Opposition Brief — Benny Lee Hodge, Petitioner v. Laura Plappert, Warden

Supreme Court briefDec 9, 2025

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. 25-6179

In the Supreme Court of the United States

BENNY LEE HODGE,

v.

LAURA PLAPPERT, Warden,

Petitioner,

Respondent.

On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the

United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit

***CAPITAL CASE***

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION

Office of the Kentucky

Attorney General

1024 Capital Center Drive

Suite 200

Frankfort, KY 40601

(502) 696-5300

Matt.Kuhn@ky.gov

MATTHEW F. KUHN*

*Counsel of Record

Deputy Solicitor General

December 9, 2025

Solicitor General

JOHN H. HEYBURN

Principal Deputy

Solicitor General

JACOB M. ABRAHAMSON

i

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

*CAPITAL CASE*

Over 40 years ago, Petitioner Benny Hodge murdered 20-year-old Tammy

Acker and left her father Dr. Roscoe Acker for dead in Letcher County, Kentucky. A

jury and judge sentenced him to death for the murder. His direct appeal was unsuccessful. And his state and federal attempts at securing post-conviction relief likewise

failed. Most recently, the en banc Sixth Circuit affirmed the denial of his federal habeas petition. Now seeking certiorari from that judgment, Hodge presents the following questions:

1. Did the Sixth Circuit’s decision to rehear Hodge’s appeal en banc violate the

Eighth Amendment?

2. Did the Sixth Circuit’s decision to affirm the judgment denying Hodge’s habeas petition violate the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments?

3. Was the Sixth Circuit correct to hold, under the Antiterrorism and Effective

Death Penalty Act of 1996 (AEDPA), that the Kentucky Supreme Court reasonably

applied this Court’s precedents to conclude that Hodge suffered no prejudice because

of unpresented mitigation evidence during the penalty phase of his trial?

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

QUESTIONS PRESENTED ........................................................................................... i

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ......................................................................................... iii

INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1

STATEMENT OF THE CASE ....................................................................................... 2

ARGUMENT .................................................................................................................. 8

I.

Hodge offers no reason to review the Sixth Circuit’s central holding. ............. 9

II.

Hodge cannot escape the constraints of AEDPA by attacking the

appellate process. .............................................................................................. 14

A. Hodge’s arguments are unpreserved. ............................................................ 15

B. Even if preserved, Hodge’s arguments do not warrant this Court’s

intervention. .......................................................................................................... 17

CONCLUSION............................................................................................................. 21

iii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases

Andrew v. White,

604 U.S. 86 (2025) (per curiam) ............................................................................... 13

Brown v. Davenport,

596 U.S. 118 (2022) ................................................................................................... 17

Buck v. Davis,

580 U.S. 100 (2017) .................................................................................................. 15

Cullen v. Pinholster,

563 U.S. 170 (2011) .................................................................................................. 13

Cutter v. Wilkinson,

544 U.S. 709 (2005) .................................................................................................. 15

Furman v. Georgia,

408 U.S. 238 (1972) .................................................................................................. 20

Gregg v. Georgia,

428 U.S. 153 (1976) .................................................................................................. 18

Harrington v. Richter,

562 U.S. 86 (2011) .............................................................................................. 10, 17

Hodge v. Jordan,

95 F.4th 393 (6th Cir. 2024) ................................................................................ 7, 19

Hodge v. Kentucky,

502 U.S. 1037 (1992) .................................................................................................. 8

Hodge v. Kentucky,

568 U.S. 1056 (2012) ............................................................................................ 8, 14

Missouri v. Jenkins,

495 U.S. 33 (1990)..................................................................................................... 20

O’Neil v. Vermont,

144 U.S. 323 (1892) .................................................................................................. 18

iv

Pulley v. Harris,

465 U.S. 37 (1984) .................................................................................................... 18

Roberts v. Louisiana,

428 U.S. 325 (1976) .................................................................................................. 18

Shinn v. Kayer,

592 U.S. 111 (2020) (per curiam) ............................................................................. 10

Shinn v. Ramirez,

596 U.S. 366 (2022) .................................................................................................. 15

Solem v. Helm,

463 U.S. 277 (1983) ............................................................................................ 18, 20

Thornell v. Jones,

602 U.S. 154 (2024) .................................................................................................. 12

Woodford v. Visciotti,

537 U.S. 19 (2002) (per curiam) ............................................................................... 12

Statutes

28 U.S.C.:

§ 2253(c) .................................................................................................................... 15

§ 2254(b)(1) ............................................................................................................... 15

§ 2254(d) ....................................................................................................... 10, 16, 17

§ 46(c) ........................................................................................................................ 16

1

INTRODUCTION

In 1986, a Kentucky jury and judge sentenced Benny Hodge to death for the

brutal murder of 20-year-old Tammy Acker. At sentencing, Hodge presented only a

two-sentence stipulation as mitigation evidence. He now claims that his trial counsel

was ineffective for not presenting additional mitigation evidence from his childhood.

In state post-conviction proceedings, the Kentucky Supreme Court weighed the evidence presented to the jury with the new evidence and decided that Hodge did not

suffer any prejudice. The Sixth Circuit reviewed that decision under the double deference required by Strickland v. Washington and AEDPA, and held that the Kentucky Supreme Court’s decision was “within the bounds of reasonableness under

AEDPA deference.” Pet. App. A 11. * That decision was faithful to AEDPA and this

Court’s precedents applying it, so the Court has no reason to review it. Indeed, Hodge

does not suggest that the Sixth Circuit’s decision is in tension with any other circuit’s

application of AEDPA.

That should make Hodge’s petition an open-and-shut denial. Perhaps aware of

this, Hodge offers two brand-new Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment arguments:

First, that the en banc process below—which he does not suggest violated the Federal

Rules of Appellate Procedure—singled him out for unique punishment. And second,

* Hodge’s appendices comprise four separate PDFs, without continuous page number-

ing. Warden Plappert thus refers to them by their assigned letter, with citations to

internal page numbers: Pet. App. [Letter] [Internal Page Number].

2

that the Sixth Circuit’s application of AEDPA deference led to a disproportionate sentence. Both arguments level novel attacks on the appellate process that every habeas

petitioner is afforded. Neither has any basis in the constitutional text or this Court’s

precedents. And Hodge raises both for the first time at this Court, after the appellate

process ended unfavorably for him.

Hodge brutally murdered Tammy Acker over 40 years ago. He has sought postconviction relief at every level of the Kentucky and federal judiciary, all without success. The Sixth Circuit was demonstrably correct to affirm the denial of Hodge’s habeas petition. And Hodge’s eleventh-hour attempts to show otherwise should not delay finality of his case. For these reasons and as discussed below, the Court should

deny his petition for a writ of certiorari.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

1. Over 40 years ago, Benny Hodge and two accomplices murdered 20-year-old

Tammy Acker and left her father Dr. Roscoe Acker for dead. Pet. App. A 2. His crimes

were “‘heinous,’ ‘brutal,’ ‘vicious,’ ‘calculated,’ and ‘exceedingly cold-hearted.’” Id. (collecting cases).

Hodge, with Roger Epperson and Donald Bartley, planned a robbery with the

intent to leave no witnesses. Dr. Acker, the local doctor in Fleming-Neon, Kentucky,

was known to keep a large amount of cash at his home. Id. That money, stored in a

safe, was the life savings he and his late wife had set aside over 40 years of marriage.

3

Id. Hodge and his accomplices wanted that money. Id. So they planned “a white

collar ruse” to access Dr. Acker’s house. Id. And they did not intend to leave any witnesses—as “Hodge later told his cellmate,” “it was ‘the smart thing to do’ to ‘kill all

witnesses when you commit any crime so nobody can testify against you.’” Id.

The ruse began during the evening of August 8, 1985. Tammy, who was a college student, was home in the mountains of eastern Kentucky to care for her grieving

father after her mother died, and was set to head back to school the next day. Id. She

answered the door to find two men (Hodge and Bartley) claiming to be FBI agents.

Id. They looked the part: they “wore suits and appeared neatly groomed,” carrying “a

briefcase, a .41 magnum revolver, a .38 police revolver, badges, and IDs.” Id. They

claimed that “they needed to ask Dr. Acker ‘a few questions’ about someone they were

investigating.” Id. But Dr. Acker was not home, so they left with a promise to return

later that evening. Id. The reunited trio retreated to a nearby road, situated above

the house, where they watched for Dr. Acker to return. Id.

Once Dr. Acker was home, Hodge and Bartley renewed their scheme. Id. This

time, Tammy answered the doorbell via intercom and again heard two purported FBI

agents. Id. Dr. Acker met them outside, where they sought “a written statement about

a previous business acquaintance.” Id. He eventually agreed and, “after some coaxing

by Hodge,” let them inside to sign the statement with Tammy as a witness. Id.

4

The men quickly dropped their act. Hodge pulled a gun, and Bartley grabbed

Tammy. Pet. App. A 2–3. Hodge held Dr. Acker at gunpoint in the kitchen and ordered Bartley to tie up Tammy in a back room. Id. Tammy “begged” Bartley, “‘please

don’t hurt my Dad. My mother has just died.’” Pet. App. A 3. He left her bound and

gagged, face down on the floor, and returned to the kitchen to bind Dr. Acker and

cover his head. Id. With Dr. Acker and Tammy restrained, Hodge and Bartley let

Epperson into the home. Id. The men “proceeded to ‘ransack[]’ the Acker home until

finding the safe.” Id. But they couldn’t open it themselves—even after forcing Dr.

Acker to reveal its combination with “a blow to the ribs”—“[s]o they dragged Dr. Acker

to the vault and forced him to [open] it.” Id. They took all its contents: “stacks of cash”

totaling $1.9 million, guns, and jewelry. Id.

Dr. Acker and Tammy remained bound, with their heads covered. Id. But the

men decided not to leave any witnesses. Id. Hodge agreed to kill Tammy, and Epperson ordered Bartley to kill Dr. Acker. Id. Hodge returned from his initial attempt and

said, “she’s not dead.” Id. So Epperson handed him a butcher knife, and Hodge returned to Tammy. Id. He stabbed her “at least 10 times.” Id. According to a

pathologist, Hodge used a “considerable amount of force” to kill Tammy. Id. He “later

told Epperson the knife had gone ‘all the way through her to the floor.’” Id. (citation

omitted). “Tammy died of hemorrhage from the stab wounds.” Id.

5

Meanwhile, Bartley strangled Dr. Acker in the kitchen. Id. “He used the electrical cord from a curling iron to choke the physician until he lost consciousness.” Id.

The men thought Dr. Acker was dead. Id. But they were mistaken; Dr. Acker survived

the attempted murder and follow-on heart attack. Id. He awoke “to experience the

horror of finding Tammy lifeless in the corner of her room with a ‘butcher knife protruding out of her back.’” Id. He knew she was dead and “consoled himself by saying

that ‘she was in God’s hands’ now.” Id.

The trio fled to Florida and began “a spending spree with Dr. Acker’s

money . . . buying expensive vehicles and luxury goods.” Id. Hodge later bragged “that

he had stacked some of the stolen cash very high on a bed to have sex with a woman

on top of it.” Id. Thankfully, their spree was short lived. “FBI agents, with the help of

a SWAT team, arrested the three fugitives.” Id. Law enforcement seized stolen cash,

jewelry, and weapons, along with items the group had purchased with Dr. Acker’s

money. Pet. App. A 3–4. They were brought back to Letcher County to stand trial.

Pet. App. A 4.

2. At a consolidated trial for Epperson and Hodge, a Kentucky jury heard the

above facts from Dr. Acker, a now-cooperating Bartley, and several other witnesses.

Id. The jury convicted Hodge and Epperson of Tammy’s murder, Dr. Acker’s attempted murder, first-degree robbery, and first-degree burglary. Id. Before imposing

a sentence, the jury heard little additional evidence. “Hodge’s mitigation case at the

6

penalty phase consisted of just a two-sentence stipulation: he had ‘a loving and supportive family—a wife and three children,’ and ‘a public job work record.’” Id. (citation

omitted). The jury recommended a death sentence for Tammy’s murder and 60 years

in prison for the other crimes. Id.

Kentucky’s courts rejected Hodge’s direct appeal and post-conviction claims.

Pet. App. A 4–5. The only of those claims relevant here is Hodge’s assertion that his

lawyer provided ineffective assistance at the penalty phase. Pet. App. A 5. In 2011,

the Kentucky Supreme Court, after weighing “‘the totality of evidence before Hodge’s

sentencing jury, including the proposed mitigation evidence,’ . . . concluded ‘that

there exists no reasonable probability that the jury would not have sentenced Hodge

to death’ considering the ‘heinous nature’ of his crimes, and the fact that the ‘mitigation evidence’ included ‘damaging evidence’ about his criminal history.” Id. (citation

omitted). This Court, over Justice Sotomayor’s dissent who would have remanded for

further consideration, denied Hodge’s petition for a writ of certiorari from that judgment. Id.

3. Without success in the Kentucky courts, Hodge filed a federal habeas petition in the Eastern District of Kentucky. Id. Applying AEDPA, the district court denied each of Hodge’s 29 claims. Pet. App. A 5–6. It also granted a certificate of appealability for three claims—ineffective assistance of counsel, jury tampering, and

jury bias. Pet. App. C 58.

7

A panel of the Sixth Circuit originally affirmed the denial of habeas relief. Pet.

App. A 6. But before the panel decided Hodge’s rehearing petition, one member of

the panel took inactive status, after which a new judge was assigned. Hodge v. Jordan, 95 F.4th 393, 403 (6th Cir. 2024) (Siler, J., dissenting). That newly constituted

panel reversed itself in a superseding opinion on rehearing, granting Hodge habeas

relief on his ineffective-assistance claim. Pet. App. A 6. On rehearing en banc, the full

Sixth Circuit, by a 14 to 4 vote, affirmed the denial of Hodge’s habeas petition. Relevant here, it held that “the Kentucky Supreme Court articulated the correct legal

standard” and “provided adequate reasoning” under AEDPA. Pet. App. A 10. Because

the state court “weighed Hodge’s missing mitigating evidence against aggravating

evidence of Hodge’s ‘particularly depraved and brutal’ crimes to conclude that the

sentencing jury would not have spared Hodge the death penalty,” the Sixth Circuit

concluded that “the Kentucky Supreme Court acted within the bounds of reasonableness under AEDPA deference.” Pet. App. A 11 (citation omitted). And it rejected

Hodge’s argument that the Kentucky Supreme Court applied “an improper nexus requirement,” reasoning that the state court’s statement that Hodge’s mitigation evidence failed to explain his brutal crime “simply put[] a period on [its] earlier analysis.”

Pet. App. A 12. This petition followed.

8

ARGUMENT

Hodge has reached the very end of his decades-long effort to undo the decision

of a Kentucky jury and judge. After all this judicial process, he now takes the position

that he is the victim of an unfair process. But Hodge cannot escape the facts: He was

convicted and sentenced in 1986. In the nearly 40 years since, he has taken both his

direct and postconviction challenges through Kentucky’s Court of Justice, culminating in this Court’s denials of review. Hodge v. Kentucky, 502 U.S. 1037 (1992); Hodge

v. Kentucky, 568 U.S. 1056 (2012). And a federal district court heard 29 claims for

federal habeas relief, three of which were certified for appeal. His appeal resulted in

two full-length decisions from three-judge panels after briefing and argument, followed by briefing and argument before the en banc Sixth Circuit. The full Sixth Circuit’s decision to deny habeas relief is the latest stop on that long road. This Court

should make it the last one.

Hodge’s only preserved challenge is to his trial counsel’s failure to introduce

additional mitigation evidence during the penalty phase of his trial. The appropriate

inquiry is straightforward under AEDPA: Was the Kentucky Supreme Court’s conclusion that Hodge was not prejudiced by the unpresented evidence unreasonable?

Pet. App. A 8. The Sixth Circuit, by a lopsided vote, held that it was not. Hodge’s

arguments to the contrary depend on interpreting a single sentence in the Kentucky

9

Supreme Court’s unpublished decision—hardly the stakes that warrant a grant of

certiorari.

Likely recognizing as much, Hodge resorts to unpreserved arguments in an

effort to skirt AEDPA’s requirements. Both arguments suggest that the Sixth Circuit’s en banc opinion somehow caused constitutional violations warranting reversal.

The first claims that the en banc process singled out Hodge for punishment, and the

second claims that the Sixth Circuit’s opinion resulted in a disproportionate sentence.

Both unpreserved arguments are altogether untethered from existing law and, perhaps more importantly, from the procedural realities of Hodge’s habeas appeal. Neither remotely justifies certiorari.

I.

Hodge offers no reason to review the Sixth Circuit’s central holding.

On the merits, Hodge elects to challenge only the Sixth Circuit’s resolution of

his ineffective-assistance claim. He summarizes (at 22) his primary objection to the

Sixth Circuit’s analysis: its alleged “failure not [sic] to apply this Court’s holding of

Andrew v. White to the legal principle relied upon by this Court in Williams, Wiggins,

and Rompilla.” But a closer look at Hodge’s claim makes clear that the Sixth Circuit

got his case right.

To start, all agree that AEDPA governs Hodge’s challenge to the Kentucky Supreme Court’s decision to reject his ineffective-assistance claim. That means relief

10

“shall not be granted” “unless” the decision “was contrary to, or involved an unreasonable application of, clearly established Federal law, as determined by the Supreme

Court of the United States” or “was based on an unreasonable determination of the

facts” introduced in state court. 28 U.S.C. § 2254(d). Much like he did below, Hodge

purports to raise a contrary-to challenge, but in reality he simply disagrees with how

the Kentucky Supreme Court applied Strickland. As Hodge tells it, he disputes (at

22) whether the state court applied “the proper Strickland test.”

There can be no doubt that the Kentucky Supreme Court “applied the correct

governing legal principle . . . to the facts of [Hodge’s] case.” Shinn v. Kayer, 592 U.S.

111, 118 (2020) (per curiam) (cleaned up). Kentucky’s high court appropriately cited

and quoted Strickland. Pet. App. B 3. The real question, then, is whether its application of Strickland “was so lacking in justification that there was an error well understood and comprehended in existing law beyond any possibility for fairminded disagreement.” Harrington v. Richter, 562 U.S. 86, 103 (2011). It’s not enough “that the

state court’s decision was ‘merely wrong’ or ‘even clear error’”—AEDPA demands “far

more.” Shinn, 592 U.S. at 118 (cleaned up).

Hodge can show no such grievous error. The Kentucky Supreme Court’s 12paragraph analysis is more than sufficient to overcome an AEDPA challenge. As the

Sixth Circuit described, the state court “examined all of Hodge’s proposed mitigating

evidence” and “analyzed the mitigating evidence and testimony from Hodge’s mother,

11

sisters, and two psychologists.” Pet. App. A 10. It even criticized the trial court for

understating the severity of Hodge’s childhood abuse. Id. Yet it also “recognized that

Hodge’s supposed extenuating proof ‘also included the damaging evidence of his long

and increasingly violent criminal history, his numerous escapes from custody, and

the obvious failure of several rehabilitative efforts.’” Id. (citation omitted).

Next, as Strickland demands, “the Kentucky Supreme Court weighed the mitigating evidence against the aggravating ‘heinous nature of Hodge’s crime.’” Id. (citation omitted). It recounted the “direct evidence” presented “against Hodge in damning

fashion”: the vulnerability of the victims, the careful plans, and the horror of the violent murder Hodge himself committed. Id. “His crimes ‘were not just brutal and vicious, but calculated and exceedingly cold-hearted.’” Id. (citation omitted). Indeed,

“Hodge had no regrets: he enjoyed the fruits of his crimes.” Pet. App. A 11. So the

Kentucky Supreme Court, after independently weighing Hodge’s new evidence and

the evidence presented at trial, “determined the unpresented mitigating evidence was

not enough to overcome the aggravating facts of Hodge’s odious conduct.” Id. Its “conclusion was not so objectively wrong under U.S. Supreme Court precedent to be beyond any possibility for fairminded jurists to disagree.” Id.

Hodge disagrees with the Kentucky Supreme Court’s balancing, but he has

little to say about the Sixth Circuit’s actual holding under AEDPA. Instead, he argues

(at 20) that AEDPA deference “should not apply” at all. His main objection to AEDPA

12

deference (at 21–22) is that the Kentucky Supreme Court allegedly applied a nexus

requirement while applying Strickland. In making this point, Hodge takes issue with

a sentence, buried within the Kentucky Supreme Court’s analysis, stating that

Hodge’s mitigation evidence “offers virtually no rationale for the pre-meditated, coldblooded murder and attempted murder of two innocent victims who were complete

strangers to Hodge.” Pet App. B 4.

At bottom, Hodge’s argument against AEDPA deference asks the Court to

“mischaracteriz[e]” this sentence from the Kentucky Supreme Court’s opinion, despite this Court’s admonition against doing so when a state court “expressed and applied the proper standard for evaluating prejudice.” Woodford v. Visciotti, 537 U.S.

19, 22 (2002) (per curiam). The correct approach under AEDPA “demands that statecourt decisions be given the benefit of the doubt.” Id. That’s how the Sixth Circuit

treated the Kentucky Supreme Court’s opinion here: it read the decision as a whole

and found that “[t]he paragraph now under scrutiny simply puts a period on the Kentucky court’s earlier analysis.” Pet. App. A 12. It was correct to adopt that reading.

An independent assessment of the mitigating and aggravating evidence necessarily

involves considering the weight of the mitigating evidence. Indeed, while Hodge’s case

was pending before the full Sixth Circuit, this Court made it crystal clear that a sentencer can simply find mitigating evidence “unpersuasive.” See Thornell v. Jones, 602

U.S. 154, 164–65 (2024). More to the point, “where the aggravating factors greatly

13

outweigh the mitigating evidence, there may be no ‘reasonable probability’ of a different result.” Id. at 165. That sentence captures well the Kentucky Supreme Court’s

view of the evidence here.

Relying on the dissent below, Hodge also claims (at 22) that this Court’s recent

decision in Andrew v. White, 604 U.S. 86 (2025) (per curiam), means that the Sixth

Circuit erred by not following Williams, Wiggins, and Rompilla—three fact-driven

cases. This contention fails several times over. For one, Andrew—a summary reversal—broke no new ground in describing what counts as a holding under AEDPA. See

Andrew, 604 U.S. at 92 (citing preexisting caselaw). And nothing in Andrew suggests

that an AEDPA court must blindly adopt the outcomes of this Court’s fact-driven

decisions applying Strickland to different sets of mitigating and aggravating evidence. Instead, the reviewing court’s primary task is applying “the important ‘double

deferential’ standard of Strickland and AEDPA” to the state court’s prejudice analysis. Cullen v. Pinholster, 563 U.S. 170, 202 (2011) (citations omitted). Williams and

Rompilla, two of Hodge’s favored cases, “offer no guidance” on that question, as this

Court has held. Id. And the Sixth Circuit rightly concluded that Wiggins, which involved “a defendant who had no aggravating factors or history of violence,” is readily

distinguishable from the aggravating history the Kentucky Supreme Court weighed

here. Pet App. A 11.

14

Lost in all of Hodge’s arguments is the Sixth Circuit’s bottom-line conclusion:

“Regardless of the significance of Hodge’s childhood abuse, controlling Supreme Court

precedent does not render it unreasonable for the Kentucky Supreme Court to find

no prejudice here, given its view that the aggravating factors overwhelmingly pointed

to imposing the death penalty.” Id. Hodge of course continues to disagree with the

Kentucky Supreme Court’s balancing. Some judges might, too. See id. (applying

ADEPA deference despite the reality that some judges “would have reached a different conclusion in the first instance”). In fact, earlier in this case without the strictures

of AEDPA, Justice Sotomayor harbored concerns. Hodge, 568 U.S. at 1056 (Sotomayor, J., dissenting from denial of cert.). But mere disagreement with the state

court’s conclusion does not an AEDPA violation make.

All in all, Hodge’s AEDPA argument reduces to how to construe a single sentence in an unpublished decision of the Kentucky Supreme Court. Even if doubts exist

about the Sixth Circuit’s 14–4 decision, an AEDPA dispute about how to read a state

court decision that is binding on only a single inmate comes nowhere close to satisfying this Court’s high standard for granting certiorari.

II.

Hodge cannot escape the constraints of AEDPA by attacking the appellate process.

Lacking a compelling reason to justify this Court’s review, Hodge also raises two

unpreserved issues. He attempts to tie both remaining arguments to the appellate procedure he was afforded after the district court denied habeas relief. He claims (at 10)

15

that the Sixth Circuit, by rehearing his appeal en banc, “selectively, irregularly, and

arbitrarily singled-out Hodge as deserving of the death penalty.” And he adds (at 13)

that “the Sixth Circuit’s opinion violates the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments” “because it is disproportionate to the outcomes of similarly situated capital prisoners.”

Hodge made neither argument until now. The Court has no reason to review either of

Hodge’s procedural arguments—they are unpreserved and unserious.

A. Hodge’s arguments are unpreserved.

Start with the vehicle problems. Hodge raises these challenges—which ultimately argue that a rules-driven process and the resulting opinion are unconstitutional—for the first time before this Court. That is frowned upon in “a court of review,

not of first view.” Cutter v. Wilkinson, 544 U.S. 709, 718 n.7 (2005) (citation omitted).

Especially so for a habeas appeal, where federal courts must enforce AEDPA’s requirements that a habeas petitioner raise only issues that have been exhausted in

state court, 28 U.S.C. § 2254(b)(1), and certified for appeal, 28 U.S.C. § 2253(c). See

also Shinn v. Ramirez, 596 U.S. 366, 377–79 (2022) (describing the “strict rules requiring prisoners to raise all of their federal claims in state court before seeking federal relief”); Buck v. Davis, 580 U.S. 100, 115 (2017) (“A state prisoner whose petition

for a writ of habeas corpus is denied by a federal district court does not enjoy an

absolute right to appeal. Federal law requires that he first obtain a [certificate of

appealability] from a circuit justice or judge.” (citation omitted)).

16

Of course, Hodge attempts to cast his arguments as incapable of airing until now

by directing his attacks against (at 12) “the Sixth Circuit’s handling of this case” and

(at 13) “the Sixth Circuit’s opinion.” But Hodge had plenty of chances to raise his constitutional arguments below. He could have invoked his new Eighth and Fourteenth

Amendments arguments in his petitions for rehearing from the original panel decision,

given the footnote issue he now mentions (at 10–11). CA6 Dkt. 64, 72. He could have

addressed these constitutional arguments in his opposition to the Warden’s petition for

rehearing after the superseding opinion, CA6 Dkt. 87, or in his two supplemental en

banc briefs, CA6 Dkts. 92, 100. He could have raised the issue during the en banc argument or in a rehearing petition after the full Court ruled. Hodge, however, let this

constitutional issue pass without mention at every juncture—until now.

At bottom, Hodge’s late-breaking arguments are a challenge to the federal appellate process that every habeas petitioner receives. The possibility that the full

Sixth Circuit would rehear his appeal was on the table from the start. See 28 U.S.C.

§ 46(c) (adopted in 1948). Same for the possibility that AEDPA deference might result

in the Sixth Circuit affirming the denial of his requested habeas relief. See 28 U.S.C.

§ 2254(d) (adopted in 1996). If Hodge thought this process created an Eighth or Fourteenth Amendment problem, he had to say so much earlier than now. Yet it is telling

that Hodge challenges this process only after he is unhappy with its results. Indeed,

17

Hodge was fine with the en banc process when he twice sought full-court review after

the Sixth Circuit’s first panel decision. CA6 Dkts. 64, 72.

B. Even if preserved, Hodge’s arguments do not warrant this Court’s

intervention.

Preservation aside, Hodge’s procedural arguments are unsound. His key

claim—that the Sixth Circuit’s decision to rehear his appeal en banc and affirm the

denial of habeas relief was itself a constitutional violation—rests on several flawed

assumptions, with no support in the Constitution, statutes, procedural rules, or

caselaw.

1.

To start, Hodge’s arguments reflect a deep misunderstanding of the role

of the federal courts in his habeas case. His underlying claim is an attack on “the judgment of a State court.” 28 U.S.C. § 2254(d). That’s why this Court has explained that

“[g]ranting habeas relief to a state prisoner ‘intrudes on state sovereignty to a degree

matched by few exercises of federal judicial authority.’” Brown v. Davenport, 596 U.S.

118, 132 (2022) (quoting Harrington, 562 U.S. at 103). But denying habeas relief is not

the same as imposing (or even affirming) that state-court judgment in the first instance. All a denial of habeas relief means is that there was no “extreme malfunction[]

in the state criminal justice system[.]” Harrington, 562 U.S. at 102 (citation omitted).

Hodge is therefore wrong to say that the Sixth Circuit (at 12) “imposed” or

“met[ed] out the most solemn and final of penalties” and (at 13) “affirmed Hodge’s

death sentence.” A Kentucky circuit court sentenced Hodge to death in 1986 on a

18

Letcher County jury’s recommendation, and the Kentucky Supreme Court affirmed

that sentence in 1990. Pet. App. C 3. A federal district court, by contrast, denied

Hodge’s federal habeas petition, and the Sixth Circuit affirmed that denial. Pet. App.

A 13–14 (“We are not deciding the issues in this case on direct appeal.”).

That distinction destroys any connection between cases about Eighth Amendment proportionality and what happened here. The relevant decisionmaker in a proportionality analysis is the sentencing body—not the federal habeas court. So most of

the cases Hodge cites answered, on direct appeal from a state-court judgment,

whether an initial sentencing decision was so disproportionate to the crime of conviction that it violated the Eighth Amendment. See Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153, 187

(1976) (considering “whether Georgia may impose the death penalty on the petitioner

in this case”); Roberts v. Louisiana, 428 U.S. 325, 331 (1976); see also O’Neil v. Vermont, 144 U.S. 323, 339 (1892) (Fields, J. dissenting) (claiming in dissent that Vermont’s sentence for liquor-law violations was too severe).

That’s not to say that a petitioner cannot raise proportionality issues in federal

habeas. See Pulley v. Harris, 465 U.S. 37, 40–41 (1984); Solem v. Helm, 463 U.S. 277,

283–84 (1983). But the cases Hodge cites are still directed towards the initial decision

to set a punishment. Hodge has not challenged the decision to sentence him to death

on proportionality grounds here. Indeed, he admits (at 9–10) that his “death sentence

itself may not be arbitrary—any more than any death sentence is arbitrary.” If

19

Hodge’s failure to raise this concern until now does not end the proportionality analysis, that admission should do the job. There is simply no connection between the

caselaw Hodge cites and the claims he makes about the Sixth Circuit’s decision to

rehear his case and affirm the denial of habeas relief.

2.

Even if the federal habeas proceedings here could trigger Hodge’s con-

stitutional concerns, Hodge has the wrong takeaway from them. No mystery surrounds what happened in his appeal. As Judge Siler explained, “one of the original

panelists in the majority, Judge Cook, took inactive status, and was replaced by

[Judge Clay], who joined the original dissent to create a new majority contrary to the

original majority opinion in this matter.” Jordan, 95 F.4th at 403 (Siler, J., dissenting). The Warden agrees that this process was out of the ordinary—she noted as much

in seeking rehearing en banc. CA6 Dkt. 85 at 17. Regardless, the end result was more,

not less, opportunity for Hodge to assert his habeas claims on appeal. Indeed, until

the en banc Sixth Circuit granted rehearing, this procedural oddity worked to Hodge’s

benefit by granting him habeas relief. That’s why the Warden exercised her procedural right to seek rehearing en banc from a panel opinion ruling against her—a right

Hodge does not (and cannot) dispute, given that he sought en banc relief from the

panel’s original decision. CA6 Dkts. 64, 72.

20

Simply put, Hodge cannot seriously claim (at 11–12) that his habeas petition

was denied “because he lost the judicial lottery.” The full Sixth Circuit, with 18 members, heard his claims, and he lost on the merits, fair and square. The full court did so

consistent with the relevant Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure and local rules. His

disagreement with that result is, on its own, insufficient to conclude that the process

leading to it was biased against him. See Missouri v. Jenkins, 495 U.S. 33, 50 (1990)

(explaining that “adherence to published rules of procedure best promotes the principles of fairness, stability, and uniformity that those rules are deigned to advance”).

3.

Finally, Hodge offers no support for his argument (at 17) that a federal

court can violate the Eighth or Fourteenth Amendments with a holding “outside of

the judicial norm.” The way to attack an erroneous holding is to contest it on appeal,

not to say the holding itself violates the Constitution. In arguing to the contrary,

Hodge cites Solem v. Helm, which restates the proposition that the Eighth Amendment “prohibits . . . sentences that are disproportionate to the crime committed.” 463

U.S. at 284. Hodge also throws in a reference to a concurrence from Furman v. Georgia connecting “the basic theme of equal protection” to a claim that the death penalty

was “disproportionately imposed” on certain groups in the mid-twentieth century. 408

U.S. 238, 249–50 (1972) (Douglas, J., concurring). That first proposition is uncontroversial, but relevant only to the initial imposition of Hodge’s death sentence, which

21

Hodge never claims was disproportionate to his brutal crimes. And the second proposition (to the extent that the concurrence states binding law) appears relevant only

when a defendant claims that he has received a sentence for discriminatory reasons,

another claim Hodge does not make. So neither of Hodge’s chosen cases makes his

point—it’s unclear how they are even relevant to it.

Hodge’s arguments are best viewed as a disagreement with how the Sixth Circuit applied this Court’s precedents to the AEDPA question at the heart of this case.

Those objections are answered by the Sixth Circuit’s reasoning, and the Warden’s

defense of it, discussed at length above. Hodge has had his day in court and then

some. Two panels of the Sixth Circuit carefully ruled on his claims over nearly seven

years’ time, after which the full Sixth Circuit disagreed with the second panel following additional briefing and oral argument. It is hard to imagine how Hodge could

have gotten fuller, or fairer, consideration by the Sixth Circuit.

CONCLUSION

The Court should deny the petition for a writ of certiorari.

22

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Matthew F. Kuhn

Office of the Kentucky

Attorney General

1024 Capital Center Drive

Suite 200

Frankfort, KY 40601

(502) 696-5300

Matt.Kuhn@ky.gov

*Counsel of Record

MATTHEW F. KUHN*

Solicitor General

JOHN H. HEYBURN

Principal Deputy

Solicitor General

JACOB M. ABRAHAMSON

Deputy Solicitor General

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.