Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Joe Holbert, Petitioner v. Thompson Industrial Service, L.L.C., et al.
Supreme Court briefMar 16, 2026
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
26-5448
FILED
MAR 1 6 2026
^.Q’Q
No.
ORIGINAL3
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
SUPREME COURT, U.S.
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
— PETITIONER
(Your Name)-
vs.
— RESPOND
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
Qjf
(NAME OF COURT THAT LAST RULED ON MERITS OF YOUR CASE)
-
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
(Your Name)
IaW'
(Address)
(Phone Number)
>0
^OoJ^
_
QUESTION(S) PRESENTED
1. Whether the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals erred by applying a heightened standard to a
Title VII discrimination claim which was in direct conflict with the June 2025 decision in
Ames v Ohio Department of Youth Services, No. 23-1039, 605 U.S.
(2025), which held
that the “Any individual” language of 42 U.S.C. § 2000e2(A)(l) prohibited the
implementation of evidentiary hurdles.
2. Whether a pro se litigant’s Title VII complaint, which alleges specific instances of racial
slurs and sexual harassment meets the plausibility requirements of Ashcroft v Iqbal No.,
556 U.S., 662 (2009), when the lower courts failed to liberally construe the pleading as
required for self-represented parties.
LIST OF PARTIES
Thompson Industrial Services, LLC
Clean Harbors Environmental (NYSE: CLH)
Steel Dynamics, Incorporated, Sinton Division (NYSE: STLD)
Louis Garcia
Michael Pena
James Cabler
Ernest Mungia
George Gomez
David Wiggins
Montana Wiggins
Matthew Last Name Unknown (LNU)
RELATED CASES
Trial court docket Holbert v. Thompson Industrial Services, LLC et al.. No: 2:24-cv-00068 U.S.
District Court for the Southern District of Texas
Appellate Court Docket for Holbert v. Thompson Industrial Services, LLC et al.. No: 25-40GC8
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.
II. TABLE OF CONTENTS
I.
QUESTION(S) PRESENTED................................................................. i
II.
TABLE OF CONTENTS........................................................................ ii
III. TABLE OF AUTHORITIES...........................
iii
IV. PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI..............................................1
V.
OPINIONS BELOW................................................................................ 1
VI. JURISDICTION....................................................................................... 1
VII. CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED.. 1
VIII. STATEMENT OF THE CASE............................................................. 2- 7
IX. REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT....................................... 7-10
X.
CONCLUSION....................................................................................... 10
XI. APPENDIX............................................................................................. 11
INDEX TO APPENDICES
APPENDIX A — U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Right
to Sue Letter (April 26, 2024)
APPENDIX B — District Court Civil Complaint/Texas Workforce
Commission Charge of Discrimination (January 9, 2025)
APPENDIX C — District Court Complaint (March 13, 2024)
APPENDIX D — District Court Amended Complaint (April 26, 2024)
APPENDIX E — District Court Subpoena to Produce Evidence (July 24, 2024)
APPENDIX F — District court order (September 19, 2024)
APPENDIX G — District Court order to Dismiss (August 27, 2024)
APPENDIX H — District Court Order Adopting Memorandum
and Recommendation (December 11, 2024)
APPENDIX I — Court of Appeals opinion (March 26, 2025)
APPENDIX J — Order of District Court of Appeals denying rehearing
ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED
CASES
1. Supreme Court: Ames v Ohio Department of Youth Services, 605 U.S. (2025)......... 7, 8, 9,
10
2. Supreme Court: Ashcroft v Iqbal, 556 U.S., 662 (2009)............................................ 8,
3. Supreme Court, Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. (2024)................ 10
4. United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York: Prichard v. Long Island
University, N. 24-CV 1135, New York (2025)............................................................. 9,10
STATUTES AND RULES
1. 28 U.S.C. § 1254(i) - Certiorari
2. 42 U.S.C. § 2000e - 2A(1) Title VIII Discrimination...................................... 7, 8, 9
3. 42 U.S.C. § 2000e - 5FI Title VII - 180-day mandate
OTHER
1. None
iii
I.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Joe Holbert, the Plaintiff, acting on his own behalf as a Pro Se litigant, respectfully petitions
this court for a writ of certiorari to review the judgment of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals’
decision.
II.
OPINIONS BELOW
The decision of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals denying Mr. Holbert’s direct appeal is
reported in docket number 44-1. The Court of Appeals denied Mr. Holbert ’petition for hearing
on November 24, 2025. The finding is attached at Appendix J.
(RN) JURISDICTION
Mr. Holbert’s petition for hearing to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals was denied
on November 24, 2025. Mr. Holbert invokes this Court’s jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1257,
having timely filed this petition for a writ of certiorari within ninety days of the Fifth Circuit Court
of Appeal’s judgment.
(RN) STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (codified at 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2)
It shall be an unlawful employment practice for an employer (1) to fail or refuse to hire or
to discharge any individual or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to his
compensation, terms conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individuals’ race,
color, religion, sex or national origin, or (2) to limit, segregate, or classify his employees or
applicants for employment in any way which would deprive or tend to deprive any individual of
employment opportunities or otherwise adversely affect his status as an employee, because of such
individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.
1
(RN) STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On January 5, 2023, Joe Halbert (also spelled Holbert), began work as a technician with
Thompson Industrial Services, LLC (Thompson). At the time that Halbert worked for Thompson,
the company was not owned by Clean Harbors Industrial Service (Clean Harbor). Clean Harbor
purchased Thompson in May of 2023. Clean Harbors headquarters is at located at 42 Longwater
Drive, Norwell, Massachusetts 02061, (781) 792-5000.
In 2023, Thompson held a contract with Steele Dynamic in Sinton, Texas, regarding
providing environmental cleanup services.
Halbert asserts that on January 5, 2023, a fellow coworker, Ernest Mungia (Mungia),
created a toxic work environment by engaging in sexually harassing behaviors and demeaning
language aimed at Halbert because of the Plaintiff’s affiliation with a protected group, African
American individuals. Specifically, Halbert asserts Mungia’s unwanted sexual advances included
slapping him on the behind which produced feelings of shame, embarrassment, and humiliation.
Halbert’s degradation was witnessed by fellow co-workers: George Gomez (Gomez), Matthew
Solice (Solice), Efrain Hemandaz (Hernandez) Last Name Unknown (LNU), Jordan LNU, and
Chris Yanchuniz (Yanchuniz). At the time of the slapping, Halbert turned to Mungia and gave him
a look indicating he was not receptive to that sort of behavior. Moreover, Halbert believes the slap
was designed to degrade him both sexually and because of his race and national origin. To
exacerbate the issue, Mungia was designated as Halbert’s team leader meaning that Mungia’s order
were to be followed as per management protocols.
2
On a weekly basis from January 5, through August 16, 2023, Halbert reported that Mungia
sexually and racially harassed him. The frequency of the harassment occurred at least once per
month. One such occurrence resulted in Mungia requested to see the Plaintiff’s penis. Mungia
explained to Halbert that he had heard a rumor that black men were endowed with large penises,
and he wanted to know if it was true. The harassment did not stop at the request to see the
Plaintiffs penis. Mangia also made sexual comments indicating Halbert had a nice ass or that he
was fine.
Mungia’s advances scared Halbert. The Plaintiff had limited schooling which caused him
to believe that Mungia had the authority to make such requests of him especially since he had
received previous instructions from other members of management who indicated that Mungia
was his superior and his orders were to be followed. Additionally, the company did not provide
Halbert with sexual harassment training during his onboarding process; therefore, he was unaware
of his rights and available courses of actions.
Mungia’s advances often occurred in the presence of Halbert’s coworkers, but no one came
to his aid or told Mungia to desist. After each instance, Halbert told Mungia his advances were
not welcome. On one instance, Halbert specifically told Mungia to refrain from discussing “dicks”
in his presence to which Mungia responded that the Plaintiffs dick was not big enough to be a
black man’s.
Mungia was not the only member of management who sexually harassed Halbert. James
Cabler, an operational manager for Thompson, also joined Mungia in the harassment. Cabler and
Mungia were brothers-in-law, which Halbert learned three months after starting work at
Thompson’s. It is Halbert’s belief that Mungia told Cabler that the Plaintiff was disobedient and
disrespectful while performing his job duties. Moreover, Halbert asserts Mungia’s false statements
3
regarding his work abilities and attitude were retaliation for rejecting Mungia’s unwanted sexual
advances.
In the Thompson management hierarchy, Mungia was a team leader whose direct
supervisor was Michael Pena (Pena), the site supervisor. The highest-ranking site supervisor was
David Wiggins, the project manager. As an operational manager, James Cabler reported directly
to Wiggins and was the direct supervisor over Pena. The rest of Halbert’s crew, including the
Plaintiff, were designated as technicians and drivers and reported directly to Mungia.
Mungia’s harassment was not just sexual in nature. He also frequently made jokes
regarding Halbert’s race/color/national origin. On one specific occasion Mungia said, “smile, I
can’t see you. Why are you so black?” Halbert stated during his employment with Thompson’s
Mungia made several statements along a similar line.
Other members of the management hierarchy also harassed Halbert based on his race. On
or about March 15, 2023, Halbert his coworkers advised Pena that Thompson had not provided
him and his fellow co-worders with the proper PPE gear to complete an environmental cleanup
job with Steel Dynamic. When Halbert addressed the issue with Pena, Pena told Halbert, “fuck
you ni**er, meet me in the parking lot.” Halbert stated he ignored the comment and continued to
work; however, he was concerned about his safety. The Plaintiff indicated this incident was
recorded by work truck video and audio cameras in Bay 16 of Steel Dynamic and was also
observed by Hernandez and Solice.
Another incident occurred on June 7, 2023, while Halbert, Mungia, and Montana Wiggins
(David Wiggins son) were headed to a safety training in a company truck. Halbert sat in the
backseat smoking a cigarette. He requested that Mungia roll down his window because the
4
cigarette smoke was building up in the truck. Mungia reportedly responded saying, “Fuck you,”
along with variety of other inappropriate slurs and words. Mungia did not roll down the window.
Halbert then opened the back truck door while the vehicle while the vehicle was in motion. This
episode was captured on video with audio.
In or around June 2023, Halbert’s crew worked on a shutdown of the Steele Dynamic plant
in order to clean the interior of the plant and ensure the environmental safety of the facility.
Thompson sent another crew from LaPorte, Texas, to assist with the shutdown. The LaPorte, Texas
crew consisted of crew contained members who identified as African American men and African
American women.
After meeting the crews met, Halbert overheard Mungia state, “(those) Black ni**er girls
don’t do nothing...they are lazy...and they just want to sit down.” The following day, Mungia
told the LaPorte crew that the job ended and to return to LaPorte. Once the LaPorte crew left,
Mungia told the Plaintiff that “those nig***s didn’t want to work.”
Halbert advised that Mungia frequently used the ni**er word which made the Plaintiff very
uncomfortable. This episode was on video with audio. Further, he believes Mungia’s use of the
racial slur indicates Mungia’s bias and discrimination toward African American individuals.
Halbert advised that Mungia was Hispanic.
On August 16, 2023, Mungia drove a work truck containing Halbert and Luis Garcia
(Garcia). Garcia warned Mungia about an approaching vehicle. Mungia responded by saying,
“fuck that car and that ni***er.”
While saying this, Mungia looked into the rearview mirror
directly at Halbert leading Halbert to believe Mungia was calling him a ni***er. Because this
occurred in the work truck, there was audio/video of this incidence.
5
At the end of the workday on August 16, Pena advised Halbert the company did not have
any work for him the following day; however, the Plaintiff was welcome to call in and see if that
changed the following morning.
Halbert then texted Kenny LNU, the manager of the LaPorte
crew, to see if he could take a few days off to return to Mississippi to visit his mother and ill uncle.
Halbert never received a response back from Kenny.
Two hours later, Garcia texted Halbert and asked if the Plaintiff was working the following
day. Halbert advised Garcia that company did not have any work available. Garcia then told
Halbert that he had work with Thompson the next day. Eventually, Halbert came to learn that he
was the only person who was told not to report to work the next day. The rest of his crew had
work. After learning this, Halbert contacted Kenny and D Wiggins. Halbert advised men that
Mungia had called him a ni**er earlier that day.
On August 17, 2023, Halbert reported to the local unemployment office to sign up for
benefits, because he believed he had been fired from Thompson Industrial. Later, Halbert learned
that representatives from Thompson Industrial told the Texas Workforce Commission that Halbert
had been terminated because he was unable to perform work tasks. Halbert contends this in an
unfair assertion on behalf of Thompson Industrial. Based on the information presented by both
parties, the Texas Workforce Commission granted unemployment benefits to Halbert.
Because of the, Holbert contends that his employer Thompson Industrial and their
subsequent owners Clean Harbors retaliated against him for reporting a hostile work environment
based upon his gender and race, in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Chapter
21 of the Texas Labor Code.
6
The Plaintiff believes that his employer lied about the reasons for firing him, thus meeting
and proving a pretext to his termination. Specifically, his employer lied to the Texas Workforce
Commission as a larger part of a pattern of fraud. The falsehood thereby creates a genuine dispute
concerning the material facts of his termination which should have prevented the lower courts from
dismissing the case.
The Plaintiff argues that discovery materials, including video and company emails, must
be subpoenaed to prove that the information provided by David Wiggins and the Thompson
Industrial Service supervisors to the Texas Work Force Commission was false. Holbert contends
that the false information was provided in bad faith by Thompson Industrial Services and their acts
of bad faith are key elements in overcoming certain contract defenses for David Wiggins and
Thompson Industrial Service in regards to Holbert being terminated for not being able to do the
job.
On December 29, 2023, Holbert received a Notice of Right to Sue letter from the Equal
Employment Opportunity Office. A copy of the letter was filed along with a Complaint under case
number 2:4-cv-00068 in the Southern District of Texas, Corpus Christi division, on March 13,
2024. In the Compliant, Halbert alleged Thompson Industrial Services, LLC, caused a hostile
work environment based on his race, color, and gender beginning on January 5, 2023, and ending
on August 16, 2023, with his termination. The Plaintiff specifically indicated he was verbally
abused by his superiors which included racial slurs such as being called a ni**er and was sexually
assaulted. The plaintiff requested compensation for lost wages and punitive damages, because the
company lied about Halbert’s work abilities in order to fire him which made his daily living
situation a hardship. Further the Plaintiff sought additional relief including injunctions, damages,
costs and attorney fees.
7
On April 3, 2024, a status hearing was conducted during which the plaintiff was granted
30-day extension to file an Amended Complaint.
On April 26, 2024, an Amended Complaint was filed.
On September 19, 2024, the Plaintiffs case was denied with prejudice.
On December 11, 2024, a Motion to Dismiss the case was granted dismissing it with
prejudice.
On January 8,2025, the Plaintiff filed a Motion to Appeal in the Fifth Circuit Court
of Appeals.
On March 26, 2025, the Plaintiffs Notice of Appeal was denied.
November 24, 2025, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal, via a hearing en banc, affirmed its
pervious decision to dismiss the Plaintiffs case.
On March 16, 2026, a Writ of Certiorari was filed with the U.S. Supreme Court after the
Plaintiff was granted a 30-day extension.
(RN) REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION
A. To avoid a conflict between the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in Ames v. Ohio
Department of Youth Services and the dismissal of his case in both the Southern District
of Texas and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals pursuant to the U.S. Supreme Court
Rule 10.
InTmes v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, the U.S. Supreme Court (USSC) determined
that all individuals are to be treated the same under the law even if the individual is a member of
a majority group in the United States. The USSC ruled that an individual who is identified as part
of a majority group cannot be held to a higher standard than an individual who is part of minority
8
group when discrimination has been alleged. The Plaintiff believes the Fifth Circuit Court of
Appeal’s dismissal in November 2025 ignored the mandate set by the aforementioned case which
was decided in June 2025.
Specifically, Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services established the Ames Standard
which rejected the idea that there should be a heightened evidentiary hurdle for any individual
regardless of the person’s identified characteristics and provided clarification to the Title VII “any
individual” equally language. The case provides guidance to the lower courts regarding the issue
of discrimination and how it should be addressed equally across all categories of individuals.
The Plaintiff believes that by dismissing his allegations relating to racial slurs and sexual
harassment which were the cause of a hostile work environment at Thompson Industrial it kept
him from being able to effectively state a claim in a lower court. The Plaintiff is pro se and by
effectively imposing the same rigid and non-textual barriers to a pro se litigant as a formal attorney
the discrimination hurdles for some groups that^wes v. Ohio Department of Youth Services sought
to eliminate was ignored. The Plaintiff argues that the lower courts departed from the accepted
course ofjudicial proceedings by failing to liberally construe the application of a longstanding rule
regarding the less stringent standards that are afforded to pro se pleadings; therefore, implementing
heightened evidentiary hurdles which Title VII and Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services
guarantee against.
B. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal’s refusal to consider his late filed Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission (EEOC) letter resulted in the lack of plausibility needed for
an adequate determination of the case.
The Plaintiff’s EEOC letter affirms Holbert’s case possessed enough factual merit thus he
was granted the right to sue his former employer for misconduct. Had the Fifth Circuit Court of
9
Appeals allowed the late filing of this letter, then pursuant to Ashcroft v Iqbal, the plaintiff s case
would have inherently possessed enough plausibility to sustain it. In 2009, the U.S. Supreme Court
decided the landmark case of Ashcroft v Iqbal. The case provided the standard distinguishing
between a “conceivable” and a “plausible” claim.
In essence it required civil cases to possess
more than just statements pertaining to the elements of a claim.
The Plaintiff contends that he would have met the required elements of Ashcroft v Iqbal
had the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals did not hold the screening barriers for pro se litigants to an
unreasonable standard thus undermining the rulings found in Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth
Services. The Plaintiff argues had the lower courts abided by the longstanding rule that pro se
pleadings must be held to a less stringent standard as is appropriate for an individual unable to
obtain legal counsel then his case would not have been dismissed in the two lower courts.
The Plaintiff notes that his case is the perfect case for the U.S. Supreme Court to provide
additional clarification on when the Ames Equal Treatment Principle (AETP) applies by making a
specific ruling that it not only applies at the summary judgment stage but also at the initial pleading
stage. By providing this specific clarification concerning the implementation of the AETP, the
USSG will unite the circuits who have been handling pro se litigant matters differently. In such
an important matter, consistency is needed across the circuits regarding the handling of these cases
which a USSG ruling would provide. Failure to apply the AETP consistently across circuits allows
the Title VII language of “any individual” to be construed loosely by the lower courts, thus
resulting in inconsistent rulings, which is detrimental to the carriage of law. The Plaintiff believes
that judicial procedure should be free of ambiguity across the circuits.
C. The Plaintiff believes that the issuance of the EEOC’s Right to Sue Letter was
premature and is partially the reason why his case was so readily dismissed by the lower
courts.
10
The EEOC is granted a 180-day waiting period to conduct an investigation into allegations
of employer misconduct. Instead of conducting the investigation fully, the EEOC chose to issue a
Right to Sue Letter without a proper investigation, thus a factual basis for the Plaintiff s allegations
the allegations were not produced.
In 2025, the Eastern District of New York (ED/NY) District Court sought to provide
guidance in the issuance of the EEOC’s Right to Sue Letter in Pritchard v. Long Island University.
The district court ruled that the issuance of a premature Right to Sue Letter should result in the
cases dismissal without prejudice thus allowing the Plaintiffs allegations to be returned to the
EEOC so that the investigative process can be finished.
Instead of receiving a dismissal without prejudice, Halbert received a dismissal with
prejudice meaning he could not refile the case. Had the District Court dismissed the case without
prejudice, Halbert would have been able to refile the case essentially providing him with a
procedural reset which is consistent with the ED/NY District Court’s ruling in Pritchard v Long
Island University. Further, the Plaintiff stated that by dismissing his case with prejudice the courts
prevented the EEOC from fulfilling it congressional mandate which included a thorough
investigation of employment discrimination claims. The ED/NY District Court’s decision relied
heavily upon the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in the Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo.
The case decided that courts must use their independent judgment to determine the meaning of
ambiguous statutes, instead of deferring to a federal or state agency’s interpretation.
11
(RN) CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, Mr. Holbert respectfully requests that this Court issue a writ of
certiorari to review the judgment of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.
DATED this 2nd day of May 2026.
Respectfully Submitted,
Joe Holbert
Pro Se Plaintiff
12
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.