Emergency Application — West Virginia, et al., Applicants v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.
Supreme Court briefJul 23, 2024
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
service requirements of its Montana customers|,|” § 69-3-1204(2)(a)(i),
MCA.
6. The Rule introduces significant economic uncertainty for
important electricity generating units (““EGUs’”) in the portfolio of
electricity resources serving Montana residents and businesses and
underpinning the export of electricity to utilities across the pacific
northwest region of states. The Rule also limits the options for adding
new generation to serve existing and new electricity demand in
Montana. Specifically, the Rule requires major modifications to the
existing Colstrip Units 3 and 4 in Rosebud County, Montana.
7. Colstrip Units 3 and 4 are coal-fired steam generating units,
each with a nameplate generating capacity of 740 megawatts. The units
are operated by Talen Montana and currently serve residential and
commercial customers of NorthWestern Energy in Montana, large
industrial customers of Talen Montana, as well as electricity customers
of utilities with service territories including parts of Idaho, Washington,
and Oregon. The units play an integral role in maintaining operation of
the NorthWestern Balancing Authority in Montana, especially during
peak electricity demand events. NorthWestern Energy, a thirty percent
4
498a
owner of Unit 4 has announced plans to acquire Avista Corporation’s
fifteen percent shares in Units 3 and 4, effective January 1, 2026.
NorthWestern’s depreciation schedule for its current share of Unit 4
runs through 2042.
8. The Rule’s requirement of 90 percent carbon capture has not
been adequately demonstrated as required of the best system of emission
reduction (BSER) in Section 111 of the Clean Air Act. In addition to the
degree of emission limitation available through application of BSER, the
cost of achieving the reduction must be considered. Carbon capture and
sequestration/storage (CCS) has been extremely expensive to implement
and operate. Two examples of failed CCS operations are the Kemper
CCS site in Mississippi (not operating on coal any longer) and the Petra
Nova CCS site in Texas. One site that is still operating is the Boundary
Dam CCS project in Canada which, at best, operates at a 65% carbon
capture and cost $4.2 million per megawatt (MW). If this cost was scaled
to the MW ratings of the Colstrip units, capital costs would be in the
billions of dollars, not to mention the parasitic loads which are required
for capturing the carbon dioxide - most likely in an absorption tower that
requires significant heating and cooling operations.
5
499a
9. A 2016 report from the US Department of Energy (DOE)
predicted as much as $3 billion to retrofit the Colstrip units as a
preliminary cost estimate; scaling the $4.2 million per MW from
Boundary Dam to Colstrip suggests that capital costs could be as high
as $15 billion. Until projects can demonstrate 90% carbon capture,
incorporating this requirement in the Rule is not realistic on a technical
or financial basis.
10. The cost of transportation and storage for CCS is much higher
in Montana’s Powder River Basin than in other states. A study
referenced in the proposed rule reports that the CQO2 pipeline
transportation and storage cost in 2018 was $22/tonne for the Powder
River Basin. The other basins in the study were Illinois ($10/tonne), East
Texas ($11/tonne), and Williston ($15/tonne). Montana questions the
equity of its sites to have the same CCS requirements as other states,
while taking on much greater costs, which are based on reservoir geology
and thereby unavoidable.
11. EPA dismisses the potential impacts to electric system
reliability caused by closure of EGUs that are unable to justify the
economic impact of Rule compliance costs. In dismissing those concerns,
6
500a
EPA does not adequately account for direct impacts of the Rule in
Montana and the NorthWestern Energy Balancing Authority that would
be caused by potential closure of impacted EGUs. Colstrip Units 3 and 4
generated forty one percent of the electricity generated in Montana in
2022, and represented twenty three percent of total installed generating
capacity, see Electricity Statistics Tables, Mont. Department of
Environmental Quality, accessed at
https://deq.mt.gov/files/Energy/Documents/Energy_Statistics/Electricit
y Tables2023-Updated.xlsx. Colstrip’s generating capacity in high load
events varies depending on maintenance schedules, and the availability
and price of other supply resources. However, during the peak of record
setting electricity demand in the NorthWestern Balancing Authority
driven by a severe cold weather event in January 2024, coal fired EGUs
within the balancing authority generated seventy five percent of the
customer electricity demand, see Hourly Electric Grid Monitor, U.S.
Energy Information Administration,
https://www.ela.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electric overview
/balancing authority/NWMT (accessed May 8, 2024). Peak electricity
demand for that event hit on January 138, 2024, a day when
7
501la
temperatures dropped below minus 30 degrees Fahrenheit in major
population centers served by NorthWestern.
12. If the costs of compliance with the Rule prove prohibitively
expensive to undertake, the Rule requires retiring Colstrip Units 3 and
4 prior to January 1, 2032, leaving large industrial customers and utility
owners of the units to replace the generating capacity and energy output
of those EGUs with a mix of resources capable of reliably meeting
comparable energy and capacity requirements, while continuing to meet
the growing demand for electricity in Montana. The requirement to
replace the output of the Colstrip units would come at a time when the
Western Electricity Coordinating Council has assessed that, “(s)upply
chain disruptions, increasing costs, production obstacles, and an
overwhelmed interconnection queue threaten industry timelines to build
new resources,” see 2023 Western Assessment of Resource Adequacy,
Western Electricity Coordinating Council (accessed May 8, 2024),
https://www.wecc.org/Administrative/2023%20Western%20Assessment
%200f%20Resource%20Adequacy.pdf. The uncertainty of adding
replacement generation to adequately meet growing demand threatens
the ability of Montana utilities to meet customer demands in accordance
8
502a
with other legal requirements, such as North American Electric
Reliability Corporation (“NERC”) Standards. See NERC, Reliability
Standards (last visited May 3, 2024),
https://www.nerc.com/pa/Stand/Pages/ReliabilityStandards.aspx.
13. Risks to electricity system reliability, driven in part by
retirement of dispatchable, high-capacity factor thermal EGUs, is a
matter of significant concern. WECC reports that current utility
resource plans in the western interconnect “are not sufficient to meet
future demand over each of the next 10 years,” and that “starting in
2026, the number and magnitude of demand-at-risk hours increase by
orders of magnitude.” WECC attributes the growing risks to reliability
to increasing variability, “driven primarily by the addition of nondispatchable variable energy resources (VER), the retirement of
dispatchable resources, and the increase in load uncertainty due to
extreme weather events,” see 2023 Western Assessment of Resource
Adequacy, Western Electricity Coordinating Council (accessed May 8,
2024),
https://www.wecc.org/Administrative/2023%20Western%20Assessment
%200f%20Resource%20Adequacy.pdf.
9
503a
aw ona Newakeowdfe
SONJA NOWAKOWSKI
Dated: May 10, 2024
10
504a
EXHIBIT 14
505a
DECLARATION OF GAVIN MCCOLLAM
I, Gavin A. McCollam, declare as follows:
1. My name is Gavin A. McCollam. I am the Senior Vice President
and Chief Operating Officer of Basin Electric Power Cooperative (“Basin
Electric”). I am over the age of 18 years, and I am competent to testify
concerning the matters in this declaration. I have personal knowledge of the
facts set forth in this declaration, and if called upon and sworn as a witness,
could and would competently testify to them.
2. Ihave more than 35 years of experience in the electric generation
industry. I have been employed at Basin Electric since 1989. I hold an
associate’s degree from Bismarck (North Dakota) State College, a bachelor’s
degree in mechanical engineering from North Dakota State University, and
a master’s degree in systems management from the University of Southern
California. I am also a registered professional engineer.
3. Basin Electric is a member of the National Rural Electric
Cooperative Association (“NRECA”). This declaration is submitted in
support of NRECA’s and North Dakota’s legal challenges to the rule entitled
506a
New Source Performance Standards for Greenhouse Gas Emissions From New,
Modified, and Reconstructed Fossil Fuel-Fired Electric Generating Units; Emission
Guidelines for Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Existing Fossil Fuel-Fired Electric
Generating Units; and Repeal of the Affordable Clean Energy Rule, 89 Fed. Reg.
39798 (May 9, 2024) (the “Final Rule” or “Rule”).
I. BASIN ELECTRIC
4. I am familiar with how the Final Rule will affect Basin Electric,
the electric markets, and suppliers of electric equipment and services, as well
as Basin Electric’s consumer members.
5. Basin Electric is a not-for-profit generation and transmission
(“G&T”) cooperative incorporated in 1961 to provide supplemental power to
a consortium of rural electric cooperatives. Those member cooperatives— 140
of them—are Basin Electric’s owners. Through them, Basin Electric serves
approximately three million consumer members in an area that covers
roughly 500,000 square miles across nine states: Colorado, lowa, Minnesota,
Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, North Dakota, South Dakota, and
Wyoming. Basin Electric’s end-use consumer members across these nine
507a
states include residential, farm, commercial, industrial, and irrigation electric
consumers. In 2022, Basin Electric’s farm and residential consumer members
accounted for 29% of its megawatt-hour (“MWh”) sales, while the
commercial and industrial consumer members accounted for 68% of the
MWh sales.
6. As of the end of 2023, Basin Electric had an asset base of $8 billion
and operated 5,219 megawatts (“MW”) of wholesale electric generating
capability and had 8,112 MW of generating capacity within its portfolio.
Those owned electric generation facilities are located in the states of lowa,
Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Wyoming. Basin Electric’s
members provide electric service to 75% of the persistent poverty counties
located within the nine states served, according to the 2023 persistent
poverty data compiled by the U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic
Research Service.
7. In order to provide the reliable electric supply that the member
owners expect, Basin Electric is committed to an “all of the above”
generating strategy which calls for multiple generating units utilizing
508a
diverse fuel types (both fuel-fired and renewable resources) at dispersed
locations. Basin Electric has invested and committed to approximately $7
billion dollars in developing new renewable energy resources, and it
of the end of 2023). The other components of Basin Electric’s portfolio
include coal-fired generation (=2,850 MW), natural gas-fired generation
(1,250 MW), market purchases (=1,350 MW), hydroelectric (=300 MW),
other fossil fuels (175 MW), and recovered energy (50 MW).
8. Basin Electric’s diverse portfolio of electricity generation is a
result of the significant investments that Basin Electric has made in the past
two decades, as the following infographic summarizes:
YEAR
2,839 MW Poses G oF
er Cost Oii/ Diesei Jet Fuei tiydro
2400 MW + 34.6% 120 MW « 4.2% 319 MW - 11.2%
YEAR
Lr
8.112 MW oad “y 4)
—_—— Coal Natural Gas Recovered Energy Market Purchases
2280 MW + 32% 1.266 MW « 15.6% 45 Vw + 0.6%. 1339 MW « 16.5%
OW Diesel Jet Fuel Hydro Wind
T7S MW + 22°, 318 MW - 3.9%. 2,108 MW - 26%
209a
9. Basin Electric has many electric generating units (“EGUs”) that
fall within the scope of the Final Rule (“affected EGUs”) and thus must
comply with the Final Rule’s stringent new standards for coal-fired steam
units. These affected EGUs have remaining useful lives that would be
significantly shortened under the Final Rule absent massive amounts of new
investment to cover all the compliance costs that the Rule creates. These
substantial costs would fall on Basin Electric, and ultimately, on our rural
consumer members. The table below identifies the EGUs that would be
impacted if the Final Rule takes effect. The table also shows the results of
Basin Electric’s preliminary analysis of the approximate capital costs to
comply with the Final Rule.
Affected EGU | State Compliance Strategy = Capital Cost
F 2 billion
mah ork WY _|Long Term: CCS at 90%. $
Station
Antelove Valle Medium Term: Co-fire with
; P ; y ND |natural gas by 2029; retire by |$104 million
Station Unit 1
2038.
Antelope Valley Medium Term: Co-fire with
Station Unit 2 ND _|natural gas by 2029; retire by |$104 million
2038.
510a
Leland Olds ND_ |Applicability exemption; $0
Station Unit 1 retire by 2031.
Leland Olds ND _ |Applicability exemption; $0
Station Unit 2 retire by 2031.
Laramie River WY |Unknown Unknown
Station Unit 1*
Laramie River
; WY |Unknown Unknown
Station Unit 2”
Laramie Kiver WY |Unknown Unknown
Station Unit 3*
Walter Scott Jr.
Energy Center IA |Unknown Unknown
Unit 3**
Walter Scott Jr.
Energy Center IA jUnknown Unknown
Unit 4**
George Neal
South Generating IA jUnknown Unknown
Station Unit 4***
Replacement Unknown Unknown
Generation
*Basin Electric owns an undivided joint interest in Laramie River of
approximately 42%.
** Basin Electric has a power purchase agreement with one of its
members for the output of their ownership interest in Walter Scott Jr.
Energy Center Unit 3 and Unit 4. Through those agreements with its
members, Basin Electric has financial responsibility for approximately
4% of Unit 3 and approximately 6% of Unit 4. Such rights do not
provide the ability to make decisions on these Units.
5lla
*** Basin Electric has two power purchase agreements with two of its
members for the output of their ownership interest in George Neal
South Unit 4. Collectively, Basin Electric has financial responsibility for
approximately 16% of the unit. This percentage does not provide the
ability to make decisions on this unit. MidAmerican Energy Company,
as the majority owner and the operator of the unit, has this right and
responsibility.
10. Basin Electric is currently in the middle of a massive generation
and transmission buildout necessary to address load growth and long-term
grid stability for its growing membership. Basin Electric is constructing an
addition of approximately 580 MW of natural gas simple cycle generation to
the existing Pioneer Generation Station, at a cost of approximately $800
million, that is expected to come online in 2025. Basin Electric is also actively
investigating the need for more than 1,000 MW of dispatchable generation
in western North Dakota by 2030 to address members’ needs. This new
generation will also need to comply with the Final Rule. In addition to these
active generation projects, Basin Electric is also constructing over 300 miles
of high voltage transmission line projects along with several major
substation projects. The transmission line projects include the Roundup-to-
Kummer Ridge 345kV project, the Leland Olds Station-to-Tande 345kV
512a
project, and the Tande and Wheelock-to-Saskatchewan 230kV project. These
projects have a combined cost of more than $700 million.
11. The table and graph below illustrate the projected capital cost
associated with the planned generation expansion without the Final Rule
(“Base Case’), as well as the projected capital cost associated with meeting
load growth and complying with the Final Rule through 2045 (“Final Rule
Case”). The incremental capital cost through 2035 to comply with the Final
Rule is nearly $10 billion. The incremental capital cost through 2045 to
comply with the Final Rule is more than $14 billion. These costs do not
include any costs that would be associated with Final Rule compliance at
Laramie River, Water Scott Jr. Energy Center, or George Neal South
Generating Station.
51l3a
2030-2045 Base Case Final Rule
Total Need (SPP): 3,000 MW 3,500 MW
Total Need (RMPA): 350 MW 450 MW
Total Need (MISO): 45 MW 45 MW
Total Resource Need: 3,395 MW 3,995 MW
Avg Resource Costs: @ ~$2,000/kW @ ~$4,400/kW
Total Cap Costs: $6,790,000,000 $17,578,000,000
Net Incremental Costs to Resource Expansion +$10,788,000,000
NG Conversion +S 208,000,000 +
Carbon Capture on DFS + WLP Resource +S 3,800,000,000
Total incremental Costs =$14,796,000,000+
Resource Installed Costs by Year
$25,000
$29,000
$15,000 u
/ $14,796 MM
* / Ps difference
9,985 iM
difference
aes | aa a oe
mM Che ES pated L i
2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2033 2040 2041 2042 2045 2044 2045 2046 2047 20428 2049 2050
Millions of Dollars |$)
:
S.,
N
,
)
“,
Game Bose Cese Instolicd Costs wee Firiol Rule Coase Insta led Costs — — Bose Cese GQumulative Costs — — Final Rule Case Curnuletive Costs
Il. OVERVIEW OF THE FINAL RULE
12. The Final Rule sets CO2 emissions limits that States must apply
to existing coal-fired steam electric generating units, under Section 111(d).
dl4da
89 Fed. Reg. 39840. The Rule also sets CO2 emissions limits for new gas-fired
combustion-turbine units, under Section 111(b). Id. 39902. Both types of units
must meet emissions limits equal to what EPA believes 90% carbon-captureand-sequestration can achieve. Existing units that cannot achieve this must
shut down. New units that cannot achieve this must drastically limit their
output of electricity.
13. Existing coal-fired units. The Rule divides existing coal-fired steam
units into three non-overlapping subsets: two are “subcategories” and one is
an “applicability exemption.” Id. 39841. These subsets are defined by
whether a unit has committed to permanently retire, and by the retirement
date that a unit has committed to. See id. For purposes of implementing these
subcategorizations for a particular unit, EPA recognizes only those
retirement commitments that are made “federally enforceable” via inclusion
in a State plan. Id. 40000. State plans are due to EPA in 24 months. Id. 39997.
14. The first (and default) subcategory is for “long-term” units,
which EPA defines as units that “intend to operate past January 1, 2039.” Id.
39801. EPA says that the best system for this subcategory is CCS that
10
515a
captures 90% of the CO2 from a unit. Id. 39845. This system begins with the
design, engineering, and installation of COz capture technology. Id. 39846.
Then the captured COz must be transported (usually via pipeline) to a site
that can permanently sequester it (usually underground). See id. EPA
“assumes” that “work” toward “each component of CCS” will begin in “June
2024.” Id. 39874. And the Rule requires unit operators to complete that work
before January 1, 2032. Id. 39801.
15. The second subcategory is for “medium term” units: those that
commit “to permanently cease operations” sometime “after December 31,
2031” but “before January 1, 2039.” Id. 39841; see id. 39958. EPA says that best
system for this subcategory is “[nJatural gas co-firing at 40 percent.” Id.
39801. That means transforming a coal unit into a unit that combusts both
coal and natural gas. See id. Just “[a]s in the timeline for CCS,” EPA
“assumes” that “work” toward co-firing will begin in June 2024. Id. 39893.
And the Rule requires medium-term unit operators to complete that work
before January 1, 2030. Id. 39845.
11
5l6a
16. Third, the Rule establishes an “applicability exemption” for units
that commit “to permanently cease operation before January 1, 2032.” Id.
39841. These units “are not regulated by” the Rule. Id. 39843. However, if
such a unit then “continues to operate past [that date], then it is no longer
exempt,” id., putting the unit “in violation of” the State plan and the Clean
Air Act, id. 39991.
17. New gas-fired combustion turbine units. For new and modified gasfired combustion turbines, the Rule creates three subcategories. These
subcategories are defined by a unit’s “electric sales (i.e., utilization) relative
to the [unit’s] potential electric output.” Id. 39908. “Low load” units (those
that sell “20 percent or less of their potential electric output”) must comply
with a standard of performance based on “lower-emitting fuels.” Id. 39917.
“Intermediate load” units (those that sell 20-40%) must comply with a
standard based on “high-efficiency simple cycle turbine technology.” Id.
“Base load” units (those sell more than 40%) must comply with a “multiphase standard of performance.” Id. 39923. Phase I is “based on the
performance of a highly efficient combined cycle turbine” and has “an
12
517a
immediate compliance date.” Id. 39903. Phase II is based on 90% CCS and
has “a compliance date of January 1, 2032.” Id.
Ill. IMPACTS TO AFFECTED EGUs
18. Impacts at Dry Fork Station — “Long Term” subcategory. The Dry
Fork Station (“Dry Fork”) consists of one 405 MW affected EGU located in
Gillette, Wyoming. It began operation in 2011, with a construction cost of
$1.35 billion. The station uses pulverized subbituminous coal technology
and the latest generation of pollution control technologies resulting in very
low emissions. As water is a scarce resource in Wyoming, Dry Fork uses air
cooling. The plant location has potential area to site a carbon capture unit.
Dry Fork is home to the Wyoming Integrated Test Center and the Wyoming
CarbonSAFE project, both of which receive funding from the Department of
Energy and the state of Wyoming for research projects that aim to help
develop CCS technology.
19. Dry Fork is a relatively new coal-fired power plant, and its
remaining depreciable life extends into the early 2070s. As a result, Basin
Electric plans to leave Dry Fork within the Final Rule’s default category for
13
518a
“long term” EGUs. That decision requires Basin Electric to achieve 90% CCS
at Dry Fork by the end of 2031. That level of CCS, if it can be achieved at all
and in that time frame, can only be achieved with significant time and at
great expense and risk. Indeed, Basin Electric is not aware of any
manufacturer currently offering to warrant equipment that will achieve 90%
CCS under any conditions, much less under large-scale and high-demand
baseload conditions. Still, to have any hope of meeting the Final Rule’s 2031
deadline for Dry Fork, Basin Electric must immediately begin spending
money across a variety of expense categories.
20. Carbon capture costs. If it is possible to achieve 90% carbon capture
at Dry Fork, it would require the addition of a post-combustion capture
system. The cost for such a system is estimated to total approximately
$2 billion. That astronomical expenditure is more than 150% of what it cost
to construct the Dry Fork in the first place barely a decade ago. Complying
with the Final Rule’s 2031 deadline would require that Basin Electric enter
into engineering, equipment, and other contracts immediately.
14
519a
21. Basin Electric would first need to enter into engineering
contracts, as a great deal of engineering would need to be performed prior
to entering into any equipment contracts. Engineering costs typically
represent approximately five percent of project costs, and are typically more
costly for projects which involve the construction of new technology. In
addition, Basin Electric would also need to hire an engineering firm to
commence modeling work in order to apply for the permits necessary to
begin construction of such a project.
22. Thenext step is ordering equipment. The carbon capture process
equipment alone would cost Basin Electric approximately $400 million and
a down payment of approximately 10% would likely be required.
Engineering and equipment would need to be scheduled and committed to
within the next 12 months. Based on previous experience, approximately 5 —
10% of the total project cost is spent on engineering and design costs. In the
first two years alone, Basin Electric would expect to spend approximately
$20 million on preliminary engineering and design costs that, but for the
Final Rule, would not be expended.
15
520a
23. Carbon transport costs. For CCS to work, once captured, the COz
must be transported to appropriate pore space. At Dry Fork, this would
require approximately 27 miles of pipeline, based on preliminary studies.
Some level of CCS would be feasible at Dry Fork (if at all) only because there
is pore space in the region that could accommodate CO: storage. Still,
constructing a pipeline to transport captured COz from Dry Fork to this
location would cost approximately $4 million per mile. Given high demand
and long lead times for labor and specialized piping—both of which will
only worsen as owners of EGUs across the country simultaneously attempt
to comply with the Final Rule—Basin Electric must begin spending money
immediately for planning, design, engineering, siting, permitting, and
construction of a pipeline to transport captured CO2.
24. Basin Electric’s subsidiary, the Dakota Gasification Company,
recently built a COz pipeline. Based on that project, we estimate the required
pipeline for Dry Fork would cost approximately $108 million and that Basin
Electric would perform the engineering design and procure the equipment
at a cost of approximately $50 million in the first two years.
16
52la
25. Carbon storage costs. Once it is transported, the captured COz
from Dry Fork must be stored. Identifying and contracting for the necessary
pore space is likely as challenging as meeting the 90% carbon capture
requirement. Pore space in Wyoming will be challenging to procure, in light
of the large percentage of federally owned land within the state. There is
potentially suitable geology for CCS near Dry Fork, but geology is only the
first piece of the puzzle. Even once transportation is solved, pore space can
be utilized for storage only after an operator leases the thousands of acres of
pore space and designs, permits, and constructs the storage facility. As with
constructing a pipeline, all of that is outside Basin Electric’s control. Leasing
pore space for storage is both time-consuming and expensive.
26. Operational costs. According to a third-party study that Basin
Electric commissioned several years ago, the annual operating and
maintenance cost for 70% carbon capture at Dry Fork was estimated to be
$56 million (2029). But even implementing that plan would not be sufficient
to comply with the Final Rule, which would instead require Dry Fork to
achieve a 90% CCS by January 1, 2032. Assuming 90% capture could be
17
522a
achieved, that level of CCS would cost even more in annual operating
expenses. The technology for attempting to achieve 90% CCS also demands
significant water usage. Water is a scarce resource in Wyoming and would
only be available at substantial expense. All of these are costs that Basin
Electric must ultimately pass through to its consumer members.
27. Reliability impacts. One further significant cost is that CCS at any
level tends to make an EGU less reliable. This makes unplanned outages
more frequent and more severe. Basin Electric personnel have been to the
Boundary Dam CCS project in Saskatchewan, and Basin Electric is familiar
with the challenges experienced by SaskPower in maintaining and operating
that capture unit, including unplanned outages. Unplanned outages
increase Basin Electric’s overall costs, hurt its relationships with consumer
members, and can even affect its standing with the Regional Transmission
Organization (“RTO”). Therefore, the reliability impacts of CCS are another
significant risk facing Basin Electric.
28. Impacts at Antelope Valley Station — “Medium Term” subcategory.
The Antelope Valley Station (”Antelope Valley”) consists of two affected
18
523a
EGUs located in Beulah, North Dakota. Each EGU is rated at 450 MW.
Antelope Valley is located on a site adjacent to Dakota Gasification
Company’s Great Plains Synfuels Plant. Antelope Valley began operation in
the 1980s, with a construction cost of approximately $1.9 billion. Antelope
Valley is fueled by lignite coal from the adjacent Freedom Mine.
29. Antelope Valley’s remaining depreciable life extends into the
2040s. Yet the Final Rule’s default BSER—90% CCS by the end of 2031—is
not economically feasible at Antelope Valley due to the age of the units and
the short time that would be available to recover the massive investment
necessary for CCS. Basin Electric has engaged in extensive efforts to
participate in CCS research and development, including spending millions
of dollars toward project development to build a demonstration project at
Antelope Valley. That demonstration aimed to capture CO2 emissions from
about one quarter of one of the units at the plant. In other words, even this
state-of-the-art demonstration project would not be sufficient to comply with
the Final Rule. But even with a $100 million grant from the DOE and the
availability of Dakota Gasification Company’s pipeline for transporting the
19
524a
captured CQ2, Basin Electric’s feasibility study determined that the
technology required too large of a parasitic load. Additionally, it came with
an estimated cost of at least $500 million in 2010, would result in a significant
increase in the cost of electricity to Basin Electric’s members, and posed too
great a risk given the technology provider was unwilling to guarantee the
removal rate.
30. Due to these and other factors, Basin Electric plans to
subcategorize Antelope Valley into the Final Rule’s “medium term”
subcategory. That election requires Basin Electric to make a legally binding
commitment (in 2025 or 2026) to shut Antelope Valley down by 2038, and to
achieve 40% natural gas co-firing at Antelope Valley by the end of 2029. To
achieve that, Basin Electric must immediately begin spending money across
a variety of expense categories.
31. Equipment costs. Retrofitting Antelope Valley’s EGUs to co-fire
40% natural gas by the end of 2029 will require Basin Electric to make
immediate capital expenditures. Antelope Valley uses natural gas as a
startup fuel, but the existing equipment only allows for approximately 20%
20
525a
co-firing. Because of that, each EGU’s burner unit must be replaced, at an
approximate total cost of $4 to 5 million. Burners are not “off the shelf”
equipment, but instead must be purchased from a limited number of original
equipment manufacturers, all of whom will simultaneously be facing a
massive increase in demand from other affected EGUs across the country.
32. Transport costs. Basin Electric cannot co-fire natural gas at
Antelope Valley unless there is a way for natural gas to be transported to
those EGUs. Antelope Valley currently receives natural gas for startup fuel
via a pipeline sourced from the Great Plains Synfuels Plant. However, to
have an independent supply of natural gas would require installation of an
approximately 40-mile pipeline connecting Antelope Valley to the closest
interstate gas pipeline, Northern Border Pipeline, and related fuel supply
infrastructure at cost of approximately $160 million (based on the
assumption of $4 million per mile.) Given the long lead times for
construction projects, a pipeline operator must begin design, permitting,
siting, procurement, and construction immediately merely to have a chance
to have natural gas available to Antelope Valley in time for the Final Rule’s
21
526a
end-of-2029 deadline. But no operator is likely to take all those steps without
a substantial, up-front commitment from Basin Electric—either in the form
of a capital contribution to the project, or in the form of a long-term (20-30
year) supply contract. Even if Basin Electric identified an operator and
agreed to such terms, there is no guarantee that such a pipeline could
actually be completed in time. Permitting, engineering construction, rightof-way acquisition, and myriad other factors could block the pipeline or
could delay it beyond the Final Rule’s compliance deadlines. If that
happened, Basin Electric’s investments in equipment costs would be
completely lost, and Antelope Valley would need to shut down.
33. Permitting risks. Converting Antelope Valley to natural gas cofiring will also require Basin Electric to obtain new permits, including a New
Source Review permit and an updated Title V permit. But these permits are
expensive and time consuming, and their issuance is also subject to judicial
review. In order to have proper permitting in place by 2030, Basin Electric
must immediately begin the permitting process for Antelope Valley.
22
527a
[OCR skipped on page(s) 31-108]
[Read from a scan; the first 30 pages.]
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.