Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Ahmad Abouammo, Petitioner v. United States
Supreme Court briefJul 16, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 25IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
_____________
AHMAD ABOUAMMO,
v.
Petitioner,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
_____________
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit
_____________
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
_____________
CARMEN SMARANDOIU
OFFICE OF THE FEDERAL
PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR
THE NORTHERN DISTRICT
OF CALIFORNIA
450 Golden Gate Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94102
TOBIAS S. LOSS-EATON
Counsel of Record
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
1501 K Street NW
Washington, DC 20005
(202) 736-8427
tlosseaton@sidley.com
JEFFREY T. GREEN
DANIELLE HAMILTON
THE CARTER G. PHILLIPS/
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
SUPREME COURT CLINIC
NORTHWESTERN PRITZKER
SCHOOL OF LAW
375 East Chicago Avenue
Chicago, IL 60611
JAMES R. HORNER
ANA PAJAR BLINDER
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
787 7th Avenue
New York, NY 10019
Counsel for Petitioner
July 16, 2025
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
As part of an investigation into a scheme to disclose
nonpublic Twitter account information to foreign actors, San Francisco–based FBI agents visited Petitioner Ahmad Abouammo at his home in Seattle.
While they were there, Mr. Abouammo went upstairs
and emailed them an allegedly falsified document. Mr.
Abouammo’s only interaction with the agents occurred
in Seattle.
A grand jury in the Northern District of California
indicted Mr. Abouammo for (among other things) falsifying documents with the intent to impede an investigation. The parties then agreed to toll the statute of
limitations for other uncharged offenses. On the day
the tolling agreement expired, the government filed a
superseding information adding various felony counts.
Mr. Abouammo never waived prosecution by indictment. See Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(b). Four months after
the limitations period had expired, the government
dismissed this placeholder information and replaced it
with a superseding indictment containing the same
charges.
The questions presented are:
1. Whether venue is proper in a district where no
offense conduct took place, so long as the statute’s intent element “contemplates” effects that could occur
there.
2. Whether a criminal information unaccompanied
by a waiver of indictment is an “information charging
a felony” that allows the government to unilaterally
extend the statute of limitations under 18 U.S.C.
§ 3288.
(i)
ii
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING
Petitioner is Ahmad Abouammo.
Respondent is the United States of America.
No corporate parties are involved in this case.
iii
RELATED CASES
This case arises from the following proceedings in
the District Court for the Northern District of California and the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit:
United States v. Abouammo
No. 22-10348 (9th Cir.); and
United States v. Abouammo
No. 19-cr-621-EMC-1 (N.D. Cal.).
No other proceedings directly relate to this case.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Questions presented .................................................... i
Parties to the proceeding ............................................ ii
Related cases ..............................................................iii
Table of authorities................................................... .vi
Petition for a writ of certiorari ................................... 1
Opinions and orders below ......................................... 1
Statement of jurisdiction ............................................ 1
Constitutional and statutory provisions
involved .................................................................. 1
Introduction ................................................................ 3
Statement of the case ................................................. 5
Reasons for granting the petition .............................. 9
I. The Court should grant review to decide
when an offense’s intended effects can
establish venue. ..................................................... 9
A. The circuits are openly split on when
an offense’s intended effects can
support venue. ............................................ 9
B. The decision below is wrong. .................... 14
C. This case is an ideal vehicle to decide
this important and recurring issue. ......... 17
II. The Court should grant review to decide
whether a waiverless felony information tolls
the statute of limitations under 18 U.S.C.
§ 3288. .................................................................. 19
Conclusion ................................................................. 26
v
Appendices
Appendix A: Opinion and Concurrence, United
States v. Abouammo, No. 22-10348 (9th Cir.
Dec. 4, 2024).......................................................
1a
Appendix B: Order Denying Defendant’s Motion
for Judgment of Acquittal (Rule 29), and Motion for New Trial (Rule 33), United States v.
Abouammo, No. 3:19-CR-00621-EMC-1 (N.D.
Cal. Dec. 12, 2022) ............................................. 48a
Appendix C: Order Denying Rehearing, United
States v. Abouammo, No. 22-10348 (9th Cir.
Mar. 18, 2025) .................................................... 98a
vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
CASES
Page
FDIC v. Mallen, 486 U.S. 230 (1988) ..........
5
Jaben v. United States, 381 U.S. 214
(1965) ........................................................ 22, 23
Klopfer v. North Carolina, 386 U.S. 213
(1967) .........................................................
20
Smith v. United States, 360 U.S. 1 (1959)...
21
Toussie v. United States, 397 U.S. 112
(1970) .........................................................
23
United States v. Anderson, 328 U.S. 699
(1946) ........................................................ 14, 15
United States v. Angotti, 105 F.3d 539 (9th
Cir. 1997), abrogated by United States v.
Cabrales, 524 U.S. 1 (1998) .......... 10, 16, 17, 18
United States v. Auernheimer, 748 F.3d 525
(3d Cir. 2014) ...................................... 10, 11, 18
United States v. B.G.G., 53 F.4th 1353
(11th Cir. 2022) ........................................ 20, 22
United States v. Bowens, 224 F.3d 302 (4th
Cir. 2000) ........................................ 4, 11, 12, 15
United States v. Cabrales, 524 U.S. 1
(1998) ......................................................... 16, 17
United States v. Clenney, 434 F.3d 780 (5th
Cir. 2005) ........................................... 4, 5, 12, 16
United States v. Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d 1317
(S.D. Fla. 2023) ................................. 22, 24, 25
United States v. Marion, 404 U.S. 307
(1971) ......................................................... 19, 20
United States v. Miller, 808 F.3d 607 (2d
Cir. 2015) .................................................. 15, 16
United States v. Peloquin, 810 F.2d 911
20
(9th Cir. 1987) ...........................................
vii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—continued
Page
United States v. Rodriguez-Moreno, 526
U.S. 275 (1999) ..................................... 3, 15, 19
United States v. Salinas, 373 F.3d 161 (1st
Cir. 2004) .................................... 4, 9, 10, 13, 16
United States v. Smith, 22 F.4th 1236
(11th Cir. 2022), aff’d on other grounds,
599 U.S. 236 (2023) ............................ 12, 13, 16
United States v. Spirito, 36 F.4th 191 (4th
Cir. 2022) ...................................................
15
United States v. Swann, 441 F.2d 1053
(D.C. Cir. 1971) .........................................
13
United States v. Teran, 98 F.3d 831 (5th
Cir. 1996) ...................................................
21
United States v. Webster, 127 F.4th 318
(11th Cir.), cert. denied, 145 S. Ct. 1461
(2025) .........................................................
20
United States v. White, 887 F.2d 267 (D.C.
Cir. 1989) ...................................................
13
Ex Parte Wilson, 114 U.S. 417 (1885) ..........
24
CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS
U.S. Const. amend. V ................................... 1, 21
U.S. Const. amend. VI.................................. 1, 14
U.S. Const. art III, § 2, cl. 3 ......................... 1, 14
STATUTES
18 U.S.C. § 1028(a)(7) ..................................
10
§ 1030 ...........................................
10
§ 1071 ...........................................
11
§ 1343 ...........................................
6
§ 1346 ...........................................
6
§ 1349 ...........................................
6
§ 1519 ........................................... 2, 15
viii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—continued
Page
18 U.S.C. § 1542 ........................................
9
§ 1832(a) ....................................
12
§ 1956.........................................
6
§ 3282.........................................
22
§ 3282(a) ....................................
2
§ 3288...................... 2, 5, 8, 19, 20, 25
28 U.S.C. § 1254(1) .....................................
1
Anti-Drug
Abuse
Act
of
1988,
Pub. L. No. 100-690, 102 Stat. 4181 .........
23
RULES
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7 .........................................
Fed. R. Crim. P. 18 .......................................
21
14
LEGISLATIVE MATERIALS
S. Rep. No. 88-1414 (1964) ...........................
134 Cong. Rec. S17360-02 (daily ed. Nov. 10,
1998), 1988 WL 182529 ............................
25
24
OTHER AUTHORITIES
Charge, Black’s Law Dictionary (12th ed.
2024) ..........................................................
Charles A. Wright, Law of Federal Courts
§ 43 (5th ed. 1994) .....................................
21
18
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Petitioner Ahmad Abouammo respectfully petitions
for a writ of certiorari to review the judgment of the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
OPINIONS AND ORDERS BELOW
The Ninth Circuit’s opinion is reported at 122 F.4th
1072 and reproduced at Pet. App. 1a–47a. The unreported order denying panel rehearing and rehearing
en banc is reproduced at Pet. App. 98a. The district
court’s opinion is available at 2022 WL 175844238 and
reproduced at Pet. App. 48a–97a.
STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
The Ninth Circuit issued its judgment on December
4, 2024 and denied a timely rehearing petition on February 18, 2025. On June 9, 2015, Justice Kagan extended the time to file this petition to July 16, 2025.
The Court has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1254(1).
CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY
PROVISIONS INVOLVED
Article III provides, as relevant:
The Trial of all Crimes, except in Cases of Impeachment, shall be by Jury; and such Trial shall
be held in the State where the said Crimes shall
have been committed . . . .
The Fifth Amendment provides, as relevant:
No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or
otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury . . . .
The Sixth Amendment provides, as relevant:
2
In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an
impartial jury of the State and district wherein
the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by
law . . . .
18 U.S.C. § 1519 provides:
Whoever knowingly alters, destroys, mutilates,
conceals, covers up, falsifies, or makes a false entry in any record, document, or tangible object
with the intent to impede, obstruct, or influence
the investigation or proper administration of any
matter within the jurisdiction of any department
or agency of the United States or any case filed
under title 11, or in relation to or contemplation
of any such matter or case, shall be fined under
this title, imprisoned not more than 20 years, or
both.
18 U.S.C. § 3282(a) provides:
Except as otherwise expressly provided by law, no
person shall be prosecuted, tried, or punished for
any offense, not capital, unless the indictment is
found or the information is instituted within five
years next after such offense shall have been committed.
18 U.S.C. § 3288 provides:
Whenever an indictment or information charging
a felony is dismissed for any reason after the period prescribed by the applicable statute of limitations has expired, a new indictment may be returned in the appropriate jurisdiction within six
calendar months of the date of the dismissal of
the indictment or information, or, in the event of
3
an appeal, within 60 days of the date the dismissal of the indictment or information becomes final, or, if no regular grand jury is in session in the
appropriate jurisdiction when the indictment or
information is dismissed, within six calendar
months of the date when the next regular grand
jury is convened, which new indictment shall not
be barred by any statute of limitations.
INTRODUCTION
This case raises two important questions of federal
criminal procedure, one of which has generated an
acknowledged circuit split.
First: When can a criminal offense’s intended effects
establish venue for prosecution?
Article III and the Sixth Amendment mandate that
crimes be prosecuted where they were committed.
Thus, proper venue turns on the location of “the conduct constituting the offense”—meaning its “essential
conduct elements.”
United States v. RodriguezMoreno, 526 U.S. 275, 279–80 (1999). This Court has
reserved the question of whether venue “may permissibly be based upon the effects of a defendant’s conduct
in a district other than the one in which the defendant
performs the acts constituting the offense.” Id. at 279
n.2.
Absent guidance on that question, the circuits have
openly split. The Ninth Circuit held below that Mr.
Abouammo could be prosecuted under 18 U.S.C.
§ 1519 in San Francisco for allegedly falsifying documents in Seattle. Because § 1519 requires that the defendant have acted “with the intent to impede, obstruct, or influence” an investigation, the court concluded that “the contemplated [obstructive] effects are
part of the ‘essential conduct’ of the offense for venue
4
purposes.” Pet. App. 37a. And, the court said, there is
“no . . . requirement that the statute proscribe conduct
that . . . actually affects or interferes with something
in the venue.” Id. at 42a.
At least six circuits disagree—with some explicitly
rejecting the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning as “dubious,”
“unpersuasive,” and “inconsistent with” this Court’s
decisions. E.g., United States v. Salinas, 373 F.3d 161,
168 (1st Cir. 2004). These other courts hold, in various
contexts, that venue can be based on an offense’s effects “only when an essential conduct element is itself
defined in terms of its effects”—for example, when an
element requires conduct “‘affecting’ interstate commerce” or “‘obstructing’ or ‘impeding’ the administration of justice.” E.g., United States v. Bowens, 224 F.3d
302, 311, 313 (4th Cir. 2000). It is not enough that the
statute required the defendant to intend a particular
effect; such an intent element “is plainly not an ‘essential conduct element’” for venue purposes. E.g., United
States v. Clenney, 434 F.3d 780, 782 (5th Cir. 2005)
(per curiam).
The other circuits are right and the Ninth Circuit is
wrong. If a statute “contemplates” effects only through
an intent requirement, then those effects are not part
of any essential conduct element. Intent is not conduct. In any event, the relevant element in this situation is the intent itself, not the intended effects. And
“the intent element is a mental state that cannot have
been ‘committed’ anywhere but where [the defendant]
was physically present.” Id. Because Mr. Abouammo
allegedly formed and acted on his obstructive intent in
Seattle, venue in San Francisco is improper.
Second: Can the government unilaterally extend the
statute of limitations under 18 U.S.C. § 3288 by filing
a felony information—even if the defendant never
waived indictment for felony charges?
5
Below, the Ninth Circuit blessed a novel maneuver
by which the government bought itself several extra
months, beyond the limitations period, to file additional felony charges. Section 3288 gives the government six months after the dismissal of “an indictment
or information charging a felony” to refile charges in
“a new indictment” without timeliness problems (provided the dismissal was not based on a time bar to
begin with). The government used this procedure to
effectively extend the limitations period from April to
July 2020 by filing a placeholder information on the
day the limitations period was set to expire, which it
then dismissed once it was finally ready to file a superseding indictment containing identical charges.
This was improper. Federal felonies “must be prosecuted by indictment, unless the defendant waives this
right.” FDIC v. Mallen, 486 U.S. 230, 241 n.10 (1988).
Mr. Abouammo never did so. Thus, the information
the government filed within the limitations period was
a nullity—it could not be used to prosecute him. In
§ 3288’s terms, a felony information filed without a
waiver of indictment is not an “information charging a
felony” because it does not validly charge anything.
The Court should grant review to make clear that Congress has not authorized this sort of naked gamesmanship.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
1. As part of its investigation into the disclosure of
nonpublic Twitter account information to an associate
of now-Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia Mohammed bin
Salman, the FBI flew agents from its San Francisco
office to Mr. Abouammo’s home in Seattle. Pet. App.
10a. Mr. Abouammo was a former Twitter employee
who allegedly accessed company databases about the
platform’s users and provided personal information
6
about a Saudi dissident user to a Saudi national. After
leaving Twitter, he started a freelance social media
consultancy. Id. at 9a.
Upon meeting Mr. Abouammo, the agents identified
themselves as “FBI agents from the San Francisco office.” Pet. App. 10a. They then spoke with him in his
home for several hours. Id. During this conversation,
Mr. Abouammo said that he had worked with a particular Saudi official after leaving Twitter. When the
agents asked for documentation, he went upstairs and
created and emailed them an allegedly false invoice for
these consulting services. Id. at 11a.
2. Mr. Abouammo was indicted in the Northern District of California in November 2019 for one count of
acting as an agent of a foreign government under 18
U.S.C. § 951 and one count of falsifying records under
§ 1519. Pet. App. 11a–12a. In February 2020, the parties agreed to toll the statute of limitations to April 7,
2020 to discuss a possible plea deal. Id.
When the government asked for another tolling
agreement, Mr. Abouammo declined. Thus, on April
7—the day the existing agreement was set to expire—
the government filed a superseding information adding fifteen counts of wire and honest services fraud, 18
U.S.C. §§ 1343, 1346, one count of conspiracy to commit those offenses, 18 U.S.C. § 1349, and three counts
of international money laundering, 18 U.S.C. § 1956.
At the time, Mr. Abouammo had not (and still has not)
waived indictment for these felony charges.
In July 2020, after grand jury proceedings resumed—having been halted in light of the Covid-19
pandemic—the grand jury returned a superseding indictment containing the same charges as the April
2020 information. Pet. App. 12a.
7
3. Mr. Abouammo moved to dismiss the § 1519 falsifying-records charge for improper venue and the wire
fraud, conspiracy, and money laundering charges as
time-barred. Pet. App. 12a. The district court denied
the motion.
After a two-week jury trial, Mr.
Abouammo was convicted on six counts of the superseding indictment. Id.
After trial, Mr. Abouammo again sought dismissal of
his conviction for falsification of records for lack of
venue. Pet. App. 77a. The district court again rejected
his argument. Id.
4. The Ninth Circuit upheld Mr. Abouammo’s convictions.
As to venue, the court emphasized that § 1519’s intent element “expressly contemplates the effect of influencing the action of another.” Pet. App. 37a (cleaned
up). Given this “express connection between the actus
reus and its contemplated effect,” the court said, “the
contemplated effects are part of the ‘essential conduct’
of the offense for venue purposes.” Id. Thus, “the statute of conviction need not . . . require ‘actual’ adverse
effects or interference in a district for effects-based
venue to be proper there.” Id. at 42a. That is, “language such as ‘for the purpose of’ or ‘with the intent
to’” suffices to expand venue to any district where the
intended-but-not-required effect could have occurred.
Id. On this view, Mr. Abouammo’s “act of making a
false document” with obstructive intent “continued until”—and occurred wherever—“the document was received by the person or persons whom it was intended
to affect or influence,” even if he did not know who or
where those particular people were. Id. at 39a
(cleaned up).
On the statute of limitations, the Ninth Circuit held
that the government’s April 2020 information—filed
8
without any waiver of indictment—sufficed to toll the
limitations period. That holding relied on 18 U.S.C.
§ 3288, which provides that, if “an indictment or information charging a felony is dismissed for any reason
after the [applicable limitations] period . . . has expired,” the government may bring “a new indictment”
within six months of the dismissal without being timebarred. See Pet. App. 26a. The court held that this
requirement was met because “the superseding information was filed on April 7, 2020, within the statute of
limitations,” and the “superseding indictment in this
case was returned within six months of the dismissal
of the April 7, 2020 information” (indeed, on the same
day). Id.
The court thus rejected Mr. Abouammo’s argument
that this tolling mechanism requires an “information
accompanied by a waiver of indictment.” Pet. App.
26a. The court noted that the statute previously referred to an “information filed after the defendant
waives in open court prosecution by indictment,” but
Congress omitted that language in 1988. Id. at 27a
(emphasis omitted) (cleaned up).
Judge Lee concurred to agree that, under circuit
precedent, “the Northern District of California was a
proper venue.” Pet. App. 46a. He also warned that
courts “should be wary of . . . attempts by the government to cherry-pick favored venues through pretextual
reliance on out-of-district agents,” though he did not
believe this was such a case. Id. at 47a.
The Ninth Circuit denied Mr. Abouammo’s timely
petition for panel and en banc rehearing.
9
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION
I. The Court should grant review to decide
when an offense’s intended effects can establish venue.
There is an acknowledged six-to-one circuit split on
whether venue can rest on an offense’s intended effects
that are not essential to conviction. Courts on both
sides have had ample time to consider this question in
light of Rodriguez-Moreno and each other’s positions.
And the Ninth Circuit’s rule violates the Constitution’s
command to focus on acts the defendant committed.
This Court should resolve this split.
A. The circuits are openly split on when an
offense’s intended effects can support
venue.
Most courts of appeals—at least the First, Third,
Fourth, Fifth, Eleventh, and D.C. Circuits— hold correctly that an offense’s effects can support venue only
when the effects are themselves an element of the offense. The Ninth Circuit, by contrast, reasons that
venue is proper whenever the statute “contemplates”
effects through an intent element.
1. The First Circuit holds that venue for passport
fraud—“knowingly mak[ing] any false statement . . .
with intent to induce or secure the issuance of a passport,” 18 U.S.C. § 1542—is proper where “an applicant
makes a knowingly false statement,” not where “the
false statement is actually communicated to” the relevant officials. United States v. Salinas, 373 F.3d 161,
165–66 (1st Cir. 2004). In so holding, the court rejected the premise—adopted by the Ninth Circuit below—that a false-statement statute’s intent requirement “create[s] a continuing offense.” Id. at 168. If
the text “requires intent only at the moment the false
10
statement is made,” the crime is “a point-in-time offense, which can be prosecuted at the place of the false
statement but not at some different place where the
government” receives or acts on the statement. Id. at
169. “Allowing specific intent to continue a crime into
any district in which that intent has consequences,”
the court warned, “would significantly expand the
range of permissible venues.” Id.
The First Circuit also rejected the government’s reliance on the Ninth Circuit’s Angotti decision—the key
precedent underlying the decision below. See Pet.
App. 36a (holding that “Angotti governs” here); United
States v. Angotti, 105 F.3d 539, 543 (9th Cir. 1997), abrogated by United States v. Cabrales, 524 U.S. 1
(1998). Angotti, the First Circuit said, “was decided
prior to the Supreme Court’s clarification of the standards [for] venue in Rodriguez-Moreno and Cabrales.”
Salinas, 373 F.3d at 168. Because “Angotti is inconsistent with those decisions,” it is “dubious” precedent
on its own terms, and its “reasoning [is] unpersuasive,”
the First Circuit “decline[d] to follow it.” Id.
The Third Circuit likewise determines venue
based on whether Congress defined a statutory violation “in terms of its effects.” See United States v. Auernheimer, 748 F.3d 525, 537 (3d Cir. 2014). Auernheimer was charged in New Jersey with unauthorized
access to, and obtaining information from, a computer,
18 U.S.C. § 1030, and identity fraud, id. § 1028(a)(7).
The Third Circuit held that venue was improper. It
did not matter that the defendant allegedly had “the
intent to violate the New Jersey computer crime statute,” because “no essential conduct element of the alleged violation of New Jersey law occurred in New Jersey.” Auernheimer, 748 F.3d at 536; see id. at 533–35.
Nor did it matter that thousands of email addresses
“belong[ing] to New Jersey residents” were among the
11
information unlawfully obtained. Id. at 536. The
Third Circuit could not find “any case where the locus
of the [offense’s] effects, standing by itself, was sufficient to confer constitutionally sound venue.” Id. at
537. Although “there are some instances where the location in which a crime’s effects are felt is relevant to
determining whether venue is proper,” “those cases
are reserved for situations in which an essential conduct element is itself defined in terms of its effects.”
Id. (cleaned up).
The Fourth Circuit, too, focuses on whether “the
terms of the statute itself forbid affecting [conduct] in
particular ways.” United States v. Bowens, 224 F.3d
302, 313 (4th Cir. 2000). Bowens was charged in Virginia with “harbor[ing] or conceal[ing]” a fugitive “so
as to prevent his discovery and arrest.” 18 U.S.C.
§ 1071. The court held venue improper. “The only conduct proscribed by § 1071 is the act of harboring or concealing the fugitive,” so “venue will lie only where acts
of harboring or concealing take place.” Bowens, 224
F.3d at 309. And those acts occurred in South Carolina. Id. at 304–06.
It did not matter, the Bowens court explained, that
the harbored fugitives were being sought by federal officials in Virginia. While Congress may have criminalized fugitive harboring because of its harmful effects
on the administration of justice—which were felt in
Virginia—the statute’s “essential conduct element . . .
is not defined in terms of its particular effects.” Id. at
313. Though the statute contains the language “so as
to prevent the fugitive’s discovery and arrest,” that
phrase “defines the requisite intent for the offense”—
which is “not an essential conduct element.” Id.
(cleaned up).
In so holding, the Fourth Circuit recognized that this
Court’s decisions in Cabrales and Rodriguez-Moreno
12
had abrogated circuit precedent holding “that in prosecutions for crimes in the nature of obstruction of justice, venue is proper in the district where the obstruction would take effect.” Id. at 311.
The Fifth Circuit agrees. United States v. Clenney
addressed venue for the offense of removing a child
from the United States “with intent to obstruct the
lawful exercise of parental rights.” 434 F.3d 780, 781
(5th Cir. 2005) (per curiam) (quoting 18 U.S.C. § 1204).
Though “none of the acts complained of in the indictment” occurred in the forum district, the government
said venue was proper because obstructive intent “is
an element of the offense, and [the other parent’s] parental rights were violated in” the forum district. Id.
at 781–82. The Fifth Circuit held otherwise. The obstructive-intent element “merely speaks to the offender’s mens rea as he commits the conduct essential
to the crime; it is plainly not an ‘essential conduct element’ as required by Rodriguez-Moreno.” Id. at 782. In
any event, the requisite intent “was formed and existed solely in the mind” of the defendant, so it “cannot
have been ‘committed’ anywhere but where he was
physically present.” Id.
The Eleventh Circuit likewise holds that “the effects of a crime are a permissible basis for venue” only
if the statute “contain[s] an essential element . . . defined in terms of the effects of the act.” United States
v. Smith, 22 F.4th 1236, 1243–44 (11th Cir. 2022), aff’d
on other grounds, 599 U.S. 236 (2023). Smith involved
theft of trade secrets, which requires as an element
that the defendant “intend[] or know[] that the offense
will[] injure any owner of that trade secret.” 18 U.S.C.
§ 1832(a). Even so, venue was improper in a district
where the victim was located but none of the defendant’s conduct took place. As Chief Judge Pryor ex-
13
plained for the court, the “theft-of-trade-secrets statute does not define any essential conduct element of
the offense in terms of its effects on the owner of the
trade secret.” Smith, 22 F.4th at 1244. That theft necessarily involves “interference with the possessory interest of the owner” does not change the offense’s conduct elements. Id.
The D.C. Circuit also holds that venue “lies only in
a district in which the defendant committed unlawful
acts and is not proper in a district where only the effects of the crime occur,” unless those effects are elements of the offense. United States v. White, 887 F.2d
267, 272 (D.C. Cir. 1989) (R.B. Ginsburg, J.). White
concerned a bribery prosecution under 18 U.S.C.
§ 201(c). Foreshadowing this Court’s approach in Rodriguez-Moreno, then-Judge Ginsburg’s opinion focused on whether any “acts necessary to establish the
crime of bribery occurred” in the District of Columbia.
Although the bribes apparently had their intended effect in the District because the recipient committed
“many official acts” there in exchange for payment,
that did not matter; “proof that [the bribee] was actually influenced in any such acts is not an element of
the bribery offense.” Id.; see also United States v.
Swann, 441 F.2d 1053, 1055 (D.C. Cir. 1971) (venue
for attempting to influence a witness was proper only
where the attempt took place, not where the witness
would testify).
2. The Ninth Circuit held below, by contrast, that
effects can establish venue whenever a statute “expressly contemplates” those effects. Pet. App. 42a. Relying on Angotti—which the First Circuit explicitly rejected in Salinas, 373 F.3d at 168—the Ninth Circuit
reasoned that “contemplated effects” are part of the essential conduct of an offense if the statute requires a
14
defendant to intend that his conduct have those effects, whether or not the effects are actually required
for conviction. Pet. App. 37a–38a. Though Mr.
Abouammo allegedly created and delivered the false
document to agents in his Seattle residence, the Ninth
Circuit held that the act of making a false document
continued until it was received by “‘the person or persons whom it [was] intended to affect or influence,’”
who happened to be in San Francisco. Id. at 39a (quoting Angotti, 105 F.3d at 543). It did not matter that
§ 1519 requires no actual influence or obstruction—
the intent element sufficed to permit venue wherever
the intended effects may be felt. Id. at 39a, 41a.
*
*
*
In at least the First, Third, Fourth, Fifth, Eleventh,
and D.C. Circuits, this case would come out the other
way. These courts all hold that an offense’s effects are
not grounds for venue unless those effects are themselves essential elements for conviction—which is not
the case just because the defendant must intend those
effects to occur.
B. The decision below is wrong.
The Constitution forecloses the Ninth Circuit’s rule
basing venue on an offense’s “contemplated” effects.
Article III commands that “[t]he Trial of all Crimes . . .
shall be held in the State where the said Crimes shall
have been committed.” U.S. Const. art III, § 2, cl. 3.
The Sixth Amendment adds that every accused shall
be tried “by an impartial jury of the State and district
wherein the crime shall have been committed.” Id.
amend. VI (emphasis added); accord Fed. R. Crim. P.
18. The crux of the constitutional venue analysis is
thus “the place of committing the crime”—the locus delicti. United States v. Anderson, 328 U.S. 699, 703
(1946).
15
In turn, “the locus delicti must be determined from
the nature of the crime alleged and the location of the
act or acts constituting it.” Id. Rodriguez-Moreno underscored this focus on the defendant’s “act or acts” by
holding that only an offense’s “essential conduct elements” can establish venue. 526 U.S. at 279–80.
The Ninth Circuit’s decision, however, looks not to
conduct, but to effects—and not effects that are required elements of the offense, but merely those the
defendant must intend, even if they never materialize.
As other circuits recognize, effects-based venue is
proper only “when an essential conduct element is itself defined in terms of its effects.” Bowens, 224 F.3d
at 311. That is not the case here.
As relevant, § 1519 criminalizes “knowingly . . . falsif[ying] . . . any record, document, or tangible object
with the intent to impede, obstruct, or influence the
investigation or proper administration of any matter
within the jurisdiction of any department or agency of
the United States.” This language requires three elements. The defendant must (1) knowingly (2) falsify a
document (3) with the intent to impede a federal investigation. See United States v. Spirito, 36 F.4th 191,
202 (4th Cir. 2022). The investigation need not actually exist; it can be merely “contemplat[ed].” 18 U.S.C.
§ 1519.
Under Rodriguez-Moreno, determining venue for a
§ 1519 prosecution turns on which of these elements
“are essential conduct elements.” 526 U.S. at 280 (emphasis added). The word “conduct” is important—Rodriguez-Moreno did not focus “simply [on] the essential
elements” of the offense, but on “where physical conduct occurred.” United States v. Miller, 808 F.3d 607,
615 (2d Cir. 2015) (cleaned up). “The determination of
criminal venue” thus turns on “the place of the relevant physical acts,” “not where criminal intent was
16
formed.” Id. (cleaned up); see also Clenney, 434 F.3d
at 782 (distinguishing between “an element of the offense” and “an essential conduct element”).
Only § 1519’s second element—falsifying the document—involves conduct. And it is undisputed that all
the conduct encompassed in that element occurred in
Seattle, not San Francisco. Pet. App. 10a–11a. Nor
does this conduct element refer in any way to the effects of the alleged falsification.
The first and third elements, by contrast, are mens
rea requirements. And “mens rea elements [are] irrelevant to venue.” Smith, 22 F.4th at 1243 (citing Rodriguez-Moreno, 526 U.S. at 279). But even if the intent element could be deemed a conduct element, the
Ninth Circuit still erred by focusing on the location of
the intent’s object, rather than where the intent itself
was formed. Obstructive intent is “formed and exist[s]
solely in the mind” of the offender, so it cannot be “committed” anywhere but where the offender was physically present. Clenney, 434 F.3d at 782. There is no
contention that Mr. Abouammo formed the requisite
obstructive intent anywhere other than Seattle. Either way, the Ninth Circuit’s decision is wrong.
In holding otherwise, the Ninth Circuit relied almost
entirely on Angotti—a pre-Rodriguez-Moreno decision
whose venue analysis on a separate count this Court
has already rejected. See Cabrales, 524 U.S. at 6. The
court below did not pause to examine Angotti for consistency with this Court’s later decisions. Cf. Salinas,
373 F.3d at 168. And Angotti itself did not focus on
essential conduct. Instead, it reasoned that “the act of
making a communication continues until the communication is received by the person or persons whom it
is intended to affect or influence,” even if “the statements did not have to reach their intended destination
in order to constitute a crime.” 105 F.3d at 543. That
17
holding, however, “has no support in the Sixth Amendment, in case law or in logic.” Id. at 546 (Norris, J.,
dissenting); id. at 547 (arguing that “crime was committed—it was over—when Angotti delivered the
fraudulent documents” in his home district).
The court below then mashed together Angotti’s continuing-communication theory with § 1519’s intent element to uphold venue on the theory that “§ 1519 expressly contemplates the effect of influencing” an investigation—even though it does not require any such effect. Pet. App. 37a (cleaned up). None of this comports
with Rodriguez-Moreno’s approach or the Constitution’s text.
Angotti aside, the Ninth Circuit also emphasized
that Mr. Abouammo “can hardly feign surprise at the
existence of a federal investigation being conducted in
the Northern District of California,” since “many other
features of this case . . . connect Abouammo to the
Northern District, most obviously his employment
with Twitter, which gave rise to the entire case.” Pet.
App. 43a. These considerations are improper. They
have nothing to do with where the offense was “committed” for constitutional venue purposes. The decision below is wrong.
C. This case is an ideal vehicle to decide
this important and recurring issue.
This petition presents a perfect chance to resolve the
split on effects-based venue. The facts are simple and
undisputed, the issue was pressed and passed upon at
each level below, and the Ninth Circuit denied Mr.
Abouammo’s rehearing petition, making clear that it
will not budge from its outlier position.
And this issue is vitally important. “Proper venue in
criminal proceedings was a matter of concern to the
Nation’s founders.” Cabrales, 524 U.S. at 6. It is a
18
bedrock principle that the accused stand trial only
where his alleged crime occurred. “In criminal cases
venue involves important considerations of policy,
with deep historical roots,” Charles A. Wright, Law of
Federal Courts § 43, at 271 (5th ed. 1994)—which led
to the Constitution “twice safeguard[ing] the defendant’s venue right” in express terms. Cabrales, 524 U.S.
at 6. Indeed, the proper place to be tried “was so important to the founding generation that it was listed
as a grievance in the Declaration of Independence.”
Auernheimer, 748 F.3d at 532.
This issue also has significant practical importance.
The Ninth Circuit’s rule invites the government to forum-shop by sending investigators from its chosen
venue to the defendant’s location, or even just by forwarding materials around within its own offices. Indeed, while the agents here happened to mention that
they were from San Francisco, Pet. App. 43a, the
Ninth Circuit’s rule does not require the defendant to
know “where the information would ultimately be received”—it is enough for him to know that someone,
somewhere will receive it. Angotti, 105 F.3d at 543.
Nor does an offense end once a document first reaches
the recipient entity or agency; according to the Ninth
Circuit, the offense “continues” until—so venue is
proper wherever—the communications reach their final recipient. See id.; id. at 547 (Norris, J., dissenting). Thus, so long as federal agents duly forward a
defendant’s documents or statements to an office in
San Francisco, every defendant in the Ninth Circuit
can be prosecuted there. On a national level, the Ninth
Circuit’s rule is a recipe for many federal criminal
prosecutions to flow to Washington, D.C., or to any
other forum where the government feels it has an advantage. Cf. Pet. App. 47a (Lee, J., concurring) (expressing concern about “government officials trying to
19
game the system by involving agents from a particular
district with an eye towards asserting venue in what
they view as a favorable district”).
This question also arises often, as the sheer volume
of post-Rodriguez-Moreno cases attests. Indeed, this
issue can arise in every single prosecution based on a
government investigation, a false mortgage application, stolen trade secrets, computer hacking, international parental kidnapping, and any other offenses involving potential effects that can cross state or district
lines. The Court should grant review here to resolve
the question it reserved in Rodriguez-Moreno, 526 U.S.
at 279 n.2.
II. The Court should grant review to decide
whether a waiverless felony information
tolls the statute of limitations under 18
U.S.C. § 3288.
Independently, the Ninth Circuit wrongly allowed
the government to bootstrap its way into a longer statute of limitations by filing a felony information on the
last day of the limitations period, knowing full well
that Mr. Abouammo did not and would not waive his
right to indictment by a grand jury. Absent a waiver,
this information was invalid, a mere placeholder.
Thus, it did not properly “charg[e] a felony” as required
to extend the limitations period under 18 U.S.C.
§ 3288.
This issue is critical to the administration of the
criminal justice system. Statutes of limitations “represent legislative assessments of relative interests of
the State and the defendant in administering and receiving justice; they are made for the repose of society
and the protection of those who may (during the limitation) have lost their means of defence.” United
States v. Marion, 404 U.S. 307, 322 (1971) (cleaned
20
up). “These statutes provide predictability by specifying a limit beyond which there is an irrebuttable presumption that a defendant’s right to a fair trial would
be prejudiced.” Id. “Such a time limit may also have
the salutary effect of encouraging law enforcement officials promptly to investigate suspected criminal activity.” Id. at 323.
These interests, however, are gutted by a rule that
allows prosecutors to decide how much time they
should have to prosecute. Cf. Klopfer v. North Carolina, 386 U.S. 213, 221–22 (1967) (the Sixth Amendment prohibited a state criminal procedure that allowed the prosecutor to toll the statute of limitations
indefinitely by entering a nolle prosequi). And the
Ninth Circuit is not the only court to bless such an aberrant rule. See United States v. Webster, 127 F.4th
318, 324 (11th Cir.) (holding that “filing an information without a waiver tolls the statute of limitations”), cert. denied, 145 S. Ct. 1461 (2025); Pet. App.
25a (citing cases).
Nothing in § 3288 contemplates such a dangerous result. This provision merely serves to “discourage defendants from delaying their motions to dismiss until
after the statute of limitations has run.” United States
v. Peloquin, 810 F.2d 911, 912 (9th Cir. 1987) (A. Kennedy, J.). Before the Covid-19 pandemic, § 3288 was
“rarely used and [was] unheard of by most prosecutors.” United States v. B.G.G., 53 F.4th 1353, 1370 n.1
(11th Cir. 2022) (Wilson, J., dissenting). Since then,
however, prosecutors across the country have dusted
it off and used it “to achieve a tactical advantage in
derogation of [defendants’] rights.” Id. at 1371. This
Court should put a stop to that practice.
Section 3288 provides a six-month grace period only
if the government timely files “an indictment or information charging a felony,” which is then dismissed. 18
21
U.S.C. § 3288. The government did not indict Mr.
Abouammo for money laundering or wire fraud within
the limitations period. Pet. App. 23a–24a. So the key
question is whether the information it filed in April
2020, just as the limitations period was expiring, was
an “information charging a felony.” If not, § 3288 was
never triggered and the eventual indictment on these
counts was untimely.
The answer is no—the April 2020 information did
not trigger the statute. Under the Fifth Amendment,
“[n]o person shall be held to answer for a capital, or
otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or
indictment of a Grand Jury[.]” U.S. Const. amend. V.
Thus, a federal felony “must be prosecuted by an indictment” unless “the defendant—in open court and after being advised of the nature of the charge and of the
defendant’s rights—waives prosecution by indictment.” Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(a)–(b). Only after such a
waiver may a felony “be prosecuted by information.”
Id. So, absent indictment, a valid waiver is required
to “confer power on the convicting court to hear the
case.” Smith v. United States, 360 U.S. 1, 10 (1959)
(emphasis added); United States v. Teran, 98 F.3d 831,
835 (5th Cir. 1996).
Against this backdrop, a felony information that is
not accompanied by a valid waiver of indictment does
not “charg[e] a felony,” as § 3288 requires. To “charge”
is to “accuse (a person) of an offense”—to bring a “formal accusation of an offense as a preliminary step to
prosecution.” See Charge, Black’s Law Dictionary
(12th ed. 2024). A waiverless information does not do
so, because it does not and cannot begin a felony prosecution. In the Constitution’s terms, a defendant need
not “answer for” felony allegations in an information
unless he waives indictment. U.S. Const. amend. V.
In turn, the government “should not be able to grant
22
itself a six-month extension of the statute of limitations whenever it wants, in every case, simply by filing
a patently defective and meaningless charging document, and then immediately dismissing it to invoke
the savings provisions of § 3288.” United States v.
Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d 1317, 1330 (S.D. Fla. 2023). Trying to extend the limitations period by filing “a legal
nullity” is a “bad-faith gambit.” B.G.G., 53 F.4th at
1374–75 (Wilson, J., dissenting).
This analysis finds further support in the general
statute-of-limitations provision, which requires that
the “indictment [be] found or the information [be] instituted” within the prescribed limitations period. 18
U.S.C. § 3282. A waiverless indictment is “insufficient
to ‘institute’ a prosecution under section 3282.”
B.G.G., 53 F.4th at 1374 (Wilson, J., dissenting); see
also Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d at 1325 (collecting cases).
This Court’s decision in Jaben v. United States illustrates the point. That case similarly involved a limitations period that could be extended if “a complaint
[was] instituted” within the initial six-year period. 381
U.S. 214, 215 (1965). On the day before the six-year
period expired, the government filed a complaint. Id.
at 216. The defendant was later indicted; that indictment was timely only “if the complaint . . . was valid
for the purpose of bringing the nine-month extension
into play.” Id. The government argued that, “regardless of the complaint’s adequacy for any other purposes, it was valid for the purpose of triggering the
nine-month extension of the limitation period whether
or not it showed probable cause.” Id. at 217. This
Court disagreed: “[T]he complaint, to initiate the time
extension, must be adequate to begin effectively the
criminal process,” meaning it “must be sufficient to
justify the next steps in the process.” Id. at 220; accord
23
id. at 226–27 (Goldberg, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part). For the reasons just explained, the
information here was not “adequate to begin effectively the criminal process.”
The statute thus speaks clearly. But even if it were
ambiguous, the canon in favor of repose require that a
felony information be accompanied by the defendant’s
waiver of indictment to satisfy and potentially extend
the statute of limitations. See Toussie v. United
States, 397 U.S. 112, 115 (1970).
In holding otherwise, the Ninth Circuit acknowledged that “a felony cannot be prosecuted by information unless the defendant waives prosecution by indictment.” Pet. App. 25a. But it never grappled with
the implications of that fact for whether the April 2020
information actually “charg[ed]” a felony. It simply declared that “[n]othing in this language requires that
the information be ‘instituted’ or otherwise accompanied by a waiver.” Id. at 26a. It thus skipped over the
meaning of “instituted” altogether. Id. at 25a.
The crux of the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning was instead a 1988 amendment to § 3288, in which “Congress
specifically removed language requiring a waiver of indictment.” Pet. App. 27a. From 1964 to 1988, the statute applied “[w]henever an indictment is dismissed for
any error, defect, or irregularity with respect to the
grand jury, or an indictment or information filed after
the defendant waives in open court prosecution by indictment is found otherwise defective or insufficient
for any cause.” See Id. at 27a n.4 (strikeout omitted).
In 1988, Congress adopted the law’s current language:
“Whenever an indictment or information charging a
felony is dismissed for any reason . . . .” Id. (emphasis
omitted); Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1988, Pub. L. No.
100-690, tit. VII, § 7081(a), 102 Stat. 4181, 4407.
24
The court’s narrow focus on this change was erroneous in two ways. First, the court “presume[d]” that
Congress intended the 1988 deletion to “have real and
substantial effect.” Pet. App. 28a. To be sure—but
what effect? Congress answered that question: This
amendment served merely to overrule a Ninth Circuit
decision holding “that a Speedy Trial Act violation is
neither an ‘irregularity with respect to the grand jury’
nor a defect or insufficiency in the indictment itself,”
such that § 3288 did not apply to a dismissal for speedtrial violations. Section Analysis of Judiciary Committee Issues in H.R. 5210 (Senate), 134 Cong. Rec.
S17360-02, 17372 (daily ed. Nov. 10, 1998), 1988 WL
182529 (citing Peloquin, 810 F.2d 911). Congress gave
no indication that the change was meant to do anything beyond what it thought the statute already accomplished. See id. (explaining that the prior statute
already “appear[ed] to permit the extension no matter
what the reason for the dismissal of the charges”).
Second, the Ninth Circuit ignored the rest of the
statutory history. Although indictments and informations have existed for centuries, informations were
never used for felonies until the twentieth century.
See Ex Parte Wilson, 114 U.S. 417, 423–25 (1885);
Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d at 1326. Thus, when Congress
first used the phrase “information is instituted” in
§ 3282’s predecessor provision in 1790, it cannot have
intended to include a waiverless felony information.
There was no such thing. This language could have
referred only to a charging document validly alleging
a lesser offense. See Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d at 1326.
the modern usage of the same phrase carries the old
soil with it.
Likewise, § 3288’s predecessor statute did not refer
to informations at all, only indictments. See id. at
25
1327–28. Congress added the reference to informations in 1964, in response to Criminal Rule 7 “authoriz[ing] the prosecution of a noncapital felony by information if the defendant in open court waives prosecution by indictment.” S. Rep. No. 88-1414, at 2 (1964),
as reprinted in 1964 U.S.C.C.A.N. 3257, 3257–58.
That is, Congress “recognize[d] that felony prosecutions may be instituted by informations and that dismissals of such prosecutions because of technical defects in the informations should be accorded treatment
similar to that accorded prosecutions instituted by indictments.” Id. The added reference to informations
would thus “permit reindictment in similar cases
where an information was filed after the defendant
waived in open court prosecution by indictment.” Id. at
1 (emphasis added).
This history “demonstrates that Congress intended
[§] 3288 . . . to toll the limitations period at § 3282 for
dismissed informations where those informations comported with Rule 7(b)”—meaning where the defendant
waived indictment. Gatz, 704 F. Supp. 3d at 1328. In
other words, Congress assumed throughout this process that “the filed information would constitute a
valid charging document.” Id. “The idea that an ineffective information could be instituted to toll the limitations period, but not to prosecute the accused, could
not have been a consideration at [§ 3282’s] inception,
nor at the time § 3288 or its predecessor were enacted.”
Id.
This Court should grant review to make clear that
§ 3288’s requirement of an “information charging a felony” has teeth and does not allow the Government to
use a constitutionally defective, waiverless information to circumvent the limitations period. The contrary rule invites abuse.
26
CONCLUSION
For these reasons, the petition should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
CARMEN SMARANDOIU
OFFICE OF THE FEDERAL
PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR
THE NORTHERN DISTRICT
OF CALIFORNIA
450 Golden Gate Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94102
TOBIAS S. LOSS-EATON
Counsel of Record
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
1501 K Street NW
Washington, DC 20005
(202) 736-8427
tlosseaton@sidley.com
JEFFREY T. GREEN
DANIELLE HAMILTON
THE CARTER G. PHILLIPS/
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
SUPREME COURT CLINIC
NORTHWESTERN PRITZKER
SCHOOL OF LAW
375 East Chicago Avenue
Chicago, IL 60611
(312) 503-1486
JAMES R. HORNER
ANA PAJAR BLINDER
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
787 7th Avenue
New York, NY 10019
Counsel for Petitioner
July 16, 2025
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.