate. The above e-mail arrived from qpisner@aptcs.com. was
assigned sequence number #30788464 and ReadNotify reference 68ee86eec1898658932036797e9edf73, digitally
signed, and subsequently relayed. NB: This certificate irrevocably links the body and headers of this email to the date and
time they were sent. The following signature is now published online; to view it, verify it, or for more Information, please
visit www.ReadNotlfv.com.
—BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE—
Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (ReadNotifv.com TimeStamp Server v2.2)
Comment: Certificate #30788464, created Mon, 22 Aug 2016 15:00:36 GMT
iQBvAwUBV7sTIDanThAdit3tAQGp3wLPfsY3fYQBaAXvZYJ5jembleJzfWBLL0ox
KKvK+IMaUCOJRznJwoBIRPuE7MN7DrbC8+142ISGDoSloCPnQnZfKERwpVFMFES
UOGTj2gNE9t2WHXcgfUZhu5b
=BAu9
-—-END PGP SIGNATURE—
2
A-102
EXHIBIT I)
Gary Pisner
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
maria pisner <mar1aplsner@hotmail.com>
Tuesday, November 05, 2013 8:04 PM
<gpisner@aptcs.com>
Re: [1] BB & T Checks
1 contacted the heating company they only work in Va., they do not work in de or baltimore. Why was a check
written to them , gary don't write any checks out this account without consulting me. By you not sending the
credit card statements it raises suspicious behavior., The so called mistakes makes me think that the trust
account was grossly mishandled, every cent must be trust related!
Sent from my iPhone
On Nov 5,2013, at 7:46 PM, "Gary Pisner" <checked@aptcs.com> wrote:
Hi Marla,
I checked --the check that was a reimbursement check had nothing to do with Derek.
The software will migrate the memo text from the prior use of the Payee. That Is what happened. To
change the memo line one has to delete the existing memo line and place a new memo line. I know that
this had nothing to do with Derek because there were no deposits in Derek's account during that period
of time and there were no amounts deposited in Derek's account in February, March or April. There
were no other anomalies in the checks in the trust account. The small amounts of cash withdrawals
were payments to Baltimore neighbors to take care of the properties. The large sums of cash
withdrawals coincide with payments to the City of Baltimore made necessary by the fact that, because
of the tax lean, we could only pay utility bills in cash and of course at times I had to withdraw very large
sums to pay tax liens.
Please review the highlighted language in the trust document (see attachment) for reimbursement for
expenses. I get the feeling that you have forgotten the language in Paragraph 9 of the Trust document.
I have to take time to redact irrelevant entries. As I also told you, that exercise is a low priority: my todo list is massive. Moreover, I had to, unnecessarily, divert my attention and time for the taxes, at your
insistence.
From: maria pisner rmallto:marlaoisner<aihotmall.com1
Sent: Tuesday, November 05, 2013 3:31 PM
To: gary pisner
Subject: FW: BB & T Checks
Hi Gary.
I scanned the canceled checks from the the trust account, as you can see there is a payment for
Derricks books, and credit card payments every month. There is a check written out to A&T
heating out of Chantilly Va they have not worked on our DC properties., Please send the credit
card statements that were paid out of the trust, account, Please tell me what the $360
check was written for on 1/10/2013. BB&T are sending all pass statements to me with canceled
checks for my review
i
A-103
EXHIBIT E
Gary Pisner
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
maria pisner <marlapisner@hotmail.com>
Friday, July 15, 2016 10:30 PM
gpisner@aptcs.cxim
Re: Email from yesterday morning to you 7th request READ THESE E-MAILSI
Check your email email I responded! Il I!
Awhile agollltl!!
Sent from my iPhone
On Jul 15, 2016, at 8:17 PM, Gary Pisner <eoisner(aiaptcs.com> wrote:
I am on my 7°’ attempt to get a written response from you.
From: Gary Pisner fmailto:qplsner@aptcs.coml
Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2016 7:24 PM
To: 'marlaplsner@hotmail.com.readnotllv.com'
Subject: FW: Email from yesterday morning to you 6th request READ THESE E-MAILSI!
I am on my 6'11 attempt to get a written response from you.
From: Gary Pisner [mailtoiflrasner@aptcs.coml
Sent: Friday, July 08, 2016 8:16 AM
To: 'marlaplsner@hotmall.com.readnotifv.com'
Subject: FW: Email from yesterday morning to you 5th request READ THESE E-MAILSI!
Read your E-mails!!
Also read below from my E-mail re your calls to Skype.
From: Gary Pisner I mailto:oolsner@aptcs.coml
Sent: Wednesday, July 06, 2016 5:36 PM
To: 'mariaolsner@hotmail.com.readnotifv.com'
Subject; FW: Email from yesterday morning to you 3rd request
Please respond.
From: Gary Pisner fmailto:gplsner@aptcs.coml
Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2016 6:57 PM
To: 'marlaoisner@hotmail.com.readnotifv.com'
Subject: FW: Email from yesterday morning to you
I see that you tried to contact me on my Skype number multiple times, but what I have told you multiple
times, for almost a year, is that Skype only works when I am on the internet; therefore, I have told you
not to use my Skype number, if you are in a hurry.
if you want to get in touch with me, given that I will be In court much of the week, please respond to my
E-mail.
I repeat - Skype only works when I am on the internet!
t
A-104
Respond to my E-mail.
From: Gary Pisner fmailto:aDisner@aotcs.com1
Sent: Sunday, July 03, 2016 7:06 PM
To: 'maria pisner1
Subject: RE: Email from yesterday morning to you
From: maria pisner fmailto:marlaoisner@hotmail.com1
Sent: Thursday, June 30,2016 11:12 PM
To: <ooisner@aDtcs.com >
Subject: Fwd: Email from yesterday morning to you
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: maria pisner <marlapisner@hotmail.com>
Date: June 24, 2016 at 8:27:29 PM EDT
To: "gpisner@aptcs.com" <gpisner@aptcs.com>
Subject: Re: Email from yesterday morning to you
Hi Gary,
I think, at the time we were attempting to have Oliver
move, we generally were thinking we would be selling
the property at some point.
[Gary Pisner]
Absolutely not, I have written communications between the two of us were we
agreed to put Gorman on the market Immediately after we got Oliver out —
communications that I absolutely relied on in my decisions.
The bottom line here is that we agreed to put the property on the market
immediately after we got Oliver out. Even more, this was part of a written
agreement, to end our bickering, that we had before we even approached
Oliver to get her out so that we could sell Gorman ASAP, set up an
arrangement for Georgia Avenue and Mt Pleasant where the property was
split up 50/50 in new deeds, and to setup a system where the proceeds of the
rent of Georgia Ave would be distributed 50/50 to each of us.
You said it and I said it, we cannot work together under the present trust
agreement. I see a trust and I follow that trust agreement and you see
everything in terms 50/50 ownership of some assets: I have example after
example of how this has come up over and over again and your position Is
2
A-105
Incompatible with the present legal reality, which you have complained about
- again and again; therefore thing needed to change.
As for the Gorman offer that was sent to you and your attempt to hold up the
sale of the property, which Is, as we have established, contrary to the wishes
of the trust, l.e., there was a unanimous agreement by both trustees and I do
not approve of resending that agreement. Based In this, any losses due to your
holdup could make you personally liable for the losses to the trust: Do you
actually want to be put in that situation?
Let me address you holding up of the sale because you want to use the
property, in what you believe Is a way offorcing a new accounting of the trust
assets past and present.
Ignoring your potential personal liability for blocking things, let's look at the
facts:
•
•
•
First, we have an offer on the table that a real-estate agent,
Dion, who you have refused to talk to and who knows the
area, has indicated is a great deal.
Next, we have a property that is loaded with peeling lead
paint, which, as you know, is a read negative for
appraisers. Anyone attempting to get a loan to purchase the
property, with all that peeling lead paint, will result In a fire
sale appraisal: We all know this. Dion knows, I know it, the
potential buyer knows it, and unless you are living In an
alternative universe, you know this. What we have Is a
onetime way to deal with this Issue. The person who put in
the proposal, is a general contractor that wants to live in the
Gorman house. What he will do Is fix up the place, including
the peeling lead paint and clean up the place so the property
will appraise to the $170,000 rather than the 130,000, without
the trust paying for the cleanup. We are not going to get that
$170,000, unless we take the offer that is on the table or if we
put $10,000 into fixing up the place: l/Ve are talking about
$40,000 potential loss due to your actions, which you could
personally liable for. The bottom line is that, If we lose this
offer, the trust is going to lose a great deal of money: That is
stupid!
Next, let's address this whole concept that you have to buck
the wishes of the trust to get your accounting. What is so
inexplicable about this is that, simple reasoning wilt tell you
that the property is irrelevant to you're the accounting issue,
because if we take the offer, the distribution of the proceeds of
the sale can be held until Issues are resolved. In this way we
will not be losing money in property tax payments, which we
already have; losing money in utility payments, which we
already have; and risking treble penalties, in property tax
when the city finds out that Gorman is Vacant. In summary,
because of your actions, the trust is having its money flushed
down to toilet.
3
A-106
•
On the other hand, if the property is sold, no more property
taxes, no more utilities, and we may even get some interest, In
a deposit account, while we sort through the distribution
issues and the payback of the loan that I made to the trust and
that is why you behavior Is difficult to comprehend: Even if you
ignore your breach of your fiduciary duty as a Trustee, if there
is a distribution Issue, it Is financially Irrational to the point
where one could conclude that you are acting in bad faith and
in breach of your fiduciary duty as a trustee. In holding up the
sale.
As for the accounting, let's review a history of the trust's accounting:
•
•
•
First, prior to our accounting in Belair Maryland, contrary to
latest erroneous assertions that you did not receive any
statements, bank material and my credit card statements, I
have E-mails that support what I have repeated to you over
and over again, i.e., you got and we reviewed everything at
our Belair meeting.
Next, at the Belair meeting, you indicated that you were
taking over the management of the trust and pursuant to your
volunteering (demand)to do the management of the trust, all
statements of the banks were, thereafter, mailed to you and
not me, so for a long period, you received the statements, not
me.
Next, as for the Belair material, in exchange for
turning over my credit card statements, we entered
Into a confidentiality agreement where you agreed to
not distribute the credit card documents to
anyone. Regrettably, you later Informed me that you
sent all the material to Bob Lyons (without my
permission and in breach of our agreement), which I
confirmed that you did (I called his office) and
complained to you. Moreover, you also claimed that
you turned over the documents to your children and to
Gerry, which Is also a breach of our agreement. So we
know where the Belair documents, which you now
claim that you never got, went to. One would presume
that you were smart enough to make copies, before
you sent everything to Bob, so those documents should
be somewhere in your house. As for Bob's copy, when
you asked for the new accounting, I called Bob and he
told me that all the trust records had been purged,
because of the lapse of time and because Bob had sold
the accounting firm. You can call Bob to confirm
this. Given that you had copies and you walked away
with both your copy, with notes and my copy, with
notes I do not have copies and because of the lapse of
time, I don't have any economical and comprehensive
way of recreating those Belair documents; as I told you
before, you need to find your copies.
4
A-107
•
Next, as I said, everything from the banks were sent to
your Cherry Hill address Immediately after your
request, In Belair. So post Belair, anything from the
bank went to you, until I received calls from a lawyers
and agents representing the companies that had put a
statuary leans on one of our Baltimore properties.
Since you were supposedly running things, I contacted
you and you told me that you had failed to renew the
mall forwarding for Douglas Ave., that, although you
had said that you had changed the mailing addresses
for the Baltimore properties, you had not, and that you
were having problems with your Cherry Hill mail, we
agreed that everything (except stocks) would, in the
future, be sent to me, but as for the statements from
the bank, I choose to use the online system to follow
the accounts, rather than paper statements and your
also indicated that you would do the same: I even have
written communications from you questioning certain
entries on the statements, which I explained to you.
So, as I have told you over and over again in many Emails, I do not have a single statement or a single
cancelled check; everything that I have access to you
have access to and based on your E-mails you have the
same access; therefore, holding up things to get me to
turn over cancelled check, which I have told you, over
and over again, that I don't have, is, if you are actually
listening, a little crazy to me. You have been a trustee
with full access to the banks from the start. You could
and still can go online and do your own accounting
and, as I said. If there are questions, I would be more
than happy to answer them.
In summary:
•
•
•
•
We need to take the offer that is on the table before this guy
throws in the towel (he Is almost there) and the trust is fucked and
you are liable.
Since December, the trust has paid around $2,000 because of your
6 month stalling; don't you think that is enough waste?
You need to go online and do the audit using the online resources:
You are mature enough to do this without me spoon-feeding thing
to you.
You need to find your copy of the Belair Panera material that you
walked away with (assuming that you made a copy before you
sent the stuff to Lyons) along with the paper statements that you
received after: Demanding documents that I do not have is,
obviously, not going to produce any results, no matter what kind
of arm twisting that you do. You have had 6 months to do the
audit and I will bet you that you have not done anything.
5
A-108
n
I don't think I've either misrepresented my
conversations to Oliver or have necessarily changed my
mind. I am not opposed to ever selling Gorman street. I
instead logically assumed that prior to us taking any
action to sell the property that any discrepancies in the
trust would be cleared up and we would have a up to
date accounting. Since no accounting has
been completed and there remains discrepancies, I think
it would be harmful to the trust to sell a trust asset.
I also do no recall having to convince you of anything
nor having a "questionable position". It was my
understanding that we were both on the same page and
that if we ever wanted to move the property to sale, it
needed to be vacated as a first step. I was unaware
would you be resistant to clearing up the
numerous discrepancies in the trust and therefore could
not have foreseen that this would take an extended
period of time.
In regard to the accounting of the trust, I am not asking
you to perform the accounting for me, I have no issue
taking lead on it. The issue, which I have expressed to
you before, is that my files are incomplete. I have had
access to aprox. the first 2 and 1/2 years of an
accounting of the trust, including canceled checks, I
also have the information for the 2014, 2015, 2016.
However do not have the complete file on BB&T for
2011,2012, and 2013. You are correct, I did have
access to the online system, however the online
6
A-109
statements did not reflected canceled checks, which is
necessary information to complete an accounting. I
went over to the bank, hopeful they could provide
clarity to this and they told me that,unfortunately, your
address was the only one listed between the years of
2009 to present. The only way I am able to see
the canceled checks now is that technology has updated
to allow me to see canceled checks for the past 6
months. Therefore the accounting can't actually
be completed until I have the documents from those
years which are in your possession and not mine. The
bank wants to charge the Trust $3,700 for all canceled
checks, however I think it would be preferable to spare
the expense to the Trust if you can simply provide it to
me. Furthermore my current accounting information
reflects that distributions were not equal, which is a
breach of the trust agreement. This is one of the reasons
an accounting is necessary, if such a breach did occur, it
should be remedied as quickly as possible. I feel that
such an accounting is an important aspect of trust
management and believe it should be completed before
there is liquidation of assets of the trust. I look forward
to us resolving this together.
Thank you for asking about Jeremy, it was a
malignant melanoma. The prognosis seems good, as
they caught it early. We are hopeful they removed it
all.
Marla
On Jun 23, 2016, at 10:30 AM, Gary Pisner <gDisner@aotcs.com> wrote:
7
A-110
Record Extract
(r
Rec. Extract 000094
(\)6.) RE: [1]
Property tax Gorman rule 408 communication
F)(A]Dr-l nd ,.
Gary Pisner <gpisner@aptcs.com>
Thu 6/15/2017 9:01AM
To:'marla pisner' <marlapisner@hotmail.com>;
Marla,
Let me address your comments
From: maria pisner [mailto:marlapisneng/hotmall.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 15, 2017 8:01AM
To: gary pisner
Subject: Property tax Gorman
Gary,
I believe in order to avoid the tax sale list the deadline to pay a portion of the property tax was May 31,
[Gary Pisner]
That was In the tax document that I sent you. As usual, you did absolutely nothing to fix the mess you created. I have to do it. I
Contacted the tax office upon your initial refusal to pay the tax..
[Gary Pisner]
Nothing in the trust documents or In trust law forces me to give loans to the trust or to prop up the trust with my own money
and I am not required to cover your debts, nor and I required to pay for your maleficence.
You made up this alleged duty. Where were you when I had to lend my own money to bail out the Baltimore properties - you
did not pay a cent? What a hypocrite.
I will make a phone call today,
[Gary Pisner]
I made those phone calls before May 31, because knowing you, you don't pay for your mistakes and maleficence, in the end, I
usually do.
This is what they told me:
The list for the tax sale is compiled on the June 15-and the and the sale itself takes place on July 15.
Yesterday 1 dumped over $1,400.00 In the account of my own money, Just In case Howard the Georgia Avenue tenant didn't
come through with thefull amount. He paid me part nfhie rent nt midnight -yes - I met him at a parking lot last night at
midnight He paid, me in cash, but he is short. Why do I have to do this? You violated your fiduciary duty, you engaging in selfdealingfor your own enrichment.
If I received accurate info from the De Property tax office, I am requesting that no distributions be taken until all tax
obligations have been paid.
[Gary Pisner]
You do not have that option. You have a major con flict of Interest at this point and, if my recollection is correct, you don't
have a vote on the matter.
Once I pay the $2,200 today the property will not be subject to a tax sale.
As for what comes next, I will sort out this mess that you have created, and, if necessary take legal action against you regarding
the Gorman Street property. That appears to be the only way to deal with you.
A-lll
From: Gary Pisner rmailto:gDisner@aDtcs.coml
Sent: Wednesday, June 22, 2016 11:19 AM
To: 'maria pisner*
Subject: RE: Offer for sale (2nd request)
Let us for the moment, ignore the fact that in selling your payoff of
Oliver, without repairing the property (this resulted in the Trust being
sanctioned by the court), you stated both verbally and in writing that
the object of your position was to get the Gorman Street property on
the market immediately and sell it and largely because of this I finally
backed what I considered to be your questionable position, it is clear
that the you and I had a clear agreement that Gorman Street would be
put on the market after Oliver moved out. Indeed I relied on your
statement that you (we) would put Gorman on the market after Oliver
moved out. Now, it appears that one of two things have happened,
either the whole pitch that you made was false or that you changed
your mind. Can I assume that you changed your mind after we
approved the Oliver agreement? I am not certain that I understand
when and why you reversed your original position. Could you please
explain because I definitely do not understand your reversal on the sale
of Gorman?
Next, I am sorry to hear about Jeremy.
I am not quite certain how much I should be concerned about your
statement that he was having surgery for melanoma. Are you saying
that someone is removing a colored blemish on his skin, which will be
biopsied or are saying that a colored blemish was already biopsied and
was found to be cancerous? Of course I and many people have had
colored blemishes removed, but there was no cancer. There is a big
difference between the two possible interpretations.
Next, I have been concerned about your health for quite some
time. Are you having any health problems?
Finally, as I have stated repeatedly, I have no problem with you
reviewing the account of the trust, but as I stated in my text to you in
May 11, " As for an accounting, you have access to the same accounts
that I have" "As for helping you ... As I told you before, I am available to
answer any questions that you have." What I will not do is do all the
work that you are perfectly capable of doing yourself, especially
because this is your thing and not mine; moreover, you have told me on
numerous occasions that you were regularly reviewing the BB&T
account online, so you obviously know how to use it. Given how much
time has passed, I assume that you are close to completion - is this
correct and do you have any questions?
From: maria pisner fmallto:marlaDlsner@hotmail.coml
Sent: Tuesday, June 21, 2016 5:03 PM
To: aDisner@aDtcs.com
Subject: Re: Offer for sale (2nd request)
8
A-112
Hi Gary, thank you for sending me this proposal. As we have discussed
previously, I am not currently interested in selling the property. Prior to
us moving forward with any transactions regarding the trust I a
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.