Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis — Z. G., Petitioner v. M. C.
Supreme Court briefJun 23, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ORIGINAL
No.
FILED
JUN 2 3 2025 .
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
SUPREME COURT, U.S.
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
Z. G. - PETITIONER
VS.
M.C.-RESPONDENT
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS
The petitioner asks leave to file the attached petition for a writ of certiorari
without prepayment of costs and to proceed in forma pauperis.
Please check the appropriate boxes:
□
Petitioner has previously been granted leave to proceed in forma
pauperis in the following courts:
fiZ
Petitioner has not previously been granted leave to proceed in forma
pauperis in any other court.
fif
Petitioner’s affidavit or declaration in support of this motion is
attached hereto.
□
Petitioner’s affidavit or declaration is not attached because the court
below appointed counsel in the current proceeding, and:
□
The appointment was made under the following provision of law:
--------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------- - or
a copy of the order of appointment is appended
(Signature)
RECEIVED
AUG 2 7 2025
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
SUPREME COURT, US,
AFFIDAVIT OR DECLARATION
IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED
* IN FORMA PAUPERIS
I, Zachary P. Gelacek, am the petitioner in the above-entitled case. In
support of my motion to proceed in forma pauperis, I state that because of my
poverty I am unable to pay the costs of this case or to give security therefor,' and I
believe I am entitled to redress.
1. For both you and your spouse estimate the average amount of money received
from each of the following sources during the past 12 months. Adjust any amount
that was received weekly, biweekly, quarterly, semiannually, or annually to show
the monthly rate. Use gross amounts, that is, amounts before any deductions of tax
or otherwise.
Income source
Aver age monthly amount during
the p>ast 12 months
Amount expected
next month
You
Spouse
You
Spouse
Employment
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Self-employment
$ 2,303.08
N/A
Income from real
property
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Interest and dividends
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Gifts
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Alimony
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Child Support
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Retirement
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Disability
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Unemployment payments? 0
N/A
$0
N/A
Public-assistance
$0 .
N/A
$0
N/A
Other: refund, savings
$ 351.66
N/A
$0
N/A
Total monthly income:
$ 2,654.74
N/A
$ 2,909.96
N/A
' $2,909.96
N/A
2. List your employment history for the past two years, most recent first. (Gross
monthly pay is before taxes or other deductions.)
Employer
Address
Date of
Employment
Gross monthly pay
Self (Gelacek
Legal Services
LLC)
310 Grant Street,
Suite 2901,
Pittsburgh, PA
15219
April 2021 present
$2,303.08 (past 12
months)
3. List your spouse’s employment history for the past two years, most recent
employer first. (Gross monthly pay is before taxes or other deductions).
Employer
Address
Date of
Employment
Gross monthly pay
N/A
4. How much case do you and your spouse have? $ 1,300.00
Below, state any money you or your spouse have in bank accounts oi’ in any other
financial institution.
Type of account (e.g., checking or
Amount you have Amount spouse has
savings)
Compass Savings Bank checking x2366
$ 300
N/A
Huntington Bank
(Gelacek Legal Services LLC operating
checking account x0908)
$4,551.09 N/A
5. List the assets, and their values, which you own or your spouse owns. Do not list
clothing and ordinary household furnishings.
_____ Home
Value N/A
Motor Vehicle #1
Year, make & model 2018 Subaru
Value $ 3,000
Forester
Other assets
Description N/A
Value N/A
_____ Other real estate
Value N/A
Motor Vehicle #2
Year, make & model N/A
Value N/A
6. State every person, business, or organization owing you or your spouse money,
and the amount owed.
Person owing you or
your spouse money
Amount owed to you
Amount owed to your
spouse
Monica R. Costlow
$90,000 (restricted
retirement funds)
N/A
7. State the persons who rely on you or your spouse for support. For minor children,
list initials instead of names (e.g., “J.S.” instead of “John Smith”).
Name
Relationship
Age
P.G.
Son
13
L.G.
Daughter
11
8. Estimate the average monthly expenses of your and your family. Show
separately the amounts paid by your spouse. Adjust any payments that are made
weekly, biweekly, quarterly, or annually to show the monthly rate.
You
Your spouse
$0
N/A
Utilities (electricity, heating fuel,
water, sewer, and telephone)
$ 100
N/A
Home maintenance (repairs and upkeep)
$0
N/A
Food
$950
N/A
Clothing
$50
N/A
Laundry and dry-cleaning
$ 100
N/A
Medical and dental expenses
$ 100
N/A
Transportation (not including motor vehicle
payments)
$60
N/A
Recreation, entertainment, newspapers,
magazines, etc.
$85
N/A
Rent or home-mortgage payment
(include lot rented for mobile home)
Are real estate taxes included? N/A
Is property insurance included? N/A
You
Your spouse
Insurance (not deducted from wages or included in mortgage payments)
Homeowner’s or renter’s
$0
N/A
Life
$0
N/A
Health
$600
N/A
Motor Vehicle
$0
N/A
$0
N/A
Other:
___________
Taxes (not deducted from wages or included in mortgage payments)
(specify): N/A
$0
N/A
Motor Vehicle
$0
N/A
Credit card(s)
$0
N/A
Department store(s)
$0
N/A
Other: N/A
$0
N/A
Installment payments
Alimony, maintenance, and support paid to others $ 2,100
N/A
Regular expenses for operation of business,
profession, or farm (attach detailed statement)
$0
N/A
Other (specify): N/A
$0
N/A
Total monthly expenses:
$ 4,145
N/A
9. Do you expect any major changes to your monthly income or expenses or in your
assets or liabilities during the next 12 months?
No
Yes
If yes, describe on an attached sheet
10. Have you paid — or will you be paying — an attorney any money for services in
connection with this case, including the completion of this form?
Yes
No
If yes, how much? N/A
If yes, state the attorney’s name, address, and telephone number: N/A
11. Have you paid—or will you be paying—anyone other than an attorney (such as a
paralegal or a typist) any money for services in connection with this case, including
the completion of this form?
Yes
No
If yes, how much? N/A
If yes, state the person’s name, address, and telephone number: N/A
12. Provide any other information that will help explain why you cannot pay the
costs of this case.
My current monthly liabilities far exceed my current monthly earnings and I
therefore am insolvent. The jurist whose actions are at issue in this action also is
presiding over the action in which my monthly child support obligation was set.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on August 22, 2025
(Signature)
No.
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
Z. G.,
Petitioner,
v.
M. C.,
Respondent.
On Petition For A Writ of Certiorari
To The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Volume 1
Zachary Gelacek
Pro Se Petitioner
511 Neale Avenue
Ford City, PA 16226
(724) 664-5022
TABLE OF APPENDICES
Page
VOLUME 1
APPENDIX A: Opinion of Superior Court of Pennsylvania
(Dec. 30, 2024)....................... ................. ....................................... la
APPENDIX B: Opinion of Trial Court Regarding Petitioner’s Custody
Action (Aug. 5, 2024)............................................................. .....18a
APPENDIX C- Order of Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
(Mar. 24, 2025)............................................................................ 144a
VOLUME 2
APPENDIX D: Petition for Recusal (Oct. 12, 2023).................................... 145a
APPENDIX E: Written Narrative and Proposed Order (Oct. 11, 2023)... 159a
APPENDIX F: Order of Judge Henry-Taylor Regarding Recusal
(Oct. 12, 2023)..............................................................................174a
APPENDIX G: Order of Judge Henry-Taylor Regarding Recusal
(Oct. 16, 2023)..............................
...176a
APPENDIX H: Renewed Petition for Recusal (Apr. 8, 2024)..................... 177a
APPENDIX P Order of Judge Henry-Taylor Regarding Recusal
(Apr. 8, 2024)............................
203a
APPENDIX J: Motion for Reconsideration of Petition for Recusal
(May 13, 2024)............
208a
APPENDIX K: Order of Judge Henry-Taylor Regarding Recusal
(June 21, 2024)........................................................................... 226a
APPENDIX L: Order of Judge Henry-Taylor Regarding Recusal
(June 28, 2024)........................................................................... 229a
1a
J-A26015-24
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
Z. G.
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
Appellant
:
v.
M. C.
:
No. 761 WDA 2024
Appeal from the Order Entered June 4, 2024
In the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County Family Court at
No(s): FD No. 21-007339-007
BEFORE: BOWES, J., MURRAY, J., and BENDER, P.J.E.
.
■
*
'
-..'I'
.
■
FILED: December 30, 2024
MEMORANDUM BY BOWES, J.:
Z.G. ("Father") appeals pro se from the order that denied his complaint
for custody and petition for modification, and instead gave sole legal and
physical custody to M.C. ("Mother"), as it relates to the parties' two minor
children, with Father having supervised visitation. We affirm.
Father does not challenge the merits of the custody decision, nor
whether giving Mother sole custody is in the best interests of their children.
Instead, the focus of Father's appeal is how the trial court treated Father and
the conditions it imposed upon Father. Accordingly, we need not delve into
the specifics of the protracted and tumultuous custody battle underlying this
appeal, and instead provide the following abbreviated history.
Father and Mother married in 2011, separated in 2016, and divorced in
2023. Of note, Father's substance use disorder contributed to the dissolution
of the marriage and continued to be a concern "throughout the pendency of
Appendix A
"AppendfiTA"
3a
J-A26015-24
court reiterated that it would not be considered until properly filed.
Notwithstanding the court's directives, Father emailed another motion in
limine to exclude Dr. Bliss's testimony on April 6, 2024. The court did not
entertain this motion.
On April 9, 2024, the custody trial proceeded as scheduled. However,
immediately prior to commencement, Father had a disagreement with court
staff in the hallway outside the courtroom about who was permitted inside
during the trial.
This interaction was not transcribed and there is some
disagreement as to what precisely occurred.
From what we can discern,
Father sought to have specific family members present in the courtroom as
an accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA") because
the trial court's behavior in past hearings had caused him to suffer posttraumatic stress disorder. He also intended to have his brother appear as his
attorney. The trial court determined that as of April 9, 2024, no individual
had entered an appearance on behalf of Father, he had not requested an
accommodation pursuant to the ADA, and the children's guardian ad litem
("GAL") and Mother's counsel did not consent to the participation of Father's
brother as his attorney. Therefore, "[c]ourt staff informed Father that only he
may be permitted in the [c]ourtroom, but his 'support person' and family
members may be permitted to watch the trial via Microsoft Teams." Order,
4/10/24.
Father did not enter the courtroom that day. He was twice paged over
the courthouse's intercom system, but he did not respond and did not appear
- 3 -
Appendix A
4a
J-A26015-24
for the scheduled custody trial either in person or through Microsoft Teams.
Therefore, the trial was conducted in Father's absence, with Dr. Bliss, Mother,
and the GAL as the sole witnesses. The following day, the court entered an
order memorializing this series of events, closing the custody record,
cancelling the April 11, 2024 trial date, and indicating that a decision would
be forthcoming.
The trial court issued its final custody order on May 23, 2024.1 Therein,
it granted sole legal and physical custody of the children to Mother. Father
was provided supervised visitation. As conditions to that visitation, the court
ordered Father to, inter alia, begin reunification counseling and submit to a
hair follicle test seven days before the first visit. Mother and Father both filed
additional motions, which the court declined to address once Father initiated
this appeal.
He raised thirteen issues in his Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) concise
statement of errors, which the trial court thoroughly addressed in its Rule
1925(a) opinion.
In this Court, Father presents five issues for our
consideration:
I.
Whether the trial court committed reversible error by
permitting at trial the testimony of an expert witness who
was appointed - over Father's objection - in response to a
petition of Mother that was adjudicated and resolved by a
trial judge who subsequently recused herself from this
action because of her pre-existing social relationship with
Mother[.]
1 We quashed Father's initial appeal from the interim order entered on April
11, 2024. See Order, 8/5/24 (quashing appeal at 576 WDA 2024).
- 4 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
5a
IL
Whether the trial court committed reversible error and/or
violated Father's constitutional and statutory rights by
denying Father's attorney's attempt to enter an appearance
before the April 9, 2024, trial held in this matter.
III.
Whether Father's fundamental constitutional right to parent
his children and participate in their upbringing, other
fundamental rights of Father, and/or Father's rights under
the ADA were violated by the manner in which the trial court
disposed of his petition for custody in various respects.
IV.
Whether the trial court committed reversible error by virtue
of the procedure through which the presiding jurist
addressed Father's petitions for recusal as well as the
presiding jurist's refusal to recuse herself from any further
participation in this action after she made several
unprofessional and entirely unwarranted accusations about
Father.
V.
Whether the standard operating procedures ... of the trial
court were applied in a manner that constitutes an abuse of
discretion.
Father's brief at 6-7 (capitalization altered, reordered for ease of disposition).
We review custody orders "for a gross abuse of discretion." Rogowski
v. Kirven, 291 A.3d 50, 60 (Pa.Super. 2023) (cleaned up). We will only find
that kind of abuse "if the trial court, in reaching its conclusion, overrides or
misapplies the law, or exercises judgment which is manifestly unreasonable,
or reaches a conclusion that is the result of partiality, prejudice, bias, or illwill as shown by the evidence of record." Id. (cleaned up).
As noted, Father does not challenge the substance of the custody order
or the merits of the court's best-interest determination.
Rather, he attacks
several ancillary aspects of the underlying custody proceedings, including the
custody trial and the school choice hearing, both of which he failed to attend.
- 5 -
Appendix A
6a
J-A26015-24
In light of his non-participation, the trial court urges us to find many of
Appellant's claims waived. Our Supreme Court has explained that "[i]n order
to preserve an issue for appellate review, a litigant must place a timely,
specific objection on the record.
Issues that are not preserved by specific
objection in the lower court are waived." Jones v. Ott, 191 A.3d 782, 787
(Pa. 2018) (cleaned up); see also Pa.R.A.P. 302(a) ("Issues not raised in the
trial court are waived and cannot be raised for the first time on appeal.").
With these two principles in mind, we consider Father's issues in turn to
(1) whether they are properly before us and, (2) if they are,
determine:
whether Father is entitled to relief.
Admissibility of Expert Testimony
Beginning with the admissibility of Dr. Bliss's testimony, we observe that
Father clearly did not lodge a contemporaneous objection to her testimony
because he elected not to attend the custody trial. Nonetheless, Father insists
that he preserved this issue through his pre-trial motion in limine.
See
Father's brief at 84. As explained above, the motions in limine that Father
purported to file to exclude her testimony violated the court's case
management order and its subsequent order precluding him from filing such
a motion.
Pennsylvania courts have long upheld the import of adhering to
deadlines within case management orders: "[T]hese deadlines are far from
meaningless.
They are court orders!, and w]hen these deadlines are
violated with impunity, . . . the abusing party must be prepared to pay the
consequences."
Kurian ex ret. Kurian v. Anisman, 851 A.2d 152, 162
- 6 -
Appendix A
J-A26015-24
7a
(Pa.Super. 2004) (emphasis in original).
Since no motion concerning the
admissibility of Dr. Bliss's testimony was properly presented to, or considered
by, the trial court, no motion preserved the issue. Thus, we deem it waived.
New Attorney's Entry of Appearance
We turn next to Father's issue regarding the court's decision as to
whether his brother could represent him at the custody trial. The underlying
premise, that Father's brother attempted to enter an appearance as his
attorney and Father objected to the rejection, is not supported by the record.
At the relevant time, Father had been proceeding pro se.
However, he
maintains that on the morning of the trial, he tried to have his brother enter
his appearance as his attorney of record to the court staff present in the
hallway, and that he objected to the court's rejection of this request to the
same staff member. See Father's brief at 83.
Despite his averments as to what happened off the record in the
hallway, the record evidence reveals that:
(1) his brother never entered a
written appearance pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1012 or otherwise file a pleading on
behalf of Father,2 (2) his brother did not enter an oral appearance on the
2 Rule 1012(a) denotes how to enter a written appearance, though that is not
the exclusive means for entering one's appearance as the attorney of record:
Although Rule 1012 provides that an attorney "may" enter a
written appearance, it does not require an attorney to do so. The
comment to Rule 1012 states that "entry of a written appearance
is not mandatory." Pa.R.C.P. 1012, Cmt. See also Fleck v.
McHugh, 361 A.2d 410, 413 (Pa.Super. 1976) (holding entry of
(Footnote Continued Next Page)
- 7 -
Appendix A
J-A26015-24
8a
record with the trial court, and (3) Father lodged no record objection to any
purported off-the-record denial of an attempted entry of appearance. Voicing
disagreement with court staff off the record does not amount to either an
entry of appearance or a timely, contemporaneous, on-the-record objection
to a denial of such entry. Simply stated, there is nothing in the certified record
for us to review as it relates to this issue. Accordingly, it is waived.
Constitutional and ADA Rights
In his third claim of error, Father presents multiple arguments that the
trial court rendered a custody decision in violation of.his rights guaranteed by
the federal constitution and the ADA. See Father's brief at 105. We begin
with his challenge to the school choice decision. Therein, he contends that
the court's ruling, which moved the children's school closer to Mother and
further from Father, "contravened [his] right to enjoy an equal parenting
opportunity" and violated the ADA because he lacks a support network in the
chosen school district. Id. at 109-10. Father had the opportunity to attend
that hearing and voice any concerns but neglected to do so or to ask for a
continuance.3 Accordingly, any challenge to the school choice proceedings
written appearance not required if pleadings provide sufficient
information notifying parties where legal papers may be served).
Mazzuca v. Abreu, 310 A.3d 775, 783 (Pa.Super. 2024) (cleaned up).
3 The record indicates that Father may have missed the hearing due to his
simultaneous participation in an accelerated rehabilitation disposition program
for criminal charges pertaining to driving under the influence of a controlled
(Footnote Continued Next Page)
-8 Appendix A
9a
J-A26015-24
has been waived for failure to first present the issue in the trial court. See
Pa.R.A.P. 302(a).
Next, Father avers that he has a fundamental right to parent his children
and that he is protected by the ADA from negative stereotypes associated with
both his opioid use disorder and receipt of medication-assisted therapy. See
Father's brief at 105-06. Specifically, he assails the court's decision regarding
family therapy services as violative of his parental decision-making. The court
acknowledged Father's right to parent his children, but determined that clear
and convincing evidence established "that he, at times, has been a detriment
to the children's safety." Trial Court Opinion, 8/5/24, at 47. After finding the
issue waived because Father failed to participate in the custody trial, the court
expanded thusly:
Th[e trial] court has fairly given Father the ability to participate in
every proceeding and listened to both parents; Father has made
the decision to either not show up in proceedings or not behave
in a calm fashion. Based on Father's actions, th[e trial] court
correctly placed the children with Mother, placed conditions on
Father's physical custody, and disallowed him from participating
in such decisions that were for the welfare of the children.
Id. Our review of the record reveals that the court conscientiously considered
the particular circumstances in this case throughout its history, and did not
rely
upon
impermissible
stereotypes.
Since
the
record
belies
the
underpinnings of Father's claim, he is not entitled to relief.
substance. Notwithstanding the legitimacy of this other engagement, the fact
remains that Father neither attended the pre-scheduled school choice hearing
nor sought a continuance of that hearing based upon his criminal court
obligations.
-9 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
10 a
In his penultimate sub-argument, Father claims that the court abridged
his free speech rights by imposing guidelines on how the parties were to
communicate. See Father's brief at 110. Critically, Father does not elucidate
what guidelines curtailed these rights.
Therefore, he has waived any
challenge in this regard for lack of development.4 See Commonwealth v.
Armolt, 294 A.3d 364, 377 (Pa. 2023) ("[When an appellant] fails to develop
the issue in any other meaningful fashion capable of review, that claim is
waived.
It is not the obligation of an appellate court to formulate an
appellant's arguments for him." (cleaned up)).
Finally, Father attacks the court's requirement that he submit to hair
follicle testing as non-compliant with the ADA because it is inaccurate,
invasive, and imposes an onerous financial burden. See Father's briefat 11113.
He insists that "[n]either Mother nor the trial court has shown any
4 Even if not waived, he would not be entitled to relief. In First Amendment
cases, "an appellate court has an obligation to make an independent
examination of the whole record in order to make sure that the judgment does
not constitute a forbidden intrusion on the field of free expression." S.B. v.
S.S., 243 A.3d 90, 104 (Pa. 2020) (cleaned up). What we glean from the
record is that the trial court required the parties to only communicate through
the Our Family Wizard application. It is well-settled that "[r]estrictions on the
time, place and manner of expression, whether oral, written or symbolized by
conduct, are a form of a content-neutral regulation of speech," Id. at 105
(cleaned up). Such restrictions pass constitutional muster if they: "(1) are
justified without reference to the content of the regulated speech; (2) are
narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest unrelated to
speech; and (3) leave open ample alternative channels for communication of
the information." Id. (cleaned up). Here, the court imposed this guideline
after Mother sought relief from Father's inflammatory and threatening text
and email messages. Given the context and the reasonableness of the
restriction, we conclude that it withstands constitutional scrutiny.
- 10 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
11a
objective evidence - which the ADA requires - that demonstrates why hair
follicle testing must be employed here father than the urine testing that Father
already submits to through his treatment program[.]"
Id. at 113.
Consequently, Father asks us to ban the trial court from forcing him to submit
to any more such tests. Id.
Notably, Father's concise statement set forth a single issue pertaining
to the hair-follicle testing:
Whether this Court committed reversible error by subjecting
Father, at Mother's behest, to invasive, inherently-unreliable,
hair-follicle testing by a purported forensic laboratory that
previously had its license to conduct forensic testing revoked due
to unscientific practices in which it engaged in connection with a
criminal action before the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia
County, Pennsylvania.
Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) statement, 6/24/24, at 51 11.
the ADA nor to the urine testing.
He makes no reference to
In a similar vein, his complaint about the
ADA violations does not explicitly mention the hair-follicle testing. In order to
find this issue preserved, we would need to extrapolate from "the conditions
th[e trial c]ourt placed on Father's exercise of physical custody of the children"
as referencing the hair-follicle testing. Id. at U 4. The court has historically
imposed many such conditions, including supervised visitation, reunification
counseling, random drug screens, prohibiting Father from driving the children,
and restricting Father from consuming alcohol or illicit substances within
twenty-four hours of his custodial time. Notably, the court did not interpret
any of Father's issues as challenging ADA complicity of the hair follicle testing.
- 11 Appendix A
12a
J-A26015-24
Plainly, the argument Father presents on appeal regarding the hair-follicle
testing was not presented to the trial court. Accordingly, it is waived.5 See
Pa.R.A.P. 302(a).
Standard Operating Procedures
In his next issue, Father argues "that the trial court enforced its
[standard operating procedures] in a manner that would inflict maximum
damage to Father's position at any given time." Father's brief at 115.
He
does not specify which procedures were improperly enforced or which
sanctions were too extreme, but rather contends summarily that the court
abused its discretion because it held Father accountable for what he deemed
to be merely minor deviations from the court's procedures. As such, Father
waived this issue by not developing it.6 See Armolt, 294 A.3d at 377.
5 We note that had Father not waived this issue, he still would not be entitled
to relief. The ADA provides that "no qualified individual with a disability shall,
by reason of such disability, be excluded from participation in or be denied the
benefits of the services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or be
subjected to discrimination by any such entity." 42 U.S.C.A. § 12132. The
regulations interpreting this provision ensure that "charges for services violate
the ADA (1) when the fee pays for services required by the ADA; and (2) when
nondisabled people do not also incur the fee." Robishaw v. The Providence
Prob. Ct., 206 F. Supp. 3d 723, 730-31 (D.R.I. 2016) (citing 28 C.F.R.
§ 35.130(f)). The hair follicle testing in this case fails both requirements. It
is not a service compelled by the ADA, and any individual, regardless of
whether they suffer from opioid use disorder, may be required to pay for the
testing if the court so orders. Accordingly, Father's ADA challenge fails.
6 Even if not waived, the trial court properly imposed its standard operating
procedures upon Father as it would any party, whether represented by counsel
or proceeding pro se. As our Supreme Court has explained:
(Footnote Continued Next Page)
-12Appendix A
J-A26015-24
13a
Motion to Recuse
Finally, Father attacks the court's decision not to recuse itself in the
underlying matter. He highlights several instances of court conduct in August
and September 2023, upon which he based his petitions for recusal.
See
Petition for Recusal, 10/13/23, at 4-6; Father's brief at 89-90. Father argues
that the trial judge's "comments not only demonstrated animus towards
Father as someone who suffers from a federally-protected disability, they also
reflected stereotypical beliefs about large men who suffer from mental and
behavioral health issues and included comments that contained a racial
component such as [the] remark that Father appeared 'flushed.'"7 Id. at 94-
Under Pennsylvania law, pro se [litigants] are subject to the same
rules of procedure as are represented [litigants]. Although the
courts may liberally construe materials filed by a pro se litigant,
pro se status confers no special benefit upon a litigant, and a court
cannot be expected to become a litigant's counsel or find more in
a written pro se submission than is fairly conveyed in the pleading.
Commonwealth v. Blakeney, 108 A.3d 739, 766 (Pa. 2014) (cleaned up).
Father, a licensed attorney, chose to represent himself at various times during
the custody proceedings. He was held to the same standards as any pro se
litigant, with or without formal legal training and practical experience. The
trial court was not required to grant him any special treatment when he failed
to abide by those procedures and certainly did not abuse its discretion in not
granting him leniency. Further, our review of the record revealed no instances
where the court imposed an outlandish sanction for Father's non-compliance.
7 To clarify, Father maintains that the "flushed" comment had "a definite racial
component" because Father is white and the trial judge is "a woman of
color[,]" "only people of certain skin tones are capable of being described as
'flushed,'" and the judge had no medical training that would otherwise enable
her to opine on his appearance. See Father's brief at 95 n.48. If anything,
we find Father's statements to have not only a racial, but a racist, component,
which we vehemently condemn.
- 13 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
95. He insists that he presented ample evidence to demonstrate that the trial
judge's impartiality may reasonably be questioned in this custody matter, and
that he was entitled to a hearing to present witness testimony on his recusal
request. Id. at 92, 95.
Regarding the procedure employed, it is well-settled that "recusal
motions are routinely addressed in the first instance by the judge whose
recusal is sought." Commonwealth v. Dip, 221 A.3d 201, 208 (Pa.Super.
2019) (citation omitted). Consequently:
[I]t cannot be the case that any question of fact even remotely
involving a judge's impartiality requires a separate hearing before
a separate judge. Instead, the general rule is that a party seeking
the recusal of a judge, at a minimum, must satisfy a burden of
production and persuasion to show that the recusal claim is not
frivolous. This may require the presentation of witnesses or
evidence before the judge whose recusal is sought.
Id. (cleaned up).
However, "where fabricated, frivolous[,] or scurrilous
charges are raised against the presiding judge during the course of the
proceeding, the court may summarily dismiss those objections without
hearing where the judge is satisfied that the complaint is wholly without
foundation." Id. at 209 (cleaned up); see also Commonwealth v. Cherpes,
520 A.2d 439, 447 (Pa.Super. 1987) (rejecting outright appellant's claim that
the court was required to hold an evidentiary hearing on a recusal motion).
We consider substantive challenges to the denial of a recusal motion
pursuant to the following principles:
[O]ur review of a trial court's denial of a motion to recuse is
exceptionally deferential. We recognize that our trial judges are
- 14 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
15a
honorable, fair[,] and competent, and although we employ an
abuse of discretion standard, we do so recognizing that the judge
himself is best qualified to gauge his ability to preside impartially.
A trial judge should grant the motion to recuse only if a doubt
exists as to his or her ability to preside impartially or if impartiality
can be reasonably questioned.
In order to prevail on a motion for recusal, the party seeking
recusal is required to produce evidence establishing bias,
prejudice[,] or unfairness which raises a substantial doubt as to
the jurist's ability to preside impartially.
Int. ofL.V., 209 A.3d 399, 415 (Pa.Super. 2019) (cleaned up).
Here, the court entertained Father's arguments regarding his recusal
motion during a previously scheduled judicial conciliation hearing because
"[ijt's very hard to get court dates in this district[.]"
N.T. Conciliation,
10/16/23, at 5-6. Father argued that some of the trial judge's actions evinced
"stereotypical and biased and prejudiced beliefs towards people who suffer
from opioid use disorder and potentially also due to [his] gender as someone
who identifies as male." Id. at 6. He averred that while similarly situated pro
se women had been "treated with compassion and grace" for admitting to
custody violations, he had been "humiliated" and "shamed in front of [his]
peers in the legal community[.]" Id. at 6-7. Father further maintained that
throughout the custody proceedings the judge had focused on his addiction
instead of the best interests of the children.3 Id. at 7.
Mother's counsel wholly refuted Father's accusations, characterizing
them as "untrue[,]" "impertinent[,]" and "slanderous to the court." Mother's
8 Tellingly, we reiterate that Father has elected not to challenge the court's
best-interests analysis in this Court.
- 15 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
16a
brief at 9; see also Answer to Petition for Recusal, at U 47 ("Father's [p]etition
recites offensive, impertinent, and slanderous allegations against this [c]ourt
that are entirely untrue. Father's lies are not a basis for this [c]ourt to recuse
itself."). The GAL added that she "ha[d] not seen any indications of bias that
[she was] concerned about" and that introducing a new judge at the time
Father filed the motion would not have been in the children's best interest.
See N.T. Judicial Conciliation, 10/16/23, at 10. Ultimately, as noted, the court
denied the recusal motion.
It did not rule upon Father's renewed motions
immediately preceding the custody trial because they were not properly filed.
Based on the foregoing, we discern no error in how the court considered
Father's recusal request. The statements Father attributes to the trial judge
do not appear of record and, in any event, were refuted by Mother's counsel.
The certified record we have reviewed contains no evidence warranting a
reasonable person to question the trial judge's impartiality in the custody
proceedings. Therefore, we conclude that the trial court did not err in denying
Father's recusal petition, and he is not entitled to relief on this issue.
Based on the foregoing, Father has not convinced us of any reason to
disturb the court's custody order. Accordingly, we affirm.
Order affirmed.
- 16 Appendix A
J-A26015-24
17a
Judgment Entered.
Benjamin D. Kohler, Esq.
Prothonotary
12/30/2024
- 17 Appendix A
' 18a
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
FAMILY DIVISION
ZACHARY GELACEK,
OPINION
CHILDREN’S FAST TRACK APPEAL
Plaintiff/Appellant,
No.:
V.
FD-21-007339-007
Sup. Ct. No. 761 WDA 2024
MONICA COSTLOW,
Defenadnt/Appellee.
BY:
The Honorable Nicola Henry-Taylor
City-County Building, Room 712
414 Grant Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15219.
COPIES TO:
Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Bobbi Jo Wagner, Esq.
Deputy Prothonotary
310 Grant Street, Suite 600
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Self-Represented Plaintiff/Appellant:
Zachary Gelacek
511 Neale Avenue
Ford City, Pennsylvania 16226
(724) 664-5022
tn
O
UJ
jc
Counsel for Defendant/Appellee:
Brian E. McKinley, Esquire
Wilder Mahood McKinley & Oglesby
436 7lh Avenue, 10lh Floor
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219
(412) 261-4040
Guardian ad Litem:
Alyson Landis, Esquire
Boyer Paulick Eberle & Biss
108 E. Diamond Street, 3rd Floor
Butler, PA 16001
(724) 283-0077
Appendix B
19a
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
FAMILY DIVISION
ZACHARY GELACEK,
Plaintiff/Appellant,
No.: FD-21-007339-007
Sup. Ct. No. 761 WDA 2024
v.
MONICA COSTLOW,
Defendant/Appellee.
OPINION
August 5, 2024
Judge Nicola Henry-Taylor
Zachary Gelacek (“Father”) appeals from an Order of Court entered on May
23,2024.1 The Order denied his Complaint in Custody and Petition for Modification
of Custody. The Order granted sole legal custody and sole physical custody of the
parties’ children, P.G. (DOB: 06/26/2012) and L.G. (DOB: 03/11/2014)
(“Children”), to Monica Costlow (“Mother”), with Father having supervised
visitation with the Children four (4) hours per week upon the satisfaction of the
following requirements: (1) Father contact the reunification counselor to begin
counseling with the Children, (2) once the reunification counselor recommends that
the Children be integrated, Father would complete an eighteen (18) panel hair
1 Father initially appealed the interim Order of Court entered after the conclusion of trial, which indicated that
findings were forthcoming. The appeal was quashed by this Honorable Court. See docket 564 WDA 2024.
2
Appendix B
20a
follicle test within seven (7) days of the first session with the Children, and (3) Father
continue mental health treatment and substance abuse treatment and provide a copy
of the custody evaluator’s evaluation to his providers. Visitation could be expanded
upon the recommendation of the reunification counselor.
The court further ordered that Father could not file a Custody Complaint or
Petition for Modification until he showed proof to the Guardian ad Litem (GAL) and
the undersigned of his compliance with completing substance abuse treatment that
addresses co-occurring disorders and following all recommendations, engaging in
mental health treatment with a doctor that can prescribe medication, and completing
reunification counseling.
,
I.
Factual Background
A one (1) day custody trial was held in this matter on April 9, 2024. Plaintiff,
Zachary Gelacek (“Father”), and Defendant, Monica Costlow (“Mother”) are the
natural parents of two (2) minor children, Peter Gelacek (DOB: 06/26/2012) and
Louisa Gelacek (DOB: 03/11/2014) (“Children”), who are the subject of these
proceedings. Mother presently resides in Upper St. Clair, Allegheny County,
Pennsylvania with her significant other, Andrew Dittoe. Father presently resides in
Ford City, Armstrong County, Pennsylvania with Paternal Grandmother and
Paternal Step-Grandfather.
3
Appendix B
21a
I
1. Background of the Parties
The parties are highly educated, and they met while attending law school at
the University of Pittsburgh. Mother is currently employed as a Regulatory Policy
Analyst with the University of Pittsburgh. Father is currently employed in a solo
practitioner law practice.
Father has struggled to maintain stability in his
employment and housing situation due to substance use disorder. His longest job
was at Reed Smith for approximately eight (8) years; however, he was fired due to
difficulties functioning when his substance use increased.2 The Pennsylvania
Disciplinary Board has required him to address his substance use disorder through
treatment. He was evicted from his apartment in December 2019 due to financial
issues related to his addiction.
The parties were married on April 9, 2011, separated in May 2016 and
divorced on April 19, 2023. The marriage ended, at least in part, due to Father’s
substance use disorder, co-occurring mental health issues, and related dysfunction.
The evidence at trial reflected that Father continued to misuse substances, including,
but not limited to, heroin and fentanyl after the separation and throughout the
pendency of the custody case. Specifically, after the custody evaluation was
2 This information was self-reported by Father to Dr. Beth Bliss, and is reflected in her custody evaluation dated
May 26,2023. In various proceedings, Father became upset when the court would ask him about the status of his
law license and any possible interactions with the Disciplinary Board. Father filed multiple Petitions requesting that
the undersigned recuse herself from this matter, averring that these comments showed bias against him. The
Petitions were denied.
4
Appendix B
22a
completed, Father was arrested in June 2023 for driving under the influence of
fentanyl and other controlled substances. Further compounding the concerns
regarding his sobriety, he tested positive in a court mandated drug test for fentanyl
in October 2023.
2. History ofFather's Parenting Time
With respect to parenting time with the children, Father has not had overnight
custody of the children at any point since the parties’ separation. As of the day of
trial, Father’s last parenting time occurred on or around September 30, 2023. Since
that time, Father has not had any supervised visits with the Children, despite the fact
that he has permission by the Court to enjoy supervised visitation. With respect to
phone contact, P.G. called Father a few times in October and November 2023, and
L.G. called Father on Christmas Day 2023. Father has only initiated one (1) call to
the Children—a call to L.G. on her birthday. Regardless of whether the Children or
Father initiates the call, the calls only last two to three (2-3) minutes in duration.
Father did not send the Children any Christmas or birthday gifts. Dr. Bliss opined
that Father “cannot put [the Children’s] needs above his own,” which may explain
why Father has not had visits with the Children since October 2023. Father’s
objection to the fact that the Court has increased supervision and decreased the
duration of the visits is more important to him than spending any time with the
Children. It appears that Father has not made any fruitful attempt since that time to
5
Appendix B
23a
remain in contact with the Children, either through in person visits or phone or video
calls.
The history, of Father’s custody schedule, and parenting time, with the
children has been tumultuous. The parties were first before the court for an Interim
Relief Hearing before Hearing Officer Laura Valles. Following the Interim Relief
Hearing, an Order of Court was issued on June 9, 2021. This Order directed that
Father would have supervised partial physical custody with the Children every
Wednesday from 4:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. and Saturday from 12:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.
Father’s custodial time would be supervised by Paternal Grandmother, Paternal
Step-Grandfather, or a mutually agreed on third party. The Court addressed Father’s
substance use disorder from the onset and required Father to submit to random drug
screens through Mainline Drug Testing Services and scheduled a Review Hearing
before Hearing Officer Laura Valles. By consent, the parties entered into an Interim
Order of Court, on September 22, 2021, and agreed that Father would continue to
have supervised partial physical custody. Father was to continue with random drug
screens, and Mother could request that Father undergo a hair follicle test.
On January 6, 2023, Mother submitted a Motion for Custody Evaluation. In
her Motion, Mother averred that Father failed to exercise all of the visitation periods
provided in the Interim Orders, and when Father did exercise his custody time,
Paternal Grandmother and Paternal Step-Grandfather did not properly supervise
6
Appendix B
24a
Father. Father continued to have supervised custody with his mother supervising
until July 2023 when Mother submitted an Emergency Petition for Special Relief.
In her Emergency Petition, Mother averred that Father was arrested on June
16, 2023 and charged with 75 Pa.C.S.A. §§3802(d)(l)&(2) (relating to Driving
Under the Influence of Controlled Substances). Mother stated that Father concealed
this from her and has continued to drive the Children during his partial custody time.
In addition, Mother averred that Father was left unsupervised during his custodial
periods and that the Children have observed Father drink alcohol during his visits.
Mother requested that Father’s custodial periods be suspended, that his visits be
supervised by Happy Child Supervision, and that Father complete a hair follicle test
that covers opiates, heroin, and alcohol, among other substances. The Court issued
an Interim Order on July 28, 2023, stating that Father would be prohibited from
driving a vehicle with the Children present pending oral argument.
As a result of the concerns raised in Mother’s Emergency Petition for Special
Relief, the Court conducted an In Camera Interview with the Children on August 4,
2023. On August 7, 2023, the Court issued an Order directing that the Children
would be registered for and attend the Upper St. Clair School District pending the
School Choice Hearing. On September 15, 2023, Mother submitted another Petition
for Special Relief Regarding Custody and raising some educational issues.
Additionally, Mother averred that Father, Paternal Grandmother, and Paternal Step-
7
Appendix B
25a
Grandfather screamed at, and made disrespectful comments to, the Children during
Father’s custodial periods, and that Father refuses to communicate through Our
Family Wizard despite being ordered to do so. Mother requested that Father execute
any documents for Peter’s evaluation by Upper St. Clair, that his custody periods
only be supervised by Happy Child Supervision, that Father and his family cease
making negative and inappropriate comments to the Children about Mother, and that
Father only communicate with Mother on Our Family Wizard.
On September 25, 2023, Father submitted an Answer to Mother’s Petition. In
his Answer, Father denies the accusations made by Mother and again claimed that
his constitutional rights and his rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
He further averred that the evaluation by Woodland Hills was suggested by staff at
Sacred Heart—that Mother and Father consent to having an Individualized
Education Plan completed through their home school district (which was Woodland
Hills School District at the time). Father also averred that Mother has told the
Children that Father and his family are mentally ill. Father requested that Mother’s
Petition for Special Relief be denied.
On September 26, 2023, in considering all of the above, the undersigned
issued a Memorandum and Order of Court. In its Order, the Court directed that the
parties follow the schedule in the September 21, 2022, Order of Court. Father was
prohibited from using alcohol or illegal or non-prescribed drugs at least twenty-four
8
Appendix B
26a
(24) hours prior to his supervised visits. Father was ordered not to transport the
Children, and to submit to a hair follicle test within twenty-four (24) hours of the
Order. The Order also laid out provisions for phone and video calls with the
Children and for using Our Family Wizard. Father was also ordered to comply with
signing all documents for the school district to meet the Children’s educational needs
and that he would not make negative or inappropriate comments to the Children
about Mother. In addition, on October 2, 2023, the Court ordered Father and the
Children to undergo reunification counseling with Inspiring Change, LLC.
On October 5, 2023, Mother submitted a Second Emergency Petition for
Special Relief Regarding Custody. In this Petition, Mother averred that Father did
not complete the ordered hair follicle test. Mother also averred that the GAL learned
from the Children that Father left his visit to go get “energy drinks;” after Father
returned, he went into a separate room, lied down on the couch, and appeared to be
under the influence. Mother averred that Paternal Grandmother and Paternal Step-
Grandfather did not take action regarding Father’s behavior. Mother again requested
that Father’s custodial time be suspended.
On October 6, 2023, the Court issued an Order directing that pending the
October 16, 2023, Judicial Conciliation, Father’s partial physical custody would be
supervised by Happy Child Supervision. As stated above, Father has not had
parenting time with the children since Happy Child Supervision was designated as
9
Appendix B
27a
.the supervisor. Father has decided that he would rather not visit with the children
than be supervised by Happy Child Supervision.3
3. History ofFather's Conflicts with Professionals Assigned to the Case and
Involved with the Courts
Father has raised concerns about inappropriate behavior regarding almost
everyone involved in the case, starting with Mother, her attorney, the Co-parenting
Counselors, Judge Wagner and ending with the undersigned.
a. Mother
In her Motion for Custody Evaluation, Mother had previously proposed
utilizing Dr. Eric Bernstein as a custody evaluator, which Father rejected. Father
suggested Dr. Arnold Sheinvold, an evaluator based in Harrisburg, which Mother
rejected. At a Review Conciliation on December 19, 2022, Father refused to sign a
Consent Order to allow Allegheny Forensic Associates to conduct the evaluation,
claiming that their evaluations were “inadequate.” Mother averred that Father was
trying to circumvent the parties’ prior agreements and the Family Division’s
procedures for appointing custody evaluators. Mother requested that the Court enter
an Order directing the completion of a full custody evaluation by an evaluator at
Allegheny Forensic Associates.
3 Father has previously stated that he did not want Happy Child Supervision to supervise his visits with Children
because the founder of Happy Child Supervision, Susan Dzubinski Gualtieri, was a former Allegheny County
Sheriff’s Deputy.
10
Appendix B
28a
In his Answer to Mother’s Motion for Custody Evaluation, Father averred that
his selection of Dr. Sheinvold as an evaluator was governed by the fact that Mother’s
work supervisor was the Dean of the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Public
Health and that both parties’ fathers are prominent doctors in the western
Pennsylvania medical community—seeming to infer that any evaluator from
Allegheny County would be biased from Mother’s potential connections to the
aforementioned individuals. Father further claimed that Dr. Sheinvold’s evaluation
process is conducted in a more relaxed environment for children and is more diligent
about contacting collateral sources compared to Allegheny Forensic Associates, and
that Allegheny Forensic Associates is severely backlogged in cases.
Mother then submitted a Response to Father’s Counter-Petition.
In her
Response, Mother averred that Father never proposed Dr. Sheinvold as a potential
evaluator. Mother’s counsel had sent Father’s counsel four (4) emails concerning
whether Father would agree to utilize Dr. Eric Bernstein as an evaluator, but only
heard mention ofDr. Sheinvold when Father’s counsel finally responded to Mother’s
counsel.
Mother averred that there was no basis to have Allegheny Forensic
Associates removed as an evaluator for this matter, and claims that Father is trying
to “create a conflict where no conflict exists.”
On September 12, 2023, the school psychologist was attempting to contact
Father regarding his participation in P.G.’s Individual Education Plan (IEP) process.
11
Appendix B
29a
When Father did respond, he made statements claiming that Mother was making
false representations about schooling and about him. On September 20,2023, Father
sent a subsequent email with further accusations that Mother intentionally scheduled
the IEP when she knew that Father had a conflict, and that Mother was “alienating”
P.G.
In October 2023, when this Court ordered that Father’s visits would be
supervised by Happy Child Supervision, after concerns that Paternal Grandparents
were not providing adequate supervision of Father during visits, Father emailed
Mother stating that he would “see her in federal court” and he “would not allow a
sheriff’ to supervise his visits. Father also admitted to Dr. Bliss that he has made
negative statements about Mother to the Children. He told Dr. Bliss that she “has
OCD” and that she wanted to divorce him. The Children would become upset when
they would hear such negative comments, to the point where they would feel
attacked and cry. Father did not see these statements as wrong or having a negative
impact on his relationship with Mother or the Children.
b. Lynn MacBeth, Co-Parenting Coordinator
Father denied verbally abusing Lynn Macbeth during co-parenting sessions,
and claimed that he ended co-parenting counseling sessions based on a letter from
his physician, Dr. Michelle Barwell, stating that Ms. Macbeth’s participation
“contravened ethical rules” given previous interactions with Father (which Father
12
Appendix B
30a
did not detail in his Answer). Father also claimed that raising a negative inference
about his parenting based on his medical treatment would violate the Americans with
Disabilities Act and the U.S. Constitution.
The parties participated in co-parenting counseling with Lynn MacBeth for a
short period of time, until Father claimed that there was a conflict of interest with
Ms. MacBeth after he previously waived any conflict. The basis of his claimed
conflict was that Ms. MacBeth had prior contact with him during a bar association
program assisting attorneys with substance use disorder. The co-parenting sessions
were discontinued by Ms. MacBeth due to Father’s behavior of verbally attacking
Mother and Ms. MacBeth. Ms. MacBeth was not able to regulate and control the
situation sufficiently toxcontinue sessions with the parties. Father denied verbally
abusing Lynn Macbeth during co-parenting sessions, and claimed that he ended co-
parenting counseling sessions based on a letter from his physician, Dr. Michelle
Barwell, stating that Ms. Macbeth’s participation “contravened ethical rules” given
previous interactions with Father.
c. Mother’s Attorney and Judge Henry-Taylor4
In October of 2023, father sent harassing emails to attorney McKinley stating,
“I will be filing a defamation action about these allegations. I have endured enough
4 The undersigned combined the conflicts with Mr. McKinley’s conflicts due to the fact that, other than issues raised
in Father’s pleadings, Father's complaints about the undersigned were addressed in his email correspondence with
Mr. McKinley.
13
Appendix B
31a
abuse at your hands...” Father further stated that “[t]his will be addressed in a
Dragonetti action forthcoming in Armstrong County...please also know that I plan
to file a motion for Judge Henry Taylor to recuse herself in the near future. I also
plan to file complaints against her with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and the
Department of Justice’s Office of Civil Rights...”
Father further went on to state that her actions and comments in the last several
custody hearings have violated his rights under multiple federal laws and are no
different in substance of quality than those of another judge who had left the bench
due to allegations of making racists comments. He stated that he was notifying the
attorney due to the inappropriate use of an Emergency Motion, claiming: “I have a
busy law practice and I do not have time to deal with another emergency motion on
top of all of the other filings currently due. This filing is another step in a campaign
intended to harass and intimidate me from enforcing my constitutionally-guaranteed
rights to parent my children,” as well as retaliation for notifying the Upper Saint
Clair School District of [Mother’s] prior actions in this matter.”
Father’s demand included all communications “to and by Mother, her
paramour, her parents, and anyone else working on his or her respective behalf or as
her or her respective behalves [sic] or as his or her respective agents...any
communications with the Court Administrator’s Office for the Family Division as
14
Appendix B
32a
well as any communications between [Mother’s counsel] and Julie Colton, Todd
Begg, Robert Raver, and/or any other agent of Judge Eaton.”
Father sent Mother’s counsel four (4) separate emails on December 14, 2023,
claiming that the court should not be presiding over this matter and that he will raise
the court's actions to the Supreme Court, federal court, and the Judicial Conduct
Board.
d. Judge Chelsa Wagner
The case was assigned to Judge Chelsa Wagner prior to the undersigned
handling the case. On or around January 12, 2023, Father submitted a Motion for
Recusal of Judge Chelsa Wagner from the custody matter. In his Motion, Father
avered that Mother made statements to Father during the course of their relationship
that she has a “positive relationship” with Judge Wagner, who was allegedly a
classmate of Mother’s at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law. Father further
averred that this “positive relationship” may give the appearance of impropriety or
prejudice based on Mother’s comments. Father requested that Judge Wagner recuse
herself from this matter and that another Family Division judge “with no material
previous relationship with either party or other disqualifying relationship to the
people and matters involved herein” be assigned to this case.
Mother submitted an Answer to Father’s Motion. In her Answer, Mother
denied making any statements to Father about a relationship with Judge Wagner.
15
Appendix B
33a
Mother stated that Judge Wagner had been presiding over the case for a year and
Father never previously filed a Motion for Recusal. Mother requested that the Court
deny Father’s Motion. On January 27, 2023, Judge Wagner denied Father’s Motion
for Recusal and added in her Order that she did not have any recollection of Mother
and that any possible interactions did not impact her impartiality in presiding over
the case and did not merit a recusal.5
In addition, Father engaged in an exchange with Judge Wagner’s law clerk,
wherein Father responded, “Don’t worry bud, your ‘Good luck’ email is going to be
an exhibit. Are you going to self-report your conduct or do I need to file a complaint
about your email?” Judge Wagner’s law clerk responded, “Please feel free to report
my ‘conduct.’ I certainly don’t have anything to self-report. I am not aware that
wishing ‘best of luck’ to a pro se litigant, in navigating the Family Division system
runs afoul of any ethical rules or prohibitions. But, please, by all means, feel free to
do what you think is best.”
e. Randy Brodsky, Mainline Testing Services
As stated above, Father was ordered by this Court on several occasions to
undergo a hair follicle test to test for substances. For the most part, Father refused
to take these tests when ordered. Father was initially ordered to undergo random
drug testing with Mainline Testing Services but was eventually barred from testing
5 Judge Wagner ultimately recused herself from this matter.
I
16
Appendix B
34a
with Mainline due to harassing emails and calls that he sent to Mr. Randy Brodsky.
Mr. Brodsky sent an email to Father stating, “You are out of line here [Father], per
your text messages, that I am in cahoots with anyone. You calling screaming at me
without telling me who you were and then calling me an ‘a-hole’ was very
unprofessional on your part.” Mr. Brodsky followed up with another email banning
Father from further testing with Mainline Testing.
f. Dr. Beth Bliss, Custody Evaluator
The Pre-Trial Conference was held on February 5, 2024 and Father did not
participate in the proceeding. The GAL submitted her Final Report on March 28,
2024. On April 2, 2024, Father submitted an email to Mother’s counsel, the GAL,
and the Court stating that he intended to represent his Petition for Recusal. He
submitted a copy of the Petition with this email, but did not appear to submit it
through the Client Services Center as was required for all self-represented litigants
with cases in Allegheny County’s Family Division, as well as the undersigned’s
Standard Operating Procedures. Later that day, Father submitted a subsequent email
to Mother’s counsel, the GAL, and the Court stating that he would be submitting a
Motion in Limine to exclude Dr. Beth Bliss’s testimony as the court-appointed
custody evaluator because Dr. Bliss became the appointed custody evaluator while
the case was still assigned to Judge Wagner, who later recused.
17
Appendix B
35a
g. Inspiring Change. LLC. Co-Parenting Counselor
An Order of Court issued on October 16, 2023, directed Father and the
Children to undergo reunification counseling with Inspiring Change, LLC. Shortly
after the court-ordered counseling, the court received notice from Inspiring Change,
LLC that they would not be able to provide reunification counseling. Inspiring
Change, LLC handles complex/high-conflict custody cases, and it is not common
for them to terminate work with a family early in the process. The court’s staff sent
the parties, and the GAL, communication and requested that the GAL provide a
position regarding alternative providers.
On October 31, 2023, an Order of Court was issued vacating Inspiring
Change’s appointment and directing that the GAL contact Dr. Deborah Gilman
regarding her ability to conduct reunification counseling. If Dr. Gilman could not
perform it, then the GAL was to contact Dr. Shannon Edwards regarding her ability
to conduct reunification counseling. If Dr. Edwards could not perform it, then the
GAL was to contact the Parenting Institute6 regarding their ability to conduct
reunification counseling. Ultimately, on November 2, 2023, the court issued an
Order appointing Dr. Deborah Gilman to conduct reunification counseling with
6 The parties already saw Lynn MacBeth and the Parenting Institute for co-parenting counseling; however, the court
was running out of options for appropriate services to support the family’s needs.
18
Appendix B
36a
Father and the Children. That counseling never occurred due to Father’s lack of
contact with Dr. Gilman.
II.
Procedural History7
. On April 26, 2023, an Order of Court was issued reassigning this matter to
the undersigned judge. On May 4, 2023, Father submitted a Petition for Contempt
and Special Relief. In his Petition, Father averred that Mother ignored or rejected
his requests regarding therapy and communications with third parties. Father also
averred that Mother has made unilateral medical and educational decisions for the
Children, and that Mother was engaging in parental alienation, disparagement and
degradation of Father, and interfering with Father’s daily video calls with the
Children.
Father requested that Mother pay $5,000.00 in counsel fees, that a
Guardian ad Litem (“GAL”) be appointed for the Children, and that a hearing on
medical and educational decision making be scheduled.
On May 9, 2023, Mother submitted an Answer and New Matter to Father’s
Petition. In her Answer, Mother avers that Father admitted to her as late as January
2021 that he was using drugs. Mother reiterated that Father failed to comply with
random drug screens and co-parenting counseling by delaying screens and sessions
7 The court recognizes that this Procedural History is long and protracted; however, the undersigned believes it is
necessary to include this information to provide context to the events leading up to the Order of Court issued on
May 23, 2024. As such, the trial court will provide some of the procedural history in an Appendix “A” to this
Opinion.
19
Appendix B
37a
and engaging in inappropriate behavior that caused the providers to cease services
with the family.8
Following oral argument, on May 17, 2023, the undersigned issued an Order
of Court directing as follows: (1) the parties would jointly contact Dr. Bliss
concerning the status of the full custody evaluation; (2) neither party would directly
communicate with the other party’s parents or step-parents; (3) a GAL would be
appointed; (4) all other issues raised in Father’s Petition for Contempt and Special
Relief would be consolidated with the custody trial; and (5) counsel would be
prepared to provide documentation of counsel fees when the issue is litigated.
On July 6, 2023, Mother submitted a Praecipe for a Judicial Conciliation
before the undersigned, and a Judicial Conciliation was scheduled for October 16,
2023.
Also on July 6, 2023, Mother submitted a Petition for Special Relief
Regarding Custody.
In her Petition, Mother averred that P.G. experienced
behavioral issues at Sacred Heart Elementary School due to his ADHD, and had to
complete the school year virtually. P.G. needed assistance to meet his needs that
Sacred Heart would not be able to provide. Mother wanted to enroll the Children in
the Upper St. Clair School District, which would offer supports for P.G.’s
8 Mother admits that she refused to do family therapy with Father, but Hearing Officer Valles confirmed that she did
not have to participate due to Father’s conduct. Mother claims Father does not include her in all legal custody
conversations, that Father sent Mother’s parents a letter containing “untrue and defamatory statements” about Mother,
and that Father has made similar allegations to their church and the Children’s school. According to Mother, Father
invokes the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause to justify his conduct.
20
Appendix B
38a
educational needs.
Mother messaged Father asking if he agreed to enroll the
Children in Upper St. Clair, but he did not respond. Mother requested that she be
permitted to enroll the Children in the Upper St. Clair School District and schedule
a school choice hearing.
On July 11,2023, Father submitted an Answer to Mother’s Petition for Special
Relief Regarding Custody.9 In his Answer, Father averred that Mother chose the
Upper St. Clair school district, in part, because her significant other, Andrew Dittoe
lives in that school district. Father suggested that the Children attend the Riverview
School District “where Father has an opportunity to secure residency” or the North
Hills School District.10 Father also averred that having the Children attend school
in Upper St. Clair would frustrate his custodial time as Upper St. Clair is about one
and a half (1 '/a) hours away from Father’s residence in Armstrong County. Father
requested that Mother’s Petition be denied and that the Children remain at Sacred
Heart and/or cyber school until further Order and that the matter be scheduled for a
school choice hearing.
Following oral argument, on July 14, 2023, the undersigned issued an Order
of Court directing as follows: (1) Mother’s Petition for Special Relief was deemed a
Petition for School Choice Hearing; (2) a School Choice Hearing was scheduled for
’ This Answer referred to here does not appear on the Department of Court Records docket.
10 It should be noted that Father was not residing in either of these school district at the time the Petition and Answer
were submitted. Tothis Court’s knowledge, Father’s residence remained in Ford City, Armstrong County for the
entirety of the litigation.
21
Appendix B
39a
August 4, 2023; and (3) pending the School Choice Hearing, both parties could
register the Children for the school district where each parent resides. On July 18,
2023, a Pre-Hearing Order of Court was issued scheduling the matter for a half (1/2)
day School Choice Hearing on August 4, 2023.
Meanwhile, on July 11, 2023, an Order of Court was issued appointing
Kilbreth E. Barton, Esquire as the GAL for the Children. Shortly after this Order
was issued, Court Administration notified the undersigned’s chambers that Ms.
Barton-Rhea could not accept the appointment. As such, an Order of Court was
issued on July 18,2023 vacating Ms. Barton-Rhea’s appointment. On July 24,2023,
an Order was issued appointing Alyson Landis, Esquire as the GAL for the Children.
On July 27,2023, Mother submitted an Emergency Petition for Special Relief.
In her Emergency Petition, Mother averred that Father was arrested on June 16,2023
and charged with 75 Pa.C.S.A. §§3802(d)(l)&(2) (relating to Driving Under the
Influence of Controlled Substances). Mother stated that Father concealed this from
her and has continued to drive the Children during his partial custody time. In
addition, Mother averred that Father was left unsupervised during his custodial
periods and that the Children have observed Father drink alcohol during his visits.11
''Mother requested that Father’s custodial periods be suspended, that his visits be supervised by Happy Child
Supervision, and that Father complete a hair follicle test that covers opiates, heroin, and alcohol, among other
substances. The Court issued an Interim Order on July 28, 2023 stating that Father would be prohibited from driving
a vehicle with the Children present pending oral argument.
22
Appendix B
40a
An Amended Emergency Petition was submitted on July 31, 2023 which contained
additional information regarding the circumstances of Father’s arrest.12 Mother
reiterated her original requested relief.
Following oral argument, on August 2, 2023, the undersigned issued an Order
of Court directing as follows: (1) the School Choice Hearing would be continued to
a later date; (2) an In Camera Interview with the Children would be scheduled for
.August 4, 2023; and (3) Mother’s Emergency Petition would remain under
advisement pending the In Camera Interview.
On July 27, 2023, Father’s then counsel submitted an Expedited Motion to
Withdraw and Continuance.13 Father averred that he would not have enough time
to prepare for the School Choice Hearing due to the “quick scheduling” of the same
and that he would be prejudiced by the lack of time to prepare. Mother’s counsel
submitted a Response on July 31, 2023, averring that Father’s loss of counsel is not
a legitimate basis to continue to School Choice Hearing. Mother requested that
Father’s request for a continuance be denied. An Order of Court was issued on
12 In this Amended Emergency Petition, Mother averred that Father was pulled over by Blawnox Police while
driving. The police officer noticed that Father was sweating profusely and had slurred speech, pinpoint pupils, and
glossy eyes. The police officer called EMS while Father went in and out of consciousness. Father was transported
by ambulance to St. Margaret’s Hospital. At the hospital, blood tests were performed which showed that Father
tested positive for fentanyl, amphetamine, morphine, and methadone. Mother averred that the blood tests confirmed
that Father was using drugs again and that it was not safe for the Children to be left unsupervised with Father.
13 This Motion referred to here does not appear on the Department of Court Records docket.
23
Appendix B
41a
August 2, 2023 permitting Father’s counsel to withdraw on August 5, 2023 and
ordering that the School Choice Hearing be continued.14
The In Camera Interview with the Children was conducted on August 4,2023.
On August 7, 2023, the Court issued an Order directing that the Children would be
registered for and attend the Upper St. Clair School District pending the School
Choice Hearing. On August 14, 2023, a Pre-Hearing Order of Court was issued
scheduling the School Choice Hearing for December 1, 2023.
On September 15, 2023, Mother submitted a Petition for Special Relief
Regarding Custody. In her Petition, Mother averred that the Upper St. Clair School
District conducted a meeting and sent forms which would permit the school district
to evaluate P.G. for educational services. Mother stated that Father initially did not
attend the meeting, and responded to an email from the school that he would not give
permission for P.G. to be evaluated.15 On September 25, 2023, Father submitted an
Answer to Mother’s Petition. In his Answer, Father denies the accusations made by
Mother and again claimed that his constitutional rights and his rights under the
Americans with Disabilities Act.
14 In total, Father was represented by five (5) attorneys during the pendency of this custody litigation. From this
point on, Father was a self-represented litigant.
15 Mother requested that Father execute any documents for Peter’s evaluation by Upper St. Clair, that his custody
periods only be supervised by Happy Child Supervision, that Father and his family cease making negative and
inappropriate comments to the Children about Mother, and that Father only communicate with Mother on Our
Family Wizard.
24
Appendix B
42a
The GAL also submitted a Report on or around September 25, 2023. In her
Report, the GAL details her contact with the family and the issues of P.G.’s school
evaluation, Father’s alleged actions towards Mother, Father’s behavior while the
Children are in his custody, and Father’s DUI charges. The GAL recommended that
Father and the Children enroll in family therapy, that Father and Mother
communicate exclusively in Our Family Wizard, that P.G. be evaluated by the Upper
St. Clair school district, that Father would not make negative^ comments about
Mother to the Children, and that Father would not drive a vehicle with the Children
present.
On September 26, 2023, in considering the above, the undersigned issued a
Memorandum and Order of Court. In its Order, the Court directed that the parties
follow the schedule in the September 21,2022 Order of Court. Father was prohibited
from using alcohol or illegal or non-prescribed drugs at least twenty-four (24) hours
prior to his supervised visits. Father was not to transport the Children, and he was
to submit to a hair follicle test within twenty-four (24) hours of the Order. Father
was also to comply with signing all documents for the school district to meet the
Children’s educational needs and that he would not make negative or inappropriate
comments to the Children about Mother. In addition, on October 2, 2023, the Court
ordered Father and the Children to undergo reunification counseling with Inspiring
Change, LLC.
25
Appendix B
43a
On October 5, 2023, Mother submitted a Second Emergency Petition for
Special Relief Regarding Custody. In this Petition, Mother averred that Father did
not complete the ordered hair follicle test. Mother also averred that the GAL learned
from the Children that Father left his visit to go get “energy drinks;” after Father
returned, he went into a separate room, lied down on the couch, and appeared to be
under the influence. Mother averred that Paternal Grandmother and Paternal Step-
Grandfather did not take action regarding Father’s behavior. Mother again requested
that Father’s custodial time be suspended.16
Father’s Response to this Motion contained a Counter-Petition requesting that
the Court extend the deadline to file a Written Narrative and Proposed Order for the
October 16, 2023 Judicial Conciliation. As an exhibit to his Response, Father
attached the Forensic Chain of Custody and Control form for a five (5) panel and
ETG drug screen performed by Fastest Labs; no results from that test were included,
nor does the form list what substances were tested.
The GAL also submitted an Updated Report on October 6, 2023. In her
Report, the GAL, details the issues of Mother’s Emergency Petition for Special
Relief, school choice, and communication on Our Family Wizard.
The GAL
16 Father submitted an email claiming that he would be filing a defamation action against Mother’s counsel and a
Motion for the undersigned to recuse herself, as well as complaints with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and the
Department of Justice. On October 6,2023, Father submitted a Response raising many of the same points as his
email. He also claimed that this Court did not follow the Rules of Civil Procedure in sending the September 28,
2023 Order via email instead of regular mail. Father averred that Mother was litigating this matter “in a manner
designed to inflict the maximum amount of stress and trauma on Father.”
26
Appendix B
44a
recommended that Father’s custodial time be suspended pending the results of
Father’s hair follicle test, that Father get a hair follicle test that covers opioids, that
Father get make up time if his hair follicle tests were negative, and that Mother be
permitted to renew the Children’s passports.
On October 6, 2023, the Court issued an Order directing that pending the
October 16, 2023 Judicial Conciliation, Father’s partial physical custody would be
supervised by Happy Child Supervision, and that Father would be permitted to
submit his Written Narrative and Proposed Order by October 11, 2023.
On October 12, 2023, Father submitted a Petition for Recusal.
Father
mentioned comments that the undersigned allegedly made concerning his sobriety,
whether Father had reported his arrest and charge to the Disciplinary Board, and
whether he had reached out to Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers or a similar
organization.17 Father claimed that he was treated “like something less than human.”
Father requested that the undersigned recuse herself. An Order of Court was issued
on the same day stating that the Petition would be addressed at the Judicial
Conciliation and that Father had the burden of proof of demonstrating why the
undersigned should recuse herself. Mother submitted a Response on October 13,
2023 denying the allegations that Father made in his Petition. Mother requested that
Father’s Petition for Recusal be denied.
11 Father is employed as an attorney who is licensed to practice in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
27
Appendix B
45a
A Judicial Conciliation was held on October 16, 2023. Mother’s Second
Emergency Petition for Special Relief, Father’s Response, Father’s Petition for
Recusal, and Mother’s Response were all addressed at that time. Following the
Judicial Conciliation, two (2) Orders of Court were issued. The first Order issued
on October 16, 2023 denied Father’s Petition for Recusal. Then, a Memorandum
and Interim & Interlocutory Order of Court was issued on October 18, 2023. In this
Order, Mother was to have primary physical custody. Father was to have supervised
visitation on Wednesdays after school until 7:30 p.m. and every Saturday from 9:00
a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Father’s visits were to be supervised by Happy Child Supervision,
and a failure to participate in visits could raise a negative inference.18 Moreover,
Father and the Children were to undergo reunification counseling with Inspiring
Change, LLC, and Father was to submit his most recent hair follicle test and undergo
a subsequent hair follicle test within seven (7) days of the Order.
An Order of Court was issued on October 24, 2023 scheduling a Pre-Trial
Conference for February 5,2024. On the same day, an Orderwas issued scheduling
a two (2) day trial for April 9 and 11, 2024. Following these Orders, the Court
received notice from Inspiring Change, LLC19 that they would not be able to provide
reunification counseling. The Court sent the parties and the GAL this
18 The parties were to continue sharing legal custody, the Children were to continue with individual therapy, and
Father was to continue with drug and alcohol and mental health treatment.
19 Inspiring Change, LLC handles complex/high-conflict custody cases, and it is not common for them to terminate
work with a family early in the process.
28
Appendix B
46a
communication and requested that the GAL provide a position regarding alternative
providers for reunification counseling. On October 31,2023, an Order of Court was
issued vacating Inspiring Change’s appointment, and directing that the GAL contact
Dr. Deborah Gilman regarding her ability to conduct reunification counseling. If
Dr. Gilman could not perform it, the court listed alternative providers that the family
could potentially utilize.
On November 30,2023, an Order of Court was issued ahead of the December
1, 2023 School Choice Hearing. In this Order, Father was precluded from calling
any witnesses other than himself and from presenting any exhibits because he did
not submit his Pre-Hearing Statement and Exhibit Binder by the deadlines
proscribed in the August 14, 2023 Pre-Hearing Order of Court.
The School Choice Hearing was scheduled for December 1, 2023 at 8:30 a.m.
Mother, her counsel, and the GAL were all present, but Father was not. At the
hearing, the Court was made aware that Father was scheduled for an ARD hearing
before Judge Kelly Bigley in the Criminal Division beginning at 7:00 a.m. on the
same day.20 Despite waiting approximately forty (40) minutes for Father, and paging
him over the Family Division intercom, Father did not appear. Thus, the proceeding
commenced. Following the hearing, a Memorandum and Order of Court was issued
20 The GAL did note that Father may have believed the hearing started at 9:30 a.m. as originally ordered on August
14, 2023, even though an Order was issued on November 21, 2023 changing the start time of the hearing.
Moreover, Father did not present a Motion for Continuance requesting that the hearing be continued due to his ARD
hearing or for any other reason.
29
Appendix B
47a
directing that the Children were to continue attending the Upper St. Clair school
district. The Order also stated that the record from the hearing would be incorporated
into the record at trial, and all non-conflicting provisions of prior Orders remain in
full force and effect.
The Pre-Trial Conference was held on February 5,2024. The GAL submitted
her Final Report on March 28, 2024. On April 2, 2024, Father submitted an email
to Mother’s counsel, the GAL, and the Court stating that he intended to represent his
Petition for Recusal. He submitted a copy of the Petition with this email, but did not
appear to submit it through the Client Services Center as was required for all self
represented litigants with cases in Allegheny County’s Family Division, as well as
the undersigned’s Standard Operating Procedures. Later that day, Father submitted
l
a subsequent email to Mother’s counsel, the GAL, and the Court stating that he
would be submitting a Motion in Limine to exclude Dr. Beth Bliss’s testimony as
the court-appointed custody evaluator.
On April 3, 2024, an Order of Court was issued directing that, because Father
had not abided by the deadlines listed in the October 24, 2023 Pre-Trial Order to
submit his Pre-Trial Statement, (1) Father would be precluded from presenting any
witnesses at the trial other than his own testimony; (2) both parties would be
precluded from presenting Motions In Limine and any issues that would have been
raised would be deemed waived; (3) Father’s Petition for Recusal would not be
30
Appendix B
48a
addressed unless it was presented in compliance with the .undersigned’s Standard
Operating Procedures.
Mother timely submitted her Exhibit Binder on April 5, 2024.
Father
submitted a series of emails from April 5-8, 2024 with CVs for four (4) expert
witnesses which he intended to call, along with a Motion in Limine to exclude Dr.
Bliss’s testimony, and a weblink that purported to contain his exhibits and Petition
for Recusal. On April 8, 2024, Mother submitted Objections to Father’s Pre-Trial
Statement, Expert Witnesses, Motion in Limine and Petition for Recusal because
they were not submitted in a timely manner. An Order of Court was issued on April
8, 2024, directing that Father was precluded from presenting exhibits at trial,
Father’s Petition for Recusal would not be addressed at trial21, and all other
provisions of the October 24,2023 Pre-Trial Order of Court and April 3,2024 Order
of Court would remain in full force and effect.
A one (1) day custody trial was held on April 9, 2024. Mother, her counsel,
and the GAL were present during the proceedings. Prior to the beginning of trial,
Father requested that his brother, who told court staff that he was his attorney and
had not filed his appearance with the Department of Court Records, and several of
his family members be present in the courtroom during the trial.22 The Court denied
21 In the Order, the undersigned gives an analysis of whether she would have recused herself from the custody
matter, despite not addressing it directly at trial.
\
22 It is the court’s practice to sequester witnesses, whether they are participating in person or virtually via Microsoft
Teams.
31
Appendix B
49a
Father’s request to have his brother present because he was not listed as counsel of
record for Father. The Court also offered to have Father’s family members view the
proceedings from a Microsoft Teams link instead of being physically present in the
courtroom. Mother’s attorney objected to them being present in the courtroom, but
had no objection to them participating remotely. It is this Court’s understanding that
upon hearing this from court staff, Father then left the Family Law Center. As he
did not appear in the courtroom for any part of the custody, trial despite court staff
paging him twice over the building intercom. The trial proceeded with just Mother,
her counsel, and the GAL.
Following the proceedings on April 9, 2024, an Order was issued on April 10,
2024 stating that the record for the custody matter is closed, the April 11, 2024 trial
date would be cancelled, and the parties would receive both a short Order of Court
with the Court’s decision, along with this written Memorandum and Order of Court
within the following weeks.23 The Memorandum and Order of Court was issued on
May 23, 2024.
On June 10, 2024, Mother submitted a Motion for Clarification and
Reconsideration of the May 23, 2024 final Order. Father also submitted a Motion
23 A short Interim and Interlocutory Order was issued on April 11,2024 ordering that Mother would have sole legal
custody and sole physical custody of the Children, with Father having supervised visitation with the Children upon
Dr. Deborah Gilman’s recommendation and upon starting reunification counseling with Children, completing an
eighteen (18) panel hair follicle test, and continuing with mental health and substance abuse treatment. Father
appealed this Interim and Interlocutory Order prior to the Memorandum and Final Order being issued; however, his
appealed was quashed by the Superior Court.
32
Appendix B
50a
for Reconsideration of his Petition for Recusal on June 10, 2024. The Court did not
address either Motion and cancelled the scheduled oral argument due to Father’s
current appeal. The court was inclined to deny Father’s Motion and clarify Mother’s
Motion to state that Father was to begin reunification counseling, and that once the
Children were to be integrated into the sessions, Father would submit to an eighteen
(18) panel hair follicle test within seven (7) days of this first session with the
Children. The court would be willing to issue such a clarifying order once Father’s
appeal has been resolved.
On June 24, 2024, Father filed his Notice of Appeal and Concise Statement
of Errors Complained of On Appeal.
HI.
Issues on Appeal
Upon a review of the pleading submitted, this court will address the Concise
Statement of Errors as a list of thirteen (13) issues complained on appeal, which are
set forth as follows:
1. Whether this court committed reversible error by virtue of the manner in
which it adjudicated Father’s October 12, 2023, April 7, 2024, and April
8, 2024 petitions for recusal based upon various actions and statements of
the Honorable Nicola Henry-Taylor during various proceedings and at
various points in this action.
33
Appendix B
51a
2. Whether this court abused its discretion and/or committed reversible error
by denying Father’s aforementioned petitions for recusal.
3. Whether this court committed reversible error and/or violated Father’s
constitutional and statutory rights by denying Father’s attorney’s attempts
to enter an appearance during the April 9, 2024 trial held in this matter.
4. Whether Father’s fundamental constitutional right to parent his children
and participate in their upbringing and/or his rights under the Americans
with Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C. §§12131-12134, were violated by the
manner in which this court disposed of his petition for custody, including
(i)
the more than three years Father waited for a trial on his custody
claims,
(ii)
the conditions this court placed on Father’s exercise of physical
custody of the children, and
(iii)
this Court’s refusal to consult with or allow him to participate in
decisions as to the individuals who should provide services to
Father and the Children and the conditions under which such
services should occur.
5. Whether this court committed reversible error by permitting at trial the
testimony of an expert witness who was appointed - over Father’s
objection - in response to the petition of [Mother] by the Honorable Chelsa
34
Appendix B
52a
Wagner before Judge Wagner subsequently recused herself from this
action because of her social relationship with Mother.
6. Whether the court committed reversible error or abused its discretion in
the manner in which it applied the factors set forth in 23 Pa.C.S. §5323.
7. Whether the court committed reversible error by issuing an order that
forbids either part from moving for a modification pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.
§5338.
8. Whether this court committed reversible error by ordering Father to
exercise supervised custody without first receiving any evidence that
Father poses any form of danger to the Children and then, subsequently,
requiring Father to exercise custody under the supervision of individuals
who possess no specialized training or knowledge with respect to the
purported danger Father poses.
9. Whether this court committed reversible error in the manner it adjudicated
Mother’s petition to enroll the Children in the Upper St; Clair School
District and move them from Forest Hills, Pennsylvania to Upper St. Clair,
Pennsylvania.
10. Whether the conditions of this court’s September 26,2023 interim custody
order impermissibly infringed on the parties rights under the First
Amendment of the United States Constitution.
.
<
Appendix B
35
53a
11. Whether this court committed reversible error by subjecting Father, at
Mother’s behest, to invasive, inherently-unreliable, hair-follicle testing by
a purported forensic laboratory that previously had its license to conduct
forensic testing revoked due to unscientific practices in which it engaged
in connection with a criminal action before the Court of Common Pleas of
Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania.
12. Whether the Standard Operating Procedures of the Honorable Nicole
Henry-Taylor (“SOPs”), the Local Rules of the Family Division of the
Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, and the Administrative
Orders of this court, as applied in this case, combined to deprive Father, as
a pro se litigant, of due process of law.
13. Whether, through the SOPs, Judge Henry-Taylor issued rules that—if
applied as written—exceed her authority to issue such rules pursuant to the
Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
IV.
Standard of Review
When a trial court orders a form of custody, modifies custody, or permits
relocation, the best interests of the children are paramount.24 To determine the
24 23 Pa.C.S. §§ 5328, 5338.
36
Appendix B
54a
children’s best interests, the trial court must consider the custody factors enumerated
in 23 Pa.C.S. §5328(a).
When reviewing the trial court’s decision, the Superior Court applies the
following standard of review:
In reviewing a custody order, . . . [w]e must accept findings of the trial
court that are supported by competent evidence of record, as our role does
not include making independent factual determinations. In addition, with
regard to issues of credibility and weight of the evidence, we must defer
to the presiding trial judge who viewed and assessed the witnesses first
hand. However, we are not bound by the trial court’s deductions or
inferences from its factual findings. Ultimately, the test is whether the
trial court’s conclusions are unreasonable as shown by the evidence of
record. We may reject the conclusions of the trial court only if they
involve an error of law, or are unreasonable in light of the sustainable
findings of the trial court.25
V.
1.
Discussion
The trial court did not err or abuse its discretion in denying Father’s
multiple Petitions for Recusal.
Father’s first and second issues shall be addressed together because they both
address the overarching issue of whether the court erred in denying Father’s Petitions
for Recusal. Father’s first issue alleges that the trial court erred in the manner in
which it adjudicated Father’s October 12, 2023, April 7, 2024, and April 8, 2024
petitions for recusal based upon alleged “various actions and statements” of the
25 C.R.F. v. S.E.F., 45 A.3d 441,443 (Pa. Super. 2012).
37
Appendix B
55a
undersigned during various proceedings and at various points in this action. Father’s
second issue alleges that the trial court abused its discretion by denying Father’s
aforementioned petitions for recusal.
The Court went on the record at the October 16, 2023 Judicial Conciliation to
address Father’s first Petition for Recusal, which the trial court denied. In addition,
Father did not appear for the April 9, 2024 custody trial. Father had the opportunity
to come into the courtroom and state his position on the second and third Petitions
for Recusal. Instead, Father decided not to enter the courtroom and left the Family
Law Center. As such, the court argues that these issues should be deemed waived.
If the Superior Court wishes to address this issue, the trial court offers the following
analysis.
It should be noted that this is not Father’s first attempt to have a sitting judge
recused from his custody matter. As described in the Factual Background and
Appendix “A” attached to this Opinion, Father filed a Petition for Recusal against
the Honorable Chelsa Wagner claiming that Mother and Judge Wagner have a
“social relationship.” Judge Wagner denied this Petition.
Father cited Municipal Publications, Inc. v. Court of Common Pleas, 489
A.2d 1286 (Pa. 1985); however, this case does not apply to the facts presented here.
Municipal Publications, Inc. is based on a recusal when a judge has personal
knowledge of the facts and permits themselves to be a witness in the matter. In the
38
Appendix B
56a
instant case, the undersigned has no personal knowledge of any disputed facts and
is not acting as a witness in the proceedings. Therefore, this caselaw is not on point
with the circumstances of this matter.
The Superior Court has held that a judge did not abuse their discretion in
denying a petition for a recusal.26 The Court held that " [e]ven if prejudicial
information was considered by the trial court, a judge, as fact finder, is presumed to
disregard inadmissible evidence and consider only competent evidence."27
Father asserts that the undersigned used her prior knowledge and experience
as an Assistant Public Defender and Assistant District Attorney to label him as an
“addict who needs close scrutiny.” Father noted that per the United States Disability
Act, 42 U.S.C. §12131-12134, “decisions about child safety and whether a
parent...represents a threat to safety must be based on an individualized
assessment...and may not be based on stereotypes or generalizations about persons
with disabilities:” According to Kearney, a judge can knowingly use any information
that may be deemed prejudicial, and can disregard anything not applicable. Here, it
applies that her background would further add to the understanding of him being an
addict - which Father freely admits. Therefore, the undersigned’s background
26 Commonwealth v. Kearney, 92 A.3d 51 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2014).
27 Id. at 61.
39
Appendix B
57a
ultimately does^not matter. Father’s past safety concerns regarding his anger and
addiction entail an individualized assessment.
Additionally, Kearney held that “judicial remarks during the course of a trial
that are critical or disapproving of, or even hostile to, counsel, the parties, or their
cases, ordinarily do not support a bias or partiality challenge... A judge's ordinary
efforts at courtroom administration—even a stem and short-tempered judge's
ordinary efforts at courtroom administration—remain immune.”28 Father alleged
that Judge Henry-Taylor made comments to him that would be seen as stern, and
that she made commentary without him in the room in front of his attorney. The
undersigned wishes to make clear that she denies being short-tempered during any
proceeding involved in the case. But even if this happened, according to Kearney,
a judge is allowed to make such remarks without it affecting their impartiality.
Therefore, Father’s alleged statements and actions in his petitions for recusal of
Judge Henry-Taylor have no basis and should not be upheld.
2. The court did not err in not permitting Father’s brother to represent him
at the custody trial because Father‘s brother did not properly enter his appearance
as Father’s counsel.
28 Kearney, 92 A.3d at 61.
40
Appendix B
58a
Father’s third issue alleges that the court committed reversible error or
violated Father’s constitutional and statutory rights by denying Father’s attorney’s
attempts to enter an appearance during the April 9, 2024 custody trial.
Father only provided notice the morning of the trial that his brother was an
attorney and wished to represent him. In addition, Father did not appear for the April
9, 2024 custody trial. Father had the opportunity to come into the courtroom and
place his objection on the record to his brother not being allowed to represent him.
Instead, Father decided not to enter the courtroom and left the Family Law Center.
As such, the court argues that this issue should be deemed waived. If the Superior
Court wishes to address this issue, the trial court offers the following analysis.
The Superior Court has held that “Courts may disqualify attorneys for
violating ethical rules. On the other hand, courts should not lightly interfere with the
right to counsel of one's choice. Thus, disqualification is appropriate "only when
both another remedy for the violation is not available and it is essential to ensure that
the party seeking disqualification receives the fair trial that due process requires."29
In G.L.P., the court held that the trial court must cite an authority for denying an
attorney’s appearance30. The trial court in G.L.P. did not cite an authority, and there
was no validity to the denial.
29 In the Interest ofG.L.P., 131 A.3d 90 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2015).
30/d.
41
Appendix B
59a
In the instant case, the undersigned noted that Pa.R.C.P.No. 1012(a) states that
“a party may enter a written appearance which shall state an address at which
pleadings and other legal papers may be served in the manner provided by Rule
440(a)(1) and a telephone number.. .Written notice of an entry of an appearance shall
be given forthwith to all parties[; however,] entry of written appearance is not
mandatory.”31 Under Rule 1012, copies of the petition shall be served upon all other
parties to the action pursuant to Rule 440.
Furthermore, it has been determined that “In all civil litigation, the trial judge
has broad power and discretion to control the conduct of the trial... [and] the judge's
control is also limited by applicable statutory requirements, which require that all
procedures, motions, and other matters relating to the trial, by jury or otherwise, of
any civil action or proceeding, be conducted in the manner, at the times, on the terms
and conditions, and in the form prescribed by such statutes.”32 Id. Other than this,
“the trial judge may control the procedure in the trial in whatever way accords with
equitable principles and the attainment of justice.”33 This is further from the
Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, which, “specifically empowers] the court
to make and enforce rules and orders involving control over various aspects of a
trial, subject to the requirements of due process of law and of the constitutional rights
31 Pa. R.C.P. 1012.
32 See The Standard Pennsylvania Practice 2d, §48:1. Judge‘s control over conduct of trial, generally.
33 Id.
t
42
Appendix B
60a
of the parties, such as regulating or excluding the public or persons not interested in
the proceedings whenever the court deems such regulation or exclusion to be in the
interest of the public good, order or morals.”34
Here, the Court did not violate Father’s rights by not allowing Father’s brother
to orally attempt to enter an appearance at the April 9, 2024, trial because, as
discussed above, Father’s brother never made any attempt to enter an appearance
beforehand, and Father’s brother did not give notice to opposing counsel or the court.
Furthermore, as the statutes and Standard Pennsylvania Practice discuss, a judge can
control the proceeding and “make and enforce rules” over various aspects of a trial.
The undersigned’s authority as a judge allowed her to make and enforce the rule that
Father’s brother made no attempt to make an appearance before the trial; therefore,
he was denied the right of an appearance.
Even if the Superior Court were to decide that Father’s brother should have
been permitted to proceed as counsel for Father, the decision not to allow him to
enter his appearance as counsel is not a reversible error, but rather a harmless error.
A reversible error is one that affects a party’s rights so significantly that it is grounds
for reversal if the affected party properly objected at trial. “A party may not sit silent
and take his chances of a verdict, and then, if it is adverse, complaint of a matter
34 Id
43
Appendix B
61a
which, if an error, would have been immediately rectified and made harmless.”35 In
addition, “the general rule will not be applied where there is basic and fundamental
error which affects the merits or justice of the case.”36
The proper function of our legal process does not require or assure a litigant
of an errorless trial, but a fair trial.37 If no objection is taken at the time the error
was committed, (1) no decision will be reversed, or (2) only those errors are
reversible which were incorrectible at the time they were made.38 Harmless error
exists where (1) the error did not prejudice the defendant or the prejudice was de
minimis', or (2) the erroneously admitted evidence was merely cumulative or other
untainted evidence which was substantially similar to the erroneously admitted
evidence; or (3) the properly admitted and uncontradicted evidence of guilt was so
overwhelming and the prejudicial effect of the error was so insignificant by
comparison that the error could not have contributed to the verdict.39
In the instant matter, the potential error of not allowing Father’s brother to
enter his appearance as Father’s attorney is not reversible because Father did not
present an objection on the record at the custody trial. In addition, even if Father’s
brother were allowed to represent Father, it would have been highly unlikely that
35 Donald R. Ringone, Appeal of Errors in the Absence of Objection-Pennsylvania’s Fundamental Error Doctrine,
73 Dick. L. Rev. 496,496 (1969).
36 Id.
37 Id. at 498, citing Commonwealth v. Williams, 248 A.2d. 301 (Pa. 1968).
38 Id. at 503.
39 In re: A.J.R.-H. and I.G.R-H., 188 A.3d 1157, 1180 (Pa. 2018) (concurring), citing Commonwealth v. Bruno, 154
A.3d 764,796 (Pa. 2017).
44
Appendix B
62a
Father or his counsel could have made an argument as to why Father should have
increased custodial time or unsupervised custodial time given the voluminous
amount of evidence against Father showing his history of conflict with Mother (and
others involved in this court matter), his ongoing history of substance abuse, and his
inability and/or unwillingness to comply with court directives that could have given
him an opportunity to have expanded or unsupervised custodial time with the
Children. Therefore, the court’s decision to not allow Father’s brother to enter his
appearance is de minimis when compared to the admitted and uncontradicted
evidence presented at the custody trial.
3.
The court did not violate Father’s fundamental rights, either under
the U.S. Constitution or under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Father’s fourth issue alleges that the court violated his constitutional right to
parent his children and participate in their upbringing and/or his rights under the
Americans with Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C. §§12131-12134, were violated by the
manner in which this court disposed of his petition for custody.
As stated above, Father did not appear for the April 9, 2024 custody trial.
Father had the opportunity to come into the courtroom and place testimony and
objections on the record regarding the custody matter. Instead, Father decided not
to enter the courtroom and left the Family Law Center. As such, the court argues
45
Appendix B
63a
that this issue should be deemed waived. If the Superior Court wishes to address
this issue, the trial court offers the following analysis.
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has held that “the Due Process Clauses
of the Fourteenth Amendment protects the fundamental right of parents to make
decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children.”40 The Court
ruled that they “must apply a strict scrutiny analysis any infringement by the state of
the fundamental right of parents to direct the care, custody, and control of their
children.”41 In determining the strict scrutiny analysis, the appropriate test is
determined by “if the infringement is supported by a state interest and if the
infringement is narrowly tailored to effectuate that interest...[and] balancing...the
parent’s rights [is determined through the] clear and convincing evidence
standard.”42 The Court determined that there is a compelling state interest in
protecting the health and emotional welfare of the child.
Similarly, in Hiller, Father contends that his substantive due process rights
were violated in relation to custody of his son. The Court determined that the trial
court did not err and a parent’s right can be taken away when it is for the protection
of the child. In the instant case, although Father has a constitutional right to parent
his children, Father has caused the court to apply the strict scrutiny test, and the
40 Hiller v. Fausey, 904 A.2d 875, 879 (Pa. 2006).
41 Id. at 359.
42 Id.
46
Appendix B
64a
burden is met through the clear and convincing evidence standard that he, at times,
has been a detriment to the children’s safety. The court protected the children
throughout the three (3) years Father waited for a trial on his custody claims and the
conditions that the court placed on Father’s exercise of physical custody.
Moreover, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), parents’ rights
are still balanced against the best interests of the child. In a case regarding adoption,
the Court has held that the ADA was not applicable in a proceeding regarding the
termination of parental rights because if it were, it would require the court to shift
its attention from the needs of the child to those of the parent.43 In determining
whether the court violated Father’s rights under the ADA by Father’s allegations of
not having his children for three (3) years, the conditions placed on Father’s exercise
of physical custody, and the refusal to allow him to participate in some decisions
depends on whether the court did provide Father with the rights to participate.
This court has fairly given Father the ability to participate in every proceeding
and listened to both parents; Father has made the decision to either not show up in
proceedings or not behave in a calm fashion. Based on Father’s actions, this court
correctly placed the children with Mother, placed conditions on Father’s physical
custody, and disallowed him from participating in such decisions that were for the
welfare of the children.
43 In the Interest ofJJ.L., 150 A.3d 475 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2016).
47
Appendix B
65a
Moreover, 42 U.S. Code §12132 states that no qualified individual shall be
excluded from participation in services, denied services of a public entity, or
subjected to any discrimination. Father has not been excluded from any participation
or denied of services; he chose not to come inside the courtroom during the trial and
he did not adhere to the Standard Operating Procedures, Local Rules, or
Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure regarding the appearance of his brother as an
attorney. Therefore, there has been no discrimination of Father by this court, Father
chose not to participate in the proceeding.
4. The court did not err in permitting the testimony of Dr. Beth Bliss, who
was appointed by the previously recused Judge.
Father’s fifth issue alleges that the court committed reversible error by
permitting at trial the testimony of Dr. Beth Bliss, an expert witness who was
appointed - over Father’s objection - in response to the petition of [Mother] by the
Honorable Chelsa Wagner before Judge Wagner subsequently recused herself from
this action.
The court has an inherent authority to appoint an expert.44 The Supreme Court
has held that Pennsylvania courts have the inherent power to appoint expert
witnesses.45 Additionally, the Superior Court has held that under the law of
44 1 Ohlbaum on the Pennsylvania Rules of Evidence §706.06
45 Galante v. West Penn Power Co. 37 A.2d 548 (Pa. 1944).
48
Appendix B
66a
Pennsylvania, the “appointment of an expert witness...to assist...is vested in the
sound discretion of the trial court.”46
Dr. Beth Bliss is a forensic psychologist who frequently conducts custody
evaluations for the trial court. Rule 1915.8(a) leaves it to the “sound discretion” of
the Court whether or not to order an evaluation, and the Superior Court has remanded
custody determinations when a party’s request for an evaluation has been denied.47
Given the concerns regarding Father’s substance use, and the history of conflict
between the parties, Judge Wagner ordered that the parties undergo a custody
evaluation. The undersigned Judge allowed the evaluator to testify at trial, so as to
give a better picture into the mental health state of the parties and their abilities to
parent the Children. As such, the trial court used its sound discretion in having Dr.
Bliss testify at trial.
5. The court did not err in applying the factors set forth in 23 Pa.C.S. §5323
or in appointing a professional supervisorfor Father's visits with Children.
Father’s sixth and eighth issues shall be addressed together in that they both
address specific provisions of the May 23,2024 Order of Court. Father’s sixth issue
alleges that the court committed reversible error or abused its discretion in the
manner in which it applied the factors set forth in 23 Pa.C.S. §5323. Father’s eighth
46 Commonwealth v. Gelormo, 475 A.2d 765, 769 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1984).
47 Pa.R.C.P. 1915.8(a).
49
Appendix B
67a
issue alleges that the court committed reversible error by ordering Father to exercise
supervised custody without evidence that Father poses any form of danger to the
Children and then requiring Father to exercise custody under the supervision of
individuals who Father claims “possess no specialized training or knowledge with
respect to the purported danger Father poses.”
As stated above, Father did not appear for the April 9, 2024 custody trial.
Father had the opportunity to come into the courtroom and place testimony and
objections on the record regarding the custody matter or provisions of the final order.
Instead, Father decided not to enter the courtroom and left the Family Law Center.
As such, the court argues that this issue should be deemed waived. In addition, the
undersigned’s reasoning in applying the custody factors are set forth at length in its
Memorandum issued concurrently with the May 23, 2024 Order of Court, which is
attached to this Opinion. As such, the court urges affirmance of these errors based
on the Memorandum. To the extent that the Superior Court requests legal analysis
of these issues, the undersigned offers the following:
The burden of providing the trial court erred in applying the 23 Pa.C.S. §5323
custody factors falls on the party challenging the custody decision. Father has not
provided any authority or case law to prove this. Additionally, the Superior Court
has held that a trial court must “delineate the reasons for its decisions when making
an award of custody... [and] there is no required amount of detail for the trial court’s
50
Appendix B
68a
explanation; all that is required is that the enumerated factors are considered and that
the custody decision is based on those considerations.”48 The court reiterated that
the child’s well-being is the most important factor in custody trials, and the “best
interests standard” is shown through each custody factor and its reasoning. Further,
the Superior Court held that “appellate courts will find a trial court abuses its
discretion if, in reaching a conclusion, it overrides or misapplies the law, or the
record shows that the trial court’s judgment was either manifestly unreasonable or
the product of partiality, prejudice, bias or ill will.”49
Here, the trial court utilized the “best-interests standard” through the
explanation and reasoning of each custody factor. Each factor is thoroughly detailed
with factual reasoning, and the evidence of record supports the trial court’s
conclusions. The Children's best interest in their “physical, intellectual, moral and
spiritual well-being” was sound judgment, and the court did not err as there was no
abuse of discretion.50
In addition, in ordering Father to have supervised custody, the “best-interests
standard” can be utilized, and the evidence in the record supported the undersigned’s
decision. Father’s substance abuse, other disorders, and his actions were all logical
basis for supervised custody.
48 R.L v. M.A. 209 A.3d 391, 395 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2019).
49 R.L... 209 A.3d at 395.
50 Id.
51
Appendix B
69a
6.
The court did not place any unduly burdensome restrictions on Father’s
ability to file a future Petition for Modification of Custody.
Father’s seventh issue alleges that committed reversible error by issuing an
order that “forbids” either part from moving for a modification pursuant to 23
Pa.C.S. §5338. In particular, the May 23, 2024 Order of Court states that prior to
filing any future Complaint or Petition for Modification of Custody, Father must do
the following:
(1) complete substance abuse treatment that addresses co-occurring disorders
and follow all recommendations;
(2) engage in mental health treatment with a doctorate level provider that can
prescribe medication, if needed;
(3) complete reunification counseling and follow all recommendations; and
(4) submit proof of completing the above to Mother’s counsel, the GAL, and
the undersigned’s chambers.
As stated above, Father did not appear for the April 9, 2024 custody trial.
Father had the opportunity to come into the courtroom and place testimony and
objections on the record regarding the custody matter. Instead, Father decided not
to enter the courtroom and left the Family Law Center. As such, the court argues
that this issue should be deemed waived. If the Superior Court wishes to address
this issue, the trial court offers the following analysis.
52
Appendix B
70a
The Court has held that “Petitions for modification of custody orders may be
entertained at any time without regard to whether there have been any material
changes which would warrant a revaluation.”51 The Court further explained that the
“Supreme Court has provided ‘a directive that petitions for modification of custody
orders may be filed at any time, and in all such cases the court hearing the petition
must consider the best interests of the child or children.’”52 Additionally, the Court
has held that the “the State has a duty to protect the children's best interests and
welfare, it may always entertain an application for modification and adjustment of
custodial rights. This right to oversee the interests of children within this
Commonwealth is of paramount importance.”53
Pennsylvania law allows parents to file for modification of custody at any
time, and the courts are required to consider the best interests of the child. In
requiring Father to undergo treatment and counseling, these practices were serving
the Children’s needs and welfare. Caselaw does not explicitly discuss requiring
treatment and counseling before filing for a petition; however, the court has broad
discretion in determining the best interests of the child.
51 J.P. v. J.S., 214 A.3d 1284, 1290. (Pa. Super. Ct. 2019).
52 Id
53 Friedman v. Friedman, 307 A.2d 292,295 (Pa. Super. 1973).
2
53
Appendix B
71a
Father’s assertion of error is also somewhat of a mischaracterization. The
May 23, 2024 does not forbid him from filing for a Petition for Modification of
Custody at any point in time. If Father were to complete substance abuse treatment
that addresses co-occurring disorders, complete mental health treatment, and engage
in reunification therapy with the Children, the trial court would consider potentially
modifying Father’s physical and legal custody of the Children. Father is free to file
a Petition for Modification of Custody, but if he cannot show proof that he has
completed substance abuse treatment, mental health treatment, and reunification
therapy, it is highly unlikely that physical or legal custody would be modified.
7. The court did not err in adjudicating Mother‘s Petition for School Choice.
Father’s ninth issue alleges that the court erred in the manner it adjudicated
Mother’s Petition to enroll the Children in,the Upper St. Clair School District and
move them from Forest Hills, Pennsylvania to Upper St. Clair, Pennsylvania. It
should first be noted that neither party filed a Notice of Proposed.Relocation at any
point in time during this litigation; as such, any issues related to relocation are
deemed waived.
The Superior Court has held that school choice is a discrete legal issue that
does not require a full analysis of the custody factors.54 In the instant case, a school
choice hearing was scheduled for December 1, 2023 to start at 8:30 a.m. Mother,
54 See, e.g., S. W.D. v. S.A.R., 96 A.3d 396 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2014).
54
Appendix B
72a
her counsel, and the Guardian ad Litem (GAL) were all present at 8:30 a.m. Father
was not present. The GAL noted that Father may have still believed that the hearing
started at 9:30 a.m. as originally ordered on August 14, 2023. An Order of Court
was issued on November 21, 2023 directing that the start time would be changed
from 9:30 a.m. to 8:30 a.m.
The court was also made aware that Father was scheduled for an ARD
Hearing before Judge Bigley in the Criminal Division on December 1, 2023 starting
at 7:00 a.m. Father did not present any Motion for Continuance requesting that the
school choice hearing be continued because of his ARD hearing or for any other
reason. The court waited until 9:00 a.m. and paged Father over the Family Division
intercom at that time. At 9:10 a.m., Father still did not appear, and the proceeding
was concluded after waiting forty (40) minutes from the scheduled start time^for
Father to appear. Following the conclusion of the proceeding, the court granted
Mother’s Petition and ordered that the Children would attend the Upper St. Clair
School District.
Despite Father contesting Mother’s Petition for School Choice, he did not
appear for the hearing which adjudicated her claims. Father could have presented
evidence and testimony, but he was precluded from doing so because he did not
follow the August 14, 2023 Pre-Hearing Order of Court’s deadlines to submit Pre
Hearing Statements and Exhibit Binders. Moreover, Father could have presented a
55
Appendix B
73a
Motion for Continuance requesting that the school choice hearing be continued to a
later date, but he did not do so. Father had opportunities and relief available so that
he could be present and participate in the school choice hearing, but he did not avail
himself of such. Therefore, the trial court did not err in the matter in which it
adjudicated Mother’s Petition for School Choice.
8. The court reasonably restricted Father's First Amendment rights in order
to protect the Children's best interest and psychological well-being.
Father’s tenth issue alleges that the September 26,2023 interim custody order
impermissibly infringed on the parties rights under the First Amendment of the
United States Constitution. It is not clear what provisions of this Order Father claims
are a violation of the First Amendment. The September 26, 2023 interim custody
order states, in relevant part, that Father is not to drive or transport the Children, that
conversations with the Children would be age appropriate and not include any adult
issues or discussion of the litigation, and that Father is.to refrain from making
negative or inappropriate comments to the Children about Mother.
As stated above, Father did not appear for the April 9, 2024 custody trial.
Father had the opportunity to come into the courtroom and place testimony and
objections on the record regarding any speech restrictions. Instead, Father decided
not to enter the courtroom and left the Family Law Center. As such, the court argues
56
Appendix B
74a
that this issue should be deemed waived. If the Superior Court wishes to address
this issue, the trial court offers the following analysis.
The Supreme Court held that courts can restrict the First Amendment if it is
narrowly tailored and is for the protection of the Child’s welfare.55 In custody
matters, the “First Amendment freedoms must be "applied in light of the special
characteristics of the [relevant] environment”.56 In determining the characteristics
of the environment, the Court’s “exclusive purpose [was] protecting the
psychological well-being and privacy of [the] Child,” and that is the main focus.57
In the instant case, Father has a history of making inflammatory and
derogatory about Mother including to the Children. He has accused Mother of
having anxiety, OCD, and other mental health diagnoses. Father also made various
unsubstantiated claims that Mother engaged in misconduct, which led to the
breakdown in the marriage. Father made these comments not just to Mother, but to
the Children, his family, and to uninterested third parties such as the Children’s
school and church. When Father made these negative comments about Mother to
the Children, the Children would become upset, to the point where they would feel
attacked and cry. Although these comments may be otherwise protected under the
First Amendment, these comments would almost certainly cause psychological harm
55 S. B. v. S.S., 243 A.3d 90 (Pa. 2020).
56 Id. at 104.
57 Id. at 106.
57
Appendix B
75a
to the Children should these comments ever be disclosed to them. As such, the Court
found it was necessary to restrict Father’s speech by ordering him to refrain from
making derogatory comments about Mother to the Children and from discussing the
litigation with the Children.
The Superior Court most recently held that a trial court did not abuse its
discretion or err in a PFA order that included not allowing the parent to drive the
child.58 The Court reasoned that there was reasonable fear because of the parent’s
history, including a drinking problem and anger issues. The concerns in the instant
case are similar, as discussed below regarding Father’s mental health and substance
abuse.
This also relates to S.B. v. S.S. because being ordered not to drive could be a
First Amendment violation.
In determining whether it is in this matter, the
protection of the child’s welfare is the priority. Similar to Trymbiski, there have
been Concerns about Father’s mental health, anger issues, and drug addiction. These
concerns were even more heightened following his DUI around June 16, 2023. The
undersigned decided that, in the best interest of the Children’s well-being, it would
be safest for the Children to not to be in the car with Father.
58 Trymbiski v. Trymbiski, No. 2495 EDA 2023, 2024 Pa. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 1047, at *1 (Apr. 26, 2024).
58
Appendix B
76a
9.
The court did not err in ordering that Father undergo a hair follicle test
with Mainline Testing Services.
Father’s eleventh issue alleges that the court committed reversible error by
subjecting Father to hair follicle testing, which he considers to be “invasive” and
“inherently-unreliable.” Father also claimed that the laboratory in question, Mainline
Testing Services, “previously had its license to conduct forensic testing revoked due
to unscientific practices in which it engaged in connection with a criminal action
before the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania.”
The Superior Court has held that courts can require a hair follicle drug test,
and they are deemed reliable.59 Courts could require a follicle drug test based on the
parent’s history and in determining what is in the best interest of the child in terms
of custody. The court determined that the provisions of 23 Pa.C.S. Ch. 53 (relating
to child custody) apply in determining the best interests, and this requires “the fact
finder to consider not only a parent's history of drug and alcohol use but also their
mental health and physical conditions.”60
In this case, Father’s has a known prior history of substance abuse. Father has
refused to take hair follicle tests in the past for the same reasons stated in his Concise
Statement of Errors. The only proof that Father presented to this Court of taking a
” H.R. v. C.P., 224 A.3d 729 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2019).
60 Id at 736.
59
Appendix B
77a
hair follicle test was a form showing that Father submitted to a five (5) panel hair
follicle test. This document did not show which substances were tested. Father was
believed to be in active addiction throughout the litigation, as far back as 2021.
These concerns became more pressing when Father was arrested and charged with
DUI in June 2023 after he tested positive for fentanyl, norfentanyl, methadone,
morphine, and amphetamines in a blood test conducted by St. Margaret’s Hospital.
Given these past and ongoing behavioral health concerns, the trial court correctly
decided that it would be in the best interest of the Children for Father to undergo a
hair follicle test.
This court does not have independent knowledge of the claims Father raises
regarding the facility’s, Mainline Testing Services, “unscientific practices.”
Mainline Testing Services has been utilized by the Court of Common Pleas of
Allegheny County on numerous occasions to conduct hair follicle tests of litigants
who are believed to be abusing alcohol or other substances. It should be noted that,
according to Mother’s Motion for Custody Evaluation from January 2023, Father
sent harassing emails and phone calls to Randy Brodsky, the owner of Mainline
Testing Services, which resulted in Mr. Brodsky no longer permitting Father to test
through that facility. Based on this, the undersigned does not find Father’s claims
about Mainline Testing Services practices to be credible.
Appendix B
78a
10.
The court did not err or abuse its discretion in ordering that Father
comply with the undersigned’s Standard Operating Procedures.
Father’s twelfth and thirteenth issues shall be addressed together because they
both address the undersigned’s Standard Operating Procedures. Father’s twelfth
issue alleges that a combination of the undersigned’s Standard Operating
Procedures, the Local Rules of the Family Division of the Court of Common Pleas
of Allegheny County, and the Administrative Orders of the lower court combined to
deprive Father, who was a pro se litigant, of due process of law. Father’s thirteenth
issue alleges that the undersigned’s Standard Operating Procedures exceed her
authority to issue certain rules under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
As stated above, it has been determined that “In all civil litigation, the trial
judge has broad power and discretion to control the conduct of the trial... [and] The
judge's control is also limited by applicable statutory requirements, which require
that all procedures, motions, and other matters relating to the trial, by jury or
otherwise, of any civil action or proceeding, be conducted in the manner, at the
times, on the terms and conditions, and in the form prescribed by such statutes.”6'
Id. In addition to that, “otherwise, the trial judge may control the procedure in the
trial in whatever way accords with equitable principles and the attainment of
61 The Standard Pennsylvania Practice 2d, §48:1. Judge's control over conduct oftrial, generally.
61
Appendix B
79a
justice.”62 This is fiirther from the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, which,
“specifically empowers] the court to make and enforce rules and orders involving
control over various aspects of a trial, subject to the requirements of due process of
law and of the constitutional rights of the parties, such as regulating or excluding the
public or persons not interested in the proceedings whenever the court deems such
regulation or exclusion to be in the interest of the public good, order or morals.”63
The judge's control is also limited by applicable statutory requirements, which
require that all procedures, motions, and other matters relating to the trial, by jury or
otherwise, of any civil action or proceeding, be conducted in the manner, at the
times, on the terms and conditions, and in the form prescribed by such statutes.”64
Therefore, the undersigned did not exceed her authority along with the Local Rules
of the Family Division of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County and the
Administrative Orders of the Court.
Moreover, as determined above, the Constitution, focusing on the First and
Fourteenth Amendments, focuses on protecting a parent’s right; however, that right
can be varied when protecting the welfare of the child. Father has shown on multiple
occasions that the Children’s safety could be threatened, and the Judge, acting on
62 Standard Pennsylvania Practice 2d, §48:1.
63 Id.
64 Id
62
Appendix B
80a
behalf of the state and local rules and her standard operating procedures, acted
diligently in putting the Children's needs first.
Father claims that he was denied certain due processes of law because he was
a pro se litigant. “The right of self-representation has been protected by statute since
the beginning of our nation.”65 Father chose to represent himself for a significant
portion of this custody litigation; however, it should be noted that Father is not
typical of the pro se litigants that appear before the undersigned in Family Division
matters.
Father is employed as an attorney, and as such, he possesses knowledge about
the intricacies about the case law, statutes, rules, and court procedures that exceed
that of the vast majority of pro se litigants that appear in the Allegheny County
Family Division. Courts in other circuits and states have held that pro se litigants
who are licensed attorneys should not be given leniency in following statutes and
rules in proceedings. In the case of Huffman v. Lindgren66, the Ninth Circuit Court
of Appeals held that, even in jurisdictions that typically provide leeway to pro se
litigants, this leeway is not given to pro se litigants who are also attorneys.67 The
Ninth Circuit explained:
There is a good reason that we afford leeway to pro se parties, who
appear without counsel and without the benefit of sophisticated
representation: “Presumably unskilled in the law, the pro se litigant is
65 Faretta v. California, 422 U.S. 806, 813(1975).
“81 F.4th 1016 (9,hCir. 2023).
67 Id. at 1020.
63
Appendix B
81a
far more prone to making errors in pleading than the person who
benefits from the representation of counsel.” . . . That logic does not
apply to practicing attorneys, nor should the grace extend to them.”68
As an attorney, Father should understand the importance of following any
judge’s Standard Operating Procedures when appearing before them in court,
whether it is in Family Division, Civil Division, Criminal Division, or Orphan’s
Court. Based on this, Father should not be given leniency for failing to follow the
undersigned’s Standard Operating Procedures in this custody matter.
In addition, throughout the course of this litigation, Father has had no qualms
about threatening to file a King’s Bench Brief to the Supreme Court alleging
misconduct on the undersigned’s part, or to repeatedly make harassing calls and
emails to court administration about how unfairly he claims he has been treated by
the lower court. As an attorney, Father should also be aware of the Pennsylvania
Rules of Professional Conduct, particularly Rule 3.1 (regarding meritorious claims
and contentions), Rule 3.5 (regarding impartiality and decorum of the tribunal) and
Rule 8.2 (regarding statements concerning judges and other adjudicatory officers).
Sadly, it appears that Father is trying to weaponize his education and profession
when it is convenient to him and to his narrative, and the trial court strongly urges
Father to reconsider his behavior towards the undersigned and to the lower court in
any and all future proceedings.
68 Huffman, 81 F.4,h 1016 at 1021.
64
Appendix B
82a
VI.
Conclusion
Based on the above facts and applicable law, Father’s appeal should be
dismissed, and the final Order of Court dated May 23, 2024, should be affirmed.
By The Court:
Nicola Henry-Taylor
Appendix B
83a
APPENDIX “A”
Procedural History prior to April 26, 2023
66
Appendix B
84a
II.
Procedural History
The litigation began on February 23, 2021 when Father filed a Complaint for
shared legal custody and partial physical custody of the Children69. The parties were
to proceed through the Generations program70 on Father’s custody complaint, and
the parties were scheduled for Mediation on March 10, 2021. On March 10, 2021,
an Order was issued scheduling the parties for an Interim Relief Hearing before
Hearing Officer Laura Valles due to the COVID-19 pandemic for April 19, 2021.
Due to scheduling conflicts from both parties, the Interim Relief Hearing was
rescheduled by Order of Court to May 17,2021.
On or around April 12, 2021, Father filed a Petition for Special Relief: Interim
Custody. In his Petition, Father averred that the delay caused by rescheduling the
Interim Relief Hearing was negatively impacting Father’s custodial rights and that
Mother was withholding physical custody of the Children. Mother submitted a
Response to Father’s Petition. In her Response, Mother averred that the parties
separated after five (5) years of marriage due to Father’s drug usage and erratic
behavior, and claimed that Father had “limited supervised involvement” with the
Children over a five (5) year period. Mother stated that she tried to reach an
69 It is not clear from the docket whether there was a final resolution to this custody matter filed in February 2021, as
the last document filed prior to Father’s Petition for Modification was an Interim Order of Court dated September
22, 2021. Hence, the original Complaint for Custody and events leading up to the September 22, 2021 Interim
Order will also be discussed here.
70 The Generations program is administered by the Allegheny County Family Division Custody Department. The
program provides information to parents and children about engaging families and offers parents and caregivers
skills to reach their own resolution.
67
Appendix B
85a
agreement for a step-up supervised custody schedule and regular drug-testing, but
Father “refused to acknowledge his past and current drug use and abuse, his history
of repeated relapses, and his lack of involvement in the Children’s lives for the last
five (5) years.”
On April 20, 2021, Judge Jennifer Satler issued three (3) Orders of Court
denying Father’s Petition and Mother’s Answer, and directing that the claims be
addressed at the May 17,2021 Interim Relief Hearing. Following the Interim Relief
Hearing, an Order of Court was issued on June 9, 2021. This Order directed that
Father would have supervised partial physical custody with the Children every
Wednesday from 4:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. and Saturday from 12:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.
Father’s custodial time would be supervised by Paternal Grandmother, Paternal
Step-Grandfather, or a mutually agreed on third party. Mother would continue to
have primary physical custody and the parties would share legal custody. Father
was also to submit to random drug screens through Mainline Drug Testing Services,
and a Review Hearing before Hearing Officer Valles would be scheduled for
September 13, 2021.
By consent, the parties entered into an Interim Order of Court on September
22, 2021. In this Order, the parties agreed that they would share legal custody,
Mother would have primary physical custody, and Father would have supervised
partial physical custody. Father was to continue with random drug screens, and
68
Appendix B
86a
Mother could request that Father undergo a hair follicle test. The parties were also
to engage in co-parenting counseling with the Parenting Institute and enroll in Our
Family Wizard for communication about the Children.71
Father filed a Petition for Modification on June 14, 2022, seeking an increase
in partial physical custody and the lifting of the requirements for supervision and
random drug screens.
Father averred that he complied with the terms of the
September 22, 2021 Interim Order, continued to have negative drug screens for a
year, and was continuing treatment and the recovery process. The parties again
proceeded through the Generations program on Father’s Petition for Modification,
and the parties were scheduled for Mediation on June 30, 2022.
Father submitted a Praecipe on July 7, 2022 to schedule a hearing before
Hearing Officer Valles regarding modification of partial custody. On July 12,2022,
an Order of Court was issued scheduling a hearing for September 21, 2022. The
parties entered into an Interim Consent Order on September 21,2022, which directed
that Father was to obtain a hair follicle test by September 26, 2022; if his results
were negative, he would have unsupervised physical custody every Saturday from
9:00 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. Mother would have the ability to request further hair follicle
tests, and Father was to provide quarterly updates concerning his treatment plan.
71 The Order further states that a Review Hearing before Hearing Officer Valles would be scheduled for November
15, 2021; however, there is nothing on the docket scheduling this Hearing or an Order of Court coming out of that
Hearing.
69
Appendix B
87a
The parties agreed to have full custody evaluations completed, and a Review
Conciliation would be scheduled before Hearing Officer Valles. These terms were
reiterated by a further Interim Consent Order on December 19, 2022.
On or around January 6, 2023, Mother submitted a Motion for Custody
Evaluation. In her Motion, Mother averred that Father failed to exercise all of the
visitation periods provided in the Interim Orders, and when Father did exercise his
custody time, Paternal Grandmother and Paternal Step-Grandfather did not properly
supervise Father. Mother also averred that Father ended co-parenting counseling
after “verbally [abusing]” Mother and counselor Lynn Macbeth from the Parenting
Institute, and behaved inappropriately towards Randy Brodsky of Mainline Drug
Test Services, which resulted in Mr. Brodsky no longer permitting Father to test
through their organization. In a footnote, Mother states that Father sent court staff
“inappropriate and threatening emails, including claims that he would report the
court’s clerk to the disciplinary board.”
Father filed an Answer and Counter-Petition for Custody Evaluation. In his
Petition, Father avers that Mother is negatively characterizing him because of his
past opioid use and claimed that Mother was engaged in a “litigation strategy of
bullying Father as well as federally-proscribed discrimination in this dispute.”
Father also claimed that raising a negative inference about his parenting based on
his medical treatment would violate the Americans with Disabilities Act and the U.S.
70
Appendix B
88a
Constitution. Father stated that Mainline issued incorrect results and engaged in ex
parte communications with Mother’s counsel. Father requested that the Court deny
Mother’s Petition and grant Father’s Counter-Petition appointing Dr. Sheinvold to
conduct the evaluations.
Mother then submitted a Response to Father’s Counter-Petition.
In her
Response, Mother averred that Father never proposed Dr. Sheinvold as a potential
evaluator. Mother’s counsel had sent Father’s counsel four (4) emails concerning
whether Father would agree to utilize Dr. Eric Bernstein as an evaluator, but only
heard mention of Dr. Sheinvold when Father’s counsel finally responded to Mother’s
counsel. On January 27, 2023, Judge Chelsa Wagner granted Mother’s Petition and
denied Father’s Response and Counter-Petition. In the Order, Judge Wagner ordered
that any evaluator assigned to conduct the evaluator consider any potential conflicts
of interest before accepting the assignment for the custody evaluation.
On or around January 12, 2023, Father submitted a Motion for Recusal of
Judge Chelsa Wagner from the custody matter. Mother submitted an Answer to
Father’s Motion. In her Answer, Mother denied making any statements to Father
about a relationship with Judge Wagner. Mother states that Judge Wagner had been
presiding over the case for a year and Father never previously filed a Motion for
Recusal. Mother requested that the Court deny Father’s Motion. On January 27,
2023, Judge Wagner denied Father’s Motion for Recusal and added in her Order that
71
Appendix B
89a
she did not have any recollection of Mother and that any possible interactions did
not impact her impartiality in presiding over the case and did not merit a recusal.
On March 2, 2023, an Order of Court was issued appointing Dr. Beth Bliss to
conduct the full custody evaluation.
72
Appendix B
90a
APPENDIX “B”
Memorandum & Order of Court dated May 23, 2024
73
Appendix B
91a
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
FAMILY DIVISION
ZACHARY GELACEK,
MEMORANDUM &
ORDER OF COURT
Plaintiff,
No.:
FD-21-007339-007
v.
MONICA COSTLOW,
Defendant.
BY:
The Honorable Nicola Henry-Taylor
City-County Building, Room 712
414 Grant Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
COPIES TO:
Self-Represented Plaintiff:
Zachary Gelacek
511 Neale Avenue
Ford City, PA 16226
(724)644-5022
zgelacek@gmail.com
ce2.
ocr>
Counsel for Defendant:
Brian E. McKinley, Esq.
436 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1050
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
(412) 261-4040
bmckinley@.wildermahood.com
Guardian ad Litem:
Alyson Landis, Esquire
107 E. Diamond Street, 3rd Floor
Butler, PA 16001
(724)283-0077
alandis@bne-law.com
Appendix B
92a
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
FAMILY DIVISION
ZACHARY GELACEK,
Plaintiff,
No.: FD-21-007339-007
v.
MONICA COSTLOW,
Defendant.
MEMORANDUM
HEN RY-TAYLOR, J.
May 23,2024
A. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
A one (I) day custody trial was held in this matter’on April 9, 2024. Plaintiff, Zachary
Gelacek (“Father”), and Defendant, Monica Costlow (“Mother”) are the natural parents of two (2)
minor children, Peter Gelacek (DOB: 06/26/2012) and Louisa Gelacek (DOB: 03/11/2014)
(“Children”), who are the subject of these proceedings. Mother presently resides in Upper St. Clair,
Allegheny County, Pennsylvania with her significant other, Andrew Dittoe. Father presently
resides in Ford City, Armstrong County, Pennsylvania with Paternal Grandmother and Paternal
Step-Grandfather.
Mother is employed as a Regulatory Policy Analyst with the University of Pittsburgh
School of Health Sciences. Father is employed as an Attorney. The parties were married on April
9, 2011. Mother avers that the parties separated on December 5, 2016. Father avers the parties
separated on January 7, 2021. The separation was caused, at least in part, by Father’s substance
usage and behaviors. Father has opioid use disorder and has an extensive history of using heroin,
fentanyl, and other substances. This, along with other behavior that Father displayed to Mother,
2
Appendix B
93a
have caused friction between the parties. The parties submitted to a custody evaluation with Dr.
Beth Bliss in 2023, with her report being issued on May 26, 2023.
B. PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The litigation began on February 23,2021 when Father Filed a Complaint for shared legal
custody and partial physical custody of the Children1. The parties were to proceed through the
Generations program2 on Father’s custody complaint, and the parties were scheduled for
Mediation on March 10, 2021. On March 10, 2021, an Order was issued scheduling the parties
for an Interim Relief Hearing before Hearing Officer Laura Valles due to the COVID-19 pandemic
for April 19,2021. Due to scheduling conflicts from both parties, the Interim Relief Hearing was
rescheduled by Order of Court to May 17, 2021.
On or around April 12, 2021, Father filed a Petition for Special Relief: Interim Custody.
In his Petition, Father averred that the delay caused by rescheduling the Interim Relief Hearing
was negatively impacting Father's custodial rights and that Mother was withholding physical
custody of the Children. Father stated that Mother wanted his visits to be supervised by her due
to his history of opioid use disorder, which Father stated he has been “clean and compliant with
his treatment plan.” Father averred that he had only had video visits with the Children during this
time and wanted the Children to have in-person visits with him and his extended family. Father
1 11 is not clear from the docket whether there was a final resolution to this custody matter, as the last document filed,
prior to Father’s Petition for Modification was an Interim Order of Court dated September 22,2021. Hence the
original Complaint for Custody and events leading up to the September 22, 2021 Interim Order will also bediscussed here.
J The Generations program is administered by the Allegheny County Family Division Custody Department. The
program provides infonnation to parents and children about engaging families and offers parents and caregivers
skills to reach their own resolution.
3
Appendix B
94a
requested that the Court grant him supervised visits with the Children pending the outcome of the
Interim Relief Hearing.
Mother submitted a Response to Father’s Petition. In her Response, Mother averred that
the parties separated after five (5) years of marriage due to Father’s drug usage and erratic
behavior, and claimed that Father had “limited supervised involvement” with the Children over a
five (5) year period. Mother stated that she tried to reach an agreement for a step-up supervised
custody schedule and regular drug-testing, but Father “refused to acknowledge his past and current
drug use and abuse, his history of repeated relapses, and his lack of involvement in the Children’s
lives for the last five (5) years.” According to Mother, Father’s drug usage precluded him from
having unsupervised visits, and that Paternal Grandmother—one of Father’s proposed
supervisors—enables Father’s drug usage. Mother had asked Father if he wanted to spend time
with the Children, but Father has either refused Mother’s requests or failed to show up after
accepting the request. Mother requested that the Court deny Father’s Petition.
On April 20,2021, Judge Jennifer Satler issued three (3) Orders of Court denying Father’s
Petition and Mother’s Answer, and directing that the claims be addressed at the May 17, 2021
Interim Relief Hearing.
Following the Interim Relief Hearing, an Order of Court was issued on June 9, 2021. This
Order directed that Father would have supervised partial physical custody with the Children every
Wednesday from 4:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. and Saturday from 12:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Father's
custodial time would be supervised by Paternal Grandmother, Paternal Step-Grandfather, or a
mutually agreed on third party. Mother would continue to have primary physical custody and the
parties would share legal custody. Father was also to submit to random drug screens through
Appendix B
95a
Mainline Drug Testing Services, and a Review Hearing before Hearing Officer Valles would be
scheduled for September 13.2021.
By consent, the parties entered into an Interim Order of Court on September 22, 2021. In
this Order, the parties agreed that they would share legal custody, Mother would have primary
physical custody, and Father would have supervised partial physical custody. Father was to
continue with random drug screens, and Mother could request that Father undergo a hair follicle
test. The parties were also to engage in co-parenting counseling with the Parenting Institute and
enroll in Our Family Wizard for communication about the Children?
Father filed a Petition for Modification on June 14, 2022 seeking an increase in partial
physical custody and the lifting of the requirements for supervision and random drug screens.
Father.averred that he complied with the terms of the September 22,2021 Interim Order, continued
to have.negative drug screens for a year, and was continuing treatment and the recovery process.
The parties again proceeded through the Generations program on Father's Petition for
Modification, and the parlies were scheduled for Mediation on June 30, 2022.
Father submitted a Praecipe on July 7, 2022 to schedule a hearing before Hearing Officer
Valles regarding modification of partial custody. On July 12, 2022, an Order of Court was issued
scheduling a hearing for September 21.2022. The parlies entered into an Interim Consent Order
on September 21, 2022, which directed that Father was to obtain a hair follicle test by September
26,2022; if his results were negative, he would have unsupervised physical custody every Saturday
from 9:00 a.m, to 7:30 p.m. Mother would have the ability to request further hair follicle tests,
and Father was to provide quarterly updates concerning his treatment plan. The parties agreed to
1 Tlie Order further states that a Review Hearing before Hearing Officer Valles would be scheduled for November
15, 2021; however, there is nothing on the docket scheduling this Hearing or an Order of Court coming out of that
Hearing.
. 5
Appendix B
96a
have full custody evaluations completed, and a Review Conciliation would be scheduled before
Hearing Officer Valles. These terms were reiterated by a further Interim Consent Order on
December 19, 2022.
On or around January 6, 2023, Mother submitted a Motion for Custody Evaluation. In her
Motion, Mother averred that Father failed to exercise all of the visitation periods provided in the
Interim Orders, and when Father did exercise his custody time, Paternal Grandmother and Paternal
Step-Grandfather did not properly supervise Father. Mother also averred that Father ended co
parenting counseling after “verbally [abusing]”. Mother and counselor Lynn Macbeth from the
Parenting Institute, and behaved inappropriately towards Randy Brodsky of Mainline Drug Test
Services, which resulted in Mr. Brodsky no longer permitting Father to test through their
organization.
In a footnote, Mother states that Father sent court staff “inappropriate and
threatening emails, including claims that he would report the court’s clerk to the disciplinary
board."
Mother proposed utilizing Dr. Eric Bernstein as a custody evaluator, which Father
rejected. Father suggested Dr. Arnold Sheinvold, an evaluator based in Harrisburg, which Mother
rejected. At a Review Conciliation on December 19,2022, Father refused to sign a Consent Order
to allow Allegheny Forensic Associates to conduct the evaluation, claiming that their evaluations
were “inadequate.”
Mother averred that Father was trying to circumvent the parties’ prior
agreements and the Family Division’s procedures for appointing custody evaluators.
Mother
requested that the Court enter an Order directing the completion of a full custody evaluation by an
evaluator at Allegheny Forensic Associates.
Father filed an Answer and Counter-Petition for Custody Evaluation. In his Petition, Father
avers that Mother is negatively characterizing him because of his past opioid use and claimed that
Mother was engaged in a “litigation strategy of bullying Father as well as federally-proscribed
6
Appendix B
97a
discrimination in this dispute.” Father denied verbally abusing Lynn Macbeth during co-parenting
sessions, and claimed that he ended co-parenting counseling sessions based on a letter from his
physician, Dr. Michelle Barwell, stating that Ms. Macbeth’s participation “contravened ethical
rules” given previous interactions with Father (which Father did not detail in his Answer). Father
also claimed that raising a negative inference about his parenting based on his medical treatment
would violate the Americans with Disabilities Act and the U.S. Constitution. Father states that
Mainline issued incorrect results and engaged in ex pane communications with Mother’s counsel.
Father averred that his selection of Dr. Sheinvold as an evaluator was governed by the fact that
Mother’s work supervisor was the Dean of the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Public Health
and that both parties’ fathers are prominent doctors in the western Pennsylvania medical
community—seeming to infer that any evaluator from Allegheny County would be biased from
Mother’s potential connections to the aforementioned individuals. Father further claimed that Dr.
Sheinvold’s evaluation process is conducted in a more relaxed environment for children and is
more diligent about contacting collateral sources compared to Allegheny Forensic Associates, and
that Allegheny Forensic Associates is severely backlogged in cases. Father requested that the
Court deny Mother’s Petition and grant Father’s Counter-Petition appointing Dr. Sheinvold to
conduct the evaluations.
Mother then submitted a Response to Father’s Counter-Petition. In her Response, Mother
averred that Father never proposed Dr. Sheinvold as a potential evaluator. Mother’s counsel had
sent Father's counsel four (4) emails concerning whether Father would agree to utilize Dr. Eric
Bernstein as an evaluator, but only heard mention of Dr. Sheinvold when Father’s counsel finally
responded to Mother’s counsel. Mother averred that there was no basis to have Allegheny Forensic
Appendix B
98a
Associates removed as an evaluator for this matter, and claims that Father is trying to “create a
conflict where.no conflict exists.”
On January 27,2023, Judge Chelsa Wagner granted Mother’s Petition and denied Father’s
Response and Counter-Petition. In the Order, Judge Wagner ordered that any evaluator assigned
to conduct the evaluator consider any potential conflicts of interest before accepting the assignment
for the custody evaluation.
On or around January 12, 2023, Father submitted a Motion for Recusal of Judge Chelsa
Wagner from the custody matter. In his Motion, Father avers that Mother made statements to
Father during the course of their relationship that she has a “positive relationship” with Judge
Wagner, who was allegedly a classmate of Mother’s at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
Father averred that this may give the appearance of impropriety or prejudice based on Mother’s
comments. Father requested that Judge Wagner recuse herself from this matter and that another
Family Division judge “with no material previous relationship with either party or other
disqualifying relationship to the people and matters involved herein” be assigned to this case.
Mother submitted an Answer to Father’s Motion. In her Answer, Mother denied making
any statements to Father about a relationship with Judge Wagner. Mother states that Judge Wagner
had been presiding over the case for a year and Father never previously filed a Motion for Recusal.
Mother requested that the Court deny Father’s Motion. On January 27,2023, Judge Wagner denied
Father’s Motion for Recusal and added in her Order that she did not have any recollection of
Mother and that any possible interactions did not impact her impartiality in presiding over the case
and did not merit a recusal.
S
Appendix B
99a
On March 2, 2023, an Order of Court was issued appointing Dr. Beth Bliss to conduct the
full custody evaluation. On April 26, 2023, an Order of Court was issued reassigning this matter
to the undersigned judge.
On May 4, 2023, Father submitted a Petition for Contempt and Special Relief. In his
Petition, Father averred that Mother has used his struggle with opioid use disorder as a weapon
against him and has not recognized his stability. Father also claimed that he requested family
therapy, that Mother copy him on all communications with the Children’s school and providers,
and that Mother stop communicating with his parents—all of which Mother has ignored or outright
rejected. Father also averred that Mother has made unilateral medical and educational decisions
for the Children, especially in not consenting to behavioral health treatment for Peter and
organizing virtual schooling for Peter when the Children’s prior school stated that Peter was no
longer permitted to attend school in person due to behavioral issues. Father also claimed that
Mother was engaging in parental alienation, disparagement and degradation of Father, and
interfered with Father’s daily video calls with the Children. Father requested that Mother pay
$5,000.00 in counsel fees, that a Guardian ad Litem (“GAL”) be appointed for the Children, and
that a hearing on medical and educational decision making be scheduled.
On May 9,2023, Mother submitted an Answer and New Matter to Father’s Petition. In her
Answer, Mother avers that Father admitted to her as late as January 2021 that he was using drugs.
Mother reiterated that Father failed to comply with random drug screens and co-parenting
counseling by delaying screens and sessions and engaging in inappropriate behavior that caused
the providers to cease services with the family. Mother admits that she refused to do family therapy
with Father, but Hearing Officer Valles confirmed that she did not have to participate due to
Father’s conduct. Mother claims Father does not include her in all legal custody conversations,
9
Appendix B
100a
and that Father sent Mother’s parents a letter containing “untrue and defamatory statements” about
Mother. In her New Matter, Mother avers that Father has defamed Mother to her parents, their
church, and the Children’s school regarding purported behavior in which Mother engaged.
According to Mother, Father invokes the First Amendment’s Establishment Claus
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.