Emergency Application — East Kentucky Power Cooperative, Inc., Applicant v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.

Supreme Court briefNov 5, 2024

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. _______

In the Supreme Court of the United States

EAST KENTUCKY POWER COOPERATIVE, INC.,

Applicant,

v.

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY and

MICHAEL REGAN, in his official capacity as Administrator of the

United States Environmental Protection Agency,

Respondents.

TO THE HONORABLE JOHN G. ROBERTS, JR.,

CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE UNITED STATES AND

CIRCUIT JUSTICE FOR THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

APPENDIX TO APPLICATION FOR IMMEDIATE

STAY OF FINAL AGENCY ACTION

PENDING APPELLATE REVIEW

S. Chad Meredith

Counsel of Record

G. Luke Burton

SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS

(US) LLP

201 E. Fourth St., Suite 1900

Cincinnati, Ohio 45202

Telephone: +1 513 361 1200

Facsimile: +1 513 361 1201

E-mail:

chad.meredith@squirepb.com

luke.burton@squirepb.com

Attorneys for Petitioner

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Hazardous and Solid Waste Management System: Disposal of Coal

Combustion Residuals from Electric Utilities; Legacy CCR Surface

Impoundments, 89 Fed. Reg. 38950 (May 8, 2024) ..........................................App.1

Order, City Utilities of Springfield, Missouri, by and through the Board

of Public Utilities v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al., Case

Nos: 24-1200 (lead), 24-1267, 24-1269, 24-01274, 24-1275,and 241276 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 1, 2024) ........................................................................App.174

East Kentucky Power Cooperative Comments on the “CCR Rule” (July

17, 2023).........................................................................................................App.176

East Kentucky Power Cooperative v. United States Environmental

Protection Agency, et al., Docket No. EPA-HQ-OLEM-2020-0107,

Petition for Stay (August 7, 2024) ................................................................App.190

East Kentucky Power Cooperative v. United States Environmental

Protection Agency, et al., Docket No. EPA-HQ-OLEM-2020-0107,

Amended Petition for Stay (August 16, 2024) ..............................................App.209

East Kentucky Power Cooperative v. United States Environmental

Protection Agency, et al., Case No: 24-1267 Petition for Review

(August 2, 2024).............................................................................................App.228

East Kentucky Power Cooperative v. United States Environmental

Protection Agency, et al., Case No: 24-1267 Declaration of Jerry

Purvis in Suppport of D.C. Circuit Court Motion for Stay (August

19, 2024).........................................................................................................App.407

Exhibit A – KDWM’s Approval of The Closure Plan for the Former

Dale Station Impoundments .........................................................................App.427

Exhibit B – KDWM’s Letter Noting Acceptance and Termination of

the Work Performed by EKPC in Accordance with The Closure Plan ........App.430

42 U.S.C. § 6903 ..................................................................................................App.432

42 U.S.C. § 6944 ..................................................................................................App.435

42 U.S.C. § 6945 .................................................................................................App.436

Risk Assessment of Coal Combustion Residuals: Legacy Impoundments

and CCR Management Units (April 2024) ...................................................App.440

38950

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

AGENCY

40 CFR Parts 9 and 257

[EPA–HQ–OLEM–2020–0107; FRL–7814–

04–OLEM]

RIN 2050–AH14

Hazardous and Solid Waste

Management System: Disposal of Coal

Combustion Residuals From Electric

Utilities; Legacy CCR Surface

Impoundments

AGENCY: Environmental Protection

Agency (EPA).

ACTION: Final rule.

SUMMARY: On April 17, 2015, the

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA

or the Agency) promulgated national

minimum criteria for existing and new

coal combustion residuals (CCR)

landfills and existing and new CCR

surface impoundments. On August 21,

2018, the United States Court of

Appeals for the District of Columbia

Circuit vacated the exemption for

inactive surface impoundments at

inactive facilities (legacy CCR surface

impoundments) and remanded the issue

back to EPA to take further action

consistent with its opinion in Utility

Solid Waste Activities Group, et al. v.

EPA. This action responds to that order

and establishes regulatory requirements

for legacy CCR surface impoundments.

EPA is also establishing requirements

for CCR management units at active CCR

facilities and at inactive CCR facilities

with a legacy CCR surface

impoundment. Finally, EPA is making

several technical corrections to the

existing regulations, such as correcting

certain citations and harmonizing

definitions.

DATES: This final rule is effective on

November 4, 2024.

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

ADDRESSES: EPA has established a

docket for this action under Docket ID

No. EPA–HQ–OLEM–2020–0107. All

documents in the docket are listed on

the http://www.regulations.gov website.

Although listed in the index, some

information is not publicly available,

e.g., CBI or other information whose

disclosure is restricted by statute.

Certain other material, such as

copyrighted material, is not placed on

the internet and will be publicly

available only in hard copy form.

Publicly available docket materials are

available electronically through http://

www.regulations.gov.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For

questions concerning this proposal,

contact Michelle Lloyd, Office of

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

Resource Conservation and Recovery,

Materials Recovery and Waste

Management Division, Environmental

Protection Agency, 1200 Pennsylvania

Avenue NW, MC: 5304T, Washington,

DC 20460; telephone number: (202)

566–0560; email address:

Lloyd.Michelle@epa.gov, or Taylor Holt,

Office of Resource Conservation and

Recovery, Materials Recovery and Waste

Management Division, Environmental

Protection Agency, 1200 Pennsylvania

Avenue NW, MC: 5304T, Washington,

DC 20460; telephone number: (202)

566–1439; email address: Holt.Taylor@

epa.gov. For more information on this

rulemaking, please visit https://

www.epa.gov/coalash.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Table of Contents

I. General Information

A. Does this action apply to me?

B. What action is the Agency taking?

C. What is the Agency’s authority for

taking this action?

D. What are the incremental costs and

benefits of this action?

II. Background

A. 2015 CCR Rule

B. 2018 USWAG Decision

C. 2020 Part B Proposed Rule

D. 2020 Advance Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking

E. 2023 Proposed Rule and Comments

F. 2023 Notice of Data Availability

III. What is EPA finalizing?

A. Risks From Legacy CCR Surface

Impoundments and CCR Management

Units

1. Summary of May 2023 Proposal

2. 2023 Draft Risk Assessment

3. Response to Comments on the Proposal

and the NODA

4. 2024 Final Risk Assessment

B. Legacy CCR Surface Impoundment

Requirements

1. Definition of a ‘‘Legacy CCR Surface

Impoundment’’

2. Applicable Requirements for Legacy

CCR Surface Impoundments and

Compliance Deadlines

C. CCR Management Unit Requirements

1. Damage Cases

2. Applicability and Definitions Related to

CCR Management Units

3. Facility Evaluation for Identifying CCR

Management Units

4. Applicable Requirements for CCR

Management Units and Compliance

Deadlines

D. Closure of CCR Units by Removal of

CCR

1. Background

2. March 2020 Proposed Rule

3. What is EPA Finalizing Related to the

March 2020 Proposed Rule

E. Technical Corrections

IV. Effect on State CCR Permit Programs

V. The Projected Economic Impact of This

Action

A. Introduction

B. Affected Universe

C. Baseline Costs

PO 00000

Frm 00002

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.1

D. Costs and Benefits of the Final Rule

VI. Statutory and Executive Order Reviews

Regulatory Text

List of Acronyms

ACM Assessment of Corrective Measures

ANPRM Advance Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking

ARAR applicable or relevant and

appropriate requirements

ASD alternative source demonstration

CAA Clean Air Act

CBI Confidential Business Information

CBR closure by removal

CCR coal combustion residuals

CCRMU coal combustion residuals

management unit

CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental

Response, Compensation, and Liability

Act

CIP closure in place

CFR Code of Federal Regulations

COALQUAL U.S. Geological Survey coal

quality database

CWA Clean Water Act

DOE Department of Energy

EAP Emergency Action Plan

EIA Energy Information Administration

EIP Environmental Integrity Project

EJ environmental justice

ELG Effluent Limitation Guidelines

EPA Environmental Protection Agency

EPACMTP EPA Composite Model for

Leachate Migration with Transformation

Products

EPRI Electric Power Research Institute

FER Facility Evaluation Report

FERC Federal Energy Regulatory

Commission

FGD flue gas desulfurization

FR Federal Register

GWMCA groundwater monitoring and

corrective action

GWPS groundwater protection standard

HQ hazard quotient

HSWA Hazardous and Solid Waste

Amendments

ICR Information Collection Request

IRIS Integrated Risk Information System

LEAF Leaching Environmental Assessment

Framework

MCL maximum contaminant level

MDE Maryland Department of the

Environment

MNA monitored natural attenuation

MODFLOW–USG Modular ThreeDimension Finite-Difference GroundWater Flow Model

MSW Municipal Solid Waste

MW Megawatts

NAICS North American Industry

Classification System

NERC North American Electric Reliability

Corporation

NODA notice of data availability

NPDES National Pollution Discharge

Elimination System

NPL National Priorities List

NTTAA National Technology Transfer and

Advancement Act

OAFU Other Active Facilities

OLEM Office of Land and Emergency

Management

OMB Office of Management and Budget

OSHA Occupational Safety and Health

Administration

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

P.E. Professional Engineer

PM particulate matter

PRA Paperwork Reduction Act

PRG preliminary remediation goal

PUC Public Utility Commission

QA/QC quality assurance/quality control

RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery

Act

RIA Regulatory Impact Analysis

RME reasonable maximum exposure

RTO Regional Transmission Organizations

SMCL secondary maximum contaminant

level

SSI statistically significant increase

SSL statistically significant level

TDS total dissolved solids

TSCA Toxic Substances Control Act

TSDF Transportation Storage and Disposal

Facility

TVA Tennessee Valley Authority

UMRA Unfunded Mandates Reform Act

USGS U.S. Geological Survey

USWAG Utility Solid Waste Activities

Group

WIIN Water Infrastructure Improvements

for the Nation

WQC water quality criteria

I. General Information

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

A. Does this action apply to me?

This rule applies to and may affect all

CCR generated by electric utilities and

independent power producers that fall

within the North American Industry

Classification System (NAICS) code

221112. The reference to NAICS code

221112 is not intended to be exhaustive,

but rather provides a guide for readers

regarding entities likely to be regulated

by this action. This discussion lists the

types of entities that EPA is now aware

could potentially be regulated by this

action. Other types of entities not

described here could also be regulated.

To determine whether your entity is

regulated by this action, you should

carefully examine the applicability

criteria found in 40 CFR 257.50 of title

40 of the Code of Federal Regulations.

If you have questions regarding the

applicability of this action to a

particular entity, consult the person

listed in the FOR FURTHER INFORMATION

CONTACT section.

B. What action is the Agency taking?

EPA is amending the regulations

governing the disposal of CCR in

landfills and surface impoundments,

codified in subpart D of part 257 of Title

40 of the Code of Federal Regulations

(CFR) (CCR regulations). Specifically,

the Agency is establishing regulatory

requirements for inactive CCR surface

impoundments at inactive utilities

(‘‘legacy CCR surface impoundment’’ or

‘‘legacy impoundment’’). This action is

being taken in response to the August

21, 2018, opinion by the U.S. Court of

Appeals for the District of Columbia

Circuit in Utility Solid Waste Activities

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

Group v. EPA, 901 F.3d 414 (D.C. 2018)

(‘‘USWAG decision’’ or ‘‘USWAG’’) that

vacated and remanded the provision

exempting legacy impoundments from

the CCR regulations. This action

includes adding a definition for legacy

CCR surface impoundments and other

terms relevant to this rulemaking. It also

requires that legacy CCR surface

impoundments comply with certain

existing CCR regulations with tailored

compliance deadlines.

While this action is responsive to the

D.C. Circuit’s order, it is also driven by

the record, which clearly demonstrates

that regulating legacy CCR surface

impoundments will have significant

quantified and unquantified public

health and environmental benefits. As

EPA concluded in 2015, the risks posed

by unlined CCR surface impoundments

are substantial, and the risks from

legacy impoundments are at least as

significant. EPA’s 2014 Risk Assessment

concluded that the cancer risks from

unlined surface impoundments ranged

from 3 × 10¥4 for trivalent arsenic to 4

× 10¥5 for pentavalent arsenic. Noncancer risks from these same units also

significantly exceeded EPA’s level of

concern, with estimated Hazard

Quotients (HQ) of two for thallium,

three for lithium, four for molybdenum

and eight for trivalent arsenic. In

addition, as described in Unit III.A.1 of

this preamble, information obtained

since 2015 indicates that the risks for

legacy CCR surface impoundments are

likely to be greater than EPA originally

estimated. Finally, based on the

demographic composition and

environmental conditions of

communities within one and three miles

of legacy CCR surface impoundments,

this final rule will reduce existing

disproportionate and adverse effects on

economically vulnerable communities,

as well as those that currently face

environmental burdens. For example, in

Illinois the population living within one

mile of legacy CCR surface

impoundment sites is over three times

as likely compared to the State average

to have less than a high school

education (35.66% compared to

10.10%, see Regulatory Impact Analysis

(RIA) exhibit ES.14), and that

population already experiences higher

than average exposures to particulate

matter, ozone, diesel emissions, lifetime

air toxics cancer risks, and proximity to

traffic, Superfund sites, Risk

Management Plan sites, and hazardous

waste facilities (see RIA exhibit ES.15).

Consistent with the directive in section

4004(a) to ensure that the statutory

standard is met at all regulated sites,

including the most vulnerable, this final

PO 00000

Frm 00003

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.2

38951

rule will help EPA further ensure that

the communities and ecosystems closest

to coal facilities are sufficiently

protected from harm from groundwater

contamination, surface water

contamination, fugitive dust, floods and

impoundment overflows, and threats to

wildlife.

EPA is also establishing requirements

to address the risks from currently

exempt solid waste management that

involves the direct placement of CCR on

the land. EPA is extending a subset of

the existing requirements in 40 CFR part

257, subpart D to CCR surface

impoundments and landfills that closed

prior to the effective date of the 2015

CCR Rule, inactive CCR landfills, and

other areas where CCR is managed

directly on the land. In this action, EPA

refers to these as CCR management

units, or CCRMU. The final rule

expands the CCRMU requirements to a

set of active facilities that were not

regulated by the 2015 CCR rule because

they had ceased disposing of CCR in

their on-site disposal units, and they did

not have an inactive surface

impoundment. Accordingly, this rule

applies to all CCRMU at active CCR

facilities and inactive facilities with a

legacy CCR surface impoundment.

EPA is also finalizing alternative

closure provisions to allow a facility to

complete the closure by removal in two

stages: first, by completing all removal

and decontamination procedures; and

second, by completing all groundwater

remediation in a separate post closure

care period.

Finally, EPA is making a number of

technical corrections to the existing

regulations, such as correcting certain

citations and harmonizing definitions.

EPA intends the provisions of the rule

to be severable. In the event that any

individual provision or part of the rule

is invalidated, EPA intends that this

would not render the entire rule invalid,

and that any individual provisions that

can continue to operate will be left in

place. For example, EPA intends that

the provisions governing each class of

facilities—legacy CCR inactive surface

impoundments, CCR management units,

other active facility units, and regulated

CCR landfills containing waste in

contact with groundwater—to be

independently severable from one

another as each set of requirements

operates independently from the other.

Likewise, the provisions regulating

existing units at active facilities,

including those units at non-fossil-fuelfired facilities generating energy, are

severable from the other substantive

requirements—each provision may

continue operating even if one of the

others is invalidated. EPA also intends

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

38952

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

that, within each set of provisions for

legacy CCR surface impoundments and

for CCR management units, the

substantive requirements be severable

from each other. For example, if any of

the closure requirements were to be set

aside (e.g., the requirement that CCRMU

initiate closure within 48 months of

publication), the groundwater

monitoring and corrective action

requirements can continue to fully and

effectively operate. These requirements

function independently from each other,

address environmental concerns

through different means, and are not

dependent on the others; they are

therefore severable from each other.

Lastly, as set forth below, EPA has

deferred the dates by when some units

in some circumstances must comply

with the substantive standards

governing legacy CCR surface

impoundments and CCR management

units. If any of the deferrals were to be

set aside, EPA intends that the

substantive standards would remain in

place because the rationale for and

effectiveness of each set of substantive

standards is not dependent on any of

the deferrals.

For the reader’s convenience, EPA has

provided a background description of

existing requirements in several places

throughout this preamble.

C. What is the Agency’s authority for

taking this action?

EPA is publishing this notice under

the authority of sections 1008(a),

2002(a), 3007, 4004, and 4005(a) and (d)

of the Solid Waste Disposal Act of 1970,

as amended by the Resource

Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976

(RCRA), as amended by the Hazardous

and Solid Waste Amendments of 1984

(HSWA) and the Water Infrastructure

Improvements for the Nation (WIIN) Act

of 2016, 42 U.S.C. 6907(a), 6912(a),

6927, 6944, 6945(a) and (d).

RCRA section 1008(a) authorizes EPA

to publish ‘‘suggested guidelines for

solid waste management.’’ 42 U.S.C.

6907(a). RCRA defines solid waste

management as ‘‘the systematic

administration of activities which

provide for the collection, source

separation, storage, transportation,

transfer, processing, treatment, and

disposal of solid waste.’’ 42 U.S.C.

6903(28).

Pursuant to section 1008(a)(3), the

guidelines are to include the minimum

criteria to be used by the States to define

the solid waste management practices

that constitute the open dumping of

solid waste or hazardous waste and are

prohibited as ‘‘open dumping’’ under

section 4005. Only those requirements

promulgated under the authority of

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

section 1008(a)(3) are enforceable under

section 7002 of RCRA.

RCRA section 4004(a) generally

requires EPA to promulgate regulations

containing criteria distinguishing

‘‘sanitary landfills,’’ which may

continue to operate, from ‘‘open

dumps,’’ which are prohibited. 42

U.S.C. 6944(a); see id. 6903(14), (26);

6945(a). The statute directs that, ‘‘at a

minimum, the criteria are to ensure that

units are classified as sanitary landfills

only if there is no reasonable probability

of adverse effects on health or the

environment from disposal of solid

wastes at such facility.’’ 42 U.S.C.

6944(a).

RCRA section 4005(a), entitled

‘‘Closing or upgrading of existing open

dumps,’’ prohibits any solid waste

management practices or disposal of

solid waste that does not comply with

EPA regulations issued under RCRA

section 1008(a) and 4004(a). 42 U.S.C.

6945(a). See also 42 U.S.C. 6903(14)

(definition of ‘‘open dump’’). This

prohibition takes effect ‘‘upon

promulgation’’ of any rules issued under

section 1008(a)(3) and is enforceable

either through a citizen suit brought

pursuant to section 7002, or through an

EPA enforcement action brought

pursuant to section 4005(d)(4)(A). See

42 U.S.C. 6945(a), (d)(4)(A) (authorizing

EPA to use the authority under RCRA

section 3008(a) to enforce the open

dumping prohibition for CCR). RCRA

section 4005(a) also directs that open

dumps (i.e., facilities out of compliance

with EPA’s criteria), must be closed or

upgraded. See 42 U.S.C. 6945(a).

RCRA section 4005(d)(3) specifies that

the regulations in 40 CFR part 257,

subpart D ‘‘(or successor regulations

promulgated pursuant to sections

6907(a)(3) and 6944(a) of this title), shall

apply to each CCR unit’’ unless a permit

issued by an approved State or by EPA

is in effect. Similarly, section

4005(d)(6) 1 provides that:

a CCR unit shall be considered to be a

sanitary landfill for purposes of this chapter,

including subsection (a), only if the coal

combustion residuals unit is operating in

accordance with [a permit issued by EPA or

an approved State] or the applicable criteria

for coal combustion residuals units under

part 257 of title 40, Code of Federal

Regulations (or successor regulations

promulgated pursuant to sections 6907(a)(3)

and 6944(a) of this title).

1. Regulation of Solid Wastes Under

RCRA Subtitle D

Solid wastes that are neither a listed

nor characteristic hazardous waste are

subject to the requirements of RCRA

1 42 U.S.C. 6945(d)(6).

PO 00000

Frm 00004

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.3

subtitle D. Subtitle D of RCRA

establishes a framework for Federal,

State, and local government cooperation

in controlling the management of

nonhazardous solid waste. The Federal

role is to establish the overall regulatory

direction by providing minimum

nationwide standards that will protect

human health and the environment.

States may, but are not required to,

adopt these requirements into their

State programs.

Under RCRA section 4005(a), upon

promulgation of criteria under section

1008(a)(3), any solid waste management

practice or disposal of solid waste that

constitutes the ‘‘open dumping’’ of solid

waste is prohibited. The Federal

standards apply directly to the facility

(are self-implementing) and facilities are

directly responsible for ensuring that

their operations comply with these

requirements.

RCRA section 4005(d) establishes an

additional regulatory structure,

applicable exclusively to the solid waste

management of CCR, that builds on the

provisions in sections 1008(a)(3), 4004,

and 4005(a), without restricting the

scope of EPA’s authority under those

sections. See, 42 U.S.C. 6945 (d)(7).

Under 4005(d), States may seek EPA

approval of a State permitting program

under which individualized facility

permits would ‘‘operate in lieu of [EPA]

regulation of coal combustion residuals

units in the State.’’ 42 U.S.C.

6945(d)(1)(A). EPA is also directed to

‘‘implement a permit program,’’ which

would operate in absence of an

approved State program. 42 U.S.C.

6945(d)(2). However, the statute makes

clear that facilities must continue to

comply with the Federal regulations

until a permit issued by either EPA or

an approved State is in effect. 42 U.S.C.

6945(d)(3), (6).

RCRA sections 1008(a)(3) and 4004(a)

delegate broad authority to EPA to

establish regulations governing the

management of solid waste. Under

section 4004(a) EPA is charged with

establishing requirements to ensure that

facilities will be classified as sanitary

landfills and not an open dump ‘‘only

if there is no reasonable probability of

adverse effects on health or the

environment from the disposal of solid

waste’’ at the facility. Or in other words,

under section 4004(a) EPA is charged

with issuing regulations to address all

‘‘reasonable probabilities of adverse

effects’’ (i.e., all reasonably anticipated

risks) to health and the environment

from the disposal of solid waste. Section

1008(a)(3) expands EPA’s authority to

address the risks from any of the

activities identified as ‘‘solid waste

management’’ in RCRA section

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

1004(28). Specifically, EPA is

authorized to establish requirements

applicable to ‘‘storage, transportation,

transfer, processing, treatment, and

disposal of solid waste.’’ (42 U.S.C.

6907(a), 6903(28)). Under RCRA, EPA

sets these requirements without taking

cost into account as a factor. See

USWAG et al. v. EPA, 901 F.3d at 448–

49 (citing RCRA section 4004(a)).

The statute is clear that EPA is

authorized to issue regulations to

address the current risks from previous

solid waste management activities. EPA

explained at length the basis for this

conclusion as part of the Agency’s

rationale for regulating inactive

impoundments. See, 80 FR 21344—

21347. See also USWAG, 901 F.3d at

440. Among other provisions, the

statutory definition of an ‘‘open dump’’

conclusively resolves the question.

RCRA defines an ‘‘open dump’’ as ‘‘any

facility or site where solid waste is

disposed of . . . .’’ 42 U.S.C. 6903(14).

As the D.C. Circuit explained,

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Importantly, while the ‘‘is’’ retains its

active present tense, the ‘‘disposal’’ takes the

form of a past participle (‘‘disposed’’). In this

way, the disposal itself can exist (it ‘‘is’’),

even if the act of disposal took place at some

prior time . . . . Properly translated then, an

open dump includes any facility (other than

a sanitary landfill or hazardous waste

disposal facility), where solid waste still ‘‘is

deposited,’’ ‘‘is dumped,’’ ‘‘is spilled,’’ ‘‘is

leaked,’’ or ‘‘is placed,’’ regardless of when

it might have originally been dropped off.

See 42 U.S.C. 6903(3), (14). In other words,

the waste in inactive impoundments ‘‘is

disposed of’’ at a site no longer receiving new

waste in just the same way that it ‘‘is

disposed of’’ at a site that is still operating.

901 F.3d at 440. See also In re

Consolidated Consol. Land Disposal

Regulation Litig., 938 F.2d 1386, 1389

(D.C. Cir. 1991) (EPA’s reading of the

term ‘‘disposal’’ in RCRA’s subtitle C, 42

U.S.C. 6924, to include ‘‘the continuing

presence of waste’’ was reasonable);

USWAG, 901 F.3d at 453–54

(Henderson, J., concurring) (same). By

the same logic, these provisions would

authorize EPA to regulate closed units

that continue to pose risks to health or

the environment, for example by

requiring the owners or operators of

such units to remediate any

contamination from these units, or to

take action to prevent such

contamination.

The 2016 amendments further

confirm EPA’s authority over these

activities. In section 4005, Congress

referenced the 2015 regulations in the

statute, and expressly stated that the

amendments in 4005(d) were not

intended to limit or restrict the

authority already provided under

sections 1008(a)(3) and 4004(a). See, 42

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

U.S.C. 6945(d)(3), (6), (7). By

incorporating the rule into the statute

without modification, Congress has

affirmed the Agency’s authority to

impose the kind of requirements

established in part 257 (e.g., corrective

action to remediate groundwater

contamination). Moreover, Congress

made clear that EPA retains the

authority to modify or expand these

requirements as necessary to ensure that

the standard in section 4004(a) will

continue to be met. See, e.g., 42 U.S.C.

6945(d)(1)(A)(i), (3), (6) (referencing ‘‘or

successor regulations promulgated

pursuant to sections 6907(a)(3) and

6944(a) of this title’’).

EPA interprets the standard in section

4004(a) to apply equally to criteria

issued under sections 1008(a)(3) and

4004(a); namely that the criteria must

ensure that a facility is to be classified

as a sanitary landfill, and thus allowed

to continue to operate, ‘‘only if there is

no reasonable probability of adverse

effects on health or the environment’’

from either the disposal or other solid

waste management practices at the

facility. Thus, under the combined

authority conferred by sections

1008(a)(3) and 4004(a), a facility is an

‘‘open dump’’ if it engages in any

activity involving the management of

solid waste that does not meet the

standard in section 4004(a); or in other

words, any activity involved with the

management of solid waste that presents

a reasonable probability of causing

adverse effects on health or the

environment. EPA also interprets these

provisions to authorize the

establishment of criteria that define the

manner in which facilities upgrade or

close, consistent with the standard in

section 4004(a), to ensure there will be

no reasonable probability of adverse

effects on health or the environment.

D. What are the incremental costs and

benefits of this action?

As noted previously, EPA establishes

the requirements under RCRA sections

1008(a)(3) and 4004(a) without taking

cost into account. See, USWAG, 901

F.3d at 448–49. The following cost

estimates are presented in the RIA and

summarized in this preamble for

compliance with OMB Circular A–4,

E.O. 12866, and E.O. 14094. The

requirements in this rule do not rely on

these cost estimates.2

2 Although EPA did not consider costs in

developing this rule, if the Agency had considered

costs, the final rule would not have been different.

As discussed in greater detail later in this preamble

and in the RIA, the monetized benefits are based on

only a subset of adverse health effects from a single

constituent. EPA monetized the benefit from two

additional human health endpoints associated with

PO 00000

Frm 00005

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.4

38953

The RIA estimates that the annualized

monetized costs of this action will be

approximately $214–$240 million per

year when discounting at 2%. Of this,

$123–$135 million is attributable to the

requirements for legacy CCR surface

impoundments, which are subject to the

D.C. Circuit’s order in USWAG, $79–$92

million is attributable to the

requirements for CCRMU, an additional

$8–$9 million is attributable to the

requirements for CCRMU at Other

Active Facilities (OAFUs) (a term used

in the RIA) that are discussed in Unit

III.C.2.e of the preamble, and $4 million

is attributable to requirements for

landfills. The costs of this final rule are

discussed further in the RIA and

include the costs of unit closure,

corrective action, fugitive dust controls,

structural integrity inspections, and

recordkeeping and reporting.

The RIA estimates that the annualized

monetized benefits attributable to this

action will be approximately $53–$80

million per year when discounting at

2%. Of this, $43–$57 million is

attributable to the requirements for

legacy CCR surface impoundments, $9–

$21 million is attributable to the

requirements for CCRMU, $1–$2 million

is attributable to the requirements for

CCRMU at ‘‘other active facilities,’’ or

OAFUs. Requirements for landfills

account for a de minimis amount of

benefits.

In addition to monetized benefits, the

RIA describes ten categories of nonmonetized benefits. These include

human health effects from lead

exposure such as ADHD, cardiovascular

mortality, and increased cancer risk.

They also include ecosystem benefits

from avoided exposure to the heavy

metals in CCR effluent. The RIA

describes several property-related

benefits including increased property

values near closed and remediated CCR

units, and option values for remediated

land. The RIA also contextualizes the

final rule within EPA’s broader efforts to

regulate air and surface water pollution

from coal fired power plants.

Further information on the economic

effects of this action can be found in

Unit V of this preamble.

that single constituent in a sensitivity analysis and

estimated an additional $19 million per year when

discounting at 2% from that single contaminant.

The RIA also describes a number of important

benefits that cannot currently be quantified or

monetized due to data limitations or limitations in

current methodologies. Based on these estimates

EPA believes that after considering all unquantified

and distributional effects, the public health and

welfare gains that will result from the proposed

alternative would justify the rule’s costs.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

38954

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

II. Background

A. 2015 CCR Rule

On April 17, 2015, EPA finalized

national minimum criteria for the

disposal of CCR as solid waste under

Subtitle D of RCRA titled, ‘‘Hazardous

and Solid Waste Management System;

Disposal of Coal Combustion Residuals

from Electric Utilities’’ (80 FR 21302)

(2015 CCR Rule). The 2015 CCR Rule,

codified in 40 CFR part 257, subpart D,

established regulations for existing and

new CCR landfills, as well as existing

and new CCR surface impoundments

(including all lateral expansions of CCR

units). The criteria consist of location

restrictions, design and operating

criteria, groundwater monitoring and

corrective action requirements, closure

and post-closure care requirements,

recordkeeping, notification, and internet

posting requirements.

The 2015 CCR Rule also imposed

requirements on inactive surface

impoundments at active facilities. A

CCR surface impoundment is a natural

topographic depression, man-made

excavation, or diked area, which is

designed to hold an accumulation of

CCR and liquids, and the unit treats,

stores, or disposes of CCR. The 2015

CCR Rule defined an ‘‘inactive CCR

surface impoundment’’ as ‘‘a CCR

surface impoundment that no longer

receives CCR on or after October 19,

2015, and still contains both CCR and

liquids on or after October 19, 2015.’’ 40

CFR 257.53. The rule defined ‘‘active

facility or active electric utilities or

independent power producers’’ as ‘‘any

facility subject to the requirements of

this subpart that is in operation on

October 19, 2015. An electric utility or

independent power producer is in

operation if it is generating electricity

that is provided to electric power

transmission systems or to electric

power distribution systems on or after

October 19, 2015. An off-site disposal

facility is in operation if it is accepting

or managing CCR on or after October 19,

2015.’’ 40 CFR 257.53.

The 2015 CCR Rule did not impose

any requirements on inactive facilities.

EPA explained that this was consistent

with past decisions under RCRA subtitle

C. See, 80 FR 21344 (April 17, 2015).

EPA further raised concerns that it

would be difficult to identify the owners

or other parties responsible for such

facilities, as well as concerns that the

present owner of the land on which an

inactive facility was located might have

no connection (other than present

ownership of the land) with the prior

disposal activities. Id. Consequently,

EPA exempted those units at

§ 257.50(e).

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

B. 2018 USWAG Decision

The 2015 CCR Rule was challenged by

several parties, including coalitions of

regulated entities and environmental

organizations (‘‘Environmental

Petitioners’’). See USWAG et al. v. EPA,

901 F.3d 414 (D.C. Cir. 2018).

Environmental Petitioners raised two

challenges that are relevant to this final

rule. First, they challenged the

provision at § 257.101(a)(1) that allowed

existing, unlined surface impoundments

to continue to operate until they

exceeded the groundwater protection

standard. They contended that EPA

failed to show how continued operation

of unlined impoundments met RCRA’s

baseline requirement that any solid

waste disposal site pose ‘‘no reasonable

probability of adverse effects on health

or the environment.’’ 42 U.S.C. 6944(a).

Second, Environmental Petitioners

challenged the exemption at § 257.50(e)

for inactive surface impoundments at

inactive power plants (i.e., ‘‘legacy

ponds’’). Environmental Petitioners

argued that legacy ponds are at risk of

unmonitored leaks and catastrophic

structural failures.

On August 21, 2018, the U.S. Court of

Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld

most of the 2015 CCR Rule but decided

in favor of Environmental Petitioners on

these two claims. The Court held that

EPA acted ‘‘arbitrarily and capriciously

and contrary to RCRA’’ in failing to

require the closure of unlined surface

impoundments 3 and in exempting

inactive surface impoundments at

inactive power plants from regulation.

The Court vacated these provisions and

remanded the matter back to the Agency

for further action consistent with its

opinion.

In overturning the exemption for

legacy ponds, the Court evaluated the

evidence in the rulemaking record and

reached specific conclusions about the

risks that legacy ponds pose based on

the record for the 2015 CCR Rule. The

Court pointed to evidence that legacy

ponds are most likely to be unlined and

unmonitored and that such units have

been shown to be more likely to leak

than units at utilities still in operation.

901 F.3d at 432. The Court also

determined that legacy ponds:

. . . pose the same substantial threats to

human health and the environment as the

riskiest Coal Residuals disposal methods,

compounded by diminished preventative and

remediation oversight due to the absence of

an onsite owner and daily monitoring. See 80

FR at 21343 through 21344 (finding that the

3 After the Court’s ruling, the closure of unlined

CCR surface impoundments was addressed in a

separate regulatory action that was published on

August 28, 2020 (85 FR 53516).

PO 00000

Frm 00006

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.5

greatest disposal risks are ‘‘primarily driven

by the older existing units, which are

generally unlined’’). Notably, this very Rule

was prompted by a catastrophic legacy pond

failure that resulted in a ‘‘massive’’ spill of

39,000 tons of coal ash and 27 million

gallons of wastewater into North Carolina’s

Dan River. . . .

[T]here is no gainsaying the dangers that

unregulated legacy ponds present. The EPA

itself acknowledges the vital importance of

regulating inactive impoundments at active

facilities. That is because, if not properly

closed, those impoundments will

‘‘significant[ly]’’ threaten ‘‘human health and

the environment through catastrophic

failure’’ for many years to come. 75 FR at

35,177; see also 80 FR at 21,344 n. 40.

The risks posed by legacy ponds are at

least as substantial as inactive

impoundments at active facilities. See 80 FR

at 21,343–21, 344 (finding ‘‘no [ ]

measurabl[e] differen[ce]’’ in risk of

catastrophic events between active and

inactive impoundments). And the threat is

very real. Legacy ponds caused multiple

human and environmental disasters in the

years leading up to the Rule’s promulgation.

See 75 FR at 35,147 (proposed rule discusses

multiple serious incidents). For example, a

pipe break at a legacy pond at the Widows

Creek plant in Alabama caused 6.1 million

gallons of toxic slurry to deluge local

waterways. Id. Another legacy pond in

Gambrills, Maryland caused the heavy metal

contamination of local drinking water. Id.

And the preamble to the Rule itself

specifically points to the catastrophic spill at

the Dan River legacy pond in North Carolina.

80 FR at 21,393–21,394.

Id. at 432–433. Relying on this evidence,

the Court concluded there was no

logical basis for distinguishing between

the inactive impoundments at active

facilities that were regulated and the

legacy impoundments that were exempt.

Id. at 434. Consequently, the Court

vacated the provision of the 2015 CCR

Rule (§ 257.50(e)) that specifically

exempted inactive impoundments at

inactive facilities from regulation and

remanded the matter back to EPA for

further action consistent with its

opinion. Notwithstanding the vacatur of

§ 257.50(e), until EPA amended the

regulations to effectuate the Court’s

order, facilities were not legally obliged

to take any action to comply with the

Federal CCR regulations. This is

because, as originally drafted, legacy

CCR surface impoundments did not fall

within the scope of the rule, as defined

in § 257.50. The specific provision in

§ 257.50(e) exempting legacy

impoundments merely identified the

units that were not covered by

§ 257.50(b). Because the vacatur of

§ 257.50(e) did not amend § 257.50(b),

legacy impoundments remained

exempt.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

C. 2020 Part B Proposed Rule

In the March 3, 2020 proposed rule,

Hazardous and Solid Waste

Management System: Disposal of CCR;

A Holistic Approach to Closure Part B:

Alternate Demonstration for Unlined

Surface Impoundments; Implementation

of Closure (85 FR 12456), EPA proposed

revisions to the 2015 CCR Rule,

including: procedures to allow facilities

to request approval to use an alternate

liner for CCR surface impoundments;

two alternative proposed options to

allow the use of CCR during unit

closure; an additional closure option for

CCR units being closed by removal of

CCR; and requirements for annual

closure progress reports. On November

12, 2020, EPA finalized the procedures

to allow facilities to request approval to

use an alternate liner for CCR surface

impoundments. 85 FR 72506. In this

final rule, the Agency is taking final

action on the proposed closure option

for units being closed by removal of

CCR, which action is discussed in Unit

III.D of this preamble. EPA is still

considering provisions from the

proposed rule that are not addressed in

this rule and may be addressed in a

subsequent action.

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

D. 2020 Advance Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking

On October 14, 2020, EPA published

an Advance Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking (ANPRM) (85 FR 65015). In

that action, EPA requested information

related to legacy CCR surface

impoundments to inform a future

rulemaking. The Agency requested

input on its regulatory authority, input

on a potential definition of a legacy CCR

surface impoundment and specific

information on the types of inactive

surface impoundments at inactive

facilities that might be considered

legacy CCR surface impoundments.

Specifically, EPA requested information

on how many of these units exist, the

current status of these units (e.g.,

capped, dry, closed according to State

requirements, still holding water), and

the names, locations, and closure dates

of former power plants that may have

these units. Finally, the Agency took

comment on which CCR regulations

should apply to legacy CCR surface

impoundments and on suggestions for

compliance deadlines.

During the 60-day public comment

period, the Agency received over 15,000

comments from environmental groups,

four States, one Tribe, individual

utilities, and industry trade

associations. The topics raised in

comments included a potential

definition of a legacy CCR surface

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

impoundment, EPA’s regulatory

authority, the scope and applicability of

the legacy impoundment rule, and

regulatory requirements to propose.

Moreover, the comments generally

agreed that EPA must prescribe

timeframes for coming into compliance

with the regulations and they

recommended timeframes that are

shorter than compliance timeframes in

the 2015 CCR Rule.

As noted in the ANPRM, EPA took

comment on whether, in light of the

Court’s opinion in USWAG, the Agency

could reconsider whether it has the

authority to regulate inactive

impoundments under RCRA subtitle D.

85 FR 65017–65018 (October 14, 2020).

The general consensus from

commenters on the ANPRM was that,

because the Court resolved the question

based on the plain meaning of the

statute, EPA does not have the

discretion to reinterpret its authority. In

addition, no commenter identified a

factual basis for not regulating legacy

CCR surface impoundments that

addressed the Court’s concern about the

risks these units pose. Id. at 65018.

Consequently, EPA is not revisiting the

question of whether it may regulate

inactive or legacy CCR surface

impoundments.

E. 2023 Proposed Rule and Comments

On May 18, 2023, EPA proposed

revisions to the CCR regulations (88 FR

31982) (‘‘the proposed rule’’ or ‘‘2023

proposed rule’’). These revisions

included establishing regulations

specifying that legacy CCR surface

impoundments are subject to 40 CFR

part 257, subpart D and specifying that

owners or operators of legacy CCR

surface impoundments comply with all

the appropriate requirements applicable

to inactive CCR surface impoundments

at active facilities. In addition, EPA

proposed to establish requirements to

address the risks from currently exempt

solid waste management that involves

the direct placement of CCR on the land.

EPA proposed to extend a subset of the

existing requirements in part 257,

subpart D to CCRMU, which was

proposed to include CCR surface

impoundments and landfills that closed

prior to the effective date of the 2015

CCR Rule, inactive CCR landfills, and

other areas where CCR is managed

directly on the land. This proposal

would apply to all active CCR facilities

and all inactive facilities with legacy

CCR surface impoundments. Lastly,

EPA proposed to make several technical

corrections to the CCR regulations.

These are: (1) To clarify the definitions

of ‘‘feasible’’ and ‘‘technically feasible’’;

(2) To correct the CFR reference in the

PO 00000

Frm 00007

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.6

38955

definition of wetlands at § 257.61(a); (3)

To correct a reference in the

groundwater monitoring scope section;

(4) To standardize the references to CCR

websites throughout the CCR

regulations; and (5) EPA requested

comment on extending the period for

document retention and posting.

The Agency received over 33,500

comments on the proposed rule, with

over 600 unique comments.

Commenters included individual

electric utilities and independent power

producers, national trade associations,

State agencies, public interest and

environmental groups, private citizens,

and entities involved with the beneficial

use of CCR. All public comments

submitted in response to the proposal

can be found in the docket for this

action. Most commenters focused on the

scope of the proposed rule, definitions,

compliance deadlines, and EPA’s

statutory authority to regulate CCRMU.

Most commenters also requested that

EPA adopt additional requirements to

address the risks from CCR units. EPA’s

responses to the comments on the

proposed rule are addressed either in

this preamble or in a response to

comment document available in the

docket to this final rule.

EPA conducted two public hearings

on the proposed rule. EPA held an inperson public hearing in Chicago,

Illinois on June 28, 2023. At this hearing

there were 87 speakers and a total of 150

registered attendees. EPA also held a

virtual public hearing on July 12, 2023,

using an internet-based software

platform. The platform allowed the

public hearing participants to provide

oral testimony using a microphone and

speakers connected to their computers

or using a phone. It provided the ability

for any person to listen to the public

hearing via their computer. At the

virtual hearing, there were 93 speakers

and a total of 353 registered attendees.

Testimony at both public hearings

focused generally on EPA’s proposed

amendments, and on the following

topics: whether to further expand

regulation to all CCR, regardless if it was

onsite of a regulated facility; whether to

regulate structural fill and other

beneficial uses; enforcement of the CCR

regulations; requests for more

engagement with communities; and

requests for EPA to amend other

regulations to strengthen corrective

action and limit the use of alternative

source demonstrations (ASD). Finally,

some commenters discussed sitespecific concerns of facilities near their

homes, or health effects witnessed in

communities close to CCR sites, and

general concerns about the health and

environmental risks from CCR.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

38956

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

Transcripts for both public hearings are

included in the docket for this action.

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

F. 2023 Notice of Data Availability

On November 14, 2023, EPA

published a notice of data availability

(NODA), to solicit comments on

additional information and statistics

developed in response to comments on

the Agency’s May 18, 2023 proposed

rule. 88 FR 77941. Some of the

information contains data or analysis

obtained directly from comments

submitted during the May 18, 2023

proposed rule’s comment period, which

might aid in the formulation of the final

rule. EPA also solicited comments on a

supplemental risk assessment EPA

conducted in response to comments

raised on the proposed rule. This risk

assessment builds on the findings of the

previous Human and Ecological Risk

Assessment of Coal Combustion

Residuals (2014 Risk Assessment) 4 and

better quantifies the specific risks that

may result from placement of CCR in

legacy CCR surface impoundments and

CCRMU. EPA requested comment on all

aspects of the assessment including the

validity and propriety of relying on the

new information, data, and analyses

contained in the updated risk

assessment to inform the final rule.

EPA also sought further information

on legacy CCR surface impoundments

and CCRMU, including information on

the location, presence, condition,

history, and risk associated with any of

the potential legacy CCR surface

impoundments or any of the potential

CCRMU within the docket. EPA also

requested any information regarding the

presence of water, distance to surface

water bodies, proximity to floodplains,

unit size, CCR volume, depth to

groundwater, date of CCR placement,

closure status, any corrective action

associated with the unit, and any

groundwater monitoring data. EPA also

requested comment on the accuracy of

the information that was submitted

regarding potential legacy CCR surface

impoundments or potential CCRMU.

Furthermore, EPA sought similar

information on any other potential

legacy CCR surface impoundments or

potential CCRMU of which EPA may

not be aware or for which we may have

incomplete information.

EPA accepted public comment on the

NODA until December 11, 2023. The

Agency received over 70 comments on

the NODA. Commenters included

individual electric utilities and

4 U.S. EPA. 2014. ‘‘Human and Ecological Risk

Assessment of Coal Combustion Residuals.’’ RIN

2050–AE81. Office of Solid Waste and Emergency

Response. Washington, DC. December.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

independent power producers, national

trade associations, State agencies, public

interest and environmental groups,

private citizens, and entities involved

with the beneficial use of CCR. All

public comments submitted in response

to the NODA can be found in the docket

for this action. The majority of

commenters focused on the

supplemental risk assessment; some

focused on the request for additional

information on the universe of legacy

CCR surface impoundments and

CCRMU. EPA’s responses to comments

received on the NODA are addressed

either in an updated risk assessment

(the 2024 Risk Assessment), this

preamble, or in the response to

comment document available in the

docket to this final rule.

III. What final action is the Agency

taking?

In response to the USWAG decision,

EPA is finalizing a provision at

§ 257.50(e), specifying that legacy CCR

surface impoundments are subject to 40

CFR part 257, subpart D. EPA is also

requiring owners or operators of legacy

CCR surface impoundments to comply

with the following existing

requirements in the CCR regulations:

installation of a permanent marker,

history of construction, hazard potential

classification, structural stability and

factors of safety assessments, emergency

action plan (EAP), air criteria,

inspections, groundwater monitoring

and corrective action, closure and postclosure care, recordkeeping, and

notification and CCR website

requirements. EPA further is

establishing new compliance deadlines

for these newly applicable regulatory

requirements to ensure the owners or

operators of these units have time to

come into compliance.

In addition to the revisions EPA

proposed to address the USWAG

decision, EPA is establishing

requirements to address the risks from

currently exempt solid waste

management that involves the direct

placement of CCR on the land. EPA is

extending a subset of the existing

requirements in 40 CFR part 257,

subpart D to CCRMU, which are CCR

surface impoundments and landfills

that closed prior to the effective date of

the 2015 CCR Rule, inactive CCR

landfills, and other areas where CCR is

managed directly on the land. These

additional requirements apply to all

active CCR facilities, all inactive

facilities with legacy CCR surface

impoundments subject to this final rule,

and those active facilities (i.e., facilities

producing electricity for the grid as of

October 19, 2015) that ceased placing

PO 00000

Frm 00008

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.7

CCR in onsite CCR units prior to the

effective date of the 2015 CCR Rule.

EPA is also finalizing alternative

closure provisions to allow a facility to

complete the closure by removal in two

stages: first, by completing all removal

and decontamination procedures; and

second, by completing all groundwater

remediation in a separate post closure

care period.

Lastly, EPA is finalizing several

technical corrections to the CCR

regulations. These are: (1) to clarify the

definitions of ‘‘feasible’’ and

‘‘technically feasible’’; (2) to correct the

CFR reference in the definition of

wetlands at § 257.61(a); (3) to correct a

reference in the groundwater monitoring

scope section; (4) to standardize the

references to CCR websites throughout

the CCR regulations; and (5) to extend

the period for document retention and

posting.

A. Risks From Legacy CCR Surface

Impoundments and CCR Management

Units

1. Summary of May 2023 Proposal

The proposal largely relied on the

model results from the 2014 Risk

Assessment, as EPA considered the

results were equally applicable to legacy

CCR surface impoundments and

CCRMU.5 This determination was based

on the fact that many of these

unregulated units are similarly

constructed, manage the same types of

ash, and are frequently located either at

the same or nearby facilities as their

regulated counterparts. In particular,

some unregulated units are known to be

located directly adjacent to or beneath

currently regulated units.

The 2014 Risk Assessment concluded

that the management practices that EPA

believed were generally in use in 2014

at surface impoundments and landfills

were likely to pose risks to human

health through groundwater exposure

within the range that EPA typically

considers warrants regulation. For

highly exposed individuals, the cancer

risks from arsenic due to the operation

of surface impoundments were as high

as 2 × 10¥4, while noncancer risks were

as high as an HQ of 5 for arsenic, 2 for

lithium, and 2 for molybdenum. Cancer

risks associated with the operation of

landfills were estimated to be as high as

5 × 10¥6 from the ingestion of arseniccontaminated drinking water. In 2015,

EPA relied on this risk assessment to

support the regulation of both active

CCR units and inactive CCR surface

5 U.S. EPA. 2014. ‘‘Human and Ecological Risk

Assessment of Coal Combustion Residuals.’’ RIN

2050–AE81. Office of Solid Waste and Emergency

Response. Washington, DC. December.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

impoundments at active facilities. The

2014 Risk Assessment reported risks for

the units that were anticipated to be

subject to the 2015 CCR Rule and

therefore drew no conclusions about the

older units excluded from the scope of

that rule. Nevertheless, information

available in the record supports the

conclusion that these older units can

pose risks at least as high as reported in

the 2014 Risk Assessment.

EPA further proposed to find that the

risks associated with legacy

impoundments and CCRMU may be

even higher than EPA modeled on a

national scale in the 2014 Risk

Assessment for active units. First, the

proposal explained that these units have

been present onsite for longer and had

more time to leak. In addition, EPA

explained that there are several

management practices that have the

potential to result in higher leakage, but

that were previously modeled either less

frequently for active units—based on a

belief that the practices had declined

over time—or not at all—due to data

constraints on a national scale. These

include: (1) The greater prevalence of

unlined units; (2) The greater likelihood

of co-management of CCR with coal

refuse and other wastes in surface

impoundments, making the overall

waste pH far more acidic and (3) The

potential for the units to be constructed

below the water table or to have become

inundated with groundwater after

construction. The proposal estimated

that the solid waste management

practices associated with legacy

impoundments and CCRMU could pose

lifetime cancer risks from arsenic as

high as 2 × 10¥5 to 1 × 10¥3 (i.e., 2 to

100 cases of cancer for every 100,000

individuals exposed), and non-cancer

risks for cobalt as high as an HQ of 13,

mercury up to an HQ of 13, lithium up

to an HQ of 3, molybdenum up to an HQ

of 4, and thallium up to an HQ of 2,

depending on the specific management

practice. Finally, EPA explained that

each of these practices individually can

pose greater risks than those previously

modeled for the currently regulated

universe of CCR units, and a

combination of these practices could

push risks even higher.

2. 2023 Draft Risk Assessment

A number of commenters claimed that

the 2014 Risk Assessment did not

adequately capture various factors

associated with legacy CCR surface

impoundments and CCRMU that the

commenters believed will result in

significantly different risks than those

posed by currently regulated units. In

response to these comments, EPA

conducted a supplemental risk

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

assessment to determine the potential

for some of these factors to affect

national risks. This risk assessment built

on the findings of the 2014 Risk

Assessment and better quantified the

specific risks that may result from

placement of CCR in legacy CCR surface

impoundments and CCRMU.

The 2023 draft supplemental

assessment consisted of: (1) Additional

modeling of inactive and closed CCR

landfills and surface impoundments

that was actually conducted in 2014

using the same methodology and data.

These results were ultimately not

included in the original 2014 Risk

Assessment because the units were not

regulated under the final 2015 rule, and

(2) Some further model runs relying on

some updated data. In addition, EPA

modeled the placement of CCR in

smaller quantities than would typically

be found in a CCR surface

impoundments or landfill (i.e., smaller

CCRMU placements or CCRMU fills) to

determine the potential for these smaller

CCRMU placements to contaminate

groundwater. Through this modeling,

EPA identified potential for these fills to

contaminate onsite groundwater. Model

results indicated potential for

exceedance of groundwater protection

standards (GWPS) at the fill boundary

under both high-end and moderate

conditions. These results also showed

potential for substantial spread of the

resulting groundwater plume. Under

high-end conditions, these plumes are

large and persistent enough to sustain

exposures for over a century or more at

average risks of 2 × 10¥5 or higher.

Finally, EPA assessed the potential for

exposure to radiation from CCR

remaining in the soil (subsurface). EPA

found the amount of radon emitted by

CCR is not distinguishable from

background soil and so did not retain

this pathway for further consideration.

EPA also found greater potential for risk

from gamma radiation as CCR comes to

be located closer to the ground surface

due to a reduction in shielding. An

additional sensitivity analysis identified

potential for further risk if CCR becomes

mixed with surface soil. Accumulation

of CCR can result in elevated cancer risk

from incidental ingestion of arsenic and

radium, in addition to direct exposure

to gamma radiation from radium. For

high-end waste concentrations, an eight

percent mixture of CCR in surface soil

was found to result in risk on the order

of 1 × 10¥4.

The 2023 draft risk assessment was

made available for public comment as

part of a NODA released on November

14, 2023.

PO 00000

Frm 00009

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.8

38957

3. Response to Comments on the

Proposal and the NODA

The following subsection provides a

summary of comments received on

either the proposed rule or NODA that

are germane to the risk record for legacy

impoundments and CCRMU. EPA

considered these comments as it worked

to finalize the supplemental risk

assessment (‘‘2024 Risk Assessment’’).

The Agency also received a number of

general comments, which were either

editorial in nature or expressed general

support or disapproval for the risk

assessment methodology, data, or

results. However, these comments did

not provide any specific technical

recommendations or data that could

otherwise be used to update the risk

assessment. These general comments

did not provide EPA with a basis to alter

or otherwise re-evaluate the risk

assessment in response.

a. Comments Related to Applicability of

2014 Risk Assessment

Comment: Several commenters

generally affirmed the Agency’s risk

basis for regulating historical and

inactive disposal units. However, other

commenters argued the Agency’s risk

record is inadequate to support

regulation of certain legacy

impoundments or any CCRMU. Others

contended that because the 2014 Risk

Assessment supported regulation of

active landfills and surface

impoundments, it is not appropriate to

apply that record to disposal units that

previously ceased receipt of waste. In

particular, commenters pointed to the

current lack of ponded water and/or the

presence of a cap and vegetative cover

that would reduce infiltration through

certain units. Some commenters noted

that State programs may include

requirements for unit design,

monitoring, and closure that ensure a

cover is present. Commenters stated

these factors must be accounted for

through an updated risk assessment.

EPA Response: Claims that the results

of the 2014 Risk Assessment are

applicable only to active units represent

a fundamental misunderstanding of

scope of the 2014 Risk Assessment. EPA

did not only model units during

operation. Instead, the risk assessment

modeled the specific stage of the unit

lifecycle anticipated to contribute the

most to long-term risk. For surface

impoundments this was during

operation, but for landfills it was after

closure. EPA modeled the leakage that

occurred over this one lifecycle stage

and tracked the subsequent migration

through groundwater over time. The

risks to downgradient receptors

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38958

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

resulting from the modeled leakage were

used to represent risk over the entire

unit lifecycle. Consideration of a single

lifecycle stage was necessary because of

model constraints and the high

computational burden of tracking

shifting configurations for every single

unit.

Both landfills and surface

impoundments progress through similar

lifecycle stages from construction to

closure. Thus, the fact that some

historical and inactive units may no

longer contain ponded water or may

have installed a soil cover only places

these units in a different stage of that

lifecycle. That does not differentiate the

long-term risks of those units from those

previously modeled. In particular,

existing groundwater contamination

does not vanish once a unit ceases

operation. As one State commenter

noted, ‘‘[g]roundwater contamination is

an important aspect to legacy

impoundment closure and should not

be overlooked simply because the

impoundment does not contain liquid

or CCR at the date of the final rule.’’

By contrast, the 2014 Risk Assessment

only modeled landfills after closure; in

other words, EPA assumed that no

leakage occurred prior to closure, while

the landfill was operating. EPA only

modeled landfills after closure because

based on the assumption that this stage

of the landfill lifecycle would have the

greatest contribution to long-term risk

for offsite receptors because the unit

would be filled to capacity and the post

closure stage represented the greater

period of time over which leakage can

occur. EPA modeled unlined units with

a soil cap and vegetative cover

equivalent to the surrounding native

soils and found risks from arsenic as

high as 2 × 10¥5 for receptors up to a

mile away. Even assuming some

landfills have been closed in a manner

more consistent with the existing CCR

regulations (i.e., with some kind of

composite cover system), this is

unlikely to change the overall

conclusions of the risk assessment. This

is because, regardless of the cover that

is ultimately installed, higher leakage

can occur throughout the active life of

the unit when the landfill face is open

and able to intercept more precipitation.

This conclusion is reinforced by the fact

that facility monitoring reports

document that around 20% of currently

active landfills have triggered corrective

action. Additionally, EPA has seen no

evidence to suggest that the closure of

older units has been consistently more

protective than EPA modeled in 2014.

As discussed in Unit III.B.2.g.iii(a) of

the preamble, as part of developing the

2015 CCR Rule, EPA reviewed State

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

statutes and regulations, with a more

detailed focus on the 16 States

responsible for approximately 74% of

the CCR generated in 2009. See 80 FR

21324. The Agency’s review of State

programs prior to 2015 found that

oversight of these wastes and the overall

protectiveness of particular programs

varied widely. For example, EPA

estimated that in 2015, approximately

20% of the net disposable CCR was

entirely exempt from State regulatory

oversight. Similarly, a 2006 joint

Department of Energy (DOE) and EPA

study reported that only 19% (three out

of 19) of the surveyed surface

impoundment permits included

requirements addressing GWPS (i.e.,

contaminant concentrations that cannot

be exceeded) or closure/post-closure

care. Furthermore, some of the

photographs and descriptions of these

older units provided by commenters

indicate extensive growth of trees and

other woody vegetation that can

compromise the integrity of any cap

present and increase the rate of

infiltration into the unit. For these

reasons, the 2014 Risk Assessment is

equally representative of the national

risks from historical and inactive

landfills.

The 2014 Risk Assessment modeled

all surface impoundments during the

active stage of their lifecycle. This was

based on the presumption that the

highest rates of leakage would occur

while wastewater is ponded above the

ash, because this water creates a large

and sustained hydraulic head that

serves to drive leachate into the

subsurface. Although the current

configuration of historical and legacy

impoundments may vary, all these units

previously held ponded water during

the active stage of their lifecycle. And,

in the case of legacy impoundments,

ponded water may still be present. As

a result, the current configuration of the

unit is immaterial to the releases that

occurred during operation. For this

reason, the modeling approach relied

upon in the 2014 Risk Assessment is

equally applicable to historical and

legacy impoundments.

The 2014 Risk Assessment also

accurately represents the potential risks

that remains for units that were closed

consistent with the 2015 CCR Rule. If

the cover system is not adequately

maintained after closure, degradation

over time from human or animal

activity, natural settling, freeze-thaw

cycles, flooding and other extreme

weather events, and other factors can

result in greater leakage from the unit

than designed. In some cases,

groundwater monitoring may provide

the only clear evidence the cap is not

PO 00000

Frm 00010

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.9

performing as designed. Thus, the 2014

Risk Assessment accurately describes

the risks that can result if these units are

not adequately maintained and

monitored in line with regulatory

requirements.

Comment: Multiple commenters

argued that historical and inactive

disposal units will generally have a

smaller footprint than those modeled in

the 2014 Risk Assessment. For example,

some commenters noted the average

sizes of landfills and surface

impoundments modeled in the 2014

Risk Assessment were around 120 acres

and 50 acres, respectively, while the

estimated average sizes of CCRMU and

legacy impoundments in the proposed

rule were both closer to 30 acres. Others

cited to the sizes of individual units that

at their facilities to contend that these

units are much smaller than average.

These commenters contended that a

smaller footprint would result in a

lower mass loading of groundwater and

lower associated risk.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

referenced data indicate that older

disposal units are significantly smaller

in size than the units EPA modeled in

2014. The 2014 Risk Assessment relied

on data submitted by facilities in the

EPA Surveys to estimate an average

active landfill size of around 120 acres

from over 310 landfills and an average

active impoundment size of around 50

acres from over 735 impoundments. The

RIA summary referenced by

commenters relies only on data that

could be independently verified by data

from posted facility reports and recent

public comments. From the final list of

195 CCRMU and 194 legacy

impoundments, EPA identified data for

only one landfill with a size of 90 acres

and 47 historical or legacy

impoundments with an average size of

44 acres. Thus, when CCRMU are

separately grouped as landfills and

impoundments, the differences in size

are not as substantial as indicated by

commenters.

EPA also disagrees that any

differences that do exist would result in

substantially lower risks than

previously modeled. As part of the 2014

Risk Assessment, EPA modeled 122

landfills and 163 impoundments that

were excluded from the reported risk

results because these units were

determined to not be subject to that rule.

These excluded units represent some

combination of legacy impoundments,

inactive landfills, and historical

disposal units. The average sizes of

these previously excluded units are 77

acres for the landfills and 28 acres for

the impoundments. These sizes are

approximately half the size of the units

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

identified in the 2014 Risk Assessment

or more recent data collection efforts.

However, as discussed in Section 3 of

the 2024 Risk Assessment, the risks

associated with these older units are

substantially the same as those for

currently regulated units. Therefore,

there is no evidence that these

differences in size have a meaningful

impact on national risks, or that the

results of the 2014 Risk Assessment are

nor equally applicable to legacy

impoundments and CCRMU. While

there may be individual disposal units

at these sites that are smaller than

average, the model results summarized

in the 2024 Risk Assessment model

include landfills as small as 2 acres and

impoundments as small as 0.01 acres.

Therefore, there is no indication based

on the data provided that the overall

distribution of unit sizes has not been

adequately reflected in the national

model.

Finally, EPA notes that individual

unit size is not necessarily a reliable

metric to draw conclusions about the

overall risk from CCR disposal at

electric utilities. The 2014 Risk

Assessment modeled the risks from each

landfill and impoundment separately

because it was difficult to confirm the

relative locations and orientations of

different units with data from the EPA

Surveys. However, the Agency is now

aware of many sites where multiple

units, both landfills and impoundments,

are located immediately adjacent to one

another. As a result, there is potential

the 2014 Risk Assessment

underestimated site risk to some degree

by not evaluating the combined leakage

over the full contributing area of these

adjacent disposal units.

Comment: One commenter stated the

2014 Risk Assessment did not

specifically characterize the risks from

impoundments that do not contain fly

ash. This commenter argued that

historical and legacy impoundments are

more likely to only contain bottom ash

or boiler slag, as the process of

capturing fly ash was not common prior

to the 1970s. Therefore, this commenter

concluded that the 2014 Risk

Assessment does not adequately

characterize the risks for these older

units.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

2014 Risk Assessment does not address

the risks associated with these

impoundments. The risk assessment

incorporated porewater data from

impoundments that contained only

bottom ash, but EPA did not separately

break out risks for this subset of units

because the amount of data available

was inconsistent across the set of

modeled constituents. However,

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

available porewater data show the

potential for certain constituents, such

as molybdenum, to leach from bottom

ash at levels as high as from fly ash.

Additionally, available monitoring

reports for currently regulated units

posted on facility websites document

that these units have a similar potential

to contaminate groundwater as units

containing other types of CCR. Of the

units designated as managing bottom

ash, 32% of surface impoundments and

38% of landfills have triggered

corrective action. Of the units

designated as managing slag, 38% of

surface impoundments have triggered

corrective action. No landfills were

identified as dedicated to slag. For

comparison, 48% of remaining surface

impoundments and 21% of remaining

landfills have triggered corrective

action. Therefore, there is no indication

that these types of units are overall less

likely to result in groundwater

contamination.

Comment: One commenter claimed

that a nationwide assessment should not

be used to make determinations about

the risks at individual sites or to support

national requirements. This commenter

stated that, unlike individual damage

cases, the Agency’s groundwater model

does not adequately represent the

specific conditions at each individual

unit. However, this commenter

provided no data to support their broad

claims. One other commenter pointed to

data they had identified to contend that

the model does not reflect the specific

environmental conditions at their

facility.

EPA Response: The modeling

conducted for both the 2014 and 2024

Risk Assessments utilized a

probabilistic, site-based approach that

combined site-specific data with more

regional and national data sources. The

model incorporated data about the

specific location, dimensions, and liner

status of individual disposal units

where available. The aim of this

approach is not to assign an exact risk

to each individual unit, but to provide

an overall accurate picture of the

potential risks posed by these types of

units on a national scale. Indeed, many

of the findings from the 2014 Risk

Assessment were supported by available

damage cases. The commenters did not

articulate why they believe the risks

associated with individual units fall far

outside the broader distribution of

modeled units. But as acknowledged by

the one commenter who did submit

data, there is overlap between the range

of conditions modeled and those they

identified as present at their particular

facility. EPA does acknowledge that

there are some site conditions that the

PO 00000

Frm 00011

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.10

38959

2014 and 2024 Risk Assessments were

not able to adequately model, such as

waste below the water table. However,

this is why the Agency separately relied

on damage cases to identify additional

constituents of potential concern for

groundwater monitoring.

Comment: One commenter stated that

EPA should not rely on the findings of

the Environmental Integrity Project’s

report, ‘‘Poisonous Coverup: The

Widespread Failure of the Power

Industry to Clean Up Coal Ash Dumps’’

without independently validating the

quality of analyses conducted for each

site.

EPA Response: EPA recognizes that

the method used in the cited report to

identify potential exceedances of GWPS

is not the same as the regulatory

standard for triggering corrective action.

For this and other reasons, the Agency

does not rely on the report as a primary

basis for the current rulemaking or to

draw any conclusions about the

monitoring status of any individual

unit. Instead, EPA previously referenced

the report as a supplementary source of

information that further supports the

findings of the 2014 Risk Assessment.

Specifically, the fact that the

constituents identified as risk drivers in

the 2014 Risk Assessment are the same

ones detected most frequently above

GWPS indicates that the fate and

transport modeling conducted by EPA

was able to correctly identify the

constituents most likely to be released

and migrate at environmentally

significant concentrations. While high

background concentrations may be

present at some of these sites, many

have already triggered corrective action

and the Agency believes that number

will increase as more facilities come

into compliance with the rule

requirements. Because this report does

not form a basis for the rule, it is not

discussed further in the preamble to the

rule or the 2024 Risk Assessment

outside of responses to other comments

that cite to the same or similar reports.

b. Comments Related to Draft 2023

Supplemental Risk Assessment

Conceptual Model

Comment: Multiple commenters

broadly argued that the draft 2023 risk

assessment relied on data and

assumptions that represent maximum

values or otherwise reflect worst-case

scenarios that could never occur, and

therefore do not represent a ‘‘reasonable

probability’’ of adverse impacts and so

is not an appropriate basis for regulatory

action.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

design of the risk assessment is

inappropriately conservative. Consistent

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

38960

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

with EPA’s long-standing practice under

RCRA (as well as other agency

programs), an individual with

reasonable maximum exposure (RME)

provides the principal basis for

evaluating potential human health risks.

An RME scenario is intended to be

conservative, while remaining within

the range of possible high-end

exposures.6 Specifically, ‘‘high end’’ has

been defined as the part of the exposure

distribution that falls above the 90th

percentile, but below the 99.9th

percentile.7 Reliance on this type of

scenario is intended to protect sensitive

populations. Selection of the data and

assumptions incorporated in the 2024

Risk Assessment is in line with this

objective. Further critiques about the

potential for the specific data and

assumptions to overestimate risk are

addressed in subsequent responses.

Comment: Multiple commenters

argued that it was inappropriate for EPA

to consider future onsite residential

exposures as a basis for evaluating the

potential risks associated with onsite

CCR disposal. One commenter claimed

that the estimates of existing

populations living near these facilities

used in the 2024 Risk Assessment was

both overestimated and inconsistent

with estimates from the Agency’s RIA.

One commenter acknowledged that

older units tend to be located closer to

population centers. However, others

argued that this proximity to existing

populations or water bodies would not

make them overall more likely to

become residential in the future. One

commenter stated that EPA should have

surveyed the intended land use for

facilities or otherwise directly assessed

the likelihood of residential land use.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that

consideration of a population within a

five-mile radius overstates the

likelihood of residential development.

Five miles away from a population

center is a small distance for residential

development to expand, even in the

near future. Nevertheless, the Agency

has updated the population estimates in

the 2024 Risk Assessment to more

closely align with reporting in the RIA

and to include both one- and three-mile

radii. EPA also disagrees that

consideration of a future residential

land use scenario is inappropriate or

unrealistic. The substantial populations

6 U.S. EPA. 1989. ‘‘Risk Assessment Guidance for

Superfund Volume I—Part A, Human Health

Evaluation Manual.’’ EPA/540/1–89/002. Prepared

by the Office of Emergency and Remedial Response,

Washington, DC. December.

7 U.S. EPA. 2004. ‘‘An Examination of EPA Risk

Assessment Principles and Practices.’’ EPA/100/B–

04/00. Prepared by the Office of the Science

Advisor. Washington, DC. March.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

already living near many facilities and

the generally higher property value of

land near water bodies are two

indicators of the potential for land to be

attractive for future residential land use.

Facilities do not dictate the ultimate use

of a property after the land has been

sold for redevelopment. These types of

facilities can include considerable tracts

of land beyond that dedicated to waste

disposal that may be considered for a

range of different uses. EPA is currently

aware of 22 examples in which former

electric utilities have been proposed for

residential development, 19 of which

are known to have burned coal.8 Thus,

there is evidence of community interest

in residential land use at these types of

facilities.

Although future residential use is

considered as the RME scenario in the

2024 Risk Assessment, that does not

mean it is the only scenario EPA

considered or on which this final rule

is based. Depending on their location,

leakage of Appendix IV constituents

from individual CCRMU fill may

migrate off-site at levels of concern. In

addition, even if the constituents from

a single CCRMU do not migrate off-site,

the modeling conducted in 2024

confirms that smaller CCRMU fills can

meaningfully contribute to groundwater

contamination across a facility.

Concentrations from a single CCRMU

can combine with contamination from

other CCRMU, currently regulated CCR

units, or legacy CCR surface

impoundments that are also present on

the same site. Although EPA did not

model the aggregate or cumulative risk

associated with these potential sources

of co-located contamination, at a

minimum, EPA expects that the

presence of multiple sources of

potential contamination at the same

facility would increase the likelihood of

a contaminant plume that could migrate

off-site at levels of concern.

Nor is residential use the only

scenario where exposures present

concern. One commenter described

donating property to a local government

for recreational uses. Several other

commenters described redeveloping

sites as nature preserves. Even under

these non-residential land uses, the is a

reasonable potential for exposure (and

consequently risk) to human and

ecological receptors if the ash is

subsequently disturbed. For example, as

discussed in Section 6 the 2024 Risk

Assessment, concentrations of certain

contaminants may also pose risk to

8 Memorandum to the Docket: Compilation of

News Articles on Future Land Uses for Electric

Utilities.

PO 00000

Frm 00012

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.11

wildlife if ash becomes intermingled

with surface soil.

Comment: Commenters asserted that

consideration of residential land use is

inconsistent with various EPA guidance

documents 9 10 11 and Agency cleanup

programs. These commenters argued

such guidance instructs EPA to assume

that facilities surrounded by operating

industrial facilities will remain

industrial unless there is clear evidence

otherwise. These commenters further

argued that guidance instructs EPA to

account for institutional controls, such

as State or local zoning laws, that would

make residential development or

resulting exposures at individual sites

unlikely. Some commenters cited to

specific State requirements they assert

would prevent residential land use or

prohibit future use of site groundwater

as a source of drinking water. Others

claimed that due diligence reviews

would be adequate to identify and

address any remaining sources of

contamination before exposures could

occur.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that

consideration of future residential land

use at these facilities is inconsistent

with applicable guidance and cleanup

programs. First, the risk assessment was

conducted to establish minimum

national criteria rather than to clean up

an individual site. To determine

whether the section 4004(a) standard

will be met at all sites nationwide, as

the statute requires, the Agency needs to

evaluate the risks associated with full

range of reasonable scenarios. As

discussed in the previous response,

there are numerous examples in the

record of instances in which these kinds

of sites have been redeveloped for

residential use.

Moreover, as the commenters have

acknowledged, the Comprehensive

Environmental Response,

Compensation, and Liability Act

(CERCLA) and other cleanup programs

only address contamination that has

already occurred. In contrast, national

standards for waste management

developed under RCRA section 4004(a)

are to prevent environmental releases

9 U.S. EPA. 1989. ‘‘Risk Assessment Guidance for

Superfund Volume I Human Health Evaluation

Manual (Part A).’’ EPA/540/1–89/002. Prepared by

the Office of Emergency and Remedial Response,

Washington, DC. December.

10 U.S. EPA. 1991. ‘‘Risk Assessment Guidance for

Superfund Volume I Human Health Evaluation

Manual (Part B, Development of Risk-based

Preliminary Remediation Goals).’’ Publication

9285.7–01B. Prepared by the Office of Emergency

and Remedial Response, Washington, DC.

December.

11 U.S. EPA. 1995. ‘‘Land Use in the CERCLA

Remedy Selection Process.’’ OSWER Directive No.

9355.7–04. Prepared by the Office of Solid Waste

and Emergency Response. Washington, DC. May.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

before they occur. See, USWAG, 901

F.3d at 429–431. As EPA has previously

explained, groundwater contamination

is a concern, even if the aquifer is not

currently used as a source of drinking

water. Sources of drinking water are

finite, and future users’ interests must

also be protected. See, 44 FR 53445–

53448.

EPA further disagrees that the risk

assessment failed to appropriately

account for existing State and local

requirements for institutional controls

that would limit residential exposure.

The purpose of a baseline risk

assessment is to provide ‘‘. . . an

analysis of the potential adverse health

effects (current or future) caused by

hazardous substance releases from a site

in the absence of any actions to control

or mitigate these releases (i.e., under an

assumption of no action).’’ 12 Thus, the

intent of the risk assessment is to

characterize the harm that could result

if institutional and other controls are

not implemented. This provides a

consistent basis to understand the risks

to be controlled and define appropriate

national requirements such as a national

requirement for deed restrictions at all

sites at which CCRMU fills will remain

in place. The Agency did not assume

that all facilities will ultimately be used

for residential purposes as a

consequence of these factors in

developing this final rule.

Furthermore, as several commenters

have acknowledged, facilities have not

historically been required to identify

smaller placements of ash as a form of

disposal and consequently have not

maintained reliable records of where

such placements are located. Indeed,

most commenters have acknowledged

that they are currently unable to identify

all CCRMU at their existing facilities.

These commenters do not explain how

due diligence assessments would

reliably identify such placements in the

absence of such records, as such

assessments typically rely on available

site records to guide further

investigation. Nor do commenters

explain how existing State programs

would reliably identify such placements

or otherwise prevent exposures, when

the facilities themselves cannot identify

the presence of the ash on-site. This is

reinforced by EPA’s review of State

programs, which found that the specific

requirements, level of oversight over

these wastes, and the overall

protectiveness of individual programs

varied widely among States. See, 80 FR

12 U.S. EPA. 1989. ‘‘Risk Assessment Guidance for

Superfund Volume I Human Health Evaluation

Manual (Part A).’’ EPA/540/1–89/002. Prepared by

the Office of Emergency and Remedial Response,

Washington, DC. December.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

21324. As a result, EPA currently lacks

a record to conclude that currently

unidentified CCRMU fills located across

a facility would be subject to the same

institutional controls that are required

for the disposal units the commenters

reference. Given the current absence of

national requirements, and that

commenters have generally

acknowledged that they have not

reliably kept records of the existence of

CCRMU, it is appropriate to evaluate the

risks that can reasonably arise in the

absence of institutional controls.

Comment: One commenter argued

that EPA had already considered the

practice of disposal below the water

table because it had been discussed in

previous risk assessments. Another

commenter asserted the Agency’s

conceptual model assumed all legacy

impoundments were in contact with the

water table. Another commenter stated

that EPA cannot use information about

active units to make assumptions about

which historical and inactive units at

the same sites are in contact with the

water table, due to differences in unit

construction and location. By contrast, a

number of other commenters agreed that

because EPA cannot model the effects of

waste below the water table, EPA had

previously underestimated the risks

associated with CCR units. Other

commenters argued the conceptual

model for surface impoundments did

not adequately distinguish between the

types of water that may be present in an

impoundment. These commenters

asserted that any residual water

remaining after the unit has been

initially drained would not exert the

same hydraulic head within the unit

that would drive leachate into the

subsurface during unit operation, and so

leakage would more closely resemble a

landfill.

EPA Response: The conceptual

models for landfills and surface

impoundments in the 2014 and 2024

Risk Assessments did not evaluate

contact with groundwater. Although

these assessments both acknowledged

that this could occur, the scenario could

not be incorporated into groundwater

fate and transport modeling as a result

of data and model constraints. Because

the 2014 and 2024 Risk Assessments did

not directly model the effects of

disposal below the water table, neither

assessment incorporates any

assumptions about the prevalence of

this practice in the conceptual model.

EPA has acknowledged that its inability

to reliably model the effects of this

practice means that its risk estimates on

a national scale underestimate the risks

associated with higher rates of leaching

PO 00000

Frm 00013

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.12

38961

and/or formation of strongly reducing

conditions.

EPA acknowledges the rates of

leakage from surface impoundments

will generally decrease after ponded

wastewater has been allowed to drain,

reducing the overall hydraulic head

across the unit. As such, discussion in

the 2024 Risk Assessment has been

updated to clarify the distinction

between water ponded above the ash

and porewater within an impoundment.

However, any free liquids that remain

within the unit can still result in higher

leakage than would occur if the unit

were fully dewatered. And the amount

of ‘‘residual water remaining’’ can

sometimes be substantial; in some cases,

closed impoundments remain saturated

by 20–54 feet of groundwater. See, e.g.,

88 FR 31982–319873, 55236.

In addition, regardless of the current

configuration of an impoundment, it is

appropriate for the conceptual models

in the 2024 Risk Assessment to consider

the stage of the unit lifecycle anticipated

to contribute the most to long-term risk.

For surface impoundments, this is when

the units are in operation due to the

presence of wastewater ponded above

the ash. Subsequent draining of the unit

does nothing to remediate any adverse

impacts that occurred during operation.

Furthermore, to the extent that

impoundments leak at rates more

similar to landfills after ponded

wastewater has been drained, EPA notes

the 2014 Risk Assessment previously

modeled the risks from dry management

in landfills and found the potential for

unacceptable risk from these units.

Therefore, continued leakage from

drained units still has the potential to

sustain releases.

Comment: One commenter affirmed

that ‘‘EPA is likely correct in its

observations and assumptions that

CCRMU fills ‘will remain in place when

ownership of the property changes,’ and

that, ‘in the absence of land use

restrictions, there is no guarantee [that]

engineering controls will remain in

place when the property is

redeveloped.’ ’’ However, multiple

commenters argued the conceptual

model for CCRMU fills does not

adequately account for the full diversity

of CCRMU that may be present onsite.

Various commenters stated that a

conceptual model for fills does not

adequately address specific types of

placements, such as use in the

construction or closure of CCR disposal

units, storage in waste piles,

construction of roadways and railroads,

or spreading on roadways for snow and

ice control. Another asserted that

reliance on the similar conceptual

models in the 2014 Risk Assessment to

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38962

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

evaluate the disposal units and CCRMU

fills is inappropriate because the

CCRMU fills will tend to be smaller

than the disposal units modeled in

2014.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

conceptual model for CCRMU fills does

not adequately address the

configurations of these units. The

majority of the units described by

commenters have a concentrated

footprint, such as placement beneath a

parking lot. Some of the specific

alternate examples raised by

commenters are either already regulated

under the existing regulations (e.g.,

waste piles) or are outside the scope of

the current rulemaking. For others, there

is little to no information available

about the manner or frequency of such

placements that could be used to

characterize the units. Therefore, these

types of placements are not considered

as part of the conceptual model for

CCRMU fills in the 2024 Risk

Assessment.

The commenters do not explain how

placement of CCR in a landfill or

impoundment in service of construction

or closure of that unit would be

substantially different than the disposal

scenarios previously modeled and

found to pose risk. Finally, EPA has

proposed and is finalizing the definition

of CCRMU to exclude CCR used in

roadbed and associated embankments.

There is little data that could be used

to develop a conceptual model for

diffuse placements, which may occur on

a periodic basis. Nor do commenters

provide any data on the manner or

frequency of such placements. As a

result, the 2024 Risk Assessment did not

model these types of placements. This

represents a source of uncertainty in the

assessment. However, EPA notes that

even small placements of CCR can

contribute to broader leakage and have

the potential to leak Appendix III

constituents and influence nearby

groundwater monitoring. Therefore, it is

still necessary to identify where these

types of onsite placements have

occurred.

EPA also disagrees that applying a

similar conceptual model for CCR

landfills and CCRMU fills is

inappropriate. Specifically, the

conceptual model does not make any

upfront assumptions regarding the sizes

of these fills. As described in Section 4

of the 2024 Risk Assessment, EPA

considered a range of potential sizes for

these fills that were smaller than

landfills reported in the EPA Surveys.

Comment: One commenter stated that

it is inappropriate for the 2024 Risk

Assessment to rely on similar data

sources as the 2014 Risk Assessment to

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

characterize environmental parameters,

claiming these data are outdated.

Another argued that the conceptual

model does not adequately account for

the presence of alternative liners, such

as thick natural clay beneath the units.

EPA Response: First, EPA notes that

the 2024 Risk Assessment does

incorporate more recent weather data

available from the most recent version

of the Hydrologic Evaluation of Landfill

Performance Model, updated in 2020.

As explained in the 2014 Risk

Assessment, EPA found the remaining

data sources provide the most recent

and representative data to characterize

environmental conditions on a national

basis. Commenters provide no

explanation why these data should be

considered outdated. For example, why

the soil type present at a site would

have changed substantially since 2014.

EPA notes that to the extent that there

is natural clay soil present in the

vicinity of a facility, that would already

be reflected through the environmental

data.

c. Comments Related to Supplemental

Risk Assessment Groundwater Model

Comment: Some commenters asserted

that modeled leachate concentrations

are unrealistically high. One commenter

specifically argued that the LEAF data is

unable to accurately reflect field

leaching concentrations, citing two EPRI

reports comparing LEAF and field

leachate data both collected from the

same units.13 14 They separately

compared the leachate concentrations

modeled in the risk assessment to field

samples collected from around a

number of different landfills. Based on

this comparison, the commenter

asserted that the high-end

concentrations modeled in the risk

assessment were substantially higher

than measured in the field and so

unrepresentative of actual leaching

behavior. For these reasons, this

commenter concluded that porewater

data provide better representation of

leaching in the field and so EPA should

rely on that type of data to model

leakage from CCRMU fills.

EPA Reponse: EPA disagrees that

leachate concentrations modeled in the

2024 Risk Assessment are

unrealistically high. EPA has previously

demonstrated that the LEAF laboratory

leaching tests are ‘‘effective for

13 EPRI. 2020. ‘‘Leaching, Geotechnical, and

Hydrologic Characterization of Coal Combustion

Products from a Closed Coal Ash Impoundment.’’

Palo Alto, CA. June.

14 EPRI. 2021. ‘‘Leaching, Geotechnical, and

Hydrologic Characterization of Coal Combustion

Products from an Active Coal Ash Management

Unit.’’ Palo Alto, CA. February.

PO 00000

Frm 00014

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.13

estimating the field leaching behavior

for a wide range of materials under both

disposal and use conditions.’’ 15 The

two studies cited by commenters do not

contradict these findings. Indeed, one of

the cited reports concludes that LEAF

Method 1313 measurements tended to

only underestimate porewater

concentrations of lithium and

molybdenum and did not consistently

overestimate or underestimate

porewater concentrations of arsenic and

thallium. These conclusions are

consistent with previous Agency

findings that LEAF Method 1313

measurements (1) can underestimate

leakage of highly soluble constituents,

such as lithium and molybdenum, if not

adjusted to properly account for the

sample liquid to solid ratio and (2) can

over or underestimate leakage of redox

sensitive contaminants, such as arsenic,

if not further adjusted with geochemical

speciation modeling. In response to

these findings, the Agency has

established general recommendations

for how to address these issues.16

Modeling of highly soluble constituents

in both the 2014 and 2024 Risk

Assessment are consistent with these

recommendations. Sufficient data are

not yet available on the prevalence or

magnitude of reducing conditions to

allow EPA to adequately model the

effects of these conditions on leaching

behavior at a national scale. However,

given that the 2024 Risk Assessment

identified potential for extensive

groundwater contamination with overall

risks as high as 1 × 10¥4 for the less

mobile pentavalent speciation of

arsenic, this uncertainty is unlikely to

affect the conclusions of the risk

assessment.

EPA also disagrees that the field data

presented by commenters demonstrates

that the modeled concentrations are

unrealistic. As a general matter, these

commenters did not make available the

underlying data for the graphs presented

or the reports from which the graphs

were drawn. Therefore, it is not possible

to fully evaluate these graphs, as EPA

cannot determine how and where these

data were collected, how many

individual samples are represented, and

how the data were compiled. Based on

15 U.S. EPA. 2014. ‘‘Leaching Test Relationships,

Laboratory-to-Field Comparisons and

Recommendations for Leaching Evaluation using

the Leaching Environmental Assessment

Framework.’’ EPA 600/R–14/061. EPA Office of

Research and Development. Research Triangle Park,

NC. October.

16 U.S. EPA. 2019. ‘‘Leaching Environmental

Assessment Framework (LEAF) How-To Guide:

Understanding the LEAF Approach and How and

When to Use It.’’ SW–846 Update VII. Prepared by

the EPA Office of Land and Emergency

Management. Washington, DC. May.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

the limited description provided, it

appears that the graphs summarize data

on the average leachate concentrations

collected from around different

landfills. Thus, the cited median values

would represent a median of the average

measurements from each landfill. This

type of summary does not provide a

meaningful understanding of the

leaching potential of CCR. For example,

landfills can contain mixtures of

different CCR types and other wastes,

which may result in variable leaching

profiles over the footprint of the unit.

An average of measured leachate

concentrations can mask regions of

higher leaching potential over many

acres. This potential for variable

leaching is one reason why groundwater

monitoring wells are required to be

spaced along the entire downgradient

boundary of these units. In contrast,

CCRMU fills are smaller in size and

more likely to be constructed with a

single source of ash. Additionally, there

is no indication of how long the waste

has been present in these landfills prior

to sampling. More soluble constituents

can become depleted over time. For

example, Modular Three-Dimension

Finite-Difference Ground-Water Flow

Model (MODFLOW) runs conducted for

the 2024 Risk Assessment showed that

molybdenum can deplete from the ash

anywhere from several years to a few

decades after leaching first began. Thus,

these graphs could understate the full

leaching potential of CCR.

Commenters also mischaracterize the

results of the probabilistic analysis. The

90th percentile of all model inputs for

leachate concentration is not the same

as the 90th percentile of modeled risks.

There are a number of other model

parameters that will influence

contaminant release and subsurface

transport. As a result, the model runs

with the highest initial leachate

concentrations are not always the same

as those with the highest downgradient

concentrations. EPA reviewed a subset

of model runs around the 90th

percentile risk result reported in the

2024 Risk Assessment, representing 1%

of all model runs at 1,000 feet from the

waste boundary. This review found the

median leachate concentration

representative of these runs was closer

to 0.31 mg/L for arsenic and 35 mg/L for

molybdenum. There are multiple

samples in the record of porewater or

leaching tests with concentrations of the

same order-of magnitude or higher than

these concentrations. Therefore, EPA

concludes that the methods used to

generate model inputs do not result in

unrealistically high leachate

concentrations.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

EPA maintains that LEAF leachate

provides the most realistic estimate of

long-term leaching potential from CCR

placed in fills. There is little field

leachate data for dry-managed CCR

available in the record, as it can be

difficult to collect representative

samples from landfills. Additionally,

field samples would reflect the specific

waste mixtures and chemistry of these

disposal units. Instead, LEAF provides

data on the leaching behavior of

individual CCR under a range of

relevant environmental conditions. EPA

did consider using impoundment

porewater data to supplement the data

on leaching of lithium because of the

lack of LEAF data for this contaminant,

and because lithium is a highly soluble,

monovalent ion expected to be less

influenced by specific impoundment

chemistry. However, this constituent

was not modeled in the 2024 Risk

Assessment due to other data

limitations. The uncertainties associated

with exclusion of lithium are discussed

in Section 6 of the 2024 Risk

Assessment.

Comment: One commenter asserted

that the distribution of leachate pH

values used to represent CCRMU fills is

unrepresentative. In particular, the

commenter took issue with the

prevalence at which acidic conditions

were modeled within CCR fills. This

commenter pointed to field data

collected from CCR landfills to assert

that leachate from fills would rarely be

acidic.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

modeled leachate pH is

unrepresentative of conditions at

smaller CCRMU fills. Modeled leachate

pH is based on the natural pH (or ‘‘own

pH’’) of the ash sample measured with

LEAF. Thus, these data represent the

properties of real ash samples. Landfills

can contain a mixture of different CCR

types and other related waste streams

and so it is reasonable that the average

pH of larger landfills may differ from

that of individual CCR. At the same

time, regions of individual landfills can

be more acidic than average, which can

be masked by consideration of only

average values. The potential for such

variations is part of the reason that

placement of monitoring wells is

required across the full downgradient

boundary of these landfills. Smaller

CCRMU fills are more likely to be

constructed with a single ash type and

so it is most appropriate to consider the

pH of individual ash samples, rather

than broader landfill conditions. The

uncertainties associated with the

modeling of pH are discussed in Section

6 of the 2024 Risk Assessment.

PO 00000

Frm 00015

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.14

38963

Comment: One commenter stated that

use of a five-mile radius to draw

environmental data for purposes of

groundwater modeling is not adequately

justified and inconsistent with both the

2014 Risk Assessment and Draft 2023

RIA.

EPA Reponse: EPA has reviewed and

updated the sampling radius for

environmental and population data.

Based on this review, EPA established

the sampling radius for environmental

data at two kilometers (1.2 miles). This

is consistent with the methodology

applied in the 2014 Risk Assessment,

which the Agency previously found

adequately represented the

environmental conditions near units for

which a more precise location at the

facility property could not be

determined. EPA established the

sampling radii for population data to be

consistent with the rationale outlined in

the 2024 RIA.

Comment: Multiple commenters

criticized the Agency’s use of soil-water

partitioning coefficients (i.e., Kd values)

to model contaminant sorption in the

subsurface. These commenters argued

that use of individual Kd values was

inappropriate and unable to reflect the

variability of subsurface transport

conditions. They also stated that the Kd

values used in the risk assessment for

arsenic were biased low and likely to

underestimate retention on soil. These

commenters cited field measurements

collected at various locations to assert

that actual values for arsenic are likely

to be higher. One commenter cited an

alternative set of Kd values they had

calculated to contend that actual values

for arsenic would be orders-ofmagnitude different than used in the

risk assessment.

EPA Response: These commenters are

incorrect; EPA did not rely only on

individual Kd values for the risk

assessment. As part of the 2014 Risk

Assessment, EPA previously developed

sorption isotherms for each modeled

constituent, which represent the

distribution of individual Kd values

calculated and reflect the range of

anticipated subsurface conditions and

specific CCR waste characteristics. Each

individual model run in the EPA

Composite Model for Leachate

Migration with Transformation Products

(EPACMTP) samples from that

distribution based on the key factors for

that run (e.g., leachate concentration,

pH, ionic strength). No individual

model run will precisely represent

conditions at a particular site. Instead,

the model runs collectively capture the

variability of conditions that can occur

across sites. Thus, EPA relies on the

model runs in aggregate to draw

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38964

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

conclusions about the potential for risk

nationwide.

EPA also disagrees that the specific

Kd values used in MODFLOW are

unrepresentative. The limited number of

MODFLOW runs are intended to further

characterize the subset of high-end

scenarios modeled in EPACMTP. Thus,

it is entirely reasonable that these model

runs are those more likely to reflect

scenarios where pentavalent arsenic is

more mobile in the environment.

The field data shared by commenters

for specific CERCLA sites or agricultural

fields are not representative of

conditions at CCR disposal units. As

previously noted, the calculated

sorption isotherms reflect the properties

of CCR leachate, which can be vastly

different from precipitation infiltrating

through soil. In particular, both the high

ionic strength and variable pH of this

leachate are expected to result in

different sorption behavior. EPA is also

unable to fully review the Kd values

calculated by commenters or compare

them with Agency values because the

commenters provided insufficient

information regarding whether and how

specific key environmental factors were

considered. Nevertheless, EPA notes

that the range of values presented by

commenters falls within the full

distribution of Kd values developed for

arsenic in 2014. The full distribution of

values is summarized in Appendix H of

the 2014 Risk Assessment, and is the

full range of values EPA sampled from

to model groundwater transport in the

2024 Risk Assessment.

Comment: One commenter stated that

any CCR material placed beneath the

soil would become naturally compacted.

Another commenter asserted that the

pozzolanic nature of some ash would

result in far lower hydraulic

conductivity than EPA modeled.

EPA Response: In the absence of

periodic inspections and a wellmaintained cap, there is no guarantee

that any ash placed in the ground will

remain undisturbed by human or animal

activity, natural settling or freeze-thaw

cycles, flooding and other extreme

weather events, or other unforeseen

factors. Given that such disturbances

can result in increased permeability, it

was not possible to develop a fixed

probabilistic distribution of

conductivities. Instead, EPA modeled

conductivity based on the dominant soil

megatexture as described in Appendix B

of the 2014 Risk Assessment. As such,

the model assumes the ash has been

subjected to a similar degree of

compaction as the surrounding soil.

EPA acknowledges that some fly ash is

pozzolanic in nature. Yet, the

commenter provided no information

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

that would indicate how common it is

for this type of ash, which can be

marketed for use in concrete, to be

placed in CCRMU fills. EPA is also not

aware of any information that could be

used to represent the long-term

conductivity of this ash when left in the

field and exposed to the elements.

Comment: One commenter contended

that EPA had not adequately

demonstrated that consideration of more

recent weather data drawn from the

latest version of the Hydrologic

Evaluation of Landfill Performance

model would result in consistently

higher infiltration rates than previously

modeled in 2014 for CCR landfills.

EPA Response: The 2023 Draft Risk

Assessment proposed that the higher

rates of infiltration modeled for certain

soil types with the new HELP data

indicates the potential for higher

leaching and risk to groundwater than

previously modeled in 2014. However,

because EPA found that the model

results from the 2014 Risk Assessment

are sufficient to support the current

rulemaking, the Agency did not conduct

the additional modeling that would be

necessary to refine this draft analysis.

As a result, EPA does not rely on this

particular analysis to support the final

rule and so it is not included in the 2024

Risk Assessment.

Comment: Several commenters stated

that consideration of a limited subset of

contaminants for groundwater modeling

would result in an underestimation of

risk. These commenters further assert

that EPA further underestimated risk by

not accounting for the effects of

cumulative exposure to multiple

contaminants.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

selection of constituents for

groundwater modeling resulted in lower

risks than would have otherwise been

identified. The constituents selected for

groundwater modeling were those found

to be risk drivers for unlined surface

impoundments in the 2014 Risk

Assessment, as these are considered the

most likely to also result in the greatest

risks for unlined landfills and

comparable management units. EPA

notes that some of the additional

constituents raised by commenters had

been previously identified as risk

drivers only for specific CCR types, such

as flue gas desulfurization (FGD) wastes,

which are considered far less likely to

be used in CCRMU fills. The

commenters presented no new

information that could alter the

previous model results and so there is

no expectation that inclusion of these

additional constituents would identify

risks higher than those already modeled

for the relevant CCR types. Some other

PO 00000

Frm 00016

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.15

additional constituents raised by

commenters lack health benchmarks

within the Office of Land and

Emergency Management (OLEM)

hierarchy and so could not be

quantitatively evaluated. See, 85 FR

72526. Uncertainties associated with the

selection constituents for modeling is

further discussed in Section 6 of the

2024 Risk Assessment.

Comment: Several commenters argued

that a modeling horizon of up to 10,000

years was unrealistic. These

commenters stated that such a long time

frame is not consistent with identifying

a reasonable probability of adverse

effects because there is no reliable way

to predict whether any receptors will

exist that far in the future.

EPA Response: EPA ran the

groundwater model until either the

observed groundwater concentration at

the receptor point reached a peak and

then fell below a model-specified

minimum concentration (1 × 10¥16 mg/

L), or the model had been run for a time

period of 10,000 years. This is the same

modeling horizon applied in the 2014

Risk Assessment. The text in the 2024

Risk Assessment has been updated to

make it clear that the selection of a

maximum 10,000-year time horizon

does not mean that it typically took that

long for contamination be identified or

that all model simulations continue for

the full 10,000 years. EPA also notes

that the time to first exceedance of

selected risk criteria is typically

considerably less than the time to the

greatest exceedance.

EPA acknowledges that future

groundwater use patterns may shift over

time as the number and location of

receptors changes, and that it is

unknown whether or how future shifts

in receptor locations and other surface

conditions might affect risk. However,

EPA notes that all the contaminants

associated with CCR are inorganic and

so will remain present in the

environment over the full modeling

horizon. As such, a longer modeling

horizon can provide useful information

about the potential duration of

groundwater contamination in the

absence of regulation. EPA found that

contaminant plumes modeled in

MODFLOW did not fully dissipate for

around 2,300 years for arsenic V and

100 years for molybdenum.

Comment: Multiple commenters

argued that EPA was inconsistent with

the 2014 Risk Assessment and

overestimated risks for CCRMU fills by

not evaluating the interception of

groundwater by surface water.

EPA Response: EPA did not explicitly

evaluate interception by surface water

on groundwater fate and transport in the

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

2024 Risk Assessment. As

acknowledged by commenters

elsewhere, facilities have generally not

maintained reliable records about the

location or construction of all CCRMU

fills. As a result, it is not possible for

EPA to develop a representative,

probabilistic distribution of the distance

from these fills to downgradient water

bodies or offsite receptors. However,

given the diversity of reasons for such

placements listed by commenters, there

are few limitations as to where these

fills might be located onsite. As a result,

there is greater potential for these fills

to be located further away from water

bodies than disposal units, allowing for

further contaminant spread prior to any

interception. Therefore, the 2024 Risk

Assessment evaluated the potential

magnitude and extent of onsite

groundwater contamination that could

occur in the absence of interception. It

is considered unlikely that further

quantitative evaluation of interception

would affect the conclusions of the 2024

Risk Assessment. The reductions in

modeled risks attributed interception in

the 2014 Risk Assessment were

predominantly for median risks.

However, the 2014 Risk Assessment still

identified high-end risks to offsite

receptors, and it was these risks that

formed the basis for the 2015 CCR Rule.

Thus, it is similarly unlikely that

quantitative evaluation of surface water

interception would affect the high-end

risks reported in the 2024 Risk

Assessment, especially because the

current assessment considers onsite

groundwater quality prior to discharge

to a water body. Furthermore, as

discussed in the 2024 Risk Assessment

and in response to comments elsewhere,

the fact that a contaminant plume that

has migrated off-site is intercepted by

surface water does not mean that there

is no potential for risk or no need for

further action to address the presence of

groundwater contamination onsite.

Comment: Some commenters

requested clarification on the

prevalence of different types of liners

modeled for the landfills and surface

impoundments previously excluded

from the 2014 Risk Assessment. Citing

to data relied upon in the 2014 Risk

Assessment, one commenter asserted

that a majority of modeled landfills had

some form of liner and that national

regulations should be based on the risks

for all units, rather than those that are

unlined.

EPA Response: The handling of liner

status for these units was described in

Section 5 of the 2014 Risk Assessment.

Of the units evaluated in the 2014 Risk

Assessment, approximately 42% of

landfills and 65% of surface

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

impoundments were modeled as having

no engineered liner system. Of the

previously excluded units summarized

in the 2024 Risk Assessment,

approximately 71% of landfills and

57% of surface impoundments were

modeled as having no engineered liner

system. EPA has updated the discussion

of this issue in the 2024 Risk

Assessment to better distinguish the

specific liner status modeled for these

different units. Differences in the

national risks reported in 2014 and 2024

are largely attributed to the relative

prevalence of engineered liners modeled

for each. Modeled risks in both

assessments are nearly the same for the

subset of units with no engineered liner.

Far from being an isolated practice, a

substantial fraction of the currently

operating landfills across the country

have no engineered liner. Although the

2014 Risk Assessment did model a

majority of landfills as having some

form of engineered liner, data that has

become available since then indicates a

greater proportion of operating units

lack an engineered liner than EPA

previously understood. Furthermore,

the 2014 Risk Assessment modeled the

performance of both clay and composite

liners based on the assumption of good

construction practices. However, it has

become clear since then that some liner

systems do not perform as modeled. For

example, facility reporting shows that

around 10% of composite and alternatelined units have already entered into

corrective action. Therefore, it is

considered likely that national risks for

both landfills and surface

impoundments (including the inactive

landfills and legacy impoundments

subject to this final rule) are more

similar to those unlined units than

previously modeled.

Nevertheless, the 2014 and 2024 Risk

Assessments, which provided much of

the basis for this final rule, modeled the

risks associated with both lined and

unlined units. Under RCRA sections

1008(a)(3) and 4004(a), EPA establishes

national criteria; because the criteria are

national in scope EPA must evaluate the

full range of conditions. In addition,

EPA must establish requirements that

will achieve the statutory standard at all

sties subject to the criteria—including

those that pose the greatest risk. Under

these provisions, the criteria may

authorize a CCR unit to continue

operating ‘‘only if there is no reasonable

probability of adverse effects on health

and the environment from the disposal

[or other solid waste management] of

solid waste at such facility.’’ 42 U.S.C.

6903(a)(3), 6944(a). Given the

requirement that the standard be met at

each facility covered by the regulation,

PO 00000

Frm 00017

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.16

38965

it is not particularly surprising that the

final requirements are driven by the

higher end risks associated with unlined

units—especially as the overwhelming

majority of legacy impoundments and

CCRMU are expected to lack the

composite liner that would largely

mitigate the risks of CCR units. But that

does not mean that the national

regulations are not based on the risks for

all units.

Comment: One commenter argued

that modeled groundwater

concentrations and associated risk

downgradient of smaller CCRMU fills

are unrealistic because they are higher

than previously modeled for landfills

and surface impoundments. Other

commenters contended that modeled

groundwater concentrations were

unrealistic, citing comparisons to

monitoring data for all regulated units

in a report by the Environmental

Integrity Project (EIP) 17 or for some

smaller subset of units. These

commenters calculated summary

statistics from concentrations reported

for site groundwater monitoring wells to

assert that modeled concentrations were

an order of magnitude higher or more

than the concentrations that have

occurred in the field.

EPA Response: The 2014 Risk

Assessment modeled risks from landfills

and surface impoundments to receptors

located up to a mile away from these

units. The 2024 Risk Assessment

modeled the magnitude and extent of

contamination extending from smaller

CCRMU fills, including the likelihood of

exceedance of GWPS at the waste

boundary of the unit. It is entirely

reasonable that concentrations and risk

closer to the waste boundary are higher

than EPA modeled in 2015 up to a mile

away from a unit.

EPA disagrees that the modeled

groundwater concentrations are

contradicted by available monitoring

data. First and foremost, EPA modeled

the long-term potential for groundwater

contamination that may occur in the

absence of regulatory action. Thus,

monitoring data from units of variable

age and operational status do not

represent a one-to-one comparison.

Second, field monitoring data can

diverge from model results as a result of

improper well installation. As just one

example, EPA is aware of multiple

instances where monitoring wells are

located far from the waste boundary, in

some cases, hundreds of feet away. See,

for example, 88 FR 55239. Third, EPA

used EPACMTP to model

17 EIP. 2022. ‘‘Poisonous Coverup: The

Widespread Failure of the Power Industry to Clean

Up Coal Ash Dumps.’’

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38966

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

concentrations along the centerline of

the plume and to provide a best estimate

of contaminant transport potential to

inform further modeling with

MODFLOW. Even if all wells in a

network were properly installed and

spaced, there is no guarantee that any

individual well will intersect with the

exact point of highest concentration;

some wells may not intersect with the

plume at all. Finally, the 90th percentile

concentration modeled is not intended

to correspond precisely to a 90th

percentile of well concentrations.

Instead, it reflects an RME scenario that

is conservative, while remaining within

the range of possible high-end

exposures. The EIP dataset cited by

commenters do show multiple instances

of well concentrations at individual

landfills of the same order of magnitude

as modeled in the 2024 Risk Assessment

or even higher. Further, in the case of

arsenic, modeled GWPS exceedances

between 26 and 19 for arsenic III and V

are of a similar magnitude as the

exceedance of 16 estimated by one

commenter based on the EIP report.

Therefore, EPA maintains that the

magnitude of modeled groundwater

concentrations is realistic.

Comment: Some commenters claimed

that EPA had not justified modeling

groundwater concentrations at fixed

distances along the centerline of the

plume or within the upper five feet of

the aquifer and had not demonstrated

how this approach compares with the

2014 Risk Assessment, which modeled

concentrations within the top 30 feet of

the aquifer.

EPA Response: The goal of modeling

with EPACMTP was to identify the

potential magnitude of GWPS

exceedances at the waste boundary and

potential for contaminant spread to

support further modeling with

MODFLOW. For both goals, a sampling

along the centerline of the plume and to

a depth of five feet was determined to

be most relevant portion of the aquifer

for consideration for the reasons

documented in the 2024 Risk

Assessment. Because different scenarios

were modeled in the two risk

assessments, a comparison with the

results of 2014 Risk Assessment is not

relevant here.

Comment: EPA received several

comments regarding a graph from the

2023 Draft Risk Assessment, which

summarized modeled risks from the

2014 Risk Assessment for unlined

landfills as a function of unit size.

Commenters stated that it demonstrated

that risks consistently decline below a

certain acreage and that smaller units do

not warrant regulation because they

pose less risk. One commenter stated

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

that the underlying model runs for the

2014 Risk Assessment were not made

available alongside the graph and so its

validity could not be confirmed.

EPA Response: One purpose of the

referenced graph was to demonstrate

that risks remain above levels of

concern over a broad range of unit sizes

modeled in the 2014 Risk Assessment.

However, upon further review, EPA has

determined that the graph incorrectly

summarized model results for receptors

of all age cohorts into one figure. This

has the potential to bias the plotted risks

low. However, filtering the model runs

for only (1) unlined landfills, (2) where

drinking wells are located closer than

surface water bodies, and (3) where an

adult was exposed results in a relatively

small number of model runs. EPA is

concerned that this number of runs is

not sufficient to reflect national

variability or support broader

conclusions about risk. As such, EPA

does not rely on this line of evidence to

support the final rule and so it is not

included in the 2024 Risk Assessment.

EPA cautions the data presented in

the graph was for landfills and so use of

this graph to draw conclusions about

the risks from surface impoundments is

not appropriate. EPA further cautions

that it is not appropriate to use the

referenced graph to identify a specific

unit size below which landfill risks are

not possible. The graph summarized the

results of the 2014 Risk Assessment,

which modeled risks to offsite receptors

up to a mile away from the waste

boundary. The risks identified based on

these receptors provided a robust basis

for the 2015 CCR Rule. Yet, this does

not mean these are the only relevant

risks. EPA’s longstanding and consistent

policy (across numerous regulatory

programs) has been that groundwater

contamination is a significant concern

that merits regulatory action in its own

right, whether or not the aquifer is

currently used as a source of drinking

water. The 2024 Risk Assessment

identifies the potential for CCRMU fills

to contaminate groundwater above

levels of concern. Where CCR landfills

and surface impoundments are located

at the same sites even more extensive

contamination can occur as a result of

their larger size. As such, these disposal

units warrant regulation to protect

groundwater resources, regardless of

their size.

Comment: One commenter questioned

why MODFLOW—Unstructured Grid

(USG) was used to model groundwater

transport, stating that MODFLOW 6 is

more commonly used. This commenter

also inquired why the model was not

run in steady-state mode. They further

argued that insufficient information had

PO 00000

Frm 00018

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.17

been provided to allow for evaluation of

the design of MODFLOW model runs.

Finally, the commenter identified a

potential discrepancy in the reported

model inputs for EPACMTP and

MODFLOW.

EPA Response: MODFLOW–USG was

selected for its ability to: (1) Simulate

flow and transport in both the

unsaturated and saturated zones

without the need for additional

modeling packages and (2) Simulate

groundwater flow and transport

sequentially without the need for

reading cell by cell flow and transport.

Steady state simulations were not used

because they do not provide a time

series representation of plume

evolution. EPA has reviewed the model

documentation to ensure that this and

other relevant information raised by

commenters was made clear in the 2024

Risk Assessment. However, EPA notes

that this and much of the other specific

information raised by commenters was

previously described in the 2023 Draft

Risk Assessment. EPA did not

incorporate the full output files for all

MODFLOW model runs because the file

size would become prohibitively large

to manage. The level of documentation

of model inputs and outputs is

consistent with that provided for

EPACMTP. The identified discrepancy

between EPACMTP and MODFLOW

inputs were the result of a typo, which

has been corrected.

Comment: One commenter stated that

EPA had not provided sufficient

evidence to support its conclusion that

the location of legacy facilities that were

not modeled in 2014 could result in

somewhat higher risks for this subset of

units compared to those previously

modeled units.

EPA Response: EPA previously found

that the locations of legacy facilities

were clustered in the eastern half of the

country. As a result, the rates of

precipitation at these facilities will tend

to be higher than modeled for the nation

as a whole. Higher precipitation can

result in greater vertical infiltration and

subsequent leakage down to

groundwater. The Agency has not

conducted further sensitivity analyses to

support this contention, as this

argument is not central to the findings

of either the risk assessment or the

rulemaking. Instead, discussion in the

2024 Risk Assessment has been updated

to clarify that the primary finding is that

there is no indication based on

geography that these additional units

would be exposed to substantially

different environmental conditions than

EPA modeled in 2014.

Comment: Multiple industry

commenters argued that modeled

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

arsenic risks do not warrant regulation

because the associated concentrations

often fall below the current maximum

contaminant limit (MCL). One

commenter noted that 70 percent of

runs identified peak arsenic

concentrations below the MCL at the

unit boundary. In contrast,

environmental advocacy groups stated

that cancer risks within the OLEM risk

range can occur at even lower levels.

Another asserted it was inappropriate

for EPA to identify risk based on

modeled concentrations above GWPS

because corrective action requires ‘‘a

statistically significant level exceeding

the groundwater protection standard.’’

EPA Response: First, EPA notes that

arsenic is only one of the contaminants

modeled. Molybdenum was found to be

above the associated GWPS on a more

frequent basis. Indeed, EPA identified

exceedances for this contaminant at

both the 90th and 50th percentile

results. EPA disagrees that risks

identified below MCLs do not pose a

concern. MCLs are not purely risk-based

and can incorporate other

considerations, such as the technical

feasibility of reliably achieving even

lower levels. As environmental

commenters have pointed out, the

arsenic MCL in particular represents a

concentration that can fall outside the

OLEM risk range. As such, these

standards should be understood as

values that corrective action must

achieve and not levels that never

warrant concern. Indeed, EPA

established GWPS at the unit boundary

with the intent to limit downgradient

transport of contamination above this

level and prevent the same magnitude of

risk identified in the risk assessment.

EPA also disagrees that a statistically

significant increase above GWPS is an

appropriate standard for risk modeling.

It is not clear, nor do commenters

articulate, how such a statistical

analysis would be conducted as part of

the model. Thus, EPA believes this

comment represents a general

misunderstanding of both groundwater

monitoring programs and probabilistic

analysis. Statistical analysis is used in

groundwater monitoring programs

because factors, such as natural

fluctuations in groundwater and

uncertainty from sampling or laboratory

analysis procedures, can introduce

variability into the broader dataset. In

this context, statistical analysis allows

evaluation of the broader data and

identification of an exceedance of

GWPS with a specified level of

certainty. However, numerical models

are not subject to the same constraints.

A model tracks the fate and transport of

all contaminant mass from the point of

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

release to the point of exposure.

Therefore, no additional steps required

to confirm that an identified exceedance

of GWPS resulted from leakage from the

modeled unit.

Comment: Several commenters stated

that the toxicity value used for arsenic

underestimated risks from groundwater,

citing draft values they assert would

increase modeled arsenic risks by an

order of magnitude or more.

EPA Response: The Agency’s current

risk estimates are based on the same

cancer slope factor of 1.5 mg/kg/d¥1 for

arsenic in EPA’s Integrated Risk

Information System (IRIS). EPA is

currently in the process of reviewing

this slope factor and has released a draft

toxicological review, which, if finalized

without revision, would increase the

individual risk estimates for arsenic by

a factor of approximately 35. See, 88 FR

71360. However, the Agency has not yet

finalized this updated IRIS

reassessment, and EPA cannot base a

final decision on a draft IRIS value that

is subject to revision. Nor did EPA

receive any other information during the

development of this final rule that

would help to resolve this uncertainty.

The current IRIS values thus represent

the best data available to the Agency

until the IRIS reassessment is complete.

d. Comments Related to Supplemental

Risk Assessment Soil Model

Comment: One commenter contended

that radionuclides and nonradionuclides have different health

endpoints and so it is not appropriate to

treat the resulting risks as additive.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that it

is inappropriate to consider the

cumulative risk from chemical and

radiological contaminants. EPA policy

is to treat the risk resulting from

exposure to multiple carcinogens as

additive.18 Agency policy is also to

evaluate the risks from exposure to

radionuclides in the same manner as

chemical contaminants.19 Therefore, it

is appropriate to evaluate the

cumulative cancer risk from chemical

and radiation contaminants. However,

EPA notes that considering chemical

and radiological risks separately would

not alter the overall conclusions of the

analysis, as each have demonstrated

potential to individually result in risk

exceeding EPA’s levels of concern.

18 U.S. EPA. 1989. ‘‘Risk Assessment Guidance for

Superfund Volume I Human Health Evaluation

Manual (Part A).’’ EPA/540/1–89/002. Prepared by

the Office of Emergency and Remedial Response,

Washington, DC. December.

19 U.S. EPA. 2014. ‘‘Radiation Risk Assessment at

CERCLA Sites: Q&A.’’ OSWER 9285.6–20. Prepared

by the Office of Land and Emergency Response.

Washington, DC. June.

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.18

38967

Uncertainties associated with umulative

risk is further discussed in Section 6 of

the 2024 Risk Assessment.

Comment: EPA received comments

that argued the U.S. Geological Survey

coal quality (COALQUAL) database

does not adequately account for several

factors that may affect bulk content of

the resulting ash, such as: CCR type,

regional variability, coal rank, mining

practices, coal preparation prior to

combustion, and the presence of

unburnt carbon remaining after

combustion. Another commenter stated

that because the risk assessment

addresses historical disposal of CCR,

sampling of the COALQUAL database

should be updated to reflect production

over time, rather than current

production. Finally, one commenter

argued that differences identified

between activity calculated from

COALQUAL data and measured

elsewhere in the literature demonstrates

that handling of COALQUAL data is

likely to overestimate concentrations in

the ash.

EPA Response: The Agency

acknowledges that the bulk contaminant

content of specific CCR samples can be

influenced by a range of factors, such as

the manner in which a coal sample is

prepared and combusted. As detailed in

Section 6 of the 2024 Risk Assessment,

EPA considered the information

provided by commenters on the

potential for mining practices, residual

unburnt carbon, and coal washing to

affect estimated ash concentrations and

concluded these factors are likely to

have a minimal or inconsistent effect on

overall distribution of concentrations.

EPA did determine that concentrations

of some contaminants are sensitive to

differences in region and coal rank and

so reviewed the Energy Information

Administration (EIA) coal production

reports referenced by commenters when

updating the weighting of available

samples.

For purposes of modeling

groundwater exposure, EPA did not use

the COALQUAL database to estimate

the leachable content of CCR in the 2024

Risk Assessment. Previous reviews of

EPACMTP summarized in the 2014 Risk

Assessment did not identify leachable

content as among the sensitive model

parameters. Even at lower bulk

concentrations, there is often sufficient

soluble mass present to support

sustained leaching. Instead, EPA

represented leachable content using

available LEAF data in a manner

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38968

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

consistent with the 2014 Risk

Assessment and Agency guidance.20

For purposes of modeling soil

exposure, EPA retained use of the

COALQUAL database in the 2024 Risk

Assessment to calculate the bulk

content of thorium and uranium of CCR.

In this instance, use of COALQUAL

provides information about the relative

levels of each contaminant, which

allowed for a more refined estimate of

cumulative exposure that provides a

more direct comparison with relevant

benchmarks. As discussed in Section 6

of the 2024 Risk Assessment, EPA also

considered available EIA data when

updating the calculation of bulk content

for these two contaminants and found

that concentrations of both are less

sensitive than other contaminants to

regional geography. Therefore, further

efforts to refine these calculations are

considered unlikely to result in changes

that would affect the overall

conclusions of the evaluation.

The bulk contaminant content

calculated from COALQUAL represents

a mixture of fly ash and either bottom

ash or boiler slag, collectively referred

to in the 2024 Risk Assessment as the

‘‘whole ash.’’ Because fly ash is

generated in the greatest volumes during

coal combustion, the calculated bulk

content primarily reflects this type of

CCR. However, other available data

sources indicate that the activity of fly

ash and bottom ash are not substantially

different. EPA has seen no indication

that the activity of boiler slag would

differ markedly from that of bottom ash.

The whole ash does not include any

CCR generated by scrubber systems and

similar pollution control technologies.

However, these CCR types are not

considered relevant to the evaluation of

CCRMU fills. EPA further discusses the

uncertainties associated with these

different types of CCR in Section 6 of

the 2024 Risk Assessment.

Based on the comments received, EPA

reviewed the available data on

radioactivity drawn from the literature.

This review led to the removal of

several samples that were determined to

be duplicative and removed all the data

for one study because it was determined

to not be representative of the broader

ash generated at the facility. Altogether,

the data removed represent a small

fraction of the overall dataset. This

review also identified some inaccuracies

in how samples were described and

averaged to avoid biasing the overall

20 U.S. EPA. 2019. ‘‘Leaching Environmental

Assessment Framework (LEAF) How-To Guide:

Understanding the LEAF Approach and How and

When to Use It.’’ SW–846 Update VII. Prepared by

the EPA Office of Land and Emergency

Management. Washington, DC. May.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

dataset toward individual facilities that

reported a greater number of samples.

This had resulted in more samples being

averaged together than was intended.

The database presented as part of the

2024 Risk Assessment has been updated

along with a summary of these updates.

Following these corrections, the

updated summary statistics for thorium

align more closely with those calculated

with COALQUAL. Therefore, there is

general agreement between these two

datasets. It is inevitable there will be

some differences between datasets

developed through different

methodologies. In particular, any

individual study may not reflect the full

variability of coal produced over time.

However, the magnitude of differences

between activities drawn from

COALQUAL and the broader literature

are small on an absolute basis and

consequently would not affect the

overall conclusions of the risk

assessment. Therefore, EPA concludes

that COALQUAL can provide a

reasonable estimate of both median and

high-end ash activity.

Comment: One commenter critiqued

multiple individual model inputs used

in RESRAD as likely to overestimate

potential for radon exposure. They also

stated that the risk assessment should

consider an additional scenario with

RESRAD of CCR disposed at the ground

surface to provide a consistent frame of

reference to compare risk results

obtained from RESRAD and the

preliminary remediation goal (PRG)

calculator. Other commenters separately

commented that the assumed presence

of some soil cover is inappropriate,

referencing one CCRMU purported to

have been placed with the intent to

level out the ground surface and

without any additional soil cover.

EPA Response: EPA has not

established default parameters for

modeling of radon fate and transport.

Nor is there currently enough

information available on a national scale

to develop distributions that could be

sampled probabilistically. Instead, EPA

previously conducted a deterministic

analysis for radon exposure by

specifying high, moderate, and/or low

values for model inputs to capture the

range of potential exposure. EPA first

modeled risk with all inputs set to

moderate values to identify a baseline

risk more representative of the central

tendency. From this baseline, EPA

adjusted each individual input to lower

or higher values to better understand

which inputs exert the greatest

influence on modeled risks and support

development of an RME scenario.

However, EPA ultimately concluded

that the rate of radon emanation from

PO 00000

Frm 00020

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.19

CCR is not distinguishable from

background soil and so the Agency did

not develop this RME scenario or draw

final conclusions about risk from radon

exposure. For this same reason, EPA did

not retain the quantitative evaluation of

radon in the 2024 Risk Assessment.

Some CCRMU fills may currently be

uncovered, but EPA was not able to

confirm the status of the specific unit

identified by the commenter based on

the information provided. Nevertheless,

EPA maintains it is unlikely that future

residential construction would occur in

the absence of some initial soil cover. It

is generally anticipated residential

construction sites will cover any

exposed land with topsoil or turf to

support uniform lawn growth. However,

this does not guarantee this soil cover

will be adequately maintained by

residents into the future. As such, EPA

agrees it is appropriate to evaluate a

scenario of CCR without any soil cover

to provide a bounding estimate of

potential risk and a more direct link

between the primary and sensitivity

analyses. This updated scenario is

discussed in Section 6 of the 2024 Risk

Assessment.

Comment: Some commenters raised

concerns about the sensitivity analysis

conducted with the PRG calculator. One

commenter asserted that the PRG

calculator is intended for use with

contaminated soils and is inappropriate

for comparison against undiluted CCR.

This commenter further argued that the

sensitivity analysis conducted with the

PRG calculator is overly generic and did

not incorporate scenario-specific inputs,

such as the potential for greater soil

cover, shorter exposure duration, and

ability of radon to emanate from CCR.

Finally, this commenter stated that the

degree of mixing of soil with CCR would

not result in activities higher than either

background or applicable or relevant

and appropriate requirements (ARARs),

concluding that the evaluation of

radiation risk should consider

contributions from background soils

when presenting risk results. Another

commenter stated that the ARAR was

only exceeded around the 90th

percentile concentrations and that

regulation based on 90th percentile

concentrations is not appropriate.

EPA Response: EPA disagrees that the

PRG calculator is not applicable to the

modeled scenario of CCR intermixed

with soil. The commenters provide no

rationale for this assertion beyond the

fact that the PRG calculator nominally

identifies soil as an environmental

media of interest. This is reasonable as

it would quickly become overwhelming

to identify a comprehensive list of

sludges, sediments, and other soil-like

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

materials that might be encountered at

cleanup sites. EPA notes that the

exposure assumptions incorporated into

the PRG calculator are equally relevant

for CCR intermixed with soil. CCR

consist of small particulates that can be

readily intermixed with the soil and

result in exposures through the exact

same routes, specifically incidental

ingestion and direct exposure to gamma

radiation.

EPA also disagrees that the analysis of

exposure to CCR mixed with soil is

overly simplistic. First, the presence of

additional cover soil is already

considered in the main analysis and is

not relevant to the types of exposures

explicitly considered in the sensitivity

analysis. Second, because EPA

concluded the rate of radon emanation

from CCR and soil were not

distinguishable, the sensitivity analysis

explicitly does not incorporate risk from

inhalation of radon gas. Only a

relatively small fraction of the radon

generated from fly and bottom ash is

expected to escape into the ambient air

and these losses can be counteracted by

upward migration from deeper ash.

Therefore, it is unlikely that further

consideration of radon emanation

would have substantial impacts on

exposures through incidental ingestion

or direct gamma exposure. Third, the

model parameters used to characterize

exposure to gamma radiation in the PRG

calculation are generally the same as in

RESRAD and other available models.

Finally, exposure factors selected for

use in the PRG calculator are consistent

with Agency policy for characterizing

an RME scenario and many of the

remaining parameters are based on

extensive modeling.21 22 23

EPA generally only considers

contributions from disposed wastes to

risk when conducting national risk

assessments under RCRA. Background

concentrations may contribute to risk

when present and can sometimes be

higher than concentrations modeled in

a risk assessment. Although constituent

concentrations in undisturbed

environmental media can be highly

variable, they are often relatively low in

concentration. As a result, consideration

of these concentrations would generally

21 Oak Ridge National Laboratory. 2014. ‘‘Area

Correction Factors for Contaminated Soil for Use in

Risk And Dose Assessment Models.’’ ORNL/TM–

2013/00. Oak Ridge, TN. September.

22 Oak Ridge National Laboratory. 2014. ‘‘Gamma

Shielding Factors for Soil Covered Contamination

for Use in Risk and Dose Assessment Models.’’

ORNL/TM–2013/00. Oak Ridge, TN. September.

23 Oak Ridge National Laboratory. 2020.

‘‘Bateman Equation Adaptation for Solving and

Integrating Peak Activity into EPA ELCR and Dose

Models.’’ ORNL/TM–2020/1780. Oak Ridge, TN.

September.

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

have no impact on the overall

conclusions of a national risk

assessment. Therefore, consideration of

background concentrations is more

appropriate on a site-specific basis

when risk managers are determining the

need for and scope of corrective action.

EPA recognizes that a focus on

background is more common for

discussion of radioactivity, particularly

when providing context for the

associated risks to the broader public.

However, as one point of reference, EPA

has found that the median activities of

fly and bottom ashes already fall close

to the standard of 5 pCi/g radium226+228 above background soil, which

has been adopted as an ARAR for some

cleanups under Superfund and State

programs (i.e., around 4.3 pCi/g

higher).24 Additionally, EPA has found

that high-end radium-226+228 activity

in CCR has the potential to be nearly 10

pCi/g higher than typical background

soil. Thus, there is real potential for

mixing of CCR with soil to further

increase any risk already associated

with background.

Commenters are correct that mixing

small quantities of CCR with soil may

not result in a surface soil activity above

the ARAR. For high-end CCR activity,

this would require a roughly equal

mixture of soil and ash. However, risks

are still possible at activities below the

ARAR. The PRG calculator estimates

that an increase of only 1.13 pCi/g of the

thorium-232 decay chain or 1.45 pCi/g

of the uranium-238 decay chain in

surface soils could increase cancer risk

for residential receptors by 1 × 10¥4.

Such risks can result from relatively low

mixtures of CCR and soil, which are

possible if ash beneath the soil surface

is disturbed. As a result, EPA has

identified ARAR of 5 pCi/g above

background as equally applicable to

subsurface contamination that may be

disturbed in the future and concluded

‘‘it would not generally be appropriate

to allow backfilling with material with

concentration higher than 5 pCi/g.’’

Uncertainties associated with

background concentrations are further

discussed in Section 6 of the 2024 Risk

Assessment.

Comment: One industry commenter

presented an analysis they had

conducted comparing the

concentrations of certain inorganic

constituents in CCR to soil screening

levels. The commenter contended this

analysis demonstrated that ‘‘even daily

24 U.S. EPA. 1998. ‘‘Use of Soil Cleanup Criteria

in 40 CFR part 192 as Remediation Goals for

CERCLA Sites.’’ OSWER Directive 9200.4–25.

Office of Emergency and Remedial Response and

Office of Radiation and Indoor Air. Washington,

DC. February.

PO 00000

Frm 00021

Fmt 4701

Sfmt 4700

App.20

38969

direct contact to trace elements in coal

ash would not pose a significant risk to

human health.’’

EPA Response: EPA did not evaluate

the potential soil risks for human health

associated with many of the

constituents considered in the cited

analysis. The Agency believes that any

risk from additional constituents would

be mitigated by the rule requirements

that address the risks identified for

radionuclides. However, EPA notes that

the cited analysis is not sufficient to

demonstrate a lack of risk for these

additional constituents on a national

scale. The ash concentrations reported

for some constituents are already near or

above the health benchmarks, indicating

some potential for risk. Further, the

reported ash concentrations are based

on samples from a limited number of

geographically constrained facilities. As

a result, the reported concentrations

may not reflect the broader variability of

potential concentrations from across the

region or country. In particular, EPA

notes there is evidence in the regulatory

record of arsenic concentrations

approaching an order of magnitude

higher than considered in this analysis.

Comment: Several commenters argued

that EPA underestimated risk by not

considering other potential exposure

pathways, specifically inhalation of

loose CCR.

EPA Response: EPA selected direct

exposure gamma radiation and

incidental ingestion of soil as the

pathways for evaluation because these

represent the most direct routes of

exposure to contamination in the soil.

EPA agrees that inhalation is another

pathway through which future receptors

could be exposed if CCR becomes

intermixed with surface soil.

Quantitative evaluation of this pathway

would require additional model inputs

that could further increase the

uncertainty of results on a national

scale, such as the degree of vegetative

cover and mean wind speed. However,

EPA notes the default PRGs for

inhalation of the uranium-238 decay

chain in secular equilibrium is nearly

three orders of magnitude higher than

for external exposure to gamma

radiation and two orders of magnitude

higher than for incidental ingestion of

soil. As a result, it is unlikely

consideration of this pathway would

substantially increase calculated risk.

Therefore, this pathway does not

represent a major source of uncertainty

in the evaluation. EPA acknowledges

that there may be other exposure

pathways that could occur if CCR is

mixed with surface soil. These are

further discussed in Section 6 of the

2024 Risk Assessment.

E:\FR\FM\08MYR2.SGM

08MYR2

lotter on DSK11XQN23PROD with RULES2

38970

Federal Register / Vol. 89, No. 90 / Wednesday, May 8, 2024 / Rules and Regulations

e. Comments Related to Site Monitoring

Data

Comment: Some commenters stated

that, as part of any further risk

assessment efforts, EPA should

incorporate data that have been

collected as part of the monitoring

programs required by either the 2015

CCR Rule or prior State programs. Such

data might include site hydrogeology

from borings around the units and

groundwater quality sampled from

monitoring wells. These commenters

claimed these data are more recent and

more relevant to characterizing the

actual nature and extent of contaminant

release at individual sites.

EPA Response: There are multiple

reasons why it is neither practical nor

prudent to incorporate site-specific

monitoring data into national fate and

transport modeling. First, there are

documented concerns about the quality

and reliability of these data. For

example, EPA has identified significant

deficiencies in the monitoring networks

at each facility for which the Agency

has completed reviews under the Part A

(85 FR 53516, August 28, 2020) and Part

B (85 FR 72506, November 12, 2020)

Rules. It is unlikely such deficiencies

are isolated to this specific subset of

facilities. Monitoring wells that are

located too far apart, installed in the

wrong aquifer, or otherwise

inadequately installed would result in

data that are incomplete or

unrepresentative of relevant site

conditions. Thus, use of these data

would require thorough review prior to

use. Much of the site characterization

data are not required to be posted on

facility websites and so would take

substantial time to compile and review

for the over 1,000 individual landfills

and surface impoundments. Further, it

is highly unlikely that any identified

deficiencies could be remedied within a

reasonable timeframe.

Second, the hydrogeologic data that

have been collected in support of well

installation can provide an incomplete

or erroneous picture of site conditions

for the purpose of fate and transport

modeling. For example, at sites with

lower conductivity soils, EPA has

previously raised concerns that

collection of hydrogeologic data with a

focus on characterizing the predominant

soil type can underestimate the

prevalence of more localized deposits of

higher conductivity soil and other

discontinuities that can serve as

preferential flow pathways to

groundwater. See, 85 FR 72519.

Therefore, the current approach to

probabilistic characterization of soil and

aquifer characteristics using more local

VerDate Sep<11>2014

18:01 May 07, 2024

Jkt 262001

data sources is believed to provide the

most reliable means to capture the

potential variability of conditions across

different facilities and represent

contaminant f

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.