Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Evelyn Courtney, Petitioner v. Merit Systems Protection Board
Supreme Court briefDec 9, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 1
Filed: 10/31/2025
NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential.
©niteti States Court of Appeals
for tfje jfeberal Circuit
EVELYN COURTNEY,
Petitioner
v.
MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BOARD,
Respondent
2025-1348
Petition for review of the Merit Systems Protection
Board in No. SF-1221-23-0417-W-1.
Decided: October 31, 2025
Evelyn Courtney, Fresno, CA, pro se.
Karey Lauren Hart, Office of the General Counsel,
United States Merit Systems Protection Board, Washing
ton, DC, for respondent. Also represented by ALLISON JANE
Boyle, Katherine Michelle Smith.
Before Taranto, Stoll, and Cunningham, Circuit
Judges.
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 2
2
Filed: 10/31/2025
COURTNEY V. MSPB
Per Curiam.
Evelyn Courtney petitions for review of a Merit Sys
tems Protection Board (“Board”) final order, which denied
her petition for review and affirmed the administrative
judge’s initial decision dismissing the appeal for lack of ju
risdiction. Courtney v. Dep’t of the Treasury, No. SF-122123-0417-W-l, 2024 WL 4751396, at *1 (M.S.P.B. Nov. 8,
2024) (“Final Order”)- Courtney v. Dep’t of the Treasury,
No. SF-1221-23-0417-W-1, 2023 WL 4999244 (M.S.P.B.
Aug. 2, 2023) (S. App’x 8-28) (“IniiiaZ Decision’").1 For the
reasons discussed below, we affirm.
I.
Background
On March 28, 2022, Ms. Courtney was appointed as a
Tax Examining Technician in the United States Depart
ment of the Treasury, Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”).
Initial Decision at 8; S. App’x 64. The appointment was
subject to a one-year probationary period beginning on the
same date. Initial Decision at 8; S. App’x 64.
On March 2, 2023, Ms. Courtney submitted a griev
ance. Initial Decision at 9; S. App’x 82. Ms. Courtney al
leged that the “(l]ead worker. . . prepares negative
remarks on [her] case messages and provides the most
cryptic of advice” and “withholds vital information so that
[she] cannot perform [her] job duties properly.”
S. App’x 82; Initial Decision at 9. Ms. Courtney also de
scribed her belief that the lead worker was “deliberately
sabotaging [her] work here at the IRS.” S. App’x 82; see
Initial Decision at 9. As a remedy, Ms. Courtney requested
. 1 We refer to the supplemental appendix filed with
the government’s informal response brief, ECF No. 18, as
“S. App’x” throughout this opinion. Citations in this opin
ion are to the version included in the government’s appen
dix.
For example, Initial Decision at 1 is found at
S. App’x 8.
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
COURTNEY v. MSPB
Page: 3
Filed: 10/31/2025
3
that the IRS train her and not “allow managers and leads
to withhold information that is directly relevant to [her] job
duties.” S. App’x 82; see Initial Decision at 9.
Ms. Courtney’s department manager terminated her,
effective March 24, 2023.
Initial Decision at 9;
S. App’x 61—63. On April 18, 2023, Ms. Courtney appealed
to challenge her termination. See Initial Decision at 11.
While her appeal was pending, she filed a complaint with
the Office of Special Counsel (“OSC”), alleging that her ter
mination was in reprisal for filing a grievance on March 2,
2023. Id.-, S. App’x 70-80. OSC concluded that the IRS did
not terminate Ms. Courtney for reprisal. Initial Decision
at 11-12; S. App’x 79-81. On June 2, 2023, the adminis
trative judge dismissed the appeal challenging Ms. Court
ney’s termination based on lack of jurisdiction over a
termination occurring during the probationary period. See
generally Courtney v. Dep’t of the Treasury, No. SF-315H23-0324-1-1, 2023 WL 3793038 (M.S.P.B. June 2, 2023).
However, the administrative judge indicated that
Ms. Courtney could file an Individual Right of Action
(“IRA”) appeal covering any whistleblowing claim after ex
hausting her remedies with OSC. Id.-, see Initial Decision
at 11.
On June 4, 2023, Ms. Courtney filed an IRA appeal
with the Board. S. App’x 98-100. After the IRA appeal
was filed, the Board requested additional information to
determine whether it had jurisdiction over the appeal.
S. App’x 87—96. In response to the “whistleblower jurisdic
tion order,” id., Ms. Courtney repeated allegations that she
previously submitted when she filed her March 2, 2023
grievance. See S. App’x 65—68. Ms. Courtney also made
new disclosures of injury, touching, cursing, and other im
proper conduct from coworkers and supervisors. Initial De
cision at 10—11; S. App’x 65—68.
On August 2, 2023, the administrative judge dismissed
the IRA appeal for lack of jurisdiction. Initial Decision at 1.
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 4
4
Filed: 10/31/2025
COURTNEY v. MSPB
The administrative judge determined that Ms. Courtney
had exhausted her complaint with OSC with respect to the
March 2, 2023 grievance, but not with respect to the new
disclosures and complaints listed in her jurisdictional
statement. Id. at 12. Specifically, the administrative judge
concluded that Ms. Courtney failed to “exhaust [before
OSC] any potential complaints related to her injury or be
ing ‘chased’ by another employee, being touched by a
coworker, or that coworkers cursed at work.” Id. The ad
ministrative judge further found that her March 2, 2023
grievance did not raise protected disclosures or qualify as
protected activity to support Board jurisdiction. Id. at 1213. Ms. Courtney petitioned for review of the initial deci
sion to the Board. Final Order at *1. On November 8,
2024, the Board denied Ms. Courtney’s petition for review
and affirmed the administrative judge’s initial decision dis
missing her IRA appeal for lack of jurisdiction. Id. at *1.
Ms. Courtney timely petitioned for review in this court.
We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(9).
II. Discussion
We will set aside any action, findings, or conclusions of
the Board that are: “(1) arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of
discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law; (2) ob
tained without procedures required by law, rule, or regula
tion having been followed; or (3) unsupported by
substantial evidence.” 5 U.S.C. § 7703(c); Brenner v. Dep’t
of Veterans Affs., 990 F.3d 1313, 1322 (Fed. Cir. 2021)
(quoting 5 U.S.C. § 7703(c)). “We review decisions of the
Board regarding its own jurisdiction without deference.”
Kahn v. Dep’t of Just., 528 F.3d 1336, 1341 (Fed. Cir.
2008).
To establish the Board’s jurisdiction over an IRA ap
peal, the appellant must “show by preponderant evidence
that (1) [she] engaged in whistleblowing activity by making
a disclosure protected by 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8); (2) the
agency took or threatened to take a ‘personnel action’
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 5
Filed: 10/31/2025
5
COURTNEY v. MSPB
against [her] as defined in 5 U.S.C. § 2302(a)(2)(A); (3) [she]
sought corrective action from OSC; and (4) [she] exhausted
corrective action proceedings before OSC.” Serrao v. Merit
Sys. Prot. Bd., 95 F.3d 1569, 1574 (Fed. Cir. 1996). Fur
thermore, the Board “lacks jurisdiction when the employee
seeks corrective action for a prohibited personnel practice
described in section 2302(b)(9)(A)(ii), which concerns ‘the
exercise of any appeal, complaint, or grievance right
granted by any law, rule, or regulation . . . other than with
regard to remedying a violation of [section 2302(b)(8)].’”
Abutalib v. Merit Sys. Prot. Bd., 127 F.4th 373, 378
(Fed. Cir. 2025).
A.
Although Ms. Courtney has raised several potential al
legations, Appellant’s Br. 1—2,2 the Board did not err in
finding that she had only exhausted her OSC remedies
with respect to her claim that the IRS retaliated against
her for filing the March 2, 2023 grievance. Initial Decision
at 12. “[I]f the personnel action challenged by the employee
is not otherwise directly appealable to the Board, the em
ployee must first seek corrective action from the OSC.” El
lison v. Merit Sys. Prot. Bd., 7 F.3d 1031, 1035 (Fed. Cir.
1993) (citing 5 U.S.C. §§ 1214(a)(3), 1221(a), (b)). “The
Board’s jurisdiction over an IRA appeal, assuming the em
ployee does not have an independent right to appeal di
rectly to the Board, is thus limited to those issues that have
been previously raised with OSC.” McCarthy v. Merit Sys.
Prot. Bd., 809 F.3d 1365, 1374 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (internal
quotation marks and citation omitted).
Even though Ms. Courtney raised several allegations
at the Board, “[t]he appellant’s submissions to OSC, the
emails with OSC, and the OSC closeout letter only refer to
the grievance.” Initial Decision at 12. Accordingly, the
2
We cite to the ECF page numbers.
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 6
Filed: 10/31/2025
COURTNEY V. MSPB
6
administrative judge concluded that “the appellant proved
administrative exhaustion with respect to the grievance
but not other complaints.” Id. Additionally, although
Ms. Courtney now raises a failure to follow proper proce
dure under the Civil Service Reform Act and the union
agreement, neither of these alleged failures were discussed
in the grievance. Appellant’s Br. 2; S. App’x 82. See Young
v. Merit Sys. Prot. Bd., 961 F.3d 1323, 1328 (Fed. Cir.
2020). We likewise see no reversible error in the Board’s
conclusion that administrative exhaustion was limited to
the aforementioned grievance.
B.
The Board did not err in finding that Ms. Courtney’s
grievance did not raise a protected disclosure and could not
be classified as a protected activity over which it had juris
diction. Initial Decision at 12-13. “In order for the Board
to have jurisdiction over an IRA appeal” over whistleblow
ing charges, Ms. Courtney must show by a preponderance
of the evidence “that [she] engaged in whistleblower activ
ity by making a disclosure protected under the [statute],
i.e., [she] disclosed information that [she] reasonably be
lieved evidenced ‘a violation of law, rule, or regulation,’ 5
U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A)(i), or ‘gross mismanagement, a gross
waste of funds, an abuse of authority, or a substantial and
specific danger to public health and safety,’ 5 U.S.C.
§ 2302(b)(8)(A)(ii).” Herman v. Dep’t of Just., 193 F.3d
1375, 1378 (Fed. Cir. 1999) (emphasis omitted). Ms. Court
ney did not raise any protected disclosures in her griev
ance.
First, Ms. Courtney’s grievance does not contain alle
gations of a “violation of any law, rule, or regulation.” 5
U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A)(i); S. App’x 82. Second, her state
ments do not arise to the level of disclosing “gross misman
agement, a gross waste of funds, an abuse of authority, or
a substantial and specific danger to public health or
safety.”
5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A)(ii).
Ms. Courtney’s
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
COURTNEY v. MSPB
Page: 7
Filed: 10/31/2025
7
grievance only contains allegations of insufficient training,
which constitute a “[m]ere difference[ ] of opinion between
an employee and [her] agency superiors as to the proper
approach to a particular problem or the most appropriate
course of action” not arising “to the level of gross misman
agement.” White v. Dep’t of the Air Force, 391 F.3d 1377,
1381 (Fed. Cir. 2004); see S. App’x 82.
Moreover,
Ms. Courtney’s allegations contain disagreements with the
method of training and feedback she received from her su
pervisors. S. App’x 82. In the past, we have adopted defi
nitions of “abuse of authority” as “an arbitrary or capricious
exercise of power by a federal official or employee that ad
versely affects the rights of any person” or is “inconsistent
with the mission of the executive agency concerned.” Smolinski v. Merit Sys. Prot. Bd., 23 F.4th 1345, 1351-52
(Fed. Cir. 2022) (adopting definitions from Wheeler v. Dep’t
of Veterans Affs., 88 M.S.P.R. 236, 241 (2001) and 41 U.S.C.
§ 4712(g)(1)). These disagreements with the method of
training and feedback do not amount to an abuse of author
ity.
Additionally, Ms. Courtney’s act of filing the grievance
is not a protected activity. Even though filing a grievance
may be protected activity, the Board lacks jurisdiction in
IRA appeals concerning grievances unless the grievance
“seek[s] to remedy a violation of [5 U.S.C. §] 2302(b)(8).”
Young, 961 F.3d at 1329; Abutalib, 127 F.4th at 378. As
discussed earlier, the subject matter of the grievance does
not seek to remedy a violation of 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8).
Thus, Ms. Courtney’s act of filing the grievance does not
establish the Board’s jurisdiction.
Case: 25-1348
Document: 24
Page: 8
8
Filed: 10/31/2025
COURTNEY V. MSPB
III. Conclusion
We have considered Ms. Courtney’s remaining argu
ments3 and find them unpersuasive. For the foregoing rea
sons, we affirm.
AFFIRMED
Costs
No costs.
3 For example, Ms. Courtney argues that the Board
did not consider that “the new director had never met [her]
prior to terminating [her] employment” and that she had
submitted a “zip file containing falsified job evals about
[her] to the previous director.” Appellant’s Br. 2 (cleaned
up). However, Ms. Courtney does not explain how consid
eration of these additional circumstances would establish
Board jurisdiction, as none of these issues were specifically
discussed in her grievance.
S. App’x 82; see Young,
961 F.3d at 1328 (“A party cannot establish jurisdiction
through general assertions, but must provide substantive
details.”).
W. e>
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BOARD
DOCKET NUMBER
SF-1221-23-0417-W-1
EVELYN COURTNEY,
Appellant,
v.
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY,
Agency.
DATE: November 8, 2024
THIS FINAL ORDER IS NONPRECEDENTIAL1
Evelyn Courtney. Fresno, California, pro se.
Mikel C, Deimler. Esquire, San Francisco, California, for the agency.
BEFORE
Cathy A. Harris, Chairman
Raymond A. Limon, Vice Chairman
Henry J. Kerner, Member*
^Member Kerner recused himself and
did not participate in the adjudication of this appeal.
FINAL ORDER
TJ1
The appellant has filed a petition for review of the initial decision, which
dismissed her individual right of action appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
On
petition for review, the appellant does not directly dispute the administrative
judge’s conclusion but instead argues that the agency violated her collective
1 A nonprecedential order is one that the Board has determined does not add
significantly to the body of MSPB case law. Parties may cite nonprecedential orders,
but such orders have no precedential value; the Board and administrative judges are not
required to follow or distinguish them in any future decisions. In contrast, a
precedential decision issued as an Opinion and Order has been identified by the Board
as significantly contributing to the Board’s case law. See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.117(c).
2
bargaining rights and did not properly terminate her, that she proved the timing
test, and that the agency should rehire her. Generally, we grant petitions such as
this one only in the following circumstances:
the initial decision contains
erroneous findings of material fact; the initial decision is based on an erroneous
interpretation of statute or regulation or the erroneous application of the law to
the facts of the case; the administrative judge’s rulings during either the course of
the appeal or the initial decision were not consistent with required procedures or
involved an abuse of discretion, and the resulting error affected the outcome of
the case; or new and material evidence or legal argument is available that, despite
the petitioner’s due diligence, was not available when the record closed. Title 5
of the Code of Federal Regulations, section 1201.115 (5 C.F.R. § 1201.115).
After fully considering the filings in this appeal, we conclude that the petitioner
has not established any basis under section 1201.115 for granting the petition for
review.
Therefore, we DENY the petition for review and AFFIRM the initial
decision, which is now the Board’s final decision. 5 C.F.R. § 1201.113(b).
NOTICE OF APPEAL RIGHTS2
You may obtain review of this final decision. 5 U.S.C. § 7703(a)(1). By
statute, the nature of your claims determines the time limit for seeking such
review and the appropriate forum with which to file.
5 U.S.C. § 7703(b).
Although we offer the following summary of available appeal rights, the Merit
Systems Protection Board does not provide legal advice on which option is most
appropriate for your situation and the rights described below do not represent a
statement of how courts will rule regarding which cases fall within their
jurisdiction.
If you wish to seek review of this final decision, you should
immediately review the law applicable to your claims and carefully follow all
2 Since the issuance of the initial decision in this matter, the Board may have updated
the notice of review rights included in final decisions. As indicated in the notice, the
Board cannot advise which option is most appropriate in any matter.
3
filing time limits and requirements.
Failure to file within the applicable time
limit may result in the dismissal of your case by your chosen forum.
Please read carefully each of the three main possible choices of review
below to decide which one applies to your particular case. If you have questions
about whether a particular forum is the appropriate one to review your case, you
should contact that forum for more information.
(1) Judicial review in general.
As a general rule, an appellant seeking
judicial review of a final Board order must file a petition for review with the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which must be received by the court
within 60 calendar days of the date of issuance of this decision.
5 U.S.C.
§ 7703(b)(1)(A).
If you submit a petition for review to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit, you must submit your petition to the court at the following
address:
U.S. Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit
717 Madison Place, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20439
Additional information about the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit is available at the court’s website, www.cafc.uscourts.gov. Of particular
relevance is the court’s “Guide for Pro Se Petitioners and Appellants,” which is
contained within the court’s Rules of Practice, and Forms 5, 6, 10, and 11.
If you are interested in securing pro bono representation for an appeal to
the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, you may visit our website at
http://www.mspb.gov/probono for information regarding pro bono representation
for Merit Systems Protection Board appellants before the Federal Circuit.
The
Board neither endorses the services provided by any attorney nor warrants that
any attorney will accept representation in a given case.
4
(2) Judicial
discrimination.
or
EEOC
review
of
cases
involving
a
claim
of
This option applies to you only if you have claimed that you
were affected by an action that is appealable to the Board and that such action
was based, in whole or in part, on unlawful discrimination. If so, you may obtain
judicial review of this decision—including a disposition of your discrimination
claims—by filing a civil action with an appropriate U.S. district court (not the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit), within 30 calendar days after you
receive this decision.
5 U.S.C. § 7703(b)(2); see Perry v. Merit Systems
Protection Board, 582 U.S. 420 (2017). If you have a representative in this case,
and your representative receives this decision before you do, then you must file
with the district court no later than 30 calendar days after your representative
receives this decision. If the action involves a claim of discrimination based on
race, color, religion, sex, national origin, or a disabling condition, you may be
entitled to representation by a court-appointed lawyer and to waiver of any
requirement of prepayment of fees, costs, or other security.
See 42 U.S.C.
§ 2000e-5(f) and 29 U.S.C. § 794a.
Contact information for U.S. district courts can be found at their respective
websites, which can be accessed through the link below:
http.7/www.uscourts.£Ov/Court Locator/CourtWebsites.aspx.
Alternatively,
you may request review
by the
Equal
Employment
Opportunity Commission (EEOC) of your discrimination claims only, excluding
all other issues. 5 U.S.C. § 7702(b)(1). You must file any such request with the
EEOC’s Office of Federal Operations within 30 calendar days after you receive
this decision. 5 U.S.C. § 7702(b)(1). If you have a representative in this case,
and your representative receives this decision before you do, then you must file
with the EEOC no later than 30 calendar days after your representative receives
this decision.
If you submit a request for review to the EEOC by regular U.S. mail, the
address of the EEOC is:
5
Office of Federal Operations
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
P.O. Box 77960
Washington, D.C. 20013
If you submit a request for review to the EEOC via commercial delivery or
by a method requiring a signature, it must be addressed to:
Office of Federal Operations
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
131 M Street, N.E.
Suite 5SW12G
Washington, D.C. 20507
(3) Judicial
review
pursuant
to
the
Whistleblower
Protection
Enhancement Act of 2012. This option applies to you only if you have raised
claims of reprisal for whistleblowing disclosures under 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8) or
other protected activities listed in 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(9)(A)(i), (B), (C), or (D).
If so, and your judicial petition for review “raises no challenge to the Board’s
disposition of allegations of a prohibited personnel practice described in
section 2302(b) other than practices described in section 2302(b)(8), or 2302(b)
(9)(A)(i), (B), (C), or (D),” then you may file a petition for judicial review either
with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit or any court of appeals of
competent jurisdiction.3
The court of appeals must receive your petition for
review within 60 days of the date of issuance of this decision.
5 U.S.C.
§ 7703(b)(1)(B).
3 The original statutory provision that provided for judicial review of certain
whistleblower claims by any court of appeals of competent jurisdiction expired on
December 27, 2017. The All Circuit Review Act, signed into law by the President on
July 7, 2018, permanently allows appellants to file petitions for judicial review of
MSPB decisions in certain whistleblower reprisal cases with the U.S. Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit or any other circuit court of appeals of competent jurisdiction.
The All Circuit Review Act is retroactive to November 26, 2017. Pub. L. No. 115-195,
132 Stat. 1510.
6
If you submit a petition for judicial review to the U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit, you must submit your petition to the court at the' following
address:
U.S. Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit
717 Madison Place, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20439
Additional information about the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit is available at the court’s website, www.cafc.uscourts.gov. Of particular
relevance is the court’s “Guide for Pro Se Petitioners and Appellants,” which is
contained within the court’s Rules of Practice, and Forms 5, 6, 10, and 11.
If you are interested in securing pro bono representation for an appeal to
the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, you may visit our website at
http://www.mspb.gov/probono for information regarding pro bono representation
for Merit Systems Protection Board appellants before the Federal Circuit.
The
Board neither endorses the services provided by any attorney nor warrants that
any attorney will accept representation in a given case.
Contact information for the courts of appeals can be found at their
respective websites, which can be accessed through the link below:
http://www.uscourts.gov/Court_Locator/CourtWebsites.aspx.
Gin(b K Gtypandfr
FOR THE BOARD:
Gina K. Grippando
Clerk of the Board
Washington, D.C.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the attached Document(s) was (were) sent as indicated this day
to each of the following:
Appellant
Electronic Service
Evelyn Courtney
Served on email address registered with MSPB
Agency Representative
U.S. Mail
Area Counsel
IRS, Office of Chief CounseHOO First St., 18th Floor
San Francisco, California 94105
Agency Representative
Electronic Service
Mikel Deimler
Served on email address registered with MSPB
11/08/2024
(Date)
Jcdu-V
John Hayes
Additional material
from this filing is
available in the
Clerk's Office.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.